ministry of road and transport & highway government of india

`

MINISTRY OF ROAD AND TRANSPORT & HIGHWAY

GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

Consultancy Services for Detailed Project Report for

Rehabilitation and Upgrading to 2 Lane/2 Lane with Paved Shoulders

of Pratapgarh (Km 80/0) to Padi (Km 180/0)Section of NH-113

SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT

&

RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN REPORT

Including Tribal Development Plan

January 2014

Starting

Point

(80+000)

End Point

(180+000)

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

wb371432

Typewritten Text

RP1245 V4 REV

wb371432

Typewritten Text

wb371432

Typewritten Text

wb371432

Typewritten Text

wb371432

Typewritten Text

wb371432

Typewritten Text

wb371432

Typewritten Text

Rehabilitation and Upgrading of Pratapgarh-Padi of NH 113 Final Detailed Project Report

Volume V: SIA, RAP& TDP

MoRT&H

Social Impact Assessment & RAP Report

(FINAL)

TABLE OF CONTENTS

S.

No Description Page

ABBREVIATIONS

ES Executive Summary ES 1-8

1. PROJECT BACKGROUND AND INTRODUCTION 1-1 to 1-5

1.1 PROJECT BACKGROUND 1-1

1.2 PROJECT ROAD DESCRIPTION 1-2

1.3 PROPOSED PROJECT 1-4

1.4 APPROACH AND METHODOLOGY 1-4

1.4.1 Public Consultations 1-4

1.4.2 Census Surveys and Structure Marking 1-5

2. SOCIO-ECONOMIC PROFILE OF THE PROJECT INFLUENCE ZONE 2-1 to 2-5

2.1 INTRODUCTION 2-1

2.2 SOCIO- ECONOMIC STATUS OF PROJECT INFLUENCE DISTRICT 2-1

2.2.1 Pratapgarh District Profile 2-1

2.2.2 Banswara District Profile 2-2

2.3 PROJECT IMPACT ZONE 2-3

2.3.1 Population Projection 2-4

2.3.2 Literacy Status 2-4

2.3.3 Working and Non- Working Population 2-4

2.3.4 Existing Public Amenities 2-4

3.

ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES & PROPOSED IMPROVEMENT PLAN 3-1 to 3-21

3.1 NEED FOR MINIMIZATION OF IMPACT 3-1

3.2 DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS 3-1

3.2.1 Proposed Design Standards for Highway 3-1

3.3 BY-PASSES AND ALTERNATIVE ALIGNMENT 3-3

3.4 ANALYSIS OF ALIGNMENTS 3-5

3.4.1 Ghatol 3-5

3.4.2 Banswara Bypass 3-7

3.4.3 Realignments 3-10

3.5 PROPOSED IMPROVEMENT PLAN 3-10

3.5.1 Pedestrian and Animal Crossing 3-10

3.5.2 Wayside Amenities 3-11

3.5.3 Traffic Control guidance and safety and speed Control Measures 3-11

3.5.4 Design Speed 3-12



MoRT&H

S.

No Description Page

3.5.5 Horizontal Curves 3-12

3.5.6 Vertical Curves 3-13

3.5.7 Intersections 3-13

3.5.8 Visibility 3-13

3.5.9 Other Issues at Intersections 3-14

3.5.10 Access Control 3-14

3.6 CROSS SECTION, RUMBLE STRIP 3-14

3.6.1 Cross Section 3-14

3.6.2 Rumble Strip 3-16

3.7 ROAD SIGNS, PAVEMENT MARKING, OTHER TRAFFIC

CONTROL DEVICES 3-16

3.7.1 Road Signs 3-16

3.7.2 Pavement Markings 3-17

3.7.3 Traffic Control Devices 3-18

3.8 Safety Issues for Non-Motorized Traffic 3-19

4. PUBLIC INFORMATION AND CONSULTATIONS 4-1 to 4-33


4.2 LEVELS OF CONSULTATIONS 4-2

4.3 METHODOLOGY ADOPTED 4-2

4.4 TYPES OF CONSULTATIONS 4-3

4.4.1 General Consultations 4-3

4.4.2 Structured Consultations 4-3

4.4.3 Specific Consultations 4-4

4.5 STAKEHOLDER ANALYSIS MATRIX 4-7

4.6 MAJOR FINDINGS FROM CONSULTATION 4-8

4.7 CONCLUSION/RECOMMENDATIONS 4-31

5. PROJECT IMPACTS 5-1 to 5-16


5.2 EXISTING STATUS OF LAND AVAILABILITY 5-2

5.3 LAND ACQUISITION ESTIMATES FOR THE PROJECT STRETCH 5-3

5.4 TYPE OF THE LAND ACQUIRED FOR THE PROJECT 5-3

5.5 IMPACT ON STRUCTURES 5-4

5.5.1 Impact on structures by usage of structure 5-4

5.5.2 Impact on structures by typology of structure 5-5

5.5.3 Impact on Common Property Resources (CPRs) 5-5

5.6 VULNERABLE GROUPS 5-6

5.7 IMPACT ON WOMEN 5-7

5.8 IMPACT ON TRIBALS 5-7

5.9 SOCIO-ECONOMIC PROFILE OF PROJECT INFLUENCED 5-7



MoRT&H

S.

No Description Page

HABITATIONS

5.9.1 Socio-Economic survey 5-7

5.9.2 Affected Households & Persons 5-8

5.9.3 Family Types 5-13

5.9.4 Literacy & Educational Status 5-14

5.9.5 Occupational Pattern 5-14

5.9.6 Income Level 5-15

6 R&R PRINCIPLES, POLICY FRAMEWORK & ENTITLEMENT

MATRIX 6-1 to 6-27


6.2 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF APPLICABLE POLICY 6-4

6.3 PURPOSE OF RESETTLEMENT POLICY FRAMEWORK 6-6

6.4 OBJECTIVES AND SCOPE OF RESETTLEMENT POLICY

FRAMEWORK, NHIIP 6-7

6.4.1 Revision/Modification of the RPF 6-8

6.5 Resettlement and Rehabilitation Policy, NHIIP 6-9

6.5.1 Definitions 6-9

6.6 Resettlement Principles and Eligibility Criteria 6-13

6.7 Entitlement Matrix for NHIIP 6-15

6.8 Methods for Assessment of Replacement Cost 6-25

6.9 Direct Purchase of Land 6-27

7 GENDER ISSUE & WOMEN’S PARTICIPATION 7-1 to 7-6

7.1 GENERAL 7-1

7.2 IMPACT ON WOMEN 7-1

7.3 WOMEN HEADED HOUSEHOLD 7-2

7.4 WOMEN INVOLVEMENT IN DEVELOPMENT PROCESS

THROUGH EMPOWERMENT 7-2

7.5 INVOLVEMENT OF WOMEN IN CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES 7-4

7.6 SPECIFIC PROVISIONS IN THE CONSTRUCTION CAMP FOR

WOMEN 7-5

7.6.1 Temporary Housing 7-5

7.6.2 Health Centre 7-5

7.6.3 Day Crèche Facilities 7-5

7.6.4 Proper Scheduling of Construction Works 7-6

7.6.5 Educational Facilities 7-6

7.6.6 Control on Child Labour 7-6

7.6.7 Special Measures for Controlling STD/AIDS 7-6

8 TRIBAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND DEVELOPMENT PLAN 8-1 to 8-20


8.2 Status of Schedule Tribes in the Project Area 8-1



MoRT&H

S.

No Description Page

8.2.1 Pratapgarh District 8-2

8.2.2 Banswara District 8-3

8.3 METHODOLOGY FOR TRIBAL ISSUES 8-3

8.3.1 Consultation Methodology 8-3

8.4 Gram Sabha Under PESA 1996 8-4

8.4.1 Consultation Process PESA Act 1996 8-5

8.5 SOCIAL ASSESSMENT OF PROJECT AFFECTED TRIBALS 8-8

8.5.1 Direct Impact Zone 8-8

8.6 PROJECT AFFECTED TRIBAL POPULATIONS AND THEIR SOCIO-

ECONOMIC STATUS 8-8

8.6.1 Affected Tribal Households 8-8

8.6.2 Affected Tribal Population 8-9

8.7 DISTRICT WISE POPULATION 8-9

8.7.1 Marital Status 8-10

8.7.2 Age Structure 8-10

8.7.3 Educational Status 8-11

8.7.4 Employment and Occupation Status 8-12

8.7.5 Language and Culture 8-12

8.7.6 Income 8-13

8.7.7 Live Stock Assets 8-13

8.7.8 Material Assets 8-14

8.8 POTENTIAL IMPACT ON TRIBAL POPULATION 8-14

8.8.1 Impact on Land 8-14

8.8.2 Impact on Structure 8-15

8.9 COMPENSATION AND R&R ASSISTANCES 8-16

8.10 OTHER POSSIBLE IMPACTS TO TRIBAL POPULATIONS AND

MANAGEMENT/ MITIGATION MEASURES 8-17

8.11 CONSULTATION AND PARTICIPATION 8-20

8.12 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS 8-20

8.13 MONITORING ARRANGEMENTS 8-20

9 INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR RAP & TDP

IMPLEMENTATION 9-1 to 9-15

9.1 GENERAL 9-1

9.2 CENTRAL LEVEL 9-1

9.3 STATE LEVEL 9-2

9.4 SUB-PROJECT LEVEL 9-3

9.5 RAP & TDP IMPLEMENTING SUPPORT AGENCY AT SUB-

PROJECT LEVEL 9-5

9.6 REPLACEMENT COST COMMITTEE AT DISTRICT LEVEL 9-8

9.7 ROLE OF VARIOUS STAKEHOLDERS IN PROJECT CYCLE 9-9



MoRT&H

S.

No Description Page

9.8 CAPACITY BUILDING AND TRAINING 9-11

10 DISCLOSURE AND CONSULTATION PLAN 10-1 to 10-7

10.1 INFORMATION DISCLOSURE 10-1

10.2 CONSULTATION & PARTICIPATION PLAN 10-1

10.3 FRAMEWORK FOR CONTINUED CONSULTATION 10-3

10.4 SUGGESTION AND COMPLAINT HANDLING MECHANISM

(SCHM) 10-5

11 MONITORING AND EVALUATION (M&E) 11-1 to 11-6


11.2 INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENT FOR M & E 11-2

11.3 PROCESS & PERFORMANCE MONITORING 11-2

11.4 EVALUATION 11-4

11.5 REPORTING 11-5

12 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENT AND SCHEDULE 12-1 to 12-14

12.1 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENT 12-1

12.2 RAP & TDP IMPLEMENTATION 12-2

12.3 STAGES OF RAP & TDP IMPLEMENTATION: A

METHODOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK 12-4

12.3.1 Training and Capacity Building of Project Staff 12-4

12.3.2 Focus Group Discussion, Awareness Campaign and

Dissemination of Information 12-5

12.3.3 Identification, verification and updating of PAP Census 12-5

12.3.4 Micro Plans for Non-title and Title Holders 12-5

12.3.5 Entitlement cum Identity Card 12-5

12.3.6 Opening of Bank Account and Disbursement of Assistance 12-6

12.3.7 Measurement, valuation of private structure and common

property resources 12-6

12.3.8 Rehabilitation of Affected Families and Restoration of

Income and Livelihood 12-6

12.3.9 IEC for HIV/AIDS 12-7

12.4 STEPS IN IMPLEMENTATION- LIST OF ACTIVITIES 12-8

12.4.1 Site Visits / Verification 12-8

12.4.2 IEC Activities and Awareness Campaign 12-8

12.4.3 Land and Building Valuation and Distribution of I-Cards 12-9

12.4.4 Micro-Plans and Assistance Disbursement 12-9

12.4.5 Rehabilitation Process 12-10

12.4.6 Submission of Completion Report 12-10

13 GRIEVANCE REDRESSAL MECHANISM 13-1 to 13-5

13.1 GRIEVANCE REDRESSAL MECHANISM 13-1

13.2 SUGGESTION AND COMPLAINT HANDLING MECHANISM

(SCHM) 13-3



MoRT&H

S.

No Description Page

14 REHABILITATION & RESETTLEMENT BUDGET 14-1 to 14-4

14.1 R&R Budget 14-1

14.1.1 Compensation Cost for Land Acquisition 14-4



MoRT&H

TABLE OF CONTENTS FOR TABLES

S. No Description

Table 1.1 Project Road

Table 2.1 District wise List of Public Amenities

Table: 3.1 Basis of Road Designs

Table: 3.2 Project Improvement Plan of NH-113

Table 3.3 Comparison between different alternatives for Ghatol

Table 3.4 Comparison between different alternatives for Banswara bypass

Table 3.5 Detailed list of realignment sections from km 80 to km 180

Table 3.6 List of Proposed CUP Locations

Table 3.7 Design Speed

Table 3.8 Description of TCS, used in proposed designing

Table 3.9 List of Proposed Bus Bays on Project Road

Table 3.10 Breakup of the proposed culverts

Table 3.11 Locations and Types of Major Junctions

Table 4.1 Types of Consultations

Table 4.2 Gram Panchayat List of Gram Sabha under PESA Act 1996 & FRA Act

2006

Table 4.3 Stakeholder Analysis

Table 4.4 Major Findings from consultation (Public Hearing)

Table 4.5 Major Findings from consultation (Public Consultation & Gram Sabha)

Table 5.1 Land Acquisitions by District

Table 5.2 Land Acquisitions by Type of Land

Table 5.3 Summary of PAHs in Project Section

Table: 5.4 Impact on Structures

Table: 5.5 Impact on Structures by Usage

Table 5.6 Impact on Structures by Typology

Table 5.7 Impact on Common Property Resources

Table 5.8 Vulnerability Category

Table 5.9 Summary of Households

Table 5.10 Summary of Project affected Persons

Table 5.11 Family Types of PAHs

Table 5.12 Literacy Status of PAPs

Table 5.13 Occupation Patterns of PAHs



MoRT&H

S. No Description

Table 5.14 Income Level of PAHs

Table 7.1 Number of Women Headed Households

Table 8.1 Area wise Tribal Group Distribution in Rajasthan

Table: 8.2 Project Affected Schedule Tribe Households

Table 8.3 Project Affected Schedule Tribe Population

Table 8.4 District and Tehsil wise Population Distribution

Table 8.5 Marital Status of ST PAPs

Table 8.6 Age Structure of ST PAPs

Table 8.7 Educational Status of ST PAPs

Table 8.8 Employment Status of ST PAPs

Table 8.9 Occupation Pattern of ST PAPs

Table 8.10 Income Status of Employment ST PAPs

Table 8.11 Classification of Live Stock Assets

Table 8.12 Classification of Material Assets

Table 8.13 Impact on Land in Hector

Table 8.14 Impact on Structure

Table 11.1 Performance Monitoring for RAP Implementation*

Table 11.2 Impact Indicators*

Table 12.1 Activity wise Implementation Schedule - Flow Chart

Table 14.1 R&R Budget for Project Section Pratapgarh-Padi

Table 14.2 Estimate for Land Acquisition for Pratapgarh- Padi NH 113



MoRT&H

TABLE OF CONTENTS FOR FIGURES

S. No Description

Figure 1.1 Project Highway (Pratapgarh-Padi NH-113) Map

Figure 3.1 Fig 3.1 Existing Route of NH 113 through Ghatol Town

Figure 3.2 Ghatol urban area from km 133+736 to 137+814

Figure 3.3 Existing Route of NH 113 Through BanswaraTown

Figure 3.4 Banswara bypass from km 157.466 to km 173.106

Figure 3.5 Schematic Figure of Cattle Underpass

Figure 9.1 Institutional Arrangement for RAP Implementation

Figure 13.1 Grievance Redressal Mechanism

TABLE OF CONTENTS FOR ANNEXURES

S. No Description

1 Annexure

2 Sample Photographs (Social Survey & Gram Sabhas)

3 Annexure of Affected Structure List

4 Annexure of Land of Tribal PAHs

5 Annexure Social Survey Form



MoRT&H

ABBREVIATIONS

AE Assistant Engineer

BPL Below Poverty Line

BSR Basic Schedule of Rates

CA Competent Authority

CE (EAP) Chief Engineer (Externally Aided Project)

CEG Consulting Engineering Group (DPR Consultant)

CHCs Community Health Centres

CoI Corridor of Impact

CPRs Common Property Resources

CSC Construction Supervision Consultant

CUP Cattle Under Pass

CVO Central Vigilance Officer

DIZ Direct Impact Zone

DLRCC District Level Replacement Cost Committee

EAP Externally Aided Project

EC Environmental Clearance

EE Executive Engineer

EIA Environment Impact Assessment

EMP Environment Management Plan

EP Entitled Person

FGDs Focus Group Discussions

FRA Forest Rights Act

GOI Govt. of India

GOR Govt. of Rajasthan

GRC Grievance Redressal Committee

GRM Grievance Redressal Mechanism

Ha Hectare

HH Household

HIV/AIDS Human Immunodeficiency Virus/ Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome

IAY Indira Awas Yojana

ICDS Integrated Child Development Scheme

IG Income Generation

INR Indian Rupees

IRC Indian Roads Congress

ITI Industrial Training Institute

JNNURM Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission

LA Land Acquisition

LA cum SDO Land Acquisition cum Social Development Officer

M&E Monitoring and Evaluation

MCW MotherandChildWelfare

MIS Management Information System

MoEF Ministry of Environment & Forest

MoM Minutes of Meeting

MoRT&H Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MoRT&H),

MOST Ministry of Surface Transport

NACO National AIDS Control Society

NEREGA National Rural Employment Guarantee Act

NGO Non-government Organisation

NH National Highway

NHDP National Highways Development Programme



MoRT&H

NHIIP National Highways Improvement Inter-Connectivity Project

NOC No Objection Certificate

NRRP National Rehabilitation and Resettlement Policy

NTH Non-titleholder

PAH Project affected household

PAPs Project affected persons

PCU Project Coordination Unit

PDP Project Displaced Person

PESA Panchayat Extension of Scheduled Area

PHCs Primary Health Centres

PHED Public Health Engineering Department

PHH Physically Handicapped

PIA Project Influence Area

PIU Project Implementation Unit

PMC Project Management Consultant

PWD Public Works Department

R&R Resettlement and Rehabilitation

RD Rural Development

RoW Right of Way

RPF Resettlement Policy Framework

RRO Resettlement & Rehabilitation Officer

RSACS Rajasthan StateAIDSControlSociety

RTI Right to Information Act

SACO State AIDS Control Society

SBE Small Business Enterprise

SC Schedule Caste

SCHM Suggestion and Complaint Handling Mechanism

SDE Sub-divisional Engineer

SDM Sub-divisional Magistrate

SDS Social Development Specialist

SGSY Swarnajayanti Gram Swarojgar Yojana

SHG SelfHelpGroup

SIA Social Impact Assessment

SSR Social Screening Report

ST Schedule Tribe

TCS Typical Cross Section

TDP Tribal Development Plan

TH Titleholder

TOR Terms of Reference

WB World Bank

WHH Women Headed Household

WPR Work Participation Rate



MoRT&H ES-1

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

E.1 PROJECT BACKGROUND

Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MoRT&H), Government of India has taken up

National Highways Improvement Inter-Connectivity Project (NHIIP) for strengthening and

upgrading of various single/intermediate/sub-standard two lane National Highways to 2

lane/ 2 lane with paved shoulders. A total of 33 project roads have been selected by

MoRT&H for improvements. Project roads covered under Phase I of NHIIP are likely to be

implemented with World Bank (WB) assistance. The objective of the NHIIP is to provide

better connectivity of various existing National Highways in the country and induce socio-

economic development in the project area.

NH 113 connects Nimbahera in Rajasthan with Dahod district in Gujarat. The highway

originates from junction of NH 79 at Nimbahera in Rajasthan. It traverses through Bari –

Pratapgarh – Pipalkhunt - Ghatol – Banswara – Padi – Kalinjera in Rajasthan and Zalod,

Limbdi and Dahod in Gujarat. It covers a distance of 264.000 km of which 224.600 km is

in Rajasthan and 39.40 km in Gujarat.The proposed project stretch is Contract Package No.

SP/D/1 which starts from km 80.000 and end at km 180.000. It is located in southern part

of Rajasthan State.

The selected section of project road starts at Pratapgarh (km 80+000) in Pratapgarh district

and ends near Padi (km 180+000) in Banswara district in the State of Rajasthan. Total

length of the existing project roadis 100.000 km.It passes through 57 villages under four

tehsils Pratapgarh, Peepalkhut in Pratapgarh District and Ghatol and Banswara in Banswara

District of Rajasthan. More than 50 percent of the population is ST& SC. These districts

come under the Fifth Schedule of the Constitution of India. For the purpose of the study,

administrative boundaries of the districts through which the project road traverses has been

considered as the Project Influence Area (PIA) whereas boundaries of villages and towns in

which upgrading of project road is likely to affect land, structure and other properties have

been considered as Direct Impact Zone (DIZ).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nimbahera

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rajasthan

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dahod

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gujarat


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bari,_India

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pratapgarh

http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Sohagpura&action=edit&redlink=1

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banswara





MoRT&H ES-2

E.2 SOCIO ECONOMIC PROFILE OF THE PROJECT AREA

Pratapgarh District has 868, 231 population and Banswara District 1798,194 Population

as per 2011 Census of India. The ST population in Pratapgarh and Banswara districts is

59.94% and 72.27% respectively. Literacy rate of Banswara and Pratapgarh districts is

57.20% and 56.30% respectively. The area falls under Fifth Schedule of the Constitution

of India which aims at targeted social and economic development of the ST.

E.3 PROPOSED IMPROVEMENT PLAN

Additional land area is needed for various purposes namely, widening of project road,

junction improvement, approach to bridges, bypass, realignment, etc. Additional land

width is needed throughout the project road stretch. Approximately 125 hectare of

additional land area is required from 57 revenue villages which includes52.623 ha of

private land, 30.021 ha of Govt. land and 42.353 ha of forest land a. Efforts have been

made to minimize the adverse impacts of the project by (i) utilizing available ROW as

much as possible, (ii) proposing concentric widening in urban stretches, (iii) adopting the

principle of actual land requirements in open sections of project stretch instead of having

a uniform land width throughout the road stretch, and (iv) provision of bypass for

Banswara town.

E.4 PUBLIC INFORMATION AND CONSULTATIONS

Public information and consultations were held during the social screening, census and

socio-economic survey stages which covered individual consultations, public meeting,

focus group discussion, in-depth interviews, etc. It ensured participation of potential

project affected persons (PAPs), local community and other stakeholders.

People were informed in advance, and allowed to participate in free and fair manner. This

resulted in active participation by the people in making meaningful contribution during

project preparation stage. Specific consultations were also held under Panchayat

Extension of Scheduled Area Act (PESA), 1996and Forest Rights Act (FRA), 2006.

During consultations brief description about the project, road development agency,

involvement of the funding agency, likely adverse impacts and positive impacts,

employment generation, etc were discussed and initial opinion of people were solicited.



MoRT&H ES-3

Hand drawn sketches and design drawings were used to explain the proposed

improvement plan and likely adverse impacts. Concerns, views and suggestions

expressed by the participants during these consultations were shared with the design team

for minimizing the impacts wherever possible. Consultations were held at 26 places

during the project preparation.

Concerns and apprehensions expressed by the community covered compensation amount

for land, structure and other assets, impacts on structures, impact on religious structures,

impacts on sources of earning, likelyhood of being displaced, road accidents, etc. Overall,

project affected persons and other stakeholders are in favour of the proposed project. The

community perceives that the project will help development in the area and also generate

employment opportunities.

E.5 PROJECT IMPACTS

Socio-economic profile of the project affected households has been worked out on the

basis of Census & Socio-economic survey conducted for land, structures and other

properties likely to be affected. PAHs comprise both Hindus and Muslims. PAHs

constitute of 54.34% ST and SC, and all others accounts for balance 45.64% .

A total of 2509 PAPs comprising 1311 males (52.25%) and 1198 (47.74%) females from

414 households are likely to be affected by the proposed widening and upgrading of the

project road. There are 913 females per thousand males. Family types of PAHs have been

categorized based on the number of household members. 11.59% of the households are

nuclear whereas 64.97% are joint households. Extended households constitute of 23.42%

of the total affected household. The average size of the household works out to be 6.0

members.

Of the total 414 PAHs, 347 PAHs(83.81%) are likely to lose land, 61 households are

likely to lose structures and 6 kiosks (small commercial structures). As per the findings of

the survey 43.28% of the head of the households are illiterate. Primary level literate

constitute 29.77% of the total head of the households followed by those who have

completed their secondary education (22.0%), while graduates and post

graduate/technically educated accountsfor 3.94% and 0.99%respectively.



MoRT&H ES-4

Occupational profile indicates that 70.77 % of the households are engaged in agriculture

and allied agricultural activities followed by non-agriculture wage labourers (16.34%),

and others which include service professional,trade, business and self- employed

comprise 12.86% of the total households. Overall the economy of the area is largely

dependent on agriculture and allied agricultural activities.

Households having annual income of less than Rs. 36000 per annum comprise of 67.65%

of the total PAHs whereas 24.86% of the PAHs indicated annual income between Rs.

36000 to 60000 per annum. The income level of 7.47% of the households is more than

Rs. 60000 per annum. Out of the total 414 households who have indicated their monthly

income of less than equal to Rs. 30000 per annum (Rs. 2500 per month) are 38.49%

which includes SC, ST, BPL, general category and other socially vulnerablegroups.

Vulnerable households have been identified as defined in the Resettlement Policy

Framework for the project. They include head of the household who is 65 years & above

in age, households covered under below poverty line (BPL), Women Headed Household

(WHH), Schedule Tribe (ST), Schedule Caste (SC) and Physically Handicapped

Household (PHH) etc. A total of 304 households (including kiosks) have been identified

as vulnerable.

Adverse impacts of the project are distributed all along the project stretch. However,

major impacts would be experienced at Banswara only. A total of 79 structures including

CPRs and Kiosks have been identified which are likely to be affected. Out of the total

structures likely to be affected excluding CPRs (67), 47.76% are title holders.

Encroachers and squatters comprise of 43.28% and kiosks 8.95%. Kiosk has been

identified as a separate category. CPRs (12 Nos.) comprising of government,

community, religious structures, etc are also likely to be affected which constitute

15.18% of the total structures. Structures likely to be affected have been also identified

by its present use. 51.89% of them are used for residential purpose. This is followed by

structures used for commercial purposes 22.78%, and residential cum commercial

purpose 10.12%.

The cut-off date for Non-Titleholders of NH 113 project road is December 2, 2012.The

cut off date for Titleholders will be date of Section 3A of NH Act, 1956.



MoRT&H ES-5

E.6 R & R PRINCIPLES, POLICY FRAME WORK & ENTITLEMENT MATRIX

A Resettlement Policy Framework has been prepared by the Ministry of Road, Transport

& Highways of Government of India for National Highways Inter-Connectivity

Improvement Project (NHIIP). This RPF includes resettlement and rehabilitation

principles and approach which is to be followed in minimizing and mitigating adverse

impacts likely to be caused by the project implementation, entitlements as per eligibility

criteria and commensurate to the type and nature of impact, institutional arrangements,

monitoring and evaluation and grievance redressal mechanism etc. The entitlement

matrix provides the compensation and resettlement and rehabilitation measures against

the identified loss of assets and livelihood under the project. R&R assistances would be

provided for the impacts on structures to the PAPs identified in the RAP. The affected

CPRs shall be relocated or restored in consultation with the community in compliance

with the RPF. Mitigation measures proposed shall address. impacts on women,

vulnerable PAHs, Tribal PAHs. Besides, the vulnerable PAH will receive additional

support in the form of an economic rehabilitation grant to enable them to increase their

earning capacity or alternative income sources for which funds have been provided in the

budget.

E.7 GENDER ISSUE & WOMENS PARTICIPATION

Only four women headed households are likely to be affected by the proposed project.

They constitute 0.97% of the total affected households. Socio-economic parameters like

literacy, work participation rate and general health conditions etc. reveal that social

status of women is low. Participation of women has been envisaged specifically in the

pre-planning and planning stages. These include: inclusion of women members as

investigators/facilitators in the NGO/Consultancy firm for RAP implementation;

encouragement in evaluationof the project outputs with specific gender indicators. All

assistance would be paid in a joint account in the name of both the spouses; involvement

in construction activities by provision of preference in labor opportunities, temporary

Housing, health centre, day crèches, and wherever feasible, primary educational facilities

could be extended.

E.8 TRIBAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND DEVELOPMENT



MoRT&H ES-6

Both the affected districts are in declared Schedule Area under Indian Constitution. Loss

of livelihood to the affected ST households caused by road widening and development

may aggravate the disadvantaged condition unless special attention is paid to them.

Indian Constitution has given foundation to the government for formulating special

programs to assist these vulnerable groups. In this connection an assessment of impacts

specifically on Scheduled Tribes (ST) has been done during the social assessment. Since

more than 50 percent of the affected household are STs and SCs and thus the RAP

covers all these groups and in addition the TDP has been developed and included in this

report to ensure compliance with OP 4.10 and national laws, and also ensures that

mitigation is provided for adverse impacts along with some additional facilities.

A total of 225 ST households is likely to be affected which includes 1360 persons

(51.10% are males and 48.970% are females). The sex ratio is 959.

The illiteracy among the affected persons is 47.86%, primary level educated are 33.75%,

secondary level literate constitute of 15.07%, graduates‘ account for 2.79% while post-

graduation/ Technical Education accounts for 0.51% respectively. Most of the population

is literate to the primary or secondary level. The ST employed persons is 41.02% of the

total population. The main occupation of the people is agriculture or related activities

forboth male and female workers Since majority of population in the area are tribal and

more than 50 percent of the project affected are tribal all the requirements of the

Operation Policy on Indigenous People has been taken into account during the

preparation of RAP. Provision for creation of community assets for common use has also

been made as additional measures for the benefit of scheduled caste and schedule tribe

communities along the project road and is detailed under a separate chapter on Tribal

development Plan.

E.9 INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENT FOR RAP AND TDP IMPLEMENTATION

Institutional arrangements for RAP including TDP implementation include engagement

of Implementation Agency (NGO/ Consultancy Firm), designated R&R Officer at sub-

project level, formation of District Level Replacement Cost Committee and Grievance

Redressal Committee, appointed and/ or designated Land Acquisition cum Social

Development Officer at State Level, and engagement of PMC and M&E agencies at



MoRT&H ES-7

Central Level. The resettlement and rehabilitation assistance to project affected persons

shall be provided in accordance with the entitlement matrix contained in the RPF.

Besides, capacity building plan have been proposed for all staffs involved in the

implementation of RAP including TDP at all three levels. Training to implementation

agency staff will be provided from time to time as part of capacity building plan.



MoRT&H ES-8

E.10 DISCLOSURE, CONSULTATION AND PARTICIPATION PLAN

The Right to Information Act (RTI), 2005 provides for setting out the practical regime of

RTI for citizens to secure access to information under the control of public authorities, in

order to promote transparency and accountability. The process for obtaining information

and details of designated officials will be posted on the MoRTH website

http://www.morth.nic.in. Feedback, if any, would be incorporated into the final RAP

and TDP document. The list of PAPs for disbursement of benefits shall be separately

disclosed at the concerned Panchayat Offices/ Urban Local Bodies, District Collector

Offices, Block Development Offices, District Public Relations Offices (at the state and

district levels), Project office, and any other relevant offices, etc. The Executive

Summary of SIA and RAP including TDP report will be translated into the local language

(Hindi) and disclosed.

The consultation plan aims to ensure peoples‘ continued participation in the

implementation phase and to promote public understanding and fruitful solutions of

developmental problems.,The Suggestion and Complaint Handling Mechanism (SCHM)

will report project related complaints/concerns at all levels of institutions—MoRTH,

State, Project/site level. During consultations the RAP including TDPimplementation

agency personnel will explain the process of SCHM in detail. Several communication

channels viz., toll free phone number, dedicated email, mechanism for on line submission

of suggestions/complaints/inquiries, provision of suggestion/complaint box (at site and

project office), post and other suitable means shall be set up for suggestion and complaint

handling.

E.11 MONITORING AND EVALUATION (M&E)

The overall purpose of the monitoring is to keep track of the implementation processes

and progress, achievement of performance targets fixed in the annual work plans,

learning lessons and taking corrective actions to deal with emerging constraints and

issues. The evaluation study will focus on assessing whether the overall objectives of the

project are being met and will use the defined impact indicators as a basis for evaluation.

Reports on the progress of RAP including TDP implementation covering mobilization of

http://www.morth.nic.in/



MoRT&H ES-9

staff members, opening of site offices, etc of the project would be prepared by

Implementation agency and submitted to the R&R officer at sub-project level. The

Monthly Progress Report shall be prepared by the Implementation agency. Quarterly

Progress Reports shall be prepared by LA cum SDO, and six monthly progress reports

shall be prepared by M&E agency. Evaluation Report shall be prepared by the M&E

agency at the end of the project implementation as part of the project completion report.

E.12 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENT AND SCHEDULE

A time period of 30 months has been allocated for the implementation of RAP including

TDP in view of substantial land acquisition involved..

E.13 GRIEVANCE REDRESSAL MACHANISM

Any disputesorgrievances will beaddressedthroughthe grievance

redressalmechanism.TheGRCwill resolvethegrievances ofthe

eligiblepersonswithinastipulatedtime. Thedecisionof theGRCisbinding,unlessvacatedby

courtoflaw. This means the decision of the GRC does not debar PAPs taking recourse to

court of law, if he/she so desires.

The GRC will comprise five members headed by a retired Magistrate not below the rank

of SDM. Other members of the GRC will include a retired PWD Officer (not below the

rank of Executive Engineer), RRO, representative of PAPs and Sarpanch (Elected Head

of Village) of the concerned village. Grievances of PAPs in writing will be brought to

GRC for redressal by the RAP including TDP implementation agency. The RAP

including TDP implementation agency will provide all necessary help to PAPs in

presenting his/her case before the GRC. The GRC will respond to the grievance within 15

days. The GRC will normally meet once in a month but may meet more frequently, if the

situation so demands. A time period of 45 days has been fixed for redressing the

grievance of PAPs.

E.14 REHABILITATION & RESETTLEMENT BUDGET

Based on the Entitlement Matrix, the R&R budget for the Pratapgarh-Padi road section of

NH 113 has been estimated. It comprises of two broad components namely compensation

and assistance.



MoRT&H ES-10

The total estimatedR&R budget for the project works out to Rs. 8983.49lakh of which

Rs. 8045.26 lakhs is towards compensation for land and structures and Rs. 938.23 lakhs

asR&R assistance.



MoRT&H 1-1

CHAPTER 1

PROJECT BACKGROUND AND INTRODUCTION

1.1 PROJECT BACKGROUND

Ministry of Road Transport & Highways (MoRT&H) of Government of India has

decided to up- grade some of the existing single lane /intermediate lane National

Highways to at least 2-lane standards through National Highways Inter-connectivity

Improvement Program (NHIIP) with World Bank Assistance. The NHIIP comprises of

33 project roads of non-NHDP National Highways across 7 states and 1 Union Territory

with total length of 3422 km. Of these, 11 sub-projects have been proposed by

MoRT&H for implementation under Phase I of NHIIP with World Bank loan assistance.

The present report pertains to Pratapgarh - Padi section (km 80 to km 180 of the existing

length of 100 km) of NH-113 in the state of Rajasthan. MoRT&H intends to rehabilitate

and up-grade the existing single lane/intermediate/two lane between Pratapgarh - Padi of

NH–113 to 2-lanes/2-lane with paved shoulders configuration and strengthening. The

implementation of rehabilitation and up-gradation of this corridor is likely to be taken

up with World Bank loan assistance. World Bank has agreed to support this sub-project

in- principle provided the implementation confirms to environmental and social

safeguard policies of the World Bank and the legal framework of the country.

National Highway 113 (NH 113) is an interstate highway lying in western part of India.

It connects Nimbahera in Rajasthan with Dahod district in Gujarat. The highway

originates from junction of NH 79 at Nimbahera in Rajasthan passing through – Bari –

Pratapgarh – Pipalkhoont - Ghatol – Banswara – Padi – Kalinjera to Gujarat covering

Zalod, Limbdi and Dahod. It covers a distance of 264.000 km of which 224.600 km is in

Rajasthan and 39.40 km in Gujarat.

The selected section of project road starts at Pratapgarh (km 80+000) in Pratapgarh

district and ends near Padi (km 180+000) in Banswara district in the State of Rajasthan.

The project requires World Bank, Government of India (GOI) and the State Government

(GOR) clearances and approvals before the construction work can proceed. The project



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dahod



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bari,_India

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pratapgarh

http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Sohagpura&action=edit&redlink=1

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banswara





MoRT&H 1-2

passes through 25 km plain terrain, 69 km through rolling terrain and 6 km through hilly

terrain. The reserved forests section along the project road falls between km 106+000 to

km 116+000, km 136+490 to km 138+855 and km 147+715 to km 148+255 covering

atotal length of about 12.975 km (See Annexure 1.1 for forest details). Therefore,

Forest Clearance for this project is involved from concerned Regional Officein the light

of Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 as pernotification of GoI, MoEF dated 18th Feb

1998. The project section of NH-113 falls under ―Category –A‖ Project for clearance

(under the preview of EIA Notification 2006, amended in 2009) from MoEF as the total

length is 96.540 km and involves acquisition of land strip of 30 m width for Banswara

Bypass. There is no wildlife sanctuary and national park within 10 km of the project

road therefore clearance for this is not required.

MoRT&H has appointed ―Consulting Engineering Group‖ as project consultant to assist

all aspects of project preparation and implementation in accordance with the objectives

as detailed in the Terms of Reference (TOR). These tasks are linked to the engineering,

environment and social aspects of the project preparation that will be undertaken

throughout the period of consultancy agreement.

1.2 PROJECT ROAD DESCRIPTION

The existing NH-113 is two lane/intermediate lane with earthen/gravel shoulders

throughout its length. The terrain is plain from km 80.000 to km 85.000 and km

160.000 to km 180.000, rolling from km 86.000 to km 110.000 and km 115.000 to km

160.000 while from km 85.000 to km 86.000 and km 110.000 to km 115.000 is hilly.

Thus, out of 100.00 km, 94.000 km are rolling to plain terrain corridors (See Annexure

1.2 for types of terrain). The width of carriageway is 5.5 m for 74.00 km and remaining

26.00 km of carriageway is of 7.00 m width. A large number of major/minor bituminous

roads (NH, SH, & village roads) meet the project stretch at various locations. Table 1.1

gives the total length of the projected in each district.



MoRT&H 1-3

Table 1.1: Project Road

S.No Pratapgrah- Padi Section Districts Length (km)

1 Km 80+000 to 120+000 Pratapgarh 40.000

2 Km120+000 to180.000 Banswara 56.540

Total 96.540

The available Right of Way (RoW) as per the revenue records varies from minimum 6.0 m

to maximum 55.0 m from Pratapgrah to Padi Kalan in the different sections of the

corridors (See Annexure 1.3 for chainage wise details for available RoW). There are

many locations where alignment needs geometric improvements to maintain riding quality

of highway and safe movement of vehicles. Improvement of highway geometrics is

proposed in the entire stretch. All geometrically deficient curves (See Annexure 1.4 for

chainage wise details of deficient curves) are proposed for curve improvement. A route

Map of NH 113 is shown in Figure1.1.

Fig1.1Project Highway (Pratapgarh-Padi NH-113) Map



MoRT&H 1-4

1.3 PROPOSED PROJECT

Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MoRTH) has taken up the development of

the Pratapgarh- Padi section of NH 113 in the State of Rajasthan into 2-lane/2-lane with

paved shoulder configuration. Rajasthan state PWD will be the executing agency for the

project. The proposed up gradation for NH 113 aims to:

Improve and strengthen the existing quality of the pavement to take heavy loads

so that pavement failure, maintenance etc. is minimized.

Improve horizontal and vertical alignment of the existing road.

Improve the condition of existing traffic flow by removing all bottlenecks at

various locations.

Increase the carrying capacity of the existing traffic volume and enable it to cater

to the future traffic.

Improve accessibility of the existing highway.

Provide highway amenities like truck lay-bye, bus stop etc.

1.4 APPROACH AND METHODOLOGY

Experience indicates that involuntary resettlement generally gives rise to severe problems

for the affected population. Proper dissemination of project related information will help

to reduce the insecurity and opposition towards the project which may otherwise be likely

to occur. The project will therefore ensure that the affected population and other

stakeholders are timely informed consulted and actively participate in the development

process. This consultation is continued at each and every stage of the project.

1.4.1 Public Consultations

The public consultations is an ongoing process, at the feasibility stage public

consultations focused mainly on the mapping of the social issues related to the project

stretch and were targeted to understand the concerns and aspirations of the people from

the up gradation work. The second round of public consultations primarily centered on

sharing of the proposed development plan and R&R policy framework with the PAPs for



MoRT&H 1-5

their views on the development proposals and the issues related to resettlement and

rehabilitation.

In addition to the consultations with the PAPs, interactions and consultations were held

with other stakeholders especially the Gram Pardhan, PWD Officials and district

administration to elicit their views and mobilize support for the implementation phase.

The consultations with the officials of district administration including land revenue were

conducted under the Chairmanship of District Magistrate/ Block Development officer. It

helped in getting assurance from them in terms of cooperation and support for the

implementation of the project and for the nomination of Competent Authorities (CA).

1.4.2 Census Surveys and Structure Marking

Questionnaire used for census survey included all necessary data/input for preparing the

Rehabilitation Action Plan (RAP). Successful implementation of the RAP depends on

appropriate and accurate census and socio-economic surveys of PAFs/ PAPs. The surveys

were carried out for the non-titleholders and titleholders, keeping in view the

requirements for the assessment of the category and quantum of losses, so that the

entitlements can be evolved in a logical and scientific manner. The survey ensured that

each and every affected and displaced person is identified and his/her entitlements are

worked out as per the resettlement policy framework of NHIIP and the expenditure

estimates are determined on the basis of the entitlements.



MoRT&H 2-1

CHAPTER 2

SOCIO-ECONOMIC PROFILE OF THE PROJECT INFLUENCE ZONE

2.1 INTRODUCTION

This chapter contains socio-economic profile of proposed project-impacted district i,e.,

Pratapgarh and Banswara. An overview of the demographic profile includes level of

urbanization, land use pattern, occupational pattern, income level, employment pattern

and vulnerability. The other information provided is to supplement the contextual

background.

2.2 SOCIO-ECONOMIC STATUS OF PROJECT INFLUENCE DISTRICT

This section of the project highway traverses through Pratapgarh district at a length of 40

km and Banswara length is of 56.540 km.

2.2.1 Pratapgarh District Profile

Pratapgrah District is 33rd district of Rajasthan. It came into being on 26th

January 2008.

Pratapgarh District population constituted 1.27 percent of total Rajasthan population as

per 2011 Census.

The district is situated in the junction of the Aravalli mountain ranges and the Malwa

Plateau. Hence, the characteristics of both the geographic area prominently features in the

study corridor. Pratapgarh is located at 24.03° N latitude & 74.78° E longitude with an

average elevation of 491 meters (1610 feet). The district is known for pure gold and

glass-inlay handmade unique jewelry called "Thewa".

About 45% of the district is under forestland. The area falls under Schedule V category of

the Constitution and Meena tribes predominate in the region Common lands (grazing and

forest) comprise a major portion of the landscape, with habitations and villages scattered

in between. However, a number of factors, such as unfavorable tenure arrangements,

improper management systems, overgrazing and illegal tree felling together have

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008



MoRT&H 2-2

contributed to the degradation of the land over the years. Pratapgrah is one of those

districts of Rajasthan, which is best suited for eco-tourism.

The district is divided into five subdivisions, Amod, Chhoti Sadari, Dhiriyawas,

Pipalkhoont and Pratapgrah. Pratapgrah district has 1008 villages, 152 Panchayat

Sámities, 145 Patwar circles; amongst them project road traverse Pipalkhoont and

Pratapgarh subdivision.

Pipalkhoont Tehsil- Pipalkhoont has 27 Panchayat Sámities, 20 Patwar circle and

207 Villages. Total population as per 2001 census is 118439 in which Male constitute

60159 and Female is 58280. Male Literacy rate is 52.44% while Female literacy rate

is 22.74%.

Pratapgrah Tehsil- Pratapgrah has 42 Panchayat Sámities, 46 pat war circles and

297 villages.

2.2.2 Banswara District Profile

District Banswara is situated in the southernmost part of Rajasthan. It has an area of

5,037 sq km and lies between 23.11° N to 23.56° N latitude and 73.58° E to 74.49° E

longitude.

As per 2001 census, the total population in the district is 1420601, where as in 1991

census it was 1155600. The population growth rate compared to 1991 census is 29.84

% and the density of population according to 2001 census is 298 per sq km.

Banswara district presently has 5 Tehsil and 8 Development Blocks. There are total 28

ILR circles, 215 Pat war Mandal, 307 Gram Panchayats and 1516 Villages out of which

1492 are "inhabited" and 24 "un-inhabited".

Banswara Tehsil- In Banswara Tehsil, total villages are 356, out of which 342 are

inhabited villages and 14 are uninhabited villages, 73 Gram Panchayats and 46 Pat

war Mandal.

Total Population is 371320 out of which, male constitutes to 189538 and females are



MoRT&H 2-3

181782. The total literacy rate is 52.36% out of that male literacy rate is 67.32% and

female literacy rate is 36.83%.

Ghatol Tehsil- In Ghatol, total villages are 239, out of which 236 villages are

inhabited villages and 3 are un-inhabited villages, 53 are Gram Panchayats and 37 are

Patwar Mandal. Total population is 230344 of which male constitutes to 116238 and

females are 114106. The total literacy rate is 37.67% out of that male literacy rate is

54.30% and female literacy rate is 20.86%.

Demographic features of PIA districts (2001-2011) are given in Annexure 2.1.

2.3 PROJECT IMPACT ZONE

The road users and population benefited / affected by the project road aremainly those

who use the existing road/ proposed alignment for their daily needs. The impact analysis

was carried out in detail for the households falling within proposed ROW and indirect

impact was also assessed within 1 kilometer buffer zone on either side of proposed road.

Socio-Economic Profiling

The majority of the potentially affected/ benefited persons living in the project influence

zone frequently travels down the existing roads or proposed alignment of the project.

Their purpose of visit brings them generally to the prominent market places by the

roadside or transport boarding points. Other beneficiaries also pass through the important

junctions of the feeder roads connecting the project road / proposed alignment. These

junction points were selected for consultation and FGDs. Besides, administrative offices,

places of worship, community structures, in the major settlements within the project

impact zone were also taken into considerations for holding consultations.

Direct impactwill involve the habitations along the existing project road and indirect

impact habitations will involve those within 1.0 km of the project road on either side.

GOI, GOR regulations and World Bank policy require impact assessment during the

design stage to avoid, reduce or mitigate potential negative impacts of project and

enhance positive impacts, sustainability and development benefits.



MoRT&H 2-4

The project area‘s district socio economic profile has been given in Annexure 2.1. It will

help in understanding the demographic trends of both the districts which includes the

baseline study. Banswara district has more population than Pratapgarh district with

population growth of 3.74 %. As per the census of India for the year 2001 the ST

population constitutes to be 72.27 % in Banswara district and 59.94 % in Pratapgarh

District. As per 2011 census the literacy rate of both the districts is more than 55%.

2.3.1 Population

Thevillage wise population is given in Annexure 2.2. In the affected village‘s total

number of household are 51595 with population of 279955 of both the districts.

2.3.2 Literacy Status

As per 2001Census, in the affected villages male literacy is high in comparison to female

literacy rate. Village wise segregation of literacy rates by gender is attached as Annexure

2.3.

2.3.3 Working and Non- Working Population

Percentage of workers engaged in different activities indicates the nature of employment

available in the area. Work Participation Rate (WPR) is presented in Annexure 2.4. The

total working population in the project stretch is 53.07%. Data reveals that people are

primarily engaged in agriculture and cultivation. Non workers constitutes of 46.93% of

the total population which indicates high dependency ratio. Most of the non-workers in

the affected villages are females. Similar pattern has been observed at district level as

mentioned above.

2.3.4 Existing Public Amenities

Public amenities are those basic services utilized away from the individual residential

dwelling unit within the public environment. Presence of basic infrastructure facilities is

found in the project districts. They satisfy specific individual or community needs

including safety and security, communication, recreation, sport, education, health, public

administration and religious. Public amenities are generally the responsibility of



MoRT&H 2-5

government or the local authorities of the area. Accessibility of basics infrastructure is an

important factor from the social development context. List of public amenities in the

districts of the project road is presented in Table 2.1.Improvement of project road will

increase access to public facilities like higher level schools, colleges, health services

(CHCs, PHCs), government offices, etc.

Table 2.1: District wise List of Public Amenities

S.

No Amenities Units in Numbers

Pratapgarh Banswara

1. Health & Medical Amenities

CHCs Hospitals & PHCs 30 61

Others 656 404

2. PHED

Drinking Water Villages 948 -

Handpumps 872 -

Tubewell 25 -

Public Wells 163

Pond 26 -

Tank & Canal 34

3. Education

Primary & Upper Primary School 1230 2963

Secondary & Senior Secondary

School 205 348

Shikha Karmi Schools - 246

College- General & Professional 7 18

ITI 6 4

4. Post Office 7 276 5. Anganwadi Centre Working 1057 -



MoRT&H 3-1

CHAPTER 3

ANALYSIS OF ALTERNATIVES & PROPOSED IMPROVEMENT PLAN

3.1 NEED FOR MINIMIZATION OF IMPACT

Infrastructure projects not only bring the prosperity to the region but also leave behind

number of adverse impact on the society. Such adverse impacts include loss of land and

structure, loss of livelihood, loss of community properties along with fragmentation of

society. If such negative impacts are not addressed properly, it may happen that the

outcome of a project negative impacts would outweighs the project positive impacts, thus

putting question mark on project sustainability. World Bank Policy and the National

Policy on Resettlement & Rehabilitation have rightly acknowledged the seriousness of

the issue and advocates for minimizing negative impactsby exploring all feasible options

without compromising the safety aspects. The spirit of these policies has been followed

while preparing the RAP for this project.

3.2 DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS

3.2.1 Proposed Design Standards for Highway

Geometric design standards for rural (Non-urban) Highways‖ IRC-73-1980 has been

used for study of project road passing through rural areas. To set the Geometric design

for urban section i.e., sections where the highway is passing through the existing villages

& built-up zone, "Geometric Design for Urban Highways" IRC-86-1983 has been

adhered too. The proposed project road is 2-lane paved /earthen shoulder configuration.

The designing of the proposed route is carried for the upcoming next 15 years and

various type of designing standards are used viz. IRC: 37- 2001, IRC: 38 – 1988, IRC

SP: 42-1994, IRC SP 73:2007. The proposed design speed varies between 80-65 km/h in

rolling terrain and 50 km/h in hilly terrain.Adopted Design standards are given in Table

3.1.



MoRT&H 3-2

Table 3.1: Basis of Road Designs

S.No. IRC codes/Manuals Guideline used for

1 IRC:37- 2001,‖ GUIDELINE FOR DESIGN OF

FLEXIBLE PAVEMENT‖ New flexible pavement

design

2 IRC: 38 – 1988, ― GUIDELINES FOR DESIGN

OF HORIZONTAL CURVES FOR HIGHWAYS

AND DESIGN TABLES‖

Design of Horizontal

Curves

3 IRC: 58-2002 ―GUIDELINE FOR THE DESIGH

OF PLAIN JOINTED RIGID PAVEMENT FOR

HIGHWAYS‖ Design of rigid pavement

4

IRC:81-1997 ,‖GUIDELINES FOR

STRENTHENING OF FLEXIBLE ROAD

PAVEMENTS USING BENKALMAN BEAM

DEFLECTION TECHNIQUE‖

Design of overlays for

strengthening of the

flexible pavements

5 MORTH 5TH REVISION Specifications for

pavement design

6 IRC : 73-1980 GEOMETRIC DESIGN

STANDARDS FOR RURAL ( NON-URBAN)

HIGHWAYS

Specifications for

geometric design of

pavement

7 IRC SP 73:2007,‖ TWO-LANING OF

HIGHWAY THROUGH PUBLIC PRIVATE

PARTNERSHIP MANUAL OF STANDARDS ‖

Guideline for 2-lane

Highway Design

8 IRC SP : 42-1994,‖GUIDELINES ON ROAD

DRAINAGE‖ Drainage design

9 IRC SP : 41-1994,‖GUIDELINE FOR THE

DESIGN OF AT-GRADE INTRESECTIONS IN

RURAL & URBAN AREAS

Guideline for Intersection

design

10 IRC SP 23: ―VERTICAL CURVES FOR

HIGHWAY‖ Guideline for vertical

curve design

11 IRC 75:‖GUIDELINES FOR DESIGN OF HIGH

EMBANKMENTS‖ Guideline for high

embankment design

Based on outcome of various survey / Investigation, Design Consideration, Road Safety

Audit, social and environmental screening of existing project section, the improvement

plan of proposed highway have been prepared by the technical design team in

consultation with social and environmental team engaged in this project.

The improvement works will consist mainly in upgrading/improvement of road

geometrics, widening to two-lane/ intermediate-lane from the existing, intermediate-lane



MoRT&H 3-3

or single-lane width and pavement strengthening, improving the cross drainage. Road

stretches crossing urban areas may also require upgrading to a two-lane cross section,

and/or provision for drains, sidewalks and parking where required. In some cases, new

alignments (by-pass) and/or realignments may also be required. The adopted cross-

sectional element as per design standard and salient features of the project is presented in

the table 3.2 below:

Table: 3.2 Project Improvement Plan of NH-113

S.No Particulars Existing Proposed

1 Project Stretch Km 80.00 to Km 180.000 Km 80.00 to Km 176.54.

2 Road Length 100.000 Km 96.540 Km

3 Carriageway 5.5 m 7.0 m + earthen shoulders

7.0 m+ paved shoulders

4 ROW (m) 7 m to 55 m 13 -30 for widening on Existing

Alignment

30 m for bypass and realignment

5 Realignment – 7.994 Km

6 Junctions Major-2, Minor-67 Major-4, Minor-66

7 Cattle Underpasses – 3

8 Bus Bays & Shelter – 2 x 5

9 Truck Lay bay – 1

10 Major Bridges 4 8

11 Minor Bridges 39 34

12 Culverts 257 267

13 Toll Plaza – 2

(LA is not proposed for Toll Plaza)

14 Bypass – Banswara Bypass

3.3 BY-PASSES AND ALTERNATIVE ALIGNMENT

Analysis of alternatives involves a systematic study of the possible future conditions in

the project area in response to a set of alignment alternatives without the project. The

choice of widening options depends to a large extent on site constraint and construction

methodology. It has been an endeavor of the consultant to propose widening option

keeping in view the following key factors:



MoRT&H 3-4

Minimizing interference with religious structures such as temples, mosques,

churches, crematories and mazar etc.

Minimum impact on residential and commercial property abutting the corridor.

Land use and availability of land.

Optimum utilization of existing pavement and RoW at location of curve

improvement.

Drainage consideration.

Based on the above factors, the following Cross Sections have been adopted:

1. Widening is done along the existing alignment eccentrically in rural areas and

concentrically in urban areas/ habitations/market locations.

2. Wherever adequate RoW is not available, the deficient curves are improved to

design speed of 80 km/h in plain terrain and 80-65 km/h in rolling area as per

guidelines of MoRTH.

3. As far as possible the widening is accommodated within the existing RoW and

additional land acquisition is kept to absolutely minimum.

4. Numbers of realignments are kept to minimum Bypass is proposed at Banswara

5. In built up area, the widening has been proposed in the entire existing RoW to

restrict future encroachments.

Many sections of the project road are passing through congested towns. Possibility of

realignment/ bypass along the project route has been examined through field verification,

where RoW is not sufficient to improve the geometrics and there is congestion and poor

traffic condition.As such a bypass for Banswara urban section (km 157+461 to km

173+106 - 12.660 km length) and realignments of 7.994 km for curve improvements have

been proposed.



MoRT&H 3-5

3.4 ANALYSIS OF ALIGNMENTS

3.4.1 Ghatol

Ghatol urban sectionfalls between km 134.00 to 138.00 with commercial cum residential

activities along the project road. The available width between building line to building

line is only 13m to 17m. Initially Public consultation was done on the existing alignment

at three locations in Ghatol thesil at km 134, 136 and 138 respectively. Figure 3.1 gives

the satellite imagery of Ghatol town through which NH 113 is traversing.

Figure 3.1 Existing Route of NH 113 through Ghatol Town

Public consultations were conducted in villages along the existing alignment under

Ghatol tehsilbetween 18.10.2010 to 23.10.2010 in view of congestion and road safety

primarily. Initially peoplein general demanded provision of bypassfor Ghatol. After the

discussion with the stakeholders, alternatives were studied and compared as given in

Figure 3.3 and Table 3.3.



MoRT&H 3-6

Figure 3.2 Ghatol Alternative Alignments



MoRT&H 3-7

Table 3.3 Comparison between different alternatives for Ghatol

S.

No. Parameters

Through

Existing

Alignment

Option-I

(RHS )

Option-II

(RHS)

Option-III

(LHS)

1 Length

Bypass Length (m) - 4704 3597 5777

Widening Length of

approach to bypass (m) -

909 1570 0

Total Travelled Length

(m) -

5613 5167 5777

2 Existing RoW 13m-33m - - -

3 Proposed RoW of Bypass Nil 30m 30m 30m

4 Forest Area Nil

No No Reserve

Forest

5 Land to be Acquired Nil 13.65 Ha 12.36 Ha 17.33 Ha

6 Cost of the Land (In Crore) Nil 8.38 7.60 10.64

7 Structures

to be

Affected

No. of

Houses/Shops

- 7 8

8 Area of Affected

Structures Nil

- 472 Sq m 357 Sq m

9 Cost of the structures (In Crore) Nil - 3.2 1.1

10 Basic Civil Cost (In Crore) 15.65 12.48 11.4 16.20 11 Total Cost (In Crore) 15.65 20.86 22.20 27.94

Based on the three alignment options explored for bypass, Option I was found suitable

for further study. Subsequently, consultation under PESA1, 1996 was held in Ghatol

village for getting no objection from land owners and villagers. NOC was not given by

the respective Gram Sabha and this was timely intimated to MoRTH. Since NOC under

PESA could not be obtained for Bypass at Ghatol the Bypass is dropped as per ministry

letter dated 19.06.2013 No. RW/NH-2013/19/2010/SP/(D/1)P-9. Hence project roads

shall be developed within the existing RoW by providing 2 lanes with paved shoulders,

covered drains with footpath and railing either side as safety measures. The details of the

Public consultations and Gram Sabhas are provided in Chapter 4.

3.4.2 Banswara bypass

Figure 3.7 shows satellite imagery of the existing NH-113 through Banswara town.

1The proposed bypass involved land acquisition in scheduled area which required consultation under PESA, 1996.



MoRT&H 3-8

Figure 3.3 Existing Route of NH 113 through Banswara Town

Banswara is the district headquarters and is densely populated along the project road.

Built-up area is located between km 157+461 to km 173+106 with commercial activities

on the ground floor and residence at upper floors. The existing alignment passes through

the heart of the Banswara city. The available distance between building line to building

line is varying from 10m to 20m. Opting the existing alignment without any geometric

improvement was likely to affect 57 structures in the length of 2.50 km including number

of shops and offices, two school building and three temples etc. Therefore two alternative

options have been studied and analysed for bypass as in figure 3.4 and table 3.4 below:



MoRT&H 3-9

Figure 3.4: Banswara bypass from km 157+700 to 170+360

Table 3.4: Comparison between different alternatives for Banswara bypass

S.

No. Parameters

Through

Existing

Alignment

Option-I

(RHS)

Option-II

(Left)

1 Length

Bypass Length (m) - 12660 18026

Widening Length of approach

to bypass (m) -

0 0

Total Travelled Length (m) - 12660 18026

2 Existing ROW 10 to 20m - -

3 Proposed ROW - 30m 30m

4 Forest Area - No Reserve Forest

5 Land to be Acquired 38.40 Ha 54.07 Ha

6 Cost of the Land (In Crore) 18.81 23.13

7 Structurest

o be

Affected

No. of Houses/Shops 57 - -

8 Area of Affected Structures - - -

9 Cost of the structures - - -

10 Basic Civil Cost (In Crore) - 29.61 36.41

11 Total Cost (In Crore) - 48.42 59.54

Option-II

Option- I Recommended

Banswara Bypass



MoRT&H 3-10

Conclusion for Bypass at Banswara

Alternative alignment option-II for bypass on the left hand side of Banswara was not

found feasible as the alignment is passing through the Reserve Forest, pond, high cutting

of hills and length and the cost is also high. Option-I from right side of the existing

alignment is recommendedas no structure will be affected and also reduces theoverall

road length as compared to existing length.

3.4.3 Realignments

Following realignment locations have been identified to improve the horizontal

geometrics of the project road. Details of realignment are given in Table 3.5.

Table 3.5: Detailed list of Realignment Sections from km 80 to km 180

S

No

Chainage (m) Length

(m)

Reasons for Realignment

From To

1 87043 87600 557 Realignment due to Submersible bridge





and Geometry Improvement

6 116000 116600 600 Realignment due to Submersible bridge and

Geometric Improvement


8 125200 126080 880 Realignment Due to Geometric

Improvement




12 157700 170360 12660 Banswara Bypass

13 172810 173478 668 Realignment due to Curve Improvement

3.5 PROPOSED IMPROVEMENT PLAN

3.5.1 Pedestrian and Animal Crossing

On the basis of interfering traffic study, certain locations have been identified for locating

underpasses. Pedestrian/ Cattle underpass has been proposed to cater for the crossing of

pedestrian/ Cattle. Location of Cattle/ wild life passes is vetted by the environmental



MoRT&H 3-11

specialist in consultation with the forest department officials are as given in the table 3.6

below:

Table 3.6: List of Proposed CUP Locations

S.

No.

Location

(Km)

Proposed

Structure

Span

Arrangement

Super

Structure

Total

Width

1 86+570 CUP 1 x 7 x 3.5 RCC Box 12 m

2 138+278 CUP 1 x 7 x 3.5 RCC Box 12 m

3 147+730 CUP 1 x 7 x 3.5 RCC Box 12 m

Figure 3.5: Schematic Figure of Cattle Underpass

3.5.2 Wayside Amenities

Wayside amenities survey was carried out to ascertain the existing facilities available for

passenger and goods traffic along the project corridor. Wayside Amenities like petrol

pumps, dhabas, bus stops, etc., exist all along the Project Highway. However, there is a

need to integrate the amenities and also supplement by additional amenities.

3.5.3 Traffic Control guidance and safety and speed Control Measures

Road signs notify road users of regulations and provide warning and guidance safe

needed for reasonably, uniform and efficient operation. Mainly three type of sign have

been provided on the project stretch are namely Mandatory or regulatory sign, Cautionary

or warning signs and informatory or guide signs.



MoRT&H 3-12

3.5.4 Design Speed

For the whole project stretch design speeds have been adopted as per the terrain. The

whole project stretch has been classified into plain, rolling and mountainous terrain. Plain

terrain has been design for the speed of 80 kmph, rolling terrain for the speed of 80kmph-

65kmph and mountainous terrain for the speed of 50 kmph. The built-up/ urban sections

have been design for the speed of 60 kmph. Predominantly project road passes through

rolling terrain. The km wise classifications of terrain and design speed adopted are as

follows in Table 3.7.

Table: 3.7 Design Speed

S.

No. From To Terrain Adopted Design Speed

1 Km 80/000 Km 85/000 Plain 80 kmph

2 Km 85/000 Km 86/000 Mountainous 50 kmph

3 Km 86/000 Km 110/000 Rolling 80-65 kmph

4 Km 110/000 Km 115/000 Mountainous 50 kmph

5 Km 115/000 Km 160/000 Rolling 80-65 kmph

6 Km 160/000 Km 180/000 Plain 80 kmph

3.5.5 Horizontal Curves

The minimum radius of the curve has been adopted as per the IRC: 73 based on the

design speed. Horizontal curves have been provided with the circular curve flanked by

the spiral transitions at the both ends. Super elevations have been given at the curve

portion to counter act the centrifugal force subjected to a maximum of 7%. As far as

possible reverse curve are avoided but at few locations of difficult terrain reverse curve

have been provided. Reverse curves are provided with the sufficient length of the

transition between the two curves. The maximum distance maintained between the two

curves is less



MoRT&H 3-13

3.5.6 Vertical Curves

Vertical curves have been designed taking into consideration, the minimum length as

specified IRC: 73 Table: 20. Grades have been adopted based on the type of terrain.

Ruling gradient is provided as far as possible and limiting gradient is provided for a very

short length of 200m-300m.

3.5.7 Intersections

4 major junctions and 66 minor junctions are proposed on the project stretch. Out of 4

major junctions at the start and end of Banswara bypass two are of the Y-type junction.

Other two are 4-legged cross junction at SH-32 and another SH-10. All major junctions

are on the bypass and in the rural section. All 4 major junctions are designed for

channelized At-grade. Major junction are designed as per IRC:SP:41. The minimum

turning radius adopted based on the large semi-truck trailer having a minimum turning

radius of 18.20m.The inner turning radius of 20m have been adopted. The length of the

acceleration lane including taper length have been adopted 230m and deceleration length

including taper length have been adopted 130m based on the speed of 80 kmph for the

plain terrain. These lanes are also called as speed change lanes and provision of these

increases the capacity of intersection and improve safety during maneuver. The width of

the turning lanes is 5.50m adopted. At the cross road, stop sign have been given with the

rumble strip to slow down the vehicles. Vehicle crossing the NH will stop and first give

way to the traffic on the NH and then vehicle will cross the road. All the minor junctions

have been designed as per the MOST book of standard drawing for intersection.

3.5.8 Visibility

As per the IRC: SP:41 minimum of safe stopping sight distances of 130m should be

available for the design speed of 80 kmph. All obstructions in the visibility triangle like

bushes, trees and hoardings shall be removed to improve the safety. Appropriate lighting

arrangement is proposed at the junctions for night visibility. Signage is proposed viz. stop

sign, give way, object marker etc. chevron marking and kerbs marking is also proposed.



MoRT&H 3-14

3.5.9 Other Issues at Intersections

Speed control is the major issue at the junction and is controlled by proposing the speed

breaker for minor cross road and rumble strip for the major cross road like for NH/SH.

STOP line is also marked on the cross road at junctions. The vehicle crossing the NH will

stop first, give way to main road (NH) traffic and then cross the road and this will

informed the road users by proposed GIVE WAY sign on the cross road just before the

junction.

3.5.10 Access Control

The project highway is of two lane configuration with both ways traffic movements,

therefore access control cannot be maintained.

3.6 CROSS SECTION, RUMBLE STRIP

3.6.1 Cross Section

Out of the total l00 km length 74 km is intermediate lane and remaining 26 km is 2-lane.

2-lane width is available at the major town and at nearby major towns. Proposed road

section adopted is 2-lane with earthen shoulder as the traffic is less than 6500 PCU for

rolling terrain in the rural areas.

Concentric widening scheme have been adopted throughout the project stretch to

minimize the land acquisition cost and R&R cost as far as possible.

For the major towns 2-lane with paved shoulder with 1.50m wide footpath cum drain has

been proposed. The typical cross sections for rural and urban stretch are given in table

3.8.



MoRT&H 3-15

2- Lane Section for Rural Stretch

2

-

L

a

n

e

With Paved Shoulder for Urban Stretch

Table 3.8: Description of TCS, used in proposed designing

TCS No. Description Total

Length

TCS -1 Concentric widening (rural area) from existing 5.50m to 2-lane with 2.5m

earthen shoulder and open drain on either side 37.798 km

TCS -2 Concentric widening (rural area) from existing 7.0m to 2-lane with 2.5m

earthen shoulder and open drain on either side 9.693 km

TCS -3 New Construction (rural area)-2-lane with 2.5m earthen shoulder and open

drain on either side `31.113 km

TCS -4 Concentric widening (urban area) from existing 7.0m wide carriageway -Two

lanning with 1.5m paved shoulder, 0.20m raised kerb with railing, Service

road (varies) and 1.50m wide footpath cum cover drain on either side 0.742 km

TCS -5 Concentric widening (urban area) from existing 5.50m wide carriageway -

Two lanning with 1.5m paved shoulder, 0.20m raised kerb with railing,

Service road (varies) and 1.50m wide footpath cum cover drain on either side 4.175 km

TCS -6 New Construction (urban area)-Two lanning with 1.5m paved shoulder,

0.20m raised kerb with railing, Service road (varies) and 1.50m wide footpath

cum cover drain on either side 0.513 km

TCS -7 New Construction (hilly area)-Two lanning with 2.0m earthen shoulder at

valley side with crash barrier and 1.0m earthen shoulder at hilly side with

open drain 0.400 km

TCS -9A New Construction (hilly area, both side cutting)-Two lanning with 1.0m

earthen shoulder on either side with crash barrier 2.955 km

TCS -9B New Construction (hilly area, both side filling)-Two lanning with 2.0m

earthen shoulder on either side with crash barrier 1.538 km

TCS -

11A

New Construction (in approaches to minor bridge)- carriageway of varying

width (7.0 to 10.5 m) at the approaches to minor bridge with varying width

(2.5 to 1.2m) earthen shoulder and crash barrier on either side in minimum

30m length.

5.657 km



MoRT&H 3-16

TCS -11B

New Construction (in approaches to major bridge)- Carriageway of varying

width (7.0m to 10.5m) at the approaches to major bridge with varying width

(2.5 to 2.15m) earthen shoulder and crash barrier on either side in minimum

30m length.

2.229

3.6.2 Rumble Strip

The purpose of the rumble strip is to reduce the speed so that accidents due to excessive

speed can be avoided. Rumble strips are provided at the start and end of the sharp curves,

start and end of the built-up area and at the major junctions and also on the minor

junctions where traffic on the cross road is significant.

3.7 ROAD SIGNS, PAVEMENT MARKING, OTHER TRAFFIC CONTROL

DEVICES

3.7.1 Road Signs

Road signs notify road users of regulations and provide warning and guidance safe

needed for reasonably, uniform and efficient operation. Mainly three types of signs have

been provided on the project stretch viz. Mandatory or regulatory sign, Cautionary or

warning signs and informatory or guide signs.

Mandatory sign indicate requirements, restriction and prohibition. These include the

STOP, GIVE WAY, speed limit, Overtaking prohibited, Compulsory Keep Left sign etc.

STOP sign is proposed at the cross road of junctions before the stop line. GIVE WAY

sign are located at entry to the junction. Speed Limit signs are proposed prior to the

location where, design speed is being changed. Overtaking prohibited sign board is

proposed at the starting of the sharp curves, urban sections, near schools, temples,

hospitals etc.

Warning signs are used to caution and alert the road users to potential danger or existence

of certain hazardous condition either on or adjacent to the roadway so that they take the

desired action. These signs include the Built up Area, Cattle Crossing, Pedestrian

Crossing, Left/Right Curve, Rumble Strip etc. Built up Area sign boards are proposed

prior to the built up Area, Cattle Crossing Sign Board are provided prior to the cattle



MoRT&H 3-17

Under Pass. Pedestrian Crossing sign board is proposed near schools, bus bays and at

junctions.

Informatory Signs are used to provide information and to guide road users along routes.

Advance Direction Sign and Chevron sign board are provided. Advance Direction Sign

boards are posted in advance at intersections .chevron signs are used at sharp curves to

indicate the direction of curve. These signs are installed on the outside of a turn or curve.

All road signs are proposed conforming to standards of ―Code of Practice for Road

Signs‖ (IRC: 67-2010) and ―New Traffic Signs‖ (IRC: SP: 31-1992). Latest type of

reflective and fluorescent sign boards, in appropriate sizes, shall be installed. The signs

are broadly categorized as below:

(i) Mandatory/Regulatory Signs: These signs are mostly for giving instructions and are

mostly circular generally red and blue colors and sign shown in black or white.

(ii) Cautionary/Warning Signs: They are mostly triangular with red border and black

sign.

(iii) Informatory Signs: These are mostly rectangular with blue or green background and

sign in white. Advance direction sign can be mounted on steel, brass portal frame

fixed across the carriageway at a height of 5.5 m above the pavement grade at the

center of roadway and visible from a distance for the vehicles approaching.

3.7.2 Pavement Markings

Pavement marking with retro reflective thermoplastic paint is proposed for road centre

line, carriageway outer edge, bus bay locations and chevron marking, stop marking,

chevron sign at junctions. These reflective pavement markings will keep the vehicle in

their lane during day and night time which improve safety and reduction in accidents.



MoRT&H 3-18

3.7.3 Traffic Control Devices

Delineators with night reflectors are proposed at sharp curve locations. Also hazard

markers with retro reflective paints are proposed before hazardous object viz. parapets of

bridge, stationary object near earthen shoulder etc.

Road Side Furniture and Crash Barriers

Road Side Furniture

No road side furniture except signage and traffic control devices is provided.

Crash Barriers

Crash barriers have been provided where the height of embankment is more than 3m and

in 30m length on either side of the approaches of the bridge.

Guard Rail

Guard rails are proposed at urban section along the proposed alignment to segregate the

local traffic to the main highway traffic.

Merges: Ingress and Egress

As there is no service road proposed along the highway and therefore there are no

ingress/egress points.

Marking of Overtaking Sections, Sight distances, Night Visibility

Overtaking zones have been identified along the road and signboards at location of no

overtaking signs are proposed.

Night visibility is given due consideration during vertical alignment design. Also

appropriate lighting arrangements are given at built-up sections and at major junctions.

Retro reflective paints are proposed for pavement marking and signs for better visibility

in the night.

Parked Vehicles

Parking is not proposed at any specific location in the project stretch.

3.8 SAFETY ISSUES FOR NON MOTORIZED TRAFFIC

Pedestrian Facilities along the Road



MoRT&H 3-19

Raised footpath of 1.50m width is proposed on the either side of the road. This footpath is

being used for the pedestrian movement along the road. Non mountable kerbs are

proposed for separation of pedestrian movement from the vehicles over the main

carriageway and therefore ensure the safety of pedestrians.

Pedestrian Crossings

Zebra crossing marking is proposed for the pedestrian crossing. These markings are

provided near schools, temples, bus bays and at junctions. The detailed location of zebra

crossing is given with the signages and marking plan and submitted separately.

Lay-Bays / Bus Bays

Bus bays are proposed at Suhagpura, Pipalkhunt, Khamera, Senawasa and Borwat

villages. Bus bays have been provided on the both side of the road. The location of the

bus bays are as given in Table 3.9.

Table: 3.9 List of Proposed Bus Bays on Project Road

S.No. Existing

Chainage (Km)

Design Chainage

(Ch.)

Location Side

1 95+040 95.107 Suhagpura LHS

2 95+200 95.267 Suhagpura RHS

3 117+040 116.947 Peepalkhunt LHS

4 117+395 117.302 Peepalkhunt RHS

5 129+473 129.243 Khamera LHS

6 129+699 129.468 Khamera RHS

7 149+509 149.107 Khamera LHS

8 149+603 149.201 Khamera RHS

9 173+475 170.027 Borwat LHS

10 173+570 170.122 Borwat RHS

Bridges

There are 4 major bridges (total length>60.0m) and 39 minor bridges (total

length<60.0m). As per proposed alignment 8 major bridges, 34 minor bridges lie on the

project road. All existing and proposed major & minor bridges have been analyzed to

accommodate 2 lane carriage way configurations. On the basis of detail hydrological

study and topographical survey, 7 new high level bridges (1 major bridge & 6 minor

bridges) are proposed with proper waterway along the proposed bypass alignment

Banswara.



MoRT&H 3-20

In the proposed 8 major bridges, 6 new shall be new constructed (3 from minor bridges

and 3 from major bridges), one is new proposed (at Banswara bypass) and one will be

retained. There are 39 minor bridges on existing road and in the proposed road only 34

minor bridges with 2-lane configuration are proposed. Out of 39 existing minor bridges 3

minor bridges will converted into major bridges, 8 minor bridges will be abandoned due to

Bypasses. Additional 6 new minor bridges are proposed on Banswara bypass.

Culverts

There are 257 on exist road and 267 are proposed. In the proposed road 42 existing

culverts are recommended to be abandoned due to Banswara bypass. For the batter

crossing of the drainage on proposed bypass 42 new culverts are proposed at bypass.

Details of the improvement of existing culverts and new proposed culverts are provided

in Table 3.10.

Table 3.10: Breakup of the Proposed Culverts

S.No. Total 267 1. Existing Pipe culvert Proposed for widening 14 2. Existing Pipe culverts proposed for reconstruction 51 3. Existing Pipe culverts proposed for new construction due to

realignment 12

4. Existing Pipe culvert retained & rehabilitation proposed 08 5. Existing slab culvert proposed for widening 20 6. Existing slab culverts proposed for reconstruction 62 7. Existing (Slab + Pipe) Culvert proposed for reconstruction by Box

culverts 01

8. Existing Slab culvert proposed for New construction due to

Realignment 13

9. Existing slab culverts retained & rehabilitation proposed 07 10. Widened/Reconstruction (Syphon) 06 11. Syphon pipe reconstructed as Pipe Culvert 02 12. Existing Syphon pipe Retained 30 13. Pipe Culverts proposed on Bypasses 32 14. Box Culverts proposed on Bypasses 10

Intersection Improvement Proposals

Based on peak hour traffic, at At-grade intersections are proposed to be designed as per

IRC: SP-41. There are 4 major and 66 minor junctions proposed in the project stretch. All



MoRT&H 3-21

the 4 major junctions are at the proposed Banswara bypass. 5.5 m width is proposed for

turning lane at 4 major junctions on bypass. All major junctions are upgraded to four lane

divided with 1.5m median 7.0m wide carriageway on either side and 2.5 m wide earthen

shoulder on either side. The turning radius of 20 m will be proposed based on the turning

radius of a large semi-truck trailer is 18.2 m. A minimum stopping sight distance of 130

m has been maintained on all intersecting legs of the junction. Locations and types of

major junctions are provided in Table 3.11.

Table 3.11: Locations and Types of Major Junctions

Major Junctions Details of NH-113 Pratapgarh-Padi

Chainage Type Side Location 157.137 Y' Type LHS Banwara Bypass Start Junction 160.82 X' Type Both Banwara Bypass Junction (SH-32)

164.264 X' Type Both Banwara Bypass Junction (SH-10) 169.605 Y' Type LHS Banwara Bypass End Junction

All proposed or upgraded minor junctions are uncontrolled junctions. Minor junction will

be developed with 15 m turning radius and 120 m length for Acceleration and

Deceleration lane.In the proposed 66 junctions, 32 are T-type, 8 cross junctions, 1

staggered and 25 Y-type junctions



MoRT&H 4-1

CHAPTER – 4

PUBLIC INFORMATION AND CONSULTATIONS

4.1 INTRODUCTION

Consultation with PAPs is the starting point to address involuntary resettlement issues

concerning land acquisition and resettlement. People affected by resettlement may be

apprehensive that they will lose their livelihoods and communities. Participation in

planning and managing resettlement helps to reduce their fears and gives PAP‘s an

opportunity to participate in key decisions that affect their lives. The initial step for

consultation and participation is to identify the primary and secondary stakeholders and

sharing information with the affected PAPs.

Public information and consultation was carried out during the project preparation stage

in the form of public meeting, focus group discussion, in-depth interviews and individual

consultations.

The main objective of the consultation process is to inform the PAPs about the

anticipated benefits, negative impacts and mitigation measures of the project.

The objectives of public consultation as part of this project are:

Promote public awareness and improve understanding of the potential impacts of

proposed project;

Identify alternative sites or designs and mitigation measures;

Solicit the views of affected communities / individuals on environmental and social

problems;

Improve environmental and social soundness;

Identify contentious local issues which might jeopardize the implementation of the

project;



MoRT&H 4-2

4.2 LEVELS OF CONSULTATIONS

The public consultations were carried out at three stages namely screening, feasibility and

social impact assessment of the project. Public consultations at screening and feasibility

levels were conducted at those locations which could likely have more impacts than other

affected areas in the region. SIA consultations were carried out at village and district

level.

Types of consultations done with various participants using different tools including,

interviews with government officials, individual consultations, key informant interviews,

focus group discussion, stakeholder consultations, etc, are presented in Table 4.1.

Table 4.1: Types of Consultations

Level Type Key Participants

Individual Local level Consultation People along the project corridor

Individual Sample Door to Door

Personal Contact

People along the project corridor including

those who are impacted directly or

indirectly

Settlement Focus Group Discussion PAP, women, weaker sections,

agriculturist

Institutional Stake holder Discussion Line departments

4.3 METHODOLOGY ADOPTED

Different techniques of consultation with stakeholders were used during project

preparation, viz., in-depth interviews, public meetings, group discussions, Individual

Consultations etc. to understand the socio-economic profile of the community and the

affected families, structured questionnaires were used and information was collected

from the individuals on one-to-one basis. The consultations have also been carried out

with special emphasis on the vulnerable groups. The key informants during the project

preparation phase included both individuals and groups namely:

Heads and members of households likely to be affected



MoRT&H 4-3

Groups/clusters of PAPs

Village Panchayat, Sarpanch and members

Local voluntary organizations and NGO

Government agencies and departments such as local revenue authority

Other project stakeholders with special focus on PAPs belonging to the vulnerable

group.

4.4 TYPES OF CONSULTATIONS

4.4.1 General Consultations

The dissemination process and type of information shared with the stakeholders during

consultations are described below:

While undertaking inventory of road side utilities, structures and PAHs census survey

the information disseminated focused on the proposed road improvements.

Potential PAHs were consulted about the proposed road improvement program,

resultant impacts, possible socio-cultural conflict (if any) and loss of CPRs and its

relocation.

People were requested to gather at common places including Panchayat Bhawan,

temples, schools, etc.

During these consultations pictorial methods were also used to explain proposed

improvement and possible social impacts in the concerned villages.

4.4.2 Structured Consultations

Consultations were conducted in structured format. For this purpose, date and venue of

consultation were fixed in advance and in coordination with the PRI representatives at

village level and officials from Rural Development (RD), PWD and NGOs. Such

structured consultations helped in highlighting issues as raised by stakeholders with

regard to the proposed road improvement.



MoRT&H 4-4

4.4.3 Specific Consultations

Gram Sabha under PESA1996 & FRA 2006

The existing part of the project road NH-113, traverses through 2 districts i.e. Pratapgarh

and Banswara which has ST population and forest land. These two districts are listed in

Schedule V of Constitution of India. Under PESA (Panchayat Extension in Schedule

Areas) Act 1996,it is mandatory to obtain No Objection Certificate (NOC) and resolution

from Gram Sabha. The Gram Sabhas have been conducted as per the set procedure in the

affected village panchayats. The proceedings were recorded and NOCs obtained.

Further Gram Sabhas under FRA (Forest Right Act) 2006 in the district of Pratapgarh and

Banswara has been conducted in 5villages where diversion of forest land is required.

Prescribed legal procedure including mandatory notice period of 15 days have been

followed. All the Sabhas have been attended by the representative of NH- PWD officer,

Gram PO, Gram Sarpanch, Block Officer and DPR consultant. Minutes of each Gram

Sabha have been recorded including videography. List of villages where Gram Sabha

has been conducted is given in the Table 4.2 below.

Table 4.2: Gram Sabha under PESA Act 1996 & FRA Act 2006

S.

No.

Tehsil Gram

Panchayat

Village Name Date Gram Sabha

held under

Remarks

District-Pratapgarh

1 Pratapgarh Monohargarh Makanpura 26.12.2012

PESA ACT 1996

&

FRA ACT 2006

NOC

Obtained

2 Peepalkhut Kachotiya Kachotiya,

Padliya

02.01.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

3 Suhagpura Mota Mayanga,

Chayan, Banjari

03.01.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

4 Semaliya Semaliya, Kataro

ka Khera A,

Vakhatpura

04.01.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

5 Sodalpur Kataro ka Khera B 04.01.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

6 Peepalkhut Peepalkhut 05.01.2013 PESA ACT 1996

&

NOC

Obtained



MoRT&H 4-5

S.

No.

Tehsil Gram

Panchayat


held under

Remarks

FRA ACT 2006

District-Banswara

1 Ghatol Mudasel Mudasel, Helaij 07.01.2013 PESA ACT 1996

&

FRA ACT 2006

NOC

Obtained

2 Bhagora ka

Khera

Bhagora ka Khera 07.01.2013 PESA ACT 1996

&

FRA ACT 2006

NOC

Obtained

3 Khamera Khamera 07.01.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

4 Sevaniya Sevaniya 08.01.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

5 Ghatol Ghatol - - NOC Not

Obtained

6 Devda Dungri Pada,

Devda

08.01.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

7 Padoli

Govardhan

Padoli Govardhan 09.01.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

8 Senavasa Senavasa 09.01.2013 PESA ACT 1996

&

FRA ACT 2006

NOC

Obtained

9 Banswara Badgoan Badgoan 12.02.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

10 Lodha Janamedi 12.02.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

11 Kupda Kupda 13.02.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

12 Bachariya Bachariya,

Dusherra,

Amarpura

13.02.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

13 Tamatiya

Ada

Tamatiya Ada,

Odha ji Pardla

14.02.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

14 Sundanpur Shivpura 14.02.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

15 Tejpur Tejpur, Harmatiya 15.02.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

16 Makod Makod 15.02.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

17 Supur Supur, Bhagatpura 16.02.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained



MoRT&H 4-6

S.

No.

Tehsil Gram

Panchayat


held under

Remarks

18 Borvat Borvat 18.02.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

19 Sagrod Sagrod 18.02.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

20 Sevna Sevna 20.02.2013 PESA ACT 1996 NOC

Obtained

Source: Gram Sabha organized by CEG

For the proposed project, Gram Sabha under PESA Act 1996 has been conducted in 26

Gram Panchayats of the both the districts. During the Gram Sabha project information

along with quantum of private, s government and forest land with their respective survey

numbers was discussed with the local public. It has also been informed that all the

acquired land will be adequately compensated by the project proponent. Considering the

project benefits and its role in the development of the region, the proposed project was

appreciated by the local public and resolution for land acquisition and diversion of forest

were unanimously passed by the respective Gram Sabha. Gram Sabha under PESA Act

for the land required for Ghatol bypass was held. However, due to disagreement among

the villagers refused passing of resolution and hence NOC could not be obtained. As a

followup informal meetings with the Sarpanch, other former and present panchanyat

members, stakeholders were conducted on 10.12.2012 and 11.12.2010 and issues

discussed but the issue could not be resolved. Thus the proposed Ghatol bypass was

dropped on the instruction of MoRTH vide letter dated 19.06.13 No.RW/NH-

12013/19/2010/SP/ (D-1)/P-9. Resolutions passed and NOCsobtained from all concerned

villages are given as Annexure 4.1.

For the diversion of Forest land, Gram Sabha under the FRA Act 2006 has also been

conducted in 5 project affected villages of the district Pratapgarh and Banswara. During

these Sabhas, local people mainly demanded for adequate arrangement of re-plantation of

trees towards the compensation of cutting and felling of existing trees due to the proposed

widening. Gram Sabha has been informed that trees will be adequately compensated as

per the latest Forest Act. In the interest of the project and considering its positive



MoRT&H 4-7

impactsfor the development of the area, the resolutions were unanimously passed by the

respective Gram Sabhas.

4.5 STAKEHOLDER ANALYSIS MATRIX

After the analyses it was found that majority of stakeholders were supportive and showed

positive interest in the project. District level authorities including the Tribal welfare

officer has been consulted. Information gathered from them clearly indicates that this

area falls under Schedule V Area of the Constitution of India. Local users of the road and

persons likely to be affected were in favor of the proposed project. The people were

concerned about road sides‘ safety, afforestation, expected employment opportunities,

means of livelihood, bypass etc in the project.

The stakeholder analysis for the project is presented in Table 4.3.

Table 4.3 - Stakeholder Analysis

Stakeholder

Category

Relevant

Stakeholders

Characteristics

(Social, location,

size,

organizational,

capacity)

Interests in

terms of

support/

opposition

Influence

(H-High,

M-

Medium,

L- Low)

Government

District Collector, of Both

the districts i.e. Pratapgarh

and Banswara,

Representatives of the

PWD NH division

Revenue Officers, Tribal

development officer

Pratapgarh and

Banswara district

Positive with

assurance of

full support.

High

Other

concerned

Departments

Telecom., Water supply,

Electricity Supportive Low

Intended

beneficiaries

Road Users, Local villagers

and Transporters

Children, women, elderly

Mixed user group,

all along the road

Dispersed across

the corridor

Supportive

Supportive

Medium

Adversely

affected

Persons

Road Side small business

units, residents and land

owners

Almost all along

the project corridor

Supportive

with

apprehensions

of adverse

impact

High



MoRT&H 4-8

Stakeholder

Category

Relevant

Stakeholders

Characteristics

(Social, location,

size,

organizational,

capacity)

Interests in

terms of

support/

opposition

Influence

(H-High,

M-

Medium,

L- Low)

Organized

interest groups

(business

associations

and

trade unions)

Town and small village

business groups having

their businesses along side

road corridors, Transport

Organizers etc.

All major habitat-

ion areas along side

road

Supportive but

apprehension

of adverse

impact

Medium

Civil society

(NGOs, CBOs,

religious

organizations)

No NGO found

Working in PIA. N.A. N.A. N.A.

Other

external/

internal

stakeholders

N.A N.A N.A N.A

Source: Data Collected During Survey

4.6 MAJOR FINDINGS FROM CONSULTATION

Major findings related to key issues such as land acquisition, compensation for land and

structures, alternative alignments, underpasses, general perception about the project,

bypasses, suggestions to mitigate hardships, as it may result from dislocation and loss of

livelihood, resettlement options, perception about HIV/AIDS awareness, impacts on

CPRs etc. Stakeholders Consultationsis given in Table 4.4, 4.5 & 4.6. Sample

photographs of Gram Sabhas conducted in both the districts are shown below.

Consultations have been carried out at several locations during project preparation have

been shared with environmental and technical team. Suggestion obtained from people and

their representatives have been analyzed on technical and economic merits. Final

decisions of engineering design team on alternative alignments, location of pedestrian

crossing, location of enhancement of community properties are conveyed to the people.

Most of the PAPs suggestions were incorporated in the final design.



MoRT&H 4-9

Table 4.4 Key findings, common issues and concern that emerged out during local

level consultations on existing alignment (18.10.2010 to 23.10.2010) in Ghatol

Township

S.N

o

Issues Raised

(i)

Response Given

(ii)

Mitigation

measures

incorporated in

design

(iii)

1

Project affected persons

belonging to the

congested Built-up

portion raised the issue

for construction of

Bypass to avoid

acquisition of their Land

and structures.

Bypasses alternative is under

consideration for Ghatol

Bypass at Ghatol

was dropped

based on analysis

of alternatives and

as NOC could not

be obtained the

villagers.

2 Negative impact on

existing business.

Apprehension to

become marginalized

and jobless

Such impacts can be minimized

by providing design alternatives

or bypass at congested locations

Design at Ghatol

has been explored

to to minimize

the impact

3 Unavailability of

suitable land for

relocation

Proper location for shifting will be

identified

Resettlement

action plan was

discussed with the

affected persons

and none of them

want to shift away

from the present

place of living.

Hence, no

relocation site

was desired by

them. .

4 Safety issues and

benefits from the project

to the Stakeholders.

Design team has kept the safety

issue on priority.

For safety

considerations the

following are

provided:

Realignment ,

Bus bay and

Truck Lay bye

5 Magnitude of acquisition

of structures within

corridor of impact and

amount of compensation

Minimum land acquisition will be

done

Adequate

compensations

shall be awarded

to the project



MoRT&H 4-10

S.N

o

Issues Raised

(i)

Response Given

(ii)

Mitigation

measures

incorporated in

design

(iii)

displaced

households as per

the agreed R&R

framework.

6 Majorityofparticipants

asked for provision of

footpath and road side

drain

Footpath,CoveredDrainsandadequ

ate wideninghave been

incorporated in the designin Built-

Up- Section.

Footpath shall be

provided over

covered drains

since available

space from

building line to

building line is

limited

7 Wideningandstrengtheni

ng of the project road

in the market areas

should be on both side

of the road.

Concentricwidening is proposed

inBuilt-up sectionexceptfor

locationwithdeficientalignment

Concentric

widening has

been proposed in

the market areas

with minor

adjustment in

design to fit

within available

space.

8 Proper traffic signage

and speed limits for

minimizing the accidents

Safety signage shall be provided. Rumble strips are

proposed to

reduce the

vehicle speed at

the location of

junctions,

schools, railway

crossings, start

and end of the

sharp curves,

start and end of

the built-up area

etc.

9 Safety of Local traffic

and pedestrian in Built-

up Zone. Provision of

Bus Stops .Loss of

shops and residential

structures

Provision for footpath and Bus

bays is made in design.

1.5 m wide

footpath cum

drain on either

side of the road.

10 Speed breaker in the Speed breaker shall be provided Same as given in



MoRT&H 4-11

S.N

o

Issues Raised

(i)

Response Given

(ii)

Mitigation

measures

incorporated in

design

(iii)

market area and at

school locations

in front of the school and traffic

will be properly guided in market

areas during construction phase.

S.No.8

11 Rate of compensation

for lost asset

Payment of compensation at

market value

compensation

will be as per

R&R policy of

NHIIP issued by

MoRTH.

12 Demand for bypass, Option for bypass are under

study

By pass option

has been dropped

vide Ministry

letter dated

19.06.13

No.RW/NH-

12013/19/2010/S

P/ (D-1)/P-9

13 Proper drainage system

along the road should be

provided

Drainage system will be

improved and proposal for Rain

Water Harvesting system will be

communicated to design team

Efficient

drainage system

and Rainwater

harvesting layout

would minimize

formation of

puddles



MoRT&H 4-12

Conclusion of Public Consultation in Ghatol tehsil

Majority of project affected house households agreed that with the given road condition

and traffic volume, widening and strengthening is necessary but not at the cost of human

life, safety and livelihood as it is a congested market area.

Safety is an important issue especially for children, women and cattle. Acquisition of

land and other immovable properties and resettlement should be on the basis of ―do first,

and then remove‖, with a simplified procedure and timely implementation of the same

Bypass was preferred by all the stakeholders of Ghatol Market area

Ghatol bypass has been dropped by the competent authority of the Ministry of Road

Transport & Highways ). Please refer Annexure 4.2.



MoRT&H 4-13

Table 4.4: Consultations with Stakeholders

S

No Date

Number of

participants Issues Raised Response Given

Mitigation

measures

incorporated

in design

1

Pratapgarh

11.06.2011

67

(Consultations

with affected

persons &

local people,

NH

representatives,

Sarpanch,

Deputy

Sarpanch,

Sectary of

Village

Panchayat)

Process of land acquisition and

compensation for property

damage during road construction

LA will be as per National

Highways Act, 1956 and

compensation will be as per the

NRRP Policy 2007 and World Bank

guidelines.

Any compensation for well and

tube wells?

If any well or tube well is affected

will be compensated. As per the

Entitlement framework and

guidelines of NRRP Policy 2007.

Safety issues and benefits from

the project to the Stakeholders.

Design team has kept the safety

issue on priority.

For safety

considerations

the following

are provided:

Total

realignmen

t of 7.994

Km

6 number

of Cattle

underpasse

s

10 number

of Bus

shelters

1 number

of Truck

Lay bay



MoRT&H 4-14

S

No Date

Number of


Mitigation

measures

incorporated

in design

High noise pollution due to

traffic congestion

Propertrafficsignforspeedlimits will

reduce thetraffic congestionwhich in

turn reducesthenoiseandairpollution

For the traffic

control and

safety

measure,

various types

of road sings,

safety barriers,

road

delineators,

road marking

and pedestrian

guard rails are

proposed at

appropriate

locations.

Acquisition of Structures within

CoI

minimum land acquisition will be

done

Adequate

compensation

s shall be

awarded to the

project

displaced

households

Majorityofparticipants asked for

provision of footpath and road

side drain

Footpath,CoveredDrainsandadequate

wideninghave been incorporated in

the designin Built-Up- Section.

The Participants getting affected

byproposed widening raised the

issue forprovisionofBy-pass.

By pass has been proposed at

Banswara

Majorityofthepeoplesdesiredthat Concentricwidening is proposed



MoRT&H 4-15

S

No Date

Number of


Mitigation

measures

incorporated

in design

thewideningandstrengthening of

the project road in the market

areas should be on both side of

the road.

inBuilt-up sectionexceptfor

locationwithdeficientalignment

Peopledemanded to adopt proper

measureto minimizethe Dust and

NoisePollution during

construction phase in Built-

upSection.

Construction work will be carried

out during daytime in Built-up

sections

To ward of

dust pollution

during

construction

phase water

will be

sprinkled three

times a day

proper traffic signage and speed

limits for minimizing the accident

Along with safety signages Traffic

flow will be permitted within the

permissible speed limits

Rumble strips

are purposed

at 26 locations

to reduce the

vehicles speed

at the location

of junctions,

schools,

railway

crossings, start

and end of the

sharp curves,

start and end

of the built-up

area etc.

Relocation of temples adjacent to

Road Carriageway

5 Affected temples will be (3 fully

and 2 partially ) relocated in



MoRT&H 4-16

S

No Date

Number of


Mitigation

measures

incorporated

in design

consultation with the concerned

sarpanch , local authorities in the

land allotted to it by the concerned

authority

Minimizing the Dust Pollution

at Junction location and at the

approach of built-up sections

Dust will be suppressed by

sprinkling water and tree plantation

Junction improvement and proper

traffic signage for speed limits to

minimizing the accident.

Proposed improvement will reduce

the traffic congestion and proper

traffic signage will be provided for

limiting speed

Rumble strips

are purposed

at 26

locations

2 Banswara

11.05.2012

49 PAPs belonging to the congested

Built-up portion raised the issue

for construction of By-Pass to

avoid acquisition of their Land

and structures.

Bypasses are proposed at Banswara

2.Banswara Bypass; Length: 12.660

Km

Constructionofadditional2-

LaneRoad onOldAlignment.Such

provisionwillminimizethetraffic

congestioninBuilt-upZoneand

finallyreducetheNoise,DustandAir

pollution.

Issue has been recorded

the same shall be conveyed to the

project authorities for appropriate

action

Widening of existing Bridge and

improvement of existing

Geometric on either side of

existing Bridge to avoid

accidents in approach to Bridge.

The suggestion was agreed and

incorporated in the Design Report

with proposal for improvement of

approach alignment on either side

of existing bridge.

Noise and Dust Pollution during Water sprinkling and Tree



MoRT&H 4-17

S

No Date

Number of


Mitigation

measures

incorporated

in design

construction and after

construction.

plantation will be done to suppress

the Dust pollution. Construction

work will be carried out during

daytime in Built-up sections

Tree also work as noise barrier.

Safety of Local traffic and

pedestrian in Built-up Zone.

Provision of Bus Stops

Provisionfor footpath and

Busbaysismadein design.

1.5 m wide

footpath cum

drain on either

side of the

road.

Employment opportunity for

local labour & worker during

Construction

Preference shall be given to the

local labour & worker during

Construction

Rehabilitation of CPR structures CPR will be relocated in

consultation with the concerned

Sarpanch , local authorities in the


authority

Loss of shops and residential

structures

Such impacts have been overcome

by providing bypass at congested

locations.

Negative impact on existing

business .Apprehension to

become marginalized and jobless

Rate of compensation for lost

asset


replacement value as per proposed

policy of NHIIP

Adequate livelihood support to

the affected persons

Project policy provides:

1) for training assistance of Rs



MoRT&H 4-18

S

No Date

Number of


Mitigation

measures

incorporated

in design

10,000/- for income generation

per family

2) Temporary employment in the

project construction work to

project affected persons with

particular attention to vulnerable

groups by the project contractor

during construction, to the extent

possible.

3) Monthly subsistence/transitional

allowance equivalent to twenty-

five days minimum agricultural

wages per month for a period of

one year from the date of

displacement.

4) One time additional financial

assistance equivalent to 300 days

of minimum wages to all

vulnerable including STs.

5) 5Each ST affected family shall

get an additional one time

financial assistance equivalent to

two hundred days of minimum

agricultural wages for loss of

customary rights or usage of

forest produce .

6) Customary rights on land and

usage of forest will have to be



MoRT&H 4-19

S

No Date

Number of


Mitigation

measures

incorporated

in design

certified by the Gram Sabha or

such appropriate authority.

7) Each Scheduled Tribe family

affected families resettled out of

the district will get twenty-five

per cent higher rehabilitation and

resettlement benefits

During implementation these

Information‘s will be provided to

the PAP‘s in the form of leaflets

Speed breaker in the market area

and at school locations

Speed breaker in front the school

Speed breaker in the market area

Design shall be adjusted to avoid

impact on market

Electric transformer should be

shifted at suitable location

Electric transformer has been

recorded in our utility shifting plan

and the same shall be shifted by the

concern department

Peopledemanded to adopt proper

measureto minimizethe Dust and

NoisePollution during

construction phase in Built-

upSection and at Junction

location and at the approach

built-Up Section

Mitigative measures have been

incorporated in EMP for Dust

suppression during and after

construction work in Built-up Zone

proper traffic signage and speed

limits for minimizing the accident

Along with safety signages Traffic

flow will be permitted within the

permissible speed limits

Relocation of temples adjacent to Temples will be relocated in



MoRT&H 4-20

S

No Date

Number of


Mitigation

measures

incorporated

in design

Road Carriageway consultation with the concerned

Sarpanch , local authorities in the


authority

3 Ghatol

21.08.2011

83 The approaches on either side of

the bridges are deficient,

The suggestion was accepted and

incorporated in the Design Report

with

Proposal for

improvement

of approach

alignment on

either side of

existing bridge

including

proposal for

additional two

Lane Bridge.

High noise pollution due to

traffic congestion

Proper traffic sign for no honking

will be provided at sensitive

locations

School at km

176 + 500



MoRT&H 4-21

Table 4.5: Consultation with Stakeholders under PESA Act 1996

S

No

Date/ Tehsil

/Village

Number of

participants Issues Raised Suggestions

1 10.12.2012 &

11.12.2012

Ghatol

Village,

Ghatol Tehsil

Informal

Meeting was

conducted

twice

Around

200participants.

Consultation

with Gram

Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders, affected

stakeholders

Small land

holdings

Many families

depend on the

agriculture land

Livelihood will be

affected majorly

Twice the meeting was

conducted to explain them the

benefits of the highways,

government compensations

under special considerations

as per PESA Act, Tribal

Development Plan etc.

It was conveyed to them that

under PESA Act special

consideration towards

compensation of their land

holdings as well as structure

will be given.

It was told to them that under

the PESA Act their livelihood

will be secured with the help

of various programs such as

training, employment

opportunities during

construction, TDP etc.

2 26.12.2012

Pratapgarh

Tehsil

Monohargarh

25 participants Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Loss of shops and

residential

structures.

Rate of

compensation for

lost asset




market value

3 2.1.2013

Peepalkhut

Tehsil

Kachotiya

38 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Hand pump should

be provided both

side of the road

Loss of shops and

residential

structures

Design shall be adjusted to

avoid impact on Hand Pumps

Rearrangements for affected

families who are losing

residents structures

4 3.1.2013

Peepalkhut

Tehsil

Suhagpura

48 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Speed breaker in

the market area

and at school

location

Adequate

Speed breakers will be

provided

Project information shall be

shares regularly



MoRT&H 4-22

S

No

Date/ Tehsil

/Village

Number of


Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing


5

4.1.2013

Peepalkhut

Tehsil

Semaliya

66 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Speed breaker in

the market area

Impact on water

supply pipe line


provided

Water supply pipe line will be

shifted

6

04.01.2013

Peepalkhut

Tehsil

Sodalpur

50 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing


Rate of

compensation for

lost asset




market value

7 05.01.2013

Peepalkhut

Tehsil

Peepalkhut

74 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Adequate

arrangements for

Rain Water

Harvesting

Proper Drainages

system along the

road should be

provided

Barkiest and CC

road in market

area

Adequate e Proper Drainages

system will be provided.

Proposal for Rain Water

Harvesting system will be


8

07.01.2013

Ghatol Tehsil

Mudasel

47 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing


Rate of

compensation for

lost asset




market value

9 07.01.2013

Ghatol Tehsil 40 participants

Consultation Adequate

rearrangements for





MoRT&H 4-23

S

No

Date/ Tehsil

/Village

Number of


Bhagora ka

Khera

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

affected families

who are losing


Rate of

compensation for

lost asset


market value

10 07.01.2013

Ghatol Tehsil

Khamera

40 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Apprehension to

become

marginalized and

jobless

Rate of

compensation for

lost asset

Demand for by

pass, whenever

4lane provision

will proposed

Adequate livelihood support

to the affected persons

Rearrangements for affected

families who are losing


Project information shall be

shares regularly

11 08.01.2013

Ghatol Tehsil

Savniya

34 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing


Rate of

compensation for

lost asset




market value

12 08.01.2013

Ghatol

Tehsil

Devda

67 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Apprehension to

become

marginalized and

jobless

Rate of

compensation for

lost asset




market value

13 08.01.2013

Ghatol Tehsil

Padoli

Govordhan

69 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing


Rate of

compensation for

lost asset




market value



MoRT&H 4-24

S

No

Date/ Tehsil

/Village

Number of


leaders

14 09.01.2013

Ghatol Tehsil

Senawasa

15 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Rate of

compensation for

lost asset

Proper Drainages

system along the

road should be

provided


market value




15 12.02.2013

Banswara

Tehsil

Bargaon

51 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Rate of

compensation for

lost asset

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing



market value



16 12.02.2013

Banswara

Tehsil

Lodha

33 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Rate of

compensation for

lost asset

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing



market value



17 13.02.2013

Banswara

Tehsil

Koupda

39 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Railway line and

Highway passes

through this

village. The land

owners are

worried about their

livelihood

Banswara is

declared Schedule

area; why Tribal is

differentiated with

general caste for

compensation and

other schemes.

Proposed project should Pay

compensation at market value




market value for all affected

families

Tribal have been considered

vulnerable and that is why

they are entitled for additional

benefits.

18 13.02.2013

Banswara 46 participants

Consultation Rate of

compensation for





MoRT&H 4-25

S

No

Date/ Tehsil

/Village

Number of


Tehsil

Bachariya

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

lost asset

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing


Compensation Payment at

market value

Photos provided at the end of the

table and list of signature is

enclosed as Annexure 4.1

19 14.02.2013

Banswara

Tehsil

Tamtiya Ada

40 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Banswara is

declared Schedule

area; why Tribal is

differentiated to

general caste for

compensation and

other schemes.

Rate of

compensation for

lost asset


market value for all affected

families






20 14.02.2013

Banswara

Tehsil

Sundenpur

16 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing


Rate of

compensation for

lost asset




market value

21 15.02.2013

Banswara

Tehsil

Tejpur

34 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Adequate

arrangements for

Rain Water

Harvesting

Proper Drainages

system along the

road should be

provided

Impact on water

supply pipe line




Drainage system will provide

as design

Water supply pipe line will be

shifted




22 15.02.2013

Banswara

Tehsil

Makod

30 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing


Speed breaker in




provided



MoRT&H 4-26

S

No

Date/ Tehsil

/Village

Number of


level opinion

leaders

the market area

23 16.02.2013

Banswara

Tehsil

Surpur

31 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing


Rate of

compensation for

lost asset

Surpur is near to

Banswara.

Whether the

proposed by pass

will pass through

this village?




market value

Proposal communicated to

design team

The bypass will pass though

the village

24 18.02.2013

Banswara

Tehsil

Borwat

47 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing


Rate of

compensation for

lost asset




market value

25 18.02.2013

Banswara

Tehsil

Sagrod

52 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Gram Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

level opinion

leaders

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing


Rate of

compensation for

lost asset

Speed breaker in

the market area




market value


provided

26 20.02.2013

Banswara

Tehsil

Sevana

20 participants

Consultation

with NH

representative,

Block level

officials, Gram

Panchayat-

Sarpanch,

Sectary village

Adequate

rearrangements for

affected families

who are losing


Rate of

compensation for

lost asset




market value

Proposal incorporate in RAP

The rule pertaining to leaving

the requisite land width

unutilized is as per land



MoRT&H 4-27

S

No

Date/ Tehsil

/Village

Number of


level opinion

leaders Compensation for

leaving 132 feet

long land from the

road center

unutilized.

conversion rules. This is not

within the purview of NHIIP

project.

Source: Data Collected During Survey

In the meetings conducted, NOCs from the Gram Sabha‘s in both the districts were

obtained. Copies of the Gram Sabhas NOC& resolutions are attached as Annexure

4.1.Largely the communities along the project road are supportive of the project.

However, NOC from Ghatol Gram Sabha was not obtained as the affected people and

their representatives had opposed for the bypass from their village.The proposed Ghatol

bypass alignment was in therevenue boundary of Ghatol village affecting 63 khasras i.e.

161 households and all are of vulnerable category. The likely affected land due to bypass

in Ghatol village was about 4.704 ha.Affected households have small land holdings and

are worried about their livelihood post land acquisition and thus have not granted NOC

under PESA.

The competent authority, Government of India, Ministry of Road Transport & Highways

(EAP) has taken the decision of dropping the Ghatol Bypass with reference to letter no

RW/NH-12013/19/2010/SP/ (D/1)/P-9, dated 19.06.2013. Annexure 4.2 is attached with

regards to the reference of the letter mentioned above.

Since the NOC under PESA could not be obtained for Ghatol Bypass therefore the

decision taken by the competent authority, Government of India Ministry of Road

Transport & Highways (EAP)is that the existing road through Ghatol village may be

improved by providing two lanes with paves shoulder, covered drains with footpath and

railing on either side as safety measure.



MoRT&H 4-28

GRAM SABHA UNDER PESA ACT 1996 (Sample Photograph)

GRAM SABHAS AT PRATAPGARH DISTRICT



MoRT&H 4-29



MoRT&H 4-30

GRAM SABHA AT BANSWARA DISTRICT



MoRT&H 4-31

Source: Gram SabhaConducted by CEG

4.7 CONCLUSION/RECOMMENDATIONS

Major findings related to key issues such as general perception about the project,

suggestions to mitigate hardships resulting from dislocation and loss of livelihood, the

details of which are presented below. Most of the people were aware about the project

As NOC for Ghatol bypass was not obtained, theexisting road will be developed.



MoRT&H 4-32

People were convinced about the importance of proposed highways in their area

since it will reduce accidents and enhance economic opportunities

People consented to cooperate, if adequate compensation is given

Most people preferred to resettle if required near to their previous place of business

and residence and preferred self-resettlement

Cultivators preferred cash compensation at market rate.

Requests were made by the people for providing facilities and amenities like rain

shelter and safer accessibility at points of congestion and intersections

Minimum impact on structures along the road

On site relocation for small business enterprise (SBE) is preferred option. They

perceived low business growth at new locations

Affected People asked about creation of new employment opportunities during road

construction and later phases of the project for them

People suggested that adequate safety measures should be provided such

as speed breaks, signage‘s etc. near inhabited areas, school and hospitals

Based on the finding of the consultation with the various stakeholders and especially with

the people living along the project corridor, alternative options has been worked out to

reduce the loss of assets and livelihood of the people in project impact zone. The

consultation process was continued during the detail design period to minimize the

adverse impact.

The community perceives that the project will help in increasing road safety, promote

more business, better service facilities, and better conveyance and promote local

employment opportunities. They consider that it would lead to increase in land rates and

smooth traffic. Apprehensions raised by the community include more accidents, houses

coming closer to the proposed alignment, increase in noise, agriculture loss, impacts on



MoRT&H 4-33

livelihood, losing of land holdings, affecting livelihood etc. Compensation should be paid

at market rate with special preferences to (PESA ACT 1996) ST land owners.

The public meeting was held on 2nd

Dec-2012 to 20th

Feb 2013 in presence of Executive

Engineer, Assistant Engineer PWD NH-Division Pratapgarh and Banswara, Tehsildar,

Land Acquisition officer, local public and their representative in Tehsil Pratapgarh,

Peepalkhut, Ghatol and Banswara. Bypass alternative options were explained and

discussed in detail during the meeting. The affected people agreed for Banswara bypass

and provision of realignments for improved road.



MoRT&H 5-1

CHAPTER 5

PROJECT IMPACTS

5.1 INTRODUCTION

The proposed project is likely to bring substantial social and economic development in

the region. The social benefits arising due to the project will be triggered off due to

improved accessibility to various services such as easy access to markets, health

facilities, schools, workplace etc which in turn increases the income of the locals, and

ultimately elevating their standard of living. The possible direct and indirect positive

impacts are listed below.

The immediate benefits of road construction and improvement will come in the

form of direct employment opportunities for the roadside communities and

specially those who are engaged as wage labourers, petty contractors and suppliers

of raw materials.

Improved road network provides for improved linkages between the village

communities and urban centre, which provides wider marketing facilities;

Road networks not only links the village communities to better markets, but also

opens up wider work opportunities in distant places. People can shuttle to distant

work sites and towns and engage in construction, factories, business as well as

domestic works.

Improved road networks encourage urban entrepreneurs to invest in far and remote

areas in commercial farming and industrial activities.

Improved roads also help people building strong institutional network with outside

agencies. Essential and emergency services can be availed fast like schools, health

centre, public distribution system etc.

For the proposed project, a number of adverse effects are likely to be encountered by the

people. While some of the losses are direct, some others are indirect effects. However,



MoRT&H 5-2

the direct losses likely to be experienced by the people are: loss of residential structure,

loss of commercial structure, loss of agricultural land, loss of fruit bearing and non-fruit

bearing trees and loss of common property etc. Similarly, acquisition of land and

consequently widening of the existing roads also have many likely indirect adverse

effects.

In this particular stretch, the impact of land acquisition is involved in the project section

for pass, realignments and curves improvement at some locations. In context of the

existing available RoW and the encroachments in the RoW, the project-affected

structures are owned by both titleholder and non-titleholders. Among the Non-

titleholders, the squatters were found to be of three types in the stretch comprising

residential, commercial and residential-cum-commercial. Amongst the commercial

squatters and kiosks, the nature of activities varied from small shops, tea stalls, grocery,

general stores, cigarette/ pan stalls, shoe repair, auto repair shops etc. The commercial

squatters/ kiosks exist at few locations in built-up section along the road. The cut-off

date for Non-Titleholders of NH 113 project road is December 2, 2012.The cut off date

for Titleholders will be date of Section 3A of NH Act, 1956.

5.2 EXISTING STATUS OF LAND AVAILABILITY

The up-gradation and widening of 100 km length of highways under the project is

expected to have both positive and negative impacts on the environment and people of

the project area. Despite all efforts taken for modifying the design of the project roads, a

section of the communities along the corridor are going to be negatively impacted due to

clearing of encroachment and squatters from the public RoW and the proposed

realignment sections. Negative impacts also include loss of economic opportunities/

livelihood, source of earning etc. In addition to the above, a small number of

community/cultural properties are also going to be negatively impacted. The chainage

wise detail of existing carriageway, RoW is given in Annexure: 1.3.



MoRT&H 5-3

5.3 LAND ACQUISITION ESTIMATES FOR THE PROJECT STRETCH

Land is to be acquired for by pass, junction improvement, realignments, widening and

other purposes. In table 5.1, district wise land acquisition details in the 57 affected

villages in the proposed project stretch is given.

Table: 5.1 Land Acquisitions by District

District No. of Villages in which land

is to be acquired

Land to be Acquired (Area in

Ha)

Pratapgarh 19 50.314

Banswara 38 79.391

TOTAL 57 129.705

5.4 TYPE OF THE LAND ACQUIRED FOR THE PROJECT

The land being acquired for the subproject is of various types such as Private land 52.623

ha, Government land is 30.021 ha and Forest Land 42.353 ha. Out of the total forest land

for widening and realignment purpose 41.125 ha and 1.229 ha land is required. Table:

5.2show the type of land to be acquired along the road stretch.

Table: 5.2 Land Acquisitions by type of Land

District Tehsil Land to be acquired (in ha) Private Government Forest Total

Pratapgarh Pratapgarh 0.591 2.235 8.808 11.634 Peepalkhut 8.326 7.228 23.127 38.680

Sub Total 8.917 9.463 31.935 50.314

Banswara Ghatol 12.82 5.902 10.418 29.140 Banswara 30.886 14.656 0.000 45.541

Sub Total 43.706 20.558 10.418 74.682

TOTAL 52.623 30.021 42.353 124.996

Source: Social Survey, CEG



MoRT&H 5-4

Private land required for the project shall be acquired by the provisions of the National

Highway Act 1956 and government land required shall be transferred as per established

procedures. For village wise break up of LA, refer to Annexure 5.1

In the table 5.3 the summary of PAHs in the project stretch is given. The households are

classified in type of land and social stratification. 414 PAHs are getting affected by the

proposed project.

Table 5.3: Summary of PAHs in Project Section

Land &Structure PAHs SC ST General BPL Other

Agriculture land losers 347 17 219 106 1 4

Structure Losers 32 1 3 25 1 2

Encroachers 14 1 3 7 2 1

Squatters 15 2 - 9 - 4

Kiosks 6 2 - - 1 3

Total 414 23 225 147 5 14


*Others include WHH, Differently abled, OBC

5.5 IMPACT ON STRUCTURES

In both the districts total 79 structures are getting affected due to the proposed project

road. In which 32 are titleholders, 29 encroachers, 6 kiosks and 12 are CPRs. Table 5.4

Impact on Structures shows the district wise details on impacted structures.

Table 5.4: Impact on Structures

Name of District Titleholders Squatter & Encroachers Kiosks CPRs Total Pratapgarh 5 14 4 7 30 Banswara 27 15 2 5 49

Total 32 29 6 12 79 Source: Social Survey, CEG

5.5.1 Impact on structures by usage of structure

79 structures will be affected in both the districts. There are 41 residential structures and

18 commercial structures. 8 structures are getting impacted are used for both residential



MoRT&H 5-5

and commercial purposes in the project road. In table 5.5 shows the Impact on structures

by Usage.

Table 5.5: Impact on structures by Usage

District Residential Commercial Res cum comm. CPRs Total

Pratapgarh 7 9 7 7 30

Banswara 34 9 1 5 49

Total 41 18 8 12 79


5.5.2 Impact on structures by typology of structure

The permanent structures which are getting affected by typology in both the districts are

56 including 12 CPRs. The temporary structure includes kiosks and other types of

structures. The table 5.6 gives the details of Impact on structures by typology and area in

sq. m. The built up area of approximately 11445.63 sq. m is getting affected.

Table 5.6: Impact on Structures by Typology

District Permanent Semi-Permanent Temporary Total

Units Area in

sq m Units Area in

sq m Units Area in

sq m Units Area in

sq m Pratapgarh 16+7C

PR 3922.90 2 161.00 5 303.60 30 4387.50

Banswara 28+5

CPR 5933.53 16 1124.60 0 - 49 7058.13

Total 44+12

CPR 9856.43 18 1285.60 5 303.60 79 11445.63


5.5.3 Impact on Common Property Resources (CPRs)

Including both districts only12 CPRs will be affected. Types of CPRs impacted include

Temples, Schools, Government buildings, Bus stop which will be partially impacted. The

total affected area is approximately is 757.10 sq m. Table 5.7 shows the Impact on

Common Property Resources. Chainage wise CPRs are given in Annexure 5.2.



MoRT&H 5-6

Table 5.7: Impact on Common Property Resources CPRs Nos. Area in sq.mtr

Temples 5 277.30

School 3 173.10

Government Building 3 167.38

Bus Stand 1 139.32

Total 12 757.10


5.6 Vulnerable Groups

The following groups of households are considered socially vulnerable and thus need

special consideration so that they can benefit from the project. Single vulnerability has

been calculated as per the households being affected in the project stretch. The maximum

vulnerability is of STs in the project affected households. Women Headed Household is

least in number in vulnerability category. The ST population affected by the project is

mostly involved in farming and trading. They are part of the mainstream in terms of

livelihoods and society. They have fixed assets like house & land, and income from

farming and small business. They share their sources of water, folklore, infrastructure and

other resources with the rest of the community, are open to new ideas like family

planning and formal education. Most of them have nuclear families. Table 5.8 gives the

details of the vulnerability category.

Table 5.8: Vulnerability Category

Vulnerability Category Nos.

Women Headed Household 4

Physically Challenged 0

Below Poverty Line 5

Scheduled Caste 38

Scheduled Tribe 225

Old Age (Above 65 years) 32

Total 304




MoRT&H 5-7

5.7 IMPACT ON WOMEN

Project would impact 4 Women headed households. The percentages of such families

affected are around 0.69% from the total affected households.. Table 5.8 shows that 4

women headed households are getting affected by losing agricultural land and/or

commercial & residential accommodationChapter 7 provides details on mitigation and

other support measures regarding gender issues.

5.8 IMPACT ON TRIBALS

Project would impact 225 Tribal households. The percentages of such families affected

are around 54.34 % of the total affected households.Chapter 8 provides details on

impacts,compensation and other additional support measures.

5.9 SOCIO-ECONOMIC PROFILE OF PROJECT INFLUENCED HABITATIONS

Socio-economic profile of the project area with particular reference to indigenous people,

poverty level, gender issues and local economy like agriculture, industry, health and

educational status has carried out on random sampling basis.

The study has been carried out with a participatory approach by involving the

stakeholders, particularly the project beneficiaries and probable affected persons through

a series of consultative process techniques. The population groups that consulted include

beneficiary group of people in the project influence area, particularly the shopkeepers,

farmers, transport operators, Gram Panchayat Sarpanch/ members, village elders, the

local youth and government officials who are involved in rural and women development

programs and employment generation schemes. Care has been taking to form

participatory consultative groups as homogenous as possible. The methods that were

adopted during the survey and social analysis and assessment are:

5.9.1 Socio-Economic Survey

Households likely to be affected were approached by the surveyors for administration of

questionnaire for collection of detailed information.



MoRT&H 5-8

Focus Group Discussionswere organized, in separate sessions, with groups like, youth /

elders, shopkeepers / operators, women & especially vulnerable people who were

available during survey.

Community consultations were heldalong major settlements near to the proposed

alignment and with those who are likely to be connected because of implementation of

the proposed project. Meetings have been held with affected titleholders, cultivators,

shopkeepers, squatters, kiosks etc at few important junctions along the project stretch.

Key informant interviews were conducted with local leaders / village Panchayat

functionaries, members & Senior citizen of the area to gain an insider‘s views regarding

specific highway related issues in the area. In some cases, interviews were undertaken at

places convenient to the key persons, even beyond project impact zone.

Gender Analysis has been given proper emphasis during public consultation discussions.

Separate discussion sessions were held with women who could share their experience

related to highway for the purpose such as by pass, bus bays, employment, transportation

issues that are specific for the women. Their collective perception about project impacts

and probable benefits particularly for the women has been taken.

Structured Direct Observations- Field observation on general socio-economic and

health status of the people, infrastructural set up or lack of it requirement of the people in

view of project road alignment, etc. were recorded by the survey team.

Review of Secondary Information- Apart from afore mentioning techniques and tools a

desk review and preliminary analysis were undertaken of existing statistical records,

census and gazetteers. Published works, research reports, National Human Development

reports, State women development cell reports and periodic reviews has been consulted

to get an overview of the general gender, health, trafficking issues.

5.9.2 Affected Households & Persons

The socio-economic characteristics of the project affected habitation (direct and indirect

influence zone) have been analyzed.The total affected households both by land and



MoRT&H 5-9

structures are 414. The detail of summary of households is given in table 5.9 which show

the villages wise break up of households getting affected by social stratification. In table

5.10 the village wise breaks up of proposed project affected people with their sex ratio

and literacy rate are given.

Table 5.9: Summary of Households

Districts Tehsil Project

Affected

Villages SC ST General BPL Others Total

Pratapgarh

Pratapgarh Makanpura - 1 2 - 1 4

Teemarwa - - - 1 1

Manohargarh - 1 2 - - 3

Chatriya

Kheri

- - -- - - -

Sub Total- 5 - 2 4 - 2 8

Pipalkhut Padliya - 4 - - - 4

Kachotiya - 12 1 - - 13

Mota

Mayanga - 17 1 1 - 19

Chayan 2 3 3 - 8

Suhagpura - - 1 - - 1

Banjari - 1 1 - 1 3

Semaliya 1 1 2 - 2 6

Relan - - - - - -

Vakhatpura - 1 - - - 1

Kataro ka

Khera (B) - 2 1 - 3

Kataro ka

Khera (A) - 2 - - - 2

Lamba Dabra - - - - - -

Chhari - - - - - -

Peepal Khut - 18 1 - 1 20

Sub Total-

14

3 61 11 1 4 80



MoRT&H 5-10


Affected


Banswara

Ghatol

Mudasel - 15 2 - - 17

Helaij - 18 2 - - 20

Sadari - - - - - -

Bagoro ka

Khera - - - - -

Khamera - - - - -

Udda Ji ka

Gada 1 - - - 1

Barora 1 - 3 1 - 5

Hawadi - 1 - - 1

Savniya 2 1 - - 3

Kargachiya - - - - -

Devda 1 2 4 - 1 8

Padoli

Gordhan - 9 2 - - 11

Sagthali - 5 - - - 5

Jedla - 4 - - - 4

Senawasa - 1 6 - - 7

Udpura - 1 3 - - 4

Sub Total-

17 2 58 24 1 1 86

Banswara

B Y

P A

Bhagatpura - 2 - - - 2

Pathanpura - - - - - -

Surpur 1 4 3 - 2 10

Ramoar - - - - - -

Harmatiya - 3 - - - 3

Tejpur - 3 2 - 1 6

Makod 2 6 - - - 8

Sevana - 12 2 - - 14

Bargaon 3 26 6 - - 35

Janamedi 1 2 4 - - 7



MoRT&H 5-11


Affected


S S

V I L L A G E S

Kupda 4 6 23 - - 33

Ganpatpura 3 2 27 - - 32

Shivpura 2 7 2 - - 11

Bhachaariya 1 6 4 - - 11

Dashara - 4 2 - - 6

Amarpura - 7 2 1 - 10

Tamtiya - 1 13 2 - 16

Odharaji ka

Parda 1 4 - - - 5

Borwat - 4 11 - 4 19

Borkheri - - - - - -

Sagrod - 5 7 - - 12

Sub Total-21 18 104 108 3 7 240

Total 57 23 225 147 5 14 414


The table gives the details of village wise people getting affected. Out of the four tehsils

the highest sex ratio is of Ghatol 952 females over thousand males in Banswara District

and least in Peepalkhut tehsil which is 880 females over thousand males in Pratapgarh

district.

Table 5.10: Summary of Project affected Persons


Affected

Villages

Total

PAHs

No of

PAPs Total

Males Females Sex

Ratio Literacy

%

Pratapgarh-

Pratapgarh Makanpura 4 24 12 12 1000 62.50 Teemarwa 1 6 3 3 1000 33.33 Monohargarh 3 18 10 8 800 61.11 Chatriya

Kheri - - - - - -

Sub Total- 5 8 48 25 23 920 58.33 Peepalkhut Padliya 4 24 13 11 846 54.16

Kachotiya 13 77 40 37 925 57.14



MoRT&H 5-12


Affected

Villages

Total

PAHs

No of

PAPs Total

Males Females Sex

Ratio Literacy

%

Mota

Mayanga 19 112 58 54 931 62.50

Chayan 8 47 24 23 958 53.19 Suhagpura 1 6 3 3 1000 33.33 Banjari 3 18 10 8 800 44.44 Semaliya 6 35 18 17 944 51.42 Relan - - - - - - Vakhatpura 1 6 4 2 500 33.33 Kataro ka

Khera (B) 3 18 11 7 636 61.11

Kataro ka

Khera (A) 2 11 6 5 833 45.45

Lamba Dabra - - - - - - Chhari - - - - - - Peepal Khut 20 118 64 54 843 58.47 Sub Total-

14 80 472 251 221 880 56.14

Banswara Ghatol Mudasel 17 104 54 50 925 50.96 Helaij 20 122 64 58 906 51.63 Sadari - - - - - - Bagoro ka

Khera - - - - - -

Khamera - - - - - - Udda Ji ka

Gada 1 6 3 3 1000 33.33

Barora 5 31 17 14 823 54.83 Hawadi 1 6 2 4 1500 33.33 Savniya 3 18 11 7 636 38.88 Kargachiya - - - - - - Devda 8 49 26 23 884 55.10 Padoli

Gordhan 11 67 36 31 861 52.23

Sagthali 5 31 16 15 937 51.61 Jedla 4 24 13 11 846 62.50 Senawasa 7 43 23 20 869 55.81 Udpura 4 24 13 11 846 58.33 Sub Total-

17 86 525 278 247 888 62.11

Banswara Bhagatpura 2 12 7 5 714 41.66 Pathanpura - - - - - - Surpur 10 60 31 29 935 52.45 Ramoar - - - - - - Harmatiya 3 18 11 7 636 38.88



MoRT&H 5-13


Affected

Villages

Total

PAHs

No of

PAPs Total

Males Females Sex

Ratio Literacy

%

Tejpur 6 37 20 17 850 56.75 Makod 8 51 26 25 961 59.18 Sevana 14 85 44 41 931 56.47

Bargaon 35 207 104 103 990 61.68 Janamedi 7 43 23 20 869 55.81 Kupda 33 201 103 98 951 57.21 Ganpatpura 32 197 101 96 950 54.87 Shivpura 11 67 35 32 914 50.74 Bhachaariya 11 67 34 33 970 52.23 Dashara 6 37 19 18 947 37.83 Amarpura 10 61 32 29 906 55.73 Tamtiya 16 98 51 47 921 53.06 Odharaji ka

Parda 5 30 16 14 875 56.66

Borwat 19 120 62 58 935 56.03 Borkheri - - - - - - Sagrod 12 73 38 35 921 56.16 Sub Total-21 240 1464 757 707 933 51.02

Total 57 414 2509 1311 1198 911 56.65


5.9.3 Family Types

The family types i.e. nuclear, joint or extended of the affected households have an impact

on the resettlement. The average size of the PAHs is 5.9 in Pratapgarh and 6.1 in

Banswara. Among the project-affected households joint family accounts for64.97%.

Table 5.11 gives the family type of the project households/ families.

Table: 5.11 Family Types of PAHs

District Average Family Size Nuclear Joint Extended Total Pratapgarh 5.9 9 61 18 88 Banswara 6.1 39 208 79 326 Total - 48 269 97 414

Source: Census Survey, CEG



MoRT&H 5-14

5.9.4 Literacy & Educational Status

The social development of a region can be signified by many indices. One of which is

literacy status of the population. The literacy rate in the project area speaks volume about

nature of social infrastructure of the region as well as level of awareness among the

people. Of the total literate population 29.77 % have achieved primary level of education,

while 22.00% of affected population has achieved secondary level. Graduates are only

3.94% and Post Graduate or technical qualification is 0.99% only. The major reason for

less number of graduates or post graduate/ technical qualification is school dropouts. It is

because of poor interest in education, family pressure, gender biasness etc. In the

proposed project stretch the affected persons have low education level therefore; training

programs for income restoration may be an important aspect of rehabilitation Table 5.12

shows educational level of the project-affected persons in percentage.

Table 5.12: Literacy Status of PAPs

Literacy Level Pratapgarh Banswara Total %

Illiteracy 222 864 1086 43.28

Primary 156 591 747 29.77

Secondary 98 454 552 22.00

Graduate 38 61 99 3.94

Post Graduate/

Technical Education 6 19 25 0.99

Total 520 1989 2509 99.98


5.9.5 Occupational Pattern

Occupational pattern of the head of the household were recorded. Further, occupational

pattern helps in identifying dominant economic activity in the area. Household heads are

engaged in trade and business. Besides this, about 38.95% of the Household heads

depend upon agriculture for their livelihood and another 16.34% are non-



MoRT&H 5-15

agriculturelaboureres, while 4.86 % of PAPs are in service. Table 5.13 shows the

occupational background of the project-affected persons.

TABLE: 5.13: Occupation Patterns of PAHs

TYPE OF OCCUPATION NO. %

AGRICULTURE 161 38.95

AGRICULTURE LABORER 132 31.82

SERVICE\ PROFESSIONAL 20 4.86

TRADE\BUSINESS\ SELF EMPLOYED 33 8.00

NON AGRICULTURAL LABOURERS 68 16.34

TOTAL 414 99.97


According to the socio economic analysis of the project-affected people, agriculture,

agriculture laborer and non-agricultural labourers together constitute the bulk of the total

employment among the PAH. Only few of the affected population are employed in the

private or government service sector.

5.9.6 Income Level

During the survey, incomes of a household through all possible sources have been

recorded. 67.65% of the households reported upto Rs. 36,000/- annual income. About

24.86% of household‘s annual income is between Rs. 36,001 to 60,000 7.47% of

household‘s income of Rs. 60,001 & above. Table 5.14 shows the income level of the

affected households.



MoRT&H 5-16

Table 5.14 Income Level of PAHs

Monthly income Slab Number of household

Total Percentage of

Total Pratapgrah Banswara

Up to 36,000 per annum 67 213 280 67.65

36,001-60,000 per annum 15 88 103 24.86

60,001 & Above per annum 6 25 31 7.47

Total 88 326 414 99.98

Av. HH Income (Per Month INR) 2500- 3000

Source: CensusSurvey, CEG

Out of the total 414 households who indicate their monthly income of less than equal to

Rs 2500 are of 38.49% includes SCs. STs, BPLs, General and other socially vulnerable.

It is estimated that an average household living in the PIA has an earning of Rs. 2500-

3000 per month. The proposed road alignment believes to reduce the distance between

the localities connecting Pratapgarh to Banswara section. This will facilitate growth of

more economic activities, access to better economic prospect outside the area and hence

increase in income generation.



MoRT&H 6-1

CHAPTER- 6

R&R PRINCIPLES, POLICY FRAMEWORK & ENTITLEMENT MATRIX

6.1 INTRODUCTION

This chapter of the report discusses about the existing laws and regulations of the country

and those applicable to the proposed project. It is imperative to analyze the Acts and

bylaws to understand the legalities and procedures in implementing project and

identifying the gaps and area where there is a need for strengthening to comply with

World Bank policy on resettlement and rehabilitation of project affected persons and

indigenous population development plan. The following subsections summarized the

legislative framework in which the projects will be implemented with respect to the

social issues as well as World Bank policy on resettlement & rehabilitation and

indigenous population. The preparation of a separate resettlement and rehabilitation

policy is supplemented to the existing laws in addressing various social and resettlement

issues arising out of project implementation. Applicable acts, notifications and policies

relevant in the context of the project are discussed below. The Project Authority

(MoRT&H) will ensure that project activities implemented are consistent with the

national, state, local regulatory/legal framework.

S.

No.

Acts/ Notifications/

Policies

Relevance to this project

Applicability

1 National Highways Act,

1956

Land required for the project shall be

acquired as per the provisions of this act.

Applicable

2 National Rehabilitation

and Resettlement Policy

(NRRP), 2007

Provides limited benefits to affected

family (an ex-gratia payment of not less

than Rs. 20,000/- and in case land-holder

becoming landless or small or marginal

farmer in such cases other rehabilitation

benefits as applicable.

Applicable



MoRT&H 6-2

S.

No.


Policies


Applicability

3 The Provisions of the

Panchayat (Extension to

the Scheduled Areas)

Act, 1996

One of the important provisions of this

act states ―the Gram Sabha or the

Panchayat at the appropriate level shall be

consulted before making the acquisition

of land in the Scheduled Areas for

development projects and before re-

settling or rehabilitating persons affected

by such projects in the Scheduled Areas.

Applicable

4 The Scheduled Tribes

and Other Traditional

Forest Dwellers

(Recognition of Forest

Rights) Act, 2006

This law provides for recognition of

forest rights to Scheduled Tribes in

occupation of the forest land prior to

13.12.2005 and to other traditional forest

dwellers who are in occupation of the

forest land for at least 3 generations i.e.

75 years, up to maximum of 4 hectares.

These rights are heritable but not

alienable or transferable.

Applicable

5 World Bank OP 4.12 –

Involuntary Resettlement

The project entails land acquisition

though, at a low scale for widening,

realignments, junction improvements,

bypasses etc. It would also adversely

affect structures used for various

purposes, livelihood of people (mainly

earning their livelihood by means of petty

shops and providing various services).

Many of them have been operating from

the government land. Thus both title

holders and non-title holders alike would

be affected as a consequence of the

project.

Applicable



MoRT&H 6-3

S.

No.


Policies


Applicability

6 OP 4.10 – Indigenous

Peoples

It has been found that Indigenous/ Tribal

people would also be affected in some of

the sub-projects whereas in some other

sub-projects though tribal people would

not be directly affected but are within the

immediate influence zone of the sub-

projects.

Applicable

7 The Right to Information

Act, 2005

The Act provides for setting out the

practical regime of right to information

for citizens to secure access to

information under the control of public

authorities, in order to promote

transparency and accountability in the

working of every public authority, the

constitution of a Central Information

Commission and State Information

Commissions and for matters connected

therewith or incidental thereto.

Applicable to the

project.

8 Environmental

protection Act, 1986 and

subsequent amendments

The Act provides for mandatory public

consultation for all listed projects and

activities requiring prior Environmental

Clearance (EC) and includes road and

highways requiring further land

acquisition. The Public Consultation shall

ordinarily have two components

comprising of: - (a) a public hearing at the

site or in its close proximity- district wise,

to be carried out in the manner prescribed,

for ascertaining concerns of local affected

persons; (b) obtain responses in writing

Applicable



MoRT&H 6-4

S.

No.


Policies


Applicability

from other concerned persons having a

plausible stake in the environmental

aspects of the project or activity.

9 World Bank Policy on

Access to Information

and Disclosure

World Bank safeguards policy requires

consultation with PAPs during planning

and implementation of resettlement action

plan and tribal development plan and

public disclosure of drafts. Once the draft

is prepared it is to be made available at a

place accessible to, and in a form, manner

and language understandable to the

displaced or affected people and local

NGOs. EP Act 1986 and NRRP 2007,

also requires disclosure of draft EIA, SIA,

RAP, EMP and other project reports

followed by mandatory Public Hearing.

Applicable

6.2 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF APPLICABLE POLICY

For the purpose of development, maintenance and management of national highways, a

special law, the National Highways Act (NH Act), 1956 has been promulgated in India.

This act provides for acquiring land through a ―competent authority‖, which means any

person or authority authorized by the Central Government by notification in the official

Gazette to perform functions of the competent authority for such areas as may be

specified in the notifications. For land acquisition (LA), the Act defines the various

procedures as (i) section 3A—intention of Central Government to acquire land, (ii) 3B—

power to enter for survey, (iii) 3C – hearing of objections, (iv) 3D – declaration of

acquisition, (v) 3E- power to take possession, (vi) 3F- power to enter into the land where



MoRT&H 6-5

land has vested in the central government, (vii) 3G – determination of compensation, and

(viii) 3H – deposit and payment of the amount. The Act requires that the processes must

be completed within a year from 3A to 3D. The Act covers only legal titleholders and

provides for compensation based on (i) market value of the land; (ii) additional payments

for trees, crops, houses, or other immovable properties; and (iii) payments for damage

due to severing of land, residence, or place of business. Land acquisition in this project

will be carried out under the NH Act 1956.

National Policy specifies that the compensation award shall be declared well in time

before displacement of the affected families. Full payment of compensation (section 3H

under NH Act) as well as adequate progress in resettlement shall beensured in advance of

the actual displacement of the affected families. World Bank safeguard policy also

requires that the compensation and assistance to PAPs(other than capacity

buildingsupport for livelihood restoration) be provided prior to any displacement or start

of civil works.

Both the National Policy and the World Bank guidelines on rehabilitation and

resettlement aim to see that involuntary resettlement should be avoided or minimized,

wherever feasible, exploring all viable alternative project designs, and where

displacement is unavoidable, people losing assets, livelihood or other resources shall be

assisted in improving or at a minimum regaining their former status of living at no cost to

themselves.

Similarly, National Resettlement and Rehabilitation Policy 2007 recognize the need for

rehabilitation and resettlement benefits for project affected families belonging to

Scheduled Castes and Schedule Tribes separately. Further, one of the important

provisions of PESA Act is that the consent of Gram Sabha or the Panchayats at the

appropriate level shall be obtained before making the acquisition of land in the Scheduled

Areas for development projects. The Orissa R&R Policy 2006 has special provisions for

ST affected population. The World Bank OP 4.10 emphasizes ―a process of free, prior,

and informed consultation with the affected Indigenous People‘s communities at each



MoRT&H 6-6

stage of the project, and particularly during project preparation, to fully identify their

views and ascertain their broad community support for the project.‖

Also World Bank safeguards policy requires consultation with PAPs during planning and

implementation of resettlement action plan and tribal development plan and public

disclosure of drafts. Once the draft is prepared it is to be made available at a place

accessible to, and in a form, manner and language understandable to the displaced or

affected people and local NGOs. EP Act 1986 and NRRP 2007, also requires disclosure

of draft EIA, SIA, RAP, EMP and other project reports followed by mandatory Public

Hearing.

Based on the detailed comparative analysis of the above discussed applicable legal and

policy framework, key differences identified between these policies which needs to be

addressed under the Resettlement Policy Framework (RPF) is listed below:

1. Recognition of non-titleholders who have no recognizable legal right to the land

they are occupying and extending R&R benefits under the project;

2. Establishment of cut-off date to identify the non-titleholders in the project;

3. Compensation for the entire replacement of the lost and other assets fully or

partially;

4. Need for preparation and public disclosure of Social Impact Assessment (SIA),

Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) and Tribal Development Plan (TDP) as per

project requirements.

6.3 PURPOSE OF RESETTLEMENT POLICY FRAMEWORK

The Resettlement Policy Framework for the NHIIP has been prepared based on the

findings of Social Screening Report covering initial impact assessment and review of

applicable legal and policy framework discussed above.

Review of Social Screening Reports (SSRs) ushers that legal and administrative

procedures applicable may vary from State to State and also there are gaps between



MoRT&H 6-7

Resettlement and Rehabilitation Policies of the country and certain states and the Bank‘s

Safeguard Policies. Hence, MoRT&H felt the need to understand the critical elements of

the existing legal and policy framework and agree on a mechanism that will address the

key social issues. A specific policy framework for the project has been formulated to

bridge the gaps to conform to the provisions of World Bank‘s operational policies related

to Involuntary Resettlement and Indigenous Peoples. This policy framework will help

expedite the process and facilitate consistent preparation of social management plans

which will include RAPs and TDPs (if applicable) across all project roads in different

states.

The purpose of preparing a RPF is to:

a) Bring commonality in resettlement and rehabilitation benefits under the project.

b) Bridge the gap between Bank‘s policy on Involuntary Resettlement, Indigenous

People and NRRP 2007.

c) Bring together and built upon the current good practices in terms of procedures to

address more systematic and institutional issues.

d) Establish institutional arrangements at project, state and central level (MoRT&H)

for the implementation of social management plans including RAP and TDP.

e) Establish mechanism for Redressal of grievances, monitoring and evaluation, etc.

6.4 OBJECTIVES AND SCOPE OF RESETTLEMENT POLICY FRAMEWORK,

NHIIP

The framework has been formulated to lay down the principles and procedures for

management of social impacts caused by the project. It guides the social impact

assessment report, works out mitigation plans including Resettlement Action Plans and

Tribal Development Plans for the project. This framework shall apply to all project roads

under NHIIP whether partly or fully funded by World Bank during the entire period of

loan assistance. Overall objective of this framework is to guide the preparation and

implementation of NHIIP based on the following principles:



MoRT&H 6-8

Take due precautions to minimize disturbance to human habitations, tribal areas

and places of cultural significance.

Ensure that the Project Affected Persons (PAPs) are not negatively affected by the

project.

Involve affected people from inception stage to operation and maintenance.

Consult affected people in issues of ROWs, land acquisition or loss of livelihood

Encourage consultation with communities in identifying environmental and social

implications of projects.

Pay special attention to marginalized and vulnerable groups and secure their

inclusion in overall public participation.

Provide compensation and assistance to PAPs prior to any displacement or start of

civil works.

Guarantee entitlements and compensation to affected people as per the R&R

policy. This would ensure compensation and assistance sufficient to improve or at

least restore livelihoods to levels experienced before the project.

Share information with local communities about environmental and social

implications.

Broad community support is ascertained based on free, prior and informed

consultation.

6.4.1 Revision/Modification of the RPF

RPF will be an ―up-to-date‖ or a ―live document‖ enabling revision, when and

where necessary. Unexpected situations and/or changes in the project or sub-

component design would therefore be assessed and appropriate management

measures will be incorporated by updating the Resettlement Policy Framework to

meet the requirements of country‘s legislations and Bank safeguards policies.

Such revisions will also cover and update any changes/modifications introduced



MoRT&H 6-9

in the legal/regulatory regime of the country/ state. Also, based on the experience

of application and implementation of this framework, the provisions and

procedures would be updated, as appropriate in consultation with the World Bank

and the implementing agencies/departments.

6.5 RESETTLEMENT AND REHABILITATION POLICY, NHIIP

6.5.1 Definitions

Following definitions that will be applicable unless otherwise stated specifically.

Agricultural labourer: means a person primarily resident in the affected area for a

period of not less than five years immediately before the declaration of the affected area,

who does not hold any land in the affected area but who earns his livelihood mainly by

manual labour on agricultural land therein immediately before such declaration and who

has been deprived of his livelihood;

Agricultural land: Denotes land used or capable of being used for the purpose of

agriculture or horticulture, dairy farming, poultry farming, pisciculture,

sericulture, breeding of livestock or nursery growing medicinal herbs, raising of

crops, grass or garden produce and land used by an agriculturist for the grazing of

cattle, but does not include land used for cutting of wood only;

Below poverty line (BPL) or BPL family: means below poverty line families as

defined by the Planning Commission of India, from time to time and those

included in the BPL list for the time-being in force;

Corridor of impact (COI): Refers to the minimum land width required for

construction including embankments, facilities and features such as approach

roads, drains, utility ducts and lines, fences, green belts, safety zone, working

spaces etc. Additional land width would be acquired/purchased or taken on

temporary lease if the Corridor of Impact extends beyond the available Right of

Way;



MoRT&H 6-10

Cut-off date: Refers to the date on which the census survey of PAPs starts in

that road section/stretch. For entitlement purpose, the PAPs would be those who

have been in possession of the immovable or movable property within the

affected area/zone on or prior to cut off date. However, the cut-off date for land

acquisition purpose is the date on which the notification under section 3A will be

issued under the NH Act, 1956;

Encroacher: A person who has extended their building, agricultural lands,

business premises or work places into public/government land without authority;

Entitled person (EP): A person who is adversely impacted by the project and is

entitled to assistance as per the project entitlement framework is considered to be

an Entitled Person.

Holding: means the total land held by a person as an occupant or tenant or as

both;

Kiosk: A kiosk is a booth/stall/cabin/cubicle made of wood or iron or any other

building material which could be shifted to another location as a single unit

without much damage and is used for carrying out petty business/ commercial

activities and has been in operation/existence prior to cut off date;

Land acquisition" or "acquisition of land": means acquisition of land under

the NH Act, 1956 for the time being in force;

Landowner: A person who is an allottee or a grantee of any land under any

scheme of the Government under which such allotment or grant is to mature into

ownership, who has mortgaged his land (or any portion thereof) or who has

permanent rights and interest in land;

Marginal farmer: Refers to a cultivator with an un-irrigated land holding up to

one hectare or irrigated land holding up to half hectare;

Non-agricultural labourer: means a person who is not an agricultural labourer

but is primarily residing in the affected area for a period of not less than five years



MoRT&H 6-11

immediately before the declaration of the affected area and who does not hold any

land under the affected area but who earns his livelihood mainly by manual labour

or as a rural artisan immediately before such declaration and who has been

deprived of earning his livelihood mainly by manual labour or as such artisan in

the affected area;

Non-titleholder: Affected persons/families/ households with no legal title to the

land, structures and other assets adversely affected by the project. Non-

titleholders include encroachers, squatters, etc;

Notification: means a notification published in the Gazette of India;

Occupier: means a member of a Scheduled Tribes community in possession of

forest land prior to the 13th day of December, 2005;

Project: Refers to the National Highways Interconnectivity Improvement Project

(NHIIP).

Project affected area: Refers to the area of village or locality under a project for

which land will be acquired under NH Act 1956 through declaration by

Notification in the Official Gazette by the appropriate Government or for which

land belonging to the Government will be cleared from obstructions;

Project affected family: includes a person, his or her spouse, minor sons,

unmarried daughters, minor brothers, unmarried sisters, father, mother and other

relatives residing with him or her and dependent on him or her for their

livelihood; and includes "nuclear family" consisting of a person, his or her spouse

and minor children;

Project affected person (PAP): Any tenure holder, tenant, Government lessee or

owner of other property, or non-titleholder who on account of the project has been

affected from such land including plot in the abadi or other property in the

affected area will be considered as PAP;



MoRT&H 6-12

Project displaced person (PDP): Any tenure holder, tenant, Government lessee

or owner of other property, or non-titleholder who on account of the project has

been involuntarily displaced from such land including plot in the abadi or other

property will be considered as PDP. A displaced will always be a PAP but all

PAP may not be PDP;

Project affected household (PAH): A social unit consisting of a family and/or

non-family members living together, and is affected by the project negatively

and/or positively;

Replacement cost: A replacement cost/value of any land or other asset is the

cost/value equivalent to or sufficient to replace/purchase the same land or other

asset;

Small farmer: Refers to a cultivator with an un-irrigated land holding up to two

(2) hectares or with an irrigated land holding up to one (1) hectare;

Squatter: A person who has settled on public/government land, land belonging to

institutions, trust, etc and or someone else‘s land illegally for residential, business

and or other purposes and/or has been occupying land and building/asset without

authority;

Tenant: A person who holds/occupies land-/structure of another person and (but

for a special contract) would be liable to pay rent for that land/structure. This

arrangement includes the predecessor and successor-in-interest of the tenant but

does not include mortgage of the rights of a landowner or a person to whom

holding has been transferred; or an estate/holding has been let in farm for the

recovery of an arrear of land revenue; or of a sum recoverable as such an arrear or

a person who takes from Government a lease of unoccupied land for the purpose

of subletting it;

Titleholder: A PAP/PAF/PAH who has legal title to land, structures and other

assets in the affected zone;



MoRT&H 6-13

Vulnerable group: This includes Scheduled Caste. ST, family/household headed

by women/female, disabled, handicapped, orphans, destitute, BPL, abandoned

woman; unmarried girls; widows; and persons above the age of 65 years

irrespective of their status of title (ownership). Vulnerable groups would also

include those farmers who (after acquisition of land) become small/marginal

farmers and also qualify for inclusion in BPL. For such cases, total land holding

of the landowner in that particular revenue village will be considered in which

land has been acquired;

Wage earner: Wage earners are those whose livelihood would be affected due to

the displacement of the employer. The person must be in continuous employment

for at least six months prior to the cut-off date with the said employer and must

have reliable documentary evidence to prove his/her employment.

6.6 RESETTLEMENT PRINCIPLES AND ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA

Based on the above analysis of government provisions and requirements as per World

Bank IR policy the broad resettlement principle for this project shall be the following:

Proposed highway improvement and strengthening work will take place mostly on

the existing alignment and within the available RoW except at locations where

bypass is proposed or at locations were realignment is necessary to incorporate

required safety measures;

The involuntary resettlement and adverse impacts on persons affected by the

project would be avoided or minimized as much as possible exploring viable

alternative project design;

Where it is not feasible to avoid resettlement, resettlement activities should be

conceived and executed as sustainable development programs, providing

sufficient investment resources to enable the persons displaced by the project to

share in project benefits;



MoRT&H 6-14

Efforts should be made to improve their livelihoods and standards of living or at

least to restore them, in real terms, to pre-displacement levels or to levels

prevailing prior to the beginning of project implementation, whichever is higher;

Displaced persons should be meaningfully consulted and should have

opportunities to participate in planning and implementing resettlement programs;

Replacement land shall be an option for compensation in the case of loss of land.

In case of unavailability of replacement land, cash-for-land with compensation on

replacement cost option will be made available to the PAPs;

Compensation for loss of land, structures and other assets will be based on full

replacement cost and will be paid before physical displacement of PAPs including

transaction costs;

In the event of necessary relocation, PAPs shall be assisted to integrate into host

communities;

All land acquisition for the project would be done as per the National Highways

Act, 1956. Additional assistance would be provided to the PAPs for meeting the

replacement cost of the property;

Compensation and all R&R assistance shall be disbursed except skill

enhancement entitlements before initiating civil works;

The uneconomic residual land remaining after land acquisition will be acquired

by the project. The owner of such land/property will have the option to seek

acquisition of his entire contiguous holding/ property provided the residual land is

less than the average land holding of the district;

Any structure/asset rendered unviable/unsafe because of the project shall also be

considered as affected and entitlements shall be extended accordingly;

The affected persons who does not own land or other properties, but have

economic interests or lose their livelihoods will be assisted as per the policy

principles described in this document;



MoRT&H 6-15

Cut-off date for titleholders will be the date of publication of notification under

Section 3A of the National Highways Act, 1956. For non-titleholders who has not

any legal holding of the occupied land such as squatters and encroachers the date

of project census survey or a similar designated date declared by the executing

agency will be considered as cut-off date;

An entitlement matrix for different categories of people affected by the project

has been prepared and provisions will be kept in the budget for those who were

not present at the time of census survey. However, people moving in the project

area after the cut-off date will not be entitled to any compensation or assistance;

Vulnerable groups (PAPs below poverty line (BPL), the landless, disabled,

elderly persons, women and children, indigenous peoples) will be identified and

given additional support and assistance under the project;

All common property resources (CPR) lost due to the project will be

reconstructed or compensated by the project;

Information related to the preparation and implementation of resettlement plan

will be disclosed to all stakeholders and people‘s participation will be ensured in

planning and implementation;

Appropriate grievance Redressal mechanism will be established at sub-project,

state and central levels to ensure speedy resolution of disputes;

An effective monitoring and evaluation mechanism will be established to ensure

consistent implementation of resettlement activities planned under the project

including third party monitoring.

6.7 ENTITLEMENT MATRIX FOR NHIIP

Under Resettlement and Rehabilitation Policy adopted for the project, several categories

of project affected persons are recognised with varying eligibility for the compensation

and assistance packages in the entitlement matrix below. This entitlement matrix has



MoRT&H 6-16

been developed in accordance with the basic principles adopted in the RPF and analysis

of initial identification of project impacts.

In case where a State Government through any Act or Gazette Notification or as

approved by any authority of State Government (duly authorized for the purpose) as per

their approved procedure has fixed a rate for compensation of land and is higher than the

provisions under the project, the same may be adopted by the Competent Authority in

determining the compensation for land.

Similarly, in case where a State Government through any Act or Gazette Notification or

as approved by any authority of State Government (duly authorized for the purpose) as

per their approved procedure has fixed a rate for resettlement and rehabilitation assistance

and is higher than the provisions under the project, the same may be adopted by the

Project Authority.

Entitlement Matrix

S No

Application Definition of

Entitled Unit Entitlement Details

A. Loss of Private Agricultural, Home-Stead & Commercial Land

1 Land within

the Corridor

of Impact

(COI)

Titleholder

family and

families with

traditional

land

Right

Compensation

at replacement

cost,

Resettlement

and

Rehabilitation

a) Land for land, if available. Or, Cash

compensation for the land at replacement

cost, which will be determined as mentioned

in Note (A).

b) If the compensation amount determined by

the Competent Authority is less than the

replacement cost mentioned in Note A, the

difference amount will be paid as

replacement assistance.

c) In case of land for land is not provided,

additional ex-gratia amount of Rs 20,000/-

for those losing land up to 250 sqmts of land.



MoRT&H 6-17

S No



The affected person will get Rs.80 per sqmt

for any area acquired above 250 sqmt. (para

7.19 NRRP 2007)

d) If as a result of land acquisition, the land

holder becomes landless or is reduced to the

status of a ―small‖ or ―marginal‖ farmer,

rehabilitation allowance equivalent to 750

days of minimum agricultural wages would

also be given. (para 7.14, NRRP-2007).

e) Policy for acquisition/ compensation for

residual land will be as per note B.

f) In case of allotment of land, one time

financial assistance of minimum Rs. 15000/-

per hectare for land development. (para 7.9.1

of NRRP-2007)

g) Refund of stamp duty and registration

charges incurred for replacement land to be

paid by the project; replacement land must

be bought within a year from the date of

payment of compensation to project affected

persons.

B. Loss of Private Structures (Residential/Commercial)

2 Structure

within the

Corridor of

Impact (CoI)

Title Holder/

Owner

Compensation

at replacement

rate,

Resettlement

&

Rehabilitation

Assistance

a) Cash compensation for the structure at

replacement cost which would be

determined as per Note (C).

b) Right to salvage material from the

demolished structures.

c) Three months‘ notice to vacate structures.

d) Refund of stamp duty and registration

charges for purchase of new alternative



MoRT&H 6-18

S No



houses/shops at prevailing rates on the

market value as determined in (a) above.

Alternative houses/shops must be bought

within a year from the date of payment of

compensation.

e) In case of partially affected structures and

the remaining structure continues to be

viable additional 25% of compensation

amount as restoration grant.

f) Monthly subsistence/transitional allowance

equivalent to twenty-five days minimum

agricultural wages per month for a period of

one year from the date of displacement (para

7.16 of NRRP-2007).

g) Each affected family getting displaced shall

get a one-time financial assistance of Rs

10,000 as shifting allowance (para 7.10

NRRP 2007).

h) Each affected family that is displaced and

has cattle, shall get financial assistance of Rs

15,000/- for construction of cattle shed (para

7.10 NRRP 2007).

i) Each affected person who is a rural artisan,

small trader or self-employed person and

who has been displaced (in this project

owner of any residential–cum commercial

structure) shall get a one-time financial

assistance of Rs 25,000/- for construction of

working shed or shop (para 7.12 NRRP

2007).



MoRT&H 6-19

S No



j) House construction assistance of Rs. 10,000

for families belonging to vulnerable group

will be provided.

3 Structure

within the

Corridor of

Impact (CoI)

Tenants/

Lease Holders

Resettlement

&

Rehabilitation

Assistance

a) Registered lessees will be entitled to an

apportionment of the compensation payable

to structure owner as per applicable local

laws.

b) In case of tenants, three months written

notice will be provided along with Rs 10,000

towards shifting allowance (NRRP 7.11).

c) In case three months‘ notice to vacate

structures is not provided, then three

months‘ rental allowance will be provided in

lieu of notice.

C. Loss of Trees and Crops

4 Standing

Trees,

Crops within

the Corridor

of Impact

(CoI)

Owners and

beneficiaries

(Registered/

Un-registered

tenants,

contract

cultivators,

leaseholders &

sharecroppers

Compensation

at market

value

a) Three months advance notice to project

affected persons to harvest fruits, standing

crops and removal of trees.

b) Compensation to be paid at the rate

estimated by:

i) The Forest Department for timber trees

ii) The State Agriculture Extension

Department for crops

iii) The Horticulture Department for

fruit/flower bearing trees.

c) Registered tenants, contract cultivators &

leaseholders & sharecroppers will be eligible for

compensation for trees and crops as per the

agreement document between the owner and the

beneficiaries.



MoRT&H 6-20

S No



d) Un-registered tenants, contract cultivators,

leaseholders & sharecroppers will be eligible for

compensation for trees and crops as per mutual

understanding between the owner and the

beneficiaries.

D. Loss of Residential/ Commercial Structures to Non-Titled Holders

5 Structures

within the

Corridor of

Impact (CoI)

or Govt. land

Owners of

Structures or

Occupants of

structures

identified as

per Project

Census Survey

Resettlement

&

Rehabilitation

Assistance

a) Encroachers shall be given three months‘

notice to vacate occupied land or cash

assistance at replacement cost for loss of

structures.

b) Any encroacher identified as vulnerable shall

be paid replacement cost of affected

structure to be determined as per Note C.

c) Any encroacher identified as non-vulnerable

but more than 25% of structure used for

residential purposes is affected be paid cash

assistance at replacement cost for loss of

structures to be determined as per Note C.

d) All squatters to be paid cash assistance for

their structures at replacement costs which

will be determined as mentioned in Note C.

e) Resettlement & Rehabilitation assistance to

the squatters as under:

(i) Monthly subsistence/transitional

allowance equivalent to twenty-five days

minimum agricultural wages per month

for a period of one year from the date of

displacement (para 7.16 of NRRP-2007).

(ii) Shifting allowance of Rs 10,000 per

family (para 7.11 NRRP 2007).



MoRT&H 6-21

S No



(iii) Assistance of Rs 15,000/- for loss of

cattle shed (para 7.10 NRRP 2007).

(iv) Each affected person who is a rural

artisan, small trader or self-employed

person assistance of Rs 25,000/- for

construction of working shed or shop

(para 7.12 NRRP 2007).

(v) House construction assistance of Rs.

10000/- for those belonging to

vulnerable groups.

E. Loss of Livelihood

6 Families

living within

the Corridor

of Impact

(CoI)

Title Holders/

Non-Title

holders/

sharecroppers,

agricultural

labourers and

employees

Resettlement

&

Rehabilitation

Assistance

a) Monthly subsistence/ transitional allowance

equivalent to twenty-five days minimum

agricultural wages per month for a period of

one year from the date of displacement (para

7.16 of NRRP-2007). (PAPs covered under

1(f), 2 (f) and 5 (e) (i) above would not be

eligible for this assistance).

b) Training Assistance of Rs 10,000/- for

income generation per family.

c) Temporary employment in the project

construction work to project affected

persons with particular attention to

vulnerable groups by the project contractor

during construction, to the extent possible.

F. Additional Support to Vulnerable Group

7 Families

within the

Corridor of

Impact (CoI)

Vulnerable

families

Resettlement

&

Rehabilitation

Assistance

One time additional financial assistance

equivalent to 300 days of minimum wages to all

vulnerable including STs as Economic

Rehabilitation Grant.



MoRT&H 6-22

S No



G. Additional Assistance to Scheduled Tribe Families

8 Scheduled

Tribe

families

within the

Corridor of

Impact (CoI)

Family Resettlement

&

Rehabilitation

Assistance

a) Each ST affected family shall get an

additional one time financial assistance

equivalent to two hundred days of

minimum agricultural wages for loss of

customary rights or usage of forest produce

(para 7.21.5 NRRP 2007). Customary rights

on land and usage of forest will have to be

certified by the Gram Sabha or such

appropriate authority.

b) Each Scheduled Tribe family affected

families resettled out of the district will get

twenty-five per cent higher rehabilitation

and resettlement benefits.

H. Loss of Community Infrastructure/Common Property Resources

9 Structures &

other

resources

(e.g. land,

water,

Access to

structures

etc.) within

the Corridor

of Impact

(CoI)

Affected

communities

and

groups

Reconstruction

of community

structure and

common

property

resources

Reconstruction of community structure and

Common property resources in consultation with

the community.

I. Temporary Impact During Construction

10 Land &

assets

Owners of

land &

Compensation

for temporary

Compensation to be paid by the contractor for

loss of assets, crops and any other damage as per



MoRT&H 6-23

S No



temporarily

impacted

during

construction

Assets impact during

Construction

e.g. diversion

of normal

traffic, damage

to adjacent

parcel of land /

assets due to

movement of

heavy

machinery and

plant site.

prior agreement between the ‗Contractor‘ and

the ‗Affected Party‘.

J. Resettlement Site

11 Loss of

residential

and

commercial

structures

Displaced

titleholders

and non-

titleholders

Provision of

resettlement

site/ vendor

market

Resettlement sites will be developed as part of

the project, if a minimum of 25 project displaced

families opt for assisted resettlement. Vulnerable

PAPs will be given preference in allotment of

plots/flats at the resettlement site. Plot size will

be equivalent to size lost subject to a maximum

of 250 sq mt in rural area and 150 sq mt in urban

areas (7.2 of NRRP 2007).

Similarly, if at least 25 displaced commercial

establishments (small business enterprises) opt

for shopping units, the Project Authority will

develop the vendor market at suitable location in

the nearby area in consultation with displaced

persons. Shopping unit size will be equivalent to

size lost subject to a maximum of 100 sq ft in

urban and 150 sq. ft. in rural areas.

Vulnerable PAPs will be given preference in



MoRT&H 6-24

S No



allotment of shops in vendor market.

One displaced family will be eligible for only

one land plot at resettlement site or shop in the

vendor market.

Basic facilities such as approach road, electricity

connection, water and sanitation facility, etc shall

be provided at resettlement site and in vendor

market, as applicable by the Project Authority at

project cost. Any other basic facilities shall be

provided at the time of implementation in

consultation with displaced persons depending

on the requirements. Budget for the development

of resettlement sites and vendor markets will be

included in the overall project cost.

In case of self-relocation, PAPs will be eligible

for additional support for the construction of

structure@ 15% of the financial assistance

provided for new construction of house under

IAY and JNNURM, subject to the condition that

the PAP uses the assistance money for

construction only within a period of one year

from the date full payment of compensation and

assistance amount in the concerned state. The

PAP will be required to provide documentary

evidence to that effect. Self-relocating displaced

PAPs will not be eligible for land plots at

resettlement site or shop in the vendor market.

For development of the resettlement sites

(including vendor markets, approach roads, etc.)



MoRT&H 6-25

S No



the World Bank operational policy OP 4.12 will

be applied.

6.8 Methods for Assessment of Replacement Cost

The methods for assessment of replacement cost and determination of compensation for

loss of land, structure and other assets are discussed in the notes provided below:

Note A

1. Compensation would be determined by Competent Authority:

(i) Calculate the base cost by adding 50% of the latest guideline value/circle rate

for the indented use of the land;

(ii) Add 60% solarium to the base cost of land.

Or

2. Engage/Hire an Independent Valuer registered with Government, who can assist

to assess the replacement cost of land as follows and provide inputs to the

competent authority by:

(i) Appraising recent sales and transfer of title deeds and registration certificates

for similar type of land in the village or urban area and vicinity

(ii) Appraising circle rate in urban and rural areas of the district

(iii) Appraising agricultural productivity rate for land – 20 years yield.

Or

3. Compensation as per the state approved procedure.

Replacement cost of land shall be the highest of the above three options.

Note B - Compensation for unviable residual land



MoRT&H 6-26

If the residual plot(s) is (are) not economically viable, the Project Authority will

follow the rules and regulations applicable in the state and compensate

accordingly; if there are no state specific rules and regulations available regarding

residual land and the residual land is less than average land holding of the district

after acquisition, then the EA in agreement with the project affected person will

follow one of the following:

(i) The Project Authority will buy the residual land for the project following the

entitlements listed in the entitlement matrix; or

(ii) The Project Authority will pay the project affected person 25% of the base cost of

land as hardship compensation for that portion of land (residual) without its

acquisition.

Note C - Replacement cost of houses, buildings and other structures

The replacement cost of houses, buildings and other immovable properties will be

determined on the basis of replacement cost by referring to relevant Basic

Schedule of Rates (BSR) as on date without depreciation. In case of partial

impact, if the residual structure is rendered structurally unsafe or unviable the

entire structure to be considered affected and compensated accordingly. In case of

displacement and the valuation amount is less than the amount provided under

IAY/JNNURM as applicable, compensation equivalent to provisions under

IAY/JNNURM shall be provided.

Note D - Compensation for Trees/Crops

Compensation for trees will be based on their market value. Loss of timber trees

will be compensated at their replacement cost while the compensation for the loss

of fruit bearing trees will be calculated as annual produce value calculated for the

number of years (as per standard procedure followed by concerned department)

depending on the nature of trees/crops.



MoRT&H 6-27

6.9 Direct Purchase of Land

Provision of direct purchase of land from land owners in case of sub-project where

additional land requirement is very less (minimal) may also be considered. However,

resettlement and rehabilitation benefits available to affected persons whose land would be

acquired under the statute shall also be available to those affected persons whose land

would be acquired through direct purchase.



MoRT&H

7-1

CHAPTER– 7

GENDERISSUE&WOMEN’SPARTICIPATION

7.1 GENERAL

There are two important aspects of project where gender issues require to be addressed:

impacts due to acquisition of land for the project and during the construction/

implementation phase.

Impacts on women due to land acquisition have been addressed in the following section.

Women as a vulnerable group, woman-headed households, livelihood and training for

women, etc., are mentioned in other sections of the Report also.

All the provisions as mentioned in the RAP/TDP are proposed keeping in mind the well-

being of mostly the affected women along with women of the host communities women

workers can be expected to come from outside being engaged by the construction

contractors and will be staying in the construction camps during the construction. There

may be participation from local women also in the construction activities.

7.2 IMPACT ON WOMEN

1682 females are getting affected by the project (48.18% of the total population) out of

414 households only 4 women headed households are affected by the project. They

constitute around 0.96 % of the total affected and displaced population in the project area.

Socio-economic parameters like literacy, work force participation rate and general health

conditions etc. reveals that social status of women is low respectively, thereby brought

forward the scope of considering the households headed by women as vulnerable.

Low awareness level coupled with insignificant role in decision making at household and

community level further poses constraints for women and other vulnerable groups to

access the opportunities created by the project equitably.



MoRT&H

7-2

The changes caused by relocation tend not to have equal implications for members of

both sexes and may result in greater inconvenience to women. Due to disturbance in

production systems, reduction in assets like land and livestock, women and marginalized

vulnerable groups may have to face additional challenge of running a household on

limited income and resources. This may force women as well as children to participate in

involuntary work to supplement household income, which may also lead to deteriorate

social capital/network of women and men alike hence making them more vulnerable to

both social and environmental hazards. It is therefore important to assess status of project

affected women and other vulnerable groups, their potential impacts, and accordingly,

design an appropriate strategy/plan.

7.3 WOMEN HEADED HOUSEHOLD

Women headed households constitute 0.96% of the total PAHs. Table7.1shows that 4

women headed households are getting affected by losing agricultural land and structures

followed by losing commercial & residential accommodation and Gumti, Tea stalls etc.

Table- 7.1: Number of Women Headed Households

District Women Headed Households

Pratapgarh 1

Banswara 3

Total 4

Source: CensusSurvey, CEG

7.4

WOMENINVOLVEMENTINDEVELOPMENTPROCESSTHROUGHEMP

OWERMENT

Thedevelopment experienceofatleasttwodecadesshows thatitisequallynecessarytoconsult

womenandofferthemchoices ;i.e. Inenabling themtomakeinformed

choicesanddecidefortheirown development.



MoRT&H

7-3

Participationofwomenhasbeenenvisagedspecificallyinthefollowingareas:

• Inthepre-planning

andplanningstagesparticipationfromwomencouldbesoughtthrough

allowingthemfor takingpartin theconsultationprocess.

• Each field team of the NGO/Consultancy firm shall include at least one women

investigator / facilitator

• Compensationforlandandassetslostbeingsameforalltheaffectedordisplacedfamilies,

specialcareshouldbetakenbytheNGO/Consultancy firm

forwomengroupwhileimplementing theprocessof

acquisitionandcompensationaswell.

• ItisimperativethatthePIUensuresthatthewomenareconsulted

andinvitedtoparticipatein- groupbasedactivities,

togainaccessandcontrolovertheresourceasapartoftheRAP, additionally,

• TheNGO/Consultancy firm

shouldmakesurethatwomenareactuallytakingpartinissuance ofidentitycards,

openingaccountsinthebank,receivingcompensation

amountsbychequesintheirnameornot, etc. This will further widen the perspective

of participationby the women in the project implementation

• Formonitoringandevaluation,thereshouldbescopeforwomen‘sparticipation.

Womenshouldbeencouraged

toevaluatetheprojectoutputsfromtheirpointofviewandtheir

usefulsuggestionsshouldbenotedfortakingnecessaryactionsforfurthermodifications

inthe projectcreatingbetterandcongenial

situationforincreasingparticipationfromwomen. Monitoringof

projectinputsconcerningbenefittowomenshouldinvolvetheirparticipation

thatwillmakethe processmoretransparenttothem. TheMonitoring &

Evaluationteam(s)shallconstitute–33%women.



MoRT&H

7-4

Allassistance wouldbepaidinajointaccountinthenameofboththespouses; exceptinthecaseof

womenheadedhouseholdsandwomenwageearners.

The interventions envisaged will be taken care of by the civil contractor and the

budgetprovision for it‘s with implementing mechanism will be made. The activities will

be monitored by M&E agency periodically.

Annexure 7.1 presents the identified issue / concerns and recommended actions/ strategy

for addressing the gender issue and participation from women in the project.

7.5 INVOLVEMENTOFWOMENINCONSTRUCTIONACTIVITIES

Theconstructionworksforwideningandstrengthening

theprojectcorridorwillstartaftertheR&R

activitiesareoverandtheROWisclearofanyencroachment andlandistemporarilyacquiredfor

borrowareasandconstructioncamps.Theconstructioncontractorswillsetuptheirconstruction

campsonidentifiedlocationswherelabourforcerequiredfortheconstruction activitieswillbe

providedwithtemporaryresidentialaccommodationandothernecessaryinfrastructurefacilitie

s.

Thelabourforcerequiredfortheconstructionactivitieswillbemostlyofhigh-skillnature

sincealot of machine work will be there in the constructionof the highway.In addition,

there willbe requirement ofunskilledlabourwherewomenwillcertainlycontribute.

Apartfromthis,womenas familymembersofthe skilledand semi-

skilledlabourers,willalsostay inthe constructioncampsand

willbeindirectlyinvolvedduringtheconstructionphase.Thefamiliesoflabourerswillincludeth

eir childrenalso.

Theconstruction contractors

areexpectedtobringalongtheirlabourforce.Thus,inmostcasesthe

labourers,bothmaleandfemale,willbemigratorylabourers.But,theinvolvement oflocallabour

force,especiallyforunskilledactivities,cannotberuledout.Moreover, theRAPsuggeststhe



MoRT&H

7-5

provisionofcreationofman-daysforlocalaffectedpeople.Hence,there

willbeinvolvementoflocal womenalsointhelocal labourforce.

Foreseeingtheinvolvementofwomen,bothdirectandindirectintheconstruction

activities,certain measuresare requiredtobetakentowardswelfareand well-beingof

womenandchildrenin particular duringtheconstructionphase.The civil contractor will

provide the labour camps for women workers.

7.6 SPECIFICPROVISIONSINTHECONSTRUCTIONCAMPFORWOMEN

Theprovisionsmentionedunderthissectionwillspecificallyhelpallthewomenandchildrenlivi

ng intheconstructioncamp and shall be executed by the civil contractor.

7.6.1 TemporaryHousing

Duringtheconstructionthefamiliesoflabourers/workers shouldbeprovidedwithresidential

accommodationsuitabletonuclearfamilies.

7.6.2 HealthCentre

Healthproblemsoftheworkersshouldbetakencareofbyproviding basichealthcarefacilities

throughhealthcenterstemporarilysetupfortheconstructioncamp.Thehealthcentreshouldhave

at leastadoctor,nurses,GDstaff,medicinesandminimum medicalfacilitiestotacklefirst-aid

requirements orminoraccidentalcases,linkagewithnearesthospitaltoreferpatientsof

majorillnessesorcriticalcases.

ThehealthcentreshouldhaveMCW(MotherandChildWelfare)

unitsfortreatingmothersandchildreninthecamp.Apartfromthis,thehealthcentreshouldprovid

e withregularvaccinationsrequiredforchildren.

7.6.3 DayCrècheFacilities

It is expected that among the women workers there will be mothers with infants and

small children. Provision of a day crèche may solve the problems of such women who

can leave behind their children in such a crèche and work for the day in the construction



MoRT&H

7-6

activities.

The crèche should be provided with at least a trained ICDS (Integrated Child

Development Scheme) worker with to look after the children. The ICDS worker,

preferably woman, may take care of the children in a better way and can manage to

provide nutritional food (as prescribed in ICDS and provided free of cost by the

government) to them. In cases of emergency she, as being trained, can tackle the health

problems of the children and can organize treatment linking the nearest health centre.

7.6.4 ProperSchedulingofConstructionWorks

Owing to the demand of a fast construction work it is expected that a 24 hour-long work-

schedule would be in operation. Women, especially the mothers with infants should to be

exempted from night shifts as far as possible. If unavoidable, crèche facilities in the

construction camps must be extended to them in the night shifts too.

7.6.5 EducationalFacilities

The construction workers are mainly mobile groups of people. They are found to move

from one place to another taking along their families with them. Thus, there is a need for

educating their children at the place of their work. For this at least primary schools are

required to be planned in the construction camps. Wherever feasible, day crèche facilities

could be extended with primary educational facilities.

7.6.6 ControlonChildLabour

Minors i.e., persons below the age of 15 years should be restricted from getting involved

in the constructional activities. Measures should be taken to ensure that no child laborer

is engaged in the activities. Exploitation of young unmarried women is very common in

these kinds of camps. A strong vigilance mechanism should be created to check this and

ensure ceasing of such exploitation.

7.6.7 SpecialMeasuresforControllingSTD/AIDS



MoRT&H

7-7

Solitary adult males usually dominate the labour force of construction camps. They play a

significant role in spreading sexually transmitted diseases. In the construction camps as

well as in the neighboring areas they are found to indulge in physical relations with

different women. This unhealthy sexual behavior gives rise to STDs and AIDS. While it

is difficult to stop such activities, it is wiser to make provisions for means of controlling

the spread of such diseases. Awareness camps for the target people, both in the

construction camp and neighboring villages as well.

7.6.8 Civil works contractor shall be responsible for the above interventions to the maximum

extent possible and suitable provisions in this regard are incorporated in the bid

documents.



MoRT&H 8-1

CHAPTER-8

TRIBAL IMPACT MITIGATION AND DEVELOPMENT PLAN

8.1 INTRODUCTION

Indian Constitution has given foundation to the government for formulating special

programs to develop these vulnerable groups. Article 46, of the Constitution of India has

entrusted the State with the responsibility of promoting the economic and educational

interests of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. The Constitution of India makes

special provisions in the ―Fifth Schedule‖ and the ―Sixth Schedule‖ with regard to land

alienation and other social factors.

Typically, vulnerability is relatively high among Scheduled tribes/indigenous people.

Dislocation and loss of livelihood caused by road widening and development may cause

adverse impacts on tribal population of the area, unless special attention is paid to them.

In this connection an assessment of impacts specifically on Scheduled Tribes (ST) has

been done during the social assessment. The census surveys and consultation with tribal

groups along the project stretch was conducted in 2012 and 2013 as part of the project

preparation . The tribal issues were identified that needs to be addressed under the

project. This chapter discusses the issues/ impacts likely to be caused due to proposed

project interventions and actions necessary to mitigate the impact. Since more than 50

percent of the affected household are STs and SCs and thus the RAP covers all these

groups and in addition the TDP has been developed and included in this report to ensure

compliance with OP 4.10 and national laws, and also ensure that mitigation is provided

for negative impacts along with some additional facilities.

8.2 STATUS OF SCHEDULE TRIBES IN THE PROJECT AREA

Rajasthan is one of the significant states of India where over 500 tribes are notified

under article 342 of the Constitution of India. The category classified as ―Scheduled

Tribes‖ constitutes 8.2% of the total population of the country, and 12.6% of the total



MoRT&H 8-2

population of Rajasthan. As of 2001, there were 7.1 million STs in the state, of which

3.4 million were women (48%) (Census of India 2001) The STs are overwhelmingly

rural, as 94.6 per cent of them inhabit rural areas, compared with the state average of

76.6 per cent.

Out of the twelve tribes scheduled for the State, Meena is the most populous tribe,

having a population of 3,799,971 constituting 53.5 % of the total ST population

followed by Bhil (2,805,948). Meena and Bhil together constitute 93% of the total STs

in the state, whereas the Garasia, Damor, Dhanka and Saharia combine to form 6.6 % of

the total ST population. Six tribes, Bhil Meena, Naikda, Kathodi, Patelia, Kokna and

Koli Dhor along with the generic tribes constitute the residual 0.3 % of the total tribal

population. The concentration of these tribes in the districts is as shown in table 8.1

below.

Table-8.1 Area wise Tribal Group Distribution in Rajasthan

Tribal Group Area/s

Bhil Udaipur, Dungarpur, Banswara and Chittorgarh

Meena Jaipur, Sawai Madhopur, Alwar, Chittorgarh and Udaipur

Damor In the 10-12 Panchayats of Damriya region of Simalwara

Panchayat (Dungarpur)

Khatodi In Pindwara (Sirohi District) Jhadol (Udaipur District) in

Desiya, Ambasa (Panawa) regions

Garasiya In Sirohi District, in and around Abu Road area in 24 villages

comprising the ―Bhakkar Patta‖

Sahariya In the Hadothi region, Shahbad and Kishanganj villages and

the jungles of Baran

Patelia Dungarpur and Banswara

Source: htt://www.rvkp.org/vanvasi Anchal.htm (accessed December 30, 2011

8.2.1 District Pratapgarh

Pratapgarh is newest constituted district in Rajasthan state. It came into existence on



MoRT&H 8-3

26th

January, 2008 as 33rd

district of Rajasthan. It was carved out from Chittorgarh,

Banswara & Udaipur districts. In Pratapgarh the total tribal population constitutes of

21.5%. The district has about 45% of its area under forestland. With Meena tribals

predominating in the population, the area falls under Schedule V category of the

Constitution. 65% of the local population are poor and fall below the poverty line.

Common lands (grazing and forest) comprise a major portion of the landscape, with

habitations and villages scattered in between. However, a number of factors, such as

unfavorable tenure arrangements, weakening protection and management systems,

overgrazing, and illegal tree felling, together have contributed to the degradation of the

land over the years.

8.2.2 Banswara District

The Scheduled Tribe district, Banswara, has a Scheduled Tribe population of 1 085 272,

that is, 12.57 percent of India‘s tribal population. Banswara has the highest tribal

population constituting to 72.3%. The largest forest-dwelling marginalized Scheduled

Tribes in the district are the Bhil. Historically, the Bhil in this region have struggled to

maintain their identity and customary tenure rights by resisting the dominant groups in

society. The Bhils continue to recognize the traditional system of social control and stay

in a falia (hamlet) that represents a common clan.

8.3 METHODOLOGY FOR TRIBAL ISSUES

Structured questionnaires and group discussion were conducted during social survey

(attached in as Annexure of Affected Land Holders) and Gram Sabhas etc were used to

assess the impact. The data collected through Census of India and other authentic

sources were used as additional source of information for social assessment of the tribes.

8.3.1 Consultation Methodology

Consultations was carried out with the likely affected tribal population in a culturally

appropriate manner using local languages where needed. It took place in different modes



MoRT&H 8-4

– one on one interaction during household survey and group meetings along with other

PAPs. Most of the village level consultations were carried out during the social

screening and detailed Social Impact assessment and these were in addition to the focus

group discussions and interviews with individual ST affected Households. All of these

consultations were pre prior, and informed to the affected tribal people. During specific

consultation, issues like land acquisition, relocation, options and preferences in

relocation, compensation, assistance and income generation strategies like requirement

of training to enhance the individual skills etc. were discussed.

8.4 GRAM SABHA UNDER PESA 1996

Project road traverses through two Districts namely Pratapgarh (Pratapgarh and

Peepalkhunt tehsils) and Banswara (Ghatol and Banswara Tehsils). Both the districts are

listed under the Schedule V of constitution of India therefore, it is mandatory to conduct

the Gram Sabha in these project affected villages as per the prescribed procedure with

the minimum 15 days notices period from the Block Development Officer (BDO) of the

respective panchayats. The required Gram Sabha has been conducted in the project

affected villages of Pratapgarh and Banswara district under PESA (Panchayat Extension

in Schedule Areas) Act 1996 and the NOC (No Objection Certificate) has been acquired

from the village Panchayat Sámities. Similarly, Gram Sabhas has been conducted under

FRA 2006 in the project affected villages of both the districts where any forest land is

getting affected by the proposed project. During these Gram Sabhas, an especial

attention was given on the tribal issues, their rights to land and appropriate mitigation

options. List of villages where Gram Sabhas has been conducted is provided in

annexure-8.1.

Gram Sabhas has been organized by the Social Experts and consultants of the proposed

project in the presence of Sarpanch, Sectary of Panchayat Sámities, and PWD, NHAI

Division Engineers of both the districts of the project affected villages. The Gram

Sabhas conducted to understand the type and nature of support required to enhance the

economic and social status of Schedule Tribe population in the project affected area.



MoRT&H 8-5

During the above meeting and discussion the following demands/ suggestion have been

received from the Tribal community of the villages. The following training can be

organized by the NGOs in the affected villages to develop the ST community with close

coordination with local administration. Appropriate budget provision has been made for

the proposed trainings.

8.4.1 Consultation Process PESA Act 1996

District/ Tehsil: Pratapgarh

S.

No Village

Panchayat

Village

Name Date Time Place Officer

Demands/

Suggestions

1 Monohargarh Makanpura 26.12.2012 11.30AM Panchayat

Bhawan

Shri H G Sharma Appropriate

Compensation

District/ Tehsil: Pratapgarh / Peepalkhut

S.

No

Village

Panchayat

Village

Name Date Time Place Demands/ Suggestions

1 Kachotiya Kachotiya,

Padliya

02.01.2013 10.30AM Panchayat

Bhawan,

Kachotiya

Vocational Training

Programs such as

1.Computer Training,

2.English Speaking,

3. Advance Framing

Techniques in Poultry,

Agriculture

Employment for the

trained persons.

2 Suhagpura Mota

Mayanga,

Chayan,

Banjari

03.01.2013 10.30AM Rajiv Gandi

Sava Kendra,

Suhagpura

3 Semaliya Semaliya,

Kataro ka

Khera A,

Vakhatpura

04.01.2013 11.00AM Panchayat

Bhawan,

Semaliya

4 Sodalpur Kataro ka

Khera B

04.01.2013 02.00PM Panchayat

Bhawan,

Sodalpur

5 Peepalkhut Peepalkhut 05.01.2013 11.30AM Rajiv Gandhi

Seva Kendra



MoRT&H 8-6

District/ Tehsil: Ghatol

S.

No

Village

Panchayat

Village


1

Ghatol Ghatol

10.12.2012 2.30 pm

Near old

Govt.

quarters

Small land holdings.

Many families depend on the

agriculture land.

Livelihood will be affected

majorly. NOC not obtained.

Refer Annexure 4.2. 2. 11.12.2013 12.30 pm

Near old

bypass

S.

No

Village

Panchayat

Village


1 Banswara Mudasel 07.01.2013 11.00 AM Panchayat

Bhawan

Employment for the trained

persons.

Rural Development Programs

such as DRDA, NERGA,

other new Govt. schemes.

2 Bhagora ka

Khera

07.01.2013 01.30 PM Panchayat

Bhawan

3 Khamera Uadaji

Gada

07.01.2013 04.00 PM Panchayat

Bhawan

4 Savniya Savniya 08.01.2013 11.00 AM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra

5 Devda Devda 08.01.2013 01.00 PM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra

6 Padoli

Govordhan

Padoli

Govordhan

08.01.2013 03.00 PM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra

7 Senawasa Senawasa 09.01.2013 11.00 AM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra



MoRT&H 8-7

District/ Tehsil: Banswara

S.

No Village

Panchayat Village

Name Date Time Place Officer

Demands/

Suggestions 1 Bargaon Bargaon 12.02.2013 11.00AM Panhayat

Bhawan Shri Pramod

Bhatt New Employment

opportunities,

appropriate

compensation for

the land, training

or job for one

person in the

family. Some

affected persons

demanded 5 to 10

times more

compensation. Some demanded

extra land in return

after acquisition. Life time pension

facility to head of

the affected

family. Compensation for

132 feet land from

road center. They

did not agree upon

the compensation

of 15 m land from

road center. (Total

30m ROW given

in Banswara

bypass). Due to land

acquisition some

affected persons

demanded

construction

permission for

House or Shop

after 15m

distance from the

center line of

road.

2 Lodha Janamedi 12.02.2013 02.00PM Panchayat

Bhawan Shri Valchand

Khaja 3 Koupda Koupda,

Ganpatpura 13.02.2013 11.00AM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra

Shri Pramod

Bhatt

4 Bhachadriy

a Bhachadriy

a, Dushera,

Amarpura

13.02.2013 02.00PM Panhayat

Bhawan Shri Pramod

Bhatt

5 Tamtiya

Ada Tamtiya,

Odhar ji

Padha

14.02.2013 11.00AM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra

Shri Umesh

Pandiya

6 Sundanpur Shivpura 14.02.2013 02.00PM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra

Shri Pramod

Bhatt

7 Tejpur Tejpur,

Harmatiya 15.02.2013 11.00AM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra

Shri Pramod

Bhatt

8 Makod Makod 15.02.2013 02.00PM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra

Shri Pramod

Bhatt

9 Sevana Sevana 16.02.2013 11.00AM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra

Shri Pramod

Bhatt

10 Surpur Surpur,

Bhagatpura 16.02.2013 02.00PM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra

Shri Pramod

Bhatt

11 Borwat Borwat 18.02.2013 11.00AM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra

Shri Valchand

Khaja

12 Sagrod Sagrod 18.02.2013 02.00PM Rajiv

Gandhi

Seva

Kendra

Shri Valchand

Khaja

Source: Gram Sabha under PESA Act by CEG



MoRT&H 8-8

8.5 SOCIAL ASSESSMENT OF PROJECT AFFECTED TRIBALS

Social Assessment in tribal affected areas was undertaken for the project clearly brought

out that those belonging to the scheduled caste community form integral part of poverty-

stricken, Below Poverty Line (BPL) or marginalized groups. The new infrastructure in

the villages being developed in the recent times has improved access to education and

primary health centers. While still for higher education or hospitals they have to

approach the city or the nearby well developed areas. The STs are getting benefitted

under various government schemes. The change can be well observed among the tribal

people as they are shunning away from those tradition and customs which hamper their

growth. Most of the households have adopted nuclear family system, girls are getting

educated, child marriages are restricted, many getting higher education like B.Ed.,

computer training, mobile repairing etc.

8.5.1 Direct Impact Zone

In these villages majority of tribes have adopted the culture and life style of the main

stream population. Therefore, it is very difficult to distinguish them on the basis of their

culture and life style.

Schedule Tribe Households constitutes of 54.34 % which is a significant of the total

Households in the project affected villages. The total ST affected Households are 225 in

both the districts.

8.6 PROJECT AFFECTED TRIBAL POPULATIONS AND THEIR SOCIO-

ECONOMIC STATUS

8.6.1 Affected Tribal Households

Out of the total impacted Households 225 ST Households would be affected by the

proposed project. In the SES & Census survey conducted the ST lands owners were 268

and structures were 6. The analysis is given below in the table 8.2.



MoRT&H 8-9

Table-8.2: Project Affected Schedule Tribe Households

S. No Description ST Households

1. Affected private structures 6

2. Affected by Land 219

Total 225

Source: Census & SES Survey, CEG

8.6.2 Affected Tribal Population

The data in below Table 8.3 reveals the total ST persons to be affected in the proposed

project. 225 are the ST Households in which 1360 persons are getting affected. The

average family size in Pratapgarh is 5.9 and in Banswara are 6.1 persons.

Table-8.3: Project Affected Schedule Tribe Population

S.

No Description

Affected

Households

Affected

Persons

Percentage of

Affected Persons Family Size

1. Pratapgarh 63 372 27.35 5.9

2. Banswara 162 988 72.64 6.1

Total 225 1360 99.99 -


8.7 DISTRICT WISE POPULATION

The average household size of the tribal population in the area estimated is 6. As the

Table 8.4 show that Banswara tehsil has the maximum number of affected ST

Households. The ST households and PAPs have been segregated in two i.e. existing

alignment and in bypass affected ST households and PAPs. Given below is the

description of district and tehsil wise ST Households and persons distribution.



MoRT&H 8-10

Table-8.4: District and Tehsil wise Population Distribution

District Tehsil

ST Households PAPs

Existing

Alignment In By Pass

Existing

Alignment

In By

Pass

Pratapgarh Pratapgarh 2 - 12 -

Peepalkhunt 61 - 360 -

Banswara Ghatol 58 - 354 -

Banswara 10 94 61 573

Total 131 94 787 573

225 1360

Percentile 47.81 52.18 47.43 52.56 Source: Census & SES Survey, CEG

8.7.1 Marital Status

As per socio-economic survey of the ST Households the marital status of project

affected persons is given. Married are 86.98%, unmarried constitutes of 12.50% and

widowed are 0.51 %. Marital status of tribal population is mentioned in Table 8.5.

Table-8.5: Marital Status of ST PAPs

District Wise Marital Status of ST PAPs

Total Married Unmarried Widowed

Pratapgarh 329 41 2 372

Banswara 854 129 5 988

Total 1183 170 7 1360

Percentile 86.98 12.50 0.51 99.99


8.7.2 Age Structure

The most of the PAPs fall under the productive category of 38.60% which is 19-40 age

groups. A significant number has also been noticed for the 41-60 age groups which is

32.86 %. Details are in table 8.6 as follows:



MoRT&H 8-11

Table-8.6: Age Structure of ST PAPs

District

Age Group (Years)

Total 0-18 19-40 41-60 60 & Above

Male Female Male Female Male Female Male Female

Pratapgarh 25 24 71 68 57 56 37 34 372

Banswara 81 74 195 191 169 165 59 54 988

Total 106 98 266 259 226 221 96 88 1360

204 525 447 184

Percentile 15.00 38.60 32.86 13.52 99.98


8.7.3 Educational Status

Majority of the project affected tribals are educated upto Primary level constituting to

33.75%, illiterate are 47.86%, 2.79% are Graduate, Post graduate and Technical

Education combines to 0.51%. The STs are aware of the benefits of educating their

children regardless of boy and girl. Rajasthan Government is also supporting especially

girl‘s education as they provide free books, cycles to girls, mid-day meal, special

provisions for those girls who score higher percentage such giving computers/ laptops

etc. Details have been provided in table 8.7 below.

Table-8.7:Educational Status of ST PAPs

Literacy Level Pratapgarh Banswara Total %

Illiterate 129 522 651 47.86

Primary 155 304 459 33.75

Secondary 77 128 205 15.07

Graduate 9 29 38 2.79

Post Graduate/ Technical Education 2 5 7 0.51

Total 372 988 1360 99.98




MoRT&H 8-12

8.7.4 Employment and Occupation Status

Share of employed project affected persons is 41.02 %. The employed persons in both

the districts are mainly engaged in yearly employment. The main occupation of the

people is agriculture both male and female workers are engaged. Agriculture labourers

are mainly males who work around their village. Both males and females work in

NEREGA schemes as marginal workers also. Table 8.8 & 8.9 shows the employment

status of ST PAPs and occupation pattern of ST PAPs

Table-8.8:Employment Status of ST PAPs

Employment Status Pratapgarh Banswara Total %

Employed 97 461 558 41.02

Unemployed 275 527 802 58.97

Total 372 988 1360 99.99


Table-8.9:Occupation Pattern of ST PAHs

Occupation Pattern Pratapgarh Banswara Total %

Agriculture/Agriculture Labourer 52 60 112 49.77

Non- Agriculture Labourer 38 42 80 35.55

Salaried 2 17 19 8.44

Business 5 9 14 6.22

Total 63 162 225 99.98


8.7.5 Language and Culture

The language spoken by the affected tribal households is Hindi mainly while tribals

were also heard speaking “Bagri” the local dialect. Socio-Culture environment in the

project area was more influenced with the changing lifestyle. It could be well assessed



MoRT&H 8-13

with their appearance. Also they are giving away those practices which hamper their

growth such as child marriage, not spending much on social functions, adopting new

techniques in work etc.

8.7.6 Income

The income level of the project affected families is low. In the whole project stretch

most of the families come under BPL category. There were few who have completed

their higher education but still they are not getting employment. Many PAPs are school

drop outs as they are only educated to primary level. This is one of the major reasons of

people working more as agriculture laboureres or daily wagers. Table 8.10 shows the

income status of employment ST PAPs.

Table-8.10: Income Status of Employment ST PAHs

Income Level (Units in Rs Monthly) Pratapgarh Banswara Total %

Below 2,000 7 18 25 11.01

2,000-3,000 31 82 113 50.22

3,000-4,000 22 56 78 34.65

Above 4,000 3 6 9 4.11

Total 63 162 225 99.99


8.7.7 Live Stock Assets

In the ST households mostly every households has atleast 1 livestock with them. For

extra income they sell poultry such as eggs, hens etc, also trade milk in the main

markets. Goats are mostly sold in the haat bazaars or during special occasions. Table

8.11 shows the classification of livestock assets.



MoRT&H 8-14

Table-8.11: Classification of Live Stock Assets

District Cow Buffaloes Ox Goats Poultry Others Total

Pratapgarh 78 55 25 55 - - 213

Banswara 139 156 15 213 19 - 542

Total 217 211 40 268 19 - 755


8.7.8 Material Assets

In the ST households it was found that mobile was the most common material asset with

the people.

Table-8.12: Classification of Material Assets

Particulars Pratapgarh Banswara

Mobile 22 71

Two- Wheeler 7 20

Four Wheeler 1 -

Cycle 5 11

Television 2 12

Others - 3

Total 37 117


8.8 POTENTIAL IMPACT ON TRIBAL POPULATION

8.8.1 Impact on Land Khasra

331 land plotss are likely to get affected in both the districts. The existing RoW of the road will

be developed into 2 lanes with paved shoulders, covered drains with footpath and railing either

side as safety measures. The land plots have been segregatedinto those affected by existing

alignment and those that lie within in proposed bypass. Tehsil wise Impact on land of ST land

owners is given below in table 8.12.



MoRT&H 8-15

Table-8.13: Impact on Land

Districts Tehsil

Numbers of ST Khasra

Affected

Number of Villages of

Affected ST Land owners

Existing

Alignment In By Pass Existing

Alignment In By Pass

Pratapgarh Pratapgarh 2 - 1 -

Peepalkhut 104 - 11 -

Banswara Ghatol 90 - 12 -

Banswara 34 101 4 14

Total 230 101 28 14

331 42


8.8.2 Impact on Structure

The ST structure affected in the project stretch is 6. In By Pass only 1 structure is

coming. Details of affected structures are provided in the table 8.13 below.

Table-8.14: Impact on Structure

Type of Structure

Pratapgarh Banswara

Without By

Pass With By Pass

Without By

Pass With By Pass

Permanent - - - -

Semi- Permanent 1 - -

Temporary 1 - 3 1

Total 2 4




MoRT&H 8-16

8.9 COMPENSATION AND R&R ASSISTANCES

Appropriate Compensation and R&R assistances shall be provided for identified

structures on basis of Resettlement Policy Framework. An additional provision for the

affected STs has been given in the entitlement framework. Some additional or new

community facility will be provided in habitations along the project road as value

addition to the project.

Criteria: The criteria for selection and implementation of works would be as

follows:

i. Habitations which have high percentage (> 50%) of SC & ST

population would be selected for providing community facility/works;

and ;

ii. Community works shall be those that strictly benefit the larger section

of the village rather than an individual or a small group/section of

individuals

iii. The activity should not be already covered under some existing

government scheme;

iv. An indicative list of works are:

1. Provision of boundary wall for education and health facilities,

community building, religious structure;

2. Provision of furniture for school and health facilities

3. Provision of shelter for bus stand;

4. Hand pumps or repair to hand pumps;

5. Repair of dug-well, other village community infrastructure; and

6. Platform for meeting place of village community or women

7. Repair works, leveling, etc. of internal paths

In selected habitations consultations with community /villagers will be held by the RAP

implementation agency. The villagers will decide as to what type of community facility

is needed in their habitation unanimously. A resolution in this regard will be passed by

the villagers following the official procedure which will then be submitted to the Project



MoRT&H 8-17

Authority. The Project Authority either directly or through Construction Supervision

Consultant (CSC) shall get the design prepared and cost estimated, in case the

community facility is some kind of structure. The RAP implementation agency once

again will hold consultations with the community/villagers with the design. During the

consultation the design engineer of the CSC shall remain present so that modifications

or changes suggested by the community/villagers are incorporated. The final designed

shall be accepted by the community/villagers through similar procedure i.e., by

resolution.

The Project Authority will then issue a variation order to the civil contractor for

execution of work. The quality monitoring will be done by the community/ villagers or

by a group of community/villagers besides the usual monitoring carried out by the CSC

and Project Authority.

8.10 OTHER POSSIBLE IMPACTS TO TRIBAL POPULATIONS AND

MANAGEMENT/ MITIGATION MEASURES

Other direct and indirect impacts due to the construction phase which were foreseen at

the surveys and consultations are listed in table below. Preferential treatment of Tribal

and other vulnerable groups has been recommended as part of mitigation measures.

Phase Anticipated

Direct Impacts

Anticipated

Indirect Impacts

Anticipated Management/ Mitigation

Measures

Project

Execution

Demand for

labor

Frustration of

Local people not

being included in

the construction

activities

Advise the contractors about the criteria

for selecting workers, prioritizing the

people in the Project Area as long as they

meet the technical requirements. Give

preference to the vulnerable especially the

tribal population.

Inform the community in the Project Area

about the job vacancies, identifying the

number of available positions and the

application requirements. This information

will be given by the offices that will be

opened for this purpose. Preference for

Tribal and other vulnerable.

The executing agency or their contractors



MoRT&H 8-18

Phase Anticipated

Direct Impacts

Anticipated

Indirect Impacts


Measures

will train the local workers including tribal

in the application of environmental, safety,

and occupational health provisions, as

well as in the knowledge and mandatory

compliance of the Workers Code of

Conduct

Increase in the

expectations of

local population

and stakeholders.

Contractor to design and implement a

Temporary Hiring Program for the local

population that will anticipate the demand

of skilled and unskilled work force, the

time the employment will last and the

requirements the applicant will have to

meet to be accepted. Needs of the Tribal

population will have to be specially been

addressed.

Inform local stakeholders, through local

and regional communication media on the

location of his offices where they may

learn about job opportunities for laborers

and the priorities that will be given to

local workers. The Tribal welfare officer

and the NGO may also be involved for

increased participation and information

dissemination.

Migration to the

project area in

order to seek

employment

To decrease and control the flow of

population or people seeking employment

in the Project area.

It must be made clear through the mass

media that priority will be given to the

people who live in the Project area and

especially the vulnerable including ST.

Generation of

jobs, as well as

an

increased

demand for

goods and

services (raw

materials,

equipment rental,

food supply,

Increased level of

income in the

Project area

Stimulation of

local economy

The EA may consider mechanisms to

allow purchasing local products, as long as

the local market prices remain competitive

and are not affected by the company's

interest. If there are any material being

sold by a Tribal trader he may be given

preference over others

Offer training to local economic agencies

for the development of small and micro

enterprises. Training programmes with



MoRT&H 8-19

Phase Anticipated

Direct Impacts

Anticipated

Indirect Impacts


Measures

accommodations,

etc.) during

construction of

the road

Tribals may be organized.

Conflicts and

quarrels between

suppliers and

contractors

Implement a sales system to determine the

best offer regarding competitive products

and services.

The grievance redressal committee shall

have representation from Tribal Welfare

Department.

In other words, implement a sales system

designed to locate goods and services at

competitive prices, good quality and in

amounts required.

The possible

arrival of foreign

workers in the

area (Foreign

referring to

workers who are

not

residents/locals

of the area)

Interaction

between the

Project workers

and the women

from local

populations

Wide diffusion of the Project Workers

Code of Conduct and the establishment of

sanctions for offenders specially for tribal

population

All workers and subcontractors must be

subject to a Social Code of Conduct.

Documentation and diffusion of training

and educational programs

Risk of traffic

accidents

Traffic accidents

caused by

dumping

construction

material on the

site

Provide training for the project working

force (contractors and subcontractors) on

the Security and Health Plan

Sensitization programme on safety issues

for end users and specifically for tribal

population.

Erect traffic signals in the critical areas of

the Project.

Provide informative talks for the local

population on security measures to reduce

risk of accidents.

Establish and inform drivers of the speed

limits

Ensure that contractors and subcontractors

implement measures to reduce or avoid

potential accidents that may affect the

population in the area and the Project

workers themselves.



MoRT&H 8-20

Phase Anticipated

Direct Impacts

Anticipated

Indirect Impacts


Measures

Provide speed breakers near habitations,

schools and market places etc of tribal

population

Hire and train security personnel devoted

exclusively to preventing accidents in the

access road and controlling the speed of

the vehicles transporting construction

material.

8.11 CONSULTATION AND PARTICIPATION

Minor negative impacts in the proposed project were identified during the consultations

which can be mitigated. The support of tribal to widen the project road was extended

after ensuring mitigation to the anticipated negative impacts. The alternative option such

as by pass has negative impacts which have also been agreed by the tribals as they are

easily manageable. Regular consultations with the tribes are suggested during

implementation of project road and construction phase.

8.12 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS

At the implementation of RAP hiring of local level NGO should be given preference in

the project area. The Executing Agency will lay down the standards of the appointment

of NGOs in the project area. Local NGO will be given preference during the selection

others things being equal. If the NGO will be from outside the region, it would be

ensured to include representation from the project area in the team of field professionals.

This is to ensure that the NGO team is sensitive to the socio cultural profile and

practices of the project area, particularly Schedule Tribes.

8.13 MONITORING ARRANGEMENTS

Monitoring of the measures under this TDP will carried out as part of project's regular

M&E system along with inputs from the RAP&TDP implementation support agency



MoRT&H 9-1

CHAPTER 9

INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK FOR RAP & TDP IMPLEMENTATION

9.1 GENERAL

Suitable institutional arrangements will be made to manage and implement Resettlement

Action Plan including Tribal Development Plan. The institutional arrangements will be

set up at three levels viz., Central, State and Sub-Project Level.

9.2 CENTRAL LEVEL

At Central Level, the Chief Engineer (EAP), MoRTH, Govt. of India will be overall

responsible for the implementation of RPF. CE (EAP) will have all delegated

administrative and financial decisions with regard to implementation of the project as

well as land acquisition, RAP including TDP implementation.

Institutional arrangement at Central Level will include augmenting the capacity of

MoRT&H with regard to resettlement and rehabilitation and management of other social

issues. CE (EAP) will be assisted by a team comprising SE designated as Social Officer

and a suitable number of technical and secretarial staff. MoRT&H also will engage a

Social Development Specialist (SDS) either as individual consultant or through Project

Management Consultant (PMC), to work with EAP and assist Social Officer. The EAP

will be responsible for ensuring training, guidance, and recommendations for handling

policy and implementation issues at the state and sub-project levels in compliance with

RPF. The Social Development Specialist either individually or with PMC will provide

policy and strategic assistance to EAP on social issues including land acquisition and

rehabilitation and resettlement. The designated Social Officer will be specifically

responsible for implementation of RAP including TDP. The Social Officer will ensure

that all social safeguards issues are complied with as per the RPF. The roles and

responsibilities of the SDS would broadly include the following:

Ensure preparation and disclosure of SIA, RAP including TDP and Land

Acquisition Plan for sub projects as per RPF.



MoRT&H 9-2

Ensure adequate staffing at state and sub-project level to ensure timely

implementation of RAP includingTDP.

Guide and supervise in matters related to resettlement and rehabilitation &TDP to

state and sub-project level offices.

Compile data related to resettlement and rehabilitation &TDP activities received

from field offices and update Chief Engineer (CE) and suggest suitable measures

to be taken.

Interact with implementation agencies at state and sub-project level on a regular

basis.

Undertake field visits as and when required.

Facilitate necessary help needed at site with regard to LA and R&R issues.

Co-ordinate with state government departments in matters related to

implementation of RAP includingTDP.

Ensure budgetary provision for resettlement and rehabilitation of PAPs and

relocation, rehabilitation and reconstruction of common property resources

(CPRs) and implementation of RAP includingTDP.

Ensure timely release of budget for implementation of RAP includingTDP.

Monitor implementation of RAP including TDP carried out by the agency through

RRO at sub-project level.

Perform other roles and responsibilities related to implementation of RAP

including TDP as assigned by the CE (EAP) from time to time.

Ensure free, prior and informed consultation with tribal families along the project

and also ensure that sufficient supporting documentation is maintained.

Ensure third party audit of RAP including TDP implementation.

9.3 STATE LEVEL

At State Level, a Land Acquisition cum Social Development Officer (LA cum SDO)

would be appointed in the Project Coordination Unit (PCU) headed by Nodal Officer.



MoRT&H 9-3

Additional sociologist as individual consultant will also be engaged to assist LA cum

SDO in states as required, particularly in states with larger share of sub projects. The

roles and responsibilities of the LA cum SDO would broadly include the following:

Facilitate preparation and implementation of land acquisition and RAP including

TDP in compliance with RPF,

Ensure consultation and stakeholder participation in finalisation of RAP including

TDP,

Guide and supervise RAP including TDP implementation at sub-project level,

Interact with RAP including TDP implementation support agencies and undertake

field visits for first-hand information,

Guide and supervise the RAP including TDP implementing agency to roll out

HIV prevention activities,

Compile data on LA progress and RAP including TDP implementation activities

received from field offices and update EAP, MoRT&H and suggest suitable

measures to be taken,

Co-ordinate with various government departments in matters related to

implementation of RAP includingTDP,

Check implementation of RAP including TDP carried out by the agency from

time to time by undertaking site visits and consultations with PAPs,

Perform other roles and responsibilities related to implementation of RAP

including TDP as assigned by the EAP, MoRT&H from time to time,

Facilitate and cooperate in third party audit of RAP including TDP

implementation.

9.4 SUB-PROJECT LEVEL

A Project Implementation Unit (PIU) comprising officials of State PWD will be

constituted at sub-project level headed by the Superintending Engineer/ Executive

Engineer designated as Project Director. The PIU will be responsible for the project



MoRT&H 9-4

execution including RAP & TDP implementation. There will be a designated or

appointed Resettlement & Rehabilitation Officer (RRO) at respective PIUs who will be

responsible only for the implementation of RAP including TDP at site. Additional

sociologist as individual consultant will also be engaged to assist RRO as required. RRO

will assist Project Director at PIU in all matters related to resettlement and rehabilitation.

The roles and responsibilities of the Resettlement and Rehabilitation Officer are as under:

Ensure RAP including TDP implementation with assistance from implementation

agency as per the time line agreed upon.

Interact with RAP includingTDP implementation agency on a regular basis.

Undertake field visits with implementation agency from time to time.

Facilitate necessary help needed at site with regard to LA and R&R, HIV issues to

implementation agency.

Co-ordinate with district administration and other departments in matters related

to implementation of R&R.

Ensure distribution of Resettlement and Rehabilitation Policy and entitlement

matrix for the project to PAPs.

Ensure preparation and distribution of photo identity cards.

Ensure and attend meetings organised by implementation agency on thematic

areas related to resettlement and rehabilitation policy and entitlements and

awareness generation.

Ensure inclusion of PAPs who could not be enumerated during census but have

documentary evidence to be included in the list of PAPs.

Ensure preparation of identity cards, and approval from the PCU and distribution

of the same to PAPs.

Ensure timely preparation of micro-plan from RAP & TDP implementation

agency and approval from PCU.

Ensure disbursement of resettlement and rehabilitation assistance in a transparent



MoRT&H 9-5

manner.

Participate in meetings related to resettlement and rehabilitation issues.

Facilitate in opening of joint account of PAPs.

Prepare monthly progress report related to physical and financial progress of

implementation of RAP including TDP & submit to PCU.

Ensure release of compensation and assistance before taking over the possession

of land for start of construction work.

Ensure relocation, rehabilitation and reconstruction of CPRs before dismantling

through proper mechanism.

Ensure development of resettlement sites, if required.

Attend and participate in Grievance Redress Committee meetings for redressal of

grievances of PAPs and other committees involving R&R matters,

Liaison with government and other agencies for inclusion of PAPs in employment

and income generation programme/scheme.

Carry out any other work related to resettlement and rehabilitation that may be

entrusted from time to time by the PCU for compliance of R&R.

Provide all necessary information and data related to R&R on monthly basis to

designated Social Officer at Central Level through Project Director.

Ensure that tribal families get equal opportunity to participate during

implementation and become overall beneficiaries in the project.

9.5 RAP & TDP IMPLEMENTING SUPPORT AGENCY AT SUB-PROJECT LEVEL

To implement RAP & TDP for each of the sub-project, the Project Authority [CE (EAP),

MoRT&H] will engage the services of NGOs/Consultancy firms having experience in

resettlement and rehabilitation issues through standard bidding process. Detailed ToR for

hiring the services of the agency will be prepared by the DPR consultants along with

RAP & TDP. The implementation agency will work in close co-ordination with RRO and

report to PIU. Financial matters related to services of the RAP & TDP implementation



MoRT&H 9-6

agency will be dealt by Project Authority. Broad roles and responsibilities of

implementation agency would be as:

The RAP & TDP implementation agency will be the main link between the

Project Authority and PAPs,

Shall be responsible for verification of PAPs as prepared by the DPR consultants,

Undertake public information campaign along with RRO at the commencement of

the RAP&TDP,

Develop rapport with PAPs,

Distribute pamphlets of R&R Policy including Entitlement Matrix to PAPs,

Panchayat Raj Institutions, and concerned Govt. Offices in the project area, etc.

Include PAPs who could not be enumerated during census cum socio-economic

survey and certification from R&R Officer,

Distribute identity cards for PAPs,

Prepare micro-plan,

Submit of micro-plan to RRO for approval from PCU,

Organize consultations at regular interval with PAPs with regard to resettlement

and rehabilitation,

Organize training program for skill up gradation of the PAPs,

Assist PAPs in all matters related to compensation and R&R,

Assist and facilitate aggrieved PAPs (for compensation and assistance) by

bringing their cases to GRC,

Facilitate in opening of joint account of PAPs,

Generate awareness about the alternative economic livelihood and enable PAPs to

make informed choice,

Consultations with PAPs regarding the choice of resettlement (i.e. self or

assisted), development of resettlement site, participation of women, etc.

Identify training needs of PAPs for income generation and institutions for

imparting training,



MoRT&H 9-7

Undertake outreach activities for HIV prevention for awareness and behaviour

change as per RAP & TDP,

Consultations with local people and Panchayat Raj Institutions with regard to

relocation, rehabilitation, reconstruction of affected CPRs as well as provision of

new facilities under the project,

Participate in various meetings,

Submit monthly progress report, and any other activities that may be required for

the implementation of RAP &TDP, etc.

Figure -9.1: Institutional Arrangement for RAP & TDP Implementation

SE (Designated Social Officer),

MoRTH

Project Authority

CE (EAP), MoRTH

Social Development

Specialist (SDS)

Regional Officer,

MoRTH

PCU (State PWD, headed by CE NH wing and designated Nodal Officer) Supported by Land Acquisition cum

Social Development Officer

SCHM (CE) (general project related issues)

M&E Agency

(Third party)

GRC at District Level (R&R related

issues)

PIU -- SDE/AE (Designated as

R&R Officer)

District Level Replacement Cost

Committee

RAP &TDP Implementation Supporrt AgencyNGO /

Consultancy Firm



MoRT&H 9-8

9.6 REPLACEMENT COST COMMITTEE AT DISTRICT LEVEL

A committee at district level will be constituted to fix the replacement cost of land,

structures and other properties (trees, crops and other assets, tube well, hand pump, etc).

The committee may comprise seven (7) members chaired by the District Collector/ Dy.

Commissioner or his designated representative (not below the rank of SDM), Executive

Engineer of the concerned District, District Agriculture Officer, Range Officer (Forest

Department), an independent certified valuer and elected representative (MLA) of the

concerned area and Team Leader of RAP & TDP implementation agency.

The highest value of land obtained by the three methods mentioned in Section 9.4 will be

presented by the Project Authority and approved by the committee as the replacement

cost. Similarly, latest schedule of rates of the concerned districts shall be used for

obtaining replacement cost of structures. For items not available in the schedule of rates,

for those items market rates shall be collected from three different sources and then

replacement cost shall be fixed by the committee. For replacement costs of crops, trees

and other such items similar methods will be followed.

For titleholders the difference of replacement amount and the compensation paid by the

Competent Authority (CA) as per the NH Act shall be paid by the Project Authority to

the entitled persons (PAPs) as assistance. The differential amount will be included in the

micro plan to be prepared by the NGO/Consultancy firm.

The committee will be constituted through an executive order and or other suitable

instrument within one month (30 days) from the date of mobilization of RAP & TDP

implementation agency at site.

9.7 Role of Various Stakeholders in Project Cycle

ProjectStage PAPsand

Representative NGOs

Local officials

(inPAPandhost

areas)

Hosts



MoRT&H 9-9


Representative NGOs

Local officials

(inPAPandhost

areas)

Hosts

Identificatio

n

Receive

information on

projectimpacts

Representative on

coordinationcom

mittee

Participatein

census surveys

Participationin

structured

consultations to

develop

IGprograms

Keep records of

consultations

Choose

resettlement

locationsor

housing schemes

Inputstodesign of

resettlementlocati

ons

Representation on

grievancetribunal

Design and carry

out

informationcampaign

AssistincensusandSo

cio- economicsurvey

ParticipateonCoordin

ation

Committee

Participateinconsultati

ons

Representationongrie

vance tribunal

TrainVRWswherereq

uired

Facilitate PAP inter

group meetings

Assistincensusa

nd socio-

economic

surveys

Assist NGO

in

information

dissemination

Participate

in

and

arrangeconsulta

tions

Arrange

PAP

transporttosites

Help to

document

consultations

SupportVRWsw

ork

Examine

feasibility of

IG

programmes

and discuss

with PAPs

Provide

information

andinputsto

design

ofIGprograms

Identify

existing

creditand IG

schemes

Discuss areas

of possible

conflict with

PAPs

Implementat

ion

Monitor provision

of entitlements

Labourandother

input at site

Creditandother

group

Provide on-going

informationfor PAPs

and hosts

Providesupportin

group management

Monitor entitlement

ProcessIGpropos

als

Participate

in

grievanceredres

s

Assist PAPs

in use ofnew

production

systems

From joint

management

groups for



MoRT&H 9-10


Representative NGOs

Local officials

(inPAPandhost

areas)

Hosts

schememanageme

nt

O&Mofsitesand

project input

Managementof

common

propertyresources

Managecommon

property

resourcesand

community

developmentfunds

Member of

implementation

comm

ittee

provision and

implementationof IG

programmes

Membersof

implementation

committee

Provide

assistance

underlocalsche

mes

Membership

of

implementation

committee

common

resources

Monitoring Participate in

grievance

tribunals

Report to

project IG

schemes

Reportonserviceq

uality atsites

Provide information

to project staff on

vulnerable groups

Act as external

monitors for project

(where not

previouslyinvolved)

Ongoing

interaction

withPAPsto

identify

problemsin IG

programs

Participants in

correctional

strateg

ies

Provide inputs

to

MonitoringofR

&R.

9.8 CAPACITY BUILDING AND TRAINING

Thecapacitybuildingandtrainingofalltheagenciesisthemostvitalcomponenttowardssuccessf

uland timelyimplementationofRAP & TDP.TheEAP,

MoRT&Hneedstoplayimportantrole.Inthissectionan attempt has been made to provide the



MoRT&H 9-11

broad areas of capacity building and training to be planned by the project authority in

different phases/stages of implementation process are as follows:

Phase/Stage Typeofcapacitybuilding/Training Organization /

Agency / personnel

InceptionPhase

Month -1

2 day Orientation workshop on lessons learning

and experience sharing - to discuss the major

issues in implementation.

SDS,PIUandNGO

InceptionPhase

Month -1

NGOandPIUstafftrainingonimplementationprocess,

mechanismandmajorissues.

PIUandNGO

Implementation

Phase. Month-3

1 day Quarterly review workshop on

implementation issues

Note: The quarterly review workshop needs to

be organizedtoestablishapropermanagement

information systemandmakethemanagement

decisionasvital input

forimplementationdecisionmaking.

SDS,PIUandNGO

Implementation

Phase. Month-6

2 day orientation workshop for supervision

consultant- working out methodologies, indicators

of monitoring, monitoringframeworketc.

SDS,PIU,supervision

consultantandNGO

Implementation

Phase. Month-2

TrainingNeedAssessmentofPAPs.

Designlivelihoodsupport Programme forPAPs.

ArrangetrainingforPAPs

PIU,NGOand

Supervisionconsultant

Framework of Training Program on Social Management

Training Topics Resource agency / persons

Trainee/participan

ts When Frequency

Environmental andsocial management

inNHIIP project-Orientation

MoRT&H/P

MC

PIC(staff-SDS, Environmental Specialist, SE etc), PCU (SE/Social Officer, R&R

For PIC/PCU, at the project launch

One day/One time



MoRT&H 9-12


Trainee/participan

ts When Frequency

expert from supervisionconsultant etc)

Baselinedata,methodsof data

collection/verificati

on, andoverall

M&Eof indicators

Asabove Relevant staffofPIC, PCU,PST

For PIC/PCU, at the project launch;

ForPCUandPS

T:

whenasubproje

ct meets the

readiness

criteria

Twodays/Oncea year

Resettlement policies and legal framework/ Resettlement action plan

MoRT&H- PIC/PMC

PCU(SE/SocialOfficer, R&Rexpertfrom supervisionconsultant etc),PST,andotherline Departments

Whensubproject meets readiness criteria

First year- Six monthly; oncea yearfromsecond year

Rehabilitation steps As above RelevantstaffofPIC, PCU,PST

For PIC,before signingproject agreement; ForPCUandPST: whenasubproject meets the readiness criteria

One day/Once a Year

Grievanceredressal Process


For PIC,At project launch;

ForPCUandPS

T: afterproject

implementation

One day/Once a year

Progressreportingand participatory

monitoring


ForPICandPST, At theproject

launch; For

PST: Duringthe

first sixmonthof

project

implementation

First year- six monthly;

Oncea

yearfromseco

nd year

Gendermainstreamingin project


For PIC, At the project launch

One day/Once a year



MoRT&H 9-13


Trainee/participan

ts When Frequency

implementation process

ForPCUandPST: afterawardingthe contract

Labor,EHS,and HIV/AIDs

Asabove andother supports as necessary

Relevant staffofPIC, PCU,PST

For PIC,before signingproject agreement; ForPCUandPST: beforeawardingthe contract

One day/Once a Year

Project specific Training/Capacity development programs for

PSTs, NGOs, and PAPs


Trainee/participan

ts When Frequency

Environmental andsocial management inNHIIP project

MoRT&H/P MC/PST

NGOs,Contractorstaff

Withinfirstmonthof contractaward

Once a year

Resettlement policies and legalframework

MoRT&H/P MC/Bank staff/PST


Asabove Onceayear

Resettlement action plan

MoRT&H/P MC/PST


Asabove Onceayear

Baselinedata,methodsof data

collection/verificatio

n, andoverall M&Eof

indicators

Asabove PST,NGOs,Contractor staff

Before contract is awarded

Once a year

Preparationofmicroplans

NGOs PST,PAPs,construction supervisionconsulta

nt

When the contract is awarded

One day/One time

Rehabilitationsteps MoRT&H/P MC/PST

NGOs,Contractorsstaff

Asabove Oneday/Onetime

Economic development andskill building/enhancement

Asabove+ resource

personas

needed

NGOs Whenthecontractis awarded

One day/One time



MoRT&H 9-14


Trainee/participan

ts When Frequency

Roadsafety Asabove NGOs,Contractorstaff

Withinfirst two monthsofcontract award

One day/Once a year

Grievanceredressal process

Asabove NGOs,Contractor staff/GRC members


One day/One time

Progressreportingand participatory

monitoring

Asabove NGOs,Contractorstaff

Whenthecontract is awarded

One day/One time

Gendermainstreamingin project implementation process

Asabove+ expert NGO



One day/Once a year


Asabove NGOs,Contractorstaff

Withinthefirst three monthsofcivil works begins

One day/Once a year

Rehabilitationsteps and R&R assistance

NGOs/ cons ulting firm

PAPs Aftersub-project is awarded

One day/One time

Economic development andskill building/enhancement

NGOs PAPs/onepersonper family

Asabove Asperthesocial management (SM)plan

Roadsafety NGOs/cont rector

PAPs/local community/school

children

Asabove Oneday-three times a year

Grievanceredressal Process

NGOs PAPs Asabove Oneday ayearat variouslocations coveringall PAPs


NGO PAPs Asabove Quarterly at different

locations



Client : MoRT&H 12-1

CHAPTER – 10

DISCLOSURE AND CONSULTATION PLAN

10.1 INFORMATIONDISCLOSURE

The Right to Information Act (RTI), 2005 provides for setting out the practical

regime of RTI for citizens to secure access to information under the control of public

authorities, in order to promote transparency and accountability in the working of

every public authority, the constitution of a central information commission and State

Information commissions and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.

The process for obtaining information and details of designated officials is posted on

the MoRT&H website http://www.morth.nic.in.

The Draft Resettlement Action Plan (RAP) would be disclosed on MoRT&H website

as well at the World Bank Infoshop/Public Information Centre. Feedback if any

would be incorporated into the final RAP document, following which the final RAP

will be disclosed. Further to enhance transparency in implementation, the list of

PAPs for disbursement of benefits shall be separately disclosed at the concerned

Panchayat Offices/ Urban Local Bodies, District Collector Offices, Block

development Offices, District Public Relations Offices (at the state and district

levels), Project office, and any other relevant offices, etc. The Resettlement Policy

Framework, Executive Summary of the SIA, RAP and TDP will be placed in local

language in the District Collector‘s Office.

10.2 CONSULTATION & PARTICIPATION PLAN

To ensure peoples‘ continued participation in the implementation phase and

promotion of public understanding and fruitful solutions of developmental problems

such as local needs of road users, problem and prospects of resettlement, various

sections of PAPs and other stakeholders will be engaged in implementation. Key

actions would be as follows:




Communicating to PAPs and beneficiary households in the project area of

resettlement policy provisions and grievance redress mechanisms through village

level public meetings;

Holding one to one meeting with the PAPs to explain their eligibility;

Household consultation to identify skill improvement training needs, counsel for

usage of assistance amount and other activities towards livelihood restoration.

The information dissemination and consultation will start after the mobilization of

NGO/Consultancy firm at site. It will be carried out by organizing public meetings at

suitable locations involving PAPs, local communities, local authorities, NGOs, and

other institutions available in the area. For this purpose, a month wise work plan for

holding consultations will be prepared by the NGO/Consultancy firm and submitted

to R&R Officer. The date, time and venue for holding consultations will be intimated

to PAPs, local community and local authorities at least 7 days in advance. The timing

of consultation shall be fixed as per the suitability of villagers giving due

consideration to peak working time. The intimation for the consultation shall be done

by way of drum beating, announcement by loud speaker and by putting up

information on the notice board of concerned village/town, and other such public

places.

Consultation will be carried out by the Project Authority through RAP & TDP

Implementation Agency with active involvement of R&R officer at project level.

Besides, the Social officer at state level will also carry out consultations with PAPs,

local community and other government department officials at suitable time intervals

directly with support from NGO and R&R Officer at site. Information will be

disseminated through printed leaflets/ information booklets that would be prepared by

the RAP & TDP Implementation Support Agency in local language. These would be

distributed not only to PAPs but also to people (residents, businessmen and others)

within the immediate project influence area and the local community in advance so

that people discuss issues among themselves and prepare themselves for the meetings.

The leaflet/ information booklet would provide the following:

brief description of the project and its objectives;




a summary of adverse impacts (including land acquisition, and impacts on

common property resources, etc);

act under which land has been acquired;

resettlement & rehabilitation provisions of the project and specific benefits

available to vulnerable communities;

ways and means of involving local communities;

expectations from local communities;

role of NGO/Consultancy firm and RRO; and

Grievance redresses mechanisms, suggestion and complain handling mechanism,

etc.

On the day of public meeting, once again leaflets would be distributed among the

people present for dissemination of information so as to ensure that all present at the

meeting, get to know about the project in case they did not get the leaflet/ information

booklet.

The team of NGO/Consultancy firm will have women and tribal members while

carrying out consultations. Separate/additional consultations/interactions with the

women, tribal and other vulnerable groups shall be organized.

In the first three months of the RAP&TDP implementation, at least 3 rounds of

consultations will be carried out at those locations where project is likely to cause

adverse impacts. After verification of PAPs, list of PAPs will be displayed in the

concerned village/town. In the consultation meetings various aspects covered in the

RPF will be explained for better understanding of the people in general and PAPs in

particular. It is expected that people would have several questions and doubts which

require clarifications. The forum will provide a platform to discuss those questions

and clear doubts. Consultations with people at frequent intervals would improve their

understanding about the project, importance of their participation and also the likely

benefits associated with the project. Further, one to one consultations with PAPs will

also be carried out by the RAP & TDP implementation agency to inform the extent of

impact, explain the entitlement, importance of identity card, opening of joint account,

mechanisms for grievance redress, and also providing suggestions and complaints.




Micro plan approved by the project authority will be placed in concerned villages

with panchayat office for review and to minimize grievances. Every item contained in

the micro plan shall be explained to the satisfaction of PAPs so as to minimize any

grievance at a later stage or to address information gaps. Further, consultations at

household level will be undertaken for skill improvement training purpose, use of

compensation amount and livelihood restoration.

In addition to the above, the Social Officer (at State Level) shall separately organize

information dissemination and consultation meetings every quarterly in the project

stretch. In the consultation meetings various aspects of the project would be explained

and also the status of the project (technical, social & environmental)would be

revealed. PAPs, local community and others would be given opportunity to discuss

issues and seek clarifications in context of the project. It is expected that regular

interactions with PAPs and local community directly and through NGO/Consultancy

firm would help build good rapport with them. Printed leaflets/ information booklets

would be prepared by the Social Officer for distribution in the project area. The

Social Officer will play lead role to explain various aspects of the project, importance

of consultations and also seek their participation and co-operation in the project. The

RAP&TDP implementation agency will help and assist the Social Officer (Project

Authority) organizing information dissemination and consultation meetings without

any additional financial implications. For wider publicity of the consultation meetings

similar procedure shall be followed. In addition, government officials in the

surrounding areas shall be officially invited to participate in the meetings.

A Minutes of Meeting would be prepared and read out to people present in the

meeting. The Minutes of Meeting would be signed by the officials and some of the

participants present and will be kept in project file documentation purpose.




CHAPTER – 11

MONITORING AND EVALUATION (M&E)

11.1 INTRODUCTION

Monitoring and Evaluation are integral part of the World Bank assisted development

projects. Monitoring is periodical checking of planned activities and provides midway

inputs, facilitates changes, and provides feedback to project authority to keep the

programme on schedule. Evaluation on the other hand, is essentially a summing up,

the end of the project assessment of whether those activities actually achieved the

intended aims. Thus monitoring and evaluation are critical in order to measure the

project performance and fulfillment of project objectives.

The monitoring and evaluation for the proposed project will ensure monitoring of key

indicators on inputs, outputs, project processes and evaluation of impact indicators.

The overall purpose of the monitoring is to keep track of the implementation

processes and progress, achievement of performance targets fixed in the annual work

plans, learning lessons and taking corrective actions to deal with emerging constraints

and issues. Monitoring and evaluation will constitute the following:

Sample study;

Monitoring of Inputs, Implementation Progress and Outputs through a

Management Information System (MIS);

Periodic Reviews and thematic Studies;

Process documentation (case studies and lessons learnt); and

Impact evaluation.




11.2 INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENT FOR M & E

The project authority will be responsible for carrying out M&E. Internal monitoring

will be carried out by the LA cum Social Development Officer of Project Co-

ordination Unit with assistance from R&R officer and NGO whereas external

monitoring and evaluation will be carried by a third party. The intuitional

arrangement for external monitoring and evaluation is covered in the RPF. It will

engage services of an external agency (third party) to carry out monitoring and

evaluation. This will help monitor project activities closely. Regular monitoring by

undertaking site visits, reviewing civil contractors work, women and gender issues etc

will help identify potential difficulties and problems faced in the project

implementation and subsequently help take timely corrective measures including

deviations, if needed.

Monitoring will start from the next month as soon as the NGO is mobilized at site for

implementation of RAP. Components of monitoring will include performance

monitoring i.e., physical progress of the work and impact monitoring and external

evaluation. Indicators that would be monitored related to performance are provided in

the following sections. However, if during the project implementation some other

indicators are found relevant those shall be included.

11.3 PROCESS & PERFORMANCE MONITORING

Process monitoring would enable the project authority to assess the whether the due

process are being followed or not, whereas performance monitoring would mainly

relate to achievement in measurable terms against the set targets. Monitoring report

will also provide necessary guidance and inputs for any changes, if required. A list of

indicators is given in Table 11.1.

Table 11.1: Performance Monitoring for RAP Implementation*

S.

No.

Indicators Target Achievement

as of date

Remarks

1 Land area acquired (ha)




S.

No.

Indicators Target Achievement

as of date

Remarks

2 No. of public consultations meetings held

for dissemination of information and

awareness about entitlements and R&R

Policy

3 Verification of PAPs

4 Measurement of immovable properties by

certified valuer

5 No. of EPs for whom micro plan submitted

for approval

6 Identity cum entitlement card distributed

7 No. of public consultations meetings held

w. r. to relocation/rehabilitation of CPR

8 No. of EPs received resettlement

assistance

9 No. of families relocated themselves, if

displaced

10 Number of EPs re-established their

business

11 No of EPs covered under income

generation schemes

12 No. of persons provided training

13 No. of CPRs relocated

14 Outlay for R&R activities

15 Expenditure incurred on R&R activities

16 No. of grievance received, GRC meeting

held and cases resolved

* Sample only




11.4 EVALUATION

The Project Authority will engage services of an external agency (third party), which

will undertake independent concurrent evaluations at least twice a year during the

project implementation period. At the end of the project, an impact evaluation will be

carried out as part of the project completion report. Such independent evaluation will

focus on assessing whether the overall objectives of the project have been met and

will use the defined impact indicators as a basis for evaluation. The evaluation will be

carried out under a set term of reference. The evaluation study would involve both

quantitative and qualitative surveys and compare results before and after the

implementation of the project. It will focus on assessing whether the overall

objectives of the project are being met and will use the defined impact indicators as a

basis for evaluation. The evaluation study would undertake the following but not

limited to:

Review monthly progress report submitted by RAP & TDP Implementation

Agency;

Undertake consultations with PAPs in order to understand their reactions, gather

information about distribution of policy leaflet, understanding of entitlement by

PAPs, delivery of identity cum entitlement card, adequacy of dissemination of

information, consultations meetings with regard to policy and eligibility for

entitlement, alternatives and relocation related issues, measurement and valuation

of affected property, understanding and use of grievance procedure, disbursement

of assistance, behavior of RAP & TDP Implementation Agency staff, availability

of RAP & TDP Implementation Agency staff, level of satisfaction as regards the

work of RAP & TDP Implementation Agency, and other R&R related issues,

compliance of resettlement policy, deployment of RAP & TDP Implementation

Agency‘s staff, monitor the gender issues and its mitigation etc;

Carry out sample survey (25%) for making comparative analysis and also conduct

qualitative surveys to substantiate quantitative survey analysis, etc.




It is important to mention here that one of the key objectives of the project is

improvement or at least restoration of economic status of the PAPs to the pre project

level. An illustrative list of indicators is given in Table 11.2 which would be

measured against the baseline data collected for the preparation of RAP. The M&E

agency would finally select the indicators for the evaluation of the project depending

upon the progress of R&R activities.

Table 11.2: Impact Indicators*

S.

No. Indicator

Uni

t

Pre

Project

Status

After

Project

Implementat

ion

1 Monthly income of family/household (Rs.) Av.

2 Number of earning members/family Av.

3 Vulnerable families/ households No.

4 Family under debt No.

5 Size of loan (Rs.) Av.

6 Change in occupation of head of household No.

7 Landless households No.

8 Households with various sizes of land No.

9 Size of land holding Av.

10 Ownership/tenancy of dwelling units (owner,

encroacher, squatter)

%

11 Type of dwelling units (Pucca, semi-Pucca,

Kutcha, etc)

%

12 Access to water and sanitation facilities %

13 Access to modern sources of lighting &

cooking

%

14 Changes in occupation %

15 Ownership of transport and farm

implements/household

Av.

16 Animal & poultry birds/ households Av.

17 Consumer Durables/ Material Assets owned Av.

18 Migration for employment % * Sample Only

11.5 REPORTING




The Monthly Progress Report shall be prepared by the Implementation agency.

QuarterlyProgress Reports shall be prepared by LA cum SDO, and six monthly

progress reports shall be prepared by M&E agency. Evaluation Report shall be

prepared by the M&E agency at the end of the project implementation as part of the

project completion report.




CHAPTER 12

IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENT AND SCHEDULE

12.1 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENT

Involuntaryresettlementisasensitiveproblemand experienceinR&R matterswillbe

requiredbythe

PIU,R&RCell.AgoodrapportwiththeaffectedcommunitywillfacilitateasatisfactoryR&R

ofthe PAPsandminimizedisturbance

particularlyphysicalandeconomic.Toovercomethisdeficiency, experiencedandwell-

qualified Implementation Support

AgencyinthisfieldwillbeengagedtoassisttheM/ORT&H inthe

implementationoftheRAP.

ThissectionparticularlydetailstheroleofImplementation Support

Agency.TheImplementation Support AgencywillworkasalinkbetweenthePIU- R&Rand

the affectedcommunity.The Implementation Support Agencywilleducatethe PAPsonthe

needtoimplementthe Project,onaspectsrelatingtoLAandR&Rmeasures

andensuresproperutilizationofvarious

compensationsextendedtothePAPsundertheR&Rentitlementpackage.

NGOConsultancywill betofacilitate theresettlementprocess.Itsbroad objectivesWill

beto:

• EducatePAPsontheirrights,entitlements,andobligationsundertheRAP;

• Ensuringthat PAPsreceivetheirfullentitlements;

•

Whereoptionsareavailable,theNGOshallprovideadvicetoPAPsonrelativ

ebenefitsofeach option;

• AssistPAPsongrievanceredressalthroughthe establishedsystem;and

• Collect dataasrequiredanddecidedwithPIUtohelpPIUto

monitorandassessprogress;




InassistingthePAPstochooseamongdifferentoptionsavailabletothem,ananalysis

mustfirstbe madeoflikelybenefitsandpotentialrisksforeachoftheoptions.Conducting

thisanalysisisthe

responsibilityoftheM/oRT&H,incollaborationwiththeagencies(GovernmentorImpleme

ntation Support Agency) engagedin implementingthevariousactivities.

Followingsuchananalysis,therisksandbenefitsshallbe explained

tothePAPsandsufficient timegiventothemtomakeaninformed choice.Inchoosing

betweendifferentoptions,whetheritiscashcompensationorvariousrehabilitation

schemes,the MoRT&Hshallmakeuseofthebaselinesocio-economic

surveydata,andensurethatthosePAPs

consideredvulnerableareencouragedtochoosetheoptionsentailingthelowestrisk.

AsageneralprinciplefortheRAP,individualPAPswillbemonitored

toensurethattheyareableto regainorimprovetheirformersocio-economic

statusandqualityoflife.Ifitbecomesclearthatthe

assistancegivenundertheProjectisinsufficient

toobtainthisgoalwithinthelifeoftheresettlement program,thenconsideration

shouldbegiventowhetheradditionalassistanceorsupporttowards differentactivities

needbegiven.

Inordertocarryoutsuchtasks,theemployees oftheImplementation Support

Agencyaretobestationed intheprojectarea.

BesidescontactingthePAPsonanindividualbasistoregularlyupdatethebaselineinformatio

n, groupmeetingsandvillage-level meetingswillbeconductedbytheImplementation

Support Agencyonaregularbasis.The frequencies

ofsuchmeetingswilldependontherequirements ofthePAPsbutshouldoccuratleast

onceamonth.TheImplementation Support Agencywillhavetoencourageparticipation

ofindividualPAPsinsuchmeetingby

discussingtheirproblemsregardingLA,R&Randotheraspectsrelatingtotheirsocio-

economiclives. Suchparticipationwill makeit easiertofinda solutionacceptable toall

involved.




12.2 RAP & TDP IMPLEMENTATION

Theimplementation ofResettlementActionPlan(RAP)& Tribal Development Plan

(TDP) isprimarilyenvisaged,asaparticipatory

exercisewheretheconsultingImplementation Support Agencyisresponsible

fortheimplementationofRAPisexpectedtoplay aroleofsecondarystakeholder

orinotherwordstheimplementing agencywouldbeapartnerinthe wholeexercise.

The role of the implementing Implementation Support Agency would be to mitigate

the adverse effects of the project, both, from the MoRT&H perspective, to ensure

timely completion of the road construction, and, from the perspective of affected

people, to ensure that their rehabilitation process is taken up in a right spirit with a

comprehensive livelihood system and these people are able to take advantages of the

options available. The prime responsibility of the implementing agency is to ensure

that each and every eligible project affected person receive appropriate and due

entitlement within the overall framework of R&R policy and entitlement matrix and

the PAPs have improved (or at least restored) their previous standard of living by the

end of the RAP including TDP implementation process.

Theotherresponsibilitiesinclude:

• Workinginco-

ordinationwiththecumSDO/SDE(R&R),MoRT&H(alternativelycalledthe

SDSandassisthim/herincarryingouttheimplementationoftheRAP;

• Toco-ordinatewiththeDLCsandGRCsinimplementingtheRAP;

• Coordinate

themeetingsoftheDistrictlevelcommitteeforapprovalofthemicroplanswherever

required.

• Assist the SDSin undertaking all public meetings, information

campaigns at the

commencementoftheprojectandgivefullinformationtotheaffectedcommunity;

• TranslatetheR&Robjectives andguidelines




toimplementactionsformitigatingadverse impacts onthePAPs;

•

AssisttheEngineers(SupervisionConsultants)toensurethattheContractsc

omplywiththe

applicablelabourlaws(includingprohibitionofchildlabour)andgenderissues;

•

AssistthePIUand/ortheEngineersinensuringcompliancewiththesafety,he

althandhygiene

norms,andtheRAPactionsproposedforHIV/AIDSawareness/preventioncampaig

ns.

• Report to SDS on a monthly basis, and quarterly basis including physical and

financial progress,both in termsof quantitativeandqualitative aspectsandthe

problemsandissues addressed andtackledwiththePAPsandthesolutions

foundespecially focusing thewomen's issuestheirproblems

andwhathasbeendone(withintheframework oftheRAP)toensuretheir

participationin decision-makingas well as the options made available for them

to access economicopportunities,marketingandcredit.

• DatabasemanagementofthePAPs.

• Videographyanddigital photographycostrequiredforimplementationoftheRAP.

• FacilitatePAPsfortheIncomeGenerationSchemetrainingandtoensurethatthe

provisionsmadefortrainingcomponentarebestutilized.

12.3 STAGES OF RAP & TDP IMPLEMENTATION: A METHODOLOGICAL

FRAMEWORK

Theobjectiveoftheprojectistostrengthentheexistingroadinfrastructure

aimedateconomicand

socialdevelopmentoftheregion.Oneofthekeyactivitiesintheprojectcycleistheimplement

ation ofResettlementActionPlanwithanobjectiveofminimising

theadverseimpactoftheproject implementationon thelivesofpeoplelivingintheproject

area. The MoRT&HR&R policy envisagesthattheproject-affected




families(PAFs)aretoberesettledandrehabilitatedsothatthe

adverseimpactduetoproposedimprovement oftheroadgetsminimized. Thestepwise

methodology forimplementationoftheRAP including TDP hasbeenshown below

througha flowchart.

12.3.1 TrainingandCapacityBuildingofProjectStaff

Asa firststep,it isessentialtobuildthecapacityofourstaffi.e.TeamLeader,Supervisors,

Engineers,

Villagelevelworkersetc.Theaspectsoftrainingtobeimpartedwouldincludesocial

impactassessmentsurvey,conductingfocusgroupdiscussions,communityparticipation,

PRA/RRA, relocationofcommonpropertyresourcesetc.

12.3.2 FocusGroupDiscussion,AwarenessCampaignandDisseminationofInformation

InordertomaketheRAPimplementationprocesstransparentasperWBguidelines,aseriesof

FGDs/meetingsetc wouldbe organisedwith all stakeholdersfor disseminationof

information regardingrehabilitationprocessandentitlementframework.

TheRAPpolicywillbeprintedinHindi languageaswell

asEnglishandthesamewillbedistributedtothe PAFsinordertomakethe process

transparent.

12.3.3 Identification,verificationandupdatingofPAPCensus

Theworkincludeidentification, verificationandupdatingthatwillbedonethroughdoor-to-

door socio-economic

impactassessmentsurvey,throughpersonalinterviewofeachheadofthehousehold

ofPAPsbyfieldstaffunderthedirect supervisionoftheother

staffandoverallguidanceoftheTeam Leader.Theverifiedandupdatedinformation

ofPAPswillbeprocessedinthecomputerandthe

databaseforthesamewouldbecreatedwhichwouldalsohelpineffectivemonitoring

oftheoverall

processofresettlementactionplanimplementation.Thefinaloutputofthisexercisewouldbe

a profileofeachPAPwithsocio-economic

indicatorslikedemography,income,occupation,nature,




extent,valueoflosses,detailsofentitlementetc.Thisinformation

willbeusefulforpreparingand issuingidentitycardstothePAPs.

12.3.4 MicroPlansforNon-titleandTitle Holders

ThemicroplanswillbepreparedforTitleHolders(TH)andNon-title

Holders(NTH)(kiosks, squattersandtenant)aspertheentitlement matrix.

12.3.5 EntitlementcumIdentityCard

Inordertokeeptransparencyinsystem,theentitlement-cum-identitycardindicating

typeoflossand entitlementwill beprovidedtoeachPAF.

12.3.6 OpeningofBankAccountandDisbursementofAssistance

ThenextcriticalstepinthisprocesswouldbeintheformofassistancetotheMoRT&Hforopen

ing upofthebank accountofPAPs.Thebank accountwouldbeopenedinthejoint

nameofhusbandand wife.Theassistance

willbedisbursedonlyonthebasisoftherecommendationsofthefieldstaffand

MoRT&Hofficialsbasedonthecommunitycenteredtransparentmechanisms.

12.3.7 Measurement,valuationofprivatestructureandcommonpropertyresources

Oneoftheimportantaspectsoftheprojectasenvisaged

byuswouldbemeasurementandvaluation ofstructure.Themeasurement

andvaluationofdifferentstructureslikeprivatehouses,schools,

colleges,religiousstructuresliketemple,mosquewouldneedtobedonebyourengineeringte

am.

ThecurrentapplicableScheduleofRateswouldbethebasisforvaluationofthestructures.

The communitystructurewilleither

berelocatedtoanewareaandthecommunity'sdecisionswouldform

thebasisofrebuildingsuchstructures.

12.3.8 RehabilitationofAffectedFamiliesandRestorationofIncomeandLivelihood

RehabilitationofallthePAFsisoneofthecriticaltasksoftheprojectimplementationprocessi

n ordertohelpthecommunities derivethemaximum




benefitsoutoftheprojectwithoutlosingtheir livelihoodsandtheleastimpact onsocio-

culturalaspectsoftheirlives.Itincludeslivelihoodanalysis,

preparationandimplementationofacomprehensive

livelihoodsupportplananddevelopmentofa comprehensive

livelihoodsupportsystem.Thisprocessmustresultinimprovedoratleastrestored

livingstandards,earningcapacityorimprovethequalityoflifeofthepeopleaffectedbythepr

oject.

Accordingly,rehabilitationwillbeconceivedandshallbeimplementedasadevelopmentpro

gramme

withparticularattentiontotheneedsofwomenheadedhouseholdsandvulnerablegroups.

TheeffortoftheImplementation Support

AgencyshallbetoimprovethePAPseconomicproductive capacityandbuildingupa

permanent capacityforself-development.Oneofthekeystrategies

wouldbetofacilitateinclusion of PAPs,ifnotalreadyincluded,

intheexistingSelfHelpGroups(SHGs) withinthe locality/neighborhood.

ThemembersoftheexistingSHGsshallbepersuadedbytheImplementation Support

Agencyforthe

inclusionofthePAPs.TheotherwaywouldbetoformSHGsofPAPsexclusively

forupgrading/ restorationoflivelihood.SGSYisself-

employmentprogramforruralpoor.SHGsareformedbased

oncommoninterest.Theobjectiveoftheprogramistobringthe self-

employedabovepovertylineby

providingtheincomegeneratingassetsthroughbankcreditandgovernment

subsidy.Formation of SHGofPAPsexclusively,

wouldbepossiblewhereenoughPAPsareavailable.

Organizingtheeconomicactivitieswould beaccordingtotheskills

possessedbytheaffectedfamilies and in case the affected PAFs wants to shift to other

suitable /viable economic activity for

enhancementoftheirlivelihood,thecorrespondingskillupgradationtrainingwouldbearran




gedby theImplementation Support

AgencyinaccordancewiththeentitlementwiththehelpofPIU(MoRT&H)&DistrictAuthor

ity‖. ThePAPswillbefreetochoosetoactasindividuals

orasinformalgroupslikeSHGsforaccessing

credit,MilkProducerGroups(MPGs),AgricultureCommodities

(likevegetable,pulse,wheat) ProcessingGroupsetcorasco-operatives,

withtheiroveralloperatingefficiencyandviabilityofthe

livelihoodoptionschosenbythem.Thecostforimpartingnecessarytrainingforlivelihoodan

d IncomeupgradationisincludedinR&Rbudget.

Incontextofthesocio-economicprofileoftheregion,theirexistingactivitybaseandtheskills,

effortswillalsobemadetoensurethatthe groupsare

resettledinamannersothattheirbackwardand forwardlinkagesintheactivitiesperformed

bythemaremaintained andtheyareprovided supportin

improvingtheirincomethroughsupportofothergovernmentsponsoredprogramsalso.

12.3.9 IECforHIV/AIDS

One of the important objectives of the project is to reduce the vulnerabilityon health

aspect especially,HIV/AIDS.Officialsof Rajasthan

StateAIDSControlSociety(RSACS)inthe projectdistricts

wereconsulted.Itwasinformedthatseveralhealthawarenessprogrammeswith thehelp

ofNGOsare

beingimplementedintheprojectarea.Besides,aninterventionprojectfundedbyNationalAi

ds controlOrganization(NACO)isbeingimplementation

withthehelpofNGOsintheproject

influencearea.Theyalsohaveservicesavailablefortestingandtreatmentwithspecialfocuso

nthe womenandtheyouth.

Undertheprojectawarenessgeneration aboutHIV/AIDS

alongtheprojectroadsection(covering

schools,Dhabas,publicplaces,busstops,andothersuitablelocations)hasbeen




includedasone ofthe importantcomponents

oftheproject.Theresponsibilityofcarryingouttheawarenessgeneration

activitiesonHIV/AIDShasbeenincludedinthescopeofworkofImplementation Support

Agency. TheImplementation Support Agencyengaged forthe

implementationofRAPwithsupportfromPIU,willestablish

contactandcollaboratewithconcerned agencies(SACO/NACO

&DistrictAdministration) toextendtheadvantageoftheon-going programmes

(awarenessgenerationactivitiesandholdingofcamps)alongtheprojectroadsection

targetingroadusers,laboursites/campsoftheroadproject,truckers,local people,etc.

12.4 STEPS IN IMPLEMENTATION- LIST OF ACTIVITIES

12.4.1 SiteVisits/ Verification

1. VerificationofPAPsandconductingsurveyofleft outPAPs,ifany.

2. Visitby theteammembersforrapportbuildingwiththecommunity

3. Measurementofstructures,propertyandassetsforvaluation

4. DigitalphotographyofeachstructureandassetswithinRoW.

5.

Preparationofinventoryofassets(privateproperty,commonpropertyresou

rcesetc).

12.4.2 IECActivitiesandAwarenessCampaign

1. PreparationanddistributionofR&Rpolicydocument/ information

leafletstothePAPs(Bilingualpolicy document) Hindi especially highlighting

the need for the project and its impact, entitlementpackagesetc.

2. OrganizeawarenesscampaignsforsharinginformationonRAPwithindividualsand

groupsofPAPsusingparticipatorytoolsandapproachesasapartoftheinitialaswella

s on-goingconsultationexercise.

3. Confidence building measures through participatory process with the

community and individuals affected by the project especially involving

women to ensure smooth eviction during the resettlement process.




4. Consultation meetings with the contractors and their project staff including

construction labours to understand the socio-cultural profile.

5. Developing messages and training material for awareness campaigns on HIV/

AIDS.

6. Organize awareness campaigns for the construction labours on HIV/ AIDS.

12.4.3 LandandBuildingValuationandDistributionofI-Cards

1. Evolvinglandandbuildingvaluationmethods

2. Measurement and valuation of land and structures (private buildings,

community structures,treesetc.)

3. Preparationofentitlement/ compensationandassistancedetails

fortheTHandNTH.

4. PhotographyoftheentitledPAPsforpreparationanddistribution

ofentitlement-cum- identitycardtotitleholdersandnon-titleholders.

12.4.4 Micro-PlansandAssistanceDisbursement

1. PreparationofMicroPlans(Non-titleholders)

2. Preparationof microplan(Title holders)

3. Openingofbankaccount

4.

InformingEPsabouttheirentitlement,creatingawarenessontheroleofDLRC

C and GRC, procedureforgrievancesapplication

etcandrecordingofthegrievances, ifany,andits

representationtotheDLRCC and GRCalongwiththeaffectedperson.

5. Disbursementofentitlement/compensation/assistance.

12.4.5 RehabilitationProcess

1. Livelihoodanalysis/optionsforPAPs/PDPs.

2. Identificationoftrainingneeds(TrainingNeedsAssessment).

3. FormationofSavings/SelfHelpGroups(SHGs)




4. Vocational

trainings,skillupgradationtrainingsetcbasedonthemicroplans,livelihood

analysisandidentifiedtrainingneeds.

12.4.6 Submission of Completion Report

Below given is the activities wise Impletion Schedule: Flow Chart in table 12.1.



MoRT&H 12-22

Table:12.1ActivitywiseImplementationSchedule-FlowChart

TheactivitiesgivenintheimplementationSchedulearethebriefdescriptionoftheactivitystatementsdetailedoutasapartoftheactivitylistgiveninthe sectiononapproachandmethodology.

Sl.

No. Activity MonthwiseProgram

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30

A PreparatoryActivities

1. Collection and review of

RAP Report & other

relevant documents

2. Reconnaissancesurveyand

rapport building with

community &district

3. Training of RRO and

project staff for

familiarizationwith RAP

report

4. Orientation training of

project staff (Supervisors/)

on the RAP

5. SubmissionofIdentification

andVerificationReportfor NTH

6. SubmissionofIdentification andVerificationReportfor

Titleholders

C IEC and Awareness

Campaign



MoRT&H 12-23

Sl.


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30

7. Preparationanddistribution ofR&Rpolicydocumentto thePAPs

8. Organize awareness Campaigns for sharing

informationonRAP

9. Confidence building

Measures through

participatory process

10. Consultation meetings

with

projectstaff,contractorsand

labours

11. Developing messages

and training material for

awarenessonHIV/AIDS

12. Organize awareness

campaigns for

construction

laboursonHIV/ AIDS

D Establishment of

DLC/GRC

E Land and Building

Valuation

13. Evolvinglandandbuilding

valuationmethods

14. Measurement & valuation

of land and structures (private /community etc.)



MoRT&H 12-24

Sl.


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30

15 Photography of EPs for

distribution of

entitlement- cum- identity

Cards

F Micro Plans &

Disbursement

16. PreparationofMicroPlans (Non-title holders)

17. PreparationofMicroPlans

(Title holders)

18. Openingofbankaccountin

joint names for

disbursement

19 Informing EPs about

entitlement, DLC/ GRC,

grievances application

20. Disbursement of

entitlement/

compensation/ assistance

G Community Welfare

measures for SC&ST

populated villages

21 Conducting of

consultations for provision

of community works in

identified SC and ST

villages and passing of

resolution

22

Preparation of micro plan

and approval for

community works (in two

batches)



MoRT&H 12-25

Sl.


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30

23 Holding of health

awareness, check up

camps and other events

under community works

24 Information regarding

jobs and provision of

labor opportunities by

Contractor with

preference to vulnerable

PAHs and Tribals -

Intermittently

H Rehabilitation Process

25 Livelihood

analysis/options

for PAPs/ PDPs

26 Identification of training

Needs (Training Needs

Assessment)

27 Formation of Savings/

Self Help Groups (SHGs)

28 Vocational, skill up

gradation trainings based

on the micro plans etc.

I Monitoring and

Evaluation

J Completion Process

29 Submission of

Completion Report



MoRT&H 13-1

CHAPTER - 13

GRIEVANCEREDRESSALMECHANISM

13.1 GRIEVANCE REDRESSAL MECHANISM

The GRC will be constituted by the Project Authority with the aim to settle as many

disputes as possible on LA and R&R through consultations and negotiations. There will

be one GRC for each PIU. The GRC will comprise five members headed by a retired

Magistrate not below the rank of SDM. Other members of the GRC will include a retired

PWD Officer (not below the rank of Executive Engineer), RRO, representative of PAPs

and Sarpanch (Elected Head of Village) of the concerned village. Grievances of PAPs in

writing will be brought to GRC for redressal by the RAP& TDP implementation agency.

The RAP& TDP implementation agency will provide all necessary help to PAPs in

presenting his/her case before the GRC. The GRC will respond to the grievance within 15

days. The GRC will normally meet once in a month but may meet more frequently, if the

situation so demands. A time period of 45 days will be available for redressing the

grievance of PAPs. The decision of the GRC will not be binding to PAPs. This means the

decision of the GRC does not debar PAPs taking recourse to court of law, if he/she so

desires. Broad functions of GRC are as under:

Record the grievances of PAPs, categorize and prioritize them and provide solution to

their grievances related to resettlement and rehabilitation assistance.

The GRC may undertake site visit, ask for relevant information from Project

Authority and other government and non-government agencies, etc in order to resolve

the grievances of PAPs.

Fix a time frame within the stipulated time period of 45 days for resolving the

grievance.

Inform PAPs through implementation agency about the status of their case and their

decision to PAPs and Project Authority for compliance.

The GRC will be constituted within 3 months by an executive order from competent

authority (centre/ state) from the date of mobilization of RAP implementation agency.

The RRO will persuade the matter with assistance from implementation agency in



MoRT&H 13-2

identifying the suitable persons from the nearby area for the constitution of GRC.

Secretarial assistance will be provided by the PIU as and when required.

Figure – 13.2: Grievance Redressal Mechanism

Grievance Redressal Mechanism

BROAD F U N C T I O N S

RECORD, CATEGORIZE

AND PRIORITISE

GRIEVANCES

CONVEY DECISION OF

GRC TO PAPS IN

WRITING

DECISIONS OF GRC MEETING IS

DRAFTED

Gri

evances

Redre

ssed

PIU

ORG

AN

IZES G

RC

MEETIN

G PIU CO-ORDINATES WITH

GRC&PAPS

Gri

evances

Not

Redre

ssed

NGO INITIATES NECESSARY

PREPARATION TO ASSIST PAPS

RRO CHECK GRIEVANCE &

CATEGORIZE AND INFORM NGO

AND FOR CASES TO BE

REFERRED TO GRC

PAPS LODGE GRIEVANCE TO

PIU DIRECTLY OR TO R&R

OFFICER IN WRITING WITH A

COPY TO NGO

POTENTIAL GRIEVANCES OF

PAPS

GRC MINUTES PREPARED AND

SIGNED BY MEMBERS

GRC DECISIONS CONVEYED TO

PAPS IN WRITING

GRC DECISION SENT TO

PA/EA FOR INFORMATION &

COMPLIANCE

BACK TO RRO FOR

IMPLEMENTATION

RAP IA TO INITIATE ACTION PAPS GRIEVANCE MET

OPTIONS TO MOVE COURT

P R O C E S S

UNDERTAKE FIELD

VISITS, ASK FOR

RELEVANT PAPERS,

ETC AS REQUIRED

FIX A TIMEFRAME TO

RESOLVE THE

GRIEVANCE WITHIN

STIPULATED TIME

PERIOD



MoRT&H 13-3

13.2 Suggestion and Complaint Handling Mechanism (SCHM)

The design of NHIIP is complex and its geographical scale is immense, and the project is

expected to have a wide array of enquiries, comments, suggestions as well as face some

operational risks. MORTH is working to establish a sound Suggestion and Complaint

Handling Mechanism (SCHM) for NHIIP to address and handle external and internal

inquiries, suggestions and comments, and concerns/complaints/ grievances as well as

improve accountability and service delivery under NHIIP.

SCHM Users: The users of SCHM could be anyone from the project stakeholders,

including civil servants (from MORTH, State PWDs, or from other State Departments)

PIUs, contractors, consultants, project affected people (communities), road users,

CSOs/NGOs, any other public, who realizes either impact from or relation to the

concerned project.

Management of SCHM: The overall responsibility for the operation and management of

NHIIP‘s SCHM will rest with the EAP MoRTH. The NHIIP‘s SCHM will be handled at

three levels: at the State‘s, MORTH‘s level, and project level.

Since all pre-construction and civil works will be implemented and managed by the

States, all enquiries, suggestions and complaints related to a specific road will be

submitted to the concerned implementing agency at the State Level. Each PCU at the

State level is to set up a toll free number and/or email account for the project stakeholders

and general public to submit their enquiries, suggestions and complaints. The toll free

number and email account are to be displayed at the sign boards at the start and end of

each project road. The bidding documents will have a requirement for the contractor to

put in place signs at the start and end of the project road which will display the toll free

number and email account to submit enquiries, suggestions and complaints to the

concerned implementing government agency. Similarly, inquiries, suggestions, or

complaints related to specific roads can also be submitted to project authority as well, but

the project authority will encourage complainants to send their queries/concerns directly



MoRT&H 13-4

to the PCU or EAP authorities. In whichever level the queries are submitted, a due

recording and documentation will be carried out by the respective authorities.

The EAP head will be in charge of assigning the responsible person/entity to address and

handle enquiry, suggestion or complaint submitted at the MORTH‘s level. However,

within his/her team he/she will assign an officer (engineer) who will be responsible for

coordinating inquiries/comments and complaints/ concerns/grievances. His/her

responsibilities will include:

To respond to as many inquiries/comments as possible

To receive and sort concerns/grievances

To forward them to appropriate team members for resolution as per

recommendation of the EAP Head

To track/monitor complaint/grievance acknowledgement and resolution

To review and report on complaint/grievance data and trends to the MoRT&H

EAP Head, who in turn will report to Central Vigilance Officer (CVO),

MoRT&H, NHIIP Project Oversight Committee, and World Bank.

After receiving complaints, the complainants will be informed within three weeks about

the status of the complaints and what action will be taken further.

Channels: The following channels should be established to receive inquiries/comments

and concerns /grievances:

Toll free phone

Email

On-line form

Regular post/mail

Suggestion box/Walk-ins

It is critical to assign a specific e-mail ID and a phone/fax number, and to set up an easy-

to-access suggestion box and walk-in office. The project website will have a permanent

sub-window that will contain an on-line form and facilitates grievance/complaint

collection.



MoRT&H 13-5

On-line Form for Suggestions and Complaints: The on-line form for suggestions and

complaints will be provided on the NHIIP website. The form will contain only three

entries as outlined below.

Subject: ______________________

NHIIP Road: ____________________

Content: _______________________

Your email: _____________________

Suggestions/complaints submitted through this on-line form is to go directly to (a) the

EAP Head‘s email account and (b) internal reporting system for SCHM (excel file).

SCHM Reporting Format: The internal reporting system for SCHM (excel file) will

have the following entries/columns:

1. Date

2. Subject

3. Road

4. Content

5. Email (of the complainant)

6. Acknowledgment date (Date when EAP sent an email to the complainant to

acknowledge that the email has been received, the issue will be handled within

that period of time and the response/feedback will be provided to the complainant

by that deadline)

7. Responsible Person

8. Deadline for Feedback

9. Actual Date for Feedback

10. Solution/Feedback on the Suggestion/Complaint

11. Additional Comment (e.g., if the person was unsatisfied with the

feedback/solution provided and indicated that he/she will go to another authority

to complain)

The entries 1-5 should be filled in automatically once an on-line form is submitted. The

other entries are to be entered manually by the EAP and each State-level PIU. All



MoRT&H 13-6

SCHM-related reports are to be consolidated by the EAP. The concerned Nodal Officer is

SE, NH/PWD cum Nodal Officer, Jaipur. The contact number is +919889137402.



MoRT&H 14-1

CHAPTER 14

REHABILITATION & RESETTLEMENT BUDGET

14.1 R&RBUDGET

BasedontheEntitlementMatrix,theR&Rbudgetforthe Pratapgarh-Padi

h a s finalizedandispresentinginTablebelow.Itcomprisesoftwobroadcomponents

namelycompensationandassistance.

ThetotalR&Rbudgetforthe project worksouttoRs.8983.49lakh ofwhich

Rs.8045.26 lakhs istowardscompensationforlandandstructures. R&R

Assistance cost of the project (Pratapgrah -Padi section NH-113) is

Rs. 938.23lakhs. Thedetailsofthebudgetasperthe entitlementmatrix

andtheLAPlanaresummarizinginTable14.1 below. TheBreak-upofCost of

PrivateLand acquisitionworkedoutasperagreed RPF for the overall

projectispresentedinTable14.2&14.3

Table14.1:R&RBudget

S.No

. ITEMS Unit

Cost/unit

inRs.

Total

Units

Area/

Number

Compensation

inLakh. Assistance in

Lakh

A Land Acquisition Compensation including solarium amount

@ 60%andcent ages

Ha AsperLA Plan 40

lakh/Ha

52.629 5958.63

Additional ex-gratia amount for the Affected

personlosinganylandareabeyond250sq

[email protected](para

7.19 NRRP 2007)

Sq m @Rs.80 sqm

25960

-- 20.76

Additional ex-gratia amount of Rs

20,000/-forthoselosinglandupto250

sqmt.(para7.19NRRP2007)

No. of Households

@Rs.20,000

260 -- 52.0



MoRT&H 14-2

S.No

. ITEMS Unit

Cost/unit

inRs.

Total Units

Area/

Number

Compensation


Lakh

Assistance for landholder becomes

landlessoris reducedtothestatusofa

―small‖or ―marginal‖ farmer, rehabilitation

allowance equivalent to

750daysofminimumagricultural wages wouldalsobegiven.(para7.14,NRRP-

2007)=750x175=

No. of Households

@Rs175/- for 750 days

150 -- 196.87

SubTotalA

5958.63 269.63

B ReplacementCostforStructures *Titleholders &Non-Titleholders

Permanent Structures- 9099.33 sqm sqm Rs500/- 44 2001.85 --

Semi-permanent Structures-1285.60 sqm sqm Rs350/- 18 80.99 --

Temporary Structures-303.60 sqm sqm Rs250/- 5 3.79 --

Sub Total B

2086.63 --

C Assistance for title holders

Monthly subsistence / transitional





Household 300 days @

Rs 175/-

32 -- 16.80

Shifting allowance to PAFs as one-time

financial assistance of Rs 10,000 as per

(para 7.10 NRRP 2007).

Household @Rs10,000 32 -- 3.20

Sub Total C -- 20.00

D Assistance to Squatters & Encroachers

Monthly subsistence/transitional





Household 300 days

@Rs175/-

29 -- 15.22


financial assistance of Rs 10,000 as per

(para 7.10 NRRP 2007).

Household 10,000 29 -- 2.90



MoRT&H 14-3

S.No

. ITEMS Unit

Cost/unit

inRs.

Total Units

Area/

Number

Compensation


Lakh

House construction assistance for those

belong to vulnerable groups equivalent to

the latest construction cost of Indira Awas

Yojana Scheme for Rural Areas (Effective

from 01.04.2004) Department of Rural

Development Krishi Bhawan, Ministry of

Rural Development New Delhi

Household Rs25,000 304 -- 76.00

Additional Support to Vulnerable Group

One time additional financial assistance

equivalent to 300 days of minimum

agricultural wages to all vulnerable

Household @Rs175 for

300 days

304 -- 159.60

Additional Support to ST affected family

shall get an additional one time financial

assistance equivalent to two hundred days

of minimum agricultural wages for loss of

customary rights or usage of

forestproduce (para 7.21.5 NRRP 2007).

Household @Rs175 for

200 Days

225 -- 78.75

Sub Total D -- 332.47

E Assistance to Kiosks (commercial

structures)


financial assistance of Rs 10000/- for

assistance for Kiosks

10000 6 -- 0.60

Sub Total E -- 0.60

F Other Assets Relocation of Religious Structures LS 250000 5 - 12.50 Compensation for School LS 500000 3 - 15.00 Compensation for Government Building LS 500000 3 - 15.00

Sub Total F - 42.50

G Training Training for PAFs (Title Holder &Non-

Title Holder)

Household 5000 (per

person)

414 -- 20.70

Training of M/MoRT&H,

PIU, Supervision Consultants and NGO/

staff

Lump sum -- 10.00

Sub Total G 30.70

H Support for RAP Implementation Fee of M&E Consultants Estimated 45.00

NGO/Consultancy firm Estimated 90.00

Sub Total H 135.00

I Provision for Value Added Work in

villages with more than 50% SC and ST

Estimated 80.00

Sub Total I 80.00

J TOTAL (Sum A to I) 910.90



MoRT&H 14-4

S.No

. ITEMS Unit

Cost/unit

inRs.

Total Units

Area/

Number

Compensation


Lakh

K Contingencies 3% of J 27.33

8045.26 938.23

L Grand Total 8983.49

*Does not include area of Common Property Resources (CPRs)

14.1.1 CompensationCostforLandAcquisition:TheCostof PrivateLandacquisitionhas

been worked outasperapplicable Entitlement Matrix for NHIIP projects and is

presentedinTable14.2.

Table 14.2 Estimate for Land Acquisition for Pratapgarh- Padi NH 113

S. No Description Cost (Rs in Lakhs)

1. Cost of Land Acquisition based on current circle rate 2105.16

2. Adding 50% as per Entitlement Matrix 1052.58

Total (1+2) ―A‖ 3157.74

3. Adding 60%Solarium of ―A‖ as per Entitlement

Matrix

1894.64

4. Total (A+3) ―B‖ 5052.38

5. Interest @ 12% for one year on ―B‖ 606.28

6 Departmental Charges 9 % of ―A‖ 284.19

7. Contingency Charges 0.5% on ―A‖ 15.78

Grand Total Cost for Land Acquisition 5958.63

Total R&R Budget including acquisition of land works out to Rs. 8983.49lakhs for

proposed project.

ANNEXURE

Annexure 1.1

List of Forest along the Road Stretch

S. No. Existing Location (Km) Forest

Category Length Side

From To

1 106+100 116+170 Reserved 10.070 B/S

2 136+490 138+855 Reserved 2.365 L/S

3 147+715 148+255 Reserved 0.540 B/S

List of type of Terrain along the Road Stretch

S. No.

Existing Km

Terrain From To

1 Km 80/000 Km 85/000 Plain

2 Km 85/000 Km 86/000 Mountainous

3 Km 86/000 Km 110/000 Rolling

4 Km 110/000 Km 115/000 Mountainous

5 Km 115/000 Km 160/000 Rolling

6 Km 160/000 Km 180/000 Plain

List of Water Bodies along the Road Stretch

S. No. Existing Km SIDE

1. 149+000 LHS

2. 176+500 LHS

3. 163+000 LHS

4. 166+300 LHS

5. 168+650 LHS

Annexure 1.2

Existing RoW Details

Pratapgrah-Padi Section NH-113

S No Single/ Intermediate/

2-Lane Chainage

ROW as per

Revenue Map

Intermediate

Lane/2 Lane

From

(Km) To (km) 10m-55m

1 Intermediate Lane 80+000 80+500 26m - 55m







































2-Lane Chainage

ROW as per

Revenue Map































69 Intermediate Lane 114+000 114+500 26m - 30.m
















2-Lane Chainage

ROW as per

Revenue Map



























110 2 Lane 134+500 135+000 9m - 22m

111 2 Lane 135+000 135+500 12m - 22m

112 2 Lane 135+500 136+000 11m - 19m

113 2 Lane 136+000 136+500 16m - 22m

114 2 Lane 136+500 137+000 13m - 26m














128 Intermediate/2- Lane 143+500 144+000 15m - 29m


2-Lane Chainage

ROW as per

Revenue Map

129 2-Lane 144+000 144+500 7m - 24m

130 2-Lane 144+500 145+000 13m - 30m

131 2-Lane 145+000 145+500 12m - 42m

132 2-Lane 145+500 146+000 14m - 43m

133 2-Lane 146+000 146+500 16m - 20m

134 2-Lane 146+500 147+000 15m - 18m

135 2-Lane 147+000 147+500 14m - 22m

136 2-Lane 147+500 148+000 14m - 20m

137 2-Lane 148+000 148+500 22m - 32m

138 Intermediate/2- Lane 148+500 149+000 27m - 31m






















160 Intermediate Lane 159+500 160+000

Banswara





165 2 lane 162+000 162+500

166 2 lane 162+500 163+000

167 2 lane 163+000 163+500

168 2 lane 163+500 164+000

169 2 lane 164+000 164+500

170 2 lane 164+500 165+000

171 2 lane 165+000 165+500

172 2 lane 165+500 166+000

173 2 lane 166+000 166+500


2-Lane Chainage

ROW as per

Revenue Map

174 2 lane 166+500 167+000 Bypass

175 2 lane 167+000 167+500

176 2 lane 167+500 168+000

177 2 lane 168+000 168+500

178 2 lane 168+500 169+000

179 2 lane 169+000 169+500

180 2 lane 169+500 170+000

181 2 lane 170+000 170+500

182 2 lane 170+500 171+000

183 2 lane 171+000 171+500

184 2 lane 171+500 172+000

185 2 lane 172+000 172+500

186 2 lane 172+500 173+000

187 2 lane 173+000 173+500 11m - 14m

188 2 lane 173+500 174+000 12m - 18m

189 2 lane 174+000 174+500 6m - 20m

190 2 lane 174+500 175+000 12m - 20m

191 2 lane 175+000 175+500 11m - 18m

192 2 lane 175+500 176+000 13m - 16m

193 2 lane 176+000 176+500 14m - 16m

194 2 lane 176+500 177+000 13m - 16m

195 2 lane 177+000 177+500 14m - 17m

196 2 lane 177+500 178+000 13m - 15m

197 2 lane 178+000 178+500 13m - 22m

198 2 lane 178+500 179+000 15m - 16m

199 2 lane 179+000 179+500 14m - 16m

200 2 lane 179+500 180+000 17m - 18m

Annexure 1.3

PRATAPGARH - PADI (NH-113)

Improvement of Deficient Horizontal Curve

S.

No.

Chainage Deficient Observed and

Remarks Improvement Proposed

From To

1 83470 83546 Deficient horizontal curve radius is less than 230m in Plain terrain

Propose to improve the deficient horizontal curve as per the minimum requirement of plain terrain along with the extra widening

2 85000 86102 Deficient horizontal curve (Hair Pin Bend) radius is less than 60m in mountainous terrain

Propose to Improve the hair pin bend along with the extra widening , provision of safety barrier and traffic signage

3 87030 87600 Deficient horizontal curve (Broken Back Curve) radius is less than 150m in Rolling terrain

Propose to improve broken back curve with a single curve and provision of extra widening with safety barriers

4 87800 88100 Deficient horizontal curve radius is less than 150m in rolling terrain

Propose to improve the deficient horizontal curve along with the extra widening

5 88500 89300 Deficient horizontal curves (Broken back curve)

Propose to improve the deficient geometry with single curve


Propose to improve the deficient horizontal curve radius within existing ROW for the speed of 80 km ph

7 90800 91600

Deficient horizontal curve radius is less than 150m in rolling terrain and submersible major bridge

Propose to improve the deficient curve and new construction of high level major bridge adjacent to the existing submersible major bridge


Propose to improve the deficient curve radius

9 97000 97120 Deficient horizontal curves (Reverse curves) radius is less than 150m in rolling terrain




11 98300 99500 Deficient horizontal curves (broken back curves) and submersible major bridge

Propose to improve the deficient (Broken back) curve and new construction of high level major bridge adjacent to the existing submersible major bridge



13 102600 103100 Deficient horizontal Curve (Broken back curve)

Propose to improve the broken back curve with single curve

14 108200 108500 Deficient horizontal Curve (Zig-Zag)

Propose to improve with single curve

15 108900 109250

Deficient horizontal curve radius is less than 60m in mountainous terrain. Site distance is also get obstructed due to road side vegetation & hill on both side

Propose to improve the deficient curve radius along with traffic signage





S.

No.



From To





20 116100 116600

Deficient horizontal curve radius is less than 150m in rolling terrain and submersible minor bridge

Propose to improve the deficient curve and new construction of high level minor bridge adjacent to the existing submersible major bridge

21 117600 117750 Deficient horizontal curve radius is less than 150m in rural area


22 121700 121900 Deficient horizontal curve radius is less than 150m in rural area


23 122000 122800 Deficient horizontal curve (Zigzag geometry) radius is less than 150m in rural area


24 123000 123200 Deficient horizontal curve radius less than 200m offering design speed of 55 km ph in rural areas

Propose to improve the deficient curve for the speed of 80 km ph with extra widening and traffic signage





27 124800 126400

Deficient horizontal curves radius less than 200m and two numbers of broken back curves in this stretch of rural areas

Propose to improve the deficient geometry

28 130000 130400

Deficient horizontal curve radius less than 150m offering design speed of 50 km ph in built-up areas of Khamrea town

Propose to improve the deficient geometry within existing ROW for design speed of 65 km ph

29 131200 131800

Deficient horizontal curve radius less than 150m offering design speed of 50 km ph in semi urban areas and submersible major bridge

Propose to improve deficient curve with new construction of major bridge adjacent to submersible major bridge


Propose to improve the broken back curve with single curve within existing ROW


Due to retained bridge at Ch 138710 and Ch 138754 not possible to improve the broken back curve and restrict speed of 64 km ph with proper signage provisions and safety barriers.


Due to habitation of Pandoli Village not possible to improve the broken back curve and restrict speed of 55 km ph with proper signage provisions with proper traffic signage and marking.

33 149200 149600 Deficient horizontal curve (zigzags geometry) in semi builtup area

Propose to improve deficient curve

S.

No.



From To

34 153500 153900

Deficient horizontal curve radius of 200m offering speed of 60 km ph speed in semi built-up area

Propose to improve deficient curve for the speed of 80 km ph

35 155400 154720 Deficient horizontal curve radius less than 120m in semi urban area

Propose to improve deficient curve for the speed of 80 km ph and also provision of extra widening

36 156100 156700 Deficient horizontal curve radius less than 120m in semi urban area and also broken back curve

Propose to improve broken back curve with a single curve and provision of extra widening

37 156900 157200

Deficient horizontal reverse curve radius less than 150m offering speed of 40 km ph and submersible minor bridge

Propose to improve horizontal curve with a single curve and new construction adjacent to submersible bridge

38 172800 173100 Deficient horizontal curve radius less than 100m offering speed of 45 kmph

Propose to improve deficient horizontal curve radius for speed of 80 km ph with traffic signage

39 173100 173500 Deficient horizontal curve radius less than 100m offering speed of 45 km ph

Propose to improve deficient horizontal curve radius for speed of 80 km ph with traffic signage


Due to habitation of Sagrod Village not possible to improve the broken back curve and restrict speed of 20 km ph with proper signage provisions with proper traffic signage and marking.

Annexure 1.4

Land Use Pattern along the Road Stretch

Existing Km Adjacent Land Use Pattern Village/

Town Name From To Left Right

80+000 80+700 builtup area builtup area Pratapgarh

80+700 81+500 agriculture agriculture

81+500 82+000 agriculture agriculture 82+000 82+335 barren agriculture 82+335 83+435 forest agriculture 83+435 83+500 agriculture + barren agriculture + barren 83+500 84+000 agriculture+ barren agriculture+ barren 84+000 84+500 barren agriculture + barren 84+500 85+000 barren agriculture + barren 85+000 85+500 forest+ forest 85+500 86+000 forest forest 86+000 86+500 agriculture + barren barren 86+500 87+000 agriculture + barren barren 87+000 87+500 agriculture + barren barren + builtup area Padliya 87+500 88+000 barren + builtup area barren + builtup area Padliya 88+000 88+500 barren+ builtup area barren+ builtup area Padiya 88+500 89+000 barren+builtup a rea barren + builtup area Kachotiya 89+000 89+500 barren barren + builtup area Kachotiya 89+500 90+000 barren barren 90+000 90+500 agriculture + barren agriculture+ barren 90+500 91+000 agriculture + barren agriculture + barren

91+000 91+500 agriculture agriculture Bara Mayanga

91+500 92+000 agriculture agriculture Bara Mayanga 92+000 92+500 agriculture agriculture Bara Mayanga 92+500 93+000 agriculture agriculture 93+000 93+500 barren + agriculture barren + agriculture 93+500 94+000 barren + agriculture barren + agriculture Chhayan 94+000 94+500 agriculture + barren agriculture + barren Chhayan 94+500 95+000 agriculture + barren agriculture + barren Suhagpura 95+000 95+500 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture Suhagpura 95+500 96+000 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture Suhagpura 96+000 96+500 builtup area + barren builtup area+ barren Madhav Fala 96+500 97+000 builtup area + barren builtup area + barren 97+000 97+500 barren barren 97+500 98+000 barren barren 98+000 98+500 barren agriculture + barren 98+500 99+000 barren agriculture + barren 99+000 99+500 barren+builtup area agriculture+ builtup area+ Semaliya



barren

99+500 100+000 barren+builtup area agriculture+ builtup area+

barren Semaliya

100+000 100+500 barren + agriculture barren + agriculture Semaliya 100+500 101+000 barren + agriculture barren + agriculture 101+000 101+500 barren barren 101+500 102+000 barren barren 102+000 102+500 barren + agriculture barren Mata ji ka Bada

102+500 103+000 barren + agriculture barren Mata ji ka Bada Kataro ka Khera

103+000 103+500 barren + agriculture agriculture + barren Kataro ka Khera 103+500 104+000 barren+ agriculture agriculture+ barren Kataro ka Khera 104+000 104+500 barren barren 104+500 105+000 barren barren 105+000 105+500 agriculture agriculture Lambadabra 105+500 106+000 agriculture agriculture Lambadabra 106+000 106+500 agriculture + builtup area agriculture + builtup area Lambadabra 106+500 107+000 agriculture + builtup area agriculture + builtup area Lambadabra 107+000 107+500 forest forest 107+500 108+000 forest forest 108+000 108+500 forest forest 108+500 109+000 forest forest 109+000 109+500 forest forest 109+500 110+000 forest forest 110+000 110+500 forest forest 110+500 111+000 Forest + Hilly Forest + Hilly 111+000 111+500 Forest + Hilly Forest + Hilly 111+500 112+000 Forest + Hilly Forest + Hilly 112+000 112+500 Forest + Hilly Forest + Hilly + agriculture 112+500 113+000 Forest + Hilly Forest + Hilly + agriculture 113+000 113+500 Forest + Hilly Forest + Hilly 113+500 114+000 Forest + Hilly Forest + Hilly 114+000 114+500 Forest + Hilly Forest + Hilly 114+500 115+000 Forest + Hilly Forest + Hilly 115+000 115+500 forest forest 115+500 116+000 forest forest 116+000 116+500 barren + builtup area barren + builtup area 116+500 117+000 barren + builtup area barren + builtup area Pipalkhoont 117+000 117+500 builtup area builtup area Pipalkhoont 117+500 118+000 builtup area builtup area Pipalkhoont 118+000 118+500 agriculture agriculture + builtup area 118+500 119+000 agriculture agriculture + builtup area 119+000 119+500 agriculture agriculture



119+500 120+000 agriculture agriculture Munda Saer 120+000 120+500 agriculture agriculture + builtup area Munda Saer 120+500 121+000 agriculture agriculture + builtup area Munda Saer 121+000 121+500 agriculture + barren agriculture + barren Munda Saer 121+500 122+000 agriculture + barren agriculture + barren 122+000 122+500 barren+ forest barren+ forest 122+500 123+000 barren + forest barren + forest 123+000 123+500 barren forest 123+500 124+000 barren forest 124+000 124+500 forest forest 124+500 125+000 forest forest 125+000 125+500 barren + agriculture barren + agriculture 125+500 126+000 barren + agriculture barren + agriculture 126+000 126+500 barren + agriculture barren + agriculture 126+500 127+000 barren + agriculture barren + agriculture 127+000 127+500 barren barren 127+500 128+000 barren barren 128+000 128+500 agriculture + builtup area agriculture + builtup area Naka Khamera 128+500 129+000 agriculture + builtup area agriculture + builtup area Naka Khamera 129+000 129+500 builtup area builtup area 129+500 130+000 builtup area builtup area 130+000 130+500 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture 130+500 131+000 builtup area + agriculture builtup area+ agriculture 131+000 131+500 agriculture agriculture 131+500 132+000 agriculture agriculture 132+000 132+500 agriculture + builtup area agriculture + builtup area 132+500 133+000 agriculture + builtup area agriculture + builtup area 133+000 133+500 agriculture agriculture 133+500 134+000 agriculture agriculture 134+000 134+500 agriculture + builtup area agriculture + builtup area 134+500 135+000 agriculture + builtup area agriculture + builtup area Ghatol 135+000 135+500 builtup area builtup area Ghatol 135+500 136+000 builtup area builtup area Ghatol 136+000 136+500 builtup area builtup area Ghatol 136+500 137+000 builtup area builtup area Ghatol 137+000 137+500 builtup area + agriculture builtup area 137+500 138+000 builtup area + agriculture builtup area 138+000 138+500 forest barren 138+500 139+000 forest barren 139+000 139+500 agriculture agriculture 139+500 140+000 agriculture agriculture 140+000 140+500 agriculture agriculture 140+500 141+000 agriculture agriculture



141+000 141+500 agriculture agriculture 141+500 142+000 agriculture agriculture Dewada 142+000 142+500 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture Dewada 142+500 143+000 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture Dewada 143+000 143+500 builtup area + agriculture agriculture 143+500 144+000 builtup area + agriculture agriculture 144+000 144+500 builtup area + agriculture agriculture 144+500 145+000 builtup area + agriculture agriculture Pandoli 145+000 145+500 builtup area + agriculture agriculture + builtup area Pandoli 145+500 146+000 builtup area + agriculture agriculture + builtup area Pandoli 146+000 146+500 agriculture agriculture 146+500 147+000 agriculture agriculture 147+000 147+500 agriculture agriculture 147+500 148+000 agriculture agriculture 148+000 148+500 barren barren 148+500 149+000 barren barren

149+000 149+500 barren+ agriculture+ builtup

area builtup area + barren Senawasa

149+500 150+000 barren+ agriculture+ builtup

area builtup area + barren Senawasa

150+000 150+500 barren + agriculture agriculture 150+500 151+000 barren + agriculture agriculture 151+000 151+500 agriculture agriculture 151+500 152+000 agriculture agriculture 152+000 152+500 agriculture agriculture 152+500 153+000 agriculture agriculture 153+000 153+500 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture Surpur 153+500 154+000 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture Surpur 154+000 154+500 agriculture agriculture Surpur 154+500 155+000 agriculture agriculture 155+000 155+500 barren + agriculture barren + agriculture Ramor 155+500 156+000 barren + agriculture barren + agriculture Ramor 156+000 156+500 agriculture agriculture Harjotiya 156+500 157+000 agriculture agriculture Harjotiya 157+000 157+500 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture Tejpur 157+500 158+000 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture Tejpur 158+000 158+500 agriculture + barren agriculture + barren 158+500 159+000 agriculture + barren agriculture + barren 159+000 159+500 agriculture + builtup area agriculture + builtup area 159+500 160+000 agriculture + builtup area agriculture + builtup area 160+000 160+500 agriculture agriculture 160+500 161+000 agriculture agriculture 161+000 161+500 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture



161+500 162+000 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture 162+000 162+500 builtup area builtup area Banswara 162+500 163+000 builtup area builtup area Banswara 163+000 163+500 builtup area builtup area Banswara 163+500 164+000 builtup area builtup area Banswara 164+000 164+500 builtup area builtup area Banswara 164+500 165+000 builtup area builtup area Banswara 165+000 165+500 builtup area builtup area Banswara 165+500 166+000 builtup area builtup area Banswara 166+000 166+500 builtup area builtup area Banswara 166+500 167+000 builtup area builtup area Banswara 167+000 167+500 builtup area builtup area Banswara 167+500 168+000 builtup area builtup area Thikariya 168+000 168+500 builtup area builtup area Thikariya 168+500 169+000 builtup area builtup area Thikariya 169+000 169+500 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture Thikariya 169+500 170+000 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture 170+000 170+500 agriculture agriculture 170+500 171+000 agriculture agriculture 171+000 171+500 Agriculture + Builtup area agriculture 171+500 172+000 Agriculture + Builtup area agriculture 172+000 172+500 Agriculture + Builtup area agriculture 172+500 173+000 Agriculture + Builtup area agriculture 173+000 173+500 Agriculture + Builtup area Agriculture + Builtup area Borwat 173+500 174+000 Agriculture + Builtup area Agriculture + Builtup area Borwat 174+000 174+500 Agriculture + Builtup area Agriculture + Builtup area Borwat 174+500 175+000 Agriculture + Builtup area Agriculture + Builtup area 175+000 175+500 agriculture agriculture 175+500 176+000 agriculture agriculture Chhinch Tiraha 176+000 176+500 Builtup area + Agriculture builtup area + agriculture Sagrod 176+500 177+000 builtup area + agriculture builtup area + agriculture Sagrod 177+000 177+500 agriculture agriculture Sagrod 177+500 178+000 agriculture agriculture 178+000 178+500 agriculture agriculture 178+500 179+000 agriculture agriculture 179+000 179+500 agriculture agriculture 179+500 180+000 agriculture agriculture

Annexure: 2.1

Socio Economic Statistics of Project influence districts

Source: Directorate of Census Operations in Rajasthan

Districts Pratapgrah Banswara

Description 2011 2001 2011 2001

Actual Population 868,231 706,807 1,798,194 1,420,601

Male 437,950 359,021 908,755 719,997

Female 430,281 347,786 889,439 700,604

Population Growth 22.84% 27.09% 26.58% 27.61%

Area Sq. Km 4,112 4,112 4,508 4,508

Density/km2 211 172 399 315

Proportion to Rajasthan Population 1.27% 1.25% 2.62% 2.51%

Sex Ratio (Per 1000) 982 969 979 973

Child Sex Ratio (0-6 Age) 926 953 925 961

Average Literacy 56.30 48.25 57.20 45.54

Male Literacy 70.13 64.27 70.80 61.50

Female Literacy 42.40 31.77 43.47 29.22

Total Child Population (0-6 Age) 148,753 142,692 321,288 297,227

Male Population (0-6 Age) 77,227 73,066 166,923 151,571

Female Population (0-6 Age) 71,526 69,626 154,365 145,656

Literates 405,100 272,149 844,722 511,729

Male Literates 252,990 183,782 525,217 349,581

Female Literates 152,110 88,367 319,505 162,148

Child Proportion (0-6 Age) 17.13% 20.19% 17.87% 20.92%

Boys Proportion (0-6 Age) 17.63% 20.35% 18.37% 21.05%

Girls Proportion (0-6 Age) 16.62% 20.02% 17.36% 20.79

SC population to total NA 7.32 NA 4.28

ST population to total NA 59.94 NA 72.27

Annexure 2.2

District wise Socio-Economic Statistics of project-affected villages

S.

No.

Village/

Town

No. of

HH

Total

Population

% of Total Population Sex Ratio

Male Female Males

ST

Females

ST Overall ST

District-Pratapgarh

Tehsil- Pratapgarh

1 Pratapgarh 37466 201229 48.91 51.08 28.69 27.55 957 960

2 Makanpura 100 586 48.65 51.35 39.19 43.24 1055 1103

3 Manohargarh 15 74 51.68 48.32 49.09 46.37 934 944

4 Teemarwa 279 1544 52.39 47.61 51.02 46.76 908 916

5 Chatriya

Kheri NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA

Total 37860 203433 - - - - - -

Tehsil- Peepalkhunt

6 Padliya 95 576 50.35 49.65 17.88 18.58 986 1038

7 Kachotiya 227 1166 50.17 49.83 49.23 49.40 993 1003

8 Mota

Manyaga 84 492 45.73 54.27 43.50 50.20 1186 1154

9 Chhayan 88 459 49.24 50.76 18.08 20.48 1031 1132

10 Suhagpura 228 1036 57.82 42.18 21.81 9.36 729 429

11 Banjari 137 705 52.34 47.66 50.92 46.67 910 916

12 Semaliya 89 466 50.64 49.36 19.74 18.88 974 956

13 Relan 5 34 - - 41.17 58.82 - 1428

14 Vakhatpura NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA

15 Kataron Ka Khera - B

59 331 55.59 44.41 46.22 55.59 798 843

16 Kataron Ka Khera - A

117 703 52.20 47.80 49.50 52.20 915 910

17 Lamba Dabra 262 1414 50.28 49.71 42.36 41.58 988 981

18 Chhari 244 1240 51.04 48.95 42.66 41.11 958 964

S.

No.

Village/

Town

No. of

HH

Total

Population


Male Female Males

ST

Females

ST Overall ST

19 Peepal Khoont

815 4352 50.55 49.45 42.37 42.30 978 998

Total 2450 12974 - - - - - -

District- Banswara

Tehsil- Ghatol

20 Murasel 450 2241 49.13 50.87 41.86 43.42 1035 1037

21 Hilej 110 608 52.63 47.37 49.18 44.24 900 899

22 Sadri 76 398 49.25 50.75 49.25 50.75 1030 1030

23 Bhagoron Ka

Khera 116 618 52.75 47.24 52.26 46.76 895 894

24 Khamera 403 2191 50.61 49.38 9.31 9.63 975 1034

25 Udaji Ka Gara 320 1617 53.49 46.51 25.79 23.38 869 906

26 Baroda 176 896 51.00 49.00 32.37 28.91 960 893

27 Hawri 75 413 50.85 49.15 26.39 23.97 966 908

28 Savniya 165 974 49.59 50.41 29.77 30.80 1016 1034

29 Ghatol 2205 11885 50.54 49.46 21.24 21.48 978 1011

30 Kargachiya NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA

31 Dewada 671 3899 49.73 50.27 35.91 35.98 1010 1002

32 Paroli

Gordhan 425 2366 50.21 49.79 45.14 45.14 991 1000

33 Sagthali 63 357 49.58 50.42 49.58 50.42 1016 1016

34 Jedla 288 1622 51.60 48.40 50.12 47.47 937 947

35 Senawasa 488 2672 51.91 48.09 35.14 33.38 926 949

36 Udpura 160 924 50.22 49.78 17.10 17.21 991 1006

Total 6191 33681 - - - - - -

Tehsil- Banswara

37 Bhagat Pura 120 682 50.15 49.85 50.15 49.85 994 994

38 Pathanpura 29 152 49.34 - 44.07 50.65 1026 1149

S.

No.

Village/

Town

No. of

HH

Total

Population


Male Female Males

ST

Females

ST Overall ST

39 Soorpur 340 1837 50.63 49.37 17.47 18.24 975 1043

40 Ramoar NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA

41 Harmatiya 175 1037 53.42 46.58 41.37 38.28 871 925

42 Tejpur 661 4132 51.04 48.96 37.85 36.62 959 967

43 Makod 239 1424 49.16 50.84 41.99 43.75 1034 1041

44 Sewna 394 2357 50.62 49.38 38.61 38.86 975 1006

45 Bargaon 438 2471 49.74 50.26 27.20 28.21 1010 1037

46 Janameri 240 1666 61.64 38.36 27.01 26.65 622 986

47 Kupra 115 663 52.49 47.51 12.85 11.18 905 870

48 Ganpatpura 56 372 47.58 52.42 47.58 52.42 1101 1101

49 Shivpura 65 342 46.78 53.22 44.15 51.17 1137 1158

50 Bhachariya 290 1837 49.86 50.14 33.64 35.06 1005 1042

51 Dashahara 149 911 48.74 51.26 27.33 29.42 1051 1076

52 Amarpura 115 663 46.30 53.70 34.99 39.82 1159 1137

53 Tamtiya 307 1764 52.15 47.85 21.88 20.92 917 956

54 Odharji Ka

Parda 73 400 54.50 45.50 51.00 42.00 834 823

55 Borwat 259 1503 50.83 49.17 23.62 23.82 967 1008

56 Borkheri 64 422 - - 46.91 53.08 - 1131

57 Sagrod 420 2479 50.06 49.94 27.39 28.64 997 1045

Total 5094 29867 - - - - - -

Source: Census of India 2001

Annexure 2.3

Literacy Rates Segregated by Gender

S. No. Village/ Town Total Population

Literacy %

Male Female

District-Pratapgarh

Tehsil- Pratapgarh

1 Pratapgarh

201229

28.06 13.81

2 Makanpura 586 21.62 14.86

3 Manohar garh 74 16.71 5.05

4 Teemarwa 1544 16.38 4.61

5 Chatariya Kheri 301 11.29 1.99

Tehsil- Peepalkhunt

6 Padliya 576 28.30 11.46

7 Kachotiya 1166 19.47 8.06

8 Mota Manyaga 492 20.53 8.13

9 Chhayan 459 16.12 4.36

10 Suhagpura 1036 47.39 21.81

11 Banjari 705 22.70 11.21

12 Semaliya 466 24.25 15.02

13 Relan 34 20.58 20.58

14 Kataron Ka Khera - B 331 25.68 7.25

15 Kataron Ka Khera - A 703 15.65 3.98

17 Lamba Dabra 1414 20.08 5.72

18 Chhari 1240 13.87 2.90


Literacy %

Male Female

19 Peepal Khoont 4352 18.54 9.08

District- Banswara

Tehsil- Ghatol

20 Murasel 2241 19.01 5.89

21 Hilej 608 14.47 2.80

22 Sadri 398 15.33 4.77

23 Bhagoron Ka Khera 618 29.12 8.41

24 Khamera 2191 34.82 25.65

25 Udaji Ka Gara 1617 31.91 12.31

26 Baroda 896 24.67 9.15

27 Hawri 413 27.36 11.62

28 Savniya 974 26.80 15.20

29 Ghatol 11885 31.06 18.73

30 Kargachiya NA NA NA

31 Dewada 3899 23.34 10.72

32 Paroli Gordhan 2366 25.15 10.78

33 Sagthali 357 16.53 5.04

34 Jedla 1622 19.48 7.46

35 Senawasa 2672 31.32 12.20

36 Udpura 924 27.92 8.87

Tehsil- Banswara

37 Bhagatpura 682 16.57 5.57

38 Pathanpura 152

17.76 7.23


Literacy %

Male Female

39 Soorpur 1837 30.65 16.60

40 Ramoar NA NA NA

41 Harmatiya 1037 34.52 16.68

42 Tejpur 4132 25.19 10.48

43 Makod 1424 23.46 8.85

44 Sewna 2357 30.55 12.13

45 Bargaon 2471 30.72 12.22

46 Janameri 1666 43.40 5.22

47 Kupra 663 34.92 16.63

48 Ganpatpura 372 26.61 12.90

49 Shivpura 342 23.10 16.37

50 Bhachariya 1837 28.74 12.52

51 Dashahara 911 34.25 25.25

52 Amarpura 663 29.41 14.18

53 Tamtiya 1764 33.33 16.84

54 Odharji Ka Parda 400 43.50 17.00

55 Borwat 1503 25.22 8.85

56 Borkheri

422 14.45 7.58

57 Sagrod 2479 23.88 10.81

Source: Census of India, 2001

Annexure 2.4

Work Participation Rate in Villages Traversed by Project Road

S. No. Village/

Town

Workers (%) Non Worker (%)

Total Main

Male

Main

Female

Marginal

Male

Marginal

Female Total Male Female

District-Pratapgarh

Tehsil- Pratapgarh

1 Pratapgarh 113145 44.40 30.36 7.61 17.61 88084 49.87 50.12

2 Makanpura 32 46.88 31.25 9.38 12.50 42 24.32 32.43

3 Manohargarh 1092 31.96 3.94 20.70 43.41 452 14.44 14.83

4 Teemarwa 300 35.67 26.33 17.67 20.33 286 25.09 23.72

5 Chatariya

Kheri 151 37.74 1.32 10.59 50.33 150 61.33 38.66

Total 114720 - - - - 89014 - -

Tehsil- Peepalkhunt

6 Padliya 240 47.50 27.92 6.25 18.33 336 27.95 30.38

7 Kachotiya 607 43.49 43.33 3.13 10.05 559 25.90 22.04

8 Mota

Manyaga 244 31.15 27.87 14.75 26.23 248 22.97 27.44

9 Chhayan 280 47.14 1.43 4.29 47.14 179 17.86 21.13

10 Suhagpura 308 86.04 10.06 3.25 0.65 728 31.27 39.00

11 Banjari 396 44.44 28.28 4.29 22.98 309 24.96 18.87

12 Semaliya 149 67.79 20.13 4.03 8.05 317 27.68 40.34

13 Relan 20 20.00 - 30.00 50.00 14 25.57 71.42

14 Vakatpura NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA

S. No. Village/

Town


Total Main

Male

Main

Female

Marginal

Male

Marginal


15 Kataron Ka

Khera – B 81 85.19 3.70 11.11 0.00 250 32.02 43.50

16 Kataron Ka

Khera – A 196 68.88 30.61 0.00 0.51 507 33.00 39.12

17 Lamba

Dabra 753 40.63 40.23 9.29 9.87 661 50.68 49.31

18 Chhari 756 26.19 20.37 24.60 28.83 484 51.44 48.55

19 Peepal

Khoont 1963 53.23 26.80 5.50 14.47 2389 24.06 30.84

Total 5993 - - - - 6981 -

-

District- Banswara

Tehsil- Ghatol

20 Murasel 1203 42.81 10.39 6.82 39.98 1038 22.49 23.83

21 Hilej 337 38.87 35.91 13.06 12.17 271 23.85 20.72

22 Sadri 210 41.43 34.29 8.57 15.71 188 22.86 24.37

23 Bhagoro ka

Khera 336 51.78 44.34 0.59 3.27 282 53.19 46.80

24 Khamera 729 64.33 20.43 6.03 9.19 1462 40.69 59.23

25 Udaji Ka

Gara 928 43.97 20.69 6.36 28.99 689 24.61 18.00

26 Baroda 390 47.69 6.67 11.28 34.36 506 25.33 31.14

27 Hawri 177 49.72 40.68 3.95 5.65 236 27.85 29.30

28 Savniya 344 63.37 26.16 2.03 8.43 630 26.49 38.19

29 Ghatol 4299 58.71 22.52 4.86 13.91 7586 27.55 36.28

S. No. Village/

Town


Total Main

Male

Main

Female

Marginal

Male

Marginal


30 Kargachiya NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA

31 Dewada 1613 48.67 31.80 5.08 14.45 2286 27.49 31.14

32 Paroli

Gordhan 1078 48.14 50.09 0.83 0.93 1288 27.90 26.54

33 Sagthali 158 52.53 47.47 0.00 0.00 199 26.33 29.41

34 Jedla 759 50.72 47.43 1.71 0.13 863 27.07 26.14

35 Senawasa 1226 50.24 19.41 3.92 26.43 1446 27.06 27.06

36 Udpura 510 46.86 52.75 0.20 0.20 414 24.24 20.56

Total 14297 - - - - 19384 - -

Tehsil- Banswara

37 Bhagatpura 348 41.67 1.44 5.17 51.72 334 26.25 22.73

38 Pathanpura 69 49.27 2.89 4.34 43.47 83 45.78 54.21

39 Soorpur 977 46.47 11.57 9.21 32.75 860 21.01 25.80

40 Ramoar NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA

41 Harmatiya 350 53.71 32.29 2.29 11.71 687 34.52 31.73

42 Tejpur 2055 43.75 33.48 4.33 18.44 2077 27.13 23.14

43 Makod 789 39.67 10.14 6.21 43.98 635 23.74 20.86

44 Sewna 989 53.99 39.74 3.34 2.93 1368 26.56 31.48

45 Bargaon 1037 54.29 26.13 3.47 16.10 1434 25.50 32.54

46 Janameri 990 57.58 4.14 9.39 28.89 676 21.85 18.73

47 Kupra 1212 66.58 22.28 7.76 3.38 2204 26.11 38.41

48 Ganpatpura 87 12.64 2.30 82.76 2.30 285 25.27 51.34

S. No. Village/

Town


Total Main

Male

Main

Female

Marginal

Male

Marginal


49 Shivpura 187 35.83 12.30 12.30 39.57 155 20.47 24.85

50 Bhachariya 758 53.56 43.67 1.58 1.19 1079 27.11 31.63

51 Dashahara 490 46.94 17.35 3.88 31.84 421 21.41 24.81

52 Amarpura 290 50.34 22.41 3.79 23.45 373 22.62 33.63

53 Tamtiya 707 56.86 11.74 4.53 26.87 1057 27.55 32.37

54 Odharji Ka

Parda 197 56.85 2.03 5.08 36.04 203 24.00 26.75

55 Borwat 643 54.90 13.22 6.07 25.82 860 24.75 32.47

56 Borkheri 207 43.47 41.54 5.31 9.66 215 45.11 54.88

57 Sagrod 1190 49.41 6.05 2.44 42.10 1289 25.17 26.83

Total 13572 - - - - 16295 - -

Source: Census of India, 2001

Annexure 4.1

PARTAPGARH

BANSWARA

Annexure 4.2

Annexure 5.1

From To

1 Pratapgarh 80+000 81+050 1050 B/S 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 4.722

2 Makanpura 81+050 81+758 708 B/S 0.000 0.091 0.000 0.091 1.885

3 Manohargarh 81+758 82+950 1192 B/S 0.000 0.000 5.390 5.390 0.656

4 Teemarwa 82+950 84+063 1113 B/S 0.000 0.143 0.000 0.143 1.403

5 Chatriya Kheri 84+063 84+861 798 B/S 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 2.435

6 Manohargarh 84+861 87+415 2554 B/S 2.235 0.357 3.418 6.010 3.361

Total 2.235 0.591 8.808 11.634 14.461

7 Padliya 87+415 88+240 825 B/S 0.163 0.565 0.000 0.728 0.856

8 Kachotiya 88+240 90+925 2685 B/S 0.800 1.067 0.000 1.866 4.872

9Mota

Mayanga90+925 92+210 1285 B/S 0.548 2.461 0.000 3.009 2.757

10 Chhayan 92+210 94+590 2380 B/S 0.523 1.415 0.000 1.938 6.781

11 Suhagpura 94+590 96+000 1410 B/S 0.570 0.038 0.000 0.608 3.328

12 Banjari 96+000 99+275 3275 B/S 2.884 0.054 0.000 2.938 11.794

13 Semaliya 99+275 100+334 1059 B/S 0.239 0.309 0.000 0.548 1.695

14 Relan 100+334 101+495 1161 B/S 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 1.343

15 Vakhatpura 101+495 102+430 935 B/S 0.027 0.038 0.000 0.065 2.024

16Kataro ka

Khera(B)102+430 104+406 1976 B/S 0.004 0.262 0.000 0.265 4.096

17Kataro ka

Khera(A)104+406 105+840 1434 B/S 0.012 0.064 0.000 0.076 3.309

18 Lamba Dabra 105+840 110+060 4220 B/S 0.000 0.000 8.045 8.045 4.246

19 Chhari 109+075 109+615 540 LHS 0.000 0.000 1.495 1.495 0.000

20 Pipal Khut 110+060 118+520 8460 B/S 1.460 2.052 13.587 17.099 7.914

Forest landTotal land to

be Aquired

Total land to

be Required

Tehsil:- Pipalkhunt

LAND ACQUISITION STATUS PRATAPGARH TO PADI SECTION OF NH - 113

DISTRICT:- PRATAPGARH

Tehsil:- Pratapgarh

S. No. Village Chainage

Length Side Govt. land Private land

Total 7.228 8.326 23.127 38.680 55.015

21 Mudasel 118+520 123+835 5315 B/S 0.837 1.419 4.581 6.837 8.192

22 Helaij 123+835 125+825 1990 B/S 0.405 0.567 1.515 2.487 2.893

23 Sadari 125+825 128+000 2175 B/S 1.335 0.419 1.200 2.954 3.178

24Bhagoro Ka

Khera128+000 128+526 526 B/S 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.769

25 Khamera 128+526 129+750 1224 B/S 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 3.521

26Udda Ji Ka

Gada129+750 130+870 1120 B/S 0.044 0.013 0.000 0.057 3.595

27 Barora 130+870 131+695 825 B/S 0.114 0.163 0.000 0.277 1.663

28 Hawadi 131+695 132+060 365 B/S 0.214 0.551 0.000 0.765 0.944

29 Savniya 132+060 133+270 1210 B/S 0.053 0.057 0.000 0.111 3.494

30 Ghatol 133+270 139+605 6335 B/S 1.410 12.399 1.653 15.462 5.365

31 Kargachiya 139+605 140+020 415 B/S 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 1.101

32 Devda 140+020 143+885 3865 B/S 0.411 0.170 0.000 0.580 7.965

33Padoli

Gordhan143+885 145+775 1890 B/S 0.570 0.674 0.000 1.245 3.860

34 Sagthali 145+775 147+465 1690 B/S 0.342 0.162 0.000 0.503 2.907

35 Jedla 147+465 147+768 303 B/S 0.000 0.495 0.000 0.495 0.569

36 Senawasa 147+768 150+300 2532 B/S 0.163 0.358 1.469 1.990 5.609

37 Udpura 150+300 151+530 1230 B/S 0.004 0.082 0.000 0.085 3.011

Total 5.902 17.531 10.418 33.850 58.637

38 Bhagatpura 151+530 152+465 935 B/S 0.000 0.070 0.000 0.070 1.828

39 Pathanpura 152+465 152+851 386 B/S 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.698

40 Surpur 152+851 154+922 2071 B/S 0.451 0.509 0.000 0.961 3.699

41 Ramoar 154+922 155+330 408 B/S 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 1.295

42 Tejpur 155+330 155+860 530 B/S 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 1.343

43 Harmatiya 155+860 156+790 930 B/S 0.000 0.285 0.000 0.285 2.155

44 Tejpur 156+790 Ch. 157.605 320 B/S 0.515 1.782 0.000 2.297 2.224

45 Makod Ch. 157.605 Ch. 158.600 995 B/S 0.935 1.682 0.000 2.617

46 Sevana Ch. 158.600 Ch. 159.855 1255 B/S 0.887 2.898 0.000 3.785

Tehsil:- Banswara

DISTRICT:- BANSWARA

Tehsil:- Ghatol

47 Bargaon Ch. 159.855 Ch. 162.380 2525 B/S 4.083 4.327 0.000 8.411

48 Janamedi Ch. 162.380 Ch. 162.652 272 B/S 0.362 0.461 0.000 0.823

49 Kupda Ch. 162.652 Ch.164.085 1433 B/S 0.596 3.937 0.000 4.534

50 Ganpatpura Ch.164.085 Ch. 164.800 715 B/S 0.391 2.428 0.000 2.819

51 Shivpura Ch. 164.800 Ch. 165.600 800 B/S 1.187 1.250 0.000 2.437

52 Bhachariya Ch. 165.600 Ch. 166.545 945 B/S 0.696 2.108 0.000 2.805

53 Dashara Ch. 166.545 Ch. 167.300 755 B/S 0.000 2.267 0.000 2.267

54 Amarpura Ch. 167.300 Ch. 167.900 600 B/S 0.202 1.586 0.000 1.789

55 Tamatiya Ch. 167.900 Ch. 168.575 675 B/S 0.187 1.854 0.000 2.041

56Odharji Ka

PardaCh. 168.575 Ch. 168.758 183 B/S 0.382 0.171 0.000 0.553

57 Borwat Ch. 168.758Km.

174+278510 B/S 3.096 0.579 0.000 3.674 1.843

58 Borkheri 174+278 175+396 1118 B/S 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 1.835

59 Sagrod 175+396 179+600 4204 B/S 0.684 2.690 0.000 3.374 7.173

Total 14.656 30.886 0.000 45.541 24.092

30.020 57.333 42.353 129.705 152.205

Please Note: There are 59 villages but 2 villages are counted as double.

BA

NS

WA

RA

BY

PA

SS

Grand Total

Annexure 7.1

Issues, Recommended Actions / Strategy and Responsibility

Issues/Concerns Objectives Strategy / Action

Required Responsibility

Monitoring

documents Non deployment of participation of women representative

Ensuring at least two women must be deployed In the team of RAP implementation agency

• TOR should clearly mention this aspect

• Some weight age to be given to RAP implementation agency for

• Project Authority

• TOR for RAP implementation agency

Poor access to women regarding information on projects and R&R provisions

To provide better access to project information and R&R benefits

• Focused consultations with women group

• Focus group and /or one-to-one interaction with women members by women members of the NGOs

• NGOs to be ensured by PST’s R&R Officer

• Consultation meetings number of FGDs, Number women attended in each FGDs (supported by photographs, video graphs, signatures, proceedings)

• Development of etc)

• NGOs with help from state level LA and Social Officer

• NGO’s Term of Reference Production materials of IEC and records of plays, skits etc.

• Should be reflected on monthly report.

Gender exploitation at construction site

• To provide safer working environment for women

• One Lady will be deployed at construction site as a woman inspector (Experience social Expert / diploma Engineer). The position for women inspector will be specified in

Contractor, and Project Authority

Monthly reports



Monitoring

documents the team of contractor for the entire duration of the contract.

• Occupation health and safety measures shall be provided in gender sensitive manner (e.g. toilets, shades etc)

Women headed households are more vulnerable than men headed households

•To provide women headed households equal opportunities

• Compensation for women headed families

• One to one interaction

• Provision of additional assistance to women headed households (WHH)

NGOs and R&R Officer

• One to one report to be reflected on Monthly

reports; • Tracking of

disbursement to WHHs reflected in Monthly

reports • M&E reports

Poor level of awareness HIV/AIDs among women

HIV AIDs awareness among women (may include other women members of the neighborhood)

• Women group consultation by the women members by women members of the NGOs

•Coordinate with SACO and other specialized agencies and organize awareness campaign about HIV AIDs with women only

NGOs and necessary help will be provided by the project authority

• Monthly reports (photographs, video graphs)

Disruption of

• A minimum level of

•Make appropriate

Contractors and project Authority

Monthly reports (photographs)



Monitoring

documents mobility of women during rainy seasons and construction activities

mobility should be ensured for women during rainy season and construction activities

footpath within the available ROW

•Facilitate safe movement of school children particularly female to their school, market place, health care centers etc.

Annexure-8.1

List of villages where Gram Sabhas has been conducted

PRATAPGARH DISTRICT

1. Makanpura

2. Kachotiya

3. Suhagpura

4. Semaliya

5. Sodalpur

6. Peepalkhut

BANSWARA DISTRICT

1. Banswara

2. Khamera

3. Savniya

4. Devda

5. Padoli Govordhan

6. Senawasa

7. Bargaon

8. Lodha

9. Koupda

10. Bhachadriya

11. Tamtiya Ada

12. Sundenpur

13. Tejpur

14. Makod

15. Sevana

16. Surpur

17. Borwat

18. Sagrod

Sample Photos of Social Survey of NH-113 Project

Sample Photos of Gram Sabhas under PESA Act of NH-113

CENSUS SOCIAL SURVEY FORM-

SAMPLE

Annexure

of

Affected Structure List

SL.NO District

Exact

Chainage(m

) location

Name of

VillageType Of Property

affected (m)

Area Oof

Structure

Name Description

1

Baswara 176+950 Sagrod Panchyat Bhawan 9 Govt Property Govt Property

2

Baswara 176+950 sagrodSchool Boundary

Wall46 Govt School Govt School

3

Baswara 176+700 sagrod Hut 145.16 Pari devi Ration card no. 52

4

Baswara 175+900 Sagrod Hut 30 Owner not found

Document Not

available ( Owner

not found

5

Baswara 175+900 Sagrod Boundary Wall 79.2 Owner not found

Document Not

available ( Owner

not found

6

Baswara 175+900 Sagrod Boundary Wall 60 Owner not found

Document Not

available ( Owner

not found

7

Baswara 175+900 Sagrod Shop 79.2 Owner not found

Document Not

available ( Owner

not found

Photos

SL.NO District

Exact

Chainage(m

) location

Name of


affected (m)

Area Oof

Structure

Name Description Photos

8

Baswara 75+500 Sagrod House 17.5 Ramakant ji

Document Not

available ( Owner

not found

9

Baswara 175+050 Sagrod Boundary Wall 69 Owner not found BPL no.1505375

10

Baswara 174+100 Borwat House 166.75 Monga katara Ration card no. 84

11

Baswara 174+080 Borwat Hut 25.5 Sankar chochan Id no. Not available

12

Baswara 174+000 Borwat Hut 26.25 Dalla rathod Id no. Not available

13

Baswara 174+000 Borwat Hut 26.25 Bheru chouhan Id no. Not available

14

Baswara 174+000 Borwat Hut 14 Guddu chouhan Id no. Not available

SL.NO District

Exact

Chainage(m

) location

Name of


affected (m)

Area Oof

Structure


15

Baswara 174=000 Borwat Temple 78 Temple Temple

16

Baswara 174+000 Borwat shop 32.5 Maan singh Electricity bill1802-

0346

17

Baswara 173+800 Borwat House 1333Gajendra singh

hadaRJ/16/129/255175

18

Baswara 173+800 Borwat Temple 110Satti m ata

templeTemple

19

Baswara 173+800 Borwat Shop/ Bowndrywall 750 Ranchod patel RJ /16/129/256091

20

Baswara 173+700 Borwat Shop 50.31 Parvat singh RJ/16/129/256089

21

Baswara 157+850 Tezpur Shop 50 Khuspal jain RJ/16/129/435469 ,

SL.NO District

Exact

Chainage(m

) location

Name of


affected (m)

Area Oof

Structure


22

Baswara 157+850 Tezpur Shop 52 Cahnd mal jain RJ /16/129/435471

23

Baswara 157+800 Tezpur Shop 60Pawan kumar

jainRJ/16/129/43553

24

Baswara 157+800 Tezpur Shop 60 Hansmukh jainHkw/1650902-2204-

0177

25

Baswara 157+750 Tezpur House 9.23Jitwendra

chobisaTft/01353301

26

Baswara 157+700 Tezpur House 46.86Goutam lal

chobisaRJ/16/1291436010

27

Baswara 157+700 Tezpur House 52 Phool ji/Rupen ji RJ/16-129/455188

28

Baswara 157+650 Tezpur House 52 Goutam lal RJ16/129/435188

SL.NO District

Exact

Chainage(m

) location

Name of


affected (m)

Area Oof

Structure


29

Baswara 157+600 Tezpur Shop 20 Kamla teli RJ/16/129/436116

30

Baswara 157+550 Tezpur House 125 Parvat singh RJ/2204-0192

31

Baswara 157+500 Tezpur House 125 Deelip singh Hkw/1758101

32

Baswara 157+475 Tezpur House 150 Harish singh Hkw/1271998

33

Baswara 157+475 Tezpur House 607.5 Kachru ji RJ/16/129/436124

34

Baswara 157+300 Tezpur House 18.36 Hadmat singh RJ/16/129/435261

35

Baswara 157+300 Tezpur House 57.4 Nathu lal RJ16/129/435363

SL.NO District

Exact

Chainage(m

) location

Name of


affected (m)

Area Oof

Structure


36

Baswara 157+450 Tezpur House 120 Satyanarayan Hkw/1650910

37

Baswara 157+500 Tezpur House 270 Iswar lal RJ/16/129/435301

38

Baswara 157+400 Tezpur House 690 Dali chand RJ/16/129/435320

39

Baswara 153+300 Surpur House 84 Sankar mekwana RJ/2206-0179

40

Baswara 153+200 Surpur House 119.54Jeti devi w/o

Harimeg

Document Not

available

41

Baswara 153+200 Surpur House 180Dhuli w/o maaan

jiRJ /16/129/442091

42

Baswara 153+250 Surpur House 28.8 Devi lal RJ/16/129/441474

SL.NO District

Exact

Chainage(m

) location

Name of


affected (m)

Area Oof

Structure


43

Baswara 153+300 Surpur house 100 Andeng lalDocument Not

available

44

Baswara 153+300 Surpur house 69.3 Bajeng jiDocument Not

available

45

Baswara 153+300 Surpur house 69.3Kmlesh s/o

kachruRJ/16/129/441142

46

Baswara 142+430 Devda Boundary Wall 3.3Veer bahadur

singhRJ/16/129/442057

47

Baswara 142+250 Devda Shop/ House 172.5 Nanu lal RJ/16/130/205084

48

Baswara 142+250 Devda house 80.5 Laxman rawal RJ/16/130/904494

49

Baswara 138+700 Dungripada Temple 29.25 Shiv temple RJ/16/130/204298

SL.NO District

Exact

Chainage(m

) location

Name of


affected (m)

Area Oof

Structure


50

Banswara 135+450 GhatolPatwar Bhawan(

House)156 Patwar Bhawan Temple

51

Banswara 135+100 Ghatol Temple 25 Shiv temple Govt Property

52

Banswara 135+030 Ghatol Shop 800 Shanti lal ji Temple

53

Banswara 135+030 Ghatol Shop 800 Visesh /ganesh jiDocument Not

available

54

Banswara 135+020 Ghatol Shop 840Chanda/

radhemal

Document Not

available

55

Banswara 135+020 Ghatol Shop 65 Shanti lal jain RJ/10/130/369188

56

Banswara 134+000 Ghatol Shop 46.2Raju panchal/

O/NARJ/16/130/372473

SL.NO District

Exact

Chainage(m

) location

Name of


affected (m)

Area Oof

Structure


57

Partapgarh 120+300 Aduapada Govt School 112 Govt Property

Document Not

available ( Owner

not found

58

Partapgarh 118+900 Pipalkhunt PWD Guest house 158.4 Govt Property Govt School

59

Partapgarh 118+500 PipalkhuntBus

stop,Pipalkhunt139.32 Govt Property Govt Guest House

60

Partapgarh 118=500 Pipalkhunt House 100 Parbhu dyal Govt Bus Stand

61

Partapgarh 117++800 Pipalkhunt Shop 87.3 Gal ji/ Amra bhaiDocument not

available

62

Partapgarh 116+400 Pipalkhunt Shop/House 41 Krishna singhDocument not

available

63

Partapgarh 116+350 Pipalkhunt Hut 48.6Rajkumari w/o

Laxman singhLJC/2008548

SL.NO District

Exact

Chainage(m

) location

Name of


affected (m)

Area Oof

Structure


64

Partapgarh 110+000 amlighati Hut 60 PWD forest land LJC/1270983

65

Partapgarh 107+000 Lambadabra Hut 80 Owner not foundDocument not

available

66

Partapgarh 94+500 semliya Shop/ House 47.5 Dinesh BhagwanDocument not

available

67

Partapgarh 94=450 semliya Shop/ House 71.5 Parkash /moti lal RJ/16/130/537406

68

Partapgarh 94+450 semliya Shop/ House 75Parkash chand /

n/aRJ/16/130/537136

69

Partapgarh 94+500 semliya Shop/ House 150Ganga ram/

Kachru

Document & owner

not available

70

Partapgarh 94+500 semliya Shop/ House 54Vadhi chand/

Pyar chandRJ/16/130/538065

SL.NO District

Exact

Chainage(m

) location

Name of


affected (m)

Area Oof

Structure


71

Partapgarh 94+500 semliya Shop/ House 54Devi lal / Pyar

chand Ration Card no.35

72

Partapgarh 94+500 semliya Shop 29.6 Owner not found RJ/16/130/537282

73

Partapgarh 94+400 semliya Shop 38.88 Owner not foundDocument & owner

not available

74

Partapgarh 94+200 Mahadevfala School Toilet 15.12 Govt PropertyDocument & owner

not available

75

Partapgarh 93+750 Suhagpura shop 16Onkar mal/

Kanwar lalRJ/17//127/207624

76

Partapgarh 92+800Bada

mayngahut 80 Owner not found

Document & owner

not available

77

Partapgarh 91+800Bada

mayngaHouse 42.75 Naag ji meena

Document & owner

not available

SL.NO District

Exact

Chainage(m

) location

Name of


affected (m)

Area Oof

Structure


78

Partapgarh 88+900 Kachotiya House 120 Owner not found BPL- 19306

79

Partapgarh 84+700 Kachotiya Temple 35 Goga ji TempleDocument & owner

not available

Annexure

of

Affected Land of Tribal PAHs

1 90+80091+000 Jhanya ( Kachotiya ) Partapgarh 911,909,912,914

915,916,917,905 Jhanya ( Kachotiya ) 0.38 Habji,Mangilal s/o Gumaniya meena

Ration card- 188

2 90+30090+400 Jhanya ( Kachotiya ) Partapgarh 789,801,799 Jhanya ( Kachotiya ) 0.177 Gom ji s/o Sawla RJ /19/127/216746

3 90+90091+000 Jhanya ( Kachotiya ) Partapgarh 897,918 Jhanya ( Kachotiya ) 0.091 Kam ji s/o Jokhiya RJ/17/127/216495

4 90+800 Jhanya ( Kachotiya ) Partapgarh 896 Jhanya ( Kachotiya ) 0.070 Asha ram s/o Nanda, vakta RJ/17/127/216510,RJ/127/216016

5 89+400 Kachotiya Partapgarh 371 Kachotiya 0.052 Dhanki w/o Thwra ,Hak ji , s/o Thawra

RJ/19/127/216626 ,RJ17/127/216186, RJ/17/127/216121

6 89+300 Kachotiya Partapgarh 377 Kachotiya 0.012 Chunni lal , Mangi lal, Kelash s/o dewa ram

FQS/1540897 , RJ17/127/216367 ,

FQS /1540889

7 88+650 Kachotiya Partapgarh 318 Kachotiya 0.009 Lkhma/ mangiya meena Pan card no. AITPM 0672P

SL.NO Name of Village DistrictKhasra

No.

Present address of the

property

Affected

land( Hect)Documentary Proof

Exact

Chainage(m)

location

PhotosOwner/ Occupier of Land


No.


property

Affected


Exact

Chainage(m)

location


8 98+100 Kachotiya Partapgarh 1080 Kachotiya Babu meena s/o rajnga meena RJ/17/127/216832

9 90+600 Jhanya ( Kachotiya ) Partapgarh 899 Kachotiya 0.057 Badya meena s/o rupa meena Document not available

10 90+700 Jhanya ( Kachotiya ) Partapgarh 822, 907 Kachotiya 0.186 Pyara, Hur ji, Naag ji s/o Kachru ji RJ/17/127/216237, RJ/17/127/216385

11 89+365 Kachotiya Partapgarh 403 Kachotiya 0.012 Huak ji s/o thawra RJ/19/127/216626

12 88+600 Kachotiya Partapgarh 321 Kachotiya 0.002 Rupli, Hurji s/o pyara meena RJ/19/127/216633, RJ/17/127/216043

13 102+950 Kataro ka kheda B Partapgarh 198 Kataro ka kheda 0.015 Asiya,ditiya.Rakma,Bheriya s/o Bhaniya

RJ/16/130/540154 ,RJ/16/130/540156

,LJC/1304781, RJ /16/130/540059

14 102+700 Kataro ka kheda B Partapgarh 316. ,317 Kataro ka kheda 0.091 Bhulki w/o Jhaniya RJ/16/130/540221


No.


property

Affected


Exact

Chainage(m)

location


15 105+100 Kataro ka kheda A Partapgarh 863 Kataro ka kheda 0.055 Oukar meena LJC/1550557

16 105+200 Kataro ka kheda A Partapgarh 864 Kataro ka kheda 0.009 Savji s/o rup ji bheel RJ/16/130/564349

17 118+000 Dungri pada( pipal khunt ) Partapgarh 1857/1 Dungri pada( pipal khunt ) 0.012 Parbhu, Rupa, Shankar s/o Nathu RJ/16/130/16180

18 117+650 Dungri pada( pipal khunt ) Partapgarh 1801.1802.1806 Dungri pada( pipal khunt ) 0.083 Rupla,Hakriya,Maniya, s/o Mangliya, Amra

RJ/16/130/52221, RJ/16/130/517028

, RJ/16/130/516088

19 118+050 Dungri pada( pipal khunt ) Partapgarh 1855 Dungri pada( pipal khunt ) 0.028 kalyan singh,Bapu lal s/o Bahadur singh

RJ/16/130/516072

20 118+100 Dungri pada( pipal khunt ) Partapgarh 1852, 1851 Dungri pada( pipal khunt ) 0.088 Nanka, Pasiya s/o Dala Bheel RJ/ 16/130/516144

21 118+000 Dungri pada( pipal khunt ) Partapgarh 1977, 1976 Dungri pada( pipal khunt ) 0.121 Dhuliya s/o Hur ji RJ/16/130/516490


No.


property

Affected


Exact

Chainage(m)

location


22 92+800 Kadbaliya( pipal khunt ) Partapgarh 629 Kadbaliya( pipal khunt ) Rakma s/o kachriya meena RJ/16/30/519025

23 115+500 Kadbaliya( pipal khunt ) Partapgarh 2213/5,1955/105 Kadbaliya( pipal khunt ) Ravjii /so Badiya RJ/16/130/519072 BPL Card No. 635/1687457

24 99+600 Kadbaliya( pipal khunt ) Partapgarh 621, 620 Kadbaliya( pipal khunt ) 0.101 Kanti s/o ManjiRJ/16/131/520080 ,

03396100/937, 08/0028/0002

25 115+900 Kadbaliya( pipal khunt ) Partapgarh5159/654 .5169/666, 646Kadbaliya( pipal khunt ) 0.208 Khem ji , gam ji , s/o Hira meena RJ/16/130/52009 , RJ/ 13510/ 0000/6053

26 116+300 Kadbaliya( pipal khunt ) Partapgarh 5270 / 1617 Kadbaliya( pipal khunt ) 0.22 Punam chand s/o rakma Bheel Ration card no. 48/1687486

27 116+100 Pipal khunt Partapgarh 645 , 644 , 642 Pipal khunt 0.140 Goutam , Pnchiya , s/o Hemla Bheel

RJ/ 16/130/520114 , RJ/ 16/130/52107

28 105+600 Pipal khunt Partapgarh 873 ,866 Pipal khunt 0.254 Parbhu/ Devli LJC/ 1864768


No.


property

Affected


Exact

Chainage(m)

location


29 93+100 Pipal khunt Partapgarh 626 Pipal khunt 0.006 Maniya , Phuliya, s/o Lal ji Bheel RJ/16/130/520030 , RJ/16/130/520027

30 105+300 Pipal khunt Partapgarh 868 , 867 Pipal khunt 0.190 Mangi lal s/o Ganga ram RJ/ 16/130/586104

31 118+050 Pipal khunt Partapgarh 1856 Pipal khunt 0.018 Kishor s/o Narayan LJC/ 2007433

32 116+310 Pipal khunt Partapgarh 786 Pipal khunt 0.038 Phuliya meena s/o Raniya meena LJC/ 1800382

33 105+650 Pipal khunt Partapgarh 875, 874 Pipal khunt 0.230 Ramala s/o Hab ji RJ/16/130/522177

34 99+650 Maknpura Partapgarh 82 Makanpura 0.009 Nand lal s/o Kalu meena RJ/17/127/325000

35 117+300 Manohar garh Partapgarh 1052 manohargarh 0.247 Ram lal s/o Udiya FQS/1444751


No.


property

Affected


Exact

Chainage(m)

location


36 92+400 Chayan Partapgarh 633 ,63 ,64 , 65 Chayan 0.396 Prem chand S/I Gotya , partu RJ/19/127/210725 , RJ/17/127/2111400

37 94+400 Chayan Partapgarh490 , 432 ,431,433,430 Chayan 0.180 Asiya ram s/o rawa meena RJ/17/127/21091

38 93+000 Chayan Partapgarh 108 Chayan 0.018 Mangi lal s/o Chokla meena Document Not Available

39 87+545 Pdliya Partapgarh 159 Padliya 0.146 Ashi w/o kalu s/o Naag ji RJ/17/127/324321

40 87+400 Pdliya Partapgarh 116 Padliya 0.096 Bheru lal s/o Dhanna RJ/17/127/324456

41 87+800 Pdliya Partapgarh 125 Padliya 0.024 Amba lal s/o Kisan ji RJ/17/127/324173

42 87+500 Pdliya Partapgarh 161 Padliya 0.300 Naag ji, s/o Raminga RJ/17/127/324183 , Ac/6161876222


No.


property

Affected


Exact

Chainage(m)

location


43 96+100 Banjari Partapgarh 45 Banjari 0.005 Bheru lal ,Nanda lal s/o Kaalu ram RJ/17/127/204712

44 100+400 Semliya Partapgarh 547 Semliya 0.046 Jivan lal, dudiya,khem ji,bhvana s/o Vagla

RJ/16/130/537433

45 102+600 Vakhatpura ( Semliya ) Partapgarh 101 Vakhtpur ( Semliya ) 0.038 Kachru , Naag ji meena s/o rama meena

RJ/16/130/537073 , RJ /16/130/538256

46 91+900 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 365 Mota Maynga 0.114 Lila devi , w/o Sahab ji s/o Kaalu meena

RJ / 17/127/213019

47 91+800 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 298 , 312 , 364 Mota Maynga 0.184 Pyara meena s/o Heeram meena RJ/17/127/213266

48 91+450 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 253 , 254 , 256 Mota Maynga 0.152 Mangi lal , Bheru lal , Kanhya lal, Rupa, Kanti lal s/o Fuliya

RJ/17/127/213170 , RJ/17/213175

, RJ/17/127/213173

49 91+600 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 270 , 271 Mota Maynga 0.121 Jagdish S/o Arjun Meena RJ/17/127/213107


No.


property

Affected


Exact

Chainage(m)

location


50 91+900 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 118 , 113 Mota Maynga 0.171 Gamera s/o Naag ji RJ/17/127/213288, RJ /17/127/213109

51 91+700 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 362 , 363 Mota Maynga 0.371 Nariya s/o Deva meena RJ/17/127/213366

52 88+800 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 366 Mota Maynga 0.019 Kisan, Mohan, Dhariya s/o Nath ji RJ/17//127/213248

53 92+200 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 105 , 391 Mota Maynga 0.213 Kan ji s/o Kamji RJ/17/127/213673

54 91+300 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 246 Mota Maynga 0.107 Jyet W/o Nanda S/o Nathya BPL Card number- 19317

55 91+100 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 317 , 235 Mota Maynga 0.522 Rupa mangliya s/o Mngliya ram Ration card number- 1049

56 92+000 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 385 , 386 Mota Maynga 0.019 Kahanya Lal S/o Jeeva ram RJ/17/127/0201835


No.


property

Affected


Exact

Chainage(m)

location


57 91+250 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 244 , 245 Mota Maynga 0.122 Rupa mangliya s/o Mngliya ram Ration card number- 481

58 91+200 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 234 , 268 , 269 Mota Maynga 0.162Nakuda, heera, Rav ji , Mohan ,

Bheru , bapuda s/o Hav ji , Lachi, Kadvi

Job Card n. -7

59 91+440 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 267 Mota Maynga 0.111 Gotam , Baala ram, laxman,kawar , Jitendra s/o Lalu ram

RJ/17/127/213201 , FQS/1539642

60 91+400 Mota Maynga Partapgarh 256 Mota Maynga 0.104 Laxam las s/o Kamji meena RJ/17/127/213176

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location

Name of Village DistrictKhasra

No.

Affected land(

Hect)Owner/ Occupier of Land ID Proff

1144+100

144+200Padoli Gordhan Banswara 137 , 138 , 139 0.164 Dhuli w/o Kanheya lal

Dhuli: RJ/16/130/186200 ,

Kanhaiya; RJ/16/130/186275

2 143+900 Padoli Gordhan Banswara 90 , 91 0.128 Khatiya s/o Kubla Khatiya: RJ/16//130/186190

3 144+100 Padoli Gordhan Banswara 130 0.1 Laliya s/o Kubla Laliya: RJ/16/130/1862111

Photo

4 144+200 Padoli Gordhan Banswara 143 0.037Parbhu , Laxman , Ramesh ,

s/o Jivna Prabhu; RJ/16/130/186512

5 144+200 Padoli Gordhan Banswara 142 0.044 Vithli w/o Rupa bheel Vithli: RJ/16/130/186368

6 144+300 Padoli Gordhan Banswara 147 , 148 , 149 0.034Kaliya, vaag ji , Meg ji , s/o nanu,

Suraj mal , Vijay pal

vaag ji: RJ/16/130/186052

Kaliya: RJ /16/130/186073

,Megji: RJ /16/130/186050

7 143+800 Padoli Gordhan Banswara50 , 51 , 52 , 53 , 54

, 55 , 56 , 57 , 58 0.125 Raj mal s/o Jivat ram Rajmal: LJC/ 161232

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(

Hect)Owner/ Occupier of Land ID Proff Photo

8 162+600 Jana medi Banswara 521/3 0.004 Patu w/o Laxman Maddar s/o Raju RJ/16/131/379028

9 162+700 Jana medi Banswara 564/2 0.021Hakru S/o Dhulia, Vithli w/o Motiya ,

galbi

RJ/16/131/406263,RJ/16/131/4

06143,AWOPM/3582BRJ

,16/16/131/405295,RJ/16/131/

4006094

10 159+200 Sevna Banswara 117 0.222Pansu s/o Nani devi w/o Lt. Nanu s/o

Jeeva

Nanu: RJ/16/131/384132,

Nani: RJ/16/131/384131

Rakhiya: RJ/16/131/384151 ,

11 159+200 Sevna Banswara 134 0.116Udai lal s/o Rakhiya, Geba s/o Dhul ji

, Babli w/o Dhul ji

Rakhiya: RJ/16/131/384151 ,

Geba: SDC/0104521 ,

Babli : RJ/16/131/384723,

Udaylal: 146/1525725

12 158+900 Sevna Banswara 702/142 0.227 Heng ji s/o Dev ji , Kodri w/o Dev ji Hengji: RJ/16/131/384213

13 159+100 Sevna Banswara 136 0.040 Dhul ji s/o Naru ji Dhul ji : RJ/16/129/424002

14 159+600 Sevna Banswara 96/1 0.440Partu, Nanka s/o Her ji , Pyari w/o

Her ji

Partu: RJ/16/131/384017 ,

Nanka: Rj/16/131/384038

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


15 159+100 Sevna Banswara 140 , 139 , 138 0.509Hakru , Veer ji , Narayan, S/o

Nathuda , Jamna, W/o NathudaRation Card no. 24/1

16

159+300

159+400

159+500

Sevna Banswara 118 , 119 , 105 , 103 0.475

Kaliya, Rupa, Kaniya, Rkiya s/o Kem

ji, Rama, Balu,

Ramesh, Rupa s/o Jor ji rajeng ji s/o

Laxman

Rupa: Rj/16/131/384208,

Rakhiya: RJ/16/131/384027

17 159+300 Sevna Banswara 120 0.008

Kereng, Ramtu, w/o Humla,, Kaliya

jeeva, Man ji,m Chagan, Dalu Hur ji

, veer ji ranga, Lem ji

Raju: RJ/16/131/384669,

Kereng: RHLB/1207679 ,

Ramtu: RJ/16/131/384670

18 159+100 Sevna Banswara 138 0.071 Gebi lal s/o Nathuda, Geba s/o Dhul ji Gebi lal : SCD/0140521 ,

Babli: RJ/16/131/384723

19 159+400 Sevna Banswara 104/1 0.163 Rama, Thawra s/o Goutam s/o KerengRama: RJ/16/131/384055,

Thawra: RJ/16/31/384767

20 159+800 Sevna Banswara 33 0.152

Laxman, Kathriya, s/o Hur ji Jivna,

Galiya, nanniya, s/o Deepa, rav ji ,

Nathuda, Kaniya, sankar s/o Goutam

Bheel

Shankar: RJ/16/131/304067 ,

Ashu: HLB/1208172 ,

Kachru: SDC/407783,

nanniya: RJ/16/131/384775,

Fuliya: RJ16/16/131/384792,

Jivna: RJ/1/131/384824,

Kaniya: RJ/16/131/384786

21 163+600 Kupda Banswara 284 0.078Kachru, Parbhu, arvind, S/o Unkar,

Lala, Dhuli w/o Lala RJ/16/131/361151

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


22163+800

163+900Kupda Banswara 288/1 , 307 0.234 Vithla s/o Kenwa bheel HLB/1031657

23 163+700 Kupda Banswara 1168/282 0.128Ganga w/o Rameng / Vanita d/o

Rameng

RJ/16/131/361563 ,

RJ/16/131/361343

24 163+700 Kupda Banswara 287/1 0.164 Mani lal s/o Mangliya Bheel BPL no. S-28-0004-2706

25163+500

163+700Kupda Banswara 1279 , 332 ,285 0.078 Mrs. Ratna Ramu w/o badiya

RJ/16/131/361479 ,

RJ/16/131/361478

26 163+700 Kupda Banswara 287/2 0.164Jeeva, parkash s/o Vithla / kamla w/o

VithlaRJ/16/131/361203

27 165+000 Shivpura ( Kupda ) Banswara 1378 0.247Kachru,kaalu s/o Sapi Parta Ninaya

BheelKachru: HLB/1382167

28 165+400 Shivpura ( Kupda ) Banswara 1826/1371 0.003 Lali w/o naag ji Lali: HLB/1031937

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


29165+300

165+500Shivpura ( Kupda ) Banswara 1933/1371 , 1830/1371 0.029 Savita , akesar, kamla

Savita: RJ/16/131/361346,

Kamla: RJ/16/131/361359

30165+300

165+400Shivpura ( Kupda ) Banswara

1931/1371 , 1932/1372

, 1829/13710.369

Kachru, parteg, Darak s/o Goutam,

Nathu , nararyan s/o Ravji , Rangi

w/o rav ji Bheel

HLB/1374321

31 165+500 Shivpura ( Kupda ) Banswara 1958/1371 0.017Dhul ji s/o khatia s/o Dhuliya, Khatu

s/o ManegaDhulji: RJ/16/131/361393

32 165+400Mahadev ka temba

(Kupda )Banswara 1827/1371 0.072 Manji, Laxman

Manji: RJ/16/131/364059 ,

Laxman; RJ/16/131/363452

33 165+500Mahadev ka temba

( Kupda )Banswara 1828/1371 0.162

Tulsi w/o Dev ji s/o Kuber , Laxman,

SankarTulsi: RJ/16/131/363512

34 165+500Ganpatpura

(Kupda)Banswara 1831/1371 0.0.11 Goutam s/o Motiya Bheel Goutam: SDC/0107193

35 166+100 Bhachdiya Banswara 658/386 0.209 Rama s/o Mangliya bheel RJ/16/129/234038

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


36 166+000 Bhachdiya Banswara 659/386 0.040 Neema w/o Laxman s/o Naag ji HKW/1393628

37 166+300 Bhachdiya Banswara 641 , 380 0.214Suresh , Hardar, Vithli w/o Kereng

s/o HakruIFT/0095927 , HKW/1393750

38 166+600 Bhachdiya Banswara 544 0.020

Rj/16/129/235432 ,

HKW/1602606 ,

RJ/16/129/235440

,RJ/16/129/235388,

RJ/16/129/235312

39 166+400 Bhachdiya Banswara 542/380/1/1 0.233 Ladki w./o Kam ji s/o Vithla Bheel RJ/16/129/235380

40 165+900 Bhachdiya Banswara 661/386 0.060 Ramesh s/o Vithla Ration card no. 7/8

41 166+350 Bhachdiya Banswara 639/380 0.448 Amreng s/o Kuria , Rasi w/o vithla HKW/2065977

42 167+800 Amarpura Banswara 55 , 53 0.036deva s/o Bhoga / Pema w/o Bhoga

bheelRJ/16/129/237307

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


43 167+700 Amarpura Banswara 36/1 0.233Kaalu s/o kachru s/o Rama / Heera,

Sattu s/o Bhema

RJ/16/129/237167 ,

RJ/16/129/237224 ,

HKW/1742402

44 167+800 Amarpura Banswara 57/1 , 57/2 0.134 Dhuli w/o Dev Chrpota bheel Ration card no. 2k6/16

45167+500

167+700Amarpura Banswara 34 , 279/34 , 36/2 0.144

Laxman , kaalu , deliya, Lalashankar

s/o Goutam

RJ/16/129/237210 ,

RJ/16/129/237381 ,

IFT/0095026

46 168+300 Amarpura Banswara 62 0.039 Heera, Rupa s/o HakruRJ/16/129/237162 ,

RJ/16/129/237526

47 167+500 Amarpura Banswara 327/32 , 33 0.040Babli w/o Rupa bheel s/o Hakriya

bheel

RJ/16/129/237162 ,

RJ/16/129/237526

48 160+600 Badgaon Banswara 1596/597 0.171 Rakesh , Amrat w/o Parta Amrat: RJ/16/131/375175

49 160+700 Badgaon Banswara 799 0.089 Hur ji , Vithla s/o Kachru Hur ji : HLB/1569144

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


50 160+100 Badgaon Banswara 583/1 0.017 Ramesh, Gebi lal Ramesh: RJ/16/131/378138

51161+300

161+500Badgaon Banswara 1131/705 , 1134/705 0.260 Bheem ji s/o Majuda bheel Bheem ji: RJ/16/131/378230

52 161+000 Badgaon Banswara 1553/789 0.019 Indra w/o Goutam lalGoutam Lal:

RJ/16/131/375095

53 160+850 Badgaon Banswara 614 0.009 kishor s/o Man ji Kishor: HLB/1524438

54 160+600 Badgaon Banswara 596 0.123Lal ji , dhula , s/o Deepa / Badu w/o

deepaAdhar no. 632707402954

55 161+000 Badgaon Banswara 789 0.064 Narseng s/o Hakru Narseng: SDC/0301028

56 160+200 Badgaon Banswara 586/1 0.282 Ramesh,kamji, Nana lal

Ramesh: RJ/16/131/378138 ,

Nanka: RJ/16/131/379041 ,

Kamji: RJ/16/131/378262

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


57 161+400 Badgaon Banswara 1133/705 0.156 Khattu s/o Vajegiya bheel RJ/16/131/378191

58 161+340 Badgaon Banswara 1132/705 0.121Gotiya , Rav ji, Virji s/o Jivna , Vesti

w/o JivnaDocument not available

59 160+700 Badgaon Banswara 798 0.086 Nar ji s/o Kachru Nar Ji: RJ/16/13/375233

60 160+700 Badgaon Banswara 1589/798 0.072 Dhul ji s/o Kachru ji Dhul Ji: RJ/16/131/375200

61 161+200 Badgaon Banswara 702 0.051 Parkash s/o Goutam s/o Homla bheel Prakash:HLB/1555168

62 161+400 Badgaon Banswara 992/705 0.074 Meera w/o Mohan s/o Vajengiya Meera: RJ/16/131/378278

63 160+500 Badgaon ( Dangpada ) Banswara 593 , 594 0.093 Naag ji s/o Kereng Nag Ji: RJ/16/131/379018

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


64 160+900 Badgaon ( Dangpada ) Banswara 791 , 1578/791 100.117Amrut lal s/o Laxman Bheel / Lalita

w/o amrut lal

Amrut lal : Adhar no.

727370205979 , Lalita:

HLB/2067437

65 160+400 Badgaon ( Dangpada ) Banswara 575 0.146 Man ji s/o Dhulia RJ/16/131/378145

66 161+055 Badgaon ( Dangpada ) Banswara 696/1 , 695/2 0.166 reena w/o raman lal s/o laxman bheel

Raman Lal: Adhar card -

527332196569 , Reena: IFT

/0255349

67 161+100 Badgaon ( Dangpada ) Banswara 693/3 0.002 Durga s/o Laxman Durga: HLB/2067270

68 160+300 Badgaon ( Dangpada ) Banswara 576/1 , 592/1 0.568 Lalu s/o Kereng Lalu: RJ/16/129/282591

69 161+140 Badgaon ( Dangpada ) Banswara 696/2 0.121 Meeraw/o Vijayman Meera: RJ/16/131/378208

70 161+058 Badgaon ( Dangpada ) Banswara 695/1 0.103 Santosh s/o Vijaypal Santosh: HLB/2067429

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


71 161+600 Badgaon ( Dangpada ) Banswara 964/705 0.191 Sambhu lal s/o Goutam s/o Dhariya Gotam Lal: RJ/16/131/378228

72 160+800 Badgaon (Ganpatpura) Banswara 769 0.064 Vithla s/o Valeng pargi bheel Vithla: RJ/16/131/363097

73 141+325 Devda Banswara 1169 0.002 shankar , Laxman s/o gang ji bheel LJC/1384189

74 144+300 Padoli Gordhan Banswara 148 0.009 Surajmal S/O Pownya BhillShanti Lal: RJ/16/131/384558 ,

Kamla: RJ/16/131/384881

75 146+000 Sagthali Banswara 709/142 Lalit s/o Har ji Harji: RJ/16/131/384443

76 146+300 Sagthali Banswara 386 , 384 0.023 Kesav lal s/o Dev jiKesav: RJ/16/130/180361 ,

RJ/16/130/180051

77 145+725 Sagthali Banswara 257 0.008 Joint Khata

Lalshankar: BLP/196/1611463

, Nakasi: LJC/1377704,

Lakshmi: RJ/16/130/18117 ,

Mangali: RJ/16/130/181078 ,

Lalu: RJ/16/130/180565

Khaturam: RJ/16/130/180561

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


78 146+340 Sagthali Banswara 391 0.027Ramchndra, lalu, Toliya s/o dla, Soni

w/o Dala

Ramchandra:

RJ/16/130/180339 , Lalu:

RJ/16/130/180565

79 146+100 Sagthali Banswara 371 , 372 , 374, 392 0.046Heera ,Narayan, s/o rakma, Hur ji,

Bhaniya, s/o Punjiya RJ/16/130/180446

80 145+700 Sagthali Banswara 256 0.009Narayan , Heera lal , Rakma s/o

PunjiyaRukma: RJ/16/130/180560

81 118+740 Mudasel Banswara 2010 0.072Bahadur , munsi, s/o jeeta , Jeg ji

devi/ w/o jeevaRJ/16/130/417227

82 118+600 Mudasel Banswara 2005 0.076 rakma s/o Maliya RJ/16/130/411113

83 119+245 Mudasel Banswara1944 , 1942 , 2013 ,

20140.111 Rakma s/o Dhuliya

RJ/16/130/435146 ,

LJC/2031953

84 119+100 Mudasel Banswara 1949 0.200 Rakma RJ/16/130/435557

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


85 120+600 Mudasel Banswara 14 0.085 Hakri w/o Lalu S/o Lakhma bheel RJ/16/130/435428

86 121+150 Mudasel Banswara 890 0.007

Dhani, Kamji s/o Nathu, hurji, w/o

Paru,

Jivna, Devi lal s/o Fulia

RJ/16130/318171 ,

VBM/0057059 ,

RJ/16/130/435610,

RJ/16/130/435607,

RJ/16/130/435050

87 121+300 Mudasel Banswara 234 , 233 , 232 0.093 Mogla , Chokla , Lalu s/o LakhmaRJ/16/130/435190 ,

RJ/16/130/43515

88 143+900 Mudasel Banswara 86 0.075 Deliya s/o veniya LJC/1487248

89 118+900 Mudasel Banswara 2016 0.008 Kan ji s/o Rakma bheel YBW/214460

90 119+100 Mudasel ( Borfikhata ) Banswara 1950 , 1948 0.126 Rakla , Jivna s/o Gotam bheel LJC/1632975

91 118+800 Mudasel (Singhpura) Banswara 2015 0.049Nanka, Khemla, Daliya, Puniya, s/o

ChtriyaRJ/16/130/435551

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


92 118+700 Mudasel (Pauti) Banswara 2011 , 2012 0.06 hakri w/o Rupa RJ/16/130/516137

93 157+960 Makod Banswara 762/470 0.034

Mani la s/o Nanki w/o Hukia / Hakri,

mariy,

Fulki , Ranki , W/o MAn ji bheel

RJ/16/129/429094

94 158+600 Makod Banswara 416 0.239 Toliya s/o Punja bheel RJ/16/129/429117

IFT/0022137, HKW/1713593 ,

95 158+000 Makod Banswara 643/470 0.251Rakma, Mani lal, Parbhu, Dinesh s/o

Khatiya s/o Vithla

IFT/0022137, HKW/1713593 ,

RJ/16/129/429528,

RJ/16/129/429478

96 158+200 Makod Banswara 436 0.493 Deepa s/o HurjiRJ/16/129/429061 ,

RJ/16/129/430059

97 158+600 Makod (Saliya dungri) Banswara 483 0.049 Kaalu , Bhaniya s/o Bhem ji RJ/16/129/429443

98 158+250 Makod Banswara 452 0.046 Kaliya s/o Hemla Bheel ID Proff not available

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


99 147+300 Jedla Banswara 1478 0.151Jeeva , Harji, Toliya, Laxman,

manshankr

RJ/16/130/180445 ,

RJ/16/130/180058

100 147+400 Jedla Banswara 1483 0.086 Surta w/o manshankr LJC/1376748

101 147+200 Jedla Banswara 1476 , 1477 0.075 Hema, Heera, Nrayan, s/o rakma,

RJ/16/130/180019 ,

RJ/16/130/80546

,RJ/16/130/180279

102 147+300 Jedla Banswara 1441, 1464 0.586 Laxman s/o Kachru RJ/16/130/181058

103 168+700 Odhar ka pada Banswara 3//2 0.051 Thanu s/o Thawara RJ/16/129/250425

104 168+700 Odhar ka pada Banswara 3//3 0.051 Shankar s/o Hur ji s/o Thawra ji Kali: HKW/1407329

105 168+700 Odhar ka pada Banswara 2 0.109Gotam , Dinesh s/o Mani lal , Arjun

s/o Heera

Gautam: HKW/1604750 ,

Heera: HKW/1407501

Sanjay: SCD/0288498

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


106 168+700 Odhar ka pada Banswara 3//1 0.051 Deva, Lala, s/o Thawra HKW/1407287

107 125+100 Hilage Banswara 620 , 619 0.015 Lalu , s/o Fuliya , Vanki w/o fuliya RJ/16/130/439023

108 125+050 Hilage Banswara 611 0.066 Sawla , s/o Umji bheel RJ/16/130/439020

109 125+150 Hilage Banswara 621 , 622 0.026 Parta , Manji s/o Naksi bheel RJ/16/130/438190

110124+700

124+900Hilage Banswara 562 , 563 , 564 , 565 0.09 Ramchandra s/o habji

RJ/16/130/438165 ,

RJ/16/130/438187

111 123+770 Hilage Banswara 780 0.010 Dev ji s/o Rakma Rj/16/130/438342

112 124+500 Hilage Banswara 549 0.052 Bhagwaniya s/o Maliya Rj/16/130/438107

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


113 125+900 Hilage (Sadri) Banswara 609 / 574 0.128 Punji w/o Jeeva s/o BhartaRJ/16/130/258223 ,

RJ/16/130/358296

114 126+800 Hilage ( Sadri ) Banswara 179-180 0.012 Man ji s/o Vagla bheel RJ/16/130/358341

115 126+900 Hilage ( Sadri ) Banswara 185 , 186 , 187 0.087Laxman, Dhan ji, s/o Jivla, heera,

Bhaniya, laxman s/o vaag jiRJ/16/130/358404

116 126+400 Hilage ( Sadri ) Banswara 546 0.021 Bhem ji s/o Naag ji RJ/16/130/358018

117 126+000 Hilage ( Sadri ) Banswara 576 0.114 vakta s/o Teza RJ/16/130/358248

118 127+100 Hilage ( Sadri ) Banswara 189 0.018 Nariya s/o Hur ji RJ/16/130/358257

119 127+600 Hilage ( Vadlapada ) Banswara 7,3 0.004 Jeeva s/o Kaan ji RJ/462/1638611

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


120 156+530 Tezpur Banswara 638 0.107 Badiya s/o Hakriya RJ/16/129/438164

121 156+500 Tezpur Banswara 637 , 634 0.076 Laxman , Man ji s/o Dhar ji Ration card no. 515/1697700

122 171+100 Tezpur Banswara 384 0.030 Rakma, Rang ji s/o Kaliya, Punjiya

RJ/16/129/438215,

RJ/16/129/435382 ,

RJ/16/129/435248

123 157+600 Tezpur Banswara 925 0.219Kesar devi w/o Vithla s/o Meneg

BheelRJ/16/131/438344

124 167+000 Dashara Banswara 251/198 0.330Rupa, heera, Lasiya, Hakriya, s/o Jag

ji

Kamla:RJ/16/129/237490

, Hakriya: HKW/1603547,

Samrat: RJ/16/129/237037

125 167+000 Dashara Banswara 253/198 0.314 Jeevi w/o Hakru , Vithal s/o Balu Balu: HKW/1603729

126 167+000 Dashara Banswara 257/198 0.377 Kachri w/o Heera Heera:RJ/16/129/237048

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


127 167+000 Dashara Banswara 252/198 0.068 Vithul lal ji, narayan s/o Heera Vithuli: RJ/16/129/237328

128 172+300 Sagrod Banswara 181/2 0.100Huka, Heera, Hriya, s/o Kachru, Tola,

W/o kachru

HKW/1367713 ,

HKW/1776400,

RJ/161/129171317

129 172+800 Sagrod Banswara 172/1, 171/1/1 0.793

Dhuliya, Ramchandra. Laxman,

Harish Chandra, Badrinarayan,

Mohan, Arjun s/o Late Rakma, Nagri

W/o Rakma

HKW/1367580

130 172+600 Sagrod Banswara 171/1/2, 172/2 0.198 Lalu s/o kachru bhil RJ/16/129/171191

131 169+100 Borwat Banswara 372 0.014 Kodar , Kam ji, hur jiKamji: SDC/0011007 , Kador:

RJ/16/129/255029

132 169+040 Borwat Banswara 371 0.010Devi lal s/o Lal ji , Laxman s/o Vithla

s/o amreng

Kachari: RJ/16/129/255222,

Lalji: RJ/16/129/255330 , Lasi:

RJ/16/129/255042, Laxman:

817

133 169+300 Borwat Banswara 368 0.037Kachru s/o Abndiya , Ukriya, Laxmi,

kalu, s/o badiyaRJ/16/129/255064

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


134 169+000 Borwat Banswara 370 0.49Lal ji , Ranchod, Akchri, Laxman, s/o

Vithla

Lasi: RJ/16/129/255042,

Kachari: RJ/16/129/255222,

Lalji: Rj/16/129/255330,

Dapulal: RJ/16/129/255257,

Laxman: 817

135 151+800 Bhagtpura Banswara 68/1 0.040 Kam ji s/o Hiriya bheel RJ/16/129/451026

136 151+700 Bhagtpura Banswara 40/1 0.024 Sharda w/o Babu Meena s/o Shivlal HKW/1655265

Shambhu, rup singh s/o Toliya,

RJ/16/129/438268,

RJ/16/129/438183,

137 156+400 Hadmtiya Banswara 297 0.048

Shambhu, rup singh s/o Toliya,

Dhnki, w/o Toliya, Bhan ji s/o

Lakhiya

RJ/16/129/438183,

HKW/2060556,

RJ/16/129/439018,

Rj/16/129/438269,Rj/16/129/4

38187

138 156+000 Hadmtiya Banswara 332 0.009Babulal,Shambhu, Gattu, Vijaylal,

Kanku W/o kamji

Rj/16/129/438201,

Rj/16/129/438202

139 152+800 Surpur Banswara 67/1 , 63 0.083 Vithli,w/o balu bheelRJ/16/129/441322,

RJ/16/129/442038

140 153+900 Surpur Banswara 858/1 0.008 Rakma, Bhagu, trawati s/o Hur ji RJ/16/129/441564

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


141 153+200 Surpur Banswara 474/1 0.128 Shankar, gabhu, Unkar, kawdi RJ/16/129/441560

142 164+800 Ganpatpura Banswara 86 0.005Laxman, lala, Dilip, raju, Suraj,

Dinesh, s/o Kerng bheel

Rupa: RJ/16/131/131/363294,

Bhagu: RJ/16/131/364028,

Dhulji: RJ/16/131/363114

143 164+670 Ganpatpura Banswara 89 0.108 Rav ji s/o RupaRavji: Rj/16/131//363159 ,

Lila: RJ/16/131/363043

144 150+100 Udpura Banswara 1697, 1698, 1700 0.096 Daya s/o KuberRJ/16/130/174247,

LJC/1375807

145 132+700 Sevniya Banswara 654, 653 0.046Rajudi w/o Lalera, vesti s/o Late

manjiLJC/1640275

146 168+100 Tamtiya Banswara 140 0.063 Rajesh s/o Kam jiD/l non . RJ-03-13460

,RJ/16/129/250287

147 148+850 Senawasa Banswara 1452 0.103- lal ji s/o Kaliya LJC/1373166

SL.N

O

Exact

Chainage(m)

location


No.

Affected land(


148 130+300 Uda ji Ghda Banswara 348 0.013 Jivna s/o Dhuliya RJ/16/130/345085

ANNEXURE

SOCIAL SURVEY FORM

1

DRAFT NHIIP

Census and Community Asset Survey Schedules

Census Survey Questionnaires

PART: 1 – ASSET INFORMATION

Census Survey Code.

GENERAL A. Questionnaire No: ………B. Subproject Road Name: ..............................................

C. Village: ……..………………D. District: ………………….E. State: ……………

F. Plot No. ........................ G. Km/Chainage……….H. Side 1. Left 2. Right

I. Name of the person answering to survey……………………………………………………………. J. Relation to the owner:…………………………………………………………………………………..

K. Years of Occupation of the Affected Property _____ Years

L. Present Address of the Property: _________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________

M. Mother Tongue ___________ (Hindi-1; Odiya-2; Others-3; in case of others specify.)

DETAILS OF LAND 1. Ownership of the Land

1. Private 2. Government 3. Religious 4. Community 5. Others

2. Type of Land

1. Irrigated 2. Non-Irrigated 3. Barren 4. Forest 5. Other

3. Use of Land

1.Cultivation 2. Orchard 3. Residential 4. Commercial

5. Forestation 6. Others 7. No Use/ Barren

4. Affected area of the Land (in square meter) ..........................................................................

5. Total Area of the Land/Plot (in square meter) ........................................................................

2

6. Rate of the Land (Per sq. m) 1. Market Rate (Rs)................. ………………..

7. Status of Ownership

1. Titleholder (Pvt Owner) 2. Customary Right 3. Encroacher 4. Squatter

8. Name of the Owner/Occupier: ……………...................................................

9. Father’s Name: ........................................................................

10. Name of the owner, if the occupier is tenant…………………………………………………………..

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

11. Total Land Holding (in Acre) …………………………………………..

12. Any of the following people associated with the Land

A. Agricultural Laborer 1. Yes 2. No

(i). If Yes then How many ……………………………………………..

B. Sharecropper 1. Yes 2. No

(ii). If Yes then How many ……………………………………………………………

13. Number of trees within the affected area

1. Total………………2. Fruit Bearing………………3. Non-fruit Bearing………………

DETAILS OF STRUCTURES (cross check with part III) 14. Any structure in the Affected Land 1. Yes........ 2. No..........

15. Area of the affected structure (in Square Meter)

a) Length along the road..............…b) Width perpendicular to the road............….....c) Floor ………

16. Area of the total structure (in Square Meter)

a) Length along the road..............…b) Width perpendicular to the road..............….....c) Floor ………

17. Distance of structure from center line of the road (in mtr.)…………………………

18. Type of Construction of the Structure

1. Temporary (buildings with mud/brick/wood made walls, thatched/tin roof)

2. Semi-Permanent (buildings, with tiled roof and normal cement floor)

3. Permanent (with RCC, Single/ Double storey building)

19. Market Value of the Structure (in Rs.)............................

20. Use of the Structure (select appropriate code from below)

A. Residential Structure 1 House 2 Hut 3 Other ………..

B. Commercial Structure 4 Shops 5. Hotel 6 Small Eatery 7 Kiosk 8 Farm House

9 Petrol Pump 10 Clinic 11 STD Booth 12 Workshop

13 Vendors 14 Com. Complex 15 Industry 16. Restaurant

17. Others……….

C. Mixed Structure 18 Residential-cum-Commercial Structure

3

D. Community Structure 19 Comm. Center 20 Club 21 Trust 22 Memorials 23 Other….

E. Religious Structure 24 Mosque, 25 Shrine 26 Burial 27. Temple 28. Other…

F. Government Structure 29 Govt. Office 30 Hospital 31 School 32 College 33 Other …………

G. Other Structure 34 Boundary Wall 35 Foundation 36 Cattle Shed 37 Well/Tube Well

21. Status of the Structure

1. Legal Titleholder 2. Customary Right 3. Encroacher 4. Squatter

22. Name of the Owner/Occupier: ……………...................................................

23. Father’s Name: ........................................................................

24. Name of the owner, if the occupier is tenant…………………………………………………………..

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

a. Tenure Status…………………………………………….. (Own-1; Rented-2; Leasehold-3)

b. Monthly Rent………………………………………………

c. Utility Connection…………………………………………(1-Electricity; 2- Water; 3- Sewer)

25. Any of the following people associated with the Structure?

A. Employee/ wage earner in commercial structure 1. Yes 2. No

(i). If Yes, How Many?……………………………………………………..

B. Employee/ wage earner in residential structure 1. Yes 2. No

(ii). If Yes, How Many?.……………………………………………………..

26. Number of trees within the affected area

1. Total………………2. Fruit Bearing………………3. Non-fruit Bearing………………

27. Social Category

1. SC 2. ST 3. OBC 4. General 5. Others (specify)…………………………

28. Religious Category

1. Muslim 2. Hindu 3. Other (specify)…………

29. Vulnerability Status of the Household:

A. Is it a woman headed household? 1. Yes 2. No

B. Is it headed by physically/mentally challenged person? 1. Yes 2. No

C. Is it a household Below Poverty Line (BPL) 1. Yes 2. No

D. If BPL, provide BPL card number-------------------------------------------

30. Monthly income of the family in (Total of Q.No. 36) Rs.………….

Resettlement and Rehabilitation Option

4

31. Willing to shift 1. Voluntarily 2. Non-voluntarily

32. Assistance Option

1. Self Relocation

2. Cash for Land loss

3. Cash for House/ Shop loss

4. Project Assistance

33. Income Restoration Assistance (The most preferred option)

1. Employment Opportunities in Construction work

2. Assistance/ Loan from other ongoing development scheme

3. Vocational Training

4. Others (specify .................................................................................................... )

34. Other Support from Project (Specify)

....................................................................................................

5

Part II

SOCIOECONOMIC DETAILS

35. Name of the Head of the Household………………………………………………………

36. Number of family members Total………….Male………..Female…………

Details of Family Members above 18 years of age: (fill appropriate code)

Sl. No

Name of Persons Relationship with

Head of the Household

Sex (M/F)

Age Marital Status

Educational Qualification

Main Occupation

Monthly Income

Other Occupation

Monthly Income

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

11.

12.

13.

14.

15.

16.

Marital Status: Married-1; Unmarried-2; Divorcee-3; Separate-4; Widowed-5;

Educational Qualification: Illiterate-1; Primary Schooling-2; Upper Primary Schooling-3; High School-4; Graduate-5; Post-Graduate-6; Technical-7

Occupation : Cultivator-1: Agricultural Labourer-2; Daily Wage Earner-3; Salaried-4; Business- 6; Other-7; in case of others specify.

37. Possession of Material /Assets (Please Record Numbers)

Television Tape Recorder

Radio Refrigerator Telephone Vehicles Cooking Gas

Any Other (specify) Cycles Three

Wheeler Two-

Wheeler Four

Wheeler Bus / Truck

37 Live Stock Assets (Please Record Numbers)

Classification Cows Buffaloes Sheep Goats Poultry

Others

Give Number

37. Likely Loss of Other Assets

Tree Well Other Category I (Specify) Individual Assets

No. Species No. Type No.

38. Participation in economic activities of family members

S.No. Economic/Non-economic Activities Male Female Both

1 Cultivation

2 Allied Activities (Dairy, Poultry, Sheep rearing, etc.)

3 Collection and Sale of forest products

4 Trade & Business

5 Agricultural Labor

6 Non Agricultural Labor

7 HH Industries

8 Service

S.No. Economic/Non-economic Activities Male Female Both

9 Households Work

10 Collection of Water

11 Collection of Fuel

12 Others (Specify):

38. Decision making and participation at Household Level

Sl. No. Subject Male Female Both

1 Financial matter

2 Education of child

3 Health care of child

4 Purchase of assets

5 Day to day household activities

6 On social function and marriages

7 Women to Earn for Family 8 Land and property

9 Others

39. Women Participation at Community level

1 Do women of the household participate in decision making processes at community level

Yes- 1 No- 2

2 Is any member of the household a member or office bearer of village / block / zilla panchayat? Yes – 1; No – 2; If yes whether such member is male or female?

Male Female

3 Is any women member of the household works as Anganwadi worker or ANM? Yes No 4 Is any household member also a member of any self help groups? Yes - ; No -2

If yes, whether male or female? Male Female

5 If yes, is that SHG still active? Yes No

40. Employment opportunity in the area

1. Seasonal 2. Employed throughout the Year 3. None

41. Do family members migrate for work

S. No. Type of Work In Rs. Per year Do men migrate for work outside the village

Daily -1 Seasonal - 2 Long term – 3 No - 4

Do women also migrate for work outside the village Daily -1 Seasonal - 2 Long term – 3 No - 4

1 Agriculture

2 Shopkeeper/Business (including petty business)

3 Employer (industrialist/Factory/Mill owner, etc)

4 Government Service

5 Private Service

6 Wage Labour (Agriculture)

7 Wage Labour (Non Agriculture)

8 Self employed (insurance, finance, doctor, engineer, lawyer)

9 Not employed (income recipient such as retired, remittance, property rent, bank interest, etc)

10 Household work

13 Others (specify )

Total

42. Quality of Life (Consumption Pattern)

Kindly indicate the consumption/expenditure on different items in last one year

Sl. No. Particulars Monthly Expenditure in Rs.

Rank them from highest to lowest

1 Food

2 Agriculture

3 Housing

4 Cooking Fuel

5 Clothing

Sl. No. Particulars Monthly Expenditure in Rs.

Rank them from highest to lowest

6 Health

7 Education

8 Transport 9 Communication

7 Social functions

Others

43. Loan and Indebtedness

1 Have you taken any loan? 1-Yes, 2-No 2 Who has taken the loan? 1. Head of the HH; 2. Spouse; 3. Son; 4. Daughter

in law; 5.Head and spouse together; 6. Son and Head of the HH; 7. Daughter in law and Mother in law; 8. Other………

3 If yes, tell us sources of loan: 1-Bank, 2-NGO, 3-Money lender, 4-Relative/friend, 5- SHG; 6. Others (specify……………)

4 If yes, Amount of loan (in Rs.) 5 Could you please tell us the purpose of loan? 1-Productive investment, 2-

Purchasing durables, 3-Meeting up emergencies, 4-Marrying of children, 5- Paying off loan, 6-Others (specify………………………)

44. Access to facilities

Code Distance of following facilities/amenities from the location of interview?

Approx. km Mode to access

Frequency Trips made by M/F/Both

1 Primary School 2 Secondary School 3 College 4 Regular Market 5 Commonly visited health service place 6 Hospital 7 District Office 8 Block Office

Mode: Walk-1; Cycle-2; Personal transport-3; Public transport-4;

Frequency: Daily-1; Weekly-2; Monthly-3; Very Rare-4;

45. Health Seeking behaviour

1 Has any of your family members suffered from any disease during last 12 months? 1-Yes, 2-No, 3-Don’t Know

If yes, who suffered:

Code : Men – 1, Women - 2 Both- 3, Boy child- 4 Girl child – 5, Both children - 6

2 If yes, please specify type of disease? 3 Type of treatment taken: 1-Allopathic Government, 2-Allopathic Private, 3-

Allopathic Govt. & Private both, 4- Homeopathy, 5- Ayurved, 6- Faith healers; 7- quacks; 8-No Treatment, 9-Others (specify…………)

4 Which is the nearest formal medical facility available? PHC – 1; CHC- 2; District Hospital – 3; Private clinic – 4; Private Hospital – 5; Others - 6

5 Did you avail any health/medical facility (like medicine, routine check-up, advice from doctor etc.) during the last pregnancy?

Yes - 1 No - 2 Has not been pregnant yet - 3

If coded 1 or 3 skip the next question

6 If no, who attended while giving birth to the baby? (Multiple responses possible)

Females neighbor - 1 relatives and friends - 2 Mother-in-law - 3 Sister-in-law - 4 Others specify - 5

7 Have you heard about HIV/AIDS: Yes 1; No - 2 8 If yes, what is the source? Newspaper –

1; TV- 2; radio- 3; NGO camp– 4; Govt. camp – 5;

Signature of a person Answering the Survey………………………………… (Name of the Investigator) Date: ........................ (Signature of the investigator)

PART III

EXTENT OF LOSS (NOT TO BE ASKED BUT TO BE ASSESSED BY THE INVESTIGATOR) 1. Losing Total House 2. Losing Partial House 3. Losing Total House and part of Plot (Aangan or Courtyard) 4. Losing Total Plot and Total House 5. Losing Total Plot and Partial House 6. Losing Partial Plot 7. Losing Total Commercial Structure 8. Losing Partial Commercial Structure 9. Losing Total Commercial Structure and Partial Plot 10. Losing Total Commercial Structure and Total Plot 11. Losing Partial Commercial Structure and Total Plot 12. Losing Total House and Total Commercial Structure 13. Losing Total House, Total Commercial Structure and Total Plot 14. Losing Total House, Total Commercial Structure 15. Losing Total House, Partial Commercial Structure and Part of Plot 16. Losing Partial House, Partial Commercial Structure and Part of Plot 17. Losing Total House and Partial Commercial Structure 18. Losing Total Commercial Structure and Part of House 19. Losing Total Boundary Wall 20. Losing Partial Boundary Wall 21. Losing Total Agricultural Land 22. Losing Partial Agricultural Land 23. Losing Total Cattle Shed 24. Losing Part of Cattle Shed 25. Losing Water bodies 26. Losing Total Livelihood for Commercial Tenant 27. Others (Specify)

Status of Occupier of affected property

1. Status of Occupier (Tick in the appropriate box)

Owner Legal Tenant/sharecropper

Non-title Holders Vacant

Squatter Encroacher

2. Since how long your family has been using this property (in years) _____________________

3. Do you possess a documentary proof

1. Yes 2. No.

4. If yes, Type of documentary proof of occupation of affected property

Ration card no___________Voter IC no ______________ Receipt/Bill __________ Bank/A/c ________

5. Land Ownership (Tick under appropriate type and enter the no. of households under the same)

Single Joint Trust Community Government Forest Unclear (specify)

5.1 Type of ownership

Male Female

5.2 Ownership by Gender ( if private)

6. Does the family have legal document to prove ownership of

Structure 1. Yes 2. No. RTC No. Sub No. land 1. Yes 2. No. RTC No. Sub No. (to be asked only to the owner) (If yes, ask for the legal document and check with the Land Revenue Office)

Measurements 2.1 Structure

Offset From Existing

Central Line

Offset from Edge of Asset

up to Area Getting Affected

Land Structure Land Structure

Starting Meter

Ending Meter

Width

Total Area (in sq.m)

No. of Floors (G, G+1, G+n)

2.2 land

Total Affected

Sl. No.

Area Length Width Total Area (in

sqm)

Length Width Total Area (in

sqm)

1. Built up area

2. Open Space

3. Total Area

2.3 Boundary Wall Details

Sl. No.

Boundary / Compound Wall

Length Total length affected (in sqm)

1. Barbed wire fencing

2. Stone Dry Masonry

3. Brick / Stone Masonry

4. Mud Wall

5. Others (Specify)

2.4 Gate Details

Sl. No.

Type of Gate Length

(in m)

Height

(in m)

1. M S

2. Wooden

3. Others

2.5 WATER SOURCES GETTING AFFECTED

Sources (in No.) User (use code)* Units to be acquired

Dug Wells

Tube Wells

Supply Points

*[1.Domestic 2.Agriculture 3.Industrial 4. Others (to be specified)]

6 Diagram of the affected property (Rough diagram with dimension – Not to scale)

(PHOTOGRAPH TO BE ATTACHED – STRUCTURE ALONG WITH HEAD OF HOUSEHOLD/ RESPONDENT)

In case the tenancy/ownership is under dispute (legal or otherwise) please make a short note below Field Supervisor: _________________________________ Date: ________________________ _________________________________ Endorsed by: Revenue Officer: _________________________________ Date: ________________________

_________________________________ MoRT&H / PWD Officer: __________________________________ Date: _______________________

__________________________________

ministry of road and transport & highway government of india

Documents

Transcript of ministry of road and transport & highway government of india