Smartphones in Education: Delivering Skills for Students in the 21st Century

26
“Smartphones in Education: Delivering Skills for Students in the 21 st Century” DEVC 290 Special Problem By: Cruz, Maria Victoria

Transcript of Smartphones in Education: Delivering Skills for Students in the 21st Century

     

       

 “Smartphones in Education: Delivering Skills

for Students in the 21st Century”

DEVC 290

Special Problem

By: Cruz, Maria Victoria

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

2  

Abstract   This   research   explores   the   benefits   of   smartphone-­‐enabled   curriculum   and   its  

importance  in  the  development  of  skills  that  students  must  possess  to  thrive  in  21st  

century.   The   study   draws   upon   discussion   among   secondary   three   pupils   of   The  

Convent  of  Holy  Infant  Jesus  (CHIJ),  an  all-­‐girls  school  in  Singapore.  The  study  found  

that   smartphones   with   learning   applications   has   a   huge   potential   to   support  

students   learning.   Use   of   the   device   provides   students   with   the   opportunity   to  

develop   or   enhance   their   communication,   collaboration,   creativity   and   critical  

thinking  skills.  Such  skills  are  necessary  for  them  to  possess  in  order  to  thrive  and  

succeed   in   this   world   of   knowledge   and   information.   The   paper   calls   for   a  

restructure   in   our   education   system.   It  must   be   redesigned   in   such   a  way   that   it  

appropriately  meets  the  needs  of  today’s  learners.      

Introduction    

                                                             ‘The  value  of  deploying  mobile  technologies  in  the  service  of  

 learning  is  both  self-­‐evident  and  unavoidable.  It  requires  a  

   little  extra  effort  for  students  or  learners  to  adopt  mobile  

       phones  in  learning.”  Wagner  (2005).  

 

Technology   has   dramatically   changed   the   way   people   live.   Today’s   societies   are  

constantly  changing  and  running  at  a  more  rapid  pace.  There  is  a  strong  need  to  be  

more   competitive   given   the   huge   opportunities,   risks,   diverse   workplaces   and  

communities.   These   are   attributed   to   how   technology   and   information   have  

conquered  and  driven  people  and  their  environment.  Thus,  there  is  a  need  for  more  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

3  

people   to   learn  how  to  survive  and  thrive   in  such  a  way  that   their  knowledge  and  

skills   strategically  measure  up   to   this   new  world  of   innovation,   referred   to   as   the  

21st  century.    

 

Traditionally,  labor  and  capital  were  the  main  engines  of  development.  Today,  both  

knowledge  and  skills  are  essential  to  power  an  information-­‐based  and  technology-­‐

driven   economy.     How   can   we   produce   people   who   can   succeed   in   this   era?   We  

begin  by  focusing  on  today’s  students.  The  21st  century  education  and  students  play  

a  significant  role  to  see  a  nation  progress.    

 

Today’s   learners   need   to   acquire   the   knowledge,   skills   and   attributes   that   are  

essential   to   better   position   themselves   in   this   new  world.   This   paper  will   present  

the   big   potential   of   the   smartphone,   an   advanced   technological   device,   in   the  

development   of   competent   skills   essential   for   students   of   today.   This   study   was  

designed   to   determine   the   benefits   and   importance   of   smartphone-­‐enabled  

curriculum  in  helping  students  succeed  in  this  21st  century.  The  paper  aims  to:  

• To  elicit  students’  perspectives,  opinions  and  ideas  on  how  the  smartphone  is  

used   in   classes   and   how   it   benefits   them   in   terms   of   knowledge   and   skills  

acquisition.    

• To   determine   how   students   today   differ   from   students   of   past   generations  

and  understand  these  students’  needs  in  a  way  to  best  meet  them.

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

4  

Skills Framework for the 21st Century Learning

 

The  Partnership  for  21st  Century  Skills  is  a  national  organization  that  advocates  the  

need   for   today’s   learners   to   be   more   highly   skilled   and   competitive.   They   have  

identified   the   necessary   skills   critical   for   students   to   possess   and   ensure   their  

success  as  citizens  and  workers:    

• Critical  Thinking  &  Problem  Solving.   Students  need   to  approach   the  modern  

world  with  both  brains  (right  and  left).  Global  issues  and  problems  are  expected  

to   grow  even  more   complex;   hence,   a   demand   for   active   thinking  of   solutions  

and  alternatives.  Given  the  wide  availability  of  information  –  on  the  web,  in  the  

media,   in   homes,   workplaces   and   everywhere   else,   students   need   to   learn   to  

make  reasoned  decisions  and  take  more  purposeful  actions.    

 

• Creativity   and   Innovation.   People   with   the   ability   to   create   new   and  

worthwhile   ideas,   gain   new   perspectives,   imagine   new   scenarios   and   think  

unconventionally  are  very  crucial  to  any  of  today’s  businesses  or  organizations.    

 

• Communication   &   Collaboration.   We   live   in   diverse   and   multinational  

communities   where   competition   is   a   way   of   life,   thus   a   need   to   understand  

everyone’s  needs  across  the  globe.  There  is  a  need  to  emphasize  development  of  

written  and  oral  communication  skills.  

 

• Information,  Media  and  Technical  Skills.  Students  need   to  display  a  range  of  

functional  and  critical  skills  related  to  navigation  of  information,  exploration  of  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

5  

media  and  technology.  Given  a  vast  ocean  of  data,  students  need  to  learn  how  to  

transform  data  to  relevant  information  and  create  it  into  purposeful  knowledge.    

 

Smartphone Potential The  smartphone   is  probably  one  of   the  best   inventions   in  the  world.  Today,  a  vast  

majority   of   people   including   students   carries   this   device   that   packs   powerful  

computer   technology   in   handheld   size.   Moreover,   such   technological   device  

provides  personal  performance  improvement.  

 

A  number  of  research  surveys  indicate  a  projection  of  rapid  growth  in  the  number  of  

smartphone   users,   by  which   a   billion   units  will   be   sold   in   2015.   Below   are   some  

more   main   factors   that   potentially   make   smartphones   a   powerful   networked  

learning  environment:  

• Ubiquity   –   The   device’s   hand-­‐held   size   yet   powerful   computing   abilities  

allows  everyone  to  bring  it  anywhere  with  them.    

 

• Instant  gratification  –  Instant  messages  and  information  needed  by  student  

are  on  hand  and  just  a  few  clicks  away.    

 

• Multi-­‐functionality  –  Other   than   smartphone’s   ability   to  make   and   receive  

phone   calls   and  messages.   It   has   applications   and   features   such   as   e-­‐mail,  

calendar,  video,  camera,  etc.    

 

• Connectivity   –   Smartphone   offers   a   faster   Wireless   Fidelity   (Wi-­‐Fi)  

connection  than  any  other  cellular  networks.  

 

• Efficiency  –   It   increases  efficiency  and  productivity  of  students.  They  spend  

less  time  accomplishing  learning  tasks  using  the  device.    

 

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

6  

Through   smartphones,   learners   are   able   to   easily   access   relevant   information  

anytime   and   anywhere.   It   offers   convenience   in   learning   to   students;   providing   a  

venue  of   easier   communication   and   interaction  between   learners,   co-­‐learners   and  

their  instructors.    

 

Singapore as an Ideal Nation

Singapore   is  one  of   the  most  technology-­‐driven  countries   in  the  world.  Based  on  a  

research   study   released   by   Nielsen,   the   country   has   the   highest   smartphone  

ownership   in   the   Asia   Pacific   region.   According   to   Mobile   Marketing   Association  

(MMA),   its   mobile   phone   penetration   rate   reaches   to   148.9%   of   which   88%   are  

smartphone   subscriptions.  Old   citizens,   professionals   and   even   students   are  using  

such  technology.    

 

Given   the  ubiquity   of   smartphones   in   the   country,   the   government   encourages   its  

schools  to  integrate  such  device  with  learning  applications  in  their  class  curriculum.  

The   government   believes   in   the   potential   of   the   device   in   transforming   students’  

learning  therefore  help  them  enable  to  power  an  information-­‐based  society.    

 

The  goal  to  enrich  and  transform  the  country’s  traditional  learning  environment  to  

the  21st  century  classroom  is  part  of   the  country’s  strategic  master  plan   for   ICT   in  

education.   It   started   in  1997  and   is  now  on   its   third  and   final  phase.   Self-­‐directed  

learning   (SDL)   is   one   of   the   key   concepts   of   this   third   master   plan.   Singapore  

realizes  that  today’s  learners  must  possess  new  set  of  skills  and  values  essential  to  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

7  

thrive   in   the   21st   century   environment   and   integrating   a   technological   device   in  

their  learning  curriculum  will  help  meet  the  goal  (MOE,  2008).  

“A nation’s wealth in the 21st century will depend on the capacity of its people to learn.” Singapore’s Former Prime Minister, Goh Chok Tong

   

Engaging the Millennial Learners  

 

According   to   Historians   Neil   Howe   and   William   Strauss,   today’s   generation   of  

learners,   referred   to  as   ‘millennial   learners’   -­‐  have  unique  preferences   in   learning,  

attributed   to   the   technological   and   economic   implications   of   the   Internet.   It   is  

generally  accepted  that  millennial  learners  are  those  born  between  1982  and  2004.  

They   have   unique   attitudes,   behaviors,   learning   preferences   and   approaches   that  

widely   differ   from   those   past   generations.   Since   they   are   more   experiential   and  

exploratory,  there  is  a  need  to  provide  them  with  a  variety  of  learning  methods  and  

an  environment  to  help  them  perform  better  in  class  (Howe  &  Strauss,  2000).    

 

Restructuring Education System for the 21st Century

 

What  the  education  system  needs  is  a  new  framework  for  the  development  of  such  

essential   skills,   values   and   competencies   for   our   millennial   learners.   Such  

framework   offers   learners   enhanced   critical   thinking,   information   and  

communication   skills,   creativity   and   resilience   to   be   able   to   compete   under   this  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

8  

global  economy.  The  education  system  needs  to  be  redesigned  in  such  a  way  that  it  

will  appropriately  meet  the  needs  of  students  today.  

   

Contextual  Lifelong  Learning  (COLL)  &  Self-­‐Regulated  Learning  (SRL)  

Gut   and   Wan   (2011),   observed   and   stated   that   formal   education   is   no   longer  

sufficient   in   the  modern  world.  The  existing   formal  education  system  focuses  only  

on  acquisition  of  knowledge  and  not  so  much  on  the  development  of  skills.  It  needs  

to   adopt   variety   in   methods   of   learning.   Moreover,   students’   basic   skills   that   are  

developed  from  traditional  classrooms  are  no  longer  sufficient  in  this  era  of  literacy.  

A  nationwide  poll  of  registered  voters  in  the  United  States  reveals  that  a  majority  of  

Americans  believe  that  students  skills  needed  20  years  ago  are  different  from  those  

needed  now  to  help  them  prepare  for  the  21st  century  jobs  (The  Partnership  for  the  

21st  Century  Skills,  2007).    

 

Basically,   a   formal   education   can   no   longer   provide   students  with   the   knowledge  

and  skills  they  need  to  succeed.  Cross  (2005)  mentioned  that  only  twenty  percent  of  

skills  needed   in  a   job   is  acquired   from   formal  education.  People   therefore  need   to  

continually  enhance  their  skills  and  drive  their  professional  development  to  be  able  

to   address   immediate   complicated   problems;   thus,   a   need   to   develop   contextual  

lifelong  learning  (Sharples,  2000).    

 

The  Japanese  Ministry  of  Education,  Culture,  Sports,  Science  and  Technology  (MEXT,  

2000)  stated:  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

9  

“In  order  to  create  an  enriching  and  dynamic  society   in  the  21st  century,   it   is  

vital   to   form   a   lifelong   learning   society   in   which   people   can   freely   choose  

learning   opportunities   at   any   time   during   their   lives   and   in   which   proper  

recognition  is  accorded  to  those  learning  achievements.”  

 

Elwa  (2001–2003)   states   that   The   European   Commission   has   defined   lifelong  

learning  as:  

All  purposeful   learning  activity,  undertaken  on  an  ongoing  basis  with  the  aim  

of  improving  knowledge,  skills  and  competence.  

 

Scanlon,   Jones  and  Waycott   (2005)  emphasize   the  pedagogical  potential  of  mobile  

technology  to  create  an  opportunity   for   learning  on  the  move.   Informal   learning   is  

learning  that  is  not  confined  nor  restricted  to  a  classroom  or  formal  setting;  learners  

have   control   over   their   own   learning.   This   is  what   is   referred   to   as   self-­‐regulated  

learning   (SRL).   SRL   allows   for   an   informal   setting   that   offer   students   freedom   to  

learn   on   their   own,   at   their   own   pace.   This   has   been   found   to  motivate   students  

better;   it   also   allows   them   to   more   actively   participate   as   they   enjoy   learning  

naturally.   Livingston   (2000)   states   that   informal   learning   is   an   effective  means   of  

acquiring  both  knowledge  and  skills.   In  addition,  students  who  actively  participate  

in   class   are  more   able   to   sustain   their   interest   and   curiosity   in   learning   (Koh  and  

Looi,  2010).    

 

(Gibbons,   2002)   states   that   in   self-­‐directed   learning   (SDL),   the   learner   takes   the  

initiative   and   responsibility   for   what   occurs.   Learners   select,   manage,   and   assess  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

10  

their   own   learning   activities,   which   can   be   pursued   at   any   time,   in   any   place,  

through   any   means,   at   any   age.   Teaching   emphasizes   SDL   skills,   processes,   and  

systems   rather   than   content   coverage   and   tests.   For   the   individual,   SDL   involves  

initiating  personal  challenge  activities  and  developing  personal  qualities   to  pursue  

them  successfully.  Furthermore,  self-­‐directed   learning  potentially   leads   learners  to  

higher  academic  achievement  (Zimmerman,  1989).    

 

Winnie,   et   al.   (2006)   suggested   in   a   study   that  mobile   technologies   help   students  

develop   better   learning   strategies   and   regulate   their   own   learning   process.  

Hammond   (2006)   describes   in   her   study   that   students   are  most   successful   when  

they  are  taught  how  to   learn  as  well  as  what  to   learn.  Using  modern  technology  for  

lifelong  and  self-­‐regulated  learning  is  an  effective  instructional  approach  to  develop  

learners’  cognitive  skills  and  competencies.  

Theoretical Framework

The   “Self-­‐Regulated   Learning   Theory”   (SRL)   and   the   Heutagogy   or   “A   Child   of  

Complexity  Theory”  are  the  two   learning  theories  applied   in   this  study.  These  two  

theories  are  believed  to  define  the  characteristics  of  21st  century  education.    

 

Barry  Zimmerman  is  a  distinguished  professor  emeritus  of  educational  psychology  

who   pioneered   the   SRL   theory.   In   the   academic   context,   self-­‐regulation   is   an  

approach  where  students  exercise   their  own  skills,  manage  motivations  and  adopt  

strategies  in  order  to  achieve  more.  Such  refer  to  learners’  self-­‐generated  thoughts,  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

11  

ideas  and  feelings.  Zimmerman  stated  that  as  students  grow  and  progress,  they  also  

need   to   take  greater   responsibility   for   their  own   learning.   SRL   theory  emphasizes  

students’   ability   to   have   control   and   accountability   over   their   own   learning.   This  

helps  students  to  become  more  self-­‐reflective  and  evaluative.    

 

Heutagogy  is  another  theory  applied  to  this  study.  Chris  Kenyon  and  Stewart  Hase  

introduced   this   recent   theory,   which   is   an   approach   to   learning   that   emphasizes  

student   self-­‐directedness   in   information  discovery.   It   refers   to   the   concept  of   self-­‐

determined  learning,  which  means  that  people  inherently  know  how  to  learn.      

 

The   advent   of  modern   technology   and   outburst   of   information   have   caused   rapid  

change   in   our   society.   With   this   transformation   in   society,   a   more   innovative  

approach   to   learning   is   essential.   It   is   believed   that   such   two   theories   are  

appropriate  to  the  needs  of  learners  in  this  21st  century.  

 

Methodology

 

The   study   applied   a   qualitative   research   approach   using   Focus   Group   Discussion  

(FGD).   Four   groups   of   students,   with   each   group   having   three   or   four   members,  

participated   in   the   discussion.   The   participants   are   secondary   three   pupils   of  

Convent   of   the   Holy   Infant   Jesus   (CHIJ),   an   all-­‐girls   school   in   Singapore,   which  

recently  started   integrating  smartphones  and  other  electronic  media  devices   in   its  

curriculum.   The   girls   are   aged   15   to   16   years   old   and   are   all   smartphone   users.  

Informal  group  discussions  and  face-­‐to-­‐face  interviews  were  conducted  using  open-­‐

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

12  

ended  probe  questions  (Appendix).  The  discussion  was  conducted  during  a  school  

holiday  when  some  secondary  three  pupils  were  gathered  in  school  for  group  exam  

review.  The  interview  was  held  in  the  school  canteen  and  discussion  lasted  for  30-­‐

40  minutes  per  group.  Responses   from  interviews  were   transcribed  and   interview  

transcripts  were  analyzed  using  “open  coding.”    

 

An   informal   interview   was   also   conducted   with   a   primary   school   teacher   in  

Singapore.   The   interviewee   allows   in   class   the   use   of   YouTube   videos   via  

smartphone  to  show  students  visual  presentations  of  some  topics  for  discussions.    

 

Peer-­‐reviewed   research   articles   from   the   e-­‐resources   of   the   National   Library   of  

Singapore   were   also   used   to   gather   other   relevant   data   and   information.   An  

extensive  information  search  from  books  and  other  related  literature  reviews  were  

rigorously  analyzed.   It  also  entails  complex  reasoning  and  focus  on  the  context   for  

the  data  to  be  meaningfully  interpreted.  

Results & Discussion

This  section  analyzes  the  results  and  findings  from  the  focus  group  discussions.  The  

pupils  were   able   to  provide   the   researcher  with   significant   information   related   to  

the   study   topic.   It   discusses   the   benefits   of   smartphone   and   its   importance   in   the  

development  of  essential  skills  for  students  to  thrive  in  this  21st  century.  

 

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

13  

All   secondary   three   pupils   from   CHIJ   use   smartphones   in   their   class   learning.  

Biology,   English   and   Mathematics   are   the   subjects   where   such   technology   is  

integrated  in  lessons.  The  school  allows  their  pupils  to  bring  such  device  subject  to  

rules  and  restrictions  on  the  use  of  such  technology  inside  the  classroom.  There  are  

closets  provided  for  each  student  to  keep  their  smartphone  when  not  in  use  in  class.    

The  school’s  wireless  network  (Wi-­‐Fi)   is  accessible   to  students  only  during  school  

hours.    

 

How  are  the  Students  Today?  

The   researcher   asked   the   pupils   to   describe   themselves   as   students   and   contrast  

themselves   against   students   of   previous   generations.   Below   is   a   table   that   shows  

significant  or  dominant  responses  from  the  participants:  

Description   Detail  

More  inquisitive  and  smarter   • So   many   things   to   learn   and   many  answers  available  

• Schools   want   students   to   have  holistic  education    

Hard-­‐working     • Education  is  a  must    • Studies  is  the  only  way  to  survive    

Competitive   • Higher   expectation   from   both  parents  and  teachers  

• Need   to   compete   to   be   valued   and  accepted  

Stressed  and  Tired   • School   wants   students   to   learn   so  much  

• A   need   to   hear   and   know   so   many  things  around  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

14  

• Need  to  meet  expectations  

Techy  /  Savvy   • Must  be  well-­‐rounded  person  • Must   adapt   to   changing   technology  

and  environment  

Independent   • Must   work   on   own,   not   dependent  on  teachers  nor  parents  or   tutors  at  all  time  

• Must   constantly   work   on   own  assignments   and   tasks   even   when  parents  or  teachers  are  not  around  

• Students  can  and  will  find  answers  

 

Millennial   learners   indeed   have   unique   attitudes   and   behaviors,   learning  

preferences   and   approaches.   Most   of   the   participants   describe   themselves   as  

stressed   and   tired   students.   Singapore   is   a   nation   with   a   very   competitive  

environment.  The  society  and  even  the  educational  system  move  at  a  very  fast  pace.  

The  government  emphasizes  academic  performance;  thus,  students  work  and  strive  

hard   for   high   academic   achievements   and   competition.   Smartphone   is   a   very  

effective  technology  that  students  use  in  support  to  working  on  their  projects,  and  

assignments   and   meeting   their   deadlines   in   school.   Stress   in   accomplishing   all  

learning  tasks  is  alleviated  when  they  have  the  information  and  materials  on  hand  

provided  by  such  technology.  A  less  stressful  environment  will  better  help  students  

learn  and  acquire  knowledge  and  skills.      

 

Moreover,  students  find  themselves  to  be  more  inquisitive  and  smarter.  They  enjoy  

and   are   more   inspired   and   interested   to   learn   given   the   wealth   of   available  

information.  However,  they  feel  the  need  to  gain  more  knowledge.  Smartphones  can  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

15  

indeed   provide   huge   variety   of   knowledge   in   just   a   click   or   tap.   Not   only   does   it  

provide   knowledge;   given   a   vast   ocean   of   information,   it   helps   students   to   apply  

critical  thinking  in  order  to  identify  valid  or  reliable  information.    

 

 

Furthermore,   today’s   students’   main   interest   revolves   around   multimedia  

technology.   Information,   media   and   technical   skilled   people   are   crucial   to   run   a  

business.  Our  society  driven  technology  calls  for  people  who  are  willing  to  explore  

on   technologies.   Smartphone   provides   a   variety   of   applications   that   students   can  

technically   explore   and   traverse   therefore,   developing   their   creativity   and  

innovative  skills.  

 

The   need   for   students   to   be   hardworking   to   meet   the   school   and   societies’  

expectations   compels   them   to   work   on   things   independently.   Situations   provide  

them   opportunities   to   attain   things   on   their   own.     Smartphone   provides   self-­‐

directed   learning,   helps   and   supports   students   in   search   for   problems   solutions,  

further  thoughts  and  ideas  thus,  not  suppressing  their  creativity.    

 

How  is  Smartphone  Used  in  their  Learning?  

The  participant  pupils  were  asked  of  the  ways  they  use  smartphone  in  classes.  The  

table  below  shows   their   responses  on   the   features  or  services   that   the   technology  

provides  in  support  to  their  learning:  

 

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

16  

Smartphone  Features/Services   Function/Use  

Edmodo,  Socrative  (learning  applications)   • Post   teachers’   instructional   videos,  links  or  photos    

• Post   assigned   quizzes,   assignments  and   other   random   information  related  to  topic  discussions  

• Post   students’   comments   and   other  replies  to  teachers’  posts  

Short   messaging   service   (SMS)   &  

Electronic   mail   (e-­‐mail),   WhatsApp  

messenger  

• Post   teacher’s   updates,   reminders  and      assignments      

• Post   school   and   class  announcements  

• Set   appointments   with   teachers   for  any   questions   or   clarifications   on  related  topic  discussions  

Dictionary/Thesaurus  Application   • Reference   used   when   writing  compositions  

Video  Recording  &  Camera   • Projects  and  assignments  

Web  browser  and  Internet  search  engine   • Research  projects  and  assignments  

 

         Edmodo  Learning  Application                        Socrative  Learning  Application  

 

The   above   smartphone   features   and   services   provide   tremendous   support   in  

students’   learning.  The  students  can   freely  post  questions,  answers  and  comments  

on   related   topic   discussions   using   available   learning   applications   like   Edmodo,  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

17  

Socrative   and   even   the   popular   WhatsApp   messenger.   Normally,   there   are   class  

recitations  where  teachers  would  throw  in  questions  and  students  are  expected  to  

raise  hands  and  provide  answers.  The  smartphone  is  the  teacher’s  newest  platform  

to  engage  students  and  gain  an  indication  of  how  well  they  have  grasped  the  lessons.  

It  provides  students  an  opportunity  to  freely  and  confidently  convey  answers,  ideas  

and  opinions  related  to  class  topic  discussions.  Students  are  able  to  contribute  and  

participate   more   when   they   do   not   have   to   speak   up   in   class,   as   some   pupils  

discussed   fear   of  wrong   answers   and   embarrassment  when   they  do   so.     Although  

they  are  still  expected  to  write  their  replies  in  a  formal  manner,  most  of  the  pupils  

said  they  find  it  more  comfortable  that  they  do  not  have  to  face  their  teachers  when  

doing  so.  They   find  such   form  of   learning   to  be   less   formal  compared   to   the  usual  

recitation   in   a   classroom   setting.   In   addition,   not   only   are   pupils   given   more  

opportunity   to   work   together   and   learn   from   various   perspectives,   they   become  

more   open   to   huge   variety   of   shared   ideas   and   learning.   They   find   themselves  

providing  support  to  one  another.    Other  smartphone  services  like  short  messaging  

service   (SMS)   and   email   also   provide   easier   communication   and   efficient  

coordination   between   students   and   teachers.   Prompt   replies   allow   both   students  

and   teachers   to   save   a   lot   of   time.   Everyone   is  more   accessible   or   can   be  mostly  

reached  anytime,  even  during  weekends  and  school  holidays.    

 

Students  use  the  smartphone  web  browser  and  Internet  search  engines  to  search  for  

answers   to   their   assignments.   “Not   all   answers   can   be   found   in   our   textbooks,”  

according  to  one  student.  Before,  there  were  only  books  and  textbooks  to  refer  to;  in  

the  present,  the  Internet  provides  students  information  just  “one  click  away.”  Search  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

18  

engines   like   Google   are   widely   used   as   gateways   to   a   multitude   of   information  

resources.   In  addition,   the   Internet  also  makes  available  videos  and  news  updates.  

Such  features  of  smartphone  provide  them  with  easy  access  to  an  immense  wealth  

of  information  and  knowledge,  anytime  and  anywhere.    

 

Students   also   find   other   smartphone   features   like   camera   photography,   voice   and  

video   recording   to   be   very   useful   especially   when   it   comes   to   making   projects.  

Creating  projects  that  required  photography  and  recording  used  to  require  students  

to  have  access  to  expensive  and  bulky  equipment;  now,  they  only  need  to  use  their  

own  smartphone.  This  helps  them  create  projects  more  effectively  and  efficiently.  

 

Applications   that   provide   online   references   such   as   dictionary   and   thesaurus  

functionality   are   also   used   in   class.   These   resources   are   regularly   updated   by   the  

companies  that  produce  them,  saving  students  from  the  expense  of  buying  updated  

materials  and  the  burden  of  carrying  heavy  books.    

 

How  Are  Skills  Developed?  

The  pupils  were  presented  with   the   list   of   skills   identified  by  The  Partnership   for  

21st  Century  Skills.  Together,  they  identified  which  of  these  skills  they  were  able  to  

develop  using  the  smartphone  as  learning  support.  Initially,  participants  seemed  to  

have  a  hard  time  furnishing  answers.  They  all  mentioned  that  smartphones  mainly  

provide   them   support   in   learning.   A   few   students,   however,   specified   critical  

thinking,   communication   and   collaboration.   Others   even  mentioned   that   personal  

values  like  respect  and  politeness  are  also  enhanced.    

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

19  

 

The   smartphone-­‐enabled   curriculum   enhances   critical   thinking   because   it  

promotes  independent  learning.  Students  learn  to  think  and  manage  tasks  on  their  

own.   As   quizzes,   assignments,   projects   and   even   random   questions   on   topics   are  

sent  and  posted  via  students’  smartphones,  they  can  work  on  it  anytime  they  want  

to.   Thus,   learning   is   not   confined   to   the   classroom.   Since   students   cannot   rely   on  

teachers,  parents  and  tutors  most  of  the  time,  smartphone  applications  and  search  

engines  can  more  consistently  assist  them  in  their  learning.    

 

The   smartphone-­‐enabled   curriculum   also   helps   develop   students’   collaboration  

skills.  Students  are  better  able  to  work  together  on  tasks  given  by  teachers  and  they  

find  themselves  more  willing  to  participate.  Email  and  messaging  applications  make  

it  easier   for  students   in  separate   locations  to  communicate  and  coordinate  as   they  

work  on  their  assignments  and  projects.  

 

Students   also   agreed   that   the   technology-­‐enabled   curriculum   helps   in   enhancing  

their  written  communication  skills.  Students  are  expected  to  post  their  answers  in  

a  formal  manner.  They  also  get  to  learn  from  the  way  their  teachers  and  co-­‐learners  

compose  their  statements.    

 

Students   are   given   rules   on   how   to   communicate   online.   They   are   taught  what   is  

acceptable  and  what  is  not,  when  it  comes  to  electronic  communication.  Adherence  

to  these  rules  helps  instill  values  of  respect  and  politeness  in  students.  

 

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

20  

Potential  Danger  

When  a  primary  teacher  was  asked  of  how  she  feels  about  the  use  of  smartphone  in  

class,  the  interviewee  expressed  a  more  balanced  response.  

 

“Presenting   learning   audio   visuals   or   information   links   to   students   in   class   is  

actually   more   engaging   for   everyone,”   the   teacher   noted.   On   one   hand,   once  

students  use  any  gadget  or  technology  as  they  learn,  they  seem  more  interested  to  

listen  and  participate  in  class  topic  discussions.  Although  the  teacher  does  not  need  

to  speak  more  as  links  and  visuals  do  more  of  the  presentation,  students  are  more  

engaged  once  questions   are   thrown   in.  On   the  other  hand,   the   teacher  mentioned  

that   there   is   a   possibility   that   students   might   eventually   become   bored   with   the  

conventional   type   of   learning   that   is   still   being   practiced   most   of   the   time   in   the  

classroom.   Students   might   just   most   of   the   time   interact   more   with   their   own  

gadgets  and  rely  on  what  this  powerful  tool  could  offer.  When  this  happens,  they  are  

less   likely   to   be   interested   to   learn   using   conventional   tools   such   as   books   and  

paper.    

 

Conclusion

Today,  modern  technology  has  made  available  massive  amounts  of  information  and  

knowledge.  Learners  therefore  need  to  possess  higher  critical  thinking  skills  to  help  

them  identify   information   that   is  authentic  and  reliable,  and  be  able   to  reuse  such  

information   and   form   their   own   knowledge.   Students   must   also   know   how   to  

develop   their   own   opinion   and   communicate   it   to   others   in   an   effective   and  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

21  

confident  manner.  These  skills  are  crucial  to  help  them  succeed  and  perform  well  as  

an  individual.    

 

 

 

Smartphone  technology  offers  the  opportunity  for  students  to  interact  with  teachers  

and  fellow  learners  freely  and  acquire  knowledge  regardless  of  place  and  time.  The  

smartphone  enables   students   to   learn   in   an   informal   yet  unlimited  way   similar   to  

what  lifelong  learning  fosters.  As  a  communication  tool,  it  provides  students  with  an  

opportunity   to   confidently   engage   in   discussions   as   they   learn   naturally.   Studies  

show  that  students  see  a  less  formal  learning  environment  as  less  threatening;  thus,  

they   engage   or   participate   more   in   class.   In   addition,   it   allows   students   to   take  

responsibility   and   control   over   their   own   learning.   Self-­‐regulated   learning   allows  

learners   to  exercise  and  enhance   their   inert   skills,  motivate   themselves  and  adopt  

their  own  strategies,  thus  helping  them  become  critical  and  creative  thinkers.    

 

Using  the  smartphone  in  education  has  the  potential  to  create  a  conducive  learning  

environment.   It   enhances   students’   communication   and   collaboration   skills.   The  

portability,   information   storage   capacity,   computing   power   and   convenience   that  

the  smartphone  provides  give  learners  access  to  more  information  than  they  could  

with  traditional  learning.  Students  are  able  to  think  out  of  the  box  and  become  more  

creative  and  innovative  as  they  explore  on  their  own  strategies  and  capabilities.  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

22  

Recommendation

   

With   the   transformation   in  our   society,   a  more   innovative  approach   to   learning   is  

essential.  Brown  (2005)  suggested  a  shift  from  a  knowledge  production  paradigm  to  

a   knowledge   navigation   paradigm.   Traditionally,   the   education   system   is   teacher-­‐

centric,  with   teachers   solely   in   control   of   knowledge   to   be   passed   on   to   students.    

Today,   a   learner-­‐centric   approach   is   what   our   education   system   needs.   In   this  

approach,  students  themselves  determine  how  learning  should  take  place,  enabling  

greater  development  of  one’s  independence,  motivation  and  learning  capacity.    They  

learn   to  navigate  by   themselves   amidst   the   sea  of   knowledge,  with   teachers   in   an  

assisting   role.   Furthermore,   students   are   more   likely   to   attain   higher   academic  

achievement  when  they  are  in  control  and  engaged  in  their  own  learning.    

 

Smartphone   technology   is   the   enabler   that  makes   the   learner-­‐centric   approach   to  

education   possible.   Students   learn   best   with   variety   in   learning   methods.   The  

technology  helps  them  with  the  development  and  enhancement  of   important  skills  

they  need  to  thrive  in  today’s  complex  environment.    

 

It   is  without  a  doubt   that   learners  need   to  be   ready   for   the  global   economy.  They  

will   only   be   ready   if   they   possess   the   core   competencies   of   lifelong   and   self-­‐

regulated   learning,   collaboration,   effective   communication   and   right   motivation.  

These  universal  competencies  will  help  them  learn,  and  continue  to  learn,  far  more  

efficiently   and   effectively.   The   smartphone   is   advanced   technology   that   provides  

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

23  

support   in   the   acquisition   of   knowledge   and   skills   students   need   to   be   able   to  

succeed  in  this  generation.    

 

References

Singapore National Library Board (NLB)

E-Books Quinn, C.N. (2011). Tapping Into the Mobile Revolution for Organization Performaces. Retrieved from http://site.ebrary.com.libproxy.nlb.gov.sg/lib/singaporenatlib/docDetail.action?docID=10441389 Hayes, H. (2010). Curriculum 21: Essential Education for a Changing World. Retrieved from http://site.ebrary.com.libproxy.nlb.gov.sg/lib/singaporenatlib/docDetail.action?docID=10379928 Gut, D. & Wan, M. (2011). Bringing Schools Into the 21st Century. Retrieved from http://web.ebscohost.com.libproxy.nlb.gov.sg/ehost/ebookviewer/ebook/nlebk_371095_AN?sid=a9ad9a25-7a64-4d88-90f6-8571d394287f@sessionmgr115&vid=1&format=EB&rid=1 Web Documents & Sites Waycott, J., Jones, A., & Scanlon, E. (2005). PDAs as Lifelong Learning Tools: An Activity Theory Based Analysis. Retrieved from http://www.tlu.ee/~kpata/haridustehnoloogiaTLU/pda_s.pdf Koh, E., & Looi, C.K. (2011). An Implementation of Smartphone-enabled Seamless Learning: A Snapshot Perspective. Retrieved from http://www.lsl.nie.edu.sg/icce2012/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/C4-f-214.pdf Woodcook, B., Middleton, A., & Nortcliffe, A. (2012). Considering the Smartphone Learner: An Investigation Into Student Interest in the Use of Personal Technology to Enhance their Learning. Retrieved from http://research.shu.ac.uk/SEEJ/index.php/seej/article/view/38/Woodcock Norris, C., Hossain, A., & Soloway, E. (2011). Using Smartphones as Essential Tools for Learning. A Call to Place Schools on the Right Side of the 21st Century. Retrieved from http://cecs5580.pbworks.com/w/file/fetch/50303907/ET%2520article%2520Norris%2520Soloway.pdf

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

24  

Dillenbourg, P., Jarvela, S., & Fischer, F. (2009). The Evolution of Research on Computer - Supported Collaborative Learning. Retrieved from http://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F978-1-4020-9827-7_1#page-1 Wagner, E., (2005). Enabling Mobile Learning. Retrieved from http://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/erm0532.pdf Database

Zimmermann, B., (2008). Investigating Self-Regulation & Motivation: Historical Background, Methodological Development, and Future Prospects. Retrieved from ProQuest Dissertations & Theses. (200456437) Press Release

Ministry Of Education Singapore. (2008). MOE Launches 3rd Masterplan for ICT in Education. [Press Release]. Retrieved from http://www.moe.gov.sg/media/press/2008/08/moe-launches-third-masterplan.php Books Howe, N., & Strauss, W. (2000). Millennials Rising: The Next Great Generation. New York, United States. Totten, S., Sills, T., Digby, A., & Russ, P. (1991). Cooperative Learning: A Guide to Research. New York: Garland. Sharples, M., Taylor, J., & Vavoula, G. (2007). A Theory of Learning for the Mobile Age. The Sage Handbook of e-Learning Research. London: Sage, pp. 221-247.    

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

25  

   Photos  during  Focus  Group  Discussion      

 Group  1    

        Group  2      

Smartphones  in  Education  Cruz,  Maria  Victoria    

       

26  

 Group  3  

     

      Group  4