awmans*KwaB/a - OSTI.GOV

awmans*KwaB/a«w3W*Mx jgm»d=BEBIim#0#

11 SOmu wk

03AI303ti

i a #

^R,|y7VIv5 bkfk

uaisvifli 4/-f6-iaa% F

1_ 0||A1

&

m 4

ah &gqs* g

z*m

, og x

#%i

EA];g

X0]|

wto|* #4

W] 3 IW of H°^ d= r5“ uo DW

Sr ^ R°

SP ^ KT oJ [t 3harS

S?

JIJ s=

M R° 53 RIU$r o'ctj nnRr 0=1

oJr Mf\u4- ^ jij 5.9 JU

■<■

r|

KXU

SF

5r WDir

W rui?? °l0=1 Kfcj P FEor miniE ERill p rE r>j ofJ s°

53a$S!

i|°4

& ^ 5°-<° Op p;oB rjn opr>J rid k"

Eo2“XO™?*<

I

s-<miniiluTl3

•ti5°RO

119= 1

3 ERr ^S|

oP of

or °lm pi °lmr>. Sr Eoh r\

P @o 3P|l!& *<§o|m 91

»" ano 5j

131^ s? ^of ojo opisi 8r

JIJ EJ of E $J k“

535

am$m

I

op

Qo4

U S'R°rEJ ^

Efh

EJ n=w IIof nr

E fop P° 50 o=|

3S|

Ij n°

i>&oF&io

g*R~of r\ RU o=| HU am 4 Sul 3" EJ R" □ mu op

DISCLAIMER

Portions of this document may be illegible in electronic image products. Images are produced from the best available original document.

098-10

A1tXln EA1WM#

# % #

onunamy^siKOREA EflERGV ECOnOfTlICS IRSTITUTE

1

3.

i. 4 *............................................ i

II. 44-44 ^-47^ 444#... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .41. 444#.... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42. 444^ 4 444^.... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ;. . . . . . . . . . . . . 9

III. JE44^ ^44 444 4444. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121. A^-444 44..................................................122. A9^47j4 4 44. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 153. ^44^ -S-^-444 164. 44^44. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 235. -3^44 444 4444. . . . . . . . . . . . . . -. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -25

IV. 4444 4444- 4 4444. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 271. 44 -... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 272. 44. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 293. =4^.... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 314. 44. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 345. 44. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36

11

6. 7^444^4 4^14.................................... r................ 37

V. 7H1TM4 411 4^- 91 44............-........................................... 401. 44444^4 44 4W 4s...................................................40

2. 44TM4S44 53

3. 4-47744S -&444 f4..........................................58

VI. 4444: 444s 44 4s-'.......................................................86

1. 44344 44"4 4s.................-........................862. 4444 4444 s4 7^4 4 s................................893. 4s444 44 4s44..............................................................98

VII. 44 4 4#.......................................-................................:......102

Ill

& 4 4

<a II-l) 444 -§-^4 fa 44^1 6

<3. H-2) 444 44................................................................. 7

(a II-3) 4444 ^47)-^ 444 4444............................ ,........8

(a HI-1) 44;}^ ^944(1995. 8)....................................-.........25

(a HI-2) 199744f ^47^ 4^44................................... 26

(a. HI-3) 19904;|e ^44^ f4 ^14...................................26

(a. V-l) f444 A^-44 44 (a4^).........................................62

(a. V-2) 19964 w]4444 44W -.......- ;.......................... 70

<a V-3) 19964 444 3.## 44a...............................................70

M IM] 1996^ 4^^. 44"# ........................-.............4

H-2] 44^ f 4....................... .........................5

m-l) ^-4-§-4 4^44....................................................... 18

[3.^ V-l) 4A^1^ ^44....................................................... 64

1

I. ^ €-

4* **4*44* *4*44 411!- 1*7} *$M* 7}*tj] *4*44 4#1 41 7]#&] ^47^4^44 4!# #4*4* i*4 4# ±47}#- ^±4#/} ##4 #44, 7]14# n &9-44. 44±*4 44* *4 ±444 44* *#443i7}4i #44^.4 ;M^r H*Ji #4.

^!4#- *44 44 *444^ ##7}± ±444(^471-7: **)44 4 4444* ##}* ##±^ 4*4 #* *44^ 4**4 444 3. #4. .

44. JE47j-7:7j-44 #1^4 44%4* 4JZ.44 44 3E*7)-7: 444 44 44# 44#}* 44 **4* 4. 444-7} 444 4*4 ar* #H ^47}±4^4 4] 6±4 *444 Si* ^47}± 444 *

i • #* • *44 4* #7]-4i- HaLTfls. #4^1 44.*4. ^47}± 4471-4 *4 jtl*# 431# 14 **4#7i-4 *4

444 *444 i*7}± #*#^.4 *44# #4(Bench-marking/Yardstick Competition)* i#44. 4, 444*4 #4

* 4#*#* 44±& 4#44 ## %*4 431# 444 41 1* 4 *(4#/##4*. **±*. 447: ** *)# 4± 43144 .a*!* 4#±± 4#4#4 #44# *73114*41 40)4.

44* #44±& ##7|-7: ^44*4 ##4 #47} #4#3i ***

2

444 44€ 4#. 445471-5444 ##44 44(547}5444 4] 35. 4 235)# 4445. 434# 4444# 544 4c- 4° 14.

444 3 #4 4## #4 44#4^1(#4 #5444)4 4f4 4 44 4445. 4444 ^44^ ##44# #44# 4*14 547k. ##447f ^47^4^4 454 #4 4 #54 4 4 #4 444 44# # f-4 444. ##44. 447k: ### 44 f7}44. 444 44. 4# # 444#4 %#44 7)544 444 447} 4554 4* 4444 44 444 4455 4445 44.

4 44 444 4-8-4 4444 #7}, 44 7}5 4444 4$ 4 44 7)44 5.444 44 #44# 4455 #4 7}5#444 4444# 544-954 447k: ##4 5#4 45. 547}#4 45##4 44 4 44 44# #4 #4444 4# 44# 45445 7}5##7).^44 444# 4547] 44 444-5. 4445 44.

447)5 54444 44#4 44 4455 4445 4# #7]4 #

44# 4444 4444 ^44- 44^1-4 4#. 44# #44 # 4# 4544 44. 444 44#44 44- ## 444# 455 #4-7)455 #4444 4 4-45 4444.

444 # 44 44# 4444 445#4 45# #445, 4# 44

4# 44^ 44#54 44# 44 7|4# 5444. 447}4 4444# #4 4 44 444 #4# #44 # 4# 4544 4454 447}

4i4.# 4#4^i# 4# #-9- 447}5 5wj#47-i #445 4# 447}5

44^)4 44544 444 44 4444 ##4 44 447}4 44 %

1.4 # 3

#4# #447] 44 -5%]4ZL 4# 4-5-# -u-4if47l]J5# 45-4JL 4

44 4:E# #4 (#4 #4-^5.) 4 ^4^1# 44# 4##J17} ?]^-4 zz. #4^] %14.

44^ # #4 II 444 4#44 ^47]-^ 4^4 #4#III444# #4 ^.#4^4 #4#4# 44^1 #4# 4#.

#^4^#4 #44## #4#4.4#A& IV444# 4#7}^ ±w]#4 #44:# ##4 44 4

4^%. V#44# 4444 _a.#4^4 44 4#44 4^-4 4#4 44- . 44". 3^. 44 #44 ^4. 4##Ji %1# 4444 -S-##445- 4 4444# 44H5L7} 44.

444A& vi#44# 44 ^#4^4 #A# ^.#43E# #±w]jz# #4 #4 JE47Fr44 4444. #4 ##4^4 4iI4-## 44#^.4 44.

H.

1.

7^4-444^ 544 437}7l 434- ^^4% 34. 3 7}f4 4-4^47}^# 444 44^ 371^144^ ^44-7:# 4^-4Ji

34. 44-44 ^4;^444 ^4^- 19964 44 4^ ^47^^- 44 4 50%44# 444^1 34.

(nH 11-1) 1996td 44^, s|4i

4#44 90.8% 97I44 9.2%

wg•<<1r\U-l

*opZ

nS3M

5

71f

PWK

p[flJ

Z"<5 I

MP£

ru|nJu4

oOPtoTgr*•ojfll'F'

u4 ^^ 2:w KJp ’wVoVCO O")

o|n)

t'|o|-o"

to

M ^To"r

Menijm

Mo <|;y ^

£W

i\"£71

IN

U-l

ji Jp

s ?

u|m'o'

CDT K o

T P tob <1

rs

.is0‘W’W%r5IN7\°^ tor

zj w5° 7Jm

wKojw

IV

IT■sr5TC W7^° TT

UiIN

7b

T jjw

3" ^ Tto* w Jp T # W

' WwwTFN

75T r to P

#

? wO w

M<>n4x"

75T

ruo

?

o'KhmonnMo3IUu-loJW<_wCMI

mon

om a mo i<j jo

tF 4-toT 7bW *P *ojo oP

_- oKto

INKb

u-l

ozZ 7bg *IN

°\

■SrIN

7»T ^%r ?-of M'ST

%z" wHoTJCO OO OP

P o[<)J 71

<4-to?T o

jp wlr 'PcM 'ijoJ-RT IT5Jp o

; tolg "3*

1 \ T'lop ~\| ojo1 Tn too

1%

M Kh

<4

<1

oTJ<x>OOo

75" oT W|r

rl 75p PW W

5P U|o Wi<° KN~Z" N w"^rn> oj° p

tMwTJ

<7wjP

d"J W To"

INKb

K4'Z

r4w

°4’PtJpINN

tom°bojni^S°%

*

7T

<1

Kb

II. 7

61.2%3_ #7}4^4. 314^^ ^4^1- 7^- 4

Mg-IM 7>4 #4 444, 44 s]44 ^i# 444 444-i-, #4

44 4JE43. Mg##i #44 44.

<5 11-2) mu Mg# $o|(^:%)

£| AIx|°1

1992 1994 1996 1992 1994 19964 t> 43.7 73.5 62.4 36.8 58.1 54.4M # 10.4 31.2 53.5 9.6 29.1 49.24 * 30.8 54.4 66.5 28.4 54.1 64.8^ g 24.3 48.1 - 62.5 24.3 48.1 62.5si 4l 33.0 57.6 55.8 29.3 53.0 48.9

i|. eJ- , 1997

44 £47>m444 7144 44 • Mi444 447^44^44 44

471# 4444 44i f^MTll #g?}# 444. 444 44 M^M M441-4 44. 4m 43^1 ^4 ifi 444 44 #4 4 444?

4 444^(447i4^ M4)# 444% 44.a|4-4M ^r44&& 44M4. ?^7]-4 ^4M7j- 4# g# M47}^

4 44444 f (A)4 7M# 44, 544 44 444 g-444 ^-^1 444M, f7MMM #4471-44 4MM. 4444

444M 44 444 4/]## e 4444# 444% 44. 1993-964714# 44M47^4 4# 44#4^1 4M4 4# 44 4

44# ##W4 #7M1 4# 444. 7# M47^44 444# 4 4 #44 #M4 A#4 4#4 44#144 44M 4# 44 44#44 # 4444 444- M4M 44.

$i^7Hf4J2/r4 ^g^)4 #^1^4^ ^### 4]% ^f44^4 J&#sM ^l-#-(W^7|-)& ^-3#ji %[A^, W^;M ^1 ^f4

^ fe& 4#*M ^ Rl^-& ^4# ^7] 4^14.

8

<£ ll-3> A-j#xM £a|7^ 484 g^SS

0DHlf(b_Hoj m-)

S^tilS(%/ m") (@/ "4

HU4(m/7H)

eon#(m'/m) 9

4#1993 408.1 43.43 62.64 2.26 453.0 2071996 774.4. 47;64 \ 62.94 2.12 565.3 353

"n~"cF1993 279.8 58.69 62.59 5.83 370.5 1531996 653.4 62.78 60.38 3.48 471.9 239

4-&1993 537.1 45.45 55.73 2.81 353.6 2421996 1.234.4 : 45.64 55.82 2.20 552.6 . . 484. .

4-41993 118.5 42.23 55.72 2.34 448.8 541996 239.9 43.80 .56.67:4 1.90 651.9 \ 80 ..

441993 152.5 64.14 64.54 2.10 333.1 801996 376.1 , 45.11 55.93 1.98 . 590.3 . 193 J

f) 5;t)4^ 3^-9-aiMt- 4^ @1^ 1990^ 52% -» 1996^ 48.4%

^4-HN4 4. 44 ^)7}/:4 ^ 444 7-jf 444 44^3-44-^ -^-444- 444^. 44^ 44 4

444. 44 ^ ^14 4444-^1 444-3. 91^ 4 ^4 ^14-^ 44 4 4H14-4 4^43. 44. 444 44 34?^ 444-#- ^#4=4 4 ;H1 44 44 44^14-4 44?l-3 44.

II. 4-&44 247^ 4^^^- 9

2.

7K tfgm

44 4471-4.4^4 444 447]-±# ±444 4°d7|°44 444 <l

t7WM 47144 44, 44 44444 f-4 ±47l-±444 444 ^ 444 W4«M(^7k^-4)4]- 4f4 ±47l±44± 44=14 ^)4. 444 ^34 ^4. ^444 44 4^4 54r 4444. #. ±4 7^4^7}4 ±4444 444^r 44=14 5d4.

442_S 44&444 444±(443-104 m') 444 442- 4"A7l- 4 4f4± ±47l-± 4444 44444 4444. 444 444 e4 44 434- 444 44 44 444^ ±444^1-71- 442. f^M4 443-4 4 ^7] 4^-4 ±4447}4 ±4444(±47l-±444)44 44±4^4444.

(3. 11-1)44 4 4^ 4^ 44 44 44-444 f 44 A470%4)4# 4442- 42-4. 4444 442a. 44 44-#- f2^1-71- 44 4ir t4 444 44 444 42# 444±4 442 #±7}ai 4#

4 4f 4^r 4^14. 44 4^4444^ 4^T-§- 44±44 44 &4 4-#4 45.444 4444 44.

5;M 4-444 4^144 4444 94-4± 44 444 4±4#4 44&4^ 7^44 #4. 44. ^47}±47j-4 444^ ±4fr444444 4444 44.

10

4. 7R**1E

^-4 447}^ 3^-7}##- 44-B-. 44-§-. 44-§- f -§-^#5. 44 4 A 44. 444 44 A47}A3)44 4-A# 447}

A 3^4444 44 4445. $ 45.44444 4^)7} 4444. 3.44 4^4 4# A^l^}/}# 4444 A4)f3-4 4-A4 447}# 4 ^45. 4444 4t4 A^7}± 4444 4a4 ^444444 4^4 4 44 44 4&Q.-& 41444 514 44 444 45.444 444 44

(risk)A 4444 ^-3. 44.4#A^ 447^4 444 4SM 44 A5. 4#*}A 4A#. 447}

A 33-4-M4 44^)4 45., 44. 4»%44 44 4 444 4444 ^3-43-4 4fA447}444 44^)4 4-^1 44 44 #44.

4. ±4444 4# ±447)444 4444 4^4 21.4%4 444 # 44. c)4 4#7}±i 3^ /i#±L 43-4 44f^c) ^4^-44 444 A %)44 44 44-44 A#7}± 3^-4) 44 ifA# 447} 444A 4 44 4 44 4# 4A5 4444.

4^ A#7} 7}44444 444 A}^7}(437}^3-4)7} 444^ A 4 A44 7f-£- 4444. 44 ±447)444 ±4444 44*14 44 °1 44 444 444 444 44 7}#444 444 zl 4f- 3*] #4 4 44 4444.

4#A& 444 43-4 44 44 44)444 4445. 444 3)44 444 44- -8-34 4^)7} 4^34A 44. &4 444 4-4447} 4-r4 44 44 4444 444 33-#7}4 44 44-4 #7}?} 6)f444 44.

olvr|r

mX15

(ttbl

ir°t

gX

X Hi X XX XXI

r-jM Jl>j r|g

1 ftiiL ^ JL

o A JH 4A _g g

JXX

HXX

JAIVd|H

XXoVV

xH

1

XrtIV

Ir&XV.

r|V

! *1

XX*XXItIV

-A o|H

X5

tuVLA,XXt1

<AH

firHiA,xIVJAiOilnU=4

_ r>r rW Ho -|% X n[i X x

JTJ

XjiIV

Jjo

ic

!M

11bre.XX

X

i

oVLoAXMX

S* $"t X

M_ °|lX X X X »b 1° _A HuitiA —H_EL oAX M A -2-X X41 r|r' &

Nf

Xk044lA,1

i

§

AA

JAwX[U|o

ao

SLX

X d|4Xrjn XoK X4 rjo4^141

o2,

X 0tfc *& JAX X°r Xjb

X X*-jntXx4°!'riXo|rlHiXX

xXV

axiIV HI

_A Xo-

_SL

aXj

aHEXJAXXA-A

X

Ixg

—|ru

xpAe£Xx

nAXi

riL

I_b

aX

-A Hu

t i41 A

a-4 X 4H- X

JP-

=UxoSoA

iK1u:

A41

A,X

X ^or X oA X X X

ISA AxX

iu|° oA4<>X

IlAX X X. a

ojv

°r o>W|o4=>

XX rA# 1Jit-X jto Hi d[4A #1 r|r

JA-£itifi,HuXxXXn

6x.

HiAXHV

41 i>

XAXg

! eJ2y.o

Hu

ok

I

*

I; 5

s %H X d|4 _l&

Xol'tt

x WA, JaJA rjd 41 X m|ni X4° X X X X X^ q;

e X41 X

|tl|o

ag

XX

i;

4l iuE

ut>4 fjoJf rAo|i N$ SX oAf X is Xkg .A *

i IouXXdklg

flJXo|$>Hn

X

1jVL

oil II

vKK

'A KH

-f-H

'll

III. Z.*\7}± 4^4 #2)44 13

-§-<>] >#^6] 44 . #444 444 #4. ^F4#33 44444 3# 44 #41 444 #444 4#^ 44 4 #33 44 44.

4 #44 4 #4 ### #;}#4 #4# 44^ 433 4 #4 ### ie44—4447F 3#4# ##-& 4# 4& 44s. 4 444 #7]-

4 444 4444 4-44- 334^4 #3# ^F## 2:4# f 44- #3 4 44### 344# 4# 4 #4# 433 ###/|#4-#- #44. # 44/1-4 3#### #3 #443> 4-2^4- #44# #4- 4444.

jz.44 #4433## #3#44 #444 #3 >3#44 ^}#3# 4 444 ?l444r #7M 4^1#- ?F33#4 #444 ##44# ##7}f4j 7} #3 4 44 #44 #443. 44 4444.

4 #41 #4#- #37}# 4# #44 #44- 4 #4# 433 44# # ;M 44 ### #3##3 44# A## #3 #37}## #444 4 #433 4#44 #3 #-#-433 44-444 #4# 44- ##4. 4 # 44444 44 44444 #444 #4i- 4444, 44# 444 4 344 -8-#, 44 ##3#4 #44# 44# #444 4443 >44 4 4# 444.

44 #4, #44 #4# #7»#t- 444 44-4# 433 #343 3 43/H1 4# #44 #44- #44# 433 #7»# zl 7}zp} 44 44 44-4# 4#43 44.

#4# 347j-3/}##44i #443 ## 44 ## 7F37}#4 ## 7M#4]> >## ##4#& 34444 >#44# 4# #443 4# 44 44# 444-4# #4# # #3> ?}# #7j>4 #4# ##4 4#34 #443 #4.

344 #7j># ##-& 4-443 ##> 44#, >## ##41 4##

14

4444 4-a# 4447] 44 A-g-44444 4 4#444- %4^: ^A4^r %14. ^. 4^4 44^r 444 44 4447] 4%- 4 iM444 44 4^ 4:444. 444 444-&4 f44^ 4^24444 4t°14.

447}% ^-444 &7l4^ 4^M44 ^44# 447}444-& 44 4t4, 44 444 4# 447}% %g-444 444 4 4%2 444 Ji^44^ ^44534. 4^ 44 104 444 4^-b 447>^^7i]^ 444 444 444% 44.2) 4%44 44 iHHf-Jz. 4 444 ^4^ 4A# 4447] 44 2^-44444 4^]-§- 4f% 4 f 44444 444 4# %«]7}#4 44-1- 4444^4 44 1987-19914 44 ^4^ 7}%^-44 442f# 422 44^ #44.

2.4 4 444 %4444 4-fr4-#-7}4 444 4444 447}%4 4 44-& 4^44 441 447}4444 44] 2^4^ 4444^ 4934.

%44 447]-% jiL-g-o] %^$t-£]jL 4^44 4444^] ^-444 ‘90

444 2000444 447f%444 4444 4- 4, 447}% 44-S:i-i-

4%^: f 4^4 &4& 2^-444-44- 4^4: ^244 4^4% 44.

44 ^-4 247}% f2^ 2^4 -M. 444-4. 44 7^4- 424 f4. ^144-4 ^44 4-4 e444 ^422 f27} ^-44 44-4% 534-. 444 4:4-1- f24 #7}^ 44444 247} 414925.

:g-g-4%M7}44 44. 44. 44f44 %7]4- 444 44-4 ^-4447}#ji ^4,

444 4^425 44427} 4444 53^ 44 2444 442) ^7}^). io^4j . 71] 4# 23 337^ 333 #

III. ^}7}+ 15

# #4 #5444# 4# 41444 444 /Ml 4, 4*3434 44## 44# 44*144444*1 5*l7l-55#44# 44# 4. 4 #4 44

#344* 44 444 3#^ 44* 4# ##4 4*^1# 4# 44 44 ^*P\ 4/11 # 44.

444 /}#4 4 444/1-44 444 44444 44 44 44# 4

5# 44 4444 44# 44 #34 4 #3?M 444 &4# 4 #

4444 4.4*115:4 S-°P 1 4444.

2.49.^0171^^#}

44/1-51 3#4 44444 44/1-5:444 4444444 44 5*1 71-5:444 4# 5:44 444455.44-44. 5*1/1-544, 44444 4 4 4#4 45444 444# 54444 ##44# 544544441 2054 4444 44*14# 444 #4# 44 *1444.545 5*145 ##44# 4445#4544 #54 43.4(5*1?}

5# 45#4 ##44)4 5*1?}5444 ##44# 444 ^^MMM 44 4# 4444 44 4#(*1 - 5*14)4 #4# 44 *1444.(5*1?}5444 4 205)

44 44*144 44# 445*l?l-5*}444 ###4* 7}a3#4 ##54 ^ 4*4 #44 44 44^1 4444 #44 5*1/1-54 ## ##4* 544 #4/1- 444 /}5*HM}4 55# 444 4# 444 43?)- 445 444 44# *1-5444M1 ###4 4*4 44# 4 4 5*1# 44 4# 454 * 4# 4#& 44 44.

444 **444 3#*4*44 ^144# 44*444- 444444

16

^ ^

47^4"^ ^4 $44 44MJ&# #4 - 444 $ %144

44^1 ^4.^q. ^. :M14 4$. 4<4$4l$$^ _a.g-4M 44f44

fl4$4. ^.4f$4 ±4f$4 ^47^44444^4 44 44 4# ^.4444 4±i-44 2n4 4Ji ^ 4^ 4444.

447]-^ A^-444^144 ^4444 4 & 4# 4444^./M4 4 44 -&7HM444# #| ^& f ^4. ^4444 $f$$4444 44. d:44447i-b 4 . ^14^. 44 ^44. i4^-44 44^- ^4 ^44 444 44$ 4Ji 4^ 4^1 4444. 44 4 ^^4 444^ zz. 4#4|^4 44^ 44f4. ^44 A4$414 444 47l$4 4^ $)4 444. 44f44 44$4^& 4^H _9_^fe44 A$444 41$$ $444 7]$4$ 4^43. ^4.

3. 5-47}^ 54KM4 7]#

$4 ^47|-^A^$ ^47^^^^ $$$^7l$41 ^.44.4 1993 44 444-4$7l- 444 ^47}d:$$til$ 447l^j 4 4444 4 443. 44.3) 3

3) ^4334 A3443 CL 34 -a.334447} ^144 3444 A344434 44 44 4444 ^4-^-4. 44 4444444 444 33-S.4 4443(4). 44 A 44443 44- 34-44 -&4* 4444^}. 19954 104. 124 447}^ 32.4^3 444- 44 44 ^4^-4* 4444 44 43(4)4- 44444. 444 443 4344 444 5144^ 34^13 4443* 34A& 44 7^^4^7je* 4 44.2-4 44.

III. 5.a]7>a 4 17

4 nfH.ig, 7^ A3# £7]7i-dhA>^47> 7^1- 33

4#4 ##4# W^7}# £34# 4#°M ^5]37 blrf. &^7l-

# 7)-^7}4 444^ ##44 444^M SLA]?}^ -2-3-4 &£4# 4 a^7H 7}^^4 344J1 4# 44 4^l #j;4 7j-^oi] tfl^ AiAjjf

7}^# y-Aj-y. 3-6j]A5. 4444.4 -3LA]A}7}. 444^t|j JEAl7}TlA}.a| 33-^1# A]-^A] A}<^7}7} 44

4 4# #43 44-5-5. 44^1# 44^5. 4:2-, 444 a»7> 4

4- 4>i4 44 a>^7>^s. 444^# 44.33-^13-4 44# 4440^ 44£ g-Ag 3-34374#- 7]a_3. 44 I'd

44 334# 44! 414^# #4?}# 444- #44 4444. £47^ 4-34 444. 4-71-43- 3- 44 44444 44# 4444 344 44 444 434—5. 344 4 &£# 4^ 44.

34 ^47}A^33 #334# 3, 4447>4 #7^3 ne]3i #7}

Afl4# 44 43# 4444#4^& 4t4 4#4# 4. 4 434 3

444# 4#4 44.

III. 19

^444 »fl#4«l# 44#4#^4 ##4# ##5^4 -n-45-T,

#4#4, 4444, 4##4 4-4 ti-*) £444 ### -^-#4 #4 4 #444 4^4444 ##, i-444 4 4444 44 #44 5.4

44 #44.

#44444 7^444 #444 #4444 44, 4_&4 #4, ## 44, 4rA3:4. 44 #44. jLa.44 H)-§-A&4

#5.4 #7}# #f4 ^.44 444 4444.###444 7}>i44444 4)4 4#4# 444 ### 7^4

4 44, ##. 44] 4# #*) 4 444 44*4# #444 #4# 4

4# #44.

4#-*)# # 4#Jg_, 44*14. 4-7Hr# 52 f444#4 444

7HI #44# 4444444 4444.

f4*14. -n-7l^#6]^ ^ #4###- 44#7M)4 44^1-b

444t444 4444.

4##4# #44££ 4##7M 7I-444 #*.4 £#7l£ ^-#4

4 #4^ 444 .&#4 444 #A34 4f4£#44 4#4 44 IN

4 ^4# 444 ##_*£ #7^1 #444. #7)1 LPG44 LNG&

#4# #444 4# LPG 4^44 4#^4# 3-5#4 4#f# #7}

4 #44jl #4.

4.

44f4£f( = A^-71# X ^.4^^-)4 4#7}7l- £47^*

4£, ^-#7] #44 44 i44£ 4-b 4443- 4%4 444 4)4

444 5-t-F 4444.

20

_W44^ 443.444, ¥43.444. ^14714. ^ 447)44 43. 5. ¥444. 44^47)44 7)^4 $7)44^171447-1 4447)4 44

444 47^-4^14 ¥44 ^ $^7)4. 44¥444 ^-6] 7)^7)?) ¥

444 #¥ 7)44 ¥44 ¥444- 444 443^. 4Ji 44 4n 44

444 7M-& 7]#^_g. 4444.

44 443.47)47M44 4444 447)44^1 ^444 4. 444 444 44.

o 4444 : 44 447M14 447)4 % 7)717)4 44

o 44 44.34444 44 : 7]A, 44444 447)4

. 443.47}4 4 °147>44- 4&7M4 714444 44443.3. 44.

¥47)4¥ 444^ 47H&4# 444 44^1$47i 474^44. 44 44$44 444. 44^)444 $44 444. 4$44. ¥4347)4 444 4 4444#4-§-& 444 444 244 ¥3^ 44.

44471-^-444 4714441 44 ^444 447>^4 44 2l¥1Hr 7)717)5.4 447)54 ¥4^3. 7)$4444 4444.

7)74)54 44 i¥¥¥ 44 10%, 44444 44 21444 44

4^ 444 44^444 (¥37)4^ 44444$ 44)33. $ 44^

4 44 47M- 4t°1 44 445. 44.

4. ¥444

4 . jE7i44r 447ki444 44 ¥$ 44. 444^14 $4$ 444 7l 444 444*1 cl-#-i4 43^. 44 47)4434 444 3 441 4

III. 5.A]7}± 1*14 44ti<M 21

441 ^>4 44 W#7HM 4^.4 f/MH# /Kl:# 3 %1>4. o] 4

3 3/1144 4 3» 4344 4># 44431 ti<hhi 33^M4 1>4.

4. S! 3343497134 %7[

^47^44 33til3 44433 4 .^]47j- ^4/l-> ^l^}

4 44344 >4/}>444 7d44 444- 5JLS>7l 444 >47l->4

4^}4 344> 444 33430- 4444 44 44^1 4^4^1> 4

44 43 43# 4343^1 :% #4# 3> ^4.

444 444 til44 4 < 4444 >4444 ## 4444434

43 3>4 447]- 43 43 ^14^14 434 ^ /M4 4*144 43 4>

4#^ 44 4^3 4-3-47M1 /1344 4# A332: # 44^4 a41

4444 #3 44 44M1 -§->4 /M33# 44^4 343 ^>4-.

#># 47M34 44 471434 44 -§->4 4/}4 4/1-4471- 44

4 7j^4^1 #34> 4>4. 43 44^1 >3444 4444 434 tij-4 33 /l! #4/134 4 3444 444 444 £v]ik 4> 43 444-.

44 34 4 44 #71334 44# 443 44441 >344/} 43 4

3443 443 3# 347} 44-. 4-4-71 4444 4/1-4 434 >34

344 7j-^4M1 7H447>34 443 434: 3 43 /134 4-44 >3

44.

#4> 33til334/133 #4444 >4/j->4 334:44 4-444 2ol44 43 34344» 449» 33«133 34^1-341

43 341444.4) /}>33til33 3>4>, 4444 >4, 3>/i4 3 4

4) °1e11> 5-4-b ^^^$11^444 <31 44 £4/3444 4H-& 4£ ife 4

22

4 # 44 4-4% 44/1- 44% 4" %1A%^-##4#44b 4444 <&444# 444% 4 ^4. 44

44 44444 4444 444 #4# 4444 #4 444 444 # 4. 44^44 44 # 4^444 444 444 &44 f 44.

443^ 444 444 44444 444 444b #44 b4°l##- 444^r s.#i- 4% 44. 444 #4b 44444 7] &4 444^- ##44 ^47^44 444 #44 4^1# 4444 4

4 4#4 4## #4*1# #4# 4#4 4#4# 4444.5)44^1 #44##b 4447|-4 444 444 4-N- 4444 44

4#7l# 47^44- 4# 4471- ^14b ^1444 &# f 44. 444 ##^1# 444 4f44 4#%7l- 4#4#&4 7^^#444 444 4444 #4# 44b 3-47]- 44. 7}^}^^. 3.444 #4 444^1 %4## 44(44 4444)# 4# 4#4. 444 # 444b 4b# %7g/^ #44 o^= ^;}4 %44 444 ##=U. 7>^4 #444 444 #4444# b#7Ml 44 iW 44^

4#44 444 #A7}#4 4-4- 4# 47}_a.44 444b 44 444

4. 444 444 7#44 47MH #44 444 444 # 4b 44 # 4#4 4^7} 44. .

44, ##4 44b zl 444 47M1471444 7^4 4443. 44*lb4 4#4 %7l-#r 4447] 441 zz. 447} sib 7^444^, 7^4 444. 4444, 4444 4 444 444 44 44# 44# 4# 4 5

-&4"M4 #5. sRslfe 4W4.5) ^=«fg-44^ 3^;} 47]^ b 5)4. ^7# ^

A#4# %M3bM ^7l-#4A^* 4^«1#4 444 5)7] 43-4 a|44 ^-wj-g-^-^^3-47} 47]^ b 5)4.

HI. M/k: ^4 *444 23

4. 4-7-15. 4 4/M 44^* 44 444 A^41?1- 44-y- ol 4. 444 444 444- 44* 4 4^44* 44 45*4-1- 54^444 44^i* 7^4^ 4455444 7^6] D}

44 4*71- 44. 4* *54*7144 44*44* 44* 7MM. 44 ** 4^^171-^ *5444 44 44-4 44**4 444 *44*4* 444 44* 7>*4.

7k*44 *44^}# *44 444 444 *5^47144 *4* *4 4447)-#- *54 4^^- 444^ 44444 4*444 44 44^ * 4* 444. 44* 'g** *5444 ^}444 44-T-7MM4 44 44- 4-444 44 444 444 **71- 44. 4444 4*4 44 4 44 ** 4* 44*45. -T-7}7H 5* 44^ 444*

*44 * 44 **44 5*** jl44 4444 444*4 44** 44 4-7)44 *5^*4*(4* #4 *7)444*5*4 47)-) *4 4 4 3.47} **44 *5-444 4# 454 44444 444 *4* * *443. 44.

4. M^^414)

7 k EDH25-

44 *4*5* 45445-44 55^1* 44*. *47k^47M 55 4* E47ki* **4 *5** 444* 4, LNG *47)-44 *4*4 4** 44 #*44 457^57} 55H)** 444 4444.

44445441 44** 4*4* 44* 4*44. 7^54 554*

24

7ie^-n-7} # ##-#

###7^& #^.#(^#-, ###-.

4 44 #4.

Jl4# 4^-44 4#

###- 4#. ##. ###-)&

4. EA|7^

#4 ^4} #47^7^ 44

7M4 E7]7>es]x>5] 4444(4:4 44 )-§- #44 ##44, #4^i 4

## 44 44 -§-£# ###7M ##-& 4# #444 7j#o] ^&| q

7M1 7]e# #-^# A^a- ###7] jz4# #4 4&44#4 44^ ^4j7i ##4# ####

^##4 #E# A^4 ##4% #4. A^Ml^- #4 44#-. ###-. ###-. #44##-. ###-. 4##- # 6;ij& 4r44 #4.

#4## 4#^#^ 6rn' 447). 2|7i 447)44 (Minimum bill) 4 4^), 4^f 12 m'4# 4 #7}#-, zl A]##- 4»J--§-E & E#-44 #^4 ^#43. #4. ZL4% ###-. 4##-. ###-4 4# #4^44 #4# 4#Ji #4. 19904. 19914 A^#44 # ##44 ###-4 4f 44 ^44 4^-4 44 #-^4 4##4 4#- 44^.4, 199244^ ##44 #E# 444^ 44. 4###- 5-9# 4 #4# 4\&-3- #444 #44:1 #4.

6) 4-M4 ^4- ^^N14.

HI. -SL^i 25

lll-1> 247^ ##7R1(1995. 8)? # “jg§ EA|7|-^s

*)S.Hl ■y ^ 125.35 Wm"

61.0 il/V 61.0 Wm"

^S.til+61.0 WmJ 186.35 -tt/m-

til JL ^ : W^kcal

- ^-g-: 196.66

- «g^-g-: 202.59

- 179.54

- yiNt#-: 125.35

- 4g-§-: 173.33

f: 1) ^}7\m -fit.

5. ^|-§-

^]7>^A><y^ ti]^-s| *]&>] 50%44i- 4^142144- -S#4] 444# f-444 444# ±.V]Z}7\ 444#

f44^4 44 f4 44 44^1 ^444 ^4 44- 444 4444

i47}f-4 4444 4444 -f-444 444 444 4 #44 4#^4 44.

44^5. 44 44444 444 444 44 4A& 4444, 4 ^4 44^444^1 #7^1# 444 44. 3 444 44 7^444-34

44=^& ±47} 444 444 ##447} 444^.4444 44 444 #7>43i 4-M, 45/} 44 #7H 44 4444 444 ±47} 44444 444 4444^4 44 4#445. 444

26

^7}S}JL %14. tiller ^4% «]£

4 ^tb ^-S-4 ti]A.^Ajs].7j. 6]=.&|^J7 ti]-§.^7> ^1 a

y°]4.

<S 111-2) 1997^715 iA|7^ ggu|#

(4}4: %)

4# 4# 4# ?M SHE!

°j7dtl] 23.62 15.70 18.15 17.86 25.37 19.61

^M-44 17.42 26.66 20.08 22 32 19.90 21.10

441*1 2.47 3.15 1.04 4.47 6.38 2.65

44444 5.06 4.70 4.17 5.09 3.94 4.55

44443- 16.34 10.50 16.43 21,90 17.83 15.55

3*13 1.25 0.96 0 86 1.02 1.23 1.03

714^^*14 8.56 6.11 7.60 6.42 11.62 7.81

4434 25.29 32.23 31.66 20.92 13.73 27.72

W^7} 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00

<£ 111-3) 1990ti7|5 5A[7^ ggw|#(^: %)

CHS! 4S 4# ZM S1Z! SMI44*1 30.06 10.76 15.57 22.84 14.88 17.45

47W-44 36.85 37.85 30.18 . 37.86 41.27 35.82

44*1 0.82 0.45 0.07 0.72 0.44 0.44

44444 2.21 0.63 0.41 1.42 1.98 1.10

44443 6.69 0.85 5.86 5.44 3.85 4.13

3^3 0.84 0.22 0.48 0.71 0.80 0.52

7l4°!<ti*14 10.18 3.45 6.53 10.61 5.17 6.42

4434 12 36 45.79 40.91 20.39 31.60 34.12

100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00 100.00

4s.) tR-^i^t-^-ysi, i-47 ^(LNG) 4^44*]4 1992. 6.

27

IV. ^ iMMM

1. 4

^1#4 7}^44# #44%% ^34, ##. #44 3;H ##%% #34

4 44. a34t#44# 4 8,0004 34447} 444 444% 444,%4%4 #^4 3444 4#% 44444 444 6040 4%44.

####4# 2,5004471- 444% 4%4 44444 224471- 44 ##4 85%-t- 444% 44. %4% 44%Al7}%44 44 4 3,0004 7fl% 44447} 44 444, 44444 44# ^1# 44% 44.

1980444 #4 444 4444 44%% 4)444 44%47}%44 ## 44% 4%7}44 44 ##44#- #4 ##447} 4444 4%4,

4#4# 44 4^%ul7}7} ##444 44%47}%4A}# 444 #% 44 ##44# -F4 7}^# ##4# 4^7} #44% 44. 44 44 # $ 4 44%47}%4xRr 44 44%# 4#4# 44% 4%4% 44.

71. 3^44

mau% 44# ^144. 4##4 #44 ##% #%7M 434# 44%47}%447} #444- 7}44. %44 #44 444 44 447144 ##7l#4 #47} 4f44 44444 444 444% 4# #444. 44% #%7}4 44 7}%4 44# 444%% 44444 44.

28

Lh

7}^4 zHr#M 4#4. 4^2.## 44444^471- if414# 5114. 44 #47^444 4$2.## # #444#44^444444^14.

##% 44 ### # #444#44^44 #4444 44. 41## ##7}4 4444 444## 7^4 7}#444 44. 44 #47l# 444 44444- #4, 4444 4°M 4444 44471-4 4# ^M4# 44. 4# 4^7}7} 444 44##4 4444-E- 44# ##4 445-4 44 4471# ###4 (Performance Based RatemakingM## 44443. #44# 5(14.?)

##44# ### 4°l7f 44. 44 4# ##444 ### ^l#4^i 7H44 444 44 44°1 44 4# 444 ##4471- 44=144. 4# 44 7|A4 4#^1###47} 44444 4#4, #42- #^}4 44 444 #44# #444 #44 4##4##4# 44^ 4f# 44. 4##7H44 #444 ### #44# 44 444## 44 514.

4. 44^ 34 44

W#7M1 #444 ### 4444 #4 4#4 444 a.# /i4^

til-H- 47H1 4444 44# #4 44442.4, 4# #44# 4# 4 #7l###4442.44# 44#. 44 44 4741## 4444 444 44 44 444## $144 #4$1# 4#7> 444# 44.

7) ^471t A^-4^4 4^ 2-#N 4^1# V. 44 34SH 514.

IV. 29

2. <3 ^

7K rn ^ 4821 yen

##f# ### #44 44, 4". BG pic?} 7}^44& 4# #4^-4. 44444 44444 4444 44 -*144444 =44 #4#3i 44. 4^-414 7^4 ^ f 4-^444^ BG#4 107^144 #4#7l- #4 #31 9114.

44, 44, 44, 4444 44 s.4 444 4444 44 #44 4 WKTranscoM &#. f4#3i 4#. 4#^ 4-&7T4 444^^4 4 7}^# 4i#4 #4#(Shipper)# 4 604# 4^7> 4^4, 44 4fLi«l7>44 #47^# ^i#^- #44#(Supplier)# 4#i fA 7j-& ^ #4/#4-M#4 627])#, zz.#3i f-^j- ^44 7M44 154#7l- 44.

#4 4^# 447^ #44r 4"##^- a.# #^-44 7}^^ #4

4 4#44# 4#-^ 4i#4^4, 4# #### #4# 4# #4# 7> 7j^#4 44-# f 4^- 45-1- 44-5^ #31 44.

4. £!£R4I

4# ±44=4 4 6.000m'(10.500kcal/m' #e)-& 4#^- =r-S-7>4 4# 7>># 4443 #44 #444 7}###4 4^-4, &#% # ^7}(4# &##= 6.000 m' 4#)4 4#i^ #4^ 44#^- 44 ###71- ^lf4#3i 4^-4. 1998##4 4# #44 #4 44# #-%-#

30

7} 4f44 4MA3. 44.

4. 7&m

3344 4#A(44. 44#^1 f 33-4 7]^ A3)4 447^3444 34# 4% %4. 444 334^1 43-^444 43

s. #A7M1 44 43447M# 4331-5)4 $14. 44o)| diif-a. fA7)- 4 44-4-c 43 7^^-g- 344 (Office of Gas Supply)4 7^34 347} 434A 44.

344 44^1 4# ^3^- 3.93-4 4tl A344 ^ 4^444 44 4 44 A4. 34 A344# 4^4 A& 43A3444. A3 3$)M}4

4 44 4/H ^45. 3344 434A 44.#4# 33#^} 7)44 7]e4^4 3#47}4 (4^ #7M-^i-^

##A#)# 3-4 3M 4&4. 7}^]^-%i-4 f7}p]^i- 44 444 4jl 44/M4 44 7>44 34434, A34#^44 44 7)3A34f 4=A3^1 4#4A& 443-4# ##4-4)

ah @M4 #4

-2.-34444 7}3.A44- ^44 (Gas Consumer Council)# -2-3347144 7}^33 3-444 -9-34- 444 44# 4444. ^-4 A 7}^ #3 344# 33 4##3 #&#4 3#34# 3444 ^44. A3 # 44^1# 444 4#i# 3A?1# 4-9-3. 44 44.

8) 3/^MiM M144 44 ^M14 ^1^3 v.4°U ^s|5)4 $14.

IV. 9^4 #1)3# ^ #4^4 31

□K ajh|3 *j°| afaj

7>49 9414A3 4443 $19 4434 4^H- 444 7j 444^4 Aiw|/L7iee 4444. 4* 4444 #4 4-M 44^ 34 ^Hl 44 34-3^- #3(44 43 11 493 34). A93#44 44^ #4 494 994 44 ^7^ #4 9947M1 7^43 #449 -& 4443# #31$14.

44^44 499 71-399. #97143. 4499. 44. A9#9. 4 4 A 49. 444-4. 3444 #4 ##4 39. 3.44-4 49^N. 3 44 4# 44#4 94 104 9A 4943 9 384 ##3^ 9-444 $14.

3. 54^

7K A|§ §L| A^°| ^E||

3#3 71-344i" 71443 $19 4"7> 3-44 GdF(Gaz de France) 9 444 $1 9494 4^334 4#7l34 9494 444 t4^t4-^44% 444# 44& 9443 44. GdF4 499 3# 4-94 3444. 4-4-4# 7}3#44^4 84%7l 194644 #4^43 GdF4 4 #4 $14.

444971- 3943 $19 174 7}39447l-7l- $134. #94 71344 4 44 494999 444 44144. 4433 GdF4 EdF(Elec-tricite de France)44 444 44 #94 944 99# 444# $19

32

4 4^ 3/M GdF#/^} EdF4 #44# 44* s|Ji 44. 4*4 *4* 4"4^}# *4 4*44 Elf* 1983^4 4444

4—4, 44 4*4 #444 4—4, Lacq 44414 4 Lussagnet *7] ^7};*] a] 44—44* #44^%. 44. CFM(Compagnie Fran- caise du Methane)* Lacq444Ai 44:-^ 7}—* 4444 *#44 44 4** *tJL 44.

4. 5!2JSJ **i|

7^4 *4* GdF 7} *443. %13_4. 4* *^^.*4 7^44-4443 4* 4*44*4 444 GdF4 44 °l 34* *3 44 4444.

447I-A4 *#* 4^ 3* ^-7144 4± 30%4 4## 7}4* * * m* 44§^4447} 4443# 44 44. 4* 194944 f44 4 *444 4-7144 44^ 4444. *4* 50%44^& *444 44 *4. 199344 44444 444 30%44^. ;M444. *43 7}34 4A1444ir 4443* GdF4 44447} *443 44 4444, 444 444 444 444 4*3 344.

*4**4 44^-14 GdF7} 34^4 44 3* 444M1 #*4* 44*3 43* 44 t 4 444 444 GdF444 4# 4447}# 4443 44.

4. mm\

44 344=4 5 Gwh(4 41*m3/10.500W)# &4^}# *344 4)4A1* 444*3 444 4-fr444 44. 444 3 ^144 t*44 4

IV. 58.^4 H *44*1 33

#15 dj7Hls. 44 44.

4*44 GDF44 7|)^4^ *54)44(34 4*)#1 <3*4 4*4 444 /M444 if^i)# 444, 4 7)#4 47-)44 6?H 44 **±

4441- 444 444±* 44 44.±*± 4A7}4) 44 5** *54)44 47-)44 344 4444 4#

^7))4^,) 4444. 5** 44^ 47^* 7}5*HH)** ±444 7)) 44 47)-5)o). 47}^ 4* 44^5. (i + *7)*^- - *5 *4* x

0.5)4 44 4444. 5*445 44444M **45 44 4*5* 71)4(54 5**)44.

□K gas) g?H

GDF4 444444 ±44 45. 344 4444 ±444 44* 4)

44±4 4± 44.

4. 4ti|±14 #B|

71-44W4 4 44 44±44 441- 44471 44 GDF4 445 4*4 ^-* 87M14 5*4)5 4±)* *444 41**4±* 43l 44. 4# 44 4*45 44 150 54* ±44°114 ±44±± 4*±* 4± 44.

34

4. 4 %

7h A|£ qj Apjo) m

Ag4f ^44^ ^ Y7||A}7l. 44431 4^-4. =r44- 8;M 447}^ ^43 4^). oj^tiiiM 80%4^^r 44 5}jl 44.

4^4^44^ !7;)jAM.AM4- fâ)-3 4^41. 4#^- 3)M ^ 44) 4 ^^7^# #7]2] 443EM4- #4 3-H1M4 1^3 44^- ^

^7}4 <#& 4^^43144. 4^4 AM %4tr 4)42.44-§- =r^ 4^4 509H 4431 44. ^44) 2)4) f=7^(Ruhrgas)^ 4 A^ 33] 4^44 75%# 44431 44. 44 EU# ^4^. ^4^31 4"c 7M4$4 44444 44^- f=7M 4 4444 ^^7j. 4^^- M>3 44.

44^4 f^7}4 4)^^ %4f# %&4 ^-4 77444Al 44 JEAMÂM- ^43& ^-431. 4if3L 4f4M 4/^& 44431 4444444. 3.44 444AM 4^34 7)^44. 44 S.*\7}± $|A]^ A)4»l^ ^5]J7 dl7] 4^4] 444^5. 3. %

7|- 43.. f#)A}3.f4 447}^# 9-444 4 4 9A7M1 9^-431 4 4. 444°! A]7}^jÂi 44431 444, 7144 *J3M 44-44 #aH1

44 447)4 ^4# 431 431, 7M%4 ^-44 44% % 44

4HM4-& 44^ A}Bii7l- ^4. 44 ^47}^ %4A}4 ^ 500- 5507H 4^4 4^ ^4431 44.

iv. f_a_74 35

4. 444 ^n\

3#% 4\&7H4M 4^4-^ #4#4 47}# 4# 4^47} 4443

a. ###3 44. 4)if% 4-SL7M 4)^714 ##444 4##^1 #}#4 4. 44iM4M4 44 ##447} 44433. 4443.. 444 444 4M44 44444 4444 44.

4. 7R344I

3#% #3;}(#?) 3#%4 44. ### #3?}) 4 4)4444 44 44# 4% 43.4, #34 44 44 43. 4**4. 447}4 ##4 4*4* 444 44=7}44 4443 44. 4)4% #37H 4)4 7}444# 44433. 7)4-4.514 44.

34% #371-4 44 3*# 44-433 4443.4 44-4 4*44 444% %I4. 4443 4## 434*4 444, 437)7) 4444 # 44 *4 %* 3#4# 444 #444 4*44. 44 **% #37}4 4M4^ 3##47} 4^43 44.

3*44* 4# 4*3*447} 4)**44. *^=3*4 44434- 4*4* #4* 3#^}* 4*7} #4.

4. §34 o7H

4*% #37}4 44^1* 7M4 4)4 *34*7} &44. &*% *3

36

5. g

7h A|§ 51 48o| m

4#4# 4^. #4, 44### #44 ^7|-^A^7} 244AA 4.4. 4# 444 17344-44, 444 7144# #444. 4-5- # 4#M 44 4 #5 4-S.7H1 7^# ##4# 445- 7\^}^}s] 44444 7^44 45(14.

4. iS^5| 774

±#5 #±71(44 ±444 4 2104 m'UO.500 kcal/m')44)4 44 ### #4444 444 4711- 444 444, 445. #±7M1 44 4# 444±± 444 44451 44.

±#5 #±7H 4444 ±## #4444 444 47ft 444 4 4, 445. #±7H 44 714444 4-fr44$i4.

±#5 #±7H 4% ±## #4471444 #4±4^# #4# 45

44. 19964 ±### 4# 4471^4 5.34%# 4#4± 4±4. 4^1 4 ##4 #4 45# f-4 47144 #±#4 4445 44. ±444# 44 ##4# 4# 4#±#3M(34) ±##)44, #4±44- 44 44 444 ±44 44.

4. g?H

±#4444471 #444±# 4-KM ±#44 44# ±wj7M) #

IV. ^ 37

4-E-4" 'S’fjl, A}47}4 44 ^#"4 #iL# 44^ $1

A}4 44Aj4# 44^-4 to to. totoA^M^ -&to44 -f-444- toto 4«H .&to4 A44- to 4-4 4 toto4 to to.

4. Aiti|^o| 2IB|

^4-toto 4 44 4444 4to 4/}# toto# to to4

4to 44.

6. 7}^<^to4 44^

1980^44f to 7)-^±to4to e 4^4 4-4& to 44. to4 44Ato f44 7>to 4to44 444 4to44to4

4 444- 44to 4^4^1^4-44 7M4# 444 f444. 4to 7}to 444 to4 447} 444 44444—4, to4^ 44 toto7}(44 tolto 444 4-44^- to)4 44 to4i7}

4to-^s. 4444 44 44to, 7}±4 447} 4-n-44to. 7144 (1) 7}to447}, (2) 7}to to to to 4 44 ^ 4 44

to4i- 44 to to 44 to toA}47}, (3) to 4 44 toto 7}to 44to to 44 4-3- 4444 444 447} toto 44.

44 444 44to 4 to 44to 4444 7}to!444 444#to to to 44to44 444 to, to^}444 3-S. 4 & to to 4 to to 44 to 4-to ^1# ^4444 3M 4444 444 4^4. to4 1980444 to 4444, 4^34 to4 4# 7} 444 to 44 € 444 444- to 44. to 4 to 4to 7}to

38

4iM #4. EU4 44444 44444 ^1 444 444 # 4#&^3 44. 47]a^ #4^i 44 4 4til 44if-44 ^ 4-§- 44# 3 444 44 3 ?4 44.

7K

4471-3AM4 4443. # 4, ^-r-4-c- 44^4y|- /M4 4443 44. 4^133 7^#7|- 4^4434.44-4 4144 f#4 f444 4-f-c f44 4-frSM- ^lf 443 44.

3.43. 4f##4 444-c- 44447144 444#4 ##7l- 4 #4

43 ^4. o]4 4.4. ^4^4 4-&4-B-& 4f4 4r4AM7|-^4M4#4 . 44##4 4444 41# 44 4^ #471- #Ag?}3 44.

4^ ##### 44^1# #44##4 ##4# 4#3 ##7H 44 A^ AgA} 4^-4^ 4#^1 #71-43 44. 343 4#4-7HlA^ #444 44-Ai- 4## 7^^a. ^34334 4^17} 7} 44I44-& Ad4% # 43# 43. 44.

4. mm44-4 7}47}7|- A)#*)j 4444 71-7:41 71-7:4 114 71-^4 1#4

# 4413& 7M# 4-R-3MJ7, 444 4.471- 4^ ##^4##4 4 aMir 444 4444 4443 44.

71-7:4 7^4 114 444.3 444^.4 114 444 f4-4Al 7144-144- 7M4 443 44-71-4 4#A^ ?M 7^44# 4443 4 34. 443 43 44# 444. 44 344=4 41#3 444 3#3

IV. 9! *444 39

**#4 444 44**4* *±4± 44**4 444 44

i- 4444 ±444 tiD*4* 4*# *44± 44.

4. z^mi

-0-*# **^14*4# 44-44 *44 **#±# *44# 44 44 444. ±4± *44* ±444 4444 4#A#44±, 4*4* 4 44-0-4 4^4* *4**(44]wl* *# 4*4-0-)4^i# o]^A*44 *44* 44.

44±± 4444 47H14 44444 44* 44 44 ±4 ±44 4 444-c 444 **44* *± 44.

4. ±44**4 m\

444* *4* *44* 4* *7Mi4* ;M 44*4 444 4* 44±# 44# 4444 44 444 44±4 *444# 44 *4#

*44* 44.

40

if4444 4#44 4^# 44± 4 4.4 4if44±b 444 4^1 444 4 44.444 44441- 434 4^44 444 344 44445-1 431,

44453 444 44-71- 44 44*H1 444 b 4444 444b 4

4- 44444, 444-45. 4^114 344 444 44453 4344b

41 4444 4^71-71- 4^7144 4444* 3:444. 444 444 4344 44 4b f7}44 411 44^1-44 44-44 444-3. 44 1 4114 ±41 4434 437, 4^414 4^. ia]14 44±4 44444 7M111 -n-3.44 444 44^44 7#^ 4^0 ±4444 444 44±# 4143& 4b 4544.

444 14if445i 44%1#4 444 44 444 44 4if4 4471-7]- 4 444 44431 %U-4, 4 if4 4444 154 H-b 44 444 44?lb 444=- 4# 1 44b 41 444 4544.

1.

45 4471-7: ±4^-4/i^ 7]&4 47]-341 if4(Rate of Return) 4 47]4 A-Q-43^} 444 44 4444 44431 44.

44|, 4if4 4444 443141 44 44437} H4 444 4

V. -S-oJtHN 4# ^ 44 41

Sit- 5444.INI, 4444^1 -£.4-44 44# 471 44445 444 44xl-4 4

#. 441. 44414. 554 454 5544. 7|# ## 444 454 #44 4545. 44^1 4444 4# 4^. 444-4 545 #547] 4#4 ^]fl iM 4444 til-§-(°J7dtill- ift 444 4-§-)0l441^144.

^4. 4^17144 4:t 7^4^, 4]/M4 4f#4444 444(regulatory lag)4] 44 4444^14 44^14 4xl7ft44 541 4# ;144 44 4-0-M 45 #4 #44# 47144.

444 #4# 45 45. 45#}t 4455. ?M^14 #4#4 44 4 5# 444 447^ 4444 4#45 454, 4## 4-444 (incentive regulation) 45 4M45 44. 4444 4 #4 4 #4- 544 44 4 45715. 44.

4. 7M^El44(price-cap regulation)

7M#444t f/}5##444 #4# 4#^it 4455/1 4447144444 44. 444 4445 sit #45##444 44- #44#55, 4# 44 54t 4544 444 4°J#444(British Telecommunications)-!- 4444 44 4 #4-45(8. C. Littlechild)7f-4444 4445 sit 445/1 #4 444 ##. 44f4#4 444 7}5444- ##444 44444 7}444 f455 4#45 44. 4 44 445 4# ##455 5444 AT&T4 #71444544 444 Al-0-45 44. 4t 444 544 #4# 5544 #44 544 4# 544-0-4 4444 445 4543. 45 f4 444 #7l5#4444

42

4 444# 4# 4 #4 -H-#4± if44it4 (reguratorycapture) 4## 7J4# #44 44# 4444# 4444 4^4± %l

# 7f4if4 4444.

dl if4# 44 #4# 444 3lM4±. #471444 #4 71444 4444 7M444 44 34# 4#4±, 44 44 #

44 7M44444 444 ;M#-M 44 A#444 #4444 44# 444 ^ # ^4 ag^A^.4 4444 4±4±4 4### #4# 444±. 4# #44 ±444 #3# #444 4 4# 444. dl 4^# 4M 444471- 44±. 4#44# 44 # 44dT4± 44.

dl #4# 344## A#4 44?1# 447]- 444 4#4 A### 4# #444# 4444 #44 if44 44# ±4 44431 44. 44 4 ##44 7^44 44 ±4444 4 4±& 444± ^ 444 4 3#4. #444 #4 #4 444 %#44 #44 4±7f4## #4# #44 444-^. 44^ 4# 444± ^4.

444 7f4 44#4 4 7] 47I) 4 # #M 444 #44 = 44#7f 4#

# - 444 %#4#j ± &444. 4# 4444±4 7M44&4 44 4# 44#7f4 ###44 ##a. #44# 444 ±#4 #44 44 4 444 # 4# 4#4±## 4 444. 44± 4#4± %1# #44 4 #4# 444 44, ±4± 3444 444 44 44 4344 4# 4± 44. 444 #44 4#44 i±4 19924 444444 #444 4#4± 4# 344 7}±7f44 #4#4# # # 4#4. ± 4## 4 #4 44. 9

9) ri±4 4^4

^1#M ;M7M4 ## ^11# -M^^l# 3#^ 5H4.

'-hfttb Ikpo Ik ^ "H-kir ftk ftk ftftft kft kkk ftk t

Is ikk kftklk IblkkftftftT kkkk Ibkftg^k ftkk Ibftlk k k ft ftftk ftftv Ikftftlz ftkk klblhkk ft# kk ftftftkft

ftftpsft 3>

ftftgxft ftk? Ibftlk kk Ikftftjz ?k ftk# ^ftft kftft ftftftkftftft kftk k ftkk kfth Nuuk ft ft- Ikftftft kftl^o kftkftk?ft ftftif ft ?kk ftkft ftkftk Ibft h kk ft ftpo iToft

k ftft kkk ftftft %: ftftftft ?Tftk ftftftlk ftftft^ kkkftft# kftkft k

kft ftft #ft ftlkftk kftk ftkft ftlk-k kftftft ftlkft kkft -kftk >k ftftftT klkftftftir-Nr ^ukftNkft kftftft kkk

ftk ft ftkft ^ft'kftlb ftftk irk lbIkft kft kk -hkftklkftftk Ibftkkk Ibftk kk ft ftkft kk ftftk ftftft ftl$wft ft ft ftk 'ftk kkk ftkkk loft -klkftftftwkft qrlkftftftkft

ft-ft klk-tirftftkft (I

7T ftftft? ftftftftft Ik kkftWft : ‘130

ftp/ kftk ft ft Ik : '% kft/T ftkft : T"ft

ftkftft ftftkklb : '3 Tft ft# % : Y

ftkv-k k^ftftk ; °/t ftkftft ftkft : ‘133

zFftftir loft vft : ’Z ftftft ft A: t? : ‘W

'X -'3 + °A x(1Z-HDD) + T“ft x {mKx-idu) +1 } =*w

efr Italy fa s& ikb Hk-trpft A

44

44334 7}43 47113$ 44M 7HM1 43444 343d}37i34"47}4^ 4314A&3 444 434 $44-4dl 4"^7} 4^. $44-43 4 $^.4443 ?}444343 ^47}444 7ie4 $44 44# 7}44 443^# 4331$4 $$34444c- 44(first-best)4 4444^ 4444 4"4(second-best)47}434?} 44% $ 33.

2) 7^44444 #34

-$3M}4 7}444;} $344 3434343 347}4dl 4443 444334# 4471-4 53- zl 444 4-40] ^4^ 7)343 34. 7^444 4$ 444^ 7}4$ $_a_$ 344433. 44$ $^-3 44444 # 7|$4o] ^7] 4134 44$ 7}4$ $A7}33/} #44 3433$ 4^431, 443 44343 444$ 34-5. /}3## 43^3 43Lti-2:(cross subsidization#} 444 3 44. 44-4 7|44 447344 7}4%@4# ^4?3 44# 3 34.

^-3 4^4 7}4$%M4 7}4$ 44^3 44# ^4 7343 33

4 3 34. 4444 437}4 (price-ceiling) 3^MM 43^. .S3 434 7}4«] ^ $^}7}434 4443 443 444-^3- 444JZ. 34 4334.

347144 4333- 343 34 4^3 43 33^1$dl ^3 3343 43 443. 444 %$4 4& 443 443 433:4 4^. a.444 3343 34 433 344 A$43z. 3—3. 334 4344 $7}ji

^ 40#} $-344-3 $ 34. 344 $4^$&iM434%r 44 $ 33 7]#44 4^3 34 4444 A#

V. -frWH 4* $5- 5 AM 45

#55 4 #* #3.* *#14*4 **g}44 44.

;M44 #5** *44*53 #55 #44 44 #4 4)4 f/M

4 444 4*444 44. 44444 4444 44 #* 44445#44# 54* * 44. 5.4 #**^}# 4444 #*if#*53.* ##

#44. #4*4 4 44 ##44 444 4*4 444 **453. 44 453. #44*4 #*#* 7M*#**4* #** ;}#* 44# 44 4 4*44 4444 #* * 44.

444 444 4#* 4444* 4# 4* 5*44 *4-5 **# 4 44. 4* 44445 445 4* 44* 444 3.4)5 44* 444. 444 45 45* 54444 444 444 *4 *444 4*453. #444 #4-4- 4444 -3*) *44-4 * 44-.

5*4 *5*4 (X)* **** 44 7}444 4)5* 7)^*4 a**4 5*4 *5 *47} 4*44 7)*#* 4 4* 5*4 *7)*^* 44*4-4 4* **44 4***4 4* 44* 544-5#* 4444 ##44 4*4 ** *4* 7>4*4-.

7>4*W4* ## #4** #5 *4* #*5 *7) 4*4 *4*4 *#44# 453. ## #4-4 5* ## ##4 5** 7]#*4 *#. *4 ###51- 7f* #4*44# 7f4#4*# 44# *4*47)- 4445 ** *** 7}# #-*#4# 54* ##4 sj#j7 # 44

4. ti|H410)| 2|* 7^4*41

h)57440)* *#444 4# 5#* 3*4- 4** 4*4 4* 44(#)4 *4* 4*53 3] #534 44* *73^- *^#4 3.5## * 4* 4*4* ## *#4*. ### 44# #4*4 *4-4 ** #44

46

M4 *44* 3^14 454 44M1 3**711 =14. iM**4 7Mi- #** 4 sfl# 7)^4 4*4 47^4 4* 45# 3*44. 7] 4* til #4 4 3* 7M#4 4*5#* 447144 4-g-^s. 4*44 7}4* *44-$3.4 /g^ti] 4?1* #3?}* 3*44 7}4**^1 7}#4

44 44 444 aM 44- 7Mif44 7iMB4614.44 444 444 444 5}* = 47lM#j44* 454 447} 4

54 4 4?4 4#*333 *4*3 44. 444 44 45## 4*4 445-4 ^*7} 4* 45444 44# *4^}* 44 *34 #57} 5 4. *33444 4-§-^4 *^1 a4 4# 7144 4#* *7}44 34 4 45 34 44 4444 4*33 ?}# 4# MM #445- 54#?}43* 44* i444. 4* 44444 45 7f45-47!- 4*5- 44 444 4454 34* 4*4 4* 454#* 3544 34 4* 4* 4 54# 444 4* 344 4 45444 434- 4434* 7144* 44 4544471 4*44.

*334^14 «1#34 #4 45 444 43 43 544 4# 4*47}4 3*44 45* 34* 444 til55 4*33 5-444 35 45 4 4iM## 4*33 44 7}4* 445: *3 54*. 4# 454 4

#4 45* 44* 34 4 3*4 453# 44*4* #44 4444 444 «!## *443 444 *44 «!*# 4 444 3*571-3 /}#

44 34 44 7M* *44* *33 34 *34 44* 4*5 * 3 44. 4* *4, 44 til*4 *4# ** 50J01 714*4 7}34i4* 444 71-34444 «!#* 44* 453*, til#* 4*44*, 7}34

4#* *55*3 4# 44#** #4 4* * 43. 4 44#*4 5 5* 4*5-4 4 454 ^*47}# *7# * 44.

V. -ff-WHl c# $5- 4 44 47

#4 444 4*4-4 44443 ^1#44 444 7}43# 444*4 444- 4444 4* 444 44^£ 4444-3.4 4 444 4^14 7]5.4 444 444 #4 444 7M*4# 444 4 44. 44^1 444 444 44 /MiM# 444^, *3-###3. 4 444 #4 444 4^44 # 44?1- $1#43 ###3 3# 444 4 4 4444 iMM- 4*44# *4# 4444 444 #34 4# 44 4 4-4# #3&4 3.4 444 7^*4# ^}# 4# 44443 44. ti44 4 ##44433 4 7] 4 4 4# 44# *# 444*# 444 3., 4#4 44# 4# 43 44444 4#7M 44 4# 44444 #4 7I44 4444 444 44 4-3# 4*4 4 44444 44 44 4*# *4444 44# #4# 7I-43 44.4^4# #4 7M#4# 44433 ^ ;H4 #47N4 444 4

44 #444 4# 4#43 o]# 44 444- ##?M %#4$1 #4# #34# 4433 4*# * $134. 444 44# #44 44- 4-44# 444 #34 ##4 7M# #44334 ±#44 7MiM# 7^33# # * 44.

43341-& #4 7M#47} ##43± 4#447] 444# 3444 4 4 #*4 $134. 4# 3444 444 #4.

44, -r43T##414 44 44 444##7M1 44 7MiM4 $1 4A1# *##7l# 4443. 44# 4#44 7H447^# ##43, A] 7ijT@^7M 4544 33-4 #4=144. 444^4 444 7M #41# ###7} 44 a.#47#|- 4444. #34 71)4471-4 *#4Mi# #41# 44 444. 44Ai 47H14# 3-414*4 44# 7#)3# 444 4#7}7i- *34 444 444 4*44 33#- ##4#r 7j#

48

5# 4455 5144 5lllol 7V5-a\7§ 41 414 44. 344#1 15144 #114 5#c| 11^ 4444. 4444 514414 444 444 4445- 44. 44 44 7}4!H44 44 /M14454444 444. 44 44 ^11^551 5H71-# 15^5 444 1 444 5d-& 1 45.4. 7M44444 %445 45^(basket)4 444- #44 #47} 4# 444. 444 7MiM444 4445 3# 17}# 11 444 15^# 444 ##7} ^ #47} 44.

#4, i#44I- 44 444 /]&44 44445. 445 444 44 4 444 44444 4571- 1514 44. 4444 5H7} 444 445 44.44 #4 44444 4444 14 3.4 41-1 454, 44 4-/1- 1;H4 55#(4# #4, 4^ 44)4 4411411414 4 144.

44. 4114-44 4144 ^#>1 ^11444 14. 71114 1144 41441 4141 44#4 ;#44 %1H 41 544 4544 444455 HH 41 4411 44.

#4. 44 144 444444 14. 144 44444 41 441 14H144-4 1544 #414. 44 144 sA 41 4141 4 14 41111 5444 3 4157} 34 144145 H43 7]# 4 a.#!?} 14144 leu 1141141 7}457j 4144. 1 4 7}5l44 41 4 44444 4414, 15154 14 1 44 1

14 1544 147} 4144, 4411144 3# 14# 111 5# l7}4 11111a) 41455 1514.

41^1, 5H7} 114 3.4 41 7}li#4 H4 1^#- 441 ^ ^15114 414 44111 #11 o]#7} 1341444

V. m ^ 431 49

4M 1^4 1441 <4514, 447]jl-§#h 4444 4

#4 4H44 444- 4441 41 444 44 44-44# #44-4 %144 7Mif4* 1455 ej^. 44444 44 7}4 -tM14 447} 444 44-44 44, 4^4 5144 141 7M# 1 SMI 44. 444 ^1%144 4^4 44444 41^1 4444 ^4 41441 44447)1 444.

4. 447|g ?m 7)14011 44 141

^1 45# 44 4 14 4444444^471- 15 444444 44 45 Si# 45^. ;)M 444^}44 7M^44 444 44 44(4%^r, 4^1. 7j-N- 1)44 4444 ^o,j 4)4 #j7_ 4^44-7} 4444 4 3.4 411 444-47)1 #4% 444# i^l}# 44 4444 4^4 ^1H7H 4444 444444.

145H4 HI 1445. zL&4 11 441 ^-44^* 4 5 1 H ^47M4 14. 444# 5^l7}44 % 434- 444 4144 !4-5ll)M]sH14 44451 ?WW 1# 444 14445 43.. 7^4^14 4^.44 1541 4445. 7}## ;)|44 44 41455 47} 444714 4^.44 #7}44 144 111 4 444 4#44444 4aS4# 44#7}# 4447)1 44 #415. 44# 54447)1 1# 415 4145 44.

444 7)) 17)14=4 44 -jf-711444 714441 #4144 #5.1- 15 41 1444441 4 5 4-fl 7l4 0)17)1 #J7 4-44# 5U#}7}

41 ^H4 7)4#4 514 HI 444 ^l^}, #444. 5wM} 44 ^41 15?}# 14144# 441 414.

50

o] #|5# 444 ##4# 44#^ #44 7j-55]#

#7]# #### #4 #44 7M^^i44^(^l^ 44#54# # # 4#4 ;]-##-4o]4. 4445* jl#4# 44 444444) 2,4.0]^-

# 41#7ll 4# 447#]] #44 5t#4# 4 #4* (Profit Sharing)7-1]5& # %1* #44.

4*4* #54] 444# #44 4##5 44. 4*4 #445. 44# #7#]## 4447] 44 44 44444 44 #5.4444 4445a 54. #44 7ks44#44^ ^14 44 #444 ### 4445 #4.

Bh 44 44 7M44I

#-T7^#7]#4 444 4444^**4, #44 ^4 4*4 44 #44 #4* #^-#e}# #^=o] ^ 444 44# ##-4#4# *45S7i 5-4 #T# 4444 * 4 7#] ### 444444 44

# 4##44 4445, 6] #4# 4 #7M#4 44 7]-#- #44

57di- 444c 71444 444# 44 #44# #444. 44# #t

4 #4##447} ##7H4 #3#- #4 4444 #44# 44 #44 445 441# 4 4 #444 #44# ## 44 4444 #44 44

4 ##4 #4# #544 444 544# 4#^] 4.##444 i## #4# 5544 44] ## 7]4#4 7]#^^# 4

## 44]?]# 444 4]5# 54 4#4 4#44 #54, 444 444 447]- 444 #44#& 7^0^. 4##5, 444 ^^.4 #&# 4

4 5## 7M4 a]4 44- 7}#4 44# 7}#* ##5 ##45 44. 44-4 444 44444# #44 #4444 7]-#*## 44455 4 444# 44 444444 44 7]-###4 #44# 444. 444 ;t]

v. -frWH 4% 7js. ^ 431 51

3# 4# 444, £44-7} i 7)7444 44^# 444 41 444444 7M4- 4£44 7)4 £44 4#fr 44^ 7}4 #4 ?M# 4 7)44 x)HiAt 4444 44 44 444.444## %44 444 44 73444 4£. 7}44 444 444

4 44 44444 44s. £4-444444 t 7}4 4444 44.4< 443#M 4£7) #x4 473# a-£?}5 44 44444 4

71)7)- 44. zi #fl 455 3#Hr 7)44°1W 44-4£7)- *34)4 7)4 A34 444, 4 7)-444 44 4447)- 4—4 4444 a4. 44 0)4- £4 44^4 ^3.5)14 4#13# 4# 3#134 4)^4 3#M 4

444 4444 #£4£ 5)14 447)- 44 #4. 4. 44434 444 444 44 4 4 £4 %2iD^o)4_ 5#^ 44 44 £4 44 4 -S-4 #£4 4 3£££ #1-44 4£4 4444 (asymmetry of information) 4 #14-4. 4#i 443#1(4 #34 44 4444- 4 4# 4447)7)- 434 5)3i. 444££4 3. 447} 444 444-3! 4 4 #1)7)- 44.#1 4^4 7)44)7)1 447} m444 4 7)5-7)44 7}4# 44t)) 4

4444 4#} ?}# #117)- 44. 3#14 44 7)5444 7}44 s# 4444 431. ZL 4#) 4#7Ml£ 443! 44 4^ 7)44 4444

#1)4 #144 #44. zl44 44- 44 444 44 3£4, 45 44 4 44#}#) 43! 45^- 434 44#}# 4:44 4#§-4 44#}#1)7} #344. 4#-) 444 44#}f- #1 44 4AM44i- 44434 3444 4#} 4^44 44. 4 ^444 44^)44 7}4# 414 #}444 4#} 45 4/1)7} #344. 4 434 444 £444

444 4 43# £# 44444 434 #M7) 434 444 444

52

4# 5#a}4 444 ^-4 ##4 7114444^ 7}^?} #7344 ^4.#4, 447} #44 #4# /}#, -M #4 #44 444

44. 5# 44^1 4%3}4 4^345 4#7}# 4^4 444 4471- a}^

-c-417} ##4. #7}# #45# 444 444 4714 44 44# 4-f. #5 sl# /l^l 44-45.5- 444 6HI4 44# 445. 444/17} 4^JL, #4# 47115.# 4a}7ll>d] f^t} 47]7} S]4 JL7j7}44 #7}# #45 444 ^-43^4til-g- s4 #44# 7]^o| #4s]jl 437 44

## 7|44 if-4^1# -n-a.4 #4# #4714^1 43. 44 44.44, 4^447} a}4^ #f ##4 ^33}^ 44444 44 7}

4# #44 # #5.4, ####55 #a}4 4^. 7}## 4## #4-&4-SH-44# 4an #5# 7}# 44# 4ia}7l7} 44 44 4# if/iHl 44 ##4 m# 5#44. 44x1 ##44 ##4 ^4 f4^#ai 3#444, 4#54 #4-47}# 455 a}ji #44' 4#til-§-(sunk cost)44 #44 # #447i# 4a}4#711# 4-§*4t14-'4# d]#e}4 73# «1 # %4 4# 7^4^ 7}## a}## #43}# 44 #47} 44.

4#4, #44#4# 4# #7)15. 7433#}# #54 71444 444###4 #4^^ # 44# ## 4444 ###4554 54 ±#4 4 7}4##& 4#^ # 44# 4# 4# a}# #55. .iM7l#4 4##- 7}##4# 44471# #4#7}4 if-57} a# ^44 #57} #?}a}# 4# #5# 7144 #444-& 44a}# iM4# ## #4 #5a}4^ ## 4445 44.

V. -fKHMN 4% ^ 431 53

2.

44455 #$!## 4#4 4# 3#4$1 5±# 5445

$14.

7K 7RX|^o| Ajg

#445^ 5$1#4 7^4444^ 43-4 7}4±g. 4445^. 4# 7}4±445# 44431 $14. 7M&44^4 ±44 #7>4#, 444

#/M4\ 44(4±4) ## #44#4 43-45. 4#-# #54 444 5 4 444 444 44431 $14.

444 45#3- #$1##544 444 44 4444 4± 4^17} $1 4. 4# #4 7M44HM4 4444 ±4^} #/M44 344- #7}4 4 #^1 &-N f $154. 44444 4#4# 4^444^44 %#4 4 ## 444 43-447} /M44± %## 4 $14- 444. 5# 444 44 4444 444 444 ;}44 444 44 71-44 4&41 444.

W}45± 3.4444 4 445^ 444444 44-& 44471 4 44 44144 7M4&4 #3-^14- 444 444 43-454 4444 444 3417} $14.

4. ^44 44 45

43-44# 5^-4 43% 4 444 4# 344 44 #54 43 44 4 7}4#4 444 5444 $14. 444 44 #54# 4^7)44 44

54

444 -n-cr 4til 44^1-4 44 44444n4Total Factor Productivity). 44444 7M4&# 444-b 444444 #4444"r4 44444 #4444444 4^43.44.

4&4 444 44 43.4^- AAA 4444 7M444 4344 4 AAA, 344- 33# A A: 44434 4444 444 43 44. si4 4^ 44^ ^le# 4443# 444: f ^4.(7i-3#4, #4^4 4^3/14. ^444 444. f^7K 443 7ie -§-)

4. 34o|#^%|# 44 3*|

3^ #44 4# &44#& 444-71 4111- 3434 ## 444 #4 #34-1: 44444- ^1#433 °lTTtiH-l-(Profit sharing rule)-#- A #4^ 4f3 ^4. 34 #4433. 4444* 47^4^ #4. 3714 7ie 3#4 f** W-4 4444 ±*44 #&# 47144 434-^ 4 4 #4 4*43 44.

EK /#o| %7[

44iN4^4 #344 433 AAA 47h#4# # 4r 44. 4440-& ^71-4 #?1^ 3-544 4344. 3g7M 44# 4444 44. 7M 444 #444. #4±44 434 ** 3444.

4. §4^44 @71

4443 4433 434 444 43 4-liRi4(Pass-through) 44,4444 44# #* 44. 7)444 3^-4 4# 44 -§44. 7M #4 4 44-4 4344 444- ## 4e 344 43:44 4°1 4^4 4#4

V. >°JW1 3)4 $£. 5 43) 55

4 44* $14.

UK 4ti|^ §lo| m\

4444 44141^4 .ehH 4# 4til4 #44 44* 4444 44 444* 444^* 4^4* 4444 4*4 #44 4* 44444

43L4* 44 4*444. ^ 44-^-* 4444 44 ^44, *44

*4*4 *4. 4*444 a* &4, 4444 44431 4*4 44 *

4 44.

4. til*S7KCost Pass-through)

444 4444 h|4-444** 4*4444 4Jz4*4 444 zzf-

4 44* ** 4444 44* 4444. 444* 444*4 44 4#

44 4*4 444 *44*4 444*5. 4*4* 4*&* 4* 44

44 4444 *44 4444 4* 4#*a. 4*4. 44* *4, *4

44 44 4*44 44* 4* *4 44.

op 4#?M4 m

#4*4 ;|-4*44 44 4*44 4*4 44# 4# **4 444

4. 4**iM4 4*4 4#i-4g. *44** *44* 4J14 *44 4444 44. 4444 4*4* 4# 4*44, 4*4* 444*42.

4 44. ^444^4 2* 44&* 44*4 4&4 *# **44 4*

444. 7>>i4 **7}## 7l*7f4* ?l*-4 4 4*31. 4**4 4±

4. ^44 44*4 444 ** **44 44. 444 44=4^1 #7]]# 4*47] 44 44 71-44 4*7M *444# 4*4 4*71- 44. 4#

56

5iM4 444 447^14 445- 4-H4 4##^ 4## 444714. 47l4;#l#4 e4#4 7l#7f4# #4# #a 44.a4 #444 45445: 4444 444a "155-5 444a, 44

■5-7-144 7}4### 444 fa 44. a4 4±4 45^1# 444 45 4 7l#aa 7l#7>4# 5^4# 4a 7l#44. zz.44 4^4444 # 4?1#4 aA4# 445 471-444 7l#aa 45^1# 45a %14.

"155 5-44444 444 55555 44^1# 7l#_a_5f54 444 4#4 "15# ^4. 444 4t4 4^45 44 a&(444 4444 4545)5 441 #4144 t4445 4a4-& 4a 44.4 4#"1 4 # %14.

4#44 "1555-444714 445444# 444:471- 44. 44# 4a4#a #444 4444 at# #54# 4# a4 44444 s. #7^71#- ^#44 "144 4#4 71-45- a44a, 45 #4a 44. 4f, <43-4^. 44 7}44 ^4 ## 45-4(normaliza-tion)44 45171## a#4# 444. 44-71 "144 444 7l# #t 444 455 44^1#4 #45 f 4& #4 444 5455 7M5-4 7} ##&}# 4# 554 555 a#^H1a a## # f 44.

4. 7l4#7i|o| yo|Sg

44^ 7M5- ifTlMI# 4#4 5-44 444 4# 44^ 44# ^4 4# 44 #544. 7M#44 44"! 4# 44^4 44- 444^4 444 44# 71-44.

4#44 7^1-44 4"1 444 f# 7i#ol 444 4#7}4aa a 471-7:4-4"! 444# 444# a# ±4454 7#la# a#4# 44

V. -MiHM 4# 7)5. t 431 57

4^# 4#4# 44 /KM4. ## "1 4#4A 7^1^ A##s. ;0#4) >|ti]>; /M's #44# hJ-ai (Tariff basket regulation)^ ##7l# 61 #4^}# AA^\ ##-§- #44# 4#(Average revenue regulation)^. 4#4 # # #4. 4## ##444 #44 444 444 4*07l# 4444 44 444^4 44^1- 4444 44# 444 4. 444 9M44444 4i##4# 4a4#44 44 444, 44 44 4Al(iy14 44)4 44# 44# 444/1 44# 44 44.

^47^44/1- 4#*1# 714^1- #4(##) 44^4 4# 714^ 44444 4# 44#^# 444 # 44. 4# A#?}^ 444 #4# 4444 #44 44##444# 44444 #44#4 #44 444 4 4#*H7fl #;## 431 ^1#&# #7)144. 31431 #-#44^4 4 #. ^S4##4 #/0# /M# 7^^4^-44 #44#s.4 ^4 # 7)1# 44 ?s31, 4# ##4444 44447} 4#4# 444 7-1431# 3. 7>4### #44# 444. 444 #4444 4444 44 4#4 4#4 7}ri4#47l 444# 7}4#44444-.

44as. #a. 7Mi±4#44^ 444^.44 444 ^^4 44 #A 444 #4/141 4*0 7}4#4# /}444a 4# 44, ##5. #4/HI 4*07# A##/)!# 7M4% 44. 44^1 A##7ll4 44# ### 4" A7M1 4444. 4# 7}4#7il 444 44# 44#^ ## 44#7ll4- #44 44^1 4#& 4 # #4.

58

3. 7^45- _°_o)ifj)]a)^ ^

4. Eg±s\ 4433#*II

1) #&44=(7M3%#4)4 54 #4 4 4#

4#5 f A?M 4# 7MiM 44(5 Gwh, 4 4l3m3/10.500W3 f, jhifa. #4#447l# 19863#4 198734 34 1334 3^ 44 4 4344-7)- 444 34^1 4 f 4^1 434 7)-^# 434-344 471-33444 447} 334 #A3 33& 444. %- 7>^^-333 334441 444 431441- 3344 434 #71343 3344 43 34 43 445. 44 44344 344 4344 344 44 =34 4 37)-^47KGdP)4 #3^1 J15443. a.4 4-41?}4 3##5&4:& 7)) 3434 3431 33^1 3433 44 5543# 3433 433## -5-333334 ;1)34 44 334 #5471 #334 44 r##43j4 44 7M344# 5334 45d3.

r#l.43j 4 344 44 53# 447^47)3- 713 334 4 4# 3443 43-5-33- 71134 4 33 3 #53 33 33 103=34 33 -& 3# 33 ^-34334. #45#4 7)134 44 34=43 333 335 303 534 #343# #4 GdP4 ^3-4 44 #34#& 2023 5 355 #33 53^1 #4433. n45 4333# 43 4##44 30% 0)34 73L43-& 5##Ji. 337}54 5## 454^4 #44 34 #-& 4334 33 4355. #44 3 3, %43#5# 344 4 43-71 44 3.4354 #43 534 4 #4 4471- #3#3.

V. -MiMMI 4* 7js. ^ 431 59

1991*4 711451 *1 1993*34 45.5] 4 19944 3444 1994444 1996444 344 4444 43* r*544j 4 44 4444, 4 445- 444 444441- 44s. 444 444 3*43 44.

- 1996*3*44 4444-4 844 34 4444 444* 4-714* 443 #4 4.(4 45.4 44 344 404 =44 454 444 4SHM4 71*344 %1* 4* *43 44 44)

- 1996*4* *4*44 50% ^1*4 71-344* 3444 4.- 1996*4* 444*44 34*4* 600MW(49.133m3/10.500

hal)44 ^*4.- 1996*4* NGV4 34* 1,500444 ** 4.- 1996*44 GdF4 434a44 **7}3* 44*3 *43 **

6507114 44 100444 344 444 44/1-3# 3444 4.

2) *5/114= (71-4*444)4 **

7}) 4444**

r*&44j 4 444 4** 3*34 /M4444* 4* *4 5 Gwh4*4 4454**4 444 44 *(3***4 4*3)4 7f*(9* **4 10*3) * 444 *4 *4 7}33**e* 4*4 4* 444 441 *44* 7M44* *4 ^* 4. GdF/1- **44 344 444 7H*4 * %14.

f - fo = 1.12 x (M - Mo) + (K - ^0)

60

P : 43## 3# ##M: 7^ ##7}333, 1.12# 4a343 333±^- ^^ 4#

#3344 443# 4]4. M3 444 GdF 437H: ^#334 a3± 43(4 x]###4# 44±# 3#43. 4433 44 4 34 #4)

K : GdF3 7}^ 43a 34# 4144 ±43 ##P0, MO. KO : 3#3^3 GdF7} 344 44434 47]

444 444 43(44 103 ±4 4±)# 4# 43 444 4A4 43434.

4) 34343-43 43

K3 #444 [^44 #7}3# - GdF3 343 444 x 0.5] ax] 443#3. 3# GdF3 343 4434# GdF4 ±4444 50:50± a 4## 34 3344.

3#7} GdF3 343 4444 434 33# GdF7} #344333 4 #7]-33# 34#5- 4# 3 #33 4 3 #3 344-2-, 3## 634 441 143 43 334 3344. ±3± 3#4#H4 #43 #33 4 4 313447] 343 4443 ##4 #344.

199143 343 19934433 r#&3#j 3x]# 47]3 K#4 ^ 3443 7}7:434(34r4 4^43# 4 a4434)3 2.75% 34# 3# 33 2%. 2.75-3.25%# 3# 33 2.5%. 3.25% #4# 3# 33 3%j a. 443#4. 7Ha 343 19964433 ^#^l#j 47]# #14 a33 4343 443 2%34# 3# 3x] 2%. 2-3%# 3#

33 2.5%, 3%34# 3# 33 3%j a ##3 33 GdF3 34 #34 344 #34# 44±± ±4^4433 343#4.

V. -fMliMM 4% #5. i 431 61

4)44#M###-3#

5#^# 7}##44^ #4# 7}#4-#^# #]z#4_ ###-§-4 ?M ### ##44 ### 4# #7} 7}4-#4 7M44& 44# 4 44 4 4 444. zi 4#4& 4f## ##4 444 #4^# 444- ### %14# 4(4#&4 7}##4# 4444 %!## 7H44- 44# # ^4 #. GdF44# 4## #4# 4^M}4 ##7} #4 44.). 444 ## 44i-(X#-)4 7j.^4«i) 44# 444 #-#-44 4443. %M# 4. 4 44- #44 44# H44# Ji4#dl #444 #47} #4 #Ji. 44# 7l]#4 ##4 #44 44 A#^44 4f443i 44# #44 44 7} 44.

4) 4##tMl 44 ^444 444#

^4^4# 4#4- 4# #444^-# ^#4. #544# 444 44 4# ##444 4#44 4# •## 6o>4d}4 #44-# #44- 4-5.44 4 ##^}# 4## 44. &#- GdF# #544# 4444 44## 444- 444 4#4, 44-44 444# #44 4## f-4 544# #44 #444.

4) ##### #5

7}#4W44 4# /i#5## #4# #4471 44 GDP# 44# 4## 4# 87}## 44# ##* #444 4# ##4^4 4# 44.4# ### 4#4# ###& 4# 150 54* ±#40# 44# #4.

62

- 4%^# 44% 44344244 44)- 7^^444 ^4 1M4. 444^144 ^4#44 44- 4444!4 444444 H443- 44- ±47}^ _s_44 % 4^^-24444 44^43-- A44 43% 4eA& 24444 3-3-444- ±*14-4 4%4 44 84444 44%%- ±*14 433 8444 44444 4% -SLe- i47>4 44f- zl4jl %A% 47>1- 43 4 15444 44

4) %44-4 ^%44

333^- 54 33-A^. 33% 4 4^-4. 333%^- 7]^-A34 34A 3-4 4-1- 4% 44-4341- 444^ 44-.

7]&^3% B0A34 433 43-4^& 44-A3-4 34^1 3%% 4. Bl. B2 I A33 7|3A33 4^4 3%%44 33^33 444^. ^#44 44-. ^43. B2 8 ^-33 33-8-44 44%. 44%^- 43-4-44 4% -S-3-44-.

<5 V-1) 3433 £344 44(=i>3)

9-^m #?} m^SL tSSe

7\sJL^ 0-lMWhBO 1-7

Bl 7-30

B2 I ^30

150-7l^-§-4^. ±SN3§-

B2 8 ^ 350- 4^ ^-g-

^) lMwh^Sl.9 m3/10.500kal

V. -fKHf-44 44 $5- 5 44 63

1) #4#44# #44 44

4#44# 4$4#4 4%4 ^444 -§-44 444 44 447} 44 AM44# 444 444 44444 ###4 44 3i##44444 $## # 4 44# 444 44 44^44 444#4 4A4 4 ## 44^ ^4/^44444 4^14^ ##4 444 444 44444. 44 44 4444# 44431, 7}44%4 #4#44%# %444 444.

2) 4%34# 3144 A#4^. 4<@44

4^%## 4444# 4447144# 44#^ #3i, 444 4 #7}#4 44431444 #±# ##4^ %44# 44# 4431 44. 44 %## #5.4 4444 4#4 #44 4 5.# 4%#4%4 #444# (%4 V-l)4 44.

® 447}# 44%## ### 44 - ##44.® 7}$4& 44%## #57} 444 ##47}# 4444 ##44#

4444.® #44## 7}$^ ^.#4^ 444 44 ##47}4 44 44#

444. #44## #44$4# %##. 4X}4 44# 4444 444 ^4# 4431, 4#4 7hM 2444 43a 47}# 4444 444^ #44## 44 4$44 ##47}?} 44^.4 4444# 4, 7}$^ zj-^ 444 444-#- 4^4 , 44 %##

4.

64

444^4 4f #4 444 4444(4#44). f 44 4444 iM4^& 44 444-7]- 444 ##-4;]-# 4# 44447]-4 4:24-0^4(43.44). 344 4^4 444444 44# ^-T^.

® 44^}^ 44%#4 #3 #43. 4444- #4 444 44433 4/I-4-33.44# #&#4. o]34 445.## 344 4#43 344#4 44# 4 441 4 %[5-# 44.

n^j v-1) 435*IE £°dm\

fa}. #8f4.

V. -R-SliMM 4% $5- 5 AM) 65

3) ti)x44 >#7))x4 #>4#

7}) 44 ^ 7)4x4

4» >#4>447) 7)4#> >7)5)4. A}o)4- >7-)4 7j-o] 4^.ti)» 444 W44# 7)4 > >#7))4-& 4444. >4 4 4^47> 4#44»4 >#4#7^ »s)> >4# 444 4 4 4. >#4 >4 444 44 #7)444 4^)-# # > #»&. 444 444444 47) >444444 x>44 444x5. 4444, 444 44 444 #;§# #444 44 >#### 4#4» #:#>. >#^ 47} >xs)4 x4# 7)44 4 44.

4) 4> 444 x#4

44 7)-47)^- ® 44^^1(44. #4). ® 4> 4 4>#44 4#?}#7)1x44, © 444 # 37f44 4^> #4» >44# 4444 44 4# »#4(f>4 4»4 >7^^, 44:44. #7}4 4<343-i#x 3. #4# 4 4#, #44 3#4M 44 4444 44 444 4444 44 444 44 »44 >44 4>4 44 4># 444. &4 #7)4 44 4 44 4#44 444 x#4 44# O V-3>4 4444 44.

4) 4>47f4#4 4 4 >4 5.til>4 444 4# 7}xa}444 #7», #Xti), 44^) 4 x4#4#

(#44## >4)# 444 #7}4>^& #ti)f4 4^M)>4 44 y)> (44 #44#ti)E)- 44)4 24 47)-4»(44 ti).2.47I-445-44 4 4)» ##4>. 4)#3 f>##4 47}4 ##44##4 #7^# 44

##4 ##444 444 4# 44)»4 47ft- 71x444(443.

kkzrk # kkkk klbkk kkk [bkktkzro' kk kkk kkk k kk Ib-zirTkktkkn tokS kkk kk kkkkkk#kk kkk k kkkkkw irkk kkkk^kkk> k^k kkkk kk ’E\&=

kk#k i-kkkk kkk -a-TETlfi klbth-i-^ kkk > k kk kkk kkkk kk [bk-k-kkk k kkkkpp kirk P&kk "a kkkk klbkkk# "ir kkk ?kkkk k'ZTk## kkkkk

"kkk #zrk kk kkk kirk k#k kirk kk lbk kk Ibirk kk Ibkkkk'E'k kkkkk kkkkkk#kk

kkurk (k

kk k"5" kkkkkpakk#kk kk #kkk k#k #kkk klbkkiEk ##kk# -

kkk kk‘k-k‘k 'kkzr 'kkkkk 'kkkkk 'kk# 'k#^kk

'k# '(kk ##k k^#)k#-FT "sr?# 'kkk &kkk -kkk -

kk k#k #kkkk (2)

#k #kkk k#i^k#k 'kkk ##kk# - k-kkkkk'E' k ^kk -

(kk kk kkk ^lR#w?)-§-kk^# - (kk kk kkk kki^k^)#?k# kkkki^k -

kk kfk ##kkki^#kk (T)

kk ?vk ki^k ikFo kkkkk kk

99

V. -a-WMl 5 43 67

4444 4/1-44 44i-& 44 44, 44 zi#-^44 4M- 4 44^44 4#44. 44, 44 4444°14 44444 4°14 44 4444 44444 44, 44 nf-44 44 4444 444-444 44424- 44.

4)2.44444 44J-44 244^5.4 4444 444 444 A44 44

4-f-4-c- 4f44 4^ 444 44 4444 2:44- 44 f 444 14 24 til51444 45-4 44.

(1) /H424(4) 445. 44

4tilf7l-4 ^4 44& 4^ 4444 444-4 444 f44r 4l4f^l-#- 44 3;W4 4 W%M4 40%# &44b 44 414 f44444 47l4-4tiHl 44 4444 44 444444 4444 44 44 4444 4^& ti]5i 4%44 44423. 44^ 422 44. .s4 4-44444 444 444444 44 44 2444 #14 4

4-& 44 424 444 47f447l444 4#l7Hl 4442 47^4 ti]4- 444 2444 4444 24424 44. 4

(4) 44344444444- 44171- %14 4/K44 444447)-4 44)4 44,

^#47X4-44 4^71- 444 4444til44 444 4444 4#4 ^44 47Xrr)4 44444 42?!- 444 44=44471-4-4 444 241 44-4-4 444 ^144 24-N- 44-44 44=4447^4 44tili-

68

& 4a47MH44 444^ 3)45 44.44 ^-"^4^44 44444 4444 4#44^1 44 444

^ 444447M1 444 4?M47l444 44^144 4#4^ 447}- 45 441 4^4 44.

z 9 #103.5003 &4 70 %94.5003 54 - 103.5003 44 75 %85,5003 44 - 94.5003 ^4(^44 43) 80 %86.50041 44 - 85.5003 44 85 %76.500444 90 %

(4) 44^- 4447M444i4 4M4 444 44457)- *044444 44

547} 54 10%# A444 454^ *04 &4444 4*0 *04447} 4 4^ 44 4^ie 44 47}5 4#4 "45# 4^44^47) 44*0 ^ 4432.# 44.

(2)

3i#^4 4e 7}^7}4 4 4^47^4434 44 4?4 4&# 4^44s. 44 4444(4444)4 44 544 44444, 5#4 4444 5444^ 445 444/g-444.

- 4^f7j- 45444

<44444)- 54^4- 544 444

V. -fKli^H 44 $5. 5 A>^1 69

- 444 - *#444

4) 4*4714 444 **44

14 7}^M444 **^1^- ^ 44*0^4 ^ 3§7)4*4 4##tfl#47l4##l# ** 4 44*4 44 44 444-11-1004, 444 1- 04-^s. 4^ 4444 4444 44 444-44. ^\3L 4^4714 #*1# **4ia4 44* %M4 444 44# 444 61 444 4 4 zi#4 447}# 444 44 3^s. #444.

© 4 i #f : 4-^5. #44-71- 4SM 4#5. 4444 447}© 4 2 #4 : 1*5. 4# ##4-71 44444 4 4*5, /M4#

7147}© 4 3 #f : 4#a. %#4 3:44 4#44 4# *# 7^4.

71) ##4-2^4 ##44 4#

##4- #4##44 til#47l 4*4# 4*4 ©, 44# 444 4# 44-. 4 4 4#47l 4##!^- 444 ##4 ##44 4*4 41 4 #44-.

4 1 #* : 0 4## 44.4 2**: 4# ^1#*4#4* *#44# 44^ #4 #4 4

s47l4##4 44 444 14** #44 4#.4 3 ## : 4 2 #* 14#& #*4 #4* *#44# 44 4M

3:4 #4 4a47l4##4 4^0 444 44#(4 2 4##4 ## #)* #44 4#

&4 4*4 2:4## 4#^ 44^ 4*4. 19964 ##^47M1* 4

70

2 0.5%. 4 3 34M 4)4) 1.0%* 1524- 84142 <& v-2>4 24.

<£ V-2) 1996LJ u\mm

nm IK n 1# ffiSR j*S 4bmm 4km 5#1 f# i ff 2 fit 2 f f 3 fir 3 f#- 2 fir- 1 f if

^^i«l 2 2 f# 2 fir 2 ff 3 ff 1 TT 1 fir 3 fir

<5 V-3> 1996td 4@4 HS4

3g%E|| ISfftSfS7Hf1) EOB52) LNG, feWLPG-Air3)

4#%I4)ffSS.5)

5B

#m. 14b

8 am

21 lift 15 lift

. ii; 26 eft15 lift

16 lift21

12 lift 9 liftfm, BUS, MI. 20 am 15 lift

&#

itSI.lifc

-

. ii«

13 liftmi 27 am -

12 lift -

8 amf@,BE MW. '

ft 4 8 lift 173 lift 62 liftf: 1) ftiL7lf7l lS'LH ^ if

2) LNG. ^ if3) i-eliM# if4) f ilHM ftfft if5)

V. -MTMM1 4M1 74s. 44 71

4. oR°i ^471$ mm\

1) ><y#4 #44 tiH7|

1980444 #4 447}# #4444 #47} 4444 444 f#4 ;1^] 444^. ##444 44#/} 444 7H-4 ###44 %M4 # 44^-4444 7}#i- ## ##^#3. *PM# #^4 ^1-44.#4 1990444 #4 44^-4z|4# 444 4# 44^:444 447} 4 444^44 44 7}## 44*14 44 (by-pass)# #44 4444 s|4-5-4# #47}-!- spy##! 444 444 7]44 444 4 4# 44 4 ##444 44 ##44 #^1^4.

44 44, #414 #7}####7i] 444# 7}# #444 AM#44 %#4# ^7}47] 44 4# 444 44- 3.431 444 ### f-4 44 4, 7] 4 4 #47}## ##44 44 444# 44Hr 444317} ?}# # #4 #7]# 7}4ji 44 44-4# #71144i- #444444# 7M1444.

444 4444 4#4 #7}ji## #^4 *# 444^4 ##4##4 7}^44 4#5,i-s}4 #7]# #44 ^44 4#?}#4#4#7#]4- #4#4#7ii# #4 7}47}4 AM4 44 44 A*\ s. 4#144 ##4 4# #44#4 7}44?} 444 #5.4 444 44 7}7} 3.4# 444# 44# #4 4# #7}44 ### 44431 44# 444. 4 4444# 7^7}# ##44 4-4 #4-I- 44 &4^M4 4 ## ##4 # 44 4#4 S.i-41- #4 44444# 444## 7}# 4. 444 #4#4# 198044 #4Jr4 44, ##4-4 #<444 #44 «} 4#4, 7}#4444# #44 #444 4444 #31 4#4 A}4^

72

4# #444# 4444 444# %$#44# (Performance Based Ratemaking) 4 4 #4% 44.

2) $#$44 /-Ml

^1$4 4$$4 7}^}#^}# 44^^1 $44447} #$)4 4# 4$4# $44?} $4jif-&iMaM] #4. %# 4 4%4444# %4#$# 3.444 #%7}%4 7}4#$& 3.444 A $4 ##?}# 4^1 %4%#4 44 44 %$4%7} 4$4% 44.

(1) $$$ $44#4444 PER %#4 44 ^ ##4444 444444 7)#4 $4%#$$47} 444 ##4 ai 4

$$ ##44#4 444^14 4#4 444 4## 4#44# PER 4 %7} 4#44% 444%. $4$ 44 197# 44$444$44 %$ #4 $4$7}ki(oje} BUG)4- $44$$ 44 24)^7} PER 4%# %4%4 444. #4$ 4444 4 24ff±4 4%%4 44# %% 44, 444 174f±4 444% %4# $44 4444.

(2) %$## $4$7}7S(BUG)

(4) PBR %44 4#19944 7}&4 %$4#44 44$ $4444# BUG4 444 34

4 PBR4 4^4 #4# 47MM4. 44 44 BUG# 19944 104 1 444 4%# #44% 44. #7)1 #44% 4# BUG4 44 $4$44 4$4 4$4 #4.

(D Off System Sales Incentive : BUG7} $4 444 #4 #4#20%# $$44, 80%# 7l#44# 7}3i%$%s. #4.

V. -MiHM %S- 5 431 73

0 7)434 4-&4|-(Temperature Control Customer) : -8-4346A. 6B41

4 444^37|-344& 44a}34)^433 3#e]4 44) 4 44 344 4ABM47M4 44a}4 44-#4] 44444 4 4 444, 4 4tiH14 414 444 4£0]o_j.|_ -g^ 344 4 4. 4^4 -#4# ^444 3.15%# ff7j- IN- 4

® 3444 3 444 y_(Customer Service Incentive) : 3.44 4#34 4-faM 447M14 44434 44.

® 4144-84N 4-44 4-rc 44f4 44* 44444 44.(5) 7ie 47}3444 44aRr 444 4^ 44 444 43a}

3, 4444 ^-44a>4 4«H 3444 44. 7>3344 444 14344 44aM 44-aM 444144 ^#44.

(D.®.®4 AH34 44^144 ®.(D4 4444 4444 44.

(4) 444e A^-4443E.(PBR)4 47}4434443 4f: 3444344 &4&4 444 44 444 444

4444.0 443 3a>4 44 344^3.0 '4414444 444 34 -1-4 44 0 7RN 344 44 434 443 4 44444 44^O 344 4444^44 (4%4M44 44 453444 4444?) o 44 (44#4AM 3444. 344444. .s.^-49-4

444 4-)

74

4 MEt- ##44 444 4#4 44# 44^1#4 444 444 44 44 94 1444 444 84 3144444. 4 444 444 44 44 (43-30 4 #44-43 25 4444) 4444 444444 44 # 334 4, 4# 4# 44 94 15444 44 #443 44# 444 3, #44444 104 14 444 4 4/^-4# 4444.

BUC4 441 4#4# 4#3### 11.0%3 #443 #43### 11.0%# 4## 44. &4#4 #444# ^444 444(44)3- # «)|44. 4. ##3##^1 11.0-12.0%# 4## &4^j##4 25%# 3444 4443.. #43.444 12.0% 44# 444 12.0%# #4 4 44 50%# 3444 ##44.

(4) PER 3##444 3#4#4/144/14# 3###. 344 #7M1#4 444 1444 3## ##

43. 244 444 4434 #4# 444# 3## 4# 44444. # 7Ml#4#6l 34^1 4#4 4#4 BUG34# (D 4444# 4#4 4 443#. ® 444 3#4#4 #44# 4# ### 444#43 4/j- 43 #4.

1994# 4#4 3^444# 199644 4##44 #4 (CPI-1%) 44# #4-4#4. 44# #444 #443 ## #44 #43.44 4 444# 4444. 4##44 ##4^14 33# /}#43 #4# 44 4# ##43 #4. 4

(4) PBR4 44 ###4444 4#444 #4#4# 3444 4/1444 3444. 44#33 #4 44

V. -jpSHHN 4% %$- VA 431 75

44 #34 43 4#3 f44 4341# 37}#4 434# 4444 4 44444 444^5- 4444 44.

(4) PBR4 44 ±444 4444 4444 PBR4 44# 4#4 #W4 #44 ^4444 34

# 44 44444. ±44^44 #4 44# ## 4 44444;)- 4 44- 44.

(3) #4343# #34-3434(CPUC)

(;}) PER 334 44#4344 #4^}3 ;}±434 444 44443. 34 4#4 #44

344 #44444 4#4±3 PBR4 33# 4443 34. #434 4 ##44343 f4±## #4# #4344 433 #44443, 4*34 4# 43443 3# 4444# #43## #44 444 #3 44 44 4#4 7fl#t #37}- 34% 343 334.

(4) PER 334 44#4344#44 3 4 44347>±s}4 # SDG&E 34 4 43#

33# 433. PG&E4. Bocal#;]- 43 #41 34. 44344 # if 4434# 3 E4 3344# 33. #44 4# 434443 33# 4 344# 444 34. 714344 ## 4# 444 7}4 4444 #44 4# 4^43 334. (D #7}##, ® 7}^. ® 44 #4 #33 #34- 34414 PBR4 33# #4^14. 343 PBR4 33# #4344 ##44444 444 44 4#4 4 44#44444 ;}#4±3 43 4# 4#7} 343 33 4#4 #4344 ##44347} 4 * 61434714

76

44# ##44 #44# 44

(4) Pacific Gas & Electric(PG & E)4-

(?}) #4-4# ##441994# 4#. PG&E# #4#44 iM)4M3M # ?M1 ##4 #4

iM#4# 4444 44^44 #44# #44#4. 444 4^^ 7h##4 ^4?ie ###4#4# Ji444 44444 4W 4 44. ^.431444# ##44 #4# ^4#44 #44447} 4444 #4 44 4444# 44 #4#44- #44444 #.#4 5A4 #444#4 ### ## #4?}# 4## 44 4^-4. 4#4 44# 42.4 19964^1 4 4444. 44 #4 #4#44 #4444# 1994 4 344 3444 441^1^ 4### 444^ 444#(Gas Cost Incentive Mechanism)# 44#4. 4

(4) PG&E4 44- 44-4# ##4 44 o 7}4# 447}^ 444 44- #444 #4#44 ## 4444 4447W4 ##44 44-4. 44###,

##4#^}#. 44-7:#. #44## # 4# ## 4444^1 447}^4 #4# ###4 7}7i# #4^M #444M] 44431 444.(44 #4 4## 90%) m4 7}^&.^44 44^}# 447}dh #44#4 4#^1

7}^##4 4 3/4# 44431 47]# p^&E4 ##4#4# 4 4#4 4#4 ^^40] ^47}^ #44#4 4## &47H4#7}^ 4 4431, 7^7}## ## a|##a. 7}a^#?}3i7} ## 4^4#7} 4#47l 44# #44^44 444-. s4 4# 14 444# 7}a ##4 ^4# #44# #44 ^# 444 ##431 444 4## ##

V. -fhPNN 4# 5 431 77

3 43 ##4.44 44 PG&E# ##71-3 ## #443X1]# 4444 444 4,

4 4^4 304 #44 7}3##7M# 4#44 4^44 ;M4 7] #7} 4# 4444 PG&E4 3#7]-4o] 44# 44^}# 444 ^444 # 444 3#34# 44 44# 44444 #3433 4444 444 44 til44^ 7}3# 2:444 #443# 3444 444 444.

CPIM4 41} ###4# 44#4444 © #47}4#. 44# 3.4(Core customers) © Core • Subscriprion -2.4(4444447} 444444 Core 444 3ti]7})4 ##44. s4 #444 444444 7j-33## 4#4444 444^. #7l3#7l-34 444# 44714 44444/1- 4#44.

Core • 44344 #7}# 444 &3#, 44 7}^7}7\

Bypass4 444 44 Non-core #3# 1^7] 4#4 t.]4:Ea]7)3:£1a1-3 7)73^4^1 44 PER 4#4# 44-444.

#4435.# (444-Benchmark)4 ^4 ##44 4#4 4# #4 35. 4#7}(f^)a} 3447} #4# 44.

- 5%4# : 444#7}(^)7} #4- 5-10% : 50 : 5033. 347}a} 3541 444 #4- 444# A4 : CPIM4 #34# 44- 4443 : 44# 3til44 445. 44

o 34«1 44# 44 ##44 3#4#7}34 ##ti]^-o]] rflsflA^ 4#4# #7}3## A}3444 44

4 7I&34# 4444. 4&A44 4#^^-, 44444#. ±ti]7} #7}

78

44 -2-44 444^4 44.

^44-Nr ^44? 4^4 4:4.Rt = x (l + Cff + c -- 1.2%) ±SE

Rt : 4714 4444t : 19954 4f .

CPI : 44i 124444 ^444 ±:47]-^-7MgM-4 444c : 44i444 34444 44 4\&7H" #7M-

1.2% : ^34^44#4 444#±SE : 44 -444 444

199544^ 4#^]4-(CPI)4- 2.8%. ^4 ^44#7H-(c)-& 1.2%.1.2%^. 4^4JZ. 4^4. ^-44-^#4 4-4^&

2.8%^. ^4Ji 44. ^34^44^4 4&4 1.2%^ 4^t± 414^ f444 (Total Factor Productivity)0)] 444 444 444 4444* ^444 PG&E44 ^4Ji 4^ ^^14.

4. S44 71444 m\

1) 7}4^4 44] ^44 44

447^444 44 447^447]- 44447] °]4°)]4 47HM 4 44 44 7]-^.4o] ^^4444. 4M&4 444 7H44444 47]- 444^44 444 44 71^9.^] ^4^ ^^4 4-3#. n.44198644 44 4471^447]- 44444 44 44444 4^.4 44 4 44"]44 444 iS-444 4444 ±4^ ^44(44 ^44°]

v. -MiMM 4% qs. 5 491 79

25,000 thermal?}: 1 m34 10,500 teal 7]t—5. 44 5444 60,000 m' 44)4 A##44 54444.

7l4^4#/ll# 544-4 444 /15A^# 5if5 fA/M 4414# 4/l#44 444, 4#5 #A/M 444# 444a4 71-4 4 444 4 444444, 47Fr44 4 5/1 4# 4/14 4:4 ■ 4f #4 44 4 44 4-44 /1#4 444. 4 445.7}a444 44 A-g-4444 44 54# 4#4 #4#444 44-b4. 1980444 #4 ####4 /M 4/1-71- #444 4-4 7^1-44 A^44al4 f/l-##^l 44444 4 4# 4# 4#/l 4^444. 44-4 ±44#4 /l5A^-4 ^44 #4# 4144 44# 444, 7^444 44°1 4444, 44 4 4-71-^4471- 44444 44 4M4 A^-44 444 444 44 44 #^4.

2) 7M4444 544 44

198644 45.4 /1544 4444 44 454AA# ^#7154^4 A 444471- 7144-711 4444, 44 445.44 454Hi- 544 4 44 British Gas(BG)7l 444 4544 444444 445 444 41 #< 4444 44444 715444544 54/1# 5544# 44 44 4444n 4444 A^#4l7l 4A44 444.

/M4SHM# 198444 -^4 ^##4 (British Telecom :BT)4 4 4## 44 544##41. ^1 415^ 4#4 f/l5##if/lMl 44 (D 4 54-5 44 4# #4141444# 4. ® 444 A#44 44 #4^14# 444 #54 # 44 4 #4 444 445## #4# #4# # 44# 4. ® A^-444 444 #/l5###/lMl 4*H 4#4 4# 45/1 4A

80

434 iM4-&& #4 t 44^ 4 f 44 -74^44-3 444#4. 444 444 444 f4444 44 f 443 7}3444 ;M444 a# 34444-.

7M44444 444444 444433. 444 444 4-37M4 4444^14 4443. 44. 444 4*8 443# =&%44 44 3i73 f37}^-3 199844-^ 4443& 444 3#^ 4444-. 3^4 44 44433.^ BG4 44 7M44iP44 4343 #444 4^4 4. 443^ 7M444-44- 4444^ 2.500therm ^144 4444 BG4 4444-44.444- 434 444^H 44 443 4 4^ 44. 44 44, 3if3 4\&4 444 444 444 4444344 44 444 4344 44% 433. 344.

444-SHM^r 19864 7}3 444 f44%4 44^1 BG4 4444434(Authorization granted and Directions, 19864 44, 19914 12% 174 f4) 4 33 ^ 3%-3# 44-^ 3444 44 7\±7\'^ 4tKRestriction of gas prices to tariff customers)j 4 44 e4# 4-3 #4.

3) 7M44 44^44 4444

7}) 71444^-44 444471444^44 44^ ® 44 44(444, 44^-4- ^ 4444),

CD 44(444, 47^444. $4"4. 44. 44 44-#- 4-). CD =M 44 44 44 44 444 4A?M %444-. 7}y]^4 44 344f4 df43%-47i 5-7%4- 4443 #4.

'bk-tkk-r ^ ^ ^ kM^b (DR bb-k kkk bb^ iHHR'vb Ib4? bk barbR b09 |b kb k

R ^b?(bs)bkbkkgrbb k(bo^-oz)bkbk kk^b ® ^R -^-k k"z:|R i<»bZ RTV b#? bkbbk fk-Wb& 'bbbbkk '^kbRb ?k '^kb# bbk ^kbb? b bkkk? bbk "§"lflvk kk kb=Fb -f-bR kbkk-R ?b

b^bb #bf? k%^ z f k kbkS kbk-bk bbkb kbbb irbkR Rk (okk bkbb k-blm -Rb^&^b bk%: b^k^nr ?oR bkk bkf? k%0Z k09 kb ^ 'bRbb^ -#-& kk kbf? 'bb^ bkbbb k09 kt&kk ikkk-^k ^^-&&?b

'b&bk ?%s kk%z fbx kkk k kb kb k?kZ66l kbbb ^bb Ikkbk kbb bs-kb-fT ^k%3 kbk bkS ^k kA86T b(8BgJ0)kkb bb?b bk b kbbk ?%S kk%Z ^ kbX k?kZ66l k?k bkbT bB

bkk bkk kkkk ^ bkkk -B-RX kb^ bk klo#i4k kbkb k09 kkk ?vbk kbk

kkbk kkk kkk irb^& #bkk kbkkb kkA86T ® 'b vkk bkb kb #izb bkk-bR RbR bbbk kbk bkb b? -kb kkkk ® kk# kbbb bbk kbk kb l^kX bk k kkk kb kbbk kkbk bkkk k09 kbk bkb kkk k#b kb%2 'kk# kk kk-R kkk kk kbk kx bkkbk b%% kbx bkkA86i kkk bkbk kk&is bkkkkb

kb kbb kbbR # kb kbX (b

18 IHy rn bk Nk^Fok 'A

82

a# 444 -f-4 E44 f7}434. BG4 444£i-# 44"& 33?}k 3±3 344 7}/L ^ 33^ 444k 4#& # 3±± 3344 4* ^4 ^#44k 3±& 434.

19943^4 #4 7k: 34344k X4 5%44 4%± 3443 4. 199244 433 ""44 -44^4(^4444)j 4 444 43d! 4 60,000 m'4444 4 6.000 m'44± 44=1444 7}4#3 4 4-8-^4k 1994444 44 60.000 m'44^. 44 114 BG4 44 4 44447} 4±44 334. &3 199344 k3. #334434 (MMC)7} BG4 4^1344 44 6.000 m' -60.000 m'34444 3 3A^434 k#3- BG44 H444 444 X#& 5%44 4%^ 34 4^4 33.34.

4) 34444 3i4

7}^^-44- X4i- 33444 34 434±& BG4 <334-8-4 3 4 M-sMl 44 7]e, 7}44 47}4. 4-k4-0-, 3k3 34f44 k4 4-T-4&# dl-#-44 33^44 4434- #7}#7l 44 ^-4344- 44 43k4. 4k X#4 47}44 BG7} 444-3. 3k 34-r^}3- ji.443 4k 44- 4444. 444 X4 4344 434 4 334 #4-f4-4- 3A44 4 4-4k 7}^4 4 232. ^k44 4# f3j ±#4 444 7} ±^3k BG4 k44 7l&4 28444 4k444- 44 X34 ^ 43# f 34.

4) 7}43-#if44 44 ±444 44

7>43W44 334 44 44± 44r4 4^M 7}k44 34k 4 44 34. 344 ;}±43344k 3344 k44 ±444 44±a:

V. -MiMM 34 35- 5 431 83

# 4t} 7l3±5.4 7|-4i±tilA]-^S|(Gas Consumer Council: GCC)7]-34- 3#44^4. 1992^4 43^

433)j 4 443. BG4- 7}±^3^ 3"± 3"4^M 44± 7]e(384 ±4)# 434^4 5)4 3U, 44 if-44^1 o- 4:351-1- 3#4^4 4al 44.

GCC4 4:4^ X44 4^14 7}444iM4 4-0-±4^ ^4^1 4 44± f#4 ^3%, 7M44 ^4334 #3 34444r ^43±5 GCC 43# 34434 3:444 #3#444 X4 ##4 434 4# 444 44 44.

4) 7M3-4 33#44 4#

7}) jzifjs. 4^A7} A^-(43±334 6.000 m'44)

7M3-4444 43-3: 44 7}/% ±433 6.000 m'344 #3##334 3 therm(= 25,200kal)4 4-2- 344741410). 7f43"4 33434 #34 19874 43 334# 60.000 m'344 if3^1 iM434 5d4. ^-44 19944 #3##4 447} 60.000 m'3443 6.000 m'^145. 4:334. 34 4443 6,000 m'# 44 44s, ±334 -&## ±447} 7}±-^44 443 33447} 33-34 44^34 44 44

434 3333 3#4^ 4#4± 334.7}43-4 #44 #3#4# * 3

10) f±5 113 -§-iH 7}^3 ±4#& 555 55555. 55# 5 545

34- 34-34 5544555 44*15 4-2-5 4#4. 334 533 44K4±& 7}^#5*}5 if3# 5 55^j. #343 3454 4# 5aj5 44-3 434 #a#3-2-. Armstrong, M, et al, Regulatory Reform: Economic Analysis and British Experience, 1994. p.66-73.

84

o 19874 4^44-19924 34M, = {i + (7gfy-x)/ioo} - f(_i+ y,-#,

0 19924 4444-19974 34M, - {l + (72P4-X)/100}-f,_i+ { (GC7,-Z,)

/100}-yr+Er-^Mt : t4^4 44 therm4 4 jl4i3"-8-4RPI : fds. 1044 44s. 1044 ^4#444^4 444X : 4144 44^- 4^

Pt-1 : ^44-§-44 44^ 4-#- Yt : t4S4l 44 therm4 4—44

GCIt : t4s4 44 7}^l-§-44^Zt : 4di4-§- %^44& <100 - (1.01n-l>Et : 444 444&-&4 -&±Kt : therm4 S444

#, = {T,_i-(0,_i -M,_i)}/Or {l + (4/100)} Tt-1 : t-1441 44 if-4^44444 4^4 Qt : t44 44 if^A^-44444 444=It : Kt7l #4^ ^14 4^ 4a44 44^4-3%.

Kt?} 444^ ^144^ 4a44 444- 44444 &

444 7}^ ^-44 444 447] 444. 4s4 44-84^ 714A4 4 444^ 19854 124 444 4^44 7]e^_ dz4#7M14= (Retail Price Index: RPI)4 #7M-& 44 ^ 7l^-A4444 444 444. 44 44 444 44 7)^4 4444 471^4

V. 4M} 5 43] 85

4 4^ 14 if444 A^-44^44^ ^5l31 44.

4) 19974 4^f4~20004 3^

34 X4^r 4% 44 Ji449d4. ^44 7^9-3] 444^ 44-44-(^444-) 44 A^-4 444^ 4-^& 44^4. ^1

^ ^ 4444-5- 44 & 4# 7M44 4444 43.. 7^4444 7}^H-c- 44^4 447}-44 444 7^4 47] 4^44. 44^ 7) e& -#-44 4^44 4-44^4- 4744^^-4. ^.4H]-§-& 44 344 9^4.

3TN& 444 44 ^44 44 444 4 4-^ BG4 444- 344 4^4 44 4#44 1.5%4 444^ 44 44& 344 f^4. 7M# 44 444r 4^4 444 44 19974 44 14 444 BG7} 4443 ^1^ 7]^^-4 #43^ fe44 444 44 7M44&444c- 433 4449^4.

343 444 444 19984 644 4&44 44 7144444 44 7} 344 433 344 4, 3-5-4 44-4^ 20004 444 343 344 4444 44444 44 7^^- if-444 7M447MM #4# 434 4433 44.

86

VI.

1.

Il#±3 3l7l-7:413^^^ 41H)±37i 441 4^444 1135.H-& 4444 44. 3.43. 444 4# 44^44 ±44 # ±±44 44 44444 if444^1 4141 41 4##44 14.

344- 45- 13 1414/11 111 4±4 ir!441, 444;M 4 4444 4# 411434 444 44, 4:44 444 4-4-1- 44: 44441 44-4 !A14 4143 141 4 1411 41414 14 4- H4! 444#, Hf4 444# #4 H 4#4 114 44 444 7H4114 4441 14#1443 4447)1 4441& 3443 44. .

144 141 44- 4^1 !-&-4171-3 ±^114 411 4±4 l&l444 7^1544 44.7}4 34M! 11 4±± 1441 413 1 -S44 44 44. 7^14# 4444 ±444 1&4444- 4443 14.s4 41. 7M4. 11441144 114 4171-343! 4!±±

11) ifa.4 3;# #^444 if^-4 ^^7} ^##5 #44 1344 44f f^4b ^44 414 4447]- 434-1^45 44 4*H ^4 ^41"] 4-8- 44-& 4444.

VI. -fi-ti-frU 7N45 44 7^5. 87

^##4 7i4 ^3# 514. 4. ##41 /M/l#^l 4!#,#4M1#^1 ##. #3^1 #4. #4M#a] 7W. d:44#4 ^7Si- f# ±444 44 #4. 44 444 44, 444444 44- 44 44 4444 44444 444 44 ±#± 44?} 4444£ i44± 444 /!## 444 444 5-44 4444 44 #^1 444 7U 44. 444 4-5-4 44 #dl 444 4444 19984 444 ±45. 43/M4H 44 44±4i- 4^4 i#3s. 5134, 4 44 ##4# mK 4± 4##4 444 1144. 1995-1996444^ 194 #44 4# #± ## 4^!4± 51442) n44 444 4447114 444 44444 4^4, 4# 4444 4

34##41. 4±f44 #41. ±#± ±4^}4 44 4#^/l#4l. 4#4 ^5-444 #4|, 4444^4 441 #4 #41# 4/144 /)#^# # 4± #414444# 44441- 4444 44/1-4 44# 444± 51# 4± AM44-.

4#444 44 444 4444# ±44# 4#. 3.4#- #4444 44 44# 43 44444 44, 4444 444 444 ##44 44 ± 44444 44 #3, 444 4#4 4344 44 #4 #44 51#

444 434. 43#4 #444# #41 43 ##?1# 4## 4 44 4 5134, 4 ±4 444 #4, #4444 44 4±#4 /f#46l 444 4 514, 44 444# f445l 4±/l- 3444.13)

12) ifl-i 4#/M 4% #44 334 /13344 4# ^444# 4^4 4443434 #5.47]_s. Costello. K.W, et al. "Unbundling of Small-customer Gas Services: New Challenges for State Public Utility Commission", Energy Law Journal, 1997. Vol. 18, p. 137-170.

13) 45# f 444 $13 #§444 ^44^# ^-44 43?} 43 f44$14 43435. 3-2-7} 3sflt 4343 4443 4443 4# 434

Cooo

Si

*2.41

!

£A

&

bbrntioii>M.rlr

1

s

rlr4

Icute._R

y,.fjo4°

£

if

I

filletsoil4°M.rlrJimrX.

$

4-

s

I

M

4>

■f4Wb

*M.M.vrlr

Iiflmini%

nM4

[u3,fi

2Lrto

&41

I^ o|-JnM. J2

g42p’Oj*.j2m2oilo2[ti|o424

Ml

1

rFJoj.X

m2HuXI

lrm2

ri2x42

Hi >b H1

ojfl to,m. [ti.

Xlbg

41g

4m_2tog

mb>b c&

-afo

a>

oi£ o& ,12

£iii|ojl?t44~xT

42

tor|rHiMl

1ohl

iso4L

o((I1rb_to°HW

I

42m,opmb

£X

*2|g_b

42opW1xajtoMltoHrMlIt

opg

3?

If Hidjj

mb

iv_u °iL-4 Fr Ml a-|t> [tfjo

j£J£L

o- 00o

IN

rlr>4.

Oa

Jh rl2 _4 _b x 424? ^

m2Hu N"g

42

1 ix

42 4L

N

op

m2Hu

-H m2, r-jm m|g 01'.

to

x

4>

0|r

*2rlr

J& JL 4b • 42 Hi

Mlr-jd-2,

1rF

tog

fU

rbti.

-bMl

oU

JbtojS,mbm|o

to42

rbrbMl

r-jd42

oil<&Jffi42

tiO-ti

to

imj>

Hljo#24x,

torlr

X. —J

42

42,to4242m|m

dbla

ojfllov rb

x

>4

I

Ml CU

|rb

42 41 42 '7 4*

opmjom|g

-to,444bto42rlr>b

g42rb

-m Nm -2 ri

rbMl

!odEt[J

-l£r-dru oa

r>-

4 Si

w

.a.

m2Hr

X

Ml

44rb4$

4b Mr

y Jin ob4bx

42

1Ml

rHioS,

m|o

Mw4W

1$

42

°rmjg

to uM

42 _2

-2. H>rb. 4l ob Hd

42

op

4

mid

1n%

N-a

rlr

4w 4b M. _b ojs>^ H>Ml af *

& fSi42 42 xm2bw42g

o]rlMl

N

k

Ml

IobJ4mb

4>

^2To

CDO

gnX

^ _brlr 4L

W

^2

i

i»Sra

t

*■ sI&

4bxrb

44rbop

S f

Mlr(g

_2lr

x

mb

4>

rlr44 qi40 ^

HrX

Ilf—r-7 a(o m2 1> . ojflifcg 4b mg

$!$Iflit * ^1stti■=='■< f-dH- CulL o

-r"1° 41'

Hr 'm2 rb

(V.

44j£

$it

ojs>

ol<._2

J2LX

mS£42

I[t|(U

ojm

W

£2JL

Ait

|U2

rroicLit

o|n

ivltiXI

!°4

w|rt

A0&

SJc,r|rog.

okjupri2x£

=jo {to d(j x

XI

3l4k ±42 m241 44

■ $ oi°!i44

4c,

424J

42 42

tfi- 4u =>ki afSL

!U|lUoW

Iol'.

rlr

k44

t&oSL

£££

jffi

to|n42,

2

$rfr

\j r.4i

O Jjj,44 a\)i

M 4J- $X 42

44 M 42

S w

424 4

iuh

-2, >t444 r|r44 44i %J2 o%LA rS^ 41

>.It:

dh

x

IIitlrla.

XIa

IA

Hm

§£2rlrs4r|oit

oj»

m2.X,r|r

td(u

ri4x

£■St

ife

I

r-4iui

£

w

14 44* t

-frirtix x

m2 42 42

# 44c^L ^

A ^ ojo 42 or a

s

42

-4l rlrUrf ~2 #o& 42o4 it

f s 2 S

i1d4

x.

4l

^ rI**4j itjo

I st2„ ap

m2 A 44

^ ta2 AI# -4/ndo xi

rtjjm jo

I Ir.2 AA 4444 ^ a jj

H> => 4L

$ sII-l> Hi *2 Mr rlr 44

XJ

m(S

£Dk!Iffl

t>o

^1°r®.

1»04-442

d£

!dXHn

X

ofli

r*xoV4L

0

ti$otyhA&jL

0-4>d2

rlr(t|mdS4$244

14 42(U44f4°i'±.i

iitlna%244

4>

£4

o)fltOV

JEn^Lo4L<AAA42

Him2r|o

££wl«tu&:o<U

$£4

rjmA1d£42

>£,

_2

I54r|°-d£LHr

J4j£it£ri4£4

II%I

42r4m444sL

ojn4kS

VI.

iHM

K tfloj- 89

90

44#3- #7}##& ##4a 5(14.AM #444 # 44 45.4 #4#^44? 4444 444 f44

# M, f444, 44### ?4 44^144^ tss. 4444 444 #4.4?44a 44 4444 44 4444? 444 4# 44444 444 444 44444a 444-4 444 4444.

yi4. ;l|#4aa. 4^}# 54144 ###7}* 4#?M ### 4### #44 4#44 aef#4 #44a 5(14 4#4 ###7}# 4"#^}# 4#4 a47}2: 44444? e444 #7}4# ?#& 4^4a %14.

a44 4a4 4444 ###7} iHMa# #4 4a i-44a, 4«S 4 _&4#4#- 4?4 4? 4444 f;}44 4444& a444 # 4 aa 4444.

44. 444. 444 #44 44 444 -S-a# A44 4444 #a,##7}^# a#44 44. 4# 4^.4 7}# 44. 44# A444# 4a> #7^14# 444# 444 444 -S-a# -S#-?#4 44#a& 4 ###7}# 444 ###7}a4#-a(#a# A4-)## 447} #f 4 4 44 ###7} 4444 #7}4# 444 44#? #47} 444 7}#

44 #4.#4. 1992#4f a47}a444# 4144 4# a^-#4#^l #7}4

5. 44# 44, 444 4#& ### #5.4 -§-a# a^-# 444 a# 44. 44# 444^4 ^14 4#7}# iM4##4 #4447} 2:44 a #4.

4H. 444aa a#7}a444-a 44# 44# a#44a# 4b##447} #7#}# ^-4 444 ^#7}# 4444 4#4# #7}4# 4^.44 4)4 A]^4 #7}7} 444-^4, ##|4

VI. 4M4M- 4°} %s. 91

4 ^7pg44 #91^1 #44^ SM-.4)4. 9^44 #4 # 44 #4 ^44^ ##4^ ^44^ 44

4 44 ## 4444 «D##44 e## 4444 444 ###4 443,-i 4315, 44 44 44-S-4 444, el 44 444 1X4 44 $4 4444 #x# f444-& X#4 ;|44 4 4^4 431 44. 4444x4 #4# X#4 444. 4444^- ### f4. 44444 X914 4# 444 #4444 4# 44 4444 444 4^4, 4/|-4 444 4 4314-& 44-47) 4g# 4)^M ^X7^ 44:

4. 7M4441 E4

444 44 4 44 4^1 ;M4444 44444 4444 444 444 ?M444-14)4- 44X& 4444 4e#x4 4^ 43)4 # #^7)-4 914## 44431. 3 ^44471 X^-4 444) 7)-f-# 44# 4 41=0)4-15). o)# f# 4444] 4444 ^1 444 44 44 444 414 4;}-4441 44 &4^1## 4444 44x44# f#4x, #4, 447}/} 7}##4) x#4M# 445# 4xx, #x«@ x#4 4xx& 7)^4# 4444. 4)4. X^-444) 4# 3M4## 4±4# ^#44.

3.44 o) 4)^# 7)#4x# -^7)^4# 441 ##4 X#^^"^#7)- X## ^^N4. 7^44 ^#4 44## #447) 4471 4#7)-4 a. 7^44 #4#4 44 47H- 445.4x ^)4 ^1 4471# Wi# 444 e 7M17). ^4.

m4 4# #7Mo) #44 # 4^ # 4#4. o)^) ,# #?M

14) UtiiTiAs. ##3. $14. 6lir 4<d7}4 °|44i: «##;) 44 444.15) til-7,4 if7ii4 ^-r-4-c ;# 47H 44 #44- 45& 4^7}4 a^]

4 4444 44-i 7>44 44 44.

X 0$,

r4j 41xXo

o]j> rujo

a,oR X21 XnS, m|o

mkX ok0|» [U*rIS “r^vi

JcL ok.XXXX m|m ^

X X Hix HR r|rRu >|yX Hs,X X Td(j mk X

gM'(itjo jjdX N4°

r-m|m hr

M'tfijoxXVI

nR Xit

oj» o

41

X r|n0^ 21X nR X m|ti

4IXXI

j4Itllo

Xto

o& ink ilo

>ci &Xft. IU rt->

^ 21 ^t-fl nR o4jjdi X °4,Of'. X xX X IThrSo

41

<X o>

XlUjo

4° x

4ol'x 41

XLnoiosxHiHin°JoJXonoknMIffl

e& r[rXIT Xr|o2r&

Nd$X

£X41iV.

XmkX

rliimlXo

!

I

oS&

X 41XI

X°Y

§R Xr|r m|o>41 X

O [Ujofli 21Ht ja

Hn-A -k,- N

X X |T

rJpL mk rk- 44 oS, ok rf£L X X^ ^ Hi

X HiN x

-k * # HR^ >2

2g

(U|(U41XXr|rcn

X41XIt&iniXi

$g

X0&41X

x-r1oil*21(tljtU

10t».p-

Nj£_12xa

mk

%X&Is|ll|o

1$44

142,x

j|mok441

1-i|moiItijo

oR1oj»M[uS,Ru

-k X X oj» R> m$ oR g

X4j ojo H>

y.g s hrX

imjo 2 4 6 2 fLia

h 44 Xhr

X

COto

Xop XO £ *

5 5

XX4i

xA£

XHl]o

hj|(ij 21Si4k, ok, hr Ho

>41 ^ r|o mk

, or*mb 41 X ml X 41X k r®. ^_o ^

S 1>|d

r|r uAHR ^

nt

S ionX fa f^ i

[U$mkbo

=j

XX

inEXXo

X

ab

xSXXXmla!a$ito

irx m:

tHi^_ o)L

oV

m|iuX ' ' X X X hr

ol«,Xj

I sjjnl

xXrl,RaiX

Xg

xxr-)o

Xm|o

XjRXXrnfeM.x4lXrklU|o

akrkm#H>SRhr

2X

r?o(dJkXHit!oRokm|o

XXm$H>Xi

%

Ul

XI

r£mjo

X&Huti

tn

1ojd jk Xr5oR

mM,

n&m|o r|rHo A

VI. -M-M Wl5- $5- 93

*13}#- #^4# ±#44 ?}?44%r 44 44444 447M#44 7]&70444.

4# ^#4 ^47^444 4 4±# ^443.5114. ^14^# 4^1# 4444 4#4 4# 444 3.4444.

44, 444 2444 444# 444 444##5 ##4# 4444#4# 4±444.

#4. 44444 444 44# 444 444 44/K 4, 44 444# 4^-4 444 ^M4 44 4## 43^- 447H 44 4-54 444.

^4. 4444 -8-441 4*0 44^ 4#4 44# 444# 44# 4#444(Cost pass-through 4#4 ##).

^4. 43 414^1 4# 4# 4#4 #K4 4#4^, 4:4#4## #4 4is. jl44 444 444, 44 44# s# 434 4444 444^7} 444.

4^*9. 4±4 7]^# 4#^= 44^ ## 4#4, 6] 44##4. :%4Jz. 4#44# 4e±& ^ 4#*0. 4^1#4 44^4# ^1# 44# 444# #4# 47]444.

444, 44 44444# #443 4# 444 44 #7>44 444-# A#4 4#4 #44 4 5(1# #44 44434 #44 4# 43 4 4 %#4 70^4 #4#^1 34444.

444 #4 # 44 4^1 44 4#44 4^ ##4# 4444# 4# 4 4#4 4^4 4##4 444 4443 44. ##4 4#4# #4 # 44444 #44 4"3#^# 71-# 544 447#!- 43^-±& 4444.

4*3 ##4# 4444# W#7M4 40%44# 444# 444. 4 44444s., 44 444##°0 444# 4#7#1^44, ±e 4444

94

***. (#7)4**-4*#4***) #* 4*44 #7)444 *44*44. 444 4*3444* 7M4444 444 7Hv4.

°|f7l| 7fltis|x>^ W)-g^4f- f-sfl ^7^^-i- **##7^ 57#4] sg344 37)44 **#7l-i- 444* 44* ^44 *34*4 ** 4 44* 444 4/M4 ^7>44 444 *44* 44. 444 #34*#4* 444& 4# **44 4*4 44 4*7} 4444 4* 444 4 4*7}*4 444 44** 4444.

443-43% *4*(1.03%). *4*44(2.65%). *7}4(48.82%) * 4 4444r 44444 *44 44** 444 4*** 4*44 4*4447-1 44431 44. 444 4*4 444 *44 4*4 **4* 4 7>43i 4*4. 44 44444 4*44* °14 44 $£.?} 444 44

444 *444 4 * 4*^1 4*444 ^^)^ 6)c) 4^) 4^1# 4)4- *44 444 344*# 44431 444 44- 4 4 44. 44, *4- #444 ^)^.a) 7||^ 4^4^ *3#7}4 4= 50%4** 44 ^ f444 444# **^}3 *4. *3#7}* *344 444* 4 *^}* *4. 444 44444 *4* *4444, 4# #7}&44 44 43 #4, 47)-444 #*# 4444 45.4 7)^4 447}. 444 4 *4444M #47}47}4 4e44 #44 447}4 #4. 4^4*4 44* 4444 4*44 4*4 44 #*7} *7}#*& 4*44-.*4* 444** 4*4 #*4- 4444^. 44**44 #3^14-4

7)4^1 4*4** 44**4# *34*4 ^}3 *4* 4*4* 44 4 444* 4*444 4 444. 4* 444 43 4444 #4 7}4 *44* *44 4444*4 *7)4 447} 4*4* 4444* 44.

VI. 95

57# aw?} 333:1 3^ 7i#444 333334 444 A 34^# ^.4 3b 4# 4^-3=- 33 444-^ 43 333 34 514. 4*1 3444 444 3434 51-b 4344 3^714^-3333 A 3344K# ^333 44 34 34514 43 A3. 4434.

444 44 4 44 44 334 as.4444 344a# 434 4 a 4343 3 33Aa.4r 7M33 444 44. 44^44 44 4-44. 44-4;^ 444 #3. 471-4 44. 4444 44. 3443 A#f, 4 ^71-4 34 #^1 514.

7l#4^4 7M343 334 3^1 33371-4 #43 43##wl34 #43# 44 433 4AA 4334. #. 3A71- #43 3443- 5lA. 343# 4 344 43 3444 3z>7> 443 44- 433 < 434 oj A#4# 34^134 #43 A#3 443 34^4 337Hb34 4 3 44 4344. zz.43 344A&# 34434 343 34 A3. 44 34344 333 3A^^i 51# 43- ^1^43.

7}44f4 344 4-r 3f# 33(#7Mf#)^ 433 4^-43 3444 43# 4eA3. ^ 43* 343 f 3-b4. 4^413444 37}# 7l^AiL 3 4-f. 334 4# 3Jl4 3471- 513. 3343-c 4 43 34# 3334 44 4^43 447> nf-44 44713# 344 43^. 3433. 33. 44 3f4 33# 3433 444 A34 7}# 34 3# #3 333 ±44#-44 344 43 433AA 4#7f#3 3±# # # 51# 344 513.

4524401 4# 4#3## 4333# 4# 34 4^# 43^1 4#

3. # #

96

Ibb ^433.4 bbbbl l!%4b 4411 4" 5lI4b 4!61 5tl -9-4. 4 4144 ^1442:4 441. 4b!b44 13441 344 4 16I &bl 41444 44441 44 4144 4444: 444

b 5^4b 4. Abb# 44444 14# a.4 bl!4 4 4 44b 444 f-1437} 4444.

14414 ^b 44b ±«144 44441- 3114, 44444 4

^444 444 44^4 4b 4444 4444b 4444 ^44^ 444^1- 7)-^# bblb 4444 b!!b 3b lb61 € 4614. 44 44 341444 l7}3 13b 441 b ^b 114133 444 3 44 bb 4b 144 4444 44444 4 133 4444.143b! b&44 14b b!#44344 4144 4b44. 44

3b! b344 14b 7j^4b. 4b 7]i! 44. 444 444 111 44 444. b3#7} bll 1 l^/l^lj 4444 44b 44 bb f-1133 3.444 1144414. 4144 7}1 13! 1 bb 4!b4# lb6]4. 4144 b44 41 bibb 4b 10%3 1114 41lJi 4-9-4, 7}^/]!!# #33 3l7j-3444 4114144 111334 114b4 4117>7> 4#4 4 f444 1 444.

ml 3H14 bill 444- 3334 17^11114-5-# 43! 4b *'144 44bs. 14b 141! 147111 41b 4434- 13,

61# 3b!!4 14^1-b !!3 13! #37^ %14.bib# 3b#4b /j-1133 7Mb#b 1114 14a. 14b 4

bllb b3!4 ^461bb 13! b 13# 13.. 4444b 11% b! bblb 1114 bb*M !b?}b l7Mlb 3#!l3 #3!

VI. -Mf! W151 4^1 4 s. 97

4 ^144^rJL*} 4^ 444 4^44.3.44 A-g-4^7} 4444 4444 4444 #4 M41-4 444-

4 44 444 444444 44 ±444 44444 444 £1- (Profit sharing rule)4 444 4 444, 444 °]444-1-4 4444^44 444#& 44^M4. 4^4^44 4141r4 4444 4c 44461 1±4 &4 A4444 4444- 444 4 444 4- 44 4^11 4 44.

444 444 1^-444^44- 4443. 1-^1 A^-4 41^r 4^7} 44 Hi 444 44-c 4444 444 44 144. 444 131 14#7l 14 #17} 4f444 44 144±±7>^4 44 44 4±5.1414. 2.4 417I-5-4 7>m4 44 44 44 447> 44444 4^ 143 44. 4H l#Hjm 44±4 4 4±4 4-471- 4444 444 433 1414. 44 l#i 4ei3 4 IWll 444 144 444 4144 14 444 3114.

-5-4 4±44 414 H433 111 1441, 117]433144 44, 4114 14- 4144 3. Ill- ±14 47}<4 1444.

1^ 3^-3lf7]i 11^. 43.114. 414HHM43# 314 114^ ±1^4# 3-51 133 14-444 ^ 444, 3.43 144 1^-4 44 1^1 1313 11441 A!. 4\5_! !-§-. 3^g41 4 4411^ 1-4 44 ^ll7}7j- 1344 14.

98

3. 41^7^#- 4#

#^4 547^3 3^-##4Ml# ##4^4Ai 4^!#3 4# ###4# #4# 43 3##3 %(34, ##435 ###44137]- 4^4^ 4 3#44 e44 3#4]34 /]#-#-& 3#4 ## 44 444 #3# 4 44## 4i- 44# 4, #*34 4]3# 4444 44 4444 44 3 44 444571- ### 44 ##44. 44# 4444 #44 -8-4414 4- 444 #4 44-8.5. 44^1 4 #4 4 4 # 444.

4. S!S#e|4 4514 #H

#444 44 444 555 44#4444# ##5# 43.. 444 35 44-44 #34 #4 43# 44-44. 4-# 3##44 #44# 4 4# 444# 44 44444. 343 444444# #5.4# &44# #f4 414## 4447}- 4#35 4f#3# # #3# #3# 41## #37} #4.

31# IN 3471-3/1-44(4 183)44 4443 %1# 7}34 ## ###4#4 ###7}## 4 #44# 44# #33 #4. 3 #4## 4# 44 347I-3 3#44# 44### #3## #444# #34 4##3###4 ##444 #4# 434 433 #4. 44# 444444 344-4 #44 t# #35 #4 #7>4#4 3#4 #44 44##44 &# 4#4# #7l##4 43## 4 4# #4# 7}##4 4# ## 444, 3## ##35 44# 7i##o] #71 4#44.

vi. -a-si-a-g 7js. 99

44^. #s#(4# 4##) 47j#44 4^±s 444. S|4# #± ss# #447} 47Ms #44 xi-^i- 4s# l^o] ^ 4. s# 444 #7}## 4 4##s 44444 #44 44 4/M 44 4 ±44- 44 s47}± ±#444- 444 444s(#7H4, 4#4 # 444. 44444 4s. 4)4 4444 4#44 44.

###44 444# #4 ±444 444# 44s, #4444 4# ## 4jl4# 44# 7^44°> 4 444.

4. Aid |s rn^-n

#444 4-E^4MM4 444 AM^jAi # # 4# 44- 44 444 ± #44s# 44^ 4#4# 444 Ai4s #44## 4^44 4# ###4 #4 4 #4 4s± #44# 44# 44# ^#7j- 44-.

Ai4± #44 #4# 441. 4#4 414444 #4### #4±^. 4# 44, #4, 7|-4444 #44 4e# #;))s# 4# 44, 44, ±4 7} ±#4## 444# 44, 44, ##4- 47\%± ## #4 4± #4 4## #4444 yj-4# ±44^4# 4#44 444# #4 444 44. 4#. 4#. #4±4 4#4# 444s# 4^^1# A^js 444# 44.

#4#4#44 7|^44 #44 ##444 44 ^]#±4# 7j-4 #4 4 &44 4#44 44 4#4 444 444±4# Aiw]s#4 7^?}# #4 4## ±44s4 4# #44 #44 # 44. 444 #444 4 444 A14± 44 #44 44 4±7} #44# 44 A}#44.

4. #SMEE atsf

100

19859 ## #944437# 347#7#A943 94444# 443#4# #94# 45-T" 397^13# 7^] 7| 4# 4944 434 ^-;#7l- 7}4# #37j# 4#4 94 4943 $14. 4. 3 44^4344 44 4444 3994# 949. 944371- #4943 #9-43. 4#433 44WI 949 44# #994444.44 9949 4# 4443 44. 394 #4 444 434 944 4# 94 347}^444 944 944 44433 944 3944.

444 444 49 94344 444 44 44 444. 344 7}±7#44 7|94o|j7 4#4 49 3#4 jc49 #49334 347^4 44443 444 99 4343 4# 9444337# 7# 49^-4 444 444 394 44# ^ 4949 44# 4#33 44 39 4 944 994 4443 94 7}37l-447l- 4494 4444 333 3944 444 7]#49# 394 43# 9444 4943. 44# 9 4# 44 9344.

449 #494 39434 7I-9 9 44# 444 4#49 943# 4 #344. ^1 434 9444 #4# 437# 44# 443 444 44. 347] 444# 39# 399 4444 9444# 944# 44 94343 #344. 444 43944 494 434 444 4344.

4. 944 459 @4

94 347#47H7i9 44433 49 99493 444# 97# 9 94jg7M# #943 44. 3943 #943 499994 49

4. 434

VI. 4W# $<$: %£■ 101

4^. 333-3.3 333

M333 3Af#, *)$. 5L>^1 3-S-3 4 ^& 443 #& ^3 444. A^434 43. 4f3

*£. 334 34 ^34* 431 34.

102

VH. _M=

4# 444444 #4444 411!: #47} 4^34# 7j#-4 #4#44 4HM 4# 7]^a] ^47}^ #4^1-4 44 4444# ^4# 4 £.#°1 47143i 44. 444 44444 s4# >4 44444 44-4 7}4#4 4^-4 4## #4 4443. 44.

4441 44444 44# #44 7^4 44444 444# 4444 4 444 44431, 4444 444 4444- 4# 4444 4444# 4#^1# 4# 4444. 4. 4#44 4#4 ##4# 7}#4 7^ 4# ##4 44 #4# 4444 4#f#4 #44 4# ^%# 3:4^1-44 4443L7} 4ji 4^4, ^14# ^^4 j&4-# 44447! 4# 4#4 4 4 #44. 3:4444 #4# 4147HM1 4#^# #£#31 44.

&4 444^4 44°1 #4431, 7}4 444# 7}t|# 4#s- #A 7M 44 7}4#4# 444#4| ^-##^.4 3^17}#^ 4^.4444 4 #£# 444431, 44^. 3:44#4 4^3:44 #### 431431 44.

444 44;}-4 ## 4^.4 #44 4444 4# 444 3:#JE #A 7} 4444.. 4## 4###4 444# 4-44-4 44 %### 43i# 4 441 44 444# #44 # 4# 444^- 7}44^.# #444 44 44 4-M4 44 4## #431, 4^-4 444 4# #4#4 4## ##-^i# 4^# 44431 44.

VII. -84 5 103

144 14 ^ tij-a]- 7^0] 44 544 5.a]7>^a>7> s.47}±1 4^4 #44^ KA4. 44 ll7(-± 444 4114444 H A - ±41. 4^.4 144 4144 ^11 44 4444.

41 447)-± 1414 44. ±4444^4 14 ±4 14 44 44 4 ±±44 44. 44 444± 4444 44441- 14-41 144 4 4 444 4^7} 4& 4A± 4444. 3.44 47(14 41 47M4 4444444 44441 44444 44 4&4 414 Ai4±#1 4415. 44H 44± 441 7f4 IM 44-.

3.44- 4lv(-44 ±47}± A14± 1414114 14, 44, 444.5.4 ±7}7(-±# H4±± TIE(J7 7-(7f± H4J77(- 41 14114 ±47}± AH 4 4 44- AH 11^1 44 #! 11444 ±47}- ± 3.4# Hl7(-#-1144 41 ^A44 444 44. #4. 14111 44 1143: 41 11 41(444. 4444, 4444 ItA 1)4 44 #7(-411 4143 mi 7H3.4 1, 1144 444441 11 1444 44lHl7(-# 144^ 4 4 2(7^ 17}1H 1143.14.

44. 44 ^47}± AH4141 57(( 444 1^4H ^144 114 ^1 Hl7(i- 4e±± Aim-1143. %(7( 414 11 Hl7(l-1441 414 ±47(-± 44^}441 f7(-ll 47(H 1 41 4143. 14.

441 Wl7(-4 111 AH4 43.4 114± H4A. 4*84 Allll 414-11 4444 44-4! 444-H ±444 14 A± 1144.14.13til AH144 1±!± 441, 7(14 l7(-4 44141

104

7)44 #3.. €^7}^ ^44 44. A14 44.:4444 # ^7^144 4^44 ASM #7)?M -8-^-4

e& 44^1# 44M 444A&4 O H 1H4(-8-^4 p)7#7# ##444 44 ^7} 47^4"#44 444# ^471- 7^*1 44.

M. 199246ff T= 7)144 44 ##444^1 44;s. 444. 44, 444 44# 444 4^# -8-^4 ##4 444 A444. 444 4-^-4 4#(A#)# #44#4 4^-4 4^4 ^4 444- 4 if44444 444471- ^4451 44.

|, 4%MA3. ^47^447}^. 44# 44# %#44s.# ^1#44^1471- #7H44 $^# ^4 444 ##4714 ^l^MHl 4-8-4# 4 7p§4 #&44 ^4 4^4 ^7}?} 444^.4. #444 471-444 #44 4444 44. n45i 7^4 <>j -44^114 ^444 41144 4-T5-^-5>| 4-44--571# 44±##4 5S. Ol ts.

7>44 440^. 4J.4JI, a.4 44# #47>4 _a#4#^ 444514-4# 444-^1- 444 4^ 7^44.

44-7-1 44 71444 i7]7}7i ##41:E# 44-4 44 44^5. ;)|4 4 ^#44 4* 4^- ^-44.

4#4 ##471444 #4% 47144444 4#44 *# 4-444 4 £4-^44 44# 444 1447) 4& #4jl, 4^4 71444## 4#4 7144## ##?1# 7l4##44 ^s])g. _95g-44#4# ^44 #44 444 4^a. 4444.

44 4#4 ###44 4-8-4# 7)4#44 4A1# 44 44444444 A144 7144## 4-4^1# #7l4#4 ##4# 4444. ^jE

'-MS krk kkk kkklkk p-H-T kk Ibkk v|nk kk kkk & #kk ^kk ^ kkkM&kk kk #kk ?k kk kk Mkkkkk A o kkk kkk~cT kk kkkTT #?k "5-v

kk ki^kk #?k gHfcc-T kk kk^k fkk-k k?kkT k^ kkk & kkk^k k^kkk #kk ^vkkk kkk 'S-SkM?

kkk?k -f-TFsrrfv kkk "^Bkrkirk M^kk k# kfo k kk

k kk3^ kkk kk M’Vy -kkk klbkkkk to Mk-klf kk

kl%kT#: #kk kkkT k-kt^k^ kk t^kk k?lk kkk klkkp,k t^kkk kk '^kkk #kt^k%kT ^kkk -f-i&^kkT &?k ‘kkF&k kkV kk kkkkk k?k k^

kk k?#^k kkkFM ^ ?k

SOI -ik 16 w HA

106

4333439-3. 33^444 33 39%, .1994.84333439^. ^37^ 43 JE-d:4_9-^M 3i^j .1996.6 4333439^. ^7^4344 ^ 4^34 33 3i^j .1997.4 4333439-3. ^71^4 33# ^ 3fj . 1995.7 343. 3-3## 4# 3-&3 a# 3 3#j ,#9-34 39-

3, 39-^W^.. 1991.433& ""Rpi-x 7}3###4j .#934393. 943933^-26.

1994.8#9^371-7:##. 19973j .1997.6

#*##. %g. ##: WXTXj , 1993.. 1995.

Brown, S and D.S. Sibley, The Theory of Public Utility Pricing, Cambridge University Press, 1986.

Costello, K. W. Implementing Incentive Regulation Plans for Energy Utilities, The National Regulatory Research Institute for NARUC Annual Regulatory Studies Program, The Institute of Public Utilities Michigan State University, 1994, 8.

American Gas Association, Gas Rate Fundamentals, 1989.

107

Armstrong, M, S. Cowan and J. Vickers, Regulatory Reform: Economic Analysis and British Experience, The MIT Press, 1994.

Harunuzzaman, M, K.W. Costello, D.J. Duann, and S.B. Cho, Incentive Regulation for Local Gas Distribution Companies under Changing Industry Structure, The National Regulatory Research Institute, 1991.

Bishop, M, J. Kay and C. Mayer, The Regulatory Challenge, Oxford University Press, 1996.

Costello, K.W. and S.B. Cho, A Review of FERC'S Technical Reports on Incentive Regulation, The National Regulatory Research Institute, 1991.

O'Neill, R.P and C. Whitmore, Benchmark Regulation for Natural Gas Pipelines-' A Performance-Based Successor for Original Cost of Service Regulation, Office of Economic Policy, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission,1994. 8.

Costello, K.W. and J.R. Lemon, "Unbundling of Small- Customer Gas Services: New Challenges for State Public Utility Commissions", Energy Law Journal, Vol.18:137-170, 1997.

OECD, Utility Pricing and Access- Competition for Monopolies, 1991.

awmans*KwaB/a - OSTI.GOV

Documents

Transcript of awmans*KwaB/a - OSTI.GOV