Multiculturally Informed Therapy: Accompanying First Nations People of the Western Hemisphere
Transcript of Multiculturally Informed Therapy: Accompanying First Nations People of the Western Hemisphere
1
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
Multicultural Informed Therapy:
Accompanying First Nations People of the
Western Hemisphere
Paul Peterhans, M.Div.
Seattle University
4/22/2014
Author Note
Paul Peterhans, M.Div. Theology Chair, Seattle Preparatory School
Enrolled in Doctorate of Ministry Program with an
Interdisciplinary Focus
2
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
Correspondence for this article should be addressed to Paul
Peterhans, M.Div.,
Theology Chair, Seattle Preparatory School, 2400 11th Ave, East
Seattle, Washington 98102
Contact: [email protected]
Introductory Comments
This paper is the first of two, exploring Pastoral Therapy
with a First Nations Peoples focus. This first paper examines the
unique needs and cultural contexts and characteristics of North
American Native Peoples and ways in which pastoral therapy and
the various “treatments” associated with this “discipline” might
assist in the healing process. It is individual in focus and
first considers the my self-understanding within a multicultural
reality. It is accompanied by a second paper….
This second paper examines the social systemic and
structural realities of an “ethnocentric monoculturalism” that
both underlies the pastoral therapeutic field and its practices
and how these impinge and impact the effectiveness (or not) of
these practices and the therapeutic relationship. Implicit in
3
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
this examination is a decolonial critique along with a deeper
reflection on the underlying causes (mostly collective in nature
from my perspective and examination) of such an ethnocentric
monocultural worldview. Additionally, I investigate what caring
for one’s “soul” might look like not only from the perspective of
the individual therapist but more so from the perspective of an
entire culture or communities. This latter pint is most important
since within an indigenous worldview the healing of one
(individual) requires the healing of the other
(communal/collective). And I believe it is true of all individual
and communities – planetary and otherwise.
(10/25/14)
Context – Self-Understanding within Multicultural Reality
I am not a therapist per se. I am an educator – a
therapeutic educator, if you will – and I identify myself as a
contemplative-decolonial educator – one who cultivates a curative
(Moffett, 1994), therapeutic and healing environment and
experience for adolescent students – as well as adults on retreat
and in spiritual direction. The central focus of my educational,
4
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
“therapeutic” work is the spiritual – and in particular, the
contemplative (that is, transformative) – dimension of the gospel
(gospel as dharma, as a spiritual, transformative force alive in
all creation whether seen or unseen). I characterize the
“spiritual” as the deepest dimension of all life – requiring of
us a deep listening and “receptive apprehension” of what is, as
it unfolds within us, around us, and in all “things.” It is to
shift one’s “referent point” from oneself to an “ultimate
dimension” (or ultimate reality – Usen in Apache and Athabascan
worldviews {Weaver, 1998}), that is the “ground of being” and the
source of everything that is. In this “way of being” everything
is interconnected and “kin” – everything and everyone is equal
and possesses intrinsic value and “utility” (or purpose if you
will). This “worldview” informs my life and my work as a
spiritual, therapeutic educator. As such, anything – language,
policies, systems, behaviors, mental constructs, narratives, etc.
– that militates against and/or undermines the spiritual life and
growth of all creation (and most especially humans and in
particular those on the “margins” of dominant cultures – wherever
that may be on this planet) will become the subject of the
5
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
contemplative, de-colonial critique I employ as the necessary
truth-telling partner to the spiritual practices and teachings I
offer in my classroom and “counseling/spiritual direction office”
(McCaslin, 2005; Darder, 2012; Peterhans, 2012; Battiste, 2013).
That said, I often find myself in a therapeutic relationship –
whether one-on-one with a student (or colleague) or within the
context of the classroom. Therefore, I endeavor to design
curricula and create “constructivist classroom” environments that
provide balance for the students and a sense of freedom from the
limiting constraints of the modern educational system, as well as
for open space for students to construct their own meaning.
I am a white, middle-aged, middle-classed, hetero-sexual,
Roman Catholic male, born and bred in the Northwest Suburbs of
Chicago in the 50’s and 60’s in “wonder bread” neighborhoods. I
teach in and am Chair of the Theology Department in a privileged
(elitist?) and prestigious college preparatory Catholic, Jesuit
high school in Seattle – hardly the center of multicultural
consciousness. The student demographics are largely white,
middle/upper-middle and upper socio-economic classes. It is not
always a comfortable place for non-white students. And the
6
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
institutional culture is overwhelmingly male and white (or
European in the words of Russell Means – Peterhans, 2012) and
definitely “leaning” towards the neo-liberal globalized
capitalistic and modern-colonial matrix of power in terms of its
educational teleology and overall orientation (Hobgood, 2000,
Mignolo, 2011). In the de/post/anti-colonial perspectives, I am
everything that is wrong (imperialistic) in the world. And I am
okay with that apparent fact; aware of my limitations and the
need to diminish in that manner and learn nearly everything all
over, from the beginning. I am also aware of the privilege
afforded me as a result of all of my socio-economic, racial,
sexual, and religious markers. And I seek out ways to use that
privilege for the benefit of those who are oppressed and/or on
the margins of society and the planet – whether residing in the
U.S. or elsewhere in the world, whether human or one of the many
millions of other species and earth-systems. I hesitate saying
where I am in one of the three “white racial identity development
models” as outlined in Counseling the Culturally Diverse (Sue and Sue,
2013). I leave that to others to judge. Still, being where I am
at this stage in my life is indeed a unique “place” to be – if
7
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
one is open. It is my intention to learn from and be in dialogue
with various cultural approaches and world-views, and I do so
from a more interior perspective in terms of a transformation of
consciousness that I believe needs to occur for the necessary
social transformation(s) and multicultural consciousness and
practices (therapeutic and educational) to transpire (Cajete,
1994; Howard, 1999; Darder, 2002; Wilson &Yellow Bird, 2005;
Mignolo, 2011; Peterhans, 2012; Hooks, 2013). I am interested in
an “ethics of transformation.” That is, I believe I have been
given an ethical imperative and responsibility to undergo a
transformation of consciousness vital for the establishment of a
truly multicultural context to be long-lasting and sustainable
(Peterhans, 2012).
I am intimately aware that the overriding context of the
cultural paradigm in which I am situated is imperialistic,
violent, racist, sexist, classist and ageist. And that our
institutions, language, systems of thought and expression are
rooted in a colonial consciousness that is predominantly male,
heterosexually dominated (thus homophobic) in terms of how the
power structure is constructed – and it is Christian in terms of
8
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
its mythology (though not cosmology – for our cosmology is rooted
in capitalism and the view that creation represents the resources
for the manufacturing of mere stuff for human consumption and
waste). The United States – and all that that means
institutionally, economically, educationally, medically,
religiously, etc. – has been shaped on a Euro-centric (now
Euramerican) weltanschauung. And, unfortunately, much of the
cultural dimension of my Catholic “identity” (Moya & Hames-
Garcia, 2000) has been cloaked and shaped by these very same
realities, especially as this relates to the colonial
consciousness that brought a dehumanizing missionary zeal which
also became rooted in our educational institutions. It is a
reality difficult to ignore and, I believe, lies at the root of
why in the institution where I teach anyway (and most across the
United States), we find it so difficult to smoothly move to a
more egalitarian, mutually respectful (of all forms of diversity
– gender, income, race, learning styles and abilities, etc.) and
truly multi-cultural reality that is a more honest mirroring of
the human species in this planet. This “cultural null curriculum”
is what remains hidden, yet pervasive – hidden to white people
9
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
(especially white males – who hold the majority of power in
nearly all of our social [including religious] institutions) and
pervasive to everyone else – those we refer to as “people of
color.” Thus, there are white people and then there are people of
color – those who hold power and privilege in this culture and
those who do not. Even the term “diversity” in my mind, is
essentially a racist (and sexist, classist, and homophobic) term,
as it refers to those who are essentially outside of the power
structure and outside of the white frame of reference (Howard,
1999; Hobgood, 2000; Richardson, 2000 & 2012; Sue and Sue, 2013;
Peterhans, 2012).
Furthermore, take any one of the realities of our culture –
racism, sexism, classism, even clericalism (if you are a
“churchy” type) if you want – and you will see that these
manifestations of a distorted view of reality are deeply
entrenched in the human psyche and our mental constructs. They
also show themselves on at least three different levels: the
individual/personal (with its conscious, subconscious and
unconscious “thought” patterns and experiences),
institutional/systemic (various socio-cultural systems, family
10
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
systems, thought patterns, language, symbols, etc.), and
collective, especially as this is rooted in the collective
unconscious, inter-generational trauma and “teachings,” and
nature and the universe – each of which can be further subdivided
and classified in deeper and more subtle ways. (This three-part
schematic mirrors nicely, I believe, Sue and Sue’s Tripartite
Development Framework of Personal Identity, though with some
obvious psycho-spiritual differentiations.) These are the
cultural and social manifestations, as well as collective,
ancestral experiences of what Abbot Thomas Keating, OCSO calls
the “false self system” – a compensatory self created and
developed in early childhood as a way of protecting ourselves
from the pain suffered from abuse, neglect and ordinary
distortions passed onto us by our forebears (Keating, 1999). Our
theological term for this is “original sin” (our contemporary
terms are the dysfunctional family and the distorted self). This
false self is so deeply embedded in our individual psyches, our
institutional structures and our collective memory that it
requires both a heroic effort and a disciplined program for
addressing it if we will ever have any hope of dismantling it in
11
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
any reasonable and lasting manner whatsoever. And it is my belief
that we must address these personal, social and collective
distortions on all three levels in order to create the world –
school environments – we say we want for ourselves, our students
and children, and families, of any and all cultures (Cajete,
1994; Thornton, 1998; Thompson, 1998; Keating, 1999; Howard,
1999; McCaslin, 2005; Tisdell, 2007; Nhat Hanh, 2010; Isasi-Diaz
& Mendieta, 2012; Peterhans, 2012).
To know where I am and the psycho-cultural context in which
I am situated is one thing. To know where I need to go is
another. Gary Howard (1999) sums it up nicely, namely that;
I am convinced there is a prior and equally compelling need for White people, particularly White educators in the United States and other nations of the West, to look within ourselvesand realign our deepest assumptions and perceptions regarding the racial marker that we carry, namely Whiteness. We need to understand the dynamics of past and present dominance, face how we have been shaped by myths of superiority, and begin to sort out our thoughts, emotions and behaviors relative to raceand other dimensions of human diversity. It is essential in this inner work of multicultural growth that we listen carefully to the perceptions others have of us, particularly our students and colleagues from other racial and cultural groups…. We cannot fully and fruitfully engage in meaningful dialogue across the differences of race and culture without doing the work of personal transformation. If we as White educators are not deeply moved and transformed there is little hope that anything else will significantly shift…. As important as the inner work of personal growth is, however, it must be balanced with a vision of
12
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
multicultural education as a process of social change and transformation…. The second major theme… is an examination of the role White educators can and must play in understanding, decoding, and dismantling the dynamics of White dominance…. To hold in creative tension these two essential and inherently related themes: the personal transformation of White educators and thesocial transformation of the arrangements of White dominance.
First Nations Peoples of the Western Hemisphere
If the socio-cultural context I have described above is one in
which I am surrounded, then it is the same reality for Aboriginal
Peoples of the Western Hemisphere (Rae, 2005) – especially those
who inhabit the North American continental portion of this
hemisphere. That said, the psycho-cultural reality and context is
quite different – and this makes all the difference in the world.
I have to begin by saying that the value systems embedded in
the cultural worldviews of First Nations Peoples of North America
and that of Euro-Americans is vastly different – indeed,
diametrically opposed in almost every instance (Joseph B. Stone
in Sue et al, 2014; Coyhis, 2009). This creates a unique
challenge for everyone involved, especially for Native Peoples
who find themselves somewhere along the spectrum of “very
Traditional” and “very assimilated;” who many times are from two
13
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
or more tribes (of which there are over 560 federally recognized
tribes in the United States and hundreds more that are not
recognized, most of which are culturally different from one
another); who live in urban centers (2/3) and on reservations
(1/3); and where 50 percent of the urban Indians move back and
forth between the city and the reservation(s). Not only is there
a lot of movement among Indian people, but a large population
don’t know much (and at times know nothing) about their Native
culture due to the U.S. Federal Government’s Termination Policy
in the 1950s and 60s, as well as to the fact that many Indians
were adopted out of Native families during the 1950s through the
1970s (Coyhis, 2009; Sue et al, 2014; American Indian Relief
Council website).
Additionally, Coyhis (2009) and others (McCaslin, 2005;
Battise, 2013; Clark, 1991 & 2009; Dell et al, 2008; Duran et al,
2008; Fast & Collin-Vezina, 2010; Gone, 2009; Hagerty, 2012;
Heilbron & Guttman, 2000; Hill, Lau, Sue, 2010; Rae, 2005;
Peterhans, 2012; Wilson, & Yellow Bird, 2005; Walters et al,
2002; Thornton, 1998; Sue & Sue, 2013; Sue, Gallardo, Neville,
2014) address the reality of and seek to heal the ailments and
14
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
dysfunctions manifested both as a result of and a precondition
for intergenerational trauma over the five-plus centuries of
oppressive colonization. He and others believe this healing of
intergenerational trauma is a necessary ingredient during this
current era of self-determination and cultural revival in order
for this movement to be strong and to sustain itself over time.
The many forms of “dispossession” – whether by degrees or all
at once – have been well documented by many, many authors in
nearly all parts of North America (notably Forbes, 1979, 2008;
Deloria, Jr., 1969, 1988; Rae, 2005; Hagerty, 2012; Thornton,
1998; Wilson & Yellow Bird, 2005): land, minerals, religion,
language, communal ways of living, children through western
educational strategies (whether Boarding schools or Public
Schools), rituals and cultural ways – the list is quite
expansive. What Coyhis does that is quite brilliant is
demonstrate how traditional peoples grow up in (and as) a
“forest” whose peoples and communal structures and roles are
rooted in a “rich soil” of interconnectedness that includes
Elders’ teachings, ceremonies, spirituality, cultural values and
teachings, language and healing. All of these are largely “place-
15
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
based” and rooted in a particular land that was alive, familiar
like a grandmother and provided all that the people needed. It
gave life to their bodies and their ancestors who were constant
companions. As these were removed – especially the land –
traditional peoples’ lives were growing up from “impoverished
soil” at best, poisoned soil at worse. The interconnected nature
of their life-ways with all of the values associated with them
(grateful and cooperative, humble and generous, curious and in
intimate/familial relationship with nature, rooted in a timeless
nature of reality, grounded in the spiritual/religious dimension
of all life, in communion with the ancestors and the Unseen
Mystery, highly communal, inquisitive, culturally pluralistic and
one that valued Tradition, character, and honor) was not only
severed but decimated (see especially Hagerty, 2012) and in its
place was “offered” (violently imposed) the value system of, in the
first place, various European worldviews and then the American
madness (competitive, restless, and individualistic,
materialistic, self-important, temporally linear, acquisitive,
interfering, distrustful, segmented [i.e.: Religion was a
compartmentalized component of life], controlling, narrow group
16
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
identity and an over-identification with it, literate and one
that highly valued status and freedom). The result is that many
Native Peoples became aimless, rootless, alcoholic, domestically
abusive, depressed, lost, severely imbalanced….
Our people, they suffer from something…. A deep, embedded, genetic depression…. See…. Our people (Lakota) at one time… all Native Americans, had a very strong connection with the Creator, a very strong connection with Mother Earth, a very strong connection with nature, the forces of nature, all living things on this planet; and all of this was taken fromus, like that!!…. And we lost this connection with everything that we had and that’s where this depression comes from; a lot of our people are severely depressed and they don’t evenknow it and this depression is just now clinically diagnosedas the same thing soldiers suffer from when they return fromcombat. (Quoted from a Lakota rider and Viet Nam Veteran in Dakota 38 by Hagerty, 2012).
Worse still, Coyhis believes, is that “we started to sense
from the people that in our families, in our organizations and in
our tribes, we have lost the spiritual way. We have forgotten to
make spiritual laws a part of our daily decisions, for
individuals, organizations and communities alike” (Coyhis, 2009)
In addition to many communities losing their language, land
and traditional lifestyles, this loss of living in and from a
spiritual way is the “gift” of coloniality. Reclaiming them in
such a way that will lead to a “soul healing” will be a gift not
17
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
only to the various communities who take up that “project” but
one to the entire planet – even the “colonists” (Duran,
Firehammer & Gonzales, 2008).
In addition to the immense destruction that the colonial
project of modernity has done to Native Peoples through land,
cultural, language, tribal and family, spiritual and identity
dispossession, I have come to see the ways that western, Euro-
centric epistemologies and education have literally reshaped
indigenous brains and minds. It amounts to another form of
colonization that is perhaps, just as, if not more, insidious
because of how hidden and pernicious it is. I see it in the
people with whom I have come in contact and recognize it in the
critique of Richardson (2000 and 2010), Trudell (Rae, 2005),
Duran (Thornton, 1998), Cajete (1994), Russell Means (Peterhans
2012), and Forbes (2008). I have also seen it exquisitely
described by a West African Shaman of the Dagara Tribe, Malidoma
Patrice Somé (1998), in his book The Healing Wisdom of Africa: Finding
Life Purpose Through Nature, Ritual, and Community. For Somé, “going to
school was a radical act involving the sacrifice of one’s
indigenous self.” It involved the “unbearableness of cultural
18
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
repression.” In a more extensive quote, Somé has this to say
about his forced Western (French) education:
What I learned from my white teachers was considered poisonous, and even dangerous, to me and others. It was as if literacy destroyed the ability to learn the indigenous knowledge that I was trying to reclaim. With literacy had come a logic that was incompatible with the logic innate to the Dagara and other native peoples. It made me prone to doubt, incapable of trust, and subject to dangerous emotionssuch as anger and impatience. Worst of all, my Western perceptions of time were continually disturbing me in a culture in which timelessness prevailed…. Because of the Western consciousness I had absorbed and its grandiose notions of superiority, I was slow to accept any interference or intrusion from an indigenous worldview. It was as if one type of knowledge had colonized my thoughts, with a territorial instinct of the most vicious type. For example, my literacy came with a mind that loved to fit events into its various rational slots, it was prompt to dismiss them as primitive trickery unworthy of civilized thinking. As long as new knowledge did not fit the desired specifications for proper control, my Western-trained mind regarded it as an alien with hostile intention and thereforewould fight against it with patriotic pride. I realize now that what I thought was my civilized mind was in fact a rather narrow mind. The knowledge I had been exposed to in Western schools left a wide range of experience unexplored, and it was up to wise people in my village to help me learn to open up to all realms of knowledge of which I at that time was ignorant.
This quote, in my estimation, sums up cogently the
psychological experience of native peoples from around the world
(and not just from the Western Hemisphere). Somé was able to heal
through the careful and wise guidance of Shamanic healers from
19
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
his people. The traditions, rituals, medicine people, elders,
language, etc, were still intact in his childhood village when he
returned home after running from his French Catholic boarding
school. However, most First Nations Peoples in North America have
not been, and are not now, so fortunate. Their journey to healing
and wholeness is and will be much more arduous and challenging.
Given what has been described as the effect of coloniality and
the fact that it is ongoing and relentless, what sorts of
services and practices might best address the needs of Aboriginal
communities and persons?
Best Practices and Effective Services for Native Populations
Clinical Psychologist, Connie Hunt, describes the difference
in counseling modalities between a Western model and that of a
Traditional Native model. In her words: “Western modalities
assume a power differential. Traditional Native methods largely
promote a parallel model” (Sue et al, 2014). Additionally, she
states that in the case where linguistic, cognitive, and
emotional barriers are likely to impede or delay therapeutic
goals, it is the therapist’s responsibility to acquire greater
skills in order to listen more deeply, pick up possibly-missed
20
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
nuances and to provide essential care and consideration –
especially as these may be directed toward the existence of
behaviorally compromised immunity relative to unresolved grief and
historical trauma. The emergence of a collective energy can be
overwhelming, and a therapist must be mindful of this possibility
and provide for the client/relative’s well-being. In my spiritual
tradition, we call this psycho-spiritual dynamic the “unloading
of the unconscious” and while we focus mainly on the personal
unconscious, I am personally most concerned in both my students
and spiritual directees, the emergent intermingling of both the
personal and collective (i.e.: historical or intergenerational)
unconscious experiences – especially as these might attach
themselves to individuals’ negative mental constructs or
cognitive narratives that might further entrench personal
identification with these potent psycho-emotional “memories” (Sue
et al, 2014; Peterhans, 2012).
When considering best practices and effective services for
Aboriginal peoples, it is important, I believe, to be cognizant
of several central notions and possible responses:
21
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
First, Native peoples value healing, wholeness and balance
over treatment – note Coyhis’s coining of the term “Wellbriety”
over “sobriety” (2009). He demonstrates a beautiful integration
of the 12 Steps and Traditions with Traditional Native values and
worldview (in this case The Medicine Wheel). As Hill, Lau and Sue
(2010) state in the conclusion of their study on integrating
trauma psychology and cultural psychology; “While dominant
understandings of evidence-based practices privilege the flow of
knowledge from the scientist to the practitioner, an Indigenous
reformulation blurs the boundaries among the participants of
knowledge creation…. Involved parties in all localized
communities… engage in collaborative dialogue in the creation and
application of culture-centered traumatologic knowledge…. (Which)
facilitates a decolonizing and transformative process, one that
respects Indigenous communities’ sovereignty and rights to self-
determination” (45).
Second, regardless of the presenting problem, knowledge of co-
morbidity relative to conditions arising out of historical trauma
is essential. It amounts to what some authors refer to as “soul
wound” (Duran et al, 2008; Walters et al, 2002). Indeed, it is
22
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
not only helpful to name the historical trauma (colonization) but
to acknowledge its ongoing affects (coloniality); it is also
vital to name psychological conditions from the language and
metaphors of the cultural frame of reference of native peoples –
i.e.: depression then becomes the “spirit of sadness” visiting a
relative/client (Duran et al, 2008) and so on. In so doing, one
takes into account the relative/client’s sociohistorical context
and then is able to provide a liberatory process embedded in a
culturally appropriate praxis – for instance, use of Talking
Circles, purification rituals, and ceremonies that “call back the
client’s original spirit;” Traditional tribal worldviews,
cultural hybridity, and a concern for a person’s relationship to
the universal cosmology as opposed to “curing a culturally
defined psychological disorder” (Duran et al, 2008; Heilbron &
Guttman, 2000; Walters et al, 2002). And I am firmly convinced that this
can (and needs to be) done within an educational system. In this (a
liberatory, culturally appropriate praxis) and other senses
(telling the story of holocaust and genocide), historical honesty
and truth-telling (a central component of decolonization) are
vital to the healing process (Duran et al, 2008; McCaslin, 2005).
23
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
Third, community-based treatments and resolutions
(interventions – though not a term I like within an Aboriginal
worldview) are central to best practices and the possibilities of
establishing EBTs (Gone, 2009; Walters et al, 2002; Hill et al,
2011; Heilbron & Guttman, 2000; Duran et al, 2008; Dell et al,
2008). As Heilbron and Guttman point out, when utilizing
community-based treatment and solutions, the emphasis is not only on
individual healing but community healing as well. This works in a number
of ways. First, the use of a Healing Circle offers “a safe and
spiritually nurturing environment where unconditional support of
group members (is) evident” and in the case of this study,
provided an atmosphere where group members could “share their
feelings of (sexual) abuse and feel understood by others who
shared those same feelings and experiences. Cognitive therapy
interventions aided this process by initially emphasizing that
members shared similar concerns” (Heilbron and Guttman, 2000).
What followed was the added incorporation of traditional
ceremonies and practices, including a First Nations co-
facilitator. Out of this came profound healing for both the
individuals participating as well as the communities to which
24
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
they belonged – along with an intensifying and deepening of the
group healing of those participating in the healing circle. Other
culturally appropriate “practices” and “treatment” (or “cultural
moderators of traumatic stress and in some cases, substance use)
are an emphasis on family and community – in the case of urban
Indians, it sometimes is important for them to strengthen ties to
the reservation(s) along with urban organizations and support
systems – spirituality and re-traditionalization movements;
connection to land, animals, plants, drumming, songs, etc.
Critical in the healing process was the cultivation of a
strong Aboriginal or Indian identity. “A positive American Indian
(AI) identity has long been considered important for cultural
continuity, survival, and psychological wellness. In AI research,
identity has been conceptualized within three main frameworks:
demographic indicators, self-concept and self-perception, and
self-identification” (Walters, et al, 2002). Walters, in separate
research cited in this article, designed the Urban American
Indian Identity (UAII) model identifying four domains and five
identity attitude dimensions embedded within them. The four
domains are as follows: 1) Internalization; 2) Marginalization;
25
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
3) Externalization; and 4) Actualization, where one achieves
“integrated identity attitudes and (develops) psychological
buffers that combat residual colonizing attitudes.” And the five
identity attitude dimensions are referred to as PERCS: political,
ethnic, racial, cultural, and spiritual. Strengthening
individuals and communities within these frameworks amounts to
what some authors call “enculturation” or the “process by which
members of a minority group learn about and identify with their
cultural heritage, norms, and traditional values.” As the authors
conclude, “the indigenist stress-coping model provides an
important decolonizing conceptual framework” (Walters et al,
2002).
Gone (2009), conducting his own community-based treatment for
healing the effects of historical trauma takes this notion of
individual and community healing further by suggesting and
exploring the possibility that healing through the use of
“distinctly Aboriginal therapeutic services” provides a more
ambitious political objective, figuring “prominently in a
comprehensive, community-based decolonization agenda.” In his
words, Gone states that “decolonization is the intentional,
26
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
collective, and reflective self-examination undertaken by
formerly colonized peoples that result in shared remedial
action…. The key to decolonization is community emancipation from
the hegemony of outside interests” (Wilson and Yellow Bird,
2005). He acknowledges something I included at the end of the
previous section, where I stated that “their journey to healing
and wholeness is much more arduous and challenging” – “although
the prospects for decolonization in Native North America remain
fraught with challenges, contemporary tribal communities have
made recognizable progress in reasserting authority and wresting
control from settler society governments in multiple domains,
including tribal administration of therapeutic services” (Gone,
2009). The work this study conducted at the accredited North
Algonquian Healing Lodge with native counselors and clients alike
pushed the limits of evidence based treatment (EBT) and
culturally sensitive treatment (CST) due to the fact that
historical trauma (HT) “does not synchronize with the reigning
constructs of psychopathology in content, form, or function…
there are no consensually accepted diagnostic criteria for HT”
(Gone, 2009). That said, a number of practices (and by extension
27
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
treatments) were incorporated in this study that proved
efficacious and therapeutically applicable from an EBP/EBT
perspective: emphasis on disclosure and catharsis of childhood
pain, which mirrored “exposure treatment for PTSD”
(experimentally supported), and the “centrality of the twelve-
step approach to recovery from alcoholism in this setting” (Gone,
2009). Note the culturally specific sobriety program started in
the 1980’s and expanded upon by Don Coyhis to include historical
trauma from residential schools in the 2000’s (Coyhis, 2009).
In addition to these points above, it is vital for any
therapist, or in my case, therapeutic-teacher, to cultivate and
demonstrate authentic culturally sensitive empathy (Chung & Bemak,
2002), something that gets exhausting doing so in an institution
that on almost every level is just the opposite. Cultural
sensitive empathy manifests itself both emotionally and
cognitively (Sue and Sue, 2013) and is strongest when grounded in
six major dimensions. These are as follows:
Understand and accept the context of family and community for clients from different cultural backgrounds.
Incorporate indigenous healing practices from the client’s culture when possible.
28
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
Become knowledgeable about the historical sociopolitical background of clients.
Be knowledgeable about the psychosocial adjustment that mustbe made by clients who have moved from one environment to another. (This is especially applicable to my students of color who often come out of neighborhoods and “feeder” schools where their race, ethnicity and culture were well represented prior to enrolling at the predominantly white and elitist school environment where I teach.)
Be highly sensitive to the oppression, discrimination, and racism that are encountered by many people and often on a daily basis. (Again, this reality is pertinent to nearly allmy non-white students.)
For those clients who feel underprivileged and devalued, it is essential for effective cultural empathy to facilitate empowerment for clients (Chung and Bemak, 2002). (One of thegreatest challenges in my teaching is connecting non-white students to people and mentors with whom they can culturallyrelate and who can understand their experience going to the school where I teach. Luckily, I have been there long enoughwhere I now have many alums on whom I can call for guidance,mentoring and assistance – not only for current students butfor myself as well – and have on a number of occasions, successfully connected students with alum-mentors to the healing success of said students.)
Finally, I would be remiss if I did not include the EBP of any
counselor (and teacher) of practicing positive regard, respect,
warmth and genuineness as “qualities” of establishing an
emotional bond with a client/relative (Sue and Sue, 2013).
Indeed, I believe that these qualities are what make my teaching
of all my students most effective. If I consider student as
client/relative, my ability to practice and communicate
29
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
concretely positive regard, enables a student to see her strengths
and positive qualities and aspects; respect reveals that I am
attentive to my student and demonstrates that he is important to
me; warmth is the emotional feeling that enables a student to
realize that she is appreciated and accepted (so vital for any
teenager); and genuineness shows my students that I am real, that
I am willing to go beyond my roles and meet them where they are
(Sue and Sue, 2013). It enables me to “make contact.”
Creativity and working with another’s Strengths
In many ways, a number of the studies, attitudinal
dispositions and practices I have described above are suggestive
of effective practices and creative solutions and/or applications
of practices that incorporate at the same time culturally
sensitive treatment – or rather, healing. In this final section I
want to conclude with an example of a skillful and creative
approach to working with/healing First Nations Youth from solvent
abuse utilizing “horse as healer” as well as to suggest a
potentially creative response within an educational framework
that might lead to empowerment of Native Youth along with an
“other-side-of-the-equation” decolonization of Caucasian Youth.
30
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
In “Horse as Healer” (Dell et al, 2008) the authors examine
the efficacious healing work being conducted in one of Canada’s
numerous residential treatment centers addressing Native youth
solvent addiction. In this case the article discusses how
Canada’s Youth Solvent Addiction Committee (YSAC) culture-based
model of resiliency (developing traditional teachings relative to
morality, humour, creativity, initiative, relationships,
independence and insight) is put into practice at the White
Buffalo Residential Treatment Center through the example of
Equine Assisted Learning (EAL). The treatment center is located
on the Sturgeon Lake First Nation, near Prince Albert,
Saskatchewan. “The program is based on the concept of living
therapy, which integrates four cornerstones of treatment that
parallel teaching of the medicine wheel – spiritual, emotional,
mental, and physical” (Dell et al, 2008). Nurturing the inner
spirit is foundational in this program which is rooted in First
Nations teaching and healing – i.e.: fasting and sweat lodge,
etc.) In addition to these practices that strengthen a
participant’s inner spirit is the Center’s program of aligning
the youths’ connection to and reliance on the wider community
31
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
with whom they are in contact outside of the Center and its
treatment program. A decidedly First Nation’s worldview is
thoroughly effective where the Western concept of resiliency is
expanded to include not only the individual but the community as
well – especially as this reflects a “First Nations worldview to
see the world through the collective of community.”
Within a First Nation’s worldview, an individual is at the same time their inner spirit (internal) and relations with their collective community. Resiliency is ‘… a balance between the ability to cope with stress and adversity (innerspirit) and the availability of communal support’…. Specificattention was paid in this case to the historic and contemporary role of the horse within the lives of First Nations people. Both concepts which comprise YSAC’s definition of resiliency – the inner spirit of an individualand their community support – are illustrated using the example of EAL from the intersecting perspectives of White Buffalo’s volatile solvent abuse program, Cartier Equine Learning Center’s EAL program, and Elders’ stories (Dell et al, 2008).
EAL is a hands-on experience facilitating a unique form of
learning. “Given the horse’s superior intuitive nature, direct
interaction with it is a unique experience…. The horse’s
intuitive nature has evolved as a mere function of survival; it
is constantly attuned to its surroundings and the subtle
communication within the herd as a response to ever-changing
32
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
environments…. Horses (are) highly adaptive… (and) has the
ability to respond intuitively to human behavior and intent,
which results in immediate feedback from the animal…. (This has
resulted in) increasing life skills through hands-on doing, and
has been identified as useful in building communication problem-
solving, and team building skills, as well as enhancing personal
awareness and a sense of self” (Dell et al, 2008).
Three other findings are worth mentioning here. First, many
First Nations believe that “all animals have a spirit whose
purpose is to guide and help individuals. The animal spirit is
integral to survival…. The horse program gives youth some sense
of connection to another life form…. Through the horse, the youth
may be provided with opportunities to reflect on spirit and
identity, and apply an interpretation that is meaningful in their
own growth and self understanding” (Dell et al, 2008).
Second, due to the experiences and background of the youth
entering the program, fear, disconnection with others in the
community, and lack of trust (many are survivors of abuse),
hands-on experiences of nurturing and caring for ones horse have
led to outcomes where youth have been observed demonstrating a
33
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
sense of increased self-nurturance through self-care. “The
connection between self-care and trusting relationships with
oneself and others is a part of the cultural teaching at White
Buffalo” (Dell et al, 2008).
Finally, the youth learn to form trusting relationships with
themselves and others by beginning to learn to trust the horse.
In establishing this trusting relationship, they also learn to
look to others for support in their lives both inside and outside
of White Buffalo treatment center. Since trust has been severely
broken, this is no small matter. Growing in trusting an animal,
then oneself and finally others in the community, a youth slowly
but surely grows in faith and emotional stability.
The authors conclude their article by suggesting five “next
steps” for research to move the field of EAL forward,
particularly as it relates to First Nations community health, and
affirm the compatibility between YSAC’s culture-based model of
resiliency and a Western health promotion approach, stating
further that they complement one another. “Both account for the
individual and community approaches to understanding and
responding to health needs. And YSAC’s model further contributes
34
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
the understanding that the concepts of inner spirit and community
cannot be disentangled from one another, as is commonly done
within a Western worldview. An individual’s inner spirit is
intertwined with family, community, and the land” (Dell et al,
2008).
This notion or truth of “Horse as Healer” was powerfully on
display in the documentary Dakota 38. In 2009, a Lakota spiritual
leader and Viet Nam Vet, Jim Miller, led a group of men and women
on a 330-mile ride on horseback from Lower Brule, South Dakota to
Mankato, Minnesota where they arrived at the hanging site of 38
Dakota ancestors, warriors and leaders on the anniversary of
their mass execution on December 26th, 1862 on orders by
President Abraham Lincoln. The vision for this ride came from a
dream he had in 2005 where he was riding the Great Plains of
South Dakota and just before he awoke he arrived at a riverbank
in Minnesota where he saw 38 of his Dakota ancestors hanged. He
had known nothing of this mass execution and eventually concluded
that “when you have dreams, you know when they come from the
Creator…. As any recovered alcoholic, I made believe that I
35
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
didn’t get it. I tried to put it out of my mind, yet it’s one of
those dreams that bothers you night and day” (Hagarty, 2012).
At the beginning of the ride, he states that he has “been
through the course” – sexual abuse, emotional abuse, physical
abuse, spiritual abuse, spent time in Leavenworth Federal
Penitentiary, has blood on his hands (in fact he realized that
part of this ride was not only for the healing he and his people
need to experience at the colonial hands of Americans, but also
for the 38 Vietnamese he killed during the war). The suffering
held by the other riders is palpable and shared throughout the
film. This ride is as much for them individually as it is for
their families (broken by substance addiction, suicide, domestic
violence, etc.) – as well as the whole of their people. Again,
Jim Miller: “We can’t blame the wasichus anymore. We’re doing it
to ourselves. We’re selling drugs. We’re killing our own people.
That’s what this ride is about; is healing” (Hagerty, 2012). And
healing happens along the way – for Native and Non-Native
individuals and communities alike – especially for those riders
who greatly suffer from PTSD whether from the Viet Nam War or
from the extreme poverty and suffering on the reservations and
36
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
the weight of historical trauma ravaging their families and
communities. As to the healing significance of the horse in this
ride, one Native man described it thus:
The horse has the six directions that we use in our ceremonies. The two front legs represent the west and the north; the two back legs represent the east and the south. The head points up, the ears point up, represents Watakaya –Up Above. The tail points downward to Mother Earth. When youput those six directions together it creates a sacred centerto bring Wowakon in; the sacredness you can only have with these six directions. And you can pray while you are on yourhorse. You can think about a lot of things. Some people can remember things their ancestors went through. It’s the horseleading the way because of its healing power…. With that Wowakon inside the six directions, you place a man or a woman on a horse; you give it the seventh direction which isthe Chokota – the center of all things – it represents ‘everything-is-related-and-in-balance’ and you put all that together and you move forward, you’re able to create power as you go…. I learned a lot about the 38 plus 2 because while I was on that ride I could really look into the past and by sitting on that horse you realize, you have a lot of time to think…. They say that the Spirits are the ones leading the people. They are the ones taking us through thiscold weather, the elements; you see these elements are a part of life” (Hagarty, 2012).
And the healing and reconciliation happens along the way as
the sufferings of individuals, communities and the ancestors are
recalled, brought forth and embraced – suffering from war (in the
form of PTSD), domestic violence, residential school experiences,
alcoholism, white imperial oppression, historical depression and
37
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
more…. The suffering of individuals is embraced or better,
contained, by the community of riders, healed by the energy of and
sacred ceremony contained in the horses, washed over by the
songs, prayers and rituals – as well as by the welcoming of
native and white communities along the way. It is a powerful
example of “Horse as Healer” and of other indigenist spiritual
and cultural elements, teachings, value system and
characteristics that are so integral to deep, lasting and
profound healing.
As a High School teacher, I have great concern for
Aboriginal youth – both those living on reservations and those
inhabiting urban centers. In suggesting a proposed solution for
healing the invisibility – and all that comes with this
invisibility – of Native people (especially youth) in white
America, along with the suffocating privilege invisibly afforded
to white American youth, I intend to programmatically build on a
line cited at the top of page 20, namely that “an individual’s
inner spirit (i.e.: soul, identity, etc.) is intertwined with
family, community and the land” and offer a proposal emanating
from the heart of this line.
38
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
A Seattle Weekly feature article entitled “A Future for Rose:
The Story of Seattle’s Invisible Americans” (Driscoll, 2014)
discusses the immense challenges Seattle’s Native Americans face
day in and day out. It speaks to how they are rarely seen or
heard from, how they are not only the smallest minority (though
once were the only population of people residing here), but are
the poorest, least-supported educationally and with the greatest
health care problems. “Sometimes I don’t think they see us,” Rose
(Gibbs, 15 year-old Native female youth) says…. “To not have any
representation that reflects who you are, or honors your culture,
your tradition, your history, it’s really a profound
psychological, oppressive place to be,” says Sense-Wilson, Chair
of Urban Native Education Alliance or UNEA (Driscoll, 2014).
One of the first realities that Seattle’s Native youth are
forced to face or confront in order to change their fortune and
create opportunities for themselves is the sense of aloneness
that has been pounded into them by “politics, policy,
perceptions, and nearly 200 years of history.” Doing so is one of
the aims of UNEA’s flagship program, Clear Sky Program and the
Clear Sky Native Youth Council. Clear Sky and UNEA provide
39
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
“tutoring, art, a sense of cultural belonging and… a solid meal
to urban Native American kids who need it. As it turns out,
plenty in the Seattle area do” (Driscoll, 2014). Clear Sky held
its first meeting in 2009, largely, I believe out of response to
a growing neglect of Native youth on the part of the Seattle
Public School system. A tragedy really, as Native youth were
extremely well served until the policies and decisions of
Superintendant Goodloe, where a wildly successful Indian Heritage
High School – once housed at the Wilson-Pacific building (out of
which Clear Sky and UNEA now operate two days a week) – was
dismantled and eventually laid to waste from 2000 to 2012. Over
this time period the District withdrew support and resources and
now house the so-called “middle college” (alternative schools
that serve students of all demographics at risk of dropping out)
for Native youth in Northgate Mall. In other words, there is no
specific, culturally appropriate and supportive educational
institution for Native youth – their population is thrown in with
other “at-risk” youth of different ethnic and racial identity.
Ironic at best.
40
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
The original Indian Heritage High School was created in 1974
and found a home in the Wilson-Pacific school building. By the
mid-‘90s the school boasted 100 percent graduation rate (1994)
and became a national model of urban Native American education.
Under the leadership of Robert Eaglestaff, a Lakota from the
Cheyenne River Sioux reservation, the innovative school provided
public education to Native students while embracing cultural
identity and Native history. It worked – really, really well.
Currently the achievement gap widens, and while that is
important, it is not what I believe to be the most critical issue
at stake. Identity is – as well as a dismantling of the oppressive
white American imperialistic narrative and policies – political,
economic, and educational. As I see it, in order to strengthen
identity, decolonize the educational system – and thus the minds
of Native peoples and youth – and to have any hope of “closing
the achievement gap” there must be a serious attempt to address
what many in the native community are calling for: “Native-
specific curricula, more cultural inclusion, Native language
courses, and – primarily – a return of the District’s Indian
Heritage High School” (Driscoll, 2014).
41
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
I offer one addendum to the last phrase of the last line –
and I do so for a couple of reasons, both of which are based on
the research I have conducted and described above. First, it is
my dream (perhaps mine alone) to create a school that is
primarily for Native youth (actually for African American youth
as well, who are interested and open to creating culturally
appropriate curriculum from within their communities), but also
open to non-Native youth as well, where the curricula is Native-
specific, culturally inclusive, steeped in a decolonial, non-
Euro-centric – i.e.: non-Western, but indigenous and perhaps
cosmopolitan epistemologies and pedagogies – histories and
curricular trajectories in all subjects; Earth-centered (i.e.:
experientially rooted in nature and wilderness skills, etc.), and
surrounded by and embedded in Native language courses and inter-
spiritual practices and teachings – but mostly especially, Coast
Salish Life-Ways (thus Lushootseed language). This latter point
about inter-spiritual with a central focus on Coast Salish Life-
Ways is critical to this educational experiment; which brings me
to my second point or reason for such a school….
42
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
In a public school setting, study of religion or
spirituality – never mind actually practicing spirituality – is
impossible. Yet, within an Aboriginal worldview not practicing
and studying religion and spirituality undermines a truly
holistic education and development. And what I am proposing is
the creation of an educational system and curricula that not only
takes this domain into account, but makes it central to the
education itself. Additionally, since we are living in a
planetary community, everyone – students especially – would
benefit from being exposed to multiple approaches to life in the
Spirit and how to live that out in one’s everyday life. Again,
the centerpiece would be a spirituality rooted in Coast Salish
Life-Ways and other First Nations spiritualities – especially as
these might be reflected in the Native population who come from
the urban core – where other non-Natives could join in to the
degree that this would be culturally appropriate. But the main
point is the primacy of Aboriginal spirituality and
cosmology/religion.
Part of my reason for suggesting such a format is that
indigenous people around the planet have been and continue to be
43
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
forced to live in two worlds – one of their own choosing and the
other not of their own making. For decolonial studies,
epistemology and psychology to truly take root and disrupt Euro-
centric ontology, epistemology and pedagogy that are the
underpinnings of coloniality and Western hegemony and
Imperialism, while at the same time, laying the groundwork for “a
matrix of alternatives where we exit economic totalitarianism in
order to re-open the way to multiple histories in which each
human group, each society would define its own civilization, its
own culture, its own values, re-appropriating or re-inventing
them;” Whites of all European descent need to begin to live in
“two (or more) worlds” as well. Elsewhere I have called this
“project” a-coloniality (Peterhans, 2012) after Serge LaTouche’s
notion of “de-growth” developed in the documentary The End of
Poverty?: Think Again (Diaz, 2010) as well as in his book Farewell to
Growth (2009). Essentially, I believe it means that we must not
only delink from the “religion of economics” as a driving force
and teleological focus in education and all societies, as well as
from the structures that support them, but we must also dismantle
various forms of Euro-American privilege as these manifest
44
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
themselves in terms of sexual orientation, race, gender,
relationship with the Earth and other species, as well as in
terms of whiteness and social power. Living immersed in an
Indigenous world would be good for everyone.
Discussion
My final thoughts are basic and simple. It’s time to change
the social arrangements so that everyone has a place at the
table. It is also time to change the underlying psychological
framework, likely amassed over centuries and millennia of
intergenerational experiences and ancestral accumulation, as well
as day-to-day personal encounters. I believe that the personal
narratives that we hold, told over and over again from the
generations of family and “clan” storytellers, hold the key, if
only in beginning stages, to beginning to change the current
socio-cultural arrangements. According to Duran, Firehammer and
Gonzalez (2008), “Culture is a part of soul…. When the soul or
culture of some persons are oppressed, we are all oppressed and
wounded in ways that require healing if we are to become
liberated from such oppression. (It) is important to realize that
we have all been on both sides of the oppression/oppressor coin
45
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
at different points in our lives. It is also important to become
aware that a clear path toward healing must be undertaken by
individual counselors (teachers – anyone really!) as well as by
the mental health professions (educational systems) as a whole if
we are to realize new and untapped dimensions of our individual
and collective health and psychological liberation. In taking the
healing path, counselors (educators) will be able to provide
individual clients and the world community with much-needed
understanding of the way toward liberation and the fullness of
life in a manner that promotes harmonious interactions within the
overall web of the life-world.” Since, as they say, we are “all
part of a culture and not separate from it,” it seems like a good
time to be about the business of creating – or perhaps, re-
creating – a global culture that is reflective of reality; a
reality that is diverse, self-organizing (self-determinant) and
communal in nature. In other words, it is time that we all are
about the business of following the “healing path” because
whether we are oppressor or oppressed, each has deep
psychological and spiritual suffering underlying these different
but interrelated conditions. It is time we each open to the
46
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
“other” and create social conditions that will contain, sustain
and help each other flourish – right where we are planted.
But opening up to the other and creating social conditions
and structures that are more conducive to a flourishing human
diversity are not enough. In the contemplative spiritual
tradition in which I am situated, we speak of submitting to or
entering into the dynamic process of the Divine Therapy. This
requires deep trust and pure faith (via John of the Cross) to
submit to the profound psycho-spiritual healing initiated by the
Ultimate Mystery, the Divine Indwelling. In this spiritual
schema, we are willing to be alert to the unconscious or hidden
motivations in everything we do. Thus, we admit that more than
likely we are all “infected” with some type of emotional, social,
psycho-spiritual “disease” – or what we now call the human
condition – that manifests and has manifested itself personally,
systemically, and collectively over the millennia. Acknowledging
this reality – or “potential” if one is not yet ready to admit to
being a member of the sickest species on the planet (Keating,
1994) – is vital if any true and lasting healing is to take
place. Thus, according to Keating (1999):
47
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
If we don’t face the consequences of the unconscious motivation – through a practice or
discipline that opens us to the unconscious – then that motivation will secretly influence
our decisions all through our lives…. One needs a willingness to be exposed to the
unconscious. This requires courage and persistence. We can’tcall up the unconscious at
will…. When we are not thinking, analyzing or planning and place ourselves in the presence of God in faith, we open ourselves to the contents of the unconscious. We should do this gradually so as not to be overtaken by an overwhelming explosion of emotion…. The unconscious needs to be respectedand approached with prudence…. Contemplative prayer starts modestly, but as soon as it begins to reach a certain intensity, it opens us to the unconscious. Painful memories that we have forgotten or repressed begin to come to consciousness. Primitive emotions that we felt as children and that we have been compensating for may come to consciousness…. The divine therapy, like Alcoholics Anonymous, is based on the realization that you know where you are and that your life is unmanageable. We may be able to lead a relatively normal life, but there is no experienceof the true happiness that comes from letting go of the obstacles to the awareness of the divine presence. Spiritualawareness is designed by God to become our normal awareness.
The unfolding and deepening of the contemplative spiritual
process of the divine therapy, I believe, mirrors nicely the
“spiritual” life-ways of First Nations Peoples of the Western
Hemisphere. A profound spiritual program and path is essential to
not only dismantling the false self system and healing the
western psyche that is foundational to the colonial project that
48
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
manifests itself in all its racist (etc) expressions as these are
embedded institutionally and systemically, but it is also
supportive of nearly every Aboriginal worldview. If we are to, in
the words of Duran et al, “promote harmonious interactions within
the overall web of the life-world,” then a contemplative
spiritual vision and praxis will be indispensable for both healer
and healed, oppressor and oppressed, for everyone concerned. It
will be indispensable for cultivating a consciousness (a
transcultural consciousness) that is capable of listening to and
appreciating every culture, ethnicity and life-journey.
49
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
REFERENCES
American Indian Relief Council. History and Culture: Termination Policy – 1953-1968. Retrieved from http://www.nrcprograms.org/site/PageServer?pagename=airc_hist_terminationpolicy
Baptiste, M. (2013). Decolonizing Education: Nourishing the Learning Spirit. Purich Publishing Ltd., Saskatoon, SK, Canada.
Cajete, Gregory, Ph.D. (1994). Look to the Mountain: An Ecology of Indigenous Education. Kivaki Press, Durango, CO.
Chung, Rita C-Y and Bemak, F. (2002). The Relationship of Cultureand Empathy in Cross- Cultural Counseling. Journal of Counseling and Development. Vol. 80,pp. 154-59.
Clarke, J.F. (1991, 2009). A Gathering of Wisdoms: Tribal Mental Health: A Cultural
50
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
Perspective. Swinomish Tribal Health Project: LaConner, WA.
Coyhis, Don L. (2009). Understanding Native American Culture: Insights for Recovery Professionals and Other Wellness Practitioners, 2nd Ed. Coyhis Publishing, Colorado Springs, CO.
Darder, A. (2002). Reinventing Paulo Freire: A Pedagogy of Love. Westview Press/ Perseus Books Group, Cambridge, MA
Darder, A. (2012). Culture and Power in the Classroom: Educational Foundationsfor the Schooling of Bicultural Students. Paradigm Publishers, Boulder, CO.
Dell, C.A., et al (2008). Horse as Healer: An Examination of Equine Assisted Learning in the Healing of First Nations Youth from Solvent Abuse. Pimatisiwin:A Journal of Aboriginal and Indigenous Community Health, 6(1), 81-106.
Deloria, Vine, Jr. (1970, 1988). Custer Died for Your Sins: An Indian Manifesto. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.
Diaz, Philippe (2010). The End of Poverty? Think Again. Cinema Libre Studio, Canoga Park, CA
Driscoll, M. (2014). A Future for Rose: The Story of Seattle’s Invisible Americans. The Seattle Weekly. 39 (10), 8-16.
Duran, E., Firehammer, J., & Gonzalez, J. (2008). Liberation psychology as the path toward healing cultural soul wounds. Journal of Counseling & Development 86(3), 288-295.
Fast, E. & Collin-Vezina, D. (2010). Historical Trauma, Race-based Trauma and Resilience of
51
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
Indigenous People: A Literature Review. First Peoples Child and Family Review. Vol. 5 (1), 126-36. Forbes, J.D. (1979, 2008). Columbus and other Cannibals: The Wetiko Diseaseof Exploitation, Imperialism and Terrorism. Seven Story Press, New York.
Gone, J. P. (2009). A Community-Based Treatment for Native American Historical Trauma: Prospects for Evidence-Based Practice. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. Vol. 77 (4) 751–762.
Hagerty, S. (2012). Dakota 38. Smooth Feather Productions, Kezar Falls, Maine.
Heilbron, C.L., Guttman, M.A.J. (2000). Traditional Healing Methods with First Nations Women in Group Counselling. Canadian Journal of Counselling, 34(1), 3-13.
Heinrichs, S., Ed. (2013). Buffalo Shout, Salmon Cry: Conversations on Creation, Land Justice, and Life Together. Harold Press, Waterloo, Canada & Harrisonburg, Virginia.
Hill, J.S., Lau, M.Y., Sue D.W. (2010). Integrating Trauma Psychology and Cultural Psychology: Indigenous Perspectives on Theory, Research and Practice. Traumatology, 16(4), 29-47.
Hobgood, M.E. (2000). Dismantling Privilege: An Ethics of Accountability. The Pilgrim Press, Cleveland, Ohio.
Hooks, B. (2013). Writing Beyond Race: Living Theory and Practice. Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, New York and London.
52
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
Howard, G. (1999). We Can’t Teach What We Don’t Know: White Teachers, Multiracial Schools. Teachers College, Columbia University, New York.
Isasi-Diaz, A.M. & Mendieta, E. (2012). Decolonizing Epistemologies: Latina/o Theology and Philosophy. Fordham University Press, New York.
Jennings, K. (1995). Huchoosedah: Traditions of the Heart. KCTS, United States.
Keating, T. (1994). Intimacy with God. A Crossroad Book, New York.
Keating, T. (1999). The Human Condition: Contemplation and Transformation. Paulist Press, New York.
LaTouche, S. (2009). Farewell to Growth. Polity Press, Malden, MA, USA.
McCaslin, W.D., Ed. (2005). Justice as Healing: Indigenous Ways; Writings on Community Peacemaking and Restorative Justice from the Native Law Centre. Living JusticePress, St. Paul, MN.
Mignolo, W. (2011). The Darker Side of Western Modernity: Global Futures, Decolonial Options. Duke University Press, Durham & London.Moffett, J. (1994). The Universal Schoolhouse: Spiritual Awakening through Education. Jossey- Bass Publishers, San Francisco.
Moya, P.M.L. & Hames-Garcia, M. ed. (2000). Reclaiming Identity: Realist Theory and the Problem of Post-Modernism. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA.
53
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
Nhat Hanh, T. (2010). Reconciliation: Healing the Inner Child. Parallax Press, Berkeley, CA.
Peterhans, P. (2012). Teaching Contemplative Spirituality for a Trans-Cultural Consciousness: Towards an Ethics of Transformation. Paper written for and delivered atAESA Conference in Seattle, WA in Oct/Nov, 2012 on “Unity In/With Diversity.”
Rae, H. (2005). Trudell. Appaloosa Pictures, United States.
Richardson, T. & Villenas (2000). “Other” Encounters: Dances withWhiteness in Multicultural Education. Educational Theory. Vol. 50 (2) pp. 255-73.
Richardson, T. (2012). Disrupting the Coloniality of being: Toward De-Colonial Ontologies in Philosophy of Education. Studies in Philosophy and Education, 31 (6),539-551.
Somé, M.P. (1998). The Healing Wisdom of Africa: Finding Life Purpose Through Nature, Ritual, and Community. Jeremy P. Tarcher, New York.
Sue, D.W. & Sue, D. (2013). Counseling the Culturally Diverse: Theory and Practice. John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, New Jersey.
Sue, D.W., Gallardo, M.E., Neville, H.A. (2014). Case Studies in Multicultural Counseling and Therapy. John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, New Jersey.
Thomason, T.C. (1991). Counseling Native Americans: An Introduction for Non-Native American Counselors. Journal of Counseling and Development. Vol. 69,pp. 321-27.
Thompson, A. (1998). Not the Color Purple: Black Feminist Lessonsfor Educational Caring.
54
Multicultural Informed Therapy: First Nation Peoples
Harvard Educational Review, 68 (4), 522-555.
Thornton, Russell, ed. (1998). “The Trauma of History” by Duran, Duran & Brave Heart. Studying Native America: Problems and Perspectives.60-76. University ofWisconsin Press.
Tisdale, E.J. (2007). In The New Millennium: The Role of Spirituality and the Cultural Imagination in Dealing with Diversity and Equity in the Higher Education Classroom. Teachers College Record. Vol. 109 (3), pp. 531-560.
Walters, K.L., Simoni, J.M., Evans-Campbell, T. (2002). SubstanceUse among Native American and Alaska Natives: Incorporating Culture in an “Indigenist”Stress-Coping Paradigm. Public Health Reports, 117(1), S104-S117.
Weaver, J. ed. (1998). Native American Religious Identity: Unforgotten Gods. Orbis Books, New York.
Wilson, W.A. & Yellow Bird, M. ed. (2005). For Indigenous Eyes Only: A Decolonizing Handbook. School of American Research Press, Santa Fe, New Mexico.