Chaos and multifractality in a time delay car-following traffic model

6

Transcript of Chaos and multifractality in a time delay car-following traffic model

�������������� ��������������������������! ���"������ $#�%&��#'�(�) �)���*%&���+���(�',���-.�����0/.�1 $�2��#3�

465�798;:=<?>�@&ACBEDF798;7EGIH�J K�LIMON=BP<RQS79TU5�V(HWL;XOBP<;:YTZX�@&A\[]V_^a`9:Y8IK�LCbO79c_5(D�>3c_d;eP5�8IB�f�^CgELB�8I<�Aad;Nh7PTU7ji3BkGaNh:Y8!Hlnmporq\s]tvu�w�x�s�qEyvs]tzw�q\{+|}s]~aw�t�yv��s]q�y����6�6�E�9��or������ w�t��k����w�qn�zq\oruks]tv��o�y��E�a�������W�0�zw���w�y����}w�qI�\����t�w�s��

� |}s�~\w�t�yv��s�qEy����6�z~9~\�rors�{UmUw(yv�\s���w(yvo��]�zw�qa{nmps]�_�\w�q\or������ ��tv�Wq9s����n�Ey�w�yvs)�zq\oruks]tv��o�y��E�P ���¡W¢W�W  � ��tv��q\s����I�\�¤£\����o�w

¥Rx�s�qEyvs]tO�=��t}���r��¦aw��!x��aw�q\§Ws'����ors�q\��s��mUw����vw��_��£\��s_y�yv�z��q\��yvo�yv£9yvs}���S¨©s����\q9�W�r�W§��E�Cx�w��ª¦9tvo�{P§WsW�amUw����vw��_��£\��s_y�yv���W��«� ��P�C�}�9�

¬�­¯®�°�±(²\³W°W´ ¨��\s3~9tvs���s�q9��s3���S�_�\w�����orqny�t�w�µ��3or����yv£a{Pors�{U£\��orq\§�w���w(t�¶·�h�W�r�r��¸Oo�q9§p����{Ps��¦\w���s�{0��q�w}���P��yvs��¹���&{9s]�Yw���¶�{9o�º;s]tvs�qEyvo�w��Ps�»E£aw(yvor�Wq\��¼W½�s�¾aq\{3yv�\w�y�w�¦C�(uksOw}��s]t�y�w�orq0yvo���s{Ps���w��Uw�qa{+�h��tzo�qEyvs]tv��s�{9o�w�yvs){Ps�q\��o�y��pu�w��r£\s]�Oyv�9s)���P��yvs��¿~aw�����s��¤yv�����aw��W���=���r����¸Oorq\§�yv�\s�¤£\s]���rs]¶�¨!w�Àks�q9��¶�Ázs]¸O�\��£\��s*����s�qaw(tvor�0Â=¾\ÃPs�{)~C�WorqEy©�}��or��o�y¯�]�P���rs��©��y�¸���¶Fyv��tvok�}yv�Ptvs�s]¶Fyv��tvoW����aw��W��Ä_¼kÅ6ÃP~C�Wq9s�qEyvo�w��a{Ps���w��'���;yv�\s�~C��¸�s_t���~Cs��_y�tv£\�¹w�q\{ª~C�W��o�yvoruks¤ÆI�Ew�~\£9q\�(uÇs]ÃP~C�Wq9s�qEyv���£9~\~C��t�y*yv�9s¤s_Ã9or��yvs�q9��s¤���I�_�\w�����¼k½�s�¾aq\{'yv�aw(y*yv�9sO�_�\w���yvor�zw�y�y�t�w��]yv��tv��w(tvsz�'£\��yvo��ht�w��]y�w��ȼ

É Ê\ˤÌCÍ;Î)Ï'Ð3Ñ©Ì;ÒvΤË

QSV�BEÓjÔpÕI7EÖ×7�DÈ[_5�8Ø5(ÙCd;:hÚ;:Y[]c�:hV]V_5�`PÛ;N=B�V�B�8&<ÜÔ�7PTUÝ;Nh5(ÙÜÚ&5�dIBkGa:Y79V�@¯Þ�[�Ö}BPc079ÚIc_5�V]GP5�<5(ÙCÝ&5�V_:hTU5�8\[]BPNYNh^àß·5P@ `I@ªá�â�ãÈä(LO[_d&BE[?BPN�[]d;7PÛ;`9dåDF7PV2Nh7EÖæB�8I<åd;:h`Pd¹Ô�B�V�cj<C5�8&c�:Y[v^ç[]d;5Tp7P[_:h7P8è:=c'V_5�NhB�[_:hGP5�Nh^�c�:hTUÝ;NY59L©DF7PVª:Y8\[_5�V_TU5W<C:hB�[_5p<C5�8Ic_:Y[v^RGEBPNYÛ;5Wc+ß·:Y8é[_d;5Uc_72Ô�BPNYNh5�<ê c_^\8&Ô�d;V_798;:hf�5�<�ÕI7EÖåÝ;dIBPc_5�ëUáYâ(ãFä*[_d;5)TU7P[_:h7P8U:hc¤Ô�dIB�V�BPÔ([_5�V]:hf�5�<�Úa^+B�ÚIV_Û;Ý;[�Ô�d&B�8;`95�c:Y8�Ô�BPV]c�G95�Nh7aÔ�:�[]:Y5Wc}B�8I<2ÕI7EÖ¹Õ&ÛCÙ¯@IiÇ5�V_5ªÖz5�c�[_ÛI<;^?BpTU7a<;5�N¯ÚIB9c�5W<2798RBUc_^ac�[_5�Tì7�D<C5�N=Bk^\í�<C:Yî!5�V]5�8\[_:=B�N¯5Wï9Û&BE[_:h7P8&c�LCÖ)d;:=Ô�dRDF7PVÇc_ÛCÓjÔ(:h5�8\[_Nh^RNhBPV_`95ª<C5�NhBk^?B�8I<R:h89[]5�V]TU5�<C:YíBE[_5)<C5�8Ic_:�[v^�GEBPNYÛ;5Wc�<C5�TU7P8&cv[]V]B�[_5�c�Ô�7PTUÝ;Nh5(Ù�Ú©5�dIBkGa:h7PVWLWB�[�[]V_:hÚ;ÛC[]5�<+[_7'[_d;5)ÝIV_5Wc�5�8IÔ(57�D�Ô�dIB�7\c�@

Q}d;5UÝ;V_5Wc�5�8IÔ(5U7PD}Ô�dIBP7�[]:hÔpÝ;d;5�8;7PTU5�8IBR:Y8Ü[_V�BEÓjÔUTU7C<C5�N=c0dIB9c0Ú&5�5�8ØV]5�Ý©7PV_[_5�<:Y8ðV]5�Ô(5�8\[�c�[_Û&<C:Y5Wc�@*>3<;<C:=c_7P8ØB�8I<Ü467EÖá ñEãO7PÚIc_5�V]GP5W<éÔ�dIBP79c0:h8ØBRc_:h8;`PNh5(í�NhBP8;5UÔ�B�V_íDF7PNhNY7EÖ):h8;`jTU7C<C5�N�:h8èÖ)d;:=Ô�dòBnNh5�B9<C:h8;`?Ô�B�V3d&BPc'79c]Ô(:hNYN=BE[]:Y8;`2GP5�Nh7CÔ(:Y[v^P@!ó3BP`9BE[�B�8;:�á ô�ãV_5�Ý&79V�[]5�<�[]d;5}Ý;V]5�c_5�8IÔ�5z7PD&B'Ô�d&B�7�[]:hÔSõ�B�TöÝ;dIBPc_5�:Y8pB'N=BE[_[_:=Ô(5�da^a<;V_7C<C^a8IBPTp:=ÔzTp7C<C5�N<C5�V]:YG95�<2DFV_79T÷[_dI5�7PÝC[]:YTnB�N¯G95�Nh7CÔ(:Y[v^jTU7a<;5�N¤á ø�ã�@

ùÇ8;Nh:Ye95ª[_d;5�BPÚ&7EG95ªc�[_ÛI<;:Y5Wc�LC79Û;V)TU7a<;5�N¯:=c)ÚIBPc_5�<?7P8�BUc�^Cc�[_5�Tì7�D�B�ÛC[]7P8;79Tp79ÛIc<C5�N=Bk^\í�<C:Yî!5�V]5�8\[_:=B�Nz5�ï\ÛIBE[]:Y798Ic�L�BP8I<Ø[]d;52[]V]BP8Ic_:�[]:Y798Ø[_7ÜÔ�dIB�7\c�:=c+Ý©79c]c_:YÚ;Nh52798;Nh^Ø:Y8[_d;5�ÝIV_5Wc�5�8IÔ(5�7PDO<C5�N=Bk^P@;úÜ5+c_d;7EÖà[_dIB�[Ç[_dI5+c_^ac�[_5�TZÔ�B�8�ÝIB9c_c}[]72Ô�dIBP79c)Ga:=BUTUBP8a^c�:hTU:YN=B�VpV_79ÛC[_5Wc�L�BP8I<Ø[]dIBE[UTnB�8a^û<C:Yî©5�V_5�89[U8;798Cí�Ô�d&B�7�[]:hÔ?B�8I<üÔ�dIB�7P[_:=Ô2B�[�[_V�BPÔ([_79V]cTUBk^�Ô�7\5�ÙC:hc�['DF79Vª[_d;5Uc_BPTU5�ÝIBPV]BPTp5�[_5�V'GEB�NhÛ;5Wc�@!úÜ5pBPNhc_7279ÚIc�5�V_G95�T�ÛIN�[]:�DFV�BPÔ([]B�Nh:Y[v^7�D�[_d;5�Ô�dIBP7�[]:hÔªBE[_[_V�BPÔ�[]7PVWLaÖ)d;:hÔ�d�:=c}8;7EGP5�N¯:Y8R[]V]B�ÓnÔ0c�[_ÛI<;:Y5Wc�@

úò5�`P5�8;5�V�B�Nh:hf�5j[]d;5�TU7a<;5�N)Ý;V]7PÝ©79c_5�<üB�8I<ücv[]ÛI<C:h5�<ü:Y8¿á ýWþ;ÿkã�Úa^Ø:h8\[_V]7a<;ÛIÔ(:h8;`[_:hTp5p<C5�N=Bk^���:Y8è[_d;5U<CV]:YG95�V�� c)V]5�B9Ô�[]:Y7986@&Q}d;5+Ý;V]5�Nh:YTU:h8IB�V]^?V]5�c_Û;NY[]c37�D�[_dI5+Ý;V]5�c_5�8\[cv[]ÛI<C^?Ô�B�8RÚ&50DF79Û;8I<R:h8ðá �Eã�@

� Æ6¼a�ǼC�Pw��h�Wq\�(u�s]yzw��ȼ

Q}d;50Tp7C<C5�N¯:hcÇÚIBPc_5�<27P8?[_d;5�B9c_c_Û;TUÝC[_:h7P8?[_d&BE[�� Ô�B�V�c�TU7EGP5ª:Y8�Bpc�:h8;`PNh50NhBP8;5B�8I<2[_d;5��![]d�Ô�B�V)TU7P[_:h7P8R:hcÇ<;5�c]Ô(V]:YÚ©5�<?Úa^n[_d;5�<;5�N=Bk^9í�<C:Yî©5�V_5�8\[_:=B�N¯5�ï\ÛIB�[_:h7P8 K� �¯ß���ä � K ��� � â���� �� ß������Iä� � ß������Iä�� � ß�âWä� K ß�� �! � ß������Iä�äñ;ß � "�6ß������Iä��$#2ä �&%'��ß � ß������Iä�� �(�)+* ä-,Ö)d;5�V]5.� � â/,1010�02,3�ûL""��:=cÇ[]d;5pÔ�B�V�� cªÔ(7a79V]<C:h8IB�[_5PL �RþR:Y[]cªG95�Nh7aÔ�:�[v^9L � B�8&<4%?þc�5�8Ic�:Y[_:hGa:�[v^?ÝIB�V�B�TU5�[_5�V�c�L5#ZþjTU:h8;:YTnBPN*<C:=cv[�B�8IÔ�5�Ú&5�[vÖz5�5�8�Ô(798Ic_5�Ô(Û;[_:hGP5�Ô�BPV]c�L (�)+*þ0Ý©5�V]TU:�[_[_5�<+GP5�NY7CÔ�:�[v^9L�6ûþ�c]BEDF5�[v^'[]:YTU5}`9BPÝ6L � �� � �56879#¿[_dI5�c]BEDF5�[v^�<C:hc�[]BP8IÔ(59L� "� � "��: H �; ��B�8&< �! � � ��: H � �!@kQ}d;5ODFÛ;8&Ô�[_:h7P8<�Ø:=c*<;52=I8;5W<�BPc���ß�©ä � DF7PV>@?BAªBP8I<9��ß�©ä � A3DF79V>@CDAI@EÞ�8U7PÛ;V�Ô(79TUÝ;ÛC[]B�[_:h7P8Ic�Ö�5}ÛIc_5z[]d;5)ÝIBPV]BPTp5�[_5�V]cGkBPNYÛI5�c (�)+* � ñPý;ß�E@FHGkä�L>6 � ñ;ßIGkä�LJ# � ýIß�E�ä�L �K� ôIß�E@FHG�KWä�LL% � ñ;ßMGHN6H(äB�8I<$� � â�AHAI@¯Q}d;5nÚ&79Û;8I<;BPV_^òÔ(7P8&<C:�[]:Y798Ic�B�V]5UÝ&5�V_:h7C<C:=Ô�L6:�@¯5P@O"PQ: H � H 7BR3L PS: H � H L;Ö)d;5�V]5�Rå:hc}[]d;5�V]79BP<2NY5�8;`�[]d6@Þ�8�[_d;:=c3c�[_ÛI<;^2Ö�5�=I8I<R[]dIBE[ÇDF79V3c_ÛCÓjÔ(:h5�8\[_Nh^?N=B�V]`P5�<C5�NhBk^2[_d;5+c�^Cc�[_5�TÚ©5�dIBkG95�c:Y8�BnÔ(79TUÝ;NY5�Ù?TnB�8I8;5�VW@Cúò5�c_d;7EÖ 8aÛ;TU5�V]:hÔ�B�NhNY^9La[_dIB�[)[_d;5�BPÚ&7EG95'TU5�89[]:Y798;5�<RNh:YTU:Y[Ô(^CÔ(Nh5�c3TUBk^?Ú;:YDFÛ;V]Ô�BE[]5�:Y8\[]7n[vÖz7Pí�<;:YTU5�8&c�:h7P8IBPN![_79V_:�@Iú :Y[_d�DFÛIV�[]d;5�VªÔ�dIB�8;`95�7�DO<C5�8Cíc�:Y[v^�[]d;5Ç[]7PV]:;Ú;:YDFÛ;V]Ô�BE[]5):Y8\[_7�[_d;V]5�5�í�<C:hTU5�8Ic_:h7P8IBPNa[_7PV]:�LPÖ)d;:=Ô�dnB�V]5Çc�Û;Ú&c�5Wï9ÛI5�8\[_Nh^+<C5�ícv[]V_7E^95�<pDF7PV]TU:Y8I`pÔ�dIBP7�[]:hÔ'BE[�[]V]B9Ô�[]7PV�c�@\Q}d;:hc}c]Ô(5�8IB�V]:Y7+:hc�ea8;7EÖ)82B9cLTÇÛ;5�NhNY5�í�Q�B�e95�8Ic�íóÇ5�Ö)dI7PÛIc_50V_79ÛC[_5ª[_7jÔ�d&B�79c0á UEã�@V WpÍYX�Ë�ZaÒvÌCÒ�Î¤Ë ÌaÎ\[�]�X�ÎLZQS7èc�[_ÛI<;^é[]d;5n[_V�B�8&c�:Y[_:h7P8Ü[_7òÔ�dIB�7\c0Öz59=&V]c�[�Ô(798Ic�:=<C5�V�[_d;5jDF7PNhNY7EÖ):h8;`èc_7PNhÛC[_:h7P8ð7�Dc�^Cc�[_5�T ßvâWä

�� � � �_^`a `bced HfNhgjifk :ml-nporqMsc irt :ml ,vuwC Hg : t n orqMs ,HfNhgjiift , uw? Hg : t n orq�s , � � � �x�åâu 7 � �-, ß�ñPä

Ö)d;5�V]5yu � �wFzRð:=cO[]d;5'Ô�B�V�cO<C5�8&c�:Y[v^P@aQ}d;:=c¤c_7PNhÛC[_:h7P8jÔ�7PV]V_5Wc�Ý©7P8I<Ic�[_7�[]d;53dI7PTU7P`95(í8;5�79ÛIczÕI7EÖ�L9:h82Ö)dI:hÔ�dRB�NhN!Ô�B�V�c¤d&BkGP5Ç[]d;50c_BPTp5ªGP5�NY7CÔ�:�[v^nB�8&<jd;5WBP<CÖ}Bk^Cc¤B�V]535Wï\ÛIB�N�@úò5p:Y8\[]V_7C<CÛIÔ�5pB28;5�ÖöGkBPV_:=B�ÚINY5|{�� � � �}� â~F~uR:h8òM¤ï©@�ßvâkä�@���^?[]d;:=cªÔ�d&B�8;`95�7�DGkBPV_:=B�ÚINY5Wc)[_dI5+d;79TU7P`P5�8;5�79ÛIc}ÕI7EÖ c_7PNhÛC[]:Y798çß�ñ9ä):=c'TnBPÝ;Ý&5W<�[_7?f�5�V_7&@&Þ�[�c'c�[]BPÚ;:YNh:Y[v^Ô�B�8RÚ©5�B�8IBPNY^af�5W<2Û&c�:h8;`p[_d;5�Nh:h8;5�BPV_:hf�B�[_:h7P827PD�Mzïac�@6ß�âWä�{ �� ß���ä � �>�8�{ �� ß������Iäm7����M{ ���: H ß������Iä>��{ �� ß������Iäp�/, ß�ô9ä

Ö)d;5�V]5�� ��� 6yu;7D%h,�� � c t :ml t nporq�sf:ml gc t i :ml � � u\K�:�Dju�C Hg : t n�ofq�s B�8I<8� ��� 6yu©L� ��� uj7P[_d;5�V_Ö):=c_5P@�;7PNhNh7EÖ):Y8;`�á øIL�ýkã�LCÖz50Nh7\79enDF7PVÇBUc_7PNhÛC[_:h7P8R7�D�5�ï\ÛIB�[_:h7P8Ic�ß�ô9äz:h8?[]d;50DF7PV]T{ �� � 5�ÙaÝ*ß��+�e�H�}7��'��ä-, ß·ø\ä

x��aw��W�¤w�q\{p�ª£9��yvor�Yt�w��]y�w��rory��porqpw'yvor��s]¶�{9s���w���y�t�w�µ��)����{Ps��  

Ö)d;5�V]5�� � � Kr�P4� ß � � AY,�010�02,3���òâkä�B�8&<}�j:=c�B�Ô(79TpÝINY5�Ùp8aÛ;T+Ú&5�V�@CAaÛ;ÚIc�[_:Y[_Û;[_:h8;`ßFø\ä�:h8\[_7�ß·ô\ä�Öz5079ÚC[]BP:Y8�Bnc�5�[)7�D�B�Nh`P5�ÚIV]BP:hÔ'5�ï\ÛIB�[_:h7P8IczDF7PV��� K 7¹á �"�w���CßM���������åâWä�ã�� Nh��� � A'0 ß�ýPäQ}d;5éc_7PNhÛC[_:h7P8IcU7PD�M¤ïac�@Çß�ýPänBPV_5�[]d;5è5�:Y`95�8aGEB�NhÛ;5�cU7PD0c_^Ccv[]5�T ß·ô9ä(@S�'8;5�7PDª[]d;5�c_5c�79NYÛC[]:Y798IcRßÈDF7PV � � A9ä�:hcpf�5�V]7I@�Q}d;5?7P[_d;5�V]c+dIBkG9528;5�`9BE[]:YG952V]5�BPN�Ý&B�V_[�DF7PVnc_ÛCÓUíÔ(:h5�8\[_Nh^�d;:Y`9déB�8&<éc_ÛCÓjÔ(:h5�8\[_Nh^�NY7EÖ GEB�NhÛ;5�c'7�DLu&L©Ö)d;:=Ô�dè:Y8&<C:hÔ�BE[]5�c3[_d;5Ucv[�B�Ú;:hNh:�[v^�7�D[_d;5+d;7PTU7P`95�8;5�7PÛIc�Õ&7EÖ c_7PNhÛC[]:Y7986@&>'c�uR<C5�Ô�V_5WBPc_5�c�ß·:Y8IÔ�V_5WBPc_5�c�ä�L;Ý&B�:hV]c37�DOÔ(79TpÝINY5�Ù5�:h`P5�8aGEB�NhÛ;5WcSTnBk^0Ô(V]79c]c6[]d;5z:hTnB�`9:Y8IBPV_^0BEÙC:=c�LkÔ�BPÛIc_:Y8;`Ç[_d;5zDF7PV]TnBE[_:h7P8�7�D&c_TnB�NhN9Nh:YTU:Y[Ô(^CÔ(Nh5�c�ß�iÇ7PÝ;D�Ú;:YDFÛ;V�Ô�B�[_:h7P8Ic�ä�@

úò5pcv[]ÛI<C^R[_d;5�DF7PV]TnBE[_:h7P8�7PD�NY:hTU:�[�Ô(^CÔ(Nh5�c3Ö):�[]d�[_dI5p<C5�8Ic_:�[v^�<C5�Ô�V_5WBPc_:Y8I`UDFV_79Td;:Y`9d�[_7j:h8\[_5�V_TU5�<;:hB�[_5�GEB�NhÛ;5Wc�@©465([3DF7PV'c_7PTU5|u � u � M¤ïac�@Sß�ý9ä)Ö):Y[_dèc_7PTU5 � dIBkGP5BûÝIBP:YV?7�D�Ý;Û;V]5�Nh^ :YTnBP`P:h8IB�V]^üc_7PNhÛC[_:h7P8&céß·BüiÇ79ÝCD�Ú;:YDFÛ;V�Ô�BE[]:Y798 Ý&79:Y8\[�ä�@��;79Vxu �u � �& jÖ�58=I8I<é[_d;5n8;5�Ö)NY^\í�Ú&79V_8òNY:hTU:�[�Ô�^CÔ(Nh5+:h8Ü[_d;5pDF7PV]T¡{1�¯ß���ä;¢£ z{z�� ß���ä�L¯Û&c�:h8;`B�8èB�ÝIÝ;V_7kÙC:hTnBE[_50[]5�Ô�d;8I:hï\Û;5�c_:hTp:hN=B�V)[]7n[_dIB�['ÛIc_5�<�:h8çá�ÿWã*DF7PV)[]d;5�8;798Cí�<C5�N=Bk^?Ô�BPc_5P@�'Ú\Ga:h7PÛIc_Nh^PL9[_d;5'ÕI7EÖ¹c�[]BE[]5ªÔ�7PV]V_5Wc�Ý©7P8&<C:Y8I`�[_7�[_d;:=c}NY:hTU:�[)Ô(^CÔ�NY5ª:hc�B+Ö�BkG95ÇÖ):�[]d2[]d;5Ö�BkG95�Nh5�8;`P[_d25Wï\ÛIB�N![]7wRSF � ß·:Y8�Nh5�8;`P[_d�Û;8;:Y[]c�ä�7PVy�wF � ß·:Y8�8aÛ;T+Ú&5�V)7�D�Ô�B�V�c�ä�@

>)DÈ[_5�V}[_d;5�c_TnB�NhN©Nh:hTp:Y[3Ô(^CÔ�NY5'DF7PV)<C5�8Ic�:Y[v^2Ô�NY7\c�5'[_7+[_d;5�i37PÝCD�Ú;:YDFÛ;V]Ô�BE[]:Y7982GEB�NhÛ;5:hc}DF79Û;8I<�B�8&B�Nh^9[]:hÔ�B�NhNY^9LC:�[�c)`PNh7PÚ&B�N6Ô(798\[_:h8\Û&BE[_:h7P8R:=c)Ý&5�V�DF79V_TU5W<28aÛ;TU5�V]:=Ô�B�NhNh^j:Y8�[]d;5DF7PNhNY7EÖ):h8;`�TnB�8I8;5�VW@/�I7PVJu<¤Bu � �} 0Öz5Ç[]B�e95)[_dI5'B�8&B�Nh^9[]:hÔ�B�NhNY^+DF7PÛI8I<jB�ÝIÝ;V_7kÙC:hTnBE[_5Ý&5�V_:h7C<C:hÔ'c�79NYÛ;[_:h7P82B9czBP8n:Y8;:Y[_:=B�N¯Ô�7P8I<C:Y[_:h7P8?B�8I<jc_7PNhGP5'M¤ïac�@!ßvâkä�8aÛ;TU5�V]:=Ô�B�NhNh^P@9>ÇDÈ[_5�V[_d;5�c�79NYÛC[]:Y798�dIB9cSV]5�B9Ô�d;5�<0B�8+BE[�[]V]B9Ô�[]:Y8;`'c�5�[�LWÖz5�<C5�Ô�V_5WBPc_5ju'Ö):Y[_d+B3c_TUBPNYNac�[_5�Ý+B�8I<c�79NYG95�[]d;5n5�ï\ÛIB�[_:h7P8Ic08aÛ;TU5�V]:=Ô�B�NhNh^èB�`9BP:Y8SL![]B�ea:h8;`?[_d;5nV]5�c_Û;NY[]cªDFV]7PT []d;5nÝ;V]5�Ga:Y79ÛIccv[]5�ÝéB9cÇ:h8;:�[]:hBPN�Ô�7P8I<;:�[]:Y798Ic�@!Q}d;:=c3ÝIV_7CÔ(5W<CÛ;V]5�:hc':Y[_5�V�BE[]5�<�DFÛIV�[]d;5�VW@IÞ�8é[_d;:=c3Ö}Bk^2Ö�5eP5�5�Ý2[]d;50[_V�BPÔ�e27�DS[]d;5�ÝIBPV�[]:hÔ�Û;NhBPV}NY:hTU:�['Ô�^CÔ(Nh5P@�;7PV�[_d;5?8;7P8;í�<C5�NhBk^ðÔ�B9c�5òá ÿkãzÖ�52dIBkG95j8;7�[�DF7PÛ;8I<üB�8a^Ü7�[_dI5�V+B�[�[]V]B9Ô�[_:h8;`éc_5([�c[_dIBP8?Nh:YTU:Y[3Ô(^CÔ(Nh5�c)BP8I<}=;ÙC5�<?Ý&79:Y8\[]c�@;ú :Y[_d�BUc�TnBPNYN¯<C5�NhBk^n[]d;5�c�^Cc�[_5�T�� c}Ú©5�dIBkGa:h7PV

0.12 0.13 0.14 0.15 0.16 0.17κ=18

ρ

κ=15

κ=12

κ=16

κ=14

κ=10

limit cycle two-torus three-torus/chaos¥j¦¨§ ´z©a´ �����_�9s���w�yvor�S¦\o��=£Ptv��w�yvor��qª{PoYw�§�t�w��U�����\��¸Oorq\§Oy�t�w�q9��oryvor��q3yv�O���aw����©�htv���ü��o�ÃÇ{Po�º;s]t�¶s]q�yO�ror��o�yO�]�P���rs���¼\¨��\s�¾\§W£9tvs����\��¸O��yv�aw�yO�ror��o�yO�]�P���rs����Py�¸���¶Fyv��tvo&w�qa{��_�\w���yvo��Çw(y�y�t�w��]yv��tv���w�qU���Es_Ã9or��yO�=��tzyv�9s}�vw���s�~aw�t�w���s]yvs]t¤u�w��r£\s��ÇÂÈ��s�s}yv�9s}uks]t�yvor��w��©{9w����9s�{p�rorq\s(Ä_¼

¡ Æ6¼a�ǼC�Pw��h�Wq\�(u�s]yzw��ȼ

<C7a5�c�8;7P[�Ô�dIB�8I`P5nï\ÛIB�Nh:�[�BE[]:YG95�Nh^P@O�;79V�d;:h`Pd;5�V�GkBPNYÛI5�c�7PDS� ß·BPÚ&7EG95nB�Ý;Ý;V]7kÙC:YTnB�[_5�Nh^A;@�ý;ß+ª�ä_ä6[]d;5)Ô(^CÔ(Nh5�c�TnBk^�Û;8I<;5�V]`P73ÚI:�DFÛ;V�Ô�B�[_:h7P8Ic�Nh5�B9<C:Y8I`3[]7'[]d;5�[_V�B�8Ic_:Y[_:h7P8�[]7ªÔ�d&B�79c�@> Ú;:YDFÛ;V�Ô�BE[]:Y798è<C:=B�`PV�B�T7PÚ;[]B�:h8;5W<RDFV_79T`9NY79ÚIB�N*Ô(7P8\[]:Y8aÛIB�[_:h7P8�7�D¤c_:YÙ�<;:�î!5�V]5�8\[

NY:hTU:�[)Ô(^CÔ(Nh5�c¤DF7PVQ� � A'0 ýHUIß�ªväO:hc�c_eP5([�Ô�d;5�<j:Y8��*:h`I@!â9@\Q}d;5«=I`9Û;V_5'c�d;7EÖÇc¤[_dI53[]V]BP8Ic�:Yí[_:h7P8jDFV]7PT�5WBPÔ�dj7PD¯[_d;5Wc�50Ô(^CÔ(Nh5�c¤[_7pÔ�dIB�7\c¤Ga:=B�B�[vÖz7Pí�[]7PV]ÛIcOÝ;d&BPc_5P@\Þ�[�:=c¤:hTUÝ&79V�[�B�8\[[_7n8;7P[_5�[]dIBE['Ô�d&B�7�[]:hÔ0BP8I<�8;7P8;í�Ô�dIBP7�[]:hÔ0BE[_[_V�BPÔ([_7PV�c}Ô(7a5(ÙC:=cv[)DF79V)[_dI5�c_BPTU5�ÝIB�V�B�Tpí5([_5�V]c}GEBPNYÛ;5Wc�@

¥j¦¨§ ´�¬I´�² �8­2®IÂ�¯�Äz�=��t«°²±ö«��P�"³@±ö«���� ´�± �Hµ ���P·¶�ÄÇw�q\{}¸}±à�Hµr«� �¹~ºP·»«¼ l Ä_¼ ­ �nyv�\s�]��t�tvs���~C��qa{9orq9§�~C�(¸�s]t¤��~Cs��]y�tv£9�U¼

�*:h`I@¯ñ�½òc�dI7EÖÇcÇ[]d;5!{��¯ß���ä3[_:hTU5pc_5�V]:Y5Wc)DF79V � � âkýCL"u � A'0YâWôH�aÿCß�¾!N¯H�ä'B�8&<èB�8B�V]Ú;:�[]V]BPV_:hNh^pÔ�d;7\c�5�8w��@¿��:Y`&@Cñ�ÀðÝ;V_5Wc�5�8\[]c¤[_d;5�Ô(79V_V]5�c_Ý©7P8I<C:h8;`�Ý©7EÖ�5�V}c�Ý©5�Ô([_V]Û;T�@\Þ�[�c5(ÙCÝ&798;5�8\[]:hBPN6<C5�Ô�Bk^j:hc)BUc_:Y`98�7�D�Ô�d&B�7�[]:hÔªÚ©5�dIBkGa:h7PV}7�D�7PÛIV}c_^Ccv[]5�T á�â�AEã�@

>Ç8;7P[_d;5�Vª:h8I<C:=Ô�B�[_:h7P8Ü7�D}Ô�dIB�7\c':=cª[_dI5p5�ÙC:hc�[_5�8IÔ(5U7�D�Ý&7\c�:Y[_:hGP5U46^\B�Ý;ÛI8;7EG�5(ÙCÝ&7Pí8;5�8\[]c�@�>æ<C:YV]5�Ô([UÔ�B�N=Ô(Û;N=BE[]:Y798û7�D'[_d;5RN=B�V]`P5�c�[p4S^9BPÝ;Û;8;7EGð5(ÙCÝ©7P8;5�8\[�áYâPâ�ã}BP8I<û[]d;546^9BPÝ;Û;8;7EG�5(ÙCÝ&798;5�8\[�c¤c_Ý&5WÔ�[_V]Û;Tæá�âkñkãI^a:h5�N=<;c�[]d;V]5�5)Ý©79c_:�[]:YG95346^\B�Ý;Û;8I7EG�5(ÙCÝ©7P8;5�89[�c7�D�7PV�<C5�V0â�AYN Á�@

0 200 400 600 800 10000

200

400

600

0 200 400 600 800 10000

200

400

600

x [m]

t [se

c]

¥j¦¨§ ´�ÂI´ �P~aw���s]¶Fyvor��s3{9o�w�§�t�w��������6yv�\s)y�t�w�µ��yÃa��¸ü�=��t�³9± «���w�qa{<¸.±å��µ�«W·» ¼ l Ä_¼aÆ&s]�Yy¶e´!±å�Hµ ¡\·¶�ÄÇÂFw0��or��o�yz�]�P���rs(Ä3Äatvor§W�Ey¤¶�´!±å�Hµ ���9·¶�Ä'ÂÈ���aw�����Ä_¼;ÅSw����j{9��yz����t�tvs���~C�Wq\{9�zyv��w��w�t�¼

>3c�7PÚIc_5�V]GP5W<U:Y8RV]5�B�N&[_V�BEÓjÔPL�õ�BPTUc�ÛIc_ÛIBPNYNh^nTU7EGP53:h82ÛIÝIcv[]V_5WB�Tì<C:hV]5�Ô�[]:Y7986@'�'Û;VTp7C<C5�N6V]5�Ý;V]7C<CÛIÔ(5Wc�[_d;:=c)Ý;dI5�8;79Tp5�8;7P8S@'��:Y`&@;ôUÝ;V_5Wc�5�8\[]c)c_ÝIBPÔ�5(í�[_:hTp5�<C:=B�`9V]BPTnc¤DF79V[_d;53[_V�BEÓjÔ�ÕI7EÖåDF7PV¤[_d;53Ô�BPc_5�c�7PD¯[_d;5'c�^Cc�[_5�T :=cO7P8jB�NY:hTU:�[}Ô(^CÔ(Nh53B�8&<U7P8jB�Ô�dIBP7�[]:hÔBE[�[]V]B9Ô�[]7PVW@5�'8;5ªÔ�B�8?Ô(Nh5�B�V]Nh^p79ÚIc_5�V]GP5�õ�BPTUczTU7EGa:Y8;`+Û;ÝIc�[_V]5�BPTRL\Ú;ÛC[}:h8j[_dI5ªÔ�dIBP7�[]:hÔ

x��aw��W�¤w�q\{p�ª£9��yvor�Yt�w��]y�w��rory��porqpw'yvor��s]¶�{9s���w���y�t�w�µ��)����{Ps�� �

Ô�BPc_5�[]d;5�^ B�V]5�8;7�[RV_5�`PÛ;N=B�VjBP8I< Ý©5�V]dIB�Ý&cnNY7a79eüTU7PV]5èc_:YTU:hNhBPVj[_7çÖ)dIBE[�Ô�B�8 Ú©57PÚIc_5�V]GP5W<j7P8?[_dI5�V_7\BP<¯@Å Æ1ЫÇ�Ì;Ò�È�ÍYX�Ñ©Ì¿X>Ç�ÒvÌ�ÉËÊ Ë�X>Ç+ÉyZaÒpZQ}d;5'Ô�dIBP7�[]:hÔ�:�[v^U7�DSBP82BE[_[_V�BPÔ([_7PV�Ô�BP82B�N=c�7�Ú&50Ô�dIB�V�BPÔ([_5�V_:hf�5W<+Úa^n:Y[]c¤DFV]B9Ô�[�B�N!<C:YTU5�8Cíc�:h7P8Ic�@CúÜ5�Ô(7P8&c�:=<C5�V}[]d;5�Ô(79V_V]5�N=BE[]:Y798jDFÛ;8IÔ([_:h7P8�7�D�[_dI5�Tp79TU5�8\[y�

ÌQÍ ß�Î�ä �ÐÏ âÑ ÒÓ �ÕÔ HJÖ âÑ ÒÓ× Ô HhØ � Î;��Ù Ú � ��Ú × Ù �-ÛÍ N¯H3Ü¡ÝÞ�ß Ý , ßMà9ä

Ö)d;5�V]5yÚ � � ß�{1�¯ß�� � ä2,p{1�Sß�� � 7 � ��ä2,1010�01,3{1�¯ß�� � 7ûß �éâkä � ��ä�ä¤B�V]5 í�<C:hTU5�8Ic_:Y798IB�N&GP5WÔ�í[_7PV�cUß :=c�Ô�BPNYNh5�<ò5�T+Ú&5W<;<C:h8;`è<C:hTU5�8Ic_:Y798&ä�L � �ª:hcª[]d;5U[_dI5!=&V]c�[�f�5�V]7R7�D�[_d;5p[_:hTU5c�5�V_:h5�c+B�ÛC[]7aÔ�7PV]V_5�NhB�[_:h7P8ðDFÛ;8&Ô�[_:h7P8SL Ø :hc�[_d;5�iÇ5WBkGa:hc_:h<;5?c�[_5�ÝûDFÛ;8IÔ�[]:Y798åBP8I<�Ñ :=c[_d;5ª[_:hTU5�c�5�V_:h5�c�Nh5�8;`P[_d6LCÖ)dI:hÔ�d�c�dI7PÛ;N=<2Ú©5�c�Û;ÓnÔ�:Y5�8\[_Nh^jNhBPV_`95P@CQ}d;5�Ô(79V_V]5�N=BE[]:Y7982<C:YíTp5�8Ic_:Y798w# Í :=c¤<;52=I8;5W<nÚa^�[]d;53V]5�N=BE[]:Y798 ÌQÍ ß�Î�äJ¢áÎ~g Þ ß·c_5�5�áYâ�ôILYâ�ø�ãIB�8&<UV_5�DF5�V]5�8IÔ�5�c[_d;5�V_5�:Y8RDF7PV)TU79V_50<C5([�B�:hNhc�ä�@

QS7.=I8I<2[_d;50Ô(79V_V]5�N=BE[]:Y798j<C:YTU5�8Ic�:h7P8&cz8aÛ;TU5�V_:=Ô�BPNYNh^UÖz5ªÛIc_53[]d;5ªBPNY`97PV]:�[]d;T�Ý;V]7�íÝ&7\c�5W<?:h8Øá�â�ø�ã�@;ù3c_:Y8I`U[_d;5Wc�5�<C:hTU5�8Ic_:h7P8Ic}798;5�Ô�BP8R79ÚC[]BP:Y8?[_dI5!â�ß���äzDFÛ;8IÔ([_:h7P8ûáYâWýkã�LÖ)d;:hÔ�d�V]5�Ý;V]5�c_5�8\[�c¤[]d;5�c_Ý&5WÔ�[_V]Û;Tì7PD*DFV�BPÔ([]BPN6<C:YTU5�8Ic�:h7P8&c}7�D�[_d;5�B�[�[_V�BPÔ([_79V�@

-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8q

3

4

5

6

7

8

Dq

d=7d=8d=9d=10d=11

a

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 100

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

α

f(α)

d=11

d=10

d=9

d=8

d=7

b

¥j¦¨§ ´2ã©´�² ¼I�¤s���£\��yv�}������s�w���£9tvs���s�qEy�����yv�9sª����t�tvs���w�yvor�Wq�{Por��s�q\��or�Wq�ä«åª�h��t�æ.±èçLºzµéµ ºw�qa{.ê;±�º�µéµr«W«�ÂȦC��y�yv�W� yv�ªyv��~CÄ_¼ ­ ¼\�z~9~9tv��ÃPo���w(yvsyë©Â�ì6Ä�¾\yv���h��tOyv�\s]��sÇ{\w�y�w�¼

�*:h`I@©ø/½òc�dI7EÖÇcÇ[]d;5+V]5�c_Û;NY[]cª7�DzTp5WBPc_Û;V]5�TU5�8\[]c37�DL# Í DF7PVí� � �'ÿ¿0Õ0rÿnBP8I< �ÿ50¨0Yâ9âP@¿��:�[_[_:h8;`p[_d;5Wc�5�<;B�[]B+Ö):�[]d�BpÔ(798\[_:h8\ÛI7PÛIczDFÛ;8IÔ([_:h7P8�#èß���äzDF79V}5�BPÔ�d LCÖ�5«=I8I<[_d;5.â�ßM��äzDFÛ;8&Ô�[_:h7P8�B9Ô�Ô(79V]<;:Y8;`+[_7U[]d;50DF7PV]T�ÛINhBâ�ßM�zßM��ä�ä � �z��ß���ä����6ß���ä2,Ö)d;5�V]5í�6ß���ä � ß��;�åâWä�#éß���ä}B�8&<x��ß���ä � � F �Rß�c�5�505P@ `I@6áYâWýkãFä�@>3cOÔ�B�8UÚ&5)79ÚIc_5�V]GP5�<�DFV]7PT���:h`I@�ø�½¯LE[]d;5)GEB�NhÛ;5�c�7PDh# Í c_d;7EÖçÖ�5�BPe�Ô(798aGP5�V]`P5�8IÔ(5Ö):�[]då`9V_7EÖ):h8;`$�aLO5�c_Ý©5�Ô(:=B�NhNh^ØDF7PV Ô(Nh79c_5?[]7&A;@¤Q}d;5�V_5�DF7PV]5PL�Ý;V]5�c_5�8\[_5W<åGkBPNYÛI5�cU7�D<C:YTU5�8Ic�:h7P8&cÇTnBk^?Ú©5pÛ;8I<C5�V_5Wcv[]:YTnBE[]5�<¯@©óÇ5�GP5�V_[_dI5�Nh5�c]c�L©c�dIBPÝ&5WcÇ7PDLâ�ß���ä}DF7PVª5�B9Ô�d 5�8IBPÚ;NY50ÛIc)[_7nÔ(N=B�:hTì[]d;5�T�Û;NY[_:YDFV�BPÔ�[�B�Nh:�[v^27�DS[]d;5�Ô(798Ic_:h<C5�V_5W<?B�[�[]V]B9Ô�[_79V�@

¢ Æ6¼a�ǼC�Pw��h�Wq\�(u�s]yzw��ȼîDï È ï Í ï Ë3Ñ ï Z«�¼ � ¼ �;¼�ð)s]tvq\s]t��5ñ'¼a�¤s���¦C��tvq'òa�6�E�P��¼a�¤s�uC¼CÅ&ó  �C�z¡k��º��nÂ�«��W��¢kÄ � ¼ �C¼5ð)s]tvq9s]t��¿ñ'¼\�zs_¶��¦C��tvq ò&�6�E�9��¼&�¤s�uC¼©ÆIs]y�y�¼�ô�õI�&¡k�W ���Â�«����~ºWÄ � ¼ �;¼ ð)s]tvq9s]t-ò!�6�E�P��o��]�ǽR��tv��{ò«��?ÂF�z£P¶§W£9��y_Ä_�C���+Â�«����W�kÄ

�E¼Ç�!¼ �C¼k�z{\{Po�����q&��|ª¼ ö9¼EÆI��¸�òPx��aw��W�e÷I��º��P«3Â�«�����¹kį|ª¼ ö9¼kÆ&��¸)���!¼ �;¼W��{\{Por���Wq ò�Á���q\�rorq\s�w(t|��Pqaw���o��]� ©Hø �&«(��º�Â�«��W��¹kÄ

 �¼Ç¨�¼\Á�w�§Ww�y�w�q9o�òC�6���P��¼9�zs]u;¼9Å ø�ù �I«(�� W�pÂ�«����W�kÄ¡P¼3m?¼ � w�q\{9�P�2ð0¼2ñ}w���s]¦CsW���3¼(Á�w�À�w��Ew���wP���3¼����\or¦aw(y�wP�-úª¼(�P£\§�o���w���w����S�E�P��¼��¤s�uC¼(Å}ó © �«��� k�0Â�«����k�WÄOúª¼k�P£\§�o���w���w�¼k��q'ò�û�ü+ý-þpÿ�ÿ���������¶Sý��<ý�ü��1¶ /ý��}ý�����ü���þ���������ü����������ü� �éý�� �"!$#$#&%�')(&�*� ��þ+ -,��©s�{;¼©¦E�2|ª¼ Å�¼&½R�W�����¯m?¼6�P���9tvs]�_Àks]qP¦Cs_tv§9�&�3¼ � w����\s]� Â=½���tv��{�P��ors�qEyvo�¾a���a��orq\§kw�~C��tvs�«����W¢WÄ

�E¼ÇÅO¼\¨©����s]t��9ÆS¼a�9w��h�Wq9��uC�C�;¼ ñ}w�u��ro�q'ò9�S�E�P��¼\�¤s�uC¼9Æ&s]y�y�¼5÷ ã �\ �¹W�p·�����W�kÄ¢�¼ÇÅO¼k¨©�W��s_t��kÆ6¼��9w(�=��q\�(uC�Ew�q\{��;¼�ñ}w�u��rorq&¼k��q ò.��ü��"��þ/��������ü����������ü � �éý��10 #$#32545ý-þ6�7���$� '��ü��"��þ8�-�5���eü����*�*���1ü:9/;�����»<��þr¶��Ws�{I¼�¦E�Ç|ª¼�ñ�s��r¦\orq9§9�~ñ3¼ ö9¼�ñzs]t�tv��w�q9q&�Wm?¼k�P���9tvs���ÀE¶s�q�¦Cs]tv§9�9|ª¼ Å�¼9½R�W����·�P~Ptvorq\§Ws_t���ñzs�o�{9s��r¦Cs]tv§&= � s]tv�rorq2�����W�WÄ_�C~&¼P¡9«���¶·¡E�(¡ºE¼ÇÆS¼ �3¼\�Pw��=��q\�(uC�CÅ�¼a¨&�W��s]t�� � ¼ � ¼\�Ey�t��9§�orq&�\�;¼/ñ}w�u��ro�q'òa�6�E�P��o���w0� ¬ ÷�óI�&«]¡zºp·���W�W�WĹ�¼ÇÆS¼ �3¼��9w(�=�Wq9�(u;��Å�¼(¨©����s]t�� � ¼ � ¼��Ey�t��9§�orq&�rú'¼(�z���9Àks�q\w��]�E���;¼rñ}w�u���orq'ò(ÅS£Ptv�W~9���P��¼�Æ&s]y�y�¼r�orqp~9tvs]���3·���W��«(Ä

��¼3�;¼©Á�s]¸O�9�W£\��s��¯|ª¼¯�¤£\s��r�rsW�?>�¼¯¨!w�Àks]q\�fò6x������ª£9q&¼!mUw�yv�&¼¯�S�E�P��¼ ø/ã �¯ k��Â�«���º�¹kÄ3|ª¼�z£9s��r�rsW��>�¼\¨!w�Àks�q\���ax��W���'£\qI¼9mUw�yv�&¼\�6���P��¼ ¬�ù �&«�¢�ºpÂ�«��~ºE«(Ä

«��P¼�ñ3¼ �'¼C���_��£\��yvs_t��59�ÿ�@Mÿ3ü3»A�����¨¶+@7��þ�BC *�~ý1¶D2.EF�HG+��@�ü·ýI���/þ6@7��ý��j � xeñ'��½�s]o�q9�\s�or��«��W�k��Ä«�«W¼3m?¼ ¨�¼\�z����s�q\��yvs�orqI�5ö9¼ ö9¼Cx��W�r�rorq\���Ixz¼ ö9¼\|}sÇÆ&£9��wHò\�S�E�P��or��wª| ø óI�&«�«2ºpÂ�«��W�W WÄ«���¼Ç�Ǽ�½��W�����¿ö9¼ � ¼C��¸Oo��hy���ñ'¼ ÆS¼\��¸Oorq9q\s]�E�\�3¼ � w���y�w�q9�/ò\�S�E�P��or��wª| ©�ø �;�1¹k�pÂ�«���¹k��Ä«� P¼Ç�!¼E�zt�w�����¦Cs]tv§�s]t����_¼k�6tv�E��w�����o�wHòP�6�E�P��o���wÇ|�õ;�a«-¹���Â�«���¹� kÄmð0¼k�¯w�¸�s��r��orÀC��ñ'¼ �'¼����_��£9��¶yvs]t-ò\�S�E�P��¼P�zs�uC¼9�  óI�a¡�¹P«�Â�«���¹~º�Ä

«]¡9¼Qú'¼9�z���\ÀWs�qaw��]�Yò\�6�E�P��o���w0� ¬ ô © �a¡k��ºpÂ�«����W�WÄ«���¼3xz¼ ö9¼ �'¼6Å6uks]t�yv����� � ¼ � ¼*mUw�qa{9s]��¦Ptv��y��?Jrmp£9��yvor�Yt�w��]y�w�����s�w���£Ptvs���¼�K!��q òhñ3¼ ¶L'¼©�!s�o�yv§Ws]q&�ñ'¼/ö5M£Ptv§Ws�q9���C|ª¼a�9w�£\~CsHBC *�~ý1¶N���5� � ü���þ6@O�$� ¶6PCQyÿ�� � ü·ý���@7��ÿ3üp¶«ý��4¿þ6��ÿ��5þ3ÿ}·��~9tvorq\§�s]t�¶� s_tv�Yw�§9�9Á�s]¸�ú*��tvÀn«����k��Ä_�a~\~I¼9�k��«_¶���¡W¡