Dlaczego kochamy kicz? Teorie kulturowe i ewolucjonistyczne

17
.$0,/ à8&=$- '/$&=(*2 .2&+$0< .,&=" 7(25,( .8/7852:( , (:2/8&-21,67<&=1( :67ĉ3 1LQLHMV]\ DUW\NXá VWDQRZL UHIOHNVMĊ QDG GZRPD WHRULDPL NWyUH VWDUDMą VLĊ Z\ MDĞQLü JHQH]Ċ ]MDZLVND NLF]X ZH ZVSyáF]HVQHM NXOWXU]H 7UDG\F\MQH SRGHMĞFLH NWyUH RNUHĞODP PLDQHP ÄNXOWXURZHJR´ Z\ZRG]L VLĊ ] SUDF $EUDKDPD 0ROHVD OHF] Z QDXNDFK VSRáHF]Q\FK ZáDĞFLZHJR VIRUPXáRZDQLD GRNRQDá 3LHUUH %RXUGLHX 3DUDG\JPDW WHQ ]DNáDGD ĪH OXG]NLH JXVWD Vą ]UyĪQLFRZDQH NODVRZR D ZSá\Z QD XSRGREDQLH GR NLF]X PDMą WDNLH F]\QQLNL MDN SR]LRP GRFKRGX Z\NV]WDáFHQLD F]\ ZLHONRĞü PLHMVFRZRĞFL ] NWyUHM NWRĞ SRFKRG]L 2G SRF]ąWNX ODW ;; ZLHNX SRSXODUQRĞü ]GRE\ZD MHGQDN SDUDG\JPDW RSDUW\ QD 'DUZLQRZVNLHM WHRULL HZROXFML %DGDF]H WDF\ MDN 'HQLV 'XWWRQ F]\ 1DQF\ $LNHQ ]ZUDFDMą XZDJĊ ĪH HZROXFMD Z\NV]WDáFLáD SHZQH XSRGREDQLD HVWHW\F]QH NWyUH SUHG\VSRQXMą OXG]L GR XZLHOELHQLD SU]HGPLRWyZ NLF]RZDW\FK 7HRULD NXOWXURZD SRND]XMąFD ĪH OXG]NLH SUHIHUHQFMH HVWHW\F]QH Vą ]DOHĪQH RG SRáRĪHQLD NODVRZHJR VXJHUXMH ZLĊF ĪH NLF] MHVW RJUDQL F]RQ\ GR XSRGREDĔ Z\EUDQHM JUXS\ VSRáHF]QHM 7HRULD HZROXFMRQLVW\F]QD SRVWU]HJD ]DĞ OXG]NLH VNáRQQRĞFL GR NLF]X MDNR QDWXUDOQH L REHFQH Z FDá\P VSRáHF]HĔVWZLH : W\P VHQVLH Z\GDMH VLĊ RQD VSyMQD ] SRJOąGHP +HUPDQQD %URFKD NWyU\ SLVDá ĪH ÄNLF] QLH PyJáE\ ERZLHP DQL SRZVWDü DQL SU]HWUZDü JG\E\ QLH LVWQLDá F]áRZLHN 0*5 .$0,/ à8&=$- ± GRNWRUDQW 8QLZHUV\WHW -DJLHOORĔVNL ,QVW\WXW VRFMRORJLL VWDá\ ZVSyá SUDFRZQLN .DWHGU\ 6RFMRORJLL 2JyOQHM L $QWURSRORJLL 6SRáHF]QHM QD :\G]LDOH +XPDQLVW\F]Q\P ANDGHPLL *yUQLF]R+XWQLF]HM Z .UDNRZLH =HV]\W\ 1DXNRZH .8/ QU ± ±

Transcript of Dlaczego kochamy kicz? Teorie kulturowe i ewolucjonistyczne

.$0,/�à8&=$-

'/$&=(*2�.2&+$0<�.,&="� 7(25,(�.8/7852:(�,�(:2/8&-21,67<&=1(

:67ĉ3

1LQLHMV]\� DUW\NXá� VWDQRZL� UHIOHNVMĊ� QDG� GZRPD� WHRULDPL�� NWyUH� VWDUDMą� VLĊ�Z\�MDĞQLü� JHQH]Ċ� ]MDZLVND� NLF]X�ZH�ZVSyáF]HVQHM� NXOWXU]H��7UDG\F\MQH� SRGHMĞFLH��NWyUH� RNUHĞODP�PLDQHP�ÄNXOWXURZHJR �́�Z\ZRG]L� VLĊ� ]� SUDF�$EUDKDPD�0ROHVD��OHF]�Z�QDXNDFK�VSRáHF]Q\FK�ZáDĞFLZHJR�VIRUPXáRZDQLD�GRNRQDá�3LHUUH�%RXUGLHX��3DUDG\JPDW�WHQ�]DNáDGD��ĪH�OXG]NLH�JXVWD�Vą�]UyĪQLFRZDQH�NODVRZR��D�ZSá\Z�QD�XSRGREDQLH� GR�NLF]X�PDMą� WDNLH� F]\QQLNL�� MDN� SR]LRP�GRFKRGX��Z\NV]WDáFHQLD�F]\�ZLHONRĞü�PLHMVFRZRĞFL��]�NWyUHM�NWRĞ�SRFKRG]L��2G�SRF]ąWNX�ODW�����;;�ZLHNX�SRSXODUQRĞü�]GRE\ZD�MHGQDN�SDUDG\JPDW�RSDUW\�QD�'DUZLQRZVNLHM�WHRULL�HZROXFML��%DGDF]H��WDF\�MDN�'HQLV�'XWWRQ�F]\�1DQF\�$LNHQ��]ZUDFDMą�XZDJĊ��ĪH�HZROXFMD�Z\NV]WDáFLáD�SHZQH�XSRGREDQLD�HVWHW\F]QH��NWyUH�SUHG\VSRQXMą�OXG]L�GR�XZLHOELHQLD�SU]HGPLRWyZ�NLF]RZDW\FK��7HRULD�NXOWXURZD��SRND]XMąFD��ĪH�OXG]NLH�SUHIHUHQFMH�HVWHW\F]QH�Vą�]DOHĪQH�RG�SRáRĪHQLD�NODVRZHJR��VXJHUXMH�ZLĊF��ĪH�NLF]�MHVW�RJUDQL�F]RQ\�GR�XSRGREDĔ�Z\EUDQHM�JUXS\�VSRáHF]QHM��7HRULD�HZROXFMRQLVW\F]QD�SRVWU]HJD�]DĞ�OXG]NLH�VNáRQQRĞFL�GR�NLF]X�MDNR�QDWXUDOQH�L�REHFQH�Z�FDá\P�VSRáHF]HĔVWZLH��:�W\P�VHQVLH�Z\GDMH�VLĊ�RQD�VSyMQD�]�SRJOąGHP�+HUPDQQD�%URFKD��NWyU\�SLVDá��ĪH�ÄNLF]�QLH�PyJáE\�ERZLHP�DQL�SRZVWDü��DQL�SU]HWUZDü��JG\E\�QLH�LVWQLDá�F]áRZLHN��

0*5�.$0,/�à8&=$-� ±� GRNWRUDQW��8QLZHUV\WHW� -DJLHOORĔVNL�� ,QVW\WXW� VRFMRORJLL�� VWDá\�ZVSyá�SUDFRZQLN�.DWHGU\�6RFMRORJLL�2JyOQHM� L�$QWURSRORJLL�6SRáHF]QHM�QD�:\G]LDOH�+XPDQLVW\F]Q\P ANDGHPLL�*yUQLF]R�+XWQLF]HM�Z�.UDNRZLH�

=HV]\W\�1DXNRZH�.8/������������QU��±������±����

�� .$0,/�à8&=$-

NWyU\�OXEL�NLF]�L�MDNR�SURGXFHQW�V]WXNL�FKFH�JR�Z\WZRU]\ü��D�MDNR�NRQVXPHQW�V]WXNL�JRWyZ�MHVW�JR�NXSRZDü�L�QDZHW�GREU]H�]D�QLHJR�]DSáDFLü´�.

=JRGQLH�]�VXJHVWLą�0ROHVD�WUDNWXMĊ�NLF]�QLH�MDNR�]MDZLVNR�GHQRWDW\ZQH��VHPDQ�W\F]QLH�RNUHĞORQH���OHF]�NRQRWDW\ZQH��LQWXLF\MQH�L�]QLXDQVRZDQH2��=�WHJR�Z]JOĊGX�WUXGQR�MHVW�VIRUPXáRZDü�SUHF\]\MQą�GHILQLFMĊ�NLF]X��Ä.LF]RZDW\´�MHVW�]�SHZQRĞFLą�NDĪG\�SU]HGPLRW��NWyU\�PRĪQD�RNUHĞOLü�MDNR�ÄSU]HGPLRW�Z�]á\P�JXĞFLH �́�OHF]�WDND�GHILQLFMD�REDUF]RQD�MHVW�SUREOHPHP�ÄEáĊGQHJR�NRáD �́�1LHFR�XSUDV]F]DMąF��PRĪQD�UR]XPLHü�NLF]�MDNR�IRUPĊ�TXDVL�DUW\VW\F]Qą�����NWyUą�áDWZR�MHVW�]UR]XPLHü��RSHUXMH�SRVSROLW\P�NRGHP��QDU]XFDMąF\PL�VLĊ�RGQLHVLHQLDPL������NWyUD�áąF]\�ZLHOH�UyĪQ\FK�HOHPHQWyZ�SU]\QDOHĪQ\FK�GR�QLHSU]\VWDMąF\FK�GR�VLHELH�SRU]ąGNyZ�HVWHW\F]Q\FK��QS��]áRWH�]GRELHQLD�L�]GMĊFLD�QDMEOLĪV]\FK������NWyUD�SU]HGVWDZLD�QDMF]ĊĞFLHM�U]HF]\�SU]HFLĊWQH�����NWyUD�XGDMH��ĪH�MHVW�F]\PĞ�LQQ\P��QLĪ�MHVW�����NWyUHM�F]ĊVWR�FHFKą�MHVW�*HP�WOLFKNHLW�±�SU]\WXOQRĞü�.

$UW\NXá� VNáDGD� VLĊ� ]� WU]HFK� F]ĊĞFL��:�SLHUZV]HM� NU\W\F]QLH� DQDOL]XMĊ� WZLHU�G]HQLD�Z\Sá\ZDMąFH� ]� SDUDG\JPDWX� NXOWXURZHJR��1DVWĊSQLH� SU]HFKRG]Ċ� GR�SU]HGVWDZLHQLD� WH]� L�DUJXPHQWyZ�HPSLU\F]Q\FK�]ZLą]DQ\FK�]� WHRULą�HZROXFMRQL�VW\F]Qą��:�RVWDWQLHM� F]ĊĞFL� DQDOL]XMĊ� UHODFMH� SRPLĊG]\� MHGQ\P�D� GUXJLP�SRGHM�ĞFLHP��&DáRĞFL�Z\ZRGX� WRZDU]\V]ą�JUDILF]QH�SU]\NáDG\�RPDZLDQ\FK� URG]DMyZ� kiczu.

,�� .,&=�-$.2�=-$:,6.2�.8/7852:(

:�VRFMRORJLL�NXOWXU\�NLF]�DQDOL]XMH�VLĊ�QDMF]ĊĞFLHM�MDNR�SRFKRGQą�]UyĪQLFRZDQLD�NODVRZHJR��.RU]HQLH� WHJR�SRJOąGX� VLĊJDMą� SRáRZ\�;;�ZLHNX�� NLHG\�:\FN�9DQ�%URRNV� ]DSURSRQRZDá� WUyMVWRSQLRZ\�SRG]LDá� RGELRUFyZ�NXOWXU\��.RQFHSFMĊ� WĊ�UR]ZLMDá�Z� ODWDFK� ����;;�ZLHNX�5XVVHOO�/\QHV��� 3LVDá� RQ�� ĪH�KLJKEURZ, osoby R�ÄQDMZ\ĪV]\P´�JXĞFLH�� Vą�NDWHJRULą� OXG]L��NWyU]\�ÄSDWU]ą�QD�NLHáEDVĊ�� D�P\ĞOą�R�3LFDVVLH �́�6ą�RQL�ZLĊF�VWDOH�]DDEVRUERZDQL�VSUDZDPL�NXOWXU\��SRV]XNXMą�SLĊNQD�L�JáĊEL�ZH�ZV]\VWNLFK�RWDF]DMąF\FK�LFK�SU]HGPLRWDFK��2GELRUF\�FL�QLH�FHQLą�JXVWX�PLGGOHEURZ� �SU]HGVWDZLFLHOL�ÄNXOWXU\�SRVSROLWHM´����Z\]QDZFyZ�V]WXNL�SR]RUyZ��

�� +��% U R F K��.LOND�XZDJ�R�NLF]X�L�LQQH�HVHMH, SU]H�'��%RUNRZVND��-��*DUHZLF]��5��7XUF]\Q��:DUV]DZD�������V������

2� $��0 R O H V��.LF]�F]\OL�6]WXND�V]F]ĊĞFLD��6WXGLXP�R�SV\FKRORJLL�NLF]X��SU]Há��$��6]F]HSDĔVND��(��:HQGH��:DUV]DZD�������V�����

�� 7DPĪH��V������� 3RU��5��/\ Q H V��7KH�7DVWHPDNHUV��/RQGRQ�������� 2F]\ZLĞFLH�MHVW�WR�SRJOąG�MXĪ�KLVWRU\F]Q\��2EHFQLH�]Z\NOH�VIHUĊ�PLGGOHEURZ�XWRĪVDPLD�VLĊ�

]�W\P��FR�-RKQ�)LVNH�QD]\ZD�ÄNXOWXUą�SRSXODUQą �́�-HVW�RQD�SRZV]HFKQLH�GRVWĊSQD��MHGQDN�Z\PDJD�RG� VZRLFK�XF]HVWQLNyZ�SHZQ\FK�QDNáDGyZ� WZyUF]\FK�� NWyUH� XMDZQLDMą� VLĊ� QS�� SRSU]H]� SDVWLV]H�

��'/$&=(*2�.2&+$0<�.,&="

NRPHUFML�L�NLF]X��6ą�]DĞ�VNáRQQL�]DDNFHSWRZDü�QLHNWyUH�HOHPHQW\��QS��NRPLNV\��MD]]��z poziomu ORZEURZ�MDNR�QDWXUDOQ\�SURGXNW�WZyUF]RĞFL�OXGRZHM���7U]\�Z\]QDF]RQH�Z�WHQ�VSRVyE�NDWHJRULH�SXEOLF]QRĞFL�PRĪQD�E\áRE\�Z�VSRVyE�WHRUHW\F]Q\�SRáąF]\ü�]�SU]\NáDGDPL�UyĪQ\FK�URG]DMyZ�V]WXNL��3RGREQH�NODV\ILNDFMH�SRZVWDMą�SR�G]LHĔ�dzisiejszy�.

(PSLU\F]QHJR�X]DVDGQLHQLD� NXOWXURZHM� WHRULL� NLF]X� GRVWDUF]D� MHGQDN�SU]H�áRPRZD�SUDFD�%RXUGLHX��QDSLVDQD�Z������URNX�'\VW\QNFMD��1D�SRGVWDZLH�EDGDĔ�ZáDVQ\FK�SU]HSURZDG]RQ\FK�MHV]F]H�Z�ODWDFK�����;;�ZLHNX�%RXUGLHX�SRND]XMH��ĪH� JXVW� HVWHW\F]Q\�)UDQFX]yZ� MHVW� VLOQLH� ]UyĪQLFRZDQ\�NODVRZR��%H]SRĞUHGQLP�F]\QQLNLHP�UyĪQLFXMąF\P�OXG]L�MHVW�W]Z��NDSLWDá�NXOWXURZ\�

=JRGQLH�]�GHILQLFMą�VIRUPXáRZDQą�SU]H]�3��%RXUGLHX�L�-HDQD�&ODXGH¶D�3DVVHURQD�NDSLWDá�NXOWXURZ\�WZRU]ą�ÄGREUD�NXOWXURZH�SU]HND]\ZDQH�SU]H]�UyĪQH�URG]LQQH�G]LDáDQLD� SHGDJRJLF]QH� �'3��� NWyU\FK�ZDUWRĞü� MDNR� NDSLWDáX� NXOWXURZHJR� MHVW�IXQNFMą� G\VWDQVX�PLĊG]\� DUELWUDOQRĞFLą� NXOWXURZą�QDU]XFRQą�SU]H]�GRPLQXMąFH�'3� L� DUELWUDOQRĞFLą�NXOWXURZą�ZGURĪRQą�SU]H]� URG]LQQH�'3�Z� UyĪQ\FK�JUXSDFK�EąGĨ� NODVDFK´���1DE\ZDQLH� NDSLWDáX� NXOWXURZHJR��Z�SU]HFLZLHĔVWZLH� GR� QDE\�ZDQLD�NDSLWDáX�HNRQRPLF]QHJR�� WR�GáXJL�SURFHV� L��SRGREQLH� MDN�RSDODQLH�VLĊ�F]\�EXGRZDQLH�PDV\�PLĊĞQLRZHM��QLH�PRĪH�]RVWDü�Z\NRQDQ\�Z�F]\LPĞ�]DVWĊSVWZLH�. .DSLWDá� SRVLDGDQ\� SU]H]� URG]LQĊ� MHVW�ZLĊF� SXQNWHP�Z\MĞFLD�� OHF]� SRVLDGDQ\�SU]H]� MHGQRVWNĊ� ]DVyE�NDSLWDáX� NXOWXURZHJR� MHVW� HIHNWHP� WUDMHNWRULL� VSRáHF]QHM��DZDQVyZ� OXE� VSDGNyZ���� 3RG� SRMĊFLHP� ÄNDSLWDáX� NXOWXURZHJR´� NU\Mą� VLĊ� WU]\�UyĪQH�IRUP\�NDSLWDáX��NWyUH�ZLąĪą�VLĊ�]�Z\FKRZDQLHP��DOH�WHĪ�]�HGXNDFMą�V]NROQą�� 6ą�WR�

����NDSLWDá�LQNRUSRURZDQ\��IU��LQFRUSRUp��DQJ��HPERGLHG��±�ZLHG]D�WZRU]ąFD�NRPSHWHQFMĊ��

L�SU]HUyENL��8F]HVWQLFWZR�Z�NXOWXU]H�SRSXODUQHM�QLH�MHVW�]Z\Náą�RGELRUF]RĞFLą��OHF]�FLąJáą�JUą�]�WHNVWHP��SRU��-��F i s k e, =UR]XPLHü�NXOWXUĊ�SRSXODUQą��SU]HNá��.��6DZLFND��.UDNyZ��������,GHH�]DZDUWH�Z�WHM�F]ĊĞFL�DUW\NXáX�]RVWDá\�SU]HGVWDZLRQH�Z�LQQ\P�NRQWHNĞFLH�Z�DUW\NXOH��6��* U R G Q \��-��* U X V ] N D�L�.��à X F ] D M��2� ]DZĊĪHQLX�Z\ĪV]HJR� JXVWX� HVWHW\F]QHJR��$QDOL]D� ]MDZLVND�ZV]\VWNRĪHUQRĞFL�NXOWXURZHM�Z�3ROVFH��Ä6WXGLD�6RFMRORJLF]QH´�������QU ���V�����±����

�� 3RGDMĊ�]D��$��. á R V N RZ V N D��.XOWXUD�PDVRZD��:DUV]DZD�������V�������� 3RU��5��+ R O O L G D \��5HIOHFWLQJ�WKH�6HOI��Z��3LFWXULQJ�WKH�6RFLDO�/DQGVFDSH��9LVXDO�0HWKRGV�

DQG�WKH�6RFLRORJLFDO�,PDJLQDWLRQ��HG��&��.QRZOHV��3��6ZHHWPDQ��/RQGRQ�1HZ�<RUN�������V����±����� 3��% R X U G L H X�� -��&��3 D V V H U R Q��5HSURGXNFMD��(OHPHQW\� WHRULL� V\VWHPX�QDXF]HQLD�� SU]Há��

>]�MĊ]��IU�@�(��1H\PDQ��:DUV]DZD�������V������ P. B o u r d i e u, 7KH�)RUPV�RI�&DSLWDO��Z��(GXFDWLRQ��&XOWXUH��(FRQRP\�� DQG�6RFLHW\, ed.

$�+��+DOVH\��1HZ�<RUN�������V�������� :�F]ĊĞFL�HPSLU\F]QHM�VZ\FK�UR]ZDĪDĔ�%RXUGLHX�XSUDV]F]D�MHGQDN�WĊ�NRQFHSFMĊ��]DNáDGDMąF��ĪH�

NDSLWDá�NXOWXURZ\�MHVW�Z\]QDF]DQ\�SU]H]�]DZyG�RMFD��3��% R X U G L H X��-��&��3 D V V H U R Q��5HSURGXNFMD, V�������3��% R X U G L H X��'\VW\QNFMD��6SRáHF]QD�NU\W\ND�ZáDG]\�VąG]HQLD��SU]Há��3��%LáRV��:DUV]DZD�������V��������QDWRPLDVW�ZVNDĨQLNL�� WDNLH� MDN�SáHü��ZLHN�L�PLHMVFH�]DPLHV]NDQLD��Vą�U]DGNR�EUDQH�SRG�XZDJĊ��3��% R X U G L H X��'\VW\QNFMD��V�����±�����

�� .$0,/�à8&=$-

����NDSLWDá�]RELHNW\ZL]RZDQ\��IU��REMHFWLYp��DQJ��REMHFWLILHG��±�REUD]\��LQVWUX�PHQW\��PDV]\Q\��NWyU\PL�G\VSRQXMH�MHGQRVWND��

����NDSLWDá�]LQVW\WXFMRQDOL]RZDQ\��IU��LQVWLWXWLRQDOLVp, DQJ��LQVWLWXWLRQDOL]HG��±�G\SORP\��W\WXá\�]GRE\WH�Z�NRQNXUVDFK�

:V]\VWNLH�Z\PLHQLRQH� W\S\�NDSLWDáX�PDMą� SRGáRĪH� NODVRZH��=Z\NOH�%RXU�GLHX�Z\UyĪQLD�NODVĊ�GRPLQXMąFą� L� MHM�SU]HFLZLHĔVWZR�Z�SRVWDFL�NODV\�ÄOXGRZHM´��]GRPLQRZDQHM���:�QLHNWyU\FK�SUDFDFK��Z�W\P�Z�'\VW\QNFML��SRMDZLD�VLĊ� WDNĪH�NDWHJRULD�NODV� ĞUHGQLFK��3RPLMDMąF� V]F]HJyáRZH� UR]ZDĪDQLD�3��%RXUGLHX��PRĪQD�ZLĊF�Z\UyĪQLü�WU]\�W\S\�NDSLWDáX�NXOWXURZHJR��GRPLQXMąF\��FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\�GOD�MHGQRVWHN�]QDMGXMąF\FK�VLĊ�QDMZ\ĪHM�QD�GUDELQLH�VSRáHF]QHM���OXGRZ\��UR]XPLDQ\�MDNR�SU]HFLZLHĔVWZR�NDSLWDáX�GRPLQXMąFHJR��RUD]�]QDMGXMąFą�VLĊ�SRPLĊG]\�QLPL�IRUPĊ� SRĞUHGQLą�

5yĪQH� W\S\� NDSLWDáX� NXOWXURZHJR�PDMą� SU]HáRĪHQLH� QD� OXG]NLH� JXVWD� HVWH�W\F]QH��*XVW�±�PyZL�%RXUGLHX�±�ÄMHVW�G\VSR]\FMą�QDE\Wą�Z�FHOX�ªUR]UyĪQLDQLD©�L� ªRVąG]DQLD©�� MDN� WZLHUG]L�.DQW�� OXE�� MHĞOL� NWR�ZROL�� XVWDOHQLD� OXE�SRGNUHĞOHQLD�UyĪQLF�SRSU]H]�XVWDOHQLD�G\VW\QNFML´����*XVW�MHVW�ZLĊF�]ELRUHP�ZV]\VWNLFK�QDV]\FK�SUHIHUHQFML�HVWHW\F]Q\FK��NWyUH�ZSá\ZDMą�QD�QDV]H�Ī\FLH�Z�WDN�]QDF]Q\P�VWRSQLX��ĪH�%RXUGLHX�QD]\ZD�JR�ÄNXOWXUą�SU]HNV]WDáFRQą�Z�QDWXUĊ��F]\OL�NXOWXUą�XFLHOHĞQLR�Qą´����6SRáHF]QD�IXQNFMD�JXVWX�SROHJD�QD�UyĪQLFRZDQLX�JUXS�VSRáHF]Q\FK��GODWHJR�NDWHJRU\]XMąF� SU]HGPLRW\� L� MDNRĞFL� HVWHW\F]QH�� JXVW� NDWHJRU\]XMH� WDNĪH� OXG]L��Ä*XVW� MHVW�Z\UD]HP�áąF]HQLD� L�RGNU\ZDQLD�U]HF]\� L� OXG]L��SDVXMąF\FK�GR�VLHELH�L� RGSRZLDGDMąF\FK� VRELH´�����:�REUĊELH� SRV]F]HJyOQ\FK� NDWHJRULL� VSRáHF]Q\FK�JXVW� MHVW� F]\QQLNLHP��NWyU\� ]DSHZQLD� LFK� VSyMQRĞü� �ÄKDELWXV� ]DEH]SLHF]D� VZRMą�EOLVNRĞü�]�LQQ\PL�KDELWXVDPL´�����3R]ZDOD�WDNĪH�F]áRQNRP�W\FK�NDWHJRULL�F]HUSDü�SU]\MHPQRĞü�]�REUDQHJR�WU\EX�Ī\FLD�

'\VW\QNFMD�3LHUUH¶D�%RXUGLHX�PyZL�R� WU]HFK� W\SDFK�JXVWX��JXĞFLH� OXGRZ\P��JXĞFLH�NODV�ĞUHGQLFK�RUD]�JXĞFLH�GRPLQXMąF\P��6FKHPDW\F]QLH�SU]HGVWDZLHQLH�W\FK�JXVWyZ�]QDMGXMH�VLĊ�Z�WDEHOL����:�NRQWHNĞFLH�NLF]X�QDMZDĪQLHMV]\�MHVW�RF]\ZLĞFLH�JXVW� OXGRZ\��*XVW� GRPLQXMąF\� VWDQRZL�ERZLHP�]DSU]HF]HQLH� HVWHW\NL� NLF]RZHM��D� SU]HGVWDZLFLHOH� NODV� ĞUHGQLFK�� EH]�Z]JOĊGX�QD�ZSá\Z\�� MDNLP�XOHJD� LFK�JXVW��OXELą�ÄP\ĞOHü�R�VRELH�Z�RSR]\FML�GR�SRVSROLWRĞFL´����6NXSP\�VLĊ�ZLĊF�QD�JXĞFLH� OXGRZ\P�

��� 7DPĪH��V��������� 7DPĪH��V��������� 7DPĪH��V��������� 7DPĪH��V��������� 7DPĪH��V������

��'/$&=(*2�.2&+$0<�.,&="

7DEHOD����&HFK\�WU]HFK�RGPLDQ�JXVWX�HVWHW\F]QHJR�ZHGáXJ�3LHUUH¶D�%RXUGLHX

Odmiana gustu *XVW�OXGRZ\ *XVW�ĞUHGQL *XVW�Z\ĪV]\

Czynniki NV]WDáWXMąFH

.RQLHF]QRĞü�HNR�nomiczna

Ä,GHRORJLD�SUDFRZLWHM�DVFH]\´�RUD]�ÄGREUD�ZROD�NXOWXURZD´

6FKHPDW\�NXOWXURZH

3RĪąGDQH�FHFK\

• UHDOL]P�SU]HGVWD�ZLHĔ�

• XĪ\WHF]QRĞü�SU]HGPLRWyZ�

• ERJDWH�]GRELHQLD�kicz

• HNOHNW\]P�• FRG]LHQQRĞü�• W\SRZRĞü

• PLQLPDOL]P• ]QDF]QD�ZDUWRĞü��HNRQRPLF]�QD�

• QLHSRZWDU]DOQRĞü��RGU]XFHQLH�SU]HFLĊWQRĞFL�

• ZáDĞFLZRĞFL�IRUPDOQH��NWyU\FK�RFHQD�Z\PDJD�NRPSHWHQFML�NXOWXURZHM��QS��LQWHUWHNVWX�DOQRĞü�

3U]\NáDGRZH�SU]HGPLRW\

• ODQGV]DIW\• RJURGRZH�NUD�VQDOH

• kamyki, toczone GUHZQR

• IHOLHWRQ\��HVHMH

• SURGXNW\�NXOWXU\�ÄZ\VRNLHM´��RSHUD��PDODUVWZR�DZDQJDU�GRZH�

• SURGXNW\�SU]HP\VáX�Z\VRNLFK�WHFKQRORJLL

ħUyGáR��2SUDFRZDQLH�ZáDVQH�QD�SRGVWDZLH��3��B o u r d i e u, '\VW\QNFMD��6SRáHF]QD�NU\W\ND�ZáDG]\�VąG]HQLD��:DUV]DZD�������3��B o u r d i e X��-��&��P a s s e r o n, 5HSURGXNFMD��(OHPHQW\�WHRULL�V\VWH�PX�QDXF]HQLD��:DUV]DZD������

*XVW� OXGRZ\�Z\QLND� ]GDQLHP�%RXUGLHX� ]� ÄNRQLHF]QRĞFL´��. Francuskie po�MĊFLH�QpFHVVLWp�R]QDF]D�ERZLHP�]DUyZQR�NRQLHF]QRĞü�Z�SRGVWDZRZ\P�SROVNLP�]QDF]HQLX� WHJR� VáRZD�� MDN� L� ELHGĊ�� VWDQ�EUDNX� ĞURGNyZ�GR� Ī\FLD��.ODV\� OXGRZH��SR]EDZLRQH�QDMF]ĊĞFLHM�ĞURGNyZ�QLH]EĊGQ\FK�GR�HJ]\VWHQFML��PXV]ą�GRNRQ\ZDü�Z\ERUyZ��NWyUH� Vą� QDMEDUG]LHM� NRU]\VWQH� ]� SXQNWX�ZLG]HQLD� HNRQRPLL��6ą�ZLĊF�]EOLĪRQH�GR�VSRáHF]HĔVWZ�SURVW\FK��NWyUH�NRQFHQWURZDá\�VLĊ�QD�]DVSRNDMDQLX�SRG�VWDZRZ\FK�SRWU]HE��Z�SU]HFLZLHĔVWZLH�GR�NODV�GRPLQXMąF\FK��X�SRGVWDZ�VPDNX�NWyU\FK� OHĪ\�RGU]XFHQLH� SRVSROLW\FK�� SLHUZRWQ\FK� VDW\VIDNFML����=� WHJR�Z]JOĊGX�WUZDáRĞü�L�XQLZHUVDOQRĞü�Vą�ZDUWRĞFLDPL�FHQLRQ\PL�QDMZ\ĪHM�Z�GRPHQLH�HVWHW\NL�SU]H]�F]áRQNyZ�NODV�OXGRZ\FK��.RQLHF]QRĞü�HNRQRPLF]QD�Z\WZRU]\áD�JXVW��NWyU\�XSUDZRPRFQLD�VW\O�Ī\FLD�RVyE�Z\REFRZDQ\FK�HNRQRPLF]QLH��OHF]�WDNĪH�NXOWXURZR��-DNR�SU]\NáDG�EH]SRĞUHGQLHJR�RGG]LDá\ZDQLD�ERGĨFyZ�PDWHULDOQ\FK�QD�ÄV]WXNĊ´�PRĪQD�SRGDü�REUD]\�L�]GMĊFLD��NWyUH�SU]HGVWDZLDMą�MHG]HQLH��2F]\ZLĞFLH�]GMĊFLD�WDNLH�QLH�SRZLQQ\�G]LZLü�Z�UHVWDXUDFML��OHF]�XPLHV]F]RQH�Z�LQQ\FK�NRQWHNVWDFK�PRJą�EXG]Lü�]GXPLHQLH��3U]\NáDG�]DPLHV]F]RQR�QD�LOXVWUDFML���

��� 7DPĪH��V��������� 7DPĪH��V������

�� .$0,/�à8&=$-

,OXVWUDFMD����)RWRJUDILD�SU]HGVWDZLDMąFD�SL]]Ċ�XPLHV]F]RQD�QD�NRU\WDU]X�]DMD]GX�QD�/LWZLH��ħUyGáR��)RWRJUDILD�Z\NRQDQD�SU]H]�DXWRUD�����JUXGQLD�������

'UXJD�FHFKD�NLF]X�FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QHJR�GOD�NODV�OXGRZ\FK�ZLąĪH�VLĊ�]�QLHPRĪ�OLZRĞFLą�E\FLD�QLH]DOHĪQ\P�RG�RGG]LDá\ZDQLD�NXOWXU\�SUDZRPRFQHM��=H�Z]JOĊGX�QD�ZSá\Z�V]NRá\��D�ZH�ZVSyáF]HVQ\P�ĞZLHFLH�]DSHZQH�WDNĪH�PHGLyZ��QLNW�QLH�MHVW�FDáNRZLFLH�QLHSRGDWQ\�QD�ZSá\Z\�NXOWXU\�SUDZRPRFQHM��6\WXDFMD�WD�URG]L�SRWU]HEĊ�SRVLDGDQLD�VXEVW\WXWyZ�SRĪąGDQ\FK�U]HF]\��SLFLD�ZLQD��]DPLDVW�V]DPSDQD��QRV]HQLD�RG]LHĪ\�Z\NRQDQHM�]�LPLWDFML�PDWHULDáyZ��SRVLDGDQLD�OLWRJUDILL��]DPLDVW�REUD]yZ��=GDQLHP�%RXUGLHX�Vą�WR�ZVNDĨQLNL�ÄZ\ZáDV]F]HQLD�GR�GUXJLHM�SRWĊJL��NWyUH�GDMH�VRELH�QDU]XFLü�GHILQLFMĊ�GyEU�JRGQ\FK�SRVLDGDQLD´����&KDUDNWHU\VW\F]QD�GOD�NODV�OXGRZ\FK�VNáRQQRĞü�GR�LPLWDFML�F]\QL�RF]\ZLĞFLH�LFK�JXVW�NLF]RZDW\P��-DN�SLV]H�%RXUGLHX�

]DSRPLQDMąF�EąGĨ�RGU]XFDMąF�PDQLHUĊ�L�VW\O��ÄHVWHW\ND´��Z�VRELH��NODV�OXGRZ\FK�L�ÄHVWHW\ND´�QDMXERĪV]\FK�NXOWXURZR�NODV�ĞUHGQLFK�X]QDMH�]D�ÄáDGQH �́�ÄPLáH �́�ÄXURF]H´��UDF]HM�QLĪ�ÄSLĊNQH´��WR�ZV]\VWNR��FR�]RVWDáR�MXĪ�XNRQVW\WXRZDQH�MDNR�WDNLH�Z�ÄHVWHW\FH´�SRF]WRZ\FK�NDOHQGDU]\�RUD]�SRF]WyZHN��QD�SU]\NáDG� ]DFKyG� VáRĔFD� OXE�G]LHZF]\QND�EDZLąFD� VLĊ�]�NRWHP��WDQLHF�OXGRZ\�OXE�REUD]�PLVWU]D��SLHUZV]D�NRPXQLD�OXE�SURFHVMD�G]LHFLĊFD��.

*XVW�NODV� OXGRZ\FK� MHVW�RNUHĞODQ\�SU]H]�%RXUGLHX� MDNR� OHNNL�� áDWZ\�� IU\ZRO�Q\��SUyĪQ\��NU]\NOLZ\��SRZLHU]FKRZQ\��U]XFDMąF\�VLĊ�Z�RF]\��DQJ��PHUHWULFLRXV���FXNLHUNRZDW\��SU]HVáRG]RQ\��UyĪDQ\��PGá\����PRĪH�E\ü�ZLĊF�QD]ZDQ\�]D�SRPRFą�

��� 7DPĪH��V��������� 7DPĪH��V�������� 7DPĪH��V������

��'/$&=(*2�.2&+$0<�.,&="

WHUPLQX� ÄNLF]RZDW\ �́�0RĪQD�QD]ZDü�JR� UyZQLHĪ� ÄMDUPDUF]Q\P�HNOHNW\]PHP �́�SRQLHZDĪ�WR�Z�GXĪHM�PLHU]H�WDUJL�L�MDUPDUNL�NV]WDáWXMą�OXGRZH�SRF]XFLH�HVWHW\F]QH��:LHOREDUZQ\�WáXP��ZLHORĞü�VWRLVN�L�HNOHNW\]P�RIHURZDQ\FK�WDP�SURGXNWyZ�QDOHĪą�GR�QDMEDUG]LHM�W\SRZ\FK�FHFK�VW\OX�MDUPDUF]QHJR����-DNR�SU]\NáDG\�OXGRZHJR�NLF]X�%RXUGLHX�Z\PLHQLD��REUD]\�SU]HGVWDZLDMąFH�]DFKyG�VáRĔFD��SHM]DĪ��G]LHZF]\QNĊ�LJUDMąFą�]�NRWHP��WDQLHF�OXGRZ\22��6]F]HJyOQLH�QDUDĪRQH�QD�E\FLH�NLF]RZDW\PL�Vą�]DWHP�SU]HGPLRW\�SU]HGVWDZLDMąFH�QDWXUĊ�OXE�]DZLHUDMąFH�HOHPHQW\�GR�QLHM�QDZLą�]XMąFH��QS��RUQDPHQW\�NZLDWRZH��

:�NXOWXU]H�ZVSyáF]HVQHM�SRMDZLá�VLĊ�ZLĊF�SDUDGRNV��LP�PQLHM�QD�]LHPL�SR]R�VWDMH�QDWXUDOQRĞFL�QLH]DNáyFRQHM��W\P�ZLĊFHM�SRMDZLD�VLĊ�NLF]RZDWHM�QDWXUDOQRĞFL�estetycznej����=GDQLHP�-HU]HJR�.XURZLFNLHJR�

ZV]\VWNLH� WH�Z\WZRU\�� UD]HP�Z]LĊWH��QDOHĪą� MHGQDN� W\ONR�GR� IRONORUX�ZVSyáF]HVQRĞFL��]DVWĊSXMąFHJR�VNXWHF]QLH�GDZQH�IRONORU\�OXGRZH��1D]ZDü�MH�PRĪQD�IRONORUHP�]PDUJL�QDOL]RZDQ\FK�LQG\ZLGXDOQRĞFL��']LĊNL�QLHPX�ZV]DNĪH�WZRU]\�VLĊ�L�SRGWU]\PXMH�]áXGQ\�ÄĞZLDW�Z\ĪV]\FK�ZDUWRĞFL´��SRMDZLD�VLĊ�Z]QLRVáRĞü��]QLND�V]DU]\]QD�PRQRWRQQHM�FRG]LHQ�QRĞFL�L�QXGD�SRZWDU]DMąF\FK�VLĊ�]MDZLVN�SU]\URGQLF]\FK��.

=XSHáQLH�LQDF]HM�XPLáRZDQLH�GR�QDWXUDOQHJR�NLF]X�WáXPDF]ą�WHRULH�HZROXFMR�nistyczne.

,,�� .,&=�-$.2�=-$:,6.2�1$785$/1(

:�SU]HFLZLHĔVWZLH� GR� SRSXODUQ\FK�PRGHUQLVW\F]Q\FK� L� SRVWPRGHUQLVW\F]Q\FK�HVWHW\N�EDGDF]H� ]DMPXMąF\� VLĊ� HVWHW\Ną� HZROXF\MQą� QLH� WUDNWXMą� RGELRUX� V]WXNL�MDNR�SURFHVX�FDáNRZLFLH�]DOHĪQHJR�RG�NXOWXU\����*XVW�HVWHW\F]Q\��FKRü�QLHZąWSOL�ZLH�]DOHĪ\�Z�SHZQ\P�VWRSQLX�RG�ORNDOQ\FK�XZDUXQNRZDĔ��MHVW�]GDQLHP�EDGDF]\��WDNLFK�MDN�'��'XWWRQ��]MDZLVNLHP�R�SRGáRĪX�ELRORJLF]Q\P����8F]HQL�FL�VNáRQQL�Vą�XSDWU\ZDü�ĨUyGáD�QDV]\FK�XSRGREDĔ�HVWHW\F]Q\FK�Z�ZDUXQNDFK��Z�NWyU\FK�QDV]H�

��� -��* U D G��2E\F]DMRZR�OXG\F]Q\�Z\PLDU�MDUPDUNX��Z��.DUQDZDOL]DFMD��7HQGHQFMH�OXG\F]QH�Z�NXOWXU]H�ZVSyáF]HVQHM��UHG��QDXN��-��*UDG��+��0DP]HU��3R]QDĔ�������V�����

22 P. B o u r d i e u, '\VW\QNFMD��V��������� -��. X U RZ L F N L��(VWHW\F]QRĞü�ĞURGRZLVND�QDWXUDOQHJR��:DUV]DZD�������V��������� 7DPĪH��V��������� 1LHNWyUH�LGHH�SRMDZLDMąFH�VLĊ�Z�WHM�F]ĊĞFL�WHNVWX�]DZDUáHP�Z�DUW\NXOH��.��à X F ] D M��3HUVSHNW\ZD�

HZROXFMRQLVW\F]QD�Z�HVWHW\FH�HPSLU\F]QHM��=DáRĪHQLD��WUDG\FMH��SUREOHP\��Ä.XOWXUD�L�(GXNDFMD´�������QU����V����±�����:�SU]HFLZLHĔVWZLH�GR�SU]\MĊW\FK�WDP�UR]ZLą]DĔ�SRMĊFLRZ\FK��Z�QLQLHMV]\P�WHNĞFLH�XĪ\ZDP�WHUPLQX�ÄHVWHW\ND�HZROXF\MQD´�Z�QDZLą]DQLX�GR�SU]\MĊWHJR�Z�SROVNLHM�OLWHUDWXU]H�WHUPLQX�ÄSV\FKRORJLD�HZROXF\MQD �́�OHF]�WHRULĊ�WZRU]RQą�SU]H]�HZROXFMRQLVWyZ�QD]\ZDP�ÄHZROXFMRQLVW\F]Qą �́�D�QLH�ÄHZROXF\MQą´��DE\�XQLNQąü�P\OQ\FK�VNRMDU]HĔ�]�ÄHZROXFMą�VSRáHF]Qą´��

�� D. D u t t o n, 7KH�$UW�,QVWLQFW��%HDXW\��3OHDVXUH��+XPDQ�(YROXWLRQ��2[IRUG�������V������

�� .$0,/�à8&=$-

Py]JL�HZROXRZDá\��FR�]�NROHL�]DNáDGD�PRĪOLZRĞü�Z\ND]DQLD�LVWQLHQLD�XQLZHUVDO�Q\FK�XSRGREDĔ�HVWHW\F]Q\FK��$QWURSRORJ�'RQDOG�6\PRQV�DUJXPHQWXMH��ĪH�PXVL�LVWQLHü�Z]JOĊGQLH�VWDELOQ\�L�QLH]PLHQQ\�LGHDá�HVWHW\F]Q\��Z�VWRVXQNX�GR�NWyUHJR�OXG]LH� VWZLHUG]DMą� LVWQLHQLH�ZDG�G]LHá� V]WXNL� OXE�QLHGRVNRQDáRĞFL� XURG\� LQQ\FK�OXG]L��:�SU]HFLZQ\P�Z\SDGNX�QLH�PRJOLE\ĞP\�VWZLHUG]Lü��QD�F]\P�SROHJDMą�WH�QLHGRVNRQDáRĞFL��.

=GDQLHP� HZROXFMRQLVWyZ�QDWXUDOQH� OXG]NLH� VNáRQQRĞFL� HVWHW\F]QH� Vą� ĞFLĞOH�]ZLą]DQH� ]�PHFKDQL]PDPL� XP\VáRZ\PL� XPRĪOLZLDMąF\PL� OXG]LRP�SU]HĪ\FLH�Z�UyĪQ\FK�ĞURGRZLVNDFK��:�WHRULL�WHM�QDMF]ĊĞFLHM�ZVND]XMH�VLĊ��ĪH�QDV]H�G]LVLHMV]H�SUHIHUHQFMH� Vą� GDOHNLP� HFKHP�SUREOHPyZ�� NWyU\FK� UR]ZLą]\ZDQLH� QDOHĪDáR� GR�FRG]LHQQ\FK�RERZLą]NyZ�QDV]\FK�SU]RGNyZ��Ī\MąF\FK�MDNR�NRF]RZQLF\�Z�RNUHVLH�SOHMVWRFHQX�QD�ZVFKRGQLRDIU\NDĔVNLFK�VDZDQQDFK��:WHG\�ZáDĞQLH�±�ZHGOH�WHRULL�HZROXF\MQHM�±�NV]WDáWRZDá\�VLĊ�QDMZDĪQLHMV]H�FHFK\�RVREQLNyZ�WZRU]ąF\FK�G]LĞ�JDWXQHN�+RPR�VDSLHQV��$E\�XPRĪOLZLü�SRGHMPRZDQLH�WUDIQ\FK�GHF\]ML�GRW\F]ąF\FK�WHJR��JG]LH�VLĊ�SRUXV]Dü��RVLHGODü�L�MDNLH�F]\QQRĞFL�SRGHMPRZDü�Z�RNUHĞORQ\FK�RNROLF]QRĞFLDFK��HZROXFMD�Z\NV]WDáFLáD�VSHFMDOQH�PRGXá\�Py]JRZH��NWyUH�]D�SR�PRFą�SUHIHUHQFML�HVWHW\F]Q\FK�ZSá\ZDMą�QD�SRGHMPRZDQLH�GHF\]ML�GRW\F]ąF\FK�PLHMVFD�RVLHGOHQLD�VLĊ��-HGHQ�]�HZROXFMRQLVWyZ��6WHYHQ�.DSODQ��XZDĪD��ĪH�VNRUR�PHFKDQL]P\�WDNLH�RGSRZLDGDá\�]D�PRĪOLZRĞü�SU]HĪ\FLD�QD�VDZDQQLH��SRZLQQ\�RQH�E\ü�V]\ENLH�L�QLHNRQWURORZDQH�SU]H]�ĞZLDGRPRĞü��SRGREQLH�MDN�SURFHV�RGG\FKDQLD��. (ZROXFMRQLĞFL�]DNáDGDMą�P�LQ���ĪH�ZV]\VF\�OXG]LH�SRVLDGDMą�QDWXUDOQH�SUHG\VSR]\FMH�GR�SRVWU]HJDQLD�NUDMREUD]X�SU]\SRPLQDMąFHJR�VDZDQQĊ�MDNR�NUDMREUD]X�QDMSLĊN�QLHMV]HJR��7H]D� WD� ]QDOD]áD� SHZQH� SRWZLHUG]HQLH�Z�EDGDQLDFK� HPSLU\F]Q\FK��. :LĊNV]RĞü�HOHPHQWyZ�RNUHĞODQ\FK�Z�WHRULL�HZROXFMRQLVW\F]QHM� MDNR�ÄQDWXUDOQLH�SLĊNQH´�PRĪQD�Z\MDĞQLü� ]D� SRPRFą� ÄELRILOLL �́� SRMĊFLD� XNXWHJR�Z� ����� URNX� SU]H]�(GZDUGD�2��:LOVRQD�� NWyU\� ]GHILQLRZDá� MH� MDNR� ÄZURG]RQą� WHQGHQFMĊ�GR�NRQFHQWURZDQLD�VLĊ�QD�Ī\FLX�L�SURFHVDFK�SU]\SRPLQDMąF\FK�Ī\FLH´����:LOVRQ�QLH�VXJHUXMH�MHGQDN��ĪH�OXG]LH�Vą�Z\SRVDĪHQL�Z�ÄLQVW\QNW�DUW\VW\F]Q\´��MHVW�WR�WH]D�'XWWRQD���SRQLHZDĪ�QLH�PD�Z\VWDUF]DMąF\FK�GRZRGyZ�QD�WR��ĪH�OXG]NLH�SUHIHUHQ�FMH�Z�]DNUHVLH�SRVWU]HJDQLD�LQQ\FK�VWZRU]HĔ�Vą�SU]HND]\ZDQH�GURJą�JHQHW\F]Qą��

�� N. E t c o f f, 6XUYLYDO�RI�WKH�3UHWWLHVW��7KH�6FLHQFH�RI�%HDXW\��/RQGRQ�������V����±������ 6��. D S O D Q��(QYLURQPHQWDO�3UHIHUHQFH�LQ�D�.QRZOHGJH�6HHNLQJ��.QRZOHGJH�8VLQJ�2UJDQLVP,

Z��7KH�$GDSWHG�0LQG��(YROXWLRQDU\�3V\FKRORJ\�DQG�WKH�*HQHUDWLRQ�RI�&XOWXUH��HG��-�+��%DUNRZ��/��&RVPLGHV��-��7RRE\��1HZ�<RUN�2[IRUG�������V�����±����

��� 3RU��QS��-�'��% D O O L Q J��-�+��) D O N��'HYHORSPHQW�RI�9LVXDO�3UHIHUHQFH�IRU�1DWXUDO�(QYLURQPHQWV, Ä(QYLURQPHQW� DQG�%HKDYLRU´� ������ QR�� ���� V�� �±���� -�+��+ H H U Z D J H Q��*��2 U L D Q V��+XPDQV��+DELWDWV��DQG�$HVWKHWLFV��Z��7KH�%LRSKLOLD�+\SRWKHVLV��HG��(�2��:LOVRQ��6��.HOOHUW��:DVKLQJWRQ�������V�����±�����*��2 U L D Q V��-�+��+ H H U Z D J H Q��(YROYHG�5HVSRQVHV�WR�/DQGVFDSHV��Z��7KH�$GDSWHG�0LQG��(YROXWLRQDU\�3V\FKRORJ\�DQG�WKH�*HQHUDWLRQ�RI�&XOWXUH, V�����±�����.��à X F ] D M��3HUVSHNW\ZD�HZROXFMRQLVW\F]QD�Z�HVWHW\FH�HPSLU\F]QHM��V����±����

��� (�2��: L O V R Q��%LRSKLOLD��7KH�+XPDQ�%RQG�ZLWK�2WKHU� 6SHFLHV��&DPEULGJH� DQG�/RQGRQ�������V����

��'/$&=(*2�.2&+$0<�.,&="

1D� SRWZLHUG]HQLH� WHM� WH]\� SU]\WDF]D� RQ� EDGDQLD�� NWyU\FK�Z\QLNL� GRZRG]ą�� ĪH�OĊN�SU]HG�ZĊĪDPL�QLH�Z\VWĊSXMH�X�G]LHFL�GR�SLąWHJR�URNX�Ī\FLD��1LHPQLHM�MHGQDN�:LOVRQ�WZLHUG]L��ĪH�OXG]LH�SHZQ\FK�]DFKRZDĔ�XF]ą�VLĊ�V]\EFLHM�QLĪ�LQQ\FK��%LR�ILOLD�RSLHUDáDE\�VLĊ�ZLĊF�Z�]QDF]QHM�PLHU]H�QD�XF]HQLX��NWyUH�IDZRU\]XMH�MHGQH�ERGĨFH�Z�VWRVXQNX�GR�GUXJLFK��ELDVHG�OHDUQLQJ���.

3HUVSHNW\ZD�HZROXF\MQD�ZVND]XMH�EH]SRĞUHGQLR�NLOND�HOHPHQWyZ�]DVáXJXMąF\FK�QD�PLDQR�NLF]RZDW\FK��NWyUH�Vą�RNUHĞODQH�MDNR�F]ĊĞü�QDWXUDOQHJR�OXG]NLHJR�JXVWX�HVWHW\F]QHJR��5R]ZDĪDQLH�WHJR��Z�MDNL�VSRVyE�WHUPLQ�ÄQDWXUDOQ\´�MHVW�UR]XPLDQ\�Z� WHRULL� HZROXF\MQHM�QDZLą]XMąFHM�GR�GDUZLQL]PX��Z\NUDF]D�SR]D�FHOH�DUW\NXáX��6NUyWRZR�PRĪQD�MHGQDN�SRZLHG]LHü��ĪH�Z�XPLDUNRZDQHM�ZHUVML�WHRULL�HZROXF\MQHM�SU]\MPXMH�VLĊ��LĪ�RZH�Z]RUFH�QDWXUDOQH�VWDQRZLą�EXGXOHF��NWyU\�EĊGąF�SRGDWQ\P�QD�SHZQH�ZSá\Z\�NXOWXURZH�� VWDQRZL�SRGVWDZĊ��QD�NWyUHM� Vą�EXGRZDQH�ERGĨFH�HVWHW\F]QH��(ZROXFMD�SRZRGXMH��ĪH�SHZQH�SU]HGPLRW\�PDWHULDOQH��XĪ\WH�MDNR�V\P�EROH��PDMą�VWDáH�]QDF]HQLH��QS��G]LHFNR�EXG]L�SR]\W\ZQH�RGF]XFLD��QDWRPLDVW�SDMąN�OXE�ZąĪ�EĊGą�V\PERODPL�QHJDW\ZQ\PL�

(ZROXFMRQLĞFL�Vą�VWRVXQNRZR�]JRGQL��ĪH�QLHNWyUH�ÄNLF]RZDWH´�SU]HGPLRW\�OXE�SU]HGVWDZLHQLD� Vą� V]F]HJyOQLH� FKĊWQLH� DNFHSWRZDQH�SU]H]� OXG]L����3LHUZV]\� WDNL�HOHPHQW� VWDQRZLą� FKPXU\��Eá\VNDZLFH�� ]DFKRG\� VáRĔ�FD�� SU]HMDĞQLHQLD� RUD]� LQQH�F]\QQLNL� ]DSRZLDGDMąFH�]PLDQĊ� SRJRG\��. Badacze HZROXFMRQLVW\F]QL� XZDĪDMą��ĪH�WHJR�W\SX�HOHPHQW\�PLDá\�NOXF]RZH�]QDF]QLH�GOD�RVyE�FKFąF\FK�SU]HĪ\ü�QD� VDZDQ�QLH�� :VSyáF]HVQH� EDGDQLD�]�]DNUHVX�SHUFHSFML�DUFKLWHN�WXU\� ]GDMą� VLĊ� SRWZLHUG]Dü�OXG]Ną�VNáRQQRĞFL�GR�DNW\Z�QHJR�REVHUZRZDQLD�QDWXU\��. Formy takie jednak bardzo F]ĊVWR� SU]\MPXMą� IRUPĊ� NL�F]RZDWą�

��� 7DPĪH��V��������� 3RQLĪHM�RGZRáXMĊ�VLĊ�W\ONR�GR�ERGĨFyZ�ZL]XDOQ\FK��DE\�QLH�NRPSOLNRZDü�DQDOL]\���� *��2 U L D Q V��-��+ H H U Z D J H Q��(YROYHG�5HVSRQVHV, V��������� 3RU�� QS��7��% U L Q J V O L P D U N��7��+ D U W L J��*�*�� 3 D W L��$GDSWDWLRQ� WR�:LQGRZOHVVQHVV,

Ä(QYLURQPHQW�DQG�%HKDYLRU´�������QR����������V�����±����

,OXVWUDFMD����3RVWHU�Ä7URSLFDO�%HDFK�DW�6XQVHW´� RIHURZDQ\�Z�VNOHSLH�HX�PRYLHSRVWHU�FRP��ħUyGáR��KWWS���HX�PRYLHSRVWHU�FRP�SRVWHU�03:������7URSL�FDOB%HDFKBDWB6XQVHW�KWPO�>GRVWĊS�����NZLHWQLD�����@�

��� .$0,/�à8&=$-

,QQ\P�HOHPHQWHP��NWyU\�]ZUDFD�OXG]Ną�XZDJĊ��MHVW�RJLHĔ��MHGQDN�2ULDQV�L�+H�HUZDJHQ���]DXZDĪDMą��ĪH�PRĪH�RQ�PLHü�]DUyZQR�SR]\W\ZQH��XPRĪOLZLD�XJRWRZDQLH�SRVLáNX��]DSHZQLD�FLHSáR��SRPDJD�ZDOF]\ü�]�GUDSLHĪQLNDPL���MDN�L�QHJDW\ZQH�NRQR�

WDFMH��SRZRGXMH�SRĪDU\���%DUG]R�F]ĊVWR�SU]HGVWDZLHQLD�RJQLD�SU]\MPXMą�IRUP\�NLF]RZDWH��-HGQ\P�]�QDMF]ĊĞFLHM�G\VNX�WRZDQ\FK�SU]\NáDGyZ�MHVW�EH]�ZąWSLHQLD�NRPLQHN� HOHNWU\F]Q\�� NWyU\� VWDQRZL�LPLWDFMĊ� SUDZG]LZHJR�RJQLD��1D� W\P�SU]\NáDG]LH�MDVQR�ZLGDü��Z�MDNL�VSRVyE�QDWXUDOQD� WĊVNQRWD� ]D� FRUD]� U]DG]LHM�ZLG\ZDQ\P�RJQLHP�PRĪH�SU]HURG]Lü�VLĊ�Z�F]\VW\�NLF]�

.ROHMQ\P�HOHPHQWHP��NWyU\�]JRG�QLH�]�WHRULą�HZROXF\MQą�SRZLQLHQ�SU]\�FLąJDü�OXG]Ną�XZDJĊ��MHVW�REHFQRĞü�GX�Ī\FK�VVDNyZ��VWDQRZLąF\FK�LQIRUPDFMĊ�R�SRWHQFMDOQ\P�ĨUyGOH�SRĪ\ZLHQLD�OXE�QLHEH]SLHF]HĔVWZD��5DQG\�7KRUQKLOO�SURSRQXMH�V]F]HJyáRZą�KLSRWH]Ċ��]JRG�QLH�]�NWyUą�OXG]LRP�SRGREDMą�VLĊ�]ZLH�U]ĊWD��NWyUH�PRJá\E\�VWDQRZLü�ĨUyGáR�SRĪ\ZLHQLD� �OXE�EURQLá\E\�SU]HG�GUD�SLHĪQLNDPL���SRGF]DV�JG\�FL�VDPL�OXG]LH�SRZLQQL� EDü� VLĊ� GUDSLHĪQLNyZ�� -DNR�SLĊNQH�SRZLQQ\�E\ü� RGELHUDQH�� U\E\��]ZLHU]ĊWD�NRS\WQH��QLHNWyUH�JU\]RQLH�i ptaki����7DNLH�SU]HGVWDZLHQLD�]ZLHU]ąW�VWDQRZLą�ERZLHP�PRGHORZ\�SU]\NáDG�kiczu.

.ROHMQD�QDWXUDOQD�OXG]ND�SUHG\VSR�]\FMD�GRW\F]\�F]\QQLNyZ�]ZLą]DQ\FK�]� DNWXDOQ\P� VWDQHP�SU]\URG\�� SRUD�URNX�L�Z\QLNDMąF\�]�QLHM�HWDS�UR]ZRMX�URĞOLQQRĞFL��UR]NZLW��XĞSLHQLH���=DLQWH�UHVRZDQLH�Z]EXG]D�WHĪ�REHFQRĞü�NZLD�WyZ��NWyUD�±�MDN�Z\ND]DQR�±�ZSá\ZD�

��� 3RU��*��2 U L D Q V��-��+ H H U Z J H Q��(YROYHG�5HVSRQVHV, passim.��� 5��7 K R U Q K L O O��'DUZLQLDQ�$HVWKHWLFV� ,QIRUPV�7UDGLWLRQDO�$HVWKHWLFV��Z��(YROXWLRQDU\�

$HVWKHWLFV��HG��(�7��9RODQG��.��*UDPPHU��%HUOLQ�+HLGHOEHUJ�1HZ�<RUN�������V���±���

,OXVWUDFMD����.RPLQHN�HOHNWU\F]Q\�ħUyGáR��KWWS���UWYDJG�ZS�SO�NDW���������WLWOH�.RPLQHN�HOHNWU\F]Q\�HOHJDQFMD�F]\�NLF]�ZLG����������ZLDGRPRVF�KWPO"WLFDLG �������>GRVWĊS�����NZLHWQLD�����@�

,OXVWUDFMD����:QĊWU]H�UHVWDXUDFML�QD�6áRZDFML�ħUyGáR��)RWRJUDILD�Z\NRQDQD�SU]H]�DXWRUD��PDU]HF�������

���'/$&=(*2�.2&+$0<�.,&="

NRU]\VWQLH�QD�VDPRSRF]XFLH�F]áRZLHND��. 0RW\Z\�URĞOLQQH�E\á\�MHGQ\PL�]�SRG�VWDZRZ\FK� IRUP�NLF]X�ZVND]DQ\PL�Z�G]LHOH�0ROHVD����.LF]�SRGREQHJR�URG]DMX�ZLąĪH� VLĊ� ]� OXG]Ną� VNáRQQR�ĞFLą�GR�SU]HGVWDZLDQLD Z]EXG]DMąF\FK�OXG]NLH�HPRFMH�QDWXUDOQ\FK�HOHPHQWyZ�NUDMREUD]X�� WDNLFK�MDN�NDQLRQ\��ZRGR�VSDG\��U]HNL��JHM]HU\�L�MDVNLQLH��.

3RQDGWR� ]GDQLHP�HZROXFMRQLVWyZ�KHWHURVHNVXDOQL�PĊĪF]\ĨQL� SRZLQQL�FHFKRZDü� VLĊ� XSRGREDQLHP�GR�SU]HG�VWDZLHĔ�FLDá�NRELHF\FK�� D�NRELHW\�PĊ�VNLFK��7D� VNáRQQRĞü�PRĪH� WáXPDF]\ü�F]ĊĞFLRZR� OXG]Ną� VNáRQQRĞü� GR� WZR�U]HQLD�ZL]HUXQNyZ� VHNVLVWRZVNLFK��. %DUG]R�F]ĊVWR� ]GDU]D� VLĊ�ERZLHP�� ĪH�NRELHW\�Z�UR]HURW\]RZDQ\FK�SR]DFK� UHNODPXMą�SURGXNW\��NWyUH� WUXGQR�SRáąF]\ü�Z� MDNLNROZLHN� FLąJ� ORJLF]Q\� ]� NRELHF\P�FLDáHP��3RQLĪHM� SUH]HQWXMĊ� SU]\NáDG\�SRFKRG]ąFH�]�.UDNRZD�L�6LHGOHF�

,OXVWUDFMD� ���5HNODPD� VNXSX� ]áRPX�Z�.UDNRZLH��ħUyGáR�� )RWRJUDILD�Z\NRQDQD� SU]H]� DXWRUD�����NZLHWQLD�������

��� 3RU��'�3��:D W V R Q��$�:��% X U O L Q J D P H��7KHUDS\�WKURXJK�+RUWLFXOWXUH��1HZ�<RUN�������$��9H U Q H ] ��0 R X G R Q��-�+��+ H H U Z D J H Q��5HVLGHQW¶V�$WWLWXGHV�WRZDUG�'HVLJQ�'LYHUVLW\��5HVHDUFK�5HSRUW��:DVKLQJWRQ������

��� 3RU��$��0 R O H V��.LF]�F]\OL�6]WXND�V]F]ĊĞFLD��V��������� 3RU��*��2 U L D Q V��-�+��+ H H U Z D J H Q��(YROYHG�5HVSRQVHV��V��������� 3RU��.��à X F ] D M��6HNVL]P�Z� UHNODPLH�D� VSRáHF]QH�SU]\]ZROHQLH�� Ä6WXGLD�0HGLR]QDZF]H´�

������QU����V�����±����

,OXVWUDFMD����3DPLąWND�SU]HGVWDZLDMąFD�:LHONL�.DQLRQ��ħUyGáR��KWWS���ZZZ�HWV\�FRP�PDUNHW�FROOHFWDEOHBNLWVFK"UHI OLVWLQJBWDJ�>GRVWĊS�����NZLHWQLD�����@�

��� .$0,/�à8&=$-

,OXVWUDFMD����5HNODPD�FHQWUXP�RJURG]HĔ�Z�6LHGOFDFK��ħUyGáR��)RWRJUDILD�Z\NRQDQD�SU]H]�DXWRUD����VLHUSQLD�������

2VWDWQLH�DGDSWDFMD�HVWHW\F]QD��NWyUą�FKFLDáE\P�WX�SRUXV]\ü�� UyĪQL�VLĊ�RG�SR�]RVWDá\FK�W\P��ĪH�QLH�Z\QLND�RQD�]�ELRILOLL�DQL�LQVW\QNWX�VHNVXDOQHJR�7KRUQKLOO�XZDĪD� ERZLHP�� ĪH� SRZLQQD� LVWQLHü� DGDSWDFMD� GHF\GXMąFD� R� SR]\W\ZQ\P�RFH�QLDQLX� MHG]HQLD�Z�NDWHJRULDFK� HVWHW\F]Q\FK��1DMZDĪQLHMV]\PL� F]\QQLNDPL� MHJR�RFHQ\�SRZLQQ\�E\ü�]DSDFK�L�ZDUWRĞü�RGĪ\ZF]D��'REU\�SU]\NáDG�NLF]X�RSDUWHJR�

,OXVWUDFMD����6FHQD�]�SURJUDPX�Ä3DPLĊWQLNL�]�ZDNDFML �́�ħUyGáR��6(�SO��KWWS���ZZZ�VH�SO�PH]F]\]QD�ZV]\VWNR�R�NRELHWDFK�PLHVQ\�MH]�\RXWXEH�ZLGHR�EHDWND�L�KHQLR�F]\OL�NDWDU]\QD�PDOLQRZVND�L�SLRWU�ZDQNR�SRND]XMD�MDN�SRGHUZB�������KWPO�>GRVWĊS�����NZLHWQLD�����@�

���'/$&=(*2�.2&+$0<�.,&="

QD�SU]HGVWDZLHQLX�MHG]HQLD�]QDMGXMH�VLĊ�QD�LOXVWUDFML����,QQ\P�SU]\NáDGHP�PRĪH�E\ü�ÄPLĊVQ\�MHĪ �́�SyáPLVHN�SU]\JRWRZDQ\�SU]H]�ERKDWHUyZ�SURJUDPX�Ä3DPLĊWQLNL�]�ZDNDFML �́�.LF]RZDWRĞü�VFHQ\�L�MHM�NRPL]P��ERKDWHURZL�ĞSLHZDOL�RVREOLZą�SLRVHQNĊ��DE\�XF]FLü�WHQ�SRVLáHN��VSRZRGRZDá\��ĪH�VFHQD�WD�RELHJáD�SROVNL�,QWHUQHW�

,,,�� .,&=�1$785$/1<�,�.,&=�.8/7852:<

.WyUD� ]�GZyFK�SU]HGVWDZLRQ\FK� WHRULL�Z\GDMH� VLĊ� EDUG]LHM�ZLDU\JRGQD"� ,VWQLHMą�SU]HNRQXMąFH�DUJXPHQW\�QD�SRSDUFLH�REX��7HRULD�NXOWXURZD�RSLHUD�VLĊ�QDMF]ĊĞFLHM�QD�EDGDQLDFK�%RXUGLHX���������FKRü�Z�ZLHOX�NUDMDFK�SU]HSURZDG]RQR�ORNDOQH�EDGDQLD��NWyUH�SRWZLHUG]DMą�MHM�VáXV]QRĞü����5]HF]RZH�DUJXPHQW\�SU]HPDZLDMą�MHGQDN�WDNĪH�QD�U]HF]�GUXJLHM�WHRULL��3R]D�F\WRZDQ\PL�MXĪ�HNVSHU\PHQWDPL�ZDUWR�SU]\MU]Hü�VLĊ�GZyP�LQQ\P�ĨUyGáR�

:������URNX�9LWDO\�.RPDU�L�$OH[DQGHU�0DODPLG��DUW\ĞFL��NWyU]\�Z\HPLJURZDOL�]H�=ZLą]NX�5DG]LHFNLHJR�GR�6WDQyZ�=MHGQRF]RQ\FK��SRGMĊOL�VLĊ�GRĞü�QLHFRG]LHQ�QHJR�SU]HGVLĊZ]LĊFLD��SRVWDQRZLOL�XSUDZLDü�ÄV]WXNĊ�VRFMRORJLF]Qą �́�F]\OL�V]WXNĊ��NWyUD�E\áDE\�RSDUWD�QD�Z\QLNDFK�VRQGDĪ\��:\QLNL�X]\VNDQH�]D�SRPRFą�EDGDQLD�VRFMRORJLF]QHJR�SU]H]�ZLHOX�UHODW\ZLVWyZ�NXOWXURZ\FK�]RVWDá\�X]QDQH�]DSHZQH�]D�]DVNDNXMąFH��SRQLHZDĪ�XMDZQLá\�LVWQLHQLH�XQLZHUVDOQ\FK�OXG]NLFK�SUHIHUHQFML�HVWH�W\F]Q\FK��=DVNRF]HQL�E\OL�UyZQLHĪ�VDPL�DUW\ĞFL��.RPDU�VNRPHQWRZDá�MH�Z�QDVWĊSXMąF\�VSRVyE� Ä7XWDM�Z�$PHU\FH��]DQLP�RWU]\PDOLĞP\�Z\QLNL�VRQGDĪX��P\ĞOHOLĞP\��ĪH�QDPDOXMHP\�UyĪQH�REUD]\��]DOHĪQLH�RG�GRFKRGX��UDV\��=DPLDVW�WHJR��GRNRQDOLĞP\�]DVNDNXMąFHJR�RGNU\FLD��Z�VSRáHF]HĔVWZLH�]QDQHJR�]�ZROQRĞFL�HNVSUHVML��ZROQRĞFL�MHGQRVWNL��QDV]�VRQGDĪ�XMDZQLá��ĪH�ZLĊNV]RĞü�OXG]L�PD�LGHQW\F]QH�SUHIHUHQFMH �́�. 1D�SRGVWDZLH�Z\QLNyZ�]OHFRQ\FK�SU]H]�VLHELH�EDGDĔ�.RPDU�L�0HODPLG�QDPDORZDOL�VHULĊ�REUD]yZ��NWyUD�PLDáD�RG]ZLHUFLHGODü�OXG]NLH�ORNDOQH��QDURGRZH��SUHIHUHQFMH�HVWHW\F]QH��2ND]DáR�VLĊ��ĪH�REUD]\�ÄQDMEDUG]LHM�FKFLDQH´�L�ÄQDMPQLHM�FKFLDQH´�UyĪQLą�VLĊ�Z\UDĨQLH�RG�VLHELH��MHGQDN�RGUyĪQLHQLH�SRV]F]HJyOQ\FK�HJ]HPSODU]\�Z�UDPDFK�NDĪGHM�]�JUXS�QLH� MHVW�]DGDQLHP�áDWZ\P��8]\VNDQH�UH]XOWDW\�PRĪQD�RNUHĞOLü�]D�SRPRFą�SRMĊFLD� XNXWHJR�SU]H]� -RKDQD�.RHVODJD�� NWyU\� VWZLHUG]Lá�� ĪH� OXG]NLPL�SUHIHUHQFMDPL� HVWHW\F]Q\PL� U]ąG]L� F]ĊVWR� ÄNDLQRILOLD´� �]� JU��NDLQRV� ±� ]Z\Ná\���OXG]LH�PDMą�WHQGHQFMĊ�GR�Z\ELHUDQLD�WHJR��FR�QLHNRQWURZHUV\MQH�L�SRZWDU]DOQH��. *HQHUDOQLH� U]HF]�ELRUąF�� EH]�Z]JOĊGX�QD� F]\QQLNL� NXOWXURZH�� QDMOHSLHM� E\á\�RG�

��� 3RU��QS��$��0 D W X F K Q L D N � . U D V X V N D��*XVW�L�NRPSHWHQFMD��àyGĨ�������� 3DLQWLQJ� E\�1XPEHUV��.RPDU�DQG�0HODPLG¶V� 6FLHQWLILF�*XLGH� WR�$UW�� HG�� -��:\SLMHZVNL��

1HZ�<RUN�������V������ N. E t c o f f, 6XUYLYDO�RI�WKH�3UHWWLHVW��V������

��� .$0,/�à8&=$-

ELHUDQH�SU]HGVWDZLHQLD�QDWXU\�]DZLHUDMąFH�GXĪR�NRORUX�QLHELHVNLHJR� L�]LHORQHJR��1DJRU]HM�UHVSRQGHQFL�RFHQLDOL�V]WXNĊ�DEVWUDNF\MQą��.

,QWHUHVXMąFH�Z�W\P�NRQWHNĞFLH�Vą�WDNĪH�EDGDQLD�DQWURSRORJLF]QH�'DYLGD�+DOOH¶D��ZVND]XMąFH��ĪH�NUDMREUD]\�Vą�QDMSRSXODUQLHMV]\P�W\SHP�REUD]yZ�Z\ELHUDQ\P�SU]H]�SU]HGVWDZLFLHOL�ZV]\VWNLFK�ZDUVWZ� VSRáHF]Q\FK����:ĞUyG�EDGDQ\FK�SU]H]�QLHJR�JRVSRGDUVWZ�GRPRZ\FK�ZLHOH�SRVLDGDáR�SU]HGVWDZLHQLD�NUDMREUD]yZ������REUD]yZ�Z\ZLHV]RQ\FK�Z�GREU]H�ZLGRF]Q\FK�PLHMVFDFK�QD�0DQKDWDQLH������Z�0HGIRUG�L�QD�*UHHQSRLQFLH������Z�0DQKDVVHW�����'OD�SRUyZQDQLD�V]WXND�DEVWUDNF\MQD�E\áD�U]DG]LHM� REHFQD�ZH�ZV]\VWNLFK� W\SDFK�JRVSRGDUVWZ�GRPRZ\FK�� FKRü�Z\UDĨQH�E\áR�Z� W\P�SU]\SDGNX� ]UyĪQLFRZDQLH� NODVRZH� �������REUD]yZ�Z\ZLHV]RQ\FK�Z�GREU]H�ZLGRF]Q\FK�PLHMVFDFK�QD�0DQKDWWDQLH�� �����Z�0DQKDVVHW�� ]DOHGZLH������Z�0HGIRUG�L����QD�*UHHQSRLQFLH���.

� 7HRULD�HZROXF\MQD�QLH�Z\MDĞQLD�MHGQDN�IHQRPHQX�ÄNUDVQDOD�RJURGRZHJR �́�-DNą�ZDUWRĞü� DGDSWDF\MQą�PLDáRE\�ERZLHP�XSRGREDQLH� GR� W\FK� V\PSDW\F]Q\FK�VNąGLQąG�VWZRUyZ"�1LH�VSRVyE�]DSU]HF]\ü��ĪH�NLF]�MHVW�]DOHĪQ\�RG�NXOWXU\��Z�NWyUHM�IXQNFMRQXMH��3\WDQLH�R�WR��NWyUD�]�WHRULL�Z\MDĞQLD�OHSLHM�OXG]NLH�SUHIHUHQFMH��SR]RVWDMH�MHGQDN�QD�UD]LH�RWZDUWH��%\ü�PRĪH�VDPR�S\WDQLH�MHVW�ĨOH�SRVWDZLRQH��2ELH�WHRULH�QLH�PXV]ą�E\ü�SRVWU]HJDQH�MDNR�VSU]HF]QH��-HVW�SUDZGRSRGREQH��ĪH�FKRFLDĪ�LVWQLHMą�QDWXUDOQH�Z]RUFH�WHJR��FR�QDP�VLĊ�SRGRED��WR�NXOWXUD�VWDQRZL�ĨUyGáR��NWyUH�XF]\�QDV��FR�MHVW�Z�]á\P�JXĞFLH��:�Z\QLNX�VSU]ĊĪHQLD�W\FK�GZyFK�F]\QQLNyZ��QLNRPX��NWR�]QDMGXMH�VLĊ�Z�RUELFLH�NXOWXU\�OHJLW\PL]RZDQHM��QLH�SU]\V]áRE\�GR�JáRZ\�SRZLHVLü�REUD]X�SU]HGVWDZLDMąFHJR�QDWXUDOQ\�NLF]��ZRGRVSDG��NDQLRQ���2VRE\�SRVLDGDMąFH�OXGRZ\�W\S�NDSLWDáX�NXOWXURZHJR�]URELą�WR�MHGQDN�FKĊWQLH��:DUWR�]DXZDĪ\ü��ĪH�VDP�ZLGRN�ZRGRVSDGX�F]\�NDQLRQX�QLH�MHVW�MHV]F]H�NLF]HP��:UĊF]�SU]HFLZQLH��]QDF]ąFD�ZLĊNV]RĞü�OXG]L�X]QDáDE\�WH�ZLGRNL�]DSHZQH�]D�]DSLHUDMąFH�GHFK�Z�SLHUVLDFK��'R�RU\JLQDOQ\FK�ZLGRNyZ�PDMą�GRVWĊS�MHGQDN�Z\áąF]QLH�QLHNWyU]\��]D]Z\F]DM�FL�OHSLHM�V\WXRZDQL��3R]RVWDá\P�SR]RVWDMH� W\ONR�NLF]�� V]WXND�SR]RUyZ��3R]RU\� L� LPLWDFMH�Vą�]DĞ�RFHQLDQH�Z�QDV]HM�NXOWXU]H�QHJDW\ZQLH��&KRü�SRG]LZLDQLH�:LHONLHJR�.D�QLRQX�QD�Ī\ZR�L�QD�SRF]WyZFH�OXE�Z�NDOHQGDU]X�Z\Sá\ZD�]�WHJR�VDPHJR�ĨUyGáD��NXOWXUD�RFHQLD�WH�GZLH�F]\QQRĞFL�]XSHáQLH�UyĪQLH��:�SLHUZV]\P�SU]\SDGNX�MHVW�WR�GRĞZLDGF]HQLH�HVWHW\F]QH��Z�GUXJLP�GRĞZLDGF]HQLH�NLF]RZH�

��� 6]F]HJyáRZH�Z\QLNL�VRQGDĪX�PRĪQD�]QDOHĨü�Z��3DLQWLQJ�E\�1XPEHUV��.RPDU�DQG�0HODPLG¶V�6FLHQWLILF�*XLGH�WR�$UW.

��� 'DYLG�+DOOH��NRU]\VWDMąF�]�EDULHU�SU]HVWU]HQQ\FK�FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\FK�GOD�DPHU\NDĔVNLFK�NODV� VSRáHF]Q\FK�� SURZDG]Lá� VZRMH�EDGDQLD�Z� F]WHUHFK�RGG]LHOQ\FK� F]ĊĞFLDFK�RVLHGOL�Z�1RZ\P�-RUNX�L�RNROLFDFK��0DQKDWWDQ�]RVWDá�WX�SRWUDNWRZDQ\�MDNR�RNROLFD�FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QD�GOD�PLHMVNLHM�NODV\�Z\ĪV]HM��0DQKDVVHW�X]QDQR�]D�REV]DU�]DVLHGORQ\�SU]H]�SU]HGVWDZLFLHOL�SRGPLHMVNLHM�NODV\�ĞUHGQLHM�Z\ĪV]HM��PLHV]NDĔFyZ�*UHHQSRLQWX�X]QDZDQR�]D�PLHMVNą�NODVĊ�URERWQLF]ą��QDWRPLDVW�RVRE\�PLHV]NDMąFH�Z�0HGIRUG�QD�/RQJ� ,VODQG� ]D� SRGPLHMVNą�NODVĊ� URERWQLF]ą� �SRU��'��+ D O O H�� ,QVLGH�&XOWXUH��$UW�DQG�&ODVV�LQ�WKH�$PHULFDQ�+RPH��&KLFDJR�/RQGRQ�������V������

��� 7DPĪH��V�������� 7DPĪH��V�����

���'/$&=(*2�.2&+$0<�.,&="

$QDOL]XMąF�IHQRPHQ�NLF]X��QLH�SRZLQQLĞP\�RJUDQLF]Dü�VLĊ�GR�Z\MDĞQLHĔ�NXO�WXURZ\FK�OXE�QDWXUDOLVW\F]Q\FK��=D]Z\F]DM�ERZLHP�SRWU]HED�NLF]X�Z\QLND�]�REX�URG]DMyZ�XZDUXQNRZDĔ��7DN�SU]\QDMPQLHM� VXJHUXMH� WHRULD�� NWyUą� ]ZHU\ILNRZDü�PRJą�EDGDQLD�HPSLU\F]QH��(ZROXFMRQLVW\F]QD�WUDG\FMD�EDGDQLD�JXVWX�HVWHW\F]QH�JR��FKRü�MHVW�REHFQLH�]QDF]QLH�EDUG]LHM�SRSXODUQD�Z�6WDQDFK�=MHGQRF]RQ\FK�QLĪ�Z�3ROVFH��SRVLDGD�SHZQH�]DNRU]HQLHQLH�Z�SROVNLHM�WUDG\FML�VRFMRORJLF]QHM��3U]HG�ODW\�6WDQLVáDZ�2VVRZVNL�SLVDá�R�Ä]RRORJLL�VSRáHF]QHM �́�F]\OL�QDXFH��NWyUD�Z\SURZDG]D�XRJyOQLHQLD�QD�SRGVWDZLH�EDGDQLD�FDáHJR�ĞZLDWD�]ZLHU]ąW��GR�NWyUHJR�]DOLF]D�VLĊ�WDNĪH�F]áRZLHN����3U]HGVWDZLRQ\�Z�DUW\NXOH�SRVWXODW�ZáąF]HQLD�Z\MDĞQLHĔ�QDWXUD�OLVW\F]Q\FK�GR�WHRULL�NXOWXURZHM�VWDQRZL�QDZLą]DQLH�GR�WHM�WUDG\FML�

%,%/,2*5$),$

%DOOLQJ�-�'���)DON�-�+���'HYHORSPHQW�RI�9LVXDO�3UHIHUHQFH�IRU�1DWXUDO�(QYLURQPHQWV��Ä(QYLURQPHQW�DQG�%HKDYLRU´�������QR������V���±���

Bourdieu P., '\VW\QNFMD��6SRáHF]QD�NU\W\ND�ZáDG]\�VąG]HQLD��SU]Há��3��%LáRV��:DUV]DZD������%RXUGLHX�3���3DVVHURQ�-��&���5HSURGXNFMD��(OHPHQW\� WHRULL� V\VWHPX�QDXF]HQLD��SU]Há�� >]� MĊ]�� IU�@�

(��1H\PDQ��:DUV]DZD������Bourdieu P., 7KH�)RUPV�RI�&DSLWDO��Z��(GXFDWLRQ��&XOWXUH��(FRQRP\��DQG�6RFLHW\��HG��$�+��+DOVH\��

1HZ�<RUN�������V����±��.%ULQJVOLPDUN�7���+DUWLJ�7���3DWL�*�*���$GDSWDWLRQ�WR�:LQGRZOHVVQHVV��Ä(QYLURQPHQW�DQG�%HKDYLRU´�

������QR�����V�����±����%URFK�+���.LOND�XZDJ�R�NLF]X�L� LQQH�HVHMH��SU]Há��'��%RUNRZVND��-��*DUHZLF]��5��7XUF]\Q��:DU�

V]DZD������Dutton D., 7KH�$UW�,QVWLQFW��%HDXW\��3OHDVXUH��+XPDQ�(YROXWLRQ��2[IRUG������Etcoff N., 6XUYLYDO�RI�WKH�3UHWWLHVW��7KH�6FLHQFH�RI�%HDXW\��/RQGRQ������Fiske J., =UR]XPLHü�NXOWXUĊ�SRSXODUQą��SU]HNá��.��6DZLFND��.UDNyZ������*UDG�-���2E\F]DMRZR�OXG\F]Q\�Z\PLDU�MDUPDUNX��Z��.DUQDZDOL]DFMD��7HQGHQFMH�OXG\F]QH�Z�NXO�

WXU]H�ZVSyáF]HVQHM��UHG��QDXN��-��*UDG��+��0DP]HU��3R]QDĔ�������V����±���*URGQ\�6���*UXV]ND�-���àXF]DM�.���2�]DZĊĪHQLX�Z\ĪV]HJR�JXVWX�HVWHW\F]QHJR��$QDOL]D�]MDZLVND�

ZV]\VWNRĪHUQRĞFL�NXOWXURZHM�Z�3ROVFH��Ä6WXGLD�6RFMRORJLF]QH´�������QU����V�����±����+DOOH�'���,QVLGH�&XOWXUH��$UW�DQG�&ODVV�LQ�WKH�$PHULFDQ�+RPH��&KLFDJR��/RQGRQ������2ULDQV�*���+HHUZDJHQ�-�+���(YROYHG�5HVSRQVHV�WR�/DQGVFDSHV��Z��7KH�$GDSWHG�0LQG��(YROXWLRQ�

DU\�3V\FKRORJ\�DQG�WKH�*HQHUDWLRQ�RI�&XOWXUH��HG��-�+��%DUNRZ��/��&RVPLGHV��-��7RRE\��1HZ�<RUN�2[IRUG�������V�����±����

+HHUZDJHQ�-�+���2ULDQV�*���+XPDQV��+DELWDWV��DQG�$HVWKHWLFV��Z��7KH�%LRSKLOLD�+\SRWKHVLV, ed. (�2��:LOVRQ��6��.HOOHUW��:DVKLQJWRQ�������V�����±����

+ROOLGD\�5���5HIOHFWLQJ� WKH� 6HOI��Z��3LFWXULQJ� WKH� 6RFLDO�/DQGVFDSH��9LVXDO�0HWKRGV� DQG� WKH�6RFLRORJLFDO�,PDJLQDWLRQ��HG��&��.QRZOHV��3��6ZHHWPDQ��/RQGRQ�1HZ�<RUN�������V����±���

��� 6��2 V V RZ V N L��=RRORJLD�VSRáHF]QD�L�]UyĪQLFRZDQLH�NXOWXURZH��Z��WHQĪH��2�QDXFH��:DUV]DZD�������V�����±����

��� .$0,/�à8&=$-

.DSODQ�6���(QYLURQPHQWDO�3UHIHUHQFH�LQ�D�.QRZOHGJH�6HHNLQJ��.QRZOHGJH�8VLQJ�2UJDQLVP��Z��7KH�$GDSWHG�0LQG��(YROXWLRQDU\�3V\FKRORJ\�DQG� WKH�*HQHUDWLRQ�RI�&XOWXUH�� HG�� -�+��%DUNRZ��/��&RVPLGHV��-��7RRE\��1HZ�<RUN�2[IRUG�������V�����±����

.áRVNRZVND�$���.XOWXUD�PDVRZD��:DUV]DZD�������V������

.XURZLFNL�-���(VWHW\F]QRĞü�ĞURGRZLVND�QDWXUDOQHJR��:DUV]DZD������àXF]DM�.���3HUVSHNW\ZD�HZROXFMRQLVW\F]QD�Z�HVWHW\FH�HPSLU\F]QHM��=DáRĪHQLD��WUDG\FMH��SUREOHP\,

Ä.XOWXUD�L�(GXNDFMD´�������QU����V����±����àXF]DM�.���6HNVL]P�Z� UHNODPLH� D� VSRáHF]QH�SU]\]ZROHQLH�� Ä6WXGLD�0HGLR]QDZF]H´������� QU� ���

V�����±����/\QHV�5���7KH�7DVWHPDNHUV��/RQGRQ������0ROHV�$���.LF]� F]\OL� 6]WXND� V]F]ĊĞFLD�� 6WXGLXP�R� SV\FKRORJLL� NLF]X�� SU]Há��$�� 6]F]HSDĔVND��

(��:HQGH��:DUV]DZD������2VVRZVNL�6���=RRORJLD�VSRáHF]QD�L�]UyĪQLFRZDQLH�NXOWXURZH��Z��WHQĪH��2�QDXFH��:DUV]DZD�������

V�����±����7KRUQKLOO�5���'DUZLQLDQ�$HVWKHWLFV� ,QIRUPV�7UDGLWLRQDO�$HVWKHWLFV��Z��(YROXWLRQDU\�$HVWKHWLFV,

HG��(�7��9RODQG��.��*UDPPHU��%HUOLQ�+HLGHOEHUJ�1HZ�<RUN�������V���±���9HUQH]�0RXGRQ�$���+HHUZDJHQ� -�+���5HVLGHQW¶V�$DWWLWXGHV� WRZDUG�'HVLJQ�'LYHUVLW\��5HVHDUFK�

5HSRUW��:DVKLQJWRQ������:DWVRQ�'�3���%XUOLQJDPH�$�:���7KHUDS\�WKURXJK�+RUWLFXOWXUH��1HZ�<RUN������:LOVRQ�(�2���%LRSKLOLD��7KH�+XPDQ�%RQG�ZLWK�2WKHU�6VSHFLHV��&DPEULGJH�/RQGRQ������:\SLMHZVNL J. >HG�@��3DLQWLQJ�E\�1XPEHUV��.RPDU�DQG�0HODPLG¶V�6FLHQWLILF�*XLGH� WR�$UW��1HZ�

<RUN������

6 W U H V ] F ] H Q L H

&HOHP�DUW\NXáX� MHVW� NU\W\F]QD� DQDOL]D�GZyFK�SDUDG\JPDWyZ��Z�REUĊELH�NWyU\FK�SURZDG]RQD� MHVW�DQDOL]D�]MDZLVND�NLF]X��7UDG\F\MQH�SRGHMĞFLH��NWyUH�RNUHĞODP�PLDQHP�ÄNXOWXURZHJR �́�Z\ZRG]L�VLĊ�]�SUDF�$EUDKDPD�0ROHVD��+HUPDQQD�%URFKD�L�LQQ\FK�P\ĞOLFLHOL��OHF]�Z�QDXNDFK�VSRáHF]Q\FK�MHJR�ZáDĞFLZHJR�VIRUPXáRZDQLD�GRNRQDá�3LHUUH�%RXUGLHX��3DUDG\JPDW�WHQ�]DNáDGD��ĪH�OXG]NLH�JXVWD�Vą�]UyĪQLFRZDQH�NODVRZR��D�ZSá\Z�QD�XSRGREDQLH�GR�NLF]X�PDMą�WDNLH�F]\QQLNL��MDN�SR]LRP�GRFKRGX��Z\NV]WDáFHQLD�F]\�ZLHONRĞü�PLHMVFRZRĞFL��]�NWyUHM�NWRĞ�SRFKRG]L��2G�SRF]ąWNX�ODW�����;;�ZLHNX�GXĪą�SRSXODUQRĞü�]GRE\ZD�MHGQDN�SDUDG\JPDW�RSDUW\�QD�'DUZLQRZVNLHM�WHRULL�HZROXFML��%DGDF]H��P�LQ��'HQLV�'XWWRQ�L�1DQF\�$LNHQ��]ZUDFDMą�XZDJĊ��ĪH�HZROXFMD�Z\NV]WDáFLáD�SHZQH�DGDSWDFMH�HVWHW\F]QH��NWyUH� SUHG\VSRQXMą� OXG]L� GR� FHQLHQLD� SU]HGPLRWyZ�NLF]RZDW\FK��=DZDUWH�Z� DUW\NXOH� UR]ZDĪDQLD�WHRUHW\F]QH�X]XSHáQLRQH�]RVWDá\�SU]\NáDGDPL�IRWRJUDILF]Q\PL�

6áRZD�NOXF]RZH��NLF]��WHRULD�NXOWXURZD��WHRULD�HZROXFMRQLVW\F]QD��]GMĊFLD

���'/$&=(*2�.2&+$0<�.,&="

:+<�'2�:(�/29(�.,76&+"� 7+(�&8/785$/�$1'�(92/87,21$5<�7+(25,(6

6 X P P D U \

7KH�PDLQ�DLP�RI� WKLV�SDSHU� LV�D�FULWLFDO� DQDO\VLV�RI� WKH� WZR�SDUDGLJPV�ZLWKLQ�ZKLFK�� WKH�DQDO\VLV�RI�WKH�SKHQRPHQRQ�RI�NLWVFK�LV�FDUULHG�RQ��7KH�WUDGLWLRQDO�DSSURDFK��ZKLFK�,�UHIHU�WR�DV�³FXOWXUDO �́�VWHPV�IURP�WKH�ZRUNV�RI�$EUDKDP�0ROHV��+HUPDQQ�%URFK�DQG�RWKHUV��EXW�LW�ZDV�3LHUUH�%RXUGLHX�ZKR�SURSRVHG�LWV�SURSHU�IRUPXODWLRQ�LQ�WKH�VRFLDO�VFLHQFHV��7KLV�SDUDGLJP�DVVXPHV�WKDW�KXPDQ�WDVWHV�DUH�GLYHUVLILHG��EHFDXVH�RI�D�VRFLDO�FODVV�DQG�IDFWRUV�VXFK�DV�OHYHO�RI�LQFRPH��HGXFDWLRQ��RU�WKH�VL]H�RI�WKH�SODFH�RI�UHVLGHQFH�KDYH�DQ�LPSDFW�RQ�WKH�WDVWH�IRU�NLWVFK��6LQFH�WKH�HDUO\�����V��KRZHYHU��D�SDUDGLJP�EDVHG�RQ�WKH�'DUZLQLDQ�LGHD�RI���HYROXWLRQ�EHFRPHV�PRUH�DQG�PRUH�SRSXODU��5HVHDUFKHUV�VXFK�DV�'HQLV�'XWWRQ�DQG�1DQF\�$LNHQ�SRLQWHG�RXW�WKDW�HYROXWLRQ�KDV�GHYHORSHG�VRPH�DHVWKHWLF�DGDSWDWLRQV�WKDW�SUHGLVSRVH�SHRSOH�WR�EH�VWURQJO\�DSSHDOHG�WR�NLWVFK\�LWHPV��7KHRUHWLFDO�FRQVLGHUDWLRQV�SUHVHQWHG�KHUH�DUH�VXSSOHPHQWHG�ZLWK�SKRWRV�

.H\ZRUGV��NLWVFK��FXOWXUDO�WKHRU\��HYROXWLRQDU\�WKHRU\��SKRWRV