Post on 31-Mar-2023
CrpyKrypHa~ M npMKlla.QHafl 11 "1 H rB"1CT"1 Ka
8
ISSN 0202-2400
•••••• t •• •• •• •t •••• • ••• • • • • • • • • • • • • • t
•••••• • •••••••• ••••••••••••••
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
CAHKT-IlETEPBYPfCKHil fOCY,lJ;APCTBEHHbltt YHMBEPCMTET
CTPYKTYPHA5! I1 ITPI1KJ1A~HA.H
J111HI'BI1CTI1KA
Me~ey3oec'K:uu c6opttu'K:
Ifa.u,aeTCH c 1987 ro.u,a
BbIIIYCK 8
flo,rr, pe,n;a~neli A. C. fep,n;a
• I VI3,ll;ATEJibCTBO C.-ITETEPBYPrCKOrO YHMBEPCVITETA 2010
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
Y,LU< 80+618.31 BBK 81.1
C83
PeAaK~HOHHax KOJIJier'HH: npo<P. JI. H. BeJIJl,eBa, npo<P. A . C. I'epa (OTB. peAaKTOp), npo<p. 0. H. I'puH.6ayM, npo<P. M.A. Mapycexito
CeKpeTapb peA~OHHolt KOJIJierirn B. H. Py6uxep
Pe~eH3eHT A-P cpR1IOJI. Hayi< npocp. M . A.Mapycex1t0
C83
Ile'WmaemC.R. no nocmattoeJ1.ettu10 Peda1'"4UO'H.H0-1.13dame.n.'bc1Cow coeema
Catt?Cm-Jlemep6ypzc1e020 wcydapcmeettttow yttueepcumema
CTpyKTypHrui: u npuKna,u;Hax Me)l(Bj'3. c6. I ITo~ pe.L(. A. c. rep~a. JH-Ta, 2010. 276 C.
nuHl'BHCTHKa. Bhm. 8: CIT6 .. lfa,n;-Bo C.-IleTep6.
C6opHHK (Bbln. 7 BblllleJI a 2007 ['.) coAep.lKHT cra.TbH no mHpOKOMY Kpycy npo6neM TOOpeTH"!ecKolt H npmu:a,rvrolt JlIDI['BHCTHKH, no npaMeHeHHIO MaTeMaTH'lecKHX MeTOAOB B H3bIK03H8.HHl'I .
.lVtx cne~aJJHCTOB no TOOpHH H3blKa, IlpHKJla,D,HOlt H TOOpeTH'leCKOlt JlHHI'BHCTHKe.
BBK 81.1
@ lbAaTeJibCTBO C .-IIerep6yprcKoro rocyAapCTBeHHoro )'HHBepcHTeTa., 2010
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
A. K. <1>UJ1.unnoe
CTPYKTYPA PAMOK BAJIEHTHOCTEH JICr rJIArOJIOB IlOJIO)KEHIUI B IIPOCTPAHCTBE H
JICr rJIArOJIOB MhIIIIJIEHH.H
Kn10"1eBN:e cnosa. KoMI!bIOTepHbdi Te3aypyc, RussNet, paMKH Ba.neHTHoCTeA, KOHTeKCT, ¢opM8JlblllXA aHaJIH3.
. AnnoT~. B craTI>e n:pHBO~ MaTepHa..7Ibl ,lVlH npe.a;C'I"aB.ll:elllUI B paMKaX
KOM!IbIOTepHoro cnoBapx pyccKoA JieKcHKH RussNet. B RussNet KOHTeKcryam.aaH HH¢opM~ 0 rnarone 3~ B B~e paMOK BaJieHTHOCTeA - Ha6opa KOHTeKCTHblX MapKepoB (BaJieHTHOCTeA) ):VlH Ka)K,!l;Oro H3 npe,D;C'raBJieHHblX B RussNet 3Ha'leHHA rnarona. B Hamea era.The ~aeTCSl onHcaime paMoK BaJieHTHOCTeA roiyx neKCHKO
ceMaHTH'lecKHX rpynn pyCCKHX rJiaroJIOB - I'pyruihI rnaroJIOB IlOJIO>KeHHi! B npoCTpaHCTBe H rpYJlIIbl rnaroJIOB Mhlmnemm. OnHcaime BKJIIO'laeT B ce6x nepe'leHb BaJieHTHhlX Il03H~, xapaKTepff3YIO~ rJiaroJihl ::lTHX rpynn, a TaJOKe onm:aime 3alIOJIHHTeJieA 1<8.>K,AOA: B8JleHTHOCTH co CTaTHCTH'lecKoA, MOp¢oJIOrH'IOCKOA H ceMaHTH'leCKoA TO'leK 3peHlm. MaTepHan, H3JIO>KeHlibrl1 B CTaTbe, HJrmocTpHpoBa.H MH0£'0'£HCJieHHhIMH npHMepaMH H3 Kopnyca TeKCTOB.
A. K. Filippov
Valency Frames Structure of the Verbs of Spatial Location and the Verbs of Mental Activity
Keywords. lexical database, RussNet, valency frames, context, formal analysis. Summary. The paper presents the material for the Russian lexical database
RussNet . Within RussNet, contextual information of a verb is described via valency frames - a set of local context markers (valencies) assigned to a particular sense of a word in RussNet. Here we present a contextual description of two distinct Russian verb groups. These are the verbs of spatial location and the verbs of mental activity. The materials we present include lists of valencies, characteristic for each verb group, as well as the description of fillers for each valency from the statistical, morphological, and semantic point of view. The presentation is illustrated with numerous examples from a text corpus.
@ A. K. Cl>HmrnilOB, 2010
117
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
HacTomn;ax CTaThH 3TO qacTh orrncaarui CTpy1<Typb1 pa.MOK Ba
JieBTBOCTeii pyccKoii I'JlarQJibBOtt JieKCHKH ,LJ:JIH rrpe,n;CTaimemra B KOM
llbIOTepBOM Te3aypyce RussNet. B pycJie RussNet B CTPYKTYPY ormca
HHSI CJIOBa BXO,u;HT ero ,n;egmam:vrn, B3XTaJI H3 TOJIKOBOI'O CJIOBapSI, H
yKa3aHHe Ha CBSI3b c ,n;pyrHMH 3JieMeHTaMH npH noMOIII;H onpe.n;e.rreB
HhlX OTHOmeHHtt, KaK napa,n;Hr:MaTeqecKHX, TaK H CRHTarMaTeqecKHX.
IIocJie,n;HHe ,n;aIOT HmpopMa~ o coqeTaeMOCTH 3JieMeHTa, Koropy10
IO . .II,. AnpecSIH C"IHTaJI "18.CTbIO ero JieKcHqecKoro 3aaqearur, npe,n;Jia
raSI IIOMem;aTb TaK)'IO HH<f:>opM~ BH)'Tpb CJIOBapao-a CTaTbH B BH,n;e
Mo,n;eJIH yrrpaan:earur CJIOBa (AnpecSIH 1974: 133). B CTP)'KType Russ
Net RH<f:>opMa.wrn o KOHTeKCTHblX rrpH3HaKax CJIOB xpaHHTCH B BH,IJ;e TaK
Ba3bJBaeMb1X paMO?C ea.aettmttocmeiL. BBJieHTHOCTb B mHpoKOM CMbICJie
CJIOBa, KaK oaa TpaKTYeTC.H B RussNet, 03Ha"laeT, BO-rrepBbIX, crroco6-
BOCTh CJIOBa IIpHCoe,n;HHHTb K ce6e 3JieMeHThl (He TOJibKO CJIOBa, HO
H rpymihl cnoB) B KaqecTBe 3aBHCHMhlX (a?Cmuetta.ii ea.aettmttocm'b), a BO-BTOpbIX, ero CilOCOOHOCTb, HaOOoJ>OT, rrp0coe,n;HID1TbCX K ,n;pyrHM
CJIOBaM B KaqeCTBe 3aBHCHMOro (ero naccuetta.R. ea.aettmttocm'b). TaK,
,n;JIH Hapeq:H.H B cpaBHHTeJibHOtt CTeileHH .11,y-'t'l.Ue naCCHBHOtt BaJieHTHO
CTbIO 6y,n;eT BaJieHTHOCTb Ha I'JiaroJI (pa6omaem .!1,1f"We), a aKTHBHOtt
BaJieHTHOCTb Ha 3TaJIOH cpaBHeHHSI B <f:>opMe HMeHHott I'pynIIhl ( .11.Y"'we Metui) HJIH cpaBHHTeJibHOro o6op<>Ta (.n,1J"LULe, "teM a); y npHnara
TeJibHOro 1CpaCU6'bl.iL eCTb rraCCHBHaH Ba.JieHTHOCTb Ha cym;eCTBHTeJibHoe
( 7qXJ.CU6'bl.iL 1COH.6epm) H aKTHBHaJI BaJieHTHOCTb Ha HapeqHe ( O"tett'b ?Cpa
cueuiL) (TecTeJie~ 2001: 162). ,L(JIH I'JiaI'OJIOB, rrpIDiaraTeJlbHhIX H HX .n;epHBaTOB )'Ka3blBaIOTCX HX
aKTHBHble BaJieHTHOCTH, a ,n;JIH cym;eCTBHTeJibHhIX H Hape~ rraccHB
Hble (A3apoBa 2005: 3). HB<f:>opMa.wrn o coqeTaeMOCTH JieKc0qecKott
e~~ II03B0.1lileT B KOH€"1HOM cqeTe )'TO"IHHTb, qeM ero JieKceqe
CKoe 3HaqeHHe QTJIHqa.eTCX OT 3Baqefflitt ,n;pyrux CJIOB, CXO:>KHX c HHM
no CMhICJIY. l:.Jro KaCaeTCSI I'JlaI'OJIOB, TO CJie.uyeT 3aMeTHTb, "ITO o.n;aa H3 HX BaJKHettmux Mop<f:>oJiorH"leCKHX xapaKTepHCTHK - nepexo.n;
HOCTb / aenepexo~oCTb, 3a.BHcmn;ax OT crroco6BOCTH HJIH aecnoco6ao
CTH rJiaroJia npHCoeAHJUITb npxMoe .n;orroJiaeuue. TaKHM o6pa30M, HH
<f:>opMa~H 0 CO"leTaeMOCTH CJIOB B8JKHa KaK Ba JieKCH'iecKOM, TaK H Ba
Mop<f:>onorH'lecKOM ypoBHHX.
PaMKa BaJieHTHocrett npe,n;cTa.BJIXeT co6ott rrepeqeffb BaJieHTBhIX no-
3~ IIpH HCCJie.uyeMOM CJIOBe. 9Tu II03~H eyMepyIOTCX no qacTOT
HOCTH pea.JIH3a~ BHYTPH CeMaHTHqecKott rpyrrrrbl, K KOTOpott 3TO
118
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
CJIOBO OTHOCHTCX, - Ta, KOTOpa.H B KOHTeKCTax qam;e Bcero OK83blBa
eTCH JanoJllleHHoa, noJiyqaeT aoMep 1 u TaK /1.8.llee. B pe3YJibTaTe CJio
Ba, 6JIHJKHe ,iwyr K ,iwyry B CTPYKTYpe RussNet, 11onyqa10T OAHffa
KOBhle HOMepa A1UI O,IJ;HHX H Tex )Ke BaJieBTHblX D03m:ufit. Ha OCHO
Bamm "iacTOTHOCTH JanoJIHemra BaJieBTaoA no3HU,HH ycra.HaBJIHBaeTCH
Mepa ee o6XJaTeJibHOCTH / cl>aKyJibTaTHBHOCTH. 9To cBolkTBO BaJieBT
HOCTH IO.,Ll;. Anpecxu paccMaTpHBaer OT/J.eJibHO ea CHHTaKCH"iecKOM e: aa ceMauTH"iecKOM ypoBHe. B ceMauTH'leCKOM DJia.ee o6513aTeJlbHOCTb
HJJH cPaKYJlbTaTHBHOCTb BaJieHTHOCTH Ollpe/J.emJeTCH H3 ua6opa yqacT
HHKOB CHTyaqHH, "iHCJIO KOTOpbIX MO.>KeT 6b1Tb cPHKCHpoBaHHhIM HJIH
H3MeHXTbCH (AnpeCHH 1974: 124- 125). CHHTaKCH"iecK8Jl)Ke o6513aTeJlb
HOCTh / <PaKyJILTaTHBHOCTh 3aBHCHT OT Toro, .HBJIXeTC.H ;m rrpeMO.>Ke
HHe B OTCYTCTBHe Ollpe/J.eJieHHOI'O aKTaHTa rpaMMaTH"iecKH apaBHJih
HhIM ( Ta..>vi: .>Ke: 149). TpaKTOBKY o6H3aTeJihHOCTH / cPSKfJibTaTHBHOCTH
B RussNet MO)fCHO yrrO/J.OOHTh, cKopee, CHHTaKCH'lecKoA o6HJaTeJihHO
CTH / cl>aKyJihTaTHBHOCTH, no IO. ,LI;. Anpec.say, nocKOJibKY oaa CB.HJaua
HMeHHO c 3aIIOJIHeHHeM II03HqHH B TeKCTe.
B RussNet npHHXTa IIIK8Jla rpa,u.8.Il,HH BaJieHTHOCTeA no CTeneHH
o6.H3aTeJibHOCTH / cPaKYJibTaTHBHOCTH, "iTO TaK.>Ke BDOJIHe cornacyerca
c JIHHrBHCTH'leCKOtt Tp~ea:; cp., Harrp.: «BaJieHTHOCTH CJIOBa < ... > MOrJT CHJibHO OTJIH'laThCH ,iwyr OT APyra no CTeneHH o6HJaTeJibHOCTH
cpaKyJibTaTHBHOCTH B TeKCTe» (TaM )Ke: 149). 06HJaTeJihHOA BaJieHT
HOCTh C'iHTaeTCH, ecJIH oua BCTpe"iaeTCH 6onee qeM B 673 KOHTeKCTOB,
cPaKYJlbTaTHBHoA (xoTH H TO.>Ke cym;ecTBeHHoA A1UI pa3JIHqemra 3ua
qemi:a) OT 35 /J.O 673. BCTpe"iaeMOCTh Meeee qeM B 353 CJJyqa.eB
I'OBOpHT 0 TOM, 'ITO Mbl mreeM /I.eJIO c OKKa3HOHaJibHhIM coqeraueeM,
He IIpe/J.CTaBJUUOm;HM B8JKHOCTH A1UI JieKCHKO-rpa.MMaTH"iecKOro OIIHCa
mra. Ilpe 3TOM Be npoBO/I.HTCH p83.1IH"iIDI Me.>K/J.Y aKTa.BTaMH H cepKOH
CTaHTaMH, TP~ KOTOporo, H)JJ'lll;aJI OT JI. TeBbepa (1988), npoquo
YKOpeBHJiach B H3blK03HaHHH {cM., uanp., (AnpecHH 1974; BoryCJiaB
cKHA 1985i 1996; Helbig 1986; KaceBH'I 1988; MeJihqyK 1997; TecTeJieu;
2001)), Ho KOTopoe DJioxo ao.n;xo/J.HT AJIX 3a,u.aq RussNet: pema.rom;ee
JuaqeHHe HMeeT He rpaMMaTH"iecKaH <l>opMa npacoell.HHXeMoro aneMeH
Ta, a CTeneHb peryJI.HpHOCTH ero CO'leT8.HH.H c HCCJie/J.YeMhlM CJIOBOM.
,Ll;a.n:ee A1UI K8.)l{,ll;OA BaJieHTBOA Il03aa;HH npH CJIOBe 3a,Il;a.eTCH rp8.MMa
TH"iecK8JI xapaKTepHCTHKa H CeMaHTH'lecKSX KB8.JIHcPHKalJ,WI ( A3apoBa
2005: 4- 5). I'paMMamu"'ec?Cll.A xapa?crnepucmmca aa.n:eBTuoa nooHU,HH 3~
Mop<PonorH"iecKHe KJiacchl CJIOB, cnoco6BblX ee 3anOJIHXTh. ,l1jul rna
roJIOB oea qam;e Bcero 38.,ZJ.a.eTCH I1pe,l1,JI0)KH0-ll8.,ZJ.e)KHOA <l>oPMOA, B KO-
119
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
ropoa CJIOB0-3anomn1Te.Jlb peryIDipHo BbICTynaer B KOHTeKcTax. Ha
npHMep, rnaron cmoJim"b B 1-M 3Ha<IeHHH - «B'btm"b tta ttozax 6 Bepmu?Ca.lt"bttOM no.1to:>1Cettuu, tte d6UZMC"b c Mecrna ( o .11:1odJ£X, ::>1eu6omtt'btX}; aattUMam"b .Mecmo zde-.!I.. , ttaxodJ£C"b 6 ma?Co.M no.!l.0:>1Cettuu» HMeeT ~e BaJieHTHble rro3HIJ;MH - cy6'beKTa H o6cTo&TeJibCTBa MecTa.
TiepBa& II03HIJ;lffi 3aIIOJifill:e'r(!jl B 90, 7% I<OHTeKCTOB H, CJie)J,OBaTeJib
HO, o6H3aTeJibHasr; oHa 3anoJIHHerc& cym;ecTBHTeJibHbIM HJIH JIH'lHhIM
MecTOHMeHHeM B <i>opMe HMeHHTeJibHOro na,n;e:>Ka e,rQnICTBeHHoro HJIH
MHO:>KeCTBeHHoro <rn:CJia. BTopasr :>Ke rro3HIJ,H& OKa3bIB8.€TC& 3aIIOJIHeH
HOA JIHIIIb B 52% CJiyqaeB H, CJie)J,OBaTe.JlbHO, cPaKYJibTaTHBHasr; OHa
HMeeT TPH OCHOBHbIX BapHaHTa 3aIIOJIHeHHH: npe)J,Jlor tta + II. n., aa / nepeiJ + T. n. nH6o y/603.!1.e/ . . + P. n.
CeM0:1-1,mu"tec?CaJi "1C6a.!l.UtPu?CaU,UJ£ BaJieHTHOCTH eocTOHT B onHcaHHH
ceMaHTH'lecKHX npH3HaKOB CJIOB, 3aIIOJIH.KIOm;HX ee. <l>aKTH'ieCKH OHa
OTChmaer K O.n,HOMY H3 ceMa.HTH'leCKHX .n,epeBbeB s CTPYKTYpe RussNet.
TaK, nepBa& BaJie.HTHa& rro3HIJ;lffi rmi.rona cmoJ£m"b1 qam;e Bcero 3aT
IIOJIHHe'r(!jl cym;ecTBHTeJibHhIM, o6o3Ha'laIOIIJ;IDII 'leJIOBeKa HJIH rpynny
JIIO,n;ea H rope,n;Ka - CJIOBoM, o6o3Ha<Ia10m;HM :>KHBOTHoe. BTopy10 rro3H
IJ,HIO MO:>Ker 3aHHMaTb ,D;OBOJibHO o6IIIHpHbitt p&.n, CJIOB H Bbipa:>KeHHtt,
o6m;ee 3Ha'leHHe KOTOpbIX HenpocTo c<l:>opMyJIMposaTh. Mo:>KHo BhI,n;e
JIHTh rrpu6JIH3HTeJibHO TaKHe sapHa.HTbI: 1) adattue wiu i)pywi1 067>e?Cm, coadatt·H:bl.i1 "te.ttoee?Co.M (TaK Ha3hIBaeMbitt apmeefxi,?Cm); 2) i)pywi1 "te.ttoee?C UJtu 6oo6w,e npO'U.360.!l."btt'bLi1 o67>e?Cm, omttocume.tt"bttO ?Comopow y?Ca3'bt6aemcJ£ .Mecmon0Ao::>1eei-me. BMeHTHyIO II03Hll,HIO npH cJiose
MOrYT 3aHHMaTb He TOJibKO CHHCeTbl 0)1,HOro ceMaHTH'!eCKOrO .n,epe
sa, HO TaK:>Ke CHHCe'rbI 0)1,HOro H3 ero IIOMepeBheB HJIH o6'be,rQnieHH&
HeCKOJibKHX .n;epeBbeB. IlpHMepbl CTa.H,u,apTHbIX o6'be.n,HHeHlitt - odyW£6JteH.H'bti1 o67>e?Cm = "te.tt06e?C + :>ICU6omttoe; tteodywe6.tte'Htt'bti1 067>e?Cm = ecmecmeetttt'bLi1 o67>e?Cm + UC?CYccmeetttt'bti1 o67>e?Cm + 6ew,ecm6o HT. II.
B xo.n;e Ramero ,D;HIIJIOMHoro HCCJie.n;osamrn (<l>ununnos 2008) MhI
IIJ>OBO)J,HJIH aHaJIH3 paMOK BaJieHTHOCTeA B JieKCHKO-CeMaHTH'leCKOtt
rpynne (JICr) rJiaroJios rroJio:>Kemrn B rrpocTpaHcTse. K ttacToruneMy
BpeMeHH pa6oTy TIO orrncamuo BaJieHTHOCTett 3TOtt rpyIIIIhl MO:>KHO C'lH
TaTb 3aBepmeHHott: Ha ocHosamrn o6mupttoro MaTepHa.rra BhI,n;eJieHhI
xapaKTepHbie .n;;rn JICr BaJieHTHOCTH, OHH o6pa6oTaHbl CTaTHCTH'le
CKH H CHa6:>KeHbl Mopcl><>JiorH'leCKOtt xapaKTepHCTHKOii H ceMaHTH'le
CKOtt KBaJIHcPHKau,Hett. B HaCTo&m;ee BpeMH .n;;rn COIIOCTaBJieHHH npoBO
,n;HTCH aHaJIOrH'IHa& pa6o'ia Ha MaTepHaJie JI Cr I'JiarOJIOB MbIIIIJieHHH -
rJiaI'OJibHOtt rpynnhl, HHTJHTHBHO om;ym;aeMott KaK MaKCHMaJibHO OT,n;a-
120
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
JieHHoA ITO ceMaHTHKe OT JICr rJiarOJIOB IIOJIO.>KeHIDI B rrpoCTpaHCTBe.
K HacTomn;eMy MOMeHTy cOCTaan:eH rrepeqeffb HaH6oJiee BepoHTHbIX aa
JieHTHOCTeA 3TOA rpyIIIIbI rJiaI'OJIOB, HaKOIIJieH o6IIIBpHhllt MaTepHM
Aflll Mopcl>onorHqecKoro H ceMaHTH'iecKoro aHaJIB3a BaJieHTHblX II03H~- CprumeHHe pa.MOK aaneHTHOCTea ~yx JICr MO.>KeT AaTb mrrepec
Hhle PffiYJibTaTbl.
CTpyKTypa pa.MOK aa.'JeHTHOCTeii JieKcm<o-ceMaHTH"tfecKoii
rpynnbl rJiaroJIOB llOJIO»CeHHH B npocTpaHCTBe
IloAPQ6H~ aH8.JIH3 paMOK BaJieHTHOCTe:tt rnaroJIOB IIOJIO.>Kemrn B rrpocrpa.HCTBe 6blJI ocym;ecrBJieH a Hamett AHIIJIOMHoa pa6oTe. Oa oc
HOBhIBaJICH Ha AaHHbIX KOpnyca pyccKHX TeKCTOB «BOKpeHOK 3•, coAep)f(am;ero 21 MJIH CJIOBoyrroTpe6neHllli. ,LYrn yKa3aHHH Ha qaCTOTY BCTpeqaeMOCTH Toro HJIH HHOro CJIOBa B 3TOM Kopnyce npHMeHHJICH K0-3cl>cl>HU,HeHT ipm (items per million) - noK83aTeJlb, OTp8.)Kruom;ea 'IHCno yrroTpe6neHllli CJIOBa B AaHHOM 3Ha'ieHHH Ha MHJIJIHOH CJIOBOyno
Tpe6neHHA B Koprryce. B nepBy10 oqepeAb onpeAeJIHJICH cOCTaB JICr. B COOTBeTCTBHH c MeTOAHKOA RussNet Ha rrepBOM 3Tane aeo6xoAHMO 6hlno BMAeJIHTb rnaroJibI, rrpeACTaBJIHJOm;He co6oa HAPO 3Tott rpyIIIIbI. ,l(nx 3Toro rJiaroJihl rrepBoHa'iaJibHO 6bIJIH AOCTaTO'IHO rrpoH3BOJlbHO oTo6p8Hhl H3 qacTOTnoro CJIOBapH C. A. Illapoaa Ha octtoBaHHH HHTYHTHBHOro KpHTepIDi HX IIpHHBATie.>KHOCTH K JICr rnaroJIOB IIOJIO)KeHHH B rrpocTpaHCTBej B AaJibHettm:eM Ha MaTepHane KOpnyca 3TOT CIIHCOK 6bIJI HecKOJTuKO CKOppeKTHpoBaH. 06m;ee "IHCJIO HCCJieAJeMbIX rJiaronoB coCTaBHJIO 43: 6pocumt>, Ba./l.J!,mt>c.ii, eucemt>, ec'IW"tum'b,
ecmam'b, B'bl.ttecmu, e'bl.nacm'b, e'bima~um'b, aattt.L.M.am'b, uc"'eattym'b, .tte:>feam'b, .tte"'b, .ttO:>fCUmt>CJ!., xaxoiJumt>CJ!., OKpy:>fCUm'b, onycmum'b, ony
cmum'bCJt, ocmatt06Um'bCJt, naiJam'b, noeepttym'b, nodttUMambCR, noiJ
H..Am'bCJt, nO.ttO:>fCUm'b, nonaaam'b, nocuaem'b, nocmaeum'b, nOJt6Um'bCJ!.,
no.iieJtJtm'bCJt, nputtocum'b, npunoattJl.m'b, npucymcmeoeamt>, ca.iJum'b
CJt, cea.ttum'bc.ii, cecm'b, cuaem'b, CJtO:HCUm'b, copeam'bCJt, cnyctcam'bCJ!., cmo.iim'b, mopttam'b, y6pam'b, y.tto:>feumt>, ynacm'b. qaCTOThl BXO)f{)l;eHHH rJiaroJIOB II03BOJIHJIH p83rp8.HH'DITb a.eHTp H rrepHcl>epmo rpyuIIhl. 5l'AepHYJO qacTb JICr coCTaBHJIH ttaa6onee qacTOTHble neKcll'IecKHe eAHHH~ H Te, KOTOphle Bhlpa.>KMH 3HaqeHHe JICr B HaH6oJiee o6m;eM BH)J.e, a ee rrepHcPePHJO - rnaroJihl, o6na,n;aaIIIHe MeHbmea qacroroa BCTpe"laeMOCTH B Kopnyce TeKCTOB H Bblp8.)KaBDIHe 6onee CJIO)KHbie AeACTBHH JIH6o MapKHpoBaHHble B CTHJIHCTHqecKOM IIJiaHe. Ilony'illBillaHCH rpymra IIOJIY"IHJiaCb, KpoMe TOI'O, AOCTa.TO'lllO HeQAffOpo,.z:r;HOA
121
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
KaK B :Mop¢oJiorHqecKoM, TaK H B ceMaHTH'ieCKOM IIJiaHe. YMo3pHTeJlb
HO ee MO.>KHO 6hIJIO p83.n,eJIHTb Ha TPH OOJihIIIBe rro.n,rpyIIIlhr.
I. Co6cmeetttto 2.11.aw.11:b/. npe6'bi.6attUJt B orrpe.n,eJieHHOM rrpoCTpaH
CTBeHHOM IIOJIO:>Kemm. B Ham5oJiee o6m;eM BH.n,e 3Ha<reHHe aToA no.n.
I'pynIIbl Bhlpa,)KaIOT CJIOBa Haxodum'bcR, aaHUMam'b H 6'b,m'b (rrocne.n.
HHe ,D,Ba B COOTBeTCTBYIOm;HX3Ha<remrnx); caMhie <raCTOTHhle, O.ZJ.IiaKO,
6oJiee KOHKpeTHhle rJiaroJihl cmo.R.m'b (ipm= l47,4), cudem'b (125,9) H
.tte:Heam'b (88,4). II. Httxoamuettue 2.11.a2M'bt - rJiaroJibI co 3Ha<reHHeM rrpmrnTHH
orrpe.n,enemmro IIp<>CT'paHCTBeHHoro rrono:>KeHHH. 3.n,ecb Bb~eneHHe .n.o
MHHaHTbI 6oJiee 3aTpy.n,HeHo, <reM B no.n,rpynrre I; cym;eCTBYIOT co
MHeHHH, HY:>KHO JIB paccMaTpHBaTb B Ka<reCTBe TaKoBoA rnaroJihl aaHJim'I> H noReumt>cR. Ha BTOpoM ypoBHe 11epapxHH, KaK H B no.n.rpyrr
ne I, pacnonaraIOTC.H HaH6oJiee <raCTOTHbie JieKceMhI - cecm'b / cadum'bC.R. (13,7 /31,0), ecmam'b (68,0), .tte"l.'b / .11.0:HCUmt>cR (25,7 / 8,9).
III. Kayaamuettue 2.11.aw.11.'bt. B Ka<recTBe JieKceMhl c HaH6onee o6-· III;HM 3Ha<reHHeM 3.n,ecb, B03MO:>KHO, CJie.n.yeT yK83aTb rJiaroJI nepeMecmumt>, a HaHOOJibllYIO qacTOTHOCTb H.'vleIOT rJiaroJibl no.ttO:HCUffl'b (82,7) H nocmaeum'b (67,6). 9Ta 110.n,rpynna OTJrn<raeTCH OT rrepBhIX
,D,Byx He TOJibKO ceMaHTH<fecKH, HO H Mop¢oJioreqecKH: B Hee BXO)J..HT
nepexo.n,Hhle rJiaroJibl.
HecMoTpH Ha aeo.n,uopo.n,uocTb, o&be.n,HHeHHe Bcex Tpex no.n,rpynn
B ' e.n,HHyIO rpynny rJiaroJIOB IlOJIO:>KeHHH B npOCTpaHCTBe orrpaB)J,aHO,
nocKOJibKY ece aTH TPH no.n.rpynIIbI B cTpyKType RussNet, oqeBH.n,HO,
6y.n.yT pacnOJIO:>KeHbI 6JIH3KO .n.pyr K .n.pyry H CB.H3aHhI OTHOmeHIDIMH
CHIIXOaTHBHOCThll> H cKay3aTHBHOCTbll>.
Ha Ka)l{,.!J.bIA H3 43 rnaroJIOB H3 Kopnyca 6Lmo CJIY<faAHbIM o6pa-
30M oTo6paHo no 150 KOHTeKCTOB. IIocKOJibKY 6oJiblIIHHCTBO rJiaroJioB
6blJIH MHOI'03Ha'IHblMH, )J,JI.H aHaJIH3a paMOK BaJieHTHOCTeA HeOOXO.n,H
MO 6bIJIO OTo6paTh TOJibKO Te KOHTeKCTbI, B KOTOpbIX peaJIH30BbIBaJIOCh
KOHKpeTHoe, rrpocrpaHCTBeHHoe 3HaqeHHe rJiaroJia (HJIH 3HaqeHHH, ec
;m Ta.KHX 6bIJlo HecKOJihKO). ,L(Jrn 3TOA n;e;m oTo6paHHbie paHee KOH
TeKCTbl 6hIJIH Bpyqayro KJiaccH¢HIJ;HPoBaHhI no 3Ha<reHIDIM. 3a OCHOBY
.ZJ.JIH BbIAeJiemrn 3Ha<reHHA 6paJIHCh orrpe.n,eJieHHH «CJioBapH pyccKoro
IDhIKa» (1957-1961: T. I-IV). B cooTBeTCTBHH c MeTO.ZJ.HKOA RussNet
Ka:>K.n,oe ·3HaqeHHe rJiaroJia paccMaTpHBaJIOCb KaK OT.n,eJlbHa.H JieKceMa.
B HTOre BMecTO 43 HCXO)J.HhIX rJiaroJioB o6beKTOM HCCJie.n,oBaHH.H CTa.JIH
66 nap crJiaron - 3Ha'IeHHe». Ha HX MaTepHaJie 6hIJI cOCTaBJieH cIIH
coK BaJieHTHhIX II03HD;HA, xapaKTepH3yIOm;HX JICr rJiarOJIOB IIOJIO:>Ke
HIDI B IIJX>CT'PaHCTBe, a 3aTeM )J,JIH OT.ZJ.eJihHbIX rJiaroJIOB (3Ha<reHHA) 6bl-
122
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
JIB y.K83aHhl rpaMMaTWieCKBJI :xapaKTepHCTHKa H ceMaBTH'lecKaSI KB8.
JIBQ>HK~ BaJJeHTHbIX nooHu,mt. Ka.)K,ZJ,oA Ba.JieHTHOCTH 6blJI npHcBoeH
noKa3aTeJlb o6roaTeJibHOCTH / ¢aKJJlbTaTHBHOCTH: ~853- o6.H3aTe.llb
H8JI BaJieHTHOCTb, <853, HO ~653-¢aKJJlbTaTHBHO-OO.H3aTeJlbH8JI, <653, HO ~353-¢aeyJlbTaTHBHaH, <353, HO ~153-¢aKJJ1bTaTHBHO-OKKa.3HOHa.JibH8JI, <153- OKK83HOHa.JlbHax. IIony'leHHhIA cnHCOK
HeoKKa3HOHa.JibHbIX (T. e. peneBaHTHbIX .n;mi RussNet) Ba.JieHTHocrea
BblrJUl,ll;eJI CJie,LzyIOID;HM o6pa30M.
• IIepBoA )J.IDI Bcex paccMoTpeHHbIX rnaronoB 6bIJla BaJieHTHOCTb
Ha cy6'beKT, "ITO H Hey.rr;HBHTeJlbHO, IlOCKOJibKY 6e3JIB'IHblX rJI&
roJIOB Cpe)J.H HHX He 6bLJIO (HMeJICH B BH,Zzy ceMaHTH'lecKHA: cyfu,
eKT, a He rpa.MMaTWiecKoe noA1Ie:>K~ee). IIpaKTH'lecKH .n;mi Bcex
rJiaroJIOB aTa Ba.JieHTHOCTb 6b1Jla o6.si:3aTeJlbHOA HJIB, B KpaAHeM
cJiy'lae, ¢aKYJlbTaTHBHO-OO.H3aTeJibHOA.
• BTOpoA BaJieHTHOCTbIO All.SI IIOro:'J>ymibI KaJ3aTHBHbIX rJiaroJioB
6bIJia BaJJeHTHOCTb Ha o&beKT - IIpaKTH"lecKH Bcer,n;a o6.H3aTeJib
Ha.H.
• Cne.n;y10m;eA no3~eA, KoTOpa.si: OKa.3aJiacb Ba:>KHoA )J.IDI no,n;as
JI.HIOm;ero 6oJlbIIIHHCTBa rJiaroJIOB, 6bIJia no3~ o6CTO.HTeJib
CTBa MecTa. Y'IBTbIBa.H ceMaHTHKY JICr, TaKoA pe3JJibTaT TaK:>Ke
ae npe,n;CTa.BmleTCH HOO:>KH.n;aHHblM. CnoBa H Bblpa:>KeHHH, 3anon
H.HBnme aTY BaJieHTHJIO Il03HIJ;HIO, MO:>KHO 6hlJIO p83,D;eJIHTb Ha
TpH THIJa, OTBe'laBnme Ha BOnpoc cr,n;e?>, «Ky,n;a?> HJIB «OTKY
,n;a?>. cha BaJieHTHOCTb y pa3HhIX rJiarOJIOB MOrJia 6bITb OO.H3a
TeJibHOA, ¢aKyJlbTaTHBHO-OO.H3aTeJlbHOA HJIB <l>aKYJibTanraHoA.
BoJlbIIIHHCTBO ,zq>yrHX nooHIJ,ldt, HCCJie,n;oB8.HHbIX B xo,n;e pa6oTbI ( o6-CTO.HTeJibCTBO BpeMeHH, o6pa3a ,n;eA:CTBH.H, cnoco6a H T. n.) 3aDOJIH.H
JIHCb JIHilib OKK83HOHaJlbHO; CJie,D;OBaTeJibHO, B OITHCaHHe paMOK Ba
JieHTHOCTeA OHH He BOUIJIH. BhIJIO Bhl.HBJieHO JIHIIIb ,ZJ;Ba HCKJIIO'lemrn.
Bo-nepBbIX, .n;mi rJiarona .n.e-t'b B 3Ha'leHHH «JIO:>KHTbCH cnaTb> Ba:>KHoA
OKa3aJiacb no3~ o6CTOHTeJibCTBa ~eJIH. Oaa 6bIJia 3anoJIHeHHoA B
54,53 KOHTeKCTOB; B poJIH 3aDOJIHHTeJI.H KaJt'~i\ p83 BbICTyllaJIO 0,n;HO
H TO :>Ke CJIOBO - co6cTBeHHO HHQ>HHHTHB cnamt>. Bo-BTOpblX, .n;mi rna.
rona npucymcmeoeam'b «HaxO,n;HTbCH, 6bITb r,n;e-n. B ,n;aHHoe BpeMH> B
79,33 CJIY"laeB npHCJTCTBOBa.JIO yK83aHHe Ha co6bITHe, npH KOTOpoM
(wm Ha KOTOpoM) rrpHCJTCTByer cy6'beKT.
BT op hi M aTanoM 6hlJIO coCTaBJieHHe MOP<l>oJioreqecKoA xapaKTe
pHCTHKH H ceMaHTH"lecKoA KBaJIHQ>HKa.u,im Bcex HeoKKa3HOHaJibHhlX
Ba.JieHTHbIX 003Hu,mt.
CeMaHTH'lecKa.H KBa.JIHQ>HKaII,IDI Il03~ cy6'beKTa BbUIBHJia KOp-
123
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
pemII\HIO c ,n;ecl>HH~ COOTBeTCTBYIO~ rJiaI'OJIOB B TOJIKOBOM
CJIOBape- c )'Ka3amrnMH nma «O JIIO~ ()KHBOTHbIX, npe)I.MeTax, Be
m;ax) ». 3anoJIHeHHe no3mi;HH o6'beKTa TO)f{e 3aBHCHT OT ceMa.HTHKH rna
rona, HO no ,n;e<l>HHH~H ero rrpe,n.cKa3aTb CJIO)f{Hee. qTO Kacaerc.a rro-
3HI.T,HH o6CTOHTeJibCTBa MeCTa, TO ee MQ)f{eT 3aITOJIH.HTb ,Ll;OCTaToqHo o6-IIIHpllhill KJiacc cnoa, 3aTpy,n.H.HIOII:l';Htt B03MO)f{HOCTH .D.JI.H o6o6m;eHIDi. B
KaqeCTBe 3aITOJIHHTeJieti 3TOA Ba.JieHTHOCTeA MO)f{HO rrepeqHCJIHTb CJie
.n.yIOm;He OCHOBHbie ce~'.18.HTHqecKHe KJiaCCbI CJIOB:
• 2opU3011.ma.11:btta.R. HJIH (pe*e) aepmu?Ca.11:btta.R. rroaepxaocTh: «Bo
p.a .n.e:HCa.11. 11.a napme u c.Mompe.n. 11.a 'IC./l,Q,CCHY?O dOC?CY»' «IlOTOM
nooecbm.e JIHCTOK tta cme11.e 11.a ypoa11.e caoux 2.11.aa u Bcmatt'bme (.11,u60 cRi>bme) .AU'40M.,,. xe..wy 11.a paccmoRttuu o01tow Mempa;
• aiJa11.ue HJIH Boo6w,e npocmpattcmeo: «f,n;e-To qacoa B O,n.HHHa
MaTb .H c1n0.11..ti 11.a 6a.n.?COue c Bacett H BoJio,n;ett, MOJIO,D.bIMH ac
ITHpaHTa.MH He,n.ocHJIOBa»; «MHe *e ocTaJIOCb ua '/CYXHU awuecmu cToJI, rroCTaBHTh TaM KpoBaTh c T}'M6o'iKoA H Ha TyM6o'iKy
6y,n.HJihHHK» j
• Mecm11.ocm'b: «CoMHemrl!: He ocTaBaJIOCb: OH ~a.nCJ& 11.a oiJ-11.oM ua OT,n;aJieHHhIX 6e3JIIO,D;Hb!X rrec'iaHbIX ocmpoeoB, pacno
JIO)f{eHHhIX Ha IlOJIIlYTH Me)f{,ll;y 6eperoM MaTepm<a H OCTpoBOM
Battra'l»; «.LVra ,n;ayx3TaJKHoro CTpoeHH.H <. . > ttaXoo.siw,ezoc.si a 50 ?C.M om Moc?CB'b,, rrpH py'iHOti pa36opKe ace y,n;oBOJibCTBHe
o6oti,n;eTCH B 5-7 TbIC. ,D;OJIJiapoB B 3aBHCHMOCTH OT IIpo'iHOCTH
CTpoeHH.H» j
• cpeiJa: «PblBOK BBepX H < ... > Ka.MHeM naoaeM 6 BO(}y, C Tpy
,D;OM IIpo,lJ;HpruICb CKB03b ee rrpo3pa'iHO-pa3HO~eTHble CJIOH»j
«9Ta rpynna MOB, nonailasi 6 'ICpOB'b, pa3pymaer 3pHTpo~TbI, KJieTKH KpoBH, H reMOrJio6HH BbIXO,n.HT B IlJia3MY»;
• npeiJMem ( qacTO aPTecPaKT) HJIH ,D.a)f{e "{e,tl.06e?C, OTHOCHTeJibHO
KOTOporo onpe,n;eJI.HeTC.H MeCTOIIOJIO)f{eHHe cy6'beKTa (B CJiyqae
Kay3aTHBHbIX r JiaronoB - o6'beKTa): «l1acneKTOp XMeJibHHIJ;ICHtt
o6Tep MOKpbiti )Ke3JI, no.11.o:HCU.11. noy.n;o6Hee e PY'/CY, nocJie~Htt pa3 IIOrJIMeJI Ha Cepre.H H •.• »; «THMocl>ett raapHJIOBH'i cmo.si.1t nepeiJ HUM - ?Ca.Metttt'bl.M UdO.AOM»; «Pa3,n;eBmHCb, H BbIKJIIOqHJI
caer H .n.ez pRiJOM c Bu?Cou». fpaMMamqecKa.H xapaKTepHCTHKa paccMaTpHBaeMoti rpynnhI rna
ronoB ,n;ana BilOJIHe npe,n;cKa3yeMhie pe3yJibT3ThI. EcreCTBeHHO, B p0JIH
cy6'beKTa BhICTynaJIH cym;eCTBHTeJibHbie HJIH JIH'IHble MecTOHMeHH.H B
HMeHHTeJibHOM na,n;e*e, a B ponH o6'beKTa ( ecJIH OH 6bIJI) - B BHHHTeJib
HOM. Pa3.IIH'IIDI, KaK H O)KH,ll;aJIOCh, co,n;ep)f{aJIHCh B cnoco6e 3arroJIHe-
124
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
HIIB no3HD,mI o6CT051Te.llbCTBa MecTa. 3,n.ecb BCTpeqa.JIHcb p83aoo6paJ
Hbie npeAJIO)KHO-II8.,iJ.e)KHb1e rpymn,r (p83JlllqHbie AJI51 p83HbIX maro
JIOB - npHMepbI CM. Bbime) H aapeq:eg: « Onycmume ettua <Pna>t<oK
npe,n;oxpa.HHTeJI51>; <Bee KHHYJIHCb 3a KaMHR, OCKOJIKH AeZAU COBCeM
6.tiU3?C01>.
Bonee no.n;po6aoe onHcaHHe pa.MOK Ba.JieHTHOCTett rnaronoB nono
)Kemrn B npoCTpaHCTBe CM. (<I>HJIHIIIIOB 2008).
CTPYKTypa paMoK ean:eaTnocTeii JieKCHKO-CeMaHTH'leCKOH rpynnbl rJiaI'OJIOB MblWJieHHSI
CnHCOK rnaronoB MbllIIJieHIDI ,II.JIB aacTomu;ero HCCJie,n.oBaHIDI 6hIJI
cocTaBJieH Ha 6aJe KaH,n;H,n;aTCKoro HCCJie,n.oBaHR51 0. A. MaTpocl>aHOBott
no ceM8.HTH<J:eCKOMY OmICaHHIO IIOJiett r;raroJIOB npon;ecca "Mbllll
Jiemrn pyccKoro H aar.n:mtcKoro 513hIKOB. OpurRH8JiblihlA CIIHCOK
0. A. MHTpocl>aaoBoA BKJIIOqaJI B ce6g 36 pyccKHX maronoB, 22 R3 KO
TOpbrx COCTaBJI51JIH 11 BH,LJ.OBbIX nap, a 14 6bIJIH O,n;HOBH,ll;OBbIMH: 7 -coBepmeHHoro BR,LJ.a R 7 - aecoBepmeaaoro (MHTpocPaHoBa 1999). IloCKOJibKY HaCTOmu;ee HCCJie,n;OBaHHe 6bIJIO CB.H3aHO c aHaJIR30M KOHTeK
CTOB R3 Kopnyca pyccKHX TeKCTOB «BOKpeHOK 31>, MhI MOrJIH HCIIOJib-
30BaTb JIHIDb Te rnaroJibI, ynOTpe6neHID1 KOTOpbIX 6bIJIH aaJ:lAeHbl B
3TOM KOpnyce. qHCJIO Ta.KHX rnaroJIOB COCTaBHJIO 22; HIDKe IIpHBO,ll;HT
C51 RX CilHCOK, a TaK)Ke qacTOTbI HCCJie,n;yeMbIX rJiaroJIOB B KOpnyce B
a6COJIIOTHOM HC'iHCJieHHH H B OTHOCHTeJibHOM, Bbipa)KeHHOM B ipm.
Ta6:.im~a 1. CnacoK H '<laCTOTbl l'naronoo MblWJieeH.11
N• rn8.I'OJI qa.cro- qa.cTO- X• rnaro.n qa.cro- '!aero-n/n T3 a6c. Taipm n/n T3 a6c. Taipm
1 B.zzy-MaTbCSI 74 3,5 12 IITo.zzyMaTb 3586 170,8 2 B.zzy-MblBa.TbCSI 14 0,6 13 fIO,Lzy"MblBaTb 46 2,2 3 )I.o.zzy-MaTb 27 1,3 14 Ilopa3Mb!CJIHTb 55 2,6 4 .IJ:o.zzyMhIBaTb 15 0,7 15 fIOpa3MblIIIJll[Tb 34 1,6 5 .LJ:yMaTb 5969 284,2 16 JipH38.llyMaTbCH 43 2,0 6 ~a,zzyMaTbCSI 600 28,6 17 Jipo.zzyMaTb 219 10,4 7 ~a,zzyMbma.TbCH 446 21,2 18 Jipo.zzy-Ml>IBaTb 20 1,0 8 MbicmtTb 272 13,0 19 Pa3.a;yMb!BaTb 114 5,4 9 06.zzyMaTb 69 3,3 20 p a3MbJil.L1l.SITb 444 21,1
10 06.zzy-MblB3Tb 81 3,9 21 Pa.ccy:lK,ll;aTb 421 20,0 11 Ilepe.zzyMhIBaTb 4 0,2 22 I Coo6pa.>Ka.Tb 267 12,7
Ha 3TOM :nane ocaoBHoA Ja,n.aqeA CTaJio onpe,n;eneHHe o6in;ea CTpyK
TypbI pa.MOK BaJieHTHOCTeA rJiaroJIOB MbIIIIJieHH.H, COCTaBJieHHe nepeq:-
125
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
JUI HX BaJieHTHhIX rroo~a ( aprJMeHTOB), IIO,D;OOHO TOMy, KaK 3TO 6blJIO
c.n;eJiaHO ,ll,Jlll rJiaroJIOB IIOJIO)Keffirn B IIpOCTpaHCTBe. ,lJjrn 3Toro H3 KOp
rryca 6blJia c,n;e.n:a.Ha BbIDopKa B 150 KOHTeKCTOB Ha K~ rnaroJI;
ecJIB o6~ee 'lllCJIO KOHTeKCTOB Ha KaKoA-mt6o rJiarOJI He ,D;OXO.u;HJIO .n;o 150, TO HCIIOJib30B8JIHCb BCe H~eHHhle KOHTeKCTbl. IloCJie 3TOro Bbl-
6paHHble KOHTeKCTbI 6bI;m: rrpoaHaJIH3HpoBaHbl: B K~OM KOHTeKCTe
6blJIH BbI)J;eJieHbI Bee CHHTaKCHqeCKH 3aBHCHMbie OT r JiaroJia ··3JieMeH
TbI, H 3TH 3JieMeHTbI 6blJIH CrpymmpoBaHbI ITO KJiaCCaM. rpyIIIIHpOBKa
3Ta rrpoH3BO.u;HJiacb OOJibllieA qacTbIO no CHHTaKcHqecKOMY rrpH3HaKy,
HO rrpH Heo6xo.n;m.mcnr c orropoa Ha ceMaHTHKY H MOJXPoJIOrnIO. TaK,
rro.n; cy6'beKTOM H o6'beKTOM B 3TOM KOHTeKCTe IIOHHMaJIHCb He rpaM
MaTHqecKHe IIO)Vle)f(a~ee H npHMoe ,D;OIIOJIHeHHe, a HMeHHO ceMaHTH
qecKJrl!: cy6'beKT H ceMaHTHqecKJrl!: o6'heKT; 3TO pa3JIH'IBe cy~ecTBeHHO
He TOJibKO .n;;ra KOHCTp~ c uaccHBOM, HO TaIOKe H )VIH KOHTeKCTOB
c HeJIH~H <i>op.Ma.MH rnaroJia - HHcPHHHTHBOM, npR'iacTHeM H .n;e
errpH<iacn1eM, KOTOpble B rrpmm,m1e He CIIOCOOHbl BhlCTyrraTb B poJIH
rpaMMaTH<ieCKOro CKa3yeMoro.
Te KJiacchl sneMeHTOe, KOTOpble .n;JIH rnarona He HOCHJIH OKKa3HO
HaJibHoro xapaKTepa (noeTOpHJIHCb B pH,D;e KOHTeKCTOB), MO>KHO 6bIJIO
cqHTaTb sxo,n;H~H s pa.MKY Ba.rreHTHOCTH sToro rnaroJia. CpimHeHHe
paMoK saneHTHOCTH pa3HblX rnaroJIOB II03BOJIHJio c.n;enaTb BbIBO,D;bl o
CTPJKType ynpaeJieHIDI rnaronoB JICr rJiaroJIOB MbIIIIJieHHH B ~eJIOM. Y)Ke yrroMHHJTbIA ceMattmtNecnuu cy~enm 6hm rrepBOA H ca
Mott oqeBH,JJ;HOA BaJieHTHOCTbIOj OH Boo6~e rrpHcy~ He OT,D;eJibHbIM rna
roJiaM HJIH KaKHM-JIH6o KOHKpeTHbIM rJiaroJibHhlM KJiaccaM, a rro,n;aB
JIHIO~eMy 6oJibDIHHCTBY pyccKoti (H He TOJibKO pyccKoti) rJiarOJibHoti
JieKCHKH soo6~e. Ho ecJIH B ce~iaHTH<iecKOM IIJiaHe cy6'heKT npH rJia
ronax MblIIIJieHHH JICr ecTb Bcer,n;a, TO ero 3KCIIJIHIJ,HTHoe Bhlpa)KeHHe
y.n;anocb HMTH .n;aneKO He BO BCex KOHTeKCTax. ,lLa)Ke B KOHTeKCTax c
HCIIOJib30BaHHeM JlH'IHbIX <l>opM rJiaroJia, r,n;e <iHCTO CHHTaKCH<ieCKH HH
'ITO He MemaeT yrrOTpe6JieHHIO cy6'beKTa, BCTpeTHJIOCb MHOro cnyqaeB
3JIJIHIICHCa, CTOJib qacTblX KaK B pa3rOBOpHott, TaK H B xy.n;o)KeCTBeH
HOA. 9TO npHMepbl THila «fl Jie)KaJI, <iHTaJI, roBOPHJI CaM c co6oa.
Ecim, 3aOyMa6W.UCb, paccna6JIHJI rJia3a, 6yKBhl OTpbIBaJIHCb OT JIH
CTa H IIOBHCaJIH B npoCTpaHCTBe•; «lfA'bJI, 6bICTpo 3anHpaeT mKa<l><iHK. Paai}yM"'8aem». Ta.IOKe 3aqaCTy10 aJIJIHIITHpOB8.HHbIM OKa3bIBa.eTCH
cy6'beKT H B KOHTeKCTax c rJiaroJiaMH B <i>opMax 1-ro H 2-ro ~a, KO
TOpbie II03BOJIHIOT O.n;H03Haqff0 BOCCTaHOBHTb cy6'beKT COOTBeTCTBY
IO~ee MeCTOHMeHHe - H IIOTOMY BBH.n;y H36blTO<{H0CTH B pH.n;e cJiyqaeB
OHO OTCJTCTByeT: « 't.fHTaJI TBOIO CTaTbIO. CBoeBpeMeHHO H npaBHJibHO
126
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
M'b«!AU'l.Ut.•; «Y)f(e IIOIDIJI: H,Liy Ha BTOpott cpoK . .11.n;8.)f(e noiJyM'bl.6a70
0 .n;pyrHX nepe.n;aqax Ha TOM )Ke Ka.Ha.ii:e>. qTO )Ke KacaeTCH KOHTeKCTOB
c HeJIH'IBhlMH <l>opMaMH, TO 3.n;ecb .n;ru1<e B Tex CJiyqaxx, Kor.n;a cy6-beKT
.n;eiiCTBWI JKa.:3aH 3KCilJUiqliTHO, OH, Ka.K IlpaBHJJO, OKa.:3bIBaeTCH ('ITO H
Hey,u;HBHTeJlhHO) CHHTB.KCH"iecKH He CB.H3a.HHblM c rJiarOJIOM Henocpe.n;
CTBeHHO: «Ott xoTen c.n;eJiaTb .5IKoBy .n;o6po, He .n;aTb 3a.Mep3HJTb, qyB
CTBY.H ero xono.n;, HO e~e e.M.Y XOTeJIOCb KpacHBOCTH, H, iJyMa.11. 0 6paTe,
Ott BH.n;eJI ce6.H Toqao B o6HHMKY c HHM»; «P83)'MeeTC.H, 3TOT .n;oKJMeHT
au.pe?Cmopa.M e~e npe.n;CTOHT ,D;eT8..'lbHO H3Y"<IHTb H npoiJyMam'b Ka.K
H B Ka.KHe cpoKH peaml30BbIBaTb Te HJIH HHhle ero nono:>KeHH.H>. B .n;pyrex )Ke CJiy"ia.IDC BOCCTaHOBHTb cy&beKT He y.n;aercx Boo6~e - HH B
pa.MKax .n;rumoro npe,n;JIO)f(emra, HH B 6onee IDHpoKOM KOHTeKCTe - 3TO
CJiyqaH Heonpe.n;eneHHO-JIH'iHOro ynOTpe6nemrn THDa «Mo:>KHO 6bIJIO
noiJyMam'b, qro OH CDHT», «MHorue :>KHBYT e~e XJ:>Ke, 'leM PacKOJib
HHKOB, XOTH eCJIH aaiJyMam'bCA, TO npHXO)J;HT MhlCJib ••••.
IIocKOJibKY no.n;o6HbIX cnyqaeB 6hmo HeMano, npu oDHcaHHH pa
MOK BaJieHTHOCTeA HeOOXO.n;HMO 6bIJIO OTp83HTb peryJIHpflbdt 3JIJIHII
CHC cyfu,eKTa- JKa.:38.fIHe Ha 3aDOJIHeHHyio B 1003 CJiyqaeB BaJieHT
HOCTb cy6'beKTa .n;JIH BCex HCCJie.n;yeMhlX rnarOJIOB 6hIJIO 61,;c COBepmeHHO
HeHH<l>opMaTHBHhIM. A .n;nx Toro 'lTOObI OTp83HTb 3TO HBJieHHe, Tpe-
6oBa.Jiach e,1J;HHoo6paaHax TpaKTOBKa Bcex cnopHbIX CJiyqaeB. O,~BHM B03MO.>KHblM BbIXO,D;OM H3 DOJIO:>Kemra 6bIJIO 6bl npH3HaHHe 3JIJIHIICeca
cyfu,eKTa BO Bcex KOHTeKCTax c Bep6oH,D;aMH (KpoMe CJIY'laeB, KOI'.n;a
DpH'iacTHe HJIH npH'laCTBbIA o6opoT CB.H38.Hbl c cy6'heKTOM Henocpe.n;
CTBeHHO, K8.K, K npHMepy, B KOHTeKCTe cTo eCTb 3Ta <l>ororpacl>WI MO
)f(eT npHlleCTH .n;JIH .ll:IOaeiL, pa8M'bl.tu.11.11701.qUX 0 :>KHTb~6blTbe, HeKoe
o6o6~eHHe>). Ho, DOCKOJibKY BO MHorex CJIY'laHX, Ka.I< y)l(e roBOpe
JIOCb, KOHTeKCT D03BOJIHeT onpe,n;eJIHTb ceMaHTH"ieciarlt cyfu,eKT H .n;JIH
HeJIHqfiblX I'JiaroJibBbIX cPoPM, MbI Be C'lHTaJIH ero 3JIJIHDTHpOB8.HHbIM,
eCJie y.n;aBanocb aaATH o.n;ao3Ha'illoe JKa.:3aHHe Ha cy6'beKT B npe.n;enax
o.n;aoro IIpe,LVIO>KeBWI, KB.K B npm1epax cllo.n.'baoeame.llJi.M. Httmepttem B8JKHO HaJ"<lnTbCH CKeDTH'leCKH OTHOCHTbCH K nonyqaeMoA HMH IIO'lTe
H T~aTeJlhHO npoiJyMtAeam'b IIOCJie,n;CTBWI, IIpeJK,n;e 'ieM pacnpoCTpa
IDITb TaKHe IlOCJiaHIDI>, cf! DOBeJYreJI JIHCTOK B pJKax, coofjpa:Hca.11>.
c .n;pyrrut CTOpOHbl, eCJIH cyfu,eKT B npe.n;eJiax Dpe,ll;JIO)f(eHIDI HBHblM
o6pa.:30M He cPHrYPHpoBaJI, TO OH C'iHT8JICH 3JIJillllTHpoBaHHhIM .n;a:>Ke B
TeX CJiyqa.srx, KOr.n;a BOCCT8HaBJIHBaJICR COBepmeHBO O,n;B03Haqao - KB.K
B y)Ke ynoMRHyTblX CJiyqa.IDC c ynoTpe6JieHHeM <l>oPM 1 H 2 mm,a, a TS.K
:>Ke B CJiy'lae ecJIH maron ynoTpe6Jlj{JICH B <l>opMe HMnepaTHBa: cTB.K
'ITO, eCJIH qero ae XBaTaer-ca.MH iJoiJyMaume>. Ta.KHM o6paaoM, oc-
127
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
HOBHblM KpHTepHeM rrpH p83rpaaHqemm CJiy"<IaeB 3JIJIHilTHpOBaHHOCTH
H He3JIJIHIITHpOBaHHOCTH cy6'heKTa 6hIJIO HaJIHqHe ( HJIH OTCYTCTBHe) B
rrpe)VIO)f{eHHH qJieHa, urpaiom;ero poJih ceMaHTuqecKoro cy6'beKTa no
OTHOmeHHlO K HCCJie.zzyeMOMY rJiaroJiy.
Ta&uqa 2. ,Ll;oJUI KOHTeKcTOB c 9JlJIHDTnposaHHblM cy6'heKTOM
AJljl rJiaroJIOB MblllLIIeHIUI
rJia.roJI )J;OJIH KOHTeK-
CTOB C 9JIJIHil-
THp<>B8.HHbIM
cyfu,eKTOM
B.zzyMaTbCH 67 74 8.zzyMbIB&TbCH <!£14 )J;o.zzyMaTb 7-!_27
[1(_o,eyMbIBaTb 3f 15 )JyMaTb 33f 148
ia,IzyMaThCH 44_L 149 3a,zzyMblBaTbCH 3~ 146 MbICJIHTb 34__L 150 UO,eyMaTb 25167 06.zzyMbIBaTb 13180 Ilepe,!IYMaTb 2~105
,Ll;OJIH rJiaroJI
e%
90,5 Ilo.rr,yM&Tb
28,6 fiO,lzyMblB&Tb
25,9 Ilopa.3MbICJIHTb
20,0 Ilopa.3MbilllJIHTb
22,3 29,5 Ilpo,zzyMaTb
21,2 22,7 37,3 Pa.3MblIIIJIHTb
16,25 PaccyJK.D;aTb
27,6 Coo6p/l.)KaTb
.LJ:oJIH KOHTeK- ,Ll;oJIH
CTOB C 9JIJIHII- B % THp<>B8.HHbIM
cy6'beKTOM
4q150 29,3 10146 21,7 2~55 36,4 13 33 39,4 ~43 18,6
129 150 86,0
2q112 22,3 '!£20 20,0
3q149 24,2 1q1so 10,0
3~150 25,3
Cy,n,a no Ta6JI. 2, ,n;oJUI KOHTeKCTOB c aJIJIHIITHpoBamn~IM cy6'heKTOM
)JlIB OOJihmHHCTBa rJiaroJIOB MhIIIIJiemur KOJJe6JieTCH rrpu6JIH3HTeJihHO B
pa.Aoae OT 20 ,n;o 403. 9TH lV'lcPPhI Il03BOJUIIOT c,n;eJiaTh npe~apHTeJihHbdt BhIBO,ll; 0 TOM, qTo Y'illThIB<'l.Th perym lpHbiif 3JIJIHilCHC cy6'heKTa B
KOHTeKCTax COBeprrreHHO Heo6XO,I.iHMO.
Il03HrµIH o&beKTa 6bIJia, eCTeCTBeHHO, peJieBaHTHOtt ~ nepexo,n;
HhIX rJiaroJIOB: OOiJy.M.am'b, 000y.M'bt6am'b, o60y.M.am'b, o6iJy.M.'bt6am'b, npoiJy.M.am'b, npOOy.M.'bl.6am'b. 3,n;ecb ,ll;OJUI KOHTeKCTOB, r,n;e 3Ta II03~ 6bI
Jia 3aIIOJIHeHa, 6bIJia 6JIH3Ka K 100%, H ,ll;8.)l(e B Tex CJiyqa.HX, r,n;e 3KCilJIH
IJ;HTHbrif o6'heKT OTCYTCTBOBaJI, CKOpee Bcero, HMeJI MeCTO Bee TOT 2Ke
3JIJIHIICHC, HO Terrepb y>Ke B Il03HizylH o6'heKTa: «IloKa nepeBO,D;qJIK rOBO
pHT, M02KHO o6iJyMam'b, nepe.zzyMaTb, OCMhICJIHTb, BHeCTH nonpaBKH».
qam;e Bcero Ha ceMaHTHqec~ o6'heKT B npe)VIO)f{eHHH JK83bIBaJI o6'b
eKT rpaMMaTl{qeCKH:A - npHMoe ,n;onoJIHeHHe ( B BHHHTeJihHOM na,u.e)f{e,
a npu oTp~aHHH - B po'AffTeJibHOM). Ifape~ TY )Ke poJih urpano rrpu
,n;aToqaoe npe)VIO)f{eHHe, KOTOpoe Mb! He IIpHpaBHHBaJIH B TaKRX. cnyqa
ffi( K o6'beKTy, a Bhl,n;eJIHJIH B oco6y10 no3mzyuo: «Amr y,n;o6cTBa npo(JyMaume, z(}e nocma6Uffl'b noiJco61-t'btiJ. CfflO.ltU?C C tt.anum?Ca.M.u»; «EcJIH
3TO TaK, BOT Bbl H OO{JyMaume, ?Ca?C 3ffl0 MOZ.ltO no.n,yottUffl'bC.R.1 "'tfflO .R. ottuma.n, co6cmeetttty'IO ?C'l-LUZY 00 mow, ?Ca?C ttanuca.n, ee». flo,n;po6Hee
128
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
0 npH,LJ;aTOqHOM npeAJIO:>KeHim KaK BaJieHTHOCTH rJiarOJIOB MbililJiemIB
peqb nottAeT .n;anee. IIoMHMO rnecTH BhIIIIenepeqffCJieHHblX rnaronoa,
AJUI KOTOpbIX BaJieHTHOCTb o6beKTa HOCHT o6.a3aTeJibHbdt xapa.KTep,
6hIJIO Haii.n;eHO em;e 4, )];JI.ff: KOTOpblX OHa 6bIJia 6onee H.1IH MeHee OKKa-
3HOBaJihHOtt: M'bl.c.n.umt>, coo6pa:>team-o, i}yM.amt>, nepei}yMamt>. EcJIH MH rnaronoa noJJo>KeHIDI B rrpoCTpaHCTBe CJie.n;y10m;ea no
cne cy&beKTa H o6'beKTa Ba>KHoA aaneHTBOCThIO 6blna aaneeTHOCTb aa
OOCTOHTeJihCTBO MecTa, TO B KOBTeKCTax ~mar.ex rJiaroJIOB MhUILJieHHH
peryJIHpHO IIpHCJTCTBOBaJIH o6cmosirne.ti'bCTnBa, 1flMa'b&6a10t.4ue Ha
o6paa 'UA'U cnoco6 oet'Lcmausi. Hx IIOHBJieHHe y.n;anocb npe.n;cKa-
3aTb y:>Ke no pe3yJihTaTaM pa.6oTb1 0. A. MHTJX><i>a.ttoaoa, B KOTOpoA,
B 'laCTHOCTH, HCCJie)J;OBaJIHCb cpe)J;CTBa 3KCIIJIHKa.IJ,IDl ceM pa3JIH'il!bIX
MeHTaJihH.hlX maronoa B KOHTeKcTe (MeTpo¢aHoaa 1999). TaK, Bbl)J.e
neHHM 0. A. M1ITpo¢a.HoBoii ceMa «HHTeHCHBHOCTb» B CBOeM IIOJIO:>KH
TeJibHOM BapHaBTe )J;OJI)KBa 6b1Jla Bblpa.JKaTbCH B KOHTeKCTax IIPH IIO
MOIIOf o6cTOHTeJihCTB, yKa3b1BaIOm;HX Ha OCHOBaTeJlbHOCTh HJIH Hanp»
:>KeHHOCTb h-IbICJIHTeJJbHoro npon.ecca. II0.n;o6Hh1e o6CTOHTeJlbCTBa. .n;ett
CTBHTeJihHO 6blJIH HaA.n;eHbl npH Ta.KHX rnaroJiax, KaK ai}yMambCR, aadyMambCR, aai}yM'bl.Bamt>cR, o6i}yMamt>, o6i}yM'bLBamt>, nopaa.M'bLc.aum-o, npoi}yMamt>, npoi}y.M'bl.6amt>, pasi}yM'bl.Bamt>. BOT HeCKOJibKO npHMepoa:
«Bee 3TH Bonpocbl cne.n;yeT m~ame.1wtto o6iJyMam'b, npe>K,IJ;e qeM ''3a
BO.n;HTh" B .II;OMe :>KHBOTHbIX>); «.IJ;a, fpoMOB acer.n;a ace npOOyM'b£6aA
do Me.tio"'eu, e6o 3HaJI - a aaH~H .ex He 6bIBaeT, a pecK .n;oJI:>KeH 6hITh
onpaa.n;aHH1>u.n. KaK MO:>KHO ae,n;eTb, BblllOJIHHTh 3TY ¢yHKu;mo MO
ryT JIH6o Hape~, JIHOO HMeHHhie rpyIIIlbI. IlpoTHBOllOJIO:>KEll>dt HHTeH
CHBHOCTH npH3Ha.K - ee OTCJTCTBHe - llOJIY'laeT 3KCIIJIHIJ,HTHoe Bbipa
:>KeHHe npH noMOm;H o6cTOHTeJibCTB 3eaqHTeJibHO pe:>Ke, HO HecKOJihKO
npHMepoo TaKoro HBJieHHH ace :>Ke 6hmo Haii.n;eHo: «Ho npH 3TOM .Ma.tl.O aaoyM'b&6aeMCS& o6 a.,iwecax HX BpeMeHBO:it IIpoIIHCKH»; «HeMHOW nopa3M1>U!A'U6, Mott co6ece.n;HHK, noKHHyaumtt 0.D.eccy B MeqTax o ceol'
cnm:6aTeJJbHOM 6H3Hece, pemaeTCH nOOTKpoBeHHR'laTb». He anonae,
o~aKO )Ke, IlOH.ff:THO, Ka.KHM o6pa30M KJiaCCHQ>H.I~poBaTb npHMepbI
THna «Bbl aiJyMaii.m.ec'b cno-x:oittto H ttenpedaa.11,mo>; cBiJyMaii.m.ec'b 6ea udeo.11.ozu"'ec'ICUX npe<Jy6e[)!Cdettut'L, mpeaeo H docmoaeptto•: 3,n;ecb
Ha.JIHIJ;O OTCYTCTBHe HHTeHCHBHOCTH - H BMeCTe c TeM Tm;aTeJihBOCTb.
06CTO.H:TeJihCTBaM TaKOro THIIa eoo6m;e 3aqacTyio OKa3aJIOCb 3aTpy.n;HH
TeJibBO npmmcaTb 6onee KOHKpeTHoe 3Ha'leHHe, 'leM .n;oCTaTO"JHO pac
llJibIB'laTM «KaqecTBeHHaH xapaKTepHCTHKa cy6'beKTa». HocHTeJllIMH
3TOtt Ka'leCTBemma xapaKTepHCTHKH MOrJm 6b1Tb H HapeqJIH ( «I1 BOT
caepIIIHJIOCb TO, 'ITO y BhIIIIKapea Be'IBO ea CJIYXY 6bIJIO, 0 'leM Ka:>K-
129
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
AbIA mail.HO nodyM'bl.Ba.a ,n;a Me'lTa.JI, HO c,n;eJiaTb He MOr»), H BMeHHble
rpynnbl ( c:,lQKeKH e om"'-G..R.ttuu nodyM'bWa.a yttTe 03 KBHo), H YKa3a
TeJibHble MeCToBMeHIDI ( « Ta?C Offil M'bl.C.11.Am, TaK OHH Bocnpmrn:MalOT
MHp»). Bepo.SITHee Bcero, aTa pa3HOpo,lJ;HaH rpynna Tpe6yeT )J.OilOJIHH
TeJibHoro aHaJm3a.
Em;e o,ll;Ha BaJieHTHa.SI rro3H~.SI - 06cmoAme.t1.'bcmao BpeMeHU - TaIOKe B HeKOTOpott CTeIIeHH yr~a.Jiacb no MaTepea.JiaM
0. A. MHTpO<f>aaooott. 9Te :>Ke MaTepHa.JibI II03BOJIWIH c<l>opMyJiepo
BaTb TaKoe uepe,D;Ko BCTpe'la.IOm;eeC.SI B arott rpynne 'lacTHoe 3Ha'le
HHe, K8.K ,ll;JIHTeJibHOCTb (apo,D;OJI:>KHTeJibHOCTb) )J.ettCTBIDI ( «Il TaM,
IIO,ll; poCHbIM K)'CTOM y)[{e OT~eTa10m;e:tt KaJIHHbI, .MUttym nJim'b o6-iJyM"'6a.I& BCe )J.eTaJIH IIpe)J.CTO.Sim;ero ,n;eJia»; «He JIIo6JIIO aO.!Lao paadyMWBam'b!» ). ,I(pyrHe qacTHbie 3Ha'leHIDI o6cTO.SlTeJibCTB BpeMeHH,
o6aapy)[{eHHbre B pe3)'JlbTaTe aHaJIH3a KOHTeKCTOB - MOMeHT ,n;eACTBIDI
( cBrrpo'leM, o6 aTOM OH paadyM'bWaA y)[{e Mttoao noa:J1Ce»; «Ha c.aei)y~uil ae'H.'b ..SI nepedyMa.Aa H npHIIIJia 3a6paTb <i>oTOrpacPHIO H ,D;eHb- •
nu), aop.Sl)J.OK CJie)J.OBaHIDI ( «XOTeJI rro,n;oATH, CilpOCHTb y Koro-HH6y)J;b,
HO nomo.M nepedyMaA H MaXHyJI pyKott»; B03M0)[{H0, pa3HOBH,ll;HOCTb
Ilpe)J;hl,eym;ero) H KpaTHOCTb ( «TaK BOT, g ne pa.a o6iJyM'bU:JUJI, BOilpoc 0
rrpoHCXO)[{,ll;eHHH qy,n;ec H 0 IlpH'IHHax RX MaJIOI'O 'IHCJia B HaIIlH ,ll;HH»;
c)KeHI11;1me ape B03HHKHOBemrn meBeJieHIDI '"lepB.Sl peBHOCTH'' MO)[{
BO IlOCOBeTOBaTb nO"ta~e o6dyM'bl.Bam'b H3pe'leHHe ,D;peBHeI'pe'IeCKOI'O
cl>HJ1ocO<f>a Ilecl>aropa») ( npwrncJiemie rrocJie,n;uett KaTeropnn HMeBHo
K o6CTO.SITeJibCTBaM BpeMeHH He 6eccrropHo). 06cTO.SITeJibCTBa BpeMeHH
BCTpe'IaJIHCb B KOHTeKCTax MHOI'HX rJiarOJIOB, HO Bee )Ke HH y o,n;uoro
::IT)' BaJieHTHOCTb HeJib3.Sl 6bIJIO Ha3BaTb peryJI.SlpHOA.
Co'leTaHHe HeKOTOpbrx npeiJA0::>1et-' 'bl.X zpynn c rJiaroJiaMH MbIIll
JieHH.SI TaIOKe HOCHJIO .SIBHO HecJiyqaH:Hbl:tt xapaKTep. lib HHX B rrepsy10
oqepe)J.b Ha CTaTyc BaJieBTHOCTH npeTeH)zyeT KOHCTp)'KIJ,IDI o/o6/o6o + fl. n., IlpHCYTCTBYJOID;a.SI B 3Ha'lHTeJibHOtt ,D;OJIH KOHTeKCTOB Ta.KHX
rJiaroJIOB, KaK i)y.Mam'b, aai)y.Mam'bCJt, aaayM'bt8am'bCJt, nouy.Mam'b, nopa3.M'l>l.'U.IJl..R.m'b, paa.M'bttu.!IJl.m'b, paccy:J1Caam'b: «PaaM'bl.ULJ1..1uo o eucWe.M o6paaoeattuu, o ew cy~6ax u nepcne'/C'Tnueax»; «3a nocJie,ll;HHe
,n;Ba-TpH ro,n;a aTH cep)J.HTble MOJIO,ll;ble JIIO)J.H 3aCTaBHJIH saiJyMam'bCA o ce6e CHJibHblX MHpa cero Bcepbe3». CeMaHTH'iecKH aTa npe,ll;JIO)[{
H~ rpynna qam;e Bcero Bblpa)[{aeT o&beKT )J.eACTBHH; ecJIH Ba.JieHT
HOCTb o&beKTa xapaKTepaa )J.JI.Sl nepexo,D;HblX rJiaroJIOB, TO rpynna co
+ fl. II.» - HCKJllO'lHTeJibHO )I.JI.SI HerrepeXO)J;HbIX. 0,n;uaKO, IIOCKOJibKy,
KaK 6bIJIO CKa3aHO BbIIDe, B Ka'leCTBe OCHOBHOro KPHTepIDI )J.JI.Sl Bbl
,n;eJiemrn BaJieHTHOCTett MbI HCilOJib30BaJIH CHBTaKCH'lecKHA, o6be)J.HHe-
130
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
HHe 3THX ~yx B8JleHTHOCTeA B O,D;Hy IIpe'ACTaBJllleTCH H8.M HenpaBOMep
HbIM.
Em;e o.n;aott rrpe,n;.rro:>KHoA rpynnoA, xapaKTepHott A1lll OKpYJKeHIDI
cpa3y HecKOJibKHX rJiaroJioB, 6bIJia KOHCTP)'KII,IDI • tUW + T. n.>, o.n;aa.
KO Bbl,ll;eJieHHe ee B Ka'ieCTBe BaJieHTHOCTH, B OTJilf'me OT • O + II. n.> ),
BbI3blBaeT HeKOTOpbie COMHemrn. XOTH KOHTeKCThI, B KOTOpbIX l'JlaI'OJI
MbilIIJiemrn ynpa.BJUJeT rrpe,n;.rroroM ttao c TBOPH'I'eJI.hHblM na,u.e)f(OM, 6hl
JIH H~eHhI A1lll 8 l'JiaroJIOB, HH A1lll o.n;aoro H3 HHX 'AOJIB. TaKHX KOH
TeKCTOB He 'AOCTHI"Jia 'AaJKe 203. ,lJ.aHHaJI npeAJIO:>KHaJI rpynna, KaK H
BhIIDeormcaHHM, o6bl'iHo BhlpaJKaeT 3Ha'ieBHe o6beKTa: cKy'Aa He noa:
,z:r;H, Be3'Ae ecTh ttao 'ie.M 3aOyMamt>e.iu; cIIo::iT paaOyM"'6aem HaiJ eonpocOM :HCU3tttt u CMepmu•.
HaKOHeIJ,, A1lll I"JiaroJIOB eoyMam'bCA H 60y.M.affl'bCJ(, CYIIJ;ecTBYeT CBOH
MO'AeJJb ynpa.BJieBHH c aBMOI"H'IHOA ceMa.BTm<.oA - •a/ ao + B. n. •:
«Cero'AfiH Ilhecy "Ha. .n;ae" XO'leTCH nepe'IllTaTh 3aHOBO, Herrpe'AB3HTO
B3I"JUmyB Ba. ee nepc0H8Jl(ea:, BHHMaTeJihHO 60yMa6WUC'b6 HX c.iioea H
BI"JUi)J;eBIIIHCb 6 HX nocmymcu• j cKaK TOJlbKO OH 3aI"~B8JI B Ca.MyJO
COKpOBeHlf}'IO l'JIY6HHY HBJieBHti, CBH38.IIHbIX c pa.cIIIHpeHHeM H C)f(aTH
eM, KaK TOJibKO 60yM"'6a.t&CA OH 6 c~ecmeo nO'ICOJI. u 06U:HeeHUJI., TaK
cpa3y )Ke o6Hapy)KHB8JI HeHMOBepayIO JIO)KHOCTb Bcex TeOpHA•. ,ll;oJUJ
KOHTeKCTOB c ::rron MO'AeJihIO 'AOCT8.TO'IBO BbICOKa (Ta6JI. 3) AJIH Toro,
'IT06bI npH3H8.Tb ee B Ka'ieCTBe o.n;aott H3 Ba.JieHTHOCTett A1lll I"JiaI'OJIOB
eiJyMam'bCJI. H 60yM'bLeam'bCA. HaKoHeIJ,, MHOrHe MeHTaJibHble rnaroJibr o6Hapy.>KHJIH cnoco6HOCTb
npHCoe,z:r;HHHTh K ce6e He OT'AeJihHoe CJIOBO HJIH CJIOBOCO'ieTaHHe, a IJ,eJioe
npuiJamo~twe npeiJ.tt0:>1eexue. ,ll;ml rJiaronoB eiJy.M.am'bCJI., OyMam'b, noiJyMam'b, paaM'bLtu.n.Jim'b, paccy:Heoamt>, coo6pa:>team'b no'Ao6Hru:r coqeraeMOCTh HOCHT HBHO CHCTeMHbltt xapaKTep. IlpHCoe,z:r;HHHThCH MOl'
JIH npH,D;aTO'lllbie npe'A)lO)f(emrn: oqeHb pa3HbIX THIIOB: cMO)f(HO no0y
Mamb, '{fflO 3ma oemaJ&b .Ma.it03Ha1''U.ffleA'bHa, HO 3TO 'A8JleKO He TaK> j
<Bopo6ett IDeJI H meJI, He iJyMaa. , 'lqji)a uoem> j c0H HBHO pa8M'b&WA.AA, ?ca?C npenoiJH.ecmu Jluaaeeme ttenpwi.mtt'ble eecmu•; cllo::JTOMY
rrpe.>K,D.e qeM BOCilOJib30BaThCH opy)f(HeM, noOyMaii.rne, He 6yoem AU OHO npuMettetto npomue eac ca.MUX, H TOJibKO IlOCJie 3TOl'O npHHHMattTe
OKOH'i8.TeJihHoe pemeHHe>. 3aqa.CTYIO B KaqeCTBe npH,D;aTO'iHOI'O IIpe'A
JIO)KeJilUI BhICTynMa nocaettttaA pe~b: •Pycco, 6y~ poMa.HTH'ie
CKHM CKeilTHKOM, He OyMa.11., 'ifflO ee'iH'bL'll MUp MO:Heem 6t.,m'b ycmaH06Jtett 'npu noM~U omi)eJi'bttotl AUlli'b ~ucm">i cKopoBa iJyMaem, 'tmo Otta attmUAona zxy, IIO'AllphII"HBaeT H Bcett Maccott na.u.a.er Ha KpbI
Jio Ali,zq>10XHH0A Ma3'Abl, MOTaeT ronoBott H H,D;eT 'AaJibIDe>. 9To 'AMO
131
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
HaM OCHOBaHlle no~eCTH rro,zi; STY KaTeropmo H MHOroqHCJieHHble rrpH
Mepbl c npsiMoU pe~'b70, KOTopyro T02Ke MO:>KHO paccMaTpHBaTh KaK
rrpH,D;aTOqHoe rrpe)J,JIO>KeHHe, HO c SJIJIHilTHpOBaHHhIM 00,D;'lliHHTeJibHblM
coI03oM: «Ilemyx 6e:>1eum u iJyMaem: ''He 0020'H.10, no co2pe10c'b"»; «Be.aum pM'b c.rty"«Lattocmeii. a Haw.eil pa6ome, - paaM-wt.UAsiA OH. -
Bom 6yiJ'b .11. xom'b 'l.ym'b-'l.ym'b yMHee. . ». Mb1 3aBepm:rum 0030p BaJieHTHOcTea rJiarOJIOB MblIIIJieHIDI, Bhl,D;e
JieHHhl.X B pe3JJ1bTaTe aHaJIH3a KOHTeKCTOB. Ilpo<me 38.BHCHMb!e OT I'Jia
I'OJIOB SJieMeHTbl, o6aapy2KeHHble B xo,zi;e HCCJie,D;OBaHirn, HOCHJIH filJHO
OKK8.3HOHaJll>Hbd1 xapaKTep (cM. Ta6JI. 3).
x~
n/n
1
2
3
rj
4
5
132
Ta6Jiu~a S. Pe3yJI&TaTbl llH8JlH38. pRMOK BaJJeHTHOcTeA
rJiaroJIOB MblWJieHHJI
'IHCJIO rnaroJI KOHTeK- BaneHTHOCTit:
CTOB B.n;yMaTbCJI 74 CyfueKT- 74/ 74, 3JIJIHilTHJ>OBa.H - 67
(90,53) s / BO + B.n. -27 / 77 (35,13) npH~TO'IHOO npeA1IO:lKeHHe - 22/ 77 (28,63) 06cr. o6pa3a AeitcTBIDl ( 4KaK?•) - 6/77 (7,83); 'lacT0-3H&'leHHe •HRTeHCHBHOCTb•
B.n;yMhlB&TbCH 14 Cy6'beKT - 14/ 14, 3JIJIHilTHJ>0BaH - 4 (28,63) a / so + B .n . -11/ 14 (78,63)
.LJ:o.n;yMaTh 27 Cyfu,eKT - 27 / 27, 3JIJIHilTHJ>OB&H - 7 (25,93) 06'beKT (npaMoe AOil. B B.n.)-16/ 27 (59,33) YcHJieHHe ( •ea . .\o )-3/27 (11,13) KoHe'I. npe,ll,eJI ( cao "°"~a·) - 2/ 27 (7,43) Ilp~aTo'IHoe npeA110:>1<eHHe - 2/ 27 (7,4%)
.LJ:o.n;yl.thlBaTb 15 Cy6'beKT - 15/ 15, 3JIJIHilTHJ>OB&H - 3 (20,03) O&beKT-10/15 (66,73) (1 KORTeKCT-B P. n. npH OTp~a.HHH) Ilo 1 Pa3Y (6,73): o6cT. o6pa3a AeitCTBHH (Adv), 3a + P .n., OT + P.n., KOHe'I. npeAen ( cao IWttt~a· ), H& + Il.n. (CHG xoOy~ ), IlpH-A&TO'IHOO npeAJIO)KeHHe
.LJ:.yMaTh 5969 Cy6'beKT -148/148, 3JIJIHilTHJ>OBaH - 33 (22,33) IJp~TO'IHOO npeA11o:>KeHHe - 73/ 148 (49,33) o/o6/o6o + rr.n. -34/148 (23,03)
1
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
}(•
n/ n rnaroJJ
6 3a,zJYM&TbCll
'fHCJIO KOHTeK
CTOB
5969
600
446
272
BaneHTHOCTH
06cr. o6pa3a AeACTBWI ( cKau ?) - 12/148 (8,13); 9-Y1<83aTe.IIbHble MeCTOHMeHWI (•=11:>, cma11:•), 3-Adv 06CT. BpeMeHH - 7/ 148 (4,73); 5-rrpoAOJDKHTeJibHOCTb ( CCKOJibKO?> ), 1-MOMeHT ( cKOrAa• ?) , 1 - KOHe'l. npeAeJI ( c6o.At>tue>) 06'beKT ( c"mo•) - 5/148 (3,43) lfo<l>HHHTHB - 3/ 148 (2,03) npo + B.n. -1/148 (0,73) Cyfu,eKT-149/149, 3JlJIHfiTHpoB8.H - 44 (29,53) o/ o6/o6o + II.n. - 34/ 149 (22,93) Ha,D; + T.n . -16/149 (10,73) 06cr. o6pa3a AeACTBWI - 13/149 (8, 73) (Adv, Y1<833T. Meer., HMeHHble KOHCTpyt<-1.\HH) j 5 - HHTeHCHBHOCTb 06CT. BpeMeHH-13/149 (8,73); 10-rrpoAOJDKHTeJlbHOCTb
IlpHAaTo'IHoe npeAllO)f(eHHe - 10/149 (6,73) CyfueKT - 142/ 142, 3JlJIHIITRj)OBa.H - 31 (21,83) o/o6/o6o + II.n. - 50/142 (35,23) Ha,D; + T.n. -17 / 142 (12,03) Ilpl'[AaTO'Illoe IlpeAIIO)f(eHHe 15/142 (10,63) 06CT. BpeMeHK: 10/142 (7,03) 06CT. o6pa3a AeACTBWI: 9/ 142 (6,33); 2-HHTeHCHBHOCTb, 1 - OTCyTCTBHe HHTeHCHB
HOCTH
Cyfu,eKT-150/ 150, 3JlJIHIITHpoBaH - 34 (22,73), C OTp~eM-14 06CT. o6pa3a AeACTBWI -66/150 (44,03) O&beKT-28 (18,73); H3 HBX 12-B P.n. c OTp~eM
T.n. - 15/150' (10,03); 14- c?Came;wpwtMtl •, c o6paaaMu •, c CA06aMU >, • r;/JopMyJ1aMt1 •, ccnoco60M• H T. n. o/o6/ o6o + II.n. -6/150 (4,03) )l:.n. ( •ce6e•) - 5/150 (3,33) (acerAa. B co'leTB.HllH c OO'beKTOM B P.n. npa OTpHIJ,8HHH)
B + II.n . - 5/150 (3,33) KaK + ~ecTBHTe.IIbHOO - 3/ 150 (2,03) 06CT. BpeMeHH - 3/150 (2,03)
133
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
N• 'IHCJIO n/n rJiaro.n KOHTeK- Ba.n:eHTHOCTH
CTOB 9 06,zi;yMaTb 69 CyfueKT- 67 /67, MJIHllTHpOBaH - 25 (37,33)
i 06'beKT-62/67 (92,53)
- 06CT. o6pa33 AeACTBH.fl -18/67 (26,93); 17 -I co 3Ha'l:eHHeM •HHTeHCHBHOCTb>
06cr. BpeMeHH -8/67 (11,93) 10 06,DyMhIBaTb 81 CyfueKT-80/80, 3JIJIHIITHpoB8.H - 13
(16,253)
11 06'beKT-79/80 (98,753) 11 06CT. BpeMeHH-6/80 (7,53); 3-npoAOJDKH-
TeJibHOCTb, 2- KpaTHOCTb ( 4CKOJibKO p837> ), 1 - Koae'I:. n~en 06CT. o6pa33 AeACTBH.fl -4/80 (5,03); 3-co 3Ha'leHBeM 4HHTeHCHBHOCTb•
11 11epe,zzyMaTb 109 Cyfu,eKT-105/105, 3.IU"IHilTHpoB8.H - 29 (27,63) 06C'r. BpeMeHH-19/105 (18,13); 14 - nop.H-AOK CJI~OBaHJUI Jfo<f>HHHTHB-14/105 (13,3%) 06'J.eKT- 4/105 (3,83), 3JIJIHl1THpoBa.H -1 06CT. o6pa33 AeikTBH.H -4/105 (3,8%); 3-
1·- 3Ha<1:eaae •HeroKH,ll;a.HHOCTb• 06cr. npH'IHHhl - 3/105 (2,93) 06cr. MecTa - 2/105 (1,93)
12 110,DyMaT& 3586 CyfueKT-150/150, 3JIJIHIITHpoBa.H - 44 (29,33) 11p~TO'IHOO npeAJIOlKeHHe, np.HMa.H HJIH KOC-BeHHa.H pe'l:b -102/150 (68,0%) {1 CJiy'laA -
MJIHilTHpOBaHO) 06CT. o6pa33 AeACTBH.fl -10/150 (6,73) o/o6/o6o + 11.n. -8/150 (5,33) 06cr. BpeMeHH - 5/150 (3,33); 3-MOMeHT BpeMeHB, 2 - Ilpo,D;OJDKHTeJibHOCTb 417WJl'b!OO> -4/150 {2,73) ,11,eenp. o6op0'1' - 3/150 (2,03)
13 IlO,eyMblBaTb 46 Cy{YbeKT-46/46, 3JIJIHilTHp<>BaH-10 (21,73) o/o6/o6o + 11.n. -30/46 (65,23) lfo<l>HHHTHB-8/150 (5,33) IlpH,D;aTO'l:Hoe npeAJIOlKeaHe - 6/150 ( 4,03) 06CT. o6paaa AeACTBH.fl - 4/150 (2,73) Ha,ll, + T.n. -1/150 (0,7%) .
134
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
N• n/ n
14 I!Opa3MblCJIHTb
15 I!Opa3MbIIIIJUITb
16 IlpH38,IJJl'Ma.t'bCH
18 Ilpo~&Tb
lfHCJIO KOHTeK
CTOB
55
34
43
219
20
Ba.JieHTHOCTH
Cyfu,exT - 55/ 55, S.IIJIHllTHpoB&H -20 (36,4%) 06CT. 00j)83a ~eikTBWI - 8/ 55 (14,53); 6 -0TCyTCTBHe HHTeHCHBHOCTH1 1 - HHTeHCHB
HOCTb H~ + T.n. -8/ 55 (14,5%) 06CT. BpeMeHH-4/55 (7,3%) IIp~aro'IHoe npeAJIO>KeHHe-1/55 (1,83) Cy&beKT - 33/ 33, MJIHIITHpoBaH-13 (39,4%) o/ o6/ o6o + II.n. - 12/ 33 (36,4%) H~ + T.n. - 6/ 33 {18,2%) Ha + B .n. ( c?«l me.MY• ) - 2/33 (6,1%) Ilp~TO'IHoe npeAJIO>KeHHe -1/33 (3,03) lfo<PmmTRB - 1/ 33 (3,0%) 06CT. BpeMeHH - 1/ 33 _0,0%) Cyfu,eKT - 43 I 43, 3JIJIHilTHpoBaH - 8 (18,6%) H~ + T.n. - 3/ 43 (7,03) 06CT. BpeMeHH - 2/ 43 (4,7%) o/ o6/ o6o + II.n. - 1/ 43 (2,33) 06CT. o6pa3a ~eACTBH.11-1/43 (2,33) 06CT. MecTa (Ha + II.n.)-1/43 (2,33) IlpH,D.&TO'IHoe npeAJio>KeHHe -1/43 (2,33) Cyfu,eKT - 150/ 150; 3JIJIHIITHpOB8.H - 129 (86,0%), s nacCHse - 91 O&beKT - 142/ 150 (94,7%), s coqeTaHHH c cyfu,eKTOM B naccime - 91 06CT. o6pa3a ~eACTBWI - 58/150 (38,73); '18CTO - 3Ha'leHHe CHHTE!HCHBHOCTb• 06CT. speMeHH-17/ 150 (11,3%); caapattee•, caazoaA•, CU8tta"'a.llbttO• - 9, C6Ce-2aa. (rom.xo s coqeTaHHH c nacCHsoM)-3 Ilp~TO'l!loe OpeAJIO){(eHHe - 8/150 (5,33) 06CT. MecTa (s + II.n.) - 1/ 150j_0,1%) Cyfu,eKT - 20/ 20, 31UIHilTHpoB&H - 4/20 (20,0%) 06'beKT - 20/ 20 {1003) 06CT. OOpa3& ~eACTBH.11 - 5/ 20 (25,0%); 3H8..
qeRHe - CHHTeHCHBHOCTb• 06CT. speMeHH ( c sapaxee •) - 4/20 {20,03)
135
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
~ ~HCJIO
n/ n fJia.rOJI KOHTeK-CTOB
19 Pa3,IzyMb!BaTb 114
20 Pa3Mb!IDJU!Tb 444
·I
21 Paccy:>K,11,aTb 421
22 Coo6pa>KaTb 267
136
IIpoao.A:>1CeH-ue ma6.ll. S
Ba.n:eHTHOCTH
Cy6'beKT -112/ 112, 3JIJIHnTHpoBaH - 25 (22,33) 06cT. BpeMeHH - 13/ 112 (11,63); 3Ha'leHHe «Ilpo,!J;OJDKJITeJibHOCTb> - 11 o/ o6/ o6o + II.a. - 12/ 112 (10,73) Ha,D, + T .n. -9/112 (8,03) VIHcpHHHTHB-5/ 112 (4,53) 06CT. 00pa3a ,n;eikTBHH - 5/ 112 (4,43); 3Ha.
'leHHe «HHTeHCHBHOCTb> - 2 «H-etCozaa• 2/112 (1,83) Cy6'beKT - 150/ 150, 3JIJIHnTHpoBaH 15 (10,03) o/ o6/ o6o + II.n. - 53/ 150 (35,33) IlpH,D;aTO'IHoe npe,n;.no:>KeHHe, npHMa.!I HJIH KOC
BeHHaH pe'lb - 25/ 150 (16, 73) 06CT. o6pa3a ,11,eitCTBHH 21/ 150 (14,0%); cac.nyx> - 7, «npo ce6.10 -1 Ha,L\ + T.n. -15/150 (10,03) 06CT. BpeMeHH - 14/150 (9,3%) «M'H-OZO• -4/150 (2,73) Cy6'beKT - 148/ 148, ::imcit:nTHpoBaH - 35 (23,63) OOcT. o6p83a ,11,eitCTBHH 54/ 148 (36,53) o/ o6/ o6o + II.n. - 50/ 148 (33,83); TaK:>Ke 1 KOHTeKCT c «H-a me.My O>
IlpH,D;aTO'IHOO npe,n;.no>KeHHe, npHMIUI HJIH KOCBeHHaH pe'lh-24/ 148 (16,23) «ca.Mc co60-il.(-10)• -4/148 (2,73) «H-a me.t.ty(-t4• - 4/ 148 (2,7%) npo + B.n. - 3/ 148 (2,0%) 06CT. BpeMeHH 2/ 148 (1,43) «6 . . iJyxe• 2/148 (1,43) Ka!< + C~eCTBHTe.IIbHOO - 2/ 148 (1,43) Cy6'beKT 150/150, 3 JL11HITTHpoBaH - 38 (25,33) 06CT. o6p83a ,11,eitCTBHH - 52/ 150 (34,73) IlpH,11,aTO'IHOO npe,n;.no:>KeHHe, npHMIUI HJIH KOCBeHHIUI pe'Ih - 48/ 150 (32,03) 06'beKT -28/150 (18,73); C'H,U"ezo>-20, ""mo-mo• 4, ""mo-J1u60• - 2, c'JCOe"mo> - 1, ""ezo> - 1 06CT. BpeMeHH 8/150 (5,3%) 06CT. IlpH'IHHb!-6/150 (4,03); 4- COT + P.n.>, 2- cc + P.n.»
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
3aKJIIO'leHHe
AH8JIH3 paMoK BaJieHTHOCTet-1 JICr rnaI'OJIOB nono)KeHlUJ B npo
CTpaHCTBe Il03BOJI51eT Bbl,ll;eJIHTb cne.zzyro~e HeoKK83HOHaJibHble Ba
JieHTHble no3H1~1rn: cy&i,eKT, o6'beKT, o6cTOHTeJibCTBO MeCTa. IIocne)J.
aee HMeeT CM:bICJI paccMaTpHBaTb B Tpex BapHaaTax cr.n;e>, «Ky.n;a> H
«OTKy.n;a>. 9TH Il03HIJ;IIll Bbl,ll;emIIOTCH AJlll a;enoro pH,n;a I'JiaI'OJIOB. ,11,mJ. I'Jial'OJia Jte"'b «pacnOJio:lKHTbC51 cnaTb> TaK)Ke OKa3blBaeTCH BruKHOtt
BaJieHTHOCTb a;eJIH, a .n;JI5I rnaroJia npucymcm8oeamt> - ceaxo.n;BThCH,
6JXTb r.n;e-n. B .n;aHHoe BpeMH> - co6IXTIDI, npH KOTOpoM npoHcxo.n;uT
.n;eACTBHe.
Aa8JIH3 KOHTeKCTOB JICr rJiaroJioB MbIIUJleHHH no3BOJI51eT Bbl,Zl;e
JIHTb CJie.n;yIO~e HeoKK83HOHaJibHhie Ba.JieHTHble II03~: cy6'beKT;
,ll,Jl.H nepexo,ll,HblX I'Jlal'OJIOB - o6'heKT; IIpeAJIO>KH8JI rpynna «o / o6 / o6o +II. n.>, B03MO)KHO: npe.n;no>KH8JI rpynna «H~ + T.n.>; o6cToJlTeJib
CTBO o6p83a .n;eACTBHj[; o6cTo51TeJibCTBO BpeMeHH; IIpH.n;aTO"IHoe npe.n;JIO)KeHHe, npHMM HJIH KOcBeHHrui: pe'lb. BMeCTe c TeM Harne HCCJie.n;oBa
HHe HeJib3H C"!HTaTb 3aBepmeHHbLM: cTpyKTyphl paMoK BaJieHTHOCTeA
Tpe6yIOT no.n;po6aoro aHaJIH3a B ceMaHTH'leCKOM H Mop<l>oJiorH'lecKOM
IIJiaae.
JluTepa-rypa
Asapoaa H. B. CxeMbl ynpaB.11eHW1 s rpaMMa.THKe H pa.MKli BaJieHTHocreA s RussNet. CII6., 2005.
Anpec.1m IO. ,ll.. Jfa6paHHhle Tpy,ll;hl: B 2 T. T . 1: JleKCH<1ecKru1 ceM~. Cu-HOHHMWiecKHe Cpe,!l.CTBa .H3bIK8.. M., 1974.
BozyCJ1aBc1ct11l H. M. HccneAOBa.mm no CHHT8KCJl'lecKOA ceMaHTHKe. M., 1985. BoeyCJUlac1CUil H. M. C<Pepa AelkTsrur JieKCK'lecKHX e~. M., 1996. Kaceau'I. B. B. CeM8.HTHKa. Cm1Ta.KCHC. Mop¢o.norw1. M., 1988. Me.t1tNtJ1C H. A. Kypc o6m;eA Mop¢o.nonra: B 3 T. T. 2. M., 1997. Mumpo<fiattoaa 0. A. CTPYK'fYPHhlA a.H8.JIH3 cH!'HH<f>HKaTHBHoro 3Ha'leHml (Ha
MaTepHaJie l'JlaI"OJIOB npo~ecca MbIIILlleHHJI 8.Hl'JIID!:CKOI'O H pycCKoro .H3blKOB): ~c. K8Jl,ll;. <f>HJion. HayK. CII6., 1999. Cnosa.pb pyccKoro .H3blK8.. T. I-IV M., 1957-1961. Tettt>ep JI. OcHOBhl CTpyKzypHoro CHHTa.Kcuca / BCTyn. CTaTb11 H o6m;. ~
B. r I'll.Ka. M., 1988. Tecme.t1e~ H. r BBe,11,eHHe B o6m;uA CHHT8.KCHC. M., 2001. 4>u.t1unnoa A. K. Kop~ Me:>K,lly paMKaMH saneHTHocreA u napa.Ml!Tp8.MH
AffCTpH6yqHA s ceMa.HTH'l'.ecKOM Aepese rJiaronos nono.>KeHwr s IIpOCTpa.HCTse. M., 2008 (AHTIJIOMHa.R pa.60'ra.: xpaHHTCll Ha ~ MaTeMaTH'olecKOA JIJIHI'BHCTHKH.
CIT6rY). Helbi[J G. Geschichte der neueren Spra.chwissenschaft. Leipzig, 1986.
137
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
Ceep;eHH.H 06 aBTOpax
rep,a; AneKCB.H,Zq> CepreeBH'I - ,ll;OKTOP cpHJIOJIOrH'lecKHX HayK, npo¢eccop, 38.Be,!J;YIO~ Kact>e,!J;pOit MaTeMaTH'lecKOit JIHHrBHCTHKH cpHJIOJIOI'H'leCKOro ¢ai<yJibTeTa CfI6rY E-mail: aheard@yandex.ru
rpHH6ayM Oner HaTaHOBH'I - ,ll;OKTOP cpaJIOJIOI'H'lecKHX HaJK, npo¢eccop Ka¢e,!J;phl MaTeMaTH'lecKOit JIHHrBHCTHKH cpHJIOJIOrH'lecKoro <l>aKYJibTeTa CIT6rY. E-mail: oleg@og3580.spb.edu
,lJ;MHTpHee AneKCaH)JJ> Bna,z:i;ucJiaBOBH'I acm1pa.HT, CTapmuif npeno,a;asaTeJib Ka¢e,!J;pbl MaTeMaTH"'IecKO.fi: JIHHrBHCTHKH <l>HJIOJIOrH"'IeCKOro <PaKYJlbTeTa Cil6rY E-mail: avd84@rambler.ru
.D;o6poe AJieKceU: BJiaAffMHpOBH'I acnHpa.HT Kacpe;:q>bI MaTeMaTH'lecKoA JIHHrBHCTHKH <l>HJIOJioraqecKoro ¢aKyJI&TeTa CIT6rY. E-mail: adobrov2001@mail.ru
3axapoe BHKTop IlaeJIOBH"'-1 - KaJf,ll;H,a;aT cpHJIOJIOrH'lecKHx HayK, ,11;0-
n;eHT Kact>e;:q>hl MaTeMaTH'lecKOH JIHHrBHCTHKH cPHJIOJIOrH'leCKOro ¢ai<yJlbTeTa CIT6rY E-mail: vz1311@yandex.ru
3y6Koea ThTb.HHa HBaHoeHa Ka.H,L\H,!l;aT <l>HJIOJIOrH'leCKHX HayK, ,11;0-
n;eHT K~hl MaTeMaTH'lecKOA JIHHl'BHCTHKH <l>HJIOJIOrH'lecKoro cpaKyJlbTeTa CIT6rY E-mail: Zoobkova@mail.ru
MapThIHeHKO rpuropHH .HKOBJieBH'I ,!J;OKTOp cpHJJOJIOrH'leCKHX HayK, npo¢eccop K~bl MaTeMaTH'lecKOH mmrBHCTHKH <l>HJIOJIOnl'lecKoro <PaKYJibTeTa Cil6rY E-mail: g.martynenko@gmail.com
MHTp<><i>auoea On&ra AneKCaH)JJ>OBHa Ka.H,a;H,a;aT <l>HJIOJIOrH'lecKHX aayK, ,a;ou;eHT Ka¢e,!J;phl MaTeMaTH'l€CKO:A JIHHrBHCTHKH <l>HJIOJIOrH'lecKoro cpai<yJI&TeTa CIT6rY E-mail: alkonost-om@yandex.ru
HeMn;eea (IInaxoT.H) Ba.n:eHTHHa Bs'leCJiaBOBHa ~HHHCTPaTOp
6H3Hec-n;eHTpa 000 «AJihHHC CIT6>. E-mail: toogezza@mail.ru
HKKOJiaee Hn&.s Cepreeeuq KaH,ZJ,H,a;aT cpHJIOJIOra'lecKHX HayK, ,11;0-
u;eHT Kacpe;:q>bl MaTeMaTH'lecKOH JIHHrBHCTHKH cpHJIOJIOrH'leCKOC'O cpaKyJibTeTa CIT6rY E-mail: ilya.nikolaev@gmail.com
270
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
Por03HHa EneHa AHAJ>8eBHa cTapmHH: npenO,ZJ;a.BaTeJib KacPe,ZJ;phI MaTeMaTH'iecKoit JIHHrBHCTHKH cPHJIOJIOI'H'lecKoro cPaKYJibTeTa CII6fY E-mail: helena.rogozina@gmail.com
Py6uHep BHKTOpHH HropeBHa acnHpa.HTKa, acc:acreHT .Ka<i>eAPhl MaTeMaTH'IecKott JIHHI'BHCTHKH cPHJIOJIOrH'iecKoro cPaKYJibTeTa Cil6fY E-mail: viki m2000@mail.ru
CKpe6~oBa TaTb.HHa reoprHeBHa ~aT cPHJIOJIOrH'IecKHX HayK, AO~eHT Kact>eAPhl MaTeMaTl'r'iecKOH JIHHI'BHCTHKH cPHJIOJIOrH'iecKoro cPaKYJilr TeTa CII6fY. E-mail: tanyaskr@TS7676.spb.edu
Cooa (AKceuoBa) JII06oB& 3HHOB&eoua - ,ZJ;OKTOp cPHJIOJIOrH'l:ecKHX HayK, ,ZJ;OKTOP cPHJIOCocPHH (fepMaHH.a). E-mail: ak1937@web.de
¢1HJIHnnoB AH,!q>eA KoHCTaHTHHOBH'I - acIIHJ>a.HT Ka4>eAPhl MaTeMaTH'lecKoli JillHI'BHCTHKH cPHJIOJIOrH'iecKoro cPaKYJibTeTa CII6fY. E-mail: andrefili@mail.ru
Xoxnooa MapH.H BJia.D;HMHpooHa - acnHpa.ttTKa J<a4>eAPhl MaTeMaTH'iecKo:ii mrnrB!ICTHKH cPHJIOJIOrH'iecKoro cPaKYJibTeTa CII6fY. E-mail: vertikal-maria@yandex.ru
qe6affoB CepreH: BHKTOpoBH"I - ,n;oKrop cPHJIOJIOI'H'lecKHX HayK, npo¢eccop Ka¢eAPhl MaTeMaTH'lecKOR JIHHI'BHCTHKH cPHJIOJIOrH'iecKoro <i>a.KYJibTeTa CII6fY, npo¢eccop Ka¢eAPhl TeOpeTH'IecKoii :a npHKJI~oA JIHHrBHCTHKH BaJITHHCKoro roe. TexH. yH-Ta «Boemfex HM. ,IJ.. <t>. YCTHHooa~. E-mail: S.Chebanov@gmail.com
~eopcKlUI MapH.H BJIRAHMHpoeHa - acnHpa.HTKa KacPeAPhl MaTeMaTH'IecKo:ii JIBHrBHCTHKH cPHJIOJIOrH'iecKoro <}>a.KyJibTeTa CII6fY E-mail: Yav.mas@gmail.com
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
Information about Authors
Gerd Alexandre S. Doctor of Sciences in Linguistics, Professor. Director of the Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University.E-mail:aheard@yandex.ru
Grinbaum Oleg N. - Doctor of Sciences in Linguistics, Professor. Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University.E-mail:oleg@og3580.spb.edu
Dmitriev Alexandre V. -Assistant Professor, Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University. E-mail: avd84@rambler.ru
Dobrov Alexey V. - PhD student, Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University. E-mail: adobrov2001@mail.ru
Zakharov Victor P. Candidate of Sciences in Linguistics, associate pr<>fessor. Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University. E-mail: vz13ll@yandex.ru
Zoobkoba Tatiana I. - Candidate of Sciences in Linguistics, as&>eiate pr<>fessor. Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University. E-mail: Zoobkova@mail.ru
Martynenko Grigorij Ya. Doctor of Sciences in Linguistics, Professor. Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University.E-mail:g.martynenko@gmail.com
Mitrofanova Olga A. - Candidate of Sciences in Linguistics, associate pf(}fusror. Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University. E-mail: alkonost-om@yandex.ru
Nemceva (Plakhotya) Valentina V. Administrator of the cAlliance• Co Ltd.E-mail:toogezza@mail.ru
Nikolaev Ilya S. - Candidate of Sciences in Linguistics, associate professor. Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University. E-mail: ilya.nikolaev@gmail.com
272
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
Rogozina Elena A. - Assistant Professor, Department of Mathematical Linguis~ics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University. E-mail: helena.rogozina@gmail.com
Rubiner Victoria I. PhD student, assistant, Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University. E-mail : viki m2000@mail.ru
Skrebtsova Tatiana G. Candidate of Sciences in Linguistics, associate professor. Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University. E-mail: tanyaskr@TS7676.spb.edu
Sova {Aksenova) Lubov Z. Doctor of Sciences in Linguistics, Professor. PhD (Germany) E-mail: ak1937@web.de
Filippov Andrey K. - PhD student, Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University. E-mail: andrefili@mail.ru
Khokhlova Maria V. - PhD student, Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University E-mail: vertikal-maria@yandex.ru
Chebanov Sergey V. - Doctor of Sciences in Linguistics, Professor. Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University. E-mail: S.Chebanov@gmail.com ·
Yavorskaya Maria V. - PhD student, Department of Mathematical Linguistics, Phylological Faculty, St. Petersburg State University. E-mail: Yav.mas@gmail.com
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
CO.l(EP)KAHHE
Mapm'bi'He'H?W r. JI. MareMaTHKa rapMOHHH B ryMa.HHTapHbIX Ha)'Kax H HC-KYCCTBe ... .. . .. . . .. . . . . . . . . .. . . ... .. .. .. .. • .. .. .. .. . .. .. .. .. .. . 3
I'p1.m6ayM 0 . H. CTPYKTYPHO-p;HHaMH'l'.ecKHe B3aHMOCBH3H pHTMa H CMbICJia B nHCbMe TaTbHHbI JlapHHol!: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
Citpe6v,oea T I' rpaMMaTm<a KOHCTp~l!: K8.K JIHHrBHCTH'iecKa.s! Teo-
~ · M Coea JI. 3. 9eomo~ rpaMMaTH'iecKoro CTJXlH B H3bII<ax pa3.TlH'lHblX TmIOB 46 HeMv,eea (Il.11axom.11.) B. B., Lfe6a'H06 C. B. lIHHTBOCTaTHCTH'IOCKHe rrocJiep;-
CTBIDI op<Porpa.¢H'lecKol!: pecPopMbI 1918 r. . • . . . . . . . . 60 Mapm'bittett?Co I' H., T.:/e6attoe C. B. CeMHOTHKa <l>yr6oJibHol!: CTaTHCTHKH. 91 3y6?Wea T. H . <l>opMHpoB&me H3bIKOBol!: cnoco6HocTH: KOrHHTHBHa.s! TO'iKa
3peHIDI • . . . • . . • • . . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . • . 103 I'epa A. C. HecKOJibKO CJIOB o corzyioJIHHrBHCTm<e Ka.I< HarrpaeJieHHH npH-
KJia,IJ;Horo H3bIK03Ha.HIDI 113 <I>wn.mnoe A. K. CTpyKrypa paMOK ea.neHTHOCTel!: JICr rJiarOJIOB noJio:>Ke-
HIDI B npoc:rpa.HCTBe H JICr rJiaroJIOB MblllIJieHIDI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117 Heopc1WJ1. M. B. IloJIHMO.a;aJibHOCTb B acneKTe nep~enTHBHblX np1rnaraTen1>-
HblX H cornnepoHHMIDI npH ee npep;C'raBJ!eHHH B RussNet 138 Mumpoefja'HOea 0. A., I'pa'l.mea M . A., lIIUMopv.'H.<l A. C. ABTOMaTH'le
CKaH KJiaccH<l>m<arzylH JieKCHKH B napaJIJieJibHbIX TeKCTax (Ha MarepuaJie pyCCKOH3bI'lHb!X TeKCTOB A . c. rpuHa H me nepeso..o;os Ha CJIOB~ H3bIK) 161
3axapoe B. IT. J1orHKo-ceMaHTH'lecKoe Mop;enHpoBa.HHe JieKCHKH 3a1Ipocos s .z:IOKYM€HTaJibHblX HTIC 17 4
Py6uttep B. H. :>i<a.HpOBbie KJiaccu<l>uKalzy!H HHTepHer-cTpaHH~. 188 XoXAOea M. B . 11cCJiep;o:srume coqeraeMOCTH u ycTOl!:'iuBOCTH JieKcuqecKHX
e..o;u~ aBTOMaTH'lecKHMH MeTO)l;aMH. 206 Ao6poe A. B. Te:x:a:oJionm HHTeJIJieKT)'aJibHoro no11cKa H cnoco6bl o~eHKH
HX 3<l><PeKTHBHOCTH 219 Hu1C0.11aee H. C. 11cCJiep;osaTe.11bCKaH 6a3a .z:la.HHbIX no MoP<l>oJionm H:>KOp-
CKHX 3IIH'lecKHX neceH: TepMHHOJJOrm1, MOp;eJIH H peaJIH3arzyiH 233 Po2osu.tta E. A. Kopnyc arnorpa.¢H'lecKHX TeKCTOB CKAT: CIO)l(!ITH8Ji cxeMa
)f(HTHI!:, XML-pa3MeTKa u coop;aHue omaBJieHHI!: . 243 AMumpu.ee A. B. TonOHHMH'lecKHe ucCJiep;oBBJIHH H 3JieKTpoHHble KOJUieK-~ TOIIOHHMOB illBe~H . 250
I'epa A. C. Jles JlbBOBH'I ByJiaHHH, KaKHM s ero 3HaJI H noMmo (113 MaTep11a.noe no HCTOpHH Ka.¢e..o;pbI M8.TeMaTHqecKotl: JIHHrBHCTHKH Ca.HKT-Ilerep6yprc1<oro rocy.a;apCTBeHHoro YffHBepcHTeTa.) 262
Cse.a;eHIDI o6 aeropax 270 Information a.bout Authors 272
274
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
CONTENTS
Martynenko G. Ya. Mathematics of Harmony in Arts and Humanities Grinbaum 0. N. Structural and Dynamic Interrelations between Rhythm
and Sense in the Letter of Tatiana Larina Skrebtsova T G. Construction Grammar as a Linguistic Theory Sova L. Z. Grammatical Structure Evolution in the Languages of Different
Types Nemtseva V V {Plakhotya), Chebanov S. V Linguostatistical Consequences
of Spelling Reform of 1918. . Martynenko G. Ya., Chebanov S. V Semiotics of Football Statistics Zoobkova T I. Language Acquisition: A Cognitive Approach Gerd A. S. A Few Words about Sociolinguistics as a Branch of Applied
Linguistics Filippov A. K. Valency Frames Structure of the Verbs of Spatial Location
and the Verbs of Mental Activity Yavorskaya M. V Polymodality from the Aspect of Perceptive Adjectives
and Cohyperonymy in the Russian Database RussNet .. Mitrofanova 0. A., Grochkova M. A., Shimorina A . S. Automatic Word
Classification in Parallel Texts (Case Study of Russian Original Texts and Their Slovak Translations)
Zakharov V P Logical and Semantic Modeling of Query Vocabulary in Documentary Search Engines
Rubiner V I. Genre Classifications of Web Pages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .... Khokhlova M. V Studying Compatibility and Stability of Lexical Units by
Means of Automatic Methods . . . . . . . . . ... . Dobrov A . V Technonogies of Intellectual Information Retrieval and Tech
niques Evaluating Their Effectivenes . . . . . . . . . Nilolaev I. S. Izhorian Epic Songs Morphology Research Database: Termi
nology, Models and Implementation Rogozina E. A. cSKAT• Hagiographic Texts Corpus - Content Structure of
the Texts and Its xml-Encoding for Tables of Contents Dmitriev A. V Researches on Toponymy and Electronic Collections of Place-
Names in Sweden).... . . . . . . . . . . . . ....... . Gerd A. S. L. L. Bulanin as I Knew and Remember Him Information about Authors. . . . . . . . . . .
3
23 34
46
60 91
103
113
117
138
161
174 188
206
219
233
243
250 262 272
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA
Hay'iHOe H3,D;aHHe
CTPYKTYPHASI H IIPHKJIA,ZJ;HA.SI JIHHTBHCTHKA
Me:>tCayaoac1"Uil c6opxuit
BbIIIyCK 8
Pe'Aa.KTOp /I. A . Kapnoea 06no:>KKa xy'AO)KHHJ<a E. A. Cwioet>eecri.i
BepcrKa H. M. BMoeoil
fIO'AJ!HCaHO B ne'13Tb 19.04.2010. cI>opMaT 60x84 1 /i6 ·
BYMara o<PceTHa.sr. fle'laTb ocPceTHa.H. .JL'l'J YCJI. ne'1. JI. 16,04. TepaJK 200 3K3. 3a.Ka3 N• 1 r:Jf{.'
113,n;a-re..TuCTBO CIT6rY. 199004, C.-Ilerep6ypr, B. 0., 6-H .1IHHH.ff, 11/ 21
Ten. (812) 328-96-17; cpaKc (812) 328-44-22 E-mail: editor@unipress.ru
www.unipress.ru
Ilo eonpocaM pea.JIHJa.1.µm o6pam;aTbCH no a.zwecy: C.-ITerep6ypr, B . 0., 6-H JIHHWI, 'A· 11/21, K. 21
TenecpoHbl: 328-77-63, 325-31-76 E-mail: i7.dat-spbgu@ma.il.ru
THIIorpa<PeH 113,n;a.TenbCTaa CIT6rY 199061, C.-Ile-rep6ypr, CpeAJIID% np., 41
LA FILOLÓGICA POR LA CAUSA