Organic Pollutants Removal from Petroleum Refinery Wastewater with Nanotitania Photo-catalyst and...
Transcript of Organic Pollutants Removal from Petroleum Refinery Wastewater with Nanotitania Photo-catalyst and...
Journal of Innovative Engineering Dheeaa al deen A. Aljuboury et al., Journal of Innovative Engineering 2014, 2(3):5
Journal of Innovative Engineering ISSN: 2347-7504
Article Type: Research Article
Organic Pollutants Removal from Petroleum Refinery Wastewater with
Nanotitania Photo-catalyst and solar irradiation in Sohar Oil Refinery
Dheeaa al deen A Aljuboury1*
, Puganeshwary Palaniandy1, Hamidi Bin Abdul Aziz
1 and Shaik
Feroz2
1School of Civil Engineering, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Malaysia
2Caledonian College of Engineering, Oman
*Corresponding author: Dheeaa al deen A Aljuboury, School of Civil Engineering, Universiti Sains Malaysia,
14300 Nibong Tebal, Seberang Perai Selatan, Pulau Pinang, Malaysia, Email: [email protected]
Received September 01, 2014; Accepted October 20, 2014; Published November 04, 2014
Citation: Dheeaa al deen A Aljuboury, Puganeshwary Palaniandy, Hamidi Bin Abdul Aziz and Shaik Feroz (2014)
Organic Pollutants Removal from Petroleum Refinery Wastewater with Nanotitania Photo-catalyst and solar
irradiation in Sohar Oil Refinery. Journal of Innovative Engineering 2(3): 5
Copyright: © 2014 Dheeaa al deen A Aljuboury et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of
the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any
medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Abstract
Nowadays, there are increasingly stringent regulations requiring more and more treatment of industrial effluents to
generate product waters which could be easily reused or disposed to the environment without any harmful effects. In
the present study, Photo-catalytic activities of Titanium dioxide (TiO2 P25) under sunlight processes are
investigated through laboratory experiments as an alternative to conventional secondary treatment for the organic
content reduction of high Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) wastewater from Petroleum Refinery Wastewater plant
in Sohar Oil Refinery and develop a batch photo-catalytic reactor and continuous reactor under same condition and
evaluate their efficiency. This research addresses the photo degradation efficiency of Chemical Oxygen Demand
(COD) and Total Organic Carbon (TOC) and the generation of hydroxyl radicals using the Sunlight/TiO2 system.
All experiments are conducted to investigate the effects of parameters such as, catalyst dosage, initial concentration
of COD and TOC, initial pH and irradiation time under sunlight and also the industrial effluent is characterized.
Experimental results revealed that the photo-catalytic activity of the TiO2 for the COD removal efficiency is highest
with using 1gm/l TiO2 dosage. Optimization of catalyst dose, pH and COD concentration has been done. A
maximum COD removal of 85% from the effluent is achieved in 240 min. The percentage removal of TOC reaches
to a maximum for a catalyst loading of 1.5gm/L which is 18% in 300 minutes of reaction time period. It can be used
as a treatment step in the high organic wastewater treatment during the primary stage.
Keywords: Photo-catalysis; Sunlight; Hydroxyl radical; TiO2; COD degradation; TOC degradation
Journal of Innovative Engineering Dheeaa al deen A. Aljuboury et al., Journal of Innovative Engineering 2014, 2(3):5
Journal of Innovative Engineering ISSN: 2347-7504
1. Introduction
Industrial wastes, sewage and a wide array of synthetic chemicals, pollute considerable parts of water resources. The
elimination of toxic chemicals from wastewater is presently one of the most important aspects of pollution control.
Recently, considerable attention has been focused on complete oxidation of organic compounds to harmless
products of CO2 and H2O by the advanced oxidation processes. Photo-catalysis is a promising technique for the
treatment of contaminated water and groundwater, which has been widely studied in recent years because it was fast,
effective, eco-friendly, economically viable and able to completely oxidize organic molecules at a low energy cost
[3]. In fact, many studies on photo-catalytic degradation of pollutants by TiO2 upon illumination with sunlight have
been reported. The solar photo-catalytic wastewater treatment is based on reactive free potent chemical oxidants
such as the hydroxyl radical [1]. Upon absorption of light energy that is equal to or greater than band gap energy, the
electrons in the valence band of the semiconductors such as TiO2 can be excited to those in the conduction band,
leaving a positive hole in the valence band [1]. The positive hole is a strong oxidant, which can oxidize compound
directly or react with the electron donors in the environment such as water or hydroxide ions to form hydroxyl
radicals (OH) that are also potent oxidants [1].
The aim of this paper is to develop a method of solar photo-catalytic oxidation of synthetic high organic waste water
in Sohar Oil Refinery, Oman by TiO2/Sunlight which it is investigated in batch reactor and continuous reactor under
same condition. Wastewater with a high COD of the order of more than 1000 mg/L is treated. The effects of
parameters like optimum catalyst doses, pH and actual initial concentration of COD have also been investigated. A
wide range of organic compounds are detected in high organic wastewater in Sohar Oil Refinery, so, the study will
lead to a possibility of implementation of solar photo-catalytic process as a treatment step for high organic
wastewater in Sohar Oil Refinery, Oman.
2. Experimental Procedure:
2.1 Materials and Methods
The laboratory tests are performed using the pretreated refinery wastewater samples (after coagulationand flotation
units) from Sohar Oil Refinery. The samples of raw effluent are collected from the point that the wastewater is just
leaving the dissolved air flotation (DAF) and just into the biological treatment unit in wastewater treatment plant at
Sohar petroleum refinery. The catalyst is TiO2 Aeroxide P-25 (manufactured by Evonik Industries Co in Germany),
and it is used for the photo-catalytic degradation and 150-ml beakers are used as batch reactors. A magnetic plate is
used to stir the TiO2-wastewater solution. All the photo-reaction experiments are performed under ambient
conditions on Caledonian College of Engineering campus, located in Sultanate of Oman. In most parts of Oman,
clear sunny weather is experienced 250 to 300 days a year this makes Oman a suitable site for the solar-based
treatment processes. The solar radiation intensity was 650 W/m2 during maximum experimental runs. All the
experiments are carried out in a concentrating solar collector with a parabolic trough reflector. The photo-reactor
used is two transparent borosilicate glass tubes with 38 mm internal diameter, 0.5 m length. The system is shown in
Figure 1. It maintains the turbulent conditions and there is no mass transfer limitation. It is a nearly closed system no
vaporization of volatile compounds takes place. The initial simulated volume of wastewater is 2 L for photo-
Journal of Innovative Engineering Dheeaa al deen A. Aljuboury et al., Journal of Innovative Engineering 2014, 2(3):5
Journal of Innovative Engineering ISSN: 2347-7504
catalytic experiments. The reactor volume was 1 L. TiO2 is added in the form of a suspension with an initial sample
of the wastewater. The time period of experiments is up to 360 minutes.
Figure 1: Schematic diagram of photo-reactor model (Continuous reactor) used for Sunlight/TiO2 in Organic
Pollutants Removal from Petroleum Refinery Wastewater
Figure 2: Schematic diagram of photo-reactor model (Batch reactor) used for Sunlight/TiO2 in Organic
Pollutants Removal from Petroleum Refinery Wastewater
Journal of Innovative Engineering Dheeaa al deen A. Aljuboury et al., Journal of Innovative Engineering 2014, 2(3):5
Journal of Innovative Engineering ISSN: 2347-7504
2.2 Analytical procedure and characterization of the industrial effluent
The physicochemical characteristics of pretreated refinery wastewater samples (after coagulation and flotation units)
from Sohar Oil Refinery used for the study are given in Table (1). A Shimadzu TOC analyzer (LCSH/CSN) is used
to measure the TOC for each sample. Chemical oxygen demand (COD) is measured by COD photometer. pH is
monitored regularly throughout the experiment. pH levels are monitored by using a digital pH meter. COD is
estimated before and after treatment.
Table 1: Simulated influent concentration in the pretreated refinery wastewater samples (after coagulation
and flotation units) from Sohar Oil Refinery
No. Parameter Unit Concentration in row
wastewater
1 pH --- 6.5 -9.5
2 Conductivity mg/l 2.60 - 2.95
3 TDS ppt 1.2 – 1.5
4 D.O. mg/l 0.6 – 4.9
5 COD ppm (mg/l) 550 - 1600
6 TOC ppm 220- 265
2.3 Photo-catalytic reaction process
The photo catalytic degradation of COD and TOC in an industrial effluent is studied in a glass reactor. It is placed
outside in order to display to sunlight.
2.4 Batch Process
In a batch reactor, the reactants are charged into a container, well mixed, and are left to react for a certain period
(Figure 2). The effects of the pH, initial COD concentration and amount of catalyst on photo-degradation of COD
are investigated and optimal conditions are found out. Experiments on photo-degradation of COD using TiO2 under
sunlight are carried out.
2.5 Continuous Process
Continuous experiments (Figure 1) are carried out by taking the optimum parameters such as pH and dosage of
catalyst obtained from batch experiments. The flow rate of 5 L/min and 3 L/min are tried and dosage of catalyst
1g/L is used for period of 6 hr. the efficiency of COD degradation is analyzed.
3. Results and Discussion
3.1 Batch Process
3.1.1 Effect of TiO2 loading on photo-catalytic degradation of COD using solar irradiation: Photo-catalytic
degradation of COD in industrial waste water effluent from Sohar Oil Refinery is studied by varying the catalyst
loading from 0.1gm/L to 1.5gm/L. A set of experiments are conducted under sun light with the industrial effluent
and samples are filtered before the analysis. The catalyst concentration (TiO2) is varied as 0.1, 0.25, 0.5, 1, and 1.5
Journal of Innovative Engineering Dheeaa al deen A. Aljuboury et al., Journal of Innovative Engineering 2014, 2(3):5
Journal of Innovative Engineering ISSN: 2347-7504
g/L to obtain an optimum concentration to be used for further experiments. Based on the COD values, the photo
catalytic degradation efficiency is calculated by using the equation:
Where:
X; photo-catalytic degradation of COD
[COD]0 and [COD]t stand the initial and after any irradiation time, COD values.
Figure 3: Effect of TiO2 loading on photo-catalytic degradation of COD using Solar Irradiation in industrial
waste water effluent from Sohar Oil Refinery
The results are shown in Figures (3,4). Generally, an increase in catalyst concentration results in a very rapid
increase in degradation, which confirms to a heterogeneous regime [10]. The low photo-catalytic reaction rate at
catalyst loading of 0.1gm/L is due to less availability of active sites. The photo-catalytic degradation is observed to
increase as the catalyst loading increases. At a catalyst concentration (TiO2) of 0.5 g/L under sunlight, the photo-
catalytic degradation of COD is 46% in 240 minutes of reaction time and On increasing the concentration of catalyst
to 1 g/L, 48% COD removal is observed in same time. The percentage removal of COD reaches to a maximum for a
catalyst loading of 1gm/L. This rise in percentage of COD removal may be explained by increase in concentration of
TiO2 increases the number of active sites on the photo-catalyst surface, which in turn increases the number of OH°
radicals [6].
However, a reverse effect occurs when the TiO2 concentration increases to higher than the optimum value, the
degradation rate declines due to the interference of the light by the suspension [8,9]. The large number of active sites
is with the increase of catalyst loading upto1gm/L, the rate of radical formation in the aqueous solution increases.
Journal of Innovative Engineering Dheeaa al deen A. Aljuboury et al., Journal of Innovative Engineering 2014, 2(3):5
Journal of Innovative Engineering ISSN: 2347-7504
For to high catalyst loading beyond 1.0 upto1.5gm/L, No significant increase is observed for 1.5g/L of TiO2. It may
be due to light scattering effect and reduction in light penetration through the effluent due to the obstruction of large
number of solid particles [6,7].
3.1.2 Effect of TiO2 loading on photo-catalytic degradation of TOC using solar irradiation (Batch reactor).
Photo-catalytic degradation of TOC in industrial waste water effluent from Sohar Oil Refinery is studied by varying
the catalyst loading from 0.5gm/L to 1.5gm/L. A set of experiments are conducted under sun light with the industrial
effluent and samples are filtered before the analysis. The catalyst concentration (TiO2) is varied as 0.1, 0.25, 0.5, 1,
and 1.5 g/L to obtain an optimum concentration to be used for further experiments.
Based on the TOC values, the photo catalytic degradation efficiency of TOC is calculated by using the equation:
Where:
X; photo-catalytic degradation of TOC
[TOC]0 and [TOC]t; stand the initial and after any irradiation time, TOC values.
The results are shown in Figures (5 and 6). Generally, it is observed in this study that the catalyst loads have a
positive effect on the adsorption. This is because of the larger catalyst surface available for adsorption. the photo-
catalytic degradation is observed to increase as the catalyst loading increases and The results of photo-catalytic
degradation efficiency of TOC at 5 hours are from 12, 14 and 18% for the catalyst (TiO2) concentrations 0.5, 1, and
1.5 g/L respectively as shown in figure 5.
The percentage removal of TOC reaches to a maximum for a catalyst loading of 1.5gm/L which was 18% in 300
minutes of reaction time period. This rise in percentage of TOC removal may be explained by increase in
concentration of TiO2 increases the number of active sites on the photo-catalyst surface, which in turn increases the
number of OH° radicals [6]. After that, The TiO2 adsorption capability show a decrease of 4 % at 60 minutes
because The TOC concentrations increasing trend indicate desorption of cationic species from the catalyst surface.
Higher TiO2 load has a negative effect on the photo-catalytic degradation due to the higher slurry turbidity, which
did not allow the penetration photons of the reactor inner zones [11].
Journal of Innovative Engineering Dheeaa al deen A. Aljuboury et al., Journal of Innovative Engineering 2014, 2(3):5
Journal of Innovative Engineering ISSN: 2347-7504
Figure 5: Effect of TiO2 loading on photo-catalytic degradation of TOC using Solar Irradiation in industrial
waste water effluent from Sohar Oil Refinery
Figure 6: Effect of TiO2 loading on TOC concentration using solar irradiation in industrial waste water
effluent from Sohar Oil Refinery (Batch reactor)
3.2 Continuous Process
3.2.1 Effect of TiO2 loading on photo-catalytic degradation of COD using solar irradiation: Photo-catalytic
degradation of COD in industrial waste water effluent from Sohar Oil Refinery is studied by varying the catalyst
loading from 0.1gm/L to 1.5gm/L. A set of experiments are conducted under sun light with the industrial effluent
Journal of Innovative Engineering Dheeaa al deen A. Aljuboury et al., Journal of Innovative Engineering 2014, 2(3):5
Journal of Innovative Engineering ISSN: 2347-7504
and samples are filtered before the analysis. The catalyst concentration (TiO2) is varied as 0.1, 0.25, 0.5, 1, and 1.5
g/L to obtain an optimum concentration to be used for further experiments.
The results are shown in Figure (7), the photo-catalytic degradation is observed to increase as the catalyst loading
increases. At a catalyst concentration (TiO2) of 0.5 g/L under sunlight, the photo-catalytic degradation of COD is
48% in 240 minutes of reaction time and On increasing the concentration of catalyst to 1 g/L, 85% COD removal is
observed in same time. The percentage removal of COD reaches to a maximum for a catalyst loading of 1gm/L. This
rise in percentage of COD removal may be explained by increase in concentration of TiO2 increases the number of
active sites on the photo-catalyst surface, which in turn increases the number of OH° radicals [6]. Beyond 1gm/L,
the degradation further decreases (shown in Figure 7). No significant increase is observed for 1.5 g/L of TiO2.
Figure 7: Effect of TiO2 loading on photo-catalytic degradation of COD using Solar Irradiation in industrial
waste water effluent from Sohar Oil Refinery (continuous reactor)
By comparing photo-degradation efficiency with TiO2 / Sunlight method in batch reactor and continuous reactor
under same condition, it was noted that the photo-degradation efficiency (%) of COD using batch reactor is 48% in
240 minutes of reaction time while is 87% in 240 minutes of reaction time using continuous mode of study because
the mechanism of degradation can be achievable under prolonged exposures to sunlight irradiation. Therefore
continuous process is better since handling of feed liquid is more compared to batch method.
3.2.2 Effect of pH on degradation of COD using solar irradiation: pH has important influence on pollutant
molecules, catalyst surface charge, and also on the mechanism and the rate of hydroxyl radical generation [13].
Photo catalytic experiments are performed under sunlight at the actual pH value of the wastewater without any pH
alteration in row industrial waste water effluent from Sohar Oil Refinery with the optimum dosage of TiO2 (1 gm/l)
at 3h. The actual pH values are 6.7, 8, 8.5, 8.7 and 9. The results are depicted Maximum and fastest reaction and
Journal of Innovative Engineering Dheeaa al deen A. Aljuboury et al., Journal of Innovative Engineering 2014, 2(3):5
Journal of Innovative Engineering ISSN: 2347-7504
better removal efficiency of COD in row industrial waste water effluent from Sohar Oil Refinery at pH value of 8.7
which is found 78%, and it is considered as the optimal pH for this study as shown in Figure (8). No further decrease
is observed on performing the reaction after 180 minutes till 300 minutes. As compared to pH values, the decrease
was more in the alkaline pH range. In 180 minutes, photo catalytic degradation of COD values are 15%, 24%, 60%
and 47% at pH values 6.7, 8, 8.5 and 9 respectively. The pH affects the surface charge for the photo-catalyst as well
as the organic pollutants [6]. The decrease in adsorption values may be due to the abundance of OH- ions, causing
increased hindrance to diffusion of organics [12].
Figure 8: Effect of pH on degradation of COD using solar irradiation (1 gm/l TiO2 at 3h.) in row industrial
waste water effluent from Sohar Oil Refinery.
3.2.3 Effect of initial concentration of COD: Experiments are carried out at 4 hr with sunlight irradiation for
different initial concentrations of COD (850 ppm, 1125 ppm, 1200 ppm and 1600ppm) in row industrial waste water
effluent from Sohar Oil Refinery using 1.0 gm/l of catalyst (TiO2). The COD of solution is estimated before and
after the reactions. Based on the COD values, the photo catalytic degradation efficiency is calculated by using the
equation:
Degradation efficiency = [(Initial COD – Final COD) / Initial COD) ×100] % (3)
The results for the effect of initial concentration on COD removal at various effluent concentrations are shown in
Figure 9. It is observed that the percentage removals of COD become 48%, 52%, 70% and 49% respectively. It is
found that the degradation of COD increased with increasing the initial concentration of COD. The reason for this
can be explained by considering the formation of hydroxyl radicals in water by the irradiation [6]. The maximum
efficiency for degradation of COD is 70 % at the initial concentration of COD (1200 ppm) at 240 min. But it is
noted that the percentage removal of COD decreases as the initial concentration of COD increases after this value.
The current study reveals that the reason for the smaller degradation rate at the latter stage of the process (after 1200
ppm) is likely due to the decrease in the formation of hydroxyl radicals on the catalyst surface with the increase in
pollutants concentration and at the same time the available active sites decrease by the increase of adsorbed
Journal of Innovative Engineering Dheeaa al deen A. Aljuboury et al., Journal of Innovative Engineering 2014, 2(3):5
Journal of Innovative Engineering ISSN: 2347-7504
pollutants on the catalyst surface (the coverage of active sites by reaction intermediates), which inhibits the direct
contact between pollutants and hydroxyl radicals [3].
Figure 9: Efficiency of degradation of COD for various initial concentrations of CODin row industrial waste
water effluent from Sohar Oil Refineryusing 1 gm/l TiO2 under solar irradiation at 4h.
3.2.4 Effect of irradiation time on the removal of COD: The required duration for the complete photo-
catalytic reaction is also observed. The reaction irradiation time is varied from 1 h to 6 h under the Sunlight source
by loading of 0.1 g/L catalyst into 1.5 g/L TiO2. Results represented that COD removal efficiency increases with
time as shown in Figure 7 and photo-catalytic reaction of the industrial effluent needs longer irradiation time due to
the fact that these effluents commonly contain high molecular weight and complex structured organic pollutants [6].
The difference is very small between 2 hr and 6 hr contact time. Therefore it is concluded that 4 hr operation is
suggested as optimum reaction time and it reduces the cost of pumping.
4. Conclusions
The performance of the photo-degradation of COD and TOC for row industrial waste water effluent from Sohar Oil
Refinery in presence of TiO2 is found to be the best method and has good efficiency for the removal of COD and
TOC from row industrial waste water. Several parameters have been studied, it appear that dose of TiO2 and
concentration of COD, initial pH and irradiation time of the reaction medium mainly controls the rate of
Journal of Innovative Engineering Dheeaa al deen A. Aljuboury et al., Journal of Innovative Engineering 2014, 2(3):5
Journal of Innovative Engineering ISSN: 2347-7504
degradation. The efficiency of the process depends strongly on the experimental conditions. pH 8.7 is the optimum
value for the rapid generation of OH radicals. This gives the TiO2 a positive charge which attracts the negatively
charged pollutants onto the surface of the catalyst resulting in efficient degradation. At low loading from 0.1 to 1 g/l
TiO2, the degradation of COD increases with increase TiO2 concentration and at loading over 1 g/l TiO2,
degradation of COD is a bit or constant with increase TiO2 concentration. The COD degradation efficiency
increased as the initial COD concentration increased until COD level of row industrial waste water samples from
Sohar Oil Refinery were more than 1200 mg/L but after that the COD degradation efficiency start by decreased. So,
a catalyst (TiO2) concentration of 1g/l under pH of 8.7 and the initial COD concentration under 1200 mg/L can be
introduced as the optimum operating conditions. The time of exposure increases the degradation efficiency; the
difference is very small between 2 hr and 6 hr contact time. Therefore it is concluded that 4 hr operation is suggested
as it reduces the cost of pumping. Under these conditions, a degradation efficiency of COD more than 78% of the
organic pollutants is achieved when applying near 240 min irradiation and significant removal can still be obtained
in much shorter times, after about 120 min. By comparing photo-degradation efficiency with TiO2/Sunlight method
in batch reactor and continuous reactor under same condition, it is noted that the photo-degradation efficiency (%) of
COD using batch reactor is 48% in 240 minutes of reaction time while is 87% in same time using continuous mode
of study because the mechanism of degradation can be achievable under prolonged exposures to sunlight irradiation
therefore continuous process is better since handling of feed liquid is more compared to batch method. The
percentage removal of TOC reaches to a maximum for a catalyst loading of 1.5gm/L which is 18% in 300 minutes
of reaction time period.
Solar detoxification of high COD wastewater is a unique treatment process utilizing renewable solar energy and
treating the wastewater with minimum chemical input. The photo-degradation by titanium dioxide (TiO2) has low
operation cost and a very high probability of COD degradation. This advanced oxidation process offers an
environmental alternative for the treatment of row industrial waste water effluent from Sohar Oil Refinery.
References
1. L N Mota, L F Albuquerque, L T C Beltrame, O Chiavone-Filho, A Machulek Jr., et al. (2008) Advanced
oxidation processes and their application in the petroleum industry: a review. Brazilian Journal of
Petroleum and Gas 2:122-142.
2. Flavia Cristina SertoriPaschoalino, MatheusPaesPaschoalino, Elizabete Jordão, Wilson de Figueiredo
Jardim (2012) Evaluation of TiO2, ZnO, CuO and Ga2O3 on the Photocatalytic Degradation of Phenol
Using an Annular-Flow Photocatalytic Reactor. Open Journal of Physical Chemistry 2: 135-140.
3. Kwon S, M Fan, A T Cooper, H Yang (2008) Photocatalytic applications of micro- and nano-TiO2 in
environmental engineering. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology 38: 197-226.
4. Javad Saien, FatemehShahrezaei (2012) Organic Pollutants Removal from Petroleum Refinery Wastewater
with NanotitaniaPhotocatalyst and UV Light Emission. International Journal of Photo-energy.
5. L C Chen, C M Huang, M C Hsiao, F R Tsai (2010) Mixture Design Optimization of the Composition of S,
C, SnO2-Codoped TiO2 for Degradation of Phenol under Visible Light. Chemical Engineering Journal 165:
482-489.
6. Lipika Das, MonalDutta, Jayanta Kumar Basu (2013) Photocatalytic degradation of phenol from industrial
effluent using titania-zirconia nanocomposite catalyst. International Journal of Environmental Sciences.
7. Chandan Singh, RubinaChaudhary, Kavita Gandhi (2013) Preliminary study on optimization of pH, oxidant
and catalyst dose for high COD content: solar parabolic trough collector. Iranian Journal of Environmental
Health Sciences & Engineering 10:13.
Journal of Innovative Engineering Dheeaa al deen A. Aljuboury et al., Journal of Innovative Engineering 2014, 2(3):5
Journal of Innovative Engineering ISSN: 2347-7504
8. Chakrabarti S, Dutta B (2004) Photocatalytic degradation of model textile dyes in wastewater using ZnO as
semiconductor catalyst. J Hazard Mater 112:269–278.
9. Ehrampoush MH, Moussavi GHR, Ghaneian MT, Rahimi S, Ahmadian M (2011) Removal of Methylene
Blue Dye From Textile Simulated Sample Using Tubular Reactor And TiO2/UV-C Photocatalytic Process.
Iranian Journal of Environmental Health Sciences & Engineering 8:35–40.
10. Akpan UG, Hameed BH (2009) Parameters affecting the photocatalytic degradation of dyes using TiO2-
based photocatalysts: a review. Journal of Hazardous Materials 170:520–529.
11. Jose Colina-Marquez, Luis Zuluaga, Fiderman Machuca Martínez (2009) Evaluation of the titanium
dioxide photocatalysis for the degradation of a commercial pesticides mixture. Ingeniería & Desarrollo.
Universidad del Norte. 26: 156-167.
12. Emmanuel OA, Olalekan AMB (2008) COD removal from industrial wastewater using activated carbon
prepared from animal horns. African Journal of Biotechnology 7: 3887–3891.
13. J Saien, H Delavari, A R Solymani (2010) Sono-assisted photo-catalytic degradation of styrene-acrylic acid
copolymer in aqueous media with nanotitania particles and kinetic studies. Journal of Hazardous Materials
177: 1031–1038.