DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORT
-
Upload
khangminh22 -
Category
Documents
-
view
1 -
download
0
Transcript of DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORT
DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORT
FOR
EXPANSION OF STEEL MANUFACTURING UNIT BY, ADDITION OF TWO INDUCTION FURNACE,
UPGRADATION OF EXISTING ROLLING MILL CAPACITY AFTER EXPANSION
Steel Ingot/Billets-28,000 TPA- 2,90,500 TPA & Rolled/Flats Products- 1,40,000 TPA-2,90,500 TPA
Project Area- 23.22 acre or 93,970m2
[TOR letter no: SEIAA/MS/2021/4007 on dated 4th May, 2021] Study Period: February, March & April 2021
Monitoring done by M/s CPTL, Mohali (NABL accredited), MoEF&CC recognized, NABL Certificate TC- 6728, Validity: valid upto 08.11.2021
[Project or Activity of Schedule 3(a) Metallurgical industries (ferrous & non ferrous), Cat-B-1]
M/S AARTI STEELS LIMITED (MACHHIWARA PLANT)
VILLAGE- HARIAN, P.O. UPPAL, MACHHIWARA ROAD
TEHSIL- KOOM KALAN, DISTRICT- LUDHIANA, PUNJAB.
Prepared by Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division
(QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146) Address: E- 126, Phase- VII, Industrial Area, Mohali, Punjab- 160055.
Contacts: 0172-4669295, 5090312 E-mail: [email protected] / [email protected]
Website: www.cptl.co.in
MAY, 2021
CPTLE-DEIA-ASL-105/3
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Section Particulars Page No. Project at a Glance xi TOR Letter xiii TOR Compliance xxvi Executive Summary 1-4 Draft Environment Impact Assessment Report 6
CHAPTER 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Purpose of The Report 6 1.2 Identification of the Project & Project Proponent 6
1.2.1 Identification of the project 6 1.2.2 Project Proponent 7 1.3 Brief Description 8
1.3.1 Nature of the Project 8 1.3.2 Size of the Project 8 1.3.3 Location of the Project 8 1.3.4 Importance of the Project to the Country, Region 12 1.4 Scope of the study 13
1.4.1 Methodology 13 CHAPTER 2.0 PROJECT DESCRIPTION
2.1 Type of the Project 15 2.2 Need for the Project 15 2.3 Location of the Project 16 2.4 Size or Magnitude of Operation 24
2.4.1 Proposed Product Details 24 2.4.2 Raw Materials 24 2.4.3 Land Description 24 2.4.4 Water Requirement 24 2.4.5 Power Requirement 27 2.4.6 Manpower Requirement 27 2.4.7 Major Equipments & Machineries 28 2.5 Proposed Schedule or Approval & Implementation 29 2.6 Technology & Process Description 29 2.7 Description of Mitigation Measures 33
CHAPTER 3.0 DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT 3.1.1 Study Area 36 3.1.2 Study Period 37 3.1.3 Components of Study 37 3.1.4 Methodology 38 3.2 Environmental Baseline Data 39 3.3 Meteorology 41
3.3.1 Climate 41 3.3.2 Temperature 41 3.3.3 Rainfall 42 3.3.4 Micro Meteorology at Site 42 3.4 Ambient Air Quality 45
3.4.1 Methodology 45 3.4.2 Sampling Stations 45
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
ii
3.4.3 Monitoring Schedule 47 3.4.4 Methods of Sampling Analysis 47 3.4.5 Interpretation 50 3.5 Water Environment 55
3.5.1 Surface water sources in the study area 55 3.5.2 Ground Water 61 3.5.3 Rain Water Harvesting 65 3.6 Noise Environment 67 3.7 Soil Quality 72
3.7.1 Conclusion 76 3.7.2 Geomorphology and Soil types 77 3.8 Land Environment 81
3.8.1 Industries within study area (10km radius) 83 3.9 Biological Environment 86 3.10 Socioeconomic Environment 92 3.11 Traffic Study 97 3.12 Slag Analysis 98 CHAPTER 4.0 ANTICIPATED ENVIROMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION
MEASURES 4.1 General 99 4.2 Construction Phase Impacts 100
4.2.1 Air Environment 100 4.2.2 Water Environment 101 4.2.3 Noise Environment 102 4.2.4 Land Environment 104 4.2.5 Demography & Socio Economic Pattern 104 4.2.6 Ecological Environment 104 4.3 Operational Phase- Long Term 105 4.4 Occupational Safety & Health 115
4.4.1 General Safety Measures 115 4.4.2 General Health Measures 116 4.4.3 Occupational Health Monitoring: 116 4.4.4 Occupational Audit, Frequency, Review and Corrective action 117 4.4.5 Corrective Measures 117
CHAPTER 5.0 ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES 5.1 Analysis of Alternatives for location of proposed expansion 119 5.2 Analysis of Alternative For Technology Selection 119 5.3 Conclusion and Recommendation 120
CHAPTER - 6.0 ENVIROMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM 6.0 Prelude 121 6.1 Environment Monitoring Program 121 6.2 Objective of Monitoring Plan 121 6.3 Schedules for Environment Monitoring 122 6.4 Environmental Monitoring during Construction Phase 123 6.5 Environmental Monitoring during Operation Phase 123
6.5.1 Plantation 123 6.5.2 Budget allocation for Monitoring 123
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
iii
CHAPTER-7.0 ADDITIONAL STUDIES 7.0 Preamble 125 7.1 Public Consultation 125 7.2 Possible Risks 125 7.3 Social Impact Assessment 145 7.4 Rehabilitation & Resettlement Plan 146
CHAPTER 8.0 PROJECT BENEFITS 8.1 Introduction 147 8.2 Employment Potential 147
8.2.1 Direct Employment 147 8.2.2 Indirect Employment 147 8.3 Improvement In Infrastructure 148 8.4 Education 148 8.5 Other Tangible Benefits 148 8.6 Corporate Environment Policy 149 8.7 Details of Infrastructure Facility 149 8.8 Enterprise Social Commitment 149 8.9 Litigation And Pending Cases 149
CHAPTER-9.0 ENVIRONMENTAL COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS 9.1 Estimated Project Cost 150 9.2 Schedule of Project Implementation 150
9.2.1 Implementation Strategy 150 CHAPTER-10.0 ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT PLAN
10.0 Introduction 151 10.1 Summary of Potential Impacts with Mitigation Measures during
Construction Phase 151
10.1.1 Land Environment 151 10.1.2 Air Environment 151 10.1.3 Water Environment 151 10.1.4 Noise Environment 152 10.1.5 Solid Waste Management 152 10.1.6 Sanitation, Welfare and Safety Measures of Construction Workers 152 10.2 Summary of Potential Impacts with Mitigation Measures during
Operational Phase 152
10.2.1 Air Environment 152 10.2.2 Water Environment 153 10.2.3 Noise Environment 153
10.2.3.1 Green Belt Development Plan 153 10.2.4 Solid hazardous Waste Management 154 10.2.5 Occupational Health & Safety 157 10.3 Structure and Administrative Responsibilities of Environment
Management Cell (EMC) 159
CHAPTER-11.0 SUMMARY & CONCLUSION 11.1 Project Name and location 162 11.2 Products and capacities 162 11.3 Land Area 162 11.4 Raw Material Requirement 162
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
iv
11.5 Water Requirement 163 11.6 Power Requirement 163 11.7 Manpower Requirement 163 11.8 Flow Chart of Manufacturing Process 164 11.9 Description of mitigation measures 166
11.10 Cost Details 166 11.11 Site Details 166 11.12 Environmental Baseline Study 166 11.13 Possible hazards and Risks from Secondary Metallurgical
Industries 168
11.14 Emergency Plan 169 11.15 CER Activities 169 11.16 Environment Monitoring Plan 169 11.17 Environment Monitoring Cell (EMC) 169
CHAPTER-12.0 DISCLOSURE OF THE CONSULTANT ENGAGED 12.1 Organizational Profile 170 12.2 Scope of Services 170
LIST OF TABLES
Table No.
Particulars Page No.
CHAPTER 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Project Details 9
CHAPTER 2.0 PROJECT DESCRIPTION 2.1 Salient Features of the Project 22
CHAPTER 3.0 DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT 3.0 Ecosensitive Area around 10km radius of Study area 36 3.1 Primary Data 40 3.2 Annual Weather Averages of Ludhiana District 42 3.3 Ambient Air Monitoring Stations 46 3.4 Ambient Air Quality Abstract 49 3.5 Surface Water Sampling Stations 57 3.6 Results of Surface Water Sample (Bhakhra Canal) 58 3.7 CPCB water Quality Criteria for Surface water as per use 59 3.8 Details of Ground Water Monitoring Stations 62 3.9 Results of Ground Water Samples 64
3.10 Details of Noise Monitoring Stations 68 3.11 Noise Level Results Leq dB (A) in and Around Project Area 70 3.12 Noise Standards (Source-CPCB) 70 3.13 Detail list of Soil Quality Monitoring Stations 72 3.14 Result of Soil Samples (% W/W except pH) 75 3.15 Land Use/Land Cover Area Statistics 82 3.16 List of Industries within study area (10km radius) 83 3.17 Aspect to be covered in the study Area 86 3.18 Summary of Data Collected from various sources 87 3.19 Results of floral study 88
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
v
3.20 Results of Faunal Study 90 3.21 Slag Analysis 98 CHAPTER 4.0 ANTICIPATED ENVIONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION
MEASURES 4.1 Input data for Air Quality Modeling 110 4.2 Predicted 24 hourly short terms Maximum Incremental
Concentrations 110
CHAPTER - 6.0 ENVIROMENT MONITORING PROGRAM 6.1 Environmental Monitoring Program for Construction Phase 123 6.2 Environmental Monitoring Program For Operation Phase 124
CHAPTER-7.0 ADDITIONAL STUDIES 7.0 Hazard Identification & proposed safety system 127 7.1 Possible Risk 133 7.2 Specific Hazard & their Control 133 7.3 List of Key Person 142 7.4 List of Key persons of offsite EP 145
CHAPTER-10.0 ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT PLAN 10.1 Safety and Occupational Hazards 157 10.2 EMP Budget 160
LIST OF FIGURES
Fig no. Particulars Page No. CHAPTER 1.0 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Location Map (From India Map to Local Map) 10 1.2 Map showing Study Area and Project Site 11
CHAPTER 2.0 PROJECT DESCRIPTION 2.1 Location of the Project in Google Image 17 2.2 500m radius Google Earth Map 18 2.3 Pillar Co-ordinate 19 2.4 Layout Plan 20 2.5 Location on Master Plan of Samrala 21
2.6(a) Water Balance Diagram (a) summer 25 2.6(b) Water Balance Diagram (b) winter 26 2.6(C) Water Balance Diagram (c)rainy 26
2.7 Flow Chart of Manufacturing Process 30 2.8 Material Balance 31
CHAPTER 3.0 DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT 3.1 Monthly average temperature and rainfall 42 3.2 Wind Rose diagram for study period 43 3.3 Monitoring Locations of Ambient Air 48 3.4 Graphical representation of PM10 in Study Area 50 3.5 Graphical representation of PM2.5 in Study Area 51 3.6 Graphical representation of SO2 concentration at selected sites 52 3.7 Graphical representation of NOx in Study Area 53 3.8 Graphical representation of CO in Study Area 54
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
vi
3.9 Locations of Surface water 56
3.10 Location of ground water 63
3.11 Locations of Noise Monitoring Stations 69 3.12 Location of Soil Monitoring Stations 74 3.13 Drainage map of the study area 78
3.14 Depth to Water Level – Pre-Monsoon 79
3.15 Depth to Water Level – Post-Monsoon 80
3.16 Flowchart showing the methodology adopted for land use / land cover mapping
82
3.17 Land Use / Land Cover Map of Study Area (10 Km Buffer) 84 3.18 10km radius False Color Composite Satellite Map 85 CHAPTER 4.0 ANTICIPATED ENVIROMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION
MEASURES 4.1 Isopleths showing 24 hourly predicted GLC’s of PM10 111
LIST OF ANNEXURES
S. No. Particulars Page No. I Jamabandi Record 171 II CTE 182 III CLU 189 IV PLPA Undertaking 192 V Authorization letter 193 VI Project cost breakup 194
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
vii
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS CPTL : Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory EIA : Environmental Impact Assessment QCI : Quality Council of India NABET : National Accreditation Board for Education and Training SA : Surveillance Assessment NABL : National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration
Laboratories MoEF&CC : Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change ISO : International Organization for Standardization OHSAS : Occupational Health and Safety Assessment Series IS : Indian Standards SOP : Standard Operating Procedure PIN : Postal Index Number CPCB : Central Pollution Control Board SPCB : State Pollution Control Board SEIAA : State Environment Impact Assessment Authority SEAC : State Expert Appraisal Committee EAC : Expert Appraisal Committee GOI : Government of India R.O. : Regional Office OM : Office Memorandum EC : Environment Clearance TOR : Terms of Reference DEIA : Draft Environment Impact Assessment WP : Water Pollution AP : Air Pollution AQ : Air Quality SHW : Solid and Hazardous Waste Management SE : Socio- Economics EB : Ecology and Biodiversity LU : Land Use HG : Hydrogeology
GEO : Geology NV : Noise and Vibration RH : Risk Assessment & Hazard Management CGWA : Central Ground Water Board PSPCL : Punjab State Power Corporation Limited CTO : Consent to Operate CTE : Consent To Establish NOC : No Objection Certificate CLU : Change of Land Use DTP : District Town Planner MOA : Memorandum of Association MT : Metric Tons TMT : Thermo Mechanical Treatment MS : Mild Steel
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
viii
MTA : Metric Ton per Annum TPA : Tonnes per Annum TPH : Tonnes per Heat IF : Induction Furnace VD : Vaccum Degasser LFR : Ladle Furnace Refining EAF : Electric Arc Furnace MBF : Mini-Blast Furnace EOT : Electric Overhead Traveling Crane kVA : Kilo-Volt-Ampere KLD : Kilolitres per Day STP : Sewage Treatment Plant ETP : Effluent Treatment Plant TSDF : Treatment, Storage and Disposal Facility KL : Kilo Litre TPD : Tons per Day DG : Diesel Generator km : Kilo Meter KW : Kilo Watt CER : Corporate Environment Responsibility NH : National Highway SH : State Highway BIS : Bureau of Indian Standards NHB : National Housing Bank m2 : Meter square ZLD : Zero Liquid Discharge APCD : Air Pollution Control Devices APCS : Air Pollution Control System QC/QA : Quality Control/Quality Assurance KG : Kilo Gram dB (A) : Weighted decibels MSW : Municipal Solid Waste M BGL : Metres Below Ground Level PM10 : Particulate matter of size less than 10 micron PM2.5 : Particulate matter of size less than 2 micron SO2 : Sulphur Dioxide NO2 : Nitrogen Dioxide CO : Carbon Monoxide AAQM : Ambient Air Quality Monitoring AAQ : Ambient Air Quality ERDAS : Earth Resources Data Analysis System ARC/GIS : Always Right Click/ Geographic Information System LULC : Land Use/Land Cover SQ : Soil Quality ICAR : Indian Council of Agricultural Research gm/ cm3 : Gram per centi meter cube mg/m3 : Milligram per metric cube
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
ix
µg/m3 : Micrograms mg/kg : Milligram per kilogram Mg/l : Milligram per Litre Kg/hac : Kilogram per hectare ND : Not Detectable Fe : Iron Zn : Zinc Pb : Lead Mn : Manganese Cr : Chromium Cd : Cadmium Cu : Copper N, P, K : Nitrogen, Phosphorus and Potassium Ca, Mg, S : Calcium, Magnesium and Sulphur USDA : U.S. Department of Agriculture MPN : Most Probable Number GW : Ground Water E – Coli : Escherichia coli μg/m3 : Microgram per meter cube TDS : Total Dissolved Solids BOD : Biochemical Oxygen Demand COD : Chemical Oxygen Demand pH : Potential of Hydrogen IS: 10500:2012 : Indian Standard Drinking Water - Specification w.r.t : With respect/reference to R&R : Resettlement & Rehabilitation MOU : Memorandum of Understanding PEL : Permissible Exposure Limit MIN : Minimum MAX : Maximum Avg. : Average 0C : Degree Celsius km/hr : Kilometer per hour sq. km : Square kilometer mm : Millimeter PHCs : Primary Health Center ANM : Auxiliary Nurse Midwife AERMOD : American Meteorological Society/Environmental Protection Age
ncy Regulatory Model GLC : Ground Level Concentration PCU : Passenger Car Unit LOS : Level of Services ENVIS : Environmental Information System EMC : Environment Management Cell RDS : Respirable Dust Sampler FPS : Fine Particulate Matter Sampler ADC : Additional Deputy Commissioner
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
x
HIRA : Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment RWH : Rain Water Harvesting SMS : Soil Monitoring Station SW : Surface Water NMS : Noise Monitoring Station RET : Rare-Endangered-Threatened BSI : Botanical Survey of India ZSI : Zoological Survey of India ANM : Auxiliary Nurse Midwife IRC : Indian Roads Congress C.T : Cooling Tower C.W : Cooling Water PPE : Personal Protective Equipment EMP : Environmental Management Plan EMC : Environment Management Cell QRA : Quantitative Risk Assessment DMP : Disaster Management Plan MCA : Maximum Credible Accident HAZOP : Hazard and Operability Study FE & TI : Fire-Explosion and Toxicity Index R.M. : Raw Material RA : Risk Analysis SMC : Site Main Controller ECC : Emergency Control Center ECO : Emergency Co-ordination Officer EPO : Emergency Planning Officer RCC : Reinforced Cement Concrete AQI : Air Quality Index
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xi
PROJECT AT A GLANCE
Name of Project M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
Type of Project Steel Manufacturing Unit
Location Village Harian, P.O. Uppal, Machhiwara road, District- Ludhiana, Punjab.
Product Steel Ingots & Billets, Rolled/Flats Products
Capacity (TPA)
Product & Bye Product Existing Additional Total
Steel Billets/ Ingots 28,000 2,62,500 2,90,500
Rolled / Flats Products 1,40,000 1,50,500 2,90,500
Raw Material Existing Additional Total
MS Scrap, CI, Sponge Iron, Ferro Alloys
30,800 2,88,750 3,19,550
Cost of the Project Existing - ₹73.25 Cr. Proposed - ₹ 130.79 Cr. Total - ₹ 204.04 Cr.
Total Land Existing Additional Total
23.22 Acres or
93,970m2
NIL 23.22 Acres or
93,970m2
Power Requirement (MW)
Existing Additional Total
12 39 51
Source of power P.S.P.C.L Punjab
Source of Water Supply Own Tube- well
Consumption of Water (KLD)
EXISTING (KLD)
PROPOSED (KLD) TOTAL (KLD)
Domestic 15 18 33
Cooling 90 527 617
Total 105 545 650
Effluent Quantity Domestic = 26.4 KLD Cooling = Recirculation
Effluent treatment Domestic- through STP of 30 KLD and used for plantation
Air Pollution Control Device
Stack of adequate height equipped with Bag filter (Pulse jet with offline Technology)
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xii
Solid Waste Slag from furnace, 46.74 TPD Slag after recovery of iron will be sold to manufacturers of cement concrete blocks, tiles, and pavers under proper agreement
Hazardous Waste Hazardous waste generated (0.03kl/annum) from DG sets in the
form of used oil will be sold to authorized recyclers. About
4.26 ton/day APCD dust will be also covered under hazardous
waste and sent to M/S Madhav Alloys (P) Limited or TSDF
site Nimbuan Dera Bassi for final disposal.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xiii
TOR Letter
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xiv
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xv
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xvi
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xvii
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xviii
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xix
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xx
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxi
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxii
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxiii
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxiv
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxv
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxvi
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxvii
TOR COMPLIANCE
S.NO. TORS POINT TOR COMPLIANCE REFERENCE IN EIA
REPORT
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY M/s Aarti Steels Limited. is an existing Steel Manufacturing Unit located at Village- Harian, P.O. Uppal,
Machhiwara road, Tehsil- Koom Kalan, , District- Ludhiana, and Punjab.
The Industry has already got CTE for installation of one no. Induction Furnace of Capacity 8 TPH, Concast
and a Rolling mill of capacity 1, 40,000 TPA. The existing production of Billets/Ingot is 28000TPA and
Rolled/Flats products is 1,40,000 TPA. The project is for expansion of Billet/Ingots Manufacturing by
addition of Two no. Induction Furnaces of capacities 25 TPH each, LRF, VD, Concast and upgradation of
existing Rolling Mill. Total capacity of the project after expansion will be 2, 90,500TPA steel billets/Ingots/
rolled/flats products. The plot area of the project is 23.22 Acres or 93970m2.The project cost after
expansion including existing cost will be Rs 204.04 Crores.
The project falls within activity 3(a) Metallurgical Industries (ferrous & non-ferrous) & Non Toxic
Secondary Metallurgical processing industry with capacity > 30,000 TPA, so the project is to be treated as
Category ‘B1’, as per MOEF&CC OM dated 24th December,2013, and its Environment Clearance is to be
accorded by the SEIAA, MoEF & CC, Punjab.
Details are provided in
Chapter-1 of DEIA.
2. INTRODUCTION
(i) Details of the EIA Consultant including NABET Accreditation Chandigarh Pollution testing Lab - EIA Division,
Address- E-126, Phase-VII, Mohali (Punjab), Pin- 160055
(QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
(ii) Information about the project proponent. M/s Aarti Steels Limited is a private firm managed by the following promoters
1. Mr. Shiv Parshad Mittal
2. Mr. Mahesh Mittal
3. Mr. Rajeev Mittal
4. Mr. Vinayak Mittal
5. Mr. Sushen Mittal
All the directors are well versed with the process and can handle the project successfully
.
(iii) Importance and benefits of the project. Iron and steel have a vital role to play especially in a developing country like India. It is one of the most
important basic requirements in almost all development activities e.g. building construction, bridges,
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxviii
railways, machine tools, transport vehicles. As per the latest world Steel Association Report, India is the
largest steel producer in the world. The proposed expansion will result in the following benefits:
Employment to the local population
Infrastructure development of surroundings area.
Economic and social upliftment of suppressed class.
Environmental activities in the surrounding villages.
Revenue to State & Central exchequers.
Narrowing down the demand supply gap.
3. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
(i) Cost of project and time of completion. Cost of the Project
Existing – ₹ 73.25Cr.
Proposed- ₹ 130.79 Cr.
Total- ₹204.04 Cr.
S. No. Description Existing Cost
(Rs. in Crores)
Proposed Cost (Rs. in Crores)
Total Cost (Rs. in Crores)
1. Land 5.64 6.21 11.85
2. Building 28.64 62.75 91.39
3. APCD 0.50 3.0 6.5
4. Machinery 38.47 58.83 97.30
Total 73.25 130.79 204.04
Time of Completion- The proposed expansion will be completed within one year after granting of
Environment Clearance.
(ii) Products with capacities for the proposed project. Details of Proposed products are as follows: -
Description Proposed (TPA) After Expansion (TPA)
Steel Billets/Ingots 2,62,500 2,90,500 Rolled / Flats Products 1,50,500 2,90,500
Details are provided in
Chapter-2 of DEIA.
(iii) If expansion project, details of existing products with capacities
and whether adequate land is available for expansion, reference of
earlier EC if any.
Details of Existing Products are as follows
Description Existing (TPA)
Steel Billets/ Ingots 28,000
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxix
It is an expansion proposal for which-
The products & capacities have already been detailed.
The expansion is proposed in the existing premises measuring 23.22 acres or 93,970m2 No additional
land will be acquired & the existing land use which is industrial shall remain unchanged.
EC was not applicable for the existing project. However, the plant has valid CTO & Authorization.
Rolled / Flats Products 1,40,000
(iv) List of raw materials required and their source along with mode of
transportation.
Details of raw material along with its source and transportation is given below-
RAW MATERIAL
Capacity (TPA) Existing Proposed Total
MS Scrap, CI, Sponge Iron, Ferro Alloys
30,800 2,88,750 3,19,550
Source & Transportation Local & international markets and transport through covered trucks
Details are provided in
Chapter-2 of DEIA.
(v) Other chemicals and materials required with quantities and storage
capacities.
No chemicals are used in the manufacturing process. However, analytical grade chemicals/reagents are
required in small quantities in the laboratory for quality control. These chemicals don’t require much
storage area except a small almirah beneath the working table.
(vi) Details of Emission, effluents, hazardous waste generation and
their management.
The following are the required details for the existing & proposed facility:
Details of Hazardous waste generation and their management
The total quantity of slag after expansion will be 46.74TPD and will be disposed off to approved
S. No.
PARTICULARS EXISTING PROPOSED TOTAL
A. PROPOSED CAPACITY OF FURNACES & ROLLING MILLS 1. Induction Furnace 1X8 TPH 2X25 TPH 1X8 TPH
2X25 TPH
2. Laddle Refining Furnace Nil 30 TPH 30 TPH
3. Rolling Mill 01 No. Upgradation of Rolling mill
4. Concast 01 No. Nil 01 No.
5. Vacuum Degasser (VD) Nil 01 No. 01 No.
6. D.G. Sets 2x1500KVA
Details are provided in
Chapter-2 of DEIA.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxx
manufacturer of concrete blocks, pavers and tiles. Hazardous waste generated (0.03kl/annum) from DG sets
in the form of used oil will be sold to authorized recyclers. About 4.26 ton/day APCD dust will be also
covered under hazardous waste and sent to M/s Madhav Alloys (P) Limited or TSDF site Nimbuan Dera
Bassi for final disposal.
(vii) Requirement of water (breakup for induction and other purposes),
power, with source of supply, status of approval, water balance
diagram, man-power requirement (regular and contract).
Water requirement details:
DESCRIPTION EXISTING (KLD) ADDITIONAL (KLD) TOTAL (KLD)
Domestic 15 18 33
Cooling (makeup water) 90 527 617
Total 105 545 650
Source of Water Tubewell
Status of Approval PWRDA Application provided.
Power requirement details:
DESCRIPTION EXISTING (MW) ADDITIONAL (MW) TOTAL (MW)
Power 12 39 51
Source Punjab State Power Corporation Limited, Punjab
Water Balance of all seasons i.e. Summer, Winter, Rainy is provided at page no. 28-29
Manpower Requirement details:
DESCRIPTION EXISTING ADDITIONAL TOTAL
Manpower 300 361 661
Source Punjab State Power Corporation Limited, Punjab
Note The entire workforce is/will be local and none is/will be residing within the industry. All
the manpower will be regular.
Water balance of all
seasons i.e. summer, rainy,
water are provided in
Chapter-2 of DEIA.
(viii) The project proponent shall furnish the requisite documents from
the Competent Authority in support of drawl of ground water and
surface water (if any) and supply of electricity.
Application for abstraction of ground water from PWRDA is under process.
Supply of electricity is and will be from PSPCL
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxxi
(ix)
Process description along with major equipment and machineries,
process flow sheet (quantitative) from raw material to products to
be provided.
The industry produces ingots from melting MS Scrap. All operations are carried out in batch process. The
brief description is as follows:
MS Scrap is put into the induction furnaces pot through magnetic conveying system, where ii is heated to
1800oC. Scrap is melted and is heated for about 100 minutes. In the molten steel some Ferro Alloys are
added according to the carbon contents in the scrap. The molten metal is then fed to Concast Machine/Billet
Castor form where the material is taken to rolling mill.
The process flow chart of manufacturing process is given Figure 2.8 & the material balance is given in
Figure 2.9
Details are provided in
Chapter-2 of DEIA.
(x) Hazard identification and details of proposed safety systems. Hazard Identification and details of proposed safety systems-
S.No Plant Area Causes Consequences Mitigation Measures
1. Furnace
Operation
Moisture containing
scrap & recirculating
water coming in contact
with molten metal
Steam
Explosion
Usage of moisture free
R.M
Drying of R.M
2. Transformer
Area
Oil temperature build
up
Unsafe electrical
installation
Varying room
temperature
Sudden
flashing of fire
& bursting
Proper Electrical
installation
Transformer room
temperature monitoring
3. H.T electrical
installation
Loose Fowls, cable cut,
short circuits & burning
of fuse
Sparks in the
beginning &
devastative
fire if
neglected
Properly laid cables &
switches & fuse
4. Extremely Hot
Working area
Heat from Furnace,
Unsafe clothing,
seasonal factors e.g.
temperature, pH & air
movement
Heat Shocks Rotation of workers
Exhaust air ventilation
Shielding from radiant
heat
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxxii
5. Furnace &
Moulding
Touching Hot
Surface
Splashing of molten
metal
Radiation
Burns Providing specific PPE
are to measures risk of
manual operation
Protective barriers to
explosion
6. Furnace &
moulding
UV & IR radiation of
high intensities from
molten metal pouring
High
Radiation
Safety education to
workers
Labelling of risky areas
Providing suitable PPE
xi. EXPANSION/MODERNIZATION PROPOSALS
a. Status of compliance of Consent to Operate for the
ongoing/existing operation of the project from SPCB shall be
attached with the EIA-EMP report.
CTO will be provided in final EIA.
b. In case the existing project has not obtained environmental
clearance, reasons for not taking EC under the provisions of the
EIA Notification 1994 and/or Eia Notification 2006 shall be
provided. Copies of Consent to Establish/No Objection Certificate
and Consent to Operate (in case of units operating prior to EIA
Notification 2006, CTE and CTO of FY 2006-2006) obtained from
the SPCB shall be submitted. Further, compliance report to the
conditions of consents from the SPCB shall be submitted.
CTE is attached as Annexure II Annexure II is attached at
page no. 182
4. SITE DETAILS
(i) Location of the project site covering Village, Taluka/Tehsil,
District and State, Justification for selecting the site, whether other
sites were considered. Copy of Master Plan indicating a land use
pattern of the site is in conformity of proposals of Master Plan
shall be attached with EIA report.
The project is located at Village Harian, P.O. Uppal, Machhiwara road, Tehsil- Koom Kalan, District-
Ludhiana, Punjab.
The proposed expansion will be carried out in the existing unit where all the infrastructure facilities are
available. Alternative sites are therefore not considered.
Copy of Master plan of Ludhiana is provided at Figure 2.6.
Details are provided in chapter 2 of DEIA.
(ii) A toposheet of the study area of radius of 10km and site location
on 1:50,000/1:25,000 scale on an A3/A2 sheet. (Including all eco-
sensitive areas and environmentally sensitive places)
The project site covered under Toposheet No. H43K1, on scale 1:5000 covering 10 km covered the site has
been attached as Figure 1.2
Details are provided in chapter 1 of DEIA.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxxiii
(iii) Co-ordinates (lat-long) of all four corners of the site. The project lies in the coordinates:
LATITUDE LONGITUDE 30°54'27.07"N 76°07'48.90"E 30°54'24.15"N 76°07'56.29"E 30°54'19.62"N 76°08'00.67"E 30°54'12.25"N 76°08'00.86"E 30°54'12.39"N 76°08'49.99"E
Details are provided in
chapter 1 of DEIA.
(iv) Google Map- Earth downloaded of the project site. Google map-Earth image showing project site & its surrounding within 500m radius are shown in Figure
2.2
Details are provided in
chapter 1 of DEIA.
(v) Layout maps indicating existing unit as well as proposed unit
indicating storage area, plant, area, greenbelt area, utilities etc. if
located within an Industrial area/Estate/Complex, layout of
Industrial Area indicating location of unit within the Industrial
area/Estate.
The project is located within the Industrial Zone. Layout showing the required features is enclosed as
Figure 2.4
Area Breakup
Details Sq. mtrs. Total Plot Area 93970
Shed Area (All Machinery) 21610
Finished Good Storage area 7500
APCD area 660 Slag storage area 650
APCD Dust (Hazardous waste) storage area 100
Green area 31200
Scrap area 2860 STP area 100
Parking area 356
Admin. Office area 300
Road & open area 21591
Utilities area 7043
Details are provided in
chapter 1 of DEIA.
(vi) Photographs of the proposed and existing (if applicable) plant site.
if existing, show photographs of planation/greenbelt, in particular.
(vii) Land use break-up of total land of the project site (identified and
acquired), government/private-agricultural, forest, wasteland,
water bodies, settlements, etc shall be included. (not required for
industrial area)
The Land-use pattern of Project site is Industrial Land as per the revenue land record and doesn’t include
any government / private – agricultural, forest, wasteland, water bodies, settlements, etc.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxxiv
(viii) A list of major industries with name and type within study area (10
km radius) shall be incorporated. Land use details of the study
area.
A list of major industries within Study area (10 Km)
S.No. Name of Industries Type of Industries Distance and Direction
1. M/s Renny Strips Pvt. Ltd. Steel 5 Km, W 2. M/s Renny Strips Pvt. Ltd. (Furnace Division) Steel 5 Km, W
Land use/Land cover details are as below:
Land Use/Land Cover Area (Ha) Area Percentage
Built-Up Land 787.95 2.41
Agricultural Land 8914.32 27.22
Agricultural Fallow Land 21845.9 66.71
Open Land 585.18 1.79
Water Bodies 612.9 1.87
Total Area 32746.25 100%
The study area comprises of agricultural land of about 8914.32 ha (27.22 %) including agricultural fallow
land 21845.9 ha (66.71%). Built up land in the study area cover an area of 787.95 ha (2.41%)
approximately. The study area has open land of 585.18 (1.79%) distributed in & around study area. Study
area has 659.90 ha (2.06 %) of water bodies.
List of Industries within 10
km of radius and land use
details are provided in
Chapter 3 of DEIA.
(ix) Geological features and Geo-hydrological status of the study area
shall be included.
Sub surface geological formation comprises of fine to coarse grained sand, silt, clay & kankar.
Soils in the area are sandy loam at the surface.
Sub surface geological formation shows the existence of top layer of 10-15m of clay, kankar with sand
lenses. This layer is followed by granular zones of 20 to 30m in thickness. At a depth of 90 to 120m
another clay bed of 25 to 30m in thickness exists.
Depth to water level ranges between 10-20m bgl. The ground water flows from North East to South
West direction.
Total thickness of alluvium is expected to be more than 550m as bed rock has not been encountered
upto that depth.
Geological features and
Geo-hydrological status of
the study area are provided
at Chapter-3 of DEIA.
(x) Details of Drainage of the project upto 5 km radius of study area.
If the site is within 1 km radius of any major river, peal and lean
season river discharge as well as flood occurrence frequency based
on peak rainfall data of the past 30 years. Details of Flood Level of
the project site and maximum Flood Level of the river shall also
be provided. (Mega green field projects).
The proposed project falls at a distance of 9 km from Satluj River & 4.2Km from Ropar-Neelon Canal. The
Satluj river and Ropar-Neelon Canal is not identified as the polluted river stretched by CPCB.
Drainage map of study area is provided at Figure 3.13
Drainage Map is provided
in Chapter- 3 of DEIA.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxxv
(xi) Status of acquisition of land. If acquisition is not complete, stage
of the acquisition process and expected time of complete
possession of the land.
The project site has already 23.22 acres of land. The expansion will be carried out in existing land only.
Thus, no additional land will be required for expansion.
For reference, land papers are attached as Annexures I
Land Papers as Annexures
are attached at page no.
171
(xii) R&R details in respect of land in line with State Government
policy.
The project doesn’t involve any displacement of population and subsequent Rehabilitation & Resettlement.
5. FOREST AND WILDLIFE RELATED ISSUES (IF APPLICABLE)
i. Permission and approval for the use of forest land (forestry
clearance), if any, and recommendation of the State Forest
Department. (if applicable)
Permission and approval for the use of forest land is not required as the project site is located in Industrial
zone and no forest land is involved. Thus, no forest Clearance is required.
ii. Land use map based on High Resolution Satellite imagery (OPS)
of the proposed site delineating the forestland (in case of projects
involving forest land more than 40 ha).
No, forest land is involved within 10 km of project Site.
For reference Land Use map is attached as figure no. 3.17
Land use map is attached
in Chapter 3 of DEIA.
iii. Status of application submitted for obtaining the stage I forestry
clearance along with latest status shall be submitted.
Does not apply
iv. The projects to be located within 10 km of the National Parks,
Sanctuaries, Biosphere Reserves, Migratory Corridors of Wild
Animals, the project proponent shall be submit the map duly
authenticated by Chief Wildlife Warden showing these features
vis-a- vis the project location and the recommendations or
comments of the Chief Wildlife Warden-thereon.
Not applicable as no National Parks, Wildlife Sanctuaries, Biospheres, Migratory Corridors of Wild
Animals is present within 10 km of project site.
v. Wildlife Conservation Plan duly authenticated by the Chief
Wildlife Warden of the State Government for conservation of
Schedule I fauna, if any exists in the study area.
Does not apply
vi. Copy of application submitted for clearance under the Wildlife
(Protection) Act, 1972, to the Standing Committee of the National
Board for Wildlife.
Does not apply
6. ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS
i. Determination of atmospheric inversion level at the project site
and specific micro-meteorological data using temperature, relative
humidity, hourly wind speed and direction and rainfall.
The project site is located in sub tropical region characterized by four seasons:
- Winter: November to February
- Summer: March to June
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxxvi
- Monsoon: July to Mid September
- Post Monsoon: Mid September to Mid November
May & June are the hottest months, daily maximum & minimum temperature in the region 38.6oC&
23.1oC respectively. December & January are the coldest months with maximum & minimum
temperature 20.4oC & 6.1oC respectively.
The annual average rainfall in the region is 654 mm
The maximum-minimum temperature at site are observed as 36.3oC & 10.2oC
The RH (%) at site varies from 42 to 88
The maximum/minimum wind speed at site is 18 & 0 m/sec
The dominate wind elevation at site is observed as NW-SE
ii. AAQ data (except monsoon) at 8 locations for PM10, PM2.5, SO2,
NOX, CO and other parameters relevant to the project shall be
collected. The monitoring stations shall be based CPCB guidelines
and take into account the pre dominant wind direction, population
zone and sensitive receptors including reserved forests.
AAQ data (except monsoon) at 8 locations PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NOX, CO relevant to the project collected
from February- April, 2021.
Locations Chosen for Ambient air monitoring are as follows-
1) Project Site
2) Takhran
3) Macchiwara
4) Mughlewal
5) Ratangarh
6) Pratapgarh
7) Katani Kalan
8) Haron Kalana
iii. Raw data of all AAQ measurement for 12 weeks of all stations as
per frequency given in the NAQQM Notification of Nov. 2009
along with min., max., average and 98% value for each of the
AAQ parameters from data of all AAQ stations should be
provided as an Annexure to the EIA report.
AAQ measurement as per NAAQS-Nov-2009 has been carried out for 12 weeks. Details are provided in Chapter 3 of DEIA.
Further, Detail analysis of
Ambient Air data is given
in Chapter- 3 of DEIA.
iv. Surface water quality of nearby river (60m upstream and
downstream) and other surface drains at eight locations as per
CPCB, MoEF & CC guidelines.
Surface Water Sampling Stations
Station Sampling Location Aerial Distance (Km) and Direction from Project Site
SW-1 Satluj river 9 Km, W
SW-2 Ropar-Neelon canal 4.2 Km, W
Refer to Chapter 3 of
DEIA.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxxvii
Surface Water samples were taken from Sidhwan Canal which is 0.96 Km in North direction from the
project site.
v. Whether the site falls near to polluted stretch of river identified by
the CPCB/MoEF&CC.
No, the site does not fall near to polluted stretch of river identified by the CPCB/MoEF&CC.
vi. Ground water monitoring at minimum at 8 locations shall be
included.
Ground water monitoring locations are as follows-
1) Project Site
2) Takhran
3) Macchiwara
4) Mughlewal
5) Ratangarh
6) Pratapgarh
7) Katani Kalan
8) Haron Kalana
vii. Noise levels monitoring at 8 locations within the study area. Noise level monitoring stations are as follows-
1) Project Site
2) Takhran
3) Macchiwara
4) Mughlewal
5) Ratangarh
6) Pratapgarh
7) Katani Kalan
8) Haron Kalana
Comprehensive results
including locations are
provided in Chapter 3 of
DEIA.
viii. Soil characteristic as per CPCB guidelines. Details are provided in Chapter 3 Comprehensive results
including locations are
provided in Chapter 3 of
DEIA.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxxviii
ix. Traffic feasibility/serviceability study for at least 3 days based on
Indian Standard Codes. Further it shall also include the details of
cross section of the road on which industry is located, vehicles
movement w.r.t the industry, traffic load of other vehicles on the
road incorporating the haulage time for the vehicles for
loading/unloading within the premises and parking requirement to
avoid the traffic congestions on the link and adjoining roads.
Traffic study shall be conducted considering the traffic of the
industries located in the vicinity.
With the proposed expansion coming into being an average 17 trucks/day each @20 ton will be added to
the existing trucks. The traffic study on both sides was conducted by physical count of the vehicles for 24
hrs.
Detailed Overview of Traffic Study is provided in para 3.11 of Chapter – 3 of FEIA.
Traffic study along its
locations and its
calculations are given at
page no. 97 of Chapter 3 of
DEIA.
x. Detailed description of flora and fauna (terrestrial and aquatic)
existing in the study area shall be given with special reference to
rare, endemic and endangered species. If Schedule-I fauna re
found within the study area, a Wildlife Conservation Plan shall be
prepared and furnished.
Descriptive list of flora and fauna (terrestrial and aquatic) is provided in the Chapter-3 of FEIA.
There are no rare, endemic and endangered species found in the study area. No schedule- I fauna also not
found. Provided at para 3.9 and Table 3.19 and Table 3.20.
List of Flora and fauna is
provided in Chapter-3 of
DEIA.
xi. Socio-economic status of study area. Livelihood in the study area is primarily based on agriculture sector. Majority of main workforce are
engaged as cultivators or agriculture labourers. Due to this expansion, employment of locals will increase.
Socio- Economic data of
Ludhiana district is
provided at in Chapter 3 of
DEIA.
7. IMPACT ASSESSMENT AND ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT PLAN
i. Assessment of ground level concentration of pollutants from the
stack emission based on site-specific meteorological features. In
case the project is located on a hilly terrain, the AQIP Modeling
shall be done using inputs of the specific terrain characteristics
for determining the potential impacts of the project n the AAQ.
Cumulative impacts of all sources of emissions (including
transportation) on the AAQ of the air shall be well assessed.
Details of the model used and yen input data used for modeling
shall also be provided. The air quality contours shall be plotted
on a location map showing the location of project site, habitation
nearby, sensitive receptors, if any.
For predicting the impacts of proposed expansion, the contribution to the existing air quality from the
ongoing operation of industry has been taken into account by monitoring the stack emission. Post expansion
forecasting has been done using the AERMOD Cloud & the local meteorology to ensure the compliance of
the air quality standards. Based on the perusal of modeling results, it is seen that the resultant PM10
concentration after the implementation of project will be 89.57 µg/m3 at 75 m (WNW) from project site. Due
to the implementation of adequate & appropriate control measures like pollution control devices, tree
plantation & dust suppression, and the adverse impacts are likely to be insignificant.
Refer to Chapter 4 of
DEIA.
ii. Water Quality Modeling. Since, no process related effluent is generated & discharged, this requirement is not applicable.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xxxix
Domestic-through STP of 30.0 KLD capacity and used for plantation.
iii. Impacts of the transport of the raw materials and end products on
the surrounding environment shall be assessed and provided. In
this regard, options for transport of raw materials and finished
products and wastes (large quantities) by rail or rail-cum road
transport or conveyor-cum-rail transport shall be examined.
Raw materials and products will be transported via roads using trucks having capacity of 20 Ton each.
As estimated 17 trucks @ 20 ton/truck will be used daily for the transportation of RM, finished products &
slag. Based on the traffic study, this increase will not affect the existing carrying capacity of concerned road
and the LOS.
Further, details of raw
material and products are
provided in Chapter 2 of
DEIA.
iv. A note a treatment, recycling and reuse of wastewater from
different plant operations, extent for different purposes shall be
included. Complete scheme of effluent treatment. Characteristics
of untreated and treated effluent to meet the prescribed standards
of discharge under EPA rules. Use of treated domestic water as
makeup cooling water should be examined and submitted.
STP of 30 KLD will be installed & treated water used in Plantation/Green area. The schematic flow diagram
of STP is enclosed.
v. Details of stack emission and action plan for control of emissions
to meet standards.
The following are the detail of stack emission:
Action plan for control of emissions to meet the standards as per SOPs of PPCB are:
SOP Titled ‘Air Pollution Control in the Induction Furnace unit (s)’ devised by PPCB vide office order no. -
GPC/Guidelines/RS/SP/F-/2018/290 dated 15.06.2018 shall be followed.
During Charging & melting
- Scrap will be segregated for explosives and closed containers.
- The segregated scrap will be freed from oil, paint and grease by charging the same to I.F. maintained at
S. No.
PARTICULARS EXISTING PROPOSED TOTAL
A. PROPOSED CAPACITY OF FURNACES & ROLLING MILLS 1. Induction Furnace 1X8 TPH 2X25 TPH 1X8 TPH
2X25 TPH
2. Laddle Refining Furnace Nil 30 TPH 30 TPH
3. Rolling Mill 01 No. Upgradation of Rolling mill
4. Concast 01 No. Nil 01 No.
5. Vacuum Degasser (VD) Nil 01 No. 01 No.
6. D.G. Sets 2x1500KVA
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xl
3000C and passing the volatile emission through bag filter via suction hood with adequate suction.
- The scrap will be cut to size less than the size of crucible.
- No overcharging of furnace will be practiced and dense charge as for as practicable will be charged.
Air Pollution Control
- Bag filters with pulse jet filtration will be used.
- Rotator air lock will be operated for collection of dust from hopper.
Maintenance of bag filter
- The pressure drop across the bags will be maintained with U- tube manometer and maintained 3-6’’ (76-
152mm).
- Maintained schedule shall be strictly followed and remained maintained.
Temperature
- The temperature of flue gas will be maintained between 100-1200c by proper cooling.
Compressor
- For pulse jet of air, a compressor capable of delivering compressed air of pressure 6-7 kg/cm2 shall be
provided. The air will be devoid of oil and moisture. Recommendation of manufacturer should be
followed.
Fan Maintenance
Shall be carried out as per the maintenance schedule.
vi. Measures for fugitive emission control. For fugitive emissions during furnace charging side suction hood have been provided.
Fugitive emission like smoke, gas and heat around the furnace will be taken care of by proper exhaust
ventilation.
Details of Fugitive
emission control are given
in Chapter- 4 of DEIA.
vii. Details of hazardous waste generation and their storage,
utilization and disposal. Copies of MOU regarding utilization of
solid and hazardous waste shall also be included. EMP shall
include the concept of waste-minimization, recycle/reuse/recover
techniques, energy conservation and natural resource
conservation.
Hazardous waste generated (0.03kl/annum) from DG sets in the form of used oil will be sold to authorized
recyclers. About 4.26 ton/day APCD dust will be also covered under hazardous waste and sent to M/S
Madhav Alloys (P) Limited or TSDF site Nimbuan Dera Bassi for final disposal.
Detailed EMP is Provided in Chapter- 6 of FEIA.
Details of hazardous waste
generation and their
storage, utilization and
disposal is provided at
Chapter- 3 of DEIA.
viii. Proper utilization of fly ash shall be ensured as per Fly Ash
Notification, 2009. A detailed plan of action shall be provided.
No fly ash is either generated in the unit nor it will be generated after expansion. However, during
construction, wherever required fly ash-based cement and other products such as blocks, pavers, bricks &
tiles will be used.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xli
ix. Action plan for the green belt development plan in 33 % area i.e.
land with not less than 1,500 trees per ha. Giving details of
species, width of plantation, planning schedule etc. Shall be
included. The green belt shall be around the project boundary and
a scheme for greening of the roads used for the project shall also
be incorporated.
Area allocation for green belt: 33% i.e. 31,200 m2 of total area as per MoEF&CC stipulated norms will be
developed as the green belt. A total of 4678 trees will be planted. 100 trees have already been planted.
Selection of plant species: Existing tree species are Shisham, Mango, Safeda, and Kachnar. Tree species
like Mulberry, Bungania and False Ashok will be planted.
Action plan & estimated budgetary allocation for proposed green belt development
The proposed green belt in an area of 31,200 m2will be developed in phase wise manner viz. plantation will
be done in Phase-wise manner
No. of trees to be planted in 31,200m2= 31,200/6.67= 4678 plants.
1000 Plants have been already planted. The rest number of plants i.e. 3678 will be planted as
Phase I (June 2022) – 1226 plants will be planted
Phase II (June 2023) – 1226 plants will be planted
Phase III (June 2024)- 1226 plants will be planted
Budgetary allocation: ₹. 22 Lakhs under EMP cost.
Detail of Plantation along
with Budget allocation is
given in Chapter 10 of
DEIA.
x. Action plan for rainwater harvesting measures at plant site and
outside the area of project site shall be submitted to harvest
rainwater from the roof tops and storm water drains to recharge
the ground water and also to use for the various activities at the
project site to conserve fresh water and reduce the water
requirement from other sources.
Rain Water Harvesting calculations is provided at para 3.5.3.
Rain Water Calculations is
provided in Chapter 3 of
DEIA.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xlii
xi. Total capital cost and recurring cost/annum for environmental
pollution control measures shall be included. EMP Budget
To maintain the environmental parameters within the stipulated standards, regular monitoring of various
environmental components is necessary which will be complied as per conditions. Cost of monitoring of
environmental parameters for Air, Water, Noise and stack is ₹345 lakh and cost for Solid Waste
Management, RWH, Safety and Risk Management, Environment Monitoring and Management,
Miscellaneous ₹36.5 lakh.
S.
No
Title Capital Cost
₹ Lakh
Recurring Cost ₹
Lakh
1 Pollution Control during construction stage 2.0 ---
2 Air Pollution Control (Installation of APCD) 300.0 10.0
3 Water Pollution Control (Installation of STP @ 30
KLD) 20.0
2.0
4 Green Belt development 22.0 18.0
5 Noise Pollution Control 1.0 0.1
6 Solid/ Hazardous Waste Management 7.5 ---
7 Environment Monitoring and Management 5.0 0.10
8 Occupational Health, Safety and Risk Management 10.0 0.50
9 RWH 10.0 0.50
10 Miscellaneous 4.0 --
TOTAL ₹381.5 Lakh ₹31.2 Lakhs
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xliii
xii. Action plan for post-project environmental monitoring shall be
submitted.
Action plan for post-project environmental monitoring:
Source Monitoring Location Parameters to be
Monitored Frequency
Furnace Emissions
Stack attached to APCD PM Twice a year or as per conditions of EC or as per requirement of SPCB
Ambient Air Quality
At 2 locations (one inside the project site & one at boundary of the
project site along predominant wind
direction)
PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NOx & CO
Twice a year or as per conditions of EC or as per requirement of SPCB
Ambient Noise
At 2 locations (one inside the project site & one at boundary of the project
site)
Day & Night Equivalent Noise Level
Twice a year or as per conditions of EC or as per requirement of SPCB
Occupational Health
Continuous database
management of health parameters
General Health aspects
Yearly
DG Stack Monitoring
DG sets used during operation
Particulate Matter, SO2, NOx
Twice a year or as per conditions of EC
Details of Action Plan
during Construction Phase
is provided in Chapter -6
of DEIA.
xiii. Onsite and Offsite Disaster (natural and man-made) Preparedness
and Emergency Management plan including Risk Assessment
and damage control. Disaster management plan should be linked
with District Disaster Management Plan.
Safety Hazards
Risk Equipment Causes Mitigation Measures
Steam
Explosion
Furnace Cooling water coming in contact
with molten metal as Slag
Excessive moisture in Slag
Due to refractors
Making C.W. system
leak proof
Pre heating of raw
materials
Pre heating of refractors
Chemical
Explosion
Furnace Accidental mixing of oxidants
such as points/varnishing & oily
scrap
Chemicals/substances in scrap
Segregation of scrap
before use
Fire &
Explosion
Transformers High oil temperature Locating transformers
at isolated place
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xliv
Onsite emergency plan is drawn for handling emergencies that may be manmade or natural within shortest
possible time with the available resources. The existing set up will be further strengthened to meet any
eventually. The highlights of plan are:
The clock securely setup.
Making ‘First Aid’ available & contact with nearly hospitals, police stations and industries.
Deputing a responsible person to be contacted in case of emergency.
Free access to areas where emergency is to be attended.
Assembly points for workers/contact labour & the visitors.
Proper coding of equipments & their locations for attending the emergency.
Varying room temperature Encompassing the oil
filled equipment by
RCC wall
Sparks
followed by
fire
Electrical
installation/Sub-
station
Loose fowls, cable cut, short
circuits etc
Due diligence in
designing the electrical
sub station
8. OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH
i. Details of existing Occupational & Safety Hazards. What are the
exposure levels of above-mentioned hazards and whether they are
within Permissible Exposure Level (PEL)? If these are not within
PEL, what measures the company has adopted to keep them within
PEL so that health of the workers can be preserved.
Details of Safety Hazards:
Safety Hazards
Risk Equipment Causes Mitigation Measures
Steam Explosion Furnace Cooling water coming
in contact with molten
metal as Slag
Excessive moisture in
Slag
Due to refractors
Making C.W. system leak proof
Pre heating of raw materials
Pre heating of refractors
Chemical
Explosion
Furnace Accidental mixing of
oxidants such as
points/varnishing &
oily scrap
Chemicals/substances
Segregation of scrap before use
Table 10.1 is provided in
Chapter- 10 of DEIA.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xlv
in scrap
Fire & Explosion Transformers High oil temperature
Varying room
temperature
Locating transformers at isolated
place
Encompassing the oil filled
equipment by RCC wall
Sparks followed
by fire
Electrical
installation/Sub-
station
Loose fowls, cable
cut, short circuits etc
Due diligence in designing the
electrical sub station
Details of Occupational Health Hazards:
Occupational Health Hazards
Hazard Causes Mitigation/Control
Heat Stress Working in extreme hot conditions Shielding heat radiations from
hot surface
Supply of clean drinking water
Educating workers about the
symptoms of excessive heat
exposure
Short breaks & rotation of
workers
Burns Splashing of molten material
Touching of hot surface
Radiation
Providing specific PPE’s
Providing protective barriers to
minimum exposure
Proper design & process control
Automation to minimize risk
associated with material handling
or casting
Light
Radiation
UV & IR radiations of high intensity from
molten metal especially the pouring areas
Educating the workers regarding
risks and safety measures
Proper labeling of risky areas
w.r.t radiation
Shielding of workers and
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xlvi
providing proper PPE’s
Electrocution Contact with live wires
Flash over
Strong Electromagnetic filter
Elimination of source of risk
Safety switches
Task specific PPE
Mechanical
Hazard
Accidental fall of heavy equipments PPE
Proper training
Hearing
problems
Excessive Noise Insulate ventilation proper
Compulsory PPE
ii. Details of exposure specific health status evaluation of worker. If
the workers health is being evaluated by pre designed format,
chest x-rays, Audiometry, Spirometry, Vision testing (Far & Near
Vision, Colour Vision and any other ocular defect) ECG, during
pre placement and periodical examinations give the details of the
same. Details regarding last month analyzed data of above-
mentioned parameters as per age, sex, duration of exposure and
department wise.
Periodic medical health check up of worker is being/shall be done based on their age and the records
maintained.
The age specific frequency of examination is:
For new entrants & employees below 30 years, once in 5 years
Between 31-40, once in 4 years
Between 41-50, once in 2 years
Above 50 years, every year
Details are provided in
Chapter- 7 of DEIA.
iii. Annual report of health status of workers with special reference to
Occupational Health and Safety.
The record of medical examination will be maintained for follow up action if any.
iv. Plan and fund allocation to ensure the occupational health & safety
of all contract and causal workers.
Proper Safety measures will be taken to ensure the safety of all workers. Further, ₹10.0 lacs have been
designated for Occupational Health, Safety and Risk Management under EMP budget.
Details of EMP containing
fund allocation of
Occupational health and
Safety is provided in
Chapter- 10 of DEIA.
9. CORPORATE ENVIRONMENT POLICY
i. Does the company have a well laid down Environment Policy
approved by its Board of Directors? If so, it may be detailed in the
EIA report.
The industry has well defined Environmental policy and the same is executed by EMC. The main
objections of policy are:
Waste minimization, recycling, energy conservation and use of alternative material which are
practicable and cost effective.
Training, education and information to employees.
Compliance of provisions of applicable environmental laws.
For Detail reference, refer
to Chapter- 10 of DEIA.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xlvii
ii. Does the Environment Policy prescribe for standard operating
process/procedures to bring into focus any
infringement/deviation/violation of the environmental or forest
norms/conditions? If so, it may be detailed in the EIA.
The EMC is entrusted with the task of looking after all the environmental issues.
For Detail reference, refer
to Chapter- 10 of DEIA.
iii. What is the hierarchical system or Administrative order of the
company to deal with the environmental issues and for ensuring
compliance with the environmental clearance conditions? Details
of this system may be given.
The hierarchical system of EMC is as:
For Detail reference, refer
to Chapter- 10 of DEIA.
iv. Does the company have system of reporting of non-compliance
/violation of environmental norms to the Board of Directors of the
company and /or shareholders or stakeholders at large? This
reporting mechanism shall be detailed in the EIA report.
Yes, the non-compliances are reported by EMC to the Directors of Industry.
10. Details regarding infrastructure facilities such as sanitation, duel,
restroom etc. to be provided to the labour force construction as
well as to the casual workers including truck drivers during
operation phase.
Workers, casual labour and truck drivers have already been provided basic amenities like toilets, drinking
water, canteen and the restroom/change room and the same will be available for construction workers.
11. ENTERPRISE SOCIAL COMMITMENT (ESC)
i. To address the Public Hearing issues, 2.5% of the total project cost
of (Rs._ Crores), amounting to Rs._ Crores, shall be earmarked by
the project proponent, towards Enterprise Social Commitment
(ESC). Distinct ESC projects shall be carved out based on the
local public hearing issues. Project estimate shall be prepared
based on PWD schedule of rates for each distinct item and
schedule for time bound action plan shall b prepared. These ESC
projects as indicated by the project proponent shall be
implemented along with the main project. Implementation of such
program shall be ensured by constituting a Committee comprising
Will be given in FEIA report.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xlviii
of the project proponent, representatives of Village Panchayat &
District Administration. Action taken report in this regard shall be
submitted to the ministry’s Regional Office. No free
distribution/donations and or free camps shall be included in the
above ESC budget.
12. Any litigation pending against the project and/or any
direction/order passed by any Court of Law against the project, if
so, details thereof shall also be included. Has the unit received any
notice under the Section 5 of Environment (Protection) act, 1986
or relevant Sections of Air and Water Acts? If so, details thereof
and compliance/ATR to the notice(s) and present status of the
case.
No litigation is pending against the project or the promoter of industry.
13. A tabular chart with index for point wise compliance of above
TORs.
Complied
14. The TORs prescribed shall be valid for a period of three years for
submission of the EIA-EMP reports along with Public Hearing
Proceedings (wherever stipulated).
Tor issued with reference no. SEIAA/M.S./2021/4007 dated on 04.05.2021 is valid upto three years.
Public hearing proceedings will be added after conduction of Public hearing.
B. STANDARDISED SPECIFIC TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR EIA STUDIES FOR INDUCTION/ARC FURNACES/CUPOLA FURNACES 5 TPH OR MORE
i. Details of proposed layout clearly demarcating existing &
proposed features of the project within the plant.
A detailed layout demarcating existing and proposed features Provided at Figure 2.4 A detailed Layout is in
Chapter 2 of DEIA.
ii. Total no. of furnaces & details including capacity if each furnace. Detail of Furnaces including existing and proposed furnaces is provided below
S. No.
PARTICULARS EXISTING PROPOSED TOTAL
A. PROPOSED CAPACITY OF FURNACES & ROLLING MILLS 1. Induction Furnace 1X8 TPH 2X25 TPH 1X8 TPH
2X25 TPH
2. Laddle Refining Furnace Nil 30 TPH 30 TPH
3. Rolling Mill 01 No. Upgradation of Rolling mill
4. Concast 01 No. Nil 01 No.
5. Vacuum Degasser (VD) Nil 01 No. 01 No.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
xlix
iii. Detail of the mechanical shredder to reduce the size of raw
material.
Mechanical Shredder is used to reduce size of raw material.
iv. Complete process flow diagram describing each unit, its processes
and operations, along with material and energy inputs and outputs
(material and energy balance).
Detailed Manufacturing process and material Balance in form of Flow diagram is provided at Fig. 2.8 & Fig. 2.9
Detail of manufacturing
process and material
Balance is provided in
Chapter-2 of DEIA.
v. Details on design and manufacturing process for all units. Provided at Fig. 2.8 Figure 2.8 is present in
Chapter 2 of DEIA.
vi. Details on environmentally sound technologies for recycling of
hazardous materials, as per CPCB Guidelines, may be mentioned
in case of handing scrap and other ‘recycled materials.
The existing unit is disposing APCD dust to TSDF at Dera Bassi. However, in future the same shall be
supplied to M/s Madhav Alloys for recovery of Zinc. The used oil is partly used as lubricant within the
industry.
vii. Details on requirement of raw materials, its source and storage at
the plant.
Raw Material Details: -
RAW MATERIAL
Capacity (TPA) Existing Proposed Total
MS Scrap, CI, Sponge Iron, Ferro Alloys
30,800 2,88,750 3,19,550
Source & Transportation Local & international markets and transport through covered trucks
viii. Details on requirement of energy and waste along its source and
authorization from the concerned department. Location of water
intake and outfall points (with coordinates).
Energy Requirement
DESCRIPTION EXISTING (MW) PROPOSED (MW) TOTAL (MW)
Power 12 39 51
Source Punjab State Power Corporation Limited, Punjab
Water Requirement
DESCRIPTION EXISTING (KLD) PROPOSED (KLD) TOTAL (KLD)
Domestic 15 18 33
Cooling (makeup water) 90 527 617
Total 105 545 650
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
l
No waste water is discharged outside.
ix. Details on toxic metal content in the waste material and its
composition and end use (particularly of slag).
As per CPCB, slag is not a hazardous waste. It will be used in the manufacturing of cement, concrete
blocks, pavers & tiles under proper MOU/Agreement.
x. Details on toxic content (TCLP), composition and end use of
chrome slag. Details on the recovery of the Ferro Chrome from the
slag and its proper disposal.
Not Applicable, as the industry is not manufacturing ferro chrome alloys
C. ADDITIONAL SPECIFIC TORS DECIDED DURING MEETING OF SEAC
i. Public Consultation as required for the projects not located in
notified industrial parks/estates.
As required Public consultation will be conducted by SPCB/ PPCB
ii. Submit proof of ownership of land (existing owner) such as hard
copy of latest Jamabandi (not more than one month old) and
credible document showing status of land acquisition w.r.t project
site as prescribed in OM dated 07.10.2014 issued by MoEF.
Land Papers area attached as Annexure I Land paper as Annexure I
is provided at page no. 171
iii. Submit dully filled prescribed field data sheets and analysis reports
along with exact location of sampling/ monitoring point marked on
the layout map. Also submit the status of approvals of laboratories.
Noted. Will be provided in FEIA.
iv. Submit cost of the project duly certified by Chartered Engineer/
Approved valuer/ Chartered accountant. In the absence of above,
the project proponent may submit self-centered detail of cost of
the project mentioning the cost of land, building, infrastructure and
plant & machinery.
Submitted. Project Cost breakup is attached as Annexure X Annexure VI is attached at
page no. 194 of DEIA.
v. Certificate from the concerned authority w.r.t the location of
protected areas as notified under the Wildlife protection Act, 1972
within 5 km radius from the boundary of the project site.
Noted.
vi. Certificate from the Department of Town & Country Planning or
concerned authorities to support the claim made by project
proponent that the project site is located in the industrial zone as
per the provisions of Master Plan of Town/City in the jurisdiction
Noted.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
li
of which the project site is located otherwise project proponent
shall submit the change of land use of project site for total land
area
vii. Compliance of the siting criteria, standard operating practices,
code of practice and guidelines if any prescribed by the
SPCB/CPCB/MoEF&CC for such type of units.
Being an existing industry, the siting criteria and other requirements/guidelines prescribed by regulatory
authorities are being followed.
viii. Necessary permissions from the Central Ground Water Authority
(CGWA)/State Ground Water Authority (SGWA)/Concerned
Authority for the abstraction of ground water for the existing
requirements as well as for the expanded unit. In case of not
allowing such permissions by the concerned authority for the
abstraction of additional ground water for the expanded project,
the project proponent shall propose alternative arrangements to
meet out the additional water requirements. It shall be assured
that:-
a. In the projects where ground water is proposed as water
source, the project proponent shall apply to the Central
Ground Authority (CGWA)/State Ground Water Authority
(SGWA), as the case may be, for obtaining No Objection
Certificate (NOC) if applicable.
b. Approval/permission of the CGWA/SGWA shall be
obtained before drawing ground water for the project
activities.
c. In the absence of approval, submit a copy of
acknowledgment along with set of application filed to
CGWA/ Competent Authority for obtaining permission for
th abstraction of groundwater.
Application for G.W. abstraction is made to CGWA.
ix. Minimize the water consumption in the steel plant complex by
segregation of used water, practicing cascade use and by recycling
treated water.
Adequate water consumption measures shall be taken while operating the plant.
x. STP for treatment of waste water & reutilization of the treated
water for core/non-core activities so as to achieve the Zero Liquid
The proposed expansion involves ‘Zero Liquid Discharge’ as no water will be used in process. However,
STP of 30 KLD is being provided for treatment of domestic waste water. The treated water will be used for
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
lii
Discharge Condition as per the III (iv) of OM dated 09/08/2018
issued by the MoEF&CC for such units.
plantation and as C.W. the C.T. blow down will not be discharged anywhere but treated in STP and
neutralized.
xi. Reuse of cooling tower blow down, simultaneously ensuring the
standards prescribed for such purge waters. If required, necessary
arrangements shall be made to keep this waste stream within the
parameters required for reuse.
As point vii. Above.
xii. In case of any acid pickling activity, the spent acid/effluents
generated from such activities shall be utilized through authorized
re-processors for converting the same shall be made with the
authorized agencies.
NA,
As no acid pickling activity is included.
xiii. Adequate area to be reserved and marked on the layout plan for
the green belt as per the conditions laid down by the MoEF&CC
as per the Standard EC Conditions prescribed for
Induction/electric Arc Furnace & rolling Mills circulated vide OM
dated 09/08/2018
Green belt in a 33% of project area ( i.e. 31,200 m2) will be developed as per guidelines of CPCB and
covering the entire periphery of plant.
xiv. Detailed study report alongwith calculation for reserving land for
loading or unloading of raw material, products, slag, hazardous
waste as well as for storage of these materials and the area to be
reserved for parking incorporating the time required for loading
and unloading of vehicles for respective activities and
minimum/maximum period for which storage of the above
material is required in the premises. The areas for the respective
activities to be marked on the layout plan.
The proposed project is having adequate space for
Details Sq. mtrs. Total Plot Area 93970 Shed Area (All Machinery) 21610
Finished Good Storage area 7500
APCD area 660 Slag storage area 650
APCD Dust (Hazardous waste) storage area 100
Green area 31200
Scrap area 2860 STP area 100
Parking area 356
Admin. Office area 300
Road & open area 21591
Utilities area 7043
xv. Action plan for the compliance of standard operating procedures
and upgradation of suction and treatment arrangement for the
secondary emissions as prescribed by the State Pollution Control
Board or by MoEF&CC.
The I.F will be operated as per SOP prescribed by PPCB. The APCS will be as per the design prepared by
PSCST. The operational staff will be trained as per PPCB guidelines.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
liii
xvi. Compliance of standard operating procedures and up-gradation of
suction/treatment systems for the control of secondary emissions
with the time frame prescribed by the State pollution Control
Board. Similar action is to be implemented in the proposed
expansion project.
The suction/treatment systems have already been upgraded and operated as per SOP prescribed by PPCB
and the same shall be implemented in the proposed expansion.
xvii. Whole of the vehicle movement area as well as approach road to
the gate/weighing bridge shall be paved with
pucca/metalled/cement concrete road to control the dust emissions
expected from the vehicle movement.
The same is already made pucca with cement concrete.
xviii. The vehicles to be used for loading/unloading purpose shall not be
parked along roadside so as to avoid the traffic congestion and
dedicated parking place to be provided for the same.
Noted. It will be followed and no vehicle will be parked along road side.
xix. Adopt green technologies to conserve the water and energy
including shearing/cutting/bundling machines. Also, to provide
abrasive resistant fire bricks in the crucibles to reduce the periodic
maintenance & disposal of discarded fire bricks.
Noted. It will be followed in letter & spirit.
Green technologies shall be adopted to conserve the water and energy including shearing/cutting/bundling
machines
xx. Use of natural gas (if applicable) as substitute fuel wherever
possible in the existing industry/for expansion project.
The use of natural gas as substitute fuel shall be explored as and when N.G is made available by the Govt.
xxi. Delineate the concrete proposal regarding activities to be
undertaken under Corporate Environmental Responsibility
indicating the following:-
i) Various activities to be undertaken as per the provision of
funds.
ii) Proportionate provisions of funds
iii) The period in which CER activities is to be implemented
iv) The person (s) responsible for the implementation.
Details will be given in FEIA report.
xxii. Submit compliance w.r.t condition no. II [(i) & (ii)] subtitled as
“Air Quality Monitoring & Preservation” regarding continuous
emission monitoring system and continuous ambient air quality
monitoring as prescribed in the Standard EC conditions for
Induction/Electric Arc Furnace & Rolling Mills issued by the
MoEF&CC, New Delhi vide OM dated 09/08/2018.
Continuous emissions monitoring system shall be installed at process stacks and ambient air quality
monitoring stations shall be installed in consultation with SPCB.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
liv
xxiii. Examine and submit the proposal for: -
a. Recovery of iron from slag before disposing it off.
b. Indentify the areas for utilization of slag in scientific
manner and explore its usage in cement/construction
industry/road lying etc.
c. Recovery of precious metals like Zinc, Lead and iron etc
from the APCD dust (Hazardous Waste) through
authorized re-processor.
The slag will be generated and iron recovered magnetically.
The slag will be disposed off to manufacturers of cement concrete blocks, pavers & tiles under proper
agreement.
The APCD dust will be disposed off to authorized recyclers for recovery of zinc, lead etc.
xxiv. Air Pollution Control Arrangement details shall be provided as
below:
Noted for compliance.
xxv. Submit the compliance regarding the installation of pulse jet bag
filter with offline cleaning technology as APCD with the proposed
induction furnace.
For the proposed induction furnace, pulse jet bag filter with offline cleaning technology as APCD is
proposed.
xxvi. List of species with heavy foliage, broad leaves and wide canopy
cover. The landscape planning should include plantation of native
species. Water intensive and/ or invasive species should not be
used for landscaping.
Native Species i.e. Mulberry, Poplar, Amla and Jamun and Mango will be planted in proposed green belt
area.
xxvii. The project proponent shall assess the cost of
APCD/ESP/ZLD/ETP/STP/Continuous online monitoring system
etc from reputed supplier and shall include it in the plant and
machinery/APCD cost as per quotation and EMP. Accordingly,
total project cost should be included in the EIA report. .
Noted.
xxviii. Project proponent will submit the NOC from the concerned Noted.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
lv
territorial/wildlife DFO’s that no Forest/PLPA/Wildlife area are
Noted. involved, at the time of submission of EIA report.
xxix. The project proponent shall obtain permission from PWRDA for
abstraction of groundwater.
Noted
xxx. No activity other than securing the land securing the land will be
carried out in respect of the expansion component of the project
till grant of EC.
Noted
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
2
1.1 Project Name and location
The proposed project i.e. M/s Aarti Steels Limited. is a Secondary Metallurgical Process based
industry. The plant is located at Village- Harian, P.O. Uppal, Machhiwara road, Tehsil- Koom
Kalan, District- Ludhiana, Punjab.
1.2 Products and capacities
The Industry has already got CTE for installation of one no. Induction Furnace of Capacity 8
TPH, Concast and a Rolling mill of capacity 1, 40,000 TPA. The existing production of
Billets/Ingot is 28000TPA and Rolled/Flats products is 1,40,000 TPA. The project is for
expansion of Billet/Ingots Manufacturing by addition of Two no. Induction Furnaces of
capacities 25 TPH each, LRF, VD, Concast and upgradation of existing Rolling Mill. Total
capacity of the project after expansion will be 2, 90,500TPA steel billets/Ingots/ rolled/flats
products.
After expansion the production details will be as under:
Product Name Existing (TPA) Additional (TPA) Total (TPA)
Steel Billets/ Ingots 28,000 2,62,500 2,90,500
Rolled / Flats Products 1,40,000 1,50,500 2,90,500
1.3 Land Area
The industry is having 23.22 acres or 93,970 Sqm. of land. No additional land will be required for
expansion.
1.4 Raw Material Requirement
Raw Material Existing (TPA) Additional (TPA)
Total (TPA)
MS Scrap, CI, Sponge Iron, Ferro Alloys
30,800 2,88,750 3,19,550
Source & Mode of transport
From domestic & as well as International Markets transported
through covered trucks
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
3
1.5 Water Requirement
Water consumption for the unit will be make up water for cooling and for domestic purpose.
Water requirement will be met through existing tube well. The detail of water requirement is
given below:-
DESCRIPTION EXISTING
(KLD)
PROPOSED
(KLD)
TOTAL
(KLD)
Domestic 15 18 33
Cooling (makeup water) 90 527 617
Total 105 545 650
1.6 Power Requirement
The Power Requirement will be met by sourcing the power from Punjab State Power
Corporation limited from nearby Sub-station. The detail of power requirement existing & after
expansion is given below:-
DESCRIPTION EXISTING PROPOSED TOTAL
Power Requirement 12MW 39MW 51MW
Source Punjab State Power Corporation Limited (P.S.P.C.L.)
1.7 Manpower Requirement
Direct Employment; for expansion additional 361 persons will be required. Total number of
manpower after expansion will be 661 no’s.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
4
1.8 Flow Chart of Manufacturing Process
Raw Material
Induction Furnace
Concast Machine
Ingots/ Billets
Rolling/ Final Product
Cooling Tower
Side Suction Hood
A P C D (Bag Filter)
APCD Dust
Clean Air
Final Disposal
TSDF Site/ Disposal
Stack
51 MW Power
Make Up Water
Slag
Metal Recovery Plant
Waste Sent To Vendor for Disposal
Fugitive Emission
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
1
1.9 Description of Mitigation Measures
The purpose of mitigation measures is to avoid, reduce or minimize unwanted impacts on the
environment. To minimize & control the Flue Gas emission from the stack attached to furnace
& DG Set, M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara road) has already installed separate water
scrubber with I.F & canopy with DG set. About 46.74 TPD of slag which is not a H.W will be
generated and the same after recovering of iron will be supplied to manufacturers of cement
concrete blocks, pavers & tiles under proper agreement. STP is provided for treatment of
domestic effluent. Treated effluent is used for plantation in the premises. The industry is
regularly operating and maintaining its APCD and ensuring that the emissions are adequately
collected and concentration of air pollutants in its emissions conforms to the emission standards
laid down by the board.
1.10 Cost Details
Existing cost of the project is Rs. 73 Cr. and total cost for the expansion has been estimated Rs.
130.79 Cr. The total cost of the project has been estimated as Rs. 204.04 Cr. The proposed
expansion will be done within one year after granting of Environment Clearance.
1.11 Site Details
M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant), Village-Harian, P.O. Uppal, Machhiwara road,
Tehsil- Koom Kalan, District- Ludhiana, Punjab is having its global coordinates as Latitude
30°54'27.07"N, 30°54'24.15"N, 30°54'19.62"N, 30°54'12.25"N and 30°54'12.39"N &
Longitude 76°07'48.90"E, 76°07'56.29"E, 76°08'00.67", 76°08'00.86"E and 76°07'49.99"E.
Sahnewal is the nearest city (about 16 Km). Nearest airport is Chandigarh which is at 68 km and
Ludhiana is at 17.6 km from site. No National Parks/ Wildlife Sanctuaries/ Biosphere Reserves/
Reserved Forests exist within 5 km radius of project site. There are no water bodies near project
site
1.12 Environmental Baseline Study
1.12.1 Ambient Air Quality
The PM2.5, PM10, SO2, NO2, CO levels were monitored at eight locations in the study area for
three months (February-April,2021). The P98 levels of criteria pollutants are as follows: PM2.5 is
48.4μg/m3, PM10 is 88.1μg/m3, SO2 is 14.7μg/m3, NO2 is 38.4μg/m3 and CO is 0.68mg/ m3. The
baseline air quality level is within the National Ambient Air Quality Standards prescribed for
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
2
industrial, residential, rural & other area and also satisfies the air quality index (AQI) w.r.t. health
bracket for all the monitoring. (Standards are 60, 100, 80, 80μg/m3 and 4.0mg/m3 for PM2.5,
PM10, SO2, NOx and CO respectively). Due to better pollution abatement facilities, proposed
expansion will have insignificant impact on existing air quality.
1.12.2Water Quality
Eight groundwater samples and one surface water sample from Satluj river at 9km and Ropar
Neelon canal at located 4.2 km from project site were collected from the study area for
chemical, metallic and biological analysis. The groundwater qualities of the study area are
satisfactory as no metallic or bacterial contamination was found in the water samples. But
bacterial contamination was found in surface water. Since, no waste water will be discharged on
land, water quality is not likely to be impacted.
112.3Noise Environment
Ambient noise levels were monitored at 8 locations in the study area. Noise levels in the study
vary from 48.3 dB (A) to 70.2 dB (A) in day time and 37.5 dB (A) to 61.5 dB (A) at night. The
highest levels were observed at Project Site. The baseline noise levels are well within the
National Standards. Proposed expansion will have less impact than existing one due to better
pollution control facility.
1.12.4 Soil Quality
Eight soil samples were collected from the study area and analyzed. The texture of soil is sandy
loam. The organic matter, nitrogen, potassium and phosphorus content of the soil are moderate.
The pH of all the soil samples is within the acceptable range. No impact on soil will be there for
proposed plant as no waste will be discharged on land.
1.12.5 Ecological environment
Ecological data has been collected through secondary sources and by site visits. The tree species
Ashoka, Jamun, Peepal and Mango etc are the dominant plant species of the study area.
Mongoose, porcupine, jungle cat, cobra, krait, snakes, hare, pigeon and variety of birds are the
common animals of the study area. No endangered species of plants and animals are found in the
study area, so no impact on ecological Environment.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
3
1.12.6 Sensitive Ecosystem
Within 5 km distance of the project site, no plant or animal species were found to be on the
endangered list. No ecologically sensitive area like biosphere reserve, tiger reserve, and elephant
reserve, migratory corridors of wild elephant, wetland, national park and wildlife sanctuary are
present within 5 km distance of the project site. Kahali Dum- RF, Retwali- PF, Aleta- PF, and
Bowan- PF etc are revered/protected forests present within the study area. Agriculture and
industrial workers dominate the occupation structure of the study area. Several other industries
large and small units are present in the study area.
1.12.7 Socioeconomic Condition:
Socioeconomic status has been studied through secondary sources and by site visits. The social
requirements identified such as drinking water, Promotion of Educational institutions and Medical
facilities to the villagers (especially Senior Citizens and infants or pregnant ladies). Community
centers, recreation facilities etc will be developed as part of social responsibility.
1.13 Possible Hazards & Risks from Secondary Metallurgical Industries
The various process operations, which are having potentially high risk to human exposure and
which have high levels of attention area identified in table below:
Table 1.1: Possible Risk
S.
No.
Plant Area Possible Deviation from
normal operation
Likely Causes Consequences
1 Furnace Re-circulating and cooling
water coming in contact
with the molten iron or slag.
Leakage of water from
the walls Spurting of
metal/ slag.
Explosion under
extreme cases.
Presence of Oil & Grease
and other Impurities in raw
materials.
Negligence in material
inspection
Sudden catches
fire & flames
2 High Power
Transformer
Oil temperature being very
high.
Varying room
Temperatures.
Sudden flashing
of fire or
bursting.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
4
3 High Tension
Electrical
Installation
Heavy sparking at the pot
heads and the joints.
Loose joints, cable
cut, burning of fuses,
short circuits etc.
Sparks in the
beginning,
devastating fire if
neglected.
1.14 Emergency Plan
Emergency planning is primary for the protection of plant personnel and people in nearby areas
and the environment that could be affected by unplanned hazardous events. Furnaces are
associated with fire and electrical hazard due to sudden generation of pressure or temperature
that leads to damage, injury and death. Temperature and pressure are closely related, and when
flammable or combustible material is present in process equipment it leads to worst
consequences. Thus, an engineering evaluation will be done for worst-case scenario.
1.15 CER Activities (Corporate Environmental Responsibility)
Proposed project will result in growth of the surrounding areas by increased direct and indirect
employment opportunities in the region including ancillary development and supporting
infrastructure.
1.16 Environment Monitoring Plan
Regular monitoring of all significant environmental parameters is essential to check the
compliance status vis-à-vis the environmental laws and regulation. The frequency of the
monitoring will be as follows:
The ambient Air quality shall be monitored at project site and two upward and
downstream locations once every quarter for PM2.5, PM10, NOx & SO2, and CO levels
during the Construction Phase and Operational Phase.
The Ambient Noise Levels, Water Quality, Effluent etc. shall be monitored once every six
months or as per EC conditions.
1.17 Environment Monitoring Cell (EMC)
A duly constituted EMC comprises the following:
1. Owner
2. Project Incharge
3. Environment Consultant
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
5
DRAFT ENVIRONMENT IMPACT
ASSESSMENT REPORT
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
6
CHAPTER 1.0 INTRODUCTION
1.1 PURPOSE OF THE REPORT
The proposed project of Aarti Steel Limited (ASL) is located at Village-Harian, P.O. Uppal,
Tehsil-Koom Kalan, Machhiwara Road, District-Ludhiana, Punjab. The Industry has already got
CTE for installation of one no. Induction Furnace of Capacity 8 TPH, Concast and a Rolling
mill of capacity 1, 40,000 TPA. The existing production of Billets/Ingot is 28000TPA and
Rolled/Flats products is 1,40,000 TPA. The project is for expansion of Billet/Ingots
Manufacturing by addition of Two no. Induction Furnaces of capacities 25 TPH each, LRF, VD,
Concast and upgradation of existing Rolling Mill. Total capacity of the project after expansion
will be 2, 90,500TPA steel billets/Ingots/ rolled/flats products. The plot area of the project is
23.22 Acres or 93970m2. The project cost after expansion including existing cost will be Rs
204.04 Crores.
The project falls within activity 3(a) Metallurgical Industries (ferrous & non-ferrous) & Non
Toxic Secondary Metallurgical processing industry with capacity > 30,000 TPA, so the project
is to be treated as Category ‘B1’, as per MoEFCC OM dated 24th December,2013, and its
Environment Clearance is to be accorded by the SEIAA, MoEF & CC, Punjab. TOR were
issued vide reference number SEIAA/M.S/2021/4007 on dated 04/05/2021 for the preparation
of EIA report with a condition to conduct Public Hearing, this draft EIA-EMP has therefore
been prepared.
1.2 IDENTIFICATION OF THE PROJECT & PROJECT PROPONENT
1.2.1 Identification of the Project
The proposed project of Aarti Steel Limited (ASL) is located at Village-Harian, P.O. Uppal,
Tehsil-Koom Kalan, Machhiwara Road, District-Ludhiana, Punjab. The Industry has already got
CTE for installation of one no. Induction Furnace of Capacity 8 TPH, Concast and a Rolling
mill of capacity 1, 40,000 TPA. The existing production of Billets/Ingot is 28000TPA and
Rolled/Flats products is 1,40,000 TPA. The project is for expansion of Billet/Ingots
Manufacturing by addition of Two no. Induction Furnaces of capacities 25 TPH each, LRF, VD,
Concast and upgradation of existing Rolling Mill. Total capacity of the project after expansion
will be 2, 90,500TPA steel billets/Ingots/ rolled/flats products. The plot area of the project is
23.22 Acres or 93970m2. The project cost after expansion including existing cost will be Rs
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
7
204.04 Crores. No additional land is required for expansion.
1.2.2 Project Proponent
Aarti Group of Companies was incorporated in the year 1977 with its Plant and Head office at
Ludhiana, Punjab. Since 1979 the company has been producing Carbon Steel, Spring Steel and
Alloy Steels conforming to National and International specification through a dedicated route of
steel making i.e. Electric Arc Furnace - Secondary Refining - Vacuum Degassing – Concast
with Electro Magnetic Stirring and other modern Casting practices at their Ludhiana and
Ghantikhal plants. The products are being used by Automobile Sector, Railways and Govt.
Institutions apart from being exported to various countries.
While the group has expanded manifold in steel and yarn business, it has never ignored its
duties towards the nation. The group operates Deepak Memorial Hospital (located in Ludhiana)
which is Multi-specialty, 100% charitable Hospital with 24x7 medical emergency facilities. The
group also has a Cinema, which has been a constant source of entertainment to the residents of
Ludhiana.
Promoter’s Background:
Mr. Shiv Parshad Mittal:
The company is promoted by Mr. Shiv Parshad Mittal and his family members in 1979. Mr.
Mittal is Group Chairman and Managing Director in Aarti International Limited. Mr. Mittal is
having six decades of experience in steel business.
Mr. Mahesh Mittal:
The Steel business of the company is managed by Mr. Mahesh Mittal son of Shri Shiv Parshad
Mittal. Mr. Mahesh Mittal is having 35 years of experience in steels business. He has
successfully implemented Steel Rolling Mill and Steel Wire plant in Ludhiana. He looks after
all the production and marketing function of Ludhiana Steel Division of the Company.
Mr. Rajeev Mittal:
Mr. Rajeev Mittal son of Shri Shiv Parshad Mittal is having 33 years of experience in steels
business. He has successfully implemented Cuttack plant having manufacturing facilities of
Sponge Iron, Ferro Alloys, Steel Billets and captive Power Plants. He looks after all the
production and marketing function of Cuttack Steel Division of the Company.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
8
Mr. Vinayak Mittal:
The Textile business of the group is managed by Mr. Vinayak Mittal son of Shri Mahesh Mittal.
Mr. Vinayak is having 10 years of experience in textile business. He also looks after Steel Wire
business of Ludhiana Division.
Mr. Sushen Mittal:
The Cuttack Steel Plant is managed by Mr. Sushen Mittal son of Shri Rajiv Mittal. Mr. Sushen
has rejoined his family business after a 3-year master degree in business from London Business
School. He also looks after HR Function of the Group.
1.3 BRIEF DESCRIPTION
1.3.1 Nature of the project
Metals can be broadly classified into two categories, ‘ferrous’ and ‘non-ferrous’ metals based on
characteristics and quality of metal. The metallurgical processes of ferrous and non-ferrous
metals can be broadly divided into primary and secondary based on the raw materials and the
method of processing.
M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant) is a non toxic, secondary metallurgical process
based industry. The raw material (MS Scrap and Ferro Alloys) are processed through
conventional I.F route.
1.3.2 Size of the project
The current proposal of the project is expansion of the already established secondary
metallurgical plant and purpose to enhance the capacity in the existing land of 23.22 acres or
93970m2. The capacity of unit after expansion will be 2,90,500 TPA of steel billets/Ingots/
rolled/flats products.
1.3.3 Location of the project
M/s Aarti Steels Ltd (Machhiwara Plant) at Village- Harian, P.O. Uppal, Machhiwara road,
Tehsil- Koom Kalan, District- Ludhiana, Punjab is having its global coordinates as Latitude
30°52'27.07"N; 30°54'24.15"N, 30°54'19.62"N; 30°54'12.25" N, 30°54'12.39"N & Longitude
76°07’48.90"E; 76°07’56.29"E, 76°08’00.67"E; 76°08’00.86"E, 76°07’49.99"E . Ludhiana is
the nearest city and the nearest railway Airport (about 17.6 km in south west direction from
site). Nearest Railway station is Sahnewal which is at 16 km in South west direction from site.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
9
No National Parks/ Wildlife Sanctuaries/ Biosphere Reserves/ Reserved Forests exist within 10
km radius of project site. Location map is provided at Fig 1.1 and Map showing study area at
Fig 1.2. The project details are summarized below in Table 1.1. The global coordinates of the
project site is given as:
Coordinates of the Project Site
Latitude Longitude
30°54'27.07"N 76°07’48.90"E
30°54'24.15"N 76°07’56.29"E
30°54'19.62"N 76°08’00.67"E
30°54'12.25"N 76°08’00.86"E
30°54'12.39"N 76°07’49.99"E
Table 1.1 Project Details
S.No. PARTICULARS EXISTING PROPOSED TOTAL A. PROPOSED CAPACITY OF FURNACES & ROLLING MILLS 1. Induction Furnace 1X8 TPH 2X25 TPH 1X8 TPH
2X25 TPH
2. Laddle Refining Furnace Nil 30 TPH 30 TPH
3. Rolling Mill 01 No. Upgradation of Rolling mill
4. Concast 01 No. Nil 01 No.
5. Vacuum Degasser (VD) Nil 01 No. 01 No.
B. PRODUCTS (TPA)
1. Steel Billets/ Ingots 28,000 2,62,500 2,90,500
2. Rolled / Flats Products 1,40,000 1,50,500 2,90,500
C. RAW MATERIAL (TPA)
MS Scrap, CI, Sponge Iron, Ferro Alloys
30,800 2,88,750 3,19,550
D. GENERALS
1. Project Cost (Crores) ₹ 73.25 ₹ 130.79 ₹ 204.04
2. Land 93,970 m2 --- 93,970 m2
3. Power (MW) 12 39 51
4. Manpower (Nos.) 300 361 661
5. Working days 350 working days in year-round the clock
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
10
Location of Punjab State at Political Map of India Location of District on Punjab Map
Location of Project Site on District Map Location of Project Site on Google Earth Map
Fig 1.1 Google Location of the Project Site
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
11
Fig 1.2 Map showing Study Area and Project Site
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
12
1.3.4 Importance of the Project to the Country, Region
Steel plays a vital role in accelerating growth and development of a nation. It is considered as
backbone of human civilization as it is used as a basic material in manufacturing of metal
products, electrical machinery, transport equipment, textile, etc. In 2019, India became 2nd
largest producer of steel of the world after China. India surpassed Japan to become the world’s
second largest steel producer in 2019 with crude steel production of 111.2 million tonnes
(MT). The growth in the Indian steel sector has been driven by domestic availability of raw
materials such as iron ore and cost-effective labor. Consequently, the steel sector has been a
major contributor to India’s manufacturing output. India’s crude steel output grew 10.7 per
cent year-on-year to 25.76 million tons (MT) during January-March 2017. India’s crude steel
output during April 2017 grew by 5.4 per cent year-on-year to 8.107 MT. India’s finished steel
exports rose 102.1 per cent to 8.24 MT, while imports fell by 36.6 per cent to 7.42 MT in
2016-17. India’s steel exports rose 142 per cent in April 2017 to 747,000 tons over April 2016,
while imports fell by 23 per cent to 504,000 tons in April 2017 over April 2016. Total
consumption of finished steel grew by 3.4 per cent year-on-year at 6.015 MT during April
2017 (Source: Indian Brand Equity Foundation).
Government has taken various steps to boost the sector including the introduction of National
Steel Policy 2017 and allowing 100 per cent Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in the steel sector
under the automatic route. According to the data released by Department for Promotion of
Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT), Indian metallurgical industries attracted Foreign Direct
Investment (FDI) to the tune of US$ 13.40 billion between April 2000–March 2020.
The Government’s National Steel Policy 2017 aims to increase the per capita steel
consumption to 160 Kgs by 2030-31. The Government has also promoted policy which
provides a minimum value addition of 15 per cent in notified steel products covered under
preferential procurement.
For a developing country like India, Iron & Steel Industry has a private role to play as a pre-
requisite for industrial, construction and infrastructural development. As per report of World
Steel Association (WSI), India has surpassed US and became third largest producer of Steel.
The region will be benefited by:
Economic upliftment of suppressed class
Bridging demand –supply gap
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
13
Infrastructural development of the area
Employment to locals
Revenue to state exchequer
1.4 Scope of the study
This study contains information on the Environmental factors viz-a-viz contribution of pollution
by the proposed unit. These factors include air, water, noise, health, socio economic, land use
and agricultural pattern etc. It discusses the predicted impact of the proposed plant activities on
these factors. Broadly under the scope it is envisaged:
To assess the present status of air, water, land, noise, biological & socio economic
components of environment.
To identify, quantify & evaluate positive or negative impacts of various operations on
different environmental components.
To evaluate proposed pollution control measures and to suggest additional control
strategies, if any, to mitigate the adverse impacts.
To identify risk factors & suggest their mitigation including occupational health of the
workers.
To prepare Environmental Management Plan for utilization and adoption of safety
measures.
To delineate future Environmental quality monitoring programme.
To identify the needs of the study area and suggest supportive measures under
Corporate Social Responsibility.
1.4.1 Methodology
Various steps involved in Environmental Impact Assessment study of the proposed project are
divided into the following phases:
Identification of significant environmental parameters and to study the existing status
within the impact zone with respect to air, water, noise, soil and socio economic
components of the environment.
Study of various activities of the proposed project for manufacture of final product and
to identify the areas leading to impact/change in environmental quality.
Identification/prediction of impacts for the identified activities and to study levels of
impacts on various environmental components.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
14
Evaluation of final levels of various parameters after superimposing the predicted
impacts over the baseline quality.
Formulation of Environmental management plan for implementation in the proposed
project.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
15
CHAPTER 2.0
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
2.1 TYPE OF PROJECT
The proposed project of Aarti Steel Limited (ASL) is located at Village-Harian, P.O. Uppal,
Tehsil-Koom Kalan, Machhiwara Road, District-Ludhiana, Punjab. The Industry has already
got CTE for installation of one no. Induction Furnace of Capacity 8 TPH, Concast and a
Rolling mill of capacity 1, 40,000 TPA. The existing production of Billets/Ingot is 28000TPA
and Rolled/Flats products is 1,40,000 TPA. The project is for expansion of Billet/Ingots
Manufacturing by addition of Two no. Induction Furnaces of capacities 25 TPH each, LRF,
VD, Concast and upgradation of existing Rolling Mill. Total capacity of the project after
expansion will be 2, 90,500TPA steel billets/Ingots/ rolled/flats products. The plot area of the
project is 23.22 Acres or 93970m2. The project cost after expansion including existing cost will
be Rs 204.04 Crores.
The project falls within activity 3(a) Metallurgical Industries (ferrous & non-ferrous) & Non
Toxic Secondary Metallurgical processing industry with capacity > 30,000 TPA, so the project
is to be treated as Category ‘B1’, as per MoEFCC OM dated 24th December,2013, and its
Environment Clearance is to be accorded by the SEIAA, MoEF & CC, Punjab. TOR were
issued vide reference number SEIAA/M.S/2021/4007 on dated 04/05/2021 for the preparation
of EIA report with a condition to conduct Public Hearing, this draft EIA-EMP has therefore
been prepared.
2.2 NEED FOR THE PROJECT
Metals constitute a key input to other manufacturing sectors like engineering, electrical and
electronics, automobile and automobile components, packaging and infrastructure. The
performance of the metal sectors hence a reflection of the overall economy. The outlook for the
metal sector in India is bright. Sustained growth is expected across all key segments, aided by
several factors, such as growing domestic demand, investment in capacity addition, increasing
supply deficit in other countries and favorable government regulations. In order to cater to
growing need of steel/ sponge iron in this competitive scenario. M/s Aarti Steels Limited
(Machhiwara Plant) has identified this opportunity and has decided to become a competitive
leader in boosting field of metallurgical sector.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
16
2.3 LOCATION
The proposed project site is located at Village Harian, P.O. Uppal, Machhiwara road, Tehsil-
Koom Kalan, District- Ludhiana, Punjab. No Protected forest, Reserve forest, ecologically
sensitive area, National Park, Biosphere Reserve & Bird Sanctuary are found with-in 10 km
radius of the project site. It is well connected by road. It is well connected by road. Location at
Google image is given at Fig 2.1, 500 m radius map shown at Fig 2.2, and layout & pillar
coordinate of project site is shown at Fig 2.3 & 2.4. Master Plan of Project site is attached as
Fig 2.5. Salient feature of the project is given at Table 2.1.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1619/SA 057)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
17
Fig 2.1 Google Imagery Location of Project Site
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1619/SA 057)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
18
Fig 2.2 500m radius Google Earth Map
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1619/SA 057)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
19
Figure 2.3 Pillar Co-ordinate Map
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1619/SA 057)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
20
Figure-2.4 Layout Plan
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1619/SA 057)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
21
Figure-2.5 Location on Master Plan of Samrala
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
22
Table 2.1 Salient Features of the Project
S. No. Particulars Details
A. LOCATION DETAILS
1. LOCATION
a Village/ Town/Plot No. Harian
b Tehsil Koom Kalan
c District Ludhiana
d State Punjab
e Latitude A-30°54'27.07"N; B-30°54'24.15"N
C-30°54'19.62"N; D-30°54'12.25"N
E-30°54'12.39"N
f Longitude A-76°07’48.90"E; B-76°07’56.29"E
C-76°08’00.67"E; D-76°08’00.86"E
E-76°07’49.99"E
2. Topo-sheet No. H43K1
3. Project Area Total Area –23.22 acres or 9.397 hectare or 93970m2
B. PRODUCTION CAPACITY Existing: Steel Billets/Ingots : 28, 000 TPA Rolled Flats/ Products : 1,40,000TPA
Proposed: Steel Billets/Ingots : 2,62,500 TPA Rolled Flats/ Products : 1,50,500TPA
After Expansion: Steel Billets/Ingots : 2,90,500 TPA Rolled Flats/ Products : 2,90,500 TPA
C. ENVIRONMENTAL SETTINGS
1. Nearest Village Harian-474m North side
2. Nearest City Ludhiana, approx. 25 km in W direction from the project site
3. National Highway / State Highway/
Express Highway
NATIONAL HIGHWAY-5 LUDHIANA-KHARAR is approx. 6.2 km in SE direction from the project site.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
23
4. Nearest Railway Station Sahnewal railway, approx. 16 km in South West direction from the project site
5. Nearest Airport CHANDIGARH: - Airport approx. 68 km in south east direction from the project site. LUDHIANA: - Airport approx. 17.6 km in south west direction from the project site.
6. National Parks/ Wild Life Sanctuaries/
Biosphere Reserves within 10 km
radius
Nil
7. Reserved / Protected Forest within 10
km radius (Boundary to boundary
distance)
No, Reserved Forests exists within 10 km
radius.
8. Nearest water bodies SATLUJ RIVER-9KM North side ROPAR-NEELON CANAL- 4.2KM South side
9. Source of Water Ground water tube-well
10. Seismic Zone Zone – IV
D. COST DETAILS
1. Capital Cost of the project (after
expansion)
₹ 204.04 Cr (After expansion)
2. Total cost for Environmental
Management Plan (EMP)
₹ 9.0 Cr.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
24
2.4 SIZE OR MAGNITUDE OF OPERATION
2.4.1 Proposed Product Details
The proposed steel manufacturing plant after expansion will have Induction furnaces of capacity
2X25 TPH, 8 TPH, LRF of 30TpH, upgradation of Rolling mill & CCM. The production details
will be as under:
After expansion the production details will be as under:
Product Name Existing (TPA) Proposed (TPA) Total (TPA)
Steel Billets/ Ingots 28,000 2,62,500 2,90,500
Rolled / Flats Products 1,40,000 1,50,500 2,90,500
2.4.2 Raw Materials
The raw materials and finished goods will be transported through trucks. There is well developed
road structure on Kohara- Machhiwara road well as within premises also. No additional road
infrastructure will be required for transportation. The raw material details are given as under:
2.4.3 Land Description
The total land of 23.22 Acres or 93,970m2 is available for the existing project and its expansion.
Further, the proposed expansion will be carried out in existing land only. Thus, no additional land
is required for the proposed expansion.
2.4.4 Water Requirement
Water consumption for the unit will be making up water for cooling and for domestic purpose.
Water requirement will be met through existing tube well. The detail of water requirement is given
below:-
Raw Material Existing (TPA) Proposed (TPA) Total (TPA)
MS Scrap, CI, Sponge Iron,
Ferro Alloys
30,800 2,88,750 3,19,550
Source & Transport Local & International Markets & transport through covered Trucks.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
25
DESCRIPTION EXISTING (KLD) PROPOSED (KLD) TOTAL (KLD)
Domestic 15 18 33
Cooling (makeup water) 90 527 617
Total 105 545 650
Green area water demand
Summer (KLD) Winter (KLD) Rainy (KLD) 172 56 16
Sources of water:
S. No. Purposes Source of water 1. Domestic Own tubewell 2. Make-up water demand for cooling Own tubewell 3. Green area water demand Treated waste water
Figure-2.6(a) water Balance (summer)
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
26
Figure-2.7 (b) Water Balance (Winter)
Figure-2.7 (c) Water Balance (Rainy)
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
27
2.4.5 Power Requirement
The Power Requirement will be met by sourcing the power from Punjab State Power Corporation
Limited from nearby Sub-station. The detail of power requirement existing & after expansion is
given below:-
Power requirement along with source is given below:-
DESCRIPTION EXISTING (MW) PROPOSED (MW) TOTAL (MW)
Power 12 39 51
Source Punjab State Power Corporation Limited, Punjab
2.4.6 Manpower Requirement
The proposed project shall generate direct employment for additional 361 persons as per the details
below:
Sr. No
Designation
No. of Persons Shift-01 Shift-02 Shift-03 Total
ROLLING SECTION 01 Manager 2 -- 02 02 Clerical staff 10 -- 10 03 Supervisors 03 03 03 06 04 Foreman 01 -- 01 05 Sr. Fitter 01 01 01 03 06 Fitters 03 03 03 09 07 Pulpit Operator 05 05 05 15 08 Crane Operator 04 04 02 10 09 Welder 01 01 01 03 10 Turner 03 03 06 11 Shaper man 01 01 -- 02 12 Blacksmith 01 01 02 13 Helper 07 07 07 21 14 Tong man 04 04 04 12 15 Billet cutting
man 05 05 05 15
16 Rolled product cutting man
05 05 05 15
19 Electricians 02 02 02 06 20 QCD
Engineers/Staff 05 05 02 12
Total 150
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
28
FURNACE SECTION 01 Manager 04 04 02 Engineers 05 05 05 15 03 Shift Incharge 03 03 03 09 Charging
supervisor 01 01 01 03
04 Melter 03 03 03 09 05 First Hand 04 04 04 12 06 Bariman 04 04 04 12 07 Helper 25 25 25 75 08 Fitters 02 02 02 06 09 Welders 04 04 04 12 10 Electrical Engg 01 01 01 03 11 Electronic Engg 01 01 01 03 12 Electricians 02 02 02 06 13 Crane Operator 10 10 10 30 14 Tee merman 01 01 01 03 15 Laddle man 01 01 01 03 16 mason 01 01 01 03 17 VD Operator 01 01 01 03 Total 211 GRAND TOTAL 361
The required manpower for the proposed expansion can be classified into categories such as
managerial, supervisory, highly skilled, skilled, semi-skilled and unskilled. The direct employment
figure presented above is for the regular plant operations at full capacity.ASL have informed that
their present direct employment is 300 persons. With the above addition, total Employment after
Expansion will be 661persons.
2.4.7 Major Equipments & Machineries
The following are the major equipments & machineries used in proposed manufacturing unit:
S. No.
PARTICULARS EXISTING PROPOSED TOTAL
A. PROPOSED CAPACITY OF FURNACES & ROLLING MILLS 1. Induction Furnace 1X8 TPH 2X15 TPH 1X8 TPH
2X25 TPH
2. Laddle Refining Furnace Nil 30 TPH 30 TPH
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
29
2.5 PROPOSED SCHEDULE FOR APPROVAL AND IMPLEMENTATION
The proposed expansion will be completed within one year after granting of Environment
Clearance.
2.6 TECHNOLOGY AND PROCESS DESCRIPTION
The industry produces ingots from melting MS scrap. All operations are carried out in batch
process. The brief description is as follow.
MS Scrap is put into the induction furnace pot through magnetic conveying system, where it is
heated to 1800 0C. Scrap is melted and is heated for about 100 minutes. In the molten steel some
ferro alloys are added according to the carbon contents in the scrap. The molten steel is then put
into the moulds. The molten steel is fed to Concast (CCM) leading to the formation of
Billets/Ingots which are hot rolled through Rolling Mill to make the desired products. The process
flow chart of manufacturing process and material balance is given Figure 2.7 & Fig. 2.8.
3. Rolling Mill 01 No. Upgradation of Rolling mill
4. Concast 01 No. Nil 01 No.
5. Vacuum Degasser (VD) Nil 01 No. 01 No.
6. D.G. Sets 2x1500KVA
B. PRODUCTS (TPA)
1. Steel Billets/ Ingots 28,000 2,62,500 2,90,500
2. Rolled / Flats Products 1,40,000 1,50,500 2,90,500
C. RAW MATERIAL (TPA)
MS Scrap, CI, Sponge Iron, Ferro Alloys
30,800 2,88,750 3,19,550
D. GENERALS
1. Project Cost (Crores) ₹ 73.25 ₹ 130.79 ₹ 204.04
2. Land 93,970 m2 --- 93,970 m2
3. Power (MW) 12 39 51
4. Manpower (Nos.) 300 361 661
5. Working days 350 working days in year-round the clock
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
30
Fig 2.7: Flow Chart of Manufacturing Process
RAW MATERIAL
INDUCTION FURNACE
CONCAST MACHINE
INGOTS/ BILLETS
ROLLING/ FINAL PRODUCT
COOLING TOWER
SIDE SUCTION HOOD
A P C D (BAG FILTER)
APCD DUST
CLEAN AIR
FINAL DISPOSAL TSDF SITE
STACK
51KW POWER
MAKE UP WATER
SLAG
METAL RECOVERY PLANT
WASTE SENT TO VENDOR FOR DISPOSAL
FUGITIVE EMISSION
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
31
Figure 2.9 Material Balance
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
32
Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) as devised by PPCB for operation and maintenance of
APCD installed on I.F shall be followed.
During Charging & melting
- Scrap will be segregated for explosives and closed containers.
- The segregated scrap will be freed from oil, paint and grease by charging the same to I.F.
maintained at 3000C and passing the volatile emission through bag filter via suction hood with
adequate suction.
- The scrap will be cut to size less than the size of crucible.
- No overcharging of furnace will be practiced and dense charge as for as practicable will be
charged.
Air Pollution Control
- Bag filters with pulse jet filtration will be used.
- Rotator air lock will be operated for collection of dust from hopper.
Maintenance of bag filter
- The pressure drop across the bags will be maintained with U- tube manometer and maintained
3-6’’ (76-152mm).
- Maintained schedule shall be strictly followed and remained maintained.
Temperature
- The temperature of flue gas will be maintained between 100-1200C by proper cooling.
Compressor
- For pulse jet of air, a compressor capable of delivering compressed air of pressure 6-7 kg/cm2
shall be provided. The air will be frees of oil and moisture. Recommendation of manufacturer
should be followed.
Fan Maintenance
Shall be carried out as per the maintenance schedule
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
33
2.7 DESCRIPTION OF MITIGATION MEASURES
The purpose of mitigation measures is to avoid, reduce or minimize unwanted impacts on the
environment. To minimize & control the emission from I.F, the exhaust after suction through side
suction hood is passed through spark arrestor, air cooling and finally bag filters before its discharge
to atmosphere. DG set is fitted with a canopy and adequate stack to take care of noise and
particulate & gaseous emission. About 46.74 TPD of slag which is not a H.W will be generated
and the same after recovering of iron will be supplied to manufacturers of cement concrete blocks,
pavers & tiles under proper agreement. Treated waste water from STP will be used for plantation
within the industrial premises. Hazardous waste generated (0.03kl/annum) from DG sets in the
form of used oil will be sold to authorized recyclers. About 4.26 ton/day APCD dust will be also
covered under hazardous waste and sent to M/S Madhav Alloys (P) Limited or TSDF site Nimbuan
Dera Bassi for final disposal.
The following are the required details for the existing & proposed facility:
Facilities
S.No. Source Existing After Expansion APCD
1. Induction Furnace 1X8 TPH 1X8 TPH
2X25 TPH
Pulse jet back filter with
offline technology
2. Laddle Refining
Furnace
Nil 30 TPH Pulse jet back filter with
offline technology
3. Rolling Mill 01 no. 01 (Upgradation) Alkali Scrubber
4. Concast 01 No. 01 NO. --
5. Vacuum Degasser
(VD)
Nil 01 No. --
6. D.G. Sets 2x1500KVA ---
Effluents
S.No. Description Existing After Expansion Mitigation
Measures/Remarks
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
34
1. Industrial Effluent NIL NIL No generation of
industrial effluent
2. Domestic 14.4 KLD 26.90 KLD STP of 30 KLD will be
installed & treated water
used in Plantation/Green
area
Hazardous Waste
S.No. Waste Category After Expansion Disposal
1. 35.1
Flue gas Cleaning
residue
4.26 TPD
Will be sent to TSDF site or M/s Madhav alloys for final disposal
2. Used Oil 0.03 kl/annum will be sold to authorized recyclers
Table 2.2 Quantity of Solid/Hazardous waste
S.No. Type of waste
Source of Waste Quantity Category of waste
DISPOSAL Existing After
expansion
1
Slag Melting of Steel (IF) 3.96TPD 46.74TPD Non-
Hazardous Sent to
cement plant for reuse
2 APCD DUST
IF
0.44TPD 3.44TPD Hazardous Send to TSDF site/Madhav Alloys
LRF
Nil 0.82TPD Hazardous
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
35
Table 2.3 Details of STACK
PARTICULARS CAPACITY FUEL USED STACK
HEIGHT APCD
INDUCTION FURNACE 8TPH
ELECTRICITY
40mtr
BAG FILTERS
INDUCTION FURNACE 25TPH ELECTRICITY 40mtr BAG FILTERS
INDUCTION FURNACE 25TPH ELECTRICITY 40mtr BAG FILTERS
LRF 30 TPH ELECTRICITY 35mtr BAG FILTERS
Rolling Mill 35 TPH FO (120lt/hrs) 35mt Alkali Scrubber
DG SET STACK-1 1500 KVA DIESEL @300Ltr/Hr
25mtr Noise less
DG SET STACK-2 1500 KVA DIESEL @300Ltr/Hr
25mtr Noise less
Table 2.3 Details of APCD
Sl. No.
APCD Location Volume of Flue gases m3/h
Power Existing
After Expansion
1
Bag Filters
Induction Furnace 8TPH 40,000 NA 100KW
Induction Furnace 25TPH NA 1,20,000
300KW
Induction Furnace 25TPH NA 1,20,000
300KW
Ladle Refining Furnace 30TPH
NA 40,000 100KW
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
36
CHAPTER 3.0
DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT
3.1.1 Study Area
As a precursor for the prediction of various types of environmental impacts likely to arise due to
implementation of the project, it is essential to establish the baseline environmental setting of the
physical, natural and socio-cultural environmental parameters along the project and within the
project influence area. Details of the baseline environmental parameters are required for decision
making for the project design, implementation and operation from the environmental point of
views. The data is to be generated through primary data collection (direct monitoring) and
secondary sources (published data).
This chapter incorporates the description of existing environmental status in an area encompassed
within 10 km radius around the proposed expansion of existing steel manufacturing unit.
Details showing all Ecosensitive area & environmentally sensitive places provided in Table-3.0
and Figure 3.0
Table-3.0
Ecosensitive Area around 10km radius of Study area
Environmental Features Description (Name) Distance from Project Site
National Park/ Wildlife
Sanctuaries/Biosphere
Reserves/Tiger
Reserves/Migratory Corridors;
Migratory routes etc
Nil There is no National Park/ Wildlife
sanctuaries/Biosphere Reserves/Tiger
Reserves/Migratory Corridors; Migratory
routes etc within 10 km radius of study
area.
Historical Places/Places of
Tourist/ Archeological site
Nil There is no Historical Places/Places of
Tourist/ Archeological site within 10km
radius of study area.
Industrial Areas/Cluster
(Reference MoEF & CC OM
dated 13th Jan,2010
Rural Focal Point The project is in rural focal point.
Defence installation Nil There is no Defence installation within
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
37
10km radius of study area.
Nearest village Harian 474m North side
Reserved/Protected Forest Nil There is no reserved/protected forest
within 10 km radius from the project site Water Body Sidhwan canal SATLUJ RIVER-9KM North side
ROPAR-NEELON CANAL- 4.2KM
South side
Major Crops Wheat, Cotton, Rice,
Maize
Nearest Airport CHANDIGARH: Airport approx. 68 km in south east direction from the project site.
LUDHIANA Airport approx. 17.6 km in south west direction from the project site.
Nearest Rail head Sahnewal Approx. 16 km in South West direction from the project site
National Highway/SH NH-5 Ludhiana- Kharar
Approx. 6.2 km in SE direction from the project site.
Nearest City Ludhiana Approx. 25 km in W direction from the project site
3.1.2 Study Period
The baseline environmental monitoring for the expansion project has been collected from February
to April, 2021. Initially, a reconnaissance survey of the study area was carried out for monitoring
station selection and then field monitoring for measuring primary data was carried out following
CPTLE/QSPM-06/01–CPTLE/QSPM-06/09 as per the QMS of the organization. In addition,
certain aspects like land area, socio-economic status, past meteorological conditions, etc., have
been analyzed based on secondary information available from sources like district census reports,
district gazetteers, Indian meteorological department, etc. The baseline status of various
environmental components is described in the succeeding sections.
3.1.3 Components of Study
The main objectives of describing the environment, which may be potentially affected, are (i) to
assess present environmental quality and the environmental impacts and (ii) to identify
environmentally significant factors that could preclude project development.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
38
This chapter contains information on environmental scenario for the following parameters.
1. Land Environment
2. Meteorology
3. Air Environment
4. Noise Environment
5. Water Environment
6. Soil Environment
7. Biological Environment
8. Socio-economic Environment
3.1.4 Methodology
For the present study, all the sampling locations are marked with the help of Google maps and site
visits. The land use/ land cover map has been generated on 1:50,000 scale using Satellite imagery
and ground truth information. The baseline environmental quality has been assessed during
January to March, 2020. Samples of Air, Water, Noise and Soil from the site and nearby areas have
been collected and analyzed for the study of existing condition. The baseline data is generated
through field study within the impact zone for various components of the environment viz. Air,
Noise, Water, Land, Ecology and Socio-economic. While generating the baseline status of physical
and biological environment of the study area, the concept of impact zone has been considered. The
impact zone selection is based on preliminary screening and modeling studies. The methodologies
for various environmental facets are as follows:
1. Meteorological Data
Meteorological data of project site has been used for the study and for reference a secondary data
was obtained from Indian Meteorological Department (IMD). The important parameters
considered are temperature, humidity, wind speed, wind direction and rainfall.
2. Ambient Air Quality
The guidelines for selections of ambient air monitoring stations and analysis of air pollutants as
given in IS – 5182 part 14, 2000 (Guidelines for planning the sampling of atmosphere) and
‘Guidelines for Ambient Air Quality Monitoring’ by CPCB respectively were followed.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
39
3. Water Quality
Grab sampling was done for ground and surface water. Water samples were taken as per the
Standard Methods (IS 10500: 2012 & APHA, 23rd Edition). Necessary precautions were taken
during sampling and preservation of samples.
4. Noise Quality
At each station noise level was monitored for day and night once in a season as per IS 9989:1981.
As sensitive receptors are the prime consideration for sound levels, the monitoring locations are the
same as those decided for ambient air quality monitoring.
5. Soil Quality
For soil, augur method was used and samples were collected at 15-25 cm depth after removing the
upper crust.
6. Geology and Hydrogeology
Field survey has been conducted to verify secondary data.
7. Land Use
The land use/ land cover map has been generated on 1:50,000 scale using Satellite imagery and
ground truth information.
8. Biological Environment
Primary and secondary data collection has been carried out by the Ecology and Biodiversity
expert/ team for the study of flora and fauna in the core and buffer zone.
9. Socio Economic Environment
For demography and socioeconomics, secondary data block wise data has been collected and used
for the assessment of impacts. Field survey has been conducted to verify secondary data.
3.2 ENVIRONMENTAL BASELINE DATA COLLECTION
Baseline data for the proposed plant has been collected in summer season. Primary data has been
collected by monitoring & surveying of various environmental components/ parameters, as per
detail given in Table – 3.1.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
40
Table-3.1 Primary Data
S. NO. PARAMETERS DESCRIPTION
1 Meteorology Meteorological parameters on hourly basis at project site. Parameters:
Temperature, Relative humidity, Wind Speed & Wind Direction.
2 Air Ambient air quality monitoring (24 hourly), twice a week. Parameters are
PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NO2 & CO.
No. of Locations: 8 locations in core and buffer zone.
3 Noise Noise level monitoring (Day & Night time), once in a season.
No. of Locations: 8 locations in core and buffer zone.
4 Water Ground water sampling, once in a season.
No. of Locations: 8 locations in core and buffer zone.
Tested for physical and chemical parameters.
5 Soil Soil sampling, once in a season.
No. of Locations: 8 locations in core and buffer zone.
6 Biological Factors Biodiversity survey, once in a season.
Location: Core and buffer zone.
7 Socio-economic
Environment
Socio-economic survey, once in a season.
Location: Core and buffer zone.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
41
3.3 METEOROLOGY
3.3.1 Climatic conditions
The climate of the district is characterized by dryness except a brief spell of monsoon season in a
very hot summer and a bracing winter. The cold season extends from mid November to the early
part of March. The succeeding period up-to the end of June is the hot season. July, August and half
of September constitute the southwest monsoon. The period from mid September to mid
November is considered as post monsoon. June is generally the hottest month. Hot and scorching
dust laden winds blow during summer season. The project zone lies in the sub tropical region with
four distinct seasons;
Winter – November to February
Summer – March to June
Monsoon – July to Mid September
Post Monsoon – Mid September to mid November
In order to study the meteorology of the project area, site specific summer season meteorological
data was collected. Annual Weather Averages is provided at figure no. 3.1. Windrose diagram for
whole year and study period is provided at Fig 3.2 (a) and Fig 3.2 (b) respectively.
3.3.2 Temperature
May and June are the hottest months with daily average temperature going up to 40°C and
minimum average daily temperature as 24°C. Hot scorching dust laden winds blow during the
summer season and on individual day the temperature sometimes goes up-to 45°C to 47°C. With
the on-set of monsoon in July there is appreciable drop in temperature but due to increased
moisture in the air the weather becomes uncomfortable. After monsoon in September the night
temperature drops appreciably. December and January are the coldest months when the maximum
average daily temperature is around 22°C and minimum about 6°C. The yearly variation is from
4.0°C min to 45°C max. Monthly average temperatures and rainfall of the area are given in Table
3.2.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
42
3.3.3 Rainfall
The normal annual rainfall of the district is 680 mm which is unevenly distributed over the area in
34 days. The south west monsoon sets in from last week of June and withdraws in end of
September, contributory about 78% of annual rainfall. July and August are the wettest months.
Rest 22% rainfall is received during non-monsoon period in the wake of western disturbances and
thunder storms. Generally, rainfall in the district increases from southwest to northeast.
Figure 3.1 Monthly averages Temperature (ºC) & Rainfall (mm)
3.3.4 Micro-Meteorology at Site
Meteorological station was set-up at site to record surface meteorological parameter during the
study period.
Summary of the micro-meteorology at site is given below.
Table 3.2 Annual weather average of Ludhiana district
Month Temperature(oC) Relative Humidity (%)
Max. Min. Average
January, 2020 18.9°C 6.7°C 54%
February, 2020 21°C 8.5°C 56%
March, 2020 26°C 12.8°C 62%
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
43
Fig. 3.2 (a) Wind Rose Diagram for Study Period
(Software name: - Pavanaarekh)
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
44
Fig. 3.2 (b) Wind Rose Diagram for whole year including study period
(Software name: - Pavanaarekh)
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
45
3.4 Ambient Air Quality
The ambient air quality monitoring was done to assess the current status of air quality in the study
area. Monitoring was carried out at eight stations for February- April, 2021. The guidelines for
selections of ambient air monitoring stations given in IS – 5182 part 14, 2000 and ‘CPCB
guidelines for air quality monitoring’ were followed. These guidelines state that, “when the
objective of air sampling is to identify the contribution from specific sources of pollution, the
sampling locations should be located in upwind and the downwind direction of such sources”.
The ambient air quality monitoring locations were selected considering the following criterion:
1. Location of sensitive receptors such as reserved forests, national parks, hospitals,
archaeological sites, etc. in the vicinity of the study area.
2. The site should be representative of the area selected;
3. Topography of the study area.
4. The stations should be selected in a way so as to yield data that can be compared with another;
5. Certain physical requirements (electricity and other logistics) should be satisfied at the site.
3.4.1 Methodology
The prime objective of the baseline study with respect to ambient air quality is to establish the
present air quality and its conformity to National Ambient Air Quality Standards. This data has
been further used during impact assessment to predict the final air quality. This section describes
the sampling locations, frequency of sampling and methodology adopted for monitoring ambient
air quality.
To quantify the impact of the project on the ambient air quality, it is necessary first to evaluate the
existing ambient air quality of the area. The existing ambient air quality, in terms of Particulate
Matter (Size <10µm) or PM10, Particulate Matter (Size <2.5 µm) or PM2.5, Sulphur-di-oxide (SO2),
Oxides of Nitrogen (as NO2), and Carbon Monoxide (CO), has been measured through a planned
field monitoring.
3.4.2 Sampling Stations
To select the air sampling locations, meteorological data with respect to temperature, relative
humidity, wind speed and direction plays a vital role. Predominant wind direction plays an
important role in determining location of monitoring stations. List of Air monitoring location is
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
46
given in Table 3.3. Toposheet demarcating the location is given at Figure 3.3. Ambient air
abstract is given at Table 3.4
Table 3.3
Ambient Air Monitoring Stations
Name of Village/ Location
Distance from the Plant (Km)
Direction w.r.t. Plant
Justification for the Selection
AAQ-1 Project Site -- -- Represent the project site AAQ -2 Takhran
2 S Downwind direction of the project
site.
This station’s AAQ data captures the baseline for residential area.
AAQ -3 Macchiwara 4.8 E Crosswind direction of the project site.
This station’s AAQ data captures the baseline for residential and Industrial area.
AAQ -4 Mughlewal 8.4 N Upwind direction of the project site. This station’s AAQ data captures the
baseline for residential and Industrial area. And located in vicinity of the project site.
AAQ -5 Ratangarh 7.01 NW Upwind direction of the project site.
This station’s AAQ data captures the baseline for residential area
AAQ -6 Partapgarh 6 W Crosswind direction of the project site.
This station’s AAQ data captures the baseline for residential area.
AAQ -7 Katani Kalan
8.1 S Downwind direction of the project site.
This station’s AAQ data captures the baseline for residential area
AAQ -8 Haron Kalan 8.3 SE Downwind direction of the project site.
Further, this station’s AAQ data captures the baseline for residential
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
47
3.4.3 Monitoring Schedule
Ambient air quality monitoring was carried out twice a week with a frequency of 24 hours for 12
weeks.
3.4.4 Methods of Sampling and Analysis
Fine particulate Sampler APM-550 & RDS APM-460 were used for monitoring of Particulate
Matter (PM2.5 and PM10); gaseous pollutants like SO2, and NO2 were collected by Gaseous
Pollutant Sampler APM-433. The analysis was done as per methods mentioned below:
S. No. Parameters Analysis Method 1. PM10 µg/m3 IS:5182, (Part-23) 2006, By Gravimetric Method: 2006 2. PM2.5 µg/m3 SP-57, Issue Date-01- 05-2019,CPCB Guideline Vol-I:: 2011 3. SO2 µg/m3 IS 5182 (P-2):2001 1st Rev (RA: 2012): 2001 4. NOx µg/m3 IS:5182, (P-6), RA 2012: 2006 5. CO mg/m3 IS 5182 (P- 10):RA2014: 1999
Sample Transportation and Sample Preservation: Proper preservation of samples was done after
sampling. The Gaseous samples were preserved in an ice box (below 4°C) and transported to the
laboratory for analysis. The filter papers were collected using forceps and stored in polythene bags
and stored in dry containers during transportation.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
48
Fig. 3.3 Monitoring Locations of Ambient Air
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
49
Table 3.4
Ambient Air Quality Abstract
Locations PM2.5
µg/m3
PM10
µg/m3
SO2
µg/m3
NOx
µg/m3
CO
mg/m3
Max Min Avg. Max Min Avg. Max Min Avg. Max Min Avg. Max Min Avg.
Project Site - AAQ1 52.8 46.1 49.6 92.5 85.4 89.1 16.8 10.4 13.6 43.2 32.6 38.2 0.73 0.64 0.68
Takhran (AAQ -2) 48.6 38.4 42.7 88.6 76.6 82.6 15.0 9.2 12.2 38.2 26.6 32.6 0.72 0.64 0.68
Macchiwara (AAQ-3) 42.0 35.2 39.1 90.6 82.4 86.7 14.6 10.4 12.7 38.2 28.4 33.6 0.68 0.55 0.61
Mughlewal (AAQ-4) 38.4 31.2 34.9 86.8 78.4 82.6 15.2 8.8 12.8 36.6 27.1 33.5 0.64 0.55 0.57
Ratangarh (AAQ-5) 37.6 30.2 34.8 85.8 70.3 77.8 13.5 6.5 9.9 34.8 24.4 30.1 0.59 0.50 0.56
Partapgarh (AAQ-6) 44.2 32.1 38.3 84.1 70.6 76.9 12.8 9.1 10.9 36.2 25.5 30.9 0.55 0.43 0.50
Katani Kalan (AAQ-7) 44.4 31.5 38.5 83.2 72.0 78.4 13.1 9.4 11.4 39.2 26.6 33.1 0.60 0.46 0.52
Haron Kalan(AAQ-8) 42.5 32.1 37.5 81.5 71.8 76.6 12.8 8.2 11.2 38.6 26.5 33.3 0.56 0.44 0.48
P98 48.4 88.1 14.7 38.4 0.68
NAAQ Standards 60 100 80 80 4.0
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
50
3.4.5 Interpretation
The observations based on a perusal of the results for the study period are summarized below:
Respirable Particulate Matter (PM10):
A maximum value of 92.5µg/m3 was observed at Project site (AAQ1) and minimum value of
70.3µg/m3 was observed at Ratangarh (AAQ5). The average values were observed to be in the
range of 76.6 to 89.1µg/m3. The project site is located at designated Industrial Area and
surrounded by many other industries which ultimately add to the PM load in the subjected
area. The minimum concentration at location AAQ5 (Ratangarh) can be said due to its remote
location and no industrial activity in and around the monitoring station. Therefore experiences
minimal levels of pollution.
Fig 3.4: Graphical representation of PM10 in Study Area
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
51
Particulate Matter (PM2.5):
A maximum value of 52.8µg/m3 was observed at Project site (AAQ1) and minimum value of
30.2µg/m3 was observed at Ratangarh(AAQ5) The average values were observed to be in the
range of 37.5 to 49.6µg/m3. The minimum concentration at Ratangarh indicates that the area
experiences minimal combustion and vehicular activity. On the other hand high concentration
at location AAQ1 indicates that the area experiences high emissions from industrial activity
and vehicular movement in the surroundings.
Fig 3.5: Graphical representation of PM2.5 in Study Area
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
52
Fig 3.6: Graphical representation of SO2 concentration at selected sites
Sulphur Dioxide (SO2):
Maximum concentration of SO2 is observed to be 16.8µg/m3 at Project site (AAQ1) and
minimum value of 6.5µg/m3 at Ratangarh(AAQ5). The average values were observed to be in
the range of 11.2 to 13.6 µg/m3. The emission from industries & constant traffic and regular
movement of heavy vehicles which are diesel driven around the project area can be
considered as the principle source of emission for SO2. All the values are well within the
prescribed limit of CPCB.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
53
Nitrogen Dioxide (NOx):
The various forms of Nitrogen in NO, NO2 and N2O are collectively called as Oxides of
Nitrogen. Maximum concentration of NOx is observed to be 43.2 µg/m3 at Project Site
(AAQ1) and minimum value of 34.8 µg/m3 observed at Ratangarh (AAQ5). The average
values were observed to be in the range of 33.3 to38.2 µg/m3. The emission from industries
& constant traffic and regular movement of heavy vehicles which are diesel driven around the
project area is the main source of emission for NO2.
Fig 3.7: Graphical representation of NOx in Study Area
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
54
Carbon Monoxide (CO):
The anthropogenic source of CO is incomplete combustion of carbon-containing fuels, such
as gasoline, natural gas, oil, coal, and wood. The largest anthropogenic source of CO is
vehicle emissions. Maximum concentration of CO is observed to be 0.73mg/m3 at Project
Site (AAQ1) and minimum value of 0.43mg/m3 observed at Partapgarh (AAQ6). The average
values were observed to be in the range of 0.48 to 0.61mg/m3.
Conclusion: The descriptive statistics of the monitoring at all the locations are indicating
that pollution levels w.r.t. PM10 & PM2.5 at Project Site exceed the standards prescribed by
the CPCB.
Fig 3.8: Graphical representation of CO in Study Area
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
55
3.5 Water Environment
Water Quality
Water quality assessment is one of the essential components of EIA study. Such assessment
helps in evaluating the existing health of water body and suggesting appropriate mitigation
measures to minimize the potential impact from development projects. Water quality of
ground water has been studied in order to assess water-use in construction, drinking, cooling
and horticulture purpose. The water quality at the site and other locations within the 10 km
impact zone was monitored during January to March 2020.
Sampling frequency and Technique
Parameters for analysis of water quality were selected based on the utility of the particular
source of water as per MoEF&CC guidance. Hence quality of ground water was compared
with IS: 10500: 2012 for drinking purposes. As per the standard practice, one sample from
each station was taken in the study period. Sampling was done by standard sampling
technique as per the Standard Methods. Necessary precautions were taken for preservation of
samples.
Sampling location of surface water is given in Figure 3.9 and list of surface sample is given
in Table 3.5 & 3.8 respectively. The results of surface water is given in Table 3.6.
3.5.1 Surface water sources in the study area
The surface water resources in the study area as studied from the satellite imagery depicts that
Bhakra Canal is flowing from southeast and southwest side of the project area. The sampling
locations for the surface water were finalized after reconnaissance survey and consultation
with the functional area experts from the respective areas.
Criteria for selection of surface water quality sampling locations
While selecting a sample it is always important to take care that the sample should be
representative of the selected water body. In order to remove the bias in sample selection,
grab samples were collected on random basis considering the following key aspects:
1. The sampling locations were selected based on upstream and downstream uses of the
water body.
2. Drainage Pattern of study area in general.
3. Domestic discharge points from the near-by villages.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
56
Figure 3.9
Location of Surface water
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
57
Table 3.5 Surface Water Sampling Stations
Station Sampling Location Aerial Distance (Km) and Direction from Project Site
SW-1 Satluj River 9 KM ,N
SW-2 Ropar-Neelon Kanal
4.2 Km, S
Table – 3.6
Results of Surface Water Sample (Satluj River)
Sr. No.
Parameters Unit Upstream Downstream Detection Limit
1. pH - 7.41 7.56 2. Color H.U <5 <5 5.0 HU 3. Odour -- Agreeable Agreeable -- 4. Turbidity NTU <1 <1 0.5 NTU 5. Dissolved Oxygen mg/l 6.4 6.5 1.0 mg/l 6. Chemical Oxygen Demand mg/l 10.0 12.2 5.0 mg/l 7. BOD at 27 oC for 3 day mg/l <2 <2 2.0 mg/l 8. Total Dissolved Solids mg/l 210 218 1.0 mg/l 9. Total Suspended Solids mg/l 2.2 2.8 1.0 mg/l
10. Total Hardness as CaCO3 mg/l 100 110 1.0 mg/l 11. Chlorides as Cl mg/l 14.9 16.2 1.0 mg/l 12. Sulphates as SO4 mg/l 22.1 24.2 1.0 mg/l 13. Total alkalinity as CaCO3 mg/l 84 88 0 mg/l 14. Magnesium as Mg mg/l 6.8 7.2 1.0 mg/l 15. Calcium as Ca mg/l 18.4 20.2 1.0 mg/l 16. Nitrate as NO3 mg/l 1.16 1.20 1.0 mg/l 17. Zinc as Zn mg/l ND ND 0.5 mg/l 18. Iron as Fe mg/l ND ND 0.1 mg/l 19. Fluoride as F mg/l ND ND 0.1 mg/l 20. Sodium as Na mg/l 14.4 16.8 1 mg/l 21. Potassium as K mg/l 4.2 4.6 1 mg/l 22. Cadmium as Cd mg/l ND ND 0.01 mg/l 23. Total Chromium as Cr mg/l ND ND 0.045 mg/l 24. Mercury as Hg mg/l ND ND 0.001 mg/l 25. Aluminum as Al mg/l ND ND 0.01 mg/l 26. Boron as B mg/l ND ND 0.1 mg/l 27. Fecal Coliform MPN/100 ml 170 220 <2MPN/100ml 28. Total Coliform MPN/100 ml 350 500 <2MPN/100ml
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
58
Table – 3.7
Results of Surface Water Sample (Ropar-Neelon Kanal)
Sr. No.
Parameters Unit Upstream Downstream Detection Limit
1. pH - 7.85 7.88 2. Color H.U <5 <5 5.0 HU 3. Odour -- Agreeable Agreeable -- 4. Turbidity NTU <1 <1 0.5 NTU 5. Dissolved Oxygen mg/l 5.5 6.0 1.0 mg/l 6. Chemical Oxygen Demand mg/l 6.6 6.4 5.0 mg/l 7. BOD at 27 oC for 3 day mg/l <2 <2 2.0 mg/l 8. Total Dissolved Solids mg/l 220 224 1.0 mg/l 9. Total Suspended Solids mg/l 16.0 18.2 1.0 mg/l
10. Total Hardness as CaCO3 mg/l 160 166 1.0 mg/l 11. Chlorides as Cl mg/l 19.9 21.2 1.0 mg/l 12. Sulphates as SO4 mg/l 26.2 28.2 1.0 mg/l 13. Total alkalinity as CaCO3 mg/l 150 154 0 mg/l 14. Magnesium as Mg mg/l 10.4 12.4 1.0 mg/l 15. Calcium as Ca mg/l 26.4 26.8 1.0 mg/l 16. Nitrate as NO3 mg/l 1.32 1.36 1.0 mg/l 17. Zinc as Zn mg/l ND ND 0.5 mg/l 18. Iron as Fe mg/l ND ND 0.1 mg/l 19. Fluoride as F mg/l ND ND 0.1 mg/l 20. Sodium as Na mg/l 20.2 21.6 1 mg/l 21. Potassium as K mg/l 5.4 5.8 1 mg/l 22. Cadmium as Cd mg/l ND ND 0.01 mg/l 23. Total Chromium as Cr mg/l ND ND 0.045 mg/l 24. Mercury as Hg mg/l ND ND 0.001 mg/l 25. Aluminum as Al mg/l ND ND 0.01 mg/l 26. Boron as B mg/l ND ND 0.1 mg/l 27. Fecal Coliform MPN/100 ml 200 220 <2MPN/100ml 28. Total Coliform MPN/100 ml 300 330 <2MPN/100ml
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
59
Table – 3.7
CPCB water Quality Criteria for Surface water as per use
S. No.
Parameters Class A Class B Class C Class D Class E
1. pH 6.5-8.5 6.5-8.5 6.5-8.5 6.5-8.5 6.5-8.5
2. Dissolved Oxygen 6 5 4 4 -
3. BOD, 3days at 270C, max
2 3 3 - -
4. Total coliform organism, MPN/100ML, max
50 500 5000 - -
5. Free Ammonia (as N), mg/l, max
- - - 1.2 -
6. Electrical Conductivity, µmhos/cm, max
- - - - 2250
7. Sodium absorption ratio, max
- - - - 26
8. Boron (as B), mg/l, max.
- - - - 2
Class A: Drinking water source without conventional treatment but after disinfection.
Class B: Outdoor bathing (organized).
Class C: Drinking water source after conventional treatment and after disinfection.
Class D: Propagation of wild life fisheries.
Class E: Irrigation, Industrial cooling, controlled waste disposal.
Below E: Not meeting A, B, C, D & E Criteria
Conclusion:-
The surface water results of upstream & downstream of Bhakhra Canal are compared with
Water Quality Criteria prescribed by CPCB for different classes of water. Based upon the
perusal of analytical values, it is seem that surface water categorized in category “E” indicated
that all the parameters were found to be within the prescribed limits.
Surface water quality results are summarized below (Satluj river):
pH of the surface water collected ranged from 7.41 – 7.56
TDS was found to be 210- 218 mg/l. The tolerance limit is 1,500 mg/l as per IS:2296
Total hardness was found to be 100-110 mg/l.
Nitrate was found 1.16-1.20 mg/l.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
60
Total Coliform in water was 350-500 MPN/100ml. The likely source of bacteriological
contamination may be due to the proximity to residential area
All the heavy metals were not detectable.
Whether the site falls near to the polluted stretch of river identified by the
CPCB/MoEFCC:
The proposed project falls at a distance of 9 km from Satluj river. The Satluj river is not
identifies as the polluted river stretched by CPCB.
Surface water quality results are summarized below (Ropar-Neelon Canal):
pH of the surface water collected ranged from 7.85 – 7.88
TDS was found to be 220- 224 mg/l. The tolerance limit is 1,500 mg/l as per IS:2296
Total hardness was found to be 160-166 mg/l.
Nitrate was found 1.32-1.36 mg/l.
Total Coliform in water was 300-330 MPN/100ml. The likely source of bacteriological
contamination may be due to the proximity to residential area
All the heavy metals were not detectable.
Whether the site falls near to the polluted stretch of river identified by the
CPCB/MoEFCC:
The proposed project falls at a distance of 4.2 km from Ropar Neelon Canal. The Ropar
Neelon Canal is not identifies as the polluted river stretched by CPCB.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
61
3.5.2 Ground Water
Groundwater has been found as an important source for the local needs of water consumption
for various purposes, mainly domestic and agriculture. Keeping in view the importance of
groundwater to the local population, samples of ground water were collected from the study
area for the monitoring and assessment of groundwater quality.
Ground water can be said to be affected by activities such as uncontrolled discharge of
treated and/or untreated industrial effluent, open discharge of treated and/or untreated
sewerage in the surrounding area.
The Quality of ground water was studied by collecting 8 water samples from representative
hand pumps, tube wells. Sampling points were decided using Google imagery and field
survey. Standard procedures were followed for the sampling and analysis of physico–
chemical parameters of water.
The sampling sites were selected considering the following criteria –
1. Topography of the study area Pattern.
2. Areas which may be affected due to the activity.
3. Any probable locations with open discharge of sewage or waste water.
4. Location of any solid waste dumping facility in the vicinity of the project site.
Details of ground water locations is given in Table 3.8 . Ground water monitoring location is
provided in figure 3.10 and Results of ground water is given in Table 3.9.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
62
Table-3.8
Details of Ground Water Monitoring Stations
Name of Village/ Location
Distance from the Plant (Km)
Direction w.r.t. Plant
Justification for the Selection
GW-1 Project Site -- -- Represent the project site GW -2 Takhran
2 S Downwind direction of the project
site. This station’s GW data captures the
baseline for residential area. GW -3 Macchiwara 4.8 E Crosswind direction of the project
site. This station’s GW data captures the
baseline for residential and Industrial area.
GW -4 Mughlewal 8.4 N Upwind direction of the project site.
This station’s GW data captures the baseline for residential and Industrial area. And located in vicinity of the project site.
GW -5 Ratangarh 7.01 NW Upwind direction of the project site. This station’s GW data captures the
baseline for residential area GW -6 Partapgarh 6 W Crosswind direction of the project
site. This station’s GW data captures the
baseline for residential area. GW -7 Katani Kalan
8.1 S Downwind direction of the project
site. This station’s GW data captures the
baseline for residential area
GW -8 Haron Kalan 8.3 SE Downwind direction of the project site.
Further, this station’s GW data captures the baseline for residential
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
63
Figure -3.10 Ground water monitoring Locations
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
64
Table – 3.9 Results of Ground Water Samples
Parameters Unit GW1 GW2 GW3 GW4 GW5 GW6 GW7 GW8 * Limits pH - 7.61 7.42 7.33 7.58 7.62 7.34 7.51 7.48 6.5-8.5
Colour Hazen <5 <5 <5 <5 <5 <5 <5 <5 5.0 Odour Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable Agreeable
Turbidity NTU <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 <1 1.0 Total Dissolved Solids mg/l 324 326 320 332 314 338 340 342 500 Total Hardness as
CaCO3 mg/l 260 272 282 275 290 284 292 285 200
Calcium as Ca mg/l 58.2 56.6 58.4 54.6 56.4 57.6 54.8 55.7 75 Magnesium as Mg mg/l 18.4 20.2 24.8 26.3 22.7 27.1 23.8 21.8 30
Total alkalinity mg/l 280 260 272 260 285 281 272 280 200 Chlorides as Cl- mg/l 14.9 19.9 16.2 10.2 12.4 16.3 16.9 14.9 250
Sulphates as SO4 mg/l 12.4 16.2 10.6 16.8 14.3 12.4 14.6 10.9 200 Nitrate as NO3 mg/l 1.8 1.6 1.0 1.4 1.3 1.6 1.4 1.2 45
Total residual chlorine as Cl2
mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 1.0
Iron mg/l 0.14 0.1 0.1 0.18 0.14 0.1 0.1 0.1 1.5 Fluoride mg/l 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.1 1.2 1.4 1.0 1.1 5.0
Zinc mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 0.1 Manganese mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 0.003 Cadmium mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 0.05
Total Chromium mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 0.001 Mercury mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND 0.01
Selenium as Se mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND shall not be detectable in any of 100ml sample
Total Coliforms per 100 ml
<2 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 shall not be detectable in any of 100ml sample
E – Coli per 100 ml
Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent Absent
* As per IS:10500: 2012 acceptable limits
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
65
Observation And Analysis:
The Results above shows that the pH of all the ground water samples was within the
prescribed standards following in the range of 7.34-7.62.
The concentration of heavy metals like Total Chromium, Mercury, Selenium, and Cadmium
were not detected. Along with that Iron, Zinc, Manganese, Fluoride were also found not
detected.
Total Hardness of the entire ground water samples were found to be 260-292mg/l which is
exceeding acceptable limit but below permissible limit at all location, on the other hand,
concentration of Total Dissolved Solids ranged between 314-342 mg/l which demonstrate
all the ground water location may less contaminated from anthropogenic activity.
3.5.3 Rain Water Harvesting
The north western and south western part of the district where water level decline exits,
artificial recharge structures may help in arresting this water level decline. Generally
Recharge Trench with injection well structure is suitable for artificial recharge. Water
conservation methods like change in cropping pattern, change in Irrigation policy, timely
plantation of paddy, promotion of sprinkler and drip irrigation etc. may be adopted to
overcome the ground water decline in the area. Rooftop rain water harvesting can be adopted
in all buildings of the district.
Due to declining of water levels in the area, rainwater harvesting and artificial recharge to
groundwater is feasible in whole of the Ludhiana district. Types of recharge structures
suitable are; Trenches and injection wells. Injection wells of 40 to 60 m depth can be
constructed depending upon the local hydro geological conditions.
The trenches of three meter depth be constructed and filled with inverted filter material up to
2m of depth, remaining one meter of depth will be kept as free board which acts as storage of
storm water. The trench serves dual purpose of storing the excess water and filtering the
suspended particles / silt. For construction of recharge well borehole of 450mm (18”) dia is to
be got drilled with the Reverse Rotary method of drilling. In case sufficient space is not
available in areas close to buildings, the drilling may be taken up with hand boring and dia of
borehole should be 10”. Recharge well assembly of 6” dia should be lowered into the
borehole. The annular space between the assembly and borehole is to be filled with gravel of
3-5 mm size. The aquifers zones to be recharged should be screened by PVC/M.S. slotted
pipes. Within the trench two PVC/M.S. slotted pipes having 3 mm slot size are to be fixed on
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
66
either side of the 6” dia. pipe for filtered water to enter into the recharge well. Only aquifers
encountered at the bottom of borehole should be screened. After construction of trench cum
recharge well, the channelized water is to be connected with the recharge structures through
R.C.C. or M.S. pipes. Typical Rain Water Harvesting Pit Design is provided as below.
Typical Rain Water Harvesting Pit Design
Conclusion
The depth to water level in the area ranges between 9-26 m bgl. In the north eastern part’
Machhiwara’ block area it ranges between 5-10 m bgl and 10- 20 m in north central part
of the district in Ludhiana city and Bhaini raian . In rest of the area of the district it
ranges between 20-30 meters.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
67
3.6 Noise Environment
Noise is one of the most undesirable and unwanted by-products of our modern life style. It
may not seem as insidious or harmful as air and water pollutants but it affects human health
and wellbeing and can contribute to deterioration of human well-being in general and cause
neurological disturbances and physiological damage to the hearing mechanism in particular.
It is therefore, necessary to measure both the quality as well as the quantity of noise in and
around the site.
Methodology
The intensity of sound energy in the environment is measured in a logarithmic scale and is
expressed in a decibel, dB (A) scale. In a sophisticated type of sound level meter, an
additional circuit (filters) is provided, which modifies the received signal in such a way that
it replicates the sound signal as received by the human ear and the magnitude of sound level
in this scale is denoted as dB (A). The sound levels are expressed in dB (A) scale for the
purpose of comparison of noise levels, which is universally accepted by the international
community.
The day noise levels have been monitored during 6.00 am to 10.00 pm and night noise
levels, during 10.00 pm to 6.00 am at all the 8 locations, which covers residential areas,
commercial area, industrial area and silence zone within 10 km radius of the study area.
Sampling Locations
A preliminary survey was undertaken to identify the major noise generating sources in the
area. The noise survey was conducted to assess the background noise levels in different
zones. Gazettes Notification {S.O. 123(E)} of MoEF&CC dated February 14, 2000 on
ambient air quality standards has different noise levels for different zones viz industrial,
commercial, and residential and silence zones. Eight sampling locations were selected for the
sampling of noise levels.
Noise levels recorded at each station are computed for Equivalent noise levels. Equivalent
noise level is a single number descriptor for describing time varying noise levels. Details of
Noise monitoring locations is given at Table no. 3.10. Noise monitoring station in Topo
sheet is given in Figure 3.11. Details of Noise is provided in Table 3.11.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
68
Table 3.10
Details of Noise Monitoring Stations
Name of Village/ Location
Distance from the Plant (Km)
Direction w.r.t. Plant
Justification for the Selection
NQ-1 Project Site -- -- Represent the project site NQ -2 Takhran
2 S Downwind direction of the project
site. This station’s noise data captures the
baseline for residential area. NQ -3 Macchiwara 4.8 E Crosswind direction of the project
site.
This station’s noise data captures the baseline for residential and Industrial area.
NQ -4 Mughlewal 8.4 N Upwind direction of the project site.
This station’s noise data captures the baseline for residential and Industrial area. And located in vicinity of the project site.
NQ -5 Ratangarh 7.01 NW Upwind direction of the project site.
This station’s noise data captures the baseline for residential area
NQ -6 Partapgarh 6 W Crosswind direction of the project site.
This station’s noise data captures the baseline for residential area.
NQ -7 Katani Kalan
8.1 S Downwind direction of the project site.
This station’s noise data captures the baseline for residential area
NQ -8 Haron Kalan 8.3 SE Downwind direction of the project site.
Further, this station’s noise data captures the baseline for residential
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
69
Figure -3.11 Noise Monitoring Locations
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
70
Table 3.11
Noise Level Results Leq dB (A) in and Around Project Area
Sr. No. Location No. Day Time Night Time
1. Project Site 70.2 61.5
2. Takhran 59.5 40.3
3. Macchiwara 46.5 34.7
4. Mughlewal 44.7 36.3
5. Ratangarh 46.5 37.4
6. Partapgarh 48.6 36.5
7. Katani Kalan 49.5 41.5
8. Haron Kalan 48.3 37.5
Table 3.12
Noise Standards (Source-CPCB)
Area
Code Category of Area
Noise dB(A) Leq
Day Time
(6.0 am-10 pm)
Night Time
(10.0 pm-6.0 am)
A Industrial Area 75 70
B Commercial Area 65 55
C Residential Area 55 45
D Silence Zone 50 40
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
71
Interpretation
Industrial zone
The day time noise level at the project premises was observed as 70.2 dB (A), and during night
time the noise level was recorded to be 61.5 dB (A). It should be noted that the noise levels
during the day time as well as night time were estimated to be under the prescribed standards by
Central Pollution Control Board.
Residential zone
The noise monitoring at residential zone was conducted at two locations- Ratangarh and
Partapgarh, once in a season. The maximum noise level recorded during the day time and night
in location namely Talanian. Vehicular movement of nearby road is the main reason behind it.
All the monitored noise level is under CPCB standard.
Commercial zone
The noise monitoring at commercial zone was conducted at one location- Machhiwara once in a
season. It is observed that the permissible limit for noise level did not exceed anytime.
Silence zone
The noise monitoring at silence zone was conducted at four locations-, Mughlewal, Katani kalan,
Haron Kalan once in a season. It should be interpretated that the permissible limit for noise level
did not exceed at any of the locations selected for sampling.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
72
3.7 Soil Quality
Physical characteristics
Soil is generally considered as the upper layer of the earth that is dug or ploughed, especially
the loose material in which plants grow. It is generally unconsolidated material composed of
soil particles produced by disintegration of rocks. The void spaces between the particles may
contain Air, Water or both.
Physical characteristics of soil influence its use and behavior towards plants growth. The plant
support, root penetration, drainage, aeration, retention of moisture & plant nutrients is linked
with the physical condition of soils. Normally following physical parameters are important for
determining the quality of soil:-
(i) Texture
(ii) Porosity
(iii) Bulk density
i. Texture
On the basis of texture the study area may be classified as loamy sand, sandy loam and silty
loam.
ii. Porosity
Volume of soil mass that is not occupied by soil particles and usually occupied by air &
water are known as pore space. The plant roots grow & exist in the pore spaces. Porosity,
therefore, refers to that percentage of soil volume which is occupied by pore spaces.
iii. Bulk Density
The bulk density weight of a unit of volume of soil inclusive of pore spaces is called bulk
density. Generally the soil with low bulk density has favorable physical conditions.
The locations for collection of representative sample were selected considering - .
1. From different types of land uses in the study area.
2. From possible polluted & comparatively controlled locations in the study area
3. From the leeward and downward of the predominant wind direction
Locations of soil monitoring stations are given in Table 3.13. Soil monitoring stations on
toposheet is given in Fig 3.12. Soil Sample results are attached as Table 3.14.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
73
Table 3.13
Detail list of Soil Quality Monitoring Stations
Name of Village/ Location
Distance from the Plant (Km)
Direction w.r.t. Plant
Justification for the Selection
SQ-1 Project Site -- -- Represent the project site SQ -2 Takhran
2 S Downwind direction of the project
site. This station’s soil data captures the
baseline for residential area. SQ -3 Macchiwara 4.8 E Crosswind direction of the project
site. This station’s soil data captures the
baseline for residential and Industrial area.
SQ -4 Mughlewal 8.4 N Upwind direction of the project site.
This station’s soil data captures the baseline for residential and Industrial area. And located in vicinity of the project site.
SQ -5 Ratangarh 7.01 NW Upwind direction of the project site. This station’s soil data captures the
baseline for residential area SQ -6 Partapgarh 6 W Crosswind direction of the project
site. This station’s soil data captures the
baseline for residential area. SQ -7 Katani Kalan
8.1 S Downwind direction of the project
site. This station’s soil data captures the
baseline for residential area
SQ -8 Haron Kalan 8.3 SE Downwind direction of the project site.
Further, this station’s soil data captures the baseline for residential
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
74
Figure -3.12
Location of Soil Monitoring Stations
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
75
Table –3.14
Result of Soil Samples (% W/W except pH)
S.No. Parameter Unit SQ1 SQ2 SQ3 SQ4 SQ5 SQ6 SQ7 SQ8 Test Methods
1. pH (1:2.5) -- 7.85 7.62 7.72 7.56 7.66 7.78 7.66 7.82 IS 2720(P-26),1987 2. Electrical Conductivity (1:2) µmhos/cm 356 364 352 358 372 388 374 368 IS 14767,2000 3. Texture -- Sandy
Clay Sandy Clay Sandy
Clay Sandy Clay Sandy
Clay Sandy Clay Sandy Clay Sandy Clay CPTL, Lab SOP No. 49
4. Bulk Density (gm/cc) 1.25 1.28 1.27 1.32 1.44 1.26 1.39 1.44 IS 2720(P-3),1983 6. Color/ Visual Observation -- Brown Light
Brown Brown Dark Brown Brown Very Light
Brown Brown Brown Handbook of Agriculture,
ICAR 7. Available Calcium (mg/kg) 118 124 138 126 124 140 135 122 Handbook of Agriculture
,ICAR 8. Available Magnesium (mg/kg) 52.4 54.3 48.2 56.8 51.4 56.3 54.2 51.8 Handbook of Agriculture,
ICAR 9. Available Sodium (mg/kg) 42.2 46.1 48.3 38.6 42.2 44.6 48.3 42.4 IS9497-1980RA-1998 10. Available Potassium (kg/hectare) 25.4 26.2 30.2 24.6 22.4 27.3 30.1 24.3 IS9497-1980RA-1998 11. Available Nitrogen (kg/hectare) 1.46 1.68 1.34 1.84 1.66 1.54 1.43 1.58 CPTL, Lab SOP No. 53
12. Organic Carbon (%) 1.06 1.11 1.02 1.09 1.02 1.14 1.07 1.09 IS 2720(P-22),2001 13. Available Phosphorus Kg/hac 1.98 1.82 2.04 1.84 1.96 1.99 2.04 1.74 CPTL, Lab SOP No. 51 14. Cation Exchange Capacity (meq/100gm) 1.06 0.94 0.82 0.81 1.01 0.96 0.99 1.12 Handbook of Agriculture,
ICAR 15. Iron as Fe (mg/kg) 1.74 1.68 1.72 1.66 1.58 1.77 1.82 1.79 CPTL, Lab SOP No. 54 16. Zinc as Zn (mg/kg) ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND CPTL, Lab SOP No. 54 17. Lead as Pb (mg/kg) ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND CPTL, Lab SOP No. 54 18. Manganese as Mn (mg/kg) ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND CPTL, Lab SOP No. 54
19. Chromium as Cr (mg/kg) ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND CPTL, Lab SOP No. 54 20. Cadmium as Cd (mg/kg) ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND CPTL, Lab SOP No. 54 21. Copper as Cu (mg/kg) ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND CPTL, Lab SOP No. 54 22. Permeability cm/hr 1.7 1.5 1.8 1.9 2.2 1.6 1.5 1.9 Is:2720-(p-17)-1986[RA-2002] 24. Porosity (%) 28 29 32 36 38 40 31 33 Is:2720-(p-15)-1986[RA-2002] 25. Water Holding Capacity (%) 22.3 16.4 11.3 18.2 20.1 15.4 14.2 16.1 Is14765:2000
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
76
3.7.1 Conclusion
The analytical results of the soil samples collected during the study period are summarized
below.
The pH of the soil is an important property; vegetation cannot grow in low and high pH value
soils. The normal range of pH in the soils is 6.0 to 8.5. The pH values in the study area are
varying from 7.56-7.85 indicating that the soils are falling in slightly alkaline to moderately
alkaline.
Based on the electrical conductivity, the soils are classified into four groups (Normal, Critical
for germination, Critical for growth of the sensitive crops, Injurious to most crops). The
electrical conductivity in the study area is varying from 352-388 µmhos/cm. This is good for
germination.
The other important parameters for characterization of soil for irrigation are the primary
nutrients – Nitrogen, Phosphorus and Potassium (N, P, K) and the secondary nutrients—
Calcium, Magnesium and Sulphur (Ca, Mg, S). The primary and secondary nutrient elements
are known as major elements. This classification is based on their relative abundance, and not
on their relative importance.
Nitrogen encourages the vegetative development of plants by imparting a healthy green color
to the leaves. The available Nitrogen as N in the study area is varying from 1.34 to 1.84%.
Phosphorus influences the vigor of plants and improves the quality of crops. In the study area
available, Phosphorus was found in varying quantities of 1.74-2.04 kg/ha.
Potassium enhances the ability of the plants to resist diseases, insect attacks, cold and other
adverse conditions. The available potassium in the study area varies between 22.4-30.2
Kg/hac. This is deficient for crops.
As per physical data, the soils in the study area are coarse to modularity fine texture, having
modulated build density and impressively modulate water holding capacity. As per physical
characteristics, the soils are rated as moderately to good for agriculture. Based on the
observation during field visit of 10km buffer zone from the boundry of cement plant, the soils
are sandy loam predominantly. These soils can be classified as modularity good soil with
traces or gentle slopes and is modulate land for sustained agriculture as per USDA.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
77
3.7.2 Geomorphology and Soil types
The district area is occupied by Indo-Gangetic alluvium. And there are no surface features
worth to mention except that area is plain and major drains are Satluj and its tributaries and
Budha nala.
Soil is the end product of the parent material resulting from the consistent influence of
climate, topography and the natural vegetation over a long period of time. In the district soil
characteristics are influenced to a very limited extent by the topography, vegetation and
parent rock. The variations in soil profile characteristics are much more pronounced because
of the regional climatic differences. The soil of this zone has developed under semi-arid
condition. The soil is sandy loam to clayey with normal reaction (pH from 7.8 to 8.5).
Hydrogeology
Ludhiana district falls in central part of Punjab. The district is bounded between North
latitude 300 33/ and 310 01/ and East longitude 750 25/ and 760 27/. The Satluj forms the
border of the district in the North with Jalandhar and Hoshiarpur districts. Ropar and
Fatehgarhsahib districts mark the eastern and south eastern boundaries. The western border is
adjoining Moga and Ferozpur districts. The geographical area of the district is 3790 sq.kms.
Administratively Ludhiana district falls under Patiala division. The district has four sub-
divisions viz-Ludhiana, Khanna, Samrala and Jagraon and eleven development blocks viz.-
Ludhiana, Mangat, Doraha, Khanna, Dehlon, Pokhwal , Samrala , Machhiwara, Jagraon,
Sidhwanbet and Sudhar.
The district area is occupied by Indo-Gangatic alluvium of Quaternary age. The subsurface
geological formations of the area comprise of sand, silt, clay and kankar in various
proportions. In general the Ground water of the district is fresh except in and around
Ludhiana city where the ground water is polluted due to industrial effluents. The aquifer
disposition of the area is revealed by drilling data carried out down to 408 m by Central
Ground Water Board and state govt. The lithological data of these boreholes indicate the
presence of many sand beds forming the principal aquifers separated by clay beds at various
depths.
Drainage map of study area is given in Figure 3.13.. Depth to water level- Pre monsoon and
post- monsoon is given at Figure 3.14 and 3.15 respectively.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
78
Figure 3.13: Drainage map of the study area
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
79
Figure 3.14: Depth to Water Level – Pre-Monsoon
Source: cgwb.gov.in/District_Profile/Punjab/Ludhiana.pdf
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
80
Figure 3.15: Depth to Water Level – Post-Monsoon
Source: cgwb.gov.in/District_Profile/Punjab/Ludhiana.pdf
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
81
3.8 Land Environment
The objective of assessing the land use details of the area is to know the existing land use
pattern of the area and enable one to know about the land that can be used for the proposed
development activities in the study area. It also enables to envisage the scenario emerging due
to the increase in demand for land with increase in population and the impacts arising due to the
interface with the various project activities.
a) Geographical location of the study area
The study area comprises 10km around the project site. The study area is falling in 53B/2 and
53 B/6 of Survey of India Topographic sheet.
b) Data Collection and Quality Assurance
Satellite data
The Indian Remote Sensing satellite data LANDSAT-8 is being used for the analysis of Land
Use and Land Cover around 10 Km of the study area.
c) Methodology
The land use / land cover map is prepared by adopting the interpretation techniques of the
image in conjunction with collateral data such as Survey of India topographical maps and
census records. Image classification has been done by using visual interpretation techniques and
digital classification using ERDAS image processing 10.0 software and ARC/GIS 10.0
software. The various activities for preparation of LULC include preprocessing, rectification,
enhancements and classifying the satellite data for assessing the change in land use land cover
due to proposed developmental activities.
The imagery is interpreted and ground checked for corrections. The final map is prepared after
field check. The different land use/land cover categories in the study area has been carried out
based on the NRSC land use / land cover classification system.
Flowchart showing the methodology adopted for land use/land cover mapping is provided as Fig 3.16.
Land Use / Land Cover Study
The land use land cover study has been done through digital image processing and visual
interpretation technique to generate output of Land use / Land cover map of study area on
1:50,000 scale. Land Use / Land Cover Map of Study Area (10 Km Buffer) Fig 3.17 and a 10
Km radius False Color Composite satellite map surrounding the project site is provided in Fig
3.18.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
82
Fig 3.16: Flowchart showing the methodology adopted for land use/land cover mapping
Table 3.15
Land Use/Land Cover Area Statistics
Land Use/Land Cover Area (Ha) Area Percentage
Built-Up Land 789.95 2.41
Agricultural Land 8914.32 27.22
Agricultural Fallow Land 21845.9 66.71
Open Land 585.18 1.79
Water Bodies 612.9 1.87
Total Area 32746.25 100%
The study area comprises of agricultural land of about 8914.320 ha (27.229 %) including
agricultural fallow land 21845.9 ha (66.71%). Built up land in the study area cover an area of
789.95 ha 2.41%) approximately. The study area has open land of 585.18 (1.79%) distributed in
& around study area. Study area has 612.9 ha (1.87 %) of water bodies. The land cover pattern
and the respective coverage are given in Table 3.15 above.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
83
Conclusion & Discussion
Based on the perusal of field visit and interaction with framers, it is seen that over the period of
time variants of fruits, vegetable and fodder have been successfully grown in the study area are
indicator of healthy & conducive land environment.
3.8.1 Industries within study area (10km radius)
Bhagwanpura is a village located in east Ludhiana. Ludhiana is often known as Manchester of
India and Industrial Capital of small scale industries. A list of Industries within 10 Km radius
along with the distance and direction of the Project site is provided at Table 3.16
Table 3.16 List of Industries within study area (10km radius)
S.No. Name of Industries Type of Industries Distance and
Direction
1. M/s Renny Strips Pvt. Ltd. Steel 5km, SE
2. M/s Renny Strips Pvt. Ltd.
(Furnace Division)
Steel 5km, SE
3. Cheema Readymade Textile 300m, S
4. Malwa Industries Limited Textile 315m, W
5. Shiva Texs Fabs Limited Unit-I Textile 500M, S
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
84
Fig 3.17: Land Use / Land Cover Map of Study Area (10 Km Buffer)
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division
(QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
85
Fig 3.18: 10 Km radius False Color Composite Satellite Map
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
86
3.9 Biological Environment
A natural ecosystem is a structural and functional unit of nature. It has different biological
and physical components, which are interrelated to each other and survive by
interdependence. An ecosystem has self sustaining ability and controls the number of
organisms at any level by cybernetic rules. The basic purpose to explore the biological
environment under Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is to assist the decision making
process and to ensure that the project options under consideration are environmental-friendly.
An ecological survey of the study area was conducted, particularly with reference to listing of
species and assessment of the existing baseline ecological conditions in the study area. The
main objectives of the ecological survey were aimed at assessing the existing flora and fauna
components in the study area, to understand the possible impacts on the biological
environment caused by the proposed project activities, and to formulate if necessary the
appropriate mitigation/preventive measures for such impacts. Data has been collected through
secondary sources and by site visits.
The present study was carried out in two separate headings for floral and faunal community.
The aspects to be covered in the study for the project are given in Table 3.17
Table-3.17
Aspect to be covered in the study Area
Aspect of Environment Impacts
A. Terrestrial Ecology Impacts on terrestrial flora and fauna
Impacts on Rare-Endangered-Threatened (RET) wildlife
Impacts on socially/ economically/ genetically/ biologically
important species
B. Aquatic Ecology Impacts on aquatic fauna/flora
Impacts on spawning and breeding grounds for aquatic species
The information presented in this Chapter has been collected through field studies,
consultation with various government departments and collation of available literature with
various institutions and organizations. The summary of data collected from these sources as a
part of the EIA study is outlined in Table 3.18
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
87
Table-3.18
Summary of Data Collected from various sources
Aspect Mode of data
collection
Parameters Monitored Frequency Source(s)
Terrestrial
Ecology
Primary field survey
and secondary
literature survey
Floral and Faunal
Diversity and Their
Importance
One Season
(Winter)
Field studies,
Forest & wild life
Department and
literature review
Aquatic
Ecology
Primary field survey
and secondary
literature survey
Diversity of Species and
Their Importance
One Season
(Winter)
Field studies,
Forest/ wild life
Department and
literature review
With the change in environmental conditions, the vegetation cover as well as animals reflects
several changes in its structure, density and composition. The present study was carried out
separately for floral and faunal community respectively.
Sampling
For field assessment, i.e., primary data collection, a standard statistical sampling method was
followed. The sampling design followed random sampling method. The sampling area was
decided based on prior land-use map of the project influence zone (within the 10 km radius
around the project area), outlining forest areas and other types of habitats, topographic
features and build-up area.
Flora
Methodology for floral study
1. Secondary literature survey: Published literature, including those from relevant
organizations like the Botanical Survey of India (BSI), the Wildlife Institute of India
(WII-Dehradun), the respective Forest Department of the State concerned etc., research
papers, articles, books and reliable websites, available within and adjacent to the study
.area were compiled and inventoried as “Secondary Floral Diversity Database”.
2. Primary field survey – herbs: Herbaceous plants were studied using the quadrat method
as followed during vegetation survey. The size of each quadrat for herb survey was 1m x
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
88
1m. Field identification of the species and later identification through photographs were
followed. Unidentified herbs were collected following proper procedure and prepared
into herbarium sheets for later identification. For mosses, lichens and other plants the
plot size was taken as 0.1m x 0.1m.
3. Primary field survey – shrubs: Shrubs were studied using the quadrat method as followed
during vegetation survey. The size of each quadrat for shrub survey was 5m x 5m for
shrubs of 3m height. Field identification of the species and later identification through
photographs were followed. Unidentified shrubs were collected following proper
procedure and prepared into herbarium sheets for later identification.
4. Primary field survey – trees: Trees were studied using the quadrat method as followed
during vegetation survey. The size of each quadrat for tree survey was 20m x 20m. Field
identification of the species and later identification through photographs were followed.
Samples of unidentified trees were collected following proper procedure and prepared
into herbarium sheets for later identification.
5. Primary database: Data generated from the field survey within and adjacent to the study
area were meticulously compiled and inventoried as “Primary Floral Diversity
Database”.
6. Field instruments/materials for floral study: Measuring tape/s, herbarium sheets,
newspaper, herbarium press, polythene bags (incl. zip-locked pouches), 88clinometers,
and magnifying glass, camera, and GPS unit.
Table-3.19 Results of floral study
Common Name Scientific Name Herbs
Yam Dioscorea spp. Bathua Chenopodium album Carrot grass Parthenium hysterophorus Black nightshade Solanum nigrum Amaranth Amaranthus spp. Durva/Doob grass Cynodon dactylon
Shrubs Castor Ricinus communis Kasaundi Senna sophera Oleander Nerium oleander China rose Hibiscus rosa-sinensis
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
89
Pomegranate Punica granatum Euphorbia Euphorbia sp. Wild sage/Lantana Lantana camara Tora Senna tora Crape jasmine/Tagar Tabernaemontana divaricata
Trees Khejri Prosopis cineraria Indian gooseberry/Amla Phyllanthus emblica Indian lilac Melia azedarach White mulberry Morus alba Kikkar Vachellia karoo Jujube Ziziphus jujube Mango Mangifera indica Sacred fig/Peepal Ficus religiosa Banyan Ficus benghalensis Jamun Syzygium cumini Devil tree/Saptaparni Alstonia scholaris Fishtail palm Caryota urens Banana Musa paradisiacal Guava Psidium guajava North Indian rosewood Dalbergia sissoo Teak Tectona grandis Catechu/Khair Senegalia catechu Indian elm/Chilbil Holoptelea integrifolia Poplar Populus alba Mahogany Swietenia mahagoni Medlar/Bakul Mimusops elengi Devdaaru Polyalthia longifolia Blue jacaranda Jacaranda mimosifolia Silver oak Grevillea robusta Amaltas Cassia fistula Arjun Terminalia arjuna Eucalyptus Eucalyptus globules Lebbeck Albizia lebbeck
Fauna
Methodology for faunal study
1. Secondary literature survey: Published literature, including those from relevant
organizations like the Zoological Survey of India (ZSI), the Wildlife Institute of India
(WII-Dehradun), the Forest Department of the State, research papers, articles, books and
reliable websites, available within and adjacent to the study area were meticulously
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
90
compiled and inventoried as “Secondary Faunal Diversity Database”.
2. Primary field survey – birds: For avian diversity assessment, point count method was
used. The radius of each of the point was 50 m. Birds were identified on-site using field-
books, or later through photographs and field-sketches.
3. Primary field survey – mammals: For mammalian diversity assessment, direct
observations was done on the field. Field identification of species was done on-site and
through photographs/sketches and with the help of field-books/other reliable sources.
4. Primary field survey – amphibians and reptilians: Direct observation and indirect
evidence/sign survey were done for assessing amphibian and reptilian diversity in the
field site. Identification of species was done on-site or through photographs/sketches and
with the help of field-books or other reliable sources.
5. Primary database: Data generated from the field survey within and adjacent to the study
area was meticulously compiled and inventoried as “Primary Faunal Diversity
Database”.
6. Field instruments/materials for faunal study: Range-finder, compass, binoculars, camera,
slide-calipers, measuring tape, GPS unit, polythene bags (incl. zip-lock pouches), and
field-books.
Table 3.20
Results of Faunal Study
Bird diversity
Common Name Scientific Name Asian pied starling Gracupica contra Bank myna Acridotheres ginginianus Black drongo Dicrurus macrocercus Black winged stilt Himantopus himantopus
Cattle egret Bubulcus ibis
Common hoopoe Upupa epops Common myna Acridotheres tristis Eurasian collared dove Streptopelia decaocto House crow Corvus splendens House sparrow Passer domesticus Paddyfield pipit Anthus rufulus Red vented bulbul Pycnonotus cafer Red wattled lapwing Vanellus indicus
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
91
Rock pigeon Columba livia Rose ringed parakeet Psittacula krameri Rufous treepie Dendrocitta vagabunda White browed wagtail Motacilla maderaspatensis
White throated kingfisher Halcyon smyrnensis White wagtail Motacilla alba
Mammals (Mammalia): Nilgai, Wild Boar, Jungle cat, Jackal, Mongoose, Palm squirrel,
Hares, Rats, Mice, Rhesus Macaque, Flying fox, Fruit bats, Porcupine etc. are also present in
the area.
Reptilea (Lizards, Snakes, Turtles, etc.): Garden lizard, Northern house gecko, Monitor
lizard, spectacled cobra, Rat Snake, Black krait and Wolf snake.
Aquatic faunal diversity: The area is devoid of major water-bodies, thus may not support a
considerable aquatic faunal diversity.
Biological diversity indices:
Shannon Mean 2.73
Simpson Inv. Mean 11.84
Conclusion
About 25% of secondary steel industry of India is based at metallurgical & secondary area.
The area is plain & devoid of forest cover due to massive industrialization and agricultural
intensity. Further there are no natural water bodies. As such the area can’t support floral and
faunal diversity except the already existing meager population of their species. However
biodiversity change may be anticipated due to anthropogenic perturbations such as pollution,
cattle grazing and invasive species etc.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
92
3.10 Socioeconomic Environment Introduction
Modern day cities have complex structure comprising of numerous & intertwined/
interwoven relationships due to which town planning judgments cannot be merely treated as
technical-oriented as they affect the lives and interests of the whole community. In the
present context, the slogan “ Planning by the people and Planning for the people “ exhibits a
shifts from Physical design oriented basic concept of town planning to more of a socially
relevant and sensitive model of town Planning encompassing socio-economic richness and
viability of existing communities.
The economic sectors i.e. primary, secondary and tertiary form the economic base of the
town. Nothing can hamper the physical growth/ development of an area more than the
economic incompetence. The identity of a town depends upon the character of its population.
Demographic profile determines the demographic character of the town area in terms of
population, growth rate, density, literary rate etc. which further helps in determining the
social as well as the economic character of the area. The natural population growth has
special significance because it is a vital index of economic development, social awakening,
historical and cultural background of the town.
Therefore, the study of socio-economic and demographic factors plays an important role in
defining the character of a town as well as the urban limits of a town/city. The following
studies related to socio-economic and demographic factors for study area mainly village
Alour have been conducted to know the socio-economic and demographic character.
Methodology applied for selection of sample & data collection
The methodology which is applied for primary source of data collection i.e. gathering data
through field survey for socio- economic environment is depicted below:
A. Sampling Method
A judgmental and purposive sampling method was used for choosing respondents of various
sections of the society i.e. Sarpanch, Adult Males and Females, Teachers, Medical
Practitioners, Businessmen, Agriculture labourers, Unemployed Group etc. Judgmental and
purposive sampling methods were adopted to assess the total population that helps to fulfill
the purpose of research needs.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
93
B. Data Collection Method
For the process of data collection through primary source certain methods were used,
amongst that are:
i. Field Survey and Observations
Field survey and observations were made in nearby sampling village and the socioeconomic
status of that region was studied. Visits are made at Health Centers, Schools, Gurudwaras,
Panchayat office etc.
ii. Interview Method
Structured interview method was used to collect data regarding the awareness and opinion
from the samples selected of the various socio- economic sections of the community.
Structured interviews involve the use of a set of predetermined projected questions that
includes fixed and alternative questions. The questionnaire mainly highlights the parameters
such as income, employment and working conditions, housing, food, water supply, sanitation,
health, energy, transportation and communication, education, environment and pollution to
assess the standard of living of that particular region and general awareness, opinion and
expectation of the respondents about the proposed project. Interview method helps to collect
more correct and accurate information as the interviewer is present during the field survey.
Socio- economic survey was conducted in nearby villages of the project area.
Ludhiana District
In 2011, Ludhiana had population of 3,498,739 of which male and female were 1,867,816
and 1,630,923 respectively. In 2001 census, Ludhiana had a population of 3,032,831 of which
males were 1,662,716 and remaining 1,370,115 were females. Ludhiana District population
constituted 12.61 percent of total Maharashtra population. In 2001 census, this figure for
Ludhiana District was at 12.45 percent of Maharashtra population.
There was change of 15.36 percent in the population compared to population as per 2001. In
the previous census of India 2001, Ludhiana District recorded increase of 24.89 percent to its
population compared to 1991.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
94
Source: Fatehgarh Sahib District Census-2011 Ludhiana District Density
The initial provisional data released by census India 2011, shows that density of Ludhiana
district for 2011 is 978 people per sq. km. In 2001, Ludhiana district density was at 848
people per sq. km. Ludhiana district administers 3,578 square kilometers of areas.
Description 2011 2001
34.99 Lakhs 30.33 Lakhs
Actual population 3,498,739 3,032,831
Male 1,867,861 1,662,716
Female 1,630,923 1,370,115
Population Growth 15.36% 24.89%
Area Sq.Km 3,578 3,578
Density/km2 978 848
Proportion to Punjab Population 12.61% 12.45%
Sex ratio (per 1000) 873 824
Child Sex Ration (0-6 Age) 860 817
Average Literacy 82.20 76.50
Male Literacy 85.98 80.30
Female Literacy 77.88 71.90
Total Child Population (0-6 Age) 384,114 0
Male population (0-6 Age) 206,502 0
Female population (0-6 Age) 177,612 0
Literates 2,560,225 0
Male literates 1,428,348 0
Female Literates 1,131,877 0
Child proportion (0-6 Age) 10.98% 0%
Boys proportion (0-6 Age) 11.06% 0%
Girls proportion (0-6 Age) 10.89% 0%
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
95
Literacy Rate
Average literacy rate of Ludhiana in 2011 were 82.20 compared to 76.50 of 2001. If things
are looked out at gender wise, male and female literacy were 85.98 and 77.88 respectively.
For 2001 census, same figures stood at 80.30 and 71.90 in Ludhiana District. Total literate in
Ludhiana District were 2,560,225 of which male and female were 1,428,348 and 1,131,877
respectively. In 2001, Ludhiana District had 0 in its district.
Ludhiana Sex Ratio
With regards to Sex Ratio in Ludhiana, it stood at 873 per 1000 male compared to 2001
census figure of 824. The average national sex ratio in India is 940 as per latest reports of
Census 2011 Directorate. In 2011 census, child sex ratio is 860 girls per 1000 boys compared
to figure of 817 girls per 1000 boys of 2001 census data.
Ludhiana Houseless Census
In 2011, total 1,135 families live on footpath or without any roof cover in Ludhiana district of
Punjab. Total Population of all who lived without roof at the time of Census 2011 numbers to
4,865. This approx 0.14% of total population of Ludhiana district.
Ludhiana Religion-wise Data
Description Total Percentage
Hindu 1,502,403 42.94%
Muslims 77,713 2.22%
Christian 16,517 0.47%
Sikh 1,863,408 53.26%
Buddhist 2,007 0.06%
Jain 19,620 0.56%
Others 1,254 0.04%
Not Stated 15,817 0.45%
Ludhiana District Urban/Rural
Out of the total Ludhiana population for 2011 census, 59.16 percent lives in urban regions of
district. In total 2,069,708 people lives in urban areas of which males are 1,114,372 and
females are 955,336. Sex Ratio in urban region of Ludhiana district is 857 as per 2011 census
data. Similarly child sex ratio in Ludhiana district was 860 in 2011 census. Child population
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
96
(0-6) in urban region was 235,144 of which males and females were 126,389 and 108,755.
This child population figure of Ludhiana district is 11.34 % of total urban population.
Average literacy rate in Ludhiana district as per census 2011 is 84.93 % of which males and
females are 88.16 % and 81.16 % literates respectively. In actual number 1,558,156 people
are literate in urban region of which males and females are 871,052 and 687,104 respectively.
As per 2011 census, 40.84 % population of Ludhiana districts lives in rural areas of villages.
The total Ludhiana district population living in rural areas is 1,429,031 of which males and
females are 753,444 and 675,587 respectively. In rural areas of Ludhiana district, sex ratio is
897 females per 1000 males. If child sex ratio data of Ludhiana district is considered, figure
is 859 girls per 1000 boys. Child population in the age 0-6 is 148,970 in rural areas of which
males were 80,113 and females were 68,857. The child population comprises 10.63 % of total
rural population of Ludhiana district. Literacy rate in rural areas of Ludhiana district is 78.28
% as per census data 2011. Gender wise, male and female literacy stood at 82.77 and 73.31
percent respectively. In total, 1,002,069 people were literate of which males and females
were 557,296 and 444,773 respectively.
Description Rural Urban Population (%) 40.84% 59.16%
Total Population 1,429,031 2,069,708 Male Population 753,444 1,114,372
Female Population 675,587 955,536 Sex Ratio 897 857
Child Sex Ratio (0-6) 859 860 Child Population (0-6) 148,970 235,144
Male Child (0-6) 80,113 126,389 Female Child (0-6) 68,857 108,755
Child Percentage (0-6) 10.42% 11.36% Male Child Percentage 10.63% 11.34%
Female Child Percentage 10.19% 11.38% Literates 1,002,069 1,558,156
Male Literates 557,296 871,052 Female Literates 444,773 687,104 Average Literacy 78.28% 84.93%
Male Literacy 82.77% 88.16% Female Literacy 73.31% 81.16%
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
97
3.11 Traffic Study
Traffic & Transportation is considered as an inevitable function of land use planning. Urban
transport is an integral part of urban planning because apart from defining the form of a town,
the smooth functioning and productivity of any urban centre clearly hinges on the efficacy of
traffic & transportation system. Since roads and streets or transport network are equated with
arteries/veins of human body whereas traffic on roads/streets is comparable to blood flowing,
so any blockage/obstruction in this system acts like clot in the blood invariably leading to
numerous complications.
During Operation
Proposed production capacity =830 TPD
Raw Material = 913 TPD
Total per Day = 1743 TPD
Capacity of Truck = 20 Ton
No. of Trucks/day = 17
No. of trips = 4
With the proposed expansion coming into being an estimated 17 trucks/day each performing
four trips per day will be added to the existing road network.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
98
It can be concluded that with unit operation there will be marginal change in the LOS but the
performance of the road will remain the same.
3.12 Slag Analysis
The furnace slag from the operating unit has been analyzed as per CPCB methods and the
following are the analytical results provided in Table 3.21:
Table 3.21 Slag Analysis
S.No. Parameters Result (mg/kg)
1. Cu 6
2. Cr 9
3. Ni 5
4. Pb 9
5. Mn 22
6. Zn 8
7. Hg <0.05
8. Cd 5.0
9. Sr 9
10. Co 6.4
11. As <0.1
A perusal of above analytical values reveals that the presence of heavy metals as highly
stable oxides is within the acceptable limits. Moreover slag is not characterized as HW under
the HWM rules. Columns Leachate study of slag has also been done as per CPCB methods
for metals that Leachate out from materials and the same has been found <0.1mg/kg (The
limits prescribed by USEPA) and therefore passes the TCLP test.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
99
CHAPTER 4.0
ANTICIPATED ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS & MITIGATION MEASURES
4.1 GENERAL
Prediction of impacts is the most important component in the Environmental Impact
Assessment studies. Several scientific techniques and methodologies are available to predict
impacts of developmental activities on physical, ecological and socio-economic
environments. Such predictions are superimposed over the baseline (pre-project) status of
environmental quality to derive the ultimate (post-project) scenario of environmental
conditions. The prediction of impacts helps to minimize the adverse impacts on
environmental quality during pre and post project execution. Generally, the environmental
impacts can be categorized as either primary or secondary. Primary impacts are those, which
are attributed directly by the project and secondary impacts are those, which are indirectly
induced and typically include the associated investment and changed patterns of social and
economic activities by the proposed actions.
The primary function of an environmental impact assessment is to assertion the potential
impacts of project on environmental components such as air, water, noise, soil, flora, fauna,
land and socio-economic and their magnitude during construction and operation for adoption
of satisfactory mitigation measure.
The Impacts of project are divided into two categories i.e. impacts of a project during
construction phase and impacts during operation phase. Major project impacts will occur
during operation phase as construction work will be done in staggered manner within a small
area and for short degradation.
Environmental parameters considered for impact analysis are:-
1. Landform and Topography
2. Air Environment
3. Water Environment
4. Noise Environment
5. Biological Environment
6. Socioeconomic Environment
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
100
4.2 CONSTRUCTION PHASE IMPACTS
Construction phase will include the installation of new machineries and its related work. As
the Construction process will occur under existing shed and small area there is a limited
chance of any major impact especially outside the industrial premises. Expected impacts and
mitigation measures are with respect to parameter of impact of the project on various
environmental factors as existing in the project area which possibly could be affected both
adversely and beneficially have been identified & assessed as under.
(i) Ambient Air
(ii) Water Quality
(iii) Noise
(iv) Land use pattern
(v) Demography and socio-economic pattern.
4.2.1 Air Environment
During construction phase, the pollutant generated will be for short duration and localized in
nature and affects only the nearby area due to which impact on the natural resources will be
insignificant.
Environmental Component
Activity Impacts Mitigation
Ambient Air Excavation
will generate
PM
Movement of
service vehicles
will generate
PM, CO, NOx
Use of DG set
during power
failure will
generate PM,
CO, NOx
Both short- and
long-term
exposure to
ambient air
pollution can
lead to reduced
lung function,
respiratory
infections and
aggravated
asthma.
Excavation and erection in
staggered manner and in day
time only.
Transport vehicles in good
service condition and
environmental complied
emission also.
Unloading from high
prohibited
DG sets used as power
backup shall have proper
acoustics and stack of
adequate height
Regular sprinkling of water
on service roads and material
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
101
4.2.2 Water Environment
Environmental
Component
Activity Impact Mitigation Measures
Water Spraying
Construction
Domestic
use
curing
Excess water
may pollute
Ground &
surface water,
Water
contamination,
Land erosion.
Only need for amount of
water used for construction
purpose.
Domestic waste water will be
used only after treatment
through STP.
Direct curing will be avoided
and curing by wet cloth
/Hessian cloth will be adopted.
handling area.
Transportation of material in
covered vehicles.
Separated incoming and
outgoing vehicles.
No idling of vehicles to be
permitted beyond extended
period of time.
No screening of horns will be
allowed.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
102
4.2.3 Noise Environment
Some noise may be expected from the working of the machinery for construction purpose and
movement of vehicles. Steps will be taken to reduce its effect by resorting to staggering of
various operations. Even otherwise there will not be any large scale machinery; the activity
is not likely to have any significant effect on the overall noise environment.
Environmental
Component
Activity Impact Mitigation Measures
Noise Operation of
Construction
machinery
Vehicular
movement
Operation of
DG sets.
Irritation to people living
nearby.
Hearing related problems to
workers due to long term
expose to high noise level.
Construction work and
vehicular movement will be
allowed during day time only.
DG sets to have proper
acoustics.
PPE like ear muffs/ plugs will
be allowed to workers.
4.2.4 Land Environment
With land development and leveling, the site may have better landscape. However, this is
restricted only to the factory boundary and within factory shed. It will be replacement of
existing machinery. Hence there will be no change in land use pattern or soil quality.
Construction activities for the proposed development can have minor impact on hydrology
and ground water quality of the area if the construction waste leaches into the ground water
source. Potential sources of impacts on the hydrology and ground water quality during the
construction phase are as follows:
Soil runoff from the site leading to off-site contamination (particularly during rainy
season).
Improper disposal of construction debris leading to off-site contamination of water
resources.
Spillage of oil and grease from the vehicles and waste water generated on site
activities such as vehicles washing, workshop etc.
Following precautions and preventive measure will be taken at the site during construction to
avoid any ground and surface water contamination.
Not allowing water to leave the construction site.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
103
Disposal of construction debris in designated areas and reusing it.
Construction of storm water diversion channels to divert storm runoff from flowing
over the construction areas.
Installing oil and grease traps in construction workshop and vehicle parking areas.
Due to civil construction activities, during rainy season the surface run off may
contain more of eroded soil and other loose matter. Construction activities will be
avoided during rainy days to mitigate the small impacts on soil quality caused due to
construction activity.
With segregation of construction area and proper drainages provided prevents the
contamination of water due to soil erosion.
Discharge of untreated or inadequately treated wastewater effluent to canals and
drains with resulting effects on water quality and potential adverse effects on crops
and human health.
Disposal of solid waste, particularly that containing toxic or otherwise harmful
compounds with resulting detrimental effects on amenity, water quality and land
quality, and potential adverse effects on crops and human health.
The land at site is fairly level as it is a running plant, as such no leveling is required. No
additional land required for expansion. In view of this no deterioration of the existing
conditions will occur. Natural drainage will not be disturbed. Solid waste from construction
activities will be used within the premises under roads & refilling. The area being very small
there will not be any significant impact on land.
SOURCE IMPACT MITIGATION MEASURES
Rainfall Flooding and siltation problem
inside industrial premises due to
change in drainage system.
There will be no serious change in
drainage pattern as the excavation
process will be done under the existing
shed and in small area; Also construction
site is already leveled.
To avoid any change in slope and
drainage pattern, transport activity will
not be allowed on muddy or wet area.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
104
Surface
runoff water
during rainy
days.
Flooding and siltation problem
outside industrial premises.
Care will be taken to avoid change in
existing drainage pattern and proper
drainage system already exists for rain
water channeling.
Construction
activities
Visual Aesthetics As the construction will occur in
industrial premises and in small area
there will be no harm to visual aesthetics.
Greenbelt development will improve the
aesthetics of industry.
4.2.5 (i) Demography & Socio Economic Pattern
Majority of population the villages of study area are Sikhs followed by Hindus, Muslims are
also there is small numbers. There is sizable population of Schedule Caste and Schedule
Tribes.
(ii) Employment
The area is not an industrial area but an agriculture belt. The main occupation & dependence
is agriculture. Small no. of steel units provides employment to some extent. The village level
development walks are executed through MGNREGA schemes. In the absence of high
employment potential, the people are economically backward. The project will address the
issue but to a limited extent.
(iii) Connectivity
The site is well connected with roads. Nearest highway is NH-44 at a distance of 5Km from
project site. Nearest railway station is Doraha which is 2.5 km form site and the nearest
airport is Ludhiana at a distance 6.0 km.
(iv) Basic amenities
These amenities as education, medical, electricity, drinking water, housing, transport, post &
telegraphs are available in the area.
4.2.6 Ecological Environment
Already being a heavily industrialized zone, the project area and its buffer as demarcated, has
little value in terms of terrestrial and aquatic biodiversity and their conservation. The faunal
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
105
and floral diversity observed during the field survey does not claim considerable attention as
most of the species observed are common throughout the region and no RET species or
endemic species were present. The area also does not possess the capacity to support such
ecologically important species and their conservation. The impact of the project activities
thus is understood to be negligible on the biological environment which is already disturbed
and diminished because of previous industrial activities. As a measure to minimize the
prevailing and forthcoming environmental impacts due to industrial pollution and activities, it
is planned to increase green areas through plantations in the available lands so that the local
faunal and floral biodiversity may increase.
SOURCE IMPACT MITIGATION MEASURES
Cutting of trees and
shrubs.
Reduction in flora No tree will be cut as the construction site is
already prepared and existing. Green belt is
developed which will improve quality of
surrounding nature.
Cutting of trees and
generation of noise
and vibration from
construction
machinery.
Migration of animals
and birds from
construction site.
No tree will cut during construction activity.
Green belt development will improve the
habitat of birds and small animals. There are
no wild animal present near the construction
site. The animals and birds present near the
construction site are already adapted to
existing surroundings. However proper care
will be taken to ensure their existence and
well being.
4.3 OPERATIONAL STAGE: - (LONG TERM)
The main source of pollution during operation will be the two new induction furnaces of 25
ton capacity each. The melting of scrap at high temperature produces gases and particulate
matter.
i) Ambient Air Environment
During operating stage of the industry the main source of pollution will be through scrap
melting inside the Induction furnace, I.F will produce emissions which will be treated
through bag filters before released into atmosphere. As the furnace is operated through
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
106
electricity, there will be no pollution through fuel burning.
Air modeling is done to obtain the ground level concentration of PM.
SOURCE IMPACT MITIGATION
Transport vehicles
DG sets
Increase in NOx, CO in
Ambient Air.
i) PUC Certified Vehicles will be used for
raw material transportation.
ii) Bag filters are provided to trap the
maximum amount of PM.
iii) Development of Green Belt in 33% area.
Fugitive emissions from
furnace. Fugitive emissions
during transportation and
processing of heated metal.
Dust generation during scrap
handling.
Indoor air Quality. i) Duct is provided over the furnace as an
exit for the Gases through stack.
ii) Opening on rooftop is provided to remove
indoor pollution
iii) Paving the usage area within the
premises
iv) Scrap metal will be cleaned before
melting.
The following are the detail of stack emission:
PARTICULARS CAPACITY FUEL USED STACK HEIGHT
APCD
INDUCTION FURNACE 8TPH
ELECTRICITY
40mtr
BAG FILTERS
INDUCTION FURNACE 25TPH ELECTRICITY 40mtr BAG FILTERS
INDUCTION FURNACE 25TPH ELECTRICITY 40mtr BAG FILTERS
LRF 30 TPH ELECTRICITY 35mtr BAG FILTERS
Rolling Mill 35 TPH FO (120lt/hrs) 35mt Alkali Scrubber
DG SET STACK-1 1500 KVA DIESEL @300Ltr/Hr
25mtr Noise less
DG SET STACK-2 1500 KVA DIESEL @300Ltr/Hr
25mtr Noise less
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
107
Specific Measures:
The I.F’s shall be provided with APCS comprising side suction hood, spark arrestor, bag
filter & ID fan will be provided.
The APCS will be operated and monitored as per SOP prescribed by the board.
Dispersal of gases & particulate through adequate stack height.
Fugitive emission during process operation will be controlled by ventilation system.
Heat dissipation in work zone will be effected by exhaust ventilation.
General Measures:
Regular sweeping and sprinkling of roads.
Speed level for vehicles.
Unnecessary blowing of horns and idling of vehicles will be prohibited.
Vehicles meeting the vehicular emission norms will be employed.
All internal roads are paved.
Air Pollution Impact Prediction through Modeling
Aermod Cloud
AERMOD is an air dispersion-modeling package, which seamlessly incorporates the popular
USEPA Models, ISCST3, ISC-PRIME and AERMOD into one interface without any
modifications to the models. These models are used extensively to assess pollution
concentration and deposition from a wide variety of sources.
Aermod Model
The AMS/EPA REGULATORY MODEL (AERMOD) was specially designed to support the
Environmental Regulatory Modeling Programs. AERMOD is a regulatory steady – state
modeling system with three separate components;
AERMOD (AERMIC Dispersion Model);
AERMAP (AERMOD Terrain Preprocessor); and
AERMET (AERMOD) Meteorological Preprocessor.
The AERMOD model includes a wide range of options for modeling air quality impacts of
pollution sources, making it popular choice among the modeling community for a variety of
applications. AERMOD requires two types of meteorological data files, a file containing
surface scalar parameters and a file containing vertical profiles. These two files are provided
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
108
by AERMET meteorological preprocessor program.
o PRIME building downwash algorithms based on the ISC – PRIME model have been
added to the AERMOD model;
o Use of arrays for data storage;
o Incorporation of EVENT processing for analyzing short-term source culpability;
o Explicit treatment of multiple – year meteorological data files and the annual average;
and Options to specify emissions that vary by season, hour-of-day and day-of-week.
Deposition algorithms have been implemented in the AERMOD model – results can be
output for concentration, total deposition flux, dry deposition flux, and / or wet deposition
flux. The model contains algorithms for modeling the effects of settling and removal of large
articulates and for modeling the effects of precipitation scavenging for gases or particulates.
Aermet
In order to conduct a refined air dispersion modeling project using the AERMOD short term
air quality dispersion model, it is necessary to process the meteorological data representative
of the study area being modeled. The collected meteorological data is not always in the
format supported by the model; therefore the meteorological data needs to be pre-processed
using AERMET program.
The AERMET program is a meteorological preprocessor, which prepares hourly surface data
and upper air data for use in the AERMOD air quality dispersion model. AERMET is
designed to allow future enhancements to process other types of data and to compute
boundary layer parameters with different algorithms. AERMET processes meteorological
data in three stages and from this process two files are generated for use with the AERMOD
model. A surface file of hourly boundary layer parameters estimates a profile file of multiple-
level observations of wind speed, wind direction, temperature and standard deviation of the
fluctuating wind components.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
109
Application of AERMOD
The AERMOD model with the following assumptions has been used to predict the
cumulative GLC due to emissions from the proposed activity:
The stack tip down wash is not considered.
Plume rise is estimated by Brigg’s formula but the final rise is limited to that of
mixing layer.
Buoyancy induced dispersion is used to describe the increase in plume dispersion.
Calm processing route is used by default.
Complex terrain is used in computation.
It is assumed that the pollutants don’t undergo any physico-chemical transformation
and there is no pollutant removal by dry deposition.
Wash out due to rain is not considered.
Receptors on that terrain with no flag pole have been considered.
Atmospheric Stability
The stability class has been estimated using the hourly monitored wind velocity along with
the other computed data.
Mixing Heights
Due to non availability of site specific missing heights “ Hourly Mixing Heights &
Dissimilative Capacity of Atmosphere in India” published by Environment Monitoring &
Research Centre, IMD, New Delhi has been referred for hourly mixing heights.
Meteorological Data
The hourly meteorological data recorded at site is converted to the mean hourly
meteorological data as specified by CPCB and the same has been used in the model. Hourly
mixing heights are taken from the “Atlas of Hourly Mixing Height and Assimilative Capacity
of Atmosphere in India” published by India meteorological department, 2008, New Delhi.
The meteorological data recorded during study period continuously on wind speed, wind
direction, temperature etc., have been processed to extract the data required for simulation by
AERMOD using AERMET.
Dispersion Modeling Results
The 24 hourly average ground level concentration (GLC) values from proposed project have
been computed for PM considering topographical featured around the proposed project and
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
110
applicable stability classes. Input data for air quality modeling is given in Table 4.1. The
predicted 24 hourly short terms Maximum Incremental Concentration values for PM10 from
the proposed project are given in Table- 4.2. Corresponding isopleths plotted are shown in
Figure 4.1.
Table 4.1
Input data for Air Quality Modeling
S. No. Items Value
1. Stack height 30 m from GL
2. Stack diameter 1.0 m
3. Temperature of stack gas 80 °C
4. Velocity of gases 9.3 m/sec
5. PM concentration 50 mg/Nm3
6. Emission rate 0.3 g/sec
Table-4.2
Predicted 24 hourly short terms Maximum Incremental Concentrations
Pollutants Maximum GLC in
µg/m3
Baseline
concentration in
µg/m3
Baseline Concentration after
project implementation in
µg/m3
PM10 1.47 88.1 89.57
Predicted GLC’s of the proposed project
It is predicted that the maximum contribution in GLC’s, with units operation are 1.47 µg/m3
for TSP at 75 m West North West (WNW) direction from stack.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
111
Fig 4.1: Isopleths showing 24 hourly predicted GLC’s of TSP
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
112
ii) Water Environment
SOURCE IMPACT MITIGATION
Leaching of domestic and
industrial waste water.
Groundwater
contamination
After expansion domestic waste water
generation will be 26.4 KLD which will be
treated through STP.
The storage tank and pipelines will be
properly maintained to avoid any leakages.
Domestic and industrial
waste water.
Surface water
contamination.
All the pipelines carrying domestic and
industrial water will be checked regularly
for leakages.
Increase in water drawl
through tube well. Water
use for domestic and
industrial purposes.
Effect on ground water
level.
Groundwater will be recharged through
rainwater harvesting.
Domestic wastewater will be used for
plantation after treatment through STP.
Water Conservation Measures:
Installation of water conservation.
Urinals to reduce flushing demand.
STP treated water to be used in plantation/ & make up for C.T.
Reheating furnace will be used occasionally to reduce C.W demand.
Push type drinking water taps to be used in place of convention taps.
iii) Noise Environment
There will be no noise producing machinery or equipment except D.G. sets which will be placed
in acoustically sound proof room causing least disturbance in the area. There is no likelihood of
change in noise environment.
iv) Land Environment
No additional land has been acquired for the unit. The machinery will be installed on the
acquired land. There will be no adverse effect on the land environment with the coming up of the
unit.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
113
SOURCE IMPACT MITIGATION MEASURES
Rainfall. Flooding and siltation
problem inside industrial
premises.
To avoid any change in slope and drainage
pattern, transport activity will not be allowed
on muddy or wet area
Surface runoff
water during rainy
days.
Flooding and siltation
problem outside
industrial premises.
Care will be taken to avoid change in existing
drainage pattern and proper drainage system is
already provided for rain water.
v) Socio Economic
Social aspects can be defined as the consequences to people of any proposed action that changes
the way they live, work, relate to one another, organize themselves and function as individuals
and members of society. This includes social-psychological changes, for example to people’s
values, attitudes and perceptions of themselves and their community and environment.
Sometimes impact on people can be by far the most important consideration. Adverse social
impacts can reduce the intended benefits of a proposal, and can threaten its viability if they are
severe enough.
Broadly social and economic aspects could be as under:-
1 Individual Life Style – These are ways people behave & relate to family, friends & cohorts
on day to day basis.
2 Community aspects- These are infrastructure, services, voluntary organizations, activity
networks and cohesion.
3 Health aspects- These include mental, physical and social wellbeing of the persons in
general
4 Rehabilitation and Resettlement- These include displacement of families beyond defined
thresholds. There is no rehabilitation and resettlement of people involve in the project.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
114
vi) Soil Environment
SOURCE IMPACT MITIGATION
Solid waste
Liquid waste
Dust from Scrap
Soil contamination i) About 46.74 of slag which is not a
H.W will be generated and the same
after recovering of iron will be supplied
to manufacturers of cement concrete
blocks, pavers & tiles under proper
agreement.
ii) Sprinkling of water will be done on
the scrap material to avoid dust
generation and direct contact of scrap
with the soil will be avoided.
Particulate matter
from Stack
emission
Particulate matter
when settles down
on agricultural
fields, can reduce its
Porosity and water
and mineral soaking
capacity and hence
its fertility.
Proper stack height is provided to
disperse the PM in air.
Bag filters are provided to trap the
maximum amount of PM.
(vii) Ecological Environment
As the proposed expansion is being undertaken in the existing premises involving no
environmental sensitivities, there is little likelihood of impact on ecology of area as the impacts
if any will be manifested over a few hundred meters radius having no wildlife.
However, an elaborate green belt in minimum 33% of project area will be developed to
ameliorate fugitive emission & noise from plant.
(viii) Solid & Hazardous Waste
Secondary metallurgical operations generate solid waste some of which are hazardous.
Therefore, arrangement will be in place for their disposal.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
115
Solid Waste
Furnace slag after iron recovery will be disposed off to manufacturers of cement concrete blocks,
pavers and tiles under proper offtake agreement.
Hazardous Waste
i. Flue gas cleaning residue (APCD dust) which is a hazardous waste shall be disposed off to
approved reprocessors.
ii. Used oil from D.G. set is being used as lubricant within the industry or else will be given to
approved recyclers.
Waste Refracting Material
This shall be given to suppliers under take back agreement.
Environmental sound technologies for Recycling of Hazardous Waste
The major H.W generated of M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara road). is used oil, zinc &
lead being flue gas cleaning residues. However, it is not involved in recycling of any identified
H.W. The same will be disposed off to approve reprocessors/recyclers.
(ix) Additional Management Approach
In order to ameliorate the adverse environmental impacts of project for scientific development a
comprehensive Environmental Management Plan (EMP) shall be prepared based on the existing
environmental conditions, impacts appraisal and environmental prediction. The EMP will take
care of formulation, implementation and the monitoring of environmental protection measures
during the construction and operation of project.
4.4 Occupational Safety and Health
During construction phase, work force may be exposed to variety of physical hazards depending
upon the specific work function. The most significant occupational hazards may include fall
from height, carrying heavy loads, accidents due to malfunctioning of machinery and falling
objects from height etc.
4.4.1General Safety Measures
Standard methods and machinery is being used.
Use of Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) is mandatory.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
116
Elevated platforms and walkways, and stairways and ramps are equipped with handrails, toe
boards and non-slip surfaces.
Electrical equipment will be grounded, well insulated and conform to applicable codes.
Employees are/will be provided with hard hats, safety boots, eye and ear protection, and snug
fitting gloves as appropriate.
Masks and dust-proof clothing are/will be provided to personnel working in areas with high
dust levels.
4.4.2 General Health Measures
Sanitation facilities are well equipped with supplies (e.g., protective creams) and employees
are being encouraged to wash frequently, particularly those exposed to dust.
Ventilation systems have been provided to control work area temperatures and humidity;
Pre-employment and periodic medical examinations are being conducted for all personnel,
and specific surveillance programs instituted for personnel potentially exposed to health
hazards.
4.4.3 Occupational Health Monitoring
At the time of placement each worker is medically examined by a qualified doctor to ascertain
his physical fitness for specific job. During the course of employment, the workers are examined
for such parameters as
Chest X-ray
Vision
Audiometry
Spirometry
ECG,
The examination is conducted once in six months in the occupational health centre by a part time
factory medical officer, to evaluate the affect of exposure. The medical examination records are
maintained and made available to workers as well as inspectorate of factories. The records are
maintained in the following format.
Name of Employee
Age
Dept
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
117
General physical condition
Eye sight
Color recognition
ECG
Chest x -ray
Audiometery
Spirometry
Any Other observation
Suitability for work
Remark: In my opinion, the above employee is fit /unfit for the work in the manufacturing
process operations in steel manufacturing unit.
Signature of Doctor
4.4.4 Occupational Audit, Frequency, Review and Corrective action
Occupational audit is conducted once in a year and self certification as introduced by Directorate
of Punjab. However, statutory compliance clarified by external agencies is employed
4.4.5 Corrective Measures
As a follow up of audit by external agencies, corrective actions are taken against major and
minor non-conformances. A major non conformance results from absence of documented and
implementation process or absence of process, minor non conformance results from partially
documented and implementation process. An action plan is chalked, detailing the action to be
taken to address any identified non conformance by including the responsibility for personal and
subsequent completion dates. The action is taken within 30 days of receiving the audit report.
CONCLUSION
It can be seen from the assessment of impacts that the proposed construction and operation of
unit will not have any significant impact on the surrounding environment. Proper arrangements
for collection and treatment of effluents and supply of water are unlikely to affect water
environment adversely. Proper pollution control measures proposed for furnaces and disposal of
hazardous waste would ensure that air, water, solid waste and noise environment do not have any
adverse impact. It is concluded that with the adoption of appropriate mitigation and
enhancement measures, there will be improvement in the development of commercial
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
118
activities, generation of direct and indirect employment opportunities and the overall
quality of life in the surrounding area.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
119
CHAPTER - 5.0
ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES
5.1 ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVE SITES FOR LOCATION OF PROPOSED
EXPANSION
Since the proposed expansion is being carried out in existing premises, it is viable on account of
the following: The land area of 23.22 acres is already under the possession of promoters and is
sufficient to carry out proposed expansion.
No forest land is involved.
The site has easy access to raw material, road, rail connectivity and market.
Power connectivity from PSPCL. The total 51 KW Power Grid is viable to meet the
requirement of continuous power supply due to proposed expansion and there shall not be
any impacts on the surrounding consumers.
Water Requirement from own tube well already existing in a premises.
Manpower availability from nearby areas.
No resettlement and rehabilitation issues.
Absence of areas of archeological and historical importance within 10 km radius.
Based on the above criterion, proposed site is conducive to undertake expansion.
5.2 ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVE FOR TECHNOLOGY SELECTION
The proposed expansion involves the replacement of existing I.F with furnace of higher capacity
which has been considered technologically best on account of the following: Optimized
consistency;
Consistence in quality issues.
Quick start up, production rate can be customized.
Since, in I.F no direct contact with flame or heating elements is involved, the product quality
is improved.
Site specific heat is supplied to the small area without heating any other part thereby
insuring extended life of fixtures
Induction heating does not burn traditional fossils fuel. The system is environmentally
sound.
Reduced energy consumption thereby reduced utility bills.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
120
No warm up or cool down cycle is required.
Least Environment Pollution.
5.3 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION:
Based on the analysis of alternatives site and technology, the undertaking of expansion at the
existing site is justified.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
121
CHAPTER -6
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING PROGRAM
6.0 Prelude
Assessment of environmental and social impacts arising due to implementation of the proposed
project activities is at the technical heart of EIA process. An equally essential element of this
process is to develop measures to eliminate, offset or reduce impacts to acceptable levels during
implementation and operation of projects. The integration of such measures into project
implementation and operation is supported by clearly defining the environmental requirements
within an Environmental Management Plan (EMP).
6.1 Environment Monitoring Program
The monitoring of environmental parameters like air, water, noise, soil, and meteorological data
and performance of pollution control facilities and safety measures in the plant are vital for
Environmental management of any industrial project.
Therefore, the company shall create environmental monitoring facilities by the environmental
and safety department to monitor air and water pollutants as per the guideline. Moreover, air,
noise, drinking water, STP and soil shall be monitored by outside agencies authorized by
Pollution Control Board at regular frequencies. This department shall also carry out periodically
check of fire and safety equipment.
6.2 Objective of Monitoring Plan
The basic objective of implementing a monitoring plan on a regular basis is as follows:
Know the pollution status within the plant and its vicinity. Generate data for corrective
action in respect of pollution
Examine the adequacy of pollution control system
Assess the Environmental impacts
6.3 Schedules for Environment Monitoring
As no project can succeed unless it is monitored at regular intervals & results analyzed. Keeping
this requirement in view an elaborate Monitoring programme has been developed for this project.
Regular monitoring of all significant environmental parameters will be carried out to check the
compliance status vis-à-vis the environmental laws and regulations.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
122
The objectives of the monitoring will be as follows:
To verify the results of the Impact Assessment Study with respect to the proposed projects.
To study the trend of concentrated values of the parameters, which have been identified as
critical and then planning the mitigating measures.
To check and assess the efficacy of pollution control equipment.
To ensure that any additional parameters, other than those identified in the impact, do not turn
critical after the commissioning of proposed project.
A comprehensive Environmental Monitoring Program that has been prepared for the
purpose of implementation in the proposed Industrial unit is given below:
Identification of any environmental problems that are occurring in the area.
Initiating or providing solution to those problems through designated channels and
verification of the implementation status.
Controlling activities inside the project, until the environmental problem has been corrected.
Suitably responding to emergency situations.
To implement the EMP, a structured Environment Management Cell (EMC) interwoven with the
existing management system will be created. EMC will undertake regular monitoring of the
environment and conduct yearly audit of the environmental performance during the construction
of the project. It will also check that the stipulated measures are being satisfactorily implemented
and operated. It shall also co-ordinate with local authorities to see that all environmental
measures are well coordinated. EMC detail is provided at Chapter- 10.
6.4 Environmental Monitoring during Construction Phase
The environmental monitoring cell of the construction team will be coordinating all the
monitoring programs during the construction phase of the proposed expansion project. The
proposed monitoring schedule during the construction phase of the project is outlined in
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
123
Table- 6.1
Environmental Monitoring Program for Construction Phase
Source Monitoring Location Parameters to be
Monitored Frequency
Ambient Air Quality
Two locations:
upwind direction and
downwind direction
PM2.5, PM10.
SO2, NOx and
CO
Twice a year or as per conditions
of EC
Ambient Noise Two locations
Day & Night
Equivalent Noise
Level
Twice a year or as per conditions
of EC
Groundwater One location As per standards Twice a year or as per conditions
of EC
Soil Quality 2 location outside the
project site As per standards
Twice a year or as per conditions
of EC
DG Stack
Monitoring
DG sets used during
the construction
Particulate Matter,
SO2, NOx
Twice a year or as per conditions
of EC
6.5 Environmental Monitoring during Operation Phase
The environmental monitoring cell will co-ordinate all the monitoring programs at the industry
and data thus generated will be regularly furnished to the State Regulatory Agencies. The
proposed monitoring schedule during the construction phase of the project is outlined in
6.5.1 Plantation
Plant growth, its maintenance and survival rate will be monitored. Suggestion of horticulturist
will be taken for this purpose.
6.5.2 Budget allocation for Environment Management
To maintain the environmental parameters within the stipulated standards, regular monitoring of
various environmental components is necessary which will complied as per conditions. Cost of
monitoring of environmental parameters for Air, Water, Noise and stack is ₹. 115 lakh and cost
for Solid Waste Management, RWH, Safety and Risk Management, Environment Monitoring
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
124
and Management, Miscellaneous ₹37 lakh.
Table-6.2
Environmental Monitoring Program for Operation Phase
Source Monitoring Location Parameters to be
Monitored Frequency
Furnace
Emissions Stack attached to APCD PM, SO2, NOx and CO
Twice a year or as per
conditions of EC or as
per requirement of
Furnace slag Storage of slag
Na2O, MgO, Al2O3,
SiO2, CaO, TiO2, MnO Once a year
Ambient Air
Quality
At 2 locations (one inside
the project site & one at
boundary of the project site
along predominant wind
direction)
PM10, PM2.5, SO2,
NOx & CO
Twice a year or as per
conditions of EC or as
per requirement of
SPCB
Ambient Noise
At 2 locations (one inside
the project site & one at
boundary of the project
site)
Day & Night Equivalent
Noise Level
Twice a year or as per
conditions of EC or as
per requirement of
SPCB
Occupational
Health
Continuous
database
management of
causalities
General Health aspects Yearly
DG Stack
Monitoring
DG sets used during the
construction
Particulate Matter, SO2,
NOx
Twice a year or as per
conditions of EC
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
125
CHAPTER -7.0
ADDITIONAL STUDIES
7.0 PREAMBLE
In this chapter following issues are described and have been carried out at Village
Bhagwanpura, Dehlon Road, Tehsil- Ludhiana East, District- Ludhiana, Punjab.
PUBLIC CONSULTATION
RISK ASSESSMENT
7.1 PUBLIC CONSULTATION
Draft EIA report has been prepared for the purpose of Public Hearing.
7.2 Possible Risks
Industrial accidents result in great personal and financial loss. Managing these accidental risks
in today’s environment is the concern of every industry because the real or perceived incidents
can quickly jeopardize the financial viability of a business. Many facilities involve various
manufacturing processes that have the potential for accidents which may be catastrophic to the
plant, work force and environment or public. The main objective of the risk management study
is to propose a comprehensive but simple approach to carry out risk analysis and conducting
feasibility studies for industries including planning and management of industrial prototype
hazard analysis study in the Indian context.
Risk analysis and risk assessment provide details on Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA)
techniques used the world over to determine risk posed to people who work inside or live near
hazardous facilities and to aid in preparing effective emergency response plans by delineating a
Disaster Management Plan (DMP) to handle on-site and off-site emergencies. Hence, QRA is
an invaluable method for making informed risk based process safety and environmental impact
planning decisions, as well as being fundamental to any facility-sitting decision making. QRA
whether site specific or risk specific for any plant is complex. It needs extensive study that
involves process understanding, hazard identification, consequence modeling, probability date,
vulnerability model/data, local weather, terrain conditions and local population data. QRA may
be carried out to serve the following objectives:
Identification of safety areas.
Identification of hazard sources.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
126
Generation of accidental release scenarios for escape of hazardous materials from the
facility.
Identification of vulnerable units with recourse to hazard indices.
Estimation of damage distances for the accidental release scenarios with recourse to
Maximum Credible Accident (MCA) analysis.
Hazard and Operability Study (HAZOP) in order to identify potential failure cases of
significant consequences.
Estimation of probability of occurrences of hazardous events through fault tree analysis
and computation of reliability of various control paths.
Assessment of risk on the basis of above evaluation against the risk acceptability criteria
relevant to the situation.
Risk mitigation measures based on engineering judgment, reliability and risk analysis
approaches.
Delineation/up-gradation of DMP.
Safety Reports with external safety report/ occupational safety report.
The Risk Assessment Report covers the following in terms of the extent of damage with
recourse to MCA analysis and delineation of risk mitigation measures with an approach to
DMP
Hazard identification: Identification of hazardous activities, hazardous materials, past
accident records etc.
Hazard quantification: Consequence analysis to assess the impacts.
Risk presentation.
Risk mitigation measures.
Disaster Management Plan.
Identification of Hazards
Identification of hazards in the proposed plant is of primary significance in the analysis,
quantification and cost effective control of accidents involving materials and process. A
classical definition of hazard stated that hazard is in fact the characteristics of system /plant/
process that presents potential for an accident. Hence, all the components of a system/ plant/
process need to be thoroughly examined to assess their potential for initiating or propagating an
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
127
unplanned event/ sequence of events, which can be termed as an accident. The following two
methods for hazards identification have been employed in the study:
Identification of major hazardous units based on Manufacture, Storage and Import of
Hazardous Chemicals Rules, 1989 of Government of India (GOI Rules, 1989) and
Identification of hazardous units and segments of plants and storage units based on relative
ranking technique, viz. Fire-Explosion and toxicity Index (FE & TI). Details are given in
EIA report. The brief of risk involved due to hazardous situation and the .safety systems are
given below:
Table 7.0 Hazard Identification & proposed safety system:
S.No Plant Area Causes Consequences Mitigation Measures
1. Furnace Operation Moisture
containing scrap
& recirculating
water coming in
contact with
molten metal
Steam
Explosion
Usage of moisture
free R.M
Drying of R.M
2. Transformer Area Oil temperature
build up
Unsafe
electrical
installation
Varying room
temperature
Sudden flashing
of fire &
bursting
Proper Electrical
installation
Transformer room
temperature
monitoring
3. H.T electrical
installation
Loose Fowls,
cable cut, short
circuits & burning
of fuse
Sparks in the
beginning &
devastative fire
if neglected
Properly laid cables &
switches & fuse
4. Extremely Hot
Working area
Heat from
Furnace, Unsafe
clothing, seasonal
factors e.g.
Heat Shocks Rotation of workers
Exhaust air
ventilation
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
128
temperature, pH &
air movement
Shielding from
radiant heat
5. Furnace & Moulding Touching Hot
Surface
Splashing of
molten metal
Radiation
Burns Providing specific
PPE are to measures
risk of manual
operation
Protective barriers to
explosion
6. Furnace & moulding UV & IR radiation
of high intensities
from molten metal
pouring
High Radiation Safety education to
workers
Labelling of risky
areas
Providing suitable
PPE
Exposure Limits
The exposure level of work zone concentrations are within the Permissible Exposure Level
(PEL) as specified in Section 41F, Sch-II of Factories Act, 1948 (Permissible Level of certain
Chemical Substance in Work Environment) and the OSHA standards for Permissible Noise
Exposures which are reproduced below:
S.No. Duration per day in
Hours
Sound Level dB(A) slow
response
Remarks
1. 8 90 1. No noise environment
excess of 115 dB (A) is to
be produced.
2. For any period of
exposure falling between
any figures indicated in
column I, the permissible
sound level is determined
2. 6 92
3. 4 95
4. 3 97
5. 2 100
6. 1½ 102
7. 1 105
8. ½ 110
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
129
9. ¼ or less 115 by exposure.
All effects shall be made to comply with the standards after the operation of proposed expansion.
Ambient Air Quality Standards in respect of noise:
Area Code Category of Area Level in dB (A) Leq
Day Time Night Time
(A) Industrial Area 75 70
(B) Commercial Area 65 55
(C) Residential Area 55 45
(D) Silence Zone 50 40
Hazard Assessment & Evaluation
A preliminary hazard analysis shall be carried out to identify major hazards associated with
storages in the facility. This is followed by consequence analysis to quantify these hazards.
Finally the vulnerable zones are plotted for which risk reducing measures are deduced and
implemented.
Before evaluating the environmental risks the following terms related to environmental risks are
defined.
Term Environmental Risks
Harm Damage to person, property or the environment
Hazard Situation that poses a threat to life, health, property or the environment
Risks The likely hand of harm or harmful occurrence and its severity,
Environmental risk is a measure of potential threats to the environment, life
& property.
Consequences Effect due to the occurrence of event endangering the environment
temporarily or permanent.
Environmental
Disorder
The consequences is so severe that it can extensively damage anyone or all
the four components of environment namely:
Physiochemical
Biological
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
130
Humans &
Aesthetic
Environmental Risk Evaluation
Risk analysis (RA) is a sort of scrutinizing vehicle for establishing the perversely in risk
management that concerns human health and the environmental quality in general. Though the
proposed facility is not manufacturing, storage or handling any potentially hazardous/toxic
chemicals as scheduled in the MSIHC Rules 1989 and its subsequent amendments, the Risk
Management measures for the proposed project are:
The adaption of best safety practices.
Incorporation in design and engineering facilities/protection measures for release to air,
water, environment and land.
Electrical safety by quick response circuit breakers.
Adequate fire protection system.
Frequent Causes of Accidents
Fire and explosion, explosives, flammable material.
Struck by falling objects.
Snapping of cables, ropes, chains & slings.
Handling heavy objects.
Electricity (electrocution).
Poor illumination.
Falls from height inside industrial units or on the ground.
Struck by moving objects.
Slipping on wet surfaces.
Sharp objects.
Oxygen deficiency in confined spaces.
Lack of personal protective equipment (PPE), housekeeping practices Safety signs.
Hackles, hooks & chains.
Cranes, winches, hoisting and hauling equipment.
Physical Hazards
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
131
Noise.
Extreme temperatures.
Vibration.
Hazardous Substances & Wastes
Heavy and toxic metals.
Organo metallic substances.
Lack of hazard communication (storage, labeling, material safety data sheets).
Fire-fighting liquids.
Welding fumes.
Volatile organic compounds (solvents).
Inhalation in confined and enclosed spaces.
Physical hazards.
Noise.
Extreme temperatures.
Vibration Radiation.
(UV, radioactive materials).
Mechanical Hazards
Trucks and transport vehicles.
Scaffolding, fixed and portable ladders.
Impact by tools, sharp-edged tools.
Power-driven hand tools, saws, grinders and abrasive cutting wheels.
Failure of machinery and equipment.
Poor maintenance of machinery and equipment.
Lack of safety guards in machines.
Structural failure.
Ergonomic & Psychosocial Hazards
Repetitive strain injuries, awkward postures, repetitive & monotonous work,
excessive workload.
Long working hours, shift work, night work, temporary employment.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
132
Mental stress, human relations (aggressive behavior, alcohol and drug abuse,
violence).
Poverty, low wages, minimum age, lack of education and social environment.
General Concerns
Lack of safety and health training.
Poor work environment.
Inadequate housing and sanitation.
Inadequate accident prevention and inspection.
Inadequate emergency, first-aid and rescue facilities.
Lack of medical facilities and social protection.
Major Hazards
Induction Furnace
Moist scrap being charged may cause explosion.
Cooling water in contact with molten metal may cause explosion.
Radioactive scrap being charged librates extremely harmful radiation.
Explosive material present in scrap may cause explosion.
Continuous Casting Machine
Spillage of molten metal can occur resulting in damage to mechanical and civil structures,
electrical cables and hydraulic equipments.
Prevention and Control of Fire and Explosion
Operational staff is being and shall be trained for safe work practices.
Risk assessment to consider the potential impact of explosion in and outside the plant.
Regular safety audits shall be undertaken.
Refractories shall be preheated and dried before use.
Scrap will be inspected, shredded and cut to size before put to use.
Nature of Hazards
Equipment/Process Associated Hazard Induction/LRF Hot metal spillage/ steam and fire explosion Continuous Casting Machine Hot metal spillage
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
133
Rolling Mill Hot metal spillage Electrical rooms Fire and Electrocution Transformer area Fire and Electrocution
Possible Hazards & Risks from Secondary Metallurgical Industries
The various process operations, which are having potentially high risk to human exposure and
which have high levels of attention area identified in Table 7.1.
Table-7.1 Possible Risk
S.No. Plant Area Possible Deviation from
normal operation
Likely Causes Consequences
1 Furnace Re-circulating and cooling
water coming in contact
with the molten iron or
slag.
Leakage of water
from the walls
Spurting of metal/
slag.
Explosion under
extreme cases.
Presence of Oil & Grease
and other Impurities in raw
materials.
Fire Sudden fire &
flames
2 High Power
Transformer
Oil temperature being very
high.
Varying room
Temperatures.
Sudden flashing of
fire or bursting.
3 High Tension
Electrical
Installation
Heavy sparking at the pot
heads and the joints.
Loose joints, cable
cut, burning of fuses,
short circuits etc.
Sparks in the
beginning,
devastating fire if
neglected.
Table 7.2
Specific Hazard & their Control
S.No. Hazard Reason Control Measures
1 Molten Metal
Explosion
- Steam Explosion
- Use of oxidized or rusted
iron.
- Damp refractories or tools.
- Containers of aerosols
mobile & phone batteries.
- Checking the refractories
moisture & strategies for
pre-heating the furnace &
the refractories.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
134
- Chemical Explosion - Accidentally mixing of
oxidizing substance e.g.
KNO3 (NH4)2NO3 in furnace.
- Incorrect combination/ ratio
of metals being processed.
- Proper storage system to
ensure against accidental use
and outside the excessive
heat area. Storage paints,
solvents and other
combustible material
specially.
2 Heat Stress - Working in extreme hot
condition.
- Shielding heat radiations
from hot surface.
- Supply of clean drinking
water
- Educating workers about the
symptoms of excessive heat
exposure.
- Short breaks & rotation of
workers.
3 Burns - Splashing of molten material
- Touching of hot surface
- radiation
- Providing specific PPE’s
- Providing protective barriers
to minimum exposure.
- Proper design & Process
Control.
- Automation to minimize risk
associated with material
handling or casting.
3 Light Radiation - UV & IR radiations of high
intensity from molten metal
especially the pouring areas.
- Educating the workers
regarding risks and safety
measures.
- Proper labeling of risky
areas w.r.t radiation.
- Shielding of workers and
providing proper PPE’s.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
135
First Aid Measures
Following first aid measures will be taken:
a. Eye Contact: Rinse eyes thoroughly with water for at least 15 minutes, including under
lids, to remove all particles. Seek medical attention for abrasions and burns.
b. Skin Contact: Wash with cool water and a pH neutral soap or a milk skin detergent. Seek
medical attention for rash, burns, irritation and dermatitis.
c. Inhalation: Move person to fresh air. Seek medical attention for discomfort or if coughing
or other symptoms.
d. Ingestion: Do not induce vomiting. If conscious, have person drink plenty of water. Seek
medical attention.
Exposure Controls & Personal Protection
Exposure Controls
➢ Control of dust through implementation of good housekeeping and maintenance.
➢ Proper fume and dust extraction system to control fume/dust emission in work zone.
➢ Use of PPE, as appropriate (e.g. masks and respirators).
➢ Use of mobile vacuum cleaning systems to prevent dust buildup on paved areas.
Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)
➢ Respiratory Protection: When the dust level is beyond exposure limits or when dust causes
irritation or discomfort use respirator.
➢ Eye Protection: Wear Safety goggles to avoid dust contact with the eyes. Contact lenses
should not be worn when handling the materials.
➢ Skin Protection: Wear impervious abrasion and alkali resistant gloves, boots, long sleeved
shirt, long pants or other protective clothing to prevent skin contact.
Fire Fighting Facilities
➢ Keeping in view the nature of fire and vulnerability of the equipment and the premises,
following fire protection facilities have been envisaged for the plant.
Hydrant System
➢ Internal hydrants will be provided in all major plant units at suitable locations and in
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
136
different levels inside the plant buildings. Internal hydrants will also be provided for
conveyor galleries. Yard hydrants will be provided in the vicinity of each plant unit,
normally along the road to meet the additional requirement of water to extinguish fire.
Portable Fire Extinguishers
➢ All plant units, office buildings, laboratory, welfare buildings, etc. will be provided with
adequate number of portable fire extinguishers to be used as first aid fire appliances.
Sufficient quantities of the following extinguishers will be provided at strategic locations in
the plant.
Other Safety Measures
Safety training to the workers will be given.
PPE will be provided to the workers.
The maintenance and cleaning of bag filters will be carried out regularly.
The dust removal efficiency of bag filters will be check regularly.
Work place environment monitoring will be carried out regularly and records will be
maintained.
Good housekeeping will be implemented in the plant.
First aid box will be provided.
The industry will provide adequate lighting facility inside the plant premises.
General ventilation will be provided to control dust levels below exposure limits.
Fire extinguishers will be provided to withstand the fire or explosion condition.
Pre-employment and periodical medical examination of workers will be done by
government approved medical practitioners and the details will be recorded as per the
Regulations.
The industry will prepare on-site emergency plan.
In case any emergency, arrangement of ambulance van will be done from nearest Hospital.
Two main gates will be provided for entry and exit of the workers.
Disaster Management Plan (DMP)
Disaster
Disaster is an unplanned event that can cause death or significant injuries to employees,
customers or public. It is a catastrophic situation in which suddenly, people are plunged into
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
137
helplessness and suffering. As a result, they need protection, clothing, shelter, medical, social
care and other necessities of life.
Disasters can be divided into two main groups, namely, natural and manmade. There can be no
set criteria for assessing the gravity of a disaster, since this depends to a large extent on the
physical, economic and social environment in which it occurs. However, all disasters bring in
similar consequences that call for immediate action, whether at the local, national or international
level for the rescue and relief of the victims.
Objectives of Disaster Management Plan
Disaster Management Plan (DMP) is the process of preparing for mitigating measures,
responding to and recovering from an emergency. The DMP is aimed at ensuring safety of life,
protection of environment, protection of installation, restoration of production and salvage
operations, in this same order of priorities. For effective implementation of the DMP, it should be
widely circulated and personnel training should be provided through rehearsals/ drills.
The DMP should reflect the probable consequences of the undesired event due to deteriorating
conditions or through ‘Knock on’ effects. Further the management should be able to demonstrate
that their assessment of the consequences uses good supporting evidence and is based on
available and reliable information, incident data from internal and external sources, and, if
necessary, the reports of outside agencies.
The objective of the industrial DMP is to make use of the combined resources of the plant and the
outside services to achieve the following:
➢ Effect the rescue and medical treatment of causalities.
➢ Safeguard other people.
➢ Minimize damage to property and the environment.
➢ Initially contain and ultimately bring the incident under control.
➢ Provide authoritative information to the news media.
➢ Secure the safe rehabilitation of affected area.
➢ Preserve relevant records and equipment for the subsequent inquiry into the cause and
circumstances of the emergency.
➢ In effect, it is to optimize that the operational efficiency to rescue, rehabilitate and render
medical help and restore normalcy.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
138
Emergency Plan
Emergency planning is primary for the protection of plant personnel and people in nearby areas
and the environment that could be affected by unplanned hazardous events. The emergency may
arise from the leakage, explosion caused by over pressure in equipment, chemical storage and
handling, fire due to combustible material and social disorder.
Furnace Hazard
Furnaces are associated with fire and electrical hazard due to sudden generation of pressure or
temperature that leads to damage, injury and death. Temperature and pressure are closely related,
and when flammable or combustible mixture is present in process equipment that leads to worst
consequences. Thus, an engineering evaluation will be done for worst-case scenario.
Safety Measures
➢ Installation of automatic alarm.
➢ Explosion suppression system with detector technique and suppressant.
➢ Means of shutting off the power and raw material supply.
➢ Standard Operating Practices (SOPs) for starting sequence of furnace should include along
with checkup for exhaust system prior to ignition
➢ Piping, valves and fitting should be metallic and be in accordance with NFPA-30. (Flammable
& combustible liquid code)
Fire & Explosion
Fire consequences can be disastrous, since they involve high voltage current and huge quantities
of raw material with fuel either stored or in dynamic inventory in conveyors or hoppers or in
nearby areas. Toxic releases can affect persons working around.
Preliminary Hazard Analysis has provides a basis for consequence estimation. Estimation can be
made by using various pool fires, tank fire consequence calculations.
During the study of Risk Assessment, the nature of damages is worked out and probability of
occurrence of such hazards is also drawn up. The aim of DMP is to introduce the pragmatic
guidelines for safe storage and warehousing of hazardous/ combustible materials, thus protecting
human health and environment. The following control/ mitigating measures should be adopted.
Eliminate all sources of ignition. However, it is difficult to ascertain.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
139
All the sources of ignition, especially if there are any moving parts.
DCP type extinguishers are recommended.
All emergency and safety related equipment must be frequently and regularly checked and
maintained to ensure that their condition is satisfactory. Records should be kept of all checks
and maintenance carried out on this equipment.
The necessary first aid equipment should include emergency showers and eyewash facilities.
The firefighting media should be selected according to mode of action and their use in
combating or preventing the spread of fire. It may be water, dry chemical powder, carbon
dioxide and foam.
Extinguishers should be fitted with means to provide visual indications that the unit has
partially or wholly been discharged.
A fire detection alarm and automatically activated CO or equal fire suppression
system should be provided in the electrical room.
On-Site Emergency Plan
On-site emergency is caused by an accident that takes place in a hazardous installation and the
effects are confined to factory premises involving the people working in the factory. Preparation
of On-site Emergency plan is the responsibility of Factory Management. When the consequences
of an emergency situation are restricted essentially within plan boundaries/ premises, it becomes
an on-site emergency. Site - Emergency is under the control of senior offer of the organization
not below the rank of General Manager. Separate cell will be created to handle emergency
occurred due to natural or man–made disasters. Evacuation plan will be prepared. Fire tenders,
ambulance and mobile hospital facilities will be provided to the victims at the shortest time. One
Health Centre equipped with modern technology will be identified which has tied up with
Government district hospital to get services of the various areas.
Emergency Communication
Whoever notices an emergency situation such as fire, growth of fire, leakage etc. should inform
his immediate superior and Emergency control center. The person on duty in the Emergency
Control Centre should appraise the Site Main Controller (SMC).
Emergency Responsibilities
a. Site Controller
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
140
On receiving information about emergency, he would rush to Emergency Control Center (ECC).
Declares Emergency and orders for operation of emergency siren. He has to organize
announcement by public address system about the location of emergency. He would assess
which areas are likely to be affected, or need to be evacuated or are to be alerted.
b. Incident Controller
The incident controller assembles the incident control team, directs operations within the
affected areas, directs the shutting down and evacuation of plant, ensures that all key personnel
help is sought, provides advice and information to the Fire and Security Officer, coordinates with
emergency services at the site.
c. Emergency Coordinator
➢ Rescue, Fire Fighting.
➢ Medical, Mutual Aid, Rehabilitation, Transport and Communication.
➢ Updating emergency plan, organizing mock drills verification of inventory of emergency
facilities and furnishing report to site controller.
➢ Maintains liaison with Civil Administration.
➢ Controls rehabilitation of affected areas on discontinuation of emergency.
➢ Maintains essential services like Diesel Generator, Water, Firewater, Compressed Air/
Instrument Air, Power Supply for lighting.
➢ Ensures availability of adequate quantities of protective equipment and other emergency
materials & spares.
General Responsibilities of Employees during an Emergency
It becomes more enhanced and pronounced when an emergency warning is raised, the workers, if
they are in-charge of process equipment, should adopt safe and emergency shut down and attend
any prescribed duty as essential employee. If no such responsibility is assigned, he should adopt
a safe course to assembly point and wait for instructions. He should not resort to spread panic.
On the other hand, he must assist emergency personnel towards objectives of DMP.
Emergency Facilities
a. Emergency Control Centre
Emergency Control Centre (ECC) with intercom, telephone, self contained breathing apparatus,
fire suit, hand tools, wind direction indications, public address megaphone, hand bell, telephone
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
141
directories, factory layout, site plan, emergency lamp, hazard chart, emergency shut-down
procedures, address with telephone numbers and key personnel, emergency coordinator, and
essential employees.
b. Assembly Point
Number of assembly point depending upon the plant location would be identified wherein
employees who are not directly connected with the disaster management would be assembled for
safety and rescue. Emergency breathing apparatus, minimum facilities like water, etc. would be
organized there. In this project there is two assembly points in opposite direction.
c. Emergency Power Supply
Plant facilities would be connected to DG and would be placed in auto mode. Thus, water
pumps, plants lighting and emergency control center, administrative building and other
auxiliary services are connected to emergency power supply.
d. Fire Fighting Facilities
First Aid and Fire Fighting equipment suitable for emergency should be maintained in each and
at bulk storage of fuel.
e. Location of Wind Sock
On the top of the administration block / security block / production blocks, wind socks would
be installed to indicate direction of wind for emergency escape.
f. Emergency Medical Facilities
Stretchers, gas masks and general first aid materials for dealing with fire burns etc. Apart from
plant first aid facilities, external facilities would be augmented. Names of medical personnel,
medical facilities in that particular area would be prepared and updated.
g. Emergency Warning
Communication of emergency would be made familiar to the personnel inside the plant and
people outside. An emergency warning system would be established.
h. Emergency Shutdown
There could be more number of persons in the storage area and other areas in the vicinity. The
area would have adequate number of exits, staircases, etc.
i. All Clear Signal
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
142
At the end of an emergency, the Site Controller orders for an all clear signal. When it becomes
essential, the Site Controller communicates to the District Emergency Authority, Police and Fire
Service personnel regarding help required or development of the situation into an Off-Site
Emergency.
j. Mutual Aid
Mutual aid in the form of technical personnel, runners, helpers, special protective equipment,
transport vehicles, communication facility, etc., should be sought from the neighboring industrial
management.
k. Mock Drills
Emergency preparedness is an important aspect of planning in Industrial Disaster Management.
Personnel would be trained suitably and prepared mentally as well as physically in emergency
response through carefully planned and simulated procedures. Similarly, the key personnel and
essential personnel should be trained in the operations. List of Key persons during emergency
situation will be mentioned in the Table 7.3
Table-7.3
List of Key persons
S. No. Emergency Coordinator
1 General Manager
2 Manager (Project)
3 Manager(Maintenance)
4 Shift In charge
Hazardous Chemicals & Associated Hazards
There is no storage of any hazardous chemical in the Industry.
Off-Site Emergency Plan
Major emergencies like bursting of tankers are classified as offsite emergency and it is not
possible for single factory to handle the situation. The task of preparing the off-Site Emergency
Plan lies with the District Collector. However, the off-site plan could be prepared as a
Composite off-site Emergency Plan with the help of the local district authorities and the nearby
industries in the Industrial Estate.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
143
Off-site emergency plan follows the on-site emergency plan. When the consequences of an
emergency go beyond the plant boundaries, it becomes an off-site emergency.
Off-site emergency is essentially the responsibility of the public administration. However, the
factory management should provide the public administration with the technical information
relating to the nature, quantum and probable consequences on the neighboring population.
The off-site plan in detail should be based on those events, which are most likely to occur, but
other less likely events, which have severe consequence, should also be considered. An early
decision will be required in many cases on the advice to be given to people living within the
range of the accident. The main aspects, which should be included in the emergency plans, are:
a. Organization
Details of command structure, warning systems, implementation procedures, emergency control
centers should be there. Names and appointments of the incident controller, site main controller,
their deputies and other key personnel should be available.
b. Communications
Identification of personnel involved, communication center, call signs, network and list of
telephone numbers.
c. Specialized Knowledge
Knowledge includes details of specialist bodies, firms and people upon whom it may be
necessary to call, for example those with specialized knowledge, laboratories.
d. Chemical Information
Details of the hazardous substances stored or procedure on each site and a summary of the risk
associated with them.
e. Meteorological Information
Arrangements for obtaining details of whether conditions prevailing at the time and weather
forecasts
f. Humanitarian Arrangements
Transport, evacuation centers, emergency feeding treatment of injured, first aid, ambulances
and temporary mortuaries.
g. Public Information
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
144
Arrangements for dealing with the media press office and informing relatives.
h. Assessment
Arrangements for: (a) collecting information on the causes of the emergency and reviewing the
efficiency and effectiveness of all aspects of the emergency plan.
i. Role of the Emergency Co-ordination Officer (ECO)
The ECO should co-ordinate various emergency services. The ECO should coordinate closely
with the site main controller. The external control should be passed to a senior local authority
administrator or even an administrator appointed by the central or state government.
j. Role of the Local Authority
The duty to prepare the off-site plan lies with the local authorities. The Emergency Planning
Officer (EPO) appointed should carry out his duty in preparing for a whole range of different
emergencies within the local authority area. Rehearsals for off-site plans shall be organized by
the EPO.
k. Role of Police
Formal duties of the police during an emergency include protecting life and property as well as
controlling traffic movements.
l. Role of Fire Authorities
The cessation of a fire should normally be the responsibility of the senior fire brigade officer
who would take over the handling of the fire from the site incident controller on arrival at the
site.
m. Role of Health Authorities
Health authorities including doctors, hospitals, and ambulances and so on are a vital part of the
emergency plan. Major off-site incidents are likely to require medical equipment and facilities
additional to those available locally. A medical “mutual aid” scheme should exist to enable the
assistance of neighboring authorities to be obtained in the event of an emergency.
n. Role of Government Safety Authority
In the event of an accident, local arrangements regarding the role of the factory inspector will
apply. List of key persons will be mentioned in the Off- Site Emergency Plan in table 7.4.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
145
Table-7.4
List of Key persons of offsite EP
S. No. Emergency Coordinator
1 District Magistrate
2 Fire Brigade
3 Controller of Explosive
4 SP
5 DHO
6 SPCB
7.3 SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
The impact of the proposed expansion activity will begin with the starting up of the construction
activities at the site. The proposed expansion activity will provide employment to considerable
number of skilled, semi-skilled and un-skilled construction laborers. In normal circumstances,
the local people will be given preference for the unskilled activities, as there are many
construction laborers in the vicinity of the project and are expected to be available with normal
wages.
Provision of wage employment to the local populace during construction period of the project
will benefit the local area to some extent. This will enhance the income levels of the construction
laborers and lead for their socio-economic wellbeing during the construction phase of the
proposed expansion activity, which will be positive impact due to the project. Tertiary sector
employment and provision of goods and services for daily need, including transport
In line with the above, some more recommendations are given below:
Local people will be given preference;
All the guidelines under the Labor Act and Safety Rules as specified under Factories Act,
1948 will be implemented during the construction work to avoid any accidents;
The contractor will be instructed to provide cooking fuel to the workers to prevent damage
to trees. This will be part of the contractual agreement between the project proponent and the
contractor engaged for construction; and
The construction site will be secured with fencing and will have guarded entry Points.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
146
7.4 REHABILITATION & RESETTLEMENT PLAN
The expansion project shall be carried out within the existing plant boundary. No land shall be
acquired for the proposed expansion. Hence the proposed expansion project does not involve any
displacement of persons and no rehabilitation and resettlement is required.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
147
CHAPTER -8.0
PROJECT BENEFITS
8.1 INTRODUCTION
The development of industrial projects plays a key role in the economic growth of any country.
Iron is the most important metal to the mankind, which is widely used for domestic, agricultural,
industrial and defense purposes. Per capita iron / steel consumption is a major indicator of
economic status of any country. The growth of the steel industry significantly contributes to
economic growth as it generates employment both directly and also due to development of
downstream industries. Peripheral development takes place and due to more influx of money
through the area, overall importance of the area increases and overall the infrastructure improves.
8.2 EMPLOYMENT POTENTIAL
8.2.1 Direct Employment
Unemployment is quite a common problem. Employment opportunities are moderate and not
growing as per growth of education. People mainly depend on the agriculture and Industries for
their living in the area. The present expansion project has employment generation potential by
way of recruiting local people directly for different activities of the project.
Estimated manpower requirement after the expansion shall be100. Local people will be given the
opportunity of employment as per their capability and expertise. Priority will be given to
scheduled tribe cast and women. This will be helpful to enhance the socio economic status of the
people.
8.2.2 Indirect Employment
Indirect employment and income effects of any steel plant are non-marginal and usually remain
widespread across a long region. It is expected that substantial portion of the investment will
trickle down to the local people in the form of employment and income. The project is expected
to generate substantial indirect employment in other sectors such as service units. Employment
and income indicate that the project has strong positive effect. Since the infrastructure for
maintenance of the specialized plant and machinery may not be readily near site, adequate
maintenance facilities for day- to- day and minor plant maintenance including a well- equipped
workshop and trained technicians shall be developed for the project. Major maintenance and
annual turn around will be contracted out to reputed agencies. Odd jobs, plant cleaning, hiring of
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
148
vehicles, road and maintenance, plant security, gardening / green belt development etc. will be
locally contracted out.
8.3 IMPROVEMENT IN INFRASTRUCTURE
M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant) intended to provide the following infrastructure in
the study area of 10 km radius:
Road Transport: There will be improved road communication due to the proposed project and
maintenance will also be done time to time.
Market for product: Need for the proposed products are based on the demand and supply gap
in the current market. With increasing utilization of the current products, in future, to cater the
requirement of all the products, it is essential to have the proposed manufacturing unit.
Market for Consumer Goods: With the implementation of the project and development of area,
demand patterns will change and local consumer market will grow thus more income
opportunities for the local people will be there. The proposed project is going to have positive
income effect and consequently, the multiplier effect is expected to lead to an overall increase in
average consumption of the people of the study area.
Increasing other business opportunities for local people- There will be scope of hiring vehicle
like tractors & trolleys, bulldozers, JCB, excavators during construction and operation phase of
the project.
8.4 EDUCATION
The local peoples’ interest towards education will increase due to the expectation of getting jobs,
especially from non- agricultural sources. The project is expected to increase such aspirations by
bringing opportunities of some direct & indirect employment for the local people. The general
awareness towards the importance of education is expected to increase as a result of the proposed
expansion. The project will have positive impact on the level of education of the people.
8.5 OTHER TANGIBLE BENEFITS
Steel plants by nature serve as the nuclei for development of small- scale industries in the areas
around them. These small- scale units usually have input- output linkage with the steel plants.
The demand for spares, assemblies and sub- assemblies by steel plants are generally met through
the supply (of these items) from small- scale units located nearby. The present project is likely to
accelerate such industrialization through “Bubble Effects” in the study area. It is important to
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
149
note that the small- scale units are usually labor- intensive and high- priority industries from
social point of view.
The proposed project is expected to serve as centre of significant small- scale industrial economy
around it complemented by the services sector. This is expected to play a major role in the future
economic and social development of this area.
8.6 CORPORATE ENVIRONMENT POLICY
It is a company managed by directors. The promoters of the project are well aware of issues and
concerns regarding environmental matters pertaining to the project. The company has well
established administrative set up to deal with the environmental issues and ensuring the
compliance of statutory norms and EC conditions as per following line diagram.
8.7 DETAILS OF INFRASTRUCTURE FACILITY
Most of the labor force during construction and operation phase hired from the local areas.
Sanitation and rest rooms are available for the casual workers and truck drivers. Sufficient toilet
facility i.e. one toilet for ten persons is there.
8.8 ENTERPRISE SOCIAL COMMITMENT
As per OM F.No.-22-65/2017-IA-III dated on 01st May, 2018, the organization will spend for
Corporate Environment Responsibility. Detail will be given in final EIA report.
No adverse effect on environment is envisaged as proper mitigation measures will be taken up
for the same.
8.9 LITIGATION AND PENDING CASES
The unit has never violated the provisions under the environmental protection rules. Neither any
litigation is pending against the project nor any directions /order has ever been past by any court
of law.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
150
CHAPTER -9.0
ENVIRONMENTAL COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS
9.1 ESTIMATED PROJECT COST
Total project cost will be ₹ 204.04 Cr. after expansion.
9 .2 SCHEDULE OF PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION
Schedule of implementation of the project is the most reasonable time during which the proposed
project can be implemented. This takes into account the time required for various activates i.e.
detailed engineering of the unit including structural designs, civil construction Procurement of
equipment and machinery including utilities and services, equipment test and trial runs etc. One
year shall be needed for completion of the project after the EC Granted.
Key factors that would facilitate successful and timely project implementation:
a. Proper choice of technology and machinery suppliers.
b. Adequate diligence in formulating the technical concept and system design / selection of the
plant.
c. Proper choice of contractors for civil construction and erection of equipment.
d. Formulation of effective project team led by an experienced Project Manager.
e. Establishment of efficient system for project planning & monitoring including reporting
procedures for progress review & co- ordination.
f. Customization of project execution plan to suit the promoters profile.
9.2.1 Implementation Strategy
Typically project has four core dimensions viz:
a. Engineering: this directly impacts the smooth operations of the plant over its entire life
b. Procurement: is critical on account of the impact that it has on investment and performance
benchmarks and also in ensuring the choice of appropriate technology.
c. Construction: is critical in terms of its impact on completion quality and duration of the
project phase.
d. Project Management: other than its obvious impact on project time it also contributes to risk
minimization for the promoter.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
151
CHAPTER -10
ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT PLAN
10.0 Introduction
Environmental management plan (EMP) describes the administrative aspects of ensuring that
mitigation measures are implemented and their effectiveness monitored, after grant of EC. It
consists of various policies, control measures etc. for abatement of critical environmental
impacts arising out of the proposed project. Mitigation measures are proposed on the basis of
identified impacts. Further a suitable environment management plan will be introduced in the
project to implement and practice measures to protect and enhance the quality of environment.
The EMP is only as effective as its implementation. An appropriate environmental management
strategy is developed and presented in the form of an EMS. It is the responsibility of the project
proponents to control the utilization of resources and discharges of waste by adopting suitable
control measures in the factory to avoid adverse effects of industrial activities on the
environment and in turn to enhance the quality of the existing environment.
10.1 Summary of Potential Impacts with Mitigation Measures during Construction Phase
10.1.1 Land Environment
The site is flat and already leveled, hence no leveling is required. Earth excavated during civil
foundations will be reused for raising the plinth and backfilling the columns. Dust generated due
to earthwork including excavation and transportation activities, especially during dry weather
conditions, will be controlled by water sprinkling.
10.1.2 Air Environment
Dust will be generated at work site during the construction activity like excavation and vehicular
movement. Providing suitable surface treatment to ease the traffic flow and regular sprinkling of
water will reduce the dust generation. All internal and external roads will be asphalted and
cleaned daily, so there will be less generation of re-suspended road dust.
10.1.3 Water Environment
Temporary drainage work will be maintained, removed and reinstated as required, and all other
precautions will be taken for avoidance of damage by flooding and silt. Sedimentation pit of
sufficient capacity will be constructed to trap silt-laden water during monsoon. The wastewater
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
152
will be reused for dust suppression by adopting suitable mechanism. These will be cleaned on
regular basis.
10.1.4 Noise Environment
The noise generated during the constructed phase will be due to the movement of vehicles and
construction equipment. Construction equipments and transport vehicles would be properly
maintained so that noise generation is minimized. Regular maintenance schedule will be adopted
for all construction equipment and vehicles.
10.1.5 Solid Waste Management
Careful design, planning and good site management would minimize waste of materials such as
concrete, mortars and cement grouts. Construction waste will be segregated as much as possible
at site itself to increase the feasibility of recycling concrete and masonry as filling material and
steel pieces as saleable scrap.
Muck shall be generated from drains and sedimentation pits. The muck shall be collected daily
and stored at earmarked place. It shall be finally disposed within the plant premises for plinth
raising purpose. Litter disposal and collection points shall be established around the all
construction work sites. Construction waste shall be segregated as much as possible at site itself
to increase the feasibility of recycling concrete and masonry as filling material and steel pieces
as saleable scrap.
10.1.6 Sanitation, Welfare and Safety Measures of Construction Workers
Construction workers will be made aware of possible hazards and safety measures that need to
be taken during construction activities through routine training. Personal Protective Equipments
(PPEs) such as dust masks, goggles, earplugs/ earmuffs, safety gloves, safety belts, shoe with toe
protection, gumboots will be made available at construction site. Construction workers and
vehicle drivers will be provided with drinking water, canteen and toilet / washroom facility. Rest
room facility for truck drivers will be provided.
10.2 Summary of Potential Impacts with Mitigation Measures during Operational Phase
10.2.1 Air Environment
The major source of air emission is fugitive dust from induction furnace. The dust emissions will
be controlled by using fume capture devices and bag filters. The air pollution control system will
consists of air cooled ducts, hood for furnace, bag house, ID fan and chimney. Adequate spares
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
153
(bags, cages, compressors, pumps, and machine parts, etc) shall be maintained by the Industry.
O&M of the bag filter shall be done as per schedule prescribed by the manufacturer.
Gaseous emission from DG stack will contribute significantly in particulate matter, SO2 and NOx
level in ambient air. Stacks heights as per norms will be provided for the proper dispersion of
pollutants. The resultant air quality will conform to the stipulated standards.
10.2.2 Water Environment
Pollution of groundwater, odor from waste water treatment plant and domestic sewage are some
potential impacts of liquid effluent. Domestic sewage will be treated in sewage treatment plant
and treated effluent will be collected in treated effluent tank reused in sprinkling, watering,
irrigation of green belt and horticulture, etc. The water for cooling of furnaces will be re-
circulated and no wastewater will be discharged from outside the premises. Roof-top rain water
harvesting through recharge wells is also proposed to recharge the ground water of the area.
10.2.3 Noise Environment
Noise level will increase due to equipment and machineries in the plant area. Equipments will be
designed to conform to noise levels prescribed by regulatory agencies where necessary, high
noise generating equipment should be acoustically treated or housed. Provision of green belt and
plantation would further help in attenuating noise. Acoustic enclosure will be provided for DG
sets. Noise attenuation will be acquired to reduce noise level to 85 dB (A) at 1m distance. Ear
plugs/ear muffs will be provided to employees working in high noise areas as protective device.
10.2.3.1 Green Belt Development Plan
Area allocation for green belt: 33% i.e. 31,200 m2 of total area as per MoEF&CC stipulated
norms will be developed as the green belt. A total of 4678 trees will be planted. 100 trees have
already been planted.
Selection of plant species: Existing tree species are Shisham, Mango, Safeda, and Kachnar.
Tree species like Mulberry, Bungania and False Ashok will be planted.
Action plan & estimated budgetary allocation for proposed green belt development
The proposed green belt in an area of 31,200 m2will be developed in phase wise manner viz.
plantation will be done in Phase-wise manner
No. of trees to be planted in 31,200m2= 31,200/6.67= 4678 plants.
1000 Plants have been already planted. The rest number of plants i.e. 3678 will be planted as
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
154
Phase I (June 2022) – 1226 plants will be planted
Phase II (June 2023) – 1226 plants will be planted
Phase III (June 2024)- 1226 plants will be planted
Budgetary allocation: ₹. 22 Lakhs under EMP cost.
10.2.4 Solid and Hazardous Waste
Waste Source Quantity Potential Impact
APCD Dust Induction Furnace 4.26 TPD Health Implication
Furnace Slag Induction Furnace 46.74 TPD No adverse impact. It
will be used in road
making and land filling.
Used Oil DG sets 0.03 Kl/A possibility of soil and
water contamination due
to spillage
MSW from every
day &Domestic
Employees 145kg/day Hazardous Gas
Emission.
Natural Habitat
Degradation
Management
Dust from bag filters shall be stored in a dumping pit of R.C.C. and disposed to designated
TSDF site.
Municipal solid waste due to everyday sweeping and domestic activities will be collected in
bins.
The sludge from waste water treatment systems shall be composted and used as manure in
horticulture.
Slag produced from manufacturing process as by-product will be periodically tapped and left
to solidify. The slag will be then crushed and iron particles are taken out through the process
of magnetic separation. Mill scales are either sold in the market or used back in I.F.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
155
Summary of Environmental Impact and mitigation Measures:
S.
No.
Component of
Environment
Impact Mitigation Measures
CONSTRUCTION PHASE
1 Air Particulates, NOx, SO2 Personal protective equipments
for workers, water sprinklers.
Since the proposed project is
within the industrial land, no
impact is envisaged on the
outside areas.
2 Noise and Vibration Noise level increase due
to vehicular movement,
working of machineries
and construction
equipments.
Construction activity to be
restricted in day time only.
Proper servicing of vehicles,
PPE to be provided.
3 Water Water pollution due to
disposal of water and
domestic waste water.
Proper sanitation facilities
are/will be provided. No change
in land use as the project
execution will be in the existing
land.
4 Land Land is already industrial
which may be polluted
due to untreated sewage
and solid wastes.
Construction waste will be used
within the site and sanitation
facilities already exist which will
be further strengthened.
5 Biological Noise level may impact
the fauna
Green Belt development takes
care of this aspect.
6 Socio Economic Employment of workers Positive impact as people from
the study area will be employed.
7 Occupational Health
and Safety
Respiratory ailment due
to dust and auditory due
to noise.
Water sprinklers and PPE’s
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
156
OPERATIONAL PHASE
1 Air Increase in the air
pollution due to plant
operation and vehicular
movement.
Provisions of proper APCS and
their operation as per SOP,
adequate stacks and compliance
as per SPCB norms. PPE for
employees, regular monitoring
and compliance with HWM
(TBM) Management rules-2016.
2 Noise and Vibration No noise is generated
from Induction Furnace.
However, small noise that
too within the premises
will also generated from
the operation of
equipment.
Equipment will conform to noise
level of 85 dB (A).
Proper maintenance of
equipment and PPE. General
public will not be affected.
3 Water No impact as no water is
and in the process and
entire cooling water is
circulated. No industrial
effluent generated and
discharged.
Proper sanitation facilities. The
sludge from domestic waste
water treated to be used as
manure and treated water for
plantation.
4 Land Discharge of sewage
water
Domestic waste water shall be
used in plantation after
treatment.
5 Biological Disturbance due to noise Proper education to drivers and
transportation in day time only.
6 Socio Economic Employment to locals Positive impact
7 Occupational Health
and Safety
Accidents to operational
activities and auditory
ailments
Low noise equipments will be
employed which conform to
noise level of 85 dB (A). Proper
PPE to be provided. Storage of
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
157
H.W. as per rules. Proper safety
training to staff.
10.2.5 Occupational Health & Safety
Sources and Impacts: Exposure to noise, dust, heat and gases like CO are occupational hazards
identified in steel plant. Silicosis, Bronchitis and Noise induced hearing loss are the diseases that
could occur due to prolonged exposure / concentration found to be above the Permissible
Exposure Level. Workers involved in raw material handling section, dusty environment, near
furnaces, and are exposed to high dust levels. Workers working near / close to the furnaces are
exposed to heat stress. Over a long period of time such exposure is likely to result in respiratory
problems/ occupational health problems.
Management: Plant personnel working in dust prone areas shall wear personnel protective
equipment like air filters over their nose. Job rotation schemes shall be practiced for over-
exposed persons, particularly for heat stress. Proper illumination shall be maintained at each and
every nook and corner of the work places.
PPE like earplugs and muffs shall be provided to workers working near air compressors, pipe
plant and mills, and administrative pressure applied to the workers to use them. Workers exposed
to mechanical accident-prone areas are given personal protective equipment (PPE) like tight
rubber goggles, safety helmets, welders hand shields and welding helmets, plastic face shields,
ear plugs, ear muffs, rubber aprons, rubber gloves, shoes with non-skid soles, gum boots, safety
shoe with toe protection.
Table 10.1 Safety and Occupational Hazards
Safety Hazards
Risk Equipment Causes Mitigation Measures
Steam Explosion Furnace Cooling water coming
in contact with molten
metal as Slag
Excessive moisture in
Slag
Due to refractors
Making C.W. system leak
proof
Pre heating of raw materials
Pre heating of refractors
Chemical Furnace Accidental mixing of Segregation of scrap before
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
158
Explosion oxidants such as
points/varnishing &
oily scrap
Chemicals/substances
in scrap
use
Fire & Explosion Transformers High oil temperature
Varying room
temperature
Locating transformers at
isolated place
Encompassing the oil filled
equipment by RCC wall
Sparks followed
by fire
Electrical
installation/Su
b- station
Loose fowls, cable
cut, short circuits etc
Due diligence in designing
the electrical sub station
Occupational Health Hazards
Hazard Causes Mitigation/Control
Heat Stress Working in extreme hot
conditions
Shielding heat radiations from
hot surface
Supply of clean drinking water
Educating workers about the
symptoms of excessive heat
exposure
Short breaks & rotation of
workers
Burns Splashing of molten
material
Touching of hot surface
Radiation
Providing specific PPE’s
Providing protective barriers
to minimum exposure
Proper design & process
control
Automation to minimize risk
associated with material
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
159
handling or casting
Light Radiation UV & IR radiations of
high intensity from
molten metal especially
the pouring areas
Educating the workers
regarding risks and safety
measures
Proper labeling of risky areas
w.r.t radiation
Shielding of workers and
providing proper PPE’s
Electrocution Contact with live wires
Flash over
Strong Electromagnetic
filter
Elimination of source of risk
Safety switches
Task specific PPE
Mechanical Hazard Accidental fall of heavy
equipments
PPE
Proper training
Hearing problems Excessive Noise Insulate ventilation proper
Compulsory PPE
10.3 STRUCTURE AND ADMINISTRATIVE RESPONSIBILITIES OF
ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT CELL (EMC)
M/s Aarti Steels Limited is an existing company having qualified and experienced personnel in
environmental management and pollution control. The company has existing environmental
monitoring cell for environment monitoring and legal compliances. The details of cell are given
below:
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
160
General Manager: He will be responsible for legal compliances of the company related to
MoEF, CPCB & PPCB. He will arrange regular monitoring of the proposed pollution control
system through his associates. He will arrange evaluation environmental performance of the
systems and ensure that the stipulated measures are being satisfactorily implemented and
operated. He will ensure that there shall not be any adverse impact on air, water, noise and land
environment due to construction & operation of proposed expansion project. As per report of
DGM Environment the plant management shall take effective steps through the concerned
section head to curb the pollution and effective environmental management.
Consultant: He will supervise the monitoring & analysis of water and effluent quality by the
laboratory. As per requirement he will arrange the additional tests through external agencies. He
will also arrange regular measurement of ground water quality in the study area and
implementation of rain water harvesting measures. He will monitor the performance of air
pollution control systems through on line continuous stack emission monitoring systems and
online continuous ambient air quality monitoring stations. He will also ensure the CPCB
guidelines by arranging the outside agency to carry out monitoring & analysis of the air quality
parameters which are not available in online systems. He will facilitate the inspection,
monitoring & analysis of pollution control systems by the SPCB officials as and when required.
His other functions would be hazardous waste management. He will co-ordinate for proper reuse
or disposal of hazardous wastes. EMP costing detail is provided at Table 10.2.
Table-10.2
EMP Budget
S.
No
Title Capital Cost
₹ Lakh
Recurring Cost ₹
Lakh
1 Pollution Control during construction stage 2.0 ---
2 Air Pollution Control (Installation of APCD) 300.0 10.0
3 Water Pollution Control (Installation of STP @
30 KLD) 20.0
2.0
4 Green Belt development 22.0 18.0
5 Noise Pollution Control 1.0 0.1
6 Solid/ Hazardous Waste Management 7.5 ---
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
161
7 Environment Monitoring and Management 5.0 0.10
8 Occupational Health, Safety and Risk
Management 10.0
0.50
9 RWH 10.0 0.50
10 Miscellaneous 4.0 --
TOTAL ₹381.5 Lakh ₹31.2 Lakhs
To maintain the environmental parameters within the stipulated standards, regular monitoring of
various environmental components is necessary which will be complied as per conditions. Cost
of monitoring of environmental parameters for Air, Water, Noise and stack is ₹345 lakh and cost
for Solid Waste Management, RWH, Safety and Risk Management, Environment Monitoring
and Management, Miscellaneous ₹36.5 lakh.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
162
CHAPTER -11.0
SUMMARY & CONCLUSION
11.1 Project Name and location
The proposed project i.e. M/s Aarti Steels Limited. is a Secondary Metallurgical Process based
industry. The plant is located at Village- Harian, P.O. Uppal, Machhiwara road, Tehsil- Koom
Kalan, District- Ludhiana, Punjab.
11.2 Products and capacities
The Industry has already got CTE for installation of one no. Induction Furnace of Capacity 8
TPH, Concast and a Rolling mill of capacity 1, 40,000 TPA. The existing production of
Billets/Ingot is 28000TPA and Rolled/Flats products is 1,40,000 TPA. The project is for
expansion of Billet/Ingots Manufacturing by addition of Two no. Induction Furnaces of
capacities 25 TPH each, LRF, VD, Concast and upgradation of existing Rolling Mill. Total
capacity of the project after expansion will be 2, 90,500TPA steel billets/Ingots/ rolled/flats
products.
After expansion the production details will be as under:
Product Name Existing (TPA) Additional (TPA) Total (TPA)
Steel Billets/ Ingots 28,000 2,62,500 2,90,500
Rolled / Flats Products 1,40,000 1,50,500 2,90,500
11.3 Land Area
The industry is having 23.22 acres or 93,970 Sqm. of land. No additional land will be required for
expansion.
11.4 Raw Material Requirement
Raw Material Existing Additional Total
MS Scrap, CI, Sponge Iron, Ferro Alloys
30,800 2,88,750 3,19,550
Source & Mode of transport
From domestic & as well as International Markets
transported through covered trucks
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
163
11.5 Water Requirement
Water consumption for the unit will be make up water for cooling and for domestic purpose.
Water requirement will be met through existing tube well. The detail of water requirement is
given below:-
DESCRIPTION EXISTING
(KLD)
PROPOSED
(KLD)
TOTAL
(KLD)
Domestic 15 18 33
Cooling (makeup water) 90 527 617
Total 105 545 650
11.6 Power Requirement
The Power Requirement will be met by sourcing the power from Punjab State Power
Corporation limited from nearby Sub-station. The detail of power requirement existing & after
expansion is given below:-
DESCRIPTION EXISTING PROPOSED TOTAL
Power Requirement 12MW 39MW 51MW
Source Punjab State Power Corporation Limited (P.S.P.C.L.)
11.7 Manpower Requirement
Direct Employment; for expansion additional 361 persons will be required. Total number of
manpower after expansion will be 661 no’s.
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
164
11.8 Flow Chart of Manufacturing Process
Raw Material
Induction Furnace
Concast Machine
Ingots/ Billets
Rolling/ Final Product
Cooling Tower
Side Suction Hood
A P C D (Bag Filter)
APCD Dust
Clean Air
Final Disposal
TSDF Site/ Disposal
Stack
51 MW Power
Make Up Water
Slag
Metal Recovery Plant
Waste Sent To Vendor for Disposal
Fugitive Emission
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
166
11.9 Description of Mitigation Measures
The purpose of mitigation measures is to avoid, reduce or minimize unwanted impacts on the
environment. To minimize & control the Flue Gas emission from the stack attached to furnace
& DG Set, M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara road) has already installed separate water
scrubber with I.F & canopy with DG set. About 46.74 TPD of slag which is not a H.W will be
generated and the same after recovering of iron will be supplied to manufacturers of cement
concrete blocks, pavers & tiles under proper agreement. STP is provided for treatment of
domestic effluent. Treated effluent is used for plantation in the premises. The industry is
regularly operating and maintaining its APCD and ensuring that the emissions are adequately
collected and concentration of air pollutants in its emissions conforms to the emission
standards laid down by the board.
11.10 Cost Details
Existing cost of the project is Rs. 73 Cr. and total cost for the expansion has been estimated
Rs. 130.79 Cr. The total cost of the project has been estimated as Rs. 204.04 Cr. The proposed
expansion will be done within one year after granting of Environment Clearance.
11.11 Site Details
M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant), Village-Harian, P.O. Uppal, Machhiwara road,
Tehsil- Koom Kalan, District- Ludhiana, Punjab is having its global coordinates as Latitude
30°54'27.07"N, 30°54'24.15"N, 30°54'19.62"N, 30°54'12.25"N and 30°54'12.39"N &
Longitude 76°07'48.90"E, 76°07'56.29"E, 76°08'00.67", 76°08'00.86"E and 76°07'49.99"E.
Sahnewal is the nearest city (about 16 Km). Nearest airport is Chandigarh which is at 68 km
and Ludhiana is at 17.6 km from site. No National Parks/ Wildlife Sanctuaries/ Biosphere
Reserves/ Reserved Forests exist within 5 km radius of project site. There are no water bodies
near project site
11.12 Environmental Baseline Study
11.12.1 Ambient Air Quality
The PM2.5, PM10, SO2, NO2, CO levels were monitored at eight locations in the study area for
three months (February-April,2021). The P98 levels of criteria pollutants are as follows: PM2.5
is 48.4μg/m3, PM10 is 88.1μg/m3, SO2 is 14.7μg/m3, NO2 is 38.4μg/m3 and CO is 0.68mg/ m3.
The baseline air quality level is within the National Ambient Air Quality Standards prescribed
for industrial, residential, rural & other area and also satisfies the air quality index (AQI) w.r.t.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
167
health bracket for all the monitoring. (Standards are 60, 100, 80, 80μg/m3 and 4.0mg/m3 for
PM2.5, PM10, SO2, NOx and CO respectively). Due to better pollution abatement facilities,
proposed expansion will have insignificant impact on existing air quality.
11.12.2Water Quality
Eight groundwater samples and one surface water sample from Satluj river at 9km and Ropar
Neelon canal at located 4.2 km from project site were collected from the study area for
chemical, metallic and biological analysis. The groundwater qualities of the study area are
satisfactory as no metallic or bacterial contamination was found in the water samples. But
bacterial contamination was found in surface water. Since, no waste water will be discharged
on land, water quality is not likely to be impacted.
11.12.3Noise Environment
Ambient noise levels were monitored at 8 locations in the study area. Noise levels in the study
vary from 48.3 dB (A) to 70.2 dB (A) in day time and 37.5 dB (A) to 61.5 dB (A) at night.
The highest levels were observed at Project Site. The baseline noise levels are well within the
National Standards. Proposed expansion will have less impact than existing one due to better
pollution control facility.
11.12.4 Soil Quality
Eight soil samples were collected from the study area and analyzed. The texture of soil is
sandy loam. The organic matter, nitrogen, potassium and phosphorus content of the soil are
moderate. The pH of all the soil samples is within the acceptable range. No impact on soil will
be there for proposed plant as no waste will be discharged on land.
11.12.5 Ecological environment
Ecological data has been collected through secondary sources and by site visits. The tree species
Ashoka, Jamun, Peepal and Mango etc are the dominant plant species of the study area.
Mongoose, porcupine, jungle cat, cobra, krait, snakes, hare, pigeon and variety of birds are the
common animals of the study area. No endangered species of plants and animals are found in
the study area, so no impact on ecological Environment.
11.12.6 Sensitive Ecosystem
Within 5 km distance of the project site, no plant or animal species were found to be on the
endangered list. No ecologically sensitive area like biosphere reserve, tiger reserve, and
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
168
elephant reserve, migratory corridors of wild elephant, wetland, national park and wildlife
sanctuary are present within 5 km distance of the project site. Kahali Dum- RF, Retwali- PF,
Aleta- PF, and Bowan- PF etc are revered/protected forests present within the study area.
Agriculture and industrial workers dominate the occupation structure of the study area. Several
other industries large and small units are present in the study area.
11.12.7 Socioeconomic Condition:
Socioeconomic status has been studied through secondary sources and by site visits. The social
requirements identified such as drinking water, Promotion of Educational institutions and
Medical facilities to the villagers (especially Senior Citizens and infants or pregnant ladies).
Community centers, recreation facilities etc will be developed as part of social responsibility.
11.13 Possible Hazards & Risks from Secondary Metallurgical Industries
The various process operations, which are having potentially high risk to human exposure and
which have high levels of attention area identified in table below:
Possible Risk
S.
No.
Plant Area Possible Deviation from
normal operation
Likely Causes Consequences
1 Furnace Re-circulating and cooling
water coming in contact
with the molten iron or slag.
Leakage of water from
the walls Spurting of
metal/ slag.
Explosion under
extreme cases.
Presence of Oil & Grease
and other Impurities in raw
materials.
Negligence in material
inspection
Sudden catches
fire & flames
2 High Power
Transformer
Oil temperature being very
high.
Varying room
Temperatures.
Sudden flashing
of fire or
bursting.
3 High Tension
Electrical
Installation
Heavy sparking at the pot
heads and the joints.
Loose joints, cable
cut, burning of fuses,
short circuits etc.
Sparks in the
beginning,
devastating fire if
neglected.
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
169
11.14 Emergency Plan
Emergency planning is primary for the protection of plant personnel and people in nearby
areas and the environment that could be affected by unplanned hazardous events. Furnaces are
associated with fire and electrical hazard due to sudden generation of pressure or temperature
that leads to damage, injury and death. Temperature and pressure are closely related, and
when flammable or combustible material is present in process equipment it leads to worst
consequences. Thus, an engineering evaluation will be done for worst-case scenario.
11.15 CER Activities (Corporate Environmental Responsibility)
Proposed project will result in growth of the surrounding areas by increased direct and
indirect employment opportunities in the region including ancillary development and
supporting infrastructure.
11.16 Environment Monitoring Plan
Regular monitoring of all significant environmental parameters is essential to check the
compliance status vis-à-vis the environmental laws and regulation. The frequency of the
monitoring will be as follows:
The ambient Air quality shall be monitored at project site and two upward and
downstream locations once every quarter for PM2.5, PM10, NOx & SO2, and CO levels
during the Construction Phase and Operational Phase.
The Ambient Noise Levels, Water Quality, Effluent etc. shall be monitored once every
six months or as per EC conditions.
11.17 Environment Monitoring Cell (EMC)
A duly constituted EMC comprises the following:
Owner
Project Incharge
Environment Consultant
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
170
CHAPTER -12
DISCLOSURE OF CONSULTANTS ENGAGED
12.1 Organizational Profile:
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory (C P T L) is incorporated in 1997. The
Registered office of CPTL is at Plot no. E-126, Industrial Area, Phase-7, Mohali,
Punjab. Its laboratory division has accreditation from NABL, recognition from MoEF &
CC & PPCB (Punjab Pollution Control Board) and EIA division (i.e. CPTL-EIA) is
accredited by QCI/ NABET as Category-A EIA consultancy organization. In addition it
has certification from ISO 9001: 2015, ISO 14001: 2015 and OHSAS 18001: 2007. C P
T L is a venture of professionally qualified and experienced technical personnel. The
main aim of the company is to provide consultancy services and analytical services to
those industries which do not have complete in-house testing facilities with them.
12.2 Scope of Services
Laboratory Facilities Consultancy Services
Surface/ Ground Water testing Environment Impact Assessment
Drinking Water testing Environment Audits
Construction Water testing Environment clearance compliances
Sewage/ Effluent testing Remote sensing
Soil testing Sound level modeling
Ambient Air monitoring Air quality modeling
Stack Emission monitoring Risk Assessment
Noise level monitoring Ecology & Biodiversity study
Micro-biological testing Socio-economic studies
Manufacturing of ETP, STP & APCDs Consent from Pollution Boards
Design and installation of ETP, STP & APCDs Climate Change
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
171
ANNEXURE I JAMABANDI RECORD
13
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
172
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
173
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
174
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
175
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
176
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
177
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
178
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
179
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
180
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
181
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
182
ANNEXURE II
CTE
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
183
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
184
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
185
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
186
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
187
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
188
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
189
ANNEXURE III CLU
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
190
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
191
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
192
ANNEXURE IV PLPA UNDERTAKING
Chandigarh Pollution Testing Laboratory- EIA Division (QCI/ NABET Certificate No: NABET/EIA/1922/RA 0146)
Draft EIA Report for M/s Aarti Steels Limited (Machhiwara Plant)
193
ANNEXURE V AUTHORIZATION LETTER