Gathered Wild Food Plants among Diverse Religious Groups ...
“Response to Freudenthal, \"'Let the Waters be Gathered!' between 'Torah' and 'Science' in the...
-
Upload
independent -
Category
Documents
-
view
3 -
download
0
Transcript of “Response to Freudenthal, \"'Let the Waters be Gathered!' between 'Torah' and 'Science' in the...
i e i' i = i ii?z E\Vl ?
g E=TvElTIeii=? i Z?;1V71: : I
;+g1==?;*E7= ; *;*giL=rs,qs-ii:=;1 = F;; i33 iiE;€++izi igi: E-=Zi ;iSEZE\\;E*=,? z7.d 1:\EE
;EFiEE ; i i: =_\z+=:l=E;=:7 VE,7? iE. E=, Z?= i:+Fiq *i ii{iit ti,;; rgEiEs;gEaAt;iEf t ;fli3igii|i =rr lazi: /*E T'=-i7?i1 ;E r i+i i t1=_VVE_?Zi lsic it1li i+: X?g EiiE 'liiaIi ?t*f iii:e I
iit =;+i!
s==F i i7==iaa;xv;EZ !iiatz-e2€ i1 zt7zl: 7??r;,iiE?E 15 7a1=14 ;? ri?, =;ii:;5 ;eFE:: r
=z = += ??V=t7i?F:=77=E-??= A=,7?Zie??
;i* 1E = aE a +=T1iii.;Tai=?;1778 '7j*7158?
i*1 ?iEe? 7 iEEit?==E ';iE z: rz ,
?2, irltE i;1**l lii,?1rili t;l'!i,?ii
p - ci J 3! o -o ci < = : a- = = = $ o lD = o I J ax -: =.O TO o >vrta s =.= q qF@; - I i 't X:i:? +*6717-L===g?;l==;Eaztz: e ;aS,E= :=E7qa=io -{'''a4-- -=aeE eE1'{i_ E p=_c _?,;=,'
=t;g:i=i 7.i:= g *c4*; i=gi:3gl-?E, 4a=.-=7ia3 ls
73!1 Eitlii=-.1i=;i ;+Z7A ii =1?€ i 52.tL3 = r 3,;'tli r;e ; i I ;=i-E='l *?-;e?ci5:' * -: Ye"{is =-iza ii2i7?r:i.:-3=ez+;+E ? *d\o^-=l->=s,oisjg€€g=!6alj;iiggea -llgirS r"3=pri+=,2e=6:=a:Eda=:,'; 5
;iis iiEIi:;r€;:iiE+aeEi=++i -{;1s-: :-;7 !:E=sl=_zia;;=1i?p=? ?.'e E 9g::i _-Er;f;F=Ta?g i=Zi="?+,? $i g € #.$ F rlreS' irutlrlis+eigclal ;=q i si z i=-Z1z{;7! =i'- = ^; { e :' e
=$t z =;6r-n= -"8-.t.39H€AgS;413€; f i-"i===;=l=V=,r7=Ai;;15j TJ2 V i-i;E=2=+ -'s+-{:=ti;3'F" r :=4=-:7223.=1;;::,. 1=riEi -Ud:. [ :iRAa[g*l+9,"a?:;;;a.lil j ]
= i r qaag;f da* ir='?:s;n;:ra Er4 ? + :9"; :iiiEV+=j=gZzi =r3i r{; F 1 dilE' *6-.Fe*3e==4r. ==.6:98'
z =; i F +i ;a ??7+;ii*e7:+:=,s=9=+ sJs 5 7 7;'-. €a=E6--
' 6 F o--e sd-peseA-;i5;j-(i;,=A; E:
5 u ; E';
=,;=d ariE=!:i=1ii76aqe ?E -11E=7lli 6E:E1rr x:'+; E i:iE *: il 1l?!;iE 1F ii'ila=lfTv:i7i ' =r 1' -.sie=i?r714Ei igiiAf=€$1i|i\eljfi i33
s ri €iaitia+z=i??iz3aiirri;, iFr; iF+i**E
i ii iiai;s1#=€ rfiSiE:s rIiieialllFciig'i ;$ sr+;;i;3 itgq;i5ii5;sri€E;3i?Ei;=;'; ?i iFllsi;= =);;;iE+;!=e'€;;6;F=t2L]$!'Y,/ ; a s r + i le E: E'iiEEr-!iii-;F|?Eii+i1|?7li
i
A aS ];y-S a: 3 r 7 r 1^' == eE =;i = a 1!:E':; ?= a i.e *:7F,, 1E ?iii F E 3; i=Z?=?i 5 ? tv t ?E,zE?iii:li-l1 5q t!:*lirt E=5;,;a+Ei+*;E;Atu*;;E=-={eg#i ia F3Eii;i; E;i-!EiE+?7=,F ii:FiEi;iEE?1 ?? lF I ; 1 r; I E=12'; ; i=i-=iz+';t z =zTizi =u:+:? :'i+e+as l+twE; ;;lt="+;izil ig?';E:
=i==ry<F: i ioiiiTi'" 2 "z e < ? : =
F Fg g'di7 - fi * a --i Iii$i;ii$i 3 *5f lg 1t+r= s 1;'ii+i ;'=;ii'r* srt+ii,51 =, i ; i : i + i
= E 7 ? =t-|a='aiiEi==! E?,;:€=?= ? $ ?; i ;
;EiiFeii= +ziE r i + ; + iii-' a+iiia+jll?,a i iF ; i I6Ii ".=s=SS ; d:1ce ='==7 s'e€ :; o p s = 6 - < a
:'ii;aa$a F I;l iFe 4'= i;;; i i t g b 1 *ig $E'=E : s * 4 4q l,Lsrils i = i i=
= i =# 7i= ;E3 ?-:: ;-ias aF 13=1 i$3;F
= iitna i+= 7=:?6i i 3 'i =: =: ?: iiz I i =g: = z 7 z- =- i 2!ia7J=;-_!.j;i*-:7;7E==i71:ii€=.1;:1vE*i7;ic>a tFiiSlee; i;=;-i '. Z 6,==r- ==
i " c i';- !72 * Eleit_ jf t_ = -. r==a=; T+ I= tfl=: i,-:
=z= 7== := 73 != *E i sqe r ! + i - ? x. ! *tli a j;: + q i e a
= i-,= =i'it i 2'?!; --r
e
= s4=1i-rr z;i 5 r: =zi* f =,,i; i?_=A C; {&; =t2=7.:i i€ ;'i"{ rsJ ++=ei i =;t€E; ZZi?iE+-=aiE:;; i=arS3 'e s F*=3i rl aF ? E t r ?E?'j 7"i i 1= = e
= i=:
= =i:; + j t S g= iit 9;-i i- 3 ==7: i: i7' i;i +! --== Z z== -zi zr = t; : =-
F il r r +$ -
Et=ii 3i i+E iu t i;iiliE:!{iZ1;Tl r I,=- i i: i = i zvi: : -="
='7'; ;:7i1ziir7zE:t= z1r1 s ir 1S; : : i';.7 i+rt; 55r 1 g i*-€' ;iS i?== ?L+zi :i-rc-C iE E
= =e { r = s :3 =i3 ,? S
: 'ii
! i v?i|iil=? ;it;1!?ii7=iZii +z; t3 l
a
'i;gE*=?t gg?i!}ri??; ii3g5=a; z
rrA' !a1 ii ;i*l iE !{al1*ugl igEi+E
5
1i5; TaEl*: i+i*sii*art; t+*;;i g ;i7=*? ?==
I =ar i,!;1+{1?i?i1+7!1i2i
?izV ?7-?vE r??E ; ; 1i ?+ ??:?i7i=i,j,
iiEE sFil* g silili #rl?{a;E1Eli ?
lgE- $aa€zi E=;' s3 g;iai+.tliaEii[1ii=e 1 r!+1, i l;iie ti+ZE,=iii-li I + +;*!; i;: iFi iP: i;i?+iisiiil:3-ig
=i t ?.7; ='F. -g ?5-: +=<-<+:7z-= i,'jd.! tElaa 3: ==A3] ii 1F=E;=:tlo9ii*:34 =!Brr *4fl5, i€ Ei'* ;i;,€3i+:*:*;i $
6ai@ i:sr3:!L-g!'a:,s*= - -mtsi6 o3.,\+--... s ! 6 5ii R'E +' :
^- o
3*l qr\^o
-::vk iG ?Fs"9iliRsai* '' r
X,RFI+ # *:k;i!=^ < G :"() X + LN I -a++>6'i o \Nc+d-oi.<^
<Et:>3a*''54
ad=a
e z't 4
Y @a-:@-i-!r*.
:49:-:
^' !3.iD'P=
<3o-q+E *.96Oos?'t? -a
= "- >-:; Fi==*€ii ;i7 Ef TE.Aa.o=J;#:lrFr it; l Tc i e i ii?39: ri: Fg3i a 3 :*7Ei"iv;il$iii E z F:ai 1i E=I;=='$;F :i1i i1 !iEi?"12. i9ri=:Ei -1r=1>ig::isiii={ t7 r e : F
=
tr 1 i= ii:l 1 F
=?Z/tTEEii:iE'i Ei<Srlar = R ;
=.2)i z F =€
q a P ii a = ; i E = E: g t; =:; ; = =. I
=i ill= = t
=;_; i9=
=T - =E= 3i= i==V=E E:=-i 7=lui "7
l;=i ri ? = ; =ili?=7V?===ii 3 =7=?i;E ==Erz:=* ?
i:;li3 :; ?E ii3F V,??i?=ia =;F91:
;\Ela ;E1a :::+e+: ;i iei?!'=_?:i;5;s=== a*[;i6ix*,:r? t7b-b= 13; :2zi_+t=E
=: +=717=37i2iE S i +q iza=;i,Ev?:+i
= 1r\?=i," i s qH€aa{ i*E:liiE;; 1€c Ei==F1E:i E':;iii; ft 1. i4+,: 4i =;: :?i-+Ei="*"EZ=ie
= = zi = ==; F =; aV ;i=:ii :;
=;87?iZ=iE=,7i;ii z:iiii7_?i:+! i;+7;: i .t ia=i==+i/Ei"a*t; j;; =7:;s=i€: ?:?=i+ ;; ?;;i7=7iri==1ir7 zE=;i_7tEc-=z= :;rSe:r ?- 1'^E==7i=:E-=il;1 ;Es u j,-,Eiaii 1s3P*i la=15li ;l ?9i =??Zr F: v.i,+ il [ € i rE
= I ;==?iti !ii=j- r I ; :ei?ii: gizz=i: 1 +',igef3F3;=z a
sg s 11 a:A1;i ;'?!3Eg tE: iJ+c::1i+iii ; i
L . =i
i =: : iiE iiii i; iiii11=,i7. 7 7 ?,,,, !rqsr=i??r:a!iiligi!i ep 4 = ; qE t-= =Z;;e! ; =7 ?ii I E
i =i =: =e=i
; :_ilT Ei,E =J E9 1 1 = *7:=,i= g i + ie';ilii
= :.nl; +--- P='= =lgii=="'=il Yrydp ::+ i, i _ =, : i = =
=: ?j ==V?Z?
-,' ?i :ZE!;l ;, >V =V'|t i'i!i r=ris :; ira; iE€i{V;!:=?TEgEzni: +at;1s; rsiii ia ^=fi*;3f:*1elie=;A?.C:EFi s=:;:E
: ii*ii ii iia="EElili l3dFiF iai=i €-id€i?: =r S= ii ri?r =i=:F*Z'=",ir? =;z=i F:r_=L7+= r= i: i! f1;a, E1;Bi=Es1u=7 iqi_7i- ',rEE?Sii i= ti r+ ;Fai E+;:9;1:f1E! lF33F ;E?i1iii:ii is ii:i ialf5;; lrsE=-=#€i;i s;{-==7t= rs 7;- =t s:;= i€n=luuii;E;Egi ii!:, 5;Fsl:S :F +i S.=ili fi il iils EFiili;i:?Ei liael ?Ez;! sHs ti i= fi :;;; ;t;ValiTiEri
=,ii=; li1iit= 3= -r r-;"iAA= V6Z-ia:iuii; F=iva;- =E{=Er
'- 1< Fs sFt ti ii li =i:-l i?>F7;i;37=,iV :=s1i Z=;i1E
I G ; : 5 ; Ef FF iB;s qJESF<!==f !tit?-?7;?i!?i?7. F)i<- !z=72 !i7.=;Zs i - : " a 2c i z z_/ ;i Ii_'> gJ "-- E-E 1= t_E j,t
= 3s" ry
== = i E + 5 i1=:tr=:s7+Fl=oiEh-::<)=:ir=;ia=.2 :iEl Vl'.. - dsio s=-l-."8
==*:l)--E==!2.:''&i= i-7 -"' l-ts p.g9o =!l.a =6V'2- crrA=f=+iE=.-z'3+id'i' 1z : F-d Sj = = ; R i: =n^=;= ; :=-i?.7 -:2!.= tL-a._61!ii i= =.i a'7=2 i i---F
= :':,-.&-- ; {i s;s;i?iiieii;E: is isi? itts Figr Ssi3gt Es+ F 1 r 1 r ?": i", A Z a- Z'i = =-\ = i 2_ = i' X: ;:SJi=7-it::E;sqSl; ir=d *eia ItSi::i;VZ jp
S igip:1=?-;=?=<q*,x; ie5: i2 ji iASS-Fali=; :sE* 1=zil$rl;aq.==E;:<i --'''4 >-"rf'r =---- Ro-ia6F Es., ii=7===zglti:Ee3+i :1t.; s;td Z1i5 Siia€; ii: ;iii=7a3== le's'*=t5 *E*= 3ff ; e!sn iir-n=5 F"':t i.iiEti'z-E+iii=iit :=== ==E? iiii iA:i7i'=?i=
-ES--7a=.,8_==j iFS i'.J-e =1.?. +lS-- i-jia=7 S 7"F=* i=l=Ei3*n lg= i: x=i iF'q*"'=Sni Si;EE; S 5
=31 e+<3=_6i--s ';F ='+i ) =; i;* $"a77; t1?a i-V;27;ri rts ?7t= ii;i iAi is;F;= iEvi 1 7zz;=ii 11u= ==1=1='7= i>1 ui=i7 l ?rx? + :=z7E?? 1t_1 alEi:13= ily s:=E?." 7Ttsr * =-+
t=1 i t?i; t:i 121 1;iv iiE:.- :;: is iE=_il ?F = i :-i1;5; L =- =-€l 7=il g1:1ie:;=
=i : : <=ji1=^u I 3
= 1ii Z+=l r!l =-roi_=
?: : ; =.:?1.:l.i = 't ?-2.=.ri
F : i :i1i?ii g 7 iil,,' li! 3ll 5 i9 13 ; r
?++EitFFTi++4??i i+ r
E":=i =iiVEi ;:'ti"A 2 ?-3- t "",= ac 7?3 7 : a
7 ?a uti,al?tliE iF3 1 a iF i;e ;eieEe aF
;:;:F ili€ qiF?5rH irs;E+tt ltiFi tE
E=?!1 g F E{ii i i g i i I a ;rE*==ii : I i !i=j 5--=i {v;7E : a1=gg 4=s7??= -*i=;-" i:rE€:; ;*7?;aFlc r;F gii€i+A;ip fi #l a=tt i =-= ?.-=+E7zE,i
====_v r
= g?272 ;9 !.Er' =_ c3iE_,tJ!E;a=': ==iE>=:d=- <; EE .
s F: =/L?=u=*i-'==g ac a t=!; i i E!;:ia, EE j
7 c -.? r = r-
= i i;Eil;r7
=7 Z
-li=="l ==7
i a ; itriE;1,t-*=1 f +g;3a FFi=,fi!Ei1=?fr 3;Ci;_€EFii;ligE3:* ;sl:Fiir=q=F Es
E1TT ir ???\zz+===E IE:I*ZF ii;Ee 1;:._s 1s= s?1;E F9 sli E 9;=1:Ea++:;i-ia* 3 r! *P€ : * !l€ E :E*;E-s i2a * a a ;E c * { : 6 ;1F. s ii1?.:u;E ;atE1 i ;
!:n@=>6^P=>'-:+-;;E-+d;iA-L ! FIE @ *: :- Z f.
=., 2 =i6:-i,4:i:i.>qaT
= ot ^ fr^:-p * 5;ab';:-;:a.,6!
=< + a Y u'
"'b1=^\--.iaa77Lar;n u 9T_+! o o 'J - l
'Ftrodaura."6gs 9:-= * -S d i a6'o3^"O-9'a,^2m9,jo Y.',= ^ ; !'':=.-913 E d rQ *
! -=6ma=2;;G+v;\Xc;gs:!x=.
=a@-:t@\ d q:i<
:;3:,'-^-:vA.5 g.<d:A!Jo!: - < t-,- J 5= 6
zEzlEzTElE=E7zlrzl7tzE?#6EszllEltgi
: a i ? t!,,zi1iiV7+7' lli ?
EElilrgliEBi{,?E ?Ei€ii Fari r
iilE ?f a t:s!1E\tz7t1?iE t t titEattziil,iilz:ii +le'iiIf ' ?E:i
iggit1iE;l{zi'#*t?tef;i;*zi
N
szs'a't-
i-
:d6:?\c-!lb
(<
R. E.s.?r@
t.:os
^o-?,
=?
m:-o E.
9='d
pNp
p € { \o\oQ
ctr-Y-\t:rE9+zj;=jugii-.4_3_ir-nd:-,21r-€€J:6:!i I * y J j ; + 3-E f r Y -'; sE j squ. : V j g S j d X =z ij; s , = ; ; Y i j J :
3g i .J i : g i i, J I L ssj I j=di z =g + ? = s -.5 i :'q; i Du Y i i d =r_l A i 3 5Jz = EY s i 4 Y $; S5= E ;d S ;S -- l- g; g ,+ { -. i-r.J-it: 2 us j :: =s f -J; 3 l-3 s j =s-' Y -{ t Y,i 3." 3. ;E ; €I d; li* : ij i lE *u 4 ir s i:i == !
\:l€Giiiurrjj-=-Jl.{'E€YZdJlJZv*,=r:;,-:rs),-9!G€J&
3-n.i=Jc-r I ---t €Jfr
)rJ\r:JUi?iEu'r{;'ir"{iqJa"
3tsJ
ub-J\o
€\)a-
"l >.i
Y3oilAJ6
^62fl
zNlJ!9ii: :r=F q
ctg1 J3d nz-rY \J.az zEJ Es:JoG JAciLrJ-:JE\f+Y i_t,z= iJ Yv z .J.*-_J -. J
:1 d-j{s} ifd.z-= 8:.rzE: -dEJg gd.i {r C i}J4= udq J" r "r-gq: 3'au;Y zJ1:ii 2=-
:I:x9- .f\t i- :Jj=i € qo-€ '-r zJG- i r+jg 4, ldJv=Pe\I.-ulJiJr r = i IE3* j.-, ,; j
= q \c X <
d\i-:. \t Jj=Y s 5 s + a;ss-i 4 {4JJ U Tv.,\t-Jtrq- 5 -Jq-ii :I :rIi!-t i {':r€z -\, :J-r.lou j j*ij g :J!=
jUJ
oY9r; CJ€42-c=r+:- OUcfJAuzUA.i,-ivl!JJZttdu{oJOSU-lar:'J+:r
D|O6GUJ*
:.tfU
Fj\
*!
i+.,-\nE.\\\l\tie:d--=-,i*
xe)'t
s€,!l
i\i\(\\ '\I E\\etbs'33_;ts\,?t\lL*$'..3so'S
,$r
+R\Rii- xb**;$LSE-(i*i { ; },'l\,it u'$rI$*irt\''i \ i\i't
.' .t+Lr4 *t.bffii
z, i,;:lj: ii y;
dy gl:g;: t;iza, ? zalsi=99:;1 i ci;il;;il;ji E Y;;Ez=isl;g v 9*ilyiii :*5t 7 :=?,;;lil=g: a i=+iEESllj u = :J rrJ r - i < = -:
sq 7 I;i3rjitv5g i ggq:{,-:r:;;5t *' i r=;l;\:i?Zle +** liy[ig"ji+i;= ?l;g[; ;=:i;:it s r"=q €l;e yii j €X
*Ed s35;: cr;vs .*Ql t
s*g
iJ
NP6Ua
j3_-9u sil
6iY:ls iE:J -E:J -i :Jg 1uq €i; UJ-Jv
J-i.r9:J:lrrg
=jI ,jJ-J-<J rc Ltutj:-i uJ
J.Jd.i rf :J ll{; sE
IUJ:J:J
:Ju\'€:J
-J:f:ZJ-tr liJ€V.E:JE:JJ
IJN@@\oq
XN-xg=X
{\'Uc,f,UJ
fGN4J'J :Jrr ttJ.t\rjlJ-L'=J(:Ua
:JTJJEU
3u\f\fU -"- ! .rrr J4 ; X *,i U -r: --i .''-x -E -i E d
"i E d; q irc,i .: -f i iy-J 4. i-J - .J.l Lt { --!-J itJtzlcrezur4z