Fingerprint of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in two populations of southern sea lions ( Otaria...
Transcript of Fingerprint of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in two populations of southern sea lions ( Otaria...
Pergamon
PII: S0045-6535(97)00003-9
Chemosphere, Vol. 34, No. 4, pp. 759-770, 1997 Copyright © 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
Printed in Great Britain. All rights reserved 0045-6535/97 $17.00+0.00
F I N G E R P R I N T O F P O L Y C Y C L I C A R O M A T I C H Y D R O C A R B O N S IN T W O
P O P U L A T I O N S O F S O U T H E R N SEA L I O N S (Otariaflavescens)
L. MARSILI **, M.C. FOSSI ' , , S. CASINI*, C. SAVELLI*, °B. JIMENEZ,
*M. JUNIN, *H. CASTELLO
*Dipartimento di Biologia Ambientale, University of Siena, Via delle Cerchia 3, 53100 Siena, ITALY.
°Departamento de Anb.lisis Instrumental y Quimica Ambiental, Institute of Organic Chemistry, CS.I.C,
Juan de la Cierva 3, 28006 Madrid, SPAIN.
~'Museo Argentino de Cencias Naturales "Bernardino Rivadavia", Av. Angel Gallardo 470, 1405
Buenos Aires, ARGENTINA.
(Received in Germany 7 October 1996; accepted 15 November 1996)
ABSTRACT
The fingerprint of 14 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) was investigated in biopsy, fur, blood,
liver and faeces of live and dead specimens of two Argentinian population of southern sea lion (Otaria
f/ave,sz:ens). One colony lives in Mar del Plata harbour which is particularly polluted with petroleum, the
second (control) colony lives at Punta Bermeja (Patagonia). The highest concentrations of the five
carcinogenic PAHs were found in the Mar del Plata sea lions. © 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved
INTRODUCTION
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are ubiquitous pollutants in all parts of the world [1], formed
by incomplete/inefficient combustion of organic materials, diagenesis and biosynthesis. Because they are
strongly hydrophobic, they are taken up readily by animal tissues The scientific interest in these compounds
principally concerns their carcinogenic, mutagenic and teratogenic effects 121. Some PAHs have been shown
to cause tumours in marine mammals [3] but there are few examples of cause and effect relationships. Here
Corresponding Author
759
760
we determined total levels of PAHs and their fingerprint in different biological material from live and dead
specimens cff southern sea fions (Otariaflavescens) living in two Argentinian colonies at Mar del Plata and
Punta Bermeja (Fig. t). The principal aim of the study was to determine wheter PAHs are implicated in the
health status of Mar del Plata sea lions. In this colony a high percentage of old sea lions have diseases of the
skin and mucous membranes with fur loss and baldness. Young and old sea lions often have tumours. A
preliminary study on organochlorine levels in organs and tissues of the Mar del Plata sea lions showed
significantly lower levels than in other marine mammals of the northern hemisphere and Mediterranean and
confirmed the existence of a metabolic imbalance between high toxifying and low detoxifying potential in
pinnipeds, as reported in other marine mammals [4-6]. There is little information on concentration of PAHs in
pinnipeds [7, 8] and marine mammals in general from the different oceans of the world.
Figure I - Study areas
MATERIALS AND METHODS
761
STUDY AREAS (Fig. 1)
The Mar del Plata harbour accommodates about 400 vessels, including coastal fishing boats, large
cargo ships, naval war ships and small yachts operating in the harbour on a daily basis. The water is heavily
polluted with oil, organic material and fish scraps from fish processing factories. The sea lion colony consists
of 650-750 males [9]. Faecal analysis showed that this colony feeds mainly on cod (Merluccius hubbsi),
mackerel (Trachurtts picturatus) and squid (llex illecebrosus) [10]. Punta Bermeja, in the San Matias Gulf,
Rio Negro Province, is not a polluted environment, but may be affected by pollution from the Rio Negro
river, which has intensive agriculture in its catchment area.
SAMPLING PROCEDURES
Samples of fur and faeces were obtained in a completely non invasive way from several members of
each colony. Fur samples were cut with scissors. Blood and biopsy samples were obtained from a few sea
lions in each colony after anaesthetising them with a mixture ofketamine and rompum Peripheral blood was
obtained from the hind-flipper capillary network, and biopsy samples from the hind-flipper surface Biopsy
samples include skin as well as subcutaneous fat. Liver was obtained from dead animals in a good state of
conservation. Three livers were obtained from Punta Bermeja sea lions and one from Mar del Plata sea lions.
The samples were sent to the Department of Environmental Biology in Siena for chemical analysis and other
studies.
ANAESTHETIC DRUGS
Anaesthetic darts were shot with a blow-gun with the help of a member of the Fundacion Fauna
Argentina (Mar del Plata). The mean dose was 3.17 mg/Kg rompum (range: 1.42-5.33 mg/Kg) and 2.78
mg/Kg ketamine (range: 1.42-5.60 mg/Kg). Apnea and thermoregulatory disturbance were the two most
common side effects of anaesthesia. An analeptic drug, doxapram, was injected ira. to improve the general
respiratory and cardiac condition of the animals.
PAH ANAL YSIS
PAHs were analysed by HPLC/Fluorescence system. Extraction was carried according to Griest &
Caton [11] and Holoubek et al. [12], with some modifications. Samples were extracted with a mixture of
KOH/methanol (1/4). Extraction with 200 ml of cyclohexane was performed to obtain the PAH fraction,
which was purified in a chromatographic column containing Florisil. The organic fraction was concentrated
to 1 ml in acetonitrile and analysed by HPLC with fluorescence detection. A reversed-phase column
(Supelcosil LC-18, 25 c m x 4.6 mm i.d., 0.5 lam particle size) was used with an acetonitrile/water gradient.
The initial concentration of the gradient was 60% acetonitrile, increasing over 20 rain to 100% acetonitrile,
and then remaining stable for 10 rain. The flow rate was 1 ml/min. Quantification was carried out using an
762
external standard consisting of 16 PAHs from Supelco (EPA 610 polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons
mixture). Table 1 lists the 14 PAHs studied, with their molecular formulae, molecular weights and
carcinogenic properties
Table 1 - Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons investigated (0 = not carcinogenic; =1= = uncertain or weakly carcinogenic;
++, +++ = strongly carcinogenic [13]).
Naphthalene Naph
Ace Acenaphtheoe
Fluorene FI
Phcnanthrene Phen
Anthracene Ant
Fluoranthene Fit
Pyrene
Benzo(a)anthracene
Chrysene (93%)
Benzo(b)fluoranthene
Bcnzo(k)fluoranthene
Benzo(a) pyrene
Dibenzo(a,h)anthracene
Benzo(g,h,i)pervlene
Pyr
B[a]A
Chry
BIbIF
Blklr
BIaIP DlahlA
B[ghi]Per
CIoH8
C12Hs
Ct3HI0
CI4HI0
CI4HI0
C16H10
CI6HI9
CII~Ht2
CI~HI2
C29H12
C2oH12
CIoH12
C22H14
C22H12
128.2 0
152.2 0
166.2 0
178.2 0
178.2 0
202.2 0
202.2 0
228.3 +
228.3 +
252.3 ++
252.3 0
252.3 +++
279.2 +++
276.3 0
The results were expressed in ng/g dry weight (d.w) or fresh weight (£w). Recoveries ranged between
80 and 98% in all samples.
To calculate the water content of samples, about 1-5 g of fur, liver, biopsy, faeces or blood were
placed in an oven at 100°C for 24 h. The percentage of water was 1-3% in fur, 60-70% in liver, 8-13% in
biopsy, 75-85% in faeces and 80-90% in blood.
The extracted organic material (EOM%) from freeze-dried samples was 38.5% + 3.0 for liver (n=4),
10.4% + 12.1 for faeces (n=17), 1.4% + 0.9 for blood (n=6) and 48.1% + 18.9 for biopsy (n=6).
STATISTICAL ANAL YSIS
The data was processed by summary statistics and ANOVA using Statistica and Excel (Microsoft)
programs for a significance level (p) of 0.05.
763
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Total PAHs found in both colonies studied are summarized in Table 2. Total PAHs content was
calculated as the sum of the 14 single PAHs. The main components of these residues were low molecular
weight PAHs.
Table 2 - PAH concentrations (ng/g d.w.) in fur, biopsy, blood, l iver and faeces of sea lions from the Mar del Plata
and Punta Bermeja colonies ( ~ = arithmetic mean; S.D. = standard deviation).
FUR 1
BIOPSY 3
B L O O D 3
LIVER M.dP. n=l;
P.B. n=3
FAECES 4
521 / 379 /
2785 1676 578 263
1393 422 2294 1295
527 / 274 182
408 82 424 94
In the Mar del Plata colony, the PAH concentrations decreased in the following order: biopsy > blood
> liver = fur > faeces. In the Punta Bermeja colony, the pattern was rather different: blood > biopsy > faeces
> fur > liver. It is worth noting that the higher concentration of PAHs was not always in the Mar del Plata
samples. In fact total PAHs in the blood of the Punta Bermeja sea lions were about twice those of the Mar
del Plata animals. PAHs were about the same in faeces and fur of the two colonies. PAH levels in livers were
low in relation to fat content which was high (EOM% = 38.5). This may be because most of the PAHs
detected, especially those found in high concentrations, were the 6asiest to metabolise. PAHs are metabolised
by the microsomal mixed-function oxidase system (MFO), often termed aryl hydrocarbon hydroxylase
(AHH), which is most abundant in the liver. Hence the liver operates as a demolisher of these contaminants
rather than an accumulator. This is why liver concentrations of PAHs were not correlated with total lipids. It
is therefore better to give PAH concentrations in terms of dry weight of tissue
There were interesting differences in PAH fingerprint between the various biological materials and
between the two colonies. In fur of the Mar del Plata sea lion (Table 3), acenaphthene (32.7%) accounted for
the largest percentage of total PAHs, followed by pyrene (128%), chrysene (11.9%) and anthracene
(11.8%). The five most carcinogenic PAHs (see Table 1) accounted for 20.49% of the total (Fig. 2). In fur of
the sea lion from Punta Bermeja, acenaphthene (33.4%) again accounted for the largest percentage of total
PAHs, but was followed by naphthalene (22.4%), fluoranthene (157%), phenanthrene (15.7%) and
anthracene (13.9%). The five most carcinogenic PAHs accounted for only 0.97% of the total (Fig. 2).
764
¢,f) "1-
"6
!
20 '
15
10
. F u r IB iopsy r-qBIood
I L i v e r 1 Faeces
0 ' / I I Mar del Plata Punta Bermeja
Figure 2 - Percentage of carcinogenic PAHs (Benzo(a)anthvacene, ChtTesene, Benzo(b)fluoranthene, Benzo(a)pvrene and Dibenzo(a,h)anthracene) in sea lions fi'om the colonies of Mat" del Plata and Punta Bel'meja.
Table 3 - PAH fingerprint expressed as concentration (ng/g f.w.) and percentage of total PAHs in the fur
of a sea lion each of the hvo cohmies (% = i)ercentage of Total PAHs).
i
I Iiiiiiiiiii i i ii i i !iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii iii i / i i !! i ii iiiiii iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii I, iiiiiiiiiiiiii lliiiiiiiiiiiiiii! i!iiiiiiiiiill iiiiiiiiiiiiiiii Naphthalene 8.120
Acenaphthene 165.2
Fluorenc 4.100
Phenanthrenc 28.47
An[hracenc
Fluoranthcne
b, rene
Benzo(a)anlhracene
Chn~sene (93%)
59.81
47.57
64,91
5.890
60.15
31.49 Benzo(b) fluoranthene
Benzo(k)fluoranthene 6.660
Benzo(a)p.vrene
Dibenzo(a.h)anthracene
2.97[)
3.070
1.58
32.7
0.81
5.63
11.8
9.40
12.8
1,16
11.9
6.23
1.32
0.59
0.61
3.44
82.33 22.4
122.8 33.4
11.34 3.08
55.18 15.0
14.29 13.9
57.91 15.7
17.18 4.67
1.170 0.32
0.760 0.21
0.940 0.26
0.810 0.22
0.230 0.06
0.90O 0.24
2.310 0.63 Benzo(8,h,i)pe~lene 17.40
765
Fur is the first compartment to come into contact with these contaminants which may be in the water or
on the shore. PAHs are not metabolized in the fur Hence the percentage composition of the various PAHs in
this compartment could reflect the kind of contamination of the area studied. We found that total PAHs in fur
did not differ significantly between the two stations, but their fingerprints were quite different. Low
molecular weight PAHs which are more readily metabolized and are not carcinogenic, accounted for about
95% of the total in the fur of the Punta Bermeja sea lion, and the five most toxic were less than 1% of the
total. In the Mar del Plata sea lion, 20% of the total consisted of these carcinogenic PAHs. It therefore seems
that the two colonies come into contact with two different PAH mixtures, one consisting only of non toxic
PAHs and the other containing the five most carcinogenic ones up to 20%.
The skin biopsy specimens also included blubber; these tissues are the first area of accumulation and
metabolisation of contaminants absorbed by this route. Many enzymes, including benzo(a)pyrene
monooxygenase, metabolize these substances in the skin [14]. The greatest difference in total PAHs between
the two colonies was found in this compartment, with the Mar del Plata sea lions having levels five-fold those
of the other colony. Table 4 shows that naphthalene, acenaphthene and phenanthrene were the three most
abundant in both colonies, accounting for 68.0% in the Mar del Plata sea lions and 74.8% in the controls.
The five most toxic PAHs accounted for 5.40% and 1.79% of the total, respectively (Fig. 2).
Talfle 4 - Fingerprint of PAHs expressed as concentration (ng/g f.w.) and percentage of total PAHs in biopsy of sea
lions from the two colonies (n = number of samples; "~ = arithmetic mean; S.D. = stamlard deviation; % = percentage of
total PAHs).
l liiiiii!i!ii!i!!!iii!ii!!i!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiill ill,ill iii i i i l ! i ~iiiii~i~iiii!iii!i ii!ii!ilil ii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!iill i i i i i i!iii i i i i i i i i i i i I
, :i::~i ~i~ i~?:/~:~/~:~i:~iii~i i::::~ii:~:~::~:~::::i::::iii::i~i~:i:i:i:~: i :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ::~:j:~:::~:~::~::~:~:~:~:~::~:~:M:~:~:~: ==================================================================== ~:::~:i:iii:ii:~!~:~:~::::~:~!:~ ~?~??::~:: •
Naphthalene 536.8 257.2 23.3 138.8 139.4 24.4
Acenaphlhene 588.9 717.3 20.0 101.6 35.17 20.5
Fluorene 121.6 78.94 4.55 29.81 0.270 4.51
Phenanthrene 599.8 317.5 24.7 161.5 100.3 29.9
Anthracene 174.3 101.7 6.87 39.34 11.35 8.69
Fluoranthene 176.2 112.5 6.93 24.98 7.240 5.34
~,rene 156.6 76.60 6.49 23.06 4.330 5.13
Bcnzo(a)anlhracene 12.88 2.520 0.63 1.870 1.230 0.34
Ch~'sene (93%) 8.910 3.000 0.57 3.130 4.090 0.53
Benzo(b)fluoranthene 54.21 53.65 2.59 1.430 0.860 0.28
Benzo(k)fluoranthene 13.82 14.67 0.46 1.280 0.400 0.27
Benzo(a)pyrene 28.69 16.84 1.14 3.160 2.400 0.53
Dibenzo(a,h)anthracene 27.85 37.63 0.47 0.650 0.140 0.11
Benzo(~,h,i)perylene 45.43 51.91 1.43 4.310 3.(190 0.87
766
PAHs found in blood samples are presented in Table 5. In blood of controls, total PAHs were double
the levels found in blood of the Mar del Plata sea lions. The main components were again naphthalene,
acenaphthene and phenanthrene which accounted for 75.4% in Mar del Plata animals and 78.6% in Punta
Bermeja sea lions. No significant difference was found in the percentages of the five most carcinogenic PAHs
in the two colonies; these were 1.80% and 1.53% respectively (Fig. 2).
Table 5 - Fingerprint of PAHs expressed as concentration (ng/g d.w.) and percentage of total PAHs in blood of sea
lions from the two colonies (n = number of samples; ~ = arithmetic mean; S.D. = standard deviation; % = percentage of
total PAHs).
~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iiii~iiii!iii~ii~:i~ii~ii~:~:~i~iiiiii!i!!!~i~ii!!i~iiiiiiiiii!iiiiiiiiii i iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!!! i!!!ii!!i!ii!!!i!iiii!!~:!~i!~ ii5 ::iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!!!i!ii!i!i!i!!i!ii
[ii iiiiii iiiiiiii iii ii ii ii iiiii iii iiiiii i N~iiiiiiiiii!iiiiiJiiiiiiiiiiii;Jiii:ii iiiii:iJ i:iii; i:ili!i!i! i;iiil i[i iii iii!!: ~i: i :iii~!iii !ii iiiii !ii iiiii !ili ii iil iiiiiiii iii i li~iNii }iii}iiiiiiiiiiiiiliii iiii}ill i i}~i i! i iii i i!i: [!ii i iiii ii i iii iill ~iii i iiiii; iliil i iiill ]ii ilii:i iii i:!ii iii i~iN i: ii i:ii ii ii!ii iiiiiiiiliiiiiiiiiiiii:i[iiiiiiiiiiii~Niii!iiiii:iii:iiiiiii:iii::!;:!iiil Naphthalene 383,8 363.0 24.4 827.8 931.7 29.4
Acenaphthene 391,4 99.40 30.1 559.0 110.5 27.5
Fluorene 62.53 22.35 4.44 102.1 43.00 4.66
Phenanthrene 289,7
81.32
86.70 20.9 460.5 149.7 21.7
Anthracene 13.92 6.03 100,3 19.74 4.96
Fluoranthene 64.35 5.620 4.96 92.88 26.82 4.46
Pyrene 82.93 3.48(I 6.25 1(17.8 31.28 5.14
Benzo(a)anthracene 4.640 1.(11(I 0.34 7.810 2.620 0.37
Ch~,sene (93%) 2.870 3.450 0.26 6.080 2.010 0.33
Benzo(b)fluoranthene 7.620 2.800 0,61 9.180 0.900 0.47
Benzo(k)fluoranthene 3.670 0.320 0.27 4.980 1.680 0.23
Benzo(a)pyrene 6.030 4.860 0.43 3.750 3.420 0.23
Dibenzo(a,h)anthracene 2.25(I 1.300 0.16 3.040 0.970 0.13
(I.86 Benzo(t~.h.i)per¢. lene 8.680 8.000 7.560 10.83 0.34
The PAH fingerprint in liver is shown in Table 6. In the Mar del Plata sample, the most abundant PAHs
were naphthalene (62.5%) and benzo(g,h,i)perylene (13.3%); in the Punta Bermeja samples they were
naphthalene (44.9%), phenanthrene (19.2%) and acenaphthene (10.8%). The five most toxic PAHs
accounted for 8.22% and 1.57% of the total, respectively (Fig. 2), which is five times higher for sea lions
from Mar del Plata. This confirms the greater abundance of these components in Mar del Plata harbour.
Because of their complex structure, the liver cannot metabolize them completely and they accumulate.
767
Table 6 - Fingerprint of PAHs expressed as concentration (ng/g f.w.) and percentage of total PAHs in liver of sea lions
from the two colonies (n = number of samples; ~ = arithmetic mean; S.D. = standard deviation; % = percentage of total
PAHs; N.D. = not detected).
II :ii:: !iiiii!ili:iliiiiiiiiiiii:i::i;:!ii:i!i:il i [ ::i:iii~:i:ii:i:i:i ] ] ~i~iiiiii!iiiiii!i!i!:i!iliiiii!ilili:iiiiiiii:i:i ~i iii Naphthalene 194 62.5
2.62
76.23 54.07 44.9
Acenaphthene 8.12 17.41 14.52 1 (I. 8
Fluorene 9.14 2.95 6.9311 6.060 4.31
Phenanthrene 27.1 8.74 30.91 21.75 19.2
Anthracene 0.30 0.10 10.57 2.2711 6.57
Fluoranthene 0.27 0.119 9.270 1.100 5.76
[ Pvrene 14.2 4.58 11.33 9.840 7.05
Benzo(a)anthraccne 3.12 1.01 0.270 0.350 0.17
Cho,sene (93%) 18.1 5.84
Benzo(b)fluoranthene 0.13 0.04
! Benzo(k)fluoranthene 7.21 2.33
4.12 Benzo(a)p.vrene
Dibenzo(a,h)anthracene
1.33
13.3 Benzo(g,h.i)perylene
N . D .
0.89(I
0.670
13711
N.D.
0.990
ND.
/ /
0.120 0.55
1.150 11.42
1.270 11.85
/ /
1.100 0.62 41.2
Table 7 - F ingerpr in t of PAHs expressed as concentration (ng/g d.~v.) and percentage of total PAHs in faeces of ~ a
lions from the two colonies (n = number of samples; ~ = ar i thmetic mean; S.D. = s tandard deviation; % = percentage of
total PAHs).
I IIIIIIIIEIIIIII~II iliill i !~ ~ :iiiii ii~i ~!~ !3 ' !ill iiiii!!!!ii!!!ii!iiiiiiiiili ~iSil!?"':'!:'::!!" '!!i i i i iii! !ii iiilil iEiiiii i : !III!IIIIIIIII!!!IIIII~!~IIIIIE 151 ? ? ~ i! i!iiiiii iii :: i?
Naphthalene 179.0 79.97 42.4
Acenaphthene 39.71 15.18 9,78
Fluorene 15.95 1.070 3,98
P h e n a n t h r e n e 92.41 19.56 25.4
Anthracene 20.61 5.570 5.33
F luo ran thene 14.87 2.33(I 3.67
Pvrenc 17.35 4.790 451
Benzo(a)anth racene
Chrysene (93%)
Benzo(b)fluoranthene
Benzo(k)fluoranthene
Benzo(a)pyrene
Dibenzo(a,h)anthracene
Benzo(g,h,i)perylene
1.2511
8.200
7.55(I
0.690
6.390
13 (18
(1.32
2.03
2.94
222.2
18.54
15.59
58.54
25.36
3/I.19
29.15
1.4311
5.150
11,15
85.51 51.1
17.611 4.75
1.380 3.78
11.02 14.5
20.74 5.75
13.57 7.14
17.41 7.10
1.040
7.950
8.060
039
1.10
2.56
0.530 0.240 0.12 1.35(I 1.4110 0.38
1.710 1070 0.42 2.540 1.560 11.69
0.770 0.200 11.22 2.080 1.5511 11.58
4.1170 1,0911 0.88 2.360 1.050 11.64
768
Table 7 shows PAHs in faeces. As reported in Table 2, total PAHs were almost the same in the two
colonies. Naphthalene and phenanthrene were the most abundant PAHs, accounting for 67.8% and 65.6% of
the total in the Mar del Plata and control colonies respectively (Table 7). The percentage of carcinogenic
PAHs in the two colonies was 6.29% and 5.07% respectively (Fig. 2). There were therefore no significant
differences in excretion of PAHs in the two colonies.
The results of the analysis of fur and biopsy suggest that sea lions from Punta Bermeja come into
contact with a less toxic mixture of PAHs than the sea lions of the other colony. An index of the metabolic
capacity of a sea lion can be obtained by calculating the ratio of PAH intake by contact (levels in biopsy) and
PAHs excreted in the faeces. In fact PAHs are mostly excreted through the faeces and the amount excreted
in the urine is about one-fourth to one-fifth that excreted in the faeces [15]. The higher this ratio, the lower
the metabolic capacity & t h e animal. For the sea lions ofPunta Bermeja we obtained a ratio of 1.36, versus
5.34 for the Mar del Plata colony (Fig. 3A). A ratio of one means that all PAHs absorbed are excreted; the
ratio of the harbour sea lions means that only about a fifth of the PAHs absorbed are excreted. If we consider
only the carcinogenic PAHs, the result is surprising. Mar del Plata sea lions had 145.89 ng/g d.w. of these
compounds in biopsy and 21.60 ng/g dw. in faeces. The ratio is therefore 6.75 (Fig. 3B) which means that
less than one sixth is excreted. In control sea lions, the same quantities were 11.26 ng/g d.w. in biopsy and
21.44 ng/g d.w. in faeces. Excretion was about double the quantity absorbed through the biopsy (ratio 0.53,
Fig. 3B). This suggests that PAHs are also absorbed by other routes, such as ingestion via food and water
and inhalation.
3A 5.34 1.36
B i o p s y ~ Faeces
Mar del Plata
Biopsy Pun~ Bermeja
Faeces
3B ~ F a e c e s
Biopsy 6.75
Mar del Plata
Biops!
0.53 Punta Bermeia
:aeces
Figure 3 - Ratio of Total PAHs in biopsies and faeces (3A) and ratio ofthe sum of the five carcinogenic PAHs in biopsies and faeces (3B) in the sea lions from the colonies of Mar del Plata and Punta Bermeja.
769
It can be concluded that the high levels of PAHs in the biological samples of sea lions at Mar del Plata,
especially the high percentage of carcinogenic PAHs, are related to the poor health of the animals in this
colony. As this study was only a preliminary one, it will be interesting to see whether the results are
confirmed by more detailed research involving a larger number of samples and the study of PAH fingerprints
in sea water and soil.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to thank Mr. Juan Antonio Lorenzani and Mr. Julio Lorenzani of Fundacion
Fauna Argentina, Mar del Plata, Argentina, Mr. Edgardo Miguel Intrieri of the Reserva Faunistica de Punta
Bermeja "La Loberia", Viedma, Argentina, and Dr. Clorinda R. Costa, Viedma, Argentina, for providing
samples. This research was financed by the EC (Contract No. CI ! *-CT94-0018).
REFERENCES
[1] LAW, R.J. (1986). Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in the marine environment: an overview ICES
Coop. Res. Rep., 142: 88-100.
121 LIPIATOU, E. & SALIOT, A. (1991). Fluxes and transport of anthropogenic and natural polycyclic
aromatic hydrocarbons in the western Mediterranean Sea. Mar. Chem., 32:51-71.
[3] MARTINEAU, D., LAGACE, A., BI~LAND, P., HIGGINS, R., ARMSTRONG, D. & SHUGART, L.R.
(1988). Pathology of stranded Beluga whales (Delphinapterus leucas) from St Lawrence estuary, Quebec,
Canada. J. Comp. Path., 98:287-311.
[41 WATANABE, S., SHIMADA, T., NAKAMURA, S., NISHIYAMA, N., YAMASHITA, N, TANABE, S. &
TATSLrKAWA, R. (1989). Specific profile of liver microsomal cytochrome P-450 in dolphins and whales. Mar.
Enviroo. Res., 27:51-65.
[5] FOSSl, M.C., MARSILI, L., LEONZIO, C., NOTARBARTOLO DI SCIARA, G., ZANARDELI.I, M. &
FOCAPJgI, S. (1992). The use of non-destructive biomarkers in Mediterranean Cetaceans: preliminary data on
MFO activity in skin biopsy. Mar. Poll. Bull., 24(9): 459-461.
[6] Fossl, M.C., MARSILI, L., JUNIN, M., CASTELLO, H., LORENZANI, JA., CASrNI, S., SAVELLI, C.,
LEONZIO, C. (1996). Use of nondestructive biomarkers and residue analysis to assess the health status of
endangered species of pinnipeds in the southwest Atlantic. Marine Poll. Bull., in press.
770
[7] HELLOU, J., STENSON, G., NI, I.H. & PAYNE, J.F. (1990). Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in
muscle tissue of marine mammals from the northwest Atlantic. Marine Poll. Bull., 21(10): 469-473.
[8] HELLOU, J., UPSHALL, C., NI, I.H., PAYNE, J.F. & HUANG, Y.S. (1991). Polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons in harp seals (Phoca groenlandica) from the northwest Atlantic. Arch. Environ. Contain.
ToxicoL, 21: 135-140.
[9] LORENZANI, J.A. & LORENZANI J. (1992). Resultados preliminares de marcacion de lobos marino
de un pelo, Otariaflavescens de la colonia del puerto de Mar del Plata. Re,~tm. Va. Reun. Espec. Mamif.
Acuat. Amer. Sur. (28/9/92-2/10/92 Arg): 41.
[10] BALDAS, M.I. (1985). Estudio sobre la poblacion y alimentacion del lobo marino, Otaria
flavescens, del area Marplatense. Informe T6cnico n°l, CONICET, Bs.As., Argentina, 89 pp.
[11] GRIEST, W.H. & CATON, J.E. (1983). Extraction of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons for
quantitative analysis. In: Handbook of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Ed. by Biorseth, A., Marcel
Dekker, INC.: 95-148.
[12] HOULOBEK, I., PAAS1VIRTA, J., MAATELA, P., LAHTIPERA, M., HOLOUBKOVfi,, I., KORINEK, P.,
BOt~CEK, Z. & C./~SLAVSK~', J. (1990). Comparison of extraction methods for polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbon determination in sediments. Toxicol. Environ. Chem., 25:137-154.
[13] NRCC (1983). Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in the aquatic environment: formation, sources,
fate and effects on aquatic biota. National Research Council Canada, 18981: 1-209.
[14] FOSSl, M.C., CASTELLO, H., JUNIN, M., LORENZANI, J.A., LORENZANI, J., MARSILI, L., LEONZIO,
C., CASINI, S., SAVELLI, C., LARI, L. & MONACI, F. (1996). Use of a nondestructive biomarker approach for
hazard assessment in sea lion (Otaria flavescens) populations in the southwest Atlantic. Sixth SETAC-
Europe Anmtal Meeting, Giardini Naxos Taormina, Sicily, Italy, 19-22 May 1966:192.
[15] BECHER, G. & BJORSETH, A. (1983). Determination of occupational exposure to PAH by analysis
of body fluids. In: Handbook ofpolycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons; Ed by Bjorseth, A. & Ramdahl, T.;
Marcel Dekker, INC.; 2(7): 237-252.