B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultural: uma análise crítica de...

22
(VWXGRV GH 5HOLJLmR Y Q MXOGH] ,661 ,PSUHVVR ; ² (OHWU{QLFR B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultural: uma análise crítica de Oliveira, Brito, Abe, Reis e Leite (2012) Alexandre Dittrich* Resumo Em artigo recentemente publicado, Oliveira, Brito, Abe, Reis e Leite (2012) apresentam críticas à proposta de planejamento cultural do psicólogo estadunidense B. F. Skinner (1904-1990). Skinner seria um representante do “pseudomessianismo psicológico- FLHQWLÀFLVWDµ GDGDV VXDV UHFRPHQGDo}HV UHODWLYDV DR SODQHMDPHQWR SUHYLVmR H FRQWUROH GH SUiWLFDV FXOWXUDLV 7DLV UHFRPHQGDo}HV HVWDULDP HP GHVDFRUGR FRP D ´VRFLHGDGH GD LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGHµ H D ´VXEMHWLYLGDGH DEHUWDµ &RQWXGR QR GHVHQYROYLPHQWR GH VXD DUJX- PHQWDomR RV DXWRUHV DSUHVHQWDP FRQFHLWRV H SUHVVXSRVWRV QHP VHPSUH FODURV DOpP GH FRQFOXV}HV HTXLYRFDGDV D UHVSHLWR GD REUD GH 6NLQQHU H GD DQiOLVH GR FRPSRUWDPHQWR 2 SUHVHQWH DUWLJR EXVFD UHDOL]DU XP H[DPH FUtWLFR GHVVD DUJXPHQWDomR &RQFOXLVH TXH DV FUtWLFDV GH 2OLYHLUD HW DO VmR LQIXQGDGDV Palavras-chave: B. F. Skinner; planejamento cultural; análise do comportamento; JOREDOL]DomR B. F. Skinner on prediction and control in cultural design: a critical analysis of Oliveira, Brito, Abe, Reis e Leite (2012) Abstract In a recently published paper, Oliveira, Brito, Abe, Reis and Leite (2012) present a critical DVVHVVPHQW RI WKH SURSRVDO RI FXOWXUDO GHVLJQ PDGH E\ WKH $PHULFDQ SV\FKRORJLVW % ) 6NLQQHU 6NLQQHU LV GHSLFWHG DV D UHSUHVHQWDWLYH RI ´SV\FKRORJLFDOFLHQWLÀFLVW SVHXGRPHVVLDQLVPµ JLYHQ KLV UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV UHJDUGLQJ WKH GHVLJQ SUHGLFWLRQ DQG FRQWURO RI FXOWXUDO SUDFWLFHV 6XFK UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV DUH VDLG WR EH LQ GLVDJUHHPHQW ZLWK WKH ´XQSUHGLFWDELOLW\ VRFLHW\µ DQG WKH ´RSHQ VXEMHFWLYLW\µ +RZHYHU WKH FRQFHSWV DQG WHQHWV SUHVHQWHG E\ WKH DXWKRUV LQ WKH FRXUVH RI WKHLU DUJXPHQWDWLRQ DUH QRW DOZD\V FOHDU and they arrive at mistaken conclusions about Skinner’s oeuvre and behavior analysis. 7KH SUHVHQW SDSHU DLPV WR SHUIRUP D FULWLFDO H[DPLQDWLRQ RI WKLV DUJXPHQWDWLRQ :H conclude that the criticisms posed by Oliveira et al. (2012) are baseless. Keywords: B. F. Skinner; cultural design; behavior analysis; globalization. * é JUDGXDGR HP 3VLFRORJLD SHOD 8QLYHUVLGDGH 5HJLRQDO GH %OXPHQDX H 'RXWRU HP )LORVRÀD SHOD 8QLYHUVLGDGH )HGHUDO GH 6mR &DUORV E-PDLO DOHGLWWULFK#XISUEU

Transcript of B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultural: uma análise crítica de...

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle

no planejamento cultural: uma análise crítica de

Oliveira, Brito, Abe, Reis e Leite (2012)

Alexandre Dittrich*

Resumo

Em artigo recentemente publicado, Oliveira, Brito, Abe, Reis e Leite (2012) apresentam

críticas à proposta de planejamento cultural do psicólogo estadunidense B. F. Skinner

(1904-1990). Skinner seria um representante do “pseudomessianismo psicológico-

�FLHQWLÀFLVWDµ��GDGDV�VXDV�UHFRPHQGDo}HV�UHODWLYDV�DR�SODQHMDPHQWR��SUHYLVmR�H�FRQWUROH�GH�SUiWLFDV�FXOWXUDLV��7DLV�UHFRPHQGDo}HV�HVWDULDP�HP�GHVDFRUGR�FRP�D�´VRFLHGDGH�GD�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGHµ�H�D�´VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWDµ��&RQWXGR��QR�GHVHQYROYLPHQWR�GH�VXD�DUJX-

PHQWDomR��RV�DXWRUHV�DSUHVHQWDP�FRQFHLWRV�H�SUHVVXSRVWRV�QHP�VHPSUH�FODURV��DOpP�GH�FRQFOXV}HV�HTXLYRFDGDV�D�UHVSHLWR�GD�REUD�GH�6NLQQHU�H�GD�DQiOLVH�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR��2�SUHVHQWH�DUWLJR�EXVFD�UHDOL]DU�XP�H[DPH�FUtWLFR�GHVVD�DUJXPHQWDomR��&RQFOXL�VH�TXH�DV�FUtWLFDV�GH�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���������VmR�LQIXQGDGDV�Palavras-chave: B. F. Skinner; planejamento cultural; análise do comportamento;

JOREDOL]DomR�

B. F. Skinner on prediction and control in cultural design:

a critical analysis of Oliveira, Brito, Abe, Reis e Leite (2012)

Abstract

In a recently published paper, Oliveira, Brito, Abe, Reis and Leite (2012) present a critical

DVVHVVPHQW�RI �WKH�SURSRVDO�RI �FXOWXUDO�GHVLJQ�PDGH�E\�WKH�$PHULFDQ�SV\FKRORJLVW�%��)��6NLQQHU��������������6NLQQHU�LV�GHSLFWHG�DV�D�UHSUHVHQWDWLYH�RI �´SV\FKRORJLFDO�FLHQWLÀFLVW�SVHXGRPHVVLDQLVPµ��JLYHQ�KLV�UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV�UHJDUGLQJ�WKH�GHVLJQ��SUHGLFWLRQ�DQG�FRQWURO�RI �FXOWXUDO�SUDFWLFHV��6XFK�UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV�DUH�VDLG�WR�EH�LQ�GLVDJUHHPHQW�ZLWK�WKH�´XQSUHGLFWDELOLW\�VRFLHW\µ�DQG�WKH�´RSHQ�VXEMHFWLYLW\µ��+RZHYHU��WKH�FRQFHSWV�DQG�WHQHWV�SUHVHQWHG�E\�WKH�DXWKRUV�LQ�WKH�FRXUVH�RI �WKHLU�DUJXPHQWDWLRQ�DUH�QRW�DOZD\V�FOHDU��and they arrive at mistaken conclusions about Skinner’s oeuvre and behavior analysis.

7KH�SUHVHQW�SDSHU�DLPV�WR�SHUIRUP�D�FULWLFDO�H[DPLQDWLRQ�RI �WKLV�DUJXPHQWDWLRQ��:H�conclude that the criticisms posed by Oliveira et al. (2012) are baseless.

Keywords: B. F. Skinner; cultural design; behavior analysis; globalization.

* é�JUDGXDGR�HP�3VLFRORJLD�SHOD�8QLYHUVLGDGH�5HJLRQDO�GH�%OXPHQDX�H�'RXWRU�HP�)LORVRÀD�SHOD�8QLYHUVLGDGH�)HGHUDO�GH�6mR�&DUORV� E-PDLO��DOHGLWWULFK#XISU�EU��

B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultura 73

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

%��)��6NLQQHU�VREUH�SUHYLVLyQ�\�FRQWURO�HQ�OD�SODQLÀFDFLyQ�cultural: un análisis crítico de Oliveira, Brito, Abe, Reis y

Leite (2012)

Resumen

En un artículo recientemente publicado, Oliveira, Brito, Abe, Reis y Leite (2012) pre-

VHQWDQ�FUtWLFDV�D�OD�SURSXHVWD�GH�SODQLÀFDFLyQ�FXOWXUDO�GHO�SVLFyORJR�HVWDGXQLGHQVH�%��)��Skinner (1904-1990). Skinner sería un representante del “pseudomessianismo psicológico-

�FLHQWLÀFLVWDµ��GDGDV�VXV�UHFRPHQGDFLRQHV�UHODWLYDV�D�OD�SODQLÀFDFLyQ��SUHYLVLyQ�\�FRQWURO�de prácticas culturales. Dichas recomendaciones estarían en desacuerdo con la “sociedad

GH�OD�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGµ�\�OD�´VXEMHWLYLGDG�DELHUWDµ��6LQ�HPEDUJR��HQ�HO�GHVDUUROOR�GH�PiV�argumentación los autores presentan conceptos y presupuestos ni siempre claros, allá de

FRQFOXVLRQHV�HTXLYRFDGDV�VREUH�OD�REUD�GH�6NLQQHU�\�VREUH�HO�DQiOLVLV�GH�FRQGXFWD��(O�SUHVHQWH�DUWtFXOR�EXVFD�UHDOL]DU�XQ�H[DPHQ�FUtWLFR�GH�HVWD�DUJXPHQWDFLyQ��&RQFOXLPRV�TXH�ODV�FUtWLFDV�GH�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���������VRQ�LQIXQGDGDV�Palabras clave:�%��)��6NLQQHU��SODQLÀFDFLyQ�FXOWXUDO��DQiOLVLV�GH�FRQGXFWD��JOREDOL]DFLyQ��

Em artigo recentemente publicado, Oliveira, Brito, Abe, Reis e Leite

�������ID]HP�FUtWLFDV�j�SURSRVWD�GH�SODQHMDPHQWR�FXOWXUDO�GR�SVLFyORJR�estadunidense B. F. Skinner (1904-1990). No desenvolvimento de sua ar-

JXPHQWDomR��RV�DXWRUHV�DSUHVHQWDP�FRQFHLWRV�H�SUHVVXSRVWRV�QHP�VHPSUH�FODURV��DOpP�GH�FRQFOXV}HV�HTXLYRFDGDV�VREUH�D�REUD�GH�6NLQQHU�H�VREUH�D�DQiOLVH�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR��8P�H[DPH�DWHQWR�GHVVD�DUJXPHQWDomR�RIHUHFH�YiULRV�PRWLYRV�SDUD�TXHVWLRQDU�DV�FRQFOXV}HV�GHULYDGDV�SHORV�DXWRUHV�DFHUFD�GR�WHPD�TXH�DERUGDP��2�REMHWLYR�GR�SUHVHQWH�DUWLJR�p�UHDOL]DU�WDO�H[DPH�

Os autores1�VH�SURS}HP�D�IXQGDPHQWDU�D�WHVH�GH�TXH�´R�SODQHMDPHQWR�

FXOWXUDO�GH�6NLQQHU�QmR�VH�DSOLFD�j�VRFLHGDGH�GD�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH��,VWR�SRU-TXH�HVWD�VRFLHGDGH�p�FDUDFWHUL]DGD�SRU�SURFHVVRV�PDFURVVRFLDLV��HFRQRPLD��FXOWXUD��H�PLFURVVRFLDLV��ELRJUDÀD�LQGLYLGXDO��HP�GHVFRQWUROHµ��S������²�LVWR�p��QmR�SDVVtYHLV�GH�SUHYLVmR�H�FRQWUROH��*UDQGH�SDUWH�GR�DUWLJR�p�GHGLFDGD�D�DQDOLVDU�DV�´YDULiYHLV�>«@�TXH�SURGX]LUDP�D�VRFLHGDGH�GD�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH�H�D�VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWDµ��FRPR�YHUHPRV�HP�EUHYH�

$SyV�D�LQWURGXomR�GR�DUWLJR��TXH�H[S}H�WDLV�REMHWLYRV��VXUJH�D�SULPHLUD�VHomR��LQWLWXODGD�´2�SODQHMDPHQWR�FXOWXUDO�GH�%��)��6NLQQHUµ��1HOD��DÀUPD�VH�FRUUHWDPHQWH�TXH��SDUD�6NLQQHU��R�SODQHMDPHQWR�FXOWXUDO�FRQVLVWH�HP�´XPD�DomR�GHOLEHUDGD�SDUD�D�PRGLÀFDomR�GH�SUiWLFDV�FXOWXUDLVµ��S�������$�SDODYUD�´GHOLEHUDGDµ�H[SOLFLWD�R�TXH� Mi�p�VXJHULGR�SHOD�SDODYUD�´SODQHMDPHQWRµ��

1�� 'RUDYDQWH��QmR�FLWDUHPRV�PDLV�R�VREUHQRPH�GRV�DXWRUHV�TXDQGR�D�PHQomR�D�HOHV�IRU�evidente, registrando apenas o número das páginas do artigo eventualmente citadas.

74 Alexandre Dittrich

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

WUDWD�VH�GH�DomR�YLVDQGR�GHWHUPLQDGRV�ÀQV�RX�REMHWLYRV�2�$�´PRGLÀFDomR�GH�SUiWLFDV�FXOWXUDLVµ�VH�Gi�SHOD�DOWHUDomR�GH�TXDOTXHU�YDULiYHO�DPELHQWDO�TXH�SURGX]D�RX�WUDQVIRUPH�SUiWLFDV�FXOWXUDLV�GH�LQWHUHVVH��FRQVLGHUDGDV�FRPR�IHQ{PHQRV�FRPSRUWDPHQWDLV��3DUD�6NLQQHU��R�SODQHMDPHQWR�FXOWXUDO�GHYH�WHU�FRPR�REMHWLYR�SULPRUGLDO�D�VREUHYLYrQFLD�GDV�FXOWXUDV��FRPR�WDPEpP�QRWDP�RV�DXWRUHV��S������3

2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���S������PHQFLRQDP�R�IDWR�GH�TXH�6NLQQHU�UHFRQKHFLD�DV�GLIHUHQoDV�HQWUH�VLWXDo}HV�H[SHULPHQWDLV�H�DSOLFDGDV�HP�WHUPRV�GH�FRPSOH[L-GDGH��EHP�FRPR�DV�´GLÀFXOGDGHV�SROtWLFDV��HFRQ{PLFDV�H�FXOWXUDLV�GH�LPSOH-PHQWDomR�GH�XP�SODQHMDPHQWR�FXOWXUDOµ��HPERUD�LVVR�QmR�R�WHQKD�LPSHGLGR�de desenvolver sua proposta de planejamento cultural. A insistência de Skin-

QHU�QD�SURSRVWD�GHPRQVWUDULD�XP�´RWLPLVPR�WHFQRFLHQWtÀFRµ�H��HP�~OWLPD�DQiOLVH��XP�´SVHXGRPHVVLDQLVPR�SVLFROyJLFR�FLHQWLÀFLVWDµ��VHQGR�6NLQQHU�XP�´KHUGHLUR�GH�XP�LGHDO�GH�VDOYDomR�RULJLQDOPHQWH�UHOLJLRVR�H�SRVWHULRUPHQWH�PXQGDQL]DGR�QR�LOXPLQLVPRµ��S�������

$�VHomR�VHJXLQWH�GR�DUWLJR��LQWLWXODGD�´3VLFRORJLD�H�VRFLHGDGH�GD�LPSUH-YLVLELOLGDGHµ��EXVFD�TXHVWLRQDU�D�WHVH��VXVWHQWDGD�SHOR�´SVHXGRPHVVLDQLVPR�SVLFROyJLFR�FLHQWLÀFLVWDµ��GH�TXH�´R�FRQKHFLPHQWR�SVLFROyJLFR�SRGH�HOHYDU�a previsibilidade e o controle da vida social na sociedade da imprevisibilida-

GHµ��1R�SDUiJUDIR�LQLFLDO�GD�VHomR��RV�DXWRUHV�DSRQWDP�SDUD�R�IDWR�GH�TXH�R�´SHQVDPHQWR�VRFLDOµ�GH�6NLQQHU�´VH�GHVHQYROYHX�DQWHV�GR�DWXDO�SURFHVVR�GH�JOREDOL]DomRµ�4�DÀUPDQGR�HP�VHJXLGD�TXH�´D�LQWHUSUHWDomR�VRFLROyJLFD�H�HFRQ{PLFD�GR�FRQWH[WR�GH�JOREDOL]DomR�WHP�UHYHODGR�XPD�FRPSOH[LÀFDomR�VHP�SUHFHGHQWHV�GD�YLGD�VRFLDO��WRUQDQGR�REVROHWD�TXDOTXHU�WHRULD�TXH�QmR�FRQVLGHUD�HVWH�QRYR�FRQWH[WRµ��S����������6H�LVVR�p�XPD�LQVLQXDomR�GH�TXH�R�´SHQVDPHQWR�VRFLDOµ�GH�6NLQQHU�VH�WRUQRX�REVROHWR�HP�YLUWXGH�GH�WHU�VLGR�SURGX]LGR�DQWHV�GR�´DWXDO�SURFHVVR�GH�JOREDOL]DomRµ��Ki�YiULRV�PRWLYRV�para discordar. Esse argumento tornaria automaticamente obsoletos todos

RV�WUDEDOKRV�GH�´SHQVDGRUHV�VRFLDLVµ�SXEOLFDGRV�DQWHV�GD�*XHUUD�)ULD�²�SRU�H[HPSOR��RV�GH�:HEHU��0DUFXVH�H�)UHXG��FLWDGRV�QR�DUWLJR���HQWUH�RXWURV��

��� 2�PRGHOR�VHOHFLRQLVWD�GH�6NLQQHU��������GLVSHQVD��H�FULWLFD��TXDOTXHU�H[SOLFDomR�WHOHROy-

JLFD�SDUD�R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�KXPDQR��8VDPRV�DTXL�SDODYUDV�FRPR�´GHOLEHUDGDµ��´ÀQVµ�H�´REMHWLYRVµ�SRU�FRQYHQLrQFLD��VHP�D�SUHRFXSDomR�GH�DSURIXQGDU�R�WHPD�QR�PRPHQWR�

�� �&RPR�RXWUDV�GLVFXVV}HV�QR�EHKDYLRULVPR�UDGLFDO��WDPEpP�HVVD�DYDQoRX�SDUD�DOpP�GH�6NLQQHU��YHU��SRU�H[HPSOR��',775,&+��������0(/2��'(�526(���������$�GHVSHLWR�GH�VXD�LPSRUWkQFLD��QmR�DSURIXQGDUHPRV�R�DVVXQWR�DTXL��SRLV�QmR�WHP�LPSRUWkQFLD�FHQWUDO�para o argumento desenvolvido por Oliveira et al. (2012).

�� �2V�DXWRUHV�DSRQWDP�R�ÀP�GD�*XHUUD�)ULD�FRPR�PDUFR�LQLFLDO�GR�´DWXDO�SURFHVVR�GH�JOREDOL]DomRµ�

B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultura 75

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

&DEH�DTXL�XPD�SDODYUD�VREUH�D�RSomR�²�DVVXPLGD�SHORV�DXWRUHV�²�GH�restringir sua crítica à obra de Skinner, mesmo reconhecendo a existência de

´OLWHUDWXUD�PDLV�UHFHQWHµ�QD�DQiOLVH�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�UHODWLYD�D�TXHVW}HV�FXOWXUDLV��(VVH�IDWR��LVRODGDPHQWH��QmR�DOWHUD�D�LPSRUWkQFLD�GD�FUtWLFD��PDV�FULD�yEYLDV�OLPLWDo}HV��7RXULQKR���������SRU�H[HPSOR��DQDOLVD�DV�FRQVHTXrQFLDV�SVLFROyJLFDV�GD�´FRPSOH[LÀFDomR�VHP�SUHFHGHQWHV�GD�YLGD�VRFLDOµ�DSRLDQGR-

�VH�HP�JUDQGH�SDUWH�QRV�WUDEDOKRV�GH�6NLQQHU�²�VHP�FRQVLGHUi�ORV�REVROHWRV��PDV�DGDSWDQGR�RV�D�XPD�LQWHUSUHWDomR�GH�IHQ{PHQRV�FRQWHPSRUkQHRV��FRPR�ID]HP�FRUULTXHLUDPHQWH�LQ~PHURV�HVWXGLRVRV�GH�:HEHU��0DUFXVH��)UHXG��HWF��

1D�VHTXrQFLD��R�DUWLJR�DSUHVHQWD�TXDWUR�WySLFRV�YLVDQGR�GHPRQVWUDU�TXH�´D�RUGHP�VRFLDO�JOREDOL]DGD�SURGX]LX�D�VRFLHGDGH�GD�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH��FDUDFWHUL]DQGR�XPD�VLWXDomR�HP�TXH�DV� LQWHUDo}HV�VRFLDLV�PDFURVVRFLDLV�H�PLFURVVRFLDLV�VH�GHVHQYROYHP�HP�XP�KRUL]RQWH�GH� LQGHWHUPLQDomRµ5

(p.

�����(VVHV�WySLFRV��TXH�FRPS}HP�D�PDLRU�SDUWH�GR�DUWLJR��YHUVDP�VREUH�HFRQRPLD��´$�FULVH�ÀQDQFHLUD�LQWHUQDFLRQDO�GH������H�R�ethos da pleonaxiaµ���FXOWXUD��´&XOWXUD�HP�GHVFRQWUROHµ��H�ELRJUDÀD�LQGLYLGXDO��´$�pWLFD�GR�SUD]HU�H�D�HPHUJrQFLD�GD�VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWDµ�H�´'HVHQUDL]DPHQWR�WUDGLWLYR��GHV-FRQIHVVLRQDOL]DomR�H�HPHUJrQFLD�GD�VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWDµ���3URFHGHUHPRV�D�seguir a uma análise individual desses tópicos.

6RE�R�WtWXOR�´$�FULVH�ÀQDQFHLUD�LQWHUQDFLRQDO�GH������H�R�ethos da ple-onaxiaµ��RV�DXWRUHV�DSRQWDP�D�UHIHULGD�FULVH�FRPR�´XPD�GHPRQVWUDomR�GR�FDUiWHU�GH�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH�GD�VRFLHGDGH�JOREDOL]DGDµ��S�������,URQLFDPHQWH��RV�DXWRUHV�SDVVDP�WRGR�R�WySLFR�DSRQWDQGR�YDULiYHLV�TXH�VXSRVWDPHQWH�H[SOLFDP��RX�SHOR�PHQRV�DMXGDP�D�H[SOLFDU��SRU�TXH�D�FULVH�RFRUUHX��$OpP�GLVVR��PHQFLRQDP�R�IDWR�GH�TXH�´DFDGrPLFRV�HXURSHXVµ��FLHQWHV�GH�DOJXPDV�GHVVDV�YDULiYHLV��GHPRQVWUDUDP�SUHRFXSDomR�FRP�D�SRVVLELOLGDGH�GH�´FULVHV�JOREDLVµ�DQWHV�GD�HFORVmR�GD�FULVH�GH�������S�������6XSRQKDPRV�DJRUD�TXH��GLDQWH�GD�´LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH�GD�VRFLHGDGH�JOREDOL]DGDµ��WDLV�DFDGrPLFRV�GHL-[DVVHP�GH�DQDOLVDU�DV�FRPSOH[DV�YDULiYHLV�TXH�LQWHJUDP�DV�UHODo}HV�HFRQ{-

micas globais e de propor medidas regulatórias. Seria essa a atitude correta?

6H�VLP��SURYDYHOPHQWH�WDLV�DFDGrPLFRV�WHULDP�TXH�GHVLVWLU�GH�VXDV�FDUUHLUDV�²�PDV�SURYDYHOPHQWH�QmR�R�IDUmR��SRUTXH�HQWHQGHP�TXH�D�WDUHID�GH�TXDOTXHU�FLrQFLD�p��FRPR�VHPSUH�IRL��PHVPR�DQWHV�GD�*XHUUD�)ULD���DQDOLVDU�LQWHUDo}HV�complexas entre variáveis. Embora o assunto seja discutível em termos de

ÀORVRÀD�GD�FLrQFLD��ERD�SDUWH�GRV�FLHQWLVWDV�FRQFRUGDUi�TXDQWR�DR�IDWR�GH�TXH�D�WDUHID�SULQFLSDO�GD�FLrQFLD��HP�~OWLPD�DQiOLVH��p�DXPHQWDU�QRVVR�SRGHU�GH�SUHYLVmR�H�FRQWUROH�GH�IHQ{PHQRV�ItVLFRV�H�VRFLDLV��$�SDODYUD�´DXPHQWDUµ�5� $V�UHODo}HV�HQWUH�SUHYLVLELOLGDGH�H�GHWHUPLQDomR�VmR�FRPSOH[DV��H�SRGHULDP�WHU�VLGR�PHOKRU�

H[SORUDGDV�QR�DUWLJR��3ULYLOHJLDUHPRV�HP�QRVVD�DQiOLVH�R�SUREOHPD�GD�SUHYLVLELOLGDGH�TXH��MXQWR�j�TXHVWmR�GR�FRQWUROH��FRQVWLWXL�R�IRFR�HYLGHQWH�GR�WUDEDOKR�

�� Alexandre Dittrich

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

DTXL�p�LPSRUWDQWH��1HQKXP�FLHQWLVWD�UD]RiYHO�HVSHUD�SRVVXLU��DJRUD�RX�HP�TXDOTXHU�PRPHQWR�IXWXUR��SRGHU�DEVROXWR�GH�SUHYLVmR�H�FRQWUROH�GH�TXDOTXHU�IHQ{PHQR��ItVLFR�RX�VRFLDO�²�WDPSRXFR�HVSHUDYD�6NLQQHU��$�FRPSOH[LGDGH�VRFLDO�p�XP�IDWR�²�VHPSUH�IRL��PHVPR�DQWHV�GR�SURFHVVR�FRQWHPSRUkQHR�GH�JOREDOL]DomR��2�TXH�GHYHULDP�ID]HU�RV�behavioral scientists diante disso? Aban-

GRQDU�VHXV�REMHWRV�GH�HVWXGR"�'HL[DU�GH�SURSRU�LQWHUYHQo}HV�SODQHMDGDV�FRP�base em suas análises?

&RPSDUHPRV�D�FULVH�GH������FRP�D�DVVLP�FKDPDGD�*UDQGH�'HSUHVVmR��LQLFLDGD�HP������²�EHP�DQWHV�GR�´DWXDO�SURFHVVR�GH�JOREDOL]DomRµ�DR�TXDO�VH�UHIHUHP�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO����������$�FRPSOH[LGDGH�GRV�SURFHVVRV�TXH�OHYDUDP�j�*UDQGH�'HSUHVVmR�H�j�GLÀFXOGDGH�GH�SUHYr�ORV�p�HYLGHQFLDGD�SHOR�IDWR�GH�TXH�HVWXGLRVRV�GR�DVVXQWR�GHEDWHP�VXDV�FDXVDV�DWp�KRMH��H��J���&$/':(//��2·'5,6&2//���������7DO�FRPSOH[LGDGH�p�GLVFXWLGD�WDPEpP�SRU�-DPHV���������TXH�DSRQWD�TXH��HPERUD�´QHQKXP�FRODSVR�VHMD��p�FODUR��SUHFLVDPHQWH�FRPR�RXWUR�TXDOTXHU�>«@��Mi�KRXYH�FRPXQLGDGHV�LQWHUQDFLRQDLV�DOWDPHQWH�GHVHQ-

YROYLGDV�H�DOWDPHQWH�LQWHJUDGDV�TXH�VH�GLVVROYHUDP�VRE�D�SUHVVmR�GH�HYHQWRV�LQHVSHUDGRVµ��S������$VVLP��FRQVLGHUDQGR�TXH�D�FULVH�GH������p�DSUHVHQWDGD�SRU�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���������FRPR�XPD�´GHPRQVWUDomR�GR�FDUiWHU�GH�LPSUHYL-VLELOLGDGH�GD�VRFLHGDGH�JOREDOL]DGDµ��DSDUHQWHPHQWH�WDO�IHQ{PHQR�QmR�p�WmR�UHFHQWH��e�SRVVtYHO�DUJXPHQWDU�TXH�DV�YDULiYHLV�HQYROYLGDV�QD�FULVH�GH������IRUDP�PDLV�FRPSOH[DV�GR�TXH�DTXHODV�YHULÀFDGDV�QD�FULVH�GH������²�R�TXH�QmR�VHULD�VXUSUHHQGHQWH�²��PDV�VXJHULU�TXH�FRPSOH[LGDGH�H�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH��QD�HFRQRPLD�H�HP�RXWURV�FDPSRV��VmR�DWULEXWRV�H[FOXVLYRV�GR�SHUtRGR�SyV-�JOREDOL]DomR�p�QR�PtQLPR�TXHVWLRQiYHO��

$LQGD�GHQWUR�GHVVH�WySLFR��R�DUWLJR�DSUHVHQWD�XPD�H[SODQDomR�VREUH�R�chamado “ethos da pleonexiaµ��H[SUHVVmR�SURSRVWD�SHOR�VRFLyORJR�$QGHUVRQ�3LUHV�SDUD�GHVLJQDU�XPD�´YDULiYHO�SVLFROyJLFDµ�DSRQWDGD�FRPR�´IRUoD�PRWUL]�SDUD�R�LPSXOVR�H[SDQVLRQLVWD�GR�FDSLWDOLVPR�JOREDOµ��H��SRUWDQWR��WDPEpP�SHOD�FULVH�ÀQDQFHLUD�GH��������

O termo grego pleonaxia�p�FRPSRVWR�SRU�pleon (mais) e ekho (ter), sugerindo uma

EXVFD�GHVDWLQDGD�H�FRPSXOVLYD�SHOD�ULTXH]D��>«@�2�ethos da pleonexia PDQLIHVWD�R�SHUÀO�QDUFtVLFR�LGHQWLÀFDGR�QD�FXOWXUD�GR�QDUFLVLVPR�>«@�FDUDFWHUL]DGD�SHOD�SURGXomR�GH�XPD�VXEMHWLYLGDGH�TXH�VH�DOLHQD�GD�QHFHVVLGDGH�GR�RXWUR��YLYHQGR�apenas para a necessidade do eu (p. 42).

$QWHV�TXH�XP�DQDOLVWD�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�DSRQWH�R�yEYLR�FDUiWHU�PHQ-

WDOLVWD�H�UHGXQGDQWH�GHVVH�WLSR�GH�´H[SOLFDomRµ��XP�LQGLYtGXR�p�JDQDQFLRVR�SRUTXH�WHP�JDQkQFLD���RV�DXWRUHV�VH�DSUHVVDP�HP�DQWHFLSDU�WDO�FUtWLFD��

B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultura 77

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

8PD�REMHomR�EHKDYLRULVWD�j� LQWHUSUHWDomR�GH�3LUHV� �����D��p�TXH�XP�IDWR�psicológico (ethos da pleonaxia��QmR�VXUJH�QR�YiFXR��PDV�RUJDQL]D�VH�D�SDUWLU�GH�XPD�LQWHUDomR�FRP�R�PHLR�DPELHQWH��4XDQWR�D�HVWD�REMHomR��3LUHV������D��VXUSUHHQGH�VHX�SRVVtYHO�FUtWLFR�DR�H[WUDLU�GD�pWLFD�SURWHVWDQWH��DQDOLVDGD�SRU�0D[�:HEHU���������D�IRQWH�KLVWyULFD�GH�OHJLWLPDomR�PRUDO�GR�ethos da pleonaxia (p. 43).

$�DQiOLVH�GH�:HEHU��UHFRQKHFLGDPHQWH��DSRQWRX�YDULiYHLV�LPSRUWDQWHV�SDUD�FRPSUHHQGHU�D�FRQÀJXUDomR�GR�FDSLWDOLVPR�FRQWHPSRUkQHR�²�FRQWX-

GR��D�´OHJLWLPDomR�PRUDO�GR�ethos da pleonaxiaµ�SURPRYLGD�SHOR�FDOYLQLVPR�REYLDPHQWH�QmR�H[SOLFD�D�H[LVWrQFLD�GR�SUySULR�ethos �HQTXDQWR�XPD�´IRUoD�PRWUL]µ�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR���$VVLP��D�´REMHomR�EHKDYLRULVWDµ�FRQWLQXD�UHOH-YDQWH��2�~QLFR�tQGLFH�GD�JDQkQFLD��DPELomR�RX�pleonaxia�GH�XPD�SHVVRD�p�R�IDWR�GH�TXH�HOD�VH�FRPSRUWD��HP�PDLRU�RX�PHQRU�JUDX��GH�IRUPD�JDQDQFLRVD��ambiciosa ou pleonexa.

��7UDQVIRUPDU�FRQFHLWRV�GHULYDGRV�GD�REVHUYDomR�GH�SDGU}HV�FRPSRUWDPHQWDLV�HP�´H[SOLFDo}HVµ�SDUD�HVVHV�SUySULRV�SDGU}HV�p�R�SUREOHPD�PDLV�EiVLFR�DSRQWDGR�SRU�6NLQQHU��H��J���������������QDV�DUJX-

PHQWDo}HV�GH�FXQKR�PHQWDOLVWD��WUDWD�VH�GH�UDFLRFtQLR�FLUFXODU��VHP�TXDOTXHU�poder explicativo.

Pode-se perguntar, legitimamente, se o “ethos da pleonexiaµ�QmR�H[LVWLD�FRPR�XPD�´GLVSRVLomR�SVLFROyJLFDµ�RX�´IRUoD�PRWUL]µ�DQWHV�GR�DGYHQWR�GR�FDSLWDOLVPR�FRQWHPSRUkQHR��2V�DXWRUHV�VXJHUHP�TXH�VLP��&RQWXGR��

>«@�D�pWLFD�SURWHVWDQWH�FDOYLQLVWD��DR�OHJLWLPDU�PRUDOPHQWH�D�pleonaxia, sepultou

D�YDULiYHO�UHSUHVVRUD�LPSRVWD�SHOD�UHOLJLmR�FULVWm�QHRWHVWDPHQWiULD�D�HVWD�GLVSR-

VLomR�SVLFROyJLFD��$VVLP��R�SUREOHPD�FHQWUDO�GD�FULVH�ÀQDQFHLUD�LQWHUQDFLRQDO�GH������HVWi�QR�VLVWHPD�GH�FUHQoDV�VXEMDFHQWH�D�WRGDV�DV�SUiWLFDV�FXOWXUDLV�HQJHQGUDGDV�QR�FDSLWDOLVPR�JOREDO��HVWH�VLVWHPD�GH�FUHQoDV�Yr�VH�OLYUH�GR�YHWR�UHOLJLRVR�QHRWHVWDPHQWiULR�LPSRVWR�SHOR�LPSHUDWLYR�GR�FRQWHQWDPHQWR�QR�TXDO�D�UDFLRQDOLGDGH�GD�UHQ~QFLD�HUD�XPD�IRUoD�UHSUHVVRUD�DR�ethos da pleonaxia (p. 44).

e�VXUSUHHQGHQWH�TXH�RV�DXWRUHV�VH�FRQWHQWHP�FRP�HVVD�H[SOLFDomR�HP�XP�DUWLJR�TXH�VXSRVWDPHQWH�YLVD�DSRQWDU�D�FRPSOH[LGDGH�GRV�IHQ{PHQRV�VRFLDLV��$SDUHQWHPHQWH��JUDQGH�SDUWH�GD�KLVWyULD�HFRQ{PLFD�GD�KXPDQLGDGH�pode ser compreendida como determinada, essencialmente, por um embate

HQWUH�D�´UHOLJLmR�FULVWm�QHRWHVWDPHQWiULDµ��FRPR�VH�KRXYHVVH�XPD�~QLFD��e o calvinismo, ambos com poder variável de reprimir ou estimular uma

´GLVSRVLomR�SVLFROyJLFDµ�SDUD�D�DPELomR�RX�D�JDQkQFLD���6HULD� LJXDOPHQWH�IiFLO�LQYHQWDU�XPD�GLVSRVLomR�FRQWUiULD�H�FKDPi�OD��GLJDPRV��ethos da ágape,

WDPEpP�HOD�SRGHQGR�VHU�UHSULPLGD�RX�HVWLPXODGD��

�� 2V�WHUPRV�PHUHFHULDP��p�FODUR��GHÀQLo}HV�FRPSRUWDPHQWDLV�PDLV�DFXUDGDV�

�� Alexandre Dittrich

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

6H�R�UHJLVWUR�EtEOLFR�p�FRQÀiYHO�H�-XGDV�GH�IDWR�WUDLX�-HVXV�SRU�WULQWD�PRHGDV�GH�SUDWD�²0DWHXV�������²��DSDUHQWHPHQWH�HOH�HVWDYD�VRE�LQÁXrQFLD�do ethos da pleonexia��H�QHP�PHVPR�RV�HQVLQDPHQWRV�GR�PDLRU�GRV�FULVWmRV�QHRWHVWDPHQWiULRV�FRQVHJXLX�UHSULPLU�WDO�GLVSRVLomR�SVLFROyJLFD��RX��SRU�outro lado, estimular o “ethos�GD�iJDSHµ���(WLFDPHQWH��HOH�DJLX�GH�IRUPD�LGrQWLFD�DRV�EDQTXHLURV�FLWDGRV�SRU�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO����������TXH��FRP�VHX�´GH-VHMR�LQVDFLiYHOµ�HP�´TXHUHU�VHPSUH�PDLVµ��WHULDP�SURYRFDGR�D�FULVH�GH�������S������²�R�TXH�PRVWUD�TXH�R�GLWR�´ethos da pleonexiaµ��DOpP�GH�QmR�VHU�XP�IHQ{PHQR�UHFHQWH��p�QXOR�HQTXDQWR�FDWHJRULD�H[SOLFDWLYD�7 Etimologicamente,

cabe lembrar, a palavra ethos�UHIHUH�VH�DR�TXH�DV�SHVVRDV�ID]HP�²�LVWR�p��DR�seu comportamento.

2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���������DÀUPDP�TXH�R�´ethos da pleonexiaµ�p�XPD�GLVSRVLomR�SVLFROyJLFD�´LQFRQWUROiYHOµ��H�DSUHVHQWDP�´HYLGrQFLDV�HPStULFDVµ�GLVVR�²�SRU�H[HPSOR��R�IDWR�GH�TXH�DQWHV�GD��FULVH�GH������´FULPLQRVRV�>«@�SURFXUDUDP�DV�EUHFKDV�QD�OHJLVODomR�GR�VLVWHPD�ÀQDQFHLUR�FRP�R�REMHWLYR�GH�VH�EHQHÀFLDU�VHPSUH�j�FXVWD�GR�SUHMXt]R�GRV�RXWURVµ��S�����������-XGDV�SDUHFH�RIHUHFHU��QRYDPHQWH��XP�SDUDOHOR�SODXVtYHO���2XWUD�´HYLGrQFLD�HPStULFDµ��D�UHVLVWrQFLD�GH�DOJXQV�SDtVHV�HP�´DVVXPLU�PHWDV�GH�UHGXomR�GD�HPLVVmR�GH�FDUERQR�TXH�FRPSURPHWHVVHP�VHX�SURMHWR�GH�DFHOHUDomR�GR�FUHVFLPHQWR�HFRQ{PLFRµ��S�������$SDUHQWHPHQWH��WRGD�YH]�TXH�DOJXPD�SHVVRD�RX�JUXSR�DJLU�YLVDQGR�LQWHUHVVHV�ÀQDQFHLURV�SDUWLFXODUHV�HP�GHWULPHQWR�GR�EHP�FROHWLYR�WHUHPRV�XPD�´HYLGrQFLD�HPStULFDµ�GR�´ethos da pleonexiaµ��0DV�WHPRV�FRP�LVVR�XP�grave problema: se o tal ethos�p�´LQFRQWUROiYHOµ��DSDUHQWHPHQWH�QmR�SRGHPRV�ID]HU�QDGD�GLDQWH�GD�JDQkQFLD�TXH�GRPLQRX�R�FDSLWDOLVPR�FRQWHPSRUkQHR�

é plausível a proposta de um planejamento cultural para controle das práticas

pleonexas�GR�PHUFDGR�ÀQDQFHLUR�LQWHUQDFLRQDO"�$�WHVH�GH�3LUHV������D��LPS}H�XPD�resposta negativa. A proposta de um senso preventivo, orientado para o controle

GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�GRV�LQGLYtGXRV�DJHQWHV�GR�PHUFDGR�ÀQDQFHLUR��HQFRQWUD�R�obstáculo de uma variável psicológica em descontrole, o ethos da pleonaxia (p. 44).

(P�UHVXPR��FULVHV�ÀQDQFHLUDV�VmR�FDXVDGDV�SHOD�JDQkQFLD��H�QDGD�SR-

GHPRV�ID]HU�HP�UHODomR�D�LVVR��6H�GH�IDWR�R�´FRPSRUWDPHQWR�GRV�LQGLYtGXRV�DJHQWHV�GR�PHUFDGR�ILQDQFHLURµ�HVWLYHVVH�VRE�FRQWUROH�GH�XPD�´YDULiYHO�SVLFROyJLFD�GHVFRQWURODGDµ��D�FLrQFLD�HFRQ{PLFD�HVWDULD�HP�VpULRV�DSXURV��2�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�GRV�DJHQWHV�GR�PHUFDGR�ÀQDQFHLUR��FRPR�R�FRPSRUWDPHQ-

WR�GH�TXDOTXHU�SHVVRD��HP�TXDOTXHU�PRPHQWR�H�HP�TXDOTXHU�FXOWXUD��HVWi

7� $�%tEOLD�RIHUHFH�XPD�DOWHUQDWLYD�LJXDOPHQWH�TXHVWLRQiYHO��RV�(YDQJHOKRV�GH�/XFDV��������H�-RmR��������DWULEXHP�R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�GH�-XGDV�j�SRVVHVVmR�SRU�6DWDQiV�

B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultura 79

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

VRE�FRQWUROH�GH�YDULiYHLV�ÀORJHQpWLFDV��RQWRJHQpWLFDV�H�FXOWXUDLV�FRPSOH[DV��YLD�GH�UHJUD� LGHQWLÀFiYHLV�H�PHQVXUiYHLV��H�IUHTXHQWHPHQWH�PDQLSXOiYHLV��FRPR�WHP�VLGR�GHPRQVWUDGR�SRU�GpFDGDV�GH�SHVTXLVD�QmR�Vy�QD�DQiOLVH�GR�comportamento, mas em outras ciências. O trabalho dedicado desses cien-

tistas, em contextos básicos e aplicados, tem demonstrado consistentemente

a possibilidade de alterar aspectos relevantes do comportamento humano

²�QmR�DSHQDV�HP�QtYHO� LQGLYLGXDO��PDV�WDPEpP�JUXSDO��,VVR�QmR�VLJQLÀFD��REYLDPHQWH��TXH�D�FLrQFLD�WHQKD�DOJXP�SRGHU�PiJLFR�GH�SUHYLVLELOLGDGH�RX�FRQWUROH��0DV�D�LQDomR�VXJHULGD�SRU�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���������FHUWDPHQWH�QmR�p�D�PHOKRU�DOWHUQDWLYD��$�DGPLQLVWUDomR�H�UHJXODPHQWDomR�GD�HFRQRPLD�H�GR�PHU-FDGR�ÀQDQFHLUR�VmR�WDUHIDV�FRPSOH[DV��H�QLQJXpP�HVWi�GH�SRVVH�GH�UHVSRVWDV�GHÀQLWLYDV�H�LQIDOtYHLV�GH�FRPR�GHYHP�VHU�HIHWXDGDV��'D�PHVPD�IRUPD��FULDU�XP�ÀOKR��HQVLQDU�XPD�FODVVH�GH�DOXQRV�RX�HGXFDU�XPD�FRPXQLGDGH�WDPEpP�VmR�WDUHIDV�FRPSOH[DV��H�QmR�GHL[DPRV�GH�H[HFXWi�ODV�SRU�FDXVD�GLVVR��7DLV�WDUHIDV�VmR�HVVHQFLDLV�VH�TXHUHPRV�SURPRYHU�UHSHUWyULRV�FRPSRUWDPHQWDLV�TXH�IDYRUHoDP�R�IXWXUR�GH�QRVVDV�FXOWXUDV�²�H��SRU�RXWUR�ODGR��HYLWDU�RV�UH-SHUWyULRV�TXH�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���������VXJHUHP�VHU�XPD�PHUD�H[SUHVVmR�GH�XP�“ethos da pleonexiaµ��2�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�pWLFR�QmR�p�SURGXWR�GH�TXDOTXHU�WLSR�de ethos��HQTXDQWR�GLVSRVLomR�SVLFROyJLFD�LQWHUQD���HOH�p�IUXWR�GH�YDULiYHLV�ÀORJHQpWLFDV��RQWRJHQpWLFDV�H�FXOWXUDLV��VREUH�DV�TXDLV�SRGHPRV�DWXDU�GH�PD-QHLUD�UHVSRQViYHO�H�SURGXWLYD��2�IDWR�GH�TXH��HYHQWXDOPHQWH��RV�UHVXOWDGRV�GHVVD�DWXDomR�QmR�VHMDP�DTXHOHV�LQLFLDOPHQWH�SUHYLVWRV�QmR�VHUi�WRPDGR�SRU�XP�DQDOLVWD�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�FRPR�´HYLGrQFLD�HPStULFD�GH�GHVFRQWUROHµ��PDV�FRPR�HYLGrQFLD�HPStULFD�GH�TXH�HOH�SUHFLVD�DSURIXQGDU�VXD�EXVFD�SRU�HYLGrQFLDV�HPStULFDV��R�TXH�FRQWUROD�FRPSRUWDPHQWRV�DSDUHQWHPHQWH�´GHV-FRQWURODGRVµ"�$EULU�PmR�GH� LQYHVWLJDo}HV�GHVVD�QDWXUH]D�H�DSHODU�SDUD�R�PHQWDOLVPR�p�D�VDtGD�PDLV�IiFLO��PDV�WDPEpP�D�PDLV�LPSURGXWLYD�

2�VHJXQGR�GRV�TXDWUR�WySLFRV�GR�DUWLJR�TXH�EXVFDP�GHPRQVWUDU�TXH�D�´RUGHP�VRFLDO�JOREDOL]DGDµ�SURGX]LX�´LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGHµ�H�´LQGHWHUPLQDomRµ�LQWLWXOD�VH�´&XOWXUD�HP�GHVFRQWUROHµ��2�WtWXOR�ID]�UHIHUrQFLD�D�XP�´FRQFHLWR�cunhado para o presente artigo para caracterizar o aspecto ateleológico e

LQGHWHUPLQDGR�TXH�DVVXPLX�D�SURGXomR�GH�EHQV�VLPEyOLFRV�QR�FRQWH[WR�GD�JOREDOL]DomRµ��S�������7UDWD�VH�GH�XP�WySLFR�FXUWR��TXH�PHUDPHQWH�FRQVWDWD�D�FUHVFHQWH�FRPSOH[LGDGH�GDV�UHODo}HV�HQWUH�DV�FXOWXUDV�H�RV�HIHLWRV�GLVVR�QD�FRQÀJXUDomR�GDV�SUiWLFDV�FXOWXUDLV��&RQWXGR��RV�DXWRUHV�XVDP�WDO�FRQVWDWDomR�como premissa para um espetacular salto lógico:

1D�JOREDOL]DomR�p�LPSRVVtYHO�SUHYHU��HP�XP�FRQMXQWR�LPHQVR�GH�DJHQWHV�ORFDLV�UHFHSWRUHV�H�UHVVLJQLÀFDGRUHV��TXDLV�VHUmR�RV�UHVXOWDGRV�VLPEyOLFRV��3RUWDQWR��Ki�XP�LPSDVVH�HQWUH�D�SURSRVWD�GH�XP�SODQHMDPHQWR�FXOWXUDO��FRQFHLWR�TXH�

�� Alexandre Dittrich

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

HQIDWL]D�XP�SURFHVVR�WHOHROyJLFR��XPD�LQWHOLJrQFLD�GLUHWLYD��H�R�FRQWH[WR�GH�XPD�FXOWXUD�HP�GHVFRQWUROH��FRQFHLWR�TXH�HQIDWL]D�XP�SURFHVVR�DWHOHROyJLFR��desprovido de inteligência diretiva (p. 45).

1mR�p�IiFLO�GLVFHUQLU�R�TXH��H[DWDPHQWH��RV�DXWRUHV�TXHUHP�GL]HU�FRP�LVVR��+i��GH�IDWR��XP�JUDX�LQVXSHUiYHO�GH�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH�QD�HYROXomR�GH�TXDOTXHU�FXOWXUD��FRPR�6NLQQHU�PHVPR�DSRQWRX��H��J�������������������S�������,VVR�QmR�VLJQLÀFD�TXH�QmR�SRVVDPRV��RX�QmR�GHYDPRV��EXVFDU�FRP-

SUHHQGHU�DV�YDULiYHLV�TXH� LQIOXHQFLDP�R�FXUVR�GHVVD�HYROXomR��&RQWXGR��SRVVLYHOPHQWH�QHQKXP�SVLFyORJR�WHQKD�LQVLVWLGR�WDQWR�TXDQWR�6NLQQHU��H��J���������������QR�IDWR�GH�TXH�D�HYROXomR�GH�XPD�FXOWXUD�QmR�SRGH�VHU�H[SOLFDGD�WHOHRORJLFDPHQWH��RX�SRU�XPD�´LQWHOLJrQFLD�GLUHWLYDµ��2�SODQHMDPHQWR�FXOWXUDO��HOH�PHVPR�XPD�SUiWLFD�FXOWXUDO��p�WmR�GHWHUPLQDGR�SRU�IDWRUHV�DPELHQWDLV�TXDQWR�DV�SUiWLFDV�VREUH�DV�TXDLV�HOH�DJH��VHMD�TXDO�IRU�VXD�FRQÀJXUDomR��9iULDV�FXOWXUDV�HYROXtUDP�SRU�VpFXORV�VHP�TXDOTXHU�WLSR�GH�SODQHMDPHQWR�RUJDQL]DGR��H�D�HPHUJrQFLD�GR�SODQHMDPHQWR�H�VXD�FRPSOH[LÀFDomR�p�DSHQDV�SDUWH�GD�SUySULD�HYROXomR�FXOWXUDO��H�QmR�FRUUHVSRQGH�D�XPD�SDVVDJHP�SDUD�D�´WHOHRORJLDµ��R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�GH�XP�SODQHMDGRU�FXOWXUDO�HVWi�VXMHLWR�jV�PHVPDV�YDULiYHLV�TXH�DIHWDP�R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�GH�TXDOTXHU�SHVVRD��$VVLP��SDUD�6NLQQHU�H�SDUD�D�DQiOLVH�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR��QmR�Ki�TXDOTXHU�VHQWLGR�QR�´LPSDVVHµ�DSRQWDGR�SRU�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���������QD�SDVVDJHP�FLWDGD�

2�WHUFHLUR�WySLFR�QD�VHTXrQFLD�GR�WH[WR��DLQGD�EXVFDQGR�GHPRQVWUDU�TXH�D�´RUGHP�VRFLDO�JOREDOL]DGDµ�SURGX]LX�´LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGHµ�H�´LQGHWHU-PLQDomRµ�� LQWLWXOD�VH�´$�pWLFD�GR�SUD]HU�H�D�HPHUJrQFLD�GD�VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWDµ��1HOH��RV�DXWRUHV�DERUGDP�´R�QtYHO�PLFURVVRFLDO�GD�VRFLHGDGH�GD�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH��QD�TXDO�D�VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWD�YLYH�D�FRQVWUXomR�GH�XPD�DXWRELRJUDÀD�HP�GHVFRQWUROHµ��S�������2V�DXWRUHV�SURS}HP�´GXDV�YDULiYHLV��QmR�H[SORUDGDV�QDV�WHRULDV�SVLFROyJLFDV��>«@�SDUD�H[SOLFDU�R�VXUJLPHQWR�GD�VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWD��D�pWLFD�GR�SUD]HU�>«@�H�R�GHVHQUDL]DPHQWR�WUDGLWLYRµ��S�������2�WySLFR�DERUGD�D�SULPHLUD�GHVVDV�YDULiYHLV��UHVHUYDQGR�D�VHJXQGD�SDUD�R�WySLFR�ÀQDO��TXH�GLVFXWLUHPRV�HP�EUHYH�

(PERUD�R�FRQFHLWR�GH�´VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWDµ�QmR�UHFHED�XPD�GHÀQLomR�QR�DUWLJR��ID]�VH�DOXVmR�D�DOJXQV�DXWRUHV�TXH�H[SORUDP�´FRQÁLWRV�LGHQWLWi-ULRVµ��´FRQIXVmR�LGHQWLWiULDµ��´PXOWLIUHQLDµ�H�´IUDJPHQWDomR�H�DOHDWRULHGDGH�das identidades coexistentes no selfµ��SURGX]LGDV�SRU�DVSHFWRV�FRQVStFXRV�GD�JOREDOL]DomR��LQWHUFkPELR�HQWUH�SHVVRDV�H�FXOWXUDV��´H[LJrQFLD�GH�WRPDGD�GH�GHFLV}HV�HP�VLWXDo}HV�FRWLGLDQDVµ�H�´WHFQROyJLFDV��VLF��GD�PRGHUQLGDGH��PtGLD��WUDQVSRUWH��FRPXQLFDomR�µ��S��������$�´pWLFD�GR�SUD]HUµ��TXH�VHULD�

�� &DEH�QRWDU�TXH�HVVHV�WHPDV�VmR�DERUGDGRV�SRU�7RXULQKR��������SRU�PHLR�GH�XP�GLiORJR�entre análise do comportamento, sociologia e antropologia, embora, obviamente, com

outro linguajar conceitual.

B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultura ��

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

XPD�GDV�´YDULiYHLV�QmR�H[SORUDGDV�QDV�WHRULDV�SVLFROyJLFDVµ�TXH�H[SOLFDP�D�´VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWDµ��p�XP�FRQFHLWR�FXQKDGR��QRYDPHQWH��SHOR�VRFLyORJR�$QGHUVRQ�3LUHV��´SDUD�FDUDFWHUL]DU�R�PRGR�GH�YLGD�KHG{QLFR�GD�VRFLHGDGH�JOREDOL]DGD��QR�TXDO�WRGR�R�HVIRUoR�KXPDQR�VH�RULHQWD�SDUD�D�PD[LPL]DomR�GR�SUD]HU�H�D�PLQLPL]DomR�GD�GRUµ9� �S�������6XSRQGR�TXH�R�FRQFHLWR�VHMD�QRYR��D�FDUDFWHUL]DomR�GHOH�FHUWDPHQWH�QmR�p�²�YLGH�-RKQ�6WXDUW�0LOO���������SDUD�ÀFDU�QR�H[HPSOR�PDLV�yEYLR��0LOO�REYLDPHQWH�QmR�YLYLD�HP�XPD�´VR-

FLHGDGH�JOREDOL]DGDµ��GDGD�D�GHÀQLomR�GH�JOREDOL]DomR�DGRWDGD�SHORV�DXWRUHV��$LQGD�DVVLP��YiULDV�G~YLGDV�UHOHYDQWHV�SHUPDQHFHP��D�TXHP��H[DWDPHQWH��RV�DXWRUHV�HVWmR�VH�UHIHULQGR�TXDQGR�IDODP�HP�XPD�pWLFD�GR�SUD]HU�FRPR�XP�´PRGR�GH�YLGDµ�GD�VRFLHGDGH�JOREDOL]DGD"�$�WRGRV�QyV"�6H�VLP��D�SDUWLU�GH�TXDQGR"�$SHQDV�DSyV�R�ÀP�GD�*XHUUD�)ULD"�0D[LPL]DU�R�SUD]HU�H�HYLWDU�D�GRU�VmR�FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV�H[FOXVLYDV�GRV�FLGDGmRV�GH�XPD�VRFLHGDGH�JOREDOL]DGD"�6H�QmR��TXDO�D�GLIHUHQoD�UHOHYDQWH�HP�UHODomR�D�VRFLHGDGHV�QmR�JOREDOL]DGDV"�4XDLV�VmR�DV�´HYLGrQFLDV�HPStULFDVµ�GHVVD�WUDQVLomR"�2�TXH�QRV� OHYDULD�D�SHQVDU�TXH�XP�LQGLYtGXR�FRQWHPSRUkQHR�EXVFD�´PD[LPL]DU�R�SUD]HU�H�HYLWDU�D�GRUµ�PDLV�GR�TXH��GLJDPRV��DOJXP�FRQWHPSRUkQHR�GH�-RKQ�6WXDUW�0LOO�RX�GH�-XGDV"�7RGDV�HVVDV�TXHVW}HV�VH�WRUQDP�DLQGD�PDLV�GLItFHLV�GH�UHVSRQGHU�VHP�DOJXPD�GHÀQLomR�GR�TXH�VHMDP�´SUD]HUµ�H�´GRUµ�²�DOJR�TXH�0LOO��������pelo menos tentou.

$�YLWyULD�GD�´pWLFD�GR�SUD]HUµ�QD�JOREDOL]DomR��GH�DFRUGR�FRP�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO�� ��������UHFHEHX�IRUWH� LPSXOVR�GH�DXWRUHV�FRPR�1LHW]VFKH��)UHXG�H�5RJHUV��WRGRV�SURWHVWDQGR�FRQWUD�RV�´LPSHUDWLYRV�FDWHJyULFRV�GD�UHOLJLmRµ��HP�HVSHFLDO�FRQWUD�D�´WUDGLomR�FULVWm�QHRWHVWDPHQWiULDµ��SDUD�D�TXDO�´R�VRIULPHQWR��GRU��SUHVHQWH�DGTXLUH�VLJQLILFDGR�H�p�VXSRUWDGR�D�SDUWLU�GD�HVSHUDQoD�HVFDWROyJLFD�GH�VXSHUDomR�QD�UHVVXUUHLomR�GRV�PRUWRVµ��S�������6XSRVWDPHQWH��2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���������QmR�HVSHUDP�TXH�LVVR�EDVWH�FRPR�H[-

SOLFDomR�GDV�FRPSOH[DV�UHODo}HV�TXH�GHWHUPLQDP�R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�pWLFR�KXPDQR�²�TXH�HQYROYHP�PXLWR�PDLV�GR�TXH�SUHVFULo}HV�D�IDYRU�RX�FRQWUD�TXDOTXHU�UHOLJLmR��H�PXLWR�PDLV�GR�TXH�VHULD�SRVVtYHO�UHVXPLU�HP�XP�DUWLJR��&RQWXGR��DILUPDP�RV�DXWRUHV�TXH�

D�pWLFD�GH�6SLQR]LDQD��VLF��IRL�DVVXPLGD�QD�PRGHUQLGDGH�FRPR�FULWpULR�GD�ELR-

JUDÀD�LQGLYLGXDO��QD�TXDO�DV�HVFROKDV�GR�LQGLYtGXR�WUDEDOKDP�FRP�R�FULWpULR�GH�LGHQWLÀFDomR�HQWUH�R�ERP�H�R�EHP��5RPSH�VH�DVVLP�FRP�D�pWLFD�GR�UHQXQFLDQWH�UHOLJLRVR��TXH�GLVWLQJXH�R�ERP��EHP�HVWDU��GR�EHP��S������

9� 6H�Ki�DOJXPD�GLIHUHQoD�HQWUH�HVVH�FRQFHLWR�H�R�GH�´ethos da pleonaxiaµ��HOD�QmR�p�DSRQWDGD�no artigo.

�� Alexandre Dittrich

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

(VVD�p�XPD�IRUPD�SDUWLFXODUPHQWH�SREUH�GH�´H[SOLFDUµ�D�WDO�´pWLFD�GR�SUD]HUµ��$V�UHODo}HV�HQWUH�FRQVHTXrQFLDV�LPHGLDWDV�H�DWUDVDGDV��SDUD�R�LQGL-YtGXR�H�SDUD�RXWUDV�SHVVRDV��VmR�PXLWR�PDLV�FRPSOH[DV�GR�TXH�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO��(2012) sugerem. Analistas do comportamento e outros cientistas têm estudado

HPSLULFDPHQWH�WDLV�UHODo}HV�Ki�GpFDGDV�10�PDV�QmR�LULDP�PXLWR�ORQJH�FDVR�VH�FRQWHQWDVVHP�HP�SHQVDU�TXH�RV�LQGLYtGXRV�´WUDEDOKDP�FRP�XP�FULWpULR�GH�LGHQWLÀFDomR�HQWUH�R�ERP�H�R�EHPµ��H�TXH�VHX�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�UHVXOWD�GLVVR�

3RU�TXH�D�pWLFD�GR�SUD]HU�p�FRQVLGHUDGD�SRU�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���������XPD�´YDULiYHO�QHFHVViULDµ�SDUD�H[SOLFDU�´R�VXUJLPHQWR�GD�VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWDµ"�'H�DFRUGR�FRP�RV�DXWRUHV��SRUTXH�HOD�´DEULX�HVSDoR�SDUD�XP�FULWpULR�QDUFtVLFR�para o indivíduo consumir e descartar identidades: consuma as identidades

TXH�DXPHQWDP�R�VHX�EHP�HVWDU�H�GHVFDUWH�DV� LGHQWLGDGHV�TXH�DPHDoDP�R�EHP�HVWDUµ��S�������'H�IDWR��D�YDULDELOLGDGH�GH�SUiWLFDV�FXOWXUDLV�SUHVHQWHV�QDV�culturas contemporâneas tem aumentado a probabilidade de uma variabilidade

correspondente em termos de repertórios comportamentais. A vida de uma

SHVVRD�KRMH�WHQGH�D�VHU�PHQRV�HVWiYHO�H�SUHYLVtYHO�GR�TXH��GLJDPRV��D�GH�XPD�SHVVRD�GXUDQWH�R�UHJLPH�IHXGDO��FRPR�DSRQWD�WDPEpP�7285,1+2���������´&RQVXPLU�H�GHVFDUWDU�LGHQWLGDGHVµ��FRQWXGR��p�XPD�PHWiIRUD�SRXFR�esclarecedora para processos comportamentais complexos.

0DV�RQGH�HQWUD�6NLQQHU�QHVVD�DUJXPHQWDomR"�1R�SDUiJUDIR�ÀQDO�GHVVH�WySLFR�GR�WH[WR��D�GHVSHLWR�GH�QmR�WHUHP�FLWDGR�6NLQQHU�HP�QHQKXP�PRPHQWR�GXUDQWH�R�WySLFR��RV�~QLFRV�SVLFyORJRV�FLWDGRV�VmR�)5(8'�H�52*(56���RV�autores concluem o seguinte:

$�WHVH�GH�TXH�R�FRQKHFLPHQWR�FLHQWtILFR�SURGX]�SUHYLVLELOLGDGH�H�FRQWUROH�PRVWURX�VH�PDORJUDGD�QR�QtYHO�GD�ELRJUDÀD�LQGLYLGXDO��1mR�IRL�D�IDOWD�GH�FRQKHFL-PHQWR�SVLFROyJLFR�TXH�SURGX]LX�HVWD�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH�ELRJUiÀFD��PDV�R�DF~PXOR�GHVWH�FRQKHFLPHQWR�H�VXD�DSURSULDomR�SHOR�OHLJR�HP�VHX�H[HUFtFLR�GH�UHÁH[LYL-GDGH�>«@��4XDQWR�PDLV�D�SVLFRORJLD��H�LVVR�LQFOXL�R�EHKDYLRULVPR�VNLQQHULDQR��DÀUPDYD�VH�FRPR�IRUoD�GHVWUDGLFLRQDOL]DQWH�QD�PRGHUQLGDGH��PDLV�D�ELRJUDÀD�LQGLYLGXDO�DPSOLDYD�VHX�DVSHFWR�GH�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH�H�GHVFRQWUROH�>«@��S������

1RYDPHQWH��p�VXUSUHHQGHQWH�HQFRQWUDU�HVVH�WLSR�GH�´H[SOLFDomRµ�HP�XP�WUDEDOKR�TXH�VXSRVWDPHQWH�YLVD�DSRQWDU�D�FRPSOH[LGDGH�GRV�IHQ{PHQRV�VRFLDLV��$�SULPHLUD�IUDVH�p�IDFLOPHQWH�GHVPHQWLGD�SHOR�DF~PXOR�GH�GpFDGDV�GH�GDGRV�HPStULFRV��HP�WRGRV�RV�FDPSRV�GH�DSOLFDomR�GD�SVLFRORJLD��2V�DXWRUHV�pecam, entre outras coisas, por analisar o problema em termos de absolutos

�RX�R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�p�SUHYLVtYHO�H�FRQWUROiYHO�RX�QmR�p���H�QmR�SRU�PHLR�10� 3DUD�UHYLV}HV�GH�DOJXQV�WUDEDOKRV�UHOHYDQWHV�QHVVD�iUHD�GH�SHVTXLVD��YHU��SRU�H[HPSOR��

Fantino (1997) e Fantino e Romanovich (2007).

B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultura ��

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

GH�JUDXV�GH�SUHYLVLELOLGDGH�H�FRQWURODELOLGDGH��4XDQWR�jV�IUDVHV�VHJXLQWHV��LJQRUHPRV�DV�TXHVW}HV�GD�SUHYLVLELOLGDGH�H�FRQWURODELOLGDGH��H�VXSRQKDPRV�TXH�RV�DXWRUHV�HVWmR�VH�UHIHULQGR��TXDQGR�IDODP�HP�´LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH�ELR-

JUiÀFDµ��DSHQDV�j�FRPSOH[LGDGH�GDV�YDULiYHLV�TXH�DIHWDP�D�YLGD�KXPDQD�QD�PDLRU�SDUWH�GDV�VRFLHGDGHV�FRQWHPSRUkQHDV��e�SRVVtYHO�SHUJXQWDU�HP�TXH�JUDX�D�´IRUoD�GHVWUDGLFLRQDOL]DQWHµ�GD�SVLFRORJLD�GH�IDWR�IRL�DSURSULDGD�´SHOR�OHLJRµ��FRPR�LVVR�RFRUUHX��H[DWDPHQWH"���0DV�PHVPR�FRQFHGHQGR�TXH�LVVR�WHQKD�DFRQWHFLGR�HP�DOJXPD�PHGLGD��SRVVLYHOPHQWH�HVVD�QmR�p�XPD�YDULiYHO�GDV�PDLV�UHOHYDQWHV�SDUD�H[SOLFDU�SRU�TXH�RV�UHSHUWyULRV�FRPSRUWDPHQWDLV�individuais têm se tornado progressivamente mais complexos. Uma pessoa

exposta a práticas culturais complexas apresenta um repertório igualmente

FRPSOH[R��VHP�TXDOTXHU�QHFHVVLGDGH�GH�VH�DSURSULDU�GD�´IRUoD�GHVWUDGLFLR-

QDOL]DQWH�GD�SVLFRORJLDµ��6RE�R� WtWXOR�´'HVHQUDL]DPHQWR� WUDGLWLYR��GHVFRQIHVVLRQDOL]DomR�H�

HPHUJrQFLD�GD�VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWDµ��R�TXDUWR�H�~OWLPR�WySLFR� WUDWD�GR�TXH�RV�DXWRUHV�FRQVLGHUDP�VHU�D�VHJXQGD�YDULiYHO�UHOHYDQWH��VHQGR�D�SUL-PHLUD�YDULiYHO�D�´pWLFD�GR�SUD]HUµ��PHQFLRQDGD�QR�WySLFR�DQWHULRU��SDUD�H[SOLFDU�R�VXUJLPHQWR�GD�´VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWDµ��´D�GHVFRQH[mR�GR�VLVWHPD�GH�FUHQoDV�UHOLJLRVDV�GR�LQGLYtGXR�HP�UHODomR�j�UDL]�WUDGLWLYD�RULJLQiULD�GH�VXD�FUHQoDµ��S�������2�SHUILO�GRV�QRYRV�HYDQJpOLFRV�EUDVLOHLURV�p�XWLOL]DGR�FRPR�H[HPSOR�GH�´VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWDµ��$�GHVWUDGLFLRQDOL]DomR�GHVVHV�QRYRV�HYDQJpOLFRV�´LPSOLFRX�HP�XPD�GHVFRQIHVVLRQDOL]DomR�GD�Ip�HYDQJpOLFD�EUDVLOHLUD��SRLV�GHVSRWHQFLRX�D�GLPHQVmR�HVFDWROyJLFD�GD�FUHQoD�UHOLJLRVD�FULVWm�H�VXDV�YHUGDGHV�GRJPiWLFDVµ�²�PRUPHQWH��D�UHVVXUUHLomR�GH�&ULVWR��´FUHQoD�TXH�SURGX]LD�QD�FRQVFLrQFLD�GR�FUHQWH�D� LPSOLFDomR�GH�VDWLVID]HU�RV� LGHDLV�pWLFRV�UHVXOWDQWHV�GD�PHVPDµ��S�������7DLV� LGHDLV�WUDGLFLRQDLV�VH�H[SUHVVDP�QD�´pWLFD�GR�tQWHULP��QD�TXDO�R�GHVSUH]R�SHOR�SUHVHQWH�WUDQVL-WyULR�HP�IXQomR�GD�UHDOL]DomR�GD�HVSHUDQoD�GD�UHVVXUUHLomR�SURPHWLGD�VmR�D�EDVH�SDUD�XPD�YLYrQFLD�GR�DPRU�DJiSLFR�FDUDFWHUL]DGR�QD�UHVLJQDomR�GR�LQGLYtGXR�HP�IXQomR�GR�EHP�GR�RXWUR��QXQFD�GD�DXWRVDWLVIDomR��VLF�µ��S�������$R�FRQWUiULR�GR�QRYR�HYDQJpOLFR�EUDVLOHLUR��R�UHOLJLRVR�TXH�VHJXH�D�pWLFD�GD�´WUDGLomR�FULVWm�RULJLQDOµ�p�FRHUHQWH�HP�VXDV�Do}HV��SRLV�´p�FKD-PDGR�D�UHYHODU�HP�VXD�FRQGXWD�D�YHUGDGH�DILUPDGD�QRV�SRVWXODGRV�GH�VXD�Ip��$�PDQXWHQomR�GHVVD�FRHUrQFLD�H[LJH�LQYDULkQFLD�QD�LGHQWLGDGH�GR�FUHQ-

WH�IUHQWH�jV�FLUFXQVWkQFLDV�DPHDoDGRUDV�GH�VXD�H[LVWrQFLD� �5P������µ��S�������2�QRYR�HYDQJpOLFR�EUDVLOHLUR��SRU�VXD�YH]��RULHQWD�VH�SRU�XPD�´pWLFD�GHVHVFDWRORJL]DGD�H�GLUHFLRQDGD�SHOD�pWLFD�GR�SUD]HUµ��(OH�p�XP�´VXMHLWR�pleonexo��RULHQWDGR�SHOD� ¶LPSXOVmR�DTXLVLWLYD��H�SHOD�FRPSHWLWLYLGDGHµ��S�������&RQFOXHP�RV�DXWRUHV�

�� Alexandre Dittrich

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

Esta espiritualidade autocentrada (VpOÀFD��LQWURGX]�R�QRYR�HYDQJpOLFR�EUDVLOHLUR�QD�RUGHP�VRFLDO�GD�JUDWLÀFDomR�LPHGLDWD��QD�TXDO�R�EHP�VH�OHJLWLPD�SHOR�FULWpULR�GH�DXWR�VDWLVIDomR��pWLFD�GR�SUD]HU���$�IURQWHLUD�pWLFD�HQWUH�SURLELGR�H�SHUPLWLGR�QmR�p�PDLV�MXOJDGD�D�SDUWLU�GH�XP�WULEXQDO�GH�DXWR�FRQGHQDomR�QD�FRQVFLrQFLD�GR�QRYR�HYDQJpOLFR�EUDVLOHLUR��S������

$TXL��REYLDPHQWH��6NLQQHU�VDLX�GH�FHQD��PDV�FDEH�QRWDU�TXH�Ki�GLYHU-VRV�SUREOHPDV�QHVVD�DUJXPHQWDomR��(OD�PLVWXUD�VRFLRORJLD�VLPSOLVWD�FRP�psicologia mentalista.

2�TXH�PDLV�FKDPD�D�DWHQomR�VmR�RV�FRQFHLWRV�H�DUJXPHQWRV�XWLOL]DGRV�SHORV�DXWRUHV�DR�WUDWDU�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�pWLFR��2�WH[WR�DSDUHQWHPHQWH�SDUWH�GR�SUHVVXSRVWR�GH�TXH�p�SRVVtYHO�ID]HU�XPD�GLVWLQomR�FODUD�HQWUH�R�FRPSRU-WDPHQWR�pWLFR�GR�´QRYR�HYDQJpOLFR�EUDVLOHLURµ�H�R�GRV�´FULVWmRV�WUDGLFLRQDLVµ��0HVPR�VXSRQGR�TXH�IRVVH�VLPSOHV�FODVVLÀFDU�RV�FULVWmRV�EUDVLOHLURV�HP�XPD�RX�RXWUD�FDWHJRULD��D�´GHVFULomRµ�GH�VHX�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�pWLFR�DSUHVHQWDGD�SHORV�DXWRUHV�QmR�WHP�QHQKXP�IXQGDPHQWR�HPStULFR��H�SDUHFH�EDVHDGD�DSHQDV�QR�TXH�RV�DXWRUHV�JRVWDULDP�TXH�IRVVH�R�FDVR��RV�QRYRV�HYDQJpOLFRV�VmR�YROiWHLV��JDQDQFLRVRV�H�DXWRFHQWUDGRV��HQTXDQWR�RV�´FULVWmRV�WUDGLFLRQDLVµ�VmR�FRHUHQWHV��JHQHURVRV�H�DJiSLFRV��´QXQFDµ�EXVFDP�D�DXWRVVDWLVIDomR���e�SULYLOpJLR�GRV�DXWRUHV�SHQVDU�GHVVD�IRUPD�²�PDV��SDUD�XVDU�R�MDUJmR�GR�SUySULR�DUWLJR��XPD�FRPSUHHQVmR�PDLV�VRÀVWLFDGD�GDV�FRPSOH[DV�YDULiYHLV�HP�MRJR�QD�IRUPDomR�GH�´LGHQWLGDGHVµ�FHUWDPHQWH�WRUQDULD�WDO�FRQFOXVmR�GXYLGRVD��$V�DJrQFLDV�UHOLJLRVDV�WrP�XP�SDSHO�UHOHYDQWH�QR�FRQWUROH�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�pWLFR�GH�SHOR�PHQRV�SDUWH�GDTXHOHV�TXH�DV�IUHTXHQWDP��FHUWDPHQWH�QmR�GH�WRGRV���PDV�REYLDPHQWH�HVVH�SDSHO�QmR�p�H[FOXVLYR�11�2�VLPSOHV�IDWR�GH�DOJXpP�VHU�XP�´QRYR�HYDQJp-OLFRµ�RX�XP�´FULVWmR�WUDGLFLRQDOµ�HVWi�ORQJH�GH�HVJRWDU�DV�YDULiYHLV�UHOHYDQWHV�SDUD�H[SOLFDU�VHX�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�pWLFR��$OpP�GLVVR��Ki�LQFRQWiYHLV�H[HPSORV��KRMH�H�HP�VpFXORV�SDVVDGRV��GH�´FULVWmRV�WUDGLFLRQDLVµ�TXH�QmR�SDUHFHP�WHU�sido coerentes, generosos ou agápicos em sua conduta, apoiando ou pratican-

GR�VHP�SXGRU�WRGD�VRUWH�GH�EDUEDULVPR��SUHFRQFHLWR��HVFUDYLGmR��KXPLOKDomR��H[SORUDomR�HFRQ{PLFD��DEXVR�VH[XDO�H�DVVDVVLQDWR��HQWUH�RXWURV��(PERUD�GHÀQLU�´FRHUrQFLDµ�QmR�VHMD�WmR�VLPSOHV�FRPR�SDUHFH��p�SRVVtYHO�DUJXPHQWDU�TXH�HVVD�QmR�p�XPD�TXDOLGDGH�IDFLOPHQWH�LGHQWLÀFiYHO�HQWUH�RV�´FULVWmRV�WUDGLFLRQDLVµ�DR�ORQJR�GD�+LVWyULD��7DOYH]�GHYDPRV�ÀFDU�IHOL]HV�FRP�LVVR��SRLV�GR�FRQWUiULR�HOHV�DLQGD�HVWDULDP�VXVWHQWDQGR�YiULDV�GDV�VXSHUVWLo}HV�TXH�MXVWLÀFDUDP�FULPHV�históricos contra a humanidade, sempre praticados em nome de Deus, e hoje

�HVSHUD�VH��FRQGHQDGRV�SRU�WRGRV�RV�FULVWmRV�

11� 6NLQQHU�WUDWD�GR�DVVXQWR��SRU�H[HPSOR��HP�´&LrQFLD�H�&RPSRUWDPHQWR�+XPDQRµ�������²�RULJLQDOPHQWH�SXEOLFDGR�HP�������

B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultura ��

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

&DEH�WDPEpP�XP�FRPHQWiULR�VREUH�D�QDWXUH]D�PHQWDOLVWD�GD�DUJXPHQ-

WDomR��TXH�VH�UHSHWH�HP�YiULRV�SRQWRV�GR�DUWLJR���(OD�LOXVWUD�FODUDPHQWH�R�SULQFLSDO�SUREOHPD�DSRQWDGR�SRU�6NLQQHU��������������H�SRU�WRGRV�RV�DQDOLVWDV�do comportamento nesse tipo de raciocínio: a circularidade explicativa, e a

FRQVHTXHQWH�LPSRVVLELOLGDGH�GH�FRQWHPSODU�SRVVLELOLGDGHV�HIHWLYDV�GH�LQÁXHQ-

FLDU�R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�pWLFR��&RPR�Mi�YLPRV�QR�FDVR�GR�´ethos da pleonaxiaµ��D�UHIHULGD�FLUFXODULGDGH�SURFHGH�GD�VHJXLQWH�IRUPD��REVHUYD�VH�SDGU}HV�GH�FRPSRUWDPHQWR��LQIHUH�VH�GHVVD�REVHUYDomR�D�H[LVWrQFLD�GH�DOJXPD�HQWLGDGH�PHQWDO�H��HP�VHJXLGD��XVD�VH�HVVD�VXSRVWD�HQWLGDGH�FRPR�´H[SOLFDomRµ�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR��6H�FRQWLQXDUPRV�DFKDQGR�TXH�R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�pWLFR�GDV�SHVVRDV�p�FDXVDGR��RX�LQÁXHQFLDGR��SRU�´FRQVFLrQFLDV�DXWRGHVFXOSDELOL]D-GDVµ��´HVSLULWXDOLGDGHV�DXWRFHQWUDGDVµ�RX�´WULEXQDLV�GH�DXWR�FRQGHQDomR�QD�FRQVFLrQFLDµ��S�������WHUHPRV�SRXFR�D�ID]HU��(PERUD�WHQKDP�YDORU�HVWpWLFR��HVVDV�H[SUHVV}HV�VmR�PHWiIRUDV� LQDGHTXDGDV�SDUD�GHVFUHYHU�UHODo}HV�FRP-

portamentais complexas.

1DV�FRQVLGHUDo}HV�ILQDLV�GR�DUWLJR��RV�DXWRUHV�DSUHVHQWDP�D�VHJXLQWH�FRQFOXVmR�

2V�VNLQQHULDQRV�FRQWHPSRUkQHRV�QmR�DWHQWDUDP�SDUD�RV�HOHPHQWRV�UHÁH[LYRV�SRVWRV�QR�SUHVHQWH�DUWLJR��SRU�LVVR�QmR�SHUFHEHUDP�R�KLDWR�LQWUDQVSRQtYHO�TXH�VH�HVWDEHOHFHX�QD�JOREDOL]DomR�HQWUH�D�SURSRVWD�VNLQQHULDQD�GR�SODQHMDPHQWR�cultural e a sociedade da imprevisibilidade, com sua típica subjetividade aberta.

A proposta de Pires e a emergência da cultura em descontrole nos leva (sic) a

FRQFOXLU�TXH�RV�FRQFHLWRV�GH�SUHYLVLELOLGDGH�H�FRQWUROH�WRUQDUDP�VH�REVROHWRV�SDUD�DV�OyJLFDV�GDV�LQWHUDo}HV�VRFLDLV�SURGX]LGDV�QD�JOREDOL]DomR��S������

$�VXJHVWmR�GH�TXH�´RV�VNLQQHULDQRV�FRQWHPSRUkQHRV�QmR�DWHQWDUDP�SDUD�RV�HOHPHQWRV�UHÁH[LYRVµ�GR�DUWLJR�SRGH�VHU�FULWLFDGD�HP�YiULDV�IUHQWHV�²�D�SULPHLUD�GHODV��EDVWDQWH�yEYLD��FRPR�SRGHP�RV�DXWRUHV�VH�SHUPLWLU�TXDOTXHU�FRQFOXVmR�VREUH�´RV�VNLQQHULDQRV�FRQWHPSRUkQHRVµ�TXDQGR�GHL[DP�FODUR��GHVGH�R�LQtFLR�GR�DUWLJR��TXH�R�DUWLJR�´IRFDUi�R�SHQVDPHQWR�VNLQQHULDQRµ��GHL[DQGR�GH�ODGR�D�´OLWHUDWXUD�PDLV�UHFHQWH�VREUH�SODQHMDPHQWR�FXOWXUDOµ��S�����"��/HPEUHPRV�TXH�R�DUWLJR�LQFOXVLYH�FULWLFD�R�´SHQVDPHQWR�VRFLDOµ�GH�6NLQQHU�SRUTXH�HOH�´VH�GHVHQYROYHX�DQWHV�GR�DWXDO�SURFHVVR�GH�JOREDOL]DomRµ���2V�DXWRUHV� MXVWLILFDP�D�DXVrQFLD�GHVVD� OLWHUDWXUD�DILUPDQGR�TXH�´HOD�QmR�SURS}H�XPD�PXGDQoD�VXEVWDQFLDO�QD�UHIHULGD�WHVH�VNLQQHULDQD�12

no máximo

UHGLPHQVLRQD�DV�HVWUDWpJLDV�SDUD�VXD�YLDELOLGDGHµ��S�������5HWRPDUHPRV�HP

12� $�´UHIHULGD�WHVHµ�p�D�GH�TXH�´R�DF~PXOR�GR�FRQKHFLPHQWR�SVLFROyJLFR�SHUPLWH�HOHYDU�D�SUHYLVLELOLGDGH�H�R�FRQWUROH�GD�YLGD�VRFLDOµ��S������

�� Alexandre Dittrich

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

EUHYH�D�GLVFXVVmR�GR�DVVXQWR��PDV�GHVGH�Mi�FDEH�QRWDU�TXH�TXDOTXHU�DÀUPD-omR�FDWHJyULFD�VREUH�D�´OLWHUDWXUD�PDLV�UHFHQWHµ�SURGX]LGD�SRU�DQDOLVWDV�GR�comportamento no campo do planejamento cultural exigiria um exame siste-

PiWLFR�GHVVD�OLWHUDWXUD��R�TXH�QmR�p�DSUHVHQWDGR��$OpP�GLVVR��RV�´HOHPHQWRV�UHÁH[LYRVµ�DSUHVHQWDGRV�QR�DUWLJR��FRQIRUPH�EXVFDPRV�DSRQWDU��VmR�IXQGD-PHQWDGRV�HP�FRQFHLWRV�YDJRV�H�HP�DUJXPHQWRV�QR�PtQLPR�TXHVWLRQiYHLV��1mR�REVWDQWH��WDLV�HOHPHQWRV�ID]HP�UHIHUrQFLD�D�UHODo}HV�FRPSRUWDPHQWDLV�UHOHYDQWHV��TXH�FHUWDPHQWH�LQWHUHVVDP�DRV�DQDOLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR��$�DQiOLVH�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�WHP�IHLWR�PXLWR�PDLV�SDUD�D�FRPSUHHQVmR�GHVVDV�UHODo}HV�GR�TXH�RV�DXWRUHV�SDUHFHP�UHFRQKHFHU��RX�FRQKHFHU��

2OLYHLUD�HW�DO�� �������HQFHUUDP�R�DUWLJR�FRP�XPD�FRQFOXVmR�VXUSUH-HQGHQWH��VREUH�XP�DVVXQWR�TXH�VHTXHU�KDYLD�VLGR�PHQFLRQDGR�DWp�HQWmR��D�análise comportamental clínica. De acordo com os autores, “a emergência

GD�VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWD�WHP�LPSOLFDomR�WDPEpP�SDUD�D�SUiWLFD�FOtQLFD�GD�DQiOLVH�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWRµ��SRLV�HOD�´SURFXUD�LQWHUSUHWDU�H�LQWHUYLU�QD�YLGD�GR�LQGLYtGXR�FRQVLGHUDQGR�VHX�PLFURDPELHQWH�LPHGLDWR��H[��IDPtOLD��VDOD�GH�DXOD��UHODo}HV�LPHGLDWDV�GH�WUDEDOKR�µ��S�������,VVR�VHULD�XP�´HUUR�PHWRGROy-

JLFRµ��SRLV�R�FOtQLFR�HVWDULD�LVRODQGR�WDO�PLFURDPELHQWH��´FRQVLGHUDQGR�VXD�GLQkPLFD�DXW{QRPD�H�LQÁXrQFLD�QD�D�YLGD�LQGLYLGXDO�FRPR�GHVFRQHFWDGD�GR�PDFURDPELHQWH�FRPSOH[R�HPHUJHQWH�QD�JOREDOL]DomRµ��S�������$R�DVVLP�DJLU��R�FOtQLFR�HVWDULD�´LQDELOLWDGR�SDUD�FDSWDU�RV�HIHLWRV�GD�JOREDOL]DomR�VREUH�D�vida individual […] O macroambiente da cultura em descontrole midiatiza

PRGHORV�TXH�SURGX]HP�FUHQoDV�H�YDORUHV�FRQVXPLGRV�SHORV�LQGLYtGXRV�QR�PLFURDPELHQWH�IDPLOLDUµ��S�������(�SRU�ÀP��RV�DXWRUHV�DOHUWDP��´e�LQGLVSHQ-

ViYHO�QD�SUiWLFD�SVLFRWHUDSrXWLFD�XPD�UXSWXUD�FRP�R�PRGHOR�GH�LQWHUSUHWDomR�GD�YLGD�LQGLYLGXDO�D�SDUWLU�GR�PLFURDPELHQWH�LVRODGRµ��S�������

Em seguida, os autores mencionam o programa televisivo Supernanny FRPR�XP�H[HPSOR�GD�GHVFRQH[mR�HQWUH�PLFURDPELHQWH�H�PDFURDPELHQWH��QmR�sem acrescentar uma oportuna nota onde se dizem “conscientes das grandes

GLIHUHQoDV�HQWUH�R�SURFHGLPHQWR�QR�SURJUDPD�supernanny (sic) e a prática da

DQiOLVH�FRPSRUWDPHQWDO�FOtQLFDµ��S�������0DV�HQWmR��D�TXH�YHLR�R�H[HPSOR"�Os autores esclarecem:

Em princípio, o erro do modelo supernanny�p�R�PHVPR�GR�PRGHOR�DFDGrPLFR�VNLQQHULDQR��$PERV�WUDWDP�R�PLFURDPELHQWH�IDPLOLDU�FRPR�SDVVtYHO�GH�XPD�LQWHUYHQomR�RULHQWDGRUD�GDV�LQWHUDo}HV�VRFLDLV��GHVFRQVLGHUDQGR�R�HIHLWR�LQ-

FRQWUROiYHO�H�LPSUHYLVtYHO�GR�PDFURDPELHQWH�GD�JOREDOL]DomR�VREUH�R�PLFUR-

DPELHQWH�IDPLOLDU��S������

&RPR�TXDOTXHU�DQDOLVWD�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�DWXDQWH�QD�FOtQLFD�SHUFH-EHUi�IDFLOPHQWH��HVVDV�FUtWLFDV�GHPRQVWUDP�FRPSOHWR�GHVFRQKHFLPHQWR��RX�

B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultura ��

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

QR�PtQLPR�XPD�FRPSUHHQVmR�HTXLYRFDGD��GRV�IXQGDPHQWRV�H�GD�DSOLFDomR�da análise do comportamento. Para um analista do comportamento, como

Mi�PHQFLRQDPRV��WXGR�R�TXH�DV�SHVVRDV�ID]HP��HP�TXDOTXHU�PRPHQWR�GH�VXDV�YLGDV��p�IUXWR�GD�DomR�FRQMXQWD�GH�YDULiYHLV�VHOHWLYDV�DWXDQWHV�QRV�QtYHLV�ÀORJHQpWLFR��RQWRJHQpWLFR�H�FXOWXUDO��6.,11(5���������$V�YDULiYHLV�UHOHYDQ-

WHV�SDUD�D�SURGXomR�GH�UHVXOWDGRV�FOtQLFRV�VDWLVIDWyULRV�H�GXUDGRXURV�GHYHP�VHU�GHVFREHUWDV�HPSLULFDPHQWH��XPD�YDJD�GLVWLQomR�HQWUH�´PLFURDPELHQWHµ�H�´PDFURDPELHQWHµ�QmR�DFUHVFHQWD�QDGD�GH�LPSRUWDQWH�D�HVWH�WUDEDOKR��1mR�Ki�QHQKXP�LPSHGLPHQWR�WHyULFR�RX�PHWRGROyJLFR�SDUD�TXH�XP�DQDOLVWD�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�LGHQWLÀTXH�FRPR�XPD�YDULiYHO�HYHQWXDOPHQWH�UHOHYDQWH��SRU�H[HPSOR��RV�´PRGHORV�PLGLDWL]DGRVµ�TXH�´SURGX]HP�FUHQoDV�H�YDORUHV�FRQVX-

PLGRV�SHORV�LQGLYtGXRV�QR�PLFURDPELHQWH�IDPLOLDUµ��S�������6H�DOJXP�DQDOLVWD�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR��FOtQLFR�RX�QmR��LJQRUD�RX�QmR�Gi�DWHQomR�DR�´FRPSOH[R�DPELHQWH�GH�VRFLHGDGHµ�TXH�DMXGD�D�H[SOLFDU�R�UHSHUWyULR�FRPSRUWDPHQWDO�GH�TXDOTXHU�SHVVRD��LQFOXVLYH�GR�SUySULR�DQDOLVWD���HOH�QmR�HVWi�DWXDQGR�FRUUHWD-PHQWH��$�DQiOLVH�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�QmR�SUHVVXS}H�TXDOTXHU�GHVFRQH[mR�HQWUH�´YLGD�LQGLYLGXDOµ�H�´PDFURDPELHQWH�FRPSOH[Rµ��e�QHFHVViULR��SRU�RXWUR�ODGR��HVSHFLÀFDU�de que forma�YDULiYHLV�FXOWXUDLV�FRPSOH[DV�HIHWLYDPHQWH�DOWHUDP�R�repertório comportamental das pessoas, e a análise do comportamento tem

IHLWR�FRQWULEXLo}HV�GHFLVLYDV�SDUD�WDQWR��H��J���025(,5$��������6$03$,2��$1'(5<��������7285,1+2��������

1HQKXP�WHUDSHXWD��FRPSRUWDPHQWDO�RX�QmR�� WHP�FRQGLo}HV�GH�GLV-FULPLQDU��H� LQWHUIHULU�VREUH��WRGDV�DV�YDULiYHLV�TXH�DIHWDP�DV�SHVVRDV�TXH�SURFXUDP�DX[tOLR�WHUDSrXWLFR��2�SUySULR�6NLQQHU�������������WLQKD�FODUH]D�TXDQWR�DR�IDWR�GH�TXH�´D�VLWXDomR�WHUDSrXWLFD�p�DSHQDV�XPD�SHTXHQD�SDUWH�GR�PXQGR�GR�FOLHQWHµ��S�������H�GH�TXH�Ki�LQ~PHUDV�YDULiYHLV�TXH�IRJHP�DR�FRQWUROH�GR�WHUDSHXWD��1mR�REVWDQWH��D�WHUDSLD�DQDOtWLFR�FRPSRUWDPHQWDO�WHP�UHFRQKHFLGD�HÀFiFLD�QD�UHVROXomR�GH�XPD�VpULH�GH�SUREOHPDV��SDUD�DOJXPDV�UHYLV}HV�VLVWHPiWLFDV��YHU�',0,'-,$1�HW�DO���������08/,&.��/$1'(6��.$17(5��������3257(5��63$7(6��60,7+$0���������e�SRU�HVVH�FULWpULR��HP�HVSHFLDO��TXH�HOD�GHYH�VHU�MXOJDGD�

Previsibilidade e controle na ciência e na análise

do comportamento

´3UHYLVLELOLGDGHµ�H�´FRQWUROHµ�QmR�VmR�DSHQDV�FRQFHLWRV��PDV�UHVXOWDGRV�PHQVXUiYHLV��GHPRQVWUiYHLV�HPSLULFDPHQWH�H�TXH�YDULDP�HP�JUDXV��1HVVH�VHQWLGR��QmR�SDUHFHP�FRUUHU�TXDOTXHU�ULVFR�VpULR�GH�VH�WRUQDU�´REVROHWRVµ��D�GHVSHLWR�GD�RSLQLmR�GH�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO����������&RQIRUPH�DÀUPDPRV��QHQKXP�FLHQWLVWD��HP�TXDOTXHU�iUHD��VXS}H�WHU�SRGHU�DEVROXWR�GH�SUHYLVmR�H�FRQWUROH�GRV�IHQ{PHQRV�TXH�HVWXGD��0DV�VDEHU�VH�´R�FRQKHFLPHQWR�SVLFROyJLFR�SRGH�

�� Alexandre Dittrich

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

elevar a previsibilidade e o controle da vida social na sociedade da impre-

YLVLELOLGDGHµ��S������p�XPD�TXHVWmR�HPStULFD��QmR�GH�RSLQLmR�²�H�D�UHVSRVWD�empírica tem sido indubitavelmente positiva.

(VVD�DPSOLDomR�WHP�VLGR�XVDGD�Ki�GpFDGDV�SDUD�DX[LOLDU�SHVVRDV�QRV�mais variados contextos: clínico, educacional, organizacional, comunitário,

MXUtGLFR��HVSRUWLYR��HWF��'H�IDWR��0D\HU��6XO]HU�$]DURII �H�:DOODFH��������HV-SHFLÀFDP�����iUHDV�GH�DSOLFDomR�QDV�TXDLV�D�DQiOLVH�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�WHP�DSUHVHQWDGR�FRQWULEXLo}HV�UHFRQKHFLGDPHQWH�LPSRUWDQWHV��VHP�VXSRU�TXH�D�OLVWD�VHMD�H[DXVWLYD��6HULD�DEVXUGR�VXJHULU�TXH�RV�DQDOLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR��RX�TXDOTXHU�SHVVRD�RX�LQVWLWXLomR��GHL[DVVHP�GH�UHDOL]DU�WDLV�LQWHUYHQo}HV�HP�IXQomR�GR�IDWR�yEYLR�GH�TXH�QmR�SRGHP�SUHYHU�FRP�DEVROXWD�FHUWH]D�VHXV�UHVXOWDGRV��4XDOTXHU�DQDOLVWD�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�VDEH�TXH�XPD�LQWHUYHQomR�UHVSRQViYHO�H[LJH�D�DYDOLDomR�FRQVWDQWH�GH�VXD�HÀFiFLD�²�H��VH�QHFHVViULR��D�DOWHUDomR�GRV�SURFHGLPHQWRV�HPSUHJDGRV��$�GLVFXVVmR�pWLFD�VREUH�TXDLV�UHVXOWDGRV�VmR�PDLV�RX�PHQRV�GHVHMiYHLV��HP�TXDOTXHU�iUHD�GH�LQWHUYHQomR��p�REYLDPHQWH� LPSRUWDQWH��FRPR�RV�DQDOLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�VHPSUH�VRXEHUDP�²�PDV�QLQJXpP�WHP�D�SDODYUD�ÀQDO�D�UHVSHLWR�GHOD�

6NLQQHU�VHPSUH�UHFRQKHFHX�TXH�R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�p�´SRVVLYHOPHQWH�R�PDLV�GLItFLO�REMHWR�Mi�VXEPHWLGR�j�DQiOLVH�FLHQWtÀFDµ��������S��������/LGDU�FRP�R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�²�H�HP�HVSHFLDO�FRP�R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�KXPDQR�²�HQYROYH�FRPSOH[RV�SUREOHPDV�FRQFHLWXDLV��FLHQWtÀFRV�H�pWLFRV�FRP�RV�TXDLV�os analistas do comportamento e outros cientistas têm buscado arduamente

OLGDU��FRP�SURJUHVVLYR�VXFHVVR��DR�ORQJR�GH�YiULDV�GpFDGDV��(P�FRQWUDSRQWR��D�DUJXPHQWDomR�GHVHQYROYLGD�SRU�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���������p�GH�XP�WLSR�SDUWL-cularmente prejudicial, embora bastante comum no pensamento acadêmico

FRQWHPSRUkQHR��R�PXQGR�p�FRPSOH[R��LPSUHYLVtYHO�H�LQFRQWUROiYHO�²�SRUWDQ-

WR��QDGD�SRGHPRV�ID]HU�VREUH�HOH��H�DTXHOHV�TXH�WHQWDP�ID]HU�DOJR�HVWmR�VH�iludindo. Se concordássemos com os autores, viraríamos todos espectadores

FRQIRUWiYHLV�GR�FDRV��'XUDQWH�WRGR�R�DUWLJR�H�WDPEpP�HP�VXD�FRQFOXVmR��2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���������

VXJHUHP�TXH�RV�DQDOLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�LJQRUDP�D�FRPSOH[LGDGH�GRV�IHQ{PHQRV�UHVXPLGRV�SRU�PHLR�GD�SDODYUD�´JOREDOL]DomRµ��H�TXH�QmR�LQFRU-SRUDP�WDLV�IHQ{PHQRV�j�VXD�DQiOLVH��(VVD�LQWHUSUHWDomR�QmR�FDEH�VHTXHU�D�6NLQQHU�²�TXH�DÀUPDYD��Mi�HP�������TXH�´RV�JUDQGHV�SUREOHPDV�VmR�DJRUD�JOREDLVµ��S��������H�FHUWDPHQWH�WDPEpP�QmR�FDEH�DRV�´VNLQQHULDQRV�FRQWHP-

SRUkQHRVµ��FRPR�XP�H[DPH�FXLGDGRVR�GD�´OLWHUDWXUD�PDLV�UHFHQWHµ�SRGHULD�UHYHODU��H��J���7285,1+2��������%HKDYLRU�DQG�6RFLDO�,VVXHV���������

2�SODQHMDPHQWR�FXOWXUDO�H[LVWLX�SRU�VpFXORV�DQWHV�GR�VXUJLPHQWR�GD�DQiOLVH�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR��H�FHUWDPHQWH�FRQWLQXDULD�HYROXLQGR�PHVPR�TXH�ela jamais tivesse surgido. Em maior ou menor grau, ele está presente em

B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultura ��

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

SHOR�PHQRV�SDUWH�GDV�SROtWLFDV�S~EOLFDV�FRQWHPSRUkQHDV��2�IDWR�GH�TXH�D�PDLRULD�GRV�SURSRQHQWHV�H�JHVWRUHV�GH�SROtWLFDV�S~EOLFDV�QmR�DGRWD�sistema-ticamente DV�SUiWLFDV�GH�SUHYLVmR�H�DYDOLDomR�GH�UHVXOWDGRV�p�XP�GRV�JUDQGHV�SUREOHPDV�GR�PXQGR�DWXDO��/RQJH�GH�VXSRU�TXH�RV�UHVXOWDGRV�GH�TXDOTXHU�LQWHUYHQomR�SRGHP�VHU�SUHYLVWRV�RX�FRQWURODGRV�GH�IRUPD�DEVROXWD��RV�DQD-OLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�VmR�SUHSDUDGRV�SDUD�DYDOLDU�FRQVWDQWHPHQWH�WDLV�resultados e reorientar suas práticas de acordo com os dados produzidos

SRU�HVVD�DYDOLDomR��$OpP�GLVVR��GDGR�TXH�FXOWXUDV�VmR�FRQMXQWRV�FRPSOH[RV�GH�UHODo}HV�FRPSRUWDPHQWDLV��R�SODQHMDPHQWR�FXOWXUDO�VH�IXQGDPHQWD�QmR�DSHQDV�HP�XPD�DWLWXGH�FLHQWtÀFD��PDV�WDPEpP�QD�H[SHULrQFLD�GDV�SHVVRDV�TXH�HIHWLYDPHQWH�WRPDP�SDUWH�HP�SUiWLFDV�FXOWXUDLV��´1HQKXP�FXUVR�GH�DomR�GHYH�VHU�H[FOXVLYDPHQWH�GLWDGR�SHOD�H[SHULrQFLD�FLHQWtÀFD�>«@�$�H[SHULrQFLD�IRUPDOL]DGD�GD�FLrQFLD��VRPDGD�j�H[SHULrQFLD�SUiWLFD�GR�LQGLYtGXR�HP�XP�FRQMXQWR�FRPSOH[R�GH�FLUFXQVWkQFLDV��RIHUHFH�D�PHOKRU�EDVH�SDUD�D�DomR�HIHWLYDµ��6.,11(5�������������S�������2/,9(,5$�HW�DO��>����@���FRQWXGR��parecem ignorar o caráter experimental, dinâmico e participativo da proposta

de planejamento cultural dos analistas do comportamento.

�'pFDGDV�GH�SUiWLFD�HPStULFD�QD�DQiOLVH�IXQFLRQDO��HP�DPELHQWHV�H[-

perimentais e aplicados, tornaram os analistas do comportamento sensíveis

a diversos tipos de variáveis relevantes no controle do comportamento,

LQFOXLQGR�DV�GH�RUGHP�VRFLDO�H�FXOWXUDO��2V�HVWXGRV�YLVDQGR�LGHQWLÀFDU��FRP-

SUHHQGHU�H�DJLU�VREUH�WDLV�YDULiYHLV�FRQWLQXDP��FRPR�p�WtSLFR�HP�TXDOTXHU�FLrQFLD��6XJHULU�TXH�RV�DQDOLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�HVWmR�QHJOLJHQFLDQGR�XP�FRQMXQWR�UHOHYDQWH�GHVVDV�YDULiYHLV�VHULD�XPD�FUtWLFD�UHOHYDQWH��GHVGH�TXH�UHÁHWLVVH�RV�IDWRV�

$�SRVWXUD�LQYHVWLJDWLYD�WtSLFD�GRV�FLHQWLVWDV�Vy�p�SRVVtYHO�SRUTXH�HOHV�VXS}HP�TXH�RV�IHQ{PHQRV�ItVLFRV�H�VRFLDLV��SRU�PDLV�FRPSOH[RV�TXH�VHMDP��VmR�SDVVtYHLV�GH�DOJXP�JUDX�GH�SUHYLVmR�H�FRQWUROH��DFLPD�GR�PHUR�DFDVR��(VVH�SRGHU�GH�SUHYLVmR�H�FRQWUROH��HPERUD�MDPDLV�DEVROXWR��IRL�H�FRQWLQXD�VHQGR�GHPRQVWUDGR�HP�LQFRQWiYHLV�RFDVL}HV�DR� ORQJR�GD�+LVWyULD��$�HOH�GHYHPRV�XPD�TXDQWLGDGH� LPHQVXUiYHO�GDV�FRQTXLVWDV�GD�KXPDQLGDGH��$�FRPSOH[LGDGH��EHP�FRPR�DOJXP�JUDX�GH�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH��VmR�LQHUHQWHV�DR�WUDEDOKR�FLHQWtÀFR�²�PDV�WDLV�FDUDFWHUtVWLFDV�QmR�GHPDUFDP�R�SRQWR�QR�TXDO�D�FLrQFLD�GHYH�SDUDU��PDV�VLP�R�SRQWR�GR�TXDO�HOD�SDUWH��D�ÀP�GH�DXPHQWDU�VHX�SRGHU�GH�SUHYLVmR�H�FRQWUROH��$OJXQV�H[HPSORV�GH�GLIHUHQWHV�FLrQFLDV�SRGHP�LOXVWUDU�WDLV�DÀUPDo}HV�

����)HQ{PHQRV�DWPRVIpULFRV�VmR�IUHTXHQWHPHQWH�FLWDGRV�FRPR�LOXVWUDWLYRV�GH�VLVWHPDV�FDyWLFRV��QRV�TXDLV�SHTXHQDV�DOWHUDo}HV�SRGHP�JHUDU�HIHLWRV�GH�JUDQGH�PRQWD��1mR�REVWDQWH��PHWHRURORJLVWDV�WrP�GHVHQYROYLGR�VLVWHPDV�GH�SUHYLVmR�

90 Alexandre Dittrich

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

GR�WHPSR�FDGD�YH]�PDLV�VRÀVWLFDGRV��1HQKXP�PHWHRURORJLVWD�DÀUPD�TXH�VXD�FLrQFLD�SRVVXL�SRGHU�GH�SUHYLVmR�DEVROXWR��PDV�DV�SUHYLV}HV�PHWHRUROyJLFDV��PHVPR�FRP�VXDV�SRWHQFLDLV�IDOKDV��PRVWUDP�VH�FRUUHWDV�HP�XP�Q~PHUR�EHP�DFLPD�GR�PHUR�DFDVR��$V�DSOLFDo}HV�SUiWLFDV�GD�PHWHRURORJLD�VmR�GH�JUDQGH�LPSRUWkQFLD�HP�GLYHUVRV�FDPSRV��3UHYLV}HV�PHWHRUROyJLFDV�SHUPLWHP��SRU�H[HPSOR��HYDFXDU�SURSULHGDGHV�H�WRPDU�PHGLGDV�DGLFLRQDLV�GH�VHJXUDQoD�DQWHV�GH�GHVDVWUHV�QDWXUDLV��FDQFHODU�YRRV�SRWHQFLDOPHQWH�SHULJRVRV�H�SODQHMDU�Do}HV�na agricultura visando otimizar seus resultados. Talvez ainda mais importante: se

KRMH�HVWDPRV�FLHQWHV�GDV�PXGDQoDV�FOLPiWLFDV�TXH�DPHDoDP�D�SUySULD�H[LVWrQFLD�KXPDQD�QD�7HUUD��H�TXH�H[LJHP�Do}HV�HQpUJLFDV��GHYHPRV�LVVR�jTXHOHV�TXH��D�despeito da enorme complexidade das variáveis climáticas, buscam estudá-las

H�FRPSUHHQGr�ODV��'HYHUtDPRV�GHL[DU�GH�SODQHMDU�Do}HV�QHVVH�VHQWLGR�SRUTXH�QmR�WHPRV�FHUWH]D�DEVROXWD�GRV�UHVXOWDGRV"�6HULD�R�DFDVR�XP�MXL]�PDLV�FRQÀiYHO�GH�QRVVR�IXWXUR"����0pGLFRV�XWLOL]DP�RV�UHVXOWDGRV�GH�SHVTXLVDV�ELROyJLFDV�SDUD�LQFRQWiYHLV�DSOL-FDo}HV�TXH�YLVDP�SUHVHUYDU�RX�UHVWDXUDU�D�VD~GH�GDV�SHVVRDV��2�FRUSR�KXPDQR�p�LQGXELWDYHOPHQWH�XP�VLVWHPD�FRPSOH[R��FRPSRVWR�SHOD�LQWHUDomR�GH�WULOK}HV�GH�FpOXODV�GH�GLIHUHQWHV�WLSRV��1mR�REVWDQWH��p�MXVWR�GL]HU�TXH�D�PHGLFLQD�p�XPD�DSOLFDomR�FLHQWtÀFD�UHODWLYDPHQWH�EHP�VXFHGLGD�²�R�TXH�TXHU�GL]HU��HP�RXWUDV�SDODYUDV��TXH�VHX�SRGHU�GH�SUHYLVmR�H�FRQWUROH�WHP�DXPHQWDGR�FRQVLGHUDYHO-mente ao longo de sua história. Dada a complexidade do corpo humano, e o

JUDX�LQHYLWiYHO�GH�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH�HQYROYLGR�HP�TXDOTXHU�LQWHUYHQomR�VREUH�HOH��WHULD�VLGR�SUHIHUtYHO�TXH�D�PHGLFLQD�QmR�WLYHVVH�VXUJLGR��DPHGURQWDGD�SHOD�GLÀFXOGDGH�GD�WDUHID"�4XH�WLYHVVH�UHFXDGR�GLDQWH�GRV�KRUL]RQWHV�GH�SHVTXLVD�progressivamente mais complexos revelados por seu próprio trabalho? Por

VRUWH��RV�FLHQWLVWDV�GD�iUHD�PpGLFD�QmR�VH�DEDODUDP�FRP�DV�GLÀFXOGDGHV�LPSRV-WDV�SHOD�FRPSOH[LGDGH��H�DYDQoDUDP�GH�PDQHLUD�DGPLUiYHO�QD�FRPSUHHQVmR�GR�IXQFLRQDPHQWR�GR�FRUSR�KXPDQR��SHUPLWLQGR�FRP�LVVR�IRUPDV�GH�LQWHUYHQomR�TXH�SDUHFLDP�LPSHQViYHLV�Ki�DOJXPDV�GpFDGDV��2V�DYDQoRV�UHODWDGRV�SRU�:KLWH��������QD�SUHYLVmR�GH�DWDTXHV�HSLOpWLFRV�VmR�HVSHFLDOPHQWH�LQWHUHVVDQWHV��GDGR�R�IDWR�GH�TXH�XWLOL]DP�PRGHORV�PDWHPiWLFRV�GD�WHRULD�GR�FDRV��$�WHRULD�GR�FDRV��SRU�GHÀQLomR��HVWXGD�VLVWHPDV�GLQkPLFRV�FRPSOH[RV��PDV�HOD�RV�HVWXGD�FRP�R�REMHWLYR�GH�SUHYr�ORV�H�LQWHUYLU�VREUH�HOHV�²�RX��QDV�SDODYUDV�GH�:KLWH���������´D�WHRULD�GR�FDRV�RIHUHFH�XPD�DERUGDJHP�PDWHPiWLFD�SDUD�YHU�XP�WLSR�GH�RUGHP�HP�HYHQWRV�TXH�DQWHV�SDUHFLDP�DOHDWyULRVµ�� �����2V�DQDOLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�HVWXGDP�Ki�GpFDGDV�DV�UHODo}HV�HQVLQR-

�DSUHQGL]DJHP�FRPR�UHODo}HV�FRPSRUWDPHQWDLV�²�H�WrP��FRP�LVVR��SURGX]LGR�FRQWULEXLo}HV�UHOHYDQWHV�SDUD�R�FDPSR�HGXFDFLRQDO��H��J���+(:$5'�HW�DO���������+8%1(5��0$5,1277,���������$V�UHODo}HV�SURIHVVRU�DOXQR�VmR�FRQVLGHUD-YHOPHQWH�FRPSOH[DV�²�H��DR�FRQWUiULR�GR�TXH�HYHQWXDOPHQWH�SRGHULDP�SHQVDU�

B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultura 91

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

2OLYHLUD�HW�DO����������RV�DQDOLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�HVWmR�FLHQWHV�GH�TXH�RV�SUREOHPDV�HGXFDFLRQDLV�QmR�VH�HVJRWDP�QD�VLWXDomR�GH�VDOD�GH�DXOD��HQYROYHP�FRQGLo}HV�PDWHULDLV��VLWXDo}HV�H[WUDFODVVH�QD�YLGD�GH�DOXQRV�H�SURIHVVRUHV��JHVWmR�HGXFDFLRQDO��FXUUtFXORV��UHODo}HV�HFRQ{PLFDV�H�SROtWLFDV�LQWHUQDV�H�H[WHUQDV�jV�LQVWLWXLo}HV�HGXFDFLRQDLV��HQWUH�RXWURV�IDWRUHV��2V�UHVXOWDGRV�GH�TXDOTXHU�DomR�GH�XP�DQDOLVWD�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�QR�FDPSR�HGXFDFLRQDO�HVWmR��REYLDPHQWH��VXMHLWRV�D�DOJXP�JUDX�GH�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH��0DV�FDVR�WDLV�UHVXOWDGRV�QmR�VHMDP�os esperados, cabe reavaliar o planejamento de acordo com os dados disponíveis

H�DOWHUDU�DVSHFWRV�HYHQWXDOPHQWH�UHOHYDQWHV�GD�UHODomR�HQVLQR�DSUHQGL]DJHP�²�H��VH�SRVVtYHO�H�QHFHVViULR��GH�RXWUDV�YDULiYHLV�TXH�DIHWDP�HVVD�UHODomR��2�TXH�QmR�FDEH��RX�QmR�GHYHULD�FDEHU��p�D�SDUDOLVDomR�GLDQWH�GD�FRPSOH[LGDGH�GD�VLWXDomR�e de sua relativa imprevisibilidade.

Conclusão

3DUD�RV�DQDOLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR��FRPR�SDUD�TXDOTXHU�FLHQWLVWD��p�yEYLR�TXH�TXDOTXHU�LQWHUYHQomR��HP�SHVVRDV�RX�JUXSRV�GH�SHVVRDV��SRGH�WHU�UHVXOWDGRV�GLIHUHQWHV�GRV�HVSHUDGRV��,VVR�FDEH�WDPEpP�SDUD�R�SODQHMDPHQWR�FXOWXUDO��FRPR�6NLQQHU�VHPSUH�UHFRQKHFHX��´3RGHPRV�HVWDU�FHUWRV�GH�TXH�PXLWRV�SDVVRV�QR�SODQHMDPHQWR�FLHQWtÀFR�GH�SDGU}HV�FXOWXUDLV�SURGX]LUmR�FRQVHTXrQFLDV�LPSUHYLVWDVµ������������������S�������$QDOLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWD-PHQWR��GDGD�VXD�IRUPDomR�H[SHULPHQWDO��HVWmR�SUHSDUDGRV�SDUD�OLGDU�FRP�WDO�LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH��(OHV�QmR�WrP�D�REULJDomR�GH�DFHUWDU�VHPSUH��GH�HVFROKHU�FDPLQKRV�À[RV�RX�GH�FRQÀUPDU�GRXWULQDV�SRU�PHLR�GRV�UHVXOWDGRV�GH�VXD�DWXDomR��0DV�HOHV��FHUWDPHQWH��WrP�PDLV�VXFHVVR�QR�TXH�ID]HP�SRU�QmR�DEULU�PmR�GD�SUHYLVmR��GR�SODQHMDPHQWR�H�GD�DYDOLDomR�GH�VHXV�UHVXOWDGRV�

1mR�Ki�QHQKXPD�G~YLGD�TXDQWR�DR�IDWR�GH�TXH�RV�DPELHQWHV�FULDGRV�SHODV�FXOWXUDV�KXPDQDV�WrP�UHYHODGR�SURJUHVVLYD�FRPSOH[LGDGH�²�PDV��DR�FRQWUiULR�GR�TXH�VXJHUHP�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO�� ��������WDO�IDWR�QmR�WHP�SDVVDGR�GHVSHUFHELGR�SHORV�DQDOLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR��4XDOTXHU�FRQWULEXLomR�TXH�DMXGH�D�FRPSUHHQGHU�HVVD�FRPSOH[LGDGH�H�VHXV�HIHLWRV�p�PXLWR�EHP�YLQGD��H�WDO�WUDEDOKR�GHYH�VHU�SHUPDQHQWH��FRQIRUPH�DV�FXOWXUDV�VH�FRPSOH[LÀFDP��LJXDOPHQWH�R�GHYHP�ID]HU�DV�DQiOLVHV�FXOWXUDLV��2V�DQDOLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQ-

WR�ID]HP�SDUWH�GHVVH�HVIRUoR��H�VDEHP�WDPEpP�GD�LPSRUWkQFLD�GH�GLDORJDU�FRP�RXWURV�VDEHUHV�D�ÀP�GH�HQULTXHFHU�VXDV�DQiOLVHV��R�TXH�WHP�DFRQWHFLGR�FRP�HVSHFLDO�IUHTXrQFLD�QR�FDPSR�GDV�DQiOLVHV�FXOWXUDLV��',775,&+��������0(/2��'(�526(��������7285,1+2���������

'HYHULD�VHU�yEYLR�TXH�QLQJXpP�SRGH�VH�DUURJDU�R�FRQKHFLPHQWR�FRP-

SOHWR�GH�WRGDV�DV�YDULiYHLV�TXH�DIHWDP�R�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�KXPDQR��$�DOWHU-QDWLYD��GLDQWH�GLVVR��p�DSURIXQGDU�FRQWLQXDPHQWH�DV�SUiWLFDV�GH�SHVTXLVD�H�R�GLiORJR�HQWUH�VDEHUHV��H�p�QHVVD�SRVWXUD�TXH�D�DQiOLVH�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�WHP�

92 Alexandre Dittrich

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

investido ao longo de sua história. Os analistas do comportamento jamais se

SUHWHQGHUDP�GHWHQWRUHV�GH�YHUGDGHV�DEVROXWDV��RX�GH�VROXo}HV�LQIDOtYHLV�SDUD�RV�SUREOHPDV�KXPDQRV��&DEH��SRUWDQWR��HVFODUHFHU�DRV�OHLWRUHV�GH�2OLYHLUD�HW�DO���������TXH�D�GHVFULomR�GH�6NLQQHU�RX�GRV�DQDOLVWDV�GR�FRPSRUWDPHQWR�FRPR�UHSUHVHQWDQWHV�GH�XP�´SVHXGRPHVVLDQLVPR�SVLFROyJLFR�FLHQWLÀFLVWDµ�QmR�p�XP�UHWUDWR��PDV�XPD�FDULFDWXUD�

Referências

BEHAVIOR AND SOCIAL ISSUES.�&KLFDJR��,/��8QLYHUVLW\�RI �,OOLQRLV�²�%HKDYLRULVWV�IRU�Social Responsibility, 1991-.

&$/':(//��-HDQ��2·'5,6&2//��7KLPRW\��*��´:KDW�FDXVHG�WKH�*UHDW�'HSUHVVLRQ"µ�,Q��Social Education,�Y������S����������������'LVSRQtYHO�HP��KWWS���ZZZ�PSVD]�RUJ�UPKV�VWDII�M[FROOXPV�FODVV��DS��ÀOHV�ZKDWBFDXVHGBWKHBJ�G�B�SGI!��$FHVVR�HP�����MDQ��������',0,'-,$1��6RQD��+2//21��6WHYHQ�'���'2%621��.HLWK�6���6&+0$/,1*��.DUHQ�%���.2-

+/(1%(5*��5REHUW�-���$'',6��0LFKDHO�(���HW�DO��´5DQGRPL]HG�WULDO�RI �EHKDYLRUDO�DFWLYDWLRQ��FRJQLWLYH�WKHUDS\��DQG�DQWLGHSUHVVDQW�PHGLFDWLRQ�LQ�WKH�DFXWH�WUHDWPHQW�RI �DGXOWV�ZLWK�PDMRU�GHSUHVVLRQ�µ�,Q� Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,�Y������S�����������������',775,&+��$OH[DQGUH��´$�VREUHYLYrQFLD�GDV�FXOWXUDV�p�VXÀFLHQWH�HQTXDQWR�YDORU�QD�pWLFD�EHKDYLRULVWD�UDGLFDO"µ�,Q��+��-��*XLOKDUGL��1��&��GH�$JXLUUH��RUJV����Sobre comportamento e cognição�²�YRO������H[SRQGR�D�YDULDELOLGDGH��6DQWR�$QGUp��63��������(6(7HF��S��������',775,&+��$OH[DQGUH��´6REUHYLYrQFLD�RX�FROSVR"�%��)��6NLQQHU��-��0��'LDPRQG�H�R�GHVWLQR�GDV�FXOWXUDV�µ�3VLFRORJLD��5HÁH[mR�H�&UtWLFD��Y������S�����������������)$17,12��(GPXQG����������´-XGJPHQW�DQG�GHFLVLRQ�PDNLQJ��EHKDYLRUDO�DSSURDFKHV�µ�,Q��The Behavior Analyst,�Y������S�����������������)$17,12��(GPXQG��520$129,&+��3DXO��´7KH�HIIHFW�RI �FRQGLWLRQHG�UHLQIRUFHPHQW�UDWH�RQ�FKRLFH��D�UHYLHZ�µ�,Q��-RXUQDO�RI �WKH�([SHULPHQWDO�$QDO\VLV�RI �%HKDYLRU��Y������p. 409-421 (2007).

+(:$5'��:LOOLDP�/���+(521��7LPRWK\�(���1(()��1DQF\�$���3(7(5621��6WHSKDQLH�0���6$,1$72��'LDQH�0���&$57/('*(��*ZHQGRO\Q��*$5'1(5�,,,��5DOSK��3(7(5621��/OR\G�'���+(56+��6XVDQ�%���'$5',*��-LOO�&���RUJV����,Q� Focus on behavior analysis in education:

DFKLHYHPHQWV��FKDOOHQJHV��DQG�RSSRUWXQLWLHV��8SSHU�6DGGOH�5LYHU��1-��3UHQWLFH�+DOO�������+8%1(5��0DULD�0DUWKD�&RVWD��0$5,1277,��0��Análise do comportamento para a educação: contribuições recentes��6DQWR�$QGUp��(6(7HF�������-$0(6��+DUROG��The end of globalization�� OHVVRQV�IURP�WKH�*UHDW�'HSUHVVLRQ��+DUYDUG��0$��+DUYDUG�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV�������0$<(5��*��5R\��68/=(5�$=$52))��%HWK��:$//$&(��0LFKHOOH��´$FKLHYLQJ�ODVWLQJ�EHKD-YLRU�FKDQJH�WKURXJK�EHKDYLRU�DQDO\VLV�µ�,Q��*��5��0D\HU��%��6XO]HU�$]DURII��0��:DOODFH��RUJV����Behavior analysis for lasting change.����HG��&RUQZDOO�RQ�+XGVRQ��1<��6ORDQ�3XEOLVKLQJ��������S������'LVSRQtYHO�HP���KWWS���ZZZ�EHKDYLRU�RUJ�UHVRXUFHV�����SGI!��$FHVVR�HP�����jan. 2013.

0(/2��&DPLOD�0XFKRQ�GH��'(�526(��-~OLR�&HVDU�&RHOKR��´6REUHYLYrQFLD�GDV�FXOWXUDV�HP�6NLQQHU��XP�GLiORJR�FRP�R�PDWHULDOLVPR�FXOWXUDO�GH�+DUULV�µ�,Q��Psicologia: Teoria e Pes-quisa, Y������S�����������������

B. F. Skinner sobre previsão e controle no planejamento cultura 93

(VWXGRV�GH�5HOLJLmR��Y������Q��������������MXO��GH]���������,661�,PSUHVVR����������;�²�(OHWU{QLFR�����������

0,//��-RKQ�6WXDUW� Utilitarismo��6mR�3DXOR��63��,OXPLQXUDV��������7UDEDOKR�RULJLQDO�SXEOL-FDGR�HP������025(,5$��0iUFLR�%RUJHV��Org.). Comportamento e práticas culturais. Brasília, DF.

,QVWLWXWR�:DOGHQ���������'LVSRQtYHO�HP���KWWS���ZZZ�ZDOGHQ��FRP�EU�OLYURVZ��SGI�LZ�BPRUHLUDB����B�HGBET�SGI!��$FHVVR�HP�����MDQ�������08/,&.��3DWULFN�6���/$1'(6��6DUD��.$17(5��-RQDWKDQ�:� “&RQWH[WXDO�EHKDYLRU�WKHUD-SLHV�LQ�WKH�WUHDWPHQW�RI �376'��$�5HYLHZ�µ�,Q��The International Journal of Behavioral Consultation and Therapy, v. 7: p. 23-32 (2011).

2/,9(,5$��&OiXGLR�,YDQ�GH��%5,72��+pULFD�/DQGL��$%(��+\UDWD�+\NHQR��5(,6��0DUFRV�&ULVWLDQR�GRV��/(,7(��´6RFLHGDGH�GD� LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH��VXEMHWLYLGDGH�DEHUWD�H�VLVWHPD�GH�FUHQoDV�UHOLJLRVDV��XPD�FUtWLFD�DR�SODQHMDPHQWR�FXOWXUDO�GH�%��)��6NLQQHUµ��,Q��Estudos de Religião��Y������S���������������3257(5��-HIIUH\�)���63$7(6��&��5LFKDUG��60,7+$0��6HDQ��´%HKDYLRUDO�DFWLYDWLRQ�JURXS�WKHUDS\�LQ�SXEOLF�PHQWDO�KHDOWK�VHWWLQJV��$�SLORW�LQYHVWLJDWLRQ�µ�,Q��Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, v. 35: p. 297-301 (2004).

6$03$,2��$QJHOR�$XJXVWR�6LOYD��$1'(5<��0DULD�$PDOLD�3LH�$ELE��´&RPSRUWDPHQWR�VRFLDO��SURGXomR�DJUHJDGD�H�SUiWLFD�FXOWXUDO��XPD�DQiOLVH�FRPSRUWDPHQWDO�GH�IHQ{PHQRV�VRFLDLV�µ�,Q��Psicologia: Teoria e Pesquisa,�Y������S�����������������6.,11(5��%XUUKXV�)UHGHULF��Science and human behavior. 1HZ�<RUN��1<��0DFPLOODQ��������6.,11(5��%XUUKXV�)UHGHULF��´)UHHGRP�DQG�WKH�FRQWURO�RI �PHQ�µ�,Q��%��)��6NLQQHU� Cumu-lative record:�D�VHOHFWLRQ�RI �SDSHUV��1HZ�<RUN��1<��$SSOHWRQ�&HQWXU\�&URIWV��������S�������6.,11(5��%XUUKXV�)UHGHULF��´6RPH�LVVXHV�FRQFHUQLQJ�WKH�FRQWURO�RI �KXPDQ�EHKDYLRU�µ�In: B. F. Skinner. Cumulative record: a selection of papers��1HZ�<RUN��1<��$SSOHWRQ-

�&HQWXU\�&URIWV��������S��������6.,11(5��%XUUKXV�)UHGHULF��About behaviorism��1HZ�<RUN��1<��$OIUHG�$��.QRSI�������6.,11(5��%XUUKXV�)UHGHULF��´:KDWHYHU�KDSSHQHG�WR�SV\FKRORJ\�DV�WKH�VFLHQFH�RI �EHKDYLRU"µ�In: American Psychologist, v. 42��S�����������������6.,11(5��%XUUKXV�)UHGHULF��´6HOHomR�SRU�FRQVHT�rQFLDV�µ�,Q��Revista Brasileira de Terapia Comportamental e Cognitiva��YRO�����S������������������'LVSRQtYHO�HP���KWWS���SHSVLF�EYVDOXG�RUJ�SGI�UEWFF�Y�Q��Y�Q�D���SGI!��$FHVVR�HP����� MDQ��������7UDEDOKR�RULJLQDO�SXEOLFDGR�HP������7285,1+2��(PPDQXHO�=DJXU\��Subjetividade e relações comportamentais.

6mR�3DXOR��63��3DUDGLJPD�������:+,7(��9LFWRULD��´&KDRV�WKHRU\�KHOSV�WR�SUHGLFW�HSLOHSWLF�VHL]XUHV�µ�,Q��&RPSOH[LW\�'LJHVW��n.

����������'LVSRQtYHO�HP���KWWS���FRPGLJ�XQDP�P[�SULQWBDUWLFOH�SKS"LGBDUWLFOH ���!��Acesso em: 20 jan. 2013.

Submetido em: 2-5-2013

$FHLWR�HP������������