Mathematical modeling of a multi-stream brazed aluminum plate fin heat exchanger

12
MATHEMATICAL MODELING OF A MULTI-STREAM BRAZED ALUMINUM PLATE FIN HEAT EXCHANGER by Ahmed A. KOHIL a , Hassan A. FARAG a , and Mona E. OSSMAN b* a Chem. Eng. Dept., Faculty of Engineering, Alexandria University, Alexandria, Egypt b Mubarak City for Scientific Research and Technological Application, Alexandria, Egypt Original scientific paper UDC: 66.045.1:517.956 DOI: 10.2298/TSCI1001103K The need for small size and lightweight heat exchangers in many applications has resulted in the development of many heat transfer surfaces. This type of heat exchanger is much more compact than can be practically realized with circular tubes. In this work a steady-state mathematical model that representing one of the plate fin heat exchangers enclosed in cold box of an ethylene plant has been devel- oped. This model could evaluate the performance of the heat exchanger by predict- ing the outlet temperatures of the hot and cold streams when the inlet conditions are known. The model has been validated by comparing the results with actual operat- ing values and the results showed good agreement with the actual data. Sensitivity analysis was applied on the model to illustrate the main parameters that have the greatest influence on the model calculated results. The sensitivity analysis showed that the hot stream outlet temperature is more sensitive to cold streams inlet tem- peratures and less sensitive to hot stream inlet temperature and thermal resistance (fouling), while the cold stream outlet temperature is more sensitive to cold streams inlet flow rate and less sensitive to fouling. Key words: fouling, heat exchanger, modeling, simulation Introduction Studies on enhanced heat transfer have been reported for more than 100 years now. In recent years, due to the increasing demand by industries for heat exchangers that are more effi- cient, compact and less expensive, heat transfer enhancement has gained serious momentum [1]. Brazed aluminum plate fin heat exchangers have been successfully used in a variety of applica- tions. The major applications have been in the cryogenic separation, Air Separation Unit (ASU); natural gas processing (NGP) and liquefaction of natural gas (LNG); the production of petro- chemicals and treatment of off gases; large refrigeration systems [2]. This type of heat Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ... THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114 103 * Corresponding author; e-mail: [email protected], [email protected]

Transcript of Mathematical modeling of a multi-stream brazed aluminum plate fin heat exchanger

MATHEMATICAL MODELING OF A MULTI-STREAM BRAZEDALUMINUM PLATE FIN HEAT EXCHANGER

by

Ahmed A. KOHIL a, Hassan A. FARAG a,

and Mona E. OSSMAN b*

a Chem. Eng. Dept., Fac ulty of En gi neer ing, Al ex an dria Uni ver sity,

Al ex an dria, Egyptb Mubarak City for Sci en tific Re search and Tech no log i cal Ap pli ca tion,

Al ex an dria, Egypt

Orig i nal sci en tific pa perUDC: 66.045.1:517.956

DOI: 10.2298/TSCI1001103K

The need for small size and light weight heat exchangers in many ap pli ca tions hasre sulted in the de vel op ment of many heat trans fer sur faces. This type of heatexchanger is much more com pact than can be prac ti cally re al ized with cir cu lartubes. In this work a steady-state math e mat i cal model that rep re sent ing one of theplate fin heat exchangers en closed in cold box of an eth yl ene plant has been de vel -oped. This model could eval u ate the per for mance of the heat exchanger by pre dict -ing the out let tem per a tures of the hot and cold streams when the in let con di tions are known. The model has been val i dated by com par ing the re sults with ac tual op er at -ing val ues and the re sults showed good agree ment with the ac tual data. Sen si tiv ityanal y sis was ap plied on the model to il lus trate the main pa ram e ters that have thegreat est in flu ence on the model cal cu lated re sults. The sen si tiv ity anal y sis showedthat the hot stream out let tem per a ture is more sen si tive to cold streams in let tem -per a tures and less sen si tive to hot stream in let tem per a ture and ther mal re sis tance(foul ing), while the cold stream out let tem per a ture is more sen si tive to cold streamsin let flow rate and less sen si tive to foul ing.

Key words: fouling, heat exchanger, modeling, simulation

In tro duc tion

Stud ies on en hanced heat trans fer have been re ported for more than 100 years now. Inre cent years, due to the in creas ing de mand by in dus tries for heat exchangers that are more ef fi -cient, com pact and less ex pen sive, heat trans fer en hance ment has gained se ri ous mo men tum [1]. Brazed alu mi num plate fin heat exchangers have been suc cess fully used in a va ri ety of ap pli ca -tions. The ma jor ap pli ca tions have been in the cryo genic sep a ra tion, Air Sep a ra tion Unit (ASU); nat u ral gas pro cess ing (NGP) and liq ue fac tion of nat u ral gas (LNG); the pro duc tion of pet ro -chem i cals and treat ment of off gases; large re frig er a tion sys tems [2]. This type of heat

Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ...

THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114 103

* Corresponding author; e-mail: [email protected], [email protected]

exchangers is ca pa ble of han dling a wide va ri ety of flu ids in many dif fer ent types of ap pli ca -tions. In gen eral, flu ids should be clean, dry, and non-cor ro sive to alu mi num, trace im pu ri ties ofH2S, NH3, CO2, SO2, NO2, CO, Cl, and other acid-form ing gases do not cre ate cor ro sion prob -lem in streams with wa ter dew point tem per a tures lower than the cold-end tem per a ture of thebrazed alu mi num plate- fin heat exchanger [3]. The de sign and sim u la tion of multi stream platefin heat exchangers are mark edly dif fer ent from those of two-fluid exchangers. Fea tures like by -pass heat trans fer [4] or cross over in tem per a ture [5], com mon in multi stream heat exchangers,have no equiv a lent in two-stream units. In the sim plest form a multi stream han dles three dif fer -ent streams of flu ids. Sor lie [6] de vel oped a de sign the ory for three-fluid heat exchangers of thecon cen tric-tube and plate fin types, in which the in ter me di ate and cold streams were ther mallyin su lated. He de rived closed form so lu tions for the tem per a tures of all the streams by solv ing aset of three first or der lin ear or di nary dif fer en tial equa tions and de fined an ex pres sion for theover all ef fec tive ness. Some of the the o ret i cal re sults were com pared with ex per i ments and ex -cel lent agree ment was ob tained. Aulds et al. [7] ex tended the work of Sor lie by an a lyz ing thecase, in which all three streams were in ther mal com mu ni ca tion, which is rel e vant to manythree-fluid heat exchangers used in cryo genic sys tems. Ghosh [8] de vel oped a new al go rithm for the anal y sis of multi stream heat exchangers. The nu mer i cal tech nique in volves par ti tion ing ofthe exchanger in both ax ial and nor mal di rec tions. Con ser va tion equa tions writ ten for each seg -ment are solved us ing an it er a tive pro ce dure. The al go rithm has been tested against pub lishedre sults and good agree ment has been ob served. Georgiadis [9] de vel oped a math e mat i cal mod -el ing and sim u la tion of com plex plate heat exchanger ar range ments un der milk foul ing, us ingde tailed dy namic mod els. A com plex foul ing model based on a re ac tion mass trans fer scheme iscou pled with a gen eral ther mal dy namic model of plate heat exchangers. All the im por tant fac -tors af fect ing milk heat treat ment are for mally quan ti fied. The fi nal model com prises a set ofpar tial dif fer en tial, in te gral, and al ge braic equa tions. Reibero [10] de vel oped an al go rithm forthe steady-state sim u la tion of a plate heat exchanger. In this al go rithm he took into ac count agen eral unit with n flow chan nels, in which the hot and cold streams may flow co- or coun tercur rently. The al go rithm was suc cess fully uti lized to sim u late the steady-state op er a tion of anin dus trial plate heat exchanger used for pas teur iz ing milk. Gut [11] de vel oped a math e mat i calmodel in al go rith mic form for the steady-state sim u la tion of gas ket plate heat exchangers withgen er al ized con fig u ra tions. The con fig u ra tion is de fined by the num ber of chan nels, num ber ofpasses at each side, fluid lo ca tions, feed con nec tion lo ca tions, and type of chan nel-flow. Themain pur poses of this model are to study the con fig u ra tion in flu ence on the exchanger per for -mance and to fur ther de velop a method for con fig u ra tion op ti mi za tion. The main sim u la tion re -sults are: tem per a ture pro files in all chan nels, ther mal ef fec tive ness, dis tri bu tion of the over allheat trans fer co ef fi cient, and pres sure drops. More over, the as sump tion of con stant over all heattrans fer co ef fi cient is an a lyzed. Tovazhyansky [12] de vel oped nu mer i cal sim u la tion of multicom po nent mix tures con den sa tion in plate con dens ers. A nu mer i cal sim u la tion us ing semi-em -pir i cal equa tions of heat and mass trans fer per for mance along the sur face of plate con dens erswas car ried out for dif fer ent multi com po nent mix tures with non condensable com po nents. Theplates with cross-cor ru gated pat terns for plate con dens ers were used. The sim u la tion was donefor four dif fer ent types of cor ru gated plates of in dus tri ally man u fac tured plate heat exchangers.The com plex ity of com pact exchanger de sign equa tions re sults from the exchanger’s uniqueabil ity to trans fer heat be tween mul ti ple pro cess streams [13] and the wide ar ray of pos si ble flow con fig u ra tions. These com plex i ties make hand cal cu la tions te dious and sim ple cor re la tions in -ap pli ca ble. How ever, com puter pro grams and pro cess sim u la tors al low en gi neers to more eas ily

Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ...

104 THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114

eval u ate com plex brazed alu mi num exchangers. Pinguad et al. [14] and Luo et al. [15] have also car ried out steady-state and dy namic sim u la tion of plate fin heat exchangers. Luo et al. [16]have de vel oped an an a lyt i cal model of a multi stream exchanger with con stant phys i cal prop er -ties. In a sep a rate pa per [17], the au thors have pro posed a more gen er al ized an a lyt i cal so lu tionfor pre dict ing the ther mal per for mance of multi stream heat exchangers and their net works. This model is also ap pli ca ble to other types of one-di men sional heat exchangers such as shell andtube and plate heat exchangers. The ob jec tive of the pres ent work is to de velop a steady-statemath e mat i cal model for one of the se ries of plate fin heat exchangers used in an eth yl ene plantlo cated in Al ex an dria, Egypt. This model could eval u ate the per for mance of the heat exchangerby pre dict ing the out let tem per a tures of the cold and hot streams when the in let con di tions areknown.

The math e mat i cal model

This study will fo cus on one exchanger of the cold box of Sidi Kerir Pet ro chem i calsCom pany, Al ex an dria, Egypt. The plate fin heat exchanger con tains the fol low ing streams (fig. 1):

Cold streams: Nor mal tem per a ture [°C]– methane off gas (gas), –62 °C– low pressure hydrogen (gas), –62 °C– high pressure hydrogen (gas), –62 °C– de-ethanizer bottom feed (liq.), –57 °C– de-ethanizer top feed (liq.), –57 °C– recycle ethane (liq.). –42 °C

Hot stream:– ethylene refrigerant (liq.) –14 °C

Ar ranged in the or der shown in fig. 1.

As sump tions

(1) Steady-state op er a tion of the heat exchanger and ne glect in flu ence of in let/out let ex pan -sion/con trac tion effect.

(2) Multi-component streams are assumed to be two-component streams (one main coldstream and one main hot stream).

(3) Zero heat losses to the surroundings.(4) No heat transfer through inlet and outer

headers and distributors.(5) Thermal resistance in the cold side may increase in the de-ethanizer feed streams only

because they may contain heavier-than-design components during the start up periodconditions, which may cause freezing to take place on the heat, transfer surfaces. (Normallyduring startup this is prevented from reaching the exchanger, but sometimes it may reach bymistake).The other streams are either light gas components from the overheads of flashdrums and distillation columns mainly consisting of hydrogen, methane, and ethane, or alight component liquid like ethylene.

Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ...

THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114 105

Figure 1. Schematic of cold and hot streams forthe exchanger

– No phase change along the exchangerpassages.

– The resistance due to wall thickness was notconsidered because walls and fins are madeof very thin aluminum sheets.

The model will be de vel oped by con sid er ingthe exchanger (fig. 2) con sist ing of one maincold stream and one main hot stream [3] so as to

ap ply the nor mal steady-state heat trans fer rate bal ance equa tion.The steps of the cal cu la tions are per formed in the fol low ing se quence to ful fill the

steady-state heat bal ance equa tion:Qc = –Qh = QUA (1)

where Qc is the to tal heat en ergy gained by the cold streams, Qh – the to tal heat en ergy givenaway by the hot stream, and QUA – the heat trans ferred through the heat exchanger based on theover all heat trans fer co ef fi cient.

Heat gained by cold streams Qc can be ob tained from:

Q m C TT

T

ic ci p ci in

out

c

c= æèç ö

ø÷å

=D

1

6(2)

Heat gave away by hot streams Qh can be ob tained from:

Q m C TT

T

h h p h in

out

h

h= D (3)

Heat en ergy based on the over all heat trans fer co ef fi cient QUA can be ob tained from:

QUA = UA(dTLM)* (4)

( )( ) ( )

ln

d iho ci hi co

ho ci

hi co

TLMT T T T

T T

T T

=- - -

-

-

æ

èçç

ö

ø÷÷

(5)

where dTLM [K] is the log a rith mic mean tem per a ture dif fer ence, Thi [K] – the in let tem per a tureof hot fluid, Tho [K] – the out let tem per a ture of hot fluid, Tci [K] – the in let tem per a ture of coldfluid, and Tco [K] – the out let tem per a ture of cold fluid.

An ap proach has been sug gested to cal cu late an av er age value for the log a rith micmean tem per a ture dif fer ence (dTLM)* as fol lows:

( ) ( )*d dci

ciTLM

m

mTLM

i= å

=1

6(6)

The heat trans fer sur face area [2] for the finned pas -sages A (fig. 3), which con sists of the pri mary and sec ond -ary trans fer sur faces can be ob tained from:

A = 2Np(LW)2(1 – nd) + 2n(H – d) (7)

where per unit area of each part ing sheet:

Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ...

106 THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114

Figure 2. The exchanger simplified into onehot-one cold streams

Figure 3. Dimensions of a fin (general)

– the pri mary sur face is given by 2(1 – nd)– the sec ond ary sur face is given by 2n(H – d)

and n [–] is the fin den sity; d [m] – the fin thick ness, H [m] – the fin height, Np – the num ber ofpas sages per core, L [m] – the pas sage length, and W [m] – the pas sage width.

The over all heat trans fer co ef fi cient (U) [2] can be ob tained from:

1 1 1

UA H A h A= +

S S( ) ( )o hi o ci

(8)

where ho [kJh–1m–1K–1] is the ef fec tive heat trans fer co ef fi cient of a stream, A [m2] – the over allheat trans fer sur face and sub scripts hi, and ci: hot or cold stream i.

1 1

h hr

o

= + (9)

where h [kJh–1m–1K–1] is the heat trans fer co ef fi cient of a stream, and r [hm2KkJ–1] – the ther malre sis tance.

Heat trans fer co ef fi cient of streams (h) [3] can be ob tained from:

hjG C

=m p

Pr 23(10)

where j is the Colburn fac tor for a finned pas sage, Gm [kgm–1h–1] – the mass flux of a stream, Cp

[kJkg–1K–1] – the spe cific heat ca pac ity of a stream at con stant pres sure, and Pr – the Prandtlnum ber of a stream.

Colburn fac tor (j) (or StPr2/3 = F(Re) can be ob tained from the equa tions de vel opedfrom in ter po la tion/ex trap o la tion of the em pir i cal data ta bles [3] re lat ing the j fac tor to Re (fig. 4) to match the exchanger di men sions and con di tions. These equa tions have the for mula:

j = aRe–b (11)

Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ...

THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114 107

Figure 4. Colburn factor (j) as a function of Re number

Reynolds num ber [18] can be ob tained from:

Re =4R Gh m

m(12)

where Rh [m] is the hy drau lic ra dius (AcL/A), and m [kgm–1h–1] is the vis cos ity of fluid.Mass flux of a stream Gm, also known as the mass ve loc ity, is ob tained from [2]:

Gm

Am

c

= (13)

where m [kgh–1] is the mass flow rate.The free flow area (Ac) [2] can be ob tained from:

Ac = (H – t)(p – t) (No. of fins) (14)

Prandtl num ber for the streams is ob tained from:

Pr =C

k

p m(15)

and for sim pli fy ing the cal cu la tions, the phys i cal prop er ties (Cp, m, and k, where k [kJh–1m–1K–1] is the ther mal con duc tiv ity) were eval u ated at the av er age tem per a ture, or Tm = (Tin + Tout)/2.

Val i da tion of the model

The pro posed model was val i datedac cord ing to fig. 5, to check whether the model re pro duces sys tem be hav iorwithin ac cept able bounds. The model iscoded us ing MATLAB. The val i da tiondone by com par ing pre dicted modelout put to ac tual mea sured out put. Thepre dicted model out put gen er ated fromthe de vel oped model will be com paredwith ac tual run ning data of theexchanger af ter one year of be ing in ser -vice. By look ing at tab. 1, which con -tains sum mary of the model re sults andval i da tion of the model, it was foundthat the val i da tion showed that themodel re sults showed good agree mentwith the ac tual mea sured out put formthe heat exchanger.

The de vel oped model has been usedto sim u late the ef fect of dif fer ent pa ram -e ters on the out let tem per a tures of thecold and hot streams in the steady statecon di tions. The re sults of these sim u la -tions are rep re sented as fol lows.

Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ...

108 THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114

Figure 5. Iterative process for validating the proposedmodel

Ta ble 1. Sum mary of model va lid ity re sults

Plantload[%]

Ac tualvalue[°C]

Cal cu latedvalue[°C]

Er ror incal cu la tion

[%]

95Tc out –31.3 –30.6 –2.29

Th out –51.5 –52.2 1.34

83Tc out –30.6 –31.7 3.47

Th out –50.8 –53.0 4.15

78Tc out –33.13 –30.61 –8.23

Th out –45.08 –51.7 12.8

Ef fect of in let flow rate of coldand hot streams

It is no ticed that in creas ing thecold streams in let flow rates, with all other pa ram e ters kept con stant willre sult in lower cold streams out lettem per a tures Tc out, (fig. 6). This isbe cause in creas ing the flow rate ofthe cold streams en ter ing the heatexchanger will de crease the res i -dence time, there fore the out let tem -per a ture of the cold streams, Tc out

will be lower. Also in creas ing thecold streams in let flow rates willlower the hot stream out let tem per a -ture Th out.

This can be ex plained by thesim ple eq. (16):

mCpDTc = mCpDTh (16)

To keep this equa tion bal ance then the DTh must in crease and since thesim u la tion is done by chang ing onepro cess vari able, keep ing all othervari ables con stant, there fore Th out

must de crease for the above equa tionto ap ply. This is also can ex plain theef fect of in creas ing the hot streamflow rate whish rep re sented in fig. 7.The fig ure shows that in creas ing thehot streams in let flow rate, with allother pa ram e ters kept con stant willre sult in higher cold streams out lettem per a tures Tc out and higher hotstream out let tem per a ture Th out which agrees with the ba sic prin ci ples ofheat trans fer [19].

Ef fect of cold stream in lettem per a ture

In creas ing the cold streams in let tem per a ture, with all other pa ram e ters kept con stantwill re sult in higher cold streams out let tem per a tures Tc out, and higher hot stream out let tem per a -ture Th out, (figs. 6 and 8).

Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ...

THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114 109

Figure 6. Effect of cold streams inlet flow rate on outlettemperature of cold and hot streams

Figure 7. Effect of hot stream inlet flow rate on outlettemperature of cold and hot streams

Ef fect of hot stream in let tem per a ture

By de creas ing the cold streamsin let tem per a ture, the model pre -dicts that the out let tem per a ture ofthe cold streams will de crease aswell as the out let tem per a tures ofhot stream keep ing all other vari -ables con stant. These com puted re -sults are given in fig. 9. The ob -tained re sults show that they are allin agree ment with the ba sic prin ci -ples of heat trans fer within any heatexchanger.

Fig ure 9 shows that in creas ingthe hot streams in let tem per a ture,with all other pa ram e ters kept con -stant will re sult in higher coldstreams out let tem per a tures Tc out

while re sults in al most no change inthe hot stream out let tem per a ture Th out and this re sults showed goodagree ment with the heat trans ferprin ci ples [19].

Ef fect of ther mal re sis tance (foul ing)

Fig ure 10 shows that if the coldstreams side ther mal re sis tance(foul ing on the two liq uidde-ethanizer feed streams side) is in -creased this will re sult in a slightlylower cold streams out let tem per a -tures Tc out , and a slightly higher hotstream out let tem per a ture Th out ,while fig. 11 shows that if the hot

stream side ther mal re sis tance (foul ing) is in creased this will re sult in a slightly lower coldstreams out let tem per a tures Tc out , and a slightly higher hot stream out let tem per a ture Th out .

Sen si tiv ity anal y sis of the model

A sen si tiv ity anal y sis was per formed on the model to iden tify to what ex tent the modelis sen si tive to the vari a tion in some of the pa ram e ters, and which of these pa ram e ters has ahigher im pact on the re sults cal cu lated by the model.

Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ...

110 THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114

Figure 9. Effect of hot stream inlet temperature on outlettemperature of cold and hot streams

Figure 8. Effect of cold streams inlet temperature on outlet temperature of cold and hot streams

Fig ure 12 rep re sents that the cold streams out let tem per a ture Tc out is more sen si tive tocold streams in let flow rate Fc, and hot stream in let flow rate Fh. While it is less sen si tive to thether mal re sis tance on the cold side rc and the ther mal re sis tance on the hot side rh.

Fig ure 13 shows that the hot stream out let tem per a ture Th out is more sen si tive to coldstreams in let tem per a ture Tc in. While it is less sen si tive to the hot stream in let tem per a ture Th in

and the ther mal re sis tance on the cold and hot sides rc and rh.

Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ...

THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114 111

Figure 12. Sensitivity analysis of cold streams outlet temperature Tc out

Figure 11. Effect of hot side thermal resistance on outlet temperature of cold and hot streams

Figure 10. Effect of cold side thermal resistance onoutlet temperature of cold and hot streams

Con clu sions

A math e mat i cal model de vel oped for the plate fin heat exchanger which con tains 6cold streams and one hot stream has been tested against ac tual op er at ing con di tions of the plantthat has been run ning for more than 6 years, tak ing into con sid er ation any ex pected ef fect forpres ent or fu ture foul ing on the heat trans fer sur faces. Multi-com po nent streams were as sumedto be two com po nents streams for sim pli fi ca tion; ex clud ing com po nents with mi nor per cent -ages. The model showed very close re sults to the ac tual val ues for the cold and hot streams out let tem per a tures. The ef fect of ther mal re sis tance (foul ing) which was sus cep ti ble af ter more than 6years of op er a tion and due to ab nor mal con di tions dur ing startups in the two liq uid cold streamsside was tested and found to have a slight ef fect on the rate of heat trans fer and the streams out lettem per a tures for both cold and hot sides. The other test which was done for the ef fect of the ther -mal re sis tance (foul ing) in the hot stream pas sages showed also a slight ef fect of this re sis tanceon the rate of heat trans fer and streams out let tem per a tures. The sen si tiv ity anal y sis showed thatthe hot stream out let tem per a ture Th out is more sen si tive to cold streams in let tem per a tures Tc in

and less sen si tive to hot stream in let tem per a ture Th in and ther mal re sis tance (foul ing), while thecold stream out let tem per a ture Tc out is more sen si tive to cold streams in let flow rate Fc and lesssen si tive to foul ing. The model by pre dict ing the streams out let tem per a tures is a use ful tool formon i tor ing the exchanger per for mance dur ing nor mal op er a tion.

Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ...

112 THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114

Figure 13. Sensitivity analysis of hot stream outlet temperature Th out

No men cla ture

A – effective heat transfer surface of a– passage or layers of a stream, [m2]

Ac – exchanger minimum free-flow – area, [m2]

Ad – designed (or estimated) overall effective– heat transfer surface, [m2]

Ar – required overall effective heat transfer– surface, [m2]

Ref er ences

[1] Webb, R. L. Prin ci ples of En hanced Heat Trans fer, John Wiley & Sons Inc., New York, USA, 1994[2] ***, The Stan dards of the Brazed Alu mi num Plate-Fin Heat Exchanger, Brazed Alu mi num Plate-Fin Heat

Exchanger Man u fac tur ers As so ci a tion, UK, ALPEMA, 1994[3] Kays, W. M., Lon don, A. L., Com pact Heat Exchangers, 3rd ed., McGraw-Hill, New York, USA, 1984[4] Haseler, L. E., Per for mance Cal cu la tion Method for Multi-Stream Plate-Fin Heat Exchangers,.in: Heat

Exchangers, The ory and Prac tice (Eds. J. Taborek, G. F. Hew itt, N. Afgan), Hemi sphere Pub lish ing Corp., New work, USA, 1983

[5] Fan, Y. N., How to De sign Plate Fin Heat Exchangers, Hy dro car bon Pro cess, 45 (1966), 11, pp. 211-217[6] Sor lie, T., Three Fluid Heat Exchanger De sign The ory, Coun ter and Par al lel Flow, Tech ni cal Re port 54,

De part ment of Me chan i cal En gi neer ing, Stan ford Uni ver sity Stan ford, Col., USA, 1962[7] Aulds, D. D., Barron, R. F., Three-Fluid Heat Exchanger Ef fec tive ness, Int. J. Heat Mass Trans fer, 10

(1967), pp.1457-1462[8] Ghosh, I., Sarangi, S. K., Das, P. K., An Al ter nate Al go rithm for the Anal y sis of Multi-Stream Plate Fin

Heat Exchangers, In ter na tional Jour nal of Heat and Mass trans fer, 49 (2006), pp. 2889-2902[9] Georgiadis, M. C., Macchietto, S., Dy namic Mod el ing and Sim u la tion of Plate Heat Exchangers un der

Milk Foul ing, Chem. Eng. Sci., 55 (2000), 9, pp. 1605-1619[10] Reibero C.P., Cano Andrade M.H. A Heat Trans fer Model for the Steady-State Sim u la tion of climb -

ing-Fall ing-Film Plate Evap o ra tors, Jour nal of Food En gi neer ing, 53 (2002), 1, pp. 59-66[11] Gut Jorge, A.W., Pinto Jose, M., Mod el ing of Plate Heat Exchangers with Gen er al ized Con fig u ra tions, In -

ter na tional Jour nal of Heat and Mass Trans fer, 46 (2003), 14, pp. 2571-2585[12] Tovazhyansky, L. L., et al., The Sim u la tion of Multi-Com po nent Mix tures Con den sa tion in Plate Con -

dens ers, Heat Trans fer En gi neer ing, 25 (2004), 5, pp. 16-22[13] Polasek, J. C., Don nel ly, S. T., Bullin, J. A., Pro cess Sim u la tion and Op ti mi za tion of Cryo genic Op er a -

tions Us ing Multi-Stream Brazed Alu mi num Exchangers, Pro ceed ings, 68th An nual GPA Con ven tion,San An to nio, Tex., USA, 1989, pp. 918-928

[14] Pingaud, H., Le Lann, J. M., Koehret, B., Steady-State and Dy namic Sim u la tion of Plate Fin HeatExchangers, Comput. Chem. Eng., 13 (1989), 4-5, pp. 577-585

[15] Luo, X., et al., Dy namic Be hav ior of One Di men sional Flow Multi Stream Heat Exchangers and TheirNet works, Int. J. Heat Mass Trans fer, 46 (2003), pp. 705-715

Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ...

THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114 113

a – equation constant, [–]b – equation constant, [–]C – specific heat equation constant, [–]Cp – specific heat at constant pressure,

– [kJkg–1K–1]Di – inside diameter of a circular tube, [m]Do – outside diameter of a circular tube, [m]d – fin thickness, [m]Fc – cold streams inlet flow rate, [kgh–1]Fh – hot streams inlet flow rate, [kgh–1]Ft – correction factor to log-mean rate

– equation, [–]Gm – exchanger flow-stream mass velocity,

– [kgh–1m–2]H – fin height, [m]h – unit conductance for thermal-convection

– heat transfer, [kJh–1m–2K–1]j – Colburn coefficient (StPr2/3)k – unit thermal conductivity, [–]L – total heat exchanger flow length; also

– flow length of uninterrupted fin, [m]m – mass flow rate of a stream, [kgh–1]

n – fin density; number of fins per unit– length, [–]

Pr – Prandtl number (= mCp/k), [–]p – fin pitch, [m]Q – heat transfer rate, [kgh–1]Rh – hydraulic radius (= AcL/A)Re – Reynolds number (= 4RhGm/m)r – thermal resistance for fouling,

– [hm2KkJ–1]St – Stanton number (=h/GmCp), [–]T – absolute temperature, [K]Tc – critical temperature, [K]tr – reduced temperature, [K]ts – temperature at any arbitrary scale, [K]U – overall heat transfer coefficient between

– streams, [kcalhm–2K]W – core width, [m]

Greek letters

m – viscosity, [kgm–1h–1] r – density, [kgm–3]

[16] Luo, X., Li, K., Li, M., Pre dic tion of the Ther mal Per for mance of Multi Stream Plate Fin Heat Exchangers, Int. J. Heat Exchangers, 2 (2001), pp 47-60

[17] Luo, X., Li, M., Roetzel, W., A Gen eral So lu tion for One Di men sional Multi Stream Heat Exchangers andTheir Net works, Int. J. Heat Mass Trans fer, 45 (2002), pp. 2695-2705

[18] Perry, R. H., Green, D. W., Maloney, J. O., Perry’s Chem i cal En gi neers Hand book, 6th ed., McGraw-Hill,New York, USA, 1984

[19] Taborek, J. Spalding, D. B, Heat Exchanger De sign Hand book Vol. 1,Hemi sphere Pub lish ing Corp., NewYork, USA, 1983

Paper submitted: April 8, 2008Paper revised: February 28, 2009Paper accepted: Jun 13, 2009

Kohil, A. A., et al.: Mathematical Modeling of a Multi-Stream Brazed Aluminum Plate ...

114 THERMAL SCIENCE: Year 2010, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 103-114