PERSPE TE Volume XII No. 3 Tahun 2007 Edisi September
-
Upload
khangminh22 -
Category
Documents
-
view
1 -
download
0
Transcript of PERSPE TE Volume XII No. 3 Tahun 2007 Edisi September
'HZDVD�LQL�SHUGHEDWDQ�PHQJHQDL�
NHVHLPEDQJDQ� GDQ� NHWLGDNVHLPEDQJDQ�
EHUNRQWUDN�� NKXVXVQ\D� DSDELOD� WHUNDLW�
GHQJDQ�NRQWUDN�NRQWUDN�ELVQLV�NRPHUVLDO��
WDPSDNQ\D� VXGDK� ZDNWXQ\D� XQWXN�
GLWLQJJDONDQ�� %XNDQ� EHUPDNVXG� DSULRUL��
QDPXQ�GHPLNLDQ�SHUELQFDQJDQ�PHQJHQDL�
SRVLVL� SDUD� NRQWUDNWDQ� GDODP� SHUVSHNWLI�
NRQWUDN�NRQWUDN� ELVQLV� NRPHUVLDO� VH�
\RJ\DQ\D� SHUOX� VHFDUD� MHUQLK� GLNDML�
EHUVDPD�� WHUXWDPD� SDGD� VWUXNWXU�
EDQJXQDQ� D]DV�D]DVQ\D�� 8QWXN� LWX�
SHQX O L V � EHUPDNVXG� PHQJD MXNDQ�
DUJXPHQWDVL� EDUX� GL� ELGDQJ� KXNXP�
NRQWUDN�� GHQJDQ� VDWX� DVDV� \DLWX� WXUXW�
PHUDPDLNDQ� GDQ� PHQJHPEDQJNDQ�
NKDVDQDK� NHLOPXDQ� KXNXP�� NKXVXVQ\D�
WHUNDLW� GHQJDQ� NRQVHS� SHUNHPEDQJDQ�
KXNXP�NRQWUDN�NH�PDVD�GHSDQ�
7XOLVDQ� LQL� EHUPDNVXG� PHQJDMDN�
SDUD� SHPEDFD� EXGLPDQ� XQWXN� EHU�
NRQWHPSODVL�PHQJHQDL�KDNLNDW�KXEXQJDQ�
NRQWUDNWXDO� \DQJ� GLKDUDSNDQ�� GLEDQJXQ�
GDQ�GLODNVDQDNDQ�SDUD�SLKDN��WHUXWDPD�GL�
GXQLD� � ELVQLV�� 'DODP� ELVQLV�� SHUWXNDUDQ�
NHSHQWLQJDQ� SDUD� SLKDN� VHQDQWLDVD�
GLWXDQJNDQ� GDODP� EHQWXN� NRQWUDN�
PHQJLQJDW� ³6HWLDS� ODQJNDK�ELVQLV�DGDODK�
ODQJNDK�KXNXP� �L�F��NRQWUDN�´��8QJNDSDQ�
LQL�PHUXSDNDQ�ODQGDVDQ�XWDPD�\DQJ�KDUXV�
$=$6�3523256,21$/,7$6�
6(%$*$,�3(5:8-8'$1�'2.75,1�.($',/$1�%(5.2175$.
2OHK��
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
�H�PDLO��3HUVSHNWLIBNHDGLODQ#\DKRR�FRP�
�'RVHQ�)DNXOWDV�+XNXP�81$,5-/��'KDUPDZDQJVD�'DODP�6HODWDQ�6XUDED\D
$%675$&7
7KH�REMHFWLYH�RI� WKLV� DUWLFOH� LV� WR�DUJXH� WKDW� WKH� LVVXH�RI� HTXDO� DQG�XQHTXDO�SRVLWLRQ�RI�WKH�SDUWLHV�LV�LUUHOHYDQW�WR�FRPPHUFLDO�FRQWUDFW��7KH�HVVHQFH�RI�FRPPHUFLDO�FRQWUDFW�WKDW�SRQGHUV�EXVLQHVV�UHODWLRQVKLS�ZLWKRXW�LQWHUUXSWLRQ�GRHV�QRW�GHDO�ZLWK�WKH�LVVXH� RI� PDWKHPDWLFDO� HTXDOLW\�� UDWKHU�� LW� HPSKDVL]HV� RQ� SURSRUWLRQDO� H[FKDQJH� RI�LQWHUHVWV�RI�WKH�SDUWLHV�LUUHVSHFWLYH�RI�UHVXOW�REWDLQHG�E\�WKH�SDUWLHV�7KHUH�DUH�WKUHH�LPSRUWDQW�WKLQJV�LQ�WKLV�SDSHU�IRXQG��)LUVW��WKH�SULQFLSOH�RI�SURSRUWLRQDOLW\�LV�DSSOLHG�LQ�WKH�HQWLUH�SKDVHV�RI�FRQWUDFW��L�H��LQ�QHJRWLDWLRQ��IRUPDWLRQ��DQG�HQIRUFHPHQW�SKDVHV��6HFRQG�� WKH�SULQFLSOH�RI�SURSRUWLRQDOLW\� LV�QRW�SHUFHLYHG� IURP�PDWKHPDWLFDO�HTXDOLW\� SHUVSHFWLYH� EXW� LW� LV� YLHZHG� IURP� IDLU� H[FKDQJH�SURFHVV� DQG�SURSRUWLRQDWH�UHVXOW��ZKLFK�LV�DFFHSWDEOH�E\�ERWK�SDUWLHV��7KLUG��WKH�SULQFLSOH�RI�SURSRUWLRQDOLW\�LV�D�GRFWULQH�RI�³IDLU�FRQWUDFW´��ZKLFK�LPSURYHV�WKH�GRFWULQH�RI�IUHHGRP�RI�FRQWUDFW�WKDW�PD\�OHDG�WR�XQIDLUQHVV��,W�LV�UHFRPPHQGHG�LQ�WKLV�GLVVHUWDWLRQ�WKDW�MXULVWV��FXUUHQWO\��EH�QRW�UHJDUG� WKH� GRFWULQH� RI� IUHHGRP� RI� FRQWUDFW� VDFUHG�� UDWKHU�� WKH\� VKDOO� ILQG� RWKHU�SKLORVRSKLFDO�EDVLV�WR�GHYHORS�³IDLU�FRQWUDFW´�SURFHGXUDOO\�DV�ZHOO�DV�VXEVWDQWLYHO\��
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
GLSHUKDWLNDQ�SDUD�SLKDN�\DQJ�EHULQWHUDNVL�
GDODP� GXQLD� ELVQLV�� GLPDQD� NRQWUDN�
PHUXSDNDQ � V LPSX O � X WDPD� \DQJ �
PHQJKXEXQJNDQ� NHSHQWLQJDQ� PHUHND��
0HVNLSXQ� PHUHND� DFDSNDOL � W LGDN�
PHQ\DGDULQ\D�� QDPXQ� SHUOX� GLLQJDW�
EDKZD� VHWLDS� SLKDN� \DQJ� PHPDVXNL�
EHODQWDUD� ELVQLV� SDGD� GDVDUQ\D�
PHODNXNDQ� ODQJNDK�ODQJNDK� KXNXP�
GHQJDQ�VHJDOD�NRQVHNXHQVLQ\D��
7HQWXQ\D� ELVQLV� \DQJ� EHUDGDE�
VHQDQWLDVD� PHQJDFX� SDGD� QLODL�QLODL�
PRUDO�HWLV�GDODP�ELQJNDL�KXNXP��NRQWUDN���
+XEXQJDQ� ELVQLV� \DQJ� WHUMDOLQ� GL� DQWDUD�
SDUD� SLKDN� SDGD� XPXPQ\D� NDUHQD�
PHUHND� EHUWXMXDQ� VDOLQJ� EHUWXNDU�
NHSHQWLQJDQ�� -�� YDQ� � .DQ� GDQ� -�+��
%HHNKXLV� PHQ\DWDNDQ� EDKZD� VHPXD�
MDQML�MDQML� DQWDUD� SDUD� SLKDN� VHQDQWLDVD�
WHUNDLW�GHQJDQ�NHSHQWLQJDQ�NHSHQWLQJDQ��
WHUXWDPD�WHUNDLW�KDUWD�EHQGD��-��YDQ� �.DQ�
GDQ� -�+�� %HHNKXLV�� ������ ����� 5RVFRH�
3RXQG� PHPEHULNDQ� GHILQLVL� ³NHSHQWLQJ�
DQ´� DWDX� ³LQWHUHVW´�DGDODK� ³D� GHPDQG�RU�
GHVLUH� ZKLFK� KXPDQ� EHLQJV�� HLWKHU�
LQGLYLGXDOO\� RU� WKURXJK� JURXSV� RU�
DVVRFLDWLRQV�LQ�UHODWLRQV�VHHN�WR�VDWLVI\´��
.HUDQJND� GDVDU� \DQJ� GLJXQDNDQ� 3RXQG�
DGDODK� NHSHQWLQJDQ�NHSHQWLQJDQ� VRVLDO�
\DQJ� OHELK� OXDV� GDQ� \DQJ� PHUXSDNDQ�
NHLQJLQDQ�PDQXVLD�XQWXN�PHPHQXKLQ\D��
EDLN� VHFDUD� SULEDGL�� KXEXQJDQ� DQWDU�
SULEDGL�PDXSXQ�NHORPSRN��$WDV�GDVDU�LWX�
3RXQG� PHPEHGDNDQ� EHUEDJDL� NH�
SHQWLQJDQ� \DQJ� KDUXV� GLOLQGXQJL� ROHK�
KXNXP�� \DLWX� NHSHQWLQJDQ� SULEDGL��
NHSHQWLQJDQ� XPXP�� GDQ� NHSHQWLQJDQ�
VRVLDO�DWDX�PDV\DUDNDW���GDODP�-RKDQQHV�
,EUDKLP��/LQGDZDW\�6HZX���������������
6HULQJNDOL� WHUMDGL� NHVDODKDQ�
SHUVHSVL� EHUEDJDL� NDODQJDQ� PHQJHQDL�
HNVLVWHQVL� NRQWUDN�� NKXVXVQ\D� PHQJHQDL�
SHUWDQ\DDQ�� DSDNDK� VXDWX� NRQWUDN� LWX�
VHLPEDQJ� DWDX� WLGDN� VHLPEDQJ� �EHUDW�
VHEHODK��� %DQ\DN� SLKDN� GHQJDQ� PXGDK�
WHUMHEDN�XQWXN�PHQ\DWDNDQ�VXDWX�NRQWUDN�
LWX� EHUDW� VHEHODK� DWDX� WLGDN� VHLPEDQJ��
KDQ\D� VHNHGDU� PHQGDVDUNDQ� SDGD�
SHUEHGDDQ� VWDWXV� PDVLQJ�PDVLQJ� SLKDN�
\DQJ� EHUNRQWUDN�� 0LVDOQ\D� GHQJDQ�
VHNHGDU� PHPSHUKDWLNDQ� SHUEHGDDQ� ODWDU�
EHODNDQJ� SDUD� SLKDN� \DQJ� EHUNRQWUDN�
�%DUDW� �� 7LPXU�� DVLQJ� �� GRPHVWLN�� EDQN� ��
QDVDEDK�� SURGXVHQ� �� NRQVXPHQ���
NHPXGLDQ� VHFDUD� VXPLU� PHQ\DWDNDQ�
NRQWUDN� WHUVHEXW� EHUDW� VHEHODK� GHQJDQ�
DVXPVL�WHUGDSDW�EDUJDLQLQJ�SRVLWLRQ�\DQJ�
EHUEHGD�� 3DQGDQJDQ� WHUVHEXW� WLGDN�
VHOXUXKQ\D�VDODK��EDKNDQ�GDODP�EHEHUDSD�
KDO� KDUXV� GLDNXL� EDKZD� GDODP� VXDWX�
NRQWUDN� VHU LQJ� WHUGDSDW � NHW LGDN�
VHLPEDQJDQ� GDQ� NHWLGDNDGLODQ�PDQDNDOD�
WHUGDSDW�EDUJDLQLQJ�SRVLWLRQ�\DQJ�EHUEHGD��
NKXVXVQ\D�DSDELOD�WHUNDLW�GHQJDQ�NRQWUDN�
NRQVXPHQ��1DPXQ�GHPLNLDQ��NLUDQ\D�DNDQ�
OHELK� IDLU� GDQ� RE\HNWLI� DSDELOD� PHQLODL�
NHEHUDGDDQ� VXDWX� NRQWUDN� WHUXWDPD�
GHQJDQ�PHQ�FHUPDWL� VXEVWDQVLQ\D�� VHUWD�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
NDWHJRUL�NRQWUDN�\DQJ�EHUVDQJNXWDQ�
� 3HUGHEDWDQ� PHQJHQDL� DGD� DWDX�
WLGDNQ\D�NHVHLPEDQJDQ�SRVLVL�SDUD�SLKDN�
SDGD� GDVDUQ\D� NXUDQJ� UHOHYDQ� XQWXN�
GLNDLWNDQ� GHQJDQ� NRQWUDN� ELVQLV��
NKXVXVQ\D� NRQWUDN� NRPHUVLDO�� 'LPHQVL�
NRQWUDN�NRPHUVLDO�\DQJ�OHELK�PHQHNDQNDQ�
SDGD�DVSHN�NHPLWUDDQ�GDQ�NHODQJVXQJDQ�
ELVQLV��HIILFLHQF\�DQG�SURILW�RULHQWHG���WLGDN�
ODJL� EHUNXWDW� SDGD� NHVHLPEDQJDQ�
PDWHPDWLV��WHWDSL�MXVWUX�OHELK�PHQHNDQNDQ�
SDGD�SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�KDN�GDQ�NHZDMLEDQ�
GL� DQWDUD� SHODNX�SHODNXQ\D�� 'HQJDQ�
GLWHULPDQ\D� SULQVLS�SULQVLS� XQLYHUVDO�
VHSHUWL�LWLNDG�EDLN�GDQ�WUDQVDNVL�\DQJ�DGLO�
DWDX� MXMXU� �JRRG� IDLWK� DQG� IDLU� GHDOLQJ��
UHGHOLMNKHLG� HQ� ELOOLMNKHLG�� NHSDWXWDQ� GDQ�
NHDGLODQ�� GDODP� SUDNWLN� ELVQLV�� PHP�
EXNWLNDQ�EDKZD�\DQJ�GLXWDPDNDQ�DGDODK�
PHPEHULNDQ� MDPLQDQ� EDKZD� SHUEHGDDQ�
NHSHQWLQJDQ� GL� DQWDUD� SDUD� SLKDN� WHODK�
GLDWXU� PHODOXL� PHNDQLVPH� SHPEDJLDQ�
EHEDQ� NHZDMLEDQ� VHFDUD� SURSRUVLRQDO��
WHUOHSDV�EHUDSD�SURSRUVL�KDVLO�DNKLU�\DQJ�
GLWHULPD�SDUD�SLKDN��
3UREOHPDWLND� GL� DWDV� WHQWXQ\D�
PHUXSDNDQ� WDQWDQJDQ� EDJL� SDUD� \XULV�
XQWXN� PHPEHULNDQ� MDODQ� NHOXDU� WHUEDLN�
GHPL� WHUZXMXGQ\D� NRQWUDN� \DQJ� VDOLQJ�
PHQJXQWXQJNDQ� SDUD� SLKDN� �ZLQ�ZLQ�
VROXWLRQ�FRQWUDFW���GL�VDWX�VLVL�PHPEHULNDQ�
NHSDVWLDQ� KXNXP� GDQ� GL� VLVL� ODLQ�
PHPEHULNDQ�NHDGLODQ��
0HVNLSXQ� GLVDGDUL� XQWXN� PHP�
DGXNDQ� NHSDVWLDQ� KXNXP� GDQ� NHDGLODQ��
NRQRQ� PHUXSDNDQ� SHUEXDWDQ� \DQJ�
PXVWDKLO�� QDPXQ� PHODOXL� LQVWUXPHQ�
NRQWUDN�\DQJ�PDPSX�PHQJDNRPRGLU�SHU�
EHGDDQ�NHSHQWLQJDQ�VHFDUD�SURSRUVLRQDO��
PDND�GLOHPD�SHUWHQWDQJDQ�´VHPX´�DQWDUD�
NHSDVWLDQ� KXNXP� GDQ� NHDGLODQ� WHUVHEXW�
DNDQ� GDSDW� GLHOLPLQLU�� %DKNDQ� DNDQ�
PHQMDGL� VXDWX� NHQLVFD\DDQ� WHUZXMXGQ\D�
NRQWUDN�\DQJ�VDOLQJ�PHQJXQWXQJNDQ�SDUD�
SLKDN��ZLQ�ZLQ�FRQWUDFW���
7HQWXQ\D� XQWXN� PHQJDQDOLVLV�
VHFDUD�OHELK�FHUPDW�PHQJHQDL�VHOXN�EHOXN�
KXEXQJDQ�SDUD�SLKDN�GDODP�NRQWUDN�ELVQLV�
GLSHUOXNDQ� VXDWX� PHWRGH� SHQJXMLDQ�
WHUKDGDS� HNVLVWHQVL� VXDWX� NRQWUDN��
.HWHUSDGXDQ� D]DV�D]DV� KXNXP� NRQWUDN��
WHUPDVXN� GL� GDODPQ\D� D]DV� SURSRUVLR�
QDOLWDV�� PHUXSDNDQ� SLVDX� DQDOLVLV� XQWXN�
PHPEHGDK�HNVLVWHQVL�NRQWUDN�\DQJ�GLEXDW�
SDUD� SLKDN�� 7HQWXQ\D� VXGDK� EXNDQ�
ZDNWXQ\D�ODJL�XQWXN�EHUNXWDW�SDGD�GLOHPD�
VHPX� NHWLGDNVHLPEDQJDQ� DWDX� NHWLGDN�
DGLODQ� EHUNRQWUDN�� WHWDSL� VH\RJ\D�Q\D�
OHELK� GLIRNXVNDQ� SDGD� EDJDLPDQD�
SHUEHGDDQ�NHSHQWLQJDQ�SDUD�SLKDN�GDSDW�
G L D WX U � VHGHPLN LDQ � UXSD � VHFD UD �
SURSRUVLRQDO�
%HUGDVDUNDQ�XUDLDQ�ODWDU�EHODNDQJ�
PDVDODK� WHUVHEXW� GL� DWDV�� PDND� GDODP�
SHQHOLWLDQ� LQL� WHUGDSDW� LVX� VHQWUDO�� \DLWX��
³D]DV� 3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV� 6HEDJDL� 6HEDJDL�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN´
+DNLNDW�.HDGLODQ�'DODP�.RQWUDN
3HPEDKDVDQ� WHQWDQJ� KXEXQJDQ�
NRQWUDNWXDO� SDUD� SLKDN� SDGD� KDNLNDWQ\D�
WLGDN�GDSDW�GLOHSDVNDQ�GDODP�KXEXQJDQ�
Q\D� GHQJDQ� PDVDODK� NHDGLODQ�� .RQWUDN�
VHEDJDL� ZDGDK� \DQJ� PHP�SHUWHPXNDQ�
NHSHQWLQJDQ�VDWX�SLKDN�GHQJDQ�SLKDN�ODLQ�
PHQXQWXW�EHQWXN�SHUWXNDUDQ�NHSHQWLQJDQ�
\DQJ�DGLO��2OHK�NDUHQD�LWX�VDQJDW�WHSDW�GDQ�
PHQGDVDU� DSDELOD� GDODP� PHODNXNDQ�
DQDOLVLV�KXEXQJDQ�NRQWUDNWXDO�SDUD�SLKDN�
MXVWUX�GLPXODL�GDUL�DVSHN�ILORVRILV�NHDGLODQ�
EHUNRQWUDN� VHEDJDLPDQD� \DQJ� GL�
NHPXNDNDQ�SDUD�DKOL�
3HUWDQ\DDQ� VHSXWDU� DSD� LWX�
´NHDGLODQ´� DGDODK� VHEXDK� SHUWDQ\DDQ�
\DQJ� DFDSNDOL� NLWD� GHQJDU�� QDPXQ�
SHPDKDPDQ� \DQJ� WHSDW� MXVWUX� UXPLW�
EDKNDQ�DEVWUDN��WHUOHELK�DSDELOD�GLNDLWNDQ�
GHQJDQ� SHOEDJDL� NHSHQWLQJDQ� \DQJ�
GHPLNLDQ�NRPSOHNV��-DPHV�3HQQHU�HW��DO���
������������.HDGLODQ�PHQXUXW�$ULVWRWHOHV��
GDODP�NDU\DQ\D�³1LFKRPD�FKHDQ�HWKLFV´��
DUWLQ\D� EHUEXDW� NHEDMLNDQ�� DWDX� GHQJDQ�
NDWD�ODLQ��NHDGLODQ�DGDODK�NHEDMLNDQ�\DQJ�
XWDPD�
0HQXUXW� $ULVWRWHOHV�� ´ MXVWLFH�
FRQVLVWV� LQ� WUHDWLQJ� HTXDOV� HTXDOO\� DQG�
XQHTXDOV�XQHTXDOO\�� LQ�SURSRUWLRQ�WR�WKHLU�
LQHTXDOLW\�´�3ULQVLS�LQL�EHUDQMDN�GDUL�DVXPVL�
´XQWXN� KDO�KDO� \DQJ� VDPD� GLSHUODNXNDQ�
VHFDUD�VDPD��GDQ�\DQJ� WLGDN�VDPD� MXJD�
GLSHUODNXNDQ� W LGDN� VDPD�� VHFDUD�
SURSRUVLRQDO´� �5D\PRQG� :DFNV�� ������
�����
8 O S L DQXV � PHQJJDPED U NDQ �
NHDGLODQ�VHEDJDL�³MXVWLWLD�HVW�FRQVWDQV�HW�
SHUSHWXD� YROXQWDV� LXV� VXXP� FXLTXH�
WULEXHQGL´��NHDGLODQ�DGDODK�NHKHQGDN�\DQJ�
WHUXV� PHQHUXV� GDQ� WHWDS� PHPEHULNDQ�
NHSDGD�PDVLQJ�PDVLQJ�DSD�\DQJ�PHQMDGL�
KDNQ\D��DWDX�³WULEXHUH�FXLTXH�VXXP´���³WR�
JLYH� HYHU\ERG\� KLV� RZQ´�� PHPEHULNDQ�
NHSDGD�VHWLDS�RUDQJ�\DQJ�PHQMDGL�KDNQ\D�
�GDODP� 2�� 1RWRKDPLGMRMR�� ������ ����
3HUXPXVDQ� LQL� GHQJDQ� WHJDV� PHQJDNXL�
KDN� PDVLQJ�PDVLQJ� SHUVRQ� WHUKDGDS�
ODLQQ\D� VHUWD� DSD� \DQJ� VHKDUXVQ\D�
PHQMDGL� EDJLDQQ\D�� GHPLNLDQ� SXOD�
VHEDOLNQ\D��3HQJHUWLDQ�LQL�GLDPELO�DOLK�ROHK�
-XVWLQLDQXV� GDODP� &RUSXV� ,XULV� &LYLOLV��
-XULV�SUDHFHSWD�VXQW�KDHF��KRQHVWH�YLYHUH��
DOWHUXP� QRQ� ODHGHUH�� VXXP� FXLTXH�
WULEXHUH�� EDKZD� SHUDWXUDQ�SHUDWXUDQ�
GDVDU� GDUL� KXNXP� DGDODK� WHUNDLW� GHQJDQ�
KLGXS�GHQJDQ�SDWXW��WDN�PHUXJLNDQ�RUDQJ�
ODLQ� GDQ� PHPEHUL� SDGD� RUDQJ� ODLQ� DSD�
\DQJ� PHQMDGL� EDJLDQQ\D� �GDODP� .��
%HUWHQV���������������
7 K RPD V � $ T X L Q D V � � G D O DP �
KXEXQJDQQ\D� GHQJDQ� NHDGLODQ� PHQJ�
DMXNDQ� W LJD� VWUXNWXU� IXQGDPHQWDO�
�KXEXQJDQ�GDVDU���\DLWX�� �KXEXQJDQ�DQWDU�
LQGLYLGX� �RUGR� SDUWLXP� DG� SDUWHV���
KXEXQJDQ� DQWDU� PDV\DUDNDW� VHEDJDL�
NHVHOXUXKDQ�GHQJDQ� LQGLYLGX��RUGR�WRWLXV�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
DG�SDUWHV���GDQ�KXEXQJDQ�DQWDUD�LQGLYLGX�
WHUKDGDS�PDV\DUDNDW�VHFDUD�NHVHOXUXKDQ�
�RUGR� SDUWLXP� DG� WRWXP��� �GDODP� (��
6XPDU\RQR�,������������
0HQXUXW�7KRPDV�$TXLQDV�NHDGLODQ�
GLVWULEXWLI� SDGD� GDVDUQ\D� PHUXSDNDQ�
SHQJKRUPDWDQ� WHUKDGDS�SHUVRQ�PDQXVLD�
�DFFHSWLR�SHUVRQDUXP��GDQ�NHOXKXUDQQ\D�
�GLJQLWDV��� 'DODP� NRQWHNV� NHDGLODQ�
GLVWULEXWLI��NHDGLODQ�GDQ�NHSDWXWDQ��HTXLW\��
WLGDN� WHUFDSDL� VHPDWD�PDWD� GHQJDQ�
SHQHWDSDQ� QLODL� \DQJ� DNWXDO�� PHODLQNDQ�
MXJD�DWDV�GDVDU�NHVDPDDQ�DQWDUD�VDWX�KDO�
GHQJDQ�KDO�\DQJ�ODLQQ\D��DHTXDOLWDV�UHL�DG�
UHP��� $GD� GXD� EHQWXN� NHVDPDDQ� \DLWX��
NHVDPDDQ� SURSRUVLRQDO� �DFTXDOLWDV�
SURSRUWLRQLV��� GDQ� � NHVDPDDQ� NXDQWLWDV�
DWDX�MXPODK��DFTXDOLWDV�TXDQWLWDV����GDODP�
(��6XPDU\RQR�,,��������������
7KRPDV� $TXLQDV� PHQ\DWDNDQ�
EDKZD� SHQJKRUPDWDQ� WHUKDGDS� SHUVRQ�
GDSDW�WHUZXMXG�DSDELOD�DGD�VHVXDWX�\DQJ�
GLEDJLNDQ�GLEHULNDQ� NHSDGD� VHVHRUDQJ�
VHEDQGLQJ� GHQJDQ� \DQJ� VHKDUXVQ\D� LD�
WHULPD� �SUDHWHU� SURSRUWLRQHP� GLJQLWDV�
LSVLXV� � � 'HQJDQ� GDVDU� L WX� PDND�
SHQJDNXDQ� WHUKDGDS� SHUVRQ� KDUXV�
GLDUDKNDQ� SDGD� SHQJDNXDQ� WHUKDGDS�
NHSDWXWDQ� �HTXLW\��� NHPXGLDQ� SHOD\DQDQ�
GDQ� SHQJKDUJDDQ� GLGLVWULEXVLNDQ� VHFDUD�
SURSRUVLRQDO� DWDV� GDVDU� KDUNDW� GDQ�
PDUWDEDW�PDQXVLD�
3DXO� 7LOOLFK�� PHQ\DWDNDQ� EDKZD�
NHDGLODQ�\DQJ�WHUNDQGXQJ�GDODP�NHDGLODQ�
DWULEXWLI�� GLVWULEXWLI�� GDQ� UHWULEXWLI� EHUVLIDW�
SURSRUVLRQDO��EDLN�SRVLWLI�PDXSXQ�QHJDWLI���
2OHK� 7LOOLFK� NHDGLODQ� SURSRUVLRQDO� LQL�
GLVHEXW� ³NHDGLODQ� WULEXWLI´� �3DXO� 7LOOLFK��
�������������
6HPHQWD UD � L WX � SHPEDJ LDQ �
NHDGLODQ� PHQXUXW� SHQJDUDQJ� PRGHUQ��
DQWDUD� ODLQ�VHEDJDLPDQD�\DQJ�GLODNXNDQ�
ROHK� -RKQ� %RDWULJKW� GDQ� 0DQXHO��
9HODVTXH]� \DLWX�� D�� .HDGLODQ� GLVWULEXWLI�
�GLVWU LEXW LYH� MXVW LFH� � � PHPSXQ\DL �
SHQJHUWLDQ� \DQJ� VDPD� � SDGD� SROD�
WUDGLVLRQDO��GLPDQD�EHQHILWV�DQG�EXUGHQV�
KDUXV� GLEDJL� VHFDUD� DGLO�� E�� .HDGLODQ�
UHWULEXWLI� �UHWULEXWLYH� MXVWLFH��� EHUNDLWDQ�
GHQJDQ� WHUMDGLQ\D� NHVDODKDQ�� GLPDQD�
KXNXP� DWDX� GHQGD� GLEHEDQNDQ� NHSDGD�
RUDQJ�\DQJ�EHUVDODK�KDUXVODK�EHUVLIDW�DGLO��
F��.HDGLODQ�NRPSHQVDWRULV��FRPSHQVDWRU\�
MXVWLFH���PHQ\DQJNXW�MXJD�NHVDODKDQ�\DQJ�
GLODNXNDQ�� WHWDSL� PHQXUXW� DVSHN� ODLQ��
GLPDQD� RUDQJ� PHPSXQ\DL� NHZDMLEDQ�
PRUDO� XQWXN� PHPEHULNDQ� NRPSHQVDVL�
DWDX� JDQWL� UXJL� NHSDGD� SLKDN� ODLQ� \DQJ�
GLUXJLNDQ���GDODP�(��6XPDU\RQR�,,��������
������
'DU L � EHEHUDSD� SHPEHGDDQ�
WHQWDQJ�NHDGLODQ�WHUVHEXW�GL�DWDV��NHDGLODQ�
GLVWULEXWLI� GLSDQGDQJ� VHJDOD� DZDO� PXOD�
VHJDOD� MHQLV� WHRUL� NHDGLODQ�� 'LQDPLND�
NHDGLODQ�\DQJ�EHUNHPEDQJ�GL�PDV\DUDNDW�
GDODP� WHODDK� SDUD� DKOL� SDGD� XPXPQ\D�
EHUODQGDVNDQ� SDGD� WHRUL� NHDGLODQ�
GLVWULEXWLI�� PHVNLSXQ� GHQJDQ� EHUEDJDL�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
YHUVL�GDQ�SDQGDQJDQQ\D�PDVLQJ�PDVLQJ��
2OHK� NDUHQD� LWX� PHQXUXW� SHQXOLV��
PHODNXNDQ� WHODDK� NULWLV� PHQJHQDL�
KXEXQJDQ�NRQWUDNWXDO�SDUD�SLKDN��NKXVXV�
Q\D� GDODP� NRQWUDN�� WHQWXQ\D� KDUXV�
GLODQGDVL� SHPLNLUDQ� SURSRUVLRQDO� \DQJ�
WHUNDQGXQJ�GDODP�NHDGLODQ�GLVWULEXWLI�
�.HDGLODQ�GDODP�EHUNRQWUDN� OHELK�
WHU�PDQLIHVWDVL� DSDELOD� SHUWXNDUDQ� NH�
SHQWLQJDQ�SDUD�SLKDN� WHUGLVWULEXVL�VHVXDL�
GHQJDQ� KDN� GDQ� NHZDMLEDQQ\D� VHFDUD�
SURSRUVLRQDO���
'DODP�WHRUL�HWLND�PRGHUQ�WHUGDSDW�
GXD�SULQVLS�XQWXN�NHDGLODQ�GLVWULEXWLI��\DLWX�
SULQVLS�IRUPDO�GDQ�SULQVLS�PDWHULDO��3ULQVLS�
IRUPDO�� VHEDJDLPDQD�\DQJ�GLNHPXNDNDQ�
$ULVWRWHOHV� EDKZD�� ´HTXDOV� RXJKW� WR� EH�
WUHDWHG� HTXDOO\� DQG� XQHTXDOV� PD\� EH�
WUHDWHG� XQHTXDOO\´�� 3ULQVLS� LQL� EHUDQMDN�
GDUL� DVXPVL� ´XQWXN� KDO�KDO� \DQJ� VDPD�
GLSHUODNXNDQ� VHFDUD� VDPD´� �SULQVLS� LQL�
PHQRODN�DGDQ\D�SHUEHGDDQ�SHUODNXDQ�±�
GLVNULPLQDVL���3ULQVLS�PDWHULDO�� SULQVLS� LQL�
PHOHQJNDSL�SULQVLS�IRUPDO��+DO�\DQJ�VDPD�
GLNHPXNDNDQ�ROHK�/�-��YDQ�$SHOGRRUQ��-��
YDQ� .DQ� GDQ� -�+�� %HHNKXLV�� EDKZD�
NHDGLODQ� LWX� PHPSHUODNXNDQ� VDPD�
WHUKDGDS� KDO� \DQJ� VDPD� GDQ� PHP�
SHUODNXNDQ� \DQJ� WLGDN� VDPD� VHEDQGLQJ�
GHQJDQ�NHWLGDNVDPDDQQ\D�
$]DV� NHDGLODQ� WLGDN� PHQMDGLNDQ�
SHUVDPDDQ� KDNLNL� GDODP� SHPEDJLDQ�
NHEXWXKDQ�NHEXWXKDQ�KLGXS�+DVUDW�DNDQ�
SHUVDPDDQ�GDODP�EHQWXN�SHUODNXDQ�KDUXV�
PHPEXND�PDWD�EDJL�NHWLGDNVDPDDQ�GDUL�
NHQ\DWDDQ�NHQ\DWDDQ�� 7HUNDLW� GHQJDQ�
SDQGDQJDQ� WHUVHEXW�� SHUOX� GLSHUKDWLNDQ�
PDNQD� NHDGLODQ� GDUL� VXDWX� D]DV� \DQJ�
PHQHQWXNDQ�´EHQWXN´�PHQMDGL�D]DV�\DQJ�
PHPEHULNDQ�´LVL´�GDUL�VXDWX�VWDQGDU�DWDX�
XNXUDQ���/�-��YDQ�$SHOGRRUQ����������������
-��YDQ��.DQ�GDQ�-�+��%HHNKXLV�����������
�����
%HDXFKDPS� GDQ� %RZLH� PHQJ�
DMXNDQ� HQDP� SULQVLS� DJDU� NHDGLODQ�
GLVWULEXWLI� WHUZXMXG�� \DLWX� DSDELOD�
GLEHULNDQ�� �GDODP� -�� YDQ� � .DQ� GDQ� -�+��
%HHNKXLV�� ������D�� NHSDGD�VHWLDS�RUDQJ�
EDJLDQ�\DQJ�VDPD��E��NHSDGD�VHWLDS�RUDQJ�
VHVXDL� GHQJDQ� NHEXWXKDQ� LQGLYLGXDOQ\D��
F�� NHSDGD� VHWLDS� RUDQJ� VHVXDL� GHQJDQ�
KDNQ\D�� G�� NHSDGD� VHWLDS� RUDQJ� VHVXDL�
GHQJDQ� XVDKD� LQGLYLGXDOQ\D�� H�� NHSDGD�
VHWLDS�RUDQJ�VHVXDL�GHQJDQ�NRQWULEXVLQ\D��
I�� NHSDGD� VHWLDS� RUDQJ� VHVXDL� GHQJDQ�
MDVDQ\D��PHULW��
7HRUL� .HDGLODQ� .RPSUHKHQVLI� -RKQ�
5DZOV
7HRUL� NHDGLODQ� 5DZOV� PHUXSDNDQ�
WHRUL�\DQJ�GLDQJJDS�IHQRPHQDO�GDQ�SDOLQJ�
EDQ\DN�GLSHUGHEDWNDQ�ROHK�SDUD�DKOL��7HRUL�
NHDGLODQ�5DZOV�EHUWLWLN�WRODN�GDUL�NULWLNQ\D�
DWDV� NHJDJDODQ� WHRUL�WHRUL� NHDGLODQ� \DQJ�
EHUNHPEDQJ� VHEHOXPQ\D�� .HJDJDODQ�
WHUVHEXW� GLVHEDENDQ� ROHK� VXEVWDQVLQ\D� �
VDQJDW� GLSHQJDUXKL� EDLN� XWLOLWDULDQLVPH�
PDXSXQ�LQWXLVLRQLVPH���-RKQ�5DZOV��������
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
���
5DZO� PHQJNULWLN� XWLOLWDULDQLVPH�
\DQJ� GLSHORSRUL� -HUHP\� %HQWKDP� GDQ�
GLNHPEDQJNDQ� ROHK� -RKQ� 6WXDUW� 0LOO��
VHEDJDL� SDQGDQJDQ� PRUDO� \DQJ� VDQJDW�
GRPLQDQ� GHQJDQ� SDKDPQ\D� \DQJ�
PHQJDMDUNDQ� EDKZD� EHQDU� VDODKQ\D�
SHUDWXUDQ� DWDX� WLQGDNDQ� PDQXVLD�
WHUJDQWXQJ� SDGD� NRQVHNXHQVL� ODQJVXQJ�
GDUL�SHUDWXUDQ�DWDX�WLQGDNDQ�WHUWHQWX�\DQJ�
GLODNXNDQ�
'HQJDQ�GHPLNLDQ�EDLN�EXUXNQ\D�
WLQGDNDQ� PDQXVLD� VHFDUD� PRUDO� VDQJDW�
WH UJDQWXQJ� SDGD� ED LN � EXUXNQ\D�
NRQVHNXHQVL� WLQGDNDQ� WHUVHEXW� EDJL�
PDQXVLD��
'ZRUNLQ� PHQ\HEXWQ\D� VHEDJDL�
WHRUL� ³JRDO�EDVHG� WKHRU\´�� PHQ\DWDNDQ�
EDKZD� XWLOLWDULDQLVPH� JDJDO� XQWXN�
PHQMDPLQ� NHDGLODQ� VRVLDO� NDUHQD� OHELK�
PHQGDKXOXNDQ� D]DV� PDQIDDW� GDULSDGD�
D]DV�KDN��2OHK�NDUHQD� LWX�XWLOLWDULDQLVPH�
WLGDN� WHSDW� XQWXN� GLMDGLNDQ� EDVLV� XQWXN�
PHPEDQJXQ� VXDWX� NRQVHS� NHDGLODQ�
�GDODP�$QGUH�$WD�8MDQ�����������
.HOHPDKDQ� SRNRN� WHRUL�WHRUL�
NRQWUDN� \DQJ� EHUEDVLV� XWLOLWDULDQLVPH�
DGDODK�� D�� NHDGLODQ� VXOLW� GLMDPLQ� NDUHQD�
SHQJDPELODQ� NHSXWXVDQ� OHELK� GLWHQWXNDQ�
ROHK�SULQVLS�PDQIDDW�GDULSDGD�SULQVLS�KDN��
E��NHDGLODQ�VHEDJDL�VHEXDK�QLODL�MXJD�WLGDN�
PHQGDSDW�SULRULWDV�WHUKDGDS�SHUWLPEDQJ�
DQ�SHUWLPEDQJDQ� HNRQRPLV�� F�� NHDGLODQ�
VHDNDQ� GDSDW� GLNRPSHQVDVL� PHODOXL�
NHXQWXQJDQ±NHXQWXQJDQ� HNRQRPLV� DWDX�
NHXQWXQJDQ�NHXQWXQJDQ�VRVLDO�ODLQQ\D��G��
SDGD� WDUDI� LQL� NHWLGDNDGLODQ�DNDQ�PXGDK�
PXQFXO� GDQ� EHUVDPDDQ� GHQJDQ� LWX�
SHQJKDUJDDQ� SDGD� KDN� GDQ� PDUWDEDW�
PDQXVLD�MXJD�KLODQJ�GDQ�GLUHPHKNDQ�
.DUHQD� NHFHQGHUXQJDQQ\D�
XQWXN�PHPEHULNDQ�PDQIDDW�SDOLQJ�EHVDU�
EDJL� VHEDQ\DN� PXQJNLQ� DQJJRWD�
PDV\DUDNDW�� ´WKH�JUHDWHVW�EHQHILW� IRU� WKH�
JUHDWHVW�QXPEHU�RI�SHRSOH´�DWDX�GLVHEXW�
M X JD � ´ I H O L F L I L F � F D O FX O X V ´ � � PDND �
XWLOLWDULDQLVPH� FHQGHUXQJ� PHQJDQJJDS�
EDKZD� NHEDKDJLDQ� VHWLDS� RUDQJ� DGDODK�
VDPD�� /HELK� GDUL� LWX� NHSXDVDDQ� \DQJ�
XPXPQ\D�GLSDKDPL�GDODP�DUWL�NHSXDVDQ�
PDWHULDO�� GLDQJNDW� PHQMDGL� XNXUDQ� \DQJ�
GLDQJJDS� YDOLG� GDQ� PHQJLNDW�� 6HKLQJJD�
VHRODK�RODK�NHSXDVDDQ�GDSDW�GLNDONXODVL�
VHFDUD�PDWHPDWLV��PHVNL� VHVXQJJXKQ\D�
NHSXDVDQ� WLGDN�SHUQDK�GDSDW� GLNDONXODVL�
VHFDUD� PDWHPDWLV�� 'DUL� DVSHN� PRUDO��
GHQJDQ� OHELK� PHQJXWDPDNDQ� D]DV�
PDQIDDW� �WKH�JRRG��GDQ�PHQJHVDPSLQJ�
NDQ� D]DV� KDN� �WKH� ULJKW��� WDPSDNQ\D�
XWLOLWDULDQLVPH� PHPSXQ\DL� WXMXDQ� EDLN��
\DNQL� EHUXSD\D� PHODOXL� SHQGHNDWDQ�
WHOHRORJLV�� PHQMHPEDWDQL� MXUDQJ� DQWDUD�
SULQVLS� KDN� GDQ� SULQVLS�PDQIDDW�� QDPXQ�
GDODP� SUDNWLNQ\D� SDKDP� LQL� JDJDO�
PHPDLQNDQ�SHUDQDQQ\D�
7HJDVQ\D� PHQXUXW� EHEHUDSD�
NULWLNXV�� XQWLOLWDULDQLVPH� WLGDN� PDPSX�
PHQJKDGDSL� GXD� MHQLV� SHUPDVDODKDQ�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
PRUDO�� \DLWX�� PDVDODK� \DQJ� EHUNDLWDQ�
GHQJDQ�KDN�GDQ�PDVDODK�\DQJ�EHUNDLWDQ�
GHQJDQ�NHDGLODQ���0DQXHO�*��9HODVTXH]��
����������
0HQXUXW� 5DZOV� DGDODK� WLGDN� DGLO�
PHQJRUEDQNDQ� KDN� GDUL� VDWX� DWDX�
EHEHUDSD�RUDQJ�KDQ\D�GHPL�NHXQWXQJDQ�
HNRQRPLV� \DQJ� OHELK� EHVDU� EDJL�
PDV\DUDNDW�VHFDUD�NHVHOXUXKDQ��6LNDS�LQL�
MXVWUX� EHUWHQWDQJDQ� GHQJDQ� NHDGLODQ�
VHEDJDL� IDLUQHVV� \DQJ� PHQXQWXW� SULQVLS�
NHEHEDVDQ�\DQJ�VDPD�VHEDJDL�EDVLV�\DQJ�
PHODQGDVL� SHQJDWXUDQ� NHVHMDKWHUDDQ�
VRVLDO�
2OHK� NDUHQDQ\D� SHUWLPEDQJDQ�
HNRQRPLV� WLGDN� EROHK� EHUWHQWDQJDQ�
GHQJDQ�SULQVLS�NHEHEDVDQ�GDQ�KDN�\DQJ�
VDPD� EDJL� VHPXD� RUDQJ�� 'HQJDQ� NDWD�
ODLQ�� NHSXWXVDQ� VRVLDO� \DQJ� PHPSXQ\DL�
DNLEDW� EDJL� VHPXD� DQJJRWD� PDV\DUDNDW�
KDUXV�GLEXDW�DWDV�GDVDU�KDN��ULJKW�EDVHG�
ZHLJKW�� GDULSDGD� DWDV� GDVDU� PDQIDDW�
�JRRG�EDVHG� ZHLJKW��� +DQ\D� GHQJDQ� LWX�
NHDGLODQ�VHEDJDL�IDLUQHVV�GDSDW�GLQLNPDWL�
VHPXD�RUDQJ�
5DZOV� MXJD� PHQJULWLN� LQWXLVLRQLV�
PH� NDUHQD� WLGDN� PHPEHUL� WHPSDW�
PHPDGDL� SDGD� D]DV� UDVLRQDOLWDV��
,QWXLVLRQLVPH�GDODP�SURVHV�SHQJDPELODQ�
NHSXWXVDQ� �PRUDO�� OHELK� PHQJDQGDONDQ�
NHPDPSXDQ� LQWXLVL� PDQXVLD�� 'HQJDQ�
GHPLNLDQ� SDQGDQJDQ� LQL� MXJD� WLGDN�
PHPDGDL� DSDELOD� GLMDGLNDQ� SHJDQJDQ�
GDODP� PHQJDPELO� NHSXWXVDQ�� WHUXWDPD�
SDGD� ZDNWX� WHUMDGLQ\D� NRQIOLN� DQWDUD�
QRUPD�QRUPD�PRUDO��
'HQJDQ�PHQJDPELO�SHODMDUDQ�GDUL�
NHJDJDODQ� WHRUL�WHRUL�VHEHOXPQ\D��5DZOV�
PHQFRED� PHQDZDUNDQ� VXDWX� EHQWXN�
SHQ\HOHVDLDQ� \DQJ� WHUNDLW� GHQJDQ�
SUREOHPDWLND� NHDGLODQ� GHQJDQ� PHP�
EDQJXQ� WHRUL� NHDGLODQ� EHUEDVLV� NRQWUDN��
0HQXUXWQ\D� VXDWX� WHRUL� NHDGLODQ� \DQJ�
PHPDGDL� KDUXV� GLEHQWXN� GHQJDQ� SHQ�
GHNDWDQ� NRQWUDN�� GLPDQD� D]DV�D]DV�
NHDGLODQ� \DQJ� GLSLOLK� EHUVDPD� EHQDU�
EHQDU� PHUXSDNDQ� KDVLO� NHVHSDNDWDQ�
EHUVDPD�GDUL�VHPXD�SHUVRQ�\DQJ�EHEDV��
UDVLRQDO�� GDQ� VHGHUDMDW�� +DQ\D� PHODOXL�
SHQGHNDWDQ�NRQWUDN�VHEXDK�WHRUL�NHDGLODQ�
PDPSX�PHQMDPLQ� SHODNVDQDDQ� KDN� GDQ�
VHNDOLJXV� PHQGLVWULEXVLNDQ� NHZDMLEDQ�
VHFDUD� DGLO� EDJL� VHPXD� RUDQJ�� 2OHK�
NDUHQDQ\D� GHQJDQ� WHJDV� 5DZOV� PH�
Q\DWDNDQ�� VXDWX� NRQVHS� NHDGLODQ� \DQJ�
EDLN� KDUXVODK� EHUVLIDW� NRQWUDNWXDO��
NRQVHNXHQVLQ\D� VHWLDS� NRQVHS� NHDGLODQ�
\DQJ� WLGDN� EHUEDVLV� NRQWUDNWXDO� KDUXV�
GLNHVDPSLQJNDQ� GHPL� NHSHQWLQJDQ�
NHDGLODQ�LWX�VHQGLUL�
'D ODP� NRQ WHNV � L Q L � 5DZ OV �
PHQ\HEXW� ´MXVWLFH� DV� IDLUQHVV´� \DQJ�
GLWDQGDL� DGDQ\D� SULQVLS� UDVLRQDOLWDV��
NHEHEDVDQ� GDQ� NHVDPDDQ��2OHK� NDUHQD�
LWX� GLSHUOXNDQ� SULQVLS�SULQVLS� NHDGLODQ�
\DQJ� OHELK� PHQJXWDPDNDQ� D]DV� KDN�
GDULSDGD� D]DV� PDQIDDW�� 0HQXUXW� .��
%HUWHQV��MXVWLFH�DV�IDLUQHVV��GDODP�PDNQD�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
OHNVLNDO��NDPXV��MXVW�EHUDUWL�DGLO�MXJD�IDLU��
7HWDSL� DGD� SHUEHGDDQ�� MXVW� EHUDUWL� DGLO�
PHQXUXW� LVLQ\D� �VXEVWDQVL�� DWDX� GLVHEXW�
NHDGLODQ�VXEVWDQWLDO��VXEVWDQWLYH�MXVWLFH���
VHGDQJNDQ� IDLU� EHUDUWL� DGLO� PHQXUXW�
SURVHGXUQ\D� DWDX� NHDGLODQ� SURVHGXUDO�
�SURFHGXUDO� MXVWLFH��� &RQWRKQ\D�� XQGLDQ�
\DQJ� EHUMDODQ� IDLU� �NHDGLODQ� SURVHGXUDO���
\DQJ�GLLNXWL�RUDQJ�ND\D�GDQ�RUDQJ�PLVNLQ�
WHUQ\DWD�GLPHQDQJNDQ�RUDQJ�ND\D��PDND�
GDUL� VLVL� SURVHGXUQ\D� PHPDQJ� WHODK�
EHUMDODQ� IDLU�� QDPXQ� GDUL� VLVL� KDVLO�
GLDQJJDS�VDPD�VHNDOL� WLGDN�DGLO� �XQMXVW���
)DLUQHVV�EHUDUWL�NHDGLODQ�\DQJ�GLGDVDUNDQ�
DWDV� SURVHGXU� \DQJ� ZDMDU� �W LGDN�
GLUHND\DVD�DWDX�GLPDQLSXODVL���
5DZOV � PHUXPXVNDQ� GXD� SULQVLS��
NHDGLODQ� GLVWULEXWLI�� VHEDJDL� EHULNXW�
SHUWDPD�� WKH� JUHDWHVW� HTXDO� SULQFLSOH��
EDKZD� VHWLDS� RUDQJ� KDUXV� PHPLOLNL� KDN�
\DQJ� VDPD� DWDV� NHEHEDVDQ� GDVDU� \DQJ�
SDOLQJ�OXDV��VHOXDV�NHEHEDVDQ�\DQJ�VDPD�
EDJL�VHPXD�RUDQJ��,QL�PHUXSDNDQ�KDO�\DQJ�
SDOLQJ�PHQGDVDU� �KDN�D]DVL�� \DQJ�KDUXV�
GLPLOLNL� VHPXD� RUDQJ�� 'HQJDQ� NDWD� ODLQ��
KDQ\D� GHQJDQ� � DGDQ\D� MDPLQDQ�
NHEHEDVDQ�\DQJ�VDPD�EDJL�VHPXD�RUDQJ�
PDND� NHDGLODQ� DNDQ� WHUZXMXG� �3ULQVLS�
.HVDPDDQ�+DN��
3ULQVLS� WKH� JUHDWHVW� HTXDO�
SULQFLSOH�� PHQXUXW� SHQXOLV�� WLGDN� ODLQ�
DGD ODK � ´S U LQV LS � NHVDPDDQ� KDN´ �
PHUXSDNDQ� SULQVLS� \DQJ� PHPEHULNDQ�
NHVHWDUDDQ�KDN�GDQ�WHQWXQ\D�EHUEDQGLQJ�
WHUEDOLN� GHQJDQ� EHEDQ� NHZDMLEDQ� \DQJ�
GLPLOLNL�VHWLDS�RUDQJ��L�F��SDUD�NRQWUDNWDQ���
3ULQVLS� LQL� PHUXSDNDQ� UXK� GDUL� D]DV�
NHEHEDVDQ�EHUNRQWUDN�
.HGXD��NHWLGDNVDPDDQ�VRVLDO�GDQ�
HNRQRPL� KDUXV� GLDWXU� VHGHPLNLDQ� UXSD�
VHKLQJJD� SHUOX� GLSHUKDWLNDQ� D]DV� DWDX�
SULQVLS� ���� WKH�GLIIHUHQW�SULQFLSOH��GDQ� ����
WKH�SULQFLSOH�RI�IDLU�HTXDOLW\�RI�RSSRUWXQLW\�
3ULQVLS�LQL�GLKDUDSNDQ�PHPEHULNDQ�
NHXQWXQJDQ� WHUEHVDU� EDJL� RUDQJ�RUDQJ�
\DQJ�NXUDQJ�EHUXQWXQJ��VHUWD�PHPEHULNDQ�
SHQHJDVDQ� EDKZD� GHQJDQ� NRQGLVL� GDQ�
NHVHPSDWDQ�\DQJ�VDPD��VHPXD�SRVLVL�GDQ�
MDEDWDQ�KDUXV�WHUEXND�EDJL�VHPXD�RUDQJ�
�3ULQVLS� 3HUEHGDDQ� 2E\HNWLI��� 3ULQVLS�
NHGXD�� \DLWX� ³WKH� GLIIHUHQW� SULQFLSOH´� GDQ�
´WKH� SULQFLSOH� RI� �IDLU�� HTXDOLW\� RI�
RSSRUWXQLW\´��PHQXUXW�SHQXOLV�PHUXSDNDQ�
³SULQVLS� SHUEHGDDQ� RE\HNWLI´�� DUWLQ\D�
SULQVLS� NHGXD� WHUVHEXW� PHQMDPLQ�
WHUZXMXGQ\D� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� SHUWXNDUDQ�
KDN�GDQ�NHZDMLEDQ�SDUD�SLKDN��VHKLQJJD�
VHFDUD� ZDMDU� �RE\HNWLI�� GLWHULPD� DGDQ\D�
SHUEHGDDQ�SHUWXNDUDQ�DVDONDQ�PHPHQXKL�
V\DUDW�JRRG�IDLWK�DQG�IDLUQHVV��UHGHOLMNKHLG�
HQ� ELOOLMNKHLG��� 'HQJDQ� GHPLNLDQ� 3ULQVLS�
SHUWDPD� GDQ� SULQVLS� NHGXD� WLGDN� GDSDW�
GLSLVDKNDQ� VDWX� GHQJDQ� ODLQQ\D�� 6HVXDL�
GHQJDQ� D]DV� SURSURVLRQDOLWDV�� NHDGLODQ�
5DZOV� LQL� DNDQ� WHUZXMXG� DSDELOD� NHGXD�
V\DUDW� WHUVHEXW� GLWHUDSNDQ� VHFDUD�
NRPSUHKHQVLI�� 'HQJDQ� SHQHNDQDQQ\D�
\DQJ� EHJLWX� NXDW� SDGD� SHQWLQJQ\D�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
PHPEHUL�SHOXDQJ�\DQJ�VDPD�EDJL�VHPXD�
SLKDN��5DZOV�EHUXVDKD�DJDU�NHDGLODQ�WLGDN�
WHUMHEDN�GDODP�HNVWUHP�NDSLWDOLVPH�GL�VDWX�
SLKDN�GDQ�VRVLDOLVPH�GL�ODLQ�SLKDN��5DZOV�
PHQJDWDNDQ� EDKZD� SULQVLS� ���� \DLWX� WKH�
JUHDWHVW� HTXDO� SULQFLSOH�� KDUXV� OHELK�
GLSULRULWDVNDQ� GDUL� SULQVLS� ���� DSDELOD�
NHGXDQ\D�EHUNRQIOLN��6HGDQJ�SULQVLS� �����
EDJLDQ�E�\DLWX�WKH�SULQFLSOH�RI��IDLU��HTXDOLW\�
RI� RSSRUWXQLW\� KDUXV� OHELK� GLSULRULWDVNDQ�
GDUL�EDJLDQ�D�\DLWX�WKH�GLIIHUHQW�SULQFLSOH�
.HDGLODQ�KDUXV�GLSDKDPL�VHEDJDL�
IDLUQHVV�� GDODP� DUWL� EDKZD� WLGDN� KDQ\D�
PHUHND� \DQJ� PHPLOLNL� EDNDW� GDQ�
NHPDPSXDQ� \DQJ� OHELK� EDLN� VDMD� \DQJ�
EHUKDN�PHQLNPDWL�SHOEDJDL�PDQIDDW�VRVLDO�
OHELK�EDQ\DN��WHWDSL�NHXQWXQJDQ�WHUVHEXW�
MXJD� KDUXV� PHPEXND� SHOXDQJ� EDJL�
PHUHND� \DQJ� NXUDQJ� EHUXQWXQJ� XQWXN�
PHQLQJNDWNDQ� SURVSHN� KLGXSQ\D�� 'DODP�
NDLWDQQ\D� GHQJDQ� KDO� WHUVHEXW�� SHU�
WDQJJXQJMDZDEDQ� PRUDOLWDV� ´NHOHELKDQ´�
GDUL� PHUHND� \DQJ� EHUXQWXQJ� KDUXV�
GLWHPSDWNDQ� SDGD� ´ELQJNDL� NHSHQWLQJDQ´�
NHORPSRN�PHUHND�\DQJ�NXUDQJ�EHUXQWXQJ��
³7KH� GLIIHUHQW� SULQFLSOH´� � WLGDN�PHQXQWXW�
PDQIDDW�\DQJ�VDPD��HTXDO�EHQHILWV��EDJL�
VHPXD� RUDQJ�� PHODLQNDQ� PDQIDDW� \DQJ�
VLIDWQ\D�WLPEDO�EDOLN��UHFLSURFDO�EHQHILWV���
PLVDOQ\D��VHRUDQJ�SHNHUMD�\DQJ�WHUDPSLO�
WHQWXQ\D�DNDQ�OHELK�GLKDUJDL�GLEDQGLQJNDQ�
GHQJDQ�SHNHUMD�\DQJ�WLGDN�WHUDPSLO�
'LVLQL� NHDGLODQ� VHEDJDL� IDLUQHVV�
VDQJDW� PHQHNDQNDQ� D]DV� UHVLSURVLWDV��
QDPXQ� EXNDQ� EHUDUWL� VHNHGDU� ´VLPSO\�
UHFLSURFLW\´�� GLPDQD� GLVWULEXVL� NHND\DDQ�
GLODNXNDQ� WDQSD� PHOLKDW� SHUEHGDDQ�
SHUEHGDDDQ� RE\HNWLI� GL� DQWDUD� DQJJRWD�
PDV\DUDNDW�
2OHK� NDUHQDQ\D�� DJDU� WHUMDPLQ�
VXDWX� DWXUDQ� PDLQ� \DQJ� RE\HNWLI� PDND�
NHDGLODQ� \DQJ� GDSDW� GLWHULPD� VHEDJDL�
IDLUQHVV� DGDODK� SXUH� SURFHGXUDO� MXVWLFH��
DUWLQ\D� NHDGLODQ� VHEDJDL� IDLUQHVV� KDUXV�
EHUSURVHV� VHNDOLJXV� WHUHIOHNVL� PHODOXL�
VXDWX�SURVHGXU�\DQJ�DGLO�XQWXN�PHQMDPLQ�
KDVLO� \DQJ� DGLO� SXOD� �/RUG� /OR\G� 2I�
+DPSVWHDG��0�'�$��)UHHPDQ�����������
±������
7HUNDLW� GHQJDQ� NRPSOHNVLWDV�
KXEXQJDQ�NRQWUDNWXDO�GDODP�GXQLD�ELVQLV��
NKXVXVQ\D�WHUNDLW�GHQJDQ�NHDGLODQ�GDODP�
NRQWUDN��PDND�EHUGDVDUNDQ�SLNLUDQ�SLNLUDQ�
WHUVHEXW� GL� DWDV� NLWD� WLGDN� EROHK� WHUSDNX�
SDGD�SHPEHGDDQ�NHDGLODQ�NODVLN��$UWLQ\D�
DQDOLVLV� NHDGLODQ� GDODP� NRQWUDN� KDUXV�
PHPDGXNDQ�NRQVHS�NHVDPDDQ�KDN�GDODP�
SHUWXNDUDQ� �SUHVWDVL� ±� NRQWUD� SUHVWDVL��
VHEDJDLPDQD� GLSDKDPL� GDODP� NRQWHNV�
NHDGLODQ� NRPXWDWLI� PDXSXQ� NRQVHS�
NHDGLODQ� GLVWULEXWLI� VHEDJDL� ODQGDVDQ�
KXEXQJDQ�NRQWUDNWXDO��
0HPDKDPL� NHDGL ODQ� GDODP�
NRQWUDN�WLGDN�EROHK�PHPEDZD�NLWD�NHSDGD�
VLNDS�PRQLVWLF� �SDKDP� WXQJJDO��� QDPXQ�
OHELK�GDUL�LWX�KDUXV�EHUVLNDS�NRPSUHKHQVLI��
'DODP� NHDGLODQ� NRPXWDWLI� \DQJ�
PHQMDGL� ODQGDVDQ� KXEXQJDQ� DQWDUD�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
SHUVRQ�� WHUPDVXN� NRQWUDN�� KHQGDNQ\D�
WLGDN�GLSDKDPL�VHEDJDL�NHVDPDDQ�VHPDWD�
NDUHQD� SDQGDQJDQ� LQL� DNDQ� PHPEDZD�
NHWLGDNDGLODQ� NHWLND� GLKDGDSNDQ� GHQJDQ�
NHWLGDNVHLPEDQJDQ� SDUD� SLKDN� \DQJ�
EHUNRQWUDN�� 'DODP� NHDGLODQ� NRPXWDWLI�
GLGDODPQ\D� WHUNDQGXQJ� SXOD� PDNQD�
GLVWULEXVL�SURSRUVLRQDO�� 'HPLNLDQ� SXOD�
GDODP�NHDGLODQ�GLVWULEXWLI�\DQJ�GLSRODNDQ�
GDODP� KXEXQJDQ� QHJDUD� GHQJDQ� ZDUJD�
QHJDUD�� NRQVHS� GLVWULEXVL�SURSRUVLRQDO�
\DQJ�WHUNDQGXQJ�GLGDODPQ\D�GDSDW�GLWDULN�
NH�SHUVSHNWLI� KXEXQJDQ�NRQWUDNWXDO� SDUD�
SLKDN��
0DNQD�$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
8SD\D� PHQFDUL� PDNQD� D]DV�
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�PHUXSDNDQ�SURVHV�\DQJ�
WLGDN�PXGDK��EDKNDQ�VHULQJNDOL� WXPSDQJ�
WLQGLK� GDODP� SHPDKDPDQQ\D� GHQJDQ�
D]DV�NHVHLPEDQJDQ��3DGD�GDVDUQ\D�D]DV�
NHVHLPEDQJDQ�GDQ�D]DV�SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
WLGDN� GDSDW� GLSLVDKNDQ� NHEHUDGDDQQ\D�
GDODP�KXNXP�NRQWUDN��1DPXQ�GHPLNLDQ��
VHVHGHUKDQD� DSDSXQ� SHPDKDPDQ�
WHUVHEXW� PDVLK� GDSDW� GLWDULN� EHQDQJ�
PHUDK� PHODOXL� SHPDKDPDQ� \DQJ� OHELK�
NRPSUHKHQVLI� XQWXN� PHPEHGDNDQ�
NHGXDQ\D���
3HPLN L UDQ � PHQJHQD L � D]DV �
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� SHUOX� GLNHPXNDNDQ�
GLVDPSLQJ� D]DV� NHVHLPEDQJDQ� GDODP�
NRQWUDN�� 8QWXN� PHPEHGDNDQ� NHGXDQ\D�
SHUWDPD�WDPD�GDSDW�GLWHOXVXUL�GDUL�PDNQD�
OHNVLNDO� GLDQWDUD� NHGXD� LVWLODK� WHUVHEXW��
\DLWX� PDNQD� NHVHLPEDQJDQ� GDQ�
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV��'DODP�EHEHUDSD�NDPXV�
WHUKDGDS� GXD� LVWLODK� WHUVHEXW� DGD� \DQJ�
PHPEHGDNDQ�DUWL��QDPXQ�MXJD�DGD�\DQJ�
PHQ\DPDNDQQ\D��'DODP�NDPXV�NDWD�NH�
VHLPEDQJDQ� EHUDUWL� NHDGDDQ� VHLPEDQJ�
�VHLPEDQJ±VDPD� EHUDW�� VHWLPEDQJ��
VHEDQGLQJ�� VHWLPSDO��� GDODP� LOPX� ILVLND�
GLDUWLNDQ� VHEDJDL� NHDGDDQ� \DQJ� WHUMDGL�
ELOD� VHPXD� JD\D� GDQ� NH�FHQGHUXQJDQ�
\DQJ�DGD�SDGD�VHWLDS�EHQGD�DWDX�VLVWHP�
SHUVLV� �GLQHWUDONDQ� �DWDX� �GLODZDQ� �ROHK� �
JD\D� �DWDX� �NHFHQGHUXQJDQ� �\DQJ�VDPD�
EHVDU� WHWDSL� PHPSXQ\DL� DUDK� \DQJ� EHU�
ODZDQDQ�� 6HGDQJ� NDWD� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
DWDX� SURSRUVLRQDO�EHUDUWL�VHVXDL�GHQJDQ�
SURSRUVL�� VHEDQGLQJ�� EHULPEDQJ� �.DPXV�
%HVDU� %DKDVD� ,QGRQHVLD�� ������ ���� �
����
$%� 0DVVLHU � GDQ� 0DUMDQQH�
7HUPRUVKXL]HQ�$UWV�� GDODP� KXEXQJDQ�
GHQJDQ�KXNXP�SHULNDWDQ��PHPEHUL�PDNQD�
VHLPEDQJ� �LQ� HYHQZLWFK�� HYHQZLFKWLJ��
HYHQUHGLJ�� JHOLMNZDDUGLJ� >YDQ� �GH�
UHFKWHQ�SOLFKWHQ� YDQ�� FRQWUDFWHUHQGH�
SDUWLMHQ@� DGDODK� PHQXUXW� LPEDQJDQ�
�HYHQUHG LJ � � QDDU � HYHQUHG LJKHLG � �
SRQGVSRQGVJHZLMV��� GHQJDQ� PHPEHUL�
FRQWRK�� SHOXQDVDQ� KDUXV� GLDQJJDS�
EHUODNX� XQWXN� PDVLQJ�PDVLQJ� XWDQJ�
PHQXUXW� LPEDQJDQ� MXPODK� PDVLQJ�
PDV LQJ � � 6HGDQJ � NHVH LPEDQJDQ �
� N H V H U D V L D Q � � H Y H QZ L F K W L J K H L G � �
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
HYHQUHGLJKHLG��JHOLMNZDDUGLJKHLG��>YDQ��GH�
UHFKWHQ�SOLFKWHQ� YDQ�� FRQWUDFWHUHQGH�
SDUWLMHQ@� GHQJDQ� PHQXQMXN� GDVDU� EDJL�
NHVHLPEDQJDQ� GDQ� NHVHUDVLDQ� GDODP�
SHUMDQMLDQ� WHUVXUDW� GL� GDODP� 3DVDO� �����
%:�� KDQ\D� DSDELOD� GDODP� NHDGDDQ� LQ�
FRQFUHWR� DGD� NHVHLPEDQJDQ� GDQ�
NHVHUDVLDQ�PDND�WHUFDSDLODK�NHVHSDNDWDQ�
DWDX� NRQVHQVXV� \DQJ� VDK� DQWDUD� SDUD�
SLKDN�� 8QWXN� PHPSHUWHJDV� SHPDKDPDQ�
WHUVHEXW� GLDMXNDQ� SHQJHUWLDQ� PHQJHQDL�
³.HWLGDNVHLPEDQJDQ´� �NHWLGDNVHUDVLDQ��
RQHYHQZLFKWLJKHLG�� RQHYHQUHGLJKHLG��
RQJHOLMNZDDUGLJKHLG� >YDQ� �GH� UHFKWHQ��
SOLFKWHQ� YDQ�� FRQWUDFWHUHQGH� SDUWLMHQ@��
8QWXN�SHQHUDSDQQ\D�KDNLP�PHPSHUKDWL�
NDQ�DGDQ\D�LQGLNDVL�SDWRNDQ�WHUWHQWX�\DQJ�
PHUXSDNDQ�GDVDU�EDJL�NHVLPSXODQ�EDKZD�
WHODK� WHUMDGL� SHQ\DODKJXQDDQ� NHDGDDQ�
\DQJ� GLPXQJNLQNDQ� NDUHQD� DGDQ\D�
NHWLGDNVHLPEDQJDQ� GDQ� NHWLGDNVHUDVLDQ�
NHGXGXNDQ�SDUD�SLKDN�
�'LVLQL�$%�0DVVLHU�GDQ�0DUMDQQH�
7HUPRUVKXL]HQ�$UWV�PHPEHUL�PDNQD�\DQJ�
VDPD� XQWXN� NDWD� ³HYHQUHGLJKHLG´� \DQJ�
EHUDUWL� NHVHLPEDQJDQ�� NHVHUDVLDQ��
NHVHEDQGLQJDQ� �HYHQUHGLJKHLGVEHJLQVHO�
±�D]DV�NHVHLPEDQJDQ��
6HGDQJNDQ� SURSRUVLRQDO L WDV�
GLWXQMXN� SHQJHUWLDQ� 3URSRUWLRQDOLWH�
LWVEHJLQVHO�� ]RUJYXOGLJKHLG� \DQJ� GL�
KXEXQJDQ� GHQJDQ� ]RUJYXOGLJKHLGV�
EHJLQVHO� �D]DV� NHFHUPDWDQ�� D]DV�
NHSDWXWDQ�� NHWHOLWLDQ� GDQ� NHKDWL�KDWLDQ��
GDODP� SURVHV� SHPEXNWLDQ�� EDKZD�
NHFHUPDWDQ� \DQJ� VHSDWXWQ\D� DGD� GDODP�
SHUJDXODQ� NHPDV\DUDNDWDQ� WHUKDGDS�
SULEDGL� DWDX� EDUDQJ� RUDQJ� ODLQ�� 'DODP�
PHQLODL� PHWRGH� SHQ\LGLNDQ� \DQJ� WLGDN�
GLDWXU� XQGDQJ�XQGDQJ�� PDND� KDNLP�
PHQJXML� GHQJDQ� PHQJJXQDNDQ� D]DV�
N H FH UPD W DQ � � V XEV L G L D U L W D V � G DQ �
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
1DPXQ� SHQHUDSDQ� D]DV� LQL� OHELK�
PHQXQMXN�SDGD�SURVHV�SHPEXNWLDQ�XQWXN�
SHUNDUD�SLGDQD�VHEDJDLPDQD�GLDWXU�3DVDO�
��� D\DW� ���� .8+3� �$%� 0DVVLHU� GDQ�
0DUMDQQH�7HUPRUVKXL]HQ�$UWV�������
'DODP�1�(��$OJUD� HW�� DO��� ³.DPXV�
,VW L ODK� +XNXP� )RFNHPD� $QGUHDH�
%HODQGD±,QGRQHVLD´�PDXSXQ�GDODP�YHUVL�
EDKDVD� %HODQGD� ³)RFNHPD� $QGUHDHV�
5HFKWVJHOHHUG� +DQGZRRUGHQERHN´� WLGDN�
GLWHPXNDQ� LVWLODK� HYHQZLFKWEHJLQVHO� �
WHWDSL� HYHQUHGLJKHLGVEHJLQVHO� XQWXN�
PHQHUMHPDKNDQ� D]DV� NHVHLPEDQJDQ��
\DLWX� VHEDJDL� SHGRPDQ� GDVDU� EDJL�
SHUWLPEDQJDQ� KXNXP� PDQXVLD� \DQJ�
EHUSRNRN� SDQJNDO� SDGD� SLNLUDQ� EDKZD�
VHWLDS�DQJJRWD�SHUVHNXWXDQ�KXNXP�VDPD�
QLODLQ\D� PHQJHQDL� SHPEDJLDQ� V\DUDW�
V\DUDW�GDODP�VXND�GDQ�GXND�
6HGDQJ� XQWXN� SHQJHUWLDQ� D]DV�
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� GLWHUMHPDKNDQ� GHQJDQ�
SURSRUWLRQDOLWHLWVEHJLQVHO�� EDKZD� KDUXV�
DGD� NHVHLPEDQJDQ� WHUWHQWX� DQWDUD�
WLPEXOQ\D� NHUXJLDQ� GDQ� SHPEHULDQ� JDQWL�
UXJL� �SHPEHODDQ��� $]DV� LQL� WHUXWDPD�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
PHPDLQNDQ� SHUDQDQ� SDGD� SHPEHODDQ�
SDNVD� �SHUODNXDQ� NHNHUDVDQ� WHUSDNVD��
QRRGZHHU��GDODP�KXNXP�SLGDQD��DUW������
OLG� �� 1�� :�Y�6WU�� DWDX� 3DVDO� ��� .8+3��
GLPDQD� GLNDWDNDQ� EDKZD� PHODNXNDQ�
NHNHUDVDQ�WHUSDNVD��KDUXVODK�GLVHEDENDQ�
ROHK� SHPEHODDQ� \DQJ� PHQGHVDN�� �1�(��
$OJUD�HW��DO��������������
)�3�+�� 3ULFN� YDQ� :HO\� GDODP�
³.UDPHUV� (QJHOV� :RRUGHQERHN´ � �
PHPEHULNDQ� DUWL� SURSRUVLRQDO� GHQJDQ�
³HYHQUHGLJKHLG´� DWDX� ³SURSRUWLRQ´��
³HYHQUHGLJ´�DWDX³SURSRUWLRQDO´��
6HGDQJNDQ� XQWXN� SHQJHUWLDQ�
NHVHLPEDQJDQ� DGDODK� ³HYHQZLFKW´� DWDX�
³HTXLOLEULXP´�� ³EDODQFH´� �)�3�+��3ULFN� YDQ�
:HO\������������������
6HGDQJNDQ� 5LFKDUG� -�� &RQYLVHU��
GDODP�³*LOEHUW�/DZ�6XPPDULHV�'LFWLRQDU\�
RI� /HJDO� 7HUPV´� � PHQXQMXN� SHQJHUWLDQ�
³SURSRUWLRQDO´� SDGD� SHQJHUWLDQ� ODWLQ� ³SUR�
UDWD´��DFFRUGLQJ�WR�WKH�UDWH��LQ�SURSRUWLRQ�WR�
VRPH� UDWH� WR� VWDQGDUG�� SURSRUWLRQDWHO\��
'DODP� SHQHUDSDQQ\D� GLFRQWRKNDQ�� DQ�
LQVROYHQW� PD\� KDYH� KLV� DVVHWV� GLYLGHG�
DPRQJ�KLV�FUHGLWRUV�RQ�D�³SUR�UDWD´�EDVLV��
PHDQLQJ�HDFK�ZRXOG�UHFHLYH�SD\PHQW� LQ�
HTXDO�SURSRUWLRQ��H�J��������WR�ZKDW�KH�LV�
RZHG�� 3HQMHODVDQ� 5LFKDUG� -�� &RQYLVHU�
EHUNHQDDQ� GHQJDQ� VXEVWDQVL� D]DV�
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�� DSDELOD� GLKXEXQJNDQ�
GHQJDQ� %:� GDSDW� GLMXPSDL� GDODP�
SHQJDWXUDQ�3DVDO������%:�WHUNDLW�GHQJDQ�
SHPEDJLDQ� KDUWD� EHQGD� PLOLN� GHELWRU�
NHW LND� WHU MDGL � ZDQSUHVWDVL � � \DQJ�
PHQ\DWDNDQ� EDKZD�� ³EDJLDQ� PDVLQJ�
PDVLQJ�NUHGLWRU��NRQNXUHQ��DGDODK�VHVXDL�
GHQJDQ� SHUEDQGLQJDQ�´� 6XEVWDQVL� LQL�
PHUXSDNDQ�GDVDU�EDJL�NUHGLWRU�NRQNXUHQ�
XQWXN�PHPSHUROHK�KDNQ\D�VHVXDL�GHQJDQ�
D]DV�³SDUL�SDVVX�SUR�UDWD�SDUWH´���5LFKDUG�
-��&RQYLVHU�(G�������������
� 'DU L � SHOEDJDL � XUDLDQ�
WHUVHEXW�GL�DWDV��WHUQ\DWD�SHQJHUWLDQ�D]DV�
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� PDVLK� EHOXP� XWXK� GDQ�
SDGX�� +DO� LQL� GDSDW� GLWHOXVXUL� GDUL�� D��
0DNQD� OHNVLNDO� WHUVHEXW� GL� DWDV� PH�
Q\DPDNDQ�DQWDUD�PDNQD�SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
GHQJDQ� NHVHLPEDQJDQ�� VHEDOLNQ\D� DGD�
MXJD�\DQJ�PHPEHGDNDQQ\D�
1DPXQ� SHPEHGDDQ� WHUKDGDS�
NHGXD�LVWLODK�WHUVHEXW�EHOXP�VHFDUD�WHJDV��
E��.HVHLPEDQJDQ�DFDSNDOL�GLDUWLNDQ�GDODP�
NHVDPDDQ�� VHEDQGLQJ� GDODP� MXPODK��
XNXUDQ�� DWDX� SRVLVL�� 'DODP� SHUVSHNWLI�
NRQWUDN�� D]DV� NHVHLPEDQJDQ� GLEHULNDQ�
SHQHNDQDQ�SDGD�SRVLVL�WDZDU�SDUD�SLKDN�
KDUXV� VHLPEDQJ�� 7LGDN� DGDQ\D� NH�
VH LPEDQJDQ � SRV L V L � SD UD � S L KDN �
PHQJDNLEDWNDQ� NRQWUDN� PHQMDGL� WLGDN�
VHLPEDQJ� GDQ� PHPEXND� SHOXDQJ�
LQ WH UYHQV L � SHQJXDVD� XQ WXN � PH�
Q\HLPEDQJNDQQ\D�� F�� 3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
�D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�� DFDSNDOL� VHNHGDU�
G LSDKDPL� GDODP� NRQWHNV� KXNXP�
SHPEXNWLDQ�� PHVNLSXQ� SDGD� GDVDUQ\D�
D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� KDUXV� GLPDNQDL�
VHEDJDL� SHPEDJLDQ� KDN� GDQ� NHZDMLEDQ�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
PHQXUXW�SURSRUVL�\DQJ�PHOLSXWL� VHJHQDS�
DVSHN�NRQWUDNWXDO�VHFDUD�NHVHOXUXKDQ�
0HQXUXW�SHQXOLV��SHQJHUWLDQ�D]DV�
NHVHLPEDQJDQ� OHELK� DEVWUDN� SH�
PDKDPDQQ\D� GLEDQGLQJNDQ� D]DV�
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�� 8QWXN� PHPXGDKNDQ�
SHPDKDPDQ�DQWDUD�NHGXD�D]DV�WHUVHEXW�
GDSDW� GLWHOXVXUL� PHODOXL� SHQGDSDW� SDUD�
VDUMDQD�� NDUDNWHULVWLN� PDXSXQ� GD\D�
NHUMDQ\D��
3 H P D K D P D Q � 0 D N Q D � $ ] D V �
3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV
6HPHQWDUD� L WX � DSDEL OD � G L �
EDQGLQJNDQ� GHQJDQ� XUDLDQ� GL� DWDV�
�PHQJHQDL�UXDQJ� OLQJNXS�GDQ�GD\D�NHUMD�
D]DV�NHVHLPEDQJDQ���PDND�UXDQJ�OLQJNXS�
GDQ� GD\D� NHUMD� D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
WDPSDN� OHELK� GRPLQDQ� SDGD� NRQWUDN��
'HQJDQ� DVXPVL� GDVDU� EDKZD� NDUDNWHU�
NRQWUDN�PHQHPSDWNDQ� SRVLVL� SDUD� SLKDN�
SDGD� NHVHWDUDDQ�� PDND� WXMXDQ� SDUD�
NRQWUDNDQ� \DQJ� EHURULHQWDVL� SDGD�
NHXQWXQJDQ�ELVQLV�DNDQ�WHUZXMXG��DSDELOD�
WHUGDSDW� SHUWXNDUDQ� KDN� GDQ� NHZDMLEDQ�
\DQJ�IDLU��SURSRUVLRQDO��
�$]DV�SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�WLGDN�GLOLKDW�
GDUL� NRQWHNV� NHVHLPEDQJDQ�PDWHPDWLV��
WHWDSL� SDGD� SURVHV� GDQ� PHNDQLVPH�
SHUWXNDUDQ� KDN� GDQ� NHZDMLEDQ� \DQJ�
EHUODQJVXQJ�VHFDUD�IDLU��
0HQXUXW� SHQGDSDW� SHQXOLV� XQWXN�
PHQFDUL� PDNQD� D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
GDODP�NRQWUDN�KDUXV�EHUDQMDN�GDUL�PDNQD�
ILORVRILV�NHDGLODQ��+DO� LQL�GDSDW�GLWHOXVXUL�
GDODP�EHUEDJDL�SHQGDSDW�VHUWD�SHPLNLUDQ�
SDUD� ILORVRI� GDQ� VDUMDQD�� )LORVRI� EHVDU�
VHSHUWL� $ULVWRWHOHV�� PHQ\DWDNDQ� EDKZD´�
MXVWLFH�FRQVLVWV�LQ�WUHDWLQJ�HTXDOV�HTXDOO\�
DQG�XQHTXDOV�XQHTXDOO\�� LQ�SURSRUWLRQ� WR�
WKHLU�LQHTXDOLW\´��SULQVLS�EDKZD�\DQJ�VDPD�
GLSHUODNXNDQ�VHFDUD�VDPD��GDQ�\DQJ�WLGDN�
VDPD� MXJD� GLSHUODNXNDQ� WLGDN� VDPD��
VHFDUD�SURSRUVLRQDO��
8 O S L DQXV � PHQJJDPED UNDQ �
NHDGLODQ�VHEDJDL�³MXVWLWLD�HVW�FRQVWDQV�HW�
SHUSHWXD� YROXQWDV� LXV� VXXP� FXLTXH�
WULEXHQGL´� �NHDGLODQ� DGDODK� NHKHQGDN�
\DQJ� WH UXV � PHQHUXV � GDQ � WH WDS �
PHPEHULNDQ�NHSDGD�PDVLQJ�PDVLQJ�DSD�
\DQJ�PHQMDGL�KDNQ\D�³WR�JLYH�HYHU\ERG\�
KLV�RZQ´���$UWLQ\D�NHDGLODQ�GDSDW�WHUZXMXG�
DSDELOD� VHVXDWX� \DQJ� GLEHULNDQ� NHSDGD�
VHVHRUDQJ� VHEDQGLQJ� GHQJDQ� \DQJ�
VHKD UXVQ\D � L D � W H U LPD � �S UDH WH U �
SURSRUWLRQHP�GLJQLWDV�LSVLXV��
3DGD� KDN LND WQ\D � JDJDVDQ�
WHUVHEXW� PHUXSDNDQ� WLWLN� WRODN� EDJL�
SHPDNQDDQ�D]DV�SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�GDODP�
KXEXQJDQ�NRQWUDNWXDO�SDUD�SLKDN��
'HPLNLDQ�SXOD�GHQJDQ�SDQGDQJDQ�
EHEHUDSD�VDUMDQD��VHSHUWL�3DXO�7LOOLFK��/�-��
YDQ� $SHOGRRUQ�� -�� YDQ� � .DQ� GDQ� -�+��
%HHNKXLV�� \DQJ� PHQ\DWDNDQ� EDKZD�
NHDGLODQ� LWX� PHPSHUODNXNDQ� VDPD�
WHUKDGDS� KDO� \DQJ� VDPD� GDQ� PHP�
SHUODNXNDQ� \DQJ� WLGDN� VDPD� VHEDQGLQJ�
GHQJDQ� NHWLGDNVDPDDQQ\D�� %HDXFKDPS�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
GDQ� %RZLH�� GHQJDQ� NULWHULD� SHPEDJLDQ�
SURSRUVLRQDOQ\D�� VHUWD� SHPLNLUDQ� -RKQ�
5DZOV� WHQWDQJ� ´MXVWLFH�DV� IDLUQHVV´� \DQJ�
PHQHNDQ� SULQVLS� KDN� EHUODQGDVNDQ�
UDVLRQDOLWDV�� NHEHEDVDQ� GDQ� NHVDPDDQ��
3�6�� $WLMDK� PHPEHULNDQ� ODQGDVDQ�
S H P L N L U D Q � P H Q J H Q D L � D ] D V �
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�GDODP�NDLWDQQ\D�GHQJDQ�
SHUDQ� NRQWUDN� VHEDJDL� ODQGDVDQ� SHU�
WXNDUDQ�\DQJ�DGLO�GL�GXQLD�ELVQLV��EDKZD�
WUDQVDNVL� SDUD� SLKDN� \DQJ� EHUNRQWUDN�
VHVXDL� GHQJDQ� DSD� \DQJ� GLLQJLQNDQ�
�SURSRUWLRQ�LQ�ZKDW�WKH\�ZDQW���3DQGDQJDQ�
SDUD�VDUMDQD�WHUVHEXW�GL�DWDV�PHUXSDNDQ�
GDVDU� EDJL� DUJXPHQWDVL� \DQJ� GLEDQJXQ�
XQWXN� PHUXPXVNDQ� PDNQD� D]DV�
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
0HQXUXW�/\RQV�VXDWX�LNOLP�NRQWUDN�
\DQJ� VHVXQJJXKQ\D�� SDGD� KDNLNDWQ\D�
PHPEHUL� SHOXDQJ� EDJL� SHUEHGDDQ�
SHQGDSDW�� WDZDU�PHQDZDU�� DWDX� EDKNDQ�
SHUEHGDDQ�SHUEHGDDQ� \DQJ� UHOHYDQ� GL�
DQWDUD� SDUD� SLKDN�� $UJXPHQ� NRQWUDN�
PHQXQWXW� SHUWXNDUDQ� JDJDVDQ� VHFDUD�
EHEDV� GDQ� PHODOXL� SURVHV�� PHPLQMDP�
LVWLODK�*DGDPHU��WR�DQG�IRU��SDGD�DNKLUQ\D�
VHPXD� SLKDN� DNDQ� VDPSDL� SDGD�
NHVHSDNDWDQ�EHUVDPD�PHQJHQDL�SULQVLS�
SULQVLS�NHDGLODQ�\DQJ�WHSDW�EDJL�PHUHND��
+DQ\D�GDODP�SURVHV�VHSHUWL�LQL�KDVLO�GDUL�
VXDWX� NHVHSDNDWDQ� VXQJJXK�VXQJJXK�
PHUHIOHNVLNDQ� NHSHQWLQJDQ� VHPXD� SLKDN�
�GDODP�$QGUH�$WD�8MDQ�������������
3DGD� GDVDUQ\D� D]DV� SURSRUVLR�
QDOLWDV� PHUXSDNDQ� SHUZXMXGDQ� GRNWULQ�
´NHDGLODQ� EHUNRQWUDN´� \DQJ� PHQJRUHNVL�
GRPLQDVL� D]DV� NHEHEDVDQ� EHUNRQWUDN�
\DQJ� GDODP� EHEHUDSD� KDO� MXVWUX�
PHQLPEXONDQ�NHWLGDNDGLODQ�
.RQUDG� =ZHLJHUW� GDQ� +HLQ� .RW]��
PHQJLQJDWNDQ� SDUD� VDUMDQD� XQWXN�
PHPEXDQJ�VLNDS�PHPSHUOLKDWNDQ�VHRODK�
RODK� NHEHEDVDQ� EHUNRQWUDN� PHUXSDNDQ�
SULQVLS� XWDPD� GDODP� SHPEHQWXNDQ�
XQGDQJ�XQGDQJ� NRQWUDN�� 7XJDV� XWDPD�
SDUD� VDUMDQD� NLQL� EXNDQ� ODJL� PHQJ�
DJXQJNDQ� NHEHEDVDQ� EHUNRQWUDN��
PHODLQNDQ�PHQFDUL�NULWHULD�VHUWD�SURVHGXU�
EDJL� SHUNHPEDQJDQ� GRNWULQ� ³NHDGLODQ�
NRQWUDNWXDO´��GDODP�6DNLQD�6KDLN�$KPDG�
<XVRII���������������
3HUZXMXGDQ� NHDGLODQ� EHUNRQWUDN�
GLWHQWXNDQ� PHODOXL� GXD� SHQGHNDWDQ��
3HUWDPD�� SHQGHNDWDQ� SURVHGXUDO�� SHQ�
GHNDWDQ� LQL� PHQLWLNEHUDWNDQ� SDGD�
SHUVRDODQ� NHEHEDVDQ� NHKHQGDN� GDODP�
VXDWX� NRQWUDN�� 3HQGHNDWDQ� NHGXD�� \DLWX�
SHQGHNDWDQ� VXEVWDQWLI� \DQJ� PHQHNDQ�
NDQGXQJDQ� DWDX� VXEVWDQVL� VHUWD�
SHODNVDQDDQ�NRQWUDN��'DODP�SHQGHNDWDQ�
VXEVWDQVWLI� SHUOX� GLSHUKDWLNDQ� DGDQ\D�
NHSHQWLQJDQ�\DQJ�EHUEHGD��
0HQJDPELO�PRUDOLWDV�SHUWLPEDQJ�
DQ� WHUVHEXW��PDND� D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
EHUPDNQD�VHEDJDL�´D]DV�\DQJ�PHODQGDVL�
DWDX� PHQGDVDUL� SHUWXNDUDQ� KDN� GDQ�
NHZDMLEDQ�SDUD�SLKDN�VHVXDL�SURSRUVL�DWDX�
EDJLDQQ\D�´� $]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
PHQJDQGD L N DQ � EH U O D QJVXQJQ\D �
PHNDQLVPH� SHPEDJLDQ� KDN� GDQ� NH�
ZDMLEDQ� VHFDUD� SURSRUVLRQDO� \DQJ� GL�
ZXMXGNDQ�GDODP�VHOXUXK�SURVHV�KXEXQJDQ�
NRQWUDNWXDO� � EDLN� SDGD� IDVH� SUD�
NRQWUDNWXDO�� SHPEHQWXNDQ� NRQWUDN�
PDXSXQ� SHODNVDQDDQ� NRQWUDN� $]DV��
SURSRUVLRQDO� VDQJDW� EHURULHQWDVL� SDGD�
NRQWHNV�KXEXQJDQ�GDQ�NHSHQWLQJDQ�SDUD�
S L K D N � �PHQ M D J D � N H O D Q J V XQJDQ �
KXEXQJDQ���
8QWXN�LWX�GDODP�NDMLDQ�LQL�GLDMXNDQ�
VXDWX� NULWHULD� \DQJ� GDSDW� GLMDGLNDQ�
SHGRPDQ� XQWXN� PHQHPXNDQ� D]DV�
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� GDODP� NRQWUDN�� VHEDJDL�
EHULNXW��D��NRQWUDN�\DQJ�EHUVXEVWDQVL�D]DV�
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� DGDODK� NRQWUDN� \DQJ�
PHPEHULNDQ� SHQJDNXDQ� WHUKDGDS� KDN��
SHOXDQJ� GDQ� NHVHPSDWDQ� \DQJ� VDPD�
NHSDGD� SDUD� NRQWUDNWDQ� XQWXN�PHQHQWX�
NDQ� SHUWXNDUDQ� \DQJ� DGLO� EDJL� PHUHND��
.HVDPDDQ� EXNDQ� GDODP� DUWL� ´NHVDPDDQ�
KDVLO´�PHODLQNDQ� SDGD� SRVLVL� SDUD� SLKDN�
\DQJ� PHQJDQGDLNDQ� ´NHVHWDUDDQ�
NHGXGXNDQ�GDQ�KDN��HTXLWDELOLW\�´��SULQVLS�
NHVDPDDQ� KDN�NHVHWDUDDQ� KDN��� E��
EH U O DQGDVNDQ � SDGD � NHVDPDDQ � �
NHVHWDUDDQ� KDN� WHUVHEXW�� PDND� NRQWUDN�
\DQJ� EHUVXEVWDQVL� D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
DGDODK� NRQWUDN� \DQJ� GLODQGDVL� ROHK�
NHEHEDVDQ� SDUD� NRQWUDNWDQ� XQWXN�
PHQHQWXNDQ�VXEVWDQVL�DSD�\DQJ�DGLO�GDQ�
DSD�\DQJ� WLGDN�DGLO�EDJL�PHUHND� �SULQVLS�
NHEHEDVDQ���F��NRQWUDN�\DQJ�EHUVXEVWDQVL�
D]DV�SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�DGDODK�NRQWUDN�\DQJ�
PDPSX�PHQMDPLQ� SHODNVDQDDQ� KDN� GDQ�
VHNDOLJXV� PHQGLVWULEXVLNDQ� NHZDMLEDQ�
VHFDUD�SURSRUVLRQDO�EDJL�SDUD�SLKDN��3HUOX�
GLJDULVEDZDKL� EDKZD� NHDGLODQ� WLGDN�
EHUDUWL� VHPXD� RUDQJ� KDUXV� VHODOX�
PHQGDSDWNDQ�VHVXDWX�GDODP�MXPODK�\DQJ�
VDPD�� GDODP� NRQWHNV� LQL� GLPXQJNLQNDQ�
DGDQ\D�KDVLO�DNKLU�\DQJ�EHUEHGD�
'DODP� KDO� LQL� PDND� SULQVLS�
GLVWULEXVL�SURSRUVLRQDO� WHUKDGDS� KDN� GDQ�
NHZDMLEDQ� SDUD� SLKDN� KDUXV� PHQJDFX�
SHUWXNDUDQ� \DQJ� IDLU� �SULQVLS� GLVWULEXVL�
SURSRUVLRQDO��
'HQJDQ�GHPLNLDQ��NRQWUDN�VHEDJDL�
SURVHV�PDWD�UDQWDL�KXEXQJDQ�SDUD�SLKDN�
KDUXV�GLEDQJXQ�EHUGDVDUNDQ�SHPDKDPDQ�
NHDGLODQ� \DQJ�GLODQGDVL� DWDV�SHQJDNXDQ�
KDN�SDUD�NRQWUDNWDQ��3HQJDNXDQ�WHUKDGDS�
HNVLVWHQVL� KDN� SDUD� NRQWUDNWDQ� WHUVHEXW�
WHUPDQLIHVWDVL�GDODP�SHPEHULDQ�SHOXDQJ�
GDQ� NHVHPSDWDQ� \DQJ� VDPD� GDODP�
SHUWXNDUDQ� NHSHQWLQJDQ� �KDN� GDQ�
NHZDMLEDQ���1DPXQ�GHPLNLDQ�SHQJDNXDQ�
WHUKDGDS�KDN��NHEHEDVDQ�GDQ�NHVDPDDQ�
GDODP� SHUWXNDUDQ� NHSHQWLQJDQ �KDN� GDQ��
NHZDMLEDQ�� WHUVHEXW� WHWDS� KDUXV� GDODP�
ELQJNDL� DWXUDQ� PDLQ� \DQJ� PHP�
SHUWLPEDQJNDQ� SULQVLS� GLVWULEXVL� \DQJ�
SURSRUVLRQDO��
8NXUDQ�SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�SHUWXNDU�
DQ� KDN� GDQ� NHZDMLEDQ� GLGDVDUNDQ� SDGD�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
QLODL�QLODL� NHVHWDUDDQ� �HTXLWDELOLW\���
NHEHEDVDQ�� GLVWULEXVL�SURSRUVLRQDO��
WHQWXQ\D�MXJD�WLGDN�GDSDW�GLOHSDVNDQ�GDUL�
D ]D V � D W DX � S U L Q V L S � N H FH UPD W DQ �
�]RUJYXOGLJKHLG��� NHOD\DNDQ� �UHGHOLMNKHLG��
UHDVRQDE OHQHVV � � GDQ � NHSD WX WDQ �
�ELOOLMNKHLG�� HTXLW\��� 8QWXN� PHQHPXNDQ�
D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� GDODP� NRQWUDN�
GHQJDQ�PHQJJXQDNDQ�NULWHULD�DWDX�XNXUDQ�
QLODL�QLODL�WHUVHEXW�GL�DWDV��KHQGDNQ\D�WLGDN�
GLDUWLNDQ� DNDQ� GLSHUROHK� KDVLO� WHPXDQ�
EHUXSD� DQJND�DQJND� PDWHPDWLV�� $]DV�
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� WLGDN� PHPSHUPDVDODK�
NDQ� NHVHLPEDQJDQ� �NHVDPDDQ�� KDVLO�
VHFDUD� PDWHPDW LV � � QDPXQ� OHE LK �
PHQHNDQNDQ�SURSRUVL�SHPEDJLDQ�KDN�GDQ�
NHZDMLEDQ� GL� DQWDUD� SDUD� SLKDN� \DQJ�
EHUODQJVXQJ�VHFDUD� OD\DN�GDQ�SDWXW� �IDLU�
DQG�UHDVRQDEOHQHVV��
3HQGDSDW� LQL�SHUOX�SHQXOLV�DMXNDQ�
XQWXN� PHQMDZDE� SHUWDQ\DDQ� PHQJHQDL�
DSD�PDNQD�� NULWHULD�PDXSXQ�ZXMXG�D]DV�
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV��%XNDQ�KDO�\DQJ�PXGDK��
EDKNDQ� PXVWDKLO� PHQLPEDQJ� DWDX�
PHQDNDU� KXEXQJDQ� NRQWUDNWXDO� \DQJ�
VHVXDL� GHQJDQ� D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
GDODP� EHQWXN� KDVLO� DNKLU� \DQJ� WHUXNXU�
VHFDUD� PDWHPDWLV�� $]DV�D]DV� SRNRN�
GDODP�KXNXP�NRQWUDN�\DQJ�ODLQ�SXQ�WLGDN�
DGD�\DQJ�PHPEHULNDQ�MDZDEDQ�\DQJ�SDVWL�
PHQJHQDL�PDNQD��NULWHULD�PDXSXQ�ZXMXG�
Q\DWDQ\D�� 1DPXQ� D]DV�D]DV� WHUVHEXW�
GDSDW� GLWHPXNDQ� GDQ� GLWHULPD� PHODOXL�
LQWHUSUHWDVL� \DQJ� NRPSUHKHQVLI�� GHQJDQ�
PHPSHUKDWLNDQ� NDUDNWHULVWLNQ\D� PDVLQJ�
PDVLQJ�
&RQWRK� VHGHUKDQD� \DQJ� GDSDW�
PHQMHODVNDQ� HNVLVWHQVL� GDQ� GD\D� NHUMD�
D]DV�SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV��VHEDJDL�EHULNXW��$�
GDQ�%�VHSDNDW�XQWXN�PHPEHOL�VHEXQJNXV�
URNRN�\DQJ�EHULVL����EDWDQJ�VHKDUJD�5S��
���������� VHFDUD� SDWXQJDQ� GDQ� DNDQ�
PHPEDJLQ\D� VHFDUD� SURSRUVLRQDO�� $�
PHPSXQ\DL� XDQJ� VHEHVDU� 5S�� ���������
GDQ�%��VHEHVDU�5S������������
6HFDUD� VHGHUKDQD� PDND� SHP�
EDJLDQ� KDN� GDQ� NHZDMLEDQ� \DQJ�
SURSRUVLRQDO� GDUL� NDVXV� GL� DWDV� DGDODK�
VHEDJDL� EHULNXW�� GDUL� EHEDQ� NHZDMLEDQ�
PHPED\DU�VHEHVDU�5S�����������PDND�$�
PHPSHUROHK� KDN� VHEDQ\DN� �� �GHODSDQ��
EDWDQJ� URNRN�� VHEDOLNQ\D�� %� \DQJ�
PHPED\DU� VHEHVDU� 5S�� ���������
PHPSHUROHK�KDN�VHEDQ\DN����GXD��EDWDQJ�
URNRN�
6HFDUD�PDWHPDWLV�� VHSLQWDV� KDVLO�
\DQJ� GLSHUROHK� PDVLQJ�PDVLQJ� SLKDN�
DGDODK�WLGDN�VDPD��WLGDN�VHLPEDQJ���WLGDN�
DGLO���+DO�LQL�GLNDUHQDNDQ�VHEDJLDQ�EHVDU�
SLKDN� KDQ\D� PHOLKDW� SHUEDQGLQJDQ�
WHUVHEXW� GDUL� KDVLO� DNKLU�� � �� �GHODSDQ��
EDWDQJ� ���� �GXD��EDWDQJ��1DPXQ�DSDELOD�
GLWLQMDX� GDUL� D]DV� SRUSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
SHPEDJLDQ�WHUVHEXW�DGLO�GDQ�SURSRUVLRQDO��
6H\RJ\DQ\D� SHQLODLDQ� DGLO� DWDX� WLGDN�
KDUXV� GLDQDOLVLV� VHFDUD� NRPSUHKHQVLI�
SDGD� VHOXUXK� SURVHV�� EDKZD� XQWXN�
PHPSHUROHK� �� �GHODSDQ�� EDWDQJ� URNRN�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
WHUVHEXW�$�GLEHEDQL�NHZDMLEDQ�PHPED\DU�
5S������������7HQWXQ\D�EHEDQ�NHZDMLEDQ�
LQL� OHELK� EHUDW� GLEDQGLQJNDQ� GHQJDQ�
NHZDMLEDQ�%�\DQJ�KDQ\D�PHPED\DU�5S��
���������
6 H K L Q J J D � Z D M D U � X Q W X N �
SHQJRUEDQDQ� \DQJ� OHELK� EHVDU� $�
PHPSHUROHK�KDVLO�\DQJ�OHELK�EHVDU�SXOD��
-DGL� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� KDUXV� GLKLWXQJ� GDUL�
DZDO�SURVHV�KLQJJD�KDVLO�DNKLUQ\D��
%DLN�$�PDXSXQ�%��NHGXDQ\D�VDPD�
PHPSHUROHK� URNRN� VHUWD� PHUDVDNDQ�
NHQLNPDWDQ� URNRN�� 3HUEHGDDQ� KDQ\D�
WHU OHWDN� MXPODK� GDQ� ODPD� ZDNWX�
PHQJKLVDS� URNRN�� QDPXQ� UDVD� URNRN�
VDPD�VDPD�GDSDW�GLQLNPDWL�NHGXDQ\D�
3URVHV� SHQ\HOHVDLDQ� WHUVHEXW� GL�
DWDV�PHQJJDPEDUNDQ�EDJDLPDQD�SULQVLS�
NHVDPDDQ� DWDX� NHVHWDUDDQ�� NHEHEDVDQ�
GDQ� GLVWULEXVL� SURSRUVLRQDO� EHUODQJVXQJ�
GHQJDQ�IDLU�
0HQ\LPDN� FRQWRK� GL� DWDV�� GDODP�
PHQLODL� SRVLVL� SDUD� SLKDN� VH\RJ\DQ\D�
WLGDN� VHFDUD�PHPEDEL� EXWD�PHQ\DWDNDQ�
NRQWUDN�WHUVHEXW�WLGDN�DGLO��1DPXQ�GDODP�
SHUVSHNWLI� D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� NRQWUDN�
�NODXVXO�NRQWUDN��WHUVHEXW�KDUXV�GLDQDOLVLV�
VHFDUD�RE\HNWLI��EDKZD�SHUEDQGLQJDQ�LWX�
DNDQ� GLWHULPD� VHEDJDL� SROD� SHPEDJLDQ�
�NHXQWXQJDQ�PDXSXQ�NHUXJLDQ��\DQJ�IDLU��
GHQJDQ� PHPSHUWLPEDQJNDQ� VHOXUXK�
SURVHV�GDQ�KDVLO�DNKLUQ\D��'HPLNLDQ�SXOD�
SHUOX� GLSHUWLPEDQJNDQ� GDUL� DVSHN� ELVQLV�
\DQJ� PHODQGDVL� KXEXQJDQ� SDUD� SLKDN��
VHKLQJJD� GDSDW� GLVLPSXONDQ� DSDNDK�
KXEXQJDQ� WHUVHEXW� VHFDUD� IDLU� GDSDW�
GLWHULPD�VHEDJDL�SROD�KXEXQJDQ�NRQ�
%HUGDVDUNDQ� FRQWRK� WHUVHEXW��
PDND� GDSDW� GLVLPSXONDQ� EDKZD� GD\D�
NHUMD� D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� PHOLSXWL�
SURVHV� SUD� NRQWUDN�� SHPEHQWXNDQ�
PDXSXQ� SHODNVDQDDQ� NRQWUDN�� $VXPVL�
NHVHWDUDDQ�SRVLVL�SDUD�SLKDN��WHUEXNDQ\D�
SHOXDQJ�QHJRVLDVL�VHUWD�DWXUDQ�PDLQ�\DQJ�
IDLU�PHQXQMXNNDQ�EHNHUMDQ\D�PHNDQLVPH�
SHUWXNDUDQ� KDN� GDQ� NHZDMLEDQ� \DQJ�
SURSRUVLRQDO�
'LVLQL�SUREOHPDWLND�PHQJHQDL�DGD�
DWDX�WLGDNQ\D�NHVHLPEDQJ�DQ�SDUD�SLKDN�
SDGD� GDVDUQ\D� NXUDQJ� UHOHYDQ� ODJL�
GLXQJNDSNDQ��NDUHQD�PHODOXL� NHVHWDUDDQ�
SRVLVL� SDUD� SLKDN�� WHUEXNDQ\D� SHOXDQJ�
QHJRVLDVL� VHUWD� DWXUDQ� PDLQ� \DQJ� IDLU��
PDND�VXEVWDQVL�NHVHLPEDQJDQ�LWX�VHQGLUL�
WHODK� WHUFDNXS� GDODP� PHNDQLVPH�
SHUWXNDUDQ� KDN� GDQ� NHZDMLEDQ� \DQJ�
SURSRUVLRQDO��
0HQXUXW� 1LHZHQKXLV�� VHSDQMDQJ�
SUHVWDVL�\DQJ�GLSHUMDQMLNDQ�EHUWLPEDO�EDOLN�
PHQJDQGDLNDQ� NHVHWDUDDQ� �SRVLVL� SDUD�
SLKDN��� PDND� DSDELOD� WHUMDGL� NHWLGDN�
VHLPEDQJDQ�� IRNXV� SHUKDWLDQ� DNDQ�
GLWLWLNEHUDWNDQ� SDGD� NHVHWDUDDQ� \DQJ�
WHUNDLW�GHQJDQ�FDUD�WHUEHQWXNQ\D�NRQWUDN��
GDQ� WLGDN� SDGD� KDVLO� DNKLU� GDUL� SUHVWDVL�
GLPDNVXG�� 3DQGDQJDQ� 1LHZHQKXLV� LQL�
W HQ WXQ\D � UH O HYDQ � GHQJDQ � D]DV �
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� GDODP� NRQWHNV� NRQWUDN�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
\DQJ�PHQHNDQNDQ�NHVHWDUDDQ�SRVLVL�GDQ�
SHUWXNDUDQ�SUHVWDVL� GL� DQWDUD�SDUD�SLKDN�
\DQJ�EHUNRQWUDN��-�+��1LHZHQKXLV��������
����
'HQJDQ�GHPLNLDQ�XQJNDSDQ�\DQJ�
EHUNHPEDQJ� GDODP� SUDNWLN� ELVQLV�
GLSHOEDJDL�WHPSDW�GDSDW�GLMDGLNDQ�VHEDJDL�
ODQGDVDQ�PRUDO� EDJL� D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOL�
WDV�� NKXVXVQ\D� GDODP� NRQWHNV� NRQWUDN��
EDKZD� ´HTXDO� SD\� IRU� HTXDO� ZRUN´�� ´\RX�
SD\�SHDQXW��\RX�JHW�PRQNH\´��SHGDJDQJ�
0LQDQJ� VHULQJ� PHQJDWDNDQ� ´UDQFDN� GL�
DZDN� UDQFDN� SXOR� GL� XUDQJ´�� GDODP�
NRPXQLWDV� -DZD�EDQ\DN� XQJNDSDQ� \DQJ�
PHQJJDPEDUNDQ� SURSRUV LRQDO L WDV�
WHUVHEXW�� PLVDO�� �SL\H� SDGD� SHQDNH� VLQJ�
SHQWLQJ�SDGD�PODNXQH����DWDX�´JROHN�DSLN�
ODQ� EHQHU�� JROHN� EHQHU� ODQ� DSLN´��
.HVHPXDQ\D� L WX � SDGD� GDVDUQ\D�
PHPSXQ\DL� NDQGXQJDQ� PRUDO L WDV�
SURSRUVLRQDO�� DUWLQ\D� NLWD�PHPDQJ� VDPD�
DSDELOD� PHPDQJ� VDPD�� QDPXQ� NLWD�
EHUEHGD�NDUHQD�SDGD�GDVDUQ\D�EHUEHGD��
EXNDQ�³VDPD�UDVD��VDPD�UDWD´��WDSL�³VDPD�
UDVD��VDPD�EDKDJLD�´�
)XQJVL�$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV
�'DODP�GXQLD�ELVQLV�SHUDQ� VHQWUDO�
DVSHN�KXNXP�NRQWUDN�GDODP�PHPELQJNDL�
SROD�KXEXQJDQ�KXNXP�SDUD�SLKDN�VHPDNLQ�
GLUDVDNDQ�XUJHQVLQ\D��'LVDGDUL�DWDX�WLGDN�
PDND� VHWLDS� ODQJNDK� ELVQLV� \DQJ�
GLODNXNDQ� ROHK� SDUD� SHODNX� ELVQLV�� SDGD�
GDVDUQ\D� DGDODK� PHUXSDNDQ� ODQJNDK�
KXNXP�� \DQJ� QRWD� EHQH� EHUDGD� SDGD�
UDQDK�KXNXP�NRQWUDN��
1DPXQ� GHPLNLDQ� PDVLK� WHUDVD�
EHWDSD�OHPDKQ\D�SHPDKDPDQ�VHPHQWDUD�
SLKDN��GLPDQD�KXNXP�ELVQLV�\DQJ�PHQMDGL�
ODQGDVDQ� VHWLDS� DNWLILWDV� ELVQLVQ\D�
DFDSNDOL�GLPDNQDL�VHEDWDV�SURGXN�DWXUDQ�
\DQJ�GLWHUELWNDQ�SHQJXDVD�
+DNLNDW� KXNXP� NRQWUDN� SDGD�
GDVDUQ\D� XQWXN� PHPHQXKL� NHEXWXKDQ�
KXNXP� SHODNX� ELVQLV�� GDODP� DUWL� WLGDN�
VHNHGDU� PHQJDWXU� QDPXQ� OHELK� GDUL� LWX�
PHPEHUL� NHOHOXDVDDQ� GDQ� NHEHEDVDQ�
VHSHQXKQ\D� NHSDGD� SDUD� SHODNX� ELVQLV�
XQWXN� PHQHQWXNDQ� DSD� \DQJ� PHQMDGL�
NHEXWXKDQ� PHUHND�� +DO� LQL� NDUHQD� SDUD�
SHODNX� ELVQLV� \DQJ� OHELK� SDKDP� GDQ�
PHQJHWDKXL� VHOXN� EHOXN� SHOEDJDL�
NHEXWXKDQ�GDODP�NHJLDWDQ�ELVQLVQ\D�
6HEDJDLPDQD� GLNHWDKXL� EDKZD�
GDODP�GXQLD�ELVQLV�\DQJ�PHPSHUWHPXNDQ�
SDUD� SHODNXQ\D� GDODP� DNWLILWDV� ELVQLV��
NRQWUDN� PHUXSDNDQ� LQVWUXPHQ� SHQWLQJ�
\DQJ� VHQDQWLDVD� PHPELQJNDL� KXEXQJDQ�
KXNXP� GDQ� PHQJDPDQNDQ� WUDQVDNVL�
PHUHND�
+DPSLU� WLDGD� VDWX� SXQ� DNWLILWDV�
ELVQLV�\DQJ�PHPSHUWHPXNDQ�SDUD�SHODNX�
ELVQLV� GDODP� SHUWXNDUDQ� NHSHQWLQJDQ�
PHUHND� WDQSD� NRQWUDN�� .RQWUDN� PHQ�
MDQJNDX� EHJLWX� OXDV� DVSHN� KXEXQJDQ�
PDV\DUDNDW�� VHEDJDLPDQD� GLXQJNDSNDQ�
ROHK�'�*��&UDFNQHOO��³FRQWUDFW�LV�RQH�RI�WKH�
IHZ� DUHDV� RI� ODZ� ZLWK� ZKLFK� DOPRVW�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
HYHU\RQH�FRPHV�LQWR�GD\�WR�GD\�FRQWDFW�´�
�'�*��&UDFNQHOO����������
0HQXUX W � 1 LHZHQKX LV � OD WD U �
EHODNDQJ�DWDX�UDVLR�NRQWUDN�EHUDQMDN�SDGD�
WXMXDQ� WHUMDGLQ\D� SHUWXNDUDQ� KDUWD�
NHND\DDQ� VHFDUD� DGL O � � UX L O UHFKW�
YDDUGLJKHLG��� 3HUWXNDUDQ� \DQJ� DGLO� �IDLU�
H[FKDQJH�� DNDQ� PXQFXO� DSDELOD� GDODP�
KXEXQJDQ� WHUVHEXW� WHUZXMXG� SHULNDWDQ�
\DQJ� EHULVL� SUHVWDVL� GHQJDQ� LPEDQJDQ�
NRQWUD� SUHVWDVL�� 0HQXUXW� 3�6�� $WLMDK��
NRQWUDN� PHUXSDNDQ� EHQWXN� SHUWXNDUDQ�
\DQJ�DGLO��IDLU�H[FKDQJH���́ ZKR�FRQWULEXWHG�
ZKDW´� � WHUNDL W � GHQJDQ� NHZDM LEDQ�
NRQWUDNWXDOQ\D� �H[FKDQJH� RI� REOLJDWLRQ��
\DQJ� GLGDVDUNDQ� SDGD� SURSRUVL� PDVLQJ�
PDVLQJ�� .RQWUDN� PHUXSDNDQ� EHQWXN�
SHUWXNDUDQ� \DQJ� VDOLQJ� PHQJXQWXQJNDQ�
�H[FKDQJH�EHQHILW�IRU�EHQHILW���.HZDMLEDQ�
NRQWUDNWXDO� WHUHEXW� WLGDN� ODLQ� PXQFXO�
NDUHQD� DGDQ\D� SHUWXNDUDQ� MDQML� GLDQWDUD�
SDUD� SLKDN� �H[FKDQJH� RI� SURPLVHV���
3HUWXNDUDQ�NHSHQWLQJDQ��SUHVWDVL�±�NRQWUD�
SUHVWDVL�� PHUXSDNDQ� WLWLN� WRODN� EDJL�
WHUZXMXGQ\D�NHDGLODQ�EDJL�SDUD�SLKDN��3�6��
$WLMDK��������������
0HQXUXW� 3�6�� $WL\DK�� NRQWUDN�
PHPLOLNL� WLJD� WXMXDQ�� \DLWX�� 3HUWDPD��
NRQWUDN� ZDMLE� XQWXN� GLODNVDQDNDQ�
�PHPDNVD��VHUWD�PHPEHULNDQ�SHUOLQGXQJ�
DQ� WHUKDGDS� VXDWX� KDUDSDQ� \DQJ� ZDMDU��
.HGXD�� NRQWUDN� EHUXSD\D� PHQFHJDK�
WHUMDGLQ\D� VXDWX� SHQDPEDKDQ� NHND\DDQ�
VHFDUD�WLGDN�DGLO��.HWLJD��NRQWUDN�EHUWXMXDQ�
XQWXN� PHQFHJDK� WHUMDGLQ\D� NHUXJLDQ�
WHUWHQWX�GDODP�KXEXQJDQ�NRQWUDNWXDO�
$SDELOD� GLWLQMDX� GDUL� DVSHN�
SHUDQFDQJDQ� NRQWUDN� �GUDIWLQJ��� NRQWUDN�
PHUXSDNDQ� GRNXPHQ� KXNXP� �OHJDO�
GRFXPHQW�� \DQJ� PHQHWDSNDQ� SURVHGXU�
GDQ� V\DUDW� GDODP� VXDWX� WUDQVDNVL� ELVQLV�
\DQJ� OHELK� ULQFL� GLEDQGLQJNDQ� GHQJDQ�
NRQWUDN� NRQVXPHQ�� 0HQXUXW� (OPHU�
'RRQDQ� GDQ� &KDUOHV� )RVWHU�� GHQJDQ�
GLWXDQJNDQQ\D� SURVHGXU� VHUWD� V\DUDW�
V\DUDW� VXDWX� WUDQVDNVL� ELVQLV� GDODP�
NRQWUDN�� SDUD� SLKDN� EHUPDNVXG�� XQWXN�
PHQ\HGLDNDQ� � EXNWL� WHUWXOLV� PHQJHQDL�
WUDQVDNVL� \DQJ� PHUHND� ODNXNDQ�� XQWXN�
PHQFHJDK� WHUMDGLQ\D� SHQLSXDQ�� XQWXN�
PHQHWDSNDQ� KDN� GDQ� NHZDMLEDQ� SDUD�
SLKDN�� GDQ� XQWXN�PHQJDWXU� VHFDUD� OHELK�
ULQFL�WUDQVDNVL�ELVQLV�\DQJ�NRPSOHN��GHPL�
PHQFHJDK�KDPEDWDQ�GDODP�SHODNVDQDDQ�
NRQWUDN�\DQJ�PHUHND�EXDW���(OPHU�'RRQDQ�
GDQ�&KDUOHV�)RVWHU������������
7HUNDLW� GHQJDQ� NRPSOHNVLWDV�
GDODP�NRQWUDN��FRPPHUFLDO�WUDQVDVFWLRQV��
DSDELOD� GLEDQGLQJNDQ� GHQJDQ� NRQWUDN�
NRQVXPHQ� �VLPSOH� FRQVXPHU� WUDQVDF�
WLRQV��� -�� %HDWVRQ� PHQJHPXNDNDQ�
EHEHUDSD�IXQJVL�NRQWUDN�\DQJ�PHPSXQ\DL�
NDUDNWHULVWLN� SHUWXNDUDQ� NHSHQWLQJDQ�
PHOLEDWNDQ�SHODNX�ELVQLV��EXVLQHVV�SHRSOH�
DQG� FRPSDQLHV��� \DLWX�� D�� NRQWUDN�
PHQ MDPLQ � KD UDSDQ � \DQJ � VD O L QJ �
GLSHUMDQMLNDQ� GL� DQWDUD� SDUD� SLKDN� DNDQ�
WHUSHQXKL � � DWDX� DNDQ� WHWDS� DGD�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
NRPSHQVDVL� \DQJ� GLED\DUNDQ� DSDELOD�
WH U MDG L � ZDQSUHV WDV L � � E � � NRQ W UDN �
PHPSHUPXGDKNDQ� UHQFDQD� WUDQVDNVL�
ELVQLV� PDVD� GHSDQ� GDUL� EHUEDJDL�
NHPXQJNLQDQ�\DQJ�PHUXJLNDQ��F��NRQWUDN�
PHQHWDSNDQ� VWDQGDU� SHODNVDQDDQ� GDQ�
WDQJJXQJ� MDZDE� SDUD� SLKDN�� G�� NRQWUDN�
PHPXQJNLQNDQ� SHQJDORNDVLDQ� ULVLNR�
ELVQLV� VHFDUD� OHELK� WHSDW� �PHPLQLPDOLVLU�
ULVLNR� ELVQLV� SDUD� SLKDN��� H�� NRQWUDN�
PHQ\HGLDNDQ� VDUDQD� SHQ\HOHVDLDQ�
VHQJNHWD� EDJL� SDUD� SLKDN�� �-�� %HDWVRQ��
����������
%HUDQMDN�GDUL�SHQGDSDW�EHEHUDSD�
VDUMDQD� WHUVHEXW� GL� DWDV�� PDND� GDSDW�
GLUXPXVNDQ� EHEHUDSD� IXQJVL� DWDX� DUWL�
SHQWLQJ� NRQWUDN� GDODP� ODOX� OLQWDV� ELVQLV��
DQWDUD� ODLQ�� D�� NRQWUDN� VHEDJDL� ZDGDK�
KXNXP� EDJ L � SD UD � S L KDN � GD O DP �
PHQXDQJNDQ�KDN�GDQ�NHZDMLEDQ�PDVLQJ�
PDV L QJ � � EH U W X ND U � N RQVHV L � G DQ �
NHSHQWLQJDQ���E��NRQWUDN�VHEDJDL�ELQJNDL�
DWXUDQ�PDLQ��F��NRQWUDN�VHEDJDL�DODW�EXNWL�
DGDQ\D� KXEXQJDQ� KXNXP�� F�� NRQWUDN�
PHPEHULNDQ� �PHQMDPLQ�� NHSDVWLDQ�
KXNXP��G��NRQWUDN�PHQXQMDQJ�LNOLP�ELVQLV�
\DQJ�NRQGXVLI��ZLQ�ZLQ�VROXWLRQ��HILVHLQVL�±�
SURILW��
$JDU� VXSD\D� SURVHV� SHUWXNDUDQ�
GDODP� NRQWUDN� EHUMDODQ� IDLU�� SDUD� SLKDN�
GLWXQWXW� XQWXN� PHPDKDPL� GDVDU�GDVDU�
KXNXP�NRQWUDN��0HQJDSD�SHPDKDPDQ�LQL�
GLSHUOXNDQ�� SHUOX� GLLQJDW� EDKZD� NRQWUDN�
\DQJ�GLEXDW�DWDX�GLVXVXQ�ROHK�SDUD�SLKDN�
SDGD�GDVDUQ\D�DGDODK�SHQXDQJDQ�SURVHV�
ELVQLV�NH�GDODP�UXPXVDQ�EDKDVD�KXNXP�
�NRQWUDN��� 'HQJDQ� PHPDKDPL� GDVDU�
GDVDU� KXNXP� NRQWUDN� GLPDNVXGNDQ� SDUD�
SLKDN� PHPSXQ\DL� SHGRPDQ� GDODP�
SHQ\XVXQDQ� NRQWUDN� � NDUHQD� � D� �
0HPEHULNDQ� GDVDU� KXNXP� EDJL� NRQWUDN�
\DQJ�GLEXDW��E��0HPEHULNDQ�ELQJNDL�DWDX�
UDPEX�UDPEX�DWXUDQ�PDLQ�GDODP�WUDQVDNVL�
ELVQLV��F��6HEDJDL�EDWX�XML�DWDX�WRORN�XNXU�
HNVLVWHQVL�NRQWUDN�\DQJ�EHUVDQJNXWDQ�
'DODP� KXEXQJDQQ\D� GHQJDQ�
NHJLDWDQ� ELVQLV�� NRQWUDN� EHUIXQJVL� XQWXN�
PHQJDPDQNDQ� WUDQVDNVL�� +DO� LQL� NDUHQD�
GDODP� NRQWUDN� WHUNDQGXQJ� VXDWX�
SHPLNLUDQ� �WXMXDQ�� DNDQ� DGDQ\D� NH�
XQWXQJDQ� NRPHUVLDO� \DQJ�GLSHUROHK�SDUD�
SLKDN�� 7HUNDLW� GHQJDQ� NRQWUDN� \DQJ�
EHURULHQWDVL� NHXQWXQJDQ� SDUD� SLKDN��
IXQJVL�D]DV�SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�PHQXQMXNNDQ�
SDGD � N D U D N W H U � N HJXQDDQ � \ DQJ �
RSHUDVLRQDO� GDQ� LPSOHPHQWDWLI� GHQJDQ�
WXMXDQ�PHZXMXGNDQ�DSD�\DQJ�GLEXWXKNDQ�
SDUD�SLKDN���
'HQJDQ� GHPLNLDQ� IXQJVL� D]DV�
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�� EDLN� GDODP� SURVHV�
SHPEHQWXNDQ� PDXSXQ� SHODNVDQDDQ�
NRQWUDN� DGDODK�� D�� 'DODP� WDKDS� SUD�
NRQWUDN�� D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�PHPEXND�
SHOXDQJ�QHJRVLDVL�EDJL�SDUD�SLKDN�XQWXN�
PHODNXNDQ�SHUWXNDUDQ�KDN�GDQ�NHZDMLEDQ�
VHFDUD� IDLU��2OHK�NDUHQD� LWX�DGDODK� WLGDN�
SURSRUVLRQDO� GDQ� KDUXV� GLWRODN� SURVHV�
QHJRVLDVL�GHQJDQ� LWLNDG�EXUXN��E��'DODP�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
SHPEHQWXNDQ�NRQWUDN��D]DV�SURSRUVLRQDO�
PHQMDPLQ� NHVHWDUDDQ� KDN� VHU WD �
NHEHEDVDQ�GDODP�PHQHQWXNDQ�PHQJDWXU�
SURSRUVL� KDN� GDQ� NHZDMLEDQ� SDUD� SLKDN�
EHUODQJVXQJ� VHFDUD� IDLU�� F�� 'DODP�
SHODNVDQDDQ� NRQWUDN�� D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDO�
PHQMDPLQ � WHUZXMXGQ\D� G LV W U LEXV L �
SHUWXNDUDQ� KDN� GDQ� NHZDMLEDQ� PHQXUXW�
SURSRUVL�\DQJ�GLVHSDNDWL�GLEHEDQNDQ�SDGD�
SDUD�SLKDN��G��'DODP�KDO�WHUMDGL�NHJDJDODQ�
GDODP�SHODNVDQDDQ�NRQWUDN��PDND�KDUXV�
GLQLODL� VHFDUD� SURSRUVLRQDO� DSDNDK�
NHJDJDODQ� WHUVHEXW� EHUVLIDW� IXQGDPHQWDO�
� I XQGDPHQ WD O � E UHDFK � � VHK LQJJD �
PHQJJDQJX� SHODNVDQDDQ� VHEDJDLDQ�
EHVDU�NRQWUDN�DWDX�VHNHGDU�KDO�KDO� \DQJ�
VHGHUKDQD�NHVDODKDQ� NHFLO� �PLQRU�
LPSRUWDQW��
2OHK�NDUHQD�LWX�SHQJXMLDQ�PHODOXL�
D]DV�SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�VDQJDW�PHQHQWXNDQ�
GDOLO�NHJDJDODQ�SHODNVDQDDQ�NRQWUDN��DJDU�
MDQJDQ� VDPSDL� WHUMDGL� SHQ\DODKJXQDDQ�
ROHK� VDODK� VDWX� SLKDN� GDODP� PH�
PDQIDDWNDQ� NODXVXO� NHJDJDODQ� SH�
ODNVDQDDQ� NRQWUDN�� VHPDWD�PDWD� GHPL�
NHXQWXQJDQ� VDODK� VDWX� SLKDN� GHQJDQ�
PHUXJLNDQ�SLKDN�ODLQ��H��%DKNDQ�GDODP�KDO�
W H U M DG L � VHQJNH WD � NRQ W UDN � � D]DV �
SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� PHQHNDQNDQ� EDKZD�
SURSRUVL�EHEDQ�SHPEXNWLDQ�NHSDGD�SDUD�
SLKDN�KDUXV�GLEDJL�PHQXUXW�SHUWLPEDQJDQ�
\DQJ�IDLU�
'HQJDQ� GHPLNLDQ� NRQWUDN� \DQJ�
PHUXSDNDQ�SURVHV�PDWD�UDQWDL�KXEXQJDQ�
SDUD� SLKDN� KDUXV� GLEDQJXQ� EHUGDVDUNDQ�
SHPDKDPDQ�NHDGLODQ�\DQJ�GLODQGDVL�DWDV�
SHQJDNXDQ� KDN� SDUD� NRQWUDNWDQ��
3HQJDNXDQ�WHUKDGDS�HNVLVWHQVL�KDN�SDUD�
NRQWUDNWDQ� WHUVHEXW� WHUPDQLIHVWDVL� GDODP�
SHPEHULDQ�SHOXDQJ�GDQ�NHVHPSDWDQ�\DQJ�
VDPD� GDODP� SHUWXNDUDQ� KDN� GDQ�
NHZDMLEDQ�VHFDUD�SURSRUVLRQDO��7HQWXQ\D�
IXQJVL�D]DV�SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�VHEDJDL�EDWX�
XML�GDODP�SHODNVDQDDQ�SHUWXNDUDQ�KDN�GDQ�
NHZDMLEDQ�NRQWUDNWXDO�PHQMDGL�UHOHYDQ�GDQ�
SHQWLQJ�
%HUDQMDN� GDUL� SDSDUDQ� SHP�
EDKDVDQ� WHUVHEXW� GLDWDV�� PDND� WHUGDSDW�
EHEHUDSD� UHNRPHGDVL� SHQWLQJ� WHUNDLW�
GHQJDQ�NHEHUDGDDQ�D]DV�SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
VHEDJDL� SHUZXMXGDQ� GRNWULQ� NHDGLODQ�
EHUNRQWUDN�� VHEDJDL� EHULNXW�� +DNLNDW�
NRQWUDN� DGDODK� PHZXMXG�NDQ� SHUWXNDUDQ�
KDN�GDQ�NHZDMLEDQ�VHFDUD�DGLO��IDLUQHVV���
'HQJDQ� GHPLNLDQ�� NHWLGDNVHLPEDQJDQ�
KDVLO�GDSDW�GLWHULPD�VHEDJDL�VHVXDWX�\DQJ�
IDLU�DSDELOD�SURVHV�SHUWXNDUDQ�KDN�GDQ�NH�
ZDMLEDQ�EHUODQJVXQJ�VHFDUD�SURSRUVLRQDO�
0DNQD� D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV�
DGDODK� D]DV� \DQJ� PHQJDWXU� SHUWXNDUDQ�
KDN� GDQ� NHZDMLEDQ� SDUD� SLKDN� VHVXDL�
SURSRUVL� DWDX� EDJLDQQ\D�� \DQJ� PHOLSXWL�
VHOXUXK�SURVHV�NRQWUDN��EDLN�SDGD�WDKDSDQ�
SUD� NRQWUDNWXDO�� SHPEHQWXNDQ� NRQWUDN�
PDXSXQ� SHODNVDQDDQ� NRQWUDN�� )XQJVL�
D]DV� SURSRUVLRQDOLWDV� GDODP� NRQWUDN�
NRPHUVLDO� DGDODK�� �L�� GDODP� WDKDSDQ� SUD�
NRQWUDN�� PHPMDPLQ� WHUZXMXGQ\D� SURVHV�
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
QHJRVLDVL� NRQWUDN� \DQJ� IDLU�� �LL�� GDODP�
SHPEHQWXNDQ� NRQWUDN� � PHQMDPLQ�
NHVHWDUDDQ� KDN� VHUWD� NHEHEDVDQ� GDODP�
PHQHQWXNDQ� LVL� NRQWUDN�� �LLL�� GDODP�
SH ODNVDQDDQ� NRQW UDN � � PHQ MDPLQ �
WHUZXMXGQ\D�GLVWULEXVL�SHUWXNDUDQ�KDN�GDQ�
NHZDMLEDQ�VHVXDL�SURSRUVLQ\D�
'$)7$5�3867$.$
$%� 0DVVLHU�� 0DUMDQQH� 7HUPRUVKXL]HQ�$UWV�� ,QGRQHVLVFKH�1HGUODQGV�:RRGHQERHN� 3ULYDDWUHFKW��.,7/9� 8LWJHYHULM�� /HLGHQ�������
$QGUH�$WD�8MDQ����.HDGLODQ�GDQ�'HPRNUDVL��7HODDK� )LOVDIDW� 3ROLWLN� -RKQ�5DZOV��� .DQLVLXV�� <RJMDNDUWD�������
'DYLG�2XJKWRQ��DQG�0DUWLQ�'DYLV��6RXUFH�QG
%RRN�RQ�&RQWUDFW�/DZ��� �(G���&DYHQG L VK � 3XE O L V K L QJ � �/RQGRQ�������
'��*��&UDFNQHOO��2EOLJDWLRQ��&RQWUDFW�/DZ��2OG� %DLOH\� 3UHVV�� /RQGRQ�������
(�� 6XPDU\RQR�� � (WLND� 3URIHVL� +XNXP��.DQLVLXV��<RJ\DNDUWD�������
(OPHU� 'RRQDQ�� GDQ� &KDUOHV� )RVWHU��' U D I W L Q J � � & D Y H Q G L V K �3XEOLVKLQJ� /LPLWHG�� /RQGRQ�������
)�3�+��3ULFN�YDQ�:HO\����.UDPHUV�(QJHOV�:RRUGHQERHN�� *UDYHQKDJH��'MDNDUWD�������
-�� +�� 1LHZHQKXLV�� 'ULH� %HJLQVHOHQ� YDQ�&RQWUDFWHQUHFKW�� .OXZHU�'HYHQWHU�������
-�� YDQ� �.DQ�� -��+��%HHNKXLV��3HQJDQWDU�
, O P X � + X N X P � � * K D O L D �,QGRQHVLD��-DNDUWD�������
-�� � %HDWVRQ�� $QVRQV� /DZ� RI� &RQWUDFW��2[IRUG� 8QLYHUVLW\� 3HVV��/RQGRQ�������
-DPHV� 3HQQHU�� HW�� DO� � �HGLWRUV���,QWURGXFWLRQ� WR� -XULVSUXGHQFH�D Q G � / H J D O � 7 K H R U \ ��&RPPHQWDU\� DQG�0DWHULDOV���%XWWHUZRUWKV��/RQGRQ�������
-RKQ�5DZOV���$�7KHRU\�RI�-XVWLFH��5HYLVHG�(GLWLRQ��7KH�%HONQDS�3UHVV�RI�+DUYDUG� 8QLYHUVLW\� 3UHVV� RI�&DPEULJGH�� 0DVVDFKXVHWWV�������
������������� (WLND� +XNXP� 5HOHYDQVL� 7HRUX�+XNXP� .RGUD W � 7KRPDV�$ T X L Q D V � � . D Q L V L X V � �<RJ\DNDUWD�������
.�� %HUWHQV�� 3HQJDQWDU� (WLND� %LVQLV��.DQLVLXV��<RJMDNDUWD�������
/�� -�� YDQ� $SHOGRRUQ�� �� 3HQJDQWDU� ,OPX�+XNXP�� FHW�� [[[�� 3UDGQ\D�3DUDPLWD��-DNDUWD�������
0DQXHO� *� 9HODVTXH]���� (WLND� %LVQLV�.RQVHS� GDQ� .DVXV�� �$OLK�EDKDVD�$QD�3XUZDQLQJVLK�HW��DO����$QGL��<RJ\DNDUWD�������
0DUMDQQH�7HUPRUVKXL]HQ���.DPXV�+XNXP�% H O D Q G D � , Q G R Q H V L D � �'MDPEDWDQ�-DNDUWD�������
1��(��$OJUD����HW��DO���.DPXV�,VWLODK�+XNXP�)RFNHPD�$QGUHDH�%HODQGD�±�,QGRQHVLD�� � %LQD� &LSWD��-DNDUWD�������
2��1RWRKDPLGMRMR��0DVDODK��.HDGLODQ��7LUWD�$PHUWD��6HPDUDQJ�������
3��6�� �$WLMDK��3URPLVHV��0RUDOV�DQG�/DZ��&ODUHQGRQ� 3UHVV�� 2[IRUG��
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���
�����
��������������� 3URPLVHV�� 0RUDOV� DQG� /DZ��&ODUHQGRQ� 3UHVV�� 2[IRUG�������
3DXO� 7LOOLFK�� � � &LQWD�� .HNXDVDDQ� GDQ�.HDGLODQ�� 3XVWDND� (XUHND��6XUDED\D�������
5D\PRQG � :DFNV � -X U L VS UXGHQFH � �%ODFNVWRQH� 3UHVV� /LPLWHG��/RQGRQ�������
5LFKDUG� -�� &RQYLVHU�� �(G����*LOEHUW� /DZ�6XPPDULHV� 'LFWLRQDU\� RI�/HJDO� 7HUPV�� +DUFRXUW� %UDFH�-RYDQRY L FK � /HJD O � DQG �3URIHVVLRQDO� 3XEOLFDWLRQV��,QF���&KLFDJR�������
�������������������������9ROXPH�;,,�1R����7DKXQ������(GLVL�6HSWHPEHU3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
$]DV�3URSRUVLRQDOLWDV�6HEDJDL�
3HUZXMXGDQ�'RNWULQ�.HDGLODQ�%HUNRQWUDN
$JXV�<XGKD�+HUQRNR
3(563(����
��������������������
7,)HDGLODQ
���