Self-medication practices among adult population attending community pharmacies in Malaysia: an...
Transcript of Self-medication practices among adult population attending community pharmacies in Malaysia: an...
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Self-medication practices among adult population attendingcommunity pharmacies in Malaysia: an exploratory study
Mohamed Azmi Hassali • Asrul Akmal Shafie •
Harith Al-Qazaz • Jayabalan Tambyappa •
Subish Palaian • Vidhya Hariraj
Received: 10 December 2010 / Accepted: 11 July 2011 / Published online: 3 August 2011
� Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011
Abstract Objective To assess the prevalence of self-
medication among adults in an urban setting and to identify
any factors contributing to self-medication in relation to
consumer characteristics. Setting The study was carried out
in Kuala Lumpur, the capital of Malaysia. Methods A
cross-sectional study using a self administered question-
naire including adults above 21 years old as an exit survey
was conducted in Kuala Lumpur. Main outcome measures
Number of medications taken in a day by participants,
source of medication for the treatment of minor illnesses
among participants, common illnesses chosen for self-
medication by participants, and the sources of information
of participants. Results Of 314 participants, 62.7% had
taken at least one medication in the past week without
prescription and 62.7% believed that over the counter
medicines were just as effective as those prescribed by
doctors. 69.4% would seek a healthcare professional’s
advice before purchasing any medication and 86.9% would
consult a pharmacist prior to buying medication from the
pharmacy. Only 86% checked the expiry dates on medi-
cations and 54.5% reported keeping leftover medication.
Conclusions Self-medication practice is prevalent in Kuala
Lumpur but some practice might be harmful. Education on
appropriate use of self-medication need to be emphasized
in order to ensure quality use of medicines.
Keywords Adults � Medication � Pharmacist �Self-medication
Impact of research findings on practice
• The practice of self-medication is prevalent in Kuala
Lumpur, Malaysia and can be observed at various
socio-demographic levels.
• Data from this study can help policy makers in
Malaysia to develop legislation on self-medication
practices.
Introduction
Self-care is what people do for themselves to establish and
maintain health, and to prevent and deal with illness. It can
also be defined as the selection and use of medicines by
individuals to treat self-recognized illnesses or symptoms
[1, 2]. It is a broad concept that includes health activities
and health-related decision-making including nutrition,
lifestyle, self-medication, hygiene, and socio-economic and
environmental factors. With the advent of global net-
working, information technology, better education, new
discoveries and policy changes, consumers today demand
more alternatives and choice to make informed decisions.
Moreover, there is growing social pressure on people to
lead healthy lifestyles [3]. In Malaysia alone, commercial
gymnasiums, weight loss centers and health supplements
have flourished in the last decade, a development reflective
of a more ‘‘health-conscious’’ society.
Self-medication involves the intermittent or continued
use of a medication prescribed by a physician for chronic
or recurring diseases or symptoms. In practice, it also
M. A. Hassali (&) � A. A. Shafie � J. Tambyappa � S. Palaian
Discipline of Social and Administrative Pharmacy, School of
Pharmaceutical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 11800
Minden, Penang, Malaysia
e-mail: [email protected]
H. Al-Qazaz � V. Hariraj
Discipline of Clinical Pharmacy, School of Pharmaceutical
Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 11800 Minden, Penang,
Malaysia
123
Int J Clin Pharm (2011) 33:794–799
DOI 10.1007/s11096-011-9539-5
includes use of the medication by other family members
[1]. With better understanding of disease and health, con-
sumers are now playing an active role in their health care
and take control of their health and self-care initiatives.
The more informed consumers usually have a greater
demand for over-the-counter (OTC) medications through
self-medication [4]. It was estimated that 80% of all
medical symptoms are self-recognized and self-treated
without professional care [3]. Self-medication with the use
of OTC drugs is the most prevalent form of medical care in
the world. It is estimated that over 92% of all consumers
used at least one OTC in the last year, and 55% have used
more than one [3]. The Working Group on Drug Classifi-
cation has defined OTC preparations as a ‘‘pharmaceutical
product, drug, or medicinal specialty whose dispensing or
administration does not require medical authorization, and
it can be used by the consumers under their own initiative
and responsibility in order to prevent, relieve or to treat
minor illnesses’’ [5].
From an economic perspective, the increase in OTC
drugs is driven by consumer demand, healthcare efficiency,
market expansion, generic competition and cost-contain-
ment schemes [6]. Rising healthcare costs and prescription
drug expenditures are the driving forces for government and
health insurance payers to look for new means to contain
healthcare costs [3]. The use of OTC medication helps
(North) Americans save an average of $20 billion annually
in healthcare costs which include the costs of prescription
drugs, doctors’ visits, lost work time, insurance and travel
[4]. An individual may choose to see a doctor, consult a
community pharmacist, start taking a supplement, use
leftover drugs previously purchased or resort to comple-
mentary medicine (non-pharmacological therapies).
Although there are many options available, the key for any
individual embarking on self-medication is to recognize
symptoms, identify conditions suitable for self-medication,
choose the appropriate product, identify any adverse event
and follow the directions as indicated on the label.
It was recommended that self-medication should be
emphasized as a primary component in health care and
more health education programs should be designed to
educate communities on safer practices [7]. To date, there is
a shortage of information about self-medication pattern and
prevalence among consumers in Malaysia. With greater
availability of medicines, there is now a greater risk of
patients self-medicating without direct provider guidance.
Recognizing the prevalence of self-medication and factors
influencing self-medication among consumers will enable
pharmacists to identify the needs of the consumer as well as
to establish professional standards in terms of structured
training to support the needs of pharmacists. It might also
help to educate and improve awareness among consumers
to insure the quality and responsible use of medicines.
Aim of the study
To assess the prevalence of self-medication among adults
in an urban setting and to identify any consumer charac-
teristics that may contribute to self-medication.
Method
Study design and population
This study was a cross-sectional survey using a conve-
nience sampling method. The study was conducted in
Kuala Lumpur, the capital of Malaysia. A pilot-tested self-
administered questionnaire was distributed as an exit sur-
vey from a list of 26 pharmacies selected randomly in
Kuala Lumpur between January and May 2009. A sample
size of 384 participants was determined using the Raosoft
sample size calculator [8] for a population-based study.
Adults in Kuala Lumpur older than 21 who were able to
read and understand either English or Malay were included
in this study. At the end of the study period, 314 subjects
were included in the final analysis. A total of 70 partici-
pants were excluded after data collection because of
incomplete responses to the questionnaire.
Questionnaire development and data management
A questionnaire with two sections (Demographic and Self-
medication Assessment) was developed and used as a data
collection tool. In the demographic section, consumers
were asked to provide their ethnicity, age, gender,
employment, monthly income and level of education.
Section B contained 18 questions about their self-medica-
tion practices, the type and amount of medication used,
source of information, knowledge on adverse effects and
interactions, names and labels of medication and storage.
The questionnaire was based on previous studies and was
validated (face and content) among 20 participants whose
data were not included in this study. Data collection was
carried out by five data collectors in various zones in Kuala
Lumpur by distributing the questionnaire to customers of
selected pharmacies. The data collectors consisted of final-
year pharmacy students who were rigorously trained in
terms of the survey intention and how to contact the par-
ticipants and explore their responses.
Statistical analysis
Data analysis was done with the SPSS version 15.0 (the
software which is officially used at the University Sains
Malaysia). Chi Square test was used to test for associations
Int J Clin Pharm (2011) 33:794–799 795
123
between demographic data and self-medication assessment
questions. Significance was set at P \ 0.05.
Ethical issues
Participation in this survey was voluntary and the partici-
pants were asked to sign a consent form before completing
the survey. No findings which could identify individual
participants were published.
Results
Altogether, 384 adults responded to this study and 314
(81.7%) participants were included in the final analysis.
The socio-demographic characteristics of participants were
presented in Table 1. The majority of participants were
male 170 (54.1%), and 36.9% of patients were between the
ages of 30 and 39. Most were Chinese (144, 48.9%), and
married (181, 57.6%). With regard to educational level,
123 (39.2%) were degree holders and 149 (47.5%) worked
in the private sector and 84 (26.8%) earned more than
RM4000 (*1,150 USD). Out of the final sample, 197
(62.7%) stated that they had taken at least one medication
in the previous week at their own discretion without
prescription.
The analysis within the demographics of this population
showed that the age of the participants were associated
significantly (P \ 0.05) with self-medication in our sam-
ple, as all those above 60 years of age (13, 100%) and 36
(85.7%) participants between 50 and 59 years old were
found to self-medicate (Table 1). Of the total number of
participants, 163 (51.9%) were taking at least one medicine
daily, 143 (45.5%) were taking vitamins and 87 (27.7%)
consumed herbal or traditional supplements (Table 2). In
addition to that, 121 (38.5%) participants were suffering
from a medical condition that required regular medication.
Most participants obtained medication from either phar-
macies (n = 162, 51.6%) or clinics (n = 89, 28.3%).
The most common therapeutic groups of self-medicated
drugs were cough and cold preparations (n = 210, 66.9%)
followed by pain medication (n = 183, 57.6%), diarrhea
(n = 138, 43.9%), allergy and/or rashes (n = 111, 35.4%),
constipation (n = 105, 33.4%), weight loss (n = 84,
26.8%) and heartburn (n = 79, 25.2%). In this survey, 218
participants (69.4%) would consult healthcare profession-
als before purchasing any medication whereas 106 (33.8%)
would refer to a friend or family member. Only 29 (9.2%)
sourced information from the internet and 22 (7.0%) relied
on advertisements (Table 2). It was found that 273 (86.9%)
would consult a pharmacist before buying any medication
and 197 (62.7%) of the total participants believed that
Table 1 Demographic characteristics of participants and last week
self medication
Variable Total (%) Last week self medication
Yes; 197 (62.7%) No; 117 (37.3%)
Gender
Male 170 (54.1) 104 (61.2%) 66 (38.8%)
Female 144 (45.9) 93 (64.6%) 51 (35.4%)
Age groups
21–29 45 (14.3) 18 (40.0%) 27 (60.0%)
30–39 116 (36.9) 73 (62.9%) 43 (37.1%)
40–49 98 (31.2) 57 (58.2%) 41 (41.8%)
50–59 42 (13.4) 36 (85.7%) 6 (14.3%)
C60 13 (4.1) 13 (100.0%) 0 (0.0%)
Race
Malay 123 (39.2) 81 (65.9%) 42 (34.1%)
Chinese 144 (48.9) 88 (61.1%) 56 (38.9%)
Indian 29 (9.2) 18 (62.1%) 11 (37.9%)
Others 18 (5.7) 10 (55.6%) 8 (44.4%)
Marital status
Single 133 (42.4) 78 (58.6%) 55 (41.4%)
Married 181 (57.6) 119 (65.7%) 62 (34.3%)
No of children
None 150 (47.8) 10 (66.7%) 5 (33.3%)
1 15 (4.8) 36 (63.2%) 21 (36.8%)
2 57 (18.2) 41 (64.1%) 23 (35.9%)
3 64 (20.4) 19 (76.0%) 6 (24.0%)
4 25 (8.0) 2 (66.7%) 1 (33.3%)
5 3 (1.0) 89 (59.3%) 61 (40.7%)
Education
None 4 (1.3) 3 (75.0%) 1 (25.0%)
Primary 4 (1.3) 3 (75.0%) 1 (25.0%)
Secondary 93 (29.6) 64 (68.8%) 29 (31.2%)
Diploma 61 (19.4) 37 (60.7%) 24 (39.3%)
Degree 123 (39.2) 71 (57.7%) 52 (42.3%)
Masters/PhD 29 (9.2) 19 (65.5%) 10 (34.5%)
Employment
None 32 (10.2) 13 (40.6%) 19 (59.4%)
Government 56 (17.8) 37 (66.1%) 19 (33.9%)
Non government 149 (47.5) 95 (63.8%) 54 (36.2%)
Self-employed 60 (19.1) 39 (65.0%) 21 (35.0%)
Housewife 17 (5.4) 13 (76.5%) 4 (23.5%)
Monthly income (RM)
None 32 (10.2) 13 (40.6%) 19 (59.4%)
\1,000 14 (4.5) 9 (64.3%) 5 (35.7%)
1,000–1,999 43 (13.7) 27 (62.8%) 16 (37.2%)
2,000–2,999 72 (22.9) 47 (65.3%) 25 (34.7%)
3,000–3,999 69 (22.0) 43 (62.3%) 26 (37.7%)
C4,000 84 (26.8) 58 (69.0%) 26 (31.0%)
Health insurance
Yes 224 (71.3) 133 (59.4%) 91 (40.6%)
No 90 (28.7) 64 (71.1%) 26 (28.9%)
796 Int J Clin Pharm (2011) 33:794–799
123
over-the-counter medicines are as effective as those pre-
scribed by the doctor (Table 3).
Discussion
The results of this study showed self-medication practices
were prevalent in various age groups, gender, financial
status and education levels. Some 62.7% had taken medi-
cation in the previous week. This was low compared with a
study carried out in the United States [9] where 81% had
taken at least one medication in the preceding week and
those of Mitsi et al. [10], who reported a high use of non-
prescribed antibiotics (74.6%) in a Greek urban population.
The prevalence is higher, however, than that in other
studies conducted in Jordan (42.5%) by Yousef et al. [11]
and Suleman et al. [12] in Southwest Ethiopia (39.2%). The
findings from the basic analysis of self-medication related
data reflect the accessibility of medicines in Kuala Lumpur
where a pharmacy or a clinic can be found in every housing
area.
Interestingly, more than half of the participants
explained that pharmacies are their main source of self-
medication. Those who obtained medicines from the
pharmacy indicated that the high cost of doctors’ visits,
long waiting time at hospitals and the availability of
affordable drugs could have led to alternative ways to
source medication for their minor illnesses. This was
reflected in the WHO paper on self-medication [1] and a
study in Ethiopia by Suleman et al. [12]. The results were
comparable to other findings for types of medicines used
for self-medication. The participants’ responses with
regard to pharmacist consultation and effectiveness of OTC
medications were comparable to the results of a study
performed by the British Market Research Bureau [13]
which revealed findings of 86 and 67% respectively for
pharmacist consultation and effectiveness of OTC medi-
cation. This, however, is in contrast to a study conducted
Table 2 Self medication related data distribution
Question Yes No
1. Have you taken any medication in the
past week by your own decision?
197 (62.7) 117 (37.3)
2. Where do you obtain your medication from?
(a) Pharmacy 162 (51.6) 152 (48.4)
(b) Hospital 40 (12.7) 244 (77.7)
(c) Clinic 89 (28.3) 106 (33.8)
(d) Others 23 (7.3) 291 (92.7)
3. Do you take any vitamins? 143 (45.5) 171 (54.5)
4. Do you take any herbal/traditional
supplements?
87 (27.7) 227 (72.3)
5. How many types of medicine do you take in a day?
(1) None 75 (23.9)
(2) \2 163 (51.9)
(3) 2–5 51 (16.2)
(4) 5–10 23 (7.3)
(5) [10 2 (0.6)
6. Will you choose to buy your own medication for the following
conditions:
(a) Pain 183 (57.6) 133 (42.4)
(b) Cough/cold 210 (66.9) 104 (33.1)
(c) Allergy/rashes 111 (35.4) 203 (64.6)
(d) Heartburn 79 (25.2) 235 (74.5)
(e) Diarrhea 138 (43.9) 176 (56.1)
(f) Constipation 105 (33.4) 209 (66.6)
(g) Weight loss 84 (26.8) 230 (73.2)
7. Do you suffer from any medical
conditions (i.e. diabetes, high bloodpressure, asthma etc.) that require regular
medication?
121 (38.5) 193 (61.5)
8. Where do you source information before purchasing any
medication?
(1) Healthcare professional 218 (69.4) 96 (30.6)
(2) Friend/family member 106 (33.8) 208 (66.2)
(3) Internet 29 (9.2) 285 (90.8)
(4) Advertisement 22 (7.0) 292 (93.0)
Table 3 Answers to questions on awareness of adverse drug reactions, drug interactions and self-medication practices
Questions Yes n (%) No n (%)
Do you believe that over-the-counter medicines are as effective as those prescribed by the doctor? 197 (62.7) 117 (37.3)
Would you consult a pharmacist before buying any medication from the pharmacy? 273 (86.9) 41 (13.1)
Are you aware that certain medication/supplement may cause an adverse drug reaction? 278 (88.5) 36 (11.5)
Are you aware that certain medication/supplement can interact with food or other medication? 61 (19.4) 253 (80.6)
Do you inform your doctor/pharmacist you are taking other medications/supplements? 188 (59.9) 126 (40.1)
Do you read the label that comes with your medication? 282 (89.8) 32 (10.2)
Do you know the name of your medications? 248 (79.0) 66 (21.0)
Do you check the expiry date on your medications before and after purchasing? 270 (86.0) 44 (14.0)
Do you carry your medications with you regularly? 138 (43.9) 176 (56.1)
Do you keep leftover medication? 171 (54.5) 143 (45.5)
Int J Clin Pharm (2011) 33:794–799 797
123
by Chui et al. [14] that showed that more than half of the
participants never consulted a pharmacist on how to man-
age minor ailments.
In general, factors influencing decisions for self-medi-
cation include one’s past experience and social knowledge;
real or perceived symptom states; advertising and promo-
tion; and the lay referral network [6]. The overall sources
of information show that self-medication practices among
adults in this survey are not influenced by advertisements
or the internet but could probably be attributed to past
experience of using medication or interaction with a doctor
or pharmacist.
Among the respondents surveyed in this study, 88.5%
were aware of adverse drug reactions (ADR). This per-
centage is much higher than that reported in other coun-
tries. Suleman et al. [12] revealed findings that more than
80% of their participants had no idea of the potentially
dangerous effects of medicines without the advice of health
professionals.
The high community awareness of ADR could be har-
nessed as a potential source of pharmaco-vigilance moni-
toring in the country. In Malaysia, adverse drug reactions
are reported to the National Pharmaceutical Control
Bureau, where a committee, namely the Malaysian
Adverse Drug Reaction Committee appointed by the Drug
Control Authority monitors the safety profiles of drugs
registered in Malaysia [15]. Awareness that certain medi-
cations or supplements can interact with food or other
medication was low, however (19.4%). Potential risks
arose because a considerable proportion of participants
were also taking vitamins and herbal supplements. A study
by Indermitte et al. [16] in Basel, Switzerland demon-
strated that of 1,183 customers, 116 (26.7%) regular cus-
tomers were exposed to potential drug interactions within
their prescribed drugs and in 28 (6.5%) multiple (C2)
potential drug interactions were found. Lack of awareness
of drug interaction could pose health hazards in terms of
adverse reactions and prolonged suffering owing to unin-
tended or unrecognized interaction, as described by
Kaufman et al. [9]. Hence, appropriate self-medication or
informed decisions of consumers to self medicate is
crucial.
The health authorities of Malaysia have carried out
nationwide campaigns to educate the public on knowing
their medications. Results revealed that a high percentage
of participants read their medication labels (282, 89.8%)
and 248 (79%) knew the name of their medications.
Awareness of brand names and generic names, however,
was not assessed in this survey. A salient finding in this
study is that 270 (86%) of respondents checked expiry
dates on medications before and after purchase, 138
(43.9%) carried them regularly and, surprisingly, a large
number admitted to keeping leftover medication (171,
54.5%). Most of these respondents had a tertiary education
background. Responses to these statements may reflect
self-medication practices as consumers could reuse the
medication for future conditions. This is similar to a find-
ing by Abosede [7], which showed that more literates kept
and used leftover drugs. Among the issues of concern with
regard to this practice are deterioration of the quality of
drugs, resistance of antimicrobials and treatment failures.
These issues could be addressed by pharmacists through
implementation of pharmaceutical care in community
pharmacies to alleviate the problem [12].
Limitations
This study had several limitations that may affect its gen-
eralization. Convenience sampling and self-reported
information do not rule out selection bias, the possibility of
socially desirable responses, and probable variation in data
collection, and hence may not reflect the actual behavior
and/or practice of adults. Future studies may reveal dif-
ferent prevalences in other urban or rural settings. A sound
comparison with other studies was difficult owing to the
unique characteristics of each population, different
healthcare systems, methodologies used and small sample
size.
Conclusions
Overall, the practice of self-medication is prevalent in
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia and could be observed at various
socio-demographic levels of the community. The study
revealed that 62.7% of participants believed that OTC
medicines were just as effective as those prescribed by the
doctor and 69.4% would seek a healthcare professional’s
advice before purchasing any medication. Lack of aware-
ness about the interaction of medications or supplements
with other food or medication was identified. Although a
large number of adults from a tertiary background knew the
name of the medications taken, read the labels and
informed the doctor and/or pharmacist that they were tak-
ing other medications or supplements, education on the
appropriate use of medication should still be emphasized at
all levels.
Acknowledgments The authors wish to thank all the participants
who provided their valuable responses in answering to the
questionnaire.
Funding None.
Conflicts of interest None.
798 Int J Clin Pharm (2011) 33:794–799
123
References
1. WHO. The role of pharmacist in self-care and self-medication.
Report of the 4th WHO Consultative Group on the role of
pharmacist. The Hague, The Netherlands, 26–28 August 1998.
WHO/Dap/98.13. World Health Organization, Geneva 1998.
2. World Self-Medication Industry. Available at http://www.wsmi.
org/pdf/storyofselfcare_bdpage.pdf. Accessed 10 Feb 2011.
3. Wertheimer A, Seradell J. A discussion paper on self care and its
implications for pharmacists. Pharm World Sci. 2008;30:309–15.
4. Pawaskar MD, Balkrishnan R. Switching from prescription to
over-the-counter medications; a consumer and managed care
perspective. Manag Care Interface. 2007;20(1):42–7.
5. Working group on drug classification: definition and criteria to
apply to OTC drugs. Pan American Health Organization, regional
office of the World Health Organisation. Available at http://
www.paho.org/english/ad/ths/ev/CM-Definitionandcriteriafor
OTC.pdf. Accessed 10 Feb 2011.
6. Bradley C, Blenkinsopp A. Over the counter drugs: the future for
self medication. BMJ. 1996;312:835–7.
7. Abosede OA. Self-medication: an important aspect of primary
health care. Soc Sci Med. 1984;19:699–703.
8. Sample Size Calculator by Raosoft, Inc. Availabe at http://www.
raosoft.com/samplesize.html.
9. Kaufman DW, Kelly JP, Rosenberg L, Anderson TE, Mitchell
AA. Recent patterns of medication use in the ambulatory adult
population of the United States. The slone survey. J Am Med
Assoc. 2002; 287: 337–44.
10. Mitsi G, Jelastopulu E, Basiaris H, Skoutelis A, Gogos C.
Patterns of antibiotic use among adults and parents in the com-
munity: a questionnaire-based survey in a Greek urban popula-
tion. Int J Antimicrob Agents. 2005;25:439–43.
11. Yousef AM, Al-Bakri AG, Bustanji Y, Wazaify M. Self-medi-
cation patterns in Amman, Jordan. Pharm World Sci. 2008;30:
24–30.
12. Suleman S, Katsela A, Mekonnen Z. Assessment of self-medi-
cation practices in Assendabo town, Jimma zone, southwestern
Ethiopia. Res Social Adm Pharm. 2009;5:76–81.
13. British Market Research Bureau (BRMB). Everyday health care
study of self-medication in Britain October 1997.
14. Chui WK, Li SC. Advice-giving on self-medication: perspectives
of community pharmacists and consumers in Singapore. J Clin
Pharm Ther. 2005;30:225–31.
15. Ministry of Health Malaysia: National Pharmaceutical Control
Bureau, Ministry of Health Malaysia. [www.bpfk.gov.my].
16. Indermitte J, Reber D, Beutler M, Bruppacher R, Hersberger KE.
Prevalence and patient awareness of selected potential drug
interactions with self-medication. J Clin Pharm Ther. 2007;32:
149–59.
Int J Clin Pharm (2011) 33:794–799 799
123