Techniques and Practical Skills in Scenery, Set Dressing and ...
The Art of Scenery and Representation in Tomb Mosques' Decorations
Transcript of The Art of Scenery and Representation in Tomb Mosques' Decorations
1
The Art of Scenery and Representation in Tomb Mosques’ Decorations
Harlina Md Sharif
Hazman Hazumi
Introduction
The art of scenery or ‘scenic art’ is a technique of representation whereby a scene of
action or event is depicted, often with the inclusion of narrative aspect in its design
composition. Originally used in theatrical performances, the execution of scenery techniques
in visual and fine arts is usually found in paintings. The introduction of painting into the field
of Islamic arts is believed to have taken place during the Ilkhanid period in Persia (13th
century). The Mongol invasions that resulted in the dispersion of artisans and craftsmen
paved way to the immersion of Chinese artistic traditions, where painting was one of its
oldest and greatest art (The Arts of Islam, pp. 29, 309).
The impact of Chinese influence on the Islamic arts was evident in the art of book
and manuscript. With the Ilkhanid rulers passing through a stage of Buddhism before their
conversion to Islam in 1295 C.E., the Chinese artistic motifs such as the peony and lotus
became popular addition to existing repertoire of artistic composition (The Arts of Islam, p.
29). In the initial incorporation of illustrations in books, small size drawings were utilised
mainly as visual aids in highlighting the text intents of scientific writings. However, what
began as an illustrative method eventually developed into a distinctive art category known
as miniature paintings. Although in the beginning these paintings passed through a stage of
‘Islamicisation’ through the stylisation and modification of representational figures,
composed within symmetrical or geometrical compositional layout; they eventually
transformed into accomplished scenic and representation artistic work (The Arts, p.310).
The scenic art technique found its popular application in manuscript illuminations,
and to a small extent, textile decorations. In architecture, especially in buildings built during
Islamic rule, its application is limited and almost unknown. However, the mosaic decoration
on the walls of the Great Mosque of Damascus, was an exceptional case, with ‘more than an
acre of mosaics depicting a fanciful landscape thought to be the Quʾrānic paradise’
2
(Encyclopaedia Britannica). It preceded the Persian experimentations by more than five
centuries. Apart from this early attempt by Umayyad Caliph Al-‐Walid I (705-‐715 C.E), its
applications in other Islamic buildings are yet to be learnt. For this reason, the discovery of
the scenic art in two tomb mosques in Java, namely Masjid Sendang Duwur and Masjid
Mantingan, is not only fascinating; it is critical in the efforts of understanding the origin and
characteristics of this rare art technique.
The Tomb Mosques in Java (15th -‐16th century)
The period of 15th and 16th century is often referred to as being ‘the transition
period’ (Tjandrasasmita 1984; Ambary 2001). This epoch witnessed the transformation of
artistic cultures from its ancient origins into Islamic aesthetic values. During this formation
stage, remnants of ancient traditional practice were detected in the extant mosques of Java
Island. The architecture and decorative elements evoked archetypal memory of pre-‐Islamic
traditions, which were adapted to suit the new creed.
This study looks at two mosques, both built in the 15th and 16th century, which are
classified as tomb mosques. They are the mosques of Masjid Sendang Duwur (in Lamongan,
Central Java) and Masjid Mantingan (near Jepara, Central Java). These mosques are
considered as ‘pure’ tomb mosques based on the study’s evaluation of their principal
functions in accommodating for tomb visitors. Despite the obvious risk of over-‐simplifying a
mosque’s functional typology (since a mosque ordinarily serves multi-‐purpose functions); a
pure tomb mosque often exhibits distinctive characteristics that are identifiable through
studying its physical layout.
One of the physical identifiers for a tomb mosque is its placement on a small hill or
an elevated site. The site selected is often isolated as isolation heightens the sacrosanct
aspect of the mosque (Abdul Rochym 1983, p.86). A review on the tomb layout for Sunan
Drajat and Sunan Tembayat, both which are objects of annual pilgrimage in Java; reveals this
distinctive criterion (Figure 1). Both of the mosques of Sendang Duwur and Mantingan are
similarly found built on small hill tops overlooking surrounding areas (Figure 2). It is also
common to find that the site selected was a historically sacred site. According to Moehamad
Habib (2001), a site is also considered pure if a sacred edifice –even a pre-‐Islamic structure-‐
was previously built therein. In his research conducted on Masjid Sunan Ampel, Masjid
Sendang Duwur and Masjid Mantingan, pre-‐Islamic artefacts were found on the sites of
3
these mosques containing relief ornamentations depicting sacred figures or sacred buildings
of Hindu-‐Javanese times (Moehamad Habib 2001).
Tomb of Sunan Drajat
(Moehamad Habib 2001)
Tomb of Sunan Tembayat
Source: http://yuliantoqin.culture360.org/
Figure 1 Layout of tomb complex
4
(a) Sunan Sendang Duwur
Source: (Tjandrasasmita 1984)
(c) Masjid Mantingan – Sultan Hadlirin and Ratu Kalinyamat
Edited from: (Handinoto & Hartono 2007)
Figure 2 Layout of tomb mosques
5
The second physical identifier is the design layout of the mosque complex, especially
in terms of placement of the tombs in relationship to the mosque. In most tomb mosques,
the necropolis of the revered individuals is placed in the region approximately to the west of
the main prayer hall i.e. in the direction of the qibla behind the qibla wall. The tombs found
in Sendang Duwur and Mantingan are all located in the western part of the mosques’
compounds. These tombs are placed within a cungkup, or a roofed structure, often with a
space around the tombs provided for tomb visitors to perform prayers and invocations.
The presence of pawestren (ladies prayer area) in Javanese mosques is also a sign
that a mosque functions as a tomb mosque. The main function of a pawestren is to provide a
space for female congregation who (were usually ‘rewarded’ to) sit and read passages from
the Qur’ān and selected dhikr in selected time of the year as a tribute and invocation
towards the spirit of the deceased. This space is distinguished from the normal prayer space
designated for women congregation by its placement and design in relation to the main
prayer hall and the tombs. Ordinary female prayer space is often located near the eastern
wall of the mosque i.e. behind the saf of male congregation; if the prayer space is relatively
tight. In bigger mosques, the female prayer space is located to the left of the main prayer
hall i.e. near the southern wall or on the upper level. This space is usually not completely
sealed and could be demarcated by movable screens such as half-‐height movable divider or
by drawing a curtain. It is also often accessible from the common entrance of the main
prayer hall. The pawestren however, is usually designed completely sealed off from the main
prayer hall. It is also located adjacent to the tomb building.
In Javanese mosques, the tomb of the most revered wali or rulers are placed in
dalem i.e. the most inner part of a tomb complex, which is usually the third and last place in
terms of sequence of placement. It is accessible through gated walkways, with successive
compounds providing sequential hierarchy of the tomb’s sanctity. This study finds that the
necropolis of Masjid Sendang Duwur and Mantingan are all designed with gated walls and
gateways, either in the form of Candi Bentar (split gates) or Paduraksa (covered) (Figure 3).
6
Figure 3 Gateways and fences varieties in Masjid Sendang Duwur
(Source: Harlina Sharif & Hazman Hazumi)
7
Historical Background
Masjid Sendang Duwur -‐ also known as Makam Sunan Sendang (The Tomb of Sunan
Sendang) -‐ is located in the village of Sendang Duwur, under the district of Paciran,
Lamongan. It is said to have been founded by Raden Nur Rakhmad, the son of Raden Abdul
Qohar – an ‘alim from Lamongan; and a grandson to Syeikh Abu Jazid Al Baghdadi a renown
ulema from Egypt 1. His contributions to Islamic teachings in Sendang Duwur gave him the
title Sunan Sendang (Wiryoprawiro 1986).
The mosque complex is located on an elevated site within the villages of Sendang
Duwur and Sendang Agung (also known as Sendang Lebak). Sendang is Javanese for small
pond, whereas Duwur means high (Sendang Duwur: small pond on a high ground); while
Lebak means valley. The Sendang Duwur village is situated in a rock hill area which is quite
remote from the flat coastal region; and can be reached by car from the arterial road of
Sedayu-‐Tuban through a small road of approximately 5 km. From Sendang Duwur village, the
mosque is accessible by foot, through a series of levels ascending approximately 500 meter.
The date of the mosque’s construction is established from various sources. A
chronogram found on a wooden panel written in Javanese characters in an archaic shape
together with an inscription below it in Arabic language was translated by Pijper as follows:
“It may be known that this mosque has been built twice, the first time in 1483
(Javanese calendar) which is the same as 971 Hijrah;2 and the second time in 1851 (Javanese
calendar) which is 1339 Hijrah, which makes it 368 years between the two constructions. In
the second construction, stones and a part from the wood of the first building have been
used”.
The date of the second construction confirms the date inscribed above the doorpost
of the mosque in Arabic, Javanese and Latin characters of the year 1920. Another inscription
found on a decorative wooden panel at the tomb of Sunan Sendang is written in Javanese
characters of an ancient form. According to Stutterheim who analysed the panel, the date
1 The name al-‐Baghdadi often refers to someone who originated from Baghdad, Iraq. The validity of the above account however could not be verified. 2 Tjandrasasmita in his thesis on Sendang Duwur quoted the copy of an old manuscript that he found in relation to the history of the mosque. Sunan Sendang was said to have “flown” the mosque from Mantingan and had it landed on the Tunon Hill (Sendang Duwur). The date quoted from the manuscript coincides with the inscription found on the panel “gunaning salira tirta hayu” which correlates to 1483 Shaka or 1561 C.E.
8
inscribed was 1507 Shaka3 or 1585 C.E. This date may have been the date of the foundation
of the tomb, or the year Sunan Sendang died. The 24 years difference (between 1561 C.E.
and 1585 C.E.) is reasonable; thereby establishing the approximate date of build for the
mosque to be around that period (Tjandrasasmita 1984).
The mosque complex is made up of:
• the Sendang Duwur mosque and adjoining ablution building: the mosque is extensively
renovated although still maintaining the old form
• The eastern entrance compound which consists of a well (Sumur Giling), and a flight of
staircase directly connected to the main entrance of the mosque
• the northern compound: which houses several courtyards of old cemeteries and two
roofed structure that serve as store houses for the remnants of the old mosque
• the western compound: where the tomb of Sunan Sendang is located under cungkups
(pyramidal and hip roofs) within a courtyard which is located on a lower level to the level
of the mosque. This courtyard is locked from visitors who have no intention to pay
homage (ziyarah) to the tomb (Tjandrasasmita 1984).
• The southern compound: a steep site containing cemetery and a gated entrance to the
south giving access to the mosque for villages from Sendang Lebak.
The cemetery is a dominant feature in Sendang Duwur mosque. From the site plan,
it is evident that the mosque only occupies approximately a tenth of the whole compound.
Masjid Mantingan, also known as Masjid Astana Mantingan, is located in Mantingan
village within the district of Dati II Jepara; which is 6 kilometer to the south of Jepara town.
The mosque is accessible from the town through a series of villages and agricultural lands.
The mosque complex is located on a small hill – about 5 to 10 meter height from road level.
It is surrounded by plantation fields and located close to the woodcraft industry of Jepara.
The villagers’ dwellings are found outside the perimeter of the agricultural lands and
woodcraft industry.
Pangeran Hadlirin made Kalinyamat (18 km south of Jepara) as the ruling centre and
according to folk story, during the stressful times of ruling Jepara, from time to time he loved
3 Shaka or Saka: Javanese traditional calendar year
9
to be in seclusion at Mantingan. To enable her to be with her husband, Ratu Kalinyamat built
a house (pasanggrahan) in Mantingan. In about 1549, Hadlirin was killed by the ruler of
Jipang Panolan, Haryo Penangsang (or Arya Panangsang) and his body was buried at
Mantingan. The Mantingan Mosque was built by Ratu Kalinyamat in about 1559; at the same
site where the house was; in commemoration of her husband’s death (Graaf 1985). The date
of build is based on the inscription found on the mihrab of the mosque, written in Javanese
script referring to the year of 1481 Shaka which correlates to 1559 C.E. (Ashadi 2006).
The mosque is a three tiered pyramidal roof structure with attached pendopo style
serambi (built in 1950s). The complex could be divided into:
• The mosque with veranda and ablution area
• Eastern courtyard and main entrance to mosque
• Tomb of Sultan Hadlirin and Ratu Kalinyamat – west of the mosque
Decorative Scheme and Techniques
The art of scenery in these mosques are found applied on various mediums such as
stone slabs, wood panels and coral tiles. Masjid Sendang Duwur is the only extant mosque
known, to have preserved the art of stone carving inherited from pre-‐Islamic period. In this
mosque, the stone structures displayed an outstanding array of motif representations, with
three dimensional sculptural effects. Its decorative schemes are mainly seen employed in its
gated fences, as well as in the body of the tomb structure.
The intricate detailing reveals the expertise in execution of decorative schemes that
narrate symbolic subject matters. Vegetal and floral scrolls are stylised in the forms of
garuda wings, winged meru, life tree, lotus in pond, and scenery of mountains and forests.
Zoomorphic motifs are also found, especially around the opening of the gateways. Unique to
other tomb complexes and sacred edifices, Sendang Duwur’s winged gateway4 is found to
have no comparable references, either from traditional practices or similar edifices in Java.
In his study on this ancient artefact, Uka Tjandrasasmita (1984) cited the work of H. Bergema
in his book, “De boom des levens in schrift en Historie” that pointed out the similarity of
4 Entranceway to the tomb of the revered wali decorated with sculptured wings of garuda, a mythical bird in Javanese ancient beliefs
10
Sendang Duwur’s winged gate design to a winged gate motif found on a round seal of
ancient Babylon that symbolises a gateway to heaven, or refers to the wings of the guardians
of the gate. Tjandrasasmita however, was of the opinion that the form is an innovation in
itself as winged gateway had previously been employed only in two-‐dimensional decoration
and not as a three-‐dimensional architectural design (Tjandrasasmita 1984) (Figure 3).
The same motif similarly is repeated on the wall surface of the gateway in a variety
of compositions (Figure 4, 5). In these designs, the ‘gateway to heaven’ is depicted as having
a pair of wings. Above the entry doors is a stylised makara, an important guardian in
Javanese mythology (Figure 6). Above the makara, is a tree with branches extending
outwards, believed to be representing the life tree. Zoomorphic motifs, sometimes
silhouetted using floral and vegetal, take various symbolical functions. The trunk of the
elephant is found ‘guarding’ the sides of one of the gateways of the Sendang Duwur.
Elephant is a relief motif associated with Buddha, while an elephant in a Hindu temple is
associated with Gaņeśa (Widyosiswoyo 2007).
11
Location: Fence
Medium: Stone
Motif: Gateway, Garuda Wings, Life Tree, Makara Face, Forest
Figure 4
(Source: Harlina Sharif & Hazman Hazumi)
Location: Fence
Medium: Stone
Motif: Gateway, Garuda Wings, Life Tree, Makara Face, Forest
Figure 5
(Source: Harlina Sharif & Hazman Hazumi)
12
Naga Makara
Figure 6 -‐ Zoomorphic themes stylised in floral and vegetal motifs
Source: (Dirdjoamiguno 1970)
Another zoomorphic motif found on the tomb gate relief was the motif of kala-‐
marga which floats above and curls around the gate opening. In Hindu temples, the kala
finds its origin in the Kala-‐mikha or Kirtti-‐murkha; the Infinite manifesting itself through the
mythical creature, which crowns the arches of the temple’s doorways and niches
(Burckhardt 1967). Kala-‐marga according to Javanese conception is a floating rainbow which
has the body of a serpent with two heads on opposite ends in the shape of a deer or a
buffalo (Figure 7). This serpent is believed to be floating above the island of Java; and its
heads duck into the seas of Java Island and the Indian Ocean to suck the waters and spit
them again upon the earth (Tjandrasasmita 1984). Popular motifs in Sendang Duwur’s gate
design were stylised makara, garuda wings, naga, serpent, scorpion, phoenix, and elephant.
All of these motifs were related to pre-‐Islamic conceptions of heaven and guardians (Figure
8).
13
Location: fence Medium: stone
Motif: serpent with head of a deer, rainbow
Location: fence Medium: stone
Motif: serpent/ scorpion tail
Figure 7 Kala-‐marga with a deer head and serpent tail, curling around the gateway.
a) Naga with opened mouth b) Peacock
c) Stylised makara face with peacock wings d) Naga
Figure 8 (a-‐d) Motifs symbolically representing the concepts of heaven and guardianship (Source: Harlina Sharif & Hazman Hazumi)
14
The decorative themes for the tomb structure depict subjects that are symbolically
representing sceneries in heaven. Motifs are carved both on stone and wood panels.
Depiction of heaven is executed through the scenery of orchards, with cungkup (covered
structure) in the form of meru5, mountains, clouds, the moon and the sun as the subject
matters. Garuda wings still persist, guarding the entry to the sacred tomb, as well as in the
depiction of the gate in the heaven scenery (Figure 9, 10).
a) Garuda wings guarding entry to tomb
b) Pedestal at the foot of stairs towards the tomb entry
c) Wood panels on the body of the tomb structure
Figure 9 – decorative scheme on the tomb structure
(Source: Harlina Sharif & Hazman Hazumi)
Figure 10 – depiction of heaven in stone carved panel of the tomb.
(Source: Harlina Sharif & Hazman Hazumi)
5 Meru, in Javanese ancient beliefs, is a sacred mountain that represents the centre of the world. It is an abode for the Gods and sacred spirits.
15
Masjid Mantingan similarly employed symbolic motifs and design composition to
narrate the concepts of death, heaven and revered individuals. The subject matters of the
panel decorations varied from floral series, geometrical and scenery; with motifs of
silhouetted animals such as the monkey (Hanuman), elephant and phoenix; orchard (or
paradise) scene with split gates, fences and pendopo against meru background. In this
mosque ingenious skill of carving is evident from the intricate detailing of motif composition
on coral slabs. These slabs are currently plastered to the entry wall of the mosque’s prayer
hall in medallion-‐like manner (Figure 11).
Figure 11 – Decorative coral panels of Masjid Mantingan plastered on the entry wall
(Source: Harlina Sharif & Hazman Hazumi)
16
(a)
(b)
Location: wall Medium: coral
Motif: forest/ park, meru, life tree
Location: wall Medium: coral
Motif: candi, split gate, meru, lotus, forest
(c)
(d)
Location: wall Medium: coral
Motif: water lily, mountains
Location: wall Medium: coral
Motif: water lily, moving clouds
Figure 12 – Details of the coral designs in Masjid Mantingan
(Source: Harlina Sharif & Hazman Hazumi)
Conclusion: Extinction of the Art
The period of 15th and 16th century, was the last period that exhibited a wide
range of artistic traditions, many which originated from pre-‐Islamic practices. It was
during this era that the mosques employed full range of decorative motifs consisting of
floral and vegetal, zoomorphic, cosmos, geometric pattern, scenery, calligraphy, and
three-‐dimensional artworks. Despite the obvious potentials to be further developed to
create a more accomplished language of Islamic art, some of the pre-‐Islamic art tradition
17
failed to survive. Critical among these repertoires is the art of scenery and
representation, which totally diminished in mosque decorative schemes by the 17th
century.6
The 17th and 18th century witnessed the stagnancy in the creations or
developments of building art forms. Stone architecture and the art of stone carving
totally diminished from mosque’s design. Similarly motifs such as zoomorphic, cosmos,
scenery and three-‐dimensional artworks, almost completely disappeared during this
period. Decorative artworks that prevailed were in the ‘minor’ aspects of the building,
mainly associated with ornamental rather than architectural. The whole capacity of
decorations was reduced to the furnishings of the mosque, such as in the mimbar, the
“grandfather” clock, the lighting accessories, and the main doorway into the prayer hall.
The way in which the motifs were used across the periods studied raises several
interesting points. Firstly, how were certain features of decorative elements readily
accepted as ‘Islamic’ while others were rejected? Floral and vegetal motif, for example,
had widespread applications, regardless of time and region. It is the most dominant
form of motif used, regardless of art medium (i.e. material). On the other hand
zoomorphic, cosmos, scenery and three-‐dimensional motifs and applications were
abruptly stagnated by the 17th and 18th century. Notwithstanding the fact that these
decorative styles were absorbed after initial borrowing, and undergone rigorous filtering
and trimming stages in order to fit Islamic requirements; they failed to survive after early
applications.
Examples can be retrieved from the zoomorphic motif applications seen in
Masjid Sendang Duwur. The mythical subjects found in the gateway and stone wall
designs of the tomb complex, have been highly abstracted with a clever mix of floral and
vegetal scrolls. Although in certain cases figurative representation were unpretentious,
such as the naga figure that guards the bottom of the steps, other applications were
more subtle and required the talents of highly able artisans to execute the subject
matters without compromising artistic quality (Figure 13). In Masjid Mantingan for
example, the figure of silhouetted Hanuman among the vegetal and floral pattern can
still be recognised despite being subject of disfigurement (Figure 14).
6 Results based on analysis done on 41 mosques across the period between 15th and 20th century. The art of scenery and representation was effectively truncated by the 17th century.
18
Figure 13 Phoenix stylised in floral and leaves motifs
(Source: Dirdjoamiguno 1970)
Figure 14 Hanuman disguised in floral and vegetal pattern
(Source: Harlina Sharif & Hazman Hazumi)
Secondly, the pre-‐Islamic motifs that survived in the transition period were
found to have different meaning and application from the ‘usual’ Islamic tradition.
This peculiarity requires one to probe deeper into the origin and significance of
19
particular motifs, which warrants their survival into the early Islamic period. The
floral and vegetal motifs used in the early mosques were those which had Hindu
symbolism attached. The use of lotus, depicted in meandering movements within a
pond, according to Widyosiswoyo (2007), originally represented Brahma who was
born of waters. In early Buddhist art, it represented the Nativity (Coomaraswamy
1972). It was employed in early Islamic period, to symbolise divine beings and
denote miraculous birth and apparitional character. The lotus is a common theme
found in the decorative panels of Masjid Mantingan, as well as on the wooden
panels of the Sendang Duwur tomb structure.
Other than the lotus, life tree motif was also present in various locations in
the tomb complex of the aforementioned mosques. Although one can suppose that
the idea of a life tree echoes an Islamic reference of shajarat al-‐khuldi (the eternal
tree) which grows in the paradise, the motif was originally popular in several Hindu-‐
Javanese temples. It is not a co-‐incidence that these motifs were mainly employed in
the tomb architecture, where embodiment of concepts related to life in paradise are
expressed (Tjandrasasmita 1984).
Thirdly, features adapted from pre-‐Islamic artistic traditions often required
major adjustments or ‘disguise’ effects in order to suit Islamic purposes. Even with
the adjustments, their survival was not guaranteed. The scenery decorative styles,
depicting forest, meru, lotus, winged gateway and highly stylised makara, were
outwardly rejected afterwards. Despite being camouflaged with floral and vegetal
motifs, which are readily accepted as part of Islamic arts’ repertoire, their meanings
and origins were very much authentically related to Hindu and pre-‐Islamic beliefs
and epics. Even the style of representation i.e. depiction of life in paradise, has no
archetypal origin in Islamic artistic tradition.
The process of selective borrowing is a common phenomenon during a
transition period between different belief systems. In his study of early Indo-‐Islamic
mosque architecture of India, Robert Hillenbrand similarly highlighted the process of
filtering undergone by the Muslims in India before any artistic traditions could be
accepted as Islamic (Hillenbrand 1988). In contrast to the Indian experience,
however, Muslims in Island Southeast Asia only arrived at a period of selective
borrowing, and did not exceed the stage of experimentation between the old and
20
the new. As experimentation requires not only a vast knowledge of artistic
repertoire, but more importantly a deep understanding of both cultures; its success
depends on persistence, support and sponsorship – which, may take decades or
centuries. This requires stable socio-‐political and economic conditions. In the case of
Muslim civilisation in the Dunia Melayu, the on-‐going political turmoil especially in
the 17th and 18th century, which witnessed the disintegration of many Islamic
sultanates of the region, provided constrained opportunities for any sort of
development, especially pertaining to the arts and architecture. Furthermore, a high
level of artistic innovation is required, if ever the past artistic styles were to be
employed, incorporating fundamental appreciation of motif and material
technologies in its borrowings as well as applications. As artistic culture is an intrinsic
part of a society, understanding the past tradition and its artistic grammar, is a vital
tool in developing a unique repertoire of original Islamic arts vocabularies.
21
Bibliography
(1976). The Arts of Islam, ed. T. A. C. o. G. Britain England: The Arts of Council of Great Britain.
Abdul Rochym, 1983. Mesjid Dalam Karya Arsitektur Nasional Indonesia, Bandung: Angkasa. Ambary, H. M., 2001. Menemukan Peradaban: Jejak Arkeologis dan Historis Islam Indonesia,
Jakarta: Logos wacana Ilmu. Ashadi, 2006. Warisan Walisongo, Jakarta: Lorong Semesta. Britannica, E., Great Mosque of Damascus, in Britannica Academic Edition. Coomaraswamy, A. K., 1972. History of Indian and Indonesian art, New Delhi: Munshiram
Manoharlal. Dirdjoamiguno, W., 1970. Penjuluh tentang mengambarkan hiasan untuk seni ukir logam,
kaju, batu dan lain; ‘Instruction for Drawing on Metal, Wood, Stone Etc.’ Djakarta: Bhratara.
Graaf, H. J. D., 1985. Awal Kebangkitan Mataram, Jakarta: Pustaka Utama Grafiti. Handinoto & S. Hartono, 2007. Pengaruh Pertukangan Cina pada Bangunan Mesjid Kuno di
Jawa Abad 15 -‐ 16. Dimensi Teknik Arsitektur, Vol. 35, No 1(July 2007), 23 -‐ 40. Hillenbrand, R., 1988. Political Symbolism in Early Indo-‐Islamic Mosque Architecture: The
Case of Ajmir. British Institute of Persian Studies, Vol. 26(Iran), 105-‐17. Moehamad Habib, M., 2001. Kebudayaan Islam di Jawa Timur, Yogyakarta: Penerbit Jendela. Tjandrasasmita, U., 1984. Islamic Antiquities of Sendang Duwur, Jakarta: Pusat Penelitian
Arkeologi Nasional. Widyosiswoyo, S., 2007. Sejarah Seni Rupa Indonesia I, Jakarta: Universitas Trisakti. Wiryoprawiro, Z. M., 1986. Perkembangan arsitektur masjid di Jawa Timur, Surabaya: Bina
Ilmu.