A MultimodalAnalysis of Disney Animated Movies' Posters
-
Upload
khangminh22 -
Category
Documents
-
view
0 -
download
0
Transcript of A MultimodalAnalysis of Disney Animated Movies' Posters
Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences (PJSS)
Vol. 41, No. 2 (2021), pp. 421-432
De/constructing Feminist-Ideology:
A MultimodalAnalysis of Disney Animated Movies’ Posters
Muhammad Akbar Sajid Assistant professor NUML, Multan Campus
Hafsa Qadir Buzdar Lecturer, Department of English NUML Multan Campus
Email: [email protected]
Abstract: In this ultra-modern age of 3-D technology, visual language has
become aprevalent and pervasive phenomenon. The use of visual
image/imagery is obvious in almost every field of our modern life i.e.,
fashion, food, advertising, film, art, and entertainment, etc. Fascinated
by the omnipresence of the visual image/imagery, in general; and being
curious about its deliberate use,the present study aims to investigate
the maneuvering of visual language in promoting the feminist
ideologies in the field of Movie Advertising. More specifically, its main
objective is to confirm the application of the multimodal social semiotic
approach as proposed by Kress and van Leeuwen (2006). For this
purpose, three Disney animated movie posters (i.e., Moana, 2016;
Brave, 2012; & The Princess and the Frog, 2009) have been analyzed
by employing Kress and van Leeuwen’s (2006) model of multimodality
as an analytical tool and the feminist ideas of Julia Kristeva and Simon
de Beauvoir (1949) as a general theoretical framework.To validate the
findings of semiotic analysis, the researchers have also utilized
Kruger’s (2000) model to analyze the data gathered through
conducting two focus group discussions among the students of
linguistics and other disciplines. The analysis of the data reveals that
there isstrengthening evidence of the maneuvering of the visual
language, and has corroborated the operative power of Kress and van
Leeuwen’s brand of social semiotics.
Keywords: Visual language, Feminisms, Ideology, Multimodality, Social
Semiotics, Language of visuality/Visuality of language
I. Introduction Animation has played a role of vital significance in connecting the people of all
age groups. It is because that with the help of animated movies stories can be told in a
uniquely and easily manner which sometimes writing and live-action filmscannot.The
significance of animated movies is twofold. On one hand, they provide entertainment to
the viewers and simultaneously reinforce social ideologies through their cinematic
reflections. They represent dominant political ideologies about gender stereotypes. At the
same time, they are laced with social and cultural messages about the normative structure
of gender in a particular social set up. Animated cartoons most often carry jazz ideology
with them.
422 Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences Vol. 41, No. 2
Bignell (2013) opines that Visual narratives consist of visual signs that include
all images and graphics that are seen on the screen and aural signs consist of speech
sound and music which cinema screen shows. (Ross, 2014) argues that significance of
visual landscape has increased many folds in this ultra-modern age of 3-D technology,
because of word-picture conjunction. Therefore, visual, and verbal practices have
become a social praxis. In certain domains visual language is considered more effective,
powerful, descriptive, and emotive‖ (Lloyd, 2015).
Van der Laan (2018) conducted a research about knowing the effects of
animated movies on the behaviour of the children who regularly watch them. The
research mainly focused on determining that how Disney animated movies can inspire
children to help others immediately to others by watching the hero doing so. The data for
the research was collected from 113 Dutch children. The clips from Disney animated
movies were shown to the children. Media semiotic and linguistic analysis approach was
used to analyse the data. The research contends that that popular culture media discourses
play a significant role in shaping the character and world-view of the viewers.
UNICEF, UK‘s (2020) report about the function of animated movies and its
effects on young children and adult highlights that message imparted through using visual
and verbal means of communication go a long way in preserving a message in the
memory of viewers. The data for this research was collected from 62 pictures displayed
at a school. These pictures were about human nature in different spheres of life. The
illustrations highlighted that male characters are bossy and disrespectful to towards
female characters. Whereas, female friends are more encouraging to help other in trouble.
The pictures also highlighted the significance of parents‘ role in the upbringing and
education of their children. The research contends that message imparted through
animated movies and still pictures remains in the memory for longer time.
In this regard, the present study intends to decode visual practices employed in
the posters of mentioned animated movies by employing Kress and van Leeuwen‘s
(2006) model of multimodality as an analytical tool and the feminist ideas of Julia
Kristeva and Simon de Beauvoir (1949) as a general theoretical framework, to know how
visual and verbal practices in popular culture are employed to propagate desired
ideologies to the target audience. The research answers are the following questions.
How has the concept of feminism (white/black) been challenged discursively
through the posters ofThe Princess and the Frog(2009) and Brave(2012)?
What social semiotic resources have been used, to convey desired ideologies
through the selected movieposters?
II. Language of Visuality/Visuality of Language Lively (1987) regards language as a museum present in human heads. It is so
built into the way people live that it has become an axiom of being human (Bolton,
1994). Saussure (1959) arguesthat language is just like a sheet of paper with its front and
back. According to him thought is the front and the sound the back; one cannot cut the
front without cutting the back at the same time. However, Kraus (2001) asserts that
language is the mother of thought. Fairclough (1995) believes that language embodies
ideological power. Wodak (2001) claimed that there is power within and behind the
language. Kress and van Leeuwen (1996, 2006; Kress, 2011, Kress, Garcia & van
423
Leeuwen, 1997) argued that not only we communicate verbally rather through other
means as well including images, gestures, body language, proxemics, color, movements,
space, and time. Danesi, (2017) firmly believes that non-verbal means of communication
are more powerful.
Discourse analysis mostly focuses on text and its texture Multi-modal social
semiotic approach attempts to focus on all the representational modes involved in the
formation of multi-model texts to analyze them linguistically and semiotically (Kress,
Garcia & van Leeuwen, 1997). In this regard the following six assumptions have been
outlined by Kress, Garcia, and van Leeuwen (1997):
Every text embodies different modes in the process of meaning-making.
Texts (linguistic and semiotics) are culturally oriented.
To decode the text, one needs to become competent in different modes of
literacy.
Power relations are reproduced and exercised through texts.
Signs and symbols are designed with the mutual consent of writers and readers.
One requires the knowledge of culture and history to decode the texts
comprehensively.
According to Kress and van Leeuwen (2006), the first three assumptions were
successfully addressed by the classical semioticians,whereas the rest are being studied by
social semiotic theorists.The present study draws upon the above-stated assumptions to
analyze the movie posters at linguistic and semiotic levels.
III. Methodological Perspectives The present research utilizes a qualitative research design because it isan
ideological analysis of the selected Disney animated movie posters carrying the concept
of de/construction of feminist ideology. The data for the present research has been
collected from the posters of the four (04) animated movies namely, Frozen, Brave,
Moana, andThe Princess and the Frog. These four animated movies deal with the concept
of black/white feminism. Out of four two movies, posters such as Brave and The Princess
and the frog were randomly selected to analyze at linguistic and semiotic levels by
employing the devised research medal.
Research Modal
Table 1: Adapted from: Kress & van Leeuwen (2006)
Contact
Image Act Offer (Information)
Demand (goods/services)
Gaze Direct (degrees of Engagement)
Indirect (degrees of Disengagement)
Social Distance
Size of Frame Close (Intimate/Personal)
Medium (Social)
Long (Impersonal)
Attitude
Subjective Image
Horizontal angle (degrees of Involvement & Detachment)
Vertical angle (degrees of Power to the viewer, to the represented participants, or relation of equality)
Objective Image Action Orientation (frontal angle)
424 Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences Vol. 41, No. 2
Interactive meanings
Knowledge Orientation (top-down angle)
Modality
Colour Color saturation
Color differentiation
Color modulation
Objective Image Action Orientation (frontal angle)
Knowledge Orientation (top-down angle)
Modality
Colour Color saturation
Color differentiation
Color modulation
Contextualization Absence of background
Full detail
Representation Maximum abstraction
Maximum representation
Depth Absence of depth
Maximally deep perspective
Illumination Full representation of light and shade
Absence of light and shade
Brightness Maximum brightness
Black and white or shades of light grey and dark grey
Coding Orientation
Technological
Sensory
Abstract
Naturalistic
IV. Brave (2012) Descriptively, in the movie poster of Brave (2012), the total focus is given to
Princess Marida (see Fig, 4.2 below). She is shown to be stretching an arrow in the bow
in an aiming position. She is dressed in a flowing dress of dark blues.Her bright fire-red
hair is disheveled all around her face, neck, and her back. She is shown in the background
of a dark jungle lighted with an ominous light. Describing from the position of the
viewers, Princess Marida is shown to be occupying more of the left side of the poster.
Just above her head, right at the upper edge of the poster, the title of the movie ―BRAVE‖
is imprinted in a glossy style.
Ideologically, the very first point to be noted about this movie poster is its
appropriation of the traditional gender-specific notion of ―Bravery‖. According to
Beauvoir (1949), throughout the entire history, man is projected as brave, courageous,
valiant, heroic, bold, daring, fearless, and plucky, while a woman is described as timid,
weak, faint-hearted, deserter, and quitter. Through these adjectives, man had enslaved
woman through the ages. However, it is obvious in the visual that this concept is,
now,appropriated in a new dimension and is associated with a female i.e. Princess
Marida. In contrast to the poster of Moana (2016), where she was projected as a warrior-
like with an oar in her lefthand, in this poster, Marida, becomes a warrior armed with a
bow and arrow.
Taking about the traditional association of the word ‗Brave‘, Beauvoir (1949)
has pertinently exposed that:
Clearly, a man wants woman‘senslavement when fantasizing himself as a brave
benefactor, liberator, orredeemer; if Sleeping Beauty is to be awakened, she must be
425
sleeping;to have a captive princess, there must be ogres and dragons. Woman in the
history has mostly been represented as commodity and dependent. Most often her identity
is shown dependent. She is there at the mercy of a brave and strong man to come and to
rescue her. As a result, she was supposed to be beautiful and loyal. Her fate lies in
accepting the brave man as everything for her.
Figure 1: Movie poster of Brave (2012)
However, the movie poster under analysis challenges the constructed gender
stereotypes. It is a female with whom the word ―BRAVE‖ is associated. She is shown to
be enraged. Her fire-red disheveled hair is the symbol of warrior-like anger—a symbol of
her asserted emancipation. She is directly gazing at the viewers with sharp, focused, and
resolved looks, just in the position of aiming her target—an attacking position.
Semiotically, here, again the image act is that of demand. In the plot of the movie, she
demands her right of rejecting the suitors by portraying that she is eligible to compete for
her hand as the first-born of Clan Dunbroch. She defeats each of her suitors in an archery
contest, shaming the other clans.
Femininely, this is quite ideological. Beauvoir (1949) has disclosed that
throughout history, marriage and maternity have been both worshipped and reviled: the
mother is supposed to inculcate the ideology of being a slave to the husband to her
daughter/s that a woman‘s wellbeing depends on her obeying her husband by all means.
However, in the movie poster of Brave (2012), the traditional gender stereotypes are
deliberately appropriated with the visual archer-persona of Marida. She shoots the arrow
in an archery contest to assert her individuality. This is the novelty of her situation and
426 Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences Vol. 41, No. 2
this movie poster that attracts the viewers to the counter -discourse of individualized
maternity and brave femininity.
Apart from the demanding image act, the discourse models of the viewers are
positioned and re-positioned through the size of the frame and subjectivity of the image.
In this context, the very first point to be noted in the visual is the size and place given to
the archer Marida. Kress and van Leeuwen (2006) have called it salience of the image.
The bigger the size the more is the salience (Kress & van Leeuwen, 2006). It is obvious
in the poster that the highest salience is given to Marida encompassing from the upper
half of the poster to the whole bottom of it. All the other represented elements—i.e., the
dark green bushes, trees, and a ghost-like black bear with its shining eyes—are
modulated to be blurred. A Central focus is given to the brave Princess. Producers of this
poster want to direct the attention of the viewers towards the new ‗BRAVE‘ of the
modern era i.e. a female.
Moreover, Marida is depicted from the frontal high angle of the camera with a
projectedlow shot. This is quite significant. Kress and van Leeuwen have exposed that
such a low shot put the represented participantin a position of power. The power angle is
further intensified by her vertical bending projection provided by an aiming position. So,
the archer Marida is shown to be visually empowered by Disney Pixar. She is projected
with a rich contrast to the back-grounded image of the blurred black bear. Such detailed
contextualization enhances the ideological appropriation of the word ‗BRAVE‘—i.e.,
Marida is no more afraid of the jungle and its ghost-like wild creature. Moreover, the
black bear is depicted with a long shot, thus, its social distance is enlarged by the
producer of the poster, while Princess Marida is portrayed with a low shot, and thus, she
is shown to be more social by diminishing her social distance and increasing her size of
the frame.
In addition to this, all the markers of modality are slanted towards Princess
Marida. For example, all the color saturation and color modulation blue (i.e. different
shades of blue) is used to enhance the projection of Marida. A Fully detailed
contextualizedbackground is provided behind her figure. Right side of her face and hair
are more illuminated than the other represented elements. The Brightness of her hair
captures the focused concentration and responsiveness of the viewers. Thus, the visual
modality of the movie poster is increased enough to attract the viewers and change their
discourse model about bravery and femininity.
Rhetorically, this phenomenon is usually known as visual coherence—an
inherent quality of Augmented Reality in which ―the goal is to have visual augmentations
blend with the real world in a visually coherent manner‖. Turner has defined visual
coherence as ―the extent to which visual elements of a composition tied together with
color, shape, image, lines of sight, theme, etc.‖ (Turner, 2009). The same visual
coherence can be detected in the present visual, as various shades of blue and the dark
blues are modulated to direct the attention of the viewers towards the multi-modal
association of the word ‗BRAVE‘ and its personification i.e., Marida. Kress and van
Leeuwen (2006) have posited that the higher modalities of the visual, the more
powerfully aestheticize the audience to change their focus of attention.
427
In terms of Compositional meanings,another thing to note is the information
value of the movie poster. Kress and van Leeuwen (2006) have discussed the information
value of the page in the terms of dimensions of visual space (as given Fig, 4.3 below).
According to these dimensions, something that lies in the Center is taken as the nucleus
of the information on which all the other elements are in some sense subservient and the
upper left corner is ideal space for the New Information (see Fig, 4.3), while the upper
right corner is ideal space for already known Given Information.
Figure 2: The dimensions of visual space by Kress and van Leeuwen (2006)
Keeping the above dimensions in mind, it becomes obvious that the word
―BRAVE‖—in the upper side of the poster—is an already known Given Information;
however, the position of Marida—the center of the poster—is its newly appropriated
female-association, thus, a New Information.
Thus, in the whole of the movie poster, the visual language is manipulated
considerably to encode the social meanings of the gendered ideologies. The already
known gender stereotypes of masculinity, bravery, and archery are deconstructed to
position the discourse models of the viewers towards the novel discourse of femininity
through the visualof language.
V. The Princess and the Frog (2009) The visual and verbal practices employed in the following movie poster give a
central focus to a once-a-waitress princess, Tiana, surrounded by a multitude of other
characters (see Fig, 4.4 below). She is smiling broadly and looking towards the turned-
into-frog Prince, Naveen. The frog-prince, Naveen is also smiling broadly looking at the
viewers. However, his body-angles are projected towards the princess, Tiana. In the
lowest part of the poster, under all the characters, the title name of the movie ―The
Princess and the Frog‖ is placed with a larger font size given to the words ―Princess‖ and
―Frog‖ than ‗Disney‘.
428 Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences Vol. 41, No. 2
Figure 3: Movie poster of The Princess and the Frog (2009)
Ideologically, this movie poster deals with the ‗Black Feminism‘— ―an
ideological separation from white feminism‖ (Breines, 2002); and appropriates the race-
specific stereotypical nexus of ‗Beauty‘ and ‗Princess‘. Traditionally, the concept of
beauty has always been associated with ‗white beauty‘ only. And all the princesses had
always been white, delicate, and, hence, beautiful. This narrative has been naturalized
throughout human history dating from Romans and Greeks. No one could imagine that a
black or a bit black or a wheatish color may also be used to describe the beauty of a
‗princess‘. Thus, the concept of beauty became a questionable racist notion, as the notion
of ‗white beauty‘ marginalized all the races except the white one (Hill-Collins, 1990).
Therefore, in this postmodern age of ideology, the counter- narrative of ‗black beauty‘ is
being propagated through various means of mass media. The same narrative is being
promoted in the present visual.
Analytically, in contrast to the movie posters of Moana (2016) and Brave
(2012)—in which all the central female characters were gazing directly at the viewers, —
here, the black princess Tiana is not gazing directly at the viewers. Her black beautiful
face and her eyeballs are noticeably turned towards the frog-prince Naveen. So, in sharp
contrast to the demand image act of the above two movie posters, this poster presents the
image act of an offer. According to Kress and van Leeuwen (2006), the represented
participants in the image act of offer address us indirectly. No contact is made. They do
not want the viewers to establish any relationship with them. Rather they are presented,
―as items of information, objects of contemplation, impersonally, as though they were
specimens in a display case.‖ Thus, the black princess Tiana is presented to the viewers
as the specimen of ‗black beauty‘ and as an object of contemplation that a princess can
also be a black one—or at least that a black princess exists. This is also to be confirmed
429
by the bending gesture of frog-prince, Naveen. He is happily gazing at the viewers
making the image act of demand. Consequently, it seems that he is demanding the
viewers to have a look at his black beauty. The overall message becomes: Look! This
black beauty is the Princess. How skillfully the visual language is maneuvered to bear the
burden of ideology in this movie poster!
Apart from this, another contrasting point to be noted in this poster is the
placement of the title of the movie in the visual field of the poster. In the above-analyzed
two movie posters, the title of the movies is placed in the upper portion of the poster,
while in this poster title is given at the bottom of the poster just below the princess in the
central position of the visual field.
According to the vertical dimensions of the information value of the image
proposed by Kress and van Leeuwen (2006, see Fig, 4.5 below), the place, where the title
―The Princess and the Frog‖ is positioned, is the ideal space for New Information of the
image. Hence, the black princess, Tiana is presented as New Information and as a figure
to be idealized by the girls.
Figure 4:The Information value of the visual image (Kress & van Leeuwen, 2006)
Keeping in view the dimensions of the visual space of Fig, 4.3 above (Kress &
van Leeuwen (2006), it is quite easy to notice that the black princess Tiana is depicted as
the nucleus of the movie poster. She is marked by a circle, surrounded by various other
characters and elements. Moreover, the phenomenon of visual coherence can also be
noticed here, as most of the other surrounded characters are depicted in the same shades
Margin
Margin
Ideal
Ideal
Given
New
Centre
Margin
Margin
Ideal
Ideal
Given
New
430 Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences Vol. 41, No. 2
of the black color of which the princess is meant to be portrayed. Even the face of the
blonde female, shown in the lower right of the poster, is also modulated with mixed tints
of black and white. Thus, the black princess Tiana is presented as a nucleus of
information and focus of attention for the viewers.
Her meant-to-be idealized figure is further enhanced through the other modality
markers of the visual: The black princess is presented against the colorful sharp
background of sun-setting villas. She is metaphorically presented as the moon of the
coming night, as in the background sun will set shortly. It is she who will shine after the
sunset. In contrast to the other corners of the movie poster, the whole place where Tiana
is placed is relatively much more illuminated. Her tiara, cheeks, teeth, necklace, arms and
the dress all are sparkling with the color of moon-lit light. Thus, she is presented as an
ideal figure. A counter-specimen of the whitely beautiful princess.
The overall impression of the image is that the producers of the poster have
deconstructed the race-specific stereotype of white princess by drawing on various
linguistic and semiotic resources and, have been very effective in encoding the new
feministic social signifiers and the ideological signifieds.
VI. Focus Group Findings One of the objections that areusually leveled against semiological analysis is
that it privileges semiotician‘s perception about the visuals and the general perception is
altogether excluded. In order to meet this objection, the researcher has conducted two
focused group discussions on the selected movie posters to incorporate participants‘
views to validate their analysis. Some of the remarks of the participants from the two
groups have been mentioned in the following section. They are as under:
―I think the movie posters represent an element of change. The production of
these animated movies on the surface seems for the younger generation but they have
two-fold appeal. They are highly ideological and want to shape the tender minds in a
way. There is a message for the grown-up people as well. On one hand, they provide
entertainment and on the other, they embody gendered and cultural ideologies in them.‖
―Through these movies, an attempt has been made to make female gender more
liberal. The producers want to make our young generation westernized and this is
proving harmful for us because of our cultural and religious constraints.‖
―Change should be there but that can be embraced by us staying within our
limits. However, female fender should be empowered but not in western style.”
The remarks of the focus group participants illustrate that women should be
empowered but the western style of women‘s emancipation is not acceptable for us
because of cultural and religious constraints. However, the stereotypical marginalization
of women from the mainstream power should be discouraged. In this way, the
researchers‘ analysis of the visuals was validated up to great extent.
431
VII. Conclusion Based on the analysis of the data the research concludes that Disney animated
movie posters are an important genre for the propagation of desired gendered ideologies
about propagating different versions of feminist ideology.These movies are meant for the
younger generation but the desired feminist ideologies are disseminated through Disney
animated movies to win general consent about being male or female at large. The study
finds thatthe movie posters are not an innocent entity to be ignored nonchalantly. They
are responsible for instilling powerful ideologies through their more interactive pattern
and structure. The study has examined that the movie posters are noticeably modulated,
both at linguistic and semiotic levels, to bear the burden of language of the visuality. The
language used in the visuals is meant to disseminate politicized versions of feminist
ideology. The very notion of the construction of feminist ideology implies that
construction and reconstruction go side by side. Everywhere female is most often
represented as commodity and sex object meant to please the male partner.
In this respect, the study has pointed out that, by employing the concept of
word-picture conjunction the posters of Brave and the Frog Princess illustrate that an
attempt has been made through the selected data to deconstruct the century‘s old
gendered notion about being a woman. Different markers of modality (like illumination,
color, depth, and brightness) are predominantly manipulated to encode the various
ideologies of liberal feminism, radical feminism, metaphysical feminism, and
blackfeminism. It is an attempt to highlight the two-fold significance of animated movies
that besides entertainment they impart desired ideologies to the target audience as well.
Consequently, the analysis of the research highlight that the visual discourse models of
the target viewers are positioned interactively to view and review their traditional
stereotypical perceptions about patriarchy and matriarchy. The last but not least, the study
has found strengthening evidence of the operative power of Kress and Van Leeuwen‘s
(1996, 2006) brand of social semiotics which claims that ideology is propagated through
various modesi.e. of representational and communicational. The findings highlight that
the Multi-model approach is significant in de/constructing feminist ideologies and
popular culture is one of the best sites for investing various ideologies including the
feminist one.
References Beauvoir, S.,ed. (1949 [c2010]) The second sex. New York: Vintage Books
Bolton, W. F. (1994). Language: An introduction. In V. P. Clark, P. A. Eschholz, & A.
F. Rosa (Eds.), Language: Introductory readings (5th
ed. , pp. 3-16). New York:
St. Martin‘s Press.
Breines, W. (2002). What's love got to do with it? White women, Black women, and
feminism in the movement years. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and
Society, 27 (pp. 1095–1133).
Danesi, M. (2017). The semiotics of emoji: the rise of visual language in the age of the
internet. London: Bloomsbury.
Fairclough, N., & Wodak, R. (1997). Critical discourse analysis. In T. A. van Dijk (Ed.),
Discourse studies: A multidisciplinary introduction (2nd
ed., pp. 258–84).
London: Sage.
Hill-Collins, P. (1990). Black feminist thought. New York: Routledge.
Kraus, K. (2001). Dicta and contradict (J. McVity, Trans.): University of Illinois Press.
432 Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences Vol. 41, No. 2
Kress, G. (2011). Discourse analysis and education: A multimodal social semiotic
approach. In R. Rogers (Ed.), An introduction to critical discourse analysis in
education (2nd
ed., pp. 205–226). New York, NY: Routledge.
Kress, G., & van Leeuwen, T. (1996). Reading images. The grammar of visual design (1st
ed.). London: Routledge.
Kress, G., & van Leeuwen, T. (2006). Reading images. The grammar of visual design(
2nd
ed.). London: Routledge.
Kress, K., Garcia, R., & van Leeuwen, T. (1997). Discourse Semiotics. In T.A. van Dijk
(Ed.), Discourse as structure and process (pp. 257-291). London: Sage
Publications.
Lloyd, H. (2015). Visual language: an education resource for primary and intermediate
teachers [online]. Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa. Accessed on:
06-10-2017, Accessed from:
https://www.tepapa.govt.nz/sites/default/files/visual_language_resource_1.pdf.
Saussure, F. de (1959). Course in general linguistics (W. Baskin, Trans.) New York, NY:
Philosophical Library. (Original work published 1916).
Turner, A. (2009). Visual coherence (online webpage). Accessed on: 06-10-2017.
Accessed from: https://www.flickr.com/photos/34385497@N06/3369078696
Wodak, R. (2001). What CDA is about—a summary of its history, important concepts,
and its developments. In R. Wodak & M. Meyer (Eds.). Methods of critical
discourse analysis (1st ed, pp. 1-13). London: Sage.