THz radiation studies on biological systems at the ENEA FEL facility
-
Upload
independent -
Category
Documents
-
view
3 -
download
0
Transcript of THz radiation studies on biological systems at the ENEA FEL facility
Infrared Physics & Technology 45 (2004) 339–347
www.elsevier.com/locate/infrared
THz radiation studies on biological systemsat the ENEA FEL facility
A. Doria a,*, G.P. Gallerano a, E. Giovenale a, G. Messina a, A. Lai a,A. Ramundo-Orlando b, V. Sposato b, M. D’Arienzo c, A. Perrotta c,M. Roman�o c, M. Sarti c, M.R. Scarf�ı c, I. Spassovsky a,1, O. Zeni c
a ENEA-FIS-ACC, Via E. Fermi 45, 00044 Frascati, Italyb ICEmB at INEMM-CNR, Via Del Fosso del Cavaliere 100, 00133 Roma, Italy
c ICEmB at CNR-IREA, Via Diocleziano 328, 80124 Napoli, Italy
Available online 8 April 2004
Abstract
Emerging technologies are considering the possible use of THz radiation in different fields, ranging from telecom-
munication to biology and biomedicine. The study of the potential effects of THz radiation on biological systems is then
an important issue in order to safely develop a large number of applications. This task is being accomplished in the
framework of the EU funded THz-BRIDGE project. Experiments on the effects of THz radiation on different biological
samples with different techniques are being performed utilizing the compact free electron laser at the ENEA Research
Center of Frascati. Experimental results, together with statistical analysis are reported.
� 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The study of potential health hazard induced by
electromagnetic radiation in the THz region (100
GHz–20 THz) is one of the objectives of the EU
funded project THz-BRIDGE. Despite the recent
technological applications of THz radiation in
biology and biomedicine, which are based on the
specific spectroscopic fingerprints of biological
matter in this spectral region, very little is knownabout its interaction with biological systems. A
variety of techniques and biological assays are
* Corresponding author.1 ICTP Fellow.
1350-4495/$ - see front matter � 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserv
doi:10.1016/j.infrared.2004.01.014
employed within THz-BRIDGE to clarify such
issues [1]. In the present paper we present the studiesrelated to the interaction of THz radiation with two
important biological systems: a model of cell mem-
brane and human lymphocytes in whole blood.
A compact free electron laser (FEL) [2] has
been used to generate coherent radiation at 130
GHz. Due to the peculiar characteristics of the
electron accelerator (microtron) driving the FEL,
the radiation pulse (macropulse) is composed by atrain of 50 ps micropulses, spaced 330 ps apart.
The FEL radiation macropulse length is about
4 ls at a repetition rate that can be typically variedbetween 1 and 10 Hz. This peculiar temporal
structure of the emitted radiation allows the
investigation of the effects of high peak power,
ed.
340 A. Doria et al. / Infrared Physics & Technology 45 (2004) 339–347
while maintaining a low average power, typically
few mW, incident on the sample, thus avoiding
heating effects. The radiation is transported to a
dedicated user room by means of a special mm-
wave transmission line composed of an evacuated
copper light pipe and appropriate delivery optics.
2. Exposure of CA-loaded liposomes
The cell membrane plays an important role in
the interaction with extra cellular entities, both
from a physical and chemical point of view; it is
widely regarded as a biological structure likely tobe responsive to electromagnetic radiation as an
external physical entity. Several in vitro studies
indicate that millimeter wave radiation may alter
structural and functional properties of the cell
membrane, and the effect seems to be frequency
dependent [3–5]. Given the intrinsic complexity of
biomembranes, a simplified model membrane such
as a lipid bilayer, where all experimental parame-ters can be accurately monitored [6,7], has been
used for the present study. Liposomes are micro-
scopic vesicles in which an aqueous volume is en-
tirely enclosed by a membrane composed of
phospholipids. They form spontaneously when
amphipathic lipids are dispersed in aqueous media.
They can be prepared in such a way that they
entrap soluble materials both within their aqueouscompartment, as in our system, and within the
membrane. By constructing them with natural
phospholipids, the liposome membrane forms a
bilayer structure as it happens in the lipid portion
of cell membranes (see Fig. 1).
Fig. 1. Schematic representation of th
At cellular and sub-cellular level, the interaction
essentially develops through forces that the local
electromagnetic field exerts on the free and bound
electric charges of the biological system. It is
important to outline that, while the forces acting
on charges only depend on the electromagneticfield and on the electrical characteristics of the
‘‘particle’’, the dynamics of these ‘‘particles’’
(vibrations, displacements, rotations) also depends
on other properties (i.e. the mass, the kind of
‘‘particle’’: atomic or molecular, the chemical
bounds, etc.) and on neighbouring ‘‘particles’’.
The cationic liposomes used in the experiments
described in this article, are composed of lipidsnormally found in natural membranes such as
DPPC (dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine), choles-
terol, and positively charged stearylamine.
The soluble enzyme carbonic anhydrase (CA) is
loaded into the aqueous space of liposome.
Once its substrate (i.e., p-nitrophenyl acetate,
p-NPA) is present in the external aqueous space
of these liposomes, it is slowly hydrolysed bythe CA. Thus, any alteration of the lipid bilayer
permeability induced by THz radiation may be
evaluated by the ability of the substrate to dif-
fuse across the lipid bilayer. In this case it is
rapidly hydrolysed by the CA entrapped inside
the liposome. In particular, if the membrane
is damaged, the substrate flows into the vesicle
and interacts with the CA (the enzyme itselfcannot flow out of the vesicles) creating the
product of reactionaccording to the simple reac-
tion:
Eþ S $ P
e liposome and its lipid bilayer.
A. Doria et al. / Infrared Physics & Technology 45 (2004) 339–347 341
where E, S and P indicate the enzyme, the
substrate and the product of reaction, respec-
tively.
The enzyme activity measurements of CA were
carried out by following the appearance of reac-tion product, p-nitrophenolate, at its peak of
absorbance (k ¼ 400 nm), on a UV spectrophoto-
meter computer controlled (Cary 50). An increa-
sing value of substrate hydrolysis rate can be
directly associated with a membrane damage.
Two different irradiation set-up have been de-
signed and constructed, referred to as A (Fig. 2)
and B (Fig. 3).(A) The FEL radiation at the central frequency
of 130 GHz is transported through a copper light-
pipe of 25 mm diameter and is then fed into a
‘‘THz delivery system’’ (TDS) specifically designed
to match the irradiation requirements. The TDS is
made of aluminum and is built to provide a uni-
Fig. 3. Exposure of CA-loaded liposomes: setup B. (a) Irradiation fro
focusing the radiation onto the cuvette.
Fig. 2. Exposure of CA-loaded liposomes: setup A.
form irradiation of the liposome samples. The THz
beam coming from the light pipe into the TDS is
first focused down to a 17.5 mm diameter aperture
by means of a conical section and is then let ex-
pand by diffraction to about 52 mm diameter to
match the required irradiation area. Calculationshave been performed in order to minimize internal
reflections in the cone, making the beam expansion
similar to the free space expansion. The cuvette
containing the liposome samples is placed in a
Teflon grid, positioned in the region of maximum
uniformity of the field in the TDS over the entire
time of exposures (60 min).
(B) In order to irradiate the liposomes and carryout the kinetic measurements in real time, the cell
compartment of the spectrophotometer has been
modified to deliver the THz beam into the cuvette
containing the liposomes in a final volume of 1.5
ml. Two possible irradiation geometries have been
considered: irradiation from the side and from the
top of the cuvette. In the present experiments we
irradiated from the side of the cuvette (Fig. 3). Anelectroformed copper horn is used to match the
circular cross-section of the THz beam to the
rectangular cross-section of the cuvette.
The p-NPA hydrolysis rate, expressed as rate
of change in absorbance units at 400 nm/min
ðDA=minÞ, is computed automatically as the slopeof a linear fit to experimental recorded curves (Fig.
4). Data from exposed and sham samples arecompared and their variance is analyzed according
to the unpaired two-tailed Student’s at 95% con-
fidence interval.
m the side of the cuvette, (b) top view, showing the copper horn
0.8
0.85
0.9
0.95
1
0.0 0.3 0.5 0.8 1.0 1.3 1.5 1.8 2.0Time (min)
Abs
orba
nce
(400
nm
)
exposed
sham
Exper. dataLinear interp.
Fig. 4. Real time exposure of CA loaded liposomes: change in
absorbance of exposed and sham samples as a function of time.
Table1
Effectsofirradiationat130GHzonCA-loaded
liposomes(summary
oftheexposureconditionsandexperimentalresults)
Setup
Roomtemp.
(�C)
Timeof
exposure
Power
(mW/cm
2)
Pulserepetition
rate
DA=min
control
Da=min
exposed
%CAenzyme
activitycontrol
%CAenzyme
activityexposed
A20–22
600
0.16
4ls/5Hz
0.0064±0.0015
0.0059±0.0022
34±8
28±9
(n¼18)
(n¼20)
A20–22
600
0.23
4ls/7Hz
0.0024±0.0018
0.0036±0.0019
16±12
24±13
(n¼8)
(n¼10)
(p¼0:100)
B26–29
20
5.6
4ls/5Hz
0.0025±0.0011
0.0027±0.0018
21±10
23±14
(n¼18)
(n¼25)
B22
20
7.8
4ls/7Hz
0.0027±0.0014
0.0058±0.0014
14±8
31±9
(n¼22)
(n¼27)
(p¼8:6E)10)
B29
20
11.1
4ls/10Hz
0.0034±0.0010
0.0046±0.0014
28±8
37±12
(n¼7)
(n¼9)
(p¼0:041)
342 A. Doria et al. / Infrared Physics & Technology 45 (2004) 339–347
In the two sets of exposures (setup A and B), we
investigated the effect of 130 THz at different pulserepetition rate and average power delivered to the
CA-loaded liposomes. We obtained a significant
increase of the p-NPA hydrolysis rate ðDA=minÞfrom 0.0027± 0.0014 to 0.0058± 0.0014
(p ¼ 8:6�10) at 7 Hz, while there was no significantincrease at other frequencies of pulse repetition
rate (Table 1). This increment was calculated over
three sample and sham liposome preparations.Interesting, the observed differences in p-PNA
hydrolysis rate were significantly higher in setup B
than in setup A, indicating that real time exposures
might reveal possible reversible effects induced by
the field. In Fig. 5 the effect of exposures is re-
ported as the increase of enzymatic activity in
comparison to the total CA activity, determined
after rupture of liposomes by detergent, taken as100%. We obtained a significant increase of CA
activity from 14±8 to 31± 9 ðp ¼ 1:72E� 09Þ. Inspite of an intrinsic variability of the membrane
system due to the use of different liposome prep-
arations throughout all the experiments, the ob-
served effects cannot be merely due to a difference
of average power delivered to the system.
Our preliminary results indicate that the mem-brane model used in these studies appears to be
a system sensitive to THz exposure, especially
regarding the frequencies of pulse repetition rate.
Resonance effects on these cationic liposomes
entrapping carbonic anhydrase have already been
observed in the ELF (extremely low frequencies)
region at 7 Hz [8,9]. Future studies will provide
further information about any possible correlationbetween resonance effects observed at a pulse
THz effects on CA-loaded Liposomes
0
10
20
30
40
50
5B 7B 10B 7APulse repetition rate (Hz)
% Enzymatic activity
Sham
Exposed
Fig. 5. THz-stimulated diffusion of p-NPA through CA-loaded liposomes at different pulse repetition rates (the suffix A or B refers to
the exposure setup A and B, respectively). The total enzymatic activity of CA liposomes, after detergent rupture, was taken as 100%.
Table 2
Absorption coefficient of whole blood, serum and water at
A. Doria et al. / Infrared Physics & Technology 45 (2004) 339–347 343
repetition rate of 7 Hz and the previous effects
observed in the ELF region.
120 GHzWhole blood a ¼ 75 cm�1
Serum a ¼ 71 cm�1
Water a ¼ 85 cm�1
3. Irradiation of whole bloodIn this part of the work, human lymphocytes
have been used as a biological model for studying
potential genotoxic effects of THz radiation. The
study of genotoxic effects is indeed one of the most
interesting aspects in the risk assessment of humanexposure to ionizing and non-ionizing electro-
magnetic radiation, due to the close correlation
between DNA damage and cancer occurrence.
Human lymphocytes are a well-known biological
system playing a key role in the defense mecha-
nisms, they are the only blood constituents with a
nucleus, they are semi-synchronised cells easily
obtainable from peripheral blood and can bestimulated to divide in vitro by a variety of sub-
stances (mitogens).
Prior to the irradiation of whole blood, trans-
mission measurements performed at the frequency
of 120 GHz showed that absorption at THz fre-
quencies is mainly due to the water content of the
plasma [10,11]. The evaluation of the absorption
helps in the identification of the THz powereffectively absorbed by the different blood com-
ponents among which there are lymphocytes to be
tested in the genotoxic analysis. The measured
absorption coefficient of whole blood, serum andwater are reported in Table 2.
Cytogenetic techniques allow one to test DNA
damage, at cellular and molecular level, induced
by various chemical and physical agents. Two
different tests, the Micronucleus (MN) and the
Comet assays, with different sensibility, have been
applied on human lymphocytes. Different expo-
sure set up have been employed by using theCompact FEL at the ENEA Research Centre of
Frascati. The cytokinesis-block micronucleus
technique is a very sensitive and simple indicator
of structural chromosome damage, which also
provides information on cell cycle progression [12].
The alkaline single-cell gel electrophoresis (SCGE)
or Comet assay, is a promising tool for measuring
DNA damage at the individual cell level in bothin vitro and in vivo studies. In this type of assay
DNA damages result in a ‘‘comet’’, clearly visible
with the microscope, left from the cell when sub-
jected to electrophoresis. A brief description of the
assays and of the related experimental activity is
given in the following.
344 A. Doria et al. / Infrared Physics & Technology 45 (2004) 339–347
3.1. Micronucleus test
The nucleus is the organelle in the cell that
contains the genetic material (DNA) that controls
normal cellular function and cellular reproduction.In cells of eukaryotic organisms, the nucleus con-
tains DNA packaged into chromosomes. Chromo-
some shape, size, and number are constant for a
species. During cell division, the genetic material
replicates and then divides equally between the
two daughter cells that are produced. If the pro-
cess is interrupted, or the chromosomes are broken
or damaged by an external agent, like for instanceradiation, the distribution of genetic material be-
tween the two daughter nuclei during cell division
may be affected and pieces or entire chromosomes
may fail to be included in either of the two
daughter nuclei. When this occurs, the genetic
material that is not incorporated into a new nu-
cleus may form its own ‘‘micronucleus’’ which is
clearly visible with a microscope. Thus, to assesschromosomal damage by means of MN test,
samples are irradiated and then the frequency of
micronucleated cells is determined after cell divi-
sion is occurred. If an exposed group of samples
shows a significantly higher frequency of micro-
nucleated cells than the untreated control samples,
the radiation is considered to be capable of
inducing structural and/or numerical chromo-somal damage.
Previous experimental activity, performed on
whole blood from 9 healthy subjects aged between
30 and 45 years, showed that THz radiation for 20
min at both 120 and 130 GHz at a pulse repetition
frequency of 2 Hz does not affect MN formation
and does not influence cell proliferation [10,11]. In
the following we report the results of 20 minlymphocytes irradiation by THz radiation at 130
GHz and at a pulse repetition frequency of 5 and 7
Hz at a higher incident power.
In the first set of experiment an average power
of 3.5 mW, at a pulse repetition frequency of 5 Hz
was delivered to the sample. The corresponding
peak electric field is 7.8 kV/m, while the average
electric field is 35 V/m. For each irradiation set upblood samples from five healthy subjects have been
investigated in order to take into account indi-
vidual variability. The samples were placed in Petri
dishes of 52 mm diameter and irradiated for 20
min. The biological assay was conducted following
the protocol described in [11]. Results of the MN
test are reported in Fig. 6(a).
In the second set of experiments the pulse repe-
tition rate was raised to 7 Hz, causing an increaseof the average power up to 5 mW, and a corre-
sponding increase of the average electric field to
42 V/m. Results of the MN test are shown in Fig.
6(b). The cell proliferation is evaluated by scoring
the number of nuclei in 500 cells and determin-
ing the Cytokinesis-block proliferation index
(CBPI); the definition of the mean number of cell
cycles per cell [13] is:
CBPI ¼ ½M1þ 2M2þ 3ðM3þM4Þ=Nwhere M1 to M4 indicate the number of cells with
1–4 nuclei respectively, and N the total number of
cells scored.
All the experiments performed so far indicatethat radiation at 130 GHz does not induce
chromosome damage (MN assay) in human lym-
phocytes and does not induce alteration of cell
cycle kinetics (CBPI).
3.2. Comet assay
The comet assay consists of a single cell gel
alkaline electrophoresis to measure DNA damage
in various types of cells exposed to potential
genotoxic agents both chemical and physical.
Damage results in a comet, left from the mainnucleus of the cell when subjected to electropho-
resis, and clearly visible with the microscope as
illustrated in Fig. 7. Single cell electrophoresis is a
rapid method for detecting DNA strand breaks in
lymphocyte cells. In the original form of the assay
[14] cells embedded in agarose on microscope
slides were lysed and subjected to electrophoresis
under neutral conditions, enabling the detection ofDNA double strand breaks. A later modification
using alkaline conditions made it possible to detect
DNA single strand breaks and alkali labile sites
[15].
In the present study the Comet test was per-
formed on lymphocytes separated from the aque-
ous part of the blood (serum) and directly exposed
to THz radiation with two different experimental
Fig. 6. MN frequency and CBPI in human lymphocytes following 20 min THZ irradiation at 130 GHz and two different pulse
repetition rate: (A) 5 Hz, (B) 7 Hz. Results are expressed as mean±SD of five healthy donors employed for both 5 and 7 Hz.
Fig. 7. Nuclei of human lymphocytes as appeared following an
alkaline single cell gel electrophoresis. It is evident a damaged
nucleus, in which DNA fragments move from the main nucleus
forming the tail of the comet.
A. Doria et al. / Infrared Physics & Technology 45 (2004) 339–347 345
setup. Both setup resulted in a higher power
impinging on the single cells when compared to the
power impinging on lymphocytes immersed in the
serum, thus reducing the shielding effect of water
mentioned earlier and described by the absorption
data reported in Table 2. The two setup are shown
in Fig. 8. In the first setup (Fig. 8(a)) a centrifugedblood sample, composed of a lymphocyte layer on
top of red blood cells, is prepared in an Eppendorf
tube, which is placed inside a metallic cone and
then exposed to THz radiation with the cap of the
tube kept closed. In the second setup (Fig. 8(b))
the radiation is focused by means of the metallic
cone to the top of the Eppendorf tube, which is put
inside a PVC holder. This holder allows the tube tobe kept open avoiding the reflection and diffusion
of THz radiation by the cap of the Eppendorf. In
the setup of Fig. 8(a) we have to take into account
Fig. 8. Lymphocytes separated from the serum are exposed
directly to THz radiation. (a) First setup: the eppendorf tube
inside the metallic cone. (b) Second setup: the Eppendorf tube
placed into the PVC holder (after the metallic cone).
346 A. Doria et al. / Infrared Physics & Technology 45 (2004) 339–347
that the effective power impinging on the sample is
reduced by a fraction equal to the ratio between
the sample area and the area of the cross-section ofthe cone itself. In the setup of Fig. 8(b) the whole
power entering the cone also reaches the sample
surface.
Radiation is delivered to the sample in short
pulses at 7 Hz repetition rate, as described before.
The incident average power in setup (a) is 1.9 mW,
while in setup (b) it is 5.0 mW, corresponding to an
average electric field of 152 and 245 V/m respec-tively and a peak electric field of 28.7 and 46 kV/m
respectively (calculated on the 4 ls pulses). Fivesubjects were investigated in each setup using the
following protocol:
Fig. 9. Tail factor % in human lymphocytes following 20 min THz irra
setup A and B.
For each subject two Eppendorf tubes (1.8 ml)
containing each 1.5 ml of whole blood are ex-
posed/sham exposed to 130 4Hz for 20 min with
the above irradiation parameters after a suitable
portion of serum is removed by centrifugation at
1000 rpm · 10 min. At the end of exposure/shamexposure the homologous serum is added and the
blood samples are processed to perform the Comet
assay according to the method developed by Singh
[15].
The results of the Comet assays, expressed as
comet tail factor % according to Ivancsitz et al.
[16], are shown in Fig. 9 for the two different setup.
Our preliminary results obtained exposing wholeblood samples to 130 GHz radiation produced
different results for the two different setup. When
the sample is exposed inside the PVC holder (Fig.
8(b)), there is no evidence of a statistically signifi-
cant difference between the exposed sample and
the sham sample. On the contrary, when the
sample is exposed inside the metallic cone (Fig.
8(a)), a statistically significant effect is observed,despite the lower incident power. A possible
explanation of this result is that, when the Ep-
pendorf tube is placed inside the cone, the cone is
acting as a resonant cavity leading to a much
higher value of the effective electric field at the
surface of the lymphocyte layer. Further
improvements on the irradiation setup and inves-
tigation on a larger number of subjects are inprogress to validate this positive finding.
4. Conclusions
Investigations of the effects of THz radiation
have been conducted on two important biological
diation at 130 GHz and 7 Hz pulse repetition rate, for exposure
A. Doria et al. / Infrared Physics & Technology 45 (2004) 339–347 347
systems: a membrane model based on CA-loaded
liposomes and human lymphocytes on whole
blood. The preliminary results indicate the pres-
ence of a change of membrane permeability when
the samples are exposed to 130 GHz radiation
with a pulse repetition rate of 7 Hz. As to theexposure of human lymphocytes, the MN assay
performed so far indicate that radiation at 130
GHz does not induce chromosome damage (MN
assay) and does not induce alteration of cell cycle
kinetics (CBPI). However, in one of the experi-
mental setup, a positive result of the Comet assay
has been found that need further investigation. A
model of the interaction mechanism that takesinto account the evaluation of the power effec-
tively absorbed at a microscopic level by the
lymphocytes when placed in a THz resonant
cavity is being developed and will be the object of
future work.
Acknowledgements
This work has been carried out with financial
support from the Commission of the European
Communities, specific RTD programme ‘‘Quality
of Life and Management of Living Resources’’,
QLK4-CT2000-00129 ‘‘Tera-Hertz Radiation In
Biological Research, Investigation on Diagnostics
and study on potential Genotoxic Effects’’.
References
[1] J. Biol. Phys. 29 (2–3) (2003), Proceedings of the THz-
BRIDGE Workshop, Capri, Italy, October 2002; see also
the THz-BRIDGE web site: www.frascati.enea.it/thz-
bridge.
[2] G.P. Gallerano, A. Doria, E. Giovenale, A. Renieri,
Infrared Phys. Tech. 40 (1999) 161–174.
[3] S.I. Alekseev, M.C. Ziskin, Effects of millimeter waves on
ionic currents of Lymnaea Neurons, Bioelectromagnetics
20 (1999) 24–33.
[4] S.I. Alekseev, M.C. Ziskin, Millimeter microwave effect on
ion transport across lipid bilayer membranes, Bioelectro-
magnetics 16 (1995) 124–131.
[5] W.R. Adey, Neurochem. Res. 13 (1988) 671–677.
[6] A. Ramundo-Orlando, C. Arcovito, A. Palombo, A.L.
Serafino, G. Mossa, Enzymatic kinetic change of ascorbate
oxidase loaded into liposomes induced by microwave fields
exposure, J. Liposome Res. 3 (1993) 717–724.
[7] A. Ramundo-Orlando, G. Mossa, G. d’Inzeo, Effect of
microwave radiation on the permeability of carbonic
anhydrase loaded unilamellar liposomes, Bioelectromag-
netics 15 (1994) 303–313.
[8] A. Ramundo-Orlando, G. Mossa, G. d’Inzeo, U. Morbi-
ducci, Effect of low frequency, low amplitude, magnetic
fields on the permeability of carbonic anhydrase loaded
unilamellar liposomes: evidence for charged lipid involve-
ment, Bioelectromagnetics 21 (2000) 491–498.
[9] A. Ramundo-Orlando, G. Mossa, G. d’Inzeo, U. Morbid-
ucci, Effect of low frequency, low amplitude, magnetic
fields on the permeability of carbonic anhydrase loaded
unilamellar liposomes: no evidence for surface enzyme
involvement, Bioelectromagnetics 21 (2000) 499–507.
[10] E. Giovenale, M. D’Arienzo, A. Doria, G.P. Gallerano, A.
Lai, G. Messina, D. Piccinelli, Absorption and diffusion
measurements of biological samples using a THz free
electron laser, J. Biol. Phys. 29 (2003) 159–170.
[11] M.R. Scarf�ı, M. Roman�o, R. Di Pietro, O. Zeni, E.
Giovenale, M. D’Arienzo, A. Doria, G.P. Gallerano, A.
Lai, G. Messina, D. Coniglio, THz exposure of whole
blood for the study of biological effects on human
lymphocytes, J. Biol. Phys. 29 (2003) 171–177.
[12] M. Fenech, Mutation Res. 285 (1993) 35–44.
[13] Surralles et al., Mutation Res. 341 (1995) 169–184.
[14] O. Ostling, K.J. Johanson, Microelectrophoretic study of
radiation-induced DNA damages in individual mammalian
cells, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 123 (1984) 291–298.
[15] N.P. Singh, M.T. McCoy, R.R. Tice, E.L. Schneider, A
simple technique for quantitation of low levels of DNA
damage in individual cells, Exp. Cell Res. 175 (1988) 184–
191.
[16] S. Ivancsits, E. Diem, A. Pilger, H.W. Rudiger, O. Jahn,
Induction of DNA strand breaks by intermitted exposure
to extremely low frequency electromagnetic fields in human
diploid fibroblasts, Mutation Res. 519 (2002) 1–13.