SME CLOUD PROJECT
-
Upload
independent -
Category
Documents
-
view
4 -
download
0
Transcript of SME CLOUD PROJECT
December 2012
Business Model Development for TDP-ERP
SME Cloud Product
By: Gergely Balazs
December 27 2012
Gergely Balazs
December 2012
Business Model Development for TDP-ERP
SME Cloud Product
The Bachelor Degree in International Sales and Marketing
Author: Gergely Balazs
Assignment: Bachelor Project
Supervisor: Christian Preuthun Pedersen
Characters: 105 480
Submitted: 28 December 2012
Gergely Balazs
December 2012
Table of contents
1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................................1
1.1 Problem formulation ..........................................................................................................................1
1.2 Delimitation ........................................................................................................................................2
1.3 Scientific approach ............................................................................................................................2
1.3.1 Choice of scientific paradigm ...................................................................................................2
1.3.2 Choice of models and methods ...............................................................................................3
1.4 Reflection ............................................................................................................................................4
1.4.1 Quality Assessment and Source Criticism ..............................................................................4
1.4.2 Process Reflection .....................................................................................................................4
2. Product description ..................................................................................................................................5
3 The main characteristics of the SME sector ..........................................................................................6
3.1 SME categories ..................................................................................................................................6
3.2 Size of the SME sector ......................................................................................................................6
3.3 Characteristics of the SME Sector ...................................................................................................7
3.3.1 Political factors of the SME sector (Political)..........................................................................7
3.3.2 The financial situation of the SME sector (Economy) ...........................................................7
3.3.3 Managerial characteristics (Social) .........................................................................................8
3.3.4 ERP systems in the SME sector (Technological) ....................................................................9
3.4 Conclusion of SME sector .................................................................................................................9
4. Bookkeeping and accounting .............................................................................................................. 10
4.1 Internal bookkeeping and accounting ......................................................................................... 10
4.2 External bookkeeping ..................................................................................................................... 10
4.3 The range of provided services ..................................................................................................... 11
4.3.1 Provided services of the external bookkeepers .................................................................. 11
4.4 Market size of the bookkeepers ................................................................................................... 11
4.5 Pricing strategy ................................................................................................................................ 12
4.6 Relationship and partnership ........................................................................................................ 13
4.7 Competition on the bookkeeper market ...................................................................................... 14
4.7 Conclusion of the bookkeeping sector......................................................................................... 15
5. The characteristics of the Hungarian bank sector ............................................................................ 16
5.1 Strategy of Granit Bank .................................................................................................................. 16
5.2 Pillars of growth Strategy of Granit Bank ..................................................................................... 17
5.3 Sales channels of Granit Bank...................................................................................................... 18
Gergely Balazs
December 2012
5.4 Channel expansion ......................................................................................................................... 18
5.5 Conclusion of the bank sector and Granit Bank ......................................................................... 18
6 IT sector in Hungary ............................................................................................................................... 19
6.1 Financing ERP implementation ..................................................................................................... 19
6.2 Software developers of the SME cloud system .......................................................................... 20
6.2.1 Libra Szoftver ........................................................................................................................... 20
6.2.2 Sales channel of Libra Szoftver ............................................................................................. 20
6.2.3 Consortium of TDP-ERP and Global Solution....................................................................... 22
6.2.4 Sales channels of TDP-ERP.................................................................................................... 23
6.3 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................... 23
7 Establishing partnership ........................................................................................................................ 23
7.1 In depth understanding of the customer`s requirement .......................................................... 24
7.2 In depth understanding of the partner`s requirement .............................................................. 24
7.3 Reduction or elimination of cost of sale ...................................................................................... 25
7.4 Value-added chain .......................................................................................................................... 25
7.1.4 Value addition through partnership to the end users ........................................................ 26
7.5 Conclusion of the partnership ....................................................................................................... 26
8 SWOT analyses ....................................................................................................................................... 27
9 Business model ...................................................................................................................................... 28
9.1 Key partners .................................................................................................................................... 29
9.2 Key activities ................................................................................................................................... 29
9.3 Key resources .................................................................................................................................. 31
9.4 Value proposition ............................................................................................................................ 31
9.5 Customer relationship .................................................................................................................... 32
9.6 Channels .......................................................................................................................................... 32
9.7 Customer segment ......................................................................................................................... 33
9.8 Cost structure .................................................................................................................................. 33
9.9 Revenue stream .............................................................................................................................. 34
10 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................ 34
Bibliography .................................................................................................................................................... i
Appendix 1: Personal interview with Istvan Cieleszky ............................................................................. iv
Appendix 2: Notes from SME Academy Conference ............................................................................... vi
Appendix 3: Personal Interview with Istvan Harkai ................................................................................. vi
Gergely Balazs
December 2012
Executive Summary
The Cloud SME product is developed by the international consortium of TDP-ERP and Global
Solution. The development phase is 13 month; the expected date of product launch is the
beginning of 2014. The project is partly financed by the EUREKA_HU_12 grant offered by the New
Szechenyi Plan. The product provides integrated and complex solution for the SMEs in order to
reduce their resources spent on administration activities. The project has several stakeholders;
Granit Bank provides banking services, Libra Szoftver adds the modular ERP system. The
bookkeeping services are planned to be done by quality partners.
The agreement concerning the collaborative product launch has not been done yet, therefore it is
necessary to evaluate how the partners can benefit from the partnership and create a business
model as a basis of negotiation.
The analysis covers the SME sector in order to find the main characteristics and needs. The
bookkeeping industry is evaluated from the aspect of competition on the market, pricing and the
relationship between the clients. Granit Bank is one of the main stakeholders within the product
launch. The SME cloud product is planned to be the part of the bank`s product range and to be
sold through the existing sales channels. The analysis covers the sales strategy of the bank and
the value creation. The ERP system is developed by Libra Szoftver and the consortium of TDP-ERP
and Global Solution. The main characteristics, core competences and the sales channels are
investigated.
The second part of the analysis is moving from the individual level of companies to the level of
possible long term partnership. The aim is to investigate the additional values and benefits
concerning the product launch in partnership.
The findings clearly shows, that the product launch in a partnership creates more value for the
clients and partners, reduces the cost of sales and increases the sales possibilities. It is also
important from the sales aspect. Granit Bank as a newly established financial institute is still
acquiring clients. The sales channel of the bank is not enough to penetrate the market. The
resources are booked on the regular business activities; therefore it is necessary to use
alternative methods for client acquisition. Targeting the existing clientele of the partners gives the
possibility for sales activities at low cost. It also creates a win-win situation to the partners.
The quality bookkeeping services positively affect the lending activities of Granit Bank, which
evaluates the loan application based on the ledgers, reports and books. The ERP system is
special in a way that some modules can be accessed by the SMEs, and the bookkeeping module
by the bookkeepers. The data is provided from the cloud server base. The bookkeepers can
withdraw the data from the database to the bookkeeping module, which saves time adding those
manually. Libra Szoftver can target the micro and small segments. Other benefits are acquiring
the customer needs from different channels.
The business model should be built on the basis of partnership concerning the sales possibilities
and the required quality of the services. The key partners in the business model are the
consortium of TDP-ERP and Global Solution, Granit Bank, Libra Szoftver and the bookkeeping
companies.
The key activities contain individual and centralized activities. Due to the core competences the
partners should deal with tasks concerning the services they provide, such as help and support
Gergely Balazs
December 2012
function. The partnership should be managed by TDP-ERP. The centralized activities are similar to
the tasks of project management, it has defining and organizing part which is creating the overall
strategy and objectives. It is done by consensus of the partners. Within the planning the tasks
should be broken down to the individual level. The controlling function is done by TDP-ERP, which
is responsible for comparing the targets with actual results, and make action in case of deviation.
The overall quality should be measured also by collecting feedbacks from the end users.
The key resources at the beginning of the product launch are mainly provided by the partners. The
cost of sales and marketing activities is planned to be covered by part of the revenue of sales.
This is the reason why in the first stage of the sales the existing sales channels should be used
targeting the clientele of the partners.
The product provides several values to the clients such as cost savings, increasing
competitiveness of the SME, quality bookkeeping and online banking services. The cloud system
enables the managers to have a real time access to the company results everywhere at any time
requiring only an internet connection. The partnership creates values for the partners concerning
the increased sales, R&D activities or strengthening the client relationship with extended
services.
The partners have already established relationship between the clients. In order to strengthen the
relationship with the end users, communication channels are established. It is necessary also to
collect the client feedbacks and develop the services offered to them.
The sales are done through the channels of the partners targeting existing clients. The strongest
relationship exists between the bookkeepers and their clientele. This is the reason why it is
important to increase the amount of bookkeeper partners. The trust is the basis of relationship
selling, which enables increased sales activities through the bookkeepers.
The targeted customer segment of the TDP-ERP cloud concept is micro small and medium sized
enterprises which do not have ERP system and using the services of external bookkeepers.
The main costs of the partnership after the product development phase are the management,
marketing and sales activities. The establishment of agreements with bookkeeping companies
also requires additional costs. For better control over the costs budgets should be created
according to the common strategic objectives.
The revenue is the sum of the sales price, which contains the fee of basic banking services, the
bookkeeping and the ERP license. TDP-ERP receives royalty on the basis of the sales price. The
royalty also covers the cost of centralized activities.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 1
1 Introduction
The consortium of TDP-ERP and Global Solution started to develop an innovative product concept
targeting small and medium sized enterprises (hereinafter referred to as SME). The project is
carried out within the EUREKA, which is an international organization aiming for raising the
productivity and competitiveness by supporting the R&D activities. The purpose is to get closer
the companies and research institutes from the member countries, and initiate partnerships
between them. The TDP-ERP SME Cloud project is financed by own resources and 45 percent of
the development costs expected to be funded by the New Széchenyi Plan within the
EUREKA_HU_12 grant. The development phase of the project has been started in November
2012. The expected date of market launch will be in 2014 depending on the outcome.
The background of the project idea is the need discovery of the SME sector. The research
covered the main business activities and processes and the incurred costs. As a result the SMEs
are spending way too much covering their administration tasks, which contains regular business
processes such as billing, invoicing. The other administrative expenses concern the costs of
banking services and meeting the taxation and reporting requirements settled by the legislation.
The high administration expenses reduces the competitiveness of the sector, because the
companies need to spend a lot on administration instead of developing new products and
services or investing in marketing activities.
The main characteristics of the activities are the multiply, repetitive processes, where a single
data added and used multiply times during the business. Without an ERP system the managers
and other employees of the SMEs have no up-to-date knowledge about the performance, liquidity
and other relevant information, which are required for decision making and daily business
management. In order to be competitive on the market, they need to have a better control over
the costs. Based on the aforementioned characteristics, it is assumed that the SME sector
requires a cheap and innovative solution for business activities, such as accounting, sales or
purchase transaction processing, controlling or payroll.
The research involved the banks and bookkeepers as well. They are facing problems concerning
the SME sector. The bookkeepers need to do repetitive tasks due to the paper or excel based
SME administration. Almost all the transaction related processes done within a company should
be done again by the bookkeeper, which results a repetitive processing of the same data. It
increases the internal costs due to the time consumption, in the other hand the SMEs need to
pay more for the service and due to the price sensitivity do not buy other services from the
bookkeeper.
In the banking sector the aim is to decrease the costs concerning the financial transactions.
Instead of personal administration their aim is to increase the use of online banking services.
The banks are important elements of the SMEs daily business by handling their daily financial
flows and activities like transfers, cash, credit, investment management, and the data from the
bank are used for financial forecasting and parts of the bookkeeping.
1.1 Problem formulation
The project is expected to be partly financed by the EUREKA_HU_12 grant established by the
New Széchenyi Plan. The requirement concerning the application is a publication about the
project in an optional topic. The purpose is to fulfil the aforementioned requirement. The other
purpose of the project is settling down the main elements of the business model of the TDP-ERP
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 2
SME Cloud product launch. The complex product involves services provided by several partners;
therefore the planning of the model is important before entering to the market. The goal is to
evaluate the possibilities and create a basis for further agreements with the partners.
During the development phase the bank agreed with the concept, but the final decision has not
been made. There is no agreement with bookkeeping firms, and there is only verbal agreement
with Libra Software about the ERP system, which indicates the requirement of creating a basic
business model as a starting point of the agreements.
In order to fulfil the purpose of the project, the following problems should be answered:
What are the main values and benefits of a possible partnership?
How should be the business model of the TDP-ERP SME Cloud product?
1.2 Delimitation
The background of the project is a product development. The concept contains an ERP system,
as one of the most innovative part of a package offered by a bank. Deep description of the ERP
features is not a part of the project, since it is obvious nowadays in a business life. The features
and the advantages of the ERP is well known, the project is focusing on how the complex product
and its services can create value over the values of the single elements.
Within the pre-development phase focus group interviews has been made to develop the product
concept and measure the willingness of the bookkeepers participation. The analysis had positive
results, therefore the high level of willingness and interest are assumed in the project without
further analysis.
The developed product is planned to be sold on the Hungarian market. However the Consortium
contains the Polish Global Solution, the company is irrelevant in the product launch activities in
the domestic market concerning the sales activities. There is an agreement to develop and
launch the product on the Polish market based on the Hungarian results. This future plan is not
part of the project. Global Solution is introduced in the project as key partner within the
partnership as appreciating their quality and hard work in the product development.
1.3 Scientific approach
1.3.1 Choice of scientific paradigm
The chosen scientific paradigm is the social constructivism in the project. The explanation of the
main reason in a simplified way is first to understand the reality, and in the second part of the
project try to re-construct. The development of the business model first requires understanding
the status of the SME sector, the specification of Granit Banks’, the ERP developer’s and the
bookkeeper’s business. On the ontological level the reality is social construction. The aim during
the project is to know the reality, especially the areas for providing benefits not just to the clients
but also to the partners in order to create the model with the purpose of establishing win-win
situation. On the epistemological level the reality is acquired through the researcher, which is
therefore relative. Through the research methods and techniques the researcher should gather
enough information in order to understand the interests of the involved parties creating a basis
for the recommendations.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 3
1.3.2 Choice of models and methods
The basis of the project is desk research supplemented by personal interviews and internal
communications. During the project the main research method is the qualitative, however for a
better understanding quantitative data are used as well. The reason of the interviews is the
reinforcement of the information gathered during the desk research.
The business model development requires focusing on value creation, individual strength of the
partners and their sales potential, especially the sales channel and the relationship between
their clients.
The analysis is structured as it follows in order to solve the problem:
1. Analysis of the SME sector
The importance of the SME analysis is to find out the market size of the sector using
segmentation and identifying the characteristics applying the PEST analysis. In order to find out
the needs of the SME sector the analysis is done concerning the following research question:
What is the size of the market?
What are the main characteristics of the SME sector?
2. Analysis of the bookkeeping sector
Within the product concept it is necessary to find the main characteristics of the sector. The
analysis covers the relationship between the clients and service providers, the range of offered
services and the elements of the sales strategy such as pricing and sales channels. During the
analysis the theories of relationship management and Porter`s Five forces model is used to
evaluate the competition. The research questions in this part are the following:
How is the competition in the bookkeeping market?
How is the relationship between the clients and bookkeepers?
3. Analysis of Granit Bank
The complex product will be a part of the product portfolio of Granit Bank. It is necessary to
analyze the strategy and the way of customer acquisition in order to find out if Granit Bank has
the established sales channel for selling the product. The research questions in this part are the
following:
What is Granit bank sales strategy?
What kind of channels the bank is using in order to acquire new clients?
4. Analysis of the ERP developers
The analysis covers the characteristics of the ERP developers with a strong focus on the sales
activities. It is important to find out whether the companies have sales channel and good
customer base. The research questions are the following:
What are the characteristics of the developers form the sales aspect?
5. Evaluation of relationship
The final part is built upon the result of the analysis of the stakeholders from the aspect of
relationship management. In this section it is necessary to analyse how the concept can be
improved by an established partnership. In this part Brennan`s partnership approach is used to
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 4
determine the values, benefits and the essence of the establishment. The research questions are
the following:
How the partners can create values and benefits by establishing partnership?
What are the required activities in order to sustain and improve the partnership?
1.4 Reflection
1.4.1 Quality Assessment and Source Criticism
Methods and models assessment
The analysis contains two main elements; it starts with investigating the individual level of the
stakeholders. The second part is the analysis of the possible partnership. The first part is
descriptive. The aim is to understand the main characteristics of the SME sector and business of
Granit Bank, TDP-ERP, Libra Szoftver and the bookkeeping industry. In the first part segmentation
is used to analyze the market potential regardless of industry. The SME sector is investigated
also from the managerial behaviour in order to get a clear picture. The analysis concerning the
bookkeeping industry focuses mainly on the relationship and the competition using Porter`s Five
Forces model.
Granit Bank is analyzed form the aspect of the growth strategy and the sales organization, while
TDP-ERP and Libra from the core competences and sales activities.
In the second part Brennans` partnership approach is used in order to analyze the values and
benefits of the possible partnership. The approach is ideal to find out how the partnership
creates values for both the partners and the customers. The findings are collected within a SWOT
table.
The applied models resulted enough information in order to understand the reality and based on
it reconstruct the business model.
Source assessment
The sources for the analysis are gathered via desk research and interviews. The used online
materials are from official entrusted sites such as KSH (Central Statistic Office), HFSA (Hungarian
Financial Supervisory Authority) or other company websites (K&H, Granit Bank). There is no
available statistical data concerning the competition on the IT market, which is a weakness of the
project. The interviews were done with two acknowledged person from the bookkeeping industry.
The credibility of their words is high. During the research and analysis in the online articles and
projects the author found the same statements than during the interviews. It strengthened both
the data and information gathered from online materials and from the interviews.
Validity and reliability
The research is mainly qualitative rather than quantitative. The results are valid; those answer
the question on a high extent. The research provides a good basis for collecting the findings and
makes the recommendation on a basis of those.
1.4.2 Process Reflection
At the beginning of the project it was hard to find relevant topic concerning the SME Cloud
Project, which can be useful for the company as well. The business model creation seemed to be
a good choice, but due to the business secret it was not allowed to use lot of the previously
gathered information. During the analysis I tried to use only relevant theories instead of adding
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 5
too much which are irrelevant concerning the main problem. The value creation of partnership
part was added only in the middle of the analysis into the problem statement, because I realized,
that the business model cannot stand without it. After all the final result is close to my
expectation, which was creating a business model as a basis for further agreement with the
partners. The time management of the project was definitely wrong, the project was finalized
more than 7 days after the planned deadline.
2. Product description
The product is developed by the consortium of the Hungarian TDP-ERP and the Polish Global
Solution. The product concept contains an ERP cloud system which includes online bank services
provided by Granit Bank and bookkeeping services offered by external bookkeepers. The basis of
the ERP system is the Libra S3 owned by Libra Szoftver designed for small and medium
enterprises. The system has a modular architecture which enables the clients to get a
customized product due to the requirements and company specifications. The TDP-ERP Cloud
system is planned to have only the most important modules, the billing, invoicing, cash register,
banking and stock modules. The speciality of the system is that the bookkeeping module can be
accessed by the bookkeepers and the reporting and features of controlling by both, the client and
bookkeeper. The implementation of the system does not require huge investments from the
clients such as internal server. The ERP is running on cloud system giving the ability to the
owners and managers to have access regardless of place. The only requirement is having a
computer, tablet or iPhone with internet connection.
The concept is linking together the elements, and provides a common online user web interface
for the different services, which makes easier solving the tasks of the company, and providing
good control and knowledge about the actual results, and business performance. As an
assumption in the complex, integrated product the users should only add a data once to the
system, which will be processed in different modules of the ERP. During the business activities
the added data can be viewed any time, and it will be used and modified during the processes.
The data required for bookkeeping will be withdrawn from the database and from the bank to
finalize bookkeeping, balance sheet, profit and loss account, income statement, VAT registry etc.
The bank provides the relevant data and sheets to both the ERP system for reporting and to the
bookkeeping firms. This solution reduces the process time, the costs, and gives a better control
to the managers over the company.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 6
3 The main characteristics of the SME sector
3.1 SME categories
According to European Law “ The category of micro, small and medium –sized enterprises (SMEs)
is made up of enterprises which employ fewer than 250 persons and which have an annual
turnover not exceeding EUR 50 million and/or an annual balance sheet total not exceeding 43
million“ (2003/361/EC). The quoted definition is the general description of the SMEs. Within the
recommendation the micro, small and medium sized businesses are defined by the number of
employees and the turnover or balance sheet total:
Table 1: Displaying SME Categories
Category Employees Turnover Total Balance
Medium 50-249 ≤ EUR 50 m ≤ EUR 43 m
Small 10-49 ≤ EUR 10 m ≤ EUR 10 m
Micro 0-9 ≤ EUR 2 m ≤ EUR 2 m
Source: Adapted from 2003/361/EC
The used categorization in the Commission Recommendation was implemented by the Hungarian
legislation as well.
3.2 Size of the SME sector
During the analysis it is important to differentiate and calculate the amount of the registered and
the active companies. At the end of 2011 the number of the registered companies were 1,79
million (KSH, 2012). This amount contains both the sole proprietorships and joint ventures. In
2012 the number of sole companies were 1,06 million and the joint companies were almost 0,6
million. The amount of the joint ventures started to grow compared to the sole proprietorship
from the end of 2007 as a result of the reduction of minimum foundation capital from HUF 3
million to HUF 0,5 million concerning the limited liability company (Llc.) and from HUF 20 million
to HUF 5 million concerning the companies limited by shares (Plc.). The ratio of the registered
and active companies is approximately 30% of the sole and 66% of the joint companies. It results
approximately 317 000 active sole and 395 000 active joint ventures.
Table 2: Table Displaying the SME Sector in Hungary
2012 Sole Proprietorship Joint Ventures
SUM 317 000 395 000
Micro (%) 95,5 % 92 %
Micro (nr.) 315 415 363 400
Small (%) 0,5 % 6,6 %
Small (nr.) 1 585 26 070
Medium (%) 0,001 % 1,3 %
Medium (nr.) 25-30 5 135
Source: Own production
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 7
From the aspect of establishment, closure and bankruptcy the sector shows stagnation in the
last 7 years regardless the effects of the economical crisis (European Commission, 2012). This
result does not mean, that the Hungarian economy responded in a positive way for the crisis. The
number of the companies was stagnating before the crisis and during the last 5 years the
government made several actions in order to keep the number of the companies such as
maximizing the administration time for company establishment. After the regulation the
establishment could have been done within 1 hour. At the beginning of 2012 this rule has been
changed by requiring the prior control of the National Tax Authority in order to filter the founders
who had previously tax debt or whose activities were against the law. This action has a positive
effect on the sector; however it will decrease the amount of the established companies.
3.3 Characteristics of the SME Sector
The support and development of the Hungarian SME sector is a never ending story in the politics.
There have been many different attempts to improve reducing the competitive disadvantages of
the sector without breakthrough results. The sector is facing several problems, such as low
capitalization, lack of funding, circular debt and low efficiency and productivity. Often dealing with
administration tasks, which exceeds their resources (KSH, 2011). The analysis of characteristics
includes the political, economical, social aspects.
3.3.1 Political factors of the SME sector (Political)
The government is aware of the importance of the SME sector. It actively supports the sector by
establishing guarantee funds in order to bear the risks with the banks in case the SME cannot
repay the loan. Another funding alternative is the grant, which contain European and Hungarian
sources. Generally the SMEs can apply for grants with support intensity vary from 20 up to 100 %
for innovation, research and development, organization development, market entry etc… The
positive aspect of the grants are that the investment is only partly financed by own resources.
3.3.2 The financial situation of the SME sector (Economy)
In the Hungarian market, as general in the other European countries, the strongest player is the
SME sector. On the labour market 74 % of the 2, 7 million people are employed by SMEs. The
micro sized companies are dominating in the employment rate covering 51-54 % of the overall
employment, followed by the small and medium sized enterprises with 21-24 % (KSH, 2011). The
SME sector is important concerning the Hungarian Gross Value Added (GVA) with its 56% of the
overall output. The difference between the sole proprietorship and the joint ventures in the sector
can be shown by the revenue; the joint ventures resulted HUF 41 600 billion, while the sole
companies only HUF 2 065 billion.
Governmental intervention concerning the consumer debt in foreign currency hit negatively the
SME sector in 2012. In the previous years the Hungarian banks offered CFH based loans to
households with lower interest rate than the HUF loans. The crisis affected negatively the
economy and increased the risks of repayment. “The financial crisis in the euro zone led to
increased sovereign risks, which in turn brought significant growth risk premiums and
contributed to the major appreciation of the CFH against the euro”( Hungarian Financial
Supervisory Authority, 2012).
The amount of the debt dramatically increased, many households could not pay the loan. The
government set the CFH-HUF exchange rate below the real market rate and let the households
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 8
repay the loan on the basis of the fixed rate. Another regulation allowed the change of CFH loans
to HUF loans using the above mentioned rates. The intervention had two results; first of all the
bank sector suffered losses, second the households used their savings in order to pay the debt,
which decreased the demand for goods on the market. The SME sector as suppliers is still
suffering from the bad market environment and conditions.
In the SME sector the capital supply is low, the companies are often underfinanced. In many
cases the efficiency and productivity are low. Of course in the financial situation the mentioned
lack of managerial business knowledge has also a negative impact. The Hungarian companies
are producing mainly to the domestic market; therefore the unstable economy has also a bad
impact on the sector. The SMEs are normally financing themselves internally by reinvesting the
yearly profit, because it is hard for them to get a bank loan. Due the negative market conditions
and concerning the size and management knowledge of the micro and small companies, the
banks evaluate the lending as high risk activity (KSH, 2011).
3.3.3 Managerial characteristics (Social)
In the SME sector it is common that the owner cannot differentiate the company interest with the
own interest. The company income often viewed as a personal. It means that running a business
is always self-interest; the goal is to increase the personal income instead of the revenue of the
company. It affects negatively the basic financial management knowledge by lack of
differentiating the accounting and financial approach. The main objective of the owners is to
increase the expenses and reduce the invoiced revenue in order to pay less tax and increase the
“grey income” (Harkai, 2012). This management attitude has a negative impact on the economy
by strengthening the black market. The mentioned behaviour also affects the performance
measurement and results companies with limited or zero profits.
The background of the problem is the lack of managerial and business knowledge in the sector.
Normally a company is viewed as temporary cash cow without long run planning and strategies.
In the business life a common mindset to optimize the resources and decrease the costs,
however in the Hungarian SME sector, especially in the micro segment the aim is to increase the
costs in order to reduce the tax to be paid.
Some of the SMEs are running without strategic or financial plans. Often it is experienced that
managers and owners have a limited knowledge of the actual business performance of the
company. This affects negatively the planning, managing and decision making activities
(Demcsak & Harkai, 2012). The lack of business knowledge also negatively affects the liquidity of
the companies, which often ends up with insolvency or bankruptcy. This is one of the main
reasons of the circular debt in the economy.
According to the theories of management planning and control systems, one of the main
problems within the SME sector can be demonstrated. The main purpose of the management
control systems to use the resources and assets in an effective and efficient way. The control
activities are only small parts of the overall system. First of all the managers should know the
company, its capabilities and resources, which gives a basis for strategic planning. Of course a
good strategy requires knowledge about both; the external and internal characteristics and
elements. Some of the Hungarian companies, especially the micro and small enterprises are
already failing at the first step by having limited knowledge of the company (Balazs & Guangyu,
2012).
The business strategy is always designed on the basis of actual or present status of the
organization, however the contents of the strategy is always something predicted or forecasted; a
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 9
wanted future direction and status. In order to increase the effectiveness of the strategy,
managers often add objectives and targets, which can be measured during the period of the
strategy. Those can be budgets, forecasted or targeted results etc... The essence of the control
system is measuring the results, evaluating those according to the planned and initiating actions
in order to react due to the variance between the actual and the planned. It is more than obvious
that the strategic planning and management control activities require elementary business
knowledge or intelligence, which is not really common in the Hungarian SME sector.
3.3.4 ERP systems in the SME sector (Technological)
Within the segment of large firms, the ERP usage is covered 100%, in the SME sector it is only
40% (Toth, 2009). The ERP penetration is approximately 68 % in the medium, 21 % in the small,
and 4% in the micro sized enterprises sub-sectors.
Figure 1: Frequency of ERP usage within the SME sector
Source: Own production
It can be assumed the frequency of using ERP system is increasing by the size of the enterprises.
The cause is related to the growth of the organization and the internal characteristics such as
financial background or the amount of different business processes. A small or micro companies
cannot afford and do not require complex ERP solutions. In the medium sized sub-sector the
companies are using integrated solutions for covering 5-6 processes, in the small sized sub-
sector the result is only 1-2 (Fekete, 2009).
3.4 Conclusion of SME sector
The SME sector has a strong economic power in the Hungary. There are more than 600 000
active SMEs, which gives a big market potential. In the last few years the financial crisis affected
negatively the sector. The SMEs are producing mainly for the domestic market. The private sector
used their savings for paying back the loan which result a decrease in the market demand. The
government tried to intervene in order to strengthen the competitiveness of the sector with
insignificant success. The sector depends on the bank loans and different EU funding schemes in
order to finance the investments. The managers are lacking business knowledge in the SME
Micro enterprises
Small Enterprises
Medium Enterprises
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 10
sector especially in the subsector of micro sized companies. The ERP penetration within the
micro and small sub-sector is relatively low, which is definitely positive concerning the SME cloud
project.
4. Bookkeeping and accounting
The difference between the meaning of bookkeeping and accounting should be described in
order to have a better understanding. From the side of the activities, basically there are four
entities:
Data register: Person who adds and registers the data in the bookkeeping system
concerning the transactions of the companies.
Bookkeeper: The bookkeeper is responsible mainly for making reports, books and ledgers
according to the Act C of 2000 on Accounting.
Accountant: The accountant has wider tasks and responsibilities than the bookkeeper.
The accountant is analysing and evaluating the financial data and creates information
from those. In a medium size company the accountant deals with financial strategies,
costing systems or controlling.
Auditor: The auditor is examining the accounting system and the outputs from the
aspects of validity, reliability of the information and the activities from a legal point of
view.
In the Hungarian system there are internal and external bookkeepers and accountants. It
requires the differentiation and explanation of the two systems.
4.1 Internal bookkeeping and accounting
The internal bookkeeping contains all the activities concerning data registry, accounting and
bookkeeping within the company. Depending on the size of the organization the tasks of data
registry, bookkeeping and accounting might be done by a single or several persons. On the
Hungarian market these kinds of companies are mainly using ERP system in order to reduce the
cost and other resources of administration activities. The internal bookkeeping and accounting is
not relevant for the introduced SME product.
4.2 External bookkeeping
The micro and small sized enterprises mainly outsource the bookkeeping to external
bookkeepers. The data registry and accounting is done internally, and the reports, books, ledgers
are created by the external bookkeeper according to the legal requirements. As a matter of fact
within the sub sector of micro and small enterprises the spread of ERP systems are very low; only
approximately 4-5% of the active companies are using those (Toth, 2009 p.1). It has a negative
impact on the administration processes, because first the invoices, bills are manually (paper
based) registered within the company, and the transactions registered again at the external
bookkeepers in order to create the reports, books and ledgers. The accounting related activities
are mainly done by the manager or owner of the SME, but as it has been written due to the low
level of business and managerial knowledge the main activities such as financial planning or
control are basically undone.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 11
4.3 The range of provided services
The external bookkeepers are providing the companies mainly with the basic services required by
the law. All the companies in Hungary should create statements about the operations, asset,
financial and income situation at the end of each business year (2000/C, 2012). The format of
the statements depends on the NET Income, Balance and number of employees. According to the
regulations the bookkeeping activities should be done by authorized and registered bookkeepers
or accountants except for companies having less than HUF 10 million Net income in the previous
2 years.
The audit service is compulsory for companies using double-entry bookkeeping, except the net
income was under HUF 200 million, and the number of employees was less than 50. The
government is planning to increase the amount of minimum net income for the next few years,
which will reduce the amount of companies require compulsory audit. It will have an effect on the
bookkeeping market, because some of the auditors might start doing bookkeeping also.
4.3.1 Provided services of the external bookkeepers
The bookkeepers are providing basic and additional services. The basic services mainly cover the
requirements given by the law concerning SME administration obligations of reporting and tax
admit.
Figure 2: Bookkeeping services
Source: Own production
The provided service depends on the service contract. Often the SME clients require more for the
price than the basic services, especially consultation and business advices. The bookkeepers
defend themselves by providing the services described in the contract, not more and not less. For
additional services the client should pay extra. Often the clients turn to the bookkeepers before
establishing a company in order to get relevant information concerning the possible company
forms and the tax liability (Harkai, 2012).
4.4 Market size of the bookkeepers
The market size of the registered and authorized bookkeepers is approximately 65 000 in
Hungary, there are 32 000 companies doing bookkeeping as main business activities (NGM,
2012). According to the law the authorized bookkeeper should have an accounting related
diploma and 3 years of experiences within the field of bookkeeping, accounting or controlling. In
order to follow up with the legal changes concerning the accounting rules, the registered
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 12
members should participate on a compulsory accounting course once a year (200/C, 2012). The
registration of the bookkeepers is done by the Ministry of National Economy.
According to the amount of active companies and the bookkeeping firms, there are
approximately 20 companies for a bookkeeping company in average. This result however does
not show the clear picture of the market, because there are many unregistered bookkeepers
working on the Hungarian market (Harkai, 2012). The result was calculated from the number of
active companies, which contains the enterprises with less than HUF 10 million net income.
These companies, at it has been written before, does not require registered and authorized
bookkeeping services, often the owner or one of the employees is dealing with the bookkeeping
and other administration related tasks. It can be concluded that less than on average a
bookkeeper has less than 10 clients in average. In practice the number of clients depends on
many factors like type or size of the company, financial details, number of employees, number of
invoices, recipes etc... (Cieleszky,2012).
4.5 Pricing strategy
Before the analysis of the pricing it is important to differentiate the two most common types of
bookkeeping companies. On the Hungarian market according to the bookkeepers there are
“dabblers” and bookkeepers. (Harkai, 2012) The first one is registering the transactions into the
book, and simply withdraws the different reports from the bookkeeping software. The aim is to
reduce the time spent on the bookkeeping activities for the companies, regardless the quality.
The real bookkeepers are doing quality bookkeeping; the transaction registering is only the basis
of the real task. The aim is always to reduce the amount of tax obligation, and provide the
authorities and the owner with correct reports according to the legal requirements. This is why it
is often said that the business performance of a company always depends on who is doing the
bookkeeping. The theoretical and practical knowledge concerning the accounting law is
important within the bookkeeping business.
The bookkeeping companies are using special pricing. The main factors affecting the price is the
time spent on the service activities and the sympathy of the owner (Harkai, 2012). Of course
other factors are also relevant such as receiving the data on paper base or by ERP system, but
normally these are the matters of time consumption. The sympathy is an uncommon specialty
compared to other businesses. The reason is basically the establishment of partnership between
the company and the bookkeeping firms, which will be described in the next section.
There are two main price setting strategies in the industry; the “dabblers” or low-price companies
mainly try to keep the price as low as possible. They are using fixed, menu-based pricing
depending on the company form, number of invoices, recipes per month. These kinds of
companies are taking strong online marketing effort in order to acquire clients (Cieleszky, 2012).
The price of the basic bookkeeping service starts from HUF 5 000, which implies that high quality
cannot be expected. In order to keep the price low, the companies are reducing their costs and
the time spent on the activities. The bookkeeping due to the saving has a low quality and it is
more transaction recording then a classical bookkeeping. Often the office is placed at the private
residence or in a garage in order to reduce the costs (Harkai, 2012).
The other type of bookkeeping companies provides high quality services to the clients. The basic
monthly fee depends on the financial results, size, form and industrial category of the SME. The
price is not fixed; the bookkeeper is arbitrary setting the price by considering the required time
consumption of the service. The behaviour and sympathy of manager or owner of the company
has a huge impact on the final price. Often the bookkeeper is overpricing the service in case of
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 13
lacking sympathy (Harkai, 2012). This is a method of customer relationship management, where
as a starting point it is important to find the right customers.
These kind of bookkeeping firms do not spent huge marketing effort in order to acquire new
clients. Normally the satisfied clients recommend the service to other businesses; which enables
the bookkeeping firms acquire new clients in a way of word by mouth marketing.
4.6 Relationship and partnership
The typical client bookkeeper relationship is built up on trust, which is also the basis of the long
term commitment. Often it is said, that the main reason of the close relationship is that the
bookkeeper knows all the financial details and “tricks” done for the client concerning the reports,
books, ledgers or tax admit, therefore the owner does not want to take the risk by leaving the
bookkeeper (Herczeg et al. 2012). The clients are cancelling the service contract in case of
mistakes in the bookkeeping, lack of communication and consultancy, bad overall quality of the
service and loss of trust (Demcsák & Harkai, 2012). Due to a research 95 % of the SME owners
would change the bookkeeper in case of loss of trust, which clearly shows the most important
element of the relationship (Herczeg et al., 2012).
The other reason of the long term relationship is the aspect of quality. There is no basis for
comparing the services on a basis of quality. Until the SME is not charged by the tax authority
because of mistakes in the reports or late delivery, the bookkeeper is assumed to provide a good
service, even if there are quality differences concerning the outputs (Harkai, 2012). The practical
and theoretical knowledge of the bookkeeper affects the quality of the output and the amount of
taxation. In this manner an SME can save a lot finding the ideal bookkeeper. There is no basis for
measuring the quality on quantitative data, which is the reason why the SMEs are finding the
bookkeepers by word-by-mouth (recommendation of business partners).
The relationship between the SMEs and the bookkeepers is strong with the aim to create
partnership. The companies rely on the work of the bookkeepers and their advices concerning
taxation, legal or financial problems. The knowledge of the bookkeepers is useful for
compensating the lack of business and managerial intelligence of the owners and leaders of the
SMEs. The described partnership is not that simple as it has been described. There is a
misunderstanding concerning the pricing and provided services between the SME and the
bookkeeper. The owners and managers expect consultancy and advices for the price they are
paying for the bookkeeping; however those are additional services, which are not part of the
basic price. The service contract clearly states what the price covers, but still the owners require
more services. This is one of the weaknesses of the partnership.
According to theory of creating customer relationship management the bookkeeping companies
are trying to select the most valuable customers. The evaluation is done basically on the financial
aspects such as profitability or the cost of serve the clients (Huth&Speh, 2010). In this manner
the bookkeepers often decide not just on financial aspect but also on the subjective personality
as it have been described at the pricing strategy. However it sounds a bit strange, by thinking it
over the bookkeepers would like to establish long term relationship between the clients. The long
term commitment increase the potential future benefits for both of the parties, therefore it is
reasonable to eliminate those clients who are unable to fit into the requirements of cooperation.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 14
4.7 Competition on the bookkeeper market
The competition on the market is analysed using Porter’s Five forces model. The competition in
the industry is affected by potential entrants, bargain power of the buyers and suppliers and
substitute services. The model is useful to demonstrate the specialities of the bookkeeping
market.
Figure 3: Competition in the market
Source: Adapted from Porter (2008)
Force 1: Barriers to entry
The entry is easy and requires low resources. According to the law in order to work as a
registered and authorized bookkeeper the requirement is accounting related education and 3
years of experience. From the cost aspects at the beginning the office can be located at the
home residence of the bookkeeper. The biggest expense is buying the accounting software,
which consists of basic entry fee and monthly payment for the licence. As a summary entering to
the market is quiet easy and does not require large investments. The loyalty of the clients is high;
therefore starting a bookkeeping company is done by penetration pricing strategy offering the
services at fixed low prices or by taking the existing clientele from the previous bookkeeping firm.
Due to the mentioned main characteristic; the relationship is strong between the bookkeeper
and the client who are following the person in case of opening a new company.
Force 2: Threat of substitute service
The offered main services of the bookkeepers are the same. Those differs only on the basis of
price and quality, however the last one is hard to measure. The bookkeeping firm is bearing the
switching cost in case the client is changing the service provider. In practice it is easier for the
bookkeeper to redo the books, reports and ledgers in the middle of the financial year than
continue the work of the previously contracted company.
Force 3: Bargaining power of the clients
The clients are looking for quality or price. The low price bookkeeping companies are mainly
providing services to micro sized enterprises, while the quality is important for the small and
Competition within the Industry
Potential Entrants
BuyersSuppliers
Substitute services
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 15
medium sized businesses. The price is only fixed at the low price bookkeeping firms, while the
other service providers evaluating the price based on different aspects. The clients by evaluating
the competitors often ask for recommendations from the business partners in order to find the
ideal bookkeeper and to be sure concerning the quality. The clients do not change often
bookkeeping company, because of the built up trust and also evaluating the risks of changing for
lower quality service. The client migration is not common in the industry.
Force 4: Bargaining power of the suppliers
On the market the bargaining power of the suppliers is strong; the bookkeeping companies can
afford to evaluate the client and pricing the service on a basis of client behaviour. However there
are more than 60 000 registered bookkeepers and 32 000 registered bookkeeping firms in
Hungary, and the offered services are the same the bargaining power is strong. This is a
deviation from the other industries. As it has been written before, even if there are other
companies offering the same service, due to the recommendation from business partners the
SME does not want to take the risk to try an unknown bookkeeping company. There are attempts
to somehow measure and improve the bookkeeping companies from the aspect of quality. The
Association of High Quality Bookkeepers continuously makes success by providing trainings,
education and newsletter in order to increase the quality of the member companies. The
association has more than 120 registered members. This number rapidly increases month by
month (Harkai, 2012).
Force 5: Competition within the industry
The competition within the industry is specific; there are lots of companies providing standard
services which make strong rivalry between them. Within the industry there is no clear
differentiation strategy in a manner of differentiating the services from the others. The aim of the
quality bookkeepers is to increase the client satisfaction. Some of the bookkeeping firms does
not even have a website, and do not spend on marketing (Cieleszky, 2012). The word-by-mouth is
enough marketing for them in order to acquire new clients. The companies are put efforts on
keeping the existing clients, however on the other side the clients are rarely changing the
bookkeeping firm.
4.7 Conclusion of the bookkeeping sector
The bookkeeping is an important element of the SME administration activities. Due to the legal
requirements there are services can only be provided by the bookkeepers such as making
reports, books, and ledgers. The sector offers other services as well, since they are financial
experts. However they offer the same services, those differ by price and quality. The competition
in the market is strong. Some of the bookkeeping companies try to differentiate themselves by
the quality of the service; however it is hard to measure it. The companies take huge effort to
have a good reputation, because rest of the new clients are acquired based on the
recommendation of the existing ones. There is normally a strong relationship between the
bookkeeper and the SME, switching service provider happens only in case of strong
dissatisfaction. In general the SMEs do not want to take the risk of finding a new bookkeeper,
since the quality is unknown; therefore there is a risk to change the bookkeeper for another one
with lower quality. There is a need in the sector for differentiation and a potential to offer
extended services such as consultancy.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 16
5. The characteristics of the Hungarian bank sector
The economic crisis affected the banking sector also. In the past 13 years 2011 was the year,
when the sector suffered first time losses. The reason of the negative performance was the
repayments of foreign mortgage loans on a fixed HUF-CFH exchange rate, the rising of bad loan
provisions and the implemented industry taxes. The banking sector reacted on the market
changes in different ways. Some of the banks decided to reduce the costs by closing branches,
and started to follow the trends and focus more on developing the online banking solutions. Due
to the fact that only approximately 8,9 per cent of the Hungarian bank system is owned by the
Hungarians, it is obvious that the foreign owners like UniCredit Group SpA, Intesa Sao Paolo SpA,
Raiffeisen Bank International AG or Erste Group Bank AG are more cautious investing or
developing radical new solutions and services in Hungary (Bloomberg, 2012).
The decline in the Hungarian economy hinders the demand for financial products, and in this way
affects negatively the profitability, quality of the portfolios of the banks, and making the financing
possibilities more limited and expensive. As a matter of fact it has a negative impact on financing
especially lending to the SME sector. In the private sector the result of the crisis, especially the
repayment of the bank loans, and due to the decreasing real income by the inflation decreasing
the consumption on the market. The effect of this in the bank and SME sector is the decreasing
SME investment activities which results decreasing lending activities for the banks (HFSA, 2012).
As a result of the declining lending services it is important for the banks to find new services and
acquire customers or reduce the internal costs in order to maintain the profitability or at least
reduce the losses. Within the industry the banks follows the international trend of providing
online banking solutions, and in a way switching from personal administration to online. This way
is definitely reduces the overhead costs of the banks by requiring less branches. All the banks in
the Hungarian market offer e-banking solutions for private and business clients. For the larger
enterprises using SAP, Oracle or Microsoft ERP system it is possible to connect directly to the
banking interface and execute the transactions. The rest of the SME sector is still managing and
executing the transactions manually.
5.1 Strategy of Granit Bank
Granit Bank is a fully Hungarian owned bank placed in Budapest. The bank is part of the Demjan
Group of Companies. In 2010 the Magyar Tőketársaság Zrt. (Hungarian Capital Company cPlc)
bought the Milton Bank. The new management implemented new strategy with a main focus on
the SME and private sector. The bank has only one branch; however it built up partner
relationships with companies like Brokernet, KPMG, Hungarian Development Bank Plc. which are
acting on the market as banking agents (Granit Bank, 2012b). The main reason of having one
branch is a cost saving decision and the overall philosophy which says; provide the clients with
more service cheaper than the competitors. According to the “one-branch-strategy” it is quiet
important to improve the online solutions, and implement better or cheaper services to be
competitive with the other banks in Hungary.
The bank is focusing on acquiring customers; the applied pricing strategy is the penetration
pricing. The charges and fees of the banking services are the lowest on the Hungarian market.
The prices might be raised when the bank gained enough market shares. Granit Bank tries to
differentiate the products and services and focus on innovation. It was the first bank
implementing real time virtual customer support using web-cameras. The strategy is continuously
focusing on IT development, and creating new services for the customers and clients.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 17
5.2 Pillars of growth Strategy of Granit Bank
The strategies of the banks are similar to each other. The key element is increasing the number
of customers like other businesses. The difference at the banks is the type of customer from the
aspect of acting as a creditor or debtor. As a basic model the bank gains capital from the clients
and lending those to others. The profit is the difference of the interest of deposits and loans. It is
very simplified description of the banking activities, but stands here for a better understanding of
customer acquisition. A newly established bank first takes the effort to gather as many clients as
possible, in order to start investing or lending. The growth strategy of Granit Bank has three
pillars: Innovative solutions, Lending to focused business segments, and Client acquisition.
Figure 4: Pillars of Gránit Bank Growth strategy
Source: Adatpted from Hegedüs (2012)
Innovative solutions
The innovative solutions has two main aspects; first by developing new online products the one-
branch disadvantage can be reduced, second the services are developed based on the market
demands. The innovation activities only concerning IT development. The bank does not have IT
developer. The product development is done by subcontractors. The bank buys only the license of
the product; the further development and maintenance is the duty of the subcontractor.
Customer acquisition
The main objective of the bank is increasing the amount of deposits. The penetration price
strategy serves this pillar by providing the regular banking services for lower cost than the
competitors. The acquisition is hard task even if the bank offers innovative solutions at low price.
The legal background of personal presence at concluding the banking service contract requires
increased number of banking agents.
Lending to focused segment
Growth Strategy
Innovative solutions
Focused segments
Customer acquisition
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 18
In order to keep the high quality of the lending portfolio the bank targets reliable SMEs, and
stable large sized organizations with governmental guarantee. The lending as it has been written
requires a careful evaluation of the clients. The present status of the SME is evaluated on the
basis of different financial ratios from books, reports and ledgers made by the bookkeepers.
5.3 Sales channels of Granit Bank
The bank acquires customers through different sales channels. First of all Granit Bank has one
branch which also works as headquarter. In November 2012 a new customer centre was opened
in the WestEnd City Centre. The features of the centre are limited and not similar to a regular
branch; it does not offer cash related and other classic banking services. The future client can
get information about the services, and conclude banking agreement within few minutes. The
other sales channels are the contracted companies which are acting on the market as banking
agents such as Brokernet or KPMG. The client visiting the office of the previously mentioned
companies and getting information or can conclude banking agreement. The partner businesses
are receiving fixed commission after each new client. The final channel is acquiring clients by
phone call or online application. In these cases a bank representative is visiting the future client
at his/her workplace or home in order to conclude the contract (Granit Bank, 2012).
Due to the law it requires personal presence and verification for opening a bank account and
establishing the agreement. This is the main barrier of the fully online expansion and customer
acquisition strategy of Granit Bank and other banks. The bigger banks such as OTP, Raiffeisen,
Unicredit, K&H or GE have the infrastructure for acquiring new customers by local branches at
several geographic locations in Hungary. K&H bank has more than 200 (K&H, 2012) while OTP
has more than 400 (OTP, 2012) branches in Hungary compared to Granit Bank, which has only
one.
5.4 Channel expansion
According to the Act on Credit Institutions and Financial enterprises, there are two types of
activities. The first group contains financial services, which can be provided only by financial
institutions. The second is the supplementary services including the banking agents. There are
two types of banking agents:
a, The agent acts on behalf of the bank. The bank is liable for the activities of the agent, who is
providing financial and supplementary services.
b, The agent is promoting the financial and supplementary services provided by the bank. The
bank in this case is not liable for the activities of the agent.
The main purpose of using agents in the bank sector is to increase the financial related activities
and give the possibilities to the bank to acquire more clients.
5.5 Conclusion of the bank sector and Granit Bank
The Hungarian bank sector was hit by the economic crisis. The banks acted in different ways on
the effects of the negative market atmosphere, but for all of them the cost reductions became an
important element. Granit Bank is relatively new on the market. The main objective of the bank is
to acquire new clients; however it has only one branch. The bank offers innovative online
solutions to the targeted segments and low prices due to the penetration pricing strategy. The
customer acquisition is done by online advertisements, internal sales representatives and
banking agents allowed by the law. The bank does not have extended sales channels, which is a
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 19
weakness concerning the fact, that the SME Cloud product is planned to be a part of the Granit
Bank portfolio.
6 IT sector in Hungary
On the Hungarian market both the international and national ERP developers sell products. The
large international IT companies such as Oracle, Microsoft and SAP covers the ERP market in the
large sized companies sub-sector. The key players in the SME sector are SAP, Progen, Microsoft,
Epicor, Libra Szoftver, Infor, QAD (Fekete, 2009).
Due to the fact of the amount of micro and small firms there is a good market potential within the
SME sector for small ERP systems with modular architecture. The IT industry has a good sales
perspective in Hungary. Approximately 68% of the companies within the SME sector are planning
development investments in 2013. Concerning the intention of the investments the IT
developments are on the first place since about 30% of the SMEs are planning such an
investment (K&H, 2012b).
6.1 Financing ERP implementation
The main barrier of the ERP implementation in the SME sector is the price. The sector is price
sensitive concerning the costs of developing the IT infrastructure. A regular ERP system requires
additional costs such as hardware costs (servers), additional wages (IT developers), and the
expenses concerning the training of employees. In Hungary the IT implementations are financed
mainly by three different sources:
own source
loans
EU/Governmental grants
The most popular of the sources is the EU/Governmental grants offered within the New
Széchenyi Plan (hereinafter referred to as NSZP). The action plan is ending in 2013. The main
purpose of NSZP is strengthening the economy and increasing the employment. Within the plan
several grants were established concerning the development of business environment. The SMEs
can apply for grants covering from 25% to 70% of the overall expenses depending on the
company size, financial background and the expected increase of employee rate and revenue.
Companies prefer the grants compared to the bank loans and -due to the liquidity matters within
the sector- to own sources.
The micro and small sized enterprises do not require the implementation of expensive ERP
systems. Even if they choose the grants to finance the implementation, they can use only limited
features of the system. The implementation of ERPs which are not suited for the companies can
easily turn into failure. Other aspect is the cost of maintaining the system, which often places a
heavy financial burden on the SME. The IT sector recognized the special needs of the micro and
small sized companies, and started to develop modular systems, which can be easily suited for
the specifications and characteristics of the SMEs. Concerning the financial aspects the
companies can get the system or the selected modules for a one time fixed price or for
entry/installation fee and monthly license fee depending on the pricing.
The technology innovation in the IT industry enables the SMEs reducing the costs of purchasing
and maintaining the hardware by using cloud solutions. The cloud ERP systems do not require
expensive implementation and internal server background. The only costs appear over the
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 20
purchasing price or license fee are the education of the employees, computers and internet
subscription. The user can access to the system from anywhere at any time; the only need is the
device and internet coverage. The ERP developers recognized the cost saving function of the
cloud system, and started to offer the existing or new systems on the cloud.
6.2 Software developers of the SME cloud system
The product developments contain three stakeholders; the international consortium of TDP-ERP
and Global Solution and the subcontractor of Libra Szoftver. The design of the product concept
and the specifications are made by the consortium on the basis of the Libra 3s ERP system
developed by Libra Szoftver. The decision of using an existing ERP system was the time and cost
concerns. It is expensive to develop a new system from the beginning, and contain wide range of
risks.
6.2.1 Libra Szoftver
More than 600 companies are using the LIBRA 3s. Libra target segment is the small and medium
sized enterprises in all industries. The main characteristic of the system is the flexibility; the ERP
is built up by modules which can be configured due to the specialities, characteristics and
requirements of the enterprises (Libra, 2012a). Libra has more than 28 years of experiences in
ERP system development, which makes them a strong market player in Hungary.
Libra provides IT systems both to the SME sector and to the bookkeeping firms. The bookkeepers
use the software to create the books, reports and ledgers for the clients. The customer
acquisition on the SME sector has a straightforward effect on the sales of the bookkeeping
software; the more companies are using Libra ERP, the more bookkeeping firms purchase the
bookkeeping system in order to reduce the time consumption of the work. The connected
systems increase the efficiency and effectiveness of the external bookkeeping activities. Libra
recognised the importance of the price sensitivity within the SME sector. Following the IT trends
the company is planning to develop cloud system in order to lower the costs for the clients.
6.2.2 Sales channel of Libra Szoftver
Libra Szoftver has a creative and efficient marketing and sales strategy. The company
established partnerships with Hungarian universities, colleges and other education institutes.
The content of the agreements are educating the students for using the Libra ERP and
bookkeeping systems. At the moment more than 9000 university students learnt the features
and use of Libra S3 system which is the basis of TDP SME Cloud System development (Libra,
2012c). Behind these agreements the company planned the future sales strategy. According to
the change management theories and concerning the barriers and difficulties of the ERP
implementation, the managers and other employees who learnt the Libra S3 system in the school
might chose to use it at the company as well.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 21
The sales channel of Libra Szoftver has 3 pillars; sales representatives, distributors, partner ERP
developers.
Figure 5: Sales channels of Libra Szoftver
Source: Own production
The sale is mainly done by the sales representatives, who are working as ERP consultants as
well. The sales of ERP require deep knowledge of the system, but also the ability to find and
analyse the needs of the clients. Libra built up partnership with 14 distributors around Hungary
and with 11 software and ERP developer, who are competitors on the market. The reason of
partnering with competitors is the essence of the Libra ERP system, which is built up by modules.
Due to special client requirements, it is cost effective to buy a module or sub system from
competitor than develop a new one for a single buyer. The ERP developers only sell exact Libra
modules, not the whole system.
Libra Szoftver
Sales representatives
Distributor chain
Partner IT developers
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 22
6.2.3 Consortium of TDP-ERP and Global Solution
The consortium of TDP-ERP and Global Solution designed an innovative integrated solution
involving all the key elements of the financial administration; the bank and bookkeepers. The
product concept contains banking and bookkeeping services together with an ERP system for the
SMEs.
Figure 6: SME cloud concept
Source: Own production
The aim of the consortium is to develop the product and enter to the market in 2014. According
to the agreement between the software developers, the license of the modified ERP will be
owned by Libra Szoftver, which is getting a licence fee after each acquired clients. The owner of
the know-how of the service based product is the consortium.
TDP-ERP is the project owner and main participant in the EUREKA consortia project. The main
activities are ERP system development, information technology development and consultancy.
Within the field of ERP development, TDP-ERP has a wide range of knowledge and experiments in
product customization, operation and maintenance of network infrastructure and ERP
implementation. The company provides services in several industries to SMEs and large
enterprises like TriGranit Development Ltd., Tököl Airport Zrt, Euroinvest Ltd, Bakony Power Plant
Ltd., WestEnd Property Management Ltd. or Badacsony Winery Co. TDP-ERP is presented in
seven countries (e.g. Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, and Croatia), the largest non-domestic market
is Poland.
TDP-ERP gathered relevant experiences in different ERP system design. The company has a good
knowledge of the IT market in Hungary, especially the competition, the range of the offered
products and the demand of the SME sector. The company proficient in project management;
the used method is a five stage cycle covering the main activities, which is part of the general
mapping, comprehensive analysis, design, development, implementation and maintenance. This
ensures that the product follows, and often even foregoes the needs of the SMEs due to the
environmental changes.
TDP-ERP had five employees at the beginning of the product development. The project required
more human resource; therefore six more employees were hired. The number of the staff was
dramatically increased for the duration of the project, which ends up in December 2013. The
plan of TDP-ERP is to assign the new employees to tasks related to product launch and
administration after closing out the project.
SME cloud
concept
Banking services
Bookkeeping services
ERP system
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 23
6.2.4 Sales channels of TDP-ERP
The main portfolio of TDP-ERP is to provide services such as system development or
maintenance. The company was established with the purpose of ensuring the IT needs of the
Demjan Group of companies. Almost all the clients are affiliates. In this manner TDP-ERP can be
seen as an IT department of the Demjan Group. In order to get the SME Cloud Product to the
market it is necessary to establish the sales channel, which is resource consuming. The company
would be basically a new entrant on the ERP market which requires hiring sales representatives,
agreeing with agents or establishing a distribution channel. It is necessary also to spend on
marketing activities as well.
6.3 Conclusion
There is a good market potential within the IT sector. Approximately 68% of the companies within
the SME sector are planning development investments in 2013. Concerning the intention of the
investments the IT developments are on the first place since about 30% of the SMEs are
planning such an investment. The sector is price sensitive, the micro and small sized enterprises
cannot afford the implementation due to the high expenses. The industry recognized the needs
of cheap but quality system, therefore the development is tend to move to the direction of cloud
computing, which does not require internal server base. The other positive aspect of the cloud
system is the mobility, it can be accessed from anywhere at any time having internet connection.
Concerning the ERP developers of the cloud project, only Libra Software has an established sales
channel in Hungary.
7 Establishing partnership
The basis of the successful product launch is the quality of the established partnership. However
the development phase of the TDP-ERP SME Cloud project contain a pilot version of product
launch and testing, it is important to build up the business model and strengthen the relationship
between the partners and clients. The essence of the relationship building is that the transaction
costs are reduced, the quality is improved, while the management costs stays on a lower level
(Egan, 2011 p 189). The positive side of the external collaboration the different knowledge, skills
and other assets what the partners are adding to the jointly developed and launched product.
This affects not just the internal business aspects, but also the value creation to the clients.
The total value of the developed product is more than the value of the added services
individually. The difference is given by the collaboration. According to the theory of Brennan the
members of the partnership acquire different short and long term benefits from the
collaboration. Without attempting to be comprehensive there are wide range of benefits, such as
the aforementioned cost advantages, especially the marketing and R&D costs, fast response on
client needs or increased possibility to get to the market by establishing several sales channels
(Egan, 2011 p.196).
Within the product launch the aim is to establish horizontal relationship between the partners
and clients in order to maximize the benefits. The result of the analysis clearly shows the
individual strength and weaknesses of the partners and the SME sector. The analysis of the
possible partnership is done using the partnership approach of Brennan (Egan, 2011 p.196).
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 24
7.1 In depth understanding of the customer`s requirement
The partnership enables Granit Bank, the software developers and the bookkeepers to share the
knowledge about the SME sector and their needs. According to the trust between the
bookkeepers and the clients, there is a good possibility to gather and share relevant information
about the main business activities, the barriers of financial developments. Since the clients are
honest with the bookkeeper about their problems needs to be solved, those information can be
used by the bank to develop new financial products suited for the general needs of the SME
sector.
Libra Szoftver and the consortium of TDP-ERP and Global Solution can also use the information
from the bookkeepers for product development. However the companies are close to their
clients by giving them IT advices, maintaining IT help desk or taking part in the ERP
implementation, the information of the needs concerning the SME sector from the bank or the
bookkeepers are useful for product development.
The bank has a good knowledge about the financial situation of the macro economy and the
financial situation of the SME sector. This information is important to develop the pricing strategy
on the basis of the financial background.
7.2 In depth understanding of the partner`s requirement
The understanding of the partner needs is not part of Brennan`s approach, but it is required in
order to maintain the horizontal collaboration by knowing the requirements and providing
possible solution for those. The core business of Granit Bank is increasing the number of
customers and simultaneously the deposits, and lending money to the clients. The objective of
the bank is to maintain the quality of the lending portfolio. The decision concerning the loans is
done based on the financial background and business plan of the SME. The bookkeepers are key
element in this evaluation, since the ledgers, books and reports are created by them. There is a
strong dependency between the bank and the quality of the bookkeeping services.
The bank prefer having clear information of the actual financial performance and the future
forecast and targets and also an entity with good business and accounting knowledge as security
for the positive outcome. The business knowledge and intelligence of the SME managers and
owners are low. The bookkeepers have the ability to provide them with advices concerning the
financial related activities. A quality bookkeeping service in this way can easily affect positively
the lending activities of the bank. It creates benefits for the bank by having a good bookkeeper
who creates realistic books, ledgers and reports, and provides the SME sector with valuable and
useful advices. In the other hand the SME require quality from the bookkeeper, since it is hard to
measure, partnering and being recommended by the bank can provide the bookkeepers with
extra value and quality towards to the clients.
Libra software has existing sales channels towards to SMEs and bookkeepers. The company is
focusing on adding values to the clients; therefore it has agreements with business and financial
consultancy and business development firms. In order to strengthen the relationship between the
clients, Libra Szoftver offers more than ERP system and related IT services. The complex SME
product enables the company to offer the clients bookkeeping and banking services. The benefit
of the new product is that Libra Szoftver can target new customer segments, the micro and small
sized companies, who do not require complex ERP system, only modules for 3-4 main activities.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 25
7.3 Reduction or elimination of cost of sale
From the aspect of sales channels all the partners, Granit Bank, Libra Szoftver and the
bookkeepers are interested in acquiring new clients. On the individual level each company has
their own sales strategy and established sales channel. The establishment of partnership might
offer benefits in a way of increasing the sales in a more efficient way by using the partners’ sales
channel to get the product to the market. The product as it has been mentioned before will be
the part of Granit Bank portfolio, but it does not mean necessarily that only the bank can sell the
product on the market.
The regular sales activities are focusing on acquiring new customers. According to the Leaky
bucket theory the businesses are losing their clients by focusing too much on acquiring new one
(Egan, 2011 pp.73-74). The strong focus on sales activities reduces the quality of client services
and decreases their satisfaction. In this way the cost of sale increasing since new customers are
acquired, but old loyal customers are lost. The partnership between the partners enables the
sales of the product through different channels by selling the product to existing customers and
in this way increases their satisfaction. The complex product offers more than the individual
services.
The sales to existing customers reduce the marketing and sales costs, because there is no need
to invest in establishing new channels and target new clients. The aforementioned statement is
not exactly true, more precisely in order to acquire new clients for the Cloud SME product the
partners` sales channels are used targeting the existing clientele. It results extended sales
possibilities, and increased quality of services to the clients. From the sales aspect bookkeepers
are part of the system, however agreements have not been made with them yet. The involvement
of the bookkeepers into the sales activities has good potential due to the strong relationship
between the clients.
7.4 Value-added chain
Within the collaboration the partners focus on activities of the value-added chain what are their
core competencies, other aspects can be letting to do by the trusted partners. This is applied at
the SME Cloud concept as well. The key activities concerning the elements of the complex
product are delegated to that partner, who is professional on the given field. Granit Bank is
providing banking related services and sells the complex product through the existing sales
channel to new and existing customer. The bank do not deal with ERP related helpdesk function
or consultancy which are planned to be done by Libra Szoftver. It is the same concerning the
bookkeepers, who are adding only the bookkeeping related services.
The value addition is done by the individual services and by the complexity and integrated
solutions of the product. It concerns the future development of the concept. All the partners are
focusing on activities which are their core competencies, which increase the quality of the overall
product.
In a partnership there is a need however for an entity that is responsible for managing the overall
activities such as quality control or sales and marketing. The SME Cloud concept is special in a
way, that there are more partners from different industry. The plan is to establish a quality
bookkeeper chain which dramatically increases the number of the collaborating enterprises.
Without control and management the overall quality can be decreased. The different decisions
concerning the product cannot be done all the time with agreement between all the
stakeholders. It would also decelerate the common progresses.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 26
7.1.4 Value addition through partnership to the end users
The customer value consists of benefits and sacrifices (Hutt & Speh, 2010, pp. 216-218). The
benefit has two forms; the core and the add-on.
1. Core benefits: The core of the SME Cloud product is the complexity. It provides all the
administration related services to the SME regardless of size or industry; banking, ERP
and bookkeeping in order to decrease the resources spent on administration activities,
and increase the effectiveness and efficiency. It enables the management to plan,
manage and control the activities of the enterprises, and have a real time overview of the
performance regardless of time or space.
2. Add-ons: The additional benefits provided by the individual service and product element.
It contains the benefits of the ERP system, the cloud solution, online banking services
and the bookkeeping services. The aim is of course to provide the best quality which is
also an important value to the client. Since the characteristic of the offered complex
product assumes a long term commitment from the client, there are benefits such as
continuous service developments according to the requirements.
The sacrifices have three forms:
1. Purchase price: There is no exact concept concerning the price of the complex product. It
depends on the added services given by the bank and the bookkeeping services which
will be part of the agreements between the partners. In general the pricing strategy is
planned to be bundling pricing, which means that the total price of the offered services is
less than individually purchasing them. The pricing depends on also whether there can be
an agreement using fixed prices for the services by the bookkeepers, which will be hard
to agree on concerning the expected number of bookkeeping partners. The bank can
easily add a basic package for low price, which goes also for Libra Szoftver, who agreed
on providing the ERP licence for HUF 10 000 per month which is very low price on the
market.
2. Acquisition costs: The basis of the product is the cloud concept, which those not require
additional costs such as purchasing internal servers. However the SMEs are facing with
costs concerning the implementation; the education of employees.
3. Operating costs: The whole concept idea is to reduce the operating costs concerning the
administrative activities and in a way increase the effectiveness and efficiency of the
enterprises. From the aspect of operating cost the product provides benefits rather than
sacrifices.
7.5 Conclusion of the partnership
The collaboration provides extended values and benefits to the partners and the clients. From
the sales aspect it gives the possibility to use the existing sales channels and target existing and
new customers with the product. It increases the information sharing between the partner
organizations, and positively affects the understanding of the client requirements. The in depth
understanding of the stakeholders improves the relationship building.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 27
8 SWOT analyses
The SWOT analysis is used to summarize the findings. The analysis is done from the view of the
“product organization” rather than from an individual company. The main reason is that the
overall approach contains the strength weaknesses, opportunities and threat on both the
individual and collaboration level. It would also be hard to prioritize the partners, since the added
services are equal, and all the stakeholders in the product launch are equally important. The aim
of a partnership is exactly to use each other strength against the weaknesses.
Figure 7: SWOT analysis
STRENGTH
Complex, innovative product
Professional partners
Product Covers all administrative activities
Multiplied sales channels (partnership)
Ability to capture the client requirements
Lower cost of R&D activities (partnership)
Strong relationship between the clients
and bookkeeping companies
WEAKNESSES
Quality is hard to measure
Lack of agreements between the partners
Weak sales channel of Granit Bank
Lack of sales channel of TDP-ERP
Libra targeted mainly medium and large
enterprises
No clear business model
Several stakeholders
OPPORTUNITIES
Product fulfils the SME needs
Not industry specific product
Possibilities for cross sale and up sale
activities
Large market
Price sensitivity
IT investment is a priority in the SME
segment
THREATS
Economic crisis
Unstable SME sector
Liquidity problems, low competitiveness,
circular debt
Low level of managerial knowledge in the
SME sector
Price sensitivity
Source: Adapted from Kotler et al. (2009)
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 28
9 Business model
The business model is designed on the basis of the analysis and the requirements of stakeholder
cooperation. The development of business model is vital in order to enter to the market with the
product and maintain the product management and sales activities. Due to the amount of
stakeholders and the different business lines it is important to design the model concerning the
competencies and tasks. From the financial aspect the ideal model provides benefits and
profitability to all of the stakeholders by establishing a win-win situation. It is not just a sum of
services therefore it is necessary to coordinate the activities of the stakeholders, managing the
product related activities such as sales or marketing. According to the basic business model the
concept is designed and developed by TDP-ERP, however the product will be a part of the
portfolio of Granit Bank, which actually adds only the banking services.
Figure 8: Business model canvas
Source: Adapted from Osterwalder (2012)
The model contains the main elements of a business model.
Key partners Key Activities
Key resources
Value proposition Customer relationship
Channels
Customer segment
Cost structure Revenue Stream
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 29
9.1 Key partners
The SME Cloud project contains several key partners. Each of the stakeholders has different
roles and competences. They add various services to the complex product. The key partners are
involved not just in the development phase, but also in the market launch and in the service
provider activities in the future. The key partners should be the following:
Gránit Bank
Libra Szoftver
Consortium of TDP-ERP and Global solution
bookkeeping companies
National Development Agency (NFÜ): financing the product development
Figure 9: Key partners of SME cloud project
Source: Own production
9.2 Key activities
The complex product has two levels of activities; first of all there is a level of individual services
provided by the partners, and a level of the complex product. Even known the project owner is
the consortium of TDP-ERP and Global Solution, in the business model it is not enough to cover
only their activities. The individual activities are all the services provided by the partners; banking
services by Granit Bank or ERP development and maintenance by Libra Szoftver. The activities
concerning the complex product are more important and necessary to identify in order to have a
successful partnership.
SME CLOUD Project
NFÜ
TDP-ERPLIBRA
SZOFTVER
GRÁNIT BANK
BOOKKEEPING FIRMS
System design and development
Banking servicesFinancing
Bookkeeping services
ERP development
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 30
The key activities concerning the complex product launch are related to the way of managing the
partnership. The regular business activities such as sales and marketing or quality management
and control should be centralized; managed by one entity on a basis of consensus. Managing the
partnership is similar to a project management; where the aim is having a control over the
individuals and teams. The main elements are the common planning and managing. The
partners should share a common vision and develop the strategy according to achieve it. In order
to define the key activities, the Project Management Manual is used as a framework, which
contains three main areas of the project management which is used to identify the key activities
of managing the partnership.
Figure 10: Key activities
Adapted from: Harvard Business Review (1997)
Define and organize
Within the partnership it is important to define the overall vision, mission, objectives and the
strategy. In the complex product all the services are equally important, which means that the
dissatisfaction of a partner risks the product launch. The activities of the definition part should be
done in consensus. On the strategic level the development of common marketing and sales
strategy concerning the cloud product is necessary. The product is the part of Granit Bank
portfolio, however it should be marketed through own channels of the partners as well targeting
the existing clientele.
The implementation of the common strategies requires defining key performance indicators,
targets, the way of measuring activities and the controlling.
The complex product requires continuous improvements and development in order to maintain or
even increase the competitiveness. The internal communication between the partners is vital
concerning the cooperation.
Plan
The activities related to planning are assigned to the partners. The overall strategy should be
broken down to individual levels by specifying the tasks for the partners which are necessary to
achieve the overall strategic targets.
The effectiveness and efficiency of the partnership requires defining the tasks and
responsibilities for the members. Behind the main activities concerning the services there are
Planning and Managing the
Partnership
Define and Organize
PlanTrack and manage
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 31
additional tasks, which should be defined. The service providers should provide all the regular
services such as help and support activities, what they do in their business for the given price to
the clients.
Track and manage
The measuring and controlling activities are the relevant concerning the tracking. It is important
that TDP-ERP is responsible for these functions concerning the overall performance. In case of
deviation of the targeted and actual results, action should be initiated on the level of partnership
or at the individual companies. The managing activities contain the administration and
coordination.
9.3 Key resources
The main resources concerning the product launch are the capital and human resources. TDP-
ERP finances the development from own and EUREKA_HU_12 sources. The product launch
requires additional sources to cover the expenses. Instead of expensive marketing activities at
the beginning of the product penetration, the sources of partners should be used. All the partners
have existing sales channels and clientele; therefore first those clients should be targeted with
the product. In order to do this, it is important to establish agreements with bookkeeping
companies.
The resources concerning the services of the product concept is provided by the individual
partners. It means that the internal costs of the main and related services should be covered by
the partners individually. All the members has existing capital and skilled human resources to
provide high quality service and support activities.
9.4 Value proposition
The complex product provides values to the SMEs and additional partners. The value stream in
the business model covers both sides.
On the client side the SMEs using ERP system reducing the amount of resources spent on
administrative tasks. The system enables the managers and owners to have a better control over
the activities and process. The information from the system can be used for planning, controlling
and managing activities.
The data flow between the elements of the system (bank, bookkeeper) dramatically reduces the
time, and optimizes the administration. The involvement of bookkeepers adds value also by
improving the business knowledge of the SME sector. The bookkeepers have a good financial
knowledge to analyse, interpret and explain the results to the managers and give advices
concerning the required actions.
The bank provides the SMEs with cheap and quality services; therefore the companies can save
on the administrative costs of banking activities. The good quality of the bookkeeping services
positively affects the loan application of the SME by having clear and professional books, ledgers
and reports, which are the basis of the loan evaluation.
The business model creates values and benefits for the partners as well. Since the agreements
have not been concluded concerning product launch, it is necessary to propose those to the
partners as well. Over the benefits of the common sales and marketing activities, the extended
sales channels of the partnership add more benefits. The concept is that the bank, bookkeepers
and the ERP provider adds basic services to the complex product and keeping the opportunity for
cross-selling and up-selling activities; sales of additional modules or consultancy. The bank
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 32
purpose is to have a high quality lending portfolio. The offered ERP and bookkeeping services
increase the quality of the SME business activities. The clear reports and real time controlling
tools together with the quality bookkeeping and financial advices definitely reduce the lending
risk for Granit Bank.
The benefits of involvement for the bookkeeping firms are the reduced time spent on the
bookkeeping activities which is one of the main cost drivers of the industry. By providing the
bookkeeping services within the product concept the companies can provide more to the clients
for the same price than before. From the aspect of pricing the bookkeepers will be able to make
higher margin due to the fact of reduced time and costs and keeping the existing prices or offer
additional services to the SMEs.
9.5 Customer relationship
The purpose of the complex product is providing the SMEs with quality services for low price. In
order to keep the high quality it is important to get customer feedbacks and requirements for
improvement. The basis of the relationship is however done on the individual partner level. The
communication activities concerning the service elements should be assigned to the bank,
bookkeeper or ERP provider concerning their core competencies and profession fields. The
centralized communication would require a shared service center, which increases the costs.
The communication platform is part of the ERP system where the client can communicate online
with the bank, bookkeeper or ERP provider in case of questions or problems. On the centralized
level it is required to collect the feedbacks from the clients, which helps to improve the services.
In the business model the existing strong relationship between the client and the bookkeeper on
the market is important. The owners and SMEs are not changing often the bookkeeper because
of the established trust and the unknown quality of the services on the competitors’ side. The
established trust would increase the effectiveness of the sales activities using relationship
selling.
9.6 Channels
The main sales channel where the product is sold should be done using the bookkeepers as
sales agents. The reason is the established relationship and the trust between the clients. The
complex product can be offered through this sales channel. Using the trust for selling the product
has a business ethics concern. Due to the fact that the product represents innovative solutions
and high quality, which increases the competitiveness of the SME, there is no doubt concerning
the ethical aspects. The amount of acquired customers depends on the number of established
partnership agreement with bookkeeping companies.
The probability of success is directly proportional to the agreements. It is important to build up a
quality bookkeeping chain and sell the products through those companies. The chain
development requires high financial resources in order to find the bookkeeping firms which
provide quality services. Concerning the time and cost consumption, agreement with an already
established association would be beneficial. Association of High Quality Bookkeepers has more
than 120 registered members all around Hungary. The partnership agreement would create a
good basis for the sales activities. It is recommended to involve the association.
The SMEs should be targeted from the side of the bank and ERP producer as well. The product
will be the part of the bank portfolio, which means that the bank should make also huge
marketing effort to promote the product. In case the SME contacts the bank with a request to buy
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 33
the product, the bank should let the client choose the bookkeeper from a list of existing partners,
or the client prefer keeping the existing bookkeeping firm, than establish a new partnership
through the new client. This solution enables the client to keep the trusted bookkeeper, and in
the other hand the sales channel might be widen by inviting the bookkeeping company to the
partnership.
9.7 Customer segment
The offered complex product is able to meet the demand of micro, small and medium sized
organizations regardless of industry. It is required however to focus on specifying the segment.
According to the planned sales channel the low budget bookkeeping companies should not be
partners due to the low level of quality. It would negatively affect the overall product quality, and
would create an intensive price competition between the partners, which is not the overall
objective. Concerning the sales and marketing activities, the targeted SME should have at least
adequate business knowledge in order to understand the core benefits of the product. Targeting
SMEs with limited knowledge would increase the marketing expenses and decrease the return on
the marketing investments.
The target segment should be the small and medium sized enterprises which does not have ERP
system and using the services of external bookkeepers. The sales possibility is positive due to the
fact that the IT investment has a priority in the SME segment. The partnering agreement with
bookkeeping companies would increase the effectiveness and efficiency of the targeting
activities. From the aspect of segmenting it is clear that the product is useful from the SMEs
regardless of industry or size, however companies with internal accounting and bookkeeping
department probably are not interested in purchasing the product. This is the reason why instead
of focusing on segmenting the end users, the focus should be switched to the bookkeeping
industry.
9.8 Cost structure
The most relevant costs in the product launch period are the administration and marketing costs.
The overall management, measurement and control activities are done by the consortium of TDP-
ERP and Global Solution. It is obvious that the Polish company cannot be involved in the
aforementioned activities on the Hungarian market. It is important to differentiate the costs on
the individual level and the expenses concerning partnership. The cost management on the
individual level are assigned to the partners. The centralized marketing, sales, management and
controlling activities should be assigned to TDP-ERP, who is responsible for the aforementioned
tasks. At the end of the development phase 6 employees will be available at the company, which
gives the employee basis to work on the collaboration related activities.
The costs of the centralized product launch and management contains the following costs for
TDP-ERP:
Employee salaries
Percentage of the overhead costs (calculated by the total overhead divided by the
employee number assigned to the management activities)
Marketing expenses (advertisements)
Sales expenses (establishing agreements with bookkeeping companies)
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 34
9.9 Revenue stream
The basis of the revenues is the sales price of the complex product. By setting the price it is
important to take into account the price sensitivity and cost reduction aims of the SME sector.
Within the price the ERP licence fee, basic banking and bookkeeping services are implemented.
It contains also the royalty fee for the consortium of TDP-ERP and Global Solution, in which the
coverage of the costs concerning the centralized activities should be built in. Due to the legal
requirements the service agreement between the SME and the Bank requires an individual
contract. This affects the pricing method of the product which should be the following:
Free basic banking services in case of buying the SME Cloud system, since the bank
purpose is to acquire new clients. The main income of the bank is the cross selling (e.g.
interest income of loans, transactional fees etc.)
Price of the SME Cloud product which contains the basic bookkeeping fee and a margin
over the elements in order to pay the royalty fee to the TDP-ERP consortium.
This method of pricing creates win-win situation for the partners, which are able to offer more
services over the basic product. The possibility of up-selling gives the opportunity to the partners
to provide additional services to the clients; additional ERP modules, consultancy or banking
services. It is a question however that the basis of calculating the royalty fee for TDP-ERP should
contain the up-sales, or only the sales price of the basic complex product.
10 Conclusion
The SME Cloud product is developed in a consortium of the Hungarian TDP-ERP and the Polish
Global Solution. The development is financed by own and EUREKA_HU_12 grant sources in a
55% to 45 % share. The product contains several services and involves many stakeholders. The
main partners are the TDP-ERP and Global Solution, Granit Bank, Libra Szoftver and the
bookkeeping firms. Maintaining and developing the quality of the product requires close
relationship between the partners which should be the basis of the business model. The
partnership gives values on both the individual and collaborative level. The requirements and
needs of the end user; the SME sector can be attained through different channels and due to the
information sharing it enables the partners for continuous development of their core
competences.
The total value of the developed product exceeds the value of the added services individually.
The difference is given by the collaboration. Within the product launch the aim is to establish
horizontal relationship between the partners and clients in order to maximize the benefits. The
partnership enables Granit Bank, the software developers and the bookkeepers to share the
knowledge about the SME sector and their needs. Libra Szoftver and the consortium of TDP-ERP
and Global Solution can also use the information from the bookkeepers for product and business
development.
In order to maintain the partnership it is required to understand the needs of the partners, and
provide them with benefits. Granit Bank requires clear basis for evaluating the loan application
which is done by the bookkeepers in a form of ledgers, books and different reports. The
bookkeepers’ financial knowledge can be used by the SME sector in order to compensate their
lack of business knowledge. It reduces also the risk of the lending, since the SME has a
professional financial background and control over the activities. The aforementioned activities
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 35
directly affects the financial performance of the companies, and keeps the high quality of the
bank`s lending portfolio.
One of the main characteristics of the competition in the bookkeeping industry is the aim to
provide the clients with high quality services. The complex product gives the possibility to the
bookkeeping firms to differentiate themselves from the competitors on the basis of quality and
range of services. Being recommended by a bank increases their potential to acquire new
customers.
The benefit of the new product is that Libra Szoftver can target new customer segments, the
micro and small sized companies, who do not require complex ERP system, only few modules to
cover their activities.
The partnership reduces the cost concerning the sales activities. All the partners are interested in
acquiring new customers. The collaboration enables that the sales of the complex product is
done through the existing sales channels to the existing clientele. It gives benefits to the bank,
ERP developer and the bookkeeper by widening the services to keep the clients and increase
their satisfaction. The sales to the existing clients reduce the marketing and sales cost, because
there is no need to invest in creating new channels. The involvement of the bookkeepers into the
sales activities has good potential due to the strong relationship between the clients.
Concerning the value-added activities within the collaboration the partners should focus on their
core competencies and the other tasks should be done by the trusted partners. The key activities
concerning the elements of the complex product are delegated to that partner, who is
professional on the given field. Granit Bank is dealing with banking related services, while the
ERP developers main task is the IT related activities. The bookkeepers should focus only on their
regular business. The partnership should be managed and control in order to achieve the overall
objectives and keep the high quality.
The client values consist of benefits and sacrifices. The core benefit of the SME Cloud product is
the complexity. It provides all the administration related services to the SME regardless of size or
industry; banking, ERP and bookkeeping in order to decrease the resources spent on
administration activities, and increase the effectiveness and efficiency. The additional benefits
provided by the individual service and product element. It contains the benefits of using ERP
system, the cloud solution, online banking and the bookkeeping services. The sacrifices are the
purchasing price, acquisition and operating cost. According to the price sensitivity and liquidity
problems of the SME sector the price is a monthly fee without the regular implementation fee
used in the IT business.
The pricing strategy is bundling, therefore it is cheaper to the SMEs to buy the complex product
instead of purchasing the services individually. From the cost aspect the implementation of the
SME Cloud product eliminates the cost of expensive internal server system. The product is
developed to decrease the cost of administration.
The business model is built upon the partnership. The project owner is TDP-ERP, but the business
model should cover the involvement of the partners as well. The key partners of the product
launch are the consortium of TDP-ERP and Global Solution, Granit Bank, Libra Szoftver and the
bookkeeper companies. The key activities on the individual level contain the core competencies
of the partnering organizations. In order to increase the effectiveness and efficiency of the
product organization, there is a need for centralized management and control activities, which
are assigned to TDP-ERP.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 36
The key resources are the capital and human resources of the partnership, which should be
distinguished on the individual and collaboration level. Even known the key activities require
sources, at the beginning of the product launch first the existing clientele of the partners should
be targeted with the product. The revenue from the sales provides the financial background of
the centralized activities.
The SME cloud product provides values to both the end users and the partners. On the client side
the complex, integrated product reduces the cost of administration activities. The ERP gives a
better control over the processes and performance of the SMEs. The information from the system
can be used for planning, managing and controlling activities. The cloud concept can be
accessed from everywhere at any time requiring only internet connection. The financial
knowledge of the bookkeepers compensates the lack of managerial knowledge within the sector.
In general using the product improves the overall business and competitiveness of the SME.
Over the benefits of the common sales and marketing activities, the extended sales channels of
the partnership add benefits to the partners by increasing the client base. The product contains
basic services and gives the opportunity for up-sale activities to the partners. The activities of the
bookkeepers affect the lending activities of the bank which is using the books and ledgers for
evaluating the SME loan applications. The bookkeeping companies can save the time spent on
data register, because using ERP system the data required for making the reports can be easily
withdrawn from the cloud database. It reduces the resources and gives the opportunity to
acquire more clients. Libra Szoftver can target new segment with the product, the micro and
small companies.
The customer relationship should be done on individual level concerning helpdesk and support
functions. The ERP system has a communication feature in order to communicate online with the
bank, bookkeepers or ERP developer. The existing strong relationship and trust between the
bookkeepers and the clients should be used for relationship selling.
In order to acquire customers it is important to sell the products through the sales channels of
the partners and simultaneously conclude agreements with bookkeeping firms or bookkeeping
association. The sales depend on the number of established agreement with the bookkeepers.
The offered complex product is able to meet the demand of micro, small and medium sized
organizations regardless of industry. It is required however to focus on specifying the segment.
According to the planned quality requirements, the low budget bookkeeping firms should not be
partners. The targeted segments are micro and small enterprises which are using external
bookkeeping services. From the sales aspect it is positive that the IT investment is prioritized
within the SME sector.
The main costs of the partnership after the product development phase are the management,
marketing and sales activities. The establishment of sales agreements with bookkeeping
companies also requires additional costs. This is the reason why the sales should be done by
targeting first the customer base of the partners, and covering the future cost by the revenues
from the sales. For better control over the costs budgets should be created according to the
common strategic objectives.
The basis of the revenue is the sales price which contains the ERP licence fee, basic banking and
bookkeeping services. TDP-ERP receives royalty after the sales which cover the common
managing, sales and marketing expenses. The basis of calculating the royalty does not contain
the individual income from the up-selling activities.
i
Bibliography
Act C of 2000 on accounting, 2012. (Pdf) Available at:
http://www.ecovis.hu/angol/accounting.pdf (Accessed 27 November 2012)
ACT CXII/1997. Act on Credit Institutions and Financial Enterprises. (Online). Can be retrieved at:
https://www.imolin.org/doc/amlid/Hungary/Hungary_Act_CXII_on_Credit_Institutions_and_Finan
cial_Enterprises_1996.pdf (Accessed 17 December 2012)
Ankli, R.E., 1992. Michael Porter’s Competitive Advantage and Business History. Business and
Economic History, Second Series, Volume 21, 1992. Business History Conference. (Pdf.)
Available at: http://www.thebhc.org/publications/BEHprint/v021/p0228-p0236.pdf (Accessed
27 November 2012)
Balazs, G., Guangyu, X.,2012. Performance measurement in the responsibility centers.
(Assignment). June 2012. Horsens, VIA University College.
Bloomberg, 2012. Hungary’s Banking Sector Unprofitable for First Time in 13 Years. (Online). Can
be retrieved at http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-02-23/hungary-s-banking-sector-
unprofitable-for-first-time-in-13-years.html (Accessed 19 October 2012)
Cieleszky, I., 2012. Bookkeeping in Hungary. (Interview). (Personal Communication , 05 October
2012)
Commission Recommendation 2003/361/EC of 6 May 2003 concerning the definition of micro,
small and medium-sized enterprises
Demcsák, M. & Harkai, I., 2012. “ KKV Könyvelése”,Piac & Profit Akadémia. (Conference.)
Budapest, Hall of Budapest Chamber of Commerce and Industry. (Conference, 03 October 2012)
Doing Business, 2012. Economy Profile: Hungary. (Online.) Available at:
http://www.doingbusiness.org/~/media/giawb/doing%20business/documents/profiles/country/
HUN.pdf (Accessed 19 November 2012)
Egan, J., 2011. Relationship Marketing. 4th edition. Harlow: Pearson Education Limited.
European Comission, 2012. Enterprise and Industry SBA Fact Sheet 2012 Hungary. (Online.) Can
be retrieved at: http://ec.europa.eu/enterprise/policies/sme/facts-figures-
analysis/performance-review/files/countries-sheets/2012/hungary_en.pdf (Accessed 22
November 2012)
Fekete, G., 2009. Hegemoniaja visszaszerzesere torekszik idehaza az SAP. (Online). Can be
retrieved at: http://businessonline.prim.hu/cikk/73659/ (Accessed 20 December 2012)
Granit Bank, 2012a. About. (Online). Can be retrieved at
https://www.granitbank.hu/rolunk/granit-bank (Accessed 27 November 2012)
Granit Bank, 2012b. Partners. (Online). Can be retrieved at
https://www.granitbank.hu/rolunk/partners (Accessed 27 November 2012)
Harkai, I., 2012. Bookkeeping in Hungary. (Interview). Personal Communication, 19 November
2012)
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 ii
Harvard Business Review, 1997. Project Management Manual. Harvard Business Review, 6
October, 1997.
Hegedüs, E., 2012. A Gránit Bank üzleti modellje, szerepe a vállalkozások
finanszírozásában.(Pdf) Can be retrieved at http://www.mkt.hu/docs/2012-10-02-18-56-27-
Hegedus_Eva.pdf (Accessed 14 December 2012)
Herczeg, B.,Csite, A., Mike, K., 2012. A könyvelő-ügyfél kapcsolat és a piac szerkezetének hatása
a könyvelőkre. Hétfa Kutatóintézet. (Pdf). Available at:
http://www.gvh.hu/domain2/files/modules/module25/20928C18A5BCA7A9C.pdf (Accessed 02
December 2012)
HFSA, 2012. Risk Report. Hungarian Financial Supervisory Authority. May 2012. (Pdf). Can be
retrieved at http://www.pszaf.hu/data/cms2376019/Risk_report_May_2012_ENG_final.pdf
(Accessed 02 December 2012)
Hutt, M.D. & Speh, T.W., 2010. Business Marketing Management B2B. 10th edition. Mason:
South-Western, CENAGE Learning.
KSH, 2012. Statisztikai Tükör. VI.évfolyam, 19. szám. (Online.) Available at:
http://www.ksh.hu/docs/hun/xftp/gyor/gaz/gaz21112.pdf (Accessed 25 November 2012)
KSH, 2011. A kis- és középvállalkozások helyzete a régiókban. (Online.) Available at:
http://www.ksh.hu/docs/hun/xftp/idoszaki/regiok/gyorkkv.pdf (Accessed 10 December 2012)
K&H, 2012a. Branches. (online). Can be retrieved at:
https://www.kh.hu/publish/kh/en/products_services/alkalmazasok/fiok_ATM_kereso.html
(Accessed 27 November 2012)
K&H, 2012b. It fejlesztesek allnak a kkv beruhazasok kozeppontjaban. (Online). Can be retrieved
at:
https://www.kh.hu/publish/kh/hu/khcsoport/sajtokozlemeny/2012/2012__II__negyedev/az_IT
_fejlesztesek_allnak_a_kkv_beruhazasok_koezeppontjaban_.html (Accessed 11 December
2012)
Kotler, P., et al., 2009.Marketing Management. Harlow: Pearson Education Limited.
Libra, 2012a. Libra 3s Vállalatirányítási Rendszer. (Online). Can be retrieved at
http://mve.hu/hu/libra3s-vallalatiranyitasi-rendszer (Accessed 5 December 2012)
Libra, 2012b. Cégünkről. (Online). Can be retrieved at http://mve.hu/hu/cegunkrol (Accessed 5
December 2012)
Libra, 2012c. Oktatasi intezmenyek. (Online). Can be retrieved at http://mve.hu/hu/oktatasi-
intezmenyek (Accessed 6 December 2012)
NGM, 2012. Könyvviteli szolgáltatást végzők (regisztráltak) névjegyzéke. Nemzetgazdasági
Minisztérium. (excel). Available at: http://www.kormany.hu/hu/nemzetgazdasagi-
miniszterium/ado-es-penzugyekert-felelos-allamtitkarsag/hirek/konyvviteli-szolgaltatast-vegzok-
regisztraltak-nevjegyzeke (Accessed 20 November 2012)
Osterwalder, A., 2012. Business model canvas. (Online). Can be retrieved at:
http://www.businessmodelgeneration.com (Accessed 17 December 2012)
OTP, 2012. Branch Locator. (Online). Can be retrieved at
https://www.otpbank.hu/portal/en/Branch_locator (Accessed 27 November 2012)
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 iii
Porter, M., 2008. The Five Competitive Forces That Shape Strategy. Harvard Business Review,
January 2008. (Online). Available at: Harvard Business Review http://hbr.org/2008/01/the-five-
competitive-forces-that-shape-strategy/ar/1 (Accessed 20 December 2012).
Szerb, L.&Ulbert, J., 2009. The Examination of the Competitiveness in the Hungarian SME Sector:
A Firm Level Analysis. (E-book.) Acta Polytechnica Hungarica. Vol. 6, No.3, 2009. Available at:
http://www.uni-obuda.hu/journal/Szerb_Ulbert_19.pdf (Accessed 22 November 2012)
Toth, Sz., 2009. A KKV-k és az ERP rendszerek Magyarországon. (Pdf). Available at:
http://www.tmte.hu/07projektek/071texplat/071_texplat_anyagok_091112/071_texplat_kkv_
erp.pdf (Accessed 26 November 2012)
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 iv
Appendix 1: Personal interview with Istvan Cieleszky
Bookkeeping in Hungary
Participants: Istvan Cieleszky (bookkeeper and auditor)
Gergely Balazs
Place: Budapest, Egressy Street 75.
Date: 05 October 2012
The interview started with a short introduction and product description. Due to the continuous
conversation the answers are reconstructed from the notes. Istvan Cieleszky agreed on using the
interview for the project purpose.
Q: What are the main tasks of a bookkeeper?
A: The tasks are always concluded within a service contract. The bookkeeper provides always
services according to that. In general the bookkeeper registers the data of transactions, creates
the books, ledgers and reports. Often the clients require consultancy concerning the taxation or
company establishment. The bookkeeper should always do the work according to the legal
requirements.
Q: What are the main bookkeeping related activities on the client and the bookkeeper side?
A: Basically the client should register all the transaction concerning the business activities. It
means that it is necessary to making bills, invoices, registering the daily cash transactions,
making bank transfers etc... There is a wide range of activities. Of course it is important to
provide the bookkeeper with the documentations. On the bookkeeper side it always starts with
sorting and selecting the records, adding those to the bookkeeping software, withdrawing the
bank transactions from the bank, and creating the books. The most time consuming is the data
input.
Q: How the bookkeeper setting the price?
A: It depends on the bookkeeper. The quality bookkeeping has its price. There are many
unqualified bookkeepers on the market who are making the books for few thousand HUF. It
depends on the client what he/she wants for his/her money. Normally the price depends on the
size and form of the company, the financial details, the amount of bills, recipes, the form of
taxation and the additional services if required.
Q: Are the price menu based or fixed for different services?
A: No. The bookkeeper is always guessing the time consumption and evaluating other aspects in
order to give the final price.
Q: What are the other aspects?
A: For example sympathy or available resources for the work.
Q: Does the sympathy really matter?
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 v
A: The bookkeeping is a long term commitment. Companies are not often changing the
bookkeeper, who knows a lot about the company. Of course we would like to select also our
clients.
Q: How is the communication between the clients and bookkeepers?
A: Mainly we are communicating by phone or by e-mail. Normally the client visits the bookkeeper
once a month. Otherwise sends the documents by post, and we can also withdraw the banking
transaction from the banks.
Q: How is the competition on the market?
A: There is a strong competition, especially because of the increased amount of low-budget
bookkeeping companies. Luckily we have still the possibility to evaluate the clients before
concluding the service contract.
Q: Is there any marketing activities concerning the bookkeeping companies?
A: Some companies have website and launching online advertisements. Within the business life
the clients are communicating with each other, and asking for recommended bookkeepers in
case of changing the bookkeeper or establishing a company. The serious owners and managers
know the price of the quality, so they do not believe in advertisements offering bookkeeping
service for very cheap price.
Q: What do you think about the product concept? Do you have any recommendations?
A: The idea is good. It reduces the time spent on data input on the bookkeeper`s side. Also it
would save our costs, since we have employees doing only data input.
It is important that the ERP modules should not be able to make the bookkeeping, only the data
input on the client site. I am not sure that the clients would trust in cloud system, even if it saves
costs. It is important to assure the clients about the data protection.
According to the concept it is necessary to find out the interests of the clients and bookkeepers
and find the balance between those. The bookkeeper similar to other businesses would keep the
existing clients and acquire new ones. It would be a good idea if the bank would evaluate the
documents provided by the partner bookkeepers as trusted documents.
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 vi
Appendix 2: Notes from SME Academy Conference
Piac&Profit KKV Akademia – Piac & Profit SME Academy
Date: 03-10-2012
Place: Budapest Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Budapest, Krisztina korut 99.
Presenter: Istvan Harkai, Maria Demcsak
Pitfalls of the SMEs
The SME do not make financial plans. The managers and owners do not have adequate
business knowledge.
The owners often lacking knowledge about the company performance.
Wrong decision making based on the limited knowledge.
The SMEs cannot afford the implementation expensive ERP systems.
The owner is fully responsible and reliable from the date of the company establishment.
Often the owners are choosing wrong company forms, and wrong bookkeepers. They do
not use consultancy services.
The bookkeepers are professionals in finance and accounting. Their knowledge is
available however the SMEs do not often use that kind of services.
The choice of bookkeeper is always contain risks; the client cannot be sure what kind of
service will be provided.
Partnership is an important part of the bookkeeping business.
The clients do not often change the bookkeeper. The reason is the built up trust, however
dissatisfied clients are acting in the same way. The reason is the stereotype that the
bookkeeper knows a lot about the company and the business activity, therefore they do
not want to take the risk changing the bookkeeper.
The clients are cancelling the service contract in case of mistakes in the bookkeeping
resulting penalty from the tax authorities or when lacking of communication and
consultancy, bad overall quality of the service or loss of trust
The bookkeeper can do additional services in order to help the business of the SME like
cost analysis, analysis of the financial effects of decision making, buyer-supplier analysis.
However the activities are limited due to the features of the software used by the
bookkeeper.
The misunderstandings concerning the provided service range are often causing
problems. The bookkeeper is always providing the services concluded in a service
contract. The clients often expect more for their money than simple bookkeeping
activities. They require financial advices, consultancy etc... It is important to make it clear
at the beginning what kind of services will be provided.
Appendix 3: Personal Interview with Istvan Harkai
Bookkeeping in Hungary
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 vii
Participants: Istvan Harkai (authorized bookkeeper, president of the Association of Quality
Bookkeepers)
Gergely Balazs
Place: Erd, Angyalka Street 1/A. Hungary.
Date: 19 November 2012.
The interview started with a short introduction and product concept description. Due to the
continuous conversation the answers are reconstructed from the notes. Istvan Harkai agreed on
using the interview for the project purpose.
Q: What are the main problems on the SME market from the bookkeeper point of view?
A: The main problem is the low level of business knowledge the managers and owners are
having. This affects negatively the overall business atmosphere within the sector. The lack of
knowledge affects of course the decision making, planning and other activities. Sometimes we
cannot even talk about strategic or financial planning and controlling.
It is hard for the managers to distinguish the “company money” from the “own money”. They aim
for own wealth instead of looking at the company as an individual entity. I always tell to my
clients that treat the own business in a way that they would sell it. From this point of view they
can concentrate to increase the value of it.
The grey market is also increasing on the market in order to take out the money from the
company without taxation. It is done by selling products without recipes or bills.
Q: How is the relationship between the bookkeepers and the clients?
A: The relationship can be described as a long term commitment. Since it is hard to differentiate
the bookkeepers by quality, the clients do not want to take the risk of switching to the new one.
However it is the only way to find out the differences between the levels of the provided services.
The clients would like to feel themselves secured in a way that the books, ledgers and other
reports are done due to the deadline and legal requirements.
Q: What is the reason of changing bookkeepers?
A: It is done in case of lack of trust, bad quality work, penalties from the tax authorities because
of mistakes in the books, or high level client dissatisfaction. Some of the bookkeepers do not
have insurance covering the caused damages to the client, and of course the clients do not sue
the bookkeeper who knows a lot about the activity of the companies (Author`s explanation: the
bookkeepers know a lot about the grey market activities of the clients), even known that the
bookkeeper should keep the business secrets.
Q: What can you tell me about the competition on the bookkeeping market?
A: The bookkeeper profession is very stressful. The whole year is busy according to the monthly,
quarterly and yearly reports, and the VAT admission. There are many new entrants on the market.
As a president of Association of Quality Bookkeepers I visited many bookkeeping offices in
Hungary. Often I experienced that the office is located in a garage or at the private home. The
entry does not require huge investments. The competition is really strong especially because of
the dabblers who are offering bookkeeping at HUF 5-6 000. Of course a quality job cannot be
expected for that amount. It is also hard to differentiate the quality of the services; at least there
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 viii
is no ideal measurement for that. Mainly the bookkeepers try to focus on increasing the client
satisfaction. If a client satisfied, there is a good possibility to recommend the bookkeeper to
business partners. This is the only way the quality bookkeepers can acquire clients, which is
getting harder from year to year.
Q: What are the requirements to make quality bookkeeping?
A: Until there is no penalty from the tax authorities, the customer believes that the service has a
good quality. However there are other aspects. The knowledge of the bookkeeper affects the
output of the financial results in a way of amount of payable taxes, choice of suitable company
form or financial advices. It is also important how the bookkeeper is communicating with the
clients, how the office looks like etc... The main essence is the knowledge. The bookkeeper
should follow the changes of the financial laws, which are changing quiet often nowadays. As a
legal requirement the bookkeeper should be a member of a chamber. In order to keep the
licence it is required to take part on trainings. As a matter of fact many of the bookkeepers do not
do this and still have the licence, and even if they lose it, nothing happens, they can still making
books and ledgers. There is no control over these activities, which is a main reason why the
quality differs a lot within the industry.
Q: What is the main purpose of the Association of Quality Bookkeepers?
A: I established the association with the vision of increasing the quality of the members`
business activities. The main objectives are the actions against the dabbler bookkeepers,
professional help to the members in bookkeeping, creating a culture for the bookkeepers and
represent the bookkeepers` interest. We also organize trainings for the members and providing
them with online newsletters. The future plan is to acquire positive recognition in the market,
which means that being a member of the association is a guarantee for the high quality. We set
up minimum requirements for joining to the association, such as local inspection in order to
evaluate the location, accessories of the bookkeeping office. This is important, that the office
should show the professionalism, it means that when a client enters to the office, should have a
positive first impression. We require also the official registration and the profession insurance.
Over the quality the bookkeeper should provide more services than the regular bookkeeping. We
have establishment with different organizations in order to offer more to our clients.
Q: How is the pricing in the industry?
A: In Germany there are fixed prices for the services. In Hungary the low budget bookkeeping
companies using menu based pricing, offering fixed prices for the different services. The quality
bookkeepers prefer evaluating the clients before agreeing on prices and services. Since it is a
long term relationship, we evaluate the price also on sympathy. In case of unwanted client
instead of saying no, we give a high price. The time consumption of the work is an important
driver of the final price. It depends on the type and size of the companies, the amount of recipes,
bills etc... The most time consuming activity is selecting and sorting the transaction document
and add those to the bookkeeping software. When it is done, starts the “real bookkeeping”. It is
important to say, that the quality has always a price, however it is not always true that the high
price equals to high quality as well.
Q: What do you think about the SME Cloud Concept?
A: It is a good idea concerning reducing the time consumption of the data input. The bookkeepers
can benefit from it by offering more quality services. It would definitely increase the competitive
advantage. However it is necessary to say, that the SME sector is not ready for the concept,
either the bookkeepers. The average age in the bookkeeping industry is about 40-50 years. The
Gergely Balazs
December 2012 ix
old bookkeepers do not have trust in the modern technological solutions. They are afraid also
from learning something new. There is a lack of complex thinking in Hungary. People do not want
to innovate or try something new.