It’s just juxtabridity: Place making, spectacle and the periphery. A case study of a place that...

58
"#$% &'%# &'(#)*+,-,#. "#$%& '$()*+, -.&%/$%#& $*0 /1& .&2).1&23 4 %$-& -/503 67 $ .#$%& /1$/ 5-&0 /6 8& (*69* $- :5'.#)*+/6*

Transcript of It’s just juxtabridity: Place making, spectacle and the periphery. A case study of a place that...

!

! ! !"#$%!&'%#!&'(#)*+,-,#.!! ! !"#$%&!'$()*+,!-.&%/$%#&!$*0!/1&!.&2).1&23!! ! !!! ! !4!%$-&!-/503!67!$!.#$%&!/1$/!5-&0!/6!8&!(*69*!$-!:5'.#)*+/6*!

!!!!!!!!!!!

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

!"#$%&'$()'($*+,-."#$/&'$01'2/,!*65*!!•! *#$!8%)59!3#-)59%4!%0,!'&6%05Q%E'0%4!)*&+9*+&$)!%0,!(%9545E$)!R$B6B!8+54,506)7!&'%,)7!3'.$&!)+3345$)S!0$$,$,!('&!*#$!'3$&%E'0!'(!%!)'95$*-!'&!$0*$&3&5)$!

!!345+!"#$%&'$()'($*6!•! T0(&%)*&+9*+&$!%)!&$52%650$,!50!%!64'8%4!,5)9'+&)$!9'09$&0506!&56#*)!*'!*#$!95*-!%0,!9'23%&%84$!4$G$4)!'(!%99$))!*'!)$&G59$)!50!%!3&5G%E)$,!2%&/$*B!

•! T0(&%)*&+9*+&$!%)!%!9'0)E*+$0*!3%&*!'(!*#$!,5)9'+&)$!)+&&'+0,506!*#$!95*-!&$65'0!%0,!64'8%4!95E$)B!

•! T0(&%)*&+9*+&$!%)!%!3&',+9$&!'(!)3%9$B!•! T0(&%)*&+9*+&$!%)!%0!50*$6&%4!%&9#5*$9*+&$!50!*$9#059%47!)$9+&$D&$%42!%0,!$9'4'659%4!9'0*$I*)B!!

•! U&$)$09$!'(!*#$!&$65'0!50!9'0*$23'&%&-!,5)9'+&)$7!%!&$)*%E06!'(!V$,,$)5%0!5,$%)!*#%*!9%00'*!560'&$!*#$!2%00$&!.5*#!.#59#!50(&%)*&+9*+&$!5)!8'+0,!.5*#!*#$!9%35*%4!%0,!2%*$&5%4!W'.)!'(!*#$!95*-B!

!!

7*$894*$5+,9/-$.#:/;$8,!*65*!•! *#$!'+*$&!4525*)!'&!$,6$!'(!%0!%&$%!'&!'8H$9*!•! %!2%&650%4!'&!)$9'0,%&-!3')5E'0!507!'&!%)3$9*!'(7!%!6&'+37!)+8H$9*7!'&!)3#$&$!'(!%9EG5*-!

!!345+7*$894*$56!•! "#$!+&8%0!3$&53#$&-!%)!*#$!)$X06!('&!G5)584$!50(&%)*&+9*+&$)B!•! "#$!3$&53#$&-!%)!*#$!+06'G$&0$,!)3%9$!*#%*!#%)!3$&25Y$,!%!#5)*'&59%4!%0,!9'0E0+506!)$&5$)!'(!4%&6$D)9%4$!('&2%4!523')5E'0)!'0!*#$!4%0,)9%3$B!

•! "#$!3$&53#$&-!#%)!2'G$,!(&'2!8$506!*#$!9+&5'+)!4$Z'G$&!)3%9$!%*!*#$!$,6$!'(!*#$!95*-!*'!8$9'2$!*#$!3&52%&-!+&8%0!)$X06!('&!,$G$4'32$0*B!

•! [)!*#$!\&)*!.'&4,!#%)!2'G$,!(&'2!3&',+9EG$!*'!9'0)+23EG$])$&G59$!,&5G$0!$9'0'25$)!*#5)!#%)!8$$0!34%-$,!'+*!$I34595*4-!50!*#$!3$&53#$&-B!

!!

<9*)'%)=*+,-&9>1'/1:/;=,+*65*!•! %0!$G$0*!'&!)9$0$!&$6%&,$,!50!*$&2)!'(!5*)!G5)+%4!523%9*!!!345+&9*)'%)=*6!•! ^3$9*%94$!5)!+)$,!#$&$!50!*#$!1$8'&,!)$0)$!*'!9'0G$-!*#$!5,$%!'(!*#$!52%6$!)%*+&%*$,!%0,!#-30'E9!9'0)+23EG$!$I3$&5$09$!'(!*#$!95*-B!

•! ^3$9*%94$!5)!%4)'!+)$,!#$&$!50!5*)!45*$&%4!,$\05E'0)C!,&%2%E9!%0,!)*&5/506B!

•! T0(&%)*&+9*+&$!%0,!*#$!3$&53#$&-!#%G$!9'2850$,!*'!9&$%*$!)3$9*%94$!50!8'*#!'(!*#$!%8'G$!9'09$3E'0)B!

!!

O_*`#$!50*$&,$3$0,$09$!8$*.$$0!50(&%)*&+9*+&$!%0,!+&8%0!,$G$4'32$0*!#%)!%4.%-)!8$$0!'0$!'(!*#$!2')*!523'&*%0*!*'359)!'(!+&8%0!34%00506B!F'.$G$&7!50!*#$!,5)9'+&)$!'(!+&8%0!,$)5607!50(&%)*&+9*+&$!#%)!34%-$,!%!9'23%&%EG$4-!)+8'&,50%*$!&'4$B<!RF%+9/7!"!a!;4$50$/'&*7!bB7!cd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e'8$&*!^25*#)'0!50!#5)!$))%-!4!;652!67!/1&!<6*5'&*/-!67!"$--$)%,!=&9!>&2-&37!50!.#59#!#$!,$)9&58$)!50,+)*&5%4!W'*)%2!'0!*#$!(&506$)!'(!#5)!#'2$!95*-!%)!2'0+2$0*)!%0,!&$G$%4)!*#$!)3$9*%9+4%&!50!*#$!$G$&-,%-B!!

Of-!9'0)5,$&506!*#$!95*-!%)!%0!$0'&2'+)!%&*$(%9*7!*#$!)5Q$!%0,!,5)*&58+E'0!'(!5*)!)5,$.%4/)7!8+54,506)7!)N+%&$)7!3%&/)7!)$.$&)!%0,!)'!'0!9%0!8$!50*$&3&$*$,!%)!&$2%&/%84$!3#-)59%4!&$9'&,)!'(!*#$!)'95'D*$9#059%4!.'&4,!50!.#59#!*#$!95*-!.%)!,$G$4'3$,!%0,!9'09$5G$,B<!R[58%&!%0,!f5H/$&7!?@@gS!!!"#5)!%33&'%9#!9%0!8$!$I*$0,$,7!3$&#%3)!$G$0!2'&$!\X064-7!*'!*#$!)3$9*%9+4%&!523')5E'0)!*#%*!50(&%)*&+9*+&$)!2%/$!3%&E9+4%&4-!%*!*#$!$,6$)!'(!95E$)B!!!K#$&$!^*$3#$0!V&%#%2!%&6+$)!*#$!&$D$2$&6$09$!'(!50(&%)*&+9*+&$!50!*#$!9$0*&%4!95*-!%)!%!)'95'D)3%E%4!,'2%50!*#&'+6#!O*#$!$&')5'0!'(!9'23&$#$0)5G$!34%00506<!RV&%#%27!cdddS7!%2'06)*!'*#$&!(%9*'&)7!5*!5)!3')5*$,!#$&$!*#%*!%!9'234$*$!4%9/!'(!34%005067!%0!+0($Y$&$,!)$N+$09$!'(!'33'&*+05E$)7!5)!3&$)$0*$,!%*!*#$!3$&53#$&-!*#%*!#%)!9'0)5)*$0*4-!523')$,!)3%E%4!'&,$&!8-!$I34595*!3#-)59%4!50*$&G$0E'0B!![)!;0'I!R?@@hS!0'*$)7!+&8%0!34%00506!O8$9%2$!509&$%)5064-!6$%&$,!*'!*#$!0$$,)!'(!3&',+9$&)!%0,!*#$!.%0*)!'(!9'0)+2$&)i!"#$!'+*9'2$!#%)!8$$0!%!,5)'&6%05)$,!%33&'%9#!*#%*!#%)!4$,!*'!%!9'44%6$!'(!#56#4-!,5=$&$0E%*$,!)3%9$)!%0,!)$X06)<!j!/'(#)*+,-,#.0!!

^E9/506)!J'9/!'0!*#$!&5G$&!T&.$44B!!9B!?Akd!

Navigable  course  of  the  Irwell.  Trafford  Deer  Park.  Bridgewater  Canal.  Farming.  Moss.  

?$2/6*!?2)0+&!8&762&!/1&!@6*-/25%A6*!67!/1&!B1).!@$*$#!!nB!f'44%0)7!?A@d!^%4('&,!M+)$+2!a![&*!V%44$&-!

!OT!2+)*!'.07!T!,+&)*!0'*!G$0*+&$!*'!.%4/!'G$&7!%)!T!%42')*!*&$284$!*'!8$#'4,!*#$!4%&6$!&5G$&!T&.$44!8$0$%*#!2$7!%9&'))!.#59#!*#5)!0%G56%E'0!5)!9%&&5$,!8-!%!8&5,6$!.#59#!9'0*%50)!+3'0!*#5)!9%0%4!'(!.%*$&7!.5*#!8%&6$)!50!5*!,&%.0!8-!#'&)$)!.#59#!.%4/!+3'0!*#$!8%Y4$2$0*)!'(!*#5)!$I*&%'&,50%&-!8&5,6$<!j![!M%09#$)*$&!>'&&$)3'0,$0*7!B/C!>$'&-D-!@126*)%#&!!OT*!5)!50,$$,!%!2')*!0'84$!)5*$!j!4%&6$!G$))$4)!50!(+44!)%54!+0,$&!*#5)!%N+$,+9*7!%0,!*#$!1+/$<)!G$)))$4)!)%54506!%*!*#$!)%2$!E2$!'G$&!*#$2!0$%&!\Z-!($$*!%8'G$!*#$!0%G56%84$!&5G$&<!j!;1&!E&*/#&'&*D-!<$+$F)*&!!OT*!5)!3$&#%3)!*#$!6&$%*$)*!%&E\95%4!9+&5')5*-!50!*#$!.'&4,B!>&'.,)!'(!3$'34$7!5094+,506!*#')$!'(!\&)*!(%)#5'07!&$)'&*!*'!5*!,%54-<!D!![!4%,-7!;1&!E&*/#&'&*D-!<$+$F)*&!!O"#$!$=$9*!'(!9'2506!%*!'09$!'0!*'!f%&*'0!f&5,6$!%0,!4''/506!,'.0!+3'0!%!4%&6$!&5G$&!.5*#!8%&6$)!'(!6&$%*!8+&*#$0!*'.506!%4'06!5*!%0,!+3!*'!%0'*#$&!&5G$&!#+06!50!*#$!%5&!.5*#!8%&6$)!)%54506!+3'0!5*!('&2!%4*'6$*#$&!%!)9$0$&-!)'2$.#%*!45/$!$09#%0*2$0*<![&*#+&!o'+06!!OT*!5)!%!)*&%06$!%=%5&!*#%*!*#$!*'.0!'(!M%09#$)*$&!,'$)!0'*!3'))$))!%!8'%*!('&!*#$!%99'22',%E'0!'(!5*)!'.0!50#%85*%0*)!%0,!)*&%06$&)!.#'!#%G$!9'2$!*'!)$$!5*B<![&*#+&!o'+06!

Manchester  Ship  Canal.  Barton  Swing  Aqueduct.    

?$2/6*!B9)*+!4G5&05%/!

!OT*)!5)!%4)'!G5)5*$,!%)!%0!'8H$9*!'(!50*$&$)*7!0'*!8-!9&'.,)!0'.%,%-)!8+*!9$&*%504-!8-!(%2545$)B<!R?@pdS!!Of+*!'0$!,'+8*)!*#%*!E2$!.544!$G$&!9%*9#!+3!.5*#!*#$!2'0)*$&!.'0,$&!'(!*#$!050$*$$0*#!9$0*+&-7!.#59#!5)!*#$!f%&*'0!).506!8&5,6$7<!!f%&*'0!%N+$,+9*!*'!8$9'2$!*#$!('9%4!3'50*!'(i!%!+05N+$!9'0)$&G%E'0!%&$%!R?@gpS!!n'#0!M544%&!5)!N+'*$,7!O"#$!94')$!3&'I525*-!'(!*#5)!$0650$$&506!2%)*$&35$9$!50!*#$!%N+$,+9*!%0,!*#$!9'0*$23'&%&-!).506!8&5,6$!5)!+05N+$!%0,!*#$!8%0/)!'(!*#$!)#53!9%0%4!%&$!.$44D+)$,!G%0*%6$!3'50*)!('&!)56#*)$$&)B<!!

Davyhulme  Sewage  Works.  ParcelisaEon  of  agricultural  lots.    

1%G-#+42$!^$.%6$!K'&/)!?A@q!!OMB!V%&05$&!)%5,!*#%*!*#$!,$4$6%E'0!.$&$!523&$))$,!8-!*#$!#+6$0$))!%0,!523'&*%09$!'(!M%09#$)*$&7!%0,!$0H'-$,!*#$5&!*&53!*'!1%G-#+42$B!"#$-!('+0,!*#$!.'&/)7!.#59#!.$&$!4%&6$&!*#%0!*#')$!*#$-!)%.!%*!J$$,)7!2'&$!50*$&$)E06B!"#$-!#%,!0'*!)$$0!%0-*#506!45/$!*#$2!$4)$.#$&$B!T*!.%)!50!(%9*!*#$!\&)*!E2$!*#$-!#%,!)$$0!.'&/)!'(!)+9#!523'&*%09$<!R?@dkS!!OT*!.%)!4$Z!*'!#52!*'!)%-!.#%*!2')*!'(!*#$!cdd!G5)5*'&)!#%,!3&'8%84-!8$$0!*#50/506i!"#$!2$&$!(%9*!*#%*!*#$-!.$&$!%44!*#$&$!*'!.%*9#!*#$!J'&,!2%-'&!'r95%44-!'3$0!*#$!4%*$)*!$I*$0)5'0)!*'!*#$!.'&/)!.%)!3&''(!*#%*!)$.%6$!5)!%!#56#4-!523'&*%0*!)+8H$9*!('&!%0-!4'9%4!%+*#'&5*-B<!R?@ppS!!

Barton  Power  StaEon.  Trafford  Park  Industrial  Estate.  Ford,  Guinness,  Brooke  Bond  and  Henry  Royce.    

f%&*'0!U'.$&!^*%E'0B!?@chD?@g@!

O"#$!)5*$!'(!*#$!)*%E'07!.#59#!5)!?qBk!%9&$)!50!$I*$0*7!5)!'0!*#$!)'+*#!)5,$!'(!*#$!f&5,6$.%*$&!>%0%4!%0,!94')$!*'!*#$!M%09#$)*$&!^#53!>%0%4B<!!O"#$!9'0,$0)506!.%*$&!.544!8$!,&%.0!(&'2!*#$!^#53!>%0%4<!!O[!0$.!&'%,!%0,!8&5,6$!#%,!*'!8$!2%,$!'G$&!*#$!f&5,6$.%*$&!>%0%4<!!OT*!5)!50!5*)!.%-!%0!523&$))5G$!)56#*B!m'+&!)*+23-!9#520$-)!'(!)*$$4!#%G$!50)35&$,!*#$!#+2'&'+)!*'!9%44!5*!*#$![N+5*%05%B<!!O[!9'+34$!'(!9'0G$-'&)!2%/$!%!4'06!%&2!*'!*#$!&%54.%-!%0,!+0,$&!*#$2!&+0)!%!\06$&!'(!*#$!9%0%4B<!!"#$!'3$0506!8&'9#+&$!+)$,!%!e+)/50!N+'*$!j!OK$!&$N+5&$!(&'2!8+54,506)7!%)!(&'2!2$07!*.'!/50,)!'(!6'',0$))C!\&)*7!*#$!,'506!*#$5&!3&%9E9%4!,+*-!.$44C!*#$0!*#%*!*#$-!8$!6&%9$(+4!%0,!34$%)506!50!,'506!5*B<!n'#0!e+)/507!;1&!B/6*&-!67!H&*)%&,!IJJK!!Oi5*!&$N+5&$)!2'&$!*#%0!%0!'&,50%&-!$I$&95)$!'(!*#$!52%650%E'0!('&!5*)!95EQ$0)!*'!2%/$!*#$!450/!8$*.$$0!9%+)$!%0,!$=$9*7!8$*.$$0!*&%2)7!456#E067!.%*$&7!#$%4*#!%0,!)$9+&5*-7!%0,!*#$!('&9$)!%0,!'&6%05)%E'0)!&$)3'0)584$!('&!*#$)$!*#506)B<!

!O"#$!*+&850$!&''2!9%00'*!8$!,$)9&58$,!.5*#'+*!*$9#059%45E$)B!T*!5)!%!.'0,$&(+4!&''2!('&!*#')$!.#'!)$$!8$%+*-!50!3'.$&<!

Barton  High  Level  Bridge  [orbital  motorway  secEon]  New  highways  infrastructure.  Decline  in  rail  distribuEon.  

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`620!83X.$--O!41,!/1&!.2)%&!67!.26+2&--C!

m459/&!D!1%G$!;$39'G$!

Landfill.  ShiZ  towards  light  industry  in  Trafford  Park.  

[*!%!3'459-!4$G$4!*#$!&$4%E'0)#53!8$*.$$0!+&8%0!('&27!50(&%)*&+9*+&$!%0,!$9'4'6-!5)!'0$!*#%*!5)!9'0)*%0*4-!%,,&$))$,!*'!$=$9EG$4-!9'00$9*!*#$!3'))58545E$)B!K&5E06!50!*$&2)!'(!2%*$&5%4!W'.!%0%4-)5)7!M%&G50!$*!%4B!Rcd?cS!)*%*$!*#%*!O*#$!,$)5607!9'0)*&+9E'0!%0,!'3$&%E'0!'(!50(&%)*&+9*+&$)!9&$%*$!%!)'95'D*$9#059%4!$0G5&'02$0*!*#%*!34%-)!%0!523'&*%0*!&'4$!50!)#%3506!#'.!&$)'+&9$)!%&$!3&'9+&$,7!+)$,!%0,!,5)3')$,!'(!8-!*#$!95*-<B!!!"#$!,$)5607!9'0)*&+9E'0!%0,!'3$&%E'0!'(!50(&%)*&+9*+&$)!%4)'!9&$%*$!%!3#-)59%4!$0G5&'02$0*!*#%*!(%G'+&)!(+&*#$&!523')5E'0!%0,!5)!('&2$,!8-!*#$!&$)'+&9$)!*#%*!%&$!3&'9+&$,7!+)$,!%0,!,5)3')$,!'(!8-!*#$!95*-B!T0(&%)*&+9*+&$!8$6$*)!50(&%)*&+9*+&$!%0,!*#$!3$&53#$&-!3&'G5,$)!%!3&52$!)5*+%E'0!('&!*#$!9'%4$)9$09$!'(!!O*$9#0'4'659%4!(+09E'0)!_*#%*`!9'$G'4G$!.5*#!)'95%4!(+09E'0)!%0,!)'95%4!50*$&$)*)<B!RM%&G50!$*!%4B!cd?cS!!+++++!"?@@$+&15A?8B8"C+%"?+&188"CD+E(F9=8"C'@"+GHIG+

Trafford  Centre.  Dry  Ski  Slope.  Golf  Driving  Range.  Asda.  Infrastructure  of  consumpEon.  

T0!*#$!:;!,+&506!*#$!?@gd)!&$65'0%4!34%00506!2'G$,!(&'2!%!)3%E%4!3&%9E9$!*'!%0!$9'0'259!'0$7!*#$!%&9#5*$9*D34%00$&!.%)!&$34%9$,!%*!$G$&-!)9%4$!'(!6'G$&0%09$!8-!*#$!$9'0'259D34%00$&7!*#+)!*#$!50*$&&$4%*$,!3#-)59%4!'&,$&!'(!4%&6$!)9%4$!+&8%0!3&'H$9*)!.%)!,52505)#$,B!>'+34$,!.5*#!*#$!)3%E%4!(&%62$0*%E'0!%99$4$&%*$,!8-!*#$!3&5G%E)%E'0!'(!0$*.'&/)!%0,!)$&G59$)!%!,5)H+09EG$!)5*+%E'0!%&')$!.#$&$50!&$65'0%4!34%00506!&$%9#$,!%!O9#$$&(+4!%99$3*%09$!'(!&$65'0)!%)!%&9#53$4%6')!'(!$094%G$)<B!f')2%7!;B!a!F$44506%7!FB!R?@@AS!

H+I*%8&5,5*-!)9'&$s!k !2'*'&.%-D!$4$9*&595*-D)/5D6'4(D9%&!.%)#!

H+I*%8&5,5*-!)9'&$s!p !2'*'&.%-D!$4$9*&595*-D)/5D6'4(D#'*$4D'r9$!

H+I*%8&5,5*-!)9'&$s!h !6&%G$D2'*'&.%-D!)/5!

H+I*%8&5,5*-!)9'&$s!k !&'%,D)#53!9%0%4D2'*'&.%-D!)/5D9#+&9#!

H+I*%8&5,5*-!)9'&$s!h !&'%,D9%0%4D)#53!9%0%4!

H+I*%8&5,5*-!)9'&$s!q !!$4$9*&595*-D3+8D)/5D9%&!3%&/!

H+I*%8&5,5*-!)9'&$s!c !9#+&9#D1To!.%&$#'+)$!

H+I*%8&5,5*-!)9'&$s!q !85448'%&,D9'0*%50$&!3'&*DH+09E'0D)#'33506!

<JKLM!!!

T*!5)!523'&*%0*!*'!9'0)5,$&!50(&%)*&+9*+&$!(&'2!*#$!2+4E4$G$4!3$&)3$9EG$!%0,!%)!)'2$*#506!*#%*!2%-!*&%0)5E'0!0'*!50!%99'&,!.5*#!4'9%4!9'0,5E'0)7!8+*!.5*#!&$65'0%47!0%E'0%4!'&!50*$&0%E'0%4!,$2%0,)B!T0!%&9#5*$9*+&%4!*$&2)!*#5)!9%0!8$!+0,$&)*'',!%)!)9%4$B!!!"#$!)9%4%&!&$4%E'0)#53!'(!%!35$9$!'(!50(&%)*&+9*+&$!*'!5*)!9'0*$I*!9%0!G%&-!.5,$4-C!50(&%)*&+9*+&$!9%0!8$!,$)560$,!*'!$06%6$!%*!&$65'0%47!0%E'0%4!'&!50*$&0%E'0%4!)9%4$)!8+*!.544!%4.%-)!523%9*!4'9%44-B!"#5)!523%9*!9%0!8$!522$,5%*$!%0,!'8G5'+)7!%)!%*!*#$!3$&53#$&-7!'&!)54$0*!%0,!)'2$E2$)!,5G5)5G$!50!*#$!.%-!5*!8-3%))$)!*$&&5*'&5$)!%0,!(%G'+&)!'*#$&)B!!!/'(#)*+,-,#.!*#&5G$)!'0!*#$!3#-)59%4!)9%4%&!9'0*&%)*)!.&'+6#*!'(!*#$!G%&5'+)!0$*.'&/)!.5*#!.#59#!50(&%)*&+9*+&$)!9'00$9*B!V&%G$)*'0$)D%6%50)*D50,''&!)/5!9$0*&$)D%6%50)*D2'*'&.%-!8&5,6$)B!e'2%0$)N+$D0%+E9%4!*#&$)#'4,B!/'(#)*+,-,#.!$I5)*)!%*!%44!)9%4$)B!!

N!OM!!!

F5)*'&-!#%)!&$G$%4$,!4%-$&!+3'0!4%-$&!'(!560'&%0*!523')5E'0)!%9&'))!*#$!)5*$!%*!f%&*'0D1+234506*'07!$%9#!'0$!&$6%&,4$))!'(!9'0*$I*B!/'(#)*+,-,#.!%*!*#5)!3$&53#$&%4!4'9%E'0!5)!0'*!%!$I94+)5G$4-!%!&$9$0*!5095,$0*B!"#$!0$'DV'*#59!9#+&9#7![44!^%50*)!RLBKB!U+6507!?ApgDAS7!)%*!%,H%9$0*!*#$!(+09E'0%45)*!2',$&0!2%))!'(!*#$!3'.$&!)*%E'0!8$*.$$0!?@ch!%0,!?@g@B!B!!

7LKP!!!

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

KM<NQMN!J!!!

/'(#)*+,-,#.!5)!0$'D%+*#$0E9B!T0!1+234506*'0!5*!5)!9'23')$,!'(!*#$!0$'DV'*#597!*#$!0$'D94%))59%47!*#$!0$'D9+4*+&%47!*#$!0$'D,'2$)E9!%0,!)'!'0B!"#$!0$'D0$))!5)!%!9'0)*%0*!50!*#$!%$)*#$E9!'(!*#$!3$&53#$&-B!T*!5)!%4.%-)!0$'B!T*!9%0!8$!0$'D84%0,7!0$'D2+0,%0$7!0$'D(+*+&5)*7!*#$!523'&*%0*!(%9*'&!5)!*#%*!5*!5)!*&6C!!

ab6#0!Q$%/!;1$/!U1)%1!)-!E660D!;1&!42'-!67!;2$L620!<6c6!!!;1&!;2$L620!@&*/2&!@2&-/!!!;1)-!02$'$A%!\'!/$##!-%5#./52&!82&$/1&-!#)7&!)*/6!/1&!-3'86#)%!7&$/52&-!67!/1&!;2$L620!@6$/!67!42'-C!@6*/$)*&0!)*!)/-!$2'-,!%2&-/!$*0!-5..62/&2-!$2&!&'8#&'-!/6!2&.2&-&*/!&$%1!67!/1&!/&*!%6''5*)A&-!67!;2$L620d!4#/2)*%1$',!?6906*,!@$22)*+/6*,!:5*1$'!<$--&3,!b$#&,!"$2A*+/6*,!B$#&,!B/2&`620,!e2'-/6*!$*0!U$2852/6*C!!!;1&!f6'$*!*5'&2$#!g!2&7&2&*%&-!/1&!/&*!%6''5*)A&-!$*0!)-!762'&0!83!/96!-1$M-!67!#)+1/*)*+!-3'86#)%!67!;2$L620D-!&#&%/2)%$#!)*05-/23C!!!;1&!'3/16#6+)%$#!e*)%62*!$*0!E2)T*!h$*(!/1&!@&*/52)6*!-/$*0)*+!8&1)*0!1)-!-1)&#0C!;1)-!)-!-.#)/!$%26--!/1&!%&*/2&!9)/1!$!9$R3!#)*&,!2&.2&-&*A*+!/1&!f)R&2!<&2-&3!$*0!/1&!<$*%1&-/&2!B1).!@$*$#C!

<7MJNKJLM!!T0!*$&2)!'(!)3$9*%94$!50!*#$!9'0G$0E'0%4!+)$!'(!*#$!.'&,B!1+234506*'0!'3$&%*$)!50!*.'!94$%&!.%-)s!!_?`!U$&G$&)$!)3$9*%9+4%&s!*#$!%995,$0*%4!9'445)5'0!'(!H%&&506!3&'6&%22$)7!)9%4$)!%0,!G5)+%4!4%06+%6$)7!%!#-8&5,!H+I*%3')5E'0!j!&'(#)*+,-,#.0!!!_c`!U+84594-!)3$9*%9+4%&s!^3%9$)!,$)560$,!)3$95\9%44-!*'!%33$%&!)3$9*%9+4%&B!"#$!#56#4-!3)-9#'4'659%44-!$0650$$&$,!50*$&5'&!)3%9$)!'(!*#$!"&%='&,!>$0*&$!%)!.$44!%)!5*)!%33&'%9#!%0,!*#&$)#'4,!)$N+$09$!9&$%*$)!5*)!'.0!('&2!'(!&'(#)*+,-,#.0!!

[33&'%9#!(&'2!f&5,6$.%*$&!>%0%4!

[I5%4!%33&'%9#!_3$,$)*&5%0!3&5'&5*-`!

[*!-6%)&A&-!91&2&!'60&2*!%6*0)A6*-!67!.2605%A6*!.2&R$)#,!$##!67!#)7&!.2&-&*/-!)/-&#7!$-!$*!)''&*-&!$%%5'5#$A6*!67!-.&%/$%#&-C!_R&23/1)*+!/1$/!9$-!0)2&%/#3!#)R&0!1$-!'6R&0!$9$3!)*/6!$!2&.2&-&*/$A6*C!

J5'0)!6+%&,!*#$!$0*&%09$!*'!*#$!O>#%28$&!'(!^*%*+$)<!

M$*!8-!*#$!8&56#*!456#*)!'(!*#$!9%&'+)$4!%0,!*#$!#%4(DE28$&$,!#'*,'6!#+*)B!

[!9+&)'&-!9+*!*'!;&5)3-!;&$2$!%0,!8%4$,!9%&,8'%&,!

;1&!)'$+&-!0&/$%1&0!726'!&R&23!$-.&%/!67!#)7&!75-&!)*!$!%6''6*!-/2&$'!)*!91)%1!/1&!5*)/3!67!/1)-!#)7&!%$*!*6!#6*+&2!8&!2&&-/$8#)-1&0C!f&$#)/3!%6*-)0&2&0!.$2A$##3!5*76#0-,!)*!)/-!69*!+&*&2$#!5*)/3,!$-!$!.-&506X962#0!$.$2/,!$*!68i&%/!67!'&2&!%6*/&'.#$A6*C!;1&!-.&%)$#)F$A6*!67!)'$+&-!67!/1&!962#0!)-!%6'.#&/&0!)*!/1&!962#0!67!/1&!$5/6*6'65-!)'$+&,!91&2&!/1&!#)$2!1$-!#)&0!/6!1)'-&#7C!;1&!-.&%/$%#&!)*!+&*&2$#,!$-!/1&!%6*%2&/&!)*R&2-)6*!67!#)7&,!)-!/1&!$5/6*6'65-!'6R&'&*/!67!/1&!*6*X#)R)*+C!

;1&!-6%)&/3!8$-&0!6*!'60&2*!)*05-/23!)-!*6/!$%%)0&*/$##3!62!-5.&2W%)$##3!-.&%/$%5#$2,!)/!)-!75*0$'&*/$##3!-.&%/$#)-/C![*!/1&!-.&%/$%#&!j!/1&!R)-5$#!2&h&%A6*!67!/1&!25#)*+!&%6*6')%!620&2!j!+6$#-!$2&!*6/1)*+!0&R&#6.'&*/!)-!&R&23/1)*+C!!V+-!1$8'&,!j!B6%)&/3!67!/1&!B.&%/$%#&!

"#$!,'43#50)!%0,!*#$!2$&2%5,)!_&506!'(!59$`!

V+5,$,!8-!*#$!,&%50%6$!9#%00$4B!

"#$!G5)*%!'(!G$0,506B!

"#$!*+00$4!'(!*&%0)5E'0!_9'0G$0E'0%4!0$'D0$'0!)$9E'0`!

"#$!*+00$4!'(!*&%0)5E'0!_e'2%0$)N+$D9'0*%50$&!3'&*!)$9E'0`!

B&.$2$A6*!)-!)/-&#7!.$2/!67!/1&!5*)/3!67!/1&!962#0,!67!/1&!+#68$#!-6%)$#!.2$k)-!-.#)/!5.!)*/6!2&$#)/3!$*0!)'$+&C!;1&!-6%)$#!.2$%A%&!91)%1!/1&!$5/6*6'65-!-.&%/$%#&!%6*726*/-!)-!$#-6!/1&!2&$#!/6/$#)/3!91)%1!%6*/$)*-!/1&!-.&%/$%#&C!?5/!/1&!-.#)/!9)/1)*!/1)-!/6/$#)/3!'5A#$/&-!)/!/6!/1&!.6)*/!67!'$()*+!/1&!-.&%/$%#&!$..&$2!$-!)/-!+6$#C!;1&!#$*+5$+&!67!/1&!-.&%/$%#&!%6*-)-/-!67!-)+*-!67!/1&!25#)*+!.2605%A6*,!91)%1!$/!/1&!-$'&!A'&!$2&!/1&!5#A'$/&!+6$#!67!/1)-!.2605%A6*C!

"#$!*+00$4!'(!*&%0)5E'0!_522$&)5'0!%33&'%9#$)`!

l*&!%$**6/!$8-/2$%/#3!%6*/2$-/!/1&!-.&%/$%#&!/6!$%/5$#!-6%)$#!$%AR)/3d!-5%1!$!0)R)-)6*!)-!)/-&#7!0)R)0&0C!;1&!-.&%/$%#&!91)%1!)*R&2/-!/1&!2&$#!)-!)*!7$%/!.2605%&0C!^)R&0!2&$#)/3!)-!'$/&2)$##3!)*R$0&0!83!/1&!%6*/&'.#$A6*!67!/1&!-.&%/$%#&!91)#&!-)'5#/$*&65-#3!$8-628)*+!/1&!-.&%/$%5#$2!620&2,!+)R)*+!)/!.6-)AR&!%61&-)R&*&--C!l8i&%AR&!2&$#)/3!)-!.2&-&*/!6*!86/1!-)0&-C!_R&23!*6A6*!Wk&0!/1)-!9$3!1$-!*6!6/1&2!8$-)-!/1$*!)/-!.$--$+&!)*/6!/1&!6..6-)/&d!2&$#)/3!2)-&-!5.!9)/1)*!/1&!-.&%/$%#&,!$*0!/1&!-.&%/$%#&!)-!2&$#C!;1)-!2&%).26%$#!$#)&*$A6*!)-!/1&!&--&*%&!$*0!/1&!-5..62/!67!/1&!&k)-A*+!-6%)&/3C!

"#$!*+00$4!'(!*&%0)5E'0!_50G5)584$!J$00'0!)$9E'0`!

;1&!-.&%/$%#&!+2$-.&0!)*!)/-!/6/$#)/3!)-!86/1!/1&!2&-5#/!$*0!/1&!.26i&%/!67!/1&!&k)-A*+!'60&!67!.2605%A6*C![/!)-!*6/!$!-5..#&'&*/!/6!/1&!2&$#!962#0,!$*!$00)A6*$#!0&%62$A6*C![/!)-!/1&!1&$2/!67!/1&!5*2&$#)-'!67!/1&!2&$#!-6%)&/3C![*!$##!)/-!-.&%)W%!762'-,!$-!)*762'$A6*!62!.26.$+$*0$,!$-!$0R&2A-&'&*/!62!0)2&%/!&*/&2/$)*'&*/!%6*-5'.A6*,!/1&!-.&%/$%#&!)-!/1&!.2&-&*/!'60&#!67!-6%)$##3!06')*$*/!#)7&C![/!)-!/1&!6'*).2&-&*/!$T2'$A6*!67!/1&!%16)%&!$#2&$03!'$0&!)*!.2605%A6*!$*0!)/-!%626##$23!%6*-5'.A6*C!;1&!-.&%/$%#&D-!762'!$*0!%6*/&*/!$2&!)0&*A%$##3!/1&!/6/$#!i5-AW%$A6*!67!/1&!&k)-A*+!-3-/&'D-!%6*0)A6*-!$*0!+6$#-C!!V+-!1$8'&,!j!B6%)&/3!67!/1&!B.&%/$%#&!

"#$!*+00$4!'(!*&%0)5E'0!_94%))59%4!'3+4$09$!)$9E'0`!

L0*$&506!U$$4![G$0+$!

>'0)+2$&)!2%&G$4!%*!.'&4,<)!4%&6$)*!J$6'!>#&5)*2%)!*&$$!

a;1)-!%$2!8&#6*+&0!/6!<2-!<$2+$2&/!<$23!U1)c$(&2,!/1&!'6/1&2!67!/1&!@1$)2'$*!$*0!Q65*0&2!67!"&&#!b6#0)*+-!.C#C%C!$*0!;1&!;2$L620!@&*/2&C![/!)-!)*-/$##&0!$/!;1&!;2$L620!@&*/2&!$-!$!#$-A*+!/2)85/&!762!$##!1&2!-5..62/,!)*-.)2$A6*!$*0!+5)0$*%&C!IK/1!B&./&'8&2!ImmJD!

[+*#$0E95*-!

"5*%059!_.5*#!W-506!)4$56#`!

e*0&2!/1&!-1)''&2)*+!0)R&2-)6*-!67!/1&!-.&%/$%#&,!8$*$#)F$A6*!06')*$/&-!'60&2*!-6%)&/3!/1&!962#0!6R&2!$*0!$/!&R&23!.6)*/!91&2&!/1&!0&R&#6.&0!%6*-5'.A6*!67!%6''60)A&-!1$-!-&&')*+#3!'5#A.#)&0!/1&!26#&-!$*0!68i&%/-!/6!%166-&!726'C!;1&!2&'$)*-!67!2&#)+)6*!$*0!67!/1&!7$')#3!n/1&!.2)*%).$#!2&#)%!67!/1&!1&2)/$+&!67!%#$--!.69&2o!$*0!/1&!'62$#!2&.2&--)6*!/1&3!$--52&,!'&2+&!91&*&R&2!/1&!&*i63'&*/!67!/1)-!962#0!)-!$T2'&0j/1)-!962#0!8&)*+!*6/1)*+!6/1&2!/1$*!2&.2&--)R&!.-&506X&*i63'&*/C!!

>#50$)$!4%0*$&0!50!0$'_0`D94%))59%4DM$,5*$&&%0$%0!50*$&5'&!!

;1&!'60&2*!-.&%/$%#&,!6*!/1&!%6*/2$23,!&k.2&--&-!91$/!-6%)&/3!%$*!06,!85/!)*!/1)-!&k.2&--)6*!/1&!.&2')c&0!)-!$8-6#5/&#3!6..6-&0!/6!/1&!.6--)8#&C!;1&!-.&%/$%#&!)-!/1&!.2&-&2R$A6*!67!5*%6*-%)65-*&--!9)/1)*!/1&!.2$%A%$#!%1$*+&!67!/1&!%6*0)A6*-!67!&k)-/&*%&C![/!)-!)/-!69*!.2605%/,!$*0!)/!1$-!'$0&!)/-!69*!25#&-d!)/!)-!$!.-&506X-$%2&0!&*A/3C![/!-169-!91$/!)/!)-d!-&.$2$/&!.69&2!0&R&#6.)*+!)*!)/-&#7,!)*!/1&!+269/1!67!.2605%AR)/3!83!'&$*-!67!/1&!)*%&--$*/!2&W*&'&*/!67!/1&!0)R)-)6*!67!#$862!)*/6!$!.$2%&##)F$A6*!67!+&-/52&-!91)%1!$2&!/1&*!06')*$/&0!83!/1&!)*0&.&*0&*/!'6R&'&*/!67!'$%1)*&-p!$*0!962()*+!762!$*!&R&2X&k.$*0)*+!'$2(&/B!

M%&84$!)*%5&!_.5*#!0$'0`!

[*!/1&!&--&*A$#!'6R&'&*/!67!/1&!-.&%/$%#&,!91)%1!%6*-)-/-!67!/$()*+!5.!$##!/1$/!&k)-/&0!)*!15'$*!$%AR)/3!)*!$!h5)0!-/$/&!-6!$-!/6!.6--&--!)/!)*!$!%6*+&$#&0!-/$/&!$-!/1)*+-!91)%1!1$R&!8&%6'&!/1&!&k%#5-)R&!R$#5&!83!/1&)2!762'5#$A6*!)*!*&+$AR&!67!#)R&0!R$#5&,!9&!2&%6+*)F&!652!6#0!&*&'3,!/1&!%6''60)/3,!916!(*69-!-6!9&##!169!/6!-&&'!$/!W2-/!+#$*%&!-6'&/1)*+!/2)R)$#!$*0!68R)65-,!91)#&!6*!/1&!%6*/2$23!)/!)-!-6!%6'.#&k!$*0!-6!75##!67!'&/$.13-)%$#!-58/#&A&-C!!;1)-!)-!/1&!.2)*%).#&!67!%6''60)/3!7&A-1)-',!/1&!06')*$A6*!67!-6%)&/3!83!q)*/$*+)8#&!$-!9&##!$-!/$*+)8#&!/1)*+-,O!91)%1!2&$%1&-!)/-!$8-6#5/&!75#W##'&*/!)*!/1&!-.&%/$%#&,!91&2&!/1&!/$*+)8#&!962#0!)-!2&.#$%&0!83!$!-&#&%A6*!67!)'$+&-!91)%1!&k)-/!$86R&!)/,!$*0!91)%1!-)'5#/$*&65-#3!)'.6-&!/1&'-&#R&-!$-!/1&!/$*+)8#&!.$2!&k%&##&*%&C!!;1&!962#0!$/!6*%&!.2&-&*/!$*0!$8-&*/!91)%1!/1&!-.&%/$%#&!'$(&-!R)-)8#&!)-!/1&!962#0!67!/1&!%6''60)/3!06')*$A*+!$##!/1$/!)-!#)R&0C!

O"#$!4%06+%6$!'(!*#$!)3$9*%94$!9'0)5)*)!'(!-)+*-!'(!*#$!,'250%0*!)-)*$2!'(!3&',+9E'0!j!)560)!.#59#!%&$!%*!*#$!)%2$!E2$!*#$!+4E2%*$!$0,D3&',+9*)!'(!*#%*!)-)*$2<!!V+-!1$8'&,!j!B6%)&/3!67!/1&!B.&%/$%#&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!123+

!

! ! !"#$%!&'%#!&'(#)*+,-,#.!! ! !"#$%&!'$()*+,!-.&%/$%#&!$*0!/1&!.&2).1&23!! ! !!! ! !4!%$-&!-/503!67!$!.#$%&!/1$/!5-&0!/6!8&!(*69*!$-!:5'.#)*+/6*!

!!!!!!!!!!!