Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

download Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

of 61

Transcript of Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    1/61

    MEMBANGUN BUDAYAMEMBANGUN BUDAYAKESELAMATAN PASIENKESELAMATAN PASIEN

    BUDI SAMPURNABUDI SAMPURNA

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    2/61

    SISTEMATIKASISTEMATIKA

    PendahuluanPendahuluan

    Pengertian Budaya Keselamatan pasienPengertian Budaya Keselamatan pasien Manfaat Budaya Keselamatan pasienManfaat Budaya Keselamatan pasien

    Survei Keselamatan PasienSurvei Keselamatan Pasien

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    3/61

    Medical servicesMedical services

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    4/61

    WHAT ARE THE HAZARDS

    PROBABILITY, SEVERITY, AND EXPOSURE ?

    LEVEL OF RISK ?

    ACCEPTABLE ?

    CAN IT BE ELIMINATED ?

    CAN IT BE REDUCED ?

    CANCEL THE MISSION

    YES NO

    ACCEPT THE RISK

    ELIMINATE

    REDUCED

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    5/61

    SUDAHKAH SUATU PROSEDUR BETUL-BETUL AMAN?ADAKAH POSSIBLE FAILURE MODE?

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    6/61

    KENALILAH PENYEBAB KECELAKAAN, BAIK DARISISI FAKTOR MANUSIA MAUPUN FAKTOR SISTEM

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    7/61

    MISHAP ANALYSISMISHAP ANALYSIS

    MISHAP OCCURS

    RISK UNACCEPTABLE RISK ACCEPTABLE

    MANAGEMENT

    FACTORS LTA

    MISHAP

    ACCEPTABLE

    PREVENTION

    METHODS

    LTA

    IMPLEMENTATION

    PREVENTION

    METHODS LTA

    PREVENTION

    POLICY LTA

    IMPLEMENTATION

    OF POLICY LTA

    RISK ASSESSMENT

    LTA

    RISK PREVENTION

    LTA

    LTA = LESS THAN ADEQUATE

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    8/61

    BUDAYA SAFETYBUDAYA SAFETY

    A safety culture is where staff within an

    organisation have a constant and activeawareness of the potential for things to gowrong. Both the staff and the organisation are

    able to acknowledge mistakes, learn from them,and take action to put things right.

    Budaya keselamatan adalah dimana staf dalam suatu

    organisasi memiliki kesadaran yg konstan dan aktiftentang hal yg potensial menimbulkan kesalahan.

    Baik staf maupun organisasi mampu membicarakankesalahan, belajar dari kesalahan tsb, dan mengambiltindakan perbaikan

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    9/61

    BUDAYA SAFETYBUDAYA SAFETY

    Being open and fair means sharing information

    openly and freely, and fair treatment for staffwhen an incident happens. This is vital for boththe safety of patients and the well-being of those

    who provide their care.

    Bersikap terbuka dan adil / jujur berarti membagi

    informasi secara terbuka dan bebas, dan penangananadil bagi staf bila insiden terjadi.

    Hal ini penting bagi keselamatan pasien dan

    ketenangan bagi pemberi layanan

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    10/61

    BUDAYA SAFETYBUDAYA SAFETY

    The systems approach to safety acknowledges

    that the causes of a patient safety incidentcannot simply be linked to the actions of theindividual healthcare staff involved. All incidents

    are also linked to the system in which theindividuals were working.

    Pendekatan sistem pada keselamatan menerangkanbahwa penyebab insiden keselamatan pasien tidakdapat dihubungkan dengan sederhana ke staf yangterlibat. Semua insiden berkaitan juga dengan sistemtempat orang itu bekerja

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    11/61

    BUDAYA SAFETYBUDAYA SAFETY

    Changing values, beliefs and attitudes is

    not easy . Developing a safety culture in anorganisation needs strong leadership andcareful planning and monitoring.

    Mengubah nilai-nilai, keyakinan, dan perilaku tidaklahmudah. Pengembangan budaya keselamatan dalamsuatu organisasi memerlukan kepemimpinan yang kuat

    dan perencanaan & pemantauan yang cermat

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    12/61

    BUDAYA SAFETYBUDAYA SAFETY

    It is vital that not only clinical staff but all

    those who work in organisations, as wellas patients and carers, ask themselveshow they can help to improve the safety ofpatients.

    Perubahan nilai, keyakinan dan perilaku tersebutpenting bukan hanya bagi staf, melainkan juga semuaorang yang bekerja di rumah sakit tersebut, sertapasien dan keluarganya. Tanyakan apa yang bisamereka bantu untuk meningkatkan keselamatan pasien

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    13/61

    KOMPONENKOMPONEN

    1) acknowledgment of the high risk, error1) acknowledgment of the high risk, error--

    prone nature of an organization's activities,prone nature of an organization's activities, 2) blame2) blame--free environment wherefree environment where

    individuals are able to report errors or closeindividuals are able to report errors or close

    calls without punishment,calls without punishment, 3) expectation of collaboration across ranks3) expectation of collaboration across ranks

    to seek solutions to vulnerabilities, andto seek solutions to vulnerabilities, and 4) willingness on the part of the4) willingness on the part of the

    organization to direct resources to addressorganization to direct resources to address

    safety concerns.safety concerns.

    Penjelasan / pemahaman tentang aktivitasorganisasi yang bersifat risiko tinggi dan rentan

    kesalahan

    Lingkungan yang bebas-menyalahkan, sehingga

    orang dapat melapor kesalahan tanpapenghukuman

    Harapan kerjasama lintas tingkatan untuk mencarisolusi atas vulnerabilitas

    Kemauan organisasi untuk mengarahkan sumberdaya untuk kepentingan keselamatan

    AHRQ

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    14/61

    Components of a Culture of Safety

    Commitment to safety articulated at the highest levels of the

    organization and translated into shared values, beliefs, and

    behavioral norms at all levels.

    Necessary resources, incentives, and rewards provided by the

    organization to allow this commitment to occur.

    Safety is valued as the primary priority, even at the expense of

    production or efficiency ; personnel are rewarded for erring on

    the side of safety even if they turn out to be wrong.

    Communication between workers and across organizational levelsis frequent and candid.

    Unsafe acts are rare despite high levels of production.

    There is an openness about errors and problems; they are reported

    when they do occur. Organizational learning is valued; the response to a problem

    focuses on improving system performance rather than on individual

    blame.

    Source: Singer SJ, Gaba DM, Geppert JJ, et al. The culture of safety: results of an organization-widesurvey in 15 California hospitals. Qual Saf Health Care 2003 Apr;12(2):112-8.Reproduced with permission from the BMJ Publishing Group.

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    15/61

    BLAMINGBLAMING vsvs SAFETYSAFETY

    BLAMING:BLAMING:

    ANALISIS BERAKHIR PADA HUMAN FACTORSANALISIS BERAKHIR PADA HUMAN FACTORS

    TINDAKAN: MENYALAHKAN DAN MENGHUKUMTINDAKAN: MENYALAHKAN DAN MENGHUKUM

    (LESS) REWARD AND (MORE) PUNISHMENT(LESS) REWARD AND (MORE) PUNISHMENT

    SIKAP: SEMBUNYIKAN KESALAHANSIKAP: SEMBUNYIKAN KESALAHAN

    SAFETY:SAFETY:

    REPORTING, ANALYSIS, LEARNING,REPORTING, ANALYSIS, LEARNING,

    (MORE) REWARD AND (LESS) PUNISHMENT(MORE) REWARD AND (LESS) PUNISHMENT TINDAKAN: CARI UPAYA PENCEGAHANTINDAKAN: CARI UPAYA PENCEGAHAN

    SIKAP: BERLOMBA BERBUAT BAIK DANSIKAP: BERLOMBA BERBUAT BAIK DAN

    MENCEGAH YG BURUK (BUDAYA BELAJAR)MENCEGAH YG BURUK (BUDAYA BELAJAR)

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    16/61

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    17/61

    BLAMING ?BLAMING ?

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    18/61

    SUPPORTING?SUPPORTING?

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    19/61

    SIKAP RUMAH SAKITSIKAP RUMAH SAKIT

    Pastikan RS memiliki kebijakan ygmenjabarkan apa yg harus dilakukan staf

    segera setelah terjadi insiden, bagaimanalangkah pengumpulan fakta harus dilakukan& dukungan apa yang harus diberikan

    kepada staf, pasien - keluarga Pastikan RS memiliki kebijakan yg

    menjabarkan peran & akuntabilitas individualbilamana ada insiden

    Tumbuhkan budaya pelaporan & belajar dariinsiden yang terjadi di RS.

    Lakukan asesmen dengan menggunakansurvei penilaian KP

    KKP RS

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    20/61

    SIKAP STAF DALAM TIMSIKAP STAF DALAM TIM

    Pastikan rekan sekerja anda merasa

    mampu untuk berbicara mengenaikepedulian mereka & berani melaporkan

    bilamana ada insiden

    Demonstrasikan kepada tim anda ukuran

    yang dipakai di RS anda utk memastikan

    semua laporan dibuat secara terbuka &terjadi proses pembelajaran serta

    pelaksanaan tindakan / solusi yg tepatKKP RS

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    21/61

    TERBUKA DAN JUJURTERBUKA DAN JUJUR

    staff are open about incidents they have beeninvolved in;

    staff and organisations are accountable for theiractions;

    staff feel able to talk to their colleagues andsuperiors about any incident;

    organisations are open with patients, the public

    and staffwhen things have gone wrong, andexplain what lessons will be learned;

    staff are treated fairly and supported when an

    incident happens.NHS

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    22/61

    Being open and fair does notmean an absence of

    accountability.

    Accountability for patient safety means being openwith patients, explaining the actions taken and

    providing assurance

    that lessons will be learned.NHS

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    23/61

    TERBUKA DAN JUJURTERBUKA DAN JUJUR

    SINGKIRKAN MITOSSINGKIRKAN MITOS--MITOS:MITOS:

    the perfection myth:bila orang bekerja keras maka mereka tidakakan membuat errors

    the punishment myth:

    bila kita menghukum orang yang melakukan

    errors maka akan semakin sedikit pembuaterrors, atau bahwa tindakan pendisiplinandapat memperbaiki melalui channelling atau

    meningkatkan motivasi.NHS

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    24/61

    Penanganan InsidenPenanganan Insiden

    Staff harus sama persepsinya tentangStaff harus sama persepsinya tentang

    insideninsiden Staff harus tahu apa yang harus dilakukanStaff harus tahu apa yang harus dilakukan

    bila menemui insiden: mencatat, melapor,bila menemui insiden: mencatat, melapor,dianalisis, memperoleh feeddianalisis, memperoleh feed--back, belajarback, belajar

    dan mencegah pengulangandan mencegah pengulangan

    Staff harus akuntabel dan tahu bagaimanaStaff harus akuntabel dan tahu bagaimanapendekatan sistem dan personilpendekatan sistem dan personil

    SO O O O

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    25/61

    RESOLUTION OF ERRORRESOLUTION OF ERROR

    NEGLECT / USED WRONG PROCEDURE

    DID NOT KNOW

    CORRECT

    PROCEDURE

    KNEW CORRECT

    PROCEDURE

    LACKED

    EXPERIENCE

    LACKED

    INFORMATION

    LACKED TRAINING

    OR PRACTICE

    LACKED

    TRAINING

    DELIBERATE

    INTENTIONAL

    TOLERATED

    PRESSURES

    LACKED

    DISCIPLINE

    PUNISHMENT

    NEVER KNEW FORGOT

    MANAGEMENT ACTION TO CORRECT THE SYSTEM

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    26/61

    MENGAPA BUDAYA SAFETY?MENGAPA BUDAYA SAFETY?

    Bukti di industri lain menunjukkan bahwaBukti di industri lain menunjukkan bahwa

    budaya organisasi yang berorientasi kebudaya organisasi yang berorientasi kekeselamatan dan sikap karyawan yangkeselamatan dan sikap karyawan yang

    berani bicara tentang terjadinya kesalahanberani bicara tentang terjadinya kesalahan

    telah meningkatkan keselamatantelah meningkatkan keselamatan

    Di Rumah Sakit WimmeraDi Rumah Sakit Wimmera --Australia:Australia:

    Penurunan Adverse EventsPenurunan Adverse Events Pd pasien rawat inap : 1,35%Pd pasien rawat inap : 1,35% -- 0,74%0,74%

    Pd pasien IGD : 3,26%Pd pasien IGD : 3,26% -- 0,48%0,48%

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    27/61

    MANFAAT BUDAYA SAFETYMANFAAT BUDAYA SAFETY

    a potential reduction in the recurrence and

    in the severity of patient safety incidentsthrough increased reporting andorganisational learning;

    Potensi mengurangi angka kejadian dankeparahan kejadian patient safety melalui

    peningkatan pelaporan dan pembelajaranorganisasi

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    28/61

    MANFAAT BUDAYA SAFETYMANFAAT BUDAYA SAFETY

    a reduction in the physical and

    psychological harm patients can sufferbecause people are more aware of patientsafety concepts, are working to prevent

    errors and are speaking up when things gowrong;

    Pengurangan derita fisik dan psikologis pasien,karena orang makin sadar tentang konseppatient safety akan bekerja mencegahkesalahan dan berbicara bila terjadi kesalahan

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    29/61

    MANFAAT BUDAYA SAFETYMANFAAT BUDAYA SAFETY

    a lower number of staff suffering from

    distress, guilt, shame, loss of confidenceand loss of morale because fewerincidents are occurring;

    Penurunan jumlah staf yang menderita

    tertekan, merasa bersalah, malu, kehilanganpercaya diri, dan kehilangan keberanianmental, karena berkurangnya insiden yang

    terjadi

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    30/61

    MANFAAT BUDAYA SAFETYMANFAAT BUDAYA SAFETY

    an improvement in waiting times fortreatment through a higher turnover of

    patients. This is because patients whoexperience a safety incident require, on

    average, an extra seven to eight days inhospital over and above the time theirtreatment would normally require ;Peningkatan turnover pasien, mengingatpasien yg terkena insiden umumnya

    membutuhkan perawatan 7-8 hari lebih darimasa rawat normal

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    31/61

    MANFAAT BUDAYA SAFETYMANFAAT BUDAYA SAFETY

    a reduction in the costs incurred for

    treatment and extra therapy; a reduction in resources required for

    managing complaints and claims;

    Pengurangan biaya untuk pengobatan /penatalaksanaan ekstra akibat insiden

    Pengurangan kebutuhan sumber daya untukmenangani komplain dan klaim

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    32/61

    MANFAAT BUDAYA SAFETYMANFAAT BUDAYA SAFETY

    a decrease in wider financial and social

    costs incurred through patient safetyincidents including lost work time anddisability benefits.

    Penurunan biaya finansial dan sosial yangdiperlukan untuk menangani insiden patientsafety, termasuk kehilangan jam kerja danpembayaran kecacatan

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    33/61

    BAGAIMANA MEMULAIBAGAIMANA MEMULAIPENERAPAN BUDAYAPENERAPAN BUDAYA

    KESELAMATAN PASIEN?KESELAMATAN PASIEN?

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    34/61

    MULAILAH DENGAN SURVEIMULAILAH DENGAN SURVEI

    TENTANG ISUTENTANG ISU ::

    Bagaimana kemampuan managemensenior melihat ke depan danberkomitmen ke arah keselamatan

    Bagaimana komunikasi antara stafdengan manager

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    35/61

    TENTANG ISU:

    Bagaimana sikap dan perilaku dalammelaporkan suatu kejadian, blaming danpenghukumannya

    Bagaimana faktor-faktor dalam lingkungankerja mempengaruhi kinerja, seperti

    kelelahan, pemecahan perhatian, desainperalatan dan ketersediaan/kesiapan alat.

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    36/61

    TOOLS UNTUK SURVEITOOLS UNTUK SURVEI

    TYPOLOGY:TYPOLOGY: Checklist for Assessing Institutional Resilience (CAIR )

    Manchester Patient Safety Assessment Tool20(MaPSaT)

    Advancing Health in America (AHA) and Veterans

    Health Association (VHA): Strategies for Leadership.An Organisational Approach to Patient Safety

    DIMENSIONAL: Safety Attitudes Questionnaire (SAQ)

    Stanford Patient Safety Centre of Inquiry Culture

    Survey

    contoh

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    37/61

    contoh

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    38/61

    I. Background VariablesI. Background Variables

    A.A. What is your primary work area or unit in this hospital?What is your primary work area or unit in this hospital?

    H1.H1. How long have you worked in thisHow long have you worked in this hospital?hospital?H2.H2. How long have you worked in your current hospitalHow long have you worked in your current hospital

    work area/unit?work area/unit?

    H3.H3. Typically, how manyTypically, how many hours per weekhours per week do you work indo you work inthis hospital?this hospital?

    H4.H4. What is your staffWhat is your staff positionposition in this hospital?in this hospital?

    H5.H5. In your staff position, do you typically have directIn your staff position, do you typically have directinteraction orinteraction or contact with patientscontact with patients??

    H6.H6. How long have you worked in your current specialtyHow long have you worked in your current specialtyor profession?or profession?

    Ocontoh

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    39/61

    II. Outcome measuresII. Outcome measures

    Frequency of Event ReportingFrequency of Event Reporting

    Overall Perceptions of SafetyOverall Perceptions of Safety

    Patient Safety GradePatient Safety Grade

    Number of Events ReportedNumber of Events Reported

    contoh

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    40/61

    Overall Perceptions of Safety:Overall Perceptions of Safety: A15.A15. Patient safety is never sacrificed to getPatient safety is never sacrificed to get

    moremore work done.work done. A18.A18. Our procedures and systems are goodOur procedures and systems are good

    at preventing errors from happening.at preventing errors from happening. A10r.A10r. It is just by chance that more seriousIt is just by chance that more serious

    mistakes donmistakes dont happen around here.t happen around here.(reverse worded)(reverse worded)

    A17r.A17r. We have patient safety problems in thisWe have patient safety problems in this

    unitunit (reverse worded)(reverse worded)

    Reliability of this dimensionReliability of this dimensionCronbachCronbachss alpha (4 items) = .74alpha (4 items) = .74

    Keselamatan pasien tidak pernah dikorbankan untukmemperbanyak pekerjaan yang bisa dikerjakan

    Prosedur dan sistem kita adalah bagus dalam mencegahterjadinya kesalahan

    Hanyalah suatu kebetulan bahwa kesalahan yang lebihserius tidak terjadi disini (neg)

    Kita memiliki masalah keselamatan pasien di unit ini (neg)

    IIIIII. Safety Culture DimensionsSafety Culture Dimensionscontoh

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    41/61

    III.III. Safety Culture DimensionsSafety Culture Dimensions

    (Unit level)(Unit level) Supervisor/manager expectations & actionsSupervisor/manager expectations & actions

    promoting safetypromoting safety Organizational LearningOrganizational LearningContinuousContinuous

    improvementimprovement

    Teamwork Within Hospital UnitsTeamwork Within Hospital Units Communication OpennessCommunication Openness

    Feedback and Communication About ErrorFeedback and Communication About Error

    NonpunitiveNonpunitive Response To ErrorResponse To Error StaffingStaffing

    Hospital Management Support for PatientHospital Management Support for Patient

    SafetySafety

    Harapan dan tindakan supervisor dan manajer dalam

    mempromosikan keselamatanPembelajaran organisasi perbaikan kontinyu

    Kerjasama tim di RS

    Keterbukaan dalam berkomunikasi

    Umpan balik dan komunikasi tentang Kesalahan

    Tanggapan yang tidak menghukum terhadap kesalahan

    Staff

    Manajemen RS mendukung Keselamatan Pasien

    contoh

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    42/61

    Supervisor/manager expectations & actionsSupervisor/manager expectations & actions

    promoting safetypromoting safety

    B1.B1. My supervisor/manager says a good word whenMy supervisor/manager says a good word whenhe/she sees a job done according to establishedhe/she sees a job done according to establishedpatient safety procedures.patient safety procedures.

    B2.B2. My supervisor/manager seriously considers staffMy supervisor/manager seriously considers staffsuggestions for improving patient safety.suggestions for improving patient safety.

    B3r.B3r. Whenever pressure builds up, my supervisor/managerWhenever pressure builds up, my supervisor/managerwants us to work faster, even if it means takingwants us to work faster, even if it means takingshortcuts. (reverse worded)shortcuts. (reverse worded)

    B4r.B4r. My supervisor/manager overlooks patient safetyMy supervisor/manager overlooks patient safety

    problems that happen over and over. (reverseproblems that happen over and over. (reverseworded)worded)

    Reliability of this dimensionReliability of this dimensionCronbachCronbachss alpha (4 items) = .75alpha (4 items) = .75

    Supervisor / Manajer:

    Memuji bila staf melakukan prosedur PS

    Mempertimbangkan usulan staf untuk peningkatan PS

    Memerintahkan percepatan kerja dengan melakukan jalanpintas (neg)

    Tidak memperhatikan masalah PS yg sudah terjadiberulang (neg)

    contoh

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    43/61

    Teamwork Within Hospital UnitsTeamwork Within Hospital Units

    A1.A1. People support one another in this unit.People support one another in this unit.

    A3.A3. When a lot of work needs to be done quickly,When a lot of work needs to be done quickly,we work together as a team to get the workwe work together as a team to get the workdone.done.

    A4.A4. In this unit, people treat each other withIn this unit, people treat each other withrespect.respect.

    A11.A11. When one area in this unit gets really busy,When one area in this unit gets really busy,others help out.others help out.

    Reliability of this dimensionReliability of this dimensionCronbachCronbachss alpha (4 items) = .83alpha (4 items) = .83

    Orang saling membantu di unit ini

    Bila terdapat pekerjaan banyak yg membutuhkandiselesaikan secepatnya, kita bekerja bersama dalam satutim untuk menyelesaikannya

    Dalam unit ini orang memperlakukan orang lain denganhormat

    Bila salah satu area di unit ini sibuk, maka yang lain akan

    membantunya

    IV.IV. Safety Culture DimensionsSafety Culture Dimensionscontoh

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    44/61

    IV. Safety Culture Dimensionsy

    (Hospital(Hospital--wide)wide) Teamwork Across Hospital UnitsTeamwork Across Hospital Units

    Hospital Handoffs & TransitionsHospital Handoffs & Transitions

    contoh

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    45/61

    Teamwork Across Hospital UnitsTeamwork Across Hospital Units

    F4.F4. There is good cooperation among hospitalThere is good cooperation among hospital

    units that need to work together.units that need to work together.F10.F10. Hospital units work well together to provideHospital units work well together to provide

    the best care for patients.the best care for patients.

    F2r.F2r. Hospital units do not coordinate well withHospital units do not coordinate well witheach other. (reverse worded)each other. (reverse worded)

    F6r.F6r. It is often unpleasant to work with staff fromIt is often unpleasant to work with staff fromother hospital units. (reverse worded)other hospital units. (reverse worded)

    Reliability of this dimensionReliability of this dimensionCronbachCronbachss alpha (4 items) = .8alpha (4 items) = .8

    Terdapat kerjasama yg baik antar unit yg

    harus bekerjasamaUnit-unit bekerja bersama untuk memberilayanan terbaik kepada pasien

    Unit-unit tidak bekerjasama satu sama lain(neg)

    Sangat tidak menyebangkan bekerjadengan staf dari unit lain (neg)

    MANFAAT SURVEIMANFAAT SURVEI

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    46/61

    MANFAAT SURVEIMANFAAT SURVEI

    Suatu organisasi perlu mengetahuiSuatu organisasi perlu mengetahui

    budayanya yg sekarang sebelum bisabudayanya yg sekarang sebelum bisamengubah budaya tersebutmengubah budaya tersebut

    Mengubah sikap dan perilaku itu sulit danMengubah sikap dan perilaku itu sulit dan

    lama, perlu pemahaman tentanglama, perlu pemahaman tentang

    keselamatan pasien dan pendekatankeselamatan pasien dan pendekatan

    sistem padasistem pada errorserrors dandan incidentsincidents Leadership penting dalam membentukLeadership penting dalam membentuk

    valuevalue dandan beliefbelief dalam budayadalam budaya

    LEVEL OF MATURITY WITH RESPECTLEVEL OF MATURITY WITH RESPECT

    O S C

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    47/61

    TO A SAFETY CULTURETO A SAFETY CULTURE

    Risk

    management

    Is an integral

    Part of

    Everything

    That we do

    Risk

    management

    Is an integral

    Part of

    Everything

    That we do

    We arealways

    On alert forRisks that

    Mightemerge

    We areWe arealwaysalways

    On alert forOn alert forRisks thatRisks that

    MightMightemergeemerge

    We havesystems in

    Place toManage allLike risks

    We havesystems inPlace to

    Manage allLike risks

    We doSomething

    when weHave anincident

    Why wasteour time

    On safety?

    Why wasteWhy wasteour timeour time

    On safety?On safety?

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    48/61

    SELANJUTNYASELANJUTNYABAGAIMANA?BAGAIMANA?

    LangkahLangkah langkahlangkah

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    49/61

    LangkahLangkah--langkahlangkah

    1. Assess the culture of safety.

    2. Provide science-of-safety education.3. Identify safety concerns.

    4. Establish senior leader partnerships withunits.

    5. Learn from one defect per month.

    6. Re-assess (re-measure) the culture ofsafety.

    Membangun budaya adalah suatu siklus yg tak henti-henti

    ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    50/61

    ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS

    Seek leadership support for the creation of aculture of safety throughout the organization.

    Support can be gained by providing datademonstrating that communication problems aremajor causes of medical errors and information onhow teamwork failures lead to malpractice claimsand by sharing success stories of facilities that

    have affected patient safety by improving safetyculture.

    ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    51/61

    ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS

    Partner with clinicians and managers in conducting

    an assessment of the existing safety climate in theorganization. Appoint a project team, accountableto a senior executive, to carry out the assessment

    using surveys, interviews, or other techniques.

    Based on survey findings, formulate and execute

    an action plan to improve the culture of safety.Establish realistic measures to gauge theeffectiveness of action plans.

    ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    52/61

    ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS

    Provide safety science education tofrontline staff, managers, and physicians.Include teamwork training and educationin communication techniques.

    Incorporate safety culture initiatives intothe overall organizational patient safetyplan. Ensure that patient safety initiatives,

    action plans, and results of interventionsto improve safety are periodically reportedto the board of directors.

    ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    53/61

    ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS

    Establish a nonpunitive system for reportingerrors, events, and near misses. Consider

    implementing a reward-based reporting system,and ensure timely feedback to staff on howreports are used to improve patient safety.

    Ensure that disclosure policies are in keeping

    with current regulations and standards. Worktoward using disclosure with apology as a claim-avoidance strategy.

    ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    54/61

    ACTION RECOMMENDATIONS

    Share information on improvements and

    successes based on safety culturechanges to maintain enthusiasm forparticipation and support. Communicate

    plans to address areas still in need ofimprovement and other opportunities to

    enhance patient safety.

    PengalamanPengalaman VHAVHA

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    55/61

    PengalamanPengalaman VHAVHA

    The Veterans Health Administration (VHA) hasThe Veterans Health Administration (VHA) hasimplemented a multifaceted safety initiative,implemented a multifaceted safety initiative,

    which was designed to build a culture of safetywhich was designed to build a culture of safetyand address system failures.and address system failures.

    The approach consists of 4 major elements:The approach consists of 4 major elements: 1) partnering with other safety1) partnering with other safety--related organizationsrelated organizations

    and affiliates to demonstrate a public commitment byand affiliates to demonstrate a public commitment byleadership,leadership,

    2) establishing centers to direct safety efforts,2) establishing centers to direct safety efforts, 3) improving reporting systems, and3) improving reporting systems, and

    4) providing incentives to health care team members4) providing incentives to health care team members

    and division leaders. These tactics are detailed belowand division leaders. These tactics are detailed below

    PengalamanPengalaman SMUHSMUH

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    56/61

    ggSouth Manchester University HospitalSouth Manchester University Hospital

    Membangun sistem pelaporan insidenMembangun sistem pelaporan insiden

    yang berbasis web bagi ujung tombakyang berbasis web bagi ujung tombak Bila laporan dimasukkan, sistem langsungBila laporan dimasukkan, sistem langsung

    mengirim email ke Manajemenmengirim email ke Manajemen RS merawat inap 69.000 pasien/tahunRS merawat inap 69.000 pasien/tahun

    Expected AE: 7.000 / tahunExpected AE: 7.000 / tahun

    Setelah 3 tahun sistem dibangun, laporanSetelah 3 tahun sistem dibangun, laporansudah mencapai 4.500 / tahunsudah mencapai 4.500 / tahun

    33--7% anonim, dirangsang utk pakai nama7% anonim, dirangsang utk pakai nama

    PengalamanPengalaman SMUHSMUH

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    57/61

    gSouth Manchester University HospitalSouth Manchester University Hospital

    Penjelasan tentang hubungan antaraPenjelasan tentang hubungan antara

    Pelaporan dengan PendisiplinanPelaporan dengan Pendisiplinan Penjelasan tentang hubungan antaraPenjelasan tentang hubungan antara

    Pelaporan dan pembelajaranPelaporan dan pembelajaran

    Pelatihan dilakukan di tempatPelatihan dilakukan di tempat

    Informasi dalam web: clinical risk, medicalInformasi dalam web: clinical risk, medical

    alert, archived safety materials, patientalert, archived safety materials, patientsafety newslettersafety newsletter

    OSF St. Joseph Medical Center,OSF St. Joseph Medical Center,

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    58/61

    in Bloomington, Ill.in Bloomington, Ill. Membolehkan juga pelaporan bersifatMembolehkan juga pelaporan bersifat

    informal oleh staf keperawatan, ahliinformal oleh staf keperawatan, ahlifarmasi, laboratorium dll, melalui:farmasi, laboratorium dll, melalui:

    Briefing saat pergantian shift jagaBriefing saat pergantian shift jaga Ronde rutin oleh manajemenRonde rutin oleh manajemen

    Telepon hotlineTelepon hotline

    Krause et alKrause et al

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    59/61

    Krause et alKrause et al

    Di luar bidang kedokteran:Di luar bidang kedokteran:

    safety assessments,safety assessments, steering committee formation,steering committee formation,

    development of checklists of welldevelopment of checklists of well--specifiedspecifiedcritical behaviors related to safetycritical behaviors related to safety

    observer training regarding the criticalobserver training regarding the critical

    behaviors,behaviors,

    observation and feedbackobservation and feedback

    FAKTAFAKTA

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    60/61

    FAKTAFAKTA

    Dengan sistem patient Safety, Sentara Norfolk GeneralDengan sistem patient Safety, Sentara Norfolk GeneralHospital: 84 % pengurangan Pneumonia yg berkaitan dgHospital: 84 % pengurangan Pneumonia yg berkaitan dg

    ventilator dari 2001 s/d Juni 2004ventilator dari 2001 s/d Juni 2004 Dengan Tim Tanggap Cepat di Missouri Baptist MedicalDengan Tim Tanggap Cepat di Missouri Baptist Medical

    Center telah menurunkan 60 % penurunan panggilanCenter telah menurunkan 60 % penurunan panggilandarurat henti nafas dan krisis serupa dan penurunandarurat henti nafas dan krisis serupa dan penurunan

    15% henti jantung.15% henti jantung. Johns Hopkins Hospital mengalami peningkatan 49Johns Hopkins Hospital mengalami peningkatan 49 -- 9191

    % proporsi pelaporan staf ICU tentang iklim safety dan% proporsi pelaporan staf ICU tentang iklim safety dan

    menghilangkan kasus infeksi pembuluh darah akibatmenghilangkan kasus infeksi pembuluh darah akibatkateterisasi, mencegah 8 kematian dan berhemat $2 jutakateterisasi, mencegah 8 kematian dan berhemat $2 jutapertahun.pertahun.

    Kasus adverse drug events menurun 91 percent di OSFKasus adverse drug events menurun 91 percent di OSFSt. Joseph Medical Center.St. Joseph Medical Center.

    KATA AKHIRKATA AKHIR

  • 8/10/2019 Bs Membangun Budaya Keselamatan Pasien

    61/61

    KATA AKHIRKATA AKHIR

    Keselamatan Pasien di Rumah SakitKeselamatan Pasien di Rumah Sakithanya dapat dicapai dengan membangunhanya dapat dicapai dengan membangunbudaya yang berorientasikan kepadabudaya yang berorientasikan kepadakeselamatan pasienkeselamatan pasien

    Budaya keselamatan pasien harusBudaya keselamatan pasien harusdipahami, dihayati dan diamalkan olehdipahami, dihayati dan diamalkan olehseluruh unsur rumah sakitseluruh unsur rumah sakit

    Peran pimpinan, baik formil maupun nonPeran pimpinan, baik formil maupun nonformil diperlukan dalam membentukformil diperlukan dalam membentuk nilainilai

    dan memberi teladan.dan memberi teladan.