Large-scale characteristics of plate boundary deformations related to the post-seismic readjustment...

Post on 04-Feb-2023

0 views 0 download

Transcript of Large-scale characteristics of plate boundary deformations related to the post-seismic readjustment...

Geo

phys

. J. R

. ast

r. SO

C. (1

982)

71,

175-

792

Larg

e-sc

ale c

hara

cter

istic

s of p

late

bou

ndar

y de

form

atio

ns re

late

d to

the

post

-sei

smic

read

justm

ent

of a

thin

ast

heno

sphe

re

F. K

. Leh

ner a

nd V

. C. L

i *D

ivis

ion

of E

ngin

eerin

g, B

rown

Uni

vers

ity,

Prov

iden

ce, R

hode

Isla

nd, U

SA

Rec

eive

d 19

82 A

pril

26; i

n or

igin

al fo

rm 1

981

Oct

ober

9

Sum

mar

y. T

he la

rge-

scal

e re

spon

se o

f an

elas

tic li

thos

pher

e, ri

ding

on

a ‘th

in’

visc

oela

stic

asth

enos

pher

e, t

o pe

riodi

cally

occ

urrin

g ru

ptur

es a

t a tr

ansf

orm

or

subd

uctio

n-ty

pe p

late

bou

ndar

y is

des

crib

ed a

ppro

xim

atel

y by

app

ropr

iate

lim

it cy

cle

solu

tions

for

a pl

ate/

foun

datio

n m

odel

intro

duce

d pr

evio

usly

by

Rice

. Th

e cy

clic

beh

avio

ur o

f th

ickn

ess-

aver

aged

disp

lace

men

ts, s

train

s an

d st

rain

rat

es,

thei

r de

cay

away

fro

m t

he p

late

bou

ndar

y, a

nd a

reso

lutio

n in

to

cose

ismic

and

pos

t-sei

smic

alte

ratio

ns a

re o

btai

ned

and

thei

r de

pend

ence

on

repe

at t

ime

and

a ch

arac

teris

tic r

elax

atio

n tim

e in

vesti

gate

d. A

com

paris

on

is m

ade

with

exi

sting

per

iodi

c so

lutio

ns f

or t

he s

urfa

ce d

efor

mat

ions

in

a N

ur-M

avko

ha

lf-sp

ace

mod

el.

This

sugg

ests

impo

rtant

ef

fect

s du

e to

vi

scos

ity s

tratif

icat

ion

on p

ost-s

eism

ic r

ebou

nd w

hen

earth

quak

e re

peat

tim

es

exce

ed re

leva

nt r

elax

atio

n tim

es b

y at

leas

t one

ord

er o

f mag

nitu

de.

1 In

trod

uctio

n

Mod

el s

tudi

es o

f po

st-s

eism

ic su

rface

def

orm

atio

ns a

t act

ive

plat

e bo

unda

ries

have

bec

ome

an i

mpo

rtant

met

hod

of in

vesti

gatin

g th

e su

bcru

stal

rheo

logy

of

the

Earth

. Beg

inni

ng w

ith

the

wor

k of

Nur

& M

avko

(19

74)

and

Smith

(197

4),

the

typi

cal e

arth

mod

el a

ssum

ed i

n su

ch th

eore

tical

ana

lyse

s is

that

of

a vi

scoe

lasti

c ha

lf-sp

ace w

ith a

n el

astic

sur

face

laye

r, th

e la

tter

repr

esen

ting

the

litho

sphe

re a

nd t

he f

orm

er a

n as

then

osph

eric

sub

stra

tum

cap

able

of

visc

ous

rela

xatio

n, u

sual

ly i

n th

e m

anne

r of

a li

near

Max

wel

l bod

y. In

the

two-

dim

ensi

onal

N

ur-M

avko

m

odel

an

edge

or

scre

w d

islo

catio

n is

intro

duce

d at

a c

erta

in d

epth

with

in th

e lit

hosp

here

to

repr

esen

t a s

udde

n un

iform

disp

lace

men

t al

ong

a di

p-sl

ip o

r str

ike-

slip

faul

t w

hich

ext

ends

inde

finite

ly a

long

stri

ke. T

he q

uasi

stat

ic su

rface

def

orm

atio

ns p

redi

cted

by

this

mod

el m

ay b

e co

mpa

red

with

geo

detic

obs

erva

tions

of

post-

seism

ic r

ebou

nd m

otio

ns

asso

ciat

ed w

ith l

arge

ear

thqu

akes

, th

us a

llow

ing

new

inf

eren

ces

of r

elax

atio

n tim

es a

nd

visc

ositi

es

for

the

asth

enos

pher

e.

This

earth

quak

e lo

adin

g pr

oble

m

has

since

be

en

mod

elle

d in

gre

ater

det

ail i

n st

udie

s whi

ch a

llow

for

fin

ite fa

ults

and

arb

itrar

y di

strib

utio

ns

of s

lippa

ge (

Bark

er 1

976;

Run

dle &

Jack

son

1977

a, b;

Run

dle

1978

; Mat

su’u

ra &

Tan

imot

o 19

80)

as w

ell

as f

or m

ore

com

plex

rhe

olog

ical

lay

erin

g (C

ohen

19

80,

1981

; Y

ang

&

Toks

oz 1

981)

. D

etai

led

com

paris

ons

betw

een

mod

el p

redi

ctio

ns a

nd g

eode

tic o

bser

vatio

ns

Now

at D

epar

tmen

t of C

ivil

Engi

neer

ing,

MIT

, Cam

brid

ge, M

assa

chus

etts

021

39, U

SA.

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

776

have

bee

n re

porte

d in

par

ticul

ar b

y Th

atch

er &

Run

dle

(197

9) a

nd T

hatc

her

et a

l. (1

980)

fo

r thr

ee m

ajor

Japa

nese

thru

st e

vent

s. H

ere

we

take

a s

peci

al i

nter

est

in t

he w

ork

of S

avag

e &

Pre

scot

t (1

978)

and

Spe

nce

&

Turc

otte

(19

79),

who

hav

e in

depe

nden

tly a

naly

sed

the

cycl

ic b

ehav

iour

dis

play

ed b

y a

Nur

-Mav

ko

eart

h m

odel

in r

espo

nse

to a

seq

uenc

e of

iden

tical

strik

e-sl

ip ev

ents

. One

oft

he

impo

rtan

t co

nclu

sion

s th

at m

ay b

e dr

awn

from

the

ir w

ork

is th

at t

he d

epth

of p

enet

ratio

n of

sig

nific

ant

post

-sei

smic

def

orm

atio

n in

to t

he p

late

int

erio

r de

pend

s no

t on

ly o

n th

e pr

esen

ce o

f a

visc

oela

stic

subs

trate

and

the

dept

h of

fau

lting

, but

also

stro

ngly

on

recu

rren

ce

time.

The

par

amet

er w

hich

gov

erns

the

latte

r dep

ende

nce

is es

sent

ially

a d

imen

sion

less

rat

io

of r

ecur

renc

e tim

e to

a c

hara

cter

istic

Max

wel

l rel

axat

ion

time

of th

e as

then

osph

ere

and

for

the

abov

e m

entio

ned

mod

els

this

num

ber

is ty

pica

lly o

f or

der

10. T

hus,

the

tim

e sp

ans

allo

wed

foi

visc

oela

stic

rela

xatio

n pr

oces

ses

by p

erio

dica

lly r

ecur

ring

earth

quak

es a

re s

uch

as

to w

arra

nt l

ittle

em

phas

is o

n rh

eolo

gica

l la

yerin

g be

yond

the

mod

ellin

g of

the

lay

er o

f lo

wes

t vi

scos

ity.

How

ever

, if,

as

has

ofte

n be

en p

ostu

late

d, t

his

low

visc

osity

zon

e is

conf

ined

to

a ‘t

hin

laye

r’,

then

pos

t-sei

smic

su

rfac

e de

form

atio

ns d

ue t

o vi

scoe

lasti

c re

laxa

tion

may

be

expe

cted

to

diff

er s

igni

fican

tly f

rom

def

orm

atio

ns p

redi

cted

by

half-

sp

ace

mod

els.

In o

ther

wor

ds,

the

ratio

of

recu

rren

ce t

ime

for

grea

t ea

rthq

uake

s ov

er

estim

ated

ast

heno

sphe

ric re

laxa

tion

time

appe

ars

to b

e sm

all e

noug

h to

exp

ect

a do

min

ant

influ

ence

of

the

zone

of l

owes

t visc

osity

in th

e Ea

rth’s

man

tle o

n po

st-s

eism

ic d

efor

mat

ions

. Su

ch d

efor

mat

ions

sho

uld

thus

be

indi

cativ

e of

the

exis

tenc

e of

a lo

w v

iscos

ity l

ayer

. In

the

follo

win

g w

e ex

plor

e th

is q

uest

ion

by d

evel

opin

g ap

prop

riat

e lim

it cy

cle

solu

tions

fo

r ‘in

finite

’ fa

ults

, usin

g a

simpl

e th

in l

ayer

mod

el w

hich

is

iden

tical

with

the

gen

eral

ized

El

sass

er p

late

mod

el in

trodu

ced

and

anal

ysed

pre

viou

sly b

y Ri

ce (

1980

) an

d Le

hner

, Li &

Ri

ce (

1981

), an

d by

a s

ubse

quen

t co

mpa

rison

with

the

hal

f-sp

ace

mod

el o

f Sa

vage

&

Pres

cott

and

Spen

ce &

Tur

cotte

. As m

ay b

e ex

pect

ed, p

ost-s

eism

ic d

efor

mat

ions

will

app

ear

mor

e cl

osel

y co

nfin

ed t

o th

e fa

ult

zone

in

the

thin

lay

er m

odel

. Mor

eove

r, th

ere

will

be

sign

ifica

nt q

uant

itativ

e di

ffer

ence

s in

the

res

pons

e of

the

tw

o m

odel

s. Th

e th

in l

ayer

ap

prox

imat

ion

prop

osed

her

e sh

ould

the

refo

re f

urni

sh a

rou

gh c

hara

cter

izat

ion,

in s

impl

e an

alyt

ical

term

s, o

f ast

heno

sphe

re st

ratif

icat

ion

effe

cts i

n po

st-s

eism

ic r

ebou

nd.

F. K

. Leh

nera

nd V

. C. L

i

2 Th

e th

in la

yer

mod

el

We

re-d

eriv

e br

iefly

the

gov

erni

ng e

quat

ions

of t

he g

ener

aliz

ed E

lsass

er m

odel

intr

oduc

ed b

y Ri

ce (

1980

) an

d di

scus

sed

and

anal

ysed

in

deta

il by

Leh

ner

et a

l. (1

981)

. We

shal

l lim

it ou

rsel

ves

to th

e on

e-di

men

sion

al p

robl

ems

perta

inin

g to

a v

ery

long

rupt

ure

on a

stri

ke-s

lip

or t

hrus

t fa

ult,

in w

hich

the

rel

evan

t va

riabl

es w

ill b

e th

ickn

ess-

aver

aged

dis

plac

emen

ts a

nd

stres

ses

in t

he e

last

ic l

ithos

pher

e. F

ig.

1 sh

ows

the

sche

mat

ic g

eom

etrie

s as

sum

ed i

n m

odel

ling

a tra

nsfo

rm a

nd s

ubdu

ctio

n-ty

pe p

late

bou

ndar

y by

a l

ine

acro

ss w

hich

the

th

ickn

ess-

aver

aged

dis

plac

emen

t rH

u(

y, t)

= H

-’ I

u‘(y

, z, t

) dz

JO

suff

ers

an e

piso

dic

jum

p di

scon

tinui

ty in

reg

ular

rec

urre

nce

time

inte

rval

s, T

, dur

ing

whi

ch

ther

e m

ay b

e as

eism

ic s

lippa

ge a

long

dee

per

sect

ions

of

the

faul

t. N

otic

e in

par

ticul

ar t

he

sche

mat

ic p

ictu

re o

f a

subd

uctio

n-ty

pe b

ound

ary

at w

hich

the

stre

ss d

rop

and

cose

ismic

di

spla

cem

ent

of O

UI

mod

el a

re t

o be

gi

ven

the

inte

rpre

tatio

ns o

f th

ickn

ess-

aver

aged

qu

antit

ies

defin

ed a

t th

e lo

catio

n y

= 0

whi

ch c

orre

spon

ds p

erha

ps r

ough

ly t

o th

e tre

nch

axis.

Thu

s, th

e ac

tual

thru

st p

lane

lies

at y

< 0,

but

eve

nts

on it

are

rele

vant

to

the

mod

ellin

g of

pla

te s

tress

es a

nd d

efor

mat

ions

at

y >

0 on

ly i

n as

muc

h as

the

y in

fluen

ce b

ound

ary

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

Plat

e bo

unda

ry d

efor

mat

ions

77

7

eu

+

L H

/

Figu

re 1

. (a)

Str

ike-

slip,

and

(IJ)

unde

rthr

ust m

odes

of

plat

e bo

unda

ry a

s ide

aliz

ed in

thin

laye

r m

odel

.

cond

ition

s at

y =

0.

Also

sho

wn

in F

ig.

1 is

the

dire

ctio

n of

the

uni

form

pla

te m

otio

n at

sp

eed

V fa

r fr

om t

he p

late

bou

ndar

y, w

hich

driv

es t

he e

arth

quak

e cy

cle.

In

term

s of

th

ickn

ess-

aver

aged

stre

sses

and

shea

ring

tract

ions

, T

P,

actin

g on

the

low

er s

urfa

ce o

f th

e lit

hosp

heric

pla

te i

n th

e ne

gativ

e 0-

dire

ctio

n, th

e re

leva

nt e

xact

equ

ilibr

ium

equ

atio

ns in

the

plan

e of

the

plat

e ar

e

au,,/

ax,

= TP

/H.

(1)

Follo

win

g Ri

ce (

1980

), a

sim

plifi

ed c

oupl

ing

to a

Max

wel

lian

visc

oela

stic

asth

enos

pher

e is

now

ass

umed

thro

ugh

the

rela

tion

i,b/G

t

T,h/

q =

(2)

whe

re b

is

an e

ffec

tive

leng

th

for

shor

t-tim

e el

astic

cou

plin

g, w

hich

will

be

sele

cted

ap

prop

riate

ly f

urth

er b

elow

. Fo

r si

mpl

icity

we

shal

l as

sum

e he

re t

hat

the

shea

r m

odul

us

G at

tain

s a

unifo

rm v

alue

thro

ugho

ut th

e lit

hosp

here

and

ast

heno

sphe

re. F

or s

ubse

quen

t use

w

e de

fine

the

para

met

ers

a H

Gh/

q,

0 = bH

.

The

ratio

T =

p/a

det

erm

ines

the

rela

xatio

n tim

e in

an

Elsa

sser

-type

pla

te m

odel

that

invo

lves

a

Max

wel

lian

visc

oela

stic

foun

datio

n.

In t

he p

robl

ems

to b

e st

udie

d he

re,

as d

epic

ted

by F

ig.

1, th

ere

is on

ly o

ne n

on-z

ero

thic

knes

s-av

erag

ed d

ispl

acem

ent

com

pone

nt in

the

pla

ne o

f th

e pl

ate.

Thu

s, if

we

assu

me

a st

ate

of p

lane

stre

ss f

or th

e pl

ate,

the

stres

s-str

ain

rela

tions

for a

n is

otro

pic

elas

tic p

late

are

si

mpl

y

uxy

= G

au

/ay,

fo

r the

stri

ke-s

lip m

ode

(3a)

uyy =

[2/

(1 -v

)]G

au/a

y,

for t

he th

rust

mod

e.

(3b)

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

778

Subs

titut

ion

of (2

) an

d (3

) in

(1) t

hen

yiel

ds th

e di

ffer

entia

l equ

atio

n F.

K. L

ehne

r and

V. C

. Li

p2(a

+pa/

at)a

2u/a

y2 =

auja

t (4

)

whe

re p

2 3

1 f

or t

he s

trike

-slip

mod

e an

d p2

2/

(1 -

v)

for

the

thru

st m

ode.

It i

s see

n th

at

whe

n el

astic

pro

perti

es o

f th

e as

then

osph

ere

are

disr

egar

ded,

one

reco

vers

Elsa

sser

's (1

969)

di

ffus

ion

equa

tion

with

diff

usiv

ities

(Y fo

r th

e st

rike-

slip

mod

e an

d 2(

~/(1

- v) f

or th

e th

rust

m

ode,

an

equa

tion

empl

oyed

also

by

Bot

t &

Dea

n (1

973)

and

And

erso

n (1

975)

in st

udyi

ng

the

prop

agat

ion

of d

istu

rban

ces a

way

fro

m s

uch

plat

e bo

unda

ries.

Q

uite

obv

ious

ly t

here

are

a n

umbe

r of

sho

rtcom

ings

atta

ched

to o

ur m

odel

equ

atio

n (4

). It

is a

n eq

uatio

n in

a th

ickn

ess a

vera

ged

disp

lace

men

t an

d it

is ba

sed

on si

mpl

ifyin

g as

sum

p-

tions

, am

ong

othe

rs a

neg

lect

of

shea

r str

esse

s ux

y with

in t

he a

sthe

nosp

here

whi

ch, f

or th

e st

rike-

slip

mod

e, b

ecom

e im

port

ant

near

the

pla

te b

ound

ary.

We

emph

asiz

e, h

owev

er,.

that

we

sha

ll be

con

cern

ed w

ith q

uant

itativ

e as

pect

s of t

he p

late

def

orm

atio

n m

ostly

at d

ista

nces

of

the

ord

er o

f on

e lit

hosp

here

thi

ckne

ss f

rom

the

fau

lt, w

here

a p

late

the

ory

beco

mes

m

ore

appr

opria

te.

Also

, we

wish

to

take

adv

anta

ge h

ere

of th

e an

alyt

ical

sim

plic

ity o

f a o

ne-

dim

ensi

onal

m

odel

an

d se

arch

fo

r di

stin

ctiv

e qu

alita

tive

feat

ures

in

the

post

-sei

smic

de

form

atio

ns p

redi

cted

by

a th

in la

yer m

odel

, whi

ch la

ter m

ight

be

stud

ied

in g

reat

er d

etai

l.

3 A

perio

dic

solu

tion

repr

esen

ting a

n ea

rthq

uake

cyc

le

We

seek

a s

olut

ion

to e

quat

ion

(4)

desc

ribin

g th

e di

spla

cem

ent

in a

pla

te w

hich

mov

es a

t a

unifo

rm s

peed

V fa

r fr

om th

e pl

ate

boun

dary

, but

at t

he b

ound

ary

exhi

bits

a q

uasi

-per

iodi

c m

otio

n w

hich

is

sepa

rabl

e in

to a

com

pone

nt o

f un

iform

mot

ion

at s

peed

V a

nd a

stri

ctly

pe

riodi

c di

spla

cem

ent,

the

perio

d T

fixin

g th

e re

curr

ence

tim

e of

sei

smic

eve

nts i

n an

infin

ite

sequ

ence

of

eart

hqua

ke c

ycle

s. Th

e pe

riodi

c th

ickn

ess-

aver

aged

dis

plac

emen

t at

the

plat

e bo

unda

ry w

ill i

nvol

ve c

ontr

ibut

ions

fro

m c

osei

smic

slip

page

as

wel

l as

inte

rsei

smic

fau

lt cr

eep

and - a

t an

unde

rthr

ust b

ound

ary - fr

om a

sthe

nosp

here

read

just

men

ts in

the

verti

cal

plan

e y

= 0

(cf. F

ig.

1).

The

gene

ral

appe

aran

ce o

f a

plot

ver

sus

time

of t

he t

hick

ness

av

erag

ed d

ispl

acem

ent

u+ =

u(O

+, t

) on

the

y =

O* s

ide

of th

e pl

ate

boun

dary

will

thus

be

of

the

kind

ind

icat

ed b

y th

e do

tted

lines

in

Fig.

2(a

) sh

owin

g co

seism

ic s

hifts

of m

agni

tude

Au

+ a

t t =

n T

(n =

0, f

1, f 2

, . . .

). T

o fix

idea

s, co

nsid

er f

irst

a tra

nsfo

rm f

ault

rupt

urin

g do

wn

to d

epth

D (cf.

Fig.

1) d

urin

g ea

ch s

eism

ic e

vent

and

ther

eby

cont

ribu

ting

an a

vera

ge

disp

lace

men

t (ta

ken

over

the

who

le l

ithos

pher

e) e

qual

to

Au+

= u

(O+,

n T'

) - u

(O',

n T-)

on

the

y=

O+

sid

e of

the

fau

lt. S

ubse

quen

tly,

cree

p on

dee

per

sect

ions

of

the

faul

t will

ac

coun

t fo

r a

furt

her,

inte

rsei

smic

ave

rage

dis

plac

emen

t, al

thou

gh th

e up

per s

ectio

ns o

f the

(a 1

(b)

(C)

Figu

re 2

. Sy

nthe

sis

of t

hick

ness

-ave

rage

d fa

ult

disp

lace

men

t, (a

) by

sup

erpo

sitio

n of

str

ictly

per

iodi

c di

spla

cem

ent,

(b)

of

'ele

men

tary

ea

rthq

uake

seq

uenc

e'

and

(c)

linea

rly

incr

easin

g di

spla

cem

ent

of

unifo

rm p

late

mot

ion.

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

Plat

e bo

unda

ry d

efor

mat

ions

77

9

faul

t may

rem

ain

lock

ed b

etw

een

seism

ic e

vent

s. N

ot e

noug

h se

ems t

o be

kno

wn

abou

t the

se

inte

rsei

smic

his

torie

s an

d fo

r thi

s rea

son

we

shal

l dea

l her

e on

ly w

ith th

e ap

prox

imat

ion

of a

lin

ear i

nter

seis

mic

dis

plac

emen

t-tim

e re

latio

n as

rep

rese

nted

by

the

solid

line

s in

Fig.

2 (a

). Th

is in

clud

es t

he e

xtre

me

case

of

a ve

ry r

apid

pos

t-sei

smic

cre

ep a

djus

tmen

t al

ong

the

deep

er s

ectio

ns o

f th

e fa

ult,

in w

hich

Au+

= VT

and

the

plat

e re

spon

ds q

uasi

-sta

tistic

ally

as

for

a ru

ptur

e de

pth

D =

H. W

hen

D <

H, t

hen

on th

e as

sum

ptio

n of

neg

ligib

le i

nter

seis

mic

sli

p on

the

rupt

ure

surf

ace

one

has

u+ =

H-'

For g

reat

und

erth

rust

eve

nts,

on

the

othe

r han

d,

[u'(O

+, z,

n T

+) - u'

(O+,

z, n

T-)]

dz

= V

TD/H

.

u+=

VT

(6)

wou

ld

seem

a r

easo

nabl

e ap

prox

imat

ion

in v

iew

of

the

gene

rally

lar

ger

ratio

D/H

of

dow

n-di

p ru

ptur

e w

idth

to

litho

sphe

re t

hick

ness

(se

e, e

.g.

Dav

ies

& H

ouse

197

9; S

penc

e 19

77).

Fig.

2 i

llust

rate

s the

man

ner i

n w

hich

the

act

ual p

late

bou

ndar

y di

spla

cem

ent

is vi

ewed

as

a su

perp

ositi

on o

f st

rictly

per

iodi

c di

spla

cem

ent

ue

, for

min

g an

'ele

men

tary

ear

thqu

ake

sequ

ence

', an

d a

disp

lace

men

t ur

n whi

ch in

crea

ses a

t a u

nifo

rm ra

te V

, pre

cise

ly a

s for

mul

ated

pr

evio

usly

by

Sava

ge &

Pre

scot

t (1

978)

. Th

is d

ecom

posi

tion

mak

es c

lear

tha

t it

suff

ices

to

obta

in s

olut

ions

to

equa

tion

(4)

for

the

stric

tly p

erio

dic

boun

dary

dis

plac

emen

t u e

. Fo

r fin

ite T

thes

e va

nish

at

infin

ity, b

ut a

ddin

g ur

n eve

ryw

here

will

pro

duce

the

plat

e's r

espo

nse

to t

he b

ound

ary

cond

ition

fur

nish

ed b

y th

e so

lidly

dra

wn

line

in F

ig. 2

(a).

Inde

ed, w

hile

fu

lly d

eter

min

ing

stra

ins

and

stra

in

rate

s, t

he s

olut

ion

for

the

elem

enta

ry e

arth

quak

e se

quen

ce u

e w

ill y

ield

a d

ispl

acem

ent

mea

sure

d w

ith r

espe

ct t

o a

line

norm

al t

o th

e fa

ult

and

atta

ched

to

an o

bser

ver

'sitti

ng o

n th

e pl

ate'

at a

lar

ge d

ista

nce

from

a t

rans

form

bo

unda

ry. B

earin

g th

is in

min

d w

e no

w c

onsi

der

a so

lutio

n to

(4) o

f the

form

U(Y

, t)

= U

YY

, t>

+ u

"W +

U"Y

) (7

)

whe

re u

'(y)

is a

time-

inde

pend

ent

disp

lace

men

t th

at d

epen

ds o

n th

e ch

oice

of

refe

renc

e st

ate

and

~'(

0)

=

0. F

urth

erm

ore,

u"(t)

= Vt

- %

Au+

(8

)

and

u"

(y, t)

is

a so

lutio

n fo

r th

e el

emen

tary

ear

thqu

ake

sequ

ence

as

repr

esen

ted

by t

he

Four

ier

serie

s Au+

rn

1

7r n

=l

n ue

(O+,

t) =

~ - s

in(2

nnt/

T)

whi

ch is

the

perio

dic

exte

nsio

n of

the

func

tion

as s

how

n in

Fig

. 2(b

). A

sol

utio

n to

(4),

subj

ect

to (

9) m

ay n

ow b

e ob

tain

ed in

a m

anne

r sim

ilar

to t

hat

disc

usse

d by

Car

slaw

& J

aege

r (1

959,

sec

tion

2.6)

fo

r he

at c

ondu

ctio

n pr

oble

ms

with

tim

e-pe

riodi

c bo

unda

ry

cond

ition

s.

Acc

ordi

ngly

, we

co

nsid

er

first

a pa

rticu

lar s

olut

ion

of th

e fo

rm

u"

(y, t)

=u,(

y/d)

exp(

inw

t),

w=

2n/T

, ~

'=p

/"'~

. (1

0)

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

780

Subs

titut

ing

ths i

n (4

) we

get

F. K

. Leh

nera

nd V

. C. L

i

v”-A

Z,v,

= 0

,

AZ, =

in a/( 1/r +

in a).

Then

uE(y

, t) =

A,

exp

I- [R

e A, t

i Im

A,]

y/d

1 exp

(in a

t)

Reh

, --fy, =

f {

[l +

(1+

e~

)1/2

]/2(

1+e~

)}1/

2

Imh,

--fq

, =

-fe,

/i?-

(ite

~)[~

+(i

+e~

)~/~

]t~/

~ 0,

= T/

(2nn

r).

A re

al s

olut

ion,

van

ishin

g at

infi

nity

and

sat

isfy

ing

Au+

nn

u,

(O+,

t) =

~ sin

(2nn

t/T

)

is ob

tain

ed f

rom

(13

) for

iA,

= A

u”/n

n as

Au+

uE

( y, t

) = _

_ e

xp (-

Y, y

/d) s

in (2

n n t/

T - 77

, y/

d).

nn

Hen

ce, b

y su

perp

ositi

on,

Au+

- 1

n n

=ln

u

e(y,

t)=

~

1 - e

xp(-

yny/

d)si

n(2n

nr/T

-r),

y/d)

(13)

(14)

furn

ishe

s th

e so

lutio

n to

equ

atio

n (4

) fo

r th

e el

emen

tary

ear

thqu

ake

sequ

ence

(1)

. W

ritin

g th

is a

s a

Four

ier

serie

s, bu

t ob

serv

ing

that

the

sin

e se

ries

conv

erge

s to

war

ds a

pie

cew

ise

cont

inuo

us f

unct

ion

with

jum

p di

scon

tinui

ties

at t

= n

T, o

ne c

an w

rite

(15)

as th

e su

m o

f a

piec

ewise

co

ntin

uous

fun

ctio

n ue

(O+

, t) ex

p (-

y/d)

and

a c

ontin

uous

fun

ctio

n so

tha

t w

ithin

the

inte

rval

0 G

t Q

T

m

ue(v

, t) =

A,+

( 1 - i

) exp (-

y/d)

- A

u+

[a, c

os (2

nntl

T) +

6, s

in (2

rznt

/T)]

n

= 1

1 nn

1 nn

an =

-’ ~

XP

(.

- Yn ~

/d

)

sin (77

, ~

/d

)

(16)

6, =

- [

~X

P

(-~

/d) - ~

XP

&

Yn ~

/d

)

cos (7

7, .~

/d)l

.

Clea

rly, a

t la

rge

enou

gh n

such

that

0,

e 1,

7, -, I - 3/

26,

and

77, +

%On

. As

see

n fr

om (1

2),

the

limits

0, +

0 a

nd h

ence

the

limits

7, +

1 a

nd 77

, +

0 m

ay a

lso b

e in

terp

rete

d in

term

s of

a ve

ry l

arge

rel

axat

ion

time 7. T

he F

ourie

r co

effic

ient

s van

ish i

n th

is li

mit

and

this

mak

es

clea

r th

at i

t is

esse

ntia

lly t

he s

erie

s te

rm i

n (1

6) w

hich

fur

nish

es t

he c

ontr

ibut

ion

to th

e di

spla

cem

ent

due

to v

iscoe

lasti

c re

laxa

tion.

To

fin

d th

e co

seism

ic d

ispl

acem

ent

jum

p at

any

loca

tion

y 2 0

, we

eval

uate

(16

) at t

= 0

an

d t =

T a

nd th

us o

btai

n

Au

(y)=

ue(

-~?,

O

)-ue

(y, T

) = A

u* e

xp(-

y/d)

. (1

7)

This

exp

ress

ion

repr

esen

ts a

n in

stan

tane

ous

elas

tost

atic

resp

onse

to

a su

dden

slip

eve

nt o

n th

e fa

ult.

As s

uch

it m

ust

obvi

ousl

y be

inde

pend

ent o

f rel

axat

ion

prop

ertie

s of

the

asth

eno-

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

Plat

e bo

unda

ry d

efor

mat

ions

78

1 sp

here

and

inde

ed m

ust

coin

cide

, as

it do

es, w

ith th

e ze

ro-ti

me

solu

tion

for a

sing

le is

olat

ed

slip

even

t as g

iven

pre

viou

sly

by L

ehne

r et a

l. Th

e to

tal

disp

lace

men

t as

def

ined

by

(7)

may

now

be

obta

ined

by

addi

ng t

o (1

6) t

he

expr

essio

ns fo

r u"(

t) an

d uo

(y).

For

the

for

mer

we

have

from

(5)

and

(8),

whi

le f

or u

o(y)

we

sele

ct

1 2 uo

((y)

= - A

u' [

l -ex

p(-y

/d)]

.

Acc

ordi

ngly

u(y,

t) =

Au+

[l-e

xp(-

y/d)

] +

Au+

C[.

. .],

0

9 1

9 T

T

whe

re t

he s

erie

s is

the

sam

e as

in (

16).

Her

e uo

((y)

has

been

sel

ecte

d so

as t

o m

ake

u(y,

t =

Term

by

term

diff

eren

tiatio

n of

(19)

now

yie

lds

the

follo

win

g ex

pres

sion

for

the

stra

in:

0')

= 0.

au

nu

+

y(y

t)=

-=-

' ay

d

[a;

cos(

2nnt

/T)

+ b;

sin (

2nnt

/T)]

a; =

da,/d

(y/d

),

b; =

db,

/d(y

/d).

(20)

The

cose

ism

ic e

last

osta

tic ju

mp

in s

train

is g

iven

by

MY

) = (v

, 0) - Y

(Y,T

) = - (A

u+/d

) exp

(-Y/

d)

and

is se

en to

diff

er f

rom

the

disp

lace

men

t jum

p (1

7) in

sig

n an

d by

a fa

ctor

l/d

.

by v

irtue

of r

elat

ions

(3) a

nd (2

1), i

s giv

en b

y B

oth

ue

and

y m

ay a

lso b

e ex

pres

sed

in t

erm

s of

a 's

tress

dro

p' A

a at

the

faul

t, w

hich

,

AU E

uap(

T, 0

') - ~

~p(0

,O')

= A

u'G

/d.

(22)

How

ever

, si

nce

uap

repr

esen

ts a

mea

n st

ress

whi

ch, e

spec

ially

for

the

cas

e D

< H

, is

not

easil

y re

late

d qu

antit

ativ

ely

to f

ault

stre

sses

, it

seem

s pr

efer

able

to

reta

in t

he d

ispl

acem

ent

jum

p A

u+ in

the

abov

e ex

pres

sion

s. Fi

nally

, by

ter

mw

ise

diff

eren

tiatio

n of

(20

) w

ith r

espe

ct t

o tim

e an

d an

app

ropr

iate

ex

tract

ion

of a

pie

cew

ise c

ontin

uous

par

t, w

e ob

tain

an

expr

essi

on f

or th

e st

rain

rat

e of

the

form

Au'

-

-_

_

[a,

cos(

2nnt

/T)

+ (3,

sin

(2nn

t/T

)]

rd

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

782

The

cose

ism

ic ju

mp

in th

e st

rain

rate

is fo

und

to be

F. K

. Leh

nera

nd V

. C. Li

Ai.

(y) =

+(y

, O)-

j.(y

, T

) = 2 7

d

4 D

iscus

sion

and

com

paris

on o

f thi

n la

yer a

nd h

alf-

spac

e m

odel

s

In p

roce

edin

g no

w to

a d

iscu

ssio

n of

thes

e re

sults

we

first

em

phas

ize

agai

n th

at th

e un

ilate

ral

disp

lace

men

t jum

p A

u+ ap

pear

ing

in e

quat

ions

(16

), (1

7) a

nd (

19)-(

24)

is to

be

view

ed as

gi

ven

eith

er b

y re

latio

n (5

) or

(6)

in t

erm

s of

the

quan

titie

s V

, T an

d D

/H, w

hich

we

rega

rd

as k

now

n. B

ut it

is c

onve

nien

t to

def

er th

is s

ubst

itutio

n fo

r Au+

until

con

side

ratio

n is

give

n to

a pa

rticu

lar

case

. W

e sh

all

base

sub

sequ

ent

quan

titat

ive

inte

rpre

tatio

ns o

f ou

r re

sults

on

the

num

eric

al

valu

es q

= 2

.0 x

lOI9

Pas

(2.

0 x

10''

pois

e) f

or t

he v

isco

sity

of

the

asth

enos

pher

e an

d G

= 5

.5 x

10"

Pa

for

the

shea

r mod

ulus

of

the

crus

t an

d up

per

man

tle, s

o th

at v

/G =

10 y

r in

agr

eem

ent w

ith a

rece

nt e

stim

ate

of T

hatc

her

el a

l. (1

980)

bas

ed o

n ea

rthqu

ake

load

ing

data

. Fu

rther

mor

e, w

e sh

all

assu

me

H=

30km

for

the

thi

ckne

ss o

f th

e lit

hosp

here

and

h

= 1

50 km

for

the

low

vis

cosi

ty l

ayer

(as

then

osph

ere)

. Th

ese

estim

ates

yie

ld T =

fl/a

= 10

b/h

yr f

or t

he r

elax

atio

n tim

e of

the

thin

laye

r mod

el a

nd if

b is

giv

en th

e va

lue

(n/2

)'H,

as is

pro

pose

d fu

rthe

r bel

ow, o

ne h

as T

= 5 y

r fo

r the

thin

laye

r mod

el.

In F

ig. 3

a p

lot

of th

e no

rmal

ized

per

iodi

c so

lutio

n (1

6) v

ersu

s tim

e is

show

n an

d th

is is

be

st i

nter

pret

ed i

n te

rms o

f the

dis

plac

emen

ts m

easu

red

with

resp

ect t

o a

line,

per

pend

icul

ar

to a

tran

sfor

m f

ault

and

mov

ing

alon

g w

ith a

rem

ote

poin

t (y +

-)

on th

e pl

ate.

The

figu

re

repr

esen

ts a

sin

gle

earth

quak

e cy

cle

and

its p

erio

dic

exte

nsio

n to

the

right

and

to

the

left

will

the

refo

re c

onst

itute

an

infin

ite e

arth

quak

e se

quen

ce.

The

stric

tly s

ymm

etric

per

iodi

c m

otio

n im

pose

d by

con

ditio

n (9

) at

y/d

= 0

giv

es w

ay t

o a

char

acte

ristic

dam

ping

and

ph

ase

lag

beha

viou

r w

ith g

row

ing

dist

ance

s fr

om t

he f

ault,

the

latte

r eff

ect b

eing

sole

ly d

ue

to a

sthe

nosp

here

rel

axat

ion.

Whe

n m

easu

red

in t

he m

ovin

g co

ordi

nate

sys

tem

of

Fig.

3,

disp

lace

men

ts w

ill t

hus

cont

inue

to

grow

'co

-dire

ctio

nally

', i.e

. in

the

dire

ctio

n of

the

0.4 7

7

U'/h

U+

0.2

-0.4

tn\

i

c 4 0

0 0.

25

0.5

0.75

1 TI

ME

t/T

Figu

re 3

. T

imep

erio

dic

thic

knes

s-av

erag

ed d

ispla

cem

ent

in e

lem

enta

ry e

arth

quak

e cy

cle

at v

ariou

s di

stan

ces from

the

faul

t. R

epea

t tim

e 15

0 yr

.

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

Plat

e bo

unda

ry d

efor

mat

ions

78

3

-0.4

ue/A

u+

-0.2

m B 2 z Q

0,2

@ 0.

0

a

0.4

- 0.4

u'/A

u+

- 0.2

M z; @

0.0

3 ti la 0<

2

0.4

0 1

2 3

4 5

DIS

TAN

CE

y/d

0 1

2 3

4 5

DIST

ANCE

j/

d

Figu

re 4

. T

hick

ness

-ave

rage

d dis

plac

emen

t in

elem

enta

ry ea

rthq

uake

cycl

e as a

func

tion

of d

ista

nce f

rom

th

e fa

ult,

at v

ario

us ti

mes

. Rep

eat t

imes

: (a)

150

yr; (

b) 4

0 yr

.

cose

ismic

dis

plac

emen

t, bu

t, af

ter

atta

inin

g a

max

imum

whi

ch d

epen

ds o

n th

e di

stanc

e fro

m th

e fa

ult,

will

sw

ing

back

. The

cos

eism

ic ju

mp

in (t

otal

) di

spla

cem

ent,

as g

iven

by

the

simpl

e ex

pone

ntia

l re

latio

n (1

7),

may

also

be

read

off

Fig

. 3

by t

akin

g th

e di

ffere

nce

betw

een

the

func

tion

valu

es a

t t =

0 a

nd t

= T

for

any

giv

en r

atio

y/d

. So

me

of t

hese

pr

oper

ties

appe

ar, h

owev

er, m

ore

clea

rly o

n a

plot

of t

he sa

me

disp

lace

men

t ver

sus d

istan

ce

from

the

fau

lt as

sho

wn

in F

ig.

4 fo

r re

peat

tim

es o

f 15

0 an

d 40

yr,

resp

ectiv

ely.

The

du

ratio

n of

a c

ycle

cle

arly

gov

erns

the

'pen

etra

tion

dept

h' o

f sig

nific

ant d

ispl

acem

ent.

Sinc

e th

e co

seism

ic d

ispla

cem

ent

jum

p ac

cord

ing

to e

quat

ion

(17)

is

unaf

fect

ed b

y re

peat

tim

e,

this

diff

eren

ce i

n pe

netra

tion

dept

h is

entir

ely

due

to t

he f

arth

er s

prea

d of

sig

nific

ant

rela

xatio

n in

the

asth

enos

pher

e du

ring

the

long

er c

ycle

. Thi

s also

poi

nts

to th

e di

ffic

ulty

of

infe

rring

mag

nitu

des

of p

ost-s

eism

ic m

otio

ns d

ue to

sub

crus

tal r

elax

atio

n pr

oces

ses

from

a

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

784

‘sin

gle-

even

t mod

el’ o

f fa

ultin

g at

a p

late

bou

ndar

y. S

uch

mod

els

will

tend

to

over

estim

ate

mot

ions

due

to

rela

xatio

n an

d in

deed

may

dis

play

a s

ensi

tivity

to

a sp

ectru

m o

f rel

axat

ion

times

, pe

rhap

s re

sem

blin

g st

ratif

icat

ion

effe

cts,

whi

ch w

ould

be

dras

tical

ly r

educ

ed i

n th

e ca

se o

f an

ear

thqu

ake

sequ

ence

to

a re

spon

se g

over

ned

sole

ly b

y la

yers

with

rela

xatio

n tim

es

shor

ter t

han

the

cycl

e le

ngth

. A f

urth

er im

port

ant

redu

ctio

n of

thi

s pe

netr

atio

n de

pth

will

of c

ours

e be

due

to th

e fin

ite le

ngth

of r

eal r

uptu

res.

How

ever

, as a

lread

y ap

pare

nt fr

om F

ig.

4, s

ome

of t

he m

ost

inte

rest

ing

obse

rvab

le d

efor

mat

iona

l fe

atur

es m

ay o

ccur

at l

ocat

ions

ar

ound

y =

2d,

i.e.

app

roxi

mat

ely

3 lit

hosp

here

thi

ckne

sses

fro

m a

(tra

nsfo

rm)

faul

t. Fo

r ru

ptur

e le

ngth

s of

sev

eral

hun

dred

kilo

met

res (

grea

t ea

rthqu

akes

) the

cro

ss-s

ectio

nal m

odels

di

scus

sed

here

will

ther

efor

e be

mea

ning

ful.

In F

ig. 5

the

tota

l thi

ckne

ss av

erag

ed d

ispl

acem

ent

acco

rdin

g to

(19)

has

bee

n pl

otte

d an

d m

ay b

e co

mpa

red

with

the

sur

face

dis

plac

emen

ts p

redi

cted

by

the

half-

spac

e mod

el (d

ashe

d lin

es)

for

the

sam

e tim

e ra

tio T

, TG

/q =

15 a

s w

ell

as f

or t

he li

mit

case

T, +

0 o

f pur

ely

elas

tic r

espo

nse

(dot

ted

lines

). W

e ha

ve o

mitt

ed t

he t

ime-

depe

nden

t co

ntri

butio

n fro

m th

e se

cond

te

rm i

n (1

9)

arisi

ng

from

fau

lt cr

eep

at d

epth

, as

sum

ing D=H, i.e

. a

rapid

post

-sei

smic

adj

ustm

ent.

Thes

e se

ts o

f cur

ves a

re la

belle

d by

val

ues o

f f/T

in s

teps

of

1/10

of T

and

evol

ve fr

om th

e ze

ro r

efer

ence

lin

e at

t =

O+,

i.e.

im

med

iate

ly a

fter

the

last

eve

nt, t

o a

final

sha

pe a

t t =

T,

i.e.

just

bef

ore

the

next

eve

nt d

urin

g w

hich

the

dis

plac

emen

t w

ill j

ump

to t

he v

alue

u/A

u+ =

1 ev

eryw

here

. Sur

face

dis

plac

emen

ts f

or t

he p

urel

y el

astic

hal

f-sp

ace

are

show

n on

ly f

or ti

mes

t =

0, 0

.1 T

, 0.2

T, a

nd f

or t

= T

whe

n th

e di

spla

cem

ent

beco

mes

inde

pend

ent

F. K

. Leh

nera

nd V

. C. Li

0.0

u/Au

+

02

W

0

a

0.6

0

0.8

10

0

I 2

3

4

5

DIS

TAN

CE

y/

d Fi

gure

5.

Tota

l th

ickn

ess-

aver

aged

disp

lace

men

t fo

r th

in la

yer

mod

el (

solid

line

s) a

nd

men

ts fo

r ha

lf-sp

ace

mod

el (d

ashe

d lin

es; d

otte

d lin

es fo

r el

astic

hal

f-spa

ce) a

s fun

ctio

ns

the

faul

t at

succ

essiv

e tim

es fr

om t

= 0

to t

= T

= 15

0 yr

(in

crem

ent 0

.1 T

).

surfa

ce di

splace

of

dista

nce f

mm

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

Plat

e bo

unda

ry d

efor

mat

ioiis

78

5

of t

he p

aram

eter

T,.

For

the

thin

lay

er m

odel

the

cos

eism

ic ju

mp

from

U(J

~, T

)/A

u' to

1 .O

is

of c

ours

e th

at g

iven

by

the

expo

nent

ial

in e

quat

ion

(17)

. Fo

r th

e ha

lf-sp

ace

mod

pl t

he

resu

lt of

Spe

nce

& T

urco

tte (

thei

r equ

atio

n 5.

3), w

hen

wri

tten

in o

ur n

otat

ion,

is

a(5)

In t

he e

last

ic li

mit

of T

, -+ 0

this

bec

omes

exp (-

t) s

inh .$

, 0

-G t Q

T.

(36)

2A

u't

'ITT

arct

an (

y/H

),

0 Q

t Q

T.

- ___

The

surf

ace

stra

ins

pred

icte

d by

the

half-

spac

e mod

el a

re o

btai

ned

by d

iffer

entia

tion

of (

25)

and

in th

e el

astic

lim

it Ts

+ 0

one

has

dire

ctly

from

(26)

the

sim

ple

resu

lt

au

2 Au'

t 1

3.Y

'ITH

T 1 +

(y/H

P

Yb, t)

= - (

Y, t

) = ~

and

henc

e th

e ju

mp

in s

train

for

the

half-

spac

e mod

el

This

resu

lt is

now

use

d fo

r det

erm

inin

g th

e ef

fect

ive

elas

tic th

ickn

ess 6

whi

ch e

nter

s int

o th

e th

in l

ayer

mod

el t

hrou

gh e

quat

ion

(2),

but

has

been

lef

t un

spec

ified

so

far.

We

fix 6

by

requ

iring

tha

t th

e ju

mps

(21)

and

(28

) pre

dict

ed b

y th

e tw

o m

odel

s mat

ch a

t the

fau

lt, th

at

is at

y =

0.

Sinc

e, u

nder

the

ass

umpt

ion D

=H

, the

jum

p in

dis

plac

emen

t ha

s th

e sa

me

mag

nitu

de A

u+ fo

r bot

h m

odel

s, it

is se

en th

at th

is m

atch

requ

ires

d =

p"' =

('IT

/Z)H

or

b

= (n

/2)'

H.

(29)

It wi

ll be

not

iced

tha

t fo

r th

e pr

esen

t di

sloc

atio

n pr

oble

m t

he a

ppro

pria

te el

astic

thic

knes

s b i

s fou

r tim

es la

rger

than

it is

for t

he a

nalo

gous

cra

ck p

robl

em (L

ehne

r et a

l. 19

81 ).

Here

and

subs

eque

ntly

it s

houl

d be

kep

t in

min

d th

at a

ll di

spla

cem

ents

disc

usse

d fo

r the

ha

lf-sp

ace m

odel

are

sur

face

dis

plac

emen

ts.

In p

lotti

ng th

ese

in F

ig. 5

the

argu

men

t ji

/H h

ad

to b

e re

plac

ed b

y (n

/2)y

/d so

that

the

com

paris

on w

ith th

e th

in la

yer

mod

el p

erta

ins

to th

e str

ike-

slip m

ode,

whi

le th

e so

lutio

n (1

9) re

mai

ns o

f cou

rse

valid

inde

pend

ently

for

the

thru

st

mod

e, if

d is

take

n eq

ual t

o 1/

(1-

v)nH

/2. T

he c

osei

smic

jum

p in

sur

face

dis

plac

emen

t fo

r the

hal

f-spa

ce m

odel

app

ears

in F

ig. 5

and

is g

iven

by

Au(

y)=

Au*

{1-(2

/7r)

arct

an [

(n/2

)j?/

d]}.

(3

0)

A co

mpa

rison

with

the

jum

p (1

7) f

or t

he t

hin

laye

r m

odel

sho

ws

that

the

lat

ter

pred

icts

so

mew

hat

too

larg

e po

st-s

eism

ic d

ispl

acem

ents

at

grea

ter

dist

ance

s fr

om t

he f

ault.

With

in

abou

t tw

o lit

hosp

here

thi

ckne

sses

fro

m t

he f

ault,

how

ever

, th

e di

scre

panc

y in

tot

al p

ost-

sei

smic

disp

lace

men

t at

t =

T re

mai

ns s

mal

l for

the

tw

o m

odel

s. In

con

tras

t her

ewith

, pos

t- sei

smic

disp

lace

men

ts e

arlie

r in

the

cycl

e di

ffer

ver

y m

arke

dly

as m

ay b

e se

en f

rom

the

att

itude

of

the

plot

s fo

r t/T

= 0

.1 a

nd 0

.2, f

or e

xam

ple.

Thi

s per

mits

us

to c

oncl

ude

that

the

28

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

786

F. K

. Leh

ner a

nd V

. C. L

i

0.6

yd/A

u+ 0.2

0.0

i

--4

-02

I- 0

1 2

3

4 5

DIST

ANCE

v/

d -,

Fip

re 6

. Th

ickn

ess-

aver

aged

str

ain

for

thin

lay

er m

odel

as

a fu

ncti

on o

f di

stan

ce f

rom

the

fau

lt, at

va

riou

s tim

es. R

epea

t ti

me

150

yr.

Das

hed

line

repr

esen

ts to

tal

elas

tic s

urfa

ce s

trai

n ac

cum

ulat

ed during

sam

e ea

rthq

uake

cycl

e ac

cord

ing

to h

alf-

spac

e m

odel

.

thin

lay

er m

odel

exh

ibits

a g

enui

ne s

tratif

icat

ion

effe

ct w

hich

man

ifest

s its

elf

durin

g the

ea

rlier

par

t of

an

eart

hqua

ke c

ycle

in

an a

mpl

ifica

tion

and

conc

entr

atio

n of

pos

t-seis

mic

disp

lace

men

ts n

ear

the

faul

t. Th

e am

ount

of v

iscoe

lasti

c re

laxa

tion

may

be

infe

rred

for e

ach

mod

el u

pon

com

parin

g, a

t t/

T =

0.1

or

0.2,

the

rele

vant

cur

ves w

ith th

e do

tted

lines

for t

he

pure

ly e

last

ic re

spon

se.

In F

ig. 6

the

dim

ensi

onle

ss s

train

, acc

ordi

ng t

o eq

uatio

n (2

0),

is pl

otte

d ve

rsus

dist

ance

fr

om t

he f

ault

for

vario

us t

imes

t/T

. Cor

resp

ondi

ng t

o ou

r ch

oice

of

refe

renc

e sta

te, th

is st

rain

is

zero

at

t = O

+ ju

st a

fter

the

even

t. Th

e va

lue

of y

at

t = T

is th

eref

ore

iden

tical

in m

agni

tude

with

the

stra

in ju

mp

as g

iven

by

(21)

. Thi

s m

ay b

e co

mpa

red

with

the

dashe

d lin

e, r

epre

sent

ing

the

tota

l ac

cum

ulat

ed s

urfa

ce s

train

for

the

hal

f-sp

ace

mod

el a

t t=

T ac

cord

ing

to (

27)

with

y n

orm

aliz

ed b

y d

= (n

/2)H

, as a

ppro

pria

te fo

r the

stri

ke-s

lip mo

de.

Clos

e to

the

faul

t, th

at is

at y

< H

the

tot

al s

train

acc

umul

atio

n di

ffer

s on

ly sl

ight

ly fo

r the

two

mod

els,

the

disc

repa

ncy

read

ing

at 6

per

cen

t at

y =

H. B

eyon

d th

is d

istan

ce th

e post

. se

ismic

stra

ins

pred

icte

d by

the

thi

n la

yer

mod

el a

re l

ikel

y to

be

affe

cted

by

the

large

r re

lativ

e di

scre

panc

y in

cos

eisr

nic

disp

lace

men

t be

twee

n th

e tw

o m

odel

s an

d ar

e the

refore

le

ss s

uite

d fo

r qua

ntita

tive

com

paris

ons.

Ther

e ar

e, h

owev

er, q

ualit

ativ

e fe

atur

es o

f inte

rest,

amon

g w

hich

we

notic

e sig

n re

vers

al o

f po

st-s

eism

ic s

train

s whi

ch, a

s is

also

appa

rent

from

Fig.

5, i

s du

e to

ast

heno

sphe

re r

elax

atio

n. In

the

refe

renc

e sy

stem

sel

ecte

d he

re, t

he st

rain

will

atta

in m

easu

rabl

e ne

gativ

e va

lues

that

per

sist o

ver l

arge

fra

ctio

ns o

f an

earth

quak

e cycl

e at

gre

ater

dis

tanc

es f

rom

the

fau

lt. A

gain

, as

with

dis

plac

emen

t, th

e pe

netra

tion

depth

of

sign

ifica

nt p

ost-s

eism

ic s

train

s will

incr

ease

stro

ngly

with

cyc

le le

ngth

. O

f pa

rticu

lar

inte

rest

is

the

beha

viou

r of

the

stra

in r

ate

give

n by

(23

) wh

en p

lottad

ag

ains

t di

stan

ce f

rom

the

pla

te b

ound

ary

as in

Fig

. 7 f

or tw

o di

ffer

ent r

epea

t tim

es. M

ost

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

Plat

e bo

unda

ry d

efor

mat

ions

78

7

0.06

0.04

+d/Au+

0.02

F 2 0.00

rn -0

.02

8 -0.04

-0.0

% 0

1 2

3 4

5 D

ISTA

NC

E y

/d

0.06

OB4

%d/

Au+

0.02

-0,02

-0-04

-0.06

c 1 1

0 1

2 3

4 5

DIST

ANCE

?/

a Fi

gure

7. T

hick

ness

-ave

rage

d str

ain

rate

for

thi

n la

yer

mod

el a

s a

func

tion

of d

istan

ce fr

om th

e fa

ult,

at

vario

us ti

mes

. Rep

eat t

ime:

(a)

150

yr; (

b) 4

0 yr

.

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

788

F. K

. Leh

ner a

nd V

. C. Li

0.08

0.06

T-r

d/A

u+

0.04

-0,0

2

-0,0

4

-0,0

6 0

0.25

0.

5 0,

75

1

TIME t/T

08

8

0.06

jrd/

Au+

0.04

E 0.

02

vl

0'00

8 -0

82

0 0.

25

0.5

0.75

1

TIME

t/T

Figu

re 8

. Tim

e-pe

riod

ic th

ickn

ess-

aver

aged

stra

in r

ate

for

thin

lay

er m

odel

for

one

ear

thqu

ake C

ycle,

at va

rious

dist

ance

s fro

m th

e fa

ult.

Rep

eat t

ime:

(a)

150

yr; @

) 40

yr.

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

Plat

e bo

unda

ry d

efor

mat

ions

78

9

cons

picu

ous

is th

e ap

pear

ance

of

the

cose

ismic

jum

p, g

iven

by

equa

tion

(24)

, whi

ch a

ttain

s its

max

imum

Au+

/(Td

) at y

= 0

, rev

erse

s its

sig

n at

y =

d a

nd r

each

es a

noth

er p

rono

unce

d ex

trem

um

at

y =

2d

of

mag

nitu

de

exp

(- 2

) Au+

/(2d

T). T

hese

lo

catio

ns

and

jum

p m

agni

tude

s ar

e in

depe

nden

t of

rep

eat

time

and

inde

ed w

ould

be

of t

he s

ame

for

a sin

gle

even

t. Th

e st

rain

rat

es t

hem

selv

es a

nd t

heir

tem

pora

l dec

line

will

, how

ever

, dep

end

stro

ngly

on

repe

at ti

me

as m

ay b

e se

en f

rom

the

two

plot

s.

A p

erha

ps s

urpr

isin

g fe

atur

e is

the

jum

p ex

trem

um a

t y

= 2d

, tha

t is

at c

onsi

dera

ble

dist

ance

fro

m t

he f

ault.

For

a g

reat

ear

thqu

ake

with

Au+

= 4

m, s

ay, a

nd o

ur c

hoic

e of

5 y

r fo

r th

e re

laxa

tion

time

T,

the

jum

p in

stra

in r

ate

at y

= 2

d w

ill b

e yr

-',

i.e. j

ust

mea

sura

ble,

at

leas

t fo

r th

e lo

nger

rep

eat

time

of 1

50 y

r, w

hen

pres

eism

ic s

train

rat

es a

re

negl

igib

ly s

mal

l. An

atte

mpt

to

dete

ct a

fea

ture

suc

h as

the

pron

ounc

ed e

xtre

mum

in A

T at

y=

2d

by

mon

itorin

g st

rain

rat

es a

long

a s

urve

y lin

e pe

rpen

dicu

lar

to t

he f

ault

wou

ld

ther

efor

e se

em q

uite

just

ified

. In

Fig

. 8

norm

aliz

ed s

train

rat

es a

re p

lotte

d ag

ains

t tim

e fo

r va

rious

dis

tanc

es f

rom

the

faul

t. Cl

early

, a

few

mea

sure

men

ts d

urin

g th

e fir

st y

ears

fol

low

ing

the

even

t w

ith a

rep

eat

time

of 1

50 y

r w

ill s

uffic

e. E

xtra

pola

ting

back

to

t = 0'

and

dete

rmin

ing

the

loca

tion

ym

, sa

y w

here

the

(ne

gativ

e) s

train

rat

e ju

mp

of g

reat

est

mag

nitu

de I

AT I,,,

occu

rred

, one

has

th

e es

timat

es

and

from

I AT

Im =

exp

(- 2

) Au+

/(? d7

):

r -- 2

Au+

/(15

ym 1 A

T lm).

(32)

Nex

t we

show

that

the

half-

spac

e mod

el p

redi

cts a

qua

litat

ivel

y sim

ilar b

ehav

iour

for

sur

face

str

ain

rate

s, b

ut t

hat

ther

e ar

e si

gnifi

cant

qua

ntita

tive

diff

eren

ces

betw

een

thes

e an

d th

e av

erag

ed s

train

rat

es p

redi

cted

by

the

thin

lay

er m

odel

. Th

e re

leva

nt s

train

rat

e is

obta

ined

up

on d

iffer

entia

tion

of (2

5) w

ith re

spec

t to

y an

d t,

givi

ng

and

from

this

we

read

ily d

eriv

e th

e ju

mp

quan

tity

Corre

spon

ding

exp

ress

ions

for

i. a

nd A

T co

uld

be d

educ

ed f

rom

the

res

ults

of

Spen

ce &

Tu

rcot

te u

nder

less

res

trict

ive

assu

mpt

ions

rega

rdin

g in

ters

eism

ic f

ault

slip

page

, but

we

shal

l he

re lim

it th

e di

scus

sion

to a

com

paris

on o

f (3

3) an

d (3

4) w

ith r

esul

ts f

or t

he t

hin

laye

r m

odel.

A

plot

of

stra

in r

ate

vers

us d

ista

nce,

per

tain

ing

to s

trike

-slip

faul

ting,

is s

how

n in

Fig

. 9

and

may

be

com

pare

d w

ith t

hat

in F

ig. 7

. The

max

imum

jum

p A

q(0)

whi

ch o

ccur

s at

the

faul

t is e

qual

to 2

Au+

G/(

37iH

~)

and

from

this

one

has

the

estim

ate

q/G

= ?

Au+

/[3n

HA

j.(O

)].

(35)

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

790

F. K

. Leh

ner a

nd V

. C. L

i 0.

100

0.07

5

jq d

/'GA

u"

0.05

0

0.00

0

-0 0

25

DIST

ANCE

y,'id

Fi

gure

9.

Surf

ace

stra

in r

ate

for

half

-spa

ce m

odel

as

a fu

ncti

on o

f di

stan

ce f

rom

the

fau

lt, a

t vari

ous

times

. R

epea

t tim

e 15

0 yr

.

It is

of c

ours

e cl

ear

that

thi

s sim

ple

resu

lt w

ill lo

se i

ts v

alid

ity,

whe

neve

r in

ters

eism

ic fa

ult

cree

p be

com

es im

port

ant.

Ther

e is

agai

n an

out

er e

xtre

mum

in A

?, lo

cate

d at

ym

= nH

= I

d, i

.e. t

he sa

me

distan

ce

as w

as f

ound

for

the

thi

n la

yer m

odel

, and

its m

agni

tude

I A?

1, =

Au*G

/( 1

.5

~~

~~

).

W

e also

re

tain

re

latio

n (3

1) a

s a

mea

ns

for

dete

rmin

ing

H

from

y,

and

the

rela

xatio

n tim

e ap

prop

riate

for

the

half-

spac

e mod

el m

ay b

e es

timat

ed f

rom

q/G

1 A

u'/(l

511,

I Ay

Im ).

(36)

It fo

llow

s th

at f

or t

he s

ame

valu

es o

f A

uf, q

/G a

nd H

in

both

mod

els,

the

jum

ps in

strai

n ra

te a

re re

late

d by

1 A?

Im t

hin

laye

r =

O.8

(h/H

) I A'?

1 m h

alf-

spac

e.

(37)

Con

clus

ions

A sim

ple

plat

e/fo

unda

tion

mod

el o

f an

ela

stic

lith

osph

ere

ridin

g on

a 't

hin'

asth

enos

pheri

c su

bstra

tum

sug

gests

that

visc

osity

stra

tific

atio

n in

the

upp

er m

antle

may

alte

r po

st-sei

smic

defo

rmat

ions

due

to

visc

oela

stic

rela

xatio

n ef

fect

s sig

nific

antly

in c

ompa

rison

with

defor

ma-

tions

pre

viou

sly

pred

icte

d fo

r a

Nur

-Mav

ko

half-

spac

e m

odel

. In

the

thi

n lay

er m

odel

rela

xatio

n ef

fect

s du

ring

an e

arth

quak

e cy

cle

are

conf

ined

to

an e

ven

narro

wer

zon

e abo

ut th

e pl

ate

boun

dary

, its

'pe

netr

atio

n de

pth'

dep

endi

ng s

trong

ly o

n th

e ra

tio o

f rec

urren

ce

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

Plat

e bo

unda

ry d

efor

mat

ions

79

1 tim

e to

rel

axat

ion

time

and

beco

min

g m

inim

al in

the

elas

tic li

mit

whi

ch is

virt

ually

atta

ined

wh

en t

his

ratio

is

less

tha

n or

equ

al t

o on

e. A

ccor

ding

to

this

ana

lysi

s, si

gnifi

cant

pos

t- se

ismic

visc

oela

stic

rela

xatio

n ef

fect

s fo

r re

curr

ence

tim

es o

f th

e or

der

of 1

00 yr

are

in

dica

tive

of v

iscos

ities

of

the

orde

r of

lO

I9 P

as (

10”

P) o

r le

ss f

or l

ithos

pher

e/as

then

o-

sphe

re t

hick

ness

ratio

s of

the

ord

er o

f 11

5. Th

e ea

rly p

ost-s

eism

ic d

istri

butio

n of

stra

in r

ates

alo

ng a

lin

e pe

rpen

dicu

lar

to a

ver

y lo

ng t

rans

form

fau

lt in

bot

h th

in l

ayer

and

hal

f-sp

ace

mod

els e

xhib

its a

pro

noun

ced

extr

emum

at

abou

t th

ree

litho

sphe

re th

ickn

esse

s aw

ay f

rom

th

e fa

ult,

whi

ch m

ay b

e ob

serv

able

afte

r a

larg

e ev

ent

and

wou

ld t

hen

perm

it in

depe

nden

t es

timat

es

of

asth

enos

pher

e re

laxa

tion

time

and

litho

sphe

re

thic

knes

s. Fo

rmul

ae

for

obta

inin

g su

ch e

stim

ates

are

giv

en h

ere

for

a th

in la

yer

as w

ell

as f

or a

hal

f-sp

ace

mod

el.

Sim

ilar

rela

tions

may

be

expe

cted

to

exis

t al

so f

or m

ore

com

plex

thr

ee-d

imen

sion

al

prob

lem

s.

Ack

now

ledg

men

ts

This

rese

arch

was

sup

port

ed b

y th

e N

atio

nal

Scie

nce

Foun

datio

n G

eoph

ysic

s Pr

ogra

m a

nd

the

US

Geo

logi

cal S

urve

y Ea

rthq

uake

Haz

ards

Red

uctio

n Pr

ogra

m. W

e th

ank

Prof

esso

r J. R

. Ri

ce f

or h

elpf

ul d

iscus

sions

and

wish

to

ackn

owle

dge

valu

able

com

men

ts m

ade

by t

he

revi

ewer

s. N

atio

nal

Scie

nce

Foun

datio

n G

eoph

ysic

s Pr

ogra

m G

rant

EA

R78

- 129

48 0

1 an

d US

Dep

artm

ent o

f Int

erio

r, U

S G

eolo

gica

l Sur

vey

Con

tract

14-

08-0

001-

1979

3.

Refe

renc

es

And

erso

n, D

. L.,

1975

. Acc

eler

ated

pla

te te

cton

ics,

Sci

ence

, 18

7, 1

077-

1079

. Ba

rker

, T. G

., 19

76. Q

uasi

-sta

tic m

otio

ns n

ear

the

San

And

reas

faul

t zon

e, G

eoph

ys. J

. R. a

str.

Soc.

, 45,

Bot

t, M

. H. P

. & D

ean,

D. S

., 19

73. S

tres

s diff

usio

n fr

om p

late

bou

ndar

ies,

Nat

ure,

243

, 339

-341

. Ca

rslaw

, H. S

. & J

aege

r, J.

C.,

1959

. Con

duct

ion

ofH

eat

in S

olid

s. 2

nd e

dn, O

xfor

d U

nive

rsity

Pre

ss.

Cohe

n, S

. C.,

1980

. Pos

tsei

smic

vis

coel

astic

sur

face

def

orm

atio

n an

d st

ress

, 1, T

heor

etic

al co

nsid

erat

ions

, di

spla

cem

ent a

nd s

train

cal

cula

tions

, J. g

eoph

ys. R

es.,

85, 3

131-

3150

. Co

hen,

S.

C.,

1981

. Po

stse

ism

ic r

ebou

nd d

ue t

o cr

eep

of t

he l

ower

lith

osph

ere

and

asth

enos

pher

e,

Geo

phys

. Res

. Let

t., 8

,493

-496

. D

avies

, J.

N. &

Hou

se,

L.,

1979

. A

leut

ian

subd

uctio

n zo

ne s

eism

icity

, vol

cano

-tren

ch

sepa

ratio

n, a

nd

thei

r rel

atio

n to

gre

at th

rust

-typ

e ea

rthq

uake

s, J.

geo

phys

. Rex

, 84,

4583

-459

1.

Elsa

sser

, W.

M.,

1969

. Con

vect

ion

and

stre

ss p

ropa

gatio

n in

the

upp

er m

antle

, in

The

App

licaf

ion

of

Mod

ern

Phys

ics

to t

he E

arth

and

Pla

neta

ry I

nter

iors

, pp

. 22

3-24

6,

ed.

Run

corn

, S.

K.,

Wile

y (I

nter

scie

nce)

, N

ew Y

ork.

Le

hner

, F.

K.,

Li, V

. C. &

Ric

e, J

. R.,

1981

. Stre

ss d

iffus

ion

alon

g ru

ptur

ing

plat

e bo

unda

ries,

J. g

eoph

ys.

Res.,

86,

615

6-61

69.

Mat

su’u

ra, M

. &,

Tani

mot

o, T

., 19

80. Q

uasi

-sta

tic d

efor

mat

ions

due

to

an in

clin

ed, r

ecta

ngul

ar f

ault

in a

vi

scoe

last

ic h

alf-

spac

e, J

. Phy

s. Ea

rth,

28,

103

-118

. Nu

r. A

. & M

avko

, G.,

1974

. Pos

t-sei

smic

vis

coel

astic

rebo

und,

Sci

ence

, 183

, 204

-206

. Ri

ce, J

. R.,

1980

. The

mec

hani

cs o

f ea

rthq

uake

rupt

ure,

in P

hysi

cs o

fthe

Eur

th ’s

Infe

rior

, pp.

555

-649

, ed

s Dzi

ewon

ski,

A. &

Bos

chi,

E., I

talia

n Ph

ysic

al S

ocie

ty/N

orth

Hol

land

, Am

ster

dam

. R

undl

e, J

. B.,

1978

. Vis

coel

astic

cru

stal

def

orm

atio

n by

fin

ite, q

uasi

-sta

tic so

urce

s, J

. geo

phys

. Res

., 83

, 59

37-5

945.

R

undl

e, J

. B.

& J

acks

on,

D.

D.,

1977

a. A

thr

ee-d

imen

sion

al v

isco

elas

tic m

odel

of

a st

rike

slip

fau

lt,

Geo

phys

. J. R

. ast

r. So

c.,

49,5

75-5

91.

Run

dle,

J. B

. & J

acks

on, D

. D.,

1977

b. A

kin

emat

ic v

isco

elec

tric

mod

el o

f th

e Sa

n Fr

anci

sco

eart

hqua

ke

of 1

906.

Geo

phys

. J. R

. ast

r. So

c., 5

0,44

1-45

8.

Sava

ge, J

. C. &

Pre

scot

t, W

. H

., 19

78. A

sthe

nosp

here

rea

djus

tmen

t and

the

eart

hqua

ke c

ycle

, J. g

eoph

ys.

Res.

, 83,

336

9-33

76.

Smith

, A. T

., 19

74. T

ime-

depe

nden

t st

rain

acc

umul

atio

n an

d re

leas

e at

isl

and

arcs

: im

plic

atio

ns f

or t

he

1946

Nan

kaid

o ea

rthq

uake

, PhD

the

sis,

Mas

sach

uset

ts I

nstit

ute

of T

echn

olog

y, C

ambr

idge

, 295

pp.

689-

705.

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from

792

F. K

. Leh

nera

nd V

. C Li

Spen

ce, D

. A. &

Tur

cotte

, D. L

., 19

79. V

isco

elas

tic r

elax

atio

n of

cyc

lic d

ispl

acem

ents

on

the

San

And

reas

Fa

ult,P

roc.

R. S

OC

. A, 3

65,1

21-1

44.

Spen

ce,

W.,

1977

. Th

e A

leut

ian

arc:

tec

toni

c bl

ocks

, ep

isod

ic s

ubdu

ctio

n, s

train

dif

fusi

on, a

nd m

agm

a ge

nera

tion,

J. g

eoph

ys. R

es.,

82, 2

13-2

30.

That

cher

, W.

& R

undl

e, J

. B.,

1979

. A m

odel

for

the

ear

thqu

ake

cycl

e in

und

erth

rust

zon

es,J

. geo

phys

. R

es.,

84,5

540-

5556

. Th

atch

er,

W.,

Mat

suda

, T.

, K

ato,

T.

& R

undl

e, J

. B.

, 19

80.

Lith

osph

eric

loa

ding

by

the

1896

Rik

u-u

eart

hqua

ke,

Nor

ther

n Ja

pan:

im

plic

atio

ns f

or

plat

e fl

exur

e an

d as

then

osph

eric

rhe

olog

y, J

. ge

ophy

s. R

es.,

85,6

429-

6435

. Y

ang,

M.

& T

okso

z, M

. H.

, 19

81.

Tim

e-de

pend

ent

defo

rmat

ion

and

stre

ss r

elax

atio

n af

ter

strik

e-sli

p ev

ents

, J. g

eoph

ys. R

ex, 8

6,28

89-2

901.

by guest on September 20, 2014http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/Downloaded from