133! 1. 2013

!"#"$

%&&

!"#$$#%&'# $()*+,%-# !"#$# %&'(#: ) !'#*$+,+ -.*/+)0" !#$&0&1+-)#2#

3+4-0%&5 % 6!#7. !#-08#'3&9,"

!"#$%&" '()*+"1

!"#$% &. !"#$$#%&'# $()*+,%-#: ' #(#.&/0 1)"$ ,)-"+$+(()2 *&/(&.

&'#'(. ) "*. +.,.-&'*#%(%. /%0 #'0. +.-&'$1"$2. 3%)4(2: +0 32#5"$'6 &#')), 2013.

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«/%)*%/'#2"162» («2(*%$%6$%5% 62#4)"162»), )#'0" /#'0)*2("*'9'. 4%*%#%. 6%E$% *24E' $21(2*@ $'6'G-4%5% 24*"(")*2, ")*%#"42, )%G"%9%52 " (#2<2 I2#92-D2.$G2 J%*23, 'BK %0$%5% "*29@8$)4%5% «2(*%$%6$%5% 62#4)")*2» L#2$4% «M"N%» M'#2#0"4, 32#"% O#%$*"5, 2 *24E' #80 0#:5"F 2(*%#%(, <@" "6'$2 629% "1(')*$; /%)*)%('*)4"6 "$*'99'4-*:2926, ( *%6 <")9' /#"<")98=B"6 )'A8 4 9'(;6".

P/'#2"16 ("*. operaismo- – 0%)9%($% /'#'(%0"*)8 424 «#2A%<"16», F%*8 0%)9%($;. /'#'(%0 0% 4%$G2 $' /'#'02K* )6;)9 )26%5% Q*%5% /%$8*"8)-– 9'(%' 0("E'$"', (%1$"4?'' ( 7*29"" ( 1960-' $2 (%9$' 4#"1")2 *#20"G"%$$;F '(#%/'.)4"F 4%6/2#*". " /#%N)%=1%(, #21%<2#%(2$"8 6%9%0;F '(#%/'.-)4"F 9'(;F ( )%('*)4%6 %A#21G' )*#%"*'9@)*(2 )%G"29"162 1 O2*@8$2 R"E%(2 – $2:<$;. )%*#:0$"4 7$)*"*:*2 N"9%)%N""

C+C M'92#:)" (5.-3"$)4, M'92#:)@).2 &'$1"$ +. C%(;' )%G"29@$;' ):AH'4*;: ('#)"8 &2%9% !"#$% //

6")7()/&,. 2006. S 3. T. 145–165. [U9'4*#%$$;. #'):#)] O%<42 0%)*:/2: http://www.alternativy.ru/ru/node/726.

3 &'#'(%0; '5% *'4)*%( 6%E$% $2.*" ( "$*'#$'*' /% 20#'):: http://revsoc.org/archives/1771.

4 Berardi F. 8e Soul at Work: From Alienation to Autonomy // [U9'4*#%$$;. #'):#)] O%<42 0%)*:/2: http://libcom.org/Vles/Franco%20’’Bifo’’%20Berardi%20-%20The%20Soul%20at%20Work%20From%20Alienation%20to%20Autonomy.pdf.

5 Tronti M. Our operaismo // New Left Review. 2012. Jan.-Feb. S-73. [U9'4*#%$$;. #'):#)] O%<42 0%)*:/2: http://libcom.org/library/our-operaismo-mario-tronti.

134

(!"#$%$ &$'" &"($)"&$*"+,- $.$/-++$ $.!&$ 0&$1*,2$ .-/1 * 1956 %$'3, 0$.2- **-'-+,1 .$*-!.#,4 *$5.# * 6-+%&,7).6 8-&*$+")"29+$ $0-&",.!.#,- %&300: $/;-',+12,.9 *$#&3% <3&+"2" 0$' +"(*"+,-= Quaderni rossi («>&".+:- !-!&"',»). 6 0&$!,*$*-. #2"..,)-.#$5 ="&#.,.!.#$5 #$+?-0?,, 0&-$'$2-+,1 $!)3<'@++$%$ !&3'" 03!@= &-*$27?,, , -%$ 0&-*&"A-+,1 * $.*$/$<'@++:5 !&3', $0-&",.!: *:'*,%"2, !-(,. $ !$=, )!$ * ,+'3.!&,"29+$= $/A-.!*-, %'- 0&$-,(*$'.!*$ $&%"+,($*"+$ 0$ 0&,+?,03 #$+*-5-&" («B$&',(=»), !&3' .*$/$'+:= /:!9 +- =$<-!. 8$C!$=3 03!@= ("/".!$*$#, ."/$!"<", 0$&), ,=3A-.!*" , 0&$),4 B$&= $!#"(" $! &"/$!: +-$/4$',=$ *:-+3',!9 #"0,!"2,(= .$*-&D-+.!*$*"!9 !-4+$2$%,,, .$*-&D"!9 0--&-4$' $! ,+'3.!&,"29+$%$ $/A-.!*" # $/A-.!*3 ,+B$&="?,$++:4 !-4+$2$%,5.

6$ *!$&$5 0$2$*,+- 1970-4 C!$ *-.9=" +-$'+$&$'+$- '*,<-+,-, 0-&-<,* &1' &".#$2$*, !&"+.B$&=,&3-!.1 * !"#$"!%&'()*, ,2, '+-$","*()*7, %'- *$(+,#"7! '*- $.+$*+:- !-+'-+?,,E– «"*!$+$=+:- ="&#.,.!:» , "*!$+$=+:- %&300: 2,/-&!"&+$%$ "+"&4,.!.#$%$ !$2#". F$/.!*-++$, 8"$2$ 6,&+$, #"# , G+!$+,$ H-%&,, $!+$.,! .-/1 # 0-&*$5.

>+,%" -&'**'$(.' *,"/%#$+' 0&-'.!"*21-! .$/$5 03/2,-#"?,7 '$#2"'" 6,&+$ +" .-=,+"&-, #$!$&:5 0&$4$',2 * 2001 %$'3 +" B"#329!-!- .$?,$2$%,, I+,*-&.,!-!" >"2"/&,, (.. 5), 0$C!$=3 .!&3#!3&+$ ,('"+,- '-2,!.1 +- +" %2"*:, " +" «'+,», *#27)"1 * .-/1 0&-',.2$*,-, )-!:&- '+1 .-=,+"&" , 0$.2-.2$*,- &-'"#!$&" G2-#.-1 8-+(,+". G#!3"29+$.!9 0$.!"*2-++:4 * #+,%- *$0&$.$* +- *:($*-! .$=+-+,1 3 ),!"!-21, #$!$&:5 4$!1 /: =,+,="29+$ 0$-%&3<@+ * #$+!-#.! .$*&-=-++$5 2-*$5 !-$&,, , +".3A+:4 0&$/2-= 2-*$%$ '*,<-+,1 * ?-2$=.

6 0-&*37 $)-&-'9, C!$ +"!&"# " !",0$(( «&'1"2%3" .4'##'», 0&-'.!"*21!9 #$!$&:5 3<- .$ *!$&$5 0$2$*,+: XX *-#" +- =$<-! 2,D9 #2".. ,+'3.!&,"29+:4 &"/$),4. J"(*,!,- .B-&: 3.23% , !$&-%$*2,, ,+!-22-#!3"2,("?,1 !&3'", ="..$*:5 *:*$' 0&$,(*$'.!* ,( «0-&*$%$» =,&" * «!&-!,5»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bid.7 Tronti, op.Ecit.

!. "!"#$% ! !&%''%(!)% '*#"+,($% !"#$# %&'(#

135! 1. 2013

! "#$%& '(")& *+,#$-(&'./ .0/1(##23 . *&402- !"#$#% !#-&$#' + .567&"'& *+8$'$9&."+%+ ,&3.'0$/ 0 5.8+0$/: .+04&-&##+%+ "(*$'(8$1-( $ + .*+.+6& &%+ +4%(#$1(;$$, 9'+ .&%+,#/ '(")& /0-8/&'./ *4&,-&'+- -#+%+9$.8&##2: ,&6('+0 $ +6.5),&#$3 .4&,$ 8&02: "4$'$"+0 "(*$'(8$1-(: .8&,5&' 8$ +.'(0('<./ #( *+1$;$/: 6+4<62 1( $#'&4&.2 «"8(..( =".*85('$45&-2:» $8$ )& #&+6:+-,$-+ 0"8>9$'< 0 *+0&.'"5 ,#/ «,45%$& 5%#&'?##2& %45**2» (*+ *4$1#("5 *+8(, 4(.2, .&".5(8<#+3 +4$&#'(;$$ $ *4.); *+ "("+-5 *4$#;$*5 ,+8)#+ +.5@&.'08/'<./ 0#5'4&##&& 01($-+,&3.'0$& 0 #+0+- ,0$)&#$$A– '4(,$;$+##(/ *(4'$3#(/ «$&4(4:$/» $8$ «%+-4$1+#'(8<#+-.&'&0+3» *4$#;$* +4%(#$1(;$$, $8$ $: 0+1-+)#2& .+9&'(#$/? (-"$)"*+,, (0'+4 .+0&4B(&' *+*2'"5 +'0&'$'< #( $1-0&9#23 0+*4+.: «C'+ ,&8('<?»A– D("+3 ,+8)#( 62'< .'4('&%$/ %8+-6(8<#2: +6@&.'0&##2: $1-&#&#$3?

E("$- +64(1+-, #( -+3 01%8/,, 0 "#$%& $,?' 4&9< + '4?: "8>-9&02: *4+68&-(: (:+'/ /0#+ +#$ (0'+4+- #& F+4-58$45>'./): "'+ /08/&'./ #+02- .567&"'+- .+;$(8<#2: $ *+8$'$9&."$: *4&+64(-1+0(#$3; "("$- +64(1+- +4%(#$1+0(# ,(##23 .567&"'; "("+0( .'4(-'&%$/ &%+ ,&3.'0$3?

G+,&4)(#$& "#$%$ 04(@(&'./ 0+"45% #&."+8<"$: 6(1+02: "+#-;&*'+0, 0 4(."42'$$ "+'+42: +.5@&.'08/&'./ *+*2'"( +'0&'$'< #( +6+1#(9&##2& 02B& '4$ 0+*4+.(. H'$ *+#/'$/A – I#+)&.'0+, *+.'F+4,$1-, *+1($-.'0+0(##(/ 5 J(##2 K4&#,' '4$(,( «E45,–L#'&88&"'–M&3.'0$&», General Intellect, L.:+,. N+-$-+ #$: !$4#+ 00+,$' &@? 4/, 0'+4+.'&*&##2: *+#/'$3: .'4(:/'4&0+%(, 0$4'5+1-#+.'<, *(4'$'54(, 6$+*+8$'$"(, +**+4'5#$1- $ ;$#$1-, 6+8'+0#/ $ 8>6+*2'.'0+. I2 +.'(#+0$-./ 8$B< #( '&:, "+'+42& *+8(%(&- 0 "(9&.'0& 6(1+02:.

N+#/'$& «!"#$%&'(#» (8('. multitudo, (#%8. multitude) 5)& +'-#+.$'&8<#+ *4+9#+ 0+B8+ 0 +6$:+, 45.."+/129#+3 $#'&88&"'5-(8<#+3 *568$"$ 68(%+,(4/ 1#("+-.'05 . *&4&0+,(-$ "#$% O&%4$ $ J(4,'( -.&)$+/ (2004) $ 01#2)'"!# (2006). P#+ +'.28(&' #(. " 3#4+"+5)'6#.7 "$86"8"7 G*$#+12 $ *+8$'$9&."+3 F$8+.+F$$ Q+66.(. R.8$ *&4023 +*$.20(&' «-#+)&.'0+» "(" $.'+9#$" %4()-,(#."$: .0+6+,, «-+@< #(4+,(»8, +*4&,&8/>@(/ «*4(0+ %+.5,(4-.'0(», '+ 0'+4+3, "(" 1(-&9(&' .(- !$4#+, «-#+)&.'0+ *4+.'+ '&4*&'< #& -+)&'» (.. 10). G+.'+/#$& 0+3#2 0.&: *4+'$0 0.&:, '(" #(120(&-+& «&.'&.'0&##+& .+.'+/#$&»,A – ='+ $ &.'< 4(1#+4+,#+& «-#+)&.'0+», *4+'$0+*+.'(08/&-+& Q+66.+- «#(4+,5» (populus)A– &,$#+-5 +4%(#$1-5, "+'+423 0+1#$"(&' *4$ 5.8+0$$ .5@&.'0+-0(#$/ Q+.5,(4.'0(-S&0$(F(#(. (C'+ :(4("'&4#+, #( 45.."$3 /12" multitudo G*$#+12 *&4&0+,$'./ "(" «#(4+,», Q+66.(A– "(" «-(..(», «'+8*(», .++'0&'.'0&##+ *+859(/ 4(18$9#5> .-2.8+05> $ ;&#-#+.'#5> #(%451"5.)

C'+ )& '(" *4$08&"8+ $'(8</#."$: (0'+4+0 0 *+851(62'+- '&4--$#&, *+1($-.'0+0(##+- $1 ,05: *4+'$0+*+8+)#2: *+ ,5:5 *+8$-8 G*$#+1(. 3#4+"+5)'6+% "$86"8". -9:$811;) &$#+9!)<)1+/. E. 2. I.,

1957. G. 188.

136

!"#$%&"' (")*%*("+ ,*-*.* -/$0$1"? 2)$345 %6"1*7*-%&*+ «6*7"-!"-1*+» !/8&!*-&$ 3811*.* %)*-8 " 9*:%*-*04 6/*!"-*6*%!8-)$1"; /871*/*31*.*, 3"(($/$1<"/*-811*.* «01*=$%!-8» " 0*1*)"!1*.* «18/*38», 6*%!*6$/8"%!> 781*-* --*35! $.* - *:*/*! 6*)"!"#$%&*+ (")*%*("". ?811>+ !$/0"1, 1$ *:)8385 =@%!&* 783811*+ - (")*-%*(%&*+ !/83"<"" %0>%)*-*+ 18./47&*+, - A!*+ %-*$+ «/>')*%!"» " 1$6/$3783811*%!" -$%B08 43*:$1 3)5 !*.*, #!*:> 18./47"!B $.* 3*6*)1"!$)B1>0 %0>%)*0 " % $.* 6*0*CB; *6"%8!B ($1*0$1 "7 8:-%*);!1* 1*-*+, 6* 01$1"; D"/1* (" E.F,$./"), %*<"8)B1*+ /$8)B-1*%!".

2 *31*+ %!*/*1>, «01*=$%!-*» (&8& 01*.**:/87185 <$)*%!-1*%!B, 1$ %-*3"085 & $3"1*04 7180$18!$);) 6/*!"-*6*%!8-)5$!%5 «18/*34» (6*15!"$, *!%>)8;C$$ 18% & $3"1%!-4 18<""-.*%438/-%!-8)F – 6/$3)8.8$!%5 6*)1*%!B; "%&);#"!B "7 )$&%"&*18 -!*/*$ -780$1 18 6$/-*$ &8& :*)$$ 83$&-8!1*$ 08/&%"%!%&"0 6/$3%!8-)$-1"50 * «18/*3$» " - <$)*0 18G$04 -/$0$1". 2 3/4.*+ %!*/*1>, *1* "%6*)B74$!%5 3)5 6$/$%0*!/8 !8&*.* &);#$-*.* 6*15!"5 &)8%%"#$-%&*.* 08/&%"708, &8& «/8:*#"+ &)8%%». ,$ *!:/8%>-85 6*)1*%!B; 6*15!"$ «/8:*#$.* &)8%%8», 8-!*/ %*-$/G8$! 6*6>!&4 *!&878!B%5 *! $.* 47&*.* 718#$1"5, *!%>)8;C$.* 18% & *6>!4 "134%!/"8)B1*+ A6*'" 3* -!*/*+ 6*)*-"1> XX -$&8, & 6/$3%!8-)$1"50 &)8%%"#$-%&*.* 08/&%"708 * 6/*)$!8/"8!$ &8& * 6/*0>G)$11>' /8:*#"', 8 !*#1$$, "%6*)B745 8-!*/%&4; !$/0"1*)*.";,F– & A6*'$ «(*/3"708».

D %-57" % A!"0 %-*" 38)B1$+G"$ /8%%4=3$1"5 D"/1* %!/*"! 18 *%1*-81"" !.F1. «!"#$%"&'(#$#)"*"» 6*3'*38, %*.)8%1* &*!*/*04 - 1*-$+G$+ "%!*/"" 0*=1* ->3$)"!B 3-8 *%1*-1>' A!868 %6*%*:8 6/*"7-*3%!-8, */.81"78<"" !/438, %*<"8)B1*+ 6*)"!"&" " 6*)"-!"&" - <$)*0: «(*/3"70» " «6*%!(*/3"70». ?)5 6$/-*.* '8/8&-!$/1> 08%%*-*$ &*1-$+$/1*$ 6/*"7-*3%!-* %!8138/!"7"/*-811>' !*-8/*-, !/43*-85 (8:/"#185 3"%<"6)"18, %")B185 3"(($/$1-<"8<"5 !/438 " - %-57" % A!"0 6/$-8)"/*-81"$ 6/"0"!"-1*.*, 1$ !/$:4;C$.* *%*:*+ &-8)"("&8<"" !/438, 6*)185 7815!*%!B, #@!&*$ /873$)$1"$ 0$=34 /8:*#"0 " 1$/8:*#"0 -/$0$1$0, %!"04)"/*--81"$ -14!/$11$.* 6*!/$:)$1"5, welfare-state " !.F6.9 H31"0 %)*-*0, &*1-$+$/185 3"%<"6)"18 18 6/*"7-*3%!-$ 6);% &$+1%"81%!-* - A&*1*0"&$ " 6*)"!"&$. D A6*'4 6*%!(*/3"708 - %")4 /538 6/"#"1, %/$3" &*!*/>' 1$-"3811*$ /87-"!"$ !$'1*)*."+, "70$1$1"$ %!/4&-!4/> %6/*%8 (-0$%!* !"6*->' !*-8/*- -%@ :*)$$ -*%!/$:*-811>0" %!81*-5!%5 «1$%!8138/!1>$» !*-8/> " /871**:/871>$ 4%)4."), %80 !/43, 6* 01$1"; D"/1*, "70$15$! %-*+ '8/8&!$/, %!81*-5%B -%@ :*)$$ «.":&"0», !/$:4;C"0 3/4."' 18->&*-, -*-)$&8;C"0 "1-!$))$&!, 57>&*->$ %6*%*:1*%!", 8(($&!> " 6/*#"$ %4C1*%!1>$ %-*+%!-8 «01*=$%!-8». D %-57" % A!"0 4 D"/1* (".4/"/4$! 1$ 6*-15!"$ /8:*#"+ &)8%%, 8 I1*=$%!-*F – «*%1*-185 &8!$.*/"5 6*)"-!"#$%&*+ 0>%)", " 73$%B 0> 6*)B74$0%5 $; 3)5 *:J5%1$1"5 1$&*-9 K$-#4& E.D. !"#$%"&'(#$#)(* )"+,*-,(( ()&($(.*#)(/ 0+01(2).

L8781B, 2000. 2. 14–20. [M)$&!/*11>+ /$%4/%] N*#&8 3*%!468: http://ecsocman.hse.ru/text/19198507/

!. "!"#$% ! !&%''%(!)% '*#"+,($% !"#$# %&'(#

137! 1. 2013

!"#$% "&#'(')*+,-% .'#!, &#-/0,-% &"/!1"#(-/!/2"30 /&"/"40 &#"-56"(/!67» (/. 48). 87997* 27!':"#-* &#-56797 "4;'(-9-!< &"( 5972"3 2)7//7 =2/&)07!-#0'3$% 6/'% 97>39$% #74"!9-2"6?– «1--5-.'/2":"» - «03/!6'99":"» !#0(7, &#"-56"(/!6'99"@ - 9'&#"-5-6"(/!6'99"@ /1'#$.

A/!".9-2"3 '(-9/!67 B9"C'/!67 /)0C7! «"4,-' 3'/!7 #75037, "4,-' )-9:6-/!-.'/2"-&"59767!')<9$' /&"/"49"/!-» (/. 40), -)- General Intellect,? – ',> "(9" &"9*!-' -5 -/!"#-2"-1-)"/"1/2":" 97/)'(-* (97 =!"! #75?– -5 !"#$#%# &'(#$#)*+%', -%'.'/##» ()*"-.'0', .12"'+'% 1857–1858) B7#2/7), !72 C' 272 - multitudo, 9' #7/-2#$!"' 6 "#-:-97)<9"3 !'2/!' - "!!":" 9' /)-D2"3 97:#0C'99"' 272-3-)-4" -597.7)<9$3 /3$/)"3. 8)* ':" &"*/9'9-* E-#9" 7&')-)-#0'! 2 ',> 4")'' (#'69-3 -/!".9-273, "!/$)7* .-!7!')* 2 !'#-3-90 «"4,-' 3'/!7» (topoi konoi) -5 3#$'"#%# F#-/!"!')* (/. 29). G72-3 "4#75"3:

«'(-9/!6", 2"!"#"' 97%"(-!/* 57 /&-9"@ 39"C'/!67, /"5(79" “"4,-3- 3'/!73-” #75037, "4,-3- )-9:6-/!-.'/2"-&"59767!')<9$3- /&"/"4-9"/!*3- 97D':" 6-(7, / &"3",<+ General Intellect» (/. 40).

E /-!07H-- &'#'3'9 (799$' «"4,-' 3'/!7» 6 #'.-, &" /)"673 76!"#7 4"1//1$#%# /.'5*+$01, «6$%"(*! 97#0C0» - (7+! 973 «2#-!'#-- "#-'9!7H--» !73, :(' «!#7(-H-"99$' /""4,'/!67 #75-#0D7+!/* - :(' 974)+(7'!/* 9'57,-,>99"/!< "! 3-#7 6 ':" !"!7)<-9"/!-» (/. 30–31). G72"' &"*/9'9-', 97 3"@ 65:)*(, /2"#'' 57!'39*'!, .'3 &#"*/9*'! &"57-3/!6"6799$@ -5 "(9":" 3'/!7 6 Grundrisse B7#2/7 !'#3-9. I#-6)'.'9-' C' 76!"#"3 7#:03'9!"6, 27/7+,-%/* «#75#0D'9-* !#7(-H-"99$% "4,'/!6» (9' /"6/'3 &"9*!9", 272-' -3'99" !#7(-H-"99$' "4,'/!67 -3'+!/* 6 6-(0), - 6"6/' 06"(-! 97/ 6 /!"#"90 "! 2"9H'&!7 «"4,':" -9!'))'2!7». E (7)<9'@D'3, &"-3-3" "4,-% 027579-@ 97 !", .!" General Intellect?– =!" 9'2-' "4,-' 2"3309-27!-69"-&"59767!')<9$' /&"/"49"/!- B9"C'/!67, 6 29-:' 9' &#-6"(-!/* &"(#"49":" #7/2#$!-* !'#3-97 / "!/$)2"@ 2 /"H--7)<9"30 1'9"3'90, 2"!"#$@ "9 &#-5679 "&-/$67!<, 2 &#-3'#73 &#"*6)'9-@ «"4,'/!6'99":" -9!'))'2!7» 6 /"6#'3'99"3 3-#'. F 6'(<, 272 - B9"C'/!6", General Intellect?– =!" 475"6"' &"9*!-' &"-)-!-.'/2"@ 1-)"/"1-- E-#9", "&-/$67'3"' -3 "(9"6#'3'99" 272 "/9"697* &#"-56"(-!')<97* /-)7 /"6#'3'99"/!- - 272 "/9"67 ()* 9"6":" &")-!-.'/2":" ('@/!6-*, ()* /73""#:79-57H-- /04;'2!7?– B9"C'/!67. I"&$!20 (7!< !720+ "!/$)20 /(')7)- ':" 2"))':-:

«B$ /3"C'3 )0.D' &"9*!< "!9"D'9-* 3'C(0 "4,'/!6'99$3 &#"--56"(/!6"3 - 4-"6)7/!<+ … -/&")<50* !72-' !'#3-9$, 272 “-9!')-)'2!07)<97* /-)7 37//”, “737!'#-7)<9$@ !#0(”, 7 !72C' 37#2/-/!/20+ 2"9H'&H-+ “6/'"4,':" -9!'))'2!7”. … E'(0,7* #")< 6 /"5(79-- &#--476".9"@ /!"-3"/!-, &#'C(' &#-97()'C76D7* !#0(0 #74"!9-2"6 37/-/"6":" 174#-.9":" &#"-56"(/!67, 6" 6/> 4")<D'@ 3'#' &'#'%"(-! 2

138

!"#$%&'(") ")"%*!'"+,&$-$ %!./", 0"&1%2) 3 45*!* 6!$'03$/4%3" ' 6*!*/"7' '&5$!)"8''»10.

9"(') $#!"0$), *4+' 6$62%"%,41 6$/2%$:'%,, 6$/ «$#;') '&-%*++*(%$)» )$:&$ 6$&')"%, "#4%!"(%&$* 32!":*&'* 34*< 4$3$(.6-&$4%' ($++*(%'3&2= 46$4$#&$4%*< ' ($)6*%*&8'< 7*+$3*7*4%3" &" $6!*/*+>&&$) '4%$!'7*4($) ?%"6*. @ .4+$3'1= ("6'%"+'4%'7*4($-$ 6!$'03$/4%3" $&' 6$/7'&*&2 '&%*!*4") '03+*7*&'1 6!'#2+', " 6$?%$). $%7.:/*&2 $% &*6$4!*/4%3*&&2= 3+"/*+,8*3 ' 3 $3*;*4%-3+>&&$) 3'/* 6!'&')"A% 5$!). !"0+'7&2= %$3"!$3 ' .4+.-. B+1 $#!"%&$-$ 6!'43$*&'1 34*-$ #$-"%4%3" 0&"&'<, %*=&$+$-'<, ($)).-&'("8'<, 6$ 3*!4'' @'!&$, &*$#=$/')$ 4$3*!C'%, 3":&2< C"-D– $% «"+,1&4"» !"#$%%$&#' ( )*+,' 6*!*<%' ( «&$3$). "+,1&4.» !"-#$%%$&#' ( -.%(#(/$0&.1. 2$30#4(5 (4. 81). (E/*4, 3$0&'("A% $7*!*/&2* 0"')4%3$3"&&2* ("%*-$!''D– &" ?%$% !"0 36$+&* !"0!"-#$%"&&2*: '= '46$+,0.*% ' /">% ') 43$> %$+($3"&'* F"&&" G!*&/% 3 (&'-* Vita activa, !"! # $!%&! '()*("+&,-.) H&%*++*(%, 6!$13-+1A;'< 4*#1 3 ("6'%"+'4%'7*4($) )'!* +'C, 3 &">)&$) %!./* ' %"(') $#!"0$) 6!$%'3$6$4%"3+*&&2< 4*#* 4")$)., &*$#=$/')$ ("(')-%$ $#!"0$) 323*4%' 3 45*!. ./0"!1&,2, (%$ *4%, «6$+'%'7*-4($-$», ("( *-$ 6$&')"*%, 3 %$) 7'4+*, G!*&/%), 3 45*!. B*<4%3'1. @ ("7*4%3* 4%!"%*-'', 6$03$+1A;*< 6!$'03*4%' ?%$% «4("7$(», "3%$! 345665*!7! 6&,$(8*95 6!*/+"-"*% ($&8*68'' «-!":/"&4($-$ &*-6$3'&$3*&'1» ' «'4=$/"»:

«I"( )$:&$ 3$$#!"0'%, 4*#* 6$+'%'7*4($* /*<4%3'*, #"0'!.A-;**41 &" General Intellect? J$ ?%$< 0*)+* &.:&$ 4%.6"%, $7*&, $4%$-!$:&$. @4>, 7%$ )$:&$ 4/*+"%,,D – ?%$ .("0"%, &" ",2!1(87/: ;,46/ 7*-$-%$, 7*). &*/$4%">% $4&$3"%*+,&$-$ ?)6'!'7*4($-$ $62%". J!*/-+"-"A /3" (+A7*32= 4+$3": -!":/"&4($* &*6$3'&$3*&'* ' '4=$/» (4.D82).

I 4$:"+*&'A, ("( ' 3 4+.7"* 4 !1/$) 6!*/2/.;'= %*!)'&$3, ?%' /3" $#K14&1A%41 0/*4, (!"<&* +"($&'7&$, #.(3"+,&$ &" $/&$<-/3.= 4%!"&'8"=. J$/ «-!":/"&4(') &*6$3'&$3*&'*)» 6$/!"0.)*3"A%41, 6$-3'/')$)., 3$34* &* 6!"(%'(' !"0&$-$ !$/" &*&"4'+,4%3*&&$-$ 4$6!$%'3+*&'1, 0"#"4%$3$( ' 6!. L$:&$ 6!*/6$+$:'%,, 7%$ 6!*/+"--"*%41 &*('< -+$#"+,&2< $%("0 L&$:*4%3" $% M$4./"!4%3" ' *-$ '&-4%'%.%$3D– 3 6!*/*+,&$ "#4%!"(%&$) 3'/* 6$4%.+'!.*%41 &*$#=$/'-)$4%, 32=$/" '0 '-!2 6$ 6!"3'+"), 6!*/0"/"&&2) 4.;*4%3.A;') 0"($&$/"%*+,4%3$), &*-+"4&2)' 3&.%!*&&')' .4%"&$3+*&'1)' ' %.D6.: «!"/'("+,&$* &*6$3'&$3*&'*, $ ($%$!$) )2 -$3$!'), 4%"3'% 6$/ 3$6!$4 %. 4").A 46$4$#&$4%, ( 6!'("0. 4$ 4%$!$&2 M$4./"!-4%3"» (4. 82). N$#4%3*&&$, 0/*4, )2 6*!*=$/') ( ($&8*6%. «'4=$/"». B+1 *-$ 6$14&*&'1 "3%$! $#!";"*%41 ( 4=*)* 4$8'$+$-" ' ?($&$-)'4%" G+,#*!%" F'!C)"&" '0 *-$ (&'-' <=>,', 2,",8 ! 9(4&,8*+11, 10 F"!/% L., O*-!' G. ?6.(4!). L.: J!"(4'4, 2004. N. 40–41.11 F'!C)"& G.P. <=>,', 2,",8 ! 9(4&,8*+: 4(57@!) &5 /.5',7 ;!46, ,425-

&!%5@!- ! 2,8/'548*9. L.: O$3$* '0/-3$, 2009.

!. "!"#$% ! !&%''%(!)% '*#"+,($% !"#$# %&'(#

139! 1. 2013

!"#$%!&" '"(")"* +",-".&/ ()0 !()%(1#00 '"$$1'(0+&"#" 2"+1-31&04 + "(+1( &% 565371&01 '%81!(+% ("+%)%, 9)1&3% (0$0 .1 5!$5#0, #"!53%)!(+1&&"#" 0&!(0(5(%): 2)"(1!(, $"4$:&"!(: 0$0 "('%, (exit).

;%' 0 + !$58%1 ! )%30'%$:&/- (#)%.3%&!'0-) &12"+0&"+1&01-, %+(") +1!:-% !'52" 2)"4!&41( !+"< 2"&0-%&01 «0!6"3%». = "3&"* !(")"&/, >0)&" 2)"(0+"2"!(%+$41( 1#" 2)"(1!(5, &%,/+%4 0!6"3 !'")11 «31,1)(0)!(+"-», 0 + '%81!(+1 2)0-1)% + "81)13&"* )%, 2)0-+"30( ,%0-!(+"+%&&5? 5 @%)'!% 0!(")0? «" -%!!"+"- 91#!(+1 "( ,%+"3!'"#" )%!2")43'%, )1%$0,"+%&&"- %-1)0'%&!'0-0 )%9"80-0 + !1)130&1 AIA +1'%: 2)"3+0#%4!: +!< 3%$:71 ' “B)"&(0)5” 3$4 '"-$"&0,%C00 317<+/6 ,1-1$:, "&0 +"!2"$:,"+%$0!: +",-".&"!(:? )%30'%$:&" 0,-1&0(: !+"< 0!6"3&"1 2"$".1&01» (!. 85), % (%'.1 "('%, 0(%$:4&!'"* -"$"3<.0 + '"&C1 1970-6 "( 2"!("4&&"* ,%&4-("!(0 &% 9"$:706 2)132)04(046 + 2"$:,5 +)1-1&&"* 0 8%!(08&"* ,%&4("!(012.

D")%,3" 9"$11 2"$&" 3%&&/* (1)-0& )%!')/( + !(%(:1 E.FG1&-,0&% !"#$%, + '"(")"* 2"38<)'0+%1(!4 !+4,: 3%&&"#" '"&C12(% ! (1)-0&"$"#01* H.FI1$<,% 0 J.FD+%((%)0 («&"-%30,-», 31(1))0("-)0%$0,%C04», «$0&00 91#!(+%») 0 "!5K1!(+$41(!4 2"2/('% 9"$11 8<('" L'!2$0C0)"+%(: ,&%81&01 3%&&"#" !$"+%:

«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»13.

O%!'"$:'" .1 53%$"!: %+(")5 )%,)170(: ()0 2)"9$1-/, "9"-,&%81&&/1 -&"* + !%-"- &%8%$1 '%' '$?81+/1 3$4 3%&&"#" (1'!(%: "20!%&01 !"+)1-1&&"#" )%9"81#" '$%!!% 0 +/31$1&01 &"+"#" !59P-12 > '%81!(+1 2)0-1)% -".&" &%,+%(: B1&"-1& «B)0(1)"+» (42. fur&t') +

!"+)1-1&&"* Q2"&00F – -&"#"-0$$0"&&"* -%!!/ -"$"3<.0, 2" !"9-!(+1&&"* 0&0C0%(0+1 0$0 + !0$5 "9!("4(1$:!(+ &1 +!()"0+71*!4 + '")2")%(0+&5? !0!(1-5 2".0,&1&&"#" &%*-% 2" 42"&!'"-5 "9)%,C5. J)0(1)/, &1 0-14 !(%90$:&"* ,%&4("!(0, &1 +6"34( + 2)"B!"?,/, &1 2$%(4( +,&"!/ + 21&!0"&&/1 B"&3/, '%' 2)%+0$", &1 ,%+"34( 31(1* 0, + "($0801 "( !+"06 9"$11 «5!217&/6» !+1)!(&0'"+, "9$%3%?( -%!!"* !+"9"3&"#" +)1-1&0. > !"+)1-1&&"* Q2"&00 "&0, ! "3&"* !(")"&/, +/!(52%?( + )"$0 %)-00 &0,'"'+%$0B0C0)"+%&&/6 )%9"(&0'"+, + "(-&"71&00 '"(")/6 )%9"("3%(1$: B%'(081!'0 &1 0-11( &0'%'06 "94,%-(1$:!(+, ! 3)5#"*F– )%!!-%()0+%?(!4 + '%81!(+1 5#)",/ '")2")%(0+-&"* '5$:(5)1, "9K1!(+1&&"-5 5'$%35 0 31-"#)%B081!'"* !0(5%C00 + «!(%)1?K1*» Q2"&00.

13 G1&,0& E. R!6"3 // ()*$+,$-.$) "$$/0)"1*$. 23$""4567. @., 2012. [M$1'()"&&/* )1!5)!] S"8'% 3"!(52%: http://issuu.com/quietmars/docs/glossariy/1.

140

!"#$ %&'($)*+,- ./!&0/$1&2$+(3 ("&+'!.# 4+&5!%#2$), &./!6!-)!+(! %.&%&0$ !7& 2+8#/!++!3 &/7$+(1$'(( (4+&5!%#2& ( General Intellect), /$%"/,#(! !7& %#/$#!7(( 6!3%#2(3 ((%-&6)? 9$ :&3 217);6, <#$ .&.,#"$ &"$1$)$%* +! %)(="&: 86$>+&3 2 %()8 >/!12,>$3+&3 ./(2!/5!++&%#( $2#&/$ (%.&)*1&2$+(? #!/:(+&2 2 ./!6!)*+& $0-%#/$"#+&: 1+$>!+((, $ #$"5! +!"&#&/&3 ./&(12&)*+&%#( 2 (- 2,-0&/! ( #/$"#&2"!. «@/$"#(>!%"$; A()&%&A(;» ( #$"&7& /&6$ «%-&-)$%#(>!%"(3» .&6-&6, $ #&>+!!B– (+#!))!"#8$)*+&! .8#!=!%#2(! &# "$#!7&/(( " "$#!7&/(( 0!1 >C#"(- 6!A(+('(3 ( "&+"/!#(1$'(( 22&-6(:,- #!/:(+&2, ./!6%#$2);?#%; :+! +!%&2:!%#(:,:(. D (#&7! :, (:!!: 6&%#$#&>+& &%#/&8:+8?, +& $0%&)?#+& :!#$A(1(>!%"8? :&6!)*, &0/$1&2$++8? (1 %)&5+&7& %&>!#$+(; .&)(#(>!%"&3 .)$#-A&/:, (.&%#)&.!/$(1:$, "&+'!.'(( .&%#A&/6(1:$, A!+&:!+&-)&7(( E$++, F/!+6#, /;6$ &#%,)&" " 4$/#(+8 E$366!7!/8,B– 2%C <#& 2:!%#! /$10$2)!+& .&+;#(!: General Intellect, .&1$(:%#2&2$++,: (1 &6+&7& +!0&)*=&7& A/$7:!+#$ 8 4$/"%$. @/( <#&: 1+$>!+(! #/C- ")?>!2,- .&+;#(3: 4+&5!%#2&, General Intellect ( (%-&6B– >(#$#!)* 2,+856!+ 6&:,%)(2$#* %$:&%#&;#!)*+&.

G &6+&3 %#&/&+,, .&.,#"$ ./!6!)*+& /$%=(/(#* .&+;#(! «/$-0&>!7& ")$%%$», 2,2!%#( !7& 1$ /$:"( 81"&7& 1+$>!+(; /$0&>(- ./&:,=)!++&%#(B– <#& ./&6("#&2$++$; %&2/!:!++,:( /!$)(;:( +!&0-&6(:&%#*. H6+$"& 0&)*=&3 :(+8% «%80I!"#$-:+&5!%#2$» 1$-")?>$!#%; 2 #&:, >#& &+ %)(="&: /$1:,#, !7& 6(AA!/!+'(/&2$+-+&%#* 2 !6(+%#2! )(=* .&%#8)(/8!#%;. 9!;%+,: &%#$C#%;, >!7& &+ -&>!# ( :&5!# -&#!#*, 2 >C: 1$")?>$!#%; !7& «")$%%&2,3» (+#!/!% (!%)( #$"&2&3 (:!!#%;)? J%)( #$"&7& !6(+&7& (+#!/!%$ +! %8K!-%#28!#, #& :&5!: )( :, 7&2&/(#* & +C: "$" & !6(+&: %80I!"#!? L)(, :&5!# 0,#*, 8 +!7& !%#* +!"(! .!/2(>+,!, &0I!6(+;?K(!, (+#!-/!%, ( 2#&/(>+,!, .&6>C/"(2$?K(! 2+8#/!++(! /$1)(>(;? 9$ 2%! <#( 2&./&%, $2#&/ +! 6$C# &#2!#$.

9! #$" 2%C &6+&1+$>+& ( % %$:&3 "&+'!.'(!3 .&%#A&/6(1:$, "&-#&/$; +!&6+&"/$#+& .&62!/7$)$%* "/(#("! 1$ %2&3 68$)(1:, «(1&-0()(! 8./&KC++,- 0(+$/+,- ./&#(2&.&%#$2)!+(3 (A&/6(1:B – .&%#A&/6(1:, :$%%&2&! ./&(12&6%#2&B – 7(0"$; %.!'($)(1$'(; ( #.B..)»14. M #&:8 5! %$:$ .& %!0! &+$ 2!%*:$ +!&6+&/&6+$, 2 !C /$:"$- (:!!#%; +!%"&)*"& .&6-&6&2, /$1)(>+,: &0/$1&: (+#!/./!#(/8-?K(- #/$+%A&/:$'(? #/86$. @&%#A&/6(%#,B– %#&/&++("( #!&/(( /!78);'((B– +$.&:(+$?# +$: & +!/$2+&:!/+&: :(/&2&: /$12(#(( ( &#)(>(;- 2 %A!/! #/86$ 2 /$1)(>+,- /!7(&+$-:

«M&+'!.'(; 7(0"&3 %.!'($)(1$'(( ( +!&=8:.!#!/($+', 2 '!)&: /(%8?# “/&1&28?” "$/#(+8 0868K!7& 2 &#)(>(! &# #!&/(( /!78);'((… N"$1,2$!#%; #$"5! +$ 68$)(%#(>+&%#* /,+"$ /$0&>!3 %(),, 2!68K!3 " #&:8, >#& "2$)(A('(/&2$++$; /$0&#$ 2,.&)+;!#%; /$0&>(:( (1 ;6/$, #&76$ "$" +!"2$)(A('(/&2$++$; #!3)&/(%#%"$; /$0&#$ &%#$C#%; +$ .!-/(A!/((, ;6/& -$/$"#!/(18!# 7(0"$; %(%#!:$, #&76$ "$" +$ .!/(A!/((

14 O!2>8", 8"$1.B%&>., %. 47.

!. "!"#$% ! !&%''%(!)% '*#"+,($% !"#$# %&'(#

141! 1. 2013

!"#$"%!&!'!()$#%* &+(,!-., (/0+#"!1/.! *,(/ 2 +%"+2"+. *23*-4#%* .)56!"7, #+8,/ 1/1 5$"9!"7 "/:+,*#%* "/ ;$(!&$(!!»15.

< %/.+. ,$3$, 2 "/(!%+2/""+= <!("+ 1/(#!"$ «!"#$33$1#)-/3!-/'!!» #(),/ +0"/()5!2/$#%* 6($-.$("/* -/'!13$""+%#> "/ %+%#+*"!! ,$3 2 #/1 "/-72/$.+. «;$(2+. .!($» % $8+ !"&+(-./#!-/'!$=, ,$!",)%#(!/3!-/'!$=, (/-2!#!$. %$1#+(/ #+(8+23! ! )%3)8. < #+ 2($.* 1/1 2 %#(/"/: ;$(!&$(!! -/ %6?# "$2!,/""+= @1%;3)/#/'!! ./%%+2+8+ "$12/3!&!'!(+2/""+8+ #(),/ (2%;+."!. "$,/2"!= %3)6/= 8!0$3! 0+3$$ #7%*6! (/0+#"!' ! (/0+#"!1+2 "/ A2$="+= &/0(!1$ 2 B/"83/,$A) $5$,"$2"+ ;(+!-2+,!#%* +8(+."+$ 1+3!6$%#2+ #+2/(+2 ,3* ;+#($0!#$3$= «(/-2!#+8+ .!(/». C/1 6#+, 2$(+*#"+, %3$,)$# ;(!%3)A/#>%* "$ 1 "$+A).;$#$(!/"%1+.), / 1 ./(1%!%#%1+.) #$6$"!4 ;+%#&+(,!-./ (#$+(!! ($8)3*'!!), ;($,-%1/-72/49$.) ,/3>"$=A)4 !"#$"%!&!1/'!4 &+(,!-./ "/ «;$-(!&$(!!». D $%3! "/ ,/""7= .+.$"# E!#/= 0+3$$ )5$ "$ *23*$#%* %!.2+3+. (7"1/ ,$A?2+= (/0+6$= %!37, #+ $8+ .$%#+ -/"*3! B/"-83/,$A, <>$#"/., E/.0+,5/ ! D",+"$-!*, / %3$,)49!. 2 +6$($,!, 2$(+*#"+, %#+!# /&(!1/"%1!= 1+"#!"$"#.

F/.7. 5$ !,$/3!%#!6$%1!. ! )#+;!6$%1!. .+.$"#+. 2 1"!8$ 2783*,!# ;+;7#1/ +#2$#/ "/ 2+;(+% «6#+ ,$3/#>?». G)%#> «!%:+,» 1/1 +#2$# "/ ,/""7= 2+;(+%H – @#+ 3!A> %/.7= +09!= ;3/", «"/-0(+%+1», 1/1 ;+,6?(1!2/$# /2#+(, #$. "$ .$"$$ +" )5$ 1/5$#%* %3!A1+. %3/07. ! )*-2!.7. 2 (+3! ;)%#> ,/5$ %/.+= +09$= ;+-;7#1! ;+.7%3!#> "$2+-.+5"+$, 27=,* -/ ;($,$37 "/3!6"7: ;+3!-#!6$%1!: ;(/1#!1:

«F +,"+= %#+(+"7, General Intellect )#2$(5,/$#%* 2 2!,$ /2#+-"+."+= +09$%#2$""+= %($,7, #+3>1+ $%3! +#($-/$#%* %+$,!"$"!$, 1+#+(+$ ;(!2*-72/$# $8+ 1 ;(+!-2+,%#2) #+2/(+2 ! "/?."+.) #(),). F ,()8+= %#+(+"7, "!%;(+2$(5$"!$ 1/;!#/3!%#!6$%1!: +#"+A$"!= ;(+!-2+,%#2/ .+5$# ;(+*2!#>%* #+3>1+ % )%#/"+23$"!$. !"#$%&'()-%*+"!!$, -&./01!$, %2")3, ;+3!#!6$%1+8+ %++09$%#2/, !.$49$8+ 2 %2+$= +%"+2$ General Intellect» (%. 81).

I$ %3!A1+. +6$2!,"+, 1/1 !.$""+ .+5$# &+(.!(+2/#>%* @#/ /2#+"+."/* +09$%#2$""/* %($,/, 2 6?. )5$ .+5"+ )%.+#($#> $? ;(+*23$"!* ($%3! #+3>1+ ($6> "$ + %)01)3>#)(/:, %12+##!"8$, "$--/2!%!.7: 8/3$($*:, )3!6"7: ;$(&+(./"%/: ! ;(+6!: «;(+8($%-%!2"7: ;(/1#!1/:», !.$49!: %#/#)% %1+($$ :),+5$%#2$""+8+ 5$%#/, 6$. ;+3!#!6$%1+8+ ,$=%#2!*, @%1/;!-./, "$5$3! ;+;7#1! 27:+,/ -/ ;($,$37 2+-.+5"+8+).16

15 J$26)1, )1/-.H%+6., %. 33.16 K#%731! 5$ /2#+(/ 1 «0$8%#2)» /.$(!1/"%1!: (/0+6!: 2 "$ -/"*#7$

"!1$. ((/-2$ 6#+ !",$='/.!) -/;/,"7$ -$.3! 3!A> %0!2/4# % #+31), #.H 1. 27-72/4# /%%+'!/'!! % «8+3+%)49!.! "+8/.!» ."+8+6!%3$"-"7.! 8/%#/(0/=#$(/.! !- <+%#+6"+= L2(+;7 ! @1%-FFFM. I/ ,/""7= .+.$"# @#/ .+0!3>"+%#> (/0+6$= %!37H – +%"+2"+$, 6#+ %,$(5!2/$# 2+3") %+'!/3>"+8+ 2-(72/ 2 %#(/"/:-/)#%/=,$(/:.

142

!"#$%& «'()"#*» +$ ",-.(+.$/, !"!#$ %&'"(%$ 0+"1$(/2" (3"(",+" 4/2$5#'/& *2/"+"0+46 ",7$(/2$++46 (5$#4, 35'(2"'/& ($,$ ",5*/+" (2"6 «1'8+$++46 ('%4»9– General Intellect. : '(/"5'' 2/"5"; 3"%"2'+< XX 2$=* $(/& ">$+& ('%&+<; 35'0$5 /"?", =*= /*=*. 3"3</=* ,<%* "(47$(/2%$+* ' /5*?'>+" 35"2*%'%*(&9– 5$>& " @'%' 25$0A+ B%&$+#$, ?#$ 2 3$5'"# ( 1970 3" 1973 35"'8"CA% +$-2'#*++<; 3"#-A0 0*(( (0+"1$(/2*), 2(3%$(= #$;(/2'/$%&+" «+*-5"#+"?" /2"5>$(/2*»9– 35'0$5 +*5"#+"?" $#'+(/2*17 2 $?" 0+"1$-(/2$++"(/' ' +$"#+"5"#+"(/'. D#+*=" "?5"0+<; 3"/$+E'*% F/"?" 3"#-A0* 5*8+"",5*8+<) ('% +$ 4(3$% ($,. 35".2'/& =*= (%$#4$/, 3"(="%&=4 ,<% ?54," 5*8#*2%$+9 – +$ 2 3"(%$#+66 ">$5$#& 8#$(& (<?5*%" 8%46 5"%& "/(4/(/2'$ (3"(",+"(/' 8*7'7*/& (2"' 8*2"-$2*+'.. G* ($?"#+. 0< '0$$0 ,"%$$ (2$1'$ 35'0$5<: OCCUPY 2 HIB ' J25"3$, «*5*,(=*. 2$(+*» 2 K4+'($ ' J?'3/$. J(%' 2 3$52"0 (%4>*$ «2+$3"%'/'>$(=';» =*5+*2*% «0+"1$(/2*» ,<% 5*8"?+*+ ('-%"2<0' 0$/"#*0', * /*=1$ ,<(/5" (*0 ($,. '(>$53*%, /" 2 (%4>*$ K4+'(* ' J?'3/* E$+"; ,"%&C') 1$5/2 4#*%"(& "/(/"./& 3",$#4. G" /$0 3$>*%&+$$ "=*8*%(. 5$84%&/*/: 2 "/(4/(/2'$ $#'+<) E$%$; ' (3%">A++"; "5?*+'8*E'' 5*85"8+$++"$ «0+"1$(/2"» 35"'?5*%" 5*#'=*%&+<0 04(4%&0*+(='0 L"50'5"2*+'.0 ( "35$#$%A++"; (/54=/45"; ' '#$"%"?'$;.

M"F/"04 3"=* +* 4%'E*) H*+/&.?", H/*0,4%*, B+=*5<, N*'5*, !$)'=" ' /.9 #. 35"%'2*$/(. =5"2& ' %6#$; /5*2./ ?*8"0, 0"1+" (=*8*/&, >/" ,"5&,* 8* «*2/"+"0'6», 8* «+$2"80"1+"$» +'>$0 +$ 3")"1* +* 0"#$%& '()"#*, 35$#%"1$++46 M*"%" :'5+". @/",< «/5$,"2*/& +$2"80"1+"?"» ' 2<;/' 8* 5*0=' ('(/$0<, +$",)"#'0" (%"0*/& (*04 ('(/$049 – '+*>$ "+* ">$+& ,<(/5" 35$($>A/ %6,<$ 3"3</=' 2<;/' 8* $A 35$#$%<. B >/" =*(*$/(. 5$2"%6E'"++"?" (4,-$=/*, /" "+ +$ 2"8+'=+$/ '+*>$, >$0 2 35"E$(($ /*="; ,"5&,<, 34/A0 3"'(=* «5*#'=*%&+" +"2"?" ("E'*%&+"?", 3"%'/'>$(="?", "5-?*+'8*E'"++"?" ' F="+"0'>$(="?" 0'5"2"885$+'.»18, +"2<) "5?*-+'8*E'"++<) L"50, >$5$8 +$'8,$1+<$ +* F/"0 34/' "C',='.

17 «G*5"#+"$ $#'+(/2"» ('(3. Unidad Popular)9 – ="*%'E'. %$2<) ' %$-2"E$+/5'(/(=') 3"%'/'>$(=') 3*5/'; ' "5?*+'8*E'; 2 @'%', ="/"5<$ 3"##$51'2*%' =*+#'#*/454 H*%&2*#"5* B%&$+#$ +* 2<,"5*) 35$8'-#$+/* 2 1970 ?"#4.

18 :'%&.0( B., I5+'>$= G. )!*+,+'"-#%.#*/*!#0 $".#1+*/ // [O%$=-/5"++<; 5$(45(] K">=* #"(/43*: http://liva.com.ua/manifesto-accelerate.html.

!. "!"#$% ! !&%''%(!)% '*#"+,($% !"#$# %&'(#