Omaha, NE July 31, 2018 MINUTES Age - Southwest Power ...
-
Upload
khangminh22 -
Category
Documents
-
view
1 -
download
0
Transcript of Omaha, NE July 31, 2018 MINUTES Age - Southwest Power ...
1
Southwest Power Pool, Inc. SPECIAL MEETING OF MEMBERS
Embassy Suites Downtown/Old Market – Omaha, NE July 31, 2018
MINUTES
Agenda Item 1 – Administrative Items
SPP Board of Directors Chair Mr. Larry Altenbaumer called the meeting to order at 8:00 a.m. Mr. Altenbaumer asked for a round of introductions. There were 146 people in attendance either in person or via the phone representing 29 Members (Attendance List – Attachment 1). Mr. Nick Brown reported proxies (Proxies – Attachment 2). Agenda Item 2a – Election of Members Committee Representatives
Mr. Nick Brown began by reporting on the three items under consideration for the Membership. There is the election of three new Members Committee representatives (Membership Recommendation Members Committee Ballot – Attachment 3), revisions to the Bylaws in sections 4.1, 4.6, 5.1, 9.0, 9.2, 9.3, 9.4, 9.5, 9.6, 9.7, and 10 (Membership Recommendation Revision to Bylaws/SPP Regional Entity Removal – Attachment 4) and revisions to the Bylaws in section 4.2 (Bylaws/De Minimis Investments – Attachment 5). There are two vacancies and one new slot on the Members Committee. It is the responsibility of the Corporate Governance Committee (CGC) to fill vacancies on the Members Committee on a temporary basis, which was done in June, until the next meeting of the Membership. Representatives on the Members Committee do serve on staggered three-year terms. The openings are in the investor owned utility sector (IOU), independent power producer/marketer sector (IPP/Marketer) and large retail customer sector. The large retail customer (LRC) sector has been in place since 2003 and Walmart is the first company to join and qualify to fill the vacant seat. The CGC met on June 1 and agreed to nominate three individuals to these open seats. Mr. Brown reminded the Membership that it is only one vote per affiliate group. The nominees are Mr. Bleau LaFave, NorthWestern Energy (IOU sector), Ms. Holly Carias, NextEra Energy Resources (IPP/Marketers sector), and Mr. Chris Hendrix, Walmart Inc. (LRC sector). Mr. Larry Altenbaumer asked if there were any nominations from the floor. There were none. The Membership voted by ballot. The ballots were counted. The three candidates were elected. The term for Mr. Bleau LaFave will expire in 2019. The terms for Ms. Holly Carias and Mr. Chris Hendrix will expire in 2020. Agenda Item 2b – SPP Bylaws Revisions (Removal of the Regional Entity)
Last year the Board of Directors and Members Committee approved the dissolution of the SPP Regional Entity (SPP RE). On July 1, the Midwest Reliability Organization and SERC Reliability Corporation regional entities took over the responsibilities from the SPP RE, and on August 31 the SPP RE will legally be dissolved. In order to effectuate the process there are modifications to the SPP Bylaws that must be approved and then the changes will be filed with FERC. The proposed changes were approved by the CGC unanimously at the June 1 meeting. Mr. Mike Wise moved to accept the revisions to the Bylaws for the removal of the Regional Entity. Mr. Stuart Lowry seconded the motion. The Membership voted in favor with one abstention (Nebraska Public Power District). Agenda Item 2c – SPP Bylaws Revisions (De Minimis Investments) Mr. Brown reported on the bylaws revisions concerning de minimis investments by board members within the SPP suite of services. Over the years many of the ISOs/RTOs have hit this particular issue earlier because of retail access in their footprint. FERC approved similar modifications very easily with little to no protest. All revisions
SPP Special Meeting of Members Minutes July 31, 2018
2
proposed are patterned after the other three RTOs. This becomes more important with the addition of Walmart. The modifications are in section 4 of the Bylaws. The revisions were approved unanimously by the CGC. Mr. David Osburn moved to accept the revisions to the Bylaws for De Minimis Investments. Mr. Stuart Lowry seconded the motion. The Membership voted in unanimous approval; the motion passed. Adjournment
With no further business, Mr. Altenbaumer adjourned the Special Meeting of Members at 8:20 a.m.
Respectfully Submitted, Paul Suskie, Corporate Secretary
Antitrust: SPP strictly prohibits use of participation in SPP activities as a forum for engaging in practices or communications that violate the antitrust laws. Please avoid discussion of topics or behavior that would result in anti-competitive behavior, including but not limited to, agreements between or among competitors regarding prices, bid and offer practices, availability of service, product design, terms of sale, division of markets, allocation of customers or any other activity that might unreasonably restrain competition.
Southwest Power Pool, Inc.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS/MEMBERS COMMITTEE MEETING July 31, 2018
Embassy Suites Downtown/Old Market – Omaha, NE • A G E N D A •
8:00 a.m. – Noon Special Meeting of Members
1. Call to Order and Administrative Items……………………………………...…Mr. Larry Altenbaumer
2. Corporate Governance Committee Report……………………………………………..Mr. Nick Brown
a. Election of Members Committee Representatives b. SPP Bylaws Revisions (Removal of the Regional Entity) c. SPP Bylaws Revisions (De Minimis Investments)
Adjourn for Board of Directors/Members Committee Meeting Board of Directors/Members Committee Meeting
1. Call to Order and Administrative Items…………………………………………Mr. Larry Altenbaumer
2. Reports to the Board
a. President’s Report………………………………………………………………..Mr. Nick Brown
b. Regional State Committee Report…………………………….President Shari Feist Albrecht
c. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Report…………………………..Mr. Patrick Clarey
d. Regional Entity Trustees Report…………………...Messrs. Mark Maher and Steve Whitley
e. Oversight Committee Report……………………………………………….......Mr. Josh Martin
f. Finance Committee Report……………………………………………………Mr. Bruce Scherr
g. Strategic Planning Committee Report…………………………………………..Mr. Mike Wise
h. Holistic Integrated Tariff Team Report…………………………………………...Mr. Tom Kent
3. Consent Agenda
a. Approve April 24, 2018 Minutes
b. Corporate Governance Committee i. Recommendation – Finance Committee Nomination ii. Recommendation – SPP Bylaws and Membership Agreement Revisions
(Removal of the Regional Entity) iii. Recommendation – SPP Bylaws Revisions (De Minimis Investments) iv. Recommendation – Charter Approvals
1. Model Development Working Group 2. Reliability Compliance Working Group
c. Markets and Operations Policy Committee i. CTPTF
1. RR279 Competitive Upgrade Re-Evaluation Process
Antitrust: SPP strictly prohibits use of participation in SPP activities as a forum for engaging in practices or communications that violate the antitrust laws. Please avoid discussion of topics or behavior that would result in anti-competitive behavior, including but not limited to, agreements between or among competitors regarding prices, bid and offer practices, availability of service, product design, terms of sale, division of markets, allocation of customers or any other activity that might unreasonably restrain competition.
ii. MWG 1. RR177 Remove Reference to NERC Standards 2. RR266 JOU Combined Single Resource Modeling post Settlement Share
Allocation 3. RR277 ARR Funding Amount Correction 4. RR304 Accelerate Frequently Constrained Area Process 5. RR306 Multi-Day Minimum Run Time 6. RR310 Order 844 Compliance
iii. ORWG 1. RR309 Separation of RC Area SOL Methodology from Planning Criteria
iv. PCWG 1. Multi-Road Runner kV 115 Loop Rebuild 2. NTC 200401 Modification
v. RTWG 1. RR278 Seams and Interregional Agreement Clean-up 2. RR312 Schedule 12 FERC Assessment Charge 3. RR315 Removal of References to SPP Acting in the Role of Regional
Entity vi. TWG
1. 2018 ITPNT Assessment and Report 2. NW Aberdeen Upgrade
4. Markets and Operations Policy Committee Report…………………………….........Mr. Paul Malone a. MWG
i. RR272 NDVER to DVER Conversion
5. Future Meetings
2018 RSC/BOD – October 29-30……………………………………….Little Rock, AR BOD – December 4…………………….………………………….Little Rock, AR 2019 RSC/BOD – January 28-29……………………………………….New Orleans, LA RSC/BOD – April 29-30…………………………………………...Tulsa, OK BOD – June 10-11…………………………………………………Little Rock, AR RSC/BOD – July 29-30……………………………………………Denver, CO RSC/BOD – October 28-29……………………………………….Little Rock, AR BOD – December 3…………………….………………………….Little Rock, AR
Note: Following the Board of Directors/Members Committee meeting, the Board of Directors/Members Committee will convene an executive session.
Arkansas Electric Cooperative Corporation
Reliable ● Affordable ● Responsible
1 Cooperative Way P.O. Box 194208 Little Rock, Arkansas 72219-4208 (501) 570-2200
July 25, 2018 Ms. Shaun Scott, Assistant Corporate Secretary Southwest Power Pool 201 Worthen Drive Little Rock, Arkansas 72223-4936 Dear Shaun: By this letter, I assign my proxy to Andrew Lachowsky for the SPP Members Committee meeting on July 31, 2018. Sincerely,
Duane Highley President/CEO DH:lh
I will not be able to attend this BOD meeting due to a company board meeting conflict. Pleaseaccept Bill Grant as my proxy on the Members Committee.
Thank you,David T. HudsonXcel Energy | Responsible By NaturePresident, TX & NM790 S. Buchanan St., Amarillo, TX 79101P: 806.378.2824E: [email protected]________________________________________________XCELENERGY.COMPlease consider the environment before printing this email.
Southwest Power Pool, Inc. CORPORATE GOVERNANCE COMMITTEE
Recommendation to the Membership July 31, 2018
Nominations to Fill Vacancies on the Members Committee
Background There are three vacancies on the Members Committee due to a retirement, a job change, and an open position that had never been filled due to the absence of a Member in the sector. The open positions are to fill three mid-term vacancies. Analysis Representatives on the Members Committee are elected by the SPP Membership for staggered three-year terms. When a vacancy occurs the Corporate Governance Committee may elect an interim representative from the same sector to serve until a replacement representative from the same sector is elected and takes office. A special election shall be held at the next meeting of Members to fill the vacancy for the unexpired term. The replacement representative shall take office immediately following the election. Recommendation The following candidates are nominated for the respective terms indicated:
Members Committee (sector): Bleau LaFave (IOU) – Term ending 2019 Holly Carias (IPP) – Term ending 2020 Chris Hendrix (LRC) – Term ending 2020 Other nominations for the Members Committee may be made from the floor. Approved: Corporate Governance Committee June 1, 2018 Action Requested: Conduct the election
Southwest Power Pool, Inc. SPECIAL MEETING OF MEMBERS
July 31, 2018
Ballot for SPP Members Committee Special Election
SPP MEMBERS COMMITTEE: Each Member should vote for the number of nominees allocated for each sector. Investor Owned Utilities: (All Members should vote for 1 nominee)
Recommended by Corporate Governance Committee: For Against
Bleau LaFave (NorthWestern Energy) – Term Expires 2019 Additional Nominees:
_____________________________________________ _____________________________________________ IPP/Marketer: (All Members should vote for 1 nominee)
Recommended by Corporate Governance Committee: For Against
Holly Carias (NextEra Energy Resources) – Term Expires 2020
Additional Nominees:
_____________________________________________ _____________________________________________
Large Retail Customer: (All Members should vote for 1 nominee)
Recommended by Corporate Governance Committee: For Against
Chris Hendrix (Walmart) – Term Expires 2020
_____________________________________________ _____________________________________________
MEMBER: ___________________________________________________________________ REPRESENTATIVE’S SIGNATURE: ______________________________________________
Members Committee Nomination Form Nominee Name & Title:
Bleau LaFave; Director Long Term Planning
Company:
NorthWestern Energy
Type of Experience & Responsibilities with Company:
Long Term Planning of electric and natural Gas systems; Production Asset Optimization; Regional Market(s) Oversite; Natural Gas Production and Storage
Nominee’s Phone Number & Email Address:
605-798-2897; [email protected]
Nominated by:
John Hines – VP Supply
Sector:
Investor-Owned Utility Member
Members Committee Nomination Form Nominee Name & Title:
Holly Carias; Sr. Director, Regulatory Affairs
Company:
NextEra Energy Resources, LLC
Type of Experience & Responsibilities with Company:
In Holly’s current role on the NextEra Regulatory and Legislative Team, she is responsible for coverage of the stakeholder process for both MISO and the SPP region. Since Holly covers multiple regions, I believe she would be a very valuable asset to the SPP Members Committee. Prior to this role, Holly was on our Power Origination team negotiating and executing long-term energy purchases and sales contracts with various public power entities and cooperatives. Holly started with the company in our Wind Development team focused on development of projects in the SPP region. Her main responsibilities included site prospecting, financial analysis, contract negotiations, and coordinating with internal subject matter experts. It was during this role that Holly became familiar with SPP. She frequently attended stakeholder groups including the MOPC and several working groups. In addition, Holly advocated for NextEra to become a SPP member and allocate a Regulatory individual to the SPP region. Holly is from Oakley, Kansas. She holds a BS in Mathematics from Kansas State University, and a MA in Human Resource Management from Webster University. Prior to joining NextEra Energy, she worked for the Air Force as a Personnel Officer and was stationed in Kansas, Alaska, and Illinois.
Nominee’s Phone Number & Email Address:
561-358-6821
Nominated by:
Michele Wheeler, VP, Regulatory and Political Affairs
Sector:
Independent Power Producer – Transmission Using Member
Members Committee Nomination Form Nominee Name & Title:
Chris Hendrix
Company:
Walmart
Type of Experience & Responsibilities with Company:
Responsible for directing and implementing regulatory and legislative policies for Walmart’s retail and wholesale business interests related to electricity and natural gas in the competitive markets of the United States and the United Kingdom. Participates in the ISO Stakeholder process of ERCOT, PJM, and ISO-NE.
Nominee’s Phone Number & Email Address:
Nominated by:
self
Sector:
Large Retail Customer – Transmission Using Member
Southwest Power Pool, Inc. CORPORATE GOVERNANCE COMMITTEE
Recommendation to the Membership July 31, 2018
Revision to Bylaws/SPP Regional Entity Removal
Background The SPP Regional Entity’s delegated authority and its registered entities will transfer to the Midwest Reliability Organization and SERC Reliability Corporation, respectively, on July 1, 2018, and the SPP Regional Entity will dissolve on August 31, 2018, concurrent with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission approved termination effective date for the Regional Delegation Agreement between SPP and the North American Electric Reliability Corporation. Analysis The proposed revisions are necessary to remove references to the SPP Regional Entity from SPP’s Bylaws. Section 10 of the Bylaws requires that modifications to Sections 4, 5, 9, and 10 be approved by the Membership. Notice of these Bylaws changes were provided to the Membership by Assistant Corporate Secretary Shaun Scott on June 25, 2018. Recommendation Approval of the removal of references to the SPP Regional Entity from the Bylaws as outlined above and reflected in the changes to Bylaws Sections 4.1, 4.6, 5.1, 9.0, 9.1, 9.2, 9.3, 9.4, 9.5, 9.6, 9.7, and 10 (attached).
Approved: Corporate Governance Committee June 1, 2018 Action Requested: Approve recommendation
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 4.0 Board of Directors --> Bylaws 4.1 Duties
Effective Date: 8/5/2010 - Docket #: ER10-2145 - Page 1
4.1 Duties
The Board of Directors shall at all times act in the best interest of SPP in its
management, control and direction of the general business of SPP. The Board of
Directors shall solicit and consider a straw vote from the Members Committee as an
indication of the level of consensus among Members in advance of taking any actions
other than those occurring in executive session. Its duties shall include, but are not
limited to the following:
(a) Direct activities of all SPP Organizational Groups;
(b) Serve on SPP Organizational Groups;
(c) Remove Members, and approve the re-entry of Members that have been
removed;
(d) Authorize all substantive contracts and debt instruments;
(e) Select and review the performance of SPP Officers, who shall serve at the
pleasure of the Board of Directors;
(f) Approve policies by which positions, duties, qualifications, salaries,
benefits and other necessary matters pertaining to the SPP Officers are
determined;
(g) Review, approve, disapprove or recommend revision to the actions of any
Organizational Group;
(h) Act on appeals pursuant to Section 3.10;
(i) Approve and implement Regional Criteria for enforcement under the
terms and
conditions of the SPP Membership Agreement;
(j) Provide input with the Members Committee to the Regional Entity
Trustees, on
SPP Regional Reliability Standards presented by the MOPC to the
Trustees or otherwise developed under the auspices of the Trustees for
submission to the ERO for its approval;
(kj) Approve or revise the operating and capital budgets and any additional
expenditures;
Formatted: Indent: Hanging: 0.5"
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 4.0 Board of Directors --> Bylaws 4.1 Duties
Effective Date: 8/5/2010 - Docket #: ER10-2145 - Page 2
(lk) Convene a meeting of Members at least annually;
(ml) Approve amendments to these Bylaws as permitted by these Bylaws;
(nm) Approve amendments to the Membership Agreement as permitted by the
Membership Agreement;
(on) Approve Regional Criteria pertaining to planning and operating standards
and policies and penalties for non-compliance with such Criteria; and
(po) Authorize filings with regulatory bodies.
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 4.0 Board of Directors --> Bylaws 4.6 Functioning of the Board of Directors
Effective Date: 8/15/2015 - Docket #: ER15-1924-000 - Page 1
4.6 Functioning of the Board of Directors
In reaching any decision and in considering the recommendations of any
Organizational Group or task force, the Board of Directors shall abide by the principles in
these Bylaws.
4.6.1 Meetings and Notice of Meetings
The Board of Directors shall meet at least three times per calendar year
and additionally upon the call of the Chair or upon concurrence of at least a
majority of directors. At least fifteen days' written notice shall be given by the
President to each director, the Members Committee, and the Regional State
Committee of the date, time, place and purpose of a meeting of the Board of
Directors, unless such notice is waived by the Board of Directors. Telephone
conference meetings may be called as appropriate by the Chair with at least one-
day prior notice. Board of Directors’ meetings shall include the Members
Committee, a representative from the Regional Entity Trustees, and a
representative from the Regional State Committee (as defined in Section 7.2) for
all meetings except when in executive session; provided however, the failure of
representatives of the Members Committee and/or of the Regional Entity Trustees
and/or of the Regional State Committee to attend, in whole or in part, shall not
prevent the Board of Directors from convening and conducting business, and
taking binding votes. The Chair shall grant any Member’s request to address the
Board of Directors.
4.6.2 Chair and Vice Chair; Election and Terms
The Board of Directors shall elect from its membership a Chair and Vice
Chair for two-year terms commencing upon election and continuing until their
duly elected successors take office or until their term as a director expires without
re-election. The President of SPP may not serve as the Chairman of the Board of
Directors. The Vice Chair shall act for the Chair:
(a) at the request of the Chair;
(b) in the event the Chair should become incapacitated and unable to
discharge the functions of the office; or
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 4.0 Board of Directors --> Bylaws 4.6 Functioning of the Board of Directors
Effective Date: 8/15/2015 - Docket #: ER15-1924-000 - Page 2
(c) if the office of Chair becomes vacant, until the next regularly
scheduled meeting of the Board of Directors, at which meeting a
new Chair shall be elected by the Board of Directors to fill the
vacancy. The Chair shall appoint a director to fill a vacant Vice
Chair position until the next meeting of the Board of Directors, at
which meeting a new Vice Chair shall be elected by the Board of
Directors to fill the vacancy.
4.6.3 Quorum and Voting
A majority plus one of the directors shall constitute a quorum of the Board
of Directors; provided, that a lesser number may adjourn the meeting to a later
time. Decisions of the Board of Directors shall be by simple majority vote of the
directors present and voting. Directors must be present at a meeting to vote; no
votes by proxy are permitted. Voting will be by secret ballot. The Corporate
Secretary will collect and tally the ballots, and announce the results of a vote.
Only voting results will be announced and recorded in the minutes; individual
votes will not be announced or recorded.
4.6.4 Compensation of Directors
Directors shall receive compensation as recommended by the Corporate
Governance Committee, and approved by the Membership, and shall be
reimbursed for actual expenses reasonably incurred or accrued in the performance
of their duties.
4.6.5 Executive Session
Executive sessions (open only to directors and to parties invited by the
Chair) shall be held as necessary upon agreement of the Board of Directors to
safeguard confidentiality of sensitive information regarding employee, financial,
or legal matters.
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 5.0 Committees Advising the Board of Directors --> Bylaws 5.1 Members Committee
Effective Date: 11/10/2014 - Docket #: ER14-2851-000 - Page 1
5.1 Members Committee
The Members Committee shall work with the Board of Directors to manage and
direct the general business of SPP. Its duties shall include, but are not limited to
the following:
(a) Provide individual and collective input to the Board of Directors,
including but not limited to a straw vote from the Members Committee
representatives as an indication of the level of consensus among Members,
on all actions pending before the Board of Directors;
(b) Serve on committees reporting to the Board of Directors as appointed by
the Board of Directors; and
(c) Provide input with the Board of Directors to the Regional Entity Trustees
on SPP Regional Reliability Standards presented by the MOPC to the
Trustees or otherwise developed under the auspices of the Trustees for
submission to the ERO for its approval.
5.1.1 Composition and Qualifications
5.1.1.1 Composition
Provided that Membership is sufficient to accommodate these provisions,
the Members Committee shall consist of up to 24 persons. Six representatives
shall be investor owned utilities Members; five representatives shall be
cooperatives Members; two representatives shall be municipals Members
(including municipal joint action agencies); three representatives shall be
independent power producers/marketers Members; two representatives shall be
state power agencies Members; one representative shall be from a Federal Power
Marketing Agency; two representatives shall be alternative power/public interest
Members; one representative shall be from an independent transmission company
Member, defined as having assets under the OATT and no Affiliate Relationships
in other categories of Membership; one representative shall be a large retail
customer Member, defined as non-residential end-use customers with individual
or aggregated loads of 1-MW or more; and one representative shall be a small
retail customer Member, defined as residential customers and other customers
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 5.0 Committees Advising the Board of Directors --> Bylaws 5.1 Members Committee
Effective Date: 11/10/2014 - Docket #: ER14-2851-000 - Page 2
with individual or aggregated loads of less than 1-MW. Representatives will be
elected in accordance with Section 5.1.2 of these Bylaws.
5.1.1.2 Qualifications
A representative shall be an officer or employee of a Member with
decision-making responsibility over SPP related activities, and must be the
Member's representative to the Membership.
5.1.2 Term and Election
Representatives shall be nominated by the Corporate Governance Committee and
elected each year at the meeting of Members to staggered three-year terms commencing
upon election and continuing until their duly elected successors take office. The election
process shall be as follows:
(a) At least 90 calendar days prior to the meeting of Members at which
election of new representatives is required, the Corporate Governance
Committee shall nominate persons equal in number to the representatives
to be elected;
(b) At least 30 calendar days prior to the meeting of Members, the Corporate
Governance Committee shall determine the persons it nominates for
election as representatives, specifying the nominee for any vacancy to be
filled. The Corporate Secretary shall prepare the ballot accordingly,
leaving space for additional names, and shall deliver same to Members at
least two weeks prior to the meeting of Members;
(c) For purposes of electing and removing representatives only, each group of
Members with Affiliate Relationships shall be considered a single vote;
(d) At the meeting of Members, any additional nominee or nominees may be
added to the ballot if a motion is made and seconded to add such nominee
or nominees; and
(e) The required number of representatives shall be elected by written ballot.
A Member shall be entitled to cast a number of votes equal to the number
of representatives to be elected. A Member may not cumulate votes. The
candidates in each sector receiving the greatest number of votes will fill
vacancies.
Formatted: Keep with next, Keep lines together
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 5.0 Committees Advising the Board of Directors --> Bylaws 5.1 Members Committee
Effective Date: 11/10/2014 - Docket #: ER14-2851-000 - Page 3
5.1.3 Resignation and Removal of Members Committee Representatives
Any representative may resign by written notice to the President noting the
effective date of the resignation. A representative may be removed, with cause, by the
affirmative vote of a majority of the Members at a meeting of Members. Removal
proceedings may only be initiated by a petition signed by not less than twenty percent of
the Members. The petition shall state the specific grounds for removal and shall specify
whether the removal vote is to be taken at a special meeting of Members or at the next
regular meeting of Members. A representative who is the subject of removal proceedings
shall be given fifteen days to respond to the Member petition in writing to the President.
5.1.4 Vacancies
If a vacancy occurs the Corporate Governance Committee may elect an interim
representative from the same sector to serve until a replacement representative from the
same sector is elected and takes office. A special election shall be held at the next
meeting of Members to fill the vacancy for the unexpired term. The replacement
representative shall take office immediately following the election.
5.1.5 Meetings
The Members Committee shall meet only with the Board of Directors.
Formatted: Keep with next, Keep lines together
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 9.0 Regional Entity Function
Effective Date: 8/5/2010 - Docket #: ER10-2145 - Page 1
9.0 REGIONAL ENTITY FUNCTIONReserved for future use
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 9.0 Regional Entity Function --> Bylaws 9.1 Regional Entity
Effective Date: 8/5/2010 - Docket #: ER10-2145 - Page 1
9.1 Regional Entity
SPP operates as a Regional Entity under FERC jurisdiction with oversight powers
delegated to it by the ERO. The Regional Entity Trustees shall appoint representatives to
ERO organizational groups as necessary to represent the interests of the SPP Regional
Entity. SPP may pay appropriate associated travel expenses of those appointed
representatives upon receipt by the Secretary to the Trustees of an expense report as
normally filed within the representative’s system.
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 9.0 Regional Entity Function --> Bylaws 9.2 Regional Entity Staff
Effective Date: 8/5/2010 - Docket #: ER10-2145 - Page 1
9.2 Regional Entity Staff
The Regional Entity Trustees will oversee staffing requirements for the SPP
Regional Entity. All SPP Regional Entity staff shall report through the Regional Entity
(RE) General Manager to the Trustees.
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 9.0 Regional Entity Function --> Bylaws 9.3 RE General Manager
Effective Date: 8/5/2010 - Docket #: ER10-2145 - Page 1
9.3 RE General Manager
The RE General Manager shall be selected by and report to the SPP Regional
Entity Trustees, and will provide leadership and vision, oversee the execution of RE
strategic direction, and direct the day-to-day operations of the RE. The RE General
Manager shall carry out the rights, duties and obligations of the SPP RE pursuant to the
authority granted by these Bylaws, the Regional Entity Trustees, and SPP corporate
policies. The RE General Manager’s responsibilities shall include but are not limited to:
(a) Providing guidance and oversight of the execution of the performance of
delegated statutory functions from the ERO;
(b) Developing and managing an appropriate organizational structure and
staffing levels to accomplish the RE functions;
(c) Developing an annual RE business plan and budget for RE Trustee, NERC
and FERC approval;
(d) Providing sound fiscal management;
(e) Ensuring compliance with SPP’s Bylaws and Regional Entity Delegation
Agreement, as well as other applicable federal, state, and local laws; and
(f) Interfacing with SPP members and stakeholders, federal and state
regulators, other Regional Entities, and NERC on matters related to the
reliability of the bulk power system.
The President shall ensure that the RE General Manager has adequate resources,
access to information, and the full cooperation of Staff and Organizational Groups for the
effective execution of his/her duties.
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 9.0 Regional Entity Function --> Bylaws 9.4 Duties of Regional Entity Staff
Effective Date: 8/5/2010 - Docket #: ER10-2145 - Page 1
9.4 Duties of Regional Entity Staff
Regional Entity functions related to compliance monitoring and enforcement shall
include but are not limited to:
(a) Investigation of all reports or discoveries of non-compliance with
approved ERO policies and standards;
(b) Obtaining all information needed to investigate all facets of possible
noncompliance with ERO policies and standards;
(c) Performance of in-depth reviews of operations in conjunction with the
Compliance Monitoring and Enforcement Program (CMEP);
(d) Comprehensive audits when recurring issues covering a broad spectrum of
violations of ERO policies and standards are determined and documented;
(e) Recommendation of financial penalties and/or sanctions for non-
compliance with ERO policies and standards pursuant to ERO guidelines;
(f) Assist the Regional Entity Trustees with third party audits to confirm that
SPP is conforming to ERO policies and standards;
(g) Utilization of dispute resolution procedures as necessary to resolve
conflicts or appeals; and
(h) Coordination of policy modifications to clearly define ERO requirements,
and penalties in order to objectively monitor compliance.
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 9.0 Regional Entity Function --> Bylaws 9.5 Regional Reliability Standards Development...
Effective Date: 8/5/2010 - Docket #: ER10-2145 - Page 1
9.5 Regional Reliability Standards Development Process
When an SPP working group or task force is considering an SPP Regional
Reliability Standard, it will be designated the Standards Development Team (SDT) for
that Standard in accordance with the SPP Regional Entity Standards Development
Process Manual. For purposes of an SDT, participation and voting will be open to any
interested party in accordance with the Standards Development Process and without
regard to membership status in SPP.
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 9.0 Regional Entity Function --> Bylaws 9.6 Compliance Monitoring and Enforcement...
Effective Date: 8/5/2010 - Docket #: ER10-2145 - Page 1
9.6 Compliance Monitoring and Enforcement Program
The Regional Entity Trustees will oversee SPP’s Compliance Monitoring and
Enforcement Program (CMEP). The CMEP will enforce compliance according to ERO
reliability standards for Registered Entities. Regional Entity staff shall oversee
compliance auditing of registered entities, and will report audit results to the Regional
Entity Trustees. All audits of SPP’s compliance with ERO reliability standards will be
performed by external third party auditors as coordinated and managed by the Regional
Entity Trustees.
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 9.0 Regional Entity Function --> Bylaws 9.7 Regional Entity Trustees
Effective Date: 1/29/2016 - Docket #: ER16-430-000 - Page 1
9.7 Regional Entity Trustees
9.7.1 Functions and Duties of the Regional Entity Trustees
The Regional Entity Trustees shall at all times act in the best interests of SPP’s
role as the SPP Regional Entity in its management, control, and direction of the general
business of the Regional Entity functions. In reaching any decision and in considering the
recommendations of an appropriate entity, the Regional Entity Trustees shall abide by the
principles in these Bylaws. Its duties shall include, but are not limited to oversight of the
following:
(a) Select, oversee and review the performance of the SPP RE General
Manager in carrying out the statutory functions and duties as defined in
the Delegation Agreement between ERO and SPP;
(b) Approve the annual RE business plan and budget;
(c) Perform function assigned by the SPP Compliance Monitoring and
Enforcement Program;
(d) Track and review Regional Standards from MOPC for submission to the
ERO and FERC for approval and implementation.
(e) Complete a self-assessment annually to determine how effectively the
Regional Entity Trustees are meeting their responsibilities; and
(f) Provide an annual report to the Board of Directors regarding the
effectiveness of the Regional Entity function and processes.
9.7.2 Composition and Qualifications
9.7.2.1 Composition
The Regional Entity Trustees shall consist of up to four (4) persons, but no
less than three (3) persons. The trustees shall be independent of the SPP Board of
Directors, any Member, industry stakeholder, or SPP organizational group.
Regional Entity Trustees do not serve as members of the SPP Board of Directors.
A trustee shall not be limited in the number of terms he/she may serve.
9.7.2.2 Qualifications
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 9.0 Regional Entity Function --> Bylaws 9.7 Regional Entity Trustees
Effective Date: 1/29/2016 - Docket #: ER16-430-000 - Page 2
Regional Entity Trustees shall have relevant senior management expertise
and experience in the reliable operation of the bulk electric transmission system in
North America.
9.7.2.3 Conflicts of Interest
Regional Entity Trustees shall not be a director, officer, or employee of,
and shall have no direct business relationship, financial interest in, or other
affiliation with, a Member, a customer of services provided by SPP, or a
Registered Entity in the SPP footprint. Trustees may invest in accordance with the
SPP Standards of Conduct. Participation in a pension plan of a Member,
customer, or Registered Entity in the SPP footprint shall not be deemed to be a
direct financial benefit if the Member’s, customer’s, or Registered Entity’s
financial performance has no material effect on such pension plan.
9.7.3 Term and Election
Regional Entity Trustees shall be elected at the meeting of Members to a three-
year term commencing upon election and continuing until his/her duly elected successor
takes office. The election process shall be as follows:
(a) At least 90 calendar days prior to the meeting of Members when election
of a new trustee is required, the Corporate Governance Committee shall
commence the process to nominate persons for the position to be elected;
(b) At least 45 calendar days prior to the meeting of Members, the Corporate
Governance Committee shall determine the person it nominates for
election as a trustee, specifying the nominee for any vacancy to be filled.
The Corporate Secretary shall prepare the ballot accordingly, leaving
space for additional names, and shall deliver same to Members at least 30
calendar days prior to the meeting of Members;
(c) For purposes of electing or removing trustees only, only Members that are
Registered Entities in the SPP Regional Entity footprint shall be
considered a Member, and Members with Affiliate Relationships shall be
considered a single Member;
(d) Any additional nominee(s) may be added to the ballot if a petition is
received by the Corporate Secretary at least 15 calendar days prior to the
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 9.0 Regional Entity Function --> Bylaws 9.7 Regional Entity Trustees
Effective Date: 1/29/2016 - Docket #: ER16-430-000 - Page 3
meeting of Members and evidencing support of at least 20 percent of the
existing Members; and
(e) 1) If only one candidate is nominated for a seat, each Member shall be
entitled to cast a vote for or against the nominee. The votes will be
calculated in accordance with Section 3.9 Voting of these Bylaws, which
requires a super majority. In the event a trustee position is not filled the
Corporate Governance Committee will determine a new nominee for
recommendation for election by the Members at a special meeting of
Members to be held but no later than the next regular Board of
Directors/Members Committee meeting;
2) If multiple candidates are nominated for a seat, each Member shall be
entitled to cast a vote for only one nominee, but may vote against each
candidate. The votes will be calculated in accordance with Section 3.9
Voting of these Bylaws, with the exception that a simple majority of votes
cast will determine which nominee is elected. In the event a trustee
position is not filled, the Corporate Governance Committee will determine
a new nominee for recommendation for election by the Members at a
special meeting of Members to be held no later than the next regular
Board of Directors/Members Committee meeting.
9.7.4 Resignation and Removal of Regional Entity Trustees
Any Regional Entity Trustee may resign by written notice to the President noting
the effective date of the resignation. The Members may remove a trustee with cause in
accordance with Section 3.9 Voting of these Bylaws. Removal proceedings may only be
initiated by a petition signed by not less than twenty percent of the Members. The petition
shall state the specific grounds for removal and shall specify whether the removal vote is
to be taken at a special meeting of Members or at the next regular meeting of Members.
A trustee who is the subject of removal proceedings shall be given fifteen days to respond
to the Member petition in writing to the President.
9.7.5 Vacancies
If a vacancy occurs, the Corporate Governance Committee will present a nominee
to the Members for consideration and election to fill the vacancy for the unexpired term
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 9.0 Regional Entity Function --> Bylaws 9.7 Regional Entity Trustees
Effective Date: 1/29/2016 - Docket #: ER16-430-000 - Page 4
at a special meeting of Members following 30 calendar days notice from the corporate
Secretary. The election will be held in accordance with Section 9.7.3 Term and Election
of these Bylaws. The replacement trustee shall take office immediately upon election.
9.7.6 Meetings and Notice of Meetings
Regular Regional Entity Trustees’ meetings will be scheduled in conjunction with
the regularly scheduled SPP Board of Directors meetings, provided the meeting schedule
may be adjusted for good cause and with sufficient notice, and additionally upon the call
of the chair or upon concurrence of at least a majority of trustees. Except as otherwise
provided in these Bylaws, all meetings will be open to any interested party. At least
fifteen days' written notice shall be given by the chair to each trustee, the Board of
Directors, and the Members Committee of the date, time, place and purpose of a meeting,
unless such notice is waived by the trustees. Telephone conference meetings may be
called as appropriate by the chair with at least one-day prior notice. The chair shall grant
any party’s request to address the Regional Entity Trustees.
9.7.7 Chair
The Regional Entity Trustees shall elect from its membership a chair for a two-
year term commencing upon election and continuing until the chair’s duly elected
successor takes office or until the chair’s term as a trustee expires without re-election.
The panel may elect to rotate the chair to the senior member of the panel when the initial,
or subsequent, chair’s term expires.
9.7.8 Quorum and Voting
A majority of the trustees shall constitute a quorum of the Regional Entity
Trustees necessary for a binding vote. Decisions of the Regional Entity Trustees require a
simple majority vote. Trustees must be present at a meeting to vote; no votes by proxy
are permitted. All Regional Entity Trustee decisions regarding the Regional Entity are
final except as subject to oversight by the ERO and FERC.
9.7.9 Compensation of Regional Entity Trustees
Regional Entity Trustees shall receive compensation as recommended by the
Corporate Governance Committee, and approved by the Members that are Registered
Entities in the SPP Regional Entity footprint, submitted for approval as part of the ERO
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 9.0 Regional Entity Function --> Bylaws 9.7 Regional Entity Trustees
Effective Date: 1/29/2016 - Docket #: ER16-430-000 - Page 5
budget process. Trustees shall be reimbursed for actual expenses reasonably incurred or
accrued in the performance of their duties.
9.7.10 Executive Session
Executive sessions (open only to Trustees and parties invited by the chair of the
Regional Entity Trustees) shall be held as necessary upon agreement of the Regional
Entity Trustees to safeguard confidentiality of sensitive information regarding employee,
financial or legal matters, or confidential information related to compliance matters.
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 10.0 Amendments To These Bylaws, The Articles...
Effective Date: 8/15/2015 - Docket #: ER15-1924-000 - Page 1
10.0 Amendments To These Bylaws and, The Articles Of Incorporation, And
Membership Agreement
Except for modifications to Section 4.0 BOARD OF DIRECTORS, Section 5.0
COMMITTEES ADVISING THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS, Section 8.7.5 LIMITATION ON
FINANCIAL AND PENALTY OBLIGATIONS, Section 9.0 REGIONAL ENTITY
FUNCTION, and Section 10.0 AMENDMENTS, these Bylaws may be amended, repealed, or
added to by the Board of Directors only upon 30 days written notice to the Membership of the
proposed modification(s). Approval of amendments to the Bylaws by the Board of Directors
must be by an affirmative vote of a majority plus one of directors. Sections 4.0, 5.0, 8.7.5, 9.0,
and 10.0 of these Bylaws and the Articles of Incorporation may be amended, repealed, or added
to only by approval of the Membership. Provided, that all changes to Federal Power Marketing
agency/administration representation in Section 5.1.1 and any change to Section 8.7.5 must be
mutually agreed to by the Federal Power Marketing Agency Member and SPP. All amendments
are subject to the requisite regulatory approval(s).
Commented [A1]: Amendment of the Membership Agreement is per section 8.12 of that agreement.
Southwest Power Pool, Inc. CORPORATE GOVERNANCE COMMITTEE
Recommendation to the Membership July 31, 2018
Revision to Bylaws/De Minimis Investments Background The Corporate Governance Committee has considered and recommends incorporating the proposed de minimis investment methodology into Bylaws Section 4.2.3 - [Board of Directors] Conflicts of Interest to clarify in SPP’s Bylaws the concept of a financial interest in principle with the methodology accepted by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (“Commission”) for other Independent System Operators (“ISOs”) and Regional Transmission Organizations (“RTOs”) to allow SPP directors to invest in companies that have a de minimis relationship with SPP and the electric sector. Analysis The Commission’s regulations (specifically Orders No. 888 and 2000) require that ISOs and RTOs, their employees, and any non-stakeholder directors not have financial interests in any market participant and maintain independence from “any entity whose economic or commercial interests could be significantly affected by the RTO’s actions or decisions.”1 The term “market participant” is defined in the Commission’s
regulations as:
(i) Any entity that, either directly or through an affiliate, sells or brokers electric energy, or provides ancillary services to the [RTO], unless the Commission finds that the entity does not have economic or commercial interests that would be significantly affected by the [RTO]’s actions or decisions; and
(ii) Any other entity that the Commission finds has economic or commercial interests that would be significantly affected by the [RTO]’s actions or decisions.2
Per Order No. 2000 Commission approval is required for SPP to adopt a de minimis investment methodology.
Section 10 of the Bylaws requires that modifications to Section 4 be approved by the Membership. Notice of these Bylaws changes were provided to the Membership by Assistant Corporate Secretary Shaun Scott on June 25, 2018. Recommendation Approval of the incorporation of a de minimis investment methodology into SPP’s Bylaws as outlined above and reflected in the changes to Bylaws Section 4.2 (attached).
Approved: Corporate Governance Committee June 1, 2018 Action Requested: Approve recommendation
1 Regional Transmission Organizations, Order No. 2000, FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,089 (1999),
order on reh’g, Order No. 2000-A, FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,092 (2000), aff’d sub nom. Pub. Util. Dist. No. 1 v. FERC, 272 F.3d 607 (D.C. Cir. 2001).
2 18 C.F.R. §35.34(b)(2).
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 4.0 Board of Directors --> Bylaws 4.2 Composition and Qualifications
Effective Date: 8/15/2015 - Docket #: ER15-1924-000 - Page 1
4.2 Composition and Qualifications
4.2.1 Composition
The Board of Directors shall consist of up to ten persons, but no less than
seven persons. The directors shall be independent of any Member; one director
shall be the President of SPP. A Director shall not be limited in the number of
terms he/she may serve. The President shall be excluded from voting on business
2related to the office of President or the incumbent of that office. No other Staff
member shall be permitted to serve as a director
4.2.2 Qualifications
Directors shall have recent and relevant senior management expertise and
experience in one or more of the following disciplines: finance, accounting,
electric transmission or generation planning or operation, law and regulation,
commercial markets, and trading and associated risk management.
4.2.3 Conflicts of Interest
Directors shall not be an employee, director, officer, or
employeeconsultant or contractor of, and shall have no direct business
relationship, financial interest in, or other affiliation with, any Third Party, or any
of its AffiliatesMember or customer of services provided by SPP, which shall be
deemed to include ownership (outside of a mutual fund, blind trust, or similar
arrangement as permitted herein) by a Director or his/her immediate family
members of Prohibited Securities.
For purposes of this section:
“Affiliates” include any two or more entities of which one controls the other or
they are under common control. “Control” shall mean the possession, directly or
indirectly, of the power to direct the management or policies of an entity.
Ownership of publicly-traded equity securities of another entity shall not result in
control or affiliation for purposes of these Standards if the securities are held as an
investment, the holder owns (in its name or via intermediaries) less than 10% of
the outstanding securities of the entity, the holder does not have representation on
the entity's board of directors (or equivalent managing entity) or vice versa, and
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 4.0 Board of Directors --> Bylaws 4.2 Composition and Qualifications
Effective Date: 8/15/2015 - Docket #: ER15-1924-000 - Page 2
the holder does not in fact exercise influence over day-to-day management
decisions. Unless the contrary is demonstrated to the satisfaction of the Corporate
Governance Committee, control shall be presumed to arise from the ownership of
or the power to vote, directly or indirectly, 10% or more of the voting securities of
such entity.
“Immediate family members” include spouses, minor children, or any person for
whom the Director has power of attorney or guardianship rights.
“Prohibited Securities” include the securities of a Third Party that has been
engaged or qualified to engage in activities or transactions under the SPP OATT
in the previous 12 months or the securities of its Affiliates, if:
(i) the primary business purpose of the Third Party, or its Affiliates, is to buy,
sell or schedule energy, power, capacity, ancillary services or transmission
services as indicated by an industry code within the “Electric Power
Generation, Transmission, and Distribution” industry group under the
North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) or otherwise
determined by SPP;
(ii) the Third Party has been pre-qualified as eligible to be a Qualified RFP
Participant pursuant to Attachment Y to the SPP OATT;
(iii) the total (gross) financial settlements regarding the use of transmission
capacity of the Transmission System and/or transactions in the centralized
markets that SPP administers under the SPP OATT for all Third Parties
affiliated with the publicly-traded entity at issue during its most recently
completed fiscal year is equal to or greater than 0.5% of its gross revenues
for the same time period; or
(iv) the total (gross) financial settlements regarding the use of transmission
capacity of the Transmission System and/or transactions in the centralized
markets that SPP administers under the SPP OATT for all Third Parties
affiliated with the publicly-traded entity at issue during the prior calendar
year is equal to or greater than 3% of the total transactions for which the
Integrated Marketplace Counterparty is a counterparty pursuant to
Attachment AE to the SPP OATT for the same time period.
Governing Documents Tariff --> Bylaws, First Revised Volume No. 4 --> Bylaws 4.0 Board of Directors --> Bylaws 4.2 Composition and Qualifications
Effective Date: 8/15/2015 - Docket #: ER15-1924-000 - Page 3
“Securities” shall mean negotiable or non-negotiable investment of financing
instruments that can be sold and bought. Securities include bonds, stocks,
debentures, notes, and options.
If an SPP Director owns Prohibited Securities, he/she must dispose of
them within six months of:
(i) the commencement of engagement at SPP;
(ii) notification of a new Third Party conducting business with SPP; or
(iii) the date of receipt of a gift or inheritance or other taking of legal control of
those Prohibited Securities.
“Third Party” shall mean a Member; a customer of services provided by SPP
under the SPP OATT or any other tariff that SPP administers; an entity for which
SPP provides services under contract, including, but not limited to, tariff
administration services; or an entity that has been pre-qualified as eligible to be a
Qualified RFP Participant pursuant to Attachment Y to the SPP OATT.
SPP Directors may indirectly own publicly-traded Prohibited Securities
through a mutual fund, blind trust, or similar arrangement under which the SPP
Director does not control the purchase or sale of such Prohibited Securities,
except for any fund or arrangement specifically targeted towards the electric
utility industry, or any segments thereof.
SPP will maintain a listing of Third Party entities and publicly-traded
Prohibited Securities for SPP Directors’ reference.
Directors may invest in accordance with SPP’s Standards of Conduct.
Participation in a pension plan of a Member or customer shall not be deemed to
be a direct financial benefit if the Member’s or customer’s financial performance
has no material effect on such pension plan.