Feasibility Study MAU

download Feasibility Study MAU

of 40

Transcript of Feasibility Study MAU

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    1/40

    1

    Feasibility Study for a Medical

    Assessment Unit Service inMonaghan Hospital

    January 2012

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    2/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    2

    Contents

    Glossary .........................................................................................................................3

    1. Executive Summary................................................................................................5

    1.1. Major Issues Identified.........................................................................................51.2. Limitations of the Study .......................................................................................5

    2. Background.............................................................................................................63. Terms of Reference ................................................................................................74. Project Deliverable .................................................................................................7

    5. Process....................................................................................................................76. Methodology ...........................................................................................................7

    6.1 Limitations of Methodology..................................................................................7

    7. Medical Assessment Units.....................................................................................87.1 Acute Medical Assessment Units.........................................................................87.2 Medical Assessment Units...................................................................................8

    8. Description of Current Services ............................................................................88.1 Gap Analysis .......................................................................................................89. Establishing a Clinical Need ................................................................................ 10

    9.1 Advantages of an MAU in Monaghan ................................................................11

    9.2 Disadvantages of an MAU in Monaghan............................................................119.3 Major Issues Identified .......................................................................................11

    10. Resource Requirement ........................................................................................1111. Discussion ............................................................................................................12

    12. Conclusions ..........................................................................................................1213. References ............................................................................................................1314. Appendices ...........................................................................................................14

    Appendix 1 Team Membership.............................................................................14

    Appendix 2 Gap Analysis Monaghan Hospital.................................................... 15Appendix 2a Gap Analysis Monaghan Hospital Vs Model 2 Hospital............................15

    Appendix 2b Gap Analysis Monaghan Hospital Vs the Model 2 Hospital(National Acute Medicine Programme) Interdependencieswith other Clinical Programmes ...............................................................21

    Appendix 2c Gap Analysis Monaghan Hospital Vs Model 1 Hospital............................ 24

    Appendix 2d Gap Analysis Monaghan Hospital Vs the Model 1 Hospital(National Acute Medicine Programme) Interdependencieswith other Clinical Programmes ...............................................................29

    Appendix 3 Activity Statistics................................................................................ 32Appendix 3a Cavan & Monaghan Hospital Yearly Stats 2008-2011 .............................32

    Appendix 3b Cavan Hospital MAU Stats 2009-2011 ....................................................34Appendix 3c Cavan ED Figures 2008-2011 ................................................................. 35

    Appendix 3d Cavan ED Triage Figures 2008-2011 ...................................................... 36Appendix 3e Minor Injury Unit, Monaghan Hospital Figures 2009-2011 ....................... 37Appendix 3f Cavan Hospital OPD Waiting Time for OPD Appointments...................... 38Appendix 3g Drogheda Stats........................................................................................ 39

    Appendix 4 Resource Requirements ....................................................................40

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    3/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    3

    GlossaryThe following definitions were obtained from the Report of the National Acute MedicineProgramme1, 2010 and are key to understanding the principles underlying this report.

    An acute medical unit (AMU) is a facility whose primary function is the immediate

    and early specialist management of adult patients (i.e. aged 16 and older) with awide range of medical conditions who present to a model 4 (tertiary) hospital. Itsaim is to provide a dedicated location for the rapid assessment, diagnosis and

    commencement of appropriate treatment. Physicians, supported by amultidisciplinary team, will carry out patient assessment and treatment. It isenvisaged that AMUs will operate on a 24/7 basis. The AMU should be co-locatedwith the ED. Every AMU should have a designated lead consultant physician,

    clinical nurse manager and therapy lead. If required, patients can be admitted tothe short stay medical beds within the unit for a short period for acute treatmentand/or observation where the estimated length of stay is less than 48 hours.

    An acute medical assessment unit (AMAU) will operate as an AMU with thefollowing exceptions: It will be located in a model 3 (general) hospital; the hours of

    operation may vary from 12 to 24 hours, 7 days per week, depending on serviceneed; and it will not have contiguous short stay medical beds.

    The AMU/AMAU lead physician is a consultant physician with a special interest inacute medicine who has overall responsibility for the effective management of the

    AMU/AMAU.

    A medical assessment unit (MAU). A medical assessment unit (MAU) in a model2 (local) hospital will manage GP referred, differentiated medical patients who

    have a low risk of requiring full resuscitation. Only patients referred by a GP willbe seen. This unit will have assessment beds in a defined area and serve a

    clinical decision support function. Admissions will be to in-patient beds in amodel 2 hospital. Patients who deteriorate unexpectedly will have guaranteedtransfer to a model 3 or model 4 hospitals. GPs will refer low-risk medical patient(i.e. unlikely to require high intensity cardiopulmonary and/or neurologicalsupport) for assessment in the MAU during daytime hours. Patients with a

    significant risk of clinical deterioration should be referred to the associated model3 or 4 hospital. However, patients should not be transferred if a Do NotResuscitate order is made and/or if patients make an informed decision toremain in the model 2 hospital.

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    4/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    4

    A decision regarding discharge/admission should be made within 6 hours and willbe facilitated by dedicated radiology, laboratory and other services, includingnursing, therapy professionals and medical social workers. In the event of

    discharge, the relevant GP will be informed (on the same day) of the decisiontogether with all relevant clinical details and care plans. Every MAU should have

    a designated lead consultant physician, who will be jointly appointed to the model2 and associated model 3 or 4 hospital, a designated clinical nurse manager and

    assigned therapy resource. MAUs may be operational from 8am to 8pm, 7 daysper week.

    The models of hospitals involve 4 levels of acute hospitals in relation to acutemedicine patients, as proposed by the national clinical programmes. Themodels are: model 4 - tertiary hospital; model 3 - general hospital; model 2 -

    local with selected (GP-referred) medical patients; and model 1 -community/district.

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    5/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    5

    1. Executive SummaryThe delivery of safe, quality care in a timely manner and in the appropriate setting hasbeen identified as the aim of the National Acute Medicine Programme1. The programme

    provides a framework for the delivery of acute medical services which seeks tosubstantially improve patient care. It also clarifies the structures and processes of

    hospitals and acute medical care provided therein.

    The Cavan/Monaghan hospital network currently provides services to the population ofboth counties. Acute medical services are based in Cavan General Hospital including anew Acute Medical Assessment Unit ( AMAU) which opened in 2009. Step down andrehabilitation services are based in Monaghan hospital and also some outpatientservices. Both services are complementary and provide a wide range of patient care.

    Patients also have an option of accessing services in other hospitals in Drogheda,Navan or outside the region.

    A Medical Assessment Unit (MAU) in Monaghan would provide services to a limited

    number of patients who fulfilled certain criteria and would be low risk, GP referredpatients. From a local perspective it would be a welcome and convenient developmenthowever on current evidence this development is not feasible. To provide the necessarystructures and staffing would entail a significant cost and the volume of patients

    anticipated would be unlikely to warrant such expenditure. It could not be developed atpresent within current resources.

    1.1. Major Issues Identified

    Monaghan is not a model 2 hospital (c.f. Appendix 2) and as such does notcurrently have many of the requirements for setting up an MAU

    Does not currently have medical personnel on site apart from sessional out

    patients (OPD) therefore patient safety would be a major concern Does not have laboratory on site so samples must be transported to Cavan

    Does not have access to a wide range of emergency diagnostics

    Does not currently have sufficient medical, professional and administrative staffavailable to staff MAU

    Has no facility to admit patients from an MAU

    Extra resources to develop an MAU would be needed

    Patient safety must remain a major consideration

    1.2. Limitations of the Study

    This study was carried out within a very short time frame which limited the time

    for discussion and data collection Data available was limited and it was agreed that prospective collection of data

    would have provided more accurate information

    All definitions used were from the National Acute Services Programme which is aclear and concise document. The degree of flexibility in relation to theinterpretation of this document was the subject of much debate in the group. Inthe end the majority agreed to adhere to the written document but there was a

    view that this interpretation was excessively rigid.

    Costs could not be clearly defined as the size and scope of the proposed unitwas not agreed. As a guide the costings for the AMAU in Cavan are included toillustrate the cost of setting up a unit in a hospital which already has many of the

    basic requirements.

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    6/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    6

    2. BackgroundThe development of Medical Assessment Units in acute hospitals has been a recentsuccessful initiative. It greatly improves the timeliness of treatment for medical patients

    and streamlines the admission process. Instead of being referred to EmergencyDepartments (ED) medical patients are admitted to assessment units where they are

    seen by a senior clinician and have rapid access to appropriate diagnostics. They arethen discharged home, admitted to the hospital for further treatment or transferred to a

    more specialised unit.

    Table 1 Comparison of Acute Medical Services

    Acute Hospital

    in Patient

    ED OPD AMAU/MAU

    Testing Over days Triage

    Inpatient

    Treatment

    Discharge

    On attendance On attendance

    Evaluation of results Days Same day if

    performed

    Next or other

    visit

    Day of visit

    Reporting back Days, week s or months

    Same day Weeks tomonths

    Day of visit

    Timeliness Depends on

    bed availability

    Same day Weeks to

    months

    Same or next

    day

    Duration of stay Days Hours-depends ontriage

    Hours Hours

    Level of competency

    of assessor

    Intern to

    Consultant

    ED SHO+/- Reg

    Med SHO+/-Reg

    Intern to

    Consultant

    Consultant

    In 2009 an Acute Medical Assessment Unit (AMAU) was commissioned for patients inthe Cavan/Monaghan hospital network and was based in Cavan General Hospital.Monaghan hospitals role changed to provide rehabilitation, step down beds and out

    patient services.

    A request from Minister Reilly, Minister of Health, was made to the Regional Director ofOperations, Dublin North East, to establish a representative group to undertake anindependent feasibility study of the development of a Medical Assessment Unit (MAU) atMonaghan Hospital. The terms of reference for this group are outlined below:

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    7/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    7

    3. Terms of Reference of the Committee Establish a schedule of meetings to enable the collation of data and analysis of

    the health demographic of the Monaghan population pertaining to acute

    medical service needs. Evaluate current acute service provision and access to Acute Medical Services

    to the Monaghan population as part of the Cavan & Monaghan Service Area. Establish if there is a clinical need for an MAU in Monaghan Hospital

    Provide a detailed analysis of the pay and non pay costs and support servicesassociated with provision of an MAU Service in Monaghan Hospital.

    The meeting quorum is 4 People Provide the Hospital Group General Manager with a report outlining the

    feasibility or not of a Medical Assessment Unit on the Monaghan Hospital site.

    Deliver the report in a timely fashion 6 weeks from commencement tocompletion.

    4. Project Deliverables

    This Group will complete an independent feasibility study; To establish if a there is a clinical need for a Medical Assessment Unit in

    Monaghan Hospital for the Monaghan population.

    To establish the pay and non pay costs and internal/external support servicesassociated with the establishment and running of a MAU in Monaghan.

    The project will demonstrate evidence of the local health demographic and local healthdata of the Monaghan population relevant to medical assessment unit services.

    5. ProcessThe process commenced on 17th October 2011 and consisted of six meetings held in

    Monaghan hospital. Activity data was collated by Mr. G. Clerkin, Risk Advisor.

    6. MethodologyThe methodology employed was as follows:

    Agree terms of reference Define Medical Assessment Unit Evaluate the resources available in Monaghan

    Compare resources to standards outlined by Acute Medicine Programme Identify deficiencies Determine resources required

    6.1 Limitations of Methodology Time constraints-project timeframe was 6 weeks Lack of data in relation to current use of services

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    8/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    8

    7. Medical Assessment UnitsIn an attempt to provide standardisation nationally, the National Acute MedicineProgramme Report 20111 defined what was necessary for the setting up and optimal

    working of an MAU. (For a full description please see the Glossary)This document hasbeen accepted as the blueprint for the development of acute hospital services in Ireland.

    While we accept there are deviations from this model the majority of the group decidedto accept the definition as laid down in the document (Dr Duffy did not agree with this

    decision)

    7.1 Acute Medical Assessment Unit (AMAU)1

    This unit which is based in a model 3 hospital manages all adult patients who presentwith a wide range of medical conditions. Its aim is to provide a dedicated location for therapid assessment, diagnosis and commencement of appropriate treatment. Physicians,supported by a multidisciplinary team carry out patient assessments and treatment. Thisis the type of unit based in Cavan General Hospital.

    7.2 Medical Assessment Unit (MAU)1

    This unit, which is the one proposed for Monaghan hospital, manages low risk patients

    only. This is a small proportion of the total population of patients attending with acutemedical conditions.

    8. Description of Current ServicesCavan hospital is a general hospital which provides a wide range of services. It f its thedescription of a Model 3 hospital under the definition in the acute services programmeand has an acute medical assessment unit (AMAU) which provides a service to thepopulation of Cavan/Monaghan. Patients are referred directly to this unit by their GP or

    they are referred on by the triage nurse in the emergency department. Patients in

    Monaghan may be referred either to the AMAU in Cavan or Drogheda.

    Monaghan hospitals primary role includes the continuing care for medically discharged

    patients requiring in-patient step down and rehabilitation care and extensive out patient,theatre, Day Services and a Minor Injury Unit. There are 6 step down beds and 20rehabilitation beds and a wide range of day services. The physician services areprovided by staff based in Cavan general hospital that travel to Monaghan to carry out

    their duties. There are no doctors based in the hospital in Monaghan and it currentlydoes not meet the criteria for either a model 1 or a model 2 hospital but falls somewherein between. (c.f. appendix 2)

    8.1 Gap AnalysisIt has been clearly stated in the report of the National Acute Medicine Programme that amodel 1 hospital shall not have an ED, ICU, High dependency unit (HDU) coronary careunit or an AMU/AMAU/MAU In a model 2 hospital the requirements for a MAU are very

    clearly outlined as detailed below. Table 2 illustrates the criteria for an MAU and thecurrent situation in Monaghan

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    9/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    9

    Table 2 Gap Analysis for Monaghan in Relation to MAU

    MAU Criteria Monaghan Gap

    GP referred patients who

    are at low risk of requiringresuscitation

    Admission currently is requested by

    consultant/geriatrician.

    There are no acute beds, only

    rehabilitation and convalescence

    Assessment beds in

    defined area 4-12

    beds/trolleys

    No dedicated area at present There is a potential area which could

    be developed

    Admission will be to model2 hospital

    Monaghan is not a Model 2 hospitalunder the criteria laid down in acutemedicine programme

    No facility for admission of patientsto Monaghan from a unit such as this

    Patients would have to be

    transferred to Cavan

    Dedicated radiology On call x-ray only for Minor injuriesunit Limited radiology service

    Dedicated laboratory No laboratory facility on site in

    Monaghan

    Samples couriered to Cavan with

    subsequent time delay

    Dedicated nursing Dedicated nurses would have to be

    employed

    Staffing insufficient to cover MAU

    Designated leadconsultant physician

    All medical consultants are currentlybased in Cavan

    There is currently no medical officeron site and no out of hours medicalcover

    NCHD staff All NCHDs are currently based inCavan

    No NCHDs are currently assigned toMonaghan

    NCHD at night There are no medical staff resident onsite at night

    Resident medical registrar/SpR andSHO and a consultant on call

    Nursing staff Limited number of nursing staff-

    managed from Cavan

    Additional nursing staff would have

    to be employed

    Dedicated nurse manager

    for MAU

    Based in Cavan Would have to be recruited

    Operational 8-8 sevendays per week Not available at present Staffing and cost implications

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    10/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    10

    9 Establishing a Clinical Need

    Relevant information that was required here:

    The number of patients from Monaghan currently attending AMAUs in Cavan

    and Drogheda

    Type of patient attending, i.e. low risk who would be suitable to attend an MAUor general medical suitable for AMAU only

    The AMAU in Cavan became operational in March 2009. In 2011 the population for theCavan/Monaghan region was 133,369, Monaghan (60,495) and Cavan (72,874)2.

    Table 3 Attendances at Cavan AMAU by County of Residence

    CavanAMAU

    Patients with CAVAN Addresses Patients with MONAGHAN Addresses

    Year Totalnumbersattending

    Numbersattending

    Dailynumbers

    Rate per10,000 ofpopulation

    Numbersattending

    Dailynumbers

    Rate per 10,000population

    2010 43602639

    (61%)10 3.6

    1310

    (34.5%)5 2.1

    2011 37462273

    (61.2%)8.7 3.1

    1137

    (30.6%)4.3 1.8

    In 2011, 61.2% of patients attending Cavan AMAU had Cavan addresses and 30.6%

    (1137) had Monaghan addresses. The remaining 336 were from neither county.

    In 2010, 61.6% of patients were from Cavan, 30.6% from Monaghan and the remainderfrom other counties.3

    In 2011 these figures reflect 3.5 visits per 10,000 population for Cavan and 2.1 visits per10,000 population for Monaghan. This equates to 3 more patients from Cavan beingseen per day than from Monaghan. This discrepancy of 3 patients may be accountedfor in Monaghan patients attending Drogheda and other hospitals. To achieve equalrates of attendance to the AMAU in Cavan would entail 3 extra patients per day being

    seen from Monaghan. A limitation of these figures is that they reflect the experience of

    two years only. It is quite possible that the trend over several years may show quite adifferent finding.

    On average 20 patients per month from Monaghan attend Drogheda AMAU. (c.f.Appendix 3)

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    11/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    11

    The type of patient attending would also need to be clearly identified . Only low riskpatients would be suitable to attend an MAU and it is not currently possible todetermine how many of the patients attending the the AMAU in Drogheda and

    Cavan would be in this category. If an MAU were to be made available in Monaghanthere is no clear evidence that the critical mass of low risk patients needed would be

    available.

    In the six weeks available to carry out this study it was not possible to obtain morecomprehensive figures on the issues raised above. Activity data for Cavan/Monaghan isincluded in Appendix 3

    9.1 Advantages of an MAU in Monaghan Convenient and accessible for local patients

    Timely access for GPs to specialist medical care-this is currently available inCavan

    Timely access to limited diagnostics

    9.2 Disadvantages of an MAU in Monaghan Patient safety issues as there are no medical personnel on site and there is

    no facility for admission

    Resource intensive for small critical mass

    Cost

    9.3 Major Issues Identified Monaghan is not a model 2 hospital and as such does not currently have

    many of the requirements for setting up a MAU

    Does not currently have medical personnel on site apart from sessionalOPD therefore patient safety would be a major concern

    Does not have laboratory on site but samples can be fast tracked to Cavan

    Does not have access to wide range of emergency diagnostics

    Does not currently have sufficient medical, professional and administrativestaff available to staff MAU

    Has no facility to admit patients from an MAU

    Extra resources to develop an MAU would be needed

    Patient safety must remain a major consideration

    10. Resource Requirement

    The cost of setting up and running an MAU is considerable as can be seen from thecosting for the Cavan AMAU in Appendix 4. The major cost is in relation to pay,

    approximately1.2 million. Because the throughput of an MAU in Monaghan cannot beclearly outlined the costings must remain an estimate and although a slightly lessernumber of staff may be required the cost would still be substantial. A critical mass ofpatients is required to make a service cost effective and sustainable and a substantialnumber of patients would be required to justify such a large resource investment.

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    12/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    12

    11. DiscussionEvery community desires a comprehensive medical service in close proximity to them toprovide the highest quality medical care. However extensive research has shown that to

    provide an excellent service a critical mass of patients must be available for theclinicians to maintain and develop their skills

    . 4In the current climate it is also vital that

    services are cost effective and scarce resources are used in the best manner possible.The population of Cavan/ Monaghan have access to excellent medical services provided

    on two sites in the Cavan/Monaghan network. Each hospital has quite a different role,and while Cavan is focused on providing acute medical care, Monaghan provides theequally important step down and rehabilitation facilities. Extensive OPD and day surgeryis also a feature of what Monaghan can provide. They also have access to an AMAU inDrogheda

    Two AMAUs are available and accessible within a reasonable distance to the populationof Monaghan. These units would appear to serve the population well as there is noclear evidence of an unmet need in this population although further analysis would be

    necessary to confirm this.

    One limitation of this study was that it was carried out in a very short time frame of sixweeks. Further analysis of data would be necessary to give a more definitive

    conclusion.

    12. ConclusionThe population of Cavan/Monaghan have access to a wide variety of acute medicalservices within a reasonable distance of their residence. Patient safety must remain ourpriority when deciding where services are located. This is about patients receiving theright care, in the right place, at the right time. The objective is to provide the highest

    quality care to patients and ensuring that those who require care can get access to it asquickly and as safely as possible. The cost of maintaining such services is immense.To ensure cost effectiveness and the maintenance of skills a satisfactory critical mass ofpatients must attend the service available. To develop an MAU in Monaghan at thiscurrent time would entail a considerable input of resources and would necessitate

    moving scarce resources from other services to serve a relatively small number ofpatients.

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    13/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    13

    References1. Health Service Executive. Report of the National Acute Medicine Programme,

    2010

    2. Central Statistics Office. Reports on Vital Statistics. Yearly summary. Dublin:

    Central Statistics Office, 2011

    3. Hospital Inpatient Enquiry System. Dublin. The Economic and Social ResearchInstitute, 2011

    4. Hospital volumes and health care outcomes, costs and patient access. EffectiveHealthcare Bulletin 1996; 2(8):1-8.

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    14/40

    CONFIDENTIAL

    14

    Appendix 1

    Group Membership

    Core Membership:

    Dr Louise Doherty, Specialist in Public Health Medicine, HSE North West (Chair)

    Dr James Hayes, Clinical Director, Cavan & Monaghan Hospital Group

    Ms Eileen Whelan, Director of Nursing, Louth/Meath Hospital Group

    Ms Ruth Murdiff, Service User Representative, Cavan & Monaghan Hospital Group

    Mr Robert Dancey, Service User Representative, Cavan & Monaghan HospitalGroup

    Mr Gerry Clerkin, Risk Advisor, Cavan & Monaghan Hospital Group (GroupFacilitator)

    Mr Cathal Hand, Service Development Manager, Cavan & Monaghan HSE Area

    Dr Ilona Duffy, GP Representative from Cavan/Monaghan

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    15/40

    15

    Appendix 2 Gap Analysis Monaghan Hospital

    Appendix 2a Gap Analysis Monaghan Hospital Vs Model 2 Hospital (Acute Medicine Programme)

    MH Vs Level 2 ModelStatus Report

    14/0311 Implemented 23 (39%)

    partiallyi mp le me nte d 1 3 ( 22 %)

    not implemented 23 (39%)

    Characteristics of a Level 2

    Hospital

    Current status of Monaghan

    Hospital

    Implications of achieving the

    Characteristics of a level 2hospital i.e Structural, capacity,resources financial & human

    Is it feasible toachieve requirement

    within resourcesYes/No

    Persons whowould be

    responsible forleading on thisinitiative

    Status

    Implemented orNot implemented

    Additional

    comments

    Hospital has a day time MAU No MAU

    Significant resources tofacilitate this service. FullMedical team required with

    anesthetic cover and nursing.

    Not feasible within

    resourcesN/A Not implemented

    GP will refer low risk (i.e. unlikelyto require high intensity

    cardiopulmonary and/orneurological support) medicalpatients for assessment in the

    MAU during daytime hours

    No MAU N/A Not implemented

    The Hospital will provide in-patientand out-patient care fordifferentiated, low risk medical

    patients, who are not likely torequire full resuscitation. Allpatients will have an appropriate

    care plan

    Patients in the 26 bedded unit aremedically discharged and therefore

    deemed as being low risk. There isan emergency protocol which is tobe initiated in the event of patient

    becoming medically compromised.There is a minor injury unit onlywith clear criteria for GPs/patients

    as to what condition will beassessed in the MIU. Treatmentplans are in place.

    implemented

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    16/40

    16

    This hospital will not have an ICU,

    so the patient will be assessedand tracked using the national

    early warning score (ref section6.4) and where appropriate, thisscore will prompt an acutemedicine response and if

    necessary, transfer to theassociated model 3 or 4 hospital.

    No ICU, daily obs undertakenroutinely on all patients, if pt comesill Potts score is calculated.

    implemented

    A p atient's condition maydeteriorate and after detection and

    treatment by acute medicine apatient's acuity may be ICS Level2 unstable or Level 3 (ref

    appendix 17.9) requiring criticalcare retrieval and transfer to ICU

    in a model 3 or 4 hospital

    Not applicable as there is no acute

    medical team on call.Non applicable

    There will be guaranteed

    acceptance of transfer of allpatients who deteriorate by theassociated model 3 or 4 hospital

    (bi-directional patient flow mustalso occur if required)

    transfer protocol in place implemented

    patients requiring palliative,

    respite, rehabilitation and pre-discharge care and patients fordirect GP to consultant referral

    (via MAU) can be admitted to thishospital

    Rehabilitation service only for

    medically discharged patients.Direct referrals from GP notaccepted, pre-discharge care not

    available, no respite,

    partiallyimplemented

    Patients can be admitted from theMAU under the care of the namedconsultant and out-of-hours

    selected medical patients can beadmitted by agreement between

    the GP and the on call medicalteam /consultant

    No MAU Non applicable

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    17/40

    17

    The medical department and

    medical staff need to be part of awider rotation under governanceof the acute medicine service in

    the ISA linked model 3 or 4hospital. During the day there willbe appropriate NCHD presence in

    the MAU and wards

    No MAU Not implemented

    The Medical staffing at night willbe a resident medicalregistrar/SpR and the senior

    house officer (both of whom areadvanced cardiac life support(ACLS) certified). In addition there

    will be a consultant on call.

    Not available Not implemented

    Nurse staffing at night will includea nurse manager/supervisor for

    the nursing services.

    not in place Not implemented

    Therapy staffing will be at a seniorgrade within each therapy

    discipline with additional therapyresource comprising staff andassistant grade positions. Clinical

    specialists in ISA model 3 and 4hospitals will provide advice and/or support as required.

    in place implemented

    standards of care should be

    measured and should becomparable to those delivered inmodel 3 and 4 Hospitals

    in place, cross site clinical

    governance committees oversee

    the standards of service delivery ineach specialty, Medicalgovernance committee toincorporate 26 beds MH

    partiallyimplemented

    The hospital may have a minorinjury unit (MIU)

    in place implemented

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    18/40

    18

    The following day services could be made available 5 days a week based on local need.

    Day surgery in place implemented

    Pre-operative clinics in place implemented

    Day services /ambulatory care

    assessment for older personsfalls clinic planned, partially

    Antenatal/Post natal careante natal only, post natal always

    carried out by GPimplemented

    Endoscopy /PEG tube insertion endoscopy only partially

    Non invasive cardiology in place implemented

    Cardiac Failure clinic in place implemented

    Cardiac Rehabilitation in place implemented

    Venesction, infusion andtransfusion therapy

    in place implemented

    Bone Marrow aspiration andtrephine biopsy

    Not availablenotimplemented

    Abdominal paracentesis andthoracentesis

    Not availablenotimplemented

    lumbar puncture Not availablenotimplemented

    Diabetic Day centre in place implemented

    Rheumatology day services planned 2012Notimplemented

    Dermatology day servicesNot available in MH, is available inCGH

    notimplemented

    Oncology /hematology day ward not availablenot

    implemented

    Mental Health day services St Davnets site implemented

    COPD outreach planned 2012-13Notimplemented

    Pulmonary rehabilitation in place implemented

    Heptatology day services planned 2014Not

    implemented

    Diagnostic Imaging in place implemented

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    19/40

    19

    other services depending localpolicies and protocols

    ENT, Community audiology, OPD

    to include Medical, Surgical,Gynae, orthopaedics, Paediatrics,Dental, AHP led services, CNS

    clinics,

    partiallyimplemented

    Patient flow will be enhanced byexpanded nursing and therapypractice (e.g. nurse prescribing of

    medicinal products and ionisingradiation /xrays and therapyfacilitated discharge) These

    services will be developed inresponse to service need.

    Nurse prescribing in place in MIU,Heart failure, Diabetes day centre

    partiallyimplemented

    Clinical Pharmacy services will beprovided by clinical pharmacistsattached to model 3 or 4 hospitals

    not availablenotimplemented

    All model 1 & 2 hospitals musthave an in-house clinicalpharmacy service or formal

    access to and reportingrelationship with the service in amodel 3 or 4 hospital

    Not availablenot

    implemented

    All hospitals must have a persontrained and responsible for

    infection prevention and control onsite and formal access to advicefrom a consultant microbiologist/infectious disease physician

    in place implemented

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    20/40

    20

    Consultant physician work

    practices

    Current status of Monaghan

    Hospital in achieving level 2 status

    Implications of achieving theConsultant work practices of a

    level 2 hospital

    Is it feasible toachieve requirementwithin resources

    Yes/No

    Persons whowould beresponsible for

    leading on thisinitiative

    StatusImplemented orNot

    implemented

    Additional

    comments

    The consultant physician on-callfor the MAU will have a primaryresponsibility to be present and

    make management decisionsduring core working hours.

    Not availableNot

    implemented

    There will be ward rounds everyday on all newly admitted patients,patients whose clinical status

    deteriorates and patients identifiedfor potential discharge.

    Not availableNot

    implemented

    Board rounds (i.e. desktop

    review of patient status with aview to potential discharge) willoccur on all medical patients,

    once daily before 11am, includingPublic Holidays and weekends.

    Not availableNotimplemented

    At least 2 comprehensive wardrounds on all patients should take

    place weekly.

    Not availableNot

    implemented

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    21/40

    21

    Appendix 2b Gap Analysis Monaghan Hospital Vs the Model 2 Hospital (National Acute medicine

    Programme) Interdependencies with other National Clinical ProgrammesGap analysis Monaghan Hospital Vs the Model 2 Hospital (National Acute Medicine Programme)

    Interdependencies with other national clinical programmes

    National Clinical Programme National Recommendation Gap analysis

    Acute cardiology

    Patients should be managed according to referral guidelines and clinicalprotocols. An out-patient clinic session should be provided by a visiting

    cardiologist one day per week to review the results of non-invasive tests.Patients with acute presentations should be transferred to a model 3 or 4

    hospital according to protocol.

    Not available

    Ambulance servicesGPs, hospital staff and ambulance services will agree the protocols forambulance transfer to and between hospitals.

    in place

    Asthma There will be out-patient services available on site utilising spirometry in place

    COPD In-patients will have care up to, and including, non-invasive ventilation(NIV). OPD, pulmonary rehabilitation and outreach may be available.

    OPD & rehabilitation only

    DiabetesDiabetic day care, including chiropody and ophthalmology, may be

    available.in place

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    22/40

    22

    Diagnostic ImagingPlain film X-ray, ultrasound and CT-scanning will be provided. There will bean on-call diagnostic imaging service.

    in place on call Xray only for MIU

    EndoscopyUpper and lower gastrointestinal endoscopy and bronchoscopy may beavailable.

    endoscopy only

    Epilepsy and Neurology services Epilepsy and neurology out-patient management may be available. Not available

    Health Care Associated Infection

    A person trained and responsible for infection prevention and control will beemployed on site. Formal access to advice from a consultant

    microbiologist/infectious diseases physician is required.part time cover

    Heart Failure

    A heart failure service will be established under the governance of a leadconsultant physician. Selected heart failure patients with a clearly defined

    care plan who develop decompensated heart failure may be admitted.There will be a rapid access clinic for out-patient IV therapy to stablilise

    patients with deteriorating heart failure, possibly including inotropic care. Afull out-patient service for diagnosis and specialist review will be provided.

    OPD only

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    23/40

    23

    Palliative Care

    Patients with palliative care needs may be managed in model 2 hospitalswith appropriate support from the specialist palliative care services as

    required. Services provided in model 2 hospitals should be sufficientlyflexible and integrated with specialist palliative care services to allow rapid

    and efficient movement of patients from one care setting to anotherdepending on their clinical needs and personal preferences. Admission

    criteria, discharge protocols and interface with specialist palliative careservices will be according to agreed national palliative care programme

    protocols

    OPD only

    Primary CareDirect access for some of the services listed (i.e. radiology, endoscopy,

    laboratory etc.) as part of agreed protocols.

    endoscopy & radiology only, in-

    direct access to laboratory.

    RheumatologyRheumatology out-patient services will be linked to the nearest

    rheumatology unit in a model 3 or 4 hospital.

    currently not in place, however

    this is planned for 2015 +

    Stroke Stroke rehabilitation will be provided in place

    Surgery Day surgery and pre -admission assessment clinics will be provided. in place

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    24/40

    24

    Appendix 2c Gap Analysis Monaghan Hospital Vs Model 1 Hospital (Acute Medicine Programme)

    MH Vs Level 1 Model Status Report

    14/0311 Implemented 24 (62%)

    partially implemented 6 (15%)

    not implemented 9 (23 %)

    Characteristics of a Level 1

    Hospital

    Current status of

    Monaghan Hospital

    Implications of achieving theCharacteristics of a level 1

    hospital i.e Structural,capacity, resources financial

    & human

    Is it feasible

    to achieverequirement

    withinresources

    Yes/No

    Persons who would beresponsible for leading

    on this initiative

    StatusImplemented

    or Notimplemented

    Additional

    comments

    The hospital will be a community

    hospital with sub-acute in-patientbeds

    in place, beds referred toas non-acute beds

    implemented

    admissions can be requested by

    a GP, consultant geriatricianand/or consultants following

    agreement with a medical officer

    consultant /geriatricianonly not GPs

    partially

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    25/40

    25

    patients with rehabilitation,respite and /or complex palliative

    care needs and patients whoremain under the care of GPs

    may be admitted appropriately toin-patient beds in this hospital.

    These patients will be managedunder the care of a medical

    officer(e.g. designated GP orgroups of GPs) who will be

    supported as necessary byconsultant physicians. All

    patients have an appropriatecare plan.

    Rehabilitation only,service not available to

    respite or palliative carepatients, medical officer

    is under discussion

    partially

    This hospital will not have anED, ICU, high dependency unit

    (HDU), coronary care unit or anAMU/AMAU/MAU

    in place, implemented

    As this hospital will not have anICU, patients requiring a higher

    level of care will be transferredto the ISA model 2,3 or 4

    hospital

    in place implemented

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    26/40

    26

    there will be guaranteed transferof patients whose clinical status

    deteriorates from the model 1hospital to the ISA model 2, 3, or

    4 hospital (s). Where a patient iscritically ill (ICS levels 2 & 3), the

    regional critical care retrievalteam will effect safe transfer.

    Remote critical care retrieval willinclude continued resuscitation,

    stabilisation and safe transportby the retrieval team (ref

    appendix 17.9).

    in place implemented

    Patients whose clinical statushas improved sufficiently may be

    transferred from a model 3 or 4hospital to a model 1 or 2

    hospital for further cae (bi-directional patient flow must also

    occur). However, patients shouldnot be transferred is a "Do not

    resuscitate" order is madeand/or if patients make an

    informed decision to remain inthe model 1 hospital.

    in place implemented

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    27/40

    27

    The following day services could be made available 5 days a week based on local need.

    Out patient department (OPD) in place implemented

    Day services /ambulatory careassessment for older persons

    falls clinic planned,notimplemented

    Venesection / phlebotomy in place implemented

    warfarin service in place implemented

    COPD outreach planned for 2014 +notimplemented

    Pulmonary rehabilitation in place implemented

    Cardiac Failure clinic in place implemented

    Supra-pubic catheter re-

    insertion

    in place (replacement of

    Supra-pubic catheter)implemented

    percutaneous endoscopicgastrostomy (PEG) tube re-

    insertion

    nonot

    implemented

    Antenatal/postnatal servicesantenatal in place post

    natal undertaken by GPsimplemented

    other services depending localpolicies and protocols

    ENT other services will

    be introduced dependinglocal policies and

    protocols

    Partiallyimplemented

    Many of these services will benurse led and /or therapy led

    with expansion of nursing and

    therapy practice in response toservice need

    in place implemented

    Clinical Pharmacy services willbe provided by clinical

    pharmacists attached to model 3or 4 hospitals

    no clinical pharmacynot

    implemented

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    28/40

    28

    All model 1 & 2 hospitals must

    have an in-house clinicalpharmacy service or formal

    access to and reportingrelationship with the service in a

    model 3 or 4 hospital

    not availablenot

    implemented

    All hospitals must have a persontrained and responsible for

    infection prevention and controlon site and formal access to

    advice from a consultantmicrobiologist /infectious disease

    physician

    in place implemented

    Consultant physician work

    practices

    Current status of

    Monaghan Hospital inachieving level 2 status

    Implications of achieving the

    Consultant work practices ofa level 2 hospital

    Is it feasible

    to achieverequirement

    withinresources

    Yes/No

    Persons who would be

    responsible for leadingon this initiative

    StatusImplemented

    or Notimplemented

    Additional

    comments

    The medical officer (s) or his /her

    deputy, will carry out weekdayward rounds and will be

    available on call or as part of an

    "out of hours" GP service.

    partially in place, Out of

    Hours not in place andmedical officer is

    planned

    partially

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    29/40

    29

    Appendix 2d Gap analysis Monaghan Hospital Vs the Model 1 Hospital (National Acute Medicine

    Programme) Interdependencies with other Clinical Programmes

    Gap Analysis Monaghan Hospital Vs the Model 1 Hospital (National Acute Medicine Programme)

    Interdependencies with other

    national clinical programmes

    National Clinical Programme National Recommendation Gap analysis

    Acute cardiologypatients with a suspected acute coronary syndrome should

    not be admitted to or treated in a model 1 hospital exceptunder defined circumstances

    in place

    Ambulance servicesGPs, hospital staff and ambulance services will agree the

    protocols for ambulance transfer to and between hospitals.in place

    Anaesthesia An anesthesia service will not be providedNot available to in patients, provided for Day servicesENT, Gynae, Surgery and pre-operative assessment

    Asthma

    There will be out-patient services available on site utilising

    spirometry in place

    COPDOut reach programmes and pulmonary rehabilitation maybe available

    rehabilitation only

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    30/40

    30

    Diabetes Diabetic cl inics may be available in place

    Diagnostic Imaging There may be imaging depending on local need in place on call Xray only for MIU

    Epilepsy /Neurological

    services (e.g. Parkinson'sdisease).

    Epilepsy and neurology out-patient management may be

    available. Not available

    Health Care Associated

    Infection

    A person trained and responsible for infection preventionand control will be employed on site. Formal access to

    advice from a consultant microbiologist/infectious diseasesphysician is required.

    part time cover from a cross site IPCT

    Heart Failure

    Medical officers will manage patients with heart failureaccording to guidelines. The hospital may provide

    ambulatory services for diagnostics and OPD managementof heart failure.

    in place

    Medicine for Older peopleambulatory care assessments for older persons may be

    provided on site.planned for 2015 +

    Mental Health services Out patient clinics may be available on St Davnets site

    Palliative Care

    Patients whose palliative care needs could be met by their

    GP in a model 1 hospital environment e.g.. end of life care,titration medication. Admisssion criteria, discharge

    protocols and interface with specialist palliative careservices will be according to agreed national palliative care

    programme protocols

    Not in place

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    31/40

    31

    Primary CareClose liaison with GPs and Primary care teams with regard

    to direct access for services admission criteria anddischarge policies and procedures

    Not in place

    Rheumatology Rheumatology out-patient services will be linked to thenearest rheumatology unit

    Currently not in place, however this is planned for 2014+

    Stroke The hospital may have a stroke rehabilitation unit on sitestroke rehabilitation service in place, no dedicatedstroke unit

    Surgery Surgical OPD may be available in place

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    32/40

    32

    Appendix 3a Cavan & Monaghan Hospital Yearly Stats 2008 2011

    CAVAN/MONAGHAN HOSPITAL GROUP

    YEARLY ST ATS

    Items marked in red are Jan-Nov 2011 figures

    2008 2009 2010 2011 Jan-Dec

    CGHSite MH Site

    Cross SiteTotal

    CGHSite M H Site

    Cross SiteTotal

    CGHSite MH Site

    CrossSite Total

    CGHSite M H Site

    Cross SiteTotal

    Admissions

    Surgical 3297 0 3297 2937 0 2937 2566 0 2566 2588 0 2588Medical 4877 2431 7308 6220 1400 7620 7136 0 7136 6696 0 6696

    Paeds 1729 0 1729 1626 0 1626 1636 0 1636 1630 0 1630

    Obs 3064 0 3064 3164 0 3164 3080 0 3080 3152 0 3152

    Gynae 746 0 746 739 0 739 693 0 693 539 0 539

    Rehab 0 0 0 0 67 67 0 157 157 0 113 113

    Stepdown 0 0 0 0 98 98 0 264 264 0 245 245

    Psychiatry 131 0 131 140 0 140 108 0 108 112 0 112

    Total 13844 2431 16275 14826 1565 16391 15219 421 15640 14717 358 15075

    Births 1957 0 1957 1945 0 1945 2032 0 2032 1879 0 1879

    Daycases

    Surg General 784 1381 2165 813 1524 2337 808 1689 2497 766 1772 2538

    Surg Endoscopy 2439 1316 3755 2450 1538 3988 2852 1495 4347 2915 1017 3932

    Medical Gen 597 556 1153 522 700 1222 724 946 1670 755 841 1596

    Med Endoscopy 299 1585 1884 256 1325 1581 259 1088 1347 287 1128 1415*Other 13098 73 13171 14426 56 14482 13708 109 13817 14105 123 14228

    Total Daycases 17217 4911 22128 18467 5143 23610 18351 5327 23678 18828 4881 23709

    Outpatients

    New 9998 3455 13453 9602 3574 13176 10085 3510 13595 8804 3188 11992

    Review 29161 12256 41417 29672 11562 41234 28955 10793 39748 29575 10069 39644

    Total 39159 15711 54870 39274 15136 54410 39040 14303 53343 38379 13257 51636

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    33/40

    33

    X-Ray

    Inpatients 11089 6119 17208 13898 4538 18436 16115 2376 18491 15848 658 16506

    Outpatients 38098 12744 50842 39201 10954 50155 39519 10565 50084 37016 13596 50612

    Total 49187 18863 68050 53099 15492 68591 55634 12941 68575 52864 14254 67118

    A&E

    New 25285 9540 34825 26400 5105 31505 25742 0 25742 26609 0 26609

    Review 1830 2374 4204 1777 1154 2931 1990 0 1990 1968 0 1968

    Total 27115 11914 39029 28177 6259 34436 27732 0 27732 28577 0 28577

    MITU

    New 0 0 0 0 1808 1808 0 5446 5446 0 6595 6595

    Review 0 0 0 0 406 406 0 1438 1438 0 1542 1542

    Total 0 0 0 0 2214 2214 0 6884 6884 0 8137 8137

    MAU

    Attend only 0 0 0 1217 0 1217 1734 0 1734 1687 0 1687

    Admitted 0 0 0 2219 0 2219 2626 0 2626 2059 0 2059

    Total Attended 0 0 0 3436 0 3436 4360 0 4360 3746 0 3746

    *Other daycases include Renal dialysis, GDU, Gynae, Orthopaedic, Oncology, Paeds, Obstetric, Dermatology & ENT

    COMMENTS:

    In July 09 Medical inpatient services in MGH Ceased

    In July 09 Rehab & Stepdown services commenced in MGH

    In July 09 Treatment room services in MGH Ceased

    In July 09 MITU commenced in MGH

    30th March 09 MAU opened in CGH

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    34/40

    34

    Appendix 3b Cavan Hospital MAU Stats 2009 2011

    2009

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    Attend only 0 0 8 75 130 124 125 136 109 172 174 164 1217

    Admitted 0 0 5 208 232 226 300 264 266 244 253 221 2219

    Total Attendance 0 0 13 283 362 350 425 400 375 416 427 385 3436

    2010

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    Attend only 133 148 149 177 183 138 126 139 167 147 116 111 1734

    Admitted 216 202 225 227 200 237 230 260 224 206 206 193 2626

    Total Attendance 349 350 374 404 383 375 356 399 391 353 322 304 4360

    2011

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    Attend only 106 108 124 99 140 137 140 164 132 174 180 183 1687

    Admitted 156 202 187 105 228 188 151 173 172 129 208 160 2059

    Total Attendance 262 310 311 204 368 325 291 337 304 303 388 343 3746

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    35/40

    35

    Appendix 3c Cavan ED Figures 2008 2011

    2008

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    New 1959 1871 2075 2221 2351 2156 2228 2096 2098 1995 1970 2265 25285

    Review 114 123 154 160 188 146 154 165 142 156 155 173 1830

    Total 2073 1994 2229 2381 2539 2302 2382 2261 2240 2151 2125 2438 27115

    2009

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    New 1978 1997 2336 2331 2344 2221 2243 2195 2171 2268 2118 2198 26400

    Review 114 118 146 157 161 148 162 155 140 150 153 173 1777

    Total 2092 2115 2482 2488 2505 2369 2405 2350 2311 2418 2271 2371 28177

    2010

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    New 2021 1894 2319 2205 2334 2135 2250 2140 2236 2124 2037 2047 25742

    Review 168 124 137 143 151 180 161 172 196 212 197 149 1990

    Total 2189 2018 2456 2348 2485 2315 2411 2312 2432 2336 2234 2196 27732

    2011

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    New 2257 2019 2262 2317 2265 2195 2137 2287 2212 2215 2217 2226 26609

    Review 186 171 165 132 161 157 130 163 163 159 193 188 1968

    Total 2443 2190 2427 2449 2426 2352 2267 2450 2375 2374 2410 2414 28577

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    36/40

    36

    Appendix 3d Cavan ED Triage Figures 2008 2011

    2008

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    P1 6 8 14 2 3 19 11 8 13 9 11 22 126

    P2 282 264 332 330 326 410 405 294 323 345 314 350 3975

    P3 1002 1005 1153 1090 1138 1131 1022 989 1053 1110 1046 1279 13018

    P4 626 519 586 748 835 547 710 812 683 610 582 620 7878

    P5 16 5 5 10 12 19 4 9 11 6 4 9 110

    Dressings 14 7 14 9 24 7 13 11 6 10 16 10 141

    Physician Review 19 17 19 23 28 32 25 26 32 32 29 32 314

    Code Not Entered 131 92 115 142 186 137 135 92 131 135 125 128 1549

    2009

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    P1 15 4 2 10 12 8 12 16 11 15 14 19 138

    P2 280 352 366 370 417 413 390 398 363 444 376 430 4599

    P3 1068 1073 1227 1378 1334 1269 1336 1233 1282 1278 1273 1351 15102

    P4 568 549 651 551 601 571 543 551 543 543 517 450 6638

    P5 4 15 5 2 3 4 7 7 6 9 6 8 76

    Dressings 6 8 3 3 4 3 6 4 4 13 4 10 68

    Physician Review 18 22 31 21 21 25 20 34 16 27 20 28 283

    Code Not Entered 132 141 197 164 123 94 98 108 88 82 94 94 1415

    2010

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.P1 17 14 10 9 10 12 14 10 11 7 12 18 144

    P2 344 351 380 355 352 355 366 319 343 363 334 360 4222

    P3 1246 1094 1233 1308 1411 1112 1342 1199 1289 1208 1334 1273 15049

    P4 461 455 618 528 581 579 581 667 625 502 434 430 6461

    P5 3 5 3 6 6 8 4 7 5 3 3 3 56

    Dressings 8 3 4 4 2 6 5 4 4 9 7 8 64

    Physician Review 20 18 21 15 20 25 22 33 42 29 20 14 279

    Code Not Entered 82 79 177 110 81 234 86 87 108 237 84 93 1458

    2011

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    P1 16 13 18 17 6 8 7 24 11 18 19 20 177

    P2 386 371 343 343 356 338 332 356 337 337 354 394 4247

    P3 1371 1241 1267 1353 1347 1237 1309 1410 1369 1368 1400 1342 16014

    P4 537 453 639 548 568 583 450 493 474 441 416 490 6092

    P5 3 3 4 3 7 2 2 8 2 5 4 14 57

    Dressings 5 12 7 4 8 10 7 4 3 1 2 10 73

    Physician Review 17 11 20 12 17 10 15 14 13 18 11 16 174

    Code Not Entered 139 100 138 171 126 172 146 160 195 218 234 138 1937

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    37/40

    37

    Appendix 3e Minor Injury Unit, Monaghan Hospital Figures

    2009 2011

    2008

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D

    New 786 728 789 910 963 892 817 787 796 701 635 736 9540

    Review 235 208 204 178 184 244 228 183 169 162 177 202 2374

    Total 1021 936 993 1088 1147 1136 1045 970 965 863 812 938 11914

    Admissions thru 210 189 176 192 199 201 186 167 186 196 198 213 2313

    2009-Treatment Room

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    New 726 645 764 810 816 835 509 0 0 0 0 0 5105

    Review 244 202 235 212 96 98 67 0 0 0 0 0 1154

    Total 970 847 999 1022 912 933 576 0 0 0 0 0 6259

    Admissions thru 229 188 221 209 222 215 92 0 0 0 0 0 1376

    2009 -MITU

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    New 77 365 368 356 324 318 1808

    Review 13 39 87 91 89 87 406

    Total 0 0 0 0 0 0 90 404 455 447 413 405 2214

    MITU 20102010

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    New 333 297 397 507 578 481 492 469 469 532 421 470 5446

    Review 108 77 120 143 182 171 184 120 102 35 85 111 1438

    Total 441 374 517 650 760 652 676 589 571 567 506 581 6884

    MITU 2011

    2011

    Description Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Y.T.D.

    New 414 393 549 619 630 647 750 700 605 564 430 294 6595

    Review 112 97 110 179 181 180 85 113 146 149 101 89 1542

    Total 526 490 659 798 811 827 835 813 751 713 531 383 8137

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    38/40

    38

    Appendix 3f Cavan Hospital OPD Waiting Time for OPD

    Appointments

    OPD Validation Baseline Data Template

    HOSPITAL NAME: Cavan/ Monaghan General Hospital

    COMPLETED BY: Gary Keenan

    DATE OF COMPLETION: 03/01/2012

    Wait inweeks

    Wait inweeks

    Wait inweeks

    Wait inweeks

    Wait inweeks

    Wait inweeks

    Specialty Consultant 0 to 12 13 to 25 26 to 39 40 to 52Greaterthan 52 Total

    General Medicine Dr. Hayes 79 85 63 9 3 239

    Dr. Pinherio 18 5 0 2 0 25

    Dr. Pinherio MH 26 38 12 3 0 79

    Dr Sheikh 72 18 4 0 0 94

    Dr Murugasu 17 10 0 2 1 30

    Dr Muthu 23 10 5 0 0 38

    Dr. Muthu MH 16 8 2 1 0 27

    Dr Mac Mahon 58 77 70 23 0 228

    Dr. McDermott 15 10 2 2 0 29

    Dr. Smith 22 15 4 4 0 45

    Dr. Hannon 38 27 5 2 1 73

    907

    Total 384 303 167 48 5 907

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    39/40

    39

    Appendix 3g Drogheda Statistics

    In total 242 patients with Monaghan addresses attended the MAU/AMAU, this worksout at an average of 20 patients per month but clearly there are variations in relationto the monthly trend (see table):

    2011

    Month No of Patient

    January 14

    February 19

    March 23

    April 18

    May 13

    June 24

    July 26

    August 21

    September 26

    October 18

    November 21

    December 19

    The analysis of the patient addresses showed that the majority of patients come fromCastleblayney and Carrickmacross. There are single numbers of patients withaddresses from Ballybay, Inniskeen, Smithsboro, Monaghan town which are all inthe vicinity of south Co. Monaghan. It is important to note that a high percentage ofthese patients would be patients of the medical department of Louth County Hospitaland subsequently are now patients of Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital, Drogheda.

  • 7/27/2019 Feasibility Study MAU

    40/40

    Appendix 4 Resource Requirements for Setting up the AMAU in

    Cavan

    NAME OF AGENCY Cavan General Hospital AMAU

    A GRADE OF POST WTE SALARY COST

    Administration

    Clerical Grade 3 - Wards Clerk - 9 to 5 Mon to Sun 3.00 34,178 102,534

    Bed Manager Grade 7 (33hrs) 1.00 69,850 69,850

    0.00 - 0

    Medical & Dental

    Consultant 1.00 220,000 220,000

    Radiologist 1.00 220,000 220,000

    Nursing

    CNM II 1.00 69,111 69,111

    CNM II 1.00 59,210 59,210

    Staff Nurses 7.15 48,500 346,775

    Chest Pain Nurse (CNS) 1.00 59,210 59,210

    Allied Health Professionals

    Radiographer 0.50 66,718 33,359

    0.00 66,718 0

    0.00 66,718 0

    0.00 66,718 0

    0.00 66,718 0

    0.00 66,718 0

    Support Services

    Attendants 2.58 37,915 97,821

    Other Pay

    TOTAL PAY COSTS 19 1,277,870

    B NON PAY COSTS

    Non Pay Costs-- 70:30 ratio of Pay to NonPay

    (Automatically calculated by dividing pay costs by 70 and multiplying by 30) 547,658

    Please include any additional non pay costs if not adequately refelected in the 70:30% above

    2 contract computers 2,200

    1 Photocopier 4,500