Who should regulate the regulators ?

10

Transcript of Who should regulate the regulators ?

��������������� ����������������������������� ��������������� ������������� ��������������������

!"�#!"$%&�'()$%*+(�+!(�'()$%*+"'#,�-./01�21341�-56789

��������������� � ������ ����������

�� ������������������� !

"#$%&"'%()*�*+,-.�)/0,)12*�+32�4/*521*�67�+32�0,2*+)6/*�67�8534+�*36,9-�:2�+32�;4)/�<,1<6*2*�67�12=,94+61*>?�61�8536�*36,9-�12=,94+2�+32�12=,94+61*>?�61�:2++21�54.�67�<6*)/=�+32�0,2*+)6/�)*�8536�*36,9-�*,<21@)*2�+32�12=,94+61*>?ABCDEFGHIJ�K2=,94+2L�12=,94+61*L�*,<21@)*61L�-,2�-)9)=2/M2L�M61<614+2�=6@21/4/M2A

��������������� � ������ ����������

���������������������� �!

#$%�&'()�*%�+($,�%'�)$-�%#$%�$�./'.')*%*',�'0�1$2�*)�%/3(4�5'/�.')*%*67*)%)8�$�./'.')*%*',�'0�1$2�*)�%/3(�*0�*%�$99'/&)�2*%#�9(/%$*,�*,)%*%3%*',$1�0$9%)7�/31()�'0�/(9':,*%*',�$)�2$)�%#(�9$)(�2*%#�;<;$/%�'/�:/$,&�,'/+�2$)�2*%#�;<=(1)(,<�>'+(�,$%3/$1�1$2-(/)�$/:3(�%#$%�$�./'.')*%*',�'0�1$2�*)�%/3(�*0�*%�$99'/&)�2*%#�9(/%$*,�*,)%*%3%*',$1�9$)()<�?(�'%#(/�,$%3/$1�1$2-(/)�$/:3(�%#$%�$�./'.')*%*',�'0�1$2�*)�%/3(�*0�*%�*)�9',)*)%(,%�2*%#�./*,9*.1()�'0�3,*6(/)$1�@3)%*9(�%#$%�.3%�%#(�1$2�*,�*%)�A()%�1*:#%<�>%*11�%#(�'%#(/)�.'*,%�'3%�%#$%�%/3%#�,$+()�$�9',76(/:(,9(�*,�*,%(/./(%*6(�$))3+.%*',)�$A'3%�1$2<BCD�"#(/($)�%#(�/($1*)%)�1''E)�*,%'�#'2�%#(�*,)%*%3%*',)�2'/E�*,�/($1*%-<BFDG(:31$%'/)�/(:31$%(�1$2�$99'/&*,:�%'�%#(�%#('/(%*9$1�$))3+.%*',)�%$E(,�A-�%#(�H$%*',$1�I))(+A1-<�G(:31$%'/)�$/(�'A1*:(&�%'�%$E(�*,%'�$99'3,%�,$%*',$1�1$2)�*,�0'/9(�$)�2(11�$)�9',6(,%*',)�$,&�*,%(/,$%*',$1�)%$,&$/&)�$&'.%(&�A-�)3./$�,$%*',$1�A'&*()<�G(:31$%'/)�)#'31&�.$-�$%%(,%*',�*,%'�%#(�./*,9*.1()�'0�*,,(/�+'/$1*%-�/(:$/&7*,:�%#(�.(,&*,:�&/$0%�1(:*)1$%*',<�?()(�./*,9*.1()�$/(�$)�0'11'2)JBKDG31()�+3)%�A(�:(,(/$1�$,&�91($/�$,&�$1)'�A(�3,&(/)%$,&$A1(�A-�%#(�.3A1*98G31()�+3)%�,'%�A(�$..1*(&�%'�%#(�.$)%�9$)()7./'#*A*%*',�'0�LM�NOPQ�RSTQO�USVP8WX�G31()�+3)%�,'%�A(�%(+.'/$/-�*,�%*+(8YX�G31()�+3)%�,'%�A(�*,�9',%/$&*9%*',�2*%#�'%#(/�/31(8ZX�G31()�+3)%�,'%�&(+$,&�%'�([(93%(�%#(�*+.'))*A1(�%#*,:)�\./*,9*.1(�'0�31%/$�.'))(]<�I)�$�+$%%(/�'0�0$9%8�%#(-�$/(�%#(�9/39*$1�.'*,%)�0'/�)$%*)0-*,:�%#(�0((1*,:�'0�@3)%*9(<�?(�)$+(�0((1*,:�)#'31&�$1)'�A(�)$%*)(&�*,�%#(�./'9())�'0�$&+*,*)%/$%*,:�@3)%*9(<�?*)�/(_3*/()�%#(�0$*/�%/*$1�0'/�.1$*,%*�$)�2(11�$)�&(0(,&$,%<BaD�?*)�*)�$,'%#(/�2$-�'0�)$-*,:�%#$%�%#(�(_3$1*%-�'0�$/+)�A(�./'6*&(&�%'�$:(,%)�*,�%#(�9$)()<�b/*$1�*)�$�9'11(9%*6(�./'9())�$,&�(6(/-�A'&-�)#'31&�%$E(�$�/'1(�*,�A/*,:*,:�$A'3%�%#(�0$9%)�'0�9$)(�%'�%#(�0'/(0/',%<����"#*1(�9',%*,3*,:�%#(�9*/931$%*',�',�%/*$,:1(�'0�$+',:�./')(93%'/8�@3&:(�$,&�1$2-(/�0'/�&*)%/*A3%*,:�0$*/�@3)%*9(�*,�%#(�9/*+*,$1�%/*$1)8�/(:31$%'/)�#$6(�%'�.$-�$%%(,%*',�%'�,'%�',1-�%#(�A*,&*,:�/31(�A3%�$1)'�&(70$9%'�$..1*9$%*',)�'0�%#()(�/31()<�I,'%#(/�2'/&)8�/(1*$,9(�',�$�)%/*9%1-�9',9(.%3$1�$,$1-)*)�*)�,'%�:''&�(,'3:#8�2(�)#'31&�$1)'�1''E�*,%'�%#(�((9%)�'0�%#')(�9',9(.%)<�;(/(�9'+()�%#(�A*:�_3()%*',�'0�cVdSQ�PdOeUf�gL�QdL�hSij�NekNOPLP�OR�kLleUSQOkPmn�'/�cVdO�PdOeUf�kLleUSQL�QdL�kLleUSQOkPmn�'/�A(%%(/�2$-�'0�.')*,:�%#(�_3()%*',�*)�cVdO�PdOeUf�PeNLkoiPL�QdL�kLleUSQOkPmnp$*,�.3/.')()�%#$%�$/(�/(_3*/(&�%'�#$6(�0'/�/(:31$%'/)�$/(�%'�./'6*&(�(_3$1�$,&�0$*/�%/($%+(,%�0'/�(6(/-�9*%*q(,8�$,&�%#(�./'%(9%*',�'0�03,&$+(,%$1�/*:#%)�$,&�BCD� r(*%(/�s8�ctguLTQioiQv�Sjf��QdL�wkOgULhP�OR�xekiPNkefLjTLn8�yF�b([$)�r$2�G(6*(2�Czy8�C{{K8�.<z<BFD� |-:3/�H<�c}ekSh~�vULh��S�USh�n8��=�8�C{��8�)<yK7z�8�r(2(11-,�=<r8�cxekiPNkefLjTL��LSUiPh�ij��LOkv�Sjf�wkSTQiTLn8��#*9$:'��/())8�C{�F8�.<a�C<BKD� 5311(/�r<�r8�c�L��OkSUiQv�OR��SVn8�C{�{8�..<�K{8�K<BaD� >9#/'(&(/8��(,*)(-�6(��(3E(/%8���(q$�p3#$E(+()*,&(�c�Sik��kiSUn��1E()*8��)%$,A31�s$/8C{{{<

��������������� � ������ ����������

�� ������������������� !

"#$$%&'(�)*%�+),$)(�-&#./(�"&#�0*%010%/)2�-2)0'(3�4+/(�$*),2$�+/')*�,$0*5(�0*�4+$�-&''/*046�+)1$�"$$20*5(�&"�()"$46�)*%�($-/#046789:���;$4�'$�-&'$�4&�4+$�(4)#40*5�.&0*4�&"�#$"$#$*-$3�#$5/2)4&#(�(+&/2%�$*<&6�4+$�-&'='&*�'0*0'/'�,$20$"�(6(4$'�>+0-+�$*),2$�4+$'�)�-&''&*�)..#&)-+�)*%�4+/(�%&�)>)6�'0(4#/(4�)'&*5�4+$'($21$(7�?*�)%%040&*3�4+$6�(+&/2%�#$10$>�,&4+�&"�*)40&*)2�)*%�0*4$#*)40&*)2�)-4(3�#$5/2)40&*(3�%0#$-401$(�$4-7�)*%�)2(&�4+$�(&-0)2�#/2$(�"&#�.#$=.)#0*5�&#�)'$*%0*5�*&#')401$�(6(4$'�&"�#/2$(7�@$-&*%263�4+$6�(+&/2%�%$4$#'0*$�,&4+�(&-0)2�)*%�2$5)2�*$$%(�"&#�)22�-&*-$#*$%7�A4�4+0(�.&0*43�)�5#$)4$#�-&*-$#*�,$�501$*�4&�4+$�&,<$-4�&"�4+$�#$5/2)40&*3�07$73�>+$4+$#�')B0*5�)�*$>�#/2$�0(�(/04),2$C$D$-401$�&#�*&4�"&#�4+$�0((/$�)4�+)*%�"&#�4+$�5&&%�&"�./,20-�&#�4+$�&*$�0*4$#$(4$%�.$#(&*(C0*(404/40&*(7��A"4$#�+)10*5�%$)24�>04+�$1)2/)40&*�)*%�-#&((=-+$-B(3�$*&/5+�-)#$�)*%�.#&4$-40&*�,$�501$*�4&�0*%010%/)2�#05+4(�)*%�&>*$#(+0.(7�?4�0(�#$E/0#$%�4+)4�4+$�#$5/2)4&#(�.#$1$*4�)*6�),/($�&"�"/*%)'$*4)2�#05+4(�&"�)22�-040F$*(7��A24+&/5+�4+$�2)>�')B0*5�0(�.#&-$((�4)B0*5�)�2&*5�40'$3�0*1&210*5�')*6�.$&.2$�&"�%0D$#$*4�'&401)40&*(3�4+$0#�)4404/%$(�'/(4�,$�4)B$*�>04+�-)/40&*�)*%�(/(.0-0&*�0*�4+$�$1$#6�(4$.�&"�.#$.)#)40&*�"&#�%#)"4�#$5/2)40&*(7�G)'$�4+$&#6�(+&/2%�,$�4)B$*�)�.&0*4�&"�#$"$#$*-$�"&#�H*%0*5�)�</(4�(&2/40&*�)*%�')*)5$),2$�-&(4�4&�4+$�./,20-7�?4�0(�>$22�B*&>*�4+)4�</(40-$�4&�)22�-&(4�0(�*&4�)�</(40-$�)4�)227�?*�4+0(�(04/)40&*3�4+$6�(+&/2%�)%&.4�4+$�#/2$�&"�IJKLM�NLOP�QRSRTUKV�)*%�%&�4+$�4$(4�&"�)*)26F0*5�4+$�IWPLXS�YKZ�QL[SV7�A*&4+$#�>&#%(3�4+$�$-&*&'0-�)(.$-4�&"�4+$�#$5/2)40&*�0(�*&4�4&�,$�%0(#$5)#%$%�)4�)227�\0#%263�)44$*40&*�(+&/2%�,$�501$*�4&�4+$���$4+0-)2�#/2$(�&"�-&''/*046]�)*%�0"�.&((0,2$�'&,020F$�4+$�'&#)2�(/..&#4�20$(�>04+0*�4+$'7��#&'�4+0(�)*52$3�./,20-�-&*(-0$*-$�0(�4&�,$-&'$�)�#$)2�#$"$#$*-$�"&#�4+&($�#$5/2)40&*�-&*(0%$#$%�4&�,$�(/04),2$�&#�*&4�4&�,$50*�%/#0*5�4+$�),&1$�'$*40&*$%�)(($(('$*4�.$#0&%7�A4�4+$�$*%3�4+$�.#&%/-43�#/2$(�)*%�#$5/2)40&*�')6�$*<&6�4+$�./,20-�/*%$#(4)*%0*5�)*%�(/..&#4]�4+/(�$1$*4/)2�)--$.4)*-$�&"�4+&($�-&*-$#*0*5�4+$�#$5/2)40&*7��_4+$#>0($3�4+$�#$5/2)40&*�0(�4&�#$')0*�)�%$�</#$�$0(4$*-$78a:�#&'�4+$�-&*(404/40&*)2�.$#(.$-401$3�#$5/2)40&*(�>+0-+�5&1$#*�4+$�%0D$#$*4�)/4+&#040$(�)#$�(&�-#/-0)2�"&#�4+$�()B$�&"�0*%$.$*%$*-6�&"�)"&#$'$*40&*$%�)/4+&#0=40$(7�b/#0*5�4+$�2)>=')B0*5�.#&-$((3�#$5/2)4&#(3�H#(4263�+)1$�4&�4)B$�0*4&�)--&/*4�>+$4+$#�4+0(�2$50(2)40&*�0(�")0#�&#�*&4�"&#�)22�-&*-$#*$%7�@$-&*%263�4+$6�(+)22�-&*(0%$#�),&1$�'$*40&*$%�>+$4+$#�4+$�0*(404/40&*)2�#$E/0#$'$*4(�)#$�'$4�&#�*&47�\0#%263�4+$6�&,205$�4&�B*&>�4+0(�2$50(2)40&*�>+$4+$#�,#0*5(�$c-0$*4�(&2/40&*(�#$5)#%0*5�2$5)2�-&*d0-4(C%0(-#$.)*-0$(�&#�*&47�\$6�+)1$�4&�-&*4#&2�)*%�.#&10%$�>+$4+$#�2$50(2)401$�)/4+&#046�0(�(&2$26�0*%$.$*%$*4�&#�*&47�#&'�4+0(�.&0*4�&"�10$>3�#$5/2)4&#(�(+&/2%�)*)26F$�4+$�>+&2$�.#&-$((�0*�%$4)02(�)*%�%&�-#&((=-+$-B�)22�&"�4+$�.)#)%05'(�/.�4&�,&4+�$*10#&*'$*4)2�)*%�&4+$#�-&*%040&*(7�A4�4+0(�#$)-+0*5�.&0*43�#$5/2)4&#(�(+&/2%�)(($((�4+$�>+&2$�.)#43�0*-2/%0*5�&"�)22�%)4)7��?*�4+0(�(04/)40&*3�4+)4�4$(4�>022�,$�'$)(/#),2$�),&1$�4+0(�')44$#7�\$�&4+$#�")-4�0(�4+)4�#$5/2)4&#(�(+&/2%�#$10$>�89:� e)5*)�f)#4)3�f+).4$#�gh78a:� i&2'$(�_7j3�IkU�lYSm�Ln�SmU�oYMV3�i)#1)#%�;)>�p$10$>3�q&27rh3�rstu3�.7g9u7

��������������� � ������ ����������

���������������������� �!

"#$�%"&'�(#%)�"**)+#%�%,'�)%,'-�.'/(0."%(1'�-'/+."%()#02�3)-')1'-4�-'/+."%)-0�,"1'�%)�*)#0($'-�5,'%,'-�%,(0�.'/(0."%()#�(0�0+(%"6.'�"**)-$(#/�%)�/'#'-".�.'/".�'%,(*�"#$�7+-(08-+$'#*'�)-�#)%2��9':�,"1'�%)�/)�(#%)�%,'�$-";%�.'/(0."%()#�5,'%,'-�(%�<''%0�8+6.(*�*)#0*('#*'�)-�#)%2��=**)-$(#/�%)�8+6.(*�."54�<"#"/'-0�,"1'�%)�8":�"%%'#%()#�%)�-'/+."%()#0�5,(*,�/)1'-#0�%,'(-�)5#�6+0(#'002>'%�<'�%'..�%,'�;"*%�%,"%�<'#%()#'$�%-"#0(%()#�0,)50�+0�%,'-'�(0�%,'�0"<'�8)(#%�);�1('5�6'%5''#�8+6.(*�"#$�<"#"/'<'#%�."502��3"#"/'-("..:�08'"&(#/4�5,"%�<"#"/'<'#%�<'"#0�(0�"0�%,(#�.(#'�6'%5''#�'<8.):'-0�"#$�'<8.):''02�?<8.):'-�,"0�%)�6',"1'�"0�"�-'/+."%)-2�@'�0,)+.$�$'%'-<(#'�"..�-'A+(-'<'#%0�6)%,�);�0%-+*B%+-'�"#$�'<8.):''2�3"#"/'<'#%�(0�-'A+(-'$�%,"%�$'*(0()#0�5,(*,�,"0�%"&'#�6'�*)#0(0%'#%�-'/"-$(#/�(#0%(%+%()#".�0+67'*%2�9'�0+**'00�);�"�$'*(0()#�%,"%�5"0�%"&'#�0,)50�(#0%(%+%()#".�8'-;)-<"#*'2��9'�)%,'-�8)(#%�(0�<"#"/'-�"0�"�.'/(0."%)-�0,)+.$�%,(#&�.'/".�'#%(%:2�C-)<�%(<'�%)�%(<'4�,'�0,)+.$�%"&'�$'*(0()#0�*)#0($'-(#/�%,'�(#0%(%+%()#".�8'-08'*%(1'�"**)-$(#/�%,'�*)#D(*%02�E+6.(*�<"#"/'<'#%�(0�-'A+(-'$�%,"%�6'�<)-'�8-)$+*%(1'�"#$�&''8�%,'�%)8(*�);�.'/".�'#%(%:2��F#�%,(0�0(%+"%()#4�%,'�6"0(*�8)(#%�(0�%)�$'G#'�%,'�8+-8)0'2��3"#"/'-0�,"1'�%)�$'%'-<(#'�5,'%,'-�%,(0�8+-8)0'�(0�0+(%"6.'�-'/"-$(#/�)H*(".�8'-08'*%(1'�)-�#)%2��9'�6'0%�%"-/'%�5(..�6'�-'"0)#'$�5(%,�%,'�6'0%�8-"*%(0'2�9'�6'0%�8-"*%(0'�5(..�6'�".0)�-'".(I'$�6:�<'"#0�);�6'0%�-'/+."%()#02��C)-�%,(0�-'"0)#4�<"#"/'-�0,)+.$�0,"-'�(#;)-<"%()#�-'."%'$�%)�<"#"/'<'#%�6:�+0(#/�6)%,�);�;)-<".�"#$�'%,(*�-+.'2��J)�'#0+-'�*)#0(0%'#*:�"#$�.(<(%�$(0*-'%()#�0''<0�)6.(/"%)-:�"%�%,(0�8)(#%2��F#�%,(0�0(%+"%()#4�%,'�<"#"/'-�,"1'�%)�"#".:I'�$'%"(.'$�)1'-�*:*.'�"#$�&#)5�,)5�%)�0,"-'�(#;)-<"%()#�"<)#/�%,'�8"-B%(*(8"#%02�9(0�<'"#04�"<)#/�)%,'-�%,(#/04�%,"%�(%�0,)+.$�6'�#'(%,'-�(--'.'1"#%�#)-�'K*'00(1'�;)-�%,'(-�8+-8)0'04�"#$�<+0%�)#.:�6'�$(0*.)0'$�(%�%)�)%,'-0�5,'-'�%,)0'�)%,'-�"/'#*('0�".0)�#''$�%)�&#)5�%,'�8"-%(*+."-�(#;)-<"%()#�0,"-'$2�F#�"$$(%()#4�0)<'�G'.$0�"-'�0+67'*%�%)�08'*(G*�."50�)-�-'/+."%()#02�L'*(0()#0�%)�0,"-'�(#;)-<"%()#�6'%5''#�"/'#*('0�"6)+%�"#�(#$(1($+".�"-'�+0+"..:�6"0'$�)#�0)<'�7+$/<'#%0�"6)+%�%,'�-(0&�%,"%�<(/,%�6'�;)+#$�."%'-�5,'#�(#;)-<"%()#�,"0�6''#�0,"-'$�"#$�;+-%,'-�(#1'0%(/"%()#0�$)#'�%,"%�"#�(#$(1($+".�;"*'04�)-�%,"%�%,'�(#$(1($+".�8-'0'#%02�=%�%,'�8)(#%�5,'-'�"�$'*(0()#�)#�5,'%,'-�)-�#)%�%)�0,"-'�%,'�(#;)-<"%()#�(0�6'(#/�<"$'4�%,'�8-);'00()#".M0�*)#G$'#*'�(#�%,'(-�7+$/<'#%�);�-(0&�(0�+#"1)($"6.:�-"%,'-�.)54�;)-�#'(%,'-�%,'�0'#$(#/4�#)-�%,'�-'*'(1(#/�)-/"#(0"%()#�8)00'00'0�"�;+..�8(*%+-'2�F;�%,'�$'*(0()#�%)�0,"-'�(0�#)%�"88-)8-("%'4�%,'#�8-'0+<"6.:�%,'�(#(%(".�0+08(*()+0�);�-(0&�5"0�"�;".0'�8)0(%(1'�7+$/<'#%�'--)-2�9'�*)#1'-0'�'--)-4�"#�"88-)8-("%'�$'*(B0()#�#)%�%)�0,"-'�(#;)-<"%()#�"-(0'0�5,'-'�%,'�(#(%(".�."*&�);�0+08(*()#�);�-(0&�(0�"�*"0'�);�"�NOPQRS�TSUPVWXSY�7+$/<'#%�'--)-2�F;�,"1(#/�0,"-'$�%,'�(#;)-<"%()#�"#$�*)#$+*%'$�;+-%,'-�(#;)-<"%()#4�%,'�(#(%(".�7+$/<'#%�'--)-�(0�#)%�*)--'*%'$�;)-�"#:�-'"0)#4�%,'#�(#"88-)8-("%'�(#%'-1'#%()#�<":�;)..)5�Z5-)#/.:�%"&(#/�"�*,(.$�(#%)�*"-'�)-�+##'*'00"-:�*)<8'..(#/�"�8+%"%(1'.:�<'#%"..:�(..�8'-0)#�%)�6'�%-'"%'$�(#�"�80:*,("%-(*�+#(%�)-�;"..(#/�%)�$)�0)�5,'#�(%�5)+.$�,"1'�6''#�5"--"#%'$2�9'�8-)6B.'<�;"*(#/�<"#:�8-);'00()#".0�"#$�0%-''%B.'1'.�8-)6.'<�0).1(#/��"/'#%0�(0�8-'*(0'.:�%,"%�"#:�$'*(0()#�-+.'�)-�#)-<4�5,'%,'-�;)-<".�)-�(#;)-<".�(#�*,"-"*%'-4�"88.('$�

��������������� � ������ ����������

�� ������������������� !

"#$%&�'"()�(*#$+,+*#'�*-�.+/+,%$�0#$�*102"%�+#-*&/0,+*#�3+..�+#%4+,05.6�'**#%&�*&�.0,%&�&"#�,)%�&+'7�%+,)%&�*-�89:;<=�>=?:@AB=C�*&�%.'%�*-�89:;<=�DE<A@AB=C�F"$G/%#,�%&&*&'H�I+'�011&*0()�/"',�5%�(*/1.+0#,�3+,)�8J:>:?=J=>@�@K=ELMNCOPQR10&,�-&*/�,)%�0#0.6,+(0.�(*#'+',%#(6�*-�.%G+'.0,+*#S�,)%&%�+'�,)%�*,)%&�1*+#,�+'�,)%�/*&0.�(*#,%#,�*-�,)%�.%G+'.0,+4%�1&*(%''HOTQ�R,�,)+'�1*+#,S�&%G".0,*&'�')*".$�$%,%&/+#%�0#6�/*&0.�)0U0&$�3)+()�3+..�0&+'%H�V*&0.�)0U0&$�/06�(*/%�+#,*�-*&%-&*#,�+#�/0,,%&'�*-�(*/1%#'0,+*#H��W,�+'�0.'*�'*�+/1*&,0#,�-*&�&%G".0,*&'H�I%6�')*".$�/07%�0�1"5.+(�*1+#+*#'X�'"&4%6H��Y)%#�3%�&%,"&#�,)%�Z&',�2"%',+*#S�,)%�0#'3%&�,*�,)%�2"%',+*#�+'�)+$$%#�+#�,)%�0#'3%&�,*�5%�G+4%#�,*�,)%�'%(*#$�2"%',+*#H��[*&�,)+'�&%0'*#S�'"1%&4+'+*#�+,'%.-�0''"/%'�,)%�&%2"+&%/%#,�,)0,�'"1%&4+'*&'�0'�3%..�0'�&%G".0,*&'�/"',�1.06�%2"0.�&*.%'H�I%�-"#(,+*#'�*-�'"1%&4+'+#G�0#$�&%G".0,+#G�0&%�(*/1.+/%#,0&6�%.%/%#,'�*-�0�',&"(,"&%H�I%�'"1%&4+'*&'�/"',�)04%�,)%�&0,+*#0.%�*-�,)%�&%G".0,+*#H�I%6�/"',�0.'*�5&+#G�05*",�0..�,)%�#%(%''0&6�/%0'"&%'�,07%#�,*�)04%�-"..�011.+(0,+*#�*-�,)%�&%G".0,+*#H�W/10&,+0.+,6�*#�,)%�10&,�*-�'"1%&4+'*&'�+'�0�4%&6�+/1*&,0#,H�I+'�+'�1'6()*.*G+(0.�-%%.+#G�*#�,)%�10&,�*-�(*#'"/%&'H�I+'�2"0.+,6�(*/%'�0-,%&�0�.*#G�1&*(%''+#G�*-�$+\%&%#,�(0'%'�$%0.,�56�,)%�'"1%&4+'*&'H�]"1%&4+'*&'�0.'*�'%&4%�0'�30,()$*G'�0G0+#',�0#6�$+'(&%,+*#0&6�05"'%'H�[&*/�,)+'�0#G.%S�,)%6�1&*4+$%�%2"0.�,&%0,/%#,�*-�,)*'%�(*/%�"#$%&�0%G+'�*-�'"1%&4+'*&'-0+&�F"',+(%H�R'�,)%�(*#',+,",+*#0.�.03�$+(,0,%'�,)0,�,)%�&%G".0,+*#�+,'%.-�1&*4+$%'�-*&�,)%�-"#(,+*#+#G�*-�&%G".0,*&'H�]"1%&4+'*&'�0.'*�1&*4+$%�-%%$50(7'�-*&�,)%�&%0.+'0,+*#�*-�+#,%#$%$�1"&1*'%�3+,)�,)%�&%G".0,+*#H��I+'�+'�0#*,)%&�306�*-�'06+#G�,)0,�0..�,)%�&%G".0,+*#'�0&%�*1%#�,*�'"1%&4+'+*#H�I+'�+'�0#�011&*0()�0$*1,%$�56�,)%�1&0G/0,+','HO_Q�I%�*,)%&�1*+#,�*-�'"1%&4+'+*#�+'�"1�,*�,)%�/*#+,*&+#GH�I%�5%',�G*4%&#0#(%�&%2"+&%'�,)0,�/*#+,*&+#G�0'�0�1*.+(6�*-�1&*$"(,+4+,6�+'�,*�5%�0$*1,%$�56�,)%�/0#0G%&G*4%&#*&�+#�0#�%\%(,+4%�306H�]*�,)%�5%',�/0#0G%&�')*".$�$%,%&/+#%�3)%,)%&�,)%�-0(,'�,)0,�$+'(*4%&%$�0&%�-0+&�0#$�/%0'"&05.%�*&�#*,H��a%�)0'�,*�)04%�,)%�3)*.%�%(*#*/+(�0#$�0$/+#+',&0,+*#0.�,)%*&+%'�0#$�7#*3�)*3�,*�011.6�,)%/H�W#4%',+G0,+*#�+'�&%2"+&%$�,)0,�$+.+G%#,�+#2"+&+%'�(0&&+%$�*",H�R,�,)0,�1*+#,�'"1%&4+'*&�+'�*5.+G%$�,*�)%.1�/*#+,*&'H�b*,)�*-�,)%/�')*".$�1&%10&%�&%G".0,+*#�-*&�/*#+,*&+#G�1&*(%''H��W,�G*%'�3+,)*",�'06+#G�,)0,�'"1%&4+'+#G�0#$�/*#+,*&+#G�')*".$�5%�%2"0.�+/1*&,0#(%�-*&�&%G".0,*&'H�V*#+,*&'�')*".$�)04%�,*�')0&%�+#-*&/0,+*#�3+,)�'"1%&4+'*&'H�]*�+,�')*".$�5%�,)%�(0'%�3+,)�,)%�'"1%&4+'*&'H��W,�+'�*-�#*�$*"5,�,)0,�5*,)�'"1%&4+'*&'�0#$�/*#+,*&'�/"',�5%�*1%#/+#$%$�1%&'*#'H�a04+#G�'%%#�,)0,�#%(%''+,6�$*%'�#*,�/%0#�,)0,�,*�&%0()�,)%�&%0.+,6H�[*&�,)+'�&%0'*#S�&%G".0,*&'�)04%�,*�(*#'+$%&�+#,%G&0.�10&,�*-�,*,0..6H�]*�,)%6�3+..�5&+#G�'*.",+*#'�3+,)�G%,,+#G�%0'+.6H��[&*/�,)%�0#G.%�*-�G*4%&#+#G�1%&'1%(,+4%S�/0#0G%&�')*".$�(*#'+$%&�,)%�&".%�*-�8cd=�cA;A?=>e=CHOfgQ��[*&�&%0()+#G�'"((%''S�%h(+%#,�$"%�$+.+G%#(%�+'�&%2"+&%$�OPQ� 333H5"'+#%''H(*/$+&%(,*&6/0#0G%/%#,/0#0G%/%#,i,)%*&6S�b*#*�$%�j$30&$a%..%&�k*5%&,S�8l:>:?=J=>@�m=ELMCS�I+#7+#G�V0#0G%&'S��nggoHOTQ� p"q"&0$+�rHS�8sEc=�E9�t@Au�:>c�v:wCS�a[]RxT�yr',H�b0&zS�ngg{S�'H_SffHO_Q� |0/%'�YS��}&0G/0,+'/�0#$�~,)%&�j''06'�Y0')+#G,*#�]2"0&%�}&%''S��%3��*&7S�f_o{S�1HnPHOfgQ��03&%#(%��0&6�VHS�8�d=��A;A?=>e=�A>��d<A>=<<��L:><:e@AE><CS��b"'+#%''�0#$�j(*#*/+('S�f__�H

��������������� � ������ ����������

���������������������� �!

"#$%"&'($�)#$%)�#(*'*+,��-(�*.'/�/'*0%*'1(2�%�3#/*�4%(%$#"�/.10)&�5"#/04#�%(&�6%)60)%*#�7.1)#�51//'3')'*'#/�%(&�61(&'*'1(/,��81"#�6"#%*'9#�%6*'9'*'#/�'/�"#:0'"#&�41"#�&#*%')#&�%(%)+/'/,�;+�*.#�4#%(/�1<�4#(*'1(#&2�"#$0)%*1"=4%(%$#"�7'))�"#%6.�3#/*�/1)0*'1(�%661"&'($�*1�'(6'&#(*=61(>'6*,�?9#"+*.'($�&#5#(&/�1(�*.#�(#6#//'*+�1<�&0#�&')'$#(6#,�-<�*.#�4%(%$#"�7%(*�*1�3#�%�/066#//'9#2�.#�/.10)&�61(/'&#"�*.#�"#/0)*/�1<�&0#�&')'$#(6#@<##&3%6A,�B/�%�3#/*�"#$0)%*1"2�4%(%$#"�13)'$#&�*1�#(*#"*%'(�&0#�&')'$#(6#,�-<�*.#�4%(%$#"�7'/.�*1�"#$0)%*#�<1"�%))�61(6#"(#&2�.#�/.10)&�$'9#�'451"*%(6#�"#$%"&'($�&0#�&')'$#(6#,�C#"#�'/�%)/1�*.#�1*.#"�6"06'%)�51'(*�7.'6.�'/�503)'6�4#%/0"#/,�8%(%$#"/�.%9#�*1�%)/1�61(/'&#"�*.#�/%<#$0%"&�*.#�$#(#"%)=503)'6�'(*#"#/*,��D#�/.10)&�61(/'&#"�7.1)#�51//'3')'*'#/,�D#�/.10)&�&#*#"4'(#�*.#�/5#6'E6�#61(14'6�51)'6+�13F#6*'9#�6)#%")+�&#E(#&,�D#�/.10)&�5"#9#(*�&'/6"'4'(%*'1(,�D#�40/*�.%9#�%�61(/6'10/�1<�31*.�*.#�6%5%6'*+�1<�'(/*'*0*'1(�%(&�#45)1+##/,�-*�'/�%)/1�#G5#6*#&�*.%*�.#�40/*�3#.%9#�'(�%661"&%(6#�7'*.�*.#�&#4%(&/�1<�/.%"#.1)&#"/,�B*�*.'/�51'(*2�.#�/.10)&�<160/�1(�*.#�"0)#�1<�61"51"%*#�$19#"(%(6#,�C#�"0)#�1<�61"@51"%*#�$19#"(%(6#�7'))�3#�3%/'6�7%+�<1"�"#%6.'($�$11&�$19#"(%(6#,�-(�*.#�5"16#//�%/�/06.�"#$0)%*1"/�/.10)&�61(/'&#"�/05"%@(%*'1(%)�%/5#6*�1<�*.#�"0)#�1<�HIJKLJKMNO�PJQOKRMRIOS,TUUV81"#19#"2�<"14�*.#�%($)#�1<�5"#/#(*�%55)'6%*'1(/2�"#$0)%*'1(�1<�61"51"%*#�%6*'9@'*+�'(�6#"*%'(�/#6*1"/�'/�*.#�41/*�7'&#)+�0/#&�'(/*"04#(*�*1�/%<#$0%"&�*.#�$#(#"%)�'(*#"#/*�%(&�*.#�503)'6�51)'6+�13F#6*'9#/,�W#$0)%*'1(�.%/�*.#�4#"'*�1<�/5#))'($�10*�6)#%")+�*.#�503)'6�51)'6+�13)'$%*'1(/�1<�*.#�6145%(+�1"�%�/#"9'6#�5"19'&#",�?G%45)#/�'(6)0&#�10*"'$.*�(%*'1(%)�"#$0)%*'1(�1<�/055)+�61(&'*'1(/�'(�/#6*1"/�6.%"%6*#"'/#&�3+�(%*0"%)�41(151)'#/2�#'*.#"�*."10$.�)#$'/)%*'1(�1"�*."10$.�41('*1"'($�3+�"#$0)%@*1"/2�%/�'(�*.#�6#"*%'(�/#6*1",�W#$0)%*'1(�6%(�%)/1�3#�#G#"6'/#&�7'*.'(�%�61(6#//'1(�/+/*#42�7.#"#�5"1&06*'1(�61(&'*'1(/�%"#�)%'&�&17(�'(�*.#�"#)#9%(*�)#$'/)%*'1(2�%/�7#))�%/�'(�*.#�*#(&#"'($�61(&'*'1(/�%(&�*.#�61(6#//'1(�61(*"%6*/2�7'*.�*.#�%'")'(#�%(&�3"1%&6%/*'($�/#6*1"/�%/�#G%45)#/,�W#$0)%*1"�/.10)&�&#*#"4'(#�31*.�(%*'1(%)�%(&�'(*#"(%*'1(%)�)#$%)�<"%4#71"A,B/�%�"#/0)*2�"#$0)%*'1(/�%"#�3'(&'($�7.1)#�)#$'/)%*'9#�5"16#//�0(&#"�*.#�*.#1"#*'@6%)2�41"%)�%(&�*.#�1*.#"�%55"1%6.#/,�X1"�*.'/�"#%/1(2�%))�"#$0)%*1"/�/.10)&�*%A#�&#6'/'1(/�7'*.�'(&#5#(&#(*)+�%(&�'(<1"4#&�61(/6'#(6#,�C#+�/.10)&�5%+�%**#(@*'1(�*1�"0)#/�1<�%6610(*%3')'*+�%(&�*"%(/5%"#(6+,�B/�%�"#/0)*�1<�%6610(*%3')'*+2�*.#+�610)&�3#�.#)&�"#/51(/'3)#�'(�*.1/#�6%/#/�*.#+�6%0/#/�.%"4�&0#�*1�5#"/1((#)�<%0)*,�B*�*.'/�51'(*2�(1�1"$%(/2�%0*.1"'*+�1"�5#"/1(�/.%))�(1*�$'9#�%(+�'(/*"06*'1(/2�&0#�*1�'(>0#(6#�1(�*.#�&#6'/'1(/�7.'6.�*.#�"#$0)%*1"�.%/�$'9#(,�-(�/044%"+2�"#$0)%*'1(�61(/'/*/�1<�31*.�#(<1"6#4#(*�%(&�4%(%$#4#(*,�-*�'/�'451"*%(*�*.%*�*.#�/*%3')'*+�1<�1"$%('/%*'1(%)�/*"06*0"#�3#�5"1*#6*#&,��X"14�*.'/�%($)#2�"#$0)%*1"/�%"#�13)'$#&�*1�3#�"#/51(/'3)#�*1�6%""+�1(�30"&#(/�1<�/+/*#4�<1"�5"19'&'($�/*%3')'*+�7'*.�*.#�'(*#(&#&�50"51/#�'(�*.#�<1"#<"1(*,�D%9'($�E))#&�7'*.�TUUV�8%"A/�W13#"*�B,Y,Z�8'(17�[#))2�\1"51"%*#�Y19#"(%(6#�2�;)%6A7#))�]03)'/.'($2�C'"&�?&'*'1(2�__,�]0)%a)b�D%/%(2��\1"51"%*#�Y19#"(%(6#@�B(1('4�c'"A#*�de(#*'4'(&#�d#('�81&#)2�B(A%"%�f%7�X%60)*+2�B(A%"%�__,

��������������� � ������ ����������

�� ������������������� !

"#$%&'$()*#�+,'-.(&'$/�$,%#"0($&"$�1$�2#**�1$�"#3,*1.&"$�'##4�$%#-(1*�%"&.#-.(&'�+&"�)&.5�.5#�.#',"#�1'4�"#6,'#"1.(&'7�89�,$('3�.5($�('$.",6#'./�2#�-1'�"#1-5�.5($�1'$2#"�&+�.5#�:,#$.(&'�&+�;<=>�?=>@AB�CDE@AFGD�G=D�CDE@AFG>C?�>H�ID=FAJ�>J�CDFK=LHE�G=D�GC@G=�>J�AF<MN

��������������� � ������ ����������

������������������������

!"!#"$%&'()*+,-,�./�0.123.45/66/3�7,8/39:�;2-2</=/-9�>?/,3@:�>?A-BA-<�;2-2</3C:�DEEFGHI66/3�JG�J:�>?/�;,326A9@�,K�J21:�LMFM:�NNGOM:POG5,6=/C�QGR:�S>?/�T29?�,K�9?/�J21U:�523V23.�J21�7/VA/1:�W,6GLE:�LXMY:�NGZPYG[2=/C�RG:�T32<=29AC=�2-.�Q9?/3�0CC2@C:�R2C?4A-<9,-�\]I23/�T3/CC:�/1�_,3B:�LMFO:NGDYGIaI32.A�bG:�S09AB�b6B/6/3�V/�5IBIBU:�5H\cde�fghijklmn�ojpqhmrs���ts�hu�vs��uJ213/-w/�x23@�;G:�SyI/�yA6A</-w/�A-�+ICA4-/CC�>32-C2w9A,-C:�+ICA-/CC�2-.�0w,-,=AwC:�LMMZGJ/A9/3�+G:�Q8z/w9AVA9@�2-.�T3,86/=C�,K�[I3AC4N3I./-w/:�YD�>/{2C�J21�7/VA/1�LXY:�LMMO:��NGXGJ/1/66@-�G�J:�[I3ACN3I./-w/�7/26AC=�A-�>?/,3@�2-.�T32w9Aw/:�|?A2<,�T3/CC:�LMFD:�NGZELG;23BC�7,8/39�cGxG�}�;A-,1�/66:�|,3N,329/�x,V/3-2-w/:�+62wB1/66�TI86AC?A-<:�>?A3.��0.A9A,-:�DEEOG;2<-2�|2392:�|?2N9/3�ZEGTI62~6��52C2-:�|,3N,329/�x,V/3-2-w/4�c-,-A=��A3B/9�_�-/9A=A-./�_/-A�+A3�;,./6:��+2-B2�V/�>Aw23/9�5IBIBI�c32~9�3=2�0-C9A9�C�:�c-B232�DEEOG\w?3,/./3:�_/-AC/@:�T/IB/39:�|/�2�;I?2B/4=/CA-./�SH2A3�>3A26U�b6B/CA:�bC92-8I6�+23,CI:��LMMMG