Perception of British English vowels by Persian listeners

53
Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568 Perception of British English vowels by Persian listeners Abstract The perceptual difficulties encountered by the listeners in identification of Second language (L2) vowel sounds have been investigated by many studies of L2. The attribution of foreign accented speech production to the learners’ inaccurate perception of non-native vowel sounds has been also discussed by some researchers (Escudero, 2005). The interference of the first language (L1) in L2 acquisition and development is highlighted as the most essential influence involved in L2 learners’ perception problems by recent studies. The purpose of the present study is to explore and analyse the Persians’ identification of British English (BE) vowels based on Second Language Linguistic Perception (L2Lp) and vowel inventories. In particular, the study attempts at investigating the possible difficulties encountered by Persian speakers of English in catergorisation of BE Vowel contrast /I/-/i:/ and /ɔ/ vowel sound. A total of three female native Persian and one male non-native Persian speaker of English of first-year postgraduate TESOL students currently studying at the University of Western Sydney who were between the 21 and 31 years of age participated in the present study. Three listeners were bilingual and one listener was multilingual. An identification task revealed that three listeners did not have difficulty in their perception of the selected English vowels and 1 School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Transcript of Perception of British English vowels by Persian listeners

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Perception of British English vowels by

Persian listeners

Abstract

The perceptual difficulties encountered by the listeners in

identification of Second language (L2) vowel sounds have been

investigated by many studies of L2. The attribution of foreign

accented speech production to the learners’ inaccurate perception

of non-native vowel sounds has been also discussed by some

researchers (Escudero, 2005). The interference of the first

language (L1) in L2 acquisition and development is highlighted as

the most essential influence involved in L2 learners’ perception

problems by recent studies. The purpose of the present study is

to explore and analyse the Persians’ identification of British

English (BE) vowels based on Second Language Linguistic

Perception (L2Lp) and vowel inventories. In particular, the study

attempts at investigating the possible difficulties encountered

by Persian speakers of English in catergorisation of BE Vowel

contrast /I/-/i:/ and /ɔ/ vowel sound. A total of three female

native Persian and one male non-native Persian speaker of English

of first-year postgraduate TESOL students currently studying at

the University of Western Sydney who were between the 21 and 31

years of age participated in the present study. Three listeners

were bilingual and one listener was multilingual. An

identification task revealed that three listeners did not have

difficulty in their perception of the selected English vowels and

1School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

therefore the research predictions and L2LP model were not

supported by their results. Contrastively, the results of the

multilingual listener was in line with the research’s prediction

in respect to difficulty in classification of /I/ -/i:/ and

thus the predication and L2LP model were partially supported.

This finding confirms that the perception difficulty can be

caused by the absence of some L2 vowels in L1 vowel inventory.

Introduction

Over the last few decades, English has become the most widespread

language around the world spoken by people of diverse linguistic

backgrounds. Most Second language (L2) learners of English aim

to communicate effectively with non-native and native speakers of

English and to achieve this they need to be able to accurately

perceive the non-native sounds such as vowels that are not

present in their native language. Differences in perception of

English vowels by non-native learners of English result in

various and often accented speech production. L2 listeners may

encounter difficulty in categorization of the L2 vowels which may

have different acoustic properties from their native vowel

inventory (Bradlow 1993, Fox et al. 1995, Levy & Strange 2008,

Polka 1995, Scholes 1967 & 1968, Terbeek 1977). perceptual

difficulty has been identified as a basis for the insufficient

production of L2 Vowel sounds due to the influence of L1 system

as a 'phonological filter' (Trubetzkoy, 1969). According to

2School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Trubetzkoy, the perception and classification of L2 sounds occur

through L2 phonological filtering system.

Many believe that foreign accent originate from the specific –

language perceptual patterns used by the L2 learners of English

(Ekman, 2004, Escudero, 2007). According to Ekman and Escudero

(2004), these strategies are so strongly established in L2

learners’ mind that the use of them in the L2 acquisition process

is inevitable. The perception of English vowels across the

speakers of different languages widely varies. Thus, a word may

be pronounced differently on the basis of the individual

variations of the speakers of a language (Hall, 2007).

Several empirical studies have considered different aspects of L2

pronunciation and identified vowels as being the most challenging

aspect for L2 learners (Bohn & Flege, 1990, 1992, 1997; Ingram

and Park, 1997, Morrison, 2008, 2009). Other researchers have

revealed some differences in the degree of difficulty in L2

pronunciation among the learners. Accordingly, individual

variations such as the age of acquisition and length of residence

influence the extent of foreign accent (Flege, Birdsong,

Bialystok, Mack, Sung and Tsukada, 2006; MacKay, Flege and Imai,

2006; see also Piske, MacKay, and Flege, 2001). Cross-linguistic

studies on the notion of speech perception have also demonstrated

a relevance of linguistic experience to the recognition of native

and L2 speech sounds. For instance, Flege (1994) indicated the

impact of the degree of English exposure and proficiency on the

perception of non-native vowels by the native Spanish speakers.3

School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Swan and Smith (1987) also believe that the pronunciation errors

made by the L2 learners of English are due to the influence of

the vowel inventories and the perceptual patterns in their first

languages.

As addressed to by the Second Language Linguistic Perception

(L2Lp) model (Escudero, 2005), full copying of the first language

(L1) system and mechanisms are the bases for acquiring the L2

perception system. ((Boersma, Escudero & Hayes, 2003). The

Speech Learning Model (SLM) developed by Fledge (1992) aims to

explain the influence of t the age- related issues on listeners’

ability to produce L2 vowel and consonants in a native-like

manner.

Similarly, a few studies have been carried out to investigate the

perception of English vowels by native speakers of Persian. Hall

(2007) from the results of a study that she has conducted in

Australia proposed that phonological characteristics of Farsi

interfere with the intelligibility of Persian speakers of English

in their interaction with L1 Australian English speakers. This

can be interpreted as that inaccurate perception of English vowel

categories by Persian speakers of English results in an accented

speech production which consequently influences their

intelligibility to L1 English speakers.

The tense and lax distinction in English vowel inventory has been

identified as one of the most challenging areas in perception of

English categories for Iranian speakers of English (Bakhtiarvand,

2006). According to Bakhtiarvand (2006), the perception and

4School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

pronunciation of the tense and lax vowel contrasts of English

such as /I/-/i:/ are so identical by Persians as if they are the

same vowels. For instance Iranians may perceive and produce such

words as ‘sleep’ in the same way as ‘slip’.

A study by Hunter and Kebede (2012) on the notion of English

vowels’ pronunciation by Farsi speakers also revealed that the

absence of some English categories in Farsi vowel inventory may

result in the failure of Farsi speakers of English in correct

pronunciation of those vowels. Keshavarz (1994) also pointed out

that Persians may make some phonological errors due to the

absence of certain English tokens in Farsi vowel inventory.

According to him, Persian speaking listeners of English have

difficulty with the English vowel sound /I/ as it does not exist

in Farsi. Lack of such English vowels as /I/ in’ bit’ and / ɔ/ in

the middle vowel sound of ‘sympathy’ has been also identified as

cause of perception difficulty for Persian speakers of English by

Seddighi (2010).

“Farsi” or “Parsi” referred to as indigenous name of the Persian

language is known as the national and official language of Iran

(Akbarzadeh, 2005). Farsi, a branch of Indo-European languages

is a quiet widespread language spoken by over 70 million speakers

in Iran and other countries like Afghanistan, Tajikistan and

Pamir mountain areas (Hall, 2007). As demonstrated in Figure 1,

Persian includes 6 vowels: three lax vowels (/ɒː/, /e/, /o/) and

three tense vowels (/æ/, /i:/, /o:/) (Bakhtiarvand, 2006).

5School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Figure1. Farsi/Persian vowels chart

In contrast, British English has 11 distinct vowels (/i/,

/I/,/ɛ/, / æ/, /ɑ/, / ɒ/, / ɔ/, /ʊ/, / u/, /ʌ/, /ɜ/). As it can

be seen in figure 2, the 5 English vowels (/I/, /ɛ/, / ʊ/, / ʌ/,/

ɔ/) are absent in Farsi vowel system ( Hall, 2007)

Figure2. British English vowel chart

The general objective of the present study was to explore the

difficulties encountered by the Persian learners of English in

their perception of English vowels. In particular, this study

attempted to find out whether native-Persian listeners were able

to correctly identify the BE /I/ and /i/ contrasts as well as /ɔ/

sound. Several studies have been conducted to explore the

weaknesses and strengths of native Farsi speakers’ in acquisition

6School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

of the English sound system. Hunter and Kebede (2012) have

postulated that L1 Farsi listeners usually get confused in their

attempts at pronunciation of /I/ and /i/. The present study also

attempted to predict the problems faced by Persian listeners in

perceiving the English vowels.

To explain and analyse L2 perceptual difficulties, three

theoretical speech perception models including Speech Learning

Model (SLM), Perceptual Assimilation Model (PAM) and Second

Language Linguistic Perception (L2Lp) can be used by researchers.

According to PAM (Best, 1995) and L2Lp (Escudero, 2005) model,

listeners’ difficulty in perceiving L2 new vowel sounds can be

predicted based on their linguistic background. The models

explain that catergorisation and filtration of the L2 sounds by

the L2 learners are possible through the vowel sounds existing in

their L1 vowel inventory (Elvin & Escudero, 2014). L2Lp

The study’s hypotheses were made on the basis of L2LP (Escudero,

2005) model which attempts to predict and analyse the L2 sound

categorization at all stages of learning as well as the vowel

inventories of Persian and English languages. Accordingly, it was

predicted that native-Persian listeners would have difficulty in

perception of the English vowel pairs /I/, i:/. As some English

vowels do not exist in the six-vowel inventory of Farsi, Persian

speakers of English would have difficulties perceiving those

absent vowels. As stated by Hale (2007), /i/ in Farsi is similar

to the close-front-tense /i/ in English, while half-close, front

7School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

lax English vowel /I/ is not present in Farsi. Hence, /i/ may be

used instead of /I/ occasionally by Farsi speakers of English.

The fact that the Farsi vowel inventory is characterized as a

typical six-vowel system suggests that Farsi speakers of English

would have difficulties producing English vowels that do not

exist in the Farsi vowel system. For instance, in Farsi, /i/ is

similar to the close-front-tense /i:/ in English but /I/, which

is a half-close, front-lax vowel in English is absent in Farsi.

Thus, the result will be the use of /i/ instead of /I/ which

would create misunderstanding and in some cases embarrassment for

Farsi speakers of English. For example, some may pronounce the

words ‘ship’ and ‘sheep’ the same. This scenario may also happen

in many other words such as: ‘eat/it; keen/kin; seen/sin;

heat/hit; least/list; beat/bit, and cheap/chip

Persian listeners would also encounter difficulty when attempting

to identify the English / ɔ/ sound as it is not present in

Persian vowel inventory. They would be likely replace the English

vowel / ɔ/ with /e/ vowel from their L1 vowel inventory.

As L2Lp model suggests, the perceptual patterns used by Native-

Persian learners of English in recognition of the English vowels

may differ due to their individual variations.

Method of the research

8School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Listeners

A total of four native and non-native Persian-speakers of English

participated in the present study. All participants were of first

– year postgraduate students of TESOL currently studying at the

University of Western Sydney. The listeners included three female

native Persian and one male non-native Persian speaker of English

between the ages of 21 and 31. Three participants have been

living in Australia for more than one year and one was born and

was grown up in Australia. One listener was multilingual and

three were bilinguals. With respect to the length of residence

and exposure to English in terms of naturalness and formality,

individual variations were demonstrated across the listeners. All

participants, except the one born in Australia had commenced

their acquisition of English at young age at private language

institutes or High schools in Iran. In terms of formal exposure

to English, two listeners had reached to tertiary level and one

to advanced level through studying at an English language

institute in Iran. In respect to natural exposure, the

participant who was born and grown up in Australia had a chance

of naturally being exposed to English from the early childhood.

The multilingual listener’s exposure to such different languages

as Arabic, Farsi, Spanish and English was noticeable among the

other participants.

Stimuli or sounds

9School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

The participants listened to the contrasts /ɪ/ and /i: / as well

as particular /ɔ/ sound of the BE vowel inventory. The listeners

listened to the selected vowels in terms of the categories [heed]

and [hid] for the perception of /ɪ/ and /i: / sounds and [caught]

for the identification of /ɔ/ sound. The two Be /æ/ and /ʊ/

vowels were also included as distracters. Thus, the listeners

subsequently listened to /æ/ and /ʊ/ vowels in terms of the

categories [had] and [hood]. Each vowel sound was randomly

listened to for eighteen times by each individual listener.

Hence, the listeners were exposed to 3x18 + 2x 18 English vowels

for a total of 90 sounds.

Tasks

An identification task presented in Pratt software program was

administered to determine the extent to which the Participants

were able to identify the English vowels. The experiment was

conducted in a quite computer room where all listeners were

exposed to five English response categories orthographically

showed on the computers’ screens. A standard computer and a

headphone were provided to each participant and the instructions

were given in English. The listeners’ task was to classify the

selected auditory tokens of English in respect to those five

categories which were all actual English words. The sounds that

were played, were the synthesised sounds taken from Escudero and

Chladkova’s study (2010). The participants were allowed to

frequently listen to the vowel sounds at their own pace as well

10School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

as take three short breaks. The listeners were tested in one

session lasting less than 10 minutes.

Results

The assessment of the selected English vowels revealed that most

were perceived in accordance to the proposed English categories

by three of the listeners. This indicates that three participants

had high-level of capability and competence in correct perception

of the English input tokens and one did not. Thus the results are

not in line with the research’s predictions. Table 1 shows the

outcomes obtained from the listener 1. As indicated in this

table, the vowel contrast /I/- /i:/ and vowel / ɔ/ are

perceived accurately with random occurrence of a few mistakes.

The results from the listener 2 informed similar performances and

accuracy level in classification of the intended English

categories. According to table 2, the listener 2 accuracy level

in perception of the English contrast /I/-/I:/ and vowel /ɔ/

has subsequently been seventeen and sixteen correct responses out

of 18 . In contrast, the obtained results from the listener 3,

revealed a significant difference with respect to the perception

of the English contrast /I/ - /i:/. The difficulty level of this

listener in categorisation of /I/-/i:/ contrast is demonstrated

in table 3 as 14 inaccurate and 4 accurate responses. Table 4

indicates the outcomes of the listener 4 which is identical to

the results of the listener 1 and listener 2 in respect to

identification of the selected English vowels. All listeners were

11School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

able to correctly identify the distractors sounds which validates

the task.

Table 1: Perception of vowel contrast /I/ - /i:/ and vowel / / by listener 1

ResponsesSounds Caught

(distractor)

Had Heed Hid Hood(distractor)

Caught 16 18 0 0 0Had 0 0 0 0 0Heed 0 0 16 2 0Hid 0 0 2 16 0Hood 2 0 0 0 18

Figure 1: perception of BE vowel contrast /I/-/i:/ by listener 1

caught had heed hid hood0

5

10

15

20

Listener 1

caught had heed hid hood

Sounds

Num

ber o

f sou

nds

12School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Table 2: Perception of BE vowel contrast /I/ - /i:/ and vowel / / by listener 2

ResponsesSounds Caught

(distractor)

Had Heed Hid Hood(distractor)

Caught 18 18 0 0 1Had 0 0 0 0 0Heed 0 0 17 1 0Hid 0 0 0 17 0Hood 0 0 1 0 17

Figure2: Perception of BE vowel contrast /I/-/i:/ by listener 2

13School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

caught had heed hid hood 02468101214161820

Listener 2

caught had heed hid hood

Sounds

Num

ber o

f sou

nds

Table 3: Perception of BE vowel contrast /I/ - /i:/ and vowel / / by listener 3

ResponsesSounds Caught

(distractor)Had Heed Hid Hood

(distractor)Caught 18 18 0 0 1Had 0 0 0 0 0Heed 0 0 4 0 0Hid 0 0 14 0 0Hood 0 0 0 18 17

14School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Figure3: Perception of BE vowel contrast /I/-/i:/ by listener 3

caught had heed hid hood 02468101214161820

Listener 3

caught had heed hid hood

Sounds

Num

ber o

f sou

nds

15School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Table 4: Perception of BE vowel contrast /I/ - /i:/ and vowel / / by listener 4

ResponsesSounds Caught

(distractor)Had Heed Hid Hood

(distractor)Caught 16 18 0 0 1Had 0 0 0 0 0Heed 0 0 18 2 0Hid 0 0 0 16 0Hood 2 0 0 0 17

Figure 4: Perception of BE vowel contrast /I/-/i:/ and / / vowel sound

caught had heed hid hood 0

4

8

12

16

20

Listener 4

caught had heedhid hood

Sounds

Num

ber o

f sou

nds

16School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Discussion

The study aimed to investigate the perceptual difficulties

encountered by Persian speakers of English in their

identification of BE English vowel sounds. The results addressed

the aim but did not support the predictions.

Prediction 1 posited that the native Persian speakers of English

experience difficulty in perception of vowel contrast /I/-/i:/ as

the front- lax English vowel /I/ does not exist in Farsi vowel

inventory. Accordingly, the Persian speakers of English

perception of vowel contrast /I/-/i:/ may be very similar as if

they are the same vowels. The results obtained from three

listeners did not support the prediction1 .Contrastively, the

results of one listener were in line with the prediction 1 and

therefore it was partially supported.

These unanticipated results may be analysed through a comparison

of the listeners’ linguistic background such as the number of

vowel inventories they know and their length of formal or natural

exposure to English. As previously mentioned, three listeners did

not encounter difficulty in perception of the selected vowel

contrast /I/-/I:/. It worth mentioning that these listeners were

all bilingual native-Persian speakers of English who had formal

phonological training and were exposed to this language at young

age in language institutes, High Schools or universities in Iran.

Additionally, these participants were current Postgraduate TESOL

students at the University of Western Sydney. Thus, they were all

17School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

familiar with the L2 issues and were also well trained with the

inherent of the identification task through studying ‘Investigating

Second Language Acquisition’ (SLA) subject. Hence, their successful

completion of the task and accurate classification of the /I/-i:/

English contrast could be due to their high proficiency and

competence in English, their previous experience and knowledge,

as well as their continued study and training in TESOL in the

English speaking country of Australia.

In contrast, the multilingual listener’s failure in accurate

perception of English vowel contrast /I/-/I:/ can be attributed

to his multilingualism and familiarity with more vowel inventory

systems than other listeners. As previously pointed out, the

difference in L1 and L2 vowel inventory results in perceptual

difficulty in terms of the vowels that are not present in L1

inventory. Thus, the multilingual participant encountered more

difficulty and confusion in perception of the selected English

contrast /I/ -/i:/ as he knew more L2 vowel inventory systems

different from his L1 (Arabic) inventory. In spite of his high

English proficiency and long exposure to this language, the

multilingual listener’s categorization of English /I/-/I:/

contrast was inaccurate and therefore partly supported the

prediction 1. As demonstrated in table 3, the vowel sound / i:/

in terms of the category [heed] has been 14 times classified

as /I/ in terms of the [hid] and only 4 times as / i:/ sound.

The second prediction was concerned to Persian listeners’

probable difficulty in identification of /ɔ/ English vowel sound

18School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

due to its absence in Persian vowel inventory. It was predicted

that English vowel /ɔ/ would be likely replaced with /e/ sound

from the Farsi vowel inventory by Persian speakers of English.

However, the results obtained from the listeners did not support

the prediction. Unexpectedly, four listeners were able to

accurately perceive the /ɔ/ sound with only a few occasional

errors. As previously discussed in analysis of the first

prediction, this unpredictable result may be interpreted through

a revision of the listeners’ language background. This unexpected

result may be related to the high proficiency and competence

level of the participants in English as well as their linguistic

experience in L2 which has been lead to their accurate

classification of /ɔ/ vowel sound. The correct perception of the

distracters æ/ and /ʊ/ with 100% (18 accurate responses out of

18) accuracy by three listeners and 16 accurate responses out of

18 by one listener supported and validated the task.

Lack of access to the listeners of the same background was one of

the limitations of the current research which was significantly

reflected in the participants’ performances and the findings of

the research. Further research is required to look into the

complexities involved in the perceptual difficulty and

development of the multilingual learners who are familiar with

more than two differing vowel inventory systems. Future research

is also needed to further investigate the Persian speakers’

perception problems in categorization of English tokens with more

19School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

participants of homogenous background in order to obtain more

reliable and valid results.

References

Bakhtiarvand, M. (2006). Phonological Differences between

Persian and English: Several potentially problematic Areas of

Pronunciation for Iranian EFL Learners. Research and science center of

Islamic Azad university Of Ahvaz. Retrieved from:

http://www.academia.edu/2424713/Phonological_Differences_between_

Persian_and_English_Several_potentially_problematic_Areas_ofPronu

nciation_for_Iranian_EFL_Learners

Boomershine, A. ( 2013). The perception of English vowels by

monolingual, bilingual and heritage speakers of Spanish and

English. In S. Blackwell and C. Howe (Eds.), Selected

Proceedings of the 15th Hispanic Linguistics Symposium. Massachusetts:

Cascadilla Press, pp 103 - 118. Retrieved from:

20School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

http://uncw.edu/fll/spanish/documents/CV_Boomershine_2014_sho

rtened.pdf

Detey, S. (2009). Phonetic input, phonological categories and

orthographic representations: A Psycholinguistic Perspective

on Why Language Eeducation Needs Oral Corpora. . In Corpus

Analysis and Variation in Linguistics, Kawaguchi, Yuji,

Makoto Minegishi and Jacques Durand (eds.), 179–200.

Eckman, F. R. (2004). From phonemic differences to constraint rankings : Research onSecond Language Phonology. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 26 (4).

513- 549

Escudero, P. (2007). Second Language Phonology: the role of perception”. In M. C.Pennington (ed.) Phonology in context. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. 109-134.

Escudero, P., & Chladkova, K. (2010). Spanish listeners'

perception of American and Southern British English vowels.

Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 128(5), EL254-EL260.

Hall, M. (2007). Phonological characteristics of Farsi Speakers

of English and L1 Australian English speakers’ Perceptions

of Proficiency, M.A. Dissertation, Curtin University of

Technology, Perth, Australia. Retrieved from:

http://www.asian-efljournal.com/Thesis-M-Hall.pdf

Hunter, G and Kebede , H (2012). Formant frequencies of British

English vowels produced by native speakers of Farsi.

21School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Proceeding of the Acoustics 2012 Nantes Conference, France. Retrieved

from:

http://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/docs/00/81/05/80/PDF/hal-

00810580.pdf

Keshavarz, M. H. (1994). Contrastive analysis and error analysis.Tehran: Rahnama Publication.

Ladefoged, P., & Johnson, K. (2011). Phonology and phonetic

transcription. In A course in phonetics (6th ed., pp. 33-48).

Boston, MA: Wadsworth. Retrieved

from:https://vuws.uws.edu.au/bbcswebdav/pid-1106162-dt-

content-rid-13529832_1/courses/100919_2014_spr/

100919_2013_spr_ImportedContent_20130718110418/

LadefogedPJohnsonK_Chapter2.pdf

Mayr, R., & Escudero, P. (2010). Explaining individual variation

in L2 perception: Rounded vowels in English learners of

German. Bilingualism: Language and Cognition, 13(3), 279-297.

Seddighi, Sh. (2010). An account of Iranian EFL pronunciation

errors through L1 transfer. Iranian Journal of Applied Language

Studies, 2(2), 197-214. Retrieved from:

http://en.journals.sid.ir/ViewPaper.aspx?ID=269408

Trubetzkoy, N. S. (1929). Zur algemeinen theorie der phonologischen vokalsysteme. Travaux duCercle linguistique de Prague 1, 39-67.Trubetzkoy, N. S. (1969). Principles of Phonology. Berkeley, CA:

University of California Press.

22School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Appendixes:

Appendix I : Questionnaires

Appendix II: Listeners’ perception results

23School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Questionnaire for English Study

Date: _____________20.10.2014__________ Name: Kiana Kianian

Phone: ______0449979542 Email: kianna [email protected]

Age: 21 Date and Place of birth: 27/07/1993, Sydney, Australia

Year at UWS: 4th (currently studying a Graduate Diploma, previously studied a Bachelors of Social science_______ Studyprogram: __________________________________

1) Are you interested in participating in our study? _Yes, I aminterested in participating in your study__________________

2) Will you be available in September or October 2012? Yes I will beavailable.___________________

3) Can we contact you by phone or email to make an appointment? _Yes,you may contact me via phone.__________________

If you answered yes on the first 3 questions, please keep filling outthe questionnaire.

4) Cities and countries where you lived since you were born:

24School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

City and country: Sydney_____________________, For how long: _1-5 years__old_______________

City and country: Iran_______________, For how long: 5- 11 yearsold __________________

City and country: Sydney_____________________, For how long: _11-current time_________________

5) Place of birth of your parents (city and country): a) Mother:_Tehran, Iran____________________ b)Father: Tabriz,Iran__________________

6) Do you speak English at home? _yes I do speak English athome._______ Are any other languages spoken at you home? _Yes, Farsi isalso spoken at home______________________.

7) Are you currently studying any foreign language? Specify the language, level (1-6, advanced, beginner, etc), and the place where youare studying it (UWS, any other institution, private classes, etc)no, Iam not currently studying a foreign language

Language: ________________, Level: _____________, Place:________________

Language: ________________, Level: _____________, Place:________________

8) How many hours per week do you study each language?

Language: ________________, Hours per week: _____________

Language: ________________, Hours per week: _____________

9) Have you ever studied a foreign language before? Yes, I have. ______

10)If yes, how old were you when you started?, How long did you studythe language? Up to which level did you study the language?

Language: ___French____________, Age: __18-20___________, Howlong: __1.5 years_____________, Level reached: Certificate 2 inFrench______________

25School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Language: _______________, Age: _____________, How long:_______________, Level reached: ___certificate 2 in French___________

11) Choose the number that corresponds to your current level ofcomprehension of the following languages:

(0 means you don’t understand anything; 7 means you understandabsolutely everything).

English: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Other language: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: ______)

Other language 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: ______)

12) Choose the number that corresponds to how well you speak thefollowing languages:

(0 means you don’t speak at all; 7 means you speak perfectly, like anative speaker)

English: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Other language: French 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: _)

Other language: Farsi 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: _______)

13) What percentage of time do you hear the following languages on adaily basis? The percentages must add up to 100%. If you hear otherlanguages, include them in the percentage.

English, percentage (from 0 to 100%) ___50%_

Other (Language: ______French_____), percentage (from 0 to 100%) __0%

Other (Language: __Farsi_________), percentage (from 0 to 100%) ____50%

14) What percentage of time do you communicate in the followinglanguages on a daily basis? The percentages must add up to 100%. If you

26School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

communicate in other languages, include them in the percentage.English,percentage (from 0 to 100%) _____________

Other (Language: ___________) percentage (from 0 to 100%)_____________

Other (Language: ___________), percentage (from 0 to 100%)_____________

Questionnaire for English StudyDate: __1/10/2014_________ Name: _____Maryam Menhaj_______

Phone: ____0449501235_________ Email: [email protected]____________

Age: ______29_______ Date and Place of birth: ___Tehran, 1985__________

Year at UWS: __1st_____ Study program: _____TESOL_______________

1) Are you interested in participating in our study?_______yes____________

2) Will you be available in September or October 2012?_______yes____________

3) Can we contact you by phone or email to make an appointment?______yes_____________

If you answered yes on the first 3 questions, please keep filling outthe questionnaire.4) Cities and countries where you lived since you were born:

City and country: Iran__________, For how long: _____24years_____________

City and country: Malaysia________, For how long: ________3years__________

City and country: Australia_____________, For how long: ________2years__________

27School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

5) Place of birth of your parents (city and country): a) Mother:___Tehran, Iran________ b) Father: __Tehran, Iran___

6) Do you speak English at home? _No_ Are any other languages spokenat you home? ___Farsi___________

7) Are you currently studying any foreign language? Specify the language, level (1-6, advanced, beginner, etc), and the place where youare studying it (UWS, any other institution, private classes, etc)

Language: ____English____________, Level: ___Advanced__________,Place: _____UWS___________

Language: ________________, Level: _____________, Place:________________

8) How many hours per week do you study each language?

Language: _____English___________, Hours per week: ____6 -8_________

Language: ________________, Hours per week: _____________

9) Have you ever studied a foreign language before? __English____

10)If yes, how old were you when you started?, How long did you studythe language? Up to which level did you study the language?

Language: __English__, Age: _12_____, How long: __not sure______,Level reached: __Advanced________

Language: _______________, Age: _____________, How long:_______________, Level reached: ___

11) Choose the number that corresponds to your current level ofcomprehension of the following languages:

(0 means you don’t understand anything; 7 means you understandabsolutely everything).

English: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Other language: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: ___________)

28School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Other language 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: ___________)

12) Choose the number that corresponds to how well you speak thefollowing languages:

(0 means you don’t speak at all; 7 means you speak perfectly, like anative speaker)

English: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Other language: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: _________)

Other language 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: _________)

13) What percentage of time do you hear the following languages on adaily basis? The percentages must add up to 100%. If you hear otherlanguages, include them in the percentage.

English, percentage (from 0 to 100%) ___40%__________

Other (Language: ___Farsi________), percentage (from 0 to 100%)_____60%________

Other (Language: ___________), percentage (from 0 to 100%)_____________

14) What percentage of time do you communicate in the followinglanguages on a daily basis? The percentages must add up to 100%. If youcommunicate in other languages, include them in the percentage.English,percentage (from 0 to 100%) ____30%_________

Other (Language: __Farsi_________) percentage (from 0 to 100%)____70%_________

Other (Language: ___________), percentage (from 0 to 100%)_____________

29School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Questionnaire for English StudyDate25/09/2014 Name: AZHER AL-HADI

Phone:0481300770 Email: [email protected]

Age:31 Date and Place of birth: IRAQ 1983

Year at UWS: 3 MONTHS Study program: TESOL

1) Are you interested in participating in our study? YES

2) Will you be available in September or October 2014? YES

3) Can we contact you by phone or email to make an appointment? YES

If you answered yes on the first 3 questions, please keep filling outthe questionnaire.4) Cities and countries where you lived since you were born:

City and country: NAJAF/IRAQ, For how long: 7 YEARS

City and country: TEHRAN/IRAN, For how long: 9 YEARS

City and country: DAMASCUS/SYRIA, For how long: 13 YEARS

City and country: SYDNEY/AUSTRALIA, For how long: LESS THAN 2YEARS

5) Place of birth of your parents (city and country): a)Mother:NAJAF/IRAQ b)Father: QADESIYA/IRAQ

6) Do you speak English at home? NO.. Are any other languages spoken atyou home? ARABIC

7) Are you currently studying any foreign language? Specify the language, level (1-6, advanced, beginner, etc), and the place where youare studying it (UWS, any other institution, private classes, etc) NO

Language: ________________, Level: _____________, Place:________________

Language: ________________, Level: _____________, Place:________________

8) How many hours per week do you study each language?

30School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Language: ________________, Hours per week: _____________

Language: ________________, Hours per week: _____________

9) Have you ever studied a foreign language before?PERSIAN/ENGLISH/SPANISH

10)If yes, how old were you when you started?, How long did you studythe language? Up to which level did you study the language?

Language: PERSIAN Age: 7 YEARS, How long: 9 YEARS, Level reached:SCHOOL

Language: ENGLISH Age: 14 How long: 10 YESR Level reached:UNIVERSITY

Language: SPANISH Age: 22 How long: 3 COURSES Level reached:LEVEL 1

11) Choose the number that corresponds to your current level ofcomprehension of the following languages:

(0 means you don’t understand anything; 7 means you understandabsolutely everything).

English: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Other language: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: ARABIC)

Other language 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: PERSIAN)

12) Choose the number that corresponds to how well you speak thefollowing languages:

(0 means you don’t speak at all; 7 means you speak perfectly, like anative speaker)

English: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Other language: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: ARABIC)

31School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Other language 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: PERSIAN)

13) What percentage of time do you hear the following languages on adaily basis? The percentages must add up to 100%. If you hear otherlanguages, include them in the percentage.

English, percentage (from 0 to 100%) 40%

Other (Language: ARABIC), percentage (from 0 to 100%) 60%

Other (Language: PERSIAN ), percentage (from 0 to 100%) 0%

14) What percentage of time do you communicate in the followinglanguages on a daily basis? The percentages must add up to 100%. If youcommunicate in other languages, include them in the percentage.

English, percentage (from 0 to 100%) 25%

Other (Language: ARABIC) percentage (from 0 to 100%) 75%

Other (Language: PERSIAN), percentage (from 0 to 100%) 0%

Questionnaire for English Study

Date: ___22 sep. 14_______________ Name: _______Shadan Seifollahi___________________________

Phone: ______0405028967_________ Email: [email protected]______________________

Age: __________________________ Date and Place of birth: ______12/10/1987___________________

Year at UWS: _first year__________ Study program: _Graduate Diploma in TESOL

1) Are you interested in participating in our study?____Yes_______________

32School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

2) Will you be available in September or October 2012?______Yes_____________

3) Can we contact you by phone or email to make an appointment?___________________

If you answered yes on the first 3 questions, please keep filling outthe questionnaire.

4) Cities and countries where you lived since you were born:

City and country: ___ Tehran/Iran________, For how long: ___26years________

City and country: ___Sydney/Australia____, For how long: ___1year__________

City and country: _____________________, For how long:__________________

5) Place of birth of your parents (city and country): a) Mother:___Iran____________ b)Father: ___Iran__________

6) Do you speak English at home? No Are any other languages spokenat you home? __Persian________________

7) Are you currently studying any foreign language? Specify the language, level (1-6, advanced, beginner, etc), and the place where youare studying it (UWS, any other institution, private classes, etc)

Language: _____English ____, Level: ___Advanced__, Place: __SelfStudy______

Language: ________________, Level: _____________, Place:________________

8) How many hours per week do you study each language?

Language: ___English_______, Hours per week: ___40 hours___

Language: ________________, Hours per week: _____________

9) Have you ever studied a foreign language before? __Yes____

33School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

10)If yes, how old were you when you started?, How long did you studythe language? Up to which level did you study the language?

Language: ___English______, Age: ____10, How long: __16 years,Level reached: _Advanced_____

Language: _______________, Age: _____________, How long:_______________, Level reached:

11) Choose the number that corresponds to your current level ofcomprehension of the following languages:

(0 means you don’t understand anything; 7 means you understandabsolutely everything).

English: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Other language: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: ___________)

Other language 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: ___)

12) Choose the number that corresponds to how well you speak thefollowing languages:

(0 means you don’t speak at all; 7 means you speak perfectly, like anative speaker)

English: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Other language: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: _______)

Other language 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7(Language: ______)

13) What percentage of time do you hear the following languages on adaily basis? The percentages must add up to 100%. If you hear otherlanguages, include them in the percentage.

English, percentage (from 0 to 100%) _30____________

34School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Other (Language: ___________), percentage (from 0 to 100%)_____________

Other (Language: __________), percentage (from 0 to 100%)_____________

14) What percentage of time do you communicate in the followinglanguages on a daily basis? The percentages must add up to 100%. If youcommunicate in other languages, include them in the percentage.

English, percentage (from 0 to 100%) ___40__________

Other (Language: ___________) percentage (from 0 to 100%)_____________

Other (Language: ___________), percentage (from 0 to 100%)_____________

Listener 1

subject stimulus response reactionTime

Ho British_caught.wav hood 3.7733924021510648

Ho British_hood.wav hood 8.088587375444135

Ho British_had.wav had 2.108527177422969

Ho British_heed.wav hid 1.4667959816054934

Ho British_hid.wav heed 8.300524083284484

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.9254304484599154

Ho British_hid.wav hid 5.863899574555951

Ho British_caught.wav hood 7.913525352279814

Ho British_heed.wav heed 3.000569281618181

Ho British_had.wav had 2.6645368801193436

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.8952888662645393

Ho British_caught.wav caught 8.35500619099422

35School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_had.wav had 2.0495732425864865

Ho British_hid.wav hid 5.550286542943401

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.9382381526472137

Ho British_hid.wav hid 5.958712816671382

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.8383027346350942

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.8856464041056782

Ho British_caught.wav caught 4.096661029706812

Ho British_had.wav had 1.7873518033591393

Ho British_caught.wav caught 6.37222639383414

Ho British_had.wav had 3.790332266628502

Ho British_hood.wav hood 4.185145599321798

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.7954014544986598

Ho British_hid.wav heed 3.5473137787890145

Ho British_hood.wav hood 3.9601059035907604

Ho British_had.wav had 1.5667966156502224

Ho British_hid.wav hid 5.1366334759330075

Ho British_caught.wav hood 2.2516238339237495

Ho British_heed.wav heed 3.976511811800997

Ho British_hid.wav hid 7.7667417254894495

Ho British_heed.wav hid 1.5883034139687144

Ho British_caught.wav caught 2.845536732477542

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.5819217534416965

Ho British_had.wav had 1.608728713079394

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.9066618177338412

36School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_caught.wav caught 3.152033064528544

Ho British_had.wav had 2.225276103849253

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.067065631784827

Ho British_hid.wav hid 9.552993008297785

Ho British_had.wav had 1.7204492116558954

Ho British_hood.wav hood 4.535030520197491

Ho British_hid.wav hid 4.797944426882401

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.6018040385027805

Ho British_caught.wav caught 2.371798413619976

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.8235399081359849

Ho British_hood.wav hood 3.730742022584648

Ho British_caught.wav caught 2.1477043503623214

Ho British_had.wav had 1.5106573866667707

Ho British_hid.wav hid 3.8491824898575

Ho British_hood.wav hood 3.7084933918948844

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.147000560676759

Ho British_had.wav had 2.027629406271379

Ho British_caught.wav caught 2.4381539152717253

Ho British_hid.wav hid 5.023229588513984

Ho British_caught.wav caught 3.7665977067506873

Ho British_heed.wav heed 6.796882401906509

Ho British_had.wav had 1.5574960847735544

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.5238581986063409

Ho British_hid.wav hid 5.786984963175558

37School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_had.wav had 1.2332007575929176

Ho British_hid.wav hid 2.5162686828082106

Ho British_caught.wav caught 2.1138585880910443

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.854755290424239

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.2119099873825436

Ho British_caught.wav caught 2.5613352258059914

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.4157997614180284

Ho British_hid.wav hid 2.553225340414122

Ho British_hood.wav hood 3.832168351565158

Ho British_had.wav had 1.3346519954747502

Ho British_caught.wav caught 1.288408846554771

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.1166823517263524

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.9649690269133333

Ho British_hid.wav hid 4.233706181845893

Ho British_had.wav had 2.473205268368524

Ho British_caught.wav caught 3.4555004741748485

Ho British_had.wav had 2.2339969366580394

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.1472043607787676

Ho British_heed.wav heed 4.36669571195531

Ho British_hid.wav hid 2.715758639086314

Ho British_caught.wav caught 1.267223599508395

Ho British_had.wav had 1.5704369383608339

Ho British_hid.wav hid 2.248347181172799

Ho British_hood.wav hood 3.6716694307999913

38School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.7437997215637313

Ho British_caught.wav caught 2.2906669516847766

Ho British_had.wav had 1.8447958058845453

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.69680613537953

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.6100679061938925

Ho British_heed.wav heed 5.356513858859777

Listener 2

subject stimulus response reactionTime

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.545844606498446

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.2653690185802358

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.8058441717244764

Ho British_had.wav had 2.190698925656606

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.4124311721764777

Ho British_heed.wav hood 0.2705260669389826

39School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_had.wav had 1.834540584752113

Ho British_hid.wav heed 2.7680451403639106

Ho British_hood.wav caught 2.3762494078472827

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.3404159152479667

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.7172400393830347

Ho British_had.wav had 1.6627905396900413

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.8714166280957378

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.072518869624935

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.1100851159803264

Ho British_had.wav had 2.0032621602990526

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.7874410225147797

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.6877456357341607

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.5506221337779251

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.3257826150360457

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.439105435303628

Ho British_had.wav had 1.660090414783154

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.023382212145818

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.9373201464098035

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.8993725674192836

Ho British_had.wav had 1.6523632206937007

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.6189336635194955

40School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.6832344072541925

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.7372740422982522

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.2330603619672247

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.333789241709519

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.8591677890770442

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.664784157576219

Ho British_had.wav had 1.6634621742482145

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.5609122273719072

Ho British_had.wav had 1.995356527898523

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.8524740879494521

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.8888107403559715

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.609869540761286

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.768484895695106

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.8135093200049333

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.2332170616010067

Ho British_had.wav had 1.4889318429053828

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.9266962735375746

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.4273683609851533

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.7899889766788437

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.7820004655701103

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.764901184123672

41School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.2104938031182666

Ho British_had.wav had 1.764454635455814

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.625404996091512

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.7322193468796698

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.9453426242025147

Ho British_had.wav had 2.0455479641276524

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.122352070563888

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.8391079714822745

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.6311965421009242

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.6371855477649746

Ho British_had.wav had 1.7839057700788534

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.017273190866411

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.6684199513960474

Ho British_had.wav had 1.6956449276874084

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.701779310756986

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.8042436615901931

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.8335247544661195

Ho British_had.wav had 1.7570132143986843

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.6759202480382738

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.3485339526439053

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.8414385388708001

42School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.8883900063675239

Ho British_had.wav had 2.4003313336768333

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.007295590762332

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.8956516304459399

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.871077414148066

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.9719711455285291

Ho British_had.wav had 1.3550641608011522

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.8682559149582472

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.1202117166036567

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.725552366209837

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.4467950395962004

Ho British_had.wav had 1.8513812665136653

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.801817987487664

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.9018919895688744

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.002485908355365

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.877238064786732

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.034844382771047

Ho British_had.wav had 1.90731488383829

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.7657856765663282

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.6476875934648518

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.5131994532723194

43School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Listener 3

subject stimulus response reactionTime

Ho British_had.wav had 1.6367990080325399

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.7690545399018447

Ho British_heed.wav heed 3.761416536399338

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.7933428592587006

Ho British_hid.wav hood 4.217361448354495

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.139048703997105

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.7895086962598725

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.7265512639132794

Ho British_had.wav had 1.7659518488071626

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.4994805523165269

Ho British_had.wav had 1.5906099160201848

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.048402167733002

Ho British_heed.wav hid 2.573822915685014

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.610630227420188

Ho British_hid.wav hood 3.3154785146471113

44School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_heed.wav hid 2.0730091065488523

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.6451871434474015

Ho British_hood.wav caught 4.6026521454550675

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.3560304213970085

Ho British_had.wav had 1.5854854141798569

Ho British_hid.wav hood 2.6702657136993366

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.7046817467489745

Ho British_had.wav had 1.5814231327021844

Ho British_heed.wav hid 1.4539063072224963

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.2985776883360813

Ho British_hid.wav hood 2.1092276953568216

Ho British_had.wav had 1.5109695128267049

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.9299251780757913

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 3.175155332814029

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.809800044131407

Ho British_had.wav had 1.4604097828778322

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.7092226571548963

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.9548166818494792

Ho British_heed.wav hid 1.6415908954149927

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.767931208058144

Ho British_had.wav had 1.410383262358664

45School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.225618030781334

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.333922522760986

Ho British_heed.wav hid 2.3728673372097546

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.4808000287375762

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.282467579425429

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.04761751483602

Ho British_heed.wav hid 2.814318096046918

Ho British_had.wav had 2.1278298469478614

Ho British_hid.wav hood 5.651161141671764

Ho British_heed.wav hid 2.6856602117113653

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.8087882057589013

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.7030294039577711

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.742878295299306

Ho British_had.wav had 1.9506760283838958

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.0383635555263027

Ho British_had.wav had 1.800541886332212

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.7118919698114041

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.2869697703426937

Ho British_heed.wav hid 1.838897977861052

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.540137421558029

Ho British_hood.wav hood 3.0283450028291554

46School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_heed.wav hid 2.0347439825054607

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.4947147889324697

Ho British_had.wav had 4.887691539050138

Ho British_heed.wav hid 1.663842009533255

Ho British_had.wav had 2.2587619184923824

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.9330050106727867

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.52247526733845

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.20695616719604

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.3141172678224393

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.5244410980812972

Ho British_heed.wav hid 1.1619673795285053

Ho British_had.wav had 1.6165123251630575

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.8588721057749353

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.8002064728716505

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.6698939132475061

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.6638182180322474

Ho British_heed.wav hid 3.4288655234558973

Ho British_had.wav had 1.715151404889184

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.7245602421753574

Ho British_had.wav had 3.0241306423704373

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.7608749299688498

47School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.067086423310684

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.6036098698314163

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.8457741869715392

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.296457912605547

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.9376186950830743

Ho British_had.wav had 2.1648969991438207

Ho British_heed.wav hid 2.4483134394467925

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.527566647673666

Ho British_heed.wav hid 2.470972741008154

Ho British_hid.wav hood 1.553944420258631

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.7238488297589356

Ho British_had.wav had 1.9404522157128667

Listener 4

subject stimulus response reactionTime

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.7174390736550222

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 7.355509955273299

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.3120422485458474

48School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.4291278923370314

Ho British_had.wav had 1.3231079908481376

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.7830785715708846

Ho British_hid.wav hid 2.7868873172844055

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 8.752690577679395

Ho British_had.wav had 2.2190816801596096

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.6779245823060904

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.3426852155451634

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.651795499792629

Ho British_had.wav had 2.8825579373173578

Ho British_hid.wav heed 4.04567732270087

Ho British_caught.wavhood 2.4647801977830737

Ho British_hid.wav heed 1.5727139826708711

Ho British_caught.wavhood 2.386057816850483

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.2311274611925083

Ho British_had.wav had 1.7778391685793036

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.3526468291852107

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.2601848849405

Ho British_hid.wav hid 2.7336799095682904

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.4039272198963628

Ho British_had.wav had 1.9937117200675738

49School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 4.743622502123977

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.3268927337646073

Ho British_had.wav had 1.7843126776433302

Ho British_hood.wav caught 3.925559174593586

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 3.676538760441229

Ho British_hid.wav hid 2.4453415552725737

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.6288963785666446

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.3312730177765768

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.1763245468000414

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.6591521306331725

Ho British_had.wav had 1.3023546290978565

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.9304756720329919

Ho British_had.wav had 1.3493539171658517

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.9019762000946083

Ho British_hid.wav hid 2.14271881946097

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.231106175693259

Ho British_hid.wav hid 2.2947715567761353

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.6272478845837384

Ho British_had.wav had 1.8003442816279884

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.3508457136439533

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.37001987250443

50School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.33461801133657

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.1856326503254544

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.9198401685448792

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.3252071033787407

Ho British_had.wav had 1.3151454026039486

Ho British_hid.wav hid 2.293758910472235

Ho British_heed.wav heed 0.8762338796309468

Ho British_hood.wav hood 5.4582514369976805

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.9847138413713585

Ho British_had.wav had 1.45450518913293

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.5478004380284152

Ho British_had.wav had 1.5219752399827295

Ho British_hood.wav hood 4.477957733338844

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.730426851249672

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 4.152864303583792

Ho British_hid.wav hid 3.1005984395464563

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.1311793615799033

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.377445794438243

Ho British_had.wav had 1.5400457230639006

Ho British_hood.wav hood 2.787449345040694

Ho British_had.wav had 1.443096161545207

51School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.1003783384267893

Ho British_heed.wav heed 4.2497862392417165

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.4506285109751476

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.7471377796778524

Ho British_had.wav had 1.3067820129379986

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.9599619759464877

Ho British_hid.wav hid 2.089162691863921

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.6902828525830156

Ho British_heed.wav heed 5.562932616449832

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.6891189433696863

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.764043447779874

Ho British_had.wav had 1.3521857943295617

Ho British_heed.wav heed 2.672546144245057

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.7595467728466296

Ho British_hood.wav hood 4.492235321610274

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.7277349149214267

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 2.2726160693744624

Ho British_had.wav had 1.887409672493158

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.5244353002341235

Ho British_hood.wav hood 1.831059709901274

Ho British_caught.wavcaught 1.8869712817856659

52School of Humanities and Communication Arts

Name: Homerya Surname: Asalni Malayeri Student number: 16437568

Ho British_had.wav had 1.5015710509965396

Ho British_hid.wav hid 1.5265457348388802

Ho British_heed.wav heed 1.2702366222900943

53School of Humanities and Communication Arts