A simple spatio-temporal procedure for the prediction of air pollution levels

Post on 16-May-2023

0 views 0 download

Transcript of A simple spatio-temporal procedure for the prediction of air pollution levels

! "#$%&' "%()#*+)'$%*,(& %,*-'./,' 0*, )1' %,'.#-)#*2 *0(#, %*&&/)#*2 &'3'&"

Jorge M. Mendes1 and Kamil F. Turkman2*1Higher Institute of Statistics and Information Management, New University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal2CEAUL Faculty of Sciences, University of Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal

!"#"$%"& '( )"*+,-+. (//'0 !"%$1"& 2 3"45"6*"+ (//(0 7##"45"& 2 8#59*"+ (//(

42 )1#" %(%', 5' ")/.6 )1' "%()#*+)'$%*,(& 7'1(3#*/, *0 (#, %*&&/)(2)" $'("/,'. .(#&6 *3', )1' -#)6 *0

8#"7*29 :*,)/;(&< =/, "%'-#0#- (#$ #" )* %,'.#-) (#, %*&&/)(2) &'3'&" #2 )#$' (2. "%(-' *3', ( 0#2' ;,#.

*0 &*-()#*2" 7("'. *2 *7"',3()#*2" 0,*$ ( "$(&& 2/$7', *0 $*2#)*,#2; "#)'"< =/, "/;;'")'.

%,'.#-)#*2 %,*-'./,' #" 7("'. *2 )1' "#$%&' (2. #2)/#)#3' #.'( *0 0#,") $(>#2; %,'.#-)#*2" #2 )#$' ()

)1' $*2#)*,#2; "#)'" (2. )1'2 '?)'2.#2; )1'"' %,'.#-)#*2" #2 "%(-' )* &*-()#*2" *)1', )1(2 )1'

$*2#)*,#2; "#)'" /"#2; >,#;#2; $')1*."< @*%6,#;1) ! ABBA C*12 D#&'6 E F*2"9 8).<

GHID=JKFL 14-5$9:5"649+-; 69&";10 <+$=$>=0 6,;5$%-+$-5" 5$6" 1"+$"1

M< 4NOJ=KP@O4=N

?@" #$5. 9A B$1*9> $1 5@" *$=="15 ,+*-> -+"- $> C9+5,=-;D E5 $1;9#-5"& *. 5@" "15,-+. 9A 5@" +$%"+ ?-=,1 -5 2F°GG! HI J°F! KDE51 595-; -+"- $1 FG <6(I #9++"149>&$>= 59 - 494,;-5$9>&">1$5. 9A LD(L( $>@-*$5->51 4"+ <6(D

8M$>= 59 $51 ;9#-5$9> 9> 5@" 75;->5$# #9-15 ->& 5@" >9+5@M$>&1 5@-5 9A5"> *;9M 9%"+ 5@" #$5.I @$=@ #9>#">5+-5$9>1 9A49;;,5->51 -+" +-+"D N9M"%"+I ,>&"+ -&%"+1" 6"5"9+9;9=$#-;#9>&$5$9>1I M"-< M$>&1 ->& 5@"+6$# $>%"+1$9>1I "14"#$-;;. $>-,5,6> ->& M$>5"+I @$=@ #9>#">5+-5$9>1 9A 49;;,5->51 #->9##,+D

O-+1 ->& 4,*;$# 5+->149+5-5$9> -+" 5@" 6-$> 19,+#" 9A-56914@"+$# 49;;,5$9> $> 5@" #$5.D P6$11$9>1 A+96 $>&,15+$-;A-#$;$5$"1 &9 >95 @-%" - =+"-5 $>A;,">#"I 1$>#" 9%"+ 5@" ;-15 A"M."-+1 5@" 6-$> $>&,15+$"1 @-%" *""> &"-#5$%-5"&D 75 4+"1">55@" 69>$59+$>= >"5M9+< $1 #96491"& 9A "$=@5 69>$59+$>=15-5$9>1I *,5 5@"+" -+" 4;->1 59 "Q4->& 5@" >"5M9+< 59 'G15-5$9>1D 3"%"+-; 49;;,5->51 -+" 69>$59+"& 9%"+ 5@" >"5M9+<I1,#@ -1 #-+*9> 69>9Q$&" RO8SI >$5+9="> 9Q$&"1 RH8 ->&H8(SI 1,;4@,+ &$9Q$&" R38(SI >$5+9="> 82 ->& 4-+5$#,;-5"6-55"+ RCT'/SD 8M$>= 59 5@" +";-5$%" $649+5->#" 9A 5+-AA$#"6$11$9>1I 5@+"" 9A 5@"1" 49;;,5->51I O8I H8 ->& H8(I -+"69>$59+"& -5 -;; "$=@5 15-5$9>1D

?@" 14-5$-; &$15+$*,5$9> 9A 5@" >"5M9+< M-1 1"5 ,4 *."64$+$#-; =,$&";$>"1D U"#-,1" 9A 5@" "Q4"#5"& @$=@ 49;;,5->5#9>#">5+-5$9> ;"%";1I ;9#-5$9>1 M$5@ - @$=@ $>5">1$5. 9A 5+-AA$#->& - @$=@ &">1$5. 9A 4"&"15+$->1 M"+" #@91">I -1 M";; -1 5@""-15"+> +"1$&">5$-; -+"-1 9A 5@" #$5. M@"+"I ,>5$; 196" ."-+1

-=9I 5@" 6-V9+ $>&,15+$"1 M"+" #9>#">5+-5"&D )$=,+"1 ' ->& (1@9M 5@" ="9=+-4@$#-; &$15+$*,5$9> 9A 5@" "$=@5 69>$59+$>=15-5$9>1 9%"+ - 6-4 9A B$1*9>D

75 "-#@ 69>$59+$>= 15-5$9>I -$+ 1-64;"1 -+" #9;;"#5"&#9>5$>,9,1;.D 3"%"+-; &"%$#"1 5@"> ->-;.1" 5@" 1-64;"I ->&5@" #9>#">5+-5$9> ;"%"; 9A "-#@ 49;;,5->5 $1 &"5"+6$>"& *-1"&9> 945$#-; #@-+-#5"+$15$#1 9A 5@" -$+ 1-64;"D P;"#5+$#-; 1$=>-;1-+" =">"+-5"& ->& #9>%"+5"& 59 >,6"+$#-; %-;,"1 5@-5 -+"1">5I *. - 4@9>" ;$>"I 59 - #">5+-; #964,5"+ M@"+" 5@" &-5--+" %-;$&-5"& ->& 4+9#"11"&D

E> 5@$1 4-4"+ 9,+ 9*V"#5$%" $1 59 15,&. 5@" 14-5$9:5"649+-;

Figure 1. The air quality monitoring network in Lisbon.

*O9++"149>&">#" 59W XD )D ?,+<6->I YPE8I )-#,;&-&" &" O$">#$-1I U;9#9O(I O-649 Z+->&"I C:'LGJ:/'[ B$1*9-I C9+5,=-;DP:6-$;W <-6$;D5,+<6->\A#D,;D45O9>5+-#5]=+->5 149>19+W C9+5,=,"1" 3#$">#" )9,>&-5$9> R)O?S0 O9>:5+-#5]=+->5 >,6*"+W C!7^E3]C]'//']JFD

O94.+$=@5 ! (//( _9@> K$;". ` 39>1I B5&D

_8a!H7B 8) ONPT8TP?!EO3J. Chemometrics (//(0 MQW [(2b[2(C,*;$1@"& 9>;$>" $> K$;". E>5"+3#$">#" RMMMD$>5"+1#$">#"DM$;".D#96SD Y8EW '/D'//(]#"6DL[[

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c'dD

?@" 1,=="15"& 4+9#"&,+" $1 *-1"& 9> 5@" 1$64;" ->&$>5,$5$%" $&"- 9A A$+15 6-<$>= 4+"&$#5$9>1 $> 5$6" -5 5@"69>$59+$>= ;9#-5$9>1 ->& 5@"> "Q5">&$>= 5@"1" 4+"&$#5$9>1 $>14-#" 59 ;9#-5$9>1 M@"+" 5@"+" -+" >9 9*1"+%-5$9>1I ,1$>=-44+94$-5" <+$=$>= 6"5@9&1D 7;6915 -;; ">%$+9>6">5-;4+9#"11"1 1@9M %-+$-*$;$5. 9%"+ 14-#" ->& 5$6"I $>%9;%$>=#964;$#-5"& 14-5$9:5"649+-; 15+,#5,+"1 ->& $>5"+-#5$9>1DU-."1$-> @$"+-+#@$#-; 69&";1 R1"" "D=D !"A"+">#"1 c(I2dS 1""659 *" 4-+5$#,;-+;. 1,$5"& A9+ 5@" 69&";;$>= 9A 14-5$9:5"649+-;4+9#"11"1D 3,#@ 69&";1 4+9%$&" 15+-5"=$"1 A9+ $>#9+4-+-5$>=#964;$#-5"& 14-#"b5$6" $>5"+-#5$9>1 -5 &$AA"+">5 15-="1 9A 5@"@$"+-+#@.I 5@,1 6-<$>= $5 +";-5$%";. A"-1$*;" 59 $64;"6">5 $>@$=@ &$6">1$9>1 ->& A9+ ;-+=" &-5- 1"51D E> 196" #-1"1I M@">5@" >,6*"+ 9A 69>$59+$>= 1$5"1 -1 M";; -1 5@" &-5- 1"51 -+"%"+. ;-+=" ->& @$=@ +"19;,5$9> 9A 4+"&$#5$9>1 $1 >""&"&I 5@">5@" $64;"6">5-5$9> 9A U-."1$-> @$"+-+#@$#-; 69&";1 6-. >95*" "-1. 9+ "%"> A"-1$*;"I -1 5@"1" 6"5@9&1 +"e,$+" #964;"5"14"#$A$#-5$9> 9A 5@" V9$>5 14-5$9:5"649+-; #9%-+$->#" 15+,#:5,+"1D E> 1,#@ #-1"1I &$6">1$9>:+"&,#$>= -44+9-#@"1 R1"""D=D !"A"+">#" cGdS 6-. *" 5@" 6915 -44+94$-5" M-. 9A@->&;$>= 5@" &-5-D N9M"%"+I -;; 5@"1" 6"5@9&1 >""&-&%->#"& 15-5$15$#-; <>9M;"&=" ->& #964,5-5$9>-; 1<$;;1DK" *";$"%" 5@-5 5@" 1,=="15"& 1$64;" 4+9#"&,+" 6-. 1"+%"-1 - +"A"+">#" 59 69&";;$>= 14-5$9:5"649+-; &-5- A9+ 5@91"4+-#5$5$9>"+1 M@9 &9 >95 @-%" "-1. -##"11 59 69+"194@$15$#-5"& 6"5@9&9;9=$"1 1,#@ -1 U-."1$-> @$"+-+#@$#-;69&";1 ->& TOTO RT-+<9% O@-$> T9>5" O-+;9S 6"5@9&1D

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f M" 4+"1">5 - 1$64;" 69&"; %-;$&-5$9> 4+9#"&,+"D3"#5$9> [ $1 &"&$#-5"& 59 5@" &$1#,11$9> 9A 4+"&$#5$9> "++9+ 9A5@" 69&";D E> 3"#5$9> L M" =$%" 196" #9>#;,1$9>1 59="5@"+M$5@ 4911$*;" $64+9%"6">51 $> 5@" 69&"; ->& 5@" &-5-->-;.1$1D

A< ORH S=KH8

K" -11,6" 5@-5 gTR"I!SI " ! "I ! h /I 'I ij $1 5@" 14-5$9:5"649+-; 4+9#"11 =">"+-5$>= 5@" H8( &-5-I M@$#@ -+"9*1"+%"& &-$;. -5 " h F 9*1"+%-5$9> 1$5"1 9%"+ f ."-+1I 195@-5 5@" &-5- -+" $> 5@" A9+6

?#"#! !$! # % '! ! ! ! ! F! ! % '! (! ! ! ! ! 'F([

N"+" "&"( $1 196" +"=$9> +"4+"1">5$>= 5@" ="9=+-4@$#-;-+"- 9A B$1*9>D B"5

T#!$ % #T#'$#!$!T#($#!$$ #'$

M@"+"

T#($#!$ % #$#"'! !$!$#"(! !$! ! ! ! !$#""! !$$ #($

$1 5@" ":&$6">1$9>-; 5$6" 1"+$"1 +"4+"1">5$>= 5@" %-;,"1 9A49;;,5$9> #9>#">5+-5$9> -5 5@" " 9*1"+%-5$9> 1$5"1 ->&

T#'$#!$ % #$#""''! !$!$#""'(! !$! ! ! ! !$#""'%! !$$

$1 -> %:&$6">1$9>-; 5$6" 1"+$"1 9A 49;;,5$9> #9>#">5+-5$9>1-5 % ;9#-5$9>1 $> & M@"+" 5@"+" -+" >9 9*1"+%-5$9>1 ->& M"M->5 14-5$-; 4+"&$#5$9>1D ?@,1 5@" &-5- -+" 9A 5@" A9+6?R!S h R?R'SR!SI ?R(SR!SI ! h 'I (I iI 'F([SI M@"+" ?R'SR!S $1 5@",>9*1"+%-*;" %"#59+D 3$>#" 5@" 9*1"+%"& 5$6" 1"+$"1 ?R(SR!S1@9M $>&$#-5$9>1 9A >9>:#9>15->5 %-+$->#"I - ;9=-+$5@6$#5+->1A9+6-5$9> $1 -44;$"& 59 5@" &-5-D N">#"I A+96 >9M 9>I9,+ 4+9#"11 TR"I !S +"4+"1">51 5@" 5+->1A9+6"& 49;;,5$9>;"%";1D

H9M M" M$;; M+$5" 9,+ ;$<";$@99&I ,>&"+;.$>= #;"-+;. 5@"-11,645$9>1D

!""/$%)#*2 M)9+ ->. !I

'#?#'$#!$(?#($#!$! ?#! ) '$! * * * ! ?#'$$

% '#?#'$#!$(?#($#!$$ #2$

E> R2S M" -11,6" 5@-5 -5 ->. 5$6" ! 5@" 49;;,5$9> ;"%";1 -5,>9*1"+%"& 1$5"1I #9>&$5$9>-; 9> 9*1"+%-5$9> 1$5"1 -5 5$6" !->& -;; 5@" 4-15 $>A9+6-5$9> #9>5-$>"& ,4 59 5$6" !) 'I&"4">& 9> 5@" %-;,"1 9A 49;;,5$9> ;"%"; -5 5@" 9*1"+%"& 1$5"1-5 5@" 1-6" 5$6" 49$>5 !D

Figure 2. Geographical configuration of air quality monitoringstations in Lisbon.

O94.+$=@5 ! (//( _9@> K$;". ` 39>1I B5&D () *+,%-%,!.#/0 (//(0 MQW [(2b[2(

[(G _D TD T">&"1 ->& XD )D ?,+<6->

!""/$%)#*2 A

'#?#($#!$(?#! ) '$! * * * ! ?#'$$

% '#?#($#!$(?#($#! ) '$! * * * ! ?#($#! ) '$$ #G$

A9+ 196" $>5"="+ 'D E> RGS M" -11,6" 5@-5 5@" 4+9#"11 -59*1"+%"& 1$5"1I #9>&$5$9>-; 9> -;; 5@" $>A9+6-5$9> ,4 59 ! ) 'I&"4">&1 9>;. 9> 5@" 9*1"+%-5$9>1 5-<"> 9> 5@" 1-6" 1$5"1 -55$6" 49$>51 =9$>= *-#< 59 196" 5$6" ;-= 'D

?@"1" 5M9 -11,645$9>1 -+" -> 9%"+ 1$64;$A$#-5$9> 9A 5@"+"-;$5.I 1"4-+-5$>= 5@" 14-5$-; ->& 5"649+-; &"4">&">#"15+,#5,+"1 $> - %"+. 14"#$A$# 6->>"+I A-#$;$5-5$>= $>A"+">#"DH95" 5@-5 Pe,-5$9> R2S &"A$>"1 5@" 14-5$-; &"4">&">#"M@"+"-1 Pe,-5$9> RGS &"A$>"1 5@" 5"649+-; &"4">&">#"D

U-1"& 9> 5@"1" 5M9 -11,645$9>1I 5@" ;$<";$@99& A9+ 5@"&-5-

+ % '#?#!$! ?#! ) '$! * * * ! ?#'$$

% '#?#!$(?#! ) '$! * * *$'#?#! ) '$(?#! ) ($! * * *$

* * * '#?#'$$

1"4-+-5"1 $>59 5M9 4+9&,#51

!"

!%'''

'#?#'$#!$(?#($#!$$

->&

!"

!%'''

'#?#($#!$(?#($#!) '$! * * * ! ?#($#! ) '$$

, '#?#($#'$! * * * ! ?#($#'$$

+"4+"1">5$>= 1"4-+-5";. 5@" 14-5$-; ->& 5"649+-; 15+,#5,+"1DN">#" 5@" +"14"#5$%" 1"51 9A 69&"; 4-+-6"5"+1 #-> *""15$6-5"& 1"4-+-5";.D

K" >9M 6-<" 9,+ -11,645$9>1 9> 5@" 4+9*-*$;$5.&$15+$*,5$9>1 =$%"> $> R2S ->& RGSD

'D

'#?#'$#!$! ?#($#!$$ - 1#"#"! !$!##"$$ #f$

M@"+"

"#"! !$ % %#"$ ' !#"! !$ #[$

N"+" %R"S $1 5@" 14-5$-; 5+">& ->& !R"I !S $1 5@" 14-#":&"4">&">5 5$6" 1"-19>-; #9649>">5 59 *" 14"#$A$"& ;-5"+D

(D ?@" &"5+">&"&I &"1"-19>-;$k"& 5$6" 1"+$"1 IR(SR!S hR$R"#I !S ) "R"#I !SI # h 'IiIFS $1 - 6,;5$%-+$-5" Z-,11$->4+9#"11 M$5@ 6"-> k"+9 ->& #9%-+$->#" 6-5+$Q

#9% #I#($#! ' +$!I#($#!$$ % ##($#+$ #L$

N"+" 5@" #9%-+$->#" 6-5+$Q M$;; *" ,>$e,";. &"A$>"& *.-11,6$>= 5@-5 5@" &"5+">&"&I &"1"-19>-;$k"& 1"+$"1 $1 -15-5$9>-+. 6,;5$%-+$-5" -,59+"=+"11$%" R7!S 4+9#"11D

?@"1" -11,645$9>1 #;"-+;. 1,=="15 @9M 59 6-<" 4+"&$#:5$9>1 9A 5@" 49;;,5$9> ;"%";1 RTR'SR!' +SI TR(SR! ' +SS -5 9+$=$> !$> 5M9 15-="1D

$ P15$6-5" 5@" 6,;5$%-+$-5" 7!R'S 15+,#5,+" $> RLS A+96 5@"

&"1"-19>-;$k"& 1"+$"1 gIR(SR!Sj 59 9*5-$> 5@" 4+"&$#59+"I#($#!' +$ A9+ IR(SR! ' +SD

$ P15$6-5" 5@" 14-5$-; 15+,#5,+" $> RfS A+96 5@" &"5+">&"&I&"1"-19>-;$1"& 1"+$"1 gIR(SR!Sj ->& 5@"> ,1" -> -44+94$-5"<+$=$>= 6"5@9& 59 4+"&$#5 5@" %-;,"1 "I#'$#!' +$ A9+IR'SR! ' +S h TR'SR! ' +S ,1$>= 5@" 4+"&$#5"& %-;,"1 "I#($#! '+$ $>15"-& 9A IR(SR! ' +SD

$ ?@" 4+"&$#5$9>1 A9+ TR'SR! ' +S ->& TR(SR! ' +S #-> 5@"> *"9*5-$>"& *. -&&$>= 5@" 5+">& ->& 1"-19>-; #9649>">51#-;#,;-5"& -5 +"14"#5$%" ;9#-5$9>1 9> IR'SR! ' +S ->&IR(SR! ' +SD

U< ORH K!O! !NK ORH HFO4S!O4=N

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k" ->& >"=;$=$*;" H8( 49;;,5$9>D

?@" &-$;. &-5- 9*5-$>"& -5 5@" "$=@5 15-5$9>1 1@9M - ;-+=">,6*"+ 9A 6$11$>= 9*1"+%-5$9>1D )9+ $>15->#"I 9,5 9A 'F([&-$;. 9*1"+%-5$9>1I 5@" 15-5$9> -5 !,- &- C+-5- R9*1"+%-5$9>1$5" "f0 1"" )$=,+" (S @-1 2L[ 6$11$>= 9*1"+%-5$9>1I 9A M@$#@((2 -+" #9>1"#,5$%"D ?@" 6$11$>= 9*1"+%-5$9>1 -5 "-#@ 1$5" -+"A$;;"& $> *. - 69&"; M@$#@ 5-<"1 $>59 #9>1$&"+-5$9> 5@" 15+9>=1"-19>-; #9649>">5I 69%$>= -%"+-="1 RT71S 9A -&V-#">5&-$;.I M""<;. ->& ."-+;. 9*1"+%-5$9>1 ->& -44+94+$-5"+->&96 #9649>">51D 71 1,#@I 5@" 6$11$>= 9*1"+%-5$9>$%R"#I !S -5 5$6" ! 9A 5@" 1"+$"1 9*1"+%"& -5 ;9#-5$9> "# $1#-;#,;-5"& A+96 5@" 69&";

$%#"#! !$ % 2#"#! !$ ' T7 #"#! !$ ' "#"#! !$ #F$

?@" 1"-19>-; #9649>">5 -5 "-#@ 1$5" $1 "15$6-5"& *. -5+$=9>96"5+$# +"=+"11$9> 9A 5@" A9+6

"2

3%'

43#"#$ #91#"3!$ '"2

3%'

53#"#$ 1$>#"3!$

M$5@ A+"e,">#$"1 "3 -5 (#!]LI (#!]J/ ->& (#!]2[fD ?@"69%$>= -%"+-=" #9649>">5 -5 "-#@ 1$5" $1 6-&" ,4 9A 5@"M"$=@5"& -%"+-=" 9A 5@+"" 1"4-+-5" 69%$>= -%"+-="1W

T7#"#! !$ % /#Lf T7'#"#! !$ ' /#(f T7(#"#! !$

' /#(f T72#"#! !$

M@"+" T7'R"#I !SI T7(R"#I !S ->& T72R"#I !S -+" 5@" 69%$>=-%"+-="1 9A 'I L ->& 2[f &-. ;-=="& 9*1"+%-5$9>1 +"14"#:5$%";.D ?@" +"1$&,-; #9649>">5 $R"#I !S $> RFS $1 =">"+-5"& A+96$D$D&D >9+6-; &$15+$*,5$9>1 A$55"& 59 &"1"-19>-;$k"& &-5- -5"-#@ 9*1"+%-5$9> 1$5"D

)$=,+"1 2 ->& G 1@9M +"14"#5$%";. 5@" 9+$=$>-; &-5- 1"51M$5@ 6$11$>= 9*1"+%-5$9>1 ->& 5@" &-5- 1"51 M$5@ "15$6-5"&6$11$>= 9*1"+%-5$9>1D

O94.+$=@5 ! (//( _9@> K$;". ` 39>1I B5&D () *+,%-%,!.#/0 (//(0 MQW [(2b[2(

C+"&$#5$9> 9A -$+ 49;;,5$9> ;"%";1 [(f

Figure 3. Daily mean concentration (log-transformed) of NO2 in Lisbon from 1/1/94 to 31/12/98: (a)–(h) s1 (Olivais), s2

(Entrecampos), s3 (Beato), s4 (Chelas), s5 (Rua da Prata), s6 (Casal Ribeiro), s7 (Benfica) and s8 (Av. Liberdade).

Figure 4. Daily mean concentration (log-transformed) of NO2 in Lisbon from 1/1/94 to 31/12/98 after filling in missingobservations: (a)–(h) s1 (Olivais), s2 (Entrecampos), s3 (Beato), s4 (Chelas), s5 (Rua da Prata), s6 (Casal Ribeiro), s7

(Benfica) and s8 (Av. Liberdade).

O94.+$=@5 ! (//( _9@> K$;". ` 39>1I B5&D () *+,%-%,!.#/0 (//(0 MQW [(2b[2(

[([ _D TD T">&"1 ->& XD )D ?,+<6->

U<M< F%()#*+)'$%*,(& ),'2. (2. "'("*2(&-*$%*2'2)"K" -11,6" 5@-5 -5 ->. 49$>5 " $> " ->& 5$6" ! 5@" ;9=:5+->1A9+6"& 4+9#"11 $R"I !S $1 9A 5@" A9+6

$#"! !$ % "#"! !$ ' 6#"! !$ #J$

M@"+"

"#"! !$ % %#"$ ' !#"! !$

% %#"$ '"2

3%'

43#"$ #91#"3!$

'"2

3%'

53#"$ 1$>#"3!$ #'/$

E> 9+&"+ 59 *" -*;" 59 "Q5+-49;-5" 5@" 14-5$-; 5+">&A,>#5$9> %R"S ->& 5@" 5"649+-; 1"-19>-; #9649>">5#2

3%' 43#"$ #91#"3!$ '#2

3%' 53#"$ 1$>#"3!$ "15$6-5"& A+96 5@"9*1"+%-5$9> 1$5"1 59 ->. 49$>5 $> 14-#"I M" -11,6" 1$64;"A,>#5$9>-; +";-5$9>1@$41 9A 5@" A9+6

%#"$ % 7/ ' 7'8' ' 7(8( ' 728(' ' 7G8

(( ' 7f8'8(

43#"$ % 9/!3 ' 9'!38' ' 9(!38(

53#"$ % //!3 ' /'!38' ' /(!38(

M@"+" 8' ->& 8( -+" 5@" "-15 ->& >9+5@ #9:9+&$>-5"1 9A 5@"49$>5 "I $D"D " h R8'I 8(SI ->& "3 -+" 5@" A$Q"& A+"e,">#$"1 (#]LI(#]J/ ->& (#]2[f +"14"#5$%";.D ?@" #9"AA$#$">51 -+" 5@">"15$6-5"& *. ;"-15 1e,-+"1D

8>#" 5@" &-5- -5 5@" "$=@5 ;9#-5$9>1 -+" &"5+">&"& ->&&"1"-19>-;$k"& *. $R"I !S ) "R"I !SI 5@"> 5@" #9%-+$->#"15+,#5,+"1 #R"S ->& !R(SR+S =$%"> $> RfS ->& RLS +"14"#5$%";.#-> *" "15$6-5"& A+96 5@" &"5+">&"& ->& &"1"-19>-;$k"&&-5-D

U<A< H")#$()#*2 *0 )1' "%()#(& .'%'2.'2-'"),/-)/,'?@" 1-64;" #9%-+$->#" *"5M""> %-;,"1 -5 15-5$9>1 "# ->& ":I

# h : h 'I iI LI $1

/#: %'

'F([

"'F([

!%'

;#"#! !$;#":! !$

?@" 14-5$-; &$14"+1$9> <(#: #-> *" #-;#,;-5"& *.

<(#: % "%-+.;#"#! !$ ) ;#":! !$/ % /## ' /:: ) (/#:

H95" 5@-5 $A 5@" 14-5$-; 4+9#"11 $1 1"#9>&:9+&"+ 15-5$9>-+.I5@"> 5@" 14-5$-; &$14"+1$9> ->& 5@" 1-64;" %-+$9=+-6 -+"$&">5$#-; cfdD )$=,+" f 1@9M1 5@" 14-5$-; #9>A$=,+-5$9> 9A 5@"1"%"> 15-5$9>1 ->& 5@" =+-4@ 9A 5@" #9++"149>&$>= 14-5$-;&$14"+1$9>1 -1 - A,>#5$9> 9A 5@" ="9=+-4@$#-; &$15->#"*"5M""> 5@" 15-5$9>1I M@$;" ?-*;" E =$%"1 5@" %-;,"1 9A14-5$-; &$14"+1$9> *"5M""> 5@" 1"%"> 15-5$9>1D

E5 $1 e,$5" #;"-+ A+96 )$=,+" f 5@-5 5@" 14-5$-; &$14"+1$9> $1>95 - A,>#5$9> 9A 5@" ="9=+-4@$#-; &$15->#"D ?@$1 6-. *" &,"59 5@" A-#5 5@-5 5@" 49;;,5$9> #9>#">5+-5$9>1 -+" @$=@"+ -;9>=5@" ;-+=" -%">,"1D

E> 9+&"+ 59 "15$6-5" 5@" 14-5$-; &"4">&">#" 15+,#5,+",>&"+ 1,#@ #9>&$5$9>1I M" ,1" - 6"5@9&9;9=. 1,=="15"& $>!"A"+">#" cfdD ?@" *-1$# $&"- $1 59 +";9#-5" 5@" 9*1"+%-5$9>1$5"1 -##9+&$>= 59 5@" >"M &$15->#" 9A &$14"+1$9>I -1

Figure 5. (a) Spatial configuration in G-plane: s1 (Olivais), s2 (Entrecampos), s3 (Beato),s4 (Chelas), s5 (Rua da Prata), s6 (Casal Ribeiro) and s8 (Av. Liberdade). (b) Spatialdispersion versus geographical interpoint distance.

Table I. Observed spatial dispersion for the seven air qualitymonitoring stations

35-5$9> "' "( "2 "G "f "[ "F

"' l"( ([D[( l"2 'fD/J (2DJL l"G (/D[F 2(D[G (LDFf l"f 2'DJL 2FDJ( 2(D([ ([DJG l"[ (LDJJ 2'DFf (GDL2 2GDLF 2GDF' l"F 2'D(/ 2(DJL (JD'F (FD2f 2GDLL 2[DJf l

O94.+$=@5 ! (//( _9@> K$;". ` 39>1I B5&D () *+,%-%,!.#/0 (//(0 MQW [(2b[2(

C+"&$#5$9> 9A -$+ 49;;,5$9> ;"%";1 [(L

#964-+"& 59 5@" 9+$=$>-; ;9#-5$9>1 491$5$9>"& -##9+&$>= 59="9=+-4@$#-; &$15->#"D ?@$1 #-> *" -#@$"%"& *. ,1$>=6,;5$&$6">1$9>-; 1#-;$>=I M@$#@ =">"+-5"1 - 5M9:&$6">:1$9>-; #9:9+&$>-5" +"4+"1">5-5$9> 9A 5@" 1-64;$>= 15-5$9>1M$5@ $>5"+49$>5 &$15->#"1 +"4+"1">5$>= 5@" 1-64;" 14-5$-;&$14"+1$9>D 8>#" 5@" 1-64;$>= 15-5$9>1 -+" +"491$5$9>"&I -5@$> 4;-5" 14;$>" $>5"+49;-5$9> A9+ "-#@ #9:9+&$>-5" #-> *"6-&" 59 4+9%$&" - 6-44$>= *"5M""> 5@" +"4+"1">5-5$9>1 9A5@" 15-5$9>1 $> 5@" 5M9 #9:9+&$>-5" 1.15"61D 85@"+ #9:9+&$>-5"1 M@"+" 4+"&$#5$9>1 -+" >""&"& #-> "-1$;. *" 5+->1:A9+6"& A+96 9>" #9:9+&$>-5" 1.15"6 59 ->95@"+ ,1$>= 5@$1A$55"& 5@$> 4;-5" 14;$>" $>5"+49;-5$9>D 71 $> !"A"+">#" cfdI M"#-;; 5@" 9+$=$>-; #9:9+&$>-5" 1.15"6 5@" ="9=+-4@$#-; 4;->"RZ:4;->"S ->& 5@" 5+->1A9+6"& #9:9+&$>-5" 1.15"6 5@"&$14"+1$9> 4;->" RY:4;->"SD B"5 "# h R8'#I 8(#S *" - 49$>5 $>5@" Z:4;->"D ?@" #9++"149>&$>= Y:4;->" 49$>5 "!# h R;'#I ;(#S $1#-;#,;-5"& *. A$55$>= 5@" 5@$> 4;-5" 14;$>"1W

"0# % #;'#! ;(#$ % # 4'#"#$! 4(#"#$$

M@"+"

4=#"#$ % %#=$/ ' %#=$' 8'# ' %#=$( 8(#

'"L

:%'

&#=$: 3:#"#$! = % '! (

->& 3:R"#S h (": ) "#(( ;9=R(": ) "#(SD )$=,+"1 [R-S ->& [R*S 1@9M+"14"#5$%";. 5@" #9>A$=,+-5$9> 9A 5@" 1"%"> 15-5$9>1 $> 5@">"M Y:4;->" ->& 5@" 4;95 9A 5@" 14-5$-; &$14"+1$9> -1 -A,>#5$9> 9A 5@" >"M &$15->#"I M@$#@ M" #-;; 5@" 6,;5$:&$6">1$9>-; 1#-;$>= $>5"+49$>5 RT3ES &$15->#"D ?-*;" EE1@9M1 5@" A$55"& 5@$> 4;-5" 14;$>"1D

?@" 15+9>= +";-5$9> *"5M""> 5@" 14-5$-; &$14"+1$9> ->& 5@">"M T3E &$15->#" $1 >9M %"+. #;"-+ A+96 )$=,+" [R*SD 7>$195+94$# 96>$&$+"#5$9>-; "Q49>">5$-; 1"6$%-+$9=+-6 $1

A$55"& 59 5@" &$14"+1$9> $> )$=,+" [R*SW

$#+$ % /#//L ' /#2FJJ ' ) "Q4 ) 2+'#/FL

$ %& '#''$

34-5$-; 4+"&$#5$9> 9+ <+$=$>= #-> >9M *" 4"+A9+6"& A9+->. ;9#-5$9> ,1$>= 5@$1 "15$6-5"I *. A$+15 5+->1A9+6$>= 5@" #9:9+&$>-5"1 9A 5@" >"M ;9#-5$9> $> 5@" Z:4;->" 59 5@" Y:4;->",1$>= 5@" "15$6-5"& 14;$>" A,>#5$9>1D K" +"5,+> 59 5@$1 49$>5;-5"+ -A5"+ 69&";;$>= 5@" 5"649+-; #9649>">5D

U<U< H")#$()#*2 *0 )1' )'$%*,(& -*$%*2'2)K" -11,6" 5@-5 5@" &"1"-19>-;$k"& 1"+$"1 IR"#I !S h RTR"#I!S ) "R"#I !SI ! h 'I ***I 'F([I # h 'I ***I LS A9;;9M - 15-5$9>-+.6,;5$%-+$-5" 7!R'S 4+9#"11D N9M"%"+I $> 9+&"+ 59 %-;$&-5"5@" 14-5$9:5"649+-; 4+"&$#5$9>1I M" M$;; 69&"; 9>;. 5@" A$%"15-5$9>1 -5 "( RP>5+"#-6491SI "2 RU"-59SI "G RO@";-1SI "[ RO-1-;!$*"$+9S ->& "F R7%D B$*"+&-&"SI ;"-%$>= 9,5 5@" 5$6" 1"+$"19*1"+%"& -5 ;9#-5$9>1 "' R8;$%-$1S ->& "f R!,-&- C+-5-S A9+

Figure 6. (a) Spatial configuration in D-plane: s1 (Olivais), s2 (Entrecampos), s3 (Beato),s4 (Chelas), s5 (Rua da Prata), s6 (Casal Ribeiro) and s8 (Av. Liberdade). (b) Spatialdispersion versus MSI distance. The curve represents the exponential semivariogramfitted to the MSI distance.

Table II. Estimated thin plate splines

= h ' = h (

%#=$/ /D'J /D((

%#=$' 2DGF GDJ2

%#=$( )(D/( )(DFf

&#=$' /D'/ /D'(

&#=$( )/DG/ )/Df[

&#=$2 /D/G /D(f

&#=$G )/D/( )/D/[

&#=$f /DGJ /DfG

&#=$[ /D'L /D/f

&#=$F )/Df[ )/Dff

O94.+$=@5 ! (//( _9@> K$;". ` 39>1I B5&D () *+,%-%,!.#/0 (//(0 MQW [(2b[2(

[(F _D TD T">&"1 ->& XD )D ?,+<6->

%-;$&-5$9>D ?@" ="9=+-4@$#-; 491$5$9>1 9A 5@"1" 15-5$9>1 -+"1@9M> $> )$=,+" LD

C9$>5 4+"&$#59+1 A9+

6#"(! ! ' +$!6#"2! ! ' +$!6#"G! ! ' +$!6#"[! ! ' +$!6#"F! ! ' +$

M$;; A9+6 5@" *-1$1 9A <+$=$>= 59 4+"&$#5 5@" %-;,"1 9A49;;,5$9> ;"%"; 9%"+ -> -+"- M$5@$> 5@" #9:9+&$>-5"1 '''Pb''[DfP ->& 'JfHb(//HI -1 M";; -1 4+"&$#5$>= 5@" 9*1"+%"&%-;,"1 -5 ;9#-5$9>1 "' R8;$%-$1S ->& "f R!,- &- C+-5-S A9+%-;$&-5$>= 5@" 69&";D ?@" =+$& ;9#-5$9>1 -1 M";; -1 5@"15-5$9>1 ,1"& A9+ %-;$&-5$9> -+" 1@9M> $> )$=,+" LD

7 6,;5$%-+$-5" 7!RGS $1 A$55"& 59 5@" &"1"-19>-;$k"& 5$6"1"+$"1 -5 5@" A$%" ;9#-5$9>1 ,1$>= 5@" 19A5M-+" C"15 c[dD ?@"->-;.1$1 9A 5@" +"1$&,-;1 1@9M"& 5@-5 5@" A$55"& 69&"; $1-&"e,-5"D

V< F:!O4=+OHS:=J!8 :JHK4@O4=NF

?@" 14-5$9:5"649+-; 4+"&$#5$9> $1 6-&" ,1$>= 5@" A9;;9M$>=4+9#"&,+"D

'D C+"&$#5 +:15"4:-@"-& 49;;,5$9> ;"%";1 6R"(I !' +SI 6R"2I!' +SI 6R"GI ! ' +SI 6R"[I ! ' +S ->& 6R"FI ! ' +S A9+ &$AA"+">5%-;,"1 9A + ,1$>= 5@" A$55"& 6,;5$%-+$-5" 7!RGS 69&";D

(D U-1"& 9> 5@" "15$6-5"& 1"6$%-+$9=+-6 R''S ->& ,1$>=9+&$>-+. <+$=$>=I 4+"&$#5 5@" %-;,"1 9A 6R"/I !' +S *-1"& 9>5@" 4+"&$#5"& %-;,"1 6> R"(I !' +SI 6> R"2I ! ' +SI 6> R"GI !' +SI6> R"[I ! ' +S ->& 6> R"FI !' +SD

2D ?@" %-;,"1 9A -#5,-; 49;;,5$9> ;"%"; TR"/I ! ' +S -5 "/ #->>9M *" #-;#,;-5"& A9+ 5$6" ! ' + *. -&&$>= 59 6> R"/I ! ' +S5@" 14-5$-; 6"-> A,>#5$9> 6m R"/S ->& 5@" 14-5$9:5"649+-;1"-19>-; #9649>">5 "!#"/! !' +$ =$%"> $> R'/SI ->& 5@"> ;9=:5+->1A9+6$>= *-#< 5@" 1"+$"1D

?@" 4;95 9A 9>":15"4:-@"-& 14-5$9:5"649+-; 4+"&$#5$9>1 A9+5@" M@9;" =+$& A9+ ! h L2' $1 1@9M> $> )$=,+" F0 95@"+ 9>":15"4: -1 M";; -1 +:15"4:-@"-& 4+"&$#5$9> 1,+A-#"1 A9+ &$AA"+">5%-;,"1 9A ! #-> -;19 *" #-;#,;-5"& M$5@9,5 ->. -&&$5$9>-;&$AA$#,;5.D

W< S=KH8 X!84K!O4=N

E> 9+&"+ 59 %-;$&-5" 5@" 69&";I M" A$55"& 7!RGS 69&";1 59 5@"A$%" ;9#-5$9>1D ?@"> M" 4+"&$#5"& 5@" A$+15 L &-.1 9A _->,-+.'JJJ R9>":15"4:-@"-& 4+"&$#5$9>1 9>;.S M$5@ 5@$1 69&"; ->&"Q5">&"& 5@" 14-5$-; 4+"&$#5$9>1 "Q4;-$>"& -*9%" 59 5@" 5M99*1"+%-5$9> 1$5"1 ;"A5 A9+ %-;$&-5$9>I >-6";. 15-5$9>1 "'R8;$%-$1S ->& "f R!,- &- C+-5-SD ?-*;" EEE ->& )$=,+" J 1@9M5@"1" 4+"&$#5$9>1 59="5@"+ M$5@ 5@" 9*1"+%"& 49;;,5$9> ;"%";1-5 "-#@ 9A 5@"1" 5M9 ;9#-5$9>1 A9+ 5@91" L &-.1D K" -;19-44;$"& - ;"-%":5M9:9,5 -44+9-#@ 59 -;; #96*$>-5$9>1 9A15-5$9>1I $> M@$#@ 5@" 49;;,5$9> ;"%";1 -5 5M9 15-5$9>1 -+"4+"&$#5"& -1 - A,>#5$9> 9A 5@" &-5- -5 5@" +"6-$>$>= 15-5$9>1A9+ -;; #96*$>-5$9>1D ?-*;" En =$%"1 - 1,66-+. 9A 5@" e,-;$5.9A 4+"&$#5$9>1 A9+ 5@$1 ;"-%":5M9:9,5 %-;$&-5$9>D !"1,;51 1@9M5@-5 5@" 4+"&$#5$9>1 -+" >95 -;M-.1 =99& -#+911 5@" M@9;"+"=$9>D 8>" 4911$*$;$5. A9+ "Q4;-$>$>= 5@"1" 6$Q"& +"1,;51 $15@-5 5@" 69>$59+$>= 15-5$9>1 -+" $>15-;;"& -5 ;9#-5$9>1 M@"+"69+" 49;;,5$9> $1 "Q4"#5"&I 5@,1 $>5+9&,#$>= *$-1 $> 5@"4+"&$#5$9>1D

711,645$9>1 ' ->& ( $> 3"#5$9> ( >""& 59 *" %-;$&-5"&DN9M"%"+I 5@$1 6-. >95 *" -> "-1. 5-1< 9M$>= 59 5@" A-#5 5@-55@"1" #9>&$5$9>1 +";-5" 59 5@" &"4">&">#" 15+,#5,+" 9A 5@"4+9#"11 *"5M""> 5@" 9*1"+%-5$9> 1$5"1 ->& 95@"+ 1$5"1 M@"+"5@"+" -+" >9 9*1"+%-5$9>1D 711,645$9>1 ' ->& ( #-> *"%-;$&-5"& *. ;99<$>= -5 5@" 4-+5$-; #+911:#9++";-5$9>1 ->&4-+5$-; -,59#9++";-5$9>1 9A 5@" 4+9#"11 -5 9*1"+%"& ->&,>9*1"+%"& 1$5"1D 3$>#" -> "15$6-5" 9A 5@$1 A,>#5$9> #->>95 *"9*5-$>"& 9M$>= 59 5@" ;-#< 9A 9*1"+%-5$9>1 -5 ,>9*1"+%"&

Figure 7. Selected area for modelling and prediction.

Figure 8. One-step-ahead spatio-temporal predictions for thewhole grid for t = 731.

Table III. One-step-ahead spatio-temporal predictions and actualvalues of daily mean concentration (log-transformed) of NO2 for

s1 (Olivais) and s5 (Rua da Prata)

! 6> R"'I !S 6> R"fI !S 6 R"'I !S 6 R"fI !S

L2' 2D2F 2D2F GDGF GD/JL2( 2DF2 2DFL GDL/ 2DJfL22 2DF[ 2DF( 2DG' 2DG'L2G 2D(' 2D2' 2DL/ 2DFGL2f 2DJG 2DLJ 2DFF GD//L2[ 2DJ/ 2DL/ GD[[ GD/2L2L GD2G GD/L fD/J GD2J

O94.+$=@5 ! (//( _9@> K$;". ` 39>1I B5&D () *+,%-%,!.#/0 (//(0 MQW [(2b[2(

C+"&$#5$9> 9A -$+ 49;;,5$9> ;"%";1 [(J

1$5"1I M" ;99<"& -5 5@" %-+$9,1 A9+61 9A 4-+5$-; #+911:#9++";-5$9>1 ->& -,59#9++";-5$9>1 9A 5@" 4+9#"11 -5 9*1"+%"&1$5"1D P15$6-5"& 4-+5$-; #+911:#9++";-5$9>1 ->& -,59#9++";-:5$9>1 &$" 9AA "Q49>">5$-;;. A-15 $> 6915 #-1"1I $>&$#-5$>= 5@-5711,645$9>1 ' ->& ( +"-19>-*;. #-45,+" 5@" &"4">&">#"15+,#5,+" 9A 5@" &-5-D N9M"%"+I 9M$>= 59 5@" #964;$#-5"&&$15+$*,5$9>-; A9+61 9A 5@"1" "64$+$#-; 4-+5$-; #+911:#9++";-:5$9>1I $5 $1 >95 4911$*;" 59 =$%" A9+6-; 15-5$15$#-; 5"151D

Q< :JHK4@O4=N HJJ=JF

E> 5@" 4+"%$9,1 1"#5$9> M" 1@9M"& @9M 9>" #-> 9*5-$> 5@"

14-5$9:5"649+-; 4+"&$#5$9> A9+ 5@" &"5+">&"& ->& &"1"-19>:-;$k"& 49;;,5$9> #9>#">5+-5$9>1 6R"/I ! ' +S A9+ 196" A$Q"&49$>5 $> 14-#"I "/I ->& 5$6" ! ' +D EA 9*1"+%-5$9>1 -5 A$%";9#-5$9>1 -+" -%-$;-*;" -5 5$6" ! ' +I 5@"> 5@" 4+"&$#59+ 9A6R"/I ! ' +S $1 =$%"> *.

?.6#"/! ! ' +$(6!'+/ %"f

#%'

"#;#"#! ! ' +$

M@"+" " h R"#I # h 'I iI fS -+" <+$=$>= M"$=@51 59 *" "15$6-5"&A+96 5@" &-5-D N9M"%"+I 9*1"+%-5$9>1 6R!' +S h R6R"#I !' +SI# h 'I iI fS -+" >95 -%-$;-*;" ->& 9,+ 1,=="15"& 4+"&$#59+ $1

""6#"/! ! ' +$ % ?.6#"/! ! ' +$("I#! ' +$/ #'($

M@"+"

"I#!' +$ % ?.I#! ' +$(6#!$! 6#! ) '$! * * */

->& IR!S &">95"1 5@" A$%":&$6">1$9>-; 5$6" 1"+$"1D EA 5@"9*1"+%-5$9>1 6R! ' +S h R6R"#I ! ' +SI # h 'I iI fS -+" -%-$;-*;"I

Figure 9. One-step-ahead spatio-temporal predictions, confidence intervalsand actual values of daily mean concentration (log-transformed) of NO2 for s1

(Olivais) and s5 (Rua da Prata).

Table IV. Summary of prediction results for leave-two-outvalidation

O96*$>-5$9>>,6*"+

35-5$9>1$>

35-5$9>19,5

35->&-+&6"-> "++9+1

o 4+"&$#5"&%-;,"1 $>1$&" Jfo#9>p&">#" ;$6$51

( "( "2 "G "f "F "' "[ 'DJI )'D2 'GD2I FfDL2 "( "2 "G "f "[ "' "F (D2I /DF (FD[I '//D/G "( "2 "f "[ "F "' "G (D(I /D( (FD[I FfDLf "( "G "f "[ "F "' "2 'DJI 'D2 G(DJI L'DG[ "2 "G "f "[ "F "' "( (D(I )/D' (FD[I '//D/L "' "G "f "[ "F "( "2 /D'I 'Df FfDLI G(DJF "' "2 "f "[ "F "( "G /D'I /D/ '//D/I FfDLJ "' "2 "G "[ "F "( "f /D/I /D[ '//D/I '//D/

'/ "' "2 "G "f "F "( "[ )/D2I )'D2 FfDLI FfDL'' "' "2 "G "f "[ "( "F /D(I /DF '//D/I '//D/'( "' "( "f "[ "F "2 "G 'DLI /DF G(DJI FfDL'2 "' "( "G "[ "F "2 "f /DGI /D[ fLD'I '//D/'G "' "( "G "f "F "2 "[ /D(I )'DG L'DGI FfDL'f "' "( "G "f "[ "2 "F /DFI /DF fLD'I '//D/'[ "' "( "2 "[ "F "G "f /D(I /DG FfDLI '//D/'L "' "( "2 "f "F "G "[ )/D'I )'D( FfDLI FfDL'F "' "( "2 "f "[ "G "F /D(I /D[ FfDLI '//D/'J "' "( "2 "G "F "f "[ /D(I )'D( '//D/I FfDL(/ "' "( "2 "G "[ "f "F /D2I )/D( LLD[I J2DJ(' "' "( "2 "G "f "[ "F )'D(I /Df FfDLI '//D/

Figure 10. Prediction errors.

O94.+$=@5 ! (//( _9@> K$;". ` 39>1I B5&D () *+,%-%,!.#/0 (//(0 MQW [(2b[2(

[2/ _D TD T">&"1 ->& XD )D ?,+<6->

5@"> 5@" 4+"&$#5$9> "++9+ %-+$->#"

'(#"/! ! ' +$ % ?.#6#"/! ! ' +$ ) "6#"/! ! ' +$$(/

% ?.#6#"/! ! ' +$ ) ?.6#"/! ! ' +$(6#! ' +$/$(/ #'2$

#-> *" #-;#,;-5"& ,1$>= 5@" 15->&-+& -+=,6">51 9A <+$=$>=DN9M"%"+I 6R"I ! ' +S -+" >95 -%-$;-*;" ->& -+" 4+"&$#5"& A+965@" 9*1"+%"& &-5- ,4 59 5$6" !D K@-5 $1 5@" "AA"#5 9A ,1$>=""6#"/! !' +$ % ?.6#"/! !' +$("I#!' +$/ 9> 5@" 4+"&$#5$9> "++9+q

B"5

""'(#"/! ! ' +$ % ?.#6#"/! ! ' +$ ) ""6#"/! ! ' +$$(/

?@">I *. -+=,6">51 =$%"> $> 5@" 744">&$QI

""'(#"/! ! ' +$ % "'(#"/! !' +$ ' "##"! ! ' +$"? #'G$

M@"+" #R"I ! ' +S $1 5@" +:15"4:-@"-& 4+"&$#5$9> "++9+9*5-$>"& A+96 5@" 6,;5$%-+$-5" -,59+"=+"11$%" 69&"; A$55"&59 5@" &-5-D )$=,+" '/ 1@9M1 5@" 9>":15"4:-@"-& 4+"&$#5$9>"++9+ 1,+A-#"1 #-;#,;-5"& A+96 R'GSD Jfo #9>A$&">#" $>5"+%-;1A9+ 5@" 9>":15"4:-@"-& 4+"&$#5$9>1 -5 5@" 5M9 %-;$&-5$9> 1$5"1-+" =$%"> $> )$=,+" JD

Y< @=N@8PF4=NF

K" *";$"%" 5@-5 5@" 1$64;" 14-5$9:5"649+-; 69&"; 1,=="15"&#-45,+"1 5@" "11">5$-; 14-5$9:5"649+-; &"4">&">#" 15+,#5,+"$> 5@" &-5- ->& =$%"1 +"-19>-*;" 4+"&$#5$9>1D 8M$>= 59 5@"14"#$A$# #9>&$5$9>-; $>&"4">&">#" #9>&$5$9>1I 5@" 69&";4"+6$51 ,1 59 #-;#,;-5" 5@" 14-5$-; ->& 5"649+-; 4+"&$#5$9>1-1 M";; -1 5@"$+ "++9+1 $> -> -&&$5$%" M-.D 7;5@9,=@ *. >96"->1 5@" *"15 M-. 9A 69&";;$>= 5@" &-5- 9M$>= 59 5@"+"15+$#5$%" -11,645$9>1 6-&" 9> 5@" &"4">&">#" 15+,#5,+"1I5@$1 1$64;" 69&"; 4"+6$51 ,1 59 ,1" M$&";. -%-$;-*;"19A5M-+" 9> <+$=$>= ->& 6,;5$%-+$-5" 5$6" 1"+$"1D E>4+$>#$4;"I 5@" e,-;$5. 9A 5@" 1@9+5:5"+6 4+"&$#5$9>1 1@9,;&*" &+-15$#-;;. $>#+"-1"& *. $>#9+49+-5$>= #9%-+$-5"1 1,#@ -1M$>& &$+"#5$9> ->& $>5">1$5.I 5"64"+-5,+" ->& 4+"#$4$5-5$9>DN9M"%"+I -5 4+"1">5I >9 1,#@ &-5- M"+" -%-$;-*;" A9+ 5@"-,5@9+1 $> #9>V,>#5$9> M$5@ 5@" 49;;,5$9> &-5-D ?@"1"#9%-+$-5"1 M9,;& -;19 *" @$=@;. %-;,-*;" $> +"&,#$>= 5@""AA"#5 9A >9>:15-5$9>-+$5. 9> 5@" 4+"&$#5$9>1D

!->2*5&'.;'$'2)"?@$1 M9+< M-1 1,449+5"& *. 5@" C9+5,=,"1" 3#$">#")9,>&-5$9> R)O?0 4+9V"#5 C!7^E3]C]'//']JFSD

!::HNK4T

B"5

""'(#"/! ! ' +$ % ?.#6#"/! ! ' +$ ) ""6#"/! ! ' +$$(/

->&

"'(#"/! ! ' +$ % ?.#6#"/! ! ' +$ ) "6#"/! ! ' +$$(/

?@">

""'(#"/! ! ' +$ % ?.#6#"/! ! ' +$ ) ""6#"/! ! ' +$$(/

% ?.#6#"/! ! ' +$ ) "6#"/! ! ' +$

' "6#"/! ! ' +$ ) ""6#"/! ! ' +$$(/

% ?.#6#"/! ! ' +$ ) "6#"/! ! ' +$$(/

' ?.#"6#"/! ! ' +$ ) ""6#"/! ! ' +$$(/

' (?.#6#"/! ! ' +$ ) "6#"/! ! ' +$$

, #"6#"/! ! ' +$ ) ""6#"/! ! ' +$$/ #'f$

?@" A$+15 "Q4+"11$9> 9> 5@" +$=@5:@->& 1$&" 9A R'fS $1"'(#"/! ! ' +$I M@"+"-1

?.#"6#"/! ! ' +$ ) ""6#"/! ! ' +$$(/

% ?"f

#%'

"#6#"#! ! ' +$ )"f

#%'

"#"6#"#! ! ' +$

( )(

% ?"f

#%'

"#"#"#! ! ' +$( )(

% "!#"! !' +$"? #'[$

M@"+" %R"I !' +S h R6R"#I !' +S ) 6> R"#I !' +SI # h 'I iI fS $1 5@"+:15"4:-@"-& 4+"&$#5$9> "++9+ 9*5-$>"& A+96 5@" A$%":&$6">:1$9>-; 7!RGS 69&"; -5 9+$=$> !I ->& !R"I ! ' +S $1 5@" %-+$->#"b#9%-+$->#" 6-5+$Q 9A $R"I ! ' +SD ?@" 5@$+& "Q4+"11$9> 9> 5@"+$=@5:@->& 1$&" 9A R'fS #-> *" M+$55"> -1

(?.#6#"/! !'+$) "6#"/! !'+$$, #"6#"/! !' +$) ""6#"/! !' +$$/

% (? "#"/! !'+$"f

#%'

"#"#"#! !'+$( )

%"f

#%'

"#?."#"/! !' +$"#"#! !' +$/ #'L$

M@"+" %R"/I !' +S h 6R"/I !' +S ) 6> R"/I ! ' +S $1 5@" 14-5$-;4+"&$#5$9> "++9+D H95" 5@-5 5@" 14-5$-; ->& 5@" +:15"4:-@"-&5"649+-; 4+"&$#5$9> "++9+1 %R"/I !' +S ->& R%R"#I !' +SI # h 'IiI fS -+" >95 $>&"4">&">5I *,5 5@". -+" $>&"4">&">5#9>&$5$9>-; 9> 6R"I !' +SSD N">#"

?."#"/! ! ' +$"#"#! ! ' +$/

%*

?."#"/! ! ' +$"#"#! ! ' +$(6#"! ! ' +$ % 6/&@6#"!!'+$#6$

%*

?."#"/! ! ' +$(6/?."#"#! ! ' +$(6/&@6#"!!'+$#6$

3$>#"

?."#!/! ! ' +$(6/ % 6#!/! ! ' +$

) ?.6#!/! ! ' +$(6#"! ! ' +$ % 6/ % /

M" 1"" 5@-5 5@" 5@$+& 5"+6 9> 5@" +$=@5:@->& 1$&" 9A R'fS $1k"+9 ->&

""'(#"/! !' +$ % "'(#"/! ! ' +$ ' "!#"! ! ' +$"? #'F$

O94.+$=@5 ! (//( _9@> K$;". ` 39>1I B5&D () *+,%-%,!.#/0 (//(0 MQW [(2b[2(

C+"&$#5$9> 9A -$+ 49;;,5$9> ;"%";1 [2'

JHZHJHN@HF

'D !"$1 TI 76-+-; ?,+<6-> T7 ->& ?,+<6-> X)D 7U-."1$-> -44+9-#@ 59 "%">5 4+"&$#5$9>D () A#%, 2,.#,0(//(0 $> 4+"11D

(D K$<;" OXI U"+;$>"+ BT ->& O+"11$" HD N$"+-+#@$#-;U-."1$-> 14-#"b5$6" 69&";1D ?"B#.-") ?/-=) 2!7!#0!) 'JJF0WW ''Lb'fGD

2D U+9M> C_I B" HY ->& r$&"< _nD T,;5$%-+$-5" 14-5$-;

$>5"+49;-5$9> ->& "Q491,+" 59 -$+ 49;;,5->51D *7") () 2!7!#0!)'JJG0 AAW GFJbf/JD

GD K$<;" O ->& O+"11$" HD 7 &$6">1$9>:+"&,#"& -44+9-#@ 5914-#"b5$6" X-;6-> p;5"+$>=D C#-%,!.#37 'JJJ0 [QW F'fbF(JD

fD 3-6419> CY ->& Z,559+4 CD H9>4-+-6"5+$# "15$6-5$9> 9A>9>15-5$9>-+$5. 14-5$-; #9%-+$->#" 15+,#5,+"D () D%) 2!7!#0!)D00-/) 'JJG0 [YW '/Fb''JD

[D U+9#<M";; C_ ->& Y-%$1 !7D E"!.-<F/!#-" !- A#%,0 2,.#,0 7"<@-.,/70!#"5D 34+$>="+W H"M s9+<I 'JJ[D

O94.+$=@5 ! (//( _9@> K$;". ` 39>1I B5&D () *+,%-%,!.#/0 (//(0 MQW [(2b[2(

[2( _D TD T">&"1 ->& XD )D ?,+<6->