Brand Audit on Buddha Air Submitted by
Transcript of Brand Audit on Buddha Air Submitted by
Submitted by:
Amrita Acharya
Kanta Subedi
Kripa Shakya
Nischal K.C.
Prakash Bhusal
Brand Audit on Buddha Air
MBA, TERM 5
Ace Institute of Management
Acknowledgement
This report has been prepared with the view to accomplish the
brand audit of Buddha Air. This kind of work provides us an
opportunity to have practical experience on collecting,
processing, analyzing information and draw some conclusion on a
particular topic.
First and foremost we would like to express our sincere gratitude
to Mr. Sujan Raja Shrestha for giving us this opportunity to
carry on such a useful project.
Our sincere gratitude goes to all the staffs at Buddha Air office
who helped us in giving the information. Also, we would like to
thank all those who cooperated with us to answer some of our
queries without which the project would be incomplete.
A special thanks goes to passengers of different airlines, who
patiently filled the questionnaire.
Finally, we would like to thank all our friends and other
individuals who had supported us directly and indirectly
throughout the project with their valuable suggestions and
guidance.
Executive Summary
After exercise and survey, we have been able to produce this
audit of one of the best airline of the country, Buddha Air.
Through this report, we got a good opportunity to know how the
airline companies such as Buddha, Yeti, Agni has able to create
itself as a brand and what are the basic elements they are
focusing so as to help in creating a strong brand in the market.
The number of respondents who helped us during this research is
30 who shared their valuable information with us. Some of major
findings from this research are:
Passengers preferred Buddha Air in comparison to other
airlines
Buddha Air is also considered as the safest domestic airline
of the country.
Top of the mind brand recall of Buddha Air is high. This
means that whenever, people think of domestic airline
company, Buddha Air is the first name to come up.
The passengers are not satisfied with the service provided
by Buddha Air.
Buddha Air had various promotional programmes and also
provides sponsorship.
The brand’s future looks promising and has a huge potential in
the Nepalese market. What is left to be seen is how it carefully
handles its customer’s sentiments and requirements in the future.
More innovative ways of marketing and improving their service to
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 History of airline industry in Nepal
The airline industry in Nepal started with Nepal
Airlines (formerly known as Royal Nepal Airlines) which is the
flag carrier of Nepal in July, 1958. Indian Airlines ruled the
Nepalese sky prior to this date .Royal Nepal took over the
international schedules in 1960. In the year 1996, the
services were extended to China and Japan. The international
destinations of Nepal Airlines includes cities in various
countries such as Bangkok, Mumbai, Calcutta, Delhi, Dubai,
Frankfurt, Hong Kong, London, Osaka, Shanghai and Singapore.
1.2 Domestic airline industry in Nepal
There are more than 10 domestic flight carriers operating
scheduled flights to almost 44 districts of the Kingdom. Today
it is possible to reach to most of the tourist destinations in
Nepal, from the remote airfields to major hub cities by air
and this facility has greatly enhanced the tourism industry.
When the government of Nepal adopted an open sky policy
allowing the private airlines to step in the domestic air
service front, tourism sector was positively affected.
The following is the list of domestic airlines operating in
Nepal:
Air Dynasty
Agni Air
Buddha Air
Fishtail Air
Guna Air
Manang Air
Nepal Airlines
Shangri-la Air
Shree Airline
Simrik Airline
Sita Airlines
Tara Air
Yeti Airlines
1.3 Industry Analysis of the Aviation Industry in Nepal
Industry analysis deals with those environmental variables
that have the capacity to influence the organization at
present as well as the performance of other players in the
industry. The important players in the industry are market,
customers, and competitors. Suppliers and other stakeholders
determine the success or failure of the company in the airline
industry.
Threat of New Entrants (high, medium or low)
New entrants to an industry typically bring to it new
capacity, a desire to gain market share, and a substantial
resources. They are, therefore, threats to an established
company. Buddha Air, as such, is one of the established
companies in the domestic airline industry in our country.
There are different factors influencing the other companies to
enter the market:
• Capital requirements: The capital requirement for a new
entrant in aviation industry is huge. There has been a policy
that aircrafts cannot be purchased in lease and the new
operating airlines have to fully purchase the aircrafts.
Therefore it would be difficult for the new comer to enter the
scene.
• Technical expertise: Any aircraft needs highly skilled
manpower that is pilots or the engineers needed for both
operations and maintenance. The demand of the skilled manpower
in market is more than the supply. In fact, the existing
companies are competing amongst themselves to recruit them.
• Government Policy: the airlines industry is controlled by
the Civil Aviation that sets norms and regulations for the
industry. This creates difficulty for the new entrants in the
industry.
Rivalry among existing firms
In most industries, corporations are mutually dependent. A
competitive move by one firm can be expected to have a
noticeable effect on its competitors and thus may cause
retaliation or counter efforts. In case of airline industry,
competition is aggressive due to which price reduction or new
product introduction is quickly imitated by other
participants. The same condition prevails in Nepalese domestic
airline industry. In Nepal, sky is in equal share ruled by
many rival airlines. This leads to:
• Number of competitors: When an industry involves aggressive
number of participants, there is constant watch on each
other's move, and make sure that they match the move by an
equal performance. In Nepal domestic airlines industry, as
mentioned earlier has many players which results in intense
competition. Each of these airlines has come up with different
schemes and service facilities for the ultimate customers with
intensive promotion campaign as well.
• Rate of industry growth: The airlines industry is growing at
faster pace, which is causing threat as well as opportunities
to the participants. The companies that can recognize these
problems and exploit these as opportunities win the game and
those companies which fail to do so are back in the line.
• Diversity of rivals: the presence of scores of number of
rivals in one way forces the players to come up with diverse
ideas to be a challenge and/or hold a strong position in the
industry. There is one prevailing example about Yeti Airlines
which is coming up with innovative promotions to attract
customers. The innovative taglines in the commercials in print
ads or TVC creates a sense of security in the minds of
passengers unlike other major player Buddha Air. This is a
threat to such an established Airline.
Threat of Substitutes
Substitute limits the potential returns of an industry by
placing a ceiling on the prices firms in the industry can
profitably charge. Thus, substitutes may have strong effect on
an industry.
The transportation industry has many substitutes in itself;
road transport is a main substitute to airlines industry.
Bargaining power of buyers
Buyers affect an industry through their ability to force down
prices, bargain for higher quality or more services and thus
play competitors against each other. Buyers hold a strong
position if:
• Suppliers are plentiful
• Cost of switching suppliers is low.
In Nepalese context, though the number of suppliers is not too
many, the cost of switching is very little. Therefore, the
number of loyal customers is low.
Bargaining power of suppliers
When the fuel prices increase, the airline company has no
choice except increasing the surcharge for tickets issued.
1.4 Introduction to company
Buddha Air Pvt. Ltd is a privately operated air travel company
founded on 23 April 1996 and registered as a private limited
company at the Company Registrar Office of the Ministry of
Industry, Government of Nepal, under the Company Act, 2021 BS of
Nepal. The company headquarter is located at Jawalakhel, Lalitpur
while there are two city sales offices in the most convenient
locations within the Kathmandu Valley.
After 12 years of dedicated non-stop service, more than 100,000
flight hours logged in with over 3 million passengers flown to
nine destinations with permanent runways in the country, Buddha
Air today is the largest domestic air travel operator in Nepal
employing more than 500 experienced professionals. The company
has the largest fleet of the world’s best aircrafts amongst all
domestic airliners in operation with four 18 seat Beechcraft-1900
D, three 47 seat ATR-42 and one 72 seat ATR 72-500 flying out to
all the trunk routes with a minimum of 1200 m of permanent
runway. It is the company’s policy to place safety at the highest
priority.
Buddha Air’s safety record and reliability has earned us a host
of awards including the Highest Safety Award given by the
Ministry of Tourism and Civil Aviation of the Government of Nepal
as well as a list of the most esteemed clientele in Nepal
including most United Nations organizations, all major diplomatic
missions, international non government organizations as well as
national level organizations.
Buddha Air prides itself in maintaining an absolutely clean and
transparent financial accounting which is one of the reasons why
the company has gained the trust of some of Nepal’s major banks
as well as international institutions like the International
Finance Corporation/World Bank (IFC/WB), General Insurance of
India. Starting with an authorized capital of NRS 70 million the
company cleared its loan of NRS 71 million within 6 years of
establishment. On 27 September 2004, the Ministry of Culture,
Tourism, and Civil Aviation honored Buddha Air for being the
first among private sector airlines in foreign exchange earnings
during the fiscal year 060/061. The company’s good governance
practices earned the confidence of the International Finance
Corporation/World Bank who provided a loan of USD 10 million for
the purchase of the latest addition in Buddha Air’s fleet, the
ATR 42.
Buddha Air places great emphasis on safety and as well as
operating new modern equipment , each aircraft is fully equipped
with navigational aid equipment and flights are only operated in
airports with asphalt runway of not less than 4000 feet length.
The maintenance and engineering department has a fully trained
work force including 45 cockpit crew, 5 flight operation
officers, 18 qualified engineers and 31 technicians. We maintain
an inventory of aircraft and engine spares replacing any part
that doesn’t pass our tests regardless of whether it is new or
old with absolutely new parts. Buddha Air has also successfully
completed a Cooperative Development of Operational Safety and
Continuing Airworthiness Project – South Asia audit as a an
ardent follower of the manufacturers and industry standard in the
performance of our flight operations maintenance and safety &
procedures. Buddha Air has renewed its aviation insurance for the
12th consecutive year with zero claims, something no other
airliner in Nepal has done.
CHAPTER TWO
COMPETITORS ANALYSIS2.1 Dealing with Competition
It would seem a simple task for a company to identify its
competitors but the range of company's actual and potential
competitors is actually much broader. A company is more likely
to be hurt by emerging competitors or new technologies than by
current competitors.
The scenario is a bit different in case of Buddha Air. The
country market being limited, there are lesser chances for the
new entrants to succeed with respect to penetrate as well as
to capture the market. Therefore, the company faces lesser
threat from these newer companies.
Though there is large number of competitors, the major ones
comprise of Yeti Airlines and Agni Air. Furthermore, each of
these airlines has its own set of target customers. Buddha Air
as such focuses on the executives, whereas the others focus on
the middle-class passengers.
Their business strategies differ accordingly. Buddha Air
follows the leadership strategy; it is the market leader
determining the price and other airlines following its pricing
strategy. Buddha Air, having it own segment of customers, does
not give much emphasis on the price changes, rather continues
to provide better service. As such Buddha seems to be
following defensive and other airlines following the offensive
strategy to cover a large market share.
2.2 SWOT ANALYSIS
Strengths
• Innovation: Buddha air introduced the first e-ticketing in a
move to catch up with the pace of time. In 2002, Buddha air
launched its frequent flyer program , the Royal Club , which
rewards passengers with mileage points every time to fly which
can be redeemed for free tickets, holiday packages or
shopping. Buddha Air is the first to introduce this program in
the country. All these factors add benefit to the airlines and
make it the most appreciable airlines over other airlines.
• Differentiation: Buddha Air always keeps itself up-to-date
in the industry and introduce diverse types of strategies with
the new era of comfort and luxury, which has helped to
dominate in the market for a long time. Innovation on
different sectors within airline industry has given them
supremacy over other airlines'. As Buddha Air quotes “As
flight safety is our top priority, pilots and engineers are
frequently sent abroad for refresher training”, this airlines
places its highest priority on the safety of its flights and
that's the reason why they have no record of aviation
insurance claim since the airline was launched in 1997. To
keep the flights safe, the engineers inspect each aircraft
thoroughly everyday as per the Standard Operating Procedure,
Nepalese Civil Airworthiness Requirement and the Aircraft
Operators Maintenance Manuals. Buddha Air is the only private
flight operator in Nepal to install the Aircraft Data
Acquisition System (ADAS) device in all its aircrafts in
addition to the Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR) and the Flight
Data Recorder (FDR). Innovation on different sectors within
airline industry has given them supremacy over other
airlines'.
• Brand Image: Buddha Air's Beechcraft and ATRs are unique in
Nepalese airlines industry. Its main favorability comes from
the record of no accident since its establishment in 1997. The
highly recognized comfort focus by the introduction of bigger
aircrafts also adds benefit to the company in building its
brand image among the customers.
• Youngest Fleet: Buddha Air has maintained the youngest fleet
of aircraft of all the major aircrafts.
Weaknesses
• Buddha Air's aircrafts require 1000 meters runway. This
limits its access to STOL market (Remote areas) where runways
are shorter.
• The mileage card Buddha Air offers is not appropriate with
the business clients.
Opportunities
• Technology: The rapidly changing technology always provides
opportunities to adopt new technology and implement them to
improve customer experience.
• Formation of Alliance: The alliance with international
airlines will prove beneficial for Buddha Air as it provides
opportunity to work with other friendly airlines and would
enable them to reach to other different destinations around
the globe.
Threats
• Increase competition: There has been increase in the number
of competitor in the domestic airlines in Nepal. These
competitors are the cheaper airlines that provide similar kind
of services at lower rate which makes the travelers interested
in the competitors' facilities as Buddha Air being relatively
expensive Airlines.
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
We conducted both qualitative and quantitative research and we
used inferential analysis statistical tool to analyze the
results.
We went to the head office of Buddha Air at Jawalakhel, Lalitpur
and conducted the informal focus group discussion with the staffs
at the Buddha Air to get information
Then, we went to Tribhuwan International Airport in domestic
flight sector to fill the questionnaires. We chose 30 samples for
the survey regarding the brand audit of the Buddha Air.
CHAPTER FOUR
FINDINGS AND DISCUSSIONS
4.1 Findings of Focused Group Discussion (FGD)
To know about the customers' perception about Buddha Air and
Domestic Airlines in general, we decided to conduct a research at
the domestic airport targeting the domestic airlines passengers.
First, a focus group discussion was conducted at the airport
lounge restaurant where the participants were the passengers who
were waiting for their flights. From the focus group discussion,
we got the key elements behind the success of domestic airlines
and the issues relating to them. The FGD went on for 30 minutes.
Most of the participants agreed that Buddha Air was their first
preference over other flights. The main factors for any
passengers to choose any airlines were first and foremost the
comfort factor; safety, time, fare, service, schemes of the
airlines and promotion beings the other factors.
4.2 Brand Associations of Buddha Air
• Favorability – Buddha Air's main favorability come from its
safety record in the last 13 years of operation.
• Strength – Its strength lies in their policy of only buying
high quality new aircrafts, its own brand image, motivated and
well trained staff & quotes. As flight safety is our top
priority, pilots and engineers are frequently sent abroad for
refresher training& quotes;
• Uniqueness – Its aircrafts from Beechcraft and ATR are unique
in the Domestic Airlines industry of Nepal. People recognize this
fact and it is the major reason behind the safety image of Buddha
Air.
4.3 Brand equity
Buddha Air Pvt. Ltd. is the largest domestic air travel operator
in Nepal established on 10th November 1997 as a Domestic Flight
Operator.
A variety of brand elements can be chosen that inherently enhance
brand awareness or facilitate the formation of strong, favorable,
and unique brand associations. Buddha Air is in the top of mind
of the consumers when spelled about any domestic airlines.
The logo is one aspect of a company's commercial brand, and its
shapes, colors, fonts, and images usually are different from
others in a similar market. The logo of Buddha Air which shows
dove symbolizing peace implied as well as by its name i.e.
Buddha. The logo is memorable. People can recognize the brand
when the picture of two doves is shown; moreover the logo can be
easily recalled. The message it wants to portray through its logo
is meaningful. Nepal is popular as a birthplace of Buddha and
famous in the world as a peaceful country. The name and the logo
signify it. The logo and the name has been registered under
Nepal's Company Act, hence cannot be misused by others.
The airlines flew its 19 seat Beechcraft-1900 in 12 destinations
with a total number of 5 aircraft. Earlier, it focused on flight
speed with Beechcraft aircrafts and moved on to ATR's aircrafts
focusing on space and comfort. Now, the airlines owns 3, 47 seat
ATR-42-320 and 1, 70 seat ATR-72-500. It initiated its
international operation recently on August, the instigating
destination being Paro in Bhutan. It further plans for expansion
in India and China. The company has a policy to buy only brand
new aircrafts and the other main reason that the consumers admire
this brand is its safety record and reliability. The reasons for
preferring Buddha Air among others are:
Schedule time
Flight speed
Comfort
Less noise
13 years history of no accidents(1 accident recently)
Brand Equity of Buddha Air has been developed through combination
of its Brand awareness and Brand Image. It has been known as the
largest domestic air travel operator. The company has been
operating new modern equipment with navigational aid
equipment .The first and foremost priority of the airlines has
been passenger safety and the best service. The records have been
a proof for its timely scheduled flights.
The company has targeted corporate houses as its main target and
it has succeeded to attract customers from those segments. It has
strong Relation with Business House; most esteemed clientele in
Nepal including most United Nations organizations, all major
diplomatic missions, international non government organizations
as well as national level organizations.
4.4 Brand Image
We asked the people about which was the first name that comes to
their mind when talking about domestic airlines and this was
their top of the mind Flight. Their responses were as follows:
Brand Recall
AirlinesNo of
RespondentsPercentage
Buddha 21 70%Yeti 4 13%Agni 2 7%Others 3 10%Total 30 100%
4.5 Buddha Air Leveraging Primary Brand Knowledge to Build its
Brand Equity
The criteria that we selected for evaluating the domestics
airlines are time, safety, fare, service, comfort and Promotions.
Time:
Out of total 30 respondents, 37% responded with Buddha Air; 33%
responded with Yeti and 30% responded with Agni in terms of
timely flight. Thus, Buddha Air’s flights are on time.
Safety:
Out of total 30 respondents, 47% responded with Buddha Air; 40%
responded with Yeti and 17% responded with Agni in terms of
safety. Thus, the safer airlines was Buddha.
Fare:
Out of total 30 respondents, 27% responded with Buddha Air; 33%
responded with Yeti and 40% responded with Agni in terms of
ticket price. Thus, Buddha Air was perceived relatively
satisfactory in comparison to other airlines.
Service:
Out of total 30 respondents, 30% responded with Buddha Air; 37%
responded with Yeti and 33% responded with Agni in terms of
service. Thus, the passengers were not satisfied with the service
provided by Buddha Air.
Comfort:
Out of total 30 respondents, 37% responded with Buddha Air; 33%
responded with Yeti and 30% responded with Agni in terms of
comfort. Thus, respondents considered Buddha Air as comfortable
airlines.
Promotion:
Out of total 30 respondents, 37% responded with Buddha Air; 37%
responded with Yeti and 27% responded with Agni in terms of
promotion. Thus, passengers found both Buddha and Yeti Air as
visible airlines in terms of promotion.
4.6 Promotional programmes:
More specifically, promotion is the element in an organization’s
marketing mix that serves to inform, persuade, and remind the
market of a product and or the organization selling it, in hopes
of influencing the recipient’s feelings, belief, or behavior. The
other forms of marketing mix activities of product planning,
pricing, and distributing are performed mainly within a business
or between a business and the members of its distribution
channels. However, through its promotional activities, a firm
communicates directly with potential customers. Promotion serves
three essential roles –it informs, persuades, and reminds
prospective customers about a company and its projects. The most
useful product or service will be a failure if no one knows it is
available.
Promotional strategies are mainly handled by the marketing
department of an organization. As part of the function, marketing
department designs promotional programs on the basis of allocated
budget for the fiscal year. It comprises of personal selling,
advertising, sales promotion, public relations and publicity.
Today there is so much competition around the local market and
international market that has forced companies to adopt efficient
and effective promotional strategies. Because of massive
competition, the product and services are similar and
homogeneous. So, with the help of promotional activities, the
consumers can be attracted resulting high volume of sales.
Buddha Air started its operations with just one brand new Beech
1900D aircraft worth US$ 5 million since October 1997. At present
it is operating with four brand new Beech 1900Dsand two
Beech1900C. In a market where other airlines are operating
aircraft 10 years or older aircraft, Buddha airline is the only
domestic airlines to operate brand new pressurized aircraft. It
has been operating service in ten different sectors in the
country.
Buddha airline has established its own Airline Management
Information System. It is the first company in Nepal to go
paperless and totally into computer software system. This has
provided a major edge regarding prompt decision making.
Buddha airline is named as marketing company. It applies both
push and pulls strategy. For the promotion of the company, it
participates and works jointly with the world class travel agency
of the country and outside the country. It helps foreigner to get
the opportunities to know about the BA and thus it is able to
attract such customer. BA does not believe in short term
promotion thus it has not such any promotional campaign. It
advertises about its service in various Medias like newspapers,
journals and through its own broachers. More over for promotion
it gives the information about mountain flight in various
languages like English, Francis, Espanol, Deutsch, Italia no,
Japanese and Thai so that people from different country can
easily understand. The most effective promotional campaign of the
company is Royal club.
Royal club is the frequent flyer program of Buddha air and
totally free. The program rewards passengers with mileage points
every time they fly BA. The more they fly the more miles they
will accumulate. Once they gather enough miles they will be
promoted to Platinum status where they have the option of many
benefits, they can fly free to qualifying destination, even go on
holidays to exclusive resorts and Hotels, or even go for
shopping.
In India:
Budhha air participated in a three-day Border Promotion Sales
Mission in India organised by Nepal
Tourism Board in Lucknow on 10 May, in Kanpur on 11 May and in
Varanasi on 13 May. Travel partners and journalists attended the
program. The events were covered by most of the newpapers. From
Buddha Air, Uddav Subedi, Lucknow Station and Bibash Thapa,
Officer-Marketing, represented the airline in the events. During
the events, the travel partners in these three cities were keen
to promote Nepal as a tourist destination.Buddha Air is planning
to operate direct flights between Kathmandu and Varanasi in the
near future. Hence the airline disseminated information regarding
the operations among the travel partners and journalists.
Partnership between the Alliance Française in Kathmandu and
Buddha Air
On the last April 24 has been signed a sponsorship between Buddha
Air and the Alliance Française in Kathmandu, by Mr. Birendra
Basnet, General Manager of Buddha Air, and Mr. Keshav Raj Jha,
President of the Alliance Française, in the presence of His
Excellency Gilles-Henri Garault, French Ambassador to Nepal.
This sponsorship is mainly about an annual financial support of
Buddha Air to the Alliance, which gives in return its image and
notoriety for the promotion of the company towards French and
French speaking networks of Nepal.
4.7 CBBE MODEL
4.8 Buddha Air Leveraging Secondary Brand Knowledge to Build its
Brand Equity
Secondary associations of Buddha Air are as follows:
Channels of distribution
Selling Buddha Air tickets through large and established
travel agents has added on to the image of Buddha air
Company of aircrafts
Beechcraft 1900D manufactured by Raytheon Aircraft (now
Hawker Beechcraft), and ATR 42 and ATR 72-500 manufactured
by Alenia Aeronotica (France)
Corporate Sponsorship –
In 2000 Buddha Air started an agricultural extension program
as a pilot project in Morang district
Buddha Air funded the seed money to start Smallholder
Agribusiness Support (SABS)
Buddha Air donates over Rs. 1.5 million to Dangihat VDC of
Morang district every year for health and education from
2010.
Buddha Air conducted a one day health camp in the Dangihat
VDC of Morang for 1200 people.
Third party sources – award
Highest Safety Award given by the Ministry of Tourism and
Civil Aviation of the Government of Nepal
Ministry of Culture, Tourism, and Civil Aviation honored
Buddha Air for being the first among private sector airlines
in foreign exchange earnings during the fiscal year 060/061
It has also been awarded from various sources such as
Pacific Asia Travel Association, United Nations World
Tourism Day, 3rd World Aviation, Education and Safety
Congress, and Pratt & Whitney, Canada Corporation.
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
• We recommend that Buddha Air to increase its brand awareness
and build a strong position in the consumer mindset should place
its booth inside the waiting hall.
• Buddha Air should arrange refreshment such as newspaper,
magazines, vending machine that would provide tea, coffee, and
cold drink in case of delay in flights over an hour.
• If Buddha wants to further expand itself domestically with its
present fleet of airlines it may not be possible. So, we would
recommend Buddha to add on newer aircrafts which could even
travel to stall routes and shorter runways. Here, Buddha to
extend its brand further can used the multi branding strategy
which has already been followed by Yeti Airlines by introduction
of Tara Air.
• The magazine published by Buddha Air i.e. Yatra should be
published in Nepali language as well.
• Lastly, Buddha Air should make the customer service form
available both in Nepali and English languages so that it can be
understood by the Nepalese mass and distribute it during the
flight time.