Taylor trial transcript - 28 October 2009 - Special Court for ...
-
Upload
khangminh22 -
Category
Documents
-
view
0 -
download
0
Transcript of Taylor trial transcript - 28 October 2009 - Special Court for ...
Case No. SCSL-2003-01-T
THE PROSECUTOR OFTHE SPECIAL COURTV.CHARLES GHANKAY TAYLOR
WEDNESDAY, 28 OCTOBER 20099.30 A.M. TRIAL
TRIAL CHAMBER II
Before the Judges: Justice Richard Lussick, PresidingJustice Teresa DohertyJustice Julia SebutindeJustice El Hadji Malick Sow, Alternate
For Chambers: Ms Erica Bussey
For the Registry: Ms Rachel IruraMr Benedict Williams
For the Prosecution: Ms Brenda J HollisMr Christopher Santora Ms Maja Dimitrova
For the accused Charles Ghankay Taylor:
Mr Courtenay Griffiths QCMr Morris AnyahMr Silas Chekera
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:32:30
09:33:16
09:33:38
09:33:52
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30492
Wednesday, 28 October 2009
[Open session]
[The accused present]
[Upon commencing at 9.30 a.m.]
PRESIDING JUDGE: Good morning. We'll take appearances,
please.
MS HOLLIS: Good morning, Mr President, your Honours,
opposing counsel. This morning for the Prosecution, Brenda J
Hollis, Christopher Santora and with us our case manager Maja
Dimitrova.
PRESIDING JUDGE: Thank you.
MR GRIFFITHS: Good morning, Mr President, your Honours,
counsel opposite. For the Defence today, myself, Courtenay
Griffiths. With me, Mr Morris Anyah, Mr Silas Chekera of
counsel.
PRESIDING JUDGE: Thanks, Mr Griffiths. Mr Taylor, you are
still bound by your oath. Please go ahead, Mr Griffiths.
MR GRIFFITHS: May it please your Honour.
DANKPANNAH DR CHARLES GHANKAY TAYLOR:
[On former affirmation]
EXAMINATION-IN-CHIEF BY MR GRIFFITHS: [Continued]
Q. Mr Taylor, yesterday afternoon when we adjourned we were
looking at the testimony of one Foday Lansana, a radio operator.
You recall that?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. And the last topic we dealt with was his return to Sierra
Leone from Vahun to install a radio there, he said, on the
instruction of the one Galakpalah. Do you recall that?
A. Yes, I do.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:34:25
09:34:56
09:35:13
09:35:41
09:35:54
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30493
Q. And that he took a radio which he then installed at
Foday Sankoh's address in Pendembu, yes?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, Mr Taylor, I need to ask you some further questions
about this for this reason: You've told us that after May/June
of 1992 you severed all links with Foday Sankoh. Is that right?
A. That is correct.
Q. Now, bearing that fact in mind, I want you to listen
carefully, please, to the following testimony from this witness.
And we pick up where we left off yesterday afternoon. Page 4380,
line 3:
"Q. Who went with you to" --
PRESIDING JUDGE: Yes, Ms Hollis.
MS HOLLIS: Excuse me. What date is that?
MR GRIFFITHS: That is for 20 February 2008:
Q. Line 2 - well, let me start at the top:
"A. I moved immediately with an escort to go to Pendembu.
Q. Who went with you to Pendembu?
A. Mr Sankoh sent some securities from the RUF side to
receive me on the borderline."
Jump to line 17:
"Q. You say promotion to overall signal commander. Who
gave you the promotion?
A. I received this promotion based by recommendation made
by Mr Sankoh for me to go and work with him and he did say
that I was a peaceful person and that I was not part of the
dispute that took place between his men and the others, so
he said I should go back to Sierra Leone and work with
him."
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:36:34
09:36:57
09:37:26
09:37:50
09:38:18
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30494
Over the page to page 4381, please, line 10:
"Q. For which group were you working as the overall signal
commander?
A. This time round for RUF.
Q. You said you met some of Foday Sankoh's securities at
the border. What happened after that?
A. They received me and we proceeded directly to Pendembu.
I met with Mr Sankoh. He gave me some men for them to help
me to install the radio on his ground that was referred to
as Executive Mansion Ground in Pendembu and that was where
he resided at that particular time. The installation took
place. I tested the communication. I confirmed it with
Treetop, Butterfly and he requested" - that being Sankoh -
"that he wanted to talk to Mr Charles Ghankay Taylor. I
made all the necessary arrangements with the operators and
at that particular time Mr Charles Ghankay Taylor spoke
with Mr Sankoh and he asked a few questions of him with
regards the situation in Sierra Leone after the NPFL were
evacuated back to Liberia."
Do you follow?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. So what this witness is clearly saying, Mr Taylor is, one,
not only did your of your employees, Galakpalah, facilitate the
move of this radio operator back to Pendembu to work for the RUF,
but thereafter you remained in contact with Mr Sankoh. Do you
get it? What do you say to that?
A. That is not true. But even if you - and the reason why
it's not true, if you look at this witness's statement as is
given here, for this man to go back two weeks after I withdraw
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:39:21
09:39:48
09:40:12
09:40:36
09:41:06
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30495
people to install a radio and it is only at that time that
Foday Sankoh is able to contact me, suggests that Foday Sankoh
has no radio at all, because it did not take him to return in May
1992 to make a call. So the suggestion that there is no radio
that he is already suggested in statements you read yesterday is
total nonsense, because this will mean that Foday Sankoh is
operating in Sierra Leone for close to one year without any
communication. Now - I mean, you know, there's got to be some
logic put into these people's statements.
He returns to Sierra Leone before Foday Sankoh calls me,
okay, to - for me to ask him what's going on in Sierra Leone.
But mind you, we've been cooperating for some nine months and
it's only the conflict that brings the withdrawal, so there must
be a way that Foday Sankoh - if there is no human called Foday
Lansana, none whatsoever, we must assume that Foday Sankoh has a
means to contact me because he's been contacting me. Okay.
There's been contacts over the radio between August 1991 up to
the withdrawal. So for this witness to suggest that it only
takes him to return with one radio before there can be contact, I
mean, one can see that it is totally, totally impossible and
incredible, as he explains it. It is not true.
My suggestion is that, normally, I didn't speak to
Foday Sankoh after that particular time. Look, two weeks after I
withdraw my men, if Foday Sankoh - if I had chosen to speak to
Foday Sankoh because maybe he was trying to make mends to what
had happened, I would tell this Court, "I spoke to him two weeks,
three weeks, a month after," and I still say, "No, I want nothing
to do with you." Why would I lie and say, "Oh, I never talked to
him after May 1992"? Total nonsense.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:41:40
09:42:01
09:42:21
09:42:46
09:43:10
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30496
My suggestion is that this boy being - this man being a
Sierra Leonean at heart, as I mentioned yesterday, stole this
radio, probably, and went back and took it on to Foday Sankoh.
But this man cannot tell this Court that up until the time he
returned two weeks after the May 1992 incident there was no radio
in Sierra Leone. He says that that was the only radio he had to
take back. What is that? Impossible. While others are claiming
that I'm speaking to them and sending arms and ammunition as in
the case of Isaac Mongor. I mean, it just doesn't make sense and
it's totally - it's totally false because I do not speak to
Sankoh. If I had spoken to Sankoh two weeks after, I would have
said, "I spoke to Sankoh."
But for me, Charles Ghankay Taylor, to get on a radio?
Nonsense. Total nonsense. Anyone that have come to this Court
and said they heard my voice on the radio is a liar. That is not
possible.
Q. Well, Mr Taylor, let's continue in the same vein so you get
the full import of what this witness is saying on this topic. We
move then to page 4383 commencing with an answer at line 5:
"A. I arrived in Pendembu and Mr Sankoh received me and he
gave me some gallant men who assisted me to erect the
antenna to install the radio communication and I tested it
with the radio communication in Gbarnga, Butterfly, Treetop
and it was confirmed."
Now, you recognise both of those names, Butterfly and
Treetop, don't you?
A. Yes. But don't forget, this man is trained by the NPFL.
He knows this. So, these names, by spewing them out to this
Court, really, it shouldn't make a difference. He is trained by
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:43:45
09:43:58
09:44:12
09:44:38
09:44:59
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30497
the NPFL. This man in 1990 states that he is trained by the
NPFL, he goes through special training, he runs away, he flees,
goes back to Sierra Leone. First he goes to Ganta to see his
people. So this man knows the system. So he can call almost all
the names, yes.
Q. But he continues:
"A. ... He also asked me that I make arrangements to
enable him to speak with Mr Charles Taylor and I did.
Q. Who asked you that, to make the arrangements to speak
to Mr Charles Taylor?
A. Mr Sankoh at that particular time.
Q. You said you made this arrangement?
A. Yes.
Q. How did you do that?
A. After I had installed the radio I tuned to the
frequency and I called Butterfly and Butterfly answered,
and I arranged - made arrangement that Mr Sankoh wanted to
talk to Mr Taylor. Then he told me to hold on until he
makes Mr Taylor available. Then he spoke with Mr Sankoh.
Q. Were you present when this occurred?
A. Yes."
He goes on to mention that your code name was Ebony and
that Mr Sankoh's code name was Toyota. And moving to page 4385,
he continues like this, line 1:
"Q. Describe what you observed in terms of this
conversation between Mr Sankoh and Mr Taylor at this time
in Pendembu, after you installed the radio set.
A. After the installation of the radio station, Mr Taylor
was then available on the radio and Mr Sankoh also was now
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:45:47
09:46:10
09:46:45
09:47:07
09:47:34
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30498
available in my own station, and he called him and said,
'Big brother, this is Toyota speaking', and he answered."
Jump to line 22:
Q. I just want you to describe what you observed in terms
of the conversation between Mr Sankoh and Mr Taylor at this
time in Pendembu after you installed and tested the radio
set.
A. Mr Sankoh called Butterfly by saying, 'Toyota for
Butterfly' and Mr Taylor answered. He said, 'Big brother,
this is Toyota speaking.' And Mr Taylor answered, he said
'I am all right.' He said, 'How is the situation after the
departure of the NPFL'" - note that - "'troops from Sierra
Leone?' And he said, Mr Sankoh said, 'Things are a little
okay. The men are all right and the relationship between
the civilians and the fighting men is okay. The only thing
that we are short of is that the fighting men took away all
the materials, the arms and ammunition with them and for
now I need your assistance in light of these
materials.'
Q. Was there anything else said?
A. Yes, Mr Taylor ordered Mr Sankoh to travel to Gbarnga
for them to establish a better understanding.
Q. When you say ordered, what do you mean?
A. He told him that he was to report to him for a 'better
understanding of what you are trying to discuss with me'
and then he said goodbye to him."
Then the witness goes on to say that he remained in
Pendembu for the rest of '92 and '93 and, "I was instructed by
Mr Sankoh for me to start training operators in Pendembu."
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:48:21
09:48:54
09:49:17
09:49:48
09:50:14
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30499
He is quite clear, Mr Taylor. He is suggesting that the
relationship continued after Top Final and the order sent via
Dopoe Menkarzon to withdraw NPFL troops. There was still
contact. What do you say?
A. Well, look, the only way these - I say no. I say totally
no. But to understand this kind of disinformation here you have
to look at other statements to really understand it. I guess
there is a crucial question here that must be asked. First we
have an assumption. Nya Lansana becomes the radio operator for
Foday Sankoh and he is supposed to become the radio operator for
Foday Sankoh in May of 1992 - excuse me, not May. June, because
he said two weeks later. He now becomes the radio operator for
Foday Sankoh following our withdrawal of our men.
But the crucial question is who is Foday Sankoh's radio
operator between March of 1991 up until May of 1992? Does he
have any radio operator? Does he have any radio? Because if we
conclude that Foday Sankoh could not have operated in Sierra
Leone for a year without a radio operator, Nya Lansana's own lie
here that suggests that he becomes really the first real radio
operator to make contact - because it does not take Nya Lansana
to contact to call to Gbarnga if a call has to be made even
before the two weeks that he speaks about. I'm talking pure -
you know, it doesn't take him. So why does Foday Sankoh have to
wait for two weeks if he is calling me? Why does he have to wait
for two weeks? He is suggesting here that Foday Sankoh, one, did
not have a radio or, two, did not have a radio operator that knew
how to contact me. But what was Nya Lansana doing prior to May
of 1992? Was he working with Foday Sankoh? Was he his operator?
These boys - and as he testifies here and comes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:51:03
09:51:25
09:51:47
09:52:04
09:52:26
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30500
specifically with the NPFL after this I can see where it is
going. Somebody had to tell him to tie in specifically. What is
the relevance of contact with Foday Sankoh before May 1992 or at
the end of 1993? What is the real relevance as far as this is
concerned, that somebody would have to sit here - look, your
Honours, if Foday Sankoh had called me three, four months after I
pulled my troops to talk to me I would say he called but I still
told him no. This young man here suggests things that are
totally impossible that the RUF did not have communication, this
is what he suggests, and that Foday Sankoh had virtually no means
of getting to me until he took one radio back in May after they
had been in operation for a long time and had been in full
cooperation with the NPFL at the particular time.
And the way he even suggests it, he goes to the border and
Foday Sankoh sent people for him. The only thing I can come
again and say is that this boy ran away, he went right back to
Sierra Leone as most of them had gone back to go because they
were more Sierra Leoneans than Liberians. That's all I can put
it to.
But the suggestion that I was in contact with Foday Sankoh
and that he made such arrangements and that I spoke to
Foday Sankoh on the radio is a lie. I never spoke to anyone on
the radio. If I needed Foday Sankoh during the time of our
cooperation he came to Liberia. Now what is more incriminating?
Foday Sankoh coming to Liberia that I tell you he came there
during that period and someone saying that I have to deny that,
oh, there was a radio call. Total nonsense. He is a liar.
Q. Well, Mr Taylor, you note that in the passage I read out to
you mention was made of you ordering - note, ordering - Sankoh to
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:53:09
09:53:35
09:54:05
09:54:26
09:55:00
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30501
go to Gbarnga to provide more details. Did you note that?
A. Yes, I noted that. I didn't comment on it.
Q. Well, this witness continues on that topic in this way,
page 4387, commencing with an answer at line 5:
"After the training and within a period of one month there
were operators and radio communication was then available
in order to carry out an effective operation, so we had a
radio station at Pendembu, Kailahun, Koindu, Kuiva,
Gandorhun and up to Kono.
Q. How did these radio installations take place?
A. Mr Sankoh departed Sierra Leone after the communication
between himself and Mr Taylor and he travelled to Gbarnga,
and he came back with some operators who were also RUF but
had been pushed back from Pujehun and then they went
through Liberia and they were based in Gbarnga and they
came back to Sierra Leone.
Q. Who were these radio operators that Sankoh came back
with? Do you know them?
A. Yes, some I think Alfred Brown, King Perry Kamara,
Samuel Lamboi, Osman Tolo, Sahr James, Alfred Malloh."
Now, Mr Taylor, let's take this in stages so that we get
the full understanding of what the witness is saying before I ask
for your comment. Now you will recall from the evidence there
was a two-pronged initial invasion of Sierra Leone: one through
Kailahun and one through Pujehun, yes?
A. Uh-huh.
Q. You recall that?
A. Uh-huh.
PRESIDING JUDGE: Mr Taylor, you'll have to say something
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:55:13
09:55:41
09:55:57
09:56:09
09:56:27
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30502
that can be recorded.
THE WITNESS: Okay. Okay.
MR GRIFFITHS:
Q. Do you recall that, Mr Taylor?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. Now, whereas we are told the Kailahun axis, as various
witnesses refer to it, met with some success, the Pujehun route
was repelled at some stage and a number had to return into
Liberia and you recall we looked at testimony about you meeting
with that group with Foday Sankoh, that group which had retreated
from Pujehun. Do you remember that?
A. Yes.
Q. And that being wrapped up with the creation of Black
Kadaffa, do you recall that testimony?
A. Yes.
Q. And it being thereafter said that those individuals then
travelled through Liberia to join up with their RUF comrades in
Kailahun. Do you remember that?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. And you provided, it is alleged, trucks to enable that to
occur. You recall?
A. Yes.
Q. So bear that fact in mind. So what the witness is saying
against that background is that after Top Final when you give the
order for the NPFL to withdraw from Sierra Leone, Sankoh travels
to Liberia and he's in Liberia and able to link up with those
members of the RUF who had retreated from Pujehun. Do you
follow? And that he then returns with some of them who he names
specific radio operators. Do you see? That's what's being
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:57:21
09:57:50
09:58:15
09:58:35
09:59:03
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30503
suggested. That's the scenario I want you to comment on.
A. But - well, if - what I understand here, he's speaking
about May of 1992 after he returns to Sierra Leone.
Q. Well, he's speaking about sometime after May of 1992.
A. May of 1992. The other incident of the mix-up occurs at
the beginning of the operation in March of 1991, okay. So what I
see him trying to say here is that some people are still in
Liberia and Foday Sankoh goes back after he returns in May 1992
and he brings in these radio operators. But interestingly -
interestingly, counsel - just above the page there he mentions
radio installations in certain areas.
Q. Yes?
A. About four or five. Where are those radios coming from?
Because we see here he is talking about radio operators going but
- so there are radios in those areas. I'm looking for I think
it's Kuiva or some other areas, a few towns.
Q. Line 8?
A. Yes. So what is this witness really saying? Remember this
witness said that he had to be sent back with one radio to
Foday Sankoh before contact could be made. But there are radios
- there's supposed to be stations in other places, okay. So who
is operating these things? And mind you, Alfred Brown - Alfred
Brown is a vanguard, according to testimony before this Court,
okay. So if Alfred Brown is a vanguard, he is older - and a
radio operator, he is older in the RUF organisation than even
this Foday Lansana, okay. So Alfred Brown is a vanguard based on
testimony before this Court, and Alfred Brown trained some of
these people including the James Sahr and the King Perry.
Look, how can there be radio stations at these areas in
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
09:59:48
10:00:11
10:00:33
10:01:01
10:01:27
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30504
Sierra Leone that Foday Sankoh does not contact me? He has to
return with one radio before a contact is made? Your Honours,
it's a lie. It's impossible, as he is trying to link it. He
didn't put this lie together properly. Either there are radios
in Sierra Leone or he takes the first one there. That's the
point I made before. Only to get to find out that there are
other stations, okay, where he is saying that there are radios
but Sankoh had to come back to Liberia to carry these operators,
and we know this Alfred Brown is mentioned as a vanguard. So who
comes first, he or Alfred Brown? Alfred Brown is a vanguard and
radio operator. So he just did not make up this lie properly.
He cannot associate this May 1992 situation.
I tell you, your Honours, if Foday Sankoh had dared put his
foot in Liberia after Top Final, I don't think he would have
survived. There were a lot of people that got killed on both
sides in that Top Final operation, and for Foday Sankoh to have
come up into Liberia, that's totally false. But mind you, there
are so many, many, many, many, many Prosecution witnesses that
have come before this Court that have dealt with this very issue
after Top Final. I recall, and I stand corrected, no incident
where any of these witnesses reflect that Foday Sankoh returned
to Liberia after Top Final. He's the only one. I mean - so I
stand corrected on that, but I do not recall that because it did
not happen. Foday Sankoh never put his foot back in Liberia
following his departure in I would say late May, early June 1992.
Never did. Never.
Q. Who is Alfred Brown, Mr Taylor?
A. Alfred Brown is a vanguard that is mentioned throughout the
testimony and the brother of this Fatou Brown that, based on
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:02:14
10:02:39
10:02:58
10:03:29
10:03:55
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30505
evidence in this Court, was supposed to be the fiance or
girlfriend of Foday Sankoh at the time he was putting this
operation together sneaking around in the area. Fatou Brown was
the woman with him. And the lady whose name - who is a protected
witness, I cannot mention here, who claimed to have been also
with Fatou Brown in testimony before this Court, this Alfred
Brown is the brother of that Fatou Brown that was the wife or
fiance of Foday Sankoh at the time of this operation.
Q. The other names mentioned at lines 18 and 19, Mr Taylor, do
you recognise any of them?
A. Lines --
Q. On page 4387.
A. Yes, here in this Court we saw King Perry.
Q. At the time, back in 1992, how many of these names meant
anything to you?
A. None whatsoever. None whatsoever.
Q. The witness continues at page 4388 in this way, line 5:
"A. During 1992 there was a ceasefire in the first place.
In the middle of the ceasefire the Guinean contingent
attacked our position in Bayama. The last quantity of arms
and ammunition - a large quantity of arms and ammunition
was captured in Bayama village. This report was sent to
Mr Charles Taylor by Mr Foday Sankoh. Based on this
attack, which was at the end of the ceasefire between the
RUF and the Government of Sierra Leone, under the
leadership of President Joseph Saidu Momoh, the RUF were
equipped with communication sets and operators that were
trained began to use those communication sets. We had a
radio station in Kailahun, Bunumbu, Gandorhun, Koidu,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:04:45
10:05:02
10:05:22
10:05:49
10:06:13
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30506
Kuiva."
Let's complete the sequence. Let us go then to page 4390
commencing at line 26 with this question:
"Q. Now, you described an occasion where you facilitated a
communication for Foday Sankoh to Charles Taylor when you
arrived in Pendembu.
A. Yes. I said there was a building in Pendembu which was
called Executive Mansion and it was the residence of
Mr Sankoh."
Bottom of the page, line 29:
"Q. Now, you earlier, as I mentioned, discussed the
communication between Sankoh and Taylor at Pendembu. Was
this the only time you described - witnessed such a
communication?
A. Yes."
Over the page to page 4393, line 8:
"A. ... When the Guinean and the Nigerian contingents
attacked the positions of the RUF at Bayama a large
quantity of arms and ammunition were captured from them and
this report was sent to Gbarnga to Mr Taylor. Mr Sankoh
said because the weapons that were captured were all
artillery and it could not use those artilleries in this
country simply because he has not got ammunition for those
weapons. Mr Taylor requested him to send all the artillery
weapons to Gbarnga.
Q. You said a report was sent to Charles Taylor. Describe
exactly what you mean.
A. Mr Sankoh contacted Mr Taylor in a radio conversation
and he said, 'Big brother, these are the materials that
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:06:57
10:07:31
10:08:10
10:08:38
10:09:19
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30507
have been captured.' He named very few of them and
Mr Charles Taylor, in his response, told him that he should
report with those materials to Gbarnga.
Q. Were you present for this report being sent?
A. Yes, I was the operator."
Now, taking things in stages, Mr Taylor, did you receive
such a gift from Mr Sankoh?
A. Well, the fact of the matter is, to answer your question, I
did receive an artillery piece from Sankoh, but in answering yes
to that question, this did not happen after May 1992. How and
where would this artillery have passed? Where? And don't let's
forget, Nya does not become, from evidence - and I can strongly
suggest this - operator for Foday Sankoh until after he retreats
two weeks after Top Final. So whatever he is talking about here,
his knowledge now of my dealing with Sankoh, he must - his
knowledge must start from about June 1992, if I'm write in my
assumption here, because that's when he goes back and now he
becomes the operator.
But, your Honours, by June - by August 1992, ULIMO has
completed the control of Lofa. By the time we withdraw our
people in May, the battle is so intense. No human being in their
right mind would be moving any equipment or ammunition or arms
out of any place. So at the time that this equipment is brought
into Liberia is before - before we separate from the RUF. And,
in fact, we have exhibited the weapon here before this Court.
It's a 155 millimetre gun that was used as an exhibit that we
showed to this Court. This is not a little piece of thing. This
is a weapon that can only be moved by being pulled by a truck.
It is a long-barreled, heavy, several ton weapon, and nobody -
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:10:01
10:10:28
10:10:50
10:11:16
10:11:40
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30508
the road between the border into Liberia by this time, nobody
will put a vehicle on that road.
So, again, when these boys - these men are trying to put
these lies together, they get it wrong. There is no such thing
after this particular time. No. So did I receive artillery from
the RUF during that period? Yes. But not after we severed
relationship. That road was too - nobody would even dare - only
military people walked on that road and supplies were not carried
on that road.
Q. But he continues, page 4394, line 7:
"Q. After the ceasefire was broken, can you describe
generally what was the state of communication at this time
in Pendembu between Mr Sankoh and Mr Taylor?
A. Mr Sankoh - Mr Sankoh briefly gave outlines of arms and
ammunition that were captured during the attack on Bayama.
He spoke about rocket-propelled grenade launcher. He
talked about a huge quantity of anti-tank that was
captured, that is one-barreled AA. He talked about RPG,
BZT twin-barrel and he said that he had no ammunition for
these weapons and he has deemed it necessary not to use
them, but that he was requesting for light weapons like
AK-47s and G3 ammos.
Q. Do you know, if any, was there any response from
Mr Taylor during this communication?
A. Yes, Mr Taylor requested Mr Taylor to go himself to
Gbarnga with the materials that he is reporting about.
They would sort everything out upon his arrival."
Line 28:
"Q. What was Mr Taylor's response exactly to Mr Sankoh?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:12:14
10:12:36
10:13:05
10:13:30
10:14:03
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30509
A. That he should go.
Q. Who is he?
A. He said Mr Sankoh should go to Gbarnga with those
materials that he had said were not necessary for him to
use in his operation in order to exchange them.
Q. After this communication --
A. Yes.
Q. -- did anything happen?
A. Yes, Mr Sankoh left Pendembu for Gbarnga. Upon his
return Mr Mohamed Tarawalli, Sam Bockarie, Issa Sesay, and
Morris Kallon were instructed to go to Koidu, a
diamond-rich area in Sierra Leone, for a fresh operation,
or attack on the government troops. The operation went
smoothly and at the end of 1992 they were chased out of
Koidu on to Pendembu.
Q. Before you proceed, you said that when Sankoh was
discussing this issue with Mr Taylor he was requesting for
light weapons like AK-47s and G3 ammos. And then after
this conversation he proceeded to Gbarnga. Do you know if
anything happened with relation to this request?
A. Yes, Mr Sankoh went to Gbarnga and he returned with
some quantity of arms and ammunition before Mohamed
Tarawalli, Issa Sesay, Sam Bockarie, Morris Kallon, could
proceed for the Kono operation.
Q. When you say he returned from Gbarnga with some
quantity of arms and ammunition, how do you know that?
A. He travelled to Gbarnga and he came back to Sierra
Leone.
Q. How do you know he returned with ammunition - a
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:14:38
10:14:53
10:15:15
10:15:31
10:16:01
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30510
quantity of arms and ammunition?
A. When he returned he went to the G4 ground or the area
where arms and ammunition were kept and I was on the scene
and I saw it at that time before the troops could leave for
Kono.
Q. Was this while you were in Pendembu?
A. Yes, yes.
Q. When you say G4 area, what are you referring to?
A. It's where arms and ammunition are kept for
safekeeping."
Now, Mr Taylor, putting that together, what is being said
by the witness is this: There's that initial visit to Gbarnga by
Foday Sankoh after the initial installation of the radio in
Pendembu. Do you follow?
A. Yes.
Q. He then returns with those radio operators including Alfred
Brown. You follow?
A. Yes.
Q. He now makes a second trip after the capture of this
artillery and other heavy weapons and in effect he exchanges
them, those heavy weapons, with you in return for lighter
weapons, AK-47s and G3 ammos, and it's that material provided by
you which thereafter enables an attack on Kono. Do you get it?
A. Yes.
Q. What do you say about that?
A. Well, I can tell you there is no contact after this time in
May/June 1992 so this witness is totally off. But there is
sufficient evidence before this Court to show that throughout the
period that I have accepted that I dealt with the RUF there was
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:16:51
10:17:15
10:17:39
10:18:15
10:18:35
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30511
always a problem with ammunition. It was always a problem with
the material that they are getting. Foday Sankoh demonstrated
his frustration with that. There was no quid pro quo. The heavy
155 millimetre cannon gun that was given before this break-up was
given - there was no quid pro quo attached to the giving of that
weapon. This whole nonsense about radio operators for the first
time just going back to Sierra Leone after May 1992 is all
hogwash. That's all it is. Trying to piece things together.
I have given the picture here and that's the story and if
you look at most of the other even Prosecution witnesses that
have testified here again they do not deal with any testimony
here that reflects this witness's recollection that there is
relationship between Foday Sankoh and Charles Taylor and their
movement of material, arms and ammunition, after the Top 20, Top
40, Top Final thing. So this witness's own recollection is
totally false. His recollection is wrong, especially as he deals
with dates and times it's totally wrong.
Q. Let me ask you specifically, Mr Taylor, so that we're all
clear about the position: You accept that you did receive a
piece of heavy weaponry from Foday Sankoh, yes?
A. Oh, yes. Yes.
Q. Did you give him anything in return?
A. No. He brought the weapon. I had always been giving
Foday Sankoh small amounts of arms and - I mean of ammunition.
So like I'm saying, there was no quid pro quo. We were not doing
a business to say there was a quid pro quo, but I had been giving
Foday Sankoh some material throughout the time that we were
cooperating on the border. So there was not a quid pro quo.
Q. So you're saying there wasn't any kind of deal between the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:19:15
10:19:35
10:19:53
10:20:21
10:20:49
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30512
two of you in those terms?
A. No, no, no. He brought the weapon, I had been giving him
things. Whenever Foday Sankoh had problems I would give him what
I had. My security people were in there. I kept them busy
giving them supplies. But Foday Sankoh didn't come, "I'm
bringing you a weapon, please exchange it with this." Whether he
brought a gun or not, I was going to give him some ammunition to
protect that border to fight ULIMO so it did not take a deal.
There was no deal. If he had brought nothing but his hands
swinging and I had material to protect that border I would have
given it to him as I did on many occasions. So I wouldn't
mislead this Court about that. Yes, I - so it was not like we
were running some little game where, "Okay, you give me
something, I give you something back." No.
JUDGE SEBUTINDE: Mr Griffiths, if I might seek
clarification. Why was it necessary to return this artillery
piece to you, Mr Taylor?
THE WITNESS: Well, where they were, he really didn't need
it. This artillery piece, your Honour, is a piece that fires
155. We're talking about - and I could stand corrected on this -
maybe 18 to 21 kilometres. It's a long-range cannon. They were
in the bush and he felt that it was not safe and we were really
fighting mostly in the city area and so we needed it more than
they needed it.
MR GRIFFITHS:
Q. Tell me, Mr Taylor, as far as you were aware did the RUF
have the capabilities in terms of ammunition or training or
expertise to operate weapons of that kind? Did you know?
A. I would think so, yes, because they had several - from what
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:21:32
10:21:59
10:22:25
10:22:51
10:23:12
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30513
Sankoh said, they had several former members of the Sierra
Leonean armed forces working with them too so I would think they
did, yes.
Q. Let's move on, please, because in addition to describing
those two trips made by Sankoh to Gbarnga after the period
May/June which we know to be the timing of Top Final, the
witness, a radio operator, goes on to say this at page 4439, line
11:
"We used to have what we called prearrangement. Like what
I've just discussed with you in the past. Whenever Mr Sankoh
wanted to communicate to Mr Charles Taylor you have to make the
prearrangements and such communication can never be encoded.
They will speak to each other and make sure that the frequency on
which they were communicating was free from all other stations
except the two."
Page 4441, line 19:
"Q. Now you said commanders including you said when
Foday Sankoh wanted to communicate with Charles Taylor
there would be a prearranged frequency. What do you mean
by this?
A. For example, as I just said, the national frequency in
case you wanted to communicate to Mr Sankoh, you first come
to the national frequency and make a net call or call the
code name of Mr Sankoh's radio station. The operator would
answer and you would tell the operator to switch to so and
so frequency for arrangement and you people will have to go
there and make the arrangements for another frequency that
would be appropriate for that particular communication."
So in addition to visits by Sankoh, there were these
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:24:04
10:24:34
10:24:59
10:25:35
10:25:59
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30514
pre-arranged radio conversations going on, according to this
witness. What do you say?
A. That's not true. You know, I wonder if the question is
posed in trying to understand this witness's testimony, what is
Nya Lansana doing before this time? We haven't - because Nya
Lansana is featuring his dramatic return two weeks after Top
Final. This is where Nya Lansana - what is he doing before this
time?
And maybe another important question will be since he is a
trained radio operator, who is he operating as operator for?
Because this boy - we'll be running in circles with this liar and
we will not find it. Who is Nya Lansana working for prior to May
1992? Who is he working for? Because we don't trace Nya
Lansana. We know that he is trained, from his testimony, and we
know that he says he goes to Ganta to visit his people. He goes
into Sierra Leone and he is captured. He is brought into Vahun
and he goes back. But what we do not know is what is Nya Lansana
doing before this two weeks return to Sierra Leone? What is he
doing? Obviously Nya Lansana is lying here with his activities.
So is Nya Lansana suggesting to this Court, as he did, that
prior to his involvement as a radio operator for Foday Sankoh
there was no means of communicating with Foday Sankoh? I mean,
what is he suggesting to this Court? What is he suggesting to
this Court? That the real communication with Foday Sankoh starts
two weeks after he goes and installs a radio in Pendembu? I
mean, you know, if we look at it logically what is he doing? Who
does he work for? Is he operating a radio prior to his gallant
two weeks return? Who is he working for? This boy doesn't know
what he is talking about.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:26:34
10:26:59
10:27:17
10:27:42
10:28:03
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30515
And I'm asking these rhetorical questions because it's at
the heart of his testimony. Here is a man that for the first
time is saying that he really becomes operational two weeks after
he goes back with a radio on this assignment. Prior to that he
has no assignment in Sierra Leone. At least I haven't seen it
yet in his testimony. His first assignment in Sierra Leone comes
two weeks after Top Final when Galakpalah sends him back. What
is he doing in Sierra Leonean before then? Is he operating a
radio? Is he operating a radio in Liberia? I mean, this - look,
he's just blowing smoke all over this place and you are talking
nonsense, okay. If you're a radio operator giving information
there is prearranged things and this, well, look, if you're a
radio operator in Liberia even calling from one station to
another you know it's prearranged, but nobody attracts Nya
Lansana here until after May 1992 and all of a sudden he is
centre stage, the only radio operator for Sankoh and he is doing
all this work. It is not true, your Honours. This man cannot be
right about what he is saying here.
Now, I had relationship with the RUF. Of course I did. I
said to this Court that Foday Sankoh came. I gave Foday Sankoh a
house in Gbarnga. Where is this radio operator Nya Lansana
throughout this whole period between August '91 and '92 when
Foday Sankoh is given a guesthouse is Gbarnga? Where is this
man? Look, there is relationship between us. You understand me?
But after Top Final when this man is supposed to be sent on this
special assignment and springs up where he is not accounted for
anywhere in Sierra Leone doing any radio work at that particular
time, all of a sudden he shows up is total nonsense. It is not
true. There is absolutely no contact. If there were contact I
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:28:45
10:29:05
10:29:29
10:29:51
10:30:18
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30516
would say so, because between May and June or July of course.
But there was none.
So unless we put these little logical pieces together about
this man who actually - if I'm placing Nya Korto now I'm placing
Nya Korto in the picture after Top Final. That's when I'm
looking at Nya Korto because that's when says he gets his orders
from Galakpalah to go in and he is lying unless he can define who
he was doing before, who he worked for in Sierra Leone, he is in
and out. In fact if he was in Liberia, what was he doing in
Liberia? So of course if you're a Liberian operator you know
that you are trained in 1990. You are trained. You know the
different stations. But picturing Nya Korto in Sierra Leone we
have to reflect on 1992 after Top Final which is May and Nya
Korto is lying on whatever happens after that because really he
is really a Johnny-come-late. That's all and he is just trying
to pick here and there.
Because all of the evidence like I see come here, if Nya
Korto or anybody, Foday Sankoh, had come on that road any time
after I would say July or August he would have encountered ULIMO.
He would have encountered ULIMO that had Lofa and in fact if they
were not in certain towns or villages they were in other villages
that it became a very militarised zone that no one could
penetrate so easily. So he is basically lying and he is a
latecomer and does not know what he is talking about when he
begins to talk about Alfred Brown and others that is a vanguard
who was in Sierra Leone long before him. No.
Q. Very well. Well, we're going to leave 1992 now and jump
ahead. I would like us to go, please, to page 4475, testimony of
21 February 2008. Could we begin, please, at line 7:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:31:06
10:31:26
10:31:51
10:32:08
10:32:24
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30517
"Q. Did anyone outside Sierra Leone have access to the
codes, that is the codes that were used by the radio
operators?
A. If anybody else outside Sierra Leone had access to the
codes he should be an operator.
Q. Did this occur?
A. Yes.
Q. Who else had access to the codes?
A. Like I told you: Osman Tolo, Memunatu Deen who were
at the lodge or the guesthouse in Monrovia were all
operators and they also had access to these codes.
Q. The codes themselves, who was in charge of creating the
codes?
A. The code was brought from Liberia and it was a code
from the NPFL and we extracted them from the NPFL code
system.
Q. You mentioned Osman Tolo and Memunatu Deen as having
access to the codes. Is that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. How do you know that?
A. Because they were external delegates from the RUF side
based in Monrovia.
Q. Why did they have access to the codes? Do you know?
A. Yes. Because they were operators and they used to
communicate with the RUF as external delegates.
Q. How do you know that?
A. I knew that as an operator and it was agreed and they
sent them for that purpose, and even before they went to
Monrovia, they were with Mr Sankoh in Ivory Coast. And
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:33:03
10:33:17
10:33:41
10:34:07
10:34:31
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30518
later after Mr Sankoh was dislodged, they escaped and
entered Monrovia.
Q. I want to take you to the time when Sam Bockarie was in
charge of the RUF.
A. Yes.
Q. When Sam Bockarie was in charge of the RUF, did anyone
outside of Sierra Leone have access to the RUF codes?
A. Yes.
Q. Who?
A. Osman Tolo was an operator who had access to the RUF
codes. Another operator by the name of Memunatu Deen also
had access to these codes and many others who were assigned
with Benjamin Yeaten, otherwise referred to as 50. Some
were assigned in Vahun and Foya.
Q. Who was Benjamin Yeaten?
A. Benjamin Yeaten was the immediate coordinator,
according to how I understood it when I arrived in Monrovia
in 1999, 22 December. I was introduced to him by Mr Sankoh
and he explained himself to me that he had been the
coordinator between Mr Charles Ghankay Taylor and Sam
Bockarie."
Now, let's just take things slowly, shall we. Firstly
this: You accept, don't you, Mr Taylor, that the RUF did have
radio operators at the guesthouse in Monrovia? We've dealt with
this, yes?
A. Yes, that's 1998.
Q. Now, if we look, first of all, at page - at lines 6 and 7
on page 4476. I don't want this detail to escape us, so let's
deal with this. "They went to Monrovia. They were with
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:35:19
10:35:57
10:36:24
10:36:38
10:37:02
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30519
Mr Sankoh in Ivory Coast and later, after Mr Sankoh was
dislodged, they escaped and entered Monrovia." What do you know
about that?
A. But this is so clear. This is so clear. They were with
Mr Sankoh in Ivory Coast. When was Mr Sankoh in Ivory Coast?
Mr Sankoh is in Ivory Coast in 1996. That's when Sankoh is in
Ivory Coast. Sankoh is in Ivory Coast '96. He goes into Nigeria
early '97 and is arrested. Now, here we have an association with
'96 all the way up to 1998. Because the guesthouse is given to
the RUF when Sam Bockarie comes to Liberia, in fact, the second
trip in October 1998. So I don't know how this man can associate
these two periods. I don't, because you can't talk about
Foday Sankoh in Ivory Coast, like I say, in '96 and talk about
installation at the guesthouse, then you're talking about two
different time periods.
Q. But, Mr Taylor, was it the case that after Mr Taylor was
dislodged --
A. After Mr Sankoh.
Q. Mr Sankoh was dislodged and that occurs - and that is
linked in the context of this answer with the Ivory Coast, is it
the case that RUF operators escaped from the Ivory Coast and went
to Monrovia?
A. I really don't know. No, I do not know if Sierra Leoneans
entered Monrovia after Sankoh was arrested in la Cote d'Ivoire.
I don't know. I don't know.
Q. As far as you're aware, did the Ivorian authorities take
action against the RUF delegation in la Cote d'Ivoire following
Sankoh's arrest in Nigeria in March 1997?
A. I can say specifically they took no action. They did not -
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:37:48
10:38:12
10:38:35
10:38:58
10:39:15
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30520
like by action you mean like trying to arrest them that they were
threatened? No. In fact, the guesthouse was not taken from
them. People stayed there, from my understanding, what I got to
know, that they were not harassed in la Cote d'Ivoire at all.
Q. Well, in light of that answer, can you recall any need for
RUF members to escape from la Cote d'Ivoire following Sankoh's
arrest?
A. No need whatsoever. No. In fact, even if we look at the
record, even when Sankoh is arrested in Nigeria, he alone he's
arrested. He's also with other Sierra Leoneans that are not even
touched. Gibril Massaquoi is with Sankoh during his arrest in
Nigeria. There is no reason, in specific answer to your
question, for anyone to escape. No one is threatened. The
Ivorian authorities are not hostile to Sankoh people that are on
the ground, I mean, to the best of my knowledge, in Ivory Coast.
Q. And at the time of Mr Sankoh's arrest in the Ivory Coast -
in Nigeria, Mr Taylor, which is March 1997 --
A. That is correct.
Q. -- did the RUF have a guesthouse in Monrovia?
A. No. I'm not even elected President yet of Liberia. I am
not the President of Liberia in March 1997. The head of the
Council of State is Ruth Sando Perry. They do not have a
guesthouse in Liberia at that time, no.
Q. Now, the second aspect of this passage that I want us to
deal with is this: You will note that at line 8 the witness's
attention is brought forward to the time when Sam Bockarie is in
charge of the RUF.
A. Yes.
Q. And in that context you will see at lines 17, 18 and 19
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:40:08
10:40:36
10:41:04
10:41:27
10:41:54
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30521
these words: Having dealt with who had access to the codes, it
goes on: "Some were assigned in Vahun and Foya." "Some" in the
context of the answer must be a reference to radio operators who
had access to the codes. Now, the question, Mr Taylor, is this:
After Sam Bockarie took charge of the RUF, apart from the radio
operator based, as you accept, at the guesthouse in Monrovia,
were there further RUF operators based in Vahun and Foya?
A. No. But how would they be based there? What - how? Sam
Bockarie takes charge of the RUF in when? In 1997 March when
Foday Sankoh is arrested in Nigeria. Who is in charge of this
area? Who is in charge of Lofa in '97 March? ULIMO. ULIMO is
in charge of Lofa. When does ULIMO relinquish Lofa? It's after
my election in July. So who would be there? If there were
operators there, there had to be arrangements between the RUF and
ULIMO.
March 1997, how would I be having radio people in that
particular area? Impossible. Impossible. Impossible. That's
totally, totally, totally false, okay. So, I mean, to even
suggest this.
But let me just make a point about this code thing. Don't
forget, this man is a trained radio operator by the NPFL as far
back as 1990. So the knowledge of codes or the Liberian - you
know, the knowledge of codes, Nya Lansana knows the codes because
that's a part of the training and he took - he took, you know,
the training on how to do codes. It did not take anyone in
Liberia sending him a set of codes before he would know how to
put codes together. No. So he is totally - he is totally,
totally, totally making this up about having radio operators in
Vahun and other places after Sam Bockarie takes over. Well,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:42:44
10:43:09
10:43:25
10:43:39
10:44:04
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30522
someone would argue, well, he's not talking about the early part.
He is talking about the latter part, which would still be false.
Q. Well, Mr Taylor, Foya and Vahun may have a significance
which may in due course be relied upon. So, consequently, let me
take you now, please, to page 4483 of the transcript and we see
how Vahun and Foya might figure in the overall picture. Line 19:
"Q. Now, in terms of the communications between Benjamin
Yeaten and Sam Bockarie" --
And, remember, Yeaten is supposed to be the coordinator
between Charles Taylor and Sam Bockarie.
A. Yes.
Q. "Q. Now, in terms of the communication between Benjamin
Yeaten and Sam Bockarie, when Sam Bockarie was acting
leader of the RUF, do you remember any of the content of
those communications?
A. Yes.
Q. Can you explain?
A. Yes. Whenever Benjamin Yeaten was dispatching material
to Foya, or to Sam Bockarie, he will always send a message
or he will say that this particular person was coming with
some rations for you to your location. Upon the arrival of
the person, he will only come on the net to testify that he
has reached with that material. He will come with them and
a document. That was the procedure of communication that
was conducted during Sam Bockarie's time and Benjamin
Yeaten as mediator between Mr Charles Taylor and Sam
Bockarie.
Q. You said 'whenever Benjamin Yeaten was dispatching
material to Foya or to Sam Bockarie.' What do you mean by
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:44:42
10:45:04
10:45:28
10:45:56
10:46:15
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30523
the word 'material'?
A. When I talk about materials I mean arms and ammunition
or anything that had to do with war material. Most of the
time it is not explicit. It cannot be simplified on the
net. But as an operator it can be revealed to you that
there is a transaction to you. There is a transaction
between that individual and the next person who was
receiving that information."
So let's just pause, remind ourselves of those two
locations, Foya and Vahun. They are on the route from Monrovia
to Kailahun, aren't they, Mr Taylor?
A. Well, Foya, yes. Foya is on the route.
Q. And Foya is quite close to the border with Sierra Leone, is
it not, or close enough?
A. Close, yes. Okay, close enough, yes.
Q. Now, consider this scenario: Benjamin Yeaten is
coordinator and, as coordinator, he may well want the recipient
of this material to know when it had reached within striking
distance of that recipient. Do you follow?
A. Yes.
Q. So bearing that in mind, it might be of some use to have a
radio operator in a location like Foya. Do you follow?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. So that when the material reaches Foya, the RUF radio
operator there can get in touch with the troops over the border,
"Guess what, chaps. We're close." Do you follow?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. So that's the significance of it, Mr Taylor. So I'm asking
you again: Did you permit the RUF to have radio operators in
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:46:59
10:47:25
10:47:49
10:48:13
10:48:36
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30524
Foya and Vahun?
A. No. N-O, no. Every town and nearly every village in
Liberia, the NPFL at the time and even my government had a radio
installed. It did not take the RUF to have a radio in this place
for them to communicate. If communication had to be done it
could have been done from any one of the stations and that's why
these people's logic, you know - again this whole case - I think
Chris Santora in his work, they forgot to investigate the
presence of material in Liberia. You know this whole case rests
on the capacity of Taylor after he becomes President to provide
material to the RUF. If they had done their homework they would
have known that there was no material in Liberia.
And I tell you something, this is a shut and closed case.
If anyone believes that Liberia had arms and ammunition or
Charles Taylor had possession of those arms and ammunition in
Liberia between the time he becomes President up to about 2001
when I order material then really I'm already guilty in this
case. They did not do their work, they fabricated this lie on
the assumption that he had material, he had the stocks of
material in Liberia and he delivered them. That's where this lie
and everyone that comes here keeps talking about arms and
ammunition going. There are no arms and ammunition in the
possession of my government. The United Nations had all of them
and destroyed every last one. I do not know where I could have
pulled these arms out of a magical hat or whatever. It's a
blatant lie. Any arms that is alleged to have gone into Sierra
Leone from my government from the time I became President is
totally, totally a lie and that's how the lie was built and every
liar has been here talking about a bunch of arms. There's been a
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:49:07
10:49:29
10:49:47
10:50:11
10:50:27
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30525
lot of truth, I do not deny that small amounts of arms went
across that border, but my government did not send them. Whoever
bought their arms and things, fine. But that's the basis of this
lie.
And so this man is another one of them that have them
pushed right down the line. They have got to show that somebody
is supposed to be calling, "Guess what, the arms are almost
approaching. Is it there?" I have radios in those towns and
villages. If my government is sending arms why do we have to
install an RUF radio? If Benjamin Yeaten is sending an official
amount of arms from the Government of Liberia why do I need an
RUF operator? It's very simple. It's very simple. You use a
Liberian operator and Liberian securities would take them across
the border. It just doesn't make sense, but this is the basis of
my suffering because of this kind of lie on the assumption that,
well, if it's there he sent it. They just should have checked to
see if Liberia had arms at that time. They didn't.
Q. Well, Mr Taylor, the suggestion may well be that it's
precisely because there was a clandestine operation which you
didn't want the world to know about, but it was sophisticated
nonetheless, why you needed to use these outsiders. Do you see?
A. But which outsiders now?
Q. The RUF radio operators.
A. Yeah, but Benjamin Yeaten is supposed to be central to all
of this. Why would Benjamin Yeaten have to use an RUF operator?
These are not secret radios. These radios I'm sorry we need to
bring more to this. These radios, everyone and his grandmother
can listen to them. These are open air communications. There is
nothing cryptic - there is no cryptic thing here. These are
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:51:01
10:51:19
10:51:44
10:52:02
10:52:23
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30526
nothing but SSB radios that everyone and his grandmother can
listen to. Once you get on a frequency there's nothing secret,
so why do you need an RUF operator clandestinely with a radio in
a little --
PRESIDING JUDGE: Mr Taylor, I'm sorry to interrupt but the
court reporter cannot keep up and is having trouble getting this
down, so please slow down.
THE WITNESS: Okay, I will. I'm sorry. The point I'm
trying to make here is Benjamin Yeaten is central. If there is
supposed to be this movement a Liberian operator can be used, but
in fact if it is really clandestine why could do you need to call
at all? If it's really clandestine, one of the most senior
security people in the country is moving through an area with
arms and ammunition, why do you have to be calling at different
points? Did it get there? If it's really clandestine all you
have to do is put armed men and escort it. Why do you have to
call when you know everybody can listen.
And mind you what time are we talking about? Nobody in
West Africa is stupid. I surely am not stupid and I do not claim
that these intelligence agencies don't listen to telephone. You
know we've heard this Court listen to, "He's on the satellite
phone." Well, listen, a satellite phone is even more dangerous
in terms of listening from intelligence agencies just as a radio.
What is a satellite phone? You go up, link to a satellite, they
pick it up from the satellite as you link it down. So anybody
knows, even as President I knew, telephones operate at about
18,000 gigahertz and anyone - we had the capacity in Liberia, my
government, to intercept telephone calls, even from landlines.
So nobody is stupid here that somebody has got to be sneaking on
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:53:04
10:53:30
10:53:55
10:54:16
10:54:38
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30527
an open SSB to listen.
This is all - you know, trying to make up this cloak and
dagger business has got me in jail for four years trying to prove
a negative. That's all it amounts to. He had weapons; there
were no weapons. He's calling, "Vahun, Vahun, come in. Are the
materials there?" "Yes, it's passing." Nonsense. Total, utter
nonsense. You are operating clandestinely and you are on an open
communication. It didn't happen, but we have to go through it
this way.
This man is totally out of his league and there is nothing
going through but the little bits and pieces that people are
buying in Lofa that Prosecution witnesses have mentioned before
this Court and I'm in no position to disagree that small amounts
of arms and ammunition, and mostly ammunition, went across that
border by people that - ULIMO and other people that dug them up
and sold them. My government I am stating categorically did not
have arms or access to arms in Liberia to send it to Jesus if
possible.
MR GRIFFITHS:
Q. Now, Mr Taylor, remember to date in relation to this
witness we've been dealing with various means of communication
between you and the RUF in that period after May/June 1992. You
recall that, yes?
A. Yes.
Q. In that same vein let's move on to another allegation this
witness makes about your involvement in communication with the
RUF after that period. Page 4490, transcript of 21 February
2008, line 13:
"Q. When Foday Sankoh was arrested in Nigeria how did you
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:55:31
10:55:53
10:56:25
10:56:48
10:57:11
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30528
come to learn of this?
A. Foday Sankoh made a trip from Ivory Coast along with
Gibril Massaquoi, Martin Moinama, an operator, with the
intention of going to Libya and he was arrested in Nigeria
at the airport. Gibril Massaquoi escaped and he was in
Nigeria along with Martin Moinama. While in Nigeria he
used to visit Mr Sankoh.
Q. Who is 'he'?
A. Martin Moinama used to visit Mr Sankoh to get
information from Mr Sankoh and then transmit that
information to Liberia and from Liberia we received all
necessary communication into Sierra Leone. To set a bright
and clear example, Mr Sankoh was imprisoned in Nigeria.
When he promoted Sam Bockarie, Isaac Mongor, Morris Kallon,
Issa Sesay, Peter Vandi and many more saw communication
that they should cooperate until his release. That
particular communication was received from Martin Moinama
in a telephone conversation from Nigeria to Liberia and
from Liberia it was transmitted on the HF" - high
frequency, no doubt - "transmission into Sierra Leone.
Q. So while Foday Sankoh was in Nigeria, just to make sure
it's clear, we would - you said in this particular
communication as an example he would have Martin Moinama
visit him and Martin Moinama would use the phone to
transmit a message to Liberia and from that point on from
Liberia the message would be transmitted to the RUF in
Sierra Leone through the HF system. Is that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. Who in Liberia received the message from Martin Moinama
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
10:57:43
10:58:17
10:58:34
10:59:01
10:59:28
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30529
in this example?
A. Martin Moinama made me to understand this when he
returned to Sierra Leone after the AFRC coup that he used
to transmit that message, telephone communication to
Mr Charles Ghankay Taylor and then Taylor would download
the message or inform Benjamin Yeaten and from Benjamin
Yeaten to Sam Bockarie. Even the communication that we
received an order for us to join the AFRC was done through
the same process."
Do you see?
A. I see.
Q. So Sankoh got his radio operator Martin to call you,
Mr Taylor, and that's why you were the one who promoted Sam
Bockarie to general and Issa Sesay to general and ordered the RUF
to join with the AFRC. Do you see? You were the messenger boy
for Mr Sankoh. Is that right?
A. Well, I was not and as he explained it it's totally
erroneous. I think this Court doesn't need to be told any more.
They know the process through which the RUF and the AFRC got
together. It's been cleared here that Foday Sankoh spoke to
Johnny Paul Koroma. The conversation was recorded and played on
the radio and the BBC. And his own account that - I don't know
how these people let these people come and do this kind of thing.
Somebody he said escaped from Nigeria but he used to go to Sankoh
to get information. Now, when I hear the expression escaped,
that I equate - you know, I associate escaping with flight, fear.
How will you escape and you will be able to go in Nigeria? You
escape from Nigeria but you've brave enough - you are under
threat and fear but you are right in the presence that you can
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:00:13
11:00:37
11:00:56
11:01:20
11:01:47
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30530
get messages. What is he talking about? Did these people
escaped? What are these people talking about?
So this account, your Honours, is just incredible for me
that I - you know, I have heard testimony and I have read
statements provided by the Prosecution of one of the individuals
provided whose name is mentioned here. His account of this - he
hasn't been brought to this Court yesterday, but his account of
this is quite different. He's given letters when they leave
Nigeria. They are - in fact, Foday Sankoh is in communication,
because for Foday Sankoh to be able to speak to Johnny Paul
Koroma and record a message, it simply means that there is a
degree of freedom with Foday Sankoh while he's in Nigeria. But
everything is done - the promotion is done by Foday Sankoh.
Mind you, the same witness has said I ordered Sankoh. Then
Sankoh is a very, very terrible officer. How dare Sankoh promote
people without my instructions? He's a terrible officer under me
to do that. All this fabrication is just what it is. I have
nothing to do with any promotion of Bockarie and the rest. I
have nothing to do with the AFRC and the RUF coming together. It
is all Foday Sankoh that does this.
Q. Well, help me with this, Mr Taylor: This man, Martin
Moinama, line 16, page 4490, an operator, one assumes in this
context a radio operator, can you help us. Why would Mr Sankoh
take a radio operator with him?
A. I don't know. I don't know why. I'm sure - well, to help
the Court, when - when Sankoh - I understand, while he was in la
Cote d'Ivoire, he was given a guesthouse and installed at the
guesthouse was communication that he will stay in contact with
his people behind him in Sierra Leone.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:02:25
11:02:41
11:03:09
11:03:24
11:03:42
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30531
Q. Yes.
A. That is my understanding.
Q. Yes. So help me, Mr Taylor, if Sankoh had that facility in
Cote d'Ivoire, why was he using you as his messenger boy?
A. I don't know why. And, in fact, just to add to it, at this
particular time that this witness is talking about, I'm still not
elected President of Liberia. He's still referring to it. I'm
not elected President of Liberia, and so the fact that there's an
operator in Monrovia, I don't know where he would be, and so I'm
still not President. I guess, mixing it up, he associates this
period with my presidency, which is not the case.
Q. Now, just help me, please, with this, because given what is
said about your direct involvement in downloading the message or
informing Bockarie, I want to ask you about the technicalities of
these things, Mr Taylor. Do you follow?
A. Yes.
Q. So when we return to page 4491, we see at line 19, the
witness is asked:
"Q. In terms of the transmissions from Liberia to Sierra
Leone, you said it was over HF. Is that correct?
A. No.
Q. How is the message from Liberia - once it arrived in
Liberia, how would it be sent to the RUF in Sierra Leonean?
A. From Liberia to Sierra Leone it was done through the HF
communication and from Nigeria to Liberia it was done
through telephone conversation."
So help me, Mr Taylor. If you're receiving these telephone
calls from Nigeria, what were you downloading?
A. I don't - I don't know. When I hear download, technically,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:04:21
11:04:38
11:04:56
11:05:16
11:05:35
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30532
I think that it mostly refers to internet activities, to download
something.
Q. Well, you were supposed to be doing it, Mr Taylor, that's
why I'm asking you to provide us with an explanation. What were
you doing?
A. There was no such thing that anyone could download because
I would not work for Foday Sankoh. On the one hand, I can't be
ordering Foday Sankoh and working for him at the same time, so
there is no such thing. And there would not be what - if a
telephone - maybe he is trying to say that maybe a telephone
conversation came and instruction - he is using big words that he
doesn't understand, but there is no way you can download a
telephone call. I don't know how - I have never downloaded one
even for myself. I don't know if technically it's possible to
download a telephone call.
But, again, this is a reflection of the incredible nature
of these statements that these witnesses have been prompted to
come here with and they just go off talking nonsense. Total
nonsense.
Q. Page 4492, same topic, line 8:
"Q. Now, you said there was also a message related to the
AFRC.
A. Yes, that was another one.
Q. Explain this message.
A. We received that instruction from Sam Bockarie that
Mr Sankoh had agreed with Johnny Paul Koroma that the RUF
should join the AFRC junta in Freetown. That message was
sent from Sam Bockarie. According to him, it was a
communication that was received from Martin Moinama to
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:06:22
11:06:50
11:07:10
11:07:33
11:07:55
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30533
Gibril Massaquoi that we were to comply with with immediate
effect. According to him there were details that were
recorded. Upon his arrival in Freetown it would be
presented to the hard core of the RUF.
Colonel Isaac Mongor refused to obey that command. He
asked Sam Bockarie to clarify that report before his troops
could join the AFRC in Matotoka. Sam Bockarie reiterated
to Isaac Mongor that he was to comply with this instruction
notwithstanding. When Martin Moinama and Gibril Massaquoi
were invited to Freetown after the AFRC coup, they
themselves - I mean Martin Moinama and Gibril Massaquoi
made it very he clear that every conversation that was
going on between Mr Sankoh on to Liberia and then
transmitted on the HF to Sam Bockarie were conducted by
them."
Over the page. He is asked again in relation to this
message regarding the AFRC, line 5:
"A. Martin was in Nigeria. He had a means of
communication with Mr Sankoh and in return send a telephone
message to Mr Charles Taylor in Liberia. After that
conversation he would communicate all necessary messages
that will be received on to Sam Bockarie through the HF
radio."
Then he continues, line 18:
"A. When the AFRC overthrew the NPRC in 1997, Martin
confirmed the communications that we used to receive from
Sam Bockarie through Benjamin Yeaten on the orders of
Mr Charles Taylor having been received from Martin and
Gibril Massaquoi from Nigeria."
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:08:42
11:09:08
11:09:41
11:10:15
11:10:40
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30534
Nothing could be clearer, Mr Taylor.
A. Yes, that's true. Based on his explanation, he thought it
was clear. But there's nothing truthful about this. And I don't
need to repeat this. I think there's sufficient record before
this Court that Foday Sankoh spoke to Johnny Paul Koroma and
Johnny Paul Koroma recorded that message and played it on Sierra
Leonean radio and on the BBC. So this whole thing is nothing but
a fabrication on his part that there was supposed to be some
communication from Sankoh to me downloaded, in a call Bockarie
and Bockarie then told them - it's all nonsense and just a lie,
like a host of other lies that they have been telling.
Q. Mr Taylor, I want us to deal with this allegation very
briefly. This witness also suggests that Issa Sesay was sent to
you with diamonds in exchange for arms. What do you say,
quickly?
A. Never. Never. No. Never.
Q. Thank you. Let's move on to another topic. At page 4571,
testimony of this witness of 22 February 2008, the witness said
this, line 1:
"Q. Did you remain in Sierra Leone for all of 1999?
A. No. After the Lome Peace Accord was signed we were the
first batch that Mr Sankoh instructed to disarm in Port
Loko. I joined Superman and we disarmed over 2,000 troops
in Port Loko and I was asked by Mr Sankoh to move to
Freetown."
The question is repeated:
"Q. The question was in 1999 did you remain in Sierra Leone
the whole time?
A. No. After the disarmament in Port Loko I moved to
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:11:25
11:11:36
11:12:08
11:12:29
11:13:05
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30535
Mr Sankoh in Freetown and every document in respect of my
travelling was put in place and on 21 December I travelled
to see my family in Monrovia and I was in Monrovia from the
22nd" - that's 22 December 1999, Mr Taylor, yes?
A. Yes.
Q. "... up to April 2000." Okay?
A. Uh-huh.
Q. So this was a man with family links to Liberia and to
Sierra Leone, do you follow?
A. Yes, yes.
Q. "During my stay in Monrovia Mr Sankoh introduced me to
Benjamin Yeaten." Pause there. Tell me, in that period,
December 1999 to April 2000, was Mr Sankoh in Monrovia?
A. December 1999, yes. Mr Sankoh did go to Monrovia in
December of 1999. In fact, late in December there's a
discussion, remember, between he, Foday Sankoh, when he meets
Obasanjo and myself. So he is in Monrovia in December 1999.
Q. And just remind us. What was the purpose of that Sankoh
visit?
A. This was at the height of the conflict between he and Sam
Bockarie. He had come for what I would call a final discussion
on Sam Bockarie agreeing to two things: accept his orders and
commence the disarmament process in Sierra Leone. That's when I
invited Obasanjo to come for us to have this final decision on
moving Lome.
Q. I'm grateful. Moving on:
"During my stay in Monrovia Mr Sankoh introduced me to
Benjamin Yeaten in order to meet Mr Charles Ghankay Taylor and
explain to him the issues of misunderstanding that went on
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:13:36
11:14:01
11:14:29
11:14:50
11:15:12
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30536
between Sam Bockarie and Superman. But during my stay in
Monrovia I was not fortunate to speak with Mr Charles Ghankay
Taylor one to one. I frequently met with Benjamin Yeaten at his
residence and he made me to understand that there wasn't any need
of meeting with Mr Charles Ghankay Taylor and according to him
they had investigated and came to know the truth and that the
misleading informations that were given to them by Sam Bockarie
and based on that fact he was the one who received Sam Bockarie
from Lofa County. Sam Bockarie was under his control in Monrovia
and he was under serious monitoring and he was under perfect
security protection and in due course he was going to face the
consequences of what he did in Sierra Leone, but they needed
sufficient proof about the disorderly conduct in Sierra Leone."
Now, what's that about, Mr Taylor?
A. I really don't know. I really don't know what nonsense
this boy is talking about. I have no idea of what he is talking
about.
Q. Let's try and unpack it carefully, shall we? What's this
misleading information which was given by Sam Bockarie, please?
A. Nothing. I have no idea what it is. Nothing. In fact,
being there to - who is he that he - that Sankoh - he is there to
meet me one on one. I mean all this gibberish is just that.
Nothing of this sort that there's some misunderstanding. What
does this boy know? Nothing. I don't know what he is talking
about really. It doesn't amount to anything, what he's saying
here.
Q. And help me, please. "In due course he was going to face
the consequences of what he did in Sierra Leone." Was it your
intention to put Mr Bockarie on trial, Mr Taylor?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:15:42
11:16:04
11:16:21
11:16:50
11:17:05
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30537
A. No, never.
Q. So what are these consequences that the witness speaking
of, please?
A. This boy does not know, counsel, what is he talking about.
Nothing. Sam Bockarie is in Liberia as a free man moving around.
There was no intention on the part of the Government of Liberia
to investigate, arrest or anything with Sam Bockarie or any of
his people. This boy is talking pure nonsense.
Q. Well, let's go over the page to page 4572 and see if we can
some clarification on this because if we look at commencing line
24 we see this:
"What I'm trying to say is that there was a
misunderstanding or misinformation that Sam Bockarie used to pass
on to Benjamin Yeaten and that Superman and the entire Liberian
troops that were under his command were breakaway factions and
that they a different intention, different from the RUF agenda."
Over the page, line 6:
"The information was given to Benjamin Yeaten by Sam
Bockarie. He explained a lot to me" - that's Benjamin Yeaten -
"regarding what was going on. Especially the thing in respect of
the infighting that took place in Makeni and Koinadugu and even
the time of our stay at Lunsar."
Line 15:
"Benjamin Yeaten said that even if Mr Charles Taylor were
to send for Superman or any commander in Liberia were to send for
Superman, Superman will never be brave enough to go to Monrovia
because he knew what he had done and he knew the plans that he
was carrying on with presently with the SLA and he knew the rules
and regulations of the RUF code of conduct."
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:17:52
11:18:15
11:18:36
11:18:58
11:19:23
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30538
Now, you see the implication of that, don't you, Mr Taylor?
That such was your control over the RUF that, in effect, you
would be dishing out discipline where they broke the rules and
regulations of the RUF code of conduct. You do follow, don't
you?
A. Yes, I do. I see what he is trying to say here.
Q. Well, is that the case?
A. That's not the case. I mean, this is so far off of what is
associated with my knowledge or understanding of what is going on
during this period that I don't even - I can't - I can't lay any
hands on what this young man is trying to say. I mean really
because when you look at it, we have evidence that Superman comes
to Monrovia. Superman comes to Monrovia, he travels back to
Sierra Leone. There is no intention on the part of my government
to embarrass or arrest or harm anybody, Sierra Leoneans come in
and go. So I cannot associate what is he talking about. He is
just for me way out in left field talking nonsense about Superman
would not do this and all of --
Q. But, Mr Taylor, it's my fault entirely. Can I just draw
your attention back to page 4571, because I omitted to deal with
one aspect of the testimony which I would like you to have an
opportunity to comment on. Going back to that page, 4571, you'll
recall the witness saying at line 13:
"During my stay in Monrovia Mr Sankoh introduced me to
Benjamin Yeaten in order to meet Mr Charles Ghankay Taylor and
explain to him the issues of misunderstanding."
So he was, on my understanding, due to speak to you on
behalf of Mr Sankoh. Now he goes on to say, "I frequently met
with Benjamin Yeaten," and he has this discussion with Benjamin
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:20:06
11:20:21
11:20:39
11:20:54
11:21:16
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30539
Yeaten, lines 18 to 28.
And then he goes on, line 29:
"So as a matter of fact there was no reason for me to meet
Mr Charles Ghankay Taylor as I was instructed by Mr Foday Sankoh
in Monrovia."
Now help me. Mr Sankoh was in Monrovia in the December,
wasn't he?
A. Yes, he was.
Q. And did you prevent him from speaking his mind to you on
any issue, Mr Taylor?
A. No, Foday Sankoh met with me during that stay several times
and if there was anything that he wanted to discuss with me he
would have discussed it with me because remember now Foday Sankoh
is in a heated something with his under man Sam Bockarie, we're
trying to settle it, another colleague of mine come in. So
there's nothing that Foday Sankoh wanted to say to me that he
could not have said, that he would have had to wait for him to
explain it to me.
Q. Because the witness is saying that Sankoh introduces him to
Yeaten in order for the witness to be able to explain to you what
Mr Sankoh wanted to tell you, so help me.
A. It doesn't make sense. I mean wasn't it easier - isn't it
logical for Sankoh to bring him to me in a meeting to say, "Well,
look, here is a young man that was on the ground." Why does
Sankoh have to take this man, introduce him to Benjamin Yeaten
who is supposed to explain something to me when all Sankoh has to
do is to bring the man along with him. That's how these people -
that's how they make up things, okay. What is it so much that is
going on that Sankoh cannot either explain to me himself or bring
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:21:58
11:22:30
11:22:55
11:23:20
11:23:42
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30540
this Nya Korto man.
The only suggestion I can make here is this, it's good for
the Court to - Nya Korto is a Mano man from Nimba County.
Benjamin Yeaten is a Gio man from Nimba County. The Gios and the
Manos are like brothers. You speak Gio, you understand Mano.
You speak Mano, you understand Gio. All I can suggest here, and
it's a mere suggestion, is that this Nya Korto, because as far as
the work that I have done that Lansana was a fake name that he
put up in Sierra Leone. He is Korto. He is a Mano boy from
Nimba County. He returns to Liberia and probably meets a brother
like Benjamin Yeaten and wants help and that's why he is visiting
Benjamin all the time.
Because, let's face it, here is a radio operator that once
served as radio operator for Foday Sankoh, as he alleges. And
here is someone that is not featured - because Foday Sankoh comes
to Monrovia in 1999 and Nya Korto is not featured anywhere in the
staff that Foday Sankoh leaves in Monrovia. He is not a radio
operator. He is nothing in Monrovia. He doesn't feature. So
what my head is telling me here is that Nya Korto probably leaves
and is returns to Liberia and is trying to seek assistance from
Benjamin. Because one would say at this particular guesthouse in
Monrovia there are people and, for a senior person like him, one
would want to believe that he could be utilised in Monrovia even
between '99 up to the 2000 that he suggests that he is in
Liberia. But there's something funny about his presence in
Liberia where he does not participate in any RUF activities
besides staying there waiting to explain the unexplainable what
he is trying to allege here.
So I think there is something suspect here about his
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:24:19
11:24:39
11:24:58
11:25:21
11:25:44
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30541
presence in Liberia and I think he went to Liberia on his own and
maybe trying to seek assistance from a brother from Nimba County
because the Manos and the Gios are very close.
Q. A couple of other matters I want to deal with in relation
to this witness, Mr Taylor. Let us go back to page 4573, please.
Line 21:
"Q. So what was Benjamin Yeaten's assessment, if you know,
of the situation?
A. He came to know the truth during the time that Sam
Bockarie challenged the leadership of Foday Sankoh, saying
that he was no longer going to take any mess from
Foday Sankoh and that he was prepared to declare himself as
another leader and that report was sent to Mr Charles
Ghankay Taylor. And Mr Foday Sankoh made his report
categorically clear that this had been the honest
misunderstanding and that Sam Bockarie was now defying his
authority. So he said, 'Big brother, I am kindly asking
you to intervene and see how best you can calm down Sam
Bockarie in respect of his new decision' and, under the
command of Mr Charles Taylor, Sam Bockarie was ordered to
pack up and leave Sierra Leone to Liberia."
True, Mr Taylor?
A. No. Not under my command. Sam Bockarie was brought to
Liberia under the auspices of ECOWAS and the United Nations and I
say that because the United Nations - the special representative
of the Secretary-General --
Q. I think we can deal with this fairly briefly, Mr Taylor,
because we've got five minutes and I would like to --
A. Okay. ECOWAS was present, so his explanation of under my
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:26:13
11:26:52
11:27:08
11:27:21
11:27:43
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30542
order is just total nonsense.
Q. What about this report allegedly sent to you by
Foday Sankoh, where is it?
A. There was no report sent by Foday Sankoh.
Q. Just a couple of other matters for completeness. Can we go
to page 4583, please. There the witness told us this during the
course of his cross-examination:
"Q. You told us you went by a nickname of CO Nya?
A. Yes.
Q. Now Foday Lansana is not the name you answered when you
were growing up in Liberia, is it?
A. Yes.
Q. Your father's name or your family name is Nessian, is
it not?
A. Yes.
Q. In fact your full name given to you by your father is
Nyahn Korto Nessian?
A. Yes.
Q. You were born in Nimba County, correct?
A. Yes.
Q. And you're a Mano man, that's your tribe, is it not?
A. Yes."
And then finally when we go to page 4574 of the transcript
we learn that this witness was arrested on 7 May by the Sierra
Leonean authorities. He was accused of being a Liberian
mercenary working as a mediator between Foday Sankoh and Charles
Ghankay Taylor, page 4575, lines 20 and 21. He says he was
seriously tortured and taken to Pademba prison. He was
thereafter put on trial for shooting with intent to murder and
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
11:28:28
11:28:48
11:29:03
12:03:02
12:03:24
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30543
conspiracy to murder arising out of the 15 May incident outside
Mr Sankoh's residence at Spur Road in Freetown and he was
sentenced to 150 years' imprisonment.
Now, Mr Taylor, given that this man was born in Liberia
what did you do about this punishment imposed on a Liberian
citizen?
A. Nothing. This is just a traumatised man that they managed
to seduce to come here and lie unfortunately. He is just a
traumatised individual. He was tortured, given 150 years. I
would lie myself I guess.
MR GRIFFITHS: Would that be a convenient point
Mr President? That's all I ask about witness.
PRESIDING JUDGE: Yes, we're almost out of tape anyway,
Mr Griffiths, so we'll take the morning break and resume at 12
o'clock.
[Break taken at 11.29 a.m.]
[Upon resuming at 12.00 p.m.]
PRESIDING JUDGE: Ms Hollis, yes.
MS HOLLIS: Thank you, Mr President, before we move on to
the next witness, prosecution would like to place on the record
its objection that Defence counsel has misstated and
mischaracterised portions of the testimony of this witness Foday
Lansana, and we will deal with that in cross-examination.
Mr President, while I'm on my feet, we would also note that
we have not received the two-week notice regarding witnesses and
exhibits for next week. Now, we know the Defence had estimated
that this accused would continue to be on direct examination for
next week. We have received no written notice of that, nor have
we received anything in writing relating to exhibits for next
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:03:58
12:04:18
12:04:35
12:04:56
12:05:14
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30544
week, and we would ask that we be provided this information
today. Thank you.
PRESIDING JUDGE: Thank you, Ms Hollis. Well firstly, the
Prosecution objection to the first point raised, is now a matter
of record.
And the other matter raised regarding the notice,
Mr Griffiths, do you have anything to say about that?
MR GRIFFITHS: Save that all exhibits to be relied upon
have long been served upon the Prosecution.
PRESIDING JUDGE: So there is nothing more to expect?
MR GRIFFITHS: Nothing more to expect.
PRESIDING JUDGE: Does that satisfy your query, Ms Hollis?
MS HOLLIS: As to the exhibits, yes. And could we get
verification about the witness for next week, if direct will
continue in or through next week?
PRESIDING JUDGE: Yes, I note you did anticipate two weeks.
MR GRIFFITHS: [Microphone not activated].
PRESIDING JUDGE: So in other words, going along with that
estimation, the witness for next week will be Mr Taylor only?
MR GRIFFITHS: I anticipate that. And thereafter I
anticipate some cross-examination by the Prosecution, which I
presume might last a little while. So from our point of view
there are no surprises in terms of witnesses to come.
PRESIDING JUDGE: Thank you, Mr Griffiths.
Well, there you have it, Ms Hollis.
Yes, please go ahead.
MR GRIFFITHS:
Q. Mr Taylor, we are going to move on to deal with another
witness. This witness is witness TF1-571, Karmoh Kanneh, who
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:06:00
12:06:30
12:06:50
12:07:10
12:07:31
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30545
gave evidence in open session in May of last year. Now, the
first point I want to deal with in relation to this witness,
Mr Taylor, is the circumstances in which he came to join, as he
explained, the RUF, and there are particular questions that I
want to ask you about that. Now, the witness told us this on 8
May 2008 at page 9315, line 1:
"Well, when they came and attacked the town, they started
shooting all around. Most of our colleagues escaped but
some of us who were unable to escape, they captured us.
Q. When you say 'us', how many of you were captured?
A. In all, myself plus 16 others. All of us who were
captured were men.
Q. What ages were you?
A. Well, there were two people amongst us who had about 10
years of age and then the other - the remaining others were
above 23 years of age.
Q. What do you mean by 'captured'?
A. Well, then we they captured the town those of us they
met around they assembled all of us and we were the men
amongst the women who were captured, so they assembled all
of us it together and then they warned us asking that we
join them and they said we should not attempt to escape at
all. They said if anybody attempted to escape, if that
person was caught he or she would be killed."
Now, bear in mind, Mr Taylor, this is said to be occurring
in 1991. And when we go to page 9316, quickly, he goes on to
mention at line 14 that - well, perhaps for completeness sake I
ought to go back to 9315 and pick up.
"Q. When you say 'they', do you know the person who was
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:08:23
12:08:39
12:08:52
12:09:07
12:09:37
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30546
saying this to you? Did that person have a name?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What was the person's name?
A. One Man One.
Q. And what was that person's position, if you know?
A. Well, he was in control of all the rebels who entered
on the Pujehun front. He was the leader amongst them
there.
Q. How did you know that he was the leader?
A. Well, he was later introduced to us as the leader.
Q. Where was he from?
A. Liberia.
Q. With what happened to you after you were captured?
A. After some days, they told us they were going to take
us to the base.
Q. How do you know that the person One Man One was a
Liberian?
A. Well, he was speaking in Liberian tongue and at the
same time later after I had joined them I came to know."
And he goes on to mention that he was familiar with
Liberian English and then says at line 22, "After some days they
told us they were going to take us to a base."
At page 9317, that base was at Gisiwolo, a training base.
Line 11, that is: "Those who entered through Pujehun, that was
where they had their training base."
Line 19:
"Q. What did you do when you were at Gisiwolo?
A. Well, they started training us. They started training
us."
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:10:01
12:10:30
12:10:55
12:11:12
12:11:52
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30547
Now, I've read all of that, Mr Taylor, to ask this. First
of all, One Man One, is that name familiar to you?"
A. Well, yes, I have heard it here, but I don't know --
Q. Pardon?
A. I have heard it in this courtroom, and I will explain my
knowledge of that expression as I have known it. That was not an
individual's name that was - it was used, was a description like
an aka of a particular weapon.
Q. An alias?
A. An alias, yes.
Q. Very well. But outside of this courtroom, does that name -
that alias, One Man One, mean anything to you?
A. Yes. It means - for me, that's what I am saying, when I
hear "One Man One" it refers - it's a description of a weapon. I
have never heard it as associated with a name of someone.
Q. Oh, I see.
A. So I have heard the name, yes.
Q. Very well. But in any event, Mr Taylor, the reason why I
have begun with this passage is straightforward. You appreciate
that the allegation here is people speaking Liberian English were
forcefully conscripting individuals into the RUF. Do you follow?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. By extension, one possible interpretation is that your NPFL
forces in Pujehun were forcefully conscripting Sierra Leonean
citizens into the RUF. Do you follow?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, the first question I want to ask you is this: Was
such forceful conscription a policy adopted in Liberia by the
NPFL?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:12:29
12:12:58
12:13:24
12:13:47
12:14:12
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30548
A. No, it was not.
Q. Had the NPFL at any stage during the Liberian conflict
employed such strategies?
A. No.
Q. Had you instructed NPFL soldiers to adopt such strategies
in Sierra Leone?
A. No. I was not involved in this 1991 operation in Sierra
Leone, so I could not have instructed any NPFL soldier. As far
as I am concerned, there were not NPFL soldiers involved in
Sierra Leone and if they were, they were on their own. So there
were no instructions given to anyone in Sierra Leone.
Q. During that period when you accept that you cooperated with
Foday Sankoh in Sierra Leone, did you instruct, condone,
acquiesce in the forceful conscription of Sierra Leonean citizens
into the RUF?
A. No, but let me clarify that "no". The operations that were
conducted in Sierra Leone between '91 and '92 had nothing to do
with training of Sierra Leoneans. I sent a security force to the
border that operated against ULIMO. The force that went into
Sierra Leone was not a force of cooperation that dealt with
training for the advancement of a war in Sierra Leone. I sent
men that were involved in combat against ULIMO in Sierra Leone
and I withdrew those men. So I want to draw a distinction. So I
did not send a unit for any - to help the RUF in their training
in tactics and weapons to fight their war, no. My involvement in
Sierra Leone was purely security for Liberia.
Q. Now, that may well be your position, Mr Taylor, but I need
to ask you nonetheless: Were you aware of any NPFL forces that
you sent to Sierra Leone behaving in the manner I have suggested,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:15:12
12:15:46
12:16:06
12:16:33
12:16:49
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30549
that is, forcefully recruiting Sierra Leonean citizens into
combat?
A. No. Absolutely no.
Q. Were you aware of the presence of a training base at a
place called Gisiwolo in Sierra Leone?
A. No, I was not aware.
Q. Now, Mr Taylor, do you recall when we were dealing with the
testimony of Foday Lansana this morning I took a little time to
outline in order to place in context Sankoh allegedly returning
to Liberia after Top Final, after the RUF's penetration into
Pujehun had been repelled? Do you remember me asking you about
that?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. Well, this witness also deals with that episode. So let us
look at his account. Page 9332, the witness says this at line
10:
"Finally we were pushed and we were attacked from all
fronts. They attacked us and they even captured Bo
Waterside and all of us ran away into Liberia.
Q. Whereabouts in Liberia did you run to?
A. The first place we went to was Tiene."
Now you remember us mentioning Tiene before, Mr Taylor?
A. Yes.
Q. And Tiene is in which country?
A. Tiene is in Liberia.
Q. "Q. Did you stay in Tiene?
A. No.
Q. Where did you go from Tiene?
A. Well, we went to Bomi Hills.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:17:23
12:17:44
12:18:08
12:18:26
12:18:46
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30550
Q. Did you remain for any time in Bomi Hills?
A. Well, we were there for just a few days."
Now pause there. Help us. Mr Taylor, were you aware of a
force of RUF combatants retreating in the face of an onslaught
from Sierra Leonean government forces into Bomi Hills in Liberia?
Were you aware of that, such a movement of people?
A. No, I was not aware. But let's be very clear about this
now, counsel. The period this witness I think is referring to is
1991, am I correct about that?
Q. Based on my reading of his evidence, yes.
A. Okay. So if he is talking about 1991, then this is
unrelated to the Top Final thing that this other man is talking
about. This now he is talking about - early in that conflict I
am not aware that there is this movement into Liberia from across
the border. This is around March/April 1991. No, I am not aware
of that.
Q. And he continues, line 22:
"Q. What happened whilst you were there" - that's in Bomi
Hills?
"A. Well, that same commander, the battle group commander,
One Man One, we met all of them there, because that was
where all the senior commanders stopped, so we all went and
stopped there.
Q. You said you were there for just a few days. What
happened during those few days that you were there?
A. Well, we were there when we saw Foday Sankoh and at the
same time we saw Mr Taylor. All of them came.
Q. How did Mr Taylor come? Do you know how he came
there, what method he came there?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:19:26
12:19:48
12:20:13
12:20:31
12:20:57
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30551
A. Well, we just saw him. He was in the vehicle. They
came on board a vehicle. And where we were based they all
came there, he and Foday Sankoh.
Q. Did he and Foday Sankoh come together?
A. No, Foday Sankoh came first - first came.
Q. When you say Mr Taylor, who are you talking about?
What's the full name of that person, if you know?
A. Well, that name, Charles Ghankay Taylor, that is what
we normally called him by.
Q. Had you ever seen him before that time?
A. No, that was my first day - first day to see him.
Q. What did Charles Taylor do?
A. Well, they called us to a formation and then all of us
were briefed. They gave us courageous words. They said we
shouldn't fear. We will have to return. They said we
shouldn't fear.
Q. When say they gave you courageous words, who was
speaking?
A. Well, he himself. Charles Taylor, was the first person
who spoke and then later he buttressed by Foday Sankoh.
Q. What did Charles Taylor say exactly at that formation?
A. Well, he said he had come with armament, materials and
all other things and he said we were going to get ready and
back to Sierra Leone.
Q. Did he say anything else?
A. Yes.
Q. What did he say?
A. He said he was going to divide the group into two."
Over the page, page 9334, picking it up at line 23:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:21:37
12:21:53
12:22:11
12:22:24
12:22:34
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30552
"It was Mr Ghankay first who spoke and Foday Sankoh spoke
later. It was Foday Sankoh.
Line 28:
"Q. You also said previously that Charles Taylor said he
was going to divide the group into two. He told us that.
Did he divide the group into two?
A. Yes.
Q. How many were in the one group before it was divided?
A. Well, we were many, but our group that we went with,
that is the one I will be able to give an account about.
Q. How many were placed into the group that you were
placed into?
A. Well, in our group that we moved with initially when we
moved to Bomi Hills, although some later added, but we were
initially 500.
Q. How many were there in the group that you were placed
into?
A. Where we went, Mano River, the group that we moved
with.
Q. The big group was divided into two, is that so?
A. Yes, yes.
Q. You were put into one of those new groups, is that
right?
A. Yes.
Q. How many in the group that you were put into?
A. 250.
Q. Did the group that you were placed into have a name?
A. Yes.
Q. Who gave the group the name, if you know?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:22:59
12:23:11
12:23:31
12:23:57
12:24:28
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30553
A. It was Mr Taylor.
Q. And what was the name of the group?
A. It was called Black Kadaffa."
Over the page:
"Q. When you were placed into that group, was there
someone who was in charge of the group?
A. Yes.
Q. Who was that?
A. General Pepe.
Q. Where was General Pepe from?
A. He was an NPFL general.
Q. Was there a person who was his - was reporting to him
in the group? Who was that?
A. General Devon."
Pause there. Now, Mr Taylor, there is a lot there for us
to digest. Firstly, this witness attaches you with presence in
Bomi Hills in company with Foday Sankoh following this retreat
from Pujehun in Sierra Leone, do you see?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. And you addressed that group, put simply, geeing them up
for further combat and providing them with war materials, yes?
A. Yes.
Q. And you note, of course, how this testimony synchronises
with what we looked at this morning with Foday Lansana. Sankoh
returning to Liberia at some stage following the expulsion of the
RUF from Pujehun and returning later with radio operators who had
been part of that group expelled, including Albert Brown and
others, do you see? What do you say about that, Mr Taylor?
A. Well, in the first place, this is not true. But, again, I
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:25:15
12:25:38
12:25:51
12:26:20
12:26:45
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30554
may be missing you. I may be missing out on what you are
referring to again, because again I think we may be talking about
two different times here. But he also associates me with Black
Kadaffa.
Q. Yes, you gave the name to the group, Mr Taylor?
A. And this is the same group that is planning to destroy me
and the whole NPFL and Degbon and the rest. Well, Degbon doesn't
have - there is no one - Degbon is a Special Force and a very
senior and a very educated man. And there is no way that there
is a General Pepe that he talks about here.
Q. Can I interrupt briefly just to seek some clarification on
something?
A. Yes.
Q. And please hold the answer - continue with your answer in
due course. General Pepe, known to you?
A. No, that's what I am saying. I don't know a General Pepe,
okay. The only - if we want to help the Court, I know a General
Dry Pepper, which is Anthony Mekunagbe. So I am not sure now if
this is - but Degbon would not work under Mekunagbe because
Degbon would be senior to Anthony Mekunagbe. I have mentioned to
this Court General Degbon was amongst the top in the NPFL, very
educated. He had a master's degree from a major European
university in geology and was educated. Anthony Mekunagbe was a
little - he had been just an under high school graduate and a
police officer before. Degbon was most senior to Mekunagbe, so
he cannot be referring here to - I can't see him mixing Dry
Pepper with Pepe. So I am just suggesting - I don't know what he
is talking about here. But, in any case, Black Kadaffa is not a
group associated with me. It's an anti-NPFL group. We've talked
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:27:24
12:28:07
12:28:32
12:28:53
12:29:29
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30555
about it. That's how Degbon and they rest of them get arrested,
charged, tried and all of that.
So this account that he is giving referring to - and I am
not sure, counsel, maybe I am missing something. I cannot still
associate this with this return in 1992. But, anyway, we will go
on with this. But I think this retreat he is talking about could
be a different line and I am sure of what I am saying, but there
is no association with me being in Bomi in direct answer, one,
with Foday Sankoh. There is no association of me being a part of
or naming the Black Kadaffa. I went after Black Kadaffa. Black
Kadaffa and the leadership were arrested and tried for the
anti-revolutionary activities. And so for anyone to suggest
this, it shows that he is up to something that is not true
because I went after Black Kadaffa and following the arrest of
Degbon, Oliver Varney, Anthony Mekunagbe and the rest of them
that were charged, prosecuted and executed for wanting to kill me
and the rest of the NPFL and what they were doing, Black Kadaffa
failed to exist. So for somebody to come here and say I stood
before Black Kadaffa and named them and all that type of
nonsense, that's totally untrue.
Q. We may get a hint, bearing in mind what you said about Pepe
or Dry Pepper, because on that same page, the testimony of the
witness continued in this way. Mr Munyard intervened at line 25
and said: "Not in the document that I have got from the
Prosecution that gives these very names double P in the middle."
And then the witness is asked: "Do you know how Dry Pepper
spelt the name Pepe?"
Do you see that?
A. Yes, I do.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:30:04
12:30:24
12:30:44
12:31:02
12:31:29
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30556
Q. And the Dry Pepper you were talking about is who?
A. Anthony Mekunagbe.
Q. And you have already mentioned to us how you say Anthony
Mekunagbe was implicated in the Black Kadaffa plot?
A. Definitely.
Q. Along with General Degbon?
A. Degbon, Oliver Varney and the rest of them, yes.
JUDGE SEBUTINDE: If I may seek clarification. How did the
name Black Kadaffa come about?
THE WITNESS: I really don't know, your Honour, how they
came up with that name to call it Black Kadaffa. I really don't
know how they came up with that name. It could have been one of
Degbon and their own construction because of what they were
trying to do, they just called it Black Kadaffa. I have no
attachment to my understanding of why or how they came up with
that.
JUDGE SEBUTINDE: So it was not a group that existed
officially in the NPFL and later became renegade?
THE WITNESS: No, no it was not - it was a group that they
just came up and put together that operation that was stopped
when we arrested them. I understand your question. Was it a
group that became a renegade? No. It was a non-existing
official NPFL group. It was an entire group that they just came
up with in their diabolical work.
MR GRIFFITHS:
Q. Now I am moving on, Mr Taylor. Because at page 9354, the
witness moves ahead and speaks of attending a meeting with Foday
Sankoh, line 7, and he says this:
"Well, Foday Sankoh went to Abidjan to sign the peace
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:32:12
12:32:30
12:32:51
12:33:09
12:33:27
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30557
accord on our behalf. On his return, that was the time
that I met with him.
Q. Were you the only person who met with him, or were
there others who met with him at that time?
A. There were other people there. But when he came, at
first he called for a formation. The soldiers with whom we
were, officers and soldiers, we all assembled at the
grounds for the formation. Well, he addressed, told us
about the peace that he had signed and he said he had done
it in the interests of the movement, for all of us. That
was what he told us at the formation. He said he had
signed the peace on our behalf, but that does not mean the
war has ended. He said during times of peace, those are
times that we should prepare for war. He said we should
not forget. Yes, because by then the Kamajors were behind
us and they had dislodged us from some of our areas -
Zogoda and some other areas - and so I believe that that
was the reason why he said that."
Line 17:
"Q. What happened after the formation?
A. Well, he informed the senior officers that they should
tell all of us, the officers who were present, for us to
assemble at his place where he was staying so that we would
have an officers' meeting.
Q. Who was it that informed you to assemble at his place?
A. It was General Issa Sesay. All of us met there."
And then he continues:
"Where he was staying, the EMG ground", Executive Mansion
Ground, no doubt, "where he always stays - where he always stays,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:34:17
12:34:42
12:34:59
12:35:18
12:35:40
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30558
that was where we met."
He goes on to mention that Foday Sankoh was present and
then he names others present: Bockarie - Colonel Bockarie,
Mosquito, Issa was there, Jungle was there, AB was there, FOC was
there, Jackson Swarray was there, and he goes on to name others.
Abubakar, so on and so forth. And then we come to this at page
9358:
"Q. Now, at the time meeting who spoke?
A. Well, Foday Sankoh spoke.
Q. What did he say?
A. Well, in the first place we saw him hand over his
satellite phone to Mr Bockarie, Sam Bockarie.
Q. When you say 'satellite', what is satellite?
A. Satellite. Satellite phone.
Q. Did he say anything when he handed the phone - the
satellite phone to Sam Bockarie?
A. Well, in the first place he told us that we should take
all orders from Sam Bockarie and at the same time he was
going on a political tour. He said he was going to Libya
and other areas. He said we should all take instructions
from Bockarie while Bockarie should be taking instructions
from Mr Ghankay. That was why he gave him that satellite
so that we would be having links."
Line 18:
"Q. Who is Mr Ghankay?
A. That is the NPFL leader, Charles Ghankay Taylor.
Q. Did he say anything else when he was at the meeting?
A. Yes.
Q. What did he say?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:36:08
12:36:29
12:36:58
12:37:09
12:37:27
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30559
A. Well, he introduced Jungle to us as Mr Taylor's
representative for us there."
Note "introduced".
"Q. Did he refer to Jungle in any particular way?
A. Well, he said he was the Pa's representative. They had
been discussing that and so he was trying to introduce him
to us. He said he was Charles Ghankay Taylor's
representative, Jungle.
Q. Did Jungle say anything at the meeting?"
Let's pause there, Mr Taylor. Now, just to put this in
context, you recall after the signing of the Abidjan Peace
Accord, Sankoh did indeed return to RUF-controlled areas in
Sierra Leone to, in effect, quote unquote, sell the idea of the
peace agreement so his soldiers on the ground. Do you remember
that?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. We have been told that by more than one witness how he
arrived by helicopter. Do you recall that?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. And had made various lightening visits. Now first of all,
were you aware - no, let me start before that. Up to that time -
and remember we are talking about - November 1996 is the signing
of the Abidjan peace accord.
A. Yes.
Q. Were you were you in contact with Foday Sankoh by satellite
phone?
A. Not at all, no.
Q. I ask for this reason: Were you aware that he had given
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:37:55
12:38:22
12:38:46
12:39:14
12:39:33
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30560
his satellite phone to Sam Bockarie?
A. No, I was not aware.
Q. And I ask that in turn for this reason. At line 12:
"He said he was going to Libya and other areas. He said we
should all take instructions from Bockarie, while Bockarie should
be taking instructions from Mr Ghankay. That was why he gave him
that satellite so that we would be having links."
So he is giving Bockarie this satellite phone so that
Bockarie can receive orders from you. The unspoken conclusion is
you had already been in communication with him via this phone and
so it was a normal, agreed line of communication. Do you follow?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. Now, what do you say about that, Mr Taylor?
A. I say this is awful. This is awful. What is going on?
This is totally awful. It's a lie and it's awful. Foday Sankoh
goes to Abidjan, and from testimony here he is given two
telephones and a fax machine. And Foday Sankoh goes back to -
based on testimony I have heard here - goes back to the region
for two reasons that have been told to this Court. The first
reason is to sell the peace agreement, but there is a second
reason. The second reason is to tell his people to get involved
in mining that they can raise material. That's the evidence
before this Court.
Q. You are talking about the Mohamed Talibi letters?
A. Exactly. So it's so awful that - it's so - it's horrific
that these people can put together these kind of lie. I don't
know how they do it. Foday Sankoh and I have no contact. Those
telephones are given him, and in fact I listened to testimony in
this Court that one of those telephones, if I am not mistaken,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:40:14
12:40:39
12:41:02
12:41:30
12:42:01
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30561
was given to him by someone from International Alert, Dr Seboe.
I stand corrected on that. So here I am now, boom, Charles
Taylor back in the centre. How do I get a telephone to Foday
Sankoh when I am not involved in the entire process? I am a
member of the council of state in 1996 in Liberia. I am not
President of Liberia in 1996. I have nothing do with that peace
accord going on in that place. No contact. Foday Sankoh is down
there. We've introduced letters here exchanged between he and
Mohamed Talibi and monies that he has received and wanting more.
My God, what do I have to do with it that somebody now comes with
this blatant lie before this Court and say, Charles Taylor
gave - he gave Sam Bockarie a telephone that he would be in touch
with Ghankay. Total nonsense. It's not true, and it's awful
that these lies are just as diabolical as they are.
Q. Now, at this time, Mr Taylor, late 1996, were you aware of
a trip that Sankoh was proposing to make to Libya?
A. I had no contact with Sankoh. I had no knowledge of it.
None whatsoever. Absolutely none.
Q. Now, Mr Taylor, I want you to bear very much at the
forefront of your mind what we've heard about the origins of this
man Jungle. Now, bearing that in mind, we were being told by
this witness that in late 1996 Jungle was being introduced as
your representative. What do you say about that?
A. That is false. But we have already been told when Jungle
got cut off behind the line, we go all the way back to '92. So
Jungle now is invisible in that particular area all the while,
and mind you a principal - and I want to believe a principal
witness brought by this Prosecution - and I think one of the
witnesses that I am sure we will deal with - sat here - and I
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:42:44
12:43:13
12:43:33
12:43:55
12:44:06
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30562
can't mention the name because he is a protected witness - I can
just say he came very close to the end of the Prosecution's case,
said how Jungle got over there, and the introduction of Jungle by
Sam Bockarie to Foday Sankoh. Now, here is Foday Sankoh
introducing him to them, 1996, okay, after he had been with them
some four years. That figures.
Q. Now, Tongo Fields, Mr Taylor; what do you know about that
location in Sierra Leone?
A. Nothing whatsoever.
Q. You have heard testimony in this Court and evidence
generally that it's a major diamond mining area in Sierra Leone,
haven't you?
A. Yes, I have.
Q. Well, help me. This witness says, page 9369, that he was
involved in an operation to capture Tongo Fields and he was asked
this at line 11 on page 9369:
"Q. After you captured the place Tongo Field and you were
the commander of that mission, did you speak to anyone
about the fact that you had accomplished the mission?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Who did you speak to?
A. Mr Bockarie.
Q. And what was said?
A. When I spoke - well, all of us went on the mission. He
thanked us a lot.
Q. Were you thanked by anybody else apart from Sam
Bockarie?
A. Well, that was later. Later we received praises and
thanks. That was at the time that we were based there,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:44:41
12:45:10
12:45:34
12:45:54
12:46:12
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30563
when we told Mr Taylor that we have captured so and so.
Q. What do you mean by 'so and so'?
A. When we captured - after we had based we
informed - first we informed Johnny Paul and he thanked us
and later he informed Mr Taylor."
What do you say, Mr Taylor?
A. I never spoke to Johnny Paul Koroma throughout. The first
time I got in contact or spoke personally voice to Johnny Paul
Koroma was in August 1999, that I, Charles Ghankay Taylor, ever
spoke to Johnny Paul Koroma. First time. And that was in
relations to arrangements to have him taken from his
incarceration in Sierra Leone and brought to Liberia. Never
ever, ever spoke to Johnny Paul Koroma.
Q. Not according to this witness, Mr Taylor, because the
witness continues, line 28:
"Q. How do you know that later Johnny Paul Koroma informed
Mr Taylor? How do you know that?
A. No, it was not Johnny Paul who informed Mr Taylor. It
was Sam Bockarie, Sam Bockarie. The first information went
to Johnny Paul that we had accomplished the mission. It
was later that Sam Bockarie did this.
Q. How do you know that he did that?
A. Well, it was through a satellite phone for them to have
links. That was why Foday Sankoh had come with that
satellite phone.
Q. So when you say it was through a satellite phone, what
happened with the satellite phone in relation to the
accomplishment of the mission?
A. Well, they communicated. They communicated. Because a
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:46:43
12:46:52
12:47:06
12:47:17
12:47:32
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30564
satellite phone, they did not talk - he did not talk with
Johnny Paul through the satellite phone. The satellite
phone was just between himself and Mr Taylor.
Q. Who is the 'himself'?
A. Sam Bockarie.
Q. And did you hear Sam Bockarie talking on that satellite
phone to Mr Taylor?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What did Sam Bockarie say?
A. Well, he said we have captured the mining area, which
is Tongo Field. And so the Pa too - we were close to
him - he thanked him a lot.
Q. Who thanked him?
A. Pa Taylor.
Q. When you say 'we were close to him', what do you mean
by that?
A. We were in a room, that was Sam Bockarie's room, where
this communication was going on.
Q. And you said he was thanked. Could you hear the voice
on the other end of the phone?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How were you able to hear that voice?
A. Well, it was not the voice that mattered, because at
that time we were all doing things in common and so they
were not hiding most of the things from me. So they told
me - he told me that he was talking to Mr Taylor and Jungle
too was there.
Q. Who told you that he had been talking to Mr Taylor?
A. Sam Bockarie.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:48:05
12:48:21
12:48:48
12:49:11
12:49:29
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30565
Q. You said that Jungle too was there. What was Jungle
doing?
A. Well, always Jungle was by the commanders. As long
- because he was introduced to us as the Pa's
representative. He was always with the top commanders,
from one commander to another.
Q. Now you said that the civilians were doing the mining
and they were not doing it voluntarily. Did you ever see a
civilian who did not wish to do mining?
A. Yes, it used to happen."
Now, Mr Taylor, there are a couple issues of there I want
to tax you with. The first is this: Do you recall an occasion
when you spoke to Sam Bockarie on a satellite phone and
congratulated him on the capture of Tongo Fields?
A. No, never did. Never did.
Q. Secondly, by implication, the sting in the tail of this
account is this: The telephone conversation is associated with
knowledge of slave labour being used for the mining in Tongo
Fields. Do you get it?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. Were you aware that slave labour was being used by the RUF
to mine diamonds in Tongo Fields, or anywhere else in Sierra
Leone for that matter?
A. No, I was not aware.
Q. Did you order such a thing?
A. No, never did.
Q. Did you, with knowledge that such things were happening,
acquiesce or condone such behaviour?
A. No, no. But maybe to just maybe help for the context of
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:50:29
12:50:58
12:51:22
12:51:46
12:52:10
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30566
this, the reference here to a report being made to Johnny Paul
Koroma but Sam Bockarie conveying that to me, I'm not sure - it
does not reflect the time but in my head, and probably this could
help, what this witness is referring to now, it could be proper
to assume that we are talking about prior to February 1998. I am
saying this because February 1998 is the intervention, so the
control of Johnny Paul Koroma where somebody would report to him,
we know it ceases after the intervention. So I'm not sure - I
don't know when this so-called Tongo Field is supposed to be
captured. So that means it is captured in 1997 or up to February
of 1998.
Now, we would have to probably look at it because to unpack
these people's lies we have to look at it very seriously because
he is talking about Tongo Field and a report to Johnny Paul
Koroma, who Johnny Paul Koroma congratulates everybody and then
Sam Bockarie passes the message. And the intervention occurs in
February of 1998. So what he is talking about now must occur in
1997. I can't reflect off the top of my head now when this Tongo
operation occurs, whether it is post February 1998. It may help
us to unpack this lie. I know nothing about this, but just in
terms of how he has given this lie and my knowledge of the
testimony that has been given here in assigning dates, we may
unpack this by determining when this Tongo operation is supposed
to go on because that means that Johnny Paul Koroma must be in
control where he congratulates everybody and that's got to be
before February 1998.
But in the direct answer to your question, it is no to all
of them. I did not order. I did not condone. I knew nothing
about any Tongo operation. Neither did Sam Bockarie call me at
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:52:58
12:53:19
12:53:44
12:54:07
12:54:23
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30567
that time. I don't know if Sam Bockarie - he is alleging here
that Sam Bockarie had a telephone but let me just reflect on
another thing. Don't let's forget, this witness claims that
Foday Sankoh returns from - that's around November.
Q. Abidjan?
A. Yeah, from Abidjan of 1996 and asks everybody to pay
attention to Sam Bockarie as the commander. So that means Sam
Bockarie - and I know based on testimony given here, he does
leave a fax and a telephone with Sam Bockarie, definitely not
from me. But I am not aware of what is going on in Sierra Leone
at this particular time. No, I am not.
Q. Again, Mr Taylor, for completeness, we need to look at, and
I hope we can deal with this briefly, two specific allegations
made by this witness in relation to you and diamonds, okay? And
let's try and do it as quickly as possible because we have dealt
with this diamond issue ad nauseam. Page 9380, and he is dealing
with the mining in Tongo Fields. Line 8:
"The first diamond that we had, we took that diamond and
brought it to Mr Bockarie.
Q. What did Bockarie do with the diamond?
A. Well, he called me, Jungle, JR and Lion, we all
assembled at his place."
Line 25:
"Q. And what happened to the diamond?
A. Well, we showed the diamond to Sam Bockarie. All of us
were present and he thanked us a lot. That was the
diamond. We counted those diamonds, parceled them and the
diamonds were taken to Liberia."
Over the page, line 12:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:54:58
12:55:15
12:55:31
12:55:46
12:56:04
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30568
"I said we parceled them and we wrote the total on the
paper.
Q. What was the total?
A. The first one was 43" - specific number - "pieces of
diamond.
Q. What happened to the package?
A. Well, Mr Bockarie called Mr Taylor and informed him
about the work that we had done. He told him about the
total and he too told him that we should hand them over to
Jungle who would in turn travel with them.
Q. How did he talk to Mr Taylor?
A. Well, he sent a satellite. They spoke through a
satellite phone.
Q. Could you hear Mr Taylor's voice?
A. Yes, because a satellite phone is not like the other
communication. When people are conversing you will know.
And he told us that he had contacted him, so the two of
them were talking.
Q. Did you hear what Mr Taylor said?
A. Yes, he thanked him a lot and he told him to hand over
the diamond to Jungle who would be able to travel with it.
Q. Did he hand over the diamond to Jungle?
A. Yes, when we handed the diamond over to Jungle they
gave the - they handed over the mic to Jungle and Jungle
confirmed the total to him.
Q. To who?
A. To Mr Taylor."
Package, 43 diamonds, Mr Taylor; yes or no?
A. No. But, counsel, there is something interesting here. I
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:56:43
12:57:03
12:57:24
12:57:42
12:58:01
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30569
know we don't want to deal with it, but there is something - I
think we have to attach some time. We are talking about Tongo
and he has just said previously that Johnny Paul had
congratulated them, but the congratulatory message was passed to
me by Sam Bockarie. So this demonstrates some control on the
part of Johnny Paul Koroma. He is in authority somewhere. So I
think - because, you know, it's a matter of credibility how they
put together these lies.
Let me inform this Court, any human being on this planet
who from these Sierra Leonean people come here saying that he
explained earlier that Sam Bockarie is in his room and making a
satellite phone call is on something. I don't know what he is
smoking, because nobody on these satellite phones can make a
satellite phone call from in your bedroom. It's a lie. That's
the first lie.
The second lie - now, what would be Johnny Paul's role in
this thing? So Sam Bockarie now just takes the diamonds and he
sends it away. Who is in authority over there? So you can see
how the lie unravels, okay. They are supposed to be with these
diamonds. Does Johnny Paul Koroma know anything about these
diamonds? So Sam Bockarie takes the diamonds and he sends it off
by a Jungle to me. I mean, who is in control at this time?
Because if we are saying that - because we know from this Court
that Johnny Paul is humiliated, okay, shortly after he arrives.
The humiliation occurs when Johnny Paul Koroma is arrested, strip
searched and the diamonds taken away from him and he is put into
incarceration.
So my head logically will be telling me that if Johnny Paul
is playing any substantive role in what this witness is talking
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
12:58:42
12:59:06
12:59:20
12:59:34
13:00:00
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30570
about it has got to be before he is humiliated. It's got to be
before February of 1998. So if he is in control, that means that
Sam Bockarie is acting ultra vires to what is expected in this
organisation. So this lie cannot stand. It's a lie, okay, that
Sam Bockarie would send me diamonds. There is really no such
thing going on. And based on his own analysis, his statements of
what's going on, it has to be a fabrication. That's all it is.
Q. And we can get some further assistance as to timing,
Mr Taylor, because the witness talks on the same page about the
means by which Jungle, the messenger, carried these diamonds.
Line 12:
"Q. What did he do after he confirmed the total" - that
being Jungle?
"A. Well, he told him that he should move with it.
Q. Move where?
A. Liberia, because Foya was always the station.
Q. The station for what?
A. That was where the helicopter would pick him up to
Monrovia.
Q. Do you know whether Jungle left Tongo Fields?
A. Yes, Jungle left with an escort. Mr Bockarie gave
somebody, that is CO Lion, who escorted him up to Foya.
Q. Do you know where he went after Foya?
A. Well, Lion stopped there. I was there when a
helicopter picked him up and Lion returned and met us in
Tongo.
Q. So you also went to Foya?
A. At that time, no, I was in Tongo?"
So that's occasion number one. So Tongo Fields, Bockarie
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:00:46
13:01:21
13:01:46
13:02:09
13:02:30
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30571
sends 43 pieces of diamonds transported to you by helicopter in
the safe hands of Colonel Jungle, and you say that didn't happen,
Mr Taylor, yes?
A. It definitely did not. Look, if this Prosecution produces
any evidence to this Court that my government, after being
elected in July 1997, going into the time that Johnny Paul Koroma
up to February 1998, had a helicopter, I submit my guilt. Total
lies. The Government of Liberia did not even have a bee, not to
let's talk about a helicopter. A blatant, blatant - just even on
the assertion that there is a helicopter going to pick up
diamonds from Tongo that Johnny Paul has already congratulated
people for capturing Tongo is total, outright nonsense. A lie.
That's all it is. That's all it is.
Q. Very well. Well, let's deal with the second allegation
regarding diamonds so far as this witness is concerned, shall we.
Page 9383, line 7:
"Q. Was there ever another occasion when RUF diamonds were
handed over to Sam Bockarie?
A. Yes, during that month that I was there it happened
twice when we brought diamonds to Sam Bockarie.
Q. You've told us about one time. I want to ask you to
tell us about the second time it happened. This time how
many diamonds were involved?
A. Well, the second one we met - by the time Jungle came
back we had got 18 pieces. Among them we had a big one,
which was not among the 43 that was first taken.
Q. So you had 18 pieces, including a big diamond. What
did you do with the 18 pieces?
A. Well, it was the same procedure. When Jungle came the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:03:05
13:03:25
13:03:39
13:03:58
13:04:15
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30572
diamonds were shown to him at Mr Bockarie's place, because
he too wherever - when he was doing it he would have a
witness and they will be around when he does the handing
over.
Q. Who would have a witness?
A. He, Bockarie. He did not do it alone.
Q. Did you do anything to those 18 diamonds?
A. Yes, we parceled it just like we did the first one, we
wrote the total on it and we followed the same procedure as
the first one.
Q. Were there any calls made on this occasion?
A. Yes, it's the same way. Mr Bockarie informed Mr Taylor
and he told him the total and Jungle too confirmed the
total.
Q. Could you hear this particular conversation?
A. Yes, sir, all five us of us were in the same place. He
told us that he was calling Mr Taylor and they were
conversing. They were talking.
Q. When you say all five of you, who was there? Who were
the five?
A. I was there, Mosquito was there, Jungle was there, Lion
and Junior Vandi, who was Sankoh's bodyguard attached to
Mosquito.
Q. What happened after the calls to Charles Taylor?
A. Well, they explained the same thing to him that they
have got so and so amount and that we've parceled it. Then
he said they should give the parcel to Jungle, so they
thanked the man a lot that he should keep it up.
Q. Who thanked the man?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:04:41
13:05:02
13:05:24
13:05:47
13:06:14
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30573
A. Mr Taylor.
Q. And which man did he thank?
A. Sam Bockarie.
Q. And was the parcel given to Jungle?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What did Jungle do with the parcel?
A. He was given the same escort to the border."
And then he goes on to say that - well, we needn't trouble
with that.
Now, Mr Taylor, what's your answer to that second occasion
within a month?
A. It never happened. Never. It's a lie. We listened to
another witness here, I think earlier during the week, explaining
Bockarie in late 1998 taking diamonds, but he could not see me
and he left it to be turned over for material that he could not
get when he went. Here is another witness now saying that this
is far earlier, and still we do not know the period that he is
talking about. But there is no such thing about no 40 - now 18 -
pieces of diamond coming with somebody called Jungle. That's
totally, totally false. Totally false.
Q. Well, Mr Taylor, if we just pause and just take stock for a
moment. Bockarie was bringing you diamonds, not always
successfully because on one occasion he didn't meet you. Issa
Sesay brought you diamonds, although he lost them. Jungle was
bringing you diamonds, and other named individuals were bringing
you diamonds at the same time.
A. Eddie Kanneh.
Q. Yes. What did you do with them, Mr Taylor?
A. There was nobody bringing me any diamonds. I don't know
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:06:47
13:07:08
13:07:38
13:08:01
13:08:21
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30574
how they got these people awfully and shamefully to put these
lies together. Not one of them, the Eddie Kanneh or the Issa
Sesay, nobody, no human being in Sierra Leone - and mind you, all
of these people that are talking about these diamonds were never
there when they were presented, but they were presented according
to them. So - now Jungle is supposed to bring them. Jungle is
dead. So maybe those that are alive, if they are brave enough to
come to the Court, will be able to tell the truth. But I never
received diamonds from any human being in Sierra Leone. Never.
Q. Very well. Let's briefly look at another version of a
topic which we are now familiar with, Mr Taylor. Let's look at
page 9395, line 2:
"A. Well, he", that being Sam Bockarie, "left us in Sierra
Leone and went to Monrovia and we were - we used to call
him Colonel Bockarie and then he came with two
promotions and those were high promotions. He was called general
now, he and Issa Sesay, and he said it was
President Taylor, Pa Taylor, who gave them that promotion.
Q. What did he tell you about the second thing he told
you, the command structure between you said 'us and the
AFRC'?
A. Well, it he made it clear to all, that being Sam
Bockarie, all the AFRC men who were present that AFRC was
no longer in power and that where we had now come it was
called the Jungle and that everybody was supposed to be
under the RUF command and that the RUF - anywhere the RUF
was serving as a commander the AFRC should serve as a
deputy."
So we can place this. This is after the intervention?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:08:51
13:09:08
13:09:35
13:09:59
13:10:22
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30575
A. That's it. That's what I am saying.
Q. You promote Bockarie to general, didn't you, Mr Taylor?
A. No, I did not.
Q. And you were handing out these promotions willy-nilly?
A. No.
Q. Because Issa Sesay at the same time was promoted, wasn't
it - according to this - by you?
A. That never happened, and then it conflicts very seriously
with testimony before this Court that those promotions were made
by Johnny Paul Koroma after he retreated from Sierra Leone - from
Freetown in February 1998, Johnny Paul Koroma held a meeting and
he made these promotions in which Sam Bockarie became, well, the
chief of defence staff in Sierra Leone. Now he is attributing
that to me. Never, ever gave any suggestion or recommendation
for any promotion or anything closely related to that in Sierra
Leone. Never did.
Q. Well, according to this witness, Mr Taylor, your hand in
this was much greater than you are letting on to us, because he
goes on to say this.
"Q. What did Sam Bockarie say about the role of Jungle at
the meeting?
A. Well, he put it clear to Pa Paul, Pa Johnny Paul, that
that was the man who the leader had introduced to us to be
Pa Ghankay's own representative in the RUF territory. So
he was the person that always linked us to Pa Taylor and he
wanted them to know that for them to recognise him.
Q. Who did he want? Who is 'them'? Who did he want to
know that?
A. Well, the new men that joined us, that is the AFRC
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:11:00
13:11:16
13:11:36
13:12:07
13:12:20
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30576
group, Johnny Paul and his men."
Now, Mr Taylor, I thought you had been in touch with Johnny
Paul Koroma during the period of the junta?
A. Never. That's I mean. Never, never been in touch during
the period of the Jungle.
Q. So help me then. Why hadn't you told Johnny Paul, during
the course of that communication, that Jungle was your
representative? Why hadn't you told him that?
A. Because I am not in touch with him. Just not in touch with
him. That's a part of the lie. Never in touch with him. And
like you say, if I am in touch with him, of course I will be:
Well, listen, Johnny Paul, you are in there now. My man on the
ground is Jungle. That would be logically what one would expect.
No, I don't do that if I am in touch with him all that time.
Only at this particular time now, there is someone in a meeting
after he comes out to say: Oh, guess what? Here is a man.
There is no such thing. No such thing.
Q. And it goes on at page 9396:
"Another thing you said was discussed at the meeting was
the Fitti-Fatta mission."
Now, bear in mind, Mr Taylor, this is after the
intervention, yes?
A. Yes.
Q. "What was said about that particular mission?
A. Well, he said he would want us to go and clear the
mining area, that is Kono, and that the Pa had told him
that nothing goes for nothing and that he had no machine to
make arms, that they were materials. He also bought them
from some other areas. So he said - he said we should go
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:12:59
13:13:32
13:13:53
13:14:18
13:14:39
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30577
and capture the mining area so that we would be able to get
money from there and get the materials.
Q. Just so it's clear who is this person, the Pa, that you
just referred to?
A. That is Mr Taylor - Mr Charles Taylor. Former
President Taylor."
Now, Mr Taylor, what about that? You, in effect, ordered
the Fitti-Fatta mission, the capture of Kono, and the reason for
it is quite plain and simple: I'm not giving you arms for free.
If you need them, you are going to have to pay for them. The
only way you are going to pay is diamonds, so capture Kono.
That's the reasoning. What do you say?
A. Yes. Totally no. It's false. But you can see the
falsehood, how it develops. It's on the basis that there is
material, and so that's how it's going. There is no such thing.
So there is Fitti-Fatta now, so this is supposed to be around
about what? March, April 1998. Because now Johnny Paul is
already up-country and this operation is supposed to be going on.
There is no such thing. I have no knowledge and/or involvement
in this thing. And diamonds must come in because it has to be
proven that diamonds are going to Charles Taylor when he is
supposed to produce material, only that there are no materials in
Monrovia. So the whole diamond thing falls like a house of cards
because there is no materials, and they should have known that
there is no material in Monrovia for anyone.
So you can say maybe: Oh, well, he took the diamonds and
didn't provide the material. But to say that Taylor took
diamonds and provided materials; total lies. Total lies.
Q. Before we move on, Mr Taylor, we note from the passage when
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:15:40
13:16:05
13:16:25
13:16:42
13:17:11
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30578
according to this witness you gave orders for Fitti-Fatta, yes?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, the witness continues in this vein, same page 9396,
and remember this is a meeting the witness is talking about, the
famous Waterworks meeting following the intervention, yes?
A. Yes.
Q. "Q. Another thing that you said was discussed at the
meeting was Sam Bockarie's travel to Burkina Faso with
General Ibrahim, is that right? Was that discussed at the
meeting?
A. Yes, yes, yes, we discussed that.
Q. What did Sam Bockarie say about that?
A. He said that Mr Taylor told him that he would link him
in with Blaise Compaore, the President of Burkina Faso, and
it was Mr Ibrahim Bah who was going to travel with him. He
was to move with him.
Q. Move with him where?
A. To Burkina Faso.
Q. Did Sam Bockarie say when this was to take place?
A. Well, he did say that it was not going to take a long
time and it was going to be in the same month. After the
month that we held the meeting, after the Fitti-Fatta
operation, then he moved on this mission."
Now, Mr Taylor, as far as you're aware, when did Sam
Bockarie travel to Burkina Faso in company with, inter alia,
Ibrahim Bah?
A. November late, early December 1998.
Q. Yes. And remind us, when was the intervention?
A. February 1998.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:17:48
13:18:06
13:18:54
13:19:14
13:19:36
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30579
Q. And this meeting in the Waterworks?
A. This had to be somewhere around February/March 1998.
Q. According to the witness, Bockarie was going on this
mission in the same month, yes?
A. Yes.
Q. Are you aware of Bockarie travelling to Burkina Faso, you
having set up the connection, on any other occasion other than
late November 1998?
A. No, I am not aware of that. And if he did, he didn't come
through Liberia.
Q. Now, on the same topic he continued, 9397, line 22:
"Q. Did Sam Bockarie say why Charles Taylor was going to
link him to Burkina Faso - send him to Burkina Faso?
A. Yes, because he said he told him about the mission that
we would take to free the leader and it was a mission that
involved heavy materials because we were supposed to clear
the ECOMOG force before we get to Freetown, so he said he
was going to link us up where we would be able to get
direct material so that we would bring them over and be
able to run the mission.
Q. When he referred to this mission to free the leader,
what mission was he referring to?
A. Well, that was Operation Free the Leader and that was
the material he went for for us to come and run the mission
to capture Freetown and free the leader."
And then he goes on to say that this Waterworks meeting
lasted for some eight hours. Now, Mr Taylor, again we have
another witness linking you to the forward planning behind the
Freetown invasion, do you follow?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:20:32
13:21:02
13:21:23
13:21:41
13:22:03
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30580
A. Yes, I do.
Q. Now, on this version, what you do is this, and I am putting
it in simple terms to give you an opportunity of dealing with it.
You link Bockarie with Blaise Compaore because for the capture of
Freetown a lot of material will be required. Bockarie travels to
Burkina Faso where the desire for sufficient material is met and
it is that material which is used in Operation Free the Leader.
You follow that, don't you?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. And you were the one who, through your contacts,
facilitated that. Do you follow me?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. What do you say about that, Mr Taylor?
A. It's a lie. But, you know, the logic of this thing is why
do - I mean, I have material in Liberia. Mind you, I have been
delivering this material, so why at this particular time I have
to go outside and get somebody else if --
Q. You'd probably run out, Mr Taylor. You had been sending so
much, you see, you'd run out?
A. But, mind you, I am supposed to also be delivering in 1999.
I am supposed to be delivering material up to 1999 where there
are other operations that I am sending. There is an unending
supply of ammunition. So that's the way the lies go. I mean, I
am supposed to hook him up. These people had some well planned
people outside. Don't forget Ibrahim Bah who they keep talking
about. Where is Ibrahim Bah living at this time? Ibrahim Bah is
living in Burkina Faso. Evidence before this Court, he comes
from Burkina Faso to meet Foday Sankoh in 1996 in Abidjan. When
the junta comes to power, he goes to Freetown according to
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:22:40
13:23:09
13:23:44
13:24:05
13:24:28
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30581
evidence led in this Court. So if there is any hook up, I am the
only one to hook up. Am I in command of Blaise Compaore that I
would link them and Blaise is supposed to send this heavy amount
of material? I don't know how they made it up, but I did not
link Sam Bockarie up with Blaise Compaore. They made their own
contacts and that was the contact that had been explained that
granted them with ECOWAS and the United Nations freeing up a few
of them to travel to where they wanted to go and that's how they
made their contacts. So that is totally false.
Q. Let's move to page 9424. Now the witness is speaking of a
second meeting at Sam Bockarie's house in Buedu. This is after
he had obtained arms from Burkina Faso and this was a meeting in
mid-December 1998 and he says this, page 9424, line 1:
"When Mr Bockarie came he called on us because there was no
need for him to call all the officers again. So those of
us who were close to his location, he invited us. We came
to Buedu and then he explained to us that he has brought
ammunition, he has brought enough logistics so that we will
be able to run any kind of mission. So he said we should
now plan how to take the move and that the first target
should be Kono, to Makeni, up to Freetown. And then the
next target should be Segbwema and Daru, that is heading
towards Kenema, and to go to the southern province. So
those were the things we discussed and the issue of
SAJ Musa's disloyalty that he has been doing all along.
That was also something we discussed.
Q. When you say the first target should be Kono to Makeni
up to Freetown, what do you mean by that the first target
was to be Kono?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:25:09
13:25:24
13:25:47
13:26:12
13:26:32
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30582
A. Well, Kono is a mining area. In that whole country
that is the place we know for high level productivity for
diamonds, so we believed that if we were able to capture
there first it would have been good for us. That was the
reason why Kono - he said Kono should serve as the first
target that we should capture.
Q. Were any particular commanders given the role of
capturing Kono?
A. Well, yes.
Q. Who?
A. Well, Sam Bockarie told us that this plan was designed
in Monrovia with Mr Taylor. He said it was designed in
Monrovia so he only brought it to brief us, that that
should be the way we should do things so that we will be
able to succeed in the war."
Plan hatched in Monrovia, Mr Taylor?
A. That sounds like legal language to me. It sounds like
legal. This whole response sounds like very, very, very legal
language; the whole thing was planned and designed there in
Monrovia. It was designed in Monrovia, so he brought us the
brief. This sound like legal language. He was really put
together. He was really put together with this lie. And nobody
designed or planned nothing. I did not know about what was going
on in Sierra Leone. Never met Sam Bockarie. Never knew what
they were doing in Sierra Leone about no invasion of Sierra Leone
or Freetown to put anything together. And whoever put this lie
together, it's just a lie. That's all it is.
Q. Well, Mr Taylor, based on the suggestion being made by the
witness, let me ask one or two questions. Firstly, were you
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:27:20
13:27:36
13:28:01
13:28:23
13:28:47
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30583
aware of this issue of SAJ Musa's disloyalty?
A. No, never knew of SAJ Musa. Never heard of him, no.
Q. Well, when you were designing the move to Freetown,
Mr Taylor, did you not advise Sam Bockarie as to what to do about
such an important issue as SAJ Musa's disloyalty?
A. No, never.
Q. Why didn't you?
A. Because I never spoke to him about it, about any of the
things that they were doing.
Q. Because you see when we go on to page 9426 it appears that
that particular issue loomed quite large at the time. Line 18:
"After the meeting" - this is the meeting he has just
described - "but there had been arguments even before the
meeting, before this mission there had been an argument. Just at
the time Sam Bockarie sent the message to all the stations, right
from that time SAJ Musa was not happy about it. He was
disgruntled right up to this mission time and after they had held
the meeting he sent the same order to SAJ Musa and he refused
even before the Kono thing."
Why were you allowing this to happen, having spent so much
time designing this mission, Mr Taylor?
A. I knew nothing about it, so that's a fabrication. So it's
not that something I would let happen or not let happen. I don't
even know what they are doing in Sierra Leone.
Q. Because it continues, you see, over the page on page 9427,
line 3:
"Q. Now the second issue that you said was discussed at
the meeting was SAJ Musa.
A. Yes.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
13:29:13
13:29:31
13:29:50
13:30:11
13:30:34
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30584
Q. What was it about SAJ Musa that was discussed at the
meeting?
A. Well, Sam Bockarie told us that the complaint had gone
up to Mr Taylor, that the man's complaint had been lodged
about his disloyalty towards the mission, and he too gave
his own piece of advice.
Sam Bockarie lodged a complaint to Mr Taylor against
SAJ Musa record regarding his attitude. He said he was a
man who did not take any order from people who is disloyal
to the command.
Q. At the meeting was there any other discussion about
SAJ Musa?
A. Yes, Mr Bockarie made us to understand that that man
should not live to tell the story." That's SAJ Musa.
And over the page, line 8:
"He said he should go all out to ensure that the man should
not live to tell the story."
So, according to this, Mr Taylor, SAJ Musa's disloyalty was
brought to your attention when you're planning the meeting. So I
am asking you again: What did you do about it?
A. I did not know what was going on, so I couldn't have done
anything about it. I have no idea about what man is talking
about me giving - receiving a complaint on SAJ Musa. I have no
idea of what this witness is talking about. Because no such
thing occurred, whether it is a message from - or complaint from
Sam Bockarie or nothing. I have no idea what is going on. None.
PRESIDING JUDGE: That might be a good time, Mr Griffiths.
MR GRIFFITHS: Very well.
PRESIDING JUDGE: We will break for lunch now and resume at
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:31:55
14:32:11
14:32:46
14:33:34
14:33:48
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30585
2.30.
[Lunch break taken at 2.30 p.m.]
[Upon resuming at 2.30 p.m.]
PRESIDING JUDGE: Ms Hollis?
MS HOLLIS: Mr President, we simply notice a change of
appearance for the Prosecution this afternoon. Mr Santora is not
with us this afternoon.
PRESIDING JUDGE: Thank you. That's noted.
MR GRIFFITHS:
Q. Right, Mr Taylor, we're continuing with the same witness,
Karmoh Kanneh. Now, you recall before the luncheon adjournment
we were looking at various things said by this witness to have
occurred during a meeting at Sam Bockarie's address. Now, he
tells us at page 9429, testimony of 9 May 2008, that that
meeting, line 20, took place on a night, line 27, in December
1998. Now, he went on to suggest this, and I'm looking now at
page 9431 - yes, he says this, dealing with the plan which you
had designed in Monrovia, do you follow?
A. Yes.
Q. Line 2:
"Q. And what leader was to be released from Pademba Road?
A. Foday Sankoh.
Q. The person Jungle who you discussed yesterday, was he
at this meeting?
A. Yes, yes, he was part of this 12-man meeting.
Q. Did Jungle speak to the meeting?
A. Yes, later after the plan had gone on Sam Bockarie
spoke to Mr Taylor about the plan, how the mission was to
carry on."
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:34:29
14:34:58
14:35:18
14:35:44
14:36:06
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30586
Line 16:
"A. They briefed President Taylor, the former President,
about the plan, how it was set. After that Jungle too
buttressed the same topic to him, how the plan had been
made, and he in turn thanked them and told them to carry on
and that he said he would pray that the mission would be
successful."
Over the page on the same note, line 5:
"Q. What did Jungle say in the meeting?
A. Well, in the first place, Jungle himself told us about
the material that Mr Bockarie had brought and that we
should not fear this time round and that there was no force
that could withstand us. That was what he said in the
meeting. And he said he had discussed it with the Pa in
Monrovia even before they came.
Q. And did he say what the Pa had said in Monrovia?
A. Yes, it was just what Sam Bockarie told us. He just
spoke about the same issues Sam Bockarie had spoken about,
that the Pa had said our first target should be Kono before
we should proceed."
And then the learned judge, her Honour Judge Sebutinde
asked: "Well, Mr Taylor was not in the meeting." And Ms Baly
responded:
"I know, your Honour, the questions I have asked you are
about what Jungle said in the meeting and you've told us that
Jungle said he had some discussion with the Pa in Monrovia about
the plan."
Then this response, line 26:
"A. Yes, that is what I explained. I said they were the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:36:48
14:37:05
14:37:28
14:37:52
14:38:22
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30587
ones who came, so he told us about the materials that had
been brought for the mission and that the Pa - that they
had discussed with the Pa how the mission should go. That
is Pa Taylor."
Over the page, line 13:
"Q. Now, apart from Jungle telling you that he had
discussed the plan with the Pa in Monrovia, did Jungle say
anything else at that meeting?
A. Well, that is what he said. That is what he said."
Now, Mr Taylor, you understand now, don't you, this is
evidence which attaches you with direct complicity in the
Freetown invasion? You appreciate that, don't you?
A. Yes.
Q. You are - based on the testimony of this witness, you will
be depicted in due course undoubtedly as the architect of that
design. Do you follow?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. Were you?
A. No, I was not.
Q. Now, on the same note, the testimony continues in this way,
line 13, page 9434:
"Q. You gave some evidence earlier when you used the
phrase 'they briefed President Taylor'?
A. Yes, yes. After the meeting and during the meeting are
not the same questions. I spoke about after the meeting
and after the meeting everybody went to bed.
Q. Who briefed President Taylor?"
Line 25:
"A. First it was Sam Bockarie, he held the phone and spoke
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:39:01
14:39:22
14:39:50
14:40:22
14:40:57
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30588
to the Pa. He briefed him about the arrangement we had
done about the mission and later Jungle himself went on the
same phone and spoke on the same topic to President Taylor
that we had arranged everything to run the mission.
Q. Where was this phone?
A. It was the same veranda at the back of Mr Bockarie's
house. The veranda at the back. That was where the phone
was.
Q. What type of phone was it?
A. It was a satellite phone."
So, Mr Taylor, just so we understand the sequence of
events, Bockarie goes to Monrovia. You link him to Blaise
Compaore. He comes back with a lot of material. You then make a
plan with him, a plan which involves the capture of Kono, Kenema,
Makeni, Lunsar and in due course Freetown. Bockarie goes back to
his redoubt in Kailahun province where he holds a meeting in
mid-December. Having briefed everyone on the discussions he had
with you and assured them that they were now in possession of the
necessary material, he then calls you on the satellite phone,
discusses the matters with you and also with your agent, Jungle.
That in a nutshell is the scenario described. Mr Taylor, in
December 1998, were you so engaged?
A. No, I was not. I was not. And in fact, the whole thing is
just - it's just very, very, very painful. The man - if this
account is true, Blaise Compaore, President of a country,
chairman of the OAU, is supposed to give the RUF a large amount
of arms and ammunition and doesn't know what it's for - if the
story is true. It is only Taylor who - so they just go there and
Blaise said: Well, here's some arms and ammunition. A whole
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:41:47
14:42:16
14:42:34
14:43:18
14:43:42
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30589
lot, if this account is correct. And Taylor sits down and he - I
didn't plan any operation or nothing with them. Never did.
Never did. It's beyond me. It's beyond my comprehension how -
how these people manage this. I don't understand it. I don't
understand it. I do not understand it. I never under this
heavens, under this - on this planet with Charles Taylor sitting
down arranging for someone to go to a grown man like Blaise
Compaore, just go there, hook you up, got there, get ammunition,
come in, sit down. I don't know Sierra Leone. I have never -
besides going to Freetown to see Joseph Momoh earlier, I don't
know any other part of this place. We sit down and plan and do
this and that; it never happened. But, I mean, how they get them
to come here and say this, it beats me. It beats me. I swear I
don't know.
Q. Now in addition - because some of this witness's evidence
was not dealt with in chronological order, the witness also at a
later stage in his testimony spoke of events earlier in 1998, and
I begin at page 9448, line 1:
"A. I had a call from our high command who was Sam
Bockarie who called me at his base in Buedu.
Q. What did Sam Bockarie say to you?
A. He said Pa Taylor was to send some ammunition for the
RUF, that we were to go and collect it.
Q. Did he say to you why you were selected to go and
collect it?
A. Well, one of the reasons was that I was one of the
commanders in that Kailahun area where he was based and the
second was I had a vehicle. That was the reason why I was
involved in that ammunition issue.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:44:14
14:44:32
14:44:54
14:45:15
14:45:34
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30590
Q. What kind of vehicle did you have at that time?
A. I had a Land Rover.
Q. What did you do after the phone call you had with Sam
Bockarie?
A. When he called me he told me that ammunition was to be
brought to Foya, so we should go and collect it and I was
happy because if you are fighting a war and you are without
material that is not good. But if there is material that
is a success to you.
Q. What did you do? What action did you take?
A. So I joined him and we travelled. We took his two
jeeps that he had and mine and we moved to Foya.
Q. Who did you join?
A. Mosquito. I joined Mosquito.
Q. And you said, 'We took his two jeeps that he had and
mine and we moved to Foya', so how many jeeps went to Foya?
A. Three. Three vehicles.
Q. And who were the people that went to Foya?
A. I went - the two of us went with few of his security
men.
Q. What did you do when you got to Foya?
A. Well at that time we went but the helicopter had not
arrived yet."
Note, helicopter, Mr Taylor?
A. Yes.
Q. "Because the helicopter was to bring the materials and we
went to the commander.
Q. Who was the commander that you went to?
A. One Commander Joseph.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:46:02
14:46:39
14:47:01
14:47:23
14:47:45
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30591
Q. Where was this Commander Joseph?
A. In Foya near the roundabout. We were based there until
my commander told me to wait until the helicopter would
land and we will go to the field."
There was then a break. Now, later he goes on to say that
he took the materials to his base at Bayama and these were
materials that Sam Bockarie gave him out of that assignment,
those being specifically AK rounds and RPG rockets, and then he
spoke of another occasion when he made such a trip to pick up
arms and ammunition, and this is page 9458:
"Q. When was this second occasion?
A. That was in 1998 still."
So note, Mr Taylor, a helicopter, 1998 still.
"Q. When abouts in 1998?
A. Well, after this mission because this other one was
around March to April, it was not too long. It was a short
time. That was the time ULIMO and LURD forces invaded
Lofa.
Q. At the time that the ULIMO and LURD forces invaded
Lofa, where were you?
A. I was in Baiima with my battalion.
Q. And how did you become involved on that occasion in
obtaining the arms and ammunition?
A. The commander called me again - that is Mosquito - at
the same place, Buedu, and explained the issue to me, that
that was what the Pa had told him that those men had
invaded his men at Lofa County."
Q. And who was that person?
A. Mr Taylor."
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:48:39
14:49:07
14:49:20
14:49:35
14:50:07
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30592
So, Mr Taylor, twice in earlyish 1998 you send war materiel
by helicopter to Foya to be picked up by Sam Bockarie for use in
Sierra Leone. Is that true?
A. Totally false. That is not true. But this guy goes
further. He has a telephone too, so he's big in this
organisation. He has a telephone. 9448, line 16 he talks about
a telephone conversation that he holds with Sam Bockarie. So we
have another telephone over there. Sam Bockarie is not the only
one with this other lie. 16.
Q. Yes, I've got it.
"Q. What kind of vehicle did you have at the time?
A. I had a Land Rover.
Q. What did you do after the phone call you had with Sam
Bockarie?"
A. So he's talking with Sam Bockarie. See what I mean? He
has a phone, because you can't talk on one phone after the
phone - so even he has a phone now. So maybe there's a second
satellite, just like all the many other lies. It's just
incredible. I don't know how to respond to all of this except
just say it plainly, that it is totally unfounded of what this
gentleman is explaining here to the point of holding telephone
conversations with Bockarie and getting instructions. I don't
know, it's just - it's not true. It's not true.
Q. Now, the witness was asked for further clarification
regarding these shipments of arms. Page 9451, line 18:
"Q. Can I take you back to just before the break. You
said you had gone to Foya and you went to a person by the
name of Commander Joseph near a roundabout at the main
junction. Can I ask you do you know this person Commander
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:50:44
14:51:18
14:51:54
14:52:33
14:53:03
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30593
Joseph's full name?
A. No, that is the name I knew for him, because that was
the first day I saw him.
Q. And I just want to clarify the timing of this event a
little bit. You said it was just after the ECOMOG
intervention. When was it in relation to the death of
Abacha who you've referred to earlier?
A. This happened - it took some months before Abacha died.
Q. What do you mean when you say, 'It took some months
before Abacha died'?
A. Well, this mission took place, then Abacha died
thereafter."
And then at the last line, agreed fact number 11, Abacha
died in June 1998. So he's being very specific, Mr Taylor, about
the time frame he's talking about. Now help us, what were you
doing around about that time?
A. In fact around this time, we're talking around about around
about June of 1998, I am responding, in fact, to I would say a
near citation. The President of the Security Council has already
held a meeting with the Liberian ambassador, Mr Wisseh, and had
talked about Liberians being involved in the operations in Sierra
Leone and had asked for a response. Now, depending on that, in
fact, Abacha dies in June, I rush off to Nigeria. In July Kofi
Annan comes, so I'm very busy with this whole intervention and
the issues that follow thereafter by June of 1998 around this
time.
Q. Yes.
A. If you remember, counsel, following the February situation,
by March/April Okelo has already sent this memo to the Security
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:53:55
14:54:17
14:54:44
14:54:58
14:55:21
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30594
Council saying that most of the individuals involved in the
Freetown situation are Liberians. To be followed by the
President of the Security Council inviting Mr Wisseh, my
ambassador charge in New York holding a meeting and asking for a
response. So this is the sequence that's going on at this
particular time. I am very busy now having to respond to
Mr Okelo's memo to the Security Council concerning his assertion
- I mean, at least - that this whole situation that Liberians are
the ones that are involved in the Sierra Leonean crisis because
of the number of them that have been arrested or killed during
the February operation. So I'm not there playing games with
these people.
Q. And returning briefly to page 9458, Mr Taylor, the witness
explains at line 10:
"Q. When abouts in 1998?
A. Well, after this mission because the other one was
around March to April, it was not long. It was a short
time. That was the time ULIMO and LURD forces invaded
Lofa."
Was there such an incursion by ULIMO and LURD in
March/April 1998?
A. Never. No. Except he knows more than I know about ULIMO.
What I know about 1998, there is a little situation where there's
a Mosquito Spray. I don't know. ULIMO is not involved, to my
knowledge, in any attacks on Liberia at this time, or LURD. We
don't get to know who or what this whole thing is until somewhere
about late '99/2000 before the name LURD starts coming up. Other
than that, we don't know.
Q. Now, you've mentioned the Okelo situation and your
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:56:11
14:56:31
14:56:44
14:56:58
14:57:18
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30595
ambassador to the United Nations being summoned by the President
of the Security Council. Now in light of that, Mr Taylor, I
mention this. At page 9453 he's talking about this same delivery
by helicopter:
"Q. You said you were waiting for a helicopter. How long
did you wait for?
A. We were there for up to an hour because when we went
there it did not take long.
Q. Was this in the day or was this at night?
A. It was daytime.
Q. What happened after the hour had expired?
A. We saw a helicopter coming.
Q. Where did the helicopter come to?
A. It came to Foya. It was flying over Foya.
Q. Where did it land?
A. Foya Airfield.
Q. Can you describe this helicopter, please?" Line 29.
Over the page:
"A. It was a military helicopter.
Q. What do you mean by military?
A. It had a green colour.
Q. Did you see how many people were in this helicopter?
A. I saw the two pilots that were there and I saw up to
five people, those who alighted the helicopter that I saw.
Q. After they came did you come to know any of the five
people?
A. Yes, later there was introduction.
Q. Where did the introductions take place?
A. After we had unloaded the materials and brought them
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:57:44
14:58:14
14:58:39
14:58:58
14:59:11
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30596
into the vehicles that was when the introductions were
done.
Q. Who were you introduced to?
A. Mr Bockarie introduced me to a man whom he said was
Mr Taylor's chief bodyguard. He said his name was Benjamin
Yeaten and they used to call him Director."
Now, broad daylight, military helicopter ferrying military
supplies to Foya airfield. Mr Taylor, why were you behaving so
blatantly in light of your ambassador to the UN being summoned by
the President of the Security Council? Didn't you care?
A. No such thing happened. In fact, now, Sam Bockarie is at
the airport. It is not him now going for this material because
his commander calls him, but Sam Bockarie is present in Foya.
This is what he's saying. Sam Bockarie is also present in Foya.
I thought first that his commander had called him and he had gone
for this material.
Q. Well, let's not worry about those details, Mr Taylor. Just
deal with the essential point. Why are you acting so blatantly?
A. But there's no such thing happened, so that's how, you
know, you crack up this whole nonsense. There's no such thing
that happened, I mean, because it would be silly. In fact, I
don't have a helicopter --
Q. I was coming to that.
A. -- at this particular time. And, in fact, any technical
person that we call upon, an Mi-2 helicopter with five
individuals on board and a shipment of ammunition on an Mi-2
helicopter? Because the first helicopter we even get in Liberia
in 1999 is an Mi-2, which is a very small chopper, and nobody,
the Russians on down, ask, will you tell you it's impossible to
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
14:59:53
15:00:06
15:00:22
15:00:35
15:00:48
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30597
bring two pilots, five individuals, seven, with a load of
ammunition on an Mi-2.
Q. But, Mr Taylor, despite your protestations, I fear I have
to continue with the description given by the witness, same page,
line 24:
"Q. Were you introduced to any of the other men who had
come on the helicopter apart from Benjamin Yeaten?
A. No.
Q. Did you see the person who was the pilot of this
helicopter?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Can you describe what that person looked like?
A. He was white. They were white people.
Q. When you say 'they were white people', how many of the
five were white people?
A. Two.
Q. Did you know where they had come from?
A. No.
Q. Apart from the fact that the pilot was white, was there
anything else that you can describe about that particular
person?"
And then he was asked to clarify:
"Q. Did you know where this helicopter had flown from?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where?
A. Monrovia."
And then he goes on to say that he learnt from Sam Bockarie
that the two white men were Ukrainians. Mr Taylor, did you
employ Ukrainian helicopter pilots in or about March/April 1998
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:01:33
15:02:05
15:02:23
15:02:41
15:03:00
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30598
after the ECOMOG intervention to ferry arms to Sam Bockarie in
Foya by helicopter?
A. No, I didn't. I didn't have a helicopter at this time.
Q. Did you have access to Ukrainian pilots at this time?
A. No. What would they fly? I didn't have a helicopter, no.
Q. And for completeness, the witness goes on to describe the
consignment sent. Page 9456, line 6:
"Q. Can you remember what the materials were?
A. Yes.
Q. What were they?
A. They were AK rounds and there were RPG rockets and
there was RPG tube.
Q. How many AK rounds - or how much AK rounds were there?
A. Forty boxes of AK rounds were there.
Q. How many RPG rockets were there?
A. We had 10 boxes of RPG rockets.
Q. And how many RPG tubes?
A. I didn't count that one. It was just a few. And some
arms were there too.
Q. What arms?
A. AK-47s.
Q. How many?
A. I cannot recall."
And then he goes on to say how the ammunition was
thereafter transported to Sierra Leone. Let's try and move on
from that then, Mr Taylor.
Now, you note that reference was made by the witness to
there being an incursion by ULIMO, LURD at or about this time.
Did you at that time, Mr Taylor, seek the assistance of the RUF
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:04:21
15:04:39
15:05:04
15:05:18
15:05:31
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30599
to repel those invaders?
A. No, I did not.
Q. Because the witness goes on to say this, page 9458, line
28:
"Q. Who were those men who invaded and who were his men?
A. The LURD forces.
Q. And who had the LURD forces invaded?" Page 9459.
"A. Charles Taylor.
Q. And what else did Sam Bockarie tell you?
A. So he said we were to put men together and to go and
help to clear the enemy from that place.
Q. And what did you do when you were told to put men
together and to go and help to clear the enemy?
A. Well, he gave me my own task that I was to go and
prepare men in Kono."
Line 17:
"A. I was to go and prepare manpower for that same
mission and he said he had told Issa and Morris Kallon to
do the same preparation in Kono.
Q. Did you prepare manpower?
A. Yes.
Q. What did you do in relation to the manpower?
A. I brought them to Buedu.
Q. How many men did you bring to Buedu?
A. One platoon.
Q. How many in one platoon?
A. Sixty-two in number.
Q. What did you do when you got to Buedu?
A. We waited for the troops. All the troops were brought
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:06:03
15:06:24
15:06:39
15:06:51
15:07:07
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30600
together and we called a formation.
Q. What happened then?
A. We divided the number into two groups and we divided
them and told them that they were to enter at two flanks.
Well, Sam Bockarie and I were to enter by the Foya axis.
And the other flank, they too were to enter by Vahun.
Q. And did you and Sam Bockarie enter by the Foya axis?
A. Yes.
Q. And what did you do?
A. We attacked the Foya Town.
Q. Who did you attack?
A. The LURD forces.
Q. Were you successful in attacking the LURD forces?
A. Yes, we chased them and we went to that same Kolahun.
Q. Where did you chase them to?
A. Voinjama.
Q. What happened when you got to Voinjama?
A. When we got there that was their base. We fought
against them for the whole day. Thankfully we were able to
capture the place.
Q. When you say thankfully you were able to capture the
place, what place did you capture?
A. Voinjama.
Q. What happened after you captured Voinjama?
A. We had an order from Benjamin Yeaten to chase the men
right to where they'd come from.
Q. Where they'd come from?
A. They said they had come from Guinea.
Q. Did you chase them to Guinea?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:07:38
15:08:00
15:08:27
15:08:47
15:09:12
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30601
A. Yes."
Now, when was this occasion, Mr Taylor, when a town in the
sovereign country of Liberia was captured by RUF soldiers from
neighbouring Sierra Leone?
A. At no time. No time did the RUF capture any town.
Q. Voinjama?
A. In fact, Voinjama, if we look at the UN report here of the
attack on Voinjama, from the best of my recollection, and the
looting of my forces in Voinjama, this occurred in 1999. So I
don't know how this Voinjama business comes back up, because 1999
we know that as people are moving to Lome, there is some little
problems in the Voinjama area and people have to be picked up.
Mind you, according to all of the UN documents brought
here, where are people picked up from to go to Lome? Vahun.
That's where the helicopter finally lands, in Vahun. If you look
at all of the - according to the UN reports, the first two
individuals that go are - just a reminder - are Ibrahim Bah and
Golley, but they are picked up in Vahun. Now, he's supposed to
be attacking - some other group is supposed to be attacking in
the Vahun axis and all this nonsense. But the people are picked
up - the UN helicopters go to Vahun to pick up the people.
The crisis in Voinjama, that's in 1999, so I don't see what
he's talking about here, because what I understand, this is
happening in 1998 with all these operations - I do not want to
say that I'm misquoting what he said, this looks like, again,
we're talking about around Abacha's situation.
Q. That's the period from - my understanding of the testimony
of this witness --
A. So we're talking about June 1998, and we know from UN
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:09:49
15:10:07
15:10:46
15:11:05
15:11:27
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30602
documents here that the Voinjama situation occurs in 1999. So it
is not true. And this attack from the Vahun axis again, that's
where the United Nations helicopters go to pick up all the
people. All of the reports here, the delegation from Sierra
Leone are picked up in Vahun. So I don't know what attacks are
going on in Vahun that the UN would avoid Lofa and go to Vahun
for because attacks are going on there. It's not true.
But, I mean, these things are just so many that you just
keep saying, "No, it's not true. It's not true." It is really
not true. What he's saying here is not true.
Q. Let's see if we can conclude the rest of the account given
by this individual, because he continues, page 9461, line 12:
"Q. What happened after you chased them to Guinea?
A. We captured a town that was called Bayalo in Guinea.
Q. What did you do after you captured the town?
A. We received order to burn the entire town and that we
did.
Q. Who did you receive the order from?
A. From Benjamin Yeaten.
Q. What happened after you had burnt the entire town?
A. We withdrew back to Voinjama.
Q. And what happened after you got to Voinjama?
A. We passed the night there and in the morning we put our
men together and we returned to Foya. Then we left the
Liberians there.
Q. Where did you go?
A. Then Sam Bockarie took me to go to Monrovia.
Q. Did Sam Bockarie tell you why you were going to
Monrovia?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:11:57
15:12:16
15:12:36
15:12:53
15:13:14
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30603
A. He said Mr Taylor had invited him for us to go and
receive morale boosters.
Q. Did you go to Monrovia?
A. Yes.
Q. Who went to Monrovia?
A. I went and Sam Bockarie went too and one of his
bodyguards called Magazine. All of us went.
Q. Did anybody else go?
A. Well, we were the ones who went.
Q. How did you get to Monrovia?
A. That same military helicopter with the combat colour
picked us up from Foya.
Q. And where did you go when you got to Monrovia?
A. We landed at a field that I did not know. That is in
the Monrovia city.
Q. Had you been to Monrovia city before?
A. No.
Q. When you landed in this field that you didn't know,
where did you go to from there?
A. A vehicle came to receive us and we drove together with
Benjamin Yeaten and we went to Benjamin Yeaten's place,
White Flower.
Q. Where did you meet Benjamin Yeaten?
A. Well, this helicopter that came, all of us travelled in
it."
He goes on to explain that they met Benjamin Yeaten in
Foya, that on arrival in Monrovia they went to Benjamin Yeaten's
place at White Flower. Over the page, 9463, pick it up at line
14:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:13:46
15:14:01
15:14:10
15:14:28
15:14:39
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30604
"Q. How long did you spend in Monrovia on this occasion?
A. We spent some days in Monrovia.
Q. How many days?
A. Like three days.
Q. What did you do during the three days you were in
Monrovia?
A. I was at Mr Benjamin's place and in the morning the two
of them would go out to meet with the President. They'll
say they were going to meet with the President.
Q. Who are the two of them?
A. Benjamin Yeaten and Sam Bockarie.
Q. Did you yourself ever go to meet with Mr Taylor on that
occasion some.
A. No.
Q. Did you speak to Sam Bockarie after he had met with
Charles Taylor?
A. Yes, he told me that they had come from the President's
and that was the Mansion Ground.
Q. Did he tell you what had taken place in this meeting
with Charles Taylor?
A. The Pa said we should wait, that he had promised to
give us morale booster and some ammunition for us to go
back with.
Q. And did you wait?
A. Yes. The day that we were to move was when I saw some
ammunition and Sam Bockarie told me that the Pa had given
$10,000. The ammunition was AK rounds and some RPG
rockets. Can't recall how many."
Over the page:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:15:13
15:15:43
15:16:03
15:16:39
15:16:59
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30605
"Q. You said that Sam Bockarie told you that the Pa had
given $10,000. Did you see $10,000?
A. Yes.
Q. Where did you see the money?
A. He told me there and when we got to Foya all of us met
together with Issa and others and they got out the money
and it was counted."
Now, Mr Taylor, bearing in mind when this is supposed to
occur, remember ULIMO/LURD March/April 1998, you seek assistance
from Sam Bockarie across the border.
A. Yes.
Q. He comes over with men; they successfully capture Voinjama;
drive the invaders back into Guinea; burn a town on the way; and
then, no doubt as a vote of thanks, they are taken back to
Monrovia, where they're given further weapons and $10,000, yes?
A. Yes. Total, total false. Total false, and maybe one of
the things we ought to consider, we have to get the technical
information on an Mi-2. Forty boxes of AK ammunition on an Mi-2,
it would never get off the ground. Added to that ten boxes of
RPG, five human beings --
PRESIDING JUDGE: Did the evidence actually say the
helicopter was an Mi-2?
THE WITNESS: But that's the only helicopter that we got in
1999. So even if he's talking about that, I'm trying to say the
helicopter that finally the Government of Liberia gets is an Mi-2
in 1999, okay?
MR GRIFFITHS:
Q. Just to be clear, Mr Taylor, apart from that Mi-2, did the
Government of Liberia at any stage have access to any larger
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:17:33
15:18:03
15:18:20
15:18:37
15:18:52
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30606
helicopters?
A. Yes.
Q. When?
A. In 2000 we get an Mi-8 - in 2000 when the war intensifies.
But what we have on the ground beginning 1999 is an Mi-2. They
are parked now at the Spriggs Payne Airport in Monrovia.
Q. And I want to be clear about this. Prior to getting the
Mi-2, did you have access to a helicopter?
A. No, the Liberian government did not have a helicopter at
that time, no.
Q. All right.
A. No.
Q. Was there any body in Liberia prior to 1999 who had access
to helicopters?
A. Yes.
Q. Who?
A. There was an aircraft company there. Weasua had an Mi-8
helicopter that was leased by the United Nations and other
places, people - painted white, but they had an Mi-8.
Q. What colour was it?
A. White.
Q. Sure it wasn't camouflage paint?
A. No, no, no, no. A white Mi-8 that was used by NGOs, United
Nations. It was painted white to demonstrate that it was used
for legal international purposes. No, it was an Mi-8 painted
white, owned by Weasua.
Q. Did your government ever use it?
A. No, we did not. We did not use it as a government, no.
The UN leased it on a few occasions.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:19:46
15:20:04
15:20:30
15:21:01
15:21:34
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30607
Q. Now, the witness goes on to suggest, Mr Taylor, that in
addition to the various occasions when he went to collect arms -
do you remember he spoke of two trips to Foya to pick up arms?
A. Yes, yes, yes.
Q. He says at page 9469:
"Q. Was there a third occasion when you yourself were
involved in obtaining arms and ammunition for the RUF?
A. Yes. I was involved in another one again.
Q. When was this other one?
A. 2000, after the May incident that occurred in
Freetown."
Now, the May incident in Freetown is what, Mr Taylor?
A. Well, to the best of my knowledge, the May incident in
Freetown must be the assault on Foday Sankoh's house, if I'm
correct.
Q. After that event did you send a shipment of arms to the
RUF?
A. No, I didn't. How would I send? No, I didn't. No.
Q. Now, who is Damate Conneh?
A. Damate Conneh ended up being the last leader of LURD.
Q. Now, the witness mentions his name in relation to another
incursion by LURD when once again he received - page 9474, line
24 - a similar instruction from Mr Sesay that "I should put men
together to go and join Benjamin Yeaten at Kolahun." What about
that one, Mr Taylor?
A. No. I'm not aware of that, no. But you asked a question
about May 2000 and what is going on at that time. If we look at
to see how this witness is not telling the truth, what's also
going on in May 2000? We dealt with this also with another
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:22:22
15:22:45
15:23:26
15:23:40
15:23:53
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30608
witness. There are UN hostages, right, that have been taken -
more than 500 of them that have been taken. We begin the
negotiations for the release of those hostages in May, and the
United Nations is on the ground and everybody is on the ground.
We finally get those people released. So now here I am at this
particular time trying to get more than 500 UN peacekeepers
released; I'm sending ammunition to Freetown. So I just wanted
to put in perspective that period that he's talking about to
demonstrate that it is not true.
Q. And once again the witness says at page 9478 that following
the successful capture of Voinjama once again he's taken in the
same military helicopter to Monrovia - page 9478 - and he goes on
at page 9479, line 12:
"Q. Where did the helicopter take you?
A. Straight back to the main field where myself and Sam
Bockarie had landed. That was the same playing field that
we landed in Monrovia.
Q. Where did you go after you arrived?
A. White Flower.
Q. Who was on that trip?
A. Benjamin Yeaten and me.
Q. Anybody else?
A. No."
And then he says that they did meet some person:
Q. Who was that person who met you there?
A. General Sesay."
Now, what's this, Mr Taylor? A trip to Monrovia, White
Flower, by Benjamin Yeaten, Issa Sesay and this man Karmoh Kanneh
taken there by helicopter following their assistance to your
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:24:36
15:24:50
15:25:14
15:25:38
15:26:13
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30609
government in Lofa to fight off LURD sometime in 2000. What do
you say?
A. That's not true. That is not true. So he meets Issa Sesay
in Monrovia?
Q. Well --
A. Is that my understanding?
Q. I can only look at what is recorded in the testimony at
line 23, page 9479:
"Q. Was there anybody else in Monrovia that you met after
you arrived?"
A. Well, no. We did not meet some other person but
somebody met us there.
Q. Who was the person that met you there?
A. General Sesay, Issa Sesay."
So Sesay is in Monrovia. Yeaten and this man come to
Monrovia and meets him there. That's the sequence.
A. That's not true. That's not true. What is he, some VIP?
What is he - because we're talking about 2000 now. We're talking
about Issa Sesay as leader of the RUF. Issa Sesay is now RUF
leader, okay, because we've passed the incident of the arrest of
Foday Sankoh. So except where Issa Sesay has now ordered he's
some top individual - I don't know him as being so senior in the
RUF that the Issa Sesay is on the ground waiting for him. That
beats me. But it didn't happen as he says it here, no.
Q. Now, he goes on. On that occasion, he says - remember, he
meets Issa Sesay in Monrovia. And it goes on at page 9481, line
10:
"Q. The person you met or who met you in Monrovia you said
was Issa Sesay. Whereabouts did he meet you?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:27:05
15:27:25
15:27:54
15:28:40
15:28:52
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30610
A. Well, he met us at Benjamin Yeaten's place which is at
the back of the President's house.
Q. How long were you in Monrovia?
A. For about four or five days?
Q. What did you do during those four or five days?
A. Well, after Mr Issa Sesay had arrived I did not
actually know what their discussion was and my meeting -
even my meeting with the President was cancelled."
Pausing there. So you were scheduled to meet him,
Mr Taylor, but the meeting was cancelled.
A. I had no meeting with this person here, ever. Why would
Issa Sesay be in Monrovia? Because if Issa Sesay met him, that
means that Issa Sesay got in Monrovia before he got there. Who
is this man that I had a scheduled meeting with, for God's sake?
No. Who is this man?
Q. Very well. The witness then goes on to speak of meeting
Sam Bockarie at Sam Bockarie's house in Monrovia. Page 9490.
And I will ask you about this. He was asked:
"Q. Whereabouts in the house did you meet?
A. It was at the front of his house, John Benjamin,
because he lived at the back of the President's house, the
former President's house, Mr Taylor.
Q. Who was present, apart from yourself, when you met Sam
Bockarie?
A. I was there, Director, that is Benjamin Yeaten himself
was there, Sam Bockarie was there and Benjamin's security
officers were there and his signal man too was there.
Q. Can you name any of the security officers who were
present?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:29:29
15:29:43
15:29:58
15:30:14
15:30:35
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30611
A. I can recall one of them was called Varney. That I can
recall."
He cannot recall the name of the signal man:
"Q. On Friday you said that you and Sam Bockarie exchanged
greetings. Did you have any further conversation with Sam
Bockarie at that time?
A. No, we spoke and what we said was that we greeted each
other and after the greetings he made an appointment with
me to meet him at his base, because Director was there. He
wanted us to discuss, but director was there.
Q. What do you mean 'He wanted us to discuss but Director
was there'?
A. That was why he made an appointment with me. He said I
should meet him and that there was something he wanted us
to discuss, but because Benjamin Yeaten was present that
was why he deferred it so that I would meet him at his" -
Sam Bockarie's - "house.
Q. Did you meet him at his house?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where was his house?
A. His house around ELWA Junction. The road that led to
his house was called Four Houses Road.
Q. Had you been to this house before?
A. No, that was my first time to go.
Q. Did you go there with anyone else apart from yourself?
A. No.
Q. Did you meet with Sam Bockarie?
A. Yes.
Q. Was anybody else present apart from yourself and Sam
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:30:57
15:31:14
15:31:23
15:31:38
15:31:52
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30612
Bockarie?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Who?
A. I saw his child, they used to call his child Copal, and
I saw his mother and his clerk was called Jabbati and his
wife and some other people that I did not know.
Q. Did you see anyone else there apart from his child, his
mother, his clerk Jabbati and his wife?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Who did you see?
A. They were both men and women. I could not recognise
them because I did not know them before that time.
Q. Did you speak to Sam Bockarie?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where did you speak to him?
A. He invited me to his bedroom where he used to sleep.
Q. In the bedroom, who was in the bedroom apart from
yourself?
A. We met his wife. His wife was in the room. She was
the third person.
Q. What was said?
A. At first when we entered it was about the RUF business
that he told me about, the way the RUF had treated him. He
said the RUF had been ungrateful to him, that he was not
expecting, but from that time that he had left the RUF and
he had put a curse on the movement and he will continue to
put a curse on the movement on a daily basis, when he would
go to bed he would curse the movement that the movement
will never succeed. He said that he was just sorry for
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:32:27
15:32:54
15:33:16
15:33:47
15:34:03
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30613
some of us that what - the way he was using us during the
war, he was just sorry for us, but that the movement will
never be successful. That was the first topic that he
spoke about."
And then he continues, line 27:
"A. He said he was discouraged, because he had just come
from the police station as the President Mr Taylor had made
him to be invited to the police station and he was in open
detention for between three and four days and I asked, I
said, 'Why, why were you invited?' He said the President
Mr Taylor said he had a lot of pressure from the
international community to hand over Sam Bockarie. He said
he was there for three days and he said what he told him,
if he was going to hand him over, that is Sam Bockarie, he
would explain everything, all the deals that were between
RUF and Mr Taylor, he the Sam Bockarie would explain that
to the Special Court, and that was what he said and after
that day - after the two to three - three to four days he
was released again and he returned to his house.
Q. Did he tell you what happened to him after he had been
released and returned to his house?
A. He did not tell me about any other thing that happened
to him, but I don't think anything happened. He said when
he said that the Pa sent an order for his release, but he
told me that he was worried about this, for his life.
Q. Did he tell you why he was worried for his life?
A. He said the Pa said he had a lot of pressure for him to
be arrested, so that was why he said he was worried for his
life and at the same time he said the Pa had said he had a
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:34:45
15:35:19
15:35:50
15:36:22
15:36:50
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30614
mission for him, but he did not tell me what mission it
was."
Now, there's a lot there, Mr Taylor. But let's just break
it down. Whilst in Monrovia, 2000, witness meets up with Sam
Bockarie at Benjamin Yeaten's address. Bockarie tells him, "Need
to speak to you alone." So he goes to Bockarie's address, meets
with Bockarie who tells him that you, Charles Taylor, President
of Liberia, ordered, in effect, his arrest because you were under
pressure from the international community to hand him over and
that, in effect, Bockarie, through fear for his life, was
blackmailing you, saying, "If you hand me over, I'll tell
everything about the deals you and I did." Is that true,
Mr Taylor?
A. Your Honours, Sam Bockarie was never arrested in Liberia,
not even for a second. Never. The whole while Sam Bockarie was
in Liberia before he left, and mind you, I do not know - well,
he's talking about early in 2000. Sam Bockarie leaves Liberia in
late 2000. Sam Bockarie is never, ever arrested. So this other
one about Sam Bockarie being arrested and kept for four or five
days or picked up at the police station is as unfounded as it
gets. He was never sent to the police station. Every newspaper
would have picked it up. Every radio station would have picked
it up. It never happened. Never was Sam Bockarie ever
embarrassed in Liberia in this way about being sent to the police
station. I don't know how this man can bring - can say this. It
never happened, ever. As simple as that. So all this other
nonsense, that's all I can put it to. It looks like a
well-written script and he is just following the script.
Sam Bockarie arrested in Monrovia at the time? Mind you,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:37:42
15:38:03
15:38:22
15:38:41
15:39:11
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30615
before this Court there was a lady that says she was Sam
Bockarie's radio operator, that when Sam Bockarie got into
Monrovia they set up a radio at Four Houses, and the question was
asked whether I was aware of it. I don't know of any of those
that accompanied Sam Bockarie to Monrovia that testified here,
Jabbati Jaward, I forgot the lady's name who was the radio
operator, there was another young man, I'm not sure if he was a
protected witness, who says he was an operator working in
Benjamin Yeaten's yard. All the people that went with Sam
Bockarie, I know of none of them that have told this Court about
Sam Bockarie being embarrassed, including this gentleman who is
also protected that was supposed to have escorted Sam Bockarie
around Africa and wherever he went. Sam Bockarie was never
picked up and arrested.
Q. That's TF1-579.
A. Never arrested. Never embarrassed at any time. When it
was time for Sam Bockarie to leave, we sent him out of the
country. He was never arrested. So all of this stuff is a
blatant, really unfortunate lie.
Q. Well, Mr Taylor, there is a matrix of facts being
established here which you need to have clearly in mind because
what the witness is saying and what is being relied on is this:
You knew, in effect, that this Special Court was on your trail
and you were being blackmailed by Sam Bockarie about that.
That's the crux of the allegation. You do get it, don't you?
A. But that was never the case. Sam Bockarie never, ever
threatened in any way because there was nothing - I really - I
did not know, quite frankly, that any court, Special Court, was
on my trail. Never. Never. Not from my wildest imagination,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:39:45
15:40:06
15:40:29
15:40:39
15:40:54
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30616
no. And Sam Bockarie - there was no discussion with Sam Bockarie
where there was some - well, if you knew all of this, then why
let him leave the country?
Q. 2000.
A. Yes, but why would he leave? If you know that he holds the
key to me, then the best thing to do is not to let him leave.
Q. Well, you see, what the witness is saying is that you had a
particular mission for him. Remember that being mentioned?
A. Yeah.
Q. Now, we know what that mission is, don't we? Where does he
end up, Mr Taylor?
A. He ends up in la Cote d'Ivoire.
Q. Right. So he's got a choice then, unpacking the evidence
of this witness. Go on this mission or - that's the choice you
gave him.
A. Come on, no.
Q. Well, Mr Taylor, listen, it's not a question of "come on".
A. No, no.
Q. These are very serious allegations being made against you
by this Prosecution.
A. Yes, but it's a foolish accusation. I mean, they will want
to put it - you want somebody that has the key to getting you
arrested and killed, and you send him out of the country. What's
the best thing? If you want to arrest or kill the man, he's in
your hands; what do you do? You do it. But, no, you take him
and you send him, say "Go and fight a war." So the man leaves
the country. Do you have control over him? It would be silly
for anybody to even - I mean, only sick minds would believe that.
Let's be honest about this. I mean, I know what this whole case
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:41:30
15:41:50
15:42:09
15:42:27
15:42:53
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30617
is about, but it is sick if anyone would say Bockarie, who holds
the key to getting me whatever, he's in my hands and I let him
go. He goes, I send him off to a war. It doesn't make sense. I
mean, anybody wanted to believe that, I can't stop them from
believing that. You've got the man, he's supposed to be
threatening you. Instead of - you want to destroy him. Instead
of you do it, you send him out of the country. What control do
you have when he's gone out of the country? None. So it doesn't
make sense. So all these silly things that these people have
lead these people here to talking about, I have no control over
it. But logically, no sound person would look at this as being
anything sensible, that this man has the key but I sent him out
of the country to go and fight a war. Come on. I mean, why let
him go? He goes and he tries to fight his way back into the
country. Does this look like a man that is threatened by me?
No. So, I mean, the logic as they have lead these witnesses
through it is just totally warped, and I don't understand it.
But you are right, there is a major allegation here. But, I
mean, it's like - you know, it's almost like pick what you want.
I mean, it's just a maze of - it's like, you know, something like
the Rubik's Cube. You've got to fight your way out of this.
Here is somebody that - here's Chief Foday - Issa Sesay is in
Monrovia; he comes. Here is a man that is supposed to be wanting
to meet me that - it's cut off. I don't even know how important
he is, if he was an important individual in the RUF - because
they talk about those that were very important - he probably
would have been arrested himself and probably going through the
Special Court of Sierra Leone. This man is virtually nothing,
but he's got a meeting with me. I'm just trying to point out
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:43:40
15:43:52
15:44:16
15:44:42
15:45:08
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30618
there's a crop and crop of total, total fabrications made up and
it does not lead to anything logical. None.
Q. Now, Mr Taylor, later in the testimony of the witness the
witness was allowed to offer this opinion during the course of
his testimony, page 9496:
"Q. Did you learn whether anything happened to Sam
Bockarie?
A. Yes.
Q. What?
A. Later I heard over the same BBC that Sam Bockarie was
dead, so I just recalled when he said he was worried for
his life and I recalled again that - I thought again that
Mr Taylor would never hand that man over because of that
statement. I was not there" - and then he offers this
opinion - "but I just concluded that that could have been
the reason why he killed that man: For him not to ever
come to this Court and explain anything."
That is the hidden conclusion. And the point being made,
Mr Taylor, is this: You don't cover your tracks unless you've
got something to hide. Do you get it? It's a guilty man, they
say, who commits murder to silence potential witnesses. You get
it? That's how significant this is.
A. Well, I tell you something. I don't care who the person
is, if this kind of logic holds, then I don't - then I'm guilty.
Because nobody who is educated would believe this nonsensical
logic that Sam Bockarie, who leaves the country far out of my
reach, returns to Liberia, and all of a sudden he gets killed
because I'm trying to hide something when the man is in Liberia.
He fights his way back into the country. Sam Bockarie is there
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:45:47
15:46:14
15:46:32
15:46:55
15:47:47
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30619
in the first instance. He's there. He suggests that in 2000 -
before Sam Bockarie leaves in 2000, he suggests that Sam Bockarie
is at a police station in 2000 and he's kept. But because he
threatens me in 2000, I have to let him out. And what do I do?
I tell him you have a choice of going out to go and fight a war.
2003 Sam Bockarie, who has left the country for more than two
years, okay, is out there and now he comes and he's supposed to
be killed because of what I did not accomplish in 2000 when I let
him go, I accomplished it in 2003. Then that type of logic I
don't need to sit in this Court, because that logic would not
suffice. It's a silly logic, I mean, for him to even draw, that:
Well, Mr Taylor did this because of that. When you say before in
2000 - the man threatened me in 2000 and he left the country. So
what did I do, throw a hook and hook him and bring him back into
Liberia? Do I have extraterritorial powers to go to Ivory Coast
or Burkina Faso and arrest Sam Bockarie and bring him to Liberia
and kill him? I mean, these are the type of things that make
this whole case just reel when you have this kind of thinking. I
mean, this is total, total, utter nonsense, I would call it, with
this kind of logic that he proposes here.
Q. The final matter I want to put to you with regard to this
witness, Mr Taylor, is this. The witness speaks of a large
consignment of arms and ammunition being brought to Sierra Leone,
and he says he was later told why that was done by Issa Sesay.
Line 26:
"Q. What did he tell you?
A. At one time I was at my base in Pendembu and he invited
me, because he was based in Kono. When I went there, he
told me about the mission."
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:48:16
15:48:34
15:48:59
15:49:24
15:49:34
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30620
And I should add that this at a time when UNAMSIL have
deployed in Sierra Leone.
"Q. What mission?
A. The reason why the materials were brought. He said
Mr Taylor had given those materials and the weapons and
that we were to attack Guinea from two flanks from the
Sierra Leone end. He said those were the materials and
even the money that he had told me about was for the
mission. That was what he told me.
Q. What money?
A. That the trip that we went on, we brought with us
$50,000. He gave us $50,000 that we brought from Monrovia.
I thought when we would get to Pendembu he will share it
amongst us, but we did not do that. He said President
Taylor had given us the money together with the material.
Q. Who had he given the money to?
A. Issa Sesay."
Now, Mr Taylor, effectively what's being said is you were
paying the RUF to do your fighting for you by attacking Guinea.
A. From Sierra Leone?
Q. Yes.
A. For what reason? Never gave Issa Sesay any arms or
ammunition.
Q. Well, let me offer you a reason so you can deal with it.
A. Okay.
Q. Lansana Conte never liked you. His country was being used
a base for raids into Liberia. What better way to respond to him
than unleashing your boys from across the way in Sierra Leone?
You get it?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:50:08
15:50:34
15:50:55
15:51:30
15:51:58
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30621
A. Yeah, but if I'd wanted to do that --
Q. That's the logic.
A. Yeah, I would do that myself. I would not have to use
anybody. And in fact, we did - I did follow. In 2001/2002, I
did follow LURD forces into Guinea and - on a search-and-destroy
mission and it didn't take - I mean, well, I had larger, stronger
forces by this time - by this time we have written the Security
Council and I have other weapons in Liberia and we have certain
capacities, and I did go after LURD forces in two towns in
Guinea, Liberian forces. So here I am now paying RUF forces out
of Sierra Leone to go and attack Guinea. That's not true.
That's not true. In fact, I think there is evidence before this
Court that there were some clashes between Sierra Leonean and
Guinean forces for reasons that were good for the RUF, but not
for my side, no. No, I wouldn't have done that, and I wouldn't
have given Issa Sesay any money or ask him to do anything.
Q. All right. Mr Taylor, that is all I ask you about this
witness. In the same vein we're continuing one of the themes
raised by that witness. We're now moving on to a witness
TF1-579.
A. Is that protected?
Q. It's a protected witness, but it's a witness who dealt with
certain movements regarding Sam Bockarie. You remember?
A. Okay.
Q. Let's set it in context, shall we. Let's put it in
context. Let's start - this person gives evidence, and I want to
start with the evidence he gave on bonfire night, 5 November
2008, starting at page 19795, line 1:
"Q. What else did Sankoh say about his mission that you
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:53:02
15:53:18
15:53:36
15:54:01
15:54:17
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30622
can recall?
A. I remember that he was telling Oliver that this
revolution that we are here to launch, I do not want any
looting. I do not want my citizens to be harassed. That
was what I heard him say.
Q. Did Sankoh indicate how he would get the men and the
equipment to do this invasion?
A. Yes, Sankoh said his men were trained at Naama and that
most of them were Liberians at that time and the supplies
were given to him by Mr Taylor and that every support for
that movement came from Mr Taylor.
Q. Do you know whether or not Oliver Varney was surprised
to see Sankoh come and say he was bringing men through Bomi
Hills?
A. No, I was not surprised, because Oliver, Sankoh and
others, all of them came from Libya together. According to
him, he said all of them were there and that he was a
friend to Mr Taylor and he was friendly to all of them and
so all of them came together. So it was not a surprise to
me, nor Oliver.
Q. Was there any communication before the arrival of
Sankoh?
A. Yes, the communication took place in the radio room
whilst I was standing there and it came directly from
Mr Taylor in Gbarnga to Oliver and he said Sankoh was en
route and that he should make sure that he gives him every
support he needed."
In there from the beginning, Mr Taylor, directing Oliver
Varney, who, according to you, is involved in this dreadful
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:55:09
15:55:39
15:55:55
15:56:25
15:57:01
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30623
conspiracy with others and Sankoh behind your back, and there you
are, according to this witness, instructing Oliver Varney to
provide every assistance to your friend from Libya, Foday Sankoh.
See?
A. Yes, I see. I never, never called Oliver Varney at any
time to give him any instructions of such. Never.
Q. But you agree that there came a time, did there not, when
you did provide Foday Sankoh with accommodation in Gbarnga?
A. Oh, yes. Yes, I did.
Q. Just a little detail: Was that in an area called Sugar
Hill?
A. Yes.
Q. And do you recall whether there were any SBUs based at that
address?
A. No.
Q. What about a task force?
A. No, at this time I'm not - there was a police - yeah, I
think there was a task force. There was a task force, but it was
very near the Executive Mansion in Gbarnga.
Q. What was very near to the Executive Mansion in Gbarnga?
A. The task force headquarters.
Q. And were there any SSS based at that address in Sugar Hill?
A. No. At that time we had not put together the SSS yet, no.
Q. For completeness, page 19814, line 13:
"When I came under Benjamin Yeaten's command Foday Sankoh
was given a house right at the area called Sugar Hill, Sugar
Hill, and that is where he stayed. At this house there were
SBUs, task force and some SSS personnel assigned at the house,
not far away from Benjamin Yeaten's house and not far away from
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
15:57:45
15:58:08
15:58:32
15:58:57
15:59:22
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30624
the mansion, and we used to go there and speak to him. That was
where I saw him again."
That's the testimony of the witness, Mr Taylor.
A. How can a whole unit of SSS and task force be at wherever
Foday Sankoh is? Foday Sankoh has a house in Gbarnga. I gave
him a house in Gbarnga. The police headquarters, the task force
is attached to the police at the time. They have a headquarters
in the building near the mansion because they have to protect the
mansion too. At this particular time the SSS is not really put
together. The SSS is a creation of the government of Liberia and
it's an old organisation.
We had with us behind the line, we're talking about way
back in '91 and '92, we had some senior officers that had managed
to reach to Gbarnga and what we were trying to do at this
particular time, we started using them to begin to train the
people in VIP protection. So by this time in '91/'92, while
Sankoh is there, the SSS is still not put together, no. We only
have bodyguards provided by the Executive Mansion Guard, but even
that terminology or acronym SSS is not actually in place at this
time yet.
Q. Mr Taylor, at this time when the Executive Mansion was
based in Gbarnga, was there an ammunition dump at the Executive
Mansion?
A. Yes, we had something like - well, you call it an arm dump.
We had something like a container where we kept supplies outside
of the fence but within the security zone in the general area. I
would say just maybe about a hundred yards or more from the
Executive Mansion.
Q. And did the NPFL have a G4 position or section within its
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:00:14
16:00:44
16:01:04
16:01:27
16:01:52
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30625
hierarchy?
A. Well, I can say yes, but --
Q. Was it called that?
A. Yes, but let me just get one thing clear. Every unit had
an S4. But the S4 is at the unit level and they kept their
material, but a general G4 at that particular time, we didn't
have an assigned individual as a G4.
Q. No?
A. I beg your pardon?
Q. You didn't?
A. No. We had supplies and we had people at the warehouse.
That G4, just to explain for - I'm sure there are military people
here that understand. The S4, G4, they carry out the same
function except that the G4 is on the overall level. It's the
highest position. We did not have a G4, because as supplies
came, they had to go out so quickly. But each unit in the field
had their S4 that took care of the ammunition and they had their
ammo dump under what we call the S4.
Q. And was that controlled by a man called Moses?
A. No. This Moses that keeps running around - Moses is not
even a third grade student. He can hardly read and write, this
Moses, and I'm referring to Moses Duo that has been flaunted
around this Court. Moses Duo can barely read and write. No, he
was not.
Q. Because, just to put everything together, the witness says
this, he is asked whether or not Foday Sankoh was staying at his
residence in Gbarnga or sometimes travelling, page 19815, line
20:
"A. Sankoh used to travel and come to Gbarnga.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:02:36
16:03:07
16:03:23
16:03:40
16:04:04
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30626
Q. Where was he going?
A. I don't know.
Q. When you were in Gbarnga, did you receive any
assignments at any time to go to other parts of Liberia?
A. Yes. I was Gbarnga at the mansion when at one time an
enemy hit. ULIMO hit some part of Lofa and there was a
supply to take to Lofa at that time and I was part of that
convoy. Mr Yeaten gave the order and we drove to that
place. The RUF came from in and repelled the attack. I
met with one of the commanders called Yellow Man and the
supply was turned over to them. That was one of the
assignments that we had.
Q. Do you recall what year this was that you travelled to
Lofa?
A. It was in the same 1992."
He then explained that the supply he was talking about was
ammunition. Line 15:
"Q. Where in Gbarnga was the ammunition kept?
A. The ammunition was kept right at the mansion. There
was a G4 section right at the mansion. That was where the
ammunition was kept.
Q. Can you explain what you mean is brought back by the
RUF came in and repelled the attack?
A. Yes, when we were in Gbarnga the RUF - because their
supply used to come from Gbarnga to reach them and so that
was their supply route, so any attack that would block
their route they will come from in to repel that attack
because Mr Taylor used to send them supplies and so that
route was not supposed to be blocked.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:04:38
16:05:12
16:05:39
16:06:01
16:06:25
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30627
Q. Did you ever make any other trip to Sierra Leone or
trips?"
No, we'll come back to that in a moment. And he goes on to
mention that the person from whom they received the ammunition at
a place near to your house was a man called Moses. Now, let's
look at two aspects of that, firstly. After ULIMO began
attacking Liberia, Mr Taylor, did you at any stage seek the
assistance of the RUF to enter into Liberia to repel them?
A. No.
Q. Never?
A. Never. Never.
Q. Now, the witness goes on. He is asked:
"Q. Did you ever make any other trip to Sierra Leone or
trips?
A. Yes. The second time was with Zigzag Marzah, Jungle,
Daniel Tamba" --
MS HOLLIS: Could I ask for a page reference, please?
MR GRIFFITHS: I'm sorry. 19837, line 16:
Q. "Q. Did you ever make any other trip to Sierra Leone or
trips?
A. Yes, yes. The second time was with Zigzag Marzah,
Jungle, Daniel Tamba, Sampson Weah and I. When we drove to
Benjamin Yeaten's house, and Yeaten told us to follow him
to the warehouse and we followed him to the warehouse and
that was right at Mr Taylor's house, that is on the
left-hand side of the house, that was where they had the
warehouse. We went there and Yeaten took a list of those
things that we were supposed to carry and he presented it
to the G4 section. The commander there was Moses Duoh and
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:07:12
16:07:33
16:07:53
16:08:16
16:08:41
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30628
we also received another supply of ammunition, mortar guns,
RPG rockets, LAR, AK rounds and that was Zigzag, Sampson,
Jungle and I, we left and we went to Buedu, along with
three bodyguards who were on top of the car and one of them
was called Enforcer, so we went there.
Q. Sir, you said this second trip began - you said you
went to Benjamin Yeaten's house. Where was Benjamin
Yeaten's house?
A. Benjamin Yeaten's house was right at the back of
Mr Taylor's house, sloping down the hill. No sooner you
slope down the hill you see the house on the right-hand
side. That was Benjamin Yeaten's house.
The warehouse was attached right on Mr Taylor's house.
That is when you come to the front side of the house, by
the left-hand side you will see the warehouse.
This warehouse is right at Mr Taylor's house, the left-hand
side of Mr Taylor's house. When you stand at the front of
the house you watch at the left side, you just walk by the
side of the road, then you go down and you will see the
warehouse and it was attached directly to Mr Taylor's
house.
Q. When he presented the list to Moses Duoh, do you recall
any conversation?
A. He presented the list to Moses and he got back into his
car and left and we stayed there. We started going through
the list so that we received those supplies of ammunition."
Now, just in terms of the physical layout, Mr Taylor, was
there such a warehouse - and we need to be careful here, we're
not talking about Gbarnga here, we're talking about Monrovia.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:09:16
16:09:45
16:10:13
16:10:38
16:11:00
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30629
A. Yes.
Q. Was there such a warehouse attached to your residence in
Monrovia?
A. No, no.
Q. Was there ever a Moses Duoh employed effectively as G4,
let's put it in ordinary language, warehouse man at your address?
A. No. There is a Moses Duoh, he is not G4.
Q. What is he?
A. Moses Duoh is one of the workers in the SSS warehouse that
is located right outside - I mean, in the vicinity of White
Flower. The man in charge of that warehouse is a man called Kai.
Q. Kai?
A. Kai Sony [phon].
Q. And what was Kai's responsibility at the warehouse?
A. Kai was responsible for maintaining the - he held the keys.
Everything, everything that had to do with that warehouse. It
was a warehouse - it's an office - it's a building, it's a
building that hosts the SSS. At the top floors you have the SSS
offices. At the bottom floor, that's where the SSS keep their
supplies that are needed for presidential protection and Kai is
responsible for the keys for that.
Q. Just give us an idea, Mr Taylor, and we'll come, not this
afternoon, perhaps tomorrow, to look at the location in a bit
more detail.
A. Okay.
Q. But for now, just help us to this extent: This warehouse
attached to the SSS, how far from your residence would it be?
A. It is separated by the fence. It is right next to the
fence of my house. Right next to it.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:11:45
16:12:10
16:12:28
16:12:45
16:13:11
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30630
Q. So I just want to be clear. When you say "right next to
it", does it actually adjoin your residence?
A. When you say adjoin my residence, I would say - in your
question I would say yes, but in the legal sense now to say it
adjoined my residence - because my property is on one acre and
the entire acre is fenced. This is not like a little lot. It's
on an entire acre and the acre is fenced. So that building falls
on the outside of that fence. So I know how you asked the
question. I would say yes, but maybe for other purposes we may
have to clarify it more.
Q. So it's next door then?
A. I would say yes.
Q. It's next door. And just describe the structure for us?
A. Which structure? The building?
Q. No, the warehouse.
A. Well, the building is a two-storey building. The top
storey contains offices. That's where the SSS and all of the
securities that are there for the protection of the President,
they are housed in there. All of the material that they use for
movement are in there. That is when I'm moving out of town,
materials are loaded and carried; when they come, they put it in
back in. Also in that warehouse you have food and other things
that - in fact, every Saturday in Monrovia I distributed about
400 bags of rice to poor people around the city. So it's a
warehouse that contains supplies for the presidency, as far as
food is concerned, and materials - as far as the Secret Service,
the police and the military personnel assigned to protect the
President, all of their materials are housed in there.
Q. And who has access to that warehouse?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:13:43
16:14:09
16:14:29
16:15:11
16:15:32
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30631
A. That warehouse is under the command of the SSS director
Benjamin Yeaten.
Q. Right. And it's right, is it not, that Yeaten's residence
is not far from yours?
A. I would say - well, I would say it's a little - it's far.
Benjamin Yeaten's residence is some distance from my house.
It's, I mean, it's several, several houses away from my house.
Q. Okay. Now did yourself directly have access to that
warehouse?
A. No. I would have no need to be, no.
Q. I mean, putting it in very simple terms that we can all
understand, did you have a key to the warehouse?
A. No, no. I didn't have a key to it.
Q. Very well. Let's go back to the witness. The witness goes
on to say this, Mr Taylor. He talks about a trip he makes to
Buedu to deliver arms and ammunition, okay, and in that context
he said this at page 19843, line 3:
"Q. When you got to Buedu, was Mosquito there?
A. Yes, Mosquito was in Buedu, we saw him and he welcomed
us and we turned those things over to him, but the problem
that we faced with him then was that he said he wanted a
jeep and we told him that the jeep belonged to General
Yeaten, your friend, and that indeed if you wanted the jeep
you should please make a call to him so that we will not be
in problem with him and he said, 'That man is my friend.
All you need to do is that you should just go and tell him
that your friend says he wants the jeep,' and he was able
to give $2,000 US to Sampson and I, so we left the jeep
with him".
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:16:09
16:16:36
16:17:02
16:17:16
16:17:34
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30632
Do you recall this incident, Mr Taylor - this testimony?
A. I recall the testimony, yes.
Q. "But before leaving Buedu, when he said he wanted a jeep
there was a tank, a war tank, with a chain under it, those big
military tanks. It was captured behind the Moa River where they
were fighting and he said Mr Taylor said he wanted a tank. He
said that he should send it to him in Monrovia. So we used this
jeep. We drove from Buedu to the Moa River and when we got to
the river, the tank was across the river. You could stand at the
other side of the river and see the tank across."
And then he goes on to mention how the ferry was broken,
and remember the whole episode about the tank. We don't need all
the details, just this for now: Do you recall a conversation
with Sam Bockarie when you expressed a desire to have a tank?
A. No.
Q. A battle tank?
A. No.
Q. Or do you recall a conversation with Mr Bockarie when he
said, "Guess what, chief, I've got a tank for you"? Did you have
such a conversation with him?
A. No, I did not.
Q. Do you know anything at all about this tank episode?
A. None whatsoever. If Sam Bockarie had a tank that I wanted,
I would have sent for it. Not some guy who goes there, he goes
to deliver ammunition, no. Never discussed any tank matter with
Sam Bockarie, never.
Q. Now, in the context of these trips made by the witness to
Sierra Leone, he continued at page 19848 in this way:
"Q. Do you have any idea when the trips that you were
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:18:26
16:18:52
16:19:08
16:19:35
16:20:04
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30633
aware of - just the ones that you were aware of - began?
A. Yes, I have an idea. It was around '98.
Q. And, sir, how long did these trips continue, to your
knowledge?
A. The trips continued even when Mr Taylor took over as
President. The trips still continued until Taylor left
Liberia."
So you see the time frame, Mr Taylor. From 1998 up until
2003 these trips are being made to Sierra Leone. Do you follow?
A. Yes, I do.
Q. "Q. Now, Mr Witness, you talked about General Mosquito and
seeing him on your three trips to Buedu. Do you know if
General Mosquito stayed in Sierra Leone or if anything
happened?
A. Yeah. When Mosquito was in Sierra Leone, at that time
it was after my three trips. I was back to my duty in
Monrovia and General Mosquito and his deputy Issa Sesay had
a problem. This problem used to happen not often. I can
remember that there was a dispute between Issa Sesay and
General Mosquito. Both of them were sent for from Buedu by
Mr Taylor. They came to Monrovia and were taken to General
Yeaten's house. From Yeaten's house they were taken to
White Flower to Mr Taylor's house. That dispute was
settled between them - between the two of them. They
settled the dispute. The one that I can remember again was
General Issa, along with the late Superman, one general,
there was a dispute between Issa and Superman. Issa and
Superman were against Mosquito and they sent for them again
to settle this dispute between them, and when they left
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:20:53
16:21:23
16:21:44
16:22:09
16:22:40
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30634
they went back to Buedu and were still not reconciled."
Now, was there an occasion when you acted as mediator,
Mr Taylor, between Sam Bockarie and Issa Sesay?
A. Never. I know of no conflict, and I don't think he knows
of any conflict that occurred between Issa and Sam Bockarie, no.
Q. Well, Mr Taylor, the witness is being quite clear about
this and he's going on to suggest, it appears, that you
intervened to mediate in this way or more than one occasion.
Because you note, "Issa and Superman were against Mosquito and
they sent for them again to settle this dispute." What about
this other instance involving Superman?
A. No, there was no dispute that I settled between Issa and
Mosquito and Superman. Never.
Q. When was the first time you met Issa Sesay, Mr Taylor?
A. On my very life, in 2000 was the first time I laid my eyes
on Issa Sesay. When Issa Sesay, with this UN situation, I
invited Issa Sesay to come to negotiate the release. Besides,
before then - and even if you look in Issa Sesay's testimony it
will be clarified - I never saw that man before 2000, ever, in my
life.
Q. And by the time you saw Issa Sesay, where was Sam Bockarie?
A. By this time in - Sam Bockarie was in Liberia still by this
time in 2000 when Issa Sesay came to Liberia, because that is in
around May/June of 2000 that Issa Sesay came to Liberia.
Q. Now, Mr Taylor, were you ever involved in resolving any
disputes between individuals in Sierra Leone?
A. Yes.
Q. Who?
A. Sam Bockarie and Foday Sankoh.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:23:13
16:23:59
16:24:06
16:24:25
16:24:55
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30635
Q. What about the suggestion being made by this witness that
you were a regular mediator?
A. No, never. But I don't think those men had that type of
confusion that he's talking about. Never, no.
Q. Did you ever meet this Superman?
A. No, I never met Superman. I knew that there was a Superman
and that he was Liberian, but I never met with him to sit down
and talk, no.
Q. Now he goes on, and this is the real thrust of this
testimony that I want us to deal with now that we've set the
scene. So we know what the scene is now, Mr Taylor. He's been
involved in transporting arms and ammunition backwards and
forwards to Buedu and to Mosquito for a while, yes?
A. Yes.
Q. We've got that clear now.
A. Yes.
Q. We now come to the meat of the suggestion. He talks about
Bockarie coming to Liberia in December 1999, yes?
A. Yes.
Q. Page 19850, line 1:
"A. He came along with a huge manpower, bodyguards.
Q. When you say huge, can you give us any kind of rough
estimate of the number of people that came with him?
A. Close to 2,000 men."
Just to clarify that detail, Mr Taylor, because it might be
of importance subsequently, was it 2,000 men?
A. I doubt it. I don't know the exact number, but when he
talks about men here, I don't know what he's referring to. But
if you look at the military man whose testimony we went through
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:25:31
16:25:55
16:26:17
16:26:34
16:26:55
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30636
yesterday or the day before, Jabaty Jaward, he deals with those
numbers. And I don't have a fight with Jabaty's numbers, so it's
closer to me to about 1,000 people in total.
Q. Very well. Let's not quibble over that.
"Q. Do you recall yourself the names of the people that
came with Bockarie that you knew?
A. Yeah, I can remember the late Salami, one Martin, a
computer man for Mosquito, Toasty, General Sheriff. Not
Varmuyan Sherif, but there was another Sheriff from
Freetown."
Then he goes on, line 24:
"A. All those people whom I have named were Sierra
Leoneans.
Q. What happened to these fighters - excuse me, these men
who with were with Sam Bockarie that came into Liberia?
A. When they came they took them - they were received
at Voinjama and taken to Monrovia and all his men whom he
had brought, the manpower, they were put into the ATU.
Mr Taylor gave an order that they should go to the ATU, so
they were sent for ATU training at Gbatala. After the ATU
training they brought them to town and deployed them."
He explains what ATU means and how they used to dress, and
we're not quibbling with that, are we, Mr Taylor?
A. No, we are not.
Q. And then he goes on to deal with a particular assignment
that he was given, page 19859, line 1:
"Benjamin Yeaten called me to take up assignment with him
and I was with him. I was with Benjamin Yeaten when Sam Bockarie
crossed. Then for the safety of he himself and Sam Bockarie,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
16:27:39
16:27:57
16:28:10
16:28:44
16:28:51
CHARLES TAYLOR
28 OCTOBER 2009 OPEN SESSION
SCSL - TRIAL CHAMBER II
Page 30637
because they wanted a Liberian security to be assigned to Sam
Bockarie just in case there is an information which could be
passed over to Benjamin Yeaten, it was then that he gave us that
assignment, that was what I said."
So he has now been assigned to Sam Bockarie by Benjamin
Yeaten. Now, just pause there, Mr Taylor. Is it the case that
Liberian security personnel were assigned to Bockarie when he
arrived in Monrovia?
A. Yes. Some intelligence people, yes.
Q. Very well.
A. I don't know who, but yes.
Q. "Q. Where did you stay when you were on this assignment?
A. I had my house right opposite the White Flower,
Mr Taylor's house."
Was there such a resident opposite your house for this use?
A. I'm not sure. I'm not sure. It's likely, but I'm not sure
because most of the buildings within the general area, securities
would try to settle in them. But it's possible. It's possible.
Q. Now, he comes on to deal with this relationship with Sam
Bockarie.
MR GRIFFITHS: I don't know if that might be a convenient
time, Mr President.
PRESIDING JUDGE: I think it would be.
We'll adjourn for the day.
Mr Taylor, there's an order not to discuss your evidence.
We'll adjourn until 9.30 tomorrow.
[Whereupon the hearing adjourned at 4.28 p.m.
to be reconvened on Thursday, 29 October 2009
at 9.30 a.m.]