i
MOBILE BANKING PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION AND SERVICE
DELIVERY IN ECOBANK RWANDA LIMITED
RUGERI NZIZA
MBA/0540/13
A Research Project Report Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for
the Award of the Degree of Master of Business Administration (Project
Management) of Mount Kenya University
OCTOBER 2016
ii
DECLARATION
This research project is my original work and has not been presented to any other
institution for any academic award. No part of this research project should be reproduced
without the author’s consent or that of Mount Kenya University.
Student’s Name: Rugeri Nziza Reg. No: MBA/0540/13
Signature…………………………… Date………………………………………
This research project has been submitted with my approval as Mount Kenya University
Supervisor.
Name of Supervisor: Onsoti Nyabera
Signature…………………………… Date………………………………………
iii
DEDICATION
Dedicated to my husband Mr. Eric Milenge and my beloved family Rugerinyange for
their love, upbringing and parental guidance.
iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This research project report could not have been completed without the assistance and
support of others. Firstly, I am grateful to the Almighty God, for His divine guidance
during my academic progress and the production of this research project report. I am
equally indebted to my supervisor Mr. Onsoti Nyabera, for the valuable time he has
sacrificed to guide me during the preparation of this research project report. Last but not
least, I extend my gratitude the management and staff Ecobank who granted me
permission to use their mobile banking project as a case study and also provided both
primary and secondary data during the writing of the final project.
v
ABSTRACT
The study focuses on Mobile banking project implementation and service delivery in
banking institutions in Rwanda using Ecobank Rwanda Limited Main Branch as a case
study. The study was guided by their specific objectives which include: assessing the
usage of Mobile Banking services, establishing the factors that influence customer
adoption of mobile banking services, and determining the contribution of mobile banking
on service delivery. The researcher used a descriptive case study design because the study
aimed to establish the link between mobile banking project and service delivery using
Ecobank as a case study. The researcher selected a sample size of 167 who were selected
from a population of 258 people by use of random sampling. Primary data was collected
by use of the questionnaire and interview guide while secondary data was gathered from
review of secondary sources such as market reports, HR manuals, brochures, Ecobank
website, etc. Validity and reliability of research instruments was measured by use
standardized pilot tests and collecting data from people who had experience on mobile
banking. Before data was entered into the computer, the researcher coded and cross
checked responses to remove any errors. The data was then entered into the computer
using SPSS v16.0 which produced tables that were backed by frequency and percentage
presentation. The analysis and interpretation of findings was then done based on the
SPSS output. Narrative data from interviews and secondary sources was analyzed where
opinions, ideas, beliefs, attitudes, statements or arguments were classified into themes,
categorized and then discussed within the context of interpretation of findings. Findings
show that the most frequently used mobile banking services were payment of bills (99%),
checking account status (99%), funds transfer (98%), accessing bank statement (97%),
purchasing bank products (96%), changing password (90%) and requesting a loan (93%).
Additionally, factors related to perceived use which influenced customers to adopt
Ecobank mobile banking were attracted reliability (100%), efficiency (97%) and speed
(87%). In regard to perceived ease of use, customers were influenced by clear
instructional materials (93%), followed by ease to learn (83%) and presence of co-
operative staffs (62%). However, in terms of perceived risk and security, 99% felt not
legally protected, 98% felt they were vulnerable to MB signal failure, 89% felt that
fraudsters can access their accounts while 83% felt that Ecobank security policies did not
guarantee safety. Pertaining to its contribution in service delivery, the study finds that
MB is quick in providing services (100%), easy to access (100%), saves time (99%),
ensures physical safety (98%), saves money (97%) and provides customer comfort
(95%). The researcher also conducted a Pearson correlation test which showed that there
was a strong relationship between mobile banking and service delivery in Ecobank. The
strength of the relationship is shown by a positive correlation value of 0.892 with the
level of significance at P-value of 0.01. There is need to sensitize mobile banking
customers in Ecobank about the security measures available to protect their accounts
from unauthorized access, and continuously educate customers about new ways of
developing tight security for their accounts.
vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DECLARATION............................................................................................................... ii
DEDICATION.................................................................................................................. iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ............................................................................................... iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS ................................................................................................ vi
LIST OF FIGURES ...........................................................................................................x
LIST OF TABLES ........................................................................................................... xi
LIST OF ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS ....................................................... xi
DEFINITIONS OF KEY TERMS ................................................................................ xiii
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION ..............................................................................1
1.0 Introduction ....................................................................................................................1
1.1 Background of the study ................................................................................................1
1.2 Problem Statement .........................................................................................................3
1.3 Objectives ......................................................................................................................4
1.3.1 General Objective .......................................................................................................4
1.3.2 Specific Objectives .....................................................................................................5
1.4 Research Questions ........................................................................................................5
1.5 Significance of the Study ...............................................................................................5
1.6 Limitations of the Study.................................................................................................6
1.7 Scope of the Study .........................................................................................................7
1.8 Organization of the Study ..............................................................................................8
CHAPTER TWO: REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE ......................................9
2.0 Introduction ....................................................................................................................9
vii
2.1 Theoretical Literature .....................................................................................................9
2.1.1 Mobile Banking Concept ............................................................................................9
2.1.2 Mobile Banking Tools/Devices ................................................................................10
2.1.3 Mobile Banking Services ..........................................................................................12
2.1.4 Factors that Influence Adoption of Mobile Banking ................................................13
2.1.5 Mobile Banking and Service Delivery in the Banking Sector ..................................15
2.2 Empirical Literature .....................................................................................................17
2.3 Critical Review and Research Gaps Identification ......................................................22
2.4 Theoretical Framework ................................................................................................24
2.4.1 Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA)...........................................................................24
2.4.2 Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) ....................................................................25
2.4.3 Diffusion of Innovation Theory (DIT) ......................................................................26
2.6 Summary ......................................................................................................................30
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH METHODOLOGY ..............................................31
3.0 Introduction ..................................................................................................................31
3.1 Research Design...........................................................................................................31
3.2 Target Population .........................................................................................................31
3.3 Sample Design .............................................................................................................32
3.3.1 Sample Size ...............................................................................................................32
3.3.2 Sampling Techniques ................................................................................................32
3.4 Data Collection Methods .............................................................................................33
3.4.1 Data Collection Instruments .....................................................................................33
3.4.2 Administration of Data Collection Instruments ........................................................34
viii
3.4.3 Validity and Reliability .............................................................................................34
3.5 Data Analysis Procedure ..............................................................................................35
3.6 Ethical Considerations .................................................................................................36
CHAPTER FOUR: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION ....................................................38
4.0 Introduction ..................................................................................................................38
4.1 Response Rate ..............................................................................................................38
4.2 Respondents’ Background Information .......................................................................39
4.3 Research Findings ........................................................................................................41
4.3.1 Ecobank Mobile Banking Accounts and Devices Used ...........................................41
4.3.2 Usage of Mobile Banking services in Ecobank ........................................................42
4.3.3 Factors that influence customer adoption of mobile banking in Ecobank ................46
4.3.4 Contribution of mobile banking project on service delivery ....................................52
4.3.5 Pearson Correlation ...................................................................................................55
CHAPTER FIVE: SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS ...57
5.0 Introduction ..................................................................................................................57
5.1 Summary of Findings ...................................................................................................57
5.1.1 Usage of Mobile Banking services in Ecobank ........................................................57
5.1.2 Contribution of mobile banking project on service delivery in Ecobank .................58
5.2 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................58
5.3 Recommendations ........................................................................................................59
5.4 Area for further research ..............................................................................................61
REFERENCES ..................................................................................................................62
APPENDIX 1: LETTER OF INTRODUCTION ..............................................................72
ix
APPENDIX 2: LETTER OF ACCEPTANCE ..................................................................73
APPENDIX 3: INTERVIEW GUIDE FOR BANK STAFFS ...........................................74
APPENDIX 4: QUESTIONNAIRE FOR BANK CUSTOMERS ....................................76
x
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 2.1: Technology Acceptance Model……………………………………………25
Figure 2.2: Conceptual Framework……………………………………………………30
xi
LIST OF TABLES
Table 3.1: Target Population……………………………………………………………..33
Table 3.2: Correlation Coefficient Guide………………………………………………..37
Table 4.1: Respondents’ Background Information………………………………………41
Table 4.2: Possession of Mobile Banking Accounts and Devices Used…………………42
Table 4.3: Frequency of Using Mobile Banking Services in Ecobank…………………44
Table 4.4: Perceived Usefulness…………………………………………………………48
Table 4.5: Perceived Ease of Use………………………………………………………..50
Table 4.6: Perceived Risk or Security……………………………………………………52
Table 4.7: Mobile Banking Project and Service Delivery……………………………….54
Table 4.8: Pearson Correlation…………………………………………………………56
xii
LIST OF ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS
ATMs Automatic Teller Machines
BK Bank of Kigali
DIT Diffusion of Innovation Theory
FSPs Financial Service Providers
GSMA Global System for Mobile Association
HR Human Resource
ICT Information and Communication Technology
MB Mobile Banking
M-Banking Mobile Banking
MKU Mount Kenya University
MM Mobile Money
MMS Mobile Messaging Service
MMT Mobile Money Transfer
PC Personal Computer
PDA Personal Digital Assistant
PIN Personal Identification Number
RURA Rwanda Utilities and Regulatory Agency
SIM Subscriber Identification Module
SMS Short Messaging Service
TAM Technology Acceptance Model
TRA Theory of Reasoned Action
WAP WAP Wireless Application Protocol
xiii
DEFINITIONS OF KEY TERMS
Banking institution: A business organization registered and licensed to deal in lending
money obtained from depositors and the sale of bonds, securities or other obligations of
any kind.
Customer: A person, organization or group of people who make use of bank services or
products.
Mobile banking: An arrangement that allows customers of a financial institution to carry
out transactions by use of mobile devices such as a mobile phone, iPad or tablet.
Project: Planned set of interrelated activities that are executed by a banking institution
over a fixed period and within certain costs and other limitations.
Project implementation: The process of executing project activities to ensure that the
targets and plans are achieved.
Service delivery: The process of providing a service to customers in a banking
institution.
1
CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION
1.0 Introduction
This research focuses on Mobile Banking Project implementation and service delivery in
the banking sector by considering Ecobank Mobile Banking project as a case study. This
chapter therefore highlights the background, statement of the problem, research
objectives, scope and significance of the study.
1.1 Background of the study
Over the past 15 years technology has increasingly been employed in the delivery of
services. The adoption of technology into service industries is becoming a strong trend as
service providers are now being urged by industry bodies to invest in technology
(Kwashie, 2012) as a way of securing their future in the electronic age.
The role of technology in service organizations has been predominantly employed to
reduce costs and eliminate uncertainties. In the service sector, technology has been used
to standardize services by reducing the employee/customer interface (Gonzalez, 2008).
The majority of consumers now more than ever prefer to opt for a technology-based
service delivery over that of the employee.
In the banking sector, technological progress has tremendously improved service delivery
by ensuring convenience/accuracy, feedback/complaint management, efficiency, queue
management, accessibility, cost effectiveness and customization. Service delivery has
been defined by Adewoye (2013) as the distribution of services to meet customer needs,
demands and preferences.
2
One of the most important technologies adopted by the banking sector to improve
effectiveness, convenience, efficiency and time management in service delivery has been
the adoption mobile banking. The technology emphasizes provision of banking services
anywhere, anytime to anybody with the sole objective of enhancing customer outreach
and flexibility in transactions (Carr, 2007).
Mobile banking is a system that allows customers of a financial institution to conduct a
number of financial transactions through a mobile device such as a mobile phone or
personal digital assistant (PDA). It also refers to provision and availment of banking and
financial services with the help of mobile telecommunication devices (Tiwari, Buse &
Herstatt, 2007). Services offered include mobile money transfers and payments, mini-
statements and checking account history, alerts on account activity, monitoring of term
deposits, access to loan statements, access to card statements, insurance policy
management (Tiwari & Buse, 2007).
The emergence of mobile banking projects in Africa was first implemented in Kenya in
2007 (Godoy, Tortora, Sonnenschein and Kendall, 2012). As the new wave sweeps
towards a cashless economy, Rwanda has equally kept pace. Telecom companies and
banks through mobile banking to create a platform for the introduction of the cashless
economy that will help to bring on board the unbanked. Banque Populaire, Eco Bank,
FINABANK, I&M Bank and Bank of Kigali (BK) among others have already embraced
the technology which enables clients to conduct banking transactions via their mobile
phone handsets thus curbing the long queues within the bank's premises.
3
Ecobank Mobile Banking Project involves the delivery of financial services to bank
customers through various mobile channels. Mobile banking products include e-product
(such as e-statements, e-alerts, SMS banking) internet banking (such as online and real-
time account information (Sonko, 2011), account statements and history, term deposits,
loan/standing instruction enquiries, balance enquiry, transaction details), transfers and
payment services such as foreign exchange, western union and rapid transfer (Petrova,
2002), loans (personal loan, car and motor cycle loan, mortgages), Ecobank Mobile
money (deposit and withdraw money, send and receive money, purchase airtime, pay for
bills, goods and services and check account balance), ATM and VISA card (Rivari,
2005).
The focus of the study was to provide academicians with a fact base on the relevance and
frequency of usage of mobile banking services in Ecobank Rwanda Limited, Mobile
Banking devices used, factors influencing customer adoption of mobile banking services
in Ecobank Rwanda Limited and the contribution of mobile banking project on service
delivery.
1.2 Problem Statement
Mobile banking projects offer opportunities for improving service delivery and increasing
revenues in banking institutions. These include monetizing the value of customer
analytics, delivering greater real-time access to products and services, and conducting
targeted marketing campaigns based upon the knowledge of consumer preferences that
banks collect, promoting convenience, flexibility and speed of delivery (Delloitte and
Touche, 2010).
4
Rwanda has been identified as one of the eight (8) fastest growing mobile banking
economies in the world (MTN/BK Joint Media Releases, June 28, 2012) because of her
commitment to financial sector reforms one of which is to speed up service delivery
through technological progress.
Amidst this technological revolution, Ecobank Rwanda implemented mobile banking
projects in order improve efficiency, flexibility and speed of service delivery so as to
compete favorably in the Rwandan financial sector.
However, there is no available academic research that has been conducted in Rwanda
using Ecobank as a case study to establish the role of mobile banking towards service
delivery. This means that there no academic data on whether mobile banking improves
service delivery in Ecobank. The research problem for this study therefore is: “what is the
role of mobile banking on service delivery in Ecobank Rwanda Limited between 2010
and 2015?”
1.3 Objectives
The study was guided by two types of objectives. Those included the general objective
and specific objectives as indicated below:
1.3.1 General Objective
The main objective of the study was to examine the contribution of mobile banking
project implementation on service delivery in the banking sector focusing on Ecobank
Rwanda Limited Main Branch, which is located in Nyarugenge District Kigali City.
5
1.3.2 Specific Objectives
i. To assess the usage of Mobile Banking services in Ecobank Rwanda Limited
Main Branch in Kigali City.
ii. To examine the factors that influence customer adoption of mobile banking in
Ecobank Rwanda Limited - Main Branch in Kigali City.
iii. To determine the contribution of mobile banking project on service delivery in
Ecobank Rwanda Limited Main Branch in Kigali City.
1.4 Research Questions
i. To what extent are Mobile Banking services used in Ecobank Rwanda Limited -
Main Branch in Kigali City?
ii. What are the factors that have influenced customer adoption of mobile banking in
Ecobank Rwanda Limited - Main Branch in Kigali City?
iii. What is the contribution of mobile banking project on service delivery in Ecobank
Rwanda Limited - Main Branch in Kigali City?
1.5 Significance of the Study
To Ecobank Rwanda Limited: The findings will enable Ecobank Rwanda Limited to
come up with realistic policies for improving its mobile banking services since it is used
by many mobile phone subscribers. The findings especially on challenges are expected to
remind the technical staff about the implications of their technology in creating quality
mobile banking services.
Other banking institutions: The findings of this study will be seen as a contribution to
existing works on mobile banking and performance of banks. This will help to develop
the literature on mobile banking.
6
To Mount Kenya University: Indeed, this will help other researchers and scholars in
building up academic knowledge in a wide range of issues about financial services
delivery. Therefore, the final project report will be put in the MKU library which will add
to the stock of academic resources.
To the Researcher: The study will also help the researcher to obtain a Masters of
Business Administration in Project Management from MKU. This is because the study
forms a partial requirement for the award.
Bank customers: The study will highlight the importance of mobile banking over brick
and mortar banks. This will encourage people to adopt this banking platform so as to
easily access bank services on the move.
Other research students and scholars: The final project report will act as a reference
manual for other research students and scholars. This will help to increase knowledge in
the academic field
1.6 Limitations of the Study
This research was limited by the following factors:
Due to lack of documented case study information of Mobile banking services in
Rwanda, the researcher lacked enough empirical data for complementing primary data.
As such the researcher was forced to rely solely on studies from other countries when
trying to compile empirical literature.
The study was limited to the role of mobile banking on service delivery in banks, yet
there are many other factors that influence service delivery in banks. Therefore, even if
7
the relationship between the two variables was found out to be very significant, it remains
unfounded whether mobile banking has promoted service delivery in exclusion of other
factors.
Mobile banking is a new service that has been recently introduced in Rwanda. For that
matter, some respondents especially customers did not fully understand how it operates.
For this reason the researcher encountered some poor/irrelevant responses during
interviews. However, respondents were interviewed in the local language for easy
response.
1.7 Scope of the Study
The scope of this study refers to the limits or coverage of the study. It involves subject
scope, geographical scope and time scope.
Subject scope: The study focuses on mobile banking project and service delivery in
banks in Rwanda. Mobile banking is the independent variable for this study while service
delivery is the dependent variable. These variables were preferred because studies
indicate that banks in Rwanda provide better quality services than other sectors (Pamela
& Lakabamba, 2010). This improvement in service delivery coincided with the adoption
of mobile banking platforms. The focus on these variables was therefore intended to
examine whether the improvement in service delivery was brought about by mobile
banking.
Geographical scope: The study was conducted at Ecobank Rwanda Limited Main
Branch in Kigali City Nyarugenge district. This branch was preferred because it has a big
8
number of customers and as such the data needed to accomplish the work was presumed
to be easy to collect.
Time scope: The study covered the period from 2010-2015. This period was preferred
because it is during this time that the financial sector registered rapid technological
revolution.
1.8 Organization of the Study
This research is divided into five chapters. The first chapter is the general introduction. It
covers the background of the study, statement of the problem, research objectives and
questions, limitations, scope and significance of the study.
Chapter two is the review of related literature and it covers the theoretical literature,
empirical literature, critical review and gaps identification, theoretical framework and
conceptual framework.
Chapter three is the methodology; it covers the research design, target population, sample
design, data collection methods, data analysis and ethical considerations.
Chapter four deals with the presentation, analysis and interpretation of results. It
specifically focuses on the mobile banking devices used, the frequency of usage of
mobile banking services, factors that influence customers to adopt mobile banking
services, contribution of mobile banking on service delivery, and the Pearson correlation
of mobile banking and service delivery in Ecobank Rwanda Limited.
Lastly, chapter five covers the summary of findings, conclusions and recommendations.
9
CHAPTER TWO: REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
2.0 Introduction
In this chapter, the research discusses the related literature on mobile banking project
implementation and service delivery in the banking sector. The literature focuses on
theoretical and empirical literature, critical review and gap identification, theoretical and
conceptual frameworks.
2.1 Theoretical Literature Review
2.1.1 Mobile Banking Concept
Mobile Banking is a system of providing services to a customer to carry out banking
transactions on the devices especially the mobile phone through a cellular service-
provider. Banks have to provide facilities to their customers whenever they are in need
and wherever they are (Tiwari, et al., 2007b). This facility can rather be called,
“anywhere and any moment banking”, but it is restricted to only information about a
person‘s account and not the cash services. Mobile banking operates through short
messages and customers have to configure Short Message Service (SMS). They have to
activate Mobile Messaging Service (MMS) in the mobile phone (Puschel, et al., 2010).
Mobile banking is one of the important channels through which customers can be
migrated from front office operations to indirect channels, in order to save their valuable
time as also that of the executives working in the bank. The time saved can be effectively
utilized for business development and cost reduction.
Mobile devices, especially cellular phones have gained so much prominence in everyday
life that a person cannot survive without this communication channel (Senn, 2000). In
every country the number of consumers using cell phones has increased to unexpected
10
levels. It is believed that at least 90% of these customers have bank accounts in various
banks which use technology and avail themselves of mobile banking services (Muisyo, et
al., 2014). Therefore, banks have chosen mobile banking as one of the best methods for
channel migration of customers to improve service delivery and customers are also
pleased to have these services.
2.1.2 Mobile Banking Tools/Devices
The provision of mobile banking relies on a mobile end-user device; currently there are in
fact two basic types of mobile end- user devices - the mobile (cellular, cell) phone and
the portable handheld computer known as Personal Digital Assistant (PDA).
Mobile Telephone Service
Mobile Telephone service is the most common device for m-banking as compared to
PDAs. Digital mobile telephone services offer voice communication and secure data
communication. Mobile phones are equipped with a smart card (Subscriber Identification
Module card, or SIM card). The SIM card can store user data; text messaging is enabled
trough a special stored application known as Short Message Service (SMS) (Petrova,
2002).
The basic functionality of the SIM card supports additional cervices. The extended
platform is called STK (SIM Application Toolkit Specification). It allows different
operators to load their own applications into the SIM, with full access to the keyboard,
the menus and the communications network.
11
These applications can offer new value-added service to the owner of the mobile handset
– and among them, access to mobile transactions (mobile banking) based on SMS (Lule,
et al., 2012).
The installed mobile device base, the security offered by the platform and the level of
standardization achieved provide a reliable platform for personal financial services.
Currently, services offered to subscribers vary from checking an account balance to
making a bill payment, transferring funds. More innovative services include level alerts,
automatic payment, direct payment (e.g. a car wash). Current developments include
applications based on the standard for mobile devices known as WAP Wireless
Application Protocol (WAP), which allows full access to the Internet (Riivari, 2005).
Senn (2000) also agrees that mobile phones will continue to be an important and
significant part of the part of the underlying infrastructure for mobile commerce and will
be the device of choice for mobile transaction management, digital content delivery, and
telemetry services. Still there is another device which will play a role in transaction
banking applications - the PDA.
Personal Digital Assistant
A personal digital assistant (PDA), also known as a handheld PC, or personal data
assistant (Alexander, 2009) is a mobile device that functions as a personal information
manager. The term evolved from Personal Desktop Assistant, a software term for an
application that prompts or prods the user of a computer with suggestions or provides
quick reference to contacts and other lists.
12
PDAs were largely discontinued in the early 2010s after the widespread adoption of
highly capable, in particular iOS and Android-based, smartphones (Smith & Wempen,
2011).
It must be recognized that nearly all PDAs have the ability to connect to the Internet
which allows the user to electronically connect with his/her bank account on the move. A
PDA has an electronic visual display, enabling it to include a web browser, all models
also have audio capabilities enabling use as a portable media player, and also enabling
most of them to be used as mobile phones (Suri & Jack, 2011).
2.1.3 Mobile Banking Services
Anguelov, et, al. (2004), Ovia (2001) and Chovanova (2006) have identified various
services that are provided by commercial banks through mobile banking. These services
include cash transfers, payment of bills, account statements, account opening, etc.
Cash transfers: This involves the transfer of money from one account to another by use
of mobile devices. It can involve transferring money from a bank account to a mobile
money account as well as transferring money from one physical location to another via
mobile devices. For example, people who live and work in foreign countries may transfer
money to their relatives and friends back home using mobile money.
Payment of bills: This involves effecting a payment for certain services by use of mobile
money. These services may include airtime, water, electricity, school fees, insurance,
purchase of securities on the stock exchange, etc.
Account statements: Through mobile money, a customer can access his/her account
statement and determine how much money balance is available, how many transactions
13
were made on the account, the destination and dates of those transactions, etc. This saves
time from going to the physical ban branch.
Account opening: The prospective customer can also open up an account with the bank
using mobile banking devices after seeking guidance from his/her bank on the procedure.
Other mobile banking services: Other mobile banking services according to the authors,
include electronic check conversion, transfer funds, purchase bank products, change
passwords, request a credit/debit card or cheque book, request a loan and check status,
stock information, tax documents and information/tax payment, currency exchange.
2.1.4 Factors that Influence Adoption of Mobile Banking
There are various factors that can influence users’ adoption of mobile banking. These
factors include demographic characteristics, convenience prior internet knowledge,
security perception, perceived risk and level of awareness about mobile banking.
Demographic factors have also been found to be associated with adoption of different
banking channels, especially internet banking (Al-Ashban and Burney, 2001; Karjaluoto
et al., 2002). For instance, people with high educational attainment may have an aptitude
for computers and possess good information processing skills. These qualities are crucial
in the context of internet banking and therefore a relationship between formal education
and adoption is propounded.
Convenience has been identified as an important adoption factor of innovation
technologies (Pew, 2003).
The author defines convenience goods as a class of consumer products that were
intensively distributed and required minimal time and physical and mental effort to
14
purchase. For example, the 24-hour service availability, home access, world wide access,
time savings, and wide variety of services accessible (Gerrard & Cunningham, 2003) are
seen as drivers of convenience in mobile banking.
Gerrard and Cunningham (2003) contend that convenience is one of the dominating
factors in transaction channel preferences and a key determinant of consumer satisfaction
with mobile banking. Kwashie (2012) also observes that another factor that influences the
consumer adoption of internet banking is the prior experience of technologies, especially
prior experience of computers. Thus, consumer's familiarity with technologies in general
facilitates her appreciation of the potential added value which is inherent in a technology.
The prior computer experience is associated with use of use of PC, the Internet and e-
mail.
Security is one of the very important factors in determining the decision of consumers to
use mobile banking. According to Polatoglu and Ekin, (2001), security comprises of three
dimensions: reliability, safety, and privacy. Consumers’ concerns about security, which
arise from the use of an open public network, have been emphasized as being the most
important factor inhibiting the adoption and use of internet banking (Hamlet and Strube,
2000).
The next factor that influences the adoption of internet banking by customers is the
perceived risk. Eastin (2002) argue that consumer risk perceptions to be a primary
obstacle to the future growth of mobile banking.
Perceived risk is defined in terms of uncertainty and negative consequences associated
with consumer’s actions. Perceived risk increases with uncertainty and/or the magnitude
15
of associated negative consequence (Akinci, et al., 2004). It should be stressed that
consumers are influenced by risks that they perceive whether or not such risk exists.
Consequently the lower the perception of risks involved in using Internet banking the
more likely an individual would be prepared to use it.
The important factor that consumers consider before adopting is the level of awareness
about mobile banking. In this context, Nassri (2011) identified it as a major factor
impacting the adoption. While the use of internet banking services is fairly new
experience to many people, low awareness of mobile banking is a major factor in causing
people not to adopt internet banking.
2.1.5 Mobile Banking and Service Delivery in the Banking Sector
According to Fiserv (2013) adoption of mobile banking service by financial institutions
has far reaching effects in many aspects. Mobile banking service adoption has the
potential of greatly improving the level of service delivery in any financial institution.
This happens as a result of the short time it takes a customer to complete a transaction
using a mobile phone than walking to the bank to have the payment effected. This
improvement in service delivery due to adoption of mobile banking has the potential of
capturing approximately 20% online customers who prefer better service delivery
through mobile banking.
An increase in the number of customers is also likely to lead to higher revenues and
increased profits for the bank. However, there are concerns from customers that although
service delivery greatly improves with adoption of mobile banking, security of mobile
16
banking service still remains a challenge that needs to be addressed in order to enhance
service delivery.
Gonzalez (2008) is one of the scholars who assert that mobile banking has significantly
transformed traditional banking practices to the extent that it has created a pattern shift in
marketing practices resulting in positive performance in the banking sector. This is an
indication that efficient delivery of quality customer service in the banking industry is to
a greater extent facilitated by adoption of appropriate information technology.
Similarly, Christopher, et al. (2006) equally argues that mobile banking provides an
important channel through which commercial banks can market their products and
services and thus is more of a necessity for commercial banks that anticipate financial
and customer service delivery success. It is evident too that the quality and efficiency of
service delivery within the banking industry has improved significantly in the global
market as a result of integrating information communications technology into a number
of banking activities.
Stevens (2002) indicates that rapid changes in business activities in the form of
technological improvement require banks to serve their customers electronically. It has
therefore become more important for commercial banks to adopt information and
communication technology in order to cope with the complex business environment that
has more informed customers.
This drive to transform the operations of commercial banks may not be successful
without the adoption of appropriate ICT such as mobile banking since it affects quality of
products and services and the way they are delivered to customers (Gupta, 2008).
17
Information communication technology such as mobile banking service has been found
to lead to improvement in business efficiency and service quality and hence attract and
retain customers (Kannabiran & Narayan, 2005).
Mobile banking has experienced explosive growth and has transformed traditional
practices in banking (Gonzalez, 2008). As per prediction of Maholtra and Singh, (2007)
the m-banking is leading to a paradigm shift in marketing practices resulting in high
performance in the banking industry. Delivery of service in banking can be provided
efficiently only when the background operations are efficient. An efficient background
operation can be conducted only when it is integrated by an electronic system. The
components like data, hardware, software, network and people are the essential elements
of the system. Banking customers get satisfied with the system when it provides them
maximum convenience and comfort while transacting with the bank. Internet enabled
electronic system facilitate the operation to fetch these result.
According to Christopher, et al., (2006), m-banking has become an important channel to
sell the products and services and is perceived to be necessity in order to stay profitable
in successful. There is a growing interest in understanding the users’ experience (Pyun,
2002), as e-banking is observed to be a larger concept than user satisfaction. Customers
have therefore started evaluating the banks based on the convenience and comforts it
provides to them.
2.2 Empirical Literature
Various empirical studies have been conducted in regard to m-banking tools and services,
factors favoring adoption of m-banking and the impact of m-banking on service delivery
18
in banks. In regard to the mode of application, mobile banking is conducted through
mobile devices such as phones and other related tools.
A recent empirical study by Singh (2014) found that mobile phones and personal digital
assistants were the only available mobile devices for facilitating Mobile banking services
in the Capital Region of Delhi in India. The study further found out that with an
increasing mobile subscriber base in India, mobile banking has picked up steam in recent
years. The financial services that were conducted via m-banking account opening,
checking balance, changing PIN, payment of bills, purchasing airtime and tax payment
and documentation among others.
Regarding the factors that influence adoption of m-banking, perceived usefulness,
perceived ease of use, perceived risk and social influence have been identified as the
most significant factors. Perceived usefulness is the primary factor that determines the
behavioral aim to use a computer system (Venkatesh and Davis, 2000). According to
(Akturan and Tezcan, 2012), perceived usefulness directly affected attitudes towards
mobile banking, and that attitude was the major determinant of mobile banking adoption
among 435 university students of Turkey.
In a recent research by (Chitungo and Munongo, 2013) conducted on the adoption of
mobile banking services in rural districts of African country Zimbabwe, perceived ease
of use had significant effect on users’ attitude thus influenced the intention to adopt.
A study performed on the factors influencing the intention to adopt mobile banking
services in Kenya, perceived ease of use was one of the significant factors in usage
intention (Lule, Omwansa, and Waema, 2012).
19
The possible risk of illegal activities and fraud has always been a concern for both
consumer and service providers. According to (Dineshwar and Steven, 2013), perceived
risk and reliability were found to be the main obstacles to mobile banking usage in the
African country of Mauritius. Risk in mobile banking is perceived to be higher than
conventional banking because information exchange on wireless infrastructure, which
produced inherent doubts among consumers as hacking and other malicious attacks,
might cause financial and personal data loss (Yousafzai, et al, 2003).
Social influence has been revealed to have a positive effect on the intention to adopt
mobile banking services. The empirical research conducted by (Yu, 2012) in Taiwan by
sampling 441 respondents, the most significant predictor was social influence, in the
individual intention to adopt mobile banking.
In his study Eastin (2002) found that perceived convenience was the strongest predictor
of online banking usage. Finally, the same study also indicated that the perceived
convenience was the most influential variable of overall adoption of all four e-commerce
activities investigated. Karjaluoto, et al. (2002) showed that prior experience with
computers and technologies and attitudes towards computers influence both attitudes
towards online banking and actual behaviors.
In an empirical study of Tunisian consumers Nassri (2011) found that consumers were
unaware about the possibilities, advantages/disadvantages involved with mobile banking.
Guiltinan and Donnelly (1983; cited in Nasri, 2011) identify "information about the
benefits of using a product/service" as an essential service/product promotion strategy.
Hence, for adoption of internet banking, it is necessary that the banks offering this service
20
make the consumers aware about the availability of such a product and explain how it
adds value relative to other products of its own or that of the competitors.
In terms of its influence on service delivery in banks, a study carried out by Adewoye
(2013) impact of mobile banking on service delivery in the Nigerian commercial banks
reveals that mobile banking improves banks’ service delivery in many ways such as
transactional convenience, saving of time, quick transaction alert and save of service cost
which has recuperate customer’s relationship and satisfaction.
The study recommends that the management of commercial banks should create
awareness to inform the public about the benefits derived on the mobile banking service.
Collaboration among banks should perfectly maintain, skilled manpower and computer
wizard should be employed by every bank in order to prevent fraudulent personnel and
hackers from manipulating the banks’ data and stealing money from the banks’ accounts.
Adewoye (2013) further recommends that provision and maintenance of public network
system, such as telephone is fundamental to the efficient functioning of the mobile
banking service.
According to the findings of an investigation on electronic payments systems and mobile
banking in Nigeria carried out by Agboola (2006), it was established that that there has
been a very significant change from the use of cash to electronic payments. It was clear
from the study findings that the automation of payment systems had significantly reduced
the volume of cash transactions handle by commercial banks.
It was also evident that mobile banking has great potential of broadening the customer
relationship; improve customer service delivery which will result to high rate of customer
21
retention and customer loyalty. This will in turn enable commercial banks to gain a large
portion of market share. However this can only be possible if challenges such as such as,
ineffectiveness of telecommunications services, epileptic supply of power, high cost, fear
of fraudulent practices and lack of facilities necessary for their operation were taken care
of. Agboola (2006) further asserts that mobile banking has also changed service delivery
patterns of banks completely by radically reducing the volume of direct cash transactions.
Kwashie (2012) carried out a study on the impact of electronic banking on service
delivery to customers of Ghana commercial bank limited. The study findings showed a
positive correlation between electronic banking and service delivery which implies that
there is a positive impact of electronic banking on service delivery.
Okiro and Ndungu (2013) carried out a study on the impact of mobile and internet
banking on performance of financial institutions in Kenya. The study established that
these two technologies had not significantly affected the performance of the financial
institutions. In a study carried out by Aluoch (2012) on the adoption of mobile banking in
Kenya, it was revealed that customers are quickly adopting mobile banking technology
amid security concerns.
An exploratory study by Sonko (2011) on the status of mobile money services in Uganda
found out that most mobile banking subscribers reported easy access to financial services,
speed and reliability, reduced transaction costs and convenience as the major reforms in
financial service delivery that have been made easy by the introduction of mobile
financial services. However, 80% of the respondents reported lack of skills to operate the
mobile devices, fear of sending money on wrong accounts and financial cybercrimes as
the fears they still experience for possessing mobile money accounts.
22
2.3 Critical Review and Research Gaps Identification
Although mobile banking is an effective platform for improving service delivery in
banks, it still faces a challenge of limited user confidentiality and trust. This is due to the
fact that there are no clear financial regulations and legislation to standardize mobile
banking operations. Due to this challenge users find it unreliable to transact business via
this platform where large amounts of money are involved (Njenga, 2008).
Additionally, there is maximum amount of money that can be transacted on mobile
banking. For example, in Bank of Kigali, the maximum amount of money that can be sent
from the customer’s M-money account to the Bank account and vice versa is Rwf
500,000 per day (Bank of Kigali, 2015). This limits business transactions and hinders
service delivery.
Though not seriously impaired, the capacity of a wider population of Rwanda m-banking
users is fairly curtailed by not being fully conversant with all that they can accomplish
through the mobile financial platform. Deliberate interventions must be undertaken to
successfully ensure that the targeted persons particularly the rural residents are
empowered not only with technology but with skills and finance as well. To prevent these
communities from lagging behind they must be familiarized with the benefits and
opportunities of mobile banking.
Calculated strategies to overcome hindrances require exploration so that these groupings
can be converted into meaningful participants who will utilize this technology for
economic take off.
Furthermore, contrary to the great excitement about the potential for mobile banking in
improving efficiency and speed, there is limited scholarly research on empirical benefits
23
of mobile banking towards service delivery in the developing world (Donner and Tellez,
2008). With the exception of Uganda (Kakoza, 2008; Ssonko, 2011) and Kenya (USAID,
2011; Suri and Jack, 2011; Morawczynski, 2009), the majority of the studies conducted
on mobile banking application and service delivery (such as Donovan, 2012; Mas and
Radcliffe, 2010) have been conducted outside East Africa leaving the region especially
Rwanda with a dearth of scholarly research on mobile banking and its effect on service
delivery.
Yet it presents a potential market for the development of this financial service especially
in rural areas where the majority of unbanked populations live. In Rwanda, particularly,
the researcher finds no academic research that has been conducted on mobile banking. It
is towards this goal of analyzing mobile banking and service delivery on the local context
that this study aims to make a contribution.
Lastly, since most research studies are based on only TRA and TAM theories, which
consist of two constructs; perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness which are not
sufficient to explain factors affecting adoption of M-Banking and how it affects service
delivery. There is need to adopt more theories in this study in order to include more
variables namely; relative advantage, compatibility, complexity, trialability, and
observability. For that matter, the innovation diffusion theory has been incorporated in
this study. Lastly given that much of existing research relevant to this study are on online
banking, M-commerce and electronic commerce, this research study will shed light on
M-banking project in Rwanda and its effect on service delivery. Hence fill the research
gap in this regard.
24
2.4 Theoretical Framework
Enormous theoretical work has been compiled in regard to mobile banking adoption and
service delivery. Among those, the Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA), Technology
Acceptance Model (TAM) and Diffusion of Innovation Theory (DIT) have been selected
as suitable and relevant for adoption in compiling the theoretical foundation of this study.
2.4.1 Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA)
Theory of Reasoned Action is a psychological theory that tries to explain an individual’s
action that is determined by his/ her behavioral intention to perform it (Ajzen and
Fishbein, 1975). It is one of the most important theories that are used to explain the
human behaviors (Puschel, et al., 2010) in regard to adopting new technology.
According to their theory, behavioral intention is explained by people's attitudes toward
that behavior and subjective norms. People's attitude toward a behavior includes
behavioral beliefs, assessment of the consequences of behavior, subjective norms,
normative beliefs and motivations that must be answered (Riivari, 2005). This theory, as
long as the behavior is voluntarily controlled by the individual, can accurately explain the
adoption of m-banking technology and its effect on service delivery in the banking sector
(Laukkanen and Cruz, 2009).
Therefore, TRA is a useful model that will be used to assess mobile banking project in
Rwanda and how it influences service delivery. In 1989 Davis took the same model and
extended it to the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) and linked it to the user
acceptance of an information system.
25
2.4.2 Technology Acceptance Model (TAM)
The Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) was originally proposed by Davies in 1986.
According to Davis (1989, cited in Park, 2009), TAM predicts user‘s acceptance of
Information Technology and usage in an organizational context. TAM focuses on the
attitude explanations of intention to use a specific technology or service and it has
become a widely applied model for user acceptance and usage (Davis, 1986; cited in
Lule, et al., 2012). Bertrand and Bouchard (2008) have also demonstrated that TAM is a
valid, robust and powerful model for predicting technology user acceptance. TAM was
also the first model that established external variables (such as geographical and social-
cultural factors) as key factors in studying and determining user’s behaviors and attitudes
in technology adoption (Davies, 1986; cited in Lule, et al., 2012). Figure 2.1 shows the
original illustrated Technology Acceptance Model.
Figure 2.1: Technology Acceptance Model
Source: Original TAM (Davies, 1989; cited in Park, 2009)
TAM model which deals with perceptions as opposed to real usage, suggests that when
users are presented with a new technology, two important factors influence their decision
about how and when they will use it (Davis, 1989; cited in Lule, et al., 2012). These key
factors are perceived usefulness of the technology and perceived ease-of technological
Perceived
Ease of
Use
Perceived
Usefulness
Attitude
Towards
Use
Actual Use
Behavioral
Intention
to Use
External
Variables
26
use. Perceived usefulness of technology is the degree to which a person believes that
using a particular system would enhance his or her job performance while perceived
ease-of-use is the degree to which a person believes that using a particular system would
be free from effort.
TAM posits that a user’s acceptance of information system is determined by that users’
intention to use the systems, while perceived usefulness and ease of use can predict the
usage intention, and perceived ease of use is hypothesized as a predictor of perceived
usefulness.
According to Fishbein and Ajzen (1975, cited in Lule, et al., 2012), users’ beliefs
influence their attitude, which in turn influence behavioral intention. Both perceived
usefulness and perceived ease of use are beliefs. Thus, they will affect users’ attitude. In
addition, TAM states that perceived ease of use will have a direct effect on perceived
usefulness.
Therefore, based on the above TAM analysis, it is worth to conclude that users’ attitude
to use of M-banking, perceived usefulness of M-banking and perceived ease of use of M-
banking have a significant effect on service delivery among banks that have adopted M-
banking platform.
2.4.3 Diffusion of Innovation Theory (DIT)
The Diffusion of Innovation Theory was first propounded by Rogers in 1983 (Rogers,
2003) and later elaborated by Mahajan and Rambocas in 2012. Accordingly, Rambocas
(2012) defines innovation as any idea, object or practice that is perceived as new by
members of the social system. Diffusion of innovation is the process by which the
27
innovation is communicated through certain channels over time among members of
social systems. Diffusion of innovation is dependent on the perceived characteristics of
an innovation.
Diffusion of innovation theory attempts to explain and describe the mechanisms of how
new inventions in this case mobile banking is adopted and becomes successful. Rogers
(1983, 2003) identified five critical attributes that greatly influence the rate of adoption of
an innovation. These include relative advantage, compatibility, complexity, triability and
observability. According to Rogers, the rate of adoption of new innovations will depend
on how an organization perceives its relative advantage, compatibility, triability,
observability and complexity (Rambocas, 2012).
In terms of relative advantage, the use of new technology is highly dependent on the
comparable benefits derived from its use. New technology is considered to possess a
relative advantage over existing technology based on its perceived usefulness or its
ability to enhance the user’s state of well being defined either economically, financially,
physically or socially (Taylor & Todd, 1995).
The ease of use refers to the extent to which the new system would require less physical
and mental effort in getting output and is based on subjective opinions of customers.
Compatibility is the second dimension of DIT and refers to the extent to which the
innovation is deemed to be aligned with customer values, past and potential wants and
needs (Rambocas, 2012).
28
Al-Majali and Nik Mat (2011) refer to compatibility as the extent to which the innovation
supersedes all other options in meeting the desires and needs of the adopter. It generally
refers to the ability of the technology to fit within the lifestyle of the customer.
The third dimension of DIT model is complexity which relates to the amount of physical
and mental effort require understanding the innovation. The level of complexity of
internet banking is a function of the level of skill and expertise the customer has with the
internet and computer. Trialability allows the adopter the opportunity to test the
innovation on a limited time scale before full adoption takes place.
Rogers (2003) argued that trial of innovation reassures the adopter and reduces risks and
uncertainty associated with adopting the technology. There is a positive correlation
between the likelihood of adopting innovative technology and the opportunity given to
customers to experiment with this technology prior to adoption.
The fifth and last component of the DIT model is observability, which is the extent to
which the technology is observable by others. Because of the nature of the service under
investigation, the relevance of this construct to the study’s purpose was deemed
redundant. In other words, most if not all banking transactions are done privately, not
observable or visible to others. Therefore, the construct of observability does not apply to
private purchases (Al-Majali & Nik Mat, 2011).
Therefore, with regard to the banking sector in Rwanda, bank customers will be
motivated to adopt mobile banking platform because of its relative advantages like
convenience, speed, availability of mobile banking tools, compatibility with their
financial needs such as effective mobile payments via mobile money.
29
However, Sevcik (2004) stated that not all innovations are adopted because, even if an
innovation is good, it may take a long time for it to be adopted by users. He further stated
that resistance to change may be a hindrance to diffusion of innovation which slows
down the adoption rate although it might not stop the innovation. This is relevant in
Rwanda especially rural areas where the majority rural folks lack the necessary mobile
tools and skills to use mobile banking platform.
2.5 Conceptual Framework
The conceptual framework in Figure 2.2 shows the link between mobile banking project
implementation and service delivery.
Figure 2.2: Conceptual Framework
Source: Researcher
According to the Figure 2.2, mobile banking as an independent variable adopted for this
study involves the use of mobile devices such as mobile telephone service, Automatic
Teller Machines and Personal Digital Assistants (see section 2.1.2) to execute mobile
banking transactions.
M-Banking Project
Mobile telephone
Automatic Teller Machines
Personal Digital Assistants
Service Delivery
Cash transfers
Payment of bills
Statements
Account opening
Government Regulations
Customers’ perceptions
Independent Variable Dependent Variable
Intervening Variables
30
Service delivery as a dependent variable for this study involves the ease of delivering
mobile banking services such as opening account, checking balance, requesting bank
statement, payments of bills, money transfer, payment of tax, changing account
password, etc (see section 2.1.3).
On the other hand, there are also intervening variables such as government regulations
and customers’ perceptions which affect the adoption and application of mobile banking.
For example, government regulations will determine the security and safety of mobile
banking while customer perceptions will encourage or discourage users to adopt m-
banking if they are positive or negative respectively.
2.6 Summary
Empirical and theoretical evidence in the literature has shown that mobile banking offers
various services which improve service delivery in banking institutions. This is also
supported by both the theoretical and conceptual frameworks which elaborate how each
variable influences the other in the mobile banking paradigm.
Particularly, Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) suggests that perceived usefulness of
the technology and perceived ease of use are the two important factors that influence user
adoption of m-banking. Perceived usefulness of technology shows the importance of the
technology which includes convenience, speed reduced transaction costs while perceived
ease of use shows that users are able to use the technology without technical hardships.
All these factors influence service delivery.
31
CHAPTER THREE: RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.0 Introduction
This chapter focuses on the methodology of research; namely research design, target
population, sample design and size, sampling technique, data collection methods,
reliability and validity of data instruments, data analysis procedure and ethical
consideration.
3.1 Research Design
The researcher used a descriptive case study design. This research design was preferred
for this study because the researcher was interested in determining the link between two
variables (mobile banking and service delivery in the bank). This means to study whether
the introduction of m-banking was linked to change in service delivery of financial
services in Ecobank.
The researcher used Ecobank Rwanda Limited – Main Branch as a case study. Creswell
(2008) defines a case study as a detailed analysis of a single person, group or
geographical setting and its relationship to a phenomenon. The case study approach was
used because according to Lodico, et al. (2006), case studies allow the researcher to
collect in-depth data from a single phenomenon.
3.2 Target Population
The target population of this study was 698 people who included Ecobank staffs and
customers. According to Ecobank HR and customer database, there were 67 staffs in
Ecobank Main Branch and 631 customers as shown by Table 3.1.
32
Table 3.1: Target Population
Population Strata Target population
Ecobank staffs 67
Ecobank customers 631
Total 698
Source: Ecobank, HR Office/Customer Database (2015)
3.3 Sample Design
3.3.1 Sample Size
Since the total target population of this study was 698 people, the researcher was unable
to contact the entire population because of limited time. Therefore, the sample size was
determined based on Yamane’s 1967 simplified formula for calculating sample sizes
(Israel, 2013). This formula is stated as , where n is the sample size, N is
the population size (698), and e is the level of precision (0.05).
The sampling equation below shows the application of Yamane’s formula to the above
population size which gives the sample size of 258 respondents.
Therefore, the sample size was 258.
3.3.2 Sampling Techniques
The researcher used simple random sampling to select population samples for the study.
This method was applied in selecting both the bank customers and staffs.
33
To apply this technique, the rotary and number method was used, whereby the researcher
wrote numbers from 1 to 698 on pieces of paper which were folded and carried in a bag.
Before engaging the respondent, the researcher requested him/her to pick his/her lucky
number. People who randomly picked numbers 1 to 258 (which was the calculated
sample size) were selected to participate in the study.
3.4 Data Collection Methods
3.4.1 Data Collection Instruments
The researcher used three instruments or tools during the data collection process. These
included the questionnaire, interview guide and secondary documents (both published
and unpublished). The questionnaire (see appendix 2) was used during primary data
collection. The questionnaire was preferred because it collects information from many
respondents in a short time frame. All respondents were given the same sets of questions
except in technical circumstances. The questionnaire was composed of only close-ended
questions because they are easy to answer and score.
Both formal and informal interviews with selected Ecobank staffs and customers were
also conducted using the interview guide (appendix 1). Guiding questions were used for
the interviews but during the course, other questions were asked depending on the
responses by the respondents. The interview guide was composed of open-ended
questions and this was intended to give respondents a chance to support their opinions in
a free atmosphere in addition to predetermined choices. Results from interviews helped in
complementing information obtained from the questionnaire.
Documents such as market reports, mobile banking financial statements, newspapers,
magazines, brochures, etc were reviewed to establish the impact of mobile banking
34
project on service delivery. Documentary analysis was used because it enhances the
researcher’s overall understanding of the situations under study, by providing information
which cannot be obtained using other instruments.
3.4.2 Administration of Data Collection Instruments
After the approval of the proposal by Mount Kenya University (MKU), the researcher
sought a letter of introduction to Ecobank Rwanda Limited Main Branch. The researcher
then met the management and sought permission to administer the research instruments
to their staffs and customers. The major research instrument, the questionnaire was given
to technical staffs and experts to get their comments on where changes were needed.
This expanded the validity and consistency of questionnaire after their input. After
making some modifications, it was then re-administered. The researcher then
administered research instruments.
3.4.3 Validity and Reliability
Validity refers to how well a test measures what it is purported to measure (Cozby,
2001). Validity means the success of the scale in measuring what it sets out to measure.
The researcher pre-tested the questionnaire by using research experts at Mount Kenya
University. Those were requested to judge whether questions in the questionnaire were
relevant and able to collect valid data for the study. The lecturers, particularly the
research supervisor were requested to make some recommendations for improvement.
Where suggestions were made, the researcher made changes in line with the supervisor’s
suggestions.
Reliability is the degree to which an assessment tool produces stable and consistent
results (Colin & Julie, 2006). The researcher determined the reliability of the instruments
35
through retest reliability. This measure of reliability was obtained by administering the
questionnaire and interview guide to different groups of people (several times to each
group). The result scores were then correlated and it was found out that there was
stability and consistency of results over time across all sampled groups. The researcher
then proved that the tools were reliable
Besides, the researcher also believes that the tools were reliable since the respondents
were selected from M-banking project implementers and beneficiaries based on their past
experience in m-banking. Therefore, the researcher believes that their responses on which
the findings of this project report were credible and reliable.
3.5 Data Analysis Procedure
Before data was entered into the computer, the researcher coded and cross checked
responses to remove any errors. The data was then entered into the computer using SPSS
v16.0 which produced tables that were backed by frequency and percentage presentation.
The analysis and interpretation of findings was then done based on the SPSS output.
Narrative data from interviews and secondary sources was analyzed where opinions,
ideas, beliefs, attitudes, statements or arguments were classified into themes, categorized
and then discussed within the context of interpretation of findings.
Since this study is based on descriptive case study design, the researcher also used SPSS
version 16.0 to determine correlation between mobile banking and service delivery in
Ecobank using a correlation matrix in which each variable (mobile banking project and
service delivery) were numbered in a table to show correlations or association that exists
between the two. Asterisks were used to indicate correlations that are statistically
significant.
36
Correlational coefficients range from -1.00 to +1.00 with positive numbers used to
identify a positive relationship and negative numbers being used to identify a negative
relationship. A correlation coefficient of 0.00 indicates there is no linear association
between the variables. Thus, the closer a correlation coefficient is to 0.00, the weaker is
the relationship between variables (Creswell, 2008). The following table was used to
guide the researcher in determining the strength of a relationship using Pearson
Correlation Coefficient.
Table 3.2: Correlation Coefficient Guide
Correlation Coefficient Strength of Relationship
.70-1.00 Strong
.30-.69 Moderate
.00-.29 None (.00) to weak
Source: Creswell (2008)
As indicated in Table 4.8, the Pearson correlation test produced a correlation value of
0.892** with P-values of 0.01 which shows that there is a very strong relationship
between mobile banking and service delivery in Ecobank Rwanda Limited.
3.6 Ethical Considerations
While conducting the study, the researcher observed various research ethics such as
honesty, integrity, humility, confidentiality, etc.
The researcher first explained the purpose of the research to respondents and then sought
permission for conducting the study in their banking institution. The researcher then
respected human dignity and respected the respondents’ choice to answer/not answer the
37
questions presented in the questionnaire and interview guide. Confidentiality was then
observed and names of respondents were not published in final project report.
38
CHAPTER FOUR: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
4.0 Introduction
The study focuses on Mobile banking project implementation and service delivery in
banking institutions in Rwanda using Ecobank as a case study. Therefore, the aim of this
chapter is to present real data from the field and establish real evidence on how mobile
banking affects service delivery in EcoBank.
Data analysis and interpretation helps to present enormous and ambiguous data in a
simple and straightforward form such that it can be easily understood by other readers.
The data is divided into sections based on the objectives of the study. These sections
include response rate, respondents’ relevant background data, the relevance of Mobile
Banking services in Ecobank, factors that influence customer adoption of mobile banking
in Ecobank and the contribution of mobile banking project on service delivery in
Ecobank.
4.1 Response Rate
In order to obtain primary data for presentation of research findings, the researcher
distributed questionnaires to 258 staffs and customers in Ecobank to clearly collect their
views of how M-banking has affected service delivery. However, 91 of the administered
questionnaires were returned blank as respondents reported that they lacked adequate
time to respond.
39
Therefore, out of the sample size of 258 people who were selected, data was collected
from 167 respondents, who constituted a response rate of 65%. This response rate is valid
since it exceeds Altman and Bland’s (2007) recommendation of at least 50%.
Altman and Bland (2007) indicate that obtaining a response rate that exceeds a half of the
selected samples is preferable because the missing data is always inevitable since some
respondents may decide not to respond to some items or the whole questionnaire.
4.2 Respondents’ Background Information
The study questionnaire was designed beginning with relevant background data on
gender, level of education, length of time spent using Ecobank m-banking services. This
section is very important as it helps the researcher to determine respondents’ backgrounds
which have implication on the relevancy, validity and reliability of data provided. Table
4.1 shows the findings.
40
Table 4.1: Respondents’ Background Information
Gender Frequency Percent
Male 87 52
Female 80 48
Total 167 100
Level of Education Frequency Percent
University/Postgraduate 67 40
Secondary 35 21
Tertiary, technical or vocational 65 39
Total 167 100
Time Using M-banking Frequency Percent
0-2 years 25 15
2-4 years 60 36
4-6 years 52 31
6+years 30 18
Total 167 100
Source: Primary Data
As Table 4.1 shows, 52% of the respondents were male while 48% were female. This
indicates that both sexes were equitably represented in the study which is an important
element since Rwandan communities have mainstreamed gender issues in all
development programs.
Concerning education, 40% were university and postgraduates, 39% had completed
tertiary, technical or vocational education while 21% had completed secondary school.
Since education enables people to widen knowledge, it can be argued that the respondents
have better understanding of the contribution of M-banking on service delivery and
therefore the data they provided was valid and relevant for the study.
41
Regarding the length of time spent using Ecobank m-banking, 85% had used Ecobank m-
banking services for a period of 2 or more years. This period is adequate to enable
respondents understand how the service has affected the way they receive financial
services from Ecobank.
4.3 Research Findings
4.3.1 Ecobank Mobile Banking Accounts and Devices Used
The study sought to determine the number of respondents who owned m-banking
accounts and the devices they used to carry out transactions. Table 4.2 shows the
findings.
Table 4.2: Possession of Mobile Banking Accounts and Devices Used
Registered with M-Banking Frequency Percent
Yes 156 93
Neutral 11 7
Total 167 100
M-banking Device Used Frequency Percent
Mobile phone 167 35
ATM 152 32
Ipad 87 18
Others 69 15
Total 475 100
Source: Primary Data
42
As shown in Table 4.2, 93% were registered with mobile banking while 7% remained
neutral. This indicates that majority respondents had experiences on the usage of m-
banking services.
Regarding the devices used, 35% used mobile phones, 32% used automatic teller
machines (ATM), 18% used I pads while 15% used other devices such as visa cards,
computers, etc. This signifies that the mobile phone, ATM and I pads are the mostly used
devices to carry out mobile banking transactions in Ecobank. This is attributed to the fact
that the mobile telephone in particular is on a positive penetration rate in Rwanda. For
example, as of January 2013, active mobile subscribers stood at 5,902,630 (penetration
rate of 55.1%) but this figure increased to 6,619,113 active mobile subscribers
representing a penetration rate of 62.8% as of July 2013 (RURA, 2013b).
Similarly, data from interviews revealed that the mobile telephone was the mostly used
device in transacting operations via mobile banking. One respondent said, “I always use a
smart phone whenever I want to access banking services such as account status, payment
of bills and money transfer because the mobile phone is always with me all the time”.
4.3.2 Usage of Mobile Banking services in Ecobank
The study also sought to investigate the frequency at which Ecobank customers used m-
banking services. Table 4.3 shows the findings.
43
Table 4.3: Usage of Mobile Banking Services in Ecobank
No. M-Banking Service Usage of Service
Always Sometimes Rarely Never
1 Open a bank account - 4(2%) 163 (98%) -
2 Check my account status 165 (99%) 2 (1%) - -
3 Pay bills 166(99%) 1 (1%) - -
4 File taxes and access tax
information
57(34%) - - 110(65%)
5 Electronic check conversion 9(5%) 12(7%) 3(2%) 143(86%)
6 Transfer funds 164(98%) 3(2%) - -
7 Bank statement 162(97%) 5(3%) -
8 Change passwords 150(90%) 2(1%) 4(2%) 11(7%)
9 Purchase m-banking
products/services
161(96%) 7 (4%) - -
10 Request a loan and check status 123(73%) 2(1%) - 42(26%)
11 Stock information 23(14%) 31(19%) 15(9%) 98(59%)
12 Currency exchange 8(5%) 13(8%) 5(3%) 141(84%)
Source: Primary Data
As Table 4.3 shows, respondents always used most mobile banking services available in
Ecobank.
Findings in item 3 show that 99% reported that they always used MB to check their
account status. This indicates that there is strong desire among customers to be constantly
updated about their accounts such as the balance and the transactions conducted.
44
Similarly, according to item 2, 99% said that they always used MB to pay bills. This
indicates that MB is the mostly used form of payment for bills such as water, electricity,
etc because of its convenience.
Thirdly, item 6 show that 98% always used MB to transfer funds. This can be attributed
to the fact that transferring funds from one mobile account to another is efficient and
effective in both time and financial cost.
Furthermore, item 7 show that 97% always used MB to access bank statements. Bank
statements are important in determining the customer’s financial position.
Additionally, 96% reported that they always used MB to purchase m-banking
products/services. These products included cheque books, airtime, standing orders, visa
cards, etc. This indicates that m-banking is dramatically changing bank transactions into
cashless form which encourages security.
Moreover, 90% also always used MB to change passwords. This indicates that m-banking
customers are cautious about the security of their mobile accounts.
It was also found out that 73% always used MB to request and apply for bank loans. This
indicates that customers can have the convenience of seeking loans without having to
travel to meet the bank manager.
However, 98% rarely used MB for account opening. This is attributed to the fact that
most customers open accounts once and find no need of opening other bank accounts in
the same bank.
45
Furthermore, 86% never used mobile banking service in electronic check conversion.
This can be attributed to the fact that the use of electronic checks as a mode of payment is
not common.
In item 12, it was found out that 84% also never used mobile banking in currency
exchange. This is attributed to the fact that majority customers conduct their transactions
in the local currency (Rwandan Francs). This explains limited usage of currency
exchange in mobile banking.
Additionally, 65% never used m-banking in filing taxes and accessing tax information.
This can be attributed to the fact that taxes are only paid by people who are engaged in
profit-making activities while others use third parties to do the job of tax filing on their
behalf.
Lastly, the majority (59%) also never used mobile banking to access stock information.
This may indicate that most of the respondents do not deal in shares trading on the stock
exchange.
In a related development, data from interviews produced similar results. Most
respondents said that they always used mobile banking services such as in checking
account status, payment of bills (water, electricity, internet, airtime, etc), transfer of
funds, accessing bank statement, changing account password and purchasing bank
products such as cheque books, visa cards, etc. One respondent said, “I always use m-
banking services because they help me to easily carry out transactions without having to
go and queue at the bank”.
46
Similarly, most respondents said they rarely used mobile banking service in opening bank
accounts. One respondent said, “I don’t really need to always open an account with
Ecobank. I only have one account with Ecobank, I opened that account once and it helps
me do all the transactions I do with the bank. I don’t need to open any other account with
the same bank”.
Majority also said that they never used m-banking in tax-related assignments because
they were not engaged in taxable activities. One respondents said, “I don’t do tax filing
because I am not engaged in any profit making business. So there is no need of using this
mobile banking service”. It was also revealed that majority did not use m-banking in
electronic cheque conversion because the usage of such cheques is rare. Most
respondents even said that they did not understand what an electronic cheque was or how
it is used.
4.3.3 Factors that influence customer adoption of mobile banking in Ecobank
The study also investigated the factors that influence customers’ adoption of mobile
banking in Ecobank. The factors were based on Technology Acceptance Model (TAM).
According to Davies (1989), TAM suggests that people will adopt a form of technology
based on some drivers which include perceived usefulness of the technology, perceived
ease of use and perceived risk or security of the technology.
Perceived Usefulness of Mobile Banking
Perceived usefulness is the extent to which a customer believes that using a particular
technology would enhance his or her job performance. Table 4.4 shows the findings in
regard to perceived usefulness of mobile banking.
47
Table 4.4: Perceived Usefulness
No. Perceived Usefulness Strongly
Agree
Agree Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 I can complete my banking tasks more
easily with M-banking
118(71%) 18(11%) 20(12%) 11(7%)
2 MB allows me to transact business all
the time
167 (100%) - - -
3 MB increases my efficiency in utilizing
banking services
161(97%) 3(2%) 2(1%) -
4 MB allows me to know account status
faster
145(87%) 10(6%) 3(2%) 9(5%)
Source: Primary Data, May 2016
As Table 4.4 shows, in item 2, all respondents strongly agreed that they adopted MB
because it allows them to transact business all the time. This indicates that service
reliability is highly valued by customers.
Secondly, item 3 shows that 97% also strongly agreed that they were influenced by the
efficiency of mobile banking platform in utilizing banking services. This can be
attributed to the reduction in transactional costs brought by mobile banking.
Furthermore, 87% strongly agreed that MB allowed them to know their accounts’ status
faster. This can be attributed to the fact that use of mobile banking does not require the
customer to line up in the queue to receive services.
48
Lastly, in item 1, 71% revealed that they adopted MB platform because it allowed them
to complete banking tasks more easily. This can be attributed to the fact that people
always move with their mobile devices which allows them to easily access banking
services.
Data from interviews was also analyzed and it was consistent with the findings of the
questionnaire. Some interviewees said that they adopted m-banking because of its
simplicity in allowing access to financial services. One respondent said, “even if I am in a
foreign country, I can easily access financial services in Rwanda courtesy of mobile
banking platform”.
It was also revealed that customers adopted MB because of its fulltime reliability unlike
the brick and mortar banking platform. One respondent said, “I was so impressed with
mobile banking when Ecobank staffs told me that it operates all the time even at night.
Since there are times when I need financial services when the bank has already closed, I
found mobile banking platform very relevant to my financial needs”.
Perceived Ease of Using Mobile Banking
Perceived ease-of-use is the extent to which a bank customer believes that using mobile
banking technology would be free from effort. Table 4.5 shows the findings.
49
Table 4.5: Perceived Ease of Use
No. Perceived Ease of Use Strongly
Agree
Agree Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 I can easily learn to use m-banking 139(83%) 12(7%) 11(7%) 5(3%)
2 Instructions on the m-banking system
are clear and understandable
156(93%) 5(3%) 4(2%) 2(1%)
3 There are co-operative staffs to teach
me how to use M-Banking
103(62%) 18(11%) 21(13%)
25(15%)
Source: Primary Data
As shown by Table 4.5, 93% strongly agreed that they were influenced to adopt m-
banking because instructions on the m-banking system are clear and understandable. This
indicates that customers can easily follow the MB instructions to carry out financial
transactions.
Secondly, item 1 shows that 83% were attracted to adopt m-banking because they could
easily learn to use the financial platform. This indicates that the ability to learn a
technology will influence users to easily adopt it.
Lastly, item 3 shows that 62% of the respondents also strongly agreed that they were
attracted to use MB because of the presence of co-operative staffs in Ecobank to teach
them how to use M-Banking. This indicates that customers adopt a service not because of
its attractiveness but also the availability of help in the use of such services.
Findings from interviews also produced similar results. Majority interviewees said that
mobile banking was easy to learn and use, had clear messages and that the staffs of
Ecobank were co-operative in helping customers understand how to conduct transactions
50
online and secure their accounts. One respondents said, “when am using m-banking, I
feel happy because it brings me various languages from which to choose from”.
Similarly, another interviewee said, “Ecobank staffs are very helpful to me whenever I
get a challenge in carrying out services via mobile money. They help and guide me how
to solve problems. Even at first, I was hesitant to operate a mobile banking account but
the staffs motivated me to operate it by telling me about the benefits”.
Form the above findings, it is very clear that ease of use is one of the important factors
that influence customers to adopt mobile banking platform.
Perceived Risk or Security
Perceived ease of risk or security is the degree to which customers feel that their accounts
will be vulnerable or free from financial risks or loss. The researcher investigated this
factor to determine how secure mobile banking customers felt they were. Table 4.6 shows
the findings.
51
Table 4.6: Perceived Risk or Security
No. Perceived Risk or Security Strongly
Agree
Agree Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1 I feel that MB will allow unauthorized
person to access my private information
149(89%) 3(2%) 6(4%) 9(5%)
2 MB is prone to signal failure and network
congestion
163(98%) 4(2%) - -
3 I feel that am not legally protected from
cyberspace fraud
166(99%) 1(1%) - -
4 The security policies of the bank give me a
feeling that money via MB will be safe
9(5%) 18(11%) 138(83%) 2(1%)
Source: Primary Data
With regard to perceived risk or security of the mobile banking platform, item 3 in Table
4.6 shows that 99% felt that they were not legally protected from cyberspace fraud. This
can be attributed to lack of awareness of the available laws that that protect e-commerce
and mobile banking.
Secondly, in item 2, 98% also strongly agreed that they perceived MB to be prone to
signal failure and network congestion. This was attributed to technical failure and poor
internet connection that may disrupt mobile banking transactions.
Furthermore, item 1 shows that 89% also felt that m-banking will allow unauthorized
person to access their private information. This was attributed to the increase in
technological know-how that has promoted fraud through account hacking.
52
Lastly, 83% also said that the security policies of the bank gave them feelings that money
transactions via MB were not safe. This can be attributed to the bank’s failure to assure
customers that they have anti-cyber crime policies which help to ensure security of
customers’ finances.
However, findings from interviews produced mixed results. Some interviews revealed
that they trusted that the Rwandan law was comprehensive and strict against cybercrimes
which gave them assurance that there were no chances of technological fraud in mobile
banking.
On the other hand other interviewees said that they were not sure of security. There was
general lack of understanding of Ecobank’s policies in regard to customer protection
from fraudulent practices via mobile banking.
Furthermore, it was also revealed by most interviewees trusted that unauthorized person
cannot access their financial secret information because the bank provides options for
password security.
4.3.4 Contribution of mobile banking project on service delivery
The study also sought to establish the contribution of mobile banking project on service
delivery in Ecobank. This was aimed at determining how MB influences customer
experiences. Table 4.7 shows the findings.
53
Table 4.7: Mobile Banking Project and Service Delivery
No. Importance
Very
Imp
orta
nt
Imp
orta
nt
Average
Not
Imp
orta
nt
1 It is cost saving/cost effective 162(97%) 2(1%) - 3 (2%)
2 Time saving (no need to go to bank or ATM) 166(99%) 1(1%) - -
3 Ease of access (can make transaction any
time)
167 (100%) - - -
4 Physical security 164(98%) - 3(2%) -
5 Customer comforts 159(95%) 4(2%) 3(2%) 1(1%)
6 Speed of service delivery 167(100%) - - -
Source: Primary Data
According to item 3 in the Table 4.7, the study finds that MB is very important to all the
surveyed customers in easing financial access (100%). This was attributed to the fact that
the customer can make transaction any time which increases convenience.
Similarly, item 6 indicates that 100% also rated MB as very important in speeding service
delivery. This is because electronic transactions that are executed in virtual space are
instantly completed.
Additionally, item 2 also shows that 99% of respondents rated MB’s role in service
delivery as time saving (no need to go to bank or ATM). This was attributed to the time
that the customer saves by carrying out transactions without having to abandon other
duties since it can be executed by the customer on the move.
54
In item 4 98% rated MB as very important in ensuring physical security. This was
attributed to the fact that MB does not require the customer to move with physical cash.
Furthermore, in item 1, 97% rated mobile banking as very important in saving costs. This
was attributed to the lower rates and lower transaction fees charged in addition to
transportation savings that would otherwise be spent going to the bank.
Item 5 also shows that MB platform was rated as very important in ensuring customer
comfort (95%). This was attributed to the fact that financial transactions can be executed
via the platform at any time without any need for the customer to move.
Data from interviewees was also analyzed to determine how mobile banking influences
service delivery and the analysis produced consistent results. It was revealed that mobile
banking platform speeds up service delivery to customers. One respondent described
mobile banking speed by saying, “conducting financial transactions using mobile banking
is very quick and takes the speed of light. For example, whenever am in the US, I easily
make transactions in Rwanda using mobile money and I get instant results and feedback”.
It was also revealed that mobile banking saves time for customers. For example, one
interview said, “conducting business by using mobile money does not require me to move
from office. I just use a click of mouth or my smart phone and the transaction gets
executed. This saves me time to engage in strategic planning for the business. It also
saves me the costs of using agents to do transactions on my behalf which sometimes has
been risky as some agents are financially untrustworthy”.
55
Form the above analysis, it can be concluded that mobile banking platform is an effective
element in the banking institutions that helps customers to receive quick services at lower
costs, in a short time and being secured from theft that usually result from carrying large
sums of physical cash.
4.3.5 Pearson Correlation
Having established the contribution of mobile banking on service delivery in Ecobank,
the researcher also ran a Pearson Correlation to determine the level of significance of the
relationship that exists between mobile banking and service delivery. Table 4.8 shows the
findings.
Table 4.8: Pearson Correlation for Mobile Banking and Service Delivery in Ecobank
Mobile Banking Service Delivery
Mobile Banking Pearson Correlation 1 .892**
Sig. (2-tailed) . .000
N 167 167
Service Delivery Pearson Correlation .892** 1
Sig. (2-tailed) .000 .
N 167 167
Source: Primary Data **Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
The study also conducted a statistical analysis of Pearson correlation which showed that
there was a strong relationship between mobile banking and service delivery in Ecobank.
The strength of the relationship is shown by a positive
56
Pearson correlation value (0.892**) with the level of significance (P=0.01). The
significance (P=0.01) shows that the relationship between mobile banking and service
delivery is very significant.
57
CHAPTER FIVE: SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
5.0 Introduction
The study was conducted the Mobile banking project implementation and service
delivery in banking institutions in Rwanda using a case study of Ecobank. Its objectives
were to establish the relevance of Mobile Banking services in Ecobank, factors that
influence customer adoption of mobile banking in Ecobank and the contribution of
mobile banking project on service delivery in Ecobank. In this chapter, the researcher
presents the summary of findings, conclusion, recommendations and suggestions for
further research. The aim of this chapter is to present the findings in a brief format for
easy interpretation by other readers.
5.1 Summary of Findings
5.1.1 Usage of Mobile Banking services in Ecobank
Ninety three percent (93%) were registered with Ecobank mobile banking and were also
using the platform to transact business.
The mobile phone and automatic teller machine were the frequently used devices to carry
out mobile banking with 35% and 32% of the respondents respectively.
The most frequently used mobile banking services were payment of bills (99%), checking
account status (99%), funds transfer (98%), accessing bank statement (97%), purchasing
Bank products (96%), changing password (90%) and requesting a loan (93%).
58
5.1.2 Factors that influence customer adoption of mobile banking in Ecobank
Regarding perceived usefulness as a factor that influence customer adoption of mobile
Banking most customers were attracted by its reliability (100%), efficiency (97%) and
speed (87%).
In regard to perceived ease of use, 93% were attracted by clear instructional materials,
followed by ease to learn (83%) and presence of co-operative staffs (62%).
However, in terms of perceived risk and security, 99% felt not legally protected, 98% felt
they were vulnerable to MB signal failure, 89% felt that fraudsters can access their
accounts while 83% felt that Ecobank security policies did not guarantee safety.
5.1.2 Contribution of mobile banking project on service delivery in Ecobank
Pertaining to its contribution in service delivery, the study finds that MB is quick in
providing services (100%), easy to access (100%), saves time (99%), ensures physical
safety (98%), saves money (97%) and provides customer comfort (95%).
5.2 Conclusion
The study covers the contributions of mobile banking on service delivery in banking
Institutions in Rwanda using a case study of Ecobank Rwanda Limited, Main Branch in
Nyarugenge district.
The study covers and has fulfilled three objectives which include the usage frequency of
MB services, factors favoring the adoption of MB and contribution of MB in service
delivery.
59
It is recognized that most Ecobank customers frequently use MB services in the payment
of bills, checking account status, transferring funds, requesting bank statement,
purchasing bank products and changing password.
Ecobank customers have been influenced to use MB platform because of its usefulness
(cost reduction, speed, reliability, etc) as well as ease of use where customers can carry
out transactions by following clear instructions.
Mobile banking platform is important in promoting service delivery in Ecobank by
encouraging quick delivery of services, reducing transaction costs, saving time, physical
security and ensuring customers’ comfort.
However, users have some negative perceptions on MB platform, for example, they fear
technological fraud through access of their secret passwords, inadequate legal protection,
technical failure and loopholes within the bank’s policy that may be exploited by
Cybercriminals to steal their money from mobile banking accounts.
There is need to sensitize mobile banking customers in Ecobank about the security
measures available to protect their accounts from unauthorized access, and continuously
educate customers about new ways of developing tight security for their accounts.
5.3 Recommendations
Customers should be instructed on how to design tight security for their accounts by
opening passwords that are complicated for hackers to copy and defraud mobile banking
customers. This is because most customers feel that m-banking will allow unauthorized
person to access their private information.
60
Ecobank should ensure that its mobile banking platform is fully connected all the time
and free from technical faults. Customers should also be sensitized about this security
such that they become sure that they will access services anytime. This will remove their
feelings of doubt based on the fact that MB is prone to signal failure and network
congestion.
Ecobank management should familiarize themselves with the available cyberspace laws
such that they sensitize customers who have negative perception in regard to the
inadequacy of the available laws to protect their MB accounts.
This is because customer indicated that they felt they were not legally protected from
cyberspace fraud yet there are available laws that protect online businesses.
Ecobank should sensitize customers about the bank’s policies and how such policies
prevent cyberspace fraud. This is because most respondents said that security policies of
the bank gave them feelings that money transactions they conducted via MB were not
safe.
Ecobank should sensitize its customers about what an electronic cheque is, how to use it
and its benefits to the user. This is because most respondents seemed not to understand
what an electronic cheque was.
Electronic banking is not the only factor that improves service delivery in banking
institutions. However due to limited time, other factors were not covered by the study.
Therefore, future researchers should be encouraged to carry out studies on the factors that
help to improve service delivery in banking institutions.
61
5.4 Area for further research
Electronic banking is not the only factor that improves service delivery in banking
institutions. However due to limited time, other factors were not covered by the study.
Therefore, future researchers should be encouraged to carry out studies on the factors that
help to improve service delivery in banking institutions.
62
REFERENCES
Adewoye, J. (2013). Impact of Mobile Banking on Service Delivery in the Nigerian Commercial
Banks. International Review of Management and Business Research, 4(7), 145-160
Agboola, A. A. (2006). Electronic Payment Systems and Tele-banking Services in Nigeria.
Journal of Internet Banking and Commerce, 11(3),16-38. Available online
[http://www.arraydev.com/commerce/jibc/]. Accessed on 04/02/2016
Akinci, S., Aksoy, S., and Atilgan, E. (2004). Adoption of internet banking among sophisticated
consumer segments in an advanced developing country. International Journal of Bank
Marketing, 22 (3), 212-32.
Akturan, U., and Tezcan, N. (2012). Mobile banking adoption of the youth market: Perceptions
and intentions. Marketing Intelligence & Planning, 30(4), 444-459
Al-Ashban, A.A., and Burney, M.A. (2001). Customer adoption of tele-banking technology: the
case of Saudi Arabia. International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol. 19 No. 5, pp. 191-
200.
Alexander, A. (April 10, 2009). The History of Personal Digital Assistants 1980-2000. Agile
Mobility. ICT Review, 3(7), 11-17
AL-Majali, M., & Nik Mat, N.K. (2011). Modeling the Antecedents of Internet Banking Service
Adoption (IBSA) in Jordan: A Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) approach. Journal of
Internet Banking and Commerce, 16(1), 1-15
63
Aluoch, R. (2012). Factors Affecting Adoption of Mobile Banking Technology in Kenya: A
Case of Bank Customers within Nakuru Municipality. A Master of Business
Administration Thesis (unpublished) Submitted to Kabarak University
Anguelov, E., Christoslav, A., Hilgert, M. & Jeanne, M.H. (2004). U.S Consumers and
Electronic Banking, 1995-2003. Federal Reserve Bulletin, 3(1), 6-9
Bank of Kigali (2015). Frequently asked questions (FAQs) on moving money between BK bank
accounts and MTN Mobile Money Wallets. Available online
[http://www.bk.rw/documents/press_release/Q&%20A%20for%20BK%20MTN.pdf].
Accessed on 13/12/2015
Bertrand, M. and Bouchard, S. (2008). Applying the Technology Acceptance Model to VR with
people who are favorable to its use. Journal of Cyber Therapy & Rehabilitation, 1 (2) 29-98
Carr, M. (2007). Adoption and Diffusion of Internet Banking. Journal of Technology and
Management, 4 (9), 211-257
Chitungo, S. K., and Munongo, S. (2013). Extending the Technology Acceptance Model to
Mobile Banking Adoption in Rural Zimbabwe. Journal of Business Administration and
Education, 3(1), 51-79.
Chovanová, A. (2006). Banking Sector: Forms of electronic banking, BIATEC, 16 (6), 61-102
Christopher, G. C., Mike, L. V. & Amy, W. (2006). A Logical Analysis of Electronic Banking in
New Zealand. International Journal of Bank Market, 24(9), 360-383.
Christopher, G., Mike, C., Visit, L. and Amy, W. (2006). A Logit Analysis of Electronic
Banking in New Zealand. International Journal of Bank Market, 24(8), 360-383
64
Clark, A. (2008). Mobile banking & Switching. Retrieved from Available online
[www.mcom.co.nz/assets/sm/163/.../CriticalSwitchingEvents-WhitePaper.pdf]. Accessed
on 27/2/2016
Colin, P. and Julie, W. (2006). Exploring Reliability in Academic Assessment. UNI Office of
Academic Assessment. Available online
[https://www.uni.edu/chfasoa/reliabilityandvalidity.htm] Accessed on 13/8/2015
Cozby, P.C. (2001). Measurement Concepts. Methods in Behavioral Research. Seventh edition.
Rome: Illviya
Creswell, J. (2008). Educational research: Planning, conducting, and evaluating quantitative and
qualitative research. New Jersey: Pearson: Merrill Prentice Hall.
Cronin, P. (2001). Sending Out an SMS. Sept 15 (2001). Available online [http://www.m-
commerceworld.com/articles/article.cfm/]. Accessed on 17/11/2015
Delloitte and Touche (2010). Mobile banking: A catalyst for improving bank performance.
Available online
[https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/ie/Documents/Process/mobile_banking
_bank_performance.pdf]. Accessed on 13/11/2015.
Dineshwar, R., and Steven, M. (2013). An Investigation on Mobile Banking Adoption and
Usage: A Case Study of Mauritius. Proceedings of third Asia-Pacific Business Research
Conference 25 - 26 February 2013, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia: Asia-Pacific Business
Research Conference
65
Donner, J. and Tellez, C.A. (2008). Mobile banking and economic development: Linking
adoption, impact, and use. Asian Journal of Communication, 18(4), 318-322.
Donovan, K. (2012). Mobile Money for Financial Inclusion. Available online
[http://siteresources.worldbank.org/EXTINFORMATIONANDCOMMUNICATIONAN
DTECHNOLOGIES/Resources/IC4D-2012-Chapter-4.pdf]. Accessed on 29/01/2016
Eastin, M. (2002). Diffusion of E-commerce: An Analysis of the Adoption of Four E-commerce
Activities. Telemetric and Informatics Review, 19 (3), 251-267.
Fiserv. (2013). Mobile Banking Adoption: Your Frontline Staff Holds the Key to Growth. Fiserv
White Paper Series.
Freedman, C. & Goodlet, C. (1998). The Financial Services Sector: Past Changes and Future
Prospects. Review of financial ethics, 3(8), 1-23
Gerrard, P., and Cunningham, J.B. (2003). The diffusion of Internet banking among Singapore
consumers. International Journal of Bank Marketing, 21(1), 16-28.
Godoy, J. Tortora, B. Sonnenschein, J. & Kendall, J. (2012). Payments and Money Transfer
Behaviors of Sub-Saharan Africans. New York: Gallup, Inc
Gonzalez, M. E. (2008). An Alternative Approach in Service Quality: An E-Banking Case Study,
Journal of Quality Management, 15(4), 41-48
GSMA (2009). Mitigating the Risks that Accompany Mobile Money. Mobile money for the
unbanked: Quarterly update 1 (3): 35-36.
Gupta, P. K. (2008). Internet Banking in India: Consumer Concern and Bank Strategies, Global
Journal of Business Research, 2(1), 43-51.
66
Guriting, P. and Ndubisi, N.O. (2006). Borneo online banking: Evaluating customer perceptions
and behavioral intention. Management Research News, 29(1/2), 6-15.
Hamlet, C. and Strube, M. (2000). Community banks go online. ABA Banking Journal's 2000
White Paper/Banking on the Internet, 3 (3), 61-5.
Harker, P.T. & Zenios, S.A. (1998). What drives financial performance? The Wharton Financial
Institutions Center, New York.
Israel, G.D. (2013).Determining Sample Size - EDIS - University of Florida
Kakooza, A. C. (August 06, 2008). Embracing E-Commerce in Uganda: Prospects and
Challenges. Kampala, Uganda
Kannabira, G. & Narayan, H. (2005). Deploying internet Banking and e-Commerce: Case Study
of a Private Sector Bank in India, Information Technology for Development, 11(4), 363-
379.
Karjaluoto, H., Mattila, M., and Pento, T. (2002). Factors underlying attitude formation towards
online banking in Finland. International Journal of Bank Marketing, 20(6), 261-72.
Kleijnen, M., Wetzels, M. and Ruyter, K. (2004). Consumer acceptance of wireless finance.
Journal of Financial Services Marketing, 8(3), 206-217.
Kwashie, W. (2012). The Impact of Electronic Banking on Service Delivery to Customers of
Ghana Commercial Bank Limited. An unpublished Master’s Thesis submitted to the
Institute of Distance Learning, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology
67
Laukkanen, T. and Cruz, P. (2009). Comparing consumer resistance to mobile banking in
Finland and Portugal, in Filipe and Obaidat (Eds), e-Business and Telecommunications,
Berlin: Springer Publications
Luarn, P. and Lin, H.H. (2005). Toward an understanding of the behavioural intention to use
mobile banking. Computers in Human Behavior, 21 (5), 873-891
Lule, I., Omwansa, T.K. & Waema, T.M. (2012). Application of Technology Acceptance Model
(TAM) in M-Banking Adoption in Kenya. International Journal of Computing and ICT
Research, 6(1), 11-49
Maholtra, P. and Singh, B. (2007). Determinants of Internet Banking Adoption by Banks in
India, Emerald Internet Research. 17(3), 323-339
Mas, I., and Radcliffe, D. (2010). Mobile Payments Go Viral: M-PESA in Kenya. In the “Yes
Africa Can: Success Stories from a Dynamic Continent. World Bank: Washington, DC
Morawczynski, O. (2009. Examining the Usage and Impact of Transformational M-Banking in
Kenya. Internationalization, Design and Global Development. ICT Journal, 2(4), 12-47
MTN/BK Joint Media Release (2012). BK rolls out ‘Mobile Money’ services in partnership with
MTN Rwanda. Joint Media Release. Thursday 28th June 2012
Mugenda,O.M and Mugenda, A.G. (2003). Research Methods: Quantitative and Qualitative
Approaches. Nairobi: Act Press
Muisyo, J.M., Alala, O. and Musiega, D. (2014). The Effects of Mobile Money Services on the
Performance of the Banking Institutions: A Case of Kakamega Town. The International
Journal of Engineering and Science (IJES), 3 (4), 16-24
68
Nasri, W. (2011). Factors Influencing the Adoption of Internet Banking in Tunisia. International
Journal of Business and Management, 6(8), 28-49
Njenga, A.D.K. (2008). Mobile phone banking: Usage experiences in Kenya. Available online
[http://www.w3.org/2008/10/MW4D_WS/papers/njenga.pdf]. Accessed on Accessed on
21/8/2015
Okiro, K. (2013). The impact of mobile and internet banking on performance of financial
institutions in Kenya. European Scientific Journal, 9 (11), 98-131
Ovia, J. (2001). Internet Banking: Practices and potentials in Nigeria, A paper presented at a
seminar organized by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nigeria (ICAN). Lagos
Sheraton Hotel & Towers, Ikeja, (September 05).
Pamela, A. and Lwakabamba, G. (2010). Development with a Smile? Kigali: Institute of Policy
Analysis and Research-Rwanda
Park, S.Y. (2009). Analysis of the Technology Acceptance Model in Understanding University
Students’ Behavioral Intention to Use e-Learning. Educational Technology & Society, 12
(3), 150-162
Petrova, K. (2002). Mobile banking: Background, services and adoption, Business Review, 5(2),
29-51
Pew. (2006). Convenience is King, Internet and American Life Project, 2003
Polatoglu, V.N. and Ekin, S. (2001). An empirical investigation of the Turkish consumers'
acceptance of internet banking services. International Journal of Bank Marketing, 19 (4),
156-65.
69
Porteous, D. (2007). Just How Transformational Is M-Banking? FinMark Trust
Puschel, J., Mazzon J. A., and Hernandez J. M. C., (2010). Mobile banking: Proposition of an
integrated adoption intention framework. International Journal of Bank Marketing, 28(5),
389-409.
Pyun, C.S., Scruggs, L. and Nam, N. (2002). Internet Banking in the US, Japan and Europe,
Multinational Business Review, 3 (6), 73-81
Rambocas, M. (2012). Using Diffusion of Innovation Theory to Model Customer Loyalty for
Internet Banking. International Journal of Business and Commerce, 1(8), 01-14
Riivari, J. (2005). Mobile banking: A powerful new marketing and CRM tool for financial
service companies all over Europe. Journal of Financial Services Marketing, 10 (1), 11-
20
Rogers, E. M. (2003). Diffusion of innovation, fifth edition. New York: Simon and Schuster, Inc
RURA (2013a). Statistics and tariff information in Telecom sector as of June 2013
RURA (2013b). Active mobile subscribers (90-days revenue generating subscribers) as of July
2013
Rwanda Focus (June 29, 2012). Bank of Kigali, MTN in new mobile money deal. Available at
[http://focus.rw/wp/2012/06/bank-of-kigali-mtn-in-new-mobile-money-deal/ Accessed on
06/8/2015
Senn, J. (2000). The Emergence of M-Commerce. IEEE Computer, 8 (4), 148-150.
70
Sevcik, P. (2004). Innovation diffusion. Business Communications Review, 34(9), 8-11.
Springston
Singh, S. (2014). Customer Perception of Mobile Banking: An Empirical Study in National
Capital Region Delhi. Journal of Internet Banking and Commerce, 19 (3), 123-1.
Slavin, R. (2007). Educational research in an age of accountability. Boston: Pearson Education
Smith, A. and Wempen, F. (2011). CompTIA Strata Study Guide. John Wiley & Sons: London
Sonko, G.W. (2011). Status of mobile money services in Uganda: An exploratory study. Working
Paper, No: BOUWP0811
Steven A. (2002). Information System: The information of E-Business, New Jersey
Suri, T. and Jack, B. (2011). Risk Sharing and Transaction Costs: Evidence from Kenya’s
Mobile Money Revolution. Working paper. Massachusetts Institute of Technology:
Cambridge
Taylor, S., & Todd, P. A. (1995). Understanding Information Technology Usage: A Test of
Competing Models. Information Systems Research, 6(2), 144-176
Tiwari, R. and Buse, S. (2007). The Mobile Commerce Prospects: A Strategic Analysis of
Opportunities in the Banking Sector, Hamburg University Press
Tiwari, R., Buse, S. and Herstatt, C. (2007). Mobile Services in Banking Sector: The Role of
Innovative Business Solutions in Generating Competitive Advantage. Cited in
Proceedings of the International Research Conference on Quality, Innovation and
Knowledge Management, New Delhi, pp. 886–894
71
USAID (2011). Better than cash: Kenya Mobile money market assessment. Available at
[http://nethope.org/assets/uploads/Kenya-Mobile-Money-Assessment.pdf] Accessed on
01/8/2015
Vaidya, R.S. (2011). Emerging Trends on Functional Utilisation of Mobile Banking in
Developed Markets in Next 3-4 Years. International Review of Business Research, 7(1),
301-312.
Venkatesh, V. and Davis, F. D. (2000). A theoretical extension of the technology acceptance
model: Four longitudinal field studies. Journal of Management Science, 45(2), 186-204.
Yousafzai, S. Y., Pallister, J. G. and Foxall, G. R. (2003). A proposed model of e-trust for
electronic banking. Technovation, 23(11), 847-860
Yu, C.S. (2012). Factors affecting individuals to adopt mobile banking: empirical evidence from
the UTAUT Model. Journal of Electronic Commerce Research, 13(2), 104-121
74
APPENDIX 3: INTERVIEW GUIDE FOR BANK STAFFS
Dear Respondent
I am a student of Mount Kenya University, pursuing a Masters Degree in Business
Administration (Project Planning and Management). I am currently conducting a study on
Mobile banking project implementation and service delivery in banking institutions in
Rwanda using Ecobank as a case study. The study is solely for academic purposes and
your m-banking project has been identified as one of the most effective due to your
international experience. You are hereby requested to please assist in completing the
attached questionnaire.
Section 1: Respondents’ background information
Request respondents to reveal their age, gender, level of education and length of time
working with Ecobank
Questions on Ecobank Mobile Banking
1. Explain the trend of mobile money usage (number/volume of transactions and value)
between 2010 and 2015
2. How do you describe the usage of mobile banking services by Ecobank customers?
(Use increasing, decreasing or constant)
3. The explain the devices that are used by your customers to carry out m-banking
transactions
……………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
75
4. Explain the financial services that are supported by your m-banking platform
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
5. What factors that influence customer adoption of mobile banking services in Ecobank?
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
6. How has your mobile banking platform contributed to improvement in service
delivery?
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
76
APPENDIX 4: QUESTIONNAIRE FOR BANK CUSTOMERS
Section 1: Respondents’ background information
1. Age (Tick one) 18-24 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-and above
2. Gender Male Female
3. Level of education attained (Tick one) University Secondary Tertiary
Primary
4. How long have you used Ecobank mobile banking services? 0-2 years 2-4 years
4-6 years 6+years
Questions on Ecobank Mobile Banking
1. Are you registered on mobile banking? Yes No
2. Which of the following devices do you mostly use to execute m-banking transactions?
Mobile phone ATM Debit Card Others (specify)
3. Mobile Banking services used by Ecobank
For each of the bank services in the table, select the M-banking service(s) that are
relevant to your banking needs in Ecobank and indicate how often you use that mobile
banking service (For each service you are required to select ONLY ONE code, e.g.
4=Always, 3=Sometimes, 2=Rarely, 1=Never).
4 3 2 1
Open a bank account
Check my account status
Pay bills
File taxes and access tax documents
77
Electronic check conversion
Transfer funds
Bank statement
Change passwords
Purchase bank products
Request a credit/debit card or cheque book
Request a loan and check status
Stock information
Tax documents and information/tax payment
Currency exchange
4. Factors that influence customer adoption of mobile banking in Ecobank
For each of the statements in the table, tick below the codes of your choice in regard to
factors influencing customer adoption of mobile banking (For each factor you are
required to select ONLY ONE code, e.g. 4=Strongly Agree, 3=Agree, 2=Disagree,
1=Strongly Disagree)
Factors for customer adoption of m-banking 4 3 2 1
Perceived usefulness
I can complete my banking tasks more easily with M-banking
MB allows me to transact business 24hours
MB increases my effectiveness and efficiency in utilizing banking
services
MB allows me to know account status faster
78
Perceived ease of use
I can easily learn to use m-banking
Instructions on the m-banking system are clear and understandable
The m-banking website is user-friendly
The m-banking system is easy to use
Perceived risk and security
I feel that m-banking will allow unauthorized person to access my
private information
MB is prone to signal failure and network congestion
I feel that am not legally protected from cyberspace fraud
The security policies of the bank give me a feeling that money
transactions via MB will be safe
5. Contribution of mobile banking project on service delivery
How would you rate the importance of Mobile Banking towards service delivery? (Use
codes where 4=Very important 3=Important 2=Average 1=Not important at all).
4 3 2 1
Cost saving (Lower rates, transaction fees)
Time saving (no need to go to bank or ATM)
Ease of access (can make transaction any time)
Physical security (no need to go out with Cash)
Customer comforts
Speed of service delivery
Top Related