ROLE OF MASS MEDIA ON SOMALI POLITICS
-
Upload
jobkeyuniversity -
Category
Documents
-
view
3 -
download
0
Transcript of ROLE OF MASS MEDIA ON SOMALI POLITICS
1
ROLE OF MASS MEDIA ON SOMALI POLITICS
_____________________________________________
SUBMITTED BY
ILYAS MOHAMED ABDULKARIM
HK-MDIR-014/12
BIT, SU
_____________________________________
_____________________________________
A RESEARCH DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL
IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE AWARD OF
THE DEGREE OF MASTER INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS & DIPLOMACY
OF KAMPALA UNIVERSITY
OCTOBER 2014
2
DECLARATION A
I Ilyas Mohamed Abdulkarim declare this thesis is my original work and has not been
presented for a Degree or any other academic award in any university or Institution of
learning”
Signature: _____________________________________
Date: __________/_______/_______________________
3
APPROVAL
“I confirm that the work reported in this thesis was carried out by the candidate under
my/our supervision”.
Name and signature of Supervisor:
Date: ___________________________
4
DEDICATION
The researcher dedicates this thesis his parents Ubah Agane and Mohamed Abdulkarim,
with much love, for any effort and sacrifice they provided throughout my academic life and
career development and my respected friends for being supportive to me spiritua l ly,
emotionally, morally.
5
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First praise is due to Allah who made me this book possible to be completed.
Furthermore, the researcher would like to convey deep appreciation to Kampala Univers ity
and Hope University.
Likewise, the researcher thanks his supervisor Mrs. Monica A. Ssengendo, for the precious
advice, valuable comments, remarks and suggestion since starting of this research.
6
Table of Contents
DECLARATION A 2
APPROVAL 3
DEDICATION 4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 5
ABSTRACT 8
LIST OF TABLES AND FIGURES 10
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND 11
1.0 Introduction 11
1.1 Background to the Study 11
1.2 Statement of Problem 14
1.3 Purpose of the Study 15
1.4 Objectives of the Study 15
1.4.1 Major Objectives: 15
1.4.2 Specific Objectives: 15
1.5 Research Questions 15
1.6 Scope of the Study 16
1.6.1 Content Scope 16
1.6.2 Geographical Scope 16
1.6.3 Time scope 16
1.7 Definition of Key Terms 16
1.8 Significance of the Study 17
1.9 Theoretical Framework 18
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW 20
2.0 The Role of the Media in Peace Building, Conflict Management, and Prevention 20
2.1 Relationship between Media and Politics 23
2.2 Politics and Journalism 24
2.3 Shaping the Political Agenda 25
2.4 Freedom of Speech 26
2.5 Role of Mass Media in today’s world 27
7
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCHMETHODOLOGY 31
3.0 Introduction 31
3.1 Research Design 31
3.2 Study Area and Population 31
3.3 Sample techniques 32
3.3.1 Sampling Procedure 33
3.4 Validity and Reliability of the Instrument 33
3.5 Data Collection Methods 33
3.6 Data Analysis and Interpretation 34
3.7 Ethical Considerations 35
3.8 Limitation of the Study 35
CHAPTER FOUR: DATA PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSIONS 37
4.1 Biographical Information 37
4.2 Analysis of Variables Based on Objectives 42
4.3 Interview Guide Discussions 52
CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSION, SUMMARIES CONCLUSIONS AND
RECOMMENDATIONS 54
5.1 Summary of Findings 54
5.2 Conclusion 56
5.3 Recommendations 57
5.4 Suggestions for Further Research 57
REFERENCES 58
APPENDIX I: QUESTIONNAIRE 61
APPENDIX II: INTERVIEW QUESTIONS 64
8
ABSTRACT
The theme of this research is all the role of media on the political situations in Somalia;
mass media has been very active in the essence of political plays in the country, this research
illustrates the relationship between them and the implication of their correlations.
Journalists face many problems from both the government of Somalia as they are detained
and accused of poor referenced broadcast of news and the assassinations from militants of
Alshabab for the unfavorable news they provide to the public in any channel, this makes in
Somalia a very red area that the being a journalist one of the riskiest jobs in the country and
in particularly.
The objectives of this research is disseminate the effects of Somali Media on the politica l
stabilization, good governance and economic development, in addition to determine the
relationship between the media and politics in Somalia. Moreover, to inaugurate methods,
strategies and means of using media to best stabilize the political situation in Somalia.
The findings of the research include that lack of national policy and unprofessional media
workers caused the relationship between the media and the politicians more insignificant
nowadays; this made the killing of journalists in Somalia and in particularly Mogadishu
more acquainted and familiar. Furthermore, training and seminars on capacity building
programs for the journalists are needed to build the capacity of the media. Journalists face
many problems from both the government of Somalia as they are detained and accused of
poor referenced broadcast of news and the assassinations from militants of Alshabab for the
unfavorable news they provide to the public in any channel, this makes in Somalia a very
red area that the being a journalist one of the riskiest jobs in the country and in particular ly
Mogadishu.
Media in Somalia has been in anarchism role of for two decades and half, they seldom
contain nationalist and those who know the goodness of good governance and systems,
therefore the need for training courses to reinforce these fellows are crucial. However, the
need for national policy plan that guides the relationship is vital.
10
LIST OF TABLES AND FIGURES
Table 1: Selection of Sample size.
Table 2: Age Distribution of the Respondents
Table 3: Gender of the Respondents
Table 4: Marital Status of the Respondents
Table 5: Education Level of the Respondents
Table 6: Experience of the Participants
Table 7: Occupation of Respondents
Table 8: Level in the Organization
Table 9: Objective One Table
Table 10: Objective Two Table
Table 11: Objective Three Table
Table 12: Objective Four Table
11
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND
1.0 Introduction
This research dissertation titled the role of mass media on Somali politics; it focuses on the
relationship between the two parties of journalists and the politicians, the effects of media
on the political stabilizations, and the role of media on good governance, economic
development, peace process, conflict resolutions and community mobilization and
awareness to the security, health and environmental factors
While press freedom is only one among many civil and political liberties, the historica l
contribution of the press to democracy merits special attention. Around the world, the media
has historically played a vital role in social transformation and political liberalisa t ion
through the exercise of two principal functions: informing the public of matters of public
interest and serving as a watchdog of government. Access to information enables the public
to make informed choices, to actively participate in decision-making processes and to assess
the performance of their leaders: essential elements of a functioning democracy.
So critical are these functions to the healthy functioning of the body politic that freedom of
opinion and expression including the right to “receive and impart information and ideas
through any media and regardless of frontiers” is enshrined in Article 19 of the Universa l
Declaration of Human Rights, and further guaranteed by the constitutions of most
democratic states.
1.1 Background to the Study
Somalis are accustomed to such a well-preserved pattern of freedoms. Liberty of speech and
movement were inherent in their traditional nomadic livelihood, and their egalitar ian
political culture was famously described as a “pastoral democracy.” Even the colonial
powers were careful not to antagonize the Somalis by excessively restricting their free
expression and movement. It was firmly and repeatedly drummed into serving colonial
officers in Somalia that nothing should be done that might seriously antagonize the local
population. (Lewis, 1994).
12
Media of Somalia includes various radio, television, print and internet outlets. The federal
government operates two official radio and TV networks, which exist alongside a number
of private and foreign stations. Print media in the country is progressively giving way to
news radio stations and online portals, as internet connectivity and access increases. In
February 2013, the Ministry of Information, Posts and Telecommunication also launched a
broad-based consultative process for the reformation of media legislation, while in August
2014 the legislation has been passed by the Council of Ministers. Zakaria F. (2013)
There are a number of radio news agencies based in Somalia. Radio is the most important
and effective communication channel in the country and the most popular type of mass
media. In total, about one short-wave and over ten private FM radio stations broadcast from
the capital, with several radio stations broadcasting from the central and southern regions
and from Puntland. Zakaria F. (2013)
In the early 2000s, print media in Somalia reached a peak in activity. Around 50 newspapers
were published in Mogadishu alone during this period, including Qaran, Mogadishu Times,
Sana'a, Shabelle Press, Ayaamaha, Mandeeq, Sky Sport, Goal, The Nation, Dalka,
Panorama, Aayaha Nolosha, Codka Xuriyada and Xidigta Maanta. In 2003, as new free
electronic media outlets started to proliferate, advertisers increasingly began switching over
from print ads to radio and online commercials in order to reach more customers. A number
of the broadsheets in circulation subsequently closed down operations, as they were no
longer able to cover printing costs in the face of the electronic revolution. In 2012, the
political Xog Doon and Xog Ogaal and Horyaal Sports were reportedly the last remaining
newspapers printed in the capital. Street, J. (2001)
It is an undisputable fact that the media plays an integral role in the way we, society, view
daily politics and the politicians. Somalis spend almost a full day each week watching
television, listening radios and reading websites or newspapers. This is an obvious
indication that people rely heavily on the information portrayed in the news. In an age where
the popularization of television and other media sources has dominated the information
scene, it is hard to know if the information you are receiving is from reliable and unbiased
13
sources, due to the last couple of decades war and anarchy experienced by the state, Street,
J. (2001)
In democratic societies, mass media have been defined as the "fourth power" because of
their social influence and their function as a counterbalance to possible abuses by the other
powers. In this sense, the media are seen as a tool for invigorating the democratic health of
a country. The media plays an important part in influencing public policy by influenc ing
our thoughts and opinions about what we feel is important. It also influences our opinions
on how the problems should be solved and pressures politicians into implementing new laws
and programs in order to meet our needs. Zioutos, G. (1954)
According to Zioutos, G. (1954), media and politics are in a tense relationship in a
functioning democracy. Despite their divergent missions, it is a symbiotic correlation.
Political forces turn to the public to motivate their actions, to campaign for their ideas and
to win people’s trust. Media, in turn, have to inform people about politics and to exercise
control over politicians when the latter perform their duties. They need each other and, at
the same time, they benefit from each other. Without access to current affairs, media would
be deprived of topics to cover, and without media, politicians would hardly find a way to
the people. Both players have to be aware of their roles and to live up to them. The
politicians have to correctly communicate their public activity to the people.
What they mostly need is trust. Making good policy alone is not enough. Of no less
importance is the skilful public presentation of goals, decisions and achievements. Only
those who are familiar with the rules of media democracy and know how to apply them
would survive as politicians and win majorities. With this communication missing, the
image of the political institutions would be distorted and prejudices would be reinforced
(Street, J.2001).
It becomes critical when politicians try to erect a media façade, to instrumentalize media
and even to manipulate them. At this juncture, media are called upon as watchdog and
corrective. For this task to be accomplished, free and independent media are required. The
status and plurality of media are vital for the quality of the democratic public because the
14
level of citizens’ awareness and the public opinion are largely shaped by the media.
Therefore, it is even more imperative to ensure press freedom and transparency of the media
structures, to guarantee fair working conditions for journalists, to counteract partisanship
and corruption in media and to provide for plurality of views and the free formation of
opinion. The relationship between politics and media thus lies at the core of democracy.
This relationship needs constant rebalancing. Highest transparency and a permanent critical
evaluation are of utmost importance. Despite their interdependence, the demarcation line
between them must be maintained. We need a sensible balance between media and politics
for the sake of democratic society. This holds true not only for transition countries like
Somalia but also for all free democratic policies (Garnham, N. (2000).
1.2 Statement of Problem
Somalia has been on an anarchy for the past two decades, this brought substantia l ly
lawlessness/uncontrolled media containing radios, TVs, Newspapers and Websites
providing out defectively and relatively weak edited news that sometimes target directly
towards some politicians/ social workers. Despite this, some of the reports that the media
provides can to a large extent rub the wrong way and offend some target politicians thus
with the result to that they may use extra powers to the media and fracture the freedom of
speech. Zakaria F. (2008)
Journalists face many problems from both the government of Somalia as they are detained
and accused of poor referenced broadcast of news and the assassinations from militants of
Alshabab for the unfavorable news they provide to the public in any channel, this makes in
Somalia a very red area that the being a journalist one of the riskiest jobs in the country and
in particularly Mogadishu.Zakaria F. (2008)).
Currently, Shabelle Media Network, Sky FM has been closed down by the government of
Somalia, and their chairmen has been detained and waiting for the court to review their
cases, while other local FM has experienced temporary suspension and pressure from the
militants and the government itself.
15
In this research dessertation, the researcher focused what is wrong with the media and define
the role of mass media on the politics of Somalia, the researcher will also look for obtaining
strategies that media should be safe from political effects and improve their relationship and
the role of media on politics without harm.
1.3 Purpose of the Study
The purpose of this study is to assess the role of media in Somali Politics.
1.4 Objectives of the Study
1.4.1 Major Objectives:
The objective of the study is to identify the role of Somali Media on Politics.
1.4.2 Specific Objectives: To be sought further study were as follows
1. To define the effects of Somali Media on the political stabilization, good governance
and economic development of Somalia.
2. To demonstrate the relationship between the media and politics in Somalia.
3. To establish methods, strategies and means of using media to best stabilize the
political situation in Somalia.
4. To utilize media’s positive broadcasting programs and minimize the side effects of
it on both politics and the entire society.
1.5 Research Questions
1. What are effects of Somali Media on the political stabilization, good governance and
economic development of Somalia?
2. What is the relationship between the media and politics in Somalia?
3. What are the methods, strategies and means of using media to best stabilize the
political situation in Somalia?
4. How can media’s positive broadcasting programs be utilized; and minimized the
side effects of it on both politics and the entire society?
16
1.6 Scope of the Study
1.6.1 Content Scope
The researcher has focused to explain deeply the role of media on the political stabilizat ions
and the general political situation of Somalia.
1.6.2 Geographical Scope
This study was conducted in Mogadishu where is the capital city of Somalia and has
enormously subsequently outnumbering media for the last decade.
1.6.3 Time scope
The research was conducted between the periods of 2009 to 2013. For the reason of
choosing this time scope is that, it is a period that the country got various political situations
that had a great impact generally on the society and in the media in particular.
1.7 Definition of Key Terms
Good Governance: Good governance refers to the management of government in a manner
that is essentially free of abuse and corruption, and with due regard for the rule of law.
Curran, J., Gurevitch, M. & Woollacott, J (eds) (1977)
Media: means of communication, as radio and television, newspapers,
and magazines, which reach or influence people widely. Deutsche Welle (2009)
Political Stability: Political stability is the durability and integrity of a current government
regime. This is determined based on the amount of violence and terrorism expressed in the nation
and by citizens associated with the state. A stable society is one that is satisfied with the ruling party
and system of operations and is not interested in revolutionary or despotic ideas.
A stable political scene is one where the ruling government is favored by the population and
does not experience strong indicators of social unrest. While there are problems within any
nation, and times of war or hardship are common, a stable political system is one that can
withstand these occurrences without major societal upheaval and ongoing endurance of
these circumstances.
17
Politics:The science of government; that part of ethics which has to do with the regulat ion
and government of a nation or state, the preservation of its safety, peace, and prosperity, the
defense of its existence and rights against foreign control or conquest, the augmentation of
its strength and resources, and the protection of its citizens in their rights, with the
preservation and improvement of their morals. David Brewer (2012)
The management of a political party; the conduct and contests of parties with reference to
political measures or the administration of public affairs; the advancement of candidates to
office; in a bad sense, artful or dishonest management to secure the success of politica l
candidates or parties; political trickery.
Social Responsibility: is an ethical theory that an entity, be it an organization or individua l,
has an obligation to act to benefit society at large. Social responsibility is a duty every
individual has to perform so as to maintain a balance between the economy and the
ecosystems. Hallin, D., Papathanasopoulos, S. (2002)
1.8 Significance of the Study
This study provides the information of the role of media and the political situation of
Somalia and tries to lighten up the current relationship between the government of Somalia
and the media.
The findings and recommendation of the study would be useful for academic institution and
public and the private media which deal with politics and good governance through reading
this thesis which will be available in public libraries and a printed copy would be available
for those participants that contributed in.
The study helps future researchers in this discipline to get father information that is useful
for understanding the relationship between the media and Somali politics, while it attempts
to create solid better relationship between the two sides.
To the researchers the study is a requirement for the partial fulfillment of the award of
Master of International Relations and Diplomacy at Kampala University.
18
1.9 Theoretical Framework
Few would argue with the notion that the institutions of the mass media are important to
contemporary politics. Yet the media are not just neutral observers but also political actors.
There are various theoretical approaches, which aim to tackle this relationship. To analyze
all different theories and schools is beyond the scope of this thesis.
Classical Marxism proposes an opposition between superstructure and economic base. A
Marxist tradition sees the media as integrated into the existing economic and political elites
and therefore reflecting their interests. The different schools of thought within Marxist
media theory are categorized and listed in three paradigms: structuralist, culturalist and
political economy (Gurevitch et all: 1982: 8).
Media political economy considers ideology as subordinate to the economic infrastruc ture
(Curran et all: 1982: 26). Graham Murdock and Peter Golding (1977) deem that a 'critical'
political economy approach' that locates the power of media in the economic processes and
structures of media production is the most important way to analyze the current and past
developments, such as ownership concentration, conglomeration and content of the media
systems. Noam Chomsky and Edward Herman (1988) see media as close to an instrument
of class domination, because of the interests of conglomerates are reflected in the
commercial press and the broadcasting outlets they control.
Street's (2005:18) proposes three theoretical schisms regarding the relationship between the
politics and the mass media. These are those represented bypluralism, constructivism and
structuralism. Pluralism, as a theoretical approach supports that media effects are limited
or improvable, the effects of watching television news and reading newspaper are largely
positive, that the mass media contribute positively to political knowledge (Norris: 2000:
212) and that the media act only as instrumental inter-mediaries between agents and the
options offered by the political system.
Constructivism sees the political world that it is re-constituted according to the conventions
of the medium in which it comes to exist; it is constructed as 'reality' by the media that
present and report it, a reality in which politics is a superficial game of appearances (Street:
2005: 23). Bob Franklin, for instance, regards that the spin doctors and advertising
19
executives were recruited by governments and parties to disempower citizens and to
diminish politics (Franklin: 1994). According to Street, Franklin approach could be located
within constructivism.
The third theoretical approach is that of structuralism. The development of the media has
to be understood as part of a larger process of state formation and capitalist development.
Garnham, for example, writes that all theories of the media rest upon historical theories as
to the process of the historical development of media institutions and practices and their
relationship to the development of modernity and its characteristic social structures and
practices' (Garnham: 2000:38). According to Street, Garnham represents an account of the
politics-mass media relationship that locates it within the structures of the political economy
that organize both (2005:29).
20
CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW
2.0 The Role of the Media in Peace Building, Conflict Management, and
Prevention
Information is power and insight can affect public discourse. This way, perceptions can be
changed by access to media. Different types of media are utilized globally to distribute
knowledge and idealistically, free mass media is a tool of and signpost for democracy.
Freedom of expression is not only the core of a healthy media but also a fundamental human
right and vital for a democratic structure. It stands for freedom of speech, the right to
information and the representation of different opinions in a heterogeneous society. In any
culture of prevention, effective and democratic media are an essential part and indispensab le
for societies trying to make a transition towards peace and democracy. Harry S. Truman
once said, “You can never get all the facts from just one newspaper, and unless you have all
the facts, you cannot make proper judgments about what is going on” Trueman, H. (2011).
This statement reflects the need for free access to unbiased information. Not giving people
the possibility of political participation and not allowing them to express themselves freely
is a significant cause of conflict. On the one hand free, independent and pluralistic media
provide a platform for debate and different opinions. On the other hand, media can be
misused for propaganda purposes, to incite hatred and spread rumours and therefore
artificially create tensions, Wolfsfeld, Gadi (2004).
The transmission of ideas is also not limited to conventional media such as newspapers, TV
or radio. Arguably, the traditional media takes primacy in this, however, new technologies,
the internet and digital content should also be considered in this context. Pankowski, Rafal
(2007). Lack of information can, at any stage of a conflict, make people desperate, restless
and easy to manipulate. The ability to make informed decisions strengthens societies and
fosters economic growth, democratic structures and the positive outlook on the future. For
this very reason, the United Nations Millennium Declaration stressed the need “to ensure
the freedom of the media to perform their essential role and the right of the public to have
access to information”.
21
Journalism does not need justification for its existence. Its service to society is justifica t ion
in itself. Journalism can not only help to distribute information but also counter hate-speech
and create an environment of balanced opinions, an information equilibrium. Koven, Ronald
(2004, For the media it can be problematic to find a balance between preventing harm
caused by speech and protecting individual expression. Being able to find this balance,
however is important especially in conflict situations. Responsible journalism does not just
re-publish press releases but is truly concerned with a truthful, balanced and fair account of
events. In order to achieve this journalists have to stay clear of judgemental representations
and describe reality without embellishment. If democracy is to work properly, society needs
access to news and information; analysis of the status quo, debate, practical information and
exchange as well as entertainment are needed and provided by the media. The definition of
conflict and defining conflict areas is not easy and no two places are alike. Journalists need
to know what they can expect on sight in order to define the objectives of their project.
Deutsche W. (2009).
In case of a crisis or a conflict, the international media can attract worldwide attention. The
mass media is a pervasive part of daily life especially in industrialized countries and thus
able to shine a light on conflicts anywhere in the world. Since most armed conflicts, these
days have governmental and not territorial reasons; the parties are often concerned with
making sure that the majority of people are on “their” side, which bears a lot of potential
for misrepresenting facts and trying to seize control over the distribution of information. For
this very reason, the intervention of unbiased and free global media is important not only
for the world public but also for the people directly affected. The number of conflicts,
however, that gets international attention is small; therefore, local media is vital in this
context. United Nations Office for West Africa (2005).
Broadcasting news by using community radios can help reach people in different areas, even
with different languages more easily. This way people can be addressed directly and their
own personal experiences and lives can be incorporated much better, than with foreign
media. The danger of manipulation and inflammation of ethnic tensions, however, cannot
be ignored. Another advantage of local media, especially radio is that in border areas it is
possible to convey peace messages to passing fighters and refugees alike. Democratic media
22
structures need more than this; it is vital that the use of information within a society is not
solemnly passive but that the population gets actively involved in creating content and
broadcasting it. Deutsche W. (2008).
Internal conflicts do not occur spontaneously but tend to have a history. Local media usually
have a deeper understanding of the existing political structures, the participants of the
conflict as well as the changes preceding the outbreak of violence. The media can therefore
not only influence society before the conflict by recognizing and properly addressing the
issue but afterwards. Unlike international media covering conflicts, local media are a
recognized part of society with the ability to accelerate and magnify fears or reduce them.
One should not forget that journalism could play a role in escalating conflicts, which also
demonstrates the potential for positive purposes. The media have the power to defuse
tensions before they even reach a critical point and keep a critical eye on government,
opposition and society. By supplying credible information and reaching a large audience,
the media help in managing conflicts and promote democratic principles. In the aftermath
of a conflict, reconciliation and societal development can be encouraged as well. Westphal,
F. (2004).
A measure of peace building can be enhanced peace journalism. Peace journalists try to
uncover the causes behind a conflict and true goals of all participants while making sure to
humanize all victims of the conflict. The journalists do not try to exploit the loss and
suffering but make sure that the reporting is balanced and also demonstrate how easily news
can be manipulated. Part of the ethical guidelines for this kind of reporting is to bring out
people that use peaceful measures, speak out against war and violence, and document the
suffering and loss on all sides. Possible solutions and trying to prevent further escalation of
the conflict are at the centre of peace journalism as well. A suggested framework used by
peace-building media can employ different strategies such as (1) Conflict-sensitive and
peace journalism; (2) Peace-promoting entertainment media; (3) Media regulation to
prevent incitement of violence, but also (4) Peace-promoting citizen media. Himelfarb,
Sheldon and Chabalowski, Megan (2008).
23
Media and journalism can be a great assistance in conflict management and peace building.
However, the power they have is also limited, as they will never be able to eliminate armed
conflicts altogether. The media can be a good tool in a healthy and functioning environment
but more is needed than ethical and responsible reporting to ensure lasting peace and safety.
The role of the media is twofold: on the one hand, the media report and reflect on pressing
issues and can help to question established concepts and ideas. On the other hand, they can
be used for propaganda purposes and instead of revealing truths, try to cover things up and
by this curtail people’s freedom and right to information. Regardless, the potential of the
media in conflict and post-conflict situations remains a net positive, and has been sadly
underutilized to this point in time.
2.1 Relationship between Media and Politics
The relationship between politics and media has begun to develop as a rather semi-
autonomous research field, within social sciences, in the last three decades. Historically the
issue of mass media's relationship to politics has been framed by the idea of propaganda and
fear of its effect on mass society (Street: 2005: 19). For instance, Lasswell wrote his doctoral
dissertation on propaganda and that became his first book (Schramm: 1997:32). The so-
called 'Frankfurt School' turned its attention to the role of the media after the fascist success
in Germany in 1933 (Curran and Corner, Seaton: 199 1: 249). The Frankfurt theorists tried
to explain the role of the press and radio, which were extensively used by Nazis, as means
of propaganda. These approaches although they were different in ideological and
epistemological departures, they had to do more with the effects f the media to the public
rather than a specific research approach concerning media's relationship to politics itself on
the basis of political and economic structures. The latter was accompanied by the historica l
orientation of communication research with media effects. According to Hallin and Mancini
'For many years empirical research in communication was almost synonymous with the
media effects paradigm which was concerned not with larger media structures but with the
effects of particular messages on individual attitudes and beliefs' (Hallin and Mancini: 2002:
15).
24
John Street (2005: 19-20) proposes four additional categories of research focusing mass
media's relationship to politics.
o The 'political effects' research which is concerned and organized around the
elections;
o Research that has been focused on political communication, party organization and
government communication;
o Research that has been focused on the relationship between media and democracy.
o Research that has been devoted to the relationship between public policy and the
media which has to do also with regulation of media and broadcasting policy and
2.2 Politics and Journalism
In many ways the history of journalism in the world is closely parallel to political history of
the media. Limited development of media markets meant that newspapers were smaller, and
less likely to be self-sustaining. And state intervention, particularly in periods of
authoritarianism, interrupted the development of journalism as a profession. The level of
professionalization in journalism thus has remained lower in the world (Zioutos: 1954),
although it increased in important ways in the last couple of decades of the twentieth century
(Hallin and Papathanassopoulos: 2002). The notion of journalistic professionalism, which
forms the basis for journalists' claims of autonomy, is connected with the idea that
journalists serve a public interest that transcends the interests of particular parties, owners
of social groups. To what extent this model can be applied to other countries, especially to
those, which have experienced a different political culture and development? How can this
model be applied to everyday practices of other countries, especially in those societies
where a sense of public interest transcending particular interests has been increasingly
difficult to achieve? Paolo Mancini (2000: 266) referring to Italy notes that: 'In reality [in
other countries] journalists act in a different way: they follow a different model of
journalism'.
As Papathanassopoulos argues (2001), this is the case of Greek journalism as well. One can
say that due to the political particularities of Greek society, it is difficult to develop a culture
of journalistic professionalism faithful to the Anglo-American model. This is because
25
journalism always reflects and embodies the historical processes within which it has
developed and the contemporary social conditions within which it is made (McNair: 1998:
64).
It is worth mentioning to make clear what the researcher means when he says the level of
professionalization is lower. This does not, for example, mean that journalists in Greece are
less educated than their European colleagues. Journalists in Somali are more likely to have
university degrees today than those in major Developed countries (Weaver: 1998).
2.3 Shaping the Political Agenda
Shanto Iyengar looks at why we think what we do about politics in Is Anyone
Responsible? But the theories and premises of his research are derived in large part from
his 1987 book News That Matters (co-authored with Donald Kinder). In the book, he
examines how we think about politics, suggesting that television determines what we
believe to be important issues largely by paying attention to some problems and ignoring or
paying minimal attention to others. "Our evidence implies an American public with a limited
memory for last month's news and a recurrent vulnerability to today's," Iyengar and Kinder
write. "When television news focuses on a problem, the public's priorities are altered, and
altered again as television news moves on to something new."
The idea of the media as agenda-setter was hardly new. In the late 1960s, Maxwell E.
McCombs and Donald L. Shaw began studying the agenda-setting capacity of the news
media in American presidential elections. They were especially interested in the question of
information transmission — what people actually learn from news stories, rather than
attitudinal changes, the subject of earlier research. Their research precipitated a stream of
empirical studies that underscored the media's critical role as vehicles of politica l
information.
In their 1977 book, The Emergence of American Political Issues, McCombs and Shaw
argued that the most important effect of the mass media was "its ability to mentally order
and organize our world for us." The news media "may not be successful in telling us what
26
to think," the authors declared, "but they are stunningly successful in telling us what to think
about."
McCombs and Shaw also note that the media's tendency to structure voters' perceptions of
political reality in effect constitutes a bias: "to a considerable degree the art of politics in a
democracy is the art of determining which issue dimensions are of major interest to the
public or can be made salient in order to win public support."
The presidential observer Theodore White arrived at the same conclusion in his landmark
book, The Making of a President: "The power of the press in America is a primordial one.
It sets the agenda of public discussion; and this sweeping political power is unrestrained by
any law. It determines what people will talk and think about — an authority that in other
nations is reserved for tyrants, priests, parties and mandarins."According to David Brewer
(2012).
2.4 Freedom of Speech
The media has been called the “fourth branch” of government and is sometimes placed on
a level akin to the three official branches of government—legislative, executive, and
judicial. Though the media has no direct governing power, at times it may serve as a check
on the other three branches by informing the public of the government’s actions, allowing
the people to respond accordingly. Like other forms of exmediaion, freedom of the media
is essential to the advancement and operation of a democracy, providing important benefits
to individuals, to society, and to the government:
• A free media allows for communication and the open exmediaion of ideas with others.
Human dignity advances when people can print their thoughts and ideas and read from
others with similar or different views.
• A free media informs people of new and better ideas, which benefits a community and
allows it to improve and change with the times. This contributes to intellectual growth and
broader understanding.
• A free media provides a mechanism for communicating freely with local, state, and
national representatives and is essential to the operation of representative government.
27
• A free media can help bring about peaceful social change by working as a mediaure valve
to release tension when people feel wronged or mistreated. It also gives the government
and members of society important information on how their actions or statements have
been received.
• A free media provides people with a mechanism to speak out against perceived violat ions
of personal rights and is essential for the protection of all people’s rights.
The existence of independent media is a vital component of any democratic society. Under
the Libertarian Media Model, the news media play a critical role in democratic governance.
Its key functions include serving as a timely and reliable information source for the public;
providing objective reporting and interpretation of political issues and events; performing a
watchdog function by keeping the activities of the government under scrutiny; and
facilitating dialogue between politicians and citizens (McCombs, Shaw & Weaver, 1997).
2.5 Role of Mass Media in today’s world
According to David Brewer (2012), the continuing explosion of digital communica t ion
technology has raised new questions about the inclusion of cell phones, video and computer
games in mass media. Currently, marketers and advertisers are planning to tap into satellites
and broadcast commercials and advertisements directly to millions of cell phones,
unsolicited by the phone's user. Advertisers are looking into placing advertisements as well
as incorporating product placement into the video games as well.
Mass media has the potential to play a key role in developing a culture of peace and non-
violence. Unfortunately, it has failed to live up to its potential. To the contrary, it has not
only almost completely ignored the culture of peace and non-violence, but also it privileges
news of the culture of war and violence. In fact, it appears as if a campaign or propaganda
has beenpromulgated in the mass media in order to justify political policies of militarism. It
has been used to increase publicity in recent decades for the myth that war and violence are
intrinsic to human nature.
The present situation can be compared to the earlier use of racist myths to justify slavery
and colonialism in mid-19th and mid-20th centuries as a last-resort effort by those who had
28
a vested interest in slavery and colonialism. That was their last effort to defend these
institutions by appealing to the vulnerable belief systems of individual psychology at a time
when they could no longer justify the institutions by economic or political arguments. If this
is correct, even for certain sections of the media, the struggle for culture of peace in the
mass media needs to receive top priority and careful strategy.
It has been observed in recent past, during a violent incident, the media goes full- fledged
reporting and covering it live. However, the same cannot be said about a peaceful but
important event. The media has to remember that it influences how their audiences think
and behave. In fact, mass media plays a crucial role in forming and reflecting public opinion,
connecting the world to individuals and reproducing the self- image of society.
There is a complex interaction between the media and society, with the media on generating
information from a network of relations and influences and with the individua l
interpretations and evaluations of the information provided, as well as generating
information outside of media contexts. Thus, the consequences and ramifications of the
mass media relate not merely to the way newsworthy events are perceived, but also to a
multitude of cultural influences that operate through the media.
The ability of the media to reach a wide audience with a strong and influential message has
the potential to have a strong social and cultural impact upon society. Marshall McLuhan
uses the phrase "the medium is the message" as a means of explaining how the distribution
of a message can often be more important than content of the message itself.
The ability of the media to reach a wide audience with a strong and influential message has
the potential to have a strong social and cultural impact upon society. Marshall McLuhan
uses the phrase "the medium is the message" as a means of explaining how the distribution
of a message can often be more important than content of the message itself.
It is through the persuasiveness of influential media such as television, radio and print media
that they have been largely responsible for structuring people's daily lives and routines.
Television broadcasting has a large amount of control over the content society watches and
29
the times in which it is viewed. The internet creates a space for more diverse politica l
opinions, social and cultural viewpoints and a heightened level of consumer participation.
Studies of various commercials, advertising and voter campaigns prove that media influence
behavior. In the 20th century, aggressive media attention and negative coverage of trials
involving celebrities like Roscoe Fatty Arbuckle or Michael Jackson influenced the general
public‘s opinion, before the trials effectively started.
Though the media could have an effect on people's behavior, it is not necessarily always the
case. Many copycat murders, suicides and other violent acts nearly always happen in
abnormal upbringings. Violent, emotionally neglectful or aggressive environments
influence behavior more than watching certain programs, films or listening to certain music.
Just because an audience sees acts of violence in media, this does not mean they will actually
commit them. Of the millions of people who watch violent films, only a small number have
carried out acts of violence as a direct result. People regularly exposed to violent media
usually grow up to be completely normal people. If there are any effects from media, they
only affect a very small number of people. So, there also develops a case where it is wrong
to always blindly blame the media because people are not copycats, instead we should be
aware of someone mental state and take other factors into account before making such
claims.
There are other social and cultural factors in criminal acts in which the media are not the
basic influence. Actually, there is no such thing called violence in the media that either could
or could not cause violence. It is the social factors and background that make some people
consume media in specific way. There is no connection between exposure to media violence
and real life violence, because humans are not copycats and can realize what is wrong and
what is right. Although some research claims that heavy exposure to media violence can
lead to more aggressive behavior, it has been suggested that exposure alone does not cause
a person to commit crimes.
Often, there are demands for the banning of certain songs or the labeling of obscene albums.
Such demands are put forward by people with political objectives. The public is bribed with
30
good radio, television and newspapers into an acceptance of the biased, the misleading, and
the status quo. The media are, thus, not crude agents of propaganda, but are those who
organize public understanding.Vineet Prakash, (2012).
However, the overall interpretations they provide in the long run are those most preferred
by, and least challenging to, those with economic power. It cannot be denied that the mass
media play an agenda-setting function as people tend to share the media's composite
definition of what is important.
Although a sizable portion of mass media offerings particularly news, commentar ies,
documentaries, and other informational programmes deal with highly controversia l
subjects, the major portion of mass media offerings are designed to serve an entertainment
function. These programmes tend to avoid controversial issues and reflect beliefs and values
sanctified by mass audience.
Such programmes have the potential to make individuals 'irrational victims of false wants'
that are thrust upon them by corporations through both the advertising in the media and
through the individualist consumption culture it promulgates. Thus, the modern media train
the young for consumption. It would not be wrong to state that 'leisure had ceased to be the
opposite of work, and had become a preparation for it.'
Again, there is a threat of media bringing hyper-reality i.e. projecting more than what the
reality is. The case of O.J. Simpson is an example. Another threat arises from self-
censorship by members of the media in the interests of the owner, or in the interests of their
careers. The two-way relationship between mass media and public opinion is now beginning
to change, especially after the advent of new technologies such as blogging. Vineet Prakash,
(2012).
31
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCHMETHODOLOGY
3.0 Introduction
This study focused on the relationship between the Somali Media and the Political Actors
and player, while it established core aspects that should build sustainable better relationship
between the parties. Nevertheless, this study would use one of the most popular mixed
methods designs in educational research, which is the correlational research.
3.1 Research Design
This study employed correlation research design to investigate the relationship between
Media and the politics of Somalia. The research design was about the arrangement of
variables, conditions and participants for the study. The researcher used Correlation
research design, which involves conducting data in order to determine whether and to what
degree a relationship exists between two or more variables.
3.2 Study Area and Population
This study was conducted among government members, Somali politicians, private and the
public media, and civil society group. The researcher selected those groups because they
have information, facts and experience of the role of media on the politics and the
association/relationship that persists currently between them and how this can be improved.
The study consists of 300 target populations of civil society, Somali politician, civil servants
and the media. All these are most important sources that we could get reliable information
about the study. For this reason, it is the most suitable for the required information relating
to this study.
The sample size of the study identified using Slovin’s formula –the sample has been revised
after correcting the population
32
n= N / (1 + (N*e^2))
Where
N= Population
n= Sample
e= is the confidence level at 0.05
n=300/ (1+ (300*0.0025)) 170 subjects.
Table 1: Selection of Sample size
No. Respondents Target
Population
Sample size
1 Civil servants 70 38
2 Mass Media 95 55
3 Politician 68 30
4 Civil Society 67 47
5 Total 300 170
Source: Primary Data, 2014
The sample size consisted of 47civil society members, 30 politicians; 55 mass media and
38 civil servants selected from the target population 170 members.
3.3 Sample techniques
A sampling technique is the name or other identification of the specific process by which
the entities of the sample should be selected. Alternatively, the methods used in drawing
samples from a population usually in such a manner that the sample facilitated determina tion
of some hypothesis concerning the population.
33
3.3.1 Sampling Procedure
This study employed purposive sampling techniques. Purposive sampling technique is a
technique that the researcher uses his or her own judgment or common sense regarding the
participant from whom information was collected (Amin, 2005). The researcher shall use
purposive sampling to choose the respondents believes that they have the relevant
information.
3.4 Validity and Reliability of the Instrument
The validity of an instrument refers to the ability of the instrument to collect justifiable and
truthful data. In other words, it is about the ability of the instrument to measure what it is
developed to measure. Validity is the quality of the test doing what is designed to do
(Salkind; 2000).
Reliability of the respondent’s through the instruments of the questionnaire shall be
established. The reliability of the research instruments concern with the degree to which the
research instrument has given the same result. The reliability of an instrument refers to the
ability of the instrument to collect the same data consistently under similar conditions
(Odiya; 2009).
To ensure the reliability of the questionnaire, the researcher has used method of expertise
judgment, after construction of the questionnaire; the researcher approached the supervisor
and other experts to ensure the reliability and validity of the research instruments.
3.5 Data Collection Methods
The following data collection procedures have been implemented while the researcher used
questionnaire, interview, observation, and survey for this study.
A. Before the administration of the questionnaires and interviews
The researcher shall requested for an introduction letter from Hope University/Kampala
University postgraduate Centres addressed to the authorities of the university under
study for their permission to conduct this study. The letter shall contained the criteria
34
for selecting the respondents and the request to be provided with list of bonafide students
in the university.
After approval, after approval, the researcher identifies that information based on the
role of media on the political stability and the general political situation of the county.
Thus, the researcher utilizes the table on the respondents (Table 1) to determine the
suitable participants to be included in the research.
B. During the administration of the questionnaires and interviews
Especially the researcher is seriously particular in requesting the respondents to the
following: (1) to sign the informed consent; (2) to answer all the questions hence, they
should not leave any item unanswered; (3) to avoid bias and to be to the objective in
answering the questionnaires. The researcher and his assistants tried retrieving the
questionnaires with 5 days from the day of distribution. All questionnaires retrieved
were checked if they are completely filled out.
C. After administration of the questionnaires and interviews
The data collected has been organized, collected, summarized, statistically treated
and drafted in tables using the Statistical Package for Social Scientists (SPSS).
3.6 Data Analysis and Interpretation
To determine the profile of the respondents, frequency and percentage distribution was used
for analyzing it. Mean, Ranking and Interpreting data was also be used to compute for the
role and the relationship between the mass media and the Somali politics. An item analysis
based on the mean scores and ranking were reflected the strengths and weakness of the
respondents in the items of mass media and politics. The measurement of media and politics
was measured in different questionnaires, each shall be selected in one to four scale for
respondents 1= Strongly Disagree, 2= Disagree, 3= Agree, 4= Strongly Agree. To interpret
the obtained data profile of the media and politics for the following numerical value and
descriptions was used.
35
Mean Range Description Means
3.21-4.00 Very good You agree without doubt
2.51-3.20 Good You agree with doubt
1.76-2.50 Fair You disagree with doubt
1.00-1.75 Poor You disagree without doubt
3.7 Ethical Considerations
The data that the researcher is to collect from the respondents was kept at most confidentia l
and be used for the purpose of the fulfillment of the requirement for the award of the degree
of Master of International Relations and Diplomacy. The respondent was also informed the
content of the research and its aims because researchers whose subjects are people or
animals must consider the conduct of their study and give attention to the ethical issues
associated with carrying out the research.
Some of the key ethical issues that was given due attention in this study were privacy of
participants, voluntary nature of participation and the right to withdraw partially or
completely from the process, consent and possible deception of participants, maintenance
of the conditionality of data to be provided by individuals or identifiable participants and
their anonymity.
3.8 Limitation of the Study
1. Testing: The use of research assistants can be about inconsistency in the
administration of the questionnaire in terms of tie of administrat ion,
understanding of the items of in the questionnaire and explanations given to the
respondents.
2. Attrition/ Morality: Not all questionnaires may be turned completely answered
nor even retrieved back due to circumstances on the part of the respondents such
as travels sickness, hospitalization and refusal/withdrawal to participate. In
anticipation to this, he the researcher reserved more respondents by exceeding
the minimum sample size. The respondents also reminded not to leave any item
37
CHAPTER FOUR: DATA PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND
DISCUSSIONS
4.0 Introduction
This chapter presents and analyzes the findings of the study and their interpretation that is
based on the research questions and objectives which included assessing the role of media
on Somali politics. To investigate the impact of media on the politics and the vise verse. To
identify challenges faced by Somali media development towards the political effect. This
part presents the summary of information about the respondents using statistical frequency
table.
4.1 Biographical Information
Profile of Respondents
The profile of the respondents are personal information of the participants, this allows the
researcher to know the age, gender, experience and education of the respondents of the
research.
Age Distribution
Table 2: Age Distribution of the Respondents
Age of the respondents of this research is shown in the table, the age of the respondents
were useful for this research in order to know the level of the majority of participants.
38
Table 2: Age Distribution of the Respondents
Age
Frequency Percent
Valid 20-25 6 3.5
26-31 22 12.9
32-37 45 26.5
38-43 24 14.1
44-49 47 27.6
50 and Above 26 15.3
Total 170 100.0
Source: Primary Data, 2014
According to the first table of 2; 3.5 % of the respondents were between the ages of (20-
25), whereas 12.9% were between (26-31); while26.5% of the respondents were aged
between (32-37), whereas 14.1% were (38-43) years old whilst 27.6% were 44-49 years old
and lastly 15.3% of the respondents were aged 50 years and above.
So, the findings of the table above indicates that most participants of the study were between
the age of 44-49 years as shown in the table while a significant number of the respondents
also aged 32-37 years.
Gender of the Respondents
The profile of gender distribution of the respondents are explained in the table 3 below, this
gives the researcher the chance to discover the proportion of gender participation in the
research that was conducted.
39
Table3: Gender of the Respondents
Gender
Frequency Percent
Valid Male 108 63.5
Female 62 36.5
Total 170 100.0
Source: Primary Data 2014
Table 3 indicates that the majority of the respondents which is 63.5% are male on the other
hand 36.5% of respondents were female.
This indicates that men were the most respondents of the study met by the researcher, for
the reason that most of experts in this kind of media political relationships were men.
Marital Status
There are various categories of the respondents ranging from single to divorced as indicated
in table 4.
Table 4: Marital Status of the Respondents
Marital Status
Frequency Percent
Valid Single 51 30.0
Married 66 38.8
Widowed/Divorced 53 31.2
Total 170 100.0
Source: Primary Data
40
The table 4 shows that 30 % respondents were single , while other 38.8% of the participants
were married as revealed in the above table, Also the table shows that 31.2% out of the
respondents were either widowed or divorced.
Although it was a close annexation, the conclusion of the table shows that married people
were the most participants of the study.
Education Level of the Respondents
The table 5 below indicates the level of the education of the respondents ranging from
certificates to postgraduate level.
Table 5: Education Level of the Respondents
Educational Level
Frequency Percent
Valid Certificate 55 32.4
Diploma 62 36.5
Bachelor 20 11.8
Postgraduate Level 33 19.4
Total 170 100.0
Source: Primary Data 2014
As table 5 reveals, regarding the qualifications of respondents, with diploma among them
were 36.5% out of total of the respondents, while respondents with certificate (Secondary
Certificate or equivalent) were 32.4%. Bachelor Degree holders among the participants
were 11.8%, while Postgraduate holders of these research participants were 19.4%.
The finding of the study in table 5 shows that respondents with Diploma were dominant
participants in the research with close inclusion of Certificate holders.
41
Experience Level
The table below indicates the level of experience of the research participants.
Table 6: Experience of the Respondents
Years of Experience
Frequency Percent
Valid 1-2 Years 6 3.5
3-4 Years 43 25.3
5 Years and Above 121 71.2
Total 170 100.0
Source: Primary Data, 2011
Table 6; which indicates the experience level of the respondents states, 71.2% of the
respondents had an experience of 5 years and above, whereas 25.3% out of the respondents
had (3-4 Years) of experience. Also 3.5% had 1 -2 years of experience. (
The table concludes that 5 years and above of experience were most participants of the study
as table 6 illustrates.
Occupation of Respondents
The table 7 below illustrates the occupation of the participants in the research
Occupation
Frequency Percent
Valid Politician 30 17.6
Journalist 55 32.4
Civil Servant 85 50.0
Total 170 100.0
42
Source: Primary Data 2014
The table above signposts the occupational type of the respondents of this research, 50% of
the research participants were civil servants, while 32.4% were Journalists and those with
high information and experience in media and related issues, also 17.6% of the respondents
were politicians.
The table designates that the civil servants were the leading part participating in this research
that has information on both media and its role on political situations in Somalia.
Level in the Organization
As the below table shows, the level of the participants in the organization, ranging from top
level to supervisory level.
Table 8: Level in the Organization
Level in The Organization
Frequency Percent
Valid Top Level 27 15.9
Middle Level 113 66.5
Supervisor Level 30 17.6
Total 170 100.0
Source: Primary Data 2014
4.2 Analysis of Variables Based on Objectives
The variables of this research conducted is Somali Media and politics which is to discover
the effect of media on the political situations in Somalia, meanwhile four aspect ratio was
used to measure this effect on the entrepreneurship which was: 1= Strongly Disagree, 2=
Disagree, 3= Agree, 4= Strongly agree. The responses from the research participants were
used SPSS’s summary of statistics showing the mean of the responses as shown in the table
9 below:
43
Objective 1: To define the effects of Somali Media on the political stabilization, good
governance and economic development of Somalia.
Descriptive Statistics
N Mean Rank Interpretation
1. The Somali media focuses on ethics in their
editorial part in broadcasting news. 170 3.03 1 Good
2. Televisions and newspapers are the best
sources of accurate newscast, while
websites and radios are foundations of
erroneous news programs in the country.
170 2.33 2 Good
3. Somali media is contributing to the good
governance of the country. 170 2.58 3 Good
4. Somali media broadcasts news that creates
nationalism 170 2.30 4 Good
Source: Primary Data 2014
The table above indicates that media and journalist give greater attention to the details of
the news they broadcast, they always discover, according to the participants’ reaction and
the results shown in the table which is 3.03 mean range illustrates that producing favorable
news to the public is a theme, but the media network containing radios, TVs, Newspapers
and websites motivate the good editorial journalistic ethical news that are impersonal to a
specific individual or group of people. However, ethical differences are in everywhere, and
one man’s meat is another man’s poison. Some of the participants submitted their argument
that personality issue in broadcasting news is rarely involved.
Similarly, the table 9 above signposts that radios and websites have greater erroneous
contents in their news, this comes after the details that is to be given to the headline or the
44
issue need to be addressed more exhaustive to satisfy the need of the target audiences for
the niceties and the details of a particular caption of news. Unlike TVs and Newspapers, this
research divulges that both TVs news need videos and evidence for the newsflash, they
comparatively address more accurate information and their editorial image in the country is
relatively positive while newspapers which have reasonably fewer audiences compared to
all other media means focus on the realities of the bulletin and the details that follow.
A remarkable number of the participants in this research demonstrates that Somali media
is contributing the good governance of the country, it broadcasts nationalism programs that
build the mental nationalism ideology of audiences, they mobilize the peace, conflict
resolutions, and hygiene agendas and programs to the community, they promote the
prevention of security harms, terrorism activities; disease outbreak and other detrimenta l
activities expected. The table concludes that Somali media has virtuous effect on the good
governance of Somalia.
Nationalism is a attaching to one’s nations, so many numbers of nationalist have been
involved in this research, the researcher identified that the participants have been created as
nationals by the media through their creative programs that enhance the recreation and
redesign of nationalism ideology in Somalia. Some few numbers disagree the argument that
media takes part on the patriotism and devotion of the individual blood to the country, the
community and the entire country’s interests. The table above indicates that Somali media
has reflective influence on this issue of nationalism and its related productions.
45
Objective 2: To demonstrate the relationship between the media and politics in Somalia.
Descriptive Statistics
N Mean Rank Interpretations
1. It is a business root cause why radios are nowadays
outnumbering in Mogadishu. 170 2.91 1 Good
2. Media gets information from informal/casua l
sources with substandard editing. 170 2.72 2 Good
3. During elections, politicians have very good
relationship with the mass media in Somalia. 170 2.62 3 Good
4. Politicians use media to advertise their politica l
opinions, and their personal politics. 170 2.54 4 Good
5. One of the reasons why journalists are killed is that
they provide inaccurate and or unfavorab le
targeted personal information.
170 2.51 5 Good
6. Many politicians avoid media usage when they are
no usage of it. 170 2.42 7 Fair
7. There is a significant relationship between the
media and politicians in Somalia. 170 2.00 8 Fair
8. Media and politics have been dwindling
relationship between them for the last couple of
decades.
170 1.91 9 Fair
9. Media is the fourth power in the country after the
government’s three other systems. 170 1.84 10 Fair
Source: Primary Data 2014
During the past decade, the radio networks especially FMs are outnumbering in the country
more than ever, yet there more 30 news broadcasting FM radios in Mogadishu, the capital
46
city of Somalia while there are more than 100 other radio network organizations in other
parts of the country, The table elucidates that it’s a business motive that creates the
outstripping radios FM broadcasts in Somalia, as 2.91 mean average of the participants of
this research declared. They emphasized their effects can be multiple and need to be
addressed, so that the government of Somalia and their parliament should as soon as possible
pass their policy that guides, directs and controls the media especially radios in Somalia.
As the participants of this research professed and as already the table 9 prior this current
one indicates, media especially radios and websites have greater flawed blemished news
that can create bad impact on the community and the country at large. This table the
information of its former one indicating that radios and websites get informal information
form the public or they do not moderately edit their bulletin and reports in a professiona l
moral way, the mean in the above table which is 2.72 shows that research participants agree
that sources of news from the local media in Somalia is not relatively trustful.
One of the most interesting part of the findings of this research indicates that politicians are
the friends of the media whenever their interest is sought in media campaigns, for example,
in the times of elections that the politicians want to market their personal politics and their
figurative appearances, media is the best way they can gain the giant audiences. The table
shines that politicians have biggest interest to use media when the time is best for them as
their mean indicates 2.62, which means the respondents have agreed with some little doubt
in it.
Somalia is one of the country that is not a safe haven for the journalists, according the
statistical facts shown by the Somali Journalist Associations indicates, every month 2-4
journalists are killed in the country, 10-15 others are threatened to death while 5-10 of them
imprisoned by the authorities. This research indicates that the news they broadcast does
reasonably relate to the way, type, editorial and the intention of the newscast they broadcast
to the public audience, this may effect to a specific persons, group or groups that has a
common or exclusive interest in it. The table above, which as mean range of 2.51 shows
that despite the fact of there is a reservation and doubt in the existence of this motive, the
47
respondents believe that the case of killing has a relationship with the news that journalists
carry and convoy.
Rendering to the significance of the relationship between the two sides of media and politics
in Somalia, the table above indicates that there is no significant affiliation and connection
between them, whenever the side captures the interest to work with the politicians, they
directly target and vise verse is also true; the table which has a mean of 2.00 mean range
indicates that with the respect of some reservation and hesitations from the respondents of
the research they declined the existence of noteworthy relationship between the parties.
According to the table 10 above divulges, the relationship between the media networks and
political figures of Somalia has been ambiguous, it neither declined nor increased in value.
The table also indicates that there was always a fair relationship between the two organs and
has been with each other according to their personal judgment, interests, tryouts and
probations. This does not mean that the researcher found out the relationship has been
deteriorating or growing in good graphic way, it means that their relationship was more or
less passive.
Somalia as a country has three powers, the Presidential , the Parliament and the Courts of
the country, its arguable that the fourth power in Somalia is the media, although the results
of this research unveils that Somali media is not the fourth power succeeding after other
three systems of the government; the table above exposes that media is far to be more or
less the fourth power in Somalia, the mean of this issue as the researcher realized is 1.84
which is a negative result shown by the respondents of the research.
Objective 3: To establish methods, strategies and means of using media to best stabilize
the political situation in Somalia
48
Descriptive Statistics
N Mean Rank Interpretation
1. Media is powerful tool that can be
used to stabilize the country. 170 3.58 1 Very Good
2. Media is double-edged blade that can
cause harm and good to the country. 170 3.23 2 Very Good
3. Peace and good governance programs
are tools that can boost country’s
peace and stabilization.
170 3.15 3 Good
4. Use of media to create nationalists and
mobilized community is the best way. 170 2.29 4 Good
Source: Primary Data, 2014
Media is an influential gizmo that has an impact on the community, the country and common
cause of activities related to the entire Somalia, the table above illuminates that Somali
media has outstanding grander impact on the stabilization of the country, and use of media
to alleviate and improve the stabilization of Somalia. The mean range with outstanding 3.58
mean range that indicates the respondents of the research have no doubt to agree with the
Barney, which indicates that media can be used to stabilize the country.
All media networks are two-edged tool that can either detriment or can be virtuous, thus
more care is needed to effectively use and benefit from it. The participants of the research
has displayed the requirement for attention and consideration of the side effects of media
despite the fact that their mean is 3.21 which entitles that they agree that careful
responsiveness to details of the importance and usage of media.
49
Good governance and peace building programs are some of the artistic ways to benefit from
media that can broadcast the control and implementation of good governance to the target
audience in Somalia. As the table above indicates, the participants of this research believes
that the tools that media can be utilized is to transmit programs that enhances and improves
peace and good governance in Somalia as their mean shows 3.15 that means they agree this
indication.
Mobilization of community through media means is a fundamental notion, which has its
greater importance for the nationalism enhancement and improvement of its related
aspects, the research participants explained the power of media to mobilize the community
and develop nationalism inspiration in Somalia.
Objective 4: To utilize media’s positive broadcasting programs and minimize the side
effects of it on both politics and the entire society.
50
Descriptive Statistics
N Mean Rank Interpretation
1. Media has great “positive” impact on
community mobilization and awareness. 170 3.32 1 Very Good
2. Giving training to journalists about good
governance, peace and nationalism is a
way to minimize the side effects of media
on society.
170 3.22 2 Very Good
3. There is a strong need for bill/legal policy
that guides the media to passed by the
government of Somalia and it’s a heavy-
duty.
170 3.21 3 Very Good
4. Some of the Somali journalists are not very
professionals in the field 170 2.43 4 Good
Source: Primary Data, 2014
The impact of media can surely be positive if it is used in an approach or system that goes
forward to the awareness and creating good independent society and country, that effect can
be done in many ways that includes mobilizing the community in various currently based
programs including prevention of decease outbreak, giving reliable information and other
facets which can reinforce and underline the positive of media to the society at large. The
table above indicates that media has ‘positive’ impact on the community.
51
Providing capacity building and technically related training and seminars for journalist is
obligatory in order to flourish journalists ability, skills and talents to publish and broadcast
reports, newscast and bulletin to the public audiences. The table above shows the need for
such training and seminar programs for the journalist in Somalia as their mean points out.
Planning guiding, controlling, monitoring and taking corrective action plan is the
responsibility of the Federal Government of Somalia and the FGS cannot excise such actions
if there is no written and passed bill that dictates the does and don’ts that a journalist needs
to follow, such policies are important but the FGS is yet drafting the bill and hopes to pass
through the parliament of Somalia. The researcher’s findings explains that the respondents
have pointed out the importance of such law to be processed immediately.
A reality and observational based approach in this research indicates that if you visit the
radio, TVs and website centers, you will discover that professionalism in this media
programs are more than important as a word. While the mean in the table above of 2.43
indicates a little bit of disagreement while the respondent has a doubt about it, the journalists
need more capacity building, training and technical assistance to be better effective workers
for the country and its people.
52
4.3 Interview Guide Discussions
Interview guides have been created in this research to question and collect information that
busy participants who do not have much time to excel in the questionnaire, and those who
want to provide more and effective information that questionnaire was not sufficient way to
deliver their contributions to the research.
Below you can find the summary of the interview points that has been brought up by the
respondents of the research.
Some of the strategies that can be used to minimize the side effects of media on
political aspects include:
o Training programs to the journalists that builds the capacity, skills and the
knowhow of media.
o Mobilization to media workers, owners, editors and journalists to be and act
as nationalists for the country.
o To develop a policy plan that governs, guides and controls radios,
newspapers, websites and Televisions in Somalia.
According to the respondents of the research, they admired that media can be utilized
in different ways that can assist the community through mobilization, awareness,
preparation and prevention programs to protect the public from decease outbreak,
terrorism and security problems and so on and so forth.
To the interview question about the reason why journalists are killed in Somalia and
in particularly Mogadishu , the respondents included their argument that journalists
are killed in some reasons consisting:
o Sources, types and the target of the news they provide to the audiences.
o General security problem in Somalia.
o Personal related target.
According the respondents of the research, media increase in number is nowadays
familiar in the eyes and ears of the audiences in Somalia, the participants pointed
out simple reasons, they mentioned that political aim is one of them, this facilita tes
the politician to submit his/her political ideas, personal politics and market his party
53
to the community, another reason that some of respondents claimed is a business
motive.
Media is a powerful tool that governs the community, media is the eye of society,
they get accustomed to what media broadcasts, and political stabilization has been
effected much by the media networks. Participants acknowledged the effects of
media on political steadiness and balance is uncountable and limitless.
Respondents of the research indicated the times when politicians use most in media
are the times of election, times of political disorder, and whenever politicians think
that media should be used right away.
Media and political relationships can be harmonized in different ways according to
the respondents of this interview, they stated:
o The need for policy plan that administers, guides and controls media powers
and gives them their rights, points out the dos and don’ts in media.
54
CHAPTER FIVE: DISCUSSION, SUMMARIES CONCLUSIONS AND
RECOMMENDATIONS
5.0 Introduction
This chapter discusses the findings, conclusions and recommendations of the study,
First it would discuss the major findings of the study as it is based on the findings discovered
by the researcher secondly, Conclusion would be drawn from the findings of the study and
lastly the researcher shall bring recommendation and further researches are to be suggested
in the study.
5.1 Summary of Findings
The study was guided by four objectives, which were before them to determine the
demographic characteristics of the respondents in terms of: (a) Age, (b) Gender (c) Marital
Status, (d) Educational Level (e) Years of Experience (f) position in the organization, (1)
To define the effects of Somali Media on the political stabilization, good governance and
economic development of Somalia. (2)To demonstrate the relationship between the media
and politics in Somalia. (3) To establish methods, strategies and means of using media to
best stabilize the political situation in Somalia. (4) To utilize media’s positive broadcasting
programs and minimize the side effects of it on both politics and the entire society.
Consistent with the respondents of the study, descriptive statistics result showed frequencies
and percentages indicating the characteristics of the respondents and showed the distribution
of the population in the study. The study results indicated that men dominated in media
political relationship; also the finding indicates that that diversified age among respondents
from youth to elders who have more information about the field of study and can provide
very useful information to the study.
In addition, level of experience and the level of education of the research participants was
another useful factor that declared how experienced and educated those in the media, civil
society and politicians were.
55
According to the first objective of the research, the effects of media on Somali Politics, A
remarkable number of the participants in this research demonstrates that Somali media is
contributing the good governance of the country, it broadcasts nationalism programs that
build the mental nationalism ideology of audiences, they mobilize the peace, confl ict
resolutions, and hygiene agendas and programs to the community, they promote the
prevention of security harms, terrorism activities; disease outbreak and other detrimenta l
activities expected. This makes the findings of this objective that the media is having a
positive effect on the stabilization, good governance and other important factors that are
favorable to the society at large.
The second objective of the research of the relationship between the parties One of the most
interesting part of the findings of this research indicates that politicians are the support
system of the media whenever their interest is sought in media movements, for example, in
the times of determinations that the politicians want to market their personal politics and
their figurative appearances, media is the best way they can gain the giant audiences. The
table shines that politicians have biggest interest to use media when the time is best for them
as their mean indicates 2.62,
The significance of the relationship between the two sides of media and politics in Somalia,
the table above indicates that there is no substantial affiliation and connection between them,
whenever the side captures the interest to work with the politicians, they directly target and
vise verse is also true; the mean of 2.00 mean range indicates that with the respect of some
reservation and hesitations from the respondents of the research they declined the existence
of noteworthy relationship between the parties.
The Third Objective media is an influential gadget that has an impact on the community,
the country and common cause of activities related to the entire Somalia, the research
indicates that Somali media has outstanding grander impact on the stabilization of the
country, and use of media to alleviate and improve the stabilization of Somalia. The mean
range with outstanding 3.58 mean range that indicates the respondents of the research have
no doubt to agree with the run-in.
56
On the other hand, media networks are two-edged tool that can either detriment or can be
virtuous, thus more care is needed to effectively use and benefit from it. The participants of
the research has displayed the requirement for attention and consideration of the side effects
of media despite the fact that their mean is 3.21.
Lastly, the utilization of media, first of all a reality and observational based methodology in
this research identifies that if you visit the radio, TVs and website centers, you will the
journalists need more capacity building, training and technical assistance to be better
effective workers for the country and its people. However, planning guiding, controlling,
monitoring and taking corrective action plan is the responsibility of the Federal Government
of Somalia and the FGS cannot excise such actions if there is no written and passed bill that
dictates the does and don’ts that a journalist needs to follow, such policies are important but
the FGS is yet drafting the bill and hopes to pass through the parliament of Somalia. The
researcher’s findings explains that the respondents have pointed out the importance of such
law to be processed immediately.
5.2 Conclusion
It is an undisputable fact that the media plays an integral role in the way we, society, view
daily politics and the politicians. Somalis spend almost a full day each week watching
television, listening radios and reading websites or newspapers. This is an obvious
indication that people rely heavily on the information portrayed in the news. In an age where
the popularization of television and other media sources has dominated the information
scene, it is hard to know if the information you are receiving is from reliable and unbiased
sources, due to the last couple of decades of war and anarchy experienced by the state.
There are a number of radio news agencies based in Somalia. Radio is the most important
and effective communication channel in the country and the most popular type of mass
media. In total, about one short wave and over ten private FM radio stations broadcast from
the capital, with several radio stations broadcasting from the central and southern regions.
The need for policy plan and more capacity building seminars for the media workers,
owners, editors and chiefs to train them to effectively broadcast positive ideologies to the
society.
57
5.3 Recommendations
According to the findings of the data collected and analyzed by the researcher, the following
recommendations have been drawn:
Need for Capacity Building: Media in Somalia has been in anarchy role of law for
two decades and half, they rarely contain nationalist and those who know the blimey
goodness of good governance and systems, thus the need for seminars and training
programs to strengthen these fellows are crucial.
Development of National Policy Plan: National policy plans govern to the
goodness of the society, media currently doesn’t have a policy that guides, controls
and takes a corrective action plan to those who break the law. According to this
research, the need for this plan is inexhaustible and unlimited.
Security Reinforcement for Media: Nowadays killing a journalist is familiar in
Somalia and in particularly the capital city Mogadishu, The Federal Government of
Somalia and its National Army (SNA) needs to boost its security capabilities to offer
media.
Mobilization through Media: Nationalism, good governance, conflict resolution
and peace building programs should be the main aim of media in order to double the
positive effect of media to the society.
Political Pressure to Media: Politicians should decrease their compression and
pressure to the public media, in order for the relationship between them be a
significant and favorable one.
5.4 Suggestions for Further Research
The Role of Media on Peace and Good Governance of Somalia.
The Effects of Media on the Economic Development of Somalia.
The effects of Media on the Civil War in Somalia.
The Role Media in Peace Building and Conflict Resolution.
58
REFERENCES
Amin M. E. (2005), Social Science Research: Concept, Methodology
Berry, D. (2008) “Journalism, Ethics and Society” pages 75-77, Ashgate Publishing
Limited (Farnham)
Corner, J., Robinson, P. (2006) 'Politics and Mass Media: A response to John
Street' Political Studies Review, vol. 4, pp 48-54.
David Brewer (2012) the Relationship between Journalists and Politicians. Indiana,
Kothari C.R. (2004), Research Methodology: Methods and Techniques Jaipur,
India, New Age International (P) Limited, Publishers.
Deutsche Welle – Global Media Forum (2008) Media in Peacebuilding and Conflict
Prevention. p.59-61.
[ [
Deutsche Welle – Global Media Forum (2009) Conflict Prevention in the Multimedia Age. p.69
[
Curran, J., Gurevitch, M. & Woollacott, J (eds) (1977) Mass Communication
and Society, London, Edward Arnold.
Deutsche Welle – Global Media Forum (2009) Conflict Prevention in the Multimedia Age.
Franklin, B. (1997) Newszak and News Media, Edward Arnold, London.
Garnham, N. (2000) Emancipation, the Media and Modernity, Oxford,
OxfordUniversity Media.
59
Hallin, D., Papathanasopoulos, S. (2002) 'Political clientelism and the media:
southern Europe and Latin America in comparative perspective',
Media Culture and Society, vol. 24:2, pp 175-195.
Himelfarb, Sheldon and Chabalowski, Megan (2008) Media, Conflict Prevention and
Peacebuilding: Mapping the Edges. United States Institute for Peace.
URL: http://www.usip.org/resources/media-conflict-prevention-and-peacebuilding-mapping-edges
Koven, Ronald (2004) An Antidote to Hate Speech: Journalism, Pure and Simple.
McCombs, M., Shaw, D. L. & Weaver, D. eds. (1997). Communication and Democracy.
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
McNair, D. and Siune. K. 1992 (eds),Media policy Convergence, Concentration
and Commerce, London: Sage.
Nations Office for West Africa (2005) UNOWA Workshop on Reporting for Peace. p.3-5
Noam, Eli (1991) Television in Europe. New York: Oxford University Media.
Pankowski, Rafal (2007) How to Understand and Confront Hate Speech.
Papathanassopoulos, S. (1997a) 'The Politics and the Effects of the
Deregulation of Greek Television', European Journal of
Communication 12(3), pp. 351-68.
Samaya T. (2005) Research Methods and Writing Research Proposal Cairo, Egypt,
University of Cairo Publishers.
Street, J. (2001) Mass Media, Politics and Democracy, Palgrave, New York.
Trueman, Harry S. URL: http://www.sayings-quotes.com/harry_truman_quotes/
60
Vineet Prakash, (2012) Mass Media And The World, New York
Weaver. (1998) Opposition and Disagreement: Newspapers' attitude during;
the dictatorship, Kastaniotis, Athens
Westphal, Florian (2004) The Right Information at the Right.
Time. URL:http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0013/001389/138983e.pdf page 27-29
Wolfsfeld, Gadi (2004) Media and the path to peace. p.8-10
Zakaria F. (2013)Social Media and Politics in East Africa. Case of Somaliland.
Zioutos, G. (1954), Introduction to the Media Science, Athens.
61
APPENDIX I: QUESTIONNAIRE
Dear Sir/Madam,
Greetings!
I am a Master of Arts in Diplomacy and International Relations candidate of Kampala University/
Hope University. Part of the requirements for the award is a Thesis. My study is entitled, The Role
of Somali Media on Politics , within this context, may I request you to participate in this study by
answering the questionnaire; kindly do not leave any option unanswered. Any data you will provide
shall be for academic purposes only and no information of such kind shall be disclosed to others.
May I retrieve the questionnaire within five days?
Thank you very much in advance.
Yours faithfully,
Ilyas Mohamed Abdulkarim
INFORMED CONSENT
I am giving my consent to be part of the research study of Ilyas Mohamed Abdulkarim that focused
on The Role of Somali Media on Politics . I shall be assured of privacy, anonymity and
confidentiality and that I will be given the option to refuse participation and right to withdraw my
participation anytime.
I have been informed that the research is voluntary and that the results will be given to me if I ask
for it.
Initials: ____________________________
Date: ______________________________
62
FACE SHEET
Code #_________ Date received by the respondent______________
RESPONDENT’S PROFILE
Age
__ 20-25
__ 26-31
__ 32-37
__ 38-43
__ 44-49
__ 50 and above
Gender
__ Male
__ Female
Occupation
__ Journalist
__ Politician
__ Civil Servant
Level in the Organization
___ Top Level
___ Middle Level
___ Supervisor Level
Marital Status
__ Single
__ Married
__ Widowed/ Divorced
Educational Level
___ Certificate
___ Diploma
___ Bachelor
___ Postgraduate Level
Years of Experience
__ 1- 2 Years
__ 3-4 Years
__ 5 Years and Above
Attention: 1=Strongly Agree, 2=Agree, 3= Disagree, 4=strongly disagree
Questions Ranking
1 2 3 4
1. Somali media broadcasts news that creates nationalism.
2. The Somali media focuses on ethics in their editorial part in broadcasting news.
3. Televisions and newspapers are the best sources of accurate newscast, while websites and
radios are foundations of erroneous news programs in the country.
4. Somali media is contributing to the good governance of the country.
5. Media and politics have been dwindling relationship between them for the last couple of
decades.
6. Media gets information from informal/casual sources with substandard editing.
7. Media has great “positive” impact on community mobilization and awareness.
8. . It is a business root cause why radios are nowadays outnumbering in Mogadishu.
9. Some of the Somali journalists are not very professionals in the field
10. One of the reasons why journalists are killed is that they provide inaccurate and or
unfavorable targeted personal information.
11. There is a significant relationship between the media and politicians in Somalia.
12. Politicians use media to advertise their political opinions, and their personal politics.
13. During elections, politicians have very good relationship with the mass media in Somalia.
14. Media is the fourth power in the country after the government’s three other systems.
15. Many politicians avoid media usage when they are no usage of it.
16. Media is powerful tool that can be used to stabilize the country.
17. Media is double-edged blade that can cause harm and good to the country.
18. Peace and good governance programs are tools that can boost country’s peace and
stabilization.
19. Use of media to create nationalists and mobilized community is the best way.
20. Giving training to journalists about good governance, peace and nationalism is a way to
minimize the side effects of media on society.
21. There is a strong need for bill/legal policy that guides the media to passed by the government
APPENDIX II: INTERVIEW QUESTIONS
1. What strategies do you think can be used to minimize the side effects of media to the
public community of Somalia?
2. How do you think that media can be best utilized for its goodness and positive
effects of the nation and the society?
3. What are the reasons can you mention that Somalia journalists are targeted by
Alshabab and the government of Somalia?
4. Why do you think Somali media e.g. websites and radios are nowadays
outnumbering in Mogadishu and entire of Somalia?
5. What is the role of media on the political situation in Somalia?
6. What are effects of Somali Media on the political stabilization, good governance and
economic development of Somalia?
7. When do politicians use mass media most? And why?
8. How can the relationship between media and politics be improved in a positive
sustainable manner?
9. Any other comments, recommendations and remarks you want to contribute to this
research on the role of Somalia media and politics.
____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________