qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

152
UC Berkeley UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations Title Migrant Returns: The Transnational Migration of Filipinos, Ambivalence, and the Production of a Balikbayan Economy Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/1462p3k3 Author Pido, Eric J. Publication Date 2011 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California

Transcript of qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Page 1: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

UC BerkeleyUC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations

TitleMigrant Returns: The Transnational Migration of Filipinos, Ambivalence, and the Production of a Balikbayan Economy

Permalinkhttps://escholarship.org/uc/item/1462p3k3

AuthorPido, Eric J.

Publication Date2011 Peer reviewed|Thesis/dissertation

eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital LibraryUniversity of California

https://escholarship.org/uc/item/1462p3k3
https://escholarship.org
http://www.cdlib.org/
Page 2: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!"#$%&'()*'+$&,-(./*(.$%&,&%'"0&%1(!"#$%'"0&(02(3"1"4"&0,5(678"9%1*&:*5(%&;('/*(

<$0;+:'"0&(02(%(=%1">8%?%&(@:0&07?(

(=?((

@$":(A0/&(<";0(((((

6(;",,*$'%'"0&(,+87"''*;("&(4%$'"%1(,%'",2%:'"0&(02('/*((

$*B+"$*7*&',(02('/*(;*#$**(02((

C0:'0$(02(</"10,04/?(("&((

@'/&":(D'+;"*,((

"&('/*((

E$%;+%'*(C"9","0&((

02('/*((

F&"9*$,"'?(02(G%1"20$&"%5(=*$>*1*?((((

G077"''**("&(:/%$#*-((

<$02*,,0$(G%'/*$"&*(G*&"H%(G/0?(<$02*,,0$(I/%'/%$?%(F7(<$02*,,0$(6&%&?%()0?(

(3%11(JKLL(

((((((

Page 3: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!

Page 4: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!"

#$%&'()&"

*+,'(-&"./&0'-%1"23/"2'(-%-(&+4-(5"*+,'(&+4-"46"7+5+8+-4%9"#:$+;(5/-)/9"(-<"&3/"

='4<0)&+4-"46"(">(5+?$(@(-"A)4-4:@"

$@""

A'+)"BC"=+<4"

D4)&4'"46"=3+54%483@"+-"A&3-+)"E&0<+/%""

F-+;/'%+&@"46"G(5+64'-+(9">/'?/5/@""

='46/%%4'"G(&3/'+-/"G/-+H("G34@9"G3(+'"

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

Page 5: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!

"!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

#$!%&'()!*$'!+,(-."/0!1,!+.,!1,(/"/0!$*!-$11&/"+23!

Page 6: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!

""!

!!!!!!!"#$%&'(&)'*+%*+,&!!4/+'$5&-+"$/3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333336!!"#$%&'()*&+&,$-./,/0+1$2&33(,4$5('(3(,/$!6&,7,&8(/,&'(70$/,$8"#$%&'()*&+&,$!7.(8+,'!6933333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333!:;!!!"#$9#('#:$;(8+1$<&'+$;(8+$&,:$8"#$!6&,7,&8(/,&'$5('(3(,/$=&,:7.&3#$!7.(8+,'!:9333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333<=!!!6&,7,&8(/,&'$>#&'$-78&8#1$?#''(,4$8"#$@0#6(.&,$<6#&0$(,$8"#$A"('(33(,#7$!7.(8+,'!>9333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333;?!!%&'()*&+&,$A&6&,/(&1$!/B6(70$<#C#'/30#,8$&,:$8"#$@,D(#8+$/E$>#8B6,$!7.(8+,'!<9933333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333?@!!?3&.#7$/E$%&'()*&+&,$F#/'(*#6&'(701$!/B6(78(.$G/,#7$&,:$?3#.(&'$>#7(:#,8$>#8(6##$9(7&7$!7$/-A&B"$/33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333336:>!!%&'()*&+&,$H6*&,(701$2&,('&I7$%&'()*&+&,$=&,:7.&3#$&,:$@0*(C&'#,8$>#8B6,7$!C"DA"$0'(8.233333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333!6>;!

Page 7: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!

"""!

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

Page 8: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!"

""""""

!!!!!!!!

"#$%&'()$*&#!!

+,-!./0*12/3/#!4)&#&53!!

6/77*#8!9*0*7*#&!+%/#:#/$*&#/0*:5!&#!$,-!./0*12/3/#!

!

Page 9: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

#"

"#!"$%&'()*%+'$!"$%&"'(()*)+,-"*+"./,&-*+0-",&123"45)2*"%+6&"1&/&"-+"/&7&,*23"7+682&*&("*%'*"

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

A+/"*%&"8'-*"-)H"3&'/-?"4+*%"./,&-*+"',("E(&2&"%'@&"/&*5/,&("*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"&'7%"-566&/"*+"+@&/-&&"*%&"45)2(),>"+:"*%&)/"%+6&"),"D'/'T'U5&"K)*3?"'"65,)7)8'2)*3"),"S&*/+"S',)2'"1&-*"+:"S',)2'"N'3"',("I5-*"'"-%+/*"()-*',7&"'1'3":/+6"1%&/&"V),+3"EU5),+"C,*&/,'*)+,'2"E)/8+/*"WVECEX")-"2+7'*&(<"""

E*":)/-*"1&"1',*&("*+"453"'"%+6&"*%'*"1'-"'2/&'(3"45)2*<"P&"()(,0*"/&'2)Y&":/+6"*%&"W/&'2"&-*'*&X"'(@&/*)-&6&,*-"%+1"6)-2&'(),>"*%&3"1&/&"5,*)2"1&"'//)@&(<"S',3"+:"*%&"%+6&-"1&/&"8++/23"45)2*<"B+6&*)6&-?"/&'2*+/-"%'("*&,',*-"1%+"1&/&"'2/&'(3"2)@),>"*%&/&"&@&,"*%+5>%"*%&"%+6&-"1&/&"-588+-&(23",&1"+,&-<"P&"(&7)(&("*+"85/7%'-&"',"W&68*3X"2+*"),-*&'("',("45)2("+,")*<"P&";,&1")*"1+52("*';&"'"2+*"+:"*)6&"-),7&"1&"(+,0*"2)@&"%&/&"8&/6',&,*23"3&*<""

"

Page 10: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Z"

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

P%'*"7',"3+5"(+["P&"2)@&"),"K'2):+/,)'"',("*%&3"2)@&"%&/&<"C*"7+-*-"'"2+*"+:"6+,&3"*+"7'22"*%&6"&@&/3('3<"$%&3"(+,0*"%'@&"'">++("),*&/,&*"7+,,&7*)+,<"B+"*%&3"7',,+*"-&,("5-"8)7*5/&-"+:"*%&"1+/;"*%'*0-"4&),>"(+,&<"P&"(+,0*";,+1"1%'*";),("+:"8/+>/&--")-"4&),>"6'(&<"O+5",&&("*+"4&"%&/&"&@&/3('3"):"3+5"1',*"*%)-"*+"%'88&,"8/+8&/23<"O+5"-%+52("4&"%&/&"*+"1'*7%"1%'*")-"%'88&,),>"45*"*%'*0-")68+--)42&\1&"2)@&"),"K'2):+/,)']"V+*%),>")-"1%'*"3+5"1+52("&H8&7*<"$%'*0-"*%&"6+-*"()::)752*"*%),>"'4+5*"6+@),>"4'7;"%&/&<"V+"6'**&/"%+1"6',3"8&+82&"3+5"*'2;"*+?",+"6'**&/"1%'*";),("+:"'--5/',7&-"*%&3">)@&?"7+6),>"4'7;"%&/&")-",+*"2);&"7+6),>"%+6&<"$%),>-"'/&"@&/3"()::&/&,*<"

""

^^^^^"""+,-!./0*12/3/#!;%&8%/5!/#'!6*8%/#$!<-$(%#:!

"./,&-*+"',("E(&2&0-"&H8&/)&,7&-"1)*%"45)2(),>"*%&)/"%+6&"),"D'/'T'U5&"',("

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

_&7&,*">+@&/,6&,*"&-*)6'*&-"*%'*":/+6"'"8+852'*)+,"+:"'88/+H)6'*&23"`L"6)22)+,"8&+82&?"a?bL#?`cb"A)2)8),+-"'/&"1+/;),>"+@&/-&'-"WDd.E"#LLMX<"C,"#LLM?"*%&/&"1&/&"Z?Lcc?cbL"A)2)8),+-"7+,*/'7*&("'-"*&68+/'/3"1+/;&/-"'4/+'("',("!?Mee?b#e"1&/&"72'--):)&("'-"Q)//&>52'/R?"&)*%&/"1+/;),>"+,"*+5/)-*"@)-'-"+/"2'4+/&("'-"5,(+756&,*&("'-")22&>'2"/&-)(&,*-"+@&/-&'-<"E*"*%&"+*%&/"&,("+:"*%)-"-8&7*/56?"*%&/&"1&/&"#?aZe?M#`"8&/6',&,*"&6)>/',*-"-&**2&("),"()::&/&,*"8'/*-"+:"*%&"1+/2(<"$%)-":)>5/&"),725(&-"4'2);4'3',-"2)@),>"8&/6',&,*23"),"82'7&-"2);&"*%&"=<B<"',("(+&-",+*"&,7'8-52'*&">&,&/'*)+,-"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"1%+"%'("4&&,"/&-)(),>"),"*%&"=<B<"-),7&"*%&"&'/23"8'/*"+:"*%&"*1&,*)&*%"7&,*5/3<"$%)-",564&/"-5/>&("1%&,"A)2)8),+-"&6)>/'*&("),"2'/>&",564&/-"':*&/"*%&"8'--'>&"+:"*%&"F'/*9K&22'/-"E7*"+:"!ceM<"B),7&"*%&,?"*%&",564&/"+:"A)2)8),+-"/&-)(),>"),"*%&"=<B<"/+-&"*+"'26+-*"Z<!"6)22)+,?"*%&"

Page 11: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

b"

2'/>&-*",564&/"+:"8&/6',&,*"A)2)8),+"&6)>/',*-"/&-)(),>"+5*-)(&"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"W=<B<"K&,-5-"#LLaX<"" P%)2&?"2);&"6',3"+*%&/"2'4+/"-&,(),>"7+5,*/)&-?"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"(+&-",+*"6'),*'),"'"-3-*&6":+/"7+22&7*),>"('*'"+,"/&*5/,"6)>/',*-?"7+,-&/@'*)@&"&-*)6'*&-"-5>>&-*"*%'*"-),7&"!cc`?"#<M"6)22)+,"A)2)8),+"6)>/',*-"%'@&"8&/6',&,*23"/&*5/,&("*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"WN'**)-*&22'"#LLb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

A+/"*%&-&"/&'-+,-?"*%)-"()--&/*'*)+,"&H82+/&-"*%&"-54I&7*"+:"4'2);4'3',-"*%/+5>%"*%&"'7*)+,-"',("()-7+5/-&-"+:"*%/&&"),*&//&2'*&(">/+58-"+:"-+7)'2"'7*+/-f"*%&"D%)2)88),&"-*'*&g"*%&"@'/)+5-"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"',("/&'2*+/-"7+68+-),>"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"),(5-*/3"4&*1&&,"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("*%&"=<B<g"',("A)2)8),+"6)>/',*-"*%&6-&2@&-<"E*"*)6&-?"*%&"'7*)+,-"',("()-7+5/-&-"8/&-&,*&("43"*%&-&"*%/&&"-+7)'2"'7*+/-"'/&"),)*)'*&("43"()-*),7*23"-&8'/'*&"',("&@&,"7+,:2)7*),>"6+*)@'*)+,-"',(">+'2-"',("+*%&/"*)6&-?"*%&3"7+682&6&,*"+,&"',+*%&/"+/"+@&/2'8<"C"'6":+75-),>"+,"%+1"*%&"/&*5/,"+:"8+-*9!ceM"A)2)8),+")66)>/',*-"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("*%&"(&7'(&-"+:"/&6)**',7&-?"4+*%":),',7)'2"',("-+7)'2?"%'@&"&,'42&("*%&"8/+(57*)+,"+:"1%'*"C"7'22"*%&"Q4'2);4'3',"&7+,+63R<""

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ceM"A)2)8),+")66)>/',*-"),*+"J'23"K)*3"',("7+,*&H*5'2)Y&"*%&"),7&8*)+,"+:"*%&"4'2);4'3',"&7+,+63"43"()-75--),>"*%&"1'3-"),"1%)7%"*%)-"7+665,)*3"6'),*'),-"7+,,&7*)+,-"1)*%"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*%/+5>%"/&6)**',7&"-&,(),>"',("8/+8&/*3"),@&-*6&,*-<"$%)-"%&28-"*+"5,(&/-7+/&"*%&"-&7+,("8'/*"+:"63"','23-)-f"$%&"-*'*&0-"5-&"+:"*+5/)-6?"8/+8&/*3"(&@&2+86&,*?"',("4'2);4'3',-"'-"'"6&',-"+:"(&@&2+8),>"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63<"A),'223?"C":+22+1"*%&"'64)@'2&,*"/&*5/,"+:"4'2);4'3',-"'-"*%&3"2&'@&"J'23"K)*3"',("2)*&/'223"/&945)2("*%&)/"2)@&-"),"@'/)+5-"8'/*-"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"E-"Q/&*)/&&-R?"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!N'**)-*&22'"&H82'),-"*%'*"*%&"Dd.E"+,23"6'),*'),-"/&7+/(-"+,"2/0*1=5/#88/8/>/"+/""Q/&%)/&-R<"$%&-&"7+,*/'7*&("A)2)8),+"2'4+/&/-"%'@&"%'("*%&)/"7+,*/'7*-"/&,&1&(<"O&*?"*%&"'5*%+/")-"72&'/"*%'*"*%&"*%)-"7'*&>+/3"8/+@)(&-"'"@&/3"'"2)6)*&("8&/-8&7*)@&"+,"*%&",564&/-"+:"A)2)8),+-"1%+"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"&)*%&/"*&68+/'/)23"+/"8&/6',&,*23<"B&&"h/'Y)',+"N'**)-*&22'0-"Q_&*5/,"S)>/'*)+,"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-f"C--5&-"',("D+2)7)&-R"),""#$-%#/$*&#/0!6*8%/$*&#?!;%&:7-)$:!/#'!;&0*)*-:!*#!/!@0&2/0!6/%1-$?"&()*&("43"J<"B<"S'--&3"WdH:+/(f"dH:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLbX<""

Page 12: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

M"

*%&-&"4'2);4'3',-"5,&'-)23"-*/'((2&"*%&"),*&/-*)'2"-8'7&"4&*1&&,"*%&)/",&1"',(":+/6&/"2)@&-"',("'/&":+/7&("*+"/&7+,7)2&"*%&)/"'64)@'2&,7&"*+1'/(-"'"%+6&2',("*%'*")-"U5)7;23"7%',>),>"45*")-"'2-+"),"6',3"1'3-"-*)22"*%&"-'6&<"

A)/-*"),)*)'*&("),"!caZ?"*%&"N'2);4'3',"D/+>/'6"1'-"&,>),&&/&("*+"2&--&,"),*&/,'*)+,'2"*&,-)+,-"+@&/"*%&"8'/*)752'/23"'5*+7/'*)7"()6&,-)+,-"+:"S'/*)'2"i'1?"1%)7%"1'-")682&6&,*&("43"S'/7+-"I5-*"'"3&'/"8/)+/<"d/)>),'223"*%&"8/+>/'6"-+2&23"&,*')2&("@'/)+5-"),7&,*)@&-":+/"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"6'),23"),"V+/*%"E6&/)7'"*+"@)-)*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"43"'77&2&/'*),>"*%&"8/+7&--"+:"+4*'),),>"*/'@&2"@)-'-"',("/&(57&("')/:'/&-<"S'/7+-"%+8&("*%'*"*%&"6&/&"8/&-&,7&"+:"*%&-&"Q>2+/):)&("*+5/)-*-R":/&&23"*/'@&2),>"*%/+5>%+5*"S&*/+"S',)2'"',("*%&)/"%+6&"8/+@),7&-"1+52(":5,7*)+,"*+"2&>)*)6)Y&"S'/*)'2"i'1"W_+(/)>5&Y"#LL#X<"D/+@)(&("1)*%"-8&7)'2"4'2);4'3',")(&,*):)7'*)+,?"A)2)8),+"/&*5/,&&-"'2-+"%'("'77&--"*+"()-7+5,*"/&*')2"/'*&-?"7&/*'),"8/)@)2&>&-"1%&,"'//',>),>"),*&/9)-2',("*/'@&2-?"',("-':&"*/'@&2),>"8&/6)*-"(5/),>"75/:&1"%+5/-"WBY',*+,"N2',7"!cceX<"

N3"!c`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c`#"1%&,"S'/7+-"&H82'),&(?""" "

A+/"5-?"+@&/-&'-"&682+36&,*"'((/&--&-"*1+"6'I+/"8/+42&6-f"5,&682+36&,*"',("*%&"4'2',7&"+:"8'36&,*-"8+-)*)+,<"C:"*%&-&"8/+42&6-"'/&"6&*"+/"'*"2&'-*"8'/*)'223"-+2@&("43"7+,*/'7*"6)>/'*)+,?"1&"'2-+"&H8&7*"',"),7/&'-&"),",'*)+,'2"-'@),>-"',("),@&-*6&,*"2&@&2-"Wh+,Y'2&Y"!cc`X<""

"E>'),-*"'"4'7;(/+8"+:">2+4'2)Y'*)+,?"*%&-&"%)-*+/)7'2"8'**&/,-"+:";),-%)8"*)&-":),("*%&)/"1'3"),*+"*%&"7+,*&68+/'/3"*%/+5>%"*%&"),*&/*1),),>"+:"/&6)**',7&"-*/&'6-f"*%&":),',7)'2"',("&6+*)+,'2"-':&*39,&*"8/+@)(&("43":'6)23"6&64&/-"2)@),>"',("2'4+/),>"),"+*%&/"7+5,*/)&-"*%/+5>%"6+,*%23"'22+1',7&-?"'>/&&6&,*-"*+":),',7&"'"-)42),>0-"7+22&>&"&(57'*)+,?"-8+,-+/":'6)23"6&64&/-"*+"&6)>/'*&?"',("8/+8&/*3"),@&-*6&,*-<""

$%&"),*&/2),;),>"+:"7'8)*'2"8/+(57*)+,"7/&'*&("43"8&/6',&,*"A)2)8),+"&6)>/',*-"',("*%&"N'2);4'3',"&7+,+63"1'-"6'(&"72&'/"43"!c`c"1%&,"D/&-)(&,*"K+/'Y+,"EU5),+"/&(&:),&("*%&"2&>'2"(&:),)*)+,"+:"4'2);4'3',?"*%)-"*)6&"4/+'(&,),>"*%&"*&/6"*+"&,7+68'--"',3"A)2)8),+"1%+"%'("2)@&("'4/+'(":+/"'*"2&'-*"+,&"3&'/"/&>'/(2&--"+:"7)*)Y&,-%)8<"A5/*%&/6+/&?"*%&"6&6+/',(56"+/(&/"WV+<"#ZLX"6',('*&("

Page 13: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

e"

*%'*"ML"8&/7&,*"+:"*%&"*+*'2"=BJ"j!LLL"'22+1&(":+/"(5*3":/&&"-%+88),>"*+">+"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&"V'*)+,'2"$/&'-5/3":+/"/&8'36&,*"+:",'*)+,'2"(&4*-<"A+/"'"1%)2&?"-57%"6',('*&-"/&7+,:)>5/),>"*%&"2&>'2"(&:),)*)+,"+:"'"4'2);4'3',"%'("*%&"&::&7*"+:"7+,:2'*),>"@&/3"()::&/&,*"%)-*+/)7'223"72'--&("-54I&7*-f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

$%&-&"-*/&'6-"%'@&"'"(5'2985/8+-&"'-"1&22<"P%)2&"*%&3"7/&'*&"'":),',7)'2"/&-&/@+)/":+/":'6)2)&-"*+"&-*'42)-%"45-),&--&-?"6';&"/&8')/-"',("-54-*',*)'2")68/+@&6&,*-"*+"*%&)/"%+6&-?"+/"-5882&6&,*"*%&)/"),7+6&?"*%&"/&6)**',7&-"*%'*"4'2);4'3',-"-&,(":/+6"'4/+'("'2-+":5,7*)+,"*+"-*'4)2)Y&"',("-&75/&"*%&"2'/>&/"&7+,+63"+:"*%&)/"%+6&"7+5,*/3<"d,&"+:"*%&"6+-*"7/57)'2":+/6-"+:"-*'*&92&("*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"%'-"+775//&("*%/+5>%"*%&">'/,)-%),>"',("&H82+)*'*)+,"+:"6)>/',*"/&6)**',7&-<"V&H*"*+"C,()'?"K%),'?"',("S&H)7+?"*%&"D%)2)88),&-")-"*%&":+5/*%"2'/>&-*"/&7&)@&/"+:"/&6)**',7&-"-&,*"43"+@&/-&'-"&6)>/',*-<"$%)-"4&7+6&-"6+/&"-*'/*2),>"1%&,"+,&"7+,-)(&/-"*%'*"*%&"*+*'2"8+852'*)+,"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"'"2)**2&"+@&/"`L"6)22)+,?")-"+,23"'"U5'/*&/"+:"*%&"8+852'*)+,"+:"*%&"+*%&/"*%/&&"7+5,*/)&-"8/&@)+5-<"A)2)8),+-":/+6"*%&"=<B<"7+,*/)45*&"*%&"2'/>&-*"'6+5,*"+:"6+,&*'/3"/&6)**',7&-"+:"',3">/+58"2)@),>"'4/+'(<"d@&/"*%&"8'-*"(&7'(&?"/&6)**',7&-"%'@&"7+,-*)*5*&("4&*1&&,"c"',("!!"8&/7&,*"+:"*%&"*+*'2"hJD"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"Wi&"N+/>,&"#LLcX<""

C"-&&;"*+"(&-7/)4&"%+1"7+,*&68+/'/3"8'**&/,-"+:"&7+,+6)7"',("752*5/'2"*)&-"4&*1&&,"*%&"=<B<"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-"&H8/&--&("*%/+5>%"*%&"7+,7&8*"+:"6)>/',*"/&*5/,-"6'*&/)'2)Y&-")*-&2:"),*+"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"2',(-7'8&"2),;),>"J'23"K)*3"*+"S',)2'"',("8&/8&*5'*),>"'":/'>6&,*&("-&,-&"+:"4&2+,>),>"*+"'"82'7&"+,7&"*%+5>%*"+:"'-"Q%+6&R<"E-"-57%?"63"1+/;"),*&/@&,&-"*%&"2)*&/'*5/&"+,">2+4'2)Y'*)+,"',("*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"43"'-;),>"*1+"6'I+/"U5&-*)+,-f"W!X"%+1"%'@&"4'2);4'3',-"4&7+6&"8)@+*'2"'7*+/-"7+,,&7*),>",&*1+/;-"+:">2+4'2)Y'*)+,"4&*1&&,"*%&"=<B<"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-["E,("W#X"%+1"(+"*%&"7%',>&-"*';),>"82'7&"*%/+5>%+5*"S',)2'0-"2',(-7'8&?"&,'42&("),"6',3"1'3-"43"*%&"),@&-*6&,*-"+:"4'2);4'3',-?"/&U5)/&"-7%+2'/-"*+"/&7+,-)(&/"*%&"7+/&97&,*&/&(",+*)+,-"6'(&":'6+5-"43"P'22&/-*&),"',("+*%&/"7/)*)7-"+:"(&@&2+86&,*"*%&+/)&-?"1%)7%"7+,*),5&"*+"8/&(+6),'*&":/'6&1+/;-"+:">2+4'2)Y'*)+,"',("*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6["

$%&"),*&22&7*5'2"&,&/>3"8')("*+"'/*)752'*),>"*%&"7+,*+5/-"+:">2+4'2)Y'*)+,")-"&H%'5-*)@&"*+"-'3"*%&"2&'-*<"k+5/,'2)-*-?"8+2)*)7)',-?"',("*%),;&/-"%'@&"'22"1&)>%&("),*+"*%&"()-7+5/-&"',("8+-)*)+,&("*%&6-&2@&-"),"@'/)+5-"*%&+/&*)7'2"7'68-<"E"-)>,):)7',*",564&/"%'@&"6'/;&("*%&"-)>,):)7',7&"+:"7+,*&68+/'/3">2+4'2)Y'*)+,"*%/+5>%"',"','23-)-"+:",&*1+/;-"+:"652*),'*)+,'2"7+/8+/'*)+,-"+:"'>&,7)&-?"1%)7%"*+>&*%&/"%'@&"-58&/-&(&("*%&"-+@&/&)>,*3"+:",'*)+,9-*'*&-"WK'-*&22-"#LLLg"B'--&,"#LL!g"l&223"#LL!X<"d*%&/-"8+),*"*+"*%&"@)*'2")68+/*',7&"+:"-)*5'*),>"*%&"-7+8&"+:">2+4'2)Y'*)+,0-"),U5)/3"'1'3":/+6":'7&2&--"',("-&&6),>23"+6,)8+*&,*"7+,>2+6&/'*&-"',("+,*+"*%&"7+665,)*3"+:"6)>/',*-?"2'4+/&/-?"',(")66)>/',*-"1%+"7+,*),5&"*+",'@)>'*&"),@)-)423"'2+,>"*%&"7+,*+5/-"+:"*%&-&">2+4'2)Y&(",&*1+/;-"

Page 14: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

a"

WB6)*%"#LL!g"B6)*%"!cc`g"N5/'1+3"!cc!X<"$%&")68+/*',7&"+:"63"1+/;?"4+*%"'*"8/&-&,*"',("),"*%&":5*5/&?")-"*%&"6',,&/"),"1%)7%")*"'/*)752'*&-"*%&"()-I5,7*5/&"8/+(57&("43">2+4'2)Y'*)+,"4&*1&&,"&6)>/',*-"',("*%&)/"%+6&"7+5,*/3"*%/+5>%"*%&":/'>6&,*&("-&,-&"),"1%)7%"4'2);4'3',-")6'>),&"',("6'),*'),"7+,,&7*)+,-"1)*%"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""

E*"*%&"),*&/-&7*)+,"4&*1&&,">2+4'2)Y'*)+,"',("),*&/,'*)+,'2"6)>/'*)+,")-"',"&H'6),'*)+,"+:"@'/)+5-"*)&-"4),(),>",'*)+,9-*'*&-"',("()-*',*"2+7'2)*)&-"*+"+,&"',+*%&/"1)*%),"*%&",&*1+/;"+:">2+4'2)Y'*)+,"*%/+5>%"*%&"8/'7*)7&-"+:")66)>/',*-"1%+"/&6'),"-)*5'*&("-)652*',&+5-23"4&*1&&,"*%&)/",&1"%+6&"',("*%&)/"+/)>),'2"%+6&2',(<"A+/"*%)-"/&'-+,?"*%&":)>5/&"+:"*%&"4'2);4'3',")-"),-*/56&,*'2"*+"*%&"&6&/>),>"2)*&/'*5/&"4/+'(23"&,7+68'--&("43"*%&":)&2("+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6<"

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

N3"*%&"!ceL-?"(&-)/),>"%)>%239-;)22&("',("&(57'*&("2'4+/&/-"*+":)22"2'4+/",&&(-"1)*%),"',"),7/&'-),>23"(&9),(5-*/)'2)Y),>"E6&/)7',"&7+,+63?"A)2)8),+-"6'(&"*%&)/"1'3"),*+"*%&"=<B<"*%/+5>%"2'4+/"/+5*&-"'2/&'(3"8'@&("43"=<B<"7+2+,)'2)-6<#"$%&"C66)>/'*)+,"',("V'*)+,'2)*3"E7*"+:"!ceM"85*"',"&,("*+"*%&"V'*)+,'2"d/)>),-"A+/652'?"1%)7%"7+,:)>5/&(")66)>/'*)+,"),*+"*%&"=<B<"-),7&"*%&"C66)>/'*)+,"E7*"+:"!c#b<"C,")*-"82'7&?"2&>)-2'*)+,"),)*)'*&("'"a98+),*"8/&:&/&,7&"-3-*&6"*%'*?"'6+,>-*"+*%&/"7/)*&/)'?"/',;&(")66)>/',*-"'77+/(),>"*+"*%&)/"&(57'*)+,"'**'),6&,*"',("-;)22"m2&@&2<""

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#"A/+6"*%&"@&/3"+,-&*"+:"=<B<"+7758'*)+,"',("7+2+,)Y'*)+,"+:"S',)2'?"E6&/)7',"7+/8+/'*)+,-"-&,*"2'4+/"/&7/5)*&/-"-*'/*),>"),"/&>)+,-"),"V+/*%&/,"D%)2)88),&-"*+"1+/;"),"'>/)752*5/'2"',(":++("8/+(57*)+,"-&7*+/-"),"F'1'))?"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"=<B<"P&-*"7+'-*?"',("E2'-;'<"B&&?"'-"'":&1"&H'682&-?"J+/+*%3"N<"A5I)*'9_+,30-"A5-%*)/#!B&%1-%:C!D&0&#*/0!;&>-%?!;,*0*77*#-!E-/$$0-!/#'!$,-!+%/#:7/)*F*)!B-:$C!GHGH=GHIG"WN&/;&2&3f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"K'2):+/,)'"D/&--?"#LL#X?"_)7;"N'2(+Y0-"+,-!+,*%'!A:*/$*)!"#J/:*&#?!457*%-!/#'!6*8%/$*&#!*#!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/C!GKHK=GHIL"WV&1"O+/;f"V&1"O+/;"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#L!!X<""

Page 15: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

`"

$%&"!ce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ce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

""+,-!M-*0?!A52*J/0-#)-!/#'!$,-!N*5*$:!&F!+%/#:#/$*&#/0*:5!

"$%&"!ceM"C66)>/'*)+,"E7*"8/+(57&("'"8)@+*'2"6+6&,*"),"*%&"%)-*+/3"

4&*1&&,"*%&"=<B<"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-"4&7'5-&")*"),-*)*5*)+,'2)Y&("',(":'7)2)*'*&("'">'*&1'3"*%/+5>%"1%)7%"'",&*1+/;"+:"A)2)8),+"6)>/'*)+,"7+52("6';&")*-"1'3"),*+"*%&"=<B<"',("-&**2&"),*+"*%&"8+-*7+2+,)'2"6&*/+8+2&"*%&/&43"85**),>"*%&"4'2);4'3',"),*+"82'7&<"$%&-&"&7+,+6)&-"1&/&"6'(&"8+--)42&"4&7'5-&"4'2);4'3',-"1%+"6)>/'*&("*+"*%&"=<B<"':*&/"!ceM?"1&/&"+,"*%&"+,&"%',("5,)U5&23"-;)22&("',("&(57'*&("),"-57%"'-"1'3"*%'*"*%&3"1&/&"@)&1&("'-"'"(&-)/'42&"8++2"+:"6)>/',*-"1%+"7+52(":)22"@'/)+5-"2'4+/">'8-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"=<B<"&7+,+63"',("+,"*%&"+*%&/?"6',3"+:"*%&-&"6)>/',*-"1&/&"'2-+"7'8'42&"+:")66)>/'*),>"*+"*%&"=<B<"/&>'/(2&--"+:"*%&)/"2'7;"+:"-;)22-"',("&(57'*)+,"(5&"*+"-*)852'*)+,-"1)*%),"*%&"E7*"*%'*"'22+1&(":'6)23"6&64&/-"*+"4&"/&5,)*&("1)*%":'6)23"1%+"%'("'2/&'(3"-&**2&("),"@'/)+5-"8'/*-"+:"*%&"=<B<"WF),>"!ccZg"K%+3"#LLZX<"C,":'7*?"*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:"6)>/',*-"1%+")66)>/'*&("*+"*%&"=<B<"*%/+5>%"*%&"!ceM"C66)>/'*)+,"E7*"1&/&"8&/6)**&("*+"6)>/'*&"*%/+5>%"*%&":'6)23"/&5,):)7'*)+,"8/+@)-)+,<"B54-&U5&,*23?"*%&"1'@&"+:"8+-*9!ceM"A)2)8),+")66)>/'*)+,"8/+(57&("'"(5'2"7%'),"+:"6)>/'*)+,"*+"*%&"=<B<"Wi)5"!cc!X<"O&*?"1%)2&"A)2)8),+-"7+68/)-&"+,&"+:"*%&"2'/>&-*")66)>/',*">/+58-"*+"6)>/'*&"*+"*%&"=<B<"'-"'"/&-52*"+:"*%)-"8'/*)752'/"2&>)-2'*)+,?"*%&/&"/&6'),-"+,23"'"-6'22"%',(:52"+:"2)*&/'*5/&"()-75--),>"*%&"-8&7):)7")68'7*"+:"*%)-";&3"2&>)-2'*)+,"+,"*%&"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"1%+"7+,*),5&"*+"7/&'*&"'",564&/"+:"@)4/',*"&*%,)7"-8'7&-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"2'/>&/"=<B<"2',(-7'8&<Z""d,&"+:"*%&"6+-*")68+/*',*"&H'682&-"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"2)*&/'*5/&"+,"8+-*9!ceM"A)2)8),+")66)>/'*)+,")-"N&,)*+"G&/>'/'0-"W#LLcX"1+/;"+,"A)2)8),+-"1%+"-&**2&("),*+"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Z"B&&":+/"&H'682&?"O&,"i&".-8)/*50-"O&5-!.&(#'?!9*0*7*#&!N*J-:!A)%&::!D(0$(%-:C!D&55(#*$*-:C!/#'!D&(#$%*-:"WN&/;&2&3f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"K'2):+/,)'"D/&--?"#LLZX?"_)7;"N+,5-0"N&)/$*#8!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#:?!4$,#*)*$3!/#'!$,-!D(0$(%/0!;&0*$*):!&F!E7/)-"WD%)2'(&28%)'f"$&682&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLLX?"',("N&,)*+"G&/>'/'0-";*#&3!D/7*$/0?!$,-!9*0*7*#&!#/$*&#!*#!P/03!D*$3"WD%)2'(&28%)'f"$&682&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLcX<""

Page 16: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

c"

J'23"K)*3<"C,"',"'**&68*"*+"7+,@&3"*%&"(')23"7+,,&7*)+,-"6'),*'),&("43"A)2)8),+-"),"J'23"K)*3"1)*%"*%&)/"%+6&2',(?"G&/>'/'"&682+3-"*%&"*&/6"Q/&8&'*&("*5/,),>R<"N+//+1),>":/+6"*%&"-&,-&"+:"+42)>'*)+,"&@+;&("1)*%),"l%'7%)>"$n2n23',0-"W!cceX"7+,7&8*)+,"+:"()'-8+/'?b"G&/>'/'"'/>5&-"*%'*""

P%&*%&/"6',):&-*&("'-"8+2)*)7'2"'7*)@)-6?"'--&/*)+,-"+:"&*%,)7"8/)(&?",+-*'2>)'?"7+,-56&/)-6?"+/"I5-*"@'>5&"/&6&64&/),>?"*%&"/&8&'*&("*5/,),>")-"+42)U5&23"+88+-&("*+"*%&",'//'*)@&"+:"'--)6)2'*)+,<"$%&"*&,-)+,"4&*1&&,"*%)-"/&6&64/',7&"',("*%&"(&6',(-"+:"7)*)Y&,-%)8"),"*%&",&1"%+6&2',(?"*%&"+42)>'*)+,-"),"()::&/&,*"()/&7*)+,-?"7+,-*)*5*&"'"8/&()7'6&,*":+/"*%&"A)2)8),+")66)>/',*g"C"&H'6),&"%+1"*%&3",&>+*)'*&9+/"),(&&(?":')2"*+":),(9'"4'2',7&"4&*1&&,"*%&"*1+"W#LLc?"bX<""

"""$%&")68+--)4)2)*3"+:"Q6';),>9*1+"1+/2(-":)*R?"*+"4+//+1"'"8%/'-&"5-&("43"D&>>3"i&@)**"W#LL!X"*+"(&-7/)4&"7+682&H)*)&-"'/+5,("*/',-,'*)+,'2"8/+7&--&-?")-"'::)/6&("43"4+*%"./,&-*+"',("E(&2&0-",'//'*)@&"8/+@)(&("&'/2)&/"',("G&/>'/'<"C,*&/&-*),>23?"1%)2&"*%)-")68+--)4)2)*3")-"7+,*),5+5-23"%'5,*-"*%&"2)*&/'*5/&"+,"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-?"@&/3":&1"-7%+2'/-"'**&68*"*+"'/*)752'*&")*-"8/&-&,7&<""

$%&-&"(')23",&>+*)'*)+,-"',("*%&")68+--)4)2)*3"*+":),("'"4'2',7&"'/&"/&6),)-7&,*"+:"8&/%'8-"*%&"6+-*"),:25&,*)'2"-7%+2'/"*+"*%&"+@&/2'88),>":)&2(-"+:"&*%,)7"',("/'7)'2"-*5()&-<"E*"*%&"*5/,"+:"*%&"*1&,*)&*%"7&,*5/3?"P<.<N<"J5"N+)-"85*"1+/(-"*+"*%&"@&)2"*%'*"6'-;&("*%&"2)@&-"',("752*5/&"+:"N2'7;":+2;<"oB1'*%&("1)*%),"*%&":+2(-"+:"*%&"@&)2"+:"7+2+5/?o"'-"(&-7/)4&("43"D'52"h)2/+3"W!ccZX?"*%&"&H8&/)&,7&-"+:"E:/)7',"E6&/)7',-"),"*%&"=<B<"1&/&"6'(&"&,*)/&23"),@)-)42&"*+"*%&"&3&-"+:"*%&"(+6),',*"752*5/&"-5//+5,(),>")*"W!#ZX<"B)652*',&+5-23?"',("),"',"),*&,-&23"'64)@'2&,*":'-%)+,?")*"'2-+"8/+@)(&("E:/)7',"E6&/)7',-"-+6&"'4)2)*3"*+"7+,7&'2"*%&6-&2@&-"),"'"-&,-&":/+6"*%&"2'/>&/"1%)*&"-+7)&*3<""

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

C,"+/(&/"*+"7+,@&3"*%&-&"2)6)*-?"C"65-*":)/-*"'**&68*"*+"85-%"63"','23-)-"*+"*%&"4+5,('/)&-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6<"$%&/&:+/&?"C"'6"'2-+"/&23),>"+,"*%&"1+/;"+:"C,(&/8'2"h/&1'2"W#LLMX"',("*+">&*"4&3+,("1%'*"-%&"@)&1-"'-"'"8/&@')2),>"()-7+5/-&"1)*%),"752*5/'2"',("&*%,)7"-*5()&-"*+"@)&1"6)>/'*)+,"',(")66)>/'*)+,"-+2&23"*%/+5>%"*%&":/'6&"+:"*%&"=<B<"'-"',")68&/)'2)-*",'*)+,9-*'*&<"_'*%&/?"2);&"h/&1'2?"C"*++"'6"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""b"G&/>'/'"8'3-"8'/*)752'/"'**&,*)+,"*+"$n2n23',0-"U5+*&?"QC*"6';&-"6+/&"-&,-&"*+"*%),;"+:"()'-8+/',"+/"()'-8+/)7"&H)-*&,7&"'-",+*",&7&--'/)23"),@+2@),>"'"8%3-)7'2"/&*5/,"45*"/'*%&/"'"/&9"*5/,?"'"/&8&'*&("*5/,),>"*+"*%&"7+,7&8*"',(p+/"*%&"/&'2)*3"+:"*%&"%+6&2',("',("+*%&/"()'-8+/',";),"*%/+5>%"6&6+/3?"1/)**&,"',("@)-5'2"*&H*-?"*/'@&2?">):*-"',("'--)-*',7&R"W#LLc?"!bm!MX<""

Page 17: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!L"

&H82+/),>"%+1"$,-!*'-/!&F!A5-%*)/"%'-"o8/+(57&("6',3";),(-"+:"'>&,73"',("()@&/-&"-54I&7*-o":+/"A)2)8),+-"',("%+1"*+"6';&"-&,-&"+:"%+1"*%)-")(&'":5,7*)+,-"o'-"'"()-7+5/-&"+:",&+2)4&/'2)-6"6';),>"8+--)42&"-*/5>>2&-":+/"/)>%*-"*%/+5>%"7+,-56&/)-*-"8/'7*)7&-"',(")6'>),'/)&-"*%'*"7'6&"*+"4&"5-&("4+*%"),-)(&"',("+5*-)(&"*%&"*&//)*+/)'2"4+5,('/)&-"+:"*%&"=,)*&("B*'*&-o"W#X<"$%&"6&*'8%+/"+:"*%&"@&)2":+/7&-"/&'(&/-"+:"()::&/&,*"4'7;>/+5,(-"*+"-5-8&,("'"=<B<97&,*/)7":/'6&1+/;"1%&,"@)&1),>"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"',("),-*&'(?"7+682)7'*&"*/'()*)+,'2"',(":)7*)*)+5-"4),'/)&-"-57%"'-"*%+-&")68+-&("4&*1&&,"E6&/)7',"',(")66)>/',*?"7+2+,)Y&/"',("7+2+,)Y&(?"',("+88/&--&("',("+88/&--+/<""

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f"QK+6),>"4'7;"%&/&")-",+*"2);&"7+6),>"%+6&<"$%),>-"'/&"@&/3"()::&/&,*<R"$%&)/"5,)U5&,&--"+:"4'2);4'3',-")-"),"*%&"6',,&/"),"1%)7%"*%&3"7'//3"*%&"1&)>%*"+:"+42)>'*)+,-"',("),(&4*&(,&--"+:"*%&"4'2);4'3',"&7+,+63"+,"*%&)/"-%+52(&/-"1%&,"*%&3"/&*5/,<"C,"*%)-"1'3?"4'2);4'3',-"'/&"&H)2&("*%/+5>%"*%&"*/',-:+/6'*)+,"+:?",+*"+,23"*%&6-&2@&-?"45*"*%&"@&/3")(&'"+:"%+6&"',("*%&)/"%+6&2',("'-"1&22<"""N*$-%/$(%-!<-J*->!

"N+*%"%)-*+/)7'2"',("7+,*&68+/'/3"8'**&/,-"+:"6)>/'*)+,"4&*1&&,"*%&"

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

N'-7%?"h2)7;"B7%)22&/?"',("B',*+,"N2',7"W!cceX"(&:),&")*"'-"*%&"Q8/+7&--&-"43"1%)7%")66)>/',*-":+/>&"',("-5-*'),"652*)-*/',(&("-+7)'2"/&2'*)+,-"*%'*"2),;"*+>&*%&/"*%&)/"-+7)&*)&-"+:"+/)>),"',("-&**2&6&,*R"WeX<"$/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"&6&/>&("'-"'"1'3"+:"*%),;),>"'4+5*"6)>/',*-"',(")66)>/',*-"1%+"'/&",+"2+,>&/"Q58/++*&(R"),"*%&"()'-8+/)7"-&,-&"45*"/'*%&/?"1%+"6+@&"4'7;"',(":+/*%"'7/+--",'*)+,9-*'*&"4+/(&/-"',("7+,*),5&"*+"6'),*'),"72&'/"7+,,&7*)+,-"1)*%"*%&)/"%+6&2',(-"*%/+5>%"*%&"6&',-"+:"*&7%,+2+>)7'2"',("7+665,)7'*)@&"),,+@'*)+,-"',("2&--"&H8&,-&"*/'@&2"

Page 18: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!!"

Wl&'/,&3"!ccMg"_+5-&"!cc!g"G&/*+@&7"!cccg"i&@)**"#LL!X<"C,"'"8/+:+5,("1'3?"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"*/',-:+/6-",+*)+,-"+:"Q%+6&R":/+6"'"6)>/'*)+,"8&/-8&7*)@&"),"-57%"'"1'3"*%'*"Q%+6&"',("%+-*"-+7)&*3"4&7+6&"'"-),>2&"'/&,'"+:"-+7)'2"'7*)+,R"WS'/>+2)-"!ccM?"#cX<""

J5/),>"*%&"*)6&"+:")*-"),7&8*)+,?"*%&"-7%+2'/-"*%'*"'(+8*&("*%&"2&,-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"1&/&"7+,*),5'223"'-;&("*+"8/+@)(&"'"72&'/"(&:),)*)+,"',(":/'6&1+/;":+/")*-"','23-)-<"K+,-&U5&,*23?"S'%2&/"W#LLeX"'**/)45*&-"657%"+:"*%&"7/)*)7)-6"8+),*&("*+1'/(-"*%&+/)&-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"-*&6":/+6"*%&"4&2)&:"*%'*"*%&"*&/6"%'-"4&7+6&"'"Q-2)88&/3"7+,7&8*R?"1%)2&"+*%&/-"%'@&"'/>5&("*%'*"*%&"*&/6")*-&2:"(+&-",+*")2256),'*&"8/+7&--&-"*%'*"'/&"8'/*)752'/23"5,)U5&"*+"%)-*+/3<M"h5'/,)Y+"W!ccaX"'**&68*-"*+"8/+@)(&"72'/)*3"*+"*%&"(&:),)*)+,"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"',("'/>5&-"*%'*"*&/6"-%+52("7+,,+*&"'"Q-&/)&-"+:"&7+,+6)7?"-+7)+9752*5/'2?"',("8+2)*)7'2"8/'7*)7'2"',("()-75/-)@&"/&2'*)+,-"*%'*"*/',-7&,("*%&"*&//)*+/)'223"4+5,("I5/)-()7*)+,"+:"*%&",'*)+,9-*'*&R"WcX<""F&/&?"1%'*"4&7+6&-"7/57)'2")-"*%&"7+,*/)45*)+,"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2"*%+5>%*"*+"'/*)752'*),>"*%&"6',,&/"),"1%)7%"@'/)+5-"6)>/',*-"%'@&"4&7+6&"7'8'42&"+:"*/',-7&,(),>?"),"7+682&H"1'3-?"*%&"4+5,('/)&-"+:",'*)+,9-*'*&"-+@&/&)>,*3<"$%&"*&/6"Q*/',-6)>/',*R"4/+'(23"&,7+68'--&-"),()@)(5'2-"1%+"%-8(0/%03"&,>'>&-"),"7/+--94+/(&/"'7*)@)*)&-"W.,>2',("!cccg"h2)7;"B7%)22&/?"N'-7%?"',("N2',7"!ccMg"h5'/,)Y+"!ccaX<""

$%&"U5&-*)+,"+:",'*)+,9-*'*&"-+@&/&)>,*3"%'-"7+68&22&("',+*%&/"-&*"+:"-7%+2'/-"*+"&H'6),&"*%&"8+*&,*)'2":+/"5-),>"'":/'6&1+/;"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"*+"6';&"-&,-&"+:"&6&/>&,*":+/6-"+:"7)*)Y&,-%)8"*%'*"&H*&,("4&3+,("*%&"(&6'/7'*)+,-"+:"*%&",'*)+,9-*'*&<"$%&-&"()-75--)+,-"-*&6":/+6"*%&"72')6"8+-&("43"'",564&/"+:"-7%+2'/-"1%+"@)&1"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"'-"8+),*),>"*+"*%&"(&*&//)*+/)'2)Y'*)+,"',("&@&,"'7*5'2"()-),*&>/'*)+,"+:",'*)+,9-*'*&"-+@&/&)>,*3"WE88'(5/')"!cceg"h58*'"!cc#g"F',,&/Y"!cc#X<"B'--&,"W!cceX?":+/"&H'682&?"&682+3-"*%&":+/6'*)+,"+:"&H8+/*"8/+7&--),>"Y+,&-<"E-"(&-)>,'*&("'/&'-"5*)2)Y&(":+/"*%&"6',5:'7*5/),>"+/"()-*/)45*)+,"+:">++(-?"1%'*"6';&-".Dq-"5,)U5&")-"*%'*"*%&3"7+,*),5&"*+"+8&/'*&"+5*-)(&"+:"*%&"-+@&/&)>,*3"+:"*%&",'*)+,9-*'*&"4+5,('/)&-"',("&'7%"-*'*&0-"*/'(&"/&>52'*)+,-<"B57%"Y+,&-?"7%'/'7*&/)Y&":+/"B'--&,?"*%&"8'/*)'2"(&*&//)*+/)'2)Y'*)+,"+:"-*'*&"*&//)*+/3<e"h58*'"',("A&/>5-+,"W!cc#X"&,7'8-52'*&"*%)-"'--&/*)+,?"72')6),>"*%'*?"""

P&"2)@&"),"'"1+/2("1%&/&")(&,*)*)&-"),7/&'-),>23"7+6&"*+"4&?"):",+*"1%+223"(&*&//)*+/)'2)Y&(?"'*"2&'-*"()::&/&,*23"*&//)*+/)'2)Y&(<"_&:5>&&-?"6)>/',*-"()-82'7&("',("-*'*&2&--"8&+82&-9*%&-&"'/&"8&/%'8-"*%&":)/-*"*+"2)@&"*%&-&"/&'2)*)&-"),"*%&)/"6+-*"7+682&*&":+/6"WcX<""

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""M"A+/"',"),9(&8*%"()-75--)+,"+,"*%&"(&4'*&"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"'-"'":/'6&1+/;?"-&&"E2&I',(/+"D+/*&-0"QC,*/+(57*)+,f"*%&"J&4'*&-"',("B)>,):)7',7&"+:"C66)>/',*"$/',-,'*)+,'2)-6R?"@0&2/0!Q-$>&%1:"!fZ"Wk523"#LL!X?"!`!9!cb<"C,"/&-8+,-&"-57%"7/)*)7)-6-"'/+5,("Q1%'*")-",&1R"'4+5*"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6?"_+4&/*"B6)*%"W#LLZX"-'3-?"Q):"*/',-,'*)+,'2"2):&"&H)-*&("),"*%&"8'-*"45*"1'-",+*"-&&,"'-"-57%?"*%&,"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"2&,-"(+&-"*%&",&1"','23*)7'2"1+/;"+:"8/+@)(),>"'"1'3"+:"-&&),>"1%'*"1'-"*%&/&"*%'*"7+52(",+*"4&"-&&,"4&:+/&R"Wa#MX<"""e"A+/"7'-&9-*5()&-"&H'6),),>".Dq-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"h2+4'2"B+5*%?"-&&"S'/r'"A&/,s,(&Y9l&2230-"9&%!B-!/%-!E&0'C!"!/#'!63!;-&70-?!B&5-#!/#'!"#'(:$%3!*#!6-R*)&S:!9%&#$*-%!WE24',3f"B=VO"D/&--?"!cc#X"',("l/)-"d2(0-"W#LL!X"@0&2/0*T/$*&#!/#'!U%2/#!D,/#8-?!D/7*$/0C!D(0$(%-C!/#'!;/)*F*)!<*5!6-8/=;%&V-)$:"WdH:+/(f"dH:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LL!X<"A+/"'"()-75--)+,":+75-&("+,"*%&"7'-&"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"-&&""

Page 19: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!#"

"B&@&/'2"',*%/+8+2+>)-*-?"),"8'/*)752'/?"@)&1"*%&"*/',-7&,(),>"8/'7*)7&-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2"6)>/',*-"'-"5,(&/6),),>"Q*%&"8+2)*)7'2"(+6),',7&"&H&/*&("43"*%&"-*'*&"',(")*-"752*5/'2"'5*%+/)*3R"W_+5-&"!ccM?"ZM`X<a"h2)7;"B7%)22&/"',("A+5/+,"W#LL!X?":+/"&H'682&?"(&-7/)4&"2+,>9()-*',7&"F')*)',",'*)+,'2)-*"1%+"&,>'>&"),"*/',-4+/(&/"7)*)Y&,-%)8<"B)6)2'/23?"B6)*%"W#LLeX"8/+@)(&-";&3"&H'682&-"*%'*"7+,@&3"%+1"*/',-,'*)+,'2"*)&-"4&*1&&,"S&H)7',"8+2)*)7'2"7+665,)*)&-"),"$)75',)?"S&H)7+"',("V&1"O+/;"),"*%&"=<B<?"%'@&":+/>&("8+1&/:52"6&',-":+/"S&H)7',-"*+"Q:)>%*":+/"/&7+>,)*)+,"',("/&-8&7*R"),"4+*%"S&H)7+"',("*%&"=<B<"WaeX<""

D&/%'8-"*%&"6+-*"'/(&,*"8/+8+,&,*"+:"*%&"(&*&//)*+/)'2)Y'*)+,"*%&-)-"(&/)@&-":/+6"*%&"*%&+/&*)7'2"7+,*/)45*)+,-"+:"E)%1'"d,>"W!cccX?"1%+-&",+*)+,"+:"Q:2&H)42&"7)*)Y&,-%)8R"/&:2&7*-"*%&"&::+/*-"+:"-7%+2'/-"*+"-%&(92)>%*"+,"*%&"7+,-&U5&,7&-"+:">2+4'2"7'8)*'2)-6"',("*%&"(&7/&'-),>"-)>,):)7',7&"+:",'*)+,9-*'*&"-+@&/&)>,*3<"E77+/(),>"*+"d,>?":2&H)42&"7)*)Y&,-%)8"7'8*5/&-"Q*%&"-*/'*&>)&-"',("&::&7*-"+:"6+4)2&"6','>&/-?"*&7%,+7/'*-?"',("8/+:&--)+,'2-"-&&;),>"*+"4+*%"7)/756@&,*"',("4&,&:)*":/+6"()::&/&,*",'*)+,9-*'*&"/&>)6&-"43"-&2&7*),>"()::&/&,*"-)*&-":+/"),@&-*6&,*-?"1+/;?"',(":'6)23"/&2+7'*)+,R"W!ccc?"!!X<"A+/"d,>"',("+*%&/-?"5,(&/-*',(),>">2+4'2)Y'*)+,"*%/+5>%"*%&":/'6&1+/;"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"8/+@)(&-"'"-7%&6'*)7?"'24&)*"U5)*&"@'>5&?":+/"&H82+/),>"*%&"'64)@'2&,*"6',,&/"*%/+5>%"1%)7%"-8&7):)7'223"7'8'42&"),()@)(5'2-"',("652*),'*)+,'2"7+/8+/'*)+,-"+8&/'*&"4&3+,("*%&"/&>52'*),>"7+,*/+2"+:",'*)+,9-*'*&"2'1-"',("&7+,+6)7"2)6)*-<`""

$%&-&"6+/&"7&2&4/'*+/3"()-7+5/-&-"'/+5,("*%&"&::&7*-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"%'@&">&,&/'*&("*%&"6+-*"(&4'*&"'6+,>-*"8/+8+,&,*-"',("7/)*)7-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2"*%&+/3<c"$%&-&"7/)*)U5&-"8+),*&("*+"3&*"',+*%&/"6'I+/"8/+42&6"7+,:/+,*),>"*/',-,'*)+,'2"-*5()&-")-"),"*%&",&&("*+"7+,@&3"*%&"6'*&/)'2"1'3-"*%'*")66)>/',*-"+8&/'*&"1)*%),"'"*/',-,'*)+,'2"-+7)'2":)&2(?"3&*"7+,*),5&"*+"4&"4+5,(&("1)*%),"*%&"2'/>&/"7+,*&H*"+:",'*)+,945)2(),>"8/+I&7*-"WB6)*%"',("h5'/,)Y+"!cc`g"B6)*%"#LL!X<"C,"2),&"1)*%"B6)*%t-"7+,7&8*)+,"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6?"l&'/,&3"W!ccMX"'/>5&-":+/"',"&H'6),'*)+,"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2"-+7)'2"/&2'*)+,-"*%'*"'/&"ot',7%+/&("),t"1%)2&"'2-+"*/',-7&,(),>"+,&"+/"6+/&",'*)+,9-*'*&-o"WMb`X<"

F+1"*%&,"(+&-"*%&":/'6&1+/;"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"+8&/'*&"'*"4+*%"*%&"-7'2&"+:"*%&"-*'*&"',("*%&"),()@)(5'2["C-"*%&/&"'"1'3"+:"5,(&/-*',(),>"*%&"-)652*',&)*3"+:",'*)+,9-*'*&"&,>'>&6&,*"1)*%"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"',("*%&"-*/'*&>)7"/+2&"*%'*"),()@)(5'2-"'/&"82'3),>"1)*%),"*%&-&"8/+7&--&-["C,"+/(&/"*+"',-1&/"*%&-&"U5&-*)+,-?"C"-%'/&"i&@)**0-"W#LL!X"@)&1"*%'*?"""

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""a"B&&"'2-+"E/I5,"E88'(5/')0-"6&'-%#*$3!/$!N/%8-?!D(0$(%/0!P*5-#:*&#:!&F!@0&2/0*T/$*&#"WS),,&'8+2)-"g"i+,(+,f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"S),,&-+*'"D/&--?"!cceX?"S)7%'&2"l&'/,&30-"$%&"i+7'2"',("*%&"h2+4'2f"$%&"E,*%/+8+2+>3"+:"h2+4'2)Y'*)+,"',("$/',-,'*)+,'2)-6?"A##(/0!<-J*->!&F!A#$,%&7&0&83""#b"W!ccMX?"Mba9MeM?"',("D%)2)8"l&2230-"N/#':)/7-:!&F!@0&2/0*T/$*&#?!O(5/#!@-&8%/7,*-:!&F!4)&#&5*)!D,/#8-!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:!WV&1"O+/;f"_+5*2&(>&?"#LL!X<""`"B&&"'2-+"l'*%'/3,&"S)*7%&220-"D%&::*#8!$,-!Q-&0*2-%/0!N*#-?!;/)*F*)!<*5!6*8%/$*&#!/#'!$,-!6-$%&7&0*:!WD%)2'(&28%)'f"$&682&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLbX<""c"B&&?":+/"),-*',7&?"7/)*)U5&-"'/+5,("*%&"()-7+5/-&"+:"%34/)()*3"),"l'*%'/3,&"S)*7%&220-"W!ccaX"J)::&/&,*"J)'-8+/'-"',("*%&"F38&"+:"F34/)()*3?"4#J*%&#5-#$!/#'!;0/##*#8!P?!E&)*-$3!/#'!E7/)-"!MfM"W!ccaX?"MZZ"m"MMZ<"

Page 20: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!Z"

C,()@)(5'2"'7*+/-"7',,+*"4&"@)&1&("),")-+2'*)+,":/+6"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"-+7)'2":)&2(-"),"1%)7%"*%&3"'/&"&64&((&(<"$%&"&7+,+6)7"),)*)'*)@&-?"8+2)*)7'2"'7*)@)*)&-?"',("-+7)+9752*5/'2"&,*&/8/)-&-"*%&3"&,>'>&"),"'/&"8+1&/:5223"-%'8&("43"*%&"-+7)'2":)&2(-"),"1%)7%"*%&3"+775/R"WaX<""

"E-"-57%?"',"','23-)-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"7',,+*"-&8'/'*&"8/+7&--&-"*%'*"'/&"+775//),>"7+,>/5&,*23"'*"4+*%"*%&"-*'*&"',("),()@)(5'2"-7'2&<"C,"+/(&/"*+"6';&"-&,-&"+:"8/'7*)7&-"*%'*"+8&/'*&"'*"',"),()@)(5'2"-7'2&?"h5'/,)Y+?"1/)*),>"*+>&*%&/"1)*%"S<"D<"B6)*%"W!cc`X?"I5H*'8+-&-"*%&"&@&/3('3"8/'7*)7&-"+:"),()@)(5'2"6)>/',*-"',(")66)>/',*-"+/"Q*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6":/+6"4&2+1R":/+6"2'/>&/"8/'7*)7&-"+:">2+4'2">+@&/,',7&"+/"1%'*"+*%&/-"%'@&"7'22&("Q-*'*&92&("*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6R<""

D&/7&)@),>"*/',-,'*)+,'2"6)>/'*)+,"*%/+5>%"'":/'6&1+/;"+:"Q*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6":/+6"4&2+1R"8/+@)(&-"'"1'3"+:"-%):*),>"-*/57*5/&97&,*&/&("()-7+5/-&-"'/+5,(">2+4'2)Y'*)+,"'1'3":/+6"*%&"+:*&,":'7&2&--,&--"+:"*%&">2+4'2"6'/;&*?">2+4'2"7)*)&-?"+/"*%&",&*1+/;&("-+7)&*3?"',("+,*+"),()@)(5'2-"',("7+665,)*)&-<"D+/*&-"&*"'2<"W!cccX?":+/"&H'682&?"7+,7&(&-"*%'*"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6")-"'"@'25'42&"*++2"*+"','23Y),>"*%&"&7+,+6)7?"8+2)*)7'2?"',("-+7)+9752*5/'2"8/'7*)7&-"+:")66)>/',*-?"-8&7):)7'223"1)*%),"*%&"7+,*&H*"+:")66)>/',*"45-),&--&-"*%'*"/&U5)/&"',"+,>+),>"/&2'*)+,-%)8"1)*%"*%&)/"%+6&2',(<""

B*'*&92&("*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"+,"+*%&/"%',(?"7%'/'7*&/)Y&-"*%&"1'3-"*%'*"*%&"-*'*&"*/)&-"*+"'77+66+('*&"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"6+@&6&,*-"+:")*-"8&+82&"',("*%&":+/6'*)+,"+:"(&*/&/)*+/)'2)Y&(",'*)+,9-*'*&-?"43"*/3),>"*+"/&),7+/8+/'*&")*-"*/',-6)>/',*-"),*+")*-",'*)+,945)2(),>"8/+I&7*-<"N'-7%"&*<"'2<"W!ccbX"/&:&/-"*+"*%)-"*38&"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"'-"*%&"Q(&*&//)*+/)'2)Y&(",'*)+,9-*'*&Rg"'"/&7+,:)>5/'*)+,"+:"*%&",'*)+,9-*'*&"1%&/&"Q*%&",'*)+,0-"8&+82&"6'3"2)@&"',31%&/&"),"*%&"1+/2("',("-*)22",+*"2)@&"+5*-)(&"*%&"-*'*&R"W#ecX<!L"$%&"6'*&/)'2)Y'*)+,"+:"*%)-"/&7+,:)>5/'*)+,?"'77+/(),>"*+"h5&@'//'"W#L!LX?"),725(&"Q&,7+5/'>),>"*/',-6)>/'*,-"*+"6';&"7'8)*'2"),@&-*6&,*-"),"*%&)/"%+6&"7+5,*/)&-"'-")(&'2"82'7&-":+/"%+2)('3"@'7'*)+,-R"WeX<"

d:*&,?")66)>/',*-"7+,:/+,*"',(",'@)>'*&"8+2)7)&-"',("/&>52'*)+,-"7/&'*&("43"*%&"-*'*&"45*"'/&"I5-*"'-"+:*&,"&,'42&("43"*%&"-'6&"-&*"+:"8+2)7)&-"',("/&>52'*)+,-"*+"-&&;"+5*"1'3-"*+"4&**&/"*%&6-&2@&-"',("*%&)/":'6)2)&-<"k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h5&@&//'"W#L!LX"'/>5&-"*%'*"*%&"2'4+/"4/+;&/),>"),-*)*5*&-?"2'4+/"6)>/',*-?"',("/&6)**',7&-"7+,@&3"%+1"-*'*&92&("*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"%'-"4&7+6&"Q7/57)'2":+/"6','>),>"*%&"-*'*&0-"@52,&/'4)2)*3"*+"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!L"B&&"i5)-"h+2(/),>0-"+,-!6-R*)/#!E$/$-!/#'!+%/#:5*8%/#$!X%8/#*T/$*&#:?!Q-8&$*/$*#8!$,-!.&(#'/%*-:!&F!6-52-%:,*7!/#'!;/%$*)*7/$*&#?"N/$*#!A5-%*)/#!<-:-/%),!<-J*->"ZafZ"W#LL#X?"MM9cc<""

Page 21: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!b"

&7+,+6)7">2+4'2)Y'*)+,?"-8&7):)7'223"),"*&/6-"+:"&,-5/),>"'"8/+:)*'42&"-*/'*&>)7"8+-)*)+,),>"),"*%&">2+4'2"&7+,+63R"WeX<""

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f"*%+-&"*%'*"*';&"82'7&"*%/+5>%"652*),'*)+,'2"7+/8+/'*)+,-?"*%&"8/+(57*)+,"+:"6&()'"*&7%,+2+>)&-?"',("*/',-,'*)+,'2"&2)*&-"+,"*%&"+,&"%',("',("*%+-&"8/+(57&("43"+88/&--&("',("&H82+)*&(":2+1-"+:":2&H)42&"2'4+/"+,"*%&"+*%&/<""

S'%2&/"W!cc`X"8/+@)(&-"'"8+)>,',*"&H'682&"7+,@&3),>"*%&"8/+42&6-"8/+(57&("43"*%)-"+@&/-)682):)7'*)+,<"""

A+/"&H'682&?"),"63"+1,"/&-&'/7%"'6)(-*"B'2@'(+/',-"1%+":2&("7)@)2"1'/:'/&"),"*%&)/"7+5,*/3"',("-+5>%*"/&:5>&"),"*%&"=,)*&("B'*&-?"C",+1":),("U5)*&"7+66+,"*%&":+22+1),>"-7&,'/)+f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d@&/"-&@&/'2"3&'/-?"%&"-U5&&Y&("+5*"+:"%)-"&'/,),>-"&,+5>%"6+,&3"*+"45)2("'",&1"%+5-&"),"%)-"%+6&*+1,"),".2"B'2@'(+/"',("*+"453"-&@&/'2"'7/&-"+:"2',(<"F&",+1"8'3-"*1+"('3"1+/;&/-?";,+1,"'-"5&T&:?"*%&"6),)656"(')23"1'>&"*+"1+/;"*%)-"2',("',("/&2)&@&"%)-"1):&"',("7%)2(/&,"+:"*%'*"45/(&,<"$%&"6)>/',*0-"/&6)**',7&-":),',7&"*%&"&(57'*)+,"+:"%)-"7%)2(/&,"1%+"'-8)/&"*+"4&7+6&"8/+:&--)+,'2-<"S&',1%)2&?"*%&"6+Y+-"7',"4'/&23":&&(?"2&*"'"2+*"&(57'*&"*%&)/"7%)2(/&,?"1%+"),"*5/,?"'-8)/&"*+"&6)>/'*&"*+"*%&"2',("+:"(+22'/-"WeMX<"""""""""""

"S'%2&/0-"&H'682&")225-*/'*&-"*%&"652*)82&"',("),*&/-&7*),>"()6&,-)+,-"',("'>&,7)&-"8/+(57&("43"6+(&-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6<"B%&">+&-"+,"*+"'-;?">)@&,"%&/"&H'682&?"""

C-"*%&":+/6&/"8&'-',*"&H82+)*&(?"&H82+)*&/?"+/"4+*%["K',"*%&"6&*'9,'//'*)@&"+:"=,)*&("B*'*&-"%&>&6+,3"+@&/"i'*),"E6&/)7'"&H82'),"&@&/3"2&@&2"+:"+88/&--)+,"%&/&["C:",+*?"',("'"652*)82)7)*3"+:"8+1&/:52"'>&,*-"',("+88/&--)+,-")-"'7;,+12&(>&(?"-%+52(,0*"*%&3"*%&,"4&"()-*),>5)-%&("43"6'>,)*5(&"+:"),:25&,7&"',("43"/&2'*)+,-%)8"*+"+*%&/"'>&,*-["C,"-%+/*?"*%&"(5'2)-*"@)-)+,97+2+,)Y&/"',("

Page 22: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!M"

7+2+,)Y&(?"7+/&"',("8&/)8%&/3?"A)/-*"',("$%)/("P+/2(-9)-"4&7+6),>"5,'77&8*'42&?"/&82'7&("43"'"6+/&"*&H*5/&("',("8/+42&6'*)Y&("8+/*/')*?"45*"*%)-"8+/*/')*")-",+1%&/&",&'/"7+682&*)+,"W)4)(X<""

"E-"'"6&',-"+:"'((/&--),>"*%)-"8/+42&6'*)7?"S'%2&/"',("+*%&/-"%'@&"2++;&("*+"h/&1'2"',("l'82',0-"W!ccb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f"652*)82&?"+@&/2'88),>?"',("()-7/&*&<"

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

"$/',-,'*)+,'2"*%&+/3"%&28-"-7%+2'/-"*+",+*"+,23"6';&"-&,-&"+:"*%&"1'3-"),"

1%)7%"6)>/',*-"',(")66)>/',*-"*/',-:+/6"*%&"-8'7&-"),"1%)7%"*%&3"-&**2&"',("1+/;"45*"*%/+5>%"*%&"@'/)+5-":+/6-"*%'*"/&*5/,"*';&-?"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"8/+@)(&-"'"6&',-":+/">/'882),>"1)*%"*%&"1'3-"),"1%)7%"*%&-&"-'6&">/+58-"'/&"*/',-:+/6),>"*%&"7+5,*/)&-"*%'*"*%&3"%'@&"2&:*<"_&>'/(),>"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6?"G&/*+@&7"W#LLbX"&H82'),-"*%'*"8'**&/,-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"7',"-+6&*)6&-"2&'("*+"-+7)'2"*/',-:+/6'*)+,"'*"'"657%"2'/>&/"-7'2&"-'3),>?""

"P%)2&",+*"4/),>),>"'4+5*"-54-*',*)'2"-+7)&*'2"*/',-:+/6'*)+,"43"*%&6-&2@&-?"8'**&/,-"+:"7/+--94+/(&/"&H7%',>&"',("/&2'*)+,-%)8"'6+,>"6)>/',*-"6'3"7+,*/)45*&"-)>,):)7',*23"*+"4/+'(&,),>?"(&&8&,),>"+/"),*&,-):3),>"7+,I+),&("8/+7&--&-"+:"*/',-:+/6'*)+,"*%'*"'/&"'2/&'(3"+,>+),>"Wca#X<""

Page 23: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!e"

"$%&"/&*5/,"6)>/'*)+,"+:"A)2)8),+"&H8'*/)'*&-":/+6"*%&"=<B<")-"'"-),>52'/"7+68+,&,*"1)*%),"*%&"4/+'(&/"-+7)'2":)&2("8/+(57&("43"A)2)8),+"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"',("*%&"%)-*+/)7'2"2),;'>&"4&*1&&,"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("*%&"=<B<"$%&"6'--)@&"*/',-:+/6'*)+,"+:"S',)2'0-"2',(-7'8&"',("8/+(57*)+,"+:"/&'2"&-*'*&?":+75-&("+,"7'8*5/),>"*%&"&7+,+6)7"),@&-*6&,*"+:"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"'4/+'(?"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"7)*3"',(")*-"8&/)8%&/)&-"%'@&"%'("',"),(&2)42&"&::&7*"+,"*%&"-+7)'2"2):&"+:"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""

S+-*"-7%+2'/-"1%+"&H'6),&"/&*5/,"6)>/'*)+,"*&,("*+"&H82'),"*%&"8%&,+6&,+,"8/)6'/)23"'-"'"/&-8+,-&"*+"@'/)+5-"&7+,+6)7"8/&--5/&-?"1%&/&43"/&*5/,")-"*%&":),'2"8%'-&"1)*%),"*%&"6)>/'*)+,"8/+7&--<"P)*%),"*%)-":/'6&?"8&/)+()7"@)-)*-"',("+*%&/"*38&-"+:"*&68+/'/3"-*'3-"'/&"@)&1&("'-"4&),>"-&8'/'*&":/+6"*%&"8%&,+6&,+,"+:"/&*5/,"6)>/'*)+,<"N'**)-*&22'"W#LLb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

h6&27%"W!c`LX?"+,&"+:"*%&":)/-*"-7%+2'/-"*+"'**&68*"*+"72+-&23"&H'6),&"/&*5/,"6)>/'*)+,?"7+,:/+,*-"*%&-&"7+682&H)*)&-"43"(/'1),>"'"4'-)7"()-*),7*)+,"4&*1&&,"&6)>/',*-"1%+"),*&,("*%&)/"(&8'/*5/&"*+"4&"8&/6',&,*"',("*%+-&"1%+"),*&,(")*"*+"4&"*&68+/'/3<"$%&"'5*%+/"8+),*-"+5*"*%'*"6+-*"-*5()&-"),()7'*&"*%'*"-*/+,>":'6)23"*)&-?"/'*%&/"*%',"&7+,+6)7":'7*+/-?"+,&0-":')25/&"*+"'7%)&@&":),',7)'2"-577&--?"'/&"*%&"6'I+/"),7&,*)@&":+/"/&*5/,<"A/+6"'"6+/&"2+7'2"7+,*&H*?"K'/+2"B*'7;"8/+@)(&-"+,&"&H'682&":+/"h6&27%0-"8&/-8&7*)@&<"B*'7;"W!cceX"1/)*&-"'4+5*"E:/)7',"E6&/)7',-"1%+"/&*5/,&("*+"*%&)/"/5/'2"%+6&-"),"*%&"=<B<"B+5*%<"B%&"&H82'),-"*%'*"/&*5/,"6)>/'*)+,?"+/"),"*%)-"7'-&"/&*5/,"),*&/,'2"6)>/'*)+,?":+/"E:/)7',"E6&/)7',-?")-"'"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!!"A+/"',"),"(&8*%"7+68'/'*)@&"()-75--)+,"+,"*%&-&"*38+2+>)&-"1/)**&,":/+6"'",&+72'--)7'2"8&/-8&7*)@&?"-&&"_+-&6'/)&"_+>&/-0"7%'8*&/"Q_&*5/,"S)>/'*)+,"),"K+68'/'*)@&"D&/-8&7*)@&-R"),"l54'*?"J',)&20-"W&(<X"+,-!;&0*$*):!&F!<-$(%#"WB*'*&,"C-2',(?"VOf"K&,*&/":+/"S)>/'*)+,"B*5()&-?"!c`bX"88<"#aa9cc<""

Page 24: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!a"

7+68+-)*&"+:"@'/)+5-"),*&/-&7*),>"7+68+,&,*-"*%'*"%'@&"2)**2&"*+"(+"1)*%"&7+,+6)7"/'*)+,'2&<"A+/"%&/?"/&'-+,-":+/"/&*5/,"6)>/'*)+,"),725(&?"""

E"8+1&/:52"42&,("+:"6+*)@&-g"4'("*)6&-"4'7;"%+6&"7',"8522"'-"1&22"'-"85-%<"D&+82&":&&2"',"+42)>'*)+,"*+"%&28"*%&)/";),("+/"&@&,"'"-&,-&"+:"6)--)+,"*+"/&(&&6"'"2+-*"7+665,)*3\<+/"-)6823"'"4/&'*%),>"-8'7&?"'"/&:5>&":/+6"*%&"6'&2-*/+6"W!cce?"H@X<""

"P%)2&"1/)**&,":/+6"'"=<B<"8&/-8&7*)@&?"*%&"7+682&H)*3"',("'64)@'2&,7&"'/+5,("7+,7&8*-"+:"Q%+6&R"&H5(&("1)*%),"B*'7;0-"1+/;"7+,*),5&-"*+":5,7*)+,"'-"'":+7'2"8+),*"1)*%),"*%&"4/+'(&/"2)*&/'*5/&"'/+5,("/&*5/,"6)>/'*)+,<""

_&*5/,"7',"'2-+"4&"8'/*"+:"*%&"),)*)'2"6)>/'*)+,"-*/'*&>3?"'24&)*":/&U5&,*23"8+-*8+,&(<"$%5-"*%&"7+,7&8*"+:"-+I+5/,&/"%'-"4&&,"),*/+(57&("'-"'"()-*),7*"*38&"+:"6)>/',*<"A+/"&H'682&?"S'/>+2)-"W!ccMX",+*&-"*%'*"N/'Y)2)',-"),"*%&"=<B<"-&&"*%&6-&2@&-"'-"-+I+5/,&/-?"*'/>&*"&'/,&/-"1%+"'/&"6+*)@'*&("Q43"*%&"(&-)/&"*+"-'@&"6+,&3"*+"6&&*"-+6&"-8&7):)7">+'2"4'7;"%+6&9453"'"%+5-&"+/"'8'/*6&,*?"'"7'/"+/"*&2&8%+,&?"-*'/*"45-),&--?"+/"8&/%'8-"/&*5/,"*+"-7%++2R"WZ!X<"B)6)2'/23?"S)Y5;'6)"W#LLaX"72')6-"*%'*"*%&"*&68+/'2"',("6+/&"-+I+5/,&/"7+,()*)+,"%'-"8/&(+6),'*&("k'8',&-&"6)>/'*)+,"*+"E5-*/'2)'"-),7&"*%&"!ceL-"1%&/&")*")-"+:*&,"*%&"7'-&"*%'*"k'8',&-&")66)>/',*-"1%+"6)>/'*&"*+"E5-*/'2)'",&@&/"&,@)-)+,&("*%&)/"-*'3"*+"4&"8&/6',&,*"',("),":'7*"/&*5/,"*+"k'8',"':*&/"*%&)/"2'4+/"7+,*/'7*-"'/&"7+682&*&(<"

$%&"U5&-*)+,"+:"-&**2&/"+/"-+I+5/,&/")-"8'/*"+:"'"2)*&/'*5/&"+,"6)>/'*)+,")(&+2+>3"*%'*"('*&-"4'7;"*+"D%)28+**0-"W!caZX"/&-&'/7%"+,"P&-*"C,()',"6)>/'*)+,<"C,"*%&"D+/*5>5&-&"7'-&":+/"),-*',7&?"N/&**&22"W#LLZX"8/+@)(&-"',"&*%,+>/'8%)7"-*5(3"+:"*%&"752*5/'223"&64&((&("7+,7&8*"+:":/('/'-"+/",+-*'2>)'":+/"*%&"%+6&2',(<"G'/)+5-"6',):&-*'*)+,-"+:",+-*'2>)'?"'"-&,*)6&,*"*%'*"+:*&,")64/)7'*&-"1)*%",+*)+,-"+:"Q%+6&R?")-"7+,*),5+5-23"4/+5>%*"58"1)*%),"/&*5/,"6)>/'*)+,"2)*&/'*5/&?"8'/*)752'/23"),"*%&":)&2(-"+:"E,*%/+8+2+>3"',("K+68'/'*)@&"i)*&/'*5/&<".-8)/)*5"W#LLZX?"1/)*),>"),"*%&"7+,*&H*"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"),"K'2):+/,)'?"@)&1-",+-*'2>)'"'-"'"6'I+/"7+68+,&,*"1)*%),"7+,*&68+/'/3"6+(&-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6<"B%&"@)&1-",+-*'2>)'"'-"*%&"8/)6'/3"@&%)72&":+/"6+(&-"+:"/&*5/,"-'3),>?"QC"1+52("'/>5&"*%'*"'22")66)>/',*-9/&>'/(2&--"+:"72'--97',"',("(+"u/&*5/,"%+6&0"*%/+5>%"*%&")6'>),'*)+,R"W!!X<"

N&7'5-&"+:"*%&",'*5/&"+:"/&*5/,"6)>/'*)+,?"-&@&/'2"-7%+2'/-"&H'6),&"*%&")68'7*"+:"+5*96)>/'*)+,"+,"*%+-&"2&:*"4&%),("',("*%&"/&),*&>/'*)+,"+:"*%+-&"1%+"%'@&"/&*5/,"':*&/"6',3"3&'/-"'4/+'(<"S',(&2"W!c`c?"!ccLX"(&-7/)4&-"*%&"8'),"',("()-+/)&,*'*)+,"7%'/'7*&/)-*)7"+:"'(+2&-7&,*"$5/;)-%"/&*5/,&&-?"',("),"',+*%&/"&--'3"-%&"'225(&-"*+"*%&"7/&'*)+,"+:"'",&1"&*%,)7"7'*&>+/3":+/"$5/;-"1%+"%'@&"/&8'*/)'*&(9A0/5/#3/0*"+/"*%&"Qh&/6',2);&R<"$-5('"W#LLcX"/&:&/-"*+"*%)-"-&7+,(">/+58"+:"/&*5/,"6)>/',*-"'-"&*%,)7"/&*5/,"6)>/',*-"+/"*%&"Q2'*&/9>&,&/'*)+,"(&-7&,(',*-"+:"()'-8+/)7"8&+82&-"1%+"u/&*5/,"*+"*%&)/"7+5,*/)&-"+:"',7&-*/'2"+/)>),"':*&/"2)@),>"+5*-)(&"*%&)/"&*%,)7"%+6&2',(-":+/">&,&/'*)+,-"W!X<""

J&-8)*&"*%&"/&2'*)@&23"2'/>&",564&/"+:"&*%,)7"/&*5/,"6)>/',*-"'/+5,("*%&"1+/2(?"*%&"*+8)7"%'-",+*"/&7&)@&("657%"'**&,*)+,"),"6)>/'*)+,"-*5()&-<"=-5'223"/&:&//&("*+"),"*%&"2)*&/'*5/&"'-"&*%,)7"'::),)*3"6)>/'*)+,?"6+-*"/&-&'/7%"'-"(&'2*"1)*%"

Page 25: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!`"

k&1)-%"',("&*%,)7"h&/6',"/&*5/,<!#"$%&/&"%'@&"4&&,"'"%',(:52"+:"-7%+2'/-"1%+"%'@&"(&'2*"1)*%"&*%,)7"/&*5/,"6)>/'*)+,?"%+1&@&/"$-5('"-5>>&-*-"*%'*"*%&/&")-"3&*"*+"4&"'">&,&/'2"7+68'/'*)@&"','23*)7'2":/'6&1+/;"*%'*"%'-"4&&,"),*/+(57&("*+"7+,@&3"*%&",5',7&-"+:"*%&"*%)-"8'/*)752'/"6)>/'*)+,":2+1<!Z"

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

A+/"*%)-"/&'-+,?"$-5('"W#LLcX"&682+3-"*%&"*&/6"Q()'-8+/)7"%+6&7+6),>-R"/&),*/+(57&-"*%&",+*)+,"+:"()'-8+/'"),*+"*%&"2)*&/'*5/&"+:"/&*5/,"6)>/'*)+,<"$%&"5-&"+:"*%&"*&/6"()'-8+/'"%&28-"*+"%)>%2)>%*"*%&""

"d:*&,"'64)@'2&,*?"):",+*",&>'*)@&"&H8&/)&,7&-":+/"6',3"&*%,)7"/&*5/,"6)>/',*-<"J&-8)*&"),)*)'2"&H8&7*'*)+,"*%'*"*%&)/"8/&-56&("&*%,)7"'::),)*3"1)*%"*%&"%+-*"-+7)&*3"W'-"u7+9&*%,)7-0X"1+52(":'7)2)*'*&"*%&)/"-+7)'2"),*&>/'*)+,?"*%&3"'/&"+:*&,"&*%,)7'223"&H725(&("'-":+/&)>,&/-"),"*%&)/"',7&-*/'2"%+6&2',(-"4&7'5-&"+:"*%&"'2)&,"752*5/'2"()::&/&,7&-"*%&3"%'@&"'7U5)/&("1%)2&"2)@),>"'4/+'(":+/">&,&/'*)+,-"WZ9bX<""

"i);&"*%&"7'-&"+:"4'2);4'3',-?"S'/;+1)*Y"',("B*&:',--+,"W#LLb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

"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!#"B&&?":+/"),-*',7&?"_'),&/"Sv,Y"',("_'),&/"d%2)>&/0-"P*/:7&%/:!/#'!4$,#*)!6*8%/#$:?!@-%5/#C!":%/-0C!/#'!;&:$=E&J*-$!E())-::&%!E$/$-:!*#!D&57/%/$*J-!;-%:7-)$*J-"Wi+,(+,f"_+5*2&(>&?"#LLZX"',("i'/)--'"_&6&,,)7;0-"W#LLcXQA+/6&/"B+@)&*"k&1-"),"$%&)/"V&1pd2("F+6&2',(f"N&*1&&,"C,*&>/'*)+,"',("B&8'/'*)-6R"),"$';&35,)"$-5('"W&(<X"P*/:7&%*)!O&5-)&5*#8:?!4$,#*)!<-$(%#!6*8%/$*&#!*#!D&57/%/$*J-!;-%:7-)$*J-"WB*',:+/(f"B*',:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLcX?"#L`9##e<""!Z"B&&"E,(/&'"i+5)&0-"D,*#-:-#-::!A)%&::!.&%'-%:?!<-#-8&$*/$*#8!D,*#-:-!"'-#$*$*-:!*#!D,*#/!/#'!$,-!U#*$-'!E$/$-:"WJ5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLbX?"k+-%5'"F+*';'"_+*%0-".%&1-%-'!O&5-0/#'?!Y/7/#-:-!.%/T*0*/#!6*8%/#$:!*#!Y/7/#"WC*%'7'f"K+/,&22"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LL#X?"',("',("$';&35;)"$-5('0-"E$%/#8-%:!*#!$,-!4$,#*)!O&5-0/#'?!Y/7/#-:-!.%/T*0*/#!<-$(%#!6*8%/$*&#!*#!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!;-%:7-)$*J-"WV&1"O+/;f"K+2564)'"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLZX<"

Page 26: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!c"

B),7&"*%&"8542)-%),>"+:"A/&("K+/(+@'0-"9*0*7*#&:?!9&%8&$$-#!A:*/#!A5-%*)/#:"),"!c`Z?"*%&/&"%'-"4&&,"'"8/+2):&/'*)+,"+:"-*5()&-"+,"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"1/)**&,"*+"7+,*&-*"1%'*"S'**%&1"A/3&"k'7+4-+,"7'22-"Q)68&/)'2"'6,&-)'R"+/"*%&"Q'/*-"+:"'6,&-)'"',("*%&"&H*/'+/(),'/3"),>&,5)*3"1)*%"1%)7%"E6&/)7',-"%'@&"4&&,"'42&"*+":+/>&*"*%&)/")68&/)'2"8'-*"W',("-+"*+"'4-+2@&"*%&)/")68&/)'2)-*"8/&-&,*XR"W!ccc?"!!aX<!b"N3"%)-*+/)7'223"-)*5'*),>"*%&"2),;'>&"4&*1&&,"*%&"=<B<"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1)*%),"*%&"&8+7%"+:"=<B<")68&/)'2)-6?"*%)-"-&*"+:"2)*&/'*5/&")-"*%&":)/-*"-&/)+5-"'**&68*"*+"7+,I+),"*+>&*%&/"*1+"+*%&/1)-&"-&8'/'*&"3&*"7+,75//&,*"-+7)'2":)&2(-f"*%'*"+:"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("*%+-&"),"*%&"=<B<""

K+/(+@'0-"8)7*+/)'2"&--'3"(&8)7*),>"*%&"2)@&-"+:"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"-),7&"-+6&"+:"*%&)/"&'/2)&-*"-&**2&6&,*-"),"i+5)-)','"43"1'3"+:"B8',)-%">'22&+,-"*/'@&2),>"4&*1&&,"S&H)7+"',("B8'),"),"!ae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

$%&">/+5,(1+/;"%'("4&&,"'/(5+5-23"2')("43"*%&-&"8)+,&&/),>"-7%+2'/-"+8&,),>"58"*%&"1'3":+/"',"+,/5-%"+:"',"&,*)/&">&,&/'*)+,"+:",+*"+,23"-7%+2'/-"45*"8+&*-?"'/*)-*-?"',("*%),;&/-?"6',3"+:"1%+6"1&/&"*%&"7%)2(/&,"+:"A)2)8),+")66)>/',*-<".6&/>),>"1)*%),"*%&"6)2)&5"+:"=<B<"652*)752*5/'2)-6"',("-*&&8&("),"8+-*7+2+,)'2"*%&+/3?"*%)-">&,&/'*)+,"-+5>%*"*+"7+682)7'*&"*%&">+'2"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"-7%+2'/-%)8<"$%&)/"1+/;"1'-":+75-&("+,"),*&//+>'*),>"1%'*"d-7'/"G<"K'68+6',&-"7'22&("*%&"Q-8&7*/&"+:"),@)-)4)2)*3R"7'-*&("+,*+"A)2)8),+-"*%/+5>%"*%&"7+,*),5'2",&>2&7*"+:"*%&"2'/>&/"=<B<"%)-*+/)+>/'8%3"*+"'77+5,*":+/"*%&"&8+7%"+:"E6&/)7',"7+,U5&-*"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<!e"C,"7+,@&3),>"*%&"85/8+-&"+:"%)-"&()*&("@+256&?"$)+,>-+,"W#LLeX"),()/&7*23"&H82'),-"*%&"2'/>&/"-%):*"1)*%),"A)2)8),+"B*5()&-"),"',+*%&/"1'3?"-'3),>?"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!b"k'7+4-+,0-"'/*)72&"+,"*%&"6',,&/"),"1%)7%"D542)7"N/+'(7'-*),>"B*'*)+,"WDNBX"-&/)&-"+,"E6&/)7',"D/&-)(&,*-":')2&("*+"'7;,+12&(>&"$%&+(+/&"_++-&@&2*0-"7&,*/'2"/+2&"),"*%&"7+,U5&-*"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"(5/),>"*%&"=<B<9D%)2)88),&"1'/")-"-6'22"7+,*/)45*)+,"*+"'"657%"2'/>&/"4+(3"+:"1+/;"*%'*"4/),>-"*+"2)>%*"*%&"7+2+,)Y'*)+,"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'-"',"'**&68*"*+"8/+@)(&"*%&"=<B<"'"-*/'*&>)7"*/'(&"8+-)*)+,"1)*%"7+5,*/)&-"),"E-)'<"B&&"k52)',"h+"',("E,,&"i<"A+-*&/?"&(-<?"+,-!A5-%*)/#!D&0&#*/0!E$/$-!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:?!@0&2/0!;-%:7-)$*J-:!WJ5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLZXg"B%'/+,"J&26&,(+?"+,-!E$/%94#$/#80-'!./##-%?!X#-!O(#'%-'!Z-/%:!&F!A5-%*)/!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:"WV&1"N/5,-1)7;f"_5*>&/-"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLbX<"E6&/)7',)-*"-7%+2'/-"+:"=<B<")68&/)'2)-6"1%+":+75-"+,">&,(&/"'-"'"6+(&"+:"','23-)-"),725(&"l/)-*),"i<"F+>',-+,?"9*8,$*#8!F&%!A5-%*)/#!6/#,&&'?!O&>!@-#'-%!;&0*$*):!;%&J&1-'!$,-!E7/#*:,=A5-%*)/#!/#'!;,*0*77*#-=A5-%*)/#!B/%:"WV&1"F'@&,f"O'2&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"!cc`X<"!M"B&&"'-"'":&1"&H'682&-?"k+,'*%',"O<"d;'65/'0-""5/8*#*#8!$,-!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#!P*/:7&%/?!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!<-0/$*&#:C!"'-#$*$*-:C!/#'!D&55(#*$*-:"WV&1"O+/;f"h'/2',("D54<?"!cc`X"',("N'/4'/'"S<"D+-'('-0"+,-!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#:"WP&-8+/*f"h/&&,1++("D/&--?"!cccX<""!e"K'68+6',&-"1'-"+,&"+:"*%&":)/-*"A)2)8),+"-7%+2'/-"*+"7/)*)U5&"Q*%&"/&8&*)*)+5-"',("5,/&:2&7*)@&"5-&"+:"*%&"6+():)&/"u:+/>+**&,0"*+"(&-7/)4&?"&@&,"/&,&1?"*%)-"75/-&"+:"),@)-)4)2)*3R"1)*%),"&'/23"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',)-*"2)*&/'*5/&<"P%'*"%&"7'22-"*%&"Q-8&7*/&"+:"),@)-)4)2)*3R"/&:&/-"*+",&&("*+"8&/8&*5'*&"*%&"),@)-)4)2)*3"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"-8&7):)7'223"1)*%),"=<B<"%)-*+/)+>/'8%3"8/)6'/)23"4&7'5-&"Q*%&"',,&H'*)+,"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"8/+@&("*+"4&"7+,-*)*5*)+,'223"',("752*5/'223"8/+42&6'*)7":+/"E6&/)7',"

Page 27: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

#L"

"$%)-"@+256&\')6-"*+"6+/&"*%',"I5-*":)22"'">'8?"*%'*")-?"*+"7+68&,-'*&":+/"*%&"(&'/*%"+:"-7%+2'/-%)8"+,"A)2)8),+-?"1%)7%"5-5'223"*';&-"*%&":+/6"+:"5,7+@&/),>"A)2)8),+"u'77+682)-%6&,*-0"+/?"I5-*"'-"8/+42&6'*)7"',("),-)()+5-?"(+756&,*),>"A)2)8),+"u:)/-*-0\C,-*&'(")*"')6-"*+"&,>'>&"),"*%&"6+/&"()::)752*"45*",&7&--'/3"*'-;"+:"(&2),&'*),>"*%&"7+,*+5/-"+:"1%'*")*"6&',-"*+"&H%'5-*)@&23"'77+5,*":+/"*%&"-8&7):)7)*)&-"+:"A)2)8),+-"WeX<""

"B)6823"85*?"/'*%&/"*%',"*';),>":+/">/',*&("*%&"),@)-)4)2)*3"+:"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<?"*%)-">&,&/'*)+,"+:"-7%+2'/-%)8":+75-&("*%&)/"','23-)-"+,"(&6+,-*/'*),>?"),"@&/3"72&'/"1'3-?"%+1"'"-&*"+:"8+2)7)&-"',("2&>)-2'*5/&"7+,-*/57*&("(5/),>"*%&"=<B<"7+2+,)'2"8&/)+("8/&7)8)*'*&("*%&"@'/)+5-":+/6-"+:"),@)-)4)2)*3"*%'*"A)2)8),+-"&H8&/)&,7&"1)*%),"*%&"=<B<"*+('3<!a"""

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

C,"*%&"7+,*&H*"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"B*5()&-?"*%&":/'6&1+/;"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"%'-":'7)2)*'*&("',"5,(&/-*',(),>"+:"%+1"*%&"%)-*+/3"+:"=<B<")68&/)'2)-6"7+,*),5'223"'::&7*-"*%&"&H8&/)&,7&-"+:">&,&/'*)+,-"+:"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"',("%+1">2+4'2"8/+7&--&-"',("6&6+/3"*)&-"*%&6"4'7;"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"W.-8)/)*5"#LLZX<"F)-*+/)',-"-57%"'-"K'*%&/),&"K&,)Y'"K%+3"W#LLZg"#LLMX?"J+/+*%3"A5I)*'9_+,3"W#LLZX?"',("E5>5-*+".-8)/)*5"W#LLMX"&682+3&("'"*%&+/&*)7'2":/'6&1+/;"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"),"+/(&/"*+"7+,@&3"*%&"%)-*+/)7'2"/+2&"*%'*"D%)2)88),&"2'4+/"',("*%&"8/+(57*)+,"+:"D%)2)88),&"),*&22&7*5'2-"82'3&("),"&H8',(),>"*%&"=<B<0-"&7+,+6)7"8/&-&,7&"*%/+5>%+5*"E-)'<""""

O&*?"'8'/*":/+6"*%&"%)-*+/)7'2"2)*&/'*5/&":+75-&("+,"=<B<")68&/)'2)-6"4&*1&&,"4+*%"7+5,*/)&-?"*%&/&"/&6'),-?"+,23"'"%',(:52"+:"*&H*-"&H'6),),>"*%&"+,>+),>"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""8+2)*)7'2"',("7)@)2"-+7)&*3"'/+5,("*%&"*5/,"+:"*%&"7&,*5/3"',("*%&/&':*&/R<""B&&"d-7'/"G<"K'68+6',&-0"7%'8*&/"QA)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=,)*&("B*'*&-"',("$%&)/"i)*&/'*5/&"+:".H)2&R"),"i56?"B%)/2&3"h&+;92),"',("i),>?"E630-"W&(-<X"<-/'*#8!$,-!N*$-%/$(%-:!&F!A:*/#!A5-%*)/"WD%)2'(&28%)'f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"$&682&"D/&--?"!cc#X<""!a"E2+,>"1)*%"K+/(+@'?"',+*%&/"-7%+2'/"1%+"&682+3&("*%&"*&/6"R:+/>+**&,R"+,*+"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"1'-"_+,'2(+"$';';)?"1%+-&"7%'8*&/"+,"&'/23"A)2)8),+"6)>/'*)+,-"%'("'"4&&,"*%&"8/)6'/3"*&H*":+/"5,(&/-*',(),>"*%&")66)>/'*)+,"%)-*+/3"+:"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<":+/"+@&/"'">&,&/'*)+,<"B&&"$';';)0-"E$%/#8-%:!F%&5!/!P*FF-%-#$!E,&%-?!A!O*:$&%3!&F!A:*/#!A5-%*)/#:"WN+-*+,f"i)**2&?"N/+1,"',("K+68',3X<"A+/"'"-3-*&6'*)7"7/)*)U5&"+:"*%&"),@)-)4)2)*3",'//'*)@&?"-&&"S'&"V>')0-"*&H*""57&::*20-!E(2V-)$:?!"00-8/0!A0*-#:!/#'!$,-!6/1*#8!&F!6&'-%#!A5-%*)/"WD/),7&*+,f"D/),7&*+,"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLbX":+/"'"()-75--)+,"*%&"2&>)-2'*)@&"%)-*+/3"7+,-*)*5*),>"A)2)8),+-"'-"5,(&-)/'42&"2'4+/"',("G)7*+/"N'-7'/'0-"6&'-0=6*#&%*$3!"57-%*/0*:5"WS),,&-+*'f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"S),,&-+*'"D/&--?"#LLeX":+/"',"&U5'223",5',7&("()-75--)+,"+,"%+1"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"&64+(3"*%&"2)6)*-"',("7+,*/'()7*)+,-"+:"=<B<"7)*)Y&,-%)8":/+6"'"7+68'/'*)@&"2)*&/'*5/&"','23-)-<""

Page 28: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

#!"

7+,,&7*)+,"4&*1&&,"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"',("*%+-&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<!`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

N&7'5-&"*%&-&"),*&/1&'@),>"7+682&H)*)&-"-)652*',&+5-23":5,7*)+,"+,">2+4'2"',("2+7'2"2&@&2-?"1%&,"-*5(3),>"*%&"/'7)'2":+/6'*)+,"+:"A)2)8),+-"4&*1&&,",'*)+,-?"-57%"'"8%&,+6&,+,"/&U5)/&-"',"','23-)-"*%'*?"'-"D'52"l/'6&/"W#LLeX"'/>5&-?"-2)(&-9-7'2&-<"C,"+/(&/"*+"7+68/&%&,("*%&"8+-)*)+,'2)*3"+:"A)2)8),+-"1)*%),"*%)-"*/',-,'*)+,'2"7)/752'*)+,?"+,&"7',,+*":+22+1"'"2),&'/"7%/+,+2+>3"1%)7%"4&>',"),"!`c`"',("-*+8"'*"*%&"8/&-&,*<"V+/"7',"+,&"-)6823"8&&/"4'7;"'*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-":/+6"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!`"A/+6"'"%)-*+/)7'2"8&/-8&7*)@&?"G)7&,*&"_':'&20-"*&H*"B,*$-!N&J-!/#'!X$,-%!4J-#$:!*#!9*0*7*#&!O*:$&%3"WJ5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLLX"',("%)-"'**&68*"*+"7%/+,)72&"*%&"+,>+),>"8/&-&,7&"+:"*%&"=<B<"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*%/+5>%"*%&"8/+(57*)+,"+:"@'/)+5-"8+-*7+2+,)'2"-54I&7*)@)*)&-")-"-&6),'2<"$1+"7+,*&68+/'/3"*&H*-"%'@&"(&'2*"1)*%"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"),"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"-7%+2'/-%)8"),"),,+@'*)@&"1'3-<"S'/*),"S','2',-',0-"@0&2/0!P*J/:?!9*0*7*#&!@/3!6-#!*#!$,-!P*/:7&%/"WJ5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLZX"&H82+/&-"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"7+,-*/57*)+,"+:">'3")(&,*)*)&-"'6+,>-*"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"),"V&1"O+/;<"F&"&H'6),&-"*%&"@'/)+5-"1'3-"A)2)8),+">'3":>/%':7-/1"+/"$'>'2+>9.,>2)-%"7+(&9-1)*7%),>"4&7'6&"),*&>/'2"*+"8/+(57),>"'"-8'7&"+:"'::),)*3"4&*1&&,">'3"A)2)8),+-"),"V&1"O+/;"+/"7+,*),5'223"7+,:/+,*&("()-7/)6),'*)+,":/+6"652*)82&"-)(&-f"%+6+8%+4)'"',(",'*)@)-6<"C,"'"-)6)2'/"@&),?".6)23"C>,'7)+0-".(*0'*#8!P*/:7&%/?!9*0*7*#&!)&55(#*$3!9&%5/$*&#!&#!$,-!"#$-%#-$!WD)-7'*'1'3f"_5*>&/-"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLbX"7/)*)U5&-"',("&H8',(-"*/'()*)+,'2",+*)+,-"'/+5,("Q*%&",'*)+,R"',("Q%+6&2',(R"43"(&-7/)4),>"*%&"()::&/&,*"1'3-"A)2)8),+-"4+*%"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("),"*%&"=<B<":+/6"7+665,)*)&-"*%/+5>%"()::&/&,*"),*&/,&*"*&7%+,+2+>)&-<"d,&"+:"*%&"4&-*"&H'682&-"%+1&@&/"+:"7+,*&68+/'/3"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&-&'/7%"2),;),>"*%&"=<B<"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*+>&*%&/")-"h5&@'//'0-"6/%1-$*#8!P%-/5:C!6/#(F/)$(%*#8!O-%&-:?!+,-!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!N/2&%!.%&1-%*#8!&F!9*0*7*#&!B&%1-%:"WD)-7'*'1'3f"_5*>&/-"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#L!LX<""

Page 29: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

##"

),-)(&"+:"*%&"8&/-8&7*)@&"+:"E6&/)7'"+/"@)7&9@&/-'<"$%&",+*)+,"+:"-2)(),>9-7'2&-"&-*'42)-%&-"7+,,&7*)+,-"',("'/*)752'*),>"()@&/>&,7&-"4&*1&&,"',"'//'3"+:"2)*&/'*5/&"1/)**&,":/+6"7+//&-8+,(),>"',("7+68&*),>"8+-)*)+,'2)*)&-?"1)*%),"*%&"=<B<?"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"',("*%/+5>%+5*<"l/'6&/t-"-*5(3"+,"*%&"o*/',-,'*)+,'2"8+2)*)7-"+:"/'7&o")-"+,&"&H'682&"'225(),>"*+"*%&"'**&,*)+,"+,&"65-*"8'3"*+"-%):*),>9-7'2&-"',("6+@&"+,&t-":/'6&"+:"/&:&/&,7&":/+6"*%&"o:'6)2)'/o"*+"*%&"o5,:'6)2)'/<o""

""

""#!,-.-/&*0!1)-.%+'$.!/$(!2-%0'('3'45!!"U#J-*0*#8!$,-!"#J*:*20-?!4$,#&8%/7,3!&F!$,-!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!

"C,"+/(&/"*+"&H82+/&"%+1">2+4'2)Y'*)+,")-":+/>),>"*/',-,'*)+,'2"7+,,&7*)+,-"

',("8/+(57),>",&1"5/4',"-8'7&-?"C"1)22"&682+3"*1+"6'I+/"7'-&-"-*5()&-f"W!X"*%&"-&**2&6&,*"+:"8+-*9!ceM"A)2)8),+")66)>/'*)+,"),*+"-545/4',",&)>%4+/%++(-"),"J'23"K)*3?"K'2):+/,)'"',("W#X"*%&"/&8'*/)'*)+,"+:"*%&-&")66)>/',*-"4'7;"),*+"&6&/>),>"-545/4',",&)>%4+/%++(-"),"S&*/+"S',)2'?"D%)2)88),&-<""C"1)22"'**&68*"*+"7'8*5/&"*%&-&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"8/+7&--&-"43"(&-7/)4),>"*%&"6'*&/)'2"'::&7*-"+:"*%&-&"7)/752'*)+,-"+,*+"*%&"2',(-7'8&?"45)2*9&,@)/+,6&,*?"',("8+2)*)7-"1)*%),"&'7%"+:"*%&-&"82'7&-<""

A5/*%&/6+/&?"*%&":/'6&1+/;"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2"5/4',)-6"'**&68*-f"W!X"*+"6+@&"'1'3":/+6"'">2+4'2"@&/-5-"2+7'2"4),'/3g"',("W#X"&68%'-)Y&"*%&"8'/*)752'/"/+2&"82'3&("43"),()@)(5'2-"',(">/+58-"7+68+-),>"*%&-&"*/',-,'*)+,'2":2+1-<"$%&/&:+/&?"*%&"-&7+,("7+68+,&,*"*+"63"-*5(3?")-"),*&/@)&1),>"),()@)(5'2-"1%+"'/&";&3"*+"7/&'*),>"',("/&8/+(57),>"1%'*"*%&-&"82'7&-"o6&',o?"-8&7):)7'223"*%+-&"1%+"'/&"453),>"',("-&22),>"8/+8&/*3"),"*%&-&"8'/*)752'/"2+7'2&-<"C"1)22"4&"&H'6),),>"*%&")(&'2-"',("8/'7*)7&-"+:"8/+8&/*3"+1,&/-%)8"7/&'*&("',("6'),*'),&("43"A)2)8),+"/&'2*+/-"',("*%&)/"72)&,*-"4+*%"),"*%&"=<B<"',("),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"'-"1&22"'-"*%&)/"72)&,*-<""

C"4&>',"8/&2)6),'/3":)&2("/&-&'/7%"),"*%&"=<B<"(5/),>"#LLa9`"(5/),>"63":)/-*"3&'/"'-"'":&22+1"'*"=K"N&/;&2&30-"C,-*)*5*&":+/"*%&"B*5(3"+:"B+7)'2"K%',>&<"$%&/&"C"7+22&7*&("('*'"',("-&*958"8/)6'/3"7+,*'7*-"'-"'"1'3"+:"8/&8'/),>":+/"63"3&'/2+,>":)&2(1+/;"),"4+*%"7)*)&-<"C"&H'6),&("K&,-5-"('*'":/+6"!ca#9#LLe"),"+/(&/"*+"7/&'*&"'"8)7*5/&"+:f"W!X"A)2)8),+"/&'2*+/-"),"7+68'/)-+,"*+"+*%&/"/&'2*+/-"1+/;),>"),"4+*%"7)*)&-g"'-"1&22"'-"A)2)8),+"%+6&+1,&/-"),"4+*%"7)*)&-<""

A+22+1),>"',"&,56&/'*)+,"+:"'22"6'I+/"+/>',)Y'*)+,-"(&'2),>"1)*%"/&'2"&-*'*&"),"*%&-&"'/&'-"W5-),>"8542)7"()/&7*+/)&-"',("+,92),&"/&-+5/7&-X?"C"'88/+'7%&("),()@)(5'2-"'::)2)'*&("1)*%"*%&-&"'>&,7)&-<"C"'2-+"/&7/5)*&("-54I&7*-":/+6"+8&,"%+5-&-"4&),>"%+-*&("),"4+*%"7)*)&-<"d*%&/"8542)723"'@')2'42&"2)-*-"*%'*"7+,*'),&("7+,*'7*"),:+/6'*)+,":+/"8+*&,*)'2"/&-8+,(&,*-"),725(&("+/>',)Y'*)+,'2"()/&7*+/)&-"+:"A)2)8),+"+/>',)Y'*)+,-?"4'2);4'3',"-&/@)7&-?",&1-8'8&/-?"',("C,*&/,&*"1&4-)*&-<""

$%&-&"),9(&8*%"),*&/@)&1-"4&7'6&"*%&":527/56"+:"63"/&-&'/7%"-),7&"C"1'-"'**&68*),>"*+"7'8*5/&"%+1"8'/*)752'/"8/'7*)7&-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2"7)/752'*)+,"'/&"o',7%+/&("),o"8'/*)752'/"82'7&-<"$%&"-54I&7*-"1&/&"7+,*'7*&("*%/+5>%"/&:&//'2-"1)*%"&'/2)&/"-54I&7*-<"$%)-"-,+14'22"*&7%,)U5&"1'-"5-&("1)*%"4+*%"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*-"',("*%&)/"72)&,*-<""

C"7+,(57*&("Z#"),9(&8*%"),*&/@)&1-"+:"/&'2*+/-"W!bX"',("*%&)/"72)&,*-"W!`X"),"*%&":'22"+:"#LL`<"E22"45*"*1+"+:"*%&"/&'2*+/-"1&/&"6&,<"F+1&@&/?"*%&">&,(&/"

Page 30: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

#Z"

4/&';(+1,"+:"A)2)8),+"%+6&453&/-"',("%+6&+1,&/-"1'-"&U5'223"8/+8+/*)+,&("4&*1&&,"c"6&,"',("c"1+6&,<"E26+-*"'22"+:"63"),*&/@)&1&&-")(&,*):)&("'-":)/-*">&,&/'*)+,"A)2)8),+-"1%+"%'("6)>/'*&("*+"*%&"=<B<"4&*1&&,"!ceM"',("!c`M<"E-"-57%?"'22"+:"*%&"/&-8+,(&,*-"1&/&"4&*1&&,"*%&"'>&-"+:"bM"',("eZ<"$%&"8&/)+(":/+6"!ceM"',("!c`M"1+52("1)*,&--"+,&"+:"*%&"6+-*"(/'6'*)7"-%):*-"),"(&6+>/'8%)7-"7/&'*&("43")66)>/'*)+,"&@&/"&H8&/)&,7&("),"*%&"=<B<"J5&"*+"*%&"/')-),>"+:"U5+*'-"-&*"+,")66)>/'*)+,":/+6"*%&"D%)2)88),&-":/+6"!LL"*+"#L?LLL?":/+6"!cee"*+"!caM?"!!b?!La"A)2)8),+-")66)>/'*&("*+"*%&"=<B<""J5/),>"*%)-"-'6&"8&/)+(?"'88/+H)6'*&23"ZLL?LLL"A)2)8),+-"/&2+7'*&("),*+"*%&"=<B<"':*&/"*%&"D%)2)88),&"8/&-)(&,*"A&/(),',("S'/7+-"(&72'/&("S'/*)'2"i'1"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"),"!ca#<""

$%)-"-%):*"%'(",+*"+,23"*5/,&("'"+,7&"8/&(+6),',*23"6'2&"7+,:)>5/'*)+,"+:"A)2)8),+"6)>/',*-"),*+"'"8/&(+6),',*23":&6'2&"+,&"(5&"*+"*%&">&,(&/&("*/',-:+/6'*)+,"+:">2+4'2"2'4+/"6)>/'*)+,"),*+"*%&"=<B<"45*"*%&"-+7)+&7+,+6)7"4'7;>/+5,("+:"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"4&7'6&"&H*/&6&23"%&*&/+>&,&+5-<"S',3"+:"*%&"6)>/',*-"'//)@),>"':*&/"!ce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d,23"*%/&&"+:"*%&"/&-8+,(&,*-"7'6&"*+"*%&"=<B<"'-"'(+2&-7&,*-"',(?"5,2);&"*%+-&"1%+"'//)@&("'-"'(52*-?"*%&3"&68%'-)Y&("*%&"),@+25,*'/),&--"+:"*%&)/"6)>/'*)+,<"d:*&,"1%&,"'-;&("*+"(&-7/)4&"*%&)/"/&'-+,-":+/"7+6),>"*+"*%&"=<B<"*%&3"&H8/&--&("-'(,&--":+/"%'@),>"2&:*":/)&,(-"',(":'6)23"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("'64)@'2&,7&"1)*%"/&>'/("*+"*%&)/"),*&>/'*)+,"),"*%&"=<B<"$%+-&"1%+"6)>/'*&("'-"'(52*-"'2-+"7+,@&3&("'"-&,-&"+:"'64)@'2&,7&"'4+5*"6)>/'*),>"*+"*%&"=<B<?"45*"*%&)/"),*&,*)+,-"',(">+'2-"1&/&"657%"72&'/&/<"$%&3"+:*&,"&H8/&--&("*%&"(&-)/&"*+":),("-*'42&"1+/;"*+"%&28"/')-&"*%&)/"7%)2(/&,"',("*+"+4*'),"+88+/*5,)*)&-"*%'*"1&/&",+*"'@')2'42&"*+"*%&6"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"

C"4&>',"8/&2)6),'/3":)&2("/&-&'/7%"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"(5/),>"*%&"-566&/"+:"#LL`<"$%&/&"C"7+,(57*&("'"/5()6&,*'/3"-5/@&3"+:"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,7)&-"',("(&@&2+86&,*-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"'/&'<"N&7'5-&"C"'6"6';),>"'"()::&/&,*"'/>56&,*"/&>'/(),>"*%&"*/',-:+/6'*)+,"+:"D%)2)88),&"-+7)&*3?"C"4&>',"-5/@&3),>"*%&">/+1*%"+:"/&'2"&-*'*&"(&@&2+86&,*-"*%/+5>%+5*"S&*/+"S',)2'<"$%)-"1)22"2'*&/"4&"I5H*'8+-&("'>'),-*"+*%&/"7+66&/7)'2"',("/&*')2"(&@&2+86&,*-"*%'*"1)22"%&28"6&"*+"6';&"',+*%&/"'/>56&,*"'4+5*"*%&"8'/*)752'/"oE6&/)7',)Y'*)+,o"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&"2',(-7'8&<"C"'2-+"4&>',"7+22&7*),>"',("7/&'*),>"7+,*'7*-"+:"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*-"1%+"C"6)>%*"),*&/@)&1"(5/),>"63"&H*&,(&(":)&2(1+/;"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"J&8&,(),>"+,"*%&"

Page 31: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

#b"

:),',7)'2"-588+/*"C"/&7&)@&":/+6"=K"N&/;&2&3"+/"+*%&/":&22+1-%)8-?"C"),*&,("+,"2)@),>"),"',("(+),>"/&-&'/7%"),"S&*/+"S',)2'":+/"c9!#"6+,*%-<""

B)6)2'/"*+"*%&"6&*%+(-"*%'*"C"1)22"&682+3"),"*%&"=<B<?"C"1)22"'2-+"&,56&/'*&"'22"6'I+/"+/>',)Y'*)+,-"(&'2),>"1)*%"/&'2"&-*'*&"),"S&*/+"S',)2'"W5-),>"8542)7"()/&7*+/)&-"',("+,9"2),&"/&-+5/7&-X<"d*%&/"8542)723"'@')2'42&"2)-*-"*%'*"7+,*'),"7+,*'7*"),:+/6'*)+,":+/"8+*&,*)'2"/&-8+,(&,*-"),725(&"+/>',)Y'*)+,'2"()/&7*+/)&-"+:"-*'*&"'>&,7)&-?"4'2);4'3',"-&/@)7&-?",&1-8'8&/-?"',("C,*&/,&*"1&4-)*&-<"C"1)22"*%&,"'88/+'7%"),()@)(5'2-"'::)2)'*&("1)*%"*%&-&"+/>',)Y'*)+,-<"$%&"72)&,*"/&-&'/7%"-54I&7*-":+/"),9(&8*%"),*&/@)&1-"1)22"4&"7+,*'7*&("*%/+5>%"/&:&//'2-"1)*%"&'/2)&/"-54I&7*-<"$%)-"-,+14'22"*&7%,)U5&"1)22"'>'),"4&"5-&("1)*%"4+*%"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*-"',("*%&)/"72)&,*-<""

C"7+,(57*&("b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

"$%&/&"'/&"*1+"6'),"8'/*-"+:"*%&"()--&/*'*)+,f"$%&":)/-*":+75-&-"+,"*%&"

*/',-,'*)+,'2"-+7)'2":)&2("4&*1&&,"J'23"K)*3"',("S&*/+"S',)2'"8/)6'/)23"*%/+5>%"*%&"2&,-"+:"/&'2"&-*'*&"+1,&/-%)8"',("(&@&2+86&,*"',("*%/+5>%"*%&"45-),&--&-"),"4+*%"*%&-&"'/&'<"$%&"-&7+,("8'/*":&'*5/&-"*%&"8%3-)7'2"6)>/',*"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*%/+5>%"*+5/)-6"',("/&*)/&6&,*?"',("%+1"*%)-"6)>/',*"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"-%'8&-"*%&"45)2*"&,@)/+,6&,*"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'<"

K%'8*&/"!"&H82'),-"%+1"*%&"@&)2"-%/+5(&("+@&/"J'23"K)*3?"7+@&/),>"'"2)**2&"+@&/"'"*%)/("+:")*-"/&-)(&,*-?":5,7*)+,-"*+"7+,7&'2"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"2',(-7'8&"7+,,&7*),>"A)2)8),+-"1)*%"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"C"'/>5&"),-*&'("*%'*"*%&"8'/*)752'/"-&**2&6&,*"+:"8+-*9!ceM")66)>/',*-"),"J'23"K)*3")-"2&--"7+,7&/,&("1)*%"7/&'*),>"'"8&/6',&,*")(&,*)*3"',("Q%+6&R"),"*%&)/"8+-*91'/"-545/4',",&)>%4+/%++("*%',"6'),*'),),>"'"72&'/"7+,,&7*)+,"*+"4+*%"*%&)/")66&()'*&":'6)2)&-"),"*%&"=<B<"',("6+/&")68+/*',*23"*%+-&":'6)23"6&64&/-"*%'*"/&6'),"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"_'*%&/"*%',"8&/7&)@),>"J'23"K)*3"'-"'"A)2)8),+"&,72'@&"',("*%/)@),>"7+665,)*3"+:"'"72+-&239;,)*",&*1+/;"+:"A)2)8),+-?"C"'/>5&"*%'*"J'23"K)*3")-"'"()'-8+/)7"-8'7&"7/&'*&("43"'"

Page 32: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

#M"

8'/*)752'/">/+58"+:"6)>/',*-"1%+"'21'3-"-'1"*%&6-&2@&-"'-"4&),>"'42&"*+"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<!c"

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d,>0-"7+,7&8*)+,"+:"Q,&+2)4&/'2)-6"'-"&H7&8*)+,R?"C"(&-7/)4&"%+1"*%&-&"QY+,&-R"+8&/'*&"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!c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i+;"B)50-"A:*/#!P*/:7&%/:?!Q->!9&%5/$*&#:C!Q->!D&#)-7$*&#:"WB*',:+/(f"B*',:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"#LLaX<""

Page 33: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

#e"

+5*-)(&"+:"*%&",+/6-"+:"2+7'2">+@&/,',7&"*%/+5>%"*%&"2&>'2"8/)@)2&>&-"*%&3"'/&"'::+/(&("),"+/(&/"*+"8/+@)(&"*+"*%&)/">5&-*-"1)*%"',"'45,(',7&"+:"5,)U5&"25H5/)&-<"" A),'223?"*%&"7%'8*&/"+,"4'2);4'3',"5/4',)-6"&H'6),&-"*%&"'64)@'2&,7&"*%'*"A)2)8),+-":&&2"'4+5*"/&*5/,),>"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("1%&*%&/"+/",+*"*%&-&"/&*5/,&&-"(&-)/&"*+"/&6'),"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("*%&")682)7'*)+,"',(":5*5/&"7+,-)(&/'*)+,-"+:"*%&-&"*/&,(-<"$%&"6'I+/"U5&-*)+,"*%'*"*%)-"7+,725(),>"7%'8*&/"1+52("2);&"*+"',-1&/")-f"*+"1%'*"&H*&,*"'/&"7+,*&68+/'/3"*/',-:+/6'*)+,-"1)*%),"*%&"4/+'(&/"2',(-7'8&"',("&7+,+63"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"(/'1),>"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"4'7;"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("8/+@)(),>"',"),7&,*)@&"*+"*%&-&"N'2);4'3',-"*+"'7*5'223"-*'3"',("2)@&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""

Page 34: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

#a"

"

!!!!!!!!

D,/7$-%!G!!

+,-!M-*0-'!D*$3!!!

P/03!D*$3!/#'!$,-!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!9*0*7*#&!N/#':)/7-!

Page 35: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

#`"

90/:%-&!;!"

"QK',"1&")6'>),&"*%&"=<B<"'-"',"&H*&,-)+,"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-[R""

9 K'*%&/),&"K&,)Y'"K%+3"W#LLM?"cbX""QF+1"(+&-"*%&":+>"+:"*%)-"E6&/)7',"-545/4"'88'/&,*23"7+,7&'2"m"',("1%3"*%)-"7+,7&'26&,*"+:"*%&"2)@&-"+:"8&+82&"1%+"7+68/)-&"'"*%)/("+:")*-"/&-)(&,*-[R"""" " " " " " """""""9""""""""N&,)*+"G&/>'/'"W#LLc?"bMX""

"" D+),*),>"*+"'"*),3"/&-*'5/',*?",&-*2&("),7+,-8)75+5-23"4&-)(&"'"2+7'2":2+/)-*?"E/6',(+"-2+1-"%)-"7'/"(+1,"',("'-;-?"QJ+"3+5"-&&"*%'*"82'7&"*%&/&["d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w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

E-"+,&"6),+/"%54"1)*%),"'"2'/>&/"*/',-,'*)+,'2",&*1+/;"+:"/&-*'5/',*-"-8',,),>"4&*1&&,"*%&"J'23"K)*3"',("B+5*%&/,"i5Y+,?"+,&"7',":),'223")6'>),&"%+1"A)2)8),+"K5)-),&"',("*%&"-*/&'6"+:"A)2)8),+"@)-)*+/-"7+6),>"*+"&'*"*%&/&?"/&8/&-&,*"%+1?"'-"K'*%&/),&"K&,)Y'"K%+3"-5>>&-*-?"*%&"=<B<")-"',"&H*&,-)+,"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"i);&1)-&?"+,&"6)>%*"4&>),"*+"-&&"%+1"'22"+:"J'23"K)*3"',("*%&">&,&/'*)+,"+:"8+-*9!ceM"A)2)8),+")66)>/',*-"2)@),>"*%&/&"-&&"*%&6-&2@&-"'-"/&-)(),>"),"',+*%&/"8'/*"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("%+1"*%&)/"&@&/3('3"2)@&-"4&-8&';"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"*)&-"2),;),>"*%&6"*+"*%&)/"%+6&2',("7'5-),>"*%&6"*+"2++;"4'7;<"""+,-!M-*0!XJ-%!P/03!D*$3!

"

Page 36: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

#c"

i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

$%&"-3,7+8'*&("/&8&*)*)+,"+:")*-"'/7%)*&7*5/&?"),"8'/*)752'/?")-"7%'/'7*&/)-*)7"+:"1%'*"%'-"7+6&"*+"4&";,+1,"'-"*%&"8/+*+*38)7'223"(/'4"8+-*91'/"-545/4',"-8/'12<"J&6'/7'*&("),*+",),&"()-*),7*",&)>%4+/%++(-?"*%&")66&()'*&"4+/(&/-"+:"J'23"K)*3"'/&"&(>&("43"B+5*%"B',"A/',7)-7+"*+")*-",+/*%"',("K+26'?"+/"*%&"Q7)*3"+:"*%&"-)2&,*R?"I5-*"4&2+1")*<#!"$%&"/'*%&/"65,(',&"5/4',"2):&"+:"J'23"K)*3"2)&-"),"6'/;&("7+,*/'-*"*+"*%&"45-*2),>"',("7+,>&-*&("&,@)/+,6&,*"+:"x5&Y+,"K)*3"),"S',)2'?")*-"Q-)-*&/"7)*3R<"P%)2&"x5&Y+,"K)*3?"*%&":+/6&/97'8)*'2"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"W!cb`9!caeX?"1'-"+/)>),'223"82',,&("*+"4&7+6&"'";),("+:"-545/4',"&-7'8&":/+6"*%&"5/4',"%'88&,),>-"1)*%),"S',)2'"K)*3"(5/),>"*%&"!cbL-"2);&"J'23"K)*3?")*"%'("-),7&"@&&/&("),"',+*%&/"()/&7*)+,?"4&),>"7+682&*&23"&,@&2+8&("),"*%&"7+2+--'2"5/4',"6)2)&5"+:"*%&"V'*)+,'2"K'8)*'2"_&>)+,"WK'+)2)"!c``X<""

x5&Y+,"K)*3"%'-"'2-+"4&7+6&"*%&"2&>)-2'*)@&"%54"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"%+5-),>"*%&"N'*'-',>"D'64',-'"+/"*%&"D%)2)88),&"F+5-&"+:"_&8/&-&,*'*)@&-?"',("4&7'6&"*%&"2+7'*)+,":+/"'"2)*',3"+:"-7%++2-?",'6&23"*%&"*1+"6+-*"()-*),>5)-%&("5,)@&/-)*)&-"),"*%&"7+5,*/3f"*%&"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-9J)2)6',"',("E*&,&+"(&"S',)2'"=,)@&/-)*3<"J'23"K)*3?"+,"*%&"+*%&/"%',(?"1%)2&"),7+/8+/'*&("),"!c!!?"*1&,*39&)>%*"3&'/-"4&:+/&"x5&Y+,"K)*3"4&7'6&"'":+/6'2"65,)7)8'2)*3"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'?"1'-",&@&/"6&',*"*+",+/"1)22"&@&/"4&"*%&":+7'2"8+),*"+:"K'2):+/,)'"8+2)*)7-"',("657%"2&--"*%&"/&-*"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#L"k'6&-"F+1'/("l5,-*2&/"(&-7/)4&-"*%&"%)-*+/)7'2"8/+7&--"+:"5/4',"-8/'12"1%)7%"%&"4&2)&@&-"(&-*/+3&("Q-57%"'>&"+2("-+7)'2"'//',>&6&,*-"'-"*%&"()-*),7*)+,"4&*1&&,"7)*3"2):&"',("7+5,*/3"2):&R"',("()--+2@&("*%&"2',(-7'8&"'/+5,("7+665,)*)&-"2);&"J'23"K)*3"),*+"'"Q>&+>/'8%3"+:",+1%&/&Rg"'"-8'7&"*%'*"%'("Q7&'-&("*+"4&"'"7/&()42&"%56',"%'4)*'*R<"E2*%+5>%"%)-"8+2&6)7'2"*';&"+,"*%&"%)-*+/)7'2"8'**&/,"+:"-545/4',"(&@&2+86&,*"),"*%&"=<B<"*&,(-"*+"+@&/-%'(+1"*%&"5,)U5&"',("@)4/',*"7+,*/)45*)+,-"*%'*"@'/)+5-"7+665,)*)&-"%'@&"6'(&"1)*%),"*%&"-545/4',"2',(-7'8&?"+,&"7',,+*"&'-)23"()-6)--"*%&"7%'/'7*&/)-*)7")6'>&-"%&"8'),*-f"*%&"7'/97&,*/)7"5,)@&/-&"+:"*/'7*"%+6&-?"&H*&,(&("8'/;),>"2+*-?"-*/)8"6'22-"',("-58&/%)>%1'3-?"'22"+:"1%)7%"%&"5-&-"*+"(&-7/)4&"',"&@&/"-%/),;),>"-+7)'2"-8%&/&"*%'*")-"4&7+6),>"6+/&"',("6+/&"),()@)(5'2)Y&(?"%+6+>&,)Y&(?"',("(+1,/)>%*"(522<"B&&"l5,-*2&/?"k<"F<?"+,-!@-&8%/7,3!&F!Q&>,-%-?!+,-!<*:-!/#'!P-)0*#-!&F!A5-%*)/S:!6/#=6/'-!N/#':)/7-"WV&1"O+/;f"B)6+,"w"B7%5-*&/?"!ccZX<"#!"K+26'0-"()-*),7*)+,"'-"%'@),>"6+/&"(&'("/&-)(&,*-"*%',"2)@),>"+,&-")-"(5&"*+"*%&"(&()7'*)+,"+:")*-"2',("*+"7&6&*&/)&-<"

Page 37: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ZL"

+:"*%&"=<B<"J'23"K)*3"&6&/>&("'-"'"/&:5>&"',("'2*&/,'*)@&"*+"B',"A/',7)-7+"',("/&6'),-"*%'*"1'3"),"6',3"1'3-<"d/)>),'223?"*%&"7)*3"1'-"45)2*"'-"*&68+/'/3"%+5-),>":+/"5/4',"/&:5>&&-"1%+"1&/&"-&&;),>"82'7&-"*+"2)@&"':*&/"*%&"()-'-*/+5-"!cLe"B',"A/',7)-7+"&'/*%U5';&"',("*%&"-54-&U5&,*":)/&"*%'*"&,>52:&("657%"+:"*%&"7)*3<"i'7;),>"',3";),("+:"8+2)*)7'2"-)>,):)7',7&"+/"6',5:'7*5/),>"8/+1&--?"J'23"K)*30-"&7+,+63"%'("'21'3-"4&&,"8&/)8%&/'2"7+68'/&("*+"*%&"&7+,+63"+:")*",&)>%4+/"*+"*%&",+/*%"',("1'-"/&2&>'*&("*+"8/+(57),>"8/)6'/)23"(')/3?"7'44'>&?"',("8)>":'/6),><"

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x5&Y+,"K)*3?"1%)7%"()7*'*&"),"6',3"1'3-"*%&":5*5/&"+:"*%&"2'/>&/"7+5,*/3?"J'23"K)*3"82'3-"'"/&2'*)@&23"),-)>,):)7',*"/+2&"1)*%),"*%&"=<B<"',("+,23"'"-588+/*),>"/+2&"'-"'"Q4&(/++6"7+665,)*3R"*+"B',"A/',7)-7+<"E-"'"7+,-&U5&,7&?"1)*%":&1"),(5-*/)&-"+8&/'*),>"1)*%),"J'23"K)*3?"*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:")*-"/&-)(&,*-"*&,("*+"1+/;"+5*-)(&"+:"*%&"7)*3<""

$%)-"-8'*)'2"()@)-)+,"+:"2'4+/"1)*%),"B',"S'*&+"K+5,*30-"&7+,+63")-"@)@)(23"/&:2&7*&("),"*%&">&+>/'8%3"+:"*%&"7)*3<"d,":++*?"1'2;),>"*%&"J'23"K)*3"4&7+6&-"'"('5,*),>"*'-;"1)*%"'22"+:")*-"1),(),>"/+'(-"',("'4/58*"),72),&-<"D&/%'8-"),"*%)-"-),>52'/"1'3?"*%&"-%&&/"),'4)2)*3"*+"1'2;"*%&"7)*3?"(+&-"J'23"K)*3"6)//+/"x5&Y+,"K)*3<".H7&8*"1%&/&"@)-)*+/-"'/&":+/7&("*+"7+68&*&"1)*%"7+,>&-*)+,"7/&'*&("43"5,82',,&(",&)>%4+/%++(-?"'/6)&-"+:"45-&-"',("I&&8,&3-?"',("(')23"7+665*&/-"*/'@&2),>"43"*'H)"+/"*/)7372&-"),"x5&Y+,"K)*3?"+,&")-"4&-&*"1)*%"*%&"7%'22&,>&"+:",'@)>'*),>"*%/+5>%"*%&"&H8',-)@&"+8&,9-8'7&-"+:"J'23"K)*3<"$%)-"+8&,,&--"1'-"7/&'*&("43"85/8+-&:5223"82',,&("*/'7*9,&)>%4+/%++(-?"1%)7%"'/&"-&*":'/"'8'/*":/+6"45-),&--"()-*/)7*-"',("6'I+/"*%+/+5>%:'/&-<"$%&"()-7+,,&7*&(,&--"+:"*%&"7)*30-"-545/4',"(&-)>,"',("'88'/&,*"),@)-)4)2)*3"+:")*-"/&-)(&,*-"'2+,>"J'23"K)*30-"/&-)(&,*)'2"-)(&1'2;-"2&'(-"G&/>'/'"W#LLcX"*+"&H72')6"*%'*?"Qd,&"%'/(23"-&&-"',3+,&"1'2;),>"+,"*%&"-)(&1'2;-"4&7'5-&?"+,&"/&'2)Y&-?"*%&/&")-",+"82'7&"*+"1'2;"*+R"WZ!X<"N3"7'/?"+,&"6)>%*"-&,-&"*%'*"*%&"*+8)7'2"*&//'),"+:"*%&"7)*3")-"'*"+((-"1)*%"*%&"()-*),7*23"-545/4',">/)("*%/+5>%"1%)7%"*%&"7)*3"1'-"(&-)>,&(<"B54-&U5&,*23?"*%&"-+6&*)6&-")22+>)7"6'88),>"+:"J'23"K)*3":+/7&-"(/)@&/-"*+"8'3"72+-&"'**&,*)+,":+/"),7+,-8)75+5-"6'/;&/-"*%'*"6)>%*"/&@&'2"*%&)/"2+7'*)+,<""

$%&"()-*),7*":'6)2)'/)*3"4/+5>%*"+,"43"*%&"-545/4',"2',(-7'8&"'22+1-"4+*%"@)-)*+/-"',("/&-)(&,*-"1)*%),"*%)-">&+>/'8%3"+:",+1%&/&"7+6&"*+":&&2"2);&"*%&3"7+52("4&"',31%&/&"),"*%&"=<B<"D'/*)752'/23"1)*%),"*%&"/&2'*)@&23",&1&/",&)>%4+/%++(-"+:"J'23"K)*3?"*%&"8&/:&7*23">/'(&("-*/&&*-?"/&>52'*&(":/+,*"3'/(-?"',("6'*7%),>"7+2+/"-7%&6&-?"&@+;&-"-545/4',"(&-)>,"*%'*"*38):)&-"*%&"72'--")(&'2-"+:"8+-*1'/"-545/4',)-6<##"$%&"%+6+>&,&)*3"&H5(&(":/+6"J'23"K)*3":5,7*)+,-"'-"3&*"',+*%&/"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""##"$%)-")(&'2"2',(-7'8&")-"4'-&("+,"8&/*5'*&("'"-545/4',"6+(&2"7+,-*/57*&("),"*%&"=<B<"4&>),,),>"),"*%&"2'*&",),&*&&,*%"',("8&/:&7*&("(5/),>"*%&"7+5/-&"+:"*%&"*1&,*)&*%"7&,*5/3<"$%+-&"2',(-7'8&-"7+,9"

Page 38: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Z!"

2'3&/"7'-*&("58+,")*-"/&-)(&,*-?"7+,:),),>"),()@)(5'2)*3"',("72'--"()-*),7*)+,"),*+"'"Q2++;9'2);&?"*%),;9'2);&"),-*',*"-545/4R"WK%',(2&/"!caZ?"!La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l&)2"#LLeX<""

F+1"*%&,"(+&-"+,&"7+,*&,("1)*%"5,7+@&/),>"*%&"8'2)68-&-*"+:"2'3&/-"*%'*"@&)2?"'-"N&,)*+"G&/>'/'"-5>>&-*-?"Q*%&"2)@&-"+:"8&+82&"1%+"7+68/)-&"'"*%)/("+:")*-"/&-)(&,*-[R"E,("6+/&")68+/*',*23?"1%'*":5,7*)+,?"):"',3?"(+&-"*%)-"@&)2?"*%&"Q:+>R"J'23"K)*3?"82'3":+/"*%&"A)2)8),+-?"'"72&'/23"%&*&/+>&,&+5-"',("5,)U5&">/+58"+:")66)>/',*-"*+"*%&"=<B<?"1%+"),%'4)*")*-"8'/*)752'/23"%+6+>&,)Y&("',("),()-*),7*23"7+,-*/57*&("-8'7&-["P%)2&"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"-7%+2'/-"2);&"N&,)*+"G&/>'/'"',("k'6&-"B+4/&(+?"'-"1&22"'-"@'/)+5-"6&()'"I+5/,'2-?"'/&"U5)7;"*+"8+),*9+5*"*%&"7)*30-"2'4&2"'-"*%&"QV&1"A)2)8),+*+1,R?"Qi)**2&"S',)2'R?"+/"&@&,"*%&"QK'8)*'2R"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"),"*%&"=<B<?#b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

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""*'),&("'"@&/3"-8&7):)7"-+7)'2"+/>',)Y'*)+,"',("8+852'*)+,"+:"1%)*&"1+/;),>972'--"E6&/)7',-"1%+"1+52("2'*&/")(&,*):3"*%&6-&2@&-"'-"6)((2&972'--"4'-&("+,"*%&"&H725-)+,"+:",+,91%)*&"7+665,)*)&-"',("+*%&/"7+665,)*)&-"*%'*"()(",+*"7+,:+/6"*+"%&*&/+9,+/6'*)@&"-*',('/(-"-57%"'-"*%&"-+97'22&(",572&'/":'6)23<"B&&"k'7;-+,?"l<"$<?"D%/28%/::!9%&#$*-%?!+,-!E(2(%2/#*T/$*&#!&F!$,-!U#*$-'!E$/$-:"WV&1"O+/;f"dH:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"!c`MX<"#Z"$)7;39*'7;3?"'"8%/'-&"(&,+*),>"-2&'Y3"+/"-%+((3"6'*&/)'2"5-&("&-8&7)'223"),"*%&"7+,-*/57*)+,"+:"2++;9'2);&"*/'7*"%+5-&-?"'7*5'223"(&/)@&(":/+6"*%&"23/)7-"+:"*%&":+2;"-+,>"Qi)**2&"N+H&-R"1/)**&,"43"S'2@),'"_&3,+2(-"),"!ce#"':*&/"(/)@),>"8'-*"J'23"K)*3"',("-&&),>"*%&"-&/)&-"+:"*/'7*"%+6&-"7+@&/),>"*%&"%)22-":/+6"*%&":/&&1'3<"#b".*%,)7",&1-8'8&/-"',("6'>'Y),&-?"8'/*)752'/23"A:*/#!B--1"',("9*0*7*#/:?"%'@&"4&&,"U5)7;"*+")(&,*):3"J'23"K)*3"'-"*%&"R%+6&R":+/"A)2)8),+")66)>/',*-"',("*%&)/":'6)2)&-"2)@),>"+5*-)(&"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"E,("1%)2&",+,&"+:"*%&"A)2)8),+"),*&/@)&1&&-"*%'*"C"%'("),*&/@)&1&("),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'("%&'/("'4+5*"J'23"K)*3?"-+6&"I+5/,'2)-*-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'@&"-),>2&(9+5*"*%&"7)*3"'-"'"8+*&,*)'2"2+7'2&":+/"+@&/-&'-"),@&-*6&,*<"B&&"WS'7'4&,*'"#LLLX<"#M"P&)"i)?"1%+"%'-"1/)**&,"-&@&/'2"'/*)72&-"+,"*%&"K)*3?"+8&/'*)+,'2)Y&("'"*%&+/3":+/"&*%,)7"-545/4',"&,72'@&-?"'/>5),>"*%'*"*%&"&*%,+45/4":/'6&1+/;"Q)2256),'*&-"*%&"7+682&H"7+'2&-7&,7&"+:">2+4'2"',("2+7'2?"&7+,+6)7"',("8+2)*)7'2?"),()@)(5'2"',("),-*)*5*)+,'2?"5/4',"',("-545/4',":+/7&-"*%'*"2&("*+"*%&"),*/)7'7)&-"+:",&>+*)'*),>"2):&"',(":5*5/&"8/+-8&7*-":+/"*%)-"652*)&*%,)7"-545/4',"82'7&R"W!cc`?"Z9bX<"B&&"Wi)"!cc`X<"

Page 39: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Z#"

1)*%),",&1&/":+/6-"+:"7+,*&68+/'/3"-545/4',"&*%,)7"&,72'@&-"2);&"S+,*&//&3"D'/;?"K'2):+/,)'<#e""

_&>'/(2&--"+:"*%'*"-)>,):)7',*",564&/"+:"A)2)8),+-"),"J'23"K)*3?",+/"),"',3"+:"*%&"A)2)8),+"-545/4-"*%'*"2)&"'/+5,("*%&"2'/>&/"N'3"E/&'?"*%&"%)-*+/3"',("7+665,)*3":+/6'*)+,"+:"6+-*"A)2)8),+-"7+,*),5&-"*+"4&"-%/+5(&("4&,&'*%"*%&"@&)2?":'/"'1'3":/+6"*%&"7+,-7)+5-,&--"+:"6+-*"+:"*%&"E6&/)7',-"1%+"2)@&"'/+5,("*%&6<"h)@&,"*%&":'7*"*%'*"A)2)8),+-"+,23"4&>',"-&**2),>"),"2'/>&/",564&/-"(5/),>"*%&"!c`L-?")*"6';&-"-&,-&"*%'*"1)*%),"*%&"&,*)/&"%)-*+/3"+:"J'23"K)*3"1/)**&,"43"B'65&2"K%',(2&/"',("8542)-%&("),"!caZ"*%&/&"/&6'),-",+*"+,&"-),>52'/"*/'7&"+:"*%&"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*3"),"%)-"%)-*+/)+>/'8%3<"S+/&"7+,:+5,(),>")-"*%&"&/'-5/&"+:"*%&"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*3"),"*%&"/&7&,*23"8542)-%&("8)7*+/)'2"%)-*+/3"+:"J'23"K)*3"7+68)2&("43"*%&"+::)7)'2"%)-*+/)',"+:"*%&"7)*3"N5,,3"h)22&-8)&?"'2+,>-)(&"%&/"%5-4',("l&,"h)22&-8)&?"),"#LLZ"1%&,"A)2)8),+-"%'("'2/&'(3"7+68/)-&("+,&9*%)/("+:"*%&"8+852'*)+,<#a"A5/*%&/6+/&?"/&>'/(2&--"+:"*%&":'7*"*%'*"*%&"S'3+/"+:"J'23"K)*3"S)7%'&2"D<"h5),>+,'")-"&@&,"(&-7&,(&(":/+6"A)2)8),+"8'/&,*-"',("+:*&,"%+-*-"@'/)+5-"A)2)8),+"-%+1-"+,"$%&"A)2)8),+"K%',,&2"W$AKX?",&)*%&/"J'23"K)*30-"1&4-)*&",+/")*-"8'>&":+/"K)*3"F'22"7+,@&3-"',3"*/'7&"+:"*%&"&*%,)7"7+665,)*3"1%+"7+68/)-&-"*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:")*-"/&-)(&,*-<"P%&,"@)-)*),>"4+*%"*%&"B&//'6+,*&"S'),"i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d,&"7+52("),*&/8/&*"*%&"2'7;"+:"'**&,*)+,"8')("+,"*%&"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*3"),"J'23"K)*3"'-"3&*"',+*%&/"&H'682&"+:"*%)-"()-'@+1'2<"d,"*%&"+*%&/"%',(?"+,&"6)>%*"),*&/8/&*"*%)-"),@)-)4)2)*3"'-"'";),("+:"@&)2?"-7/&&,),>"',("-%)&2(),>")66)>/',*-?"2);&"A)2)8),+-?":/+6"*%&"-7/5*),3"7/&'*&("43"*%&"),*&/-&7*)+,'2)*3"+:"/'7)-6?"H&,+8%+4)'?"-&H)-6?"+/"%+6+8%+4)'<"N+,5-"W#LLLX"-5>>&-*-"o'-"/'7)'2)Y'*)+,"',("),@)-)4)2)*3"%'@&"1+/;&("*+"6'/>),'2)Y&"+/"&H82+)*"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-?"*%&3"%'@&"'2-+"8/+@)(&("*%&6"1)*%"'"8/+*&7*)@&"7+2+/'*)+,"*%'*"'22+1-"*%&6"*+"7+,*&-*"*%+-&":+/7&-o"WcX<"D&/%'8-?":/+6"4&,&'*%"*%)-"@&)2?"+,&"6)>%*"5,(&/-*',("),@)-)4)2)*3"6)>%*"'2-+"4&"5,(&/-*++("'-"&,'42),>"',(":'7)2)*'*),>"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/+5*&-"+:"A)2)8),+"6)>/'*)+,"4&*1&&,"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("*%&"=<B<"F+1"*%&,"6)>%*"',"&,*)/&"7)*3"2++;"1%&,"6',3"+:")*-"),%'4)*',*-"2)@&"4&,&'*%"*%)-"*/',-,'*)+,'2"@&)2["

k5-*"'-"'88'/&,*"'/&"*%&"2'7;"+:",+,9.,>2)-%"2),>5)-*)7"6'/;&/-"*%'*"*&,("*+"4&")68/),*&("+,"-*/&&*",'6&-"+/"45-),&--"-)>,-"',("6'/;"',"&,72'@&"'-"()-*),7*23"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#e"A+/"'"()-75--)+,"+,"*%&"8+2)*)7'2"&6&/>&,7&"+:"S+,*&//&3"D'/;"'-"*%&":)/-*"Q-545/4',"K%),'*+1,?R"-&&"WA+,>"!ccbX<"#a"B&&"N5,,3"h)22&-8)&0-"P/03!D*$3C!"5/8-:!&F!A5-%*)/"WK%'2/&-*+,f"E/7'()'?"#LLZX<"C,*&/&-*),>23?"-&@&,"3&'/-"8/)+/?"1%&,"*%&"h)22&-8)&-"1&/&"),*&/@)&1&("43"*%&"&*%,)7",&1-8'8&/"A:*/#!B--1?"4+*%"1&/&"U5)7;"*+"()-75--"*%&"&6&/>&,7&"+:"*%&"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*3"),"J'23"K)*3?"&H82'),),>"*%'*"4&>),,),>"),"*%&"!caL-?"QA)2)8),+-"1&/&"1&27+6&("*+"*%&",&)>%4+/%++(R<"_&:2&7*),>"+,"*%&)/",&)>%4+/-":/+6"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"N5,,3"h)22&-8)&"-5>>&-*&("*%'*"oA)2)8),+-"'/&"'"7+665,)*3"+:"-6)2&-o"',("*%'*"o*%&3"'/&"@&/3":'6)239+/)&,*&(?"/&2)>)+5-"8&+82&?"',(";&&8"*%&)/"%+6&-"4&'5*):52R<"B&&"N&/*".2I&/'0-"9*0*7*#&:!9*#'!O&5-!*#!P/03!D*$3?"A:*/#!B--1"W!cceX?"S'3"Z9c<"

Page 40: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ZZ"

5,)U5&":/+6"*%&",&)>%4+/%++(-"+/"7)*)&-"-5//+5,(),>")*<".@&,"*%&"B+5*%"+:"S'/;&*",&)>%4+/%++("+:"B',"A/',7)-7+"%'-"'"8'/*)752'/"42+7;"+:"-*/&&*-?"1%+-&"-*/&&*-"%'@&"4&&,"(&()7'*&("1)*%"*%&",'6&-"+:":'6+5-"A)2)8),+"%&/+&-"2);&"_)Y'2?"S'4),)?"i'859i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k+2)4&&"+/"h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

J'23"K)*3")-"()-*),7*23"#&$"5,)U5&?")*-"2',(-7'8&"',("45)2*9&,@)/+,6&,*"'/&"5,&H7&8*)+,'2"7+68'/&("*+"+*%&/"-545/4',",&)>%4+/%++(-<"A+/"&H'682&?"C"-*&88&("),-)(&"+:"'"N2+7;45-*&/"@)(&+"-*+/&"'(I'7&,*"*+*"%&"k+22)4&&"',("_&("_)44+,"4';&/3?"()-*),7*23"A)2)8),+"/&-*'5/',*-?"',("-8&7):)7'223"2++;&("*+"'"A)2)8),+"&682+3&&"1+/;),>"*%&/&":+/"'"-&7*)+,":+/"A)2)8),+"6+@)&-<"C"/&'-+,&("*%'*"1%)2&"C"6'3",+*":),("'"-*+/&"(&()7'*&("*+"-&22),>"A)2)8),+"6+@)&-"+,"S)--)+,"B*<?"+,&"+:"*%&"6'I+/"-*/)8-"7+,,&7*),>"J'23"K)*3"*+"*%&"bLM"A/&&1'3?"C"1'-"7+,@),7&("*%'*?"&@&,"):"*%&"-*+/&"2'7;&("',"&,*)/&"-&7*)+,"(&@+*&("*+"A)2)8),+"6+@)&-?"'*"*%&"@&/3"2&'-*"*%&/&"1+52("'"8++2"+:"A)2)8),+"*)*2&-"*+"-&2&7*":/+6"),"*%&":+/&)>,"-&7*)+,"+:"N2+7;45-*&/"@)(&+<"i)*&/'223"-7/'*7%),>"%)-"%&'("',("7+,@&3),>"'"2++;"*%'*"&H8/&--&("'"-&,-&"-&2:9()--'*)-:'7*)+,"),"%)-"+1,"',-1&/?"*%&"72&/;"-)6823"/&82)&(?"QV+R"',("'((&("QE,("C"1+52(,0*"&@&,";,+1"1%&/&"*+"*&22"3+5"*+":),("*%&6"W),"*%&",&)>%4+/%++(X<R""

d@&/"*%&"2'-*"(&7'(&?"*%&/&"%'-"4&&,"'"/&@&2'*)+,"+:"-*5()&-"+,"A)2)8),+-"8/+8&22&("43"'"%+-*"+:"&6&/>),>"2)*&/'*5/&"1/)**&,"*+"7+,*&-*"*%&"8&/7&)@&("o),@)-)4)2)*3o"+:"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"W$)+,>-+,"#LLeX<"$%)-"2)*&/'*5/&"%'-"(+,&"657%"*+"5,/'@&2"*%&"*',>2&("%)-*+/)&-"4&*1&&,"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("*%&"=<B<"$%&":+22+1),>"7%'8*&/"/&-*-"+,"*%&"-%+52(&/-"+:"*%)-"&6&/>&,*"2)*&/'*5/&"',("'**&68*-"*+"&H82'),"%+1"*%&"@&)2"-%/+5(&("+@&/"J'23"K)*3?"7+@&/),>"'"2)**2&"+@&/"'"*%)/("+:")*-"/&-)(&,*-?"7+,7&'2-"'"*/',-,'*)+,'2"2',(-7'8&"7+,,&7*),>"A)2)8),+-"1)*%"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""

B7%+2'/-"*&,("*+"-&&"&*%,)7"-8'7&-"'-"*%&"6'*&/)'2)Y'*)+,"+:"',"&*%,)7"7+665,)*30-"-*/5>>2&"*+"&)*%&/"/&*'),"*%&)/"752*5/&"+/"'--)6)2'*&"),*+"*%&"2'/>&/"

Page 41: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Zb"

:'4/)7"+:"*%&"-+7)&*3"'/+5,("*%&6<#`"d,"*%&"+*%&/"%',(?"'"%+-*"+:"*%),;&/-"',("-7%+2'/-"'**&68*),>"*+"&257)('*&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"8/'7*)7&-"'6+,>-*"@'/)+5-"7+665,)*)&-"7+,*),5'223"),-7/)4&?"1%'*"B6)*%"',("h5'/,)Y+"W!cc`X"7'22"'"Q2)4&/'*+/3"7%'/'7*&/R"+,*+"',"'//'3"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2"8/'7*)7&-<"$%&-&",'//'*)@&-"%'@&"8/+(57&("',"&,*)/&"()-7+5/-&"'/+5,("*%&"8/+(57*)+,"+:"'"Q*%)/("-8'7&R?"Q(&*&//)*+/)'2)Y&(",'*)+,9-*'*&-R?"',("Q7+5,*&/9,'//'*)@&-"+:"*%&",'*)+,R<#c"O&*?"*%&"(&>/&&"+:"7'8)*'2"7)/752'*)+,"',("*%&"/&),7+/8+/'*)+,"+:"7)*)Y&,-"',(",'*)+,'2-"2)@),>"'4/+'("&,'42&("43">+@&/,),>"*&7%,+2+>)&-"8/+(57&("43",'*)+,9-*'*&">+@&/,6&,*-"*%/+5>%+5*"i'*),"E6&/)7',"',("E-)'"8+),*"*+"'"6+/&"7+682&H":+/6"+:"*&//)*+/)'2)Y'*)+,"4&*1&&,"()'-8+/)7"7+665,)*)&-"',("*%&)/"%+6&2',(-<"d,&"*%'*")-":'/":/+6"*%&"()'2&7*)7'2"+88+-)*)+,"&H*+22&("43"1/)*&/-"1%+"@)&1"*/',-,'*)+,'2"-54I&7*-"'-"&)*%&/"+88+-)*)+,'2"*+":+/6-"+:">+@&/,',7&"+/"&,*)/&23"&H82+)*&("43"*%&6<"_'*%&/"*%',"),*&/8/&*),>"J'23"K)*30-"-8'/-&",&*1+/;"+:"/&-*'5/',*-?"/&6)**',7&"7&,*&/-"',("7%5/7%&-"'-"Q(&6'/7'*),>"*%&"-8'*)'2"4+5,('/)&-"',("2+7'2)Y'*)+,"+:"'"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"7+665,)*3R?"1%'*"'/&"+:*&,"7+,-*/57*&("'-"&*%,)7"&,72'@&-?">%&**+-?"',("&*%,)7",&)>%4+/%++(-<"C,-*&'(?"'-"d;'65/'"W!cc`X"&H82'),-?"Q*%&3"7+52("4&"6+/&"8/+(57*)@&23"5,(&/-*++("'-"),()7'*),>"*%&"@'/)+5-"1'3-"43"1%)7%"*%+-&"4+5,('/)&-"'/&"4&),>"*/',-7&,(&("+,"'"(')23"4'-)-"43"*/',-,'*)+,'2"2),;'>&-"+:"8&+82&?"6+,&3?">++(-"',("),:+/6'*)+,R"W`X<""

N3"@)/*5&"+:"*%&"5,)U5&"-&**2&6&,*"+:"6)((2&972'--"A)2)8),+-"),"J'23"K)*3?"C"'/>5&"),-*&'("*%'*"*%&"8'/*)752'/"-&**2&6&,*"+:"8+-*9!ce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

x5+*),>"'"-'682&"-5/@&3"7+,(57*&("+,"A)2)8),+-"1%+"1&/&")--5&("@)-'-"*+"*%&"=<B<"),"!c`e?".-8)/)*5"W#LLZX"&H82'),-"*%&"2+,>),>":+/"A)2)8),+-"*+"/&*5/,"%+6&"*%/+5>%"*%&"7+,*&H*"+:"*%&"/&8+/*0-":),(),>-?"1%&/&"'"Q-54-*',*)'2"8&/7&,*'>&"WZe<#"8&/7&,*X"&H8&7*&("*%'*"*%&3"&@&,*5'223"1+52("/&*5/,"8&/6',&,*23"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"&@&,"*%+5>%"'26+-*"*%/&&9:+5/*%-"Wab<Z"8&/7&,*X"-*'*&("*%'*"*%&3"'2-+"82',,&("*+"4&7+6&"=<B<"7)*)Y&,-R"WcbX<ZL"$/'@&2"4'7;"*+"*%&"%+6&2',(")-"),(&&("'"8/)@)2&>&"',("+,&"'77+/(&("*+"'"-&2&7*",564&/"+:")66)>/',*-<"F+1&@&/?"43"@)/*5&"+:"*%&"&7+,+6)7":+5,('*)+,"*%'*"&,'42&("'",564&/"+:"A)2)8),+-"*+"&6)>/'*&"*+"J'23"K)*3"':*&/"!ceM?"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#`"A+/"',"),-)>%*:52"','23-)-"+:"*%&"@'/)+5-"1'3-"-7%+2'/-"%'@&"),*&/8/&*&("',("5*)2)Y&("*%&"&*%,)7"&,72'@&"%38+*%&-)-"',("6+(&2?"-&&"_+>&/"P'2(),>&/0-"Q$%&".*%,)7".,72'@&"J&4'*&"_&@)-)*&(R?""#$-%#/$*&#/0!Y&(%#/0!&F!U%2/#!/#'!<-8*&#/0!<-:-/%),"!afZ"W!ccZX?"bbb9bM#<""#c"A+/"'"8'/*)752'/23"),:25&,*)'2"&H'682&"+:"*%)-"()-7+5/-&?"-&&"N%'4%'0-"P*::-5*Q/$*&#?"!ccL<"ZL"$%&"-5/@&3"*%'*".-8)/)*5")-"U5+*),>"(&/)@&-":/+6"N&,I'6),"K'/)T+0-"Q$%&"V&1"A)2)8),+"C66)>/',*-"*+"*%&"=,)*&("B*'*&-f"C,7/&'-),>"J)@&/-)*3"',("K%',>&R?";/7-%:!&F!$,-!4/:$=B-:$!;&7(0/$*&#!"#:$*$($-[!O&#&0(0(?!4/:$=B-:$!D-#$-%"W!ccLX<"

Page 42: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ZM"

6',3"+:"*%&-&"A)2)8),+-"7',"7+6&"4'7;"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"&)*%&/"*+"@)-)*?"*+"/&8'*/)'*&?"+/"&@&,"*+"'**&68*"*+"/&8'*/)'*&"',("/&*5/,":+/">++(<""

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

"P)*%),"*%&"@&)2&("5/4',)-6"+:"J'23"K)*3?"*%&")68+/*',7&"',("),:25&,7&"+:"

+42)>'*)+,"',("7+//&-8+,(),>"-3-*&6-"+:"/&7)8/+7)*3"'/&"6'(&"@)-)42&"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"),,&/91+/;),>-"+:"A)2)8),+-"1%+"2)@&"*%&/&f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i&@)**"#LL!X<"

K'/2'"k)6&,&Y?"'",5/-&"1%+"6)>/'*&("*+"J'23"K)*3"),"!c`#":/+6"'"-6'22"*+1,"),"*%&"8/+@),7&"+:"i'>5,'?"&H82'),-"*%&"5,/&2),U5)-%),>"8/&-&,7&"+:":'6)2)'2"+42)>'*)+,-"@)@)(23">/)88),>"%&/"*+"%&/"7+665,)*3"4'7;"%+6&<""

"P%&,"C":)/-*"'//)@&(?"C"1+52("-&,("'*"2&'-*"%'2:"+:"63"8'37%&7;"*+"63"8'/&,*-"W),"i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

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Z!"B&&":+/"),-*',7&"WC>,'7)+"#LLMX<"

Page 43: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Ze"

-'3),>"*%'*")*0-"4'(<"C*0-"I5-*"*%'*"-+6&*)6&-"63":'6)23"(+&-",+*"/&'2)Y&"*%'*"C06",+*"6'(&"+5*"+:"6+,&3<"

"K'/2'0-"'64)@'2&,7&"8+),*-"*+"*%&"7+682&H)*)&-"+:":'6)2)'2"+42)>'*)+,"',("*%&"-5-*'),),>"*)&-"8&/8&*5'*),>"*%&"5,&@&,"/&2'*)+,-%)8"4&*1&&,"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"',("*%+-&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"K'/2'0-"&H8&/)&,7&-"%&28"*+"6';&"-&,-&"+:"%+1"+@&/"(&7'(&-"+:"6)>/'*)+,":/+6"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"*%&"7)/752'*)+,"+:":),',7)'2"/&-+5/7&-"4&*1&&,"J'23"K)*3"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'-"*/',-:+/6&("*%&"45)2*9&,@)/+,6&,*"+:"J'23"K)*3"',("-+7)'2"2):&"+:"*%&"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"*%&/&<""

_&6)**',7&-"8/+@)(&"'"7/57)'2"6&',-"+:"5,(&/-*',(),>"*/',-,'*)+,'2"*)&-":+/"@'/)+5-"/&'-+,-<"$%&-&"8/'7*)7&-"%&28"&257)('*&"*%&"6',,&/"),"1%)7%"6)>/',*"',(")66)>/',*"7+665,)*)&-"7+,*),5&"*+"4&"*%/&'(&("*+>&*%&/"43"'"7+66+,"(&-)/&"*+"6'),*'),"*%&)/"7+,,&7*)+,-"1)*%"*%&)/"%+6&2',("Wh2)7;"B7%)22&/"#LL!g"N'-7%?"h2)7;"B7%)22&/?"',("BY',*+,"N2',7"!ccbX<"$%&-&":2+1-"'2-+"8/+@)(&"'":/'6&1+/;":+/"&H'6),),>"%+1"*%&",'*)+,9-*'*&"'**&68*-"*+"/&),7+/8+/'*&"7)*)Y&,-"',(",'*)+,'2-"2)@),>"'4/+'(":+/"*%&"85/8+-&"+:"(&@&2+8),>"*%&)/",'*)+,'2"&7+,+6)&-"Wi&--),>&/"!cc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cc`X<"

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je<M"4)22)+,"(+22'/-<"C,"#LLe?"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"-&,*"6+/&"*%',"j`"4)22)+,?"1%)7%"/&8/&-&,*-"May"+:"*%&"*+*'2"'6+5,*"/&7&)@&("43"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"

d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

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Z#"J5&"*+"*%&"-*/+,>"/&8/&-&,*'*)+,"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"),"%)>%92&@&2?"-&/@)7&9+/)&,*&("8/+:&--)+,-"-57%"'-"%&'2*%7'/&"1)*%),"J'23"K)*3?"'8'/*":/+6"E-)',"C,()',"E6&/)7',-?"*%&)/"6&()',"%+5-&%+2("),7+6&"*&,(-"*+"4&"%)>%&/"*%',"+*%&/"/'7)'2"',("&*%,)7"7+665,)*)&-"),"*%&"=<B<?"),725(),>"+*%&/"E-)',"

Page 44: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Za"

'(@',*'>&"+:"*%&",564&/"+:",&1"A)2)8),+")66)>/',*-"1%+"7+,-)-*&,*23":)2*&/"*%/+5>%"*%&",&)>%4+/%++(<ZZ""

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

"S3":/)&,(-0"%'(":'6)23"),"*%&"-'6&"*+1,"1%&/&"63":'6)23"2)@&(<"C"()(,0*"%'@&"'">++("I+4":+/"'"2+,>"*)6&<"C"7+52(,0*"-&,("@&/3"657%"6+,&3"4'7;"%+6&<"C*"1'-"-%'6&:52<"B+"63":/)&,(-"-')(?"uF&28"5-"1)*%"*%&"-*+/&<"O+5";,+1?"I5-*"-6'22"'77+5,*),>"*%),>-<"V+*%),>"/&'223"4)><"E,("1&022"I5-*"-&,("6+,&3":+/"3+5"4&7'5-&"3+50/&"1+/;),>"%&/&"*++<0"B+"'"8+/*)+,"+:"*%&"6+,&3"*%'*"*%&3">'@&"*+"*%&)/":'6)23"1'-">)@&,"*+"63":'6)23"*++<"

"d*%&/"*)6&-?"+1,&/-"+:"A)2)8),+"45-),&--&-"1)22"8/+@)(&"*%&"1+/;"+:"/&6)**',7&"7&,*&/-"',(":+/"',"),:+/6'2":&&?"Q(+":'@+/-R":+/"*%&)/"72)&,*-"43"*/',-'7*),>"6+,&3"*%&6-&2@&-<"$%&,"*%&/&"'/&"*%&":+/6'2"7+,*/'7*-"*%'*"45-),&--"+1,&/-"1)22"6';&"1)*%"4',;-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("8/+@)(&"/&6)**',7&"-&/@)7&-"'2+,>"1)*%"-&22),>"*%&)/">++(-<""

E2+,>"1)*%"*%&"/&6)**',7&"7&,*&/-?"7'/>+9-%)88),>"7+68',)&-"2);&"k+%,,3"E)/"K'/>+"),"B*<"A/',7)-"BU5'/&"+/"*%&"D%)2)88),&"+1,&("iNK".H8/&--?"'/&"-7'**&/&("*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"7)*3<"$%&-&"),*&/,'*)+,'2"-%)88),>"7+68',)&-"-8&7):)7'223"7'*&/"*+"A)2)8),+"72)&,*&2&"',("1%+-&"&,*&/8/)-&"-8&7)'2)Y&-"),">5'/',*&&),>"(')23"-%)86&,*-"+:"',"&H+/4)*',*"'6+5,*"+:">):*-"',("6'*&/)'2">++(-"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""S''-"W#LL`X"(&-7/)4&-"%+1"*%&-&"Q(++/9*+9(++/R"-&/@)7&-?"8/&@'2&,*"1)*%),"7)*)&-"&@&,"),"*%&"V&*%&/2',(-?"',("*%&"Q()::5-&(":+/6-"+:"-+2)('/)*3"',(">&,&/'2)Y&(":+/6-"+:"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""E6&/)7',"7+665,)*)&-<"E77+/(),>"*+"*%&"=<B<"K&,-5-?"#LLa"E6&/)7',"K+665,)*3"B5/@&3"/&8+/*-"+,"*%&"6&()',"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"%+5-&%+2("),7+6&")-"jeM?aLL"',("'26+-*"b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bc9ML<"ZZ"S&*/+4',;"'2-+"),*&,(-"*+"*';&"'(@',*'>&"+:"7/+--9-&22),>"+88+/*5,)*)&-"),"+*%&/"7+5,*/)&-":+/"*%&"4&,&:)*"+:"/&6)**&/-"',("*%&)/"4&,&:)7)'/)&-"%&/&<"S&*/+4',;t-"/&6)**',7&"-&/@)7&-"),725(&"'"/&'29*)6&"',("/)-;9:/&&"&2&7*/+,)7"*/',-:&/"/&6)**',7&"-&/@)7&g"'"-'@),>-"'77+5,*":+/"dAP-g"',("'"-*+/&("@'25&"'5*+6'*&("*&22&/"6'7%),&"7'/(":+/"dAP"4&,&:)7)'/)&-<"$%&"4',;"'2-+"8/+@)(&-"%+5-),>"',("45-),&--"2+',-"*+"dAP"4&,&:)7)'/)&-<"S&*/+4',;"%'-"',"),*&/,'*)+,'2",&*1+/;"+:"&)>%*":+/&)>,"4/',7%&-?"#e"/&6)**',7&"+::)7&-?"bL"/&6)**',7&"*)&958-?"',("6+/&"*%',"'"*%+5-',("7+//&-8+,(&,*"4',;-<"C*"%'-"8/&-&,7&"),"*%&"=B?"K','('?"*%&"S)((2&".'-*?"$')1',?"B%',>%')?"k'8',?"l+/&'?"F+,>"l+,>?"B),>'8+/&?"C*'23?"*%&"=<l<?"B8'),?"',("E5-*/)'<"B&&"W(&2'"D&,'"#LLaX"

Page 45: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Z`"

/&7)8/+7)*3R"*%'*"*%&3"&,7+5/'>&?"'/&"),*&>/'2"*+"*%&":+/6'*)+,"+:"*%&"A)2)8),+"*/',-,'*)+,'2"7+665,)*3R"W!ZeX<""" _&-8+,(&,*-"%'@&"7+,-)-*&,*23"6&,*)+,&("*%'*"*%&"2'/>&-*"8&/7&,*'>&"+:"/&6)**',7&-"*%'*"*%&3"-&,("'/&"'7*5'223",+*"8/+7&--&("*%/+5>%"/&6)**',7&"7&,*&/-?"45*"'/&"7+,@&,)&,*23"*/',-'7*&("+@&/"*%&"),*&/,&*"*%/+5>%"1&4-)*&-"%+-*&("43"P&-*&/,"=,)+,?"S+,&3h/'6?"q++6<7+6?"',("+*%&/-<"_'*%&/"*%',"6';),>"*%&)/"1'3"*+"/&6)**',7&"7&,*&/-?"8/+@)(&("*%&3"'/&"'42&"*+"+::&/"'"2)6)*&("'6+5,*"+:"8&/-+,'2"),:+/6'*)+,"',("'/&"1)22),>"*+"8'3"2'/>&/"*/',-'7*)+,":&&-?"),()@)(5'2-"7',"-)6823"5-&"*%&)/"7/&()*"+/"(&4)*"7'/(-"*+"-&,("6+,&3"*+"D%)2)88),&"4',;-"+/"(&-)>,'*&("/&6)**',7&"7&,*&/-"'26+-*"',31%&/&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"_+4&/*+"K'/(&,'-"(&-7/)4&-"%)-"/&-8+,-)4)2)*3"*+"%)-":'6)23"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"43"-'3),>?""

"C06"*%&"+2(&-*"),"*%&":'6)23<"$%'*"6&',-"*%'*"C06"*%&":)/-*"8&/-+,"*%'*"63"4/+*%&/-?"-)-*&/-?"',("63"8'/&,*-"7'22"):"*%&3",&&("6+,&3<"C"-&,("+,&"+:"*%&6"6+,&3"'*"2&'-*"&@&/3"+*%&/"6+,*%<"B+6&*)6&-"I5-*"jML?"-+6&*)6&-"6+/&<"V+*"'21'3-"'"2+*"+:"6+,&3"45*"'22"+:"*%'*"45)2(-958<""

"_+4&/*+"K'/(&,'-"',("%)-"1):&?"_+-&6'/)&?"6&*"),"*%&"=<B<"*%/+5>%":/)&,(-"',("':*&/"_+4&/*+":+5,("'"8&/6',&,*"8+-)*)+,"1+/;),>":+/"*%&"K)*3"+:"B',"A/',7)-7+"'-"'"7)@)2"&,>),&&/?"4+*%"%&"',("_+-&6'/)&"4+5>%*"'"%+6&"),"1%'*"1'-"*%&,"*%&",&1&/"8'/*"+:"J'23"K)*3"),"!c`e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i'-"G&>'-"5,*)2"%&"4&>',":'22),>"(&&8&/"',("(&&8&/"),*+"(&4*"'-"*%&"2'/>&/"&7+,+6)7"7/)-)-"),"#LLa"4&>',"*+"*';&"-%'8&?":+5,("/&6)**',7&-"',("*%&"),*&/*1),),>"+42)>'*)+,-"'/+5,("*%&6"&H*/&6&23"45/(&,-+6&<"A+/"D'()22'?":'6)2)'2"+42)>'*)+,-",+*"+,23"*';&"*%&":+/6"+:"/&6)**',7&-"45*"'2-+"),@+2@&"*%&")682)7'*)+,-"*%'*"7+6&"1)*%"-&,(),>"6+,&3"4'7;"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"""

C*"4&>),-"1)*%"-&,(),>"6+,&3"%+6&<"N5*"1%'*"3+5"'/&"*&22),>"3+5/":'6)23")-"*%'*"C"'6"*%&"7'/&*';&/"+:"*%&":'6)23<"C"'6"*%&"+,&"1%+")-"/&-8+,-)42&":+/"*%&)/"1&2:'/&<"S3"3+5,>&/"4/+*%&/"',("-)-*&/-"()(",+*"4+*%&/"*+"1+/;"),"*%&"

Page 46: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Zc"

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u$%)-")-"3+5/":'6)23<"O+50/&"*%&"+2(&-*<"O+50/&"*%&"+,&"1)*%"*%&"6&',-<0"B+"&@&,"*%+5>%"*%&3"(+,0*";,+1"%+1"4'("*%),>-"'/&"/)>%*",+1?")*"-*)22"6';&-"6&"%'883"*+"8/+@)(&":+/"*%&6<"

"$%&"-)>,):)7',7&"*%'*"+42)>'*)+,"&,*')2-"/&6'),-"@)*'2"1)*%),"*%&"2)@&-"+:"

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b""

$';),>"+,"*%&-&"72')6-?"I+5/,'2)-*-"%'@&"'2-+"+4-&/@&(?"&@&,"2'6&,*&("'*"*)6&-?"*%&">2'/),>"2'7;"+:"A)2)8),+"&,*/&8/&,&5/-%)8"'7*)@)*3"),"*%&"=<B<"7+68'/&("*+"*%&)/"E-)',"7+5,*&/8'/*-<"S&/75/)+"W#LLeX?"'"1/)*&/":+/";,*0*77*#-!Q->:?"/&'-+,-"*%'*"A)2)8),+-">&,&/'223"*&,("*+1'/(-"4&),>"&682+3&&-"/'*%&/"*%',"+1,),>"*%&)/"+1,"45-),&--&-<"S&/75/)+":5/*%&/"&H82'),-"*%)-"/&257*',7&":+/"&,*/&8/&,&5/-%)8"43"-5>>&-*),>?"8&/%'8-"-+6&1%'*"7'/&2&--23?"*%'*"A)2)8),+-"*&,("*+"/&:5-&"*+"8'/*';&"),"*%&"/)-;-"),@+2@&("1)*%"+1,),>"'"45-),&--"',("-54-&U5&,*23"-*&&/"72&'/"+:"*%&"Q%'--2&-"+:"'22"*%&"2)7&,-&-"*+">&*R"',("Q*%&"/&>52'*)+,-"*+":+22+1"Q<""

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Zb"C,"*1+"-&8'/'*&"'/*)72&-?"+,&"43"k'6&-"A'17&**"',("_+4&/*"h'/(,&/"',("*%&"+*%&/"43"D3+,>"h'8"S),?"%'@&"7)*&("'"-5/@&3"7+,(57*&("),"!c`a"+,"B5/@&3"+:"S),+/)*39d1,&("N5-),&--".,*&/8/)-&-"WN5/&'5"+:"*%&"K&,-5-?"!cc!X<"E77+/(),>"*+"*%&"-5/@&3?"A)2)8),+-"/',;&(":):*%"4&%),("*%&"2'/>&-*"E-)',"7+665,)*)&-"),"*%&"=<B<f"K%),&-&?"l+/&',-?"k'8',&-&?"',("E-)',"C,()',")66)>/',*"+1,&("45-),&--&-<"N+*%"-*5()&-"7+68'/&("A)2)8),+9+1,&("45-),&--&-"1)*%"*%+-&"+1,&("43"l+/&',-"',(":+5,("*%'*"A)2)8),+"45-),&--&-",+*"+,23":&22"-)>,):)7',*23"4&%),("),"'@&/'>&"/&7&)8*-"45*"'2-+"),"*%&">/+1*%"+:",&1"45-),&--&-<"P%)2&"*%&",564&/"+:"A)2)8),+"+1,&("45-),&--&-"%'@&">/+1,"43"b`"8&/7&,*"4&*1&&,"!cca"',("#LL#?"$%&"#LL#"B5/@&3"+:"N5-),&--"d1,&/-"WBNdX":),(-"*%'*"2&--"*%'*"!"8&/7&,*"+:",+,:'/6"45-),&--&-"),"*%&"=<B<"'/&"+1,&("43"A)2)8),+-<"B&&"WA'17&**"!ccbX"

Page 47: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

bL"

S),"W!c`e9`aX"+,"*%&"+*%&/"%',(?"/&:/'),-":/+6"'**/)45*),>"*%&"2'7;"+:"A)2)8),+"&,*/&8/&,&5/-%)8"*+"*%&"752*5/'2"*&,(&,7)&-"+:"*%&"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*3"',("),-*&'("(/'1-":/+6"*%&"%)-*+/)7'2"7+,*&H*"+:"A)2)8),+")66)>/'*)+,"),*+"*%&"=<B<"h'8"8/+@)(&-"',"'2*&/,'*)@&"),-)>%*"*+"S&/75/)+"43"'/>5),>"*%'*"4+*%"*%&"&(57'*)+,"',(":'7)2)*3":+/"-8&';),>".,>2)-%"'22+1-"A)2)8),+-"*+"85/-5&"I+4-"*%'*"'/&",+*"/&-*/)7*&("*+"45-),&--"+1,&/-%)8"',("&682+36&,*"1)*%"7+9&*%,)7"1+/;&/-"WMe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

C,"J'23"K)*3"'2+,&?"8'/*)7)8',*-"%'@&"1+/;&("'-"&,>),&&/-?"+::)7&"'(6),)-*/'*+/-?"8+-*'2"1+/;&/-?"',("&2&6&,*'/3"-7%++2"')(-<"P%)2&"6+-*"+:"*%+-&"),*&/@)&1&("1&/&":+/*5,'*&"*+"4&>),"1+/;),>"),"%)>%&/9-;)22&("8/+:&--)+,-?"6',3"+:"*%&)/"-8+5-&-"',("-)42),>-"4&>',"),"-&/@)7&"),(5-*/)&-"1+/;),>"'-"'5*+96&7%',)7-?"(+6&-*)7"1+/;&/-?"',("I',)*+/-?"&@&,*5'223"6';),>"*%&)/"1'3"*+"6+/&"-;)22&("8/+:&--)+,-<"d*%&/"),*&/@)&1&&-"&@&,"2&:*"*%&)/"7'/&&/-"*+"4&7+6&"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*-?"4/+;&/-?"',("-'2&-"/&8/&-&,*'*)@&-":+/"-8&7)'2*3")*&6-<"E26+-*"'22"+:"63"8'/*)7)8',*-"%'("'*"+,&"*)6&"+/"7+,*),5&"*+"/&7&)@&"6+/&"*%',"+,&"),7+6&"',("-+6&"%'@&"%&2("6+/&"*%',"*1+"I+4-"'*"+,&"*)6&<"O&*?"'8'/*":/+6"*%&"-8&7):)7"45-),&--"+1,&/-"1%+6"C"-8+;&"*+?",+,&"+:"63"),*&/@)&1&&-"%'@&"@&,*5/&("),*+"*%&"&,*/&8/&,&5/)'2"'/&,'"',("),@&-*&("6+,&3"),"4&7+6),>"*%&"-+2&"+1,&/"+:"'"45-),&--<""

_&>'/(2&--"+:"*%&"/&'-+,-?"4&7'5-&"+:"*%&"2'7;"+:"',"&*%,)7"&,*/&8/&,&5/)'2"7+/&"+:"A)2)8),+"45-),&--&-?"J'23"K)*3"*';&-"+,"'"@&/3"()::&/&,*"-%'8&":/+6"+*%&/"*38)7'2"&*%,)7",&)>%4+/%++(-?"&,72'@&-?"+/"&*%,+45/4-<"C,":'7*?"1%)2&"*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:"A)2)8),+9+1,&("45-),&--&-"),"*%&"=<B<"'/&"2+7'*&("),"K'2):+/,)'"Wba"8&/7&,*X?"&@&,"A)2)8),+"I+5/,'2)-*-"1/)*),>"'4+5*"J'23"K)*3":/+6"*%&"D%)2)88),&-":),(")*"75/)+5-"*%'*"*%&",564&/"+:"A)2)8),+9+1,&("45-),&--&-"),"*%&"7)*3"2'7;-"),"/&2'*)+,"*+"*%&"8/&@'2&,7&"+:"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"7)*3"WS'7'4&,*'"!cccX<"P)*%),"*%)-"7+,*&H*?")*"1'-"'22"*%&"6+/&"),*&/&-*),>"*%'*"1%&,"C"/&9@)-)*&("B&//'6+,*&"S'22"-%+/*23"':*&/"*%&"6'22"&H8&/)&,7&("'"8&/)+("+:"/&6+(&2),>"),"#LL`?"*%&"*/'()*)+,'2"&8)7&,*&/"+:"*%&"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*3"),"J'23"K)*3?",+*"+,23"()("'",564&/"+:"A)2)8),+"-*+/&-"()-'88&'/"45*"'2-+"*%&"725-*&/"+:"*'42&-"1%&/&"*%&"+2(&/">&,&/'*)+,"+:"A)2)8),+-"1+52("7+,>/&>'*&"%'(">+,&"'1'3<"""" P%)2&"7+68'/),>"/'*&-"+:"45-),&--"+1,&/-%)8"4&*1&&,"l+/&',"',("A)2)8),+")66)>/',*-?"A'17&**"',("h'/(,&/"W!ccbX"8/+@)(&"',"+4-&/@'*)+,":/+6"*%&)/":),(),>-"*%'*"'((-"*+"*%&"7+682&H)*3"+:"A)2)8),+"&,*/&8/&,&5/-%)8<"N+*%"'5*%+/-"-5>>&-*"*%'*"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""ZM"h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

Page 48: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

b!"

1%)2&"*%&"'775652'*)+,"+:":),',7)'2"7'8)*'2"'88&'/-"*+"4&"2&--")68+/*',*"*+"A)2)8),+")66)>/',*-"7+68'/&("*+"*%&)/"l+/&',"7+5,*&/8'/*-?"1%'*"/&6'),-"@)*'223")68+/*',*"*+"A)2)8),+-"'/&"*%&)/":'6)2)&-"4+*%",&'/"/#'":'/<"E)(&("43"*%&"&(57'*)+,'2"7'8)*'2"*%'*"6',3"8+-*"!ceM"A)2)8),+")66)>/',*-"4/),>"1)*%"*%&6"',("*%&",&*1+/;-"+:"A)2)8),+-"'2/&'(3"2)@),>"),"@'/)+5-"8'/*-"+:"*%&"=<B<?"A)2)8),+-":),("*%&6-&2@&-"),"'"@'/)&*3"+:"2'4+/":)&2(-"',("'/&",+*"7+,-*/'),&("*+"-&2:9&682+36&,*<"E,("7+,-)(&/),>"*%&">&+>/'8%)7'2?"8+2)*)7'2?"',("&7+,+6)7"7+,*&H*":/+6"1%)7%"*%&3"%'@&"2&:*?"'-"A'17&**"',("h'/(&/"'/>5&?"""

S',3"A)2)8),+")66)>/',*-":&&2"*%'*"*%&3"'/&"(+),>"@&/3"1&22"),(&&(?"),"7+68'/)-+,"1)*%"*%&)/"2):&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"1%&,"*%&3"%'@&"'"-*'42&"I+4"),"*%&"=,)*&("B*'*&-"1)*%">++(":/),>&"4&,&:)*-"',("',"),7+6&"2&@&2"*%'*">)@&-"*%&6"'"-*',('/("+:"2)@),>"*%'*"*%&3"/&>'/("'-"6)((2&"72'--"W!ccb?"#ZMX<""

P%'*"*%&,"1+52("'"7)*3"2++;"2);&"):"*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:")*-"8+852'*)+,")-"7+,*),5'223"2++;),>"4'7;g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h/+7&/3?":+/"&H'682&?")-"+,23"-&7+,('/3"*+"*%&"6'),"/&'-+,"(/'1),>"-&@&/'2">&,&/'*)+,-"+:"A)2)8),+-"*+"*%&"-*+/&"+@&/"*%&"2'-*"*1+"(&7'(&-f")*-"1/%-=1/%-?"+/"+H*')2"',("8&',5*"-*&1<"E/6',(+"1%+"%'-"4&&,"'7*),>"'-"4+*%"63"8/)6'/3"),:+/6',*"',("-&2:9(&-7/)4&("&*%,)7"*+5/">5)(&"'/+5,("J'23"K)*3"1'-"*%&":)/-*"*+"*';&"6&"*+"A)2)8),+"h/+7&/3"45*"'-"C"-8&,*"6+/&"*)6&"),"*%&"7)*3"1)*%"),*&/@)&1&&-?"C"1'-"7+,*),5+5-23"'-;&("):"C"1+52("2);&"*+">+"*%&/&":+/"'"6&'2<"=,2);&"*%&"6+/&"&-*'42)-%&("A)2)8),+"/&-*'5/',*-"1)*%),"',("'/+5,("J'23"K)*3?"1%&/&"8'*/+,-"6)>%*"-8&,("-&@&/'2"%+5/-"-+7)'2)Y),>"1)*%":/)&,(-"1%)2&"&'*),>?"75-*+6&/-"'*"A)2)8),+"h/+7&/3"6';&"4/)&:"@)-)*-"',("*%&"7+,@&/-'*)+,-"4&*1&&,"8'*/+,-"',("&682+3&&-"*&,("*+"2'-*"+,23"'-"2+,>"'-")*"*';&-"*+"453"*%&)/":++(")*&6-<"$%&-&"-&&6),>23"4/)&:"&,7+5,*&/-"6';&-")*"'22"*%&"6+/&"'-*+,)-%),>"*%'*"*%&/&")-"'"72&'/":&&2),>"*%'*"&@&/3+,&";,+1-"&'7%"+*%&/"),"*%&"-*+/&<"

E-"C"&H8&7*&(?"*%&"-*+/&"1'-"2+7'*&("-&@&/'2"42+7;-"'1'3":/+6"*%&",&'/&-*"6'),"-*/&&*?",&-*2&("(&&8"1)*%),"*%&"7+/,&/"+:"/&-)(&,*)'2",&)>%4+/%++(<"E7/+--":/+6"*%&"N/+'(6++/"J)-*/)7*?"+,"*%&"+*%&/"-)(&"+:"*%&"k5,)8&/+"B&//'"A/&&1'3"W+/"6+/&"7+22+U5)'223?"*%&"#`LX?"+,23"*%/&&"+/":+5/"75-*+6&/-"1+52("7+6&"),*+"*%&"-*+/&"'*"'"*)6&"(5/),>"*%&"1&&;('3-"45*"'77+/(),>"*+"*%+-&"1%+"1+/;&("*%&/&?")*"*&,(-"*+":)22958"),"*%&"&@&,),>"1%&,"75-*+6&/-">&*"+5*"+:"1+/;<"B)6)2'/"*+"N+,5-0"W#LLLX"(&-7/)8*)@&"()-75--)+,"+,"Qd/)&,*'2"-*+/&-R"'/+5,("B',"J)&>+?"*%&"&*%,)7"4+5,('/)&-"&H5(&("1)*%),"*%&"h/+7&/3"B*+/&"1&/&"72&'/23"6'/;&("*%/+5>%"-+5,(-?"-)>%*-?"',("

Page 49: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

b#"

-6&22-<"F)((&,":/+6"4&,&'*%"'"@&)2?"*%&-&"45-),&--&-"',("*%&">++(-"',("-&/@)7&-"*%'*"*%&3"-&22"*+"A)2)8),+-"),"J'23"K)*3":+/6?"'-"d;'65/'"W!cc`X"-5>>&-*-?"*%&"*/'7&-"+:"*%&"Q*%&"()'-8+/)7")(&,*)*3"',("7+,-7)+5-,&--"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"7+665,)*)&-"-),7&"*%&3"-)>,):3"752*5/'2?"&7+,+6)7?"',("-+7)'2"7+,,&7*)+,-"*%&"D%)2)88),&"%+6&2',(R"W`X<"

C*&6-"2);&"82'-*)7"$:*#-0/:!z),&H8&,-)@&"-2)88&/-"8+852'/23"1+/,"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-{?"A)2)8),+"6'>'Y),&-")68+/*&(":/+6"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"1&/&"),*&/-8&/-&("1)*%"+*%&/"8/+(57*-"6'/;),>"*%&"-8'7&"'-"()-*),7*23"A)2)8),+"-57%"'-"*%&"8)2&-"+:"-,'7;":++(-"',("7',(3"*%'*"+,&"7',"+,23":),("),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"P%)2&",+*"'"8'/*)752'/23"2'/>&"-*+/&?"*%&"-8'/-&"-&2&7*)+,"+:">++(-">'@&"+,&"*%&"-&,-&"*%'*"*%&3"1&/&"),"*%&"6)((2&"+:"1%'*"+,7&"1'-"'"1'/&%+5-&<"$+1'/(-"*%&":/+,*"+:"*%&"-*+/&?",&H*"*+"*%&"(+542&9(++/-?"1'-"'"-6'22"-&2&7*)+,"+:"A)2)8),+"6+@)&-?"*&2&@)-)+,"(/'6'-?"',("7+,7&/*"(@(-<"$%&"6'I+/)*3"+:":++("8/+(57*-"*%'*"1&/&"-+2("),"*%&"-*+/&"1&/&"8'7;'>&("+/"/&:/)>&/'*&("+,"+,&"-)(&"+:"*%&"-*+/&<"E8'/*":/+6"*%&"8'7;'>&-"+:"(/)&(":/5)*-"+,"*%&"-%&2@&-"',(":/+Y&,"@&>&*'42&-"),"*%&":/&&Y&/-?"*%&/&"1'-"'"@&/3"2)6)*&("-&2&7*)+,"+:"8/+(57&<""

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h/+7&/3?"'>'),"/&;),(2),>"N+,5-0"()-75--)+,?"*%&"-*+/&")-"'"6&&*),>"82'7&"*+"&,*&/*'),"A)2)8),+":/)&,(-"1%+"@)-)*":/+6",&'/43"7)*)&-"1)*%"Q'5*%&,*)7R"A)2)8),+":++("+/"*+"-)6823"7%'*"1)*%"*%&"-*+/&0-"&682+3&&-"1%+6"*%&3"%'@&"4&7+6&"72+-&/"*+"+@&/"*%&"3&'/-<"$%)-":'6)2)'/)*3"',("),*)6'73")-"6'(&"'88'/&,*"43"*%&"(&8*%"+:"*+8)7-"+,&"6)>%*"+@&/%&'/"(5/),>"*%&"4/)&:"7+,@&/-'*)+,-"4&*1&&,"&682+3&&-"',("8'*/+,-"*%'*"+:*&,"*+"/5,"657%"(&&8&/"*%',"8+2)*&"7%)*97%'*f"*%&"/&257*',7&"'"8'/&,*"%'-"+@&/"*%&",&1":/)&,(-"*%&)/"7%)2("6'(&?"*%&"I+3"%'("+@&/"'":'6)23"6&64&/":),(),>"1+/;?"+/"/+5*),&"*/+542&-"7'5-&("43"),92'1-"+/"&H*&,(&(":'6)23"6&64&/-<"P%)2&")*"/&6'),-")68+/*',*"*+"(&-)>,'*&"*%&":5,7*)+,"+:"-57%"&*%,)7"-8'7&-"'-"'":+/6"+:"82'7&96';),>"*%'*"',7%+/-?"'-"N+,5-"&H82'),-?"Q'";),("+:"-8'*)'2")(&,*)*3R"*%'*":5,7*)+,-"*+"'--&/*"+,&0-"-*',(),>"',("Q()-*),7*"(&6'/7'*)+,",+*"+,23"4&*1&&,"1%)*&-"',("A)2)8),+-"45*"'6+,>"A)2)8),+-R?Ze")*")-"&U5'223"-)>,):)7',*"*+"7+,*),5&"(/'1),>"+5*"*%&"6',,&/"),"1%)7%"*%&-&"-*+/&-":+/6"*/',-,'*)+,'2"2),;'>&-"*+":'6)23"6&64&/-?"7+665,)*)&-?"',("&@&,*-"4'7;"),"*%&"%+6&2',(<""

E-)(&":/+6"*%&"&,>/+--),>"()-75--)+,-"+,":'6)2)'2"8+2)*)7-"',("&,2)>%*&,),>"'(@)7&"*+"4&"%'(?"A)2)8),+-"'2-+"7+6&"*+"A)2)8),+"h/+7&/3"*+";&&8"),"7+,*'7*"1)*%"*%&)/"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Ze"N+,5-?"N&)/$*#8!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#:?"#LLLf"eL<"

Page 50: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

bZ"

:'6)23"6&64&/-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"J&,+*&("43"*%&"2'3&/-"+:"8%+,&"7'/("'(-"',("8+-*&/-"@&/):3),>"7'22),>"/'*&-?"75-*+6&/-"7+6&"*+"*%&"-*+/&"*+">&*"(&'2-"+,"7'22),>"7'/(-"',("6+/&"/&7&,*23"*+"453"*%&"7+685*&/"+8&/'*&("Q6'>)7"I'7;R"'('8*&/<".@&,"*%&"),*)6'73"),@+2@&("),"%'@),>"7+,@&/-'*)+,-"',("-&&;),>"'(@)7&"/&>'/(),>"+,&0-":'6)23"-)>,'2-"*%&")68+/*',7&":&2*"43"A)2)8),+-"*+"7+,*),5'223"6'),*'),"*%&)/"7+,,&7*)+,"*+"*%&)/"%+6&2',(<"E:*&/"-&@&/'2"@)-)*-"*+"A)2)8),+"h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

QWC,"*%&"=<B<X?"1&"+:*&,"7+6&"%&/&"1)*%+5*"+5/"8'/&,*-"+/"4/+*%&/-"+/"-)-*&/-<"C,"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1&"%'@&"'"2'/>&":'6)23"1%+"7',">)@&"-588+/*"1%&,"/')-),>"+5/";)(-?R"&H8/&--&("C/6'"h+,Y'2&Y?"1%+"6+@&("*+"J'23"K)*3"),"!cac"',("%'-"4&&,"'"8'*/+,"+:"A)2)8),+"h/+7&/3":+/"+@&/"'"(&7'(&<""

"C*0-"7+6:+/*),>"*+"-8&';"*+"*%&":/)&,(-"1&"%'@&"6'(&"%&/&<"$+";,+1"*%'*"*%&"8/+42&6-"3+5"%'@&"1%&,"3+5"'/&"/')-),>"3+5/";)(-"%&/&"'/&",+*"5,)U5&<"P&"'/&",+*"'2+,&?")*0-"()::)752*"*+"4&"'2+,&"),"*%&"=<B<?"*+"/')-&"7%)2(/&,"%&/&"1%&,"*%&)/":/)&,(-"%'@&"()::&/&,*"@'25&-"*%',"1&"%'@&<"""P%)2&"'"-6'22"8)2&"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',",&1-2&**&/-"',(",&1-8'8&/-"'/&"

-*'7;&("),"'"6&*'2"()-8&,-&/"),"*%&"7+/,&/"+:"*%&"-*+/&?")*")-"*%&"A)2)8),+"6'>'Y),&-"*%'*"'/&"82'7&(":/+,*"',("7&,*&/<"i);&"$AK?"*%&-&"6'>'Y),&-"'/&"1)2(23"8+852'/"1)*%"A)2)8),+"75-*+6&/-"1%+"'/&"&'>&/"*+",+*"+,23";,+1"*%&"2'*&-*">+--)8"+,"*%&)/":'@+/)*&"A)2)8),+"'7*+/"45*"*+"-*'3"'4/&'-*"+:"*%&"8+2)*)7'2"%'88&,),>-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"_&7&,*"*+8)7-"2);&"*%&"1'@&"+:"()-'-*/+5-"*38%++,-"*%'*"%'@&"%)*"S',)2'"',("V+/*%&/,"i5Y+,?"*%&"/&7&,*"8'--),>"+:"*%&":+/6&/"D%)2)88),&"8/&-)(&,*"K+/3"EU5),+?"',("*%&"7+6),>"8/&-)(&,*)'2"&2&7*)+,?"'/&"'"%',(:52"+:"&H'682&-"+:"*+8)7-"*%'*"%'@&"8/+(57&("%&'*&("(&4'*&-"',("2+,>),>",+-*'2>)'"4&*1&&,"&682+3&&-"',("75-*+6&/-<"$%&"7+,*&,*"+:"*%&-&",&1-8'8&/-"',("7+,@&/-'*)+,-"'/&"-+6&"+:"*%&"),)*)'2"-)>,-"8+),*),>"*+"*%&"+5*1'/(23"+/)&,*&("8+2)*)7-"+:"6',3"A)2)8),+-?"'2+,>"1)*%"*%+-&"2)@),>"),"J'23"K)*3<""

E/6',(+"'>/&&("1)*%"C/6'0-"-&,*)6&,*-"&H82'),),>"*%'*?"QA)2)8),+"h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

Page 51: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

bb"

A)2)8),+")66)>/',*-"*+"'"657%"2'/>&/"7+665,)*3?"*+"*%&)/";'8'6)23'"',(";'8'*)("),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"4&3+,(",+-*'2>)'"',("),*+"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"8/&-&,*<""""\@&0'!*#!P/03!D*$3]?!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!"#J-:$5-#$:!

"S'--0"W#LL`X"/&-&'/7%"+,"(++/9*+9(++/"7'/>+"'>&,*-")2256),'*&-"%+1"*%&"

752*5/'2"@'25&-"+:"8'*/+,'>&"',("),(&4*&(,&--"%'@&"8/+(57&("'"*/',-,'*)+,'2"&7+,+63"+:"-6'22"45-),&--&-"45)2*"+,"2),;),>":'6)23"6&64&/-"'7/+--"*%&"D%)2)88),&"()-'8+/'"*+"*%&)/":'6)2)&-"',("7+665,)*)&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"B%&"&H82'),-"*%'*"

"_&7)8/+7)*3"',(":'6)2)'2"+42)>'*)+,-"4&*1&&,"*%+-&"1%+"2&:*"',("*%+-&"1%+"-*'3&(":+/6"*%&"4&(/+7;":+/"),)*)'2"*/',-,'*)+,'2"'7*)@)*)&-?"1%)7%"8/)6'/)23"7&,*/&"+,"*%&9+,&91'39-&,(),>"+:"6+,&3"',(">):*-"*+"*%&"%+6&":/+,*<"B57%"8/)6+/()'2"4+,(-":+/6"'"257/'*)@&"4'-&":+/"45-),&--"*/',-'7*)+,-"W!bbX""

S+/&"/&7&,*23"%+1&@&/?"8'/*)752'/23"+@&/"*%&"2'-*"(&7'(&?"*%&"A)2)8),+"*/',-,'*)+,'2"&7+,+63"1)*%),"J'23"K)*3"),7/&'-),>23"8/+@)(&-"',"&H'682&"+:"%+1"*%&-&"&7+,+6)7"*)&-"'/&",+*")-+2'*&("*+"*%&"),@&-*6&,*-"',("*/',-'7*)+,-"7+,(57*&("43"-6'22"A)2)8),+9+1,&("45-),&--&-<"

d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

C,"*%)-"1'3?"J'23"K)*30-">&+>/'8%)7'2"2+7'*)+,",+*"+,23"6';&-"*%&"7)*3"'"2+>)7'2"82'7&":+/"A)2)8),+-"1%+"1+/;"),"B',"A/',7)-7+"*+"-&**2&"),"J'23"K)*3?"45*")*-",&'/,&--"*+"'",564&/"+:"*%/)@),>"',("()@&/-&"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*)&-"'/+5,("V+/*%&/,"K'2):+/,)'"6';&-"*%&"7)*3"'",'*5/'2"2+7'2&":+/"+@&/-&'-"A)2)8),+"45-),&--&-"',("7+/8+/'*)+,-"*+"*'/>&*"*%&)/"),@&-*6&,*-<"J5/),>"*%&"!ccL-?"J'23"K)*3"4&7'6&"*%&":)/-*"2+7'*)+,":+/"*%&":'6+5-"D%)2)88),&":'-*":++("7%'),"k+22)4&&"',("'2-+"+,&"+:"*%&"7+5,*/30-"6+-*"8/+6),&,*"/&6)**',7&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"'*"*%&"*)6&?"*%&"A'/".'-*"N',;"',("$/5-*"K+68',3<"E2*%+5>%"/&-*'5/',*-"+1,&("43"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"*&,("*+"7+6&"',(">+?"*%&/&"'/&"'",564&/"+:"/&-*'5/',*-"+1,&("43"D%)2)88),&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"*%'*"6'),*'),"'"-*&'(3"72)&,*&2&"',("/&6'),"8+852'/f""$)*+"_&3"_&-*'5/',*?"h+2()2+7;-?"*%&":)/-*"V+/*%&/,"K'2):+/,)',"2+7'*)+,-"+:"_&("_)44+,"N';&"B%+8"',("S'H"A/)&("K%)7;&,?"N'//)+"A)&-*'?"',("'"%+-*"+:"+*%&/"D%)2)88),&"7+/8+/'*)+,-<""

F+1&@&/?"*%&":'7*"*%'*"6+-*"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"V+/*%&/,"K'2):+/,)'"*&,("*+"8&/7&)@&"J'23"K)*3"'-"*%&"Q7'8)*'2R"+:"A)2)8),+-"'/+5,("*%&"P&-*"7+'-*?"1%)7%"%'-"2&("*+"J'23"K)*3"4&7+6),>"'":+7'2"8+),*":+/"+@&/-&'-"),@&-*6&,*?")-",+*"6&/&23"4&7'5-&"+:")*-"-364+2)7"/&8/&-&,*'*)+,"'-"-57%<"C*")-"'2-+"4&7'5-&"4+*%"A)2)8),+"',(",+,9A)2)8),+"

Page 52: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

bM"

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jM!?LLL"*+"j!LL?LLL"WS'7'4&,*'?"!cccX<"S'/;&*&/-"-&22),>"QD),+3">+2(R"),"J'23"K)*3"7+,*),5'223"5*)2)Y&"*%&"/&2'*)@&23"2+1"-*',('/("),7+6&"+:"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'-"'"6&',-"+:"25/),>"),@&-*+/-"*+"&-*'42)-%"'":++*%+2("1)*%),"*%&"2'/>&/"-+97'22&("Qj``"N)22)+,"A)2)8),+"6'/;&*R"),"*%&"=<B<Za""

K+,@&/-&23?"E6&/)7',"45-),&--"),@&-*+/-":/+6"*%&"J'23"K)*3pK+26'"K%'64&/"+:"K+66&/7&"/+5*),&23"@)-)*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("()-75--"65*5'2"45-),&--"82',-<"d,&"+:"*%&":)/-*"&H'682&-"1'-"1%&,"*%&":+/6&/"6'3+/"+:"J'23"K)*3"E(/)&,,&"k<"$)--)&/"2&("'"*/'(&"',(">++(1)22"6)--)+,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"(5/),>"*%&":)/-*"('3"+:"*%&"#M*%"D%)2)88),&"N5-),&--"K+,:&/&,7&"WDNKX"'*"*%&"P&-*),"D%)2)88),&"D2'Y'"),"S',)2'"),"!ccc<"$)--)&/")225-*/'*&("*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"*)&-"7/&'*&("4&*1&&,"J'23"K)*3"',("S',)2'"8&/:&7*23"),"%&/"-8&&7%?"&H82'),),>"*%'*?"oE-)(&":+/"*%&"752*5/'2"&H7%',>&?"1&"'/&"2++;),>":+/"),*&/,'*)+,'2"),@&-*6&,*-"',("45-),&--"+88+/*5,)*)&-"%&/&<"P&"'2-+"1',*"*+"(&@&2+8"',("+8&,"*%&"(++/":+/"A)2)8),+"45-),&--&-"*+"/&2+7'*&"),"J'23"K)*3R"WK+,72'/'"!cccX<"$)--)&/?"'",+,9A)2)8),+"/&-)(&,*"+:"J'23"K)*3"1%+"1+52("2'*&/"4&7+6&"*%&"B',"S'*&+"K+5,*3"B58&/@)-+/?"%'("43"!ccc?"/&7+>,)Y&("*%&"8+*&,*)'2"&7+,+6)7"-)>,):)7',7&"+:"6'),*'),),>"*%&"'2/&'(3"@)4/',*"2),;'>&"4&*1&&,"*%&"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*3"),"J'23"K)*3"1)*%"*%&)/"%+6&2',("-'3),>?"QP&"%+8&"*+"752*)@'*&"4/+'(&/"7+665,)7'*)+,"',("5,(&/-*',(),>"4&*1&&,"+5/"7+5,*/)&-"',("752*5/&-R"W)4)(X<""

$%&-&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"2),;'>&-"4&*1&&,"J'23"K)*3"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'/&":+/6'223"'7;,+12&(>&("&'7%"3&'/"1%&,"A)2)8),+-":/+6"'/+5,("*%&"N'3"E/&'"7+,>/&>'*&"),"J'23"K)*3":+/"'"*1+9('3"A)29E6"A/)&,(-%)8"K&2&4/'*)+,<"d/>',)Y&("43"*%&"B)-*&/"K)*3"K+66)**&&?"1%+"%&28&("*+"&-*'42)-%"x5&Y+,"K)*3"'-"J'23"K)*30-"-)-*&/"7)*3"),"!ccb?"*%&"7&2&4/'*)+,":5,7*)+,-"'-"'"6&',-"+:"6'*&/)'2)Y),>"*%&"*)&-"4&*1&&,"J'23"K)*3"',("*%&"45-),&--"',("'/*-"),(5-*/)&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"43"),@)*),>"@'/)+5-"45-),&--&-?"+/>',)Y'*)+,-?"',("'/*)-*-":/+6"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*+"*%&"7)*3"',("7'*&/"8'/*)752'/23"*+"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*)&-"'/+5,("V+/*%"K'2):+/,)'":+/"*1+9('3-<"B8&';),>"+:"*%&"&@&,"),"#LLb?"*%&,"6'3+/"+:"J'23"K)*3"B'2"$+//&-"&H8/&--&("*%&"(5'29/+2&"+:"J'23"K)*3"'-"'"4+*%"'"-)>,):)&/"+:"652*)752*5/'2)-6"',("()@&/-)*3":+/"E6&/)7',-"'-"657%"'-")*")-"'":+7'2"8+),*":+/"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"-'3),>?""

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Za"S+-*"/&7&,*23"+,"#e"S'/7%"#L!L?"*%&"6+-*"/&7&,*":),',7)'2"7+,:&/&,7&":+75-&("+,"(/'1),>"+@&/-&'-"),@&-*6&,*-"),*+"*%&"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"6'/;&*"1'-"+/>',)Y&("43"6'/;&*&/-":/+6"*%&"N'2)*'"S&()'"C,7<"B8+,-+/&("43"'"%+-*"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'223":5,7*)+,),>"7+/8+/'*)+,-":/+6"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"),725(),>"*%&"D%)2)88),&"J&8'/*6&,*"+:"$+5/)-6?"D%)2)88),&"E)/2),&-?"',("*%&"8/+6),&,*"D%)2)88),&"6&()'"7+/8+/'*)+,"hSE"i):&"$G?"*%&">'2'"1'-":+75-&("+,"()-75--),>"/&7&,*"-*'*)-*)7-"+,"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"453),>"8+1&/"'*"*%&"F)2*+,"),"=,)@&/-'2"K)*3?"i+-"E,>&2&-<"E,*+,)+"G)22&>'-?"',"),-*/57*+/":/+6"*%&"K+22&>&"+:"E2'6&('?"'**&,(&("'-"*%&";&39,+*&"-8&';&/"',("8/&-&,*&("7&,-5-"('*'"-5>>&-*),>"*%'*"*%&",&*91+/*%"+:"7+,*/)45*)+,-"43"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"),"*%&"=<B<"1'-"1+/*%"j``"N)22)+,?"-&7+,("+,23"*+"*%+-&"43"*%&"K%),&-&"E6&/)7',"7+665,)*3<""

Page 53: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

be"

"$%)-"*1+9('3":)&-*'"'**/'7*-":'6)2)&-"',(":5,9-&&;&/-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"N'3"E/&'\C*")-"',"&@&,*"*%'*"7+66&6+/'*&-"*%&"%)-*+/)7'2"'22)',7&"4&*1&&,"*1+",'*)+,-<"C*")-"'2-+"',"+88+/*5,&"*)6&"*+"&,I+3"*%&"A)2)8),+"752*5/&"m")*-"7+2+/:52"(',7&-"',("65-)7?">/&'*"(&2)7'7)&-?",'*)@&"'/*-"',("7/':*-<"E-"S'3+/?"C"'6"8'/*)752'/23"8/+5("+:"4&),>"8'/*"+:"*%&":&-*)@'20-"!L*%"',,)@&/-'/3<"$%)-"6)2&-*+,&":5/*%&/"8/+@&-"*%'*"J'23"K)*3")-"'"*/5&"7&,*&/"+:"()@&/-)*3?"'"7+665,)*3"*%'*"&64/'7&-"',("*%/)@&-"+,"2&'/,),>"'4+5*",&1"752*5/&-"WK)*3"+:"J'23"K)*3"#LLbX<"" ""P%)2&"*%&"%)-*+/)7'2"6+/8%+2+>3"+:"J'23"K)*3"'-"'"A)2)8),+"7)*3")-"5,)U5&"*+"*%&"

(&@&2+86&,*"+:"+*%&/"A)2)8),+"7+,7&,*/'*&("2+7'2&-"1)*%),"*%&"=<B<?"2);&"*%&",'@'2"7+665,)*)&-"),"B',"J)&>+?"G'22&I+?"+/"k&/-&3"K)*3?"+/"*%&"*/'()*)+,'2"'>/)752*5/'2"7+665,)*)&-"),"B*+7;*+,"+/"*%/+5>%+5*"F'1'))?"*%&"),*&/-&7*),>"7+,:25&,7&"+:"%)-*+/)7'2"',("&7+,+6)7"8/+7&--&-"),:+/6),>"*%&"7/&'*)+,"+:"J'23"K)*3"'-"',"&8)7&,*&/"+:"A)2)8),+"-&**2&6&,*")-"#&$"5,)U5&<"F&*&/+>&,&+5-":2+1-"+:"A)2)8),+"6)>/'*)+,"%'@&"-),7&"!ceM"),7/&'-),>23"7+6&"*+"I+),"*%&)/"1/7/5*03/"),"1%'*"6)>%*"%'@&"4&&,"+*%&/1)-&"*38)7'223"-545/4',",&)>%4+/%++(-<"i);&"J'23"K)*3"+/")*-"N'3"E/&'"7+5,*&/8'/*"=,)+,"K)*3?"*%&"%)>%&-*"7+,7&,*/'*)+,"+:"A)2)8),+-"',3"7+5,*3"),"*%&"=<B<"'/&"2+7'*&("),"i+-"E,>&2&-"K+5,*3Z`"',("'/&"-8/&'("*%/+5>%+5*"-545/4',"7+665,)*)&-"2);&"K'/-+,?"i+,>"N&'7%?"J)'6+,("N'/?"P&-*"K+@),'?"',("P'2,5*<""

"" "

A!@-&8%/7,3!&F!4J-%3>,-%-!"B*/+22),>"),94&*1&&,"'"-%):*),>">/+58"+:"(',7&/-"',("65-)7)',-?"*%&"6'>,&*)7"

A)2)8),+")7+,?"k+%,"i2+3("K/5Y?"-*'/&("+5*"),*+"*%&"/&-*2&--"+7&',"+:"A)2)8),+":'7&-"),-)(&"K+1"D'2'7&"'/&,'"1%+"'(+/),>23"7%&&/&("4'7;"),"/&-8+,-&<"QE/5/=:/5/!$/3&#8!0/,/$!#/!5/8'*%*>/#8[!z$+>&*%&/"1&"7&2&4/'*&"'-"'":'6)23"',("3+5"'/&"),725(&("'-"1&"7&2&4/'*&"*%)-{R?"K/5Y"&H8/&--&("1%)2&"-*',(),>"'*"*%&"&(>&"+:"*%&"-*'>&"'-"(+Y&,-"+:"'5()&,7&"6&64&/-"/5-%&("*+1'/(-"%)6"),"'"72+5("+:"7'6&/'":2'-%&-"',("-7/&'6-<"""

QA$!1(#8!,*#'*!'/,*0!:/!*#3&C!,*#'*!*$&!5/8*8*#8!5/8*)!#/$*#8!0/,/$[!zE,("):")*"1'-,0*":+/"3+5?")*"1+52(,0*"4&"'22"+5/"6'>)7{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d,*'/)+?"K'2):+/,)'?"45*"*+,)>%*?"*%&3"1',*&("*+"7&2&4/'*&"*+>&*%&/"Q'-"'":'6)23R"),"J'23"K)*3<"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Z`"#e#?"LLL"'77+/(),>"*+"*%&"#LL`"=<B<"K&,-5-<"

Page 54: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ba"

C,"'"8&/:&7*23"6&6+/)Y&("7%+/&+>/'8%3?"N&'"E2+,Y+?"1%+"%'-"4&&,":+/"*%&"6+6&,*?"*%&"5,()-85*&(",'*)+,'2"-1&&*%&'/*"+:"*%&"7+5,*/3"',("*%&"+*%&/9%'2:"+:"*%&"Q2+@&"*&'6R"1)*%"k+%,"i2+3("K/5Y?":+22+1&("%&/"8'/*,&/"',("-%+5*&("+5*?"QS'%'2"8+",'6),>";'3+"zP&"2+@&"3+5"'22{<R"C66&()'*&23":+22+1),>"N&'0-"1+/(-?"*%&"&,*)/&"7'-*"+:"B*'/"S'>)7?"(/'8&("),"-364+2)7'223"8'*/)+*)7"3&22+1"7+2+/-?"7+,725(&("*%&)/"7+,7&/*"1)*%"'"/&,()*)+,"+:"S',,3"D'U5)'+0-"-+,>"N/,*#8!;*#&3<"P'@&-"+:"A)2)8),+-"/')-&("*%&)/"%',(-"'*"*%&"-*/566),>"'7+5-*)7">5)*'/"',("-%+5*&("+5*"&'7%"1+/("*+"*%&"()'-8+/)7"',*%&6?"1%)7%"2)*&/'223"6&',-?"*%&"QA)2)8),+"/'7&R"+/"QA)2)8),+"8&+82&<R"""

i'>)";5,>")*'*''-"WC"1)22"'21'3-"/')-&X""N',()2'",>"D)2)8),'-"W*%&":2'>"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-X""B'',"6',>"-52+;",>"65,(+"WC,"',3"7+/,&/"+:"*%&"1+/2(X""C1'1'>'31'3";+")*+"WC"1)22"1'@&")*X""

"l'%)*"-'',";'%)*";')2',"WE,31%&/&?"',3*)6&X""N'-*'t*";5,>"8'/'"-'"4'3',"WE-"2+,>"'-")*t-":+/"*%&"7+5,*/3X""N5%'3";+"'3")2'2'',"WC"1)22"-8&,(p(&()7'*&"63"2):&X""B'"258'";+,>"-),)2',>',"WC,"*%&"2',("1%&/&"C"1'-"4+/,X""

"D)2)8),+?"D)2)8),+?"D)2)8),+""E,>"2'%)";+"W)-"63"/'7&X""D)2)8),+?"D)2)8),+?"D)2)8),+""E,>"2'%)";+"W)-"63"/'7&X""D)2)8),+?"D)2)8),+?"D)2)8),+""E,>"2'%)";+"W*%&"A)2)8),+"8&+82&X"

"E-"C":+5,("63-&2:"+@&/1%&26&("43"*%&"-&,-&"+:",'*)+,'2)-*"-&,*)6&,*"',("-),>),>"'2+5("*%&"-'6&"7%+/5-"*%'*"C"%'("%&'/("(+Y&,-"+:"*)6&-"82'3),>"+,"63"6+*%&/0-"*&2&@)-)+,"-&*?"C"1'-"7'5>%*"+::">5'/("43"*%&"%',("+:"&2(&/23"A)2)8),'"1%+">/'44&("63"'/6<"D522),>"6&"72+-&/"',("725*7%),>"63"'/6?"-%&"*&,(&/23"&H72')6&("'6)(-*"*%&"-),>),>"7/+1(?"QO+5"1+52(",&@&/";,+1"*%'*"W-+"6',3X"A)2)8),+-"'/&"%&/&<"+/0/8/!#/5/#8!:/!0/,/$!#8!:(0&1!#8!5(#'&!#/%&%&&#!$/3&C!,*#'*!2/^!zP&0/&"/&'223"&@&/31%&/&?"'/&,0*"1&[{R<""

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

Page 55: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

b`"

"""""""""""""""

D,/7$-%!_!!

+%/#:#/$*&#/0!<-/0!4:$/$-!!

E-00*#8!$,-!A5-%*)/#!P%-/5!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:!

Page 56: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

bc"

90/:%-&!<!"QA+/"*%+-&"1%+"'/&"2)@),>"+,"6+(&-*"-+7)'2"-&75/)*3"8&,-)+,-?"'"4&**&/"+8*)+,")-"*+"7+6&"4'7;"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"F&/&?"*%&3"7',"2)@&"7+6:+/*'42&"2)@&-?"1)*%"%+5-&%+2("%&28?"825-"1%'*"8&+82&",&&("6+-*"),"*%&)/"+2("'>&f"/&2'*)@&-"',(":/)&,(-<"$%&/&"-%+52("4&"+88+/*5,)*)&-"),"*%)-"()/&"-)*5'*)+,":+/"*%&"D%)2)88),&"_&*)/&6&,*"E5*%+/)*3"',(":+/"6)(98/)7&("/&'2"&-*'*&"(&@&2+86&,*-R"""

"""""""9"h/&>"S'7'4&,*'?"#LL`<"!9%&5!D%*:*:!$&!D%*:*:!

".2&',+/">&,*23"*5>>&("'*"+,&"-)(&"+:"*%&"+/,'*&23"1+@&,"*'42&72+*%"*)>%*23"

%5>>),>"*%&"-5/:'7&"+:"%&/"+';"1++("(),),>"*'42&<"B%&">'@&")*"+,&"6+/&"1'@&"*+"-6++*%&,"+5*"*%&"/&6'),),>"1/),;2&-?"8&/%'8-"*%),;),>"*+"%&/-&2:"*%'*"*%&3"6)>%*"-+6&%+1"(&*&/"%&/">5&-*-":/+6"-'@+/),>"*%&":/&-%"2&7%+,"z8+/;{"+/"+,&"+:"%&/"8'),-*';),>23"6'(&"2568)'"-%',>%')"z:/)&("&>>/+22-{<"$%&"*'42&72+*%"1'-"I5-*"+,&"+:"@'/)+5-"+/,'6&,*-"(&7+/'*),>"%&/"-6'22"(),),>"/++6?"'"6)2)&5"+:"*/&'-5/&-"*%'*"-%&"'775652'*&("1%)2&"1+/;),>"),"k&(('%<"$%&"-&7+,("2'/>&-*"7)*3"),"B'5()"E/'4)'?"*%&"7+'-*'2"6&*/+8+2)-"1'-"%+6&"*+".2&',+/":+/"*%/&&"3&'/-"1%)2&"-%&"1+/;&("'-"'",5/-&<""E:*&/1'/(-?"-%&"8)7;&("58"+,7&"'>'),"',("7+682&*&("%&/"(/&'6"+:"2)@),>"',("1+/;),>"),"*%&"=<B<""

E"-%),3"4/'--"7+::&&"8+*"1/&-*&("'1;1'/(23"'*+8"',"C-2'6)7"8/'3&/"/5>"),"+,&"7+/,&/"+:"*%&"/++6<"$%&"7+64),'*)+,"+:")*-"2+,>"8/+*/5(),>"-8+5*"8+),*),>"*+1'/(-"'"-&*"+:"6'*7%),>"758-"/&-*),>"+,"*%&"-'7/&("/5>"&@+;&("',")6'>&"+:"8/+-*/'*&("'7+23*&-"8/'3),>"*+1'/(-"*%&"E2'((),"2'6892);&"8+*<"C,"'"6&*'8%+/)7'2"-&,-&?"*%&"'--+/*6&,*"+:"E/'4)7"(|7+/"6&/>&("-+6&1%'*"&::+/*2&--23"1)*%"*%&"*38)7'223"QA)2)8),+R"()-%&-"(&@+5/&("43">5&-*-"'-"&'7%":2+'*&("),"',("+5*"+:"*%&"/++6<"$+>&*%&/?"*%&"/++6":5-&("),*+"'"-,'8-%+*"+:"'"8'/*)752'/"6+6&,*"),"A)2)8),+"6)>/'*)+,?"1%&/&"@'/)+5-23"-;)22&("A)2)8),+"6)>/',*-"*/'@&2&(":'/":/+6"*%&)/"%+6&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"':*&/"*%&"+)2"7/)-)-"+:"*%&"!caL-"*+"6';&"6+6&,*'/3"8)*"-*+8-"),"*%&"S)((2&".'-*"4&:+/&"'//)@),>"*+"*%&)/":),'2"(&-*),'*)+,-"),"P&-*&/,".5/+8&"',("V+/*%"E6&/)7'<""

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

F+1&@&/?"*%)-"1'-",+*"&H'7*23"'":)&-*'<".2&',+/"E758',>?"'"2+,>"*)6&"/&-)(&,*"+:"J'23"K)*3":+/"*1&,*39*1+"3&'/-?"1'-"%+-*),>"'"8')/"+:"/&'2*+/-":/+6"S',)2'"1%+"%'("7+6&"*+"*%&"B',"A/',7)-7+"N'3"E/&'"*+"-&22"8/+8&/*3"*+"A)2)8),+-"1%+"%'("4&&,"-&**2&("),"*%&"=<B<":+/"6',3"3&'/-<"N+*%"/&'2*+/-"1&/&"&682+3&&-"+:".*+,"D/+8&/*)&-"D%)2)88),&-?"C,7<?"*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+68+,&,*"+:"*%&"657%"2'/>&/"),*&/,'*)+,'2"

Page 57: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ML"

7+,>2+6&/'*&?"*%&"i57)+"$',"h/+58<".2&',+/?"1%+"/&7&,*23"4&>',"-5882&6&,*),>"%&/",5/-),>"),7+6&"43"4&7+6),>"',"),(&8&,(&,*23"+8&/'*),>"/&'2*+/"-&22),>"8/+8&/*)&-"+,"4+*%"-)(&-"+:"*%&"N'3?"7'6&"),*+"7+,*'7*"1)*%".*+,"(5/),>"+,&"+:"%&/"6',3"/&*5/,"*/)8-"*+"S',)2'<"P%)2&"),U5)/),>"'4+5*"'"8'/*)752'/"8/+8&/*3"'(@&/*)-&6&,*"I5-*"+5*-)(&"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'?".2&',+/"1'-"()/&7*&("*+"*%&"7+/8+/'*&"+::)7&"+:".*+,"2+7'*&("),"*%&"K&,*/'2"N5-),&--"J)-*/)7*"WKNJX"+:"S';'*)<""

"C"*+2("*%&6"*%'*"*%&/&"'/&"'"2+*"+:"A)2)8),+-"2);&"6&"1%+"'/&"*%),;),>"'4+5*"/&*)/),>"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"S',3"A)2)8),+-"'/&"*%),;),>"'4+5*"/&*5/,),><"E:*&/"C"7+,@),7&("*%&6"*%'*"C"7+52("4&"'"%&28:52"7+,*'7*"),"*%&"=<B<?"1&"+/>',)Y&("'"*)6&":+/"*%&6"*+"7+6&"',("-8&';"*+"63":/)&,(-"',(",&)>%4+/-"%&/&<"

".2&',+/"+,7&"'('6',*23"4&2)&@&("*%'*"-%&"%'(":),'223":+5,("'"%+6&"),"J'23"K)*3"',("*%'*"-%&"1+52(",&@&/"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"*%5-"&,(),>"%&/"-54I&7*)@)*3"'-"'"()'-8+/)7",+6'(<"N5*"2);&"6',3"+:"%&/"/&2'*)@&-"',("A)2)8),+":/)&,(-"1%+"6)>/'*&("',("-&**2&("*%/+5>%+5*"7)*)&-"'2+,>"*%&"E6&/)7',"1&-*"7+'-*"'/+5,("*%&"-'6&"*)6&"*%'*"-%&"()(?"*%&"')2),>"&7+,+63"%'("85-%&("%&/"*+"/&7+,-)(&/"*%&"-*'4)2)*3"+:"%&/"2):&-*32&"',("/&-)(&,7&"),"*%&"=<B<""

$%&"&6&/>),>"*/&,("+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"),@&-*),>"),"8/+8&/*3"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-")-"'":')/23"/&7&,*"+,&g"'"*/&,("*%'*"+,23"4&>',"8)7;),>"58"-*&'6"(5/),>"*%&"&'/23"!ccL-<"d,7&"*%&"),*&/&-*":+/"8/+8&/*3"),@&-*6&,*-"'/+5,("*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1'-")(&,*):)&("43"'"%',(:52"+:"+88+/*5,)-*)7"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"/&'2*+/-"',("&,*/&8/&,&5/-?">2+4'2"/&'2"&-*'*&":)/6-"+8&/'*),>"6'),23":/+6"S&*/+"S',)2'"4&>',"*&-*),>"*%&"6'/;&*"),"*%&"=<B<"D%)2)88),&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"4&>',"43"-&,(),>"+5*"Q/+'("-%+1-R"',("7+,,&7*),>"1)*%"'",&*1+/;"+:"Q4)/((+>-R"*%'*"*'/>&*&("2'/>&"7+,7&,*/'*)+,-"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"',("&@&,*5'223"&H*&,(&("*%&)/"'(@&/*)-),>"*+"A)2)8),+",&1-8'8&/-"',("*%&"),*&/,&*<""

N3"!cca"%+1&@&/?"*%&"&,*)/&"/&>)+,"+:"E-)'"&H8&/)&,7&("'"-5((&,":),',7)'2"7/)-)-"4&>),,),>"),"$%')2',(<"J&-7/)4&("'-"'"Q7+,*'>)+,R"+/"*%&"6+/&"8/&()7*'423"/'7)'2)Y&("@&/-)+,9*%&"QE-)',":25R943"-&@&/'2"&7+,+6)-*-"',("8+2)73"6';&/-?"*%&"7/)-)-"U5)7;23"-8/&'("*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:"E-)'?"8'/*)752'/23"S'2'3-)'?"C,(+,&-)'?"B),>'8+/&?"B+5*%"l+/&'?"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"J/)@&,"43"),*&/,'*)+,'2"-8&752'*)+,"',("),@&-*6&,*?"*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"&7+,+63?"1%)7%"%'("4&&,"4++6),>"(5/),>"*%&"2'*&"!c`L-"',("&'/23"!ccL-?"7'6&"*+"'"U5)7;"%'2*<""P%)2&"+*%&/"E-)',"7+5,*/)&-"-*/5>>2&("(&-8&/'*&23"*+"-*'3"':2+'*"':*&/"*%&"7/)-)-"-1&22&(?"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63"/&4+5,(&("/&2'*)@&23"U5)7;23"WN'2)-'7',"',("F)22"#LLZg"l/),;-"#LL#X<"P%)2&"*%&/&"'/&"-8&7):)7"/&'-+,-"*%'*"%&28"&H82'),"1%3"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"&H8&/)&,7&("'"/&2'*)@&23"6)2("/&7&--)+,"7+68'/&("*+")*-",&)>%4+/-?"*%&":+75-"+:"*%)-"7%'8*&/")-"+,"'"8'/*)752'/"-&7*+/"+:"*%&"7+5,*/30-"&7+,+63"*%'*"%'-"7+,*),5'223"-5-*'),&(")*-":),',7)'2"-3-*&6"),"*%&":'7&"+:"/&8&'*),>"7/)-)-<""

$%)-"7%'8*&/"&H'6),&-"*%&"8/+(57*)+,"+:"'"-&*"+:"-54I&7*)@)*)&-"7+,-*)*5*&("*%/+5>%"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"8/+7&--&-"7)/752'*),>"4&*1&&,"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*-"',("4/+;&/-"+8&/'*),>"4&*1&&,"*%&"=<B<"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"C,"/&7&,*"3&'/-?"8/+88&("58"43"'"7+,*),5+5-"-*/&'6"+:"/&6)**',7&"7'8)*'2?"45-),&--"+5*-+5/7),>?"',("&H8+/*'*)+,"+:"2'4+/"8/+(57&("1)*%"*%&"N'2);4'3',"&7+,+63?"*%&"D%)2)88),&"/&'2"&-*'*&"6'/;&*"%'-">'),&(",&1"6+6&,*56<"K+/8+/'*&"),*&/&-*"),"*%&"8+*&,*)'2"7'8)*'2"),@&-*6&,*-"

Page 58: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

M!"

+:"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"'4/+'(?"&-8&7)'223"),"*%&"=<B<?"%'-"2&("*+"',"'>>/&--)@&"7'68')>,"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"'(@&/*)-&6&,*"',("),*&,-)@&"8/+8&/*3"(&@&2+86&,*"+,"*%&"8'/*"+:">2+4'2"/&'2"&-*'*&":)/6-"),"S&*/+"S',)2'<""

E-"',"&,*)/&">&,&/'*)+,"+:"8+-*9!ce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

$%)-"7%'8*&/"1)22":+75-"+,"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"7)/752'*)+,"+:"/&'2"&-*'*&"(&@&2+86&,*"7'8)*'2";,)**),>"*+>&*%&/"*%&"'-8)/'*)+,-"+:"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"),"*%&"=<B<"1)*%"-*'*&"'>&,*-"',("7+/8+/'*&"(&@&2+8&/-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"_&7&,*23?"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"1&/&"4&-&*"43"*%&"&6&/>&,7&"+:"',"&7+,+6)7"7/)-)-"*%'*"8/&7)8)*'*&("'"2+,>"-&/)&-"+:"6+/*>'>&"(&:'52*-?"%+6&":+/&72+-5/&-?"',("'"*/&6&,(+5-"2+--"+:"8&/-+,'2"'--&*-"4&>),,),>"),"#LLa<""d,&"+88+/*5,)-*)7"/&'2*3"&,*/&8/&,&5/?"1/)*),>":/+6"*%&"8&/-8&7*)@&"+:"A)2)8),+-"),"K'2):+/,)'"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&",&1-8'8&/".(:*#-::B&%0'?"5/>&("7+/8+/'*)+,-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*+"7+,*),5&"*'/>&*),>"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"&'>&/23"-5>>&-*),>"*%'*?"QA+/"*%+-&"1%+"'/&"2)@),>"+,"6+(&-*"-+7)'2"-&75/)*3"8&,-)+,-?"'"4&**&/"+8*)+,")-"*+"7+6&"4'7;"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"F&/&?"*%&3"7',"2)@&"7+6:+/*'42&"2)@&-?"1)*%"%+5-&%+2("%&28?"825-"1%'*"8&+82&",&&("6+-*"),"*%&)/"+2("'>&f"/&2'*)@&-"',(":/)&,(-R"WS'7'4&,*'"#LL`X<"

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

$%)-"8+),*&("),*&/&-*"),"'**/'7*),>"),@&-*6&,*-":/+6"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"-2+123"&@+2@&("+5*"+:"(&7'(&-"+:"&7+,+6)7"',("752*5/'2"/&2)',7&"+,"/&6)**',7&"6+,&3"-&,*"43"A)2)8),+-"1+/;),>"'4/+'(<"$%)-"1&4"+:"/&6)**',7&-"*%/&'(-"*+>&*%&/"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"',("*/',-9%)-*+/)7'2"@&)2"4&,&'*%"1%)7%"A)2)8),+-":),("*%&6-&2@&-"*)&("*+"4+*%"*%&"=<B<"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"$%)-"7'8)*'2":2+1"+:"/&6)**',7&-"%'-"'2-+"4&&,":5,('6&,*'2"*+"-5-*'),),>"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63"-),7&"*%&"!c`L-<"P%)2&"8+*&,*)'2"/&*5/,&&-"2);&".2&',+/"-2+123"-%+/&"58"*%&)/"),@&-*6&,*-"),*+"8/+8&/*3"(&@&2+86&,*-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"+,"+,&"-)(&"+:"*%&"4'2);4'3',"&7+,+630-"8'*%1'3?"652*),'*)+,'2"8/+8&/*3"(&@&2+8&/-"8/&8'/&":+/"*%&)/")68&,(),>"/&*5/,"*%/+5>%"*%&"7+,-*/57*)+,"+:"6'--)@&"6&>'98/+I&7*"(&@&2+86&,*-"*%/+5>%+5*"S&*/+"S',)2'0-"8&/)8%&/)&-<"d,"*%&"+*%&/"-)(&"+:"*%)-"8'*%1'3"7+,@&3-"'"657%"2+,>&/"%)-*+/)7'2"

Page 59: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

M#"

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

""QP&0@&"85*"+5/"%+5-&"),"+/(&/\$%&/&"'/&"'**/'7*)@&"),@&-*6&,*"8'7;'>&-":+/"3+5"):"3+5"1',*"*+"&H82+/&?"(&@&2+8"',("8/+7&--"6),&/'2"/&-+5/7&-\.'-3"&,*/3":+/"&H8'*/)'*&"-*'::\J+&-,0*"*%'*"-+5,("2);&"',"+::&/"3+5"7',0*"/&:5-&["P&"2);&"652*),'*)+,'2-<"S',)2'0-",'*5/'2"7%'/6-"'-"'"/&>)+,'2"45-),&--"7&,*&/"%'@&"4&&,"&,%',7&("43"'"-8&7)'2"),7&,*)@&"8'7;'>&\3+5/"&H8'*/)'*&96','>&/-"1)22"&,I+3"E-)'0-"2+1&-*"2)@),>"7+-*-"'6+,>"*%&"6+-*"+5*>+),>"8&+82&"),"*%&"D'7):)7\E77+5,*',*-"7+6&":+/"jea?"&H&75*)@&"-&7/&*'/)&-":+/"j!b`<"S+@&"3+5/"E-)',"%&'(U5'/*&/-"*+"S',)2'"',("6';&"3+5/"7+-*"'77+5,*',*-"%'883\$%&"7+5,*/3")-"2+@&23<"E,("2+'(&(<"N&,&'*%"*%&"*/+8)7'2"2',(-7'8&-"+:"+5/"a?LLL")-2',(-"2)&-"'"1&'2*%"+:",'*5/'2"/&-+5/7&-\RZc""$%&"'(@&/*)-&6&,*"4+5>%*"43"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*"',("8/),*&("),"*%&"

Q->!Z&%1!+*5-:"W#`"k523"!cabX"7+,@&3-"%+1":+/"'26+-*"'"7&,*5/3?"8+2)73"6';&/-"',("&,*/&8/&,&5/-?":/+6"&'/23"8/+9&H8',-)+,)-*-"),"*%&"=<B<"*+"7+,*&68+/'/3"652*),'*)+,'2"7+/8+/'*&"&H&75*)@&-"),".'-*"E-)'?"%'@&"-+5>%*"*+"*5/,"*%&"-8&752'*)@&">'Y&"+:"8/+-8&7*)@&"),@&-*+/-"+,*+"*%&"'/7%)8&2'>+"1)*%"'"7+,:)(&,7&"),-8)/&("43"*%&"7&$-#$*/0"+:"&7+,+6)7"&H8',-)+,"',("1&'2*%"'7U5)-)*)+,"/'*%&/"*%',")*-"'7*5'2"8/&-&,7&<bL"P%&*%&/")*"1'-"*%&"-&/&,()8)*+5-">&+>/'8%)7'2"2+7'*)+,"*%'*"6'(&"*%&"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Zc"x5+*&(":/+6"$'()'/?"9/#$/:3!;%&'()$*&#?!E-R(/0!4)&#&5*-:?"8<"bZ<"""bL"A+/"',")2256),'*)@&"()-75--)+,"+,"*%&"),*&>/'2"/+2&"+:"=<B<"8/),*"6&()'"+,"-588+/*),>"8/+9&H8',-)+,)-*"@&,*5/&"),*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"-&&"h/&3"E<"N/&7%),?""57-%*/0!E/#!9%/#)*:)&?!U%2/#!;&>-%C!4/%$,03!<(*#"WN&/;&2&3f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"K'2):+/,)'"D/&--?"#LLeX?"8><"!#!9!aL<"$%&"XJ-%0/#'!6&#$,03?":+/"),-*',7&?"*%/+5>%"'"2)*',/3"+:"'/*)72&-?"'77+68',3),>"8)7*+/)'2-?"',("/%&*+/)7"+:"S',):&-*"J&-*),3?"1'-"'7*)@&"),"),:+/6),>"*%&"E6&/)7',"8542)7"+,"Q*%&"E6'Y),>"I5,>2&-"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-R"',("*%&)/"@'/)+5-",'*5/'2"/&-+5/7&"1')*),>"*+"&H8/+8/)'*&(<"C,"/&7&,*"(&7'(&-?".,>2)-%"-8&';),>"7+5,*/)&-?"'2+,>"1)*%"k'8',?"&,7+5/'>&("43"*%&"),7/&'-&("2)4&/'2)Y'*)+,"+:"*/'(&"'>/&&6&,*-":+22+1),>"*%&"8'--'>&"+:"*%&"A+/&)>,"C,@&-*6&,*-"E7*"+:"!cc!"43"*%&"_'6+-"E(6),)-*/'*)+,"W1%)7%"'22+1&(":+/&)>,"&U5)*3"8'/*)7)8'*)+,"+:"58"*+"!LLy"),"'",564&/"+:"5,/&-*/)7*&("),@&-*6&,*"'/&'-X"',("2+1"-&*958"7+-*-?"&-*'42)-%&(",56&/+5-"7+8+/'*&"+::)7&-"),*+"S&*/+"S',)2'<"B&&"WK+/,&2)+9D/+,+@&"!cccX<"P%)2&"*%&"=<B<?"k'8',?"',("7+5,*/)&-"),"P&-*&/,".5/+8&"%'@&"*/'()*)+,'223"7+68/)-&("*%&"2'/>&-*"8&/7&,*'>&"58"AJC-"*)22"!cca?"+@&/"*%&"2'-*"(&7'(&?"'**/'7*&("*+"),@&-*6&,*-"),".,>2)-%"2',>5'>&"2&'/,),>"-7%++2-"',("/&2'*)@&23"2+1"7+-*),>"8/+8&/*)&-?"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'-"4&&,"&H8&/)&,7),>"'"6'--)@&"-5/>&"),":+/&)>,"),@&-*6&,*"8/&(+6),',*23":/+6"l+/&'<"C,"#LLZ?"*%&"D%)2)88),&"J&8'/*6&,*"+:"$+5/)-6"2'5,7%&(")*-".,>2)-%"'-"'"B&7+,("i',>5'>&"$+5/"D/+>/'6<"$%&"8/+>/'6"7+64),&-"2',>5'>&"2&'/,),>"'7*)@)*)&-"1)*%"@'7'*)+,"*/)8-<"E2*%+5>%"*%&"8/+>/'6"7'*&/-"*+"8/)6'/)23".'-*"E-)',"2&'/,&/-"),"K%),'"',("k'8',?"Ql+/&',-"6';&"58"*%&"452;"+:")*-"75-*+6&/-R"WJ'6'Y+"#LLaX<"

Page 60: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

MZ"

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b!""

C,"*%&"7'-&"+:"A+/&)>,"J)/&7*"C,@&-*6&,*-"WAJC-X?"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"/&6'),-"7+68&*)*)@&"1)*%"+*%&/"E-)',"7+5,*/)&-"),"'**/'7*),>":+/&)>,"),@&-*6&,*-"43"(&@+*),>"'"-)>,):)7',*"8+/*)+,"+:">+@&/,6&,*"-8&,(),>"*+"),7/&'-),>"*+5/)-6"',("&,7+5/'>),>"*/'(&"*%/+5>%"*%&"2)4&/'2)Y'*)+,"',("(&/&>52'*)+,"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63<"C,*&>/'2"*+"*%&"&H8',-)+,"+:"),(5-*/)&-"',("*/'(&"'/&"*%+-&"-8&752'*+/-"1%+"/)-;&("),@&-*),>"-8&752'*)@&"7'8)*'2"),*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"(5/),>"@'/)+5-"6+6&,*-"+:"&7+,+6)7"7/)-)-"',("8+2)*)7'2"*/',-)*)+,<"C,"'"/&7)8/+7'2":'-%)+,?"*%&"&2'4+/'*&"2'4+/"4/+;&/),>"),(5-*/3"*%'*"-&,(-"6)22)+,-"+:"A)2)8),+-"'4/+'("*+"1+/;"'-"d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dAP-"*+"7+,*),5&"*+"1+/;"'4/+'("1%)2&"/&()/&7*),>"'"8+/*)+,"+:"*%&)/"),7+6&"4'7;"*+"*%&"B*'*&<""

A5,('6&,*'223?"*%&-&"()@&/>&,*"3&*":5,7*)+,'223"),*&/2),;),>"8/+7&--&-?">&,&/'*&("',("6'),*'),&("43":2+1-"+:"-8&752'*)@&"7'8)*'2"W+,&"(/'1),>":+/&)>,"7'8)*'2"),*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1%)2&"*%&"+*%&/"-&'/7%&-":+/")*"'4/+'(X?"7+68/)-&"*%&"8/+(57*)@&":+/7&"*5/,),>"*%&"6'7%),&/3"+:"*%&"4'2);4'3',"&7+,+63<"E-"-8&752'*)@&"),@&-*+/-?"@'/)+5-"&,*)*)&-"'**&68*"*+"1),"8/+:)*-"43"'4-+/4),>"*%&"/)-;?"2)*&/'223"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""b!"D&/%'8-"+,&"+:"*%&"6+-*"8&/@'-)@&"8/'7*)7&-"+:"-8&752'*)@&"7'8)*'2"*%/+5>%+5*"B+5*%&'-*"E-)'"',("+*%&/"8'/*-"+:"*%&"h2+4'2"B+5*%"'/&"*%+-&"8/'7*)7&("43"*%&"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3<"E-"'"6&',-"*+"8/+@)(&"),-*',*":+/&)>,"),@&-*6&,*?"&'-&"2+7'2"5,&682+36&,*?"',("/&>52'*&"*%&"7%',,&2),>"+:"/&@&,5&"4'7;"*+"*%&"A&(&/'2"h+@&/,6&,*?"+,&"+:"*%&":)/-*"6'I+/")682&6&,*'*)+,-"&,:+/7&("43"A&/(),',("S'/7+-"1'-"*%&"7/&'*)+,"+:"*%&"S),)-*/3"+:"$+5/)-6"WSd$X?"*%&"'>&,73"D%)2)88),&"$+5/)-6"E5*%+/)*3"WD$EX"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&"K+,@&,*)+,"N5/&'5"WDKNX"),"!caZ<""S57%"+:"*%&"8+2)*)7'2"-7)&,*)-*"i),('"_)7%*&/0-"4+(3"+:"1+/;?"),"8'/*)752'/?"8/+@)(&-"',"),9(&8*%"','23-)-"+,"%+1"*%&"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1'-"),*&>/'2"*+"'22&@)'*),>"),*&/,'*)+,'2"7/)*)7)-6"+:"S'/7+-0"()7*'*+/)'2"/&>)6&"',("%)-")682&6&,*'*)+,"+:"6'/*)'2"2'1"43"8/&-&,*),>"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*%/+5>%"'"Q:'}'(&"+:"u,+/6'2)*30R"7+,-*/57*&("43"*%&"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3<"A+/"'"*%+/+5>%"()-75--)+,"+,"*%&"8+2)*)7'2"5-&"+:"*+5/)-6"43"*%&"S'/7+-"E(6),)-*/'*)+,?"-&&"W_)7%*&/"!c`cX<"

Page 61: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Mb"

85/7%'-),>")*?"),"+/(&/"*+"-*'4)2)Y&"'"8'/*)752'/"6'/;&*?"(&*&/6),&"*%&"8/)7&":+/"'">)@&,"7+66+()*3?"',("&@&,*5'223"'77/5&"',"&,+/6+5-":),',7)'2"/&*5/,"',("&@&,"*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:"*%&"7+66+()*30-"6'/;&*<"C,"4+*%"7'-&-?"*%&/&"1&/&"/&2'*)@&23":&1"-':&">5'/(-":+/"),)*)'2"),@&-*+/-"),"*%&"4'2);4'3',"&7+,+63?"1%)7%"1+52("&,-5/&"'"8/+:)*":+/"*%&"*/',-'7*)+,-"+/"2'4+/<"E-"-57%?"*%&"&7+,+63"+:"'88&'/',7&-")-"'21'3-"8/),7)82&("58+,"*%&"8/+6)-&"+:"1%'*"7+52("4&"/'*%&/"*%',"1%'*"1'-"'2/&'(3"*%&/&<""

C,*&/,'*)+,'2"8/+8&/*3"-8&752'*)+,"',("/&'2"&-*'*&"(&@&2+86&,*?"8'/*)752'/23"),"*%&"7'-&"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?")-"*%&"8/&&6),&,*"&H'682&"+:"$-),>0-"&7+,+63"+:"'88&'/',7&-<"C,"*%&)/"&,(&'@+/"*+"()-7+@&/"&6&/>),>"-+5/7&-"+:":),',7)'2"7'8)*'2?"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"&,*/&8/&,&5/-"'/&"7+68&22&("*+"&H'>>&/'*&"*%&"8+*&,*)'2":+/"7'8)*'2"1&'2*%"'775652'*)+,"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"),"+/(&/"*+"'**/'7*"*%&"),@&-*6&,*-"*%&3",&&("*+"85/-5&"*%&)/"*+*'2"45-),&--"82',-"),":522<"$%&"/&6'),),>"7%'8*&/"(&-7/)4&-"%+1"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"2++;"*+"*%&"&7+,+63"+:"'88&'/',7&-"'-"'"6&',-"+:"7+68&22),>"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"*+"),@&-*"),"/&'2"&-*'*&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""

E77+/(),>"*+"$-),>0-":+/652'*)+,?"Q8&/:+/6',7&"%&/&")-"-)652*',&+5-23"&7+,+6)7"8&/:+/6',7&"',("(/'6'*)7"8&/:+/6',7&R<"P%&*%&/"*%&"'-8)/'*)+,":+/"8/+:)*"6)>%*"&,*')2"6'/;&*),>"'",&1"72+*%),>"2),&"+/"),*/+(57),>"',"),,+@'*)+,"1)*%),"*%&":++("),(5-*/3?"*%&"Q&7+,+63"+:"'88&'/',7&-\*%&"-&2:97+,-7)+5-"6';),>"+:"'"-8&7*'72&")-"'",&7&--'/3"')("*+">'*%&/),>"),@&-*6&,*":5,(-\C*")-"'"/&>52'/":&'*5/&"+:"*%&"-&'/7%":+/":),',7)'2"7'8)*'2R<"P%&*%&/"/&'2"+/")6'>),&(?"*%&"'**/'7*)+,"+:"7'8)*'2"),@&-*6&,*-"/&23"+,"*%&"(/'6'*)Y'*)+,"',("&H'>>&/'*)+,"+:"8+--)4)2)*)&-"),"+/(&/"*+"4&>),"+8&/'*),>"+/"*+"7+66&,7&"&H8',-)+,"+:"*%&)/"),(5-*/)&-<"Q$%&"6+/&"-8&7*'752'/"*%&"7+,I5/),>?"*%&"6+/&"8+--)42&"',"),@&-*6&,*":/&,Y3R<"$-),>0-",+*)+,")-"8'/*)752'/23"/&2&@',*"*+"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&?"1%&/&"6+/&"+:*&,"*%&"),*&,(&("8/+8&/*3"+/"*+1,-%)8")-"-*)22"),"*%&"6+(&2"8%'-&?":),',7),>"7'8)*'2")-"),*&>/'2"*+"7+66&,7&"45)2(),>"',("'7%)&@),>"*%&-&"@'/)+5-"(&@&2+86&,*"8/+I&7*-<"$%)-")-"&-8&7)'223"*%&"7'-&"),"S&*/+"S',)2'"1%&/&"8/+8&/*)&-"'/&"7+66+,23":5,(&("43"Q8/&9-&22),>Rb#"58"*+"bL"8&/7&,*"+:"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*"WK+/,&2)+9D/+,+@&"!cccX<"QC,"+/(&/"*+"'**/'7*"7+68',)&-?"7+5,*/)&-?"/&>)+,-?"',("*+1,-"65-*"(/'6'*)Y&"*%&)/"8+*&,*)'2"'-"82'7&-":+/"),@&-*6&,*<"J/'6'*)7"8&/:+/6',7&")-"*%&"8/&/&U5)-)*&"+:"*%&)/"&7+,+6)7"8&/:+/6',7&R"W!!`X<""

$-),>0-"Q&7+,+63"+:"'88&'/',7&-R")-"),-*/57*)@&":+/"7+68/&%&,(),>"*%&"8/+7&--&-"8/+(57),>"7)/752'*)+,-"+:"7'8)*'2"),@&-*6&,*"4&*1&&,"*%&"=<B<"',("*%&"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""b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b"8&/7&,*"),"E6&/)7',"4',;-"+/"),"E6&/)7',"6+,&3"6'/;&*"82'7&6&,*-R"WD'-75'2"#LLZ?"bLX"

Page 62: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

MM"

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i+52&,"F'1'))"B8+/*-"P&'/"'-"1&22"'-"*%&"7+9+1,&/"+:"K/+1,"K+5/*"_&-*'5/',*<"F&"'(6)*-"*%'*"%&")-"8'3),>"72+-&"'**&,*)+,"*+"*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"6'/;&*"),"8/+@),7&-"2);&"C2+7+-"V+/*&<"oCt@&"-&&,"*%&"&7+,+63")68/+@&"&@&/3"3&'/?o"N5*'3"-')(<"o$%&"6)((2&"72'--")-"-*'/*),>"*+">/+1<"S3":/)&,(-"'/&"/)7%<"$%&"-%+88),>"7&,*&/-"'/&"657%"4&**&/"%&/&"*%',"),"F'1'))"',("*%&"6'),2',(o"Wl/&):&2-"#LLcX<"i);&"+*%&/"A)2)8),+"),@&-*+/-"1%+"7%+-&"*+"85/7%'-&"8/+8&/*3"+5*-)(&"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'?"N5*'30-",&123"'7U5)/&("8/+8&/*)&-"'/&"2+7'*&("),"*%&"8/+@),7&-"+:"N'*',>'-"',("x5&Y+,"-+5*%&'-*"+:"S',)2'<"P%)2&"%&")-"'1'3?"%)-":'6)23"2++;-"+@&/"%)-":'/6-"1%&/&"*%&3"/')-&"8+52*/3<""

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

E*"*%&"75//&,*"6+6&,*"%+1&@&/?"*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:"A)2)8),+-"1%+"%'@&"2)@&("),"*%&"=<B<"-),7&"*%&"!caL-"',("!c`L-?"*%+-&"1%+"'//)@&("'-"%)>%23"&(57'*&(")66)>/',*-"',("%'@&"),:5-&("*%&6-&2@&-"1)*%),"*%&"-;)22&("-&7*+/"+:"*%&"=<B<"2'4+/"6'/;&*?"7+,*),5&"*+"/&6'),"7+,*&,*&("*+"/&-)(&"),"*%&)/"'(+8*&("7+5,*/3<"A+/"*%&"

Page 63: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Me"

6+6&,*?",&)*%&/"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"%'@&"7%+-&,"*+"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"-#!5/::-",+/"'/&"*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:"/&'2"&-*'*&"(&@&2+86&,*-"45)2*"*+"'77+66+('*&"*%)-"/&*5/,"7+682&*&<"C,"+/(&/":+/"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"6'/;&*"*+"(/'1"A)2)8),+-":/+6"*%&"=<B"',("6&&*"*%&-&"/&*5/,&&-"1)*%"/&'2"&-*'*&"(&@&2+86&,*-?"'":+5,('*)+,"+:"-8&752'*)@&"7'8)*'2"),@&-*6&,*"65-*"4&"),*/+(57&("',("*%&":)/-*"/+5,("+:"6'--)@&"),:/'-*/57*5/&"',("/&'2"&-*'*&"%'-"*+"4&"45)2*<""

d@&/"*%&"8'-*"(&7'(&?")6'>),'*)@&"&,*/&8/&,&5/-"%'@&"),7/&'-),>23"),@&-*&("&,+/6+5-"'6+5,*-"+:"-8&752'*)@&"7'8)*'2"),*+"652*)9-7'2&("8/+8&/*3"(&@&2+86&,*-"',("*%&">2+4'2"'(@&/*)-),>"+:"*%&-&"(&@&2+86&,*-<"E2/&'(3"-54-)()Y&("),"6',3"1'3-"43"*%&"+::)7&"8/+8&/*3"6'/;&*"4++6"+:"*%&"!c`L-"',("cL-?"),@&-*+/-"%'@&"2++;&("*+"*%&"%+5-),>"6'/;&*"*+"()@&/-):3"*%&)/"8+/*:+2)+-"WK+/,&2)+9D/+,+@&"!cccX<"N3"*%&"&,("+:"*%&"!ccL-?"),@&-*+/-"4&7'6&"),7/&'-),>23"7+,@),7&("*%'*"/&*5/,),>"A)2)8),+-"1+52("4&"1)22),>"*+"85/7%'-&"58-7'2&"%+5-),>"8/+8&/*)&-?"8'/*)752'/23"A)2)8),+-"1+/;),>"'4/+'("),"*%&"1%)*&"7+22'/"-&7*+/<"P)*%),"*%&"/&-)(&,*)'2"-&7*+/"'2+,&":+/"&H'682&?"),"x5&Y+,"K)*3?"'"*/'()*)+,'223"588&/972'--&("-&7*)+,"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'"1%&/&"*%&":)/-*"1'@&"+:"-545/4',)Y'*)+,"%'("4&>5,"),"*%&":)/-*"%'2:"+:"*%&"*1&,*)&*%97&,*5/3?"*%&/&"1&/&"'4+5*"#b"()::&/&,*"8/)@'*&"/&-)(&,*)'2"-54()@)-)+,-"1)*%"'4+5*"eLLL"%+6&-"),"*%&"&'/23"!ccL-<"S+-*"+:"*%&"%+6&-"1&/&"-),>2&"(&*'7%&("%+5-&"',("&'7%"-54()@)-)+,":)22&("'4+5*"M"-U5'/&9;)2+6&*&/-"+:"5/4',"-8'7&"WV)&//'-"!cc#X<"C,"2&--"*%',"'"(&7'(&?"(&@&2+8&/-"&H8',(&("*%&",564&/"+:"-54()@)-)+,-"*+"MLL?"%+5-),>"+@&/"'"6)22)+,"/&-)(&,*-"',("(/'-*)7'223"*/',-:+/6),>"*%&"/&-)(&,*)'2"7+/&"+:"5/4',)-6"),"S&*/+"S',)2'"*+1'/(-"-545/4',)Y&("(1&22),>-"WK+,,&22"!cccX<"S52*),'*)+,'2"7+/8+/'*)+,-"4'-&("),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"4&>',"45)2(),>"8/+8&/*)&-",+*"+,23"),"%)>%9/)-&"7+,(+6),)56-"),"*%&"K&,*/'2"N5-),&--"E/&'"WKNJX"+:"S';'*)?"45*"1&-*&/,"45,>'2+1-"',("652*)985/8+-&("*+1,-%)8-"'/+5,("*%&"8&/)8%&/3"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'<"Q.@&,*5'223"*%&"1'@&"+:"A)2)8),+"/&*)/&&-"1)22"6';&"*%&)/"1'3"4'7;"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"B++,"*%&"*/)7;2&"1)22"4&7+6&"'"/)@&/R?"72')6&("V+/6',"_&3&-?"',"&H&75*)@&"+:"),*&/,'*)+,'2"-'2&-"'*"E3'2'"i',(-<""

E-"*%&-&"(&@&2+86&,*-"-2+123"/&7+,:)>5/&"*%&"-+7)'2"1+/2("+:"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*%/+5>%"*%&"*/',-:+/6'*)+,"+:"*%&"45)2*"2',(-7'8&"',("*%&"/&()/&7*)+,"+:"2'4+/?"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"'/&"),7/&'-),>23"&,7+5/'>&("*+"),@&-*"6+/&":),',7),>"7'8)*'2"'-"6+/&"',("6+/&"A)2)8),+-"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"1)*,&--"*%&-&"&@+25*)+,-?"',("),"*5/,?"2++;"*+"),@&-*"*%&)/":),',7&-"),*+"*%&)/":5*5/&"4'7;"),"*%&"%+6&2',(<""

D'-75'2"W#LLZX"%'-"-&/@)7&("*%&"A)2)8),+")66)>/',*"7+665,)*3"),"B+5*%&/,"K'2):+/,)'":+/"+@&/"*1&,*393&'/-<"F&"%'-"'2-+"4&&,"+,&"+:"*%&"8)+,&&/),>":)>5/&-"),"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"4&*1&&,"4+*%"7+5,*/)&-<"A+/&7'-*),>"*%&"8+*&,*)'2"85/7%'-),>"8+1&/"+:"/&*5/,),>"A)2)8),+-"'*"*%&"&,("+:"*%&"!c`L-?"D'-75'2":)/623"4&2)&@&-"*%'*"I5-*"'-""Q+*%&/"7+5,*/)&-"%'@&"-&&,"',"),:25H"+:"/&*)/&&-"-)6823"4&7'5-&"*%&3"%'@&"(&@&2+8&("6&',-"*+";&&8"*%&-&"/&*)/&&-"),"*%&)/"8'*&/,'2"'4+(&<"C"4&2)&@&"*%'*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"7',":),("1'3-"',("6&',-"*+"(+"*%&"-'6&":+/"*%&"*%+5-',(-"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"/&*)/&&-R"W!Z9!bX<"D'-75'20-"),:+/6'*)@&"*&H*?"O&>!$&!;%&F*$!F%&5!$,-!`_a!.*00*&#!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#!6/%1-$C"(&-7/)4&-"%)-"&'/23"8'/*,&/-%)8"1)*%"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"),"-&22),>"D%)2)88),&"8/+8&/*3"*+"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"),"*%&"=<B<"$%/+5>%"453&/"8/+:)2&-"',("),-)>%*"*%'*"%&">'),&("1%)2&"(&'2),>"

Page 64: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Ma"

1)*%"A)2)8),+-"),"4+*%"7+5,*/)&-?"D'-75'2"'/>5&-"*%'*"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"-%+52("4&"*%&"8/)6'/3"*'/>&*":+/":),',7)'2"),@&-*6&,*-?"8'/*)752'/23"),"*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"-&7*+/<""

S+/&"4/+'(23?"%)-"%',(4++;")225-*/'*&-"*%&"(5'2"Q8&/:+/6',7&R"+:"-8&752'*)@&"7'8)*'2"*%'*")-"6'(&",&7&--'/3"),"+/(&/"*+"&,*)7&"2&$,"/&'2"&-*'*&"(&@&2+8&/-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("8+*&,*)'2"8/+8&/*3"453&/-"),"*%&"=<B<"*+"),@&-*"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&"/&'2"&-*'*&"&7+,+63<"E-"-57%?"$-),>0-"&7+,+63"+:"'88&'/',7&-"+775//),>"1)*%),"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"),(5-*/3"+8&/'*&-"+,"*1+"-)652*',&+5-":/+,*-f"W!X">'/,&/),>"-8&752'*)@&"7'8)*'2":+/"(&@&2+86&,*"8/+I&7*-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("W#X"&2)7)*),>"),)*)'2"),@&-*6&,*-":/+6"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"*+"85/7%'-&"8/&9-&22),>"8/+8&/*)&-<""

"S+-*"+:"*%&"8/+8&/*)&-"*%'*"1&"'/&"-&22),>"),"*%&"=<B<"6'/;&*"%'@&"3&*"*+"4&"7+682&*&(<"d5/"72)&,*-"%'@&"*+"*';&"'"2&'8"+:":')*%"',("453"8/+8&/*)&-"*%'*"*%&3"1)22",+*"6+@&"),*+":+/"-&@&/'2"3&'/-<"B5/&")*0-"',"),@&-*6&,*"45*"1&"'2-+";,+1"*%'*")*0-"@&/3"()::&/&,*"*%',"%+1"3+5"453"%+6&-"),"*%&"B*'*&-?""

"&H82'),-"K'/2+-".-*&2?"',"),*&/,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*"1+/;),>":+/"_+4),-+,-"i',("K+/8+/'*)+,<"$%&">2+4'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,")-"*%&"8'/&,*"7+68',3"*+"_+4),-+,-"S'22-?"*%&"-&7+,("2'/>&-*"-%+88),>"6'22"',("/&*')2"+8&/'*+/"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("I5-*"+,&"+:"@'/)+5-"7+/8+/'*)+,-"(&@+*),>"-54-*',*)'2"/&-+5/7&-"*+"-&22),>"8/+8&/*3"*+"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"""

$%&"4)>>&-*"+4-*'72&"*+"-&22),>"8/+8&/*3"*+"A)2)8),+-")-"'--5/),>"*%&6"*%'*"*%&3022">&*"1%'*"*%&3"453<"A+/"6+-*"7+68',)&-?")*0-"',"&@&,"4)>>&/"8/+42&6"4&7'5-&"*%&3"7',,+*"45)2("5,*)2"*%&3"-&75/&"&,+5>%"),@&-*6&,*-":/+6"453&/-"'4/+'(<".-8&7)'223"),"S',)2'"z1%&/&"8/+8&/*3")-"6+/&"&H8&,-)@&{<"$%)-")-"4&7'5-&"*%&3"(+",+*"+1,"*%&"2',("*%&3"'/&"(&@&2+8),>"+,<"$%)-")-",+*"'"8/+42&6":+/"_+4),-+,-"-),7&"1&"+1,"6',3"8/+8&/*)&-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""

$%)-"-&,*)6&,*"1'-"6)//+/&("43"',+*%&/"),*&/,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*"+8&/'*),>"*%/+5>%".*+,"D/+8&/*)&-<"""

P&"'/&"5,(&/"*%&"i57)+"$',"K+/8+/'*)+,-<"$%&"7+/8+/'*)+,"'2/&'(3"+1,-"*1+"4',;-"',("*%&/&"'/&"6',3",+,98&/:+/6),>"'--&*-<"C,-*&'("+:")(2&"2',(-?"1&0("/'*%&/"(&@&2+8")*<"C:"1&"'/&",+*"*%&"4)>>&-*"(&@&2+8&/"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"1&"'/&"7&/*'),23"*%&"4)>>&-*"2',("4',;<"A+/"-+6&"(&@&2+8&/-?"*%&)/"8/+42&6")-?"1%&/&"*+"453"2',(":+/"*%&6"*+"(&@&2+8<"d5/"8/+42&6")-"1&"%'@&"-+"6',3"2',(-?"1%)7%"+,&"-%+52("1&"(&@&2+8":)/-*<"_)>%*["k5-*")6'>),&"1&"%'@&"+,&"*%+5-',("%&7*'/&-?")*"1)22"*';&"3+5"#L"+/"ZL"3&'/-"*+"(&@&2+8"*%'*<"A+/"I5-*"+,&"8/+I&7*<"P&22?"1&"%'@&"!Z"8/+I&7*-"/)>%*",+1<""O&*"6+-*"/&'2"&-*'*&"(&@&2+8&/-"(+",+*"%'@&"*%&"25H5/3"+:"+1,),>"*%&"

8/+8&/*3"*%&3"'/&"'**&68*),>"*+"45)2("58+,<"=,2);&"2'/>&"2',("+1,),>"7+,>2+6&/'*&-"2);&"E3'2'?"_+4),-+,-?"+/"i57)+"$',?"-6'22&/"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+68',)&-"'/&",+*"+,23":+/7&("*+"'**/'7*"-8&752'*)@&"7'8)*'2"),@&-*6&,*-"*+"85/7%'-&"2',("',("7+66&,7&"

Page 65: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

M`"

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f"

"P&22"-5/&?"*%+-&"A)2)8),+-"1%+"1+/;"),"F+,>"l+,>"+/"B'5()"E/'4)'"'-"%+5-&%+2("%&28&/-?"+:"7+5/-&"*%&3"7',,+*"'::+/("*%&-&"%)>%972'--"8/+I&7*-<"N5*"):"1&0/&"*'2;),>"'4+5*"A)2)8),+-"1+/;),>"),"*%&"=<B<"P&22?"-+"6',3"+:"*%&6"'/&"1+/;),>"),"*%&"6&()7'2":)&2("/)>%*["V5/-&-"',("*%+-&";),(<"$%&-&"A)2)8),+-"'/&"*%&"+,&-"1%+"7',"'::+/("*+"2)@&"),"+5/"%)>%972'--"(&@&2+86&,*-<"""

"C(&'2)Y'*)+,-"+:"*%&"2):&-*32&"2&("43"A)2)8),+-"-&**2),>"),"*%&"=<B<"',("*%&)/":),',7)'2"-577&--"'/&"43",+1"(&8)7*&("),"&@&/3":+/6"+:"D%)2)88),&"6&()'?"(&-7/)4&("),"8+852'/"2)*&/'*5/&"',("2'4+/"4/+;&/),>"6',5'2-?"',("/&2'3&("+@&/"(),,&/"*'42&"7+,@&/-'*)+,-<bZ"d:*&,"*)6&-?"A)2)8),+"6)>/',*-"*%&6-&2@&-"'/&">5)2*3"+:"8&/8&*5'*),>"*%&":+2;2+/&"+:"2)@),>"),"*%&"=<B<?">2+--),>"+@&/"*%&)/"%'/(-%)8-?"'-"'"1'3"+:"7+665,)7'*),>"*%&)/"-577&--&-"',("4/),),>"%+,+/"*+"*%&)/":'6)2)&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<".@&,"-*'*)-*)7-"*';&,":/+6"*%&"=<B<"K&,-5-"',("+*%&/"('*'"8'),*"'"8)7*5/&"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"'-"Q6+(&2"6),+/)*)&-R"1%+-&"2'/>&/"'7%)&@&6&,*-"'-"',"&*%,)7"6),+/)*3"),"*%&"=<B"&@&,"+5*1&)>%"*%&)/"1%)*&"E6&/)7',"7+5,*&/8'/*-<bb""

.@&,"'-"'"/&-)(&,*"2)@),>"),"*%&"=<B<":+/"+@&/"*1+"(&7'(&-?"D'-75'2"%)6-&2:?":+/"),-*',7&?"&682+3-"('*'"+,"&682+36&,*"-*'*)-*)7-"',("&(57'*)+,'2"'**'),6&,*?"'-"&@)(&,7&"*+"8/+I&7*"A)2)8),+-"'-")(&'2"7',()('*&-":+/"8/+8&/*3"),@&-*6&,*-"*+"(&@&2+8&/-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"E--&/*),>"*%'*"Q*%&"'@&/'>&"',,5'2":'6)23"),7+6&"+:"A)2)8),+-"E6&/)7',-")-"jML?LLL?"1%)7%")-"'26+-*"*1)7&"'-"657%"'-"*%&":'6)23"),7+6&"+:"*%&"*+*'2"E6&/)7',"),7+6&"+:"jZb?bLLR?"D'-75'2"'/>5&-"*%'*"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"Q>&,&/'223"&,I+3"-*'42&"2)@&2)%++("',(?"),"6+-*"7'-&-?"%+2("6+/&"*%',"+,&"I+4R"W!cX<"D'-75'2":')2-"*+"6&,*)+,"*%'*"+:*&,"*)6&-"*%&"%)>%"7+-*"+:"2)@),>"),"*%&"=<B<"7+68&2-"6+-*"A)2)8),+-"*+"2++;":+/"652*)82&"I+4-<"$%&"'5*%+/0-"72')6"'2-+"7+,7&'2-"*%&"()-8'/)*)&-"+:"),7+6&"+:"()::&/&,*"A)2)8),+-"1%+"'/&"&682+3&("1)*%),"@'/)+5-"2&@&2-"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""bZ"B&&"$'()'/?"9/#$/:3!;%&'()$*&#:?"#LLb<""bb"B&&"N+,5-?"N&)/$*#8!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#:?"#LLL<""

Page 66: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

Mc"

+:"*%&"=<B<"2'4+/"6'/;&*<"$%&,"*%&/&")-"*%&"6+/&"/&7&,*"8/+42&6"+:"+@&/"7+,-568*)+,"',("7/&()*"()2&66'-"'-"&@)(&,7&("43"*%&",564&/"+:"%+6&":+/&72+-5/&-"&H8&/)&,7&("43"A)2)8),+-"*%/+5>%+5*"K'2):+/,)'"',("*%&"B+5*%1&-*"()-75--&("&'/2)&/<"D'-75'20-"@)&1-?"-%'/&("43"'",564&/"+:"/&'2"&-*'*&"&H&75*)@&-?"8&/8&*5'*&-"'"7+66+,23"%&2("8&/7&8*)+,"*%'*"*%&"6&/&":'7*"*%'*"'"A)2)8),+"2)@&-"),"*%&"=<B<"&U5'*&-"*+"*%&6"-+6&%+1"4&),>":)-7'223"-&75/&<""

B57%")(&'2)Y'*)+,-"'/&"),*/),-)7"*+"*%&"8&/:+/6',7&"+:"'88&'/',7&",&&(&("*+"7+68&2"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"*+"),@&-*"),"2'/>&9-7'2&"8/+8&/*3"(&@&2+86&,*-<"

".@&/3+,&"%&/&";,+1-"*%'*"'"(+6&-*)7"1+/;&/"),"*%&"=<B<"7',"6';&"!L"*)6&-"6+/&"*%',"1%'*"*%&3"1+52("6';&"%&/&<"F+1"657%"6+/&",5/-&-?"(+7*+/-?"',("&,>),&&/-["$%&3"6';&"*%&)/"%+6&-"),"*%&"=<B<"$%&">+'2":+/"5-")-"*+",+1"7+,@),7&"*%&6"*%'*"*%&3"7',"6';&"*%&)/"%+6&"%&/&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*++?""

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

C,"*%&"7'-&"+:"K'/2+-?"%&"1'-"+,&"+:"'"%',(:52"+:"/&'2"&-*'*&"&H&75*)@&-"1%+"1&/&"8/)@3"*+"*%&"(')23"82)>%*"+:"6+-*"E6&/)7',-?"2&*"'2+,&"A)2)8),+")66)>/',*-?"1%+"&H8&/)&,7&"()::)752*)&-"),"8'3),>":+/"*%&)/"%+6&-"),"*%&"=<B<"',("6';),>"'"2)@),>"),"*%&"),*&,-&23"7+68&*)*)@&"=<B<"2'4+/"6'/;&*<"P%&,"7+68'/&("*+"*%&"8+*&,*)'2":+/":),',7)'2"),@&-*6&,*"'77/5&("43"6+-*"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%+1&@&/?"),"*%&"6),("+:"*%&-&"&H&75*)@&-?"*%&")(&'"',("8/+6)-&"+:"*%&"-+97'22&("Qj#a"4)22)+,"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"6'/;&*R"'88&'/-"'26+-*"2)6)*2&--"',("5,:&**&/&(<"C*"1'-"*%&"8&/:+/6',7&"+:"*%&-&"'88&'/',7&-?"7+582&("43"*%&"),7/&'-),>",564&/"+:"8/+8&/*3"85/7%'-&-"6'(&"43"4'2);4'3',-?"*%'*"&@&,*5'223"2&("*+"'"-5/>&"+:"8/+8&/*3"(&@&2+86&,*"*'/>&*),>"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"/&*)/&&-"),"*%&"2'-*"(&7'(&<"E3'2'"i',("C,7+/8+/'*&("2'5,7%&("E3'2'"i',("C,*&/,'*)+,'2"B'2&-"C,7+/8+/'*&("),"&'/23"#LLM"*+"7'*&/"&H725-)@&23"*+"dAP-"',("8&/6',&,*"&6)>/',*-?"8'/*)752'/23"8/+:&--)+,'2-"',("/&*)/&&-"4'-&("),"*%&"=<B<"',(".5/+8&<"

"B)6)2'/23?"*%&"N/)**',3"K+/8+/'*)+,"(&@+*&("-54-*',*)'2"/&-+5/7&-"*+"1+/;),>"1)*%"=B94'-&("/&'2*3":)/6-"',(":),',7)'2"82',,&/-"),"+/(&/"*+">'),"'"(&&8&/">/'-8"+:"*%&"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"6'/;&*<"$%&"438/+(57*"+:"*%&-&"7+22'4+/'*)+,-"1'-"'":+75-"+,"Q8'*/)+*)7"),@&-*6&,*-R"),"+/(&/"*+"7+68&2"A)2)8),+-"1%+"2+,>"*+"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"

Page 67: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

eL"

D%)2)88),&-<"C,":'7*?"'22"+:"*%&"6'I+/"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'@&"'"(&@&2+86&,*"-&7*+/"(&@+*&("*+"4'2);4'3',-"+/"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"/&*)/&&-<""

"=/>3-!;#!?0+3+::+$-!,-/3!@.%/%-!9'&:'&/%+'$.!A0'!0/B-!:&'C-*%.!.:-*+7+*/335!%/&4-%+$4!D+3+:+$'!EF-&+*/$!G)5-&.!!

J&@&2+8&/" S'),"i+7'*)+,p-" S'),"K'*&>+/3" y"A)29E6"N53&/-"

_+4),-+,0-"i',(" S&*/+"S',)2'" K+,(+6),)56-" MLy"

B*'/2',("D/+8&/*)&-"C,7<"

B54)7" _&*)/&6&,*"G)22'-" `Ly"

N/)**',3"K+/8<" V'*)+,1)(&"i+*-?"F+5-&"',("i+*-?"K+,(+-"

MLy"

J<d<"D2'Y'".-*'*&-" D'/'T'U5&" F+5-&"',("i+*-" ZLy"

S&>'1+/2(" S&*/+"S',)2'" K+,(+6),)56-" !Ly"

!

6')&*-!;#!H=/$I!,-/3!@.%/%-!G)5-&!?&'7+3-!/$(!G-0/B+'&J!K-3:.!5')!)$(-&.%/$(!%0-!'B-&.-/.!D+3+:+$'!A'&L-&.M!>)5-&!>-0/B+'&I!<NNOPI!:#!;Q!

"O&5-!9&%-)0&:(%-:!/#'!6(0$*F/)-$-'!<&0-:!&F!9*0*7*#&!<-/0$&%:!

"$%&"2',>5'>&"+:"/&*5/,":+/"6+-*"A)2)8),+-"*&,(-"*+"2),>&/"),"'64)@'2&,7&<"$%&"

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

$/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*-"',("4/+;&/-"'/&",+*"+,23"4&-&*"1)*%"*%&"*'-;"+:"7+,@),7),>"A)2)8),+-"*+"6+@&"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"*&68*),>"*%&)/"7+68'*/)+*-"1)*%"6+(&/,"7+,@&,)&,7&-?":'6)2)'/"7+6:+/*-?"',("*%&"+8*)6)-*)7":&/@+/"&H5(&("43")6'>&"':*&/")6'>&"+:"*%&"*/',-:+/6),>"2',(-7'8&"+:"*%&)/"%+6&2',("(&8)7*&("+,"4/+7%5/&-"',("8+1&/"8+),*-<"$%&"6+/&"()::)752*"7%'22&,>&")-"*+"7+68&2"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"*%'*"

Page 68: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

e!"

*%&"2):&"*%'*"*%&3"%'("45)2*":+/"*%&6-&2@&-"),"*%&"=<B<?"*%&)/":/)&,(-"',("7+665,)*3?"8+*&,*)'2"8/+:&--)+,'2"+88+/*5,)*)&-?"',("%+6&-"'/&"7&/*'),23"1+/*%"2&'@),>"4&%),(<""

B&22),>"',("2&'@),>"+,&0-"%+6&")-"8&/%'8-"*%&"6+-*"@)@)("&H'682&"(&8)7*),>"*%&"7+682&H)*)&-"*)&("*+"*%&"(&7)-)+,"+:"/&*5/,<"J5/),>"*%&"&'/23"8'/*"+:"*%&"&7+,+6)7"7/)-)-"'/+5,("#LLe9#LLa"%+1&@&/?"4&-&*"1)*%"7+68+5,(),>"(&4*?"/&7&,*"2'3"+::-?"',("+:*&,"2'7;),>"*%&";,+12&(>&"+:"'2*&/,'*)@&-?"6',3"A)2)8),+-"%'("2)**2&"7%+)7&"45*"*+"2&'@&"*%&)/"%+6&-<"B+6&":+5,("/&:5>&"),"*&68+/'/3"2)@),>"-)*5'*)+,-"1)*%"+*%&/"/&2'*)@&-"+/":/)&,(-<"d*%&/-"'4/58*23"/&*5/,&("*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"C,"*%&"6)(-*"+:"*%&"7/)-)-?"2+7'2"A)2)8),+"/&'2*+/-"1&/&"5,)U5&23"8+-)*)+,&("*+"'--)-*"A)2)8),+-"1%+"1&/&"-*/5>>2),>"*+";&&8"%+2("+:"*%&)/"%+6&-"',("2'7;&("*%&";,+12&(>&"'/+5,("*%&)/"4'-)7"8/+8&/*3"/)>%*-?"%+1"*+")682&6&,*"*%&-&"/)>%*-?"',("*%&"@'/)+5-"1'3-"),"+/(&/"*+",'@)>'*&"'/+5,("*%&"2+--"+:"*%&)/"%+6&-"',("+*%&/"'--&*-<"E-"-57%?"A)2)8),+"/&'2*+/-"8/+@)(&("@'/)+5-":5,7*)+,-"',("+8&/'*&("'2+,>"-&@&/'2"7'8'7)*)&-f"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*-"',("4/+;&/-?"2&>'2"'(@)-+/-"',("'(@+7'*&-?"',("&6+*)+,'2"7+5,-&2+/-<""

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`g"G'-)235;"#LL`X<"_'*&-"+:":+/&72+-5/&-"1&/&"/&:2&7*&("),"*%/&&"+*%&/"7)*)&-"*%'*"1&/&"7+68+-&("2'/>&23"43"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*)&-<"E2+,>"1)*%"J'23"K)*3?"B*+7;*+,"',("G'22&I+?"'22"7)*)&-"),"K'2):+/,)'?"i'-"G&>'-"%'("*%&"%)>%&-*",564&/"+:"%+6&":+/&72+-5/&-":/+6"#LLa"*)22"*%&"&,("+:"#LLc<"bM""

$%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"7/)-)-"',("-54-&U5&,*"%+6&":+/&72+-5/&-"7/&'*&("'"-6'22"1),(+1"+:"+88+/*5,)*3":+/"'"-6'22",564&/"+:"/&'2*+/-"1%+"1&/&"7'8'42&"+:"1&'*%&/),>"*%&"+42)*&/'*),>"7/'-%"+:"*%&"2'/>&/"/&'2"&-*'*&"),(5-*/3<"J5/),>"#LLa?"8/+8&/*3"8/)7&-"4&>',"*+"U5)7;23"82566&*"*+"'"8+),*"1%&,"*%&"@'25&"+:"6+-*"%+6&-"1+52("(/+8"*+"+,&9%'2:"*+"+,&9*%)/("+:"*%&"8/)7&"*%'*"%+6&+1,&/-"%'("+/)>),'223"85/7%'-&("*%&6<"_&'2*+/-?"*%+-&"1%+"+8&/'*&("),"4+*%"2'/>&/":)/6-"+/"),(&8&,(&,*23?":+5,(")*",&'/23")68+--)42&"*+"-&22"*%&"%+6&-"+:"*%&)/"72)&,*-"',("4&*1&&,"#LLa"',("#LL`?"*%&"%+5-),>"6'/;&*"1'-"'*"-57%"'":/'>)2&"-*'*&?"*%'*"8+*&,*)'2"%+6&"453&/-?"%+8),>"*+"-&)Y&"*%&"+88+/*5,)*3"+:"*%&"-8)/'2),>"8/)7&-?"/&6'),&("*&,*'*)@&<""

.(,'?"1%+"'//)@&("*+"*%&"=<B<"'-"'"4)+97%&6)-*"',("1+/;&("'*"'"2'4"),"D'2+"E2*+":+/"'26+-*"*1+"(&7'(&-?"%'("+,23"/&7&,*23"4&>5,"1+/;),>"'-"'"/&'2*+/"',("&@&,"2&--"'-"'":5229*)6&"'>&,*<"O&*?"-%&":+5,("*%'*"%&/">/&>'/)+5-"()-8+-)*)+,"',("%&/";,'7;":+/":),',7&-"&'-)23"7+682&6&,*&("'"8/+:&--)+,"),"-'2&-?"8'/*)752'/23"),"*%&"-'2&"+:"8/+8&/*3<"_'*%&/"*%',"*%/+1),>"),"*%&"*+1&2"+,"%&/",&19:+5,("8'--)+,?".(,'"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""bM"P)*%"'"8+852'*)+,"+:"!Le?LLL?"J'23"K)*3"%'("##`"8/+8&/*)&-"),"(&:'52*"',("##!"),"4',;"+1,&/-%)8"+/"58":+/"'57*)+,<"

Page 69: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

e#"

),@&-*&("6+/&"6+,&3"),"*/'@&2),>"*+"/&'2*3"7+,:&/&,7&-"),"i'-"G&>'-?"D'26"B8/),>-?"',("'-":'/"'-"A2+/)'<".@&,*5'223".(,'"/&'2)Y&("*%'*"%&/",+*+/)&*3"),"*%&"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*3"8/+@)(&("%&/"1)*%"'"8'/*)752'/",)7%&?"-%&"),*&>/'*&(",&1"-*/'*&>)&-"*+"6'/;&*),>"%&/-&2:<"E:*&/"-%&"-577&--:5223"-+2("'":/)&,(0-"%+6&"),"=,)+,"K)*3?"+*%&/":/)&,(-"',("()-*',*"/&2'*)@&-"),"*%&"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*3"4&>',"'-;),>"%&/":+/"'(@)7&"',("-+2)7)*),>"%&/"-&/@)7&-<"C*"4&7'6&"'88'/&,*"*%'*"6+/&"',("6+/&?"A)2)8),+-"1&/&"&H8&/)&,7),>"-)6)2'/"%+5-),>"8/+42&6-<""

"C,"*%&":)/-*"U5'/*&/"+:"#LL`?"C"1'-"-+"&H7)*&("*+"(+"*%)-<"N&7'5-&"1&"%'@&"72)&,*-"1%+"7+6&"),"'/&"-+"()-*/&--&("'/&">+),>"%+6&"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"E,("*%&-&"72)&,*-"'/&"-+"8'/',+)(<"$%&3"(+,0*";,+1"1%'*"*+"(+<"$%&3"%'@&"4',;-"1%+"'/&"7+,-*',*23"7'22),>"*%&6"',("*%&3"(+,0*";,+1"1%'*"*+"(+<""

"E-".(,'"4&>',"/&7+5,*),>"'"-&/)&-"+:"-*+/)&-?"(&*')2),>"*%&"&H8&/)&,7&-"+:"A)2)8),+-"1%+"1&/&"+,"*%&"4/),;"+:"2+-),>"*%&)/"%+6&-?")*"4&7'6&"72&'/"*+"6&"1%3"-%&"1'-"7'8'42&"+:"8&/-)-*),>"1%)2&"*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"),(5-*/3"'/+5,("%&/"1'-":'22),>"*+"8)&7&-<"F&/"&3&-">2)-*&,&("1)*%"-),7&/)*3"',("%&/"@+)7&"7/'7;&("4&,&'*%"%&/"1+/(-"'-"-%&"-8+;&"*+"6&"'4+5*"%&/"72)&,*<"C*"1'-"'88'/&,*"*%'*".(,'":&2*"7+68&22&("*+"8/+*&7*"',(">5)(&"*%+-&"A)2)8),+-"1%+"1&/&"6+-*"@52,&/'42&"(5/),>"*%)-"7/)-)-<""""

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

"C,(&&(?",+*"'22"A)2)8),+"/&'2*+/-"&H8&/)&,7&("*%&"-'6&"2&@&2"+:"'2*/5)-6<"

D/&('*+/3"2&,(&/-"1+/;&("*+>&*%&/"1)*%"'",564&/"+:"+88+/*5,)-*)7"A)2)8),+"/&'2*+/-"*+"*';&"6+/&"'(@',*'>&"+:"A)2)8),+-"1%+"1&/&",+*"+,23"),"(',>&/"+:"2+-),>"*%&)/"%+6&-"4&7'5-&"+:"-5498/)6&"6+/*>'>&-"+/"I+4"2+-&-?"45*"*%&-&"8'/*)752'/"A)2)8),+"

Page 70: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

eZ"

/&'2*+/-"8/+6)-&("*%&)/"72)&,*-"*+"%&28"'(I5-*"6+/*>'>&-"+/"8/+@)(&"2&>'2"'--)-*',7&"*+":+/&72+-),>"*%&)/"%+6&-":+/"'"8/)7&<be"" $%&"()/&"-)*5'*)+,"&-7'2'*&("*+"-57%"'"8+),*"1%&/&"+,-!9*0*7*#&!D,/##-0"W$AKX"4&>',"%+-*),>"'"-&/)&-"+,"*%&"QA)2)8),+":+/&72+-5/&"7/)-)-R<"$%&"-8&7)'2"-&/)&-"*)*2&("QD'3+,>"l'8'6)23'"-'"A+/&72+-5/&R"1'-"%+-*&("43"*%&"7%',,&20-",&1-"-%+1"N'2)*',>"E6&/)7'"),"#LLc<"C,"'"7%'/'7*&/)-*)7'223"+@&/"*%&"*+8"',("+@&/"-&,-'*)+,'2)Y&("6',,&/?"*%&",&1-"-%+1"4&>),-"1)*%"65-)7"),*&,(&("*+"&H5(&"'"-)*5'*)+,"+:"8',)7"',("%3-*&/)'<"A+/",+"&H82)7'42&"/&'-+,?"'"7'6+5:2'>&("@+)7&"/&'(-"+5*"2+5("QA'7*f"e"+:"*%&"*+8"7)*)&-"1+/-*"%)*"43":+/&72+-5/&-"'/&"),"K'2):+/,)'?":+22+1&("43"i'-"G&>'-?"_&,+?"V&@'('?"D%+&,)H"E/&'"),"E/)Y+,'"',("K'8&"K+/'2"E/&'"),"A2+/)('R<"A')*%"N'5*)-*'?"D/&-)(&,*"+:"S'45%'3"E22)',7&?"'2+,>"1)*%"'>&,*-"/&8/&-&,*),>"2+',),>"'>&,7)&-?"1&/&"'-;&("43"'",564&/"+:"U5&-*)+,-"/&>'/(),>"1%'*"8+--)42&"'2*&/,'*)@&-"@)&1&/-"6)>%*"*';&"),"*%&"6)(-*"+:"2+-),>"*%&)/"%+6&-"*+":+/&72+-5/&<""

J&@&2+8),>"-588+/*?"4&>),,),>"1)*%"'",564&/"+:"Q:+/&72+-5/&"72),)7-R"%+-*&("),"@'/)+5-"7)*)&-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"=<B<?"*%&"S'45'%'3"E22)',7&"%'("-577&--:5223"'(@+7'*&("/&-)(&,*-"2)@),>"),"*%&"7)*3"+:"G'22&I+?"'"7)*3"*%'*"4+'-*&("*%&"*&,*%"%)>%&-*":+/&72+-5/&"/'*&"),"*%&"7+5,*/3"'*"*%&"*)6&?"*+"82'7&"'"6+/'*+/)56"+,":+/&72+-5/&-"W.%/&,/&)7%?"#LLcX<"$%&"S'45%'3"E22)',7&"1&/&"7'8'42&"+:">'/,&/),>"657%"8+2)*)7'2"'**&,*)+,"*+"*%&"82)>%*"+:"6),+/)*)&-?"8'/*)752'/23"A)2)8),+-?"&H8&/)&,7),>"%+6&":+/&72+-5/&-"*%'*"),"&'/23"#LLc"*%'*?"*+>&*%&/"1)*%"V'*)+,'2"A&(&/'*)+,"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"E--+7)'*)+,-"WV'AAEEX?"6&64&/-"-577&--:5223"6&*"1)*%"*%&"2&'(),>"6&64&/-"+:"*%&"d4'6'"'(6),)-*/'*)+,":),',7&"'(@)-+/-?"),725(),>"A&(&/'2"_&-&/@&"K%')/6',"N&,"N&/,',;&?"A&(&/'2"J&8+-)*"C,-5/',7&"K%')/1+6',?"B%&)2'"N')/?"B&7/&*'/3"+:"$/&'-5/3?"$)6+*%3"h&)*%,&/"',("F+5-&"A),',7)'2"B&/@)7&-"K+66)**&&"K%')/6',?"N'/,&3"A/',;"WE-)',"k+5/,'2?"#LLcX<"N+*%"+/>',)Y'*)+,-"6&*"1)*%"'(6),)-*/'*)+,"6&64&/-"*+"-5>>&-*"-+25*)+,-"*+"*%&":+/&72+-5/&"7/)-)-"*%/+5>%"*%&)/"7+22&7*)@&"&H8&/)&,7&-"'-"'(@+7'*&-":+/"%+6&+1,&/-"',("'-"/&'2"&-*'*&"8/+:&--)+,'2-<"""

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ba""

d*%&/"A)2)8),+"/&'2*+/-"%'@&"'(+8*&("6+/&"7/&'*)@&"-*/'*&>)&-"),"+/(&/"*+"-5882&6&,*"*%&)/"-'2&-"+/"*/',-:+/6"*%&)/"6'/;&*),>"-*/'*&>3"&,*)/&23<"i);&"*%&"8'/*"%+-*&("43".2&',+/"E758',>"),"J'23"K)*3?"+*%&/"A)2)8),+"/&'2*+/-"),"*%&"=<B<"%'@&"*';&,"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""be"J5/),>"*%&"8'-*"*%/&&"3&'/-?"*%&/&"%'@&"4&&,"'"-2&1"+:"7'-&-"),@+2@),>"A)2)8),+"/&'2"&-*'*&"4/+;&/-"',("'>&,*-"(&:/'5(),>"+*%&/"A)2)8),+"%+6&453&/-<"d,&"+:"*%&"6+/&"%)>%23"8542)7)Y&("7'-&-"),@+2@&(""ba"S&',1%)2&?"%+6&+1,&/-"'/&"'42&"*+"6)*)>'*&"*%&"('6'>&"*+"*%&)/"7/&()*"%)-*+/3"',("8'/*)'223"7+,*/+2"*%&"(&4*<"E2-+?"-%+/*"-'2&-"'/&"5-5'223":'-*&/"',("2&--"&H8&,-)@&"*%',":+/&72+-5/&-<"C*"(+&-",+*"&H*),>5)-%"*%&"/&6'),),>"4'2',7&"5,2&--"*%&)/"'>/&&6&,*"1)*%"*%&"2&,(&/"72&'/23"),()7'*&-")*"+,"*%&"'77&8*',7&"+:"+::&/<"

Page 71: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

eb"

+,"6+/&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"'88/+'7%&-"*+"*%&"-&22),>"+:"/&'2"&-*'*&<"_+'(-"-%+1-"%'@&"4&7+6&"'"7+66+,":'7&*"+:"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"),(5-*/3<".'7%"D%)2)88),&"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,"*'/>&*),>"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"(&@+*&-"'"-)>,):)7',*"'6+5,*"+:":),',7&-"+,"'(@&/*)-),><"d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i&)-5/&")-"'"7+66+,"*%&6&"),"D%)2)88),&"/&'2"&-*'*&"'(-<"E775-*+6&("*+"%&'/),>"'4+5*"*%&"(&6',(),>"8'7&"+:"2):&"),"*%&"=<B<?"*%&"/&'2*+/":/+6"N/)**',3"7+,*),5+5-23"&@+;&("),*)6'*&"',("/+6',*)7")6'>&-"+:":'6)23"6&64&/-":),'223"4&),>"'42&"*+"-8&,("*)6&"1)*%"*%&)/":'6)2)&-<"D)7*5/&-"+:"*)/&"-1),>-"',("*%/&&9-*+/3"1++(&,"6',-)+,-"7/&'*&("',"&,@)/+,6&,*"/&6),)-7&,*"+:"*%&"82'7&-":+/"1%)7%"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*"1'-"*+"4&",'6&("m"h&+/>)'"K254"),"E5>5-*'"B',*'"_+-'<"$%&"8/&-&,*'*)+,"&68%'-)Y&("*%&"7&,*/'2"2+7'*)+,"+:"*%&"-++,"*+"4&"45)2*"(&@&2+86&,*f"

"h&+/>)'"K254")-"'"7&,*/'2"(&@&2+86&,*"),"*%&":'-*"&6&/>),>"),(5-*/)'2"%54"+:"*%&"B+5*%<"C*")-"72+-&"*+"8/&6)&/"/&7/&'*)+,'2"(&-*),'*)+,-9:/+6"*%&"*+8">+2("7+5/-&"*+"*%&"7++2"6+5,*'),"/&*/&'*-"+:"$'>'3*'3"',("*%&"),@)*),>"4&'7%&-"+:"N'*',>'-<"$%&"7+5,*/30-":+/&6+-*"'7'(&6)7"),-*/57*)+,-"'/&"'2-+"72+-&"43?"),725(),>"*%&"bM9%&7*'/&"7'685-"+:"*%&"=,)@&/)-*3"+:"B'),*+"$+6'-<"_)>%*",&'/43?"D'-&+"(&"B',*'"_+-'?"*%&"7+66&/7)'2"7&,*&/"4/),>-"*+>&*%&/"/&-*'5/',*-?"4'/-?"-%+8-"',("+*%&/"2):&-*32&"&-*'42)-%6&,*-<""

".66'"E/',&*'?"*%&"/&'2*+/"8/&-&,*),>"*+"',"'5()&,7&"+:"Z#"A)2)8),+-"',("'"%',(:52"+:",+,9A)2)8),+-?")*&/'*&("*%&"(&-7/)8*)+,-"+:"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*"'-"):"%'@),>"6&6+/)Y&(")*":/+6"*%&"4/+7%5/&"),"63"%',(-<"i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z',(",+*"),"*%&"=<B<{<R"$%&"U5'-)98/+:&--)+,'2"

Page 72: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

eM"

/&2'*)+,-%)8"*%'*".66'"%'-"1)*%"%&/":'6)23"6&64&/-")-"),()7'*)@&"+:"',"),7/&'-),>23"7/&'*)@&",&*1+/;"+:"A)2)8),+"/&'2*+/-"1%+"7+,*),5'223"7+22'4+/'*&"'6+,>-*"&'7%"+*%&/"4&*1&&,"*%&"=<B<"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"""" $%)-">/+1),>",&*1+/;"+:"/&'2*+/-"',("/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-")-"(&@+*&("*+"7+,,&7*),>"453&/-"),"*%&"=<B<"1)*%"8/+8&/*3"),@&-*6&,*-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"E2+,>"1)*%"(&@&2+8&/-"1%+"+8&/'*&"1)*%"'-"6',"'-"*1&,*3"),*&/,'*)+,'2"-'2&-9+::)7&-":+75-&("+,"-&22),>"*+"dAP-?"7+/8+/'*)+,-"'/&"),7/&'-),>"*%&)/"8/&-&,7&"),"*%&"=<B<"',("(&@&2+8),>"&2'4+/'*&"-*/'*&>)&-"*+">/'4"%+2("+:"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2*3"6'/;&*"),"*%&"=<B<".(1'/("$',")225-*/'*&-"*%&"7+66+,"'7*)@)*)&-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2*3",&*1+/;-f""

F'@),>"-'2&-"',("6'/;&*),>"+::)7&-"'4/+'("1)*%"/&>52'/"'7*)@)*)&-"*%&/&?"%'@),>"*%&)/"+1,"/&>52'/"/+'("-%+1"8/&-&,*'*)+,-"),"-&2&7*&("7+5,*/)&-?"7++/(),'*),>"',("%'@),>"7+,,&7*)+,-"1)*%"A)2)8),+"/&'2*3"+/>',)Y'*)+,"'4/+'(?"'(@&/*)-),>"),"*%&"6'),"4/+'(-%&&*-"4+*%"),"*%&"8%3-)7'2",&1-8'8&/"',("*%&"C,*&/,&*?"82'7),>"'(-"),"-8&7)'2)Y&("dAP",&1-8'8&/-"',(p+/"A)2)8),+",&1-8'8&/-"'4/+'(?"U5+*),>"(+22'/"'6+5,*-"*+"-&22"*%&)/"8/+I&7*-"),"*%&)/"1&48'>&?"82'7),>"'(-"),"@'/)+5-"dAP"1&4"8'>&-?"%'@),>"*%&)/"+1,"7'22"7&,*&/-?"&H%)4)*-"'*"*%&"(5*3":/&&"-%+8-"',("I+),),>"/&>52'/"),*&/,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&":')/-"+/>',)Y&("43"*%&"K%'64&/"+:"_&'2".-*'*&"',("N5)2(&/-0"E--+7)'*)+,-?"C,7<"WK_.NEX"C,*&/,'*)+,'2"A+5,('*)+,?"C,7<"W#LLa?"bcX<"

"k+),),>"),"/&'2*3"'--+7)'*)+,-"2);&"K_.NE"8/+@)(&-"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"*%&"+88+/*5,)*3"*+"8'/*)7)8'*&"),"',,5'2"/+'("-%+1-"+/>',)Y&("),"7)*)&-"2);&"$+;3+?"i+,(+,?"',("i+-"E,>&2&-?"8'/*)752'/23":+/"2'/>&/"7+/8+/'*)+,-<"B57%"'--+7)'*)+,-"8/+@)(&"'"-8&752'*)@&"&(>&"*+"2'/>&/"7+/8+/'*)+,-"-),7&"6&64&/-%)8-":&&-"'/&"+:*&,"*++"4&3+,("*%&"45(>&*"+:"-6'22&/"(&@&2+8&/-<"i'/>&/"7+/8+/'*)+,-"'/&"7'8'42&"+:"1/)*),>"+::"*%&"/)-;"+:"2+-),>"8/+-8&7*-"+/"4&),>"5,'42&"*+">'),":),',7)'2"7+66)*6&,*-":/+6"453&/-<"B6'22&/"(&@&2+8&/-?"&'>&/"*+":),("'"8+-)*)+,"1)*%),"*%&"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"6'/;&*?"'/&"2)6)*&("*+"I+),),>"2+7'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"&H%)4)*-"+/"82'7),>"'(-"),"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',",&1-8'8&/-<"P%)2&"2+7'2"-%+1-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"7+-*"4&*1&&,"DZM?LLL"W=BJjaeLX"*+"DML?LLL"W=BJj!?LcLX?"8'/*)7)8'*),>"),"/+'("-%+1-"'4/+'("7',"7+-*"&'7%"/&'2*+/"6+/&"*%',"*1)7&"*%'*"'6+5,*<"E77+/(),>"*+"*%&"K_.NE?"6&64&/-%)8":&&-":+/"*%&"P&-*"K+'-*?"=BE"/+'("-%+1":/+6"B&8*&64&/"!e"*+"d7*+4&/"!?"#LLe"7+-*"&'7%"6&64&/"'4+5*"Dc#?LLL"W=BJj#?LLLX":+/":++(?"*'H&-?"4++*%?"8+-*&/-?"',(":23&/-"W$',"#LLMX<"E-".66'"'2/&'(3"(&,+*&(?"*%)-"8/)7&"()(",+*"),725(&"*%&"82',&":')/"+/"*/'@&2"@)-'":&&-":+/"*/'@&2"*+"*%&"=<B<"" "" ".*%'!P&8:!/#'!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!<-/0$3!Q-$>&%1!

"=,2);&"-&@&/'2"A)2)8),+":'6)2)&-"1%+"%'("2+-*"*%&)/"%+6&-"),"*%&"&'/23"1';&"+:"

*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"7/)-)-?"*%/+5>%"'"6)H*5/&"+:":+/&-)>%*"',(":+/*5,&?"*%&"K'/(&,'-"82'7&("*%&)/"*1+9-*+/3"45,>'2+1"),"J'23"K)*3":+/"'"-%+/*"-'2&"/'*%&/"*%',"/)-;),>">/&'*&/":),',7)'2"2+--&-"43"&@&,*5'223":+/&72+-),>"+,"*%&)/"%+6&<"=8+,"6';),>"63"1'3"),*+"*%&"&,*/',7&"',("-*&88),>"),*+"*%&)/":+3&/?"C",+*)7&("*%'*"'8'/*":/+6"'":&1"

Page 73: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ee"

4+H&-"-*'-%&("*+"*%&"-)(&"+:"*%&"2)@),>"/++6"',("*%&"(522"1%)*&"-%&&*-"(/'8&("+@&/"657%"+:"*%&":5/,)*5/&?"*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:"*%&"K'/(&,'-0"8'7;),>"1'-"2&:*":+/"*%&"2'-*"('3-"4&:+/&"*%&3"1+52("6+@&"+5*<"d,&"4+H"),"8'/*)752'/?"8'/*)'223":)22&("1)*%"*%&)/"7%)2(/&,0-"8/)6'/3"-7%++2"3&'/4++;-"',("+2("4&'*"58"*&H*"4++;-?"7/&'*&("',")6'>&"+:"'":'6)23"1%+"1&/&",+*"3&*"7+682&*&23"/&'(3"*+"2&'@&"'"2):&"*%&3"%'("-*/5>>2&("-+"%'/("*+"45)2(<""

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k&::/&3"E4&22'?"1'-"'"7%)2(%++(":/)&,("1%+">/&1"58"1)*%"_+4&/*+"),"E,*)8+2+?"+,&"+:"*%&"@'/)+5-"7)*)&-"7+68+-),>"*%&"8/+@),7&"+:"_)Y'2"4+/(&/),>"*%&"&(>&"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'<"E4&22'"6+@&("1)*%"%)-":'6)23"*+"*%&".'-*"N'3"+:"K'2):+/,)'"',("1+/;&("'-"'"/&'2*+/"),"=,)+,"K)*3"-),7&"*%&"!ccL-<"_&'2*3"7'6&":')/23"&'-)23"*+"E4&22'"-),7&"-&@&/'2"+:"%)-":'6)23"6&64&/-"1+/;&("),"*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"),(5-*/3"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"C,"*%&"&'/23"8'/*"+:"%)-"7'/&&/"'-"'"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*?"E4&22'"1+52("+77'-)+,'223"/&:&/"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"72)&,*-"*+":'6)23"6&64&/-"1%+"7+52("4/+;&/"8/+8&/*3"(&'2-"'/+5,("S',)2'<""

Q$%)-")-"*%&";&3"*+"453),>"8/+8&/*3"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"O+5"%'@&"*+";,+1"3+5/"'>&,*"@&/3"1&22<"C*"%&28-"):"*%&3"'/&"'":'6)23"6&64&/"+/"'":/)&,(?R"_+4&/*+"-')("-*&/,23<"C*"1'-"+,&"+:"*%&":&1"7+66&,*-"*%'*"%&"6'(&"),"-57%"'"-&/)+5-"*+,&<"F)-"7+66&,*"6'(&"&,+/6+5-"-&,-&"),"*%&"7+,*&H*"+:"*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"8/+:&--)+,"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-g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

E4&22'"%'("8/+8+-&("*%'*"_+4&/*+"2++;"),*+"85/7%'-),>"'"%+6&"',("2+*":/+6"'"6&64&/"+:"%)-":'6)23"1%+"-+2("8/+8&/*)&-"),"_)Y'2<"QN53),>"*%&"8/+8&/*3"1'-"-)682&<"

Page 74: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ea"

S';),>"-5/&"*%&"%+5-&"1'-"45)2*"*+"-8&7"1'-"',+*%&/"*%),>"&,*)/&23?Rb`"_+4&/*+"7+,*),5&(<""

"V+*"+,23"1&/&"k&::0-":'6)23"/&-8+,-)42&":+/"*%&"-'2&"45*"*%&3"1&/&"/&-8+,-)42&":+/"2++;),>"+@&/"*%&"7+,-*/57*)+,"+:"*%&"%+6&<"C*"1'-"%'/(&/"*+"(+"*%'*"z-58&/@)-&"k&::0-":'6)23"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-{"*%',"*+"*';&"7'/&"+:"-&22),>"+5/"%+6&"%&/&<"K',"3+5")6'>),&"*%'*["P)*%"*%&"1'3"*%'*"*%&"6'/;&*")-"%&/&["P&"1&/&"257;3"*+">&*"/)("+:"+5/"%+6&"&@&,"):")*"1'-"'*"-57%"'"2+1"8/)7&"45*")*"1'-",+*%),>"7+68'/&("*+"(&'2),>"1)*%"*%&"8/+42&6-"+:"45)2(),>"+5/"%+6&"+@&/"*%&/&<"D++/"k&::"1'-"),"*%&"6)((2&"+:"'22"+:"*%'*<"

"C,(&&(?",+*"+,23"()("E4&22'"%&28"*+"-&22"8/+8&/*3"*+"*%&"K'/(&,'-"),"_)Y'2"45*"%&"+@&/-'1"*%&"-%+/*"-'2&"+:"*%&)/"%+6&"),"J'23"K)*3<"""

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

"$%&"@&/-'*)2&"/&'2"&-*'*&"(&'2),>"7+,(57*&("43"E4&22'"8+),*-"*+"*%&"

),*&/1&'@),>"1&4"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2"2'4+/"8/+(57&("),"*%&">2+4'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"),(5-*/3<"F'@),>"8/+-8&7*)@&"72)&,*-"(&-)/),>"*+"85/7%'-&"8/+8&/*3"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"E4&22'"+77'-)+,'223"8/+@)(&("2&'(-"*+"%)-":'6)23"6&64&/-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("7+,,&7*&("*%&6"1)*%"%)-"72)&,*-"),"*%&"=<B<"E2*%+5>%"E4&22'"1+52(",&@&/"7'22"%)6-&2:"-57%?"%&")-"-::-#$*/003"1%'*"D'-75'2"/&:&/-"*+"'-"'"/&'2"&-*'*&"Q4)/((+>R<"i);&"*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:"A)2)8),+"/&'2*+/-"+8&/'*),>"*%/+5>%+5*"K'2):+/,)'?"D'-75'2"+/)>),'223"1+/;&("5,(&/"'"2'/>&":)/6?"K&,*5/3"#!"',("-+2("8/+8&/*)&-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&">/&'*&/"i+-"E,>&2&-"E/&'"(5/),>"*%&"!c`L-"',("!ccL-<"C*"1'-"*%&"6',,&/"*%/+5>%"1%)7%"D'-75'2"'>>/&--)@&23"*'/>&*&("8/+8&/*)&-"),"'(I+),),>"'/&'-"*%'*"-&*"%)6"'8'/*":/+6"+*%&/"A)2)8),+-<"C,*&>/'2"*+"*%)-"-*/'*&>3"1'-"%)-"/&7/5)*6&,*"',(")682&6&,*'*)+,"+:"Q4)/((+>-R"1%+6"%&"&,7+5/'>&("*+"1+/;"1)*%"+*%&/"'>&,*-"',("&H8',("*%&)/"-'2&-"+5*-)(&"+:"*%&)/"8'/*)752'/"+::)7&"2)-*),>-<""

QA/+6"!c``"*+"!ccb?R"D'-75'2"-'3-?"QC"/&7/5)*&(?"*/'),&("',("6','>&("'"/+45-*"-'2&-">/+58"*%'*"1'-"8/&(+6),',*23"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-<"S+-*"+:"*%&6"'/&",+1"'"8'/*"+:"+5/">/+1),>",&*1+/;"*%'*"(&()7'*&"*%&)/"&::+/*-"),"8/+6+*),>"',("-&22),>"D%)2)88),&"8/+8&/*)&-"*+"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"),"*%&"=<B<R"i);&"*%+-&"%5,*&/"(+>-"1%+":&*7%"8%&'-',*-"':*&/"*%&3"'/&"8257;&(":/+6"*%&"-;3?"/&'2*3"4)/("(+>-"-7+5/":+/"/&'2"&-*'*&-"(&'2-"',("&'/96'/;"*%&6":+/"),@&-*+/-":+/"',"'>/&&(":&&<"$%)-"6&*%+("+:"&682+3),>"'"1)(&23"-8/&'(",&*1+/;"+:"/&'2*+/-"&682+3&("43"D'-75'2")-",+*"5,)U5&"*+"*%&"/&-*"+:"*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"),(5-*/3"45*")-"),":'7*?"'"7+66+,"7+68+,&,*"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""b`"$%&"-)>,):)7',7&"+:"%'@),>"-+6&+,&"*+"2++;"+@&/"*%&"45)2(),>"+:"8/+8&/*)&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1)22"4&"()-75--&("),"657%"6+/&"(&*')2"),"*%&",&H*"7%'8*&/<""

Page 75: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

e`"

*+"7/&'*)@&"8/+8&/*3"-'2&-"6'(&"),7/&'-),>23",&7&--'/3"(5&"*+"*%&"75//&,*"()/&"-*'*&"+:"*%&"),(5-*/3<""" _&7+>,)Y),>"'"8+*&,*)'2"6'/;&*",)7%&"),"*%&"&'/23"!ccL-?"D'-75'2"(&@+*&("%)-"1+/;"*+"-&22),>"D%)2)88),&"8/+8&/*3"*+"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"1%)2&"1+/;),>"'-"',"'77+5,*',*"',("KDE"*+"-5882&6&,*"%)-"),7+6&<"F&"',("%)-"-*'::"4&7'6&"'(&8*"),"*%&"6+-*"6),5*&"/52&-"',("8/+7&(5/&-"/&>'/(),>"&-7/+1"2'1-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-";,+1),>":522"1&22"*%'*"',3"%),*"+:"),7+68&*&,7&"+/"6'2:&'-',7&"1+52("(/)@&"8+*&,*)'2"72)&,*-?"1%+"'/&"'2/&'(3"/&257*',*?"'1'3"7+682&*&23<"""

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`9McX<""

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oN'2);4'3',-"7',"/&'2)Y&"!LL"8&/7&,*"8/+:)*"),"+,&"3&'/?o"72')6-"_&3,'2(+"J5*&/*&?"'"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*"1)*%"_D"J5*&/*&"_&'2*3"),"S',)2'<"J5*&/*&"'('6',*23"4&2)&@&-"*%'*"/&'2"&-*'*&"),"*%&"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1)22"&H8&/)&,7&"'*"2&'-*"'"#L"*+"ZL"8&/7&,*"',,5'2">/+1*%"+@&/"*%&",&H*":)@&"3&'/-<"oA)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"-%+52("2++;"%&/&"*+"),@&-*"',("/&*)/&o"Wl/&):&2-?"#LLcX<"h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

Page 76: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ec"

"QE",&1"7)*3")-"'4+5*"*+"4/&'*%&"2):&"*+"S&*/+"S',)2'0-"-+5*%f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h2+4'2"K)*3"),"A+/*"N+,):'7)+?"*%&"*+1,-%)8"+:".*+,"K)*3"1)22"),725(&"&@&/3"'6&,)*3"8/+@)(&("1)*%),"'"*+5/)-6"()-*/)7*"2);&">+2:"7+5/-&-"',(",'*5/&"8/&-&/@&-"'2+,>"1)*%"*%&"6'22-?"45-),&--"()-*/)7*-?"',("-7%++2-"*%'*"+,&"1+52(":),("'**'7%&("*+"',3"+:"*%&"/&-)(&,*)'2"(&@&2+86&,*-"-8/+5*),>"58"),"S&*/+"S',)2'<"P%'*"'2-+"6';&-".*+,"K)*3"()::&/&,*")-"*%'*")*")-"'26+-*"&,*)/&23"7'*&/&("*+"A)2)8),+"/&*)/&&-?"8'/*)752'/23"*%+-&"7+6),>":/+6"*%&"=<B<"" "" QC,-8)/&("43":'6+5-"2';&-)(&"7+665,)*)&-"+@&/-&'-"-57%"'-\i';&"i'-"G&>'-"),"V&@'('"',("A+-*&/"K)*3"),"K'2):+/,)'?"*+",'6&"'":&1?"B+5*%"i';&"G)22'>&"'*".*+,"K)*3"%'-"6'(&"7+-6+8+2)*',")-2',("2)@),>"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'"/&'2)*3?R"4+'-*-"+,&"8'>&"),"*%&"4/+7%5/&":+2(&/<"$%&"P&-*"P),>"_&-)(&,7&-?")66&()'*&23"-)>,'2),>"*%&"*)*2&"+:"*%&"8+852'/"!ccL-"*&2&@)-)+,"-%+1"+,-!B-:$!B*#8?")-"+,&"+:"*%&"-545/4',"(&@&2+86&,*-"4&),>"45)2*"1)*%),".*+,"K)*3"',("1'-"-8&7):)7'223"6+(&2&("':*&/"@'/)+5-",&)>%4+/%++(-"),"K'2):+/,)'<"_'U5&2"(&"h5Y6',?"',"),*&/,'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*"1)*%".*+,?"&H82'),&("*%'*"""

P&"(&-)>,&("*%)-"':*&/"*%&"P&-*&/,"=,)*&("B*'*&-<"C*0-"4'-)7'223"(&-)>,&("*+"4&"'"*38)7'2"1&-*&/,"%+5-&<"C,":'7*"+5/"6+(&2"%+5-&-"1&/&"'22",'6&("':*&/"=<B<"8/&-)(&,*-<"$%&"%+5-&"6+(&2-"'/&"7'22&("k&::&/-+,?".)-&,%+1&/?"S7l),2&3\*%+-&"'/&"*%&"()::&/&,*";),("+:"%+5-&"6+(&2-<"P&"(&-)>,&("*%&-&"/&-)(&,7&-"*+"6';&"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-":&22"2);&"*%&3"1)22"4&"+1,),>"'"8)&7&"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1%)2&"*';),>"E6&/)7',"1)*%"*%&6<"

"S+/&"'775/'*&23?".*+,"K)*3")-"4&),>"6+(&2&("6+/&"-+"':*&/"*%&"7+,*&68+/'/3?"6'--)@&"&,72'@&9-*32&"/&-)(&,7&-"75//&,*23"4&),>"45)2*"*%/+5>%+5*"N/'Y)2?"C,()'?"l+/&'?"K%),'?"',("+*%&/"7+5,*/)&-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"h2+4'2"B+5*%<bc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d7&',"2);&"S'5)?"h5'6?"A)I)?"N'2)"+/"+*%&/"7&,*&/-"+:"*+5/)-6"2);&"C4)Y'?"N&/65('?"S'2()@&-?"',("S'7'5<"$%&"6+(&2"+:"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""bc"B+6&"&H'682&-"),725(&"W~2@'/&Y9_)@'(522'"#LLag"i&)-7%"#LL#g"B'27&(+"',("$+//&-"#LLbg"K'2(&)/'"#LLLX"

Page 77: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

aL"

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cccX"()-75--&-"*%)-"&'/2)&/"6+(&2"+:">'*&("7+665,)*)&-"*%'*"U5)7;23"&6&/>&("*%/+5>%+5*"S&*/+"S',)2'"(5/),>"*%&"!c`L-"',("cL-<"K+,,&22"()-75--&-"%+1"*%&-&"Q:+/*/&--"&,72'@&-R?"1%)7%"/&:2&7*&("5/4',)Y'*)+,"*/&,(-"),"'",564&/"+:"82'7&-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"h2+4'2"B+5*%"2);&"B'+"D'52+?"N/'Y)2?"1'-"*%&"8%3-)7'2"6',):&-*'*)+,"+:"-+7)'2"()@)-)+,"7/&'*&("43"',H)&*3"',("8'/',+)'"+:"),-&75/)*3"',("7/)6&<ML"C,"%)-"-*5(3"+:"/&'2"&-*'*&"'(@&/*)-),>"),"S',)2'?"K+,,&22"'/>5&-"*%'*"&'7%"+:"*%&"'(@&/*)-&6&,*-"&@+;&("M"7+66+,"*%&6&-f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x5&-*)+,-R"8+-&("*+".*+,"&682+3&&-"43"4'2);4'3',-"7+,-)(&/),>"1%&*%&/"*+"85/7%'-&"8/+8&/*3"),"*%&"B+5*%"i';&"G)22'>&?"'"-54()@)-)+,"72+-&-*"*+"*%&"B+5*%"i5Y+,".H8/&--1'3"',("'(I'7&,*"*+"*%&"-+5*%&/,"8'/*"+:"*%&"2';&<"d,"*%&"2)-*"'/&"7+,7&/,-"7+66+,"*+"6+-*"A)2)8),+-"1%+"%'@&"2)@&("),"S&*/+"S',)2'"/&>'/(),>":2++(),>?"1'*&/"-58823?"',("&@&,",+)-&"8+225*)+,":/+6"*%&":/&&1'3<"$%&/&"'/&"'2-+"U5&-*)+,-"*%'*"'/&"6+/&"8'/*)752'/"*+"*%&"7+,7&/,-"+:"4'2);4'3',-"1%+"%'@&">/+1,"'775-*+6&("*+"*%&)/"%+6&-"),",+,9*/+8)7'2"&,@)/+,6&,*-<""""""""""

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�+"D'52+<"A5/*%&/6+/&?"K'2(&)/'"'/>5&-"*%'*"1%)2&"*%&-&"(&@&2+86&,*-"',("*%&"'(@&/*)-&6&,*-"-&22),>"*%&6"'/&"7+57%&("),"'"2',>5'>&"+:"7/)6&?"*%)-"/%&*+/)7"+:"-&>/&>'*)+,"/&@&'2-"(&&8&/":&'/-"8/+(57&("43"2'/>&/"8+2)*)7'2"8/+7&--&-"+:"-+7)'2"(&6+7/'*)Y'*)+,"4/+5>%*"+,"43">2+4'2)Y'*)+,"',(">2+4'2"8/+>/&--)@&"6+@&6&,*-<"B&&"WK'2(&)/'"#LLLX<"

Page 78: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

a!"

"

""

"P%)2&"7+,7&/,-"'/+5,("6+-U5)*+&-?">'/4'>&"()-8+-'2?"'&/'*)+,?"-1)66),>"8++2-?"'88&'/"+4@)+5-"*+"-+6&?"*%&3"-8&';"*+"'",564&/"+:"+4-*'72&-"*%'*"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2*+/-"7+,:/+,*"1%)2&"'**&68*),>"*+"7+,@),7&"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"*+"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""

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

C,"*%&"4/+7%5/&":+/"*%&"h&+/>)'"K254":+/"),-*',7&?"*%&"(&-7/)8*)+,"+@&/*23"7+665,)7'*&-"*%&"(&-)/&"+:"D%)2)88),&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"*+"-8&7):)7'223"'**/'7*"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"),"*%&"=<B<""

!<"P)22"*%&"1'*&/"4&"'"4/&&(),>">/+58":+/"6+-U5)*+&-[" c<"F+1"1)22"3+5"&,-5/&"'&/'*)+,"+:"*%&"2';&["

#<"P)22"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*"4&"8/+,&"*+":2++(),>?"&-8&7)'223"""(5/),>"*38%++,-["

!L<"P%&/&"1)22"*%&"1'*&/"),"*%&"2';&"7+6&":/+6["

Z<"F+1"1)22"*%&"8+--)4)2)*3"+:"',"+@&/:2+1"4&"'((/&--&([" !!<"F+1"1)22"*%&"1'*&/"()-7%'/>&"-3-*&6":+/"*%&"2';&"1+/;["

b<"P+,0*"*%&"/)@&/"1'*&/"4&"-+5/7&"+:"8+225*)+,[" !#<"P%&/&"1)22"*%&"@)22'>&"1'*&/"-58823"7+6&":/+6["

M<"F+1"1)22"*%&"'775652'*)+,"+:"*++"657%"'2>'&"4&"8/&@&,*&(["

!Z"F+1"1)22"*%&",+)-&"8+225*)+,":/+6"B+5*%"i5Y+,".H8/&--1'3"4&"'((/&--&(["

e<"F+1"1)22"3+5"&,-5/&"*%'*"*%&"1'*&/"),"*%&"2';&"1)22":2+1),>["

!b<"P)22"2+*"+1,&/-"4&"'22+1&("*+"%'@&"-1)66),>"8++2-"),"*%&)/"4'7;3'/(["

a<"P)22"*%&/&"4&"'">'/4'>&"()-8+-'2"8+2)73["!M<"F+1"1)22"*%&"1'*&/"4&"*/&'*&(["P)22"*%&"1'*&/"),"*%&"/)@&/-"4&"*/&'*&("'2-+["

`<"P)22"&/+-)+,"+:"*%&")-2',("',("2';&-)(&"2+*-"+775/[" !e<"P%'*"1)22"4&":+5,("),"*%&"7&,*&/")-2',(["

D+4)&-!<#!RD&-S)-$%35!E.L-(!1)-.%+'$.R!3+.%-(!+$!>&'*0)&-!7'&!@%'$!9+%5!&-/3!-.%/%-!(-B-3':F-$%#!

Page 79: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

a#"

"C*0-"*)6&"*+"7'22"*%)-"7%'/6),>"7+665,)*3"3+5/"%+6&<"E"ZL9%&7*'/&"7+665,)*3"(&-)>,&("*+"/&:2&7*"*%&">/'7)+5-?"72'--)7"'/7%)*&7*5/&"+:"*%&"E6&/)7',"-+5*%<"P)*%")*-",'*5/'223"25-%"2',(-7'8&"+:"-8/'12),>"*/&&-?")*-"),*&/*1),&("8'/;1'3-"',("8&(&-*/)',"8'*%1'3-"*%'*"2),;"*%'*",&)>%4+/%++(?"h&+/>)'"K254"&@+;&-"',")(322)7?"-545/4',"2):&-*32&<"

"QK%'/6),>R?"QE6&/)7',"-+5*%R?"Q-8/'12),>"*/&&-R?"Q)(322)7R?"Q-545/4',"2):&-*32&R"*+>&*%&/"&@+;&")(&'-"',("-&,*)6&,*-"*%'*"'/&"'26+-*"',*)*%&*)7'2"*+"*%&"@)-5'2"2',(-7'8&"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'<"$%&"),@+7'*)+,"+:"*%)-"5,*%),;'42&"1+/2(?"*%&"h&+/>)',"7+5,*/3-)(&"),"S',)2'?"'22+1-"A)2)8),+-"*+"4&>),")6'>),),>"'"D%)2)88),&-"7+682&*&23"5,2);&"*%&"+,&"*%'*"*%&3"2&:*"4&%),("(&7'(&-"'>+<"$%&"7'8*)+,-"(&-7/)4),>"*%&"QS',-)+,-"+:"h&+/>)'"K254R"'/&"I5-*"'-"8/+@+7'*)@&<"QP)*%"1/+5>%*")/+,":&,7&-?"7+2+/:52"-%5**&/-"+,"A/&,7%"1),(+1-?"4/)>%*23"7+2+/&("(++/-?"),@)*),>":/+,*"8+/7%&-?"',("+8&,":2++/"82',-?"$%&"S',-)+,"+:"h&+/>)'"K254")-"'"8&/:&7*"7+64),'*)+,"+:"'/7%)*&7*5/&"-&*"'6)(-*",'*5/&0-"4&'5*3<R"C,@+;),>"'"*&2&@)-)+,92);&")6'>&"+:"*%&"E6&/)7',"B+5*%?"-5-8&,(),>"*%&"/&'(&/"),"*)6&"1)*%"Q1/+5>%*")/+,":&,7&-R"',("Q),@)*),>":/+,*"8+/7%&-R?"*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"'(@&/*)-&6&,*"7/&'*&-"'"1+/2("*%'*")-",+*%),>"2);&"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&,@)/+,6&,*"-5//+5,(),>")*<""

$%&"4/)>%*23"7+2+/&("(&-)>,-"(&8)7*&("),"*%&"4/+7%5/&"'(@&/*)-),>"E5>5-*'"B',*'"_+-'"',("*%&"h&+/>)'"K254"'/&"8'/*"),"8'/7&2"+:"N/)**',30-",&1"6'/;&*),>"7'68')>,"*+"-&22"8/+8&/*3"*+"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<"N/)**',3")-"*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"(&@&2+86&,*"'/6"G)-*'"i',("',("i):&-7'8&-"C,7<?"'"652*),'*)+,'2"7+/8+/'*)+,"*%'*"*+5*-")*-&2:"'-"*%&"2&'(),>"-&22&/"+:"58-7'2&"',("25H5/3"8/+8&/*)&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"K5//&,*23?"h&+/>)'"K254"2+7'*&("),"B',*'"_+-'?"i'>5,'")-"I5-*"+,&"+:":+5/"2'/>&9-7'2&"8/+8&/*3"(&@&2+86&,*-"75//&,*23"4&),>"45)2*"),"8/+@),7&-"'/+5,("S&*/+"S',)2'<"E22"+:"1%)7%"'/&"4&),>"'7*)@&23"6'/;&*&("*+"@'/)+5-"),*&/,'*)+,'2"7+665,)*)&-?"8'/*)752'/23"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<""

E2+,>"1)*%"),5,('*),>"*%&"),*&/,&*"1)*%"'(@&/*)-&6&,*-?"*/',-,'*)+,'2"/&'2*+/-":+75-"657%"+:"*%&)/"'(@&/*)-),>"),"',"'//'3"+:"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',",&1-8'8&/-<"$';&"+,&",&1-8'8&/"'/*)72&"'(@&/*)-),>"',+*%&/"+:"N/)**',30-"/&'2"&-*'*&"(&@&2+86&,*-"8/),*&("),"*%&"8+852'/"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',",&1-8'8&/"*%&";,*0*77*#-!Q->:"W!`"B&8*&64&/"#LLaX<"N/)**',3"N'3?"'"652*)85/8+-&"7+,(+6),)56"(&@&2+86&,*?"72')6-"*+"'::+/(")*-"/&-)(&,*-"QB',"A/',7)-7+"i)@),>"),"S&*/+"S',)2'R"W:)><"#X<"$%&"'5*%+/"'(@&/*)-),>"*%&"3&*"5,45)2*"/&-)(&,*)'2"7+682&H"72')6-"*%'*"'2+,>"1)*%":'7)2)*)&-":+/"45-),&--&-?"N/)**',3"N'3"8/+@)(&-")*-"/&-)(&,*-"1)*%"Q/&*')2?"7254%+5-&-?"-&/@)7&("'8'/*6&,*-"',("*%&"2);&?"7/&'*),>"'"2)@&982'3"2):&-*32&R<"P%)2&"*%&"h&+/>)'"K254"7'*&/-"*+"*%&")(322)7"/5/'2"-&,-)4)2)*)&-"+:"A)2)8),+-"(&-)/),>"*+"/&-&**2&"),"*%&"8/+@),7&-?"$%&"N/)**',3"N'3"'(@&/*)-&6&,*"/&82)7'*&-"7+66+,"5/4',"*%&6&-?"1%)7%"(/'1")6'>&-"+:"B',"A/',7)-7+?"'"6'I+/")66)>/'*)+,"%54"+:"A)2)8),+-?"),"+/(&/"*+"7+,@),7&"A)2)8),+-"*%'*"*%&3"1)22",+*"%'@&"*+"2&'@&"*%&"=<B<"'*"'22<"""

$%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+,>2+6&/'*&"D%)2*+1,"5-&-"-)6)2'/")6'>&/3"*+"8/+6+*&"*%&)/"(&@&2+86&,*-<"C,"'"-),>2&98'>&"2'3+5*"8/),*&("),"*%&";,*0*77*#-!Q->:!W#Z"V+@&64&/"#LLaX?"D%)2*+1,"'(@&/*)-&-"*%&)/"7+,(+6),)56-"'>'),-*"*%&"4'7;(/+8"+:"*%&"P%)*&%+5-&?"S+5,*"_5-%6+/&?"*%&"F+2231++("-)>,?"',("+*%&/"8'/'()>6'*)7")7+,-"+:"E6&/)7',"'/7%)*&7*5/&"',("2',(-7'8&<"$%)-"'(@&/*)-&6&,*"&@'(&-"',3"-54*&/:5>&"

Page 80: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

aZ"

*%'*"6)>%*"7+,7&'2")*-"6+*)@&<"E77+/(),>"*+"*%&"'("2'3+5*"6'/;&*),>"*%&"D%)2*+1,"7+/8+/'*)+,?"Q&'7%"8/+I&7*"+:"D%)2*+1,"$%/#:)-#':"6&/&"'((/&--"),*+",&1"/&'26-"+:"'/7%)*&7*5/&R"W63"&68%'-)-X<"E(@&/*)-&/-"'/&"+8&,23"6'/;&*),>"*%&"*/&,("+:"7+,*&68+/'/3"5/4',"*/',-:+/6'*)+,"),"S&*/+"S',)2'"',("*%&"'**&68*"*%'*"(&@&2+8&/-"'/&"6';),>"*+"7/&'*&",+(&-"+:"5/4',)-6"*%'*"'22+1"58-7'2&"8/+8&/*3"+1,&/-"*%&"),&*)-"*+"438'--"S&*/+"S',)2'"'26+-*"&,*)/&23<""

A),'223?"',+*%&/"7+66+,"'(@&/*)-&6&,*"),"*%&";,*0*77*#-!Q->:"-&22-"*%&"i';&-%+/&"(&@&2+86&,*-"43"72')6),>"Q$+('3?"+/(),'/3":+2;-"7',",+1"*';&"82&'-5/&"),"&H*/'+/(),'/3"8&/;-"),"'"@&/3":'6)239:/)&,(23"&,@)/+,6&,*"*%'*"&-8+5-&-",'*5/'2"4&'5*3?"+8&,"-8'7&?"',("2):&9&,%',7),>"'6&,)*)&-<R"$%/+5>%"*%&"2',>5'>&"+:"2&)-5/&"',("+/(),'/3"-8'7&"*%'*"*%&"'(@&/*)-&6&,*"5*)2)Y&-?"*%&"'(@&/*)-&6&,*"+,7&"'>'),"/&7+,-*/57*-"*%&":'6)2)'/)*3"+:"E6&/)7',"-545/4',"2):&-*32&-?"'"2&'/,&("-&,-)4)2)*3?"1%)7%")-"7+682&*&23"+88+-&("*+"*%&"()-*),7*23"-*/'*):)&("1+/2("+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"<""Qd/(),'/3":+2;-?R"Q&H*/'+/(),'/3"8&/;-?R":'6)239:/)&,(23?R"Q,'*5/'2"4&'5*3?R"Q+8&,9-8'7&?R"*+>&*%&/"()/&7*23"-)>,'2"*%&"*/',-7&,(&,7&"+:"72'--"()::&/&,7&"&H5(&("43"*%&")(&'2-"+:"E6&/)7',"-545/4)'<"""

i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h2+4'2"B+5*%"Wi&)7%&,;+"#LLMX<"$%&-&")(&'2-"+:"-+7)'2"()@)-)+,"*%/+5>%"-545/4',)Y'*)+,"7&/*'),23"6)//+/"*%&"%)-*+/3"+:"-545/4',)Y'*)+,"',("-545/4',"-8/'12"),"*%&"=<B<"',("*%&"&@+25*)+,"+:"QE6&/)7',"J/&'6R<M!""

P%'*"4&7+6&-"'88'/&,*"%+1&@&/?"1%&,"@)&1),>"*%&"2'3+5*-"+:"*%)-"7+,*&68+/'/3"1'@&"+:"7+,(+6),)56-"',("%+5-&-"4&),>"45)2*"),"S&*/+"S',)2'?")-"*%'*"*%&/&")-"'"8'/*)752'/"7+,@&/>&,7&"4&*1&&,"'"(&-)/&":+/"QE6&/)7',R"',("QA)2)8),+R"*'-*&-<"$+>&*%&/?"*%&"752*5/'2"6&',),>-"&H5(&("43"*%&-&"(&-)>,-"7/&'*&"',")(&'"+:"*%&"Q>2+4'2R"43"-)>,'2),>"*'-*&-"',(")(&'2-"*%'*"7',,+*"4&"5,(&/-*++("'-"4&),>"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""M!"S3"7+,7&8*)+,"+:"*%&"QE6&/)7',"J/&'6R"1)*%),"*%)-"7+,*&H*"),725(&-"*%&"'-8)/'*)+,-"/&:2&7*&("43"*%&"),7/&'-&"+:"-),>9:'6)23"(&*'7%&("%+6&-"),"*38)7'223"-545/4',",&)>%4+/%++(-<"$%&-&"'-8)/'*)+,-"7+,@&3"*%&"(&-)/&":+/"72&'/23"6'/;&("2),&-"+:"-+7)'2"()@)-)+,"&H%)4)*&("1)*%),"*%&"45)2*9&,@)/+,6&,*"7+582&("*+>&*%&/"1)*%"2)4&/'2",+*)+,-"+:"8/+8&/*3"+1,&/-%)8"',("8/+8&/*3"/)>%*-<"_+4),"i)&7%&,;+"',("P)22)'6"B+2&7;)"'/>5&"*%'*"*%&"),7/&'-),>"(&-)/&":+/"-545/4',"-*32&"%+5-),>"8'/'22&2-"*%&"(&7/&'-&"),"%+5-&%+2("-)Y&"),"-&@&/'2"8'/*-"+:"*%&"(&@&2+8),>"1+/2("43"'26+-*"!b"8&/7&,*"4&*1&&,"!caL"',("#LLL<"E77+/(),>"*+"*%&-&"'5*%+/-?"*%&"/&'-+,-":+/"*%)-"(&7/&'-&"'/&"),()7'*)@&"+:"8'**&/,-"+:"&7+,+6)7">2+4'2)Y'*)+,?"*%&">/+1),>"6)((2&"72'--"',("',"),7/&'-&"+:"),7+6&-"1)*%),"7&/*'),"-&7*+/-"+:"*%&-&"-+7)&*)&-<"P)*%"*%&-&"8'**&/,-"7+6&-"'"(&72),&"),"4)/*%"/'*&-?"*%&"8&/-+,'2"7%+)7&"*+"2)@&"),"-545/4',",&)>%4+/%++(-?"',("'"(&72),&"),"&H*&,(&(":'6)23"7+665,'2"-*32&"%+5-&%+2(-<"B&&"Wi&)7%&,;+"#LLMX<"

Page 81: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ab"

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

d,&"1'3"*+"&H'6),&"*%)-"8'/*)752'/"%34/)()*3")-"*%/+5>%"*%&"(+6&-*)7"-8'7&"7/&'*&(":+/"6')(-"),"&'7%"+:"*%&-&"(&@&2+86&,*-<"i);&"+*%&/"%+6&-"*%/+5>%+5*"i'*),"E6&/)7'?"7+,*&68+/'/3"%+6&-"45)2*"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'/&"'26+-*"'21'3-"&U5)88&("1)*%"'"/++6"',("&@&,"'"-&8'/'*&"4'*%/++6":+/"'"(+6&-*)7"-&/@',*<"C*")-"'26+-*"5,*%),;'42&"1)*%),"'"=<B<"7+,*&H*"*+"'22+7'*&"'"/++6"',("4'*%/++6"),"'"-545/4',"%+5-&%+2(":+/"'"(+6&-*)7"-&/@',*<"V+*"+,23"4&7'5-&")*"4&7+6&-"5,'::+/('42&"*+"%+5-&"'"(+6&-*)7"-&/@',*"1)*%),"'"-545/4',"%+5-&%+2(?"45*")*"'2-+"(&:)&-"*%&"72'--2&--")(&'2"&-8+5-&("43"-545/4',"2):&-*32&-<"$%/+5>%+5*"'22"+:"*%&":2++/"82',-"+:"*%&"D%+&,)H"h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

C"1')*&("8'*)&,*23"1)*%"./,&-*+"K'2(&/+,"'*"i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

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""M#"k',&"k'7+4-0"7'-&"-*5(3"+,"*%&"82'7&96';),>"8/'7*)7&-"+:"N&,>'2)")66)>/',*-"),"i+,(+,"(&-7/)4&-"*%&"7+682&H"-&*"+:"8/'7*)7&-"',("-54I&7*":+/6'*)+,"*%'*"*';&-"82'7&"1)*%),"8+-*7+2+,)'2">&+>/'8%)&-?"Q'"-&,-&"+:"82'7&"1%)7%")-"45)2*"'/+5,("@&7*+/-"+:"7+,,&7*)+,"',("%)-*+/)&-"+:"()-7+,,&7*)+,\*%&"8+-*97+2+,)'2">&+>/'8%)&-"%'@&"/&82'7&("*%&"-&75/)*3"+:"*%&"6'8-"+:"*%&"8'-*"1)*%"*%&"5,7&/*'),*3"+:"*+5/),>"*%&"5,-&**2&("-8'*)'2)*)&-"+:"8+1&/"',(")(&,*)*3"),"*%&"8/&-&,*R<"B&&"Wk'7+4-"!cceX<"

Page 82: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

aM"

1'-"*%&"/)>%*"*)6&":+/"%)6"*+"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"P%)2&"C"1'-"@)-)*),>"63"6+*%&/"),"B+5*%&/,"K'2):+/,)'?"./,&-*+"*+2("6&"*%'*"%&"%'(":+5,("'"(&'2"+,"'"*)7;&*"*+"S',)2'"45*"%'("*+":23"+5*"+:"i+-"E,>&2&-"/'*%&/"*%',"B',"A/',7)-7+<"l,+1),>"*%'*"C"1'-"),"B+5*%&/,"K'2):+/,)'?"%&"*+2("6&"*%'*"%&"1+52("I5-*"6&&*"6&"'*"*%&"')/8+/*"*+"()-75--"%)-"*/)8"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("%)-"82',"*+"2++;":+/"'"/&*)/&6&,*"%+6&":+/"%)6"',("%)-"3+5,>&/"4/+*%&/0-":'6)23<""" QC"(+,0*";,+1"1%&*%&/")*"1)22"4&"72+-&"*+"S',)2'"+/"),"J56'>5&*&R<"J56'>5&*&"K)*3"%'-"4&7+6&"'"*%/)@),>"%54"+,"*%&"-+5*%&/,"7+'-*"+:"*%&"C-2',("+:"V&>/+-"d/)&,*'2<"./,&-*+"%'(">/+1,"58"*%&/&"',(">/'(5'*&(":/+6"B)22)6',"=,)@&/-)*3"3&'/-"4&:+/&")*"4&7'6&"',"'**/'7*)+,":+/"*+5/)-*-?"4+*%",+,9A)2)8),+"',("A)2)8),+"'2);&<"S+/&"*%',"'"(&7'(&"'>+?"%&"2+',&("%)-"3+5,>&/"4/+*%&/"jMLLL"*+"+8&,"'"45-),&--"*%&/&<"A+/"-&@&/'2"3&'/-"*%&":)-%"-*',("%)-"4/+*%&/"/',"%'("(+,&"1&22"45*"6+/&"/&7&,*23"7+68&*)*)+,":/+6"2'/>&/"45-),&--&-"%'("-2+1&("*%&"8/+:)*-<"_'*%&/"*%',"/5,,),>"'":)-%"-*',(?"./,&-*+"1'-":')/23"7+,:)(&,*"*%'*"%&"',("%)-"4/+*%&/"7+52("+8&,"'"/&-*'5/',*"1)*%"*%&"6+,&3"*%'*"./,&-*+"%'("-'@&(<""

d,"*%&"+*%&/"%',(?"./,&-*+"'2-+"%'(":/)&,(-?"/&*5/,),>"A)2)8),+-"2);&"%)6-&2:"1%+6"%&"%'(";,+1,"),"B',"A/',-)7+?"1%+"%'("+8&,&("'"8)YY'"8'/2+/"),"$'>'*'3<"$%&"2';&-)(&"7)*3"1'-"+,23"MM";)2+6&*&/-"'1'3":/+6"S',)2'"',("%'("4&&,":+/"6',3"3&'/-"'"@)4/',*"*+5/)-*"(&-*),'*)+,":+/"S',)2&T+-?"1%)7%?"'77+/(),>"*+"./,&-*+0-":/)&,(-?")-"-2+123"'775652'*),>"6+/&"45-),&--"'-"(&@&2+86&,*-"'/&"7+,*),5),>"*+"4&"45)2*"),"*%&"'/&'<"F&"()(,0*"-&&6"*+"6),("*%&":'7*"*%'*"$'>'*'3"-)*-"'(I'7&,*"*+"$''2"i';&?"1%&/&"*%&"-*)229'7*)@&"$''2"@+27',+")-"-)*5'*&(<"A+/"./,&-*+?"*%&"@'25&"+:"6+@),>"*+"&)*%&/"82'7&"(&8&,(&("6+/&"+,"*%&"45-),&--"+88+/*5,)*)&-"&'7%"82'7&"+::&/&("/'*%&/"*%',"*%&"72)6'*&"+/"7+,@&,)&,7&-<"F)-"*/)8"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-")-"6+/&"+:"',"&H82+/'*+/3"@)-)*"45*"&@&,"./,&-*+"'>/&&("*%'*"%&"1+52("7&/*'),23"453"'",&1"%+6&")-"%&":+5,("*%&"/)>%*"-)*5'*)+,<""

$%&/&"'/&"'"%+-*"+:"/&'-+,-"1%3"A)2)8),+-"7%++-&"*+"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"E77+/(),>"*+"./,&-*+?"%)-"/&'-+,-":+/"/&*5/,),>"1&/&"8/),7)8'223"'"6'**&/"+:":),',7&"',("-&75/)*3<"""

C0@&"4&7+6&"5,'775-*+6&("*+"*%&"1&'*%&/<"D&+82&"-'3"*%'*"C"7',"6+@&"*+"N'>5)+"z1%&/&"*%&"72)6'*&")-"7++2&/{"45*"1%+"(+"C";,+1"*%&/&["C"1',*"*+">+"1%&/&"C"7',"85*"63"-'@),>-"*+"5-&"',("%+8&:5223"6';&"&,+5>%"6+,&3"1%&/&"C"7',"%)/&"-+6&4+(3"*+"(+"*%&"('3"*+"('3"*'-;-"':*&/"'":&1"3&'/-<"C06"'2/&'(3"+2("3+5";,+1?R"%&"-'3-"1%)2&"2'5>%),>"2+5(23<""

"./,&-*+")-"'7*5'223"ea?"%'@),>"'//)@&("*+"K'2):+/,)'"1%&,"%&"1'-"#Z<"F&"1+/;&("'-"',"'5*+96&7%',)7":+/"'">'/'>&"),".H7&2-)+/"4&:+/&":),(),>"-*'42&"&682+36&,*"'*"*%&"D+-*"d::)7&<"i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

Page 83: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ae"

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

$%&,"*%&/&")-"*%&")(&'"+:"%+5-&%+2("%&28<"E-"'2/&'(3"6&,*)+,&(?"6+-*"%+5-&%+2(-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'@&"'*"2&'-*"+,&"%+5-&%+2("%&28&/<"_&*5/,),>"A)2)8),+-"'/&"&'>&/"*+"/&2),U5)-%"*%&)/"%+5-&%+2("(5*)&-"*+"(+6&-*)7"%&28<""A+/"),-*',7&?"E2&H"K'('3?"'"/&*)/&("/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*"1%+"2)@&("),"F'1'))":+/"#L"3&'/-?"7+22&7*-"'4+5*"j!?MLL"'"6+,*%"),"B+7)'2"B&75/)*3"',("),"/&*)/&6&,*"4&,&:)*-<"E77+/(),>"*+"%)6?")*"()(",+*"7+@&/"%)-"&H8&,()*5/&-"),"F'1'))"45*"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"1%&/&"%&"/&*)/&("),"!c`c?"%&"7',"'::+/("*1+"6')(-"*+"%&28"4+*%"%)6"',("%)-"1):&?"1%+"'2-+"/&7&)@&-"B+7)'2"B&75/)*3"',("/&*)/&6&,*"4&,&:)*-<"oCt6"6+/&"-&75/&"%&/&":),',7)'223"',("-+7)'223?o"-')("K'('3?"1%+"%'("/&*)/&("),"C2+7+-"V+/*&?"%)-"%+6&"8/+@),7&<"oS3"/++*-"'/&"%&/&<"S3"+2(":/)&,(-"'/&"%&/&<"C"%'@&"8/+8&/*3R"Wl/&):&2-?"#LLcX<""" E77+/(),>"*+"'"-5/@&3"*%'*"D'-75'2"W#LLZX"',("%)-"7+22&'>5&-"7+,(57*&("+,"),*&/&-*&("A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"453&/-"),"!cca"',("#LL#?"%&"8/+@)(&("*%&":+22+1),>"-'682&"/&-8+,-&-"/&>'/(),>"/&'-+,-"1%3"%)-"72)&,*&2&"'7*)@&23"85/-5&("453),>"8/+8&/*3"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("%'@&"7%+-&,"*+"/&*5/,"W!Z9!bXf""

!< QN&7'5-&"+:"*%&"*/&6&,(+5-"),:/'-*/57*5/&"',("45)2(),>"4++6",&'/"*%&"&7+,+6)7"()-*/)7*-"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'?"453),>",&'/"*%&-&"2+7'*)+,-")-"'"1),91),"8/+8+-)*)+,R<"

#< QE@')2'4)2)*3"+:"(+22'/":),',7),>R<"Z< QN&2)&:"*%'*"*%&"D%)2)88),&"/&-5/>&,*"&7+,+63")-"6+@),>"-*&'()23"*+1'/(-"

8/+>/&--"',("-*'4)2)*3R<"b< Q$%&"-*'42&"',("1+/;),>"(&6+7/'73"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"=,2);&"),"6+-*"

8'/*-"+:"E-)'"1%&/&"*%&"-*'4)2)*3"+:">+@&/,6&,*-")-"7+,*),5'223"*%/&'*&,&(?"7+58"(0|*'*-?"1%)2&"+:*&,"-*'>&("),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"'/&"7+,-)(&/&("%&'2*%3"&H8/&--)+,-"+:"(&6+7/'73R<""

M< QP',*-"*+"85*"58"'"45-),&--"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("*%&/&:+/&",&&(-"'"/&-)(&,7&"',("',"+::)7&R<"

e< QP)22"-*'3"+,"*%&"8/+8&/*3"'-"'"/&*)/&&"1%)2&"(+),>"45-),&--"+,"*%&"-)(&R<"a< QP',*-"',"&H*/'"-+5/7&"+:"),7+6&"+,"*%&"-)(&R<"`< QP',*-"7%)2(/&,"',(">/',(7%)2(/&,"*+"&-*'42)-%"/++*-R<"c< Q$%&"'88'/&,*"*/&,(",+1")-":+/"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"*+"-&,("*%&)/"7+22&>&"

4+5,(";)(-"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-":+/"-*5()&-<"$5)*)+,-"'/&",+*"+,23"2+1?"45*"*%&"U5'2)*3"+:"&(57'*)+,")-"&H7&22&,*R<"

!L< QS'/;&*"@'25&"),7/&'-&-":'-*&/"),"D%)2)88),&"),@&-*6&,*"8/+8&/*3"@)-9Ä9@)-"),"*%&"=<B<R<"

Page 84: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

aa"

!!< Qh++("/&-'2&"@'25&"-&&6-"8/&-&,*"-),7&"8/+-8&7*)@&"*';&/9453&/-"'/&"82&,*3?"),725(),>":+/&)>,&/-R<""

!#< QP',*-"*+"*';&"'(@',*'>&"+:"*%&"4&-*"*&/6-"&H*&,(&("43"(&@&2+8&/-"-57%"'-":'@+/'42&"+::982',"W8/&9-&22X"8/)7&-"',(",+,9U5'2):3),>":),',7&"*&/6-R<"

!Z< QP',*-"*+"453"8/+-8&/)*)&-"1)*%"6'/;(+1,"8/)7&-"4&7'5-&"+:"+@&/9-58823"+:"/&-)(&,*)'2"8/+8&/*)&-R<"

!b< Qi+@&-"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',(")*-"8&+82&<"C,@&-*"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-":)/-*"/'*%&/"*%',"),"+*%&/"7+5,*/)&-R<""

!M< Q$%&3"7',"2&'@&"*%&"7'/&"',("6'),*&,',7&"+:"*%&)/"8/+8&/*)&-"*+"1/$*>/0/:"z/&2'*)@&-"3+5"7',"*/5-*{<"S',3"'4%+/"*%&-&"'//',>&6&,*-"*%+5>%?"'-"*%&3"4&7+6&"7+5,*&/98/+(57*)@&":+/"4+*%"8'/*)&-R<"

!e< QE-"'"-&7+,("/&-)(&,7&?"*%&3"7',"&,I+3"*/&6&,(+5-"*'H"4/&';-"),"*%&)/"=B"!LbL"*'H&-<"E-"'"/&,*'2"),7+6&"8/+8&/*3?")*"6'3"4/),>"&H*/'"),7+6&"1%)2&"(&(57*)+,-"'/&"'22+1&("),"*%&)/"=B"!LbL"*'H&-R<""

!a< Q_&*)/&&0-"8&,-)+,"',("-+7)'2"-&75/)*3"(+22'/-"7',"4&"-&,*":/&&23"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"B)6)2'/"*+"-&@&/'2"+*%&/"7+5,*/)&-"1)*%+5*"*%&"+4I&7*)+,"+:"*%&"=<B<">+@&/,6&,*<"i);&1)-&?"6&()7'2"7+@&/'>&":+/"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',-"7',"&'-)23"4&"6'(&"*+"&H*&,("*+"7+@&/"*%&)/"6&()7'2",&&(-"1%)2&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"N25&"B%)&2("(+&-"*%)-",+1?"45*"%+8&:5223"+*%&/-"1)22":+22+1"-++,R<""

!`< QS',3"%'@&":+5,("+5*"*%'*"&@&,"4)>"8/)@'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"',(">)',*"8&,-)+,":5,("2);&"*%&"K'2D._B"WK'2):+/,)'"D542)7".682+3&&-0"_&*)/&6&,*"B3-*&6X":5,(-"*%'*"%'-"4)22)+,-"+:"(+22'/-"),"8+/*:+2)+-"%'@&"-*/+,>23"7+,-)(&/&("-&@&/'2"),@&-*6&,*-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-R<""

!c< QN&7+6),>"'"(5&297)*)Y&,"%'-"'(@',*'>&-R<"#L< QE-"'"/&*)/&&?"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1+52("-8&,("2&--"6+,&3"',("*)6&"

*/'@&2),>R<"""

E22"+:"*%&-&"/&'-+,-"(&-7/)4&"'"-&,-&"+:"+8*)6)-6"*%'*"%'-"&,&/>)Y&("*%&"(3,'6)7"*/',-:+/6'*)+,"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'0-"2',(-7'8&<"E:*&/"(&7'(&-"+:"/&6)**),>"6+,&3"',("6'*&/)'2">++(-"4'7;"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("/')-),>"*%&"-*',('/("+:"2)@),>":+/"6',3"+:"*%&)/":'6)23"6&64&/-?"A)2)8),+-"%'@&"&2&@'*&("*%&)/"&H8&7*'*)+,-":+/"1%'*"*%&)/"%+6&"7+5,*/3"6)>%*"+::&/"4'7;"*+"*%&6-&2@&-<"i);&"*%&"8'/'(+H)7'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"'(@&/*)-&6&,*-"8/+6)-),>"E6&/)7'"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"/&8'*/)'*),>"A)2)8),+-"%'@&"7+6&"*+"&H8&7*"*%&")68+--)42&<"P%'*")-"),":'7*"'"7+,-7)+5-,&--":+/>&("*%/+5>%"7&,*5/)&-"+:"%34/)()*3"',("*/',-:+/6'*)+,?"*%&)/")(&'2)-6?"-)>,'2&("43"*%&",+*)+,-"+:"8+2)*)7'223"-*'4)2)*3"',("&7+,+6)7"'::+/('4)2)*3"&H8/&--&("'4+@&?"*&,(-"*+"+@&/7+6&"*%&"7+,*/'()7*)+,-"',("5,7&/*'),*)&-"&,@&2+8),>"*%&)/"/&*5/,<""

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

Page 85: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

a`"

>2+4'2",&*1+/;-"',("*+"-&>6&,*-"+:"*%&)/"+1,"7+5,*/)&-?"1%)2&"),*&/,'223"()-7+,,&7*),>"2+7'2"8+852'*)+,-"*%'*"'/&"&)*%&/":5,7*)+,'223"5,,&7&--'/3"+/"-+7)'223"()-/58*)@&R"WK'-*&22-"#LLLX<"

F+1&@&/?"*%)-"(3,'6)7"&,&/>3"/&7+,-*)*5*),>"S',)2'"%'-",+*"4&&,"8/+8&22&("43"*%&"4'2);4'3',"&7+,+63"'2+,&<".7+,+6)7"8+2)7)&-"')6&("'*"+8&,),>"',("(&/&>52'*),>"6'/;&*-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'-"7/&'*&("'",&1"-5/>&"),"',("()@&/-):)7'*)+,"+:"&H8+/*&("2'4+/<"N&>),,),>"1)*%"*%&"A)(&2"_'6+-"E(6),)-*/'*)+,"W!cc#9!cc`X?"6+*)@'*&("43"*/&,(-"),"*%&">2+4'2"6'/;&*"',("*%&"-577&--"+:"*%&)/"E-)',"7+5,*&/8'/*-?"*%&"7+5,*/3"%'("'>>/&--)@&23"'(+8*&("'"8+2)73"+:"2)4&/'2"&7+,+6)7"/&:+/6<"P)*%"',"),-8)/&("7+,:)(&,7&"6'(&",&7&--'/3"8'/*23"4&7'5-&"+:"*%&"(&8'/*5/&"+:"=<B<"4'-&-?"_'6+-0"'(6),)-*/'*)+,"/&-5//&7*&("*%&"NBD"),"!ccZ"',("+8&,&("*%&"*&2&7+665,)7'*)+,-"),(5-*/3"*+":+/&)>,"',("(+6&-*)7"7+68&*)*)+,<"E,("5,2);&"),"8/&@)+5-"'(6),)-*/'*)+,-?"1%)7%"'22+1&("*%&"7+5,*/30-"&7+,+63"*+"4&"(/)@&,"2'/>&23"+,"(&4*"',(":+/&)>,"')(?"_'6+-0"&7+,+6)7"8+2)7)&-"1&/&"8/),7)82&("+,":+/&)>,"',("(+6&-*)7"),@&-*6&,*-"W(&"J)+-"#LLZX<"

$%&-&"/&:+/6-"8'@&("*%&"1'3":+/"*1+"7+,>/5&,*"),:2+1-"+:":),',7)'2"7'8)*'2"*+"/&),@)>+/'*&"*%&"7+5,*/30-"&7+,+63"',("*/',-:+/6"*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"6'/;&*"+@&/"*%&"2'-*"(&7'(&<"$%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'-"4&7+6&"'">2+4'2"2&'(&/"),"N5-),&--"D/+7&--"d5*-+5/7),>"WNDdX"1)*%"+@&/"a`L"+8&/'*)+,'2"7'22"7&,*&/-"8/+@)(),>"-'2'/)&-"*%'*"'/&"7+,-)(&/'423"%)>%&/"*%',"*%&"'@&/'>&"),7+6&"+:"6+-*"A)2)8),+-<"B&7+,(23?"8&/&,,)'2"1'@&-"+:"/&*5/,),>"dAP-"%'@&"'2-+"4/+5>%*"),"),7/&'-&("),7+6&"',("%'@&"4&&,"8'/*)752'/23"&'>&/"*+"),@&-*"),"/&-)(&,*)'2"8/+8&/*3"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"$%)-"(5'29:2+1"+:"7'8)*'2"7/&'*&("43"&H8+/*&("2'4+/?"7+64),&("1)*%"),@&-*6&,*-"6'(&"43"/&*5/,),>"A)2)8),+-"2);&"./,&-*+?"%'@&"&,'42&("'",&1:+5,("6+6&,*56"1)*%),"*%&"/&'2"&-*'*&"6'/;&*"*%/+5>%+5*"S&*/+"S',)2'"',(")*-"-5//+5,(),>-<""""""""""""""""""""""

Page 86: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ac"

""""

!!!!

!!!!!

D,/7$-%!b!!

./0*12/3/#!;/%/#&*/!!!

+&(%*:5!P-J-0&75-#$!/#'!$,-!A#R*-$3!&F!<-$(%#!

"

Page 87: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

`L"

!90/:%-&!T!""$+5/)-6?"):")*")-",+*%),>"&2-&?")-"*%&";),("+:"*/'@&2?"*%&";),("+:">&+752*5/'2"6+@&6&,*?"*%'*"-8&7):)7'223"2&'@&-"*%&"82'7&"+:"*%&"*/'@&2&/0-"%+6&"4&%),(\$%&"6),5*&"*+5/)-*-"4&>),"*+"4&2)&@&"*%&"%'@&"u7+6&"%+6&?0"*%&)/")(&,*)*3"'-"*+5/)-*-":'22-"),*+"U5&-*)+,?"+/?"'-"1)*%"*%&"./0*12/3/#?"4&7+6&-"82'5-)423"(&,)'42&<""

"""""m"B%&223"E,,"V&--"W#LLZX""+,-!./0*12/3/#!O&$-0!

"$%&"'(@&/*)-&6&,*-":+/"*%&"S'45%'3"S',+/"F+*&2?"82'3&("/&8&'*&(23"+,"$AK"

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

E8'/*":/+6"*%&"@)4/',*"8'-*&2"7+2+/-"*%'*"+,23"-&&6"*+"'77&,*5'*&"*%&"7+,*+5/-"+:"*%&"%+*&2-0"()6),5*)@&"-%'8&?"*%&/&"'/&":&1"&2&6&,*-"*%'*"()-*),>5)-%"*%&"S'45%'3"S',+/0-"*%/&&9-*+/3"-*/57*5/&"'-"'"82'7&"1%&/&"*+5/)-*-"6)>%*"4&"-*'3),><"$%&"%+*&20-"+5*1'/("-*32&?"1)*%")*-":2'*?"'(+4&92);&":'}'(&"',(">/&&,9*),*&(?":)H&("1),(+1-?"-8&';-"6+/&"*+"',"E6&/)7',"-545/4',"8'-*)7%&"/'*%&/"*%',"*%&"6+(&/,"-;3-7/'8&/"%+*&2-"*%'*"*&,("*+"4&"'--+7)'*&("1)*%"1+/2("*/'@&2<"d,"+,&"&,("+:"*%&",'//+1"8'--'>&1'3"1%&/&"*%&"%+*&2")-"2+7'*&(")-"'"725**&/&("8'/;),>"2+*"'(I'7&,*"*+"*%&"D'>7+/"K'-),+"K254<"i+7'2"/&-)(&,*-"/'*%&/"*%',"*+5/)-*-"*&,("*+"@)-)*"*%&"7254?"1%)7%")-"+8&,"'*"'22"%+5/-"+:"*%&"('3?"*+"*/3"*%&)/"%',(-"'*"-+6&"4'77'/'*"+/"8'/*';&"),"'"-6'22">'6&"+:"8+;&/<"$+1'/(-"*%&"+*%&/"&,(")-"+,&"+:"*%&"6',3"G)7*+/)'"K+5/*"6+*&2-"-7'**&/&("*%/+5>%+5*"S',)2'?"'":/',7%)-&"*%'*")-";,+1,"*+"4&"'"1&229:/&U5&,*&("%54"1)*%),"*%&"-&H"),(5-*/3"7)/75)*<""

A/+6"*%&"%+*&20-"2+7'*)+,"'2+,&?")*"4&7+6&-"/&'()23"'88'/&,*"*%'*"*%&"S'45%'3"S',+/?"1%+-&"'(@&/*)-&6&,*-"*+5*-")*-&2:"'-"*%&"Q:)/-*"4'2);4'3',"%+*&2"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-R?")-":'/":/+6"4&),>"*%&"Q1+/2(972'--":+/"*%&"1+/2("6'/;&*R"&-*'42)-%6&,*"(&8)7*&("+,")*-"7+66&/7)'2-"')/&("),"*%&"=<B<"D2+**&("),"*%&"6)((2&"+:"*%&"2&--":'-%)+,'42&"7)*3"+:"D'-'3?"'"@)-)*+/?"-*'3),>"'*"*%&"%+*&2"',("&'>&/"*+"&-7'8&":/+6"*%&":/&,&*)7"',(">/)**3"-8'7&"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'?")-":+/7&("*+"&,(5/&"*%&"*/'::)7"+,".JBE"),"+/(&/"*+"*/'@&2"1&-*"*+"*%&"S'22"+:"E-)'<"V+1"*%&":+5/*%"2'/>&-*"6'22"),"E-)'?"BS"SdE")-"*%&",&'/&-*"2+7'*)+,"1%&/&"*+5/)-*-"7',"-'*)'*&"*%&)/"7/'@),>-":+/"-8&7)'2*3":++(-"+/"&,*&/*'),6&,*<"S+/&"'64)*)+5-"%+*&2">5&-*-"1)22"6+/&"2);&23"6';&"*%&"'/(5+5-"I+5/,&3"&'-*1'/("',(",'@)>'*&"*%/+5>%"S',)2'0-"6'Y&"+:"-*/&&*-"),"+/(&/"*+"/&'7%"*%&"@'-*23"6+/&"8+852'/"7+66&/7)'2"()-*/)7*-"+:"S';'*)"+/"S',('253+,><"

Page 88: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

`!"

"P%)2&"4'2);4'3',-"6'3",+*"%'@&"82',,&("*+"4&>),"*%&)/"/&*5/,"I+5/,&3"4'7;"*+"*%&)/"%+6&2',("),"-57%"'":'-%)+,?"'**&68*),>"*+",'@)>'*&"'/+5,("*%&"%+*&20-"-5//+5,(),>">&+>/'8%3")-"'"I'//),>"6&*'8%+/"+:"%+1"*%&"/+5*-"+:">2+4'2"*+5/)-6"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-")-"7+,*),5+5-23"%),(&/&("43"-&7*+/-"),"*%&"&7+,+63"*%'*"'/&"2&--"6+4)2&<"$%&":/'7*5/&("',("()-I+),*&(",'*5/&"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'"'2+,&"8/&-&,*-"'":+/6)('42&"7%'22&,>&":+/"'"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3"-7/'442),>"*+"(/'19),":+/&)>,"7'8)*'2"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"8'/*)752'/23"*+"*%&"V'*)+,'2"K'8)*'2"_&>)+,"WVK_X<"E-"*%&"E-)',"6'/;&*"7+,*),5&-"*+"&@+2@&"',("&H8',("'*"2)>%*"-8&&(?"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*"/&6'),-"-*&'(:'-*"*+")*-"/&2)',7&"+,"*+5/)-6"'-"'":5,('6&,*'2"6&',-"+:";&&8),>"*%&"7+5,*/30-"&7+,+63"'8'7&"1)*%")*-"/&>)+,'2",&)>%4+/-<"

B*'*&"'(6),)-*/'*+/-"%'@&"7%'/>&("*%&"J&8'/*6&,*"+:"$+5/)-6"WJd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t-">5&-*-"7',,+*")66&()'*&23"4&"7'*&>+/)Y&("'-"+@&/-&'-"+/":+/&)>,<"$%&"%+*&2")-"-8&7):)7'223"(&-)>,&(":+/"4'2);4'3',-?":+/6&/"D%)2)88),&"7)*)Y&,-"/&*5/,),>"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""

F)((&,"1)*%),"*%&")66&()'*&"+5*-;)/*-"+:"S',)2'?"*%&"S'45%'3"S',+/")-"5*)2)Y&("6+/&"'-"'"1&27+6),>"8+),*"1%&/&"4'2);4'3',-"/&7+@&/":/+6"*%&)/":2)>%*-"',("82',"*%&"/&-*"+:"*%&)/"@)-)*"*+":'6)23"6&64&/-"),"+*%&/"8'/*-"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"$%&"%+*&2")-"+,&"+:":+5/",&123"45)2*"%+-8)*'2)*3"7&,*&/-"+1,&("43"i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

P%)2&"*%&"6+(&/,"(&-)>,"+:"*%&"%+*&20-"),*&/)+/"2'3+5*"',("(|7+/"1'-"72&'/23"+@&/-*'*&(?"'",'-7&,*"-54*&H*"+:"E6&/)7',"7+2+,)'2)-6"8&/6&'*&("*%&"%+*&20-"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""MZ""i&>&,("F+*&2-"C,*&/,'*)+,'2"K+/8+/'*)+,?"N-8-#'!O&$-0:!"#$-%#/$*&#/0!D&%7&%/$*&#!O&5-7/8-?"#LLa?"%**8fpp111<2&>&,(%+*&2-<7+6<8%p%+*&28/+8&/*)&-p),(&H<%*62"W'77&--&("E8/)2"a?"#L!LX<"

Page 89: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

`#"

,+-*'2>)7"-5//+5,(),>-?")225@)'*),>"2);&"72'3":/+6"1&*"-',(<"A/+6"*%&":/+,*"(&-;?":+/"&H'682&?"*%&"7+,7)&/>&-"()::&/&,*)'*&("*%&6-&2@&-":/+6"*%&"/&-*"+:"*%&"-*'::"43"7+665,)7'*),>"),")68&77'423"7+,-*/57*&("E6&/)7',"'77&,*-"',("8'/2'3&("4&*1&&,">5&-*-"1%)2&"'(&8*23"5*)2)Y),>"@'/)+5-"E6&/)7',"7+22+U5)'2)-6-<"d,&"'2-+"U5)7;23"()-7&/,-"*%&"-+5,("+:"1(#'*5/#"65-)7?"-+"7%'/'7*&/)-*)7"+:"8+852'/"65-)7"(5/),>"*%&"bL-"',("ML-?"82'3),>"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"%+*&2"2+443"',("/&-*'5/',*<Mb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

G)-)*+/-"'/&"*/',-8+/*&("&@&,":5/*%&/"),*+"*%&)/"7%)2(%++(-"1%&,"*%&3"&,*&/"*%&"%+*&20-"/&-*'5/',*"1%&/&"'6+,>-*"*%&"45::&*"+:"*38)7'223"A)2)8),+"4/&';:'-*":'/&")-"*%&"%+*&20-"@&/3"+1,"#/80/0/1&?"1%+"1')*-"+,"&'7%"*'42&"1)*%":/&-%23"8/&8'/&("*/'()*)+,'2"(&--&/*-<"i);&"2)**2&"7%)2(/&,?"8'*/+,-"2)>%*"58"'*"*%&"-)>%*"+:"2*2*#81/C!7($&C!1($:*#$/?"',(")/::/J/",&-*2&("),-)(&"+:"',"'256),56"2/c-%/"2),&("1)*%"4',','"2&'@&-<MM"C"7+52("%&'/"1%)-8&/-"+:"7+,@&/-'*)+,"'-"8'/&,*-":+,(23"/&7+5,*&("*%&)/"7%)2(%++(-"1%)2&"*%&"7%&:":+2(&("&'7%"4',','"2&':"',("7'/&:5223"-2)7&("*%&)/"4';&("7+7+,5*"),(52>&,7&-"1%)2&"*%&)/"7%)2(/&,")68'*)&,*23"2)-*&,&(9+,<"$%)-")6'>),'/3"-8'7&?"-5-8&,(&("),"*)6&?")-")225-*/'*)@&"+:"*%&"6',,&/"),"1%)7%"*%&"Jd$")-"'**&68*),>"*+"%'/,&--"*%&"@'25&-"+:"2&)-5/&?"&7+,+6)7"+88+/*5,)*3?"',("8'*/+,'>&"43"8/+@)(),>"-&/@)7&-"*%'*"'22+1-"@)-)*+/-"*+"*/',-7&,("*%&")66&()'*&"&,@)/+,"+:"S',)2'0-"()YY3),>"*&68+"',("@&H),>">&+>/'8%3"',("/&*5/,"*+"',")(&'2)-*)7"%+6&2',(<"""

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

$%)-"7%'8*&/"'2-+"&H'6),&-"*%&"8/+(57*)+,"+:"-54I&7*)@)*)&-"*%/+5>%"1%)7%"/&*5/,),>"A)2)8),+-"5,&'-)23"-*/'((2&"*%&"),*&/-*)'2"-8'7&"4&*1&&,"*%&)/",&1"',("

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Mb"d(#'*5/#?"'">&,/&"+:"*/'()*)+,'2"A)2)8),+"2+@&"-+,>-"',("1&/&"7%'/'7*&/)-*)7"+:"A)2)8),+"65-)7"8+852'/"(5/),>"*%&"!cbL-"',("ML-"4&:+/&"d/)>),'2"D%)2)88),&"S5-)7"WdDSX"4&7'6&"8+852'/<""MM"A)2)8),+"-*/&&*"@&,(+/-?"+/"#/80/0/1&:?"7+66+,23"7'//3"2/c-%/:?"-6'22"6&*'2"8+*"5-&("*+"-*+/&":++(?"-25,>"+@&/"*%&)/"-%+52(&/-?"+:*&,"4'2',7),>"*%&"8+*-"+,"&'7%"&,("+:"'"2+,>"1++("8+2&<""

Page 90: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

`Z"

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d$?"',(")*-"),*&/*1),),>"8'/*,&/-?")-"'7*)@&23"7+,:/+,*),>"1%)2&"(&@&2+8),>"-*/'*&>)&-"*+"&,*)7&"A)2)8),+-"*+"/&*5/,"',("52*)6'*&23"/&8'*/)'*&"4'7;"*+"*%&)/"%+6&2',(<"

""

E$/$-!P-J-0&75-#$!/#'!$,-!;-%F&%5/#)-!&F!+&(%*:5!"P%&,"85/7%'-),>"'"*)7;&*"*%/+5>%"'"4'2);4'3',"*+5/)-6"'>&,73"+/"/&>)-*&/),>"

1)*%"*%&"4'2);4'3',"7&,*&/?"&)*%&/"),"*%&"=<B<"+/"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"+,&"U5)7;23"()-7+@&/-"*%&"1'3-"),"1%)7%"*%&"Jd$"%'-"72&@&/23")682&6&,*&("'"*+5/)-6"7'68')>,":+/6&("'/+5,("'"Q-8)/)*R"+:"5/2(,/3<".H&75*)@&-"+8&/'*),>"1)*%),"',("'/+5,("*%&"Jd$"%'@&"*';&,"*+"*%&")(&'"+:"*/',-:+/6),>"*%&"8/'7*)7&"+:"5/2(,/3"',(":+/6'2)Y),>")*"),*+"'"Q752*5/&"+:"*+5/)-6R?"1%)7%")-"4&),>"*'5>%*"*+"2+7'2">+@&/,6&,*-"',("&@&,"2/%/#8/3"2&'(&/-"),"7)*)&-"',("8/+@),7&-"1%&/&"*+5/)-*-"'/&"8/+6),&,*<"A+/"),-*',7&?"6',3"%+*&2-"',("/&-*'5/',*-"6)>%*"+:*&,"+::&/"*1+"-&8'/'*&"-&*-"+:"/'*&-":+/"2+7'2"A)2)8),+-"',(":+/&)>,"*+5/)-*-<"$%&"Jd$"',("8'/*,&/),>"'>&,7)&-"%'@&"'**&68*&("*+"+/>',)Y&"*/'),),>"8/+>/'6-"),"*%&"752*5/&"+:"*+5/)-6"*+"&,7+5/'>&"%+*&2-"',("/&-*'5/',*-"*+"8/+@)(&"'22">5&-*-"1)*%"'"-),>2&"-*',('/("/'*&"WG)22'6+/"#LL#X<""

$%&"*&/6"5/2(,/3?"-)6)2'/"*+"*%&"1+/("F'1'))',"&H8/&--)+,"+:"/0&,/?"7+,,+*&-"-&@&/'2"6&',),>-<"$%&"2)*&/'2"6&',),>"+:"5/2(,/3")-"Q2+,>"2)@&R<"O&*"1%)2&"*%&"7&2&4/'*+/3"*&/6")-"+77'-)+,'223"5-&(":+/"*+'-*-"2);&"*%&"1+/("Q7%&&/-R?")*")-"6+/&"+:*&,"5-&("*+"1&27+6&">5&-*-"',("'-"-57%?"%'-"4&&,"'(+8*&("43"*%&"Jd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

Page 91: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

`b"

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f"1%)2&"45*"'"6),)-752&":/'7*)+,"+:"*%&"7+5,*/30-"2+7'2"A)2)8),+"8+852'*)+,")-"7'8'42&"+:"&H8&/)&,7),>"*%&"1+/2("+:"2&)-5/&"8/+6)-&("43"*%&"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3?"4'2);4'3',-?"A)2)8),+-"/&*5/,),>"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"'/&"1&27+6&("*+"&,I+3"*%&"7+5,*/30-"5,)U5&"+::&/),>-"',("&2)*&"8/)@)2&>&-"1%&,"*%&3"@)-)*"%+6&<""

d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

A+/"&H'682&?":/+6"!caM9!cae?"4&*1&&,"=BJjb!L"',("jMbM"6)22)+,"+:">+@&/,6&,*"6+,&3"1'-"*)&("*+"*%&":),',7),>"+:"%+*&2"45)2(),>"'/+5,("S',)2'"F'/4+/"W_)7%*&/"!c`c?"MaX<"$+"8/+@)(&"'"7+,7&8*5'2"-7'2&"+:"*%)-":),',7)'2"7+66)*6&,*?"*%&"*+*'2"'6+5,*"-8&,*"+,"%+*&2"45)2(),>"1'-"4&*1&&,"+,&9-&@&,*%"*+"+,&9:):*%"+:"*%&">+@&/,6&,*0-"*+*'2"&H8&,()*5/&-"*%'*"3&'/"',("6+/&"*%',"*%&"*+*'2"'6+5,*"4+//+1&(":/+6"*%&"P+/2("N',;"WjZ!M"6)22)+,X<"J5/),>"*%'*"-'6&"3&'/?"*%&"J&@&2+86&,*"N',;"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"WJNDX"-8&,*"'"Q-*'>>&/),>"j##c<#c"6)22)+,R"+,"*+5/)-6"8/+I&7*-<Me""

$%&"&,*1),),>"7+,,&7*)+,-"2),;),>"8/+8&/*3"(&@&2+86&,*"',("*+5/)-6"*+>&*%&/"1&/&":+/>&("43"S'/7+-0"&'/23"8+2)*)7'2"'>&,('"*+"5-&"*+5/)-6"'-"'"*++2":+/"-*'*&"(&@&2+86&,*<"F'@),>"45)2*"',"&7+,+63"'/+5,("(&4*"7+,-568*)+,?"*%&"S'/7+-"'(6),)-*/'*)+,"4&2)&@&("*%'*"'",&1"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3"1+52("8/+@)(&"*1+"),*&/(&8&,(&,*"85/8+-&-<"A)/-*?"*%&"8/)6'/3"/+2&"+:"*+5/)-6"1'-"*+"8/+@)(&"8+2)*)7'2"()@)(&,(-"*+"',"'(6),)-*/'*)+,"*%'*"%'("4&7+6&"),7/&'-),>23"4&2&'>5&/&("43"7/)*)7)-6<"N3"*%&"*)6&"S'/*)'2"i'1"1'-"&-*'42)-%&(?"',,+3&("+@&/"*%&"(&7'(&-"+:"8+2)*)7'2"7+//58*)+,"',("@)+2&,*"-588/&--)+,"+:"8+2)*)7'2"+88+-)*)+,"&H%)4)*&("43"*%&"S'/7+-"'(6),)-*/'*)+,Ma?"*%&",+*)+,"*%'*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1'-"*%&"6+-*"(&6+7/'*)7",'*)+,"),"B+5*%&'-*"E-)'"1'-"U5)7;23"()6),)-%),>"),"*%&"&3&-"+:"*%&"),*&/,'*)+,'2"7+665,)*3<"K+,:/+,*&("43"*%)-">/+1),>"()-'88/+@'2?"S'/7+-"1'-"),*&,*"+,"'--5/),>":+/&)>,"),@&-*+/-"*%'*"%)-")682&6&,*'*)+,"+:"S'/*)'2"i'1"1+52(",+*")68&(&":+/&)>,"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Me"QE-)'"$/'@&2<R"+,-!A:*/!<-)&%'"WJ&7&64&/"!c`#Xf"#e?"U5+*&("),"_)7%*&/?"Q$%&"D+2)*)7)Y'*)+,"+:"$+5/)-6R?"!c`cf"Ma<""Ma"C,"!cec?"S'/7+-"4&7'6&"*%&":)/-*"8/&-)(&,*"-),7&"),(&8&,(&,7&"*+"4&"/&9&2&7*&("),"1%'*"1'-"1)(&23"'7;,+12&(>&("*+"%'@&"4&&,"',"5,5-5'223"7+//58*"',("/)>>&("&2&7*)+,<""

Page 92: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

`M"

')("+/"7/&'*&"+4-*'72&-"*+"D%)2)88),&"&H8+/*-<"S'/7+-"4&2)&@&("*%'*"'"@)4/',*"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3"1+52("&,-5/&"*%'*"),*&/,'*)+,'2"4',;-"1+52("7+,*),5&"*+"8/+@)(&"2+',-"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*<"

E-"_)7%*&/"W!c`#?"!c`cX"&H82'),-?"(/'1),>"@)-)*+/-"*+"*%&"7+5,*/3"1'-"&--&,*)'2":+/"&-*'42)-%),>"*%&"8+2)*)7'2"2&>)*)6'73"+:"*%&"S'/7+-">+@&/,6&,*"),"*%&":'7&"+:"S'/*)'2"i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

E/+5,("*%&"-'6&"8&/)+(?"'-"S'/7+-"&64'/;&("+,"%)-"7+2+--'2"82',"+:",'*)+,'2"/&(&@&2+86&,*"*%/+5>%"*%&"6',('*&-"(&*')2&("),"*%&"82',":+/"'"QV&1"B+7)&*3R?"*%&"@'-*"6'I+/)*3"+:">+@&/,6&,*'2"/&-+5/7&-"1&/&"/&()/&7*&("*+"',("7+,7&,*/'*&("+,"*%&"5/4',"/&,&1'2"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'<M`"$%&"'(6),)-*/'*)+,"1'-"8'/*)752'/23"),@&-*&("),"-%+/),>"58"*%&"&7+,+6)7"-*'4)2)*3"+:"*%&"VK_"',("),*/+(57),>",&1"),85*-"*%'*"1+52(">&,&/'*&":/&-%"7'8)*'2"),*+"*%&"&7+,+63"43"'**/'7*),>":+/&)>,"),@&-*6&,*-"),*+"*%&"5/4',"7+/&"WN&22+"!c`#X<"$%&"'(6),)-*/'*)+,"4&2)&@&("*%'*"*%&"/&),@)>+/'*)+,"+:"*%&"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3"1'-"),*&>/'2"*+"'7%)&@),>"%)-"-&7+,("',("2'/>&/">+'2f"*%&"/&-*/57*5/),>"+:"*%&"7+5,*/30-"&7+,+63<""$%&"2'/>&/"6',('*&":+/"'"V&1"B+7)&*3?"1%)7%"'2+,>"1)*%"*%&"/&2+7'*)+,"+:"),:+/6'2"-&**2&6&,*-"',("),*&,-)@&"2',("(&@&2+86&,*"*%/+5>%"*%&"45)2(),>"+:"7+66&/7)'2"',("/&-)(&,*)'2"8/+8&/*3?"&@&,*5'223"8/+8&22&("*%&"7/&'*)+,"+:"',"&,*)/&"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"$%5-?"'6)(-*"*%&"-+7)'2"5,/&-*"',("8+2)*)7'2"*5/6+)2"*%'*"%'("+/)>),'223"8/&7)8)*'*&("*%&"(&72'/'*)+,"+:"S'/*)'2"i'1"),"B&8*&64&/"!ca#?")*"6';&-"7+682&*&"-&,-&"*%'*"*%&"'(6),)-*/'*)+,"&-*'42)-%&("*%&"Jd$"),"S'3"!caZ"2&--"*%',"'"3&'/"2'*&/<""

E-"'"7+68+,&,*"+:"*%&"B*'*&0-"2'/>&/"8+2)*)7'2"'88'/'*5-?"*%&"Jd$"1'-")682&6&,*&("*+"/&:2&7*"+*%&/">+@&/,6&,*'2"),-*)*5*)+,-"*%/+5>%")*-"+/>',)Y'*)+,'2"-*/57*5/&<"C*"1'-"()@)(&("4&*1&&,"8+2)73?"8/+6+*)+,'2"',("/&>52'*+/3"/+2&-<"$%&"Jd$"7+68+-&("*%&"&H&75*)@&"'/6"+:"*%&"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3"',("+@&/-'1"'22")--5&-"/&2'*&("*+"*+5/)-6"),"*%&"7+5,*/3"),725(),>?"82',,),>?"2)7&,-),>?"*'/)::-?"),-8&7*)+,?"'77+5,*),>"8/+7&(5/&-?"8/+6+*)+,?"',("/&8/&-&,*'*)+,"'4/+'(<"C,"+/(&/"*+"6'),*'),"2+7'2"7+,*/+2"+@&/"*%&"/)>%*"*+"),-8&7*?"-58&/@)-&?"',("2)7&,-&"',3"&-*'42)-%6&,*"7'*&/),>"*+"*+5/)-*-?"S'/7+-"'2-+"&-*'42)-%&("*1+"+*%&/"4/',7%&-"),725(),>"*%&"D%)2)88),&"$+5/)-6"E5*%+/)*3"WD$EX"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&"K+,@&,*)+,"N5/&'5"WDKNX<"$%&"DKN?"2'*&/"/&,'6&("D%)2)88),&"K+,@&,*)+,"',("G)-)*+/-"K+/8+/'*)+,"WDKGKX?"1'-"/&-8+,-)42&":+/"8/+@)(),>"*%&"6'),"*%/5-*"+:"'(@&/*)-),>":+/"*+5/)-6"),"*%&"7+5,*/3<"$%&"N5/&'5"1+/;&("72+-&23"1)*%"*%&"Jd$"*+"8/+6+*&"@'/)+5-")-2',("2+7'*)+,-"*%'*"1&/&"@)&1&("'-"8/)6&"),@&-*6&,*-":+/"*+5/)-6"7'8)*'2<"$%&"D$E?"+,"*%&"+*%&/"%',(?"1'-"),"7%'/>&"+:"6'),*'),),>"/&2'*)+,-"1)*%"*%&"8/)@'*&"-&7*+/"',("6','>&("*%&"(&@&2+86&,*"+:"2',(":+/"*+5/)-*"85/8+-&-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"O&*"-),7&"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""M`"S'/7+-"72')6&("*%'*"6'/*)'2"2'1"1'-"*%&"8/&25(&"*+"7/&'*),>"%)-"./8&#8!N*7(#/#?"'"V&1"B+7)&*3"4'-&("+,",&1"-+7)'2"',("8+2)*)7'2"@'25&-<"A+/"'"()-75--)+,"+,"S'/7+-"82',":+/"'"V&1"B+7)&*3?"-&&"Wi)7+"#LLZX<"

Page 93: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

`e"

657%"+:"*%&"7+66&/7)'2"',("/&-)(&,*)'2"45)2(),>"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"7+5,*/3"'2/&'(3"+@&/2'88&("1)*%"*%&"*+5/)-*"),(5-*/3?"*%&"D$E"%'-"7+,*),5'223"82'3&("'"@)*'2"/+2&"),"*%&"45)2(),>"+:"8/+8&/*)&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""

E2*%+5>%"*%&"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3"1+52("&@&,*5'223"4&7+6&"'"8)@+*'2":+/7&"1)*%),"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63?"*%&"8/+(57*"+:"S'/7+-0"&'/23"&,(&'@+/-"),"*+5/)-6"(&@&2+86&,*"8/+@&("*+"4&"7+5,*&/"*+"%)-"2'/>&/">+'2"+:"-*'4)2)Y),>"*%&"7+5,*/3t-"')2),>"&7+,+63<"E-"',"),-*/56&,*":+/"&7+,+6)7"(&@&2+86&,*?"*%&"),*/+(57*)+,"+:"*+5/)-6"(&@&2+86&,*"43"S'/7+-"),*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"/&:2&7*&(?"'-"_)7%*&/"W!c`#X"-5>>&-*&(?"Q',"'26+-*"7'@'2)&/"()-/&>'/(":+/"*%&"&7+,+6)7"7+-*-"+:"-57%"',"&,(&'@+/\),()7'*)@&"+:"*%&")6'>),'*)+,"'-"1&22"'-"*%&"@',)*3"+:"*%&"V&1"B+7)&*3R"W!!MX<"i);&"'",564&/"+:"*%&":+/6&/"D/&-)(&,*t-"6&>'98/+I&7*-?"*%&",&1"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3"*%'*"S'/7+-")682&6&,*&("1'-"7+-*),>"*%&"7+5,*/3"',"+@&/1%&26),>"'6+5,*"+:"-*'*&"/&-+5/7&-<"

$%&":)/-*"72&'/"&H'682&"+:"*%)-"7'@'2)&/"()-/&>'/("+775//&("),"!cab"1%&,"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1+,"*%&"4)("*+"%+-*"*%&"C,*&/,'*)+,'2"S+,&*'/3":5,(9P+/2("N',;"K+,:&/&,7&"),"d7*+4&/"!cae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`"6+,*%-<""QC,"*%&"/5-%"*+"45)2("*%&"%+*&2-?",+/6'2"2+',"8/+7&(5/&-"1&/&"-%&2@&(?R"&H82'),&("C/)&,+"E>5)//&?"*%&"J)/&7*+/"+:"*%&"N5/&'5"+:"$+5/)-6"B&/@)7&-"(5/),>"*%'*"8&/)+("W_)7%*&/"!c`c?"MeX<""

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cae"1+52("7&'-&"4&),>"&7+,+6)7'223"@)'42&"1)*%),"!M"3&'/-?"*%&">+@&/,6&,*"7+,*),5&("*+"&H*&,(":),',7),>"*+"*%&"%+*&2-"'-"'"6&',-"+:"(/'1),>"6+/&"7'8)*'2"),*+"*%&"B*'*&"',("-)8%+,"*'H8'3&/"6+,&3"1)*%"&'7%"&,-5),>"*+5/)-6"8/+I&7*<"N3"!c`Z?"*%&"JND"%'("'77/5&("`L"8&/7&,*"+:"*%&"/&-8+,-)4)2)*3":+/"/&8'3),>"*%&",'*)+,t-"(&4*"*%/+5>%"6+/&"*%',"aL"*+5/)-6"/&2'*&("8/+I&7*-"W_)7%*&/"!c`c?"MaX<"""

E,+*%&/"7+68+,&,*"*+"'--5'>),>"*%&",&>'*)@&"8&/7&8*)+,"'/+5,("S'/*)'2"i'1"',("'**/'7*),>":+/&)>,"),@&-*6&,*"*%/+5>%"*%&"'(6),)-*/'*)+,0-"*+5/)-6"6'-*&/"82',"1'-"*%&":)-7'223"6)-6','>&("./0*12/3/#"8/+>/'6"&-*'42)-%&("),"!caZ<"E-"8/&@)+5-23"()-75--&(?"*%&"./0*12/3/#"8/+>/'6?"1%)7%"-54-)()Y&("*%&"@)-)*'*)+,"+:"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"'4/+'("*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*%/+5>%"'",564&/"+:"*/'@&2"),7&,*)@&-"',("75-*+6-"7+,7&--)+,-"1'-"+/)>),'223")682&6&,*&("43"S'/7+-"*+"8/+@)(&"8/&:&/&,*)'2"*/&'*6&,*"*+"4'2);4'3',-<"N&7'5-&"*%&"S'/7+-"'(6),)-*/'*)+,?"*%/+5>%"'22"6',,&/-"+:":),',7)'2"6)-6','>&6&,*"',("8+2)*)7'2"7+//58*)+,?"%'("45)2*"',"&7+,+63"*%'*"1'-"

Page 94: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

`a"

&,*)/&23"(&8&,(&,*"+,"(&4*"'775652'*)+,?"%&"-*/'*&>)7'223")682&6&,*&("*%&"8/+>/'6"'-"'"-&7+,('/3"6&',-"+:"-&75/),>"*%&":2+1"+:":+/&)>,"')("',("/&6)**',7&"6+,&3"WBY',*+,"N2',7"!cceg"_+(/)>5&Y"#LL#X<"C*"1'-"'*"*%)-"6+6&,*"*%'*"4'2);4'3',-"4&7'6&"),*&>/'223"2),;&("*+"*%&"7+5,*/3t-"*+5/)-*"&7+,+63<"

$%&"*/5&"@'25&"+:"*%&"N'2);4'3',!8/+>/'6"/&-*&("%+1&@&/?",+*"),"*%&"6'*&/)'2":),',7)'2"7'8)*'2"(/'1,":/+6"),()@)(5'2"4'2);4'3',-"1%+"/&*5/,&("*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"45*"),"*%&"8&/:+/6',7&"+:"@'/)+5-"-*'*&"',("2+7'2"'>&,*-"1%+-&"2'4+/"(&8)7*&("*%&"7+5,*/3"'-"8+2)*)7'223"',("&7+,+6)7'223"-*'42&<"i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d$0-"_&-&'/7%"',("B*'*)-*)7-"J)@)-)+,"72')6&("*%'*"""

$%&">+@&/,6&,*"+:"7+5/-&?"%'-"2+-*"',(")-"2+-),>"'"/'*%&/"-54-*',*)'2"'6+5,*"+:"/&@&,5&":/+6"*%&"8/+>/'6<"N5*"*%&"4&,&:)*-"(&/)@&("43"*%&"7+5,*/3"'/&",+*"+,23":/+6"*%&":+/&)>,"75//&,73"-8&,*"%&/&\)*")-"'2-+"',"&::&7*)@&"6&',-"+:"/&45**),>"*%/+5>%"'7*5'2"&H8&/)&,7&"*%&"2)&-"*%&3"%'@&"-8/&'("'4+5*"*%)-"7+5,*/3"),":+/&)>,"2',(-<Mc"""$%&"/+2&"8&/:+/6&("43"*%&"&7+,+63"+:"'88&'/',7&-"1)*%),"*%&"Jd$"72&'/23"

)225-*/'*&-"*%&"6',,&/"),"1%)7%"(&@&2+86&,*"-7%&6&-"/&23"+,"6',5:'7*5/),>"',("/&>52'*),>"8542)7"8&/7&8*)+,-"'-"'"6&',-"+:"(/'1),>"-8&752'*)@&"7'8)*'2"*%'*"1)22"%+8&:5223"*/',-:+/6"),*+"2'/>&/"&7+,+6)7"/&*5/,-<"A+/"&H'682&?"*%&")(&+2+>3")682)7)*"1)*%),"*%&-&"8&/:+/6'*)@&"*&7%,)U5&-"1&/&"6'(&"8'*&,*23"72&'/"43"*%&"7+5,*/30-"Q_&5,)+,":+/"D&'7&R?"2'5,7%&("),"&'/23"!caa<"C,-8)/&("43"-)6)2'/"),)*)'*)@&-")682&6&,*&("43"*%&"'5*%+/)*'*)@&">+@&/,6&,*"),"B+5*%"l+/&'"*+"),-8)/&":'@+/'42&"/&@)&1-"'6+,>-*"7+68'*/)+*-"2)@),>"'4/+'(?"*%&"8/+>/'6"-8&7):)7'223"-54-)()Y&("*%&"/&*5/,"+:":+/6&/"P+/2("P'/"CC"-&/@)7&6&,"',("*%&)/":'6)2)&-"2)@),>"'4/+'(<"N3":5,,&2),>"*%&6"),*+",+-*'2>)7"*+5/-"+:"+2("4'**2&>/+5,(-"',("6&6+/)'2-"-57%"'-"*%+-&"),"K+//&>)(+/"',("N''*',?"*%&"'(6),)-*/'*)+,"%+8&("*+"8/&-&,*"*%&"7+5,*/3"'-"',"),(&8&,(&,*"',("(&6+7/'*)7",'*)+,9-*'*&"*%'*"1'-"7+66)**&("*+"8&'7&:52"/&7+,7)2)'*)+,<"N3"!ca`"'2+,&?",&'/23"'"6)22)+,"A)2)8),+-"%'("5*)2)Y&("*%&">+@&/,6&,*'2"8/+>/'6"',("6+/&")68+/*',*23?"*%&"8+-)*)@&"/&@)&1-"+:"@'/)+5-"4'2);4'3',-"1&/&"-577&--:5223"*/',-6)**&("*+"*%&)/"A)2)8),+-"/&-)(),>"),"V+/*%"E6&/)7'?".5/+8&?"',("E5-*/'2)'"W_)7%*&/"!c`c?"eLX<"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""Mc"C,*&/@)&1"7+,(57*&("43"i),('"_)7%*&/"),"N/#'!<-F&%5!/#'!+&(%*:5?"8<"!cZ<"

Page 95: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

``"

C,"*%&":'7&"+:"&@&/98/&-&,*"8+@&/*3?"8+225*)+,?"',("-%+/*'>&-"),"&,&/>3?"1'*&/?"',("%+5-),>?"'2+,>"1)*%"*%&"8542)7"-%'6&"'/+5,("*%&"7+5,*/30-"*%/)@),>"-&H"),(5-*/3?"',("+,>+),>":)-7'2"6)-6','>&6&,*"43"*%&"S'/7+-"'(6),)-*/'*)+,?"-54-&U5&,*"8/&-)(&,*-"%'@&"4&&,"7%'22&,>&("43"*%&"*'-;"+:"8/+88),>958"*+5/)-6"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("6'),*'),),>"*%&":'}'(&"+:"8/+-8&/)*3"*%'*"2&("*%&"7+5,*/3"),*+"&,+/6+5-"(&4*<"d,&"+:"D/&-)(&,*"K+/'Y+,"EU5),+0-"8/)6'/3"*+5/)-6"8+2)73"'>&,('-"1'-"*+"75*"*%&"45(>&*"+:"*%&"Jd$"',("&,-5/&"*%'*"*%&"6','>&6&,*"+:")*-":),',7&-"1&/&":+75-&("+,",'*)+,'2"(&@&2+86&,*"/'*%&/"*%',"8&/8&*5'*),>"'"-*/57*5/&"*%'*"%'("-8&,*"&H+/4)*',*"'6+5,*-"+:"*'H8'3&/"6+,&3"',("-%):*&("&7+,+6)7">'),-"*+1'/(-"8/)@'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"',("),()@)(5'2-<"

C,"8'/*)752'/?"-*'*&"'(6),)-*/'*+/-"1&/&";&&,23"'1'/&"+:"*%&"8&/7&8*)+,"7/&'*&("43"*%&"7+5,*/30-"%)-*+/)7'2"7+682'7&,73"*+1'/(-":+/&)>,"-&H"*+5/)-6"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"B*'*&9()/&7*&("8+2)7)&-"',("8542)7239&,(+/-&("),)*)'*)@&-"1&/&":+75-&("+,"*/',-:+/6),>"*%&":'7&"+:"D%)2)88),&"*+5/)-6"43"/)((),>"*%&",'*)+,0-"7'8)*'2"+:"*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:")*-"6+-*"@)-)42&"-&H"&-*'42)-%6&,*-"1%)2&"-)652*',&+5-23"/&:5-),>"*+"'22+1"*%&"),(5-*/3"*+":5,7*)+,"'2+,>"*%&"6'/>),-"W$'()'/"#LLbX<"A/+6"!cc!"*+"!ccb?"5,(&/"*%&"()/&7*)+,"+:"EU5),+"',("%&/"-577&--+/"A)(&2"_'6+-?"7)*3">+@&/,6&,*-"2&("*%&"72+-5/&"+:"-&H"&-*'42)-%6&,*-"'/+5,("S',)2'0-"$+5/)-*"N&2*?"8'/*)752'/23"),"./6)*'"',("S'2'*&<"A+/"&H'682&?"*%&":)/-*"'88+),*&("B&7/&*'/3"+:"$+5/)-6"'88+),*&("43"EU5),+?"k+-&"QB8&&(3R"E,*+,)+"h+,Y'2&Y?"U5)7;23")682&6&,*&("'"*+5/"8/+>/'6"*%'*"4/+5>%*"588&/972'--"k'8',&-&"1+6&,"*+"*+5/"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("8'/*';&"),")*-"*%/)@),>")68+/*"&7+,+63<"h+,Y'2&Y"%+8&("*%'*"-57%"*+5/-"1+52("8/+I&7*"',")6'>&"+:"*%&"7+5,*/3"'-"'"1%+2&-+6&"(&-*),'*)+,"/'*%&/"*%',"'"6'I+/",+(&":+/"-&H"*+5/)-6<eL"E-"-57%?"S',)2'0-"65,)7)8'2">+@&/,6&,*"*/',-:+/6&("8/&@)+5-23"45-*2),>"7+66&/7)'2"-&H"()-*/)7*-?"-8'7&-"*%'*"1&/&"(&&6&("),*&>/'2"*+"*%&"5/4',"&7+,+63"+:"*%&"VK_?"),*+"@)4/',*"7+66&/7)'2"2&)-5/&"()-*/)7*-"*%'*":&22"-&'62&--23"),*+"*%&"&6&/>),>"),:/'-*/57*5/&"+:"6'22-"',("%)>%9/)-&"8/+I&7*-"'2/&'(3"4&),>"45)2*"*%/+5>%+5*"S&*/+"S',)2'<"E*"*%&"-'6&"*)6&?"*%&"-&H"),(5-*/3"()(",+*"()-'88&'/"45*"1&/&"/&2&>'*&("*+"*%+-&"7)*)&-"',("()-*/)7*-"2&--"-)>,):)7',*"*+"*%&"7+/&"&7+,+63"+:"S',)2'"),-*&'(<"""

F+1&@&/?"*+"*%&"()-6'3"+:"*%&"VK_0-"'(6),)-*/'*+/-?"&::+/*-"*+">&,&/'*&"*+5/)-6"1)*%),"S&*/+"S',)2'"%'@&"7+,-)-*&,*23":')2&(":+/"*%&"@'/)+5-"/&'-+,-"'225(&("*+"&'/2)&/"),"*%&"7%'8*&/<".H&75*)@&-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3"1&/&"),7/&'-),>23"7+,@),7&("*%'*"(&@&2+86&,*"1+52("%'@&"*+"*';&"82'7&"'/+5,("*%&"8&/)8%&/3"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'"',("4&3+,(")*"),*+"*%&"2&--":/&U5&,*&("/&>)+,-"+:"*%&"7+5,*/30-"8/+@),7)'2"-8'7&-<"N3"*%&"6)(9!ccL-?"-*'*&"7+66)*6&,*-"*+"*+5/)-6"-%):*&("),":+75-"*+1'/(-"(&@&2+8),>"8/+@),7)'2"7)*)&-"',("*+1,-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'-"'"1'3"+:"2),;),>"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63"*+">/+1),>"EB.EV"*/'(&",&*1+/;<""$%&"Jd$"4&>',"&-*'42)-%),>"*+5/)-6"-)*&-"*%'*"1+52("(/'1"',"'//'3"+:"@)-)*+/-?"4+*%"2+7'2"',(":+/&)>,<"C,"+/(&/"*+"6&&*"*%&-&"2'/>&/">+'2-?"*%&"Jd$"),-*'22&("+::)7&-",+*"+,23"1)*%),"&@&/3"*+5/)-*"%54"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"45*"&H*&,(&(")*-"8/&-&,7&"),*&/,'*)+,'223"),"+::)7&-"-)*5'*&("*%/+5>%+5*"V+/*%"E6&/)7'?".5/+8&?"K%),'?"k'8',?"C,()'?"',("l+/&'<""

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""eL"WN'>5)+/+"#LL#X<"

Page 96: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

`c"

E2+,>"1)*%"@)-)*+/-":/+6"'/+5,("*%&">2+4&?"4'2);4'3',-"7+,*),5&"*+"82'3"',"),*&>/'2"/+2&"1)*%),"*%&"&7+,+6)7"82',-"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3<"$%&"S'45%'3"S',+/"8/+@)(&-"'"-6'22?"3&*")2256),'*),>"&H'682&"+:"*%&-&"&6&/>&,*"-*/'*&>)&-<"$%&"Jd$0-"8'/*,&/-%)8"1)*%"i&>&,(-"F+*&2-"C,*&/,'*)+,'2"+,"*%&"8/&-&,*'*)+,":+/"*%&"S'45%'3"S',+/"',("*%&"7+/8+/'*)+,-0"+*%&/"4'2);4'3',9:+75-&("%+*&2-"8/+@)(&-"*%&"6+-*"/&7&,*"&H'682&"+:"*%&"J&8'/*6&,*0-"),*&/,'*)+,'2"8/&-&,7&<"i&("43"/&8/&-&,*'*)@&-":/+6"4+*%"i&>&,(-"',("*%&"Jd$?"+,&"+:"*%&":)/-*"8/&-&,*'*)+,-"1&/&"%&2("'*"_+4&/*+0-?"'"A)2)8),+"/&-*'5/',*"),"J'23"K)*3?"),"#LL`<"_&,&"J&"i+-"B',*+-?"*%&"V+/*%&/,"K'2):+/,)'"J)/&7*+/":+/"*%&"Jd$?"'((/&--&("*%&")68+/*',7&"+:"4'2);4'3',9:+75-&("),(5-*/)&-?"6&,*)+,),>"Q$%&"J&8'/*6&,*"+:"$+5/)-6")-"'2-+"82',,),>"*+">)@&"+5*"),7&,*)@&-":+/"*%&"A)2)8),+"-8&7)'2)-*-\$%)-")-"'2-+"',"+88+/*5,)*3":+/"*/'@&2"'>&,*-"*+"&H8',("*%&)/"6'/;&*?"'-"1&22"'-"*+"&'/,"6+/&"),7+6&R"W@+,"P&**4&/>"#LL`X<""

C,"#LLc?"(5/),>"'"6&&*),>"4&*1&&,"*%&"D%)2)88),&"_&*)/&6&,*"E5*%+/)*3"WD_EX"',("&H&75*)@&-":/+6"*%&"D%)2)88),&"_&*)/&6&,*"C,(5-*/3"WD_CX?"*%&"/&8/&-&,*'*)@&"*+"*%&"8/)@'*&"-&7*+/?"2&'(&/-"()-75--&("*%&"-)>,):)7',*"/+2&"*%'*"4'2);4'3',-"82'3&("),")68/+@),>"*%&"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3"',("(&@&2+8),>"*%&"2'/>&/"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63<"i&'(&/-"&H82'),&("*%'*"*%&"&,*/&8/&,&5/)'2"@)-)+,"4&%),("*%&"7/&'*)+,"+:"'"/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/3")-"*+"o4&7+6&"'"2'/>&"+/>',)Y'*)+,"7+68+-&("+:"652*)9-&7*+/'2"6&64&/-":/+6"()::&/&,*"2),&-"+:"45-),&--"/&2'*),>"*+"*%&"%+5-),>?"%&'2*%?"',("2):&-*32&",&&(-"+:"/&*)/&&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-R"&H82'),&("*%&"D_E0-"7%)&:".(>'/(+"E>2)8'3"WE2'@&"#LLaX<".H&75*)@&-"72&'/23"'7;,+12&(>&("*%&",+*)+,"*%'*"4'2);4'3',-"1+52("4&"7/57)'2"*+"*%&"&6&/>&,7&"+:"*%)-"652*)9-&7*+/'2"),(5-*/3<"

$%&"D_E"7%)&:"'2-+"()-75--&("*%&"%),(/',7&-"7+,-*/'),),>"*%&">/+1*%"+:"4+*%"*%&"*+5/)-6"',("/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/)&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"F&"-*'*&("*%'*"6&()'"/&8+/*-"7+,*),5'223"8+/*/'3&("'"8)7*5/&"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'-"'"7/)6&92'(&,?"7%'+*)7?"',("()/*3"7+5,*/3"*&&6),>"1)*%";)(,'88&/-<"oP&"%'@&"'"4)*"+:"'"8/+42&6"%&/&?"4&7'5-&"+:"8&/7&8*)+,?o"%&"&H82'),&("*+"6&64&/-"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&"6&()'<"$%&-&"o,&>'*)@&")68/&--)+,-?o"*%&"D%)2)88),&"_&*)/&6&,*"E>&,73"WD_EX">&,&/'2"6','>&/"A&/,',(+"q<"A/',7)-7+"'>/&&(?"Q%'@&"%'68&/&("&::+/*-"*+">&*"),@&-*+/-"',("/&*)/&&-"*+"@)-)*<R"QC*t-"*%&",&>'*)@&")68/&--)+,<"$%'*t-"+5/"4)>>&-*"7+,7&/,?R"S/<"E>2)8'3"-')(?"Q),"*/'(&"6)--)+,-"'4/+'(?"*%&"7+66+,"U5&-*)+,")-"%+1"-':&")-"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"S+/&"+:*&,"*%',",+*"*%&"(+54*&/-"%'@&",&@&/"4&&,"*+"*%&"7+5,*/3R"WE2'@&"#LLaX<"

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

Page 97: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

cL"

./0*12/3/#!;/%/#&*/""N'7;"),"J'23"K)*3?"C"&'>&/23"'>/&&("*+"'--)-*"*%&"K'/(&,'-"1)*%"-+6&"+:"*%&)/"

8'7;),>"4&:+/&"*%&3"(&8'/*&("*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"$%&3"(&-)>,'*&("'"-6'22"-&7*)+,"+:"*%&)/"(),),>"/++6":+/"7/:/0(2&#8!',(!7/'/0/[LG"d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f"-&7+,("',("*%)/(9%',("*9-%)/*-"*%'*"1&/&"72&'/23"8'--&("'2+,>"*%&"2),&"+:"K'/(&,'-":'6)23":/+6"-)42),>"*+"-)42),><"Q$%&3"2+@&",'6&"4/',(-"4'7;"%+6&<"B+"C"*+2("*%&";)(-"*+">)@&"6&"*%&)/"+2("72+*%),>"45*"(&-)>,&/"72+*%),><"_+H3?"F5/2&3?"&-8&7)'223"h'8?R"_+-&6'/)&"6&,*)+,&(<"$%&"(&2)7'*&"8&,6',-%)8"*%'*"_+-&6'/)&"'882)&("*+"&'7%"4+H?"1%)7%"72&'/23"-*'*&("*%&"'((/&--"+:"%&/"-)-*&/-"4'7;"%+6&"),"42'7;"8&/6',&,*"),;?"'88&'/&("6)-82'7&("'6+,>-*"*%&"()-'//'3"+:"7+//5>'*&("4+H&-"-7'**&/&("'/+5,("*%&"*)2&(":2++/<""

B&@&/'2"+:"*%&"4+H&-"1&/&"3&22+1?"6'/;&("43"*%&"*/'(&6'/;"2+>+"+:"*%&"7'/>+"-&,(&/"EiEB<"d@&/"*%&"8'-*"(&7'(&-?"(++/9*+9(++/"-&,(),>"7+68',)&-?"4&,&:)*),>":/+6"*%&"@'/)+5-"),7&,*)@&-"7/&'*&("43"*%&">/+1),>"4'2);4'3',"8/+>/'6?"%'@&"4&7+6&"'"8+852'/"6&',-"+:"*/',-8+/*),>">++(-"',("/&6)**),>"6+,&3"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-",+*"+,23":/+6"V+/*%"E6&/)7'?".5/+8&?"',("E5-*/'2)'"45*"+*%&/"(&-*),'*)+,-"8+852'*&("43"4'2);4'3',-"',("dAP-"2);&"J54')"',("B),>'8+/&<e#"$%&";,*0*77*#-!Q->:?"/&8+/*),>"+,"*%&"-)>,):)7',7&"+:"/&6)**',7&-"',("Q4'2);4'3',""4+H&-R"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63"72')6&("*%'*"43"!c`c?"*%&"4'2);4'3',""4+H"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""e!"D'('2'"6&',-"o7+,-)>,6&,*o"+/"6+/&"'775/'*&23?"o'")*&6"*%'*")-"7+,-)>,&(o<"$%&"1+/("7+,@&3-"'"7+66+,"752*5/'2"8/'7*)7&?"5/87/'/0/"+/"*%&"*/'()*)+,"+:"'775652'*),>">++(-"*+"*';&"4'7;"%+6&"',(">)@&"*+":'6)23"6&64&/-?":/)&,(-?"',(",&)>%4+/-<"i);&"8'-'254+,>"+/">):*-?"8'('2'"7+68/)-&-"+,&":'7&*"'2+,>"1)*%":),',7)'2"/&6)**',7&-?"/&6)**',7&"',("7'/>+"7+68',)&-?"*%'*"%&28-"),)*)'*&"*%&"N'2);4'3',"&7+,+63<""e#"C,()@)(5'2-"+/":'6)2)&-"'/&"'22+1&("*+":)22"4'2);4'3',"4+H&-"1)*%"'",564&/"+:",+,98&/)-%'42&"',("2&>'223"8&/6)**&(")*&6-"),725(),>"%+5-&%+2("8/+(57*-?"'882)',7&-"',("-6'22"&2&7*/+,)7-?"7',,&(">++(-?"*+3-?"',("6+-*"+:*&,"72+*%),><"$38)7'223?"*%&-&"7+//5>'*&("4+H&-"8/+7&&("*%/+5>%"*%/&&"-*&8-f"A)/-*?"+,7&"'"4+H")-"/&>)-*&/&(":+/"(&2)@&/3"+/"8)7;&("58"43"*%&"7'/>+":+/1'/(&/?"*%&3"'/&"7+,-+2)('*&("1)*%"+*%&/"-%)86&,*-"',("82'7&("),"7+,*'),&/"@',-<"J&8&,(),>"+,"*%&"-&'-+,"+/"@+256&"+:"-%)86&,*-?"7'/>+"-&,(&/-"*38)7'223"-%)8"*%&)/"7'/>+"+,7&"'"1&&;<"d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i+7-),?"oA'-%)+,),>"'"K52*5/&"*%/+5>%"N'>5)+"K)*30-"=;'39=;'3"?o"),""Q+4<?!A!4(%&7-/#!D(0$(%/0!E$('*-:!D&#F-%-#)-!*#!E>-'-#"WV+//;n8),>f"E(@',7&("K52*5/'2"B*5()&-"C,-*)*5*&"+:"B1&(&,"WEKBCBX"?"#LLaX?"!9c<""

Page 98: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

c!"

45-),&--"%'("4&&,"7+,*/)45*),>"b<#<"4)22)+,"8&-+-"W=BJj"!cL"6)22)+,X"',,5'223"*+"*%&"+@&/'22"&7+,+63<"d:"*%&-&"8'/*)752'/":+/6-"+:"/&6)**',7&-?"Z<Z"4)22)+,"8&-+-"1+/*%"1&,*"()/&7*23"*+":'6)2)&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'-"4'-)7"6'*&/)'2">++(-?"1%)2&"!MM"6)22)+,"8&-+-"%'("4&&,"7+,*/)45*&("*+"*%&"B*'*&"*%/+5>%"8'36&,*-":+/"75-*+6"(5*)&-"',("-%)88),>"*'H&-?"',("*%&"/&6'),),>"6+,)&-"%'(">+,&"*+"-%)88),>"7+68',)&-"WS''-"#LL`g"N'-7%?"h2)7;"B7%)22&/?"',("BY',*+,"N2',7"!ccbX<"S',3"+:"*%&-&"45-),&--&-"'/&"7+,7&,*/'*&("),"'/&'-"1)*%"-)>,):)7',*"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*)&-?"8'/*)752'/23"),"K'2):+/,)'"',("V&@'('<"E2+,>"1)*%"J'23"K)*3?"E2'-"K'/>+"%'-"-%)88),>"7&,*&/-"),"i'-"G&>'-"',("&2&@&,"+*%&/"K'2):+/,)',"7)*)&-<"E2'-"%'-"4&7+6&"'"8/&&6),&,*"&H'682&"+:"*%&">2+4'2"7)/752'*)+,"+:">++(-"',("-&/@)7&-"8/+(57&("*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"4'2);4'3',"&7+,+63<"$%&"-6'22"7+68',3"'2+,&"-&,(-"!LL9#LL"4+H&-"(5/),>"1&&;('3-"',("58"*+"bLL9eLL"4+H&-"+,"1&&;&,(-"WE2'-"K'/>+"#LLaX<""

i&>)*)6'*&"7'/>+"-&,(),>"7+68',)&-?"2);&"E2'-"K'/>+?"8/+@)(&"'"@'25'42&"-&/@)7&":+/"A)2)8),+-"1%+"'/&"&'>&/"*+"58%+2("*%&)/":'6)2)'2"(5*)&-"',(">)@&"-&,(&/-"*%&"'--5/',7&"*%'*"*%&)/"7/:/0(2&#8"',("7/'/0/"1)22"'//)@&"-':&23"*+"*%&)/"(&-)>,'*&("'((/&--&&-"WBY',*+,"N2',7"!cceX<"K'/>+"4+H&-"%'@&",+*+/)+5-23"4&&,"(&2'3&("),">+@&/,6&,*"1'/&%+5-&-?"8'/*)752'/23"1%&,"-&,(),>"/&2)&:":+/"()-'-*&/"&@&,*-<"d*%&/"*)6&-?"/&7)8)&,*-"%'@&"7+682'),&("*%'*"4+H&-"%'@&"4&&,"2+-*"+/"-*+2&,<"_&+/>',)Y),>"*%&"7+,*&,*-"+:"+,&"+:"%&/"4'2);4'3',"4+H&-?"_+-&6'/)&"8522&("+5*"'"2)>%*9425&"-5&(&"85/-&"1)*%")*-"*),3"6&*'2"45**+,-"-&1,"*+")*-"4'-&"8/+*/5(),>"*+1'/(-"6&<"B%&"%&2("*%&":/)22&("2&'*%&/"*'--&2"%',>),>":/+6"*%&"2'/>&"-)2@&/"Y)88&/"4&*1&&,"%&/":),>&/-"',("&H82'),&(f""

B&&?"3+5",&@&/";,+1"1)*%"A)2)8),+-"),"75-*+6-<"C*0-"&'-3"*+"8'3"-+6&4+(3"+::"',("1&"(+,0*"%'@&"*%&"6+,&3":+/"*%'*<"K',"3+5")6'>),&["C*0-"&'-)&/"*+"8'3"*%&"=BJ"j!ML"*+"-&,("*%/&&"4+H&-"*%&,"*+"%'@&"*%&")*&6-"-*+2&,<"$%&"2'-*"*)6&"C"1'-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"63",)&7&"'-;&("6&?"u$)*'?"7',"3+5"-&,("6&"+,&"+:"3+5/"K+'7%"4'>-?"#/87/'/0/!#/!0/#8!7&!z82&'-&"I5-*"-&,(")*"),"'"4'2);4'3',"4+H{0<"$%&30/&"+4-&--&("1)*%"(&-)>,&/"*%),>-<"C*0-"&'-3"*+"85*"6',3"*%),>-"),"'"4+H<"k5-*"%',(96&"(+1,-":/+6"*%&";)(-<"$%&3"(+,0*"5-&"*%&6"',36+/&?"*%&30@&"+5*9>/+1,"*%&6<"P&"85*"*%&6"'22"%&/&"',("'2-+"-&,("*%&6"1)*%"7(-"',("(@(-<"$%),>-"*%&3"7',0*"453"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"C";,+1"*%'*"*%)-"1'3"z-&,(),>")*"*%/+5>%"E2'-{?")*"1)22"'//)@&"*%&/&<"

"=*)2)Y),>"*%&"-&/@)7&-"+:"-&,(),>"7+68',)&-"'2-+"8/+@)(&"',"'2*&/,'*)@&":+/"

7'//3),>")*&6-"(5/),>"'"*/)8"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"=,(&/"*%&-&"8&/7&)@&("*%/&'*-"+:"7+//58*)+,?"@)+2&,7&?"',("65/(&/?"4'2);4'3',-"-+6&*)6&-"/&:/'),":/+6"*/'@&2),>"4'7;"%+6&"1)*%"8/&7)+5-"I&1&2/3"+/"&H8&,-)@&"&2&7*/+,)7-<"QP%&,"C"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"C">)@&"'22"+:"*%&6"63"5-&("(&-)>,&/"-*5::<"O+5";,+1?"2);&"h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

Page 99: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

c#"

*%&3"'/&"-+6&%+1"&,-5/),>"*%&"1&2:'/&"+:"4+*%"*%&)/"1/7/5*03/"',("*%&6-&2@&-"):"*%&3"7%++-&"*+"/&*5/,"*+"*%&)/"%+6&2',(":+/">++(<"

P%)2&"),")*-"&@&/3('3"5-'>&"8'/',+)'"*&,(-"*+"4&"),*&/8/&*&("'-":&&2),>-"+:"8&/-&75*)+,"+/"*%/&'*"*%'*"'/&"5,I5-*):)&("),"/&'2)*3?"'-"N5/>),"W!cc!X"&H82'),-?"*%&-&":&&2),>-?"1%&*%&/"'7*5'2"+/":)7*)+,'2?"Q8/+(57&"/&'2"&::&7*-"),"*%&"8/&-&,*<Re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

C,"5-),>"*%&"8%/'-&"4'2);4'3',"8'/',+)'?"C"'6"#&$"'**&68*),>"*+"6';&"*%&"'/>56&,*"*%'*"7/)6&"',("@)+2&,7&"'/&",+,9&H)-*&,*"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"+/"&@&,"*+"-'3"*%'*"*%&-&"+775//&,7&-"'/&",+*"8/&@'2&,*<"S3"7+,7&8*"+:"4'2);4'3',"8'/',+)'"2)&-"),"*%&"1'3-"),"1%)7%"/&*5/,),>"A)2)8),+-"%'@&?"2);&"+*%&/"&2)*&"',("8/)@)2&>&("7+665,)*)&-?"7/&'*&("'"1+/2(":+/"*%&6-&2@&-"45)2*"'/+5,("*%&-&":&'/-"',("',H)&*)&-"*%'*">+@&/,"),"6',3"1'3-"%+1"*%&3"'7*"),"/&2'*)+,"*+"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<eb"$%&"8%/'-&"4'2);4'3',"8'/',+)'"'22+1-"6&"*+"&68%'-)Y&"*%&"/'*)+,'2)Y'*)+,-"',("4&%'@)+/"&H%)4)*&("43"/&*5/,),>"A)2)8),+-"',("*%&"&H82+)*'*)+,"+:"*%)-"2+>)7"43"'"2)*',3"+:"45-),&--&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"1%)7%"*+>&*%&/"6';&-"*%&"8'/',+)'"'"@&/3"/&'2"*%),>"/&>'/(2&--"+:"*%&"/)$(/0"@)+2&,7&"*%'*"&H)-*-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"

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c`cX"8/),*&("'"2)-*"+:"Q*)8-R":+/"4'2);4'3',-"/&*5/,),>"*+"VECE"',("-5>>&-*&("*%'*?"Q),"S',)2'?"6),)6)Y&"'(@&/*)-),>"3+5/-&2:"'-"4'2);4'3',<"$%+-&"4+H&-"1)*%"*%&"4'2);4'3',"2&**&/-"&642'Y+,&("+,"*%&6"7',"4&"3+5/"()-7+6:+/*"+/"(&'*%<R""

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eZ"P%)2&"()-75--),>"*%&"1'3-"),"1%)7%",'*)+,'2)-6"',("/'7)-6"7/&'*&"Q8'/',+)("-*/57*5/&-R?"G)7*+/"N5/>),"/&*5/,-"*+"8-37%+','23*)7"*%&+/3"),"+/(&/"*+"7+,@&3"%+1"8'/',+)'"/&8/&-&,*-"*%&"-8'7&"4&*1&&,"8&/7&8*)+,"),"7+,-7)+5-,&--?"7+,7&8*-"*%'*"%'@&"4&7+6&"Q:/+Y&,"),"+88+-)*)+,R"2);&":',*'-3"',("/&'2)*3"WN5/>),"!cc!?"##X<"eb"E>'),"K'2()&/'0-"W#LLLX"1+/;"+,":+/*):)&("&,72'@&-"',("*%&"752*5/&"+:"%38&/9-&>/&>'*)+,"8/+(57&("43"*%&6"1)*%),"B�+"D'52+")-"8'/*)752'/23")2256),'*),><"

Page 100: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

cZ"

2'5>%&(<"D&/)+()7'223?"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"4&7+6&-"'"%+-*"*+"+5*4/&';-"+:"(&,>5&":&@&/"',("-54-&U5&,*23"*+5/)-*-"'/&"'(@)-&("*+"*';&"8/&7'5*)+,-":+/")*"4&:+/&":23),>"4'7;"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<eM"J&,>+3?"+,"*%&"+*%&/"%',(?")-"*%&"7+22+U5)'2"*&/6":+/"-1),(2),><".H&682):3),>"*%&"7%'/'7*&/)-*)7":+,(,&--"*%'*"A)2)8),+-"%'@&":+/"85,-"',("+*%&/":+/6-"+:"1+/("82'3?".Y6&/'2('0-"4/+*%&/"1'-"7+68'/),>"*%&"*%/&'*"+:"(&,>5&"1)*%"*%&"+,>+),>"*%/&'*"+:"2+7'2"A)2)8),+-"7%&'*),>"4'2);4'3',-"+:"*%&)/"6+,&3"+/"(&,>+3<"

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ee"QC*0-"4&7+6&"-+"4'("*%'*"C",&@&/"*';&"'"*'H)"1)*%+5*"63"%5-4',(?R".Y6&/'2('"&H82'),-?"8+),*),>"+5*"*%&"8'/*)752'/23">&,(&/&(",'*5/&"+:"*%&-&"',H)&*)&-<"E*"*%&"6+6&,*?".Y6&/'2('")-"-*'3),>"),"'"*1+94&(/++6"7+,(+6),)56"*%'*"-%&"85/7%'-&("1)*%"%&/"%5-4',("_+-'/)+?",&'/"x5&Y+,"K)*3<""

"C"(+,0*">+"',31%&/&"1)*%+5*"%)6<"C"(+,0*";,+1"%+1"',3"1+6',"1+52("6';&"*%&"(&7)-)+,"*+"7+6&"4'7;"%&/"',("/&*)/&"1)*%+5*"*%&)/"%5-4',(<"C"(+,0*"*/5-*"*%&"8&+82&"%&/&<"P)*%+5*"63"%5-4',(?"*%&3"1+52("&'-)23"*';&"'(@',*'>&"+:"6&<"O+5"%&'/"'4+5*")*"'22"*%&"*)6&"+,"*%&",&1-"z),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-{<"S3"4/+*%&/-"',("-)-*&/-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"7'22"6&"'22"*%&"*)6&<"O&-?"*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:<".@&,"*%&3"'/&"1+//)&("'4+5*"%+1"C"'6"%&/&<"B+"C"1+,(&/"):"*%)-"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""eM"N56"J<"$&,+/)+"k/<?"J527&"E/>5&22&-"',("A2+/&,7)+"D<"V'/)*+?"oZL?LLL"N'2);4'3',-"B*'3"E1'3?o"6/#*0/!E$/#'/%'?"B&8*&64&/"#b?"!cc`<"ee"E"/&7&,*"&H'682&"'88&'/&("),"'"V&1"O+/;"$)6&-"'/*)72&"/&8+/*),>"+,"*%&",564&/"+:"-&,-&2&--"65/(&/-"7'8)*52'*&("43"8&/8&*/'*+/-"),7&,-&("43"*%&)/"@)7*)6t-"8++/";'/'+;&"/&,()*)+,"+:"A/',;"B),'*/'t-"72'--)7"-+,>"oS3"P'3o<"B&&"Wd,)-%)"#L!LX<"

Page 101: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

cb"

1'-"*%&"/)>%*"7%+)7&":+/"6&"*+"7+6&"4'7;<"N5*"C"1+52(",&@&/"(+")*"1)*%+5*"63"%5-4',(<"

"B%&":/&&23"'(6)*-"*%'*"*%&"*/',-)*)+,"*+"2)@),>"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'-"4&&,"()::)752*<"B*)22"1)*%+5*"'"7'/?"-%&"/'/&23"*/'@&2-"'*",)>%*<"C*")-"'">2'/),>"7+68/)-&"',("-*'/;"()::&/&,7&"*+"*%&"2):&"-%&"2)@&("'-"'"1+6',"),"K'2):+/,)'"1%&,"-%&"1+52(":/&U5&,*23"*';&"&@&,),>"(',7&"72'--&-"1)*%"%&/"%5-4',("+/"+77'-)+,'223"@&,*5/&"*+"*%&"7'-),+"',("82'3"42'7;I'7;"1)*%":/)&,(-"*)22"&'/23"),"*%&"6+/,),><""

.Y6&/'2('")-"%+8&:52"%+1&@&/"*%'*"*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'"),"$'>'3*'3"*%'*"-%&"',("%&/"%5-4',("85/7%'-&("1)22"4/),>"4'7;"-+6&"+:"*%&":'6)2)'/)*3"*%'*"-%&"2+-*"1%&,"/&*5/,),>"*+"S',)2'<".@&,"*%+5>%"*%&3"%'@&"',+*%&/"3&'/"*+"1')*"4&:+/&"*%&3"7',"6+@&"),*+"*%&)/",&1"/&-)(&,7&?"*%&"'229),725-)@&"'6&,)*)&-?"7+,-*',*"-&75/)*3?"',("Q>++(",&)>%4+/-R"'/&"'22"&2&6&,*-"*%'*"7+68&22&(".Y6&/'2('"',("_+-'/)+"*+"),@&-*"'"6'I+/)*3"+:"*%&)/"-'@),>-"),*+"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*-<"""

N&:+/&"1&"6+@&("%&/&?"1&"*%+5>%*"1&"6'(&"'">++("82',<"V+1"C"-&&")*0-"6+/&"()::)752*"*+"-*'/*"'"45-),&--"%&/&"*%',"C"*%+5>%*<"V+1"*%'*"C"6)>%*"4&"'42&"*+"+8&,"'"-*+/&"%&/&?"1&22?"1&0/&"4',;),>"+,"+5/",&1"%+6&"z),"$'>'3*'3{<"C"I5-*"1',*"*+"%'@&"*%&"2):&"1&"%'("),"*%&"B*'*&-"4'7;<"N5*"1&"7',0*">+"4'7;"*%&/&"-+"1&"I5-*"%+8&"1&"7',"%'@&")*"%&/&?".Y6&/'2('"&H8/&--&(?"%&/"@+)7&"()66&/),>"1)*%"(+54*<""

"$%&"&6+*)+,'2"*+22"*%'*"/&*5/,"6';&-")-"&H*/'+/(),'/3<"A)22&("1)*%"5,7&/*'),*3?"*%&"I+5/,&3"%+6&")-"1/+5>%*"1)*%"&,+/6+5-"5,-&&,"7+-*-<"P%)2&"()::)752*"*+"7'8*5/&"),"*%&)/"&,*)/&*3?"*%&-&"',H)&*)&-"'/&"'2-+"6',):&-*&("()::&/&,*23?",+*"+,23"'7/+--"*%&"()::&/&,*)'*&("72'--"2),&-"+:"4'2);4'3',-"',("dAP-"/&*5/,),>"45*"'/&"'2-+":&2*"()::&/&,*"4&*1&&,"A)2)8),+"6&,"',("1+6&,"1%+"'/&"/&*5/,),><""P%'*"%'("4&>5,":+/".Y6&/'2('"'-"'"4/)>%*",&1"45-),&--"@&,*5/&?"7+,:/+,*&("43"'"@&/3"/&'2"-&,-&"+:"',H)&*3"',(":&'/"+:":')25/&?"%&/"/&*5/,"%'(")/+,)7'223"8/+8&22&("'",&1"(&-)/&"*+"+,7&"'>'),">+"4'7;g",+*"4'7;"%+6&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"45*"4'7;"*+"*%&"=<B<"

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g"45*":+/"*%&"4'2);4'3',-"1%+"(+"/&*5/,?"*%&3"&'-)23"/'*)+,'2)Y&"*%&"&H7&--"&H8&,()*5/&-":+/"@'/)+5-"-&/@)7&-"',(">++(-"),"+/(&/"*+"&,-5/&"*%&)/"+1,"-':&*3<"N'2);4'3',-"7+,*),5'223":&'/"*%&"7+//58*)+,"+:"8+2)7&"+::)7&/-"',("*'H)"(/)@&/-?"*%&"8/+4'4)2)*3"+:"%'@),>"*+"4/)4&"'"8542)7"-&/@',*?"+/"&@&,"*%&"7%',7&"*%'*"*%&3"1)22"4&";)(,'88&(<""

A+/"*%+-&"1%+"7',"'::+/(")*?"A)2)8),+-"1%+"'/&":+/7&("+/"6';&"*%&"7%+)7&"*+"/&*5/,"1)22">2'(23"8'3"%)>%"8/)7&-":+/"25H5/)+5-"%+*&2"',("/&-+/*"'77+66+('*)+,-?"8/)@'*&"(/)@&/-?"',("4+(3">5'/(-?"),"+/(&/"*+"&,-5/&"*%&)/"-':&*3<"E*"*%&"-'6&"*)6&?"

Page 102: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

cM"

(&@&2+8&/-?"8/)@'*&"),@&-*+/-?"',("-*'*&"'>&,7)&-"'/&"'7*)@&23"&H82+)*),>"*%&-&"7+6852-)+,-?"2)*&/'223"4',;),>"+,"*%&"8'/',+)'"',("4'2);4'3',0-"(&-)/&":+/"-&75/)*3<"G'/)+5-"'>&,7)&-"',("8/+>/'6-"%'@&"4&&,"(&@&2+8&("*+"&,-5/&"*%&"-&75/)*3"+:"4'2);4'3',-"1%+"(&-)/&"*+"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("&,I+3"@'/)+5-"'6&,)*)&-"1)*%+5*"*%&":&'/"+:"4&),>"/+44&("+/"-1),(2&(<"$%&"Jd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i)@),>"F&/+&-"'*"$%&"S'45%'3"S',+/R<"$%&",&1-"'/*)72&"7+,*),5&-"*+"-'3f"

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

"C,"*%&"&,(?"43"-577&--:5223"7+,@),7),>"4'2);4'3',-"*+"/&*5/,"',("2)@&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"*%&"B*'*&"%'-"&::&7*)@&23"'7%)&@&("-+6&*%),>"*%'*"S'/7+-",&@&/"7+52("*%/+5>%"*%&"*+5/)-6"),(5-*/3<"P%&/&"4'2);4'3',-"+,7&"&64+()&("'-"_':'&2"W#LLLX"-5>>&-*-?"Q*%&":52:)226&,*"+:"A)2)8),+"(&-)/&-"/&'2)Y'42&"+,23"&($:*'-"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-R?"*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/3"/&7+,:)>5/&-"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'-"*%&"&,(),>"8+),*"),"1%)7%"*%&"*/5&"/&'2)Y'*)+,"+:"*%&-&"(&-)/&-"%'88&,<"

Page 103: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ce"

"""""""""""""""

D,/7$-%!I!!

E7/)-:!&F!./0*12/3/#!Q-&0*2-%/0*:5!!

+&(%*:$*)!e&#-:!/#'!E7-)*/0!<-:*'-#$!<-$*%--!M*:/:!!

Page 104: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

ca"

90/:%-&!U!"$%&"8+2)*)7'2"',("2&>'2"/%&*+/)7"*%'*"'*"*)6&-"%+6+>&,)Y&-"*%&"*1+"6+-*"

-)>,):)7',*">/+58),>-"+:"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"'4/+'(?"8&/6',&,*"A)2)8),+"&6)>/',*-"',("dAP-?"7+,7&'2-"*%&")68+/*',*"&7+,+6)7":5,7*)+,'2)*)&-?"',("6+/&")68+/*',*23?"*%&"()-*),7*23"()::&/&,*"2)@&("&H8&/)&,7&-"+:"&)*%&/"7+22&7*)@&<"_&7&,*"%)>%23"8542)7)Y&("7'-&-"),@+2@),>"'45-&-"'>'),-*"(+6&-*)7"1+/;&/-"%'@&"%'("*%&"(5'29&::&7*"+:"7'-*),>"dAP-"'-"4+*%"%)>%23"@52,&/'42&"Q@)7*)6-R"',("+:*&,"&H82+)*&("Q2+19-;)22&(R"2'4+/&/-"/&>'/(2&--"+:"*%&)/"()@&/-&"',("+:*&,*)6&-"7+22&>&"&(57'*&("4'7;>/+5,(-"+/"*%&",56&/+5-"*/',-,'*)+,'2":&6),)-*-"6+@&6&,*-"*%'*"%'@&"4&&,"2&("8'/*23"43"*%&-&"-'6&"(+6&-*)7"1+/;&/-"Wi'1"#LL#g"D'//&T'-"#LL!g"_+(/)>5&Y"#LL#X<"=,2);&"*%&)/"4'2);4'3',"7+5,*&/8'/*-"1%+"'/&"7'8'42&"+:"72')6),>"/)>%*-">/',*&("*%/+5>%"*%&"7)*)Y&,-%)8"*%&3">'),&(":/+6"+*%&/"7+5,*/)&-?"43",'*5/&"+:"*%&)/"*&68+/'/3"-*'*5-?"*%&"/)>%*-"+:"dAP-"'/&"-54-56&("',("/&>52'*&("1)*%),"'"D%)2)88),&"8+2)*)7'2"-3-*&6"*%'*"1)22"6+/&"+:*&,"7%++-&"*+"-':&>5'/(")*-"&7+,+6)7"/&2'*)+,-%)8"1)*%"+*%&/"7+5,*/)&-"/'*%&/"*%',"(&:&,(),>"*%&"/)>%*-"+:"7)*)Y&,-"1%+"&,7+5,*&/"%56',"+/"2'4+/"/)>%*-"@)+2'*)+,-"),"*%&)/"7+5,*/3"+:"&682+36&,*"Wd,>"#LLeX<""

_&23),>"+,"E)%1'"d,>0-"*%&+/3"+:"8+-*(&@&2+86&,*?"_+(/)>5&Y"W#L!LX"'/>5&-"*%'*"43"7+,*/'7*),>"A)2)8),+-"*+"1+/;"*%/+5>%+5*"'",564&/"+:"B8&7)'2".7+,+6)7"q+,&-"WB.qX"8'/*)752'/23"*%/+5>%"*%&"*/'(),>",&*1+/;"+:"*%&"EB.EV"-*'*&-?"*%&"D%)2)88),&"-*'*&">)@&-"'"8+/*)+,"+:")*-"-+@&/&)>,*3"*+"7+/8+/'*&"&,*)*)&-<""E*"*%&"-'6&"*)6&?"%+1&@&/?"2+7'2"&2)*&-"'/&"'22+1&("*+"6'),*'),"*%&)/"&7+,+6)7"-+@&/&)>,*3"(5&"*+"*%&)/"&,*/&,7%&("8+-)*)+,-"1)*%),"*%&"2+,>9-*',(),>"2',("*&,5/&"-3-*&6"',("*%&)/"6+,+8+2)Y'*)+,"+:"7'8)*'2"%+2(),>-<""E77+/(),>"*+"_+(/)>5&Y?"&H8+/*),>"A)2)8),+"2'4+/"'4/+'(":'7)2)*'*&-"'",564&/"+:"-*'*&"),*&/&-*-f"""

S)>/'*)+,"'4-+/4-"*%&"&H7&--"+:"2'4+/&/-"*%'*")-",&7&--'/)23"8/+(57&("1%&,"*%&"-*'*&"'4',(+,-")*-"-+@&/&)>,*3"*+"652*),'*)+,'2-0"',("652*)2'*&/'2-0"(&6',(-":+/"&H8+/*98/+(57*)+,g"6)>/'*)+,")-"'2-+"'"u4)+8+2)*)7'2"),@&-*6&,*0"8/+@)(),>"&682+36&,*"',("),7+6&"*+"7)*)Y&,-"',("*%&/&43"8/&-&/@),>"*%&"8+2)*)7'2"',("&7+,+6)7"-*'*5-"+:"*%&"&2)*&"W!eX<"

"E2*%+5>%"+,"*%&"-5/:'7&?"*%&"D%)2)88),&"-*'*&"%'-"&-8+5-&("'"/%&*+/)7"+:"8/+*&7*),>"*%&"/)>%*-"+:"dAP-"'/+5,("*%&"1+/2(?"&@&,"8'--),>"*%&"_&8542)7"E7*"V+<"`Lb#"+,"k5,&?"!ccM"1%)7%"1+52("'88'/&,*23"7+,7/&*)Y&"*%&">+@&/,6&,*0-"7+66)*6&,*"*+"8/+*&7*"*%&"/)>%*-"',("8/+6+*&"*%&"1&2:'/&"+:"6)>/',*"1+/;&/-?"*%&)/":'6)2)&-?"',("+*%&/"+@&/-&'-"A)2)8),+-"),"()-*/&--?",56&/+5-"7'-&-"+:"'--'52*"',("65/(&/"+:"dAP-"%'@&"4&&,"6&*"1)*%"2)**2&"/&8&/75--)+,"+,"*%&"-)(&"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*"Wh5&@'//'"#LLeX<""

_&7+>,)Y&("43",+1"'-"'"8)@+*'2"'7*+/":&'*5/),>"1)*%),"*%&"7+5,*/30-"(&@&2+86&,*"8+2)7)&-?"*%&"Jd$"%'-"),"/&7&,*"3&'/-"4&>5,"1+/;),>"72+-&23"1)*%"2',("(&@&2+8&/-"',("/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"),"+/(&/"*+":'7)2)*'*&"',("7%',,&2"*%&"

Page 105: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

c`"

:),',7)'2"7'8)*'2"+:"4'2);4'3',-"4'7;"),*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<ea"N3"2),;),>"*%&"),*&/&-*-"+:"-*'*&"'>&,7)&-"*+>&*%&/"1)*%"8/)@'*&"),@&-*+/-?"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*")-"),@&,*),>",&1"1'3-"*+"8&/-5'(&"4'2);4'3',-"*+"7+,*),5&"4&),>"8'*/+,-"+:"*%&"-*'*&?",+*"+,23"43"(/'1),>"+@&/-&'-"A)2)8),+-"*+"@)-)*"*%&)/"%+6&2',("45*"'2-+"*%/+5>%"),@&-*),>"),"8/+8&/*3"',("/&*)/),>"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""

$%&"'775652'*)+,"+:"*%&-&"),@&-*6&,*-"%'-":),',7&("*%&"7+,-*/57*)+,"+:"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'-f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d,>0-"7+,7&8*"+:"Q,&+2)4&/'2)-6"'-"&H7&8*)+,R?"C"(&-7/)4&"%+1"*%&-&"QY+,&-R"+8&/'*&"+5*-)(&"+:"*%&",+/6-"+:"2+7'2">+@&/,',7&"*%/+5>%"*%&"2&>'2"8/)@)2&>&-"*%&3"'/&"'::+/(&("),"+/(&/"*+"8/+@)(&"*+"*%&)/">5&-*-"1)*%"',"'45,(',7&"+:"5,)U5&"25H5/)&-<"""".&$,!9&%-*8#!/#'!N&)/0?!+,-!;<A!/#'!E7-)*/0!M*:/:!

C,"#LLa?"D/&-)(&,*"h2+/)'"S'7'8'>'29E//+3+?"6'(&"',"'88&'/',7&"'*"*%&"5,@&)2),>"+:"*%&"C68&/)'2"B)2@&/"$+1,"_&*)/&6&,*"G)22'>&"8/+I&7*"',("*+5/&("'"8+/*)+,"+:"*%&"ZM?!LL"-U5'/&"6&*&/-"8/+8&/*3?"),725(),>"'",564&/"+:"*%&"G)22'>&0-"6+(&2"5,)*-<"D'/*,&/),>"1)*%"*%&"l+/&',":)/6?"B&3%5,"J&@&2+86&,*?"*%&"D_E"4&2)&@&-"*%'*"*%&)/":2'>-%)8"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&"1)22">&,&/'*&"58"*+"=BJjbb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

A+/"*%&"D_E?"*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/3")-"),*&>/'2"*+")68/+@),>"*%&"7+5,*/30-"&7+,+6)7"',("43"6';),>"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'">2+4'2"Q/&*)/&6&,*"%'@&,R?"*%&"-*'*&"1)22":),'223"4&"'42&"*+"/&@&/-&"2'4+/"6)>/'*)+,-"4'7;"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("-+2@&"*%&"8&/&,,)'2"7/)-)-"+:"Q4/'),"(/'),R"WS'/7&2+"#LLeX<"K/57)'2"*+"*%)-"&7+,+6)7"(&@&2+86&,*"-*/'*&>3?"E//+3+"%'-"7%'/>&("*%&"D_E"1)*%"4/),>),>"*+>&*%&/"*%&"*+5/)-6?"/&*)/&6&,*?"',("%&'2*%"),(5-*/)&-"+,*+"'"-),>52'/"&7+,+6)7"82'*:+/6<"B8&';),>"'*"'"8/&--"7+,:&/&,7&"%&2("':*&/"%&/"@)-)*"*+"*%&"G)22'>&?"E//+3+"1'-"72&'/"'4+5*"*%&"-)>,):)7',7&"/+2&"*%'*"*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/3"82'3&("*+"(&@&2+8),>"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63"'--&/*),>"*%'*""

"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""ea"C,"*%&"!caL-?"*%&"D%)2)88),&"-*'*&"-+5>%*"*+"%'/,&--"*+5/)-6"'-"'"-*/'*&>3"+:"&7+,+6)7"',("5/4',"(&@&2+86&,*"',("'-"'"*++2":+/"'**/'7*),>":+/&)>,"),@&-*6&,*"43":+75-),>"*+5/)-*9/&2'*&("(&@&2+86&,*"),"*%&"VK_"'("S&*/+8+2)*',"S',)2'"),"8'/*)752'/<"B&&"W_)&(&/"!ccaX<"

Page 106: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

cc"

$%&"D_E"-%+52(":),("1'3-"*+"4++-*"*%&">/+1*%"+:"*%&"4++6),>"/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/3"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?",+*),>"*%&"1+/2(t-">/'3),>"8+852'*)+,")-"/'8)(23"),7/&'-),>\$%&"D%)2)88),&-")-"),"'"@&/3">++("8+-)*)+,"*+"*';&"'(@',*'>&"+:"*%)-"8+*&,*)'2"4&7'5-&"1&"%'@&"*%&":'7)2)*)&-"',("*%&"6',8+1&/<"E-"+,&"+:"*%&":2'>-%)8"8/+I&7*-"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*?"C"1',*"z*%&{"D_E"*+"4++-*")*-"&::+/*-"*+"(&@&2+8"',("8/+6+*&"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'-"'"/&*)/&6&,*"%'@&,"',("7+,*/)45*&"*+"*%&"),7/&'-&"+:":+/&)>,"),@&-*6&,*-"WD&2+@&22+"#LL`X<""

"B)*5'*&("),"*%&"7+'-*'2"7)*3"+:"V'-5>45?"),"*%&"8/+@),7&"+:"N'*',>'-?"*%&"

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e`"E-"8'/*"+:"%)-"(5*)&-"'-"K%')/8&/-+,?"E>2)8'3")-"/&-8+,-)42&":+/"7++/(),'*),>"4+*%"*%&">+@&/,6&,*"',("8/)@'*&"-&7*+/-"*+"1+/;"*+>&*%&/"*+"7+,7&,*/'*&"+,"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*"+:"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-"*%/+5>%+5*"N'>5)+?"$/),)('(?"B54)79K2'/;?"S&*/+"S',)2'"WE2'4',>?"S5,*),258'X?"i'>5,'?"N'*',>'-?"K'@)*&?"K&45?"B'6'2"C-2',("',("K'>'3',"(&"d/+<""

P%)2&"*%&"'>&,73"7+,*),5&-"*+"4&"/&:&//&("*+"'-"*%&"D_E?"+/)>),'223?")*"%'("4&&,"7'22&("*%&"D%)2)88),&"_&*)/&6&,*"D'/;"B3-*&6?"':*&/")*"1'-"&-*'42)-%&("*%/+5>%"S'/7+-0"8'--'>&"+:".H&75*)@&"d/(&/"!LZa"),"k523"!c`M<"C,"E5>5-*"#LL!?"85/-5),>"E//+3+0-"8+2)73"+:"7+,I+),),>"*+5/)-6?"/&*)/&6&,*?"',("%&'2*%"),(5-*/)&-"*+>&*%&/?"-%&"7+,-+2)('*&("*%&"'>&,73"5,(&/"*%&"N+'/("+:"C,@&-*6&,*-"WNdCX"',("+::)7)'223"/&,'6&("*%&"'>&,73"*%&"D%)2)88),&"i&)-5/&"',("_&*)/&6&,*"E5*%+/)*3"WDi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d::)7&"+:"*%&"D/&-)(&,*?")*"7+,*),5&-"*+":5,7*)+,"'-"'"-54-&*"+:"*%&"B*'*&0-"J&8'/*6&,*"+:"$/'(&"w"C,(5-*/3"WJ$CX"()/&7*23"5,(&/,&'*%"*%&"N5/&'5"+:"C,(5-*/3"',("C,@&-*6&,*-"WCCh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

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""e`""A&2"G<"S'/'>'3?"ohSE"P+,t*".H*&,("E>2)8'3t-"$&/6?o"6/#*0/!E$/#'/%'?"k',5/'/3"#!?"#LLM<"

Page 107: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!LL"

),(5-*/3?"*%&"D_E")-"/&-8+,-)42&":+/"8/+@)(),>"),,+@'*)@&"-+25*)+,-"*+":),',7&"*%&"45)2(),>"+:"*%&-&"652*)94)22)+,"(+22'/"6&>'98/+I&7*-<"

D_E"&H&75*)@&-"+8*)6)-*)7'223"4&2)&@&"*%'*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1)22"4&"%+6&"*+"'26+-*"!"6)22)+,"/&*)/&&-"43"#L!M"WS+226',"#LLaX<"D/+I&7*)+,-"'2-+"-5>>&-*"*%'*"/&*)/&&-"1)22"7+,*/)45*&"=BJj!e<Me"4)22)+,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63<"C,"+/(&/"*+"'7%)&@&"*%)-">+'2?"+,&"+:"*%&"),,+@'*&"-+25*)+,-"'(+8*&("43"*%&"D_E"*+"%&28">'*%&/":),',7),>":+/"*%&"45)2(),>"+:"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-"1'-"*+"),)*)'*&"*%&":+/6'*)+,"+:"D%)2)88),&"_&*)/&6&,*"C,7+/8+/'*&("WD_CX<"P%)2&"*%&"D_Et-"8/)6'/3":5,7*)+,")-"*+"8/+6+*&"*%&"7+5,*/3"'-"'"/&*)/&6&,*"%'@&,?"*%&"D_C"/&>52'*&-"*%&"U5'2)*3"+:"/&*)/&6&,*":'7)2)*)&-?"%&'2*%"7'/&"8/+@)(&/-?"',("2&)-5/&"-&/@)7&-"),"+/(&/"*+"&,-5/&"*%'*"*%&3"6&&*"Q>2+4'2"-*',('/(-R<"oz$%&{"D_C")-"*%&"8/)@'*&"-&7*+/<"$%&"8/)@'*&"-&7*+/")-"'((/&--),>"'22"*%&",&7&--'/3"/&U5)/&6&,*-":+/"5-"*+"4&"'42&"*+"4&">2+4'223"7+68&*)*)@&?o"&H82'),&("S/<"E>2)8'3"WN57+"#LLeX<""

D_C"6&64&/-"),725(&"'"82&*%+/'"+:"-&/@)7&-"',("/&*')2&/-"/&>)-*&/&("'-"Q+8&/'*+/-"+:"/&*)/&6&,*":'7)2)*)&-R?"),725(),>"2&)-5/&"',("/&-+/*"(&-*),'*)+,-?"7+,(+6),)56"',("%+5-),>"(&@&2+8&/-?"%+-8)*'2-?"%&'2*%"),-5/',7&"8/+@)(&/-?"*/',-8+/*"',("*/'@&2"-&/@)7&-?"7'/&9>)@),>"*/'),),>"-7%++2-?"%&'2*%"6','>&6&,*"+/>',)Y'*)+,-?":),',7)'2"),-*)*5*)+,-?"*+5/)-6"'(@+7'*&-?"4/+;&/-?"45)2(&/-?"%&'2*%"',("1&22,&--"+/>',)Y'*)+,-"',("+*%&/"-&/@)7&"8/+@)(&/-"),"*%&"7+5,*/3<"E77+/(),>"*+"*%&"D_E?"*%&/&"'/&"!Lc"'77/&()*&("6&/7%',*":'7)2)*)&-"',("bb"'77/&()*&("/&*)/&6&,*":'7)2)*)&-<"E-"*%&"6&64&/-%)8"',("7+22'4+/'*)+,"4&*1&&,"*%&"D_E"',("D_C"7+,*),5&-"*+"&H8',(?"'>&,73"+::)7)'2-"'/&"7'8'42&"+:"2+443),>"*%&"B*'*&">+@&/,6&,*"*+"2+1&/"*%&"8/)7&"+:"/&'2*3"8/+8&/*)&-?"'(("6+/&"),7&,*)@&-?"',("&@&,"6';&")68/+@&6&,*-"*+"*%&">&,&/'2"),:/'-*/57*5/&"+:"*%&"7+5,*/3<""

B8&';),>"'*"D%)2)88),&"_&*)/&6&,*"C,(5-*/3"C,@&-*6&,*"B566)*"),"#LLe?"D_C0-"D/&-)(&,*"./,&-*+"S<"d/(+,&Y"&H82'),&("*%'*"Q*%)-")-"*%&":)/-*"*)6&"()::&/&,*"6'/;&*"82'3&/-"9"%+-8)*'2-?"-54()@)-)+,"(&@&2+8&/-?">+2:"7254-?"&*7<"9"'/&"5,)*&(?"'/&"+,&R"),"'7%)&@),>"*%'*"-%'/&(">+'2"Wh52',&"#LLeX<"d/(+,&Y"'(6)**&("*%'*"*%&"7+,*),5'2"7+,>/5&,73"4&*1&&,"8542)7"',("8/)@'*&"),*&/&-*-")-"&--&,*)'2"*+"-577&--:5223"7+68&*&"1)*%"S'2'3-)'"',("$%')2',(?"7+5,*/)&-"1%)7%"%'("4&&,"/&7&)@),>"'26+-*"#L?LLL"/&*)/&&-"3&'/23?"',("6';),>"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'"/&*)/&6&,*"%'@&,<"E6+,>-*"*%&"652*),'*)+,'2"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"8'/*,&/),>"1)*%"*%&"D_E"@'/)+5-"),)*)'*)@&-"'/&"E3'2'"i',(?"C,7<?"_+4),-+,t-"i',("K+/8<?"A)2),@&-*"i',(?"C,7<?"BS"J&@t*"K+/8<"',("S&>'1+/2("K+/8<?"',("'"652*)*5(&"+:"),-5/',7&":)/6-?"*/',-8+/*'*)+,"7+68',)&-?"',("8/)@'*&23"-54-)()Y&("%+-8)*'2-"',("72),)7-<"

J&8&,(),>"+,"*%&"-+5/7&?"*%&/&")-"-+6&1%&/&"4&*1&&,"!M?b#L"*+"#L?LLL"/&>)-*&/&("/&*)/&&-"'2/&'(3"1)*%),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"$%&"*+*'2"),@&-*6&,*-"6'(&"43"/&*)/&&-"),"*%&"7+5,*/3"/&'7%&("=BJj!La<`"6)22)+,"'-"+:"k',5'/3"#L!L<"$%&"JdF"&-*)6'*&-"*%'*"4&*1&&,"*%&"3&'/-"#L!L"',("#L#L?"'/+5,("MLL?LLL"*+"Z"6)22)+,"/&*)/&("A)2)8),+9E6&/)7',-"1)22"-&**2&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"W;,*0*77*#-!P/*03!"#f(*%-%!#LLeX<"P)*%"*%&"8+*&,*)'2"=BJjb"4)22)+,"+:"*+*'2"),@&-*6&,*-"),"*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/3"'*"-*';&?"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*"%'-"'7*&("U5)7;23"',("),725(&("*%&"(&@&2+86&,*"+:"'",564&/"+:"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-"*+"*%&">+@&/,6&,*'223"-8+,-+/&("#LLe"C,@&-*6&,*-"D/)+/)*3"D2',"WCDDX<"P)*%"*%&"&H8',(),>"D%)2)88),&"S&()7'2"$+5/)-6"C,(5-*/3"',("*%&">/+1),>",&&("*+"&682+3"*%&">/+1),>"-5/825-"+:"&(57'*&("',("-;)22&("A)2)8),+"8%3-)7)',-"',(",5/-&-?"(&@&2+8&/-"'/&"'2-+";&&,"*+"&-*'42)-%"

Page 108: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!L!"

%+-8)*'2-"+/"72),)7-"1)*%),"&'7%"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&<"h+@&/,6&,*'2"'>&,7)&-"%+8&"*%'*"*%/+5>%"*%&"-3,7%/+,)Y'*)+,"+:"*%&"*+5/)-6?"/&*)/&6&,*?"',("6&()7'2"),(5-*/)&-"*%'*"4'2);4'3',-"',("+*%&/":+/&)>,",'*)+,'2-":+/6"1)22"7%++-&"*+"/&*)/&"),"+,&"+:"*%&"7+5,*/30-"Q1+/2("72'--R"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-<"

$%&")(&'"+:"(&@&2+8),>"&H725-)@&"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-":+75-&("*+1'/(-"(/'1),>":+/&)>,",'*)+,'2-"',(":+/6&/"A)2)8),+"7)*)Y&,-"*+"/&*)/&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-")-"43",+"6&',-"'"/&7&,*"7+,7&8*<"d,&"+:"*%&":)/-*"/&*)/&6&,*"8/+I&7*-"1'-"&-*'42)-%&("),"!ccM<"$+>&*%&/"1)*%"*%&"_V"J&@&2+86&,*"K+/8+/'*)+,?"*%&"D_E"),@&-*&("j=BJe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cc!?"1+52("/&),@)>+/'*&"*%&"2+7'2"&7+,+63"',("8/+@)(&"A)2)8),+-"1)*%"657%",&&(&("&682+36&,*<"

d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f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aX<"A),'223?"WZX"4'2);4'3',-"'2/&'(3"(&-)/&"*+"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("'77+/(),>"*+"6',3"(&@&2+8&/-?"+,23",&&("*+"4&"7+,@),7&("*%'*"/&*5/,),>")-"*%&"/)>%*"(&7)-)+,<"S',5&2"E>/)8&?"',"&H&75*)@&"1)*%"N&22&"(&@&2+8&/-?"-')(?"Q$%&3"+,23"/&'223",&&("*+"4&",5(>&(<"P%+"A)2)8),+"1+52("7%++-&"*+",+*"/&*5/,"):"3+5"()(,0*">)@&"*%&6"'">++("/&'-+,<R""

C,"J&7&64&/"#LLZ?"*%&"P'-%),>*+,"J<K<"4'-&("A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',":)/6"D%)2)88),&-"_&'2".-*'*&"K&,*&/"WD_.KX"1'-"5*)2)Y&("*+"%&'("*%&"6'/;&*),>"',("8/+6+*)+,"+:"*%&"B54)7"F+2)('3"G)22'-"-8&7):)7'223"*+"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"),"*%&"=<B<""

"B54)7"F+2)('3")-"*'/>&*),>"/&*)/&("A)29E6-"'-"8+*&,*)'2"72)&,*-"',("1&"+,23",&&("!y"+:"+@&/"#<`"6)22)+,"A)29E6"8+852'*)+,":+/"*%&6"*+"4&"8'/*"+:"*%)-"8/+I&7*<"C*")-"I5-*"+5/"1'3"+:"-'3),>"*%'*"B54)7"A/&&8+/*")-"'>++("82'7&"*+"1&27+6&"4'2);4'3',-"',("7+,*),5&"*%&"U5'2)*3"+:"2):&"z%&/&"*%'*{"*%&3"'/&"

Page 109: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!L#"

&,I+3),>"),"*%&"=<B<?R"-5>>&-*&("D_.K"K%')/6',"S)7%'&2"h'@)+2'"W.(:*#-::B&%0'!#LLZX<""

"i);&"*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"7+665,)*3"&-*'42)-%&("),"K2'/;"E)/"N'-&?">+@&/,6&,*'2"'>&,7)&-":&2*"*%'*"*%&"8/+8&/*3"'/+5,("*%&":+/6&/"6)2)*'/3"4'-&"),"B54)7"N'3"1'-"8++/23"5*)2)Y&(<"P%&,"*%&"G)22'-"+8&,&("),"#LLe?"/&*)/&&-"1&/&"'42&"*+"5*)2)Y&"&H725-)@&"'6&,)*)&-"),725(),>"-7%++2-"',("/&7/&'*)+,'2"'6&,)*)&-"2);&"-754'"()@),>?"%);),>?"I&*"-;)),>?"*%/+5>%"*%&)/"),@&-*6&,*-"),"*%&"B54)7"N'3"A/&&8+/*"q+,&"WBNAqX<"_&-)(),>"),"*%&"-8&7)'2"&7+,+6)7"Y+,&"'2-+"&,*)*2&("*%&6"*+"5*)2)Y&"*%&"B54)7"N'3"S&()7'2"K&,*&/?"1%&/&"*%&)/"%&'2*%"7'/&"1+52("4&"-54-)()Y&("43"'",564&/"+:"8/+6),&,*"E6&/)7',"FSdt-"-57%"'-"$/)9K'/&?"G&*&/',-"B*',('/(-?"N25&"K/+--"N25&"B%)&2(<"

$%&"8/)6'/3"7+,()*)+,":+/"6&64&/-%)8"),"*%&"BNAq"+/"',3"+*%&/"(&6'/7'*&("Y+,&"&H725-)@&"*+"/&*)/&&-")-"*%&"+4*'),6&,*"+:"'"B8&7)'2"_&-)(&,*"_&*)/&&t-"G)-'"WB__GX<"$%&"D_E")-"(&2&>'*&("*%&"/&-8+,-)4)2)*3"+:")--5),>"*%)-"-8&7)'2"@)-'"1%)7%"8/+@)(&-")*-"%+2(&/-"1)*%"*%&"8/)@)2&>&"+:"-*'3),>"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"8&/6',&,*23"',("'"652*)82&9&,*/3"-*'*5-<"$%&"8/)@)2&>&-"'2-+"),725(&"'"+,&9*)6&"&H&68*)+,":/+6"75-*+6-"(5*)&-"',("*'H&-?"',("*'H9:/&&"8&,-)+,-"',("',,5)*)&-"/&6)**&("*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"$%&"B__G"'2-+"8/+@)(&-"'"2)*',3"+:"*'H9:/&&"),7&,*)@&-"',("4&,&:)*-":/+6"'"%+-*"+:"8'/*,&/),>"&-*'42)-%6&,*-"-57%"'-"%+*&2-?"/&-+/*-?"/&*)/&6&,*":'7)2)*)&-?"',("/&-*'5/',*-<"E77+/(),>"*+"*%&"/&>52'*)+,-?"*%&"6),)6'2"/&U5)/&6&,*":+/"'882)7',*-"-*'*&"*%'*":+/&)>,",'*)+,'2-"4&*1&&,"*%&"'>&-"+:"ZM9ML"1&/&"/&U5)/&("*+"(&8+-)*"*%&"6),)6'2"'6+5,*"+:"=BJjaM?LLL"1)*%"'",564&/"+:"D_E"'::)2)'*&("4',;-<"$%+-&"+2(&/"*%',"ML"1&/&"/&U5)/&("*+"(&8+-)*"'"2&--&/"'6+5,*?"=BJjML?LLL<"$%&"D_E"'((&("*%'*"*%+-&"1%+"U5'2):)&(":+/"B__G0-"1&/&"'22+1&("*+"4/),>"'"-8+5-&"',("58"*+"*1+"7%)2(/&,?"8/+@)(&("*%'*"*%&3"1&/&"5,(&/"*%&"'>&"+:"#!"',("-),>2&"WD%)2)88),&"_&*)/&6&,*"E5*%+/)*3"#LLaX<"

$%+-&"%+1&@&/"1%+"'/&"'42&"*+"6'),*'),"'"-*'42&"),7+6&"':*&/"/&*)/&6&,*"*%/+5>%"*%&)/"8&,-)+,-"'/&"/&U5)/&("*+"),@&-*"'"7+,-)(&/'423"2&--"'6+5,*<"A+/"*%+-&"ML"3&'/-"+2("',("'4+@&?"*%&"(&8+-)*"'6+5,*")-"=BJj!L?LLL?"jZ?LLL"+:"1%)7%")-";&8*":+/":5,&/'2"&H8&,-&-"1%)2&"*%&"/&-*"7',"4&"7+,@&/*&(":+/"'"@'/)&*3"+:"/&*)/&6&,*"),@&-*6&,*-<"$%&"6),)656"8&,-)+,"/&U5)/&6&,*":+/"'"-),>2&"),()@)(5'2")-"j`LL"8&/"6+,*%"',("):"+,&"%'-"'"-8+5-&?"*%&"'6+5,*"),7/&'-&-"*+"j!?LLL<"E77+/(),>"*+"*%&"D_E?"5,(&/"*%&"Q4/'),">'),R"8/+>/'6?"/&*)/&("-7)&,*)-*-"',("-7%+2'/-"'/&"'22+1&("*+"%'@&"*%&)/"(&8+-)*-"1')@&("'-"2+,>"'-"*%&3"'/&"1)22),>"*+"*&'7%"1)*%),"*%&)/"'/&'-"+:"&H8&/*)-&"WJ'U5)Y"#LLeX<"

S+/&"/&7&,*23?"*%&"B__G"1'-"6+():)&("-8&7):)7'223"*+"7'*&/"*+":+/6&/"7)*)Y&,-"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"+/"4'2);4'3',-<"E77+/(),>"*+"*%&"-*)852'*)+,-"8'--&("),"#LLZ?"*%&"C,@&-*+/-"',("_&*)/&&"_&-)(&,*"WC_#X"4'2);4'3',"@)-'"'22+1-"4'2);4'3',-"*+"(&8+-)*"'"6),)6'2"'6+5,*"+:"I5-*"=BJj!?MLL<"$%)-"@)-'"'2-+"8/+@)(&-"%+2(&/-"*%&"8/)@)2&>&"+:"+1,"/&'2"&-*'*&"58"*+"M?LLL"-U<"6&*&/-?"1%&*%&/")*")-"/&-)(&,*)'2?"5/4',"+/"'>/)752*5/'2"8/+8&/*3<"E2+,>"1)*%"*%)-"6+():)7'*)+,?"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*"&,7+5/'>&-"4'2);4'3',-"*+"'7*"'-"&,*/&8/&,&5/-"*%/+5>%"*%&"_&8542)7"E7*"V+<"c!a`"+/"E7*"*+"D/+6+*&"*%&".-*'42)-%6&,*"+:"./%/#8/3"S)7/+9N5-),&--".,*&/8/)-&<"N'2);4'3',-"'/&"'2-+"&,*)*2&("*+"85/7%'-&"j!?MLL"1+/*%"+:">++(-":/+6"',3"+:"*%&",564&/"+:">+@&/,6&,*"/&>52'*&("(5*39:/&&"-%+8-"2+7'*&("'/+5,("*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""

Page 110: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!LZ"

E-;&("1%3"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*"),-*)*5*&("'"-*)852'*)+,":+/"4'2);4'3',-"-8&7):)7'223?"k<"E,*+,)+"i&@)-*&?"*%&"D_E"K%')/8&/-+,"),"#LLZ?"&H82'),&(?""

"P%)2&"1+/;),>"'4/+'(?"6+-*"+:"*%&6"%'@&"/&6)**&("6+,&3"*+"*%&)/"/&2'*)@&-"'*"%+6&?"*%5-"%&28),>"4+2-*&/"+5/"7+5,*/3t-":+/&)>,"&H7%',>&"/&-&/@&-\C*t-"*%&"2&'-*"1&"7',"(+":+/"+5/":+/6&/"7+68'*/)+*-?"1%+"'/&"/)>%*23"(544&("*%&"6+(&/,"%&/+&-"+:"+5/"7+5,*/3\N'2);4'3',-"'/&"'2-+"4&),>"&,*)7&("4'7;"*+"*%&)/"7+5,*/3"+:"+/)>),"4&7'5-&"':*&/"&'/,),>"%'/(9&'/,&("75//&,73"'4/+'(?"*%&3"(&-&/@&"/&-*"',("2&)-5/&"1)*%"-+6&"7+,-)(&/'*)+,-":/+6"*%&)/"7+5,*/36&,"1%+"%'@&"4&,&:)*&(":/+6"*%&)/"/&6)**',7&"+:":+/&)>,"75//&,73"WN5-),&--P+/2("#LLZX<""

i&>)-2'*)+,"'5*%+/)Y),>"*%&"8'--'>&"+:"()::&/&,*"@)-'-"1'-"&--&,*)'2"*+":'7)2)*'*),>"*%&"),@&-*6&,*-"+:"4'2);4'3',-"),*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63<"F+1&@&/?"*%&"(5*)&-"*%'*"4'2);4'3',-"'/&"+42)>'*&("*+"8'3"()(",+*"7&'-&"+,7&"*%&3"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"C,-*&'(?"6',3"4'2);4'3',-"1&/&"*+/,"+,"(&7)(),>"%+1"657%"*%&3"1&/&"/&'223"1)22),>"*+"),@&-*"),"*%&":5*5/&"+:"*%&)/"%+6&2',(<""\;/3*#8!Z&(%!P(-:]?!<-$*%-5-#$!A::&)*/$*&#:!/#'!9*#/#)*/0!6*:5/#/8-5-#$!

"N&*1&&,"#LLe"*+"#L!M?"D_E"',("D_C"&H&75*)@&-"+8*)6)-*)7'223"&H8&7*"*%'*"*%&"

75652'*)@&"&'/,),>-"+:"*%&"`Mc?#ML"/&*)/&&-"*%'*"'/&">5'/',*&&("*+"-&**2&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'2+,&"1)22"'6+5,*"*+"=BJjbb"4)22)+,"WD%)2)88),&"_&*)/&6&,*"C,7<"#LLa?"cX<"$%)-")-"'"2+:*3"'64)*)+,">)@&,"*%'*"58"5,*)2"#LLe?">+@&/,6&,*'223"-8+,-+/&("8/+>/'6-"6'),*'),&("43"*%&"D_E"%'@&"+,23"4&&,"'42&"*+"&,*)7&"'4+5*"!#?LLL"),()@)(5'2-"*+"/&*)/&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"-),7&"*%&"'>&,73"1'-"&-*'42)-%&("),"!c`M"Wh52',&"#LLeX<"O&*?"-),7&"#LLe?"*%&"+@&/'22"*+*'2"+:"B__G0-")--5&("*+":+/&)>,",'*)+,'2-"',(":+/6&/"A)2)8),+"7)*)Y&,-"%'@&"4&&,"-*&'()23"),7/&'-),>"W:)><"!X<"$%)-"8+-)*)@&"*/&,("%'-"),-8)/&("'>&,73"&H&75*)@&-"*+"7+,*),5&"'>>/&--)@&23"*'/>&*),>"/&*)/&6&,*"7+665,)*)&-"8'/*)752'/23"),"E-)'"',("A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"),"*%&"=<B<?"8542)-%),>"8'68%2&*-"',("-&,(),>"/&8/&-&,*'*)@&-"*+"+/>',)Y&"/&*)/&6&,*":')/-"*+"&2)7)*"&@&,"6+/&"),*&/&-*<"h)@&,"*%&"2+,>"%)-*+/3"+:"8+2)*)7'2"7+//58*)+,"',(">/':*"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"7+,7&/,-"%'@&"7+,*),5'223"'/)-&,"/&>'/(),>"*%&"6','>&6&,*"+:"/&*)/&&"),@&-*6&,*":5,(-<""""""""""""""

Page 111: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!Lb"

"$+*'2".,/+26&,*":+/"

"B8&7)'2"_&*)/&6&,*"_&-)(&,*"G)-'"WB__GX"D/+>/'6"

#LLc" Z?!#L"

#LL`" #?eLL"#LLa" #?Zce"#LLe" !?#a!"#LLM" !?#Mc"#LLb" `!`"#LLZ" aZ#"#LL#" McZ"#LL!" ZM#"#LLL" !Z!"!

6')&*-!<!?0+3+::+$-!,-%+&-F-$%!E)%0'&+%5!

" "A+/"4'2);4'3',-"%+1&@&/?"*%&"7+,7&/,-"+@&/":),',7)'2"6)-6','>&6&,*")-"

>/'@&"8'/*)752'/23":+/"*%+-&"1%+"'/&"7+,@),7&("*%'*"7+//58*)+,")-"5,'@+)('42&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<ec"$&,-)+,-":)/-*"7'6&"*+"'"%&'("),"!ccM?"1%&,"),@&-*)>'*)@&"/&8+/*-"()-7+@&/&("*%'*"*%&"D_E"%'("2+-*"DbM<c"6)22)+,"),"),@&-*6&,*":5,(-<"C,"(',>&/"+:"%)-"'(6),)-*/'*)+,"4&),>"6)/&("),"7+,*/+@&/-3"-+"&'/23"),*+"%)-"*&,5/&?"A)(&2"_'6+-"/&:5-&("*+"'22+1"*%&"D_E"*+"4&"()--+2@&("',("7%+-&"'/4)*/'*)+,"),-*&'(<"D/&-)(&,*"_'6+-"7%+-&"_'6+,"S<"K+22'(+"'-"*%&"'**+/,&3"1%+"1+52("2&'("*%&"'/4)*/'*)+,"8/+7&--"',("-'@&"*%&"D_E":/+6"7&/*'),"(&6)-&<"D+2)*)7'2"'77+5,*'4)2)*3"%'("2+,>"4&&,"',")--5&"+:"7+,7&/,":+/"8&+82&"),*&/&-*&("),"),@&-*),>"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"

P%)2&"C"),*&/@)&1&("h'/3"i'Y'/+"'4+5*"*%&"D_E?"%&">2)423"-5>>&-*&("*%'*"%&"%'("4&7+6&"',"),@&-*+/"),"*%&"D_E"1%&,"6+-*"+:"*%&"B__G"/&7)8)&,*-"1&/&"Q.5/+8&',"()82+6'*-?"k'8',&-&"7+/8+/'*&"&H&7-?"+/"E6&/)7',"/&*)/&("-&/@)7&6&,R?"',(",+*"*%&"4'2);4'3',""/&*)/&&-"2);&"%)6"1%+"%'@&"4&&,"),7/&'-),>"),",564&/"-),7&"*%&"6)(9#LLL-<"_&*)/),>"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"),"!ccL?"*%&"ec"3&'/9+2(">+2:"':)7)+,'(+"8&/-&@&/&("%)-"1'3"),*+"4&7+6),>"'"*+892&@&2"&H&75*)@&"'*"S&*2):&"(5/),>"*%&"!caL-"',("`L-<"F&"(&7)(&("*+"2&'@&"%)-"825-%"8+-)*)+,"'*"S&*2):&"1%&,"'"5,)U5&"+88+/*5,)*3"*+"1+/;"'2+,>-)(&"%)-"2+,>9*)6&":/)&,(?"S',5&2"D',>)2),',?"*%&"K%')/6',":+/"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""ec"A)2+6&,+"G<"E>5)2'/"k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u()/*30"8+2)*)7-"',("),&::&7*5'2">+@&/,',7&Å&@&,"43"&6)>/',*-"1%+"'::)/6"*%&)/"A)2)8),+")(&,*)*3?"-57%"'-"*%&"6',"1%+",&@&/"4+*%&/&("*+"4&7+6&"'",'*5/'2)Y&("=<B<"7)*)Y&,"3&*"7+,-)(&/&("'4-&,*&&"@+*),>"'-",+,-&,-)7'2"W1/,*2/#8/#X<"$%&"()-*/5-*"+:"D%)2)88),&"8+2)*)7'2"),-*)*5*)+,-")-"6+-*"8'28'42&R<"B&&"A)2+6&,+"G<"E>5)2'/"k/<0-"oD+2)*)7'2"$/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"',("*%&"B*'*&0-"_&),7+/8+/'*)+,"+:"d@&/-&'-"A)2)8),+-?o"),"4R70&%*#8!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!D&55(#*$*-:!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:?"!Ma9!eZ"Wx5&Y+,"K)*3f"D%)2)88),&"S)>/'*)+,"_&-&'/7%"V&*1+/;"',("D%)2)88),&"B+7)'2"B7)&,7&"K+5,7)2?"#LLaX?"8<!eL<"

Page 112: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!LM"

D%)2)88),&"i+,>"J)-*',7&"$&2&8%+,&"K+68',3"WDiJ$X"',("'":&22+1"7+22&'>5&":/+6"P%'/*+,"N5-),&--"B7%++2"1%&/&"4+*%"%'(">/'(5'*&("),"!cec?"%'("&6&/>&(<""

h'/3"7+52("&'-)23"4&"-8+**&("8&/:&7*),>"%)-">+2:">'6&"'*"*%&"E2'4',>"K+5,*/3"K254?"I5-*"'":&1"42+7;-"'1'3":/+6"%)-"%+6&"),"*%&"E3'2'"E2'4',>"G)22'>&<"V+1"/&*)/&(?"%&":/&U5&,*&("*%&"8+852'/"7254"),"S5,*),258'":+5/"*)6&-"'"1&&;"',("1'-"%'883"*+"/&-8+,("*+"',3"+:"63"U5&-*)+,-"8/+@)(&("C"1'-"+8&,"*+"-8&,(),>"',"&@&,),>"1)*%"%)6"+,"*%&">+2:"7+5/-&<"$'88),>"-%/&(-"+:">/'--"'1'3":/+6"*%&"4+**+6"+:"%)-"-%+&"'>'),-*"*%&"-%),3"6&*'22)7"%+-&2"+:"%)-"c9)/+,?"QN+4+3R?"'-"%)-":/)&,(-"7'22&("%)6?"&H8/&--&("%)-"@)&1-"+,"D%)2)88),&"8+2)*)7-"1)*%"'"%&'2*%3"6)H*5/&"+:"%56+/"',("()-'88+),*6&,*<"QK+//58*)+,")-"),"*%&"42++("%&/&<"C*0-",+*"2);&"),"*%&"=<B<"1%&/&"*%&/&"'/&"7%&7;-"',("4'2',7&-<"J+,0*">&*"6&"1/+,>?"*%&/&0-"82&,*3"+:"z7+//58*)+,{"),"*%&"=<B<"N5*"'*"2&'-*"+@&/"*%&/&?"*%&3"*/3"*+"%)(&")*?R"h'/3"65/65/&("*%/+5>%"*%&"2)*97)>'/&**&"*%'*"%&"1'-"*/3),>"*+";&&8":/+6"(/)442),>"+5*"+:"%)-"6+5*%"'-"%&"*'2;&(<"""

"O+5"'-;&("6&"):"C"1+52("-*)22"7+6&"%&/&"):",+*":+/"S',5&2"+::&/),>"6&"*%&"I+4"1)*%"DiJ$<"S'34&\45*"C"'2-+"%'("'"@&/3">++("2):&"),"V&1"O+/;<"S3"1):&"()(,0*"7+6&"*+"2)@&"1)*%"6&"%&/&"5,*)2"3&'/-"':*&/"C":)/-*"7'6&"4'7;<"=,*)2"!cc`<"E,("*%'*"1'-"+,23"4&7'5-&"+:"*%&"),@&-*6&,*"+88+/*5,)*)&-"*%'*"7'6&"58<"d*%&/1)-&?"C"1+52("%'@&"I5-*"),@&-*&("63"6+,&3?"3+5";,+1?"4+5>%*"8/+8&/*3"),"S';'*)"+/"D'2'1',"2);&"'22"*%&"+*%&/":+/&)>,&/-"',("/&*5/,&("*+"*%&"=<B<"':*&/"C"-*+88&("1+/;),>"z'*"DiJ${<"C"1+52("I5-*"6','>&"63"8/+8&/*)&-":/+6"*%&"=<B<"C*0-"'7*5'223"657%"&'-)&/"*+"6';&"6+,&3"),"),@&-*6&,*-"),"*%&"=<B<"z*%',"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-{<"N5*"*%&,"1&"%'("4)>>&/"+88+/*5,)*)&-"*+"6';&"),@&-*6&,*-<"C"(&7)(&("*+"/&*)/&"),"S5,*),258'<"N5*"C"1'-"-*)22"@&/3"7'5*)+5-"'4+5*"85**),>"63"6+,&3"1)*%"*%&"D_E<"O+5";,+1?"*%&3"7',"4&"@&/3"*/)7;3<"$%&3"*&22"8&+82&"*%'*"1)*%"*%&"@)-'"3+5"7',"1)*%(/'1"3+5/"(&8+-)*"'*"',3"*)6&<"N5*")*"1'-,0*"*/5&<"O+5"%'@&"*+";,+1"1%+"*+"*'2;"*+<"k5-*"2);&"&@&/3*%),>"%&/&<"O+5"'21'3-"%'@&"*+";,+1"1%+"*+"*'2;"*+<"N5*"1%'*"):"3+5"(+,0*";,+1"1%+"*+"*'2;"*+<"O+50/&">+),>"*+"2+-&"'"2+*"+:"6+,&3<""

"_'6+,"K+22'(+0-"+/)>),'2"/&7+66&,('*)+,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*"1'-"

/&:2&7*&("1)*%),"h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aL?"D_ESE"1'-"),-*)*5*&("*+"

"E(@+7'*&":+/"*%&"/)>%*-"+:"*%&"&2(&/23"8&+82&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"C*"7+,(57*-":+/56?"1+/;-%+8?"',("-&6),'/-"+,"E>&),>"1)*%"*%&"7+22'4+/'*)+,"+:"+*%&/",+,9>+@&/,6&,*"+/>',)Y'*)+,-"',("),()@)(5'2-<"C*"')6-"*+"(&@&2+8"*%&"_&*)/&6&,*"C,(5-*/3"),"*%&"7+5,*/3"',("%&28"7+,-+2)('*&"-&/@)7&-"-57%"'-"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""aL"J&-7/)8*)+,"*';&,":/+6"/&8+/*"8/&-&,*&("*+"*%&"=<V<""

Page 113: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!Le"

%&'2*%7'/&?">&/)'*/)7"72),)7-?"'7*)@)*3"7&,*&/-?"2&)-5/&"7254-?"*/'),),>"7&,*&/":+/"7'/&>)@&/-"',("-+7)'2"1+/;-?"6&6+/)'2"'--)-*',7&?"',("+*%&/-":+/"*%&"4&,&:)*"+:"*%&"&2(&/23"8&+82&<"D/'6'"8'/*)7)8'*&-"),"6&&*),>-"),*&/,'*)+,'223"',("2+7'223"*+">'*%&/",&1"),:+/6'*)+,"+,"-)*5'*)+,-"',("4&-*"8/'7*)7&-"7+,7&/,),>"*%&"&2(&/23"8&+82&<"C*"'2-+"+77'-)+,'223"-588+/*-"'7*)@)*)&-":+/"*%&"&2(&/23"8&+82&"*%/+5>%">/',*-<""

"C,"2&--"*%&,"*&,"3&'/-?"D_ESE"&,/+22&("e?!`c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

K+22'(+"'2-+"/&7+>,)Y&("*%'*"*%&"D_E"7+,*),5&("*+"2+-&"6+,&3"4&7'5-&"/&*)/&&"(&8+-)*-"1&/&"4&),>"()-8&/-&("'6+,>-*"#Z"()::&/&,*"4',;-<"C,"+/(&/"*+">'),"'"6+/&"7+68&*)*)@&"),*&/&-*"/'*&?"*%&"'**+/,&3"7+,@),7&("*%&"D_E"*+"7+,7&,*/'*&"*%&"(&8+-)*-"4&*1&&,"+,23":+5/"4',;-<"$%&"@'25&"+:"BB_G"(&8+-)*-")66&()'*&23"),7/&'-&("':*&/"*%&)/"),*&/&-*"/'*&-"1&/&"6+():)&(<"E:*&/"),75//),>"+8&/'*),>"2+--&-"'6+5,*),>"*+"DjbM<c"6)22)+,"),"!cc#?"(5&"*+"K+22'(+0-"&::+/*-?"43"!cce?"*%&"*+*'2",&*"),7+6&">'),&("43"/&*)/&&"(&8+-)*-"'6+5,*&("*+"jbM<e"6)22)+,<"D/&@)+5-"*+"*%'*?"*%&"/&*)/&&-"1&/&"2+-),>"'-"657%"'-"j#M?LLL"'"('3"',("'4+5*"j!`"6)22)+,"'"3&'/"),"),*&/&-*"),7+6&"'2+,&"WK/5Y"#LL#X<"C,"/&7+>,)*)+,"+:"D_ESE0-"-577&--:52"),*&/@&,*)+,-?"*%&"/&6'),),>":+5/"4',;-"+::&/&("*%&"A+5,('*)+,"'"+,&"8&/7&,*"6','>&6&,*":&&?"1%)7%"D_ESE"(&7)(&("*+"-%'/&"1)*%"*%&"D_E<""

$%&"D_E"',("D_ESE"+::)7)'223"-)>,&("'"6&6+/',(56"+:"'>/&&6&,*"),"S'3"!ccc?"4+*%"8'/*)&-"'>/&&),>"*+"Q&,-5/&"*%&"&::&7*)@&"',("&::)7)&,*"8/+6+*)+,"',(")682&6&,*'*)+,"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&"_&*)/&6&,*"D/+>/'6"'(6),)-*&/&("43"*%&"D_E<Ra!"$%&"'>/&&6&,*"%'("'2-+"-&*"),*+"6+*)+,"'",564&/"+:"82',-"*+"(&@&2+8"45-),&--"8'/*,&/-%)8-"4&*1&&,"),@&-*+/-"',("2+7'2"&,*&/8/)-&-"*%/+5>%"-6'22"',("6&()56"-)Y&("8/+I&7*-"4'7;&("43"*%&"-)>,'*5/&-"+:"*%&"D_E"',("*%&"N5/&'5"+:"C,@&-*6&,*-"WNdCX<"E2/&'(3"&'/23"),*+"*%&"&-*'42)-%6&,*"+:"D_ESE?"*%&"2),&-"4&*1&&,"-*'*&?"8/)@'*&?"',("),()@)(5'2"),@&-*+/-"4&7'6&"65((2&("',("-&@&/'2"+:"D_ESE0-"&'/23":),',7)'2"),@&-*6&,*-"%'("'2/&'(3"4&7+6&"7+,@&/>&,*"1)*%"*%&"@&/3"&,*)*)&-"*%'*"*%&3"1&/&"-588+-&"*+";&&8"'77+5,*'42&<"B57%")-"*%&"%)-*+/3"+:"D%)2)88),&"8+2)*)7'29&7+,+63?"1%&/&?"2);&"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*"+:"-;3-7/'8&/-"',("7+,(+6),)56-"'2+,>"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""a!"$%&"6&6+/',(56")-"U5+*&("),"*%&".(:*#-::B&%0'!'/*)72&?"oS+E"-&&;-"*+"(&@&2+8"_D"'-")(&'2"/&*)/&6&,*"%'@&,?o".(:*#-::B&%0'?"k5,&"#!?"!ccc<""

Page 114: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!La"

S',)2'0-"45)2*92',(-7'8&?"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*"+:"*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/3"7+52("+,23"4&"6'(&"8+--)42&"*%/+5>%"*%&"-%'/&("),*&/&-*-"4&*1&&,"8+2)*)7'2"&2)*&-"',("8/)@'*&"(&@&2+8&/-<"E>'),"',("'>'),?"*%&"7%&7;-"',("4'2',7&-"),-*)*5*&("*+"8/+*&7*"8/)@'*&"),()@)(5'2-":/+6">+@&/,6&,*'2":/'5("%'("4&&,"'22"45*"&2)6),'*&(<"

N3"#LL#?"*%&"D_E"%'("'775652'*&("j#LL"6)22)+,?"+:"1%)7%"jeL"6)22)+,"%'("4&&,"&'/,&("43"*%&"'--+7)'*)+,<"O&*?",+*"'22"6&64&/-"1&/&"-'*)-:)&("43"D_ESE0-"2&'(&/-%)8<"D_ESE"%'("4&7+6&"*%&"+,23">+@&/,6&,*'223"/&7+>,)Y&("'--+7)'*)+,"/&8/&-&,*),>"*%&"),*&/&-*-"+:":+/&)>,"',(":+/6&/"A)2)8),+"7)*)Y&,"/&*)/&&-<"C,"S'3"#LL!?"'">/+58"+:"/&*)/&&-?"()-7+,*&,*&("'4+5*"-&@&/'2"2&'(&/-%)8")--5&-?"-82),*&/&(":/+6"*%&"'--+7)'*)+,?":+/6&("'">/+58"7'22&("K+,7&/,&("D%)2)88),&"_&*)/&&-"h/+58?"',("4/+5>%*"*%&)/"7+,7&/,-"*+"S'2'7',',>"*+":+/6'223":)2&"'"7'-&"'>'),-*"D_ESE<"h/+58"6&64&/-"&H8/&--&(">/)&@',7&-"+@&/"K+22'(+0-"'88'/&,*"'5*%+/)*'/)',"2&'(&/-%)8"',("%)-"&H725-)+,"+:"'",564&/"+:"'--+7)'*)+,"6&64&/-":/+6"@+*),>?"1%)7%"2&("*+"%)-"),@'2)("/&9&2&7*)+,"'-"8/&-)(&,*<"A),'223?"*%&"6+-*"-&/)+5-"+:"'22"*%&">/)&@',7&-?"1'-"*%'*"Dj`a"6)22)+,"+:"*%&"6&64&/-%)8":5,(-"7+52(",+*"4&&,"'77+5,*&("43"*%&"'--+7)'*)+,0-"*/&'-5/3<"P%)2&"*%&"-82),*&/":'7*)+,"7+52(",+*"/&-+2@&"*%&":),',7)'2"7/)-)-"+:"*%&)/"2+-*"),@&-*6&,*":5,(-?"),@&-*+/-"1&/&"/&2)&@&("*+"/&6+@&"*%&"6',('*+/3"/&U5)/&6&,*":+/"6&64&/-%)8"),"D_ESE"Wh&,&/'2"#LL#X<""

P%)2&"6',('*+/3"'--+7)'*)+,"6&64&/-%)8-"'/&"7+66+,"),"*%&"=<B<?"8'/*)752'/23"1)*%"8/+8&/*3"+1,&/-%)8?"*%&":+/6'*)+,"+:"8/+8/)&*'/3"'--+7)'*)+,-"1'-"2'/>&23"',"'(@&,*"+:"*%&"2)4&/'2"&7+,+6)7"6+@&6&,*"*%'*"&6&/>&("),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"(5/),>"*%&"!ccL-<"h)@&,"*%&",564&/"+:"7+682'),*-"'>'),-*"*%&"'--+7)'*)+,"),725(),>"*%)-"6+-*"/&7&,*"+,&?"-&@&/'2"/&*)/&&-"%'@&"&H8/&--&("'"72&'/"()-),72),'*)+,"*+"I+),),>"D_ESE<"QC",&@&/"4&2)&@&("*%'*"6&64&/-%)8"-%+52("4&"6',('*+/3<".-8&7)'223"1%&,"3+5"2++;"'*"4+*%"WD_ESE"',("D_EX<"$%&30/&"*%&"-'6&<"O+5"7',0*"*&22"+,&":/+6"*%&"+*%&/?R"h'/3"7+682'),&(<"P%)2&"D_ESE"(+&-"'(@+7'*&":+/"@'/)+5-"6&'-5/&-?"),725(),>")68/+@&6&,*-"),"%&'2*%"7'/&":+/"),-*',7&?"h'/3"1&,*"+,"*+"&H8/&--"%)-"',,+3',7&"1)*%"*%&"'--+7)'*)+,<"

""_&'223?"*%&)/"+,&"',("+,23"/&'2"I+4")-"*+"6';&"-5/&"*%'*"*%&":5,(-"*%'*"/&*)/&&-"),@&-*"),*+"*%&"D_E")-,0*"6)-%',(2&(<"$%&30/&"-588+-&"*+"6';&"-5/&"*%'*"+5/"6+,&3")-,0*"-*+2&,<"$+"6';&"-5/&"*%'*"1%&,"/&*)/&&-",&&("*%&"6+,&3?"*%&3"7',">&*")*<"N5*"1%&,"3+5"7',0*"&@&,">&*"3+5/"6+,&3":/+6"D_ESE?"1&22"1%'*">++("'/&"*%&3["P%'*0-"*%&"()::&/&,7&"4&*1&&,"*%&6"',("*%&">+@&/,6&,*[""

P%&,"&H'6),),>"*%&"45-),&--"(&'2),>-"+:"D_ESE"+,&"4&>),-"*+"-&&"-+6&"*/5*%"),"h'/30-"7+,7&/,-<"$%&"6/#*0/!E$/#'/%'"/&8+/*&("'-":'/"4'7;"'-"!cc`?"*%&"D_ESE"A+5,('*)+,"1'-"'2/&'(3":),',7),>"82',-":+/"*%&"7+,-*/57*)+,"+:"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-"),"N'*',>'-?"1%)7%"&H&75*)@&-"1',*&("*+"7'22"*%&"h+2(&,"G)22'>&<"D2',-"1&/&"6'(&"*+"45)2("*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&"+,"'"!#L9%&7*'/&"8/+8&/*3"',("1+52("),725(&"'6+,>-*"'",564&/"+:"-8+/*-":'7)2)*)&-?"-&@&/'2"6&()7'2"',("(&,*'2"7&,*&/-?"'"6'/;&*"',("'"-%+88),>"'/7'(&?"-7%++2?"',("'"7%5/7%<""

K/)*)7'2"*+"D_ESE"',("*%&"D_E"),"8'/*)752'/"1'-"*%&"7+66+,"5-'>&"+:"*%&"*&/6"Q1+/2(972'--R"*+"(&-7/)4&"*%&"-&/@)7&-"',("'6&,)*)&-"+::&/&("1)*%),"*%&"h+2("G)22'>&"/&*)/&6&,*"8/+I&7*<"E77+/(),>"*+"*%&"+/>',)Y'*)+,0-"/&8/&-&,*'*)@&-?"*%&"G)22'>&")-"'"Q1+/2(972'--"-&2:97+,*'),&("/&-+/*"',("/&-)(&,*)'2"7+665,)*3"*%'*"+::&/-"

Page 115: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!L`"

%&'2*%"-&/@)7&-?"'::+/('42&"',("7+,@&,)&,*"%+5-),>?"'7*)@&"2):&-*32&"'6&,)*)&-"-57%"'-"'"6'/),'?"'">+2("7+5/-&"',("-1)66),>"8++2-"',("&@&,"'"45-),&--"',("7+66&/7)'2"7&,*&/?"',("),@&-*6&,*"+88+/*5,)*)&-"*+"/&*)/&&-"1)*%"'"6+,*%23"8&,-)+,"+:"j!?#LL"*+"j#?LLL"W),"=<B<"75//&,73XR"WS'7'4&,*'"!cc`X<"QP+/2("72'--R?"'"8%/'-&"7+,-*',*23"/&8&'*&("*%/+5>%+5*"/&*)/&6&,*"4/+7%5/&-"',("'(@&/*)-&6&,*-"(&,+*&-"4+*%"*%&"72&'/"'**&68*-"*%'*"*%&"D%)2)88),&"/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/3")-"6';),>"*+"'**/'7*"+@&/-&'-"),@&-*6&,*-"',("*+"&,*&/*'),",+*)+,-"+:"4'2);4'3',"8'/',+)'"43"7/&'*),>"'"7+5,*&/9()-*),7*)+,"4&*1&&,"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-"',("*%&")66&()'*&"&,@)/+,6&,*"-5//+5,(),>"*%&6<""

$%&/&"1'-",+*%),>"()::&/&,*"4&*1&&,"*%&"h+2(&,"G)22'>&"',("',3"+:"*%&"8/+I&7*-"82',,&("43"D_E"&H7&8*"*%'*"D_ESE"1+52("7'22"*%)-"+,&")*-"+1,<"S&',1%)2&?"7+5/*"8/+7&&(),>-"7+,*),5&"*+"8&/-)-*"4&*1&&,"D_E"',("D_ESE"+@&/"+4-*/57*)+,"82'7&("4&*1&&,"D_ESE":/+6"1)*%(/'1),>"),@&-*6&,*":5,(-"',("Q&24+1),>"D_ESE"+5*"+:"*%&"),*&/&-*">&,&/'*&(":/+6"/&*)/&&-0":5,(-R"'*"*%&"-'6&"*)6&"Wi+7-),"#LL#X<""" Q$%&/&0-"-+6&*%),>"*+"4&"-')(":+/"8+2)*)7)',-"'7*),>"2);&"*%&30/&">++("8&+82&<"F&/&?"8+2)*)7)',-"'7*"1)*%")685,)*3<"F+1"(+"3+5"*/5-*"8&+82&"2);&"*%'*["F+1"(+"3+5"(+"45-),&--"1)*%"-+6&+,&"2);&"*%'*["F+1"7',"3+5"&,*/5-*"*%+5-',(-?"%5,(/&(-"+:"*%+5-',(-"+:"(+22'/-"+:"3+5/"%'/("&'/,&("6+,&3"1)*%"8&+82&"2);&"*%'*?R"N'//3"A5&,*&-?"',+*%&/"4'2);4'3',"/&*)/&&?"'-;&("6&"),"'"/%&*+/)7'2"*+,&<"""

O+5";,+1"1%&,"3+5"6&&*"1)*%"3+5/"'>&,*"'*"*%&"D_E?"*%&3"'7*"2);&")*0-"',"%+,+/"*+"%'@&"z4'2);4'3',-{"),@&-*"*%&)/"6+,&3"1)*%"*%&6<"N5*"':*&/"'"1%)2&?"3+5"5,(&/-*',(")*0-"I5-*"',+*%&/"1'3"*+">&*"6+/&"6+,&3"+5*"+:"5-<"O+5"*%),;")*0-"'22"&H8&,-&-"8')(":+/?"2);&"',"'229),725-)@&"@'7'*)+,?"2);&"'"7/5)-&<"$%'*0-"%+1"*%&3"-&22")*"*+"3+5"'*"*%+-&"7+,@&,*)+,-<"N5*"1%&,"3+50/&":),'223"%&/&?")*0-"+,&"*%),>"':*&/"',+*%&/\3+5"1+,(&/?"1%&/&0-"'22"*%)-"6+,&3">+),><""

"_&>'/(2&--"+:"*%&)/"()-82&'-5/&"1)*%"D_ESE"',("*%&"63/)'("+:"8/+42&6-"*%'*"8&/-)-*"1)*%),"*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/3?"4+*%"N'//3"',("h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e&#-:!&F!"55*8%/#$!4R)-7$*&#/0*$*-:!*#!+/8/3$/3!

"J5/),>"*%&"),'5>5/'2"+/'*)+,":+/"*%&"A/&&"=,)@&/-)*3?"1%)2&"8/&-&,*),>"

,'//'*)@&-"+,"K%),'0-"&@&/"&H8',(),>"&7+,+6)7",&*1+/;"+:"+@&/-&'-"2'4+/"7+,*/'7*-"',("5-'>&"+:":+/&)>,"7+,7&--)+,-"*%/+5>%+5*"B+5*%&'-*"E-)'"',("E:/)7'?"V3r/)"Ds2",+*&("),*/)>5),>"+4-&/@'*)+,-"%&"/&7+/(&("1%)2&"@)-)*),>"*%&"h+2(&,"N+*&,"K)*3?"'"

Page 116: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!Lc"

/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&"'(I'7&,*"*+"*%&"4+/(&/"+:"V+/*%&/,"i'+-<a#""d8&,&("),"&'/23"#LL`?"*%&"Q6+-*"),*&/,'*)+,'2)Y&("6+(&/,"7)*3"),"i'+-R"1'-":),',7&("',("(&@&2+8&("43"*%&"K%),&-&"),@&-*6&,*"7+68',3"A59l%),>"',(")-"-)*5'*&("+,"bLLL"'7/&-"+:"2&'-&("2',("*%'*"+7758)&-"+,&"+:"K%),'0-",56&/+5-"(&-)>,'*&("-8&7)'2"&7+,+6)7"Y+,&-"WB.qX<"$%&"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&0-":'7)2)*)&-?"1%)7%"),725(&"7+66+,"/&*)/&6&,*"'6&,)*)&-"-57%"'-"'"-%+88),>"()-*/)7*?"7+,(+6),)56-?"',("'">+2:"7+5/-&?"'/&"(&-)>,&("*+"%)>%2)>%*"*%&"%+*&297'-),+"7+682&H"*%'*"2)&-"'*"*%&"7&,*&/"+:"*%&"@)22'>&<"S+/&"),*/)>5),>"*+"Ds2"%+1&@&/?"1'-"*%'*"'8'/*":/+6"*%&"-8'/-&",564&/"+:"$%')"',("i'+*)',"*+5/)-*-"-*/&1,"'/+5,("*%&"@)22'>&"2',(-7'8&?"*%&"@'-*"6'I+/)*3"+:"*%&"7+682&H0-"-*'::?":/+6"*%&"-*+/&"6&/7%',*-"*+")*-"6)2)*'/)Y&("-&75/)*3?"1&/&"7+68+-&("+:"K%),&-&"7+,*/'7*&("2'4+/<"!

d,&"7',")6'>),&"*%&"2++;"+:"-5/8/)-&"+,"*%&":'7&"+:"*%&"',*%/+8+2+>)-*"'-"%&"1'-"'-;&("*+"8'3"1)*%"K%),&-&"35',"/'*%&/"*%',"*%&"),:2'*&("i'+-";)8"75//&,73<"C*"1+52("-&&6":/+6"Ds2u-"(&-7/)8*)+,-"*%'*"&@&,"*%&"6),5*&-*"(&*')2"+:"*%&"@)22'>&"4&-8+;&"*%&"8/&-&,7&"+:"K%),&-&">+@&/,',7&"),725(),>"*%&"@)22'>&0-"&2&7*/)7"-+7;&*-?"1%)7%"&@&,"7+,(57*&("K%),&-&"+1,&("&2&7*/)7)*3<"$%&"&,*)/&"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&"',("*%&"-8&7)'2"&7+,+6)7"Y+,&"*%'*")*"/&-)(&("1)*%),"%'("4&7+6&"7%'/'7*&/)-*)7":&'*5/&-"+:"K%),'0-"8+2)*)7'2"',("&7+,+6)7"8/'7*)7&"+:"&H*/'*&//)*+/)'2)*3<aZ"Ds2u-"&H8&/)&,7&-"),"i'+-"'/&"8&/*),&,*"*+"()-75--),>"*%&"),*&/6),>2),>"+:"&7+,+6)7"),*&/&-*-"&6&/>),>"4&*1&&,"&7+,+6)7'223"(&6'/7'*&("/&>)+,-"),"E-)'"72&'/23<"$%&"),*&/*1),),>"+:"*%&-&"),*&/&-*-"'/&"/&8/&-&,*&("*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"8/+(57*)+,"+:"&7+,+6)7"Y+,&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-0"/&*)/&6&,*"2',(-7'8&-<"O&*?"5,2);&"K%),&-&"/&*)/&6&,*"Y+,&-"-57%"'-"*%&"h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

N&:+/&"()-75--),>"*%&"&6&/>&,7&"+:"/&*)/&6&,*"2',(-7'8&-?"*%&)/"(&-)>,'*)+,"'-"B.q-"43"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*?"',("*%&"&@)(&,7&"*%'*"*%&-&"4/+'(&,),>":+/6-"+:"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*'2)*3"'/&"8+),*),>"*+1'/(-"*%&"7+5,*/30-"U5)7;23"-%):*),>"8+2)73"'1'3":/+6"=<B<97&,*/)7"&7+,+6)7"(&8&,(&,73?")*")-"1+/*%1%)2&"*+"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""a#"V3r/)"Ds20-"2&7*5/&"+,"*%&"h+2(&,"N+*&,"K)*3")-"8'/*"+:"'"2'/>&/"7%'8*&/"*%'*"%&"1/+*&"),"V3r/)"Ds2"',("K%/)-"i3**2&*+,0-"oJ'6-?"K'-),+-"',("K+,7&--)+,-f"K%),&-&"S&>'8/+I&7*-"),"i'+-"',("K'64+()'?o"),"4#8*#--%*#8!4/%$,?!+,-!"57/)$:!&F!6-8/4#8*#--%*#8!;%&V-)$:?"WV&1"O+/;f"B8/),>&/?"#LLaX?":+/*%7+6),><"aZ"A+/"'"7+,7)-&"),*/+(57*)+,"*+"7+,*&68+/'/3"8'**&/,-"+:"K%),&-&"&H*/'*&//)*+/)'2)*3?"-&&"E)%1'"d,>?"o$%&"K%),&-&"EH)-f"q+,),>"$&7%,+2+>)&-"',("G'/)&>'*&("B+@&/&)>,*3?o"Y&(%#/0!&F!4/:$!A:*/#!E$('*-:"!a?",+<"b"W#LLbXf"ec9ce<"$%&"8+2)*)7'2"%)-*+/3?".)2&&,"B75223"(&-7/)4&-"*%&"%)-*+/)7'2"8/'7*)7&"+:"&H*/'*&//)*+/)'2)*3"),"K%),&-&"8+2)*)7'29&7+,+63"),".)2&&,"D<"B752230-"Q$';),>"*%&"i+1"_+'("*+"B),+9E6&/)7',"_&2'*)+,-f"d8&,"J++/".H8',-)+,)-*-"',("*%&"$1+"K%),'"S'/;&*-?R"Y&(%#/0!&F!A5-%*)/#!O*:$&%3"`#?",+<"!"W!ccMXf"e#9`Z<"""

Page 117: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!!L"

I5H*'8+-&"*%&-&"7+,*&68+/'/3"(&@&2+86&,*-"*+"2'/>&/"()-75--)+,-"'/+5,(">+@&/,6&,*'2)*3"',("&7+,+6)7"Y+,&-<"S57%"%'-"4&&,"1/)**&,"'4+5*"*%&"7+,*&68+/'/3"&6&/>&,7&"',("5-&"+:"&7+,+6)7"Y+,&-"'-"'"Y+,&"+:"8+2)*)7'2"&H7&8*)+,"',("@'/)&>'*&("-+@&/&)>,*3"*%/+5>%+5*"/&>)+,'2"-8'7&-"2);&".'-*"E-)'?"*%&"K'/)44&',?"',("P&-*"E:/)7'<ab"d,>"W#LLa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d,>"'/>5&-"*%'*"*%&"2'7;"+:"'77+5,*'4)2)*3"*%'*"K%),&-&"),()@)(5'2-"%'("*+1'/(-"*%&"2+7'2"2&>'2"-3-*&6"/&8/&-&,*-"'",&1":+/6"+:"B*'*&"7+,*/+2"8/'7*)7&("43"*%&"K%),&-&">+@&/,6&,*<""E-"V3)/)t-"&H8&/)&,7&"),"i'+-"8+)>,',*23"(&6+,-*/'*&-?"7+,@&/-'*)+,-"'/+5,("*%&-&"*38&-"+:"&H*/'*&//)*+/)'2)Y&("-8'7&-"4'/&"&,+/6+5-"1&)>%*"+,",+*"+,23"7+,7&8*)+,-"+:"7)*)Y&,-%)8"',(",'*)+,9-*'*&"-+@&/&)>,*3?"45*"*%&"7/&'*)@&"6&'-5/&-">+@&/,6&,*-"*';&"),"+/(&/"*+"(/'19),"7'8)*'2"*+"-&7*+/-"+:"*%&)/"&7+,+63"*%'*"1+52("+*%&/1)-&"4&"5,-5-*'),'42&"',("6'),*'),"7+,*/+2"+:"*%&"8/+:)*-"'77/5&("43"*%&-&"&7+,+6)7"-&7*+/-<""

$%&"-*/57*5/&"+:"/&*)/&6&,*"2',(-7'8&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"7+682)7'*&"7+,7&8*)+,-"+:"&H*/'*&//)*+/)'2)*3")682)7)*"1)*%),"Y+,&-"+:"&H7&8*)+,<"$%+5>%"*%&3"'/&"'(6),)-*/'*&("43"*%&"),*&/-&7*),>"),*&/&-*-"+:"'",564&/"+:"652*),'*)+,'2"7+/8+/'*)+,-?"6',3"+1,&("43"l+/&',"+/"k'8',&-&"),@&-*+/-?"*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"2',(-7'8&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"8'/*)752'/23"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-"*%&6-&2@&-?"7+,*),5&"*+"4&"%)>%23"/&>52'*&("43"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*'2"8+2)7)&-"',(")*-"+1,"2)4&/'2"&7+,+6)7"+4I&7*)@&-<"C,"*%)-"1'3?"/&*)/&6&,*"2',(-7'8&-"/&8/&-&,*"*%&"6',,&/"),"1%)7%"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*"7+,*),5&-"*+"6'),*'),"7+,*/+2"'6)(-*"7'*&/),>"*+":2+1-"+:"7+68&*),>":+/&)>,"),@&-*6&,*-<"

d,7&"),@&-*+/-"',("(&@&2+8&/-"4&2)&@&("*%'*"*%&3"%'("(&@&2+8&("'"-577&--:52"6+(&2"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-"*%'*"1+52(":),'223"7+,@),7&"4'2);4'3',-"*+"/&*)/&"),"*%&"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""ab"C66&/-&("),"7+,@&/-'*)+,-"'/+5,("h)+/>)+"E>'64&,t-")2256),'*)@&"7+,7&8*-"+:"o4'/&"2):&o"',("oY+,&-"+:"),()-*),7*)+,o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cc`X<"=,2);&"E>'64&,0-"','23-)-"+:"8'/*)752'/)Y&("Y+,&-"1%&/&"),()@)(5'2-"1&/&"-*/)88&("+:"/)>%*-"),"82'7&-"1%&/&"-*'*&"2'1"%'("4&&,"-5-8&,(&(?"'",564&/"+:"-7%+2'/-"+,"*%&"+*%&/"%',(?",'6&23"E)%1'"d,>?"1&/&"),*&/&-*&("),"'/*)752'*),>"*%&"+*%&/"-)(&"+:"&H7&8*)+,<"d,>0-"W#LLaX"/&7&,*"1+/;"&H'6),&-"%+1"K%),&-&",&+2)4&/'2"&7+,+6)7"8+2)7)&-"'/&"8/+(57),>"Y+,&-"+:"&H7&8*)+,"1%&/&43"K%),&-&"7+/8+/'*)+,-?"),@&-*+/-?"',("2'4+/"6)>/',*-"5*)2)Y&"B.q-"*+"&H8',("*%&"K%),&-&"&7+,+63"*%/+5>%+5*".'-*"',("B+5*%&'-*"E-)'<"B&&"Wd,>"#LLeX<"A+/"'"/&2'*&("()-75--)+,"+,"&7+,+6)7"Y+,&-"7/&'*&("43"/&-+5/7&"&H*/'7*)+,"),"P&-*"E:/)7'?"-&&"WA&/>5-+,"#LLMg"P'**-"#LLbX"

Page 118: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!!!"

D%)2)88),&-?"'22"*%'*"1'-"2&:*"1'-":+/"*%&"D_E"',("(&@&2+8&/-"*+"2+443"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*"*+"),-*)*5*&"6&'-5/&-"*%'*"1+52(":5/*%&/":'7)2)*'*&"*%&"-&**2&6&,*"+:"4'2);4'3',-"),*+"/&*)/&6&,*"-&**),>-<"$%&-&"6&'-5/&-"%'("*%&"&::&7*"+:">/',*),>"@)22'>&"+1,&/-?"+8&/'*+/-?"',("/&*)/&&-"'",564&/"+:"-8&7)'2"/)>%*-"*%'*"1&/&"8/&725(&(":/+6"2+7'2"A)2)8),+-?"),725(),>"*%+-&"1%+"1+/;&("'*"*%&"/&*)/&6&,*":'7)2)*)&-<"O&*?"1%)2&":'7)2)*)&-"7+,*),5&"*+"4&"+1,&("',("6','>&("43"k'8',&-&"+/"l+/&',"7+/8+/'*)+,-?"*%&)/"-&/@)7&-"'/&",+*"2)6)*&("*+"&)*%&/"k'8',&-&"+/"l+/&',"72)&,*&2&<"$%&"4&,&:)*-"4&-*+1&("*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*"43"8'/*23"7'*&/),>"*+"4'2);4'3',-";&&8-"*%&">+@&/,6&,*":/+6"4&),>"),&H*/)7'423"2),;&("1)*%"*%&"),*&/&-*-"+:":+/&)>,"),@&-*+/-<"

C,"6',3"7'-&-?"*%&"7+66)*6&,*"43"K%),&-&"+::)7)'2-"',("7+/8+/'*&"&H&75*)@&-"*+"7+66&,7&"45)2(),>"8/+I&7*-"),"()::&/&,*"7+5,*/)&-"),"E:/)7'"%'@&"&,*)*2&("*%&"K%),&-&"*+"'22"6',,&/-"+:":5*5/&"&7+,+6)7"8/)@)2&>&-"4&*1&&,"7+5,*/)&-"Wi&&"#LLcX<"C,"*%&"7'-&"+:"*%&"h+2(&,"N+*&,"K)*3?"&,*/&8/&,&5/)'2"8'/*,&/-%)8-"4&*1&&,"i'+-"',("K%),'"%'@&"*%&"&::&7*"+:"-*/&,>*%&,),>"',"'2/&'(3"-*5/(3"2),;'>&"4&*1&&,"4+*%"7+5,*/)&-<"C,"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%+1&@&/?"5,2);&"*%&"h+2(&,"N+*&,"K)*3?"1%)7%"%'("4&7+6&"'"*+5/)-6"7+,:)>5/'*)+,"+:"8/)6'/)23"i'+*)',?"$%')?"',("6+-*23"K%),&-&"@)-)*+/-?"*%&-&"/&*)/&6&,*"Y+,&-"1&/&"8/+(57&("),"-57%"'-"1'3"*%'*"*%&3"7'*&/&("*+"',"'//'3"+:"@)-)*+/-<"$%&"Jd$"',("D_E"8/+I&7*&("*%'*"/&*)/&&-"1+52(",+*"+,23"7+,-)-*"+:"4'2);4'3',-"+/"+*%&/"E6&/)7',-"45*"1+52("'2-+":'7)2)*'*&"*%&":2+1"+:"&2(&/23"8+852'*)+,-"7+6),>":/+6"K%),'?"k'8',?"',("&-8&7)'223"l+/&'<""

$%&3"/&23"+,"*%&"7+,:25&,7&"+:"&7+,+6)7"'>&,('-"4&*1&&,"*%&"*+5/)-6?"/&*)/&6&,*?"',("6&()7'2"),(5-*/)&-"),"+/(&/"*+"8/+(57&"%)>%23"7+68&*)*)@&"*+5/)-*)7"&,@)/+,6&,*-?"1%)7%"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*"%+8&-"1)22"'**/'7*"*%&"&2(&/23"8+852'*)+,-"+:"'",564&/"+:"(&@&2+8&("7+5,*/)&-"',("&@&,*5'223"6';&"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*%&">2+4'2"/&*)/&6&,*"%'@&,<"E-"+:"#LLc?"+5*"+:"*%&"*1+9%5,(/&("',("-&@&,":52239+8&/'*),>"B.q-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"&2&@&,"'/&"-8&7):)7'223"(&6'/7'*&("'-"$+5/)-6".7+,+6)7"q+,&-"W$.qX"+/"S&()7'2"$+5/)-6"K&,*&/-"WS$KX"W:)><"!"',("#X<"P%)2&"6+-*"'/&"7+,7&,*/'*&("'/+5,("*%&"8&/)8%&/3"+:"*%&"VK_?"/&*)/&6&,*"2',(-7'8&-"&H)-*"),"V+/*%&/,"i5Y+,?"*%&"G)-'3'-"',("),"K&45"),"8'/*)752'/?"',("),"*%&"@'7'*)+,"/&-+/*-"'/+5,("*%&"D'2'1',"C-2',(-<"d*%&/"$.q-"'/&"4&),>"(&@&2+8&("'/+5,("*%&"8/+@),7&-"+:"K'6'/),&-"B5/"',("*1+"'/&"4&),>"(&@&2+8&("),"K'@)*&<"A5/*%&/6+/&?"82',-"*+"7+,*),5&"(&6'/7'*),>"B.q-"',("7/&'*),>"$.q-"),"82'7&-"J'@'+"',("S),(','+"%'-"4&7+6&"6+/&"7/57)'2"'-"6&',-"+:"45**/&--),>"&7+,+6)7"/&2'*)+,-"1)*%"&6&/>),>"&7+,+6)&-"),"*%&"B+5*%&'-*"E-)',",&*1+/;"WV&--"#LLZ?"!!L9!!!X<"$%&"8+2)*)7'2"&7+,+6)7"5-&"+:"$.q-"4&7+6&-"&@&,"6+/&"'88'/&,*"1)*%"()-75--)+,-"'/+5,("(&@&2+8),>"Y+,&-"),"S),(','+"*%/+5>%"1%)7%"'(6),)-*/'*+/-"%+8&"*+"U5&22"*%/&'*-"+:"*&//+/)-6"WV&--"#LLMX<"

E*"*%&"-'6&"*)6&"%+1&@&/?"),"+/(&/"*+"'7%)&@&"*%&-&">+'2-?"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*")-"7'/&:5223"4'2',7),>"*%&"),@&-*6&,*-"+:"@'/)+5-":+/&)>,">/+58-<"P%)2&"*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/3")-"'>>/&--)@&23"*'/>&*),>":+/6&/"A)2)8),+"7)*)Y&,-"&-8&7)'223"),"*%&"=<B<?")*")-"'2-+">+),>"*+"-)6)2'/"2&,>*%-"*+"7'*&/"*+":+/&)>,"),@&-*+/-?"8'/*)752'/23"*%+-&"),"+*%&/"E-)',"7+5,*/)&-<"A+/"),-*',7&?"),"$'>'3*'3?"l+/&',-"%'@&"&-*'42)-%&("-&@&/'2"/&-*'5/',*-"',("',"),*&/,'*)+,'2"-7%++2"(&-)>,&("-8&7):)7'223":+/".,>2)-%"

Page 119: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!!#"

2',>5'>&"),-*/57*)+,<aM"E((),>"*+"*%)-"*/&,(?"),"A&4/5'/3"#LL!?"*%&"l+/&'9D%)2)88),&-"A/)&,(-%)8"F+-8)*'2"1'-"&-*'42)-%&("I5-*"+5*-)(&"+:"$'>'3*'3"),"*%&"6'I+/"6&*/+8+2)*',"7)*3"+:"K'@)*&<"$%&"%+-8)*'2"1'-"2'/>&23":5,(&("43"6&64&/-"+:"*%&"l+/&',"C,@&-*+/-"E--+7)'*)+,"K'@)*&?"'">/+58"+:"l+/&',"45-),&--6&,"1%+"%'@&"4&,&:)*&(":/+6"*'H"),7&,*)@&-"7/&'*&("43"*%&"KEiENE_qdV"&7+,+6)7"Y+,&"Wl&223"#LL!X<ae"""

$%)-">/+1),>"7+665,)*3"+:"l+/&',")66)>/',*-"%'@&"2'/>&23"4&,&:)*&(":/+6"-8&7)'2"'77+66+('*)+,-"2);&"*%&"B__G?"-*5(3"8&/6)*-?"',("*'H"),7&,*)@&-"*%'*"%&28"*+"6+*)@'*&"&,*/&8/&,&5/)'2">/+1*%<"$%&"/)-&"+:"l+/&',"),@&-*6&,*-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"/&>)+,"%'-"4&&,"/&7&)@&("1)*%"6)H&("/&@)&1-":/+6"2+7'2"A)2)8),+"7+665,)*)&-<"E*"*%&"-'6&"*)6&"%+1&@&/?"$'>'3*'3")-"U5)7;23"4&7+6),>"%+6&"*+"'">/+1),>",564&/"+:"4'2);4'3',-"1%+"'/&"4&,&:)**),>":/+6"*%&"-'6&"),7&,*)@&-"',("'/&"'2-+"45)2(),>"%+6&-"+/"-&**2),>"),*+"*%&"@)4/',*"/&*)/&6&,*"7+665,)*)&-"1)*%),"$'>'3*'3<"$%)-"6)H*5/&"+:"2+7'2"A)2)8),+-?"4'2);4'3',-?"',("l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

d,&"+:"*%&"/&'-+,-"1%3"2+7'2"A)2)8),+-"'/&"/&-&,*:52"*+1'/(-"*%)-"),7+6),>">/+58"+:")66)>/',*-"'/&"*%&"@'/)+5-"&H7&8*)+,-")66)>/',*-"&H8&/)&,7&"1%)2&"/&*)/),>"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"d,&"+:"*%&"8/)@)2&>&-"),725(&("),"/&*)/&6&,*"Y+,&-"'/&">+@&/,6&,*'2"),7&,*)@&-"*%'*"-588+/*"/&*)/&&-"1%+"(+"#&$"1',*"*+"/&*)/&<"S'/)-+2".-*/&22'"K'2'>T',"J'22&3?"'"/&7&,*"Q/&*)/&&R"/&-)(),>"'*"*%&"$'>'3*'3"i';&@)&1".-*'*&-?"'('6',*23"4&2)&@&-"*%'*"'26+-*"'22"4'2);4'3',"/&*)/&&-"'/&"),72),&("*+1'/(-",+*"/&*)/),><"""

E*":)/-*")*"-&&6-"2);&"'">++(")(&'<"N5*"):"3+5"%'@&"-8&,*"6',3"3&'/-"'4/+'(?"3+5022">+"7/'Y3"):"3+5"(+,0*"1+/;"%&/&<"O+5"%'@&"*+":),("*%),>-"*%'*"1)22";&&8"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""aM"C*")-"+5*-)(&"+:"*%&"-7+8&"+:"*%)-"8'8&/"*+"()-75--"*%&"%)-*+/)7'2"1'@&-"+:"l+/&',")66)>/'*)+,"),*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*%'*"4&>',"),"-8'/-&"),7/&6&,*-"4&>),,),>"),"*%&"`*%"7&,*5/3"',("*++;"'",&1"&7+,+6)7":+/6"':*&/"*%&"!c`L-<"E,,5'2"_&8+/*"+:"B*'*)-*)7-"+,"C66)>/'*)+,"',(".6)>/'*)+,"K+,*/+2"+:"*%&"B+5*%"l+/&',"S),)-*/3"+:"k5-*)7&?":/+6"!c`M"*+"#LL!?"*%&"',,5'2",564&/"+:"/&>)-*&/&("l+/&',-")66)>/'*),>"),*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'-"),7/&'-&("43"!e"8&/7&,*<"B&&"G)/>),)'"E<"S)/'2'+?"o=,(&/-*',(),>"*%&"l+/&',"J)'-8+/'"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?o"),"4R70&%*#8!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!D&55(#*$*-:!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:?"#b9Zc"Wx5&Y+,"K)*3f"D%)2)88),&"S)>/'*)+,"_&-&'/7%"V&*1+/;"WDS_VX"',("D%)2)88),&"B+7)'2"B7)&,7&"K+5,7)2"WDBBKX?"#LLaX<""ae"D%)2)8"l&223"6)>%*"'/>5&"*%'*"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*"2&("43"l+/&',"),@&-*+/-"),"KEiENE_qdV")-"&,(&6)7"+:"7+,*),5+5-"'**&68*-"6'(&"43";&3"),@&-*+/-"',("(&@&2+8&/-"*+"&2)7)*"6&',-"),"+/(&/"*+"7+68&*&"1)*%"*%&"VK_"'-"*%&"/&>)+,0-"2&'(),>"&7+,+6)7"8/+(57&/<"P%)2&"7+66&/7)'2"',("/&-)(&,*)'2"8/+I&7*-":),(")*"()::)752*"*+"7+68&*&"1)*%"*%&"6'/;&*"'**/'7*)@&,&--"+:"*%&"VK_?"*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/3")-"),7/&'-),>23"2++;),>"*+"KEiENE_qdV"'-"'"8+*&,*)'223"-577&--:52"'2*&/,'*)@&<"B&&"D%)2)8"l&223?"N/#':)/7-:!&F!@0&2/0*T/$*&#?!O(5/#!@-&8%/7,*-:!&F!4)&#&5*)!D,/#8-!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:"Wi+,(+,f"_+5*2&(>&?"#LLLX<"

Page 120: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!!Z"

3+5"45-3<"C"*%+5>%*?"1&22?")*"1+52("4&",)7&"*+"%'@&"'"7%',>&"+:"8'7&<"C0@&"4&&,"1+/;),>"'22"63"2):&\:+/"'26+-*":)@&"(&7'(&-]"C"7'6&"%&/&"',("1&"4+5>%*"'"/&*)/&6&,*"8'7;'>&"%&/&"),"$'>'3*'3<"C"-*'/*&("*+">&*"'"2)**2&"7/'Y3"',("*%&,"C"*+2("63"%5-4',("*%'*"C"1',*&("*+">+"4'7;"*+"1+/;<"$%&,"%&"-')(?"uC"*%+5>%*"3+5"1',*"*+"/&2'H?"1%3"()("1&"&,("58"7+6),>"4'7;"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-0<"C"*+2("%)6?"uP&22"1%'*"(+"3+5"&H8&7*?"C0@&"4&&,"1+/;),>"'22"+:"63"2):&0<"C06"',"),(&8&,(&,*"1+6',]"C"7',0*"I5-*"-)*"'/+5,("*%&"%+5-&"',("6';&":++(":+/"63"%5-4',(?R"S'/)-+2"-')(?"%&/"1+/(-"425/*&("+5*"),"4&*1&&,"),*&/6)**&,*"4+5*-"+:"2'5>%*&/<"

"S'/)-+2"1'-":+/*5,'*&"*%'*"%&/"%5-4',("%'("7'-%&("),"%)-"),@&-*6&,*-"4&:+/&"*%&3"(&*&/)+/'*&("),"*%&"/&7&,*"-*+7;"6'/;&*"7/'-%<"F'@),>"1+/;&("8/)6'/)23"'-"'"7'/&>)@&/?"S'/)-+2"%'("6'(&"%&/"1'3"'2+,>"*%&"+5*-;)/*-"+:"_+6&"',("i+,(+,"'*"'"3+5,>"'>&"4&:+/&":),'223"-&**2),>"),"B+5*%"B',"A/',7)-7+"1%&/&"-%&"6&*"%&/"%5-4',("h&+/>&<"F&/"%5-4',(?"4&),>"'",'*)@&"+:"=*'%"1)*%"/++*-"*%'*">+"4'7;"-&@&/'2"(&7'(&-?"%'(",&@&/"-*&88&(":++*"+5*-)(&"+:"*%&"7+5,*/3"5,*)2"%&"6'//)&("S'/)-+2"',("+,23"*%&,"*+"@)-)*"%)-"),92'1-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"h&+/>&",&@&/")6'>),&("*%'*"%&"1+52("/&*)/&"),"%)-"1):&0-"%+6&"7+5,*/3<"F+1&@&/?"4&7'5-&"+:"S'/)-+20-"652*),'*)+,'2"&682+36&,*"%)-*+/3"',("),'4)2)*3"*+":),(":5229*)6&"1+/;"*%/+5>%+5*"%&/"3&'/-"),"*%&"=<B<?"%&/"),7+6&"()(",+*"'77/5&"&,+5>%"-+7)'2"-&75/)*3"*+"-5::)7)&,*23"-5882&6&,*"h&+/>&0-"),7+6&<"d,7&"4+*%"S'/)-+2"',("h&+/>&"1&/&"),*/+(57&("*+"*%&")(&'"+:"/&*)/),>"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"4+*%"4&>',"7'/&:5223"82',,),>"*%&)/":5*5/&"),@&-*6&,*-"),"*%&"$'>'3*'3"i';&@)&1".-*'*&-<"Qd5/"7%)2(/&,"1&/&"-&**2&(?"*%&3"1&/&"6'//)&(?"',("&@&,"%'(";)(-<"B+"*%&3"1&/&"%'883"*+"7+6&"',("-&&"5-"+,7&"'"3&'/<"$)6&-"'/&"*+5>%"W:),',7)'223X"45*"'*"2&'-*"+,&"+:"+5/"7%)2(/&,">&*-"*+"7+6&"(5/),>"K%/)-*6'-"*)6&R?"h&+/>&"-'3-"1%)2&"2++;),>"7+68'--)+,'*&23"'*"S'/)-+2<"Q$%'*0-"*%&"%'/(&-*"*%),>":+/"5-?"45*"&-8&7)'223":+/"S'/)<R""

F+1&@&/?"*%&"7+582&"/&:5-&("*+"-*'3"/&*)/&(":+/"@&/3"2+,><"N&,&:)*),>":/+6"'"2&,)&,*"4',;":),',7),>"8/+>/'6?"*%&"J'22&3-"1&/&"'42&"*+"5-&"6+,&3"*%'*"h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z4'2);4'3',-{?R"h&+/>&"6&,*)+,&("'-"%&"8/&8'/&("'"-*&'6),>"758"+:"&-8/&--+<"Q$%'*0-"*%&"+,23"(&7&,*"758"+:"&-8/&--+"*%'*"3+5022":),(":+/"6)2&-?R"%&"&H72')6&("1%)2&"2'5>%),>"2+5(23<"

A+/*5,'*&23":+/"S'/)-+2"W',("h&+/>&X?"4'2);4'3',-"1%+"'/&"2++;),>"*+"),@&-*"),"'"-6'22945-),&--"'/&"&,7+5/'>&("43"/&7&,*"6&'-5/&-"8'--&("),"#LL#"43"*%&"D%)2)88),&"K+,>/&--<"E77+/(),>"*+"_<E<"V+<"c!a`?"*%&">+@&/,6&,*?"Q8/+6+*&-"*%&"&-*'42)-%6&,*"+:"4'/',>'3"6)7/+"45-),&--"&,*&/8/)-&-"WNSN.-X<R"B6'22"45-),&--&-"2);&"*%&"J'22&30-"/&-*'5/',*"'/&"2+',&("4&*1&&,"Dj!LL?LLL"*+"jMLL?LLL"43"(&-)>,'*&("4',;-"*+";&&8"*%&)/"&-*'42)-%6&,*-"':2+'*<"P%)2&"*%&"NSN.-"'/&":+75-&("+,"/&I5@&,'*),>"45-),&--&-"),"*%&"'>/)45-),&--"',("'U5'752*5/&?"1++("',("%',()7/':*-?"),:+/6'*)+,"*&7%,+2+>3"',("4)+*&7%,+2+>3?"%&'2*%"7'/&?"',("&(57'*)+,"

Page 121: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!!b"

',("*/'),),>"-&7*+/-?"h&+/>&"1'-"7'/&:52"*+"6&,*)+,"*%'*"*%&"4',;-"%'("'::+/(&("S'/)-+2"',("%)6"-+6&"2&&1'3"4&7'5-&"*%&3"1&/&"Q/&*)/&&-R<"P%)2&"*%&"'--)-*',7&"8/+@)(&("43"*%&">+@&/,6&,*"*%/+5>%"*%&"NSN."6&'-5/&"6)>%*"'88&'/"6),+/?")*"6'(&"',"&H*/'+/(),'/3"'6+5,*"+:"()::&/&,7&"*+"*%&"J'22&3-<""

C*"6&',*"*%'*"S'/)-+2"',("h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h&+/>&"/&7&)@&("*%&"2+',":/+6"'"D%)2)88),&"4',;?"S'/)-+2"7+52("7+,*),5&"-&,(),>"6+,&3"*+"%&/"/&2'*)@&-"&@&,"*%+5>%"-%&"',("h&+/>&",+"2+,>&/"2)@&("),"*%&"=<B<"',("'-"-57%?"%'(",+"+42)>'*)+,"*+"/&6)*"',3"6+/&"6+,&3<"P)*%"2&--"*%',"=BJj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

d,"'"657%"2'/>&/"-7'2&?"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-"'/&"'::+/(&("'"*/&6&,(+5-"'6+5,*"+:"2&&1'3"43":),',7),>"),-*)*5*)+,-"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*<"B.q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q+,&"E5*%+/)*3"WD.qEX?"*%&">+@&/,6&,*'2"'>&,73"/&-8+,-)42&":+/"(&*&/6),),>"',("+@&/-&&),>"*%&"),7+/8+/'*)+,"+:":+/&)>,"),@&-*6&,*-"5,(&/"*%&"B8&7)'2".7+,+6)7"q+,&"E7*aa"WV>"#LLeX<""

E77+/(),>"*+")*-"1&4-)*&?"D.qE")-"'">+@&/,6&,*"'>&,73"*%'*")-"/&-8+,-)42&":+/"8/+6+*),>"Q),@&-*6&,*-?"&H*&,("'--)-*',7&?"/&>)-*&/?">/',*"),7&,*)@&-"*+"',(":'7)2)*'*&"*%&"45-),&--"+8&/'*)+,-"+:"),@&-*+/-"),"&H8+/*9+/)&,*&("6',5:'7*5/),>"',("""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""aa".,'7*&("43"*%&"_'6+-"'(6),)-*/'*)+,"),"!ccb?"_<E<"V+<"ac!e")-"',"Q'7*"8/+@)(),>":+/"*%&"2&>'2":/'6&1+/;"',("6&7%',)-6-":+/"*%&"7/&'*)+,?"+8&/'*)+,?"'(6),)-*/'*)+,?"',("7++/(),'*)+,"+:"-8&7)'2"&7+,+6)7"Y+,&-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"7/&'*),>":+/"*%)-"85/8+-&?"*%&"D%)2)88),&".7+,+6)7"q+,&"E5*%+/)*3"WD.qEÇ?"',("+*%&/"85/8+-&-R"D%)2)88),&".7+,+6)7"q+,&"E5*%+/)*3?"E7-)*/0!4)&#&5*)!e&#-!A)$?"#L!L?"%**8fpp111<8&Y'<>+@<8%p),(&H<8%8[+8*)+,É7+6Ç7+,*&,*w@)&1É'/*)72&w)(ÉcawC*&6)(ÉMM"W'77&--&("S'/7%"Z?"#L!LX<"

Page 122: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!!M"

-&/@)7&":'7)2)*)&-"),-)(&"-&2&7*&("'/&'-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"7+5,*/3"8/+72')6&("43"*%&"D/&-)(&,*"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'-"D.qE"B8&7)'2".7+,+6)7"q+,&-R"WD%)2)88),&".7+,+6)7"q+,&"E5*%+/)*3"#L!LX<"D/+I&7*-"'88/+@&("*+"4&"&H&68*&(":/+6"*'H'*)+,"*%/+5>%"*%&"BDq"),725(&"8&*/+7%&6)7'2"()-*/)45*),>?"*/',-8+/*"+)2"(&8+*-?"%&'2*%"7'/&"-&/@)7&-?"8'26"+)2"/&:),),>?"),:+/6'*)+,"*&7%,+2+>3":'7)2)*)&-?"'4'7'"8528"8/+7&--),>?"')/7/':*"6'),*&,',7&":+/":+/&)>,"')/2),&-?"',("-++,"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-<""

d,7&"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-"1&/&"&)*%&/"),725(&("1)*%),"*%&"8/+@)-)+,"+:"&7+,+6)7"Y+,&-"+/"7+,-*)*5*&("*%&6-&2@&-"'-"'"B.q?"*%&3">'/,)-%&("-&@&/'2"8/)@)2&>&-"),725(),>">&,&/+5-"*'H"4/&';-"',("*%&"25H5/3"+:")68+/*),>"&U5)86&,*"',("/&-+5/7&-":/+6"+*%&/"7+5,*/)&-"(5*39:/&&<".(>'/"F'4'2+?"'"/&'2*+/"1)*%"i',(&,6+/&"D/+8&/*)&-?"'"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,"*%'*"-8&7)'2)Y&-"),"-&22),>"8/+8&/*)&-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"KEiENE_qdV">/+1*%"7+//)(+/"W1%)7%"),725(&-"$'>'3*'3X?"&H82'),-"*%'*"*%&-&"(5*39:/&&"),7&,*)@&-"1&/&"7/)*)7'2"*+"*%&"-577&--"+:"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-<""

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

"C,(&&(?".(>'/0-"),-)>%*-"1&/&"@'2)("+,"'",564&/"+:"2&@&2-<"P%&,"*%&"D_E"'**&68*&("*+"&68%'-)Y&"%+6&-*'3),>a`?"'":&'*5/&"+:"*+5/)-6"1%&/&"*/'@&2&/-"7+52("-*'3"'*"*%&"%+6&-"+:"2+7'2"/&-)(&,*-"',("&,I+3"&'*),>"',("),*&/'7*),>"1)*%"2+7'2-"/'*%&/"*%',"4&),>"-&725(&("*+"@'7'*)+,"/&-+/*-?"*%&">+@&/,6&,*'2"'>&,730-"),,+@'*)+,"1'-"-%+/*92)@&(<"$%&"D_E"U5)7;23"/&'2)Y&("*%'*"*%&"/&-+5/7&-"',("7+,@&,)&,7&-"/&U5&-*&("43"*+5/)-*":/+6"*%&)/"%+-*-"4&7'6&"1'3"*++"7+-*23"WN5-),&--P+/2("#LLMX<"B++,?"A)2)8),+"%+5-&%+2(-"1&/&"-8&,(),>"*1+"*+"*%/&&"*)6&-"*%&"'6+5,*"+:"6+,&3"*%&3"%'("6'(&"),"%+5-),>"'"-),>2&"*+5/)-*<"""

C";,+1":/+6"2)@),>"),"*%&"=<B<":+/"6',3"3&'/-"*%'*"+,&"+:"*%&"1+/-*"*%),>-"'4+5*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-")-"*+",&&("*+"5-&"*%&"4'*%/++6"45*"*%&/&")-",+"-',)*'/3",'8;),-<"O+5";,+1?",+"*+)2&*"8'8&/<"E6"C"/)>%*["P&22"*+5/)-*"'88/&7)'*&"*%'*"),"'22"+:"+5/"4'*%/++6-"1&"%'@&",)7&"-+:*"*+)2&*"8'8&/<"N5*"1%&/&"(+"3+5"*%),;"1&">&*"'22"+:"*%+-&",)7&":25::3"*+)2&*"8'8&/<"P&")68+/*")*":/+6"F+,>"l+,><""

"P%)2&".(>'/"8+-&("%)-"/%&*+/)7'2"U5&-*)+,?"%&"/544&("%)-"*%564"'>'),-*"*%&"&,(-"+:"%)-"*1+9:),>&/-"'-"):"*+"-'3?"QS+,&3?")*"*';&-"2+*-"+:"6+,&3R<""

C*"1+52("-&&6"*%'*"*%&"&,*)/&"/&*)/&6&,*"),(5-*/3"/&-*&("5,&'-)23"+,"*%&"*/5*%"+:".(>'/0-"1+/(-<"$%&"JdC"',("D_E"%'@&"-8&,*"'">/&'*"(&'2"+:"&,&/>3"7+,@),7),>"*%&"D/&-)(&,*?"7+,>/&--)+,'2"6&64&/-?"',("7+/8+/'*&"&H&75*)@&-"*%'*"',"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""a`"B)6)2'/"*+"%+6&-*&'(),>"),"+*%&/"7+5,*/)&-<"

Page 123: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!!e"

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dC"',("D_E"7+,*),5&("*+":&/@&,*23"85-%":+/"6+/&"),@&-*6&,*-":/+6"*%&"8/)@'*&"-&7*+/<""

N3"),725(),>"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-"1)*%),"*%&"8/+*&7*&("2)-*"+:"B.q-?"*%&"D%)2)88),&">+@&/,6&,*")-">'642),>"+,"*%&"&,72'@&-"'**/'7*),>"@'/)+5-":+/6-"+:":+/&)>,"),@&-*6&,*-<"d,7&"D.qE"1'-"&-*'42)-%&(?"@'/)+5-"*+5/)-*)7"&,*&/8/)-&-"4&>',"'8823),>"*+"4&"7'*&>+/)Y&("'-"B.q-"',("),725(&("1)*%),")*-"564/&22'"+:"8/)@)2&>&-<"d,"*%&"'>&,730-"1&4-)*&?"*%&/&"'/&"'",564&/"+:"(+1,2+'(-"'22+1),>"@'/)+5-"45-),&--&-"*+"'8823<"E22"*%'*")-",&&(&(")-":+/"45-),&--"+1,&/-"*+"2)*&/'223"(+1,2+'("'"(+756&,*":/+6"*%&"1&4-)*&"',(":)229)*9+5*<"$%&"(&2)4&/'*)+,"8/+7&--")-"2+,>"',("),725-)+,":&&-"'/&"&H8&,-)@&<"O&*?"*%&"'88'/&,*"'77&--)4)2)*3"+:"*%&"'>&,730-"1&4-)*&"/&8/&-&,*-"*%&"&H54&/',7&"*%/+5>%"1%)7%">+@&/,6&,*'2"'>&,7)&-"'/&"/&7&)@),>"*%&">/+1*%"+:"*%&"2&)-5/&"),(5-*/3<"C*"'2-+"6)//+/-"*%&"+@&/&H*&,-)+,"+:"8542)7"7+66)*6&,*"8/&@)+5-23"8')("*+"S'/7+-0"&'/23"*+5/)-6"8/+I&7*-"1%)7%"+@&/&-*)6'*&("*%&"('5,*),>"7+-*-"+:"45)2(),>"'*"-57%"',"'77&2&/'*&("8'7&<"d,"*%&"+,&"%',(?"D_E"2+443)-*-"'/&"*/3),>"(&-8&/'*&23"*+"/&(57&"*%&"7+-*"+:"),)*)'2"(5&-":+/"/&*)/&&"@)-'-?"1%)2&"+,"*%&"+*%&/?"*%&"D_E")-"*/3),>"*+"/&(57&"*%&"+8&/'*),>"7+-*-"+:"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-<"h)@&,"*%&"%)-*+/3"+:"D%)2)88),&"8+2)*)7'29&7+,+63?"*%&":),'2"7+-*-"1)22"6+/&"*%',"2);&23"4&"82'7&("+,"*%&"4&2&'>5&/&("-%+52(&/-"+:"A)2)8),+"*'H98'3&/-<""

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x5+*),>"'"-*5(3"7+,(57*&("43"*%&"J&2+)**&"K&,*&/":+/"F&'2*%"B+25*)+,-"+,"Z?LLL"E6&/)7',-?"'>&,73"&H&75*)@&-":/+6"*%&"Jd$"&7-*'*)7'223"8/&-&,*&(",&1-"*%'*"'4+5*"aML?LLL"=B"7)*)Y&,-"*/'@&2&("'4/+'("*+">&*"6&()7'2"7'/&<"A5/*%&/6+/&?"*%&"/&8+/*"-5>>&-*&("*%'*",564&/"1'-"&H8&7*&("*+"),7/&'-&"*+"e?LLL?LLL"43"#L!L"W.(:*#-::B&%0'!#LL`X<""

N',;),>"+,"*%&"/&8+/*0-":5/*%&/"7+,725-)+,"*%'*"'*"2&'-*"*1+9+5*9+:9:)@&"E6&/)7',-"1+52("4&"1)22),>"*+"*/'@&2"'4/+'(":+/"%&'2*%7'/&?"'>&,73"&H&75*)@&-"7+66&,7&("82',-":+/"+8&,),>"-*'*&9+:9*%&9'/*"%+-8)*'2-"),"/&*)/&6&,*"@)22'>&-<"G'/)+5-"&H&75*)@&-"),"*%&"D_E"2+44)&(":+/"7+,>/&--)+,'2"-588+/*"43"7)*),>"&@)(&,7&"*%'*"43"+8&,),>"%+-8)*'2-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"*%&">+@&/,6&,*"7+52(":),'223"-+2@&"*%&"8/+42&6"+:"Q4/'),"(/'),R":+/7),>"6',3"-;)22&("A)2)8),+-"*+"1+/;"'4/+'("4&7'5-&"*%&3"7+52(",+*":),("1+/;"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"P%)2&"()-75--),>"*%&"8/&@'2&,7&"+:"k'8',&-&"7)*)Y&,-"/&*)/),>"),"B+5*%&'-*"E-)'?"$+3+*'"W#LLeX"&H82'),-"%+1"'-"8'/*"+:"*%&"8/+@)-)+,-"(&*')2&("A/&&"$/'(&"E>/&&6&,*-"4&*1&&,"k'8',"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-"),"

Page 124: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!!a"

#LLe?"k'8',&-&"-+5>%*"*%&"-&/@)7&-"+:"%&'2*%"7'/&"1+/;&/-"',(",5/-&-"*+"%&28"8/+@)(&"7'/&"*+"*%&"&H8+,&,*)'223">/+1*%"+:"*%&"'>&),>"8+852'*)+,"),"k'8',<"$%&-&"),)*)'*)@&-"%'("*%&"&::&7*"+:"'22+1),>"'"2)6)*&(",564&/"+:"%)>%23"U5'2):)&("A)2)8),+-"*+"&,*&/"k'8',"4&>),,),>"1)*%"bLL"A)2)8),+",5/-&-"',("eLL"U5'2):)&("7'/&>)@&/-"-*'/*),>":/+6"#LLe"WM#!X<""

C,"#LLc?"85-%&("43"*%&"7/)-)-"+:"*%&">/+1),>",564&/"+:"&2(&/23"8&+82&"),"k'8',?"k'8',&-&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"(&@&2+8&("82',-"*+"+8&,"%&'2*%":'7)2)*)&-"*%'*"1+52(":'7)2)*'*&"*%&"6+@&6&,*"+:"*%&"k'8',&-&"&2(&/23"+5*-)(&"+:"k'8',"',("),*+"82'7&-"2);&"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"A+/"&H'682&?"*%&"k'8',&-&":)/6"$+;5-%5;')"S&()7'2"K+/8+/'*)+,"'>/&&("*+"),@&-*"j!LL"6)22)+,"),*+"*%&"&-*'42)-%6&,*"+:"'"eL9%&7*'/&"%&'2*%"7'/&"Y+,&"*+"4&"82'7&("+,"/&72')6&("2',(<"O&*"1%)2&"*%&"%+-8)*'2")-"82',,&("*+"4&",'6&("*%&"N&,)>,+"EU5),+"S&6+/)'2"F+-8)*'2?"7+,7&/,-">/&1"1%&,"*%&"7+/8+/'*)+,"-*)852'*&("*%'*"*%&"%&'2*%"7'/&":'7)2)*3"1+52("+,23"&682+3"k'8',&-&"%&'2*%"7'/&"-*'::"',("-&/@&"8/)6'/)23"k'8',&-&"72)&,*&2&"WA2+/&-"#LLMX<"""

S+/&"*%',"*+5/)-*-":/+6"k'8',?"@)-)*+/-":/+6"B+5*%"l+/&'"%'@&"),"/&7&,*"3&'/-"7+68/)-&("*%&"6'I+/)*3"+:"*+5/)-6":2+1-"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"&H7&&(),>"*%&",564&/"+:"@)-)*+/-":/+6"*%&"=<B<"),725(),>"/&*5/,),>"dAP-<"N3"#LLe?"+@&/"MaL?LLL"B+5*%"l+/&',-"@)-)*&("*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("'77+/(),>"*+">+@&/,6&,*'2":)>5/&-?"58"*+"!LL?LLL"B+5*%"l+/&',-"%'@&"-&**2&("),*+"*%&"7+5,*/3"'-"8&/6',&,*"/&-)(&,*-<"i+7'2"A)2)8),+-"%'@&"'64)@'2&,*23"/&7&)@&("*%)-"),:5-)+,"+:":+/&)>,&/-<"P%)2&"*%&"*+5/)-6"',(")66)>/'*)+,"8/+(57&("43"B+5*%"l+/&',-?"1%+"7+6&"*+"D%)2)88),&-"5-5'223"'-"8'/*"+:"*%&"),7/&'-),>23"8+852'/".,>2)-%"2&'/,),>"8/+>/'6-?"K%/)-*)',"6)--)+,'/)&-?"+/"'-8)/),>"-6'22"45-),&--"&,*/&8/&,&5/-?"'/&"7+,*/)45*),>"'26+-*"%'2:"+:"*%&":),',7)'2"),@&-*6&,*-"W'77+5,*),>":+/"=BJj!<#"4)22)+,"+:"*%&"jZ<M"4)22)+,"),"),@&-*6&,*"7'8)*'2"*%'*"&,*&/&("*%&"D%)2)88),&-"),"#LLeX"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63?"-+6&"A)2)8),+-"%'@&"4&7+6&"5,-&**2&("43"*%&)/"),7/&'-),>"8/&-&,7&"WJ'6'Y+"#LLaX<"E"2)*',3"+:",&1-"/&8+/*-"',("&()*+/)'2-"%'@&"2'*7%&("+,*+"'"/',>&"+:"&@&,*-?":/+6"2&>'2"),7)(&,*-"*+"',&7(+*'2"&@)(&,7&?"),@+2@),>"2+7'2"45-),&--"+1,&/-"',("/&-)(&,*-"1%+"%'@&"'/&"),7/&'-),>23"/&-&,*:52"*+1'/(-"B+5*%"l+/&',"45-),&--"+8&/'*+/-":+/"'22&>'*)+,-"+@&/")68/+8&/"7+,(57*"',("()-7/)6),'*)+,"*+1'/(-"A)2)8),+-"',("*+5/)-*-"1%+"'/&"-')("*+"*/&'*"2+7'2"A)2)8),+-"4'(23<ac""

d,&"8'/*)752'/23"1&229;,+1,"',("/&'7*)+,'/3"&()*+/)'2)-*?"N5*7%"(&2"K'-*)22+"W#LLc'?"#LLc4X?"1/+*&"'"*1+98'/*"7+66&,*'/3"+,"*%&"Q),@'-)+,R"+:"*+5/)-*-"',("6)>/',*-":/+6"B+5*%"l+/&'<"$%&":+/6&/"8/&-)(&,*"+:"*%&"657%"1)(&23"7)/752'*&("6/#*0/!.(00-$*#"-5>>&-*&("*%'*"*%&"8/&-&,7&"+:"l+/&',-")-"/&6),)-7&,*"+:"*%&":+/&)>,"+7758'*)+,"+:"k'8',&-&"-+2()&/-"+,"*%&"'/7%)8&2'>+"(5/),>"*%&"P+/2("P'/"CC"',("'/&"-&**),>"58"Q4&'7%:/+,*-R"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"),"+/(&/"*+"&H82+)*"*%&"7+5,*/3"*%/+5>%"'",564&/"+:"-%'(3"/&-+5/7&"&H*/'7*)+,"8/+I&7*-<"B2)>%*23"85YY2&("43"*%&"H&,+8%+4)'"&,-7+,7&("1)*%),"*%)-"','2+>3?"V+/6',"K'-*/+?"'"A)29C,@&-*"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*?"+8&,23"1&27+6&("*%&"),:25H"+:"B+5*%"l+/&',-"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"C":)/-*"6&*"V+/6',"1%&,"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""ac"_&7&,*23?"*%&/&"%'-"4&&,"'"-8'*&"+:"'/*)72&-"8542)-%&("),"D%)2)88),&"(')2)&-"()-75--),>"*%&"Q),@'-)+,R"+:"B+5*%"l+/&',-"),*+"*%&"7+5,*/3<"B&&"'6+,>-*"+*%&/-?"k&*"J'6'Y+?"Ql+/&'"C,@'(&-"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?R"A:*/!E-#$*#-0?"#LLaf"!!9k523g"N&/,'/(+"i+8&Y?"o=DBFd$g"l+/&',"C,@'-)+,?o".(:*#-::B&%0'?"k',5'/3"!a?"#LL`f"B!pbg"S',)2'"B*',('/(?"ol+/&'"C,@'-)+,?o"6/#*0/!E$/#'/%'?"S'/7%"b?"#LLe<"_+,'2("S&),'/(5-?"otl+/&',"1'@&t"-1&&8-"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?o"+,-!Y/7/#!+*5-:?"J&7&64&/"#LLM?"#LLM<"

Page 125: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!!`"

%&"'88/+'7%&("6&"'*"B%',>/)92'"D2'Y'?"+,&"+:"*%&"6+/&"58-7'2&"6'22-"),"S',('253+,>"',("'"(&-*),'*)+,"6+-*":/&U5&,*&("43":+/&)>,"*+5/)-*-?"),725(),>"B+5*%"l+/&',-?"1%+"+88+/*5,)-*)7'223"-7+5/"*%&"6'22"%+8),>"*+"-8+*"(&'2-"+,"72+*%&-":/+6"F5>+"N+--"+/"-%+&-":/+6"B'2@'*+/&"A&//'>'6+<""

=,2);&"(&2"K'-*)22+?":5223"'1'/&"+:"*%&",&>'*)@&"-&,*)6&,*"*%'*"6',3"A)2)8),+-"),*&/,'2)Y&"*+1'/(-"B+5*%"l+/&',-?"V+/6',0-"-368'*%3"*+1'/(-"*%&":&&2),>-"+:"%)-"7+68'*/)+*-"1&/&"72&'/23"6&'-5/&("43"'"-&,-&"+:"(&:)',*"+8*)6)-6<"

"C"*%),;"zA)2)8),+-{"6)>%*"4&"*)/&("+:"&@&/3+,&"4&,&:)**),>":/+6"+5/"/&-+5/7&-<"S'34&")*0-"2);&"1%&,"'">5&-*"+@&/-*'3-"*%&)/"1&27+6&<"$%&,"*%&3"-*'3":+/"'":&1"('3-"2+,>&/"*%&,"*%&"('3-"4&7+6&"6+,*%-?"Q/!7/%/#8!#/8*8*#8!F%--!0&/'-%:!#/!0/#8!:*0/!z*%&3"%'@&"4&7+6&":/&&"2+'(&/-"'2/&'(3{<"C"*%),;"-+6&"A)2)8),+-"*%),;"*%'*"1'3<""3&#!:*8(%&!/#8!'/,*0/#!1(#8!2/1*$!#/8:/:/>/!#/!:/!1/#*0/!/#8!*2/#8!;*#&!zS'34&"*%'*0-"1%3"A)2)8),+-"%'@&"4&7+6&":&(958"1)*%"*%&6{["l'-)"8'/',>"),))-'%',"*'3+",>"6>'";+/&',+"zN&7'5-&"*%&"l+/&',-"'/&"*';),>"'(@',*'>&"+:"5-{?"-+")*0-"2);&"*%&"A)2)8),+-"*%),;"*%'*"*%&30/&"I5-*"&,(),>"58">&**),>"*%&"-%+/*"&,("+:"*%&"-*)7;?"'*2/[""

"V+/6',?"+,"*%&"+*%&/"%',(?"'88/&7)'*&("*%&"B+5*%"l+/&',"72)&,*&2&"1%+"1&/&"6+/&"2);&23"*+"85/7%'-&"*%&"6+/&"2'@)-%"5,)*-"*%'*"%&"',("%)-"7+91+/;&/-"+::&/&("*%',"%)-"7+68'*/)+*-<"F)-"'64)@'2&,7&"/&8/&-&,*-"),"6',3"1'3-?"*%&"()@&/>&,*"),*&/&-*-"4&*1&&,"*%&"D%)2)88),&"-*'*&?"1%)7%")-"'>>/&--)@&23"6'/;&*),>"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*+"),@&-*+/-"),"B+5*%"l+/&'?"',("6',3"+:"*%&"2+7'2"8+852'*)+,"1%+":),("*%&6-&2@&-"&H725(&(":/+6"*%&"4&,&:)*-"+:"*%&"7%',>&-"7/&'*&("43"*%&-&"6)>/'*)+,-"',("()-6'3&("*+"-&&"-+7)'2"),&U5)*3"),"*%&)/"7+5,*/3"/&6'),"2'/>&23"*%&"-'6&<"

K%',>&-"),"(&6+>/'8%3"'/&"&-8&7)'223":&2*"'6+,>-*"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"),"-6'22&/"8/+@),7)'2"*+1,-"2);&"$'>'3*'3"K)*3<"F&/&?"*%&"),:25H"+:"l+/&',"-*5(&,*-"%'@&"+8&,&("+88+/*5,)*)&-":+/"A)2)8),+-"*+":),("1+/;"*5*+/),>".,>2)-%"+/"&@&,"*&'7%),>"*%&"2',>5'>&"'*"*%&"l+/&',"%&'(&("),*&/,'*)+,'2"-7%++2<"C,"$'2)-'3?"'"*+5/)-*"'/&'"'(I'7&,*"*+"$'>'3*'3"K)*3?"82',-"2')("43"B+5*%"l+/&',"+1,&("k5,>"E,>"C,*&/@&,*5/&"K+/8+/'*)+,":+/"'"-8'"/&-+/*"'/+5,("*%&"7)*30-"6'),"*+5/)-*"'**/'7*)+,?"*%&"$''2"G+27',+?"%'@&"7'5-&("7+,*/+@&/-3"'6+,>-*"2+7'2"7+665,)*)&-"1%+"'/&"'/>5),>"*%'*"*%&"7+/8+/'*)+,")-"@)+2'*),>"&,@)/+,6&,*'2"/&-*/)7*)+,-<`L"P%)2&"*&,-)+,-"7/&'*&("+@&/"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*-"43"*%&"2&)-5/&"),(5-*/3"'/&"()/&7*23"/&2'*&("*+"7+,*),5+5-"7+,:2)7*-"+@&/"2',("*&,5/&"',("*%&"-5-*'),'4)2)*3"+:"2+7'2"2)@&2)%++(-?"*%&3"'/&"-368*+6'*)7"+:"'"657%"2'/>&/"%)-*+/3"+:"7+,:2)7*":/+6":+/&)>,"+7758'*)+,<"F'@),>"'2/&'(3"(&'2*"1)*%"*%&"7&,*5/)&-"2+,>"-*/'*):)7'*)+,"',("+88/&--)+,"5,2&'-%&("43"B8',)-%"',("K%),&-&":+/&)>,"&2)*&-?"6',3"A)2)8),+-"'/&"1'/3"'4+5*"*%&"),7/&'-),>"8/&-&,7&"',("&7+,+6)7"),*&/&-*-"+:"l+/&',-"),"$'>'3*'3<""

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""`L"D542)7"(&6+,-*/'*)+,-"2&("6+-*23"43"2+7'2"/&-)(&,*-?":)-%&/6',?"',(":'/6&/-?":&'/),>"*%'*"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*-"1+52(":5/*%&/"(&82&*&"*%&"2)@&2)%++("+:"$'2)-'3"2+7'2"&7+,+63?"1&/&"&@&,*5'223"6&*"1)*%"43"+::)7)'2-":/+6"*%&"J&8'/*6&,*"+:".,@)/+,6&,*"',("V'*5/'2"_&-+5/7&-"WJV._X"1%+"(&&6&("*%'*"k5,>"E,>0-"72')6-"+@&/"*%&"2',("1&/&"@'2)("'*":)/-*<"F+1&@&/?"':*&/"-&@&/'2"8/+6),&,*":)>5/&-"-*++("),"-588+/*"+:"*%&"'7*)@)-*-"),725(),>"E/7%4)-%+8"_'6+,"E/>5&22'-?"*%&"JV._"),@'2)('*&("k5,>"E,>0-"8&/6)*"*+"45)2("*%&)/"/&-+/*"),"$'2)-'3<"B&&"S'/2+,"E2&H',(&/"i5)-*/+?"oi)8'"4)-%+8"1',*-"*+*'2"-*+8"*+"$''2"-8'?o";,*0*77*#-!P/*03!"#f(*-%?"k5,&"ZL?"#LLaf"E#!<""

Page 126: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!!c"

d,"*%&"+*%&/"%',(?"1%)2&"*%&"85/8+-&"+:"*+5/)-6"',("/&*)/&6&,*"4&*1&&,"B+5*%"l+/&',-"',("4'2);4'3',-"6)>%*"4&"*%&"-'6&?"*%&"/&7&8*)+,"+:"4'2);4'3',-!43"A)2)8),+-")-"6'/;&(23"()::&/&,*<"A)2)8),+-"+:*&,"-&&"4'2);4'3',-"'-"/&*5/,),>"7+68'*/)+*-"1%+"%'@&"'"8&/-+,'2"),@&-*6&,*"*+"(&@&2+8),>"*%&"D%)2)88),&"&7+,+63<"E,("*%&)/"8&/6',&,*"8/&-&,7&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-":5,7*)+,-"'-"&@)(&,7&"+:"*%&)/"7+66)*6&,*"*+")68/+@),>"*%&"7+5,*/3"/'*%&/"*%',"'-"'"6&',-"+:"&H82+)*),>")*-"/&-+5/7&-"'-"+88+-&("*+"l+/&',-?"k'8',&-&?"',("&-8&7)'223"*%&"K%),&-&"1%+"'/&"(&8)7*&("'-"*';),>"'(@',*'>&"+:"A)2)8),+-<`!"$%&"7+682&H"',("-+6&*)6&-"7+,*/'()7*+/3"8+2)*)7'2"/%&*+/)7"7+,-*)*5*),>"4'2);4'3',-"'-"Q%&/+&-R"%'-"%'("'"-)6)2'/"'::&7*"+,"*%&"1'3-"*%/+5>%"1%)7%"4'2);4'3',-"8&/7&)@&"*%&6-&2@&-<"" QP%3"1+52("*%&3"/&-&,*"5-["P&0/&"A)2)8),+]R"k',&**&"x5),+@&@'?"'"4'2);4'3',"1%+"%'("45)2*"'"@'7'*)+,"%+6&"),"$'>'3*'3"*1+"3&'/-"'>+?"&H72')6&(<"k',&**&"%'-"*/'@&2&("4'7;"',(":+/*%"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"&'7%"3&'/":+/"*%&"2'-*"(&7'(&"',("2);&"'",564&/"+:"4'2);4'3',-?"-%&"45)2*"'"/&*)/&6&,*"%+6&"),"$'>'3*'3?"1%)7%"-%&"5-&-"'-"'"@'7'*)+,"%+6&"'*"2&'-*"+,7&"'"3&'/<"

"d:"7+5/-&"*%&3"(+,0*"*%),;"+:"5-"2);&"*%&"l+/&',-"4&7'5-&"1&0/&",+*"l+/&',<"P%+"7',"42'6&"A)2)8),+-":+/"4&),>"',>/3"1)*%"l+/&',-<"$%&3"7+6&"%&/&"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"*+"2&'/,".,>2)-%"',("'/&"-+?"1%'*"3+5"-'3?";',3'9;',3'"z-*)7;"*+"*%&6-&2@&-{`#<"N5*"C"'6"7+6),>"%+6&<"C"()(,0*">/+1"58"z),"$'>'3*'3{"45*"*%&3"-*)22";,+1"6&"%&/&<R"-%&"/&-8+,(&(">2)423<""

"F&28),>"k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k',&**&"+/"',3"4'2);4'3',"2);&"%&/":/+6"4&),>"'42&"*+"-&&6"*%&6-&2@&-"'-"+,&"),"*%&"-'6&"'-"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?")*")-"*%&":'7*"*%'*"*%)-"1&'2*%"',("*%&"@'/)+5-"@)-'"8/)@)2&>&-"-%&"&,I+3-"*+>&*%&/"/&8/&-&,*"%&/"'4)2)*3"*+"4&"'"*/',-,'*)+,'2"-54I&7*?"'"4'2);4'3',"1%+"7',"7+6&"4'7;"',("2&'@&"'-"657%"-%&")-":),',7)'2"7'8'42&"+:"(+),>"-+<"$%)-"'4)2)*3"*+"

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""`!"G'/)+5-"1/)*&/-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'@&"()-75--&("*%&"2+,>9%&2("%)-*+/)7'2"8/&I5()7&"%&2("*+1'/(-"K%),&-&"A)2)8),+-<"B&&?":+/"),-*',7&?"$&/&-)*'"E,>"B&&0-"+,-!D,*#-:-!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:?!;%&20-5:!/#'!;-%:7-)$*J-:!WS',)2'f"l')-'"D'/'"B'"l'5,2'/',?"!ccLX<""`#"d/#3/=1/#3/")-"'"7+66+,"&H8/&--)+,"1)*%),"$'>'2+>"@&/,'752'/"*%'*"6&',-"Q5,*+"*%&6-&2@&-R<"C,*&/&-*),>23?"1%)2&"'",564&/"+:"/&-8+,(&,*-"5-&("*%&"&H8/&--)+,"*+"()-75--"*%&"8&/7&)@&("),-52'/"-&**2&6&,*"+:"l+/&',?"k'8',&-&?"',("K%),&-&")66)>/',*-"),*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"6',3"+:"*%&"/&-8+,(&,*-"1&/&"I5-*"'-"U5)7;"*+"(&-7/)4&"A)2)8),+"8+2)*)7-"5-),>"*%&"-'6&"&H8/&--)+,<"E-"-57%?"*%&"&H8/&--)+,"'2-+"(&,+*&-"'"()-),*&/&-*"),"*%&"2'/>&/"8+2)*)7"+:"D%)2)88),&"-+7)&*3"+/"1%+"+*%&/"),*&/@)&1&&-"7'22&("*%&"5/:/"+/"6'--&-"+:"A)2)8),+-<""

Page 127: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!#L"

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ce"),"#LL`?"*%&/&"1&/&"'-"6',3"'-"#L?LLL"A)2)8),+"/&*)/&&-"1%+"%'("-&**2&("*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"WE2',>5)2',"#LL`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`Z"$%&"/&*)/&6&,*"2',(-7'8&"%'-"4&7+6&"*%&"%38&/9/&'2)Y'*)+,"+:"3&*"',+*%&/"8'/'(+H)7'2"5,)*3f"*%&"-)652*',&)*3"+:"4&),>"'*"+,7&"'"*+5/)-*"',("%+6&*+1,"%&/+<"""""

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""`Z"$%)-"7+,*),5&-"*%&"()-75--)+,"+,"*%&"7+,-*/57*)+,"+:"2/0*12/3/#:"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'("),"K%'8*&/"M<"G)7&,*&"_':'&2"'/>5&-"*%'*"*%&"-*'*5-"+:"2/0*12/3/#:")-"(&,+*&("43"Q+,&0-"/&2'*)+,-%)8"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-")-"7+,-*/5&("),"*&/6-"+:"+,&0-"-&,*)6&,*'2"'**'7%6&,*-"*+"+,&0-"%+6&*+1,"',("&H*&,(&(":'6)23"/'*%&/"*%',"+,&0-"2+3'2*3"*+"*%&",'*)+,9-*'*&<"E*"*%&"-'6&"*)6&?"4&),>"'"4'2);4'3',"(&8&,(-"+,"+,&0-"8&/6',&,*"/&-)(&,7&"'4/+'(<"C*"6&',-"*%'*"+,&"2)@&-"-+6&1%&/&"&2-&"',("*%'*"+,&0-"'88&'/',7&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-")-"*&68+/'/3"',("),*&/6)**&,*?"'-"):"+,&"1&/&"'"*+5/)-*R<"B&&"W_':'&2"#LLLX"

Page 128: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!#!"

""

"""!

D+4)&-!T#!?0+3+::+$-!@*'$'F+*!V'$-.!':-&/%+$4!%0&')40!<NNWI!H?0+3+::+$-!@*'$'F+*!V'$-!E)%0'&+%5!<NNWP#!

"

Page 129: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!##"

"!

!

D+4)&-!U#!?0+3+::+$-!@*'$'F+*!=')&+.F!V'$-.!':-&/%+$4!%0&')40!<NNWI!H?0+3+::+$-!@*'$'F+*!V'$-!E)%0'&+%5!<NNWP#!

Page 130: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!#Z"

"""""""""""""

"D&#)0(:*&#!!

./0*12/3/#!U%2/#*:5!!

6/#*0/g:!./0*12/3/#!N/#':)/7-!/#'!A52*J/0-#$!<-$(%#:!!

Page 131: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!#b"

9'$*3).+'$!""o6/,*%/7/#82(,/3!W'&&#h!7-%&5/:/3/!W#/5/#hR"zWC,"*%&"D%)2)88),&-X"i):&")-"%'/("45*")*"1'-">++({<!

""""""""""9"G'/)+5-"C,*&/@)&1&&-"!Q$%&"'7*"+:"*/'@&/-),>"8+2)*)7'2"',(">&+>/'8%)7"4+/(&/-"6+/&"+:*&,"*%',",+*"7+,:&/&("7+-6+8+2)*',"6+(&/,)*3"+,"*%&"/&*5/,&&<<<"F+1&@&/?"*%&-&":+/652'*)+,-"+/")(&'-"'4+5*"()'-8+/'"',("/&*5/,"1&/&"5,'42&"*+"7'8*5/&"*%&",+,2),&'/"',("6&--3")*),&/'/)&-"*%'*"(&@)'*&":/+6"*%&")(&'2",+/6R<"" " " " " " """""9"S'/*),"S','2',-',"#L!!?"F&%$,)&5*#8"

!"C*")-",+*"5,7+66+,"*+"%&'/"A)2)8),+-?"1%+?"%'@),>"2)@&("),"*%&"=<B<":+/"-&@&/'2"

(&7'(&-?"&H8/&--"',"),*&,-&"-&,-&"+:"'64)@'2&,7&"58+,"/&*5/,),>"*+"*%&"7+5,*/3"1%&/&"*%&3"-8&,*"*%&)/":+/6'*)@&"3&'/-<"P%'*"*&,(-"*+"4&"7'8)*52'*&("*%/+5>%"-58&/:)7)'2")//)*'*)+,-?"1%&,"/&'("6+/&"72+-&23?"+,&",+*)7&-"*%'*"*%&-&"-&,*)6&,*-"'/&"'7*5'223"-*&&8&("1)*%),"'"7+682&H23"),*&/1+@&,"72+*%"+:"&6+*)+,-<"$%&"@&)2?"(/'8&("+@&/"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=<B<?"(+&-",+*"()-'88&'/"1%&,"*%&3"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<""

J&&8":&&2),>-"+:"/&>/&*?"&64'//'--6&,*?"',("',>&/"*&,("*+"4&"-%/+5(&("43"-&&6),>23"*/)@)'2"7+,7&/,-"+@&/"*/'::)7?"()/*),&--?"72)7%|-"+:"45/&'57/'*)7"7+//58*)+,"+/"*%/&'*-"+:"7/)6&?"',("+:"7+5/-&?"*%&"+88/&--)@&23"4/5*'2"*/+8)7'2"%56)()*3<"V&@&/"6+/&"(+&-"*%&"()::&/&,7&"4&*1&&,"*%&"=<B"',("*%&"D%)2)88),&-"4&7+6&"6+/&"()-*),7*"*%',"1%&,"4'2);4'3',-"/&*5/,"%+6&<"d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

A+/"A)2)8),+-"1%+"/&*5/,"*+"S',)2'?"'*"*)6&-?"*%&"-58&/:)7)'2"4&-8&';-"*%&"(&&8&/":+/7&"+:"'"-1&22),>"-&,-&"+:"()-)225-)+,6&,*<"A/+6"),-)(&"+:"+,&"+:"*%&",)7&/";'/),(&/)'-?"'"-6'22"/&-*'5/',*?"'2+,>"l'*)85,',"E@&,5&?".Y6&/'2('"'**&68*&("*+"&H82'),"%&/":)/-*")68/&--)+,-"+:"%&/"2):&"4'7;"),"S',)2'<"F'@),>"I5-*"*5/,&("*%&"/&*)/&6&,*"'>&"+:"eM?")*"7'6&"*)6&":+/"%&/"*+"2&'@&"*%&"=<B<"',("%&/"'(52*"'>&("7%)2(/&,"',("6';&"%&/"1'3"4'7;"%+6&"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"E":&1"6&*&/-":/+6"+5*-)(&"+:"*%&"1),(+1"4&-)(&"+5/"*'42&"-*++("'"1&'*%&/&("-)>,4+'/("657%"2);&"*%+-&"+,&"1+52("-&&"'*"',"+2("8542)7"%)>%"-7%++2"',31%&/&"),"*%&"=<B<"$%&"2&**&/-"/&'("E*&,&+"(&"S',)2'"=,)@&/-)*3"),":'(&("425&?"42+7;"2&**&/-<"E*&,&+?"'-"6+-*"A)2)8),+-"/&:&/"*+")*?"%'-"%)-*+/)7'223"4&&,"*%&"-)*&"1%&/&"6+-*"+:"S',)2'0-"&2)*&"-*5(&,*-"1&/&"&(57'*&("',("1'-"1%&/&".Y6&/'2('"/&7&)@&("%&/"(&>/&&"),"45-),&--"'(6),)-*/'*)+,"1)*%"',"&68%'-)-"),"'77+5,*),><"$%)-"(&>/&&"&@&,*5'223"4&7'6&"%&/"Q>+2(&,"*)7;&*R"*+"*%&"=<B<"E,("&@&/"-),7&"%&/"'//)@'2"*+"*%'*"7+5,*/3"*%)/*39-)H"3&'/-"'>+?"-%&"2+,>&("*+"

Page 132: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!#M"

:52:)22"%&/"(/&'6"+:"/&*5/,),>"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("-*'/*),>"'"45-),&--"-+6&1%&/&"),"%&/"%+6&*+1,"+:"x5&Y+,"K)*3<""

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

E2+,>"1)*%"-&@&/'2"+:"63"),*&/@)&1&&-?")*")-"7+66+,"*+"%&'/"A)2)8),+-"2)@),>"),"*%&"=<B<"/&8&'*"3&*"',+*%&/"7+66+,"/&:/'),f"o6/,*%/7!/#8!2(,/3!W'&&#h!7-%&!5/:/3/!W#/5/#hR"zWC,"*%&"D%)2)88),&-X"i):&")-"%'/("85*")*">/:">++({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

S','2',-',"W#L!!X"@)@)(23"(&6+,-*/'*&-"%+1"*/'()*)+,'2"7+,7&8*-"'/+5,("()'-8+/)7"/&*5/,"4&7+6&"7+682)7'*&("43"*%&"&H8&/)&,7&-"+:">'3"A)2)8),+"/&*5/,&&-"1%&/&"1)*%),"*%&)/"

"G&H&("/&2'*)+,-%)8"1)*%"%+6&"',("*%&"7+682&H"&/+*)7"5,(&/8),,),>-"+:"*%&"'7*"+:"/&*5/,),>"*+"*%&"%+6&2',(\WF&/&X"*%&"&/+*)7":5,7*)+,-",+*"'-"'"*/'@&2"-)>,8+-*"2&'(),>"*+"'"(&:),)*)@&"(&-*),'*)+,?"45*"),-*&'(?")*"+8&,-"58"*+"6&--3"&,*',>2&6&,*-"',("&,>'>&6&,*-"1)*%"-&H5'2?">&,(&/&(?":'6)2)'2?",'*)+,'2"',("*/',-,'*)+,'2"'::),)*)&-"Wb`X<"

"C,"'"-)6)2'/":'-%)+,?"C"5,(&/-7+/&"*%&"7+682&H)*)&-"',("7+,*/'()7*)+,"'/+5,("*%&"Q(&-)/&-"',("&H8&7*'*)+,-":+/"*%&"()'-8+/)7"&2-&1%&/&R"*%'*"S','2',-',0-"),*&/@)&1&&-"'-7/)4&"+,*+"4'2);4'3',-"W#L!!?"eLX<"C*")-",+*"*%'*"*%&"&H8&/)&,7&-"+:"4'2);4'3',-"6)//+/"*%+-&"+:"A)2)8),+">'3"6'2&"/&*5/,&&-<"$+"6';&"*%'*"'--&/*)+,"1+52("4&"*',*'6+5,*"*+"*5/,),>"'"42),("&3&"*+"*%&"-)>,):)7',7&"&H*&,(),>":/+6"*%&-&"-&8'/'*&"',("5,)U5&"&H8&/)&,7&-"',("1+52("()-6)--"',3"+88+/*5,)*3"7%'22&,>&"*%&"%&>&6+,)&-"'/+5,(",+/6'*)@&"6'-752),)*)&-"*%'*"'7;,+12&(>),>"*%&"()::&/&,7&-"1+52("),)*)'*&<""

C,"'"2'/>&/"1'3?"*%)-"()--&/*'*)+,"'/>5&-"*%'*?"/&>'/(2&--"+:"*%&"7'-&?"/&*5/,"6)>/'*)+,"',("()'-8+/)7"/&*5/,")-",&@&/"/&82&*&"+:"'64)@'2&,7&"+/"&@&,"5,&'-&<"$%&")6'>),'/3"7+,-*)*5*),>"*%&":+/6'*)+,"+:"4'2);4'3',-"1'-"8/&6)-&("43"'"-&*"+:"2&>'2"8/)@)2&>&-"',(")(&'2-"'/+5,("6+4)2)*3"',("=<B<"7)*)Y&,-%)8?"1%)7%":+/"'22"+:")*-"8/+42&6-?"-%+52("%'@&"*/',-:+/6&("4'2);4'3',-"),*+"'";),("+:")(&'2"A)2)8),+<"S+(&2-?":+/"1%)7%?"*%&"'/7%)*&7*-"1%+"2')("*%&":+5,('*)+,":+/"-57%"',")(&'2"%+8&("6',3"

Page 133: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!#e"

A)2)8),+-"1+52("'-8)/&"*+1'/(-"',("%&28"2&'("*%&"7+5,*/3"*+",'*)+,'2"582):*<"E,("3&*?"6+-*"+:"63"),*&/@)&1&&-":+5,("*%'*"),"6+@),>"'1'3?"-&,(),>"6+,&3"',("+*%&/"6'*&/)'2-"4'7;"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"',("52*)6'*&23"/&*5/,),>"*+"*%&)/"%+6&2',(?"%'("(+,&"2)**2&"*+"4/),>"*%&"7%',>&-"4'2);4'3',-"%+8&("1+52("*';&"82'7&<"_&*5/,?"43")*-"@&/3",'*5/&?")-"'21'3-?"*+"5-&"S','2',-',0-"1+/(-?",+,2),&'/"',("6&--3<""

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

$%&"3&'/"!ca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f"1&/&,0*"*%&"(5*)&-"7+,*/)45*&("43"4'2);4'3',-"(+),>"',3*%),>"*+"7%',>&"*%&"7+5,*/3":+/"*%&"4&**&/[""

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`"),"+/(&/"*+"6&&*"'"*/&6&,(+5-"-8);&"),"*/',-8+/*'*)+,"(&6',("+@&/"*%&"2'-*"*1+"(&7'(&-<"C*"1'-"45)2*"*+"-&/@)7&"'"

Page 134: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!#a"

7'8'7)*3"+:"I5-*"+@&/"ZZ?LLL"6+/&"8'--&,>&/-?"(')23<"E,("),"*/5&"S',)2'":'-%)+,?"*%&"*&/6),'2"%'-"'":+5/9-*+/3"6'22"45)2*"+,"*+8"+:")*<""

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

A),'223?"*%)-"()--&/*'*)+,")-"+,&"'**&68*"*+"),*/+(57&"7+682&H)*)&-"1)*%),"*%&"2)*&/'*5/&"+,"*%&";),("+:"-+7)'2"*/',-:+/6'*)+,"*%'*")-"8/+(57&("43"8/+7&--&-"+:"*/',-,'*)+,'2)-6<"d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g:!./0*12/3/#!N/#':)/7-!

"K+,*&68+/'/3"S&*/+"S',)2'")-"6+/&"'775/'*&23"'"7+,>2+6&/'*)+,"+:"()-*/)7*-?"

7)*)&-?"',("65,)7)8'2)*)&-"/'*%&/"*%',"+,&">&+>/'8%)7'223"()-*),7*"5/4',"7&,*&/<"d/)>),'223":+5/"2'/>&/"7)*)&-"WS',)2'?"D'-'3?"K'2++7',?"',("x5&Y+,"K)*3X"',("*%)/*&&,"65,)7)8'2)*)&-?"S&*/+"S',)2'"),*&>/'*&-"),*+"'"*+*'2"'/&'"+:"eZ?eLL"%&7*'/&-<"C*-"8+852'*)+,"&H7&&(-"I5-*"+@&/"!!<M"6)22)+,<""P%)2&"*%&"'7*5'2"-)Y&"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'"7+68+-&-"+:"+,23"L<#"8&/7&,*"+:"*%&"7+5,*/30-"*+*'2"2',(6'--?"'26+-*"!Z"8&/7&,*"+:"*%&"7+5,*/30-"*+*'2"8+852'*)+,"%'-"7+6&"*+"-)*5'*&")*-&2:"),*+"*%&"/&>)+,0-"(&,-&23"7+68'7*&("',("(3,'6)7'223"-*/57*5/&("-8'7&<"$%)-",564&/")-"7+68+5,(&("&'7%"3&'/"43"'">/+1*%"/'*&"+:"#<`"8&/7&,*<""

B),7&")*-"/+2&"'-"',"&7+,+6)7"/&>)+,"1'-"+::)7)'223"&-*'42)-%&("),"!cae?"S&*/+"S',)2'"',("*%&"/&-*"+:"*%&"V'*)+,'2"K'8)*'2"_&>)+,"WVK_X"%'-"7+,*),5'223"+5*8&/:+/6&("+*%&/"/&>)+,-"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"A+/"),-*',7&?"*%&"VK_0-"hJD")-"*1)7&"

Page 135: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!#`"

*%&"-)Y&"+:"*%&",'*)+,'2"'@&/'>&<"C*"6';&-"-&,-&"*%&,"*%'*"*%&":+75-"+:"*%&"7+5,*/30-"),*&/,'2"6)>/'*)+,"/&6'),-"8+),*&("*+1'/(-"*%)-"/&>)+,"',("*%'*"*%)-"+@&/1%&26),>"7+,7&,*/'*)+,"+:"),*&/,'2"2'4+/"6)>/'*)+,"',("&7+,+6)7"8/+(57*)+,"%'-"'2-+"6'(&"S&*/+"S',)2'"*%&":+75-":+/"6',3"+:"*%&"7+5,*/30-"(&@&2+86&,*"8/+I&7*-<""

E*"*%&"-'6&"*)6&?")*"4&7+6&-"()::)752*"*+"/&7+,7)2&"*%&"+@&/1%&26),>"+6,)8/&-&,7&"+:"8+@&/*3?"657%"+:"1%)7%"7+68&22&("6+-*"4'2);4'3',-"*+"2&'@&"),"*%&":)/-*"82'7&?"1)*%"*%&")6'>&-"+:"),,+@'*)+,"',("1&'2*%"),-8)/&("43"-57%"*/',-:+/6'*)+,-<"S&*/+"S',)2'"%'-"4&7+6&"5,&'-)23"7+,-*)*5*&("43"*%&-&"*1+"+88+-),>"3&*"-)652*',&+5-23"),*&/2),;&(")6'>&-f"8+@&/*3"',("1&'2*%?"(&*&/)+/'*)+,"',("/&,&1'2?"',"&@&/9>/+1),>"8'/'(+H)7'2"5,)*3<"_&:2&7*),>"*%&"()'2&7*)7'2"()2&66'"+:"7/&'*)@&"(&-*/57*)+,"8/&-&,*&("),"N&/6',0-"W!c``X"&2+U5&,*"7/)*)U5&"+:"6+(&/,)*3?"657%"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'")-"-%'8&("43"'"-*'*&"+:"8&/8&*5'2"7+,-*/57*)+,?"-2&&;",&1"+::)7&"45)2(),>-"',("*+1&/),>"7+,(+6),)56-"8/+*/5(),>"*%/+5>%+5*"S&*/+"S',)2'0-"7+,7/&*&"2',(-7'8&?"+,&"':*&/"',+*%&/<""

B85//&(9+,"43"*%)-">/+1*%?"7+/8+/'*&"),@&-*+/-"',("2',("(&@&2+8&/-"%'@&"2),;&("*+>&*%&/"1)*%"-*'*&"'(6),)-*/'*+/-"*+"*'/>&*"*%&"/&>)+,":+/"'",564&/"+:"7+66&/7)'2"',("/&-)(&,*)'2"8/+I&7*-"')6&("'*">&,&/'*),>"6+/&"),@&-*6&,*-":/+6"+@&/-&'-<"h'@),"B%'*;),"W#LL`X"5*)2)Y&-"*%&"7+,7&8*"+:"Q438'--9)682',*"5/4',)-6R"*+"(&-7/)4&"*%&"),7/&'-),>"7+682)7)*3"4&*1&&,"2'/>&"(&@&2+8&/-"',(">+@&/,6&,*'2"8'/*,&/-"*%/+5>%"*%&"8/)@'*)Y'*)+,"+:"82',,),><"F&"'/>5&-"*%'*f""

C,"*%)-"7+,*&H*"+:"5,5-5'223"),&/*"',("(&:&/&,*)'2">+@&/,6&,*?"8/)@'*&"(&@&2+8&/-"%'@&"4&&,">/',*&("7+,-)(&/'42&"8+1&/"*+"/&&,>),&&/"7)*)&-"*+"7/&'*&",&1"-8'7&-":+/"8/+(57*)+,"',("7+,-568*)+,?"',("*+":'7)2)*'*&"*%&":2+1"+:"8&+82&"',("7'8)*'2"4&*1&&,"*%&-&"-8'7&-?"43"Ñ438'--),>t"*%&"7+,>&-*&("'/*&/)&-"+:"*%&"Ñ8542)7"7)*3t"',("Ñ)682',*),>t",&1"-8'7&-":+/"7'8)*'2"'775652'*)+,"*%'*"'/&"(&-)>,&(":+/"7+,-56&/)-6"',("&H8+/*9+/)&,*&("8/+(57*)+,"WZ`bX<"""

"S)//+/),>"),"6',3"1'3-"6+(&2-"+:"7+/&"',("8&/)8%&/3?"*%&"45)2*"&,@)/+,6&,*"7/&'*&("43"438'--9)682',*"5/4',)-6"*%/+5>%+5*"S',)2'0-"2',(-7'8&"'75*&23"-)>,):)&-"*%&"@'/)+5-"-*/'*):)7'*)+,-"1)*%),")*-"+1,"-+7)&*3<"$%&"6',,&/"),"1%)7%"*%)-"8/+7&--"+775/-")-"/&8/&-&,*&("),"*%&"7+,-*/57*)+,"+:"*%&-&"652*)985/8+-&"&,72'@&-"',("%38&/9-&>/&>'*)+,")*"7/&'*&-<"P)*%),"S&*/+"S',)2'")*-&2:?"*%&"-545/4',"6+(&2?"-+"8+852'/"4&*1&&,"*%&"!cML-"*%/+5>%"*%&"!c`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w"i&':?"',("B&'**2&0-"N&-*?"+,&"7',"'2-+":),("+/>',)7'223"8/+(57&("4+(3"-+'8"'*"i5-%"+/"/&("@&2@&*"758"7';&-"'*"$&'"K';&"),"6'22-"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"S&*/+"S',)2'<"A/',7%)-&-"*%'*"+,&"1+52("

Page 136: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!#c"

:),("),"+,&"+:"*%&"6+/&"58-7'2&"6'22-"+/",&)>%4+/%++(-"),"*%&"=<B<"'/&":),(),>")*-"1'3"),"6+/&"',("6+/&"7+66&/7)'2"()-*/)7*-"',("6'22-"*%/+5>%+5*"S',)2'<"

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

S'22-"%'@&"'2-+"4&7+6&"',"),*/),-)7"*+"*%&"4'2);4'3',"2',(-7'8&"*%/+5>%+5*"S',)2'"WK+,,&22?"D),7%&-X<"P)*%"2)**2&"8542)7"-8'7&"2&:*?"6'22-"%'@&"4&7+6&"-+"657%"6+/&"*%',"'"-8'7&"+:"7+,-568*)+,"45*"+,&"+:"()-*),7*)+,"'-"1&22<"F&/&?"*%&"A/&,7%"F0i#-(%!-*/+22),>"*%/+5>%"*%&"-*/&&*-"',("82'Y'-"+:"D'/)-`b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i_$"2),&":+/"),-*',7&?"+,&"65-*"),":'7*?"1',(&/"*%/+5>%"*1+"-&8'/'*&"6'22-"*+"/&'7%"*%&)/"(&-*),'*)+,<"S'22-"'/&":5,('6&,*'2"*+"*%&"(')23"2):&"+:"S',)2&T+-"),"'"1'3"*%'*")-"),7+68/&%&,-)42&"*+"+,&"-+7)'2)Y&("1)*%),"*%&",572&'/"',("),()@)(5'2)Y&("&*%)7-"(/)@),>"*%&"()-'88&'/',7&"+:"7+665,'2"-8'7&"),"E6&/)7'<"""

""

./0*12/3/#!U%2/#*:5!!

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

$%&"652*)985/8+-&"&,72'@&?":+/"),-*',7&?")-",+*"5,2);&"'"/&-+/*?"1%)7%"7+,*'),-"-%+8-?"-1)66),>"8++2-?"*&,,)-"7+5/*-?"+/"'-"k&//3?"'"A)2)8),+"/&'2"&-*'*&"'>&,*"-5>>&-*-?"QO+5",'6&")*?")*0-"*%&/&]R"B&22),>"*%&"7+,(+"'-"'"/&-+/*")-"5*)2)Y&("'>'),"',("'>'),":+/"8+*&,*)'2"4'2);4'3',"/&*)/&&-<"O&*?"*%&"&,72'@&")-"657%"6+/&"*%',"',"'229

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""`b"$%&":)>5/&"+:"*%&"F0i#-(%?"'/)-*+7/'*)7">&,*2&6&,"1%+"6'(&"',"'/*":+/6"+5*"+:"-*/+22),>"')62&--23"*%/+5>%"D'/)-?")-"&642&6'*)7"*+")6'>&-"+:"6+(&/,)*3<"E-"-54I&7*-"*%'*"1&/&"'*"+,7&"'"8'/*"+:"',("'8'/*":/+6"*%&"7)*3?"4+*%"+4-&/@&/-"+:"',("7+66+,":)>5/&-"1)*%),"*%&"2',(-7'8&"+:"7)*3"-*/&&*-?"*%&"F0i#-(%")-"*+"*%&"D'/)-")6'>),'/3"(5/),>"6+(&/,)*3"'-"3'3'-"',("6')(-"'/&"*+"7+,*&68+/'/3"S',)2'<"B&&"P'2*&/"N&,I'6),0-"$%&"E/7'(&-"D/+I&7*"WK'64/)(>&f"F'/@'/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--?"!cccX<"

Page 137: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!ZL"

),725-)@&"/&-+/*?")*"8+/*&,(-"*+"4&"'"1+/2("1)*%),")*-&2:<"E-"-57%?"7+582&("*+>&*%&/"1)*%"'"%+-*"+:"2&)-5/&"'6&,)*)&-?"*%&-&"&,72'@&-"'/&"'2-+"/&82&*&"1)*%"('37'/&-?"&2&6&,*'/3"-7%++2-?"72),)7-?"',("7':&-<"P%&,"+,&"),725(&-"*%&"1+/2("+:"*%&"6'22"',(")*-"7%5/7%&-"',("*%&'*/&-"),*+"*%)-"7+,:)>5/'*)+,?"'"1+/2(":/+6"1%&/&"'22"+:"S',)2'"2):&"/&@+2@&-?"*%&"8+--)4)2)*)&-"'88&'/"&,(2&--<""

i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

E-"-++,"'-"',"'>&,*"%&'/-"-+6&+,&"-8&';),>".,>2)-%?"1%&*%&/")*"4&"'"4'2);4'3',"+/"'"2+7'2"A)2)8),+?"'>&,*-"'/&"*/'),&("*+":+75-"*%&)/"'**&,*)+,"+,"-&22),>"*+"*%&6<"QO+5"(+,0*",&&("*+"'-;?"I5-*"-8&';".,>2)-%"',("*%&3022":),("3+5]R"B%&//3"D')/&Y"&H82'),&("1)*%"'"6)H*5/&"+:"%56+/"',("-&/)+5-,&--<"B%&//3")-"'"/&2'*)@&23"3+5,>"4'2);4'3',"1%+?"2);&".Y6&/'2('?">/&1958"),"x5&Y+,"K)*3"',("%'("*%+5>%*"'4+5*"85/7%'-),>"8/+8&/*3"'/+5,("S',)2'"&@&,"4&:+/&"-%&"2&:*"*+"1+/;"'-"'"*&'7%&/"),"J'23"K)*3<"P%&,"%&/"('5>%*&/"-*'/*&("7+22&>&"',("&H8/&--&("-+6&"),*&/&-*"),">+),>"*+"-7%++2"(5/),>"*%&"-566&/"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"B%&//3":&2*")*"1'-"',")(&'2"+88+/*5,)*3"*+"@)-)*":'6)23"),"S',)2'"',("*&-*"*%&"1'*&/"),"*&/6-"+:"453),>"8/+8&/*3<"

"C*"-&&6-"2);&"'"/&'223"&'-3"8/+7&--"),"*%&"4&>),,),><"$%&"'>&,*"'*"*%&"6'22?"),"63"7'-&"*%&"S'22"+:"E-)'"W),"D'-'3"K)*3X?"4/+5>%*"6&"*+"*%&"-%+1"/++6"+,"*%&"*%)/(":2++/<"$%&,"C"-8+;&"*+"',"+2(&/"6',"',("*+2("%)6"*%'*"C"1'-"2++;),>":+/"'"7+,(+",&'/"x5&Y+,"K)*3"',("*%'*0-"1%3"C"8)7;&("*%)-"+,&"4&7'5-&")*"1'-"2+7'*&(",&'/"S)/)'6"K+22&>&"1%&/&"63"('5>%*&/"7',"*';&"72'--&-<"

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

"$%&3022"1'2;"3+5"),*+"',"+::)7&"',("'26+-*")66&()'*&23"-%+1"3+5"'">/'8%"+:"'22"*%&"5,)*-"*%'*"%'@&"'2/&'(3"4&&,"-+2(<"_&6&64&/",+*%),>"%'-"4&&,"45)2*"3&*]"O+5"-&&"*%'*"*%&/&"'/&"#"5,)*-"2&:*"1)*%"4'27+,)&-"',("):"3+5"(+,0*">53"

Page 138: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!Z!"

*%&6",+1?"3+5022"2+-&"*%&"+88+/*5,)*3<"d,7&"3+5"-%+1"',3";),("+:"&H7)*&6&,*"4&7'5-&"3+5":&&2"3+50/&">&**),>"'">++("(&'2?"*%&3"-'3"*%'*"*%&3",&&("*+"*'2;"*+"-+6&+,&<"$%&,"*%&"'>&,*"7+6&-"4'7;"',("-'3-"*%'*"*%&3"*'2;&("*+"*%&)/"-58&/@)-+/"',("*%&"-58&/@)-+/"-')("*%'*"-+6&*%),>"&2-&"I5-*"+8&,&("58<"E,("):"3+5"85/7%'-&"*1+"5,)*-?"3+5"4'-)7'223">&*"*%&"-&7+,("+,&"'*"'9*%)/("+:"*%&"8/)7&<"B+"+:"7+5/-&"C"()(")*<"C"+,23"%'("*+"85*"j#?LLL"=BJ"(+1,"*+"/&-&/@&"4+*%"+:"*%&"5,)*-<"

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

.6&/-+,"7+,*),5&("*+"&H82'),"*%'*"%&"%'(",+")(&'"*%'*"*%&"5,)*-"*%'*"%&"85/7%'-&("()(",+*"7+6&"1)*%"%+*"1'*&/?":+/"),-*',7&<"""

C";,&1"*%'*"C"%'("*+"85/7%'-&"')/"7+,()*)+,),>"5,)*-"',("'",&1"-*+@&<"$%),>-"2);&"*%'*<"N5*"C"*%+5>%*"*%'*"u),-*'22'*)+,":&&-0"7+@&/&(",+*"+,23"*%&"&2&7*/)7'2"1)/),>"45*"'2-+"%+*"1'*&/<"K',"3+5")6'>),&"*%'*["C"%'("*+"85/7%'-&"'"-&8'/'*&"1'*&/"%&'*&/":+/":+5/"4'*%/++6-]"C*0-"2);&"4&),>"4'7;"),"*%&"%+5-&"C">/&1958"),?"1%&/&"1&"()(,0*"%'@&"',3"%+*"1'*&/<"

".6&/-+,0-"/&-&,*6&,*"%&28-"*+")2256),'*&"*%&"'64)@'2&,7&"',("52*)6'*&":')25/&"+:"/&*5/,<"P%&,"6',3"4'2);4'3',-"/&*5/,"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"',("'7*)@&23"7+,-)(&/"/&-)(),>"*%&/&"8&/6',&,*23?"*%&3"/&'2)Y&"*%'*"*%&)/"6&6+/)&-"+:"%+6&"7',,+*"4&"/&*5/,&("*+"',("*%'*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"+:"*%&)/"7%)2(%++(")-",+*%),>"2);&"*%&"+,&"+:"8/&-&,*"('3<"

QC,"6',3"1'3-"3+5"&H8&7*"*%),>-"*+"7%',>&?R"&H*+2-"S)/',('"S'>'T'?"'"7+/8+/'*&"+::)7&"'(6),)-*/'*+/"1%+"85/7%'-&("'"7+,(+6),)56"),"*%&"x5&Y+,"K)*3",&)>%4+/%++("+:"K54'+":+/"%&/"6+*%&/"',("+2(&-*"4/+*%&/<""

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

"$%&-&"5,/&'2)-*)7"&H8&7*'*)+,-":+/"7%',>&"'/&"8&/8&*5'*&("43"8&/)+()7"/&*5/,-"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1%&/&"4'2);4'3',-"&,I+3"%+-*),>":'6)23"6&64&/-":+/"(),,&/"'*":),&"/&-*'5/',*-"),"*%&"7)*3"+/"'/&")66&()'*&23"(&:&//&("/&-8&7*"43"@'/)+5-"-&/@)7&"

Page 139: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!Z#"

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d,7&"',"),()@)(5'2"85/7%'-&-"'"5,)*?"'-"2+,>"'-"*%&3"7+,*),5&"*+"8'3"*%&)/"6+,*%23"'6+/*)Y'*)+,"W1%)7%"6',3"/&'2"&-*'*&"7+/8+/'*)+,-"+@&/-&&"Q),"%+5-&RX?"*%&/&"'/&",+"/&>52'*)+,-"/&-*/'),),>"+1,&/-":/+6"2&'-),>"*%&)/"7+,(+6),)56"*+"/&,*&/-<"E",564&/"+:"63"),*&/@)&1&&-"2&'-&"*%&)/"7+,(+6),)56-"),"S',)2'"*+"A)2)8),+-"1%+"1+/;"),",&'/943"7'2297&,*&/-?"dAP-?"+/"&@&,"*&68+/'/)23"7+,*/'7*&(":+/&)>,&/-"1%+"*/'@&2"4'7;"',(":+/*%"*+"*%&"D%)2)88),&-":+/"1+/;"'--)>,6&,*-<"d,&"+:"63"),*&/@)&1&&-"&@&,"/&,*-"%&/"5,)*"*+"*1+"E5-*/')2)',94+/,"A)2)8),+-"1%+"/&2+7'*&("*+"S',)2'"),"%+8&-"+:"-*/);),>"',"'7*),>"7'/&&/"1)*%"&)*%&/"+,&"+:"*%&"*1+"6'I+/"6&()'">/+58-f"ENB9KNV"+/"hSE<""""<-$(%#*#8!$&!E(2(%2*/!

".@&,"S',)2'")*-&2:"%'-"4&7+6&"',"+4-*'72&"),"&,*)7),>"4'2);4'3',-"*+"),@&-*"),"

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d*%&/"(&@&2+8&/-"%'@&"7%+-&,"*+"),,+@'*&"*%&"+2("6+(&2"+:"-545/4',)Y'*)+,"',("&-*'42)-%"6&>'9*+1,-%)8-"1%&/&"*%&"6+-*"&2)*&"+:"A)2)8),+-"7',"2)@&"8&'7&'423"),"*%&"8&/)8%&/3"'/+5,("S&*/+"S',)2'"/'*%&/"*%',")*-":/',*)7"7+/&<""

$%&"E3'2'"K+/8+/'*)+,?"*%&"6+-*"-577&--:52"2',("(&@&2+8&/"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?")-"),"*%&"6)((2&"-*'>&-"+:"'7%)&@),>"*%)-"-%):*"'1'3":/+6"(&@&2+8),>"8/+8&/*3"),"*%&"7&,*&/"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'<"$%&"7+/8+/'*)+,"%'-"2')("+5*"82',-"*+"45)2("'",&1"6&>'9*+1,-%)8"1)*%),"*%&"B',*'"_+-'9$'>'3*'3"'/&'"7'22&("V5@'2)<"C,"'"2+7'*)+,"-+5*%1&-*"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'?"E3'2'"82',-"*+"2)*&/'223"45)2("'"Q,&1"@'22&3R"82+**&("+,"!?eLL"%&7*'/&-"+:"8/+8&/*3<"$%)-"6&>'98/+I&7*"/&8/&-&,*-"*%&"7+682&*&"/&'2)Y'*)+,"+:"438'--9)682',*"5/4',)-6<"C,"+*%&/"8'/*-"+:"S',)2'?"82',-"'/&"5,(&/1'3"*+"&H*&,("%)>%1'3-"'2+,>"6+/&"8/+I&7*-"6)//+/),>"V5@'2)<"F&/&"),"*%&-&"*+1,-%)8-?"4'2);4'3',-"',("+*%&/"&2)*&"A)2)8),+-"7',"&H8&/)&,7&"1%'*"8/+8&/*3"(&@&2+8&/-"'/&"7'22),>"Q1+/2("72'--"2)@),>R"6&/&23"43",&@&/"%'@),>"*+"-*&89:++*"),"*%&"/&-*"+:"S',)2'<"

P%'*"4&7+6&-"&H*/'+/(),'/3"1%&,"@)&1),>"*%&"82',-":+/"*%&"V5@'2)"'/&",+*"*%&"'6&,)*)&-"*%'*"%'@&"4&7+6&"7+66+,"*%/+5>%+5*"*%&"S&*/+"S',)2'"7+,(+9&,72'@&"2',(-7'8&<"$%&"-),>52'/"&2&6&,*"+:"6+4)2)*3"4&7+6&-"*%&"7+,7&8*"-%'8),>"

Page 140: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!ZZ"

*%&"(&-)>,"+:"*%)-"8'/*)752'/"Y+,&"+:"&H7&8*)+,<"E(@&/*)-&6&,*-":+/"*%&"(&@&2+86&,*"/&'("*%'*"V5@'2)")-"(&-)>,&(":+/"'"o:5*5/&"*%'*"@&&/-"'1'3":/+6"*%&"-&@&/&"-8/'12"+:"7+,@&,*)+,'2"5/4',"(&@&2+86&,*<o"A+/"),-*',7&?"k+&2"i5,'?"*%&"7%)&:"'/7%)*&7*"+:"*%&"E3'2'"i',("C,,+@'*)+,"',("J&-)>,"h/+58"',("*%&"V5@'2)"8/+I&7*?"-'3-"*%'*"7&,*/'2"*+"*%&"(&-)>,")-"*%&"45)2(),>"+:"1)(&/"-)(&1'2;-<"B57%"'"-&&6),>23"6),+/"(&-)>,"7+,7&8*":+/7&-"'"-)>,):)7',*"-%):*"1)*%),"*%&"752*5/&"+:"6+4)2)*3"),"S',)2&T+"-+7)&*3"43"&,7+5/'>),>"Q6+/&"8&+82&"*+"1'2;"/'*%&/"*%',"*';&"*%&)/"7'/<"$%)-")-"'2-+"-':&/"',("6+/&"8&(&-*/)',":/)&,(23<"P&"'/&"'2-+"45)2(),>",'//+1&/"8'@&6&,*-<<<-+"*%&/&t-"6+/&"/++6":+/",'*5/'2"2',(-7'8),><"$%&/&"1)22"4&"(+542&9/+1-"+:"*/&&-"),-*&'("+:"*%&"*38)7'2"-),>2&"/+1<o"

P%'*"+,&"-&&-"),"*%&"5/4',"7+/&"+:"S',)2'"1%)2&"/$$-57$*#8"*+"1'2;"*%&"7)*3?")-",+*"&H'7*23"*%&"8)7*5/&"+:"7+,>&-*&("-8'7&-?"*%&"8+1&/"+:"7/+1(-?"',("*%&"6)H),>"+:"-+7)'2">/+58-"*%'*"_':'&2"8'),*-"+:"*%&"-)(&1'2;-"+:"*%&"7)*3<`M"E-"C"%'@&"7+,@&3&(?"7&/*'),23"72'--"()@)-)+,")-"(&6'/7'*&("43"+,&t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`e"1+52("'**&68*"*+"/&82)7'*&"+/"*%&"6+/&"/&7&,*"/&@',7%),)-*"7)*3"+:"/&,&1'2"',(">&,*/):)7'*)+,`a"7+52("#-J-%"4&"8+--)42&"),"S&*/+"S',)2'<""

S+-*"-)(&1'2;-"),"S',)2'"'/&",+*":)22&("1)*%"8&+82&"-)6823"4&7'5-&"6+-*"8&+82&"(+",+*"1'2;<"$%)-")-"1%3"*%&/&"'/&":)@&"*38&-"+:"8/)@'*)Y&("6&',-"+:"8542)7"*/',-8+/*'*)+,"7+,>&-*),>"*%&"7)*30-"-*/&&*-"W*%&"S_$")-"*%&"+,23":+/6"+:"8542)7"*/',-8+/*'*)+,X<"$%&"45-"-3-*&6"),"S',)2'"'2+,&")-"+@&/8+852'*&("43"'"-2&1"+:"6+,-*/+5-"*+5/"45-"-)Y&("@&%)72&-"6+/&"*%',"bLL"45-"7+68',)&-"+8&/'*&("),"S&*/+"S',)2'?"),725(),>"6+/&"*%',"!LL"*%'*"/',"'2+,>"*%&"),,&/"/),>"/+'("+:".JBE"'2+,&"Wh5'/)T+"#LL!X<"$%&"),*&,-&"7+68&*)*)+,":+/"8'--&,>&/-"()7*'*&("*%'*"*%&"6+-*"8/+:)*'42&"-*/'*&>3":+/"',3">)@&,"45-"1'-"*+")(2&"'2+,>"*%&"-)(&"+:"*%&"/+'("1')*),>":+/"8'--&,>&/-?"*%5-"72+>>),>"*%&"/+'("',("-2+1),>"*/'::)7"*+"'"7/'12<"K+68&*)*)+,"'2-+"()7*'*&("*%'*"45-"7+68',)&-"85/7%'-&"*%&"7%&'8&-*"5-&("45-&-"'@')2'42&"+,"*%&"),*&/,'*)+,'2"6'/;&*9),&@)*'423?"+2(&/"6+(&2-"*%'*"&6)*"6+/&"8+225*)+,<""

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""`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f"S&--)',)7"D+2)*)7-"),"*%&"K+,*&68+/'/3"D%)2)88),&-?";(20*)!D(0$(%-"!M<Z"W#LLZX"Zcc9b#M<""`e"B&&?":+/"),-*',7&?"J'@)("N/+(30-"M*:(/0*T*#8!A5-%*)/#!457*%-?!X%*-#$/0*:5!/#'!"57-%*/0*:5!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:"WK%)7'>+f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"K%)7'>+"D/&--?"#L!LX<"""`a"B&&"V&)2"B6)*%0-"+,-!Q->!U%2/#!9%&#$*-%?!@-#$%*F*)/$*&#!/#'!$,-!<-J/#),*:$!D*$3"WV&1"O+/;f"_+5*2&(>&?"!cceX<""

Page 141: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!Zb"

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

"$%&/&")-"'"(&7&8*)@&"'5/'"+:"+8*)6)-6"*%'*"&H5(&-"'6+,>-*"*%&"75//&,*"

'(6),)-*/'*)+,-0"+8*)6)-6"'/+5,("*%&":5*5/&"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"E"2)*',3"+:"'/*)72&-"8/),*&("+,"*%&":/+,*"8'>&-"+:"S',)2'0-",&1-8'8&/-"6)H"1)*%"*&2&@)-&("8542)7"',,+5,7&6&,*-"*%'*"*+>&*%&/"&H8/&--"'"7+66+,"/%&*+/)7"+:"&7+,+6)7"-*'4)2)*3"',("'"7+,:)(&,7&"*%'*"6)>%*"'88&'/",'Ö@&"(5/),>"'"8&/)+("+:">2+4'2"&7+,+6)7"7/)-)-<"h+@&/,6&,*'2"'>&,7)&-"',("6&()'"7+,-*)*5&,*-"8+),*"*+"@'/)+5-"),()7'*+/-?"6+-*",+*'423"-5/>&-"),"8/+8&/*3"',(":+/&)>,"45-),&--"),@&-*6&,*-?"'-"'"6&',-"+:"-5-*'),),>"'"*+,&"+:"%+8&:52,&--"),"*%&":'7&"+:">/+1),>",'*)+,'2"(&4*"',(">2+4'2"),-&75/)*3<"$%)-"'**)*5(&"1'-"&642&6)Y&("43"*%&"S)22&,,)56"J&@&2+86&,*"h+'2?"),"1%)7%"E//+3+"8/+I&7*&("*%'*"8+2)7)&-"()/&7*&("43"%&/"'(6),)-*/'*)+,"1+52("&::&7*)@&23"/&(57&"8+@&/*3"43"%'2:"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"43"#L!M<``""

d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

d,"*%&"+*%&/"%',(?"/&7&,*"-*5()&-"7+,@&3"'"7+,*/'/3"',("657%"6+/&"42&';"&7+,+6)7"8/+:)2&<""A+/"),-*',7&?"N'2)-'7',?"'"8/+:&--+/"+:"&7+,+6)7-"'*"*%&"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"72')6-"*%'*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"%'("+,23"&H8&/)&,7&("Q6+(&-*"&7+,+6)7">/+1*%"),"/&7&,*"3&'/-"45*")*"()(",+*"8/&@&,*"8+@&/*3":/+6"/)-),><"$%),>-"%'@&"/&'223">+,&"1+/-&"),"*%&"2'-*"-)H"*+"-&@&,"3&'/-R"W_&6+"#LLcX<"N'2)-'7',0-"7+,725-)+,"/&@&'2-"'"657%"Q('/;&/"-)(&R"+:"&7+,+6)7">2+4'2)Y'*)+,"',("),7/&'-&("

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""``"C,"'"B*'*&"+:"*%&"V'*)+,"E((/&--">)@&,"),"#LLa?"E//+3+"1'-"+8*)6)-*)7"*%'*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1+52("-577&--:5223"7+,:/+,*"8+@&/*3"),"*%&"7+5,*/3"',("'7%)&@&"*%&)/"#L!M"(&'(2),&?"-'3),>"oF',>'/),";+,>"6'8'4)2',>"',>"D)2)8),'-"-'"6'3'3'6',>"4',-'"-'"2++4",>"('2'1'685,>"*'+,"WC"4&2)&@&"*%'*"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"1)22"4&"+,&"+:"*%&"1&'2*%3"7+5,*/)&-"1)*%),"#L"3&'/-{<"N3"*%&,"8+@&/*3"-%'22"%'@&"4&&,"6'/>),'2)Y&(g"',("*%&"6'/>),'2)Y&("/')-&("*+"'"/+45-*"6)((2&"72'--R<""

Page 142: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!ZM"

6'/;&*"2)4&/'2)Y'*)+,<"_'*%&/"*%',"8/+(57),>"&7+,+6)7"&U5'2)*3?"@'/)+5-"-7%+2'/-"*&,("*+"4&2)&@&"*%'*">2+4'2)Y'*)+,"'7*5'223"1)(&,-"*%&"()-*',7&"4&*1&&,"-+7)'2"72'--&-<""

A5*5/&"/&-&'/7%")-",&7&--'/3"),"+/(&/"*+"6';&"-&,-&"+:"*%&"1'3-"),"1%)7%"*%&"4'2);4'3',"&7+,+63"%'-":'7)2)*'*&("'"(+1,1'/("8/&--5/&"+,"1'>&-"*%/+5>%"*%&"7+,*),5'2"(&8&,(&,7&"+,"/&6)**',7&-?"*%&"+,>+),>"(&@'-*'*)+,"+:"*%&"2+7'2"&,@)/+,6&,*"43"@'/)+5-"(&@&2+86&,*"8/+I&7*-"',(",&1"),:/'-*/57*5/&-?"',("*%&":5/*%&/"()-82'7&6&,*"+:"8++/"7+665,)*)&-<"E-"-57%?"*%&",&>'*)@&")68'7*"+:"*%&"4'2);4'3',"&7+,+63")-"()-8/+8+/*)+,'*&23":&2*"43"*%&"5/4',"8++/"',("'"*+,&"+:"+8*)6)-6"4'-&("+,"&7+,+6)7"),()7'*+/-"+:">/+1),>"),7+6&-"',("),7/&'-&("-8&,(),>")-"72&'/23"(&7&)@),><"_&>'/(2&--"):"*%&"8++/"6)>%*"%'@&"),7/&'-&("'77&--"*+"7+,-56&/">++(-"2);&"&2&7*/+,)7"&U5)86&,*"+/"%+5-&%+2(")*&6-"2);&"1'-%),>"6'7%),&-?"*%&3"7+,*),5&"*+"2'7;"*%&"4'-)7",&7&--)*3":+/"&7+,+6)7"-*'4)2)*3?"7&,*/'223"2+7'*&("5/4',"-8'7&"WB%'*;),"#LLbX<"

E**&68*-"*+">&,&/'*&"5/4',)Y'*)+,"'2+,>"S&*/+"S',)2'0-"8&/)8%&/3"%'-":5/*%&/"8/+8&22&("*%&"8/+7&--"+:"()-2+7'*)+,"+:"*%&"5/4',"8++/<"E2+,>"1)*%"*%&"/5),+5-"&::&7*"7/&'*&("43":2++(),>"+,*+"*%&-&":'6)2)&-?")-"*%&"7+68+5,(),>"8/+42&6"7/&'*&("43"'"7+,7&/*&("&::+/*"43"7+/8+/'*&"(&@&2+8&/-"*+";&&8":'6)2)&-":/+6"/&*5/,),>"*+"*%&)/"%+6&-<"A+/"&H'682&?"*%&"/&7&,*"7'*'-*/+8%)7"&::&7*-"+:"$/+8)7'2"B*+/6"d,(+3"),"#LLc"%'@&"*';&,"'",564&/"+:"7+665,)*)&-"43"-5/8/)-&"',("2&:*"',"&,+/6+5-",564&/"+:":'6)2)&-"%+6&2&--?"8'/*)752'/23"),"*%&"7)*)&-"+:"D'-)>"',("S'/);),'<"P%)2&"6',3"7+665,)*)&-"2)@),>"'2+,>"7+'-*'2"/&>)+,-"+/"'(I'7&,*"*+"*%&"*1+"2'/>&/"/)@&/-"'/+5,("S&*/+"S',)2'?"-57%"'-"*%+-&"2)@),>"),"S'2'4+,?"'/&"'775-*+6&("*+":2++(),>?"7+665,)*)&-"-57%"'-"*%+-&"),"*%&"),,&/"/&>)+,-"+:"D'-)>"',("S'/);),'"1&/&"2&--"8/&8'/&(<"i'7;),>"'2*&/,'*)@&"%+5-),>?"6',3"+:"*%&-&":'6)2)&-"1&/&":+/7&("*+"/&-)(&"),"*&68+/'/3"%+5-),>"1)*%":'6)2)&-<"C:"6+,&3"8&/6)**&(?"+*%&/":'6)2)&-"6+@&("*+"/&,*&("7+,(+6),)56-"),"+*%&/"'/&'-"'/+5,("*%&"7)*3<"P%)2&"+*%&/-"%'("2)**2&"7%+)7&"45*"*+"-*'3"),"*%&"(&@'-*'*&("/&6'),-"+:"*%&)/"+2("%+6&-"',(",&)>%4+/%++(-<""

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`L"8&/7&,*"+:"S&*/+"S',)2'?"'"/'*%&/"-&/&,()8)*+5-"+8&,),>"1'-"7/&'*&(":+/"(&@&2+8&/-"*+"-&)Y&"6+/&"8/+8&/*3"-5//+5,(),>"*%&"7)*30-"8&/)8%&/3<""

P%&,"C"@)-)*&("S'/';),'"*+"1)*,&--"*%&"(&@'-*'*)+,"7/&'*&("43"d,(+3"',("%&28"1)*%"/&45)2(),>"8/+I&7*-"6+,*%-"':*&/"*%&"-*+/6?"C"1'-"82&'-&("*+"-&&"*%'*"+,&"+:"*%&"6'I+/"2&@&&-"-&8'/'*),>"+,&"+:"*%&"4'/',>'3-"6+-*"&::&7*&("43"*%&":2++(),>"+:"D'-)>"/)@&/"%'(",+*"+,23"4&&,"/&8')/&("45*"&H*&,(&("),"4+*%"2&,>*%"',("%&)>%*<"C"1'-"

Page 143: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!Ze"

*+2("*%'*"*%&":),',7),>"7+-*-"1&/&"8')("43"-&@&/'2":'6)23"6&64&/-"1%+"2)@&("'/+5,("B',"A/',7)-7+<"$%&3"()(",+*"7+6&":/+6"J'23"K)*3"45*"/&-)(&("),"*%&"N'3"E/&'",+,&*%&2&--<"E-"-++,"'-"*%&"-*+/6"%'("8'--&(?"A)2)8),+"7%5/7%"7+,>/&>'*)+,-"%'("1+/;&("*+"/')-&":5,(-":+/"@)7*)6-"),"d,(+3"',(":'6)23"6&64&/-"1&/&"),-*/56&,*'2"),"%&28),>"*+"/&8')/"*+1,-%)8-"*%/+5>%+5*"S'/);),'<""

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

Page 144: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!Za"

G+>3+'4&/:05!!E>'64&,?"h)+/>)+<"!cc`<"O&5&!E/)-%?!E&J-%-*8#!;&>-%!/#'!./%-!N*F-<"B*',:+/(f"

B*',:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"E2'@&?"l/)-*),&"i<"#LLa<"_&*)/&6&,*"F'@&,"B7%&6&"F'68&/&("43"C6'>&"C--5&<"

.(:*#-::B&%0'?"A&4/5'/3"##?"#LLa"B!p!<"~2@'/&Y9_)@'(522'?"S'/r'"k+-|"#LLa<"h+2(&,"h%&**+-f"h'*&("K+665,)*)&-"',("K2'--"

_&-)(&,*)'2"B&>/&>'*)+,"),"S+,*&@)(&+?"=/5>5'3<"4#J*%&#5-#$!/#'!;0/##*#8!A"Zc"W!Xfba9eZ""

E8&2'7)+?"K'*%3<"#LLa<"_D"4&-*"/&*)/&6&,*"%'@&,":+/":+/&)>,",'*)+,'2-?"-'3-"h&,<"E>2)8'3<"6/#*0/!E$/#'/%'?"S'/7%"#c?"#LLa<"

E88'(5/')?"E/I5,<"!cce<"6&'-%#*$3!/$!N/%8-?!D(0$(%/0!P*5-#:*&#:!&F!@0&2/0*T/$*&#<"S),,&'8+2)-"g"i+,(+,f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"S),,&-+*'"D/&--<"

N'>5)+/+?"i5Y<"#LL#<"V&@&/"6),("*%&"/)-),>"7/)6&?"2&*t-">+"-%+88),>g"S',)2'"1)22"8)*7%"4/',(9,'6&"-%+88),>"),"S';'*)"*+"'::25&,*"k'8',&-&"1+6&,"),")*-"2'*&-*"85-%":+/"*%&"*+5/)-*"(+22'/<"+,-!E$%/*$:!+*5-:?"d7*+4&/"#M?"#LL#<"

N'2)-'7',?"E/-&,)+"S<?"',("F'2"F)22<"#LLZ<"E,"C,*/+(57*)+,"*+"*%&"l&3"C--5&-<"C,"+,-!;,*0*77*#-!4)&#&53[!P-J-0&75-#$C!;&0*)*-:C!/#'!D,/00-#8-:?"&()*&("43"E<"S<"N'2)-'7',"',("F<"F)22<"x5&Y+,"K)*3f"E*&,&+"(&"S',)2'"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

N'-7'/'?"G)7*+/<"#LLe<"6&'-0=5*#&%*$3!*57-%*/0*:5<"S),,&'8+2)-f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"S),,&-+*'"D/&--<"

N'-7%?"i),('"h?"V),'"h2)7;"B7%)22&/?"',("K/)-*),'"BY',*+,"N2',7<"!ccb<"Q/$*&#:!U#2&(#'?!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!;%&V-)$:C!;&:$)&0&#*/0!;%-'*)/5-#$:C!/#'!P-$-%%*$&%*/0*T-'!Q/$*&#=E$/$-:<"V&1"O+/;f"_+5*2&(>&<"

N'**)-*&22'?"h/'Y)',+<"#LLb<"_&*5/,"S)>/'*)+,"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-f"C--5&-"',("D+2)7)&-<"C,""#$-%#/$*&#/0!6*8%/$*&#?!;%&:7-)$:!/#'!;&0*)*-:!*#!/!@0&2/0!6/%1-$?"&()*&("43"J<"B<"S'--&3<"dH:+/(f"dH:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

N&22+?"P'2(&,"A<g"l),2&3?"J'@)(g".2),-+,?".2'),&<"!c`#<"P-J-0&75-#$!P-2/)0-?!+,-!B&%0'!./#1!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:<"d';2',(f"A++("A)/-*"N++;-<"

N&,I'6),?"P'2*&/<"!ccc<"+,-!A%)/'-:!;%&V-)$<"K'64/)(>&f"F'/@'/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"N&/6',?"S'/-%'22<"!c``<"A00!+,/$!*:!E&0*'!6-0$:!*#$&!A*%?!!+,-!4R7-%*-#)-!&F!6&'-%#*$3<"

V&1"O+/;f"G);),>"D&,>5),<"N%'4%'?"F+6)"l<"!ccL<"J)--&6)V'*)+,f"$)6&?"V'//'*)@&"',("*%&"S'/>),-"+:"*%&"

S+(&/,"V'*)+,<"C,"Q/$*&#!/#'!Q/%%/$*&#<"i+,(+,f"_+5*2&(>&<"N+,5-?"_)7;<"#LLL<"N&)/$*#8!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#:!?!4$,#*)*$3!/#'!$,-!D(0$(%/0!;&0*$*):!&F!

E7/)-<"D%)2'(&28%)'f"$&682&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"N/&**&22?"K'/+2),&<"#LLZ<"A#$,%&7&0&83!/#'!6*8%/$*&#?!4::/3:!&#!+%/#:#/$*&#/0*:5C!

4$,#*)*$3C!/#'!"'-#$*$3<"P'2,5*"K/&&;?"KEf"E2*'6)/'"D/&--<"N/+(3?"J'@)(<"#L!L<"M*:(/0*T*#8!A5-%*)/#!457*%-?!X%*-#$/0*:5!/#'!"57-%*/0*:5!*#!$,-!

;,*0*77*#-:<"K%)7'>+"g"i+,(+,f"$%&"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"K%)7'>+"D/&--<"N57+?"N&,I'6),"G<"#LLe<"BD.KCEi"_.Dd_$f"D%)2)88),&"_&*)/&6&,*"C,(5-*/3g"D_E"

',("D_Cf"F',("),"%',("),"8/+6+*),>"*%&"D%)2)88),&-"'-"'"/&*)/&6&,*"(&-*),'*)+,<".(:*#-::B&%0'?"J&7&64&/"#!?"#LLe<"

N5/'1+3?"S)7%'&2<"!cc!<"4$,#&8%/7,3!U#2&(#'?!;&>-%!/#'!<-:*:$/#)-!*#!$,-!6&'-%#!6-$%&7&0*:<"N&/;&2&3f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"K'2):+/,)'"D/&--<"

N5/>),?"G)7*+/<"!cc!<"D'/',+)'7"B8'7&<"M*:(/0!A#$,%&7&0&83!<-J*->"a"W#Xf##9ZL<"

Page 145: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!Z`"

K'2(&)/'?"$&/&-'<"#LLL<"D*$3!&F!B/00:?!D%*5-C!E-8%-8/$*&#C!/#'!D*$*T-#:,*7!*#!Ej&!;/(0&<"N&/;&2&3f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"K'2):+/,)'"D/&--<"

K'68+6',&-?"d-7'/"G<"!cc#<"A)2)8),+-"),"*%&"=,)*&("B*'*&-"',("$%&)/"i)*&/'*5/&"+:".H)2&<"C,"<-/'*#8!$,-!N*$-%/$(%-:!&F!A:*/#!A5-%*)/?"&()*&("43"B<"h<92<"i56"',("E<"i),><"D%)2'(&28%)'f"$&682&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

K'+)2)?"S',5&2"E<"<"!c``<"+,-!X%*8*#:!&F!6-$%&7&0*$/#!6/#*0/?!A!;&0*$*)/0!/#'!E&)*/0!A#/03:*:<"x5&Y+,"K)*3f"V&1"J'3"D542)-%&/-<"

K'/)T+?"N&,I'6),"G<"!ccL<"+,-!Q->!9*0*7*#&!"55*8%/#$:!$&!$,-!U#*$-'!E$/$-:?!"#)%-/:*#8!P*J-%:*$3!/#'!D,/#8-?";/7-%:!&F!$,-!4/:$=B-:$!;&7(0/$*&#!"#:$*$($-<"F+,+2525f".'-*9P&-*"K&,*&/<"

K'-*&22-?"S',5&2<"#LLL<"+,-!<*:-!&F!$,-!Q-$>&%1!E&)*-$3<"#,("&(<"S'2(&,f"N2'7;1&22"D542)-%&/-<"

K%+3?"K'*%&/),&"K&,)Y'<"#LLZ<"457*%-!&F!D/%-?!Q(%:*#8!/#'!6*8%/$*&#!*#!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#!O*:$&%3<"J5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

K%+3?"K'*%&/),&"K&,)Y'<"#LLM<"$+1'/(-"$/',-9D'7):)7"B+7)'2"k5-*)7&f"P+6&,"',("D/+*&-*"),"A)2)8),+"E6&/)7',"F)-*+/3<"Y&(%#/0!&F!A:*/#!A5-%*)/#!E$('*-:"`"WZXf#cZ9ZLa<"

K+,72'/'?"k<"!ccc<"J'23"K)*3"2++;),>":+/"A)2)8),+"),@&-*+/-<".(:*#-::B&%0'?"d7*+4&/"#!?"!ccc?"e<"

K+,,&22?"k+%,<"!ccc<"N&3+,("S',)2'f"P'22-?"S'22-?"',("D/)@'*&"B8'7&-<"4#J*%&#5-#$!/#'!;0/##*#8!A"Z!"WZXfb!a"m"bZc""

K+/,&2)+9D/+,+@&?"S+,)U5&g"K%&,>?"K%&6&/)&<"!ccc<"S&*/+"S',)2'<"C,"D*$*-:!*#!$,-!;/)*F*)!<*5?!;0/##*#8!E3:$-5:!/#'!;%&7-%$3!6/%1-$:?"&()*&("43"k<"S<"N&//3?"B*',2&3<"V&1"O+/;f"."w"AV"B8+,<"

J'6'Y+?"k&*<"#L!L<"d&%-/!"#J/'-:!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:""#LLa"z7)*&("k',5'/3"!#"#L!L{<"E@')2'42&":/+6"%**8fpp111<'-)'-&,*),&2<7+6p),(&H<8%8[C*&6)(ÉZbw)(ÉMaMw+8*)+,É7+6Ç7+,*&,*w*'-;É@)&1""

J'U5)Y?"S'"B5Y&**&"_<"#LLe<"BD.KCEi"_.Dd_$f"D%)2)88),&"_&*)/&6&,*"C,(5-*/3g"P%+"(+"1&"1',*"*+"7+6&[".(:*#-::B&%0'?"J&7&64&/"#!?"#LLe<"

(&"J)+-?".66',5&2"B<g"F5*7%7/+:*?"D'52<"#LLZ<"D+2)*)7'2".7+,+63<"C,"+,-!;,*0*77*#-!4)&#&53?!P-J-0&75-#$C!;&0*)*-:C!/#'!D,/00-#8-:!&()*&("43"E<"S<"F<"N'2)-'7',?"F'2<"x5&Y+,"K)*3f"E*&,&+"(&"S',)2'"=,)@&/-)*3<"

(&2'"D&,'?"h&/'/("B<"#LLa<"S&*/+4',;"-&*-"58"K'2):+/,)'"/&6)**',7&"5,)*<".(:*#-::B&%0'?"E5>5-*"#b?"#LLa<"

J&26&,(+?"B%'/+,<"#LLb<"+,-!E$/%=4#$/#80-'!./##-%?!X#-!O(#'%-'!Z-/%:!&F!A5-%*)/!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:<"V&1"N/5,-1)7;?"V<k<f"_5*>&/-"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

.2I&/'?"N&/*<"!cce<"A)2)8),+-"A),("F+6&"),"J'23"K)*3<"A:*/#!B--1?"S'3"Z9c<"

.,>2',(?"B'/'%<"!ccc<"V&>+*)'*),>"_'7&"',("D2'7&"),"*%&"h'/):5,'"J)'-8+/'f"C(&,*)*3"A+/6'*)+,"',("$/',-,'*)+,'2"h/'--/++*-"D+2)*)7-"),"V&1"O+/;"K)*3"',("F+,(5/'-<""'-#$*$*-:"e"W!XfM9MZ<"

.-8)/)*5?"E5>5-*+"A'5,)<"#LLM<"9*J-!9/)-:!&F!4R*0-?!+,-!Q/$*&#!/#'!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#!"#$-00-)$(/0:<"B*',:+/(f"B*',:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

.-8)/)*5?"O&,"i&<"#LLZ<"O&5-!.&(#'?!9*0*7*#&!N*J-:!A)%&::!D(0$(%-:C!D&55(#*$*-:C!/#'!D&(#$%*-:<"N&/;&2&3f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"K'2):+/,)'"D/&--<"

Page 146: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!Zc"

A'17&**?"k'6&-g"h'/(,&/?"_+4&/*<"!ccb<"E-)',"C66)>/',*".,*/&8/&,&5/-"',("V+,9.,*/&8/&,&5/-f"E"K+68'/'*)@&"B*5(3"+:"_&7&,*"l+/&',"',("A)2)8),+"C66)>/',*-<";&7(0/$*&#!k!4#J*%&#5-#$"!M"WZXf#!!9#Z`<"

A&/>5-+,?"k'6&-"',("E;%)2"h58*'<"#LLM<"B8'*)'2)Y),>"B*'*&-f"$+1'/("',".*%,+>/'8%3"+:"V&+2)4&/'2"h+@&/,6&,*'2)*3<"C,"A#$,%&7&0&8*-:!&F!5&'-%#*$3!?!9&()/(0$C!8&J-%#5-#$/0*$3C!/#'!0*F-!7&0*$*):?"&()*&("43"k<"Ü<"C,('<"S'2(&,?"SEf"N2'7;1&22"D54<"

A&/,s,(&Y9l&223?"S'/r'"D'*/)7)'<"!c`Z<"9&%!B-!/%-!E&0'C!"!/#'!63!;-&70-?!B&5-#!/#'!"#'(:$%3!*#!6-R*)&S:!9%&#$*-%<"E24',3f"B=VO"D/&--<"

A2+/&-?"E2&,'"S'&"B<"#LLM<"j"!LL6"k'8',&-&"S&()7'2"A'7)2)*3"_)-),>"'*"_&72')6&("i',(<"6/#*0/!E$/#'/%'?"A&4/5'/3"M?"#LLM<"

A+,>?"$)6+*%3"D<"!ccb<"+,-!9*%:$!E(2(%2/#!D,*#/$&>#?!+,-!<-5/1*#8!&F!6&#$-%-3!;/%1C!D/0*F&%#*/<"D%)2'(&28%)'f"$&682&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

A5I)*'9_+,3?"J+/+*%3"N<"#LLZ<"A5-%*)/#!B&%1-%:C!D&0&#*/0!;&>-%?!;,*0*77*#-!E-/$$0-!/#'!$,-!+%/#:7/)*F*)!B-:$C!GHGH=GHIG<"N&/;&2&3f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"K'2):+/,)'"D/&--<"

h)22&-8)&?"N5,,3<"#LLZ<"P/03!D*$3?""5/8-:!&F!A5-%*)/<"K%'2/&-*+,?"BKf"E/7'()'<"h)2/+3?"D'52<"!ccZ<"+,-!.0/)1!A$0/#$*)?!6&'-%#*$3!/#'!P&(20-!D&#:)*&(:#-::<"

K'64/)(>&?"S'--<f"F'/@'/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"h2)7;"B7%)22&/?"V),'"',("A+5/+,?"h&+/>&-".5>&,&<"#LL!<"@-&%8-:!B&1-!U7!N/(8,*#8?!

N0&#8=P*:$/#)-!Q/$*&#/0*:5!/#'!$,-!E-/%),!F&%!O&5-<"J5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

h2)7;"B7%)22&/?"V),'?"i),('"h"N'-7%?"',("K%/)-*),'"BY',*+,"N2',7<"!ccM<"A/+6"C66)>/',*"*+"$/',-6)>/',*f"$%&+/)Y),>"$/',-,'*)+,'2"S)>/'*)+,<"A#$,%&7&0&8*)/0!l(/%$-%03"e`"W!Xfb`9eZ<"

h+?"k52)',?"',("E,,&"i<"A+-*&/<"#LLZ<"+,-!A5-%*)/#!D&0&#*/0!E$/$-!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:?!@0&2/0!;-%:7-)$*J-:<"J5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

h+,Y'2&Y?"k+'U5),"i<"!cc`<";,*0*77*#-!N/2&(%!6*8%/$*&#?!D%*$*)/0!P*5-#:*&#:!&F!;(20*)!;&0*)3<"B),>'8+/&f"C,-*)*5*&"+:"B+5*%&'-*"E-)',"B*5()&-<"

h/&1'2?"C,(&/8'2<"#LLM<"$/',-,'*)+,'2"E6&/)7'f"A&6),)-6-?"J)'-8+/'-?"V&+2)4&/'2)-6-<"J5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"%**8fpp111<7+2564)'<&(5p7>)94),p752p/&-+2@&[72)+eee!McL<"

h/&1'2?"C,(&/8'2?"',("K'/&,"l'82',<"!ccb<"E)/$$-%-'!O-8-5&#*-:?!;&:$5&'-%#*$3!/#'!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!9-5*#*:$!;%/)$*)-:<"S),,&'8+2)-f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"S),,&-+*'"D/&--<"

h5'/)T+?"J+6),>+"i<"<"#LL!<"E"B*5(3"),*+"*%&"G)'4)2)*3"+:"K+,-+2)('*),>"N5-"K+68',)&-"d8&/'*),>"),"S&*/+"S',)2'<"5,8542)-%&("6'-*&/t-"*%&-)-?"B7%++2"+:"=/4',"',("_&>)+,'2"D2',,),>?"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"J)22)6',<"

h5'/,)Y+?"i5)-<"!cca<"$%&".6&/>&,7&"+:"'"$/',-,'*)+,'2"B+7)'2"A+/6'*)+,"',("$%&"S)/'>&"+:"_&*5/,"S)>/'*)+,"E6+,>"J+6),)7',"$/',-6)>/',*-<""'-#$*$*-:"b"W#Xf#`!9Z##<"

h5&@'//'?"E,,'"_<"#LLe<"S','>),>"G52,&/'4)2)*)&-t"',(".68+1&/),>t"S)>/',*"A)2)8),'"P+/;&/-f"$%&"D%)2)88),&-t"d@&/-&'-".682+36&,*"D/+>/'6<"E&)*/0!"'-#$*$*-:"!#"WMXfM#Z9Mb!<"

h5&@'//'?"E,,'"_<"#L!L<"6/%1-$*#8!P%-/5:C!6/#(F/)$(%*#8!O-%&-:?!+,-!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!N/2&%!.%&1-%*#8!&F!9*0*7*#&!B&%1-%:<"V&1"N/5,-1)7;f"_5*>&/-<"

Page 147: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!bL"

h52',&?"k5(3"$<"#LLe<"D2',"8+-)*)+,-"_D"'-"/&*)/&6&,*"%'@&,<".(:*#-::B&%0'?"S'3"ZL?"#LLe""

h58*'?"E;%)2<"!cc#<"$%&"B+,>"+:"*%&"V+,'2)>,&("P+/2(f"$/',-,'*)+,'2"C(&,*)*)&-"',("*%&"_&),-7/)8*)+,"+:"B8'7&"),"i'*&"K'8)*'2)-6<"D(0$(%/0!A#$,%&7&0&83"a"W!XfeZ9ac<"

h58*'?"E;%)2?"',("k'6&-"A&/>5-+,<"!cc#<"N&3+,("oK52*5/&of"B8'7&?"C(&,*)*3?"',("*%&"D+2)*)7-"+:"J)::&/&,7&<"D(0$(%/0!A#$,%&7&0&83"a"W!Xfe9#Z<"

F',,&/Y?"=2:<"!cc#<"$%&"h2+4'2".756&6&"'-"'"V&*1+/;"+:"V&*1+/;-<"C,"D&#)-7$(/0*T*#8!E&)*-$3?"&()*&("43"E<"l58&/<"i+,(+,"g"V&1"O+/;f"_+5*2&(>&<"

F),>?"N)22"d,><"!ccZ<"6/1*#8!/#'!%-5/1*#8!A:*/#!A5-%*)/!$,%&(8,!*55*8%/$*&#!7&0*)3C!GKmn=GHHn<"B*',:+/(?"K'2):<f"B*',:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

F+>',-+,?"l/)-*),"i<"!cc`<"9*8,$*#8!F&%!A5-%*)/#!6/#,&&'?!O&>!@-#'-%!;&0*$*):!;%&J&1-'!$,-!E7/#*:,=A5-%*)/#!/#'!;,*0*77*#-=A5-%*)/#!B/%:<"V&1"F'@&,"K+,,<f"O'2&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

C>,'7)+?".6)23<"#LLM<".(*0'*#8!P*/:7&%/?!9*0*7*#&!D&55(#*$3!9&%5/$*&#!&#!$,-!"#$-%#-$<"V&1"N/5,-1)7;f"_5*>&/-"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

k'74-+,?"S'**%&1"A/3&<"!ccc<"C68&/)'2"E6,&-)'f"$&((3"_++-&@&2*?"*%&"D%)2)88),&-?"',("*%&"S+(&/,"E/*"+:"A+/>&**),><"</'*)/0!O*:$&%3!<-J*->"aZf!!a9!#a<"

k'7+4-?"k',&"S<"!cce<"4'8-!&F!-57*%-!?!7&:$)&0&#*/0*:5!/#'!$,-!)*$3<"i+,(+,"g"V&1"O+/;f"_+5*2&(>&<"

l&'/,&3?"S<"!ccM<"$%&"i+7'2"',("*%&"h2+4'2f"$%&"E,*%/+8+2+>3"+:"h2+4'2)Y'*)+,"',("$/',-,'*)+,'2)-6<"A##(/0!<-J*->!&F!A#$,%&7&0&83"#bfMba9MeM<"

l&)2?"_+4<"#LLe<"N*$$0-!.&R-:?!+,-!A%),*$-)$(%-!&F!/!D0/::*)!6*')-#$(%3!E(2(%2<"J'23"K)*3?"KEf"E(@&7*)+,"S&()'<"

l&223?"D%)2)8"A<"#LL!<"i',(-7'8&-"+:"h2+4'2)Y'*)+,f"F56',"h&+>/'8%)&-"+:".7+,+6)7"K%',>&"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<"V&1"O+/;f"_+5*2&(>&<"%**8fpp111<7+2564)'<&(5p7>)94),p752p/&-+2@&[72)+MZaa!bb<"

l/'6&/?"D'52"E<"#LLe<"+,-!.0&&'!&F!@&J-%#5-#$?!</)-C!457*%-C!$,-!U#*$-'!E$/$-:C!/#'!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:<"K%'8&2"F)22f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"V+/*%"K'/+2),'"D/&--<"

l/&):&2-?"B5-',<"#LLc<".7+,+6)7"N++6"D522-"N'2);4'3',-"N'7;"F+6&<"O&#&0(0(!E$/%!.(00-$*#?"d7*+4&/"#e?"#LLc<"

l/),;-?"D&*&/"E<"#LL#<"+,-!4)&#&53!&F!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:?!40*$-:C!"#-f(/0*$*-:!/#'!4)&#&5*)!<-:$%()$(%*#8<"V&1"O+/;f"_+5*2&(>&<"

i'1?"i)-'<"#LL#<"B)*&-"+:"$/',-,'*)+,'2"E7*)@)-6f"A)2)8),+"V+,9>+@&/,6&,*"d/>',)-'*)+,-"),"F+,>"l+,><"C,"@-#'-%!;&0*$*):!*#!$,-!A:*/=;/)*F*)!<-8*&#?"&()*&("43"N<"B<"E<"$<"O&+%?"D&>>3g"F5',>?"B%)/2&,'<"V&1"O+/;<"

i&"N+/>,&?"./)7<"#L!L<"<-5*$$/#)-:!/#'!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:S!4)&#&53?!$,-!40-7,/#$!*#!$,-!<&&5<"P+/2("N',;"#LLc"z7)*&("S'/7%"Z"#L!L{<"E@')2'42&":/+6"%**8fpp42+>-<1+/2(4',;<+/>p&'-*'-)'8'7):)7p/&6)**',7&-9',(9*%&98%)2)88),&-9&7+,+639*%&9&2&8%',*9),9*%&9/++6<"

i&&?"K%),>"l1',<"#LLc<"_'1".,7+5,*&/-f"K%),&-&"S','>&/-?"E:/)7',"P+/;&/-"',("*%&"D+2)*)7-"+:"K'-5'2)Y'*)+,"),"E:/)7't-"K%),&-&".,72'@&-<"+,-!D,*#/!l(/%$-%03"!cc"W9!Xfeba9eee<"

i&)7%&,;+?"_+4),"S<g"B+2&7;)?"P)22)'6"J<"#LLM<".H8+/*),>"*%&"E6&/)7',"J/&'6f"$%&"h2+4'2)Y'*)+,"+:"B545/4',"K+,-568*)+,"i',(-7'8&-<"<-8*&#/0!E$('*-:!Zc"W#Xf#b!m#MZ<"

Page 148: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!b!"

i&)-7%?"F'/'2(<"#LL#<"h'*&("K+665,)*)&-"),"C,(+,&-)'<"D*$*-:"!c"WMXfZb!9ZML<"i&--),>&/?"k+%',,'<"!ccM<"9%&5!$,-!@/#8-:!$&!$,-!O(':&#?!"#'*/#!*55*8%/#$:!*#!Q->!

Z&%1!D*$3<"N+-*+,f"E223,"',("N'7+,<"i&@)**?"D&>>3<"#LL!<"$/',-,'*)+,'2"S)>/'*)+,f"$';),>"B*+7;"',("A5*5/&"J)/&7*)+,-<"

@0&2/0!Q-$>&%1:"!"WZXf!cM9#!e<"i&@)**?"D&>>3<"#LL!<"+,-!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!M*00/8-%:<"N&/;&2&3f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"K'2):+/,)'"

D/&--<"i)?"P&)<"!cc`<"E,'*+63"+:"'"V&1".*%,)7"B&**2&6&,*f"$%&"K%),&-&".*%,+45/4"),"i+-"

E,>&2&-<"U%2/#!E$('*-:"ZM"WZXfbac9ML!<"i)7+?"h&/'/(<"#LLZ<"4'*F*)-!D&570-R?!;&>-%C!63$,C!/#'!6/%)&:!E$/$-!A%),*$-)$(%-<"

x5&Y+,"K)*3f"E*&,&+"(&"S',)2'"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"i)5?"k+%,"S<g"d,>?"D'52"S<g"_+-&,-*&),?"K'/+23,<"!cc!<"J5'2"K%'),"S)>/'*)+,f"D+-*9

!ceM"A)2)8),+"C66)>/'*)+,"*+"*%&"=,)*&("B*'*&-<""#$-%#/$*&#/0!6*8%/$*&#!<-J*->"#M"WZXfb`a9M!Z<"

i+5)&?"E,(/&'<"#LLb<"D,*#-:-#-::!A)%&::!.&%'-%:?!<-#-8&$*/$*#8!D,*#-:-!"'-#$*$*-:!*#!D,*#/!/#'!$,-!U#*$-'!E$/$-:<"J5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

S''-?"S'/)-%'<"#LL`<"J++/9*+9(++/"K'/>+"E>&,*-f"K52*)@'*),>"',(".H8',(),>"A)2)8),+"$/',-,'*)+,'2"B8'7&<"C,"+/0-:!&F!P-J-0&75-#$?!;-&70-C!;&>-%!/#'!E7/)-?"&()*&("43"D<"B<"F&4),7;?"B&:g"B6)*%?"i+*%'/<"E--&,f"G',"h+/756<"

S'7'4&,*'?"h/&>"N<"!cc`<"_&*)/),>"),"*%&"D%)2)88),&-<".(:*#-::B&%0'?"B&8*&64&/"c?"!cc`<"

S'7'4&,*'?"h/&>"N<"!ccc<"h+2("),"J'23"K)*3<".(:*#-::B&%0'?"d7*+4&/"#L?"!ccc?"b<"S'7'4&,*'?"h/&>"N<"#LLL<"E"A)2)8),+"$+1,"),"K'2):+/,)'<".(:*#-::B&%0'?"k523"!#?"

#LLL?"b<"S'7'4&,*'?"h/&>"N<"#LL`<"F'/("$)6&-"),"E6&/)7'<".(:*#-::B&%0'?"k5,&"!`?"#LL`?"

B!pb<"S'%2&/?"B'/'%"k<"<"!cc`<"$%&+/&*)7'2"',(".68)/)7'2"K+,*/)45*)+,-"$+1'/("'"_&-&'/7%"

E>&,('":+/"$/',-,'*)+,'2)-6<"C,"+%/:#/$*&#/0*:5!F%&5!.-0&>?"&()*&("43"S<"D<"B6)*%"',("i<"h5'/,)Y+<"V&1"N/5,-1)7;f"$/',-'7*)+,<"

S','2',-',?"S'/*),<"#LLZ<"@0&2/0!P*J/:?!9*0*7*#&!@/3!6-#!*#!$,-!P*/:7&%/<"J5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

S','2',-',?"S'/*),<"#L!!<"P'31'/("./+*)7-f"S&()'*),>"x5&&/"J)'-8+/)7"_&*5/,<"C,"F&%$,)&5*#8!6-'*/C!+%/#:#/$*&#/0*:5C!/#'!A:*/#!4%&$*):?"&()*&("43"D<"S',;&;'/"',("i<"B7%&),<"J5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

S'/7&2+?"B'6',*%'"i&-2)&"i<"#LLe<"BD.KCEi"A.E$=_.g"d2(")-"),"WK+52("_D"4&"*%&",&H*"/&*)/&6&,*"%'@&,[X<".(:*#-::B&%0'?"k5,&"c?"#LLe<"

S'/>+2)-?"S'H),&"i<"!ccM<"$/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"',("D+852'/"K52*5/&f"$%&"K'-&"+:"N/'Y)2)',"C66)>/',*-"),"*%&"=,)*&("B*'*&-<"+,-!Y&(%#/0!&F!;&7(0/%!D(0$(%-"#c"W!Xf#c9b!<"

S'/;+1)*Y?"A/',?"',("E,(&/-"F<"B*&:',--+,<"#LLb<"O&5-)&5*#8:?!U#:-$$0*#8!;/$,:!&F!<-$(%#<"i',%'6?"S(<f"i&H),>*+,"N++;-<"

S&,I)@'/?"K&7)2)'g"J'G',Y+?"k52)&g"h/&&,1&22?"i)-'g"G'2(&Y?"_<"N5/7)'>'<"!cc`<"_&6)**',7&"N&%'@)+/"'6+,>"B'2@'(+/',"',("A)2)8),+"C66)>/',*-"),"i+-"E,>&2&-<""#$-%#/$*&#/0!6*8%/$*&#!<-J*->"Z#"W!Xfca9!#e<"

S&/75/)+?"D%)2)8"J+6),>5&Y<"#LLe<"C,*&/&-*),>"E-)',"E6&/)7',"45-),&--"-*'*-<";,*0*77*#-!Q->:?"B&8*&64&/"#a?"#LLe<"

Page 149: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!b#"

S),?"D3+,>"h'8<"!c`e9`a<"A)2)8),+"',("l+/&',"C66)>/',*-"),"B6'22"N5-),&--f"E"K+68'/'*)@&"E,'23-)-"A5-%/:*/!Y&(%#/0"!Z"W!XfMZ9a!<"

S)*7%&22?"l'*%'/3,&<"!cca<"J)::&/&,*"J)'-8+/'-"',("*%&"F38&"+:"F34/)()*3<"4#J*%&#5-#$!/#'!;0/##*#8!P?!E&)*-$3!/#'!E7/)-"!M"WMXfMZZ9MMZ<"

S)*7%&22?"l'*%'/3,&<"#LLb<"D%&::*#8!$,-!Q-&0*2-%/0!N*#-?!;/)*F*)!<*5!6*8%/$*&#!/#'!$,-!6-$%&7&0*:<"D%)2'(&28%)'?"DEf"$&682&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

S)Y5;'6)?"$&*-5+<"#LLa<"$%&"B+I+5/,&/"K+665,)*3f"k'8',&-&"S)>/'*)+,"',("_&-)(&,73"),"E5-*/'2)'<"N+-*+,f"N/)22<"%**8fpp111<7+2564)'<&(5p7>)94),p752p/&-+2@&[72)+a!`a#bc<"

S+226',?"B*&@&<"#LLa<"$%&"D&/:&7*"D2'7&<"+,-!B/00!E$%--$!Y&(%#/0?"E8/)2"e?"#LLa<"Sv,Y?"_'),&/?"',("_'),&/"d%2)>&/<"#LLZ<"P*/:7&%/:!/#'!4$,#*)!6*8%/#$:?!@-%5/#C!

":%/-0C!/#'!;&:$=E&J*-$!E())-::&%!E$/$-:!*#!D&57/%/$*J-!;-%:7-)$*J-<"i+,(+,f"_+5*2&(>&<"

V&--?"B'223"E,,<"#LLZ<"B,-%-!A:*/!E5*0-:?!A#!4$,#&8%/7,3!&F!;,*0*77*#-!+&(%*:5<"D%)2'(&28%)'f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"D&,,-32@',)'"D/&--<"

V&--?"B'223"E,,<"#LLM<"$+5/)-6m*&//+/)-6f"$%&"2',(-7'8),>"+:"7+,-568*)+,"',("*%&"('/;&/"-)(&"+:"82'7&<"A5-%*)/#!4$,#&0&8*:$"Z#"W!Xf!!`9!bL<"

V>')?"S'&"S<"#LLb<""57&::*20-!E(2V-)$:?!"00-8/0!A0*-#:!/#'!$,-!6/1*#8!&F!6&'-%#!A5-%*)/?";&0*$*):!/#'!:&)*-$3!*#!$>-#$*-$,=)-#$(%3!A5-%*)/<"D/),7&*+,f"D/),7&*+,"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

V)&//'-?"k')6&g"K'-',+@'?"i)2)'g"F+/,)22'?"i),('<"!cc#<"C68/+@),>"*%&"=/4',"D2',,),>"',("S','>&6&,*"D/+7&--"',("D&/:+/6',7&f"S&*/+"S',)2'<"<-8*&#/0!P-J-0&75-#$!P*/0&8(-"!Z"W!X<"

d;'65/'?"k+,'*%',"O<"!cc`<""5/8*#*#8!$,-!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#!P*/:7&%/?!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!<-0/$*&#:C!"'-#$*$*-:C!/#'!D&55(#*$*-:<"V&1"O+/;f"h'/2',("D54<"

d;'65/'?"k+,'*%',"O<"!cc`<""5/8*#*#8!$,-!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#!P*/:7&%/?!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!<-0/$*&#:C!"'-#$*$*-:C!/#'!D&55(#*$*-:?"A:*/#!A5-%*)/#:<"V&1"O+/;f"h'/2',("D54<"

d2(-?"l/)-<"#LL!<"@0&2/0*T/$*&#!/#'!U%2/#!D,/#8-?!D/7*$/0C!D(0$(%-C!/#'!;/)*F*)!<*5!6-8/=;%&V-)$:<"dH:+/(g"V&1"O+/;f"dH:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

d,>?"E)%1'<"!ccc<"90-R*20-!D*$*T-#:,*7?!+,-!D(0$(%/0!N&8*):!&F!+%/#:#/$*&#/0*$3<"J5/%'6?"VKf"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

d,>?"E)%1'<"#LLe<"V&+2)4&/'2)-6"'-".H7&8*)+,f"S5*'*)+,-"),"K)*)Y&,-%)8"',("B+@&/&)>,*3<"J5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

d,>?"E)%1'<"#LLa<"V&+2)4&/'2)-6"'-"'"S+4)2&"$&7%,+2+>3<"+%/#:/)$*&#:!&F!$,-!"#:$*$($-!&F!.%*$*:,!@-&8%/7,-%:"Z#"W!XfZ9`<"

d,)-%)?"V+/)6)*-5<"#L!L<"B),'*/'"B+,>"d:*&,"B*/);&-"J&'(23"K%+/(<"Q->!Z&%1!+*5-:?"A&45/'/3"e<"

D'//&T'-?"_%'7&2"B'2'Y'/<"#LL!<"$/',->/&--),>"*%&"V'*)+,9B*'*&f"$%&"D'/*)'2"K)*)Y&,-%)8"',("oC6'>),&("Wh2+4'2X"K+665,)*3o"+:"S)>/',*"A)2)8),'"J+6&-*)7"P+/;&/-<"E*8#:?!Y&(%#/0!&F!B&5-#!*#!D(0$(%-!k!E&)*-$3"#e"WbXf!!#c9Mb<"

D'//&T'-?"_%'7&2"B'2'Y'/?"',("i+;"K<"J<"B)5<"#LLa<"A:*/#!P*/:7&%/:?!Q->!9&%5/$*&#:C!Q->!D&#)-7$*&#:<"B*',:+/(?"K'2):<f"B*',:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

D'-75'2?".(>'/"$<"#LLZ<"O&>!$&!;%&F*$!F%&5!$,-!`_a!.*00*&#!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#!6/%1-$<"x5&Y+,"K)*3f"h)/'::&"N++;-<"

Page 150: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!bZ"

D&2+@&22+?"_+3<"#LL`<"_&*)/&6&,*"E>&,73"h&*-".H*/'"A5,7*)+,<"6/#*0/!E$/#'/%'?"A&4/5'/3"M?"#LL`<"

D+/*&-?"E2&I',(/+?"i5)-"h5'/,)Y+?"',("D'*/)7)'"i',(+2*<"!ccc<"$%&"B*5(3"+:"$/',-,'*)+,'2)-6f"D)*:'22-"',("D/+6)-&-"+:"',".6&/>&,*"B+7)'2"A)&2(<"4$,#*)!/#'!</)*/0!E$('*-:"##"W#Xf#!a9#Za<"

D+-'('-?"N'/4'/'"S<"!ccc<"+,-!9*0*7*#&!A5-%*)/#:?"+,-!#->!A5-%*)/#:!:-%*-:C<"P&-*8+/*?"K+,,<f"h/&&,1++("D/&--<"

_':'&2?"G)7&,*&"i<"#LLL<"O+5/"h/)&:"C-"d5/"h+--)8f"d@&/-&'-"A)2)8),+-"',("d*%&/"B8&7*/'2"D/&-&,7&-<"C,"B,*$-!N&J-!/#'!X$,-%!4J-#$:!*#!9*0*7*#&!O*:$&%3?"&()*&("43"G<"i<"_':'&2<"J5/%'6f"J5;&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

_':'&2?"G)7&,*&"i<"#LLZ<"$%&"K&22"D%+,&"',("*%&"K/+1(f"S&--)',)7"D+2)*)7-"),"*%&"K+,*&68+/'/3"D%)2)88),&-<";(20*)!D(0$(%-"!M"WZXfZcc9b#M<"

_&6&,,)7;?"i'/)--'<"#LLc<"A+/6&/"B+@)&*"k&1-"),"$%&)/"V&1pd2("F+6&2',(f"N&*1&&,"C,*&>/'*)+,"',("B&8'/'*)-6<"C,"P*/:7&%*)!O&5-)&5*#8:?!4$,#*)!<-$(%#!6*8%/$*&#!*#!/!D&57/%/$*J-!;-%:7-)$*J-?"&()*&("43"$<"$-5('<"B*',:+/(f"B*',:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

_&6+?"S)7%&22&<"#LLc<"_D">'),-"-')("*+"*/',-2'*&"*+"/)-&"),",564&/"+:"8++/"8&+82&"";,*0*77*#-!P/*03!"#f(*%-%?"V+@&64&/"!M?"#LLc<"

_)7%*&/?"i),('"l<"!c`#<"N/#'!<-F&%5!/#'!+&(%*:5!P-J-0&75-#$?!;&0*)3=5/1*#8!*#!$,-!;,*0*77*#-:<"K'64/)(>&f"B7%&,;6',"D54<"K+<"

_)7%*&/?"i),('"l<"!c`c<"+,-!;&0*$*):!&F!+&(%*:5!*#!A:*/<"F+,+2525f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"F'1'))"D/&--<"

_)&(&/?"i5(1)>"h<"!cca<"D%)2)88),&-f"$%&"J&@&2+86&,*"+:"D%)2)88),&"$+5/)-6"),"*%&"D+-*9S'/7+-"&/'<"C,"+&(%*:5!/#'!4)&#&5*)!P-J-0&75-#$!*#!A:*/!/#'!A(:$%/0/:*/?"&()*&("43"A<"S<"h+"',("K<"i<"k&,;),-<"i+,(+,f"K'--&22<"

_+()-?"_+(&2<"#LL`<"$%&"uA0"P+/(<"C,"A:*/#B--1<"_+(/)>5&Y?"_+43,<"#LL#<"S)>/',*"F&/+&-f"V'*)+,'2)-6?"K)*)Y&,-%)8"',("*%&"D+2)*)7-"+:"

A)2)8),+"S)>/',*"i'4+/<"D*$*T-#:,*7!E$('*-:"e"WZXfZb!9ZMe<"_+(/)>5&Y?"_+43,<"#L!L<"6*8%/#$:!F&%!4R7&%$?!O&>!$,-!;,*0*77*#-!E$/$-!.%&1-%:!N/2&%!

$&!$,-!B&%0'<"S),,&'8+2)-f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"S),,&-+*'"D/&--<"_+*%?"k+-%5'"F+*';'<"#LL#<".%&1-%-'!O&5-0/#'?!Y/7/#-:-!.%/T*0*/#!6*8%/#$:!*#!

Y/7/#<"C*%'7'f"K+/,&22"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"_+5-&?"_+>&/<"!cc!<"S&H)7',"S)>/'*)+,"',("*%&"B+7)'2"B8'7&"+:"D+-*6+(&/,)-6<"

P*/:7&%/"!"W!Xf`9#Z<"B'27&(+?"_+(/)>+?"',("E2@'/+"$+//&-<"#LLb<"h'*&("K+665,)*)&-"),"B',*)'>+f"P'22"+/"

A/+,*)&/[""#$-%#/$*&#/0!Y&(%#/0!&F!U%2/#!/#'!<-8*&#/0!<-:-/%),"#`"W!Xf#a9bb<"B'--&,?"B'-;)'<"!cce<"N&:*#8!D&#$%&0^?!E&J-%-*8#$3!*#!/#!A8-!&F!@0&2/0*T/$*&#<"V&1"

O+/;f"K+2564)'"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"B'--&,?"B'-;)'<"#LL!<"+,-!@0&2/0!D*$3?!Q->!Z&%1C!N&#'&#C!+&13&<"#,("&(<"D/),7&*+,?"

V<k<f"D/),7&*+,"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"B%'*;),?"h'@),<"#LLb<"D2',,),>"*+"A+/>&*f"C,:+/6'2"B&**2&6&,*-"'-"tA+/>+**&,"D2'7&-t"

),"h2+4'2)-),>"S&*/+"S',)2'<"U%2/#!E$('*-:"b!"W!#Xf#bec9#b`b<"B%'*;),?"h'@),<"#LL`<"$%&"K)*3"',("*%&"N+**+6"i),&f"=/4',"S&>'8/+I&7*-"',("*%&"

D/)@'*)Y'*)+,"+:"D2',,),>"),"B+5*%&'-*"E-)'<"4#J*%&#5-#$!/#'!;0/##*#8!A"bL"W#XfZ`Z9bL!<"

Page 151: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!bb"

B6)*%?"E,(/&'"i<"#LLZ<".5/+8&t-"C,@)-)42&"S)>/',*-f"K+,-&U5&,7&-"+:"*%&"K+2+,)-*-t"_&*5/,<"E6-*&/('6f"E6-*&/('6"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

B6)*%?"S)7%'&2"D<"#LL!<"+%/#:#/$*&#/0!U%2/#*:5?!N&)/$*#8!@0&2/0*T/$*&#<"S'2(&,?"S'--<f"N2'7;1&22"D542)-%&/-<"

B6)*%?"S)7%'&2"D<g"h5'/,)Y+?"i5)-<"!cc`<"+%/#:#/$*&#/0*:5!9%&5!.-0&><"V&1"N/5,-1)7;f"$/',-'7*)+,"D542)-%&/-<"

B6)*%?"V&)2<"!cce<"+,-!Q->!U%2/#!9%&#$*-%?!8-#$%*F*)/$*&#!/#'!$,-!<-J/#),*:$!D*$3<"i+,(+,g"V&1"O+/;f"_+5*2&(>&<"

B6)*%?"_+4&/*"K<"#LLZ<"J)'-8+/)7"S&64&/-%)8-"),"F)-*+/)7'2"D&/-8&7*)@&f"K+68'/'*)@&"C,-)>%*-":/+6"*%&"S&H)7',?"C*'2)',"',("D+2)-%"K'-&-<""#$-%#/$*&#/0!6*8%/$*&#!<-J*->"Za"WZXfa#b9aMc<"

B6)*%?"_+4&/*"K<"#LLe<"6-R*)/#!Q->!Z&%1?!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!N*J-:!&F!Q->!"55*8%/#$:<"N&/;&2&3f"=,)@&/-)*3"+:"K'2):+/,)'"D/&--<"

B*'7;?"K'/+2"N<"!cce<"D/00!$&!O&5-?!AF%*)/#!A5-%*)/#:!<-)0/*5!$,-!<(%/0!E&($,<"V&1"O+/;?"VOf"N'-)7N++;-<"

BY',*+,"N2',7?"K/)-*),'<"!cce<"N'2);4'3',f"E"A)2)8),+".H*&,-)+,"+:"*%&"V'*)+,'2"C6'>),'/3"',("+:"B*'*&"N+5,('/)&-<";,*0*77*#-!E&)*&0&8*)/0!<-J*->"bb"W!9bXf!a`9!cZ<"

$'()'/?"V&:&/*)"Ü),'"S<"#LLb<"9/#$/:3!;%&'()$*&#?!E-R(/0!4)&#&5*-:!/#'!X$,-%!;,*0*77*#-!D&#:-f(-#)-:!F&%!$,-!Q->!B&%0'!X%'-%<"F+,>"l+,>f"F+,>"l+,>"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

$';';)?"_+,'2(<"!cc`<"E$%/#8-%:!F%&5!/!P*FF-%-#$!E,&%-?!/!O*:$&%3!&F!A:*/#!A5-%*)/#:<"=8('*&("',("/&@<"&(<"N+-*+,f"i)**2&"N/+1,<"

$',?".(1'/("i<"#LLM<"<-/0!4:$/$-!.(3-%!;%&F*0-!/#'!.-,/J*&%?!O-07:!Z&(!U#'-%:$/#'!$,-!XJ-%:-/:!9*0*7*#&!>&%1-%:S!.(3-%!.-,/J*&%<"S',('253+,>"K)*3f"S)/'72&"D54<"

$)+,>-+,?"E,*+,)+"$<g"h5*)&//&Y?".(>'/(+"G<g"h5*)&//&Y?"_)7'/(+"G<"#LLe<";&:*$*J-03!Q&!9*0*7*#&:!A00&>-'?!.(*0'*#8!D&55(#*$*-:!/#'!P*:)&(%:-?"A:*/#!A5-%*)/#!,*:$&%3!/#'!)(0$(%-<"D%)2'(&28%)'?"D'<f"$&682&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

$n2n23',?"l%'7%)><"!cce<"_&*%),;),>"J)'-8+/'W-Xf"B*'*&2&--"D+1&/"),"*%&"$/',-,'*)+,'2"S+6&,*<"P*/:7&%/"M"W!XfZ9Ze<"

$+3+*'?"S);'<"#LLe<"E>&),>"',("*/',-,'*)+,'2"%+5-&%+2(),>f"k'8',&-&"/&*)/&&-"),"B+5*%&'-*"E-)'<""#$-%#/$*&#/0!P-J-0&75-#$!;0/##*#8!<-J*->"#`"WbXfM!M9MZ!<"

$-),>?"E,,'<"#LLL<"C,-)(&"*%&".7+,+63"+:"E88&'/',7&-<";(20*)!D(0$(%-!!#"W!Xf!!Mm!bb<"

$-5('?"$';&35;)<"#LLZ<"E$%/#8-%:!*#!$,-!4$,#*)!O&5-0/#'?!Y/7/#-:-!.%/T*0*/#!<-$(%#!6*8%/$*&#!*#!+%/#:#/$*&#/0!;-%:7-)$*J-<"V&1"O+/;f"K+2564)'"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

$-5('?"$';&35;)<"#LLc<"P*/:7&%*)!O&5-)&5*#8:?!4$,#*)!<-$(%#!6*8%/$*&#!*#!/!D&57/%/$*J-!;-%:7-)$*J-<"B*',:+/(?"K'2):<f"B*',:+/("=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"

G'-)235;?"B'-%'<"#LL`<"J'23"K)*3"A+/&72+-5/&"_'*&"F)>%&-*"),"K+5,*3<"C,"4R/5*#-%<"G&/>'/'?"N&,)*+"S','2+<"#LLc<";*#&3!)/7*$/0?!+,-!9*0*7*#&!Q/$*&#!*#!P/03!D*$3<"

D%)2'(&28%)'f"$&682&"=,)@&/-)*3"D/&--<"G&/*+@&7?"B*&@&,<"!ccc<"K+,7&)@),>"',("_&-&'/7%),>"$/',-,'*)+,'2)-6<"4$,#*)!/#'!

</)*/0!E$('*-:"##"W#Xfbba9e#<"G&/*+@&7?"B*&@&,<"#LLb<"S)>/',*"$/',-,'*)+,'2)-6"',("S+(&-"+:"$/',-:+/6'*)+,<"

"#$-%#/$*&#/0!6*8%/$*&#!<-J*->"Z`"WZXfcaL9!LL!<"

Page 152: qt1462p3k3.pdf - eScholarship

!bM"

@+,"P&**4&/>?"V)7%+2'-<"#LL`<"i&>&,("F+*&2-"P++-?"P+1-"N'2);4'3',-<"9*0A5!E$/%?"k5,&"!e9ZL?"#LL`<"

P'2(),>&/?"_+>&/<"!ccZ<"$%&".*%,)7".,72'@&"J&4'*&"_&@)-)*&(<""#$-%#/$*&#/0!Y&(%#/0!&F!U%2/#!/#'!<-8*&#/0!<-:-/%),"!a"WZXfbbb9bM#<"

P'**-?"S)7%'&2<"#LLb<"_&-+5/7&"K5/-&["h+@&/,6&,*'2)*3?"d)2"',("D+1&/"),"*%&"V)>&/"J&2*'?"V)>&/<"@-&7&0*$*):"c"W!XfML9`L<"

""


c - eScholarship

c - eScholarship

qt7pd2h1rq.pdf - eScholarship

qt7pd2h1rq.pdf - eScholarship

qt9p22n051.pdf - eScholarship

qt9p22n051.pdf - eScholarship

qt6nz7k5hw.pdf - eScholarship

qt6nz7k5hw.pdf - eScholarship

qt80z369tb_noSplash_9039f607... - eScholarship

qt80z369tb_noSplash_9039f607... - eScholarship

Download PDF - eScholarship

Download PDF - eScholarship

qt1p4898qc.pdf - eScholarship

qt1p4898qc.pdf - eScholarship

Radiation Sounds - eScholarship

Radiation Sounds - eScholarship

qt0080t60q.pdf - eScholarship

qt0080t60q.pdf - eScholarship

The Remarkables - eScholarship

The Remarkables - eScholarship

qt1s60w39f.pdf - eScholarship

qt1s60w39f.pdf - eScholarship

qt8d59b6zn.pdf - eScholarship

qt8d59b6zn.pdf - eScholarship

qt30m7g8nx.pdf - eScholarship

qt30m7g8nx.pdf - eScholarship

'" N - eScholarship

'" N - eScholarship

Research Proposal - eScholarship

Research Proposal - eScholarship

8nf603h8.pdf - eScholarship

8nf603h8.pdf - eScholarship

UC Riverside - eScholarship

UC Riverside - eScholarship

UC Irvine - eScholarship

UC Irvine - eScholarship

eu - eScholarship@McGill

eu - eScholarship@McGill

Programmed Moves - eScholarship

Programmed Moves - eScholarship