Researching Defiance: Norm Violations and the Regime Dynamics (ISA New Orleans 2015)

18
Researching Defiance Norm Violations and the Regime Dynamics Michal Smetana Institute of Political Studies Charles University in Prague ISA Annual Convention 2015 New Orleans, USA

Transcript of Researching Defiance: Norm Violations and the Regime Dynamics (ISA New Orleans 2015)

Researching Defiance Norm Violations and the Regime Dynamics

Michal Smetana

Institute of Political Studies

Charles University in Prague

ISA Annual Convention 2015

New Orleans, USA

NPT

violation of the regime norms

strictly negative effect on the regime

health

violation of the regime norms

strictly negative effect on the regime

health

?

research framework

norm violation act

regime change

?

international regime

three-level normative structure

metanorms

principles

norms

international regime

three-level normative structure

metanorms

principles

norms

sources of regime change

dynamic nature of social norms

norm 1

(a)

norm 1

(b)

norm 1

(c) ...

norm violation act

norm change

actors' (re)actions

trigger event / "window of opportunity"

principle

change

actors' (re)actions

initial "verbal" response

(non) sanctioning

social reconstruction

individual (non)compliance

inter-norm dynamics within the regime

norm (2) change

norm (3) change

norm (1) change

principles

metanorms

norm (2) change

norm (3) change

norm (1) change

principles

metanorms legitimacy

research framework (refined)

norm violation act actors' (re)actions

metanorms

principles

norms

legitimacy

Change

Change

Change

regime change

change

case study

norm-violating practices by Iran & DPRK (2005-2015)

nuclear nonproliferation regime change?

?

nuclear nonproliferation regime

NPT explicit

nonproliferation

peaceful use

disarmament

NPT implicit

non-testing

non-use

nsa

proliferation pessimism

unacceptability of nuclear war

civilian applications

verification and safeguards

universality

unequal status

transformatory nature

right to withdraw

distributive justice

procedural justice

sovereignty

community

hiearchy

metanorms

principles

norms

preliminary findings

peaceful use

disarmament nonproliferation

distributive justice (equity) conflicts

legitimacy

norm-violating practices by Iran & DPRK (2005-2015)

The END

Email: [email protected]

Web: http://cuni.academia.edu/MichalSmetana