Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan - City of Oak Ridge

Americans with Disabilities Act Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan

PUBLIC REVIEW VERSION

MAY 2020

Prepared by:

Project No. 1811.0029.00

Project Support Provided by:

i

Oak Ridge, TN ADA Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan

TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Abbreviations/Acronyms ................................................................................................... iv

Executive Summary ...................................................................................................................... v

1.0 Introduction and Overview ................................................................................................. 1

1.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Purpose ................................................................................................................................................. 1 1.3 Transition Plan Overview ...................................................................................................................... 2 1.4 Legislative Background & Framework................................................................................................... 3 1.5 Facility Access versus Program Access .................................................................................................. 4 1.6 Undue Burden ....................................................................................................................................... 5 1.7 ADA Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan Requirements ....................................................................... 6 1.8 Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan Process ......................................................................................... 6 1.9 Facility Audit.......................................................................................................................................... 6 1.10 City Administration and Departments .................................................................................................. 7 1.11 Department Self-Evaluation ................................................................................................................ 11 1.12 Public Outreach ................................................................................................................................... 11

2.0 Self-Evaluation of City Policies, Services, Activities, and Programs - Findings & Recommendations .......................................................................................................... 18

2.1 Program Evaluation Interdepartmental Memo .................................................................................. 18 2.2 Overall Findings – General Policies and Practices ............................................................................... 18 2.3 Public Information .............................................................................................................................. 19 2.4 Designation of ADA Coordinator ......................................................................................................... 20 2.5 Grievance/Uniform Complaint Procedures ........................................................................................ 20 2.6 Public Meetings ................................................................................................................................... 21 2.7 Accommodations to Access Programs, Services, and Activities ......................................................... 23 2.8 Special Events and Private Events on City Property ........................................................................... 25 2.9 Ordinances, Design Standards, and Other Documents ...................................................................... 26 2.10 Contracted Services and Contractors ................................................................................................. 29 2.11 Customer Service, Satisfaction, and Input .......................................................................................... 29 2.12 Equally Effective Communication ....................................................................................................... 30 2.13 Alternate Communication Formats .................................................................................................... 34 2.14 Fees and Surcharges ........................................................................................................................... 34 2.15 Information and Signage ..................................................................................................................... 35 2.16 Staff Training ....................................................................................................................................... 35 2.17 Emergency Evacuation Procedures ..................................................................................................... 37 2.18 Employment ........................................................................................................................................ 40 2.19 Department Self-Evaluation Findings and Recommendations ........................................................... 44 2.20 Facility Self-Evaluation Findings and Recommendations.................................................................... 45

3.0 Self-Evaluation of Pedestrian Facilities within the Public ROW – Project Approach ............ 48

3.1 Data Collection and Methodology ...................................................................................................... 48 3.2 Database Analysis ............................................................................................................................... 48 3.3 Barrier Ranking .................................................................................................................................... 48 3.4 Accessible Pedestrian Signals .............................................................................................................. 49

ii


3.5 Future Improvements ......................................................................................................................... 55

4.0 Self-Evaluation of Pedestrian Facilities within the Public ROW – Sidewalk Inventory ............. 57

4.1 Pedestrian Access Route ..................................................................................................................... 57 4.2 Width .................................................................................................................................................. 57 4.3 Grade (Running Slope) ........................................................................................................................ 58 4.4 Cross Slope .......................................................................................................................................... 59 4.5 Changes in Level / Surface Condition.................................................................................................. 59 4.6 Obstructions, Protrusions, and Utility Considerations ....................................................................... 61 4.7 Overall Compliance ............................................................................................................................. 63 4.8 Sidewalk Barrier Ranking Analysis ...................................................................................................... 63

5.0 Self-Evaluation of Pedestrian Facilities within the Public ROW – Curb Ramp Inventory ......... 65

5.1 Curb Ramp Types ................................................................................................................................ 65 5.2 Ramp Width ........................................................................................................................................ 68 5.3 Ramp Running Slopes.......................................................................................................................... 68 5.4 Ramp Cross Slopes .............................................................................................................................. 69 5.5 Landings/Turning Spaces .................................................................................................................... 70 5.6 Flares ................................................................................................................................................... 71 5.7 Ramp Grade Breaks and Clear Space .................................................................................................. 72 5.8 Detectable Warnings........................................................................................................................... 73 5.9 Drainage .............................................................................................................................................. 77 5.10 Obstructions, Protrusions, Vertical Discontinuities, and Horizontal Openings .................................. 78 5.11 Overall Compliance ............................................................................................................................. 81 5.12 Curb Ramp Barrier Analysis................................................................................................................. 81

6.0 Transition Plan ................................................................................................................. 83

6.1 Phasing of Corrections ........................................................................................................................ 83 6.2 Public Outreach ................................................................................................................................... 84 6.3 Priorities for Barrier Removal ............................................................................................................. 84 6.4 Transition Plan Phasing ....................................................................................................................... 88 6.5 Plan Updates and Enforcement .......................................................................................................... 89 6.6 Summary of Transition Plan Costs ...................................................................................................... 90

7.0 ADA Tool Kit ..................................................................................................................... 91

7.1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................................ 91 7.2 Federal Accessibility Standards and Regulations ................................................................................ 91 7.3 Resources for Providing Accessible Programs & Facilities .................................................................. 95 7.4 Technical Resources ............................................................................................................................ 95

8.0 Definitions ......................................................................................................................103

iii


FIGURES

Figure 1-1 – Oak Ridge Location Map Figure 1-2 – Oak Ridge Facilities Location Map

APPENDICES

Appendix A – Building Facilities and Parks Physical Barrier Summaries Appendix B – Public Right-of-Way Facilities Summaries Appendix C – City Questionnaires Appendix D – Public Outreach Appendix E – Forms and Notices

iv


List of Abbreviations/Acronyms

AA – Affirmative Action AASHTO – American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials ABA – Architectural Barriers Act of 1968 ADA – Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 ADASAD – 2010 Americans with Disabilities Act Standards for Accessible Design CDBG – Community Development Block Grant CFR – Code of Federal Regulations D.A.R.E. – Drug Abuse Resistance EducationDOJ – U.S. Department of JusticeDOT – U.S. Department of TransportationDW – Detectable WarningsEEOC – Equal Employment Opportunity CommissionEMS – Emergency Medical ServicesFHWA – U.S. DOT Federal Highway AdministrationFTA – U.S. DOT Federal Transit AdministrationG.E.D. – General Educational Development or General Educational DiplomaGIS – Geographic Information SystemHR – Human Resources DepartmentHTML - Hyper Text Markup LanguageISA – International Symbol of AccessibilityIT – Information TechnologyMOT – Maintenance-of-TrafficNCA – National Center on AccessibilityPAR – Pedestrian Access RoutePCA – Pedestrian Circulation AreaPDF – Portable Document FormatPROWAG – 2011 Proposed Accessibility Guidelines for Pedestrian Facilities within Public Right-of-WayRA – Rehabilitation Act of 1973ROW – Right-of-WaySETP – Self-Evaluation and Transition PlanTDD – Telecommunications Devices for Deaf PersonsTDOT – Tennessee Department of TransportationTTY – TeletypewriterUFAS – Uniform Federal Accessibility Standards

v


Executive Summary

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is a comprehensive Federal civil rights statute enacted in 1990. Comprised of five major parts, or “titles”, the ADA’s stated purpose was to provide a “clear and comprehensive national mandate for the elimination of discrimination against individuals with disabilities”. It is estimated by the U.S. Census Bureau that over 50 million U.S. residents have a disability, and over 50% of senior citizens age 65 or older have a disability. Title II requires that all public entities with 50 or more employees perform a self-evaluation, prepare a transition plan, make the transition plan available for three years, publish a notice of non-discrimination, designate an ADA Coordinator, and develop a formal complaint form and grievance procedure.

The City of Oak Ridge (City) has completed a self-evaluation of all City facilities, including facilities within the public right-of-way (ROW), programs, and procedures and prepared this Transition Plan. Oak Ridge has made efforts over the years to improve accessibility, including the completion of this Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan (SETP). This Transition Plan outlines the necessary steps to become compliant with the requirements of Title II of the ADA. The City will strive to ensure that all residents and visitors are able to access all services, programs, and activities, and will promptly investigate any formal grievance filed according to the grievance procedures outlined. Additionally, the City will strive to include annual budgetary allotments to make required improvements that will eventually make the various facilities fully accessible, with emphasis given to the improvements that most impact the ability of persons with disabilities to access facilities or programs. Where access cannot be attained, an alternate means to offer the same opportunities to persons with disabilities will be provided.

In performing this self-evaluation, the City identified areas open to the public and employee common-use areas at facilities providing programs and services. These areas were assessed at the following City facilities:

City Facilities (Owned, Leased, or Hosting Programs) Municipal Building & Police Department 1010 Incubator Building Animal Shelter Badger Building Baseball Complex Central Services Civic Center/Recreation Building Fire Station 1 Fire Station 2 Fire Station 3 Fire Station 4 Centennial Golf Course Public Library Scarboro Community Center Wastewater Treatment Plant Water Filtration Plant

City Parks Alvin K. Bissell Park

Big Turtle Park Briarcliff Park Carl Yearwood Park Cedar Hill Park Elm Grove Park Elza Gate Park Groves Park at South Hills Haw Ridge Park Highland View Park LaSalle Park Melton Lake Park Milt Dickens Park Pinewood Park Municipal Swimming Pool Scarboro Park Solway Park Tennis Courts

vi


Public areas reviewed included parking lots, walks, park/site amenities, and areas within buildings that are not restricted to employees, such as restrooms, meeting spaces, reception areas, stairways, elevators, and hallways. Some buildings or areas of certain buildings have infrequent public access and were evaluated under the same guidelines. Typical employee common-use areas evaluated included break rooms, employee restrooms, locker rooms, conference rooms, etc. Spaces dedicated as employee work areas are exempt from the self-evaluation process, but that does not obviate the need of the City to ensure full accessibility is provided to employees with disabilities, consistent with the requirements of Title I of the ADA.

In addition to City facilities, the self-evaluation reviewed existing City policies and procedures within each department. The focus of this review began with distribution of a questionnaire to each department, followed by interviews or other data gathering if needed to better understand the responses or the operation of each department. Key items reviewed within each department included ADA-specific training of employees, past interaction and accommodation of persons with disabilities, review of publications produced by each department, and staff suggestions to help them accommodate persons with disabilities. Following this review, recommendations were made to improve accessibility of programs for each department.

It is the goal of the City to make facilities for all services, programs, and activities fully accessible within 30 years, though this will be largely dependent on a number of economic factors and future changes to the ADA Standards for Accessible Design (ADASAD) or other unforeseen requirements that would necessitate additional improvements to City facilities. The City has committed to provide training for staff on the requirements of the ADA and make accommodations for employees with disabilities, many of which can be done without costly architectural renovations. The Transition Plan will be reviewed and updated periodically to ensure the City is fully compliant with ADASAD standards and Title II.

The self-evaluation identified a number of architectural barriers at City facilities. The estimated cost to correct these deficiencies is over $1,314,895. In addition, approximately $912,982 in deficiencies on the greenways within the city and over $30,440,672 in pedestrian right-of-way facility deficiencies were identified based on the evaluation by LDA Engineering. In some cases, the cost of corrective action could not be defined due to additional investigation being needed that is outside the scope of an ADA self-evaluation. Investigation of structural walls, plumbing and other utilities within walls, compliance with plumbing and other codes, etc. are examples of additional investigations that might make estimating costs impossible as part of this plan. The degree to which these barriers limited accessibility and their priority for corrective action was subjectively categorized as “High”, “Medium”, or “Low”. “High” priority included barriers that effectively prohibited access to a service or program or present a safety hazard. “Medium” priority included barriers that either partially prohibited access or made it quite difficult. “Low” priority barriers typically do not limit access but are not compliant with standards. In some cases, the priority was adjusted based on the type of facility and proximity to high use areas. The improvements will be categorized into a 30-year phasing program to spread out the cost for implementation and address the most serious deficiencies at the most used City facilities. The actual implementation schedule, budgeting, and prioritization is up to the administration and is likely to be impacted by complaints, new regulations and requirements, and availability of funding. Note that these costs are to resolve accessibility issues by making architectural improvements and in many instances, there are procedural changes or other modifications that can be made to provide equal access to City programs. Additions and some modifications are not required until renovations are completed. These modifications are noted within this report.

vii


The statements and findings contained in this Transition Plan and supporting information are the opinion of DLZ based on our knowledge and interpretation of ADA requirements. Nothing in this document should be considered as legal advice. Clients are urged to seek appropriate legal assistance as needed on ADA issues.

1


1.0 Introduction and Overview

1.1 Introduction

The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA), enacted on July 26, 1990, is a Federal civil rights statute, under the jurisdiction of the United States Department of Justice (DOJ), which provides civil rights protection to qualified individuals with disabilities in the areas of employment, public accommodations, state and local government services, transportation, and telecommunications. The DOJ is the lead agency that oversees the ADA. The ADA itself is not enforceable by any state or local governmental unit code official. The law states its purpose is “to provide a clear and comprehensive national mandate for the elimination of discrimination against individuals with disabilities”. Similar protections are provided by Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. The ADA was signed into law by President George Bush on July 26, 1990, extending civil rights protections to individuals with physical or mental disabilities in the following areas:

1. Title I – Employment (all Title II employers and employers with 15 or more employees)2. Title II – Public Services (state and local government, including public school districts and public

transportation)3. Title III – Public Accommodations and Services operated by Private Entities4. Title IV – Telecommunications5. Title V – Miscellaneous

Oak Ridge is located in east-central Tennessee (Figure 1-1) in both Roane and Anderson County, approximately 25 miles west of Knoxville. The City had a population of approximately 29,330 at the 2010 Census and contains a total land area of approximately 90 square miles. The City is governed by a modified City Manager-Council form of government. It is classified as a “public entity” pursuant to Title II of the ADA. The City is also required to comply with Title I, which requires state and local government entities to practice nondiscrimination in all parts of the employment process.

1.2 Purpose

Federal Regulations (CFR) is the codification of the general and permanent rules published in the Federal Register by the executive departments and agencies of the Federal government. It is divided into 50 titles that represent broad areas subject to Federal regulation. Each volume of the CFR is updated once each calendar year and is issued on a quarterly basis.

Relative to the ADA on July 26, 1990, the DOJ issued rules implementing Title II, which is codified at 28 CFR Part 35, which applies to Oak Ridge. Title II requires state and local governments to make their programs and services accessible to persons with disabilities. This requirement extends not only to physical access at

Figure 1-1 – City of Oak Ridge Location Map

Roane County

Anderson County

Morgan County

Loudon County

Knox County

2


government facilities, programs, and events, but also to policy changes that state and local governmental entities must make to ensure that all people with disabilities can take part in, and benefit from, the programs and services of state and local governments.

The ADA regulations [ref. U.S. DOJ, 28 CFR Part 35, Subpart A, 35.105 and 35.150(a) and (d)] require state and local governments to conduct a self-evaluation of their programs and services to identify barriers to access. One of the fundamental reasons for performing the self-evaluation is to identify potential problems before they occur, so that discrimination complaints won’t be necessary. By identifying the policies, programs, services, and activities that do not comply, the City can take action to remove those barriers to ensure that the City is not discriminating against individuals with disabilities. Title II of the ADA stipulates that Oak Ridge is required to perform six administrative responsibilities:

1. Publicize the name and contact information of thedesignated ADA Coordinator responsible to overseecompliance [28 CFR 35.107 (a)]

2. Administer and write a self-evaluation of theprogrammatic barriers in services offered by the localgovernment and provide an opportunity to interestedpersons, including individuals with disabilities ororganizations representing individuals with disabilities,to participate in the self-evaluation process bysubmitting comments [28 CFR 35.105]

3. Publicize and inform applicants, participants, andbeneficiaries of the City’s policy of nondiscriminationon the basis of disability related to City services,programs, and activities [28 CFR 35.106]

4. Establish a complaint/grievance procedure to respondto complaints of noncompliance from the public [28CFR 35.107 (b)]

5. Develop a transition plan if structural changes arenecessary for achieving program accessibility [28 CFR35.150 (a) and (d)]

6. Retain the self-evaluation and provide it for publicinspection for three years [28 CFR 35.105 (c)]

The City is committed to complying with the tenets of Title II of the ADA of 1990, and other Federal and state statutes and regulations intended to make City-owned and operated facilities, programs, services, and activities accessible to persons with disabilities. This ADA Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan (SETP) establishes a new benchmark for compliance with ADA and identifies a plan to remove barriers.

1.3 Transition Plan Overview

The City of Oak Ridge became aware of the need to be in full compliance with the requirements of the ADA by the Tennessee Department of Transportation (TDOT), who sent letters to all local public agencies requiring them to have a compliant ADA Transition Plan to remain eligible for federal funding. The City responded by contracting in summer 2018 with LDA Engineering, Inc., and sub-consultant DLZ National, Inc., to assist in preparing a SETP.

3


A work plan to assess City-owned and operated facilities, programs, policies, services, and activities for compliance with ADA was initiated to complete the ADA SETP. Facility audits were performed only in those areas open to the public for this project, along with employee common-use areas. Other areas within City-owned facilities that are not accessible to the public must also be accessible for employees with disabilities as a requirement of Title I. Accessibility in employee work areas will be assessed on a case-by-case basis based on the needs of the individual and nature of their disability. The City is committed to ensuring that all workspaces are accessible pursuant to the requirements of each job and making the necessary modifications and reasonable accommodations when needed for a disabled employee to perform essential job functions. City pedestrian facilities within the public City right-of-way (ROW) were included.

All the recommendations in this plan for structural or programmatic solutions to facilitate the opportunity of access to all individuals are subject to review, revision, and approval of the City Council and appropriation of funding to implement the improvements. These recommendations are intended to serve as the transition plan and framework for implementation.

This transition plan is an on-going, dynamic document that will need periodic review and updating. In particular, additional evaluations will be required when updates are made to the ADA or supporting statutes, existing accessibility guidelines change, or new guidelines are established. In its efforts to maintain compliance, the City has several mechanisms in place to provide for an ongoing update of the transition plan:

Designated ADA Coordinator is empowered with oversight responsibility for implementation of therequirements of the ADA.

Implementation activities will be part of the City’s annual Capital Improvement Plan.

1.4 Legislative Background & Framework

For more than 40 years, Oak Ridge has been subject to many of the non-discrimination provisions contained in the ADA. Significant precursory legislation to the ADA includes the Architectural Barriers Act of 1968 (ABA) and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (RA).

Congress’ first significant effort to address discrimination on the basis of disability was its enactment of the ABA, which provided that all buildings constructed, altered, leased, or financed by the U.S. Government shall be accessible to, and usable by, individuals with physical disabilities.

Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act states: “No otherwise qualified individual with a disability in the United States shall, solely by reason of his disability, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance or under any program or activity conducted by any Executive Agency”. It also requires Federal agencies to provide accessible programs and facilities.

The ADA was effective on January 26, 1992, and modeled after Section 504. The ADA applies to state and local government entities, public accommodations, public transportation, and commercial establishments. The key points of understanding for ADA are:

The ADA is fundamentally civil rights legislation. This legislation protects the rights of people withdisabilities in employment, transportation, public accommodation, and access to services offered to thepublic.

4


The ADA addresses facility access and access to programs and services. Buildings are required to beaccessible and the activities that are offered inside and outside those buildings also must be accessible.

Outdoor recreation standards as they relate to ADA for a variety of facilities were included in the 2010ADA Standards for Accessible Design (ADASAD). Standards for amusement rides, boating and fishingfacilities, exercise machines and equipment, golf and miniature golf facilities, play areas, andswimming/wading pools and spas went into effect on March 15, 2012 for all new or altered facilities.

The primary focus of this report is to assess the compliance of Oak Ridge facilities, programs, policies, services, and activities related to Title II of the ADA.

Governmental entities must ensure effective communication, including the provision of necessary auxiliary aids and services, so that individuals with disabilities can participate in civic functions. Public entities are not required to take actions that would result in undue financial and administrative burdens. However, they are required to make reasonable modifications to policies, practices, and procedures where necessary to avoid discrimination, unless they can demonstrate that doing so would fundamentally alter the nature of the service, program, or activity being provided.

One important way to ensure that Title II's requirements are being met in communities of all sizes is through self-evaluation, which is required by the ADA regulations. Self-evaluation enables local governments to pinpoint the facilities, programs, and services that must be modified or relocated to ensure that local governments are complying with Title II requirements of the ADA. A public entity that employs 50 or more employees must retain its self-evaluation for a minimum of three (3) years.

1.5 Facility Access versus Program Access

The ADA addresses two types of accessibility:

Facility accessibility Program accessibility

Facility accessibility requires that a building or structure be physically accessible. Individuals with disabilities cannot be provided access to programs, services, and activities if a building is inaccessible. Program accessibility includes facility accessibility, but also means that a person with a qualified disability receives the same benefits from a program or service and has an equal opportunity to participate as any other participant. The ADA requires all City programs, but not all City buildings, to be accessible. The regulation implementing Title II, 28 CFR Part 35 (as amended September 15, 2010) contain two “safe harbor” provisions. Under the first “safe harbor” provision, elements of existing facilities that already comply with either the 1991 ADA Standards or Uniform Federal Accessibility Standards (UFAS) are not required to comply with the 2010 ADA Standards unless they were altered on or after March 15, 2012. Under the second “safe harbor” provision elements comprising a path of travel to an altered primary function area are not required to comply with the 2010 ADA Standard merely as the result of an alteration to a primary function area, provided those elements comply with the 1991 ADA Standard or UFAS.

There is some flexibility with regard to program accessibility. Not every building (or each part of every building) needs to be accessible. Structural modifications are required only when there is no alternative available for providing program access.

The City is required to provide program access, which means that programs, services, and activities when viewed in their entirety, are readily accessible to and usable by individuals with disabilities. When choosing a

5


method of providing program access, the City will give priority to the one that results in the most integrated setting appropriate to encourage interaction among all users, including individuals with disabilities. In accordance with Title II program accessibility requirements, the City is required to:

Provide equal access to programs, services, and activities as provided to other members of thecommunity. [28 CFR 35.130(a)-(b)(1) (vii)]

Provide programs, services and activities in an integrated setting, unless separate or different measuresare necessary to ensure equal opportunity. [28 CFR 35.130(b)(2); (d)]

Absorb any costs necessary to ensure nondiscriminatory treatment, such as making modificationsrequired to provide program accessibility or providing qualified interpreters. [28 CFR 35.130(f)]

Allow a person with a disability to participate in a program, service or activity regardless of disability. [28CFR 35.130(g)]

Eliminate unnecessary eligibility standards or rules that deny individuals with disabilities an equalopportunity to enjoy programs, services or activities unless necessary for the provisions of the program,service or activity. [28 CFR 35.130(b)(8)]

Modify policies, practices, or procedures that deny equal access to individuals with disabilities [28 CFR35.130(b)(7)]

Furnish auxiliary aids and services when necessary to ensure effective communication. [28 CFR35.160(b)(1)-(2)]

Provide appropriate signage and structural communication to inform and alert individuals with visual,mobility, and hearing disabilities. [28 CFR 35.163]

Eliminate physical barriers to programs, services, and activities by remodeling existing facilities,constructing new facilities, or moving programs, services or activities to an accessible location. [28 CFR35.150(b)(1)]

Ensure that newly constructed or altered buildings and facilities are free of physical and communicationbarriers that restrict accessibility of people with disabilities. [28 CFR 35.151]

1.6 Undue Burden

The City does not have to take any action that it can demonstrate would result in a fundamental alteration in the nature of a program or activity, would create a hazardous condition for other people, or would represent an undue financial and administrative burden. A fundamental alteration is a change to such a degree that the original program, service, or activity is no longer the same. For example, assume that a community sponsors college-level classes that may be used toward a college degree. To be eligible to enroll, an individual must have either a high school diploma or a General Educational Development certificate (“G.E.D”). If someone lacks a diploma or G.E.D. because of a cognitive disability, it is unlikely that the community would have to alter the requirement to provide equal access. Modifying the rule would change the class from college level to something less than college level and would fundamentally alter the original nature of the class.

The determination that an undue financial burden would result must be based on an evaluation of all resources available for use in a program. For example, if a barrier removal action is judged unduly burdensome, the City must consider other options for providing access that would ensure that individuals with disabilities receive the benefits and services of the program or activity.

6


1.7 ADA Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan Requirements

The purpose of this ADA SETP is to document the City’s review of access to facilities, programs, services, and activities by individuals with disabilities in order to determine if there are any discriminatory or potentially discriminatory practices, policies, or procedures.

In accordance with the Title II requirements for self-evaluation, the City:

1) Identified all the public entity's programs, activities, and services. [28 CFR 35.105(a)]2) Reviewed all the policies and practices that govern the administration of the City's programs, activities,

and services. [28 CFR 35.105(a)]

If structural changes are identified to provide program accessibility as part of the self-evaluation, the ADA identifies specific elements to be included in the transition plan. At a minimum, the elements of the transition plan are:

1) A list of the physical barriers in the City’s facilities that limit the accessibility of its programs, activities, orservices to individuals with disabilities. [28 CFR 35.150 (d)(3)(i)]

2) A detailed outline of the methods to be utilized to remove these barriers and make the facilitiesaccessible. [28 CFR 35.150 (d)(3)(ii)]

3) The schedule for taking the necessary steps to achieve compliance with Title II of the ADA. If the timeperiod for achieving compliance is longer than one year, the plan should identify the interim steps thatwill be taken during each year of the transition period. [28 CFR 35.150 (d)(3)(iii)]

4) The name of the official responsible for the plan's implementation. [28 CFR 35.150 (d)(3)(iv)]

1.8 Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan Process

A work plan and method to assess City-owned and operated facilities, programs, policies, services, and activities for compliance with the ADA was implemented to complete the ADA SETP. This work plan included:

Facility audits (interior and exterior) Self-evaluation of City programs, services, and activities Public outreach to advocacy groups Facilitate designating an ADA Coordinator Develop grievance procedures Identify required/suggested training for City staff Prioritize facilities improvements for accessibility Develop transition plan Public involvement Adoption

Recommendations are intended to serve as the transition plan and framework for implementation. All the recommendations in this plan for structural or programmatic solutions to facilitate the opportunity of access to all individuals are subject to review, revision, and approval of the City Council.

1.9 Facility Audit

In 2018 and 2019, audits of building and facility interiors, exterior site features, and facilities within the public ROW were performed. These audits included only those areas of each facility that are open to the public and employee common-use areas. This review identified physical and architectural barriers and provided

7


recommendations to comply with Federal accessibility requirements. The locations of City facilities and parks (by number) are shown on Figure 1-2, addresses for each can be found in the appendix.

Photographs of architectural and site conditions at the time of the inspection for all building amenities were taken for the record. The specific site and architectural improvements recommended to remove barriers and improve accessibility are listed in the appendices.

1.10 City Administration and Departments

There are several distinct departments that provide City services, programs, and activities that are available to the public. The level of interaction of each Department is classified as extensive (high numbers daily), regular (variable but generally low numbers daily to weekly), limited (generally weekly or less), or none. These Departments and descriptions of their functions and types and regularity of interaction with the public are:

City Manager (200 S. Tulane Avenue) – The City Charter establishes the City Manager as the chiefexecutive officer of the City. The City Manager is appointed by and serves at the pleasure of City Council.The City Manager is responsible for planning, organizing, directing, controlling, and evaluating theoperations of the municipal government in order to implement Council policies in an effective, andeconomic manner. In carrying out these responsibilities, the Manager advises and initiates Council-determined policy, oversees the enforcement of all ordinances and state-mandated requirements,appoints and removes department heads and employees, provides supervision over all departments,prepares and recommends annual operating and capital improvement budgets, recommends legislationthat appears necessary and desirable, advises Council of the financial conditions and future needs of the

5 6

7

1 – Municipal Building/Police 2 – Incubator Building 3 – Animal Shelter 4 – Badger Building 5 – Baseball Complex 6 – Central Services 7 – Civic Center/Recreation 8 – Fire Station 1 9 – Fire Station 2 10 – Fire Station 3 11 – Fire Station 4 12 – Centennial Golf Course 13 – Public Library 14 – Scarboro Community Ctr 15 – Wastewater Treatment 16 – Water Filtration 17 – Bissell Park 18 – Big Turtle Park 19 – Briarcliff Park 20 – Carl Yearwood Park 21 – Cedar Hill Park 22 – Elm Grove Park 23 – Elza Gate Park 24 – Groves Park 25 – Haw Ridge Park 26 – Highland View Park 27 – LaSalle Park 28 – Melton Lake Park 29 – Milt Dickens Park 30 – Pinewood Park 31 – Municipal Pool 32 – Scarboro Park 33 – Solway Park 34 – Tennis Courts

3

1

2

4 7

Figure 1-2. Oak Ridge Facilities Location Map.

11

13 17

31

18 15

8

27

26

24

14 32 16

6 5 10

23 29

28

12

25

33

22

9 34

30 20 19

21

8


City, and represents the City with the public, the press, and other governmental and private agencies. Within the City Manager’s Office is Government Affairs & Information Services. Interaction with the public is extensive.

Animal Shelter (395 Belgrade Road) – Animal control is a division of the police department. Currently,the City of Oak Ridge has 4 full-time certified Animal Control Officers. Animal Control is responsible foranimal welfare related issues in the field and daily operations of the Oak Ridge Animal Shelter.Interaction with the public is extensive.

City Clerk (200 S. Tulane Avenue) – The Clerk's Office is the City of Oak Ridge's information sourceregarding all of its legislative actions and many other areas of citizen interest and concern. The City Clerkserves as administrator of the City Council's legislative actions and is the designated custodian of thegoverning authority's legislative record. The general areas of legislative action by the Oak Ridge CityCouncil are matters pertaining to city utilities, community development and human resources, cityadministration, financial and executive actions, public safety and legal administration, transportation andzoning affairs. Ordinances, resolutions with supporting documentation, reports, communications, andCouncil meeting minutes, agendas and videotapes of proceedings are processed and maintained by theCity Clerk's Office. As custodian of the City's legislative record, the City Clerk publishes and maintains theCity of Oak Ridge Charter and Code of Ordinances. Interaction with the public is extensive.

City Court (200 S. Tulane Avenue) – City Court has jurisdiction within Oak Ridge over cases involvingviolations of city ordinances. The courtroom is located in the Municipal Building and the City Court Clerk'sOffice is adjacent to the courtroom. The City Court Clerk's Office records and maintains permanentrecords of cases that come before City Court. The City Court Clerk's Office also receive monies for finesand costs. Interaction with the public is extensive.

Community Development (200 S. Tulane Avenue) – Community Development is responsible forcoordinating the City's planning and code enforcement functions, while focusing on sustainability andquality of life issues. The department oversees the zoning ordinance, subdivision regulations, signregulations, planned unit developments (PUDs), and site plan reviews. Community Development alsoprocesses rezoning and permitting requests. The Department staff consists of 10 employees who alsoprovide support to several other boards and commissions and also administers the CommunityDevelopment Block Grant Program (CDBG). The CDBG program is a federal program with the objective ofimproving communities by providing decent housing, a suitable living environment, and expandingeconomic opportunities, principally for persons of low and moderate income. The City of Oak Ridge is anentitlement jurisdiction receiving an annual allocation of CDBG funds from HUD. Interaction with thepublic is extensive.

Economic Development (200 S. Tulane Avenue) – The City of Oak Ridge supports economic developmentactivities by utilizing the expertise of city staff, partner organizations directly involved with economicdevelopment, and elected officials. Partner organizations receiving staff and financial support from theCity include the Oak Ridge Chamber of Commerce, Convention and Visitors Bureau, Knoxville-Oak RidgeInnovation Valley of East Tennessee, Anderson County Economic Development Association, and TheRoane Alliance. Interaction with the public is regular.

Electric Department (100 Woodbury Lane) and Electric Business Office (200 S. Tulane Avenue) – TheCity of Oak Ridge Electric Department provides a variety of services within Oak Ridge related to theprovision of electricity to residents and businesses. The services include engineering, maintenance,education, safety, and bill payment. Interaction with the public is extensive.

Finance (200 S. Tulane Avenue) – The Finance Department is responsible for City-wide accounting andfinancial functions. This includes preparation of the City's annual statements and budget documents,biennial utility rate reviews, financial analysis, coordinating long-term debt issuances, and administering

9


the City's cash management program and investing funds accordingly. The department is responsible for the establishment of City internal controls and recording all City financial transactions in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP). The Finance Department also provides centralized control over the procurement, storage and distribution of all materials, supplies and service required for City operations, serves as the centralized accounting service for the Public Works and Electric Departments, and is responsible for paying all City obligations. Interaction with the public is regular.

Fire Department (200 S. Tulane Avenue) – The City of Oak Ridge Fire Department is responsible for theprotection of life and property against fire and other emergencies. These duties are furthered byconducting fire prevention activities including building plan reviews, fire code enforcement, and publiceducation programs which encourage the installation of smoke detectors and fire suppression systems inall residential and commercial buildings. The headquarters are at the City Municipal Building, with 4satellite stations scattered throughout the city. Interaction with the public is regular.

Legal (200 S. Tulane Avenue) – The Legal Department provides legal guidance to ensure that all Cityfunctions are conducted in accordance with applicable laws and regulations and to protect the interestsof the City through the preparation of sound ordinances, contracts, and other official documents, as wellas the successful prosecution and defense of lawsuits. The City Attorney is hired directly by City Counciland serves pursuant to a contract approved by City Council. The City Attorney and Senior Staff Attorneyare both full-time members of the City's staff. Their duties include the preparation, review, andinterpretation of ordinances, resolutions, and contracts; the provision of legal support to the CityManager, staff, and boards and commissions; and the management of any litigation in which the City maybe involved. Some legal services are provided by outside attorneys, including certain areas of litigationand liability issues handled by the City's insurance carrier. Interaction with the public is limited.

Library (1401 Oak Ridge Turnpike) – The library provides a variety of services to the community,including providing books, music, magazines, audiobooks, and videos for checkout, children’s story time,internet services and computers, online tutorials, historical documents, space rental for meetings, andmore. Interaction with the public is extensive.

Personnel (200 S. Tulane Avenue) – The Personnel Department coordinates personnel management forall City departments. Services include recruitment and retention of employees, maintenance of theclassification plan, coordination of the merit system, performance evaluations, and compensation plan,coordination of training and development, managing employee benefits, and providing support to thePersonnel Advisory Board. The Personnel Department is also responsible for administering the City’s RiskManagement Program, Employee Safety Program and all insurance coverage. This department isresponsible for managing the risks of the City in order to minimize the loss of physical, financial andhuman resources; including management of exposure and accidents, acts of nature, liability, theft andvandalism, and safety and employee health. The Personnel Advisory Board assists in representing thepublic interest in the improvement of personnel administration in the City service. The Board, uponrequest of the City Council or the City Manager or upon its’ own initiative, will have the responsibility ofproviding advice and counsel on all aspects of public personnel administration including, but not limitedto: training, position classification, employee salaries, all aspects of the merit system, overall personnelplan, and related rules and revisions. The Board shall also investigate complaints made in accordancewith the established grievance procedure. Interaction with the public is extensive.

Police (200 S. Tulane Avenue) – The Oak Ridge Police Department provides administrative, patrol, andinvestigative services as the law enforcement agency for Oak Ridge. The Patrol Division is the spearheadof the Oak Ridge Police Department in its mission to reduce the incidence and fear of crime and toenhance public safety for the citizens, businesses, and visitors of Oak Ridge. Tasked with making the Cityof Oak Ridge a safe place to live, work, and visit, the Patrol Division’s 40 patrol officers and supervisorsmaintain peace and order by conducting crime prevention and suppression patrols, traffic safety

10


enforcement, and community relations in the city’s neighborhoods and business corridors. Officers in the Patrol Division are all Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) certified and cross-trained for additional duties. The Criminal Investigations Division (CID) of the Oak Ridge Police Department consists of specially trained officers (Detectives) who are generally assigned to investigate alleged, specific crimes, including murder, rape, robbery, burglaries and major thefts (over $5,000.00). The division increases resources for all major crimes to gather further leads and information in an effort to make timely arrests. The CID maintains constructive working partnerships with the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), United States District Attorney General’s Office and other state and local agencies, as well as other City departments. As well as investigating and monitoring criminal activity, the Criminal Investigations Division is also called upon to conduct Internal Investigations of our own officers to maintain public confidence of our agency, therefore adding to open communications and transparency. Interaction with the public is extensive.

Public Works (100 Woodbury Lane) – The Public Works Department is responsible for the maintenanceof City streets, water and wastewater treatment plants, water distribution system, wastewater collectionsystem, and City-owned buildings; for the construction of and improvements to these facilities; and formaintenance, service and repair of all City automotive vehicles, heavy equipment and stationaryequipment. The Department also prepares and administers the Solid Waste Collection Contract andserves as the City staff representatives on the Traffic Safety Advisory Board. The Department consists of98 employees in the following divisions, which have limited interaction with the public overall:

1) Administration – ensures the provision of an acceptable level of physical services, to provide generalsupervision of Public Works programs, ensure implementation of these programs through effectiveand efficient management, and coordinate extraordinary maintenance improvements to the City'sphysical assets

2) Engineering – oversees the design and construction of various municipal infrastructure and utilityimprovements within the City. These include capital projects initiated by the City and portions ofprojects built for City ownership by private developers.

3) Wastewater Treatment – The primary purpose of the Wastewater Treatment Plant (WTTP) isprotecting the health and well-being of our community. The City operates two (2) wastewatertreatment plants that are staffed 365 days a year. These wastewater treatment plants treat acombined flow of 5.6 million gallons of wastewater per day for a total of 2.1 billion gallons per year.The operators perform daily operations of the main wastewater plant and the Rarity Ridgewastewater plant.

4) Water Treatment – The United States Department of Energy (DOE) owned and operated a potablewater treatment plant at its Y-12 facility that sold water to the City of Oak Ridge for distribution toOak Ridge residents and businesses. On May 1, 2000, ownership of the water treatment facility wastransferred to the City of Oak Ridge. The City owns and operates the water distribution system.Public Works Department water plant and operations employees are charged with maintaining thesystem and ensuring a safe and sufficient supply of water will be delivered to its customers.

5) Equipment and Fleet Maintenance – the Equipment Maintenance and Fleet Management Division isresponsible for maintenance, service and repair of all City automotive vehicles, heavy equipment andstationary equipment. The Equipment Shop personnel are responsible for maintaining the City fleet,which is quite large. It consists of approximately 60 sedans, 70 light trucks, 65 heavy trucks includingfire apparatus, ambulances and electrical department line trucks, and over 300 various light andheavy equipment pieces. The mechanics also perform routine maintenance of the fueling station,emergency generators, and security gates at the Central Services Complex. Each Fleet MaintenanceTechnician has their own specialties, but can perform work on all types of equipment ranging fromlawn mowers and chain saws to heavy construction equipment.

6) Operations – the Operations Division is responsible for General Maintenance, City StreetMaintenance, Water Distribution System, Wastewater System, and State Highway Maintenance.

11


7) Building Maintenance Division – is responsible for the maintenance of all City-owned buildings.

Recreation & Parks Department (1403 Oak Ridge Turnpike) – The Oak Ridge Civic Center, built in 1970, isa 39,242 square feet building consisting of 2 large meeting room, 2 small meeting rooms, and a full sizegymnasium. The building is situated near the city center in a 41-acre park area. The facility is available forrental for business as well as personal events. The gym is available for free play basketball as use permits.There is also an indoor pool that is open for public use on a varying schedule and an outdoor pavilion thatis used for concerts and other events. The department also offers a variety of programs and activities atthe Scarboro Community Center, Senior Center, and numerous parks scattered throughout the city.Interaction with the public is extensive.

1.11 Department Self-Evaluation

As part of this self-evaluation, DLZ provided a questionnaire to the ADA Coordinator in order to better understand the operation and services offered by various City departments regarding ADA compliance. A blank questionnaire is in Appendix C. Responses provided by each department were used to compile the information in this SETP. Policies, programs, activities, and services were evaluated, and in the case where policies are not currently in place, this report provides recommendations for the implementation of corrective actions to comply with the ADA. Refer to Section 2.19 Department Self-Evaluation - Findings & Recommendations.

1.12 Public Outreach

Public outreach began by sending notices by U.S. mail to several local and regional disability advocacy groups (see Appendix D). In addition, an online survey posted on the home page of the City’s website was provided to solicit input from the public and business owners. The online survey was open from May 2019 to February 2020, with all responses being anonymous to ensure full transparency for the respondents to provide any comment they desired. The online survey was hosted on the City’s website, with a direct link provided. A total of 31 responses were provided by the public, and the results are below. Some comments provided information about non-City facilities or other issues not under the control of the City. Comments deemed to be relevant and which were considered in the Transition Plan have been highlighted. Some minor spelling errors have been corrected in the comments to provide clarity about the response in this document and personal information of respondents (names, phone numbers, email, etc.) has been redacted if included in responses. Response ratio for questions that allowed multiple selections by responders may not total 100%.

Constant Contact Survey Results Survey Name: City of Oak Ridge ADA Survey

1. What is your association with the City of Oak Ridge? Check all that apply.# Response(s) Response Ratio

Resident 25 86.2% Business Owner 1 3.4% Work in Oak Ridge 8 27.5% Visitor/tourist 1 3.4% None of the above 1 3.4% 2. Do you or a family member have a disability?

# Response(s) Response Ratio Yes (please describe below) 14 45.1% No (please continue with survey) 15 48.3% No Responses 2 6.4%

12


14 Comment(s) - COPD and use mobility scooter.- Son with TBI.- Son is mentally and physically disabled. He cannot work and is under doctor's care. He resides at xxx xxxxxxxxxx,

Oak Ridge, TN. He receives no income at this time.- My dad has problems with mobility due to bad hips and knees from military. He also has dementia.- Autism, physical disability- I have both a mental and physical disability. I have been in recovery from my mental disability for around 20 years. I

have given numerous talks to Officers in the CIT program about my mental illness. I lost my left leg above the kneea little over 3 yrs ago. I am confined to a wheelchair.

- Family member and myself- My Aunt was but is now deceased. My uncle is confined to a wheelchair as is a close family friend.- Family member and self.- Deaf- bad hips- Not yet, but I will.- hit by car, strokes, TIA's- C6 incomplete quadriplegic using a manual wheelchair for mobility

3. Have you, a family member, or someone you know encountered any difficulties accessing cityfacilities or programs due to the disability?

# Response(s) Response Ratio Yes (please describe below) 15 48.3% No 13 41.9% No Responses 3 9.6% 14 Comment(s) - Broken and uneven sidewalk.- My dad cannot attend the football games because he cannot go down or up the stairs to sit down and has to bring

his own chair but there are tents there so he can't usually come. The energy solutions field doesn't have a rampthey only have stairs and it floods too much. So my dad cannot come to watch my son practice or play soccer there.

- Yes, no sidewalks leading to benches, bleachers. No sidewalks leading to restrooms or port-o-potties. Also, port-o-potties not being handicap accessible for a wheelchair.

- I have had friends unable access certain parts of city buildings, the police dept to get a report for example. Myfriends and I both have had difficulties with sidewalks. No ramps just can't get on the sidewalks sometimes you ride and sidewalk ends with no way to get off. Sometimes mud on sidewalk will side you off into really soggy land where you bury in the mud. If you can find a sidewalk you can get ...But I have so much more to say. Most crosswalk buttons are out of the reach of. branches cars

- Sometimes you have to go all over the place just to get to where you need to go.- No access to getting on sidewalks. Sidewalks end into grass so not fully wheelchair accessible. No way to push

buttons to crossroads.- We have sidewalks in disrepair, vehicles or shrubbery intruding on sidewalks, crosswalk buttons that cannot be

reached by persons in wheelchairs and do not lend enough time to cross before the light changes. - The police dept to pick up a report.- No accessibility to communication due no sign language interpreters.- Steps are always a problem. People parking in handicapped spaces when they're not handicapped.- I have seen people not be able to get into places in Oak Ridge because they are not accessible. They have to wait

for people to open doors for them and sometimes that takes a while or does not happen at all.- unable to access the pavilion, in the woods, in AK Bissell park and other places- I went to the egg hunt at the civic center a few years back and had trouble on the looping trail. The aggregate was

sometimes loose making it hard to get back to the Civil Center from the field.- Person who is blind is not able to walk to church with her guide-dog because there is no crossing and sidewalk

available.

4. Have you, a family member, or someone you know had difficulty accessing city parks or programsoffered at city parks?

# Response(s) Response Ratio Yes (please describe below) 9 29.0% No 19 61.2% No Responses 3 9.6%

13


8 Comment(s) - My dad cannot attend the football games because he cannot go down or up the stairs to sit down and has to bring

his own chair but there are tents there so he can't usually come. Also, the energy solutions field doesn't have aramp they only have stairs and it floods too much. So my dad cannot come to watch my son practice or play soccer there.

- No access down to sitting area at Soccer Fields. Steps only, no ramp. We had to sit with a handicap spectator in theparking lot of traffic so they could watch a game. Help monitor traffic so they wouldn't get it.

- Even if you can get to the park. It might be too muddy to join in activities. It seems as if you are always standing(sitting) on the edge.

- Not all parks are able to reach in wheelchair or kids cannot play if in wheelchair. Abingdon Virginia has an amazingpark designed for kids with different abilities.

- See comments in 3- Rocky and gravel path behind civic center. Festival there is 90 percent inaccessible.- I have seen no accommodations made by the city about this. All they seem to care about are Mexican and Chinese

restaurants. I have bad knees and a bad ankle, and I am not that old. It will not be long before I am disabled myself.Unfortunately, I will still be here.

- see above

5. Are there specific accessibility barriers you believe need to be addressed immediately by the city?# Response(s) Response Ratio

Yes (please describe below) 19 61.2% No 8 25.8% No Responses 4 12.9% 21 Comment(s) - Easier access at city hall for those with disabilities. Locations that are more clearly defined inside and outside of the

building. - Sidewalk at Central Ave., next to Jackson Plaza needs to be fixed. Caused ambulance ride to the hospital for

stitches on 6/16/19 leaving Lavender festival. Broken sidewalk tripped my mobility scooter and tossed me into theroad.

- Sidewalk connectivity and repairs- Kudzu is overrunning the yard located at my son's residence at xxx N Hollywood Circle. He is unable to maintain

yard work due to his disability.- ALL stalls in public places (stores, etc.) need to be larger to accommodate larger patrons and those with small

children. Currently it is impossible for this category of residents and visitors to use anything but the handicappedstalls in these places.

- Put a ramp in at both the orhs football field and the energy solutions field because I'm sure I'm not the only familywith this barrier and the football field is being renovated so it's the perfect time to do so!

- Speaking of soccer and softball fields. Sidewalks leading to restrooms, port-o-potties, handicap accessible port-o-potties, ramps leading down to field vs steps only.

- Intersections at Lafayette and Emory Valley Road extremely dangerous. Just being able to reach crosswalk buttons.I have to cross a lot of times without their benefit. Make the low enough and concrete up to the poles.

- Crosswalk lights, sidewalks- clear, continuous and with ramps.- Sidewalks stop and no way to get wheelchair into sidewalks everywhere.- See comments in 3- Some of the intersections are dangerous.- Have communication accessibility available for everything provided by City of Oak Ridge- Sidewalk infrastructure all along Pennsylvania Avenue leading to ORHS from all directions.- I rarely get out of the house anymore due to my handicap so I cannot comment.- Too many to count really. I mean, we have some, but we could do SO much better. Have more buttons to push to

open doors that are within reach. I am really taking this survey for a friend. I feel bad for her.- parking and distance to services and events- better access to all the parks- There are many sidewalks behind sloping curbs or flush with the roadway. I think the most concerning is on

Lafayette. I do not think it's safe to travel on a roadway with my back to traffic with no barrier but what looks to be a3' striped buffer. 6" curb and gutter won't necessarily protect pedestrian but it sure is better than sloping and flushcurbs. I realize that some access is better than none but I think that is a real safety issue.

- Sidewalk all the way down Briarcliff Ave.- Crosswalk at Lafayette and OR Turnpike and sidewalk on south side of turnpike in front of Summit Medical

14


6. Please rate the accessibility of city buildings you have visited.# Response(s) Response Ratio

Very Good - no access issues 7 22.5% Good - only very minor issues 11 35.4% Fair - many issues encountered 9 29.0% Poor - portions of facilities not accessible 0 0.0% No Responses 4 12.9% 6 Comment(s) - The entrance to the city manager’s office is great!- As a city we also do not hold places of business to proper ADA requirements.- Going to a city council meeting would be extremely hard to do walking up those steps.- Don't get me started- distance and uneven walks- The building next to Kroger's which has been used for voting was particularly hard to navigate. I think it is a

museum now and hope it is private and not city owned as the entrance ramp and lip at the door are difficult tomaneuver. I understand that Oak Ridge has many older building in which are constrained when it comes torestrooms and width of hallways and doorways.

7. Please rate the accessibility of parking at city buildings or public parking lots you have visited.# Response(s) Response Ratio

Very Good 9 29.0% Good 10 32.2% Fair 7 22.5% Poor 2 6.4% No Responses 3 9.6%

5 Comment(s) - Parking spaces are too narrow to accommodate the wide variety of trucks and SUVs that many of us in Tennessee

utilize.- The road by Walmart could use a little maintenance- I have a ramp coming out the side of my van and parking is seldom wide enough.- Decent. But we could do better. Will we? I doubt it.- Generally OK. If I recall some look like they need to be repainted. I'm not sure all access aisle comply with width

because I'm going off memory.- Parking spaces are too narrow to accommodate the wide variety of trucks and SUVs that many of us in Tennessee

utilize.- The road by Walmart could use a little maintenance

8. Please rate the accessibility of sidewalk curb ramps you have used.# Response(s) Response Ratio

Very Good 5 16.1% Good 8 25.8%

Fair 7 22.5% Poor 8 25.8% No Responses 3 9.6% 12 Comment(s) - Caused ambulance ride to the hospital for stitches.- Very few of these, have to walk a long way to one.- The ramps at the intersection on Emory Valley Rd beside the car wash could be lowered. I watched a woman in a

wheelchair get stuck trying to go off the ramp and almost fell out of her chair. Luckily there was a nice citizen thatgot out of his car and assisted her in getting down safely

- I really don't want to talk much about that. I recently had a police officer to tell me to get on the sidewalk 3 times and3 times I told him I couldn't because there were no ramps.

- If there is one missing it is too many.- They are not always available- Along most streets the sidewalks are only on one side without crosswalk to aid in crossing to other side when the

sidewalk ends. Pennsylvania Avenue/Tennessee Ave could never be used by wheelchair- We don't have enough.

15


- you have a handicap ramp in Jackson Square that lead to steps. seriously?- I have not traveled in the ROW as I'm usually going to a specific building or business and parking there. Not

impressed by the new curb ramps at Tulane and the Turnpike. The height of returned curb makes no sense forpedestrians or vehicles.

- Need Sidewalk all the way down Briarcliff Ave.- Oak Ridge needs to set a goal of becoming a walkable city for all citizens and guests.

9. Please rate the accessibility of city sidewalks you have used.# Response(s) Response Ratio

Very Good 3 9.6% Good 6 19.3% Fair 8 25.8% Poor 10 32.2% No Responses 4 12.9% 10 Comment(s) - Caused ambulance ride to the hospital for stitches.- We need sidewalks in the east and west reaches of the city. Many residents wish to walk, and to do so they are in

the street!- Most are over overgrown, cracked, and falling apart. The new addition to the turnpike has been really nice. I'm a

walker for exercise and I typically walk from Priceless IGA to Kroger and back. Sidewalks have improved. Wouldlove to see more of that on each side of the road.

- Branches grown over them. Big cracks making your teeth chatter. Muddy, people don't want you in their buildings.Sometimes sidewalks just end.(I understand this is going to be a much more frequent problem with new plans)There telephone poles in the middle of them. slopped way too much. Cars and garbage cans in the middle or edge of sidewalks. raised access ports and large curves around mailboxes with steep banks.

- Cars parked on them, garbage cans blocking them, not enough ramps.- See comments in 3- Our sidewalks are far away from buildings people need to get into. Case in point, IGA. I mean, seriously? I saw my

poor friend maneuvering through a parking lot while at that stupid red light on Emory Valley and Briarcliff and almoststarted crying for her. In fact, it is worse than poor. But whatever, we need more Mexican restaurants so...whocares, right? It's about money, not people. For shame, Oak Ridge.

- often find people parking on sidewalks and blocking them or parking in the van loading area of handicap parking- I have not traveled in the ROW as I'm usually going to a specific building or business and parking there. I may not

have used them but I see asphalt sidewalks that look no more than 3' in the Hillside Road area. I also think thathomeowners especially in these areas should understand that placing trash cans on the sidewalk would create non-compliance for the city.

- no sidewalks in my neighborhood of Briarcliff. The thoroughfare, Briarcliff Avenue, needs sidewalks!10. Please rate the accessibility of city parks and greenways you have visited.

# Response(s) Response Ratio Very Good 6 19.3% Good 10 32.2% Fair 8 25.8% Poor 2 6.4% No Responses 5 16.1% 9 Comment(s) - Caused ambulance ride to the hospital for stitches.- Some are average and some are good.- Greenways have been good. Parks especially athletic parks need lots of attention- The disk golf course at Carl Yearwood park could use a good trim and better labeled entrances and guides. I have

noticed only bricks to label it and some children picked the bricks up when the parents weren’t watching and werethrowing them around on the sidewalks and around the park. That could be a little dangerous

- You can get to them even if you must sit to the side of what’s going on.- N/A- Do not go- Greenways are hidden and parking is usually a gravel lot or a grassy field away from entrance.- They're there but I rarely get out to enjoy them due to my walking problems.

16


11. How do you get information about city government, meetings, etc.?# Response(s) Response Ratio

City Web Site 22 75.8% Personal visits to facilities 3 10.3% Telephone 2 6.8% Newspapers 8 27.5% Friends or family members 9 31.0% Other 11 37.9% Other - Social media/Facebook, from council members, member of neighborhood watch. member of 10+ OR FB groups, media, Online, emails

5 Comment(s) - Caused ambulance ride to the hospital for stitches.- and I usually find out too late- Receive email from Mrs. Chan- Mostly about Mexican restaurants. We already have 10. Thank God we are finally getting a Dairy Queen back. And

we have too many empty buildings that have been there for years. But bring on more stuff we DONT need cause wealready have too many of them.

- member of neighborhood watch. member of 10+ OR FB groups12. Please provide any specific information about your access needs to city facilities or programsthat can assist the city in prioritizing accessibility improvements at our facilities. 17 Response(s) - Sidewalks need to be smooth for wheeled individuals. Caused ambulance ride to the hospital for stitches.- None at this time.- 1. Need larger bathroom stalls in women’s bathrooms.

2. Need wider parking spaces in parking lots3. Need sidewalks in eastern and western neighborhoods.

- Nothing other than that- Milt Dickens - needs handicap accessible portable toilets. Needs a flat accessible sitting area for wheelchairs and

walkers and some with a cane.

Energy Solutions - Needs handicap accessible portable toilets, ramps leading down to the field, water fountain with a sidewalk leading to it, sidewalk leading to a sitting area where wheelchair, walker or cane people can access without having to access the field during wet conditions.

Katie Hunter - now that this has a new sidewalk and handicap accessible portable toilets it is great to host events at. - Overall, I think Oakridge should definitely pride itself in being so inclusive for all individuals and for maintaining such a

beautiful city with wonderful well kept parks. The few minor suggestive improvements are all I personally have noticed.I work with individuals with disabilities and they enjoy all the parks available. The restrooms at Melton Lake Marina are a wonderful place for our group to stop along with the beautiful park there with amazing walk trails. I think for the mostpart you all do an amazing job at keeping Oakridge beautiful and inclusive.

- Branches grown over them. Big cracks making your teeth chatter. Muddy, people don't want you in their buildings.Sometimes sidewalks jus end.(I understand this is going to be a much more frequent problem with new plans) Theretelephone poles in the middle of them. slopped way too much. Cars and garbage cans in the middle or edge ofsidewalks. Raised access ports and large curves around mailboxes with steep banks.

- Handicapped entrances.- Maybe go on a walk with someone in wheelchair and just see their point of view and challenges- N/A- Interpreters at neighborhood meetings, events d- I have never seen a city with such neglect of sidewalk infrastructure. Not only is it impossible for wheelchair but people

can hardly enjoy walking and running. I see kids train for cross country up and down Pennsylvania Avenue usingsidewalks that are broken asphalt, narrow, and littered with tree branches gravel and trash. in 20 years the sidewalkshaven’t been repairs and there are tree debris, rocks at each corner making even a ramp unusable because thestreets haven’t been cleaned.

- I am fine now but I will be disabled before long. Already have problems with stairs. But hey, thank GOD for Amazon.Geez.

- provide cheap/ free transport for all residents above 50 years old to city facilities. ETHRA does not serve the need.you can't always plan for a ride 24 hours in advance

17


- A lot of time the focus is getting into the building but there also needs to be priorities inside the building. Restroomsare a huge concern followed by water fountains. Thought should be taken into where voting is taking place includingearly voting. I have been to two different early voting locations so I know the city has the ability to change venues. Ithink sidewalk connections are vital and the system needs to be expanded for those that live with the city. I would liketo see a permanent surface on the trail around the Civic Center so that all can enjoy the activities.

- I would like for the sidewalk in front of Summit Medical and the crossing light at Lafayette and Turnpike to be a priority.I also believe making Oak Ridge a universally walkable city is a goal that we need to embrace.

- Trash pickup service is unreliable.

The responses and comments from the public survey above will be considered in the Transition Plan recommendations in Section 6.

Following completion of the draft SETP, it was made available for public review. It was placed at the following locations in Oak Ridge:

Oak Ridge Municipal Center, Community Development offices, 200 S. Tulane, Oak Ridge Oak Ridge Public Library, 1401 Oak Ridge Turnpike, Oak Ridge City web site (www.oakridgetn.gov/default.aspx)

The report was available from May 11 to 22, 2020, for public review and comment. [INSERT ACTUAL NUMBER AFTER PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD HERE] public comments were received during the comment period.

18


2.0 Self-Evaluation of City Policies, Services, Activities, and Programs - Findings & Recommendations

This section of the self-evaluation summarizes the review of current City-wide policies, services, activities, and programs based on correspondence with City staff and responses to the program accessibility questionnaire received from City departments and divisions. The findings and recommendations contained in this section will provide the basis for the implementation of specific improvements for providing access to City programs.

2.1 Program Evaluation Interdepartmental Memo

The self-evaluation of the City's services, programs, and activities required and involved the participation of all City departments. Oak Ridge evaluated its policies, procedures, and programs to determine current levels of service and the extent to which its policies and programs created barriers to accessibility for persons with disabilities. DLZ distributed a questionnaire to the City ADA Coordinator as one measure to determine the level of ADA compliance. Each department was also issued a department specific questionnaire (See Appendix C).

The primary purpose of the questionnaires was to allow DLZ staff to better understand how each department operates and the programs provided by each so that an accurate assessment can be made of architectural and procedural barriers and how each can be corrected to provide access. The level of investigation into the operations of the various departments was generally consistent with the amount of interaction with the public and the extent of the public programs offered by each. Note that the response rate to the questionnaire is often less than 100%. In some instances, the information provided below may not be accurate due to either lack of response to the questionnaire, inaccurate answers being provided on submitted questionnaires, or the lack of detail in some responses.

2.2 Overall Findings – General Policies and Practices

The self-evaluation of the Departments identified common accessibility issues between all City departments. The findings from the City departments can be organized into the following general categories:

Public Information Designation of ADA Coordinator Grievance/Uniform Complaint Procedures Public Meetings Accommodations to Access Programs, Services, and Activities Special Events and Private Events on City Property Ordinances, Design Standards, and Other Documents Contracted Services and Contractors Customer Service, Satisfaction, and Input Equally Effective Communication Alternate Communication Formats Fees and Surcharges Information and Signage Staff Training Emergency Evacuation Procedures

19


Employment Department Self-Evaluation Findings & Recommendations

The findings and recommendations in the following subsections generally apply to all departments except where noted.

2.3 Public Information

The City is required to notify the public of their rights and protections under the ADA (28 CFR 35.106), which states: “A public entity shall make available to applicants, participants, beneficiaries, and other interested persons information regarding the provisions of this part and its applicability to the services, programs, or activities of the public entity, and make such information available to them in such manner as the head of the entity finds necessary to apprise such persons of the protections against discrimination assured them by the Act and this part.” In addition, notices regarding ADA should be included in a number of other situations to inform the public of their rights and opportunities to ensure accessibility, including signage directing the public to accessible routes and entrances.

Self-Evaluation General Findings: A poster entitled “Equal Opportunity is the Law”, defining the requirements of Title VII, was observed in

most City buildings. The City has not assembled an internal ADA Team, which would be comprised of the ADA Coordinator

and representatives from other departments, or formed a citizen’s committee, which is typicallycomprised of key City staff and representatives of the community that are disabled, advocate for thedisabled, or are caregivers.

Grievance procedures for the ADA were adopted in August 2018 and is available on the website. SeeAppendix E.

The City has published an ADA Notice, which can be found on the website. See Appendix E. Public meeting agendas for the City Council and other boards/commissions provide no non-

discrimination statement regarding how someone needing a meeting accommodation would proceed orwho to contact.

Printed materials reviewed have no information regarding ADA accommodation. ADA compliance information, including the ADA Notice and link to the Grievance Procedure, is located on

the City website at http://www.oakridgetn.gov/content.aspx?article=3956. Signage is absent at most larger facilities directing visitors to the accessible entrances where multiple

entrances are present and not all are accessible. The International Symbol of Accessibility (ISA) is notpresent or in clear view at all accessible entrances.

Recommended Action: The City should consider forming an ad-hoc committee comprised of the ADA Coordinator and

representatives from various city departments, particularly those that have extensive interaction with thepublic or those that are responsible for various city facilities. The responsibilities of this committee can bereviewed and established internally in conjunction with the administration. The City could also considerforming a committee that includes residents with experience in disability access and issues to assist inimplementation of this Transition Plan.

Public meeting agendas for the City Council and other boards/commissions should all have a non-discrimination statement that provides information regarding how someone needing a meetingaccommodation would proceed or who to contact. The statement could include language similar to thefollowing “Individuals with disabilities who require accommodations for participation in meetings must

20


request accommodations at least 3 business days ahead of the scheduled meeting. Contact the ADA Coordinator, Bryan Mills, at (865) 425-1807 or email at [email protected].”

The Notice of Non-Discrimination should be used by all departments for all City publications and printed materials as applicable.

Increase outreach to persons with disabilities by finding additional methods and formats to provide information about meetings and other City activities. The City should endeavor to inform the public of the possible modifications required to make its services, programs, and activities accessible.

Include the following notice on all materials printed by the City that are made available to the public:“This publication can be made available in alternative formats, such as Braille, large print, audiotape, or .pdf. Requests can be made by calling (865) 429-1807. Please allow at least 3 business days for your request to be processed.”.

List City agencies, departments, and specialized services that offer TDD/TTY in printed City directories.(See also section 2.12 and 2.13).

Signage directing visitors to City buildings should be placed along the accessible routes and the ISA should be placed in clear view at all accessible entrances.

2.4 Designation of ADA Coordinator

The ADA regulations require any public entity with fifty or more employees to designate at least one employee to coordinate ADA compliance (28 CFR 35.107 (a)). Federal regulations require public entities to make available to interested persons the name, office address and telephone number of the ADA Coordinator. The ADA Coordinator’s role is to plan, coordinate, organize, facilitate, and promote compliance efforts. The Coordinator responds to requests for accommodations or barrier removal. The Coordinator also receives and investigates complaints and grievances.

Self-Evaluation Findings: Oak Ridge appointed the City Engineer as the ADA Coordinator effective in May 2020.

- Mr. Bryan Mills, ADA Coordinator- Phone: (865) 429-1807- Email: [email protected]

The contact information for the ADA Coordinator is included on the website in multiple locations.

Recommendations: Activities related to ADA compliance should be directed to the Coordinator, and each City department

should designate a liaison for ADA issues and publicize the identity of this person. Information regarding the identity of the City’s ADA Coordinator should continue to be provided to staff,

posted at all City facility locations, incorporated into employee handbooks, staff, and public phonedirectories, placed in frequently used publications, and on the City website.

The designated ADA Coordinator should be familiar with the requirements of ADA and get appropriatetraining to ensure compliance by the City.

It is strongly suggested that each department have one individual with knowledge of ADA issues that canrespond to issues that arise within their department and assist the ADA Coordinator.

2.5 Grievance/Uniform Complaint Procedures

A public entity that employs 50 or more employees must adopt and publish grievance procedures which provide for the prompt and equitable resolution of complaints alleging any action that would be prohibited by the ADA (28 CFR 35.107 (b)).

21


Self-Evaluation Findings: Oak Ridge has an ADA Grievance Procedure on the website (see Appendix E) that was adopted in August

2018. The procedure can be found on the city website atwww.oakridgetn.gov/images/uploads/Documents/ADA%20Grievance%20Procedure%20AUG%202018.pdf

There does not appear to be a Grievance Form that an individual could obtain and submit. The procedureincludes a description of the information to be provided in the complaint.

The policy includes timelines for the review process and includes information about how the decision canbe appealed.

Recommendations: Revisit the grievance procedure and update as needed. Some recommendations include:

o Update the policy and grievance procedure to specifically address issues that the public may havewith accessibility to City programs. Ensure that all steps for the review of the grievance includesspecific timelines, details of how the investigation will be performed, how the results arecommunicated to the person filing the grievance, and the appeal process.

o Develop a standard grievance form to ensure all information needed to review complaints isprovided. An example grievance form used by TDOT can be found in Appendix E, which can beadapted for use by the City. Verify that forms are available at all facility locations and considerproviding the form on the City website, along with the revised grievance procedure.

Centralized record keeping of complaints and tracking of complaint resolution will help the City toregularly update its compliance efforts, and plan for additional compliance implementation. The ADACoordinator should ensure that records are kept of all ADA-related complaints, including informal itemsbrought to their attention.

The City should review its current administrative policy and be able to provide the recommended ADAGrievance Form in an alternate accessible format, i.e. Braille, audio-tape, e-text, large print, etc.

Administrative policies and procedures should continue to be developed, adopted, and implemented toprovide consistency for filing complaints or grievances and record-keeping.

2.6 Public Meetings

Public meetings are routinely held by various City departments, boards, and commissions. The ADA prohibits public entities from excluding persons with disabilities from programs, services, or activities offered by a public entity. The law does allow a public entity to use both structural and nonstructural methods to achieve accessibility to programs, services, and activities (28 CFR 35.150 (a)(1); (b)(1)). While most of the meetings are open to the general public and advertised as required by law, the public does not regularly attend several of the meetings of the groups noted.

Self-Evaluation Findings: The following boards/commissions meet at various times on City business and would be considered open

meetings that can be attended by members of the general public. Other groups may meet, but do nothave regular published schedules. Meetings are held in the Oak Ridge Municipal Building Training Room104 (200 S. Tulane Avenue), unless otherwise noted.

o City Council – 2nd Monday each month, with additional meetings as-needed, in the Municipal BuildingCourtroom and Work Sessions on the 3rd Tuesday at the Central Services Multi-Purpose Room

o Board of Zoning Appeals – monthly, 2nd Tuesday in the Municipal Building Courtroomo Oak Ridge Municipal Planning Commission – monthly, 3rd Thursday, Municipal Building Courtroomo Beer Permit Board – as-needed monthly, generally the 1st Wednesday

22


o Board of Building and Housing Code Appeals – 2nd Thursday monthlyo Convention and Visitors Bureau/Explore Oak Ridge – as-needed, 1400 Oak Ridge Turnpikeo Environmental Quality Advisory Board – monthly as-neededo Health and Educational Facilities Board – monthly as-neededo Industrial Development Board – monthly as-neededo Oak Ridge Housing Authority – monthly, 1st Thursday, Housing Authority Community Room (76

Honeysuckle Lane)o Oak Ridge Land Bank Corporation Board of Directors – 3rd Wednesday each montho Personnel Advisory Board – as-neededo Recreation and Parks Advisory Board – monthly, typically the 2nd Thursday, Civic Center Social Room

(1403 Oak Ridge Turnpike)o Senior Advisory Board – monthly, 1st Monday, Senior Center A Room (1405 Oak Ridge Turnpike)o Trade Licensing Board – as-needed, Municipal Center City Manager’s Conference Roomo Traffic Safety Advisory Board – 3rd Tuesday monthly as-neededo Youth Advisory Board – twice monthly, Civic Center Social Room

The Personnel Department indicated they sometimes sponsor public meetings at various sites, includingBissell Park, Library Auditorium, and Civic Center Gymnasium.

The Public Works Department noted that they have held public meetings at the Municipal Building andthe Central Services Center.

The Library noted that they have held public meetings at the Library Auditorium. The Community Development Department noted that in addition to the regular Boards and Commission

meetings they staff, they sponsor public meetings at various locations. These include the Chamber ofCommerce, Civic Center, and local schools and churches for community meetings.

The City Courtroom upgrades in 2015 included installation of a Listen LT-803 Assistive Listening System(ALS). The City has 4 receivers. A sign was noted by City IT staff to be present at the courtroom to indicatethe presence of an ALS but was not observed during field inspections.

A number of other rooms in city facilities were identified as being used for various meetings. None of therooms have an audio amplification system or an ALS.

City Council meetings are televised live at www.oakridgetn.gov/councilstreaming.aspx. Meetings are alsorecorded and re-broadcast on the city website, with videos being accessed at the location where agendasare provided (www.oakridgetn.gov/content.aspx?page=34). No captioning is provided to permit personswith hearing loss from understanding the meetings either live or in the recording.

Public meeting agendas for the City Council and other boards/commissions provide no non-discrimination statement regarding how someone needing a meeting accommodation would proceed orwho to contact.

Public notices are posted in a variety of places, including newspaper advertisements, website, and postedin some City facilities. Notices on the website www.oakridgetn.gov/content.aspx?article=1728 containedno information about meeting accommodations and a majority of the notice and documents on thewebsite are scanned documents and not able to be used by computer screen reading software for thevision impaired.

Meeting minutes, resolutions, and many other documents with signatures that posted on the website formany boards and commissions are scanned documents and not able to be used by computer screenreading software for the vision impaired.

Agendas for the City Council and some other boards and commissions are posted on the City website. No requests for special accommodations, including American Sign Language or other interpreters, has

been made at public meetings.

23


Recommendations:

2.7 Accommodations to Access Programs, Services, and Activities

The ADA prohibits public entities from excluding persons with disabilities from programs, services, or activities offered by a public entity. A public entity may not adopt policies that are discriminatory or engage in practices that are discriminatory. This prohibition applies to policies that are explicitly exclusionary and to those which appear to be neutral but have discriminatory effect. The law does allow a public entity to use both structural and nonstructural methods to achieve accessibility to programs, services, and activities (28 CFR 35.130 (b)(3); 35.150 (a)(1); (b)(1)).

The City should schedule and hold public meetings in the most accessible locations whenever possible. Meetings which the public regularly attends should be made the highest priority.

An assistive listening system is in place in City Courtroom. Based on occupancy of the rooms combined, a total of 3 receivers are required, 2 of which must be hearing-aid compatible. IT staff reported that 4 receivers are available but did not note if they were compatible. Ensure that there are hear-aid compatible receivers available and post the required signage conspicuously outside the room at the main public entrance.

Other rooms used for meetings do not utilize audio amplification. If installed in the future, these rooms should also be equipped with and ALS and the appropriate number of assistive listening devices. The City should review which meetings are held in locations without audio amplification and consider the ability of someone with hearing loss to participate in those meetings.

Standard language on all City publications regarding availability of andrequests for accommodations should be provided to departments.

Public notices for meetings should include information related to compliancewith the ADA, including reasonable accommodations for persons withdisabilities needing it to participate in meetings. Notices should include thename and contact person, along with deadlines, for requests to be made.International Symbol of The statement could include language similar to the following “IndividualsAccess for Hearing Loss with disabilities who require accommodations for participation in meetingsmust request accommodations at least 3 business days ahead of the scheduled meeting. Contact the ADA Coordinator, Bryan Milles, at (865) 425-1807 or email at [email protected].”

The City should develop procedures for obtaining and providing auxiliary aids such as sign language interpreters, readers, descriptive services, and other assistive technologies. (See also section 2.11.)

The City should make reasonable modifications to enable individuals with disabilities to attend and participate in all public meetings.

Ensure that all documents provided on the website are in a format that are usable by persons utilizing a screen reading program due to vision loss. Signed documents are currently often scanned, a picture of the scanned photo could be utilized instead or a notation made on the signature line that an original with signature can be reviewed at the appropriate department office.

Provide meeting agendas and minutes in alternative formats when requested. The City should assemble and maintain a list of readily accessible meeting spaces to facilitate the

scheduling of meetings and/or the relocation of meetings upon request. The City should create a simple checklist for creating accessible meetings and selection of accessible

meeting spaces. This checklist should be utilized and available to all City departments for their programs and events.

24


Self-Evaluation Findings: There is no evidence of intentional discriminatory practices, intentional exclusion of individuals with

disabilities, or practices to segregate individuals with disabilities or limit access to City programs, services, or activities.

The Library staff noted that some residents with mobility devices cannot access all library stacks due to narrow turn-around space at the end. Staff regularly assists these and other patrons by retrieving books for them.

Community Development staff noted that they have placed seating closer to the presentation screen for an individual that had vision and hearing loss so she could participate in a public meeting.

The Legal Department noted that they have assisted individuals in wheelchairs with access to the courtroom and City Clerk’s office.

Several departments noted that access to the Municipal Building and Police Department is difficult and that an additional access at the main front entrance would be better for wheelchair access.

The Recreation & Parks Department staff indicated that they have used a notepad to write out conversations for persons with hearing impairments.

The Recreation & Parks Department staff indicated they regularly assist patrons that need help getting into the pool at either the lift or ladder stairs.

The Oak Ridge City Camps Policies and Procedures Handbook includes a section entitled “Special Needs Campers” that provides information for parents to consider for various programs based on the abilities and special needs of their children. The section includes no indication of accommodating campers to the extent possible without impacting the experience for everyone.

The Scarboro Summer Program application includes the statement “My child has been examined by a physician within the past 12 months and is found to be physically able to participate in the Recreation and Parks Department Summer Programs, which may include physical activities requiring rapid and strenuous movement.” There is no indication whether children with disabilities can be accommodated for some programs.

The Recreation & Parks Department offers the MyRide program, where volunteers provide rides for seniors to the Senior Center. The application for MyRide includes information regarding the types of vehicles the applicant is able to get into and out of without or with some assistance and examples of other assistance that may be needed (travel between car and buildings, carrying items, etc.).

The golf course staff indicated that they issue special flags to disabled golfers that allow cart access to two fairways normally closed to cart traffic and closer to all greens on the course.

The Library staff noted that they have provided a resident with a large print library application form in the past and now have a supply on hand.

Some City departments have provided simple accommodation at programs in the past. Public meetings are held in locations that are thought to be accessible to persons with mobility

impairments and staff had no recollection of any previous complaints or issues. Not all facilities are owned by the City and were not part of the self-evaluation.

Recommended Action: Information directing the public how to request accommodations should appear on all public notices,

announcements, and agendas. Front line staff, such as administrative assistants, receptionists, and staff that has everyday contact with

the public, should receive training on interacting and accommodating individuals with disabilities. The City should provide additional and ongoing training for staff, including volunteers, regarding the

requirements of the ADA and accommodations that provide equal access to programs, services, and activities.

25


Programs offered especially by the Recreation & Parks Department should all be reviewed to determinewhich ones would be altered extensively if accommodations were needed for a camper with a disabilityand which programs could accommodate a camper for all or portions of these programs. Both the CityCamps and Scarboro Summer Programs give no indication of whether a disabled child could participate inwhole, or part, in these programs. Assess all similar programs within the department and publish policiesfor each related to participation by children with disabilities and accommodations that can and cannot bemade.

High use facilities that sponsor a variety of programs should have an accommodation request formavailable on the website and all publications that provide information about the programs sponsoredthere. The statement should provide contact information and deadlines for accommodation requests toparticipate in the programs.

The ADA Coordinator should continue to monitor programmatic access, making any necessary changes toensure access and document compliance efforts.

2.8 Special Events and Private Events on City Property

The City could provide opportunities for private organizations to utilize City facilities for special or private events. Contained within the ADA are two titles that pertain to public and private entities. Public entities are not subject to Title III of the ADA. Conversely, private entities are not subject to Title II. In many situations, however, public entities have close relationships with private entities that are covered by Title III (Public Accommodations), with the result that certain activities may be at least indirectly affected by both Titles. This is the case with certain special events or private organizations that may use City facilities.

Self-Evaluation Findings: The City provides several rooms/facilities for rental by the public, including small and large rooms,

kitchens and kitchenettes, and gymnasiums at the Civic Center and Scarboro Community Center,Performing Arts Pavilion, Melton Lake Waterfront Pavilion, pools for private parties, and athletic fields.

The Special Events Application of the City includes a requirement that one portable toilet be provided forevery 80 participants but includes no requirement for any to be accessible.

The Special Events Application does not appear to include any specific information related to theresponsibility of renters for accessibility based on the needs of persons attending their event. The rentalagreement does not address any accessibility requirements by the end user nor do they specify whethereach of these facilities is accessible.

The City sponsors/participates in a number of special events that occur on City property, including TheSecret City Festival in A.K. Bissell Park on the third Friday and Saturday in June.

A wide variety of programs at City parks and properties are sponsored by the Oak Ridge Recreation &Parks Department.

Recommended Action: Address the facility accessibility needs identified in Appendix A. The City should thoroughly review the current accessibility conditions of the facilities available for rent

and indicate availability of accessible facilities on the rental descriptions and website. Consider adding language to the Special Events Applications regarding accessibility, including ensuring

that any special access needs for the event of private individuals is the responsibility of the group leasingthe facility. Consult the City attorney for any appropriate language in rental agreements aboutaccessibility needs and responsibility for access.

In situations where private organizations sponsor events in City facilities, the City should encourageprivate organizations to comply with applicable ADA requirements. The City may want to provide a

26


checklist and information during the application process to inform organizers of their responsibility for accessibility under the ADA, if applicable.

Ensure that appropriate temporary accessible facilities are provided as needed for events regardless of whether they are sponsored by the City or another group, including accessible portable restrooms and accessible parking.

Guidelines or policies should be in place for ensuring that all special events are accessible, including items such as accessible parking, designated wheelchair seating, and accessible restroom facilities. Ensure that accessible facilities are clearly marked with the ISA and that directional signage is provided, accessible facilities are shown on literature for the event, and that accessible routes are provided to and from all amenities of the events.

2.9 Ordinances, Design Standards, and Other Documents

Title II entities typically have a number of documents that specify requirements, design standards, and other requirements for construction of various facilities. Often, these documents reference pertinent guidance, such as state DOT, International/State Building Codes, etc. A review of documents that contain, or should contain, provisions related to accessibility was done by searching key words where possible.

Self-Evaluation Findings: Pedestrian facilities within the public ROW utilize City’s Standard Construction Requirements and Details,

which was noted by staff as needing to be updated. The last date they were updated is not known. The City utilizes the 2009 Accessible and Usable Buildings and Facilities Code (ICC A117.1-2009) and 2018

International Code Commission (ICC) codes for building, mechanical, plumbing, and fire and the 2017 National Electric Code.

No information was provided regarding any specific training for plan reviewers or inspectors related to ADA requirements.

Review of the Oak Ridge Zoning Ordinance noted the following: o The term “handicapped” is rarely used in the document when referring to persons with disabilities

but included in 2 locations. o Section 11.02-‘Required Off-Street Parking’ includes a requirement for accessible parking spaces for

disabled drivers. It requires identification of disabled parking spaces consistent with Tennessee Code. o Section 11.03(f)(5) includes provisions for dimensions of spaces and access aisles for disabled drivers

and signage. The requirements included exceed ADASAD requirements by requiring 2 van spaces per 8 disabled parking spaces (ADASAD requires 1 per 6). Specific language for signs at van-accessible spaces is provided but the height of the signage is not included (60” min. to bottom of lowest sign).

o Several areas within the ordinance discuss requirements for driveways but do not specifically note the requirements for driveway slopes when crossing a pedestrian access route.

o Section 13.02(f)4.(3) states ‘Plant materials or existing significant vegetation shall be kept trimmed so as not to obstruct any sidewalk, pedestrian way, vehicular aisle, and/or safe line of sight’.

o Section 9.04(p)9.a.(1) states ‘Bus shelters, utility and light poles, trash receptacles, fire hydrants, traffic signs, newspaper vending boxes, bicycle racks and similar elements in a manner that does not obstruct pedestrian access’ and Section 9.04(p)9.b. states ‘Said zone shall also be unobstructed for a minimum height of eight (8) feet, by any permanent or nonpermanent element such as retail displays, outdoor dining, plantings, sculpture and similar elements.’ in reference to the sidewalk clear zone.

Review of the City’s Standard Construction Requirements and Details (undated) found the following items of note:

27


o Section 3.02(d)(7) Sidewalks states ‘Sidewalks shall be constructed in accordance with the latest

edition of the TDOT, Standard Specifications for Road and Bridge Construction with the following incorporated changes’.

o Subsection 3.02(d)(7)(b) states ‘Sidewalks shall have a uniform slope toward the roadway of two percent with a tolerance of one percent’. The maximum permitted by PROWAG is 2%.

o Subsection 3.02(d)(7)(c) states that ‘Sidewalk construction shall meet the requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Accessibility Guidelines for Buildings and Facilities found in 36 CFR (Code of Federal Regulations) Chapter XI, Part 1191’, which allows up to 2.083% cross slope.

o Detail 3.10 Standard Concrete Sidewalk depicts the cross slope of the sidewalk at 4% for a typical section without grass strip and 2% with grass strip. The 4% cross slope exceeds PROWAG maximum of 2%.

o Detail 3.11 Typical Handicap Ramp “A” has a note that ‘surface contrast required on all handicap ramps’ but does not indicate the requirement for detectable warnings or a level landing at the top of the ramp per PROWAG requirements. The detail also does not show the grade break location, which is required to be perpendicular to the path of travel. The slope of the ramp is shown at 12:1, which is the maximum allowed by PROWAG but section ZZ notes ‘slope not to exceed 12:1’.

o Detail 3.12 Typical Handicap Ramp “B” does not indicate the requirement for detectable warnings or a level landing at the top of the ramp per PROWAG requirements. The detail also does not show the grade break location, which is required to be perpendicular to the path of travel. The slope of the ramp is noted to have maximum slope of 12:1, which is the maximum allowed per PROWAG.

o Detail 3.13 Typical Handicap Ramp “C” has a note that ‘surface contrast required on all handicap ramps’ but does not indicate the requirement for detectable warnings or a level landing at the top of the ramp per PROWAG requirements. The detail also does not show the grade break location, which is required to be perpendicular to the path of travel. The plan view indicates the ramp slope at 12:1 with section AA noting 12:1 max.

Review of the Oak Ridge Bicycle and Pedestrian Plan (date March 2011 and prepared by the Knoxville Regional Transportation Planning Organization) has a section entitled ‘The Americans with Disabilities Act’ and discussed accessibility and standards that apply to public facilities. The document is slightly outdated and references old versions of the standards and makes no specific mention of PROWAG.

Review of the Oak Ridge Subdivision Regulations (as of May 16, 2019) found the requirement for a ‘Where sidewalks or pedestrian ways intersect a curbed pavement, a handicap ramp shall be installed.’ The regulations also require sidewalks a minimum width of five (5) feet located at least two (2) feet behind the curb.

The City of Oak Ridge Waterfront Redevelopment Plan is a scanned document that must be converted to readable format for screen readers. The document includes minimal discussion related to access for persons with disabilities other than a comment during the public outreach noting this as a goal and during discussion for an arched bridge that would reduce distance from vehicles for the elderly and ‘handicapped population’ at Melton Hill Lake Greenway.

The City of Oak Ridge Comprehensive Plan (last updated 1998 and is severely out of date) uses the term ‘handicapped’ throughout the document.

The City Blueprint (dated May 13, 2019) has limited mention of disability issues but does note the current ADA Transition Plan being in progress and desire by public meeting participants to improve accessibility to sidewalks in the City.

The City of Oak Ridge Community Development Block Grant Annual Action Plan PY19/FY20 (draft dated for the period of July 1, 2019 to June 30, 2020) mentions in the Citizen Participation Outreach section on page 10 the need for all meetings and public hearings related to the CDBG program to be held in locations that are accessible and that the City will attempt to provide for individuals needing special

28


accommodations during the hearings. The plan also discusses a number of programs the City utilizes with other stakeholders (e.g., TORCH) to provide assistance to persons with disabilities.

The Public Library Application includes a location for the Driver’s License Number of adult patrons or parents of juvenile patrons. It is not indicated whether this information is a requirement for consideration of a library card, which would preclude persons with disabilities that don’t allow them to drive from applying.

The City of Oak Ridge Public Works Department Winter Weather Plan 2019-20 notes that ‘Public Works is responsible for the removal of snow and ice from building entrance landings, steps and walks for most City buildings, while the Parks Division will be responsible for the Civic Center complex and the other Recreation and Parks buildings.’ The plan provides little or no information about snow removal on sidewalks and curb ramps.

There was no mention in City documents regarding the prohibition of the use of Other Power-Driven Mobility Devices (OPDMD) on sidewalks, parks, etc. where wheelchairs are allowed. There were some locations noted on the website limiting the use of motorized vehicles in some areas of parks and greenways.

There was no information found regarding a specific policy city-wide regarding service animals. There were limited locations in some parks or greenways (Black Oak Ridge) that dogs were not allowed.

Recommended Action Consider use of known standards (ADASAD, PROWAG, and TDOT) for consistency and compliance with

ROW and other facilities. Ensure that all documents adhere to the most stringent standard when they are updated

For all documents, ensure updates reflect current nomenclature. For example, remove all forms and tenses of “handicap” and replace with the appropriate tense of “accessible” or “disability”.

Provide training for plan reviewers and field inspectors on the requirements of ADA facilities and ensure that design plans meet the relevant standards and that construction meets the design plans.

Provide references to the various ADA standards and guidelines in all documents that reference design and construction.

Consider immediate updates to the City’s Standard Construction Requirements and Details to address the issues noted above to ensure compliance with sidewalk and curb ramp construction. Consider including specific detail for construction of driveways at sidewalks to ensure driveways do not present excessive cross slopes for pedestrian access routes.

When the Oak Ridge Bicycle and Pedestrian Plan is updated, consider utilizing the sidewalk self-evaluation to assist in prioritizing the improvements to sidewalks and the filling of gaps in the system.

Consider providing regulations or ordinances, as appropriate for the following: o Prohibiting the blocking of all public sidewalks, even temporarily, by parked vehicles or other

obstructions (e.g., trash and recycling container). o Ensuring that site plans include ADA-compliant facilities as part of the improvements. This would

include, but not be limited to, the public sidewalk within the property boundaries, driveways, accessible entrances and signage, etc. Facilities that pre-exist the development should be required to be brought up to code as part of the development.

Consider an educational campaign regarding the barriers presented, and the prohibition by ordinance, to persons with mobility impairments of blocking sidewalks with parked vehicles, even when those vehicles are within driveways, and other temporary obstructions.

Address all the other items noted above to ensure City documents properly and adequately address ADA requirements for all properties in the City.

29


Ensure that all documents prepared by and for the City include appropriate references regarding ADAaccessibility and consideration of the special needs of the disabled population in Oak Ridge, includingresidents and visitors.

Ensure that the Public Library does not require a driver’s license as a condition of getting a library card byallowing another government-issued picture identification instead.

Consider providing information about the removal of snow from sidewalks and curb ramps. Specifically,include who is responsible for snow removal (homeowner, businesses, city, etc.), general timeframes forremoval (e.g., within 24 hours of the end of the snow event for residential properties, etc.), and specialconsiderations for ensuring access for the disabled. Important considerations should include removal ofall snow from sidewalks and curb ramps as soon as practical, with the priority being streets, then curbramps and sidewalks. For commercial properties it is also suggested that consideration be given to a Citypolicy or ordinance prohibiting the storage of plowed snow in disabled parking spaces and ensuring thatcurb ramps and other access points are cleared.

Ensure that ordinances or City policies that apply are consistent with the ADA requirements of OPDMD.OPDMD is defined in the new rules as “any mobility device powered by batteries, fuel, or other engines . .that is used by individuals with mobility disabilities for the purpose of locomotion, including golf cars,electronic personal assistance mobility devices… such as the Segway® PT, or any mobility device designedto operate in areas without defined pedestrian routes, but that is not a wheelchair”. OPDMDs arerequired to be permitting in all locations where wheelchairs are allowed unless there is a clear andobvious safety reason to exclude them in some areas. See guidance on OPDMDs at the USDOJ website atwww.ada.gov/opdmd.pdf.

Consider a service animal policy that meets the requirements of federal law in regard to where serviceanimals (dogs) must be allowed and the conditions in which they can be asked to be removed orrestricted. See guidance at www.ada.gov/service_animals_2010.htm.

2.10 Contracted Services and Contractors

Public entities cannot use contract procurement criteria that discriminates against persons with disabilities (28 CFR 35.130 (b)(5)). In addition, selected contractors should be held to the same nondiscrimination rules as the City.

Self-Evaluation Findings: No discriminatory or exclusionary practices were evident in the selection of contractors and contracted

services.

Recommended Action: All City contracts should be reviewed to ensure that they include specific, detailed ADA language to

ensure that contractors that provide City services to the public comply with the ADA. It is recommended that the City consider a means to maintain compliance when contracting for services

or when leasing facilities by:o Including ADA compliance requirements in new requests for proposals.o Reviewing ADA requirements when contracts or leases are negotiated, revised, or renewed.

2.11 Customer Service, Satisfaction, and Input

ADA requires a public entity to provide an opportunity to interested persons and organizations to participate in the self-evaluation process. For three years after completion of the self-evaluation, a public entity must maintain a record of any problems identified (28 CFR 35.105).

30


Self-Evaluation Findings: Notices of this SETP process were sent to a number of disability advocacy groups and provided on the

City website. No complaints or grievances were reported related to inability to accommodate customers with

disabilities or inability of persons with disabilities to access City programs or facilities. There were some comments provided in the Public Input Survey related to accessibility of some facilities

including sidewalks in the City, portable toilets at various City parks, the soccer field at Pinewood Park (Energy Solutions Field), A.K. Bissell Park, the Police Department, Civic Center, and Milt Dickens Park.

Recommended Action: Consider periodic customer satisfaction surveys or gather input from recipients of City services using an

alternate method, such as public hearings or focus groups. An additional emphasis should be made to survey individuals with disabilities and organizations representing individuals with disabilities.

Partner with persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocates for the disabled to identify concerns and gather comments on capital improvement projects to improve accessibility to people with disabilities during design. Valid comments provided to the City should be considered in the scheduling and prioritization of projects.

Work with private businesses through educational programs to encourage improvements that would provide better access to potential customers with disabilities.

2.12 Equally Effective Communication

The ADA calls for public entities to provide applicants, participants, members of the public, and companions with disabilities with communication access that is equally effective as that provided to persons without disabilities (28 CFR 35.160(a)-(d)). The regulations also require that the public entity provide the appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to give people with disabilities an equal opportunity to participate in, and enjoy the benefits of a service, program, or activity of a public entity. The law stipulates that the individuals can request the auxiliary aids and services of their choice and that the City will honor the request unless a suitable substitute exists or the request is not required under the law. In addition, the City may provide qualified interpreters via video from a remote location as long as it can meet the performance requirements of 28 CFR 35.160(d). AUXILIARY AIDS AND SERVICES Self-Evaluation Findings: No departments stated that they have hired/utilized transcription services and readers. The Municipal Center Courtroom has Assistive Listening Devices (ALDs) available but it is not known if

two (2) of the four (4) receivers are hearing-aid compatible. The City does not have any contracts for interpretation services or other service providers to honor

requests for accommodation.

Recommended Action: The City should provide staff training and information regarding auxiliary aids and effective

communication. Encourage staff to offer alternate means to complete transactions and assistance to complete City forms if possible.

Ensure that a list of providers for interpretation services is available and consider contracting with one or more (such as the Knoxville Center of the Deaf for interpretation services).

The City should ensure that all assembly areas (i.e., meeting rooms) with audio amplification have an ALS in place and that the proper number and type of assistive listening devices are provided for each.

31


Compliant signage that includes the International Symbol of Access for Hearing Loss should be provided outside of all entries to rooms that provide an Assistive Listening System and Devices. Signs should include guidance on where the devices are located.

The City should have a complete list of auxiliary service providers, i.e. Braille transcription services, computer assisted transcript, dictation and transcription, American Sign Language (ASL) interpreters, etc.

INTERPRETER SERVICES Self-Evaluation Findings: No departments indicated use of or requests for interpreters. The City has no contracts in place for interpretation services.

Recommended Action: The City should maintain a City-wide contract for qualified ASL interpreter services that departments

could utilize as needed. At a minimum, a list of qualified individuals should be maintained for all potential services that might be required on short notice. The City could also explore the viability of providing qualified ASL interpreters from a remote location and transmitting the disabled participant’s response to the interpreter in accordance with 28 CFR 35.160(d).

Interpreters should be provided upon request for accommodations or considered in situations where an interpreter is known or likely to be required.

Maryville College provides a bachelor’s degree program in ASL and could potentially provide students for ASL interpretation as part of the college’s Experiential Learning program (www.maryvillecollege.edu/academics/programs-of-study/american-sign-language/).

TELECOMMUNICATIONS DEVICES FOR THE DEAF Self-Evaluation Findings: The Public Works Department noted that they have used a relay system in the past to communicate with

hearing-impaired customers. The City’s website does not identify numbers capable of use with TDD/TTY. The ‘Contact Us’ and ‘Learn More About ADA Compliance’ pages include the ADA Coordinator’s name,

phone, and email can be accessed by clicking on the link on the home page. The Public Safety Communications Department is responsible for answering all 911 calls. The 911 phone

system includes technology compatible with TDD to communicate with citizens who call and have hearing loss.

Phone systems in Oak Ridge facilities are not currently compatible with TDD/TTY systems.

Recommended Action: Consider using the Tennessee Relay Service and publishing the phone number (7-1-1 or 1-800-848-0298)

for TTY/Voice communication. A person who is deaf, hard-of-hearing, deaf-blind, or speech-disabled uses a TTY to type his/her conversation to a Communications Assistant (CA), who then reads the typed conversation to a hearing person. The CA relays the hearing person's spoken words by typing them back to the TTY user. This information could be placed on the recommended website page for accessibility.

Where the City uses an automated answering system for receiving and directing incoming telephone calls, the City should enable this system to provide real-time communication with individuals using auxiliary aids and services, including TTY and telecommunications relay systems (28 CFR 35.161(b)).

All staff responsible for responding to incoming telephone calls should be trained in the protocol and use of TDD/TTY communications. Information and training should be provided on an ongoing basis.

The City should develop procedures to ensure that TDD/TTY are maintained in a working and operable condition.

32


WEBSITE Currently there are no adopted standards for websites that apply to Title II or Title III entities. However, numerous lawsuits have been filed recently, alleging discrimination due to websites not meeting the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), which apply to federal websites. Some decisions that make it to Federal Appeals Courts may be binding to all similar entities in that court jurisdiction. It is very likely that the WCAG will be the enforceable standard for all websites at some point in the future. It is highly recommended that all Title II and Title III entities work towards modifications to websites to meet WCAG sooner rather than later.

Self-Evaluation Findings: The City website home page address is www.oakridgetn.gov/default.aspx. The website includes a number

of pull-down menus and links that may be confusing for some people to use. Information about ADA is limited and is provided on the ‘Learn More About ADA Compliance’ page,

including the ADA Notice and Grievance Policy. A number of interactive features are included on the website, including payment of utility bills, bidding

on City surplus auction, property tax lookup, a variety of applications, applying for jobs, registering for Recreation & Parks programs, sign up for CodeRED, submittal of an emergency or crime in progress, sign up for Nixle Alert System, etc.

Documents available online in PDF format appear to be a mix of formats readable by a screen reader program, with many that include a signature (e.g., meeting minutes, resolutions) being scanned PDF documents that cannot be read by screen reading programs.

Content on the website is generally readable by the screen reader program NVDA. Some documents have paragraphs that read as expected where others provide no immediate program response. Moving the cursor within paragraphs of text sometimes provides the expected NVDA response when placed in the precise position.

Numerous forms and documents are provided by several departments via the website. Documents provided are not all readable by the screen reader program NVDA.

Running an accessibility check with the Web Accessibility Evaluation Tool (WAVE - wave.webaim.org/) generated the following information (see report for the home page on the next page). An unusually high number of errors was found, along with other limitations, such as structural elements, labels and description, and low contrast between text and backgrounds (which can be difficult for persons with certain visual impairments to read).

Links to a number of exterior websites can be found on the City website. The accessibility of those websites was not evaluated.

Links to exterior websites were found at the following department home pages: o Home Page – Customer Service Center, Animal Shelter,

Utility Bill Payment, Oak Ridge Chamber of Commerce, Explore Oak Ridge, Centennial Golf Course, Oak Ridge Schools, The Secret City Festival, and TVA Valley Sustainable Communities Program.

33


o Animal Shelter – Pets for Patriots and Shelter Animals Count. o Economic Development – Oak Ridge Chamber of Commerce, Oak Ridge Convention and Visitors

Bureau, Knoxville-Oak Ridge Innovation Valley of East Tennessee, Anderson County Economic Development Association, and The Roane Alliance Inc.

o Electric – Arbor day Foundation. o Legal – State of Tennessee Government, Tennessee Bar Association, Tennessee Court System and

Cases, and U.S. Supreme Court. o Library – Tennessee Electronic Library and Meet Libby. o Police – Lexis/Nexis Community Crime Map, Anderson County Sheriff’s Office Inmate Database,

Anderson County Sheriff’s Office 24 Arrest List, Anderson County Sheriff’s Office Home Page, and Roane County Sheriff’s Office Home Page.

o Public Works – Tennessee811. The website links to Facebook pages for the City of Oak Ridge Government, multiple Recreation & Parks

Department pages, Police Department, Public Library, Fire Department, Electric Department, Oak Ridge Senior Center, Centennial Golf Course, and likely others. The City Government, Centennial Golf Course, Fire Department, Public Library, Police, Recreation & Parks, Electric, and likely others also have a Twitter page. The Oak Ridge Government social media pages can be accessed directly from the website home page.

The City Facebook page is at www.facebook.com/CityofOakRidge. Several videos were found on the City website:

o The Library has a video regarding the U.S. Census Job Fair, which was closed-captioned. o A video envisioning a “Downtown Oak Ridge” is provided and is closed-captioned. o Recreation & Parks has a number of videos that contain only music with video and text being

presented on the screen and usable by persons with hearing loss without captioning. o Section 2.6 above discusses issues with City Council meeting live broadcasts and recorded video.

Recommended Action: The City’s website should be reviewed by the web developer to maintain, update, and monitor website

accessibility. When the website is redone, consider simplification in the presentation of the information. Less pulldown menus are desired. Also consider a “Documents” page that includes all documents the public would normally look for. The following may provide useful information: o Utilize an accessibility checklist similar to that published by the Access Board. o The University of Wisconsin Trace Center (https://minds.wisconsin.edu/handle/1793/6747) provides

resources and on-line information that might assist the City in development and implementation of an accessible website.

o The Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI) provides guidance on making websites fully accessible (www.w3.org/WAI/).

o The International Center for Disability Resources on the Internet (ICDRI) provides information on accessibility (www.icdri.org/section508/index.htm).

o The General Services Administration (GSA) provides resources on their website for development of compliant websites.

Ensure that all PDF documents are directly converted to PDF and not a scan of the original document. Scans are not compatible with many reader programs. Ensure that non-PDF format documents are properly formatted and usable by screen reader programs. Consider running a test of all documents to be posted to the website to ensure compliance and compatibility with screen readers prior to posting to the website.

Consider having the IT Department and other staff responsible for web content download NVDA or other commonly used screen reader program to test content (www.nvaccess.org/download/).

34


Consider adding a general disclaimer on the City website “The City of Oak Ridge cannot confirm the

accessibility of third party websites”. Consider adding a dedicated page for ADA and Title VI information that appears on the main City page.

ADA-related website content should include publicity of the statement of ADA compliance, contact information for the City ADA Coordinator, grievance and complaint procedures and form, publication of the self-evaluation and transition plan when completed, an annual list of ADA projects, and a list of the departments that offer TDD/TTY and the phone numbers.

Provide compliant captioning of all video live stream and video recordings provided on the website to allow persons with hearing loss to have access to this program of the City.

2.13 Alternate Communication Formats

A public entity has a responsibility to provide information in alternative formats to comply with 28 CFR 35.160. This section of the ADA requires state and local government entities to communicate effectively with individuals who are deaf, hard-of-hearing, or have a speech, vision, or learning disability. Communication access involves providing content in methods that are understandable and usable by people with reduced or no ability to: speak, see, or hear and limitations in learning and understanding. Some alternative formats can be produced in-house at minimal costs, i.e. large print, disks, and e-mail attachments. Other formats, such as Braille and audio-formats, may need to be produced by a vendor. Alternate communication formats that are likely to be requested include, but are not limited to: audio-formats, Braille, large print, captioned films and video, electronic text/disk/CD-ROM, or sign interpreted films and video.

Self-Evaluation Findings: The ADA Coordinator will be the main point of contact for requesting and providing information in

alternate formats on a request for accommodation basis and will communicate with other departments as needed.

The Library staff noted that they have provided a resident with a large print library application form in the past and now have a supply on hand.

Many City departments and offices produce printed information that is distributed and available to the public.

The City has not been asked to provide written materials and publications in Braille. No departments have a standard procedure to communicate and produce accessible alternate formats

for people with disabilities.

Recommended Action: The City should provide staff training regarding the requirements of accessible alternate formats, what

accessible alternate formats are, and how to provide accessible alternate formats. Procedures and methods should be established for the development of accessible alternate formats of

documents to ensure that requests are handled in a uniform and consistent manner. The City should centralize the production of alternate formats for agendas, publications, and documents,

which may result in efficiency and a cost savings.

2.14 Fees and Surcharges

Public entities may not charge a fee or add a surcharge to a fee to cover the cost of making its facilities, programs, services, or activities accessible to persons with disabilities (28 CFR 35.130(f)).

35


Self-Evaluation Findings: There was no evidence of fees charged to individuals with disabilities that were not charged to individuals

without disabilities to access programs, services, and activities.

Recommended Action: The City should continue to monitor and review policies and practices to ensure that fees and surcharges

are not charged to individuals with disabilities that were not charged to individuals without disabilities.

2.15 Information and Signage

A public entity is required to ensure that individuals with disabilities are directed to an accessible entrance to a building and to the location and existence of accessible services, activities, and facilities. The ISA shall be used at each accessible entrance of a facility (28 CFR 35.163). Paragraph (b) requires the public entity to provide signage at all inaccessible entrances to each of its facilities that directs users to an accessible entrance or to a location with information about accessible facilities.

Self-Evaluation Findings: Accessible directional and informational signs were not provided at all City facilities. Many facilities have

only one (1) entrance visible from accessible parking and are not a concern. For facilities with multiple exterior entrances visible from accessible parking, the accessible entrances should be clearly marked with the ISA on the door. Inaccessible or employee-only entrances should have directional signage located to avoid/minimize backtracking informing users where the accessible entrances are located (See Appendix A).

Signage within City buildings varies. Some of facilities provide mostly compliant signage, but other facilities frequently exhibit non-compliances including the following issues with signs: signage that is missing, signage mounted in the wrong location or wrong height, signs that provide no tactile characters and/or Braille, signs that have Braille or fonts that are not compliant, etc.

The accessibility map provided for the Municipal Building at www.oakridgetn.gov/images/uploads/Documents/Departments/City%20Manager/ADAparking.pdf is very hard to read and includes information not related to accessibility, such as location of fire, police, and staff parking, employee parking, etc.

Recommended Action: An accessible signing strategy for the non-compliant City facilities should be developed for interior and

exterior directional, informational, and permanent room signs. Design standards for accessible signs should be created to guide the production and installation of the

accessible signs. Signage replacement projects should include replacement or installation of accessible signs as required. Consider simplifying the accessibility map provided for the Municipal Building to include only accessibility

features, including location of accessible parking, the accessible entrance(s), and the accessible route from parking to the accessible entrance. All other information is not needed.

2.16 Staff Training

On-going compliance with the ADA can only be achieved if City staff receives training and education about the rights of persons with disabilities and the obligations of public entities and its employees under Title II of the ADA. Although specific training is not required by the ADA, training regarding the requirements of the ADA is strongly recommended to fully understand the City’s obligations for compliance.

36


Self-Evaluation Findings: City staff has attended the following training courses on various ADA topics:

o Personnel Department participate in Annual Legal/HR Update meetings, receive ADA bulletins, SHRM alerts, OSHA/TOSHA Updates, Worker’s Compensation/Disabilities Updates, and Risk Management Updates and have attended conferences with ADA updates.

o Several departments noted that they had staff attend an in-house ADA training in the summer 2019 provided by the Human Resources Department.

o The City Clerk attended a course entitled “Protecting Your Entity from ADA Lawsuits” at the Tennessee Association of Municipal Clerks and Recorders Fall Conference in September 2019.

o Recreation & Parks staff have received training through NRPA, MTAS, and others. Staff at the Senior Center regularly work with residents with disabilities and learn from them how to assist.

Police Department officers do not appear to receive any specialized training for recognizing or dealing with members of the public that have a disability.

Several departments suggested in-house education for employees on ADA-related topics. Several departments indicated an overall training on disabilities covered by the ADA and responsibilities

for accommodation, including planning ahead for accommodation where possible, would be helpful.

Recommended Action: The ADA Coordinator and other key staff should consider annual training on various ADA issues relevant

to their respective department responsibilities. The City should provide training regarding ADA and related civil rights legislation. Suggested training

topics include, but are not limited to: o Requirements of the ADA for Oak Ridge as a Title II entity o Consequences of Non-Compliance o Disability Etiquette – a good resource is www.unitedspinal.org/disability-etiquette/ o Acceptable Terminology and Phrases o Grievance/Complaint Procedures o Reasonable Accommodations o Awareness and Sensitivity o Accessible Locations for Meetings o Barriers to Access – Programmatic and Physical o Auxiliary Aids and Services o TDD/TTY o Building Evacuation Procedures to Assist Persons with Disabilities, especially in multi-story buildings

with public access to upper floors Building and engineering inspectors and plan reviewers should be familiar with the requirements of ADA

standards and guidelines that pertain to the facilities they are responsible for. This would include ensuring compliance with the most stringent regulation (ADA-specific at a minimum) for City facilities constructed by City or private contractors prior to acceptance or approval.

Training materials and handbooks should be prepared, if needed, in alternate formats. The ADA Coordinator should coordinate additional ADA training for all Department managers and staff

who have regular contact with the public. It is recommended that Police Department officers receive training annually on ADA accessibility issues

related to their activities. Training could include how to interact with people with mental illnesses and disabilities, addictive disorders, autism, and developmental disabilities, communicating with people who are deaf or hard of hearing (reference www.ada.gov/lawenfcomm.pdf), and developing a policy on the topic as well (refer to www.ada.gov/lawenfmodpolicy.pdf). Review of other guidance should be done as

37


well, including the publication “Commonly Asked Questions About the Americans with Disabilities Act and Law Enforcement” (www.ada.gov/qanda_law.pdf).

Additional training materials may be made available to officers on “Disabilities and Law Enforcement”, which is available on the U.S. Department of Justice web site (www.ada.gov/policeinfo.htm).

2.17 Emergency Evacuation Procedures

The City is required to establish emergency evacuation procedures to safely evacuate persons with disabilities who may need special assistance in an emergency. These plans and procedures should include identification of assembly locations for persons with disabilities in each facility, staff assigned to ensure that assembly areas are checked prior to leaving buildings during an emergency, identification of assembly locations for pickup and transport of persons with disabilities, and location of accessible shelters to be used for various types of emergencies. Depending on the nature of the emergency, some shelters may not be appropriate.

Self-Evaluation Findings: The City of Oak Ridge is bisected by the border of Anderson and

Roane County, with a majority of properties lying within Anderson County. A copy of the Anderson County Basic Emergency Operations Plan (BEOP) dated 2014 was downloaded from the county website and reviewed. No copy of the Roane County BEOP was found or reviewed.

Several departments in Oak Ridge coordinate emergency responses with the Anderson County Emergency Management Agency (EMA). The EMA is tasked by Tennessee Emergency Management Agency to coordinate and carry out a comprehensive plan to assist community efforts to prepare for, respond to, and recover from all types of man-made and natural disasters. This assistance is accomplished through planning, training, grant funding, and mitigation.

The Anderson County Emergency Operations Center (EOC) is the central location where multi-agency coordination occurs in an emergency. The purpose of the EOC is to provide a central coordination hub for the support of local emergency response activities and is located at 111 South Charles G. Seivers Boulevard in Clinton. The alternate EOC site is the Oak Ridge Municipal Building, Fire Department EOC, 200 South Tulane Avenue in Oak Ridge.

City agencies/personnel that provide emergency services coordinators (ESC) or are identified in the BEOP as support agencies/persons for various Emergency Support Functions (ESFs) include the Finance Department, City Attorney, Building Inspectors, Police Department, Utility Department, Fire Department, Public Works Department, Wastewater and Water Treatment, Animal Control, City Manager, and Mayor.

The City has an Emergency Operations Plan (EOP), draft dated February 18, 2020. A review of the draft document found the following items of note: o The City will work closely with both Anderson and Roane counties during emergency/disaster

situations. o The Transportation section specifically notes that ‘Oak Ridge City school buses will be utilized for the

evacuation of residents of nursing homes, assisted living centers, . . .and patients of Methodist Medical Center when evacuation is needed.’

o The Emergency Operations Center (EOC) is the City Municipal Building.

Guide is available HERE

38


o The EOP notes that ‘Shelters have been identified and approved by Anderson/Roane County Public

Health and Emergency Management.’ There was no indication of whether those facilities have been verified to be accessible.

o Several Emergency Support Functions (ESFs) include various provisions related to transportation (ESF #1), Communications (ESF #2), Mass Care, Housing, and Human Services (ESF #6), Public Health and Medical Services (ESF #8), and Food (ESF #11) have provisions related to the disabled. Several ESFs were not complete that also should have similar provisions, including Animal Care Services and Disease Management (ESF #16).

o ESF #6 includes specific information related to “Special Needs Populations”, identifying 6 general categories total. It is stated that this ESF addresses 2 of the categories but the only one mentioned are those with Limited English Proficiency.

o ESF #8 includes a specific section entitled “Special Needs Populations”. It includes four specific groups, including the following. The ESF mentions the responsibilities of various organizations for the care of special needs patients. Sensory impaired (includes sight or hearing loss) Mobility impaired (includes persons who utilize a mobility device, are bedridden, etc.) Mentally impaired (includes persons with various cognitive disabilities, such as Down Syndrome,

autism, etc.) Miscellaneous impairments (includes persons who depend on medications such as insulin, blood

pressure medication, etc.) The Oak Ridge Recreation & Parks Department has emergency plans for their facilities that were

developed with assistance by the Fire Department. Oak Ridge participates in the CodeRED program, which allows residents to enroll and receive emergency

alerts and notifications. A link to the CodeRED registration page is provided on the City website at oakridgetn.gov/department/FireDept/Safety/CodeRED.

There does not appear to be a comprehensive list of homebound clients and group homes that may need additional assistance during an emergency.

Based on departmental questionnaire responses and observations during facility evaluations, it appears that many City facilities have plans in place for special preparation for emergency events, such as pre-determined meeting places, drills, and safety coordinators for each building. At most City facilities, fire escape signage and information on tornado and lockdown procedure is provided but is visual only. Generally, the evacuation routes are identified on a building layout diagram. Established procedures are in place for a variety of emergencies. However, it does not appear all departments have established emergency evacuation procedures to specifically address safe evacuation of persons with disabilities.

Recommended Action: Work with Anderson County EMA to address issues specifically related to the disabled population in the

County, including identification of these individuals and where they live, ensuring availability of vehicles able to accommodate wheelchairs and other specialized medical equipment in the event of an evacuation, accessiblity of emergency shelters that must include accessible shower/bathing facilities for the disabled if shower/bathing facilities are provided, and availability of shelters to accommodate persons with service animals.

Ensure that the update to the City’s EOP includes speicific information related to the special needs of the disabled during the various types of emergency situations. Examples could include: o Involving persons with disabilities and their advocates and caregivers in planning for emergencies. o Identify potential sources of equipment that can be made available for persons with disabilities in the

event of an emergency. This equipment could include wheelchairs, walkers, etc. that might be left behind at homes or damaged during an evacuation.

39


o Determine the feasibility of a voluntary, confidential

registration of residents that would need special assistance during an evacuation or emergency that required utilization of temporary or longer-term sheltering. This may be an option in the registration on the CodeRED system but could also be a database prepared and maintained by the City Police and Fire Department.

o Ensure that designated shelters are accessible and able to meet the needs of persons with disabilities, including those with service animals.

o Consider the potential special food and dietary requirements for some persons with disabilities in the provision of food in the event of an emergency.

o Seek out volunteers with special training to assist persons with disabilities in all phases of an emergency and particularly at shelters, including American Sign Language (ASL) interpreters, mental health services, etc.

Revisit emergency plans and signage for each facility. Include guidelines for the evacuation of persons with disabilities for various emergency situations. Verify on a regular basis that each department is aware of what to do when an alarm is triggered; aware of meeting places for assistance and evacuation at staircases; and have identified floor captains who will ensure that each floor is vacated prior to leaving themselves and ensuring that persons that need assistance are removed to safety or sheltered safely until emergency personnel can evacuate them.

Include persons with disabilities and their advocates and caregivers in planning for emergencies.

City staff responsible for coordination with the Anderson County EMA Director should review and complete the Title II Emergency Management checklist at www.ada.gov/pcatoolkit/chap7emergencymgmtadd1.htm for additional information about ensuring the BEOP considers persons with disabilities adequately.

Excellent additional resources can be found at: o FEMA o www.ada.gov/emergencyprepguide.htm o http://hfcdhp.org/emergency-preparedness/ o onlinepubs.trb.org/onlinepubs/tcrp/tcrp_rpt_150.pdf o www.nad.org/resources/emergency-preparedness/ o www.tn.gov/health/cedep/cedep-emergency-

preparedness/tennessee-disaster-support-network/during-a-disaster.html o www.tn.gov/health/cedep/cedep-emergency-preparedness/tennessee-disaster-support-

network/pre-disaster-planning.html



40


2.18 Employment

Title I of the ADA requires public entities not to discriminate against persons with disabilities in all parts of the recruitment and employment process (28 CFR 35.140 and 29 CFR 1630.4). It is recommended that employment-related items be discussed with a labor attorney and/or human resources specialist familiar with ADA and case law related to essential job functions, reasonable employee accommodation, and other employment issues. The findings and recommendations below are based on limited knowledge of these issues but warrant mention and consideration to allow the City to further evaluate the need for potential updates and/or changes.

Self-Evaluation Findings: The City home page has a button for “Employment”. The page has the following language under ‘Equal

Employment Opportunity’ – ‘The City of Oak Ridge provides equal employment and advancement opportunities to all individuals. Employment decisions will be based on merit, qualifications and abilities. The City of Oak Ridge does not discriminate in employment opportunities or practices on the basis of race, sex, religion, color, national origin, age, ancestry, sexual orientation, or disability protected by law.’

The City Personnel Department performs functions of human resources by providing services to job applicants, City employees, and retirees.

The City of Oak Ridge Personnel Plan (as amended through 10/23/2019) includes (note emphasis added): o Article 7 Recruitment, Selection, and Appointment of Employees, Section 7.1 Recruitment Policy, A.

Removal from Consideration: includes the statement, ‘The City may remove from further consideration any applicant who: d. Is unable to perform the essential functions of the position with or without reasonable accommodation.’.

o Article 7 Recruitment, Selection, and Appointment of Employees, Section 7.2 Selection Policy, A. No Discrimination: includes the statement, ‘The City shall not discriminate because of race, color, gender, religion, age, national origin, sexual orientation, marital status, veteran status or because of a disability which will not interfere with the performance of essential job functions. All applicants for a position shall be evaluated against the same qualification requirements.’.

o Article 9 Terminations and Disciplinary Actions, Section 9.1 Terminations, c. Disability: includes the statement, ‘Disability. An employee may be terminated for disability when the required duties are not performed because of physical or mental impairment. Action may be initiated by the employee, a legal representative, or the City, but in all cases must be supported by medical evidence acceptable to the City Manager. The City may require an examination at its’ expense and performed by a physician of its’ choice.’.

o Article 10 Grievance Procedure outlines the process for reconciling personnel issues. A grievance is defined in Section 10.2 as ‘A complaint by an employee that there has been a violation, misapplication or misinterpretation of existing policies, rules, regulations, laws, or the Personnel Plan/Ordinance, resulting in an adverse personnel action; or a complaint by an employee that the employee's health or safety has been jeopardized by conditions which should be corrected by the City.’. Section 10.3 describes the Grievance Procedure, which is not specific nor exclusive of grievances related to disabilities. No indication was provided that the City has a standard Grievance Form for grievances related to employment issues.

o Article 13 Conduct of Employees, Section 5. No Harassment: includes the statement, ‘The City of Oak Ridge is committed to providing a workplace free of harassment based on race, color, creed, religion, sex, national origin, sexual orientation, disability, age or other legally protected status. . . Harassment is a form of discrimination and is prohibited by law. Discrimination is any distinction, whether intentional or not, based on prohibited grounds (race, color, creed, religion, sex, national origin, sexual orientation, disability, age or other legally protected status) which has the effect of imposing

41


burdens, obligations or disadvantages on an individual that are not imposed on others, or which withholds or limits access to opportunities, benefits and advantages available to others.’

The City does not appear to have an Accommodation Request Form available for employees in the event they want to request an accommodation in the workplace.

A poster entitled “Equal Opportunity is the Law”, defining the requirements of Title VII, is located in most City buildings.

The Job Openings section includes a listing of all positions for which applications are being accepted. In order to apply, a prospective applicant must create a free account with the City. The only application process provided was on the City website, no hard copy forms are known to exist.

The Employment Application includes the statement ‘It is the policy of the company to afford equal opportunity to all employees and applicants for employment without regard to age, race, religion, color, sex, national origin, marital status, expunged juvenile records, or pregnancy and to afford equal opportunities to disabled veterans, veterans of the Vietnam era, individuals with a disability, and any other characteristics protected by Federal, State, and Local law.’.

Review of various examples of job descriptions for positions at the City of Oak Ridge noted the following relevant items: o Job descriptions appear to be prepared by City staff. Job descriptions are dated as far back as 2002,

but all that were reviewed were last updated in 2018. o All job descriptions include the headings “Position Summary”, “Essential Functions”, “Knowledge,

Skills, and Abilities”, “Language Skills”, “Mathematical Skills”, “Reasoning Ability”, “Required Education, Experience, Licensing, and Certifications”, and “Physical and Work Environment”. Each section includes a written description and several sections provide specific information or examples of various knowledge, abilities, and skills required and examples of work.

o The “Essential Functions” section includes the statement “The following duties are normal for this position. These are not to be construed as exclusive or all-inclusive. To perform this job successfully, an individual must be able to perform each duty satisfactorily. Other duties may be required and assigned.” The section often includes an extensive list of duties and tasks that would not be essential for the specific person in the position to be responsible for and also typically includes ‘Other duties as assigned.’.

o The “Physical and Work Environment” section includes the statement ‘The physical and work environment characteristics described in this description are representative of those an employee encounters while performing the essential functions of this job. Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable individuals with disabilities to perform the essential functions or as otherwise required by law. Employees needing reasonable accommodation should discuss the request with the employee’s supervisor.’ The statement regarding “reasonable accommodation” are not in the correct location and not pertinent to the physical and work environment. This statement should be provided in the “Essential Functions” section of the job description.

o Most job descriptions for less specialized, administrative assistants, clerical (entry and lower level positions) in the “Physical and Work Environment” section list requirements that persons with some disabilities cannot meet, including: ‘work regularly requires sitting, frequently requires standing, speaking or hearing, using hands

to finger, handle or feel and repetitive motions and occasionally requires walking, stooping, kneeling, crouching or crawling and reaching with hands and arms, etc.

‘Work has standard vision requirements’ ‘Vocal communication is required for expressing or exchanging ideas by means of the spoken

word.’ ‘Hearing is required to perceive information at normal spoken word levels.’, etc.

42


Some of these requirements may exclude anyone with some disabilities from being qualified to perform many jobs that do not actually require the ability to meet all these physical demands. There are some jobs where these physical requirements could be essential (police officer, building inspector, paramedic, etc.) but others would be difficult to justify.

o “Normal” and other subjective terms are not defined in any way and could easily be subjectively applied or interpreted.

Recommended Action: The City should continue to practice the City policies of non-discrimination as required by ADA and other

applicable laws. Consider developing a grievance form that includes all required information consistent with the grievance

procedure for both employees and non-employees to utilize. The City should continue to practice the City policies of non-discrimination as required by ADA and other

applicable laws. Members of the public, including individuals with disabilities and groups representing individuals with

disabilities, should be encouraged to submit suggestions to the City ADA Coordinator and HR Department on how the City might better meet the needs of individuals with disabilities pursuant to employment policies.

Consider modifications to some language in the City of Oak Ridge Personnel Plan, including: o The Plan includes minimal information relevant to ADA. Consider a dedicated section entitled “ADA

Compliance” when the document is updated in the future. Consider adding language in appropriate locations to clarify that reasonable accommodation may include: making facilities readily accessible to individuals with a disability, restructuring jobs, modifying work schedules, modifying equipment, or other similar accommodations.

o Consider including a basic statement of non-discrimination such as “It is the policy of the City of Oak Ridge that qualified individuals with disabilities not be excluded from participation in or benefit from the services, programs, or activities of the City. It is the policy of the City of Oak Ridge not to discriminate against a qualified individual with a disability in: job application procedures; the hiring, advancement or discharge of employees; employee compensation; job training; and other terms, conditions and privileges of employment. It is the intent of the City to comply with all applicable requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).“

o Employee requests for an accommodation should be required to be submitted in writing on the ADA Accommodation Request Form and noted as such in the Personnel Rules.

o Consider changing the wording in Article 7 Recruitment, Selection, and Appointment of Employees, Section 7.1 Recruitment Policy, A. Removal from Consideration to read ‘d. Is unable to perform the essential functions of the position with or without reasonable accommodation.’. There is no basis for removing a person from consideration without reasonable accommodation, as this could be discriminatory for an otherwise qualified individual.

o Consider changing the wording in Article 7 Recruitment, Selection, and Appointment of Employees, Section 7.2 Selection Policy, A. No Discrimination to read ‘‘The City shall not discriminate because of race, color, gender, religion, age, national origin, sexual orientation, marital status, veteran status or because of a disability which will not interfere with the performance of essential job functions. All applicants for a position shall be evaluated against the same qualification requirements.’.’. By their very nature a disability will likely interfere with performance of essential job functions but the issue is whether they can be reasonably accommodated.

o Consider changing the wording in Article 9 Terminations and Disciplinary Actions, Section 9.1 Terminations, c. Disability to read ‘Disability. An employee may be terminated if they become disabled for disability when the employee can no longer perform the essential functions of the

43


position with reasonable accommodation and there are no other positions for which the employee is otherwise qualified for, and able to perform essential job functions for, with or without reasonable accommodation required duties are not performed because of physical or mental impairment. Action may be initiated by the employee, a legal representative, or the City, but in all cases must be supported by medical evidence acceptable to the City Manager. The City may require an examination at its’ expense and performed by a physician of its’ choice.’

Ensure that a poster entitled “Equal Opportunity is the Law”, defining the requirements of Title VII, is located in every City building.

The City should consider carefully examining and updating all job descriptions. Updates could include modernizing language to simplify the existing information as often suggested by HR professionals at the National ADA Symposium as well as a job analysis to ensure accuracy of information relied upon to update job descriptions, if needed. Update as needed to ensure that all job descriptions: o Simplify the layout of job descriptions to include three (3) basic major categories:

Summary of the position – reason for/function of the position, purpose, role, how it fits with the operations of the organization, etc.

Essential Job Functions – methods, techniques, procedures and/or tools to complete the job, time allowed to perform functions, how often function is performed, how success is measured

Job Specifications/Qualifications – qualifications, skills and required abilities, educational criteria, certifications/licensure requirements, specialized knowledge/experience, environmental, psychological, and/or physiological requirements, etc.

o Provide job functions identified as ‘Essential’ based on documentable evidence about the existence of the position for performance of the function, the limited number of employees that can perform the function, and the specialization and expertise required to perform the function. Further evidence would include employer judgment, amount of time performing the function, the consequences being serious if an infrequently performed function is not performed when needed, etc.

o Ensure that ‘Other Duties as Assigned’ is not included as an essential job function. o Do not include marginal or peripheral functions of positions within Essential Job Functions area,

though these lesser functions can be included elsewhere if appropriate. o Use clear, concise, non-technical language and avoid gender-specific language, jargon, technical

language, ambiguity, and language that may screen out individuals with disabilities. o Updates should include “ADA Compliant Language”. Examples include modifying statements such as

‘stand or sit’ to ‘stationary position’, ‘talk/hear’ to ‘communicate, convey, express oneself, exchange information’, ‘use hands/fingers to handle or feel’ to ‘operate, activate, use, prepare, inspect, detect, position’, ‘see’ to detect, perceive, identify, recognize, observe, inspect, assess’, ‘carry or lift’ to ‘transport, move, position, put, install’.

o Ensure requirements in all sections are actual requirements of the position and avoid use of subjective words such as ‘normal’ when describing visual acuity, hearing, etc. Determine need for requirements such as sense of smell or taste, depth and/or texture perception, color perception, etc., which for many jobs is unlikely to be needed to perform the duties of the job.

o Review which jobs require a valid driver’s license or commercial driver’s license and remove the requirement from jobs that do not, instead substituting the requirement for a valid photo ID.

An excellent resource to review when considering updates or modifications to various documents, including job descriptions, is the Job Assistance Network at https://askjan.org/topics/jobdesc.cfm and the U.S Department of Labor, Office of Disability Employment Policy at https://www.dol.gov/odep/#.

44


2.19 Department Self-Evaluation Findings and Recommendations

DLZ distributed a questionnaire to the ADA Coordinator that requested information about various departments, policies, and procedures of the City. This information included departmental specific items to provide information to help DLZ better understand the policies and procedures of each related to ADA understanding, training, and accommodation (see Appendix C). DLZ reviewed responses and coordinated clarifications and questions with the ADA Coordinator. The questionnaire also allows DLZ to gain an understanding of how well the person completing the questionnaire understands the obligation to ensure their programs are accessible and how to provide accommodations. Additional inquiries were also made during the facility evaluations. A general summary follows.

Self-Evaluation Findings: The City has numerous departments with extensive, daily public interaction both in person and over the

telephone. No departments responded that the programs offered for persons with disabilities were different in any

way. The City has no ADA Committee comprised of individuals from several departments or Citizens

Committee comprised of residents with disabilities, advocates, and caregivers. Many departments have publications, documents, and forms that are reviewed, provided, or submitted

to them by the public. Many of these documents are completed at office service counters, which are frequently non-compliant (See Appendix A).

No City boards or commissions appear to include an ADA statement on agendas. No accommodation requests appear to have been made during public meetings.

Recommended Action: Public interactions with persons needing special accommodation due to a disability is likely to occur for

all departments at some point. Training should be provided to all departments to review how to accommodate various disabilities and provide the same level of service.

All departments should have a liaison identified that will interact with the ADA Coordinator and be responsible for ADA compliance in their department.

Continue to ensure that all programs offered do not segregate customers with disabilities and provide the same type and level of service.

Ensure that all publications, documents, and forms that are provided to the public can be made available in alternate formats easily. This would include large print versions and electronic versions in multiple file formats. All departments should have an accessible workspace or clipboard that can be provided to someone that cannot reach counters that are above required height until such time that counter heights are made compliant.

All departments evaluated have barriers present, nearly all of which can be addressed by architectural modifications, various methods of equal accommodation, or changes in procedures.

Funding will be a key component in some instances but many improvements in service to persons with disabilities can be done inexpensively and within a short timeframe.

The report includes a number of ways that departments can accommodate persons with various disabilities, but circumstances and barriers vary between departments. Training of staff is a key component to knowing how to accommodate and provide equal service to persons with disabilities of all kinds.

Plan reviewers, inspectors, etc. that review plans and inspect buildings and sites should have adequate knowledge of the applicable standards in ADASAD (and PROWAG for ROW facilities) and special training as needed to ensure compliance with all requirements.

45


2.20 Facility Self-Evaluation Findings and Recommendations

DLZ performed a self-evaluation of the following City facilities. A comprehensive review of accessibility at all public areas of these facilities was performed consistent with ADASAD. Specific information by facility can be found in Appendix A. City Facilities (Owned, Leased, or Hosting Programs)

Municipal Building & Police Department 1010 Incubator Building Animal Shelter Badger Building Baseball Complex Central Services Civic Center/Recreation Building Fire Station 1 Fire Station 2 Fire Station 3 Fire Station 4 Centennial Golf Course Public Library Scarboro Community Center Wastewater Treatment Plant Water Filtration Plant

City Parks Alvin K. Bissell Park

Big Turtle Park Briarcliff Park Carl Yearwood Park Cedar Hill Park Elm Grove Park Elza Gate Park Groves Park at South Hills Haw Ridge Park Highland View Park LaSalle Park Melton Lake Park Milt Dickens Park Pinewood Park Municipal Swimming Pool Scarboro Park Solway Park Tennis Courts

Recommended General Actions: Specific priorities for each facility and corrections needed, with planning level costs, to fully comply with

ADA standards are included in the following section of this report and the appendices. In some cases, comprehensive costs for alteration of some spaces, especially restrooms, may not be

possible due to additional investigation required outside the scope of an ADA self-evaluation. Additional investigations required for spaces that need to be enlarged by removing a wall could include structural review for load bearing, review of plumbing or ductwork in the wall, etc. Appendix A identifies the cost for these items as “TBD”.

There are many interim fixes that can be implemented immediately to address various deficiencies and provide equal access to all users until permanent solutions are implemented. Other improvements are relatively low cost and should also be considered for implementation in early phases of the Transition Plan. These include: o Restripe parking lots to provide compliant spaces and access aisles, with proper signage, at locations

closest to accessible entrances at all facilities. When a facility has multiple parking lots, precedence should be given to the lots that have the most use by the public and are closest to facility entrances or amenities. However, all lots that serve an accessible entrance must provide accessible spaces.

o Develop a master signage plan for all facilities that includes exterior directional signage to accessible entrances and required signage within each facility. Ensure that at least one entrance at all facilities is fully accessible until the required 60% of public entrances can be made accessible and that non-accessible entrances are adequately signed to direct the public to the accessible entrance(s).

46


o Work closely with TDOT to ensure that public ROW facilities along state routes within the City,

including on-street parking, sidewalks, pedestrian signals, and curb ramps, are compliant, or made compliant, based on maintenance agreements.

o For objects that protrude inside buildings, either move these items closer to the floor where they are cane detectable, move them outside the pedestrian circulation route in buildings, or place a permanent object that is cane detectable below them. Ensure that vegetation is trimmed so it does not protrude into the path of circulation outside of facilities.

o Provide a cup dispenser at all interior non-compliant drinking fountains below 48” height at a level location that can be used by anyone at functional drinking fountains, along with a waste container, until a new compliant hi-lo drinking fountain is installed. Note that this is a very short-term solution since some users may not be able to utilize a cup to drink for various reasons.

o Develop a lockset replacement plan for all doors that have knobs and/or locks that require grasping and turning to operate. In rooms with doors that have knobs, ensure staff can see into the hallway in the event someone on the outside cannot open the door. Consider a policy that doors with non-compliant hardware are left open at all times during business hours.

o In rooms with light switches above 48” that are operated by the public, consider installation of occupancy sensors and timer controls for lighting control. The 1991 ADAAG allows up to 54” height, so in many cases this recommendation is not required until the space is altered.

o In areas that have all electrical outlets below 15” and/or above 48”, consider mounting a power strip or extension cord to the wall that is accessible within the required height range. This is especially important in today’s electronic age, with people often looking to charge their mobile devices.

o Ensure that compliant pedestrian routes exist from parking to the accessible entrances for all buildings. This may entail new construction or reconstruction of existing sidewalks.

o Determine if adjustments can be made to interior door closers to reduce the opening pressure to 5 pounds or less and/or slow the closing time to at least 5 seconds from 90 degrees open to 12 degrees from closure. If this cannot be attained, a new closer will need to be purchased and installed. Closers can also be removed from some doors.

o Review corrective actions needed for at least one accessible set of restrooms for each facility initially and provide signage to direct persons from non-accessible restrooms to the accessible one. Depending on the size and use of a facility, one set may not be adequate and one set per floor or wing may be more appropriate.

o Ensure that all public assembly areas (meeting rooms) with audio amplification have the proper number and types of assistive listening devices available and signage is installed alerting people where they are available.

o Consider automatic door openers at facilities with inadequate space in alcoves, excessive opening force requirements, or closing speeds that are too fast for exterior doors.

o Ensure that all departments that have public contact at service counters with a surface above 34” have compliant work surfaces available for persons to complete paperwork or review documents. A clipboard can be used as an accommodation temporarily until the counter can be altered.

o Move furniture or other obstructions that could be in the way of required clear spaces for persons using wheelchairs, such as door maneuvering spaces, operable parts of various items, etc.

o Lower or install an additional coat hook in each restroom stall and room where coats may be hung on the wall that is at 48” maximum height.

o Consider installation of kick plates and filler strip on the push side of all doors with glass or vents below 10” above the floor to prevent glass breakage by wheelchair users.

47


o Reposition items in restrooms that are too high, including soap dispensers, mirrors, paper towel

dispensers, etc. In some instances, it may be less costly to provide an additional amenity within compliant height (e.g., add a second mirror on different wall, install a second soap dispenser, etc.).

48


3.0 Self-Evaluation of Pedestrian Facilities within the Public ROW – Project Approach

This section of the SETP summarizes the approach for review of existing ROW facilities. The findings and recommendations contained in Sections 3-5 will provide the basis for the implementation of specific improvements for pedestrian access within the public ROW. Detailed information about sidewalk and curb ramp findings is provided in Section 4 and 5, respectively, with this section providing detailed information about other ROW elements. Additional elements that may be encountered during right-of-way evaluation include site furnishings, accessible pedestrian signals, transit stops, roundabouts, marked or metered on-street parking, and rail crossings. Pedestrian signals and trolley stop were assessed in detail (see more this section). Other features were assessed and included in the sidewalk evaluation described above, specifically excluded as part of the scope of this project, or were not present (e.g., no on-street parking in the City is marked or metered).

Site furnishings included benches, bicycle racks, and trash receptacles primarily in the downtown area. All site furnishings observed complied with reach range and clearances and did not obstruct the PAR. Furnishings should be located on an accessible route, provide clear level ground space for approaches and wheelchair parking adjacent to benches, and meet reach range requirements for any operable parts, such as trash receptacle flaps.

3.1 Data Collection and Methodology

All ROW pedestrian facilities were inventoried and assessed using PROWAG, dated July 26, 2011, as published by United States Access Board. Data collection was completed using tablets and applications to record the location of each data collection point, the numerical data, and to correlate the data with a photo of the facility inventoried. The GeoJot+ application by GeoSpatial Experts was used for data collection. The GeoJot+ application provided a platform for the creation of ADA specific attribute lists to track inventory data. Data collection was completed for most facilities in place prior to the 2019 construction season. Facilities added or modified after this date should be monitored for compliance by the City at time of construction.

3.2 Database Analysis

Upon completion of the Inventory and Assessment, the data collected was compiled into a summary for each data collection point or location. Throughout the SETP, ‘location’ refers to a single data collection point. This may be a block, a portion thereof with logical stopping point, such as an alley or area with no sidewalk present, curb ramp, intersection or non-roadway related portion of public ROW. Each location was reviewed for compliance with each criterion required within the PROWAG. A barrier ranking (High, Medium, or Low priority) was assigned to the location. Each location was then assigned a cost parameter based on the amount of modification or reconstruction required to achieve accessibility.

3.3 Barrier Ranking

The self-evaluation of the public ROW takes into account factors such as level of use, degree to which accessibility is limited, complaints or requests for repair received, and other factors. These factors can be grouped into two categories. Contributing contextual factors account for use patterns and distribution in relation to City services, residential zones, schools, and other public services. Physical Impedance factors include the actual physical characteristics of the specific right-of-way feature and the severity of the barrier to use.

49


Contributing Contextual Factors:

Areas of High Pedestrian Activity – High priority areas include areas with high levels of pedestrian traffic. These included, but are not limited to, those areas adjacent to downtown, schools, community centers, churches, public transportation hubs, retail centers, and parks.

Areas with a Higher Concentration of persons with disabilities – High priority areas include senior centers, assisted living communities, and areas adjacent to medical facilities.

Areas of High Volume Streets – High priority areas include the pedestrian facilities along major arterial streets. These are frequently the connectors between residential areas and destinations such as shopping centers, employment, and medical centers.

Areas accessing Places of Public Accommodation – High priority areas include those pedestrian facilities serving local government offices and facilities, such as municipal office buildings, public libraries, and community centers.

Physical Impedance Factors:

High priority – High priority areas include areas with conditions that make travel difficult or impossible for the independent pedestrian and affect the ability of persons with disabilities to access or use a facility or program, or are generally hazardous for any pedestrian. These include, but are not limited to, missing curb ramps, steep slopes (especially cross slopes), changes in level over 1”, and fixed obstructions limiting vertical and horizontal clearance, trip hazards, and major protrusions.

Medium priority – Medium priority areas include areas with conditions that make travel moderately difficult, but passable and affect the quality of usage for persons with disabilities to a greater extent than that afforded the non-disabled. These include, but are not limited to, moderate deviations in running and cross slopes, changes in level ½” to 1”, obstructions that allow tight passage, landing and PAR width deviations.

Low priority – Low priority areas include areas with conditions that deviate from codes and standards but alternative means of use may be available to provide equal access or opportunities. In low priority areas, conditions may be an inconvenience, but neither travel nor safety is greatly impacted. These areas allow significant usability and independent travel is possible in most cases. These included, but are not limited to, minor deviations in running and cross slopes, changes in level, landings and PAR width deviations, and presence of standard elements such as detectable warnings not in compliance with guidelines.

3.4 Accessible Pedestrian Signals

Pedestrian signals were not included in the 1991 or 2010 ADA Standards, but are addressed in the 2011 PROWAG and the previous draft documents from 2005 and 2002. This document also incorporates by reference sections of the 2009 Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD). Note that per R209.2 of PROWAG, existing pedestrian signals shall comply with the referenced sections of MUTCD only when altered, specifically when the signal controller and software are altered, or the signal head is replaced. Requirements: According to PROWAG, ‘An accessible pedestrian signal and pedestrian push button is an integrated device that communicates information about the WALK and DON’T WALK intervals at signalized intersections in non-visual formats (i.e., audible tones and vibro-tactile surfaces) to pedestrians who are blind and have low vision.’ Per R209, ‘where pedestrian signals are provided at pedestrian street crossings, they shall include accessible pedestrian signals (APS) and pedestrian push buttons complying with sections 4E.08 through 4E.13 of the 2009 Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD)’. When the City plans infrastructure improvement projects where new pedestrian signal construction or alterations of existing pedestrian signals

50


including signal controller, software, or signal head replacement occurs, accessible pedestrian signals must be provided. To determine compliance of existing pedestrian signals with Sections 4E.08 through 4E.13 of the MUTCD, the following characteristics were evaluated. Note that not all existing pedestrian signals are required to meet these standards at this time but were evaluated to these current standards. Function: Per MUTCD, accessible pedestrian signal

detectors may be pushbuttons or passive detection devices. At accessible pedestrian signal locations where pedestrian pushbuttons are used, each pushbutton shall activate both the walk interval and the accessible pedestrian signals.

Location: On an accessible route and there is an adjacent level clear space to the push button.

Distance from curb: Between 1.5’ and 6’ from edge of curb, shoulder, or pavement, 10’ max if impractical.

Distance from crosswalk: Between edge of crosswalk line farthest from intersection to 5’ max. beyond. Distance between pushbuttons: 10’ min. separation where two are provided on the same corner, if less,

special provisions apply. Height and orientation of pushbutton: Face parallel to crosswalk to be used, height of approx. 42” with

48” max. ht.) Pushbutton Operating Force: 5 lbs. max. Pedestrian pushbuttons shall be a minimum of 2 inches across in one dimension and shall contrast

visually with their housing or mounting. Audible WALK Indications: Percussive tone if pushbuttons are separated by at least 10’; speech message

if less. Vibrotactile Arrow: Located on the pushbutton, have high visual contrast (light on dark or dark on light),

shall be aligned parallel to the direction of travel on the associated crosswalk, and vibrates during walk interval.

Locator Tone: duration of 0.15 seconds or less repeating at 1-second intervals, intensity responsive to ambient sound, and be audible 6 to 12 feet from the pushbutton, or to the building line, whichever is less.

Pushbutton Signage: Signs shall be Integral and adjacent to pushbuttons and include a tactile arrow aligned parallel to the crosswalk direction. The arrow shall be raised 0.03 inches minimum and shall be 1-1/2” inches minimum in length. The arrowhead shall be open at 45 degrees to the shaft and shall be 33 percent of the length of the shaft. Stroke width shall be 10 percent minimum and 15 percent maximum of arrow length. The arrow shall contrast with the background.

Pilot Light: If provided, illuminated only at activation, remain illuminated until WALK signal indication is displayed, accompanied by speech message to ‘WAIT’.

51


Self-Evaluation Findings: A total of 30 intersections (140 locations/quadrants) had

pedestrian signals in one or more quadrants. Most signals include pushbuttons though there are some locations with a combination of pedestrian-activated pushbuttons and pedestrian signal heads that cycle with every traffic signal cycle. None have passive detection.

Several of the pedestrian signals have been installed or altered recently and they do not meet all of the current standards. Some of those installed recently may have been installed by TDOT. It is not known when construction of any pedestrian signals occurred or the scope of the work.

A majority of locations with more than one crossing direction in the same quadrant had pushbuttons located on the same pole.

Some pedestrian signal pushbuttons evaluated were not located on an accessible route and many provided a clear space of less than 30”x48” and/or exceeded 2% max. slope. At the pushbutton. In some cases, there has been additional concrete added to attempt to provide a clear space but access to these areas requires negotiation of steep cross slopes.

Several (29) pushbuttons were non-compliant for distance from curb and may be difficult for some persons with disabilities to find.

Most locations had signage present but at least 10 locations had signs that were not compliant with current requirements or did not include any signage.

Most pushbuttons met the requirement for less than 5 lbs. of operating force (35 did not).

A total of 20 pushbuttons were below 42” desired height or above the maximum height of 48”.

A total of 68 locations had small recessed buttons that do not meet current requirement for operable parts to be operated with a closed fist and/or being 2” minimum in diameter.

Tactile arrows were provided at some pushbuttons and no pushbuttons included vibrotactile features. There were some locations with newer buttons that were 2” diameter but did not include a tactile directional arrow on the button.

No audible walk indicators were provided at any location. Only 5 locations had a speech message provided for the

direction of walk or to wait. Locator tones were provided at 28 locations. Of those with

locator tones, 9 had issues with volume being audible within the required 6’-12’ range.

Example of non-compliant pushbutton operable parts (met previous standard)

Example of pushbuttons on shared pole.

Example of pushbutton that is 2” diameter and includes tactile directional arrow on the pushbutton.

Example of pushbutton that is 2” diameter but has no tactile directional arrow on the pushbutton.

52


Addressing the Issue: As the City plans infrastructure improvement projects where new signal construction or alterations including signal controller, software, or signal head replacement occurs, accessible pedestrian signals must be installed that meet the applicable standard at that time. Particular items that will need to be addressed and are prevalent at currently signalized intersections is the separation of the pushbuttons when audible and vibrotactile components are added, installation of compliant buttons and signage, provision of level clear spaces at all pushbuttons, etc. Until that time, consider addressing the following items that would present the most difficult conditions for especially wheelchair users, but also other disabled pedestrians: Provide sidewalks and/or replace sidewalks adjacent to pushbutton locations to provide a compliant size

and level clear space, particularly where slopes exceed 2.5%. This particularly important at locations where pushbuttons are not located within reach of the PAR and essentially not able to be used by persons in wheelchairs (see some examples below).

Adjust pushbuttons that require excessive force to operate and/or are outside the 36”-48” height required.

Consider providing buttons that can be operated with a closed fist. Many existing buttons are recessed and quite small, making it very difficult to impossible for persons with upper body mobility impairments to operate the signals.

Costs are difficult to assess given unknowns about the ability to move wiring for pushbuttons, presence of conduit under pavement, etc. It is likely that the cost for the minor items noted as interim measures would be $800-1500 per crossing. Given the total number of approximately 140 crossings, the total cost would likely exceed $200,000 for the interim improvements. Costs for complete upgrades to current MUTCD standards are also difficult to determine, since the costs for controllers, signal heads, items that can be reprogrammed and reused instead of being replaced, etc. cannot be determined with the information available. Installation of a new accessible pedestrian signal can easily exceed $50,000 each, and significantly more if extensive re-wiring and installation of poles and posts is required. See Appendix B for the pedestrian signal inventory data by location.

Example of pushbuttons that are not located on an accessible route or which are obstructed.

Pushbutton with no signage on pole.

53


On-Street Parking Requirements: Per R214 of the PROWAG, ‘where on-street parking is provided on the block perimeter and the parking is marked or metered, accessible parking spaces shall be provided. Accessible parking spaces should be located where the street has the least crown and grade and close to key destinations (R309.1). Where width of sidewalk or available ROW exceeds 14’, an access aisle shall be provided at street level the full length of the parking space and shall connect to a pedestrian access route. Access aisle shall comply with R302.7 and shall not encroach on vehicular travel lane. An access aisle is not required where width of adjacent ROW is less than or equal to 14’. Where an access aisle is not provided, the parking spaces shall be located at the end of the block face (R309.2). Where perpendicular or angled parking is provided, an access aisle 8’ wide minimum shall be provided at street level the full length of the parking space and shall connect to a PAR (R309.3)’. Where accessible parking is provided at angled parking, it is also recommended that the access aisle be located on the passenger side to facilitate deployment of a lift from the vehicle.

Parking space identification signage is required per R211.4 of PROWAG; pavement markings are not required nor are they a compliant substitute for a sign. Signs are required to meet the requirements of R411 and include the ISA. Signs should be located 60” minimum to bottom of sign if not located on pedestrian circulation route, with 80” minimum from finish grade provided if along pedestrian circulation route to avoid protruding objects. For parallel parking, they should be located at the head or foot of the parking space per R211.4. It is important to note that there is no differentiation between van-accessible and other accessible spaces as is the case outside the ROW. Requirements for all accessible spaces are the same, which are essentially all van-accessible but van-accessible signage is not required. On-Street Parking Self-Evaluation Findings: Marked on-street parking within Oak Ridge is widespread, located on a number of residential streets. In many locations, the markings do not delineate actual parking spaces but instead identifies the limits of on-street parking to avoid blocking driveways. Many of the streets with this type of situation are dead end cul-de-sacs, which have markings on one side of the street and also often at the end of the cul-de-sac to provide parking for adjacent residents that do not have places to park on individual properties outside of the ROW. The image that follows shows areas within the City that have markings for on-street parking spaces in red. Note that many are located to the northwest of Oak Ridge Turnpike in older residential areas. Throughout many other areas of the City, on-street parking is allowed but not marked or metered, and therefore not required to include designated accessible spaces.

54


On-street parking is provided in some commercial areas or near schools along Broadway Avenue, E. Tennessee Avenue, Vermont Avenue, Kentucky Avenue, Providence Road, and others.

Marked parking in residential areas within the City consists of a mix of parallel parking on many streets, with perpendicular parking at the end of many cul-de-sacs. Currently, there are few on-street parking spaces designated as accessible but the City will provide a sign at any location upon request of a resident.

Locations of marked on-street parking shown in red, which are located primarily in residential areas.

Examples of on-street parking on Broadway (top) and Kentucky (bottom).

55


Addressing the Issue of On-Street Parking: Following the evaluation, discussions were had with the City to obtain the purpose of the marking of on-street spaces within the numerous residential areas. The City confirmed that markings were remnants from when the subdivisions were developed and intended to avoid blocking of the limited driveways. It was recommended, and the City concurred, during those discussions that the City perform a review of all on-street parking that is marked and determine where markings can be removed. Areas where markings are desired to remain, including both commercial and some residential areas, the City understands the need to provide accessible parking spaces based on the total number of on-street marked spaces by block face. The City will continue to provide signage upon resident request as well.

3.5 Future Improvements

While the ADA does not require pedestrian facilities in the absence of a pedestrian route, it does require that pedestrian facilities, when newly constructed or altered, be accessible. Pedestrian facilities would include, but not be limited to, sidewalks, curb ramps, pedestrian signals, and site furnishings. The previous sections of this SETP addressed those facilities already existing. The focus of this section is on future construction and connection of existing corridors.

While many City construction projects do include pedestrian facilities, not all project areas are suitable for pedestrian use. As such, the following publications could be used as a guide to determine the appropriateness of pedestrian facilities in any given corridor. Any future requests for pedestrian facilities necessitate an assessment of current conditions and needs in order to be considered for implementation.

Per the policy statement in FHWA’s Accommodating Bicycle and Pedestrian Travel: A Recommended Approach, “bicycle and pedestrian ways shall be established in new construction and reconstruction projects in all urbanized areas unless one or more of three conditions are met:

Bicyclists and pedestrians are prohibited by law from using the roadway. In this instance, a greater effort may be necessary to accommodate bicyclists and pedestrians elsewhere within the right of way or within the same transportation corridor.

The cost of establishing bikeways or walkways would be excessively disproportionate to the need or probable use. Excessively disproportionate is defined as exceeding twenty percent of the cost of the larger transportation project.

Example of typical on-street parking on a residential cul-de-sac on Cahill Lane. Note the limited driveways.

56


Where sparsity of population or other factors indicate an absence

of need.”

From the FHWA’s publication, ‘Bicycle and Pedestrian Transportation Planning Guidance’, an assessment might include the following:

Determination of current levels of use for bicycling and walking transportation trips, and current numbers of injuries and fatalities involving bicyclists and pedestrians.

Evaluation of the existing transportation infrastructure (including on- and off-road facilities) to determine current conditions and capacities and to identify gaps or deficiencies in terms of accommodating potential and existing bicycle and pedestrian travel.

Identification of desired travel corridors for bicycle and pedestrian trips.

Examination of existing land use and zoning, and the patterns of land use in the community.

Basis of the need for modifications to the transportation system through surveys, origin destination studies, public input, or other data collection techniques.

(A complete listing of recommended considerations can be found at https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/planning/processes/pedestrian_bicycle/).

‘The challenge for transportation planners, highway engineers and bicycle and pedestrian user groups, therefore, is to balance their competing interest in a limited amount of right-of-way, and to develop a transportation infrastructure that provides access for all, a real choice of modes, and safety in equal measure for each mode of travel.’

(Excerpt from FHWA’s Accommodating Bicycle and Pedestrian Travel: A

Recommended Approach)

57


4.0 Self-Evaluation of Pedestrian Facilities within the Public ROW – Sidewalk Inventory

This section of the SETP summarizes the review of current sidewalks within the public ROW. The findings and recommendations contained in this section will provide the basis for the implementation of specific improvements to accessibility on City sidewalks. A total of approximately 118.5 miles of City sidewalk was assessed.

4.1 Pedestrian Access Route

Per R105.5 of PROWAG, ‘a pedestrian access route is a continuous and unobstructed path of travel provided for pedestrians with disabilities within or coinciding with a pedestrian circulation path.’ R204.2 adds that ‘A pedestrian access route shall be provided within sidewalks and other pedestrian circulation paths located in the public right-of-way. The pedestrian access route shall connect to accessible elements, spaces, and facilities required by section 206.1 of appendix B to 36 CFR part 1191 or section F206.2.1 of appendix C to 36 CFR 1191 that connect building and facility entrances to public streets and sidewalks.’ R204.3 and R204.4 note that pedestrian street crossings and pedestrian overpasses and underpasses are considered part of the pedestrian access route. Per the Technical provisions of the PROWAG, the PAR consists of multiple elements that are listed in R302.2, which must meet the following general criteria: R302.3 Continuous Width R302.4 Passing Spaces R302.5 Grade (Running Slope) R302.6 Cross Slope R302.7 Surfaces Within the following text, ‘location’ refers to a single data collection point. This may be a single block face, a portion thereof with logical stopping point, such as an alley or area with no sidewalk present, or non-roadway related portion of public ROW. Percentages and numbers shown should not be interpreted as a quantity of infrastructure. Likewise, compliance for one criterion does not indicate compliance for all criteria. Oak Ridge has an extensive non-motorized network of sidewalks, with a high percentage of residential areas including sidewalk on at least one side of the street. There are also typically sidewalks in high commercial and institutional areas. Much of the sidewalk infrastructure in Oak Ridge is aged and in varying condition, particularly in areas that were developed decades ago and have not been maintained or replaced since.

4.2 Width

Requirements: Per R302.3, the continuous clear width shall be 4’ minimum exclusive of the width of curb, with 5’ width required at all medians and pedestrian refuge islands. Five feet of width is preferred, as when the clear width is less than 5’, passing spaces must be provided every 200’ maximum. This provides greater flexibility to the pedestrian to accommodate changes in direction, passing movements, and turning space.

58


Most sidewalks within the City were 4’ or greater, with many walks 5’ in width. Some 4’ wide sections exceed 200’ of length with no passing space available. Issues observed that reduced the sidewalks to less than 48” minimum included sidewalks built prior to current standards and overgrown turf and obstructions.

Addressing the Issue in Future: As part of the City’s long-term plan for addressing sidewalks, work with owners of obstructions to either

have them removed or investigate the feasibility of providing a compliant width PAR around obstacles. Also encourage homeowners to maintain vegetation that overhangs the PAR.

Five foot width should be considered for all new sidewalk construction, and is required by City engineering standards.

4.3 Grade (Running Slope)

Requirements: Per R302.5, the grade (running slope) of the sidewalk PAR shall not exceed 5% or the grade of the adjacent street if the street is over 5%. The second part of this requirement that was included in the 2011 PROWAG is significant for many communities, less so in Oak Ridge overall compared to other communities nearer the Smoky Mountains. There are areas of the City that have streets with a running slope that exceeds 5%. Without this provision in PROWAG, the amount of non-compliance of the PAR would increase dramatically due to running slope issues. Within the City, there were several locations over 5% maximum running slope or exceed the running slope of the adjacent roadway. Often these areas of excessive running slope are limited and have other non-compliance issues. There are limited areas where the excessive running slope was implemented to minimize sidewalk replacement at driveways and provide a ramp on each side. Addressing the Issue: For areas with excessive running slopes, potential solutions may include: Lowering grade, which may require sections of curbing or other retaining structure to keep the limits

within the public ROW. Removing and regrading adjacent shallowly sloped panels to spread the slope over a greater run and

achieve a more even, compliant slope throughout.

Examples of sidewalk that is 36” or less in width and also in poor condition.

59


4.4 Cross Slope

Requirements: Per R302.6, the cross slope of the sidewalk PAR shall be 2% maximum. Exceptions to this rule occur only at pedestrian street crossings without yield or stop control or midblock crossings. Note that the City’s design standards allow 4% cross slopes, which has contributed to the amount of sidewalk with cross slope non-compliance. During the evaluation, it was noted that many blocks exhibited some level of non-compliance for cross slope. While this included some areas with minor deviations that may not be compliant but are ultimately highly useable, many of the issues are often more severe. The most significant issue is often driveways. The transition along the PAR at many driveways accommodates the driveway without consideration of the resulting cross slope of the PAR. Many driveways are built through the sidewalk, with a severe cross slope presented to pedestrians crossing the driveway. In some instances, a vertical level change (curb) is constructed at the edge of the sidewalk in an apparent attempt to not have to perform work on sidewalk panels adjacent to the driveway.

Addressing the Issue: For areas with cross slopes of over 2% that are not due to incorrect driveway construction, potential solutions may include: Lowering the sidewalk grade. Removing and regrading adjacent tree lawn, if present, to achieve a compliant slope throughout. In locations where the cross slopes issues are more extensive and due to numerous driveway issues, the only option is reconstruction of the PAR through the driveways. The slope of the driveways needs to be considered in the design and construction of the driveway to ensure not only that the PAR cross slopes are maintained at 2% or less but also that the driveway slopes are not as severe. This may require detailed investigations at locations with steep driveways to ensure vehicle transitions are able to be negotiated without scraping bottom.

4.5 Changes in Level / Surface Condition

Requirements: Per R302.7, the surface of the PAR shall be firm, stable, and slip-resistant. Grade breaks shall be flush. Vertical surface discontinuities (changes in level) shall be ½” maximum with those between ¼” and ½” being beveled at a slope not steeper than 50% across the entire discontinuity. Horizontal openings, such as grates and

Examples of driveway transitions at the PAR that introduce severe cross slopes and/or vertical elevation changes.

60


joints, may not exceed ½”. Elongated openings should be placed perpendicular to the dominant direction of travel. During the evaluation, surface condition was evaluated for damage from cracking and spalling. In general, newer sidewalks are relatively free of cracks, spalling, and displacements. Sidewalks in the most residential areas tended to be older and exhibit more surface condition concerns. In most areas that exhibited issues with displacements, surface condition, or changes in level, there were other issues (e.g., cross slope). Tree roots can cause heaving of sidewalks, but was uncommon in the City.

Addressing the Issue: Changes in level and surface condition are a common problem as infrastructure ages. These issues tend to be worse in more temperate areas that have extremes in temperature that cause heaving and where excessive salt use affects the surface. Temporary fixes of high hazard areas can be implemented to promote the safety of all users while long-term solutions are set into action. Public input is particularly important in locating hazardous areas as they occur since issues can occur at any time. In general, the following solutions can address changes in level and surface condition. It may be helpful to set up a protocol for public reporting of such areas. Level Changes Temporary placement of concrete or asphalt to ramp from adjacent panel where level changes are severe Grinding the edge at surface level changes of up over ½” to achieve allowable bevel Replacement of concrete sidewalk panels

Surface Condition Replacement of damaged concrete sidewalk panels

Examples of displacements, separations, and pavement in poor condition in need of maintenance.

61


Minimize use of salt and other compounds that can affect surface condition of pavements Maintenance to keep free of vegetation and debris

4.6 Obstructions, Protrusions, and Utility Considerations

Requirements: Per R402.2, protruding objects are those objects with leading edges more than 27” and not more than 80” above the finish surface which protrude more than 4” horizontally into pedestrian circulation paths. Per R210, street furniture and other objects may not reduce the minimum clear width of the PAR. These items would be considered an obstruction of the continuous clear width provided. Obstructions typically include light and utility poles, newspaper and mailboxes, vegetation, signs, hydrants, and site furnishings. Other barriers include, but are not limited to, manholes, valve covers, open grate castings, and access boxes. These conflicts are generally classified as vertical displacements and slip hazards. There are limited areas where vehicles in parking lots abut the PAR. Some parking lots do not have curbing or bumper blocks that restrict the vehicles from overhanging the PAR and reducing it to less than 48” width. Obstructions can also be temporary in nature, including trash and recycling containers that are placed weekly at the curb on the PAR, cars in residential driveways, and chairs and tables for outdoor dining outside of businesses. There are many residential areas with sidewalks immediately adjacent to a mountable curb or no curb where cars were observed often riding up onto the PAR to obstruct it for pedestrian traffic.

Temporary obstructions include cars in parking lots overhanging the PAR, trash and recycling containers, and outdoor dining tables and chairs.

Grinding of small displacements Temporary patching for large displacements

62


Addressing the Issues: Moveable obstructions may include furniture, signage, parked cars, and trash and recycling containers. These items may be addressed by enactment and/or enforcement of ordinances regarding their placement. Some communities have opted to include within their design standards a requirement to ensure parking on commercial sites does not overhang the PAR. Others have enacted ordinances to prohibit blocking the PAR, both within private parking lots as well as in residential areas where objects are often placed in a manner that blocks the PAR. Implementation of an ordinance restricting parking within public sidewalks may help prevent parking obstructions, particularly in residential areas but needs to be enforced. Similar restrictions on location of trash bins for pickup could be developed. Education of residents of the importance of maintaining a clear PAR is essential to the success of the issues being addressed. Vegetative obstructions and protrusions can be managed with routine maintenance and by encouraging homeowner participation in maintaining a clear ROW. Fixed obstructions may be costly to address as they generally occur with utilities and may require relocation or purchase of right-of-way from adjacent landowners. For these items, a work-around solution is often preferred. These may include widening a small portion of sidewalk where possible or providing an equivalent alternate route. Providing a narrow area of tree lawn between the curb and sidewalk can assist by providing an area for items such as signs and mailboxes to be placed without obstructing the PAR and can also assist with resolving issues for temporary items like trash and recycling containers.

Examples of obstructions of the PAR that reduces the width to less than 48”.

63


4.7 Overall Compliance

The information above is useful in identifying trends in the deficiencies as a means to prevent them from occurring in new construction. However, the goal of this Transition Plan is to list the physical barriers in the City’s ROW facilities that limit the accessibility and, therefore, it is necessary to look at each location as a whole to determine overall compliance in order to provide a detailed outline of the methods to be utilized to remove these barriers and make the facilities accessible. All solutions offered address only the criteria indicated. Complete reconstruction may be required where multiple compliance issues are involved. See Appendix B for data reports.

4.8 Sidewalk Barrier Ranking Analysis

The City’s self-evaluation of the public ROW takes into account factors such as level of use, degree of danger posed, complaints or requests for repair received, and other factors and are grouped into two categories – Contributing Contextual Factors and Physical Impedance Factors. These categories are further defined in Section 3 of this report. Self-Evaluation Findings: Based on the data collected, a percentage of replacement required was calculated for each data location. This percentage was then applied to the linear footage of that data collection area and multiplied by the approximate cost of sidewalk replacement (in 2019 dollars). Based upon these calculations, the following table illustrates the estimated value of improvements required to make all sidewalk facilities accessible. The

Examples of utility structures and debris along the PAR that can present issues for disabled users.

Example of overgrown vegetation that reduces the PAR width to less than 48”.

64


evaluation resulted in finding over 71% of sidewalk locations in the City being out of compliance overall. Even though not all panels of sidewalk are non-compliant, the actual amount of reconstruction likely to occur will require the small areas that are compliant to be included within projects since it is typically more costly to do selective sidewalk reconstruction over reconstruction of entire sections with logical endpoints. The amount of High Priority sidewalk is quite low, as there are limited areas where accessibility is limited due to primarily cross slopes and driveway issues discussed above. The City should closely evaluate the cost implications vs. the increase in accessibility in regard to corrections to highly usable areas. A percentage of the Low Priority items are due to minor cross slope deviations, but are otherwise in excellent condition. The High Priority areas typically have significant areas along each block face that have issues that severely limit accessibility, again being primarily cross slopes and driveway issues. Note that the costs provided do not include costs for ROW purchase, easements, appraisals, surveying, design, etc. and it is very likely that actual costs of the program will vary based on a number of factors. See Appendix B for data reports. Table 4.1. Summary of Sidewalk Costs.

Sidewalk Summary

Low Priority Sidewalk $14,059,171

Medium Priority Sidewalk $10,532,190

High Priority Sidewalk $2,164,308

Total Estimated Sidewalk Improvement Costs $26,755,669

65


5.0 Self-Evaluation of Pedestrian Facilities within the Public ROW – Curb Ramp Inventory

This section of the SETP summarizes the review of current curb ramps within the public ROW. Curb ramps are an essential facility within the public ROW that allows for continuation of the PAR at street crossings. ADA regulations require that a curb ramp be provided at intersections where a PAR is present. The requirements for curb ramps, as contained in R304 of PROWAG, include standards for running slope (1:12 or 8.33% maximum), cross slope (1:50 or 2% maximum), width (48” minimum), presence of landings and/or turning spaces (TS), clear spaces, grade breaks, and detectable warnings (DW). PROWAG includes within R207.1 the provision that ‘A curb ramp, blended transition, or a combination of curb ramps and blended transitions complying with R304 shall connect the pedestrian access routes at each pedestrian street crossing. The curb ramp (excluding any flared sides) or blended transition shall be contained wholly within the width of the pedestrian street crossing served.’ R207.1 essentially requires a dedicated curb ramp be provided for each direction of street crossing for all new construction and alterations, with the exception in R207.2 that ‘alterations where existing physical constraints prevent compliance with R207.1, a single diagonal curb ramp shall be permitted to serve both pedestrian street crossings. ‘ The findings and recommendations contained in this section will provide the basis for the implementation of specific improvements to accessibility on City curb ramps. Approximately 1574 data collection locations were evaluated. In some cases, curb ramps were not provided where a PAR is present or crossings were not provided in all possible directions. A determination was made regarding the need to provide crossings where they are not currently provided based on existing conditions and options available.

5.1 Curb Ramp Types

Curb ramps types are classified based on the orientation of the ramp to the adjacent curb. As stated in Advisory R304.1 of the PROWAG, the following types of curb ramps exist: Perpendicular Curb Ramp Perpendicular curb ramps have a running slope that cuts through or is built up to the curb at right angles or meets the gutter break at right angles where the curb is curved. The general direction of the curb ramp is perpendicular to the curb. Perpendicular curb ramps do not require edge delineation where the adjacent area is not part of the pedestrian circulation area (PCA) and is cane-detectable (e.g., turf). Where a PCA is adjacent on one or both sides, side flares are required.

Example perpendicular curb ramps, with and without flares based on presence/absence of PCA.

66


Parallel Curb Ramp Parallel curb ramps have a running slope that is parallel to the curb and have a ramp in each direction from the point of entry from the street. Parallel ramps can be useful where ROW is limited to get a pedestrian from street level to the sidewalk in a shorter depth space. Parallel ramps are also useful along PARs where driveway transitions require either elevation or lowering of the PAR approach to the driveway.

Combination Curb Ramp Parallel and perpendicular curb ramps can be combined and can be utilized where the sidewalk approaches are much higher in elevation that the street level at the intersection. A parallel curb ramp is often used to lower the sidewalk to a mid-landing/turning space and a short perpendicular curb ramp connects the landing to the street. Combination curb ramps can be provided where the sidewalk is at least 6.0 feet wide and can provide access in situations where the sidewalk is much higher than 6” above the street elevation.

Blended Transition Blended transitions are raised pedestrian street crossings, depressed corners, or similar connections between pedestrian access routes at the level of the sidewalk and the level of the pedestrian street crossing that have a grade of 5 percent or less. Blended transitions are suitable for a range of sidewalk conditions. In many locations, particularly in downtown business districts, diagonal blended transitions were commonly used where there were subtle differences between the PAR and adjacent roadway at intersections. As discussed below, diagonal curb ramps/blended transitions are no longer allowed per PROWAG except under unusual conditions.

Example parallel curb ramps, showing the level area at the intersection with the street crossing and adjacent

Example combination curb ramp, with a perpendicular ramp to a common landing and adjacent parallel ramps.

67


Diagonal Curb Ramp/Blended Transition A very common type of curb ramp, including many in the City, are diagonal curb ramps. Diagonal curb ramps can be either perpendicular or blended transitions. Regardless of the type, diagonal curb ramps provide access to multiple directions of street crossings. Per R207.1 of PROWAG, two ramps are typically required at each corner. Diagonal curb ramps are not the preferred method of construction due to lack of directional cues for pedestrians using the crossing and safety concerns created by vehicles misconstruing pedestrian intentions. Per R207.2, where existing physical constraints prevent compliance with R207.1, a single diagonal curb ramp shall be permitted to serve both pedestrian street crossings.

Per the Technical provisions of R304 and R305 of PROWAG, curb ramps must meet the following general criteria. Some of the requirements are specific to the type of ramp, whereas others are common requirements of all ramps. Additional discussion about most is included in following subsections:

Turning Spaces – R304.2.1 Perpendicular Ramp and R304.3.1 Parallel Ramp Running Slopes – R304.2.2 Perpendicular Ramp, R304.3.2 Parallel Ramp, and R304.4.1 Blended Transition R304.2.3 Perpendicular Ramp Flared Sides R304.5.1 Width R304.5.2 Grade Breaks R304.5.3 Cross Slope R304.5.4 Counter Slope R304.5.5 Clear Space R305 Detectable Warning Surfaces

Diagonal blended transition. Note the level transition from the street crossing to the PAR.

Diagonal blended transition (left) and diagonal perpendicular ramp (right). Both provide access to street crossings of more than one direction and are permitted by PROWAG R207.1 only in certain locations.

68


5.2 Ramp Width

Requirements: Per R304.5.1, the clear width of curb ramp runs (excluding any flared sides), blended transitions, and turning spaces shall be 4.0 feet minimum. The ramp width is typically measured at the point that the curb is at or very near the same level as the street.

Findings: A vast majority of curb ramps evaluated were compliant for width. A relatively small number were less than the required 4’ width and typically had other compliance issues that affected accessibility more than the width.

Addressing the Issue: Ramp width is typically not restricted and attaining the minimum 48” should be accomplished without difficulty. In some cases there could be permanent obstructions but typically when curb ramps are too narrow it is a result of construction errors. If an unobstructed area is available within the ROW at a current non-compliant location for width, the ramp can be widened by replacement or addition of pavement. If ROW or an obstruction is a limiting factor, a different ramp configuration may alleviate the problem. If not, the ramp or obstruction may need to be relocated, or inquiries made about obtaining additional ROW.

5.3 Ramp Running Slopes

Requirements: Per R304.2.2, the running slope of the curb ramp shall cut through or shall be built up to the curb at right angles or shall meet the gutter grade break at right angles where the curb is curved. The running slope of a curb ramp is 5% minimum and 8.3% maximum but shall not require the ramp length to exceed 15 feet. If less than 5%, it is considered a blended transition instead of a ramp. The counter slope of the gutter or street at the foot of curb ramp runs, blended transitions, and turning spaces shall be 5 percent maximum. Counter slopes and/or ramp running slopes that exceed these maximums can cause a wheelchair user’s footrests to

Examples of curb ramps that are less than the minimum 48” width required.

69


hit the ground when going down the ramp and spill the user forward out of their chair. For that reason, ramps with extreme running slopes over 10% are typically a high priority to address.

Findings: As noted above for ramp width, the number of ramps that were not in compliance with the 8.33% maximum running slope was relatively small though much higher than the number of ramps with non-compliant width. To provide a compliant 8.33% maximum running slope for a perpendicular ramp for a typical 6” curb, the distance required from the grade break to the top of the ramp is 6 feet minimum, at which point a minimum 48” top landing is required. In many areas the running slope complies but there is no landing or TS provided because of the lack of depth.

Addressing the Issue: Non-compliant ramp running slopes can be caused by a number of factors including construction tolerances, design inconsistencies, design and/or contractor error, construction prior to current standards, steep roadway grades, adjacent buildings or obstructions, or limited ROW. In Oak Ridge, most instances of running slope non-compliance was due to trying to construct a perpendicular ramp within a space that would not allow for a compliant solution. As part of the transition plan for curb ramps, given the limited ROW available at most locations, it is likely that:

Curb ramps will need to be constructed as parallel ramps rather than perpendicular Construction of 2 ramps at an existing diagonal ramp will be needed Construction of a combination ramp may be needed where elevation differences on intersection

approaches of the PAR are high Incorporating returned curbs or retaining wall to avoid adjacent obstructions or limited ROW

5.4 Ramp Cross Slopes

Per R304.5.3, the cross slope of curb ramps, blended transitions, and turning spaces shall be 2 percent maximum.

Curb ramps with excessive running slopes, typically severe slopes that exceed 10%. These ramps also exceed the counter slope requirements.

70


Requirements: Per R304.5.3, the cross slope of curb ramps, blended transitions, and turning spaces shall be 2 percent maximum. At pedestrian street crossings without yield or stop control and at midblock pedestrian street crossings, the cross slope shall be permitted to equal the street or highway grade. Findings: Within the City, there were a large number of curb ramps with cross slopes over 2%. Some are minor deviations that do not affect the usability, though many of these have other issues not related to ramp cross slope that present a barrier to access.

Addressing the Issue: Non-compliant ramp cross slopes are usually the result of minor field adjustments by contractors or errors during construction. A 2% slope, the maximum cross slope allowed, is only ¼” of elevation change per foot, so even minor adjustments or errors tend to result in non-compliant cross slopes. The only solution available is reconstruction of ramps that have excessive cross slopes.

5.5 Landings/Turning Spaces

Requirements: Per R304.2.1, perpendicular ramps require a turning space of 4.0 feet minimum by 4.0 feet minimum be provided at the top of the curb ramp, which also serves as a landing or rest area. Where the turning space is constrained at the back-of-sidewalk by a building for example, the turning space shall be 4.0 feet minimum by 5.0 feet minimum, with the 5.0 foot dimension provided in the direction of the ramp run. Parallel ramps also require a turning space per R304.3.1, which has the same dimensional requirements and is required to be 5.0 feet in the direction of the street crossing if the turning space is constrained on two or more sides. Turning spaces are also required at changes in direction that occur along the PAR, which is typically in the area of the curb ramps.

Curb ramps with excessive cross slopes. These ramps also typically have non-compliant landing cross slope.

71


Findings: Within the City, there are a high number of primarily perpendicular curb ramps that do not provide compliant turning spaces. These locations typically are located where there is not adequate room to construct a perpendicular ramp and results in no turning space being provided. Wheelchairs attempting to use these ramps would be in danger of tipping over when attempting to turn. This was the most prevalent high priority issues to address with curb ramps in the City. As illustrated in the examples shown, curb ramps with non-compliant turning spaces often have other non-compliance issues. Parallel ramps with non-compliant turning spaces were often highly usable.

Addressing the Issue: Non-compliant turning spaces/landings are caused primarily by construction of the wrong kind of ramp in a space that is inadequate to provide the required slopes and dimensions. In most cases the only means to provide a compliant turning space/landing is to reconstruct the ramp and use a parallel configuration. In areas where there is adequate space that was simply not used in the original construction, reconstruction to the extent required to provide compliant dimensions and slopes is needed. In some cases, separation of a single ramp into 2 ramps is the best solution.

5.6 Flares

Requirements: Per R304.2.3, where a pedestrian circulation path crosses the curb ramp, flared sides shall be sloped 10 percent maximum, measured parallel to the curb line. The flares are not considered part of the PAR but as part of the PCA, the slopes assist in transitioning the steep slope of perpendicular curb ramps to the flat slope of the PAR. Note that per Advisory R304.2.3, where there is no PCA adjacent to the ramp, such as a turf area, or there are objects adjacent to the ramp that essentially block it from being part of the PCA, no flares are required. In these cases, vertical curbs can be used and are preferred since they provide directional cues.

Example of curb ramps that lack a compliant turning space.

72


Findings: During the self-evaluation, it was found that: Few locations did not require a flared side. A majority of sidewalks in the City are located immediately

adjacent to the curb or street. A low number of perpendicular curb ramps that require 10% maximum flares that far exceeded the

standard. The flares that were present were often a rolled curb that exceeded 25% slope. These severe slopes are trip hazards in the PCA. In some locations, there are other more severe non-compliance issues, including lack of turning spaces.

Addressing the Issue: Non-compliant flare slopes or configurations are typically caused by design and/or construction errors and installation of perpendicular curb ramps where there isn’t adequate room to install a ramp that meets all dimensional and slope requirements. The only solution in most cases is reconstruction of the entire ramp. Where flare slopes are the only compliance issue, placement of an obstruction to the side is another option but these situations are rare.

5.7 Ramp Grade Breaks and Clear Space

Requirements: R304.5.2 requires that grade breaks at the top and bottom of curb ramp runs be provided that are perpendicular to the direction of the ramp run. Grade breaks are not permitted on the surface of the ramp run or turning spaces and slopes that meet at grade breaks are required to be flush. Grade breaks that are not perpendicular to the ramp run can cause wheelchair front casters to lift off the ground and be a hazard for the user, possibly tipping them over if slopes are severe enough.

Example of curb ramps that have non-compliant flare slopes.

73


In addition, R304.5.5 requires a 4.0 foot by 4.0 foot minimum clear space beyond the bottom grade break that is located both within the crosswalk and entirely outside of the parallel vehicle travel lane. This clear space allows a wheelchair user to negotiate the curb ramp and have a space at the bottom outside the traffic lane within which to wait to cross. Findings: During the self-evaluation, it was found that relatively few curb ramps failed to provide either a compliant grade break or clear space. Some of this is due to the high number of diagonal ramps that provide crossings in multiple directions. The few locations where there was an issue had other compliance issues in most cases. Addressing the Issue: There are no solutions to correcting these issues short of full reconstruction of the ramp. Altering the grade break will generally require chasing the grade one or more sections of sidewalk away from the curb and clear space issues will require relocation or total reconfiguration of curb ramps, most likely to a parallel ramp or reconstruction at the intersection to separate a single ramp into two.

5.8 Detectable Warnings

Requirements: Detectable warning (DW) surfaces indicate the boundary between pedestrian and vehicular routes where there is a flush rather than curbed connection (i.e., at curb ramps). Per R208.1, DW surfaces are required at curb ramps and blended transitions at pedestrian street crossings, pedestrian refuge islands (unless at street level AND less than 6’ in length), pedestrian at-grade rail crossings not located within a street or highway and transit stops, and some boarding platforms for transit. DWs are not intended to provide guidance for wayfinding for blind or low vision pedestrians. DWs have historically been poorly understood and misapplied in many situations that create confusion for blind and low vision pedestrians. DWs should not be provided at crossings of residential driveways as the pedestrian ROW continues across residential driveway aprons. They can be provided at high traffic volume commercial driveways that function similarly to roadways, such as those found at large commercial centers. Detectable warnings are not required outside the public ROW other than some transit platforms. Per R305.1, Detectable warning surfaces shall extend 2.0 feet minimum in the direction of pedestrian travel and the full width of the ramp run (excluding any flared sides), blended transition, or turning space. Some DW products require a concrete border for proper installation, which is not allowed to exceed 2 inches per Advisory R305.2. DW surfaces are required to contrast visually with the adjacent gutter, street, and PAR, either light-on-dark or dark-on-light. For perpendicular curb ramps, DWs are required to be placed:

Example of curb ramp that does not provide the required perpendicular grade break.

74


1. Where the ends of the bottom grade break are infront of the back of curb, detectable warningsurfaces shall be placed at the back of curb.

2. Where the ends of the bottom grade break arebehind the back of curb and the distance fromeither end of the bottom grade brake to the backof curb is 1.5 m (5.0 ft) or less, detectablewarning surfaces shall be placed on the ramp runwithin one dome spacing of the bottom gradebreak.

3. Where the ends of the bottom grade break arebehind the back of curb and the distance fromeither end of the bottom grade brake to the backof curb is more than 1.5 m (5.0 ft), detectablewarning surfaces shall be placed on the lowerlanding at the back of curb.

DWs at parallel curb ramps are required to be placed on the turning space at the flush transition between the street and sidewalk (R305.2.2) DWs for blended transitions are required at the back of curb.

Findings: DWs were provided at a surprisingly low proportion of existing curb ramps. There were numerous locations where curb ramps have been recently installed or reconstructed without DWs. In addition, there were a number of recently constructed ramps with DWs installed incorrectly, with the most common errors being DWs that were not full width of the ramp or oriented in a way that does not provide a full 24” depth for the entire ramp width. Note also that there are many locations in the City where DWs are used both on interior sites at parking lots and other areas and at low volume driveways. DWs should be discouraged from use outside of the public ROW except where required by ADASAD (e.g., transit platforms) and within the ROW at driveways that do not have high traffic volumes or have signal control.

75


Example of curb ramps with detectable warnings that are not full width of the ramp.

76


DWs that are oriented poorly and are not 24” depth in entire direction of pedestrian movement.

Curb ramps lacking DWs as required or which have low contrast.

77


Addressing the Issue: In many cases, curb ramps with non-compliant or missing DWs have other issues that cannot be easily addressed without reconstruction, with 155 ramps having only a missing DW as a non-compliant feature. Retrofit DW kits are available for use on ramps where all other criteria are compliant and should be considered for use in these locations. Some non-compliant locations with high pedestrian volumes or known blind pedestrian users should be considered for these retrofit kits until the ramp can be corrected entirely. For locations where the DW does not extend full width or required 24” depth, they can be removed and replaced along with any concrete damaged by the operation. For all future DW installations, steel, HDPE, or cast iron products that provide greater durability for the truncated domes are recommended. Using these products in lieu of a brick or cast concrete panel may minimize plow damage and wear of truncated domes.

5.9 Drainage

Requirements: Curb ramps should be located such that they are not located at low points in the gutter where water may pond. This water can be several inches deep in some cases, something a blind person would not know about until they walked through it. Wheelchair users have no options other than to use curb ramps in many cases, and these poor drainage locations can be an issue. During times of cold weather, even shallow depths of water can freeze, creating a slip and fall hazard at the bottom of the curb ramp. In addition to the hazard and inconvenience provided by ponded water and/or ice, sediment carried by runoff tends to accumulate where water ponds. This sediment can cause issues with slip resistance of the surface.

According to the FHWA publication “Designing Sidewalks and Trails for Access”, ‘poor drainage at the bottom of a curb ramp is inconvenient to all pedestrians. It is a particular nuisance for people who rely on the curb ramp for access and who will, therefore, not be able to avoid the area. When the water eventually dries up,

Examples of curb ramps with drainage issues and/or evidence of regular ponding, with sediment deposition.

78


debris, which further impedes access, is usually left at the base of the ramp. In cold-weather locations, water that does not drain away can turn into slush or ice, creating a more hazardous situation’.

Findings: The self-evaluation noted a number of locations with either standing water within the curb ramp at the time of the evaluation or deposits of sediment, indicating that standing water is common. In some cases, the poor drainage is a result of changes to the low point in the gutter from an asphalt overlay. In others, drainage was either not considered adequately during design of the roadway or was not constructed according to the plans. Addressing the Issue: Best practices for avoiding drainage issues include locating drainage structures on the uphill side of ramps, locating low points 6’ or more from the ramp, ‘tabling’ the intersection slightly where tying into ramps, designing gutter slopes with continuous flow to carry water past the foot of ramps, eliminating changes in level at the gutter line, and maintaining inlets and gutters to ensure adequate flow during rain events. Many of the curb ramps with noted drainage issues have other compliance issues, including providing only one ramp for multiple road crossings.

5.10 Obstructions, Protrusions, Vertical Discontinuities, and Horizontal Openings

Requirements: Per R302.3, the continuous clear width of the PAR shall be 4.0 feet minimum, exclusive of the width of the curb. Curb ramps are extensions of the PAR and therefore required to maintain the same clear width. Further, R210 states that objects along or overhanging any portion of the PCA shall comply with R402 (protruding objects) and shall not reduce the clear width required for PAR. Per R402.2, protruding objects are those objects with leading edges more than 27” and not more than 80” above the finish surface which protrude more than 4” horizontally into pedestrian circulation paths. Common obstructions and protruding objects include utility and light poles, signposts and signs, and a variety of other permanent objects. R302.7.2 requires vertical surface discontinuities be 0.5” maximum and beveled if 0.25-0.5 inches. In addition, per R302.7.3, horizontal openings in gratings and joints or cracks shall not permit passage of a sphere more than 13 mm (0.5 in) in diameter. Elongated openings in gratings shall be placed so that the long dimension is perpendicular to the dominant direction of travel.

Findings: Obstructions that were observed included light and utility poles, signposts, hydrants, and utility cabinets. In most cases, these obstructions encroached on the clear width of a turning space though some were located on the ramp run. Some obstructions could be

79


worked around when curb ramps are reconstructed, but there are several that do not have an easy solution due to lack of ROW and other significant constraints.

Vertical discontinuities were somewhat common, with the most common issue being located at the gutter pan. Some discontinuities were several inches high. Other issues were observed at displaced cracks in the pavement, at the top of the ramp at the TS, or raised utility structures.

Examples of curb ramps with obstructions at turning spaces, on the ramp, or immediately adjacent to either.

80


Horizontal openings were not common, but included drainage structures located within clear spaces and cracks that have separated to exceed ½”. Some storm structures with ½” openings are not oriented such that the openings are perpendicular to the primary path of pedestrian travel.

Addressing the Issue for Future Construction: Fixed obstructions may be costly to address as they generally occur with utilities and may require relocation or purchase of ROW from adjacent landowners. For these items, a work-around solution is often preferred and may include widening a small portion of sidewalk where possible or providing an equivalent alternate route. In some cases, obstructions may have no options for work arounds without being creative, such as providing bulb outs if on-street parking is available or the street width allows. Other obstructions, like signs, should be able to be relocated to provide the required 48” clear width of the PAR. Many locations with obstructions had other non-compliance issues that will require curb ramps reconstruction. Consideration of how to treat obstructions will need to be determined during the design phase. A low number of curb ramps have issues with vertical discontinuities. In most cases, curb ramps with vertical discontinuities exhibit other non-compliance issues that will require reconstruction. For locations that are compliant other than vertical discontinuities, these can be corrected by grinding the edge to provide the maximum ½” allowable bevel or a temporary patch of asphalt or other compliant material can be placed to eliminate the vertical issue. Horizontal displacement issues were not common but need to be addressed. In instances where drainage structures are located within clear spaces, covers should be provided that have openings that do not exceed

Examples of curb ramps with vertical discontinuities that exceed ½” at the curb, on the ramp, or the TS.

Examples of curb ramps with utility structures on the ramp or the clear space.

81


½” and oriented properly. Curb ramps with horizontal crack openings can be temporarily filled until the concrete panel can be replaced.

5.11 Overall Compliance

Overall compliance of curb ramps in the City is low, with less than 7% of existing ramps meeting all requirements. Many of the non-compliant ramps (over 64%) with one or more issues are still quite usable and typically designated as “Low” priority. Higher priority ramps tend to have compliance issues that create a more significant barrier to use, with “High” priority ramps (over 6%) being unusable or missing. The goal of this transition plan is to list the physical barriers in the City’s ROW facilities that limit the accessibility and, therefore, it is necessary to look at each location as a whole to determine overall compliance in order to provide a detailed outline of the methods to be utilized to remove these barriers and make the facilities accessible. All solutions offered address only the criteria indicated. Complete reconstruction will often be required where multiple compliance issues are involved.

The extent of reconstruction required for existing ramps and blended transitions varies, but it is likely that most ramps will need to be reconstructed to various extents. Some locations may require simple fixes such as replacing or installing tactile warnings or replacement of a non-compliant flare. A vast majority of the intersection quadrants only provide a single curb ramp for multiple crossing directions. R207.1 requires a curb ramp or blended transition for each pedestrian street crossing, essentially a dedicated ramp for each direction of street crossing. The exception to this is the presence of an existing physical constraint that prevents provision of a ramp for each crossing, in which case a single diagonal ramp would be allowed (R207.2). This exception is not applicable to most non-compliant cases found in the City. Each location will require a thorough examination in order to design the correct solution to its unique situation. Locations without a curb ramp provided constitute the greatest barrier to use and require full replacement.

5.12 Curb Ramp Barrier Analysis

The City’s self-evaluation of the ROW takes into account factors such as level of use, degree of danger posed, complaints or requests for repair received, and other factors and can be grouped into two categories – Contributing Contextual Factors and Physical Impedance Factors. These categories are further defined in Section 3 of this report. Within Appendix B, the curb ramps are ranked as Compliant, Low Priority, Medium Priority, and High Priority after considering the physical impedance factors. See information regarding contextual factors in Section 3.

In addition, the methodology used for estimating costs of corrections included categorizing all curb ramps into cost groups based on amount of rework required. The categorization includes, in most cases, the assumption that existing diagonal ramps will be separated into two ramps. Note that the costs provided below do not include costs for ROW purchase, easements, appraisals, survey, design, inspections, etc. and it is very likely that actual costs of the program will vary based on a number of factors and be much higher. See Appendix B for data summary by location.

Mid-block crossing accessed from the PAR by steps. Receiving ramp is flush with sidewalk. This ramp provides no access for wheelchair users to the shopping center on the opposite side.

82


Table 5.1. Summary of Curb Ramp Costs.

Curb Ramp Summary

Low Priority Curb Ramps $1,903,203

Medium Priority Curb Ramps $1,312,800

High Priority Curb Ramps $269,000

Total Estimated Curb Ramp Improvement Costs $3,485,003

83


6.0 Transition Plan

The Transition Plan describes how Oak Ridge will be transitioning to full compliance with the ADA and the applicable standards. Public entities, like the City, are required to provide access to City programs, services, and activities for all recipients. Thus, the City must provide access for individuals with disabilities and document areas of non-compliance. Additional documentation should be provided as barriers are removed.

If structural changes are identified to provide program accessibility as part of the self-evaluation, the ADA identifies specific elements to be included in the transition plan. At a minimum, the elements of the Transition Plan are:

1) A list of the physical barriers in the City’s facilities that limit the accessibility of its programs, activities, orservices to individuals with disabilities [28 CFR 35.150 (d)(3)(i)]

2) A detailed outline of the methods to be utilized to remove these barriers and make the facilitiesaccessible [28 CFR 35.150 (d)(3)(ii)]

3) The schedule for taking the necessary steps to achieve compliance with Title II of the ADA. If the timeperiod for achieving compliance is longer than one year, the plan should identify the interim steps thatwill be taken during each year of the transition period [28 CFR 35.150 (d)(3)(iii)]

4) The name of the official responsible for the plan's implementation. [28 CFR 35.150 (d)(3)(iv)]

The transition plan is a reaction to the findings of the facility audits, assessments of City policies, services, programs, and activities, and input from advocacy groups and the public. Recommended actions for City policies and programs can be found in Section 2.0.

The specific architectural and site improvement modifications required to make programs accessible are listed in the Oak Ridge Facility Reports (see Appendix A). Facility reports include buildings and their related grounds that are owned, operated, or leased by Oak Ridge or facilities that provide programs of Oak Ridge Government. Each facility report contains a list of items that do not meet current ADASAD standards and suggested barrier removal actions. Not all of these barriers must be removed by making renovations to the facilities in order to provide program compliance with the ADA. Removing barriers limiting access to programs or those which present a safety hazard should be the City’s first priority.

6.1 Phasing of Corrections

A phased implementation of the required corrections to remove physical barriers at City-owned facilities is recommended and required. The City, like most Title II agencies, has limited funds and cannot immediately make all facilities fully compliant with ADA standards. Prior to setting priorities, baseline criteria needed to be established to develop a starting point for ranking the deficient facilities identified during the self-evaluation.

Site priorities were determined by evaluating each site’s level of use, social need, civic function, and the general uniqueness of the site. At the time of the development of this report, few public complaints had been received about City-owned facilities. Complaints were not used as criteria to determine the phasing of improvements for any particular site, though future complaints could be the basis for funding improvements.

Each of these criteria is assumed to have equal weight and no priority over another:

Level of Use: Is the facility utilized quite frequently and by a large cross-section of the public?

84


Social Need: Does the facility provide a social service or program for less fortunate or transientcitizens?

Civic Function: Does the facility provide access to civic programs and services that implement the civiland political rights provided by the government?

General Uniqueness of the Site: Does the building, facility, or site provide a distinct program orservice that cannot occur at a different location or facility?

6.2 Public Outreach

Public participation on the final contents of the Transition Plan, including setting of priorities and the phasing of improvements, is critical to the success of the endeavor and is required by law. A draft Transition Plan was made available at the Oak Ridge Municipal Center Community Development office and Public Library for public review and comment from May 11-22, 2020, for public review and comment. A PDF version was also posted on the City web site. Comments could also be provided via email as advertised and posted in a public notice placed in City Hall and published in The Oakridger. {INSERT THE NUMBER OF COMMENTS RECEIVED AFTER THE PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD HERE] comments were received during the public comment period. The final Transition Plan will be submitted to the City formal acceptance. See also Section 1.12 – Public Outreach.

6.3 Priorities for Barrier Removal

In creating priorities, it should be the City’s intent to evaluate all areas of potential deficiency and to make structural changes where necessary and when equal accommodation cannot be made in another manner. The assignment of priorities is intended to facilitate public review and to address specific concerns of the local disabled community. It must be emphasized that it is the City’s intention that all individuals with all types of disabilities be reasonably accommodated to provide access to all programs offered at all facilities.

The timing of the improvements by site within each transition phase will be determined by the City based on their preferences and criteria. In general, the required physical improvements to meet ADA specifications at City facilities were split into three priority groups:

High priority improvements Medium priority improvements Low priority improvements

All barriers are not equal in the impact they have on persons with various disabilities to have equal access to City facilities or programs. Following evaluation of all facilities and programs, a prioritization was done to identify a ranking system to utilize when determining which capital improvements need to be considered first and those that could be implemented in subsequent years.

1. High priority barriers prohibit access for disabled persons, make access extremely troublesome, orpresent safety hazards to all users. These barriers likely do not have acceptable alternative routes ortreatments to overcome the barrier. Typically, these barriers are significant obstacles located at entrywalks and doors, interior corridors, curb ramps, rest rooms, and transaction and information counters.Examples of high priority barriers would include:

lack of barrier-free parking lack of accessible route to the building’s door stairs where ramps or level surface are needed doors that are too narrow

85


lack of elevator in a multi-level building extremely non-compliant slopes for accessible routes or ramps displacements in walks or high thresholds missing handrails some signage (particularly those related to life/safety)

2. Medium priority barriers partially prohibit access or make access quite difficult for disabled persons. Formedium priority barriers, alternative routes or treatments to overcome the barrier may or may not exist.Typically, these barriers are obstacles to amenities such as secondary entry points, light switches, vendingmachines, and drinking fountains. Medium priority barriers may also be barriers which are significantobstacles prohibiting access but for which alternative access is available or assistance is readily availableto navigate around the barrier. The presence of the medium priority barrier possibly causes a minorhazard to a disabled person who is attempting to use the facility. Examples of medium priority barrierswould include:

minor non-compliant slopes some signage minor issues with doors (small dimensional non-compliance, opening force and closing speed) non-compliant dimensional issues (vestibules, corridors, etc.) stairwell/stair issues, particularly where an elevator is not available accessible restrooms accessible work and service counters moderately non-compliant dimensional issues some protruding objects

3. Low priority barriers typically do not limit access to facilities or services for disabled persons. For lowpriority barriers, alternative routes or treatments are typically available or assistance can be provided toovercome the barrier. It is not likely that the presence of a low priority barrier would cause a danger to adisabled person who is attempting to use or access the facility. Examples of low priority barriers wouldinclude:

many signage issues minor issues with light switches, electrical outlets, etc. minor non-compliant dimensional issues

The costs to remove barriers by priority for each site are shown in Table 1 and detailed for each facility in Appendix A. In addition, a time frame had to be identified to determine an average annual budget to consider. For the purposes of this report, a 30-year time frame was utilized to address non-compliance issues and assumes that standards and guidelines are not modified in a manner that would modify compliance. This further assumes that funding is available each budget cycle to make the necessary improvements. It is highly unlikely given the economy that this is realistic, particularly when considering that there are also likely to be a large number of other improvements needed by the City as part of regular maintenance, upkeep, and repairs.

In some instances, it may be advantageous to construct all improvements at a site at once rather than correct the high priority barriers first and come back at a later date to correct the medium or low priority barriers. For some sites, the total cost of construction for the corrections requires that they be spread out over two or more phases. Oak Ridge has the right to modify the priorities based on funding levels and changes in City programs, activities, and services to have flexibility in accommodating community requests and complaints.

86


Interim resolutions, such as assigning aids, temporary signing for alternate routes or sites, and modifications of programs, activities, and services may be implemented at the City’s discretion to handle existing insufficiencies or access complaints received. All costs noted in Appendix A and Table 1 are 2019 cost opinions. These cost opinions are subject to change based on market conditions, economic conditions, inflation, material selection, etc. Multiple phases of projects, multiple bidding packages, design parameters, etc. all have an impact on project costs that cannot be finitely identified in a study with this level of detail and uncertainty related to funding.

Table 6-1. Oak Ridge facilities with priority and probable costs for corrective action. OAK RIDGE ADA SELF EVALUATION STUDY AND TRANSITION PLAN

FACILITY SUMMARY

Name & Location

Low Priority

Medium Priority

High Priority

Total Probable

Cost Municipal Building/Police, 200 S. Tulane $21,080 $30,370 $73,600 $125,050 1010 Incubator Building, 1010 Commerce Park Drive $3,700 $11,830 $3,200 $18,730 Alvin K. Bissell Park, 200 S. Tulane $7,650 $15,960 $112,100 $135,710 Animal Shelter, 395 Belgrade Road $550 $4,085 $150 $4,785 Badger Building, 205 Badger Avenue $1,250 $6,220 $550 $8,020 Baseball Complex, Wilberforce Avenue $15,070 $72,080 $73,100 $160,250 Big Turtle Park, Oak Ridge Turnpike $10,450 $26,600 $9,200 $46,250 Briarcliff Park, Deerfield Lane $3,800 $300 $3,500 $7,600 Carl Yearwood Park, Bus Terminal Road $4,870 $27,765 $450 $33,085 Cedar Hill Park, Michigan Avenue $10,300 $4,200 $0 $14,500 Central Services, 100 Woodbury Lane $67,710 $39,250 $3,700 $110,660 Civic Center/Recreation Building, 1403 Oak Ridge Turnpike $7,190 $32,360 $1,700 $41,250 Elm Grove Park, 751 E. Tennessee Avenue $0 $37,900 $9,400 $47,300 Elza Gate Park, Oak Ridge Turnpike $1,500 $550 $0 $2,050 Fire Station 1, 2097 Oak Ridge Turnpike $3,550 $8,020 $600 $12,170 Fire Station 2, 609 Oak Ridge Turnpike $4,630 $8,010 $600 $13,240 Fire Station 3, 333 Tuskegee Drive $14,690 $8,200 $7,400 $30,290 Fire Station 4, 652 Enrichment $0 $0 $0 $0 Centennial Golf Course, 101 Centennial Boulevard $12,860 $37,670 $2,300 $52,830 Groves Park at South Hills, Tuskegee Drive $0 $0 $0 $0 Haw Ridge Park, Bethel Valley Road $4,700 $100 $0 $4,800 Highland View Park, Highland View $2,400 $12,200 $300 $14,900 LaSalle Park, LaSalle Road $19,250 $33,500 $2,900 $55,650 Melton Lake Park, Melton Lake Drive $3,200 $14,100 $0 $17,300 Milt Dickens Park, Athens Road $4,000 $25,800 $10,700 $40,500 Pinewood Park, Bus Terminal Road $16,950 $17,600 $10,000 $44,550 Municipal Swimming Pool, 172 Providence Road $13,060 $16,880 $4,100 $34,040 Public Library, 1401 Oak Ridge Turnpike $3,500 $6,210 $5,200 $14,910 Scarboro Community Center, Carver Avenue $14,200 $32,450 $2,500 $49,150 Scarboro Park, Carver Avenue $27,000 $400 $0 $27,400 Solway Park, Bethel Valley Road $700 $25,350 $0 $26,050 Tennis Courts, 35 Kentucky Avenue $15,400 $20,300 $0 $35,700 Wastewater Treatment Plant, 100 Monterey Road $19,095 $22,445 $1,265 $42,805 Water Filtration Plant, 755 Bear Creek Road $9,750 $32,520 $1,100 $43,370

TOTALS $344,055 $631,225 $339,615 $1,314,895

Based on the costs developed to address the architectural and site engineering improvements required to fully comply with ADASAD standards, almost $1,315,000 in improvements would be required (2019 costs) to achieve ADA compliance at all the City facilities. It is important to note at this point that many of the noted deficiencies are not significant barriers to access and some improvements are not required until major building alterations are completed. This does not avoid the need for Oak Ridge to ensure all programs are

87


accessible by some means. It must also be mentioned that the cost to correct some significant non-compliant items cannot be determined based on the scope of the ADA self-evaluation. Additional investigation is needed to evaluate the various options and likely will include a review of other codes (plumbing, electrical, etc.) and possibly also review of the feasibility of removing walls (i.e., structural engineering review). Examples of these types of items would include:

Conversion of multi-user restrooms to single user due to non-compliant space (may require analysis ofplumbing code requirements for the number of fixtures required)

Moving of walls to enlarge multi-user restrooms to enlarge an existing non-compliant stall to meetrequirements (may require structural engineering review)

Investigation required to determine how to best provide a level space at an entry door or to providecompliant clear spaces

Costs provided are estimated based on information available from the self-evaluation and may not account for hidden items not readily visible which may impact costs (e.g., lack of backer boards where toilet grab bars need to be relocated would require drywall removal and replacement that is not included in noted costs). In some cases, the cost identified is for a specific solution and there are often multiple options with costs that can be quite variable. If Oak Ridge were to set a goal for completing all the necessary improvements to correct non-compliance issues within a 30-year time frame, it would require an annual budget of approximately $44,000 (in 2019 dollars) to bring all the City facilities evaluated in Appendix A and B of this report up to current ADA standards (no inflation included). These costs do not include any issues that require additional investigation, costs associated with training of staff, staff time related to training or overseeing implementation, design services, etc. Oak Ridge’s annual general fund budget is approximately $26 million, including line items for some specific facilities. No guidance regarding the percentage of annual general fund budget allocations to correct ADA issues has been provided and the reasonableness of this plan would be up to regulatory authorities to determine.

In addition to the facilities listed above, the City has over 60 miles of greenway. A majority of the greenways are not improved with an ADA-compliant surface that is stable and firm, with just over 7 miles of greenway being a compliant surfacing. The greenways that were a compliant surfacing were inventoried for compliance with ADA requirements and split into 6 segments. Several segments of greenway lie within the ROW and the compliance included in the PAR details. There are also some sections that lie within parks that were not considered the primary greenway and the assessment of those segments is included in the assessment for that park facility. The results of the greenway inventory found approximately 13% of the greenway had compliance issues, including excessive cross slopes, excessive running slopes, lack of resting spaces at steep sections, and minor obstructions and separations. The estimated cost of correcting the non-compliant areas of the greenway is $912,982, which includes existing pavement removal, minor grading, and new pavement. The costs do not include surveying, design, or grading over extensive areas to correct running slopes. Details about the greenway are included in Appendix B, including mapping of the segments and a table with details about each segment length, non-compliant length, and cost. Note that the costs provided include estimates for compliance of all areas of the greenway. Further investigation may note that existing topography makes compliance impractical, in which case the City should ensure that continuous sections of compliant greenway be identified that have logical termini and sections of the greenway that exceed ADA running slope standards include signage noting the extent and length of the non-compliance to allow users to make a determination about whether they are able to physically negotiate those challenging sections, whether they have a disability or not.

88


Oak Ridge should identify the most urgent access needs based on their experiences, other capital projects, and the results of the self-evaluation. A review of facility utilization and programs provided at each is critical to assisting in prioritizing which facilities should be given priority for improvements and order in which improvements should be completed. However, the facility prioritization should not be looked at in a vacuum, as improvements at lower use facilities may still warrant consideration for improvements in the near future if a barrier exists to program access. Facilities have been placed into three tiers based on their utilization by the public and programs provided at each. Note that some areas of facilities may fall within a lower or higher tier. Tier 1 facilities have the highest use and should be the first priority, with Tier 2 facilities to follow. Tier 3 facilities are relatively low use for the public or have only employee common-use areas that require corrective actions. The facilities in each tier is as follows:

Table 6-2. Oak Ridge Government facility tier listing for prioritization. Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3 Municipal Building (including City Court) Police Incubator Building Bissell Park Animal Shelter Badger Building Baseball Complex Big Turtle Park Fire Station 1 Central Services Briarcliff Park Fire Station 2 Civic Center/Recreation Building Cedar Hill Park Fire Station 3 Melton Lake Park Elza Gate Park Fire Station 4 Municipal Swimming Pool Centennial Golf Course Elm Grove Park Public Library Carl Yearwood Park Groves Park Scarboro Community Center LaSalle Park Haw Ridge Park Solway Park Milt Dickens Park Highland View Park

Pinewood Park Scarboro Park Tennis Courts Wastewater Treatment Plant Water Filtration Plant

6.4 Transition Plan Phasing

One of the most important compliance efforts for a Title II entity is to ensure that all programs provided to the public are accessible in some manner. Often there are short-term or temporary accommodations that can be made to provide this accessibility. Where these types of accommodations can be made, the priority for permanent corrections is reduced until an alteration is made to correct architectural barriers. Often, removal of architectural barriers can be accomplished during implementation of normal maintenance activities at the various facilities or as part of other capital improvements already anticipated.

An entity as large as Oak Ridge Government has the daunting task of reviewing a large number of facilities and programs to ensure access is provided. The programs of the City cross numerous departments and facilities, with some programs not being provided in City-owned facilities (primarily voting). The phasing of improvements for accessibility is not something to typically be done by any one individual without consultation of various department heads. The completion of this Transition Plan is a key first step to identifying the required facility and programmatic access needs. The next logical step is the formation of a committee of key department heads to review the results and formulate a strategy and capital improvement plan to make the necessary alterations. This committee is typically chaired by the ADA Coordinator and Facilities Department. Procedural and other changes that cross department lines should also be reviewed by a committee of key department heads, typically chaired by the ADA Coordinator and Human Resources Director. Changes within departments can be done by each department head for their individual department.

89


Generally, the improvements to be made are suggested in the following order:

1. Approach and Entrance – compliant parking, accessible route from parking to the public accessibleentrance, and an accessible entrance

2. Access to Services – within each facility, ensuring that all programs have an accessible route and areaccessible

3. Restroom Access – access to a compliant, wheelchair accessible restroom, preferably one per floor foreach gender or unisex

4. Other Access – access to lower priority items, such as drinking fountains, electrical outlets, etc.

Considering the above general recommendations, each facility needs to focus on the above priority order for improvements, while also considering the tiering provided in Table 6-2. Highest use facilities need to have improvements done to provide at least basic access to programs or determine another means to provide access. That could include relocating a program elsewhere within the facility that is accessible or relocating a program to an accessible facility until it can be accessible at its current location. Utilization of signage to identify the location of the accessible routes and entrances, accessible restroom locations, etc. can be very helpful until all necessary improvements can be made.

The ADA Coordinator, through the ADA Committee, should work closely with the City Manager and City Council to make funding available where possible to make the most urgent improvements to ensure all programs are accessible. Note that actual phasing, transitioning of improvements, etc. can be impacted by a number of factors that may be unknown currently, as well as economic conditions, grant opportunities, etc. The City is committed to becoming ADA compliant within the confines of preserving existing programs and services to all and budgetary limitations. Many of the items that are not compliant with current standards may be compliant with previous standards and are not required to be modified until a building renovation is completed. Any facility changes after the sites were surveyed are not reflected in these basic cost estimates. Additionally, it is the City’s responsibility, as required by the ADA mandate, to regularly update the Transition Plan based on the latest requirements of the ADA laws and to document constructed improvements and facilities that are brought up to current ADA standards. Finally, the site surveys performed for this report are not to design level detail and are intended to be used to give a framework to the Transition Plan. When the Transition Plan is approved, and the planning stages are begun for implementation of the first improvements, a more detailed survey of each site will need to be performed, and improvements designed by licensed professionals that are knowledgeable with ADA as well as all other applicable codes, including building and fire codes. At this time, costs are estimated but precise costs cannot be determined until final design, and the Transition Plan should be adjusted to reflect this knowledge.

Note that if any complaints are received regarding access to specific facilities or City programs, it may alter the priorities of the improvements. If the City receives complaints about access at a particular site that is not slated for upgrades for several years, they should consider adjusting the Transition Plan phasing to accommodate the implementation of improvements to be sooner or as necessary.

6.5 Plan Updates and Enforcement

Changes to Oak Ridge’s policies and programs should be drafted, implemented, and documented by the ADA Coordinator. Examples of some of these changes were provided in the Self-Evaluation. These changes should have little cost of implementation, mainly consisting of the time to develop the language of the policy and program changes, time to train City staff, and administrative costs. Some of the suggested language for City ADA documentation has been suggested in this report, but these suggestions are not exhaustive. It is also

90


important for the ADA Coordinator to receive the necessary training to implement this Transition Plan and keep apprised of changes to ADA standards and guidelines.

6.6 Summary of Transition Plan Costs

Table 6.3 details the costs and priorities for the overall ADA program for the City of Oak Ridge, including all ROW facilities, buildings, parks, and greenways. Buildings includes all buildings other than those under the oversight of the Parks & Recreation Department (Civic Center, Community Center, and all parks and facilities within). The costs included in the table are estimated based on available information as discussed earlier. It is very likely that the actual cost will vary to account for items not included (design, survey, etc.), unknown costs for alterations that cannot be quantified with available information (other applicable codes, structural wall analysis, etc.), changes to ADA standards that apply at the time of the alteration, phasing of improvements (i.e., costs may vary based on amount of improvements per contract), and other factors. Costs for facility improvements that cannot be quantified, including accessible pedestrian signals, on-street parking, etc. would be in addition to those shown in the table. The City is currently investigating budgeting options, with a goal of budgeting approximately $100,000 annually to address the most serious accessibility issues, in addition to addressing issues as part of other projects that are scheduled. Note also that costs for an on-street parking study to determine where markings are needed and accessible spaces provided, along with costs for signage and pavement markings, are not included in the table below.

Table 6.3. Overall ADA Program Costs for the City of Oak Ridge Facility Type Low Priority Medium Priority High Priority Total Cost Buildings $149,505 $177,160 $97,365 $424,030

Parks1 $194,550 $454,065 $242,250 $890,865

Greenways $0 $588,222 $324,760 $912,982

Sidewalks $14,059,171 $10,532,190 $2,164,308 $26,755,669

Curb Ramps $1,903,203 $1,312,800 $269,000 $3,485,003

Pedestrian Signals2 $0 $100,000 $100,000 $200,000

TOTALS $16,306,429 $13,164,437 $3,197,683 $32,668,549 1Includes all parks and buildings at parks, including the Centennial Golf Course, Civic Center/Recreation Building, and Scarboro Community Center. 2Cost of APS is rough estimate and divided evenly between Medium and High Priority as placeholder. Cost provided is primarily for accessible route improvements, actual costs for equipment, wiring, etc. will likely be much higher but cannot be quantified without knowing additional information about infrastructure that is not visible.

91


7.0 ADA Tool Kit

7.1 Introduction

In order to facilitate access to all City programs and departments, the City will maintain program accessibility guidelines, standards, and resources. This information is available to all employees and volunteers. The City will add to these guidelines when necessary to address its needs and include information and technological devices that help staff and volunteers communicate with individuals with a variety of disabilities. The City will periodically review the components of this section, as new technologies are developed in order to ensure that the best types of modifications are included. This section also contains the accessibility standards of care that govern new construction and alterations to facilities.

If you need any additional assistance, please contact:

Mr. Bryan Mills, ADA Coordinator Phone: (865) 429-1807Email: [email protected]

7.2 Federal Accessibility Standards and Regulations

U.S. Department of Justice The U.S. DOJ provides many free ADA materials including the ADA text. Printed materials may be ordered by calling the ADA Information Line [(800) 514-0301 (Voice) or (800) 514-0383 (TDD)]. Publications are available in standard print as well as large print, audiotape, Braille, and computer disk for people with disabilities. Documents, including the following publications, can also be downloaded from the DOJ website (www.ada.gov).

Unless noted, the ADA publications have not been updated to reflect the recent revisions to the ADA regulations that took effect on March 15, 2012.

ADA Regulation for Title II. This publication describes Title II of the ADA(www.ada.gov/regs2010/ADAregs2010.htm#titleII_final_2010), Pub. L. 101-336, which prohibitsdiscrimination on the basis of disability by public entities. Title II of the ADA protects qualified individualswith disabilities from discrimination on the basis of disability in the services, programs, or activities of allstate and local governments. This rule adopts the general prohibitions of discrimination establishedunder Section 504, as well as the requirements for making programs accessible to individuals withdisabilities and for providing equally effective communications. It also sets forth Standards for whatconstitutes discrimination on the basis of mental or physical disability, provides a definition of disabilityand qualified individual with a disability, and establishes a complaint mechanism for resolving allegationsof discrimination.

Title II Technical Assistance Manual (1993) and Supplements. This 56-page manual(www.ada.gov/taman2.html) explains in lay terms what state and local governments must do to ensurethat their services, programs, and activities are provided to the public in a nondiscriminatory manner.Many examples are provided for practical guidance.

Accessibility of State and Local Government Websites to People with Disabilities. This is a 5-pagepublication providing guidance (www.ada.gov/websites2.htm) on making state and local governmentwebsites accessible.

92


U.S. Access Board The full texts of Federal laws and regulations that provide the guidelines for the design of accessible facilities and programs are available from the U.S. Access Board. Single copies of publications are available free and can be downloaded from the Access Board's website (www.access-board.gov/the-board/laws). In addition to regular print, publications are available in large print, disk, audiocassette, and Braille. Multiple copies of publications can be ordered by sending a request to [email protected]. In addition to the guidelines, guidance material is also available to assist staff in understanding and implementing Federal accessibility guidelines.

The following publications are currently available from the U.S. Access Board.

Guidelines and Standards for Facilities Federal guidelines and standards are subject to periodic revision based on research findings and guidance from advisory committees. The City should have a regular practice of reviewing research materials posted to the U.S. Access Board’s website and updating local guidelines and practices as new standards are adopted or existing standards are revised.

ADA Standards for Accessible Design (ADASAD). This document(www.ada.gov/2010ADAstandards_index.htm) contains scoping and technical requirements foraccessibility to buildings and facilities by individuals with disabilities under the ADA, including specialprovisions where applicable for elements designed specifically for children ages 12 and under. Thesescoping and technical requirements are to be applied during the design, construction, and alteration ofbuildings and facilities covered by Titles II and III of the ADA to the extent required by regulations issuedby Federal agencies, including the DOJ and the DOT, under the ADA.

Accessibility Guidelines for Play Areas. The Access Board has developed accessibility guidelines for newlyconstructed and altered play areas. This bulletin is designed to assist in using the play area accessibilityguidelines and provides information regarding where the play area guidelines apply, what a playcomponent is considered to be, how many play components must be an accessible route, and therequirements for accessible routes within play areas. (www.access-board.gov/guidelines-and-standards/recreation-facilities/guides/play-areas)

Accessibility Guidelines for Recreation Facilities. The Access Board issued accessibility guidelines for newlyconstructed and altered recreation facilities in 2002. The recreation facility guidelines are a supplementto ADASAD. They cover the following facilities and elements: amusement rides, boating facilities, fishingpiers and platforms, miniature golf courses, golf courses, exercise equipment, bowling lanes, shootingfacilities, swimming pools, wading pools, and spas. These summaries were updated following issuance ofADASAD (www.access-board.gov/guidelines-and-standards/recreation-facilities/guides/play-areas).

Accessibility Guidelines for Outdoor Developed Areas. The Regulatory Negotiation Committee onAccessibility Guidelines for Outdoor Developed Areas was established in June 1997. The accessibilityguidelines proposed by the Committee include consideration of the latest information, design, andconstruction practices in existence. Proposed Section 16 of ADAAG requires all areas of newly designedor newly constructed and altered portions of existing trails connecting to designated trailheads oraccessible trails to comply with this section. This proposed section also provides design guidelines for allnewly constructed and altered camping facilities, picnic areas, and beach access routes. It is recognizedthat compliance with this section will not always result in facilities that will be accessible to all personswith disabilities. These guidelines recognize that often the natural environment will prevent fullcompliance with certain technical provisions, which are outlined in this publication (www.access-

93


board.gov/guidelines-and-standards/recreation-facilities/outdoor-developed-areas/draft-final-guidelines/text-of-theguidelines).

Guidance Material and Advisory Reports for Facilities The following publications provide additional information on specific aspects of the above guidelines and standards for facilities. Employees are encouraged to refer to these publications to obtain more detailed and up-to-date information when evaluating and implementing accessibility improvements to facilities. Note that several websites have been reconfigured and some outdated information removed. Some web addresses or hyperlinks may not be functional and not all information contained in the documents references current standards.

Using ADAAG Technical Bulletin. This bulletin was developed to serve the specific needs of architects and other design professionals who must apply the ADAAG to new construction and alterations projects covered by Titles II and III of the ADA. It is also intended to clarify accessibility regulations generally, including those that apply to existing facilities covered by the ADA.

Detectable Warnings Update (March 2014). Currently, the Access Board is in the process of developing guidelines on public rights-of-way that, once finalized, will supplement the new ADASAD and be the enforceable standard for ROW facilities. This update was expected in 2013 but as of publication of this SETP is still pending. While ADASAD covers various features common to public streets and sidewalks, such as curb ramps and crosswalks, further guidance is necessary to address conditions unique to public ROW. Constraints posed by space limitations at sidewalks, roadway design practices, slope, and terrain raise valid questions on how and to what extent access can be achieved. Guidance on providing access for blind pedestrians at street crossings is also considered essential. This bulletin outlines the requirements of detectable warnings, a distinctive surface pattern of domes detectable by cane or underfoot, which are used to alert people with vision impairments of their approach to streets and hazardous drop-offs. Note that detectable warnings are required in very few locations outside of the public ROW and are often installed in parking lots and similar site conditions where they are not required and should not be placed. Overuse of detectable warnings can lead to confusion for persons with vision loss and can create unsafe conditions for persons using mobility devices. (www.access-board.gov/guidelines-and-standards/streets-sidewalks/public-rights-of-way/guidance-and-research/detectable-warnings-update)

Assistive Listening Systems Technical Bulletins. Assistive listening systems are devices designed to help people with hearing loss improve their auditory access in difficult and large-area listening situations. Typically, these devices are used in such venues as movie houses, theaters, auditoriums, convention centers, and stadiums, where they are piggybacked on a public-address system. They may also be used in smaller listening locations like courtrooms, museums, classrooms, and community centers. This web site provides information about the types of systems that are currently available and tips on choosing the appropriate systems for different types of applications (www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/assistive-devices-people-hearing-voice-speech-or-language-disorders).

Guidelines for Transportation ADAAG for Transportation Vehicles. This publication provides minimum guidelines and requirements for

accessibility standards for transportation vehicles required to be accessible by the ADA, including over-the-road bus and tram systems. (www.access-board.gov/guidelines-and-standards/transportation/vehicles/adaag-for-transportation-vehicles).

ADAAG for Transportation Vehicles; Over-the-Road Buses. This publication outlines the amendments to the accessibility guidelines for over-the-road buses (OTRB) made by the Architectural and Transportation Barriers Compliance Board and the DOT to include scoping and technical provisions for lifts, ramps,

94


wheelchair securing devices, and moveable aisle armrests. Revisions to the specifications for doors and lighting are also adopted. The specifications describe the design features that an OTRB must have to be readily accessible to and usable by persons who use wheelchairs or other mobility aids. (www.access-board.gov/guidelines-and-standards/transportation/vehicles/technical-assistance-manuals-on-adaag-for-transportation-vehicles/subpart-g-over-the-road-buses-and-systems)

American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO). AASHTO is theorganization that maintains the “Green Book” for design of roads and highways and has begun to addressaccessibility of pedestrian networks. Several AASHTO publications, which can be ordered from theAASHTO website (http://transportation.org/), address accessible circulation systems, including: AASHTOGuide for the Planning, Design, and Operation of Pedestrian Facilities (1st edition) and Guide for theDevelopment of Bicycle Facilities (3rd edition).

Federal Transit Administration (FTA). FTA regulates and enforces requirements of the ADA coveringtransportation facilities and systems. FTA maintains a technical assistance line on ADA questions (888-446-4511) and on their website (www.fta.dot.gov).

Securement of Wheelchairs and Other Mobility Aids. As a public or private transit authority, theresponsibility of safe, efficient service from public agencies who offer transportation services has beenenlarged to affording ridership to people using a wide variety of mobility aids. In considering not only themany types of mobility aid devices, but also the variety and sizes of lifts, and the numerous makes ofbuses and vans, it can be easily seen that there is no single, definitive solution to accessibility on masstransit vehicles. Various publications can be found that report on the experience of transit agencies thathave taken the initiative to involve the ridership in needs assessment and have established policies,educated operators, and informed the public to achieve greater accessibility in their bus transit systems.See the example at trid.trb.org/view/362763.

Guidance Material for Communication Standards for Electronic and Information Technology. The Access Board is issuing final accessibility

standards for electronic and information technology covered by Section 508 of the Rehabilitation ActAmendments of 1998. Section 508 requires the Access Board to publish standards setting forth adefinition of electronic and information technology and the technical and functional performance criterianecessary for such technology to comply with section 508. (www.access-board.gov/guidelines-and-standards/communications-and-it/about-the-section-508-standards/section-508-standards).

Section 508 also requires that individuals with disabilities, who are members of the public seekinginformation or services from a Federal agency, have access to and use of information and data that iscomparable to that provided to the public who are not individuals with disabilities, unless an undueburden would be imposed on the agency. (www.section508.gov/).

Bulletin on the Telecommunications Act Accessibility Guidelines. As technology continues to improve ourmeans of telecommunication, it can pose challenges to accessibility on one hand, while on the other holdthe key to innovative access solutions. Section 255 of the Telecommunications Act requirestelecommunications products and services to be accessible to people with disabilities. This is required tothe extent access is "readily achievable," meaning easily accomplishable, without much difficulty orexpense. Telecommunications products covered include: wired and wireless telecommunication devices,such as telephones (including pay phones and cellular phones), pagers, and fax machines; other productsthat have a telecommunication service capability, such as computers with modems, and equipment thatcarriers use to provide services, such as a phone company's switching equipment. (https://www.access-board.gov/the-board/laws/telecommunications-act).

95


Federal guidelines and standards are subject to periodic revision based on research findings and guidance from advisory committees. The City should have a regular practice of reviewing research materials posted to the U.S. Access Board's website and updating local guidelines and practices as new standards are adopted or existing standards are revised.

7.3 Resources for Providing Accessible Programs & Facilities

ADA Document Portal: This website (adata.org/ada-document-portal) provides links to more than 7,400 documents on a wide range of ADA topics. The ADA Document Portal is supported by the 10 ADA & IT Technical Assistance Centers.

The U.S. Department of Labor, Office of Disability Employment Policy: www.dol.gov/odep/: The Office of Disability Employment Policy (ODEP) is the only non-regulatory federal agency that promotes policies and coordinates with employers and all levels of government to increase workplace success for people with disabilities.

National Center on Accessibility (NCA): The Center (http://ncaonline.org) is a cooperative effort between the National Park Service (NPS) and Indiana University to provide information and technical assistance, primarily on recreation access. An example of the research activities of the NCA is the National Trails Surface Study. Initiated in 2005, this longitudinal study is primarily the result of questions that the National Center on Accessibility has, for many years and continues to receive from organizations, agencies and individuals who desire to make their trails accessible; are interested in an unobtrusive surface that blends and is friendly to the environment; and provides a quality trail experience for people with and without disabilities.

National Center on Health, Physical Activity, and Disability: The Center (www.ncpad.org) provides information and resources on physical activity to help people with disabilities find ways to become more active and healthier. The Center also provides information on how to provide access to fitness centers, schools, recreation facilities, camps, and health and leisure services.

National Park Service: NPS has many programs that address the issue of providing accessible recreation services to people with disabilities. These include Wilderness Accessibility for People with Disabilities (www.ncd.gov/publications/1992/December1992#8-1a) and Director’s Order #42-Accessibility, which establishes the purpose and role of the NPS Accessibility Program (www.nps.gov/accessibility.htm), lists applicable laws, standards, and authorities, implementation strategies, roles, and responsibilities. It also addresses NPS policies and provides links to additional information sources.

7.4 Technical Resources

The City should utilize the many disability-related resources available through the internet. Begin at AbleData (www.abledata.com), maintained by the National Institute on Disability and Rehabilitation Research of the U.S. Department of Education. The site provides up-to-date links to assistive technologies and disability-related resources. AbleData’s mission is to provide objective information on such assistive products as: Aids for Daily Living: Products to aid in activities of daily living, including bathing, carrying, childcare,

clothing, dispenser aids, dressing, drinking, feeding, grooming/hygiene, handle padding, health care, holding, reaching, time, smoking, toileting, and transfer.

Blind and low vision: Products for people with visual disabilities, including computers, educational aids, information storage, kitchen aids, labeling, magnification, office equipment, orientation and mobility, reading, recreation, sensors, telephones, tools, travel, typing, and writing (Braille).

96


Communication: Products to help people with disabilities related to speech, writing, and other methods

of communication, including alternative and augmentative communication, signal systems, telephones, typing, and writing.

Computers: Products to allow people with disabilities to use desktop and laptop computers and other kinds of information technology including software, hardware, and computer accessories.

Controls: Products that provide people with disabilities with the ability to start, stop, or adjust electric or electronic devices, including environmental controls and control switches.

Deaf and hard of hearing: Products for people with hearing disabilities, including amplification, recreational electronics, signal switches, and telephones.

Deaf and blind: Products for people who are both deaf and blind. Education: Products to provide people with disabilities with access to educational materials and

instruction in school and in other learning environments, including classroom and instructional materials. Environmental Adaptations: Products that make the built environment more accessible, including indoor

environment, furniture, outdoor environment, vertical accessibility, houses, polling place accessibility, lighting, and signs.

Housekeeping: Products that assist in cooking, cleaning, and other household activities, as well as adapted appliances. Includes food preparation, housekeeping, cleaning, ironing, laundry, and shopping.

Orthotics: Braces and other products to support or supplement joints or limbs. Prosthetics: Products for amputees, including lower and upper extremity. Recreation: Products to assist people with disabilities with their leisure and athletic activities, including

crafts, electronics, gardening, music, photography, sewing, sports, and toys. Safety and Security: Products to protect health and home, including alarm and security systems,

childproof devices, electric cords, lights, and locks. Seating: Products that assist people to sit comfortably and safely, including seating systems, cushions,

and therapeutic seats. Therapeutic Aids: Products that assist in treatment for health problems and therapy and training for

certain disabilities, including ambulation training, biofeedback, evaluation, exercise, fine and gross motor skills, perceptual motor, positioning, pressure/massage modality equipment, respiratory aids, rolls, sensory integration, stimulators, therapy furnishings, thermal/water modality equipment, and traction.

Transportation: Products to enable people with disabilities to drive or ride in cars, vans, trucks, and buses, including mass transit vehicles and facilities, vehicles, and vehicle accessories.

Walking: Products to aid people with disabilities who are able to walk or stand with assistance, including canes, crutches, and walkers.

Wheeled mobility: Products and accessories that enable people with mobility disabilities to move freely indoors and outdoors, including wheelchairs (manual, sport, and powered), wheelchair alternatives (scooters), wheelchair accessories, transporters, stretchers, and carts.

Workplace: Products to aid people with disabilities at work, including agricultural equipment, office equipment, tools, vocational assessment, vocational training, and workstations.

Assistive Technology Vendors and Service Providers

National Center for Accessible Media – A research and development facility dedicated to the issues of media and information technology for people with disabilities in their homes, schools, workplaces, and communities. NCAM has developed an authoring tool to make web- and CD-ROM-based multimedia materials accessible to persons with disabilities. Called Media Access Generator (MAGpie, versions 1.0 and 2.01) create captions and audio descriptions of rich media and can be downloaded on their website (ncam.wgbh.org).

97


American Sign Language Interpreters – A pool of on-call American Sign Language interpreters should bedeveloped. This list should be routinely updated to ensure their availability. Some programs may need tohave a pool of interpreters who are available on a 24-hour basis to handle emergency procedures. Therequired qualifications of these interpreters should be established. Many non-certified interpretersprovided by local services may have excellent skills and be qualified to handle most circumstances.However, unique circumstances, such as the provision of emergency medical services, may requireinterpreters who are approved by the courts and can ensure a level of confidentiality. Resources andcontacts for qualified sign language interpreters and information for the deaf and hard of hearing are atthe following locations:o Vocational Rehabilitation Regional Office

20 West Summit Hill DriveSuite 301Knoxville, Tennessee 37902Telephone: (865) 594-6060

o Knoxville Center of the Deaf – http://kcdtn.org/o Registry of Interpreters for the Deaf – www.rid.org/, including the Tennessee Chapter

(www.tennrid.org/).o Maryville College – provides a bachelor’s degree program in ASL and could potentially provide

students for ASL interpretation as part of the college’s Experiential Learning program(www.maryvillecollege.edu/academics/programs-of-study/american-sign-language/).

Assistive TechnologySystems and devices amplify sound for persons with hearing disabilities should be available for publicmeetings and conferences. Different types of devices are more suitable for different types of hearingdisabilities. Devices should be chosen to accommodate the greatest number of individuals.o Telecommunications Devices Access Programs (TDAP): The Telecommunications Devices Access

Program (TDAP) is established by Chapter 417 of the Public Acts of 1999. In accordance with the Act,the program is designed to distribute appropriate telecommunications devices so that persons whohave a disability may effectively use basic telephone service. The Tennessee Public UtilityCommission was given the responsibility and authority to implement and manage this program.Devices are issued on a first-come, first-served basis. However, there are certain qualifiers that mightenable individuals to receive devices on a priority basis. www.tn.gov/tpuc/telecommunications-devices-access-programs-tdap.html

o Tennessee Relay Services (TNRS): As a service to Tennessee's deaf, deaf-blind, hard-of-hearing, andhearing and speech-impaired community, the Tennessee Relay Service (TNRS) provides free,statewide assisted telephone service to those with speech, hearing, and visual impairments.(www.tn.gov/tpuc/relay-center-services.html).

o Tennessee Relay Service: The Tennessee Relay Service is a free service for all Tennesseans, connectingindividuals who are deaf, deaf-blind, hard-of-hearing, or have a speech disability with users ofstandard telephones. Whether calling on a standard telephone or a text telephone (TTY, a specialphone with a typewriter-style keyboard), relay makes communication simple, 24 hours a day, 365days a year. Simply dial 7-1-1 to connect with the state relay provider. Confidentiality for relay usersand CA's is assured by Federal Communications Commission (FCC) ruling. Using relay is easy andoffers access to the world for Tennesseans with hearing loss who are seeking two-waytelecommunication. https://www.tennrelay.com/

o Technology Access Center (TAC): The Technology Access Center has offered services for middleTennesseans with disabilities and functional limitations since 1989. The Center is operated by thenonprofit corporation, Access Services of Middle Tennessee. The mission of the corporation’s board

98


and staff members is to promote the independence and participation of individuals of all ages with disabilities in school, work, play and everyday activities through their use of assistive technology. (tacnashville.org/).

o Spark (formerly East Tennessee Technology Access Center (ETTAC)): Spark is a regional nonprofit agency that helps people with disabilities gain knowledge about and access to assistive technology devices. These devices help people with disabilities gain education and employment skills, perform activities of daily living, and lead more independent, productive lives. Spark's assistive technology equipment is used for assessment and training, and some devices may also be available for loan. (https://www.sparktn.org/).

o Closed Caption Machine - To the extent practical, City divisions should have access to a device for encoding closed captioning on films and videotapes used for training and other programs.

o Enlarging Printed Materials - A copy machine capable of enlarging printed materials should be available for each site where programs or transaction counter services are provided to the public.

o Optical Readers - Equipment that can translate printed information into an audio format should be available to Departments.

o TDD - To the extent necessary, City Divisions should have access to a text telephone or have access to a telephone transfer service as required by the law and offered by public telephone companies.

o TDI – TDI’s (formerly known as Telecommunications for the Deaf and Hard of Hearing, Inc.) mission is to promote equal access in telecommunications and media for people who are deaf, hard of hearing, late deafened, or deaf blind. TDI’s online resources (tdiforaccess.org/) include information about telecommunications access such a TTY, pagers, telephony, VoIP, and more.

Guide to Disabilities and Disability Etiquette A summary guide to disabilities and disability etiquette has been included below. The guide will allow staff members to become familiar with a variety of types of disabilities and help them to be more sensitive to the abilities and needs of people with disabilities in order not to offend or demean them. The guide should be periodically updated to ensure that it includes current acceptable language for talking about disabilities.

The National Organization on Disability reports that more than 59 million Americans have a disability. This section is for anyone — with or without a disability — who wants to interact more effectively with people who are disabled.

The ADA was conceived with the goal of integrating people with disabilities into all aspects of American life, particularly the workplace and the marketplace. Sensitivity toward people with disabilities is not only in the spirit of the ADA, it makes good business sense. It can help the City expand its services to citizens, better serve its customers and improve relationships with its employees.

When supervisors and co-workers use disability etiquette, employees with disabilities feel more comfortable and work more productively. Practicing disability etiquette is an easy way to make all people feel more comfortable and welcomed in their environment.

There is no reason to feel awkward when dealing with a person who has a disability. This section provides some basic tips for City staff to follow. If a City employee is ever unsure how to best serve a person with a disability, just ask them.

Ask Before You Help – Just because someone has a disability, don’t assume he/she needs your help. If the setting is accessible, people with disabilities can usually get around fine without assistance. Adults with disabilities want to be treated as independent people. Offer assistance only if the person appears to need it. If they do want help, ask what type of help they would like before you offer any assistance. What you think they may need may not be what they really need.

99


Do Not Touch! – Some people with disabilities depend on their arms for balance. Grabbing them – even if

you mean well – could knock them off balance and create an injury. This is especially true of a person using a cane, crutches, or walker. When someone is in a wheelchair, never pat their head or touch their wheelchair (or scooter) without permission. This equipment is part of their personal space and touching it is considered rude.

Engage Your Mind Before Engaging Your Mouth – Always speak directly to the person with the disability NOT to their companion, aide, or sign language interpreter. Making small talk with a person who has a disability is great; just talk to him/her like you would anyone else. Respect his/her privacy and don’t ask questions about their disability unless they invite the discussion. If you are with a child who asks, don’t make the situation awkward for everyone; let the person with the disability respond directly to the child. They are used to children’s questions.

Make No Assumptions – People with disabilities are the best judge of what they can or cannot do. Do not make any decisions for them about participating in any activity or what they may or may not be able to do. Simply respond to their questions and let them make their own decisions. Depending on the situation, it may be a violation of the ADA to exclude someone because of a wrong decision on what they’re capable of doing.

Respond Graciously to Requests – When people who have a disability ask for an accommodation at a City-owned property, it is not a complaint. It shows they feel comfortable enough in your establishment to ask for what they need. If they get a positive response, they will enjoy their transaction and feel comfortable to come back again and again. Unless they are asking for something outlandish, provide what is asked for. If they request something unreasonable, contact your ADA Coordinator for a direction toward a resolution.

Terminology – PUT THE PERSON FIRST! Always say “person with a disability” rather than “disabled person”. This recognizes that they are a person first, not a disability first. If someone has a specific disability, it would be a “person who is blind”, a “person who is deaf”, or a “person with dwarfism”. Each person may have their own preferred terminology, and if you’re not sure what to use, just ask them. Most, however, will recognize the effort when you just refer to them as “people”.

o Avoid outdated, politically incorrect terms like “handicapped” or “crippled”. Be aware that many people with disabilities dislike jargon and euphemistic terms like “physically challenged” and “differently abled”. Say “wheelchair user” instead of “confined to a wheelchair” or “wheelchair bound”. The wheelchair is what enables the person to get around, but they are neither confined by it nor bound to it. The wheelchair is liberating, not confining.

o With any disability, avoid negative, disempowering words like “victim” or “sufferer”. Say “person with AIDS” instead of “AIDS victim” or person who “suffers from AIDS”.

o It’s okay to use idiomatic expressions when talking to people with disabilities. For example, saying “It was good to see you” and “See you later” to a person who is blind is completely acceptable. They will use the same terminology and it’s inappropriate to respond with questions like, “How are you going to see me later?”

o People in wheelchairs will say things like, “Let’s go for a walk” and it’s okay for you to say it too. The situation will only become awkward if you make it so.

o Many people who are Deaf communicate with sign language and consider themselves to be members of a cultural and linguistic minority group. They refer to themselves as Deaf (with a capital D) and may be offended by the term “hearing impaired.” Others may not object to the term, but in general it is safest to refer to people who have hearing loss but communicate through a spoken language as “people with hearing loss” and those who have a profound hearing loss as “people who are Deaf”.

100


Community Groups, Organizations, Associations, and Commissions There are a large number of groups nationally, regionally, and within each state that provide specialized services, information, and advocacy for persons with all disabilities. A number of advocacy groups are listed below, the list is not intended to be complete by any means:

Ability Resources, Inc.: Ability Resources Inc. (www.ability-resources.org/home.org) was founded in 1976. Their mission is to assist people with disabilities in attaining and maintaining their personal independence. One way this can be achieved is in the creation of an environment in which people with disabilities can exercise their rights to control and direct their own lives.

ADA National Network: The ADA National Network (http://adata.org/) provides information, guidance and training on the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), tailored to meet the needs of business, government and individuals at local, regional and national levels. The ADA National Network consists of ten Regional ADA National Network Centers located throughout the United States that provide local assistance to ensure that the ADA is implemented wherever possible.

American Council of the Blind: ACB (www.acb.org) is a national organization advocating on behalf of persons who are blind or have low vision. ACB also publishes A Guide to Making Documents Accessible to People Who Are Blind or Visually Impaired. ACB is located at 1155 15th St. NW, Suite 1004, Washington, DC 20005 (800.424.8666) or by e-mail at [email protected].

American Association of People with Disabilities: The American Association of People with Disabilities (www.aapd.com/) is the largest non-profit, non-partisan, cross-disability organization in the United States.

Maryville College: Maryville College developed the first bachelor’s degree program in interpreting for ASL, and could be a local resource for interpretation (www.maryvillecollege.edu/academics/programs-of-study/american-sign-language/).

National Association of the Deaf: NAD is a national consumer organization representing people who are deaf and hard of hearing. NAD provides information about standards for American Sign Language Interpreters and the Captioned Media Program on its website (www.nad.org).

National Federation of the Blind: NFB is a national organization advocating on behalf of persons who are blind or have low vision. NFB provided online resources (www.nfb.org/) for technology for the blind, including a technology resource list, a computer resource list, screen access technology, sources of large print software for computers, and sources of closed circuit TV (CCTVs). There is also a Tennessee state chapter (www.nfbtn.org/).

National Organization on Disability: The National Organization on Disability promotes the full and equal participation and contribution of America’s 54 million men, women and children with disabilities in all aspects of life. NOD maintains an on-line directory of information and links including transportation-related resources (www.nod.org/).

Paralyzed Veterans of America: PVA is a national advocacy organization representing veterans. PVA’s Sports and Recreation Program promotes a range of activities for people with disabilities, with special emphasis on activities that enhance lifetime health and fitness. PVA’s website (www.pva.org/) provides information on useful sports publications and a list of contacts.

United Spinal Association: United Spinal Association is a membership organization serving individuals with spinal cord injuries or disease. Formerly known as the Eastern Paralyzed Veterans Association, the organization expanded its mission to serve people with spinal cord injuries or disease regardless of their age, gender, or veteran status. Information on accessibility training and consulting services and recreational opportunities for people with spinal cord injuries or disease is available on their website (www.unitedspinal.org/).

World Institute on Disability: WID is an international public policy center dedicated to carrying out research on disability issues and overcoming obstacles to independent living. WID maintains an on-line

101


information and resource directory on technology, research, universal design, and the ADA. (www.wid.org/resources).

Tennessee Department of Human Services – provides information on a wide variety of disability services (www.tn.gov/humanservices/disability-services.html). Information is provided for o Vocational Rehabilitation o Blind & Visually Impaired Services o Deaf, Deaf-Blind, and Hard of Hearing Services o Tennessee Rehabilitation Center o Community Tennessee Rehabilitation Centers o Disability Determination Services o Tennessee Technology Access Program o Councils and Committees o Tennessee Business Enterprises o Vocational Rehabilitation (VR) Office Locations

Tennessee Commission on Aging and Disability: The Tennessee Commission on Aging and Disability (formerly the Commission on Aging) was created by the Tennessee General Assembly in 1963. The Commission is the designated state agency on aging and is mandated to provide leadership relative to aging issues on behalf of older persons in the state. Our mission is to bring together and leverage programs, resources, and organizations to protect and ensure the quality of life and independence of older Tennesseans and adults with disabilities. (www.tn.gov/aging.html).

Tennessee Association of the Deaf: The Tennessee Association of the Deaf (TAD) is a state association affiliated with the National Association of the Deaf and the local chapters across Tennessee. It serves as an advocate for more than 500,000 deaf and hard of hearing people living in Tennessee. The TAD is a non-profit state association operating independently of federal, state, and local. Membership includes deaf, hard of hearing, and hearing people. The mission of TAD is to promote the general welfare of deaf, hard of hearing, and hearing people by advocating accessible services and programs across Tennessee. The paramount significance of this mission is that it will enable all individuals to achieve full participation into the mainstream of life and community (www.deaftenn1897.org/).

Southeast ADA Center: The Southeast ADA Center (formerly known as Southeast DBTAC) is a leader in providing information, training, and guidance on the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and disability access tailored to the needs of business, government, and individuals at local, state, and regional levels. They also conduct research to reduce and eliminate barriers to employment and economic self-sufficiency and to increase the civic and social participation of Americans with disabilities. adasoutheast.org/

Tennessee Disability Pathfinder: Tennessee Disability Pathfinder provides free information, resources, support, and referrals to Tennesseans with disabilities and their families. Through three major program components, they provide information and resources to individuals of all ages, all types of disabilities, and language spoken. vkc.mc.vanderbilt.edu/vkc/pathfinder/

Disability Rights Tennessee: Disability Rights Tennessee (DRT) was founded as E.A.C.H. in 1978 and recently the agency was known as Disability Law & Advocacy Center of Tennessee. Today, DRT is Tennessee’s Protection & Advocacy System and has served—at no cost—more than 40,000 clients with disabilities. Their mission is to protect the rights of Tennesseans with disabilities. DRT provides services to people with disabilities across the state with numerous issues, including employment discrimination, safety in schools, abuse and neglect, and access to community resources and services. www.disabilityrightstn.org/

Tennessee Disability Coalition: The Tennessee Disability Coalition is an alliance of organizations and individuals joined to promote the full and equal participation of people with disabilities in all aspects of

102


life. The Coalition and its member organizations represent Tennesseans of every age, economic background, political persuasion and disability. Some are disability-specific groups, like the Autism Society of Middle Tennessee, while others are cross-disability and may focus on specific issues, such as independent living, employment, or assistive technology. Each is committed to collaboration toward improving the lives of all Tennesseans who are touched by a disability. www.tndisability.org/

Statewide Independent Living Council of Tennessee (SILC): Their mission has been to promote independent living philosophies in Tennessee and support its practices and values. As such, the SILC TN educates the community and public leaders about the IL philosophy, provides training and support to the Independent Living community, and, per new language of the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA), facilitates funding opportunities for expanding the practice of IL in Tennessee. silctn.org/

The Arc Tennessee: The Arc Tennessee is a grassroots, non-profit, statewide advocacy organization for people with intellectual and developmental disabilities and their families. www.thearctn.org/

Tennessee Council of the Blind (TCB): The Tennessee Council of the Blind (TCB) is a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit membership organization whose members are concerned about the dignity and well-being of blind people and a proud affiliate of the American Council of the Blind. Their members include persons who are blind, losing vision, or are parents of a child who is blind or visually impaired or fully sighted. tennesseecounciloftheblind.org/

Support and Training for Exceptional Parents (STEP): Their mission is to improve the lives of families of children with disabilities by guiding them through challenges they face accessing education and community programs. STEP provides services that promote working together with school staff to resolve issues often faced by children with disabilities at school, such as harassment, bullying, low expectations, and social isolation. www.tnstep.org/.

East Tennessee Human Resource Agency (ETHRA): Since 1973, their mission is to help families and individuals remain independent with opportunities to succeed. They maintain an Anderson County ETHRA office and American Job Center in Oak Ridge. www.ethra.org/

Deaf Link: Provides accessible hazard alert system (AHAS), video remote interpreting (VRI), pre-recorded interpreting (PRI), and Shelter Link (an internet-based interpreting service for sheltering and mass care agencies) to provide the highest standard of inclusion for persons who are Deaf, Blind, Hard-of Hearing and Deaf-Blind. www.deaflink.com/.

Potential Funding Opportunities Grants may be available from a wide variety of sources from state and federal agencies to private agencies and non-profits. A number of potential programs are listed below. The list is not intended to be complete by any means and not all grants are funded at all times.

Tennessee Department of Environment & Conservation offers a number of grants for parks and recreation facilities. Recreation Educational Services is responsible for administering federal and state recreational grant programs to local and state governments. The Division manages the Local Parks and Recreation Fund (LPRF), the Recreational Trails Program (RTP), and the Tennessee Recreation Initiative Program (TRIP), the Land and Water Conservation Fund (LWCF), and the Natural Resources Trust Fund (NRTF). Refer to their website for a matrix of grant programs (www.tn.gov/environment/program-areas/res-recreation-educational-services/res-recreation-educational-services-grants0.html).

Tennessee Department of Transportation administers several grant programs for transportation-related projects (https://www.tn.gov/tdot/government/g/gr/tdot-grant-information.html).

103


8.0 Definitions

The words, phrases and definitions summarized below are included in the ADA. Refer to the ADA 28 CFR 35.104 for full definitions. A list of common terms and definitions are included below. 2010 Standards: the 2010 Standards for Accessible Design (SAD), which consist of the 2004 ADA Accessibility Guidelines (ADAAG) and requirements contained in 35.151.

Access Board: an independent Federal agency devoted to accessibility for people with disabilities. The Access Board developed the accessibility guidelines for the ADA and provides technical assistance and training on these guidelines.

Accessible: refers to a site, facility, work environment, service, or program that is easy to approach, enter, operate, participate in, and/or use safely and with dignity by a person with a disability.

Affirmative Action (AA): a set of positive steps that employers use to promote equal employment opportunity and to eliminate discrimination. It includes expanded outreach, recruitment, mentoring, training, management development and other programs designed to help employers hire, retain and advance qualified workers from diverse backgrounds, including persons with disabilities. Affirmative action means inclusion, not exclusion. Affirmative action does not mean quotas and is not mandated by the ADA.

Alteration: a change to a facility in the public right-of-way that affects or could affect pedestrian access, circulation, or use. Alterations include, but are not limited to, resurfacing, rehabilitation, reconstruction, historic restoration, or changes or rearrangement of structural parts or elements of a facility.

Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA): a comprehensive, Federal civil rights law that prohibits discrimination against people with disabilities in employment, state and local government programs and activities, public accommodations, transportation, and telecommunications.

ADA Standards for Accessible Design (ADASAD): consist of the 2004 ADAAG and requirements contained in 35.151 with scoping and technical requirements (dated September 15, 2010) to be applied during the design, construction, and alteration of buildings and facilities covered by Titles II and III of the ADA to the extent required by regulations issued by Federal agencies, including the DOJ and the Department of Transportation (DOT).

Auxiliary Aids and Services: under Titles II and III of the ADA, includes a wide range of services and devices that promote effective communication or allows access to goods and services. Examples of auxiliary aids and services for individuals who are deaf or hard of hearing include qualified interpreters, note takers, computer-aided transcription services, written materials, telephone handset amplifiers, assistive listening systems, telephones compatible with hearing aids, closed caption decoders, open and closed captioning, telecommunications devices for deaf persons (TDDs), videotext displays, and exchange of written notes. Examples for individuals with vision impairments include qualified readers, taped texts, audio recordings, Braille materials, large print materials, and assistance in locating items. Examples for individuals with speech impairments include TDDs, computer terminals, speech synthesizers, and communication boards.

104


Civil Rights Act of 1991: Federal law that capped compensatory and punitive damages under Title I of the ADA for intentional job discrimination. The law also amended the ADA's definition of an employee, adding "with respect to employment in a foreign country, such term includes an individual who is a citizen of the United States."

Complaint: a written statement, alleging violation of the ADA, which contains the complainant’s name and address and describes the City’s alleged discriminatory action in sufficient detail to inform them of the nature and date of the alleged violation. It shall be signed by the complainant or by someone authorized to do so on his or her behalf. Complaints filed on behalf of classes or third parties shall describe or identify (by name, if possible) the alleged victims of discrimination.

Covered Entity: under the ADA, "covered entity" is an entity that must comply with the law. Under Title I, covered entities include employers, employment agencies, labor organizations, or joint labor-management committees. Under Title II, covered entities include state and local government instrumentalities, the National Railroad Passenger Corporation, and other commuter authorities, and public transportation systems. Under Title III, covered entities include public accommodations such as restaurants, hotels, grocery stores, retail stores, etc., as well as privately owned transportation systems.

Cross Slope: the grade that is perpendicular to the direction of pedestrian travel.

Curb Ramp: a ramp that cuts through or is built up to the curb. Curb ramps can be perpendicular or parallel, or a combination of parallel and perpendicular ramps.

Direct Threat: a significant risk to the health or safety of others that cannot be eliminated by reasonable accommodation.

Disability: with respect to an individual, means: a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more of the major life activities of such individual; a record of such an impairment; or being regarded as having such an impairment. Discrimination on the basis of disability: means to:

Limit, segregate, or classify a citizen in a way that may adversely affect opportunities or status because of the person's disability;

Limit, segregate, or classify a participant in a program or activity offered to the public in a way that may adversely affect opportunities or status because of the participant's disability;

Participate in a contract that could subject a qualified citizen with a disability to discrimination; Use any standards, criteria, or methods of administration that have the effect of discriminating on the

basis of disability; Deny equal benefits because of a disability; Fail to make reasonable accommodations to known physical or mental limitations of an otherwise

qualified individual unless it can be shown that the accommodation would impose an undue burden on the City's operations;

Use selection criteria that exclude otherwise qualified people with disabilities from participating in the programs or activities offered to the public; and

Fail to use tests, including eligibility tests, in a manner that ensures that the test results accurately reflect the qualified applicant's skills or aptitude to participate in a program or activity.

Employer: a person engaged in an industry affecting commerce who has 15 or more employees for each working day in each of 20 or more calendar weeks in the current or preceding calendar year, and any agent of such person, except that, for two years following the effective date of this subchapter, an employer means a person engaged in an industry affecting commerce who has 25 or more employees for each working day in each of 20 or more calendar weeks in the current or preceding year, and any agent of such person. Exceptions: The term "employer'' does not include the United States, a corporation wholly owned by the

105


government of the United States, or an Indian tribe; or a bona fide private membership club (other than a labor organization) that is exempt from taxation under section 501(c) of Title 26 [the Internal Revenue Code of 1986].

Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC): the Federal agency charged with enforcing Title I of the ADA.

Essential Job Functions: the fundamental job duties of the employment position that the individual with a disability holds or desires. The term “essential functions” does not include marginal functions of the position.

Equal Employment Opportunity: an opportunity to attain the same level of performance or to enjoy equal benefits and privileges of employment as are available to an average similarly-situated employee without a disability.

Existing Facility: refers to buildings that were constructed before the ADA went into effect. A public building constructed before the effective date of Title II does not have to be fully accessible unless the removal of barriers, including structural ones, is readily achievable.

Facility: all or any portion of buildings, structures, improvements, elements, and pedestrian or vehicular routes located in the public right-of-way.

Grade Break: the line where two surface planes with different grades meet.

Historic Properties: those properties that are listed or eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places or properties designated as historic under State or local law.

Job Analysis: a formal process in which information about a specific job or occupation is collected and analyzed.

Job Description: a detailed summary, usually written, of the major components of a job. A typical job description consists of six major components: essential job functions, knowledge and critical skills, physical demands, environmental factors, the roles of the ADA and other Federal laws such as the Occupational Safety Health Act, and any explanatory information that may be necessary to clarify job duties or responsibilities.

Job Related and Consistent with Business Necessity: standard used to determine whether a qualification standard or employment policy concerns an essential aspect of the job and is required to meet the needs of the business.

Light Duty: generally, "light duty" refers to temporary or permanent work that is physically or mentally less demanding than normal job duties. Some employers use the term "light duty" to mean simply excusing an employee from performing those job functions that s/he is unable to perform because of an impairment. "Light duty" also may consist of particular positions with duties that are less physically or mentally demanding created specifically for the purpose of providing alternative work for employees who are unable to perform some or all of their normal duties. Further, an employer may refer to any position that is sedentary or is less physically or mentally demanding as "light duty". The term is often associated with workers compensation programs.

Major Life Activity: term used in the ADA definition of disability. It refers to activities that an average person can perform with little or no difficulty, such as walking, seeing, speaking, hearing, breathing, learning, performing manual tasks, caring for oneself, and working. These are examples only. Other activities such as sitting, standing, lifting, or reading are also major life activities.

Marginal Job Functions: functions that are not considered essential to a job. Employers must consider removing marginal job functions as an accommodation under the ADA, but do not have to remove essential functions as an accommodation.

106


Medical Examination: a procedure or test that seeks information about an individual's physical or mental impairments or health. The following factors should be considered to determine whether a test (or procedure) is a medical examination: (1) whether the test is administered by a health care professional; (2) whether the test is interpreted by a health care professional; (3) whether the test is designed to reveal an impairment or physical or mental health; (4) whether the test is invasive; (5) whether the test measures an employee's performance of a task or measures his/her physiological responses to performing the task ; (6) whether the test normally is given in a medical setting; and, (7) whether medical equipment is used. In many cases, a combination of factors will be relevant in determining whether a test or procedure is a medical examination. In other cases, one factor may be enough to determine that a test or procedure is medical.

Mitigating Measures: medical treatment or devices that lessen the effects of an impairment, such as medication, a prosthesis, or a hearing aid. When determining whether a person has a disability under the ADA, the effect of mitigating measures is to be considered.

Pedestrian Access Route (PAR): a continuous and unobstructed path of travel provided for pedestrians with disabilities within or coinciding with a pedestrian circulation path.

Pedestrian Circulation Path: a prepared exterior or interior surface provided for pedestrian travel in the public right-of-way.

Physical or Mental Impairment: a physical or mental limitation that may include, but are not limited to: vision, speech, and hearing impairment; emotional disturbance and mental illness; seizure disorders; mental retardation; orthopedic and neuromotor disabilities; learning disabilities; diabetes; heart disease; nervous conditions; cancer; asthma; hepatitis B; HIV infection (HIV condition); and drug addiction if the addict has successfully completed or is participating in a rehabilitation program and no longer uses illegal drugs.

The following conditions are not physical or mental impairments: tranvestism, illegal drug use; homosexuality or bisexuality; compulsive gambling; kleptomania; pyromania; pedophilia; exhibitionism; voyeurism; pregnancy; height; weight; eye color; hair color; left-handedness; poverty; lack of education; a prison record; and poor judgment or quick temper if not symptoms of a mental or physiological disorder.

PROWAG: Proposed Accessibility Guidelines for Pedestrian Facilities within Public Right-of-Way. These proposed guidelines (dated July 26, 2011) provide design criteria for public streets and sidewalks, including pedestrian access routes, street crossings, curb ramps and blended transitions, on-street parking, street furniture, and other elements. The specifications comprehensively address access that accommodates all types of disabilities, including mobility and vision impairments, while taking into account conditions and constraints that may impact compliance, such as space limitations and terrain.

Public Accommodations: entities that must comply with Title III. The term includes facilities whose operations affect commerce and fall within at least one of the following 12 categories: places of lodging (e.g., inns, hotels, motels) (except for owner-occupied establishments renting fewer than six rooms); establishments serving food or drink (e.g., restaurants and bars); places of exhibition or entertainment (e.g., motion picture houses, theaters, concert halls, stadiums); places of public gathering

107


(e.g., auditoriums, convention centers, lecture halls); sales or rental establishments (e.g., bakeries, grocery stores, hardware stores, shopping centers); service establishments (e.g., laundromats, dry-cleaners, banks, barber shops, beauty shops, travel services, shoe repair services, funeral parlors, gas stations, offices of accountants or lawyers, pharmacies, insurance offices, professional offices of health care providers, hospitals); public transportation terminals, depots, or stations (not including facilities relating to air transportation); places of public display or collection (e.g., museums, libraries, galleries); places of recreation (e.g., parks, zoos, amusement parks); places of education (e.g., nursery schools, elementary, secondary, undergraduate, or postgraduate private schools); social service center establishments (e.g., day care centers, senior citizen centers, homeless shelters, food banks, adoption agencies); and places of exercise or recreation (e.g., gymnasiums, health spas, bowling alleys, golf courses).

Public Entity: entities that must comply with Title II. The term is defined as: any state or local government; any department, agency, special purpose district, or other instrumentality of a state or local government; or certain commuter authorities as well as Amtrak. It does not include the Federal government.

Qualified Individual with a Disability: an individual with a disability who, with or without reasonable modification to rules, policies, or practices, removal of architectural, communication, or transportation barriers, or the provision of auxiliary services or aids, meets the essential eligibility requirements for the receipt of services or the participation in programs or activities provided by the City.

Readily Achievable: easily accomplishable and able to be carried out without much difficulty or expense. In determining whether an action is readily achievable, factors to be considered include nature and cost of the action, overall financial resources and the effect on expenses and resources, legitimate safety requirements, impact on the operation of a site, and, if applicable, overall financial resources, size, and type of operation of any parent corporation or entity. Under Title III, public accommodations must remove barriers in existing facilities if it is readily achievable to do so.

Reasonable Accommodation: under Title I, a modification or adjustment to a job, the work environment, or the way things usually are done that enables a qualified individual with a disability to enjoy an equal employment opportunity. Reasonable accommodation is a key nondiscrimination requirement of the ADA.

Reasonable Program Modifications: if an individual’s disabilities prevent them from performing the essential functions of the program or activity, it is necessary to determine whether reasonable program modifications would enable these individuals to perform the essential functions of the program or activity.

Reasonable program modification is any change in a program or activity, or in the way things are customarily done, that enables an individual with a disability to enjoy equal program opportunities. Accommodation means modifications or adjustments:

To a registration or application process to enable an individual with a disability to be considered for the program or activity;

To the program or activity environment in which the duties of a position are performed so that a person with a disability can perform the essential functions of the program or activity; and

That enables individuals with disabilities to enjoy equally the benefits of the program or activity as other similarly situated individuals without disabilities enjoy.

Modification includes making existing facilities and equipment used by individuals readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Modification applies to known disabilities only. Modification is not required if it changes the essential nature of a program or activity for the person with a disability, it creates a hazardous situation, adjustments or modifications requested are primarily for the personal benefit of the individual with a disability, or it poses an undue burden on the City.

108


Record of an Impairment: an individual is disabled if he or she has a history of having an impairment that substantially limits the performance of a major life activity or has been diagnosed, correctly or incorrectly, as having such an impairment. An example: a man, who is in line for a promotion, has a history of cancer treatment, although he is now free of cancer. He is not given the promotion because his bosses are worried that, if his cancer returns, he won’t be able to do the job. He does not, at this point, meet the first part of the definition of disability because he does not have a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities. However, based on his “record of” an impairment, he is being discriminated against.

Regarded as Having a Disability: an individual is disabled if he or she is treated or perceived as having an impairment that substantially limits major life activities, although no such impairment exists. An example: a woman applies for a job as a customer service representative at a department store. Her face is badly scarred from an automobile accident. The interviewer doesn’t want to give her the job, in spite of her skills and experience, because he thinks customers will be uncomfortable looking at her. She is not substantially limited in any major life activity, but the interviewer is “regarding her as” if she has a disability.

Running Slope: the grade that is parallel to the direction of pedestrian travel.

Safe Harbor: elements of existing facilities that already comply with either the 1991 ADA Standards or UFAS are not required to comply with the 2010 ADA Standards unless they were altered on or after March 15, 2012 and elements comprising a path of travel to an altered primary function area are not required to comply with the 2010 ADA Standard merely as the result of an alteration to a primary function area, provided those elements comply with the 1991 ADA Standard or UFAS.

Service Animal: any dog that is individually trained to do work or perform tasks for the benefit of an individual with a disability, including physical, sensory, psychiatric, intellectual, or other mental disability. Other species of animals, whether wild or domestic, trained or untrained, are not service animals for the purposes of this definition. See the 2010 revised requirements at https://www.ada.gov/service_animals_2010.htm.

Substantial Limitation on Major Life Activities: an individual is disabled if she or he has a physical or mental impairment that (a) renders her or him unable to perform a major life activity, or (b) substantially limits the condition, manner, or duration under which she or he can perform a particular major life activity in comparison to other people.

In determining whether physical or mental impairment substantially limits the condition, manner, or duration under which an individual can perform a particular major life activity in comparison to other people, the following factors shall be considered:

The nature and severity of the impairment; The duration or expected duration of the impairment; and The permanent or long term impact (or expected impact) of, or resulting from, the impairment.

Title V of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973: title of the law that prohibits discrimination on the basis of a disability by the Federal government, Federal contractors, by recipients of Federal financial assistance, and in Federally conducted programs and activities.

Transition Plan: refers to a requirement that state and local governments employing 50 or more people develop plans detailing structural changes necessary to achieve facility and program accessibility.

Undue Burden: means significant difficulty or expense incurred in the provision of accommodation. Undue burden includes, but is not limited to, financial difficulty. Undue burden refers to any modification that would be unduly costly, extensive, substantial, or disruptive, or that would fundamentally alter the nature of operation of the business of the City. Whether a particular accommodation will impose an undue hardship is

109


determined on a case-by-case basis. If a particular modification is determined to cause an undue burden to Oak Ridge, the City shall attempt to identify another modification that would not pose such a burden. If cost causes the undue burden, the City must consider whether funding for the modification is available from an outside source. If no such funding is available, the City must give the person with a disability the opportunity to provide the modification or to pay for that portion of the modification that constitutes an undue burden.

Undue Hardship: with respect to the provision of an accommodation under Title I of the ADA, significant difficulty or expense incurred by a covered entity, when considered in light of certain factors. These factors include the nature and cost of the accommodation in relationship to the size, resources, nature, and structure of the employer’s operation. Where the facility making the accommodation is part of a larger entity, the structure and overall resources of the larger organization would be considered, as well as the financial and administrative relationship of the facility to the larger organization. Employers do not have to provide accommodations that cause an undue hardship.

Uniform Federal Accessibility Standards (UFAS): one of two standards that state and local governments can use to comply with Title II's accessibility requirement for new construction and alterations that took place before March 15, 2012. The other standard is the ADA Accessibility Guidelines, which is the enforceable standard for new construction or alternations done after March 15, 2012.

U.S. Department of Justice: Federal agency that is responsible for enforcing Titles II and III of the ADA.

U.S. Department of Transportation: Federal agency that enforces nondiscrimination in public and private transportation. Nondiscrimination includes access to public bus, train and paratransit, as well as privately operated bus and shuttle transportation. The ADA does not cover air transportation, which is subject to the Air Carrier Access Act.

Appendix A

Building Facilities and Parks Physical Barrier Summaries

Buildings and Park Facilities Table A-1 GreenwaysFigure A-1 Greenway Maps

Name & Location Ownership Status Low PriorityMedium Priority High Priority

Total Probable Cost

Municipal Building/Police200 S. Tulane

City Owned $21,080 $30,370 $73,600 $125,050

1010 Incubator Building1010 Commerce Park Drive

City Owned $3,700 $11,830 $3,200 $18,730

Alvin K. Bissell Park200 S. Tulane

City Owned $7,650 $15,960 $112,100 $135,710

Animal Shelter 395 Belgrade Road

City Owned $550 $4,085 $150 $4,785

Badger Building 205 Badger Avenue

City Owned $1,250 $6,220 $550 $8,020

Baseball ComplexWilberforce Avenue

City Owned $15,070 $72,080 $73,100 $160,250

Big Turtle ParkOak Ridge Turnpike

City Owned $10,450 $26,600 $9,200 $46,250

Briarcliff Park Deerfield Lane

City Owned $3,800 $300 $3,500 $7,600

Carl Yearwood Park Bus Terminal Road

City Owned $4,870 $27,765 $450 $33,085

Cedar Hill Park Michigan Avenue

City Owned $10,300 $4,200 $0 $14,500

Central Services 100 Woodbury Lane

City Owned $67,710 $39,250 $3,700 $110,660

Civic Center/Recreation Building 1403 Oak Ridge Turnpike

City Owned $7,190 $32,360 $1,700 $41,250

Elm Grove Park 751 E. Tennessee Avenue

City Owned $0 $37,900 $9,400 $47,300

Elza Gate Park Oak Ridge Turnpike

City Owned $1,500 $550 $0 $2,050

Fire Station 1 2097 Oak Ridge Turnpike

City Owned $3,550 $8,020 $600 $12,170

Fire Station 2 609 Oak Ridge Turnpike

City Owned $4,630 $8,010 $600 $13,240

Fire Station 3 333 Tuskegee Drive

City Owned $14,690 $8,200 $7,400 $30,290

Fire Station 4 652 Enrichment

City Owned $0 $0 $0 $0

Centennial Golf Course 101 Centennial Boulevard

City Owned $12,860 $37,670 $2,300 $52,830

Groves Park at South Hills Tuskegee Drive

City Owned $0 $0 $0 $0

Haw Ridge Park Bethel Valley Road

City Owned $4,700 $100 $0 $4,800

Highland View Park Highland View

City Owned $2,400 $12,200 $300 $14,900

LaSalle Park LaSalle Road

City Owned $19,250 $33,500 $2,900 $55,650

Melton Lake Park Melton Lake Drive

City Owned $3,200 $14,100 $0 $17,300

Milt Dickens Park Athens Road

City Owned $4,000 $25,800 $10,700 $40,500

Pinewood Park Bus Terminal Road

City Owned $16,950 $17,600 $10,000 $44,550

Municipal Swimming Pool172 Providence Road

City Owned $13,060 $16,880 $4,100 $34,040

Public Library 1401 Oak Ridge Turnpike

City Owned $3,500 $6,210 $5,200 $14,910

Scarboro Community Center Carver Avenue

City Owned $14,200 $32,450 $2,500 $49,150

Scarboro Park Carver Avenue

City Owned $27,000 $400 $0 $27,400

Solway Park Bethel Valley Road

City Owned $700 $25,350 $0 $26,050

Tennis Courts 35 Kentucky Avenue

City Owned $15,400 $20,300 $0 $35,700

Wastewater Treatment Plant 100 Monterey Road

City Owned $19,095 $22,445 $1,265 $42,805

Water Filtration Plant 755 Bear Creek Road

City Owned on Federal Property

$9,750 $32,520 $1,100 $43,370

TOTALS $344,055 $631,225 $339,615 $1,314,895

OAK RIDGE ADA SELF EVALUATION STUDY AND TRANSITION PLAN

FACILITY SUMMARY

General Notes: All cost estimates for City facilities are based on a estimated 20198 probable costs from various sources. Bidding in different manners or different time periods will likely require adjustments to the probable project costs. All items indicated as 'TBD' require further evaluation for feasibility due to historical, topographical, or structural concerns. Costs for TBD items are not included above. Soft costs are not included in costs provided, which may include survey, design, construction observation, etc.

City of Oak RidgeFacility Summary 1 of 1

Data collected August 2018

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost01a Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $2,000Notes: The facility has 6 public entrances, only 3 are accessible. Accessible spaces should be provided at these entrances based on public need for access. Some existing spaces have excessive slopes and should be relocated. Provide better directional signage at parking lot entrances directing persons to the accessible spaces on the north side near the ramp and the south entrances that are at grade. The other 3 entrances require stairs to access. Improved safety is possible by not requiring accessible space users on the north side to cross the main vehicle travel lane to access the curb ramp and ramp to the building entrance. Parking on the west side provides access to adjacent park but has excessive slopes. Cost assumes leveling of west parking spaces when parking lot is reconstructed in the future, restriping of all spaces and access aisles due to fading, and signage at parking lot entrances. Additional cost for relocating spaces when additional entry is made accessible.Federal Guideline: 208, 502Accessible Routes and Curb Ramps

02 Curb RampsProvide Compliant Curb Ramp High $300Notes: Curb ramp at front main entrance (not accessible entrances) has cross slope of 3.3%. Correct curb ramp when these entrances are accessible and relocate the accessible space at this location elsewhere to avoid confusion. Cost assumes space is relocated to an accessible entrance.Federal Guideline: 405.3, 406.1

Municipal Building

and Police

NOTE: There is parking on 3 sides of the building, all of which are open to the public and some shared with employees/police vehicles. All parking is connected without exiting the site so is treated as a single parking facility. There are a total of 187 spaces, with 17 reserved for police cars which can be excluded, providing 170 spaces, including 12 accessible and 4 marked as van-accessible. A total of 6 accessible spaces (including 1 van) are required.

Exterior

City of Oak RidgeMunicipal Building and Police Page 1 of 22

Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Accessible Route Medium $1,300

Notes: Thirteen (13) spaces between the two rear entrances need to be provided with bumper blocks to prevent cars from overhanging the sidewalk and obstructing the width to less than 36". Cost is for 13 bumper block.

Federal Guideline: 405.4, 406.4, 405.2, 406.6, 50505-1 Exterior ADA Ramp

Provide Compliant Handrail Extensions Medium $600Notes: Handrails do not extend on both sides 12" beyond the top and bottom and parallel to the ground. Provide extensions that comply.Federal Guideline: 505.10.1

General Public/Employee Circulation Spaces

07-1 Drinking Fountain Near Room 105Provide Compliant Width Alcove Medium $1,200Notes: Alcove required to be min. 36" width for wheelchair access. Provide compliant width alcove. Cost assumes existing alcove is widened.Federal Guideline: 602.2, 305.7.1

07-2 Drinking Fountain Near Room 109 Provide Compliant Width Alcove Low $1,200Notes: Alcove required to be min. 36" width for standing user access. Provide compliant width alcove. Cost assumes existing alcove is widened.Federal Guideline: 602.2, 305.7.1

08a-1 Administration Front Entrance Doors Typical of 4

Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $500Notes: Closing speed is less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer on 1 door and ISA symbol placed on accessible door. Federal Guideline: 216.6, 404.2.8.1

InteriorMunicipal Offices

NOTES: Total of four (4) drinking fountain provided, requiring 2 each to be wheelchair and standing accessible. Fountains near Room 105 and accessible restrooms near courtroom are wheelchair height bubbler.

NOTES: Total of six (6) public entrances provided. Per 206.4.1, 60% of public entrances are to be on an accessible route. Currently only 3 of 6 entrances are on a route that does not require use of stairs to enter the building. Explore options to provide additional access into the building at one of the main front entrances, likely the one for the Court, as the existing access to the court is distant from building entrances that are accessible.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Directional Signage High $100Notes: This entrance is not considered accessible since it requires stairs be used to access from the exterior. Provide directional sign at access stairs for this entrance that includes the ISA and an arrow pointing in the direction of the nearest accessible entrance.Federal Guideline: 216.6, 703.5

08a-2 Rear Main EntranceProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device High $400Notes: Device located at this exit door is at 60" height (48" max.). Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

08b-10 Rear Main Entrance Interior Vestibule DoorProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

09-1 Municipal Building CorridorsProvide Proper Signage Medium $3,000Notes: All permanent spaces require signage with visual and tactile letters and Braille. Existing signage is entirely visual (no tactile or Braille) or missing entirely from many spaces. Evaluate and develop a signing plan for the facility to determine how to best identify the spaces that are not included below due to public access and provide compliant signage at all doors in a compliant location. Spaces would include private offices, mechanical rooms, storage, janitor's closets, etc.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Protect Protruding Objects Low $50Notes: AED near main front entry protrudes 8" at 30" (4" max. between 27"-80"). Provide permanent, cane-detectable object below.Federal Guideline: 307.2Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) throughout most hallways in this area of the facility, but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device Low $1,600Notes: Devices in several locations at 51" (over 48" max. ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost15-2 Men's Employee Only Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Signage provided includes only visual text and 4" pictogram. Sign with tactile text, the ISA (since not all restrooms are accessible), and Braille required with min. 6" pictogram field. Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Low $110Notes: Distance to lower door louvers is less than 10" min. smooth req'd. on door. Provide kick plate with filler on door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Insulate Water Lines Medium $100Notes: Supply lines, valves, and exposed drain pipes are not insulated to protect against contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: Bottom edge of reflecting surface over sink is at 48" ht. (40" max.).Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: Operable parts at 51" above floor (15"-48" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 308, 309.3Reposition Soap Dispenser Low $50Notes: Operable parts at 51" above floor (15"-48" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 308, 309.3Provide Visual Fire Alarms Medium $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Provide Compliant Outlets Low $50Notes: Electrical outlets at 51" height (15-48" req'd.). Lowest cost option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Modify Stall Hardware Medium $200Notes: Handles not provided on stall door (handles req'd. on both sides). Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7, 604.8

NOTES: This restroom should be made to provide a compliant wheelchair stall for use by employees. There are no other restrooms with a wheelchair stall in this work area. Items below assume that renovations can be done within existing space but cost may vary if issues are discovered that are not evident from visual inspection.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Wheelchair Stall High $3,500

Notes: Stall door swings into the space, door clear width is only 28" (32" min.), total width of stall is 36" (60" min. req'd. for wheelchair stall), stall depth only 53", side grab bar is not compliant, and there is no rear grab bar. There are no wheelchair accessible facilities in the employee area, determine best option to provide (combine stalls in this restroom or renovate other space to provide unisex restroom that is wheelchair accessible). Consider modifications to provide 1 compliant width wheelchair stall and modify sink area to provide 2nd stall to maintain fixture count.

Federal Guideline: 404.2, 604, 609Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The coat hook on the back of the wheelchair stall door is located at 66" (48" max.). Lower or provide additional hook at 48" max. height.Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308

15-5 Women's Employee Only Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Signage provided includes only visual text and 4" pictogram. Sign with tactile text, the ISA (since not all restrooms are accessible), and Braille required with min. 6" pictogram field. Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Low $110Notes: Distance to lower door louvers is less than 10" min. smooth req'd. on door. Provide kick plate with filler on door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. required. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Maneuvering Space at Door Medium included belowNotes: The clear space perpendicular to the door (pull side with latch side approach) is only 39" (54" req'd. for door with closer). Best option likely to be relocation of privacy wall, which then impacts clear space in front of stalls. Cost TBD and assumed to be corrected with wheelchair stall improvements noted below.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1Insulate Water Lines Medium $100Notes: Supply lines, valves, and exposed drain pipes are not insulated to protect against contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5

NOTES: This restroom should be made to provide a compliant wheelchair stall for use by employees. There are no other restrooms with a wheelchair stall in this work area. Items below assume that renovations can be done within existing space but cost may vary if issues are discovered that are not evident from visual inspection.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Provide Compliant Outlets Low $50Notes: Electrical outlets at 51" height (15-48" req'd.). Lowest cost option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Compliant Wheelchair Stall High $5,000Notes: Stall door swings into the space, door clear width is only 23" (32" min.), space in front of door is only 36" (42" min.), total width of stall is 36" (60" min. req'd. for wheelchair stall), and there are no grab bars. There are no wheelchair accessible facilities in the employee area, determine best option to provide. Consider modifications to provide 1 compliant width wheelchair stall in existing sink area and relocate 1 sink to existing stall area to maintain total number of toilets and sinks. Cost provided assumes this alteration with relocation of entry privacy wall.Federal Guideline: 404.2, 604, 609Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The coat hook on the back of the wheelchair stall door is located at 66" (48" max.). Lower or provide additional hook at 48" max. height.Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308102 Court Clerk

18-2 City Court Clerk Office 102Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2Provide Compliant Height Electrical Outlet Low $50Notes: Electrical outlet at 8" (over 15-48" req'd.). Lowest cost option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100

Notes: No compliant signage provided, visual text only on existing sign. Sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location.

Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $900

Notes: Service counter is at 42” height (36" max. req'd. for verbal interaction). Provide min. 36" wide section of service counter at 36" max. height.

Federal Guideline: 227.3, 904.4


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost104 Training Room

18-1 Training Room 104Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100


Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703108 Conference Room

18-3 Conference Room 108Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Provide Visual Fire Alarms Medium $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100


Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No signage provided at door to storage. Sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location. Note the door to storage has non-compliant knob hardware but the space is exempt.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703113 Personnel/Risk Management

08b-7 Personnel Risk Management 113 DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100


Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost18-4 Personnel Risk Management Room 113

Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Provide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $900


Federal Guideline: 227.3, 904.4Protect/Reposition Protruding objects Low $100Notes: The service counter protrudes more then 4" at 41" into the public space. Protect the exposed side with permanent, cane-detectable object.Federal Guideline: 307.2Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100



General Public/Employee Circulation Spaces07-4 Drinking Fountain Near Community Development Reception

Provide Compliant Width Alcove Low $1,200Notes: Alcove required to be min. 36" width for standing user access. Provide compliant width alcove. Cost assumes existing alcove is widened.Federal Guideline: 602.2, 305.7.1

08a-4 Utility Business Office EntryProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08b-11 Utility Business Conference Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100


Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Replace Door Hardware Low $300Notes: Existing door lock hardware requires grasping and twisting. Replace with compliant hardware.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

Utility Business Offices/Community Development


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost09-1 Utility/Community Development Corridors

Provide Proper Signage Medium $2,000Notes: All permanent spaces require signage with visual and tactile letters and Braille. Existing signage is entirely visual (no tactile or Braille) or missing entirely from many spaces. Evaluate and develop a signing plan for the facility to determine how to best identify the spaces that are not included below due to public access and provide compliant signage at all doors in a compliant location. Spaces would include private offices, mechanical rooms, storage, janitor's closets, etc.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) throughout hallways in this area of the facility, but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device Low $800Notes: Devices in several locations at 51" (over 48" max. ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

18-7 Utility Business Office Conference RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100


Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 53" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 308.2Provide Compliant Door Hardware Medium $220Notes: Door has knobs that require tight grasping and twisting. Note that latch is disengaged but existing hardware still difficult for some persons to operate.Federal Guideline: 206.4, 404.2.7Provide Visual Fire Alarms Medium $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72

18-8 Utility Business Office Reception Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 53" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 308.2


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $900


Federal Guideline: 227.3, 904.4Provide Accessible Working Surface or Alternate Accommodation Medium $200Notes: Working surface is at 42” height (28-34" req'd). Provide working surface at 34" max. height with 27" min. knee space below. Lowest cost option is small table.Federal Guideline: 226.1, 902

General Public/Employee Circulation Spaces08a Fire Department Entry Door

Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Directional Signage High $100

Notes: This entrance is not considered accessible since it requires stairs be used to access from the exterior. Provide directional sign at access stairs for this entrance that includes the ISA and an arrow pointing in the direction of the nearest accessible entrance. Remove this sign when ramp is constructed.

Federal Guideline: 216.6, 703.5Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device High $400Notes: Device located at this exit door is at 60" height (48" max.). Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

09-1 Fire Department CorridorProvide Proper Signage Medium $1,000Notes: All permanent spaces require signage with visual and tactile letters and Braille. Existing signage is entirely visual (no tactile or Braille) or missing entirely from many spaces. Evaluate and develop a signing plan for the facility to determine how to best identify the spaces that are not included below due to public access and provide compliant signage at all doors in a compliant location. Spaces would include private offices, mechanical rooms, storage, janitor's closets, etc.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/A

Notes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) throughout most hallways in the facility, but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.


Fire Department


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost16 Fire Department Men's Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: This set of restrooms is not accessible. Replace existing sign with compliant sign on latch side wall that includes tactile letters and Braille without ISA pictogram and provide additional directional sign directing persons to the accessible set of restrooms at lobby. Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door N/A N/ANotes: The clear space on the pull side is 14" (18" min. req'd.). Explore options.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1Provide Compliant Door Hardware N/A N/ANotes: Door has knobs that require tight grasping and twisting. Federal Guideline: 206.4, 404.2.7Reposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: Bottom edge of reflecting surface over sink is at 41" ht. (40" max.).Federal Guideline: 603.3Provide Compliant Turning and Clear Space N/A N/ANotes: There is not a 60" diameter turning space within the room for a wheelchair. There is not the required 30"x48" min. clear space within the room entirely outside the door swing.Federal Guideline: 304, 305.3, 603.2Provide Visual Fire Alarms Medium $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Reposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: Bottom edge of reflecting surface over sink is at 47" ht. (40" max.).Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Toilet N/A N/ANotes: Centerline of toilet in stall located at 14" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.) and flush controls not on open side of toilet. Federal Guideline: 604.2, 604.6Provide Clear Space at Toilet N/A N/ANotes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is 30" (60" min. req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.3.1

Notes: This set of restrooms are not accessible and cannot have a compliant wheelchair space provided without significant renovations. This restroom has a single toilet fixture and sink. Consider identifying the employee restrooms as accessible after being altered and provide proper signage as noted below. Items provided below are for information only unless priority and cost is included.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Toilet Paper Dispenser N/A N/ANotes: Dispenser mounted outside 7"-9" to centerline from front of toilet as req'd.Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Grab Bars N/A N/ANotes: No grab bars provided, required on side and rear wall.Federal Guideline: 604.5

16 Fire Department Women's Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: This set of restrooms is not accessible. Replace existing sign with compliant sign on latch side wall that includes tactile letters and Braille without ISA pictogram and provide additional directional sign directing persons to the accessible set of restrooms at lobby. Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door N/A N/ANotes: The clear space on the pull side is 14" (18" min. req'd.). Explore options.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1Provide Compliant Door Hardware N/A N/ANotes: Door has knobs that require tight grasping and twisting. Federal Guideline: 206.4, 404.2.7Reposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: Bottom edge of reflecting surface over sink is at 41" ht. (40" max.).Federal Guideline: 603.3Provide Compliant Turning and Clear Space N/A N/ANotes: There is not a 60" diameter turning space within the room for a wheelchair. There is not the required 30"x48" min. clear space within the room entirely outside the door swing.Federal Guideline: 304, 305.3, 603.2Provide Visual Fire Alarms Medium $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Reposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: Bottom edge of reflecting surface over sink is at 47" ht. (40" max.).Federal Guideline: 603.3Replace Flush Controls N/A N/ANotes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6

Notes: This set of restrooms are not accessible and cannot have a compliant wheelchair space provided without significant renovations. This restroom has a single toilet fixture and sink. Consider identifying the employee restrooms as accessible after being altered and provide proper signage as noted below. Items provided below are for information only unless priority and cost is included.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Toilet N/A N/ANotes: Centerline of toilet in stall located at 14" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.) and flush controls not on open side of toilet. Federal Guideline: 604.2, 604.6Provide Clear Space at Toilet N/A N/ANotes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is 30" (60" min. req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser N/A N/ANotes: Dispenser mounted outside 7"-9" to centerline from front of toilet as req'd.Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Grab Bars N/A N/ANotes: No grab bars provided, required on side and rear wall.Federal Guideline: 604.5

18 Break RoomReposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim is 36" high (34" max. req'd). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3

General Public/Employee Circulation Spaces08a-3 Police Rear Entrance

Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device High $400Notes: Device located at this exit door is at 60" height (48" max.). Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3Provide Maneuvering Space at Door High $100Notes: Power door control clear space outside of the door swing is obstructed by trash receptacle. Move trash receptacle. Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

08a Police/Courts Main Entry Typical of 4Provide Compliant Accessible Entrance High $50,000Notes: ADA standards require 60% of public entrances be accessible. With 6 existing entrances, only 3 are accessible (4 required). This entrance would be the most logical to provide access to given proximity to the Court at this entrance. Cost assumes an accessible route (ramp with compliant handrails) is provided at this location and may vary based on assumption of a ramp being constructed.Federal Guideline: 206.4.1, 402

Police and Court


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $500Notes: Closing speed is less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer on 1 door and ISA symbol placed on accessible door. Federal Guideline: 216.6, 404.2.8.1Provide Directional Signage High $100

Notes: This entrance is not considered accessible since it requires stairs be used to access from the exterior. Provide directional sign at access stairs for this entrance that includes the ISA and an arrow pointing in the direction of the nearest accessible entrance. Remove this sign when ramp is constructed.

Federal Guideline: 216.6, 703.508a Police Employee East Door

Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08a Police Break Room East DoorProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08b-12 Vending Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100


Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The closing speed is less than 5 sec. Cost is for a new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

09-1 Court/Public Safety CorridorsProvide Proper Signage Medium $5,000Notes: All permanent spaces require signage with visual and tactile letters and Braille. Existing signage is entirely visual (no tactile or Braille) or missing entirely from many spaces. Evaluate and develop a signing plan for the facility to determine how to best identify the spaces that are not included below due to public access and provide compliant signage at all doors in a compliant location. Spaces would include private offices, mechanical rooms, storage, janitor's closets, etc.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable CostLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/A

Notes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) throughout most hallways in the facility, but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.

Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device Low $1,600Notes: Devices in several locations at 51" (over 48" max. ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

15-1 Men's Public Restroom Near CourtroomProvide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Low $110Notes: Distance to lower door louvers is less than 10" min. smooth req'd. on door. Provide kick plate with filler on door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: Bottom edge of reflecting surface over sink is at 51" ht. (40" max.).Federal Guideline: 603.3Provide Visual Fire Alarms Medium $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Modify Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: Handle not provided on outside of stall door (handles req'd. on both sides). Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7, 604.8Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The coat hook on the back of the wheelchair stall door is located at 72" (48" max.). Lower or provide additional hook at 48" max. height.Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308

15-6 Women's Public Restroom Near CourtroomProvide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Low $110Notes: Distance to lower door louvers is less than 10" min. smooth req'd. on door. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: Bottom edge of reflecting surface over sink is at 51" ht. (40" max.).Federal Guideline: 603.3Provide Visual Fire Alarms Medium $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Modify Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: Handle not provided on inside of stall door (handles req'd. on both sides). Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7, 604.8


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The coat hook on the back of the wheelchair stall door is located at 72" (48" max.). Lower or provide additional hook at 48" max. height.Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308

18-6 Police Department Reception AreaLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No compliant signage provided at 2 doors to 'Authorized Personnel Only', sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703101 Courtroom

08b-1 Courtroom Break Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No compliant signage provided, sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location. Consider signage on both sides in this location.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b-2 Courtroom Door to Police DepartmentProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No compliant signage provided, sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location. Consider signage on both sides in this location.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The closing speed is less than 5 sec. Cost is for a new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

08b-3 Courtroom Break Room Door to VendingProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No compliant signage provided, sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location. Consider signage on both sides in this location.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b-5 Courtroom Door to City Clerk OfficeProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No compliant signage provided, visual text only on existing sign. Sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location. Consider signage on both sides in this location.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost08b-6 Main Courtroom Door (Typical of 2 sets)

Provide Compliant Signage (2) Medium $200Notes: No compliant signage provided, visual text only on existing sign above door. Sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location at each set of doors. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Replace Door Hardware (2) Low $440Notes: Existing door lock hardware requires grasping and twisting. Replace with compliant hardware.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

08b-8 Police Department Door Near 114Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100



08b-9 Police Department Reception Door to Offices Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100



18 Police Break RoomReposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim is 36" high (34" max. req'd). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3

18 Courtroom Break RoomReposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim is 36" high (34" max. req'd). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost37-1 Courtroom

Provide Assistive Listening Devices and Signage High $4,000Notes: No signage is present and no indication that assistive listening system and devices are available as required. This space also used as courtroom. Approximately 52 chairs within public gallery. Per table 219.3, 3 receivers are required, 2 must be hearing-aid compatible. Cost is for signs in hallway and in the room and devices. Federal Guideline: 219.2-219.3, 216.10, 703.7.2.4, 706.1Provide Ramp Access to Upper Level Low $1,200Notes: Stairs (3 steps) at either end of the judge's bench and court reporter is the only access, no wheelchair access to the upper level. Investigate least impacting option to provide compliant access for wheelchair to the stage, likely a ramp. Cost is for pre-fabricated aluminum ramp installation.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2Provide Visual Fire Alarms Medium $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Provide Compliant Height Lectern Medium $800Notes: Existing 40" high lectern does not permit sight lines to user in a wheelchair. Provide lower height unit with working surface no higher that 34".Federal Guideline: 902Men's and Women's Restroom/Locker Room/Showers

15-3 Police Department Men's Locker Room

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Signage provided includes only visual text. Sign with tactile text, the ISA (since not all restrooms are accessible), and Braille required with min. 6" pictogram field. Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703Insulate Water Lines Medium $200Notes: Supply lines, valves, and exposed drain pipes are not insulated to protect against contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: Operable parts at 53" above floor (15"-48" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 308, 309.3

NOTES: The locker room restrooms for both genders should be made to provide a compliant wheelchair stall for use by all police employees. There are no other restrooms with a wheelchair stall in this work area. Items below assume that renovations can be done within existing space but cost may vary if issues are discovered that are not evident from visual inspection.

NOTES: ADASAD 206.2.4 Exception 1 states that raised courtroom stations (judge's bench, court reporter, etc.) are not required to provide vertical access as long as all clear and maneuvering spaces are provided to allow future installation of vertical access.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProtect Protruding Objects Low $50Notes: Electrical box protrudes 6" at 52" (4" max. between 27"-80"). Provide permanent, cane-detectable object below.Federal Guideline: 307.2Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Reposition Coat Hooks Low $50Notes: The coat hooks outside stall are located at 66" above the ground (15-48" req'd.). Provide additional hook at 48" max. Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308Modify Stall Hardware Medium $200Notes: Handles not provided on stall door (handles req'd. on both sides). Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7, 604.8Provide Compliant Wheelchair Stall High $3,500Notes: Stall door swings into the space, door clear width is only 29" (32" min.), total width of stall is 40" (60" min. req'd. for wheelchair stall), stall depth only 50", and there are no grab bars. There are no wheelchair accessible facilities in the employee area, determine best option to provide. Consider modifications to provide 1 compliant width wheelchair stall, possible options include locating wheelchair stall at sink area and relocating single sink adjacent to urinal or modify walls or expand into adjacent rooms. Cost is placeholder and may vary.Federal Guideline: 404.2, 604, 609

15-4 Police Department Women's Locker Room

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Signage provided includes only visual text. Sign with tactile text, the ISA (since not all restrooms are accessible), and Braille required with min. 6" pictogram field. Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703Provide Maneuvering Space at Door Medium $600Notes: Clearance on latch pull side of the door is 10" (18" parallel to door on latch side and 60" perpendicular req'd.). Investigate options, which may include reversing swing of door (assumed in the cost).Federal Guideline: 404.2.4Insulate Water Lines Low $100Notes: Supply lines, valves, and exposed drain pipes are not insulated to protect against contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5

NOTES: The locker room restrooms for both genders should be made to provide a compliant wheelchair stall for use by all police employees. There are no other restrooms with a wheelchair stall in this work area. Items below assume that renovations can be done within existing space but cost may vary if issues are discovered that are not evident from visual inspection.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Coat Hooks Low $50Notes: The coat hooks outside stall are located at 66" above the ground (15-48" req'd.). Provide additional hook at 48" max. Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Provide Compliant Wheelchair Stall High $3,500

Notes: Stall door swings into the space, door clear width is only 29" (32" min.), total width of stall is 39" (60" min. req'd. for wheelchair stall), clear space at door only 40" deep (42" min.), stall depth only 50", and there are no grab bars. There are no wheelchair accessible facilities in the employee area, determine best option to provide. Consider modifications to provide 1 compliant width wheelchair stall, possible option includes widening stall into sink area and providing sink in alternate. Cost is placeholder and may vary.

Federal Guideline: 404.2, 604, 60917-1 Men's Locker Room Showers

Provide Compliant Transfer Shower Low $3,500Notes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Compliant transfer shower that is 36"x36" with compliant seat and grab bars and 2" high max. threshold (existing is 7") required. Cost provided to make 1 shower stall comply and actual cost may vary.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608Provide Accessible Lockers Low $1,500Notes: Lockers have hooks and shelves within that are above 48". Provide 3 accessible lockers that have opening and locking devices operable without twisting or grasping motions and require no more than 5 lbs. of force to operate with storage devices at 48" max.Federal Guideline: 811.4, 309.4Provide Compliant Benches in Changing Area Medium $1,800Notes: There are no compliant benches in the locker room. Accessible benches required to be 42" long and 20-24" wide with back support and adjacent 30"x48" clear area for wheelchair adjacent to accessible lockers. Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost17 Women's Locker Room Showers

Provide Compliant Transfer Shower Low $3,500

Notes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Compliant transfer shower that is 36"x36" with compliant seat and grab bars and 2" high max. threshold required. Cost provided to make 1 shower stall comply and actual cost may vary.

Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608Provide Accessible Lockers Low $500Notes: Lockers have hooks and shelves within that are above 48". Provide 1 accessible locker that has opening and locking devices operable without twisting or grasping motions and require no more than 5 lbs. of force to operate with storage devices at 48" max.Federal Guideline: 811.4, 309.4Provide Compliant Benches in Changing Area Medium $600Notes: There are no compliant benches in the locker room. Accessible benches required to be 42" long and 20-24" wide with back support and adjacent 30"x48" clear area for wheelchair adjacent to accessible lockers. Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903Police Conference Room

18-5 Conference Room Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No signage provided. Sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

Facility Total: $125,050


Item # Description Priority Probable CostGeneral Notes: 1. Floor plans provided have different room numbers and use designations so accuracy as provided above cannot be confirmed.2. 6 public entrances provided, only 3 are accessible. Best additional public entrance would be at Court/Public Safety to minimize interior travel for wheelchair user accessing the court.3. Single user restrooms for employees only in Dispatch and Fire Department were not evaluated in detail. Fire Department restrooms not large enough to be made compliant. Accessible restrooms available in close proximity for employees, provide directional signage.4. Restrooms at the Courtroom for public use are the only public restrooms available and are assumed to be made to be fully compliant.5. Employee restrooms in Admin area are assumed to be made compliant since there is no close restrooms available. Will require review of options and verification of other codes for fixtures counts/ratio.6. Police locker room restrooms are assumed to be made compliant since there is no close restrooms available for police employees. Will require review of options and verification of other codes for fixtures counts/ratio.7. Visual fire alarms are required when an existing fire alarm system is upgraded or replaced or a new fire alarm system is installed. It appears as though only portions of the facility that have been renovated (portions of Police and Utility Department) have visual fire alarms. Visual fire alarms are required in all public and common use areas, including all restrooms, locker rooms, break rooms, conference rooms, and multi-employee use work areas. Rooms that are required to have visual fire alarms where none were observed are noted for addition.



ExteriorItem # Description Priority Probable Cost01a Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $4,000Notes: Accessible parking is located near the main front entrance but additional entrances to the facility exist, another on the side to the main building and several on the front to individual suites. Provide an accessible space to service the side entrance, which is also public. Existing accessible spaces and access aisles have slopes up to 2.6% (2.0% max.). Cost assumes existing parking is milled and leveled when parking lot is reconstructed, 1 existing accessible space is relocated to the side of the building (and meets van requirements), and signage, pavement markings, and curb ramp provided. Also consider relocating signage to designate the van-accessible space with the access aisle on the passenger side, where most wheelchair lifts are provided in vehicles.Federal Guideline: 208.2, 208.3, 216.5, 502, 703.7.2.1Provide Bumper Blocks Medium $100Notes: Parking spaces between the accessible parking and the pathway to the main front entrance could be obstructed by overhanging vehicles. Provide bumper blocks to limit overhang at 1 space.Federal Guideline: 403.5.1, 502.7Accessible Routes and Curb Ramps

02 Curb RampsProvide Compliant Curb Ramp High $2,500Notes: The existing curb ramp at the front of the facility provides has running slope of 10.0% (8.33% max.), cross slope of 2.5% (2.0% max.), and no level landing or turning space. Reconstruct ramp as a parallel ramp with access from the shared access aisle. Cost assumes reconstruction of ramp.Federal Guideline: 405, 406

1010 Incubator Building

NOTE: There is parking on 3 sides of the building, all of which are connected without exiting the site so is treated as a single parking facility. There are a total of 43 spaces, including 3 accessible and 1 marked as van-accessible. A total of 2 accessible spaces (including 1 van) are required.

City of Oak Ridge1010 Incubator Building 1 of 5

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost04 Accessible Routes

Provide Compliant Accessible Route Medium $1,200Notes: Sidewalks at the front of the building accessing the main front entrance have cross slopes up to 2.4% (2.0% max.). Replace walks at 2% max. in both directions with no level changes. Federal Guideline: 403.3, 403.5.2Provide Signage Medium $400Notes: Provide directional signage at two sidewalks leading directly to suites at front of the building to provide guidance to pedestrians to utilize either the main front entry or side entrance.Federal Guideline: 216.6, 703.5

InteriorGeneral Circulation Spaces

07-1 Drinking FountainReplace Non-Compliant Drinking Fountain Medium $2,500Notes: Single fountain provided, bubbler height of 36" provides accessibility to wheelchair users (36" max.). Replace with compliant height hi-lo drinking fountain.Federal Guideline: 211, 602

08a-1 Main Front Entrance Door Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08a-2 Side Entrance Door Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08a Rear Loading Dock Door Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

09-1 Building CorridorsProvide Proper Signage Medium $1,500Notes: All permanent spaces require signage with visual and tactile letters and Braille outside entry door. Existing signage is entirely visual (no tactile or Braille) or missing entirely from some spaces. Evaluate and develop a signing plan for the facility to determine how to best identify the spaces (by suite number) and provide compliant signage at all doors in a compliant location. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable CostLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) throughout most hallways in this area of the facility, but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device Low $1,200Notes: Devices in several locations at 51" (over 48" max. ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

15-1 Men's RestroomRelocate Signage High $50Notes: Signage provided is on the pull side of the door (must be on push side or wall adjacent to latch). Relocate sign to wall adjacent to latch at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) throughout most hallways in this area of the facility, but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Compliant Width Urinal Access Low $200Notes: Existing access to accessible urinal is 28-1/2" (30" req'd.). Relocate or remove partition between urinals to provide clear width.Federal Guideline: 305.3Modify Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: Handles not provided on inside of wheelchair stall door (handles req'd. on both sides). Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7, 604.8Reposition Toilet Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 22" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.2Reposition Side and Rear Grab Bars Low $500Notes: Grab bars mounted at 31" height (33-36" req'd.). Reinstall grab bars at compliant height and locations relative to interior walls and toilet centerline.Federal Guideline: 604.5, 609.4Reconfigure Partitions Low $600Notes: Stall width is only 57" (60" min. req'd.). Reconfigure partitions to provide 60" width min. stall and compliant toilet centerline. Ensure min. 56" depth of stall for wall-hung toilet.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1.2


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The coat hook on the back of the wheelchair stall door is located at 66" (48" max.). Lower or provide additional hook at 48" max. height.Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308

15-2 Women's RestroomRelocate Signage High $50Notes: Signage provided is on the pull side of the door (must be on push side or wall adjacent to latch). Relocate sign to wall adjacent to latch at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) throughout most hallways in this area of the facility, but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Modify Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: Handles not provided on inside of wheelchair stall door (handles req'd. on both sides). Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7, 604.8Reposition Toilet Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 21" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.2Replace Flush Controls Medium $400Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Reposition Side and Rear Grab Bars Low $500Notes: Grab bars mounted at 31" height (33-36" req'd.). Reinstall grab bars at compliant height and locations relative to interior walls and toilet centerline.Federal Guideline: 604.5, 609.4Reconfigure Partitions Low $600Notes: Stall width is only 57" (60" min. req'd.). Reconfigure partitions to provide 60" width min. stall and compliant toilet centerline. Ensure min. 56" depth of stall for wall-hung toilet.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1.2Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The coat hook on the back of the wheelchair stall door is located at 66" (48" max.). Lower or provide additional hook at 48" max. height.Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308


Item # Description Priority Probable CostSuites

08a Exterior Suite Access DoorsProvide Means of Egress Signage High $300Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Cost provided for signs at all suite doors (3 on front building face).Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703


General Notes: 1. There are multiple entrances to the building, one each on the front and side that provide access to the main building interior hallway and several entrances directly into various suites on the front of the building. Each main building entry should be provided with min. 1 van-accessible space nearest an accessible route to the respective door. Other doors should have directional signage placed at the main sidewalk directing persons with access needs to the main entrances.2. Several of the building spaces (suites) are unfinished. Finished spaces provide no City programs, so the extent of accessibility to individual rooms (other than common use restrooms) was limited to entry/exit doors and accessible routes to the interior building entrance.


A.K Bissell Park

Data collectedAugust and

September 2018

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost01-a Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking High $6,000Notes: Existing accessible spaces and access aisles have slopes up to 6.3% (2.0% max.). Existing parking spaces only 92" wide (96" min.). Cost assumes existing accessible parking area is leveled when parking lot is reconstructed and spaces and access aisle 96" min. width provided.Federal Guideline: 208.2, 208.2.4, 502

Accessible Routes04-1, 4-2 Southeast Sidewalk, Badger Avenue to Municipal Center Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Route and Signage High $9,500Notes: The sidewalks in this area have very limited connections that can be made accessible. Stairs are required to connect to the main park to the north and a secondary parking lot access at the Municipal Center and nearly all of the walks in this area have running slopes of 7-9% and cross slopes well over 2% maximum. Provide signage at Badger Avenue, Municipal Center south access stairs, and sidewalk intersection at Municipal Center accessible parking of severe slopes and access should be provided at the library and Civic Center parking lots. Cost assumes signage as noted and replacement of entire walk from Municipal Center accessible space to ADA seating for the amphitheater on the edge of the woods to the southwest (see area included to right).Federal Guideline: 403.3

NOTE: Parking is available at a small parking facility on Badger Avenue, in addition to the parking lot for the library and Civic Center/Recreation Building on Oak Ridge Turnpike (details included in respective facility assessments). 7 total parking spaces provided in lot, 2 marked as accessible including 1 van-accessible. 1 van-accessible space with access aisle and compliant sign required.

NOTE: Portions of the site were under construction at the time of the assessment. Sections of the accessible routes have been broken into logical sections, with information below regarding compliance issues. Recommendations include providing a compliant accessible route from all accessible parking for the park and adjacent City buildings and to connect to at least 1 of each type of site feature. Not all routes may need to be accessible and should be signed as such if there are compliance issues.

City of Oak RidgeA.K. Bissell Park Page 1 of 7

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost04-3 Loop Northeast of Amphitheater and Connection to Restrooms

Provide Compliant Accessible Route and Signage High $25,000Notes: Connector of loop to ROW at S. Tulane Ave. has 2.9% cross slope and 6+% running slope. Much of loop has cross slopes up to 2.6% and variable condition. Cost assumes replacement of entire walk from S. Tulane to loop and north half of loop to the west side and connection to restrooms at amphitheater. Signage should be placed at both ends of south loop identifying the other portion of the loop as the accessible route until it can be reconstructed (cost of south half not included). Also, several tree branches and other vegetation protrudes into the path that need to be trimmed.Federal Guideline: 403.3

04-4 Sidewalk from Amphitheater to Play StructureProvide Compliant Accessible Route High $800Notes: Slopes of sidewalk at the play structure have non-compliant slopes. Federal Guideline: 403.3

04-5 West Loop and Connection to Badger Road Parking LotProvide Compliant Accessible Route High $50,000Notes: Running slope from parking lot to bridge access to main portion of the park has running slopes of 6-7%, with slopes of bridge being well above 5%. Explore options for connectivity to north of bridge, cost assumes installation of ramp from parking to accessible route at bridge, with grading and ramp with compliant landings and handrails. Cost is likely to be much higher, depending on extent of reconstruction of loop walks.Federal Guideline: 403.3Correct Excessive Gap at Bridge High $200Notes: Gap at bridge connection to accessible route is 1" (1/2" max.). Provide flush transition plans on both ends.Federal Guideline: 403.2, 302.3

04-6 Secret City WalkProvide Compliant Accessible Route High $20,000Notes: Running slope at main entry has running slopes of up to 6%. Entire inner circle has cross slopes of 2.6% (2% max.) and connector to asphalt path is over 7% cross slope. Turning spaces not all level as required. Tree branches overhang the accessible route in many locations and need to be trimmed.Federal Guideline: 307.2, 403.3

06-1 Stairs at Municipal Center Parking Lot

Provide Compliant Landings N/A N/ANotes: Top landing has slope of 3.1% (2% max.). Reconstruct landing.Federal Guideline: 304.2Provide Compliant Handrails N/A N/ANotes: Handrail top surface is mounted at 32" (34-38" req'd.) above nosing.Federal Guideline: 505.4

NOTES: Stairs at this location are not on an accessible route to any unique facilities in the park, information provided for information only.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost06-2 Stairs at Municipal Center Parking Lot Accessible Parking

Provide Compliant Landings Medium $4,000

Notes: Landings at all 3 stairs have slopes of 7-9% (2% max.). Provide compliant landings, including adjustments to the adjacent sidewalks as needed.

Federal Guideline: 304.2 Provide Compliant Handrails Medium $3,000Notes: No handrails provided at any of the 3 stairs, handrails required on all stairs.Federal Guideline: 505Park Amenities

07-1 Drinking Fountain at Creek Near Bridge Provide Compliant Standing User Drinking Fountain Medium $1,800Notes: Bubbler height of existing fountain is at 36" and compliant with requirements of wheelchair user. However, with upgrade of fountain recommended below at playground an additional standing user fountain with 38-43" high bubbler is required. This location is best option due to proximity to fitness trail. Cost assumes replacement of the existing fountain with model with compliant height bubbler for standing user.Federal Guideline: 602.4

07-2 Drinking Fountain at Playground Provide Compliant Height Bubbler Medium $3,000Notes: Existing 37" bubbler height is not compliant with either wheelchair users (36" max.) or standing user (38-43"). Given location at child play area, consideration should be given to providing both height bubblers for use by standing adults, wheelchair users, and children. Cost assumes new hi-low double fountain is provided that provides compliant approach and level clear spaces (see below).Federal Guideline: 602.4, 602.7Provide Compliant Level Clear Space Medium $500Notes: Provide new fountain at a compliant level clear space. Existing area at fountain is 3.2% (2% max.) and does not provide min. 48" deep area for frontal approach. Ensure new fountain provides all required level approaches and clear spaces.Federal Guideline: 305.2, 602.2

15-1 Men's RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $50Notes: Sign located with the bottom of the highest tactile character at 61-3/4" (60" max.). Lower the sign.Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703.4Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Medium TBDNotes: There is only 15" clear space parallel to the door (18" min. req'd. on pull side). Explore options to provide compliant clear space.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

NOTES: Stairs at this location provide a connection between the accessible parking for the park provided at the Municipal Center parking lot and the amphitheater area. That parking provides no compliant accessible route to the amphitheater but is closest to the overlook for wheelchair seating. Information about the stairs at this location should be considered to be corrected to accommodate non-wheelchair users at all 3 stairs.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 44" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located 51" above the floor (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Reposition Soap Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located 49" above the floor (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 48-1/2" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3Reposition Coat Hooks Low $50Notes: Coat hook not located in stall at 59" (48" max. req'd.). Lower the hook or provide additional hook at 48" max.Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308Modify Stall Hardware Low $250Notes: Handle not provided on inside of stall door (req'd. on both sides) and wheelchair stall door is not self-closing. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2, 309.4Reconfigure Wheelchair Stall Partitions High $600Notes: Toilet is in-line with stall door opening (required to be offset). Reconfigure stall entry door to be within 4" of partition wall opposite the toilet wall.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1.2Reposition Toilet Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 19" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.2Provide Compliant Clear Space Medium $765Notes: Only 42" clear space provide from toilet wall to sink within the stall (60" req'd.). Remove the sink from the stall to provide clear space.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Toilet paper dispenser located 9" behind front of toilet (7-9" in front req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Grab Bars Low $1,000Notes: Side grab bar extends only 51" from rear wall (54" min.). Rear grab bar only 24" long (36" min.). Space between grab bars and wall is 3" (1-1/2" req'd.). Provide new compliant grab bars installed in proper location.Federal Guideline: 604.5, 609.3Reposition Coat Hooks Low $50Notes: Coat hook in stall above 60" (48" max. req'd.). Lower the hook or provide additional hook at 48" max.Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost15-2 Women's Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $50Notes: Sign located with the bottom of the highest tactile character at 60-1/4" (60" max.). Lower the sign.Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703.4Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Medium TBDNotes: There is only 15" clear space parallel to the door (18" min. req'd. on pull side). Explore options to provide compliant clear space.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Reposition Sink Low $600Notes: The height of the sink rim is 34-1/4" (34" max.). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max.Federal Guideline: 606.3Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 46" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located 52" above the floor (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 50" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3Reposition Coat Hooks Low $50Notes: Coat hook not located in stall at 61" (48" max. req'd.). Lower the hook or provide additional hook at 48" max.Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308Modify Stall Hardware Low $250Notes: Handle not provided on inside of stall door (req'd. on both sides) and wheelchair stall door is not self-closing. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2, 309.4Reposition Toilet Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 19" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.2Provide Compliant Clear Space Medium $765Notes: Only 42" clear space provide from toilet wall to sink within the stall (60" req'd.). Remove the sink from the stall to provide clear space.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Toilet paper dispenser located 9" behind front of toilet (7-9" in front req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Grab Bars Low $1,000Notes: Side grab bar extends only 52" from rear wall (54" min.). Rear grab bar only 24" long (36" min.). Space between grab bars and wall is 3" (1-1/2" req'd.). Provide new compliant grab bars installed in proper location.Federal Guideline: 604.5, 609.3


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Coat Hooks Low $50Notes: Coat hook in stall above 60" (48" max. req'd.). Lower the hook or provide additional hook at 48" max.Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308

22-1 Site FurnitureProvide Accessible Route to Picnic Area Medium TBDNotes: Picnic shelter in southeast portion of park is not on a compliant accessible route. Improved paths have excessive slopes, access from the main park area requires use of stairs, and the is no compliant surface to the perimeter. Explore options, which may include construction of an alternate picnic location in an area that can be made accessible.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403Provide Level Area at Benches Medium $500Notes: All benches in the park are located within lawn areas, providing no compliant clear area for wheelchair. Provide level 30"x48" min. area at 1 bench at play area and 1 bench elsewhere in the park.Federal Guideline: 1011.2.1

25-1 Play Equipment AreasProvide Access at Ground Play Elements Low $4,000Notes: No accessible route provided to swings or end of 1 slide. Only portion of playground surface is compliant surface, other is wood mulch.Federal Guideline: 240

36-2 Picnic ShelterProvide Accessible Route to Picnic Area Medium TBDNotes: Picnic shelter in southeast portion of park is not on a compliant accessible route. Improved paths have excessive slopes, access from the main park area requires use of stairs, and the is no compliant surface to the perimeter. Explore options, which may include construction of an alternate picnic location in an area that can be made accessible.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403



Item # Description Priority Probable CostGeneral Notes: 1. Only paved accessible routes were assessed in detail. Many of the accessible routes on this facility has accessibility and connectivity issues to varying degrees. Park master planning should develop and publicize accessibility options for parking and compliant accessible routes to amphitheater and other amenities, including play area, amphitheater parking, historic bell, etc. Severe limitations on access to portions of the park from all parking locations at Badger Avenue, Civic Center, Library, and Municipal Center. Dedicated parking lot on Badger Avenue has severe slope issues with parking and access to rest of park. Access from Municipal Building parking lot is useful only for wheelchair seating for the amphitheater, with most other accessible routes being either extremely steep running and/or cross slope or requiring use of stairs. Areas under construction in center of the park were not assessed but should be assumed to comply and require connectivity to and from other amenities with compliant accessible route. Information about this park on the website and publications should indicate which parking facility disabled users should use to access the various amenities until all connections can be made compliant.2. Total of three (3) drinking fountains provided within the park. Per ADASAD 211, 50% must meet wheelchair requirements and 50% must meet standing user requirements, with any odd number meeting one of the requirements. Currently 2 meet wheelchair and 1 meets neither standard. Corrective actions noted to make all comply, including modifications to provide hi-lo fountain at playground and standing user fountain along fitness trail.




Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $1,200Notes: Existing accessible spaces and access aisles have slopes up to 3.3% (2.0% max.). Cost assumes existing parking is milled and leveled when parking lot is reconstructed. Federal Guideline: 302, 502.4

Interior08a-1 Main Front Entrance Door


09-1 Animal Shelter Hallway to KennelsProvide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: All permanent spaces require signage with visual and tactile letters and Braille outside entry door. Existing signage is entirely visual (no tactile or Braille) or missing entirely outside some spaces. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

16-1 Unisex RestroomRelocate Signage High $50Notes: Signage provided is on the door, which has no closer. Signs permitted only on doors with closer, relocate sign to wall adjacent to latch side of door.Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Medium $220Notes: Door has knobs that require tight grasping and twisting. Provide compliant hardware.Federal Guideline: 404.2.7Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 45" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3

NOTE: There are a total of 10 spaces, including 1 van-accessible. A total of 1 van accessible spaces required.

Animal Shelter

City of Oak RidgeAnimal Shelter 1 of 2

Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Soap Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located 54" above the floor (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3Reposition Toilet Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 24" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.2Provide Compliant Clear Space Medium $600Notes: Only 50" clear space provide from toilet wall to sink within the stall (60" req'd.). Remove the sink from the stall to provide clear space.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Toilet paper dispenser located on rear wall (7-9" in front req'd. on side wall).Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Grab Bars Medium $1,000Notes: There are no grab bars provided, required on the rear and side walls.Federal Guideline: 604.5

18-1 Animal Shelter Office ReceptionLower Fire Alarm Activation Device Low $400Notes: Device at 50" (over 48" max ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3


General Notes:

City of Oak RidgeAnimal Shelter 2 of 2



Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $1,800Notes: Restripe parking spaces and access aisle, which should be located at ramp to building and provide compliant signage, including 1 with a van-accessible tag. Area of accessible parking is required to be 2% max. slope, currently exceeds that. Cost assumes striping and signage provided with leveling of accessible parking area when lot is modified in the future. Federal Guideline: 208, 502

05-1 Front Entrance Exterior Ramp Correct Vertical and Horizontal Displacements High $150Notes: There is a 1" vertical displacement (1/4" max. or 1/2" beveled) and 2" gap (1/2" max.) at bottom of ramp interface with parking. Cost assumes transition plate can be installed to correct both issues as noted.Federal Guideline: 302.3, 303, 403.2, 405.4Consider Providing Clear Top Landing - ADVISORY N/A N/A

Notes: The entry door swings into the top landing of the ramp, it is desired to not have this situation if possible due to potential hazard for wheelchair user being contacted by door opening at they reach top of ramp. The pull side maneuvering space complies with 18" min. required but puts a wheelchair user attempting to open the door at the top of the ramp very close to the slope of the ramp.

Federal Guideline: 404.2.4, 405.7.5Provide Compliant Handrails Medium $800Notes: The handrails do not that the required 12" min. extensions at either the top or bottom. Provide these extensions as required.Federal Guideline: 505.10.1

Badger Building

NOTE: The striping of the parking lot to delineate parking spaces is very faint and no signage identifying accessible spaces. Based on measurements there is space for approximately 45 spaces. A total of 2 accessible spaces, including 1 van-accessible space, required.

City of Oak RidgeBadger Building 1 of 8

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost06 Exterior Stairs

Provide Compliant Lower Level Access (IF REQUIRED) Medium TBDNotes: Building is owned by public entity but leased to others. Vertical access is required unless a private building is 3 stories or less or has less than 3000 sf per floor (both met) but cannot be an office for a health provider or shopping center/mall. Vertical access for public building required unless one level has occupancy load of 5 or less AND there is no public use spaces in lower level. City should ensure compliance based on user.Federal Guideline: 206.2.3Provide Compliant Handrails Low N/ANotes: Consider providing handrails on both sides of existing stairs from parking lot to lower level west exterior access door to improve conditions.Federal Guideline: 505.2

Interior

Common Features11-1 Stairway

Provide Compliant Handrails N/A N/ANotes: Existing handrails are non-compliant size, not graspable, do not switchback on inside, and provide no extensions at either the top or bottom.Federal Guideline: 505.7, 505.10

Lower Level

08a Basement Exterior DoorProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

NOTE: Portions of this facility were under construction at the time of the evaluation, with review done to the extent possible under conditions at the time.

NOTE: Requirement for access to lower levels is not known but should be considered to permit tenants to access all levels. Basement level has no accessible route from either parking lot or mid-level east door.

NOTE: Vertical access to floors may be required. Information provided about existing interior stairs is for information only and should be considered but not required since this stair is not on an egress route for upper and middle levels. Egress from lower level available but has no exterior route to get away from building.

NOTE: This level is accessed only via interior stairway from middle level. Egress route is stairway or exterior door at the rear that has no accessible route from door to get away from the building. Existing route includes stone at door exit to access rear exterior stairway within lawn area.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost09-1 Basement Corridor

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $600

Notes: All permanent spaces require signage with visual and tactile letters and Braille outside entry door. Existing signage is entirely visual (no tactile or Braille) or missing entirely outside some spaces.

Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.), but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Switch clear space at bottom of stair is obstructed by the stair and handrail. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 305, 308

16-1 Unisex Restroom at Stair

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: Sign provided is visual text with "REST ROOM" and located on the door. Sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille req'd. Provide additional sign indicating the location of the accessible restroom on the upper level. Provide sign with all compliant features on the door (latch clear space is obstructed by shelving).Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703.4Provide Compliant Doorway Entry N/A N/ANotes: The width of the doorway is 22" (32" min.). Explore options to widen door in the future if vertical access is provided to wheelchairs.Federal Guideline: 404.2.3Adjust Door Closer N/A N/A

Notes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. required. Cost is for new closer.

Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Compliant Turning Area N/A N/ANotes: The wheelchair turning space has a diameter of 36" (60" min.).Federal Guideline: 606.2, 304.3, 306.3Provide Pipe Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: Water supply and waste pipes are required to be insulated to prevent contact. Provide insulation.Federal Guideline: 606.5

Notes: It is assumed that this restroom would not be made wheelchair accessible since this level is not accessible to persons in wheelchairs. Items provided for information only unless priority and cost provided. If compliant vertical access is provided to this level in the future, all items in one lower level restroom should be corrected with that alteration.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: Operable parts of paper towel dispenser at 57" (48" max.) from the floor.Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 53" (over 48" max. ht.), but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 305, 308Provide Compliant Wheelchair Stall N/A N/ANotes: Single-user restroom with stall provided. Stall entry width less than 32" min. (stall width is only 36" [60"min.]), stall depth only 48" (59" min. for floor-mounted toilet), door swings into stall (req'd. to be out-swinging), and no grab bars provided. Only means to provide compliant width would be to modify walls within the restroom. Assumed no alterations made and upper level restroom designated as accessible restroom.Federal Guideline: 404, 604

16-2 Unisex Restroom 2

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $300

Notes: Sign provided is visual text with "TOILET" and located on the door (sign noting out of order also taped to door). Sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille req'd. Provide additional sign indicating the location of the accessible restroom on the upper level. Provide sign with all compliant features on the door or latch side wall.

Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703.4Provide Compliant Doorway Entry N/A N/ANotes: The width of the doorway is 22" (32" min.). Explore options to widen door in the future if vertical access is provided to wheelchairs.Federal Guideline: 404.2.3

Notes: It is assumed that this restroom would not be made wheelchair accessible since this level is not accessible to persons in wheelchairs. Items provided for information only unless priority and cost provided. If compliant vertical access is provided to this level in the future, all items in one lower level restroom should be corrected with that alteration.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostAdjust Door Closer N/A N/A

Notes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. required. Cost is for new closer.

Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Compliant Turning Area N/A N/ANotes: The wheelchair turning space has a diameter of 36" (60" min.).Federal Guideline: 606.2, 304.3, 306.3Provide Pipe Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: Water supply and waste pipes are required to be insulated to prevent contact. Provide insulation.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: Operable parts of paper towel dispenser at 57" (48" max.) from the floor.Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 53" (over 48" max. ht.), but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 305, 308Provide Compliant Wheelchair Stall N/A N/ANotes: Single-user restroom with stall provided. Stall entry width less than 32" min. (stall width is only 36" [60"min.]), stall depth only 48" (59" min. for floor-mounted toilet), door swings into stall (req'd. to be out-swinging), and no grab bars provided. Only means to provide compliant width would be to modify walls within the restroom. Assumed no alterations made and upper level restroom designated as accessible restroom.Federal Guideline: 404, 604

35a-1 Basement Kitchen

Reposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below N/A N/ANotes: Sink rim at 36" high (34" max. req'd.) and provides no knee space below as required. Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Kitchen with cooktop/oven/range is required to have knee space below the sink. Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3, 804.6Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2

Notes: It is assumed that this kitchen is not required to provide wheelchair access since there is no vertical access to this level. Items noted are for information only unless priority and cost provided. If compliant vertical access is provided to this level in the future, all items would need to be corrected with that alteration.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost

Middle Level08a-2 East Exterior Door

Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

08a-3 West Exterior DoorProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

Upper Level08a-1 Front Entry Door

Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Medium $220Notes: Door has knobs that require tight grasping and twisting. Provide compliant hardware.Federal Guideline: 404.2.7

09 Upper Level CorridorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $600Notes: All permanent spaces require signage with visual and tactile letters and Braille outside entry door. Several walls currently unfinished and will require signage outside all permanent spaces. Cost assumes no compliant signs provided when walls were finished after the evaluation.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

16-3 Unisex Restroom Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No signage provided. Provide compliant sign on latch side wall that includes pictogram with ISA, visual and tactile text, and Braille. Door opens out so sign not permitted to be on the door.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 41" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: Operable parts of paper towel dispenser at 57" (48" max.) from the floor.Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 53" (over 48" max. ht.), but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 305, 308Lower Outlet Low $50Notes: Electrical outlets at 56" height (48" max.). Lowest cost option likely to provide power strip at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Provide Clear Width Adjacent to Toilet Medium $1,200NOTE: Sink is located 60" clearance req'd. from toilet wall to beyond toilet. Investigate options to provide compliant toilet room. Cost assumes sink is relocated and recessed into wall in adjacent space to provide all required clearances within room. Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Replace Toilet Tank Medium $200Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Provide water tank that has flush control on wide side of toilet. Federal Guideline: 604.6Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The coat hook on the back of the door is located at 66" (48" max.). Lower or provide additional hook at 48" max. height.Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted with centerline 2" in front of toilet (7-9" to centerline in front of toilet req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.7


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost35 Break Room

Reposition Sink N/A N/ANotes: Sink rim at 36" high (34" max. req'd.). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Federal Guideline: 212.3, 606.3


General Notes: 1. There is no vertical access within the building other than stairs. Building has 3 levels, upper main level, middle level with entry door accessed by exterior stairway, a small lobby at intermediate landing of interior stairway, and 1 office/room, and lower level accessed by lower flight of interior stairway that includes 2 unisex restrooms, small break room, and storage. Requirement for access from main level to lower levels is not known but should be considered to permit tenants to access all levels. Stairs from east exterior door provides access to second set of stairs leading to lower level access door in lawn area and has elevation change with no compliant surface outside of mid-level door. Accessibility to this facility is limited to the upper level via the exterior ramp from the parking lot to the entry door. Ensure that vertical access to lower levels is not required based on meeting one of the exceptions in 206.2.3, which would be based on the specifics of the tenant and use of spaces.2. Until vertical access for wheelchairs is provided to lower 2 levels, upper level should be made to fully comply and lower level spaces signed accordingly.

Notes: This area was under construction and assumed to be a break room of some type due to presence of sink. Regardless of use, if not a private office the sink must comply with requirements as applicable depending on whether cooking device provided in common use area.


Data collected September and

December 2018

General Site Features and Concessions Building AreaItem # Description Priority Probable Cost01a Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking - Grey Strang Park Medium $400Notes: Both parking spaces are less than 8' width (space available at over-width access aisles. Pavement markings are faded and access aisle marked with "NO PARKING" on pavement but is very faint. Restripe and repaint as needed to provide clear delineation of spaces, consider also providing angle markings in access aisles.Federal Guideline: 502Provide Compliant Accessible Parking - Lady Wildcats Field Medium $5,000Notes: Parking spaces have slopes that that exceed 2% max. allowed. Accessible route to field requires circulation by pedestrians behind parked vehicles and within general vehicle circulation area (not desired). Consider relocating to provide new spaces and extension of accessible route to field to directly connect to access aisle. Cost assumes existing spaces are leveled when parking lot is reconstructed, additional cost involved in relocating spaces not included.Federal Guideline: 502

Baseball Complex

NOTE: There is 1 large parking facility for all 5 fields, with an accessible route connecting the lot in the rear of the city Central Services facility. That parking facility is evaluated in the facility report for Central Services. The main lot provides a total of 195 spaces, including 11 accessible (4 of which are marked as van-accessible). A total of 6 accessible spaces are required, including 1 van accessible space. Note that each field should be treated as a "facility entrance", and pursuant to 208.3.1 should have parking dispersed to be located on the shortest accessible route to each field.

Grey Strang Park

Wildcats Baseball

field

Kevin Calia Park

Lady Wildcats

Fieldsouthfield

City of Oak RidgeBaseball Complex Page 1 of 12

Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Accessible Parking - Kevin Calia Park Medium $5,000Notes: Parking spaces have slopes that that exceed 2% max. allowed. Accessible route to field requires circulation by pedestrians behind parked vehicles and within general vehicle circulation area (not desired). Cost assumes existing spaces are leveled when parking lot is reconstructed.Federal Guideline: 502Provide Compliant Accessible Parking - Concession Building Medium $14,000Notes: Parking spaces have slopes that that exceed 2% max. allowed. Accessible route to fields and concessions requires circulation by pedestrians behind parked vehicles and within general vehicle circulation area (not desired). Cost assumes existing spaces are leveled when parking lot is reconstructed.Federal Guideline: 502

07-3 Restroom Drinking FountainProvide Compliant Drinking Fountain Medium $3,000Notes: Only 1 fountain provided (2 req'd. when 1 is provided) with bubbler height of 36" for wheelchair user. Provide new hi-lo drinking fountain that provides 38-43" high bubbler for standing user. Cost assumes new hi-lo compliant fountain provided at current location.Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7

08a-1 Concession Exterior Doors (3 doors)

Provide Means of Egress Signage (3 signs) High $300Notes: No signage provided. Signage with tactile letters and Braille required adjacent to exit doors. Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer at main entry door only, other door openers should be replaced later if adjustment is not effective.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

NOTE: This area is assumed to be staffed by volunteers considered as general public. Items noted with cost and priority should be considered for improvements as noted, other items should be improved when the concession area is renovated to improve accessibility.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost15-1 Men's Restroom

Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Reposition Sink Low $600Notes: Sink rim is 34-3/4" high (34" max. req'd.). Reposition min. of 1 sink such that rim does not exceed 34" max. and provides min. 27" high knee space below. Provide ISA symbol at lowered sink.Federal Guideline: 606.3Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: All sinks have exposed pipes and hot water supply. Provide insulation of all piping at min. 1 sink with 34" max. rim. Provide ISA symbol at lowered sink.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 47" high (40" max.). Lower min. 1 mirror to 40" high max. at sink with max. 34" high rim and knee space below with insulated piping below. Provide ISA symbol at compliant sink if not all are made to comply.Federal Guideline: 603.3Lower Electrical Switch Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Provide Electrical Outlet Access Low $50Notes: Electrical outlets are at 50" (48" max.). Correct when altered, lowest cost would be providing power strip mounted at compliant height. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Urinal and Provide Clear Space Medium $900Notes: The top of the lip on the accessible urinal is at 18" high (17" max.). Clear space provided is only 33" width (36" width required for 24" deep alcove). Explore options, which could include modifying existing urinals to provide accessible urinal on the right and lower it to compliant height (36" width provided). Cost assumes relocation of both urinals and lowering of accessible model to 17" max. height.Federal Guideline: 605.2Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $250Notes: No handle is provided on the inside of the wheelchair stall door, is required on both sides. Door not self-closing, replace spring hinge.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Reposition Toilet Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 20" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.2


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition/Provide Compliant Grab Bars Medium $1,000Notes: The rear grab bar extends only 16" on open side of toilet (24" min.). Existing grab bar system cannot be made compliant, provide new grab bars installed in proper location after toilet centerline is corrected). Federal Guideline: 604.5Relocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hook on inside of stall door located at 65" ht. (15"-48" req'd.). Lower or provide additional coat hook in stall at 48" high max.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4Provide Toe Clearance in Stall Low $2,500Notes: Toe clearance of 9" min. required on front and 1 side, existing has toe space only at door. Stall width does not provide exception (66" width req'd. for exception). Explore options, which will likely require removal of portion of block wall at floor when restroom is altered. Additional option would be to remove the block wall and replace with metal partition. Cost is placeholder and may vary.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1.4

15-2 Women’s RestroomAdjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: All sinks have exposed pipes and hot water supply. Provide insulation of all piping at min. 1 sink with 34" max. rim. Provide ISA symbol at compliant sink if not all are made to comply.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 47" high (40" max.). Lower min. 1 mirror to 40" high max. at sink with max. 34" high rim and knee space below with insulated piping below. Provide ISA symbol at compliant sink if not all are made to comply.Federal Guideline: 603.3


Item # Description Priority Probable CostLower Electrical Switch Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Provide Electrical Outlet Access Low $50Notes: Electrical outlets are at 50" (48" max.). Correct when altered, lowest cost would be providing power strip mounted at compliant height. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handle is provided on the inside of the wheelchair stall door, is required on both sides.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Reposition Toilet Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 20" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.2Replace Flush Controls Medium $400Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Reposition/Provide Compliant Grab Bars Medium $1,000Notes: The rear grab bar extends only 16" on open side of toilet (24" min.). Existing grab bar system cannot be made compliant, provide new grab bars installed in proper location after toilet centerline is corrected). Federal Guideline: 604.5Provide Toe Clearance in Stall Low $2,500Notes: Toe clearance of 9" min. required on front and 1 side, existing has toe space only at door. Stall width does not provide exception (66" width req'd. for exception). Explore options, which will likely require removal of portion of block wall at floor when restroom is altered. Additional option would be to remove the block wall and replace with metal partition. Cost is placeholder and may vary.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1.4

34 Concessions Service CounterProvide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $900Notes: Service counter is at 40” height (36" max. req'd. for verbal interaction). Provide min. 36" wide section of service counter at 36" max. height.Federal Guideline: 227.3, 904.5


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost35a-1 Concessions

Reposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim at 36" high (34" max. req'd.) and provides no knee space below as required. Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Kitchen with oven/range is required to have knee space below the sink.Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3Lower Electrical Switch Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Provide Electrical Outlet Access Low $50Notes: Electrical outlets are at 50" (48" max.). Correct when altered, lowest cost would be providing power strip mounted at compliant height. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Replace Range/Oven Medium $1,000Notes: Controls must be operable without reaching over burners. Purchase new range/oven that has all controls on front panel.Federal Guideline: 804.6.4, 804.6.5.3

Wildcats Baseball Field04 Accessible Route to Spectator Seating

Provide Compliant Accessible Route High $8,000Notes: There is no compliant surface accessible route from the parking lot to the spectator bleachers (gravel or grass). Provide compliant surfacing material to access seating. Also ensure connection to concessions is provided.Federal Guideline: 206, 403

07-1 Drinking Fountain 3rd BaselineProvide Complaint Access and Clear Space Medium included aboveNotes: The existing fountain is wheelchair height bubbler (36" max.) and provides knee space below but the clear space of 30"x48" is not provided and the fountain is not located on a compliant accessible route (on gravel and grass). Federal Guideline: 602.2, 305.2

07-4 Drinking Fountain 1st BaselineProvide Compliant Drinking Fountain Low $2,000Notes: Standing user fountain required for this site, existing fountain bubbler height is 37" (38-43" for standing user req'd.). Provide compliant height bubbler for fountain. Cost assumes new compliant fountain provided at current location.Federal Guideline: 211, 602.7

NOTE: This area is assumed to be staffed by volunteers considered as general public. Items noted with cost and priority should be considered for improvements as noted, other items should be improved when the concession area is renovated to improve accessibility.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Complaint Access and Clear Space Medium included aboveNotes: The existing fountain clear space of 30"x48" is not provided and the fountain is not located on a compliant accessible route (on gravel and grass). Federal Guideline: 602.2, 305.2

21 Bleachers

Provide Wheelchair Seating High $30,000

Notes: Both sets of bleachers along the baseline have steps to access seating, with no access for wheelchairs and no space available for wheelchair seating. Bleachers behind home plate provides no access other than bleachers themselves. Total of 15 wheelchair spaces with companion seat adjacent required, will require investigation into options to provide seating for wheelchairs and companions at all locations to provide options similar to that for non-wheelchair fans. Cost provided assumes a platform and ramp access provided at both base lines and behind home plate and actual cost likely to vary based on conditions and options implemented. Note bleachers on baselines also lack compliant stairs and handrails.

Federal Guideline: 221.1, 221.2.3.2, 802.124-1 Game and Sports Area

Accessible Route Medium $2,200

Notes: An accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity for player access or to player seating if accessed outside area of sport activity (field). Provide connection to accessible route described above providing access to spectator seating to each dugout area. Ensure existing elevation change at dugout access is addressed.

Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403Provide Wheelchair Space at Player Bench Low $1,200

Notes: Each player seating area is required to provide min. of 1 30"x48" wide wheelchair space in-line with player seating. Existing bench within dugouts is full length. Provide clear space in each dugout.

Federal Guideline: 221.2.1.4, 802.134 Ticket Window Service Counter

Provide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $900Notes: Service counter is at 43” height (36" max. req'd. for verbal interaction). Provide min. 36" wide section of service counter at 36" max. height.Federal Guideline: 227.3, 904.5

NOTE: Three sets of bleacher seating provided, with approximately 220 seating capacity each base line bleacher and 252 seating capacity for bleacher behind home plate, which requires 5 wheelchairs spaces adjacent to companion seat for each set of bleacher seating.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost34 Concessions Service Counter

Provide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $900Notes: Service counter is at 44” height (36" max. req'd. for verbal interaction). Provide min. 36" wide section of service counter at 36" max. height.Federal Guideline: 227.3, 904.5

Lady Wildcats Field04 Accessible Route to Spectator Seating

Provide Compliant Accessible Route High $10,000Notes: Sidewalk running slope is up to 10.5% (5% max.) and would be considered a ramp since running slopes exceed 5%. Cross slopes up to 2.5% also. Explore least costly option, which may include reconstructing entire walk from parking to provide consistent grade that does not exceed 5%. Cannot confirm ability to provide this without additional investigation and survey. Cost assumes entire walk replaced. If not feasible, alternate option is to provide relief possible and construct ramp with 8.33% max. running slope and handrails. Federal Guideline: 206, 403, 405, 505

07-2 Drinking FountainProvide Compliant Drinking Fountain Medium $3,000Notes: Only 1 fountain provided (2 req'd. when 1 is provided) with bubbler height of 38" for standing user. Provide new hi-lo drinking fountain that provides 36" max. bubbler height with 27" min. knee space for wheelchair user and 38-43" high bubbler for standing user. Cost assumes new hi-lo compliant fountain provided at current location.Federal Guideline: 211, 602.7

21 Bleachers

Provide Wheelchair Seating Medium $800Notes: No seats available for wheelchairs adjacent to seating. Provide 2, 30"x48" min. wheelchair spaces at each bleacher, 1 on each side adjacent to companion seat (4 total). Existing area adjacent to bleachers is grass. Cost assumes new pavement and routes that provide a level, 30"x48" wheelchair space on each side of each grandstand to provide min. 2 wheelchair spaces on each baseline. Federal Guideline: 221.1, 221.2.3.2, 802.1

24-3 Game and Sports AreaAccessible Route Medium $8,000


Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403

NOTE: Two sets of bleacher seating provided, with approximately 50 seating capacity each, which requires 2 wheelchairs spaces adjacent to companion seat for each.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Wheelchair Space at Player Bench Low $1,200Notes: Each player seating area is required to provide min. of 1 30"x48" wide wheelchair space in-line with player seating. Existing bench within dugouts is full length. Provide clear space in each dugout.Federal Guideline: 221.2.1.4, 802.1Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The hooks in the dugout located at over 70" (48" max.). Provide min. 1 hook at 48" high max.Federal Guideline: 603.4, 308

Grey Strang Field04 Accessible Route to Spectator Seating and New Drinking Fountain

Provide Compliant Accessible Route High $4,000Notes: There is no compliant surface accessible route from the parking lot to the spectator bleachers (gravel or grass). Provide compliant surfacing material to access seating.Federal Guideline: 206, 403, 405, 505

05-1 Ramp at Bleachers - Strang FieldProvide Compliant Bottom Landing Medium included aboveNotes: Existing landing has only 37" depth of compliant surface (60" min. req'd.), with grass beyond. Provide additional compliant surface to provide 60" min. depth level landing.Federal Guideline: 405.7Provide Handrail Extensions Medium $1,000Notes: Handrails do not extend beyond the end of the ramp at either the top or bottom (12" min. extensions on both sides at top and bottom parallel to the landing req'd.). Provide extensions.Federal Guideline: 505.10.1

06-1 Stairway for Bleachers

Provide Compliant Stairs N/A N/ANotes: Risers are open, which are not provided due to trip hazard potential. Provide vertical plate at each riser.Federal Guideline: 210, 504.2, 504.3Provide Compliant Bottom Landing N/A N/ANotes: Landing at bottom of stairs has slopes over 5% (2% max.).Federal Guideline: 304.2Provide Compliant Handrails N/A N/ANotes: Handrail top surface is at 39-1/2" (34-38" req'd.). Handrails do not have compliant extensions at top (12" min. req'd.).Federal Guideline: 505.10.3

NOTE: Stairs are not part of an accessible route, ramp is present. Information provided for information only and should be considered for correction if bleachers are altered.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost07-4 Drinking Fountains (2)

Provide Compliant Drinking Fountain Medium $4,000Notes: Two drinking fountains present at this site with 1 along each baseline. Existing fountains bubbler height is 37"-37-1/2" and is post-mounted style with no knee space below, which meets neither requirement for 36" max. bubbler with knee space below for wheelchair user and 38-43" high bubbler for standing user. Cost assumes new compliant fountain provided at new location near bleachers behind home plate.Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7Provide Complaint Access and Clear Space Medium included aboveNotes: The existing fountain clear space of 30"x48" is not provided and the fountain is not located on a compliant accessible route (on gravel and grass). Federal Guideline: 602.2, 305.2

21 Bleachers - Strang Field

Provide Companion Seating Medium $1,000

Notes: Only 2 seats available for wheelchair companions adjacent to wheelchair seating. Provide 2 additional bench seats to provide min. 3 additional companion spaces adjacent to min. 36" wide wheelchair space.

Federal Guideline: 221.3, 80224-4 Game and Sports Area

Accessible Route Medium $9,000



Kevin Calia Park04 Accessible Route to Spectator Seating

Provide Compliant Accessible Route High $4,200Notes: There is no compliant surface accessible route from the existing sidewalk to the spectator bleachers on the 1st base line (gravel or grass). Provide compliant surfacing material to access seating. Also correct panel with trench drain with excessive slope.Federal Guideline: 206, 403, 405, 505

NOTE: Approximately 187 seating capacity, which requires 5 wheelchairs spaces with companion seat for each. Adequate space available for wheelchair spaces required but only 2 companion seats provided on short bench on bottom level.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost21 Bleachers

Provide Wheelchair Seating Medium $800Notes: No seats available for wheelchairs adjacent to seating. Provide 2, 30"x48" min. wheelchair spaces at each bleacher, 1 on each side adjacent to companion seat (4 total).Federal Guideline: 221.1, 221.2.3.2, 802.1

24-1 Game and Sports AreaAccessible Route Medium $2,200


Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403Provide Wheelchair Space at Player Bench Low $1,200Notes: Each player seating area is required to provide min. of 1 36"x48" wide wheelchair space in-line with player seating. Existing bench within dugouts is full length. Provide clear space in each dugout.Federal Guideline: 221.2.1.4, 802.1

South Ballfield04 Accessible Route to Spectator Seating

Provide Compliant Accessible Route High $15,000Notes: Accessible route from parking at concessions to south field is non-compliant gravel surface. Provide compliant surface accessible route to spectator seating and player entrances to dugouts/area of sport activity border. Cost assumes new firm, stable surface provided from parking.Federal Guideline: 206, 403, 405, 505

07-5 Drinking FountainProvide Compliant Drinking Fountain Medium $3,000Notes: Only 1 fountain provided (2 req'd. when 1 is provided) with bubbler height of 32" for wheelchair user but is post-mounted style with no knee space. Provide new hi-lo drinking fountain that provides 36" max. bubbler height with 27" min. knee space below and 38-43" high bubbler for standing user. Cost assumes new hi-lo compliant fountain provided at current location.Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7Provide Complaint Access and Clear Space Medium included aboveNotes: The existing fountain clear space of 30"x48" is not provided and the fountain is not located on a compliant accessible route (on gravel and grass). Federal Guideline: 602.2, 305.2



Item # Description Priority Probable Cost21 Bleachers

Provide Wheelchair Seating Medium $800Notes: No seats available for wheelchairs adjacent to seating. Provide 2, 30"x48" min. wheelchair spaces at each bleacher, 1 on each side adjacent to companion seat (4 total).Federal Guideline: 221.1, 221.2.3.2, 802.1

24-5 Game and Sports AreaAccessible Route High $1,600


Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403Provide Wheelchair Space at Player Bench Low $1,200Notes: Each player seating area is required to provide min. of 1 30"x48" wide wheelchair space in-line with player seating. Existing bench within dugouts is full length. Provide clear space in each dugout.Federal Guideline: 221.2.1.4, 802.1

Facility Total: $160,250General Notes: 1. Standards require that if 1 drinking fountain is provided that 2 must be available, 1 each that meets requirements for a wheelchair and standing user. Each field should be interpreted as a site as defined in the standards.2. Firm surface accessible routes required to connect from accessible parking to all site features, including spectator seating, drinking fountains (if present), ticketing area, concessions, and player seating and/or field access (if separate). Accessible routes may not exceed 5% running slope or 2% cross slope. Running slopes over 5% that cannot be corrected require installation of compliant ramp with handrails. None of the fields comply entirely and providing required paved surfaces is a large cost. Explore least costly options to provide compliant access, including non-paved surfaces that are firm and stable such as compacted, crushed limestone or other. 3. Each area of spectator seating that provides a different view (i.e., each baseline and home plate) for spectators must also be provided wheelchair seating. Each wheelchair seat must provide a minimum 30"x48" wheelchair space with an adjacent seat for companion of person in wheelchair to sit shoulder-to-shoulder. Only 1 field provides wheelchair seating but not enough spaces provided. Wheelchair and companion seating only required at lowest level of bleachers. Ensure ability to view entire field similar to views provided other spectators.4. Users of main concessions assumed to not be city employees so area is not technically a "work area". Modifications noted should be considered to allow wheelchair-bound and other disabled volunteers and workers in the concessions to participate.



Data collected September 2018

East Park AreaItem # Description Priority Probable Cost01a-1 Parking Lot

Provide Compliant Access Aisles Medium $1,000

Notes: None of the 4 existing spaces have an access aisle of min. width, 2 spaces in center of lot have none. Consider minor reconfiguration if desired to maintain current accessible parking count by moving all accessible spaces to the southwest corner of the lot and providing 2 shared access aisles with the 4 accessible spaces. This also provides closest access to the accessible route for all spaces which is currently not met as required. Cost assumes 4 spaces provided as noted, with relocation of 1 sign, installation of 2 new signs for spaces currently lacking signage, and pavement marking of new spaces and access aisles.Federal Guideline: 208, 502

04-3 Shelter and Restroom Area Accessible RoutesProvide Compliant Accessible Routes Medium $1,200Notes: Running slope of sidewalk between the restroom building and shelter is at 5.5% (5% max.). Federal Guideline: 403.3

07-1 Picnic Shelter Drinking Fountain

Provide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $2,000Notes: Existing bubbler height of 35-1/2" is compliant with wheelchair users (36" max.). Provide additional fountain for standing user with 38-43" high bubbler. Cost assumes new tall fountain is provided that provides compliant approach and level clear spaces.Federal Guideline: 602.4, 602.7

Big Turtle Park & Katie Hunter

Soccer Field

Note: 40 total parking spaces provided, including 4 marked as accessible, including 1 van-accessible. 2 accessible spaces required, including 1 van-accessible.

NOTE: The park has drinking fountains in the park area to the east, at the soccer field, and 2 in the dog park. Since there is no connection to the area to the east from the west parking, these areas are considered "separate facilities" and should each provide a wheelchair and standing person fountain.

City of Oak RidgeBig Turtle Park-Katie Hunter 1 of 7


15 Men's RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Low $200Notes: Existing signage is visual only and located on the door that opens out. Provide an additional sign with tactile letters and Braille that is located on the latch side wall at compliant height. Ensure new sign does not include the ISA since these restrooms are not accessible.Federal Guideline: 216, 703Provide Clear Space on Pull Side of Door Medium $400Notes: There is only 12" clear space parallel to the door (18" min. req'd. on pull side). While wheelchair users would not be expected to use this restroom, the clear space on the latch side is required to provide visually impaired person ability to read the sign outside of door swing. Provide additional firm surface adjacent to existing walk.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10, 407.4.3, 703.4

15 Women's RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Low $200Notes: Existing signage is visual only and located on the door that opens out. Provide an additional sign with tactile letters and Braille that is located on the latch side wall at compliant height. Ensure new sign does not include the ISA since these restrooms are not accessible.Federal Guideline: 216, 703Provide Clear Space on Pull Side of Door Medium $400Notes: There is only 12" clear space parallel to the door (18" min. req'd. on pull side). While wheelchair users would not be expected to use this restroom, the clear space on the latch side is required to provide visually impaired person ability to read the sign outside of door swing. Provide additional firm surface adjacent to existing walk.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10, 407.4.3, 703.4

16-1 Restroom Building Unisex Provide Pipe Insulation Below Sink Medium $100Notes: Water supply and waste pipes are required to be insulated to prevent contact. Provide insulation.Federal Guideline: 606.5Lower Electrical Switch Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 308.2.1

NOTE: The restroom building on the east provides a unisex restroom and a pair of Men's/Women's with multiple fixtures. The unisex restroom was being used as storage at the time of the evaluation and should be made usable by relocating stored items elsewhere. The multi-user set of restrooms are not at all accessible without significant alterations, only items that need to be modified are included for those restrooms. A portable toilet is also present at the parking lot that was not evaluated.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostLower Electrical Outlet Low $50

Notes: Electrical switch at 50" (over 48" max ht.). Correct when altered.

Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Provide Compliant Clear Space High $800Notes: Sink located at 38" from toilet wall (60" req'd.). Relocate the sink to provide clear space.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Replace Toilet Tank Medium $200Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Provide water tank that has flush control on wide side of toilet. Federal Guideline: 604.6Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted 0" front of toilet (7"-9" in front to centerline req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.7Reposition and Provide New Compliant Grab Bars Low $750Notes: The side grab bar is located 13" from the rear wall (12" max.). Rear grab bar is only 24" long (36" min. req'd.). Reposition side bar and provide new rear bar installed in compliant location.Federal Guideline: 604.5

21-1 Ball Field GrandstandsProvide Wheelchair Seating Low $200Notes: Seating capacity of bleachers is 136, which requires 4 wheelchair spaces be provided with adjacent companion seat. Only 1 seat provided with space in front of bleachers available if portable seats provided. Consider providing signage low on the fence designating that area for wheelchairs and companion seating only.Federal Guideline: 221.1, 221.2.3.2

24-1 Small Soccer FieldProvide Accessible Route to Area of Sport Activity Medium $8,000Notes: An accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity, none is provided. Provide compliant firm, stable surface connection from parking to soccer field.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403

24-2 Ball Field Provide Accessible Route to Area of Sport Activity Medium $800

Notes: An accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity, none is provided. Provide compliant firm, stable surface connection from parking to soccer field. Provide compliant surface connection from existing sidewalk along 3rd baseline to the dugout. Access to 1st baseline dugout has steep slopes, access should be assumed to be from 3rd baseline dugout across the field.



Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Wheelchair Space in Dugouts Low N/A

Notes: At least 1 36"x48" wheelchair space is required at the end of each bench in each dugout. Adjust benches to ensure space is provided.

Federal Guideline: 221.2.1.4, 802.1

West Park Area01a-2 Parking Lot

Provide Compliant Slopes and Relocate/Add Parking Medium $4,300Notes: Slopes of parking stalls and access aisle in existing parking area adjacent to play structure has slopes over 4% (2% max.). Mill and resurface the accessible spaces and access aisle in this location when the parking lot is reconstructed to provide 2% max. slopes. No accessible spaces provided near Dog Park. Consider adding at least 1 accessible space in that area, with compliant access aisle and signage. Cost assumes milling of existing area and addition of signage and pavement markings at Dog Park.Federal Guideline: 208.3.1, 302, 502Provide Compliant Slopes Medium $4,000Notes: Slopes of parking stalls and access aisle in area adjacent to Katie Hunter Soccer Field have slopes up to 3.3% (2% max.). Spaces recently relocated to this location with new curb ramp but no pavement work done. Mill and resurface the accessible spaces and access aisle in this location when the parking lot is reconstructed to provide 2% max. slopes. One of existing spaces have a drainage structure at the curb but it has no impact on access.Federal Guideline: 302, 502

02-1 Dog Park Curb RampProvide Compliant Curb Ramp Low $1,800Notes: Existing curb ramp has variable running slopes up to 14% (8.33% max.) and cross slope up to 3% (2% max.). Side flares far exceed 10% max. allowed. Bottom landing cross slope 3% (2% max.). Reconstruct compliant curb ramp, including compliant landings. Low priority only until accessible parking described above is provided.Federal Guideline: 405.2, 405.3, 406.2, 406.3

02-2 Curb Ramp near Play StructureProvide Compliant Curb Ramp Medium $2,000Notes: Curb ramp has cross slope of 5% (2% max.). Slope issue at adjacent accessible route to play structure to address as noted below. Cost provided corrects landing issue. Note that curb ramp has detectable warning that is not desired or required, remove and do not replace when ramp is reconstructed. Best option may be parallel ramp.Federal Guideline: 405.5



Item # Description Priority Probable Cost02-3 Curb Ramp at Katie Hunter Soccer Field

Provide Compliant Curb Ramp High $2,000Notes: New curb ramp has vertical elevation change from parking lot of 1" (1/2" max. beveled) and no landing/turning space as required. This non-level (2% or less slope) landing area presents issues on the accessible route to the restroom also as described below. Note that ramp also have detectable warning that is not desired or required, remove and do not replace when ramp is reconstructed. Cost is for reconstruction of ramp to provide parallel ramp in existing location.Federal Guideline: 303.2, 303.3, 405.4, 406.4

04-1 Play Equipment Area Accessible RoutesProvide Compliant Accessible Routes Medium $3,000Notes: The turning space on the route from accessible parking to the benches (to the right) and at the end to the play structure (to the left) both exceed 5.7% (2% max.). Sidewalk at curb ramp will need to be modified with new curb ramp, assume 2 panels in each direction. Federal Guideline: 403.3, 403.5

04-2 Soccer Area Accessible RoutesProvide Compliant Accessible Routes Medium $1,200Notes: Running slope of sidewalk at the soccer field have excessive running slopes 5.4-over 10% (5% max.). The cross slope near the portapotty is 3.1% (2% max.). Turning space at curb ramp is not level.Federal Guideline: 403.3

07-2 Soccer Field Drinking FountainNOTE: The park has drinking fountains in the park area to the east, at the soccer field, and 2 in the dog park. Since there is no connection to the area to the east from the west parking, these areas are considered "separate facilities" and should each provide a wheelchair and standing person fountain. It is suggested below that the soccer fountain be considered separately from those at the dog park and also provide a hi-lo fountain.Provide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $2,000Notes: Existing bubbler height of 36" is compliant with wheelchair users (36" max.). Provide additional fountain for standing user with 38-43" high bubbler. Cost assumes new tall fountain is provided that provides compliant approach and level clear spaces.Federal Guideline: 602.4, 602.7

07-3 Dog Park Drinking Fountains (2)Provide Compliant Clear Spaces Low $800Notes: There is no level clear space of 30"x48" at lowest fountain for dogs for wheelchair user. Concrete pad ends under the bowl and a compliant surface is needed on the operator side of each fountain. Cost assumes a firm pad of some type similar to that used at playgrounds can be placed on ground surface to provide level transition to concrete and required clear space at each fountain.Federal Guideline: 305.2, 602.2


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost16-2 Portable Toilets (2) at Soccer Field and Dog Park

Provide Compliant Signage High $400Notes: No signs provided. Provide compliant sign with tactile letters, Braille and pictogram on the latch side wall at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703Provide Compliant Wheelchair Facilities Medium N/ANotes: Height of clear door opening is 75" (80" min. req'd.). No 60" turning space within for wheelchair. Hand sanitizer at 52" height (48" max.). Width of space within only 58" (60" min.). Toilet paper dispenser at 0" in front of toilet (7-9" req'd.) and is located within the required 12" clear space above the side grab bar. Side grab bar extends only 50" from rear wall (54" min.). Rear grab bar has only 10" length on wall side of toilet centerline (12" min.). Work with owner to provide compliant facilities. Federal Guideline: 304.3, 306.3, 308, 404.2.3, 604.3, 604.5, 604.7, 606.2, 609.3Provide Compliant Level Clear Space Medium included aboveNotes: The clear space outside the entry door is 3.1% cross slope (2% max.).Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1

21-2 Soccer Field GrandstandsProvide Wheelchair Seating Low $200Notes: Seating capacity of bleachers is 40, which requires 2 wheelchair spaces be provided with adjacent companion seat. Only 1 seat provided with space to side of bleachers available if portable seats provided. If bleachers were moved to center of concrete is would provide 1 additional wheelchair space on the opposite side. Cost assumes bleachers are moved to provide 36" wide clear space at each end of bleachers.Federal Guideline: 221.1, 221.2.3.2, 802.1

22-1 Site FurnitureProvide Accessible Route and Clear Space to Benches Low $800Notes: There are numerous benches at the small dog park (4), all dogs (9), nature trail entry (1), and playground (2), none of which are located on an accessible route and/or lack clear space for wheelchair adjacent that is outside accessible route. Explore options to provide compliant surface to access and sit with companions at benches in all locations. Least costly option likely to relocate benches and provide additional level, firm surface adjacent.Federal Guideline: 206, 403, 1011.2.1Provide Trash Containers on Accessible Route Low $200Notes: There are numerous trash receptacles at the small dog park (1), all dogs (3), soccer (3), and playground (2), none of which are located on an accessible route. Relocate trash containers or provide additional to have min. of 1 at each location.Federal Guideline: 1011.2.1


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost24-2 Katie Hunter Soccer Field

Provide Compliant Accessible Routes Low TBD

Notes: Where multiple sports fields or courts are provided, an accessible route is required to each field or area of sport activity. If large field area is divided into smaller youth fields there is no route for spectators.

Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 40324-4 Dog Park

Provide Compliant Accessible Routes Low $1,200Notes: The dog parks provide no interior accessible routes for wheelchair. Provide area within each dog area for wheelchair user to traverse while controlling their dog and allow them the ability to reach waste for pick-up. Assumed 20'x5' area in each.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403

25-1 Play Equipment Area Provide Compliant Access to Play Elements High $3,500Notes: Accessible route provided only to play structure, none to the swings or at some ground play elements on structure. Existing surface is wood fiber, which requires extensive maintenance to be compliant. Provide accessible surface to swings and from end of slides.Federal Guideline: 240.2.1, 240.2.1.1Provide Compliant Ramp and Handrail High $2,500Notes: Run of one ramp is 9.1% (8.33% max.) and handrail surface at 31-39" height (20-28" req'd.). Explore options to provide compliant slope ramp.Federal Guideline: 1008.2.5


General Notes: 1. Big Turtle Park provides 2 distinct areas which have no interior improved connection. The East Park area of Monterrey Road includes a parking lot, softball field, restroom building, picnic pavilion, and small soccer field. The West Park area off Oak Ridge Turnpike provides convenient access to Katie Hunter Soccer Field, playground, and dog park. Each is considered separately.2. Note that the existing portable toilets are not accessible. Since they are not a "permanent" fixture they are not required to be accessible but consider providing a portable toilet that is wheelchair accessible at all locations that portable toilets are provided unless accessible restrooms are provided.



Item # Description Priority Probable Cost01a-1 Parking

Provide Pavement Markings Medium $300Notes: Pavement markings for spaces and access aisles is very faint and nearly not visible. Update striping. Federal Guideline: 502.3

04-1 Accessible RoutesProvide Compliant Accessible Route Low $600

Notes: Running slope of section of sidewalk at curve is 7% (5% max.).

Federal Guideline: 403.307-1 Drinking Fountain

Provide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $2,000Notes: Only 1 fountain provided, 2 min. required if 1 is provided. Existing bubbler height of 36" is compliant with wheelchair users (36" max.). Provide additional fountain for standing user with 38-43" high bubbler. Cost assumes new tall fountain is provided that provides compliant approach and level clear spaces.Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7

22-1 Site FurnitureProvide Wheelchair Accessible Picnic Table Low $800Notes: Existing picnic tables are all located in lawn areas and only provide 26-1/2" knee space below (27" min.). Provide min. 1 wheelchair compliant picnic table on an accessible route and compliant surface.Federal Guideline: 1011.2, 1011.4.2Provide Accessible Route and Clear Space to Benches Low $400Notes: There are 4 benches, all in lawn area. Provide min. of 1 bench on an accessible route with clear space for a wheelchair adjacent entirely outside of accessible route. Least costly option likely to relocate bench and provide additional level, firm surface adjacent.Federal Guideline: 206, 403, 1011.2.1

Briarcliff Park


City of Oak RidgeBriarcliff Park Page 1 of 2

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost24-1 Area of Sport Activity

Accessible Routes Low TBDNotes: Provide a compliant accessible route to the boundary of each area of sport activity (soccer and volleyball). Explore best options to provide compliant surface within existing lawn area.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403

25-1 Play Equipment Area Provide Compliant Access to Play Elements High $3,500Notes: Accessible route provided only to elevated play structure, none to the swings or ground play elements on structure. Existing surface is wood fiber, which requires extensive maintenance to be compliant. Provide accessible surface to swings and from end of slides.Federal Guideline: 240.2.1, 240.2.1.1


General Notes:

City of Oak RidgeBriarcliff Park Page 2 of 2


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost01a-1 Parking Lot

Provide Pavement Markings Medium $600Notes: Pavement markings for spaces and access aisles are very faint and nearly not visible. Update striping. Federal Guideline: 502.3Provide Compliant Accessible Routes Medium $2,000Notes: The access aisles connect to the park entrance gate at gravel driveway. Provide a compliant surface.Federal Guideline: 206.2.1, 403.5, 502.3Provide Compliant Parking Spaces Medium $6,000Notes: Running slope of accessible parking spaces and access aisles are up to 3% (2% max.). Access aisle closest to gate entrance is not required width but space available. Restripe aisle per above and level accessible parking area when parking lot is reconstructed.Federal Guideline: 206.2.1, 403.5, 502.3

04-2 Lot to Shelter Accessible RoutesProvide Compliant Accessible Routes Medium $6,000Notes: Cross-slope of the walk between the parking lot and the picnic shelter is up to 3.5% (2% max.). Federal Guideline: 403.3

07-1 Drinking Fountain at Ball FieldProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $2,000Notes: Only 1 fountain provided, 2 min. required if 1 is provided. Existing bubbler height of 36" is compliant with wheelchair users (36" max.) but knee space below is only 26-1/2" (27" min.). Provide additional fountain for standing user with 38-43" high bubbler. Investigate options to raise knee space without raising bubbler. Cost assumes new tall fountain is provided that provides compliant approach and level clear spaces.Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7

NOTE: 83 total parking spaces provided including 4 marked as accessible, including 1 van-accessible. 4 accessible spaces required, including 1 van-accessible.

Carl Yearwood

Park

City of Oak RidgeCarl Yearwood Park 1 of 4

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost15-1 Men's Restrooms

Provide Compliant Signage High $200Notes: Sign on concrete block building includes the ISA. These restrooms are not accessible, provide new sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille but without the ISA.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Medium $2,500Notes: The pull side clearance adjacent to the latch is 4-1/2" (18" req'd.). due to ramp. Explore options to provide space. Cost assumes compliant ramps provided along front portion of building for both restrooms.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 41" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Lower Electrical Outlet Low $50Notes: Electrical outlet at 58" (over 48" max ht.). Lowest cost option is to provide power strip at 48" max. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Reposition Toilet Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 18-1/2" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.2Provide Toilet Clear Space Low $600Notes: Urinal located at 57" from toilet wall (60" min. req'd.). Relocate or remove urinal to provide clear space. Cost assumes relocation.Federal Guideline: 604.3Reposition Grab Bars Low $250Notes: Side grab bar is located 12-1/2" (12" max.) from the rear wall.Federal Guideline: 604.7

15-2 Women’s Restrooms Provide Compliant Signage High $250Notes: Sign on concrete block building includes the ISA. These restrooms are not accessible, provide new sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille but without the ISA. Sign at accessible restrooms is located on the hinge side of the door, relocate to latch side.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

Note: Two separate restroom buildings are present at the ball field. One building includes restrooms considered to be single-user and should be made fully compliant (light tan colored wood building). Other building (dark brown concrete block) provides for multiple users and are not wheelchair accessible.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Medium included aboveNotes: The pull side clearance adjacent to the latch is 4-1/2" (18" req'd.). due to ramp. Explore options to provide space. Cost assumes compliant ramps provided along front portion of building for both restrooms.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 41" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Provide Toilet Clear Space Low $600Notes: Sink located at 42" from toilet wall (60" min. req'd.). Relocate sink to provide clear space. Cost assumes relocation, explore options.Federal Guideline: 604.3Reposition Grab Bars Low $250Notes: Side grab bar is located 13" (12" max.) from the rear wall.Federal Guideline: 604.7

21-1 Ball Field GrandstandsProvide Wheelchair Seating Low $800Notes: Two sets of grandstands provided. Seating capacity of bleachers is 335, which requires 6 wheelchair spaces be provided with adjacent companion seat. Room exists at inner end of both sets, providing only 2 seats with adjacent companion area. Concrete area immediately behind home plate provides additional space for wheelchair if companion brings own seat. Ensure space is avaiable for companion seating by providing signage low on fence to provide priority seating for persons in wheelchairs and their companion.Federal Guideline: 221.1, 221.2.3.2

24-1 Ball Field AccessProvide Accessible Route to Area of Sport Activity Medium $2,400Notes: An accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity, none is provided. Provide compliant firm, stable surface connection from existing sidewalk behind home plate to dugouts. Ensure turning space provided at dugouts that matches elevation of dugout for home team (existing transition has elevation difference) and at gate entrance to field on visitor's side.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403Provide Wheelchair Space in Dugouts Low N/ANotes: At least 1 36"x48" wheelchair space is required at the end of each bench in each dugout. Adjust benches to ensure space is provided.Federal Guideline: 221.2.1.4, 802.1


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost24-2 Sport Court Access

Provide Accessible Route to Area of Sport Activity Medium $4,500Notes: An accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity, none is provided. Provide compliant firm, stable surface connection from existing sidewalk at skate park to sport court beyond. Modify existing curb at entryway to eliminate 7" elevation change at entrance.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403

24-3 Skate Park AccessProvide Accessible Route to Area of Sport Activity - ADVISORY N/A N/A

Notes: No connection to sidewalk from parking is provided other than within vehicle drive. Consider connection outside of vehicle route for safety.

Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403Provide Compliant Accessible Routes Medium $3,000Notes: The existing accessible route near the skate park has a running slope of 5.9% (5.0% max.) and typical cross slope of 2.5-4.1% (2% max.). Reconstruct non-compliant sections and ensure elevation change at entrance to park is removed.Federal Guideline: 403.3


General Notes:




Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $3,000Notes: Accessible parking spaces not located nearest the marked accessible route into the park. Directional sign at the top of the curb ramp at existing parking location directs persons to the south. Relocate accessible parking to be closest to accessible entrance to the park, which will likely require modifications to existing curb ramp and parking spaces at that location to provide compliant dimensions and slopes. Cost assumes restriping to move shared access aisle slightly to the north with accessible spaces on each side, relocation of signage, removing accessible markings at current location, etc.Federal Guideline: 208.3.1, 502.3

02-1 Curb RampsProvide Compliant Curb Ramp N/A N/ANotes: Curb ramp at existing accessible parking has running slope over 8.6% (8.33% max.) and landings are 2.5% slope (2% max.) with severe spalling of concrete. Corrections required only if accessible parking remains in this location, assumed it is relocated.Federal Guideline: 405.2

04-1 Accessible Route - NW side from Basketball to ROW on NE sideProvide Compliant Accessible Routes Low $2,500Notes: Portions of the accessible route have cross slopes that exceed 2%. Areas are overgrown with turf within cracks and joints. Remove overgrowth.Federal Guideline: 303, 403.3, 403.4Provide Compliant Access From ROW Sidewalk Medium $400Notes: Access gate from ROW sidewalk has switchback that precludes wheelchair access. Provide min. 32" clear width access.Federal Guideline: 403.4, 303

Cedar Hill Park

City of Oak RidgeCedar Hill Park Page 1 of 3

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost04-2 Accessible Route - Picnic Shelter to Play Area

Provide Compliant Accessible Routes Low $400Notes: Some areas have turf growth in joints that presents elevation change. Perform maintenance to remove turf.Federal Guideline: 403.4, 303

04-3 Accessible Route - SW side from Milton Ln to Basketball CourtProvide Compliant Accessible Routes Low $400Notes: Portions of the accessible route have running slopes of 7-8% (5% max.). Trees have heaved areas to provide displacements. Recommend that signage be placed at each end alerting users to steep slopes until compliant connections can be made. Cost assumes 1 sign placed at each end of segment.Federal Guideline: 303, 403.3, 403.4

04-4 Accessible Route - Parking Area to Shelter and Drinking FountainProvide Compliant Accessible Routes Low $3,000Notes: Portions of the accessible route have running slopes up to 9.8% (5% max.), particularly accessing the fountain and many areas have uneven asphalt in excess of 1/4" or 1/2" beveled. Turning spaces are both over 3% slope (2% max.).Federal Guideline: 303, 403.3, 403.4

07-1 Drinking Fountain near BasketballProvide Complaint Fountain Low $3,500Notes: Drinking fountain is post-mounted for standing person but bubbler height only 37" (38-43" req'd.). Provide new fountain with compliant height for bubbler that is located on an accessible route (existing fountain within turf area). Cost assumes new compliant standing user fountain provided and relocated.Federal Guideline: 602.2

22-1 Site FurnitureProvide Compliant Picnic Area Low $100Notes: Provide 36" clear space at ends of picnic tables in shelter for wheelchair access. Explore options to provide clear space, which may require rearranging tables and/or moving 1 or more.Federal Guideline: 903.2, 1011.2.1Provide Accessible Route and Clear Space to Benches Low $200Notes: All benches are in lawn area. Provide min. of 1 bench on an accessible route with clear space for a wheelchair adjacent entirely outside of accessible route. Least costly option likely to relocate bench and provide additional level, firm surface adjacent.Federal Guideline: 206, 403, 1011.2.1


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Trash Containers on Accessible Route Low $200Notes: There are numerous trash receptacles, none of which are located on an accessible route. Relocate trash containers or provide additional to have min. of 1 at each amenity.Federal Guideline: 1011.2.1

24-1 Basketball CourtProvide Accessible Route to Area of Sport Activity Medium $800

Notes: An accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity, none is provided. Provide compliant firm, stable surface connection from existing sidewalk to edge of basketball court.



General Notes: 1. Note that the existing portable toilets are not accessible. Since they are not a "permanent" fixture they are not required to be accessible but consider providing a portable toilet that is wheelchair accessible at all locations that portable toilets are provided unless accessible restrooms are provided.



Exterior Item # Description Priority Probable Cost01a Parking

01a-1 Front Public Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking High $500Notes: The curb ramp access to the accessible route is located within the access aisle and the ramp flares encroach into the accessible parking spaces, all of which are required to not exceed 2%. All spaces and the access aisle are oversized, least costly option is to relocate 1 space and access aisle entirely to one side and ensure that the existing ramp and flare is not within the new space. The accessible spaces should be 8' wide and share an 8' wide access aisle. Cost assumes restriping of accessible spaces, converting 1 accessible space to non-accessible, striping of new access aisle, and moving 1 sign. Striping of new access aisle included above.Federal Guideline: 502.3.3Provide Accessible Aisle Marking High included above

Notes: Access aisle is not marked to discourage parking. Provide hatching and/or "NO PARKING" pavement markings within the access aisle.

Federal Guideline: 502.3.301a West Employee Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium TBDNotes: Consider relocating the accessible employee spaces closer to the employee entrance. The current location requires crossing of an internal vehicle circulation drive and is over 140' from the entrance. There are some existing spaces reserved for city vehicles between the west employee lot and building that would be much closer.Federal Guideline: 208.3

Central Services

NOTES: This facility includes parking in several locations. The front lot is for the general public, with parking to the east for city vehicles, and parking on the west for employees.

40 total parking spaces provided including 2 designated as accessible including 1 van-accessible. 2 accessible spaces required, including 1 van space.

159 total parking spaces provided including 7 designated as accessible including 1 van-accessible. 6 accessible spaces required, including 1 van space.

City of Oak RidgeCentral Services Page 1 of 24

Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $700Notes: The curb ramp flares encroach into the accessible parking access aisle but they are oversized and have an access aisle on each side. Access aisles not marked to discourage parking. Provide hatching and/or "NO PARKING" pavement markings within all access aisles. Cost assumes restriping of all access aisles. Federal Guideline: 502.3.3Accessible Routes and Curb Ramps

02 Curb Ramp at West Employee ParkingProvide Compliant Ramp Low $3,500Notes: Existing ramp has running slope up to 9.1% (8.33% max). Reconstruct the ramp when major sitework is undertaken, deviation from standard is minor.Federal Guideline: 406

04 West Parking Accessible RouteProvide Compliant Accessible Routes Medium $200Notes: Elevation change of 1/2" at accessible route intersection with vehicle drive. Grind edge to compliant angle to remove trip hazard.Federal Guideline: 402, 403

InteriorCommon Circulation Spaces

07 Drinking FountainsProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Medium $1,200Notes: 50% of drinking fountains are required to each be accessible to either wheelchair users or standing users. Currently there are four (4) total fountains, all of which have bubbler heights at 36" or less with knee space below. No fountains have bubbler heights of 36-43" for standing user. Reposition 2 fountains to adjust bubbler height to 38-43". Cost is to reposition and remount 2 fountains. Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7

08a-1 Main Front Entrance Exterior Door Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08a-2 Rear Entrance Exterior Door Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08b-2 Kitchen Door within Multi-Purpose RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No sign provided. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost08b-5 Multi-Purpose Room Door

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b-8 Door From Public Lobby to Employee Area CorridorAdjust Door Closer Low $450

Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.

Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.115-1 Public Lobby Men’s Restroom

Reposition Sink Low $750Notes: Sink rim is 34-1/2" high (34" max. req'd). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max.Federal Guideline: 606.3Reposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlet is mounted at 51" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handles are provided on the outside of the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hooks is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

15-2 Public Lobby Women’s Restroom Reposition Sink Low $750Notes: Sink rim is 34-1/2" high (34" max. req'd). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max.Federal Guideline: 606.3Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 41" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlet is mounted at 51" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handles are provided on the outside of the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReplace Flush Controls Low $100Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hooks is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

18-1 Administration Office ReceptionProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200

Notes: No compliant signs provided for Public Works or Electrical Department (visual only). Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille. Ensure signage is placed on wall adjacent to the latch.

Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device Low $400Notes: Device at 51" (over 48" max ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

18-3 Main Employee Hallway and Break Areas 1-3Provide Means of Egress Signage High $200Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to 2 employee entry doors on west side.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Wall Signage Medium $200Notes: Approximately 13 rooms/permanent spaces have missing or non-compliant signs.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Outlets Low $150Notes: Electrical outlets typically at 53" height (15-48" req'd.). Lowest cost option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height. Provide min. 1 at each break area.Federal Guideline: 308.3Protect/Reposition Protruding Objects Low $400Notes: Time clocks on wall at Break Area 1, 2 near drinking fountain at Break Area 2, and Break Area 3 protrude 10" at 34" (4" max. between 27"-Federal Guideline: 307.2Protect/Reposition Protruding Objects Low $500Notes: Fire extinguishers on wall at Break Area 1, 2 at Break Area 2, and at 2 doors to Schools Maintenance door protrude 6" at 40" (4" max. between 27"-80"). Federal Guideline: 307.2


Item # Description Priority Probable CostLower Fire Alarm Activation Device Medium $4,000Notes: Devices in several locations at 51" (over 48" max ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address. Verify height of all within the building and correct as needed.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

18-4 Multi-Purpose RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No sign provided at SCADA room or door to Electrical Department secretary inside this room. Provide compliant signs with visual and tactile letters and Braille at both doors inside the room.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308

35a-1 Multi-Purpose Room Kitchen Reposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim at 36" high (34" max. req'd.) and provides no knee space below as required. Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Kitchen with oven/range is required to have knee space below the sink.Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3Provide Accessible Working Surface Medium $600Notes: Work surface countertop is at 36" (34" max.) above the floor. Federal Guideline: 226.1, 902.2Replace Range/Oven Medium $1,000Notes: Controls must be operable without reaching over burners. Purchase new range/oven that has all controls on front panel.Federal Guideline: 804.6.4, 804.6.5.3Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlet is mounted at 51" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Reposition Hand Sanitizer and Paper Towel Dispensers Low $100Notes: Dispensers located well above 48" max. reach height. Reposition both.Federal Guideline: 308.2

35b-1 Break Area 1Reposition Sink Low $750Notes: Sink rim at 36" high (34" max. req'd.). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost35b-1 Break Area 2

Reposition Sink Low $750Notes: Sink rim for both sinks at 36" high (34" max. req'd.). Reposition such that rim of 1 sink does not exceed 34" max. Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3Provide Clear Space at Refrigerator Medium $200Notes: Both refrigerator doors are against a wall, provides no clear space for wheelchair user to open. Least costly option would be to either reverse swing of doors, cost assumes both are corrected.Federal Guideline: 804.6.6

35b-1 Break Area 3Reposition Sink Low $750Notes: Sink rim at 36" high (34" max. req'd.). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3Public Works

08b-1 Public Works Conference Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Low $400Notes: Door alcove greater than 8" deep, door considered a recessed door, which provides only 4" of latch side clearance to wall (18" min. req'd.). Explore options including reversing door swing into the hallway, cost is placeholder and will vary.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1

08b-11 Main Hallway Door 2 to Public Works Vehicle Parking Garage Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No sign provided. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer. Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Modify Vision Panel Medium $450Notes: Vision panel below 66" is at 54" ht. (43" max.)Federal Guideline: 404.2.11

08b-12 Main Hallway Door to Public Works Vehicle Parking GarageProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No sign provided. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable CostAdjust Door Closer Medium $450


Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Modify Vision Panel Medium $450Notes: Vision panel below 66" is at 54" ht. (43" max.)Federal Guideline: 404.2.11

09 Public Works HallwaysProvide Means of Egress Signage High $200Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door at east hall exit and vehicle parking garage man-door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Wall Signage Low $1,900Notes: Approximately 19 rooms/permanent spaces have missing or non-compliant signs.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Protect/Reposition Protruding Objects Low $100Notes: Electrical control at doors to main hallway protrudes 12" at 48" (4" max. between 27"-80"). Federal Guideline: 307.2Protect/Reposition Protruding Objects Low $100Notes: Mailboxes on wall at doors to main hallway protrude 8" at 56" (4" max. between 27"-80"). Federal Guideline: 307.2

15-7 Public Works Men's Locker Room RestroomAdjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The door closing time is less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Insulation Below Sink (4) Low $440Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Urinal Medium $450Notes: The top of the lip on the urinal is at 20" high (17" max.). Reposition 1 urinal to compliant height.Federal Guideline: 605.2Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handles are provided on the outside of the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Wheelchair Accessible Stall Medium $1,500Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 39" (60" min.), door clear width opening is 22" (32" min.), toilet centerline is 19" from wall (16-18" req'd.), door is in-swinging, and there are no grab bars provided. Investigate options to provide 1 60" min. width stall for wheelchair. Verify plumbing code fixture count. Cost is estimate and will vary based on option implemented, which could include eliminating 1 urinal to provide 2 stalls.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hook is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

15-8 Public Works Women's Locker Room RestroomAdjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The door closing time is less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: Bottom edge of reflecting surface over sink is at 41" ht. (40" max.).Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 51" (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handles are provided on the outside of the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall Medium $2,500Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 38" (60" min.), door clear width opening is 22" (32" min.), toilet centerline is 19" from wall (16-18" req'd.), door is in-swinging, and there are no grab bars provided. Investigate options to provide 1 60" min. width stall for wheelchair. Investigate options, which will require removal of concrete block wall.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hook is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

17-5 Men's Public Works ShowersProvide Compliant Transfer Shower Low $5,000Notes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Existing shower is only 32"x32" (36"x36" req'd.), has 4" high threshold, has no seat or grab bars, has no handheld showerhead, etc. Cost assumes alterations to existing shower entry and compartment to provide compliant transfer shower. Explore least costly option.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608Reposition Clothing Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the hook is 56" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

17-6 Women's Public Works ShowersProvide Compliant Transfer Shower Low $5,000Notes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Existing shower is only 32"x32" (36"x36" req'd.), has 4" high threshold, has no seat or grab bars, has no handheld showerhead, etc. Cost assumes alterations to existing shower entry and compartment to provide compliant transfer shower. Explore least costly option.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608Reposition Clothing Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the hook is 56" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

18-5 Public Works Conference RoomLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Protect Protruding Objects Low $100Notes: Wall cabinet protrudes more than 4" max. between 27-80". Provide permanent, cane-detectable object below at each end. Federal Guideline: 307.2


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost19-5 Public Works Men's Locker Room

Provide Accessible Lockers Low $400Notes: 34 total lockers provided, none marked as accessible. 5% required to be accessible (2 min.). Clothing hooks inside at 62" and shelf at 64" (48" max. each). Ensure min. 2 lockers have storage devices inside at 48" high max. and are adjacent to a compliant bench. Cost assumes existing lockers can be altered to lower devices within.Federal Guideline: 222, 225, 308, 309.4, 803, 811Provide Compliant Bench Medium $600Notes: Existing benches are only 12" deep and not all provide back support. Provide compliant bench seats 42" long x 20"-24" max. wide mounted to a wall or which has a back support that is 42" long minimum that are adjacent to accessible lockers. Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903

19-6 Public Works Women's Locker RoomProvide Accessible Lockers Low $200Notes: 4 total lockers provided, none marked as accessible. 5% required to be accessible (1 min.). Clothing hooks inside at 62" and shelf at 64" (48" max. each). Ensure min. 1 lockers have storage devices inside at 48" high max. and are adjacent to a compliant bench. Cost assumes existing lockers can be altered to lower devices within.Federal Guideline: 222, 225, 308, 309.4, 803, 811Provide Compliant Bench Medium $600

Notes: Existing benches are only 12" deep. Provide compliant bench seats 42" long x 20"-24" max. wide mounted to a wall or which has a back support that is 42" long minimum that are adjacent to accessible lockers.

Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903Electrical Department

08b-4 Electrical Department Hallway Door to Bucket Truck Parking DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No sign provided. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closers Low $450


Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.108b-7 Door to Electrical Department From Main Hallway (3 total)

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: No sign provided or sign provided is visual text only. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille. Ensure all signs are placed on the wall to the right of double doors.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable CostAdjust Door Closer Medium $1,350Notes: The sweeping time is less than 5 sec. Cost is for 3 new closers.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Modify Vision Panel (3 doors) Medium $1,350Notes: Vision panel below 66" is at 53" ht. (43" max.)Federal Guideline: 404.2.11

09 Electrical Department Front Offices HallwaysProvide Compliant Wall Signage Low $1,100Notes: Approximately 17 rooms/permanent spaces have missing or non-compliant signs.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

09 Electrical Shop HallwaysProvide Compliant Wall Signage Low $2,400Notes: Approximately 24 rooms/permanent spaces have missing or non-compliant signs.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Means of Egress Signage High $700Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door at loading dock, storage/warehouse, and other doors leading to exterior.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

15-3 Electrical Department Men's Locker Room Restrooms

Protect Protruding Objects Low $100Notes: Electrical control box inside entry door protrudes 7" at 48" (4" max. between 27-80"). Provide permanent, cane-detectable object below. Ensure it projects from wall less than 5" to avoid issues with latch pull side clear space.Federal Guideline: 307.2Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum and operating force is 7 lbs. (5 lb. max.). Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1, 404.2.9Provide Insulation Below Sink (2) Low $220Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 51" above the ground with reach over the countertop (44" max. with 20-25" reach over). Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7

Notes: All locker room restrooms, especially those with bathing facilities, should be fully accessible. The items noted below assume all will include accessible facilities throughout.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlet is mounted at 51" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Reposition Urinal - OPTIONAL Low N/ANotes: The top of the lip on the urinal is at 21" high (17" max.) and clear width is only 34" (36" width required if alcove is over 24" depth). Only 1 urinal present so not required to comply.Federal Guideline: 305.7.1, 605.2, 605.3Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handles are provided on the outside of the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall Medium $1,500Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 37" (60" min.), door clear width opening is 22" (32" min.), toilet centerline is 18-1/2" from partition wall (16-18" req'd.), door is in-swinging, and there are no grab bars provided. Investigate options, including modifications to partitions and relocation of urinal to provide 1 60" min. width stall for wheelchair. Verify plumbing code fixture count. Cost is estimate and will vary based on option implemented.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hooks is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

15-4 Electrical Department Women's Locker Room Restrooms

Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The Mirror is located at 41" , an reflective surface must be located no higher then 40" above the ground.Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 51" above the ground with reach over the countertop (48" max.). Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308



Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlet is mounted at 51" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handles are provided on the outside of the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall Medium $1,500Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 39" (60" min.), door clear width opening is 22" (32" min.), toilet centerline is 18-1/2" from partition wall (16-18" req'd.), door is in-swinging, and there are no grab bars provided. Investigate options to provide 1 60" min. width stall for wheelchair. Verify plumbing code fixture count. Cost is estimate and will vary based on option implemented.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hooks is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

17-1 Electrical Department Men's ShowersReposition Clothing Hooks Low $50Notes: The height of the hooks is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4Provide Compliant Transfer Shower Low $5,000Notes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Existing shower lacks clear space and clear width at entry, is not correct size for transfer shower, has no seat or grab bar, has 4" high threshold, lacks handheld showerhead, etc. Cost assumes alterations to existing shower entry and compartment to provide compliant transfer shower. Explore least costly option.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608

17-2 Electrical Department Women's ShowersReposition Clothing Hooks Low $50Notes: The height of the hooks is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4Provide Compliant Transfer Shower Low $5,000Notes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Existing shower lacks clear space and clear width at entry, is not correct size for transfer shower, has no seat or grab bar, has 4" high threshold, lacks handheld showerhead, etc. Cost assumes alterations to existing shower entry and compartment to provide compliant transfer shower. Explore least costly option.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost19-1 Electrical Department Men's Locker Room

Provide Accessible Lockers Low $400Notes: 22 total lockers provided, only 1 marked as accessible with ISA (NOTE: was locked so inside details could not be determined). 5% required to be accessible (2 min.). Clothing hooks inside at 62" and shelf at 64" (48" max. each). Ensure min. 2 lockers have storage devices inside at 48" high max. and are adjacent to a compliant bench. Cost assumes existing lockers can be altered to lower devices within.Federal Guideline: 222, 225, 308, 309.4, 803, 811Provide Compliant Bench Medium $600Notes: Existing benches are only 12" deep and provide no back support as required. Provide compliant bench seats 42" long x 20"-24" max. wide mounted to a wall or which has a back support that is 42" long minimum that are adjacent to accessible lockers. Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903

19-2 Electrical Department Women's Locker RoomProvide Accessible Lockers Low $200Notes: 6 total lockers provided, none marked as accessible. 5% required to be accessible (1 min.). Clothing hooks inside at 62" and shelf at 64" (48" max. each). Ensure min. 1 locker has storage devices inside at 48" high max. and are adjacent to a compliant bench. Cost assumes existing lockers can be altered to lower devices within.Federal Guideline: 222, 225, 308, 309.4, 803, 811Provide Compliant Bench Medium $600


Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903Recreation & Parks Department

08b-9 Main Hallway Door to Recreation & Parks DepartmentProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Sign provided is visual text only. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille. Ensure all signs are placed on the wall to the right of double doors.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The sweeping time is less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Modify Vision Panel Medium $450Notes: Vision panel below 66" is at 54" ht. (43" max.).Federal Guideline: 404.2.11


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost09 Recreation & Parks Hallways

Provide Compliant Wall Signage Low $700Notes: Approximately 7 rooms/permanent spaces have missing or non-compliant signs.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door at west exit door leading to exterior.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Schools Department

08a School Department Work AreasProvide Means of Egress Signage High $800Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door in vehicle maintenance (3), welding shop, storage room, chemical storage, paint room, and carpentry shop.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08a-3 School Department Exit Door at Transportation SupervisorProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The sweeping time is less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

08a-4 School Department Door to Bus Parking Near Service School Service Desk SecretaryProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The door closing time is less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device Low $400Notes: Device at 51" (over 48" max ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

08b-3 School Training Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Sign provided is visual text only. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille. Ensure all signs are placed on the latch side wall.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost08b-6 School Main Hallway Door to Offices

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Sign provided is visual text only. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille. Ensure all signs are placed on the latch side wall.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The sweeping time is less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Modify Vision Panel Medium $450Notes: Vision panel below 66" is at 54" ht. (43" max.)Federal Guideline: 404.2.11

08b-10 Main Hallway Door to Vehicle MaintenanceProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Sign provided is visual text only. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille. Ensure all signs are placed on the latch side wall.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The sweeping time is less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Modify Vision Panel Medium $450Notes: Vision panel below 66" is at 54" ht. (43" max.)Federal Guideline: 404.2.11

09 School Department HallwaysProvide Compliant Wall Signage Low $2,000Notes: Approximately 20 rooms/permanent spaces have missing or non-compliant signs.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Protect/Reposition Protruding Objects Low $100Notes: Shelf at exit door at secretary service desk protrudes 12" at 38" (4" max. between 27"-80"). Federal Guideline: 307.2Protect/Reposition Protruding Objects Low $300Notes: Time clocks (3) in hallway protrude 8" at 44" (4" max. between 27"-80"). Federal Guideline: 307.2Protect/Reposition Protruding Objects Low $100Notes: Fire extinguisher in hallway protrudes 6" at 40" (4" max. between 27"-80"). Federal Guideline: 307.2


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost15-5 Schools Men’s Locker Room Restrooms

Protect Protruding Objects Low $100Notes: Electrical control box inside entry door protrudes 7" at 48" (4" max. between 27-80"). Provide permanent, cane-detectable object below. Ensure it projects from wall less than 5" to avoid issues with latch pull side clear space.Federal Guideline: 307.2Adjust Door Closer Low $450


Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Reposition Soap Dispensers Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 52" (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Compliant Urinal Clear Width - OPTIONAL Low N/ANotes: The clear width is only 34" (36" width required if alcove is over 24" depth). Only 1 urinal present so not required to comply.Federal Guideline: 305.7.1, 605.2, 605.3Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handles are provided on the inside of the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Replace Flush Controls Low $100Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Reposition Toilet Cleaner Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located within the 12" clear space above the rear grab bar. Federal Guideline: 609.3Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hook is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4



Item # Description Priority Probable Cost15-6 Schools Women’s Locker Room Restrooms

Adjust Door Closer Low $450


Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Reposition Soap Dispensers Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 55" (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handles are provided on the outside of the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hook is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

15-9 Men’s Vehicle Maintenance Locker Room Restroom



Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Insulation Below Sink (2) Low $220Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 54" above the ground (48" max.). Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308




Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Urinal - OPTIONAL Low N/ANotes: The top of the lip on the urinal is at 19" high (17" max.) and clear width is only 34" (36" width required if alcove is over 24" depth). Only 1 urinal present so not required to comply.Federal Guideline: 305.7.1, 605.2, 605.3Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall Medium $2,000Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 39" (60" min.), door clear width opening is 22" (32" min.), no handle provided on outside of door, door is in-swinging, and there are no grab bars provided. Investigate options to provide 60" min. width stall for wheelchair. Cost is estimate and will vary based on option implemented, which may include elimination/relocation of urinal.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hook is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

15-10 Women’s Vehicle Maintenance Locker Room Restroom



Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The Mirror is located at 41" , an reflective surface must be located no higher then 40" above the ground.Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 54" above the ground (48" max.). Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308



Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Wheelchair Accessible Stall Medium $2,000Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 39" (60" min.), door clear width opening is 22" (32" min.), no handle provided on outside of door, door is in-swinging, toilet centerline at 19" from wall (16-18" req'd.), and there are no grab bars provided. Investigate options to provide 60" min. width stall for wheelchair. Cost is estimate and will vary based on option implemented.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hook is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

16-1 Men’s School Office Single-User RestroomProvide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Low N/ANotes: The clear space on the pull side of the door is only partially obstructed by rack with cleaning supplies. Explore options to relocate rack.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlet is mounted at 51" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Provide Clear Width Adjacent to Toilet Medium $1,200NOTE: Sink is located within 44" of toilet wall (60" clearance req'd.). Investigate options to provide compliant toilet room clear space at toilet. Cost is placeholder.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hook is 62" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

16-2 Women’s School Office Single-User RestroomProvide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Low N/ANotes: The clear space on the pull side of the door is partially obstructed by bench. Explore options to relocate bench.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1


Item # Description Priority Probable CostLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlet is mounted at 51" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Protect Protruding Objects Low $100Notes: Towel dispenser at the door protrudes 10" at 40" (4" max. between 27-80"). Provide permanent, cane-detectable object below. Federal Guideline: 307.2Replace Flush Controls Low $100Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Provide Clear Width Adjacent to Toilet Medium $1,200NOTE: Sink is located within 44" of toilet wall (60" clearance req'd.). Investigate options to provide compliant toilet room clear space at toilet. Cost is placeholder.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1

17-3 Men's School Area Showers Provide Compliant Transfer Shower Low $5,000Notes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Existing shower is only 34"x34" (36"x36" req'd.), has no seat, has non-compliant grab bars, etc. Cost assumes alterations to existing shower entry and compartment to provide compliant transfer shower. Explore least costly option.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608

17-7 Women's School Area Showers Provide Compliant Transfer Shower Low $5,000Notes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Existing shower is only 34"x34" (36"x36" req'd.), has 4" high threshold, has non-compliant grab bars, etc. Cost assumes alterations to existing shower entry and compartment to provide compliant transfer shower. Explore least costly option.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost17-4 Men's Showers By Vehicle Maintenance

Provide Compliant Transfer Shower Low $5,000Notes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Existing shower is only 32"x32" (36"x36" req'd.), has 4" high threshold, has no seat or grab bars, has no handheld showerhead, etc. Cost assumes alterations to existing shower entry and compartment to provide compliant transfer shower. Explore least costly option.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608Reposition Clothing Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the hook is 56" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

17-8 Women's Showers By Vehicle MaintenanceProvide Compliant Transfer Shower Low $5,000Notes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Existing shower is only 32"x32" (36"x36" req'd.), has 4" high threshold, has no seat or grab bars, has no handheld showerhead, etc. Cost assumes alterations to existing shower entry and compartment to provide compliant transfer shower. Explore least costly option.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608Reposition Clothing Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the hook is 56" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max. within the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

18-2 School Department Secretary Operations OfficeProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Compliant Outlets Low $50Notes: Electrical outlets at 53" height (15-48" req'd.). Lowest cost option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 308.3Provide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $900Notes: Service counter is at 42” height (36" max. req'd. for verbal interaction). Provide min. 36" wide section of service counter at 36" max. height.Federal Guideline: 227.3, 904.4


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost18-6 Schools Training Room

Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Compliant Outlets Low $50Notes: Electrical outlets at 53" height (15-48" req'd.). Lowest cost option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 308.3

19-3 Men's Schools Locker RoomProvide Compliant Bench Medium $600Notes: Existing benches are only 12" deep and provide no back support as required. Provide compliant bench seats 42" long x 20"-24" max. wide mounted to a wall or which has a back support that is 42" long minimum that are adjacent to accessible lockers. Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903

19-4 Men's Locker Room By Vehicle MaintenanceProvide Accessible Lockers Low $200Notes: 18 total lockers provided, none marked as accessible. 5% required to be accessible (1 min.). Clothing hooks inside at 62" and shelf at 64" (48" max. each). Ensure min. 1 locker has storage devices inside at 48" high max. and are adjacent to a compliant bench. Cost assumes existing lockers can be altered to lower devices within.Federal Guideline: 222, 225, 308, 309.4, 803, 811Provide Compliant Bench Medium $600


Federal Guideline: 803.4, 90319-7 Women's Schools Locker Room

Provide Compliant Bench Medium $600Notes: Existing benches are only 12" deep and provide no back support as required. Provide compliant bench seats 42" long x 20"-24" max. wide mounted to a wall or which has a back support that is 42" long minimum that are adjacent to accessible lockers. Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903

19-8 Women's Locker Room By Vehicle MaintenanceProvide Accessible Lockers Low $200Notes: 4 total lockers provided, none marked as accessible. 5% required to be accessible (1 min.). Clothing hooks inside at 62" and shelf at 64" (48" max. each). Ensure min. 1 locker has storage devices inside at 48" high max. and are adjacent to a compliant bench. Cost assumes existing lockers can be altered to lower devices within.Federal Guideline: 222, 225, 308, 309.4, 803, 811


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Bench Medium $600




General Notes: 1. Parking is provided on 3 sides. The front (north) is for visitor's and the general public. The east is for city-owned vehicles/pool cars. The west has 2 separate areas for employees. These are considered as 3 separate facilities based on use and access.2. There are a total of four (4) drinking fountains within this facility. This requires 2 (50%) be wheelchair-accessible bubbler height of 36" max. with knee and toe space provided and the other 2 be standing height bubbler (38-43").3. Each department restroom/shower/locker room is assumed to be made fully compliant. Alternate option would be to provide 1 fully compliant space and assign employees requiring accessible facilities there but not best option to keep department employees together.4. Several break areas exist, all have non-compliant sinks. Provide 1 break area that fully complies and publicize that location to employees, as well as provide signage.



Exterior Item # Description Priority Probable Cost01a Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $8,000Notes: Several of the existing accessible parking spaces and/or access aisles have slopes up to 3.8% (2% max.) and van-accessible space in NE corner does not have a full width access aisle. The accessible parking is quite distant from the marked accessible entrances on the east side of the building for the Recreation Center and Senior Center (over 400 feet). Consider providing accessible parking in front of the building by modifying the loop drive (not required but greatly improves accessibility). Cost assumes leveling of existing parking spaces, cost will vary if spaces are moved.Federal Guideline: 502Accessible Routes and Curb Ramps

02 Curb Ramps

Provide Compliant Curb Ramp Low $1,500

Notes: Side flares on curb ramp at drop-off in front of the building exceed 17% (10% max.). Minor issue to address when walk is reconstructed.

Federal Guideline: 406.3

Civic Center/

RecreationCenter

NOTES: This facility has dedicated parking to the west side of the building that is connected to the library parking lot to the east by an interior drive. Only the west parking for the recreation center is included. 110 total parking spaces are provided, including 14 accessible, 3 of which are van-accessible. A total of 5 accessible spaces, including 1 van-accessible space is required.

NOTES: There are multiple curb ramps on the site, the only 1 on an accessible route from parking to the accessible entrance is at the parking lot. There is an additional curb ramp at the drive loop in the front of the building.

City of Oak RidgeCivic Center-Rec Building Page 1 of 19

Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Passenger Loading Zone Medium $800Notes: Passenger loading zones require markings and signage to prevent vehicles from blocking access to the curb ramp. The existing drop-off in front of the building within the drive loop has no markings or signage as required. Provide signage designating the area as passenger loading zone only and provide pavement markings to prohibit vehicles from blocking the curb ramp. Min. markings are full length of drop-off zone (min. 20' wide at curb ramp) by 8' deep. Cost assumes pavement markings and signage is provided at each end.Federal Guideline: 209, 503

04 Accessible RoutesProvide Additional Signage Low $200Notes: The existing signage identifying the accessible route from parking to the accessible entrances should be supplemented. Provide additional signage at drop-off curb ramp facing the curb ramp.Federal Guideline: 303, 403.3, 403.4

InteriorCommon Circulation Spaces

07-1 Drinking Fountains Across From Craft Room & Club RoomProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Medium $800Notes: Both drinking fountains have bubblers at wheelchair height (36" max.). Adjust one fountain so bubbler height is at standing person height of 38-43". Another option would be to replace the fountain between the restrooms with standing user unit adjacent to the other wheelchair fountain to correct other issues at restroom door for clear space. Cost assumes restroom fountain removed and relocated to adjacent to hallway fountain at standing user height.Federal Guideline: 211, 602Protect Protruding Objects Medium $400Notes: Both drinking fountains not within compliant alcove, protruding into circulation area. Provide permanent, cane-detectable barriers on both sides of both fountains.Federal Guideline: 307.2

08a-1 Recreation Building Main EntranceProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

NOTES: There are 3 drinking fountains on the main level, which requires that 1 each meets the standards for wheelchair and standing user. The 3rd fountain can meet either. The fountains on the upper and lower level should be assumed to not be required to meet any standard until vertical access is provided.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost08a-4 Senior Center Entrance


08a-5 Main Hallway Exit Door to Pool PatioProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

09 Civic Center Gym/Game Room/Social Room HallwayProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Employee only door at gym has visual sign on door. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Lower Controls Low $50Notes: The height of the electrical switches are located at 51" above the ground and the thermostat is at 57", but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Lower thermostat and correct switch when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308

09 Senior Center Hallways and LobbyProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Storage rooms have no signage. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Protect Protruding Objects Low $200Notes: Service counter protrudes more than 4" between 27-80", provide permanent cane-detectable object below at each end.Federal Guideline: 307.2Provide Compliant Coat Rack Low $100Notes: Coat rack at the end of the hallway has coat hangers and shelf above 48" max. reach height. Provide additional storage devices within reach range.Federal Guideline: 308

11-1 Swimming Pool Locker Room Stairway Behind ReceptionProvide Compliant Handrails Medium $2,400Notes: Handrail top surface is mounted 31" (34-38" req'd.) above stair surfaces. Handrails do not extend 12" min. beyond the stairs at the top and/or bottom. Perimeter for non-circular handrail is too large at 8" (4" to 6-1/4" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 505.4, 505.7, 505.10


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost15-1 Men’s Multi-User Restroom By Drinking Fountain

Reposition Signage and Provide Directional Sign Medium $250Notes: Existing signage on the door has bottom of lowest tactile letters at 63" (60" max.). This restroom is not accessible but there is no directional signage indicating the location of the accessible restroom. Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door N/A N/ANotes: There is only 4" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.). Consider options when altered, which may include reversing the door swing into the hallway or providing a power door opener.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Reposition Sink N/A N/ANotes: Sink rim is at 36" high (34" max.). Reposition such that rim of 1 sink does not exceed 34" max. Provide ISA at this sinkFederal Guideline: 606.3Reposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 51" high (40" max.). Provide lower mirror at low sink.Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 56" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308

NOTES: This set of restrooms is not wheelchair accessible but should be made compliant to the greatest extent possible, including providing ambulatory stall. Ensure signage at both the Men's and Women's restrooms included signage with pictogram, visual and tactile letters, and Braille but not the ISA, along with an additional directional sign with ISA and visual text only directing persons to the location of the wheelchair accessible facilities. Items noted below for information only unless a priority and cost provided.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Wheelchair Accessible Stall N/A N/ANotes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 36" (60" min.), stall door has no handle on the outside and doors swing into the stall (outswinging req'd.), stall door entry width is only 24" (32" min.), and no grab bars provided. Explore option of eliminating urinal closest to stalls and reconfigure stalls to provide compliant stall. Verify plumbing code fixture count requirements prior to finalizing design. Consider providing ambulatory accessible stall until a wheelchair stall is provided, if total fixture count remains 6 or more, maintain both types of accessible stall.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3Relocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hook on inside of stall door located at 66" ht. (15"-48" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

15-2 Women’s Multi-User Restroom By Drinking Fountain

Reposition Signage and Provide Directional Sign Medium $250Notes: Existing signage on the door has bottom of lowest tactile letters at 63" (60" max.). This restroom is not accessible but there is no directional signage indicating the location of the accessible restroom. Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Reposition Sink N/A N/ANotes: Sink rim is at 36" high (34" max.). Reposition such that rim of 1 sink does not exceed 34" max. Provide ISA at this sinkFederal Guideline: 606.3Reposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 48" high (40" max.). Provide lower mirror at low sink.Federal Guideline: 603.3Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308



Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Wheelchair Accessible Stall N/A N/ANotes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 36" (60" min.), stall door has no handle on the outside and doors swing into the stall (outswinging req'd.), stall door entry width is only 24" (32" min.), and no grab bars provided. Explore option of eliminating 1 stall and reconfigure stalls to provide compliant stall. Verify plumbing code fixture count requirements prior to finalizing design. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3Relocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hook on inside of stall door located at 66" ht. (15"-48" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

16-1 ADA Main Entrance Unisex Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $400Notes: Existing signage at the restroom entry is not compliant, sign includes only the ISA with no gender pictogram and is located on the hinge side wall. Provide new sign with unisex gender pictograms, visual and tactile letters, and Braille with the ISA on the latch wall. Include similar signage for shower facility at this door also.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Replace Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Lock requires grasping and twisting. Replace lock control inside with one that is compliant.Federal Guideline: 404.2.7Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Reposition or Protect Protruding Objects Low $100

Notes: Mounted shelf on the wall protrudes more than 4" max. between 27"-80". Provide permanent cane-detectable object below on both ends.

Federal Guideline: 307.2

NOTES: This is an unusual restroom configuration, with signage indicating it is unisex and for a single user given the lock on the door. However, there is 1 stall and 2 showers within the space. It appears as though this is a designated facility for disabled users to shower for the pool since the locker rooms are on a different level and have no vertical access. In the current configuration many fixtures are being taken up by potentially only 1 user. Items below identify what is needed for compliance in current configuration but consideration should be given to modifying this space to provide 2, unisex restrooms each with a wheelchair-accessible toilet and shower. Costs for that conversion is not included due to the need for further investigation of options.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Coat Hook Low $50

Notes: The height of the coat hook outside of the stall on the wall is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max.

Federal Guideline: 308, 608.3Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handles are provided on the outside of the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Reconfigure Wheelchair Stall Partitions High $800Notes: The stall partition on the wall opposite the toilet is 8" from the wall (4" max.).Federal Guideline: 604.8.1.2Provide/Reposition Grab Bars Medium $500Notes: Both grab bars are too low (33-36" above floor required). Rear grab bar is not properly centered on the toilet centerline, 12" to wall side and 24" to opposite side is required. Reposition both grab bars to proper height and location, ensuring also that the side grab bar extends 12" max. at wall end and 54" min. at far end from rear wall.Federal Guideline: 604.5, 609.4Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hook inside of the stall is above 48" max. Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max.Federal Guideline: 308, 604.8

16-2 Men’s Accessible Restroom at Drinking Fountain Provide Compliant Signage Medium $50Notes: Existing tactile letter/Braille signage is located on the door, which opens out into the hallway. Tactile signage is only allowed on doors that open into the space. Relocate tactile signage to the latch side wall at proper height (bottom of tactile letters at 48-60").Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath, the existing insulation is in need of maintenance/replacement. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hook on the back of the door is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max.Federal Guideline: 308, 608.3Provide Clear Space at Toilet Medium $800Notes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is 39" (60" min. req'd.). Explore options, which may include relocating or recessing sink into wall. Cost is placeholder and actual cost will vary.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Replace Flush Controls Low $100Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Provide Compliant Grab Bars Medium $500Notes: Rear grab bar is only 32" long (36" min.) Provide new compliant grab bar installed in correct location when sink issue is resolved.Federal Guideline: 604.5, 609.4

16-3 Women’s Accessible Restroom at Drinking Fountain Provide Compliant Signage Medium $50Notes: Existing tactile letter/Braille signage is located on the door, which opens out into the hallway. Tactile signage is only allowed on doors that open into the space. Relocate tactile signage to the latch side wall at proper height (bottom of tactile letters at 48-60").Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath, the existing insulation is in need of maintenance/replacement. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: The height of the coat hook on the back of the door is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max.Federal Guideline: 308, 608.3Provide Clear Space at Toilet Medium $800Notes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is 41-1/2" (60" min. req'd.). Explore options, which may include relocating or recessing sink into wall. Cost is placeholder and actual cost will vary.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Grab Bars Medium $500Notes: Rear grab bar is only 32" long (36" min.). Provide new compliant grab bar installed in correct location when sink issue is resolved.Federal Guideline: 604.5, 609.4

18-6 Main Entry Reception Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $800Notes: Counter height is 42" (36" max. for verbal interaction). Lower section of counter to 36" height (34" preferred).Federal Guideline: 904.4.2Protect Protruding Objects Low $200Notes: Service counter protrudes more than 4" between 27-80", provide permanent cane-detectable object below.Federal Guideline: 307.2Kitchen

08a Kitchen Exit DoorProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

35a-1 Gym Kitchen Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No signage exists at double doors leading to gym or storage room. Provide compliant signs with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Reposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim is 36" high (34" max. req'd). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Kitchen with oven/range is required to have knee space below the sink.Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3Lower Telephone Low $50Notes: Operable parts of telephone over 48" max. ht.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Replace Range/Oven Medium $1,000Notes: Controls must be operable without reaching over burners. Purchase new range/oven that has all controls on front panel.Federal Guideline: 804.6.4, 804.6.5.3


Item # Description Priority Probable CostPool

08a Pool Exit Doors to PatioProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08b-10 Swimming Pool DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Men's Locker Room/Showers

07-3 Drinking Fountain in Men's Locker RoomProtect Protruding Object Medium $100Notes: Drinking fountains not within compliant alcove, protruding into circulation area. Provide permanent, cane-detectable barriers on both sides of fountain. Note that fountain was not operational at the time of the evaluation.Federal Guideline: 307.2

16-3 Men’s Single-User Restroom within Locker RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No compliant signage provided, existing sign is on the door (sign cannot be on a door without a closer), includes only "RESTROOM" visual text, and has a serif font. Compliant sign with visual and tactile letters in sans serif fort and Braille required in compliant location at latch side wall at the door. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door N/A N/ANotes: The sink blocks the required 18" clear space on the latch pull side of the door. Consider options when altered, which may include reversing the door swing into the hallway.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Provide Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 48-1/2" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3

NOTES: This space is not wheelchair accessible since there is no vertical access other than stairs. It includes a single-user restroom, drinking fountain, lockers, and multiple showers. Items noted below for information only unless a priority and cost provided.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Clear Space at Toilet N/A N/ANotes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is less than 60" min. req'd. Room dimension perpendicular to wall behind the toilet is only 50" (56" min. required). Explore options, which can include relocating sink.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser N/A N/ANotes: Toilet paper dispenser centerline located 0" in front of toilet (7-9" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Grab Bars N/A N/ANotes: No grab bars provided, required on the side and rear walls in compliant location. Provide compliant grab bars when vertical access to locker room is provided.Federal Guideline: 604.5

17-2 Swimming Pool Locker Room Showers (Typical for All Stalls)Reposition Clothing Hook N/A N/ANotes: The height of the hooks in the shower stall is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max.Federal Guideline: 308, 608.3Provide Compliant Benches N/A N/ANotes: The bench seat within each shower stall is only 12" deep and does not meet other requirements for accessible benches.Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903.4, 903.5Provide Accessible Shower Compartment N/A N/A

Notes: Shower area is 32"x32" (36"x36" required for transfer shower), there is no clear space at the compartment for a wheelchair user to transfer, there are not seats in the showers, grab bars are not accessible, controls are on the wrong wall, the shower provides no handheld shower head, there is a step up from the dressing area to the shower, etc.

Federal Guideline: 213.2, 603, 60819-1 Men’s Swimming Pool Locker Room

Provide Compliant Benches Medium $1,800Notes: A bench is required with a surface located at 17"-19" above the floor and dimensions of 42" long x 20"min.-24"max. in width. Bench must be connected to a wall or have a back rest. Clear floor space of 30" x 48" is req'd. at the end of bench seat and parallel. Bench should be adjacent to accessible lockers. No compliant bench present. Existing benches are 16" wide with no back rest. Cost assumes 3 new compliant benches provided and some existing benches removed to ensure 36" accessible route is maintained within the room. Total of 56 lockers, 5% (3) required to be accessible and have bench adjacent.Federal Guideline: 222.1, 803.4, 903.4, 903.5


Item # Description Priority Probable CostWomen's Locker Room

16-5 Women’s Single-User Restroom within Locker RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No compliant signage provided, existing sign is on the door (sign cannot be on a door without a closer), includes only "RESTROOM" visual text, and has a serif font. Compliant sign with visual and tactile letters in sans serif fort and Braille required in compliant location at latch side wall at the door. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door N/A N/ANotes: The sink blocks the required 18" clear space on the latch pull side of the door. Consider options when altered, which may include reversing the door swing into the hallway.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Provide Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 48-1/2" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser N/A N/ANotes: The dispenser is located at 52-1/2" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Provide Clear Space at Toilet N/A N/ANotes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is less than 60" min. req'd. Room dimension perpendicular to wall behind the toilet is only 50" (56" min. required). Explore options, which can include relocating sink.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser N/A N/ANotes: Toilet paper dispenser centerline located 20" in front of toilet (7-9" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Grab Bars N/A N/ANotes: No grab bars provided, required on the side and rear walls in compliant location. Provide compliant grab bars when vertical access to locker room is provided.Federal Guideline: 604.5

17-2 Swimming Pool Locker Room Showers (Typical for All Stalls)Reposition Clothing Hook N/A N/ANotes: The height of the hooks in the shower stall is 66" (48" max.). Relocate to compliant height or provide additional at 48" max.Federal Guideline: 308, 608.3


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Benches N/A N/ANotes: The bench seat within each shower stall is only 12" deep and does not meet other requirements for accessible benches.Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903.4, 903.5Provide Accessible Shower Compartment N/A N/A

Notes: Shower area is 32"x32" (36"x36" required for transfer shower), there is no clear space at the compartment for a wheelchair user to transfer, there are not seats in the showers, grab bars are not accessible, controls are on the wrong wall, the shower provides no handheld shower head, there is a step up from the dressing area to the shower, etc.

Federal Guideline: 213.2, 603, 60819-2 Women’s Swimming Pool Locker Room

Provide Compliant Benches Medium $1,200Notes: A bench is required with a surface located at 17"-19" above the floor and dimensions of 42" long x 20"min.-24"max. in width. Bench must be connected to a wall or have a back rest. Clear floor space of 30" x 48" is req'd. at the end of bench seat and parallel. Bench should be adjacent to accessible lockers. No compliant bench present. Existing benches are 16" wide with no back rest. Cost assumes 3 new compliant benches provided and some existing benches removed to ensure 36" accessible route is maintained within the room. Total of 32 lockers, 5% (2) required to be accessible and have bench adjacent.Federal Guideline: 222.1, 803.4, 903.4, 903.5Gymnasium

07-2 Drinking Fountain in Gym Protect Protruding Object Medium $100Notes: Drinking fountains not within compliant alcove, protruding into circulation area. Provide permanent, cane-detectable barriers on open sides of fountain.Federal Guideline: 307.2

08a-2 Main Parking Lot Entrance Door to GymProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

08a-3 Entrance to Gym at Building Front Near KitchenProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable CostAdjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

08a Boiler Room Exterior DoorProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08b-6 Gym Kitchen DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b-7 Main Hall to Gym DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The closing speed is less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer. Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

08b-8 Main Parking Lot Entrance Door to GymProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The closing speed is less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer. Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

11 Gym Stairs to RestroomsProvide Compliant Handrails Medium $2,400Notes: Handrail top surface is mounted 31" (34-38" req'd.) above stair surfaces. Handrails do not extend 12" min. beyond the stairs at the top and/or bottom. Perimeter for non-circular handrail is too large at 8" (4" to 6-1/4" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 505.4, 505.7, 505.10

15-3 Men’s Restroom in GymNOTES: This set of restrooms is not wheelchair accessible but should be made compliant to the greatest extent possible, including providing ambulatory stall. Ensure signage at both the Men's and Women's restrooms included signage with pictogram, visual and tactile letters, and Braille but not the ISA, along with an additional directional sign with ISA and visual text only directing persons to the location of the wheelchair accessible facilities. Items noted below for information only unless a priority and cost provided.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Signage Medium $250Notes: Existing signage at that restroom entry is not compliant, provide sign with pictogram, visual and tactile letters, and Braille but not the ISA, along with an additional directional sign with ISA and visual text only directing persons to the location of the wheelchair accessible facilities. This restroom is not accessible but there is no directional signage indicating the location of the accessible restroom. Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703Adjust Door Closer N/A N/ANotes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 51" high (40" max.). Provide lower mirror at 1 sink.Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Urinal and Provide Clear Space N/A N/ANotes: The top of the lip on the lowest urinal is at 19" high (17" max.). Clear width at the urinal is required to be 30", privacy partition encroaches into this, remove partition.Federal Guideline: 605.2, 605.3Provide Required Stall Hardware N/A N/ANotes: No handle is provided on the inside of the wheelchair stall door, are required on both sides. Door not self-closing, replace spring hinge.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall N/A N/ANotes: No accessible stall present. Stall approach width is only 36" (42" min.), stall width is 36" (60" min.), stall door has no handle on the outside and doors swing into the stall (outswinging req'd.), stall door entry width is only 24" (32" min.), coat hooks inside the stall are at 66" (48" max.), and no grab bars provided. Explore option of eliminating urinal closest to stalls and reconfigure stalls to provide compliant wheelchair stall when vertical access is provided. Verify plumbing code fixture count requirements prior to finalizing design. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3Provide Compliant Ambulatory Stall Medium $1,750Notes: Entry door width is only 24" (32" min.), no handle provided outside the door and door swings into the stall, stall width is required to be 35-37", no grab bars provided on side walls, and coat hook is at 66" (48" max.). Reconfigure partitions to provide a compliant ambulatory stall, can be done without reducing fixtures.Federal Guideline: 231.3, 404.2, 604.5, 604.8, 609.3


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost15-4 Women’s Non ADA Restroom in Gym

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $250Notes: Existing signage at that restroom entry is not compliant, provide sign with pictogram, visual and tactile letters, and Braille but not the ISA, along with an additional directional sign with ISA and visual text only directing persons to the location of the wheelchair accessible facilities. This restroom is not accessible but there is no directional signage indicating the location of the accessible restroom. Federal Guideline: 216.8, 703Adjust Door Closer N/A N/ANotes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Reposition Sink N/A N/ANotes: Sink rim is 34-1/2" high (34" max. req'd.). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max.Federal Guideline: 606.3Provide Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 46" high (40" max.). Provide lower mirror at 1 sink.Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser N/A N/ANotes: The dispenser is located at 51" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall N/A N/A

Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall approach width is only 36" (42" min.), stall width is 36" (60" min.), stall door has no handle on the outside and doors swing into the stall (outswinging req'd.), stall door entry width is only 24" (32" min.), coat hooks inside the stall are at 66" (48" max.), and no grab bars provided. Explore options to reconfigure stalls to provide compliant wheelchair stall when vertical access is provided. Verify plumbing code fixture count requirements prior to finalizing design.

Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3



Item # Description Priority Probable Cost18-5 Gym

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No signage exists at doors leading to kitchen or storage. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Video Room

08b-1 Video RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Medium $220Notes: Door has knobs that require tight grasping and twisting. Provide compliant hardware.Federal Guideline: 404.2.7Provide Maneuvering Space at Door Medium $600Notes: Clearance on latch pull side of the door is 6" (18" parallel to door on latch side and 60" perpendicular req'd.) due to presence of handrail. Handrail not required due to minimal elevation change. Investigate options, which may include reversing swing of door (assumed in the cost) or modifications to the floor to provide larger level area at the door for a wheelchair user.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4

18-7 Video Room Across From Meeting Room BLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Social Room

08a-6 Social Room Door at Front Near Kitchen/GymProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is under 5 second minimum. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

08b-9 Social Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The closing speed is less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer. Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1, 404.2.9


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Medium $220Notes: 8" to glazing (10" min. smooth req'd.) on both doors. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of both doors.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08b Social Room Door to StorageProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No signage exists at double doors leading to storage room. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Medium $220Notes: 8" to glazing (10" min. smooth req'd.) on both doors. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of both doors.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Game Room

08b-5 Game Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage (2) Medium $200Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Craft Room

08b-4 Craft Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

18-3 Craft Room Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Meeting Room B

08b Meeting Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

18 Meeting Room BLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No signage exists at double doors leading to Club Room. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable CostBilliard Room

08b-2 Billiard Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

18-1 Billiard Room Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Club Room

08b-3 Club Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

18-2 Club Room Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No signage exists at double doors leading to Meeting Room B. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


General Notes: 1. The accessible parking for this facility is quite distant from the accessible entrance. Signage provided to guide persons to the accessible entrance but parking could be provided closer if the existing circle drive were modified. Explore options to improve accessibility by reducing the distance.2. This facility has issues with vertical access, as there is no elevator or other access to the upper or lower levels other than stairs. Facilities on the upper and lower floors include the main men's and women's pool locker room/showers/restrooms and restrooms at the gym. Facilities are provided on the main level that are mostly accessible. Provide vertical access when facility is altered and ensure that directional and informational signage to accessible features within the facility are provided.3. Details about compliance are only provided for areas on the main floor, with information about areas of the upper and lower floors provided for reference only. 4. Six (6) drinking fountains provided within the facility, only 3 are on the main level, with 1 each in the Men's and Women's locker/shower rooms and near the gym restrooms.5. The stairs leading to the upper and lower levels are the only vertical access to those areas for non-wheelchair patrons. The stairs and handrails should be made to comply to the greatest extent practical.6. A new Senior Center was under construction at the time of the evaluation. The information included here is for the facility as it existed in August 2018.




Provide Compliant Accessible Parking High $700Notes: No accessible spaces provided in this parking facility. Provide 2 accessible spaces, including 1 van-accessible space, with shared access aisle and signage. Parking should be located in a level area closest to the accessible route into the park. Cost assumes pavement markings and signage provided at the NW side of this lot near the pathway entrance.Federal Guideline: 208, 502

01a-1 Taylor Road On-Street Parking

Provide Compliant Pavement Markings Medium $400Notes: Access aisle is not clearly marked to discourage parking in aisle, designated with "NO PARKING" that is faint. Provide diagonal striping and/or repaint existing wording to be more visible. Provide lines to delineate accessible spaces and access aisle.Federal Guideline: 502.3.3Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $4,000Notes: Slopes of parking stalls and access aisle are over 4% (2% max.). Reconstruct area to level parking and access aisle but ensure proper drainage.Federal Guideline: 302, 502.4Accessible Routes and Curb Ramps

02-1 Curb Ramp at Taylor Road ParkingProvide Compliant Curb Ramp High $2,500Notes: Running slope of ramp is over 10% (8.33% max.) and cross slope is over 4.5% (2% max.). Side flares are over 20% (10% max.) and extend to landing/turning space. No level landing provided which should function also as TS for ROW sidewalk. Cost assumes area is reconstructed to provide compliant parallel curb ramp with TS at ROW sidewalk and match accessible route into park.Federal Guideline: 406

NOTES: 25 total parking spaces provided, including 2 designated as accessible with 1 van-accessible.

NOTES: 34 total parking spaces provided, including 0 designated as accessible. 2 accessible spaces required, including 1 van-accessible.

Elm Grove Park

City of Oak RidgeElm Grove Park 1 of 5

Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Detectable Warning High $200Notes: Existing detectable warning is not the full width of the ramp as required. Ramp is located within the ROW so detectable warning should be provided that is full width of the ramp.Federal Guideline: PROWAG R208, R305

02-2 Curb Ramp at Interior Parking LotProvide Compliant Curb Ramp High $1,500Notes: No curb ramp provided at accessible route into the park. Provide compliant curb ramp at this location near the portable toilet access point into the park.Federal Guideline: 406

04-1 Sidewalk from Parking Lot to Basketball CourtProvide Compliant Accessible Route High included aboveNotes: Fence opening at the parking lot is only 36" but 32" allowed for up to 24" depth. Fence is within area of required curb ramp. Reconstruct fence to ensure compliant width.Federal Guideline: 403.5.1Provide Compliant Accessible Route Medium $12,000Notes: The running slope is 10% near the parking lot (5% max.). Approximately 50 percent of the total length of the accessible route exceeds 2% cross slope. Reconstruct accessible route to be compliant, including necessary grading to provide compliant slopes.Federal Guideline: 403.3

04-2 Sidewalk from Basketball Court to PlaygroundProvide Compliant Accessible Route Medium $2,000Notes: The running slope is 9% near the basketball court (5% max.) and there is no connection to the court. Approximately 10 percent of the total length of the accessible route exceeds 2% cross slope, including 5 areas with vertical elevation changes due to tree roots. Reconstruct accessible route to be compliant, including connection to court and necessary grading to provide compliant slopes entire length.Federal Guideline: 403.3


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost04-3 Sidewalk from Parking Lot to Accessible Parking on Taylor Road

Provide Compliant Accessible Route Medium $12,500Notes: The running slope is 9% near the basketball court (5% max.). Approximately 50 percent of the total length of the accessible route exceeds 2% cross slope, including 5 areas with vertical elevation changes over 1/2" and area near the former driveway having severe cracking. Former driveway into the park has excessive cross slope and should be reconstructed. There is no access to the sidewalk from the parking lot due to curbing. Section of asphalt walk at NW ROW parking area is overgrown with grass and restricted to less than 48" width. Cost includes construction of a compliant curb ramp at parking lot interior drive, reconstruction of non-compliant sections of the accessible route, and edging of the grass where it has overgrown the accessible route.Federal Guideline: 303, 403, 406

04-4 Sidewalk from Accessible Parking on Taylor Road to PlaygroundProvide Compliant Accessible Route Medium $1,600Notes: The running slope is 7.5% near the curb ramp (5% max.). The section leading from the main path to the playground area and the turning space at that location exceeds 2% cross slope. There are 2 areas with vertical elevation changes due to tree roots. Reconstruct accessible route to be compliant.Federal Guideline: 403

06-1 Exterior Stairs from ROW SidewalkProvide Compliant Stairway Medium $3,500

Notes: The landings on the stairs are in poor condition and have trip hazards. The handrails are not compliant with requirement for extensions at the top and bottom. There is no connection to the interior accessible route from the stairs. Stair is usable in current condition for many persons not in a wheelchair or using some mobility devices and would be the shortest route from the ROW walk to the NE to the park interior route. If stair is to remain, provide compliant handrail extensions at the top and bottom, correct issues with landings by reconstructing them, and provide connection with compliant surface to the interior accessible route. Cost assumes these improvements and signage with visual ISA symbol and directional arrow to provide location of accessible access to park for wheelchair and other users not able to use the stair.

Federal Guideline: 206, 304.2, 403, 505.10Facility Amenities

07-1 Play Area Drinking FountainProvide Compliant Drinking Fountain N/A N/ANotes: Park includes 2 drinking fountains, so 1 each must meet requirements for wheelchair and standing user. This fountain meets wheelchair height of 36" max. bubbler, knee and toe space, and clear spaces.Federal Guideline: 211, 306, 602

NOTES: Though portions of this accessible route are within the ROW, to ensure the cost to provide access is documented the ROW walk in this section is included below.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost07-2 Drinking Fountain in Lawn Area

Provide Compliant Drinking Fountain Medium $800Notes: The bubbler height of 37" for this fountain does not meet the requirements for either a wheelchair or standing user and fountain is not located on an accessible route. Least costly option would be to move this fountain to the area of the playground and ensure at installation a bubbler height of 38-43". Cost assumes reuse of this fountain.Federal Guideline: 211, 306, 602

22-1 Site FurnitureProvide Compliant Bench Seating Area Medium $700

Notes: There are 7 benches within the park, all located within lawn areas. This does not provide a compliant surface for a wheelchair to be positioned adjacent to a companion on the bench. Relocate a min. of 1 bench or provide connection from accessible route to provide clear space outside of walkway for wheelchair. Best location(s) would be somewhere along the walk loop and at the playground. Cost assumes connection made to bench at playground sidewalk spur. Consider additional locations along main pathway at similar cost.

Federal Guideline: 903.2, 1011.2.1Provide Access to Trash Containers Medium $400Notes: There are 3 trash containers in the park, all located within lawn areas. Existing containers have lids that may be difficult for someone with an upper body mobility impairment to operate. Provide a new trash container located along the existing accessible route that has compliant opening device.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 308.3.2, 1011.3

24-1 Basketball CourtProvide Access to Area of Sports Activity High included aboveNotes: There is no connection to the basketball court. Provide a compliant connection to the boundary of the court.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403

25-1 PlaygroundProvide Compliant Access to Play Elements High $4,500Notes: Compliant accessible route not provided to most ground play elements. Existing surface is wood fiber, which requires extensive maintenance to be compliant. Provide accessible surface to swings, to ground play items, and from end of slides.Federal Guideline: 240.2.1, 240.2.1.1



Item # Description Priority Probable CostGeneral Notes: 1. Parking at this site is provided by a dedicated lot outside the ROW, as well as parking within the ROW immediately adjacent to the park. This parking is clearly provided for the park, particularly since the on-street parking provides the best access to the playground. Parking is considered to be 1 facility for the non-ROW lot and ROW as a separate facility based on characteristics.2. Note that the existing portable toilets are not accessible. Since they are not a "permanent" fixture they are not required to be accessible but consider providing a portable toilet that is wheelchair accessible at all locations that portable toilets are provided unless accessible restrooms are provided.3. Portions of surfacing at play structure is compliant poured in-place (PIP) rubber, with remainder being engineered wood fiber (EWF). EWF complies with surfacing requirements only with regular maintenance. Consider providing additional PIP surfacing to provide access to ground play elements and the end of slides outside the fall zone to ensure compliance also with fall protection standards. Cost assumes compliant surfacing is provided, cost may vary due to unknown subsurface preparation needed.




Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Low $1,500

Notes: Painted access aisle at van-accessible space is not 8' min. width but is adjacent to an area marked on pavement with "NO PARKING". Provide consistent pavement markings for no parking areas, including access aisles. Typically angled striping is used. Van accessible parking space/aisle has excessive slopes up to 3.4% (2% max.). Provide level area as required.Federal Guideline: 302, 502

22-1 Site FurnitureRelocate Historical Marker or Provide Access Medium $150Notes: The Elza Gate historical marker is located in lawn area of traffic island. Accessibility and safety for all could be accomplished by moving the marker to location at the greenway. If this is not possible consider providing curb ramp and sidewalk in traffic island and rotate sign as needed to face the sidewalk level clear space. Cost assumes sign can be moved. Federal Guideline: 1011.2, 1011.4.2Provide Access to Trash Containers Medium $400Notes: Existing containers have lids that may be difficult for someone with an upper body mobility impairment to operate. Provide a new trash container located along the existing accessible route that has compliant opening device.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 308.3.2, 1011.3


Elza Gate Park

NOTE: 18 total parking spaces provided, including 2 marked as accessible, with 1 van-accessible. 1 van-accessible space required.

General Notes: 1. This park includes only parking for access to the adjacent greenway and a historical marker sign.

City of Oak RidgeElza Gate Park Page 1 of 1


Exterior Item # Description Priority Probable Cost01a Parking Lot

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Low $1,500Notes: Van accessible parking space/aisle has excessive slopes up to 4-6% (2% max.). Pavement markings at access aisle are very faded and need to be refreshed. Provide level area as required and pavement markings.Federal Guideline: 302, 502

Interior08a-1 Side Entrance to Kitchen/Dining Room

Provide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Lock requires grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Medium $110Notes: Distance to glazing only 7-1/2" from bottom (10" min. smooth req'd.) on door. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08a Rear Man Door in Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08a Front EntranceProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Medium $110Notes: Distance to glazing only 6" from bottom (10" min. smooth req'd.) on door. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

NOTE: 8 total parking spaces provided, including 1 marked as van-accessible. 1 van-accessible space required.

Fire Station

#1

City of Oak RidgeFire Station 1 1 of 7

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost08a Rear Entry into Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08a Rear Entry into Work RoomProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08a Rear Entry into Hose TowerProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08b-1 Door From Kitchen/Dining to Garage Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b-2 Door From Apparatus Bay to Day RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Low TBDNotes: There is only 6" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.). Consider options when altered, which may include reversing the door swing into the day room.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08b-3 Door From Kitchen/Dining to Day RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Doorway Medium $1,200Notes: Clear width of door is only 30" (32" min.). Provide compliant door, cost assumes enlarging the doorway and installation of 36" standard door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.3Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Door hardware is round knob that require grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost08b-4 Door To Weight Room at Front of Apparatus Bay

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b-5 Door To Weight Room at Rear of Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Threshold Medium $150Notes: Existing threshold is 1" high (1/2" max.). Federal Guideline: 404.2.5

08b Utility Room Door to Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b Utility Room Door to Work RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b Work Room Door to Furnace RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign at the door.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b Watch Office Door to Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

15-1 Restroom with ShowersNOTE: Only 1 room with shower facilities is provided. Room contains 2 showers, 2 urinals, 2 toilets, and 2 sinks. Unisex facilities are permitted to only have 1 toilet with urinal and 2 without urinals, and 1 shower per 213.2.1. This room is clearly not compliant and intended for use by firefighters. Existing layout would exclude female firefighters, though the door does have a latch.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Signage Medium $400Notes: No signage provided. Provide sign with visual and tactile letters, and Braille with the ISA on the latch wall. Include similar signage for shower facility at this door also.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Doorway Medium $1,600Notes: Clear width of door is only 25" (32" min.). Provide compliant door, cost assumes enlarging the doorway and installation of 36" standard door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.3Provide Insulation Below Sinks Low $220Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 41" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 57" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 53" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Urinal Medium $450Notes: The top of the lip on the urinal is at 20" high (17" max.).Federal Guideline: 605.2Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall Low TBDNotes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 48" (60" min.), stall door has no handle on the outside and doors swing into the stall (outswinging req'd.), and no grab bars provided. Explore options to provide compliant stall. Verify plumbing code fixture count requirements prior to finalizing design. Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4, 604.3

16-1 Apparatus Bay Unisex Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No signage provided. Provide sign with visual and tactile letters, and Braille without the ISA symbol (until it complies) on the latch wall.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

NOTE: This restroom is located in the apparatus bay and assumed to be only for firefighters. It is not currently accessible but could be made so reasonably easily. Would seem to be more sensible to have this restroom accessed from the living area since there is no restroom facility in that part of the building. Information provided below for reference only unless cost and priority is provided.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Doorway N/A N/ANotes: Clear width of door is only 25" (32" min.). Provide compliant door, cost assumes enlarging the doorway and installation of 36" standard door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.3Provide Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 41" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser N/A N/ANotes: The dispenser is located at 62" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor N/A N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 53" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Lower Electrical Outlet N/A N/ANotes: Electrical outlet at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Lowest cost option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Clear Space at Toilet N/A N/ANotes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is less than 60" min. req'd. Explore options, which can include relocating sink.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Provide Compliant Grab Bars N/A N/ANotes: Grab bars required on the rear and side wall, none provided.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1.5, 609

17-1 Shower (Typical of 2)Relocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hooks at above 56" ht. (15"-48" req'd.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4Provide Compliant Shower Low TBDNotes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Existing space has 2 non-compliant showers that are not close to the dimensional and other requirements for either a transfer or roll-in shower. Existing shower has issues with the dimensions, threshold, controls, shower head, lack of grab bars, lack of seat (for transfer), etc. Explore options, including separation of facilities for each gender. Cost is noted as "To Be Determined" due to need for further investigation of options for renovations.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost18-1 Kitchen/Dining Room

Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Lower Telephone Low $50Notes: Operable parts of the telephone on the wall is at 60" (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of door to utility room.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

18-2 Day Room Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door to Watch Office. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Wheelchair Access and Clear Space Low N/ANotes: There is no clear space for a wheelchair and no access to the television. Furniture can be rearranged if needed.Federal Guideline: 308.2.1

18-3 Weight Room Provide Compliant Signage Medium $700Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required at doors to 2 offices, 2 storage rooms, dormitory, and equipment room.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $440Notes: Door hardware at both the equipment room and front storage room is round knob that requires grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308

35a-1 Breakroom Reposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim is 36" high (34" max. req'd). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Kitchen with oven/range is required to have knee space below the sink.Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReplace Range/Oven Medium $1,000Notes: Controls must be operable without reaching over burners. Purchase new range/oven that has all controls on front panel.Federal Guideline: 804.6.4, 804.6.5.3


General Notes: 1. This facility has a single bathing/shower/restroom intended for use by multiple persons. ADASAD 213.2.1 limits the number of fixtures in a single user facility, beyond which more than 1 must be provided. The existing configuration would appear to preclude women firefighters from being assigned to this location. This situation should be investigated further and the existing be designated for "MEN" and a new facility for "WOMEN" provided with accessible toilet and shower facilities. Note also that there is a rear entry door from the exterior directly into the restroom, which could cause issues with different gender firefighters if the door is not exclusively an emergency exit door.



Exterior Item # Description Priority Probable Cost02-1 Curb Ramp

Provide Compliant Curb Ramp Low $400Notes: Landing at top of curb ramp is 3.1% (2% max.). Correct when sidewalks on the site are reconstructed.Federal Guideline: 406

Interior08a-1 Side Entrance to Kitchen/Dining Room

Provide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Lock requires grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7

08a Rear Man Door in Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08a Front EntranceProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Medium $110Notes: Distance to glazing only 6" from bottom (10" min. smooth req'd.) on door. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08a Rear Entry into RestroomProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

Fire Station #2


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost08a Rear Entry into Work Room

Provide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08a Rear Entry into Hose TowerProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08b-1 Door From Kitchen/Dining to Garage Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Low $1,200Notes: There is only 10" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.). Consider options when altered, which will likely need to include moving the door opening to the side to provide clear space. Cost assumes relocation.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08b-2 Door From Apparatus Bay to Day RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Low $1,200Notes: There is only 6" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.). Consider options when altered, which will likely need to include moving the door opening to the side to provide clear space. Cost assumes relocation.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08b-3 Door From Kitchen/Dining to Day RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Doorway Medium $1,200Notes: Clear width of door is only 30" (32" min.). Provide compliant door, cost assumes enlarging the doorway and installation of 36" standard door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.3


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Door hardware is round knob that require grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7

08b-4 Door To Weight Room at Front of Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b-5 Door To Weight Room at Rear of Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Threshold Medium $150Notes: Existing threshold is 1" high (1/2" max.). Federal Guideline: 404.2.5

08b Utility Room Door to Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b Utility Room Door to Work RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b Work Room Door to Furnace RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign at the door.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b Watch Office Door to Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost15-1 Restroom with Showers

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $400Notes: No signage provided. Provide sign with visual and tactile letters, and Braille with the ISA on the latch wall. Include similar signage for shower facility at this door also.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Doorway Medium $1,600Notes: Clear width of door is only 25" (32" min.). Provide compliant door, cost assumes enlarging the doorway and installation of 36" standard door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.3Provide Insulation Below Sinks Low $220Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 54" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Reposition Urinal Medium $450Notes: The top of the lip on the urinal is at 20" high (17" max.).Federal Guideline: 605.2Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall Low TBD

Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 48" (60" min.), stall doors do not have handles on both sides and doors swing into the stall (outswinging req'd.), and no grab bars provided. Explore options to provide compliant stall. Verify plumbing code fixture count requirements prior to finalizing design.

Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4, 604.316-1 Apparatus Bay Unisex Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Signage provided is visual text "RESTROOM" located on the door with no closer. Provide sign with visual and tactile letters, and Braille without the ISA symbol (until it complies) on the latch wall.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

NOTE: Only 1 room with shower facilities is provided. Room contains 2 showers, 2 urinals, 2 toilets, and 2 sinks. Unisex facilities are permitted to only have 1 toilet with urinal and 2 without urinals, and 1 shower per 213.2.1. This room is clearly not compliant and intended for use by firefighters. Existing layout would exclude female firefighters, though the door does have a latch.

NOTE: This restroom is located in the apparatus bay and assumed to be only for firefighters. It is not currently accessible but could be made so reasonably easily. Would seem to be more sensible to have this restroom accessed from the living area since there is no restroom facility in that part of the building. Information provided below for reference only unless cost and priority is provided.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Doorway N/A N/ANotes: Clear width of door is only 25" (32" min.). Provide compliant door, cost assumes enlarging the doorway and installation of 36" standard door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.3Provide Compliant Door Hardware N/A N/ANotes: Door hardware is round knob that requires grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Provide Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 42" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser N/A N/ANotes: The dispenser is located at 57" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Electrical Outlet N/A N/ANotes: Electrical outlet at 49" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Lowest cost option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Clear Space at Toilet N/A N/ANotes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is less than 60" min. req'd. Explore options, which can include relocating sink.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Provide Compliant Grab Bars N/A N/ANotes: Grab bars required on the rear and side wall, none provided.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1.5, 609

17-1 Shower (Typical of 2)Relocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hooks at 56" ht. (15"-48" req'd.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4Provide Compliant Shower Low TBDNotes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Existing space has 2 non-compliant showers that are not close to the dimensional and other requirements for either a transfer or roll-in shower. Existing shower has issues with the dimensions, threshold, controls, shower head, lack of grab bars, lack of seat (for transfer), etc. Explore options, including separation of facilities for each gender. Cost is noted as "To Be Determined" due to need for further investigation of options for renovations.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost18-1 Kitchen/Dining Room

Lower Telephone Low $50Notes: Operable parts of the telephone on the wall is at 60" (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of door to utility room.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of door to utility room.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

18-2 Day Room Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door to Watch Office. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Wheelchair Access and Clear Space Low N/ANotes: There is no clear space for a wheelchair and no access to the television. Furniture can be rearranged if needed.Federal Guideline: 308.2.1

18-3 Weight Room Provide Compliant Signage Medium $600Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required at doors to 2 offices, storage room, dormitory, and equipment room.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Door hardware at the equipment room is round knob that requires grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost35a-1 Kitchen/Dining Room

Provide Knee Space Below Sink Low $750Notes: Kitchen with oven/range is required to have 27" min. knee space below the sink.Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3Reposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlet is mounted at 51" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Replace Range/Oven Medium $1,000Notes: Controls must be operable without reaching over burners. Purchase new range/oven that has all controls on front panel.Federal Guideline: 804.6.4, 804.6.5.3


General Notes: 1. This facility has a single bathing/shower/restroom intended for use by multiple persons. ADASAD 213.2.1 limits the number of fixtures in a single user facility, beyond which more than 1 must be provided. The existing configuration would appear to preclude women firefighters from being assigned to this location. This situation should be investigated further and the existing be designated for "MEN" and a new facility for "WOMEN" provided with accessible toilet and shower facilities. Note also that there is a rear entry door from the exterior directly into the restroom, which could cause issues with different gender firefighters if the door is not exclusively an emergency exit door.



Exterior Item # Description Priority Probable Cost01a Parking Lot

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Low $1,500Notes: Van accessible parking space/aisle has excessive slopes up to 3.0% (2% max.). Access aisle for van space is only 61" (96" min.). Provide level area as required with proper dimensions and pavement markings.Federal Guideline: 302, 502Provide Bumper Blocks Medium $300Notes: Accessible route from accessible parking to public entry door can be blocked by vehicles overhanging the sidewalk. Provide bumper blocks at 3 total spaces along the accessible route between the access aisle the door.Federal Guideline: 502.3, 502.7

04 Accessible Route to Front EntranceProvide Compliant Accessible Route High $800Notes: Areas along the accessible route have cross slope of up to 3.9% (2% max.), particularly at the curb ramp.Federal Guideline: 403.5.1

InteriorGeneral Circulation Areas/Corridors

08b-2 Door to Apparatus Bay at Rooms 114/117Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign at the door within the hallway to identify the "Apparatus Bay".Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Door hardware is round knob that require grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Provide Maneuvering Space on Both Sides of Door Low TBDNotes: There is only 8" clear space parallel to the door on the both sides (18" min. req'd. on pull side, 12" on push side). No option exists with current layout to provide compliance due to narrow corridor. Cost TBD due to need for further investigation of options.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

Fire Station #3

NOTE: 24 total parking spaces provided, including 1 marked as van-accessible. 1 van-accessible space required.

City of Oak RidgeFire Station 3 Page 1 of 12

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost08b-5 Apparatus Bay Door to Corridor 104

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign at the door within the hallway to identify the "Apparatus Bay".Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Door hardware is round knob that require grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Provide Maneuvering Space on Both Sides of Door Low TBDNotes: There is only 8" clear space parallel to the door on the both sides (18" min. req'd. on pull side, 12" on push side). No option exists with current layout to provide compliance due to narrow corridor. Cost TBD due to need for further investigation of options.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08b-6 Door to Apparatus Bay at Rooms 118/122Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign at the door within the hallway to identify the "Apparatus Bay". Existing signage on apparatus bay side for "Fire Department Personnel Only" can remain.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Maneuvering Space on Both Sides of Door Low TBDNotes: There is only 6" clear space parallel to the door on the both sides (18" min. req'd. on pull side, 12" on push side). No option exists with current layout to provide compliance due to narrow corridor. Cost TBD due to need for further investigation of options.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

09-1 Training Room Area Corridor Provide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at rear exit door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: No signs or signs not compliant at storage, electrical, and mechanical rooms. Provide signage with visual and tactile letters and Braille in compliant location on latch side wall.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost09 Officer Quarters Corridor

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No compliant sign present at either officer quarters. Provide signage with visual and tactile letters and Braille in compliant location on latch side wall.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72100 Watch Operations Office

08a-2 Public Front Entrance DoorProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Door closes in less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device Low $400Notes: Device at 50" (over 48" max ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

08b Door to/from Day Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b Door to/from Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703101 Day Room

08b-3 101 Door to Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign on both sides of the door describing the space beyond.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Door closes in less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Door hardware is round knob that require grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Provide Maneuvering Space on Both Sides of Door Low TBDNotes: There is only 8" clear space parallel to the door on both sides (18" min. req'd. on pull side, 12" on push side). No option exists with current layout to provide compliance due to narrow corridor. Cost TBD due to need for further investigation of options.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Modify Vision Panel Low $450Notes: Vision panel below 66" is at 48" ht. (43" max.).Federal Guideline: 404.2.11

18-2 101 Day Room Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308102 Dining Room

08a-1 Side Entrance to Dining RoomProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Door hardware is round knob that require grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device Low $400Notes: Device at 50" (over 48" max ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

08b-4 102 Door From Corridor 104Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on wall adjacent to door. Provide compliant sign at the door within the hallway to identify the "Dining Room".Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Door hardware is round knob that require grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Provide Maneuvering Space on Push Side of Door Low TBDNotes: There is only 8" clear space parallel to the door on the push side (12" req'd. at doors with closer and latch). Options include removal of closer and/or latch.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost18-3 102 Dining Room

Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 53" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308103 Kitchen

35a-1 103 Kitchen Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 53" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim is 36" high (34" max. req'd). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Kitchen with oven/range is required to have knee space below the sink.Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3105 Training Room

08a Emergency Exit DoorProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device Low $400Notes: Device at 50" (over 48" max ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

08b-1 105 DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Low $600

Notes: There is only 8" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.). Consider options when altered, which will likely need to include reversing the door swing and removing the door latch or closer (12" clear space still required for doors with a closer and a latch on the push side). Cost assumes door is reversed to swing into the room and closer is removed.

Federal Guideline: 404.2.1008b Training Room Storage Door

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on wall adjacent to door. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost18-1 105 Training Room

Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308107 Unisex Restroom

16-1 107 Unisex RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Signage provided is visual text "RESTROOM" and ISA located on the door which opens out (only allowed on doors that open into the room and have a closer). Provide sign with visual and tactile letters, and Braille with the ISA symbol on the latch wall.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 41" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 53" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Clear Width Adjacent to Toilet Medium $1,400NOTE: Sink is located within 39" of toilet wall (60" clearance req'd.). Explore option of recessing sink into adjacent storage room in training room. Cost assumes sink is recessed.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Provide Compliant Grab Bar Medium $500Notes: Rear grab bar is only 24" long (36" min.). Provide a compliant grab bar installed properly.Federal Guideline: 604.5Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost113 Apparatus Bay

07-1 Drinking Fountain in Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Medium $2,000Notes: Single fountain provided at this location, bubbler height of 43" provides accessibility to standing users (36" max.). If 1 fountain is provided, 2 must be provided with 1 each providing compliance for standing user and wheelchair user (36" max. bubbler with knee space). Determine options to provide wheelchair drinking fountain within this facility. Cost assumes installation of single fountain in public entry area that meets wheelchair access requirements.Federal Guideline: 211, 602

08a Workshop Exterior Exit DoorProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

18 Apparatus BayProvide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: All permanent spaces require signage, provide at workshops and storage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on wall adjacent to door. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703117 Toilet/Shower Room 1

15-1 117 Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $400Notes: No signage provided. Provide sign with visual and tactile letters, and Braille with the ISA on the latch wall. Include similar signage for shower facility at this door also.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Door hardware is round knob that require grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Low $600Notes: There is only 12" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.). Consider options when altered, which will likely need to include reversing the door swing direction into the room. Cost assumes door swing is reversed.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

NOTE: There are 2 different rooms with restroom and shower facilities. 117 is for officers and 118 for firefighters. Room 118 contains 2 showers, 2 toilets, and 2 sinks. Unisex facilities are permitted to only have 1 toilet with urinal and 2 without urinals, and 1 shower per 213.2.1. Room 117 should be considered as unisex since it has only 1 of each fixture type and be permitted for use by all officers and female firefighters as well as the disabled, with Room 118 being dedicated to male firefighters.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 43" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 53" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall Low $2,500Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 36" (60" min.), stall doors do not have handles on outside and doors swing into the stall (outswinging req'd.), toilet flush control is on the wall side, and no grab bars provided. Explore options to provide compliant stall. Likely best option for unisex restroom would be to remove partitions, modify the sink area to provide 60" distance from toilet wall to sink, modify toilet tank to provide flush control on the open side, and installation of compliant grab bars. Cost assumes these improvements.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72

17-1 117 ShowersRelocate Clothing Hook Low $50Notes: Hooks at 56" ht. (15"-48" req'd.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4Provide Compliant Shower Head Low $50Notes: Shower is required to provide a removable shower head with 59" min. flexible hose.Federal Guideline: 608.6Provide Clear Space at Shower Entry Low $4,000Notes: Existing clear space at shower is only 32" wide (48" min. req'd.). Remove block wall between existing shower and toilet stall.Federal Guideline: 608.2Provide Compliant Threshold Low included aboveNotes: Threshold is 6" (1/2" high max.).Federal Guideline: 608.7


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Shower Low included above

Notes: Existing shower compartment is 32"x32" (transfer shower is required to be 36"x36"), has no grab bars, and no seat. Explore options to provide compliant shower compartment, which will likely require removal of the existing wall between the existing shower and toilet and install pre-fabricated transfer shower. Cost assumes wall is removed and new shower provided.

Federal Guideline: 608Provide Compliant Bench Medium $600Notes: A bench is required with a surface located at 17"-19" above the floor and dimensions of 42" long x 20"min.-24"max. in width. Bench must be connected to a wall or have a back rest. Clear floor space of 30" x 48" is req'd. at the end of bench seat and parallel. No compliant bench present. Cost assumes new compliant bench provided.Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903.4, 903.5118 Toilet/Shower Room 2

15-2 118 Men's Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $600Notes: Signage provided on the door is visual text "RESTROOM". Provide sign with visual and tactile letters, and Braille on the latch wall. Include similar signage for shower facility at this door also. Ensure neither sign includes the ISA and also provide a directional sign indicating the location of the accessible restroom and shower 117.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 216.8, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware N/A N/ANotes: Door hardware is round knob that require grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door N/A N/ANotes: There is only 10" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.). Consider options when altered, which will likely need to include reversing the door swing direction into the room. Cost assumes door swing is reversed.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Provide Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5

NOTE: There are 2 different rooms with restroom and shower facilities. 117 is for officers and 118 for firefighters. Room 118 contains 2 showers, 2 toilets, and 2 sinks. Unisex facilities are permitted to only have 1 toilet with urinal and 2 without urinals, and 1 shower per 213.2.1. Room 117 should be considered as unisex since it has only 1 of each fixture type and be permitted for use by all officers and female firefighters as well as the disabled, with Room 118 being dedicated to male firefighters. Items noted below for information only unless cost and priority provided.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Mirror N/A N/ANotes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 43" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 51" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Modify Stall Hardware N/A N/ANotes: Handle not provided on outside of stall door (handles req'd. on both sides). Federal Guideline: 604.8Provide Compliant Wheelchair Stall N/A N/ANotes: No accessible stall present. Stall door width is 30" (32" min.), width is 36" (60" min.), stall doors do not have handles on outside and doors swing into the stall (outswinging req'd.), and no grab bars provided. Explore options to provide compliant stall. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72

17-2 Typical ShowersRelocate Clothing Hook N/A N/ANotes: Hooks at 56" ht. (15"-48" req'd.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4Provide Compliant Shower Head N/A N/ANotes: Shower is required to provide a removable shower head with 59" min. flexible hose.Federal Guideline: 608.6Provide Clear Space at Shower Entry N/A N/ANotes: Existing clear space at shower is only 32" wide (48" min. req'd.). Remove block wall between existing shower and toilet stall.Federal Guideline: 608.2Provide Compliant Threshold N/A N/ANotes: Threshold is 6" (1/2" high max.).Federal Guideline: 608.7Provide Compliant Shower N/A N/A

Notes: Existing shower compartment is 32"x32" (transfer shower is required to be 36"x36"), has no grab bars, and no seat. Explore options to provide compliant shower compartment, which will likely require removal of the existing wall between the existing shower and toilet and install pre-fabricated transfer shower. Cost assumes wall is removed and new shower provided.

Federal Guideline: 608


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Accessible Lockers N/A N/ANotes: 9 lockers present, 5% (1) is required to be accessible. Federal Guideline: 225.2.1, 308, 811.3Provide Compliant Bench N/A N/ANotes: A bench is required with a surface located at 17"-19" above the floor and dimensions of 42" long x 20"min.-24"max. in width. Bench must be connected to a wall or have a back rest. Clear floor space of 30" x 48" is req'd. at the end of bench seat and parallel. No compliant bench present. Cost assumes new compliant bench provided.Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903.4, 903.5119 Dormitory

08b-7 Room 119 Door to DormitoryProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on wall adjacent to door. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Low TBDNotes: There is only 6" clear space parallel to the door on pull side (18" min. req'd.). No option exists with current layout to provide compliance due to narrow corridor. Cost TBD due to need for further investigation of options.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72122 Decontamination Room

08a Exterior DoorProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at rear exit door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08b 122 DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: All permanent spaces require signage. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on wall adjacent to door. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Weight Room

08a-3 Weight Room Door (Behind Station)Provide Compliant Accessible Route High $3,500Notes: Sidewalk from the parking lot to the entry door stoop is over 20% (5% max., 8.33% max. running slope allowed with handrails). Provide compliant accessible route with longer run walks that dogleg or switchback to avoid handrail requirement if over 5% running slope.Federal Guideline: 403.5.1


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign at this door. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Door closes in less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

18-5 Weight RoomLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 53" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308


General Notes: 1. The weight room at the rear of the building has a separate entrance and considered a separate building, with information provided here for reference. Access to the facility is via a very steep sidewalk at the parking lot that is not accessible. It is assumed that only firefighters use this facility but it is a common use area that is required to be accessible as noted above.2. This facility has 2 bathing/shower/restrooms, one that is truly a single-user with 1 toilet, sink, and shower and the other with 2 of each fixture type. ADASAD 213.2.1 limits the number of fixtures in a single user facility, beyond which more than 1 must be provided. The existing configuration would appear to preclude women firefighters from being assigned to this location unless they were an officer. It is suggested above that the Room 117 be identified as unisex and for use by officers, regardless of gender, female firefighters, and disabled persons. Room 118 would then be identified for "MEN" since it cannot be deemed as unisex due to number of fixtures and remain non-accessible due to assumed fixture count needs. An additional toilet room that is unisex is also available near the training room 105.3. This facility has several rooms with visual fire alarms, indicating the presence of an alarm system. There are a number of common use and circulation areas that do not have visual fire alarms as required in facilities with a fire alarm system in place.



Exterior Item # Description Priority Probable Cost

Facility Total: $0

Fire Station #4

General Notes:

NOTE: This facility was undergoing significant interior alterations at the time of the evaluation. No detailed review was able to be completed due to unknown details about the areas under renovation or that would be renovated at a later date.


Data collected February 2019

The Golf ClubExterior


Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Space Medium $15,000Notes: Slopes at accessible parking area up to 3.5% (2% max.). Cost is for leveling of pavement and restriping within this area to provide min. 5 accessible spaces, including 1 compliant van-accessible, with shared access aisles and signage.Federal Guideline: 208.3, 302, 502Accessible Routes and Curb Ramps

02 Curb RampProvide Compliant Ramp Medium included above

Notes: There is a 1" lip on the ramp at the parking access aisle (1/2" max.). Correct when parking area is resurfaced. Cost assumes access aisle elevation is brought up to ramp to match. In the interim this could be grinded down if timeline for parking lot reconstruction is more than a few years off.

Federal Guideline: 30304 Accessible Routes

Provide Accessible Route to Building Entrance Medium $3,000Notes: Curb ramp at the drop-off area, which is between accessible parking and the building entrance, has a cross slope of over 2%. Consider reconstructing the ramp in an alternate location that provides a parallel ramp access from the drop-off to the side of the building and the front entrance and does not result in a non-compliant cross slope along the accessible route. Cost assumes reconstruction of existing ramp and new parallel ramp slightly to the SE.Federal Guideline: 403, 406

126 total parking spaces provided, including 5 designated as accessible, 1 with van accessible signage. 5 accessible spaces required, including 1 van space.

CentennialGolf

Course

City of Oak RidgeCentennial Golf Course Page 1 of 13


InteriorCommon Circulation Areas

08a-1 Front Entry DoorsProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: The lock is located at 51" height (48" max.). Replace lock.Federal Guideline: 308, 309.4, 404.2.7Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Door closes in less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

08a-2 Rear Exit in Bar Area (3 sets of doors)Provide Means of Egress Signage High $300Notes: No egress sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: The lock is located at 51-1/2" height and the deadbolts at the top of the door are at 78" (48" max.). Replace lock and explore options for deadbolts.Federal Guideline: 308, 309.4, 404.2.7Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Door closes in less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Medium $220Notes: Distance to glazing only 9" from bottom (10" min. smooth req'd.) on door. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of both doors.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08a-3 Side Exit in Bar AreaProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: No egress sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: The lock is located at 51" (48" max.). Replace lock.Federal Guideline: 308, 309.4, 404.2.7Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Door closes in less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

08a-4 Rear Exits in Pro ShopNOTE: The rear doors in the pro shop do not appear to be used as they are obstructed by equipment. No detailed evaluation done of the rear doors.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost08a-5 Side Exit in Pro Shop

Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: The lock is located at 50-1/2" (48" max.). Replace lock.Federal Guideline: 308, 309.4, 404.2.7Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Door closes in less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

08a Kitchen Area Exit DoorProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

15-1 Men’s RestroomAdjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Door closes in less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Low $600Notes: There is only 16-3/4" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.). Least costly option would be to reverse the door to swing into the room. Cost assumes door is reversed.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 42-3/4" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 54" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 49-1/2" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Relocate Clothing Hook Low $50Notes: Hooks outside of stall at bench at 69-1/2" ht. (15"-48" req'd.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4Reposition Urinal Medium $450Notes: The top of the lip on the urinal is at 20" high (17" max.). Reposition 1 urinal to compliant height.Federal Guideline: 605.2


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handle provided on the inside of the wheelchair stall door, required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Reconfigure Wheelchair Stall Partitions High $800Notes: The opening for the wheelchair stall is located on the same wall as the toilet (req'd. to be offset) and the opening to the door is 5-1/4" from the wall (4" max.). Reconfigure stall partitions to move door to the opposite wall of the stall and 4" max from the wall.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1.2Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted with centerline at 13-1/2" in front of toilet (7-9" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Grab Bars Medium $750Notes: Both grab bars have a top gripping surface at 37" height (33-36" req'd.). Rear grab bar is only 24" long (36" min.). Provide new rear grab bar and install both bars at compliant height and location relative to walls and toilet centerline.Federal Guideline: 604.5, 609.4

15-2 Women’s RestroomAdjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Door closes in less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Low $600Notes: There is only 17" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.). Least costly option would be to reverse the door to swing into the room. Cost assumes door is reversed.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 43-3/4" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 60" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 50" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Relocate Clothing Hook Low $50Notes: Hooks outside of stall at bench at 69-1/2" ht. (15"-48" req'd.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handle provided on the inside of the wheelchair stall door, required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted with centerline at 12-1/2" in front of toilet (7-9" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Grab Bars Medium $750Notes: Both grab bars have a top gripping surface at 36-3/4" height (33-36" req'd.). Rear grab bar is only 24" long (36" min.). Provide new rear grab bar and install both bars at compliant height and location relative to walls and toilet centerline.Federal Guideline: 604.5, 609.4

18-1 Entry Hallway and Bar AreaProvide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $900Notes: Service counter at the bar is at 43” height (36" max. req'd. for verbal interaction). Provide min. 36" wide section of service counter at 36" max. height.Federal Guideline: 227.3, 904.5Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 50-1/2" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Accessible Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Electrical outlets in the hallway especially are at least partially blocked, 30"x48" min. clear space required to at least 1 in each area. Lowest cost option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Compliant Wall Signage Low $300Notes: Several permanent spaces lack a sign outside the door (kitchen and the work spaces within). Provide compliant signs for all permanent spaces.Federal Guideline: 703Protect/Reposition Protruding Objects Low $100Notes: The satellite television shelf on the wall near the rear door and pro shop protrudes 16" at 62-1/4" (4" max. between 27-80"). Provide permanent cane-detectable object below.Federal Guideline: 307.2Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device Low $1,200Notes: Three devices in this area at 50-1/2" (over 48" max ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address at all locations. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost18-2 Pro Shop

Provide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $900Notes: Service counter is at 41-1/2” height (36" max. req'd. for verbal interaction). Provide min. 36" wide section of service counter at 36" max. height.Federal Guideline: 227.3, 904.5Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 50-1/2" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Accessible Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Electrical outlets in the hallway especially are at least partially blocked, 30"x48" min. clear space required to at least 1 in each area. Lowest cost option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Compliant Wall Signage Low $100Notes: Office near side exit door lacks a sign. Provide compliant signs for all permanent spaces.Federal Guideline: 703Protect/Reposition Protruding Objects Low $100Notes: The AED unit on the wall near the side exit door protrudes 8-1/2" at 60" (4" max. between 27-80"). Provide permanent cane-detectable object below.Federal Guideline: 307.2Lower Fire Alarm Activation Device Low $400

Notes: Device in this area at 50-1/2" (over 48" max ht.). This is compliant with 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG but life safety item to address at all locations.

Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308.2-3

Golf AcademyExterior

Accessible Routes and Curb Ramps02 Curb Ramp

Provide Compliant Ramp Medium $200Notes: There is a 1/2" lip on the ramp at the parking access aisle but not beveled (1/2" max. if beveled). Cost assumes concrete is grinded to either 1/4" or less elevation change or existing 1/2" lip is properly beveled.Federal Guideline: 303


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost06 Stairs to Driving Range

Provide Compliant Handrails Low $800Notes: The handrails do not project 1-1/2" min. from the adjacent wall. Least cost option would be to remove and remount existing handrail with a shim between the existing support and the handrail support to provide min. 1-1/2" width. Cost assumes shim board placed at all main handrail supports and remounting.Federal Guideline: 505.5

Interior08a-6 Main Side Entrance

Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: The lock required grasping and twisting motion to operate. Replace lock.Federal Guideline: 308, 309.4, 404.2.7

16-4 Men's RestroomProvide Compliant Signage High $50Notes: Sign provided is located on the door and at 63-1/4" height to bottom of tactile letters. Relocate sign to the latch side wall (not allowed on a door that opens out) and with bottom of the tactile letters "MEN" between 48-60" high.Federal Guideline: 216, 703Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and hot water supply. Provide insulation of all piping.Federal Guideline: 606.5Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 52-1/2" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Clear Space at Toilet Medium $1,500Notes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is only 38" (60" min. req'd.). Explore options, which can include relocating sink or recessing it into adjacent space if available. Cost is placeholder and will vary depending on options available.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted with centerline behind front of toilet (7"-9" to centerline in front of toilet req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.7


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Grab Bars Low $750Notes: Grab bars provided only on the side (required on side and rear wall). Side grab bar extends only 46-1/2" from rear wall (54" min.). Provide compliant grab bars on the side and rear walls in compliant location.Federal Guideline: 604.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted within 12" above the location of the missing rear grab bar and will be within clear space when bar is installed.Federal Guideline: 609.4

16-5 Women's RestroomProvide Compliant Signage High $50Notes: Sign provided is located on the door and at 63-1/2" height to bottom of tactile letters. Relocate sign to the latch side wall (not allowed on a door that opens out) and with bottom of the tactile letters "MEN" between 48-60" high.Federal Guideline: 216, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Low $220Notes: Operable parts (lock) of door requires grasping and twisting. Provide compliant hardware .Federal Guideline: 404.2.7, 309.4Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Medium $600Notes: The latch side clear space on the pull side of the door is only 4-1/4" (18" min.). Explore options, which include reversing the direction of the door swing into the hall. Cost assumes door swing direction is reversed.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and hot water supply. Provide insulation of all piping.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located 57" above the floor (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 52-1/2" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Clear Space at Toilet Medium $1,500Notes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is only 40" (60" min. req'd.). Explore options, which can include relocating sink or recessing it into adjacent space if available. Cost is placeholder and will vary depending on options available.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted with centerline 4" in front of toilet (7"-9" to centerline req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Grab Bars Low $750Notes: Grab bars provided only on the side (required on side and rear wall). Side grab bar extends only 46-1/2" from rear wall (54" min.). Provide compliant grab bars on the side and rear walls in compliant location.Federal Guideline: 604.5

18-3 Public SpaceProvide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $900Notes: Service counter is at 41-1/2” height (36" max. req'd. for verbal interaction). Provide min. 36" wide section of service counter at 36" max. height.Federal Guideline: 227.3, 904.5Provide Compliant Wall Signage Low $400Notes: Several offices and other exempt spaces lack signs. Provide compliant signs for all permanent spaces.Federal Guideline: 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 52-1/2" (over 48" max. ht.) but 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Protect/Reposition Protruding Objects Low $200Notes: The service counter protrudes 8-1/2" at 60" (4" max. between 27-80"). Provide permanent cane-detectable object below at each end.Federal Guideline: 307.2

Golf Course16-1 Men’s Restroom Hole 3

Provide Compliant Signage High $200

Notes: No sign provided. Provide a compliant sign at door with visual and tactile letters and Braille on the wall adjacent to the latch at compliant height.

Federal Guideline: 216, 703Provide Compliant Accessible Route Medium $100Notes: The approach from the cart path to the restroom building slab has a 1-1/2" elevation change (1/2" max beveled). Provide a compliant transition plate to eliminate elevation change.Federal Guideline: 303Provide Compliant Threshold Low $150Notes: The threshold is 1-1/4" high (1/2" max.). Provide new threshold. Federal Guideline: 404.2.5


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 52" high (48" max.) and protrudes 8" into the circulation area of the restroom (4" max. allowed).Federal Guideline: 307.2, 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Medium $50Notes: Electrical switches at 56" (over 48" max. ht.) which is also over the 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlet is mounted at 55" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Provide Clear Space at Toilet Medium $1,500Notes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is only 41-1/4" (60" min. req'd.). Explore options, which can include relocating sink or recessing it into adjacent space if available. Cost is placeholder and will vary depending on options available.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Modify Toilet Seat Low $50Notes: Toilet seat height of 16" is too low (17-19" req'd.). Provide new seat to provide compliant height.Federal Guideline: 604.4Replace Toilet Tank Low $200Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Provide water tank that has flush control on wide side of toilet. Federal Guideline: 604.6Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted with centerline outside of 7-9" req'd. and at 49" height (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Complaint Grab Bars Medium $1,000Notes: Grab bars provided only on the side (required on side and rear wall) and side bar is only 36" long (42" min.). Provide compliant grab bars on the side and rear walls in compliant location.Federal Guideline: 604.5, 609.3

16-2 Women’s Restroom Hole 3Provide Compliant Signage High $200Notes: Sign provided includes visual text with gender pictogram only. Provide a compliant sign at door with visual and tactile letters and Braille on the wall adjacent to the latch at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Accessible Route Medium $100Notes: The approach from the cart path to the restroom building slab has a 1-1/2" elevation change (1/2" max beveled). Provide a compliant transition plate to eliminate elevation change.Federal Guideline: 303Provide Compliant Threshold Low $150Notes: The threshold is 1-1/4" high (1/2" max.). Provide new threshold. Federal Guideline: 404.2.5Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Door closes in less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 50" high (48" max.) and protrudes 8" into the circulation area of the restroom (4" max. allowed).Federal Guideline: 307.2, 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Medium $50Notes: Electrical switches at 56" (over 48" max. ht.) which is also over the 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlet is mounted at 55" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Provide Clear Space at Toilet Medium $1,500Notes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is only 36-1/2" (60" min. req'd.). Explore options, which can include relocating sink or recessing it into adjacent space if available. Cost is placeholder and will vary depending on options available.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted with centerline outside of 7-9" req'd. and at 49" height (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Complaint Grab Bars Medium $1,000Notes: Side bar is only 36" long (42" min.) and rear bar is only 24" long (36" min.). Provide compliant grab bars on the side and rear walls in compliant location.Federal Guideline: 604.5, 609.3


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost16-3 Unisex Restroom Hole 18

Provide Compliant Signage High $200Notes: Sign is visual only and located on the pull side of the door. Provide a compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille on the wall adjacent to the latch at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216, 703Provide Compliant Accessible Route Medium $5,000Notes: The restroom is located a distance from the cart path and there is no compliant accessible route surfacing to the restroom. The approach a 1-1/2" elevation change (1/2" max beveled). Provide a compliant surface that is firm and stable to access this restroom.Federal Guideline: 403Provide Compliant Door Opening Medium included aboveNotes: The stoop catches the door, which sticks open and does not open to 90 degrees. Correct stoop with new accessible route.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1, 404.2.9Provide Turning Space Low N/ANotes: Space is required to provide 60" diameter turning area for a wheelchair, space provided is substandard but there is room for most wheelchairs to turn.Federal Guideline: 304.3, 306.3, 606.2Reposition Hand Sanitizer Dispenser Low $50Notes: Soap dispenser is located at 50" (15"-48" max.) from the floor.Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted in front of toilet beyond 7-9" req'd. No toilet paper present at time of evaluation.Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Grab Bars Medium $500

Notes: Side grab bar extends only 48-1/2" from rear wall (54" min.) and rear grab bar has only 11" on the wall side of the toilet centerline (12" min.).

Federal Guideline: 604.526 Golf Course and Facilities

Provide Access to Practice Green Low TBDNotes: Access to the practice green for golf carts is restricted and may be difficult due to topography. Access to practice greens by carts is required for accessibility. Investigate options for access, which likely would include signage to limit access to practice green only for carts being used by person with a mobility impairment.Federal Guideline: 238.3, 1006.3Provide Access to Tee Boxes Low TBDNotes: Access to tee boxes (at least 2 req'd., including front tees) for golf carts may be difficult at some holes due to topography. Federal Guideline: 1006.2


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Access to Putting Greens Low TBDNotes: Access to the green for golf carts is restricted at some greens and may be difficult at others due only to topography, particularly holes 6, 9, and 17. Access to putting greens is required for accessibility. Investigate options for access if needed.Federal Guideline: 1006.2


General Notes: 1. There are 2 separate parking facilities for this location; the golf club that includes all parking to the SW of Centennial Blvd. and provides parking for golfers and functions at the golf club and the Training Academy that includes all parking to the NE of Centennial Blvd. The accessible routes on the site are limited to those from the respective accessible parking to the building. It would not necessarily be expected to have persons with disabilities travel from the golf club to the training facility directly, those with mobility impairments would like drive from one parking facility to the other. Information for the sidewalk and curb ramp connections between the 2 buildings is for information only.2. It is assumed that a golf cart would be available at the Training Academy for disabled persons to access the training area, including driving range and practice putting green. The only access to these areas is stairs or a steep sidewalk on the NW side of the building. This may need to include a change in policy for use of carts as an accommodation.3. Note that there are shower facilities in the clubhouse in both the Men's and Women's restrooms but they are not available for use by golfers and the areas are used for storage of various materials. Shower facilities were not evaluated in details but are not compliant as they lack a seat and grab bars, among other non-compliance issues. If the showers are made available, they will need to ensure they meet the requirements of 608 for transfer showers.




Facility Total: $0

General Notes:

NOTE: This facility is located on the site of a former golf course and currently used in a limited capacity for disc golfing. There are no parking facilities dedicated, with parking being on the side of the adjacent streets. There are no improved surfaces within this area, all picnic tables and benches provided lack an accessible route and clear spaces as required. An assessment of this facility should be completed when the entire disc golf course is completed, along with other amenities provided. Ensure that all requirements for golf courses in the ADA standards are met with the disc golf course improvements.

Groves Park at South Hills

City of Oak RidgeGroves Park at South Hills Page 1 of 1



01a Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Low $4,000

Notes: The slope of the accessible spaces and access aisles is up to 2.6% (2% max.). Cost assumes corrections are made in current location with minor asphalt milling and resurfacing when parking lot is reconstructed.

Federal Guideline: 50222-1 Site Furniture

Protect/Reposition Protruding Objects Medium $100

Notes: The top of the post for the air pump protrudes more than 4" max. between 27-80". Provide permanent cane-detectable object below.

Federal Guideline: 307.2Provide Access to Trash Containers Low $400Notes: All trash containers are located within lawn areas. Existing containers have lids that may be difficult for someone with an upper body mobility impairment to operate. Provide a new trash container located along the existing accessible route that has compliant opening device.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 308.3.2, 1011.3

Exterior

NOTES: 31 total parking spaces provided, including 2 designated as accessible, 1 with van accessible signage. 2 accessible spaces required, including 1 van space.

Haw Ridge Park

NOTES: Haw Ridge Park is another mostly unimproved facility that offers over 28 miles of unpaved trails over the natural terrain. A portion of the Melton Lake Greenway, which is paved and provides a trailhead parking lot on the border of the park, traverses a portion of the park and was evaluated. There are other parking areas provided that are not paved and were not assessed since they are not comprised of a compliant surface and provide no signage other than identification of the park. The greenway evaluation is provided in the assessment of the greenways.

City of Oak RidgeHaw Ridge Park Page 1 of 2

Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Bench Seating Area Low $300

Notes: There are 2 benches located within lawn areas at the parking lot. This does not provide a compliant surface for a wheelchair to be positioned adjacent to a companion on the bench. Relocate a min. of 1 bench or provide connection from accessible route to provide clear space outside of walkway for wheelchair. Best location(s) would be somewhere adjacent to the greenway. Cost assumes 1 bench is relocated to be immediately adjacent to the greenway, which is wide enough to provide a clear space for a wheelchair outside of the accessible route.

Federal Guideline: 903.2, 1011.2.1Facility Total: $4,800

General Notes: 1. Note that the existing portable toilets are not accessible. Since they are not a "permanent" fixture they are not required to be accessible but consider providing a portable toilet that is wheelchair accessible at all locations that portable toilets are provided unless accessible restrooms are provided.

City of Oak RidgeHaw Ridge Park Page 2 of 2



Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $4,000Notes: The slope of the accessible spaces and access aisles is up to 3.5% (2% max.). Cost assumes corrections are made in current location with minor asphalt milling and resurfacing when parking lot is reconstructed.Federal Guideline: 502Provide Accessible Aisle Marking High $300Notes: Accessible parking spaces and access aisle markings are very faded. Provide regular maintenance.Federal Guideline: 502

04 Accessible Routes

Provide Compliant Accessible Routes Medium $4,000Notes: There are 2 access points from the main accessible route to different play structures. The running slopes of the access routes is 9% and 11% (8.33% max.) and would be difficult for wheelchair user to traverse. The approach to the shelter has areas of 5-7.8% running slope. Best option is likely to raise the sidewalk on the approaches to the short connector on each end and between them to reduce the elevation change from the main sidewalk to the play area surfacing. Also provide compliant slope at approach to shelter, ensuring that a level turning space remains at the drinking fountain.Federal Guideline: 403.3

Exterior

NOTES: 9 total parking spaces provided, including 2 designated as accessible, 1 with van accessible signage. 1 van-accessible space required.

Highland View Park

NOTES: The parking lot ramp includes a detectable warning plate (DWP). DWPs are not required outside of the right-of-way except in very limited locations. The existing plate should be removed when the sidewalk is replaced, it is not full width of the ramp and provides no benefit.

City of Oak RidgeHighland View Park Page 1 of 2

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost07 Drinking Fountain

Provide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $2,000Notes: Only 1 fountain provided, 2 min. required if 1 is provided. Existing bubbler height of 36" is compliant with wheelchair users. Provide additional fountain for standing user with 38-43" high bubbler. Cost assumes new tall fountain with bubbler height of 38-43" is provided that provides compliant approach and level clear spaces.Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7

22-1 Site FurnitureProvide Access to Trash Containers Low $400Notes: All trash containers are located within lawn areas and require reach from accessible surface that may be difficult for some to make. Existing containers have lids that may be difficult for someone with an upper body mobility impairment to operate. Provide a new trash container located along the existing accessible route that has compliant opening device.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 308.3.2, 1011.3Provide Compliant Bench Seating Area Medium $1,200Notes: There are 5 benches located within lawn areas at the play area. This does not provide a compliant surface for a wheelchair to access the benches or to be positioned adjacent to a companion on the bench. Relocate a min. of 1 bench or provide connection from accessible route to provide clear space outside of walkway for wheelchair. Best location may be adjacent to new sidewalk so parent can see both play structures. Cost assumes 1 new bench is provided to be immediately adjacent to the accessible route and addition of concrete pad adjacent to the bench to provide a clear space for a wheelchair outside of the accessible route.Federal Guideline: 903.2, 1011.2.1

25-1 Play Equipment AreasProvide Compliant Access to Play Elements Medium $3,000Notes: Compliant accessible route not provided to most ground play elements. Existing surface is wood fiber, which requires extensive maintenance to be compliant. Provide accessible surface to ground play elements at 1 of the play structures. Consider adding similar tile surfacing under and around larger structure to access ground play elements, including swings (NOTE: since these play structures appear to be for the same age groups only 1 is required to be accessible given their proximity to each other).Federal Guideline: 240


General Notes:

City of Oak RidgeHighland View Park Page 2 of 2


Item # Description Priority Probable CostParking

01a-1 Soccer Parking Lot

Repaint Accessible Spaces and Access Aisle Low $400Notes: Existing paint is faded and should be redone. Federal Guideline: 502.3.3Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Low $2,000Notes: The slope of the south accessible space and access aisle is up to 2.5% (2% max.). Cost assumes corrections are made in current location with minor asphalt milling and resurfacing when parking lot is reconstructed.Federal Guideline: 502Provide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: The bottom of the van space sign is only 26" high (60" min.). Sign is attached to the fence, provide sign post to provide compliant height.Federal Guideline: 502

01a-2 Play Area Parking Lot

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $2,500Notes: The slope of the accessible space and access aisle is up to 5% (2% max.). Cost assumes corrections are made in current location with minor asphalt milling and resurfacing when parking lot is reconstructed.Federal Guideline: 502Accessible Routes and Curb Ramps

02-1 Curb Ramp at Play Area ParkingProvide Compliant Landing/Turning Space High $400Notes: The shared landing/turning space at the end of the ramp at the parking lot has a cross slope of 7.2% (2.0% max.). Reconstruct the landing to be level, will require removal and replacement of adjacent panel.Federal Guideline: 406

57 total parking spaces provided, including 3 accessible space with 1 van-accessible. Total of 3 accessible spaces, including 1 van space, required.

8 total parking spaces provided, including 1 van-accessible. Total of 1 van space required.

LaSalle Park

NOTE: this park includes 2 separate parking facilities, each accessed from LaSalle Road and not connected

City of Oak RidgeLaSalle Park 1 of 5

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost04-1 Accessible Routes

Provide Compliant Slope High included aboveNotes: The cross slope of the sidewalk panel between the ramp landing and play structure has a cross slope that exceeds 2% max. Federal Guideline: 403.3Provide Compliant Accessible Route Medium $500Notes: The south accessible parking space at the soccer parking has a drainage structure near the end of the access aisle that has opening well over 1/2" max. This could present issues for persons with mobility devices. Explore option of providing different casting cover on drainage structure to reduce the opening size to 1/2" or less.Federal Guideline: 302.3, 403.2

06-1 Stairs at Roadside Parking (2 stairways)

Provide Compliant Stair Surfacing N/A N/ANotes: The existing concrete surface of the steps and landings are showing signs of age, including spalling. This creates loose materials that could cause someone to slip.Federal Guideline: 504.4, 302, 304.2Provide Compliant Stair Landings N/A N/ANotes: Landing surface slope must not exceed 2% in any direction. Both the top and bottom landings exceed the maximum.Federal Guideline: 304.2Provide Compliant Handrails High $2,500Notes: Handrail top surface is mounted 27"(34-38" req'd.) above stair surfaces and provided on only 1 side at each stair. Handrail is a 2"x6" board with a (non-circular) perimeter dimension of 14" (4" to 6-1/4" max. req'd.). Handrails are not smooth and wood is splintering to present hazard to users. Handrails do not extend beyond the top and bottom of the stair 12" min. Recommended that compliant handrails be provided at the stairs in the center of the soccer field to improve safety for all users and provide assistance for disabled persons who are ambulatory and would benefit from the shorter walking distance to spectator area.Federal Guideline: 505.4, 505.8, 505.10.2, 505.10.3

NOTE: The stairs noted below are from the public ROW parking along the roadway that is used during high volume soccer events. The stairs are not considered the accessible route to the soccer field. The items noted below should be considered for information only unless a cost and priority is provided. Note also that while not the compliant accessible route, the stairs are a much shorter distance to the spectator area of the soccer field for persons that are ambulatory but may have other issues that could be improved with the shorter walk using stairs.

NOTE: This section includes only the accessible route from parking to the play structure. Compliance of other routes to soccer fields is included below in a later section.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostPark Amenities

07-1 Play Area Drinking FountainProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $2,000Notes: Only 1 fountain provided, 2 min. required if 1 is provided. Existing bubbler height of 36" is compliant with requirement for wheelchair users. Provide additional fountain for standing user with 38-43" high bubbler. Cost assumes new tall fountain with bubbler height of 38-43" is provided that provides compliant approach and level clear spaces.Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7

07-2 Main Soccer Field Drinking FountainProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Medium $4,000

Notes: Only 1 fountain provided, 2 min. required if 1 is provided. Existing bubbler height of 36-1/2" is compliant with requirements for neither wheelchair or standing users and post mount type provides no knee space below. Cost assumes new hi-low fountain is provided with compliant bubbler heights and plumbing work needed to move it to a location inside the fence that is wheelchair-accessible (existing curb at parking is a barrier).

Federal Guideline: 211, 602Provide Compliant Access Medium included belowNotes: A clear, level space, 30" wide x 48" deep min. is to be provided in front of the fountain and it is required to be on a compliant accessible route (currently in grass). Cost assumes fountain is relocated adjacent to the accessible route to the perimeter of the soccer field discussed below.Federal Guideline: 602.2, 305.2

22-1 Site FurniturePicnic Tables Low $2,000Notes: The picnic table near the play area is not on an accessible route. Provide a connection from the existing interior route (at the new landing/turning space) to the existing concrete pad. Federal Guideline: 403, 1011Provide Access to Trash Containers Low $800Notes: All trash containers are located within lawn areas and require reach from accessible surface that may be difficult for some to make. Existing containers have lids that may be difficult for someone with an upper body mobility impairment to operate. Provide min. of 1 new trash container at both the play area and main soccer field located along an accessible route that has compliant opening device.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 308.3.2, 1011.3

NOTE: Since the play area and main soccer field are not connected, each is considered its own "area" and require compliance as essentially stand-alone facilities beyond just parking as previously noted.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Bench Seating Area Medium $1,200

Notes: There are 2 benches located within lawn areas at the play area. This does not provide a compliant surface for a wheelchair to access the benches or to be positioned adjacent to a companion on the bench. Relocate a min. of 1 bench or provide connection from accessible route to provide clear space outside of walkway for wheelchair. Best location may be adjacent to sidewalk. Cost assumes 1 new bench is provided to be immediately adjacent to the accessible route and addition of concrete pad adjacent to the bench to provide a clear space for a wheelchair outside of the accessible route.

Federal Guideline: 903.2, 1011.2.124-1 Soccer Fields

Provide Accessible Route to Boundary of Area of Sport Activity Medium $25,000Notes: An accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity (soccer fields, basketball courts, baseball fields, running tracks, skating rinks, etc.). Where multiple sports fields or courts are provided, an accessible route is provided to each field or area of sport activity. No route currently exists from the parking to the spectator area or stairs to spectator area. Provide connection as required with a compliant surface to the perimeter of all fields. Cost assumes direct connection from parking to fields by installing an accessible route from the parking lot then along the west side of the west field, along the south side of the 2 west fields that connects to the west stairway, and then goes between the 2 east field all the way to the north near the smallest field. Cost assumes paving but other options may be used that could be less costly.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403

24-2 Sport Fields at Play AreaAccessible Route Low $12,000

Notes: An accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity. Where multiple sports fields or courts are provided, an accessible route is provided to each field or area of sport activity. No route currently exists from the parking to the small soccer field or ball diamond. Provide connection as required with a compliant surface to the perimeter of all fields. Cost assumes direct connection from parking to fields by installing an accessible route from the parking lot along the south side of the soccer field and along the left field/3rd baseline of the ball diamond. Cost assumes paving but other options may be used that could be less costly.

Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 40325-1 Play Area

Provide Compliant Accessible Route Low $50Notes: There is a wide gap where the sidewalk meets the playground surfacing. Provide a compliant hardener or joint filler.Federal Guideline: 303


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Height Transfer Platform Low N/A

Notes: There are 2 different transfer platforms to the play structure, they are 10" and 10-1/2" high (11-18" req'd.). The added compliant surfacing likely raised the ground level too much. Explore options, which likely includes removal of some of the base material under the accessible rubber surfacing.

Federal Guideline: 1008.3.1.2


General Notes: 1. Parking at this site is provided by a dedicated lot outside the ROW, as well as parking within the ROW immediately adjacent to the park. This parking is clearly provided for the park, particularly since the on-street parking provides the best access to the playground. Parking is considered to be 1 facility for the non-ROW lot and ROW as a separate facility based on characteristics.2. Note that the existing portable toilets are not accessible. Since they are not a "permanent" fixture they are not required to be accessible but consider providing a portable toilet that is wheelchair accessible at all locations that portable toilets are provided unless accessible restrooms are provided.



Item # Description Priority Probable CostParking

01a-1 Playground/Picnic Shelter Lot

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Low $1,200Notes: Slopes of parking stalls and access aisle up to 4.4% (2% max.). Provide level parking area when lot is resurfaced.Federal Guideline: 302, 502.4Provide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: The existing space provides no signage as required. Provide a compliant sign that includes the van tag.Federal Guideline: MUTCD, 502.6

01a-2 Boat Launch Lot

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $1,000Notes: Accessible spaces should be provided as close to the boat launch as possible, including minimum of 1 for a vehicle with trailer. Provide compliant spaces, pavement marking, and access aisle with signage.Federal Guideline: 208, 502

NOTE: This facility is quite expansive and includes what is determined to be 4 separate parking facilities. There is a very small lot at the play structure that is connected to the boat launch lot but considered for those using the playground and picnic shelter. The second lot is the boat launch parking that includes both car and cars with trailer parking. The third facility includes parking along the peninsula drive to the southeast. The fourth facility is the parking in front of a private business and the rowing club building. Each facility is considered separate due to need to disperse accessible spaces and logical separation and uses at each.

Melton Lake Park

6 total parking spaces provided, including 1 accessible space pavement markings only. Total of 1 van space required.

27 total car spaces provided, additional space for up to 19 cars with boat trailer or 2 cars for each boat-trailer space, for total maximum count of 65. No accessible spaces provided, total of 3 accessible spaces required, including 1 van space.

City of Oak RidgeMelton Lake Park Page 1 of 3

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost01a-3 Parking Along House Boat Row Peninsula

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $1,500Notes: Accessible spaces should be provided at the location of the sidewalk connection to finger piers and on main side of the river. No other facilities present so location not specific. Provide compliant spaces, pavement markings, and access aisle with signage.Federal Guideline: 208, 502

01a-4 Parking Along House Boat Row Peninsula

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $1,500Notes: Accessible spaces should be provided at the location of the sidewalk connection to finger piers and on main side of the river. No other facilities present so location not specific. Provide compliant spaces, pavement markings, and access aisle with signage.Federal Guideline: 208, 502


Provide Compliant Slope Medium $800Notes: The accessible route at the drinking fountain has slope up to 4.5% and the turning space at the drinking fountain is 3.0% (2% max. for both).Federal Guideline: 403.3Correct Vertical Elevation Changes Medium $400Notes: The accessible route at the shelter and adjacent to the drinking fountain has displaced joints in the concrete that have resulted in over 1/2" change in elevation. Cost assumes these are grinded down to compliant level of 1/4" max. or 1/2" max. if beveled.Federal Guideline: 303, 403.4Park Amenities

07-1 Drinking FountainProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $2,000Notes: Only 1 fountain provided, 2 min. required if 1 is provided. Existing bubbler height of 36" is compliant with requirement for wheelchair users. Provide additional fountain for standing user with 38-43" high bubbler. Cost assumes new tall fountain with bubbler height of 38-43" is provided that provides compliant approach and level clear spaces.Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7

105 total parking spaces provided, 0 accessible spaces provided. Total of 5 accessible spaces required, including 1 van space.

48 total parking spaces provided, 4 accessible spaces provided including 2 van-accessible spaces. Total of 2 accessible spaces required, including 1 van space.

NOTE: The only accessible routes analyzed are those from the accessible parking near the play area across the greenway to the picnic shelter. The greenway compliance information is included in the greenways section.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost22-1 Site Furniture

Provide Compliant Bench Seating Area Medium $800

Notes: There are 2 benches located within lawn areas at the play area. This does not provide a compliant surface for a wheelchair to access the benches or to be positioned adjacent to a companion on the bench. Relocate a min. of 1 bench or provide connection from accessible route to provide clear space outside of walkway for wheelchair. Best location may be adjacent to sidewalk. Cost assumes 1 new bench is provided to be immediately adjacent to the accessible route and addition of concrete pad adjacent to the bench to provide a clear space for a wheelchair outside of the accessible route.

Federal Guideline: 903.2, 1011.2.124-1 Sand Volleyball Court

Provide Accessible Route to Boundary of Area of Sport Activity Medium $2,800Notes: An accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity (soccer fields, basketball courts, baseball fields, running tracks, skating rinks, etc.). No route currently exists. Provide connection as required with a compliant surface. Cost assumes direct connection from greenway to one side of court. Cost assumes paving but other options may be used that could be less costly.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403

25-1 Play Equipment AreasProvide Compliant Access to Play Elements Medium $5,000Notes: Compliant accessible route not provided to most ground play elements, including no access to swings, or at the end of a slide back to the transfer platform on the structure. Existing surface is wood fiber, which requires extensive maintenance to be compliant. Provide accessible surface to ground play elements and end of slide nearest rubber tiles. Consider adding similar tile surfacing under and around larger structure to access ground play elements, including swings.Federal Guideline: 240


General Notes: 1. Parking at this site was determined to provide 4 separate parking facilities based on use and need for dispersion.2. Note that the existing portable toilets are not accessible. Since they are not a "permanent" fixture they are not required to be accessible but consider providing a portable toilet that is wheelchair accessible at all locations that portable toilets are provided unless accessible restrooms are provided.3. The city appears to own the property on which the buildings exist but the buildings are not city programs. None of the building facilities on the site were included in the review for that reason.4. The greenway that bisects the park was evaluated as a greenway and not as part of the park review.




Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Low $1,200Notes: Slopes of parking stalls and access aisle up to 3% (2% max.), only 1 of 4 spaces is compliant. Provide level parking area when lot is resurfaced.Federal Guideline: 302, 502.4Provide Compliant Accessible Parking High $400Notes: The east parking spaces at the soccer field are separated from the west van-accessible space, with no van access at this area. The existing area has adequate space to be restriped to provide min. 8' spaces and 8' access aisle, which is recommended to provide a van-accessible space at the soccer field. Cost assumes restriping and addition of van sign.Federal Guideline: 302, 502.4Accessible Routes and Curb Ramps

02-1 Curb Ramp at East ParkingProvide Compliant Curb Ramp High $3,000Notes: There is no level landing/turning space, is within the 7% slope of the ramp. The ramp projects into the parking access aisle. Reconstruct the ramp as a parallel ramp in the current location.Federal Guideline: 406

02-2 Curb Ramp at West Parking to ROW Sidewalk Provide Compliant Curb Ramp High $300

Notes: There is an elevation change at the intersection of ramp with the parking access aisle that exceeds 1/2". There is no level landing, has a 2.4% slope (2% max.). Ramp has a detectable warning plate that is not required nor desired, remove it and do not replace it when the ramp is reconstructed.


Accessible parking is provided to the west at Athens Road and to the east near the soccer field all within the same parking facility. 48 total parking spaces provided, including 4 accessible spaces with 1 designated as van-accessible. 2 accessible spaces, including 1 van space, are required.

Milt Dickens Park

City of Oak RidgeMilt Dickens Park Page 1 of 4

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost02 Curb Ramps at Driveway

Provide Compliant Curb Ramps High $5,500Notes: Both ramps lack a compliant landing/TS, have detectable warnings that are not required or desired. Reconstruct both as parallel ramps and ensure proper drainage.Federal Guideline: 406

04-1 ROW Sidewalk to Playground and Playground Area WalksProvide Compliant Accessible Route Medium $8,000Notes: The accessible route from the ROW to the drinking fountain has a running slope up to 8-10% (5% max.), the walk near the playground have cross slopes up to 3.5%, and the turning space at the drinking fountain is 3.7% (2% max. for both). Explore options to provide a compliant running slope for the accessible route from the ROW to the play area. There may be limitations on the amount of fill if this area is within a floodplain. The current slope exceeds the slopes allowed for ramps with handrails, which will also add to the cost if grading cannot provide compliant walk slopes. Cost assumes minor grading can be done with fill and sidewalk modified to both raise the elevation and increase the running length to provide 5% max. running slope with compliant TS at the drinking fountain spur. Additional investigation, including survey, is needed and options and costs may vary from that provided here.Federal Guideline: 403

04-2 East Parking to Portable ToiletProvide Compliant Accessible Route High $1,500Notes: The accessible route from the curb ramp to the portable toilet exceeds 2% cross slope for the entire length and 3 vehicle parking spaces could have vehicles overhang the curb and obstruct the accessible route. Some joints have separated over 1/2". Cost assumes the entire section of sidewalk is reconstructed with compliant slopes and 3 parking spaces are provided with bumper blocks to prevent them from overhanging the route.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403Park Amenities

07-1 Drinking FountainProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $2,000Notes: Only 1 fountain provided, 2 min. required if 1 is provided. Existing bubbler height of 36" is compliant with requirement for wheelchair users. Provide additional fountain for standing user with 38-43" high bubbler. Cost assumes new tall fountain with bubbler height of 38-43" is provided that provides compliant approach and level clear spaces.Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost22-1 Site Furniture

Provide Compliant Bench Seating Area Medium $800

Notes: There are 5 benches in the park, all located within lawn areas. This does not provide a compliant surface for a wheelchair to access the benches or to be positioned adjacent to a companion on the bench. Relocate a min. of 1 bench or provide connection from accessible route to provide clear space outside of walkway for wheelchair. Best location may be adjacent to sidewalk. Cost assumes 1 new bench is provided to be immediately adjacent to the accessible route and addition of concrete pad adjacent to the bench to provide a clear space for a wheelchair outside of the accessible route.

Federal Guideline: 903.2, 1011.2.1Provide Access to Trash Containers Low $800Notes: All trash containers are located within lawn areas and require reach from accessible surface that may be difficult for some to make. Existing containers have lids that may be difficult for someone with an upper body mobility impairment to operate. Provide min. of 1 new trash container at both the play area and soccer field located along an accessible route that has compliant opening device.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 308.3.2, 1011.3

24-1 Soccer FieldProvide Accessible Route to Boundary of Area of Sport Activity Medium $12,000Notes: An accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity (soccer fields, basketball courts, baseball fields, running tracks, skating rinks, etc.). Where multiple sports fields or courts are provided, an accessible route is provided to each field or area of sport activity. No route currently exists from the east parking to the spectator area. Provide connection as required with a compliant surface to the perimeter of field. Cost assumes direct connection from parking curb ramp to field by installing an accessible route to the field (assumed there is only 1 field). Cost assumes paving but other options may be used that could be less costly.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost25-1 Play Equipment Area

Provide Compliant Access to Play Elements Medium $5,000Notes: Compliant accessible route not provided to many ground play elements, including no access to swings, or at the end of a slide back to the transfer platform on the blue structure. Existing surface is wood fiber, which requires extensive maintenance to be compliant. Provide accessible surface to ground play elements and end of slide nearest rubber tiles. Consider adding similar tile surfacing under and around larger structure to access ground play elements, including swings.Federal Guideline: 240


General Notes:1. This facility includes few internal accessible routes and no connection to any facilities from the accessible parking without also utilizing the right-of-way pedestrian access route. For this reason, the direct route to the play area includes discussion of compliance of this section of PAR between the west accessible parking and the play area. The east parking area connects only to a short accessible route that parallels a portion of the parking area. The bridge over the ditch is not considered to be on the accessible route and is not compliant. An alternative to some of the deficiencies could be to provide a connection with a compliant bridge between the playground, soccer field, and accessible parking. The issues with the curb ramps at the drive would still need to be addressed, though the PAR dead ends at the short segment of walk to the parking lot with no PAR beyond.2. Note that the existing portable toilets are not accessible. Since they are not a "permanent" fixture they are not required to be accessible but consider providing a portable toilet that is wheelchair accessible at all locations that portable toilets are provided unless accessible restrooms are provided.



Ball Field AreaItem # Description Priority Probable Cost01a-1 Ball Field Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Low $3,000Notes: Slopes of parking stalls and access aisle up to 3.1% (2% max.). Van space is only 94" wide (96" min.) but access aisle is larger than needed. Access aisle and parking space pavement markings are very faded and need to be redone. Provide level parking area when lot is resurfaced, repaint pavement markings in the interim.Federal Guideline: 302, 502.4Accessible Routes and Curb Ramps

02-1 Curb Ramps at Ball Field

Provide Compliant Curb Ramp Medium $6,000

Notes: The running slope of the 2 curb ramps exceed 8.7% (8.33% max.), side flares exceed 12.7% (10% max.), curb ramps are located within the parking access aisles (not allowed), and neither ramp has a level landing/turning space as required. Recommended that the ramps be reconstructed to eliminate 1 and provide 1 compliant parallel ramp at the van-accessible access aisle. This will require work at the adjacent walk and curbs, cost assumes one ramp is eliminated and a compliant parallel ramp with related pavement work being done.

Federal Guideline: 40604-1 Sidewalk from Accessible Parking to Bleachers

Provide Compliant Accessible Route Low $8,000Notes: The accessible route has a cross slope up to 2.5% (2% max.). Cost assumes replacement of entire walk when condition warrants or when other site work is done.Federal Guideline: 403

PinewoodPark

65 total parking spaces provided, including 3 accessible spaces with 1 van-accessible. 3 accessible spaces required, including 1 van-accessible.

Note: There are 2 curb ramps at the accessible parking, neither of which is compliant.

City of Oak RidgePinewood Park Page 1 of 5

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost05-1 Ramp Bleachers

Provide Compliant Ramp and Handrails Medium $4,000

Notes: Running slope of existing ramp is 10.2% (8.33% max.). The existing total ramp rise appears to be only 30" (which is the maximum allowed) so no need for multiple runs but this should be verified by comparing elevation at bottom and top landing with survey level. Existing handrails do not extend 12" parallel to the walking surface at either the top or bottom as required. Modify and extend ramp length to provide compliant running slope and provide compliant handrail extensions at the top and bottom that return and are not protruding objects. Cost assumes single ramp run, if determined total elevation difference exceeds 30" then 2 runs with intermediate 60" deep landing will be needed, along with reconstruction of bottom landing and additional cost will be incurred.

Federal Guideline: 405, 50506-1 Stairway for Bleachers

Provide Compliant Stairs N/A N/ANotes: Risers are open, which are not provided due to trip hazard potential. Provide vertical plate at each riser.Federal Guideline: 210, 504.2, 504.3Provide Compliant Handrails N/A N/ANotes: Handrail top surface is at 38-1/2" (34-38" req'd.). Handrails do not have compliant extensions at top (12" min. req'd.).Federal Guideline: 505.10.3Park Amenities

07-1 Drinking FountainProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $2,000

Notes: Only 1 fountain provided, 2 min. required if 1 is provided. Existing bubbler height of 38" is compliant with requirement for standing users. Provide additional fountain for wheelchair user with 36" high max. bubbler. Cost assumes new fountain with bubbler height of 36" max. with 27" minimum knee space below is provided that provides compliant approach and level clear spaces. Consideration could be given to providing new double fountain (or move existing tall fountain and provide new wheelchair height one) at the bleachers and removing the fountain in the grass area beyond the 1st base player seating area. This would eliminate need to provide compliant accessible route to existing fountain also.

Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7Provide Compliant Accessible Route and Clear Space Low $2,500

Notes: The existing fountain is located in a grass area beyond the 1st base player seating. Provide a compliant surface accessible route with clear space at existing fountain. See above for alternative that would likely be similar or lower cost.


NOTE: Stairs are not part of an accessible route, ramp is present. Information provided for information only and should be considered for correction if bleachers are altered.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost21-1 Bleachers

Provide Companion Seating Medium $1,000Notes: Only 2 seats available for wheelchair companions adjacent to wheelchair seating. Provide 2 additional bench seats to provide min. 3 additional companion spaces adjacent to min. 36" wide wheelchair space.Federal Guideline: 221.3, 802

24-1 Ball FieldProvide Accessible Route to Boundary of Area of Sport Activity Medium $1,600Notes: A compliant accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity (soccer fields, basketball courts, baseball fields, running tracks, skating rinks, etc.). Existing connection to the field on the 3rd baseline includes a steep 23% ramp and a 22" wide gate (32" min.) on the 1st baseline. No existing accessible route due to ramp and narrow gate for wheelchair to the 1st baseline player seating. Least costly option would be to extend the existing accessible route to the player seating from the bleacher area. May require some grading work or moving the scorekeeper structure closer to the backstop to provide the min. 36" accessible route.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403Provide Wheelchair Space at Player Benches Low $50Notes: Each player seating area is required to provide min. of 1, 36"x48" wide wheelchair space in-line with player seating. Existing bench on 1st baseline is full width of the concrete slab, either provide additional level concrete area for wheelchair or move bench partially in the grass to provide min. 36" wide wheelchair space next to bench. Cost assumes bench is moved.Federal Guideline: 221.2.1.4, 802.1

Soccer Field Area01a-2 Soccer Field Parking Lot

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Low $1,400Notes: Slopes of the car parking stall is 4.2% (2% max.). Access aisle and parking space pavement markings are very faded and need to be redone. Provide level parking area when lot is resurfaced, repaint pavement markings in the interim. Relocate stall so access aisle lines up with stairs or provide additional access aisle to provide access to stairs from parking and ensure parked vehicles do not obstruct access.Federal Guideline: 302, 502.4

38 total parking spaces provided, including 2 accessible spaces with 1 van-accessible. 2 accessible spaces required, including 1 van-accessible.

NOTE: Approximately 186 seating capacity, which requires 5 wheelchairs spaces with companion seat for each. Adequate space available for wheelchair spaces required but only 2 companion seats provided on short bench on bottom level.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostAccessible Routes and Curb Ramps

05 Ramp Provide Compliant Ramp and Handrails High $10,000

Notes: No wheelchair access is provided to the soccer field, installation of a ramp is required. Install a compliant ramp with access at the wheelchair parking space access aisle. Due to short distance between the parking and fence, will likely need to include landing area with curb cut at parking to provide min. 60"x60" top platform with ramp run parallel to the fence to min. 60" deep landing. Cost includes purchase and installation of a pre-fabricated aluminum ramp system with curb removal at the access aisle, top 60" platform, 36" min. width ramp with handrails and extensions, installation of bottom landing, and ensuring that a compliant gate entrance is provided for wheelchair that is 32" wide min.

Federal Guideline: 405, 50506-2 Exterior Stairs at Parking Lot

Provide Compliant Stairs and Handrail Low N/A

Notes: The bottom landing on the stairs has a 3.9% slope (2.0% max.). Handrail top surface is mounted 32-1/2" to 35" (34" min. and 38" max.) above stair surfaces. Height must be consistent. Handrails provided on only 1 side (req'd. on both sides). Provide compliant sloped bottom landing and compliant handrails.

Federal Guideline: 304, 505.4Park Amenities

24-2 Soccer FieldProvide Accessible Route to Boundary of Area of Sport Activity Medium $5,000Notes: A compliant accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity (soccer fields, basketball courts, baseball fields, running tracks, skating rinks, etc.). Existing connection to the field from the stairs is very limited. Cost assumes existing connection is expanded to provide 100' long concrete area extending to the center of the field that is 60" wide for wheelchair seating.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403


NOTE: Stairs are not an accessible route. Information below includes compliance of the existing stairs and handrails, with recommendations for installation of a wheelchair-compliant accessible route to the soccer field. Stairway is going to be the shortest accessible route from parking to the spectator area of the soccer field and should be made compliant to the extent possible. Only the stair at the accessible parking is assessed, the one at the end of the field is not considered part of the accessible route due primarily to the distance from parking and the spectator area at the center.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostGeneral Notes:1. This facility is essentially split into 2 and treated as such since both the ball field and soccer field have their own dedicated parking and no internal connections.2. This facility includes few internal accessible routes and no connection between the ball field and soccer field. 3. Note that the existing portable toilets are not accessible. Since they are not a "permanent" fixture they are not required to be accessible but consider providing a portable toilet that is wheelchair accessible at all locations that portable toilets are provided unless accessible restrooms are provided.4. Access to the soccer field is extremely limited, the information provided is intended to provide a compliant stair at the accessible space access aisle and new ramp at the wheelchair accessible space access aisle. Detailed investigation of ramp location and configuration is needed. Ensure compliance with all requirements for landings, ramps, and handrails and ensure access to the field is provided via gates located on a compliant accessible route. Also provide compliant surface on the spectator side of the field to provide wheelchair seating area.



Item # Description Priority Probable Cost01a-1 Parking

04 Sidewalk at Park EntranceProvide Compliant Accessible Route Low $1,500Notes: The accessible route has a running slope of 7-8% at the park entrance (5% max.). Cost assumes corrections are made when sidewalk condition warrants replacement or when other site work is done.Federal Guideline: 403

05-1 Restroom RampProvide Compliant Handrails Medium $1,200Notes: The existing handrails are only on 1 side of the ramp (req'd. on both sides), there is no edge protection (bottom rail must be max. 4" high), and there are no compliant handrail extensions at the top 12" beyond the top of the ramp and parallel to the ground surface. Provide additional handrail on inside of ramp run, provide additional bottom rail or curb, and extension.Federal Guideline: 405, 505

06-1 Stairway at Restrooms

Provide Compliant Stairs and Handrail Low $600Notes: Handrail top surface is mounted 40" (34" min. to 38" max.) above stair surface. Height must be consistent. Handrails provided on only 1 side (req'd. on both sides). Provide compliant height handrails on both sides that include required extensions at top and bottom.Federal Guideline: 304, 505.4

07-1 Drinking Fountains

Total existing spaces provided is 75, including 3 marked as accessible including 1 van-accessible. Based on parking count, 3 accessible spaces are required within this parking facility, including 1 van-accessible. Parking is compliant.

Municipal Swimming

Pool

NOTE: Stairs are not the accessible route but provide the shortest accessible route for ambulatory persons.

NOTE: The park has 3 total drinking fountains. There are 2 in open areas outside the Men's restroom and Unisex restroom. There is an additional drinking fountain on the wall in the Women's restroom. Standards require that if 1 drinking fountain is provided that 2 must be available, 1 each that meets requirements for a wheelchair and standing user. Both fountains in open areas are wheelchair height, the fountain in the Women's restroom is at height for use by standing person.

City of Oak RidgeMunicipal Swimming Pool Page 1 of 9

Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Medium $900Notes: The 2 fountains available in the open areas at the Men's restroom and Family restroom both have bubblers at 36" max., which is compliant for wheelchair users. Both are located within the pedestrian circulation area and considered protruding objects. Raise one to have bubbler height at 38-43" and protect both sides of both fountains with cane-detectable objects. Fountain in Women's restroom also protrudes and should have a permanent, cane-detectable object placed below it at the corner of the wall.Federal Guideline: 211, 307.2, 602

15-1 Women's RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Outside of Restroom High $800Notes: Signage located on the wall is visual text only. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille on both sides at all open doorway entrances. Provide compliant sign in compliant location.Federal Guideline: 216, 703Provide Insulation Below Sink (4) Low $440Notes: The sinks have exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 52" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hook outside of stall at 60" ht. (15"-48" req'd.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 608.3Modify Wheelchair Stall Hardware Medium $350Notes: Handles not provided on outside of stall door (req'd. on both sides) and door is not self-closing. Lock hardware requires grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2Reposition Toilet for Wheelchair Stall Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 20" from side wall (16"-18" req'd. for wheelchair stall). Federal Guideline: 604.2Provide Compliant Height Toilet Seat in Wheelchair Stall Low $100Notes: Toilet seat height is at 19-1/4" (17-19" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.4Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted at 18" in front of toilet (7-9" to centerline from front of toilet req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.7Reposition Grab Bars Low $500Notes: Grab bars mounted with top of gripping surface at 37" (33-36" req'd.). Rear grab bar positioned 9"/27" relative to toilet centerline (12"/24" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.5


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Ambulatory Stall Medium $2,000

Notes: Restrooms with 6 or more toilet/urinal fixtures are required to have an ambulatory accessible stall in addition to a wheelchair accessible stall. No compliant ambulatory stall present. Available stalls are only 56" deep (60" min.), have no handles on the doors (req'd. on both sides), have doors that swing into the stall (outswinging req'd.), locking hardware requires grasping and twisting motion, entry door width only 22-1/2" (32" min.), and have no grab bars (required on both side walls). Reconfigure 1 stall to comply with all requirements.

Federal Guideline: 231.3, 404.2, 604.5, 604.8, 609.3Provide Compliant Changing Room Stall Medium $2,000Notes: Several changing room stalls are provided. Stalls have no handles on the door (required on both sides), lock hardware is not compliant, door swings in, and bench within is only 15" deep. Consider providing at least 1 stall that is larger for changing that meets requirements of wheelchair toilet stall and has a bench within that is 20-24" deep.Federal Guideline: 803.4, 903

15-2 Men's RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Outside of Restroom High $800Notes: Signage located on the wall is visual text only. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille on both sides at all open doorway entrances. Provide compliant sign in compliant location.Federal Guideline: 216, 703Provide Insulation Below Sink (5) Low $550Notes: The sinks have exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 54" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Reposition Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hook outside of stall at 60" ht. (15"-48" req'd.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 608.3Modify Wheelchair Stall Hardware Medium $350Notes: Handles not provided on outside of stall door (req'd. on both sides) and door is not self-closing. Lock hardware requires grasping and twisting.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2Reposition Toilet for Wheelchair Stall Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 26-1/2" from side wall (16"-18" req'd. for wheelchair stall). Federal Guideline: 604.2Reposition Grab Bars Low $500Notes: Grab bars mounted with top of gripping surface at 37" (33-36" req'd.). Rear grab bar positioned 13"/23" relative to toilet centerline (12"/24" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.5


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Ambulatory Stall Medium $2,000

Notes: Restrooms with 6 or more toilet/urinal fixtures are required to have an ambulatory accessible stall in addition to a wheelchair accessible stall. No compliant ambulatory stall present. Available stalls are only 56" deep (60" min.), have no handles on the doors (req'd. on both sides), have doors that swing into the stall (outswinging req'd.), locking hardware requires grasping and twisting motion, entry door width only 22-1/2" (32" min.), and have no grab bars (required on both side walls). Reconfigure 1 stall to comply with all requirements.

Federal Guideline: 231.3, 404.2, 604.5, 604.8, 609.316-1 Family Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage Outside of Restroom High $100Notes: Room includes a shower, which must be compliant if this is to designated as a family restroom and it is to remain in operation. Provide additional sign outside door for bathing facility.Federal Guideline: 216, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Operating force is 18 lbs. (15 lb. max.). Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9Reposition Sink Low included belowNotes: Knee space below the sink is 26-1/2" high (27" min.). Reposition to provide knee space and ensure rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Federal Guideline: 606.3Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 49" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low $50Notes: Light switches/controls are located at 50" (15" min. to 48" max.) above the floor level.Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Reposition Toilet Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 22-1/2" from side wall (16"-18" req'd. for wheelchair stall). Federal Guideline: 604.2Replace Flush Controls Low $100Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Provide Required Toilet Clear Space Medium $1,200Notes: Clearance is 44" from the wall to the sink at the toilet (60" req'd). Room is 69" width at toilet wall, relocate sink within the room to provide clear space. Cost includes moving existing sink and plumbing work outside of required clear spaces.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Toilet Seat Medium $100Notes: Toilet seat height is 15-3/4" (17-19" req'd.). Provide new seat that raises height or provide new toilet, cost assumes new seat.Federal Guideline: 604.2, 604.3.1Provide Compliant Grab Bars High $1,000Notes: No grab bars provided, required on rear and side walls. Provide and install compliant grab bars on the side and rear walls.Federal Guideline: 604.5Provide Compliant Transfer Shower Low $3,500Notes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Compliant transfer shower that is 36"x36" with compliant seat and grab bars required. Cost provided to remove and replace existing shower compartment.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608

16-2 Staff Unisex RestroomReposition Sink Low included belowNotes: Knee space below the sink is 26-1/2" high (27" min.). Reposition to provide knee space and ensure rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Federal Guideline: 606.3Provide Insulation Below Sink Low $110Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 49" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low $50Notes: Light switches/controls are located at 50" (15" min. to 48" max.) above the floor level.Federal Guideline: 308.2.1Reposition Toilet Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 23" from side wall (16"-18" req'd. for wheelchair stall). Federal Guideline: 604.2Provide Required Toilet Clear Space Medium $1,200Notes: Clearance is 44" from the wall to the sink at the toilet (60" req'd). Room is 69" width at toilet wall, relocate sink within the room to provide clear space. Cost includes moving existing sink and plumbing work outside of required clear spaces.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Replace Flush Controls Low $100Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Provide Compliant Grab Bars High $1,000Notes: No grab bars provided, required on rear and side walls. Provide and install compliant grab bars on the side and rear walls.Federal Guideline: 604.5


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Transfer Shower Low $3,500Notes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible, including in this space. Compliant transfer shower that is 36"x36" with compliant seat and grab bars required. Cost provided to remove and replace existing shower compartment.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608

17-1 Women's Shower

Provide Informational Signage High $200Notes: Consider providing visual, directional sign with visual text indicating that persons in a wheelchair that need a compliant shower compartment should use the family restroom shower. Add sign only after family restroom shower is made compliant. Provide signs visible at both entrances.Federal Guideline: 216, 703Reposition Clothing Hook Low $50Notes: Hook on wall at showers at 60" ht. (15"-48" req'd.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 608.3Provide Compliant Shower Head N/A N/ANotes: A removable shower head with a 59" long min. flexible hose is required. There is only a spout provided.Federal Guideline: 608.6Provide Compliant Clear Space N/A N/ANotes: The clear space is 60" from the rear wall of the compartment (is 60" deep and 36" wide). Wheelchair user could not reach the grab bars or seat from the compartment entrance.Federal Guideline: 608.3.1, 607.4.2.2Provide Compliant Transfer Shower Seat N/A N/ANotes: Top of seat is at 21-1/2" (17-19" req'd.), rear of rectangular seat is 3" from seat wall (2-1/2" max.) and front of seat is 17-3/4" from seat wall (15-16" req'd.). Seat is 14" from the rear wall (1-1/2" max.). New seat should be considered if altered. Federal Guideline: 610

Notes: The showers in this facility include both gang style at the door intended for swimmers to wash down prior to/after using the pool and a non-compliant compartment. The gang style shower has numerous fixed heads and controllers with an open curb access that could be used by a wheelchair. The compartment meets neither roll-in or transfer requirements for various problems. Information provided about the compartment for information only. Most compliant option for a wheelchair users would be to use the gang showers as an alternate roll-in type but there are no seats (not required for roll-in shower), compliant removable shower head, or grab bars. Alternate option would be to remove portion of block wall to create a compliant transfer shower compartment at a much higher cost. Information provided for compartment for information only and suggested that directional sign be provided at entrance to shower/restroom to encourage disabled persons needing an accessible shower to use the family restroom shower once it is altered to be compliant.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Grab Bars N/A N/ANotes: Grab bars and controls would need to be altered to provide the 36" deep transfer compartment.Federal Guideline: 609

17-2 Men's Shower

Provide Informational Signage High $200Notes: Consider providing visual, directional sign with visual text indicating that persons in a wheelchair that need a compliant shower compartment should use the family restroom shower. Add sign only after family restroom shower is made compliant. Provide signs visible at both entrances.Federal Guideline: 216, 703Reposition Clothing Hook Low $50Notes: Hook on wall at showers at 60" ht. (15"-48" req'd.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 608.3Provide Compliant Shower Head N/A N/ANotes: A removable shower head with a 59" long min. flexible hose is required. There is only a spout provided.Federal Guideline: 608.6Provide Compliant Clear Space N/A N/ANotes: The clear space is 60" from the rear wall of the compartment (is 60" deep and 36-1/2" wide). Wheelchair user could not reach the grab bars or seat from the compartment entrance.Federal Guideline: 608.3.1, 607.4.2.2Provide Compliant Transfer Shower Seat N/A N/ANotes: Top of seat is at 21-1/2" (17-19" req'd.), rear of rectangular seat is 3" from seat wall (2-1/2" max.) and front of seat is 17-3/4" from seat wall (15-16" req'd.). Seat is 16" from the rear wall (1-1/2" max.). New seat should be considered if altered. Federal Guideline: 610Provide Compliant Grab Bars N/A N/ANotes: Grab bars and controls would need to be altered to provide the 36" deep transfer compartment.Federal Guideline: 609

Notes: The showers in this facility include both gang style at the door intended for swimmers to wash down prior to/after using the pool and a non-compliant compartment. The gang style shower has numerous fixed heads and controllers with an open curb access that could be used by a wheelchair. The compartment meets neither roll-in or transfer requirements for various problems. Information provided about the compartment for information only. Most compliant option for a wheelchair users would be to use the gang showers as an alternate roll-in type but there are no seats (not required for roll-in shower), compliant removable shower head, or grab bars. Alternate option would be to remove portion of block wall to create a compliant transfer shower compartment at a much higher cost, especially considering that the width of the Men's compartment is 36-1/2". This would require a 1/2" wall treatment be attached to the block to provide 36" absolute width. Information provided for compartment for information only and suggested that directional sign be provided at entrance to shower/restroom to encourage disabled persons needing an accessible shower to use the family restroom shower once it is altered to be compliant.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost18-1 First Aid Room

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No sign provided. Provide signage that includes tactile and visual characters and Braille on latch side wall.Federal Guideline: 216.3, 216.8, 703, 703.7.2.1

18-2 Nursing Mom & Baby RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Sign with only visual text located on the door. Provide signage that includes tactile and visual characters and Braille on latch side wall.Federal Guideline: 216.3, 216.8, 703, 703.7.2.1Provide Compliant Entrance Low $800Notes: Clear width of the door entrance is only 29-1/2" (32" min.). Modify doorway and provide compliant door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.3Provide Compliant Door Hardware Medium $220Notes: Door has knobs that require tight grasping and twisting. Federal Guideline: 206.4, 404.2.7

18-3 Offices and Employee Break RoomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $400Notes: No sign provided outside of entry door or at several doors inside. Provide signage that includes tactile and visual characters and Braille on latch side wall at all doors to permanent rooms.Federal Guideline: 216.3, 216.8, 703, 703.7.2.1Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 52" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Protect Protruding Objects Medium $50Notes: Fire extinguisher near the door protrude 5" at 33" (4" max. between 27-80"). Federal Guideline: 307.2

18 Concessions BuildingProvide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: No sign provided at doors. Provide signage that includes tactile and visual characters and Braille on latch side wall at all doors.Federal Guideline: 216.3, 216.8, 703, 703.7.2.1Provide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $900Notes: Service counter is at 40” height (36" max. req'd. for verbal interaction). Provide min. 36" wide section of service counter at 36" max. height.Federal Guideline: 227.3, 904.5


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost23a-1 Pool

Pool Deck Surface Slope N/A N/A

Notes: Many areas of the areas surrounding the pool have compound slopes that can easily exceed 2% cross slope. Few exceed 3% and would be traversable by most wheelchairs. Most of the steeper areas are distant from the entrance and unlikely to be frequented by non-ambulatory persons. Provided for information only, consider modifications when pool deck is reconstructed in the future.

Federal Guideline: 403.3Protect/Reposition Protruding Objects Low $100Notes: Planter baskets at entrance protrude more than 4" max. between 27-80". Provide permanent cane-detectable object below or relocate them.Federal Guideline: 307.2Provide Compliant Pool Lift High N/ANotes: Pool perimeter well over 300', 2 compliant accessible means of entry are required. The existing pool lift is movable and was evaluated while in storage. Verified all requirements except for ability of lift to provide a submerged depth of 18" min. from the top of the seat (assumed). Ensure that pool lift is secured to the pool deck in location that provides max. of 48" water depth. Also ensure lift batteries are charged at all times. Federal Guideline: 1009Provide Compliant Sloped Entry High TBD

Notes: Handrails that are provided in several locations of the sloped entry side of the pool are not compliant. Handrails are required to be on both sides of an entry 33-38" apart (existing handrails are single) for the full length of the entry (not full length) with a top surface is at 33-1/2" above bottom of the pool (34-38" req'd.). Landing at the bottom of the sloped entry it to be at 24-30" water depth (appears to be over 30" depth). Investigate options to provide compliant sloped entry with compliant handrails and landing at proper water depth. Alternate is to provide a different, compliant means of entry.Federal Guideline: Chapter 4, 505, 1009


General Notes:1. The pool property includes a separate parking area at the corner of Providence Road and Robertsville Road but has no pedestrian access route connection to the pool. No information was collected on this parking area.2. Stairs at the restroom exits are not part of any required access or egress route and not evaluated. An alternate route out of the restroom to the pool via the main entrance and use of the ramp is available.

NOTE: An aquatic wheelchair is available for use upon request.



ExteriorItem # Description Priority Probable Cost01a-1 Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking - ADVISORY N/A N/ANotes: All existing parking is compliant. Consideration could be given to providing at least 1 accessible space at the Secret City area of A.K. Bissell Park. There is no other parking close to that feature but it is connected to other routes within the park with parking available at the Municipal Center and Civic Center/Recreation Center parking lots.Federal Guideline: 208.3

04-1 Sidewalk from Accessible Parking to Main EntranceProvide Compliant Accessible Route Low $50Notes: There are locations along the route to the main front entrance that have separated joints up to 1" wide (1/2" max.) Provide a compliant joint filler.Federal Guideline: 403

InteriorCommon Circulation Areas

07-1 Drinking Fountains at Restrooms Protect Protruding Objects Medium $200

Notes: Drinking fountains not within compliant alcove, protruding into circulation area. Provide permanent, cane-detectable barriers on both sides of fountains.

Federal Guideline: 307.209-1 Hallway between Lobby and Children's Room

Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No signage is provided at 110 Janitor's closet. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille located on the wall adjacent to the latch side of the door.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

Total existing spaces provided is 127, with 8 marked as accessible including 2 van-accessible. Based on parking count, 5 accessible spaces are required within this parking facility, including 1 van-accessible.

Public Library

City of Oak RidgePublic Library Page 1 of 10

Item # Description Priority Probable CostProtect Protruding Objects High $100Notes: AED unit in passageway protrudes into the circulation area. Provide permanent, cane-detectable object below.Federal Guideline: 307.2101 Children's Room

08a-2 Main Front EntranceProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

18-2 Children's RoomLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100

Notes: No signage is provided at 104 Office. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille located on the wall adjacent to the latch side of door.

Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703106 Boy's Restroom

15-1 Boy's RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Sign is located on the door and includes only visual text "MEN". Provide compliant sign on latch side wall that includes visual and tactile letters, and Braille without the ISA. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The closing speed is less then 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Modify Wheelchair Stall Hardware Medium $350Notes: Handles not provided on the stall door (req'd. on both sides) and door is not self-closing. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2Provide Compliant Wheelchair Stall N/A N/ANotes: One stall present, is less than 36" wide (60" min.), has flush controls on wall side, and no grab bars. As noted, ensure sign does not include ISA since accessible restroom will be adult restroom immediately adjacent. Federal Guideline: 404, 604

Notes: The children's restrooms are not fully compliant with standards for children, particularly since 604.9 provides for varying standards for 3 different age groups. All age groups (3-4, 5-8, and 9-12) could be expected to use the facilities. However, since none of these children would be expected to be at the library without a parent or guardian, these restrooms should be deemed need to meet the higher age class recommendations since lower age groups would likely have assistance by a parent or guardian. Currently neither child restroom is accessible to a wheelchair.


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost107 Girl's Restroom

15-2 Girl's RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Sign is located on the door and includes only visual text "MEN". Provide compliant sign on latch side wall that includes visual and tactile letters, and Braille without the ISA. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The closing speed is less then 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Modify Wheelchair Stall Hardware Medium $200Notes: Handles not provided on the stall door (req'd. on both sides). Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2Provide Compliant Wheelchair Stall N/A N/ANotes: One stall present, is less than 36" wide (60" min.), door opens into the stall, and no grab bars. As noted, ensure sign does not include ISA since accessible restroom will be adult restroom immediately adjacent. Federal Guideline: 404, 604108 Women's Restroom

15-5 Women’s Public Restroom Provide Compliant Signage Low $50Notes: Sign is mounted with bottom of the lowest tactile letters at 63" (60" max.). Reposition sign.Federal Guideline: 703.3.2, 216.8, 703.6Modify Wheelchair Stall Hardware Medium $350Notes: Handles not provided on the stall door (req'd. on both sides). Door is not self-closing.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2Replace Flush Controls Low $100Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall High $1,800Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 36" (60" min.), grab bar top surface at 32" (33-36" req'd.), and grab bars provided only on side walls (req'd. on side and rear walls). Consider converting to single-user toilet room, providing door lock, eliminating one stall, installing compliant grab bars, reinstalling toilet paper dispenser, and removing toilet partitions to provide required clear widths. Verify plumbing code fixture count requirements prior to finalizing design. Cost provided is estimate and will vary depending on options available.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4, 604.3

Notes: The children's restrooms are not fully compliant with standards for children, particularly since 604.9 provides for varying standards for 3 different age groups. All age groups (3-4, 5-8, and 9-12) could be expected to use the facilities. However, since none of these children would be expected to be at the library without a parent or guardian, these restrooms should be deemed need to meet the higher age class recommendations since lower age groups would likely have assistance by a parent or guardian. Currently neither child restroom is accessible to a wheelchair.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostRelocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hooks are at 52" ht. (48" max.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48" or relocate hook to wall when partitions removed.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4109 Men's Restroom

15-3 Men’s Public Restroom Provide Compliant Signage Low $50Notes: Sign is mounted with bottom of the lowest tactile letters at 63" (60" max.). Reposition sign.Federal Guideline: 703.3.2, 216.8, 703.6Modify Wheelchair Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: Handles not provided on outside of the stall door (req'd. on both sides). Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall High $1,500Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is 36" (60" min.), grab bar top surface at 31" (33-36" req'd.), and grab bars provided only on side walls (req'd. on side and rear walls). Consider converting to single-user toilet room, providing door lock, removing urinal, installing compliant grab bars, reinstalling toilet paper dispenser, and removing toilet partitions to provide required clear widths. Verify plumbing code fixture count requirements prior to finalizing design. Cost provided is estimate and will vary depending on options available.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4, 604.3Relocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hooks are at 52" ht. (48" max.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48" or relocate hook to wall when partitions removed.Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4112 Auditorium

08b-1 Auditorium Room Door Distant from the StageProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No signage is provided. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille located on the wall adjacent to the latch side of the door.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b-2 Auditorium Room Door Nearest the StageProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text "AUDITORIUM" on the side wall of the entryway. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to the door.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Operating force is 8 lbs. (5 lb. max.) for interior vestibule doors. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9

18-1 Auditorium Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Access to Stage Low $1,500Notes: Access to the stage is via 2 steps at either end, the steps do not have the same height riser as required and has no handrails. Adequate room for a small ramp with handrails at one of the ends.Federal Guideline: 303.2, 303.3Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space as required.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Provide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: No signage is provided at 102 Storage, 103 Projector Room, or 115 Storage. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille located on the wall adjacent to the latch side of each door.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703113 Kitchen

08b-4 Staff Breakroom Door to KitchenProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text for staff lounge on the door on the kitchen side. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to the door on both sides identifying the space beyond. Door lacks closer so signs cannot be placed on the door.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

08b Auditorium Door to KitchenProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text on the door on the auditorium side. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to the door on both sides identifying the space beyond. Door lacks closer so signs cannot be placed on the door.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

35a-1 KitchenReposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim is 36" high (34" max. req'd). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Kitchen with oven/range is required to have knee space below the sink. Cost may vary due to countertop type.Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space as required.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost116 Staff Lounge

08b-3 Staff Breakroom DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100

Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text "STAFF" on the door. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to the door (cannot be on the door unless hold-open device is removed).

Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Operating force is 8 lbs. (5 lb. max.) for interior vestibule doors. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9

18-4 Staff Break Room Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space as required.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72117 Staff Women's Restroom

15-6 Women's Staff RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: The is no signage provided other than a paper, handwritten note taped to the door that it is unisex and to open the door slowly. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to the door without the ISA and include informational sign also noting the location of the accessible restrooms in the adjacent corridor.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware N/A N/ANotes: Existing chain slide lock requires grasping and ability to insert lock into slide. This may be difficult for persons with upper mobility impairments. Provide compliant lock hardware.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door N/A N/ANotes: There is only 2" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.). Explore options to provide clear space, which may require elimination of closet in outer hallway and modifications to walls inside restroom.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

Notes: The staff restrooms both have paper signs on the door noting that they are "unisex" and appear to have been recently modified to be unisex by addition of chain slide locks. Sign directs staff to "open door slowly", assumedly to determine lock is engaged or not. Neither is accessible but could be made accessible with modifications reasonably easily if a lock were provided on the door, interior toilet compartment stalls removed, removal of toilet/urinal, and addition of compliant features that are lacking (e.g., grab bars) or not currently compliant. Assumed that the public restrooms will be the accessible restrooms, items noted below are for information only unless cost and priority is included.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror N/A N/A

Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 46" high (40" max.).

Federal Guideline: 603.3Provide Required Stall Hardware N/A N/ANotes: No handle is provided on the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Provide Compliant Wheelchair Stall N/A N/ANotes: The width of the doorway is 29" (32" min.), the width of the stall is 36" (60" min.), and the stall depth clear space outside the door swing is only 42" (59" min. for floor-mounted toilet).Federal Guideline: 404.2.3, 604Provide Compliant Height Toilet Seat in Wheelchair Stall N/A N/ANotes: Toilet seat height is at 15" (17-19" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.4Provide Compliant Flush Controls N/A N/ANotes: Flush controls are foot controlled and located near the floor. Provide auto-flush sensor or compliant manual flush control at 15-48" height.Federal Guideline: 604.6Provide Compliant Grab Bars N/A N/ANotes: No grab bars provided, required on the side and rear walls.Federal Guideline: 604.7Relocate Coat Hook N/A N/ANotes: Coat hook on the back of the stall door is at 62" ht. (max.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4118 Staff Men's Restroom

15-4 Men's Staff RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: The is no signage provided other than a paper, handwritten note taped to the door that it is unisex and to open the door slowly. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to the door without the ISA and include informational sign also noting the location of the accessible restrooms in the adjacent corridor.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

Notes: The staff restrooms both have paper signs on the door noting that they are "unisex" and appear to have been recently modified to be unisex by addition of chain slide locks. Sign directs staff to "open door slowly", assumedly to determine lock is engaged or not. Neither is accessible but could be made accessible with modifications reasonably easily if a lock were provided on the door, interior toilet compartment stalls removed, removal of toilet/urinal, and addition of compliant features that are lacking (e.g., grab bars) or not currently compliant. Assumed that the public restrooms will be the accessible restrooms, items noted below are for information only unless cost and priority is included.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Door Hardware N/A N/ANotes: Existing chain slide lock requires grasping and ability to insert lock into slide. This may be difficult for persons with upper mobility impairments. Provide compliant lock hardware.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 404.2.7Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door N/A N/ANotes: There is only 2" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.). Explore options to provide clear space, which may require elimination of closet in outer hallway and modifications to walls inside restroom.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Reposition Sink N/A N/ANotes: Sink rim at 34-1/2" high (34" max. req'd.). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3Provide Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror N/A N/A

Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 50" high (40" max.).

Federal Guideline: 603.3Provide Compliant Urinal - OPTIONAL N/A N/ANotes: The top lip of the urinal is at 20" (17" max.). The flush control for the urinal is foot controlled and not able to be operated by person in wheelchair. Only 1 urinal present so compliance not required.Federal Guideline: 305.7.1, 605.2, 605.4Provide Required Stall Hardware N/A N/ANotes: No handle is provided on the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Provide Compliant Wheelchair Stall N/A N/ANotes: The width of the doorway is 29" (32" min.), the width of the stall is 36" (60" min.), and the stall depth clear space outside the door swing is only 42" (59" min. for floor-mounted toilet).Federal Guideline: 404.2.3, 604Provide Compliant Height Toilet Seat in Wheelchair Stall N/A N/ANotes: Toilet seat height is at 15" (17-19" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.4Provide Compliant Flush Controls N/A N/ANotes: Flush controls are foot controlled and located near the floor. Provide auto-flush sensor or compliant manual flush control at 15-48" height.Federal Guideline: 604.6Provide Compliant Grab Bars N/A N/ANotes: No grab bars provided, required on the side and rear walls.Federal Guideline: 604.7


Item # Description Priority Probable CostRelocate Coat Hook N/A N/ANotes: Coat hook on the back of the stall door is at 62" ht. (max.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4119 Director Offices Reception

18 Director OfficesProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100

Notes: Existing signage at entry to reception area includes only visual text on glass. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to the door (cannot be on the door because door opens out).

Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Medium $110Notes: The glazing on the door is at 6" high (10" min. smooth req'd.). Provide kick plate with filler on push side of door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to the door for director offices.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703123 Main Entrance Lobby

08a-1 Main Front EntranceProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08a Rear Emergency ExitProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

18-3 Library Main Front Lobby Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Accessible Service Counter or Alternate Accommodation Medium $900Notes: Service counter is at 42” height (36" max. req'd. for verbal interaction). Provide min. 36" wide section of service counter at 36" max. height.Federal Guideline: 227.3, 904.5Protect Protruding Objects High $100Notes: Fire alarm controller protrudes into the circulation area. Provide permanent, cane-detectable object below.Federal Guideline: 307.2


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost125 Main Reading Room

08a Front Service EntranceProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08a Rear Emergency ExitProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

18-3 Main Reading RoomLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 51" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Compliant Signage Medium $600Notes: Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to the door for all doors to 126 Storage, 127 Typing Room, 128 Work Room, and door from work room to service entry area.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


General Notes:1. The site includes a single parking facility that is connected by an interior drive to the adjacent Civic Center/Recreation Center/Senior Center. Parking on the site provides direct access to the Library, as well as portions of A.K. Bissell Park and should be dispersed accordingly as presented above.2. It is assumed that the north curb ramp is along the accessible route from accessible parking to the Library entrance. There are multiple locations on the east side at the accessible parking that provide access to the accessible route to the east entrance at the children's reading room. The sidewalk on the east side is not on any accessible route nor is the sidewalk in the front of the building beyond the main entrance. The south curb ramp and sidewalk on the east side are not included in the evaluation.3. This facility includes 3 sets of restrooms. 1 is a pair designated for children that is not accessible to a wheelchair user. There is also 1 pair for the public adjacent to the child restrooms which are also currently not accessible to a wheelchair. The other set is for employee use only and located in the staff lounge. It is recommended that the public set of restrooms be made fully compliant for wheelchair access, which will result in the loss of fixtures. Confirm fixture count based on occupancy load. Consider modifications to combine the child and adult restrooms into a pair of adult multi-user restrooms or other alterations/additions. It is assumed that the employee restrooms will not be made compliant, though if converted to single-user there may be space available to do so.4. This facility is equipped with an updated visual fire alarm system. All public and common use spaces are required to have visual fire alarms, including hallways, restrooms, meeting rooms, etc. Only private offices and other exempt spaces are not required to provide visual fire alarms. Ensure capacity of existing system to provide and install visual fire alarms in all required spaces.



ExteriorItem # Description Priority Probable Cost

Parking01a-1 Main Parking Lot

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Low $3,000Notes: Slopes of parking stalls and access aisle up to 3.2% (2% max.). Access aisle and parking space pavement markings are very faded and need to be redone. Provide level parking area when lot is resurfaced, repaint pavement markings in the interim.Federal Guideline: 302, 502.4

01a South Parking Area

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking N/A N/ANotes: No markings or signage is present. Pavement is badly spalled and uneven, slopes exceed 2% max. for accessible parking. Min. of 1 van-accessible space would be required if designated for parking, space available for only 2 vehicles with an access aisle.Federal Guideline: 302, 502.4Accessible Routes and Curb Ramps

02-1 Main Parking Lot Curb RampProvide Compliant Curb Ramp Medium $4,500Notes: There are 2 curb ramps present, both have excessive running slopes and neither provides a level landing/turning space to access the route to the building entrance. Recommend that 1 curb ramp be converted to a parallel ramp and the other be eliminated and converted to level sidewalk. Ensure smooth transition to new curb ramp at asphalt drive. Consider pavement markings and signage at entry/exit drive near accessible spaces and curb ramp to delineate the route to the curb ramp and also visually alert drivers of potential for pedestrians. Cost assumes above improvements.Federal Guideline: 405, 406

Total existing spaces provided is 48, with 2 marked as accessible including 1 van-accessible. Based on parking count, 2 accessible spaces are required within this parking facility, including 1 van-accessible. An additional 2 parking spaces are located to the south immediately adjacent to the ROW that appear to access the access route to the side door and playground, with a crosswalk present also to the park across the street. These parking spaces are counted as a separate facility given their means of access is only from Carver Avenue.

Scarboro Community

Center

Parking located to the south of the facility immediately adjacent to the ROW. Spaces are no longer marked and have no signage, though historically they did. Unsure of status or past/current intended use, seems as though this is not being designated for parking use any longer but is available. Information noted below for informational purposes and consideration if this area is intended to be used for parking at the center or the park across the street.

City of Oak RidgeScarboro Community Center Page 1 of 14

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost04-1 Main Entrance Sidewalks

Provide Compliant Accessible Route High included aboveNotes: The cross slope of the sidewalk at the curb ramps is a hazard at over 10%. Make corrections noted to curb ramps. Federal Guideline: 403.3

04-2 South Sidewalks from Fence Gate into Play AreaProvide Compliant Accessible Route Medium $5,000Notes: The running slope near the play area exceeds 5% max. and turning space to proceed to shelter far exceeds 2% max. Approximately half of the walk to the shelter have a cross slope up to 4% (2% max.).Federal Guideline: 403Exterior Site Amenities

07-3 Drinking Fountain at ShelterProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $2,000Notes: Only 1 fountain provided, 2 min. required if 1 is provided. Existing bubbler height of 36" is compliant with requirement for wheelchair users. Provide additional fountain for standing user with 38-43" high max. bubbler. Cost assumes new fountain is provided that provides compliant approach and level clear spaces. Federal Guideline: 211, 602

22-1 Site FurnitureProvide Compliant Bench Seating Area Medium $800Notes: There are 6 benches, all located within lawn areas. This does not provide a compliant surface for a wheelchair to access the benches or to be positioned adjacent to a companion on the bench. Relocate a min. of 1 bench or provide connection from accessible route to provide clear space outside of walkway for wheelchair. Best location may be adjacent to sidewalk. Cost assumes 1 new bench is provided to be immediately adjacent to the accessible route and addition of concrete pad adjacent to the bench to provide a clear space for a wheelchair outside of the accessible route.Federal Guideline: 903.2, 1011.2.1Provide Access to Trash Containers Low $400Notes: All trash containers are located within lawn areas and require reach from accessible surface that may be difficult for some to make. Existing containers have lids that may be difficult for someone with an upper body mobility impairment to operate. Provide min. of 1 new trash container that has compliant opening device.Federal Guideline: 309.4, 308.3.2, 1011.3

25-1 Play Equipment AreaProvide Compliant Access to Play Elements Medium $6,000Notes: Compliant accessible route not provided to any ground play elements, with no access to swings, merry-go-round, rockers, or at the end of a slide back to the transfer platform. Existing surface is wood fiber, which requires extensive maintenance to be compliant. Provide accessible surface to ground play elements and end of slide nearest rubber tiles. Federal Guideline: 240


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Transfer Platform Medium $800Notes: Bottom step is too low (below 11"), transfer platform at next step is compliant height but is a triangle shape with 24" sides (req'd. to be 14" deep and 24" wide for entire platform). Explore options, assumed a compliant platform is installed.Federal Guideline: 1008.3

36-1 Park ShelterLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low $50Notes: Electrical switch controls are at 55" (over 48" max. ht.) and exceeds 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2

InteriorCommon Circulation Areas and Lobby

07-2 Drinking Fountains at Main RestroomsProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Medium $600Notes: 50% of drinking fountains are required to each be accessible to either wheelchair users or standing users. Currently there are three (3) total fountains, 2 at this location. The wheelchair accessible fountain at this location has a compliant bubbler height for wheelchair user but was not working at the time of the evaluation and the knee space for wheelchair is only 26-1/4" (27" min.). Reposition this fountain to provide 27" min. knee space and 36" max. bubbler height. Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7Protect Protruding Object Medium $100Notes: Drinking fountain not within compliant alcove, protruding into circulation area at restrooms. Standing fountain is cane-detectable, provide permanent, cane-detectable barrier on wheelchair side of fountain.Federal Guideline: 307.2

08a-2 Main EntryProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Medium $220Notes: 8" to glazing (10" min. smooth req'd.) on both doors. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of both doors.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08a-3 Parks & Recreation Administrative Offices EntranceProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Panic Hardware Low $50Notes: Panic hardware protrudes 5" (4" max.) into the clear opening when the door is fully open but door opening is larger than required. Adjust closer position if possible.Federal Guideline: 404.2.3


Item # Description Priority Probable CostAdjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The closing speed is less than 5 seconds. Cost is for new closer. Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Medium $110Notes: 8" to glazing (10" min. smooth req'd.) on door. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Reposition Doorbell Medium $100Notes: Doorbell to obtain entrance is at 51-1/2" (48" max.) and provides only visual signage with instructions (tactile and Braille req'd.). Button also within door swing, which could be a hazard for users (ADVISORY-relocate outside door swing if possible).Federal Guideline: 309.4, 703Provide Compliant Door Approach and Maneuvering Spaces High $200Notes: Slope at door 2.5% (2% max.) and only 6" clear space perpendicular to the door on the pull side (18" req'd.). Explore options, with most cost effective option being to designate this as a non-accessible entrance. Provide directional signage at walk approach to the door indicating the location of the accessible entrance at the main entrance. Cost assumes directional sign is provided.Federal Guideline: 403, 404.2.4.1

08a-4 West Exit Doors (2)Provide Means of Egress Signage High $200Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to each door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Medium $220Notes: 8" to glazing (10" min. smooth req'd.) on both doors. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of both doors.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Provide Compliant Door Approach and Maneuvering Spaces Low $800Notes: Slopes at door exceed 2% max. Doors are emergency exit only, make corrections in the future if rear walks are improved.Federal Guideline: 403

08b-8 Hallway Door to Parks & Recreation OfficesAdjust Door Closer Medium $900Notes: Operating force is 8 lbs. (5 lb. max.) for both doors. Cost is for new closer at each.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9

09-1 HallwayProvide Compliant Signage Medium $500Notes: Provide compliant signs with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to all doors for offices, janitor closets, and mechanical or electrical closets within park offices corridor.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 50" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProtect Protruding Objects High $100Notes: Mailbox at park offices protrudes into the circulation area. Provide permanent, cane-detectable object below.Federal Guideline: 307.2

15-3 Men's Park Offices Hallway RestroomAdjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed is less than 5 seconds and operating force is 8 lbs. (5 lb. max.). Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1, 404.2.9Provide Required Door Clear Space Low TBDNotes: The distance perpendicular to the door on the latch pull side is only 48" (54" required for latch side approach for doors with closer). Investigate options, which could include removing portion of privacy wall outside entry door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1Reposition Sink Low $600Notes: Sink rim is at 34-1/2" high (34" max.). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max.Federal Guideline: 606.3Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 41-1/2" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The high dispenser is located at 57" high (48" max.) and protrudes into circulation area. Relocate to 48" max. at sink side wall. Federal Guideline: 307.2, 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 54" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Modify Wheelchair Stall Hardware Medium $250Notes: Handle not provided on the inside of the stall door (req'd. on both sides). Door is not self-closing.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2Reconfigure Partitions Medium $1,200Notes: Stall door opening is 12" from wall opposite toilet (4" max.) but toilet is not offset from door opening (toilet is required to be on wall opposite door opening). Reconfigure partitions to provide compliant stall.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1.2Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted 15" in front of toilet (7"-9" to centerline req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Height Toilet Seat in Wheelchair Stall Low $100Notes: Toilet seat height is at 16-1/2" (17-19" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.4


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Grab Bars Low $750Notes: Side grab bar located 13" from rear wall (12" max. req'd.). Rear grab bar is only 30" long (36" min.). Provide new rear grab bar and install both in compliant location.Federal Guideline: 604.5Provide Required Grab Bar Clear Space Low $50Notes: Toilet cleaner dispenser located 3" above rear grab bar (12" clear space required). Relocate dispenser.Federal Guideline: 604.5Relocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hook on back of stall door is at 64" ht. (48" max.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

15-4 Women's Park Offices Hallway RestroomAdjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Operating force is 8 lbs. (5 lb. max.). Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9Provide Required Door Clear Space Low TBDNotes: The distance perpendicular to the door on the latch pull side is only 48" (54" required for latch side approach for doors with closer). Investigate options, which could include removing portion of privacy wall outside entry door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The high dispenser is located at 57" high (48" max.) and protrudes into circulation area. Relocate to 48" max. at sink side wall. Federal Guideline: 307.2, 308, 604.7Modify Wheelchair Stall Hardware Medium $250Notes: Handle not provided on the inside of the stall door (req'd. on both sides). Door is not self-closing.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2Reconfigure Partitions Medium $600Notes: Stall door opening is 5" from wall opposite toilet (4" max.). Reconfigure partitions to provide compliant stall.Federal Guideline: 604.8.1.2Replace Flush Controls Low $100Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: Dispenser mounted 15" in front of toilet (7"-9" to centerline req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Grab Bars Low $750Notes: Side grab bar located 14" from rear wall (12" max. req'd.). Rear grab bar is only 30" long (36" min.). Provide new rear grab bar and install both in compliant location.Federal Guideline: 604.5


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Required Grab Bar Clear Space Low $50Notes: Toilet cleaner dispenser located 3" above rear grab bar (12" clear space required). Relocate dispenser.Federal Guideline: 604.5

18-6 LobbyProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No existing signage present at office next to game room. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to door at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 50-1/2" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space as required.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Gymnasium

07-1 Drinking Fountain at Gym RestroomsProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Medium $600Notes: 50% of drinking fountains are required to each be accessible to either wheelchair users or standing users. Currently there are three (3) total fountains, 1 at this location. This is the only functional fountain with bubbler height at 36" max. (is at 30") but the knee space for wheelchair is only 25-1/4" (27" min.). Reposition this fountain to provide 27" min. knee space and 36" max. bubbler height. Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7Protect Protruding Object Medium $200Notes: Drinking fountain not within compliant alcove, protruding into circulation area at restrooms. Provide permanent, cane-detectable barriers on both sides of fountain.Federal Guideline: 307.2

08a-1 Emergency Exits on North Wall (2)Provide Means of Egress Signage High $200Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

08b-6 Entry Door from LobbyProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No signage provided. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille on the wall to the right when facing double doors from lobby at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $900Notes: Operating force is 8 lbs. (5 lb. max.) for both doors. Cost is for new closer at each.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost15-1 Men's Gym Restroom

Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Operating force is 8 lbs. (5 lb. max.). Cost is for new closer at each.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9Provide Compliant Knee Space Below Sinks Low $350Notes: Sinks only provide 5" deep knee space at 27" above the floor (8" min.). Modify existing panel to provide required knee space. Also provide end panel to eliminate protruding object.Federal Guideline: 306.3, 307.2, 606Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 52" high (48" max.). Consider relocating it over the side of the countertop to not be within wheelchair stall door swing.Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 50" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Compliant Urinal - OPTIONAL N/A N/ANotes: The clear width of alcove for urinal is only 32" (36" min. required for alcove over 24" deep). Only 1 urinal present so compliance not required.Federal Guideline: 305.7.1, 605Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handle is provided on the outside of the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Provide Compliant Height Toilet Seat in Wheelchair Stall Low $100Notes: Toilet seat height is at 16-1/2" (17-19" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.4Reposition Grab Bars Low $250Notes: Side grab bar extends only 51" from rear wall (54" min. req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.5Provide Required Grab Bar Clear Space Low $50Notes: Toilet cleaner dispenser located 4" above rear grab bar (12" clear space required). Relocate dispenser.Federal Guideline: 604.5Relocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hook on back of stall door is at 66" ht. (48" max.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

15-2 Women's Gym Restroom

Reposition Signage Low $50Notes: Sign with bottom of highest tactile letters at 60-3/4" (60" max.). Lower the sign.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703

NOTE: Wheelchair stall had an "OUT OF ORDER" sign taped on the outside. Appeared as though some plumbing work was being done on Men's side (was hole cut in drywall).

NOTE: Wheelchair stall had an "OUT OF ORDER" sign taped on the outside. Appeared as though some plumbing work was being done on Men's side (was hole cut in drywall).


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Knee Space Below Sinks Low $350Notes: Sinks only provide 5" deep knee space at 27" above the floor (8" min.). Modify existing panel to provide required knee space. Also provide end panel to eliminate protruding object.Federal Guideline: 306.3, 307.2, 606Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 52" high (48" max.). Consider relocating it over the side of the countertop to not be within wheelchair stall door swing.Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 50" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Required Stall Hardware Medium $100Notes: No handle is provided on the outside of the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Reposition Grab Bars Low $250Notes: Side grab bar extends only 52" from rear wall (54" min. req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.5Provide Required Grab Bar Clear Space Low $50Notes: Toilet cleaner dispenser located 4" above rear grab bar (12" clear space required). Relocate dispenser.Federal Guideline: 604.5Relocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hook on back of stall door is at 53" ht. (48" max.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

18-5 GymnasiumProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No existing signage present at storage room next to game room. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to door at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Gymnasium Kitchen

08b-5 Entry DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text on the latch side wall. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to each at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

35a-1 Gym KitchenProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No existing signage present at storage room. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to door at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim is 36-1/2" high (34" max. req'd). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Kitchen with oven/range is required to have knee space below the sink, existing knee space at 27" high is only 7" (8" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 306.3.3, 606.2, 606.3Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 50" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Reposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlets mounted at 46" height with 24-1/2" reach over countertop (44" max. reach if over 20-25" reach over counter.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Replace Range/Oven Medium $1,000Notes: Controls must be operable without reaching over burners. Purchase new range/oven that has all controls on front panel.Federal Guideline: 804.6.4, 804.6.5.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 52" high (48" max.). Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7A/B Room

08b-1 Entry Doors (2)Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text on the latch side wall. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to each door at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

18-1 A/B RoomLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 50" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Computer Lab

08b-2 Entry Doors (2)Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Existing signage in lobby includes only visual text on the latch side wall. No signage provided at entry door in hallway. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to each door at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

18-2 Computer LabLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 49-1/2" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Working Surface Low N/ANotes: Ensure that at least 1 computer station provides min. 27" knee space below for wheelchair user and has clear space for approach.Federal Guideline: 306 Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space as required.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72D Room

08a Emergency ExitProvide Means of Egress Signage High $200Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Threshold Low $150Notes: Threshold exceeds 1/2" max., provide compliant threshold.Federal Guideline: 404.2.5Adjust Panic Hardware Low $50Notes: Panic hardware protrudes 4-3/4" (4" max.) into the clear opening when the door is fully open but door opening is larger than required. Adjust closer position if possible.Federal Guideline: 404.2.3

08b-3 Entry Doors (2)Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Existing signage in lobby includes only visual text on the latch side wall. No signage provided at entry door in hallway. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to each door at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $900Notes: Operating force is 18 lbs. (5 lb. max.) for both doors. Cost is for new closer at each.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9

18-3 D RoomLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 50" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Game Room

08b-4 Entry Doors (2)Provide Compliant Signage Medium $300Notes: Existing signage in lobby includes only visual text on the latch side wall. No signage provided at entry door in gym. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to each door at compliant height. Provide sign on both sides of door to gym.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable CostAdjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Operating force is 20 lbs. (5 lb. max.) for entry door from gym. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9

18-4 Game RoomLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 50" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Means of Signage High $100Notes: Visual Signage present, Tactile signage required.Federal Guideline: 216, 703Staff Break Room

08b-9 Entry DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: No existing signage present. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to door at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Operating force is 12 lbs. (5 lb. max.) for entry door from gym. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9Provide Maneuvering Space at Pull Side of Door Low TBDNotes: Only 16" clear space perpendicular to the door on the pull side (18" min.). Explore options, which may include modifications to cabinet that currently blocks clear space.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1

35b-1 Break Room KitchenetteProvide Wheelchair Turning Space Low TBDNotes: Inadequate space within room to provide 60" diameter turning area for wheelchair. Explore options, which may include moving items to lounge and convert this space to another use.Federal Guideline: 212.3, 606.3Reposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim is 36-1/4" high (34" max. req'd). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Refrigeration blocks sink approach.Federal Guideline: 212.3, 606.3Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 50" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Reposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlets mounted at 45" height with 24-1/2" reach over countertop (44" max. reach if over 20-25" reach over counter.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 54" high (48" max.) and blocked by refrigerator. Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Multi-Purpose Room

08b-10 Entry Doors (2)Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Existing signage at east door includes only visual text on the latch side wall. No signage provided at west door. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to each door at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $900Notes: Operating force is 12 lbs. and 15 lbs. (5 lb. max.) for east and west entry doors. Cost is for new closer at both doors.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9

18-7 Multi-Purpose RoomLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch controls are at 50" (over 48" max. ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered.Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308, 305.3, 308.2Provide Means of Signage High $100Notes: Visual Signage present, Tactile signage required.Federal Guideline: 216, 703Staff Lounge

08b-11 Entry DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Existing signage at east door includes only visual text "LOUNGE" on the door. No signage provided at west door. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall adjacent to each door at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Operating force is over 20 lbs. (5 lb. max.) for entry door. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9Modify Vision Panel Medium $450Notes: Vision panel below 66" is at 55" ht. (43" max.)Federal Guideline: 404.2.11

35a-2 LoungeReposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim is 36-1/2" high (34" max. req'd). Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Kitchen with oven/range is required to have knee space below the sink (cabinet present). Federal Guideline: 306.3.3, 606.2, 606.3


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReplace Range/Oven Medium $1,000Notes: Controls must be operable without reaching over burners. Purchase new range/oven that has all controls on front panel.Federal Guideline: 804.6.4, 804.6.5.3Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space as required.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72


General Notes:1. There are 2 parking areas, a main lot and a small parking area to the south directly off Carver Avenue. The small area had no markings or signage and is in need of reconstruction/maintenance. Access to the play area and picnic shelter on the site is provided from this parking, along with access across Carver via marked crosswalk to the park on the other side.2. There are 3 total drinking fountains inside the building. 1 each is required to meet standards for wheelchair user and standing user, the 3rd can meet either. At the time of the evaluation the wheelchair fountain was not functional at the main restrooms but wheelchair fountain available at gymnasium restrooms, however it does not provide adequate knee space below. Adjust fountain to provide knee space and repair other fountain. Both a protruding objects at restrooms and need to be protected by creating an artificial alcove as noted above.




Provide Compliant Accessible Route Low $3,500

Notes: There is no parking at the site. The entire length of park frontage on Carver Avenue is fenced and curbed. There are 2 openings in the fence for pedestrians, including at a marked crosswalk from Scarboro Community Center, and 2 gated openings for vehicles. There are no accessible routes into the site or to site features. Cost assumes a curb ramp with detectable warnings and accessible route is provided at the existing crosswalk markings to the fence opening. Other routes interior at the facility that are required are presented below.

Federal Guideline: 40307-1 Drinking Fountain

Provide Compliant Accessible Route Low $4,000Notes: This segment of accessible route will connect from the gate to the existing concrete pad at the drinking fountain.Federal Guideline: 403Provide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $2,500Notes: Only 1 fountain provided, 2 min. required if 1 is provided. Existing bubbler height of 37" is compliant with requirement for neither wheelchair (36" max.) or standing (38-43" req'd.) users and is post mount type with no knee space. Adjust mount to elevate existing fountain and provide additional wheelchair accessible fountain along a compliant accessible route outside of the route so as to not be a protruding object. Cost assumes new wheelchair fountain is provided. Federal Guideline: 211, 602.4, 602.7

24-1 Ball FieldProvide Compliant Accessible Route Low $2,000Notes: An accessible route is required to connects to the boundary of each area of sport activity, i.e. soccer fields, basketball courts, baseball fields, running tracks, skating rinks, etc. Provide a connecting accessible route segment from the drinking fountain to the gate at the boundary of the field.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403

Scarboro Park

City of Oak RidgeScarboro Park Page 1 of 2

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost24-2 Tennis Court

Provide Compliant Accessible Route Low $8,000Notes: An accessible route is required to connects to the boundary of each area of sport activity, i.e. soccer fields, basketball courts, baseball fields, running tracks, skating rinks, etc. Provide a connecting accessible route segment from the drinking fountain to the gate entry to courts.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403

24-3 Basketball CourtProvide Compliant Accessible Route Low $7,000Notes: An accessible route is required to connects to the boundary of each area of sport activity, i.e. soccer fields, basketball courts, baseball fields, running tracks, skating rinks, etc. Provide a connecting accessible route segment from the drinking fountain to the gate entry to courts.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403Provide Wheelchair Seating Medium $400

Notes: No seats available for wheelchairs adjacent to seating. Seating is approximately 36, requiring 2 wheelchair companion seats. Provide 2, 30"x48" min. wheelchair spaces at bleacher, 1 on each side adjacent to companion seat.

Federal Guideline: 221.1, 221.2.3.2, 802.1


General Notes: 1. There is no compliant surface accessible routes into or on the site. See items above for details regarding what is required and cost. The park includes a tennis court, ball court, drinking fountain, and softball field. Access is required to all features. Costs provided assume pavement, lower cost options may be available that would provide a compliant surface.

City of Oak RidgeScarboro Park Page 2 of 2


East Park Area with Fishing PierItem # Description Priority Probable Cost01a-1 Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $750Notes: Only 2 signs provided for 3 accessible spaces with no van sign. No space and adjacent access aisle meets van dimensional requirements. West space is only 67" wide (96" min.) and adjacent access aisle is only 53" wide (60" min. for car space. Shared access aisle for the east spaces is only 92" wide (96" min.). All existing markings for spaces and access aisles is very faded. Restripe the area to provide compliant dimensioned spaces (left to right when facing spaces from drive aisle) of 8'-8'-8'-5'-8'. Existing area is short approximately 33", which may not be available with losing 1 existing parking space at this area. Cost assumes restriping of the entire accessible parking area and providing 1 additional sign with van tag and moving existing sign in middle of access aisle to middle of parking space (perhaps attach to bollard). Another option would be to eliminate 1 accessible space from this location and move it to provide dispersal within park as recommended below.Federal Guideline: 208, 502Provide Accessible Space Dispersal Medium $300Notes: The fishing pier is the most important feature to provide access to but additional amenities are present that should provide accessible spaces and routes. Consider providing 1 accessible space and access aisle at the west end of this area of the park to provide access to the shoreline and picnic facilities. Possible locations could include one of the angle parking areas or the parallel parking loop. Cost assumes level parking area is provided with pavement markings and signage.Federal Guideline: 208.3

Parking at this area of the park is provided from both 5 angled parking areas scattered along the loop road as well as parallel parking along the outside of the smaller loop near the former boat ramp. The only spaces on the site that are marked are those at the location of the accessible parking at the access point to the fishing pier. Based on the space available in the smaller loop and spaces at the main loop delineated by bumper blocks, the total existing spaces is 40, including 3 marked as accessible, including 1 van-accessible. Based on parking count, 2 accessible spaces are required, including 1 van-accessible space.

Solway Park

City of Oak RidgeSolway Park Page 1 of 4


Provide Compliant Accessible Route to Fishing Platform Low $300Notes: The route to the fishing platform from accessible parking has minor elevation changes at the interface of the path to the pierhead and pierhead to the pier. Monitor these areas and consider providing a transition plate that can alleviate any concerns. Note also that the wood surface of the fishing pier is weathered and warrants monitoring of the surface condition and perform necessary maintenance to reduce hazards.Federal Guideline: 206.2.1, 403Provide Compliant Accessible Route to Picnic Area Medium $2,500Notes: There is no compliant accessible route from the recommended accessible parking to any picnic table. Provide a compliant sloped surface to connect the parking area described above to the nearest picnic table and include additional pavement to provide clear space for wheelchair. Cost assumes paved surface provided. Investigate options, which may include relocating a picnic table closer to parking to reduce length of accessible route.Federal Guideline: 206.2.1, 403

22-2 Site FurnitureProvide Trash Containers on Accessible Route Low $200Notes: There are numerous trash receptacles, none of which are located on an accessible route. Ensure trash can lid can be operated by person with upper body mobility impairment. Relocate trash containers or provide additional to have min. of 1 at each amenity.Federal Guideline: 1011.2.1



West Park Area with Boat Launch01a-1 Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $15,000Notes: Provide new pavement adjacent to boat launch for 2 accessible parking spaces with shared access aisle which includes 1 space that meets van requirements with extended drop-off area for person in vehicle with trailer to be dropped off as well. 1 additional level accessible space with access aisle should be considered to the east side of the traffic island to provide parking for users of the other site features other than the boat launch. Cost assumes new level area for parking and drop-off provided immediately adjacent to the boat launch and east area with signage as noted. Federal Guideline: 208, 502Provide Accessible Space Dispersal Medium $300

Notes: The boat launch is the most important feature to provide access to but additional amenities are present that should provide accessible spaces and routes. Consider providing 1 accessible space and access aisle at the east end of this area of the park to provide access to the picnic facilities. Cost assumes level parking area is provided with pavement markings and signage.

Federal Guideline: 208.304-1 Accessible Routes

Provide Compliant Accessible Route to Boat Launch Medium $2,500

Notes: There is no compliant accessible route from the recommended accessible parking to the boat launch gangway for a wheelchair. Provide a compliant sloped surface to the extent possible to connect the parking/drop-off area described above to the concrete slab at the boat launch pier. Cost assumes paved surface provided from parking to boat launch area and a transition plate connecting the concrete slab to the gangway to eliminate abrupt elevation change possible with fluctuating water levels and gap between the two areas.


NOTES: Parking at this location is provided within a single facility that is divided into 2 sections by a traffic island. The area to the boat launch side is primarily for vehicles with boat trailers, while the area to the east of the traffic island is for vehicles without trailers. The entire parking lot is in poor condition and there are no pavement markings. No accessible spaces are provided and the condition of the pavement makes provision of compliant spaces unlikely. Counts have been estimated based on dimensions and assumed circulation patterns of the different vehicle types. There is space available for 11 cars in the east area with 16 spaces along the area facing the water. Assuming a reasonable amount of vehicle with trailer circulation, boat prep area, tie down area, and parking there is space available for approximately 18 vehicles with trailers. There are no accessible spaces provided, but based on the approximate parking at the site at least 2 accessible spaces should be provided including 1 van-accessible.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Accessible Route to Picnic Area Medium $4,000Notes: There is no compliant accessible route from the recommended accessible parking to any picnic table. Provide a compliant sloped surface to connect the parking area described above to the nearest picnic table and include additional pavement to provide clear space for wheelchair. Cost assumes paved surface provided. Investigate options, which may include relocating a picnic table closer to parking to reduce length of accessible route.Federal Guideline: 206.2.1, 403

22-1 Site FurnitureProvide Trash Containers on Accessible Route Low $200Notes: There are numerous trash receptacles, none of which are located on an accessible route. Ensure trash can lid can be operated by person with upper body mobility impairment. Relocate trash containers or provide additional to have min. of 1 at each amenity.Federal Guideline: 1011.2.1


General Notes: 1. The park has 2 separate areas, each accessed at different locations off Edgemoor Road and with segregated amenities. The west park area includes a parking area with boat launch and some picnic tables and other site furnishings. The east area includes several small parking areas that are considered 1 parking facility since all are interconnected, along with a fishing platform and picnic tables and other site furnishings.




Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $300Notes: All existing markings for spaces and access aisles are very faded. Restripe the area to provide compliant dimensioned spaces Federal Guideline: 208, 502Accessible Routes and Stairways


Provide Compliant Accessible Routes Low $4,500Notes: There is no accessible route provided from stairs near Court 6-8 and existing accessible route at stairs to Court 3-5 is not compliant width and has turf growing in most joints. Provide compliant accessible routes from both stairs, for Courts 6-8 connect to parking access aisle including partial removal of the curb and replace route at Courts 3-5 in current location.Federal Guideline: 403

06-1 Stairway Near Courts 3-5Provide Compliant Stairs and Handrails Low $4,000Notes: Tread surfaces have level changes and surface slopes exceed 3% (2% max.). The slope of the intermediate landing and bottom landing exceeds 2% max. The handrails are corroded and need to be refinished, the bottom section of handrail on one side is bent and neither a consistent height above stair treads or compliant height in some locations. Explore options. Cost provided assumes maintenance work done on stair treads as needed, landings are reconstructed, and handrails are repaired and refinished and repainted. Federal Guideline: 302, 304, 504

Tennis Courts

5 total parking spaces provided, including 2 designated as accessible with 1 van-accessible. Based on parking counts 1 van-accessible space required.

NOTE: Stairways off the ROW of Broadway Avenue discharge into the lawn areas at Courts 6-8 and have non-compliant sidewalks near Courts 3-5. Neither stairway connects to a PAR and are not considered to be an accessible route accessing the courts. Consider making corrective actions noted to improve access for ambulatory persons from Broadway Avenue.

NOTE: The routes immediately following include only the routes from parking to Courts 6-8 and the routes required from the bottom of the stairs to a connecting accessible route. Connecting routes between the courts is presented later for the game and sports areas.

City of Oak RidgeTennis Courts Page 1 of 3

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost06-2 Stairs Near Courts 6-8

Provide Compliant Stairs and Handrails Low $6,000Notes: Tread surfaces have level changes and the bottom landing is not paved. The slope of the top landing is 9% (2% max.). The handrails are provided only on 1 side (required on both) and are corroded and need to be refinished, the top extension is only 6" (12" min.), and there is no extension at the bottom. Explore options. Cost provided assumes maintenance work done on stair treads as needed, landings are reconstructed, and compliant handrails with extensions are provided. Federal Guideline: 302, 304, 504Site Amenities

07-1 Drinking Fountain at Courts 6-8Provide Compliant Drinking Fountain Low $100Notes: The access to the drinking fountain includes an area of broken concrete. Repair concrete.Federal Guideline: 305.2, 602.2

07-2 Drinking Fountain at Courts 1-2 and 3-5 (Typ.)Provide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $800Notes: These fountains are vertical post mounted with no knee space below so accessible only to standing users. Both have bubbler height at 37" (38-43" req'd. for standing user). Neither fountain has paved clear space at fountain. Cost assumes both fountain mounts are adjusted to raise bubbler to 38" min. and additional concrete pad is provided at each.Federal Guideline: 305.2, 602.2, 602.7

24-1 Courts 3-5 Provide Accessible Route to Boundary of Area of Sport Activity Medium $10,000Notes: An accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity (soccer fields, basketball courts, baseball fields, running tracks, skating rinks, etc.). Where multiple sports fields or courts are provided, an accessible route is provided to each field or area of sport activity. No route currently exists from parking to these courts. Provide connection as required with a compliant surface to the perimeter. Cost assumes direct connection from drinking fountain at Courts 6-8 to same at Courts 3-5.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403

24-3 Courts 1-2Provide Accessible Route to Boundary of Area of Sport Activity Medium $10,000Notes: An accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity (soccer fields, basketball courts, baseball fields, running tracks, skating rinks, etc.). Where multiple sports fields or courts are provided, an accessible route is provided to each field or area of sport activity. No route currently exists from parking to these courts. Provide connection as required with a compliant surface to the perimeter. Cost assumes direct connection from drinking fountain at Courts 3-5 to same at Courts 1-2.Federal Guideline: 206.2.2, 403



Item # Description Priority Probable CostGeneral Notes: 1. There are three separate sets of tennis courts. Per Advisory 206.2.2, an accessible route is required to connect to the boundary of each area of sport activity. Where multiple fields or courts are provided, an accessible route is required to each. Currently on the west courts are on an accessible route.2. Two different stairways off the ROW of Broadway Avenue discharge into the lawn areas near Courts 6-8 and to a non-compliant accessible route at Courts 3-5. Neither stairway connects to a PAR at Broadway Avenue and are not considered to be an accessible route accessing the courts.3. Note that the existing portable toilet is not accessible. Since they are not a "permanent" fixture they are not required to be accessible but consider providing a portable toilet that is wheelchair accessible at all locations that portable toilets are provided unless accessible restrooms are provided.4. Total of three (3) drinking fountains provided within the park. Per ADASAD 211, 50% must meet wheelchair requirements and 50% must meet standing user requirements, with any odd number meeting one of the requirements. Currently 1 meets wheelchair and 2 meets neither standard. Corrective actions noted to make all comply.


Data collected February 2019


Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Medium $4,000Notes: Slopes of parking stall and access aisle up to 4.1% (2% max.). Access aisle and parking space pavement markings are very faded and need to be redone. Provide level parking area when lot is resurfaced, repaint pavement markings in the interim.Federal Guideline: 302, 502.4Accessible Routes and Curb Ramps

02 Curb RampProvide Compliant Curb Ramp Low N/ANotes: The curb ramp has flares with 20% slopes (10% max.) but not on a common circulation area. Correct when sidewalk is reconstructed.Federal Guideline: 405, 406

04 SidewalksProvide Compliant Sidewalks Low N/ANotes: Sidewalks connecting the front of the building to the side have cross slopes up to 2.9% (2% max.). Not on an accessible route, correct when sidewalks are reconstructed. Federal Guideline: 403.3

Interior - Public AreaCommon Circulation Areas and Lobby

07-2 Lobby Drinking FountainProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Medium $2,000Notes: Single fountain provided at this location, bubbler height of 35-1/2" provides accessibility to wheelchair users (36" max.) but only 26-1/2" knee space provided (27" min.). If 1 fountain is provided, 2 must be provided with 1 each providing compliance for standing user (38-43") and wheelchair user. Adjust height of existing fountain to provide compliant knee space and provide additional standing user fountain.Federal Guideline: 211, 602

Total existing spaces provided is 28, with 1 marked as van-accessible. Based on parking count, 2 accessible spaces are required, including 1 van-accessible.

Wastewater Treatment

Plant

City of Oak RidgeWastewater Treatment Plant Page 1 of 10

Item # Description Priority Probable CostProtect Protruding Object Medium $200Notes: Drinking fountain not within compliant alcove, protruding into circulation area. Standing fountain required should be cane-detectable, provide permanent, cane-detectable barrier on opposite side of fountain. Movable chairs currently protect one side.Federal Guideline: 307.2

08a-1 Exterior Door Lobby Area to Employee BuildingProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Low $110Notes: 8-1/2" to glazing (10" min. smooth req'd.) on door. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08a-3 Main Front Public EntranceProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: The closing speed is less than 5 seconds, cost is for a new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Low $110Notes: 8-1/2" to glazing (10" min. smooth req'd.) on door. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08b-2 Main Front Public Entrance Vestibule Interior DoorProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Opening force for the door is 8 lbs. (5 lbs. max.), cost is for a new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Low $110Notes: 8-1/2" to glazing (10" min. smooth req'd.) on door. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

09-2 Public Lobby/CorridorsProvide Compliant Signage Medium $600Notes: Existing signage at 6 doors to exempt spaces include only visual text or have no sign. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall at compliant height at all doors to permanent spaces.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703


Item # Description Priority Probable CostLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switches at 49-1/2" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308

16-1 Men’s Lobby RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No compliant signage provided, existing sign is on the door that opens out and includes only visual text. Compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location at latch side wall at the door. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Operating force is 8 lbs. (5 lbs. max.). Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.9Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser N/A N/ANotes: The dispenser is located at 59" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50-1/2" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Toilet Medium $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 21" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.2Provide Clear Space at Toilet Medium $800Notes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is 50-1/2" (60" min. req'd.). Explore options, cost is placeholder and may vary.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Provide Compliant Height Toilet Seat Low $100Notes: Toilet seat height is at 16" (17-19" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.4Replace Flush Controls Low $400Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Provide Compliant Grab Bars Medium $1,000Notes: Grab bars provided only on sides (req'd. on wall side and rear), side bar extends only 52" from rear wall (54" min.).Federal Guideline: 604

16-2 Women’s Lobby RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No compliant signage provided, existing sign is on the door that opens out and includes only visual text. Compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location at latch side wall at the door. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Door closes in less than 5 seconds and operating force is 12 lbs. (5 lbs. max.). Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1, 404.2.9


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Paper Towel Dispenser N/A N/ANotes: The dispenser is located at 59" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50-1/2" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Toilet High $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 25" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.2Provide Clear Space at Toilet Medium $800Notes: Existing clear space from near wall of toilet to sink is 51-1/2" (60" min. req'd.). Explore options, cost is placeholder and may vary.Federal Guideline: 604.3.1Provide Compliant Height Toilet Seat Low $100Notes: Toilet seat height is at 16" (17-19" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.4Replace Flush Controls Low $400Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Reposition Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50

Notes: Toilet paper dispenser centerline located 4" in front of toilet (7-9" req'd.).

Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Grab Bars Medium $1,000Notes: Grab bars provided only on sides (req'd. on wall side and rear), side bar extends only 52" from rear wall (54" min.).Federal Guideline: 604

18-1 Conference RoomLower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50-1/2" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text "CONFERENCE" on the door. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Medium $220Notes: Door has knobs that require tight grasping and twisting. Federal Guideline: 206.4, 404.2.7Provide Compliant Working Surface Medium $400Notes: Conference room table has only 25-3/4" knee space below (27" min.). Provide compliant table. Federal Guideline: 305



Interior - Employee AreaEmployee Corridors

07-1 Drinking Fountain in Employee CorridorProvide Compliant Drinking Fountains Low $3,000Notes: Single fountain provided at this location, bubbler height of 37-3/4" provides accessibility to neither a wheelchair user (36" max.) or standing users (38-43"). If 1 fountain is provided, 2 must be provided with 1 each providing compliance for standing user and wheelchair user. Remount existing fountain to provide compliant standing user height bubbler and provide addition fountain compliant for wheelchair user (36" max. bubbler with 27" min. knee space).Federal Guideline: 211, 602Protect Protruding Object Medium $200Notes: Drinking fountain not within compliant alcove, protruding into circulation area. Provide permanent, cane-detectable barrier on both sides of fountain.Federal Guideline: 307.2

08a-2 Door to Employee Building from LobbyProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Low $110Notes: 8-1/2" to glazing (10" min. smooth req'd.) on door. Provide kick plate with filler on push side of door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08a-4 Employee Entry Door at Break RoomProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Threshold Low $100Notes: There is a lip at the threshold over 1/2". Provide compliant threshold.Federal Guideline: 404.2.5

09-1 Employee CorridorsProvide Compliant Signage Medium $1,200Notes: Existing signage at 12 doors to exempt spaces include only visual text or have no sign. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall at compliant height at all doors to permanent spaces.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Protect Protruding Objects Medium $600Notes: There are numerous protruding objects in the corridors. Mailbox protrudes 8-1/2" at 53-1/2", the time clock 6-1/4" at 53", telephone 6" at 46", fire extinguisher 5" at 35", and AED 8" at 55" (4" max. between 27" and 80"). Provide permanent cane-detectable objects below all or reposition items.Federal Guideline: 307.2


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost15-1 Men’s Restroom near Break Room

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Signage provided is visual text "WOMEN" located on the door with the "WO" blackened out. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters, and Braille without the ISA symbol (until it complies) on the latch wall.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Medium $220Notes: Door has knobs that require tight grasping and twisting. Federal Guideline: 206.4, 404.2.7Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. min. required and operating force is 12 lbs. (5 lbs. max.). Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1, 404.2.9Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Medium $800Notes: There is only 4" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.) and 9" on the push side (12" min. for doors with closer and latch. Explore options to provide clear space, cost assumes modifications to door/frame is required, cost may vary.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Provide Compliant Faucet Controls Medium $200Notes: Controls are knob type that require grasping and twisting to operate. Provide compliant faucet controls.Federal Guideline: 606.4, 309Provide Insulation Below Sinks (2) Low $220Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 51-3/4" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 59-1/2" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Reposition Soap Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 53" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308

NOTE: Both restrooms in the employee area are designated for men's use. This restroom was formerly for use by women but no women are currently employed at this facility. If women are hired in the future a dedicated women's restroom will need to be provided. One of the existing restrooms at a minimum should be altered to provide a compliant wheelchair facility.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlet is mounted at 49" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Provide Compliant Urinal - OPTIONAL N/A N/ANotes: The top lip of the urinal is at 23-1/2" (17" max.) and rim projects only 12" from the wall (13-1/2" min.). Only 1 urinal present so does not need to comply, would need different urinal to be compliant.Federal Guideline: 305.7.1, 605Provide Required Stall Hardware Low $200Notes: No handles are provided on the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall Low $4,000Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is only 35-1/2" (60" min.) and stall door entry width is only 24" (32" min.). Explore options, which may include eliminating the shower and reconfiguring room to move urinal and possibly sink to provide compliant wheelchair stall and maintain multi-user status with same fixture count. Cost assumes shower is removed, urinal is relocated to shower area with new stall partitions provided. Cost may vary.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3Provide Compliant Toilet Seat Low $100Notes: Toilet seat height is 16-1/2" (17-19" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.4Provide Compliant Toilet Paper Dispenser Low $50Notes: No dispenser provided, required to be positioned with centerline 7-9" in front of toilet.Federal Guideline: 604.7Provide Compliant Grab Bars Low $1,000Notes: Side grab bar extends only 52" from rear wall (54" min.) and there is no rear grab bar. Provide new grab bars installed in compliant location.Federal Guideline: 604.7Relocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hook on the back of the stall door is at 61" ht. (48" max.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

15-2 Men’s Restroom (on the right)

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Signage provided is visual text "MEN" located on the door. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters, and Braille without the ISA symbol (until it complies) on the latch wall.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

NOTE: Both restrooms in the employee area are designated for men's use. This restroom was formerly for use by women but no women are currently employed at this facility. If women are hired in the future a dedicated women's restroom will need to be provided. One of the existing restrooms at a minimum should be altered to provide a compliant wheelchair facility.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Door Hardware Medium $220Notes: Door has knobs that require tight grasping and twisting. Federal Guideline: 206.4, 404.2.7Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. min. required and operating force is 12 lbs. (5 lbs. max.). Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1, 404.2.9Provide Maneuvering Space on Pull Side of Door Medium $800Notes: There is only 4" clear space parallel to the door on the pull side (18" min. req'd.) and 9" on the push side (12" min. for doors with closer and latch. Explore options to provide clear space, cost assumes modifications to door/frame is required, cost may vary.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10Provide Compliant Faucet Controls Medium $200Notes: Controls are knob type that require grasping and twisting to operate. Provide compliant faucet controls.Federal Guideline: 606.4, 309Provide Insulation Below Sinks (2) Low $220Notes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Mirror Low $50Notes: The bottom of the mirror reflective surface is located at 53" high (40" max.). Federal Guideline: 603.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $50Notes: The dispenser is located at 59-1/2" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Electrical Outlets Low $50Notes: Outlet is mounted at 49" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Provide Required Stall Hardware Low $200Notes: No handles are provided on the stall door, are required on both sides. Federal Guideline: 213.3, 604.8, 404.2.7Reposition Toilet Low $765Notes: Centerline of toilet located at 18-3/4" from side wall (16"-18" req'd.). Federal Guideline: 604.2


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Wheelchair Accessible Stall Low $4,000Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall width is only 35-1/2" (60" min.) and stall door entry width is only 24" (32" min.). Explore options, which may include eliminating the shower and reconfiguring room to move urinal and possibly sink to provide compliant wheelchair stall and maintain multi-user status with same fixture count. Cost assumes shower is removed, urinal is relocated to shower area with new stall partitions provided. Cost may vary.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3Provide Compliant Toilet Seat Low $100Notes: Toilet seat height is 16" (17-19" req'd.).Federal Guideline: 604.4Replace Flush Controls Low $400Notes: Flush controls are not located on wide side of toilet. Replace with auto flush sensor. Federal Guideline: 604.6Provide Compliant Grab Bars Low $1,000Notes: No grab bars provided (req'd. on rear and side wall). Provide new grab bars installed in compliant location.Federal Guideline: 604.7Relocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hook on the back of the stall door is at 61" ht. (48" max.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4

19-1 Locker RoomRelocate Clothing Hooks Low $50Notes: Hooks located at 59" ht. (48" max.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48".Federal Guideline: 308, 603.4Provide Compliant Benches Medium $1,200Notes: Bench has seat surface at 15-1/4" high (17"-19" req'd.) and is only 12" deep (20-24" req'd.) and blocks access to the lockers. Bench that is 42" long x 20"-24" in width required. Bench must be connected to a wall or have a back rest. Clear floor space of 30" x 48" is req'd. at the end of bench seat and parallel. Bench should be adjacent to accessible lockers. Cost assumes 2 new compliant benches provided. Total of 22 lockers, 5% (2) required to be accessible and have bench adjacent.Federal Guideline: 222.1, 803.4, 903.4, 903.5Provide Accessible Lockers Low $1,000Notes: Lockers have hooks and shelves within that are above 48". Provide 2 accessible lockers that have opening and locking devices operable without twisting or grasping motions and require no more than 5 lbs. of force to operate with storage devices at 48" max.Federal Guideline: 811.4, 309.4


Item # Description Priority Probable CostBreak Room

08b-1 Break Room DoorProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text "EMPLOYEE FACILITY" on the door. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the latch side wall at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Door Hardware Medium $220Notes: Door has knobs that require tight grasping and twisting. Federal Guideline: 206.4, 404.2.7

35a-1 Break Room KitchenReposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim at 36-3/4" high (34" max. req'd.) and provides no knee space below as required. Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Kitchen with oven/range is required to have knee space below the sink.Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3Replace Range/Oven Medium $1,000Notes: Controls must be operable without reaching over burners. Purchase new range/oven that has all controls on front panel.Federal Guideline: 804.6.4, 804.6.5.3Protect Protruding Objects Medium $100Notes: The countertop near the entrance protrudes 25-1/2" at 36" (4" max. between 27" and 80"). Provide permanent cane-detectable objects at end.Federal Guideline: 307.2


General Notes: 1. Parking at this facility is provided in 2 areas. A visitor's parking area at the main front entrance includes the only accessible space. Most parking is for employees on the side of the main building with no accessible spaces. Ensure the ability to provide an employee with a compliant accessible space upon request.2. Accessible routes for this facility are limited to the route for the public from the accessible parking to the main front entrance. Additional sidewalks are present on the site but do not provide access to any site amenities.3. This facility has essentially 2 different buildings. The front public area includes the lobby and office areas at the main entrance. This area is connected to the rear employee-only area by a covered, unenclosed breezeway.4. The facility includes 2 multi-user restrooms in the employee area. Both are currently designated for "MEN", with the first 2 letters on the sign for "WOMEN" blacked out. Both restrooms include a shower compartment though neither appears to be used, but they appear to work. Neither employee restroom is accessible. One should be made accessible at a minimum, and when there is a female employee at the plant both should be. There is a pair of single-user restrooms in the public lobby area, neither of which fully complies either. Both public restrooms should be accessible to wheelchairs.


Data collected March 2019

Main BuildingItem # Description Priority Probable Cost01a Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Low $400Notes: Provide 1 van-accessible parking space with access aisle at a location close to the accessible route to the main building entrance. No public access is provided at this facility so access would be provided only to employees. Cost assumes pavement markings and sign.Federal Guideline: 302, 502.4

08a-1 Main EntryProvide Means of Egress Signage Medium $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Modify Vision Panel Low $450Notes: Vision panel below 66" is at 45-1/2" ht. (43" max.)Federal Guideline: 404.2.11

08a-2 Exterior Door Adjacent to Main DoorProvide Means of Egress Signage Medium $100Notes: Only visual sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Modify Vision Panel Low $450Notes: Vision panel below 66" is at 44" ht. (43" max.)Federal Guideline: 404.2.11

WaterFiltration

Plant

8-12 total parking spaces provided including 0 accessible spaces. 1 accessible spaces required, including 1 van space.

City of Oak RidgeWater Filtration Plant Page 1 of 9

Item # Description Priority Probable Cost08a-3 Exterior Door in Break Room

Provide Means of Egress Signage Medium $100Notes: No signage provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Provide Compliant Threshold Medium $250Notes: Threshold is 2-1/2" high (1/2" max.). Explore options, which may include a short ramped transition plate.Federal Guideline: 404.2.5Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Maneuvering Space at Door Low $100Notes: Clearance on latch pull side of the door is only 13-1/2" (18" parallel to door on latch side req'd.) due to presence of railing. Alternate entrance at main door should be provided, with this door for exit only. Provide sign with accessible route for entry for main door at sidewalk to this door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4, 703

08b-1 Double Doors at RampProvide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Low $440Notes: 8" to glazing (10" min. smooth req'd.) on door. Doors swing in both directions, provide kick plate with filler on both sides of both doors.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08b-2 Control Room Double DoorsProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text above the door. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the wall to the right when facing doors in hallway at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Low $440Notes: 9" to glazing (10" min. smooth req'd.) on door. Doors swing in both directions, provide kick plate with filler on both sides of both doors.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08b-3 Control Room Door at Double Doors to RampProvide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text above the door. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the wall to the right when facing doors in hallway at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Kick Plate on Push Side of Door Low $220Notes: 9" to glazing (10" min. smooth req'd.) on door. Door swings in both directions, provide kick plate with filler on both sides of door.Federal Guideline: 404.2.10

08b-4 Main Entry Hallway Double Doors Modify Vision Panel Medium $450Notes: Vision panel below 66" is at 48-1/2" ht. (43" max.)Federal Guideline: 404.2.11


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost08b-5 Open Doorway to Break Room in Control Room

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $100Notes: Existing signage includes only visual text above the door. Provide compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille at the wall to the right when facing doors from Control Room at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Provide Compliant Doorway Low TBDNotes: Height of clear door opening is 77-3/4" (78" min. to stop). Explore options.Federal Guideline: 404.2.3

11-1 Stairs to Lower Level Restrooms

Provide Compliant Stairs N/A N/ANotes: The riser height is 8-1/4" (4-7" req'd.), the risers are open (not permitted), and the tread depth is 9-1/4" (11" min.). Federal Guideline: 504.2Provide Compliant Handrails N/A N/ANotes: Not all areas of the handrail are 1-1/2" min. clear from the wall. Handrails do not extend min. 1 tread depth beyond the bottom of the stairs. Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72

13-1 Ramp at Control Room Level to Work Level and StairsProvide Compliant Ramp N/A N/ANotes: Ramp slope approximately 13% (8.33% max.), surface is polished from wear and slippery, has no compliant top landing and is within swing of double doors, and handrails lack compliant extensions at the top and bottom. Federal Guideline: 405.2, 405.6

15-1 Men’s RestroomProvide Compliant Unisex Restroom Medium $25,000NOTES: Existing restrooms and showers are not on an accessible route. Items noted below for stairs, ramps, and restrooms/showers are provided for information only unless cost and priority included (primarily signage and protruding objects). Recommended that a compliant unisex restroom with shower is provided on the main level near the Control Room. Cost is estimate and actual cost may vary depending on space available for compliant facility to be provided.Federal Guideline: 308, 604, 605, 606Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No signage provided. Compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location at latch side wall at the door. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Adjust Door Closer N/A N/ANotes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. and the operating force is 10 lbs. (5 lbs. max.). Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1, 404.2.9

NOTES: Existing restrooms and showers are not on an accessible route. Items noted below for stairs, ramps, and restrooms/showers are provided for information only unless cost and priority included (primarily signage and protruding objects). Recommended that a compliant unisex restroom with shower is provided on the main level near the Control Room.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser N/A N/ANotes: The dispenser is located at 50" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Reposition Hand Dryer N/A N/ANotes: Operable parts of hand dryer at 54-1/2" (48" max.). Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Protect Protruding Objects Medium $200Notes: The sink protrudes 22" at 31" and wall cabinet 17-1/2" at 29" (4" max. between 27" and 80"). Provide permanent cane-detectable objects below all or reposition items.Federal Guideline: 307.2Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space as required.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor N/A N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 53-1/2" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Switch not a compliant type, has cover that may be difficult to operate. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Electrical Outlets N/A N/ANotes: Outlet is mounted at 54" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2Provide Compliant Urinal N/A N/ANotes: The top lip of the urinal is at 29" (17" max.) and rim projects only 12" from the wall (13-1/2" min.). Flush controls at 51" (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 305.7.1, 308, 605Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall N/A N/ANotes: No accessible stall present. Stall has no handles on the door (req'd. on both sides), stall door not self-closing, entry door width is only 23" (32" min.), door swings into the stall, toilet centerline 19" from wall (16-18" req'd.), stall width only 37" (60" min.), stall depth only 56-1/2" (59" min.), toilet seat height only 16-3/4" (17-19" req'd.), toilet paper dispenser centerline at 19" in front of toilet (7-9" req'd.), the coat hook on the back of the stall door is at 60" (48" max.), and there are no grab bars provided.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3Provide Compliant Shower N/A TBDNotes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible. Existing space has a non-compliant shower. Cost is noted as "To Be Determined" due to need for further investigation of options for renovations.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608


Item # Description Priority Probable Cost15-2 Women’s Restroom

Provide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: Signage provided is visual text "LADIES RESTROOM" located on the door that opens out. Compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location at latch side wall at the door. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703Protect Protruding Objects Medium $200Notes: There is an electrical box that protrudes 21" at 35-1/2" high outside the door on the latch pull side (4" max. between 27" and 80"). Provide permanent cane-detectable objects below. Federal Guideline: 307.2Provide Maneuvering Clear Space on Pull Side of Door N/A N/A

Notes: The electrical box obstructs the pull side clearance to 13-1/2" (18" req'd.).

Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1Adjust Door Closer N/A N/ANotes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. and the operating force is 8 lbs. (5 lbs. max.). Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1, 404.2.9Provide Compliant Faucet Controls N/A N/ANotes: Faucet controls are knob-type that require grasping and twisting. Federal Guideline: 309, 606.4Provide Insulation Below Sink N/A N/ANotes: The sink has exposed pipes and water supply beneath. Provide insulation on all piping to prevent contact.Federal Guideline: 606.5Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser N/A N/ANotes: The dispenser is located at 59" high (48" max.).Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7Protect Protruding Objects Medium $200Notes: The sink protrudes 22" at 31" and wall cabinet 17-1/2" at 29" (4" max. between 27" and 80"). Provide permanent cane-detectable objects below all or reposition items.Federal Guideline: 307.2Provide Visual Fire Alarms High $400Notes: Visual fire alarms must be located in common use and general circulation areas. None in this space as required.Federal Guideline: 215.1, 702.1, NFPA 72Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor N/A N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 53-1/2" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Switch not a compliant type, has cover that may be difficult to operate. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Reposition Electrical Outlets N/A N/ANotes: Outlet is mounted at 53" height (15-48" req'd.). Least costly option is to provide power strip mounted at compliant height.Federal Guideline: 305.3, 205.1, 308.2


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Wheelchair Accessible Stall N/A N/ANotes: No accessible stall present. Stall has no handles on the door (req'd. on both sides), stall door not self-closing, entry door width is only 22-1/4" (32" min.), door swings into the stall, toilet centerline 19" from wall (16-18" req'd.), stall width only 37" (60" min.), stall depth only 56-1/2" (59" min.), toilet seat height only 15-1/4" (17-19" req'd.), toilet paper dispenser centerline behind front of toilet (7-9" in front req'd.), and there are no grab bars provided.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3Provide Compliant Shower N/A TBDNotes: Where bathing/shower facilities are provided, at least 1 must be accessible. Existing space has a non-compliant shower. Cost is noted as "To Be Determined" due to need for further investigation of options for renovations.Federal Guideline: 213.2, 608

35a-1 Break Room Reposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim at 36" high (34" max. req'd.) and provides no knee space below as required. Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Kitchen with oven/range is required to have knee space below the sink.Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3Replace Range/Oven Medium $1,000Notes: Controls must be operable without reaching over burners. Purchase new range/oven that has all controls on front panel.Federal Guideline: 804.6.4, 804.6.5.3Reposition Paper Towel and Hand Sanitizer Dispensers Low $100Notes: The dispensers are located well above 48" max.Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7

Maintenance BuildingItem # Description Priority Probable Cost01a Parking

Provide Compliant Accessible Parking Low $400Notes: Provide 1 van-accessible parking space with access aisle at a location close to the accessible route to the main building entrance. No public access is provided at this facility so access would be provided only to employees. Cost assumes pavement markings and sign.Federal Guideline: 302, 502.4

08a-4 Maintenance Shop East Exit

Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1

20 total parking spaces provided including 0 accessible spaces. 1 accessible spaces required, including 1 van space.

NOTE: This door is an emergency exit only, issues should be addressed to ensure disabled employee is able to use in an emergency.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Threshold Medium $100Notes: The threshold is 1-1/4" high (1/2" max.), replace threshold. Federal Guideline: 402.2.5Provide Maneuvering Space at Door Low TBDNotes: Pull side of door has no level space. Explore options.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1

08a-5 Maintenance Shop Main DoorProvide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1Provide Compliant Threshold Medium $100Notes: The threshold is 1-1/4" high (1/2" max.), replace threshold. Federal Guideline: 402.2.5Provide Maneuvering Space at Door Low $800Notes: Pull side of door has no level space. The 18" pull side clear space adjacent to the latch side has a level change and the door approach is uneven. Explore options, cost assumes large door stoop is provided.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1

08a-6 Maintenance Shop Rear Door

Provide Means of Egress Signage High $100Notes: Illuminated visual "EXIT" is only sign provided. Tactile letter and Braille sign required on interior wall adjacent to door.Federal Guideline: 216.4, 703Adjust Door Closer Medium $450Notes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1, 404.2.9Modify Vision Panel Medium $450Notes: Vision panel below 66" is at 58" ht. (43" max.)Federal Guideline: 404.2.11Provide Maneuvering Space at Door Low TBDNotes: Pull side of door lacks a 60" deep level space on the pull side. Explore options, cost assumes large door stoop is provided.Federal Guideline: 404.2.4.1

16-1 Maintenance Shop RestroomProvide Compliant Signage Medium $200Notes: No signage provided. Compliant sign with visual and tactile letters and Braille required in compliant location at latch side wall at the door. Federal Guideline: 216.2, 703

NOTE: This door is an emergency exit only, but steps are present outside and not accessible.


Item # Description Priority Probable CostProvide Compliant Doorway and Accessible Route Medium $800Notes: The corridor leading to the restroom is only 31" wide, is obstructed by cabinets that should be moved. Clear width of entry door is only 25" (32" min.). Provide compliant entry. Cost assumes cabinets are moved, doorway is enlarged, and new door provided. Federal Guideline: 404.2.3Provide Compliant Door Hardware Medium $220Notes: Door has knobs that require tight grasping and twisting. Federal Guideline: 206.4, 404.2.7Adjust Door Closer Low $450Notes: Closing speed less than 5 sec. and the operating force is 12 lbs. (5 lbs. max.). Cost is for new closer.Federal Guideline: 404.2.8.1, 404.2.9Lower Light Switch or Provide Occupancy Sensor Low N/ANotes: Electrical switch at 50-1/2" (over 48" max ht.) but up to 54" allowed by 1991 ADAAG. Correct when altered. Federal Guideline: 205.1, 308Relocate Coat Hook Low $50Notes: Coat hooks located outside the stall and at 65" ht. (48" max.). Provide additional single hook at or below 48" inside the stall.Federal Guideline: 308, 608.3Provide Compliant Urinal - OPTIONAL N/A N/ANotes: The top lip of the urinal is at 29" (17" max.). Only 1 urinal present so compliance not required.Federal Guideline: 305.7.1, 605Provide Wheelchair Accessible Stall Low $2,500Notes: No accessible stall present. Stall has no handles on the inside of the door (req'd. on both sides), stall width only 36-1/2" (60" min.), flush controls are not on the wide side of the toilet, toilet seat height only 16-1/2" (17-19" req'd.), and there are no grab bars provided. Consider removing partitions and urinal to provide clear space at toilet, install autoflush valve on toilet, provide new toilet seat, and install grab bars on the side and rear walls. Cost assumes those improvements. Also explore option to provide sink.Federal Guideline: 213.3, 308, 603.4, 604.3

35a-2 Maintenance Shop Break Room Reposition Sink and Provide Knee Space Below Low $750Notes: Sink rim at 36" high (34" max. req'd.) and provides no knee space below as required. Reposition such that rim of sink does not exceed 34" max. Kitchen with oven/range is required to have knee space below the sink.Federal Guideline: 606.2, 606.3


Item # Description Priority Probable CostReplace Range/Oven Medium $1,000Notes: Controls must be operable without reaching over burners. Purchase new range/oven that has all controls on front panel.Federal Guideline: 804.6.4, 804.6.5.3Reposition Paper Towel Dispenser Low $100Notes: The dispenser are located well above 48" max.Federal Guideline: 308, 604.7


General Notes: 1. This facility is located on U.S. Department of Energy property and has extremely limited access, with no public access. There are two different city buildings with common use areas. The main building includes a break room, controls room, and restrooms. The maintenance building has a small break room and single restroom. Parking at this facility is scattered, with concentrations at both buildings. 2. The Main Building has limited common use areas. Only those spaces and accessible routes to them are included. Common use areas include the restrooms (which are located in the lower level) and break room (accessed through the Control Room). There is no vertical access within the building, and a ramp and stairs are on the accessible route to the lower level restrooms. The issues with the restrooms and accessible route would likely cost significantly more to correct than to provide a fully compliant unisex restroom in the main level near the Control Room. Information provided above for reference only, consider investigating options to provide unisex accessible restroom on main level.3. The Maintenance Building has limited common use areas, including a lunch room and unisex restroom. Both areas should be made accessible.


Segment Total Length Non-Compliant LengthNon-Compliance

Issues PriorityEstimated

Cost

1 6854 60 RS and CS Medium 10,800$ 2 4774 130 RS and CS High 23,400$ 3 6114 1130 RS and CS High 203,400$ 4 11700 2100 RS and CS Medium 378,000$

Parking spaces, compliant surfacing, connection to trail

High 8,000$

5 3693 1108 CS Medium 199,422$ 6 4724 472 RS High 84,960$

Parking spaces, compliant surfacing, connection to trail

High 5,000$

Total 37859 5000 912,982$ 0

588,222$ 324,760$

Table A-1. Oak Ridge Greenways ADA Compliance and Corrective Cost with Priority

Low PriorityMedium Priority

High PriorityNOTE: 1. The non-compliant length is approximated based on field conditions at the time of the evaluation. Actual conditions may differ and should be verified by field survey prior to design. 2. The city has many other greenways that have unimproved surfaces that are not compliant with ADA requirements. No assessment of non-compliant surfaced greenways was completed. All greenways that are to be improved should be assessed and designed to be ADA compliant to the extent possible. 3. Melton Lake Greenway provides parking at Elza Gate Park, Melton Lake Park, an unimproved parking area at Melton Lake Drive and Union Valley Road, and Haw Ridge Park. Cost information about improvements needed at the unimproved parking area is provided above and includes constructing 2 accessible spaces (including 1 van-accessible) with shared access aisle and signage with a direct connection at the access aisle to the greenway. No assessment was done at the fitness area at the parking area. The improvements at other parking lots within parks is included in the individual facility assessments in Appendix A. 4. Emory Greenway provides parking only at an unimproved parking area at Cascade Lane just off Emory Valley Road. Cost information about improvements needed at the unimproved lot is included above and includes providing the required number and types of accessible parking spaces at the trail parking facility with signage. Information about improvements needed at the unimproved lot is included above.5. RS = Running Slope, CS = Cross Slope

Melton Lake Greenway

Emory Valley Greenway

Cascade Lane Trailhead Parking

Melton Lake Dr/Union Valley Rd. Trailhead Parking

Oak Ridge Greenways Page 1 of 1

Oak Ridge Greenway Mapping Page 1 of 2

Figure A-1. City of Oak Ridge Greenway Mapping Segments.

Melton Lake Greenway Mapping

Oak Ridge Greenway Mapping Page 2 of 2

Emory Valley Greenway Mapping

Appendix B

Public Right-of-Way Facilities Summaries

Table B-1 Sidewalks Table B-2 Curb Ramps

Table B-3 Pedestrian Signals

smetzer

Cross-Out

Location DescriptionTotal Segment

Length Replacement

Cost Priority

East Drive, California Ave to Clarion Rd, E side 589 35,340$ MediumEast Drive, Clarion Rd to Everest Cir, E side 924 55,440$ MediumEast Drive, Everest Cir to Everest Cir, S/SE side 595 35,700$ MediumEast Drive, Everest Cir to Evans Ln, S side 223 13,380$ MediumEast Drive, Evans Ln to Euclid Cir, SW/S side 307 18,420$ LowEuclid Circle, East Dr to Euclid Pl, S side 823 49,380$ LowEuclid Place, Euclid Cir east to end, S side 297 17,820$ LowEuclid Circle, Euclid Pl to Euclid Cir, N side 670 40,200$ LowEast Drive, Euclid Cir to Essex Ln, E side 245 14,700$ LowEssex Lane, East Dr west to end, S side 158 9,480$ LowEvans Lane, East Dr north to end, W side 500 30,000$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Pineberry East Rd to Pineberry West Rd, N side 511 30,660$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Pineberry West Rd northerly to end, N/E side 429 25,740$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Pineberry West Rd northerly to end, S/W side 203 12,180$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Pineberry East Rd to Pineberry West Rd, S side 498 29,880$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Pineberry West Rd to Parkberry St, N side 334 20,040$ LowParkberry Street, Pineberry East Rd to Broadberry Ave, NW side 1207 72,420$ LowSweetberry Street, Pineberry East Rd to Broadberry Ave, NW side 1148 68,880$ LowSweetberry Street, Pineberry East Rd east to end, N side 60 -$ CompliantBroadberry Avenue, Parkberry St to Sweetberry St, NE side 172 -$ CompliantEverest Circle, East Dr to East Dr, N sides 1179 60,129$ LowLittonberry Street, Sweetberry St to Cedarberry St, S/SW side 1142 68,520$ LowCedarberry Street, Littonberry St to Broadberry Ave, N/NW side 518 31,080$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Sweetberry St to Cedarberry St, NE side 1055 63,300$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Pineberry West Rd to Mistletoeberry Rd, W/SW side 816 -$ CompliantMistletoeberry Road, Broadberry Ave to Broadberry Ave, inside of circle 2143 -$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Mistletoeberry Road to Mistletoeberry Road, SW side 483 14,490$ LowClarion Road, East Dr to California Ave, E side 764 45,840$ LowOak Lane, Outer D. north to end, E side 340 20,400$ LowChatham Lane, California Ave south to end, E side 492 29,520$ LowCedar Lane, California Ave west to end, N side 843 50,580$ LowCarlisle Lane, California Ave west to end, N side 493 29,580$ LowCahill Lane, California Ave west to end, N/W side 962 57,720$ LowAlder Lane, W Arrowwood Rd south to end, W side 639 38,340$ LowAspen Lane, Arkansas Ave southwest to end, SE side 1078 3,234$ LowAmericus Avenue, Aluminum St to Heritage Center Blvd, E side 301 -$ CompliantAmericus Avenue, Aluminum St south to end, W side 51 3,060$ MediumAluminum Street, Americus Ave west to end, N side (at stairway) 456 27,360$ LowHeritage Center Boulevard, Aluminum St to Chromium St, E side 251 1,506$ LowHeritage Center Boulevard, Chromium St to Victorius Blvd E, E side 266 15,960$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Northberry St W to Mistletoeberry St, W side 683 40,980$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Cedarberry St to Northberry St W, NE/E side 456 27,360$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Northberry St W to Fortenberry St, NE/E side 1387 24,966$ LowNorthberry Street West, Broadberry Ave west to end at cul-de-sac 1290 77,400$ LowGaleberry Avenue, Broadberry Ave to Gooseberry Cir, NW side 755 11,325$ LowGaleberry Avenue, Gooseberry Cir island, NW side 102 -$ CompliantGaleberry Avenue, Gooseberry Cir to Fallberry St, W/SW side 1396 83,760$ MediumGaleberry Avenue, Fallberry St to Forestberry St, E side 208 6,240$ LowGaleberry Avenue, Forestberry St to Fortenberry St, NE side 281 16,860$ MediumGaleberry Avenue, Fortenberry St north to end, NE side 323 19,380$ Medium

Table B-1. Oak Ridge Sidewalks ADA Compliance and Corrective Cost with Priority

City of Oak Ridge Sidewalks Page 1 of 17

Fortenberry Street, Galeberry Ave to Broadberry Ave, NW side 660 39,600$ MediumBroadberry Avenue, Fortenberry St to Galeberry Ave, W side 1020 61,200$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Galeberry Ave to Northberry St W, W side 329 -$ CompliantFortenberry Street, Galeberry Ave to Broadberry Ave, SE side 647 3,882$ LowForestberry Street, Galeberry Ave to Broadberry Ave, NW side 608 3,648$ LowForestberry Street, Galeberry Ave to Broadberry Ave, SE side 606 3,636$ LowFallberry Street, Galeberry Ave to Broadberry Ave, NW side 690 41,400$ MediumBroadberry Avenue, Fallberry St to Forestberry St, SW side 225 -$ CompliantBroadberry Avenue, Forestberry St to Fortenberry St, SW side 185 5,550$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Fortenberry St to Falberry St, NE side 503 30,180$ LowFallberry Street, Broadberry Ave to Century Dr, S/SE side 1580 94,800$ MediumFallberry Street, Hamilton Rd to Galeberry Ave, N side 834 50,040$ LowBroadberry Avenue, W Elderberry St to Fallberry St, S side 865 51,900$ LowBroadberry Avenue, W Elderberry St east to end, S side 567 34,020$ LowWest Elderberry Street, Hitchberry Rd to Eastberry Rd, NW side 960 57,600$ LowWest Elderberry Street, Eastberry Rd to Old Union Rd, NW side 312 18,720$ LowE Tennessee Avenue, Tabor Rd to California Ave, NW side 561 33,660$ MediumDelaware Avenue, California Ave to W Dalton Rd, W/SW side 670 40,200$ MediumWest Elderberry Street, Old Union Rd to Eastberry Ave, SE side 895 53,700$ LowWest Elderberry Street, Eastberry Ave to Hitchberry Rd, SE side 904 54,240$ LowWest Elderberry Street, Hitchberry Rd northeast to end, SE side 105 6,300$ LowW Dalton Road/W Damascus Road, Delaware Ave to Delaware Ave, S side 812 48,720$ LowDelaware Avenue, Damascus Rd to Darwin Rd, SW side 235 14,100$ MediumE Dalton Road/E Damascus Road, Delaware Ave to Delaware Ave, N side 664 39,840$ LowDelaware Avenue, W Dalton Rd to W Damascus Rd, S side 353 21,180$ MediumDarwin Lane, Delaware Ave southwest to end, NW side 500 30,000$ LowDelaware Avenue, Darwin Ln to Decatur Rd, W side 137 8,220$ MediumDecatur Road, Delaware Ave to Delmar Cir, S/SW/W sides 1191 71,460$ LowDewey Road, Delmar Cir to Delaware Ave, N/NW side 769 46,140$ LowDelaware Avenue, Dewey Rd to Devon Ln, W side 183 10,980$ LowDelaware Avenue, Devon Ln to Decatur Rd, W side 199 11,940$ LowDallas Lane, Delaware Ave NE to end, NW side 137 8,220$ LowDisston Road/Darwin Road, Delaware Ave northerly to end, NE/E/SE side 943 56,580$ LowDisston Road, Delaware Ave easterly to end, S side 445 26,700$ LowEastberry Road, W Elderberry St to Hitchberry Rd, SW side 291 17,460$ LowHitchberry Road, Eastberry Rd to W Elderberry St, NW side 1042 62,520$ LowSouth Alabama Road, Arkansas Ave west to end, N side 575 34,500$ LowSouth Alabama Road, Cedar Rd east to end, S side 97 5,820$ LowCedar Road, S Alabama Rd to California Ave, W side 345 20,700$ LowCalifornia Avenue, Cedar Rd to W Arrowwood Rd, E/SE side 856 51,360$ MediumW Arrowwood Road, California Ave to Arkansas Ave, N side 1186 71,160$ LowArkansas Avenue, W Arrowwood Rd to Aspen Ln, W side 190 11,400$ MediumArkansas Avenue, W Arrowwood Rd to S Alabama Rd, W side 440 26,400$ MediumArkansas Avenue, S Alabama Rd to N Alabama Rd, W side 253 15,180$ LowEastberry Road, Juniperberry Rd to Hitchberry Rd, SW side 239 14,340$ LowJuniperberry Road, Eastberry Rd south to end at cul-de-sac, W side 366 21,960$ LowJuniperberry Road, Eastberry Rd north to end at cul-de-sac, W side 1011 60,660$ LowS Alabama Road, Arkansas Ave to Cedar Rd, E side 28 -$ CompliantN Alabama Road, Cedar Rd north to end, E side 189 -$ CompliantN Alabama Road, Arkansas Ave west to end, N/W side 1037 62,220$ MediumGallaher Ferry Road, Broadberry Rd west to end, NW side 118 7,080$ LowBroadberry Avenue, Gallaher Ferry Rd north to end, SW side 319 11,484$ LowGallaher Ferry Road, Broadberry Rd southwest to end, SE side 809 48,540$ LowArkansas Avenue, N Alabama Rd to Albany Rd, W side 415 6,225$ Low


Alhambra Road, Albany Rd to Albany Rd, inside of loop 2006 -$ LowRarity Ridge Parkway, Lawnville Rd northeast to end 905 13,575$ LowE Rarity Ridge Parkway, Broadberry Ave to Chaseberry Rd, SE/NE side 1348 80,880$ LowChaseberry Road, E Rarity Ridge Pkwy SW to end at cul-de-sac, SE side 630 37,800$ LowE Rarity Ridge Parkway, Chaseberry Rd to Brookberry Rd, SW side 327 -$ LowBrookberry Road, E Rarity Ridge Pkwy SW to end at cul-de-sac, SE side 520 31,200$ LowE Rarity Ridge Parkway, Brookberry Rd to Broadberry Ave, NW/SW side 1033 61,980$ LowE Elderberry Street, Holber Rd to Hatleyberry St, NW side 1153 20,754$ LowElderberry Road, Hatleyberry St to Fountberry St, SE side 901 54,060$ LowFountberry Street, E Elderberry St to Hackberry St, N side 239 3,585$ LowHackberry Street, Fountberry St to Rarity Ridge Pkwy, NW side 781 11,715$ LowHackberry Street, Rarity Ridge Pkwy to Hatleyberry St, NW side 361 1,083$ LowHatleyberry Street, Hackberry St to E Elderberry St, S side 240 -$ CompliantHackberry Street, Hatleyberry St to E Rarity Ridge Pkwy, SE side 401 7,218$ LowHackberry Street, E Rarity Ridge Pkwy to Fountberry St, SE side 763 45,780$ LowFountberry Street, Hardinberry St to Hackberry St, N side 241 3,615$ LowHardinberry Street, Fountberry St to E Rarity Ridge Pkwy, NW side 658 9,870$ LowHardinberry Street, E Rarity Ridge Pkwy to Hatleyberry St, NW side 524 1,572$ LowHatleyberry Street, Hardinberry St to Hackberry St, S side 270 -$ CompliantHardinberry Street, Hatleyberry St to E Rarity Ridge Pkwy, SE side 552 13,248$ LowHardinberry Street, E Rarity Ridge Pkwy to Fountberry St, SE side 621 9,315$ LowFountberry Street, Hatleyberry St to Hardinberry St, N side 215 -$ CompliantHatleyberry Street, Fountberry St to E Rarity Ridge Pkwy, NW side 538 32,280$ MediumHatleyberry Street, E Rarity Ridge Pkwy to Hardinberry St, NW side 839 20,136$ LowHatleyberry Street, E Elderberry St to Hiddenberry St, N side 457 -$ CompliantW side Hiddenberry Street, Hatleyberry St north to end, W side 284 -$ LowHatleyberry Street, Hiddenberry St to E Rarity Ridge Pkwy, NE/SE side 1101 -$ CompliantHatleyberry Street, E Rarity Ridge Pkwy to Fountberry St, SE side 561 33,660$ LowArkansas Avenue, Alger Rd to Albany Rd, NW/N side 667 40,020$ MediumAlbany Road, Arkansas Ave to Alger Rd, NE/SE side 1314 78,840$ MediumAlger Road, Albany Rd to Arkansas Ave, SW side 424 25,440$ MediumArkansas Avenue, Arizona Rd east to end, S side 20 1,200$ MediumAtlanta Road, Arkansas Ave east to end, N side 77 4,620$ LowAtlanta Road, Arkansas Ave to Anna Rd, S side 389 23,340$ MediumAnna Road, Atlanta Rd to Arkansas Ave, N/NW side 496 29,760$ MediumArizona Road, Arkansas Ave to Arkansas Ave, N side 835 50,100$ LowE Rarity Ridge Parkway, E Elderberry St to Hackberry St, NE side 240 7,200$ LowE Rarity Ridge Parkway, Hardinberry St to Hatleyberry St, NE side 244 14,640$ LowE Rarity Ridge Parkway, Hatleyberry St to Chaseberry Rd, NE side 727 43,620$ LowE Rarity Ridge Parkway, Chaseberry Rd to Bunchberry Rd, SW side 412 24,720$ LowBunchberry Road, E Rarity Ridge Pkwy to Fountberry St, SE side 686 -$ CompliantFountberry Street, Bunchberry Rd to Broadberry Ave, E side 179 -$ CompliantBunchberry Road, Fountberry St to E Rarity Ridge Pkwy, NW side 665 15,960$ LowE Rarity Ridge Parkway, Bunchberry Rd to Hatleyberry St, SW side 234 7,722$ LowE Rarity Ridge Parkway, Hatleyberry St to Hardinberry St, SW side 234 3,510$ LowE Rarity Ridge Parkway, Hardinberry St to Hackberry St, SW side 242 3,630$ LowE Rarity Ridge Parkway, Hackberry St to E Elderberry St, SW side 240 -$ CompliantFountberry Street, Checkerberry Rd west to end, S side 326 -$ CompliantFountberry Street, Checkerberry Rd to Broadberry Ave, W side 797 19,128$ LowCheckerberry Road, Fountberry St to E Elderberry St, S/SE side 1277 76,620$ LowPalladium Way, Novus Dr south to end, E side 784 2,352$ LowNovus Drive, Oak Ridge Turnpike to Novitas Pl, N side 1646 4,938$ LowRenovare Boulevard, Novus Dr south to end, E side 108 -$ LowNovus Drive, Renovare Blvd to Novitas Pl, NE side 267 16,020$ Low


Novitas Place, Novus Dr to Renovare Blvd, NW side 610 36,600$ LowRenovare Boulevard, Novus Dr to Novitas Pl, SE side 442 26,520$ LowRenovare Boulevard, Novitas Pl to northeast to end, SE side 3123 -$ CompliantImperium Drive, Oak Ridge Turnpike to Novitas Pl, NE side 970 -$ CompliantWaterview Drive, Edgemoor Rd north to end at apartment drive, W side 472 28,320$ LowWaterview Drive, west apartment drive east to end, NW side 1216 -$ CompliantWaterview Drive, Edgemoor Rd northwest to end, NE side 520 -$ CompliantWaterview Drive, Edgemoor Rd northwest to end, SW side 503 -$ CompliantCenter Park Lane, Park Meade Dr east to end at cul-de-sac, SE/S side 2791 167,460$ LowPark Meade Place, Park Meade Dr northeast to end, SE side 843 25,290$ LowPark Meade Drive, at homes between Park Meade Pl to Edgemoor Rd, E side 312 18,720$ LowEdgehill Lane, East Dr southwest to end, SE side 316 11,376$ LowAshland Lane, Alger Rd northwest to end, SW side 647 11,646$ LowE Arrowwood Road, Arkansas Ave to Athens Rd, S/SE side 1643 98,580$ MediumMontclair Road, Windham Rd to Middlebury Rd, S side 1562 93,720$ MediumAthens Road, East Dr southeast to playground entrance, NE side 500 -$ CompliantAtlanta Road, Athens Rd to Anna Rd, S side 800 48,000$ MediumAthens Road, Atlanta Rd to Arkansas Ave, W side 610 9,150$ MediumArkansas Avenue, Alger Rd to Athens Rd, N side 532 31,920$ MediumAthens Road, Arkansas Ave to Alger Rd, S side 644 38,640$ MediumAlger Road, Athens Rd to Audubon Rd, SE side 1344 80,640$ MediumWindham Road, Montclair Rd west to end, N side 790 47,400$ MediumMontclair Road, Windham Rd to Monticello Rd, S side 905 54,300$ MediumAudubon Road, Alger Rd to East Dr, W side 1762 10,572$ HighEast Drive, Audubon Rd to Athens Rd, SE side 383 22,980$ MediumEast Drive, Audubon Rd to Eastburn Ln, SE side 1396 83,760$ Medium Drive, Eastburn Ln to East Dr, NE/E side 2020 121,200$ MediumEaton Lane, East Dr SW to end, NW side 209 1,254$ LowWellington Circle, W Outer Dr to W Outer Dr, S side 1219 73,140$ MediumW Outer Road, Wayside Rd to Wayne Rd, SE side 758 45,480$ MediumW Outer Drive, Wayne Rd to Jefferson Ave, S side 498 29,880$ HighJefferson Avenue, W Outer Dr to Wayne Rd, W side 504 30,240$ HighJudd Lane, Jefferson Ave east to end, S side 132 -$ CompliantJonathan Lane, Jefferson Ave east to end, N side 556 33,360$ LowLivingston Road, Jefferson Ave to LaSalle Rd, W side 497 29,820$ MediumLaSalle Road, Livingston Rd west to end, N side 787 47,220$ MediumLouisiana Avenue, LaSalle Rd to Lawrence Ln, E side 347 20,820$ MediumLouisiana Avenue, LaSalle Rd to Lewis Ln, E side 175 10,500$ MediumLouisiana Avenue, Lewis Ln to Lehigh Ln, E side 731 43,860$ HighW Outer Drive, Louisiana Ave to Wayside Rd, SE side 1121 67,260$ MediumLouisiana Avenue, W Outer Dr to Lehigh Ln, W side 922 55,320$ MediumLaSalle Road, Louisiana Ave to Locust Ln, S side 1423 85,380$ HighLaSalle Road, Locust Ln to Revere Cir, S side 1931 115,860$ HighRevere Circle, LaSalle Rd to Robertsville Rd, W side 282 16,920$ MediumJefferson Avenue, Wayne Rd to Livingston Rd, S/W/SW side 2157 129,420$ HighJefferson Avenue, Livingston Rd to Robertsville Rd, S side 2607 156,420$ HighJefferson Avenue, Robertsville Rd to Johnson Rd, N/NE side 1365 81,900$ HighEast Drive, Alger Rd to Edgehill Ln, SW side 690 41,400$ MediumEast Drive, Edgehill Ln to Edison Ln, SW side 713 42,780$ MediumAlger Road, East Dr to Ashland Ln, NW side 729 43,740$ HighEast Drive, Edison Ln to Endicott Ln, N side 1203 72,180$ MediumEast Drive, Endicott Ln west to end, N side 381 22,860$ MediumEast Drive, Emerson Cir east to end, SE side 384 2,304$ LowE side East Drive, Emerson Cir southwest to end, SE side 304 18,240$ Low


East Drive, Englewood Ln to Essex Ln, W side 1356 81,360$ MediumAmherst Lane, Alger Rd to Andover Cir, S side 1139 68,340$ LowAndover Circle, Amherst Ln to Amherst Ln, outside of circle 1505 90,300$ LowOlney Lane, Outer Dr north to end, NW side 757 45,420$ LowOneida Lane, Outer Dr north to end, W side 629 37,740$ LowOrange Lane, Outer Dr north to end, W side 1023 61,380$ LowLouisiana Avenue, Lawrence Ln to Robertsville Rd, N/NE side 783 46,980$ HighRobertsville Road, Louisiana Ave to Lancaster Rd, S side 1078 64,680$ HighLouisiana Avenue, Robertsville Rd to Lawton Rd, N side 482 28,920$ MediumLawton Road, Louisiana Ave to Lancaster Rd, N side 1180 70,800$ MediumLancaster Road, S Lansing Rd to Robertsville Rd, E side 591 35,460$ HighLouisiana Avenue, Lawton Rd to Lancaster Rd, E side 530 9,540$ MediumLancaster Road, Louisiana Ave to S Lansing Rd, SE side 585 10,530$ MediumLouisiana Avenue, Lancaster Rd to E Lincoln Rd, E side 741 11,115$ LowS Lansing Road, N Jefferson Cir to Latimer Rd, N side 251 15,060$ LowS Lansing Road, Latimer Rd to Lancaster Rd, N side 339 20,340$ LowJoel Lane, N Jefferson Cir south to end, E and S side 469 -$ CompliantN Jefferson Circle, Latimer Rd to Jefferson Ct, N side 104 6,240$ LowRobertsville Road, east school driveway west to end, S side 422 -$ CompliantWarrior Lane, W Outer Dr to Warrior Cir, SW side 277 16,620$ LowWarrior Circle, inside of circle 1093 65,580$ MediumCalifornia Avenue, E Tennessee Ave to W Arrowwood Rd, E side 1492 89,520$ MediumRobertsville Road, Louisiana Ave to N Seneca Rd, NW side 534 32,040$ LowCalifornia Avenue, Cedar Rd northerly to end, N/NE side 1717 103,020$ MediumRobertsville Road, N Seneca Rd to Mississippi Ave, N side 1711 51,330$ LowCalifornia Avenue, E Tennessee Ave to Tacoma Rd, SW side 299 17,940$ LowRobertsville Road, Mississippi Ave to E Melbourne Rd, NW side 4159 249,540$ HighTacoma Road, California Ave southeast to end, NW side 995 59,700$ MediumTacoma Road, E Tennessee Ave to California Ave, S/SE side 1436 86,160$ LowCalifornia Avenue, Tacoma Rd to Oak Ridge Tpk, SW side 109 6,540$ LowDixie Lane, Delaware Ave, northeast to end, NW/N side 796 47,760$ LowBermuda Road, Robertsville Rd to Briar Rd, E side 545 3,270$ LowBermuda Road, Briar Rd to Oak Ridge Turnpike, NE side 553 3,318$ LowLatimer Road, S Lansing Rd to N Jefferson Cir, SE side 1777 31,986$ LowN Jefferson Circle, Latimer Rd to S Lansing Rd, N side 1406 84,360$ MediumDelmar Circle, Decatur Rd east to end around cul-de-sac, all sides 1222 73,320$ LowS Jefferson Circle, S Lansing Rd to Jefferson Ave, E/NE side 2314 138,840$ MediumJefferson Avenue, S Jefferson Cir to N Jefferson Cir, W side 454 9,534$ LowOgden Circle, inside of circle 1077 64,620$ LowOgden Lane, Oglethorpe Ln south to end, E side 482 28,920$ LowOglethorpe Lane, Ogden Ln east to end, SE side 175 10,500$ LowOuter Drive, Ogden Ln south to end, W side 600 36,000$ LowOgden Lane, Outer Dr north to end, SW side 259 15,540$ LowCalifornia Avenue, Chatham Ln east to end, S side 440 26,400$ LowRobertsville Road, Lancaster Rd to Jefferson Ct, S side 1852 111,120$ MediumCalifornia Avenue, Chatham Ln to East Dr, S side 1447 86,820$ LowOuter Drive, East Dr to Delaware Ave, S side 2701 162,060$ LowJefferson Court, N Jefferson Cir to Jefferson Ave 599 35,940$ LowJefferson Avenue, Jefferson Ct east/south to end, S/E side 601 36,060$ LowJefferson Avenue, Jefferson Terminal Rd to Jefferson Terminal Rd, E side 786 47,160$ LowRobertsville Road, Jefferson Ave west to end, N side 441 7,938$ LowDelaware Avenue/Outer Drive, Dewey Rd to Ogontz Ln, S/SE side 3425 205,500$ LowOgontz Lane, Outer Dr to Olean Rd, N side 329 19,740$ LowOgontz Lane, Olean Rd island, N side 79 4,740$ Low


Olmstead Lane, Ogontz Ln south to end, E side 384 23,040$ LowOgontz Lane, Olmstead Lane east to end, S side 465 27,900$ LowOlean Road, Ogontz Ln to Ogontz Ln, N side 208 12,480$ LowJohnson Road, Jefferson Ave to Jarrett Ln, E side 445 26,700$ MediumJarrett Lane, Johnson Rd east to end, N side 675 40,500$ LowThelma Road, Tennessee Avenue to Tilden Rd, NE side, 634 38,040$ LowTilden Road, Tennessee Avenue to Thelma Rd, NE side, 652 39,120$ LowE Tennessee Avenue, Tilden Rd to Thelman Rd, NW side 175 10,500$ LowFlorida Avenue, E Fairview Rd to E Farragut Rd, NE side 272 16,320$ LowE Farragut Road, Florida Ave to E Fairview Rd, SE side 485 29,100$ LowE Fairview Road, E Farragut Rd to Florida Ave, NW side 438 26,280$ LowFlorida Avenue, E Farragut Rd to E Faunce Ln, NE side 216 12,960$ MediumFlorida Avenue, E Faunce Ln to E Fernhill Ln, NE side 239 14,340$ MediumJohnson Road, Jellico Ln to Jarrett Ln, E side 1249 74,940$ MediumEast Faunce Lane, Florida Ave northeast to end, SE side 320 19,200$ LowJasper Lane, Johnson Rd west to end, SW side 276 1,656$ LowJay Lane, Johnson Rd west to end, S side 279 16,740$ LowEast Fernhill Lane, Florida Ave northeast to end, NW side 671 40,260$ LowJellico Lane, Johnson Rd southeast to end, NE side 600 36,000$ LowJohnson Road, Jellico Ln to W Outer Dr, NE side 595 35,700$ LowJersey Lane, Johnson Rd southwest to end, SE side 922 55,320$ LowWest Fernhill Road, W Faunce Rd to Florida Ave, SE side 460 27,600$ LowWest Faunce Road, W Fernhill Rd to Florida Ave, NW side 507 30,420$ LowWest Farragut Road, W Fairview Rd to Florida Ave, SE side 649 38,940$ LowW Outer Drive, Johnson Rd to N Illinois Ave, SE side 307 18,420$ LowOuter Drive, Ogontz Ln to Florida Ave, SE side 1232 73,920$ LowFlorida Avenue, Fulton Ln to Georgia Ave, S side 565 33,900$ LowW Outer Drive, Johnson Rd to Jefferson Ave, S side 1727 103,620$ MediumOuter Drive, Georgia Ave to Ontario Ln, S side 775 46,500$ MediumOuter Drive, Ontario Ln to Michigan Ave, S side 1700 102,000$ MediumKentucky Avenue, Michigan Ave to Kingsley Rd, S side 406 24,360$ MediumKentucky Avenue, Kingsley Rd to Kimball Ln, N side 382 22,920$ MediumKentucky Avenue, Kimball Ln to Kenwyn Rd, NE side 470 28,200$ HighKentucky Avenue, Kenwyn Rd to Kelvin Ln, NE side 210 12,600$ HighKentucky Avenue, Kelvin Ln to Knoll Ln, E side 1435 86,100$ HighW Outer Drive, N Illinois Ave to Warwick Ln, SE side 490 29,400$ MediumWarwick Ln/Ivy Lane, W Outer Dr to N Illinois Ave, SW/W side 710 42,600$ LowN Illinois Avenue, Ivy Ln to W Outer Dr, N side 710 4,260$ HighWaltham Lane, W Outer Dr south to end, E side 524 31,440$ LowWaltham Place, Waltham Ln west to end, S side 329 11,844$ LowW Outer Drive, Waltham Ln to Walsh Ln, S side 237 8,532$ LowWalsh Lane, W Outer Dr south to end, W side 222 13,320$ LowW Outer Drive, Walsh Ln to Walnut Ln, SE side 200 12,000$ LowWalpole Lane, W Outer Dr north to end, W side 130 7,800$ LowWalnut Lane, W Outer Dr southeast to end, NE side 481 28,860$ LowW Outer Drive, Walnut Ln to W Wadsworth Cir, SE side 265 15,900$ LowW Outer Drive, W Wadsworth Cir to Wainwright Rd, SE side 257 15,420$ LowW Outer Drive, Wainwright Rd to S Walker Ln, SE side 235 14,100$ LowMoylan Lane, Michigan Ave east to end, S side 546 32,760$ LowOntario Lane, Outer Dr south to end, W side 1193 71,580$ LowWainwright Road, E Wadsworth Cir to W Outer Dr, N side 1162 69,720$ MediumTabor Road, E Tennessee Ave to N Tampa Ln, NE side 1806 108,360$ LowW Wadsworth Circle, W Outer Dr to Wainwright Rd, N side 1807 108,420$ MediumW Wadsworth Circle, W Outer Dr to Wainwright Rd, W side 419 25,140$ Low


N Tampa Lane, Taylor Rd north to end, SW/S side 531 31,860$ LowS Tampa Lane, Taylor Rd south to end, SW/W side 578 34,680$ LowWakeman Lane, W Wadsworth Cir to Wakefield Rd, E side 511 30,660$ MediumWakefield Road, Wakeman Ln to W Wadsworth Cir, NW side 721 43,260$ MediumTaylor Road, N Tampa Ln to Thayer Ln, W/SW side 1939 116,340$ LowTaylor Road, Thayer Ln to E Tennessee Ave, W side 264 -$ CompliantTaylor Road, E Tennessee Ave northwest to end, NE/E side 737 44,220$ MediumThayer Lane, Taylor Rd west to end, N side 438 26,280$ LowN Illinois Avenue, Iroquois Rd to W Outer Dr, S side 1327 6,370$ HighE Tennessee Avenue, Delaware Ave to Tabor Rd, NW side 617 37,020$ LowE Tennessee Avenue, Taylor Rd to Thelma Rd, NW side 423 7,614$ LowN Illinois Avenue, Ivy Ln to Irene St, N side 1883 62,139$ MediumIrene Street, N Illinois Ave to end, NE/SE sides 273 16,380$ LowN Illinois Avenue, Independence Ln to Iona Cir, S side 204 6,732$ LowN Illinois Avenue, Iona Cir to Iona Cir, S side 240 14,400$ MediumOrchard Lane, Outer Dr to Orkney Rd, SE side 1247 74,820$ LowN Illinois Avenue, Iona Cir to Iroquois Rd, S side 231 13,860$ MediumOrchard Lane, Outer Dr to Orkney Rd, SE side 1288 77,280$ LowIroquois Road, N Illinois Ave to Ithaca Ln, E side 967 58,020$ MediumGordon Street, Georgia Ave to Glendale Ln, E side 710 42,600$ LowGlendale Lane, Gordon Rd south to end, NW side 335 20,100$ LowGlendale Lane, Gordon Rd to Georgia Ave, NW side 471 28,260$ LowGeorgia Avenue, Glendale Ln to Gordon Rd, SW side 450 27,000$ LowWadsworth Place, E Wadsworth Cir southeast to end, NE side 655 39,300$ LowKingfisher Lane, Kenwyn Rd south to end, E side 784 47,040$ LowKingsley Road, Kingfisher Ln to Kentucky Ave, SW side 770 46,200$ LowKimball Lane, Kentucky Ave south to end, W side 201 12,060$ LowKenwyn Road, Kentucky Ave to Keystone Ln, N side 509 30,540$ LowW Outer Drive, S Walker Ln to E Wadsworth Cir, S side 791 47,460$ LowKeystone Lane, Kenwyn Rd north to end, E side 182 10,920$ LowKelvin Lane, Kentucky Ave south to end, SE side 184 11,040$ LowW Outer Drive, E Wadsworth Cir to Highland Ave, S side 971 17,478$ LowE Geneva Lane, Georgia Ave northeast to end, NW side 875 52,500$ LowW Outer Drive, Highland Ave to Wabash Ln, S side 538 32,280$ MediumW Geneva Lane, Georgia Ave west to end, S side 422 25,320$ LowW Outer Drive, Wedgewood Rd to N Walker Ln, N side 2419 145,140$ MediumGeorgia Avenue, Broadway Ave to W Geneva Ln, W side 296 17,760$ MediumGeorgia Avenue, W Geneva Ln to Glendale Ln, W side 633 37,980$ LowGeorgia Avenue, Gordon Rd to Gorgas Ln, NE side 961 57,660$ LowGorgas Lane, Georgia Ave southeast to end, N/NE side 746 44,760$ LowGeorgia Avenue, Gorgas Ln to Outer Dr, E side 349 20,940$ LowFulton Lane, Florida Ave south to end, E side 612 36,720$ LowFlorida Avenue, Fulton Ln to E Forest Ln, N/NE side 839 50,340$ LowE Forest Lane, Florida Ave to Firestone Rd, NW/N side 458 27,480$ LowFirestone Road, Florida Ave to E Forest Ln, NE/N side 429 25,740$ LowW Forest Lane, Florida Ave southwest to end, SE side 187 11,220$ LowFlorida Avenue, W Forest Ln to W Fernhill Rd, S side 751 45,060$ LowS Walker Lane, W Outer Dr southeast to end, N/NE side 411 24,660$ LowN Walker Lane, W Outer Dr northwest to end, SW side 393 23,580$ LowW Fairview Road, Florida Ave to E Tennessee Ave, S side 894 53,640$ LowTrevose Lane, E Tennessee Ave north to end, W side 365 21,900$ LowFlorida Avenue, E Fairview Rd to E Tennessee Ave, NE side 209 12,540$ LowE Tennessee Avenue, Florida Ave to Tilden Rd, NW side 578 34,680$ LowHoyt Lane, Highland Ave east to end, N side 287 17,220$ Low


Oak Ridge Turnpike, Wisconsin Ave to Westover Dr, NW side 1081 9,729$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Westover Dr to Oklahoma Ave, NW side 1531 45,930$ LowOsage Road, Oxford Rd to Outer Dr, NE side 340 20,400$ LowOxford Road, Osage Rd to Outer Dr, NW/SW side 355 21,300$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Gum Hollow Rd to Grandcove Ln, SE side 1250 -$ CompliantOuter Drive, Oxford Rd to Osage Rd, NW side 169 10,140$ LowOuter Drive, Osage Rd to Key Spring Rd, NW side 963 57,780$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Grandcove Ln southwest to end, SE side 1585 -$ CompliantOuter Drive, Key Spring Rd to New York Ave, NW side 762 45,720$ LowNorwood Lane, New York Ave southwest to end, NW side 334 20,040$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Oklahoma Ave to Nebraska Ave, NW side 2694 8,082$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Nebraska Ave to Gum Hollow Rd, S side 2536 -$ CompliantNorris Ln, New York Avenue southwest to end, SE side 497 29,820$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Newport Dr to Nebraska Ave, NW side 599 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, Nebraska Ave to New Bedford Ln, SE side 1516 -$ CompliantBroadway Avenue, Kentucky Ave to Towne Rd, SE side 541 6,492$ MediumOak Ridge Turnpike, New Bedford Rd to Newport Dr, NW side 872 -$ CompliantBroadway Avenue, Towne Rd to Kentucky Ave, NE side 562 6,744$ MediumBroadway Avenue, Towne Rd to Georgia Ave, S side 580 3,480$ MediumBroadway Avenue, Towne Rd to Georgia Ave, N side 654 39,240$ MediumOak Ridge Turnpike, New Bedford Rd to Monterrey Rd, S side 1102 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, Monterrey Rd to Montana Ave, S side 558 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, Montana Ave to New Bedford Ln, N side 1834 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, Montana Ave to Bermuda Rd, S/SE side 3029 9,087$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Bermuda Rd to Bradley Ave, NW side 2075 2,490$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Bradley Ave to Montana Ave, N side 800 -$ CompliantHighland Avenue, W Outer Dr to N Hollywood Cir, W side 406 14,616$ LowN Hollywood Circle, Highland Ave to S Hollywood Cir, NW side 546 19,656$ LowS Hollywood Circle, Highland Ave to N Hollywood Cir, SE side 455 16,380$ LowHighland Avenue, N Hollywood Cir to S Hollywood Cir, W side 517 31,020$ MediumHighland Avenue, S Hollywood Cir to W Holston Ln, W side 300 18,000$ MediumW Holston Lane, Highland Ave west to end, N side 349 20,940$ LowHighland Avenue, W Holston Ln to Hillside Rd, W side 458 27,480$ MediumE Tennessee Avenue, Tacoma Rd northeast to end, S side 381 18,288$ LowHighland Avenue, Hillside Rd to Howard Ln, E side 253 15,180$ MediumHoward Lane, Highland Ave east to end, SE side 287 17,220$ LowE Tennessee Avenue, Tacoma Rd to Temple Rd, SE side 165 -$ CompliantE Holston Lane, Highland Ave east to end, SE side 187 11,220$ LowE Tennessee Avenue, Temple Rd to Thornton Rd, SE side 177 10,620$ LowE Tennessee Avenue, Thornton Rd to Tomlinson Rd, SE side 188 2,820$ LowE Tennessee Avenue, Tomlinson Rd to Townsend Rd, SE side 166 9,960$ LowE Tennessee Avenue, Townsend Rd to Florida Ave, SE side 171 -$ CompliantE Tennessee Avenue, Florida Ave to Turner Rd, SE side 807 48,420$ MediumE Tennessee Avenue, Turner Rd to Georgia Ave, SE side 979 58,740$ MediumTemple Road, Thornton Rd to E Tennessee Ave, SW side 597 35,820$ LowThornton Road, Temple Rd to E Tennessee Ave, NE side 573 34,380$ LowNew York Avenue, E Newcomb Rd to Norman Ln, NE/E side 1355 81,300$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Bermuda Rd to Wiltshire Dr, SE side 1605 4,815$ LowNew York Avenue, Norman Ln to Outer Dr, NE side 935 56,100$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Wiltshire Dr to Salem Rd, S side 796 -$ CompliantOuter Drive, New York Ave northeast to end, NW side 1859 111,540$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Salem Rd to Bermuda Rd, NW side 2421 2,905$ LowOuter Drive, Michigan Ave southwest to end, SE side 849 50,940$ MediumOak Ridge Turnpike, Salem Rd to Louisiana Ave, SE side 2626 23,634$ Low


Milton Lane, Michigan Ave west to end, N side 242 14,520$ LowMilton Lane, Michigan Ave west to end, S side 236 14,160$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Louisiana Ave to W Lincoln Rd, NW side 1623 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, W Lincoln Rd to Salem Rd, N side 784 47,040$ HighMichigan Avenue, Milton Ln to Meadow Rd, W side 284 17,040$ MediumMeadow Road, Michigan Ave west to end, N/NW side 630 37,800$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Louisiana Ave to Jefferson Ave, NW side 2765 4,977$ LowMeadow Road, Maple Ln north to end, E side 667 12,006$ LowMaple Lane, Meadow Rd southwest to end, NW side 827 49,620$ LowMaple Lane, Meadow Rd to Michigan Ave, N side 303 18,180$ LowMichigan Avenue, Meadow Rd to Mayfair Ln, W side 187 11,220$ LowMayfair Lane, Michigan Ave west to end, S side 341 20,460$ LowMichigan Avenue, Mayfair Ln to Maple Ln, W side 92 5,520$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, W Vanderbilt Dr to Louisiana Ave, SE side 2774 4,993$ LowMichigan Avenue, Kentucky Ave to Marion Rd, E side 295 17,700$ LowE Malta Road, Marion Rd to Michigan Ave, NW side 463 27,780$ LowMarion Road, E Malta Rd to Michigan Ave, S/SW side 580 34,800$ LowMichigan Avenue, Marion Rd to E Malta Rd, E side 600 36,000$ LowE side Wabash Lane, W Outer Dr to Wade Ln, NE side 251 15,060$ LowWabash Lane, Wade Ln to Waddell Pl., NE side 279 16,740$ LowWaddell Place, Wabash Ln northeast to end, NW side 96 5,760$ LowWaddell Circle, inside of circle 1342 80,520$ LowWade Lane, Wabash Ln northeast to end, SE side 720 43,200$ LowW Outer Drive, Wedgewood Rd to Westlook Dr, NE side 1178 70,680$ MediumW side Tomlinson Road, E Tennessee Ave to end, SW side 395 23,700$ LowTownsend Road, Tomlinson Rd to E Tennessee Ave, SW side 685 41,100$ LowWestlook Drive, W Outer Dr to Westlook Cir, SW side 324 19,440$ LowW Outer Drive, Westlook Dr to Pennsylvania Ave, N side 928 55,680$ MediumGeorgia Avenue, E Tennessee Ave north to end, E side 236 14,160$ MediumOuter Drive, W Outer Dr to Oxford Rd, NW side 316 18,960$ MediumW Price Lane, Pennsylvania Ave west to end, S side 466 27,960$ LowSzilard Street, TeeJay Dr to Curie Lane, E side 253 15,180$ LowCurie Lane, Szilard St to Terrace Park Pl., N side 249 4,482$ LowNorman Lane, New York Ave east to end, S side 350 21,000$ LowTerrace Park Place, Curie Ln to Oppenheimer Way, W side 179 3,222$ LowOppenheimer Way, Terrace Park Pl to Szilard Street, SE side 210 3,780$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, W Outer Dr to W Price Ln, E side 199 11,940$ MediumE Price Lane, Pennsylvania Ave to Powell Rd, NW/NE side 750 45,000$ LowPowell Road, Pennsylvania Ave to E Price Lane, E/SE side 254 15,240$ LowPowell Road, Pennsylvania Ave east to end, NW side 320 19,200$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, Powell Rd to Porter Rd, NE side 191 11,460$ MediumPennsylvania Avenue, Powell Rd to E Price Rd, NE side 200 7,800$ LowNolan Road, Nixon Rd to New York Ave, W side 465 27,900$ LowNixon Road, Nolan Rd to New York Ave, S side 355 21,300$ LowTuskegee Drive, TeeJay Dr southwest to end, NW side 2687 8,061$ LowNorton Road, New York Ave to Underwood Rd, NW side 999 17,982$ LowUnderwood Road, New York Ave to Norton Rd, SW side 904 13,560$ LowTeeJay Drive, Tuskegee Dr northwest to end, SW side 243 2,916$ LowW Malta Road, Michigan Ave southwest to end, SE side 122 7,320$ LowW Malta Road, Michigan Ave southwest to end, NE side 579 34,740$ LowMalvern Road, Michigan Ave southwest to end, SE side 297 5,346$ LowMalvern Road, Michigan Ave southwest to end, NE side 788 14,184$ LowTeeJay Drive, Teller Village Ln to Tuskegee Dr, NE side 242 14,520$ LowTuskegee Drive, TeeJay Dr to Tempura Dr, NW side 1589 4,767$ Low


Oak Ridge Turnpike between S Illinois Ave and Orau Way, S side 224 -$ CompliantS side Tempura Drive, Targa Ln to S Taube Ln 570 34,200$ LowS Taube Lane, Tempura Dr to cul-de-sac, E side 219 1,314$ LowS Taube Lane, Tempura Dr to cul-de-sac, W side 222 1,332$ LowTempura Drive, S Targa Ln west to end, S side 186 11,160$ LowN Taube Lane, Tempura Dr north to end, SW side 442 26,520$ LowTuskegee Drive, Tempura Dr to Benedict Ave, NW side 1965 5,895$ LowTuskegee Drive, Tulsa Rd to Benedict Ave, NW side 1098 65,880$ HighW Maiden Lane, Michigan Ave southwest to end, NW side 461 27,660$ LowE Maiden Lane, Michigan Ave northeast to end, NW side 549 32,940$ LowMichigan Avenue, E Malta Rd to E Maiden Ln, NE side 200 12,000$ LowMichigan Avenue, E Maiden Ln to E Magnolia Ln, NE side 200 12,000$ LowE Magnolia Lane, Michigan Ave northeast to end, SE side 508 30,480$ LowHampton Road, Tuskegee Dr to Wilberforce Ave, NE side 289 17,340$ LowW Magnolia Lane, Michigan Ave southwest to end, NW side 647 38,820$ LowWilberforce Avenue, Hampton Rd to Houston Ave, N side 1125 67,500$ MediumUlena Lane, Utah Ave northwest to end, SW side 356 21,360$ LowWilberforce Avenue, Houston Ave northeast to end, NW side 330 19,800$ MediumUmbria Lane, Utah Ave south to end, W/NW side 394 23,640$ LowUlysses Lane, Utah Ave to Upsal Rd, W side 466 27,960$ LowUlysses Lane, Upsal Rd south to end, W side 265 15,900$ LowS Benedict Avenue, Houston Ave to Tuskegee Dr, SW side 128 3,840$ LowS Benedict Avenue, Houston Ave to Wilberforce Ave, W side 525 31,500$ MediumGeorgia Avenue, Broadway Ave to E Tennessee Ave, W side 200 12,000$ MediumE Tennessee Avenue, Georgia Ave to Towne Rd, NW side 244 14,640$ MediumTowne Road, E Tennessee Ave to Broadway Ave, NE side 333 19,980$ MediumTowne Road, Broadway Ave to E Tennessee Ave, SW side 328 19,680$ MediumWilberforce Avenue, S Benedict Ave to Carver Ave, SE side 471 28,260$ MediumE Tennessee Avenue, Towne Rd to Kentucky Ave, NW side 503 30,180$ MediumCarver Avenue, Wilberforce Ave to S Benedict Ave, W side 1062 63,720$ HighS Benedict Avenue, Carver Ave to S Dillard Ave, N side 1073 64,380$ HighKentucky Avenue, E Tennessee Ave to Broadway Ave, NE side 301 9,933$ MediumBroadway Avenue, Kentucky Ave to Towne Rd, SE side 182 3,276$ LowS Dillard Avenue, Fisk Ave to Wilberforce Ave, W side 866 51,960$ MediumKentucky Avenue, Broadway Ave to Knoll Ln, NE side 145 8,700$ MediumWilberforce Avenue, S Dillard Ave to Carver Ave, SE side 274 16,440$ MediumE Madison Road, Michigan Ave northeast to end, SE side 945 56,700$ MediumBroadway Avenue, Kentucky Ave to Michigan Ave, NW side 960 57,600$ HighMichigan Avenue, E Madison Rd to Broadway Ave, N side 102 6,120$ MediumKentucky Avenue, Broadway Ave to W Tennessee Ave, SW side 276 8,280$ MediumMichigan Avenue, Broadway Ave to W Tennessee Ave, NE side 165 9,900$ MediumW Tennessee Avenue, Michigan Ave to Kentucky Ave, NW side 841 50,460$ MediumBroadway Avenue, Kentucky Ave to Michigan Ave, SE side 226 13,560$ LowTyler Road, E Tyrone Rd to W Tennessee Ave, NE side 238 14,280$ LowW Tennessee Avenue, Tyler Rd to Kentucky Ave, SE side 244 14,640$ MediumS Benedict Avenue, Carver Ave, easterly to end, N/NW side 1182 70,920$ MediumE Tennessee Avenue, Kentucky Ave to Central Ave, SE side 263 3,945$ LowCentral Avenue, E, Tennessee Ave to E Tyrone Rd, SW side 148 4,440$ LowBethune Circle, S Benedict Ave to S Benedict Ave, inside of circle 1030 61,800$ MediumCentral Avenue, Oak Ridge Turnpike to E Tennessee Ave, NE side 746 38,046$ HighE Tennessee Avenue, Central Ave to Georgia Ave, S side 683 12,294$ LowSpellman Avenue, S Benedict Ave to Hampton Rd, NW side 1241 74,460$ MediumGeorgia Avenue, E Tennessee Ave to Tyson Rd, SW side 330 9,900$ LowHampton Road, Spellman Ave to S Dillard Ave, E side 260 15,600$ Medium


Upsal Road, Ulysses Ln to Utah Ave, E side 587 35,220$ LowUtah Avenue, Upsal Rd to Ulysses Ln, S side 169 10,140$ LowS Dillard Avenue, Hampton Rd to Fisk Ave, NW side 717 43,020$ MediumS Fisk Avenue, S Dillard Ave to Wilberforce Ave, E side 673 40,380$ MediumHampton Road, Wilberforce Ave to S Dillard Ave, NE side 1108 66,480$ MediumUvalde Lane, Utah Ave south to end, W side 332 19,920$ LowUtah Avenue, Ulysses Ln to Umbria Ln, S side 289 17,340$ LowUtah Avenue, Umbria Ln to Ulena Ln, S side 280 16,800$ LowUtah Avenue, Ulena Ln to New York Ave, S side 420 25,200$ LowGroves Park Boulevard between Tuskegee Dr and Einstein Ave, NE side 103 6,180$ LowGroves Park Boulevard, Tuskegee Dr to Einstein Ave, SW side 469 1,407$ LowW Newcomb Road, New York Ave to W Newkirk Ln, SE/NE side 601 36,060$ LowNewkirk Lane, W Newcomb Rd southwest to end, NW side 535 32,100$ LowEinstein Avenue, Groves Park Blvd. E to Alley G, SE side 106 -$ CompliantW Newkirk Lane, W Newcomb Rd to New York Ave, NW side 627 37,620$ LowGroves Park Boulevard, Einstein Ave to Alley I, W side 482 28,920$ LowMichigan Avenue, E Magnolia Ln to E Madison Rd, NE side 536 32,160$ LowGroves Park Boulevard, Alley C to Oppenheimer Way, E side 106 6,360$ LowE Newcomb Road, New York Ave to E Newkirk Ln, NW/NE side 308 18,480$ LowE Newcomb Road, E Newkirk Ln northwest to end, NE side 193 11,580$ LowE Newcomb Road, E Newkirk Ln to New York Ave, S side 558 33,480$ LowNew York Avenue, E Newcomb Rd to E Newkirk Ln, NE side 156 9,360$ LowOppenheimer Way, Groves Park Blvd E east to end, N side 123 -$ CompliantE Newkirk Lane, New York Ave northeast to end, SE side 1122 67,320$ LowNew York Avenue, E Newkirk Ln to Nesper Rd, NE side 181 10,860$ LowNew York Avenue, Nesper Rd to W Tennessee Ave, NE side 278 16,680$ LowPacific Road, Pennsylvania Ave to Packer Rd, SW/S side 508 30,480$ LowPacker Road, Pacific Rd to Pennsylvania Ave, SW side 496 29,760$ LowPalmetto Lane, Pennsylvania Ave northwest to end, SW side 483 28,980$ LowMichigan Avenue, Outer Dr to Milton Ln, W side 860 18,060$ MediumCrossroads Boulevard, Cobblestone Ct southwest to end, SE side 322 2,898$ LowCrossroads Boulevard, Cobblestone Ct to Cottage Ct, SE side 227 -$ CompliantCrossroads Boulevard, Cottage Ct to Wolfcreek Way, SE side 200 1,200$ LowCrossroads Boulevard, Wolfcreek Way to Crystal Cove Ln, SE side 192 -$ CompliantCrossroads Boulevard, Crystal Cove Ln to Crescent View Ln, SE side 191 -$ CompliantCrossroads Boulevard, Crescent View Ln to Pavilion Dr, SE side 180 10,800$ LowCrossroads Boulevard, Pavilion Dr northeast to end, NW side 852 51,120$ LowCrossroads Boulevard, northeast end of circle, SW side 86 -$ CompliantCrossroads Boulevard, Pavilion Dr northeast to end, SE side 851 -$ CompliantPavilion Drive, Crossroads Blvd southeast to end, NE side 101 6,060$ LowPavilion Drive, Crossroads Blvd to Crossroads Blvd, NE side 113 -$ CompliantWolf Creek Way, Crossroads Blvd to Cross Creek Pl, SW side 557 33,420$ LowWolf Creek Way, Cross Creek Pl to Cove Point Ln, SW side 269 16,140$ MediumWolf creek Way, Cove Point Ln to Crestpointe Ln, SW/S/NW side 1179 63,666$ LowCreekview Court, Wolf Creek Way north to end, W side 1013 39,507$ LowWolf Creek Way, Crestpointe Ln southwest to end 129 1,935$ LowCross Creek Place, Wolf Creek Way northeast to end, NW side 321 -$ CompliantS Purdue Avenue, Manchester Rd to Park Ln, SE side 1819 109,140$ MediumS Purdue Avenue, Park Ln to Pratt Ln, E side 983 58,980$ MediumQuincy Avenue, Queens Rd to S Purdue Avenue, NW side 644 38,640$ MediumNorthwestern Avenue, S Purdue Ave to Nasson Ln, N side 651 39,060$ MediumNasson Lane, Northwestern Ave northeast to end, W side 819 49,140$ MediumPembroke Road, Northwestern Ave to S Purdue Ave, NW side 2019 121,140$ MediumQueens Road, Quincy Ave to Pembroke Rd, NE side 179 10,740$ Medium


Quincy Avenue, Queens Rd to S Purdue Ave, NW side 791 47,460$ LowPotomac Circle, S Purdue Ave to S Purdue Ave, inside of circle 952 57,120$ LowS Purdue Avenue, Potomac Cir to Potomac Cir, W side 490 29,400$ LowS Purdue Avenue, Potomac Cir to Woodland Terrace E, SW side 514 30,840$ LowS Purdue Avenue, Woodland Terrace E to Paris Ln, SW side 548 18,084$ LowS Purdue Avenue, Paris Ln to Pratt Ln, SE side 273 16,380$ LowW Tennessee Avenue, New York Ave to Nesper Rd, NW side 705 19,035$ LowW Tennessee Avenue, Nesper Rd southwest to end, SE side 92 2,760$ LowNesper Road, W Tennessee Ave to New York Ave, SE side 863 51,780$ MediumW Tennessee Avenue, Nesper Rd to Michigan Ave, NW side 1528 91,680$ MediumS Illinois Avenue, S Rutgers Ave to Inn Ln, SW side 591 4,255$ LowS Illinois Avenue, Inn Ln to Scarboro Ln, SW side 1469 13,221$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, New York Ave to Pacific Rd, NW side 168 -$ CompliantPennsylvania Avenue, Pacific Rd to Packer Rd, NW side 189 11,340$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, Packer Rd to Palmer Rd, NW side 183 10,980$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, Palmer Rd to Palmetto Ln, NW side 317 19,020$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, Palmetto Ln to Paoli Ln, NW side 246 14,760$ LowS Illinois Avenue, Woodland Terrace E to S Rutgers Ave, NE side 1296 15,552$ LowPaoli Lane, Pennsylvania Ave northwest to end, NE/NW side 576 34,560$ LowWoodland Terrace, S Illinois Ave to S Purdue Ave, NW side 356 5,340$ LowWoodland Terrace, S Illinois Ave to S Purdue Ave, SE side 342 7,182$ LowS Illinois Avenue, Woodland Terrace E to Lafayette Dr, NE side 1198 39,534$ LowScarboro Road, S Illinois Ave south within traffic island, W side 90 -$ CompliantS Illinois Avenue, Scarboro Rd to Scarboro Ln, SW side 446 8,028$ LowS Illinois Avenue, Lafayette Dr east to end in traffic island, N side 221 13,260$ MediumS Illinois Avenue, Lafayette Dr to Centrifuge Way, NE side 1351 81,060$ LowS Illinois Avenue, Summit Pl to Scarboro Rd, SE side 1639 98,340$ LowManhattan Avenue, S Rutgers Ave to S Purdue Ave, S side 780 46,800$ MediumManhattan Avenue, S Purdue Ave to Northwestern Ave, SE side 1106 46,452$ MediumManhattan Avenue, Northwestern Ave to Morris Ln, SE side 632 37,920$ MediumManhattan Avenue, Morris Ln to Manchester Rd, SE side 243 4,374$ LowManhattan Avenue, W Gettysburg Ave to Marietta Cir, W side 661 39,660$ LowManhattan Avenue, Marietta Cir to Marietta Cir, W side 251 15,060$ LowManhattan Avenue, Marietta Cir to Northwestern Ave, E side 221 -$ CompliantManhattan Avenue, Marietta Cir to Northwestern Ave, NW side 1166 6,996$ LowManhattan Avenue, Northwestern Ave to N Purdue Ave, NW side 1124 67,440$ MediumManhattan Avenue, N Purdue Ave to S Rutgers Ave, N side 777 2,331$ LowPalmer Road, Pennsylvania Ave to E Pasadena Rd, SE side 326 19,560$ LowE Pasadena Road, Palmer Rd to Pennsylvania Ave, S side 1734 104,040$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, E Pasadena Rd to Paoli Ln, N side 971 58,260$ LowManchester Road, Lafayette Dr to Manhattan Ave, N side 1019 9,171$ LowUnion Road, Utah Ave to Porter Rd, NW side 225 13,500$ LowPorter Road, Union Rd to Pennsylvania Ave, N side 875 52,500$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, Porter Rd to Utah Ave, E side 175 10,500$ LowMarietta Circle, Manhattan Ave to Manhattan Ave, inside of circle 1279 76,740$ LowUtah Avenue, Pennsylvania Ave to Union Rd, SW side 679 40,740$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, Utah Ave to Poplar Rd, E side 249 14,940$ LowW Gettysburg Avenue, Manhattan Ave to Goucher Cir, SE side 209 12,540$ LowGoucher Circle, W Gettysburg Ave to W Gettysburg Ave, outside of circle 1225 73,500$ LowPoplar Road, Pennsylvania Ave to Pelham Rd, SW side 664 39,840$ LowPeach Road, Pelham Rd to Pickwick Ln, NW side 707 42,420$ LowW Gettysburg Avenue, Goucher Cir to Goucher Cir, SE side 260 15,600$ LowPickwick Lane, Peach Rd north to end, W/NW side 532 31,920$ LowW Gettysburg Avenue, Goucher Cir to Lafayette Dr, SE side 200 -$ Compliant


Peach Road, Pickwick Ln to Pennsylvania Ave, NW side 165 9,900$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, Peach Rd to Pine Ln, E side 816 48,960$ LowPine Lane, Pennsylvania Ave east to end, S side 249 14,940$ LowGraham Place, W Gettysburg Ave NW to center of cul-de-sac, NE side 466 9,786$ LowGraham Place, W Gettysburg Ave NW to center of cul-de-sac, SW side 468 8,424$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, Pine Ln to Poplar Rd, E side 209 12,540$ LowW Gettysburg Avenue, Graham Pl to Manhattan Ave, NW side 231 -$ CompliantManhattan Avenue, W Gettysburg Ave to Marshall Cir, SW side 263 15,780$ LowPelham Road, Peach Rd to Pearl Rd, SW side 385 23,100$ LowPearl Road, Pelham Rd to Peach Rd, NE side 443 26,580$ LowMarshall Circle, Manhattan Ave to Manhattan Ave, outside of circle 1282 76,920$ LowParma Road, Pennsylvania Ave to Parker Rd, SW side 907 54,420$ LowParker Rd, Pennsylvania Ave to Parma Rd, NE side 641 38,460$ LowManhattan Avenue, Marshall Cir to Marshall Cir, SW side 351 11,583$ LowW Gettysburg Avenue, Manhattan Ave to Northwestern Ave, SE side 1025 61,500$ MediumPanama Road, Pennsylvania Ave southeast to end, SW side 192 11,520$ LowPanama Road, Pallas Rd southwest to end, NW side 327 19,620$ LowPallas Road, Panama Rd to Pennsylvania Ave, W side 583 34,980$ LowS Purdue Avenue, Manhattan Ave to Potomac Cir, W side 327 19,620$ LowPrinceton Avenue, S Purdue Ave to Northwestern Ave, NW side 1328 79,680$ LowNew York Avenue, W Tennessee Ave to Valetta Ln, NE side 230 3,450$ MediumNew York Avenue, Valetta Ln to E Vance Rd, NE side 214 3,210$ MediumNorthwestern Avenue, Nasson Ln to Manhattan Ave, NE side 385 23,100$ LowNorthwestern Avenue, Manhattan Ave to W Gettysburg Ave, E side 1158 48,636$ LowPomona Road, Pennsylvania Ave to Pleasant Rd, SE side 874 52,440$ MediumNorthwestern Avenue, W Gettysburg Ave to Nevada Cir, N side 261 15,660$ MediumPleasant Road, Pomono Rd to Pennsylvania Ave, E side 1105 66,300$ MediumNevada Circle, Northwestern Ave to Northwestern Ave, outside of circle 1462 87,720$ LowPlymouth Circle, Pleasant Rd to Pleasant Rd, inside of circle 608 36,480$ LowPleasant Road, Plymouth Cir to Plymouth Cir, SW side 213 12,780$ MediumPocono Lane, Pennsylvania Ave west to end, N side 246 14,760$ LowNorthwestern Avenue, Nevada Cir to Nevada Cir, N side 296 17,760$ LowNorthwestern Avenue, Nevada Cir to N Purdue Ave, N side 398 23,880$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, Peach Rd E Pawley Ln, NE side 282 16,920$ LowE Pawley Lane, Pennsylvania Ave northeast to end, NW side 315 18,900$ LowNorthwestern Avenue, N Purdue Ave to S Rutgers Ave, N side 352 21,120$ MediumPennsylvania Avenue, E Pawley Ln to E Passmore Ln, NE side 536 17,688$ LowE Passmore Lane, Pennsylvania Ave north to end, W side 240 8,640$ LowRutgers Avenue, Northwestern Ave to Manhattan Ave, E side 1785 64,260$ LowPennsylvania Avenue, E Passmore Ln to E Pasadena Rd, N side 223 5,352$ MediumRutgers Avenue, Manhattan Ave to S Illinois Ave, E side 544 32,640$ MediumHunter Place, Hunter Cir, north to end, E side 425 25,500$ LowHunter Circle, Hunter Pl to Hillside Rd, W side 691 41,460$ LowHillside Road, Hunter Cir to Pennsylvania Ave, NW side 531 31,860$ LowN Purdue Avenue, Manhattan Ave to Principia Ln, SE side 309 -$ CompliantN Purdue Avenue, Principia Ln to Northwestern Ave, W side 1379 16,548$ HighN Purdue Avenue, Northwestern Ave to Parsons Rd, SE side 567 34,020$ LowW Pawley Road, Pennsylvania Ave to W Passmore Rd, NE side 412 24,720$ LowW Passmore Road, W Pawley Rd to Pennsylvania Ave, N/NW side 557 33,420$ LowN Purdue Avenue, Parsons Rd to Manhattan Ave, E side 1118 67,080$ MediumN Tulane Avenue, Pennsylvania Ave to Providence Rd, W side 86 -$ CompliantParsons Road, N Purdue Ave to Piedmont Rd, NE side 257 15,420$ LowProvidence Road, N Tulane Ave to Oak Ridge High School loop west drive, S side 1693 25,395$ MediumPiedmont Road, Parsons Rd to Newberry Cir, N side 351 5,265$ Low


Newberry Circle, Piedmont Rd to Northwestern Ave, W side 379 5,685$ LowNewberry Circle, Piedmont Rd to Parsons Rd, SW side 610 36,600$ LowParsons Road, Newberry Cir to Piedmont Rd, NW/N/NE side 1234 74,040$ MediumProvidence Road, Oak Ridge High School loop west drive to Robertsville Rd, S side 1308 39,240$ MediumNewberry Circle, Parsons Rd to Northwestern Ave, S side 316 18,960$ LowHunter Circle, Hillside Rd to Hillside Rd, inside of circle 1169 70,140$ MediumHillside Road, Hunter Cir to Hunter Cir, N side 398 23,880$ MediumEmory Valley Road, Lafayette Dr to Fordham Rd, SE side 569 3,414$ LowEmory Valley Road, Fordham Rd to Franklin Rd, SE side 1756 15,804$ LowHunter Circle, Hunter Pl to Hillside Rd, W side 568 34,080$ LowHillside Road, Hunter Cir to Highland Ave, N side 1789 107,340$ MediumHighland Avenue, Hillside Rd to Robertsville Rd, E side 1148 68,880$ MediumRobertsville Road, Highland Ave to Providence Rd, N side 766 32,172$ HighEmory Valley Road, Franklin Rd to Fairbanks Rd, S side 1324 79,440$ HighHamilton Circle, Hillsdale Rd to Hillsdale Rd, inside of circle 1294 77,640$ LowEmory Valley Road, Fairbanks Rd to Briarcliff Ave, SE side 1008 3,024$ HighHillside Road, Highland Ave to N Hickory Ln, NW side 1760 105,600$ MediumBriarcliff Avenue, Emory Valley Rd to Donner Dr, NE side 1008 18,144$ LowRobertsville Road, Raleigh Rd east to end, S side 1078 42,042$ MediumDonner Drive, Briarcliff Ave to Emory Valley Rd, W/NW side 1038 12,456$ LowBriarcliff Avenue, Donner Dr west to end, S side 148 8,880$ LowBriarcliff Avenue, Donner Dr to Downing Dr, S side 486 4,374$ HighBriarcliff Avenue, Downing Dr east to end, S side 289 4,335$ LowBriarcliff Avenue, Fairbanks Rd to Laboratory Rd, SW side 1801 10,806$ MediumBriarcliff Avenue, Fairbanks Rd to Laboratory Rd, NE side 1798 10,788$ LowFairbanks Road, Briarcliff Ave to Dayton Rd, W side 2138 128,280$ MediumVermont Avenue, Vista Rd to Pennsylvania Ave, E side 185 6,105$ LowRobertsville Road, Providence Rd to Raleigh Rd, E side 838 50,280$ MediumRaleigh Road, Robertsville Rd to Ivanhoe Rd, S side 1172 70,320$ MediumIvanhoe Road, Raleigh Rd to Inca Cir, NW side 212 1,272$ LowVerbena Road, Vermont Ave to Venus Rd, NE side 430 25,800$ MediumVenus Road, Verbena Rd northeast to end, SE side 413 24,780$ MediumVenus Road, Vermont Ave northwest to end, NW/NE side 564 33,840$ MediumVassar Road, Vermont Ave to W Vance Rd, NE side 408 24,480$ LowW Vance Road, Vassar Rd to New York Ave, SE side 535 32,100$ LowNew York Avenue, W Vance Rd to Vermont Ave, SW side 261 -$ CompliantVermont Avenue, New York Ave to Vassar Rd, NW side 534 16,020$ LowValletta Lane, New York Ave southwest to end, NW side 406 -$ LowN Purdue Avenue, Manhattan Ave to Northwestern Ave, SE side 1813 108,780$ MediumN Purdue Avenue, Northwestern Ave to Manhattan Ave, NW side 1829 71,331$ LowE Vance Road, New York Ave to Vermont Ave, NW side 755 24,915$ MediumE Vance Road, Vermont Ave to Tennyson Rd, NW side 178 2,136$ LowE Vance Road, Tennyson Rd to Vermont Ave, SE side 255 15,300$ LowVermont Avenue, E Vance Rd to New York Ave, SE side 1053 63,180$ MediumVermont Avenue, New York Ave to E Vance Rd, NW side 988 59,280$ MediumE Vance Road, Vermont Ave to New York Ave, SE side 747 44,820$ MediumNew York Avenue, E Vance Rd to Vermont Ave, NE side 259 3,885$ LowLendon Boulevard, Lafayette Dr to Liberty Ct, NW side 139 -$ CompliantLiberty Court, Lendon Dr to Drive B, NE side 202 -$ CompliantLiberty Circle, Drive B to Maryville Cir, N side 230 -$ CompliantLiberty Circle, Drive D northerly to Liberty Ct, SW/NW side 531 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, Florida Ave to Georgia Ave, NW side 1954 7,034$ HighLiberty Circle, Drive D to Lendon Blvd, SW/SE/NE side 690 10,350$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Georgia Ave to Central Ave, NW side 624 20,592$ Medium


Bus Terminal Road, Emory Valley Rd to Laboratory Rd, E side 1055 63,300$ HighOak Ridge Turnpike, Central Ave to Tyler Rd, NW side 639 38,340$ MediumTyler Road, Oak Ridge Tpk to Talmeda Rd, NE side 126 3,024$ MediumTalmeda Road, Tyler Rd to Central Ave, SE side 644 7,728$ HighBus Terminal Road, Emory Valley Rd north to end, W side 276 -$ CompliantBriarcliff Avenue, Fairbanks Rd to Emory Valley Rd, NE side 333 19,980$ LowEmory valley Road, Briarcliff Ave to Dana Dr, NE side 1501 4,503$ MediumTyler Road, Talmeda Rd to E Tyrone Rd, NE side 231 7,623$ LowEmory Valley Road, Donner Dr to Emory Ln, SE side 817 -$ CompliantE Tyrone Road, Tyler Rd to Central Ave, SE side 634 20,922$ LowCentral Avenue, E Tyrone Rd to Talmeda Rd, SW side 376 11,280$ LowEmory Valley Road, Emory Ln to Dana Dr, SE side 719 43,140$ HighGeorgia Ave, Oak Ridge Tpk to Tyson Rd, W side 378 6,804$ LowTyson Road, Georgia Ave to Tucker Rd, SE side 1135 68,100$ MediumS Hickory Lane, Hillside Rd to Hickory Pl, SW side 221 13,260$ LowHickory Place, S Hickory Ln south to end, E side 212 11,448$ LowTucker Road, Turner Rd to Florida Ave, NW side 810 38,880$ MediumS Hickory Lane, Hickory Pl east to end, SW side 242 1,452$ LowHillside Road, N Hickory Ln to N Illinois Ave, NW side 281 16,860$ HighN Illinois Avenue, Hillside Rd to Irene St, NE side 658 39,480$ MediumFlorida Avenue, Tucker Rd to Oak Ridge Tpk, SW side 462 16,632$ LowIroquois Road, Ithaca Ln to E Irving Ln, E side 393 7,074$ MediumIroquois Road, E Irving Ln to Robertsville Rd, NE side 1045 6,270$ MediumRobertsville Road, Iroquois Rd to N Illinois Ave, NW side 1664 79,872$ HighLaboratory Road, Briarcliff Ave to Administration Rd, SE side 900 6,480$ LowRobertsville Road, N Illinois Ave west to first school driveway, S side 312 18,720$ HighAdministration Road, northwest of Laboratory Rd at parking, NE side 283 3,396$ LowN Illinois Avenue, Robertsville Rd to Ivanhoe Ln, SW side 657 39,420$ HighIvanhoe Lane, N Illinois Ave southwest to end at school driveway, NW side 264 15,840$ HighW Tyrone Road, Tyler Rd to Tyndale Rd, SE side 662 3,972$ LowTyndale Road, W Tyrone Rd to Oak Ridge Tpk, SW side 291 1,746$ HighN Illinois Avenue, Independence Ln to Robertsville Rd, SW side 1583 28,494$ MediumOak Ridge Turnpike, Tyndale Rd to Tyler Rd, NW side 645 -$ CompliantN Illinois Avenue, Hillside Rd to Robertsville Rd, NE side 536 32,160$ MediumFlorida Avenue, Tucker Rd to. E Tennessee Ave, SW side 174 10,440$ LowN Illinois Avenue, Robertsville Rd to Ivanhoe Rd, NE side 626 37,560$ MediumTurner Road, Tucker Rd to E Tennessee Ave, NE side 196 11,760$ LowN Illinois Avenue, Ivanhoe Rd to Oak Ridge Tpk, NE side 827 49,620$ MediumLaboratory Road, Oak Ridge Tpk to Home Depot driveway, NE side 851 51,060$ MediumLaboratory Road, Home Depot driveway to Briarcliff Ave, E side 597 35,820$ MediumLaboratory Road, Administration Rd to Bus Terminal Rd, S side 558 -$ CompliantAdministration Road, Milan Way southeast to end, SW side 704 42,240$ LowAdministration Road, Milan Way to Oak Ridge Tpk, SW side 364 21,840$ MediumN Illinois Avenue, Ivanhoe Ln to Ingrahm Ln, SW side 430 25,800$ MediumN Illinois Avenue, Ingrahm Ln to Oak Ridge Tpk, SW side 271 4,878$ MediumRobertsville Road, N Illinois Ave east to end, NW side 175 10,500$ LowRobertsville Road, N Illinois Ave to Raleigh Rd, S side 750 45,000$ MediumIvanhoe Road, Inca Cir to Inca Cir, NW side 219 13,140$ MediumIvanhoe Road, Inca Cir to N Illinois Ave, NW side 265 15,900$ MediumJefferson Avenue, S Jefferson Cir to Oak Ridge Tpk, W side 162 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, Jefferson Ave to Adams Rd, NW side 1377 45,441$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, W Vanderbilt Dr to Jefferson Ave, S side 478 -$ CompliantS Rutgers Avenue, Northwestern Ave to Manhattan Ave, SE side 1810 54,300$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Administration Rd to Bus Terminal Rd, SE side 564 33,840$ Medium


W Vanderbilt Drive, Oak Ridge Turnpike to Virginia Rd, N side 963 57,780$ MediumBus Terminal Road, Milan Way to Laboratory Rd, NE side 1310 78,600$ MediumVirginia Road, W Vanderbilt Dr to Villanova Rd, W/NW side 1345 64,560$ MediumLaboratory Road, E Division Rd northeast to end, NW side 648 38,880$ MediumVillanova Road, Oak Ridge Tpk to Valparaiso Rd, E side 352 21,120$ LowE Division Road, Laboratory Rd to Oak Ridge Tpk, NE side 1425 51,300$ MediumVillanova Road, Valparaiso Rd to E Vanderbilt Dr, NE side 1058 41,262$ MediumW Vanderbilt Drive, Villanova Rd to Virginia Rd, N side 1761 89,811$ MediumValparaiso Road, Villanova Rd northeast to end, NW/NE side 934 56,040$ LowValparaiso Road, E Vanderbilt Dr north to end, S side 664 27,888$ MediumE Vanderbilt Drive, Valparaiso Rd southwest to end, NW side 515 30,900$ LowE Vanderbilt Drive, Valparaiso Rd to S Illinois Ave, N/NW side 1246 74,760$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Adams Rd to Van Hicks Rd, NW side 567 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, Van Hicks Rd to N Illinois Ave, NW side 1596 14,364$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, W Vanderbilt Dr to Villanova Rd, SE side 1786 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, Villanova Rd to S Illinois Ave, SE side 1459 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, Bus Terminal Rd to E Division Rd, SE side 973 23,352$ MediumOak Ridge Turnpike, Tennyson Rd to Tennenson Rd, NW side 535 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, Tennenson Rd to Tyndale Rd, NW side 301 -$ CompliantTulsa Road, S Illinois Ave to Tusculum Dr, SW side 1057 63,420$ MediumTusculum Drive, Tulsa Rd southwest to end, NW side 464 5,568$ LowLaboratory Road, Bus Terminal Rd to Lafayette Dr, SE side 2057 43,197$ MediumTulsa Road, Tusculum Dr to Utica Cir, SW side 690 -$ CompliantTulsa Road, Utica Cir to Tuskegee Dr, SW side 527 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, Tennyson Rd to New York Ave, NW side 1028 61,680$ MediumLafayette Drive, Emory Valley Rd to Laboratory Rd, NE side 658 39,480$ MediumLafayette Drive, W Gettysburg Ave to Lendon Blvd, SW side 417 25,020$ MediumLafayette Drive, Lendon Blvd to Marquette Rd, SW side 916 54,960$ MediumRobertsville Road, Raleigh Rd to Oak Ridge Tpk, SE side 427 17,934$ MediumMarquette Road, N Purdue Ave to Lafayette Dr, NW side 286 8,580$ LowLafayette Drive, Marquette Rd to Oak Ridge Tpk, SW side 672 10,080$ LowOak Ridge Turnpike, Lafayette Dr to S Rutgers Ave, SE side 1225 73,500$ MediumRobertsville Road, Kroger driveway to Oak Ridge Tpk, W side 177 2,655$ MediumOak Ridge Turnpike, Robertsville Rd to N Illinois Ave, NW side 1280 7,680$ MediumS Illinois Avenue, Oak Ridge Tpk to Orau Way, NE side 1624 9,744$ MediumS Illinois Avenue, Tulsa Rd to E Vanderbilt Dr, SE side 243 -$ CompliantS Illinois Avenue, E Vanderbilt Dr to Oak Ridge Turnpike, SW side 1502 31,542$ MediumS Illinois Avenue, Tulsa Rd to Tuskegee Dr, S side 1693 40,632$ MediumS Tulane Avenue, Tulane Pl. to S Illinois Ave, NW side 110 -$ CompliantS Illinois Avenue, S Tulane Ave to Badger Ave, N side 520 -$ CompliantS Illinois Avenue, Badger Ave to Orau Way, NE side 1206 72,360$ MediumS Rutgers Avenue, Manhattan Ave to S Illinois Ave, W side 491 7,365$ LowS Illinois Avenue, S Rutgers Ave to E Tulsa Rd, NE side 732 -$ CompliantS Illinois Avenue, E Tulsa Rd to S Tulane Ave, NE side 929 -$ CompliantS Tulane Avenue, Tulane Pl to Oak Ridge Tpk, W side 2360 21,240$ MediumS Tulane Avenue, Wilson St to S Illinois Ave, E side 2120 6,360$ MediumOak Ridge Turnpike, N Rutgers Ave to New York Ave, NW side 1342 48,312$ MediumOak Ridge Turnpike, N Rutgers Ave to Viking Rd, NW side 1960 -$ CompliantTuskegee Drive, Tulsa Rd to S Illinois Ave, W side 1405 59,010$ MediumNew York Avenue, Oak Ridge Tpk to Vermont Ave, W side 291 17,460$ LowVermont Avenue, New York Ave to N Rutgers Ave, SE side 1342 80,520$ MediumN Rutgers Avenue, Vermont Ave to Oak Ridge Tpk, NE side 252 15,120$ MediumN Rutgers Avenue, Oak Ridge Tpk to Vermont Ave, SW side 262 15,720$ MediumVermont Avenue, N Rutgers Ave to Vienna Rd, S/SE side 1184 63,936$ Medium


Victoria Road, Vermont Ave to Vernon Rd, SE side 740 44,400$ LowVernon Road, Victoria Rd to Vermont Ave, SW side 298 17,880$ LowS Tulane Avenue at S Illinois Avenue, traffic islands on north side 166 -$ CompliantS Rutgers Avenue, Oak Ridge Turnpike southeast to end, SW side 280 8,400$ LowTuskegee Drive at S Illinois Avenue, traffic islands on south side 65 -$ CompliantRutgers Avenue, Oak Ridge Tpk to Manhattan Ave, NE side 541 6,492$ LowTuskegee Drive, S Illinois Ave to E Tulsa Rd, E side 1396 58,632$ MediumE Tulsa Road at Tuskegee Drive, northeast traffic island 135 8,100$ HighS Illinois Avenue, S Rutgers Ave to E Tulsa Rd, SW side 705 42,300$ MediumS Illinois Avenue, E Tulsa Rd to Tuskegee Dr, S side 976 52,704$ MediumE Tulsa Avenue, Tuskegee Dr to S Illinois Ave, NW side 1695 71,190$ MediumOrau Way, S Illinois Ave to Badger Ave, NE side 900 48,600$ MediumMaryville Circle, Marquette Rd to Marquette Rd, inside of circle 1065 63,900$ LowMarquette Road, Manhattan Ave to N Purdue Ave, W side 908 54,480$ MediumN Purdue Avenue, Marquette Rd to Manhattan Ave, SE side 1178 70,680$ MediumN Purdue Avenue, Manhattan Ave north to end, W side 703 10,545$ LowManhattan Avenue, Marshall Cir to N Purdue Ave, S side 246 7,380$ LowManhattan Avenue, N Purdue Ave to S Rutgers Ave, S side 329 1,579$ LowRice Road, S Rutgers Ave to Rider Rd, SE side 385 1,155$ LowRider Road, at parking between Rice Rd and S Rutgers Ave, SW side 88 -$ CompliantRutgers Avenue, Rider Rd to Rockford Rd, NW side 549 32,940$ LowRice Road, Wallace Rd southwest to end, SE side 102 6,120$ LowVista Road, Vermont Ave to Viola Rd, N/NE side 589 35,340$ LowViola Road, Vista Rd to Vermont Ave, SE side 372 22,320$ LowVermont Avenue, Victoria Rd to Viola Rd, NE side 217 13,020$ LowVermont Avenue, Viola Rd to Vista Rd, E side 563 33,780$ MediumViking Road, Vienna Rd to Vermont Ave, W side 479 28,740$ MediumVienna Road, Vermont Ave to Viking Rd, S side 698 12,564$ MediumVermont Avenue, Viking Rd to Vienna Rd, S side 201 12,060$ MediumN Tulane Avenue, Providence Rd to Vienna Rd, E side 1445 86,700$ MediumVienna Road, N Tulane Ave to Viking Rd, S side 699 41,940$ MediumViking Road, Vienna Rd to Oak Ridge Tpk, W side 385 23,100$ MediumOak Ridge Turnpike, Wallace Rd to Viking Rd, N side 1102 66,120$ MediumOak Ridge Turnpike, Viking Rd to N Tulane Ave, N side 595 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, N Tulane Ave to Robertsville Rd, NW side 2374 49,854$ HighOrau Way, Oak Ridge Turnpike to Badger Ave, E side 529 31,740$ HighE Main Street, Wilson St to Oak Ridge Turnpike, W side 279 -$ CompliantOak Ridge Turnpike, S Tulane Ave west to end at Oak Ridge Civic Center, S side 1212 47,268$ HighS Tulane Avenue, Wilson St to Oak Ridge Turnpike, E side 389 2,567$ LowWilson Street, S Tulane Ave Main St W, S side 420 -$ CompliantWilson Street, Main St W to E Main St, S side 704 -$ CompliantWilson Street, E Main St to S Rutgers Ave, S side 578 -$ CompliantMain Street W, Wilson St to Oak Ridge Tpk, E side 426 -$ CompliantN Tulane Avenue, Vienna Rd to Oak Ridge Tpk, E side 505 -$ Compliant

625850 -$ Summary by Priority

Priority Total Length (ft) Total Miles Estimated CostLow 322381 61.06 $14,059,171Medium 204537 38.74 $10,532,190High 47247 8.95 $2,164,308Compliant 51685 9.79 $0

Totals 625850 118.53 26,755,669$ Feet Miles

Total Amount of Sidewalk 625850 118.53Approximate Non-Compliant 445928 84.46 71.3%


Table B-2. City of Oak Ridge Curb Ramp Compliance, Priority, and Probable Corrective Cost.Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostBroadberry Ave at NW end boat launch parking lot SE CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Pineberry West Rd (west intersection) SE CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Pineberry West Rd (west intersection) SW CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Pineberry West Rd (east intersection) SE CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Pineberry West Rd (east intersection) SW CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Pineberry East Rd (east intersection) NW CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Pineberry East Rd (east intersection) NE CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Parkberry St E CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Parkberry St N CORNER Low $1,800Parkberry St/Pineberry East Rd W CORNER Low $1,800Parkberry St/Pineberry East Rd N CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Sweetberry St SE CORNER Low $500Broadberry Ave/Sweetberry St NE CORNER Low $3,500Sweetberry St/Littonberry St S CORNER Low $1,800Sweetberry St/Littonberry St W CORNER Medium $3,500Pineberry East Rd/Sweetberry St NE CORNER Low $1,800Pineberry East Rd/Sweetberry St NW CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Mistletoeberry Rd (north intersection) NW CORNER Low $500Broadberry Ave/Mistletoeberry Rd (north intersection) SW CORNER Low $500Broadberry Ave/Mistletoeberry Rd (south intersection) S CORNER Low $500Broadberry Ave/Mistletoeberry Rd (south intersection) W CORNER Medium $3,500Broadberry Ave/Cedarberry St E CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Cedarberry St N CORNER Low $500Cedarberry St/Littonberry St - southeast ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800Cedarberry St/Littonberry St - northwest ramp SW CORNER Low $500Broadberry Ave/Northberry St W SE CORNER Low $500Broadberry Ave/Northberry St W NE CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Northberry St W SW CORNER Low $500Broadberry Ave/Northberry St W NW CORNER Medium $3,500Northberry St W cul-de-sac N SIDE Low $3,500Northberry St W cul-de-sac S SIDE Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Galeberry Ave W CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Galeberry Ave S CORNER Low $500Galeberry Ave/Gooseberry Cir island NE CORNER Low $500Galeberry Ave/Gooseberry Cir N CORNER Low $500Galeberry Ave/Gooseberry Cir SW CORNER Low $1,800Galeberry Ave/Gooseberry Cir island SW CORNER Low $1,800Galeberry Ave - mid-block northwest of Fortenberry St S SIDE Medium $3,500Galeberry Ave - mid-block northwest of Fortenberry St N SIDE Low $1,800East Dr/Everest Cir (east intersection) NE CORNER Low $1,800East Dr/Everest Cir (east intersection) - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $5,500East Dr/Everest Cir (west intersection) W CORNER Low $1,800East Dr/Everest Cir (west intersection) - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $5,500East Dr/Clarion Rd S CORNER Low $3,500East Dr/Clarion Rd E CORNER Low $500Broadberry Ave southeast of Galeberry Ave N SIDE Low $1,200Broadberry Ave southeast of Galeberry Ave E SIDE Low $3,500Clarion Rd/California Ave E CORNER Low $1,800Clarion Rd/California Ave - provide missing ramp S SIDE Medium $3,500

City of Oak Ridge Curb Ramps Page 1 of 32

Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostBroadberry Ave southeast of Galeberry Ave E SIDE Low $1,200Broadberry Ave southeast of Galeberry Ave N SIDE Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Fortenberry St SE CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Fortenberry St NE CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/Fortenberry St SW CORNER Medium $3,500Broadberry Ave/Fortenberry St NW CORNER Low $1,800East Dr/California Ave NE CORNER Low $3,500East Dr/California Ave SE CORNER Low $3,500Broadberry Ave/Forestberry St NW CORNER Low $500Broadberry Ave/Forestberry St SE CORNER Low $500Forestberry St/Galeberry Ave N CORNER Low $500Forestberry St/Galeberry Ave E CORNER Low $500Outer Dr/Oak Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/Oak Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Outer Dr/Ogden Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Outer Dr/Ogden Ln - provide missing ramp to east NW CORNER Medium $3,500Outer Dr/Ogden Ln - south ramp NW CORNER Medium $5,500Outer Dr/Ogden Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Ogden Ln/Ogden Cir - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Ogden Ln/Ogden Cir - provide missing ramp NE SIDE Medium $3,500Ogden Cir/Oglethorpe Ln SE CORNER Low $1,800Ogden Cir/Oglethorpe Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $3,500Oglethorpe Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $3,500Galeberry Ave, alley between Fortenberry and Forestberry E CORNER Compliant $0Galeberry Ave, alley between Fortenberry and Forestberry N CORNER Compliant $0Galeberry Ave/Fortenberry St E CORNER Low $500Galeberry Ave/Fortenberry St N CORNER Low $500East Dr/Evans Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800East Dr/Evans Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $3,500Evans Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $3,500Broadberry Ave/Fallberry St SW CORNER Low $500Broadberry Ave/Fallberry St SE CORNER Low $500Fallberry St/Century Dr - provide missing ramp N CORNER Low $3,500Fallberry St/Century Dr - provide missing ramp E CORNER Low $3,500Galeberry Ave/Fallberry St NE CORNER Low $500Galeberry Ave/Fallberry St NW CORNER Low $500Broadberry Ave/W Elderberry St N CORNER Low $1,800Broadberry Ave/W Elderberry St SE CORNER Low $500East Dr/Euclid Cir E CORNER Medium $3,500East Dr/Euclid Cir S CORNER Low $3,500Euclid Cir/Euclid Cir - provide missing ramp N CORNER Low $3,500Euclid Cir/Euclid Cir - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $3,500W Elderberry St/Hitchberry Rd S CORNER Low $5,500W Elderberry St/Hitchberry Rd E CORNER Low $1,200East Dr/Essex Ln W CORNER Low $1,800East Dr/Essex Ln N CORNER Low $1,800Eastberry Rd/Juniperberry Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Eastberry Rd/Juniperberry Rd NW CORNER Low $1,800Essex Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $3,500


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostJuniperberry Rd at south cul-de-sac NE SIDE Low $1,800Juniperberry Rd at south cul-de-sac NW SIDE Low $3,500Juniperberry Rd at north cul-de-sac SE SIDE Low $1,800Juniperberry Rd at north cul-de-sac SW SIDE Low $1,800Eastberry Rd/Hitchberry Rd NW CORNER Low $3,500Eastberry Rd/Hitchberry Rd SW CORNER Low $3,500W Elderberry St/Eastberry Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800W Elderberry St/Eastberry Rd SW CORNER Low $3,500W Elderberry St/Eastberry Rd NW CORNER Low $3,500Carlisle Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp NW SIDE Low $3,500California Ave/Cedar Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500California Ave/Cedar Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500California Ave/Cedar Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Cedar Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $3,500California Ave/Carlisle Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800California Ave/Carlisle Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500W Elderberry St/Old Union Rd N CORNER Low $1,800W Elderberry St/Old Union Rd E CORNER Low $3,500California Ave/W Arrowood Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500California Ave/W Arrowood Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500California Ave/Cahill Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800Cahill Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800E Elderberry St/Fountberry St - west ramp NE CORNER Low $500E Elderberry St/Fountberry St - south ramp NE CORNER Low $500Fountberry St/Hackberry St - south ramp NW CORNER Low $500Fountberry St/Hackberry St - east ramp NW CORNER Low $500Fountberry St/Hackberry St - west ramp NE CORNER Low $500Hackberry St/Fountberry St - south ramp NE CORNER Low $500Fountberry St/Checkerberry Rd SW CORNER Low $500Fountberry St/Checkerberry Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Fountberry St/Hardinberry St - south ramp NW CORNER Low $500Fountberry St/Hardinberry St - east ramp NW CORNER Low $500Fountberry St/Hardinberry St - west ramp NE CORNER Low $500Fountberry St/Hardinberry St - south ramp NE CORNER Low $500Hatleyberry St/Fountberry St - southwest ramp N CORNER Low $500Hatleyberry St/Fountberry St - southeast ramp N CORNER Low $500Hatleyberry St/Fountberry St - northwest ramp E CORNER Low $500Hatleyberry St/Fountberry St - southwest ramp E CORNER Low $500Fountberry St/Bunchberry Rd NE CORNER Low $500Fountberry St/Bunchberry Rd SE CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Bunchberry Rd S CORNER Low $3,500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Bunchberry Rd - southeast ramp W CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Bunchberry Rd - northeast ramp W CORNER Low $500W Arrowwood Rd/Alder Ln W CORNER Medium $3,500W Arrowwood Rd/Alder Ln - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $3,500Alder Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $3,500Arkansas Ave/Aspen Ln NW CORNER Low $3,500Arkansas Ave/Aspen Ln SW CORNER Low $3,500Aspen Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostRarity Ridge Pkwy/Hatleyberry St - northwest ramp S CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hatleyberry St - southwest ramp S CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hatleyberry St - southeast ramp W CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hatleyberry St - southeast ramp W CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hatleyberry St -southeast ramp N CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hatleyberry St - southwest ramp N CORNER Low $1,800Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hatleyberry St - northwest ramp E CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hatleyberry St - southwest ramp E CORNER Low $1,800Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hardinberry St - southwest ramp E CORNER Low $1,800Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hardinberry St - northwest ramp E CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hardinberry St - northeast ramp S CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hardinberry St - northwest ramp S CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hardinberry St - southwest ramp N CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hardinberry St - southeast ramp N CORNER Low $1,800Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hardinberry St - northeast ramp W CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hardinberry St - southeast ramp W CORNER Low $1,800Arkansas Ave/E Arrowwood Rd SE CORNER Low $3,500Arkansas Ave/W Arrowwood Rd SW CORNER Medium $3,500Arkansas Ave/W Arrowwood Rd NW CORNER Low $3,500E Elderberry St/Rarity Ridge Pkwy - northwest ramp S CORNER Low $1,800E Elderberry St/Rarity Ridge Pkwy - southwest ramp S CORNER Low $500E Elderberry St/Rarity Ridge Pkwy - northwest ramp E CORNER Low $1,800E Elderberry St/Rarity Ridge Pkwy - northeast ramp S CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hackberry St - southwest ramp N CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hackberry St - southeast ramp N CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hackberry St - northeast ramp W CORNER Low $1,800Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hackberry St - southeast ramp W CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hackberry St - northeast ramp S CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hackberry St - northwest ramp S CORNER Low $1,800Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hackberry St - northwest ramp E CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Hackberry St - southwest ramp E CORNER Low $500Hackberry St/Hatleyberry St - north ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800Hackberry St/Hatleyberry St - east ramp SW CORNER Low $500Hackberry St/Hatleyberry St - west ramp SE CORNER Low $500Hackberry St/Hatleyberry St - north ramp SE CORNER Low $500E Elderberry St/Hatleyberry St - north ramp SE CORNER Low $500E Elderberry St/Hatleyberry St - west ramp SE CORNER Low $500E Elderberry St/Hatleyberry St - south ramp NE CORNER Low $1,800E Elderberry St/Hatleyberry St - west ramp NE CORNER Low $500Arkansas Ave/S Alabama Rd NW CORNER Medium $3,500Arkansas Ave/S Alabama Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Arkansas Ave/Anna Rd NW CORNER Medium $3,500S Alabama Rd/N Alabama Rd SW CORNER Low $5,500N Alabama Rd/Cedar Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500N Alabama Rd/Cedar Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Hatleyberry St/Hiddenberry Rd NE CORNER Low $500Hatleyberry St/Hiddenberry Rd NW CORNER Low $500Hatleyberry St/Hardinberry St - north ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800Hatleyberry St/Hardinberry St - north ramp SE CORNER Low $1,800Hatleyberry St/Hardinberry St - west ramp SE CORNER Low $1,800Hatleyberry St/Hardinberry St - east ramp SW CORNER Low $500


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostArkansas Ave/N Alabama Rd NW CORNER Low $3,500Arkansas Ave/N Alabama Rd - north ramp - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Arkansas Ave/N Alabama Rd - east ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800Arkansas Ave/Atlanta Rd NE CORNER Low $3,500Arkansas Ave/Atlanta Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Albany Rd/Alhambra Rd (south intersection) NW CORNER Low $1,800Albany Rd/Alhambra Rd (south intersection) - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Arkansas Ave/Albany Rd NW CORNER Low $3,500Arkansas Ave/Albany Rd SW CORNER Low $3,500W Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Broadberry Rd - southeast ramp W CORNER Low $500W Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Broadberry Rd - northeast ramp W CORNER Low $500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Brookberry Rd W CORNER Low $3,500Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Chaseberry Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Chaseberry Rd W CORNER Low $1,800Rarity Ridge Pkwy/Chaseberry Rd S CORNER Low $3,500Chaseberry Rd cul-de-sac NW SIDE Low $1,800Chaseberry Rd cul-de-sac SE SIDE Low $1,200California Ave/E Tennessee Ave E CORNER Medium $3,500California Ave/E Tennessee Ave S CORNER Medium $3,500Tabor Rd/East Tennessee Ave N CORNER Low $1,800Tabor Rd/East Tennessee Ave W CORNER Low $1,800Americus Ave at top of parking lot stairs W SIDE Low $1,200Americus Ave/Aluminum St N NW CORNER Low $1,200Americus Ave/Aluminum St S SW CORNER Low $1,800Americus Ave/Aluminum St S SE CORNER Low $1,800Delaware Ave/W Dalton Rd SE CORNER Low $3,500Delaware Ave/W Dalton Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Delaware Ave/E Dalton Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Heritage Center Blvd/Chromium St NE CORNER Low $1,200Heritage Center Blvd/Chromium St SE CORNER Low $500Heritage Center Blvd/Aluminum St NE CORNER Low $500Heritage Center Blvd/Aluminum St NE CORNER Low $1,200Delaware Ave/W Damascus Rd W CORNER Low $3,500Delaware Ave/E Damascus Rd - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $3,500Delaware Ave/W Damascus Rd S CORNER Low $3,500Dallas Ln cul-de-sac W SIDE Low $3,500Delaware Ave/Dallas Ln N CORNER Low $1,800Delaware Ave/Dallas Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $3,500Dewey Rd/Delmar Cir SW CORNER Low $3,500Dewey Rd/Delmar Cir - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Low $3,500Delaware Ave/Darwin Rd SE CORNER Low $3,500Delaware Ave/Darwin Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Delaware Ave/Darwin Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Disston Rd/Delaware Ave SE CORNER Low $1,800Disston Rd/Delaware Ave - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $3,500Delaware Ave/Dewey Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Delaware Ave/Dewey Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Delaware Ave/Devon Ln NW CORNER Low $3,500Delaware Ave/Devon Ln SW CORNER Low $3,500Devon Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $3,500


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostDelaware Ave/Decatur Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Delaware Ave/Decatur Rd NW CORNER Low $1,800Imperium Dr/Renovare Blvd E CORNER Low $1,800Imperium Dr/Renovare Blvd S CORNER Low $500Novitas Pl/Renovare Blvd E CORNER Low $500Novitas Pl/Renovare Blvd S CORNER Low $500Novus Dr/Renovare Blvd E CORNER Low $1,800Novus Dr/Renovare Blvd S CORNER Low $500Novitas Pl/Novus Dr N CORNER Low $500Novitas Pl/Novus Dr E CORNER Low $500Novus Dr/Palladium Way SE CORNER Low $1,800Novus Dr/Palladium Way NE CORNER Low $500Palladium Way at Carbon Fiber driveway NE CORNER Compliant $0Palladium Way at Carbon Fiber driveway SE CORNER Compliant $0Arkansas Ave/Alger Rd NW CORNER Low $1,800Arkansas Ave/Alger Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Arkansas Ave/Arizona Rd (west intersection) SE CORNER Low $1,800Arkansas Ave/Arizona Rd (east intersection) - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Arkansas Ave/Arizona Rd (east intersection) SW CORNER Low $3,500Arkansas Ave/Athens Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Arkansas Ave/Athens Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Alger Rd/Athens Rd SE CORNER Compliant $0Alger Rd/Athens Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800Alger Rd/Albany Rd SE CORNER Compliant $0Alger Rd/Albany Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800East Dr/Audobon Rd SE CORNER Low $3,500East Dr/Audobon Rd SW CORNER Low $500Atlanta Rd/Athens Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Atlanta Rd/Athens Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500East Dr/Athens Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500East Dr/Eastburn Ln SE CORNER Medium $3,500East Dr/Eastburn Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800Edgemoor Rd/Waterview Dr N CORNER Compliant $0Edgemoor Rd/Waterview Dr W CORNER Compliant $0Center Park Ln/Park Meade Dr NE CORNER Low $1,800Park Meade Dr/Park Meade Pl SE CORNER Low $1,800Montclair Rd/Windham Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Montclair Rd/Windham Rd N CORNER Low $1,800Montclair Rd/Middlebury Rd S CORNER Low $1,800Atlanta Rd/Anna Rd SE CORNER Compliant $0Atlanta Rd/Anna Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Montclair Rd/Monticello Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Rd/Wellington Cir (southwest intersection) N CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Rd/Wellington Cir (southwest intersection) - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500W Outer Rd/Wayside Rd E CORNER Low $1,800W Outer/Wayside Rd S CORNER Low $1,200W Outer Dr/Wayne Rd S CORNER Low $3,500W Outer Dr/Wayne Rd E CORNER Low $3,500W Outer Dr/Jefferson Ave SW CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Jefferson Ave SE CORNER Low $500W Outer Rd/Wellington Cir (northeast intersection) NW CORNER Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostJefferson Ave/Judd Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Jefferson Ave/Judd Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Jefferson Ave/Judd Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Jefferson Ave/Wayne Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Jefferson Ave/Wayne Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Jonathan Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800Jefferson Ave/Jonathan Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Jefferson Ave/Jonathan Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Jefferson Ave/Livingston Rd W CORNER Medium $3,500Jefferson Ave/Livingston Rd S CORNER Medium $1,800Louisiana Ave/Lehigh Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Louisiana Ave/Lehigh Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Louisiana Ave/Lewis Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Louisiana Ave/Lewis Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500LaSalle Rd/Louisiana Ave - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500LaSalle Rd/Louisiana Ave - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500LaSalle Rd/Locust Ln SW CORNER Medium $3,500LaSalle Rd/Locust Ln SE CORNER Medium $3,500Louisiana Ave/Lawrence Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800Louisiana Ave/Lawrence Ln SE CORNER Low $1,800Edge Hill Ln cul-de-sac SE SIDE Low $1,800Edge Hill Ln cul-de-sac NE SIDE Low $1,800East Dr/Edge Hill Ln NW CORNER Medium $3,500East Dr/Edge Hill Ln SW CORNER Low $1,800East Drive/Edison Ln SE CORNER Low $3,500East Drive/Edison Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500East Dr/Alger Rd W CORNER Low $3,500East Dr/Alger Rd N CORNER Low $1,800Eaton Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $3,500East Dr/Eaton Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Low $3,500East Dr/Eaton Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Alger Rd/Ashland Ln N CORNER Low $3,500Alger Rd/Ashland Ln W CORNER Low $1,800Ashland Ln cul-de-sac S SIDE Low $3,500Alger Rd/Audobon Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Alger Rd/Audobon Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Audubon Rd at Glenwood Elementary north driveway W SIDE Medium $3,500Audubon Rd at Glenwood Elementary north driveway E SIDE Low $1,800Audubon Rd at Glenwood Elementary middle driveway S SIDE Low $1,800Audubon Rd at Glenwood Elementary middle driveway N SIDE Low $1,800Audubon Rd at Glenwood Elementary south driveway S SIDE Compliant $0Audubon Rd at Glenwood Elementary south driveway N SIDE Low $1,800Athens Rd/E Arrowwood Rd - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $3,500Athens Rd/E Arrowwood Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500LaSalle Rd/Revere Cir NW CORNER Low $1,800LaSalle Rd/Revere Cir SW CORNER Low $1,800Livingston Rd/LaSalle Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Robertsville Rd/LaSalle Rd W CORNER Medium $3,500Robertsville Rd/LaSalle Rd - provide missing ramp S SIDE Medium $3,500Robertsville Rd/Jefferson Ct - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Robertsville Rd/Jefferson Ct - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostRobertsville Rd/Jefferson Ave NW CORNER Medium $1,800Robertsville Rd/Jefferson Ave NE CORNER High $5,500Robertsville Rd/Jefferson Terminal Rd SW CORNER High $3,500Jefferson Ave/Johnson Rd NE CORNER Medium $3,500Jefferson Ave/Johnson Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500East Dr/Emerson Cir SE CORNER Low $3,500East Dr/Emerson Cir NE CORNER Compliant $0Scenic Dr/Endicott Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800Scenic Dr/Endicott Ln NE CORNER Low $3Amherst Ln/Andover Cir SE CORNER Low $3,500Amherst Ln/Andover Cir NE CORNER Low $3,500Alger Rd/Amherst Ln W CORNER Low $3,500Alger Rd/Amherst Ln S CORNER Low $3,500Louisiana Ave/Robertsville Rd NW CORNER Medium $3,500Louisiana Ave/Robertsville Rd NE CORNER Low $3,500Louisiana Ave/Robertsville Rd SW CORNER Low $3,500Robertsville Rd/Regent Cir SW CORNER Low $1,800Robertsville Rd/Regent Cir SE CORNER Low $3,500Robertsville Rd/Lancaster Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Robertsville Rd/Lancaster Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Louisiana Ave/Lawton Rd NW CORNER Low $3,500Louisiana Ave/Lawton Rd NE CORNER Low $3,500Lancaster Rd/Lawton Rd NW CORNER Low $1,800Lancaster Rd/Lawton Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Low $3,500Lancaster Rd/Louisiana Ave - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $1,800Lancaster Rd/Louisiana Ave - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500N Jefferson Cir/Joel Ln SE CORNER Low $3,500N Jefferson Cir/Joel Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500N Jefferson Cir/S Lansing Rd - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $3,500N Jefferson Cir/S Lansing Rd - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500S Lansing Rd/Latimer Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500S Lansing Rd/Latimer Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500S Lansing Rd/Lancaster Rd - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500S Lansing Rd/Lancaster Rd - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $1,800N Jefferson Cir/Jefferson Ct NW CORNER Low $1,800N Jefferson Cir/Jefferson Ct NE CORNER Low $3,500Robertsville Rd at Robertsville MS west loop drive - north ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,200Robertsville Rd at Robertsville MS west loop drive - east ramp SW CORNER Low $500Robertsville Rd at Robertsville MS west loop drive SE CORNER Medium $3,500Robertsville Rd at Robertsville MS west loop drive NW CORNER Low $500Robertsville Rd at Robertsville MS east loop drive SE CORNER Medium $1,800Robertsville Rd at Robertsville MS east loop drive SW CORNER Medium $3,500W Outer Dr/Warrior Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Warrior Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Warrior Ln/ Warrior Cir S CORNER Medium $3,500Warrior Ln/Warrior Cir W CORNER Low $1,800Robertsville Rd/N Seneca Rd - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $1,800Robertsville Rd/N Seneca Rd - provide missing ramp W CORNER Medium $1,800Robertsville Rd/Mississippi Ave NE CORNER Low $1,800Robertsville Rd/Mississippi Ave NW CORNER Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostTacoma Rd/California Ave W CORNER Low $500Tacoma Rd/California Ave S CORNER Low $1,800Bermuda Rd/Briar Rd - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $1,800Bermuda Rd/Briar Rd - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $1,800Robertsville Rd/E Melbourne Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800Robertsville Rd/Bermuda Rd SE CORNER High $3,500Robertsville Rd/Bermuda Rd NE CORNER Medium $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/California Ave - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Chatham Ln/California Ave SW CORNER Low $1,800Chatham Ln/California Ave SE CORNER Low $1,800Chatham Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800East Dr/California Ave SE CORNER Low $1,800East Dr/California Ave NE CORNER Low $1,800Latimer Rd/N Jefferson Cir - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Low $1,800Latimer Rd/N Jefferson Cir - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Low $3,500Delaware Ave/Dixie Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Delaware Ave/Dixie Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $1,800Dixie Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800Jefferson Ave/N Jefferson Cir - east ramp NW CORNER Low $1,800Jefferson Ave/N Jefferson Cir - south ramp NW CORNER Low $1,800Jefferson Ave/N Jefferson Cir SE CORNER Low $1,800Jefferson Ave/N Jefferson Cir SW CORNER Low $1,200Jefferson Ave/Jefferson Terminal Rd NE CORNER Low $3,500Jefferson Ave/Robertsville Rd (west intersection) SW CORNER Low $1,800Jefferson Ave/Robertsville Rd (west intersection) NW CORNER Low $3,500Jefferson Terminal Rd/Robertsville Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Jefferson Ave/Robertsville Rd (east intersection) - south ramp NW CORNER Low $3,500Jefferson Ave/Robertsville Rd (east intersection) - east ramp NW CORNER Low $1,800Jefferson Ave/Robertsville Rd NE CORNER Medium $3,500Johnson Rd/Jarrett Ln SE CORNER Low $1,800Johnson Rd/Jarrett Ln NE CORNER Low $3,500Jarrrett Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Johnson Rd SE CORNER Medium $3,500W Outer Dr/Johnson Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Johnson Rd/Jersey Ln S CORNER Low $1,800Johnson Rd/Jersey Ln - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500Jersey Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $1,800Johnson Rd/Jellico Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800Johnson Rd/Jellico Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $1,800Jellico Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp NE SIDE Low $1,800Johnson Rd/Jay Ln SW CORNER Low $1,800Johnson Rd/Jay Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Jay Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800Johnson Rd/Jasper Ln SW CORNER Low $1,800Johnson Rd/Jasper Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Jasper Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/N Illinois Ave S CORNER Medium $3,500W Outer Dr/N Illinois Ave E CORNER Medium $3,500W Outer Dr/Warwick Ln S CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Warwick Ln E CORNER Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostN Illinois Ave/Ivy Ln NW CORNER Medium $3,500N Illinois Ave/Ivy Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Waltham Ln SE CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Waltham Ln SW CORNER Low $1,800Waltham Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800Waltham Pl cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $1,800Waltham Ln/Waltham Pl - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Low $3,500Waltham Ln/Waltham Pl - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500W Outer Dr/Walsh Ln SW CORNER Low $1,200W Outer Dr/Walsh Ln SE CORNER Low $1,800Walsh Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Walnut Ln SW CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Walnut Ln SE CORNER Low $3,500Walnut Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $1,800W Outer Dr/ Walpole Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/ Walpole Ln - provide new ramp NW CORNER Low $3,500Walpole Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800Ogontz Ln/Olean Rd (west intersection) NE CORNER Low $1,800Ogontz Ln/Olean Rd (west intersection) NW CORNER Low $3,500Ogontz Ln/Olean Rd (east intersection) NW CORNER Low $1,800Ogontz Ln/Olean Rd (east intersection) NE CORNER Low $1,800Olmstead Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $1,800Ogontz Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800Ogontz Ln/Olmstead Ln SE CORNER Low $3,500Outer Dr/Ogontz Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/Ogontz Ln SE CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/Delaware Ave - provide missing ramp W CORNER Medium $3,500Outer Dr/Delaware Ave - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500Outer Dr/Florida Ave - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500Outer Dr/Florida Ave - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $3,500Georgia Ave/Gorgas Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Low $3,500Georgia Ave/Gorgas Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Low $3,500Gorgas Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800Outer Dr/Georgia Ave SE CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/Georgia Ave SW CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/Olney Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Outer Dr/Olney Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Olney Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800Oneida Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800Outer Dr/Oneida Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/Oneida Ln SE CORNER Low $3,500Outer Dr/Ontario Ln SE CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/Ontario Ln SW CORNER Low $1,800Ontario Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800W Outer Dr/W Wadsworth Cir S CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/W Wadsworth Cir E CORNER Low $1,800W Wadsworth Cir/Wadsworth Pl - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500W Wadsworth Cir/Wadsworth Pl - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $3,500Wadsworth Pl cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostW Wadsworth Cir/Wakefield Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500W Wadsworth Cir/Wakefield Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500W Wadsworth Cir/Wakeman Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500W Wadsworth Cir/Wakeman Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500W Outer Dr/Wainwright Rd S CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Wainwright Rd E CORNER Low $3,500Outer Dr/Orange Ln NW CORNER Low $1,200Outer Dr/Orange Ln SW CORNER Low $3,500Orange Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $1,800Outer Dr/Orchard Ln W CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/Orchard Ln - provide missing ramp S CORNER Low $3,500Outer Dr/Michigan Ave S CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/Michigan Ave E CORNER Low $1,800Michigan Ave/Moylan Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $1,800Michigan Ave/Moylan Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Moylan Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800Kentucky Ave/Michigan Ave SE CORNER Low $500Kentucky Ave/Michigan Ave SW CORNER High $3,500E Wadsworth Cir/Wainwright Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800E Wadsworth Cir/Wainwright Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Taylor Rd/Thayer Ln - provide missing ramp W CORNER Medium $1,800Taylor Rd/Thayer Ln - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $1,800Taylor Rd/Thayer Ln - provide missing ramp N CORNER High $1,800Thayer Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800N Illinois Ave/Iroquois Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800N Illinois Ave/Iroquois Rd SE CORNER Medium $1,800N Illinois Ave/Independence Ln SW CORNER Medium $1,800N Illinois Ave/Independence Ln SE CORNER Medium $1,800N Illinois Ave/Iona Cir (east intersection) SE CORNER Medium $1,800N Illinois Ave/Iona Cir (east intersection) SW CORNER Medium $1,800N Illinois Ave/Iona Cir (west intersection) SE CORNER Medium $1,800N Illinois Ave/Iona Cir (west intersection) SW CORNER Medium $1,800Orchard Ln/Orkney Rd - provide missing ramp S CORNER Low $1,800Orchard Ln/Orkney Rd - provide missing ramp E CORNER Low $1,800Iroquois Rd /Ithaca Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800Iroquois Rd /Ithaca Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $1,800Iroquois Rd/E Irving Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $1,800Iroquois Rd/E Irving Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800Orchard Ln/Orchard Cir SE CORNER Low $1,800Taylor Rd/N Tampa Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800Tabor Rd/N Tampa Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800S Tampa Ln/Taylor Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800N Tampa Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800S Tampa Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800W Outer Dr/E Wadsworth Cir SW CORNER Low $1,200W Outer Dr/E Wadsworth Cir SE CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Highland Ave SW CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Highland Ave SE CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Wabash Ln S CORNER Low $1,200W Outer Dr/Wabash Ln E CORNER Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostW Outer Dr/Wedgewood Rd W CORNER Low $1,200W Outer Dr/Wedgewood Rd N CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/S Walker Ln E CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/S Walker Ln S CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/N Walker Ln N CORNER Low $1,800W Outer Dr/N Walker Ln W CORNER Low $1,800N Walker Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp SW SIDE Low $1,800S Walker Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp NW SIDE Low $1,800Highland Ave/Hoyt Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800Hoyt Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $1,800Highland Ave/N Hollywood Cir NW CORNER Low $1,800Highland Ave/N Hollywood Cir - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800Broadway Ave/Georgia Ave SW CORNER Medium $3,500Broadway Ave/Georgia Ave NW CORNER Medium $3,500Broadway Ave/Georgia Ave - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Broadway Ave mid-block crossing at Jacobs east entry S SIDE Medium $1,200Broadway Ave mid-block crossing at Jacobs east entry N SIDE Medium $3,500Broadway Ave at Jacobs on-street parking space S SIDE Low $1,200Broadway St at Blankenship Field east drive W SIDE Low $1,800Broadway St at Blankenship Field east drive E SIDE Medium $3,500Broadway Ave mid-block crossing at Jacobs west entry N SIDE Medium $1,800Broadway Ave mid-block crossing at Jacobs west entry S SIDE Medium $1,800Broadway St/Towne Rd - east ramp NW CORNER Low $1,800Broadway Ave/Towne Rd - south ramp NW CORNER Low $1,800Broadway St/Towne Rd - west ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800Broadway Ave/Towne Rd - south ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,200Broadway Ave/Towne Rd - provide 2 ramps SE CORNER Medium $5,500Broadway Ave/Towne Rd - north ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Broadway Ave/Towne Rd - east ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800Broadway Ave mid-block crossing at Jackson Sq east drive S SIDE Low $1,800Broadway Ave mid-block crossing at Jackson Sq east drive N SIDE Low $1,800Broadway Ave at Jackson Square east drive W SIDE Compliant $0Broadway Ave at Jackson Square east drive E SIDE Compliant $0Broadway Ave mid-block crossing at center of Jackson Sq N SIDE Low $1,800Broadway Ave mid-block crossing at center of Jackson Sq S SIDE Low $1,800Broadway Ave at Jackson Square west drive W SIDE Low $1,800Broadway Ave at Jackson Square west drive E SIDE Low $1,800Broadway Ave mid-block crossing at Jackson Sq west drive N SIDE Low $1,200Broadway Ave mid-block crossing at Jackson Sq west drive S SIDE Low $1,200Broadway Ave - Blankenship Field west drive at Kentucky Ave E SIDE Low $1,200Broadway Ave - Blankenship Field west drive at Kentucky Ave W SIDE Low $1,200Oak Ridge Turnpike/Wisconsin Ave N CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Westover Dr W CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Westover Dr N CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Oklahoma Ave NW CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Oklahoma Ave NE CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Grandcove Ln E CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Grandcove Ln S CORNER Compliant $0


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostOak Ridge Turnpike/Nebraska Ave ramp to island W CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Nebraska Ave island W SIDE Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Nebraska Ave island N SIDE Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Nebraska Ave to island N CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Nebraska Ave island SE SIDE Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Nebraska Ave to island SE CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Gum Hollow Rd E CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Gum Hollow Rd S CORNER Compliant $0Georgia Ave/Glendale Ln NW CORNER Low $3,500Georgia Ave/Glendale Ln SW CORNER Medium $1,800Gordon Rd/Glendale Ln N CORNER Low $500Gordon Rd/Glendale Ln W CORNER Low $500Glendale Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp NW SIDE Low $1,800Georgia Ave/Gordon Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Georgia Ave/Gordon Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800Florida Ave/E Farragut Rd - provide missing ramp N CORNER Low $1,800Florida Ave/E Farragut Rd - provide 2 missing ramps E CORNER Medium $5,500Florida Ave/W Farragut Rd - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $1,800Florida Ave/E Faunce Ln E CORNER Low $1,800Florida Ave/E Faunce Ln N CORNER Low $1,800Florida Ave/W Faunce Ln - provide missing ramp W CORNER Medium $1,800E Faunce Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp SE SIDE Low $1,800Florida Ave/E Fernhill Ln - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $1,800Florida Ave/E Fernhill Ln - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $1,800Florida Ave/W Fernhill Ln - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $3,500E Fernhill Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800Florida Ave/Firestone Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800Florida Ave/Firestone Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Florida Ave/E Forest Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Florida Ave/W Forest Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500W Forest Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp SE SIDE Low $1,800Florida Ave/Fulton Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Florida Ave/Fulton Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800Florida Ave/Fulton Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Fulton Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $1,800Kingsley Rd/Keystone Ln NE CORNER Low $3,500Kingsley Rd/Kingfisher Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800Kingsley Rd/Kingfisher Ln SE CORNER Low $1,800Keystone Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800Kingfisher Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp NE SIDE Low $1,800Kingfisher Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp SE SIDE Low $1,800Kentucky Ave/Kingsley Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Kentucky Ave/Kingsley Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $3,500Kentucky Ave/Kimball Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Kentucky Ave/Kimball Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800Kimball Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $1,800Kentucky Ave/Kelvin Ln SE CORNER Medium $1,800Kentucky Ave/Kelvin Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Kelvin Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $1,800Kentucky Ave/Kenwyn Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Kentucky Ave/Kenwyn Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostOak Ridge Turnpike/Newport Dr W CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Newport Dr N CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/New Bedford Ln S CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/New Bedford Ln E CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/New Bedford Ln N CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/New Bedford Ln W CORNER Low $1,800E Geneva Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp NW SIDE Low $1,800E Geneva Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp SW SIDE Low $1,800Georgia Ave/W Geneva Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $1,800Georgia Ave/W Geneva Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Georgia Ave/E Geneva Ln - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500W Geneva Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800W Geneva Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Monterey Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Monterey Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Montana Ave SW CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Montana Ave - provide 2 ramps NW CORNER Medium $5,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Montana Ave NE CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Bradley Ave NE CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Bradley Ave NW CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Bermuda Rd W CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Bermuda Rd N CORNER Low $1,800Highland Ave/Hillside Rd NW CORNER Medium $3,500Highland Ave/Hillside Dr - provide 2 ramps NE CORNER Medium $5,500Highland Ave/Hillside Rd SE CORNER Low $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Wiltshire Dr SE CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Wiltshire Dr - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Salem Rd NW CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Salem Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Louisiana Ave S CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Louisiana Ave - provide 2 ramps W CORNER Low $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Louisiana Ave N CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/W Lincoln Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/W Lincoln Rd NW CORNER Compliant $0Louisiana Ave/E Lincoln Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Jefferson Ave - provide 2 ramps NW CORNER Low $5,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Jefferson Ave SE CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Jefferson Ave NE CORNER Compliant $0Wabash Ln/Wade Ln - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $1,800Wabash Ln/Wade Ln - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500Wade Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800Wabash Ln/Waddell Cir S CORNER Low $1,800Wabash Ln/Waddell Pl N CORNER Low $500Waddell Pl cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Taylor Rd N CORNER Medium $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Taylor Rd W CORNER Medium $1,800E Tennessee Ave /Tacoma Rd S CORNER Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave /Tacoma Rd - provide missing ramp NW SIDE Medium $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Temple Rd E CORNER Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Temple Rd S CORNER Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostE Tennessee Ave/Thelma Rd N CORNER Low $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Thelma Rd W CORNER Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Thornton Rd E CORNER Low $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Thornton Rd S CORNER Low $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Tilden Rd W CORNER Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Tilden Rd N CORNER Low $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Tomlinson Rd E CORNER Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Tomlinson Rd S CORNER Low $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Townsend Rd S CORNER Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Townsend Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Tomlinson Rd mid-block south of E Tennessee - provide missing ramp SW SIDE Low $1,800Tomlinson Rd mid-block south of E Tennessee - provide missing ramp NE SIDE Low $1,800W Outer Dr/Westlook Dr NW CORNER Medium $3,500W Outer Dr/Westlook Dr NE CORNER Low $1,800Westlock Dr/Westlock Cir - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800Florida Ave/W Fairview Rd - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $1,800Florida AveE Fairview Rd - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $3,500Florida AveE Fairview Rd - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $1,800Florida Ave/E Tennessee Ave N CORNER Low $3,500Florida Ave/E Tennessee Ave - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $3,500Florida Ave/E Tennessee Ave E CORNER Low $3,500Trevose Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Trevose Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Trevose Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500W Farragut Rd/W Fairview Rd - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $3,500W Farragut Rd/W Fairview Rd - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Georgia Ave NE CORNER Low $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Georgia Ave SE CORNER Low $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Georgia Ave SW CORNER Low $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Georgia Ave NW CORNER Medium $3,500Georgia Ave/Tyson Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $1,800Georgia Ave/Tyson Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500W Outer Dr/Outer Dr NW CORNER Medium $3,500W Outer Dr/Outer Dr NE CORNER Medium $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/W Price Ln SW CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/E Price Rd SE CORNER Low $1,200Pennsylvania Ave/E Price Rd NE CORNER Medium $3,500W Price Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800Outer Dr/New York Ave NW CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/New York Ave NE CORNER Low $3,500Outer Dr/New York Ave SE CORNER Low $1,800Szilard St/Oppenheimer Way SE CORNER Low $1,800Szilard St/Oppenheimer Way SW CORNER Low $1,800Szilard St/Curie Ln NE CORNER Compliant $0Wigner St/Curie Ln SW CORNER Low $1,800Wigner St/Oppenheimer Way SW CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/Osage Rd N CORNER Low $3,500Outer Dr/Osage Rd W CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/Oxford Rd N CORNER Low $1,800Outer Dr/Oxford Rd W CORNER Low $3,500Norwood Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostNew York Ave/Norwood Ln W CORNER Low $1,800New York Ave/Norwood Ln - provide missing ramp N CORNER Low $3,500Norris Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800New York Ave/Norris Ln S CORNER Low $3,500New York Ave/Norris Ln - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $3,500New York Ave/Norman Ln SE CORNER Low $3,500New York Ave/Norman Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800Norman Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Powell Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Powell Rd N CORNER Low $1,800Powell Rd mid-block east of Pennsylvania - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800Powell Rd mid-block east of Pennsylvania - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Porter Rd N CORNER Low $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/Porter Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Tuskegee Dr/TeeJay Dr - provide 2 ramps W CORNER Low $3,500Tuskegee Dr/TeeJay Dr N CORNER Low $1,200Tuskegee Dr/Groves Park Blvd S CORNER Low $1,200TeeJay Dr/Teller Village Dr - provide missing ramp E CORNER Low $1,800TeeJay Dr/Teller Village Dr S SIDE Low $1,800Tuskegee Dr/Tempura Dr NW CORNER Low $500Tuskegee Dr/Tempura Dr NE CORNER Low $500Tuskegee Dr/Hampton Rd - mid-block NW SIDE Medium $1,800Tuskegee Dr/Hampton Rd - mid-block SE SIDE Low $1,200Tempura Dr/Targa Ln S CORNER Low $1,800Tempura Dr/Taube Ln SE CORNER Low $1,200Tempura Dr/Taube Ln - provide 2 ramps SW CORNER Low $5,500Tempura Dr/Taube Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800Tempura Dr cul-de-sac S SIDE Low $1,200Taube Ln N cul-de-sac SW SIDE Low $1,800Wilberforce Ave/Hampton Rd N CORNER Low $3,500Wilberforce Ave/Hampton Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Wilberforce Ave/Houston Ave NW CORNER Low $1,800Wilberforce Ave/Houston Ave NE CORNER Low $500Wilberforce Ave mid-block east of Houston Ave N SIDE Medium $3,500Wilberforce Ave mid-block east of Houston Ave S SIDE Medium $3,500Wilberforce Ave/S Benedict Ave W CORNER Low $1,200Wilberforce Ave/S Benedict Ave SE CORNER Low $1,800Wilberforce Ave/Carver Ave E CORNER Medium $1,800Wilberforce Ave/Carver Ave S CORNER Medium $3,500S Benedict Ave north of Bennett Ln W SIDE Low $1,800S Benedict Ave/Carver Ave - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500S Benedict Ave/Carver Ave - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500S Benedict Ave/Bethune Cir (east intersection) NW CORNER Low $3,500S Benedict Ave/Bethune Cir (east intersection) SW CORNER Low $1,800S Benedict Ave/Bethune Cir (west intersection) SE CORNER Low $1,800S Benedict Ave/Bethune Cir (west intersection) NE CORNER Low $3,500S Benedict Ave/Spellman Ave SW CORNER Low $1,800S Benedict Ave/Spellman Ave - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostE Tennessee Ave/Towne Rd W CORNER Medium $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Towne Rd - southwest ramp N CORNER Medium $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Towne Rd - southeast ramp N CORNER Medium $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Towne Rd S CORNER Medium $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Kentucky Ave E CORNER Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Kentucky Ave - southeast ramp N CORNER Low $500E Tennessee Ave/Kentucky Ave - southwest ramp N CORNER Low $500W Tennessee Ave/Kentucky Ave W CORNER Low $3,500W Tennessee Ave/Kentucky Ave S CORNER Medium $1,800Kentucky Ave/Broadway Ave - southwest ramp E CORNER Medium $1,800Kentucky Ave/Broadway Ave - northwest ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500Kentucky Ave/Broadway Ave - provide 2 ramps N CORNER Low $5,500Kentucky Ave/Broadway Ave - provide 2 ramps W CORNER Medium $5,500Kentucky Ave/Broadway Ave - provide 2 ramps S CORNER Medium $5,500Broadway Ave west of Kentucky to on-street parking S SIDE Low $1,800W Tennessee Ave/Tyler Rd NE CORNER Medium $3,500W Tennessee Ave/Tyler Rd SE CORNER Medium $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Central Ave NW CORNER Low $500E Tennessee Ave/Central Ave - northwest ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Central Ave - northeast ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Central Ave SE CORNER Medium $3,500E Tennessee Ave/Central Ave island SW SIDE Low $500E Tennessee Ave/Central Ave island NE SIDE Low $500S Fisk Ave/S Dillard Ave - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Low $1,800S Fisk Ave/S Dillard Ave - provide 2 missing ramps NW CORNER Medium $5,500S Benedict Ave/S Dillard Ave - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800S Dillard Ave/S Hampton Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500S Dillard Ave/S Hampton Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Low $1,800Groves Park Blvd mid-block southeast of Tuskegee Dr NE SIDE Low $1,800Groves Park Blvd mid-block southeast of Tuskegee Dr SW SIDE Low $1,800Groves Park Blvd/Einstein Ave W CORNER Low $1,800Groves Park Blvd/Einstein Ave N CORNER Low $1,800Groves Park Blvd/Einstein Ave E CORNER Low $1,800Groves Park Blvd/Einstein Ave S CORNER Low $1,200Einstein Ave/Alley G SE CORNER Low $1,800Einstein Ave/Alley G SW CORNER Low $1,800Einstein Ave/Alley G NW CORNER Low $1,800Einstein Ave/Alley G NE CORNER Low $1,800Groves Park Blvd/Alley I NW CORNER Compliant $0Groves Park Blvd/Alley I SW CORNER Compliant $0Groves Park Blvd/Alley C NE CORNER Low $1,800Groves Park Blvd/Alley C SE CORNER Compliant $0Groves Park Blvd/Oppenheimer Way NE CORNER Low $1,800Groves Park Blvd/Oppenheimer Way NW CORNER Low $1,800Oppenheimer Way /Wigner St SE CORNER Low $1,800Oppenheimer Way/Alley D SW CORNER Compliant $0Oppenheimer Way/Alley D SE CORNER Compliant $0Oppenheimer Way/Alley D NW CORNER Compliant $0Oppenheimer Way/Alley D NE CORNER Compliant $0


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostOppenheimer Way/Einstein Ave SW CORNER Compliant $0Oppenheimer Way/Einstein Ave SE CORNER Compliant $0Oppenheimer Way/Einstein Ave NW CORNER Compliant $0Oppenheimer Way/Einstein Ave NE CORNER Compliant $0Crossroads Blvd at northeast end NW SIDE Compliant $0Crossroads Blvd at northeast end S SIDE Low $1,800Crossroads Blvd at southeast end W SIDE Low $1,800Crossroads Blvd at southeast end SE SIDE Low $1,800Crossroads Blvd/Pavilion Dr (south intersection) E CORNER Low $3,500Crossroads Blvd/Pavilion Dr (south intersection) N CORNER Low $1,800Crossroads Blvd/Pavilion Dr (north intersection) - provide 2 ramps E CORNER Low $5,500Crossroads Blvd/Pavilion Dr (north intersection) N CORNER Low $1,800Crossroads Blvd/Pavilion Dr (north intersection) S CORNER Low $1,800Pavilion Dr at southeast end NE SIDE Low $1,800Crossroads Blvd/Crescent View Ln E CORNER Low $1,200Crossroads Blvd/Crescent View Ln S CORNER Low $1,800Crossroads Blvd /Crystal Cove Ln E CORNER Low $1,200Crossroads Blvd /Crystal Cove Ln S CORNER Low $1,800Crossroads Blvd /Wolf Creek Way N CORNER Low $1,200Crossroads Blvd /Wolf Creek Way S CORNER Low $1,800Crossroads Blvd/Cottage Ct E CORNER Low $1,800Crossroads Blvd/Cottage Ct S CORNER Low $1,800Crossroads Blvd/Cobblestone Ct S CORNER Low $1,200Crossroads Blvd/Cobblestone Ct E CORNER Low $1,200Crossroads Blvd east of High Pointe Ln S SIDE Low $1,800Michigan Ave/Meadow Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Michigan Ave/Meadow Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800Mayfair Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800Michigan Ave/Mayfair Ln SW CORNER Medium $3,500Michigan Ave/Mayfair Ln NW CORNER Medium $1,800Michigan Ave/Marion Rd - north ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Michigan Ave/Marion Rd - west ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Michigan Ave/Maple Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800Maple Ln/Meadow Rd NW CORNER Low $1,800Maple Ln/Meadow Rd NE CORNER Low $3,500Maple Ln cul-de-sac N SIDE Low $500Maple Ln cul-de-sac W SIDE Low $1,800Michigan Ave/Malvern Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Low $3,500Michigan Ave/Malvern Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Michigan Ave/E Malta Rd N CORNER Low $3,500Michigan Ave/E Malta Rd - provide 2 ramps E CORNER Low $5,500Michigan Ave/W Malta Rd S CORNER Low $1,800Michigan Ave/W Maiden Ln W CORNER Low $1,800Michigan Ave/E Maiden Ln - provide 2 ramps N CORNER Low $5,500Michigan Ave/E Maiden Ln E CORNER Low $1,800E Maiden Ln cul-de-sac N SIDE Low $1,800W Maiden Ln cul-de-sac N SIDE Low $1,800Michigan Ave/W Magnolia Ln W CORNER Low $1,800Michigan Ave/E Magnolia Ln - provide 2 missing ramps N CORNER Low $5,500Michigan Ave/E Magnolia Ln - provide missing ramp E CORNER Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostW Magnolia Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800E Magnolia Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800Michigan Ave/E Madison Rd NW CORNER Low $3,500Michigan Ave/E Madison Rd NE CORNER Low $3,500Michigan Ave/Broadway Ave N CORNER Low $1,800Michigan Ave/Broadway Ave E CORNER Low $1,800W Tennessee Ave/Michigan Ave N CORNER Low $3,500W Tennessee Ave/Michigan Ave W CORNER Low $1,800Creek View Ct - cul-de-sac E SIDE Low $1,800Wolf Creek Way/Creek View Ct NW CORNER Low $1,800Wolf Creek Way/Creek View Ct SW CORNER Low $1,800Wolf Creek Way/Crest Point Ln N CORNER Low $1,200Wolf Creek Way/Crest Point Ln W CORNER Low $1,800Wolf Creek Way at west end of sidewalk N SIDE Low $1,800Manchester Rd/S Purdue Ave SE CORNER Medium $1,800Manchester Rd/S Purdue Ave NE CORNER Medium $3,500S Purdue Ave/Park Ln E CORNER Low $1,800S Purdue Ave/Park Ln S CORNER Low $1,800S Purdue Ave/Pratt Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800S Purdue Ave/Pratt Ln SE CORNER Low $1,800Quincy Ave/Queens Rd N CORNER Low $3,500Quincy Ave/Queens Rd W CORNER Low $1,800Quincy Ave/S Purdue Ave - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800Quincy Ave/S Purdue Ave - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500S Purdue Ave/Northwestern Ave NW CORNER Low $1,800S Purdue Ave/Northwestern Ave - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Low $3,500Northwestern Ave/Nasson Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800Northwestern Ave/Nasson Ln NW CORNER Low $3,500Nasson Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800Northwestern Ave/Pembroke Rd SW CORNER Medium $1,800Northwestern Ave/Pembroke Rd NW CORNER Medium $3,500Pembroke Rd/Queens Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Pembroke Rd/Queens Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500S Purdue Ave/Pembroke Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800Potomac Cir/S Purdue Ave - provide 2 ramps NW CORNER Low $5,500Potomac Cir/S Purdue Ave SW CORNER Low $1,800Potomac Cir/S Purdue Ave NW CORNER Low $1,800S Purdue Ave/Princeton Ave NE CORNER Low $1,800S Purdue Ave/Princeton Ave SW CORNER Low $3,500S Purdue Ave/Princeton Ave - provide 2 ramps NW CORNER Low $5,500S Purdue Ave/Woodland Terrace E SW CORNER Compliant $0S Purdue Ave/Woodland Terrace E SE CORNER Compliant $0S Purdue Ave/Quincy Ave NW CORNER Low $1,800S Purdue Ave/Quincy Ave SW CORNER Low $3,500S Purdue Ave/Paris Ln SW CORNER Low $1,800S Purdue Ave/Paris Ln SE CORNER Low $1,800W Tennessee Ave/New York Ave - southeast ramp N CORNER Low $3,500W Tennessee Ave/New York Ave - southwest ramp N CORNER Low $1,800W Tennessee Ave/New York Ave E CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/New York Ave W CORNER Medium $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostW Tennessee Ave/Nesper Rd W CORNER Low $3,500W Tennessee Ave/Nesper Ave NE CORNER Low $1,800S Illinois Ave/Inn Ln W CORNER Medium $3,500S Illinois Ave/Inn Ln S CORNER Medium $3,500New York Ave/Nesper Rd SE CORNER Low $3,500New York Ave/Nesper Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Pacific Rd N CORNER Low $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/Pacific Rd W CORNER Low $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/Packer Rd N CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Packer Rd W CORNER Low $3,500Pacific Rd/Packer Rd - mid-block - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $3,500Pacific Rd/Packer Rd - mid-block - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/Palmer Rd N CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Palmer Rd - provide 2 ramps W CORNER Low $5,500Pennsylvania Ave/Pallas Rd S CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Palmetto Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Palmetto Ln NW CORNER Low $3,500Palmetto Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Paoli Ln - provide 2 ramps NE CORNER Low $5,500Pennsylvania Ave/Panama Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Paoli Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800Paoli Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800S Illinois Ave/Woodland Terrace E SW CORNER Compliant $0S Illinois Ave/Woodland Terrace E - provide 2 ramps NW CORNER Low $3,500S Illinois Ave/Woodland Terrace E NE CORNER Low $1,800S Illinois Ave/S Rutgers Ave S CORNER Medium $3,500S Illinois Ave/S Rutgers Ave E CORNER Medium $3,500S Illinois Ave/S Rutgers Ave W CORNER Medium $3,500S Illinois Ave/S Rutgers Ave N CORNER Medium $3,500S Illinois Ave/Lafayette Dr NW CORNER High $3,500S Illinois Ave /Scarboro Rd traffic island north ramp SW CORNER Compliant $0S Illinois Ave /Scarboro Rd traffic island east ramp SW CORNER Compliant $0S Illinois Ave /Scarboro Rd traffic island south ramp SW CORNER Compliant $0S Illinois Ave /Scarboro Rd to traffic island SW CORNER Medium $1,800S Illinois Ave/Lafayette Dr traffic island southwest ramp NE CORNER High $3,500S Illinois Ave/Lafayette Dr traffic island east ramp NE CORNER High $1,800S Illinois Ave/Lafayette Dr to traffic island NE CORNER High $3,500S Illinois Ave/Scarboro Rd SE CORNER High $3,500S Illinois Ave/Scarboro Ln SE CORNER Low $1,800S Illinois Ave/Scarboro Ln SW CORNER Low $1,800Manhattan Ave/S Rutgers Ave (south intersection) SE CORNER Medium $3,500Manhattan Ave/S Rutgers Ave (south intersection) NW CORNER Medium $3,500Manhattan Ave/S Rutgers Ave (south intersection) - north ramp SW CORNER Compliant $0Manhattan Ave/S Rutgers Ave (south intersection) - east ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Manhattan Ave/S Rutgers Ave (south intersection) NE CORNER Medium $3,500Manhattan Ave/S Purdue Ave SW CORNER Medium $3,500Manhattan Ave/S Purdue Ave - west ramp SE CORNER Low $3,500Manhattan Ave/S Purdue Ave - north ramp SE CORNER Low $1,800Manhattan Ave/N Purdue Ave (south intersection) - south ramp NE CORNER Compliant $0Manhattan Ave/N Purdue Ave (south intersection) - west ramp NE CORNER Compliant $0Manhattan Ave/N Purdue Ave (south intersection) NW CORNER Low $1,200


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostNew York Ave/Norton Rd W CORNER Low $1,200New York Ave/Norton Rd - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $3,500New York Ave/Nolan Rd NW CORNER Low $3,500New York Ave/Nolan Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500New York Ave/Nixon Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800New York Ave/Nixon Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500New York Ave/Utah Ave E CORNER Medium $3,500New York Ave/Utah Ave - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $3,500New York Ave/W Newcomb Rd - southwest ramp W CORNER Compliant $0New York Ave/W Newcomb Rd - northeast ramp W CORNER Low $1,800New York Ave/W Newcomb Rd - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $1,800New York Ave/E Newcomb Rd - provide 2 ramps N CORNER Low $5,500New York Ave/E Newcomb Rd E CORNER Low $3,500New York Ave/E Newkirk Ln N CORNER Low $1,800New York Ave/E Newkirk Ln E CORNER Low $3,500New York Ave/W Newkirk Ln W CORNER Low $1,800Manhattan Ave/Northwestern Ave - northwest ramp S CORNER Low $1,800Manhattan Ave/Northwestern Ave - northeast ramp S CORNER Low $3,500Manhattan Ave/Northwestern Ave - provide 2 ramps E CORNER Medium $5,500Manhattan Ave/Northwestern Ave - provide 2 ramps N CORNER Medium $5,500Manhattan Ave Northwestern Ave - northeast ramp W CORNER Medium $3,500Manhattan Ave/Northwestern Ave - southeast ramp W CORNER Medium $3,500Manhattan Ave/S Rutgers Ave (north intersection) - north ramp SE CORNER Low $1,800Manhattan Ave/S Rutgers Ave (north intersection) - west ramp SE CORNER Low $1,800Manhattan Ave/S Rutgers Ave NE CORNER Low $1,800Manhattan Ave/Rice Rd SW CORNER Low $3,500Manhattan Ave/Morris Ln S CORNER Medium $1,800Manhattan Ave/Morris Ln E CORNER Low $1,800Manhattan Ave/Manchester Rd SE CORNER High $3,500Manhattan Ave/Manchester Rd W SIDE High $3,500Manhattan Ave/Manchester Rd NE CORNER High $3,500E Newkirk Ln/E Newcomb Rd - provide 2 ramps N CORNER Medium $5,500E Newkirk Ln/E Newcomb Rd - provide missing ramp W CORNER Medium $3,500E Newkirk Ln/E Newcomb Rd - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500E Newkirk Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800W Newkirk Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800W Newkirk Ln/W Newcomb Rd N CORNER Low $3,500W Newkirk Ln/W Newcomb Rd W CORNER Low $1,800W Gettysburg Ave/Manhattan Ave - provide 2 ramps S CORNER High $5,500W Gettysburg Ave/Manhattan Ave - provide 2 ramps E CORNER High $5,500W Gettysburg Ave/Manhattan Ave - southwest ramp N CORNER Medium $1,200W Gettysburg Ave/Manhattan Ave - southeast ramp N CORNER Medium $1,200W Gettysburg Ave/Manhattan Ave - northeast ramp W CORNER Medium $1,200W Gettysburg Ave/Manhattan Ave - southeast ramp W CORNER Medium $1,200Manhattan Ave/Marietta Cir (south intersection) NW CORNER High $500Manhattan Ave/Marietta Cir (south intersection) NE CORNER High $1,800Manhattan Ave/Marietta Cir (north intersection) SE CORNER High $3,500Manhattan Ave/Marietta Cir (north intersection) SW CORNER High $500Utah Ave/Ulena Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800Utah Ave/Ulena Rd SE CORNER Low $3,500Ulena Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostUtah Ave/Umbria Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Utah Ave/Umbria Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Umbria Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800Utah Ave/Underwood Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Utah Ave/Ulysses Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Utah Ave/Ulysses Ln - provide 2 missing ramps SE CORNER Medium $5,500Ulysses Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800Ulysses Ln/Upsal Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Low $3,500Ulysses Ln/Upsal Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800Utah Ave/Upsal Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Utah Ave/Upsal Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800Uvalde Rd cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800Utah Ave/Uvalde Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $1,800Utah Ave/Uvalde Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Utah Ave/Union Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800Utah Ave/Union Rd SE CORNER Low $3,500Laboratory Rd mid-block northeast of Administration Rd NW SIDE Medium $3,500Laboratory Rd mid-block northeast of Administration Rd SE SIDE Medium $3,500Laboratory Rd/Briarcliff Ave to island SE CORNER Medium $3,500Laboratory Rd/Briarcliff Ave island south ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800Laboratory Rd/Briarcliff Ave island northeast ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800Laboratory Rd/Briarcliff Ave to island NE CORNER Medium $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/E Pasadena Rd NE CORNER Medium $3,500Pennsylvania Ave and Pasadena Rd NW CORNER Medium $1,800Pennsylvania Ave and N Tulane Ave SW CORNER Medium $1,800Pennsylvania Ave and N Tulane Ave NW CORNER Medium $3,500Providence Rd and N Tulane Ave W CORNER Low $1,800Providence Rd and N Tulane Ave S CORNER Low $3,500Providence Rd and N Tulane Ave - remove ramp S CORNER Medium $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Utah Ave - provide 2 ramps NE CORNER Low $5,500Pennsylvania Ave/Utah Ave SE CORNER Low $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/Pocono Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800Pocono Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Poplar Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Poplar Rd SE CORNER Low $3,500Peach Rd/Pickwick Ln N CORNER Low $1,800Peach Rd/Pickwick Ln W CORNER Low $3,500Pickwick Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp NW SIDE Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Pine Ln SE CORNER Low $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/Pine Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800Pine Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800Peach Rd/Pelham Rd NE CORNER Low $3,500Peach Rd/Pelham Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Peach Rd/Pearl Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Peach Rd/Pearl Rd N CORNER Low $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/Parma Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Parma Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Pennsylvania/Parker Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania/Parker Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/Pomona Rd SW CORNER Low $1,200Pennsylvania Ave/Pomona Rd - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Low $3,500


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostPennsylvania Ave/Pleasant Rd NW CORNER Low $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/Pleasant Rd - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/Peach Rd N CORNER Low $3,500Pennsylvania Ave/Peach Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/E Pawley Ln N CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/E Pawley Ln - provide 2 ramps E CORNER Low $5,500Pennsylvania Ave/Hillside Rd - provide 2 ramps S CORNER Low $5,500Pennsylvania Ave/Hillside Rd W CORNER Low $1,800E Pawley Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/E Passmore Ln - provide 2 ramps NW CORNER Low $5,500Pennsylvania Ave/E Passmore Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/W Passmore Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800E Passmore Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp W SIDE Low $1,800W Gettysburg Ave/Goucher Cir (east intersection) SW CORNER Low $1,800W Gettysburg Ave/Goucher Cir (east intersection) SE CORNER Low $3,500W Gettysburg Ave/Graham Pl NE CORNER Low $500W Gettysburg Ave/Graham Pl NW CORNER Low $1,800W Gettysburg Ave/Goucher Cir (west intersection) - provide 2 missing ramps SE CORNER Medium $5,500W Gettysburg Ave/Goucher Cir (west intersection) - provide 2 missing ramps SW CORNER Medium $5,500Manhattan Ave/Marshall Cir (southeast intersection) S CORNER Low $1,800Manhattan Ave/Marshall Cir (southeast intersection) W CORNER Low $1,800Manhattan Ave/Marshall Cir (northwest intersection) - provide 2 ramps SW CORNER Low $5,500Manhattan Ave/Marshall Cir (northwest intersection) SE CORNER Low $1,800Manhattan Ave/Marquette Rd NW CORNER Low $1,800Northwestern Ave/W Gettysburg Ave NE CORNER Low $3,500Northwestern Ave/W Gettysburg Ave NW CORNER Low $1,800Princeton Ave/Northwestern Ave W CORNER Low $1,800Princeton Ave/Northwestern Ave - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $3,500Northwestern Ave/Newberry Cir (southeast intersection) SE CORNER Low $3,500Northwestern Ave/Newberry Cir - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800Northwestern Ave/Nevada Cir (east intersection) NE CORNER Low $3,500Northwestern Ave/Nevada Cir (east intersection) NW CORNER Low $1,800Northwestern Ave/Nevada Cir (west intersection) - provide 2 ramps NW CORNER Low $5,500Northwestern Ave/Nevada Cir (west intersection) NE CORNER Low $1,800Northwestern Ave/Newberry Cir - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800Northwestern Ave/N Purdue Ave NE CORNER Low $3,500Northwestern Ave/N Purdue Ave - provide 2 ramps NW CORNER Low $5,500Northwestern Ave/N Purdue Ave - provide 2 ramps SW CORNER Low $5,500Northwestern Ave/N Purdue Ave SE CORNER Low $1,800Northwestern Ave/S Rutgers Ave - south ramp NE CORNER Low $1,800Northwestern Ave/S Rutgers Ave - west ramp NE CORNER Low $1,800Northwestern Ave/S Rutgers Ave SE CORNER Low $1,200Northwestern Ave/S Rutgers Ave NW CORNER Low $1,800New York Ave/Valetta Ln NW CORNER Medium $3,500New York Ave/Valetta Ln NE CORNER Medium $3,500Valetta Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800New York Ave/E Vance Rd N CORNER Medium $3,500New York Ave/E Vance Rd - provide 2 ramps E CORNER Medium $5,500New York Ave/W Vance Rd S CORNER Compliant $0Hillside Rd/E Hunter Cir (east intersection) - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Hillside Rd/E Hunter Cir (east intersection) - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostHunter Cir/Hunter Pl - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Low $3,500Hunter Cir/Hunter Pl - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Low $1,800Hunter Pl cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp E SIDE Low $1,800Hunter Cir/Hillside Rd (west intersection) - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Hunter Cir/Hillside Rd (west intersection) - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500N Purdue Ave/Parsons Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800N Purdue Ave/Parsons Rd SE CORNER Low $3,500N Purdue Ave/Principia Ln - provide 2 missing ramps S CORNER Medium $5,500N Purdue Ave/Principia Ln - provide missing ramp W CORNER Medium $1,800N Purdue Ave/Principia Ln - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $3,500Parsons Rd/Piedmont Rd N CORNER Low $3,500Parsons Rd/Piedmont Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Newberry Cir/Piedmont Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800Newberry Cir/Piedmont Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Providence Rd at Oak Ridge High School east drive SE CORNER Low $1,200Providence Rd at Oak Ridge High School east drive SW CORNER Medium $1,800Providence Rd at Oak Ridge High School loop east drive SE CORNER Medium $3,500Providence Rd at Oak Ridge High School loop east drive SW CORNER High $1,800Providence Rd at Oak Ridge High School loop west drive SE CORNER Low $1,200Providence Rd at Oak Ridge High School loop west drive SW CORNER High $3,500Providence Rd/Robertsville Rd E CORNER Medium $3,500Providence Rd/Robertsville Rd N CORNER Medium $1,800Newberry Cir/Parsons Rd SW CORNER Low $3,500Newberry Cir/Parsons Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Lafayette Dr/Manchester Rd NW CORNER Medium $3,500Lafayette Dr/Hendrix Dr - west ramp NE CORNER High $1,800Lafayette Dr/Hendrix Dr - south ramp NE CORNER Low $500Lafayette Dr/Emory Valley Rd traffic island west ramp SE CORNER High $1,200Lafayette Dr/Emory Valley Rd traffic island east ramp SE CORNER High $1,200Lafayette Dr/Emory Valley Rd to island SE CORNER Medium $3,500W Gettysburg Ave/Lafayette Dr - provide 2 ramps SW CORNER High $5,500W Gettysburg Ave/Lafayette Dr NW CORNER High $1,200Emory Valley Rd/Fordham Rd S CORNER Medium $3,500Emory Valley Rd/Fordham Rd E CORNER Medium $3,500Emory Valley Rd/Bus Terminal Rd to median SE CORNER Medium $3,500Emory Valley Rd/Bus Terminal Rd median S SIDE Medium $1,200Emory Valley Rd/Bus Terminal Rd median N SIDE Compliant $0Emory Valley Rd/Bus Terminal Rd to median - provide 2 ramps NE CORNER Medium $5,500Emory Valley Rd/Bus Terminal Rd NW CORNER Medium $3,500Hillside Rd/Hamilton Cir (east intersection) - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800Hillside Rd/Hamilton Cir (east intersection) - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Hillside Rd/Hamilton Cir (west intersection) - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $1,800Hillside Rd/Hamilton Cir (west intersection) - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Howard Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800Highland Ave/Howard Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Highland Ave/Howard Ln - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Highland Ave/E Holston Ln - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Medium $1,800Highland Ave/W Holston Ln - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Highland Ave/W Holston Ln - provide 2 missing ramps SW CORNER Medium $5,500E Holston Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800W Holston Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp N SIDE Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostHighland Ave/S Hollywood Cir - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800Highland Ave/S Hollywood Cir - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Emory Valley Rd/Franklin Rd SW CORNER Low $1,800Emory Valley Rd/Franklin Rd SE CORNER Medium $3,500Emory Valley Rd/Fairbanks Rd SW CORNER Medium $3,500Emory Valley Rd/Fairbanks Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Emory Valley Rd/Briarcliff Ave SW CORNER Medium $3,500Emory Valley Rd/Briarcliff Ave to median - provide 2 ramps SE CORNER High $5,500Emory Valley Rd/Briarcliff Ave to median NE CORNER High $3,500Emory Valley Rd/Briarcliff Ave median N SIDE Compliant $0Emory Valley Rd/Briarcliff Ave median S SIDE Compliant $0Robertsville Rd/Highland Ave NE CORNER Low $1,200Robertsville Rd/Highland Ave SE CORNER Compliant $0Robertsville Rd/Randolph Rd NW CORNER Low $1,800Robertsville Rd/Randolph Rd SW CORNER Low $1,200Robertsville Rd/Raleigh Rd (north intersection) SE CORNER Low $1,800Robertsville Rd/Raleigh Rd (north intersection) SW CORNER Compliant $0Robertsville Rd/Raleigh Rd (south intersection) S CORNER Low $3,500Robertsville Rd/Raleigh Rd (south intersection) W CORNER Low $3,500Briarcliff Ave/Donner Dr NW CORNER Low $3,500Briarcliff Ave/Donner Ct - provide 2 ramps SW CORNER Low $5,500Briarcliff Ave/Donner Ct SE CORNER Low $1,800Emory Valley Rd/Donner Dr SW CORNER Medium $1,800Emory Valley Rd/Donner Dr SE CORNER Low $1,200Briarcliff Ave/Downing Dr SW CORNER Low $500Briarcliff Ave/Downing Dr SE CORNER Low $1,200Briarcliff Ave/Fairbanks Rd W CORNER Medium $1,800Briarcliff Ave/Fairbanks Rd - provide 2 ramps N CORNER Medium $5,500Briarcliff Ave/Fairbanks Rd E CORNER Medium $3,500Briarcliff Ave at Roane St Comm College east drive S CORNER Medium $1,800Briarcliff Ave at Roane St Comm College east drive W CORNER Medium $1,800Briarcliff Ave at Roane St Comm College main drive SE CORNER Medium $3,500Briarcliff Ave at Roane St Comm College main drive SW CORNER Medium $1,800Briarcliff Ave at Roane St Comm College main drive NW CORNER Low $1,800Briarcliff Ave at Roane St Comm College main drive NE CORNER Low $1,800Briarcliff Ave at Home Depot access drive NW CORNER Low $1,800Briarcliff Ave at Home Depot access drive NE CORNER Low $1,800Fairbanks Rd at Jefferson Middle School south driveway SW CORNER High $1,800Fairbanks Rd at Jefferson Middle School south driveway NW CORNER High $3,500Fairbanks Rd/Dayton Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER High $1,800Vermont Ave/Vista Rd NE CORNER Low $3,500Vermont Ave/Vista Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Vermont Ave SE CORNER Medium $1,800Pennsylvania Ave/Vermont Ave - provide missing ramp NE CORNER Medium $3,500Raleigh Rd/Ivanhoe Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Raleigh Rd/Ivanhoe Rd SW CORNER Compliant $0Vermont Ave/Venus Rd N CORNER Low $1,800Vermont Ave/Venus Rd E CORNER Low $3,500


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostNew York Ave/Vermont Ave - northeast ramp W CORNER Low $3,500New York Ave/Vermont Ave - southeast ramp W CORNER Low $3,500New York Ave/Vermont Ave - provide 2 ramps E CORNER Medium $5,500New York Ave/Vermont Ave - provide 2 ramps N CORNER Medium $5,500New York Ave/Vermont Ave - northwest ramp S CORNER Low $1,800New York Ave/Vermont Ave - northeast ramp S CORNER Low $3,500Vermont Ave/Vassar Rd N CORNER Low $3,500Vermont Ave/Vassar Rd E CORNER Low $1,200Manhattan Ave/N Purdue Ave (north intersection) - west ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Manhattan Ave/N Purdue Ave (north intersection) - north ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Manhattan Ave/N Purdue Ave (north intersection) SW CORNER Low $1,800Manhattan Ave/N Purdue Ave - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $1,800Manhattan Ave/N Purdue Ave - provide 2 missing ramps NE CORNER Medium $5,500Vermont Ave/E Vance Rd - provide 2 ramps W CORNER Medium $5,500Vermont Ave/E Vance Rd - provide 2 ramps N CORNER Medium $5,500Vermont Ave/E Vance Rd - provide 2 ramps S CORNER Medium $5,500Vermont Ave/E Vance Rd - provide 2 ramps E CORNER Medium $5,500E Vance Rd/Tennyson Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800Lafayette Dr/Lendon Blvd NW CORNER Medium $3,500Lafayette Dr/Lendon Blvd SW CORNER Medium $1,800Liberty Cir/Lendon Blvd NE CORNER Low $1,200Liberty Cir/Lendon Blvd SE CORNER Low $1,200Liberty Ct/Drive B - provide 2 ramps E CORNER Low $5,500Liberty Ct/Drive B - provide 2 ramps N CORNER Low $5,500Liberty Ct/Liberty Ct - provide 2 ramps S CORNER Low $5,500Liberty Ct/Liberty Ct - provide 2 ramps W CORNER Low $5,500Maryville Cir/Liberty Ct NE CORNER Low $500Maryville Cir/Liberty Ct - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Liberty Ct mid-block at mailboxes E SIDE Low $3,500Liberty Ct mid-block at mailboxes W SIDE Low $500Liberty Cir/Drive D SW CORNER Low $500Liberty Cir/Drive D SE CORNER Low $3,500Liberty Cir/Drive A SE CORNER Low $500Liberty Cir/Drive A NE CORNER Low $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Florida Ave NW CORNER High $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Fairbanks Rd SW CORNER Medium $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Georgia Ave - provide 2 ramps NE CORNER High $5,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Georgia Ave NW CORNER Medium $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike /Laboratory Rd to traffic island SE CORNER Medium $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike /Laboratory Rd traffic island south ramp SE CORNER Medium $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike /Laboratory Rd traffic island north ramp SE CORNER High $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Central Ave NE CORNER Medium $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Central Ave median E SIDE Low $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Central Ave median W SIDE Low $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Central Ave NW CORNER Medium $3,500Bus Terminal Rd/Laboratory Rd - southwest ramp SE CORNER High $1,200Bus Terminal Rd/Laboratory Rd - northwest ramp SE CORNER High $1,800Bus Terminal Rd/Laboratory Rd NE CORNER Medium $500Bus Terminal Rd/Laboratory Rd SW CORNER Low $500Talmeda Rd/Tyler Rd - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $1,800Talmeda Rd/Tyler Rd - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostW Tyrone Rd/Tyler Rd S CORNER Low $1,800E Tyrone Rd/Tyler Rd N CORNER Low $1,800E Tyrone Rd/Tyler Rd E CORNER Low $3,500E Tyrone Rd/Central Ave S CORNER Low $1,800E Tyrone Rd/Central Ave - provide missing ramp W CORNER Low $1,800Emory Valley Rd/Dana Dr NW CORNER Low $1,800Emory Valley Rd/Emory Ln SW CORNER Low $1,800Emory Valley Rd/Emory Ln SE CORNER Low $1,800E Tennessee Ave/W Fairview Rd N CORNER Medium $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Turner Rd S CORNER Medium $1,800E Tennessee Ave/Turner Rd E CORNER Medium $3,500Turner Rd/Tucker Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Turner Rd/Tucker Rd NE CORNER Low $3,500Tucker Rd and Florida Ave W CORNER Low $3,500Tucker Rd and Florida Ave S CORNER Low $1,800N Illinois Ave/Hillside Rd N CORNER High $3,500N Illinois Ave/Hillside Rd E CORNER High $3,500Hillside Rd/N Hickory Ln - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $1,800Hillside Rd/N Hickory Ln - provide 2 missing ramps W CORNER Medium $5,500Hillside Rd/S Hickory Ln - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $1,800S Hickory Ln cul-de-sac - provide missing ramp S SIDE Low $1,800S Hickory Ln/Hickory Pl - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800S Hickory Ln/Hickory Pl - provide missing ramp SE CORNER Low $3,500Robertsville Rd/Iroquois Rd N CORNER Medium $3,500Robertsville Rd/Iroquois Rd W CORNER Low $1,800Robertsville Rd/Willow Brook School N CORNER High $1,800Robertsville Rd/Willow Brook School W CORNER High $1,800Iroquois Rd mid-block at Willow Brook Elementary NE SIDE High $1,200Iroquois Rd mid-block at Willow Brook Elementary SW SIDE High $1,800Administration Rd/Laboratory Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Administration Rd/Laboratory Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Laboratory Rd at Home Depot drive N CORNER Low $1,800Laboratory Rd at Home Depot drive E CORNER Low $1,800Ivanhoe Ln at west end (sidewalk access from parking) NE CORNER High $3,500W Tyrone Rd/Tyndale Rd E CORNER Low $1,800W Tyrone Rd/Tyndale Rd S CORNER Low $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Tyndale Rd NW CORNER Medium $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Tyndale Rd NE CORNER Medium $1,800Oak Ridge Tpke/Tennenson Rd NE CORNER High $1,800Oak Ridge Tpke/Tennenson Rd NW CORNER High $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike /Bus Terminal Rd N CORNER Medium $500Oak Ridge Turnpike /Bus Terminal Rd - provide 2 ramps E CORNER High $5,500Oak Ridge Turnpike /Bus Terminal Rd S CORNER High $3,500N Illinois Ave/Robertsville Rd - provide 2 ramps W CORNER High $5,500N Illinois Ave/Robertsville Rd - provide 2 ramps S CORNER High $5,500N Illinois Ave/Robertsville Rd - provide 2 ramps N CORNER High $5,500N Illinois Ave/Robertsville Rd E CORNER High $3,500N Illinois Ave/Ivanhoe Ln W CORNER High $3,500N Illinois Ave/Ivanhoe Ln N CORNER Compliant $0N Illinois Ave/Ivanhoe Ln E CORNER Compliant $0N Illinois Ave/Ivanhoe Rd S CORNER High $3,500


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostN Illinois Ave/Kroger driveway N CORNER Compliant $0N Illinois Ave/Kroger driveway S CORNER Low $1,800N Illinois Ave/Kroger driveway island N SIDE Low $1,200N Illinois Ave/Kroger driveway island S SIDE Low $1,200Milan Way/Administration Rd - provide missing ramp W CORNER Low $1,800Milan Way/Administration Rd - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $1,800Administration Rd mid-block north of Laboratory Way W SIDE Low $1,800Administration Rd mid-block north of Laboratory Way E SIDE Medium $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Administration Rd S CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Tyler Rd - provide missing ramp N CORNER High $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Tyler Rd - provide missing ramp W CORNER High $3,500N Illinois Ave/Ingraham Ln NW CORNER High $1,800N Illinois Ave/Ingraham Ln SW CORNER High $1,800Ivanhoe Rd/Inca Cir (east intersection) NW CORNER Compliant $0Ivanhoe Rd/Inca Cir (east intersection) NE CORNER Compliant $0Ivanhoe Rd/Inca Cir (west intersection) NE CORNER Compliant $0Ivanhoe Rd/Inca Cir (west intersection) NW CORNER Compliant $0Ivanhoe Rd at Kroger driveway SE CORNER Compliant $0Jefferson Ave/S Jefferson Cir NW CORNER Low $1,800Jefferson Ave/S Jefferson Cir SW CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/W Vanderbilt Dr SE CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/W Vanderbilt Dr SW CORNER Compliant $0Bus Terminal Rd/Milan Way N CORNER Low $1,800Milan Way/Bus Terminal Rd E CORNER Low $1,800W Vanderbilt Dr/Virginia Rd NW CORNER Low $500W Vanderbilt Dr/Virginia Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800Villanova Rd/Virginia Rd W CORNER Low $1,800Villanova Rd/Virginia Rd - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike /Villanova Rd NE CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/Villanova Rd SW CORNER Compliant $0Villanova Rd/Valparaiso Rd N CORNER Low $3,500Villanova Rd/Valparaiso Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Villanova Rd/E Vanderbilt Dr NE CORNER Low $3,500Villanova Rd/E Vanderbilt Dr SW CORNER Low $500E Vanderbilt Dr/Valparaiso Rd NW CORNER Low $3,500E Vanderbilt Dr/Valparaiso Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Adams Ln NE CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Adams Ln NW CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Van Hicks Rd NW CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Van Hicks Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800Laboratory Rd mid-block northeast of E Division Rd S SIDE Medium $500Laboratory Rd mid-block northeast of E Division Rd N SIDE Low $1,800Lafayette Dr/Laboratory Rd E CORNER Medium $1,800Lafayette Dr/Laboratory Rd median E SIDE Medium $1,200Lafayette Dr/Laboratory Rd median W SIDE Medium $1,800Lafayette Dr/Laboratory Rd W SIDE Medium $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostOak Ridge Turnpike/N Illinois Ave to traffic island W CORNER High $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Illinois Ave traffic island west ramp W CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Illinois Ave traffic island northeast ramp W CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Illinois Ave traffic island southeast ramp W CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Illinois Ave to traffic island N CORNER High $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Illinois Ave traffic island southwest ramp N CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Illinois Ave traffic island north ramp N CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Illinois Ave traffic island southeast ramp N CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/S Illinois Ave traffic island northwest ramp E CORNER Medium $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/S Illinois Ave traffic island east ramp E CORNER High $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/S Illinois Ave traffic island southwest ramp E CORNER High $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/S Illinois Ave to traffic island E CORNER Medium $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/S Illinois Ave S CORNER High $3,500Robertsville Rd at Kroger driveway NE CORNER Medium $1,800Robertsville Rd at Kroger driveway - provide 2 ramps NW CORNER Medium $3,500Robertsville Rd at Kroger driveway SW CORNER Medium $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike /Robertsville Rd NE CORNER Medium $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike /Robertsville Rd NW CORNER Low $1,200Oak Ridge Turnpike/Orau Way SE CORNER Medium $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/New York Ave N CORNER High $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/New York Ave W CORNER High $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Lafayette Dr traffic island northwest ramp S CORNER High $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Lafayette Dr to traffic island S CORNER High $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Lafayette Dr traffic island south ramp S CORNER High $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike at Kroger driveway to traffic island NE CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike at Kroger driveway to traffic island NW CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike at Kroger driveway traffic island E SIDE Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike at Kroger driveway traffic island W SIDE Compliant $0S Illinois Ave/E Vanderbilt Dr SE CORNER Low $500S Illinois Ave/E Vanderbilt Dr SW CORNER Low $500S Illinois Ave/Orau Way to traffic island NW CORNER Medium $1,800S Illinois Ave/Orau Way traffic island west ramp NW CORNER High $1,800S Illinois Ave/Orau Way traffic island east ramp NW CORNER High $3,500S Illinois Ave/Orau Way NE CORNER High $1,800S Illinois Ave/Tulsa Rd SW CORNER Medium $500S Illinois Ave/Tulsa Rd traffic island northwest ramp SE CORNER High $1,800S Illinois Ave/Tulsa Rd traffic island southeast ramp SE CORNER Medium $1,800S Illinois Ave/Tulsa Rd to traffic island SE CORNER Medium $1,800S Illinois Ave/Tuskegee Dr to traffic island SW CORNER Medium $1,800S Illinois Ave/Tuskegee Dr traffic island southwest ramp SW CORNER Medium $1,800S Illinois Ave/Tuskegee Dr traffic island east ramp SW CORNER High $3,500S Illinois Ave/Tuskegee Dr traffic island north ramp SW CORNER High $3,500S Illinois Ave/Tuskegee Dr traffic island north ramp SE CORNER Compliant $0S Illinois Ave/Tuskegee Dr traffic island west ramp SE CORNER High $3,500S Illinois Ave/Tuskegee Dr traffic island southeast ramp SE CORNER High $1,800S Illinois Ave/Tuskegee Dr to traffic island SE CORNER High $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostS Illinois Ave/S Tulane Ave to traffic island NW CORNER Compliant $0S Illinois Ave/S Tulane Ave traffic island east ramp NW CORNER Medium $1,800S Illinois Ave/S Tulane Ave traffic island south ramp NW CORNER Compliant $0S Illinois Ave/S Tulane Ave traffic island east ramp NW CORNER Compliant $0S Illinois Ave/S Tulane Ave traffic island northeast ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800S Illinois Ave/S Tulane Ave traffic island west ramp NE CORNER High $1,800S Illinois Ave/S Tulane Ave traffic island south ramp NE CORNER High $1,800S Illinois Ave/S Tulane Ave to traffic island NE CORNER Medium $1,800S Tulane Ave/Tulane Pl SW CORNER Low $500S Tulane Ave/Tulane Pl NW CORNER Low $500S Illinois Ave/Badger Ave NE CORNER Low $1,800S Illinois Ave/Badger Ave NW CORNER Low $1,800S Illinois Ave/E Tulsa Rd NE CORNER High $3,500S Illinois Ave/E Tulsa Rd NW CORNER High $3,500S Illinois Ave/E Tulsa Rd SE CORNER High $3,500S Illinois Ave/E Tulsa Rd SW CORNER High $3,500S Illinois Ave/E Tulsa Rd traffic island E SIDE Compliant $0S Illinois Ave/E Tulsa Rd traffic island W SIDE Compliant $0S Tulane Ave at Wal-Mart drive SW CORNER Low $1,800S Tulane Ave at Wal-Mart drive NW CORNER Low $1,800S Tulane Ave at Wal-Mart drive to traffic island NE CORNER Medium $1,800S Tulane Ave at Wal-Mart drive traffic island north ramp NE CORNER Low $500S Tulane Ave at Wal-Mart drive traffic island south ramp NE CORNER Low $500S Tulane Ave at Wal-Mart drive median N SIDE Low $500S Tulane Ave at Wal-Mart drive median S SIDE Low $500S Tulane Ave at Wal-Mart drive traffic island north ramp SE CORNER Low $500S Tulane Ave at Wal-Mart drive traffic island south ramp SE CORNER Low $1,800S Tulane Ave at Wal-Mart drive to traffic island SE CORNER Medium $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/S Rutgers Ave E CORNER High $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Rutgers Ave - southeast ramp N CORNER High $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Rutgers Ave - southwest ramp N CORNER High $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Rutgers Ave W CORNER High $3,500S Tulane Ave at US Post Office drive - west ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800S Tulane Ave at US Post Office drive - south ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800S Tulane Ave at US Post Office drive SE CORNER Medium $1,800S Tulane Ave at US Post Office drive SW CORNER Medium $1,800S Tulane Ave at US Post Office drive - south ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500S Tulane Ave at US Post Office drive - east ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike at Manhattan Place drive SW SIDE Low $500Tulsa Rd/Utica Cir - provide missing ramp S CORNER Medium $1,800Tulsa Rd/Utica Cir - provide missing ramp E CORNER Medium $1,800Tuskegee Dr/Tulsa Rd - south ramp NW CORNER Medium $3,500Tuskegee Dr/Tulsa Rd southeast ramp to island NW CORNER Medium $3,500Tuskegee Dr/Tulsa Rd traffic island northwest ramp NW CORNER Low $500Tuskegee Dr/Tulsa Rd traffic island east ramp NW CORNER Low $500Tuskegee Dr/Tulsa Rd SW CORNER Low $500Tuskegee Dr/E Tulsa Rd to traffic island NE CORNER Medium $3,500Tuskegee Dr/E Tulsa Rd traffic island north ramp NE CORNER Low $500Tuskegee Dr/E Tulsa Rd traffic island west ramp SE CORNER Low $1,800Tuskegee Dr/S Benedict Ave - provide missing ramp S CORNER Low $1,800Tuskegee Dr/S Benedict Ave - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostHouston Ave/S Benedict Ave W CORNER Low $1,800Houston Ave/S Benedict Ave S CORNER Low $1,800Vermont Ave/N Rutgers Ave E CORNER Low $1,800Vermont Ave/N Rutgers Ave S CORNER Low $500Vermont Ave /Verbena Rd E CORNER Low $1,800Vermont Ave /Verbena Rd S CORNER Low $1,800Vermont Ave /Verbena Rd - provide missing ramp N CORNER Medium $1,800Vermont Ave/Vernon Rd - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Medium $1,800Vermont Ave/Vernon Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Vermont Ave/Vienna Rd SE CORNER Low $3,500Vermont Ave/Vienna Rd - east ramp SW CORNER Low $1,800Vermont Ave/Vienna Rd - north ramp SW CORNER Medium $3,500Vermont Ave/Victoria Rd NE CORNER Medium $3,500Vermont Ave/Victoria Rd NW CORNER Low $500S Rutgers Ave at Food City drive NE CORNER Medium $3,500S Rutgers Ave at Food City drive SE CORNER Low $500Marquette Rd/N Purdue Ave NW CORNER Low $1,800Marquette Rd/N Purdue Ave SW CORNER Low $1,800Marquette Rd/Maryville Cir - north intersection SE CORNER Low $500Marquette Rd/Maryville Cir - north intersection NE CORNER Low $500Marquette Rd/Maryville Cir - south intersection NE CORNER Low $1,800Marquette Rd/Maryville Cir - provide missing ramp NW CORNER Low $3,500Vermont Ave/Viola Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Vermont Ave/Viola Rd NE CORNER Low $3,500Viking Rd/Vermont Ave W CORNER Low $1,800Viking Rd/Vermont Ave - provide missing ramp N CORNER Low $3,500Vienna Rd/Viking Rd SE CORNER Low $1,800Vienna Rd/Viking Rd - provide missing ramp SW CORNER Low $3,500N Tulane Ave mid-block north of W Pasadena Ln E SIDE Low $1,800N Tulane Ave mid-block north of W Pasadena Ln W SIDE Low $1,800N Tulane Ave/Vienna Rd NE CORNER Low $1,800N Tulane Ave/Vienna Rd SE CORNER Medium $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Viking Dr to traffic island NE CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Viking Dr traffic island east ramp NW CORNER Low $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Viking Dr traffic island west ramp NW CORNER Low $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/Viking Dr NW CORNER Medium $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/Main St W - west ramp SE CORNER Medium $1,200Oak Ridge Turnpike/Main St W - north ramp SE CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike at Oak Ridge High School drive NE CORNER High $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike at Oak Ridge High School drive NW CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike at Oak Ridge High School drive SW CORNER Compliant $0Oak Ridge Turnpike/E Main St SW CORNER Low $1,200S Tulane Ave at Municipal Center south drive SW CORNER Low $500S Tulane Ave at Municipal Center south drive south ramp NW CORNER Low $500S Tulane Ave at Municipal Center south drive east ramp NW CORNER Low $1,200S Tulane Ave at Municipal Center south drive NE CORNER Medium $3,500S Tulane Ave at Municipal Center south drive median W SIDE Low $1,200S Tulane Ave at Municipal Center south drive median E SIDE Low $1,200S Tulane Ave at Municipal Center north drive SW CORNER Compliant $0S Tulane Ave at Municipal Center north drive NW CORNER Low $1,800


Description/Street and Street Quadrant Priority Probable CostS Tulane Ave/Wilson St SE CORNER Low $3,500S Tulane Ave/Wilson St NE CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike at Library drive SE CORNER Low $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike at Library drive SW CORNER Low $500Oak Ridge Turnpike at Civic Center drive NE CORNER Low $500Oak Ridge Turnpike at Civic Center drive NW CORNER Low $500Wilson St/Main St W (west intersection) SW CORNER Low $1,200Wilson St/Main St W (west intersection) SE CORNER Compliant $0Wilson St/Main St W (east intersection) SE CORNER Compliant $0Wilson St/Main St W (east intersection) NE CORNER Compliant $0S Rutgers Ave/Wilson St SW CORNER Low $1,200Wilson St/E Main St SW CORNER Low $3,500Wilson St/E Main St SE CORNER Low $1,200Wilson St/E Main St NW CORNER Low $1,200N Tulane Rd at Oak Ridge High School drive NE CORNER High $1,800N Tulane Rd at Oak Ridge High School drive SE CORNER Medium $1,800N Tulane Rd at Oak Ridge High School drive SW CORNER Medium $1,800N Tulane Rd at Oak Ridge High School drive NW CORNER High $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Tulane Ave to traffic island NW CORNER Medium $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Tulane Ave traffic island west ramp NW CORNER Medium $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Tulane Ave traffic island east ramp NW CORNER Medium $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Tulane Ave to median NE CORNER High $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Tulane Ave north median west ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Tulane Ave median island east ramp NE CORNER Medium $1,800Oak Ridge Turnpike/N Tulane Ave SE CORNER High $5,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/S Tulane Ave south median east ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/S Tulane Ave south median west ramp SE CORNER Medium $3,500Oak Ridge Turnpike/S Tulane Ave traffic island east ramp SW CORNER Low $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/S Tulane Ave traffic island southwest ramp SW CORNER Low $500Oak Ridge Turnpike/S Tulane Ave to traffic island SW CORNER Low $500

Total Compliant 103 $0946 $1,903,203

Total MEDIUM Priority 434 $1,312,800Total HIGH Priority 91 $269,000

TOTALS 1574 $3,485,003

Total LOW Priority


Location Quadrant CommentsN Illinois Avenue and W Outer Drive SOUTH no level clear space at pushbuttonN Illinois Avenue and W Outer Drive EAST button distant from PAR, no level clear spaceOak Ridge Turnpike and Nebraska Avenue - island WEST both pushbuttons on same pole, small button diameterOak Ridge Turnpike and Nebraska Avenue EAST small button diameter, no level clear space at pushbuttonOak Ridge Turnpike and Nebraska Avenue SOUTHEAST small button diameter, no level clear space at pushbuttonOak Ridge Turnpike and Montana Avenue SOUTH small button diameter, no level clear space at pushbuttonOak Ridge Turnpike and Montana Avenue NORTHWEST both pushbuttons on same pole, small button diameterOak Ridge Turnpike and Montana Avenue NORTHEAST small button diameter, no level clear space at pushbutton

Oak Ridge Turnpike and Louisiana Avenue SOUTHbutton distant from PAR, small button diameter, no level clear space a pushbutton

Oak Ridge Turnpike and Louisiana Avenue WEST both pushbuttons on same pole, small button diameterOak Ridge Turnpike and Louisiana Avenue NORTH small button diameter, no level clear space at pushbutton

Oak Ridge Turnpike and Jefferson Avenue NORTHWESTone button not working, both pushbuttons on same pole, small button diameter, buttons distant from PAR

Oak Ridge Turnpike and Jefferson Avenue SOUTHEAST button distant from PAR, no level clear space, small button diameterOak Ridge Turnpike and Jefferson Avenue NORTHEAST small button diameterW Tennessee Avenue and Tyler Road NORTH button distant from PAR, no level clear spaceW Tennessee Avenue and Tyler Road EAST button distant from PAR, no level clear spaceS Illinois Avenue and S Rutgers Avenue SOUTH both pushbuttons on same pole, small button diameter

S Illinois Avenue and S Rutgers Avenue EASTheight of pushbuttons, both pushbuttons on same pole, one button diameter small

S Illinois Avenue and S Rutgers Avenue NORTHbutton distant from PAR, small button diameter, no level clear space a pushbutton, both buttons on same pole, operating force of pushbuttons

S Illinois Avenue and S Rutgers Avenue WESTboth pushbuttons on same pole, one button diameter small, no level clear space

S Illinois Avenue and Woodland Terrace E WESTS Illinois Avenue and Woodland Terrace E NORTH no level clear space at pushbutton, both buttons on same poleS Illinois Avenue and Woodland Terrace E EAST button distant from PAR, no level clear space

Table B-3 Pedestrian Signal Locations and Compliance.

City of Oak RidgePedestrian Signals Page 1 of 5

S Illinois Avenue and Lafayette Drive NORTHWESTno level clear space, one button diameter small, both buttons on same pole

S Illinois Avenue and Lafayette Drive - island SW corner NORTHEASTno level clear space, one button not working, both buttons on same pole, small button diameter

S Illinois Avenue and Scarboro Road - island NE corner SOUTHWEST both pushbuttons on same pole, small button diameterS Illinois Avenue and Scarboro Road - island S end SOUTHWEST no level clear spaceS Illinois Avenue and Scarboro Road - to S island ramp SOUTHWEST

S Illinois Avenue and Scarboro Road SOUTHEASTboth buttons on same pole, diameter of one button small, clear space at buttons too small, sign missing

S Rutgers Avenue and Manhattan Avenue SOUTHEAST both buttons on same pole S Rutgers Avenue and Manhattan Avenue NORTHEAST both buttons on same poleS Rutgers Avenue and Manhattan Avenue NORTHWEST no level clear space at pushbuttons, both buttons on same pole

S Rutgers Avenue and Manhattan Avenue SOUTHWESTno level clear space at one pushbutton, both buttons on same pole, operating force of pushbuttons

Lafayette Drive and Manchester Road NORTHWESTno level clear space, small button diameter, operating force of pushbuttons

Lafayette Drive and Hendrix Drive NORTHEAST small button diameterEmory Valley Road and Bus Terminal Road SOUTHEAST distance from curb, small button diameterEmory Valley Road and Bus Terminal Road MEDIAN single button controls both crossings, small button diameterEmory Valley Road and Bus Terminal Road NORTHEAST small button diameter, operating force of pushbuttonEmory Valley Road and Briarcliff Avenue SOUTHWEST no level clear space at button, distance from curbEmory Valley Road and Briarcliff Avenue NORTHEAST no level clear space at button, distance from curb, no signOak Ridge Turnpike and Florida Avenue NORTHWEST distance from curbOak Ridge Turnpike and Florida Avenue SOUTHWEST non-compliant size clear space at button, distance from curb

Oak Ridge Turnpike and Georgia Avenue NORTHboth buttons on same pole, buttons not working, diameter of one button small

Oak Ridge Turnpike and Georgia Avenue WESTbutton broken, small button diameter, button height, operating force of pushbutton

Oak Ridge Turnpike and Laboratory Road - island W corner EAST small button diameter, no sign

Laboratory Road and Bus Terminal Road SOUTHEASTboth buttons on same pole, pole distant from both crossings, no level clear space at pushbuttons, small button diameter

Laboratory Road and Bus Terminal Road NORTHEAST small button diameterLaboratory Road and Bus Terminal Road SOUTHWEST small button diameter, no sign


N Illinois Avenue and Robertsville Road NORTHWEST no level clear space at pushbutton, distance from curb, bad signageN Illinois Avenue and Robertsville Road SOUTHWEST pushbutton height, bad signageN Illinois Avenue and Robertsville Road NORTHEAST no level clear space at pushbutton, distance from curb, bad signageN Illinois Avenue and Robertsville Road SOUTHEAST distance from curb, bad signage

N Illinois Avenue and Ivanhoe Ln NORTHWESTboth pushbuttons on same pole, no level clear space, pushbutton height, operating force of pushbuttons

N Illinois Avenue and Ivanhoe Ln SOUTHWEST both pushbuttons on same pole, operating force of pushbuttonsN Illinois Avenue and Ivanhoe Road NORTHEAST both pushbuttons on same pole, no tactile arrowN Illinois Avenue and Ivanhoe Road SOUTHEAST both pushbuttons on same pole, no tactile arrow, distance from curbOak Ridge Turnpike and Tyndale Road NORTHWEST small button diameterOak Ridge Turnpike and Tyndale Road NORTHEAST small button diameterOak Ridge Turnpike and Bus Terminal Road SOUTHEAST both buttons on same pole, no level clear spaceOak Ridge Turnpike and Bus Terminal Road SOUTHEAST no level clear space, small button diameter Oak Ridge Turnpike and Bus Terminal Road NORTHEAST no level clear space, reach distance from PAR

Oak Ridge Turnpike and S Illinois Avenue SOUTHboth buttons on same pole, reach distance from PAR, no level clear space, distance from curb, diameter of one button small

Oak Ridge Turnpike and S Illinois Avenue - island W corner EASTno level clear space, both buttons on same pole, diameter of one button small, height of pushbuttons, operating force of pushbuttons

Oak Ridge Turnpike and N Illinois Avenue - island E corner WESTboth buttons on same pole, distance from ramp excessive, 2 buttons but 3 ramps on island could be confusing

Oak Ridge Turnpike and N Illinois Avenue - island W corner NORTHboth buttons on same pole, distance from ramp excessive, 2 buttons but 3 ramps on island could be confusing

Oak Ridge Turnpike and E Division Road EASTOak Ridge Turnpike and Tennyson Road NORTH both buttons on same pole, small button diameterOak Ridge Turnpike and Tennyson Road WEST


S Illinois Avenue and Tulsa Road SOUTHWESTboth buttons on same pole, small diameter of one button, pushbutton height, operating force

S Illinois Avenue and Tulsa Road -island NW corner SOUTHEASTboth buttons on same pole, distance from ramp excessive, small diameter of one button, 2 buttons but 3 ramps on island could be confusing

S Illinois Avenue and Orau Way - island SE corner NORTHWESTboth buttons on same pole, distance from ramp excessive, small button diameter, 2 buttons but 3 ramps on island could be confusing, operating force

S Illinois Avenue and Orau Way NORTHEASTboth buttons on same pole, no level clear space, small button diameter, one button obstructed by vegetation, pushbutton height, distance from curb

Lafayette Drive and Laboratory Road EAST small button diameterLafayette Drive and Laboratory Road - E side MEDIAN single button controls both crossings, small button diameterLafayette Drive and Laboratory Road SOUTH no level clear space, small button diameter

Oak Ridge Turnpike and Robertsville Road NORTHEASTboth pushbuttons on same pole, one button has no tactile arrow, distance from curb

Oak Ridge Turnpike and Robertsville Road NORTHWESTOak Ridge Turnpike and Orau Way SOUTHEASTS Illinois Avenue and E Tulsa Road NORTHEAST both pushbuttons on same pole, pushbutton height

S Illinois Avenue and E Tulsa Road NORTHWESTboth pushbuttons on same pole, distance from curb, one button small diameter, large button with no tactile arrow

S Illinois Avenue and E Tulsa Road SOUTHEASTboth pushbuttons on same pole, no level clear space, one button small diameter

S Illinois Avenue and E Tulsa Road SOUTHWESTboth pushbuttons on same pole, small button diameter, pushbutton height

Oak Ridge Turnpike and S Rutger Avenue EAST no level clear space, small button diameter, no signage

Oak Ridge Turnpike and N Rutgers Avenue NORTHboth pushbuttons on same pole, small button diameter, no level clear space, distance from curb, reach distance from PAR

Oak Ridge Turnpike and N Rutgers Avenue WESTno level clear space, reach distance from PAR, small button diameter, distance from curb, distance from PAR


S Illinois Avenue and Tuskegee Drive - island NE corner SOUTHWESTboth pushbuttons on same pole, no level clear space, operating force of pushbuttons

S Illinois Avenue and Tuskegee Drive - island NW corner SOUTHEAST both pushbuttons on same poleS Illinois Avenue and S Tulane Avenue - island SE corner NORTHWEST no level clear space, operating forceS Illinois Avenue and S Tulane Avenue - island SW corner NORTHEAST distance from curbOak Ridge Turnpike and N Tulane Avenue NORTHWEST no level clear spaceOak Ridge Turnpike and S Tulane Avenue SOUTHEAST no level clear space, pushbutton height, distance from crosswalkOak Ridge Turnpike and N Tulane Avenue NORTHEAST distance from PAR, distance from rampOak Ridge Turnpike and Oak Ridge High School Drive NORTHEAST no level clear spaceOak Ridge Turnpike and Oak Ridge High School Drive NORTHWEST both pushbuttons on same pole, no level clear spaceOak Ridge Turnpike and Oak Ridge High School Drive SOUTHWEST no level clear spaceNOTES: No pedestrian signals hAvenue been recently updated and, therefore, not required to meet all current st andaRoads. MUTCD 4E.08-4E.13 (08 is pushbuttons or passive detection devices, 09 is audible tones, 10 is location of pushbuttons, 11 is audible and vibrotactile indicators, 12 is tactile arrows and locator tones, and 13 is extended pushbutton features) and PROWAG R403 (clear spaces, operating force, and height) apply. Pedestrian signals are required to be updated to current MUTCD st andaRoads (2009) when the signal controller and software are altered or the signal head is replaced.


Appendix C

City Questionnaires

City-Wide Questionnaire Department Heads Questionnaire

Americans with Disabilities Act Self-Evaluation Program, Services, and Activities Questionnaire

Oak Ridge, Tennessee – City-Wide Survey

The ADA prohibits the denial of services or benefits to persons with disabilities. In the performance of common, every day services provided by local units of government, you must ensure that all services are available in some way to persons with all disabilities. To better allow us to understand each department’s interactions with the public, we request that you complete this questionnaire. Your responses are vital to ensuring that modifications can be made throughout the City to ensure access to all programs and services, if necessary. Please discuss with your staff as needed to provide thorough, complete, and accurate responses to each question. The information provided is intended to allow for changes throughout the City to provide equal access to programs and activities to everyone, without exception.

A. Provide a list of City Departments, responsibilities, and address of each. In addition, provide a brief description of the primary duties of each department and copies of any payments, publications, applications, forms, etc. that are used for each (electronic preferred).

B. List all appointed boards and commissions and when and where they meet.

C. Please provide a list of all locations and room(s) where public meetings are held.

D. Do all meeting rooms that hold public meetings have an audio system (microphones and speakers)? Do they have any assistive listening devices for the hearing impaired? If so, how many and what type.

E. Are meetings televised or provided in audio format? Are meetings recorded and rebroadcast? If so, what accommodations have been made for hearing impaired?

F. Is there a poster for “Equal Opportunity is the Law” that describes the requirements of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act located in all City buildings? If so, where (include all locations).

G. How are public meetings publicized? Are agendas posted in City Hall and on the web site? Do the agendas have an ADA statement of accommodation on them? Provide a typical copy of a recent agenda for all public meetings.

H. Please provide DLZ with a copy (electronic preferred) of the City’s Personnel Policy Manual(s), job descriptions, and Application(s) for Employment.


Oak Ridge, Tennessee Page 2

I. Provide a copy of the resolutions or ordinances, or meeting minutes associated with establishment

the ADA Coordinator, Non-Discrimination Notice, and Grievance Procedure.

J. Are you aware of any formal training of non-police and police personnel related to ADA specifically? If so, note who has taken training and the date, location, and provider of the training.

K. Are you aware of any instances where City staff has interacted with persons with disabilities and altered their normal procedures to accommodate them in some way? Please describe and be specific.

L. Has the City been requested to provide accommodation to any City employee with a disability (temporary or permanent) to allow them to perform their essential job functions? If so, please describe all requests and reasonable accommodation provided or reason for denial based on not being reasonable.

M. Do you allow any community groups, etc. to use City facilities for meetings, picnics, etc.? If so, provide a copy of any lease agreements.

N. Please list any special events that the City sponsors or participates in some way (parades, carnivals, flea markets, etc.). Include location of events, duration, etc. and any documentation you can so we can understand what happens for each.

O. Are emergency procedures in place at City facilities for evacuation in the event of an emergency? Are emergency assembly or shelter areas identified for each building? Please identify.

P. Has the City ever been asked to provide special accommodation to the public for printed materials? If so what was requested and provided?

Q. Do any City facilities have Telecommunication Devices for the Deaf (TDD) or access to a relay service to communicate to persons with hearing loss?



R. Who is the website developer for the City? How often is it updated? Who is the contact person to

discuss the website with (name and phone number/e-mail)?

S. Who at the City is the Human Resources person that would be responsible for ADA Title I? Name and contact information is needed.

T. Does the City own all the buildings that provide services to the public? Does the City lease or use space from other owners to provide services/programs to the public? Does the City lease any city-owned buildings to any public or private entity for their use? If yes for either, provide detail about the address, owner, and functions provided there. Also provide a blank copy of any lease agreements.

U. Please provide a copy of the City’s and/or County’s Emergency Management Plan. Provide name and contact info for person at EMA that can answer questions if needed in relation to the City’s participation and/or services received.

V. Some states require police officers to undergo annual training on disability issues as part on on-going continuing education, such as how to interact with people with mental illness, addictive disorders, mental retardation (intellectual disability), autism, and developmental disabilities. Have any officers completed this type of training? If so, when was the last training sessions held. Has anyone at the PD had any other formal training on interacting with persons with disabilities?

W. Are there any specific suggestions or thoughts anyone at the City has regarding how programs could

be made more accessible to persons with disabilities? Training you think would be especially helpful for anyone at the City?


Oak Ridge, Tennessee – Department Survey

The ADA prohibits the denial of services or benefits to persons with disabilities. In the performance of common, every day services provided by local units of government, you must ensure that all services are available in some way to persons with all disabilities. To better allow us to understand each department’s interactions with the public, we request that you complete this questionnaire. Your responses are vital to ensuring that modifications can be made throughout the City to ensure access to all programs and services, if necessary. Please discuss with your staff as needed to provide thorough, complete, and accurate responses to each question. The information provided is intended to allow for changes throughout the City to provide equal access to programs and activities to everyone, without exception.

Name of Department: ________________________ Contact Person: ___________________________

1. Provide a brief description of the primary duties and responsibilities of your department and blank copies of any publications, applications, forms, etc. that are provided to the public or internally to employees or prospective employees (electronic preferred). If some documents are typically provided by Human Resources, please provide only public documents and those not provided by HR.

2. Does your department sponsor Public Meetings? If no, please skip to #3: YES NO

a. Please state the locations where your meetings are held.

3. Accommodations:

a. Are you aware of any instances where your staff has interacted with persons with disabilities and altered their normal procedures to accommodate them in some way? Please describe and be specific.

b. Has your department ever been asked to provide special accommodation for printed materials? If so what was requested and provided?

c. Do you use Telecommunication Devices for the Deaf (TDD) or have access to a relay service to communicate to persons with hearing loss on the telephone?

4. Are emergency procedures in place in your department for evacuation in the event of an emergency? Are emergency assembly or shelter areas identified for your building? Please identify.

5. Are you aware of any formal training of staff in your department related to ADA specifically? If so, note who has taken training and the date, location, and provider of the training.



6. Are there any specific suggestions or thoughts anyone at the City has regarding how programs could

be made more accessible to persons with disabilities? Training you think would be especially helpful?

Appendix D

Public Outreach

Public Notices Proofs of Publication

Public Comments/Responses

January 16, 2020 Southeast ADA Center 1419 Mayson Street NE Atlanta, GA 30324 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.

We welcome your input to assist us on this project. All comments will be reviewed and considered and included in the final report. Please feel free to pass the information about this project on to others that you believe might be interested in providing input or comments. A copy of the draft Transition Plan will be made available for public review and comment prior to approval.

The city of Oak Ridge complies with the ADA and, upon request, will provide written materials in appropriate alternative formats, or disability-related modification or accommodation, including auxiliary aids or services, to enable individuals with disabilities to participate in public meetings. Please forward any comments, questions, or input to:

Stephen G. Metzer DLZ National, Inc.

1425 Keystone Avenue Lansing, Michigan 48911

(517) 908-4968 [email protected]

Please let me know if you have any questions and we look forward to your comments and questions.

Sincerely, Stephen G. Metzer, AICP, PWS Senior Planner/ADA Specialist

January 16, 2020 Disability Rights Tennessee 9050 Executive Park Drive, Suite 101-B Knoxville, TN 37923 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.








January 16, 2020 Tennessee Disability Coalition 955 Woodland Street Nashville, TN 37206 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.








January 16, 2020 The Arc of Tennessee 545 Mainstream Drive, Suite 100 Nashville, TN 37228-1213 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.








January 16, 2020 The Arc Anderson County P.O. Box 4823 Oak Ridge, TN 37831-4823 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.








January 16, 2020 Statewide Independent Living Council of Tennessee 2601 Elm Hill Avenue, Suite O Nashville, TN 37214 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.








January 16, 2020 disABILITY Resource Center 900 E. Hill Avenue, Suite 205 Knoxville, TN 37915 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.








January 16, 2020 National Federation of the Blind-Tennessee 4113 Tea Garden Way Antioch, TN 37013-5440 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.








January 16, 2020 Tennessee Council of the Blind 6010 Lilywood Lane Knoxville, TN 37921 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.








January 16, 2020 STEP – Support and Training for Exceptional Parents 712 Professional Plaza Greenville, TN 37745 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.








January 16, 2020 Tennessee Commission on Aging and Disability 502 Deaderick Street, 9th Floor Nashville, TN 37243-0860 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.








January 16, 2020 Tennessee Association of the Deaf P.O. Box 293385 Nashville, TN 37229 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.








January 16, 2020 Knoxville Center of the Deaf 3731 Martin Mill Pike Knoxville, TN 37920 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge is conducting a Self-Evaluation Study of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Title II also requires public outreach to the community, especially persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and advocacy groups for the disabled. The city of Oak Ridge is sending this letter to solicit public input and comment on barriers that exist, or are perceived to exist, to persons with disabilities to access city programs.








March 18, 2020 Southeast ADA Center 1419 Mayson Street NE Atlanta, GA 30324 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:


Comments can be provided, in writing, by the deadline of March 31, 2020, at 4 p.m. to Michael Smith, ADA Coordinator, at the Public Works Department at 100 Woodbury Lane or via e-mail at [email protected]. All comments will be reviewed and considered and included in the appendix of the document. It is the intention of the City to adopt the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan following the close of the public comment period and making any changes required as a result of public comments.

Oak Ridge is soliciting public input, especially from persons with disabilities, their caregivers, and disability advocates, on what barriers to access or use of city facilities or programs exist or are perceived to exist. This will also be an opportunity for the community to provide suggestions and comments on how to remove barriers. All comments will be reviewed and considered for inclusion in the final Transition Plan.

Oak Ridge complies with the Americans with Disabilities Act. Upon request, the city will provide written materials in appropriate alternative formats, or disability-related modification or accommodation, including auxiliary aids or services, to enable individuals with disabilities to participate in public input. Please send a written request, including your name, mailing address, phone number and brief description of the requested accommodation at least three (3) business days prior to the close of the comment period to the ADA Coordinator at (865) 425-1847 or [email protected].



March 18, 2020 Disability Rights Tennessee 9050 Executive Park Drive, Suite 101-B Knoxville, TN 37923 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:







March 18, 2020 Tennessee Disability Coalition 955 Woodland Street Nashville, TN 37206 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:







March 18, 2020 The Arc of Tennessee 545 Mainstream Drive, Suite 100 Nashville, TN 37228-1213 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:







March 18, 2020 The Arc Anderson County P.O. Box 4823 Oak Ridge, TN 37831-4823 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:







March 18, 2020 Statewide Independent Living Council of Tennessee 2601 Elm Hill Avenue, Suite O Nashville, TN 37214 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:







March 18, 2020 disABILITY Resource Center 900 E. Hill Avenue, Suite 205 Knoxville, TN 37915 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:







March 18, 2020 National Federation of the Blind-Tennessee 4113 Tea Garden Way Antioch, TN 37013-5440 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:







March 18, 2020 Tennessee Council of the Blind 6010 Lilywood Lane Knoxville, TN 37921 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:







March 18, 2020 STEP – Support and Training for Exceptional Parents 712 Professional Plaza Greenville, TN 37745 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:







March 18, 2020 Tennessee Commission on Aging and Disability 502 Deaderick Street, 9th Floor Nashville, TN 37243-0860 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:







March 18, 2020 Tennessee Association of the Deaf P.O. Box 293385 Nashville, TN 37229 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:







March 18, 2020 Knoxville Center of the Deaf 3731 Martin Mill Pike Knoxville, TN 37920 Dear Advocate for the Disabled, The city of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, has conducted a Self-Evaluation of all city-owned facilities and programs for compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and prepared a draft Transition Plan describing the results of the self-evaluation. Title II of the ADA requires that each of the city’s services, programs, and activities be readily accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. Copies of the Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan are available for public review at the following locations in Oak Ridge beginning on March 18, 2020, during normal business hours:







Appendix E

Forms and Notices

Title II Policy Statement Grievance Procedure

Example TDOT Grievance Form

NOTICE UNDER THE AMERICANS WITHDISABILITIES ACT

In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of1990 ("ADA"), the City of Oak Ridge will not discriminate against qualified individualswith disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or activities.

Employment: The City of Oak Ridge does not discriminate on the basis of disability in itshiring or employment practices and complies with all regulations promulgated by the U.S.Equal Employment Opportunity Commission under title I of the ADA.

Effective Communication: The City of Oak Ridge will generally, upon request, provide appropriate aids andservices leading to effective communication for qualified persons with disabilities so they can participate equallyin the City of Oak Ridge programs, services, and activities, including qualified sign language interpreters,documents in Braille, and other ways of making information and communications accessible to people who havespeech, hearing, or vision impairments.

Modifications to Policies and Procedures: The City of Oak Ridge will make all reasonable modifications topolicies and programs to ensure that people with disabilities have an equal opportunity to enjoy all of itsprograms, services, and activities. For example, individuals with service animals are welcome in the City of OakRidge offices, even where pets are generally prohibited.

Anyone who requires an auxiliary aid or service for effective communication, or a modification of policies orprocedures to participate in a program, service, or activity of the City of Oak Ridge, should contact the office ofMichael Smith, ADA Coordinator, at (865) 425-1847 or Mary Beth Hickman, City Clerk, at (865) 425-3411 orby email at [email protected] soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event.

The ADA does not require the City of Oak Ridge to take any action that would fundamentally alter the nature ofits programs or services, or impose an undue financial or administrative burden.

Complaints that a program, service, or activity of the City of Oak Ridge is not accessible to persons withdisabilities should be directed to Michael Smith, ADA Coordinator, at (865) 425-1847. Citizens may alsocontact the ADA information line at (865) 425-3579, or by email at [email protected].

The City of Oak Ridge will not place a surcharge on a particular individual with a disability or any group ofindividuals with disabilities to cover the cost of providing auxiliary aids/services or reasonable modifications ofpolicy, such as retrieving items from locations that are open to the public but are not accessible to persons whouse wheelchairs.

mailto:[email protected]


City of Oak Ridge

Grievance Procedure under

The Americans with Disabilities Act

This Grievance Procedure is established to meet the requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act

of 1990 ("ADA"). It may be used by anyone who wishes to file a complaint alleging discrimination on

the basis of disability in the provision of services, activities, programs, or benefits by the City of Oak

Ridge. The City of Oak Ridge’s Personnel Policy governs employment-related complaints of disability

discrimination.

The complaint should be in writing and contain information about the alleged discrimination such as

name, address, phone number of complainant and location, date, and description of the

problem. Alternative means of filing complaints, such as personal interviews or a tape recording of the

complaint, will be made available for persons with disabilities upon request.

The complaint should be submitted by the grievant and/or his/her designee as soon as possible but no later

than 60 business days after the alleged violation to:

Michael Smith

ADA Coordinator

Central Services Complex

100 Woodbury Lane

Oak Ridge, TN 37830

(865)425-3579

[email protected]

Within 15 business days after receipt of the complaint, the ADA Coordinator or the ADA Coordinator’s

designee will meet with the complainant to discuss the complaint and the possible resolutions. Within 15

business days of the meeting, the ADA Coordinator or the ADA Coordinator’s designee will respond in

writing, and where appropriate, in a format accessible to the complainant, such as large print, Braille, or

audio tape. The response will explain the position of the City of Oak Ridge and offer options for

substantive resolution of the complaint.

If the response by the ADA Coordinator or the ADA Coordinator’s designee does not satisfactorily

resolve the issue, the complainant and/or his/her designee may appeal the decision within 15 business

days after receipt of the response to the City Manager or the City Manager’s designee.

Within 15 business days after receipt of the appeal, the City Manager or the City Manager’s designee will

meet with the complainant to discuss the complaint and possible resolutions. Within 15 business days

after the meeting, the City Manager or the City Manager’s designee will respond in writing, and, where

appropriate, in a format accessible to the complainant, with a final resolution of the complaint.

All written complaints received by the ADA Coordinator or the ADA Coordinator’s designee, appeals to

the City Manager or the City Manager’s designee, and responses from these two offices will be retained

by the City of Oak Ridge for at least three years.

of 3 April 2019

Tennessee Department of Transportation

Instructions: Please complete and sign the form and submit it within calendar days ofany incident to:

ADA / Section 504 Coordinator – Margaret Z. Mahler

Physical address:

TDOT ADA / Section 504 CoordinatorADA Office

12th floor, James K. Polk Building505 Deadrick StreetNashville, TN 37243

Phone: (615) 741-4984Tennessee Relay: 7-1-1

Email: [email protected]

1. Type of Grievance (check all that apply):

Accommodation RequestProgram/ServiceFacility AccessibilityOther: ________________________________________________________________

2. Reporting Individual:

CONTACT INFORMATION

Full Name:

Address:

City, State, Zip code:

Phone: Alternate Phone:

Email:

of 3 April 2019

3. Authorized Representative of Reporting Individual (if any):Full Name:

Address:

City, State, Zip code:

Phone: Alternate Phone:

Email:

DETAILS OF COMPLAINT / INCIDENT

4. Date/Time of Incident:

5. Department/Facility/Location Involved:

6. Describe the incident/complaint with enough detail so the nature of the grievancecan be understood. Add additional pages if necessary:

7. Have attempts been made to resolve the complaint through a TDOT Department?If yes, please describe the efforts that have been made.

of 3 April 2019

8. Remedy Sought. What action do you want taken?

__________________________________________ _________________________________________ Signature Date

If you need assistance, require an accessible format, or have questions about this form, pleasecontact the TDOT ADA / Section 504 Coordinator at:

SUBMIT VIA EMAIL

ADA / Section 504 Coordinator – Margaret Z. Mahler

Physical address:

TDOT ADA / Section 504 CoordinatorADA Office

12th floor, James K. Polk Building505 Deadrick StreetNashville, TN 37243

Phone: (615) 741-4984Tennessee Relay: 7-1-1

Email: [email protected]


Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan - City of Oak Ridge

Documents

Transcript of Self-Evaluation and Transition Plan - City of Oak Ridge