مقاله اي از کتاب "مطالعه موردي قدرت نرم" گردآوري و ترجمه سيدمحسن روحاني
شرح چگونگي نمايش دادن روابط موجود در شبكه هاي اجتماعي...
Transcript of شرح چگونگي نمايش دادن روابط موجود در شبكه هاي اجتماعي...
Page 5
Transferring Excel Matrix Data into UCINET
Step 1. Copy data from Excel Step 2. Open spreadsheet editor in UCINET Step 3. Paste into spreadsheet editor in UCINET Step 4. Save as “info”
Button To Open Spreadsheet Editor
Page 6
Transferring Attribute Data into UCINET (From Tab: ConcoAttr)
Step 1. Copy data from Excel Step 2. Open spreadsheet editor in UCINET Step 3. Paste into spreadsheet editor in UCINET Step 4. Save as “attrib”
Button To Open Spreadsheet Editor
Page 8
Opening Data in NetDraw
Step 1. File > Open > Ucinet dataset > Network Step 2. Choose network dataset (info.##h)
Page 9
Opening Data in NetDraw
Step 1. Click - open folder icon Step 2. Choose network dataset (info.##h), then click OK.
Page 11
Dichotomizing in NetDraw
Step 1. Click Relations Tab Step 2. Select “Greater Than” Operator Step 3. Insert The Number 3 Or Use The Plus Button To Get To 3
Page 13
Using Attribute Data in NetDraw
Step 1. Click - open folder icon Step 2. Choose attribute dataset (attrib.##h), then click Open. Step 3. Click “OK” On Matching Box And “X” Out Of Attribute Editor. Step 4. May need to re-set tie strength levels and click lightning bolt again.
Page 14
Choosing Color Attribute in NetDraw
Step 1. Select “Nodes” Step 2. Select “Region” Step 3. Place a check mark in the color box
Page 15
Selecting Nodes in NetDraw
Step 1. Default is all groups selected. To remove one group, e.g. group 2, remove check from box
Page 16
Selecting Egonets in NetDraw
Step 1. Select “Ego” Button On ToolBar Step 2. Ensure Geodesic distance FROM/TO ego is <= 1 Step 3. Select “BM” Step 4. De-Select “AR” Step 5. Select “All” Button and “X” Out Of Ego Net Viewer
Page 17
Changing the Size of Nodes in NetDraw
Step 1. Properties > Nodes > Symbols > Size > Attribute-based Step 2. Select gender and make minimum node size 8 and maximum 16
Page 18
Changing the Shape of Nodes in NetDraw
Step 1. Properties > Nodes > Symbols > Shape > Attribute-based Step 2. Select attribute, e.g. hierarchy
Page 19
Changing the Size of Lines in NetDraw
Step 1. Properties > Lines > Size > Tie strength Step 2. Select minimum =1 and maximum = 5
Page 20
Changing the Color of Lines in NetDraw
Step 1. Properties > Lines > Color > Node attribute-based Step 2. Select Region attribute, then choose within, between or both Step 3. Select Properties > Lines > Color > General to return to black lines
Page 21
Deleting Isolates in NetDraw
Step 1. Select Iso option on the toolbar Step 2. Select ~Nodes button to bring back removed nodes (click on “Okay” in
pop-up box)
Page 22
Resizing and Re-centering in NetDraw
Step 1. Layout > Move/Rotate Step 2. Select “Center” option
Page 23
Saving Pictures in NetDraw
Step 1. File > Save diagram as > Jpeg Step 2. Choose file name, e.g. “Example Jpeg File For Powerpoint”
Page 25
The survey data that we collect is usually valued data. Although we can use valued data in UCINET we prefer to take different cuts of the data. For example, we may want to examine the data where people only responded “strongly agree” to a question. To do this we dichotomize the data i.e. convert it to zeros and ones where one means strongly agree and zero means any other response.
Dichotomizing Valued Data
Step 1. Transform > Dichotomize Step 2. Choose input dataset (info.##h)
Step 3. Choose cut-off op. and value (e.g. GE and 4) Step 4. Specify output data set (Info_GE_4)
Page 26
Measures of Network Connection
• Density – Shows overall level of connection within a network. – We can also look at ties within and between groups.
• Distance – Shows average distance for people to get to all other
people. – Shorter distances mean faster, more certain, more
accurate transmission / sharing.
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 27
Density
• Number of ties, expressed as percentage of the number of pairs • Dense networks have more face-to-face relationships
Low Density (25%) Avg. Dist. = 2.27
High Density (39%) Avg. Dist. = 1.76
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 28
Quantitative Analysis: Density
Step 1. Network > Cohesion > Density > Density Overall Step 2. Input dataset “Info_GE_4”
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Density of this network is 8%.
Page 29
Distance
Average number of steps to reach all network participants Lower scores reflect a group better able to leverage knowledge
Short average distance Long average distance
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 30
Quantitative Analysis: Distance
Step 1. Network > Cohesion > Geodesic Distance (old) Step 2. Input dataset “Info_GE_4”
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Average Distance is 3.545
Page 31
Measures of Centrality
Degree Centrality: How well connected each individual is.
Betweenness Centrality: Extent to which individuals lie along short paths.
Closeness Centrality: How far a person is from all others in the network.
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 32
Quantitative Analysis: Degree Centrality
Step 1. Network > Centrality and Power > Degree
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 33
Quantitative Analysis: Degree Centrality
Step 1. Input dataset “Info_GE_4” Step 2. Choose whether to treat data as symmetric. I almost always select no. If you
choose “no” it will calculate separate figures for the people you go to and the people that come to you.
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 34
Quantitative Analysis: Degree Centrality Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
In-degree for HA is 7
Page 35
Quantitative Analysis: Degree Centrality Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Average in-degree is 3.652
In-degree Network Centralization is 12.424%
Page 36
0.00
10.00
20.00
30.00
40.00
50.00
60.00
70.00
80.00
90.00
0.00 10.00 20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00 60.00 70.00 80.00 90.00
175
302
111
279
105
308
47
26390
273
37
51
276
300
17615
22
240
177 160
139
101
43
74
316
23430
117
231
192
14357258
81
312205
257195
188
255
315292
173
992
256
224
178
106
241
75
113
246 149145
116
78
191
140
222
202
118
242
193
54
296
89102148
19
6
248
32
35
295
230
270
91223
201
45
3
198
163
164
209167
217 38
93
20634
61
174 211
303
112
144
265
1
187
7
69
212
1555
299
10
189
26
247
16
27 153 216
243268
95147
23237
170
301
311
266
249
119
28
52
2992
169
100
82
12050
269
280
221
278
59
210
141
60
132
239
55
171
36
294245
229
18548
39 220
275
131
2339 184
56
67
8
135
136
24
213190
196
127
158
264
286
272
183
133
281
197203199
44
53
87
244
14
314317
126
Opportunities exist to re-distribute relational load. Focus on ways to de-layer those in the top right quadrant (info access, decision rights, role) while also better leveraging those in the bottom quadrant
# People Each Person Seeks Information From
# Peo
ple R
eceiv
es In
forma
tion F
rom
High Info Sources
High Info Seekers
Integrators
“From whom do you typically seek work-related information?”
Page 37
ScatterPlot Step 1: Save Text File
Step 1. Generate Degree Calc. Network > Centrality > Degree > Info_GE_4 Step 2. File > Save As > Degree Output Text
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 38
ScatterPlot Step 2: Save Text File
Step 1. Open Excel Step 2. File > Open > Txt > Degree Output Text Step 3. Step 1 (In Text Import Wizard) > Next Step 4. Step 2 (Pictured) > Insert De-Limiter Between Names and Number. Step 5. Step 3 Finish
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 39
ScatterPlot Step 3: Insert Columns Back In UCINET
Step 1. Open UCINET Spreadsheet Editor Step 2. Cut And Paste Relevant Headers And In/Out Degree Numbers Step 3. Save As A UCINET file titled, “Scatterplot”
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 40
ScatterPlot Step 4: Create Plot In UCINET
Step 1. Tools > Scatterplot Step 2. Click on open file folder to open “Scatterplot” Step 3. Play with options (e.g., uniform axis)
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 41
Cross-boundary Analysis
Density across boundaries: How connected are groups within themselves
and with other pre-defined groups. This view can be used for different boundaries. We have used the following in our research: • Function or other designation of skill or knowledge. • Geographic location (even if only different floors). • Hierarchical level. • Time in organization or time in department. • Personality traits. • Gender (interesting though may be inflammatory).
Brokers: Which individuals are the links between other groups. Brokers can
be beneficial conduits of information but they can also hold up the flow of information.
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 42
Cross-boundary Analysis
Information Network: Density as related to practice Please indicate how often you have turned to this person for information or advice on work-
related topics in the past three months (response of often or very often). Healthcare Government IT Oil & Gas Pharmaceuticals Industrial
Healthcare 17% 0% 0% 7% 38% 0%Government 0% 17% 0% 0% 0% 10%IT 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 6%Oil & Gas 4% 0% 0% 19% 3% 8%Pharmaceuticals 35% 0% 0% 1% 49% 0%Industrial 1% 9% 9% 12% 1% 8%
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 43
Density Across Practice
Step 1. Network > Cohesion > Density > Old Density Procedure Step 2. Input dataset “Info_GE_4” Step 3. Click on “…” to select “Attrib” file for Row Partitioning. Arrow to end to select col 3. Step 4. Column Partitioning will automatically be filled in with the same text as the Row Partition. Step 5. Scroll all the way down in output file for density matrix.
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Tip: Col 3 is the column that includes the practice attribute. You can select different columns for different attributes MAKE SURE TO USE THE “DENSITY /
AVERAGE VALUE WITHIN BLOCKS”
Page 44
Broker Categories
Coordinator - This person connects people within their group. Ego
A B
Gatekeeper - This person is a buffer between their own group
and outsiders. Influential in information entering the group.
A
Ego
B
Representative - This person conveys information from their
group to outsiders. Influential in information sharing.
B
Ego
A
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 45
Quantitative Analysis: Broker Metrics
Step 1. Network > Ego networks > G&F Brokerage Step 2. Input dataset “Info_GE_4” Step 3. Partition vector “attrib col 2”
Tip: Col 2 is the column that includes the gender attribute. You can select different columns for different attributes
Network Connection Centrality
Cross Boundary Analysis
Page 46
Additional Quantitative Analysis
•Symmetrization & Verification •Combining Networks
•QAP Correlation and Regression
Page 47
Symmetrizing Data
• Bill says he communicated with John last week, but John doesn’t mention communicating with Bill
• Three options – take the conservative option, and put no tie between John and Bill
(minimum) – take the liberal option, and put a tie between John and Bill (maximum) – take the average, assigning a tie strength of 0.5 for the relationship
between John and Bill (average)
Bill John
Page 48
Symmetrizing Data (Continued)
Step 1. Transform > Symmetrize Step 2. Input dataset “Info_GE_4”
Step 3. Symmetrizing method “maximum” Step 4. Output dataset “Info_GE_4-Sym”
Tip: See previous slide for how to choose the most applicable symmetrizing method.
Page 49
Combining Networks
In the picture to the left you can see the information network.
In the picture below is the combined information and value network.
Page 50
Combining Networks (Continued)
Step 1. Tools > Matrix Algebra Step 2. In the Enter Command box type “infovalue = mult(ArtCoInfo_GE_4,ArtCoKase)”
Tip: The new matrix “infovalue” can now be used for various visual and quantitative analysis.
Page 51
QAP Correlation
Step 1. Tools > Testing Hypothesis > Dyadic (QAP) > QAP Correlation (old) Step 2. 1st Data Matrix “ArtCoInfo_GE_4” Step 3. 2nd Data Matrix “ArtCoKase” (note that this file is already 1’s and
0’s so no need to dichotomize)
Page 52
QAP Regression
Step 1. Tools > Testing Hypothesis > Dyadic (QAP) > MR-QAP Linear Regression > Original (Y-permutation) method