Slide 1

1KONSEPPENGEMBANGAN EKONOMI LOKAL1PENENTU DAYA SAING NASIONALSTRATEGI PERUSAHAAN, STRUKTUR, DAN PERSAINGANINDUSTRI TERKAIT DAN INDUSTRI PENDUKUNGKONDISI FAKTORKONDISI PERMINTAANMICHAEL PORTER, 19902PENENTU DAYA SAING INTERNASIONALLINGKUNGAN BISNISINDUSTRI TERKAIT DAN INDUSTRI PENDUKUNGSUMBERDAYA YG DIANUGERAHKANPERMINTAAN DOMESTIKPOLITISI DAN BIROKRATPEKERJAPARA WIRAUSAHAWANMANAGER DAN INSINYUR PROFESIONALPERISTIWA PELUANGDAYA SAING INTERNASIONALDong-Sung Cho, 199434JANGAN HAMBURKAN

SUMBERDAYA ALAM KITA,

SEBELUM RAKYATNYA

MENGERTI4PEMBANGUNAN WILAYAHTeknologiTanahSDA dan LHSDMPertanian dan PertambanganManufaktur dan JasaPeningkatan Kapabilitas (Daya Saing, Daya Tarik dan Daya Lestari)Berburu danPengumpulBerpindah dan BertaniMasyarakat MajuMasyarakat TradisionalMANAJEMEN SUMBERDAYAMasyarakat BerkembangTRANSFORMASI SOSIAL, EKONOMI DAN BUDAYA Jawa-Bali dan Sumatera Papua, Mauku, NTT Kalimantan dan NTB Sumatera, KalimantanSulawesi dan JawaSintesis danDaur UlangPrasarana66Arah Pengembangan Revitalisasi Pengembangan Ekonomi LokalPartisipatif pelibatan stakeholders kunciBottom-up Memiliki Logframe yg jelas (Heksagonal PEL)

Mengintegrasikan sistem nilai yg disepakati bersama seluruh stakeholdersTerukurTerintegrasi ke dlm SPPNBerkelanjutanFAKTOR LOKASIKELOMPOK SASARANPROSES MANAJEMENTATA PEMERINTAHANPEMBANGUNAN BERKELANJUTANKESINERGIAN DAN FOKUS KEBIJAKAN PENGEMBANGAN EKONOMI WILAYAH BERKELANJUTAN67Definisi PELWorld BankPEL sebagai proses yang dilakukan secara bersama oleh pemerintah, usahawan, dan organisasi non pemerintah untuk menciptakan kondisi yang lebih baik untuk pertumbuhan ekonomi dan penciptaan lapangan kerja di tingkat lokal. Blakely and BradshawPEL adalah proses dimana pemerintah lokal dan organsisasi masyarakat terlibat untuk mendorong, merangsang, memelihara, aktivitas usaha untuk menciptakan lapangan pekerjaanInternational Labour Organization (ILO)PEL adalah proses partisipatif yang mendorong kemitraan antara dunia usaha dan pemerintah dan masyarakat pada wilayah tertentu, yang memungkinkan kerjasama dalam perancangan dan pelaksanaan strategi pembangunan secara umum, dengan menggunakan sumber daya local dan keuntungan kompetitif dalam konteks global, dengan tujuan akhir menciptakan lapangan pekerjaan yang layak dan merangsang kegiatan ekonomi.A. H. J. HelmingPEL adalah suatu proses dimana kemitraan yang mapan antara pemerintah daerah, kelompok berbasis masyarakat, dan dunia usaha mengelola sumber daya yang ada untuk menciptakan lapangan pekerjaan dan merangsang (pertumbuhan) ekonomi pada suatu wilayah tertentu. Menekankan pada kontrol lokal, dan penggunaan potensi sumber daya manusia, kelembagaan dan sumber daya fisik. 8NoPembuat DefinisiFokusKelebihanKelemahan1.The World BankMeningkatkan daya saingPertumbuhan ekonomi yang berkelanjutanMeningkatkan kualitas pertumbuhan ekonomiBerorientasi kepada pemerataanBerorientasi bukan hanya kepada tujuan yaitu pertumbuhan ekonomi dan kesempatan kerja akan tetapi juga kepada proses Tidak dijelaskan: aspek kelokalannyaKelayakan lapangan kerjabagaimana proses pelibatan stakeholder tersebut apakah harus partisipatif atau tidak.aspek lokasi dimana PEL tersebut dilaksanakan atau terjadi.2.Blakely dan BradshawMenciptakan lapangan pekerjaanBerorientasi bukan hanya kepada tujuan akan tetapi juga kepada prosesTidak dijelaskan: Kelayakan lapangan kerja keberlanjutan dari penciptaan lapangan pekerjaan tersebut.Aspek pemerataan aspek kelokalannyabagaimana proses pelibatan stakeholder tersebut apakah harus partisipatif atau tidakTidak menjelaskan aspek lokasi9NoPembuat DefinisiFokusKelebihanKelemahan3.ILOProses harus partisipatifLokasi PEL pada wilayah tertentuMenciptakan lapangan pekerjaan yang layakMerangsang kegiatan ekonomiBerorientasi kepada output dan proses.Pelibatan stakeholder harus partisipastif Sifat kelokalan ditunjukkan dari penggunaan sumber daya localAspek lokasi ditunjukkan bahwa PEL dilakukan pada wilayah tertentu.Tidak menjelaskan keberlanjutan pembangunanaspek pemerataanaspek lokasi dimana PEL tersebut dilaksanakan atau terjadi.4.A. H. J. HelmingKemitraan antar stakeholderKontrol lokalMerangsang pertumbuhan ekonomi dan lapangan pekerjaanBerorientasi kepada output dan proses.Aspek lokasi ditunjukkan bahwa PEL dilakukan pada wilayah tertentu.Sifat kelokalan ditunjukkan dari penggunaan sumber daya lokalTidak mencantumkan keberlanjutan pembangunanTidak menjelaskan aspek pemerataanbagaimana proses pelibatan stakeholder tersebut apakah harus partisipatif atau tidakKelayakan lapangan kerja tersebut10Definisi PELBerdasarkan analisis thd kelebihan dan kelemahan dari beberapa definisi tentang PEL (a.l. Bank Dunia, ILO, Blakely & Bradshaw, dll) dan penyesuaian thd kondisi sosial, ekonomi, dan budaya masyarakat di Indonesia, PEL didefinisikan sbb. PEL adalah usaha mengoptimalkan sumber daya lokal yang melibatkan pemerintah, dunia usaha, masyarakat lokal dan organisasi masyarakat madani untuk mengembangkan ekonomi pada suatu wilayah. 1011Fokus PELDefinisi PEL tersebut memfokuskan kepada: Peningkatan kandungan lokal; Pelibatan stakeholders secara substansial dalam suatu kemitraan strategis; Peningkatan ketahanan dan kemandirian ekonomi;Pembangunan bekeberlanjutan; Pemanfaatan hasil pembangunan oleh sebagian besar masyarakat lokal; Pengembangan usaha kecil dan menengah; Pertumbuhan ekonomi yang dicapai secara inklusif; Penguatan kapasitas dan peningkatan kualitas sumber daya manusia; Pengurangan kesenjangan antar golongan masyarakat, antar sektor dan antar daerah; Pengurangan dampak negatif dari kegiatan ekonomi terhadap lingkungan.1112Dimensi PELDimensi atau batasan PEL adalah sebagai berikut:

Pengertian lokal yang terdapat dalam definisi PEL tidak merujukpada batasan wilayah administratif tetapi lebih pada peningkatan kandungan komponen lokal maupun optimalisasi pemanfaatan sumberdaya lokal.

PEL sebagai inisiatif daerah yang dilakukan secara partisipatif.

PEL menekankan pada pendekatan pengembangan bisnis, bukanpada pendekatan bantuan sosial yang bersifat karikatif.

PEL bukan merupakan upaya penanggulangan kemiskinan secara langsung.

PEL diarahkan untuk mengisi dan mengoptimalkan kegiatan ekonomiyang dilakukan berdasarkan pengembangan wilayah, pewilayahan komoditas,tata ruang, atau regionalisasi ekonomi.1213Tujuan dan Sasaran PELTerlaksananya upaya percepatan pengembangan ekonomi lokal melalui pelibatan pemerintah, dunia usaha, masyarakat lokal, dan organisasi masyarakat madani dalam suatu proses yang partisipatif.Terbangun dan berkembangnya kemitraan dan aliansi strategis dalam upaya percepatan pengembangan ekonomi lokal diantara stakeholder secara sinergis.Terbangunnya sarana dan prasarana ekonomi yang mendukung upaya percepatan pengembangan ekonomi lokal.Terwujudnya pengembangan dan pertumbuhan UKM secara ekonomis dan berkelanjutan.Terwujudnya peningkatan PAD dan PDRB.Terwujudnya peningkatan pendapatan masyarakat, berkurangnya pengangguran, menurunnya tingkat kemiskinan.Terwujudnya peningkatan pemerataan antar kelompok masyarakat, antar sektor dan antar wilayah.Terciptanya ketahanan dan kemandirian ekonomi masyarakat lokal.1314Heksagonal PELFaktorLokasiProses ManajemenTataKepemerintahanPengembangan Ekonomi Wilayah BerkelanjutanKesinergian danFokus Kebijakan Kelompok SasaranPembangunan Berkelanjutan15 Faktor 2Faktor 3Faktor 1Indikator 1Indikator Indikator nFaktor 116Investor LuarPelaku usaha baru

Pelaku usaha lokalKelompok Sasaran1617Kelompok SasaranInvestor luar: Peraturan ttg kemudahan investasi, informasi prospek bisnis, kapasitas berusaha dan hukum, keamanan, kampanye, pusat pelayanan investasiPelaku Usaha Lokal : Modal, promosi, peningkatan teknologi, manajemen & kelembagaanPelaku Usaha Baru: Pelatihan kewirausahaan, pendampingan & monitoring, insentif, kecepatan ijin1718Faktor Lokasi Tidak Terukur Individual Faktor Lokasi TerukurFaktor LokasiFaktor Lokasi Tidak Terukur Pelaku Usaha1819FAKTOR LOKASIFaktor lokasi terukur: Akses ke dan dari lokasi, akses ke pelabuhan laut dan udara, sarana transportasi, infrastruktur komunikasi, infrastruktur energi, ketersediaan air bersih, tenaga kerja trampil,Jml Lembaga Keuangan lokal, Faktor lokasi tdk terukur untuk dunia usaha: Peluang kerjasama, Lembaga PenelitianFaktor lokasi tidak terukur individual: Kualitas: pemukiman, lingkungan, fasilitas pendidikan dan pelatihan, pelayanan kesehatan, fasos & fasum, etos kerja SDM1920Perluasan EkonomiPembangunan WilayahPemberdayaan Masyarakat Pengembangan KomunitasKETERKAITAN DAN FOKUS KEBIJAKAN2021Keterkaitan dan Fokus KebijakanPerluasan Ekonomi: Kebijakan: investasi, promosi, persaingan usaha, peran Perusahaan Daerah, jaringan usaha, informasi tenaga kerja, pengembangan keahlianPemberdayaan Masy. & Pengembangan KomunitasKebijakan: Pemberdayaan Masyarakat berbasis kemitraan swasta, pengurangan kemiskinan Pembangunan Wilayah Kebijakan: kwsn ind, pusat pertumbuhan, pengemb. Komunitas, kerjasama antar daerah, tata ruang PEL, jaringan usaha antar sentra, sistem industri berkelanjutan2122PEMBANGUNAN BERKELANJUTANEkonomiSosialLingkungan2223Pembangunan BerkelanjutaanEkonomi: Pengembangan Industri pendukung, perusahaan dgn Business Plan, perusahaan dgn inovasiSosialKontribusi thd kesejahteraan, PEL & adat/kelembagaan lokalLingkunganPenerapan amdal, daur ulang, kebijakan Konservasi Sumber Daya Alam2324TATA KEPEMERINTAHANKemitraan Pemerintah dan Dunia UsahaReformasi Sektor PublikPengembangan Organisasi2425Tata KepemerintahaanKemitraan Pemerintah & dunia usaha: Kemitraan: infrastruktur,promosi & perdagangan, pembiayaanReformasi Sektor Publik Reformasi: sistem insentif, restrukturisasi organisasi pemerintahan, prosedur pelayanan publikPengembangan Organisasiasosiasi industri: status, peran, manfaat 2526PROSES MANAJEMENMonitoring dan Evaluasi PartisipatifPerencanaan dan Implementasi PartisipatifDiagnosis Partisipatif2627Proses ManajemenDiagnosa secara partisipatifAnalisis & Pemetaan: potensi ekonomi, daya saing, kondisi politis lokal, serta identifikasi stakeholderPerencanaan dan Implementasi secara partisipatifDiagnosis vs perencanaan, jumlah stakeholder, sinkronisasi (sektoral&spasial), implementasi vs perencanaanMonev secara partisipatifKeterlibatan stakeholder: indikator & monev, frekuensi: monev & diskusi pemecahan masalah, hasil monev vs perencanaan yg akan datang2728Pengembangan dan Penguatan KemitraanPengumpulan Data Analisis DataPemetaanStatus PELPenetapanFaktor Pengungkit PELIdentifikasi StakeholderPenyusunan Rencana Tindak dan PembiayaanPenyusunan Rencana BisnisPelaksanaan PELMonitoring dan Evaluasi TAHAPITAHAP IITAHAP IIITAHAPIVTAHAPVRPJMDAdopsi dalam Dokumen Rencana DaerahRKPDAPBD2829Tahapan Revitalisasi PEL

1.Pengembangan dan Penguatan Kemitraan Strategis PEL.2. Kajian Cepat Status PEL.3.Penyusunan Rencana dan Anggaran.4.Pelaksanaan.5.Monitoring dan Evaluasi.2930Langkah 1 Identifikasi StakeholderTujuan:Mengindentifikasi stakeholder kunci yang berperan dalam mempengaruhi dan yang terkena dampak suatu kebijakan dalam pengembangan ekonomi lokalOutput:Diketahuinya stakeholder kunci dalam pengembangan ekonomi lokalCaranya: melalui forum KPEL (bila ada) atau Bappeda dan asosiasi/forum bisnis3031Langkah 2 Pembentukan dan Pengembangan Forum Kemitraan PELTujuan:Membangun kemitraan strategis antara pemerintah-dunia usaha pada daerah yang belum membentuk forum kemitraan PEL, dan memperluas keanggotaan forum kemitraan PEL pada daerah yang sudah memiliki forum kemitraan PELOutput:Dibentuk dan diperluasnya forum kemitraan PELPeran forum adalah; Membantu pemerintah dalam menyusun rencana dan anggaran yg berkaitan dgn PELMelakukan monitoring dan evaluasi pelaksanaan pengembangan ekonomi lokalMemberi masukan dan saran kepada pemerintah dalam menyusun kebijakan PEL

3132Tahap II Kajian Cepat Status PELLangkah 3 Pengumpulan DataTujuan:Mengumpulkan data dasar PEL maupun data yang sesuai dengan kuesionerOutput:Terkumpulnya data dan informasi tentang PELCaranya : melalui FGD mengisi instrumen tersedia3233Langkah 4 Analisis DataTujuan:Menganalisis data dengan menggunakan Rapid Assessment Techniques for Local Economic Development (RALED)Output:Hasil Analisis PEL3334Langkah 5 Pemetaan Status PEL Tujuan:Memetakan status PEL pada suatu wilayah ataupun status PEL suatu komoditi pada suatu wilayahOutput:Status PEL suatu wilayah ataupun status PEL suatu komoditi pada suatu wilayahHasilnya: Peta aspek PEL : < 50% buruk, 50-75% baik, > 75% sangat baik.Peta status PEL komoditas/wilayah

3435Langkah 6 Identifikasi Faktor Pengungkit PEL Tujuan: Mengidentifikasi faktor pengungkit dari setiap aspek/komponen dari Heksagonal PEL Output: Faktor pengungkit dari setiap aspek/komponen Heksagonal PEL3536Tahap III Penyusunan Rencana dan AnggaranLangkah 7 Penyusunan Rencana Tindak dan Pembiayaan PELTujuan: Menyusun rencana tindak PEL dan anggarannya berdasarkan faktor pengungkit PEL yang dilaksanakan oleh pemerintah daerah dan melibatkan pemangku kepentingan lainnya secara partisipatif. Output: Rencana tindak PEL dan anggaran partisipatif terutama faktor pengungkit menjadi prioritas.Rencana tindak dimaksud: di sektor pemerintah setiap SKPD menyusun rencana tindak secara terpadu dgn SKPD lain dgn dikoordinasikan oleh Bappeda.

3637Langkah 8 Penyusunan Rencana BisnisTujuan: Menyusun rencana bisnis berdasarkan faktor pengungkit PEL yang dilaksanakan oleh dunia usaha dan organisasi masyarakat madaniOutput: Rencana bisnis PEL3738Langkah 9 Integrasi ke dalam Dokumen Perencanaan Daerah

Tujuan: Memasukkan rencana tindak dan rencana bisnis ke dalam dokumen perencanaan daerah baik dalam jangka pendek maupun jangka menengah Output: Dokumen perencanaan daerah yang telah memuat rencana tindak dan rencana bisnis PEL3839Langkah 10 Pelaksanaan PEL

Tujuan: Melaksanakan rencana tindak dan rencana bisnis PEL yang telah disusun oleh seluruh pemangku kepentingan kunci sesuai dengan tugas pokok dan fungsi mereka Output: Kebijakan yang mendukung PEL3940Tahap V Monitoring dan Evaluasi PELLangkah 11 Monitoring dan Evaluasi PELTujuan: Melaksanakan monitoring dan evaluasi pelaksanaan PEL secara partisipatif oleh seluruh pemangku kepentingan kunci Output: Pembangunan ekonomi wilayah yang berkelanjutan4041Contoh AnalisisKab. Serang4142

KASUS SERANG : Tahap II Contoh Instrumen Kajian Cepat 4243

4344

RAPFISH Ordination - Monte Carlo Scatter Plot4445Diagram Layang Layang Hasil Analisis PEL

4546Diagram Layang Layang Hasil Analisis PELKASUS KABUPATEN SERANG

Dari gambar diatas dpt disimpulkan bahwa perlu meningkatkan faktor kesinergian dan fokus kebijakan + Proses manajemen (titik terlemah dari gambar di atas)4647

4748

4849

Leverage of Attributes (Faktor Pengungkit Kelompok Sasaran Pengembangan Ekonomi Lokal)4950NoFaktor PengungkitStrategiRencana TindakThn Pelaksanaan08091011121Promosi produk UKM dari PemdaMenyusun rencana komunikasi pemasaran produk unggulan daerah Kampanye produk unggulan daerah secara terpadu Menyusun rencana kerja komunikasi pemasaran dan implementasi pemda dan dunia usahaKampanye melalui media elektronik, cetak dan pameran dagang tunggalTemu usaha secara periodik antara stakeholder dunia usaha dan pemerintahLabeling dan standarisasi produk UKM

2Upaya Pemda untuk peningkatan teknologi, manajemen dan kelembagaanFasilitasi pengembangan teknologi dan manajemen UKMPeningkatan kapasitas kelembagaan daerah dan pemberdayaan organisasi bisnis masyarakatPelatihan teknis dan pendampingan bagi peningkatan teknologi UKMPendampingan dan konsultasi manajemen usaha UKMProgram Pemberdayaan MasyarakatPelibatan tokoh masyarakat untuk merubah pola pikir masyarakat dan pemberdayaan masyarakat

3Upaya fasilitasi permodalan dari PemdaPengembangan sentra-sentra UKM dan IKM Memberikan bantuan modal kepada para pelaku usaha Memperluas jaringan sentra-sentra produksi

Aspek Kelompok Sasaran505051NoFaktor PengungkitStrategiRencana TindakThn Pelaksanaan08091011124Pusat pelayanan investasiMemberikan pelayanan yang prima bagi investor Penguatan Investor Outreach Office (IOO)Meningkatkan dukungan pemerintah setempat dalam menarik investorMenciptakan sistem lembaga keuangan dan pasar yang sehat, dengan fokus pada potensi produk lokalMembuat Investor Outreach Office (IOO)Perbaikan sistem lembaga dan pelayanan keuanganPembuatan sistem informasi pelayanan investasi dengan komputerMeningkatkan kemampuan SDM pada instansi pemerintah dan Kadin/ Asosiasi tentang regulasi dan potensi usaha

5Kampanye peluang berusahaMenciptakan perubahan paradigma berpikir masyarakat untuk meningkatkan taraf hidup melalui peningkatan ekonomi produktifMengembangkan publikasi potensi usaha unggulan berbasis kerajinan tanganMenciptakan pekerjaan baru dan merangsang kegiatan ekonomi daerahMengadakan kampanye ekonomi produktif kepada masyarakatKerjasama Pemda dan LSM dalam pemberdayaan ekonomi masyarakat Mengadakan kampanye potensi usaha di tingkat lokal/regionl/nasional dan internasionalPembentukan klaster-sentra industri kecil

515152NoFaktor PengungkitStrategiRencana TindakThn Pelaksanaan08091011126KeamananMenciptakan lingkungan yang aman bagi pengembangan bisnis Pengawasan lingkungan yang terpaduPembangunan posko keamanan di berbagai kawasan pusat usahaTerbentuknya petugas keamanan ramah-tanggap lingkungan

7Kepastian berusaha dan hukumMenciptakan stabilitas yang kondusif Menjamin kepastian berusaha bagi para investorAdanya peraturan yang jelas bagi investorPengadaan sarana dan prasarana keamananMelakukan penyuluhan-penyuluhan hukum bagi masyarakat lokal

8Fasilitasi pelatihan kewirausahaan bagi pelaku usaha baruMeningkatkan kemampuan masyarakat bagi pemberdayaan ekonomiMenyelenggarakan pelatihan kewirausahaan bagi pelaku usaha baruMeningkatkan partisipasi masyarakat dalam kewirausahaan Menyiapkan tenaga pendamping (fasilitator) bagi pelaku usaha baruFasilitasi pelatihan kewirausahaan bagi pelaku usaha baruPelatihan pemberdayaan kelompok UKM melalui pembentukan sentra UKM

9Insentif Pemda dalam bentuk pemberian dana stimulan, dan keringanan biayaMenciptakan kesempatan kerja bagi dunia usaha baruMendukung pengengembangan kewirausahaan oleh masyarakatFasilitasi dana stimulan kepada UKM/IKMRegulasi insentif untuk produk unggulan

525253NoFaktor PengungkitStrategiRencana TindakThn Pelaksanaan080910111210Informasi prospek bisnisMembuat gambaran rencana bisnis untuk kegiatan pengembangan UKM dan industri kecil dan jasa serta pariwisataMeningkatkan efektivitas pelaksanaan kegiatan promosi bisnis melalui berbagai jenis layanan informasi dan kerjasama promosi Temu bisnisMembuat gambaran peluang investasiMengikuti dan menyelenggarakan PameranMembuat booklet dan leafletPembuatan video prospek peluang investasi Membuat dan up dating website

11Pendampingan dan monitoring bisnis pelaku usaha baruMendorong partisipasi masyarakat untuk membuka usaha sesuai dengan potensi Menerapkan sistem monitoring dan evaluasi bagi pelaku usaha baru dengan pendampinganSosialisai antar pelaku bisnis lama dan baruKemitraan dan pendampingan oleh perusahaan besar dengan usaha baruPublikasi perkembangan usaha secara periodikPertemuan secara berkala membahas perkembangan lingkungan usaha

12Peraturan tentang kemudahan investasiMenciptakan peraturan yang jelas dan mudah dipahami Kaji ulang & Penyusunan peraturan tentang investasiPublikasi buku-buku peraturan tentang investasiSosialisasi peraturan tentang investasi

535354NoFaktor PengungkitStrategiRencana TindakThn Pelaksanaan080910111213Kecepatan pengurusan ijin bagi investasi baruMenciptakan sistem perizinan terpusatMemberikan kemudahan bagi investor dalam pengurusan perizinanMemberikan pelayanan perizinan yang tidak berbelit-belit, transparan, mudah dan cepatMeningkatkan kemampuan SDM yang terlibat dalam bidang perizinanPengembangan pusat pelayanan perizinan (KPT). Pengadaan sarana dan prasarana pendukungPenyusunan SOP Sosialisasi SOP Pelatihan bagi staf pelayanan pengurusan izin investasi

5454Chart2-2.06866359710-5.834589004550-504.945158958414.783382415823.727895736730.771511077935.474529266437.892536163335.527011871330.837491989124.0059852615.83380603796.0103936195-4.4282412529-15.0542078018-25.0388660431-34.1431922913-41.405166626-46.2013435364-47.2614746094-45.0688171387-40.4836959839-33.7627220154-25.5059165955-15.7904100418-5.47514390951-1.98936367030-5.810928344750-504.973268985714.81882190723.758287429830.788440704335.480312347437.94705200235.584545135530.877120971724.057149887115.87905406956.0391101837-4.4065108299-15.0948629379-25.0229549408-34.1309013367-41.4053649902-46.2098045349-47.2503814697-45.0525169373-40.4811286926-33.755279541-25.5018501282-15.7859649658-5.461391449-1.67094802860-5.809435844450-504.972197055814.815187454223.773532867430.797594070435.487049102837.932170867935.569961547930.879121780424.057048797615.87666988376.0367798805-4.4058918953-15.088807106-25.0202102661-34.1232528687-41.4037818909-46.2075920105-47.2488937378-45.0558776855-40.4779396057-33.7542228699-25.4998855591-15.7856693268-5.4611120224-2.10557937620-5.837779521950-504.946262836514.780794143723.731788635330.761119842535.461093902637.889469146735.548824310330.833280563423.999687194815.82957267766.0096011162-4.4267053604-15.1133775711-25.0382404327-34.1385154724-41.4094161987-46.2071418762-47.2638816833-45.0538978577-40.4904136658-33.7733917236-25.5158653259-15.799861908-5.4839801788-1.63182973860-5.833387851750-504.952210426314.79122924823.745512008730.803415298535.476745605537.834575653135.527801513730.83298301724.001943588315.82595443736.0113630295-4.4236516953-15.0758666992-25.0214443207-34.1276550293-41.3875083923-46.2066955566-47.2514190674-45.0762863159-40.4834671021-33.7626495361-25.506603241-15.7954111099-5.4846763611-0.83108949660-5.812576770850-504.972122669214.79720306423.752208709730.794248580935.483188629237.814620971735.55684280430.857030868524.048118591315.85851001746.0367250443-4.4096798897-15.096364975-25.038766861-34.1536903381-41.427482605-46.2206878662-47.2545127869-45.0481376648-40.5049324036-33.7831344604-25.5287876129-15.811000824-5.4863743782-1.15046405790-5.802241802250-504.981227874814.821016311623.784648895330.820203781135.501075744637.853652954135.562606811530.877653121924.061017990115.87923526766.0580091476-4.3938097954-15.0426540375-25.0071086884-34.1128234863-41.3929672241-46.200717926-47.2464942932-45.0401916504-40.4728889465-33.7474594116-25.492609024-15.7790727615-5.4625844955-1.4783253670-5.813441276650-504.975427150714.817194938723.764621734630.788116455135.480453491237.915946960435.551811218330.84702682524.044021606415.86071205146.0407280922-4.4064869881-15.0991163254-25.0310325623-34.1381568909-41.4173049927-46.2140007019-47.2523269653-45.0638961792-40.5000343323-33.7682952881-25.5116424561-15.7918663025-5.4700322151-1.89429044720-5.836017608650-504.948879241914.798799514823.744308471730.755680084235.459300994937.921058654835.56387329130.826652526923.991870880115.81270313266.011121273-4.4284315109-15.0724010468-25.0271282196-34.130279541-41.4225769043-46.2171936035-47.2600593567-45.0475997925-40.4890403748-33.7687988281-25.5080413818-15.7880821228-5.4749827385-2.36359596250-5.841300487550-504.943005561814.780611038223.720268249530.758672714235.456840515137.8940277135.521888732930.821285247824.005813598615.82352352146.0105733871-4.4266300201-15.0650405884-25.0497570038-34.150478363-41.4097175598-46.2086677551-47.2638244629-45.0728721619-40.4931030273-33.7626342773-25.5131168365-15.7937078476-5.4800019264-2.74748802190-5.822729110750-504.960282802614.801923751823.756347656230.782629013135.476177215637.942497253435.579360961930.851295471224.046697616615.87411689766.0362024307-4.4149684906-15.0951728821-25.0391578674-34.1345176697-41.3981018066-46.2055244446-47.2581100464-45.0510826111-40.4959945679-33.7583122253-25.5074634552-15.7879638672-5.4655528069-2.9303522110-5.817795753550-504.965462207814.814255714423.778575897230.782814025935.485923767137.955314636235.563716888430.871177673324.05593490615.88587474826.0380506516-4.4132905006-15.1022768021-25.0327529907-34.1221160889-41.3969306946-46.2008781433-47.2552909851-45.0587272644-40.4832267761-33.7488670349-25.4992675781-15.7826528549-5.4607195854-1.62246465680-5.811403751450-504.977573871614.826653480523.767486572330.782772064235.474929809637.928977966335.566070556630.850883483924.044609069815.86616230016.0284314156-4.4063434601-15.0563163757-25.0169830322-34.1220779419-41.4083938599-46.2059707642-47.2579727173-45.0416488647-40.4740562439-33.73802948-25.4837703705-15.7722997665-5.4537081718-2.11107778550-5.819511890450-504.968086242714.814801216123.76579475430.773406982435.464637756337.893199920735.542243957530.85293006924.047231674215.87067127236.0324325562-4.413998127-15.0560321808-25.0336456299-34.1302375793-41.41173172-46.2137756348-47.2646865845-45.0562019348-40.4845428467-33.7487983704-25.4986057281-15.7845993042-5.4656748772-2.71640300750-5.839422702850-504.945566177414.796938896223.747953414930.764184951835.457088470537.92391586335.547031402630.822204589823.998270034815.83376312265.9946880341-4.4330887794-15.0825843811-25.0372142792-34.1291122437-41.4027061462-46.2111282349-47.2604598999-45.0535621643-40.4840393066-33.7511100769-25.4960460663-15.784529686-5.472422123-1.02582550050-5.797387599950-504.982912540414.820445060723.7727756530.816501617435.506206512537.975669860835.580459594730.877622604424.077856063815.88420104986.0570445061-4.3860220909-15.0703449249-25.0010643005-34.1148719788-41.3884963989-46.187171936-47.2386322021-45.0499420166-40.4717216492-33.7383842468-25.4900665283-15.7752313614-5.4522528648-2.12425470350-5.818008899750-504.967530250514.811236381523.758447647130.77988243135.479248046937.94448089635.560653686530.87820053124.059843063415.87295627596.035182476-4.4132313728-15.098856926-25.0261135101-34.1298675537-41.409778595-46.2100791931-47.2523727417-45.0557327271-40.48046875-33.7524299622-25.5055160522-15.789481163-5.465692997-2.52226877210-5.828926086450-504.956395626114.794755935723.740747451830.779062271135.486194610637.960769653335.547340393130.866888046324.034084320115.85583019266.0319795609-4.4181232452-15.0623407364-25.0273399353-34.1299057007-41.3969955444-46.1972618103-47.2518386841-45.0784721375-40.4753646851-33.7499084473-25.4998512268-15.7829875946-5.4669995308-1.12857151030-5.799773216250-504.987869739514.837702751223.78477859530.795276641835.482990264937.939483642635.576454162630.873174667424.060400009215.8727188116.046661377-4.3970518112-15.0949335098-25.0170192719-34.1256217957-41.4190635681-46.2149925232-47.2493362427-45.0452919006-40.4806137085-33.7566757202-25.4995269775-15.7809581757-5.4562902451-2.31311082840-5.81628322650-504.969125747714.813563346923.762079238930.782533645635.479255676337.925682067935.568874359130.860727310224.058149337815.8817787176.0455780029-4.4094576836-15.0455560684-25.0323562622-34.133354187-41.4083480835-46.2114181519-47.2573814392-45.0610275269-40.493976593-33.7546653748-25.5028247833-15.7850408554-5.4627952576-1.98313951490-5.820571422650-504.967864036614.810066223123.75253295930.779773712235.478630065937.938396453935.550643920930.862878799424.028669357315.85223484046.0348701477-4.4152121544-15.1080951691-25.0317707062-34.1377334595-41.4127883911-46.2112236023-47.2510414124-45.0544052124-40.4878425598-33.7708129883-25.5119152069-15.7911424637-5.4700684547-1.31934309010-5.807581424750-504.974659919714.808568000823.757978439330.80257034335.486030578637.946697235135.580360412630.875648498524.063468933115.8797378546.0392103195-4.3984570503-15.093290329-25.0149993896-34.1277313232-41.3982696533-46.2031822205-47.2429771423-45.0428466797-40.4746246338-33.7482414246-25.4967975616-15.7844991684-5.4602575302-1.89693880080-5.830598354350-504.954710483614.795389175423.741672515930.780742645335.475677490237.929916381835.549316406230.822498321524.020431518615.8498554236.0186963081-4.4196014404-15.0676364899-25.0231819153-34.1298179626-41.4019012451-46.2050590515-47.2513656616-45.0465164185-40.4954071045-33.7542266846-25.4976463318-15.7863883972-5.4708704948-1.62770366670-5.801914215150-504.98668527614.839796066323.788339614930.800559997635.490653991737.956398010335.586547851630.878877639824.070756912215.88127899176.0546803474-4.3945913315-15.0446033478-25.002450943-34.1073646545-41.4005393982-46.203338623-47.2433357239-45.0337486267-40.4674072266-33.7317237854-25.4817142487-15.7659339905-5.4469027519-0.97461700440-5.807797431950-504.974669456514.819917678823.760332107530.8097591435.49779510537.956832885735.551773071330.843015670824.053138732915.86780166636.0388388634-4.4000062943-15.0340709686-25.0140228271-34.1338500977-41.4025840759-46.2023544312-47.2428970337-45.0490493774-40.4938163757-33.7477798462-25.4891242981-15.7746658325-5.4532532692

Fisheries SustainabilityOther Distingishing FeaturesRAPFISH Ordination - Monte Carlo Scatter Plot

RapScoresAbbreviationKELOMPOK SASARANPeraturan tentang Kemudahan InvestasiInformasi Prospek BisnisKepastian Berusaha dan HukumKeamananKampanye Peluang BerusahaPusat Layanan InvestasiUpaya Fasilitasi Permodalan dari PemdaPromosi Produk UKM dari PemdaUpaya Pemda untuk Peningkatan Teknologi, Manajemen dan Kelembagaan LokalFasilitasi Pelatihan Kewirausahaan bagi Pelaku Usaha BaruPendampingan dan monitoring bisnis pelaku usaha baruInsentif pemda dalam bentuk pemberian dana stimulan, dan keringanan biaya perijinanKecepatan pengurusan ijin bagi investasi baruKELOMPOK SASARAN1111111111111Reference PELGOOD - best attribute values2210221112212BAD - worst attribute values0002000000000UP - half good, half bad2210222000000DOWN - opposite to UP0002000112212Anchor PEL221022111221022102211122002210221112000221022111000022102211000002210220000000221020000000022100000000002212000000000220200000000020020000000000002000000000000200000000200020000000120002000000212000200000221200020000122120002001112212000202111221200022211122120000221112212001022111221202102211122122210221112212User-entered scoring error limits per attribute:(score is expected to be in interval score-Emin to score+Emax)EminEmaxDEFAULT 95% probability scoring error limits:set at 20% of full attribute scaleError limit above or below score0.24763274190.26489526030.23937635120.20897580680.25984293220.24345403910.26145580410.21358799930.28094896670.2811276615(assumes 0 mean Normal error distribution)DEFAULT 95% probability scoring error limitsset at 20% of full attribute scaleError limit above or below score0.2000000030.2000000030.19663842020.2000000030.2000000030.2000000030.17471782860.19663842020.19663842020.2000000030.2000000030.19663842020.200000003(assumes 0 mean Normal error distribution)

RapAnalysis2D MDS ResultsRotated& Flipped & ScaledKELOMPOK SASARAN0.31610122320.18597105150.3538797498-0.096303328962.7772445679-1.9275226593GOOD1.39684486390.41541400551.4569226503-0.0334765391000BAD-1.4622197151-0.3638368547-1.5064338446-0.03347638620-5.8182535172UP0.9400924444-1.59481501580.48763069511.785896182167.290740966850DOWN-0.5646889211.3734055758-0.1836616546-1.47356188344.6376342773-50ANCHORS:1.41920089720.05707008021.38426101210.318134665597.5479965214.96915483471.3682727814-0.28931665421.24403858180.638938546292.81611633314.81140041351.2324728966-0.62845182421.02383840080.930427968585.38534545923.75428009031.0250734091-0.92241090540.74643796681.159503340776.024322509830.78230094910.7723843455-1.14995932580.44280523061.312595725165.778083801335.47916793820.2304929197-1.3807016611-0.14069147411.392720341746.087684631337.9373855591-0.1105908975-1.393453598-0.47312429551.31533145934.869567871135.5630989075-0.4491828084-1.3267395496-0.78225636481.161928653724.437744140630.8567085266-0.7669773698-1.182965517-1.05105948450.939646482515.366843223624.037103653-1.0428489447-0.9818800092-1.26434433460.67309409388.169435501115.8592910767-1.2673281431-0.7110498548-1.4097051620.35276606683.2641594416.0316443443-1.4247690439-0.4011336565-1.48010885720.01235564240.8883503079-4.4121294022-1.4594175816-0.0494478308-1.4210580587-0.33606374262.8810501099-15.1016178131-1.40676808360.3004002869-1.2782646418-0.65975469357.6996879578-25.0324382782-1.28117191790.642274797-1.0671886206-0.956570327314.8225574493-34.1387252808-1.08591949940.9412404895-0.8001912236-1.193670272823.8325233459-41.412940979-0.84120005371.1700623035-0.5039129257-1.350087046633.8305892944-46.2117996216-0.28473940491.35688877110.0820920169-1.384010314953.6056289673-47.25256347660.05808943881.37610471250.4179086089-1.312398910564.9379348755-45.05552673340.39924079181.31491339210.7309625149-1.163651347275.5020980835-40.49196243290.71941798931.17497181891.0030721426-0.94444018684.6845779419-33.76657485960.98935753110.9695889951.2095035315-0.67530167191.6507110596-25.50941848751.21280336380.70214825871.3547586203-0.358515471296.5524215698-15.7904357911.36797785760.39570716021.4238893986-0.022054176898.8852767944-5.4678206444Stress =0.1340847611IterationStressDeltaSquared Correlation (RSQ) =0.953439891310.2126878649899999982852417500000Number of iterations =220.21236231920.0003255457Memory needed (words) =6534Return value (error if > 0)0Rotation angle (degrees) =15.2459030151RAPFISH PARAMETERS USED FOR THIS ANALYSIS# fisheries =1# reference fisheries =4# anchor fisheries =24Row# of 1st fishery =2Row# of GOOD fishery =5Row# of BAD fishery =6Row# of UP fishery =7Row# of DOWN fishery =8Column letter with fisheries names =ARow# of 1st anchor fishery =9# attributes =13Column letter of 1st attribute =D

RapAnalysis

Real Kelompok SasaranReferencesAnchorsLED SustainabilityOther Distingishing FeaturesRALED OrdinationGOODBADUPDOWN

Distances000000000000000000000000000008000000000000000000000000000026.519298553550.519294738800000000000000000000000000022.652631759626.652631759636.07719421390000000000000000000000000014.919299125726.91929817223.600000381559.677188873300000000000000000000000008446.519294738822.652631759630.91929817200000000000000000000000011.86666679387.866666793842.652629852318.785964965834.78596496583.86666679380000000000000000000000011.866666793811.866666793838.652629852314.785964965838.78596496587.86666679384000000000000000000000011.866666793815.866666793834.652629852310.785964965842.785961151111.86666679388400000000000000000000015.733333587619.733333587630.78596496586.91929817246.652629852315.733333587611.86666679387.86666679383.86666679380000000000000000000022.652631759626.652631759623.866666793812.210526466447.466663360622.652631759618.785964965814.785964965810.78596496586.9192986488000000000000000000022.652631759630.652631759619.866666793816.2105274243.466663360626.652631759622.785964965818.785964965814.785964965810.919298172400000000000000000022.652631759634.65263366715.866666793820.2105274239.466667175330.652631759626.785964965822.785964965818.785964965814.9192991257840000000000000000022.652631759638.652629852311.866666793824.2105274235.466667175334.652629852330.785964965826.785964965822.785964965818.9192981721284000000000000000026.519298553542.5192985535828.077194213931.600000381538.519298553534.65263366730.652631759626.652631759622.785964965815.866666793811.86666679387.86666679383.866666793800000000000000026.519298553546.5192985535432.077194213927.600000381542.519298553538.65263366734.65263366730.652631759626.785964965819.866666793815.866666793811.86666679387.866666793840000000000000026.519298553550.5192947388036.077194213923.600000381546.519294738842.652629852338.652629852334.652629852330.785964965823.866666793819.866666793815.866666793811.866666793884000000000000026.519298553546.5192947388440.077194213919.600000381550.519294738846.652629852342.652629852338.652629852334.785964965827.866666793823.866666793819.866666793815.8666667938128400000000000022.652631759642.65262985237.866666793843.943859100315.733333587646.652629852350.519294738846.519294738842.519294738838.652629852331.733333587627.733333587623.733333587619.733333587615.866666793811.86666679387.86666679383.86666679380000000000022.652631759638.652629852311.866666793847.943859100311.733333587642.652629852346.519294738850.519294738846.519294738842.652629852335.733333587631.733333587627.733333587623.733333587619.866666793815.866666793811.86666679387.86666679384000000000022.652631759634.652629852315.866666793851.94385910037.733333587638.652629852342.519294738846.519294738850.519294738846.652629852339.733333587635.733333587631.733333587627.733333587623.866666793819.866666793815.866666793811.86666679388400000000018.785964965830.785964965819.733333587655.81052398683.866666793834.785964965838.652629852342.652629852346.652629852350.519294738843.599998474139.599998474135.599998474131.600000381527.733333587623.733333587619.733333587615.733333587611.86666679387.86666679383.86666679380000000011.866666793823.866666793826.652631759650.51929473883.05263185527.866666793831.733333587635.733333587639.733333587643.599998474150.519294738846.519298553542.519298553538.519298553534.65263366730.652631759626.652631759622.652631759618.785964965814.785964965810.78596496586.9192986488000000011.866666793819.866666793830.652631759646.51929855357.05263185523.866666793827.733333587631.733333587635.733333587639.599998474146.519298553550.519294738846.519298553542.519298553538.652629852334.65263366730.652631759626.652631759622.785964965818.785964965814.785964965810.919298172400000011.866666793815.866666793834.65263366742.519298553511.052632331819.866666793823.733333587627.733333587631.733333587635.599998474142.519298553546.519298553550.519294738846.519298553542.652629852338.652629852334.65263366730.652631759626.785964965822.785964965818.785964965814.9192991257840000011.866666793811.866666793838.652629852338.519298553515.052632331815.866666793819.733333587623.733333587627.733333587631.600000381538.519298553542.519298553546.519298553550.519294738846.652629852342.652629852338.652629852334.652629852330.785964965826.785964965822.785964965818.919298172128400008842.519298553534.65263366718.9192981721215.866666793819.866666793823.866666793827.733333587634.65263366738.652629852342.652629852346.652629852350.519294738846.519298553542.519298553538.519298553534.65263366730.652631759626.652631759622.785964965815.866666793811.86666679387.86666679383.86666679380008446.519298553530.652631759622.919298172811.866666793815.866666793819.866666793823.733333587630.652631759634.65263366738.652629852342.652629852346.519298553550.519294738846.519298553542.519298553538.65263366734.65263366730.652631759626.785964965819.866666793815.866666793811.86666679387.86666679384008050.519294738826.652631759626.91929817247.866666793811.866666793815.866666793819.733333587626.652631759630.652631759634.65263366738.652629852342.519298553546.519298553550.519294738846.519294738842.652629852338.652629852334.652629852330.785964965823.866666793819.866666793815.866666793811.8666667938840

LeverageAttributes63.7955207825100059.924579620450.535919189596.383712768690.372116088981.554801940971.069671630960.104690551839.909458160428.753761291518.579885482810.11378860473.93912482260.56593579050.58319735533.62326073659.679882049618.132366180428.22718048138.912544250558.988521575970.308311462480.667854309189.297729492295.230659484998.627449035698.626304626564.1621322632100060.524539947550.502716064596.589920043990.699073791582.02676391671.618072509860.576068878239.805328369128.158161163317.55331230168.81814002992.5218431952.50795841220.81437730793.69573020949.682553291318.026906967228.057863235538.810085296659.463844299371.232910156282.006248474190.912216186596.999954223697.000495910698.716079711960.9424247742100061.374031066950.029201507696.790695190491.129821777382.663543701272.320472717361.160724639939.776897430427.677524566716.72197532657.74554395687.7471976282.77172255520.71492701773.46596121799.178503990217.301856994627.248043060338.050525665359.32675170971.545188903882.647232055791.744422912691.744537353596.646148681698.688308715864.6845550537100061.685771942150.177680969296.9731597991.483802795483.137680053772.758171081561.380004882839.40845489527.134965896616.164903640716.16446113598.38806438453.04919743540.71031552553.28534555448.869792938216.860095977826.816772460937.85251998959.835712432972.318496704183.533485412683.533302307191.125762939596.442459106498.751564025964.8918991089100061.66493225150.340606689597.139732360891.805320739783.514648437573.026298522961.435661315939.214298248327.029996871927.029449462916.93839073188.74220943453.26263260840.76338207723.17141866688.606572151216.548524856626.606708526637.891387939560.18089675972.629455566472.629539489782.887741088990.843681335496.351799011298.817062377964.9537277222100061.283142089850.607028961297.256805419991.975929260383.631271362372.987815856961.275207519539.261337280339.261913299627.615186691317.21746635448.93264389043.42181730270.83957046273.14438509948.529332160916.529663085926.785564422638.25028991760.391654968360.391525268672.207771301382.780334472790.822746276996.351783752498.892738342360.4383964539100050.482337951749.767566680997.354873657292.214431762784.076416015673.760795593362.50432205250.743785858238.6684722927.118064880416.93652534488.90321159363.47257089610.87783646583.08095288288.26496601116.095813751226.179548263537.468544006349.201309204161.25262069772.837814331183.087211608990.862243652396.275489807198.816360473659.8941574097100076.806861877437.924854278697.316131591891.949989318883.373229980572.724929809661.517723083551.785678863539.145893096927.312147140517.10446357739.13746929173.69822573661.0188357833.22448134428.601254463216.746923446726.900722503737.675735473648.317329406761.079727172973.018341064583.283370971790.953735351696.327148437598.925666809160.0115661621100077.118591308637.8307075597.362976074292.008529663183.52738189773.209800720273.20956420951.619979858438.988296508827.358497619617.2404804239.27326583863.81964015961.04500234133.19081425678.57339286816.665081024226.544483184826.544225692748.477100372361.247913360673.059295654383.254798889290.848335266196.303436279399.016983032264.4411010742100077.331344604537.845710754497.49439239592.289627075284.207374572884.207885742273.382400512751.671577453639.242733001727.750513076817.75989532479.70727062234.02551221851.05653274063.02359795578.299859046916.035167694116.036588668826.578811645548.47735595761.043811798172.683280944882.759490966890.519912719796.168884277399.072372436564.0986328125100076.939140319837.980041503997.775512695393.000602722293.003028869683.778617858973.04821014451.830245971739.706676483228.387514114418.380784988410.17319774634.25121212011.0609347822.7622165687.62801361087.629642963416.464038848926.926658630448.323181152360.566864013772.005912780882.098297119190.025207519595.917861938599.050659179761.1133499146100075.379951477138.786361694398.115692138798.117675781291.54467010582.316383361871.784500122151.321727752739.501800537128.345930099518.34632682810.09947586064.0724678040.78533071282.25416159632.25843596468.482851028417.279012680127.502099990848.202899932960.135982513471.438072204681.555076599189.596679687595.624267578198.880004882863.3654098511100075.123939514238.798751831199.853736877496.67183685390.317314147981.458000183171.390098571851.619327545240.039726257328.914556503318.803638458310.37469005584.20298862460.73705363270.74348765613.94274854669.887945175218.270586013828.010158538847.978385925359.662544250570.923583984481.155654907289.356285095295.509956359998.9045639038-1.19629859920-6.596312999750-504.779102325414.789576530523.581369430.243612289434.423583984435.37977600131.725957870525.694581985525.694643020616.73927497865.9390015602-5.422565937-16.597328186-26.6458034515-35.6009979248-42.5447616577-46.8928260803-46.3678359985-42.910949707-36.9789733887-36.978969574-27.9563999176-17.2218456268-5.9587144852-1.4790720940-6.471670150850-504.640840053614.514833450323.34482765230.167303085334.530540466335.817623138432.498531341632.498760223425.262706756616.41035652165.812066555-5.2204828262-16.117477417-26.0441894531-35.0372543335-42.1477661133-46.6639251709-46.5016098022-43.3458442688-43.3458786011-36.2168388367-27.2648506165-16.7531414032-5.8279042244-1.79420661930-6.317288398750-504.57093906414.380661010723.290920257630.246683120734.726406097436.333602905336.330844879231.613622665424.518589019815.90382575995.6802196503-4.9723930359-15.6496953964-25.5395584106-34.6293373108-41.8723945618-46.5026092529-46.660282135-46.6598472595-42.0919532776-35.0887870789-26.3828926086-16.2523822784-5.720916748-2.79567813870-0.180302202750-5012.093686103823.521230697633.886127471941.982921600347.297737121649.862644195647.479122161942.240947723434.322105407724.709205627413.22554492951.1823549271-10.9387760162-22.1922264099-32.5395011902-40.7576980591-45.9566078186-48.3732032776-46.1476402283-41.0284233093-33.1680526733-23.3841819763-11.91842174530.1166145876-1.17573308940-5.618278026650-505.701931476616.329431533826.030609130933.482906341638.254959106438.74276733436.708518981932.079254150425.141761779816.77019316.6905684471-4.1048316956-15.4053459167-26.0858879089-35.9230461121-43.6341438293-48.5521888733-47.4179916382-45.5666770935-41.0675849915-34.2234802246-25.7883358002-15.864733696-5.2574729919-0.75164318080-5.692530155250-506.138067722317.226181030327.24172782934.847614288334.847557067938.867542266836.961174011232.401199340825.578580856317.32776832587.0060272217-4.1088647842-15.9193372726-27.0881595612-37.2670326233-45.1487617493-45.1488265991-47.7111473083-46.0042572021-41.6120109558-34.9164276123-26.4385223389-16.3839550018-5.4617056847-3.2945294380-5.786561489150-506.540741920517.952432632428.070688247728.070775985734.376781463639.038501739537.301174163832.932250976626.186861038217.83731460577.3861775398-4.1451439857-16.4654464722-28.0731563568-38.4536170959-38.4533615112-44.8970947266-48.0341796875-46.5413856506-42.3588600159-35.7278633118-27.2909317017-17.014251709-5.68419456481.01827621680.7312240775-5.806046962750-506.72246313118.133440017718.133914947527.326324462934.066001892139.150588989337.623233795233.445434570326.792196273818.39342308047.6927647591-4.1720209122-16.7287788391-28.3722743988-28.3718986511-37.8787879944-44.7466926575-48.2311096191-46.9440879822-42.9512176514-36.442615509-27.9576797485-17.4442386627-5.7791271211.38488768990.4484505595-5.554213523950-506.64362859736.644403457617.811954498327.292720794733.992652893138.925041198737.506046295233.442279815726.860019683818.39688491827.6421833038-4.178706646-16.4437541962-16.4419460297-27.7943763733-37.5161819458-44.3245582581-47.7043266296-46.4857673645-42.6314620972-36.12109375-27.5604171753-16.9483146667-5.28742074971.83481976190.1333160392-5.611173152950-50-5.58184194566.102516651217.598573684727.126777648933.854667663639.003501892137.664173126233.647506713927.0018272418.43216705327.5512189865-4.2063789368-4.2031321526-16.0572032928-27.6840686798-37.4487800598-44.2854423523-47.8302612305-46.7016830444-42.8744659424-36.3425941467-27.6425247192-16.910150528-5.35110616681.90731050350.86815548052.11465448970.75178958062.17648320541.17587949022.33884812511.36700678042.88308722782.94579879832.76567844833.31241031741.66385652943.76234235971.32138825783.83483311441.66389464494.04217704360.58816529514.1040059686

LeverageAttributes1

Fisheries SustainabilityOther Distinguishing FeaturesLeveraging Scatter - remove 1 attribute each run

MonteCarloPeraturan tentang Kemudahan InvestasiInformasi Prospek BisnisKepastian Berusaha dan HukumKeamananKampanye Peluang BerusahaPusat Layanan InvestasiUpaya Fasilitasi Permodalan dari PemdaPromosi Produk UKM dari PemdaUpaya Pemda untuk Peningkatan Teknologi, Manajemen dan Kelembagaan LokalFasilitasi Pelatihan Kewirausahaan bagi Pelaku Usaha BaruPendampingan dan monitoring bisnis pelaku usaha baruInsentif pemda dalam bentuk pemberian dana stimulan, dan keringanan biaya perijinanKecepatan pengurusan ijin bagi investasi baru

AttributeRoot Mean Square Change in Ordination when Selected Attribute Removed (on Sustainability scale 0 to 100)Leverage of Attributes

61.699848175100067.268898010344.633361816497.534667968892.815307617285.386291503976.019683837965.767715454146.103881835934.876598358224.41896438615.36382102978.1775646213.27220249180.88376152523.04153823857.678152084414.815550804123.859397888233.847267150953.60114669864.948570251575.520263671984.707557678291.66883850196.567665100198.895416259862.6134719849100067.288490295444.610179901197.538902282792.813613891685.380218505976.018013000565.772384643646.076778411934.839904785224.40110206615.32185173038.11853885653.24286890030.8884403112.85053920757.674355030114.787700653123.802867889433.796306610153.581512451264.927909851175.490455627484.673278808691.639915466396.547149658298.884292602562.2031784058100067.287734985444.606239318897.534667968892.813613891685.384086608976.016334533765.770820617746.091102600134.861141204824.403608322115.32881355298.13217163093.26379561420.88771325352.84332799917.656227588714.813743591323.809768676833.797695159953.580608367964.923591613875.492393493784.675460815491.640632629496.549972534298.885154724161.6818275452100067.269020080644.627246856797.54821014492.816932678285.388603210476.021430969265.772598266646.106143951434.85044097924.423223495515.37319660198.18668365483.27446269990.89149910212.8551583297.676767349214.829286575323.843311309833.831081390453.5885200564.93670654375.502380371184.689903259391.651107788196.550582885798.880485534758.7024650574100067.24750518844.576354980597.545303344792.826637268185.389106750576.006103515665.757225036646.151771545434.862514495824.402153015115.33827972418.18986797333.27183055880.89567208292.96931242947.658667087614.803793907223.859981536933.79591751153.563735961964.931076049875.509925842384.705009460491.655616760396.552169799898.88418579162.9023132324100067.297004699744.638301849497.540496826292.805671691985.384902954176.023620605565.780410766646.17581939734.887561798124.462537765515.38565731058.19582176213.27342557910.88564920432.87930393227.629919052114.790489196823.825593948433.827297210753.602386474664.929344177275.494209289684.674217224191.644592285296.548912048398.887161254960.6377944946100067.283470153844.586818695197.539550781292.819587707585.388336181676.012603759865.769470214846.164001464834.883880615224.423053741515.34377670298.1635999683.23433780670.89821672443.01514601717.664921760614.822546958923.833625793533.799549102853.575805664164.923889160275.505722045984.691429138291.650665283296.548042297498.890815734963.1563682556100067.301094055244.649768829397.551780700792.817123413185.387825012276.028533935565.786071777346.114959716834.901409149224.481037139915.39214420328.1963548663.2653584480.89069050552.90700840957.722543239614.849422454823.844680786133.844799041753.619464874364.94610595775.505996704184.686065673891.653633117796.552047729598.886489868260.3016281128100067.256759643644.598121643197.542823791592.828689575285.389328002976.012039184665.765182495146.082221984934.826999664324.41327476515.36118221288.21092891693.25848412510.89085221293.01113963137.696453094514.822044372623.804203033433.802795410253.584991455164.943771362375.517471313584.711952209591.669975280896.55838012798.89029693662.5660476685100067.280570983944.675697326797.541946411192.81857299885.391220092876.032012939565.785598754946.116199493434.907115936324.465034484915.39099311838.2233209613.28642225270.89068704843.09990358357.7357921614.86481857323.899961471633.883762359653.631343841664.966712951775.531776428284.711578369191.677787780896.569564819398.893844604563.4305686951100067.299530029344.652454376297.534515380992.811111450285.388145446876.030052185165.784118652346.089187622134.854400634824.450544357315.34924793248.14039421083.25211906430.88825130462.89568567287.699285507214.862198829723.868776321433.848258972253.607646942164.943099975675.502090454184.68196868991.650436401496.552307128998.88426208562.7519950867100067.292579650944.629249572897.534996032792.814231872685.387870788676.024314880465.775009155346.076786041334.870643615724.410961151115.31797885898.11109352113.24499988560.88798528912.87495136267.703659057614.878131866523.842609405533.831233978353.594715118464.929275512775.499908447384.681091308691.646087646596.550262451298.882797241261.7408599854100067.284675598144.618362426897.55157470792.82895660485.389472961476.021797180265.778930664146.103183746334.862716674824.439886093115.34580898288.15381908423.28401374820.88936233523.05748939517.731867313414.841694831823.825490951533.822959899953.602111816464.958526611375.525749206584.70648956391.666069030896.570419311598.896896362362.7444267273100067.292633056644.641647338997.544967651492.820503234985.389694213976.028228759865.786720275946.126869201734.892799377424.446241378815.34887695318.14578628543.26397371290.88978338243.08427619937.735908508314.878456115723.847288131733.840728759853.613513946564.957199096775.525856018184.704383850191.668281555296.56951904398.899467468360.5084571838100067.259140014644.618312835797.542243957592.830215454185.393531799376.017234802265.769371032746.083087921134.845668792724.414630889915.33925342568.16019248963.29447054860.88689827923.02919816977.718517303514.863380432123.857870101933.826339721753.596832275464.951972961475.528106689584.715789794991.668251037696.571205139298.889602661162.0376701355100067.293525695844.59865188697.536178588992.811286926385.380912780876.014335632365.768569946346.124141693134.863491058324.43309593215.32940387738.15734386443.25843453410.89204019312.8376474387.642476081814.77921199823.812042236333.801151275653.571533203164.924430847275.485702514684.665985107491.63530731296.54130554298.880729675362.2146034241100067.280036926344.601295471297.540992736892.812866210985.381118774476.015609741265.766990661646.07002258334.85035324124.381475448615.29232597358.11283779143.22997236250.88856148722.83108878147.656675815614.791392326423.789186477733.789787292553.574279785264.915626525975.488151550384.671073913691.639862060596.546127319398.885581970261.2579460144100067.275840759344.615802764997.54022216892.816596984985.386077880976.018997192465.768051147546.070064544734.869651794424.395511627215.32903289798.1582851413.24181604390.89133369923.03068733227.674294471714.810828208923.840364456233.825813293553.590957641664.938255310175.5080642784.694206237891.656700134396.552627563598.886650085463.2265625100067.312507629444.640869140697.545654296992.823905944885.389472961476.030693054265.792961120646.11449050934.891616821324.465469360415.3917522438.19661617283.28869652750.88737922912.91412544257.741986274714.857836723323.819684982333.828445434653.616783142164.951324462975.507720947384.685142517191.652313232496.5544357398.88563537663.1309814453100067.300804138244.638942718597.537391662692.812637329185.385856628476.027893066465.783683776946.104351043734.874843597424.44983673115.34525775918.13777065283.24250197410.8912381533.07986879357.707650661514.847157478323.841041564933.837158203153.612884521564.951599121175.51533508384.695625305291.662551879996.563270568898.898323059162.4718704224100067.287216186544.633274078497.551002502492.818000793585.385627746676.023368835465.776809692446.086528778134.880687713624.424835205115.37604045878.18455413.24993252750.88789790872.87908124927.704534530614.825412750223.833208084133.829822540353.602699279864.930496215875.500732421984.685485839891.650489807196.54708862398.882942199761.9888267517100067.291702270544.609813690297.53208160492.811523437585.384178161676.018775939965.775749206546.090351104734.85575866724.420469284115.33325576788.14002990723.27892327310.89082252982.84752726557.635660171514.775105476423.814067840633.795505523753.578647613564.924606323275.486633300884.667228698791.632568359496.54376220798.877388000560.3699073792100067.263992309644.599628448597.542259216392.822113037185.387001037676.013061523465.765357971246.08689498934.856014251724.437898635915.33740139018.15562534333.26896691320.89375817783.01235890397.675128936814.804973602323.833877563533.809162139953.582324981764.931777954175.511848449784.698463439991.653144836496.555801391698.887107849161.2837028503100067.291046142644.596851348997.550064086992.829719543585.389144897576.018074035665.776817321846.095981597934.862438201924.424362182615.32698631298.16029167183.24900412560.89598214633.03651309017.719572067314.837916374223.809370040933.799266815253.589267730764.940948486375.513275146584.694671630991.657630920496.556015014698.892059326261.913898468100067.290664672944.617969512997.536766052292.821174621685.384445190476.018638610865.773429870646.087402343834.891677856424.475767135615.36296939858.17576599123.28541994090.88980197913.04983615887.690905094114.792124748223.841140747133.827396392853.604602813764.945236206175.516830444384.698921203691.661842346296.565895080698.8961410522-2.06866359710-5.834589004550-504.945158958414.783382415823.727895736730.771511077935.474529266437.892536163335.527011871330.837491989124.0059852615.83380603796.0103936195-4.4282412529-15.0542078018-25.0388660431-34.1431922913-41.405166626-46.2013435364-47.2614746094-45.0688171387-40.4836959839-33.7627220154-25.5059165955-15.7904100418-5.4751439095-1.98936367030-5.810928344750-504.973268985714.81882190723.758287429830.788440704335.480312347437.94705200235.584545135530.877120971724.057149887115.87905406956.0391101837-4.4065108299-15.0948629379-25.0229549408-34.1309013367-41.4053649902-46.2098045349-47.2503814697-45.0525169373-40.4811286926-33.755279541-25.5018501282-15.7859649658-5.461391449-1.67094802860-5.809435844450-504.972197055814.815187454223.773532867430.797594070435.487049102837.932170867935.569961547930.879121780424.057048797615.87666988376.0367798805-4.4058918953-15.088807106-25.0202102661-34.1232528687-41.4037818909-46.2075920105-47.2488937378-45.0558776855-40.4779396057-33.7542228699-25.4998855591-15.7856693268-5.4611120224-2.10557937620-5.837779521950-504.946262836514.780794143723.731788635330.761119842535.461093902637.889469146735.548824310330.833280563423.999687194815.82957267766.0096011162-4.4267053604-15.1133775711-25.0382404327-34.1385154724-41.4094161987-46.2071418762-47.2638816833-45.0538978577-40.4904136658-33.7733917236-25.5158653259-15.799861908-5.4839801788-1.63182973860-5.833387851750-504.952210426314.79122924823.745512008730.803415298535.476745605537.834575653135.527801513730.83298301724.001943588315.82595443736.0113630295-4.4236516953-15.0758666992-25.0214443207-34.1276550293-41.3875083923-46.2066955566-47.2514190674-45.0762863159-40.4834671021-33.7626495361-25.506603241-15.7954111099-5.4846763611-0.83108949660-5.812576770850-504.972122669214.79720306423.752208709730.794248580935.483188629237.814620971735.55684280430.857030868524.048118591315.85851001746.0367250443-4.4096798897-15.096364975-25.038766861-34.1536903381-41.427482605-46.2206878662-47.2545127869-45.0481376648-40.5049324036-33.7831344604-25.5287876129-15.811000824-5.4863743782-1.15046405790-5.802241802250-504.981227874814.821016311623.784648895330.820203781135.501075744637.853652954135.562606811530.877653121924.061017990115.87923526766.0580091476-4.3938097954-15.0426540375-25.0071086884-34.1128234863-41.3929672241-46.200717926-47.2464942932-45.0401916504-40.4728889465-33.7474594116-25.492609024-15.7790727615-5.4625844955-1.4783253670-5.813441276650-504.975427150714.817194938723.764621734630.788116455135.480453491237.915946960435.551811218330.84702682524.044021606415.86071205146.0407280922-4.4064869881-15.0991163254-25.0310325623-34.1381568909-41.4173049927-46.2140007019-47.2523269653-45.0638961792-40.5000343323-33.7682952881-25.5116424561-15.7918663025-5.4700322151-1.89429044720-5.836017608650-504.948879241914.798799514823.744308471730.755680084235.459300994937.921058654835.56387329130.826652526923.991870880115.81270313266.011121273-4.4284315109-15.0724010468-25.0271282196-34.130279541-41.4225769043-46.2171936035-47.2600593567-45.0475997925-40.4890403748-33.7687988281-25.5080413818-15.7880821228-5.4749827385-2.36359596250-5.841300487550-504.943005561814.780611038223.720268249530.758672714235.456840515137.8940277135.521888732930.821285247824.005813598615.82352352146.0105733871-4.4266300201-15.0650405884-25.0497570038-34.150478363-41.4097175598-46.2086677551-47.2638244629-45.0728721619-40.4931030273-33.7626342773-25.5131168365-15.7937078476-5.4800019264-2.74748802190-5.822729110750-504.960282802614.801923751823.756347656230.782629013135.476177215637.942497253435.579360961930.851295471224.046697616615.87411689766.0362024307-4.4149684906-15.0951728821-25.0391578674-34.1345176697-41.3981018066-46.2055244446-47.2581100464-45.0510826111-40.4959945679-33.7583122253-25.5074634552-15.7879638672-5.4655528069-2.9303522110-5.817795753550-504.965462207814.814255714423.778575897230.782814025935.485923767137.955314636235.563716888430.871177673324.05593490615.88587474826.0380506516-4.4132905006-15.1022768021-25.0327529907-34.1221160889-41.3969306946-46.2008781433-47.2552909851-45.0587272644-40.4832267761-33.7488670349-25.4992675781-15.7826528549-5.4607195854-1.62246465680-5.811403751450-504.977573871614.826653480523.767486572330.782772064235.474929809637.928977966335.566070556630.850883483924.044609069815.86616230016.0284314156-4.4063434601-15.0563163757-25.0169830322-34.1220779419-41.4083938599-46.2059707642-47.2579727173-45.0416488647-40.4740562439-33.73802948-25.4837703705-15.7722997665-5.4537081718-2.11107778550-5.819511890450-504.968086242714.814801216123.76579475430.773406982435.464637756337.893199920735.542243957530.85293006924.047231674215.87067127236.0324325562-4.413998127-15.0560321808-25.0336456299-34.1302375793-41.41173172-46.2137756348-47.2646865845-45.0562019348-40.4845428467-33.7487983704-25.4986057281-15.7845993042-5.4656748772-2.71640300750-5.839422702850-504.945566177414.796938896223.747953414930.764184951835.457088470537.92391586335.547031402630.822204589823.998270034815.83376312265.9946880341-4.4330887794-15.0825843811-25.0372142792-34.1291122437-41.4027061462-46.2111282349-47.2604598999-45.0535621643-40.4840393066-33.7511100769-25.4960460663-15.784529686-5.472422123-1.02582550050-5.797387599950-504.982912540414.820445060723.7727756530.816501617435.506206512537.975669860835.580459594730.877622604424.077856063815.88420104986.0570445061-4.3860220909-15.0703449249-25.0010643005-34.1148719788-41.3884963989-46.187171936-47.2386322021-45.0499420166-40.4717216492-33.7383842468-25.4900665283-15.7752313614-5.4522528648-2.12425470350-5.818008899750-504.967530250514.811236381523.758447647130.77988243135.479248046937.94448089635.560653686530.87820053124.059843063415.87295627596.035182476-4.4132313728-15.098856926-25.0261135101-34.1298675537-41.409778595-46.2100791931-47.2523727417-45.0557327271-40.48046875-33.7524299622-25.5055160522-15.789481163-5.465692997-2.52226877210-5.828926086450-504.956395626114.794755935723.740747451830.779062271135.486194610637.960769653335.547340393130.866888046324.034084320115.85583019266.0319795609-4.4181232452-15.0623407364-25.0273399353-34.1299057007-41.3969955444-46.1972618103-47.2518386841-45.0784721375-40.4753646851-33.7499084473-25.4998512268-15.7829875946-5.4669995308-1.12857151030-5.799773216250-504.987869739514.837702751223.78477859530.795276641835.482990264937.939483642635.576454162630.873174667424.060400009215.8727188116.046661377-4.3970518112-15.0949335098-25.0170192719-34.1256217957-41.4190635681-46.2149925232-47.2493362427-45.0452919006-40.4806137085-33.7566757202-25.4995269775-15.7809581757-5.4562902451-2.31311082840-5.81628322650-504.969125747714.813563346923.762079238930.782533645635.479255676337.925682067935.568874359130.860727310224.058149337815.8817787176.0455780029-4.4094576836-15.0455560684-25.0323562622-34.133354187-41.4083480835-46.2114181519-47.2573814392-45.0610275269-40.493976593-33.7546653748-25.5028247833-15.7850408554-5.4627952576-1.98313951490-5.820571422650-504.967864036614.810066223123.75253295930.779773712235.478630065937.938396453935.550643920930.862878799424.028669357315.85223484046.0348701477-4.4152121544-15.1080951691-25.0317707062-34.1377334595-41.4127883911-46.2112236023-47.2510414124-45.0544052124-40.4878425598-33.7708129883-25.5119152069-15.7911424637-5.4700684547-1.31934309010-5.807581424750-504.974659919714.808568000823.757978439330.80257034335.486030578637.946697235135.580360412630.875648498524.063468933115.8797378546.0392103195-4.3984570503-15.093290329-25.0149993896-34.1277313232-41.3982696533-46.2031822205-47.2429771423-45.0428466797-40.4746246338-33.7482414246-25.4967975616-15.7844991684-5.4602575302-1.89693880080-5.830598354350-504.954710483614.795389175423.741672515930.780742645335.475677490237.929916381835.549316406230.822498321524.020431518615.8498554236.0186963081-4.4196014404-15.0676364899-25.0231819153-34.1298179626-41.4019012451-46.2050590515-47.2513656616-45.0465164185-40.4954071045-33.7542266846-25.4976463318-15.7863883972-5.4708704948-1.62770366670-5.801914215150-504.98668527614.839796066323.788339614930.800559997635.490653991737.956398010335.586547851630.878877639824.070756912215.88127899176.0546803474-4.3945913315-15.0446033478-25.002450943-34.1073646545-41.4005393982-46.203338623-47.2433357239-45.0337486267-40.4674072266-33.7317237854-25.4817142487-15.7659339905-5.4469027519-0.97461700440-5.807797431950-504.974669456514.819917678823.760332107530.8097591435.49779510537.956832885735.551773071330.843015670824.053138732915.86780166636.0388388634-4.4000062943-15.0340709686-25.0140228271-34.1338500977-41.4025840759-46.2023544312-47.2428970337-45.0490493774-40.4938163757-33.7477798462-25.4891242981-15.7746658325-5.453253269262.03767013550.57580184940.3558425903-1.89693880080.2744741440.214138984762.03767013550.70675659180.7539672852-1.89693880080.41861343380.22731590271000000010000000000-5.81779575350.00686740880.0111303329000-5.81779575350.00835990910.012802600967.28773498540.00484466550.0076980591500067.28773498540.00489807130.0118942261500044.61831283570.01504898070.0120735168-500044.61831283570.01998901370.0170173645-500097.54099273680.00397491460.00360107424.96808624270.00657367710.011690616697.54099273680.00431060790.00422668464.96808624270.00658321380.013375759192.81712341310.00405120850.003509521514.81123638150.00595855710.014033317692.81712341310.0049896240.003509521514.81123638150.00758552550.014297485485.38782501220.00128173830.002197265623.75828742980.00750732420.010334014985.38782501220.00131988530.002922058123.75828742980.00919914250.012775421176.01899719240.00462341310.001762390130.78277206420.01250457760.002998352176.01899719240.0053176880.002662658730.78277206420.01482200620.003709793165.77342987060.00550079350.004058837935.47925567630.00666809080.00357818665.77342987060.0069808960.004859924335.47925567630.00677490230.004325866746.09598159790.01850891110.009086608937.92991638180.01456451420.013969421446.09598159790.01897811890.009452819837.92991638180.01678085330.035888671934.86349105830.01719665530.007476806635.56065368650.00822067260.011337280334.86349105830.02038955690.007732391435.56065368650.00930786130.011829376224.42436218260.02187919620.009731292730.85703086850.01614379880.014015197824.42436218260.02547454830.011087417630.85703086850.018617630.019538879415.34525775910.01771163940.012001991324.04723167420.00991821290.018562316915.34525775910.01856327060.015853881824.04723167420.01091766360.02680015568.16019248960.02436161040.014406204215.86780166630.00886821750.01556682598.16019248960.02649116520.019798278815.86780166630.01125240330.01794624333.26397371290.00945186610.01404118546.03620243070.0029077530.00777101523.26397371290.0104889870.01496958736.03620243070.00300788880.01750612260.88980197910.00143617390.0015506744-4.41323137280.00688791280.00489187240.88980197910.00153172020.00181669-4.41323137280.00733947750.00637006762.96931242940.06137490270.0902311802-15.07586669920.01352596280.01906681062.96931242940.06720066070.0943610668-15.07586669920.01955032350.01930618297.69090509410.01674556730.0166106224-25.02712821960.00691795350.00562477117.69090509410.02761220930.0259833336-25.02712821960.01010894780.006517410314.82254695890.02461051940.0175733566-34.12990570070.00225067140.00394439714.82254695890.02687549590.0187530518-34.12990570070.0042839050.00461196923.83387756350.00943374630.0141925812-41.4051666260.00462722780.004550933823.83387756350.01080322270.0198097229-41.4051666260.00689697270.00461196933.82633972170.00474166870.025188446-46.20714187620.00380325320.003986358633.82633972170.00489425660.0267906189-46.20714187620.00395965580.004081726153.59471511840.00798416140.0123901367-47.25232696530.00194549560.00564575253.59471511840.00988769530.0132026672-47.25232696530.00299072270.005783081164.93825531010.0078506470.0089111328-45.05356216430.00542449950.002639770564.93825531010.01031494140.0089797974-45.05356216430.00596237180.005165100175.50772094730.00761413570.0069885254-40.48369598390.00322723390.006717681975.50772094730.00910949710.0078125-40.48369598390.00575637820.009407043584.69142913820.00749206540.0094604492-33.75422668460.00535964970.008407592884.69142913820.01295471190.0103378296-33.75422668460.00542831420.008422851691.65314483640.00869750980.0027084351-25.49988555910.00223922730.006717681991.65314483640.00940704350.0070571899-25.49988555910.00308799740.007577896196.55230712890.0060729980.0023345947-15.78566932680.00268173220.003811836296.55230712890.01096343990.0033950806-15.78566932680.00301647190.00474071598.88665008540.00416564940.0023574829-5.46567487720.00456285480.005195617798.88665008540.00540924070.0023880005-5.46567487720.00495529170.0067472458

10.57580184940.35584259030.2744741440.21413898470000000.00686740880.01113033290.00484466550.0076980591000.01504898070.0120735168000.00397491460.00360107420.00657367710.01169061660.00405120850.00350952150.00595855710.01403331760.00128173830.00219726560.00750732420.01033401490.00462341310.00176239010.01250457760.00299835210.00550079350.00405883790.00666809080.0035781860.01850891110.00908660890.01456451420.01396942140.01719665530.00747680660.00822067260.01133728030.02187919620.00973129270.01614379880.01401519780.01771163940.01200199130.00991821290.01856231690.02436161040.01440620420.00886821750.01556682590.00945186610.01404118540.0029077530.00777101520.00143617390.00155067440.00688791280.00489187240.06137490270.09023118020.01352596280.01906681060.01674556730.01661062240.00691795350.00562477110.02461051940.01757335660.00225067140.0039443970.00943374630.01419258120.00462722780.00455093380.00474166870.0251884460.00380325320.00398635860.00798416140.01239013670.00194549560.0056457520.0078506470.00891113280.00542449950.00263977050.00761413570.00698852540.00322723390.00671768190.00749206540.00946044920.00535964970.00840759280.00869750980.00270843510.00223922730.00671768190.0060729980.00233459470.00268173220.00381183620.00416564940.00235748290.00456285480.0051956177

Fisheries SustainabilityOther Distingishing FeaturesRAPFISH Ordination (Median with Error Bars showing 95%Confidence of Median)

10.70675659180.75396728520.41861343380.22731590270000000.00835990910.01280260090.00489807130.0118942261000.01998901370.0170173645000.00431060790.00422668460.00658321380.01337575910.0049896240.00350952150.00758552550.01429748540.00131988530.00292205810.00919914250.01277542110.0053176880.00266265870.01482200620.00370979310.0069808960.00485992430.00677490230.00432586670.01897811890.00945281980.01678085330.03588867190.02038955690.00773239140.00930786130.01182937620.02547454830.01108741760.018617630.01953887940.01856327060.01585388180.01091766360.02680015560.02649116520.01979827880.01125240330.01794624330.0104889870.01496958730.00300788880.01750612260.00153172020.001816690.00733947750.00637006760.06720066070.09436106680.01955032350.01930618290.02761220930.02598333360.01010894780.00651741030.02687549590.01875305180.0042839050.0046119690.01080322270.01980972290.00689697270.0046119690.00489425660.02679061890.00395965580.00408172610.00988769530.01320266720.00299072270.00578308110.01031494140.00897979740.00596237180.00516510010.00910949710.00781250.00575637820.00940704350.01295471190.01033782960.00542831420.00842285160.00940704350.00705718990.00308799740.00757789610.01096343990.00339508060.00301647190.0047407150.00540924070.00238800050.00495529170.0067472458

Fisheries SustainabilityOther Distingishing Features2D RAPFISH Ordinations (Median with Inter-quartile Error Bars (50% of scatter)

1

Fisheries SustainabilityOther Distingishing FeaturesRAPFISH Ordination - Monte Carlo Scatter Plot

Chart162.7857.4348.2165.1657.9951.13

SerangStatus Pengembangan Ekonomi Lokal Kabupaten Serang

Sheet1DimensiSerangDimensiCirebonDimensiPontianakSikkaDimensiBitungDimensiTernate1Kelompok Sasaran62.78Ekologi43.13Ekologi42.7453.16Ekologi51.53Ekologi55.32Faktor Lokasi57.43Ekonomi47.04Ekonomi51.0354.52Ekonomi51.74Ekonomi48.383Kesinergian dan Fokus Kebijakan48.21Sosial48.08Sosial46.3455.47Sosial50.91Sosial47.674Pembangunan Berkelanjutan65.16Kelembagaan44.93Kelembagaan33.1947.72Kelembagaan51.92Kelembagaan22.35Tata Pemerintahan57.99Teknologi61.6Teknologi51.6749.46Teknologi55.4Teknologi49.086Proses Manajemen51.13Hankam53.58Hankam41.8231.36Hankam41.82Hankam49.85

Sheet1

Status Keberlanjutan Pengelolaan Sumberdaya Perikanan dan Kelautan Kabupaten Sikka

Sheet2

SerangCirebonPontianakSikkaBitungTernate

Sheet3

SerangStatus Pengembangan Ekonomi Lokal Kabupaten Serang

CirebonStatus Keberlanjutan Pengelolaan Sumberdaya Perikanan dan Kelautan Kabupaten Cirebon

PontianakStatus Keberlanjutan Pengelolaan Sumberdaya Perikanan dan Kelautan Kabupaten Pontianak

BitungStatus Keberlanjutan Pengelolaan Sumberdaya Perikanan dan Kelautan Kabupaten Bitung

TernateStatus Keberlanjutan Pengelolaan Sumberdaya Perikanan dan Kelautan Kabupaten Ternate

Chart11.01827621681.38488768991.83481976191.90731050352.11465448972.17648320542.33884812512.88308722782.76567844831.66385652941.32138825781.66389464490.5881652951

AttributeRoot Mean Square Change in Ordination when Selected Attribute Removed (on Sustainability scale 0 to 100)Leverage of Attributes

RapScoresAbbreviationKELOMPOK SASARANPeraturan tentang Kemudahan InvestasiInformasi Prospek BisnisKepastian Berusaha dan HukumKeamananKampanye Peluang BerusahaPusat Layanan InvestasiUpaya Fasilitasi Permodalan dari PemdaPromosi Produk UKM dari PemdaUpaya Pemda untuk Peningkatan Teknologi, Manajemen dan Kelembagaan LokalFasilitasi Pelatihan Kewirausahaan bagi Pelaku Usaha BaruPendampingan dan monitoring bisnis pelaku usaha baruInsentif pemda dalam bentuk pemberian dana stimulan, dan keringanan biaya perijinanKecepatan pengurusan ijin bagi investasi baruKELOMPOK SASARAN1111111111111Reference PELGOOD - best attribute values2210221112212BAD - worst attribute values0002000000000UP - half good, half bad2210222000000DOWN - opposite to UP0002000112212Anchor PEL221022111221022102211122002210221112000221022111000022102211000002210220000000221020000000022100000000002212000000000220200000000020020000000000002000000000000200000000200020000000120002000000212000200000221200020000122120002001112212000202111221200022211122120000221112212001022111221202102211122122210221112212User-entered scoring error limits per attribute:(score is expected to be in interval score-Emin to score+Emax)EminEmaxDEFAULT 95% probability scoring error limits:set at 20% of full attribute scaleError limit above or below score0.24763274190.26489526030.23937635120.20897580680.25984293220.24345403910.26145580410.21358799930.28094896670.2811276615(assumes 0 mean Normal error distribution)DEFAULT 95% probability scoring error limitsset at 20% of full attribute scaleError limit above or below score0.2000000030.2000000030.19663842020.2000000030.2000000030.2000000030.17471782860.19663842020.19663842020.2000000030.2000000030.19663842020.200000003(assumes 0 mean Normal error distribution)

RapAnalysis2D MDS ResultsRotated& Flipped & ScaledKELOMPOK SASARAN0.31610122320.18597105150.3538797498-0.096303328962.7772445679-1.9275226593GOOD1.39684486390.41541400551.4569226503-0.0334765391000BAD-1.4622197151-0.3638368547-1.5064338446-0.03347638620-5.8182535172UP0.9400924444-1.59481501580.48763069511.785896182167.290740966850DOWN-0.5646889211.3734055758-0.1836616546-1.47356188344.6376342773-50ANCHORS:1.41920089720.05707008021.38426101210.318134665597.5479965214.96915483471.3682727814-0.28931665421.24403858180.638938546292.81611633314.81140041351.2324728966-0.62845182421.02383840080.930427968585.38534545923.75428009031.0250734091-0.92241090540.74643796681.159503340776.024322509830.78230094910.7723843455-1.14995932580.44280523061.312595725165.778083801335.47916793820.2304929197-1.3807016611-0.14069147411.392720341746.087684631337.9373855591-0.1105908975-1.393453598-0.47312429551.31533145934.869567871135.5630989075-0.4491828084-1.3267395496-0.78225636481.161928653724.437744140630.8567085266-0.7669773698-1.182965517-1.05105948450.939646482515.366843223624.037103653-1.0428489447-0.9818800092-1.26434433460.67309409388.169435501115.8592910767-1.2673281431-0.7110498548-1.4097051620.35276606683.2641594416.0316443443-1.4247690439-0.4011336565-1.48010885720.01235564240.8883503079-4.4121294022-1.4594175816-0.0494478308-1.4210580587-0.33606374262.8810501099-15.1016178131-1.40676808360.3004002869-1.2782646418-0.65975469357.6996879578-25.0324382782-1.28117191790.642274797-1.0671886206-0.956570327314.8225574493-34.1387252808-1.08591949940.9412404895-0.8001912236-1.193670272823.8325233459-41.412940979-0.84120005371.1700623035-0.5039129257-1.350087046633.8305892944-46.2117996216-0.28473940491.35688877110.0820920169-1.384010314953.6056289673-47.25256347660.05808943881.37610471250.4179086089-1.312398910564.9379348755-45.05552673340.39924079181.31491339210.7309625149-1.163651347275.5020980835-40.49196243290.71941798931.17497181891.0030721426-0.94444018684.6845779419-33.76657485960.98935753110.9695889951.2095035315-0.67530167191.6507110596-25.50941848751.21280336380.70214825871.3547586203-0.358515471296.5524215698-15.7904357911.36797785760.39570716021.4238893986-0.022054176898.8852767944-5.4678206444Stress =0.1340847611IterationStressDeltaSquared Correlation (RSQ) =0.953439891310.2126878649899999982852417500000Number of iterations =220.21236231920.0003255457Memory needed (words) =6534Return value (error if > 0)0Rotation angle (degrees) =15.2459030151RAPFISH PARAMETERS USED FOR THIS ANALYSIS# fisheries =1# reference fisheries =4# anchor fisheries =24Row# of 1st fishery =2Row# of GOOD fishery =5Row# of BAD fishery =6Row# of UP fishery =7Row# of DOWN fishery =8Column letter with fisheries names =ARow# of 1st anchor fishery =9# attributes =13Column letter of 1st attribute =D

RapAnalysis

Real Kelompok SasaranReferencesAnchorsLED SustainabilityOther Distingishing FeaturesRALED OrdinationGOODBADUPDOWN

Distances000000000000000000000000000008000000000000000000000000000026.519298553550.519294738800000000000000000000000000022.652631759626.652631759636.07719421390000000000000000000000000014.919299125726.91929817223.600000381559.677188873300000000000000000000000008446.519294738822.652631759630.91929817200000000000000000000000011.86666679387.866666793842.652629852318.785964965834.78596496583.86666679380000000000000000000000011.866666793811.866666793838.652629852314.785964965838.78596496587.86666679384000000000000000000000011.866666793815.866666793834.652629852310.785964965842.785961151111.86666679388400000000000000000000015.733333587619.733333587630.78596496586.91929817246.652629852315.733333587611.86666679387.86666679383.86666679380000000000000000000022.652631759626.652631759623.866666793812.210526466447.466663360622.652631759618.785964965814.785964965810.78596496586.9192986488000000000000000000022.652631759630.652631759619.866666793816.2105274243.466663360626.652631759622.785964965818.785964965814.785964965810.919298172400000000000000000022.652631759634.65263366715.866666793820.2105274239.466667175330.652631759626.785964965822.785964965818.785964965814.9192991257840000000000000000022.652631759638.652629852311.866666793824.2105274235.466667175334.652629852330.785964965826.785964965822.785964965818.9192981721284000000000000000026.519298553542.5192985535828.077194213931.600000381538.519298553534.65263366730.652631759626.652631759622.785964965815.866666793811.86666679387.86666679383.866666793800000000000000026.519298553546.5192985535432.077194213927.600000381542.519298553538.65263366734.65263366730.652631759626.785964965819.866666793815.866666793811.86666679387.866666793840000000000000026.519298553550.5192947388036.077194213923.600000381546.519294738842.652629852338.652629852334.652629852330.785964965823.866666793819.866666793815.866666793811.866666793884000000000000026.519298553546.5192947388440.077194213919.600000381550.519294738846.652629852342.652629852338.652629852334.785964965827.866666793823.866666793819.866666793815.8666667938128400000000000022.652631759642.65262985237.866666793843.943859100315.733333587646.652629852350.519294738846.519294738842.519294738838.652629852331.733333587627.733333587623.733333587619.733333587615.866666793811.86666679387.86666679383.86666679380000000000022.652631759638.652629852311.866666793847.943859100311.733333587642.652629852346.519294738850.519294738846.519294738842.652629852335.733333587631.733333587627.733333587623.733333587619.866666793815.866666793811.86666679387.86666679384000000000022.652631759634.652629852315.866666793851.94385910037.733333587638.652629852342.519294738846.519294738850.519294738846.652629852339.733333587635.733333587631.733333587627.733333587623.866666793819.866666793815.866666793811.86666679388400000000018.785964965830.785964965819.733333587655.81052398683.866666793834.785964965838.652629852342.652629852346.652629852350.519294738843.599998474139.599998474135.599998474131.600000381527.733333587623.733333587619.733333587615.733333587611.86666679387.86666679383.86666679380000000011.866666793823.866666793826.652631759650.51929473883.05263185527.866666793831.733333587635.733333587639.733333587643.599998474150.519294738846.519298553542.519298553538.519298553534.65263366730.652631759626.652631759622.652631759618.785964965814.785964965810.78596496586.9192986488000000011.866666793819.866666793830.652631759646.51929855357.05263185523.866666793827.733333587631.733333587635.733333587639.599998474146.519298553550.519294738846.519298553542.519298553538.652629852334.65263366730.652631759626.652631759622.785964965818.785964965814.785964965810.919298172400000011.866666793815.866666793834.65263366742.519298553511.052632331819.866666793823.733333587627.733333587631.733333587635.599998474142.519298553546.519298553550.519294738846.519298553542.652629852338.652629852334.65263366730.652631759626.785964965822.785964965818.785964965814.9192991257840000011.866666793811.866666793838.652629852338.519298553515.052632331815.866666793819.733333587623.733333587627.733333587631.600000381538.519298553542.519298553546.519298553550.519294738846.652629852342.652629852338.652629852334.652629852330.785964965826.785964965822.785964965818.919298172128400008842.519298553534.65263366718.9192981721215.866666793819.866666793823.866666793827.733333587634.65263366738.652629852342.652629852346.652629852350.519294738846.519298553542.519298553538.519298553534.65263366730.652631759626.652631759622.785964965815.866666793811.86666679387.86666679383.86666679380008446.519298553530.652631759622.919298172811.866666793815.866666793819.866666793823.733333587630.652631759634.65263366738.652629852342.652629852346.519298553550.519294738846.519298553542.519298553538.65263366734.65263366730.652631759626.785964965819.866666793815.866666793811.86666679387.86666679384008050.519294738826.652631759626.91929817247.866666793811.866666793815.866666793819.733333587626.652631759630.652631759634.65263366738.652629852342.519298553546.519298553550.519294738846.519294738842.652629852338.652629852334.652629852330.785964965823.866666793819.866666793815.866666793811.8666667938840

LeverageAttributes63.7955207825100059.924579620450.535919189596.383712768690.372116088981.554801940971.069671630960.104690551839.909458160428.753761291518.579885482810.11378860473.93912482260.56593579050.58319735533.62326073659.679882049618.132366180428.22718048138.912544250558.988521575970.308311462480.667854309189.297729492295.230659484998.627449035698.626304626564.1621322632100060.524539947550.502716064596.589920043990.699073791582.02676391671.618072509860.576068878239.805328369128.158161163317.55331230168.81814002992.5218431952.50795841220.81437730793.69573020949.682553291318.026906967228.057863235538.810085296659.463844299371.232910156282.006248474190.912216186596.999954223697.000495910698.716079711960.9424247742100061.374031066950.029201507696.790695190491.129821777382.663543701272.320472717361.160724639939.776897430427.677524566716.72197532657.74554395687.7471976282.77172255520.71492701773.46596121799.178503990217.301856994627.248043060338.050525665359.32675170971.545188903882.647232055791.744422912691.744537353596.646148681698.688308715864.6845550537100061.685771942150.177680969296.9731597991.483802795483.137680053772.758171081561.380004882839.40845489527.134965896616.164903640716.16446113598.38806438453.04919743540.71031552553.28534555448.869792938216.860095977826.816772460937.85251998959.835712432972.318496704183.533485412683.533302307191.125762939596.442459106498.751564025964.8918991089100061.66493225150.340606689597.139732360891.805320739783.514648437573.026298522961.435661315939.214298248327.029996871927.029449462916.93839073188.74220943453.26263260840.76338207723.17141866688.606572151216.548524856626.606708526637.891387939560.18089675972.629455566472.629539489782.887741088990.843681335496.351799011298.817062377964.9537277222100061.283142089850.607028961297.256805419991.975929260383.631271362372.987815856961.275207519539.261337280339.261913299627.615186691317.21746635448.93264389043.42181730270.83957046273.14438509948.529332160916.529663085926.785564422638.25028991760.391654968360.391525268672.207771301382.780334472790.822746276996.351783752498.892738342360.4383964539100050.482337951749.767566680997.354873657292.214431762784.076416015673.760795593362.50432205250.743785858238.6684722927.118064880416.93652534488.90321159363.47257089610.87783646583.08095288288.26496601116.095813751226.179548263537.468544006349.201309204161.25262069772.837814331183.087211608990.862243652396.275489807198.816360473659.8941574097100076.806861877437.924854278697.316131591891.949989318883.373229980572.724929809661.517723083551.785678863539.145893096927.312147140517.10446357739.13746929173.69822573661.0188357833.22448134428.601254463216.746923446726.900722503737.675735473648.317329406761.079727172973.018341064583.283370971790.953735351696.327148437598.925666809160.0115661621100077.118591308637.8307075597.362976074292.008529663183.52738189773.209800720273.20956420951.619979858438.988296508827.358497619617.2404804239.27326583863.81964015961.04500234133.19081425678.57339286816.665081024226.544483184826.544225692748.477100372361.247913360673.059295654383.254798889290.848335266196.303436279399.016983032264.4411010742100077.331344604537.845710754497.49439239592.289627075284.207374572884.207885742273.382400512751.671577453639.242733001727.750513076817.75989532479.70727062234.02551221851.05653274063.02359795578.299859046916.035167694116.036588668826.578811645548.47735595761.043811798172.683280944882.759490966890.519912719796.168884277399.072372436564.0986328125100076.939140319837.980041503997.775512695393.000602722293.003028869683.778617858973.04821014451.830245971739.706676483228.387514114418.380784988410.17319774634.25121212011.0609347822.7622165687.62801361087.629642963416.464038848926.926658630448.323181152360.566864013772.005912780882.098297119190.025207519595.917861938599.050659179761.1133499146100075.379951477138.786361694398.115692138798.117675781291.54467010582.316383361871.784500122151.321727752739.501800537128.345930099518.34632682810.09947586064.0724678040.78533071282.25416159632.25843596468.482851028417.279012680127.502099990848.202899932960.135982513471.438072204681.555076599189.596679687595.624267578198.880004882863.3654098511100075.123939514238.798751831199.853736877496.67183685390.317314147981.458000183171.390098571851.619327545240.039726257328.914556503318.803638458310.37469005584.20298862460.73705363270.74348765613.94274854669.887945175218.270586013828.010158538847.978385925359.662544250570.923583984481.155654907289.356285095295.509956359998.9045639038-1.19629859920-6.596312999750-504.779102325414.789576530523.581369430.243612289434.423583984435.37977600131.725957870525.694581985525.694643020616.73927497865.9390015602-5.422565937-16.597328186-26.6458034515-35.6009979248-42.5447616577-46.8928260803-46.3678359985-42.910949707-36.9789733887-36.978969574-27.9563999176-17.2218456268-5.9587144852-1.4790720940-6.471670150850-504.640840053614.514833450323.34482765230.167303085334.530540466335.817623138432.498531341632.498760223425.262706756616.41035652165.812066555-5.2204828262-16.117477417-26.0441894531-35.0372543335-42.1477661133-46.6639251709-46.5016098022-43.3458442688-43.3458786011-36.2168388367-27.2648506165-16.7531414032-5.8279042244-1.79420661930-6.317288398750-504.57093906414.380661010723.290920257630.246683120734.726406097436.333602905336.330844879231.613622665424.518589019815.90382575995.6802196503-4.9723930359-15.6496953964-25.5395584106-34.6293373108-41.8723945618-46.5026092529-46.660282135-46.6598472595-42.0919532776-35.0887870789-26.3828926086-16.2523822784-5.720916748-2.79567813870-0.180302202750-5012.093686103823.521230697633.886127471941.982921600347.297737121649.862644195647.479122161942.240947723434.322105407724.709205627413.22554492951.1823549271-10.9387760162-22.1922264099-32.5395011902-40.7576980591-45.9566078186-48.3732032776-46.1476402283-41.0284233093-33.1680526733-23.3841819763-11.91842174530.1166145876-1.17573308940-5.618278026650-505.701931476616.329431533826.030609130933.482906341638.254959106438.74276733436.708518981932.079254150425.141761779816.77019316.6905684471-4.1048316956-15.4053459167-26.0858879