Impact of North-South War 1983-2005 on Children in the Sudan
-
Upload
researchpub -
Category
Documents
-
view
2 -
download
0
Transcript of Impact of North-South War 1983-2005 on Children in the Sudan
The Impact of North-South War 1983-2005on Children in the
Sudan
Dr. Faiz Omar Mohammad Jamie
Sep.2014
2
Impact of North-South War 1983-2005 on Children in the Sudan
Dr. Faiz Omar Mohammd Jamie1
Abstract
This paper deals with the impact of the war that took place between North and South
Sudan (1983-2005) before Secession of South Sudan. It was by definition the most
severe civil war that took place in the Sudan, and considered to be the longest internal
conflict in the continent. The paper holds the opinion that, the war brought much
destruction in the economic infrastructure in the country; however the highest cost of
that war was its human cost, in terms of lost lives, disabilities caused, disappearance of
persons, orphans, widowed women, disintegration of families producing phenomena of
homeless and street children, apart from war-related child abduction….etc. the paper
shall broadly touch on the adjustments introduced by the government on the current
formal basic education programs as a result of extra demand due to war-motivated
population movement, reflecting on the point as a consequence of war furthering the
burden of war on children.
Introduction
This paper shall try to assess the high cost of this war in terms
of lost human lives, disabled, ever-increasing number of missing
army men, tribesmen, children, and women. This high human cost
is believed to be by far beyond any other cost of it. This cost
1 Associate Professor in Political Science-University of Bahri Director, Centre for Peace and Development Studies.
3
is as well an unprecedented drain of human resources ever
experienced in the modern history of the Sudan. The scope of the
war and its side-effects has covered almost 25% of the total area
of the country; accordingly the directly affected population is
more or less 25% of the total population of the country. The
focus here is on the impact of war on children, however women and
children are hardly separable parties. This evident
interconnection can be traced in many parts of this paper.
The interesting role of urban women, in the war, was well
documented in the valuable book titled "Samra'a Al-Sudan"
published by P.D.F., detailing the development of role of women
in mobilization of "Zad almujahid" extending of medical support,
and direct participation in military operations, crowned by
declaration of some women martyrs. What has not been mentioned
in the said publication was the corresponding role played by
rural women in Kordofan and Darfur, traditional areas of tribal
conflicts, where women are customarily involved in war
activities, mostly stimulating bravery of men warriors. It is
unmistakable that Sudanese rural women pioneered to participate
in the war effort, be they local poets "Hakama", foodstuff
donators, or even actual female fighters beside male fighters.
Apart from that, the mentioned publication remains of good value
documenting for roles played by Sudanese women.
The paper aims to provide an analysis of the way in which
4
children as associates of women, were affected by the effects of
the armed conflict, that took place (in the North-South conflict)
in the Sudan. The rationale behind that is the fact that, the
prevailing literature on conflict in the Sudan, hardly focuses on
children, amidst abundant literature on lost lives, disabilities,
….etc. Apart from that the paper aims to understand the response
of the Sudanese government regarding needs of displaced children
in the area of education health and other concerns.
Population in the Sudan
Let us first look into how the situation looked – like in this
country in the pre – 1983 period in terms of population
formation, in order to be able to assess the impact of the war in
the light of the the discussion that follows. The said situation
has been influenced by many factors leading to the formation of
the existing make – up; the emergence of the Sudanese nation –
state out of the big (historic) Sudanic zone. Therefore the
interaction between diverse ethnic entities, informed the "bridge
theory" as a stereotype image the Sudan, as a bridge between
North Africa and black Africa south of the Sahara, owing a lot to
the population movements from neighboring countries as refugees
and successive repatriation efforts assisted by the international
community in the region.
The total number of the Sudanese people according to 1983
5
population census was estimated to be 20, 5 million persons,
living in a approximate area of 1 million square miles, the
resulting population density is more than 8 persons per 1 square
Kilometer. The country was divided into 9 regions comprising 18
provinces. 68% out of total population live in rural areas that
was 14.5 million, whereas 20% out of the same total live in urban
areas, and almost 11% lead nomadic mode of life.
More than 5 million Sudanese live in the southern part of it,
that was nearly 25% of the total population with a little bit
lower figure in population density (persons per 1 sq. kilometer),
than the national figure. However the most populated region over
the country was the central region which hosts move the 4 million
people 20% of the population, whereas the least populated region
is the Northern region over whose land live 1 million people less
than 5% of the population.
By the year 1983 population of the capital city was only 1,8
in of whom 72% live in urban centres. The overall population
density was little more than 04 persons per 1 square kilometer,
more than twice of the figure of the central region. Latter on
the biggest receiving area of Internally Displaced population
(I.D.P), Khartoum region which was, as well receiving area for
rural – urban migrations, education seekers, drought – affected
population movements … etc.. Out of a total area of 2.5 million
square kilometer (Sudan) Khartoum region occupies only 1%
6
transformed into a residential area for 8% of the Sudan people.
Children and War in the Sudan
Children below 5 years in the Sudan make up a high percentage of
total population of the country (National population Policy
Document 2001). Before that Sudan was considered by U.N.
standards to have more than 25% of unregistered child population
(State of world's children 2000)1. Therefore discussion on
children affairs in the Sudan is so serious that the issue seems
to be concerning more or less half of the citizens, if we
considered U.N remark on unregistered children.
The issue of children raised a lot of controversy during the
second round of the civil war (post 1983), our concern here lies
on the recent practice of SPLA as regards child abduction for
military recruitment. It's common sense that for SPLA to
continue fighting, it has to secure whatever source to compensate
for the dead, lost or the getaway from among its recruits. It is
also common sense again that normal recruitment modes include
motivators; like good pay expectation in professional armies, and
other voluntary motivators, ideological, racial, mercenary or
else in guerilla movements SPLA is necessarily not a professional
army, it is rather a guerilla movement where the relevant mode of
recruitment involves what we termed voluntary motivators, SPLA
tried all the said mechanism adding another unusual mode child
7
abduction, in which case children were forcibly taken from their
parents in SPLA – controlled areas and villages among other
things including cattle and women.
Circumstances of war are conducive to all sorts of tragic
situations. In 1996 the U.N compiled its annual report on the
state of children in areas of conflict; the following quotation
of that report would illustrate better such situation:
"The conflict has already claimed more than 500,000 lives and
displaced huge numbers of people. Among these were at least
20,000 children, mostly boys between 7 - 17 years of age who were
separated from their families. Those lost boys of the Sudan
trekked enormous distances over a vast in forgiving wilderness,
seeking refuge from the fighting. Hungry, frightened and
weakened by sleeplessness and disease they crossed from Sudan
into Ethiopia and back with many dying along the way, the
survivors are now in camps between Kenya, Uganda and the Sudan" 2
Indeed in such circumstances a military unit can be a better
refuge, or a kind of alternative family. The indication here is
to the effect that in such situations abduction is most likely to
be a favor rather than a crime. Moreover involvement of children
in war affairs is not a strange pheromone in the region. In
8
neighboring Uganda the same report went on to say that the
National Resistance Army had an estimated 3000 children many
under 16 years including 500 girls mostly orphans, who consider
the Army as replacement for their parents and families.
Children's actual duties in warfare cover the whole range of
military activities, however at relatively quiet times they may
be used in cooking, carrying water, and they have exceptional
value as messengers and spies.
The U.N. secretary – General Representative for Children in
Conflict Areas presented his report to the U.N. Human Rights
Committee is 8th meeting at Geneva, where he stated that at
Rumbek alone there were about 8000 child soldiers of whom the
UNCEF managed to free or demobilize 3500 out of them, to the U.S
rather than to the Sudan(H.A.C). The rest of these children are
still in the bush, carrying on their military activities, which
the international community repeatedly condemned through a
network of declarations, campaigns and agreements for the last
decade, since world leaders adopted the convention on the Rights
of the child in 1989 and then confirmed their commitment for
children and adolescents at the 1990 world summit on children.3
Beside war impact on children in Sudan, other factors also
further their negative situation. Fresh UN reports rank the
Sudan the 43rd among 189 surveyed countries, where infant
mortality rate is most high out of every thousand children 115
9
died in the year 20004. The rate is considered a critical
indicator of the condition of children of the Sudan which is
listed among top 50 countries5 with unfavorable state for them
according to other standards.
One other indirect impact of war upon children is the phenomena
of street boys or "sons of the sun" as they are locally named
these are population of homeless children, boys and girls alike
wondering around town streets aimlessly, their only concern is to
secure living whatsoever. Khartoum as capital is most affected
by this phenomenon. War is one contributing factor driving
children who lost their families one way or another due to the
war, or children of soldiers who are away of their families for
many years at hot operation areas and many other war-related
motivations other than displacement. Other factors for the
phenomena include rural-urban migration, drought – motivated
migration and other types of population movements. All these
factors contribute, besides sheer poverty in forming this
marginal childhood, as a significant source of potential Juvenile
delinquent, beggars, drug addicts, …. etc. Khartoum alone is said
to be hosting some 6000 of boys and girls called "Shammasa"6 In
conclusion most of the surveys and studies on this field confirm
that war is one big factor among others to the phenomenon.
Another aspect of close association to this subject is the issue
of internal abduction, not necessarily for children but for
captives whoever they are. This has also been subject to
10
political maneuvers against the Sudan by western circles as a
case of slavery. Unfortunately this has been encouraged by some
alleged research findings done by some Sudanese scholars7, to the
effect that slavery is a common practice by some Arab tribes
against other non-Arab tribes. However the fact is that most
nomadic tribes has a long tradition of violent conflicts over
grazing areas and else, bringing about a series of wars raids and
quarrels most often involving captives from both waring parties,
including children, women, and livestock. The traditional
practice is that these captives are used to strengthen each
party's negotiating position over the other during the process of
customary resolution of conflicts, where the warring parties are
made to sit down and settle human and material casualties
according to customary laws and traditions sometimes captives may
stay for long periods of time depending on the life cycle of the
conflict. An outsider may not get the impression, that this is
actual slavery, but a participant observer won’t come to that
conclusion, nor will a self – respecting academic.
Victims of Sexually – Transmitted Diseases (STD)
The Sudan is definitely not among the most affected African
states with HIV/AIDS infections, this new plague killing more
people than armed conflicts. Nearly 70% of new HIV/AID
infections world-wide occurred in Sub-Saharan Africa while
countries to the south of Africa are so – called global epicenter
11
of the epidemics. UN attributes this high rate to South Africa's
end of isolation in the post apartheid era with high rates of
transmission by migrant workers from within and outside the
country, and slow progress in public information campaigns8.
The story of the Sudan with AIDS is very much associated with
migrations. The disease was traced in the Sudan as back as
1986; (National Population Policy 2000) and was particularly high
among refugees and city dwellers where sex workers could be
found. Population movements from neighboring countries
facilitated transfer of the disease. In Kenya for example 22% of
girls in the age 15 – 19 and 35% of young men tested HIV
positive. Population movements in the region were intensified by
armed conflicts, in north Uganda for more than 15 years, in
Ethiopia for the last two decades, and in addition to the this
new brand of war, between Sudan and Eritrea. It was however
understood that S.T.D. infections tend to rise during wars which
lead to forced migration. Since 1986 rate of infections was on
constant rise in Sudan until it was 6000 cases by the end of
2001. Let us quote Dr. Warren Naamara.
"Migrations therefore increases and complicates the mixing
of HIV Sub-types in a manner that will not only make vaccine
development a problem, but also further complicate the evolution
of the epidemic within the recipient and donating populations”9.
12
Carriers of virus include (among other sectors) soldiers,
returnees from military operation area, refugees and other
foreign population interacting with citizens in eastern cities,
Kassala, Gadaref and Port Sudan. Khartoum being the capital
city, where everybody comes, for every reason, actually host
almost all those infected. War – related occurrence of the
disease was identified in the south well before it was known in
the east in which armed conflicts along borders broke out only in
the mid nineties of last century. Otherwise eastern and southern
borders of the country are most potential entry doors for the
incoming virus, unlike the western and northern borders where
least or no virus entry record was noticed. That could possibly
be due to the fact that nignbouring nations over western and
northern borders are Muslims, whereas those over southern and
eastern frontiers are mostly non-Muslims, it is relevant I think
here to check professor Mazurie on recent studies on AIDs in
Africa showing that rate of occurrence of disease is lower among
Muslim than it is among non- Muslim. It is even noticeable that
concentration of disease incidence in Africa reveals that central
and southern (non – Muslim) Africa is most affected in relation
to Muslim North Africa. Recent survey in Ivory Coast indicates
that Muslim communities are less vulnerable to the disease by 50%
than their fellow non- Muslim citizens. Professor Mazurie has
brought to our notice the role of religious culture in the
dissemination of the disease worldwide.
13
Considerable HIV cases were first known in Equatoria State
(Southern Sudan) in the early 1990s. But then afterwards other
cases were detected in the capital city, mostly due to normal
population movement and forced migration of displaces. Dr. Jamie
(Pathologist) of Aaazhari University stated that HIV test became
a routine before any blood donation is to be accepted within
Khartoum state. This is indicative of high awareness among
Sudanese medical authorities rather than an evidence of high out
brake phenomenon.
The belief is that disease victims and potential victim are found
within urban areas, rather than rural ones. The main sending
cities of victim are Juba Port Sudan, Kassala and Gadarif, not to
mention some other minor sources. Despite the fact that HIV/AIDs
is most significant virus disease among STD, as direct impact of
war adding to the human cost of it, other disease also contribute
to that cost, Malnutrition, water-transmitted disease,
Tuberculosis and other evident diseases in camps and settlements,
(of less significance compared to HIV/AIDs).
Challenges in basic Education of Displaced Children
In principle education policy emanates from, and is a development
of, a nation's identity, involving a planned and an intellectual
plan of action towards continuity of cultural characters. On that
ground and as the country lacks consensus on identity issues,
education policies are often subject to controversy every now and
14
then. It is therefore quite evident that North-South war is a
violent and extreme manifestation of that very controversy.
However our concern here is primarily on the education of the
internally displaced population as a formal response of the
hosting society to that genuine need. The problem is so complex
that other partners than the government exerted efforts each from
a different perspective to deliver education as a humanitarian
service badly needed by the displaced. The total number of
school-age children is estimated to be two million, as exact
figures hardly exist. Displaced population came from more than 60
ethno linguistic groups. Their language competencies and
knowledge were varied and complex. Some speak their local
languages, others bilingual, others are monolingual Arabic
speakers. However the main lingua franca commonly used by most
IDPs is simple Arabic. Muslims and Christians are minority
believers; however the majority is adherents of traditional
African beliefs. The point here is that education of displaced
children in the Sudan is so complex that it involves, cultural,
linguistic, religious, political and humanitarian problems, not
usually encountered in other similar cases.
Other partners involved in displace education process include,
U.N. agencies, foreign government, international N.G.Os.,
15
Churches and Church organization. All these actors took part in
the formulation of educational policies and strategies for the
internally displaced school-age children. However Sudan
government has a declared strategy for education of IDP, the main
features of which include.
- The use of one national curriculum
- The use of Arabic language as a sole medium of instruction
with English as a subject.
- The non-use of vernacular languages in basic education
level.
- The full government control of all schools.
- Centralization of educational planning
- Consolidation of religion and religiosity in educational
system.
The government since long has taken many measurements to
encounter education of displacees as a humanitarian obligation.
In 1989 the Council of Ministers formed the National Committee
for education of displaced children and students from southern
Sudan, one year later, recommendations of National Conference on
Displaced Issues convened in March 1990, were adopted.
Accordingly, that committee was dissolved and the Federal
Ministry of Education took over its responsibilities and duties.
All displaced schools including those established by N.G.Os, were
to be phased out and were integrated into regular government
schools starting from the academic year 1991- 1992.
16
Before the convening of the “National Conference on Displaced
1990”, and the "National Dialogue Conference on Peace Issues in
Sudan" in September, 1989, it was natural that both conferences
discussed educational issues, however contrary to previous
language polices in education, both conferences emphasized the
significance of the use of vernacular language particularly in
basic levels. However in general the assessment of progress
towards goals and targets on displaced education, the report
reveals the following:
“There is now an operational educational system for displaced in
southern Sudan, transition zone, and Khartoum state. Hundreds of
schools have been built from scratch, supplied with furniture
educational materials. The most difficult to reach children along
the Nile corridors are now reached by barge and provided with
educational services. Traumatized school children and
unaccompanied minors are being attended to. Thousands of
displaced teachers as well as non-displaced volunteers and
salaried-teachers are now being trained."
However it has to be noted that in such a country as wide as the
Sudan, a lot needs to be done to realize an actual progress.
Nonetheless reports on education show that basic school
enrollment in displaced camps at Khartoum state is extremely low
at less than 25% of school-age population, girls enrollment
totals half that of boys, however girls situation in southern
17
Sudan is even worse, for every five boys only one girl is in
school. Teacher/student ratio is one teacher for every 47
students.
UNICEF addressed the problem of girl's education by applying
innovative strategies together with teacher training programs
including distance learning approach aiming to improve teacher
quality. A total of 3700 teachers were planned to be trained in
1995 alone.
UNICEF as a major actor in education of displaced identifies
particular target groups for special attention. The so-called
Emergency Education program initially targeted displaced and war-
affected school-age children. This group included more than
480,000 children in southern Sudan, Transition Zone and Khartoum
state. The program is oriented for the children in especially
Difficult Circumstances (CEDC) which include:
- War-Traumatized children in and out of school for whom
special training programs were designed and supported to train
teachers to understand and treat them.
- An estimated 65,000 unaccompanied children are targeted for
attention. They are children as young as 8 years old who started
to wonder between Sudan and Ethiopia since 1989.
- Hard to reach children are school-age children living in
villages and towns along barge corridors of Operation Life Line
18
Sudan (OLS) specially Juba Corridor, Tonja-Fanyak corridor,
Nassir corridor and Renk corridor.
- A Mobile Emergency Education Project by barge was planned in
1995 to benefit some 270,000 children as a joint venture with
W.F.P. While the latter distributed food assistance by barges,
UNICEF accompanying team distributes education kits to revive
basic education along barge routes.
- Adolescents, either school non-attendees or dropouts as
targeted by UNICEF for a supported project aiming to integrate
the children at higher grades of formal basic education.
- War-affected rural areas children in southern Sudan and Nuba
mountains are targeted by Islamic N.G.Os., among them is,
Mawafag, Islamic Call Foundations which offer integrated
services programs at pre-school and basic education levels.
Concluding Remarks and Recommendations
This paper has attempted to assess the magnitude of the
human cost of the war by probing into various aspects where
victims fall due to war and war impacts. Victims could be lost
lives, missing people, abducted child/soldiers, HIV/AIDs patients
and others. These are only examples indicative of the evils of
wars on humanity. This paper strongly holds the belief that this
human price is really very high to be paid in exchange for
conflicts of uncertain results between parties sharing a number
19
of commonalties.
Since the start of the war between North and South, figures of
all types of victims were on constant rise. The battle field was
southern Sudan, and neighboring northern Uganda, another area
full of, violence, unrest, and of dissatisfaction against central
authority. The two areas soon developed similarities, both areas
comprise close ethnic groups, while SPLA war was launched from
Southern Sudan, National Resistance Army (N.R.A.) war is
launched from N. Uganda. SPLA was using Ugandan land and
facilities, (N.R.A.). is currently using Sudanese land with or
without the consent of government of Sudan, very few could known.
Therefore bilateral relations between the two countries were
never warm or friendly, SPLA and L.R.A. shared the inhuman
experience of child abduction for military recruitment proposes.
The analysis in this paper, involved a series of interviews,
contacts, scrutiny of reports, in pursuit of quantifiable
atrocities of this conflict in terms of what we called impacts of
the war. But each individual impact produces another in a
multiplier – effect like mechanism. Lost lives mean more orphans
and widows means distorted social fabric, means poverty,
illiteracy prevalence of war ethics. Physical disability means
psychological imbalance, social burden, and idleness. More
20
orphans mean more street boys more Juvenile delinquents Displaced
camps and settlements means acute economic disparities between
social strata, more means security requirements. These circles
are endless (impacts) destructive elements of human life, social
fabric, and value – systems of affected societies of both warring
parties however they are. The cynical fact is that war is
decided by politicians to be carried – out by soldiers to be
ultimately suffered by civilian tax – payers who usually
innocently pay the bill of that war.
Displacement somewhere means food shortage somewhere else, in
other words wars and armed conflicts result in lack of security
necessary for farmers to grow their food products. In our case
southern Sudan is a place of scarce food supplies since long time
before, obviously because of the war. It was clear that since
1986 Sudan was party to Operation Lifeline Sudan (together with
U.N. and SPLM/SPLA) a tripartite treaty launched by international
organization on humanitarian basis, extending all sorts of
supplies for war-affected population in the South and other
places where displaced are found.
If ever this paper offers as a recommendation, will be to conduct
more research on the effects of armed conflict on children,
particularly in the Sudan, where children make up to 45% of the
population on the one hand, on the other conflict in the Sudan
seems to be a never-ending phenomena. Consequently we shall have
21
the challenge of exerting more effort to understand the impact of
that in the long run.
Endnotes and References
1 UNFP, State of World’s Children 2000, p 75.2 UNFPA, State of World’s Children 1990.
3 Faiz Jamie, “The Impact of the Civil War on Population Mobility and Character”, Ph.D Thesis, University of Juba,2003.
4 UNFPA, State of World’s Children, 2000.
5 Ibid.
6 Report by the National Council for the Welfare of Children 1996.
7 Dr. Mahmoud Ushari is among Sudanese scholars who made in his writings indications to slavery in the1980s.
8 Africa Confidential Issue Dec. 1998.
9 "HIV/AIDA Epidemic and Trafficking", paper presented by Dr. Warren Naamara to the International Migration Policy Conference, Kenya, May 2002.