Committee of Ministers - rm .coe. int/C

SECRETARIAT / SECRÉTARIAT SECRETARIAT OF THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS SECRÉTARIAT DU COMITÉ DES MINISTRES Contact: John Darcy Tel: 03 88 41 31 56

Date: 05/07/2019

DH-DD(2019)750

Documents distributed at the request of a Representative shall be under the sole responsibility of the said Representative, without prejudice to the legal or political position of the Committee of Ministers.

Meeting:

1355th meeting (September 2019) (DH)

Item reference: Action plan (01/07/2019) Communication from Ukraine concerning the cases of Burmych and Others, Ivanov and Zhovner group v. Ukraine (Applications No. 46852/13, 40450/04, 56848/00)

* * * * * * * * * * *

Les documents distribués à la demande d’un/e Représentant/e le sont sous la seule responsabilité dudit/de ladite Représentant/e, sans préjuger de la position juridique ou politique du Comité des Ministres.

Réunion :

1355e réunion (septembre 2019) (DH)

Référence du point : Plan d’action Communication de l’Ukraine concernant les affaires Burmych et autres, Ivanov et groupe Zhovner c. Ukraine (Requêtes n° 46852/13, 40450/04, 56848/00) (anglais uniquement)

DGI

SERVICE DE L’EXECUTION DES ARRETS DE LA CEDH

01 JUIL. 2019

DH-DD(2019)750: Communication from Ukraine. Documents distributed at the request of a Representative shall be under the sole responsibility of the said Representative, without prejudice to the legal or political position of the Committee of Ministers.

MIHICTEPCTBO JOCTHLJ,IÏ YKPAÏHH

Byn . ropo.Qe~bKoro, 13, M. K.-,ïB, 01001

Ten.: +380 44 278-37-23, cpaKc: +380 44 271-17-83

E-mail: [email protected]

http://www.minjust.gov.ua

Ko,Q €APnOY 00015622

tu_ rY !.tYf N2 /)lJ/i:i .l/43 -/t/ 1

Ha N2

r 7

As ta the execution of the Court 's judgment in the lvanov/Zhovner/Burmych groups of cases

Dear Sir,

Mr Fredrik Sundberg

Head of Department Ad Interim Department for the execution of judgments of the European Court of Human Rights Directorate General 1 - Human Rights and Rule of Law

Council of Europe F-67075 Strasbourg Cedex

Herewith please find enclosed the updated action plan for the execution of the Court' s

judgments in cases of Yuriy Nikolayevich Jvanov (application no. 40450/04), Zhovner group of

cases (application no. 56848/00) and Burmych and Others v. Ukraine (application no. 46852/13).

This information has been also sent by e-mail.

Encl : on /é[. pages.

I

\) /

Ivan (i,JSHCHYNA , ··

./

9-:~puty'Mini'ster - Agent before the.-Eûropean Court of Human Rights

UB M iHic1 epcn10 1on11tùï YKpaïH11 5388/5.2 .1 /23-19 Bi.Q 02.07.2019 7

i 11111111 1111 1111 111 111111111111111

Ln

0 Ln .....

1

Annex to the letter of the Agent of Ukrainebefore the European Court of HumanRights of 2 July 2019

Updated Action Planon measures to be taken for implementation of the Court’s judgments in cases ofYuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov (application no. 40450/04), Zhovner group (application

no. 56848/00) and Burmych and Others (application no. 46852/13) v. Ukraine

CASE SUMMARY

These cases relate to the important structural problem of non-enforcement ordelayed enforcement of domestic judicial decisions, mostly delivered against the Stateand State-owned or controlled entities, and to the lack of an effective remedy in thisrespect (violations of Articles 6 § 1, 13 and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).

In October 2010, the Court delivered a pilot judgment in the Yuriy NikolayevichIvanov case. It indicated that specific reforms in Ukraine's legislation andadministrative practice should be implemented without delay to resolve this problemand set a deadline of 15 July 2011 for the creation of an effective domestic remedy inthis respect. The Court further invited the respondent State to settle on an ad hoc basisall similar applications lodged with it before the delivery of the pilot judgment (1,600)and decided to adjourn the examination of similar cases. Given that the measurescalled for by the Court in its pilot judgment were not adopted within the deadlineset, in February 2012 the Court decided to resume the examination of the frozenapplications raising similar issues.

On 12 October 2017, the Grand Chamber delivered its judgment inthe Burmych case. It noted that, despite the significant lapse of time sincethe Ivanov pilot judgment, the Ukrainian Government had so far failed to implementthe requisite general measures capable of addressing the root causes of the systemicproblem identified by the Court and to provide an effective remedy securing redress toall victims at national level.

Bearing in mind its efforts in examining Ivanov-type cases for over 17 years, theCourt concluded that nothing was to be gained, nor would justice be best served, bythe repetition of its findings in a lengthy series of comparable cases, which wouldplace a significant burden on its own resources, with a consequent impact on itsconsiderable caseload.

It thus decided to strike the Ivanov follow-up applications (12,143 cases) out ofits list of cases and found that the grievances raised in these applications had to beresolved in the context of the general measures to be introduced by the authorities atnational level, as required by the execution of the Ivanov pilot judgment, including theprovision of appropriate and sufficient redress for the Convention violations,measures which are subject to the supervision of the Committee of Ministers. The

DGI


01 JUIL. 2019


2

Court envisaged that it might be appropriate to reassess the situation within two yearsof the delivery of the Burmych judgment.

GENERAL MEASURES

At the outset the Government would like to express profound gratitude to theCouncil of Europe, its Secretariat and the Human Rights Trust Fund for theircontinuous technical support and inspiration given in order to reform the system ofexecution of the domestic court judgments. In this regard, please be assured thus farsolution to a complex and long-lasting problem of the non-enforcement of judgmentsis a first priority task for Ukraine. It worth noting that recognising human rights andfreedoms, including respect for the rule of law and access to justice, is enshrined inthe Constitution of Ukraine and domestic legal acts, and considered to be the utmostvalue.

Following the Committee of Ministers previous examination of the above groupof cases at their 1348th meeting in June 2019, the Government of Ukraine remainpleased for assessing of the progress made in order to take individual measures and,thus, would like to provide for complete information on the just satisfaction and therespective domestic judgments which were enforced in the remaining cases ofZhovner/Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov group (see Annex I attached). Further informationin this regard will be submitted to the Committee at the earliest possible date.

The authorities have already noted that with the assistance of the Council ofEurope project “Supporting Ukraine in execution of judgments of the European Courtof Human Rights” they seek appropriate solutions for the problems identified throughthe National Strategy for implementation of general measures for execution of thepilot judgment in the cases of Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov v. Ukraine and Burmych andOthers v. Ukraine (the draft concept paper was submitted to the Committee on30 May 2019).

The above National Strategy aims at bringing the Ukrainian legislation andpractice further in line with standards of the Council of Europe in the area ofenforcement of domestic court judgments. It focuses on the European Court findingsand decisions/resolutions of the Committee of Ministers, as well as recentdevelopments of national practice and legislation.

After the 1348th Committee of Ministers meeting the Government Agentforwarded the draft version of the National Strategy to all competent authorities forexamination and granting proposals to its concept.


3

The date of the Interdepartmental Working Group meeting is currently expectingfor adjustment. During the IWG meeting its members will discuss an action plan forimplementation of the proposals for improvement of the problems specified within themain categories ( 1)legislative and regulatory measures of preventive nature;2) specific institutional measures; 3) financial measures; 4) statistical and fact-findingmeasures and 5) establishing remedies) of the National Strategy and indentify thetimelines for measures stated therein. Further, the adopted action plan will be bindingupon the relevant authorities and the Government of Ukraine as a whole.

It should be noted that the Government of Ukraine continue their work in orderto enforce the courts’ judgments by the competent authorities: Pension Fund ofUkraine, Ministry of Social Policy, the State Bailiffs Service (including enforcementof judgments under the Law of Ukraine “On State guarantees concerning execution ofjudicial decisions” of 2012). Moreover, the State Treasury Service of Ukraine workson the execution of judgments delivered before 1 January 2013, with funding ensuredby the 4040 budgetary programme.1 Whereas the collection of the relevant statisticaldata in this regard is prescribed by the special procedure, this information will beavailable later in due course.

As of today the Government of Ukraine intensify their efforts in order to findappropriate solutions of the problem of non-enforcement or delayed enforcement ofdomestic judgments, including through improvement of the legislation andimplementation of good practices. The Government ask the Committee of Ministers torest assured that national authorities will do their best to bring this matter to asatisfactory conclusion.

CONCLUSIONS OF THE RESPONDENT STATE

The Government of Ukraine would like to make an emphasis on ourcommitment to the European values, principles and standards of the protection ofhuman rights when executing the European Court’s judgments. They will submitupdated information on the outstanding issues by 15 July 2019.

1 In December 2014 the Law “On Amending and Revoking Certain Statutory Acts of Ukraine” conferreddiscretionary powers on the Government to set the level of social benefits, based on the framework provided bydomestic legislation. In 2011 and 2012 the Constitutional Court ruled that this was in conformity with theConstitution.


ANNEX I to the Government of Ukraine updated action plan of July 2019

Zhovner/Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov group of cases

No Name of the applicant App. no. Enforcement of the domesticjudgment

Payment of just satisfaction

Case of Vasilyev and others v. Ukraine(application no. 29266/08 and 248 others)Date of Definitive Judgment: 13/02/2014

Payment Deadline: 13/05/2014ZHOVNER GROUP

1. Aleksandr NikolayevichVASILYEV 29266/08

According to the letter of Kherson СityCouncil of 17/02/2015, decision of thedomestic court in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.

On 10/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 12/11/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 472, 50.

2. Oleksandr VasylyovychLUZGANOV 32422/08

According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in theDnipropetrovsk Region, judicial decisionsin applicant’s case were enforced in full.


3. Melaniya IvanovnaULYANOVA 12890/09

As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol. Therefore, it is not possible toreport the outcome of the enforcementproceedings regarding to the applicant.The enforcement proceeding in the presentcase was terminated on 11/04/2019.

On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38142,74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on19/06/2015 – to the applicant bank account.On 19/06/2015 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 658, 95.

4. Mykola IvanovychOMELCHUK 37392/09

Enforced. On 15/12/2016 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 1457, 89.


5. Irina Alekseyevna BOBROVA 45792/09

According to the letter of the StateTreasury Service of Ukraine of10/04/2015, decisions of the domesticcourt were enforced in full.


DGI


01 JUIL. 2019


https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng#%7B%22appno%22:%5B%2212890/09%22%5D%7D



6. Anatoliy YevgenyevichTURCHIN 66137/09

Enforced. On 31/03/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 4578, 46.

Mr Turchin failure to submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38142, 74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on31/03/2015 – to the applicant bank account.On 31/03/2015 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 738, 75.

7. Vladimir AnatolyevichKLIMOV 70163/10

According to the applicant’s statement,decision of the domestic court wasenforced in full.

Mr Klimov did not submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38142, 74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on14/01/2015 – to the applicant bank account.On 14/01/2015 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 658, 95.

8. Petro Fedorovych ROMANOV 46191/11


On 10/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 25/12/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 2 133, 72.

9. Lyudmyla MykhaylivnaMOSKALENKO

132/12Enforced. On 04/02/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 6081.


10. Alla Vladimirovna BORTNIK 8442/12Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 27981, 59.


11. Svitlana OleksandrivnaALEKSEYEVA

10513/12Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 30943, 10.


12. Mykola KostyantynovychMALTSEV

10965/12Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions inamounts of UAH 2725 and UAH 1733, 86.










13. Yuriy IvanovychMASHCHENKO

11180/12

Enforced. On 13/10/2014 and on25/12/2014 – the applicant was paid theoutstanding debts according to thedomestic court’s decisions in amounts ofUAH 11737, 80 and UAH 19070, 29.

On 10/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 12/11/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 636, 21 andUAH 390, 98.

14. Aleksandr PavlovichYAKOVENKO

11335/12

Enforced. On 21/01/2016 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 15 645, 64.

Mr Yakovenko did not submit to the StateBailiff Service his full banking details on time.On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38142, 74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on21/01/2016 – to the applicant bank account.On 21/01/2016 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 928, 75.

15. Nikolay Pavlovich SARAMUD 18821/12Enforced. On 23/12/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 3 916, 60.

On 23/12/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 32893, 52)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 12/11/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 493, 60.

16. Eduard AnatoliyovychDOMANSKYY 28474/12



17. Vasiliy Ivanovich GOLOVIN 28881/12

Decisions of the Leninskyy District Courtof Kharkiv of 25/03/2010, 05/07/2010,22/07/2011 and 25/08/2011 are notenforceable due to the death of theapplicant on 09/09/2015.


18. Nataliya MykolayivnaLESHCHENKO

33382/12Enforced. On 21/11/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 135123, 49.


19.Yuliya LeonovnaYAKOVENKO 36525/12

As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol. Therefore, it is not possible toreport the outcome of the enforcementproceedings regarding to the applicant.

On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38142, 74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on04/12/2015 – to the applicant bank account.On 04/12/2015 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 658, 95.









The enforcement proceeding in the presentcase was terminated on 15/04/2019.

20. Galyna Vasylivna SHAKHRAY 36530/12

According to the European Court’sjudgment in case of “Velikoda v. Ukraine”(application no. 43331/12, final on03/06/2014), present application must bedeclared inadmissible, as manifestly ill-founded.Thus, domestic court’s decision is notenforceable.


21. Anatoliy IvanovychLEVCHENKO

37313/12According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine of 25/12/2014, judicial decisionin applicant’s case was enforced in full.


22. Andriy IvanovychKRAVCHUK

38786/12Enforced. On 20/11/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 38504, 31.


23. Mykhaylo OleksandrovychBARYSH



24. Vasyl IvanovychZHYRNOKLYEYEV

38872/12According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in ZaporizhzhiaRegion, judicial decisions in applicant’scase were enforced in full.


25. Aleksandr VladimirovichPOGORELOV

39625/12

Enforced. On 12/01/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 2 172.

Mr Pogorelov did not submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38142, 74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on12/01/2015 – to the applicant bank account.On 12/01/2015 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 696, 95.








26. Viktor PetrovychSHAPOSHNIKOV

39633/12Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 31 813, 80.


27. Mykola IvanovychLEGKOKONETS



28. Petro GrygoriyovychTKACHENKO



29. Anatoliy Vasilyevich DIDENKO 41920/12



30. Tatyana AnatolyevnaKOVALEVA

41923/12



31. Valentina Petrovna KOVBAN 41926/12



32.Varvara ZakharovnaNAZARENKO 41927/12











33. Anatoliy PavlovychKAMARDASH

44936/12


On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38142, 74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on26/12/2014 – to the applicant bank account.On 26/12/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 1 607, 05.

34. Andrey NikolayevichYAREMCHUK

45528/12According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine, judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.


35. Yelena IvanovnaKHUSTOCHKINA

45910/12



36. Dmitriy AnatolyevichKHUSTOCHKIN

45913/12



37. Tatyana IvanovnaANNENKOVA

45920/12



38. Iryna Grygorivna TOLKACH 46270/12Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 41 61.


39. Mariya Fedotovna IVANOVA 46853/12Enforced. On 12/01/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1 497, 74.

On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38142, 74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on12/01/2015 – to the applicant bank account.









On 12/01/2015 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 685, 55.

40. Lidiya Andreyevna PINDIK 46854/12



41. Zoya AlekseyevnaSHUMEYKO

46855/12



42. Anna LeonidovnaMOISEYEVA

46856/12



43. Vladimir Grigoryevich BABKA 46858/12



44. Sergey VladimirovichSKACHKO

47115/12

Enforced. On 12/01/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 460.


45. Valentina NikolayevnaBLIZNYUK











46. Irina Dmitriyevna SKACHKO 47120/12



47. Yuriy Mikhaylovich OLEYNIK 47122/12



48. Svetlana NikolayevnaSAVCHUK

47123/12



49. Lesya Igorivna KOSTYUK 47241/12Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 5 572.


50. Oleg Ivanovych MALENKO 47335/12



51. Vitaliy Yakovych NIMETS 47570/12According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Poltava Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


52. Nataliya VolodymyrivnaYADCHENKO

47965/12 Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts according

On 10/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.









to the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 26436, 10.


53. Alyona Yuriyivna TKACHOVA 48501/12Enforced. On 18/02/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 26233, 23.


54. Galina Ivanovna BLOKHINA 48578/12



55.Leonid IvanovichPRISTINSKIY 48611/12



56. Lyudmila VasilyevnaPALCHIKOVA

48676/12



57. Zinaida Grigoryevna KEKINA 48684/12



58. Svetlana ValeryevnaKARATNYUK

48692/12










59. Alfred Andreyevich KHABLAK 49024/12



60. Yevgen MykhaylovychYAMPOLSKYY



61. Yanina StepanivnaRUCHYOVA

50568/12Enforced. On 01/03/2016 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 12556, 98.


62. Galina Fedorovna PUCHKOVA 51349/12



63. Valentina FedorovnaTARASENKO

52383/12



64. Petr KharitonovichTARASENKO

52386/12



65. Yelena Ivanovna BRIDKO 52393/12Enforced. On 13/01/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1 028, 25.











66. Volodymyr MykolayovychCHYGARYOV

52457/12In accordance with the case files, thejudicial decisions in applicant’s case wereenforced in full.


67. Volodymyr VolodymyrovychVYGIVSKYY



68. Vasyl VolodymyrovychVYGIVSKYY



69. Oleksandr OlegovychNAUMOV



70. Vladimir NikolayevichVOLOBUYEV

53299/12



71. Tatyana MikhaylovnaVOLOBUYEVA

53309/12



72. Yuliana VolodymyrivnaMATVIYCHUK



73. Olga MykolayivnaBOLISHCHUK


Ms Bolishchuk did not submit to the StateBailiff Service her full banking details on time.










to the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 8 209.

On 30/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on31/10/2014 – to the applicant bank account.On 25/12/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 555, 75.

74. Lyudmyla VasylivnaNEVMERZHYTSKA

54951/12According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine, judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.


75. Lyudmyla MykhaylivnaBONDAR



76. Ivan Pavlovych GUBATENKO 57922/12Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1 020.


77. Valeriy MykolayovychKHRUSTIN



78. Nikolay AleksandrovichSPODIN

58860/12

On 30/09/2014 – the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 6 510 was transferredto the special deposit account of theMinistry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to applicant for providing hisbanking details, but he did not respond toany of them.Thus, on 24/12/2015 the sum was returnedto the State Budget.On 30/12/2015 – the enforcementproceeding in applicant’s case wasterminated.

Mr Spodin did not submit to the State BailiffService any information on his full bankingdetails.On 30/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 523, 60were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of UkraineThe Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing his banking details, buthe did not respond to any of them.Thus, the sum was returned to the State Budget.As of today, applicant has not applied against adecision on termination of the enforcementproceedings to the domestic court.







79. Oleg LeonidovychLAGANOVSKYY



80. Sergiy MykolayovychGRYSHCHENKO

59580/12Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 19 097.


81. Nadiya PylypivnaSMORZHANYUKOVA



82. Zoya VasilyevnaAFANASYEVA

59956/12



83. Valentina FedorovnaBELUKHA

59957/12



84. Larisa AlekseyevnaBONDARENKO

59960/12



85. Natalya SevastyanovnaKAPSHANINOVA

59986/12











86. Vera Ivanovna KOSTYREVA 59997/12



87. Anatoliy IvanovichSIDORENKO

60032/12



88. Tatyana AlekseyevnaTKACHENKO

60039/12



89. Lyudmila Ivanovna TUNIK 60042/12



90. Vasiliy GrigoryevichKHADZHINOV

60045/12



91. Svetlana Anatolyevna SHCHUS 60126/12










92. Anna ParfiryevnaKUCHERENKO

60150/12



93. Lyudmila IvanovnaMAKSIMENKO

60165/12



94. Klavdiya Viktorovna SHULGA 60177/12



95. Olga VladimirovnaNIKONOVA

60179/12



96. Raisa AndreyevnaSHEVCHENKO

60250/12



97. Vladimir AleksandrovichKURINNOY

60340/12










98. Vladimir MikhaylovichLISOKOLENKO

60351/12



99. Nadezhda IvanovnaMOTRENKO

60356/12



100. Yelena GrigoryevnaTSIVKOVSKAYA 60360/12



101. Mariya Pavlovna BURLAKA 60361/12



102. Vasiliy Ivanovich MISNIK 60364/12



103. Valentina Alekseyevna MISNIK 60368/12










104. Aleksandr GrigoryevichTESLENKO 60370/12



105. Ivan Grigoryevich TESLENKO 60372/12



106. Galina NikolayevnaVYSOTSKAYA 60378/12



107. Aleksandr CHEREVKO 60384/12



108. Natalya MikhaylovnaSAMOYLOVICH 60387/12



109. Irina Mikhaylovna RYABUSH 60391/12










110. Lyudmila Nikolayevna ZIMA 60393/12



111. Aleksey Ivanovich KOSHEVOY 60395/12



112. Yelena Petrovna KIRKACH 60396/12



113. Olga Ivanovna CHERNIKOVA 60397/12



114. Vasyl Ivanovych KYREYA 60769/12



115. Vira MykolayivnaNESKORODYANA 60840/12


On 13/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 12/11/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 523, 53

116. Tamara Mykolayivna SHVAB 60874/12











117. Anatoliy GrygorovychBUNETSKYY 60945/12



118. Vasyl Yosypovych BUKHAY 60999/12

As a result of review, domestic court’sdecisions in applicant’s case were quashedby the Kharkiv Administrative Court ofAppeal on 26/09/2013.The State Bailiff Service of Ukraineterminated an enforcement proceeding inthe present case on 26/12/2014.

On 13/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)On were transferred to the applicant bankaccount.On 25/11/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 481, 95

119. Petro IvanovychZAGORUYKO 61010/12



120. Leonid FedorovichGARDASHNIKOV 61269/12

According to applicant’s statement of15/07/2015, decision of domestic courtwas enforced in full.


121. Vasyl VolodymyrovychMOZHAROVSKYY 61285/12



122. Taras Vasylyovych PYLYP 61286/12



123. Lyudmyla AnatoliyivnaSTELMASHCHUK 61295/12



124. Vitaliy Vasylyovych YARYY 61311/12Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amount

On 13/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 12/11/2014 – the applicant was also paid a










of UAH 8 755,53. simple interest in amount of UAH 604, 35

125. Andriy Sergiyovych TESLYUK 61418/12



126. Mykola OpanasovychGUNENKO 61518/12



127. Anastasiya IvanivnaGUNENKO 61524/12



128. Alla Dmytrivna LEVKIVSKA 61563/12



129. Viktor PetrovychLEVKIVSKYY 61565/12



130. Mykhaylo GrygorovychRUDYUK 61616/12



131. Oleksiy VolodymyrovychPOGULYAYKO 61660/12



132. Valeriy Andriyovych DIANOV 61696/12

According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Lugansk Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.

On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38142, 74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on10/12/2014 – to the applicant bank account.On 10/12/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 658, 95

133. Igor Petrovych 61700/12 According to the letter of the Pension Fund On 13/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)











BORYSOVSKYY of Ukraine of 30/12/2014, judicial decisionin applicant’s case was enforced in full.

were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 25/12/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 481, 95

134. Liliya VolodymyrivnaSEGRENYOVA 61838/12

According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine of 17/11/2016, judicial decisionin applicant’s case was enforced in full.


135. Ivan Vasilyevich KUNTUSH 61855/12


On 30/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on31/10/2014 – to the applicant bank account.On 25/11/2015 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 441.

136. Nadiya Fedorivna DIANOVA 61867/12


On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38142, 74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on24/12/2014 – to the bank account of applicant’srepresentative, Mr Ponomarenko.On 24/12/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 658, 95.

137. Olena LeonidivnaKOVALYOVA 61903/12



138. Natalya YevgenyevnaMARKOVSKAYA 62153/12


On 13/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 25/12/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 481, 95 andUAH 1264, 64.

139. Vasyl Mikolayovych KOKHNO 62162/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts according









to the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 26212, 40.


140. Yevgeniy VladimirovichPOLISHCHUK 62176/12

According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine, judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.


141. Sergey Ivanovich ZAVARZIN 62187/12

According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine, judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.


142. Anatoliy GrigoryevichBONDARENKO 62208/12



143. Mykola Panasovych BONDAR 62247/12

Enforced. On 25/12/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 5532.


144. Ivan Ivanovych TSYBULYOV 62334/12



145. Nadiya YosyfivnaTUMARKOVA 62423/12 Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicant

was paid the outstanding debts accordingOn 13/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.








to the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 1017, 90


146. Semen Aronovich FABRIKANT 62478/12



147. Dmitriy Vitalyevich LIGASOV 62491/12

Enforced. On 13/01/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 6 542, 68.


148. Valentin AleksandrovichSUSLOV 62501/12

Enforced. On 13/01/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 2 849.


149. Valentin PetrovichTSIGANOVSKIY 62511/12



150. Yuriy ValentinovichTSIGANOVSKIY 62517/12



151. Anatoliy DemyanovichPAVLENKO 62522/12


On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38142,74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on13/01/2015 – to the applicant bank account.On 13/01/2015 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 689, 35








152. Vadim AnatolyevichPAVLENKO 62531/12



153. Zoya MikhaylovnaPAVLENKO 62538/12



154. Viktoriya AnatolyevnaPAVLENKO 62540/12



155. Lyudmila AlekseyevnaMARICHEVA 62544/12



156. Lyudmila Vasilyevna PUGACH 62553/12



157. Zinaida TrofimovnaRASSOLOVA 62561/12










158. Vera NikolayevnaRESHETNYAK 62582/12



159. Natalya GeorgiyevnaGUMENYUK 62588/12



160. Vladimir IvanovichFOLOMEYEV 62591/12



161. Raisa Petrovna SHCHASNAYA 62593/12



162. Mariya PetrovnaNETIMENKO 63457/12



163. Oleksandr IvanovychBOZHENKO 63664/12


Mr Bozhenko did not submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 30/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on18/10/2016 – to the applicant bank account.

164. Valentyna Ivanivna SOVTER 63913/12 Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts according










to the domestic court’s decisions inamounts of UAH 27986, 96 and UAH27856, 65.

On 12/11/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 869, 04 andUAH 385,56

165. Ganna PanteleymonivnaROMANENKO 64182/12



166. Valentin VasilyevichLITVINOV 64254/12

On 25/12/2014 – the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 3315, 30 wastransferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to applicant for providing hisbanking details, but he did not respond toany of them.On 11/01/2016 – the sum was returned tothe State Budget.On 04/04/2016 – the enforcementproceeding in applicant’s case wasterminated.

Mr Litvonov did not submit to the State BailiffService any information on his banking details.On 30/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 508, 80were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests tothe applicant for providing his banking details,but he did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 24/03/2016 – the sum was returned tothe State Budget.As of today, applicant has not applied against adecision on termination of the enforcementproceedings to the domestic court.

167. Vasyl Vasylyovych VAKO 64402/12

According to the applicant’s statement of21/05/2014, decision of domestic courtwas enforced in full.


168. Anatoliy IvanovychGERASYMYUK 64413/12

On 09/02/2015 – the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 25996, 30 wastransferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to applicant for providing hisbanking details, but he did not respond toany of them.Thus, on 24/03/2016 – the sum wasreturned to the State Budget.

Mr Gerasymyuk did not submit to the StateBailiff Service any information on his bankingdetails.On 30/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 1080,20 were transferred to the special depositaccount of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests tothe applicant for providing his banking details,but he did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 24/03/2016 – the sum was returned to






On 04/04/2016 – the enforcementproceeding in applicant’s case wasterminated.

the State Budget.As of today, applicant has not applied against adecision on termination of the enforcementproceedings to the domestic court.

169. Mikhail Ivanovich RUDYKA 64449/12

In accordance with the case files, thejudicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.

As to Mr Rudyka’s death, awarded sum inamount of EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63) and asimple inerest in amount of UAH 441 weretransferred to the special deposit account of theMinistry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicants heirs for providing their bankingdetails and certificate of heirship, but they didnot respond to any of them.Thus, on 06/02/2019 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.As of today, applicant’s heirs have not appliedagainst a decision on termination of theenforcement proceedings to the domestic court.On 13/02/2019 – the enforcement proceeding inapplicant’s case was terminated.

170. Oleksandr VasylyovychMALYY 64451/12


On 13/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 12/11/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 717,57.

171. Yevgeniya TrokhymivnaFEDORYAKA 64524/12

According to the applicant’s statement,decision of domestic court was enforced infull.


172. Yuriy AleksandrovichLITVINOV 64535/12

Enforced. On 23/12/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 6336.According to the applicant’s statement of30/11/2015, second decision of domesticcourt in applicant’s case was also enforcedin full.







173. Olena ProkopivnaDEMCHENKO 64542/12



174. Valentyna Ivanivna TOKAR 64550/12



175. Viktor RomanovychVOLYNETS 64575/12



176. Anatoliy IvanovychFEDORYAKA 64582/12

According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kyiv Region,judicial decisions in applicant’s case wereenforced in full.


177. Yevgeniy VsevolodovychZUBKOV 64631/12



178. Irena Pavlivna ZUBKOVA 64636/12



179. Yuliya Dmytrivna YANKOVA 64850/12



180. Raisa Pavlovna PETRICH 64877/12



181. Yekaterina NikolayevnaFRANTSEVA 64972/12













182. Petro PavlovychBONDARCHUK 65000/12



183. Olga Mykolayivna GOLIUS 65011/12



184. Ivan Volodymyrovych BRYK 65048/12



185. Valentina AleksandrovnaSKRIPNIK 65059/12



186. Irina Nikolayevna PIKULINA 65154/12


On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38 142, 74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on11/07/2016 – to the bank account of applicant’srepresentative, Mr V. A. Kolesnikov.On 11/07/2016 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 1158, 65.

187. Irina Vladimirovna RYBINA 65170/12



188. Olga Maratovna DOGADINA 65177/12Enforced. On 26/12/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amount

On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38142, 74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on









of UAH 22 215. 26/12/2015 – to the applicant bank account.On 26/12/2015 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 1040, 85.

189. Anatoliy Nikolayevich GRIBOV 65182/12



190. Stepan OleksandrovychSHEMEYKO 65286/12

According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Rivne Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


191. Ivan Mikhaylovich SHUSHAN 65377/12



192. Dmitriy Ivanovich SHUSHAN 65384/12



193. Galyna OleksiyivnaGRYSHCHENKO 65434/12



194. Iryna Dmytrivna ULYANOVA 65593/12



195. Vitaliy IvanovychRADCHENKO 65761/12



196. Gennadiy AntonovychSIMOLCHUK 65770/12 Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicant

was paid the outstanding debts accordingOn 10/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.












197. Anatoliy IvanovychSYDORCHUK 66053/12

Enforced. On 13/10/2014 and on25/12/2014 – the applicant was paid theoutstanding debts according to thedomestic court’s decision in amounts ofUAH 17 306, 67 and UAH 16583, 26.

On 10/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 12/11/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 712, 71 andUAH 339.

198. Sergiy IvanovychKHOROLSKYY 66316/12


On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38 142,74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on26/12/2014 – to the applicant bank account.On 26/12/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 1390, 45.

199. Leonid FedorovichBOBRYSHOV 66326/12

In accordance with the case files, judicialdecision in applicant’s case was enforcedin full.

On 10/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 05/05/2015– the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 472, 50.

200. Borys MykhaylovychSKRYPAL 66409/12



201. Yevgeniy Ivanovych SENKIN 66416/12



202. Yevgeniy Ivanovych SENKIN 66420/12



203. Mykola MykolayovychMISHCHENKO 66427/12



204. Andriy IvanovychPYROZHENKO 66479/12

Enforced. On 19/11/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amount

Mr Pyrpzhenko did not submit to the StateBailiff Service his full banking details on time.On 30/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)










of UAH 26 718, 21. were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on19/11/2014 – to the applicant bank account.On 12/11/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 779, 80.

205. Irina Pavlovna KOROVNIK 66522/12



206. Igor VitaliyovychVYGOVSKYY 66530/12



207. Valeriy Ivanovych PISNYY 66576/12



208. Sergiy MykolayovychVOYTEVYCH 69249/12



209. Ivan MykhaylovychDIKHTYARUK 69360/12

Enforced. On 25/12/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountsof UAH 71 937, 09 and UAH 400.


210. Mykola GrygorovychPOGORILYY 69380/12



211. Kateryna OleksiyivnaTSYBULNYKOVA 69393/12



212. Aleksey MikhaylovichBUGROV 70092/12


Mr Bugrov did not submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 30/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)










of UAH 3674. were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on15/09/2015 – to the applicant bank account.On 15/09/2015 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 441.

213. Ruslan VolodymyrovychKAMINSKYY 70105/12



214. Mariya YakivnaKUPRIYENKO 70792/12



215. Valentyna VasylivnaGAVRYLOVSKA 71040/12



216. Ivan MykolayovychMOZHARIVSKYY 71788/12



217. Lyubov Petrivna KHOMENKO 72084/12



218. Vladimir Ivanovich BATLUK 72198/12

According to the applicant’s statement,decision of domestic court was enforced infull.


219. Mykola GrygorovychGETMAN 73771/12



220. Nataliya Vitalyivna SHAGA 73838/12 Enforced. On 13/10/2014 – the applicant On 10/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)










was paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 2 691.

were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 12/11/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 510, 75.

221. Vitaliy Arseyevich RUBAN 74442/12


On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38 142,74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on18/08/2015 – to the applicant bank account.On 18/08/2015 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 1050, 35.

222. Igor Nikolayevich KOPTSEV 74860/12



223. Vasyl Grygorovych MALYY 74865/12



224. Nadiya Petrivna POTEYEVA 74899/12



225. Dzhabir Yunus OglyKYAZYMOV 74987/12


On 20/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 39 142, 74)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on08/12/2014 – to the applicant bank account.On 13/01/2015 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 641, 76 andUAH 18, 90.

226. Georgiy GeorgiyevichTARSKIY 76104/12



227. Nataliya Leonidivna BILYK 76650/12











228. Faik Mamed-Ogly GASANOV 453/13



229. Valentyna PetrivnaAVRAMCHUK 830/13

According to the applicant’s statement,decisions of the domestic court wereenforced in full.


230. Viktor ViktorovychULYANOVSKYY 23893/13

According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kyiv, judicialdecision in applicant’s case was enforcedin full.


231. Vasyl SergiyovychTARANCHUK 23896/13



232. Yuriy Ivanovych OKOLITA 23899/13



233. Sergiy Borysovych KOROVIN 23943/13



234. Volodymyr OleksandrovychRASNOVSKYY 23953/13



235. Taras MykolayovychMOSKALENKO 27781/13



236. Mariya MykhaylivnaYANCHUK 27784/13

Enforced. On 12/11/2014 and on21/12/2016 – the applicant was paid theoutstanding debts according to the

On 10/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34 748, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 25/12/2014 – the applicant was also paid a











domestic court’s decisions in amounts ofUAH 3171 and UAH 2646.

simple interest in amount of UAH 525, 57.

237. Viktor Petrovych YANCHUK 27801/13

Enforced.On 12/11/2014 and on21/12/2016 the applicant was paid theoutstanding debts according to thedomestic court’s decisions in amounts ofUAH 3096 and UAH 5325.


238. Nataliya OleksandrivnaSHARAPOVA 27811/13



239. Oleksandr BorysovychSHARAPOV 27813/13



240.

Alla Pavlivna BULAVKO

Anatoliy Ivanovych BULAVKO

Petro OleksandrovychPONOMARYOV

49765/08

THE COURT DECLARED APPLICATIONS INADMISSIBLE

241. Mykola SemenovychTYUTYUSHCHENKO 59350/12

242. Ganna Mykhaylivna KULYK 61301/12

243. Valentyna IvanivnaGUZOVSKA 61631/12

244. Svitlana MykolayivnaAKIMOVA 64329/12

245. Vadym PavlovychKHVOROSTYANOY 68576/12

246.

Mykola YuriyovychRYBYNSKYY

2443/13












Case of YAVOROVENKO and others v. Ukraine(application no. 25663/02 and 30 others)Date of Definitive Judgment: 17/07/2014


247.

Mykola MykhaylovychYAVOROVENKO

25663/02

Enforced. On 08/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in totalamount of UAH 12 387, 28, namely:

- UAH 6 377, 68 (for a decision ofthe Zamostyanskyy District Courtof Vinnytsya dated of 06/04/2007);

- UAH 3 528, 30 (for a decision ofthe Leninskyy District Court ofVinnytsya dated of 28/03/2006);

- UAH 2 481, 30 (for a decision ofthe Zamostyanskyy District Courtof Vinnytsya dated of 16/10/2006).

On 22/08/2016 – the applicant was alsopaid the outstanding debts according to theLeninskyy District Court of Vinnytsyadated of 27/11/2006 in amount ofUAH 1 188 937, 30.

On 24/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 603, 10)were transferred to Mr Yavorovenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 22/08/2016 inamount of UAH 20, 37.

248.

LINDSELL ENTERPRISESLIMITED 23581/03

According to the applicant company’sstatement, decisions of the domestic courtwere enforced in full.

On 20/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 33 220, 81)were transferred to applicant company bankaccount.

249.

GRIG

4097/04

Enforced. On 18/10/2017 – the applicantcompany was paid the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 132 472, 57.

The applicant company did not submit to theState Bailiff Service full banking details ontime.On 22/12/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 39 257, 25)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on09/11/2015 – to the applicant company bankaccount.


As to the delayed payment, the applicantcompany was also paid a simple interest on26/11/2015 in amount of UAH 234, 30.

250.

Vadym VolodymyrovychVASKO

17556/04

Enforced. On 07/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 3, 40.According to the State Property Fund, adecision of the Pecherskyy District Courtof Kyiv, 04/12/2000 in the light of thedecision of the Golosiyivskyy DistrictCourt of Kyiv dated of 13/10/2003 wasenforced in full.

On 20/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 33 220, 81)were transferred to Mr Vasko bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 20/05/2016 inamount of UAH 8, 88.

251.

AKVATON, TOV

27218/04


On 20/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 33 220, 81)were transferred to applicant’s company bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicantcompany was also paid a simple interest on04/02/2015 in amount of UAH 12, 42.

252.

Raisa VladimirovnaTKACHOVA

Yelena Vasilyevna PETLYAK

Valentina NikolayevnaIYEVLEVA

Tatyana AnatolyevnaVETROVA

Yelena AlekseyevnaKLIMENKO

10000/05

On 17/10/2014 – the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionsin amounts of UAH 5 635, 25; UAH 5 667,29; UAH 5 370, 60; UAH 5 425, 91 andUAH 5 358, 24 were transferred to thespecial deposit account of the Ministry ofJustice of Ukraine.

The applicants did not submit to the State BailiffService their full banking details.On 17/10/2014 – EUR 10 000 (UAH 163 510,20) were transferred to the special depositaccount of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.

The Government had repeatedly sent requests to applicants for providing their bankingdetails, but applicants did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 17/10/2017 – the sum was returned to the State Budget.As of today, applicants have not applied against a decision on termination of the enforcement

proceedings to the domestic court.

253.Mykola Prokopovych KOROL

21463/05Enforced. On 09/12/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amount

On 20/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 33 220, 81)were transferred to Mr Korol bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant was


of UAH 2 987, 17. also paid a simple interest on 25/12/2014 inamount of UAH 1, 89.

254.

ZODIAK, ZAT

21954/05

Enforced. On 02/07/2015 – the applicantcompany was paid the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionsin total amount of UAH 55 525, 17.

The applicant company did not submit to theState Bailiff Service full banking details ontime.On 22/12/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 39 257, 25)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on02/02/2015 – to the applicant company bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicantcompany was also paid a simple interest on11/02/2015 in amount of UAH 234, 30.

255.

INDUSTRIALEXPORT S.A.

22422/05

Enforced. On 03/10/2016, on 24/10/2016,on 01/11/2016 and on 08/11/2016 – theapplicant was paid the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionsin total amount of USD 5 180 264, 20.

The applicant company did not submit to theState Bailiff Service full banking details ontime.On 22/12/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 39 257, 25)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on16/12/2015 – to the applicant company bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicantcompany was also paid a simple interest on12/08/2016 in amount of UAH 231.

256.

Lenina AbramivnaMAREKHBEYN

30706/05

In accordance with the case files,enforcement proceeding in the case wasterminated on 23/12/2014 due to theenforcement of the domestic court’sdecision in full.

The applicant did not submit to the State BailiffService full banking details on time.On 17/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 702, 04)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on28/11/2014 – to Ms Marekhbeyn bank account.

257.

Yevgeniy Petrovich ORLOV

34384/05

According to the applicant’s statement of25/09/2015, the decision of the domesticcourt was enforced in full.

The applicant did not to the State Bailiff Servicefull banking details on time.On 17/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 702, 04)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on19/06/2015 – to Mr Orlov bank account.


258.

Oleg Mykolayovych GRISHYN

41082/05

In accordance with the case files,enforcement proceeding in the case wasterminated on 28/05/2016 due to theenforcement of the domestic court’sdecision in full.

Mr Grishyn failure to submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 17/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 702, 04)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on18/05/2016 – to the applicant bank account.

259.

Irina VladislavovnaMARKOVA

Yelena PetrovnaMONASHOVA

Viktor Ivanovich SHYBAYEV

3093/06

According to a letter from the SimferopolCity Council dated of 22/08/2011, thedecision of the domestic court wasenforced in full.

Applicant did not submit to the State BailiffService their full banking details on time.On 17/10/2014 – EUR 6 000 (UAH 98 106, 12)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on23/10/2014 – each applicant was paid the justsatisfaction sum in amount of EUR 2 000 (UAH32 702, 04).

260.

Borys OleksandrovychYELETSKYY

16021/06

As a result of review, the HigherCommercial Court of Ukraine in itsdecision of 08/02/2007 quashed thedecision of the Kyiv City CommercialCourt dated of 21/02/2005 (as amended bythe Kyiv Commercial Court of Appeal on31/05/2005 and by the Higher CommercialCourt on 13/10/2005).Thus, that domestic decision in applicant’scase is not enforceable.The State Bailiff Service of Ukraineterminated an enforcement proceeding inthe present case on 22/02/2016.

On 20/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 33 220, 81)were transferred to Mr Yeletskyy bank account.

261.

Petr MikhaylovichKORZHIKOV

25186/06


Mr Korzhikov did not submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 17/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 702, 04)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on28/08/2017 – to the applicant’s bank account.

262. Sergey NikolayevichSIDORENKO 29072/06 Enforced. On 08/10/2014 – the applicant

was paid the outstanding debts accordingOn 20/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 33 220, 81)were transferred to Mr Sidorenko bank account.


to the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 2 091, 81.

263.

Maria Leonidovna SEREDA

23056/07


On 30/12/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 38 540, 85)were transferred to Ms Sereda bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 15/10/2015 inamount of UAH 579, 34.

264.

Nikolay AleksandrovichYAMPOLSKIY

49871/07


Mr Yampolskiy did not submit any informationon his banking details to the State BailiffService.On 17/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 702, 04)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing his banking details, butapplicant did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 27/11/2017 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.As of today, applicant has not applied against adecision on termination of the enforcementproceedings to the domestic court.

265.Viktor AlekseyevichRASPOPOV 54469/07

In accordance with the case files, thejudicial decisions in applicant’s case wereenforced in full.

On 20/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 33 220, 81)were transferred to Mr Raspopov bank account.

266.

Petro Oleksiyovych DZYUBKO

10908/08


On 20/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 33 220, 81)were transferred to Mr Dzyubko bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 25/12/2014 inamount of UAH 305, 40.

267.

UKRENERGOSTROY, TOV

30843/08


On 16/01/2015 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 39 257, 25)were transferred to the applicant company bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicantcompany was also paid a simple interest on05/02/2015 in amount of UAH 1 766, 82.


268.

Mariya OleksiyivnaDOBROVOLSKA

Mykola TarasovychDOBROVOLSKYY 35948/08

According to the applicant’s statement,decisions of the domestic court wereenforced in full.

Ms Dobrovolska did not submit to the StateBailiff Service her full banking details on time.On 08/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 893, 52)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on28/10/2014 – to applicant’s bank account.


Mr Dobrovolskyy submitted to the State BailiffService incorrect banking details.Thus, on 15/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH33 220, 81) were returned to the special depositaccount of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.On 28/10/2014 – a just satisfaction sum wastransferred to the correct bank account of theapplicant.

269.

Engels IvanovychNOVOKHATKO

Sergiy Oleksiyovych KALININ

Mykhaylo OleksandrovychTARASOV

Volodymyr MykolayevychSYURYAYEV

Yuriy Petrovych GALAYDA

Klavdiya MykolayivnaGALAYDA

54769/08

Enforced:- On 25/05/2018 – Mr Novokhatsko

was paid the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’sdecisions in total amount ofUAH 347 593, 33;

- On 16/05/2018 – Mr Kalinin waspaid the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’sdecisions in total amount ofUAH 347 593, 33;

- On 25/05/2018 – Mr Tarasov waspaid the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’sdecisions in total amount ofUAH 233 395, 55;

- On 25/05/2018 – Mr Syuryayevwas paid the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’sdecisions in total amount ofUAH 575 988, 88;

- On 16/05/2018 – Mr Galayda was

On 17/10/2014 – EUR 10 000 (UAH 163 510,20) were transferred to the special depositaccount of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.On 25/05/2018 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 702, 04)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 1 100,05 were transferred to Mr Novokhatko bankaccount.On 16/05/2018 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 702, 04)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 1 100,05 were transferred to Mr Kalinin bank account.On 25/05/2018 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 702, 04)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 738, 85were transferred to Mr Tarasov bank account.On 25/05/2018 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 702, 04)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 1 822,80 were transferred to Mr Syuryayev bankaccount.On 16/05/2018 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 702, 04)were transferred to Mr Galayda bank account.


paid the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’sdecisions in total amount ofUAH 399 692, 06.

270.

Galyna Mykolayivna DONETS

23057/09

Enforced. On 17/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 39 146, 56.In addition, according to a letter of16/02/2016 from the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Lviv Region thedecision of Lviv Circuit AdministrativeCourt dated of 30/12/2008 was enforced infull.

On 17/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 32 893, 52)were transferred to Ms Donets bank account.

271.

Dmitriy Vladimirovich VOLNA

26330/09

Enforced. On 11/03/2015 – firstapplicant’s heir was paid the outstandingdebts according to the domestic court’sdecision in amount of UAH 9020, 27.

As to Mr Volna’s death, a just satisfaction sumin amount of EUR 2 000 (UAH 37 971, 19)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine on25/11/2014.On 24/07/2015 – first applicant’s heir was paidEUR 1000 (UAH 18985, 60).As to the delayed payment, the applicant’s heirwas also paid a simple interest on 01/04/2015 inamount of UAH 254, 70.The Government had repeatedly sent requests tosecond applicant’s heir for providing hisbanking details, but he did not respond to any ofthem.Thus, on 17/10/2017 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.As of today, applicant’s heir has not appliedagainst a decision on termination of theenforcement proceedings to the domestic court.

272.NAIRI, IPP

55864/09According to the applicant’s statement of25/07/2017, the decision of the domesticcourt was enforced in full.

On 20/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 33 220, 81)were transferred to the applicant company bankaccount.


273.

Nikolay AleksandrovichKOCHEGAROV

16112/10

Enforced. On 16/02/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in totalamount of UAH 27 304, 02.

On 24/11/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 37 971, 19)were transferred to Mr Kochegarov bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 11/03/2015 inamount ofUAH 130, 72.

274.

Volodymyr IvanovychKRAVCHENKO

24245/10


On 20/10/2014 – EUR 2 000 (UAH 33 220, 81)were transferred to Mr Kravchenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 04/02/2015 inamount of UAH 85, 56.

Case of Ternovik and others v. Ukraine(application no. 19430/06 and 19 others)Date of Definitive Judgment: 11/04/2013


275.

Vasiliy AleksandrovichTERNOVIK

19430/06

A decision of the Novogrodivka Court of17/09/1998 is not enforceable due to thedeath of the applicant on 23/09/2014.

On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Mr Ternovik bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

276.

Vasyl GrygorovychDYABELKO

25358/06


On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Mr Dyabelko bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

277.

Valeriy IvanovichZVENIGORODSKIY

2555/07


Mr Zvenigorodskiy failure to submit to the StateBailiff Service his full banking details on time.On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on15/10/2013 – to the bank account of applicant’srepresentative, Mr Pogasiy.


278.

Anatoliy VasilyevichPIROZHENKO

2560/07


On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to applicant’s representativebank account, Mr Pogasyi.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

Vladimir AnatolyevichTOMILO


On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to applicant’s representativebank account, Mr Pogasyi.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

279.

Mikhail ViktorovichKOPEYKO

39111/07


On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Mr Kopeyko bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

280.

Sergey AleksandrovichBOBROVSKIY

1777/08


On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Mr Bobrovskiy bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

281.

Viktoriy GennadyevichTITARENKO

4988/08


Mr Titarenko failure to submit to the StateBailiff Service his full banking details on time.On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on15/10/2013 – to applicant’s bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

282.Olga Nikolayevna SKOBINA

13791/08Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amount

On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Ms Skobina bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant was


of UAH 6 405, 17. also paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

283.

Vladimir LeonidovichLUKICHEV

25997/08

According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Sevastopol, adecision of the Gagarinskyy District Courtof Sevastopol of 26/11/2007 was dismissedby a decision of the Higher AdministrativeCourt of Ukraine dated of 27/05/2009.

On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Mr Lukichev bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

Lyudmila MikhaylovnaBELKINA

According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Sevastopol, adecision of the Gagarinskyy District Courtof Sevastopol of 26/11/2007 was dismissedby a decision of the Higher AdministrativeCourt of Ukraine dated of 27/05/2009.

On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Ms Belkina bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

284.

Nataliya VolodymyrivnaYURCHENKO

27005/08

According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in ChernihivRegion, the judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.

On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Mr Yurchenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

285.

Vasyl Mykolayovych KRUPA

27421/08


On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Mr Krupa bank account.As to the delayed payment, a simple interest inamount of UAH 197, 22 was transferred to thespecial deposit account of the Ministry ofJustice of Ukraine on 11/07/2014.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing his updated bankingdetails, but applicant did not respond to any ofthem.Thus, on 14/07/2015 – the sum was returned tothe State Budget.

286.Igor FyodorovichPROKOPENKO 27897/08


On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Mr Prokopenko bankaccount.


of UAH 1 770. As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

287.

Vasiliy Petrovich KOCHURA

42269/08


As to Mr Kochura’s death, a full amount of justsatisfaction was transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine on 06/09/2013.On 02/07/2014 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to applicant’s heir bankaccount, Ms Grebelska.As to the delayed payment, the applicant’s heirwas also paid a simple interest on 02/07/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

288.

Petro Ivanovych MAZHAROV

23248/09

According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kyiv, the judicialdecision in applicant’s case was enforcedin full.

Mr Mazharov failure to submit to the StateBailiff Service his full banking details on time.On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on24/09/2013 – to applicant’s bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

289.

Vladislav YevgenyevichSHCHEGOLKOV

64583/09

According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in AutonomousRepublic of Crimea, the judicial decisionin applicant’s case was enforced in full.

On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Mr Shchergolkov bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

290.

Ryurik Petrovich RODICHEV

43535/10

According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in the LuganskRegion, the judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.

On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Mr Rodichev bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

291.Lyudmila VladimirovnaSHKARINA 56208/10


On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to Ms Shkarina bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant was


of UAH 3004, 70. also paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 197, 22.

292.

Mykola IvanovychDMYTRENKO

20895/09

In accordance with the case files, theapplicant was reponed by an order of aMinister of Justice of 22/01/2015.Thus, the judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.

On 04/09/2013 – EUR 1500 (UAH 15 792, 57)were transferred to Mr Dmytrenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/06/2014 inamount of UAH 147, 05.

Shtabovenko and others v. Ukraine(application no. 22722/07)

Date of Definitive Judgment: 25/04/2013Payment Deadline: 25/07/2013

ZHOVNER GROUP

293. Nadiya KostyantynivnaKRAVCHENYUK

63284/09

THE COURT DECLARED APPLICATIONS INADMISSIBLE294. Tetyana Yuriyivna PASICHNA 63328/09295. Olga Illivna YAKOVENKO 6147/11

296. Stanislav ViktorovychTSARENKO

6164/11

297. Volodymyr PanteliyovychPALIYENKO

6214/11

298. Vladimir ShabodinovichKHAMZATOV

33262/10

APPLICATIONS STRUCK OUT OF THE COURT’S LIST OF CASES299. Olena Georgiyivna

MYKHAYLOVA475/11

300.

VasylPetrovych SHTABOVENKO

22722/07 In accordance with the case files, judicialdecision in applicant’s case was enforcedin full.

On 02/10/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 11/11/2013 inamount of UAH 238, 74.

301.

Viktor Andriyovych BONDAR 13890/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 9187, 45.



302.

Valeriy VolodymyrovychSACHEK

57014/09 According to the applicant’s statement,decision of the domestic court wasenforced in full.


303.

Mariya YosypivnaTABACHUK

59484/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 207 445, 00.


304.

Oksana VladimirovnaSECHKAREVA

59562/09 Enforced. On 17/12/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 6774, 25


305.

Oleksandr VolodymyrovychBURYAK

59650/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in totalamount of UAH 7097, 57.


306.

Mykola ViktorovychTOCHENYY

59976/09 In accordance with the case files, thejudicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


307.

Anatoliy IvanovychGUMONITSKYY

60221/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 9446, 91.


308.

Mykola StepanovychVASYLYK




309.

Viktor Sergiyovych YALPUTA 61111/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 2173, 70.


310.

Anatoliy IvanovichYELISEYEV



311.

Mykola TykhonovychGORBACHUK



312.

Svitlana Mykolayivna BYSHA 62027/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 8601, 50.


313.

Olena Fedorivna DAVYSKYBA 62319/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 2223, 35.


314.

Anatoliy AndriyovychMAKSYMENKO



315.

Svetlana NikiforovnaCHERNOVA




316.

Larisa Ivanovna KLIPENKO 63028/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 3127, 99.


317.

Mariya Vasilyevna BUT 63090/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 3533, 65.


318.

Nina Vasilyevna LITVINOVA 63100/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 2305, 65.


319.

Lyudmila AlekseyevnaKOROLEVA



320.

Lidiya IvanovnaTISHCHENKO



321.

Vladimir VladimirovichPASECHNIK



322.

Igor ViktorovichMIROSHNICHENKO




323.

Eduard MikhaylovichSOLOVYEV



324.

Lyudmila AndreyevnaGORCHAKOVA


Ms Gorchakova failure to submit to the StateBailiff Service her full banking details on time.On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on13/11/2014 – to applicant’s bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 145, 32.

325.

Yekaterina VasilyevnaNESTERENKO



326.

Yevgeniy NikolayevichGUZHVA



327.

Lyudmila AlekseyevnaSEMCHISHYNA


Ms Semchishyna failure to submit to the StateBailiff Service her full banking details on time.On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on23/09/2013 – to applicant’s bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 145, 32.

328. Yekaterina ViktorovnaIVASHCHENKO





As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 02/07/2014 inamount of UAH 148, 78.

329.

Zhanetta Petrovna SHUBINA 63212/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1575, 89.


330.

Natalya VladimirovnaMADYUDYA

63213/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amounttotal of UAH 5325, 37.


331.

Vadim AleksandrovichSTAROSTENKO



332.

Nina Stepanovna GEBUZA 63224/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in totalamount of UAH 4024, 43.


333.

Valentina IvanovnaKUSHCHENKOVA



334.

Nina Alekseyevna VOLKOVA 63230/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1354, 25.


335. Tatyana GennadyevnaSAKHNO






336.

Valentin BorisovichGOLOVCHENKO


Mr Golovchenko failure to submit to the StateBailiff Service his full banking details on time.On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on15/10/2013 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 02/07/2014 inamount of UAH 148, 78.

337.

Applicant 2:

Ivan Petrovich KOROLKOV

63369/09 In accordance with the case files, thejudicial decisions in applicant’s case wereenforced in full.


338.

Lidiya Prokofyevna ORLOVA 63374/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1911, 21.


339.

Mikhail MikhaylovichNEDOPEKIN



340.

Stanislav StepanovichGURKOVSKIY



341.

Irina Ivanovna SHTOFEL 63393/09 Enforced. On 02/07/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1355, 98.

Ms Shtofel failure to submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to were transferred to the


special deposit account of the Ministry ofJustice of Ukraine and on 26/12/2013 – to theapplicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 07/07/2014 inamount of UAH 1355, 98.

342.

Aleksandr MikhaylovichSHTOFEL



343.

Yevgeniy AleksandrovichKOVAL



344.

Vladimir Ivanovich KIYAN63408/09



345.

Nikolay Vasilyevich DUDNIK 63413/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in totalamount of UAH 11622, 91.


346.

Valentina IvanovnaLISTRATENKO


On 19/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 20/06/2014 inamount of UAH193, 76.

347.

Galina VladimirovnaDUNAYTSEVA




348.

Alla Nikolayevna BOZHKO 63435/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 6639, 77.


349.

Olga Yefimovna GLADILINA 63479/09 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in totalamount of UAH 13440, 00.


350.

Sergiy StepanovychNAKONECHNYY



351.

Valentina DemyanovnaKUZOVENINA



352.

Anastasiya SemenovnaDIKAREVA



353.

Lyubov Yakivna LYAKHOVA 64434/09 On 10/07/2014 – the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionsin total amount of UAH 1198, 59 wastransferred to the deposit account of theMinistry of Justice.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to applicant for providing herupdated banking details, but she did notrespond to any of them.Thus, the sum was returned to the StateBudget.

On 04/10/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 10/07/2014 – simple interest in amount ofUAH 238, 74 was returned to the depositaccount of the Ministry of Justice due toapplicant’s bank account closing.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing her updated bankingdetails, but she did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 02/03/2016 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.


On 16/03/2016 – enforcement proceedingin applicant’s case was terminated.

As of today, applicant has not applied against adecision on termination of the enforcementproceedings to the domestic court.

354.

Sergey AleksandrovichMIKHAYLOV

65379/09 Enforced. On 02/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 209, 00 and UAH 12116, 00.


355.

Andrey VladimirovichLOBANOV



356.

Pavlo VasylyovychKOZIYCHUK



357.

Nina Dmytrivna VALENTYUKMariya OpanasivnaVALENTYUKDmytro AnatoliyovychVALENTYUKValentyna AnatoliyivnaKLIMCHUK


On 04/10/2013 – each applicant was paidawarded just satisfaction sum in amount of EUR3000 (UAH 31 585, 14).As to the delayed payment, each applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 20/06/2014 inamount of UAH 238, 74.

358.

Anatoliy VyacheslavovichVLADIMIRSKIY

19486/10 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in the LuganskRegion, judicial decisions in applicant’scase were enforced in full.


359.

Olena Vasylivna MORDOVINA 24423/10 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in totalamount of UAH 3500, 03.



360.

Igor OleksandrovychBALESNYY

25755/10 As to Mr Balesnyy’s death on 03/06/2014,the Government had repeatedly sentrequests to applicant’s heirs for providingtheir banking details, but they did notrespond to any of them.Thus, on 27/11/2018 the enforcementproceeding in applicant’s case wasterminated.

On 02/10/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the applicant bank account.As to Mr Balesnyy’s death, a simple interest on20/06/2014 in amount of UAH 238, 74 wastransferred to the special deposit account of theMinistry of Justice.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant’s heirs for providing their bankingdetails, but they did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 27/11/2018 the enforcementproceeding in applicant’s case was terminated.As of today, applicant’s heirs have not appliedagainst a decision on termination of theenforcement proceedings to the domestic court.

361.

Mykola GrygorovychPETNYAK

37249/10 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in the Lviv Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.

Mr Petnyak failure to submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to were transferred to thespecial deposit account of the Ministry ofJustice of Ukraine and on 10/02/2014 – to theapplicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 02/07/2014 inamount of UAH 148, 78.

362.

Sergey IvanovichMAYMURENKO



363.

Yaroslava Petrivna VIVCHAR 48871/10 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in the Lviv Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


364. Anatoliy GrygorovychVORONKO

63837/10 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kyiv, judicial



decision in applicant’s case was enforcedin full.


365.

Vasyl Dmytrovych NYZOVETS 67118/10 Enforced. On 08/10/2013 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in totalamount of UAH 2553, 18.


366.

Viktor Pavlovych OBLOG 70818/10 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 5758, 330.

Mr Oblog failure to submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on10/10/2013 – to the applicant’s bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 02/07/2014 inamount of UAH 148, 78.

367.

MZHK MRIYA, TOV 70849/10 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1935062, 67.


368.

Anatoliy PetrovychSANEVYCH



369.

Valentina ViktorovnaPROKOPENKO


Ms Prokopenko failure to submit to the StateBailiff Service his full banking details on time.On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on05/12/2013 – to the applicant’s bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 05/05/2015 inamount of UAH 148, 78.


370.

Valentina NikolayevnaSOKOLOVA



371.

Olga Petrivna KALASHNYUK 73067/10 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 7114, 80.


372.

Tatyana IvanovnaPOKHODZHAY



373.

Iryna Ivanivna GULCHAK 73818/10 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1177, 53.


374.

Sergey Nikolayevich PUGACH 73882/10 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 11135, 64.


375.

Galina VasilyevnaMAKSIMOVICH


Ms Maksimovich failure to submit to the StateBailiff Service his full banking details on time.On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on11/11/2013 – to the applicant’s bank account.

376.

Viktor Ivanovych KOLOSOV 1330/11 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in totalamount of UAH 2372, 13.



377.

Anatoliy KirillovichYOVZHENKO



378.

Vladimir Ivanovich MALYUK 2016/11 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 6368, 48.


379.

Viktor Pavlovych OBLOG 3203/11 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 3350, 40.

Mr Oblog failure to submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on10/10/2013 – to the applicant’s bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 02/07/2014 inamount of UAH 148, 78.

380.

Vladimir Ivanovich MALYUK 4481/11 As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol. Therefore, it is not possible toreport the outcome of the enforcementproceedings regarding to the applicant.The enforcement proceeding in the presentcase was terminated on 11/04/2019.

On 06/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on15/10/2013 – to the applicant’s bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 10/07/2014 inamount of UAH 148, 78.

381.

Mykola YuriyovychPRYSHCHEPA



382.Nikolay PavlovichZAKHAROV

5779/11 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amount

On 02/10/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 585, 14)were transferred to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant was



383.

Volodymyr VasylyovychZAMRYKOTA

5836/11 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kyiv, judicialdecision in applicant’s case was enforcedin full.


384.

Tamara VolodymyrivnaILYASHEVA



385.

Svitlana FedorivnaSHEMYAKINA



386.

Applicant 1:

Vladislav ValentinovichVOROBYEV



387.

Nikolay VasilyevichPETUSHKOVFedor Viktorovich MAKAROV

27326/10 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Donetsk Region,judicial decision in applicants’ case wasenforced in full.

On 02/10/2013 – each applicant was paidawarded just satisfaction sum in amount of EUR1500 (UAH 15 792, 57).As to the delayed payment, each applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 20/06/2014 inamount of UAH 119, 37.

388.

Tetyana Pavlivna DOLGOVA 477/11 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kharkiv Region,judicial decision in applicants’ case wasenforced in full.


389.Olena Anatoliyivna OLIYNYK 480/11 In accordance with the case files, judicial

decisions in applicant’s case were enforcedin full.



also paid a simple interest on 20/06/2014 inamount of UAH 119, 37.

390.

Sergey Georgiyevich CHURSIN 5747/11 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Donetsk Region,judicial decision in applicants’ case wasenforced in full.


Case of FEYA, MPP and others v. Ukraine(Application no. 27617/06 and 126 other applications)


ZHOVNER GROUP

391.

FEYA, MPP

27617/06


On 14/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to the applicant company bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicantcompany was also paid a simple interest on21/11/2013 in amount of UAH 299, 28.

392.

SHLYAKHOVE REMONTNO-BUDIVELNE UPRAVLINNYA33, VAT 44628/06

In accordance with the case files, judicialdecisions in applicant’s company casewere enforced in full.


393.

Mykola YevgeniyovychSEMZENIS

47368/06


On 07/02/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 673, 86)were transferred to the Mr Semzenis bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 145, 74.

394.

Natalya TimofeyevnaBEREZKINA 21136/07 In accordance with the case files, the

judicial decisions in applicant’s case wereenforced in full.

On 02/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 673, 86)were transferred to Ms Berezkina bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 145, 74.

Eduard Vladislavovich On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)


BEREZKIN were transferred to Mr Berezkin bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

395.

Valeriy Yegorovich SUBBOTIN

26935/07

In accordance with case files, judicialdecisions in the applicant’s case No. 2-5166 dated of 05/11/2003 and No. 2-2288dated of 15/08/2005 were enforced in full.Other judicial decisions were enforcedpartially.As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol. Therefore, it is not possible toreport the outcome of the enforcementproceedings regarding to the applicant.The enforcement proceeding in the presentcase was terminated on 17/04/2019.

On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Subbotin bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 05/08/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

396.

SNABMASHOBSBYT, PP

30251/07


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074)were transferred to the applicant company bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicantcompany was also paid a simple interest on23/07/2013 in amount of UAH 163, 20.

397.

Nikolay YemelyanovichMALOVICHKO

43621/07


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Malovichko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

398.

Ryurik Petrovich RODICHEV

49573/07

In accordance with the case files, judicialdecision in the applicant’s case wasenforced in full.

On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Rodichev bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.


399. CHERNIGIVTORGBUD, VAT 35243/08


The applicant company failure to submit to theState Bailiff Service full banking details ontime.On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on12/08/2014 – to the applicant company bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicantcompany was also paid a simple interest on12/08/2014 in amount of UAH 367, 82.

400.

CHERNIGIVTORGBUD, VAT

40933/08


The applicant company failure to submit to theState Bailiff Service its full banking details ontime.On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on12/08/2014 – to the applicant company bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicantcompany was also paid a simple interest on12/08/2014 in amount of UAH 367, 82.

401.

Aleksandr GeorgiyevichLUPONOSOV

46250/08


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to the bank account ofapplicant’s representative, Ms LuponosovaSvitlana Leonidivna.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

402.

Vladlen YuryevichDMITRIYEV

53963/08


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Dmitriyev bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.


403.VYROBNYCHA FIRMAASTEYS, TOV 55114/08

On 09/08/2017 – the applicant companyand the State Property Fund of Ukraine (adebtor in the case) reached the settlement.The enforcement proceeding in the presentcase was terminated on 30/08/2017.

The applicant company failure to submit to theState Bailiff Service its full banking details ontime.On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on24/01/2014 – to the applicant company bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicantcompany was also paid a simple interest on24/01/2014 in amount of UAH 367, 82.

404.

Viktor Vladimirovich SHPAK

4519/09


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Shpak bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

405.

Ivan Ivanovich DENISOV

12629/09

After the applicant's death on 27/07/2012,his heirs did not apply to the State BailiffService any requirements to enforce thedecisions of the national courts.Thus, after a payment of the full amount ofjust satisfaction to the applicant’s heirs, theState Bailiff Service of Ukraine terminatedan enforcement proceeding in the presentcase on 20/07/2016.

As to Mr Ivan Denisov’s death, the justsatisfaction sum in amount of EUR 3 000 (UAH31 736, 21) was transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice on04/09/2013 and on 03/10/2013 – to the bankaccount of the applicant’s heirs. As to thedelayed payment, the applicant’s heirs were alsopaid a simple interest on 27/11/2013 in amountof UAH 367, 82.

Igor Ivanovich DENISOV On 10/07/2014 – the outstanding debtsaccording to decisions of the domesticcourt in total amount of UAH 8 696, 10were transferred to the special deposit bankaccount of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to the applicant for providing hisbanking details, but the applicant did not

On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to the bank account ofapplicant’s heirs. Mr Igor Denisov bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.


respond to any of them. Thus, on14/07/2015 the sum was returned to theState Budget.

406.

Volodymyr MykolayovychPAVLENKO

17384/09


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Igor Pavlenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

407. Andrey AndreyevichBRYANTSEV 20888/09

According to the Law of Ukraine “On TheEnforcement Proceedings”, a certaincategory of court decisions can be enforcedexceptionally by a debtor.Thus, according to the domestic courtdecision in applicant’s case, this judgmentshould have been enforced only by theMilitary Commissariat of the AutonomousRepublic of Crimea (a debtor).The Government of Ukraine lost access tothe case-files as they are situated interritories outside governmental controlfrom 20/02/2014.Therefore, the Government of Ukrainecouldn’t able to receive from the debtor inthe case relevant information on theoutcome of the court decision enforcement.Thus, on 15/11/2018 – the enforcementproceeding in the present case wasterminated.

On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Bryantsev bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

408.

Stanislav YuryevichPOPOVICH

22588/09


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Mr Popovich bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.


409.Aleksandr NikolayevichLOKHMATOV 29900/09

As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol.Therefore, the Government of Ukrainecouldn’t able to receive from the debtor inthe case relevant information on theoutcome of the court decision enforcement.Thus, on 11/04/2019 – the enforcementproceeding in the present case wasterminated.

On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Lokhmatov bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

410. Boris Fedorovich SOLODKIY 29904/09


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Solodkiy bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

411.Aleksandr VladimirovichVOVK 30355/09


On 14/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Vovk bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 299, 28.

412. Mykola Stepanovych KHOBOT 30807/09


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Khobot bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

413.Aleksandr IvanovichVASILYEV 31440/09


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Vasilyev bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

414.Dmitriy AnatolyevichKLYAKHIN 31815/09


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Klyakhin bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.


415.

Oleksandr MykolayovychDRACHENKO

31959/09


Mr Drachenko submittet incorrect bankingdetails to the State Bailiff Service. Thus, on11/07/2013 – the just satisfaction sum wasreturned.On 05/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to the correct bank account ofthe applicant.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 06/06/2014 inamount of UAH 171, 36.

416.

Grygoriy OleksandrovychOBUSHCHAK

32061/09


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Obushchak bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

417.

Vadym OleksandrovychMOLCHANOVKateryna VasylivnaMOLCHANOVA 32178/09

In accordance with the case files, judicialdecision in the applicants’ case wasenforced in full.

On 05/07/2013 – each applicant (Mr Molchanovand Ms Molchanova) was paid EUR 1 500(UAH 15 537, 19).On 23/07/2013 – applicants were also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 74, 80 (toeach).

418.

Vitaliy NikolayevichVOLKOBOY

33252/09

Enforced. On 20/05/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in totalamount of UAH 36 000.

On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Volkoboy bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

419.

Alla AndreyevnaOMELCHENKO

33390/09


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Ms Omelchenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

420. Vasyl IvanovychVERZHYKOVSKYY 35661/09 Enforced. On 06/06/2014 – the applicant

was paid the outstanding debts accordingMr Verzhykovskyy failure to submit to the StateBailiff Service its full banking details on time.



On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice and on 11/12/2013 –to Mr Verzhykovskyy bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 11/12/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

421.

Volodymyr MykhaylovychSHALAYEV

38664/09


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Shalayev bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

422.

Vitaliy YevgenyevichSAMOFALOV

39734/09


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Samofalov bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

423.

Vera AlekseyevnaKITCHENKO

40678/09


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Kitchenko bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

424.

Aleksandr MikhaylovichSTUPAKOV

41045/09

The Government of Ukraine lost access tothe case-files as they are situated interritories outside governmental controlfrom 20/02/2014.Therefore, the Government of Ukrainecouldn’t able to receive from the debtor inthe case relevant information on theoutcome of the court decision enforcement.Thus, on 11/04/2019 – the enforcementproceeding in the present case wasterminated.

On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Stupakov bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

425. Stanislava EduardivnaFURSOVA 42857/09 Enforced. On 30/05/2014 – the applicant

was paid the outstanding debts accordingOn 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Ms Fursova bank account.




426.

Yuriy Alekseyevich FURSOV

43017/09


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 074, 39)were transferred to Mr Fursov bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 20.

427.

Volodymyr SemenovychVERESHCHAKA

45905/09


On 09/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Vereshchaka bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 281, 88.

428.

Igor Olegovich BUTENIN

46475/09


On 09/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Butenin bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 281, 88.

429.

Yevgeniy NikolayevichMATSKIY

47329/09


On 09/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Matskiy bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 281, 88.

430.

Galyna MykhaylivnaBRZHEZITSKA

48647/09


On 09/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Brzhezitska bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 281, 88.

431.

Gennadiy GrigoryevichSERENKO

50168/09


On 09/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Serenko bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 281, 88.


432.

Aleksandra ZakharovnaZHUKOVADmitriy VladimirovichZHUKOV 50804/09


Mr Zhukov and Ms Zhukova failure to submit tothe State Bailiff Service their full bankingdetails on time.On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice and on 15/10/2013 –each applicant was paid EUR 1 500 (UAH15 686, 11).

433.

Volodymyr Ivanovych SPINOV

53644/09


On 09/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Spinov bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 281, 88.

434.

Sergiy Yakovlevych TORGAN

54647/09


On 09/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Torgan bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 281, 88.

435.

Sergiy MykolayovychPODGURSKYY

54747/09


On 21/11/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 453, 25)were transferred to Mr Podgurskyy bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 04/06/2014 inamount of UAH 594, 32.

436.

Veletyna IvanivnaNAZARCHUK

58907/09


On 09/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Nazarchuk bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 281, 88.

437.

Anatoliy MykolayovychSHERSHUN

1284/10


On 09/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Shershun bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 281, 88.


438. SKLADNI SPLAVY, PP 1299/10



439.

Sergey NikolayevichLYUBENKIY

1301/10


On 09/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Lyubenkiy bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 281, 88.

440.

Venera Ilmar- VoldemarivnaMAROCHKYNA

2495/10


On 09/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Marochkyna bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 281, 88.

441.

Maya VasylivnaMRACHEK

2946/10


On 09/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Mrachek bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 281, 88.

442.

Viktor VasylyovychKOPYLTSIV

3073/10


On 14/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Kopyltsiv bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 299, 28.

443.

Volodymyr VikentiyovychKHARITONOV

3191/10


On 14/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Kharitonov bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 299, 28.

444. Larysa Sergiyivna KASHPRUK 3275/10 Enforced. On 30/05/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts according

On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Ms Kashpruk bank account.




445.

Lyudmila VladimirovnaSIDENKO

4412/10


On 14/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Sidenko bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 299, 28.

446.

Viktor AnatolyevichTKACHEV

4524/10


On 14/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Tkachev bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 299, 28.

447.

Yuriy Nikolayevich KARDASH

4541/10


On 14/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Kardash bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 299, 28.

448.

Valentina AlekseyevnaBURYAK

4743/10


On 14/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Buryak bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 299, 28.

449.

Vira Volodymyrivna BAGNO

6128/10


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Ms Bagno bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

450.

Alla Mykolayivna SHEVCHUK

9452/10

In accordance with the case files, judicialdecisions in the applicant’s case wereenforced in full.

On 14/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Shevchuk bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 299, 28.

451.Nina OleksandrivnaKALENCHENKO 9642/10


On 14/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Kalenchenko bankaccount.


of UAH 1282346, 50. As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 299, 28.

452.

Valentyn RostyslavovychSHROL

9650/10


On 14/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Shrol bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 299, 28.

453.

Liliya IvanivnaKASYANENKO

9699/10

Enforced. On 18/06/2013 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1282346, 50

On 14/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Kasyanenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 299, 28.

454.

Svitlana Anatoliyivna GOLUB

9705/10


On 23/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Golub bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 10/12/2013 inamount of UAH 327, 12.

455.

Olga Mykolayivna KAPICHON

9711/10


On 23/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Kapichon bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 10/12/2013 inamount of UAH 327, 12.

456.

Oleksandr IvanovychSLIPCHENKO

9720/10


On 23/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Slipchenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 327, 12.

457.

Oleksiy MykolayovychDANILOV

10008/10


On 23/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Danilov bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 327, 12.


458.

Mykhaylo AnatoliyovychPOLISHCHUK

10016/10


On 23/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Polishchuk bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 327, 12.

459.

Ruslana ViktorivnaBEREZOVENKO

10023/10


On 23/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Berezovenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 327, 12.

460.

Anatoliy Ivanovych OREL

10034/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Orel bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

461.

Valentyna Ivanivna KHEYFITS

10118/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Kheyfits bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

462.

Vera Vladimirovna GODIYAK

10124/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Godiyak bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

463.

Mykola MykhaylovychMOSHKIVSKYY

10126/10


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Mr Moshkivskyy bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

464. Oleg VolodymyrovychIGNATYUK 10171/10 Enforced. On 18/06/2013 – the applicant

was paid the outstanding debts accordingOn 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Ignatyuk bank account.




465.

Mykola GrygorovychAVRAMENKO

10278/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Avramenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

466.

Volodymyr MykolayovychCHERKASOV

10302/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Cherkasov bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

467.

Rayisa Mykolayivna GAYDAY

10411/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Gayday bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

468.

Irina YevgenyevnaKRASEVICH

10453/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Krasevich bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

469.

Oleksandr IvanovychVLASENKO

10575/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Vlasenko bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

470.

Volodymyr IvanovychMALTSEV

10598/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Maltsev bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

471. Nataliya SemenivnaVOROBYOVA 11480/10 Enforced. On 04/07/2014 – the applicant

was paid the outstanding debts accordingOn 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Vorobyova bank



account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

472.

Nikolay IvanovichKANDAUROV

11641/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Kandaurov bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

473.

Lidiya Fedorivna SAMKO

11721/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Ms Samko bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

474.

Valeriy YevgeniyovychPANKOV

11837/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Pankov bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

475.

FPK GROSS OOO

12328/10



476.

Volodymyr YevgenovychSMYRNOV

13643/10


On 21/11/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 453, 25)were transferred to Mr Smyrnov bank account.As to the delayed payment, a simple interest inamount of UAH 594, 32 were transferred to thespecial deposit account of the Ministry ofJustice on 10/07/2014.

The Government had repeatedly sent requests tothe applicant for providing his updated bankingdetails, but the applicant did not respond to any


of them. Thus, on 14/07/2015 the sum wasreturned to the State Budget.

477.

Grygoriy VasylyovychTABACHUK

13673/10


On 27/08/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 832, 12)were transferred to Mr Tabachuk bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 341, 04.

478.

Grygoriy YakovychKOVROVSKYY

14611/10


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Mr Kovrovskyy bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.

479.

Igor MykolayovychSOLOMOYCHENKO

14912/10


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Mr Solomoychenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.

480.

Sergiy VolodymyrovychSTRYZHAK

17874/10


On 21/11/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 453, 25)were transferred to Mr Sergiy Stryzhak bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 04/06/2014 inamount of UAH 594, 32.

481.

Igor Anatoliyovych LIPANOV

18112/10

Enforced. On 30/05/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in totalamount of UAH 3 017.

On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Mr Lipanov bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.

482.

Viktor IvanovychYAREMCHUK

18276/10


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Mr Yaremchuk bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.


483.

Yuriy MykolayovychSTRYZHAK

20170/10


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Mr Yuriy Stryzhak bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.

484.

FIRMA DILAYN, PP

20448/10

On 18/12/2014 – the outstanding debtsaccording to decision of the domestic courtin amount of UAH 552 742, 69 weretransferred to the special deposit bankaccount of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to the applicant for providing hisbanking details, but the applicant did notrespond to any of them. Thus, on24/12/2015 the sum was returned to theState Budget.


485.

Oleksandr IvanovychPOBEREZHNYY

20511/10


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Mr Poberezhnyy bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.

486.

Nikolay IvanovichTISHCHENKO

21733/10

As a result of review, the Leninsky DistrictCourt of Sevastopol in its decision of23/12/2013 held, that domestic decision inapplicant’s case is not enforceable.The State Bailiff Service of Ukraineterminated an enforcement proceeding inthe present case on 20/07/2016.

On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Mr Tishchenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 31/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.

487.

Yuriy YevgenyevichKRASNOKUTSKIY 22024/10


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Mr Krasnokutskiy bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant was



488.Ivan Yefimovich MAKSYUK

22257/10According to the applicant’s statement of05/06/2016 the decision of the domesticcourt was enforced in full.

On 11/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Mr Maksyuk bank account.

489.

Yelena Yakovlevna BENDA

22336/10


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Ms Benda bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.

490.

Oleksandra Fedorivna SHAGA

22493/10

In accordance with the case files, on13/10/2011 – the Higher AdministrativeCourt of Ukraine quashed the decision ofNovozavodskyy District Court ofChernigiv dated of 17/12/2007.Thus, the domestic court’s decision inapplicant’s case is not enforceable.The State Bailiff Service of Ukraineterminated an enforcement proceeding inthe present case on 13/12/2013.

Ms Shaga submittet to the State Bailiff Serviceincorrect banking details. Thus, on 06/08/2013– the just satisfaction sum was returned.On 11/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 30 895, 65)and UAH 171, 36 (a simple interest) weretransferred to the correct bank account of theapplicant.

491.

Tetyana Mykolayivna DIDYK

23629/10


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Ms Didyk bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.

492.

Lyudmyla PavlivnaMANKIVSKA

24443/10


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Ms Mankivska bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.

493.

Lyubov FedorivnaSYDORENKO

25298/10


On 21/11/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 453, 25)were transferred to Ms Sydorenko bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 04/06/2014 inamount of UAH 594, 32.


494.

Igor LYSAK

25989/10


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Mr Lysak bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.

495.

Fedir Frolovych FIRSOV

26673/10


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Mr Firsov bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.

496.

Galyna StepanivnaYAKOVYSHYNA

30056/10


12/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 30 724, 29)were transferred to the bank account ofapplicant’s representative, Ms Dygas SvitlanaIvanivna.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 174, 72.

497.

Tamara MykolayivnaMANDRYKA

30631/10


On 12/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Ms Mandryka bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of 177, 32.

498.

Volodymyr ValeriyovychKRAL

33325/10


On 08/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 134, 33)were transferred to Mr Kral bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/07/2013 inamount of UAH 163, 68.

499.

Svitlana Ivanivna DYGAS

33691/10


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Ms Dygas bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

500.Anastasiya SemenovnaDIKAREVA 35071/10


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Ms Dikareva bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant was


of UAH 1 378. also paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

501.

Viktor SemenovychMOVCHAN

35124/10

Enforced. On 30/05/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in totalamount of UAH 5587, 42.

12/07/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 30 724, 29)were transferred to Mr Movchan bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 10/12/2013 inamount of UAH 174, 72.

502.

Mykola AndriyovychNESOLYONYY

36266/10

After the applicant's death on 10/10/2011,his heirs did not apply to the State BailiffService any requirements to enforce thedecisions of the national courts.Thus, the State Bailiff Service of Ukraineterminated an enforcement proceeding inthe present case on 07/02/2019.

As to Mr Nesolyonyy’s death, the justsatisfaction sum in amount of EUR 3 000 (UAH31 736, 21) were transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine on 04/09/2013.The Government had repeatedly sent requests tothe applicant’s heirs for providing their bankingdetails, but they did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 27/10/2014 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.

503.

Yefim MikhaylovichTIMOSHENKO

42839/10


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to the bank account ofapplicant’s representative, Ms Platonova OlenaMikhaylivna.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

504.

Ivan Pavlovych BUSHUYEV

45624/10

On 30/05/2014 – the outstanding debtsaccording to decision of the domestic courtin amount of UAH 7 920 were transferredto the special deposit bank account of theMinistry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to the applicant for providing hisbanking details, but the applicant did notrespond to any of them. Thus, on19/06/2015 the sum was returned to theState Budget.

On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Mr Bushuyev bank account.As to the delayed payment, a simple interest inamount of UAH 367, 82 were transferred to thespecial deposit account of the Ministry ofJustice on 21/11/2013.The Government had repeatedly sent requests tothe applicant for providing his updated bankingdetails, but the applicant did not respond to anyof them.Thus, on 19/06/2015 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.


505.

Larisa ViktorovnaVYSOTSKAYA

45785/10


Ms Vysotskaya failure to submit to the StateBailiff Service her full banking details on time.On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice and on 27/11/2013 –to the applicant’s bank account.

506.

Pavlo VasylyovychGELYUNENKO

49215/10


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Mr Gelyunenko bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

507.

Olga Pavlivna PASHATSKA

53963/10


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Ms Pashatska bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

508.

Kateryna AvksentiyivnaKUYTUKLU

60317/10


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Ms Kuytuklu bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

509.

FEYA, MPP

61768/10



510.

Nina Petrivna MOZGOVA

66873/10


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Ms Mozgova bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

511.Oleksandr KostyantynovychSHEVCHENKO 68454/10

On 06/06/2014 – four applicant’s heirswere paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in

As to Mr Shevchenko’s death, the justsatisfaction sum in amount of EUR 3 000 (UAH31 736, 21) was transferred to the special


applicant’s case in total amount ofUAH 8 829, 60 (namely, UAH 2 207, 40 toeach heir).

deposit account of the Ministry of Justice on04/09/2013 and on 18/12/2013 – to the bankaccounts of applicant’s heirs(UAH 7934, 05 to each of four heirs).

512.

Nina Ivanivna PINUS

69251/10


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Ms Pinus bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

513.

Grigoriy Yefimovich LIZOGUB

70834/10


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Mr Lizogub bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

514.

Lidiya PetrivnaCHUNYKHINA

71290/10


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 3 000 (UAH 31 736, 21)were transferred to Ms Chunykhina bankaccount.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 367, 82.

515.

Volodymyr YakovychGOLOTA

42136/09


On 04/09/2013 – EUR 1 500 (UAH 15 868, 10)were transferred to Mr Golota bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 183, 38.

516.

Oleksiy Illlich LOPATINRayisa MykhaylivnaKORZHOVA 71588/10

According to the statement of applicant’srepresentative, Mr P. Sitnov, of 22/03/2013the decision of the domestic court wasenforced in full.

On 04/09/2013 – each applicant was pain EUR1 500 (UAH 15 868, 10).As to the delayed payment, each applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 21/11/2013 inamount of UAH 183, 38.


KHAYNATSKYY AND OTHERS v. UKRAINEApplication no. 12895/08 and 249 others)Date of Definitive Judgment: 09/01/2014


517.

Mykola OleksandrovychKHAYNATSKYY

12895/08 According to the letter of the Military UnitB0946 of 17/11/2016, the applicant did notapply any request to the debtor forobtaining his property.Thus, on 28/11/2016 – the enforcementproceeding in applicant’s case wasterminated.


518.

Yuriy Olegovych CHERNOUS

Oleg Igorovych CHERNOUS

43078/08 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – applicant’swere paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 6613,06 and UAH 7607,64

On 15/09/2014 – each applicant was paidawarded just satisfaction sum in amount of EUR2000 (UAH 33 420, 81).As to the delayed payment, each applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 12/11/2014 inamount of UAH 583, 17 and UAH 598, 38.

519.

Viktoriya NikolayevnaROZHKOVA



520.

Vasyl Vasylyovych OLIYNYK 58076/09 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 6700.


521.

Yuzefa IvanivnaYANUSHEVYCH



522.Oleksandra MykytivnaYESIPKO


On 15/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 420, 81)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 09/12/2014 – a simple interest in amount of


of UAH 6704, 68. UAH 606, 07 was transferred to special depositaccount of the Ministry of Justice of Ukrainedue to applicant’s bank account closing.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing her updated bankingdetails, but she did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 14/12/2015 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.On 25/12/2015 – the enforcement proceeding inapplicant’s case was terminated.As of today, applicant has not applied against adecision on termination of the enforcementproceedings to the domestic court.

523.

Lyudmyla VolodymyrivnaGOLODNYAK



524.

Vasyl Fokovych POLYARUSH 23683/11 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 8911, 32.


525.

Mariya Zakharivna ZINCHUK 23848/11 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 6384, 58.


526.

Yuriy StanislavovichMEKENZIN

34066/11 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 21241, 90.


527. Volodymyr ArnoldovychKHATSYANOV






528.

Lyubov AndriyivnaVLASENKO



529.

Larisa Teodorivna TSURKAN 35302/11 In accordance with the case files, judicialdecision in applicant’s case was enforcedin full.

Ms Tsurkan failure to submit to the State BailiffService her full banking details on time.On 12/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 420, 81)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on05/05/2015 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 05/05/2015 inamount of UAH 472, 68.

530.

Lyubov GeorgiyevnaVOLCHKOVA


Ms Volchkova did not submit to the StateBailiff Service any information on her fullbanking details.On 12/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 420, 81)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing her banking details, butshe did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 10/12/2015 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 14/12/2015 inamount of UAH 610, 38.

531.

Valentyna IvanivnaGUZOVSKA

35665/11 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 and on25/09/2014 – the applicant was paid theoutstanding debts according to thedomestic court’s decisions in amount of

On 15/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 420, 81)were transferred to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/11/2014 in


UAH 2974, 70 and UAH 1424. amount of UAH 530, 37 and on 16/02/2015 inamount of UAH 33, 80.

532.

Svetlana PetrovnaMARTYNYUK



533.

Ivan Adolfovych VYSOTSKYY 36210/11 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 61780, 10.

On 15/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 420, 81)were transferred to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 12/11/2014 inamount of UAH 1 520, 36.

534.

Sergiy Vasylyovych LOZHKA 37983/11 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 3460.


535.

Vladyslav VasylyovychGORBATYY

39204/11 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in the VinnytsiaRegion, judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.


536.

Iryna Mykhaylivna GADKOVA 39367/11 As a result of review, the decision of theZhdaniv Court of 22/10/2007 was quashedby the Court of Appeal of Donetsk Regionon 17/04/2014.The State Bailiff Service of Ukraineterminated an enforcement proceeding inthe present case on 27/10/2014.


537.

Oleksandr StepanovychSHEPSHELEY




538.

Tamara DmitriyevnaRESHETNYAK



539.

Nataliya MykhaylivnaDESYATNYK

53955/11 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH1896, 42.


540.

Grygoriy VolodymyrovychPOKORA

60947/11 Enforced. On 08/12/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 5 136, 24.

Ms Pokora did not submit to the State BailiffService information on his full banking detailson time.On 12/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 420, 81)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 555, 14were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on08/12/2014 – to the applicant bank account.

541.

Lyudmyla GrygorivnaBAGLAY



542.

Mariya Zakharivna ZINCHUK 66294/11 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 160509, 50.


543.

Viktor Fedorovych SHATROV 75189/11 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 26940, 60.


544.Yuriy Ivanovych IVANOV 23/12 Enforced. On 25/12/2014, on 13/03/2015

and on 19/03/2015 – the applicant waspaid the outstanding debts according to the



domestic court’s decisions in amounts ofUAH 41093, 40, UAH 35849, 74 andUAH 84348, 05.

also paid a simple interest on 03/04/2015 inamount of UAH 2 850, 79.

545.

Lidiya MykhaylivnaTIMAKOVA

27/12 As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol. Therefore, it is not possible toreport the outcome of the enforcementproceedings regarding to the applicant.The enforcement proceeding in the presentcase was terminated on 15/04/2019.


546.

Galyna YosypivnaMARCHENKO



547.

Alla Ivanivna NALAPIY 3549/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 11949, 69.


548.

Rynat SabirzhanovychSALAKHUTDINOV



549.

Anatoliy MikhaylovichBORTNIK

4242/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 33061.


550.

Viktor Ilyich GUDSKOV 5474/12 According to the European Court’sjudgment in case of “Velikoda v.Ukraine”(application no. 43331/12, final on03/06/2014), present application must bedeclared inadmissible, as manifestly ill-



founded.Thus, domestic court’s decision is notenforceable.

551.

Valentyn YakovychDOLGANOV

5604/12 On 01/10/2014 – the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 4680 were transferredto the special deposit account of theMinistry of Justice.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to applicant for providing hisbanking details, but he did not respond toany of them.On 02/11/2015 – the enforcementproceeding in applicant’s case wasterminated.

Mr Dolganov did not submit to the State BailiffService any information on his full bankingdetails.On 12/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 420, 81)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 547, 93were transferred to were transferred to thespecial deposit account of the Ministry ofJustice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing his banking details, buthe did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 23/10/2015 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.

552.

Mykola VolodymyrovychMOVCHANYUK

Roman MykolayovychMOVCHANYUK

Galyna VyacheslavivnaMOVCHANYUK







553.

Leonid MykolayovychBUGERA




554.

Nataliya Ivanivna ZHUK 5837/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 22713, 37.


555.




556.

Oleksandr KostyantynovychSHEVCHENKO

5997/12 Enforced. On 26/12/2014 – fourapplicant’s heirs were paid the outstandingdebts according to the domestic court’sdecisions in amount of UAH 6827.

As to Mr Shevchenko’s death, EUR 2000 (UAH33 420, 81) were transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine on 12/09/2014 and on 26/12/2014 – tobank accounts of four applicant’s heirs.As to the delayed payment, applicant’s heirswere also paid a simple interest on 26/12/2014in amount of UAH 576, 84.

557.

Ganna FedorivnaGRUSHKOVSKA


On 23/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 420, 81)were transferred to applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 26/10/2014 inamount of UAH 565, 08.

558.

Lyubov GrygorivnaBARANOVSKA

6313/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 8556.


559.

Galyna Ivanivna ZYOLKO 6421/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 33650, 90.


560. Valentina PetrovnaBESARABCHIK





As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 27/10/2014 inamount of UAH 1 117, 21.

561.

Igor AnatoliyovychRAZBORSKYY


On 15/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 420, 81)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 02/12/2014, a simple interest in amount ofUAH 567, 96 was transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice due toapplicant’s bank account closing.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing his updated bankingdetails, but he did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 14/12/2015 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.On 25/12/2015 – the enforcement proceeding inapplicant’s case was terminated.

562.

Rynat SabirzhanovychSALAKHUTDINOV



563.

Vitaliy Ivanovych BUSLAYEV 6560/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 30539, 80.


564.

Lyudmyla MykhaylivnaBUSLAYEVA



565.

Oleksandr IvanovychKHANCHYCH




566.

Ivan Stepanovych ANTONYUK 6651/12 According to the European Court’sjudgment in case of “Velikoda v.Ukraine”(application no. 43331/12, final on03/06/2014), present application must bedeclared inadmissible, as manifestly ill-founded.Thus, domestic court’s decision is notenforceable.


567.

Liliya ViktorivnaTYSHKEVYCH



568.

Vladimir AleksandrovichNOSIKOV



569.

Ganna Vasylivna BUGAYETS 7142/12 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 5008, 50.


570.

Viktor IvanovychBARANOVSKYY



571.

Anatoliy Filippovich KHODAK 7541/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 3017.


572. Ivan MykolayovychSYDORENKO






573.

Nadiya Petrivna RAYENOK 8247/12 According to the European Court’sjudgment in case of “Velikoda v.Ukraine”(application no. 43331/12, final on03/06/2014), present application must bedeclared inadmissible, as manifestly ill-founded.Thus, domestic court’s decision is notenforceable.


574.

Volodymyr ViktorovychCHUVPYLO



575.

Anatoliy VasylyovychKOSHYK



576.

Angelina MykhaylivnaBOGUSH



577.

Olena Mykhaylivna PAPKA 8305/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 12202, 40.


578.

Olga Volodymyrivna MOROZ 8365/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 23158, 20.



579.

Galyna VolodymyrivnaVERGUN



580.

Svitlana StanislavivnaTEMCHENKO



581.

Valentyna Petrivna LENKO 8439/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 26234, 98.


582.

Ivan KELMAN 8452/12 In accordance with the case files, judicialdecisions in applicant’s case were enforcedin full.


583.

Ruslan VolodymyrovychKAMINSKYY



584.

Mykhaylo MykhaylovychBARANOVSKYY



585.

Aleksandr NikolayevichREUKA

8679/12 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Donetsk Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.



586.

Yuriy SergiyovychDYVYNSKYY



587.

Mykola YukhymovychSACHOK



588.

Kateryna Ivanivna SACHOK 8873/12 Enforced. On 23/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 7066, 90.


589.

Mariya AndriyivnaKHOMUTOVSKA

8959/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 and on03/12/2014 – the applicant was paid theoutstanding debts according to thedomestic court’s decisions in amounts ofUAH 42008, 60 and UAH 4294, 80.


590.

Vasyl Pavlovych DUBOVSKYY 9076/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 42894, 41.


591.

Nataliya VasylivnaKOVALCHUK



592.

Mariya VasylivnaVASYLCHUK

9196/12 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Rivne Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.



593.

Yevgeniy MiroslavovichSOBOL



594.

Ivan IvanovichKRIVOLAPCHUK



595.

Viktor Stepanovych KANDUR 9381/12 According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine of 05/09/2014, judicialdecisions in applicant’s case were enforcedin full.


596.

Mariya OleksiyivnaRENGEVYCH



597.

Ivan GrigoryevichTERESHCHUK



598.

Izolda AnatoliyivnaFRANCHUK

9774/12 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Volyn Region,judicial decisions in applicant’s case wereenforced in full.


599.

Yuriy ValeriyovychMYKHAYLOV




600.

Valentyna AdamivnaLEVKIVSKA



601.

Mykhaylo GrygorovychYAKUKHNO

9878/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions inamounts of UAH 96183, 72 and UAH1815, 50.


602.

Petro Fedorovych FRANCHUK 9986/12 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Volyn Region,judicial decisions in applicant’s case wereenforced in full.


603.

Viktor Ivanovych SINELNYK 10044/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 8851, 75.


604.

Mykola Kuzmovych KOVAL 10295/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 8937, 97.


605.

Vitaliy OleksandrovychKIRSANOV



606.

Stepan VasylovychSKRYPNYK

10398/12 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in ChernivtsiRegion, judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.



607.

Igor Valentynovych UVAROV 10875/12 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 82307, 47.


608.

Oksana Pavlivna LEVKIVSKA 11032/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 71735, 85.


609.

LUGPROM, TOV 11038/12 Enforced. On 25/12/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1138540, 32.


610.

Volodymyr VasylyovychPOPELYANSKYY



611.

Nataliya AnatoliyivnaPATSALO



612.

Dmytro SemenovychBALATSKO



613.

Grygoriy SergiyovychSYVUKHIN




614.

Galyna Petrivna PYLYPCHUK 11772/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 32090, 62.


615.

Anatoliy MykolayovychVIZNYY



616.

Ilona VitaliyivnaZAKHAROVA



617.

Volodymyr AnatoliyovychGOLOVATYY


On 23/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 554, 89)were transferred to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 24/10/2014 inamount of UAH 506, 01 and on 24/03/2015 inamount of UAH 2 867, 60.

618.

Oksana Ivanivna SHEVTSOVA 12790/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 39593, 94.


619.

Leonid VasilyevichGOLUBNICHIY



620.

Artur Dmytrovych RASHKO 13205/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 22937, 20.



621.

Anatoliy AnatoliyovychKANEVSKYY



622.

Galyna OleksandrivnaPREDCHENKO



623.

Tamara MykolayivnaMASNEVA



624.

Vitaliy MykolayovychDANILOV

13400/12 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kyiv Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


625.

Lyudmyla Ivanivna SHMUYLO 13584/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 44048, 92.


626.

Nikolay IvanovichKRAVCHENKO

13615/1 According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine, judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.


627.

Galyna VolodymyrivnaVERGUN




628.

Nadiya PetrivnaDAVLETCHINA

13629/12 According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine of 03/10/2014, judicial decisionin applicant’s case was enforced in full.


629.

Sergey Vladimirovich VOVK 13674/12 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Lugansk Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


630.

Sergiy MytrofanovychZUBCHENKO



631.

Valentyna IvanivnaDUBNYTSKA



632.

Mykola PetrovychSMYKOVSKYY



633.

Oleksiy OleksiyovychMAKAROV



634.

Olena Vitaliyivna TARASYUK 14304/12 Enforced. On 14/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 123321, 42.



635.

Svitlana OleksandrivnaGANZHA

14463/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 and on18/12/2015 – the applicant was paid theoutstanding debts according to thedomestic court’s decisions in amounts ofUAH 60198, 91 and UAH 4415.


636.

Sergiy Volodymyrovych BURA 14497/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 78584.


637.

Mariya Teodorivna ZAGARUK 14698/12 Enforced. On 14/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 9656, 21.


638.

Mykola IvanovychMUZYCHUK



639.

Vera Nikolayevna IVAKINA 14726/12 According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine, judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.


640.

Vladimir AleksandrovichLISHCHENKO



641.

Oleksandr VolodymyrovychLYSYUK




642.

UGLESTROYSERVIS, OOO 15587/12 Enforced. On 23/03/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 363142, 67.

On 24/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 554, 89)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice and on 23/03/2015 –to the applicant company bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 23/03/2015 inamount of UAH 8 967, 34

643.

Aleksandr AnatolyevichBELOUSOV

15675/12 According to the applicant’s statement of03/10/2014, decision of the domestic courtwas enforced in full.


644.

Lyubov Yosypivna BELIKOVA 16089/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 190620, 31.


645.

Valentyna Pavlivna YANCHUK 16150/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 36736, 19.


646.

Mykola VolodymyrovychSOLOMANIN



647.

Leonid Semenovych KNEVETS

Vira Fedorivna KNEVETS






amount of UAH 1 179, 28.

648.

Viktor TrokhymovichBONDARENKO

16684/12 According to the debtor’s statement,decision of the domestic court wasenforced in full.


649.

Olena Mykolayivna PESHKO 16865/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 26431, 20.


650.

Tetyana MykolayivnaPOTIYCHUK



651.

Aleksey GeorgiyevichKUTIKOV


On 07/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 554, 89)were transferred to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 12/11/2014 inamount of UAH 1 346/08.

652.

Svetlana Ivanovna SHVAB 18058/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 22145, 67.


653.

Natalya IvanovnaDIVINSKAYA



654.Valentyna SergiyivnaYAROSHYK

18188/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 and on25/09/2015 – the applicant was paid theoutstanding debts according to the



domestic court’s decisions in amounts ofUAH 661, 81 and UAH 118134, 32.


655.

Vyacheslav OleksiyovychYATSKOVETS



656.

Volodymyr OleksandrovychGONCHAROV



657.

Svetlana SergeyevnaNEVMERZHITSKAYA



658.

Lidiya Petrivna ANANYEVA 18337/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 32027, 11.


659.

Iryna OleksiyivnaNECHYPORENKO



660.

Petro PetrovychMUKSHYMENKO



661.Svitlana YakivnaDEMYDCHUK





662.

Ivan Ivanovych DEMYDCHUK 18418/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 24034, 34.


663.

Valeriy PavlovychSEKATSKYY

18522/12 According to the applicant’s statement of01/12/2015, decision of the domestic courtwas enforced in full.

Mr Sekatskyy did not submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 23/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 554, 89)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 772, 56were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice and on 06/10/2015 –to the applicant bank account.

664.

Sergey VasilyevichMAKAREVICH



665.

Natalya VladimirovnaMAKAREVICH



666.

Sergey Leonidovich BOBROV 18599/12 Enforced. On 10/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 34439, 20.


667.

Vasyl Volodymyrovych SAPIY 18609/12 According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine of 08/09/2014, judicial decisionin applicant’s case was enforced in full.


668. Ruslana VolodymyrivnaYAKUKHNO






669.

Nadiya VolodymyrivnaVOYTOVYCH



670.

Stepan AleksandrovichNEVMERZHITSKIY



671.

Oleksiy OleksiyovychMOZHAROVSKYY



672.

Mykola StepanovychOPANASYUK

19073/12 According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine of 03/10/2014, judicialdecisions in applicant’s case were enforcedin full.


673.

Mariya YuriyivnaKOVALENKO



674.

Galyna Andriyivna KHURAVA 19409/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1516.


675.Lyudmyla YosypivnaPIDGORNA





676.

Tamara PetrovnaZOLOTAREVA



677.

Vladimir VladimirovichYABLONENKO

19556/12 According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine, judicial decisions inapplicant’s case were enforced in full.


678.

Mikhail Vasilyevich FILATOV 19853/12 Enforced. On 15/10/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 106518, 51 and UAH 39105.

Mr Filatov did not submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 17/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38 395, 41)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on15/10/2015 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 15/10/2015 inamount of UAH 3858, 72.

679.

Vasyl Viktorovych MOVCHAN 20004/12 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 4718, 30.


680.

Svitlana Oleksiyivna BOZHKO 20019/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 3834, 50.


681.

Svyatoslav MykhaylovychSHYPITKO




682.

Nina VolodymyrivnaKURANTSOVA



683.

Mykola PetrovychGARASHCHUK



684.

Galyna StepanivnaCHYCHEBA



685.

Valentina Vasilyevna TISHINA 20400/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 40342, 45.


686.

Valentin ProkofyevichCHEREPENKO

20450/12 Enforced. On 07/09/2015 – applicant’sheir, Mr N.A. Cherepenko, was paid theoutstanding debts according to thedomestic court’s decision in amount ofUAH 7503, 30.

As to Mr Cherepenko’s death, a just satisfactionsum in amount of EUR 2000 (UAH 33 370, 00)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on07/09/2015 – to the applicant’s heir bankaccount, Mr N.A. Cherepenko.As to the delayed payment, the applicant’s heirwas also paid a simple interest on 07/09/2015 inamount of UAH 621, 60.

687.

Mykola OpanasovychSUKHOKOBYLKA

20510/12 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kharkiv Region,judicial decisions in applicant’s case wereenforced in full.


688. Oleksandr FedorovychKRUPIY




to the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 85975.


689.

Vira Ivanivna SHCHAKINA 20918/12 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 5063, 95.


690.

Mariya Denisivna OREL 21067/12 Enforced. On 01/12/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 46708, 59.

Ms Orel did not submit to the State BailiffService her full banking details on time.On 24/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 370, 00)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on01/12/2014 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 01/12/2014 inamount of UAH 1 218, 00.

691.

Valentyna OmelyanivnaYAKYMENKO



692.

Sergiy AnatoliyovychCHAPTSEV



693.

Nina Fedorivna KHONDOKA 21875/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 22006, 27.


694.

Aleksandr VasilyevichAFANASYEV

21917/12 As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol.



Therefore, the Government of Ukrainecouldn’t able to receive from the debtor inthe case relevant information on theoutcome of the court decision enforcement.Thus, on 15/04/2019 – the enforcementproceeding in the present case wasterminated.

amount of UAH 507, 36.

695.

Elena Nikolayevna ISAYEVA 22030/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 28850, 21.


696.

Mariya Andriyivna PRUS 22048/12 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in ZaporizhzhiaRegion, judicial decisions in applicant’scase were enforced in full.


697.

Nina Petrivna NIKOZA 22077/12 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in ZaporizhzhiaRegion, judicial decisions in applicant’scase were enforced in full.


698.

Svetlana IvanovnaMEDVEDCHUK


Ms Medvedchuk did not submit to the StateBailiff Service her full banking details on time.On 17/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38 395, 41)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on26/03/2015 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 07/07/2015 inamount of UAH 919, 75.

699.

Mykola MykolayovychVARVADYUK




700.

Yuriy VolodymyrovychCHIRKIN



701.

Tatyana NikolayevnaGLUSHKOVA



702.

Nina Kyrylivna BEZUSHKO 22813/12 Enforced. On 07/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 6581, 50.


703.

Nina Kyrylivna BEZUSHKO 22890/12 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 69899, 50.


704.

Tetyana Mykolayivna DULKO 23503/12 According to the applicant’s statement,decision of the domestic court wasenforced in full.


705.Tetyana Mykolayivna DULKO 23508/12 According to the applicant’s statement,

decision of the domestic court wasenforced in full.


706.

Petro AndriyovychKOVTUNOVYCH



707. Mykola MykolayovychISAYKIN






708.

Volodymyr MykolayovychKARTASHOV



709.

Mykola AntonovychSHTANCHENKO



710.

Mykola AntonovychSHTANCHENKO



711.

Sergiy VasylyovychBOGATCHENKO



712.Mykola YuriyovychRYBYNSKYY



713. Sergiy Dmytrovych BOGUSH



714. Vasiliy AdamovichKOMARCHUK






715.

Sergiy IvanovychPEDCHENKO

25583/12 According to the applicant’s statement,decision of the domestic court wasenforced in full on 28/09/2015.


716.

Nina Vasilyevna ILCHENKO 28471/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 2888, 87.


717.

Nikolay Lukich ILCHENKO 28472/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 2138, 29.


718.

Irina NikolayevnaGALETSKAYA



719.

Galyna Petrivna RUSETSKA 29539/12 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 31531, 70.


720.

Igor Ivanovich VITSENTSIK 29648/12 According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine, judicial decisions inapplicant’s case were enforced in full.


721. KRUPA, PP 29881/12 Enforced. On 31/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts according

The applicant company did not submit to theState Bailiff Service information on full banking



details on time.On 24/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 370, 00)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on31/10/2014 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 24/12/2014 inamount of UAH 3 360.

722.

Gera StepanovychLYEKOMTSEV



723.




724.

Yelyzaveta PavlivnaSTAKHURA



725.

Vladimir Ivanovich BLUDOV 32549/12 According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine, judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.


726.

Mykola OleksiyovychBULAKHOV



727. Dmytro Dmytrovych OKUN 33221/12 Enforced. On 24/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts according



to the domestic court’s decisions in amounts of UAH 12531, 80 and UAH 22224, 96.


728.

Sergey NikolayevichPRUSAKOV



729.

Tamara Alekseyevna ZHOLUD 33624/12 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in amountof UAH 46269, 37.


730.

Nadiya VasylivnaOLSHEVSKA



731.

Oleksandr SergiyovychGLIBKO



732.

Nataliya LeonidivnaRULEVSKA

34118/12 As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol.Therefore, the Government of Ukrainecouldn’t able to receive from the debtor inthe case relevant information on theoutcome of the court decision enforcement.Thus, on 05/03/2019 – the enforcementproceeding in the present case wasterminated.

On 02/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 370, 00)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 04/12/2015 – a simple interest in amount ofUAH 513, 40 was transferred to special depositaccount of the Ministry of Justice of Ukrainedue to applicant’s bank account closing.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing her updated bankingdetails, but she did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 10/05/2017 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.As of today, applicant has not applied against a


decision on termination of the enforcementproceedings to the domestic court.

733.

Grygoriy GrygorovychSYUSEL



734.

Alla Viktorivna DEMBOVSKA 34484/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 661, 81.


735.

Olga Vasylivna GOROKHOVA 34487/12 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Rivne Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


736.

Galyna Ivanivna LESYK 34497/12 As a result of review, the decision of theIrpin Court of 23/09/2011 was quashed bythe desicion of the Irpin Court on13/0/2011.The State Bailiff Service of Ukraineterminated an enforcement proceeding inthe present case on 27/10/2014.


737.

Nikolay DmitriyevichPORTNOV

34589/12 Enforced. On 06/05/2015 and on04/03/2016 – the applicant was paid theoutstanding debts according to thedomestic court’s decisions in amounts ofUAH 8965 and UAH 10703, 83.

Mr Portnov did not submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 17/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38 395, 41)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on06/05/2015 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 06/05/2015 inamount of UAH 956, 43.

738.Nina TrokhymivnaKRYVOSHEYEVA

35024/12 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions in



amounts of UAH 10151, 80 andUAH 5410.


739.

Sergey AleksandrovichMIKHAYLOV

35354/12 Enforced. On 24/11/2014 and on05/02/2015 – the applicant was paid theoutstanding debts according to thedomestic court’s decisions in amounts ofUAH 41078, 76 and UAH 80669, 52.

Mr Mikhaylov did not submit to the State BailiffService his full banking details on time.On 17/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38 395, 41)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on24/12/2014 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 24/12/2014 inamount of UAH 1 613, 28 and UAH 2 292, 20.

740.

Kateryna VasylivnaGOLOVLYOVA



741.

Anatoliy MitrofanovichKHUSTOCHKIN



742.

Yevgeniy Pavlovych LEBED 36076/12 Enforced. On 03/03/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 483448, 80.


743.

Viktor Pavlovych ARAPOV 36351/12 Enforced. On 25/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 33789, 60.


744.

Nataliya Grygorivna ZDOTA 39421/12 Enforced. On 06/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 4522, 20.



745.

Mariya OleksiyivnaALEKSYEYEVA



746.

Oleksandr PetrovychDORDUKA



747.

Valentina Nikolayevna BOYKO 11641/13 Enforced. On 07/07/2016 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 12549, 86.


748.

Tatyana Yuryevna VASKO 12661/13 Enforced. On 18/02/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 3190.

Ms Vasko did not submit to the State BailiffService her full banking details on time.On 24/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 370, 00)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on19/12/2014 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 10/03/2015 inamount of UAH 601, 32.

749.

Tatyana Yuryevna VASKO 12663/13 Enforced. On 18/02/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 2900.

Ms Vasko did not submit to the State BailiffService her full banking details on time.On 24/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 370, 00)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on19/12/2014 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 10/03/2015 inamount of UAH 594, 84.

750.Nina Petrovna PAVLENKO 21480/13 In accordance with the case files, the

judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.




751.

Leonid Ivanovych TIMAKOV 27213/13 As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol.Therefore, the Government of Ukrainecouldn’t able to receive from the debtor inthe case relevant information on theoutcome of the court decision enforcement.Thus, on 05/04/2019 – the enforcementproceeding in the present case wasterminated.

Mr Timakov did not submit to the State BailiffService any information on his full bankingdetails.On 17/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38 395, 41)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 772, 56were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing his banking details, buthe did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 20/07/2016 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.As of today, applicant has not applied against adecision on termination of the enforcementproceedings to the domestic court.

752.

Fekla Antonovna MUKHINA 27220/13 On 24/09/2014 – the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 461 was transferred tothe special deposit account of the Ministryof Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to applicant for providing herupdated banking details, but she did notrespond to any of them.On 26/07/2016 – the enforcementproceeding in applicant’s case wasterminated.

On 24/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33 370, 00)a simple interest in amount of UAH 515, 76were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine due toapplicant’s bank account closing.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing her updated bankingdetails, but she did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 20/07/2016 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.As of today, applicant has not applied against adecision on termination of the enforcementproceedings to the domestic court.

753.

Raisa Nikolayevna KORZH 28295/13 According to the applicant’s statement,decision of the domestic court wasenforced in full.

Ms Korzh did not submit to the State BailiffService her full banking details on time.On 17/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 38 395, 41)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on30/03/2015 – to the applicant bank account.



754. Ivan Mykhaylovich CHUBYR 29227/10

THE COURT DECLARED APPLICATIONS INADMISSIBLE

755. Volodymyr FedorovychSHYMANSKYY

59349/11

756. Dmitriy YuryevichBABARTSEV

61732/11

757. Mykola YosypovychGLYOSHKO

9341/12

758. Tetyana VolodymyrivnaGOLOVKOVA

18293/12

759. Anatoliy OleksiyovychPOTYEKHIN

25081/12

760. Oksana Fedorivna PELEKH 35206/12

761. Oleksandr FedorovychSERDYUK

26028/13

762. Antonina YosyfivnaGORDEYUK

67987/10 APPLICATION TO BE STRUCK OUT

CASE OF ANDRIANOVA AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE(application no. 10319/04)


ZHOVNER GROUP763. Natalya Vladislavovna

ANDRIANOVA10319/04

_____________

On 26/08/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 35316, 19)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on04/09/2014 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 07/10/2014 inamount of UAH 549, 43.

764. Vladimir FedotovichANTONOV

APPLICATION WAS STRUCK OUT OF THE LIST OF CASES

765. Nadezhda NikolayevnaBLOKHINA _____________ On 26/08/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 35316, 19)

were transferred to the special deposit account


of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on04/09/2014 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 07/10/2014 inamount of UAH 549, 43.

766. Svetlana NikolayevnaVOLOSOVICH

_____________


767. Olga AleksandrovnaGOMULINA

_____________


768. Natalya VitalyevnaGLYBINA

_____________


769. Lyudmila PavlovnaDVORNIK

_____________


770. Irina GlebovnaDYOMINA _____________

On 26/08/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 35316, 19)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on


04/09/2014 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 07/10/2014 inamount of UAH 549, 43.

771. Yelena IvanovnaDYNTU

_____________


772. Olga NikolayevnaISHCHENKO

_____________


773. Valentina PetrovnaKOVALENKO

_____________


774. Aleksandr OsherovichKORZHENEVICH

_____________


775. Lyudmila DanilovnaKRAVCHUK


776. Olga VladimirovnaKUZNETSOVA



777. Valentina PetrovnaLEUSENKO

_____________


778. Tamara TimofeyevnaLOBACHYOVA

_____________


779. Galina AnatolyevnaOSOCHENKO

_____________


780. Olga IvanovnaNOSENKO

_____________


781. Marina VladimirovnaORLOVA

_____________



782. Tatyana VladimirovnaPENEDZHI

_____________


783. Lidiya AfanasyevnaPODGAYCHENKO

_____________


784. Valentina NikolayevnaSUSHENKO

_____________


785. Galina VasilyevnaTRETYAKOVA

_____________


786. Valentina PetrovnaSHVEDKINA

_____________



787. Aleksandra IvanovnaYAVORSKAYA


CASE OF ANDRUSENKO AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE(application no. 41073/02)


ZHOVNER GROUP788. Leonid Ivanovych Andrusenko 41073/02

_____________According to the case files, the applicant waspaid a just satisfaction sum in amount ofEUR 1800 (UAH 11991, 53) within time limits.

789. Valeriy VolodymyrovychBondarenko

Enforced. On 21/02/2007 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decisions inamounts of UAH 3 785, 74 and UAH8 542, 85.

According to the case files, the applicant waspaid a just satisfaction sum in amount ofEUR 1300 (UAH 8600, 55) within time limits.

790. Ivan Petrovych Mysnianko_____________


791. Oleksandr MykolayovychGoryachykh _____________


792. Volodymyr GrygorovychLeontyev _____________


793. Ivan Yegorovich Migunov_____________


CASE OF FILATOVA AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE(application no. 12424/06 and 15 others)Date of Definitive Judgment: 31/07/2014


794. Igor Grigoryevich PRYADKO 38276/07 Enforced. On 24/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 30000.

On 20/10/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33220, 81)were transferred to the applicant bank account.


1

795. Mykola GrygorovychPLOKHOTNYUK



796. Yuriy Pavlovich NIKONENKO 7436/08 According to the case files, decision of thedomestic court in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


797. SSV,PP 21974/08 Enforced. On 03/04/2018 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 485538, 03.

The applicant company did not submit to theState Bailiff Service information on full bankingdetails on time.On 22/12/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 39257, 25)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on03/04/2018 – to the applicant company bankaccount.

798. Valentin ValentinovichMOLCHANOV



799. Grigoriy VasilyevichALFYOROV

23552/08 According to the case files, decision of thedomestic court in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.

On 12/11/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 33023, 65)were transferred to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant wasalso paid a simple interest on 17/12/2015 inamount of UAH 35, 88.

800. Sergiy VolodymyrovychDYMYTRIYENKO



801. SOLO, TOV 20270/09 Enforced. On 25/06/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 5127077, 98.

The applicant company did not submit to theState Bailiff Service information on full bankingdetails on time.On 22/12/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 39257, 25)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on25/06/2015 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicant


company was also paid a simple interest on17/12/2015 in amount of UAH 184, 60.

802. Anton SergiyovychLUTSENKOOlena OleksandrivnaLUTSENKO


On 20/10/2014 – each applicant was paid a justsatisfaction sum in amount of EUR 2000(UAH 32869, 38).

803. VFK INTELSOYUZ, TOV 50417/09 According to the case files, decision of thedomestic court in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.

On 25/12/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 39257, 25)were transferred to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicantcompany was also paid a simple interest on11/12/2015 in amount of UAH 195, 25.

804. DONBASNAFTOPRODUKT,DP


The applicant company did not submit to theState Bailiff Service information on full bankingdetails on time.On 22/12/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 39257, 25)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on30/03/2016 – to the applicant bank account.As to the delayed payment, the applicantcompany was also paid a simple interest on21/04/2016 in amount of UAH 181, 77.

805. Aleksey GrigoriyevichKHLEBNIKOV



CASE OF GIMADULINA AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE(application nos. 30675/06, 30785/06, 32818/06, 34468/06 and 49001/06)


ZHOVNER GROUP806. Gimadulina Yelena

Vladimirovna30675/06 As to case files, enforcement proceeding in

the case was terminated on 28/09/2012 dueto enforcement of the Сourt’s judgment infull.

On 20/07/2010 – EUR 360 (UAH 3697, 11)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 12/09/2011 – a simple interest in amount ofUAH 18, 33 were transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine.


The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing her updated bankingdetails, but she did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 24/09/2012 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.On 28/09/2012 – the enforcement proceeding inapplicant’s case was terminated.

807. Konyayev AndreyAleksandrovich

30785/06 As to case files, enforcement proceeding inthe case was terminated on 28/09/2012 dueto enforcement of the Сourt’s judgment infull.

On 20/07/2010 – EUR 360 (UAH 3697, 11)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 12/09/2011 – a simple interest in amount ofUAH 18, 72 were transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing his updated bankingdetails, but he did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 24/09/2012 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.On 28/09/2012 – the enforcement proceeding inapplicant’s case was terminated.

808. Kozlova Valentina Grigoryevna 32818/06 As to case files, enforcement proceeding inthe case was terminated on 28/09/2012 dueto enforcement of the Сourt’s judgment infull.


809. Dankov AnatoliyKlementyevich


On 20/07/2010 – EUR 350 (UAH 3594, 41)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 12/09/2011 – a simple interest in amount ofUAH 18, 33 were transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing his updated bankingdetails, but he did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 24/09/2012 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.


On 28/09/2012 – the enforcement proceeding inapplicant’s case was terminated.

810. Bondarenko MykolaOleksandrovych



CASE OF KONONOVA AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE(application no. 11770/03 and 89 other applications)


ZHOVNER GROUP811. Svetlana Sergeyevna

KONONOVA11770/03 Enforced. On 30/01/2014 – the applicant

was paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 925.

On 21/11/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 27/06/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 247.

812. Nikolay IvanovichDOVGALYOV


On 11/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on15/10/2013 – to the applicant bank account.On 27/06/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 17, 30

813. Nonna Igorevna PORTNOVA 26918/05 According to the Law of Ukraine “OnEnforcement Proceedings”, a certaincategory of court decisions can be enforcedexceptionally by a debtor.Thus, according to the domestic courtdecision in the applicant’s case, thisdecision should have been enforced onlyby the City Council of Evpatoria (adebtor), which is located in theAutonomous Republic of Crimea.The Government of Ukraine lost access tothe case-files as they are situated interritories outside governmental controlfrom 20/02/2014.




Therefore, the Government of Ukrainecouldn’t able to receive from the debtor inthe case relevant information on theoutcome of the court decision enforcement.Thus, on 15/11/2018 – the enforcementproceeding in the present case wasterminated.

814. PARITET LTD, TOV VKP 18448/06 Enforced. On 26/04/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 38021, 84.

On 21/11/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the applicant company bankaccount.On 27/06/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 247.

815. Valeriy ViktorovychSYNELNYKOV

18673/06 Domestic court’s decision in applicant’scase was enforced in part of reinstatementof applicant to his position.After that, TOV “Naftohazhist” wasliquidated by a decision of the CommercialCourt of Kyiv dated 15/03/2011 due to itsbankruptcy.Therefore, the Government of Ukrainecouldn’t able to receive from the debtor inthe case relevant information on theoutcome of the court decision enforcement.Thus, on 11/05/2019 – the enforcementproceeding in the present case wasterminated.


816. Lyudmila FyodorovnaBOBROVA

20933/06 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kherson Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


817. Vasiliy AleksandrovichTERNOVIK

34409/06 A decision of the Novogrodivka Court of21/12/1999 is not enforceable due to thedeath of the applicant on 23/09/2014.The enforcement proceeding in applicant’scase was terminated on 27/11/2018.



818. Stanislav Ivanovych PRUDKYY 34596/06 According to the applicant’s statement of16/07/2013, decision of the domestic courtwas enforced in full.


819. Lyudmyla Viktorivna BURYAN 41295/06 Enforced. On 30/01/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 463, 67.


820. Olena YevgeniyivnaLYOVOCHKINA



821. Yelena YevgenyevnaGRYUNER

Lyubov AleksandrovnaRUSANOVA


On 23/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 27/06/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 58, 82.The Court declared applicationno. 47387/06 inadmissible insofar as it is madeby Ms Lyubov Rusanova.

822. Olena Mykhaylivna PIKUSH 9229/07 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in DnipropetrovskRegion, judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.

On 21/11/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 27/06/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 247

823. Mykola YevgenovychTATARENKO



824. Mykola Petrovych POPOV 19149/07 Enforced. On 26/04/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 10721, 58.


825. Mariya FedorivnaODNOKOPYLA

22887/07 The enforcement proceeding in applicant’scase was terminated on 03/05/2019 due tothe death of the applicant.

On 11/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on


09/10/2013 – to the applicant bank account.On 27/06/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 17, 30.

826. Irina Yuryevna TIMOFEYEVA 24362/07 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kherson Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


827. Viktor FeofanovichZATURINSKIY



828. KONEKS LTD, TOV 26676/07 Enforced. On 26/04/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 5003, 40.


829. Yakiv Mykhaylovych GORDIY 31465/07 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Ivano-FrankivskRegion, judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.


830. Vasiliy NikolayevichKOVALENKO


Mr Kovalenko submitted to the State BailiffService incorrect information on his bankingdetails.On 04/12/2013– EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)was returned to the deposit account and on24/12/2013 – to the correct bank account of theapplicant.

Boris NikolayevichADAMOVICH


Mr Adavovich submitted to the State BailiffService incorrect information on his bankingdetails.On 04/12/2013– EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)was returned to the deposit account and on24/12/2013 – to the correct bank account of theapplicant.


Tatyana VasilyevnaBRUSLINOVSKAYA



Anna Ivanovna DANILENKO Enforced. On 26/04/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 5064, 43.


Yekaterina NikolayevnaDANILENKO



Antonina NikolayevnaKRAYNYAYA



Natalya MikhaylovnaKULAYEVA



831. Lyudmila PavlovnaTOLSTOKOROVA



832. Andrey Viktorovich MALTYZ 35858/07 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Lugansk Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


833. Nina Petrovna PAVLENKO 40767/07 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kharkiv Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.



834. Vitaliy GrygorovychPASYOVIN



835. Vladimir DmitriyevichPUZENKO

51922/07 On 26/04/2014 – the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 150000 was transferredto the special deposit account of theMinistry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to applicant for providing hisupdated banking details, but he did notrespond to any of them.Thus, on 29/01/2015 the sum was returnedto the State Budget.The enforcement proceeding in applicant’scase was terminated on 14/07/2015.

Mr Puzenko submitted to the State BailiffService incorrect information on full bankingdetails.Thus, on 28/11/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31657, 08) and a simple interest in amount ofUAH 275, 56 were returned to the depositaccount.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing his updated bankingdetails, but he did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 29/01/2015 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.As of today, applicant has not applied against adecision on termination of the enforcementproceedings to the domestic court.

836. Aleksandr IvanovichKOLOSOV



837. Nikolay GrigoryevichSHEVYCH



838. Aksentiy PlatonovichDMITRASHEK



839. Viktor AleksandrovichMIKHAYLOV





840. Andriy SergiyovychSALNIKOV

28061/08 According to the letter of the Military UnitA3358 (a debtor) of 27/11/2018, thedomestic court’s decision in applicant’scase was enforced.

On 21/11/2013 – EUR 1500 (UAH 15828, 54)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 27/06/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 123, 12

841. Diana Sergiyivna SALNIKOVA 28071/08 According to the letter of the Military UnitA3358 (a debtor) of 27/11/2018, thedomestic court’s decision in applicant’scase was enforced.


842. Andriy MykhaylovychDANILOV

28090/08 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kyiv Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


843. NAK, TOV 32466/08 Enforced. On 30/07/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 26702, 09.

On 11/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on24/09/2013 – to the applicant company bankaccount.On 27/06/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 17, 30

844. Valentina MikhaylovnaMELNIKOVA 46953/08



845. Ganna Oleksiyivna SITARUK 50872/08 Enforced. On 02/12/2016 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 266, 55.


846. Yevgeniya TrokhymivnaGUTSOL

61421/08 Enforced. On 26/04/2014 and on04/03/2015 – the applicant was paid theoutstanding debts according to thedomestic court’s decision in amounts ofUAH 3592, 25 and UAH 2136.



847. Anatoliy GrygoriyovychARTYUKH

12892/09 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in ZakarpatskaRegion, judicial decision in applicant’scase was enforced in full.


848. Vasyl Yukhymovych LEGKYY 25260/09 Enforced. On 02/07/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 8796, 50.

On 11/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on15/10/2013 - to the applicant bank account.On 02/07/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 17, 30.

849. Yevgeniy AleksandrovichMATSEGORA

26397/09 On 09/06/2015 – the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 2825, 67 wastransferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to applicants heirs for providingtheir banking details and certificate ofheirship, but they did not respond to any ofthem.Thus, on 16/06/2016 the sum was returnedto the State Budget.The enforcement proceeding in applicant’scase was terminated on 06/07/2016.

As to Mr Matsegora’s death, on 11/09/2013 –EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08) were transferredto the special deposit account of the Ministry ofJustice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicants heirs for providing their bankingdetails and certificate of heirship, but they didnot respond to any of them.Thus, on 04/07/2015 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.As of today, applicant’s heirs have not appliedagainst a decision on termination of theenforcement proceedings to the domestic court.

850. Galina Vasilyevna OLENICH 32372/09 Enforced. On 26/04/2014 and on14/07/2014 – the applicant was paid theoutstanding debts according to thedomestic court’s decision in amounts ofUAH 5984, 77 and UAH 2325, 54.


851. Valeriy Fedorovych KRASYUK 33588/09 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Lviv Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


852. Nadiya MykolayivnaMELNYCHUK





On 27/06/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 247

853. Fekla Antonovna MUKHINA 44965/09 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Lugansk Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


854. ADEPT, PP 46337/09 According to Appendix 1 of Court’sjudgment in applicant’s case, a decision ofthe Sevastopol Commercial Court ofAppeal (of 28/11/2005) was quashed bythe Sevastopol Commercial Court ofAppeal on 21/06/2010.

On 21/11/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the applicant bank accountOn 10/07/2014 a simple interest in amount ofUAH 247 was transferred to special depositaccount of the Ministry of Justice of Ukrainedue to applicant’s bank account closing.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing updated banking details,but he did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 02/03/2016 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.As of today, applicant has not applied against adecision on termination of the enforcementproceedings to the domestic court.

855. Igor Viktorovych FEDOTOV 53257/09 According to the applicant’s statement of25/02/2012, decision of the domestic courtwas enforced in full.

On 11/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on15/10/2013 – tot the applicant bank account.

856. Taisiya KostyantynivnaTATARETS



857. Oleksandr FedorovychSERDYUK



858. Dmytro GrygorovychKAMENSKYY





On 27/06/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 247

859. Anatoliy IvanovichRASKHODOV



860. Vladimir Anatolyevich SENIK 65102/09 Enforced. On 26/04/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 5709, 29.


861. Vyacheslav PavlovychOVCHYNNIKOV



862. Larysa MykolayivnaRYBALKO

Yevgen OpanasovychRYBALKO

11325/10 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kharkiv Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.

On 21/11/2013 – EUR 6000 (UAH 63314, 16)were transferred to the applicants bank accountsof Ms Larysa Rybalko and Mr Yevgen Rybalko.On 27/06/2014 – applicants were also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 247 andUAH 110, 72.In addition, on 30/06/2017 at the request ofapplicants, the State Bailiff Service paid themUAH 779, 32 and UAH 887, 22 as a difference,which was caused by exchanges rate fluctuation.

Denys Yevgenovych RYBALKO On 11/09/2013 – EUR 6000 (UAH 63314, 16)were transferred to Mr Denys Rybalko bankaccount.On 27/06/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 17, 30.

Dmytro YevgenovychRYBALKO

As to Mr Dmytro Rybalko’s death, the fullamount of just satisfaction sum in amount ofEUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08) and a simpleinterest UAH 17, 30 were transferred to thespecial deposit account of the Ministry of


Justice of Ukraine.On 27/11/2013 – above mentioned sum wastransferred to applicant’s heirs’ bank account,Mr Y.O. Rybalko and Ms L.M. Rybalko.

863. Galyna OleksandrivnaTARANENKO



864. Anatoliy DanilovichMATVIYENKO

11976/10 As a result of review, domestic court’sdecisions in applicant’s case were quashedby the Higher Administrative Court ofUkraine on 24/07/2013.Thus, the State Bailiff Service terminatedan enforcement proceeding in the presentcase on 23/07/2015.

On 08/10/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 11/07/2014 – a simple interest in amount ofUAH 110, 72 was transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing his updated bankingdetails, but he did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 14/07/2015 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.

865. Aleksandr VasilyevichMOROZOV 13482/10



866. Oleksandr MykolayovychSAFONOV



Valeriy IvanovychMEDVEDEV




Valentyn FedorovychSTOROZHENKO

Enforced. On 26/04/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 8121,6


Stanislav StanislavovychKUSHTAN



Oleksandr ArsentyovychLISNENKO



Sergiy OleksandrovychZAGLUSHCHENKO



867. REAGENT, TOV 16144/10 Enforced. On 26/04/2014 – the applicantcompany was paid the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 240557, 84.

On 08/10/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the applicant company bankaccount.On 27/06/2014 – the applicant company wasalso paid a simple interest in amount ofUAH 110, 72

868. Vitaliy Vitalyevich DYACHKIN 16644/10 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Donetsk Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


869. Volodymyr Yuriyovych SIKAN 17363/10 Enforced. On 26/04/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 3315, 30.


870. Irina MikhaylovnaROMANOVA




871. Nadezhda NikolayevnaPALADIY



872. Mykola DmytrovychGRECHANYY



873. Georgiy Ivanovych BILOUS 20032/10 Enforced. On 02/07/2014 – the applicant’sheir was paid the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 2920, 48.

As to Mr Bilous death, awarded sum of justsatisfaction was transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine and on 15/10/2013 – to the applicant’sheir bank account.On 02/07/2014 – applicant’s heir was also paida simple interest in amount of UAH 17, 30

874. Petr Kuzmich KOVALENKO 22620/10 Enforced. On 04/02/2015 – the applicant’sheir was paid the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 5578, 68.

As to Mr Kovalenko’s death, awarded sum ofjust satisfaction was transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine and on 08/10/2013 – to the applicant’sheir bank account.On 04/02/2015 – applicant’s heir was also paida simple interest in amount of UAH 17, 30.

875. Vitaliy GennadiyovychPANKOV



876. Ryta VitaliyivnaADAMOVSKA



877. Mariya IvanivnaARTYUKHOVA

26232/10 Enforced. On 02/07/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 3 016.

On 11/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on06/06/2014 – to the applicant bank account.



878. Nikolay NikolayevichYUKHIMENKO

26676/10 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in the AutonomousRepublic of Crimea, judicial decision inapplicant’s case was enforced in full.

On 21/11/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31 657, 08)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 10/07/2014 – a simple interest in amount ofUAH 247 were transferred to the special depositaccount of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing his updated bankingdetails, but he did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 14/07/2015 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.On 23/07/2015 – the enforcement proceeding inapplicant’s case was terminated.

879. Grigoriy VasilyevichALFEROV

28834/10 Enforced. On 24/06/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 24/06/2015.


880. Vladimir StepanovichANTOSHCHUK



881. Nataliya MykolayivnaSAVCHENKO



882. Antonina NikolayevnaKOSHELEVSKAYA

42600/10 Enforced. On 26/04/2014 and 07/10/2014– the applicant was paid the outstandingdebts according to the domestic court’sdecision in amount of UAH 18633,79 andUAH 45000.



Yevgeniy AleksandrovichKOSHELEVSKIY



883. Vita GrygorivnaNIKITCHENKO



884. Vladimir AleksandrovichBORISOV



885. Anatoliy Ivanovych ZHUK 66602/10 Enforced. On 26/04/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 37489, 84.


886. Raisa Nikolayevna KORZH66622/10

According to the case files, decision of thedomestic court in applicant’s case wasenforced on 26/11/2010.


887. Valentyna MykolayivnaKUCHER



888. Petro VasylyovychZADERZHYNSKYY



889. Viktor AlekseyevichRASPOPOV




890. Vladyslav ValeriyovychAVDEYENKO 60679/08



891. Gennadiy Petrovych STROM 50101/09 Enforced. On 26/04/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 10434, 28.


892. Iryna Ivanivna SKOCHKO 51423/09 Enforced. On 26/04/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 15541, 99.


893. Olena VolodymyrivnaCHAYKA AKA OSTAPENKO



894. Nadiya OleksandrivnaZAGYNAYLO



Yuliya AndriyivnaSLOBODSKA AKAZAGYNAYLO

On 23/09/2013 – EUR 1500 (UAH 15726, 63)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 11/07/2014 – a simple interest in amount ofUAH 29, 41 was transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing her updated bankingdetails, but she did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 21/07/2015 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.On 23/07/2015 – the enforcement proceeding inapplicant’s case was terminated.


895. Iryna Dmytrivna ULYANOVA 52748/10 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kharkiv Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


896. Viktor Yakovych DRANYSH 55471/10 According to the case files, decision of thedomestic court in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


CASE OF KYSELYOVA AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE(Application no. 6155/05 and 22 others)Date of Definitive Judgment: 09/01/2014


897. Zhanna MykhaylivnaKYSELYOVA



898. 1) Zoya DmitriyevnaPANCHUK

38540/05 Enforced. On 11/07/2016 – applicant’s heirwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 12 906, 58.

On 22/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34589, 78)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 11/07/2016 – applicant’s heir was paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 784.

2) Irina VladimirovnaKRINITSYNA



3) Sergey VasilyevichLAKURIN



4) Irina Igorevna LAKURINA Enforced. On 14/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1 549, 88.


5) Tatyana NikolayevnaLESHEFINA

Enforced. On 18/08/2015 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts according





6) Lyubov AfanasyevnaMASHKINA



7) Lyubov AndreyevnaMOSKALENKO



8) Marina PetrovnaVALIKOVA



9) Sergey AnatolyevichVOLOVIKOV



10) Svetlana ViktorovnaVOLOVIKOVA



11) Ivan Borisovich ZUBKOV On 04/09/2014 – the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 14 072, 57 wastransferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to applicant for providing hisbanking details, but he did not respond toany of them.Thus, this sum was returned to the StateBudget.On 20/10/2017 – the enforcementproceeding in applicant’s case wasterminated.

Mr Zubkov did not submit to the State BailiffService any information on his banking details.On 04/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34589, 78)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 671, 92were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing his banking details, buthe did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 22/09/2017 the sum was returned tothe State Budget.


12) Lyudmila DanilovnaGALINSKAYA



13) Olga VasilyevnaLEBEDEVA



899. Natalya IvanovnaABAKUMOVA



900. Anna AlekseyevnaPOLYAKOVA

Yevgeniy NikolayevichPIKULITSKIY

11534/06 On 04/09/2017 – the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionsin amounts of UAH 890, 28 andUAH 1946, 29 were transferred to thespecial deposit account of the Ministry ofJustice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to applicants for providing theirbanking details, but they did not respond toany of them.Thus, these sums were returned to the StateBudget.On 20/10/2017 – the enforcementproceedings in applicants’ case wereterminated.

Ms Polyakova and Mr Pikulitskiy did notsubmit to the State Bailiff Service anyinformation on their banking details.On 04/09/2014 – EUR 4000 (UAH 69179, 56)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 1001,58 were transferred to the special depositaccount of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicants for providing their banking details,but they did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 22/09/2017 these sums were returnedto the State Budget.

901. Dmitriy Iosifovich TURLAKOV 26359/06 Enforced. On 14/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 2682.


902. Grygoriy GrygorovychBODNAR

21116/07 As a result of review, domestic court’sdecisions in applicant’s case were quashedby the Court of Appeal of KhmelnytskRegion on 11/02/2008.Thus, the State Bailiff Service terminated



an enforcement proceeding in the presentcase on 14/02/2017.

903. Tamara MykolayivnaDENYSYUK

44334/07 On 0/10/2014 – the outstanding debtsaccording to the domestic court’s decisionin amount of UAH 1500 was transferred tothe special deposit account of the Ministryof Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sentrequests to applicant for providing herbanking details, but she did not respond toany of them.Thus, this sum was returned to the StateBudget.On 26/10/2017 – the enforcementproceeding in applicant’s case wasterminated.

Ms Denysyuk did not submit to the State BailiffService any information on her banking details.On 04/09/2014 – EUR 2000 (UAH 34589, 78)and a simple interest in amount of UAH 502, 54were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine.The Government had repeatedly sent requests toapplicant for providing her banking details, butshe did not respond to any of them.Thus, on 17/10/2017 these sums were returnedto the State Budget.

904. Anatoliy VladimirovichRUDENKO

47023/07 As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol. Therefore, it is not possible toreport the outcome of the enforcementproceedings regarding to the applicant.The enforcement proceeding in the presentcase was terminated on 08/05/2019.


905. Svetlana VasilyevnaZHUKOVA



Dmitriy Olegovich ZHUKOV Enforced. On 14/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 1784, 80.


906. Volodymyr MykolayovychMELETSKYY




As a result of review, a decision of thePrydniprovskyy District Court of Cherkasydated of 28/02/2007 was quashed by theKyiv Administrative Court of Appeal on01/09/2009.Thus, the State Bailiff Service terminatedan enforcement proceeding in the presentcase on 29/10/2014.

907. Viktor NikolayevichVELICHKO

15730/08 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Odessa Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


908. Aleksandr GrigoryevichPOPKOV



909. KARINA, TOV 21701/08 Enforced. On 04/09/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 84265, 76.


910. Vyacheslav Semyonovich USOV 37616/08 Enforced. On 07/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 8516, 75.

As to Mr Usov’s death, EUR 2000 (UAH34589, 78) were transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine on 04/09/2014.On 07/10/2014 – this sum was transferred toapplicant’s heir bank account.On 30/09/2014 – applicant’s heir was also paida simple interest in amount of UAH 596, 44.

911. Yaroslav VasilyovychBOYCHUK



912. Gulyam Khabib AKBARI 59374/08 Enforced. On 14/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 73632, 25.



913. Vladimir LeonidovichKISHCHENKO



914. Vitaliy IvanovichDEMCHENKO



915. Igor Petrovych GAVRYLYUK 35246/10 Enforced. On 14/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 3865, 30.


Olena Petrivna KRYLAS Enforced. On 14/10/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 5955, 30.


916. Andriy Petrovych KITURA 42850/10 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Lviv Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


CASE OF LOGACHOVA AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE(applications nos. 4510/05, 13273/05, 26704/06 and 30757/06)


ZHOVNER GROUP917. LOGACHOVA Zinaida

Yevgenyevna4510/05 Enforced. On 18/04/2016 – the applicant

was paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 6338, 56.


918. OSTROVERKHOV LeonidVladimirovich

13273/05 As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol. Therefore, it is not possible toreport the outcome of the enforcementproceedings regarding to the applicant.

Mr Ostroverkhov did not submit to the StateBailiff Service information on his bankingdetails on time.On 02/08/2010 – EUR 24 (UAH 246, 78) weretransferred to the special deposit account of theMinistry of Justice of Ukraine and on


The enforcement proceeding in the presentcase was terminated on 05/03/2019.

17/01/2011 – to the applicant bank account.

919. GOROVENKO AleksandrIvanovich

26704/06 The enforcement proceeding in applicant’scase was terminated due to the death of theapplicant on 16/08/2011.


920. ANTIPENKO Ivan Fedorovich 30757/06 As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol. Therefore, it is not possible toreport the outcome of the enforcementproceedings regarding to the applicant.The enforcement proceeding in the presentcase was terminated on 05/03/2019.

As to Mr Antipenko’s death, EUR 2600 (UAH27127, 06) were transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice ofUkraine on 02/08/2010.On 21/07/2011 – awarded sum was transferredto the applicant’s heir bank account.

CASE OF ROZHENKO AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE(Application no. 2644/04 and 23 other applications)


ZHOVNER GROUP921. Ruslan Yevgenovych

ROZHENKO2644/04 Enforced. On 30/01/2014 – the applicant

was paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 229190.


922. Aleksandr PavlovichMIKHAYLOV

17176/07 On 21/11/2013 – the applicant was paidthe outstanding debts according to thedomestic court’s decision in amount ofUAH 1771, 22


923. Vitaliy NikolayevichSIMUSHIN

42782/07 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 11837, 12.As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol. Therefore, it is not possible toreport the outcome of the enforcementproceedings regarding to the reinstatement




of applicant to his position at the company.The enforcement proceeding in the presentcase was terminated on 05/03/2019.

924. Viktor Vasilyevich BEZRUK 46001/07 Enforced. On 20/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 11837, 12.As of today, the Government of Ukrainelost access to the case-files as they aresituated in territories outside governmentalcontrol. Therefore, it is not possible toreport the outcome of the enforcementproceedings regarding to the reinstatementof applicant to his position at the company.The enforcement proceeding in the presentcase was terminated on 05/03/2019.


925. Klavdiya IvanovnaKASPEROVICH


On 16/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31453, 25)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine and on16/01/2014 – to the applicant bank account.On 11/11/2013– the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 231, 15

926. Nadezhda PetrovnaKARPUKHINA



927. Yelena VladimirovnaPLETYONKINA 13835/08



928. Nikolay VasilyevichGORBUNOV

23406/08 Enforced. On 24/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 17682,18


929. Vadym VolodymyrovychVYGOVSKYY




to the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 25820, 36

On 11/11/2013 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 270, 66

930. Anatoliy Pavlovich SHAMIN 30858/09 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Donetsk Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


931. Tetyana MykolayivnaPAVYTSKA

35901/09 According to the case files, decision of theZhytomyr Regional Administrative Courtdated of 21/11/2007 was enforced in full.As a result of review, the ZhytomyrRegional Administrative Court dated of05/10/2007 was quashed by the HigherAdministrative Court of Ukraine on19/07/2011.Thus, the State Bailiff Service terminatedan enforcement proceeding in the presentcase on 20/11/2013.


932. Larysa MykolayivnaKOSYGINA

39123/09 According to the case files, decision of theZhytomyr Regional Administrative Courtdated of 21/11/2007 was enforced in full.As a result of review, the ZhytomyrRegional Administrative Court dated of05/10/2007 was quashed by the HigherAdministrative Court of Ukraine on19/07/2011.


933. Viktor GeorgiyovychZAGRANYCHNYI


On 18/10/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31669, 07)were returned to the special deposit account ofthe Ministry of Justice of Ukraine due toapplicant’s bank account closing.On 11/12/2013 – awarded sum was transferredto updated bank account of Mr Zagranychnyi.On 02/07/2014 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 352, 44

934. Vladyslav ViktorovychKRYZHANIVSKYY

48596/09 According to the case files, decision of theZhytomyr Regional Administrative Courtdated of 21/11/2007 was enforced in full.

On 27/09/2013 – EUR 3000 (UAH 31669, 07)were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 11/11/2013 – the applicant was also paid a


As a result of review, the ZhytomyrRegional Administrative Court dated of05/10/2007 was quashed by the HigherAdministrative Court of Ukraine on19/07/2011.Thus, the State Bailiff Service terminatedan enforcement proceeding in the presentcase on 18/11/2013.

simple interest in amount of UAH 270, 66

935. Motrona PavlivnaBOGDANETS

50861/09 According to the letter of the Pension Fundof Ukraine, judicial decisions inapplicant’s case were enforced in full.


936. Oleksandr VolodymyrovychYEVDOKYMOV

14165/10 According to the Main TerritorialDepartment of Justice in Kharkiv Region,judicial decision in applicant’s case wasenforced in full.


937. Yevgeniy PetrovichDOLINSKIY



938. Aleksandr VyacheslavovichKOVALENKO

29139/10 Enforced. On 24/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 5693


Nadezhda VasilyevnaKOVALENKO



939. Galyna OpanasivnaFEDORENKO



940. Arkadiy IvanovychSHAPOVALOV 74285/10

Enforced. On 24/06/2014 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the domestic court’s decision in amountof UAH 94500



941. Oleksandr DavydovychCHAKIR



942. Viktor ViktorovichSLOBODYANYUK



BURMA v. Ukraine(application no 15712/13 and 207 others)Date of Definitive Judgment: 18/05/2017

Payment Deadline: 08/08/2017UPDATED

ZHOVNER GROUP,YURIY NIKOLAYEVICH IVANOV GROUP943. Andriy Mykolayovych

FEDENYOV810/14 As to Mr Fedenyov’s death the full amount

of outstanding debts was transferred to thespecial deposit account of the Ministry ofJustice on 06/09/2017 and on 29/03/2019 –to the bank account of applicant’s heirs.

As to Mr Fedenyov’s death the full amount ofjust satisfaction in amount of EUR 1 000 (UAH30 841, 39) was transferred to the specialdeposit account of the Ministry of Justice on06/09/2017 and on 24/10/2017 – to the bankaccount of applicant’s heirs.

KHARUK AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE(application no 703/05 and 115 other applications)


UPDATEDZHOVNER GROUP

944. Vladimir RomanovichMALINOVSKIY

70296/10 On 03/12/2012 – the applicant was paidthe outstanding debts according to thedomestic court decision in amount of UAH1 830, 95.As to the outcome of the in-kindenforcement proceedings regarding to thecoal for the applicant, the Government ofUkraine lost access to the case-files as theyare situated in territories outside thegovernmental control. Therefore, it is not

On 16/10/2012 – EUR 3 000 (amount paid:UAH 31 103, 16; exchange rate: 10, 36772)were transferred to the Mr Malinovskiy bankaccount.



possible to report the outcome of the in-kind enforcement proceedings.Thus, on 11/04/2019 – the enforcementproceeding in the present case wasterminated.

Mykola Antonovych KOBYLYNSKYY v. Ukraine(application no 11632/13 and 316 others)Date of Definitive Judgment: 16/06/2016

Payment Deadline: 16/09/2016UPDATED

ZHOVNER GROUP945. Yuriy Yosypovych TALKO 42614/13 According to the letter of the State

Treasury Service of Ukraine of22/03/2019, the decision of the domesticcourt was enforced in full.

On 05/09/2016 – EUR 1 000 (UAH 29810, 29)were transferred to the applicant bank account.

946. Andriy Yuriyovych ROSTOV 68428/13 According to the letter of the StateTreasury Service of Ukraine of22/03/2019, the decision of the domesticcourt was enforced in full.


947. Valeriy DanylovychPANCHENKO

71803/13 Enforced. On 26/02/2019 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the decision of the domestic court inamount of UAH 53 755, 77.


948. Andriy MyronovychPEDORENKO

74035/13 According to the letter of the StateTreasury Service of Ukraine of21/03/2019, the decision of the domesticcourt was enforced in full.

On 19/09/2016 – EUR 1 000 (UAH 29 536, 97)were transferred to the applicant bank account.

949. Sergiy Grygorovych MOROZ 75973/13 Enforced. On 17/02/2019 – applicant’sheirs were paid the outstanding debtsaccording to the decision of the domesticcourt in amount of UAH 26 050, 84.

As to Mr Moroz’s death, the just satisfactionsum in amount of EUR 1 000 (UAH 28 948, 17)were transferred to the special deposit accountof the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine on04/10/2016.On 13/04/2017 – this sum was transferred to thebank account of applicant’s heirs.


950. Nataliya PetrivnaGRYSHCHUK



951. Petro PanasovychDONCHENKO



952. Lyubov GrygorivnaVOLOSHYN



953. Dmytro Fedorovych BIDOCHA 74714/14 According to the letter of the StateTreasury Service of Ukraine of21/03/2019, the decision of the domesticcourt was enforced in full.


954. Oleksandra YosypivnaVIVCHARYK



955. Olena Antonivna SEVERYN 78603/14 According to the letter of the StateTreasury Service of Ukraine of22/03/2019, the decision of the domesticcourt was enforced in full.


956. Aleksandr Petrovich DANKO 71117/13 Enforced. On 06/05/2019 – the applicant’sheir, Mr Danko S., was paid theoutstanding debts according to the decisionof the domestic court in amount ofUAH 16160, 40.


957. Mykola LavrentiyovychKALATAN

51301/13 Enforced. On 15/05/2019 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the decision of the domestic court inamount of UAH 2300, 52.


958. Galyna IvanivnaDEMYANCHUK

1323/14 According to the letter of the StateTreasury Service of Ukraine of



22/03/2019, the decision of the domesticcourt was enforced in full.

Ivan Danilovich TERLETSKIY v. Ukraine(application no 22611/12 and 359 others)Date of Definitive Judgment: 19/11/2015

Payment Deadline:19/02/2016UPDATED

ZHOVNER GROUP959. Andriy Myronovych

KOTSELOVSKYY70169/13 Enforced. On 04/03/2019 – the applicant

was paid the outstanding debts accordingto the decision of the domestic court inamount of UAH 2 928, 60.


960. Bogdan MykhaylovychKURILETS

70977/13 Enforced. On 26/02/2019 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the decision of the domestic court.


OTHER CASESZHOVNER GROUP

961. CASE OF GLOBA v.UKRAINE (final on 19/11/2012)



962. CASE OF GOGIN v.UKRAINE (final on 11/03/2009)



963. CASE OF GVOZDETSKIY v.UKRAINE (final on 01/03/2010)


The applicant did not submit a claim for justsatisfaction.

964. CASE OF IVAN PANCHENKOv. UKRAINE (final on 10/03/2010)

10911/05____________________

On 15/07/2010 – EUR 1223 (UAH 12275, 90) –were transferred to the applicant bank account.On 07/09/2011 – the applicant was also paid a


simple interest in amount of UAH 55, 65.965. CASE OF IVASHCHENKO v.

UKRAINE (final on 14/03/2007)22215/04 Enforced. On 13/06/2007 – the applicant

was paid the outstanding debts accordingto the decision of the domestic court inamount of UAH 1398, 80.


966. CASE OF KISELYOV v.UKRAINE (final on 13/06/2013)

42953/04

____________________


967. CASE OF KOMNATSKYY v.UKRAINE (final on 15/01/2010)

40753/07 Enforced. On 14/10/2010 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the decision of the domestic court inamount of UAH 245240.

On 12/04/2010 – EUR 1020 (UAH 10821) weretransferred to the applicant bank account.

968. CASE OF OSOKIN ANDOSOKINA v. UKRAINE (finalon 10/03/2010)

8437/06

____________________

On 14/07/2010 – EUR 2260 (UAH 22198, 63)were transferred to Mr Osokin bank account.On 07/02/2011 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 98, 26.On 17/07/2010 – EUR 2260 (UAH 22446, 94)were transferred to Ms Osokina bank account.On 07/02/2011 – the applicant was also paid asimple interest in amount of UAH 99, 62.

969. CASE OF PANOV v.UKRAINE (final on 10/05/2010)

21231/05 Enforced. On 26/12/2013 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the decision of the domestic court inamount of UAH 177650.

The applicant did not submit a claim for justsatisfaction.

970. CASE OF VINNIYCHUK v.UKRAINE (final on 20/01/2017)

34000/07

____________________

On 07/04/2017 – EUR 4500 (UAH 130073, 44)were transferred to Ms Vinniychuk bankaccount.On 18/04/2017 – EUR 1500 were transferred tothe bank account of applicant’s representative,Mr Markov.

971. CASE OF YANGOLENKO v.UKRAINE (final on 10/05/2010)

14077/05 Enforced. On 16/11/2011 – the applicantwas paid the outstanding debts accordingto the decision of the domestic court inamount of UAH 4574, 33



Committee of Ministers - rm .coe. int/C

Documents

Transcript of Committee of Ministers - rm .coe. int/C