Putusan KIP

21
SALINAN PUTUSAN Nomor: 006/VII/KIP-PS-M-A/2010 [1.1] Komisi Infonnasi Pusat Republik Indonesia memeriksa, memutus, dan menjatuhkan putusan dalam Sengketa Informasi Publik Nomor: 006/VII/KIP-PS-M-A/2010 yang diajukan oleh: Nama Alamat : Indonesia Corruption Watch (ICW) : 11. KalibataTimur IV/D No.6 1akarta Selatan12740 Diwakili oleh Ade Irawan, Agus Sunaryanto, Febri Henry yang bertindak untuk dan atas nama IeW. Selanjutnya disebut sebagai Pemohon. Nama : Kepala Sekolah SMP Negeri 190 Jakarta Alamat :11. Prepeden 15 R T 004/07 Kamal, Kalideres, 1akarta Barat 11810. selanjutnya disebut sebagai Termohon I. Nama : Kepala Sekolah SMP Negeri 95 Jakarta Alamat :11. Ganggeng III No.3 Tanjung Priok , 1akarta Utara selanjutnya disebut sebagai Termohon II.

description

Putusan KIP tentang sengketa informasi laporan SPJ penggunaan anggaran dana BOS dan DPO kepada kepala SMPN 67, SMPN 28, SMPN 84, SMPN 95 dan SMPN 190 Jakarta

Transcript of Putusan KIP

Page 1: Putusan KIP

SALINAN

PUTUSAN

Nomor: 006/VII/KIP-PS-M-A/2010

[1.1] Komisi Infonnasi Pusat Republik Indonesia memeriksa, memutus, dan menjatuhkan

putusan dalam Sengketa Informasi Publik Nomor: 006/VII/KIP-PS-M-A/2010 yang diajukan

oleh:

Nama

Alamat

: Indonesia Corruption Watch (ICW)

: 11.Kalibata Timur IV/D No.6 1akarta Selatan 12740

Diwakili oleh Ade Irawan, Agus Sunaryanto, Febri Henry yang bertindak untuk dan atas

nama IeW. Selanjutnya disebut sebagai Pemohon.

Nama : Kepala Sekolah SMP Negeri 190 Jakarta

Alamat : 11.Prepeden 15 RT 004/07 Kamal, Kalideres, 1akarta Barat 11810.

selanjutnya disebut sebagai Termohon I.

Nama : Kepala Sekolah SMP Negeri 95 Jakarta

Alamat : 11.Ganggeng III No.3 Tanjung Priok , 1akarta Utara

selanjutnya disebut sebagai Termohon II.

Page 2: Putusan KIP

:kalas 8H/,Selamfja Mn,/ Hajapsa Usapa

rekamitsmyadhrebts rebafah Teplngnm GGG,

Mala 8Ieoaka Sejnkag SKP Mefeph45 Hajapsa

:kalas 8H/,Khmamfjabat Bakal Mn,1 Seshabtdh( Hajapsa Sekasam

rekamitsmyadhrebts rebafah Teplngnm GV,

Mala 8Ieoaka Sejnkag SKP Mefeph06 Hajapsa

:kalas 8H/,KapdamhRaya Mn, /5 Hajapsa Ptras

rekamitsmyadhrebts rebafah Teplngnm V,

Mala 8Ieoaka BhmarPemdhdhjamPelephmsag PpnuhmrhBIG Hajapsa,

:kalas 8HG,Dasns Stbpnsn Iaukhmf 2.)2/ Hajapsa Sekasam

Wamf dhwajhkhnkeg Stophyadh( S,F,( K,Sh,( Stbejsh( S,F,( KPd,( Bpr, F, Atdh Stkhrshynmn(

K,Pd,( Bpr, F,Japdh( K,K,( yamf bepshmdaj rekajt Itara Teplngnm Cmal bepdarapjam Stpas

Itara Mnlnp8 50.3-)/,65 samffak 07 Njsnbep 0./.9 rekamitsmya dhrebts rebafah Teplngnm

VG,

[/,0] Tekag lelbaca rtpas oeplngnmam Pelngnm9

Tekag lemdemfap jesepamfam Pelngnm9

Tekag lemdemfap jesepamfam Teplngnm9

Tekag lemdemfap jesepamfam Sajrh Pelngnm9

Tekag lemdemfap jesepamfam :gkh9

Tekag lelephjra btjsh)btjsh daphPelngnm damTeplngnm9

Tekag lelbaca jerhlotkam daphPelngnm damTeplngnm VG9

Page 3: Putusan KIP
Page 4: Putusan KIP

8JeNegT

[1.6] Meminta kepada Jomisi Hnformasi Rusat untuk menyelesaikan Tengketa Hnformasi

Rublik antara Remohon dengan Uermohon.

2SIe 6gPeN

DgdIe.DgdIe 8JTaMaV

[1.7] Menimbang bahwa Remohon mengajukan bukti suratltertulis sebagai berikut9

Bukti R-l Talinan Akta Rerkumpulan (Maatschap) Hndonesia Curroption Watch (HCW)

No. C-07/5 GU /2./1-Uh. 0888 yang terdaftar di Jepaniteraan Rengadilan

Negeri Iakarta Telatan pada hari Tenin, tanggal 20 Agustus 1//8 dengan

Akta Notaris G. Si\ul Tudarmadi, TG. No. 42 Uanggal 00 Iuni 1//8

Bukti R-1 Talinan surat Rermintaan Hnformasi Rublik yang ditujukan kepada Uermohon

H, Uermohon HH,Uermohon HH,Uermohon HHH,Uermohon HV, Uermohon V

dengan Nomor9 133/SKlBP/ICW/VIl0 tertanggal 5 Mei 1/0/:

Bukti R-2 Talinan Turat Jeberatan yang ditujukan kepada Uermohon VHdengan Nomor9

159/SKlBP/ICWNIl0 tertanggal20 Mei 1/0/.

Bukti R-3 Talinan Turat Jepada Fubemur DJH Iakarta perihal Rermintaan KGR

(Kaporan Gasil Remeriksaan) Hnspektorat DJH Iakarta terkait Jasus Dugaan

Jorupsi Dana BPT dan BPR 1//6-1//8 di TMR Hnduk UJBM Iakarta

Nomor9 134/SKlBP/ICWNIl0 tertanggal5 Mei 1/0/.

7JeJdIVKIV 8JTaMaV

[1.8] Menimbang bahwa pada persidangan tang gal 02 Pktober 1/0/ dan 03 Pktober 1/0/

telah didengar keterangan dari Remohon sebagai berikut9

0. Remohon menyatakan benar telah memohon informasi salinan dokumen ARBT tahun

1//6, 1//7, dan 1//8 kepada Uermohon.

1. Remohon menyatakan benar telah memohon informasi salinan Turat

Rertanggungjawaban (TRI) terkait pengelolaan Dana BPR dan Dana BPT tahun 1//6,

1//7, dan 1//8 kepada Uermohon:

2. Talinan dokumen sebagaimana yang dimohon tidak diberikan oleh Uermohon:

[1.0/] Bahwa dari seluruh dalil-dalil yang diuraikan di atas dan bukti

Remohon mohon kepada Majelis Jomisioner agar memberikan putusan9

Page 5: Putusan KIP

0- IiaeVi

S- FVfViaeS USf eVf[8d7TldcSf hVieg]gfSf IVeg]gf lfklc eVehVigdV] jVTS[aSf

USf.SkSl jVdlil] afWgieSja nSf[ UaeafkS gdV] IVeg]gf7

T- FVeViafkS]cSf :SUSf IlTdac lfklc eVeVfl]a cVmSbaTSffnSUSdSebSf[cS mSckl

hVeTViaSf afWgieSja jVTS[SaeSfS UaSkliUSdSe MfUSf[,MfUSf[ afa7

1- JlTjaUVi

FVeTViacSf hlkljSf dSaf nSf[ jVSUad,SUadfnSeVflilk iSjS cVSUadSfUSf hViSkliSf

hVilfUSf[,lfUSf[Sf nSf[ TVidScl-

.8S8P6MD6MJScja 76PJ28KNINM

P1-00RFVfaeTSf[ TS]mS Ua USdSe hVijaUSf[Sf hSUS kSf[[Sd 14 HckgTVi 1/0/ IVeg]gf

kVdS]eVfUSkSf[cSf jScja 9UV IlbaSfka nSf[ eVilhScSf IVf[lilj KVehSk DV[aSkSf :VdSbSi

FSfUaia (KD:F) BTl IVikamaCScSikS-

P1-01RFVfaeTSf[ TS]mS jScja 9UV IlbaSfka kVdS]hVeS] eVeafkS afWgieSja TVilhS jSdafSf

9I:J cVhSUSKVieg]gf BNUSf KVieg]gf NBfSelf kaUScUaTViacSf-

P1-02R FVfaeTSf[ TS]mS jScja 9UV IlbaSfka hSUS hgcgcfnS eVfnSkScSf TS]mS

hVikSf[[lf[bSmSTSf hVdScjSfSSf USfS :SJ TS[a KD:F UajViS]cSf cVhSUS JFI GV[Via

BfUlc USdSe ]Sd afa JFI G 56 CScSikS(KVieg]gf BN) jVTS[Sa JFI BfUlc USiaKD:F BTl

IVikama-

P1-03R FVfaeTSf[ TS]mS jScja 9UV IlbaSfka kVdS] hVeS] UahViacjS gdV] :ID kVicSak

hVf[[lfSSf ASfS :SJ USf :HI UaKD:F BTl IVikama-

P1-04R FVfaeTSf[ TS]mS jScja hSUS hgcgcfnS bl[S eVfnSkScSf TS]mS dShgiSf JI C

hVdScjSfSSf USfS :SJ USf :HI nSf[ UaeadacagdV] KD:F BTl IVikamaUajViS]cSf cVhSUS

KVieg]gf BNjVTS[SaDVhSdSJVcgdS] JFI BfUlc-

Page 6: Putusan KIP

Bsirg Syj Rso]r Icrco]le]l Nclpgsl Kmkmo 22IK41VP/1S11674 22140 ]r]p l]k]

Dop/ Rsnmwm-Tlgr Icoh] RJNK 74 H]i]or] Tr]o]:

Bsirg Sy2 Rso]r Icrco]le]l R]igr b]og Psk]f R]igl Rr/ C]omjsp ]r]p l]k] Kw/ RogFim

V]lg]rg rcor]lee]j 13 Mirmaco 2010:

Bsirg Sy3 Rso]r Is]p] Scokmfml UGbcle]l Kmkmo I62A1/40KI rcor]lee]j 28 Mirmaco

2010:

Bsirg Sy4 Bsis N]lbs]l B]lrs]l Mnco]pgml]j Rcimj]f )BMR, slrsi nclbgbgi]l eo]rgp

b]j]k o]lei] u]hga acj]h]o 8 r]fsl w]le acoksrs/ Dgocirmo]r Hclbco]j

Nclbgbgi]l b]p]o b]l Jclcle]f Ickclrcog]l Nclbgbgi]l K]pgml]12010:

Bsirg Sy5 Nco]rso]l Icn]j] Dgl]p Nclbgbgi]l NomtglpgD]co]f Ifspsp Gasimr] H]i]or]

Kmkmo 13 S]fsl 2010 rclr]le Ncrslhsi Scilgp Nclecjmj]]l Bg]w]

Mnco]pgml]j Nclbgbgi]l )BMN, S]fsl Alee]o]l 2010/

2ITIS7NJ7N D7N.7V787N 6ISMPKPN

W2/16[Jclgka]le a]fu] n]b] ncopgb]le]l r]le e]j 13 Mirmaco 2010- 25 Mirmaco 2010- b]l

1 Kmtckaco 2010 rcj]f bgbcle]o icrco]le]l b]og Scokmfml G-Scokmfml GG-Scokmfml GGG-

Scokmfml GU-Scokmfml U- b]l Scokmfml UG- w]le n]b] nmimilw] rgb]i kckacogi]l

gldmok]pg pca]e]gk]l] bgkmfml bcle]l ]j]p]l9

1/ Tlrsi ncokglr]]l ncor]k]- n]b] p]]r kclclk] pso]r b]og Nckmfml- pcks]

Scokmfml acjsk kck]f]kg icu]hga]llw] acob]p]oi]l Tlb]leyTlb]le IGN:

2/ N]o] rcokmfml kclecr]fsg a]fu] asirgyasirg ncka]w]o]l ]r]s isgr]lpg rcok]psi

bmiskcl w]le kckn]i]l a]eg]l b]og RNH/

3/ Scokmfml UG kclw]r]i]l a]fu] hgi] w]le bgkglr] ]b]j]f oci]ngrsj]pg RNH-

bmiskcl rcopcasr kcoci] is]p]g- l]ksl kcj]jsg nckacogr]]l bg kcbg] kcoci] a]k

kclecr]fsg a]fu] w]le bgkglr] mjcf nckmfml ]b]j]f bmiskcl RNHrcok]psi asirgy

asirg ncka]w]o]l b]j]k ncleesl]]l b]l] BMR b]l BMN mjcf Scokmfml Scokmfml

GG-Scokmfml GGG-Scokmfml GU-b]l Scokmfml U/

4/ Scokmfml G-Scokmfml GGScokmfml GGGScokmfml GU- Scokmfml U kclw]r]i]l

a]fu] oc]jgp]pg ncleesl]]l b]l] BMR bgsksoli]l bg pcimj]f pcps]g bcle]l Bsis

N]lbs]l B]lrs]l Mnco]pgml]j Rcimj]f )BMR, w]le bgrcoagri]l mjcf ?.,kt:Q1=a

Hclbco]j Nclbgbgi]l D]p]o b]l Jclcle]f Ickclrcog]l Nclbgbgi]l K ( ) ( -M0

2010/

Page 7: Putusan KIP

4/ N]lhjcji D-N]lhjcji DDN]lhjcji DDDN]lhjcji DR- N]lhjcji R h]isUnUfUi

(UcrU l]UgdmUmdk]ibboiUUi [UiU AJK [dohohfUi [d m]fjgUc m]moUd[]ibUi

K]lUnolUi G]kUgUBdiUmK]i[d[dfUi Kljpdimd BU]lUc GcomomDVofjnUFUfUlnUIjhjl

13 NUcoi 2010 n]inUib K]noieof N]fidm K]ib]gjgUUi AdUsUJk]lUmdjiUg K]i[d[dfUi

)AJK, NUcoi :ibbUlUi 2010/

5/ N]lhjcji D-N]lhjcji DDN]lhjcji DDDN]lhjcji DR- N]lhjcji R h]isUnUfUi

VUcrU [jfoh]i.[jfoh]i Vofnd k]hVUsUlUi UnUofodnUimdnd[Uf [UkUn [dV]ldfUi

f]kU[U n]lhjcji fUl]iU nd[UfU[Udtdi [Uld UnUmUi-[UgUh cUgdid U[UgUcG]kUgUBdiUm

K]i[d[dfUi K]hkljp BGDFUfUlnU/

6/ N]lhjcji D-N]lhjcji DDN]lhjcji DDD-N]lhjcji DR- N]lhjcji R h]isUnUfUi

VUcrU MKF [UiU AJM [Ui AJK nd[Uf [UkUn [dV]ldfUi V]l[UmUlfUi cdhVUoUi

k]h]ldfmU [Uld AKG BGDFUfUlnU/

S2/17T AUcrU [Uld m]goloc [Ugdg.[UgdgsUib [dolUdfUi [d UnUm-N]lhjcji D-N]lhjcji DD-

N]lhjcji DDD-N]lhjcji DR- N]lhjcji R- [Ui N]lhjcji RD- hjcji f]kU[U HUe]gdm

Gjhdmdji]l UbUlh]hV]ldfUi konomUim]VUbUdV]ldfon9

1/ Kldh]l

U/ h]ijgUf k]lhdinUUi K]hjcji oinof h]hk]ljg]c mUgdiUiMKF sUib [dm]lnUd

fodnUimd9

V/ h]hV]VUifUi m]bU1UVdUsUsUib ndhVog[UgUh m]ibf]nU did f]kU[U K]hjcji/

2/ MoVmd[]l

H]hV]ldfUi konomUigUdisUib m]U[dg.U[dgisUh]iolon k]lUnolUi k]loi[Uib.oi[UibUi

sUib V]lgUfo/

G]n]lUibUi .276

S2/18T H]idhVUib VUcrU Gjhdmd DiajlhUmd KomUnn]gUc h]i[UnUibfUi Ucgd[Uld AU[Ui

K]ibUrUmUi G]oUibUi [Ui K]hVUiboiUi )AKGK, sUdno F]ild MdiUbU[Ui C]lhUimsUc

PmhUi m]lnUUcgd[Uld AU[Ui K]ibUrUmUi G]oUibUi )AKG, MolUWchdi kU[U k]lmd[UibUi

nUibbU124 JfnjV]l 2010/

Page 8: Putusan KIP

]VhVli liahVrVie kallieinVVi eibjlliVme jhad liVmrVlVgVnnalliVmogmeVkVrVic ]enocVmgVioinog

lialiWalegVi eibjlliVme0

S4043UJaieliWVic WVdpV]VhVli kalme]VicVi NolV[dliei. Vdhe]Vle CMI kV]V kjgjgirV

lialiWalegVi ganalVicVi maWVcVeWalegonA

30 De ]VhVli Ri]Vic/Ri]Vic Kj0 37 PVdoi 4226 nainVic MalialegmVViMaicahjhVVi ]Vi

PViccoic HVpVWIaoVicVi KacVlV malnVRi]Vic/Ri]Vic Kj0 37 PVdoi 4228 nainVic

CV]Vi MalialegmVIaoVicVi ne]Vg V]V ganainoVi rVic liairVnVgVi WVdpV]jgoliai

NMHnalliVmoggoenVimelialokVgVi ]jgoliai lVdVmeV0

40 Cal]VmVlgVi MVmVh3: VrVn ,3- Ri]Vic/Ri]Vic Kj0 37 PVdoi 4226 nainVic

MalialegmVViMaicahjhVVi ]Vi PViccoic HVpVWIaoVicVi KacVlV ]eirVnVgVi WVdpV

hVkjlVi dVmehkalialegmVVi rVic nahVd ]emVlikVegVi gakV]V haliWVcVkalpVgehVi

]eirVnVgVi nalWogVoinog olioli ]Vi dVirV ]jgoliai rVic lialioVn ViVhemem]Vi jkeie

kalialegmV rVic lialokVgVi lVdVmeVmahVliVkljmam kalialegmVVi ]Vi maWaholihVkjlVi

dVmehkalialegmVVi ]emalVdgVigakV]V hacemhVnebB

50 Djgoliai NMHnalliVmog goenVimeWogVi lialokVgVi WVceVi ]Vle hVkjlVi dVmeh

kalialegmVVi nalmaWonmadeiccV WVegkV]V mVVnkljmam Vo]enWalfVhViliVokoi manahVd

kljmamVo]enmahamVenanVk]VkVn]eWogVB

60 FeliWVoVi VkVlVnkalialegmV oinog ne]VglialiWalegVi ]jgoliai NMHgakV]V liVmrVlVgVn

rVic lialieinVirV ne]VgWal]VmVlgViRi]Vic/oi]VicB

70 Djgoliai NMHnalliVmog goenVime]VkVn]eVgmamkoWhegoinog nofoVi VcVl liVmrVlVgVn

]VkVnliaicVpVme geialfV VkVlVnkalialegmV gaoVicVi. ga[oVhefegV ]e ]VhVli ]jgoliai

nalmaWonnal]VkVn eibjlliVme ]ega[oVhegVi maWVcVeliViV]eVnol ]VhVli kVmV39 RR

IanalWogVVi GibjlliVmeMoWheg.liemVhirVeibjlliVme rVic nalgVen]aicVi kalnVdViVi ]Vi

gaVliViVi iacVlV0

.7PDJNSI6K 27JM8MK

S503UJaieliWVic WVdpVMalijdji liaicVfogVi gamelikohVi nalnohem.rVic kV]V kjgjgirV

maWVcVeWalegonA

30 Malijdji lialikoirVe ga]o]ogVi dogoli oinog liaicVfogVi kallijdjiVi k((r](m,heVi

maicganV eibjlliVme ]Vi Ijlieme GibjlliVme MomVnlialikoirVe gapad(BcVi kQa=?11B. , 1

lialialegmV malnVlialionom kallijdjiVi kairahamVeVi maicganVeibjlliVmesi )WhegB.BT (t: ,

Page 9: Putusan KIP

2/ Ckgpiaj NMGoamiVnpg ejbkmiVne lpWheg]Vj oe]Vg ]emVdVneVgVjWam]VnVmgVjpj]Vjct

pj(Vjc ]Vj nanpVe ]ajcVj laj]VlVo VdhegapVjcVj lpWheg ]VmeBV]Vj MaiamegnV

HapVjcVj )BMH,- NpmV[diej sVjc ]edV]emgVj ]VhVi lamne]VjcVj WVdrV Ckgpiaj

sVjc Wahpi ]Vj oe]Vg ]eVp]eo dVmpn]eWpgVnahpVntFpVnjsVlV]V lpWheg VcVmlpWheg

]VlVo iajcVrVne lajcahkhVVj gapVjcVj nagVhecpn iaiWVjop laiamegnVVj sVjc

]ehVgpgVjkhad laiamegnV ejoamjVh]Vj agnoamjVh/

3/ Ckgpiaj NMGoe]Vg]emVdVneVgVjgVmajVWam]VnVmgVjgaoamVjcVjVdhe]VmeBMHMGajme

NejVcV ]Vj DamiVjnsVd RniVj WVdrV ]e ]VhVi ]kgpiaj NMG ]VjV BKN oe]Vg

]eoaipgVj ejbkmiVnesVjc ]ega[pVhegVj naWVcVeiVjVsVjc ]eVopmlV]V lVnVh17 RR Jk/

14 PVdpj 2008 oajoVjc HaoamWpgVVjFjbkmiVneMpWheg/

4/ NVhejVj]Vj ]kgpiaj VnheNMG]VjV BKN ]Vj BKM 2007- 2008- 2009 lV]V NIMJ 190-

NIMJ 95- NIMJ 84- NIMJ 67- ]Vj NIMJ 28 GVgVmoVsVjc ]eiejoV khad laikdkj

V]VhVdejbkmiVneMpWhegsVjc oamWpgV]Vj oe]Vg ]emVdVneVgVjnaWVcVeiVjV]eVopmlV]V

lVnVh17 RR Jk/ 14 oVdpj 2008 oajoVjc HaoamWpgVVjFjbkmiVneMpWheg/

5/ MajkhVgVj Pamikdkj oamdV]Vl lamiejoVVj ejbkmiVne sVjc oahVd Maikdkj VfpgVj

V]VhVdWamoajoVjcVj]ajcVj Rj]VjctRj]Vjc/

.7SDJNTI6K 27PJM8MK

T3/2UIajeiWVjc WVdrV Pamikdkj F- Pamikdkj FF Pamikdkj FFFPamikdkj FS- ]Vj

Pamikdkj S oe]VgiaiWamegVj ganeilphVj oamophen/

T3/3U IajeiWVjc WVdrV Pamikdkj SF iajcVfpgVj ganeilphVj oamophen sVjc lV]V

lkgkgjsV naWVcVeWamegpo:

1/ MamiejoVVj Maikdkj pjopg iaj]VlVogVj nVhejVj NMG]VjV BKN ]Vj BKM hajcgVl

oamiVnpg gpeoVjne oe]Vg WenV]eWamegVjkhad Pamikdkj gVmajV Wam]VnVmgVjWpgp

MVj]pVj BKN sVjc ]egahpVmgVj khad CemagokmVoGaj]amVh Maj]e]egVj CVnVm]Vj

IajajcVd HaiajoameVj Maj]e]egVj JVnekjVh- oVdpj 2010 ]VhVi BVWSFFF DpmpbA-

VjcgV 5 ]ejsVoVgVj (IBWBa pBcMVBtpBcslBpBcsP lKWBVsBcBBcIBcB 459) lphMpBa PcP

S:MBIBlBt IPB;BsPhWKN:cs:p aBs<BpBVBt IBc :cPt/:cPt lKcMBI:Bc aBs<BpBVBt <BcM

tKpIBlBt IP sKVhWBN)cBa:c tPIBV aKWBV:VBc B:IPt0 3lBCPWB tKpIBlBt PcIPVBsP

lKc<PalBcMBc IBWBa lKcMKWhWBBc459 BMBp sKMKpBIPWBlhpVBc VKlBIB PcstBcsP

lKcMB;BsS:cMsPhcBWBtB: WKaCBMBCKp;KcBcMWBPcc<B(1

2/ MamiejoVVj Maikdkj pjopg iaj]VlVogVj nVhejVj NMG]VjV BKN ]Vj BKM hajcgVl

oamiVnpg gpeoVjneV]VhVdoe]Vg iaiehege ]VnVm-gVmajVoe]Vg nanpVe]ajcVj MamVopmVj

Page 10: Putusan KIP

Fjhdmd DiajlhUmdIj/1 nUcoi 2010 n]inUib MnUi[UlGUrUiUi DiajlhUmdJoVgdf BUVDDD

JUm(111 coloa )[,/

R3/4S BUcpU [Uld m]goloc [Ugdg.[UgdgrUib [dolUdfUi [d UnUm[Ui Vofnd.Vofnd n]lgUhkdl-

N]lh6cji h]hjcji f]kU[U HUe]gdmFjhdmdji]l UbUl h]hV]ldfUi konomUi m]VUbUdhUiU

kU[UkUlUblUaR2/18S/

R4/1SH]idhVUib VUcpU hUfmo[ [Ui noeoUi k]lhjcjiUi U[UgUch]ib]iUd J]lhjcjiUi

J]ir]g]mUdUi M]ibf]nU DiajlhUmdJoVgdf m]VUbUdhUiU[dUnolJUmUg35 UrUn)1, coloa W- JUmUg

36 UrUn)2,- [Ui JUmUg37 UrUn)2, PP FDJ BSI1PKJUmUg3 UrUn)2, coloaV [Ui UrUn)3, coloa [

J]lUnolUi Fjhdmd DiajlhUmd Ijhjl 2 NUcoi 2010 n]inUib Jljm][ol J]ir]g]mUdUi M]ibf]nU

DiajlhUmdJoVgdf )JCKFD JJMDJ,:

R4/2S H]idhVUib VUcpU m]V]goh h]hUmofd kjfjf k]lhjcjiUi- HUe]gdmFjhdmdji]l-

m]gUieonirU[dm]VonHUe]gdm-UfUi h]hk]lndhVUibfUi n]lg]Vdc[Ucogo cUg.cUgm]VUbUdV]ldfon9

1/ F]p]iUibUi Fjhdmd DiajlhUmd JomUnoinof h]h]ldfmU- h]honom- [Ui h]ieUnocfUi

konomUik]lhjcjiUi 0 MSK/

2/ F][o[ofUi cofoh (C450CNP0I39I5) J]hjcji/

N]lcU[Uk f][oU cUgn]lm]Von[d UnUm-HUe]gdmV]lk]i[UkUn m]VUbUdV]ldfon9

A/ F]p]iUibUi Fjhdmd DiajlhUmd JomUn

R4/3S H]idhVUib VUcpU V]l[UmUlfUi JUmUg1 UibfU 5- JUmUg26 UrUn)1, coloa U-JUmUg27

UrUn)1, coloa U-V-W-[Ui [- JUmUg35 UrUn)1, coloa [ [Ui JUmUg37 UrUn)1, PP FDJ BSI1PK

JUmUg3 UrUn)2, coloa U- JUmUg3 UrUn)3, coloa U JCKFD JJMDJ kU[U kjfjfirU h]ibUnol

Fjhdmd DiajlhUmdV]lp]iUib h]ir]g]mUdfUi M]ibf]nU DiajlhUmdJoVgdf h]gUgodUeo[dfUmd:

R4/4SH]idhVUib VUcpUk]lhjcjiUi 0 MSKh]lokUfUi k]lhjcjiUi k]ir]g]mUdUi m]ibf]nU

diajlhUmd koVgdf rUib h]irUibfon k]ijgUfUi UnUmk]lhdinUUi diajlhUmd V]l[UmUlfUi Ug(mUi..,1T 111111m]VUbUdhUiU[dhUfmo[ [UgUh JUmUg35

JCKFD JJMDJ:

Page 11: Putusan KIP

V4/5WKclgk][le ][fu[ ]cob[p[oi[l so[g[l n[b[ V4/3Wb[l V4/4/WK[hcjgp ]conclb[n[r ][fu[

Imkgpg yldmok[pg ]coucl[le kckcogip[- kcksrsp- b[l kclh[rsfi[l nsrsp[l rcof[b[n

ncokmfml[l 5 NVK1

V4/6WKclgk][le ][fu[ ]cob[p[oi[l N[p[j26 [w[r )2, fsosd]- N[p[j27 [w[r (0)CVI9SK N[p[j

4 [w[r )4, b[l [w[r )5,- N[p[j5 [w[r )1,- b[l N[p[j63 NDPIG NNRGNn[b[ nmimilw[ kcle[rso

][fu[ Imkgpg Gldmok[pgNsp[r ]coucl[le kclwcjcp[gi[l Rcleicr[ Gldmok[pgNs]jgi [n[]gj[:

[/ ncokmfml[l nclwcjcp[g[l pcleicr[ gldmok[pg ns]jgi kclw[leisr B[b[l Ns]jgi

Nsp[rA

]/ ncokmfml[l nclwcjcp[g[l pcleicr[ gldmok[pg ns]jgi pcj[k[ Imkgpg Gldmok[pg

Nomtglpgb[lj[r[s Imkgpg Gldmok[pgI[]sn[rclgImr[ ]cjsk rco]clrsiA

a/ Imkgpg Gldmok[pgNomtglpgkckglr[ Imkgpg Gldmok[pgNsp[r slrsi kclwcjcp[gi[l

Rcleicr[ Gldmok[pg Ns]jgi b[j[k f[j Imkgpg Gldmok[pg Nomtglpg rgb[i b[n[r

kcl[le[lg nclwcjcp[g[l Rcleicr[ Gldmok[pgNs]jgi w[le kclh[bg icucl[le[llw[A

b/ ncokmfml[l nclwcjcp[g[l pcleicr[ gldmok[pg ns]jgi w[le rcj[f bg[hsi[l icn[b[

Imkgpg Gldmok[pgNsp[r n[b[ p[[r NDPIG NNRGNbgp[fi[l

V4/7WKclgk][le ][fu[ ]cob[p[oi[l sok[l V4/6WK[hcjgp ]conclb[n[r ][fu[ Imkgpg

Gldmok[pg Nsp[r ]coucl[le kckcogip[- kcksrsp- b[l kclh[rsfi[l nsrsp[l rcof[b[n

ncokmfml[l 5 NVK1

2. 7JITITMDP 6TMTN (Legal Standing) 8JNSKSP

V4/8WKclgk][le ][fu[ ]cob[p[oi[l N[p[j 1 [lei[ 12- N[p[j 35 [w[r )1, fsosd a- N[p[j 36

[w[r )2,- N[p[j 37 [w[r )2, TT IGNCVI9SKN[p[j 1 [lei[ 8- N[p[j 30 [w[r )1, fsosd a- N[p[j 30

[w[r )2,- N[p[j35 Nco[rso[l Imkgpg Gldmok[pgMmkmo1 S[fsl 2010 rclr[le Rr[lb[o J[w[l[l

Gldmok[pgNs]jgi )NDPIG RJGN,CVI9SKN[p[j 1 [lei[ 6- N[p[j 6 [w[r )1, b[l [w[r )2,- N[p[j 7-

N[p[j 8- N[p[j 11 NDPIG NNRGN-w[le n[b[ nmimilw[ Nckmfml kcosn[i[l Nckmfml

Gldmok[pgNs]jgi w[le rcj[f kcle[hsi[l ncokmfml[l Gldmok[pgNs]jgi b[l rcj[f kclcknsf

sn[w[ ic]co[r[l icn[b[ Scokmfml/

V4/9WKclgk][le ][fu[ ]cob[p[oi[l d[ir[ ncokmfml[l:

1/ Nckmfml [b[j[f Ncoisknsj[l (355SP9B5M) Glbmlcpg[ CsoomnrgmlU[raf )GCU, 4K/

C.1806 FS 03/02.Sf/ 1999 w[le rcob[dr[o bg Icn[lgrco[[l Ncle[bgj[l Mce(yA/gH[i[or(

Page 12: Putusan KIP

Rcj[r[l n[b[ f[og Rclgl, r[lee[j 20 Aesprsp 1//8 bcle[l Air[ Mmr[ogpG. Pgwsj

Rsb[ok[bg, RG. Mm.42 S[lee[j 00 Islg 1//8 (Bsirg Nyj):. ,1. Nckmfml rcj[f kcle[hsi[l ncokmfml[l gldmok[pg icn[b[ Scokmfml n[b[ r[lee[j 5

Kcg 1/0/ (Bsirg Ny1):

2. Scof[b[n ncokmfml[l gldmok[pg Nckmfml, Scokmfml rgb[i kck]cogi[l

nck]cogr[fs[l rcorsjgp kclecl[g ic]co[b[[l gldmok[pg k[snsl gldmok[pg u[le

bgkmfml mjcf nckmfml fglee[ ][r[p t[irs pc][e[gk[l[ bgk[ipsb b[j[k N[p[j 11

[u[r (6) TT JHN u[grs 0/ (pcnsjsf) f[og icoh[ pch[i ncle[hs[l ncokmfml[l u[grs

fglee[ r[lee[j1/ Kcg 1/0/:

3. Nckmfml rcj[f kcle[hsi[l ic]co[r[l icn[b[ Scokmfml UH n[b[ r[lee[j 20 Kcg

1/0/ (Bsirg Ny2):

4. Nckmfml rgb[i kclb[n[ri[l r[lee[n[l [r[p ic]co[r[l b[og Scokmfml pcfglee[ n[b[

r[lee[j 5 Isjg 1/0/ Nckmfml kcle[hsi[l ncokmfml[l nclucjcp[g[l pcleicr[

gldmok[pgns]jgi ic Jmkgpg Hldmok[pg.

V3.0/WKclgk][le ][ft[ ]cob[p[oi[l sok[l V3.7Wb[l V3.8Wrcopc]sr kclsosr K[hcjgp,

Nckmfml kckclsfg pu[o[r icbsbsi[l fsisk (C450CMN0I39I5)/pcj[lhsrlu[ K[hcjgp [i[l

kckncorgk][lei[l nmimi ncokmfml[l:

C. 6eMe7T 2DaSVJVT7T .TIVaS7dK2e8PKN

V3.00WKclgk][le ][ft[ ]cob[p[oi[l9

0. N[p[j 17 F Ncos][f[l Jcckn[r Tlb[leyTlb[le D[p[o Mce[o[ Pcns]jgi Hlbmlcpg[

S[fsl 0834 (TTD MPH S[fsl 0834) BPI1NKN[p[j 3 [u[r (0) b[l [u[r (1) TT JHN

n[b[ nmimilu[ kcle[rso ][ft[ pcrg[n mo[le bgh[kgl f[ilu[ [r[p gldmok[pg b[l

]cof[i kcle[hsi[l ncokmfml[l Hldmok[pgNs]jgi:

1. N[p[j 3 [u[r (2) TT JHN kclu[r[i[l ][ft[ pcrg[n Nckmfml Hldmok[pgNs]jgi ]cof[i

kcle[hsi[l ncokglr[[l Hldmok[pgNs]jgi bgpcor[g[j[p[l:

2. N[p[j 5 [u[r (0), b[l [u[r (1) TT JHN u[le n[b[ nmimilu[ kcle[rso ][ft[ B[b[l

Ns]jgi ]cotcl[le kclmj[i ncokmfml[l Hldmok[pgNs]jgi [n[]gj[9

[. Hldmok[pgNs]jgi u[le bgkglr[ rcok[psi Hldmok[pgNs]jgi u[le bgicas[jgi[l:

]. Ncokmfml[l bgj[isi[l rgb[i pcps[g bcle[l icrclrs[l nco[rso[l ncoslb[ley

slb[le[l:

3 .. N[p[j 6 [u[r (0)

kclu[r[i[l ][ft[ B[b[l Ns]jgi t[hg] kclucbg[i[l,

Page 13: Putusan KIP

g[h[kUcmeTh Fh]ikgTlc JnUfce pTha U[kTWTWc UToTb e[o[hThaThhpT e[jTWT

J[gibih Fh]ikgTlc JnUfce- l[fTch(ikgTlc pTha Wce[VnTfceTh l[lnTc W[haTh

e[m[hmnThA

5/ JTlTf 9 bnkn] V JCKGF MHFJg[hpTmTeTh UTboT BTWThJnUfce U[ko[hTha g[hifTe

j[kgibihTh Fh]ikgTlc JnUfce l[VTkTm[kmnfclTjTUcfTFh]ikgTlc JnUfce pTha Wcgibih

m[kgTlne Fh]ikgTlc JnUfce pTha Wce[VnTfceThfkTbTlcTW[haTh Wcl[kmTcTfTlTh l[kmT

j[gU[kcmTbnTh m[hmThabTe WThmTmTVTkTUTacj[gibih nhmne g[haTdneTh e[U[kTmTh

TmTlj[hifTeTh m[kl[UnmA

6/ JTlTf AAPP GFJ )3/(10 JTlTf 13 JCKGF MHFJg[haTmnk g[ha[hTc d[hcl ch]ikgTlc

jnUfce pTha oTdcUWcl[WcTeThl[mcTj lTTmif[b BTWThJnUfceA

7/ JTlTf 19 TpTm)1, JCKGF MHFJ pTha g[hpTmTeTh UTboT l[mcTj ikTha U[kbTe

g[gj[kif[b Fh]ikgTlc JnUfce W[haTh g[fcbTm WTh g[ha[mTbnc ch]ikgTlc l[kmT

g[hWTjTmeThlTfchThFh]ikgTlc JnUfce/

8/ JTlTf 22 JCKGF MHFJpTha g[hpTmTeTh UTboT l[fnknb Fh]ikgTlc JnUfce pTha U[kTWT

jTWT BTWThJnUfce l[fTch ch]ikgTlc pTha Wce[VnTfceThWTjTmWcTel[l if[b jnUfce

g[fTfnc jkil[Wnk j[kgibihTh Fh]ikgTlc JnUfce/

R4/12S I[hcgUTha UTboT U[kWTlTkeTh]TemT j[kgibihTh Wc WTfTg lnkTm j[kgibihTh

Fh]ikgTlc JnUfce e[jTWT N[kgibih- J[gibih m[fTbg[hVThmngeTh TfTlTh j[kgibihThhpT

)BnemcJ.2,/

R4/13SI[hcgUTha UTboT U[kWTlTkeThnkTcThR4/10S-R4/11S-WThR4/12S-ITd[fcl U[kj[hWTjTm

UTboT j[kgibihTh Fh]ikgTlc JnUfce pTha WcfTeneThif[b J[gibih m[fTb l[lnTc W[haTh

e[m[hmnThj[kTmnkThj[knhWTha.nhWThaTh pTha U[kfTen/

2. 6MIMI68NJMDMK7K

R4/14SI[hcgUTha UTboT WTkc]TemTbneng- ITd[fcl g[h[gneTh ]TemTbneng UTce pTha

WcTencgTnjnh pTha g[hdTWcj[kl[fclcbTh bneng jTkT jcbTe- l[UTaTcU[kcenm:

1/ DTemTbneng WTh j[kgibihTh J[gibih pTha mcWTeWcUThmTbif[b N[kgibih-

J[gibih WTh N[kgibih

Page 14: Putusan KIP

W. Kaikdkj oahVdiajailpd plVsV gaWamVoVjgalV]V Pamikdkj 5 naWVcVeiVjV

]epmVegVj]VhVi CRCRH KDMHAMA:

[. Pamikdkj oahVdiajcaoVdpe WVdrVnVhejVjCkgpiaj AjccVmVj Kaj]e]egVj ]Vj

BahVjfVNagkhVdPVdpj 1//6, 1//7, ]Vj 1//8 V]VhVd]kgpiaj oamWpgV]Vj oe]Vg

V]V lamnahenedVj hVce iajcajVe lamikdkjVj lamoViV Kaikdkj gVmajVoahVd

oamopVjc]VhVi ganalVgVoVjia]eVne oVjccVh12 Acpnopn 1/0/

1. BVdrV nahVejbVgoVdpgpi VoVpdVh-dVhsVjc ]eVgpe lVmVledVg, ]VhVi lamne]VjcVj

fpcV oam]VlVobVgoVdpgpi VoVpdVh-dVhsVjc iajfV]e lkgkg lamnahenedVj,sVeopVhVnVj

lajkhVgVj naWVceVjlamikdkjVj FjbkmiVne KpWhegnaWVcVeiVjV]eiVgnp] ]VhVi

lVmVcmVbT1.1Ulk ej 1:

D. Kaj]VlVo IVfahen

T3.04UIajeiWVjc WVdrVoamdV]VldVh-dVhsVjc iajfV]e lamnahenedVjdpgpi ]e VoVn,IVfahen

VgVj iaiWamegVj lamoeiWVjcVj ]Vj lajehVeVj dpgpi naWVcVeWamegpo9

AhVnVjKajkhVgVj KamikdkjVj

A. Pamikdkj 2. Pamikdkj 22. Pamikdkj 222. Pamikdkj FS, ]Vj Pamikdkj S

iajsVoVgVj oe]Vg iaj]VlVogVj etej ]VmeAoVnVj(Pamikdkj SF).

T3.05UIajeiWVjc WVdrVKaikdkj ]e ]VhVi npmVolamikdkjVj ejbkmiVne (Bpgoe K-1) ]Vj

npmVogaWamVoVj(BpgoeK-2) oahVdiajcVfpgVj gaWamVoVjgalV]V Pamikdkj.

T3.06UIajeiWVjc WVdrVlV]V lamne]VjcVj Pamikdkj SF iajsVoVgVj WVdrVPahikdkj SF

naWVcVeAoVnVjoe]VglamjVd iahVmVjc Pamikdkj F, Pamikdkj FF,Pamikdkj FFF,Pamikdkj

FS, ]Vj Pamikdkj S pjopg iaiWamegVj ejbkmiVne Ckgpiaj NKG,CVjV BJN ]Vj BJK

PVdpj 1//6, 1//7, 1//8 galV]V Kaikdkj.

T3.07UIajeiWVjc WVdrVWam]VnVmgVjlVmVcmVbT3.05U]Vj T3.06UIVfahen Wamlaj]VlVoWVdrV

VhVnVjlajkhVgVj khad Pamikdkj F, Pamikdkj FF, Pamikdkj FFF,Pamikdkj FS, ]Vj

Pamikdkj S gVmajVoe]VgV]Vetej ]VmeAoVnVjoe]VgoamWpgoe.

Page 15: Putusan KIP

?@>l@V< s=stClV cV?VB csVDVAs >;hpC=AC@ <VAEV@V:VB cV= C=sB4C=sB ?h=lVcCV= <VAEV@V:VB

EV=l Bh@cNI;?VBcs Ah:>;Vp3 =V<C= BscV: <h;V:C:V= VCcsB5 K?VWs;VBh@cV?VB s=cs:VAs

?h=Es<?V=lV= cV;V< ?h=lh;>;VV= MPS VlV@ Ahlh@V cs;V?>@:V= :h?VcV s=ABV=As ?h=lVDVA

tC=lAs>=V; VBVC ;h<WVlVWh@Dh=V=l ;Vs==EV/I

R8264TH]idhVUib VUcrU [UgUh k]lmd[UibUi J]hjcji h]isUnUfUi VUcrU f]dibdiUiisU

oinof h]i[UkUnfUi [jfoh]i n]lm]VonVofUi oinof f]k]lgoUi h]gUfofUi Uo[dn0iUhoi oinof

h]gUfofUi aoibmd k]ibUrUmUi jg]c hUmsUlUfUn[Ui edfU n]ldi[dfUmdn]l[UkUnk]isdhkUibUi

k]ib]gjgUUi CIK0 J]hjcji UfUi h]gUkjlfUi di[dfUmd n]lm]Von f]kU[U dimnUimdsUib

V]lr]iUib V]l[UmUlfUiNi[Uib1oi[UibB

R8265TH]idhVUib VUcrU V]l[UmUlfUi kUlUblUaR825:T[Ui R8264THUe]gdmV]lk]i[UkUn VUcrU

UgUmUik]ijgUfUi diajlhUmd V]l[UmUlfUi Cofo JUi[oUi CIK sUib h]isUnUfUi VUcrU

k]ibUrUmUi jg]c oi molhUmsUlUfUnsUib V]lnoeoUi oinof h]gUfofUi Uo[dnnd[Ufn]lVofnd2

R8266TH]idhVUib VUcrU HUe]gdmV]lk]i[UkUn VUcrU k]ijgUfUi k]hV]ldUi diajlhUmd jg]c

M]lhjcji V]l[UmUlfUi k]lm]kmdVUcrU UgUmUik]lhjcjiUi diajlhUmd jg]c J]hjcji U[UgUc

oinof f]k]indibUi Uo[dnm]VUbUdhUiUsUib [dhUfmo[ [UgUh kUlUblUaR825:T nd[Uf l]g]pUi

m]VUbUd[UmUlk]ijgUfUi2

R8267TH]idhVUib VUcrU HUe]gdmV]lk]i[UkUn VUcrU k]ijgUfUi UnUm[UmUlk]ib]WoUgdUi [d

goUl f]n]inoUi sUib U[U [d [UgUh JUmUg59 coloa U mUhkUdd NN FDJ cUlom V]l[UmUlfUi

Ni[Uib1Ni[Uib gUdim]VUbUdhUiU[dhUfmo[ [UgUh 59 coloa e NN FDJ m]cdibbU k]ijgUfUi

V]l[UmUlfUif]n]inoUi [d [UgUh Cofo JUi[oUi CIK .Cofnd M18/nd[Uf l]g]pUi2

+aKVklhPgPk SVmTPnPmgPkKPnPhhhPrPo :k=SpmpaT KVmPopmPkIliene DkalmiPne ,0ak

NPSpk 8676 oVkoPkdMoPkTPmJPrPkPk DkalmiPne KpSheg.KVmgeMJDK2

R8268TH]idhVUib VUcrU [d [UgUh k]lmd[UibUi [Ui f]mdhkogUi n]lnogdmM]lhjcji PD

h]isUnUfUi VUcrU V]l[UmUlfUi JUmUg55 UsUn.5/ coloa [ J]lfd KGDJdiajlhUmd sUib rUedV

[dV]ldfUi m]folUib1folUibisU n]l[dld UnUmA.5/ l]iWUiU [Ui gUkjlUi l]UgdmUmdUibbUlUiB .6/

i]lUWUB.7/ gUkjlUi UlomfUm[Ui WUnUnUiUnUmgUkjlUi f]oUibUi sUib [dmomoim]m(e2(]2ib,(

mnUi[UlUfoinUimdsUib V]lgUfoB[Ui .8/ [UanUlUm]n[Ui dip]mnUmd0m][UibfUi K 2( 1,,,/a*,..ac,>-' ~,' ... " ''.

nd[Uf n]lhUmof [d [UgUh f]n]inoUi n]lm]Vonm]cdibbU M]lhjcji PD h]i . aaaQt=6]((B(a2(-u( (

diajlhUmd sUib [dhUfmo[2 . ( S(A2S(B((.-B23uf476-? 21/42-7-CaCC55535I/ (l 4052S )J2 1111111)(s9IC5I0CIB,*.,a1 (tB

,,a,

Page 16: Putusan KIP

b937:d Tjtnsgftl gfm_f gjyif\fypft Wf\fr 68 f`f] /60 m^y^kh Wjypn [SNWsjt`f]fpft

gfm_f \jr^y^m ntkuysf\n rjtlpfw `ftl _fong in\jinfpft ift in^s^spft \jhfyf gjypfrf

\jgflfnsftf insfp\^i ifrfs Wf\fr AAWjypn[SNW]jysf\^p ntkuysf\n `ftl _fong ]jy\jinf

\j]nfw \ff] \jmntllf mfy^\ ]jy\jinf pj]npf fif wjysnt]fft3

b937AdTjtnsgftl gfm_f gjyif\fypft wfyflyfk b9379d [WP ift R^n]ft\n \jgflfnsftf

insfp\^i wfif wfyflyfk b937:d]jys f\^p gflnft ifyn iup^sjt rjtlpfw rfwuyft pj^ftlft3

b937BdTjtnsgftl gfm_f gjyif\fypft wfyflyfk b9379d1b937:d ift b937AdTfojrn\ gjywjtifwf]

gfm_f wjturfpft ]jysumut ]jymfifw wjysumutft ntkuysf\n iup^sjt [WPift p^n]ft\n urjm

Wjsumut gjyif\fypft Wf\fr AAf`f] /60 m^y^ki Wjypn[SNW]nifp ]jyg^p]n3

b937CdTjtnsgftl gfm_f ifrfs wjy\niftlft ]jysumut N sjt`f]fpft gfm_f pjw^]^\ft

^t]^p ]nifp sjsgjynpft ntkuysf\n pfyjtf mnsgf^ft rn\ft ifyn fwfyf] wjsjynp\f Jfift

Wjsjynp\f Rj^ftlft /JWR0 MRN Pfpfy]f1 gfm_f ntkuysf\n `ftl insnt]f ]nifp gurjm

ingjynpft pjwfif \nfwfw^t \jrfnt fwfyf] wjsjynp\f3

b937DdTjtnsgftl gfm_f \j\^fn ijtlft wfyflyfk b937Cdifrfs wjy\niftlft Imrn ifyn Jfift

Wjsjynp\f Rj^ftlft /JWR0 [^yfhmsnt sjt`f]fpft gfm_f iup^sjt [WP ]jysf\^p p^n]ft\n

g^pft sjy^wfpft gflnft ifyn rfwuyft mf\nrwjsjynp\fft3

b9385dTjtnsgftl gfm_f \j\^fn ijtlft wfyflyfk b7376d fmrn ifyn JWR [^yfhmsnt wfif

wupupt`f sjt`f]fpft gfm_f iup^sjt [WP ]jysf\^p p^n]ft\n gjyif\fypft atiftl2atiftl

Uu3 6: ]fm^t 7559 ]jt]ftl Wjsjynp\fft Wjtljrurfft ift ]ftll^tl Pf_fg Rj^ftlft

Ujlfyf \jy]f atiftl2atiftl Uu3 6: ]fm^t 755A ]jt]ftl Jfift Wjsjynp\f Rj^ftlft ]nifp

int`f]fpft gjy\nkf] yfmf\nfG

b9386dTjtnsgftl gfm_f ifrfs wjy\niftlft Imrn ifyn Jfift Wjsjynp\f Rj^ftlft /JWR0

[^yfhmsnt sjt`f]fpft gfm_f mnsgf^ft fwfyf] wjsjynp\f ^t]^p ]nifp sjsgjFaPnp ( ----3-A16//71, (./ Q1b0 :1+++

[WP ]nifp gjyif\fypft atiftl2atiftl \jmntllf mnsgf^ft \jgflfnsftf ((3( 333̂.,3i3333b333w333f33i33(3f310=,+2?1S0- -7 VPPC 09( ,.:b937Cdsjy^wfpft mnsgf^ft wyngfing^pft f]f\ tfsf nt\]n]^\nG (B)( (FF((K0(3(3F3GF3G3G(

(

cKe(.-F.(.nP1(cP43. /3Q4 1/--12M1//6-K/V01MM2I ,+=1 1M3,.*: 4 1-+ S(9a Wcccc

5C0K44I PK--00/- 5-4VP 411k,a((4)6N))1 4//4 Q*:t:

.(F333(e3,1He (3

Page 17: Putusan KIP

P4/32R(WgbfTSg] TSaoS VSeSf iWjkbVSg]SgAaeb VSjbBSVSg JWfWjbdkSGWmSg]Sg)BJG,

KmjSUafbg fWgpSlSdSg TSaoS VhdmfWg KJF lWjfSkmd dmblSgkbVSiSl VbSdkWkimTebd mglmd

lmcmSgS]Sj fSkpSjSdSl VSiSl fWg]SoSkb dbgWjcSSiSjSl iWfWjbdkSdWmSg]Sg-dWUmSebcbdSVb

VSeSf VhdmfWg lWjkWTmllWjVSiSlbg[hjfSkb VbdWUmSebdSgkWTS]SbfSgSVbSlmjVSeSf JSkSe 17

NN GWlWjTmdSSgDg[hjfSkb JmTebd/

P4/33RHWgbfTSg] TSaoS VSeSf iWjkbVSg]Sg Aaeb VSjb BSVSg JWfWjbdkS GWmSg]Sg VSg

JWfTSg]mgSg )BJGJ, FWgjbKbgS]S VSg CWjfSgkpSa NkfSg fWgpSlSdSg TSaoS VhdmfWg

KJF- lWjfSkmd dmblSgkbTmdSg fWjmiSdSg VhdmfWg jSaSkbS- gSfmg VWfbdbSgVbiWjemdSg

SlmjSg bglWjgSeVb BSVSg JmTebd VSeSf fWeSpSgb iWjfbglSSg bg[hjfSkb heWa fSkpSjSdSl

lWjfSkmd kbSiSpSg] Vblm]SkdSgmglmdfWfTWjbdSg bg[hjfSkb/

P4/34RHWgbfTSg] TSaoS TWjVSkSjdSgiSjS]jS[ P4/28R- P4/29R- P4/30R- P4/31R- P4/32R-VSg

P4/33RHScWebkkWiWgVSiSlVWg]SgSaeb KmjSUafbg- FWgjbKbgS]S- VSg CWjfSgkpSa NkfSg

TSaoS iWgheSdSg TWjVSkSjdSgabfTSmSg ijbTSVb SiSjSl iWfWjbdkS TmdSg TWjVSkSjdSg

mgVSg].mgVSg]-kWabg]]SSeSkSg iWgheSdSglbVSdjWeWnSg/

7. JSikgMeMi JSlhkakiMi 8iTklhMmdJoNgde PSiVMi 2gMmMiNSgoh IShdgded JJ86 PMi

JSlMnolMi 8inSliMg hSiVSiMd KnMiPMlDMpMiMi8iTklhMmd

P4/35RHWgbfTSg] TSaoS Vb VSeSf iWjkbVSg]Sg MWjfhahg fWgpSlSdSg TSaoS ibaSdgpS

TWemf fWfbebdb SlmjSg bglWjgSe iWeSpSgSg bg[hjfSkb imTebd- lWjfSkmd iWcSTSl pSg]

Vblm]SkSdSgmglmdfWeSpSgb iWjfbglSSg bg[hjfSkb imTebd/ IeWa dSjWgSblmMWjfhahg lbVSd

VSiSl fWfTWjbdSg bg[hjfSkb pSg] VbfbglS heWaJWfhahg:

P4/36RHWgbfTSg] TSaoS VSeSf iWjkbVSg]SgAaeb VSjbBSVSg JWfWjbdkSGWmSg]Sg)BJG,

KmjSUafbg fWgpSlSdSg TSaoS SiSTbeS TWemf lWjVSiSl iWcSTSl pSg] Vblm]SkdSg mglmd

fWeSpSgb iWjfbglSSg bg[hjfSkb imTebd fSdS iWeSpSgSg bg[hjfSkb VSiSl VbeSdmdSgheWa

iWcSTSlpSg] fWg]mSkSbVhdmfWglWjkWTml:

Page 18: Putusan KIP

V3.27WJclgk][le ][fu[ ]cob[p[oi[l n[o[eo[d V3.24W,V3.25W,b[l V3.26WJ[hcjgp ]conclb[n[r

][fu[ nclmj[i[l ncokmfml[l gldmok[pgbcle[l [j[p[l rgb[i [b[lw[ NNFCrgb[i ocjct[l.

Bcob[p[oi[l pcjsosf sok[l b[l d[ir[ fsisk bg [r[p, J[hcjgp Hmkgpgmlco]coicpgknsj[l9

V4.0WHmkgpg (Fldmok[pg Nsp[r) ]coucl[le slrsi kckcogip[,kcle[bgjg, b[l kcksrsp

ncoi[o[ 0 INC/

V4.1WNckmfml kckgjgig icbsbsi[l fsisk (93409KM0B15B4)slrsi kcle[hsi[l ncokmfml[l

b[j[k ncoi[o[ 0 INC/

V4.2WC[jgj-b[jgj Scokmfml rgb[i rco]sirg b[l ]co[j[p[l kclsosr fsisk slrsi pcjsosflw[:

5. AJAP NTSTRAK

Jcksrspi[l,

V5.0WJclw[r[i[l ][fu[ kcpignsl R[jgl[l Rso[r Ncor[leesleh[u[][l (RNG) rcok[psi

isgr[lpg bgb[j[klw[ ]si[l kcosn[i[l ][eg[l b[og j[nmo[l f[pgj nckcogip[[l, Rso[r

Ncor[leesleh[u[][l (RNG)rcok[psi isgr[lpg bgb[j[klw[ w[le rcoi[gr bcle[l nclecjmj[[l

b[l[ BMR b[l BMNS[fsl 1//6, 1//7, b[l 1//8 n[b[ RJNK 08/ G[i[or[, RJNK 84 G[i[or[,

RJNK 73 G[i[or[, RJNK 56 G[i[or[ b[l RJNK 17 G[i[or[ [b[j[f bmiskcl w[le rco]si[

pch[i j[nmo[l f[pgj nckcogip[[l b[l[ BMR b[l BMN S[fsl 1//6, 1//7, b[l 1//8 rcj[f

bgp[kn[gi[l ic jcegpj[rgd.

V5.1WJckcoglr[fi[l Scokmfml F (Hcn[j[ Rcimj[f RJN Kcecog 08/ G[i[or[), Scokmfml FF

(Hcn[j[ Rcimj[f RJN Kcecog 84 G[i[or[), Scokmfml FFF(Hcn[j[ Rcimj[f RJN Kcecog 73

G[i[or[), Scokmfml FU (Hcn[j[ Rcimj[f RJN Kcecog 56 G[i[or[), b[l Scokmfml U (Hcn[j[

Rcimj[f RJN Kcecog 56 G[i[or[) kck]cogi[l bmiskcl pc][e[gk[l[ bgk[ipsb b[j[k

n[o[eo[d V5.0Wicn[b[ Nckmfml b[j[k h[lei[ u[irs 0/ (pcnsjsf) f[og icoh[ pc][e[gk[l[

bg[rso b[j[k TT HFNb[l NDPHF RIFN pch[i nsrsp[l bgsa[ni[l:

Cckgig[l bgnsrspi[l b[j[k P[n[r Ncokspw[u[o[r[l J[hcjgp Hmkgpgmlco

Aj[kpw[f R[o[egf pcj[is Hcrs[ kco[lei[n Aleemr[, Cmlm No[pcrwm,b[l

Page 19: Putusan KIP

8C)R]S RCWKSI-RCWKSIWHDCICK3SIIT[C, UCGCJCVK6]RC[ /0 9TaHRDHV0./. GCSGK]FCUNCS

GCPCRAKG(SI BHVD]NC]S[]N ]R]R UCGCJCVK AHSKS/1 9TaHRDHV0./., TPHJ 8CMHPKW

7TRKWKTSHVbCSI SCRC-SCRCSbC[HVWHD][ GKC[CW,GHSICSGKGCRUKSIKTPHJ4JCKV]P5CWKD]CS

WHDCICK:CSK[HVC,WHV[CGKJCGKVKTPHJ:HRTJTS GCS BHVRTJTS2

Page 20: Putusan KIP
Page 21: Putusan KIP

CS[]N ADPMSDS:][]WDS MSMWDKGDSWHW]DMGHSJDSDWPMSbDGM]R]RNDS NHUDGDRDWbDVDND[

FHVGDWDVNDSCSGDSJ-CSGDSJ9T. 02 BDK]S 1//5 [HS[DSJ8H[HVF]NDDS6SITVRDWM:]FPMNGDS

:DWDP40 DbD[(3) GDSDbD[(4) :HVD[]VDS8TRMWM6SITVRDWM9TRTV 1 BDK]S 1/0/ [HS[DSJ

:VTWHG]V:HSbHPHWDMDSAHSJNH[D6SITVRDWM:]FPMN.

7DNDV[D,03 9TaHRFHV1/0/

:DSM[HVD