The Art of Scenery and Representation in Tomb Mosques' Decorations

21
1 The Art of Scenery and Representation in Tomb Mosques’ Decorations Harlina Md Sharif Hazman Hazumi Introduction The art of scenery or ‘scenic art’ is a technique of representation whereby a scene of action or event is depicted, often with the inclusion of narrative aspect in its design composition. Originally used in theatrical performances, the execution of scenery techniques in visual and fine arts is usually found in paintings. The introduction of painting into the field of Islamic arts is believed to have taken place during the Ilkhanid period in Persia (13 th century). The Mongol invasions that resulted in the dispersion of artisans and craftsmen paved way to the immersion of Chinese artistic traditions, where painting was one of its oldest and greatest art (The Arts of Islam, pp. 29, 309). The impact of Chinese influence on the Islamic arts was evident in the art of book and manuscript. With the Ilkhanid rulers passing through a stage of Buddhism before their conversion to Islam in 1295 C.E., the Chinese artistic motifs such as the peony and lotus became popular addition to existing repertoire of artistic composition (The Arts of Islam, p. 29). In the initial incorporation of illustrations in books, small size drawings were utilised mainly as visual aids in highlighting the text intents of scientific writings. However, what began as an illustrative method eventually developed into a distinctive art category known as miniature paintings. Although in the beginning these paintings passed through a stage of ‘Islamicisation’ through the stylisation and modification of representational figures, composed within symmetrical or geometrical compositional layout; they eventually transformed into accomplished scenic and representation artistic work (The Arts, p.310). The scenic art technique found its popular application in manuscript illuminations, and to a small extent, textile decorations. In architecture, especially in buildings built during Islamic rule, its application is limited and almost unknown. However, the mosaic decoration on the walls of the Great Mosque of Damascus, was an exceptional case, with ‘more than an acre of mosaics depicting a fanciful landscape thought to be the Quʾrānic paradise’

Transcript of The Art of Scenery and Representation in Tomb Mosques' Decorations

1    

The  Art  of  Scenery  and  Representation  in  Tomb  Mosques’  Decorations  

 

Harlina  Md  Sharif  

Hazman  Hazumi  

 

Introduction  

The  art  of  scenery  or  ‘scenic  art’  is  a  technique  of  representation  whereby  a  scene  of  

action   or   event   is   depicted,   often   with   the   inclusion   of   narrative   aspect   in   its   design  

composition.  Originally  used  in  theatrical  performances,  the  execution  of  scenery  techniques  

in  visual  and  fine  arts  is  usually  found  in  paintings.  The  introduction  of  painting  into  the  field  

of   Islamic   arts   is   believed   to   have   taken   place   during   the   Ilkhanid   period   in   Persia   (13th  

century).   The  Mongol   invasions   that   resulted   in   the   dispersion   of   artisans   and   craftsmen  

paved  way   to   the   immersion   of   Chinese   artistic   traditions,   where   painting   was   one   of   its  

oldest  and  greatest  art  (The  Arts  of  Islam,  pp.  29,  309).    

The   impact  of  Chinese   influence  on   the   Islamic  arts  was  evident   in   the  art  of  book  

and  manuscript.  With  the   Ilkhanid  rulers  passing  through  a  stage  of  Buddhism  before  their  

conversion   to   Islam   in   1295   C.E.,   the   Chinese   artistic  motifs   such   as   the   peony   and   lotus  

became  popular  addition  to  existing  repertoire  of  artistic  composition  (The  Arts  of  Islam,  p.  

29).   In   the   initial   incorporation   of   illustrations   in   books,   small   size   drawings   were   utilised  

mainly   as   visual   aids   in   highlighting   the   text   intents   of   scientific   writings.   However,   what  

began  as  an   illustrative  method  eventually  developed  into  a  distinctive  art  category  known  

as  miniature  paintings.  Although  in  the  beginning  these  paintings  passed  through  a  stage  of  

‘Islamicisation’   through   the   stylisation   and   modification   of   representational   figures,  

composed   within   symmetrical   or   geometrical   compositional   layout;   they   eventually  

transformed  into  accomplished  scenic  and  representation  artistic  work  (The  Arts,  p.310).    

The   scenic   art   technique   found   its  popular   application   in  manuscript   illuminations,  

and  to  a  small  extent,  textile  decorations.  In  architecture,  especially  in  buildings  built  during  

Islamic  rule,  its  application  is  limited  and  almost  unknown.  However,  the  mosaic  decoration  

on  the  walls  of  the  Great  Mosque  of  Damascus,  was  an  exceptional  case,  with  ‘more  than  an  

acre   of   mosaics   depicting   a   fanciful   landscape   thought   to   be   the   Quʾrānic   paradise’  

2    

(Encyclopaedia   Britannica).   It   preceded   the   Persian   experimentations   by   more   than   five  

centuries.   Apart   from   this   early   attempt   by   Umayyad   Caliph   Al-­‐Walid   I   (705-­‐715   C.E),   its  

applications  in  other  Islamic  buildings  are  yet  to  be  learnt.  For  this  reason,  the  discovery  of  

the   scenic   art   in   two   tomb   mosques   in   Java,   namely   Masjid   Sendang   Duwur   and   Masjid  

Mantingan,  is  not  only  fascinating;  it  is  critical  in  the  efforts  of  understanding  the  origin  and  

characteristics  of  this  rare  art  technique.    

The  Tomb  Mosques  in  Java  (15th  -­‐16th  century)  

The   period   of   15th   and   16th   century   is   often   referred   to   as   being   ‘the   transition  

period’     (Tjandrasasmita  1984;  Ambary  2001).   This   epoch  witnessed   the   transformation  of  

artistic  cultures   from   its  ancient  origins   into   Islamic  aesthetic  values.  During  this   formation  

stage,  remnants  of  ancient  traditional  practice  were  detected  in  the  extant  mosques  of  Java  

Island.  The  architecture  and  decorative  elements  evoked  archetypal  memory  of  pre-­‐Islamic  

traditions,  which  were  adapted  to  suit  the  new  creed.  

This  study   looks  at  two  mosques,  both  built   in  the  15th  and  16th  century,  which  are  

classified  as  tomb  mosques.  They  are  the  mosques  of  Masjid  Sendang  Duwur  (in  Lamongan,  

Central   Java)   and   Masjid   Mantingan   (near   Jepara,   Central   Java).   These   mosques   are  

considered   as   ‘pure’   tomb   mosques   based   on   the   study’s   evaluation   of   their   principal  

functions  in  accommodating  for  tomb  visitors.  Despite  the  obvious  risk  of  over-­‐simplifying  a  

mosque’s  functional  typology  (since  a  mosque  ordinarily  serves  multi-­‐purpose  functions);  a  

pure   tomb   mosque   often   exhibits   distinctive   characteristics   that   are   identifiable   through  

studying  its  physical  layout.    

One  of  the  physical  identifiers  for  a  tomb  mosque  is  its  placement  on  a  small  hill  or  

an   elevated   site.   The   site   selected   is   often   isolated   as   isolation   heightens   the   sacrosanct  

aspect  of   the  mosque   (Abdul  Rochym  1983,  p.86).  A   review  on   the   tomb   layout   for  Sunan  

Drajat  and  Sunan  Tembayat,  both  which  are  objects  of  annual  pilgrimage  in  Java;  reveals  this  

distinctive  criterion   (Figure  1).  Both  of   the  mosques  of  Sendang  Duwur  and  Mantingan  are  

similarly   found   built   on   small   hill   tops   overlooking   surrounding   areas   (Figure   2).   It   is   also  

common  to  find  that  the  site  selected  was  a  historically  sacred  site.  According  to  Moehamad  

Habib  (2001),  a  site  is  also  considered  pure  if  a  sacred  edifice  –even  a  pre-­‐Islamic  structure-­‐  

was   previously   built   therein.   In   his   research   conducted   on   Masjid   Sunan   Ampel,   Masjid  

Sendang   Duwur   and   Masjid   Mantingan,   pre-­‐Islamic   artefacts   were   found   on   the   sites   of  

3    

these  mosques  containing  relief  ornamentations  depicting  sacred  figures  or  sacred  buildings  

of  Hindu-­‐Javanese  times  (Moehamad  Habib  2001).    

 

 

Tomb of Sunan Drajat

(Moehamad Habib 2001)

 

Tomb of Sunan Tembayat

Source: http://yuliantoqin.culture360.org/

 

Figure  1  Layout  of  tomb  complex  

4    

 

(a)  Sunan  Sendang  Duwur  

Source:  (Tjandrasasmita  1984)

 

(c)  Masjid  Mantingan  –  Sultan  Hadlirin  and  Ratu  Kalinyamat  

Edited from: (Handinoto  &  Hartono  2007)

Figure  2  Layout  of  tomb  mosques  

5    

 

The  second  physical  identifier  is  the  design  layout  of  the  mosque  complex,  especially  

in  terms  of  placement  of  the  tombs  in  relationship  to  the  mosque.    In  most  tomb  mosques,  

the  necropolis  of  the  revered  individuals  is  placed  in  the  region  approximately  to  the  west  of  

the  main  prayer  hall  i.e.  in  the  direction  of  the  qibla  behind  the  qibla  wall.  The  tombs  found  

in   Sendang   Duwur   and   Mantingan   are   all   located   in   the   western   part   of   the   mosques’  

compounds.  These   tombs  are  placed  within  a  cungkup,  or  a   roofed  structure,  often  with  a  

space  around  the  tombs  provided  for  tomb  visitors  to  perform  prayers  and  invocations.    

The  presence  of  pawestren   (ladies  prayer  area)   in   Javanese  mosques   is   also  a   sign  

that  a  mosque  functions  as  a  tomb  mosque.  The  main  function  of  a  pawestren  is  to  provide  a  

space  for  female  congregation  who  (were  usually  ‘rewarded’  to)  sit  and  read  passages  from  

the   Qur’ān   and   selected   dhikr   in   selected   time   of   the   year   as   a   tribute   and   invocation  

towards  the  spirit  of  the  deceased.  This  space  is  distinguished  from  the  normal  prayer  space  

designated   for   women   congregation   by   its   placement   and   design   in   relation   to   the   main  

prayer  hall  and  the  tombs.  Ordinary   female  prayer  space   is  often   located  near   the  eastern  

wall  of  the  mosque  i.e.  behind  the  saf  of  male  congregation;  if  the  prayer  space  is  relatively  

tight.   In  bigger  mosques,   the   female  prayer  space   is   located  to   the   left  of   the  main  prayer  

hall   i.e.  near   the   southern  wall  or  on   the  upper   level.   This   space   is  usually  not   completely  

sealed  and  could  be  demarcated  by  movable  screens  such  as  half-­‐height  movable  divider  or  

by   drawing   a   curtain.   It   is   also   often   accessible   from   the   common   entrance   of   the   main  

prayer  hall.  The  pawestren  however,  is  usually  designed  completely  sealed  off  from  the  main  

prayer  hall.  It  is  also  located  adjacent  to  the  tomb  building.    

In   Javanese   mosques,   the   tomb   of   the   most   revered  wali   or   rulers   are   placed   in  

dalem  i.e.  the  most  inner  part  of  a  tomb  complex,  which  is  usually  the  third  and  last  place  in  

terms   of   sequence   of   placement.   It   is   accessible   through   gated  walkways,  with   successive  

compounds  providing  sequential  hierarchy  of   the  tomb’s  sanctity.  This  study  finds  that  the  

necropolis  of  Masjid  Sendang  Duwur  and  Mantingan  are  all  designed  with  gated  walls  and  

gateways,  either  in  the  form  of  Candi  Bentar  (split  gates)  or  Paduraksa  (covered)  (Figure  3).    

 

 

6    

 

Figure  3  Gateways  and  fences  varieties  in  Masjid  Sendang  Duwur  

(Source:  Harlina  Sharif  &  Hazman  Hazumi)  

 

7    

Historical  Background  

Masjid  Sendang  Duwur  -­‐  also  known  as  Makam  Sunan  Sendang  (The  Tomb  of  Sunan  

Sendang)   -­‐   is   located   in   the   village   of   Sendang   Duwur,   under   the   district   of   Paciran,  

Lamongan.  It  is  said  to  have  been  founded  by  Raden  Nur  Rakhmad,  the  son  of  Raden  Abdul  

Qohar  –  an  ‘alim  from  Lamongan;  and  a  grandson  to  Syeikh  Abu  Jazid  Al  Baghdadi  a  renown  

ulema  from  Egypt  1.  His  contributions  to   Islamic  teachings   in  Sendang  Duwur  gave  him  the  

title  Sunan  Sendang  (Wiryoprawiro  1986).  

The  mosque   complex   is   located  on  an  elevated   site  within   the   villages  of   Sendang  

Duwur  and  Sendang  Agung   (also   known  as   Sendang   Lebak).  Sendang   is   Javanese   for   small  

pond,   whereas  Duwur   means   high   (Sendang   Duwur:   small   pond   on   a   high   ground);   while  

Lebak  means  valley.  The  Sendang  Duwur  village  is  situated  in  a  rock  hill  area  which  is  quite  

remote   from   the   flat   coastal   region;   and   can   be   reached   by   car   from   the   arterial   road   of  

Sedayu-­‐Tuban  through  a  small  road  of  approximately  5  km.  From  Sendang  Duwur  village,  the  

mosque  is  accessible  by  foot,  through  a  series  of  levels  ascending  approximately  500  meter.    

The   date   of   the   mosque’s   construction   is   established   from   various   sources.   A  

chronogram   found  on   a  wooden  panel  written   in   Javanese   characters   in   an   archaic   shape  

together  with  an  inscription  below  it  in  Arabic  language  was  translated  by  Pijper  as  follows:  

“It   may   be   known   that   this   mosque   has   been   built   twice,   the   first   time   in   1483  

(Javanese  calendar)  which  is  the  same  as  971  Hijrah;2  and  the  second  time  in  1851  (Javanese  

calendar)  which  is  1339  Hijrah,  which  makes  it  368  years  between  the  two  constructions.  In  

the   second   construction,   stones   and   a   part   from   the  wood  of   the   first   building   have   been  

used”.    

The  date  of  the  second  construction  confirms  the  date  inscribed  above  the  doorpost  

of  the  mosque  in  Arabic,  Javanese  and  Latin  characters  of  the  year  1920.  Another  inscription  

found  on  a  decorative  wooden  panel  at   the  tomb  of  Sunan  Sendang   is  written   in   Javanese  

characters  of  an  ancient   form.  According   to  Stutterheim  who  analysed   the  panel,   the  date  

                                                                                                                         1  The  name  al-­‐Baghdadi  often  refers  to  someone  who  originated  from  Baghdad,  Iraq.  The  validity  of  the  above  account  however  could  not  be  verified.    2  Tjandrasasmita  in  his  thesis  on  Sendang  Duwur  quoted  the  copy  of  an  old  manuscript  that  he  found  in  relation  to  the  history  of  the  mosque.  Sunan  Sendang  was  said  to  have  “flown”  the  mosque  from  Mantingan  and  had  it  landed  on  the  Tunon  Hill  (Sendang  Duwur).  The  date  quoted  from  the  manuscript  coincides  with  the  inscription  found  on  the  panel  “gunaning  salira  tirta  hayu”  which  correlates  to  1483  Shaka  or  1561  C.E.  

8    

inscribed  was  1507  Shaka3  or  1585  C.E.  This  date  may  have  been  the  date  of  the  foundation  

of   the  tomb,  or   the  year  Sunan  Sendang  died.  The  24  years  difference   (between  1561  C.E.  

and   1585   C.E.)   is   reasonable;   thereby   establishing   the   approximate   date   of   build   for   the  

mosque  to  be  around  that  period  (Tjandrasasmita  1984).  

The  mosque  complex  is  made  up  of:    

• the  Sendang  Duwur  mosque  and  adjoining  ablution  building:  the  mosque  is  extensively  

renovated  although  still  maintaining  the  old  form  

• The  eastern  entrance  compound  which  consists  of  a  well  (Sumur  Giling),  and  a  flight  of  

staircase  directly  connected  to  the  main  entrance  of  the  mosque  

• the   northern   compound:   which   houses   several   courtyards   of   old   cemeteries   and   two  

roofed  structure  that  serve  as  store  houses  for  the  remnants  of  the  old  mosque  

• the  western  compound:  where   the   tomb  of  Sunan  Sendang   is   located  under  cungkups  

(pyramidal  and  hip  roofs)  within  a  courtyard  which  is  located  on  a  lower  level  to  the  level  

of   the   mosque.   This   courtyard   is   locked   from   visitors   who   have   no   intention   to   pay  

homage  (ziyarah)  to  the  tomb  (Tjandrasasmita  1984).  

• The  southern  compound:  a  steep  site  containing  cemetery  and  a  gated  entrance  to  the  

south  giving  access  to  the  mosque  for  villages  from  Sendang  Lebak.  

The  cemetery  is  a  dominant  feature  in  Sendang  Duwur  mosque.  From  the  site  plan,  

it  is  evident  that  the  mosque  only  occupies  approximately  a  tenth  of  the  whole  compound.  

Masjid  Mantingan,  also  known  as  Masjid  Astana  Mantingan,  is  located  in  Mantingan  

village  within  the  district  of  Dati  II  Jepara;  which  is  6  kilometer  to  the  south  of  Jepara  town.  

The  mosque   is  accessible   from  the  town  through  a  series  of  villages  and  agricultural   lands.  

The  mosque  complex  is  located  on  a  small  hill  –  about  5  to  10  meter  height  from  road  level.  

It   is  surrounded  by  plantation  fields  and   located  close  to  the  woodcraft   industry  of   Jepara.  

The   villagers’   dwellings   are   found   outside   the   perimeter   of   the   agricultural   lands   and  

woodcraft  industry.    

Pangeran  Hadlirin  made  Kalinyamat  (18  km  south  of  Jepara)  as  the  ruling  centre  and  

according  to  folk  story,  during  the  stressful  times  of  ruling  Jepara,  from  time  to  time  he  loved  

                                                                                                                         3  Shaka  or  Saka:  Javanese  traditional  calendar  year  

9    

to  be  in  seclusion  at  Mantingan.  To  enable  her  to  be  with  her  husband,  Ratu  Kalinyamat  built  

a   house   (pasanggrahan)   in  Mantingan.   In   about   1549,   Hadlirin   was   killed   by   the   ruler   of  

Jipang   Panolan,   Haryo   Penangsang   (or   Arya   Panangsang)   and   his   body   was   buried   at  

Mantingan.  The  Mantingan  Mosque  was  built  by  Ratu  Kalinyamat  in  about  1559;  at  the  same  

site  where  the  house  was;  in  commemoration  of  her  husband’s  death  (Graaf  1985).  The  date  

of  build  is  based  on  the  inscription  found  on  the  mihrab  of  the  mosque,  written  in  Javanese  

script  referring  to  the  year  of  1481  Shaka    which  correlates  to  1559  C.E.  (Ashadi  2006).    

The  mosque  is  a  three  tiered  pyramidal  roof  structure  with  attached  pendopo  style  

serambi  (built  in  1950s).  The  complex  could  be  divided  into:  

• The  mosque  with  veranda  and  ablution  area  

• Eastern  courtyard  and  main  entrance  to  mosque  

• Tomb  of  Sultan  Hadlirin  and  Ratu  Kalinyamat  –  west  of  the  mosque  

 

Decorative  Scheme  and  Techniques  

The  art  of  scenery  in  these  mosques  are  found  applied  on  various  mediums  such  as  

stone  slabs,  wood  panels  and  coral  tiles.  Masjid  Sendang  Duwur   is  the  only  extant  mosque  

known,  to  have  preserved  the  art  of  stone  carving  inherited  from  pre-­‐Islamic  period.  In  this  

mosque,  the  stone  structures  displayed  an  outstanding  array  of  motif  representations,  with  

three  dimensional  sculptural  effects.  Its  decorative  schemes  are  mainly  seen  employed  in  its  

gated  fences,  as  well  as  in  the  body  of  the  tomb  structure.    

The  intricate  detailing  reveals  the  expertise  in  execution  of  decorative  schemes  that  

narrate   symbolic   subject   matters.   Vegetal   and   floral   scrolls   are   stylised   in   the   forms   of  

garuda  wings,  winged  meru,   life  tree,   lotus  in  pond,  and  scenery  of  mountains  and  forests.  

Zoomorphic  motifs  are  also  found,  especially  around  the  opening  of  the  gateways.  Unique  to  

other   tomb  complexes  and   sacred  edifices,   Sendang  Duwur’s  winged  gateway4   is   found   to  

have  no  comparable  references,  either  from  traditional  practices  or  similar  edifices   in  Java.    

In  his  study  on  this  ancient  artefact,  Uka  Tjandrasasmita  (1984)  cited  the  work  of  H.  Bergema  

in   his   book,   “De   boom   des   levens   in   schrift   en   Historie”   that   pointed   out   the   similarity   of  

                                                                                                                         4  Entranceway  to  the  tomb  of  the  revered  wali  decorated  with  sculptured  wings  of  garuda,  a  mythical  bird  in  Javanese  ancient  beliefs  

10    

Sendang   Duwur’s   winged   gate   design   to   a   winged   gate   motif   found   on   a   round   seal   of  

ancient  Babylon  that  symbolises  a  gateway  to  heaven,  or  refers  to  the  wings  of  the  guardians  

of   the  gate.  Tjandrasasmita  however,  was  of   the  opinion   that   the   form   is  an   innovation   in  

itself  as  winged  gateway  had  previously  been  employed  only  in  two-­‐dimensional  decoration  

and  not  as  a  three-­‐dimensional  architectural  design  (Tjandrasasmita  1984)  (Figure  3).    

The  same  motif  similarly  is  repeated  on  the  wall  surface  of  the  gateway  in  a  variety  

of  compositions  (Figure  4,  5).  In  these  designs,  the  ‘gateway  to  heaven’  is  depicted  as  having  

a   pair   of   wings.   Above   the   entry   doors   is   a   stylised   makara,   an   important   guardian   in  

Javanese   mythology   (Figure   6).   Above   the   makara,   is   a   tree   with   branches   extending  

outwards,   believed   to   be   representing   the   life   tree.   Zoomorphic   motifs,   sometimes  

silhouetted   using   floral   and   vegetal,   take   various   symbolical   functions.     The   trunk   of   the  

elephant   is   found   ‘guarding’   the   sides   of   one   of   the   gateways   of   the   Sendang   Duwur.  

Elephant   is   a   relief  motif   associated  with   Buddha,  while   an   elephant   in   a  Hindu   temple   is  

associated  with  Gaņeśa  (Widyosiswoyo  2007).    

         

   

11    

 

Location: Fence

Medium: Stone

Motif: Gateway, Garuda Wings, Life Tree, Makara Face, Forest

Figure  4  

(Source:  Harlina  Sharif  &  Hazman  Hazumi)  

Location: Fence

Medium: Stone

Motif: Gateway, Garuda Wings, Life Tree, Makara Face, Forest

Figure  5  

(Source:  Harlina  Sharif  &  Hazman  Hazumi)  

12    

Naga Makara

Figure  6  -­‐  Zoomorphic  themes  stylised  in  floral  and  vegetal  motifs  

Source:  (Dirdjoamiguno  1970)  

 

Another   zoomorphic   motif   found   on   the   tomb   gate   relief   was   the   motif   of   kala-­‐

marga   which   floats   above   and   curls   around   the   gate   opening.   In   Hindu   temples,   the   kala  

finds  its  origin  in  the  Kala-­‐mikha  or  Kirtti-­‐murkha;  the  Infinite  manifesting  itself  through  the  

mythical   creature,   which   crowns   the   arches   of   the   temple’s   doorways   and   niches  

(Burckhardt  1967).  Kala-­‐marga  according  to  Javanese  conception  is  a  floating  rainbow  which  

has   the   body   of   a   serpent   with   two   heads   on   opposite   ends   in   the   shape   of   a   deer   or   a  

buffalo   (Figure   7).   This   serpent   is   believed   to   be   floating   above   the   island   of   Java;   and   its  

heads   duck   into   the   seas   of   Java   Island   and   the   Indian  Ocean   to   suck   the  waters   and   spit  

them  again  upon  the  earth  (Tjandrasasmita  1984).  Popular  motifs   in  Sendang  Duwur’s  gate  

design  were  stylised  makara,  garuda  wings,  naga,  serpent,  scorpion,  phoenix,  and  elephant.  

All  of  these  motifs  were  related  to  pre-­‐Islamic  conceptions  of  heaven  and  guardians  (Figure  

8).  

   

13    

Location:  fence  Medium:  stone  

Motif:  serpent  with  head  of  a  deer,  rainbow

Location:  fence  Medium:  stone  

Motif:  serpent/  scorpion  tail  

Figure  7  Kala-­‐marga  with  a  deer  head  and  serpent  tail,  curling  around  the  gateway.  

a) Naga with opened mouth b) Peacock

c) Stylised makara face with peacock wings d) Naga

Figure  8  (a-­‐d)  Motifs  symbolically  representing  the  concepts  of  heaven  and  guardianship  (Source:  Harlina  Sharif  &  Hazman  Hazumi)  

14    

The  decorative  themes  for  the  tomb  structure  depict  subjects  that  are  symbolically  

representing   sceneries   in   heaven.     Motifs   are   carved   both   on   stone   and   wood   panels.  

Depiction   of   heaven   is   executed   through   the   scenery   of   orchards,   with   cungkup   (covered  

structure)   in   the   form   of  meru5,  mountains,   clouds,   the  moon   and   the   sun   as   the   subject  

matters.  Garuda  wings  still  persist,  guarding  the  entry  to  the  sacred  tomb,  as  well  as  in  the  

depiction  of  the  gate  in  the  heaven  scenery  (Figure  9,  10).  

 

a) Garuda wings guarding entry to tomb

b) Pedestal at the foot of stairs towards the tomb entry

c) Wood panels on the body of the tomb structure

Figure  9  –  decorative  scheme  on  the  tomb  structure  

(Source:  Harlina  Sharif  &  Hazman  Hazumi)  

Figure 10 – depiction of heaven in stone carved panel of the tomb.

(Source: Harlina Sharif & Hazman Hazumi)

                                                                                                                         5  Meru,  in  Javanese  ancient  beliefs,  is  a  sacred  mountain  that  represents  the  centre  of  the  world.  It  is  an  abode  for  the  Gods  and  sacred  spirits.    

15    

Masjid   Mantingan   similarly   employed   symbolic   motifs   and   design   composition   to  

narrate   the  concepts  of  death,  heaven  and  revered   individuals.  The  subject  matters  of   the  

panel   decorations   varied   from   floral   series,   geometrical   and   scenery;   with   motifs   of  

silhouetted   animals   such   as   the   monkey   (Hanuman),   elephant   and   phoenix;   orchard   (or  

paradise)   scene   with   split   gates,   fences   and   pendopo   against   meru   background.   In   this  

mosque  ingenious  skill  of  carving  is  evident  from  the  intricate  detailing  of  motif  composition  

on  coral  slabs.  These  slabs  are  currently  plastered  to  the  entry  wall  of  the  mosque’s  prayer  

hall  in  medallion-­‐like  manner  (Figure  11).  

 

 

Figure  11  –  Decorative  coral  panels  of  Masjid  Mantingan  plastered  on  the  entry  wall  

(Source:  Harlina  Sharif  &  Hazman  Hazumi)  

16    

 

(a)  

 

(b)  

Location:  wall  Medium:  coral  

Motif:  forest/  park,  meru,  life  tree  

Location:  wall  Medium:  coral  

Motif:  candi,  split  gate,  meru,  lotus,  forest  

 

(c)  

 

(d)  

Location:  wall  Medium:  coral  

Motif:  water  lily,  mountains  

Location:  wall  Medium:  coral  

Motif:  water  lily,  moving  clouds  

Figure  12  –  Details  of  the  coral  designs  in  Masjid  Mantingan  

(Source:  Harlina  Sharif  &  Hazman  Hazumi)  

 

Conclusion:  Extinction  of  the  Art  

The  period   of   15th   and   16th   century,  was   the   last   period   that   exhibited   a  wide  

range   of   artistic   traditions,   many   which   originated   from   pre-­‐Islamic   practices.   It   was  

during  this  era  that  the  mosques  employed  full  range  of  decorative  motifs  consisting  of  

floral   and   vegetal,   zoomorphic,   cosmos,   geometric   pattern,   scenery,   calligraphy,   and  

three-­‐dimensional  artworks.  Despite   the  obvious  potentials   to  be   further  developed  to  

create  a  more  accomplished  language  of  Islamic  art,  some  of  the  pre-­‐Islamic  art  tradition  

17    

failed   to   survive.   Critical   among   these   repertoires   is   the   art   of   scenery   and  

representation,   which   totally   diminished   in   mosque   decorative   schemes   by   the   17th  

century.6  

The   17th   and   18th   century   witnessed   the   stagnancy   in   the   creations   or  

developments   of   building   art   forms.   Stone   architecture   and   the   art   of   stone   carving  

totally  diminished  from  mosque’s  design.  Similarly  motifs  such  as  zoomorphic,  cosmos,  

scenery   and   three-­‐dimensional   artworks,   almost   completely   disappeared   during   this  

period.  Decorative  artworks   that  prevailed  were   in   the   ‘minor’  aspects  of   the  building,  

mainly   associated   with   ornamental   rather   than   architectural.   The   whole   capacity   of  

decorations  was  reduced  to  the  furnishings  of  the  mosque,  such  as   in  the  mimbar,   the  

“grandfather”  clock,  the  lighting  accessories,  and  the  main  doorway  into  the  prayer  hall.    

The  way  in  which  the  motifs  were  used  across  the  periods  studied  raises  several  

interesting   points.   Firstly,   how   were   certain   features   of   decorative   elements   readily  

accepted  as  ‘Islamic’  while  others  were  rejected?  Floral  and  vegetal  motif,  for  example,  

had   widespread   applications,   regardless   of   time   and   region.   It   is   the   most   dominant  

form   of   motif   used,   regardless   of   art   medium   (i.e.   material).   On   the   other   hand  

zoomorphic,   cosmos,   scenery   and   three-­‐dimensional   motifs   and   applications   were  

abruptly   stagnated   by   the   17th   and   18th   century.   Notwithstanding   the   fact   that   these  

decorative  styles  were  absorbed  after  initial  borrowing,  and  undergone  rigorous  filtering  

and  trimming  stages  in  order  to  fit  Islamic  requirements;  they  failed  to  survive  after  early  

applications.  

Examples   can   be   retrieved   from   the   zoomorphic   motif   applications   seen   in  

Masjid   Sendang   Duwur.   The   mythical   subjects   found   in   the   gateway   and   stone   wall  

designs  of  the  tomb  complex,  have  been  highly  abstracted  with  a  clever  mix  of  floral  and  

vegetal  scrolls.  Although   in  certain  cases   figurative  representation  were  unpretentious,  

such   as   the  naga   figure   that   guards   the   bottom  of   the   steps,   other   applications  were  

more   subtle   and   required   the   talents   of   highly   able   artisans   to   execute   the   subject  

matters   without   compromising   artistic   quality   (Figure   13).   In   Masjid   Mantingan   for  

example,   the   figure  of   silhouetted  Hanuman   among   the  vegetal   and   floral  pattern   can  

still  be  recognised  despite  being  subject  of  disfigurement  (Figure  14).  

                                                                                                                         6  Results  based  on  analysis  done  on  41  mosques  across  the  period  between  15th  and  20th  century.  The  art  of  scenery  and  representation  was  effectively  truncated  by  the  17th  century.  

18    

 

 

Figure  13  Phoenix  stylised  in  floral  and  leaves  motifs  

(Source:  Dirdjoamiguno  1970)  

 

 

Figure  14  Hanuman  disguised  in  floral  and  vegetal  pattern  

(Source:  Harlina  Sharif  &  Hazman  Hazumi)  

 

Secondly,  the  pre-­‐Islamic  motifs  that  survived  in  the  transition  period  were  

found  to  have  different  meaning  and  application   from  the   ‘usual’   Islamic   tradition.  

This   peculiarity   requires   one   to   probe   deeper   into   the   origin   and   significance   of  

19    

particular   motifs,   which   warrants   their   survival   into   the   early   Islamic   period.   The  

floral   and   vegetal  motifs   used   in   the   early  mosques  were   those  which   had   Hindu  

symbolism  attached.  The  use  of  lotus,  depicted  in  meandering  movements  within  a  

pond,   according   to  Widyosiswoyo   (2007),   originally   represented   Brahma  who  was  

born   of  waters.   In   early   Buddhist   art,   it   represented   the  Nativity   (Coomaraswamy  

1972).   It   was   employed   in   early   Islamic   period,   to   symbolise   divine   beings   and  

denote  miraculous  birth  and  apparitional   character.   The   lotus   is   a   common   theme  

found   in   the   decorative   panels   of   Masjid   Mantingan,   as   well   as   on   the   wooden  

panels  of  the  Sendang  Duwur  tomb  structure.    

Other  than  the  lotus,  life  tree  motif  was  also  present  in  various  locations  in  

the  tomb  complex  of  the  aforementioned  mosques.  Although  one  can  suppose  that  

the   idea  of  a   life  tree  echoes  an  Islamic  reference  of  shajarat  al-­‐khuldi   (the  eternal  

tree)  which  grows  in  the  paradise,  the  motif  was  originally  popular  in  several  Hindu-­‐

Javanese  temples.  It  is  not  a  co-­‐incidence  that  these  motifs  were  mainly  employed  in  

the  tomb  architecture,  where  embodiment  of  concepts  related  to  life  in  paradise  are  

expressed  (Tjandrasasmita  1984).    

Thirdly,   features  adapted   from  pre-­‐Islamic  artistic   traditions  often  required  

major  adjustments  or   ‘disguise’  effects   in  order  to  suit   Islamic  purposes.  Even  with  

the  adjustments,   their   survival  was  not   guaranteed.   The   scenery  decorative   styles,  

depicting   forest,   meru,   lotus,   winged   gateway   and   highly   stylised   makara,   were  

outwardly   rejected   afterwards.   Despite   being   camouflaged  with   floral   and   vegetal  

motifs,  which  are  readily  accepted  as  part  of  Islamic  arts’  repertoire,  their  meanings  

and   origins  were   very  much   authentically   related   to   Hindu   and   pre-­‐Islamic   beliefs  

and  epics.  Even  the  style  of   representation   i.e.  depiction  of   life   in  paradise,  has  no  

archetypal  origin  in  Islamic  artistic  tradition.    

The   process   of   selective   borrowing   is   a   common   phenomenon   during   a  

transition  period  between  different  belief  systems.  In  his  study  of  early  Indo-­‐Islamic  

mosque  architecture  of  India,  Robert  Hillenbrand  similarly  highlighted  the  process  of  

filtering   undergone   by   the  Muslims   in   India   before   any   artistic   traditions   could   be  

accepted   as   Islamic   (Hillenbrand   1988).   In   contrast   to   the   Indian   experience,  

however,   Muslims   in   Island   Southeast   Asia   only   arrived   at   a   period   of   selective  

borrowing,   and  did  not  exceed   the   stage  of  experimentation  between   the  old  and  

20    

the   new.   As   experimentation   requires   not   only   a   vast   knowledge   of   artistic  

repertoire,  but  more  importantly  a  deep  understanding  of  both  cultures;  its  success  

depends   on   persistence,   support   and   sponsorship   –   which,   may   take   decades   or  

centuries.  This  requires  stable  socio-­‐political  and  economic  conditions.  In  the  case  of  

Muslim  civilisation   in   the  Dunia  Melayu,   the  on-­‐going  political   turmoil  especially   in  

the   17th   and   18th   century,   which   witnessed   the   disintegration   of   many   Islamic  

sultanates   of   the   region,   provided   constrained   opportunities   for   any   sort   of  

development,  especially  pertaining  to  the  arts  and  architecture.  Furthermore,  a  high  

level   of   artistic   innovation   is   required,   if   ever   the   past   artistic   styles   were   to   be  

employed,   incorporating   fundamental   appreciation   of   motif   and   material  

technologies  in  its  borrowings  as  well  as  applications.  As  artistic  culture  is  an  intrinsic  

part  of  a  society,  understanding  the  past  tradition  and  its  artistic  grammar,  is  a  vital  

tool  in  developing  a  unique  repertoire  of  original  Islamic  arts  vocabularies.  

   

21    

Bibliography  

(1976).   The   Arts   of   Islam,   ed.   T.   A.   C.   o.   G.   Britain   England:   The   Arts   of   Council   of   Great  Britain.  

Abdul  Rochym,  1983.  Mesjid  Dalam  Karya  Arsitektur  Nasional  Indonesia,  Bandung:  Angkasa.  Ambary,  H.  M.,  2001.  Menemukan  Peradaban:  Jejak  Arkeologis  dan  Historis  Islam  Indonesia,  

Jakarta:  Logos  wacana  Ilmu.  Ashadi,  2006.  Warisan  Walisongo,  Jakarta:  Lorong  Semesta.  Britannica,  E.,  Great  Mosque  of  Damascus,  in  Britannica  Academic  Edition.  Coomaraswamy,   A.   K.,   1972.  History   of   Indian   and   Indonesian   art,  New  Delhi:  Munshiram  

Manoharlal.  Dirdjoamiguno,  W.,   1970.  Penjuluh   tentang  mengambarkan   hiasan   untuk   seni   ukir   logam,  

kaju,  batu  dan   lain;   ‘Instruction   for  Drawing  on  Metal,  Wood,   Stone  Etc.’  Djakarta:  Bhratara.  

Graaf,  H.  J.  D.,  1985.  Awal  Kebangkitan  Mataram,  Jakarta:  Pustaka  Utama  Grafiti.  Handinoto  &  S.  Hartono,  2007.  Pengaruh  Pertukangan  Cina  pada  Bangunan  Mesjid  Kuno  di  

Jawa  Abad  15  -­‐  16.  Dimensi  Teknik  Arsitektur,  Vol.  35,  No  1(July  2007),  23  -­‐  40.  Hillenbrand,   R.,   1988.   Political   Symbolism   in   Early   Indo-­‐Islamic   Mosque   Architecture:   The  

Case  of  Ajmir.  British  Institute  of  Persian  Studies,  Vol.  26(Iran),  105-­‐17.  Moehamad  Habib,  M.,  2001.  Kebudayaan  Islam  di  Jawa  Timur,  Yogyakarta:  Penerbit  Jendela.  Tjandrasasmita,   U.,   1984.   Islamic   Antiquities   of   Sendang   Duwur,   Jakarta:   Pusat   Penelitian  

Arkeologi  Nasional.  Widyosiswoyo,  S.,  2007.  Sejarah  Seni  Rupa  Indonesia  I,  Jakarta:  Universitas  Trisakti.  Wiryoprawiro,  Z.  M.,  1986.  Perkembangan  arsitektur  masjid  di   Jawa  Timur,  Surabaya:  Bina  

Ilmu.