GU』ARAT POLLUtt10N CONTROL BOARDRegional Office, Bharuch
Address: C-1l119/3, GIDC ESTATE, PHASE-ll, NARMADANAGAR, BHARUCH-392015E maiHD: Phone no: (02542) 246333
It is hereby informed that as per the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of lndia,
New Delhi vide its notification no. S.O. 1533 dated L4|O9/20[,6 and its subsequent amendment S.O.
3067 (E) dated OL/L2/aoof, Public Hearing is arranged for M/s. Methmani Flnechem timited, at plot
No. CH-1/CH-2, GIDC Dahej, Taluka: Vagra, District: Bharuch, Gujarat covered under category l(d) of
Category "8" as mentioned in their request application.
A copy of draft Environment lmpact Assessment Report and the Summary of Environment
lmpact Assessment Report were sent to the following authorities or offices to make available the draft
EIA report for inspection to the public during normal office hours, till the Public Hearing is over.
1. The District Collector Office, Bharuch.
2. District Development Office, Bharuch.
3. District lndustry Center, Bharuch.
4. Taluka Development Office, Tal: Vagra, Dist: Bharuch.
5. The Chief Conservator of Forest,
Ministry of Environment and Forest, GOl, Regional Office (West Zone), Kendriya paryavaran Bhavan,
E-5 Arera Colony, Link Road-3, Ravisankar Colony, Bhopal - 462015.
5. Regional Office, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Shed No. C-1, 119/3, G|DC, phase- , Narmadanagar,
Bharuch - 392015.
Other concerned persons having plausible stake in environmental aspects were requested to send their
responses in writing to the concerned regulatory authorities.
The Public Hearing was held on 0203/2018 at 11:OO hrs. at Project site of Meghmani Finechem Limited,
Plot No. CH-VCH-2, GIDC Dahej, Taluka: Vagra, District: Bharuch, Gujarat.
An advertisement in English was published in "The Times of tndia" on oL/o2/2oLB and in Gujarati in
"sandesh" dated 0t/o2/2o18.
Shri C.B. Balat, Resident Additional Collector & Additional District Magistrate, tharuch
supervised and presided over the entire public hearing process.
A statement showing participants present during the public hearing is enclosed as Annexute - A.
GUJARAT POLLUT10N CONTROL BOARDRegiOna!(〕ffice,Bharuch
Address:C-1/119/3,GIDC ESTATE,PHASE しNARMADANAGAR,BHARUCH-392015E mal‖ D: Phone no:{02642}246333
A statement highlighting issues raised by the participants and responded by the representative
of the applicant during the public hearing in English and Gujarati Languages is enclosed as Annexure B &
B1 respectively.
A copies of responses received in writing from other persons having plausible stake and written
representation received during Public Hearing in environmental aspects are enclosed herewith
collectively as Annexure - Cl to C29 and the replies by applicant to the same are enclosed herewith
collectively as Annexure - D1 to D29. copies of Public Hearing advertisements as published in Local
Gujarati & Local English newspaper is provided in Annexure - E1 to E2.
d
rd
an “
h
B
晩 呻
Res:dentl:lィ lil[1111111。 r
&Additiona:District
Magistrate,Bharuch
Encl:
Mノs.Meghmani Finechem Ltd
Plot No. CH-1/CH-2′ GIDCDah可′Taluka:vagra,
District:Bharuch
07′03/2018
1)Annexure A,B,Cl to C29,Dlto D29,El to E2 as above
2)Video DVD of Pub‖ c Hearing
3)CD of Public Hearing Proceeding
ANNEXURE - 8 IENGUSHIA statement showinq issues raised by the oarticioants and resoonses bv the reoresentatives of the
aoolicant durine the public hearinr
As per the provision of notification no. S.O.1533 dated L4/Ogl2OO6 and subsequentamendment S.O.3067 (E) dated I't December 2009, Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate
Change, Government of lndia, proposed project by M/s. Meghmani Finechem Ltd. For the proposed
expansion of Thermal Power Plant - (1) Power plant-5s MW to 132 MW and (2) Steam (lncludingprocess & power) -290 TPH to 650 TPH covered under category 1(d) of "B" of above referrednotification. Public hearing was conducted on 07lO3l2O78 at 11:00 Hours at the project site of M/s.Meghmani Finechem Ltd. at Plot No. CH-1/CH-2, GtDC Dahej, Ta. Vagra, Dist. Bharuch (GU.,ARAT)
under the chairmanship of Shri C.8.Balat, Resident Additional Collector & Additional DistrictMagistrate, Bharuch.
Shri R.R.Vyas, Regional Officer, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Bharuch welcomed allpresent to the Public Hearing. He outlined the various provisions of the notification and briefedabout the procedural details for conducting this public hearing and the advertisement published inlocal daily newspaper. He announced that as per the notification only locally affected persons will be
allowed to make their representation in the public hearing while having plausible stake may submittheir representation in writinB which would be included in proceedings, he made it clear that all therepresentations/ guestions raised during public hearing will be included in the proceedings of thehearing.
The public hearing was declared open with the due permission of the Chairman and invitedthe Project Proponent to start their presentation in Gujarati language.
Representative of M/s. Meghmani Finechem Ltd. presented information about company andthe proposed project in detail including technical information, Environmental Management System,
effects of the proposed project on environment and control measures proposed and socialresponsibility of the industry in Gujarati through power point presentation.
After completion of the presentation Shri C.B.Balat, Resident Additional Collector &Additional District Magistrate, Bharuch informed to the audience the following:
. The purpose of the ongoing public hearing.
o The representations of the nearby 21 affected villages specially related to plant andenvironment would be discussed.
. The presentation should be made by the representative after providing his name and villagename. Representatives other than those who are not from the above discussed 21 villagescan make written representation over here and the reply of the same will be given by thecompany.
. Neutral decision will be taken in the interest of the people considering the matters relatedto environment, plant and employment without discussing about any other matter on thisplatform.
. All representations will be recorded and then after the same will be forwarded to the upperlevel of State Committee.
After the presentation, with due permission of the chair, the representative of GpCB openedthe forum for representations; objections; or questions from the locally affected people.
Page l of 7
The statement showing issues raised by the participants and response made by the representative ofthe applicant during public hearing are as under.
Sr.
NoName and Address Point Represented and
written submissionReplies givenby concerned
officer1 Shri Jaydeepsinh
Ramsinh Rana(Sarpanch)
Vill: Dahej
Dist: Bharuch
. To spent CSR fund inDahej by MeghmaniCompany, one weekbefore the meeting was
the
representatives of thecompany. Assuranceletter for spending 50Lacs fOr the
constructionEntrancereceived.
Of
o We appreciate theinitiative taken by thecompany to provideemployment to localpeople and we requestto increase pay scale ofthe locals working sincemany years. Requestyou to take care of nodiscrimination foremployments of localpeople.
o Monthly recurring costto run STP of Dahejvillage is very high. lfcompany utilize treateddomestic water of STP,
it will reduce theoperational cost.
. We are thankful tothe Sarpanch ofDahej village and
w■ h
request as well asyour suggestion willbe noted. Weconsider Dahej andnearby villages as
our own village andwe are reallythankful to 27villages who have
supported us sincelast 10 years.
Present GIDC andDahej lndustrialAssociation jointlytaken the initiativesto reuse the treatedsewage water.
2 Shri Pushkarsinh Rana,
Vill: Dahe.i
Oist: tharuch
. Company would spendits CSR funds inconsultation with theaffected 21 villages fortheir requirement andsatisfactory needs.
. This village is stillbackward in educationfield. Request you todevelop industrial
and provide
. Chairmaninformed that
appreciablework of thecompany.Companymust takecare to utilizethe csR fundsfor theeducation
Page 2 of 7
Replies by concernedProiect Proponent
sedor
technical institutions forthe locals for theirhigher studies.
. lt is also appreciablethat company has
worked for thetechnical education,land losers, and alsoprovided the educationalong with the skilledcertificate to theunskilled people.
o The land has beenacquired by the GIDC
and that land is given tothe company, they arenot providing thebenefits which is to berequested.
. GIDC must do thecommission of CETP atthe earliest and also totake the appropriateaction for control ofwater scarcity duringsummer. Suitable Planhas to be made byGIDC, lndustries andleaders of the villaBes toensure drinking watersupplies and use ofwater utilized inindustries so that thesituation of closure ofcompany will not occur.During the high tide, thewater become turbid inthe raw water suppliedby GIDC and for thatreason health peopleget affeAed. lnupcoming days thisproblem is to be getresolved so that thiscondition will not affectvigorously.
and health of
the l● cals_
Page 3 of 7
Sr.蘭
Name and Address Point Represented andwritten submission
Replies by concernedProject Proponent
Replies given
by concernedofficer
Point Repres€nted andwritten submission
Shri Ranjitbhai Gohil,Village: Dahej,
Dist: Bharuch
. Since last 2007, thisplant has beenoperational; thecompany has not onlytaken the locals for thejobs but also promotedthe people even in HR
department which is
appreciable.
. Company has given theemplovment to the 80young people of the
Shri Jayend rasinhPravinsinh Rana,
Vill.: Dahei,
Dist,: Bharuch
Company has not spentCSR funds since last 10
company has
committed to providefund for construction ofvillage Gate. How muchfund will be providedby the company for theconstruction of awashfor the people ofscheduled caste andwithin how much timethe same will beprovided?
. Attempt should bemade to develop thegreen belt before thestarting of productionprocess of the plant.
Yearly planning ofthe CSR fund has
been done by thecompany and thesame will be utilizedaccording to theirrequirementdiscussing withvillagerePresentatives.
This project has
been sponsored byWorld Bank and ithas given guidelinesfor utilization of CSR
fund.
33Y. of thegreenbelt will bedeveloped within ayear.
. Chairmaninformedthat, thereareschemes ofthegovernmentfor awash
discussingwith theTDO andobtainingrequiredinformationthe benefitof the samecan beavailed.
Shri MahendrasinhKhumansinh Gohil,Vill.: Dahei,Dist.: Bharuch.
. Three days agocompany had declinedto provide theemployment to thepeople who weregoing for their medicalexamination.
. Management willbring the solution ofthe issue withinshort time.
Shri Suleman Patel,(Ex- Dy. Sarpanch),Vill.:Jolva,Dist.: Bharuch.
It is my request thatpriority should begiven to all nearbyvillages for utilizationof the CSR fund.
PaEe 4 of 7
Sr.聞
Name and Address Replies by concernedProiect Proponent
Replies givenby concerned
officer3
4
5
Shri Saniaybhai Gohil,
Vill:Lakhigam,
Dist:Bharuch
There are around 35 to40 companies nearbymy village thoseCompanies refuses toprovide employmentto local people. Whilethis company hasprovided employmentto 5 people of ourvillage and hasemployed two people
Shri Suresh Parmar,Vice-President ofTaluka PanchayatVagra
Vill.: Kadodara,Dist.: Bharuch.
. Activity of thecompany related toemployment to localand CSR fund areappreciable.
Shri Naresh Gohil,Vill.: Lakhigam,
Dist.: Bharuch
With other cleaneroperations available,why the coal will beused as a fuel in thecaptive power plant?
Company should giveinformation aboutspread of the dustingdue to the company itsaffect on the health.
. Oetailed informationrelated to the samehas been provided
on the page no. 116of the EIA reportprepared by thecompany and thesame has been
uploaded on thewebsite. Norms ofthe CPCB for the use
of coal are verystrict. So company
electrostaticprecipitator. Lime
will be added to coalto control theemission of SO2 and
boiler of latesttechnology will beused. Detailedinformation ofdustings areprovided in EIA
report in table no.4.8. For monitoringof the emission,online stackmonitoring system
Page 5 of 7
Sr.“
Name and Address Point Represented andwritten submission
Replies by concernedProject Proponent
R€plies given
by concernedofficer
8
9
5r.No
Name and Address Point Represented andwritten submission
Replies by concernedProiect Proponent
Replies given
by concernedofficer
From where the coalwill be brought?
During the
transportation of thecoal in the closedtruck, coal falls on theroad and accident arecaused due to thesame.
Whether company willprovide medical
assistance if any
abovementionedaccident occurs? The
ambulance facility are
not made available tothe local people.
. Can company provideonline system tomonitoring dusting innearby villages?
. Why company is notestablishing powerplant which runs ondiesel or gas? Why coalis given priority?
ln other units ofMeghmani, there havebeen incidences of fireand accident in past,then why permissionshould be granted tothis company?
will be installed and
it will be linked toGPCB'S and CPCB'S
server.
Coal will be broughtfromcompany in the PVC
coated closed truck.
After Discussingwith the AdaniCompany about thisissue care will betaken to prevent theaccident.
lnsurance are takenby the respedivecompany for thesame and medicalassistant are giveunderinsurance.
such
. To sustain ininternational market,usage of coal is
important, alsoCPCB'S norms forusage of coal is verystringent and CPCB is
serious about itscompliance.
. No such incidencehas occurred in past
10 years. Themanagement andownership of allMeghmani group ofcompanies aredifferent, although
Page 6 of 7
Sr.
NoName and Address Point Represented and
written submissionReplies by concerned
Project ProponentReplies givenby concerned
officerthey bear similarnames,
Before the public hearing, total eight (8) written representations were received, in which (1)Annonymous of dated 13/02/2018, (2) Shri Dharmesh Mistry, Bharuch, (3) Shri yogesh p. pandya,
Managing Trustee, Safety, Health and Environment Association, (4) Shri Ajitsinh Raj, president,BhartiyaKishansangh, Vagra, (5) Shri Mahesh Pandya, PariyvaranM itra, Thaltej, Ahmedabad,(6)ShriJayeshbhaiShankarbhai Patel, Rander Road, Surat,(7) Shri pravin p. Seth, Chickoowadi, Ankleshwar,(8) ShriHashmukhVora, Amroli, Surat, then after during Public Hearing one more writtenrepresentation were received from (9) Shri RanjitsinhGohil, Vill.: Dahej,
Several letters welcoming the project are received prior to this public hearing from thefollowing villages: (1) Shri Pravin K. Patel, Sarpanch, Janiyadara Gram panchayat, (2) Smt.RamilabenArjunbhaiParmar, Sarpanch, Atali, (3) Smt. KamubenGohil, Sarpanch, Suva, (4) Shri t.C.Raj,Galenda Gram Panchayat, Galenda, (5) Smt. PalavibenParma r, Sarpanch, Akhod, (6) Shri J.D. parmar,
Sarpanch, Koliyad, (7) Shri S.R. Gohil, Sarpanch, Sambheti, (8) Smt. Kaliben R. padhiyar, Sarpanch,Paniyadra, (9) Shri Thakor H. Vasava, Sarpanch, Vav, (10) Shri Narendrasinh R. Gohil, Ex-sarpanch,Narnari, (11) Shri AjitbhaiChandubhaiVasava, Sarpanch, Padariya, (12) Shri Arvindsinhparmar,Sarpanch, Kadodara, (13) Shri Jagdishbhai H. Prajapati, Sarpanch, Jolva, (14) Sarpanchshri, LakhigamPanchayat (15) Sarpanchshri, Luvara Gram Panchayat.
ln addition to the above, various organizations have also given letters welcoming thecompany's expansion project and acknowledging information about the various CSR activities carriedout by the company, namely (1) Rotary Club of Bharuch, Narmada Nagri, (2) Ashmitavikash Kendra,(3) Dahej Eco-Friendly Society, (4) Hariom Solar Foundation and (5) Central South Salt Association,Dahej, were also received. These representations as Annexure Cl to C29 and their replies by theapplicant as Annexure D1 to D29 will be included as the part of the Minutes of Meeting.
Shri R. R. Vyas, Regional Officer, GPCB, Bharuch, summarized the proceedinBs and with thepermission of the Chairman, declared the public hearing as concluded.
M/s. Meghmani Finechem LtdPlot No. CH-1/CH-2, GIDC
Dahej, Taluka: Vagra,District: Bharuch.
07 /o3/2018
R. R. VyasRegional Officer, Bharuch and
representative ofGujarat Pollution Control Eoard
& Additional DistrictMagistrate, Bharuch
Page 7 of 7
Place:
aattt_41(■ %eta)
ct18 u・ttqtt εマRal■ 1町t Ctla ttttマ %8マ q[■ utaa■ atn Цa■tγ ctt《 uRan ttQt
uЩ qι■‐aQ γatq
utd ut8tマ Ctt q4 ua Ц■qマЧ ttatc・ ta,ct4 ιdott敏さtcttЦt 3■ 3:ユun tЦ33,d
t`/OC/200S uaaCtt Цdott tuttt3■ 3 aun 3010(6), Ctt Ot/tt/200ιat u電試Цa
ミu藪 ミЦЦ颯 3t64LЦ O■ sゝはマt(1)utqt ttt記 _stミЭttaこ ■ 132ミЭtta3 un(2)』 Ц
(Щqt ua■a■ ua)2ιO a■ュЦ■ 9.。 ■■■Ц ctt騰試マЧt Щを■ ttRa%ctt(頭紀)
LゝЭta t(■ )“4"■ 4qn acttac.tD eЩ ■ゝ ct■3■■tqtt d:00/o3/20■`Ott aγ
■.00
3CtttミudミЦЦ嗅 3t6■tЦ Q■じs■ ■9晃 utぴa t13 4-■ au―■/m.■■_t,υЩ。■■
6さ%,dt CttOttt,υ Q3Ц Щa acttm ЦR3 3a3at υn ЦR3 υtttミυte■,α3■ ■■.4.
qc.ttd uさCt4■Цttdtさ6帆 ttuCtt■ Щact
■ 42.4t tta,哄LQ3■03ta,■ %マtd ututt Raλ堅 ぬs,a3■ ■ttt a3
■■tq嗅■ 6Ц〔nd ia uq3t工 裁 6.‐6a.aaRLQt.■d■d anЦ ttЭtct10■ Цa Ct■3
■囃q咀 りR4■a ЩQd ut■ aЦQぬ`嗅
ttt 4 Ct13■ ■tqЧl■ ot●■ハ リQQ Щゝ aqtaQ
vel‐γεt ЦOtd Cttqa na ЦQdottt 3m anaさЩR3 1R3 Ctatct Цn■ 観さマЦqt‐■a
3ぞ qttt uact蹟さttd■a Цet ЦteR 4■ qЧm ana観さぞtd 3a t uct ttQι Qt■■
nactt6■咆utt uta3.utりa ctla%Щ ttcttqm■ ■o3ぞてutd 3■ ■8■,誠よ` Ca刺
nd ttttqd薇赳αGan an4マでЩd and■ 3a tt3ュ ea 3tactta nЦЦt uЦtatt 3Rctt■
utqミ ana製じd3■ L Щ n3、4qRl uRO,■ ottqtt εマЩta tγ aac.t cttCtaa utqa
c.tsa 3taaЦ■■Щatt 32Cttt 4Cta
赳マ哄te a)a Цaa颯4 ЦtCtt■00■ Ct13■ottq颯ぬ 哄'Q3■
ata、n■%ctt3tta
aЦ4、nd uRa%。 tt aミ uta3織ЩЦi ЩGRマて82ctt%興tact
ЦRユ%at3tマCtt uRaQ嗽マt3.■ Qミ■ЦtS■ ,ЧRa%ctt4 ЩRハ,Ccutea tta4
Цt2■,■cttЦ■Ott ЦЭtd,総■%くt4を348Q ЦteR,.■qttta qqtЩЦくЦЩQ a■ ■ua
m und aaa颯,cun dЩ utЦo3%CttqCta Цta4 3tЦЭQa■■■%tta ЩЩ■
)3ぬ Qt4 3マ Ctt■ ut可 .
娘 a%ctt駄マ.tt uRRQ ttttマ %utd Цは鉄4●ttε ЦЩatta tはt鋼 し,嘔ミ 4n3
■囃qtt Цqt ttt記4 aЦdt quttqt cttttct4■aЦ■qttt cttCta e■■ 3tCtttt da Щミ
3aa Щ K_tttt qtЦ d■ ■■201Ц 3d tt3ta actt utγ cttγ ctt 21 0■■4?マでЦta a■ a■ Щu
3aa t_ttttctt aCd■ ■a Ц4qマ堅・ ttqd4■■ 3マ CttЦi■lqa a■ 9■びmtでЦtd a・ a
ndti cttЦ υn OttЦ 41■Ц%堅t4マγutd 3ヽ a Rcttatt Цa ctla l en 21 0■■■ uЩ att
Page 1 of 10
aa ct』,an and、 マて.d3■ 2t3a ua 3Ц4■マtミュ創ndi γcttot uuCtt■ utqユ .
螺 ヽ_la3a■ aぴ 薇赳り3tt4■■ Oott a■。tt Bd■ ua ua ua Ц■qぞ尊,《ttt Цa
a%Э■■94 ct■ cttctaa t■Ot、 ctぴa dau na an aはЦ3マ ctt■ utqミ n dЩ tt aびЦ堅
り.aa a an tЩ a acttЦi ucta un dЩ マctt8 6uctt actc.t4283R■ ■■3CtCttЦt uCtミ .
dltCtte uttQ3 ЦQ3ta,ol%ttd u長、Чt aaaЧ ぬs ttttt ua■颯4ЦマcttCt01■ 1臥tR3
Цuua ct■ a4マlμta/4Щn/tun Щ≧■u■a13qt■ 4馘
ct13■ottqtt ε04く ot%マ Qさa Ctla`ttt in3Ц iマυ3tq■ _actりn/4Щ /ミun/■dqaЦγ utγetectl uRRQ ttttt uЦ qt■ 4ね り劇da 4a■%ct e:
utl eBgr rttlt"tl
n?1iqs{lqi {at{l dlArti ir,il"ft e3nta ut0.
uexa tfl{ i.}t1t i}t"ti.
tgai ugt tata{a6!i. ebqr uiutgongai cttui. ttIl4ltt?t Ct ruX rrt"[la.
tfl{ iuqr eo currlf, ro.r{eII r,tui. "} uet
il€sta 141,irl t oteet
lual qc,t Uot utatt?.
ミЦЦtt tum mtt6さ%■ ■■■Цtマ 3s
qЦtttt a Цtゝ ιЦ■4uRRQ uta46Cttiatヽおctt■■Ot
aaQ 3Ц■ ■o
cttu4 Цtt εさ%Э ttЦa
uatt■マctat4 utua
a Цtta a8マ 3■■■
■Цa ttミct e
reuRs als-Ii t-Irctt{l
r,{Uctt r{t}at iU"ftAl
uu."tl. i QretdlrltflQ luet I NrtRs
ctLsl. qqu .r{di .tfsfl
sl E fu,l.ai ucu.t
uftqt qurcrt{ r{4.
adi A.i.{l E. tqtRs
alsfi r-Iqrcufl
r,ttUcttHl S].d Oe A{ct
E{l crqfluGle
rr{Ne ?tq[,
(reriq)ctt{: tbif.
U. :0t?U
Page 2 of 10
0■
r1e1 rg srate"j
"ttr qiutatt
rSoua sla rlatrriliu"{lar u[iRQ art
r{uA( uqd?
nc,ifQa r*Ost{t
Cl.?t lrtUlaa
uqd?
t
d Et?r A uqr qtir
trui. d{cn{ r,tta..
e&cr ctt{+[ rlnJlr{t iuat.rcuQ utrl u[&iqqtr crutl E. A{udtr{t a[ gtu slautqfti iu"0 ul.arar
crq?trr qt} a alrladl{l a qctrqqr
ur) Eal. u{"j atRqt
qat$l usrq.
eta uqtfldl r,ri e&qr
el"snflua rlrtdhluatigsa fli qdr ai utg[l
i. ga, aurtrt u[ adru! I ut) aL ue{dl. s{r6t E.
ЦЦ猟■ avξttac.t し,
マてutd
3dミ
ttt44
3tЦЭQa aatet4 auttcS4Ц D.
3Ц■ ■ ■
■Щ しЩCt
ttuq 畿ぴユ
ι nd可mauЩマ35
0tt■Ctt
ctlttt Q緻堅
ua uュЦtら ctuttu.
,{l gurG[e
?rgl.r.,
cLl,{ : EE9t,
P. : Alrl
3■■ ユ Qcttat
ma..tt:s4Цョ
Цtを ■■2olu ttOttt a uta tta em
Ott■Ctt an■ %3■■d
護a■ 2t3ta
ut ottЦ Qa噂 ユλ ξυ
ЦOtd e aЦ% Щ
■■03 0Цtt aぴ
ut autマ■ 3ゝR3a
び決a“18 鮭a a Цtゝ
めsЦ』 りЦd ata a
Цtゝ4 utγ D
i.qir )s"{lsa Qlerqr
qr) iudl A slatstul' Q"s ajut{ aur
Page 3 of 10
3Ц
1e1 ty stara"j
Atr+ rrtinaari
?Vr4td slcl tEtr,tliu"0d ufaRQ flrt
uurLa u,qar
noifQa r*Osr{l
art uurLauqd?
?
l,t"?r +e{As ctt-I }Suiaf As qcl B Iutlguo B aa
uQlaqt r,r.{li getur
aflctt-I a{l}"ttuJIfl}a uqt utQa D
I uarc"ftar E.
U.u6.fl.ril. 6t?t
crqti qr{l"t tlu{laracnrrl rrtQ E tti iqrr{la iu"{li qtucnul
r,td E lttliu.?4r6.Sl.r{1. d?geII Iatot rru.nrl utd. iurtqqtul r,ttqat arII.
i. r,uucrt fr00..
υЦt■ma nぴ a■'
鑢d dt uq Щa a
Ц≧■ 3tЦЭla 8マ4aЦγ 6ottttt■ Цt゛4aol octttqt Цじ4ЦOtC・tt a4 utaatt■ ■Цt6 a
aЦ% 6“ョぁ ■a
ottЦ4 utaCttaa■tOt倶 44 ■qtat
uttt Цa n■03qЦttttat Щ帆■
qctut 86 aa
3マ qta D油 《t4
otatqQ●■ 3Ц4こЦ
Page 4 of 10
iu"0ar u[iRQ artuurilcr u.Eaa
noiQa q0.a{lgtrr rlutLat
uqd?
1dl eg seatr"j
at{ r*ittt"uli
t!:r*ta slat {etrrl
3マ Ctta uЦa Ct uta
atactt uЦa .taatt■ υЩ。.n■
■tt e Щtt ЩЦqt■
uta e a sa屯 臥o敏破D_■a actt 3RQ
ct■■4 utuaa■32■Ot ata D‐Ott■
λqRЦi ut ua ctl■a
netua■uマ ct ttЦ
a Цtゝ Щ 電臥a u堅
cttnt ctc.tc・ ttctCtt Otu
nan e。uRanaЦtЧ
■ Ct3ttCtt
a買 3ヽa
■ 3Ц■■
■9縫 actec・t uetlぞ
ct{ ?ooo}t[ riu"0"j
iqseta et3 uaj crtee{l
atl i urcr gtII 3u"[l
A NuG.s alslil-Iqycufl {a. ixrRlri orad ud at{t}ar uar.al sla E.
iu"0Q ru-ottv"tiao cu{Lal etrtQtrt co
q*ali rlctcr.r{l
urQct E.
{ aqtuaotttl
cit&a
cU,H. : ttY,
P. : A}l
. qt:{8{Eft A1'quaa !,rruc{ttt Xt}
uzster{l aul.ctatltqatda B
irri Jt$tql
iltAq rttrqql sfla
. gu.[ rl t{lrtrttr,ra $si.r{qrr ratHcr s}a E
lrrqr lttlt"tl ruc]ctal.
ntD, xu[ti ru{"ft
r?flqtct 5ra dhluuut
$sa16uu1ct sfl{.. rd}tt?-I r,t Ulifa qcd
dI *rrfnr sla E ui Iu) {lQnr,u is stl
. iu"ft a Ec<tt rncr{rri {rl.ur,tt $s
qtQet aell. ctSct?ltl
r).suai iu"{l (t?t
ruu"j ua.u 6r.? ot"ttdl
l{tuqp{ r,ucreL igaB Eilet. r,t ut0
otld.ur u[ r{r{r?r
u[dqt+[l cutlr,rfi
颯 γ凛 籠ё
り4尊〔お ttぃ ,
OttЦ :6れ ,
υ.:α3■
Page 5 of 10
3Ц
1al rg'sratr'!
"tt{ lrtintari
a3n*ta sla latr,il3q"0ct ufeRQ ctar
uulct u.gae
noi[0..t r,r[0sr{l
fl?r qqtact
uqd?
Y
%3■ ЩQ組
ミn4 油C・ttQ utu
c・tぴ Qta a.
fli. qtqaq1 i rr)"0
ctttjscttti"t ugt tuqct
E.
o lrttcLtr[l O,s q{Xl sgZ
uurql a olaAct i.enr
s?cu.{ uttctol.
utLctttt ot"ttctctt ltt)
iu"ft }acft rres s?il
ui nu gtllui. z
o (. .o? "tt ufss?t"t tl.?
Ectt uEett cJl"td.ce
ienr EtJ rn?r a.qt
uer@il g?crt *da.o lrtt u8totl IiCtI.e 9S
ulru{i uue G.etsrgt
c-il.cral.
. 6u"[ fl aqt [t,.tttu&at olsttuil LEIga
8 ? ctt Vctl. 6ctt etliui als{l Q d.n"[
"tt qt{I.
颯 ЦさこRξ
ЧЦOt熙
510α,
OttЦ :εさ%,
つ :Q3u
。■a■Щマ 3s Ц虚
ЦLγ―Ottυal CtЩ%。ttta ttcttCtd
utuqt■ 4a a4Цt■ 0直ハ D
a{I Uaqt"tqla, (utu 3.
uariu)ru{: Actqt,
U. :QQr{
r{rtt?t cUf"[ "tUSr,{,Qtt 3tt ell UO
iu"ftr,il r,ttaar E Iiu"ftl,rl tqtRs cils-Ii
frqui d{.n"[ at ut3
E te{r} l,tt iu"0 ai,tl{L?L Jtt{otl Uir{
ulstrr,tli i afs{t Ac{lQa E qi o{Itt <1
tsLsetul.i lllJlet {iugt rtr,at E.
r(I rlqraro{d
citRc-t
rtt{: Gtu{lrttlt,
P. : Otlrl
. su"{I A reuRs afs1"0
r-Icrcufl ut) i.urdlilur,ue $s ltt)
a[ q]er uaute,
c(.. ria{tara
atcrtt 6uu5u
Page 6 of 10
3Ц
rjel ay srare"j
atr r*i.+taat{
rSoua sla 5atu1iq"0ar UIARO flrt
uuttra uqar
{r,i[ua 4[0sr{6t?t rr{Utae
Uqct?
tt
5́
0
`
Jttr{:sS'IE?t
9. : A3rr
sletL sL{]. uriu.0?r B.
ιЦ4 aぴ utぴa ntea靴マ3、ct D●■ ■ott
a tts ut ut■■■
RЧd ЦtS■ utac.tD
aЦ% a actaぴe u?
■ЦCt15 3` C・t e ctЧ■
acta cttЦマctt Цt≧
■■■4 ctt attu Ц興
358 0 0 Цtと 3Ц■
ぴan oa3)■■を3マ
C・tOttqれ,so2 4 6融式
a aand 5QqtユQЩ
utユ 、at a CミQqti
■tcta aЦ% Цctcta
b3anυ qttttぬぴc.ta
n cunЭt 8ぞ qtЦi
utqミ sJЭ t a■■
Ootdqtマ ЩQハ ぴutぴユ
aQ84ゝ哄ct 4 Y`■
ula E. 6uala 6ct{al{.uc{, :{t} rril"tatd"t
€s :L"[a{lcr Rrau
l5c{r}r[ utctil *au{tt{lo{t lrrqr {lrltdlr,0
ar ttdr ut0. c{ls Erqtxi
lrtl.ctil.
. g-Ianl. aus"[ r,retgll
iq"[ A eII ,{I.{ldt
sldlct stcn o,iU ?g-I :{i
atctcnul r,ttcril.
ぃact utcttt lat配
Цtと 鮭帆dЧ d■LuCtЧ Щヽ ●tnd堅・tt
a3(. acttじ ctt
aQuta%6ЦaOt lЦ
3t qt■ Цtqユ ?
3Ц4■こⅦ Itttt at
aa teq saot aa
aЦ%a44Qさqta
al■ 32■Ot aa a4
Цttd utucttЦ i ua?
glaul r.ttPII atqqtrll{tctt'l?
a{l a}er citGa,
rr.r.{r ctuftrtt]t
!. : Atl?l
Page 7 of 10
3Ц
5el ?! s?"tt?"i
otFt uanrati
rgora stet 1atu13,{"{l+r u{aHfa grer
uutLct u(gar
u<,i[0a uQrt{l6r?r.{uacr
uqd?
C
ЦЦ量颯ユ
γqtact t,
ut ult
4amQOLa a63Ц4anc.tu4t
■tRct●・ta
dQЩaactt
un cは 4
ЩЦ aЦγ
u3Щ d ct
uttu a
Ц●■
dιεta
tЩ4.
l{t qrora uErqft tq"{l
f,3 qqt gfli rlsrr{ta
"t nglq i ut)"ft alet{l?ru{tSi.
ut Цゝe a tdl tttマ t
uctOt■ 6c証ミ漁
acttЦi 4qa aa D,a
■6_a u3猟ld uttЦ
a 6凛 1ヽべ ■dold
ミR3ct uota Цa
こЦ I■■
octt uacteSot
eさdt4 ac・ta
dQ■ 3utd
fr sl.U l,{tql ustrtl.d
tt%l?r. aL iu"[ lCssct
uot?r r,rtuel.z 3u"[a.
tqr) !.roa1a.u ut)
riq5 stqtul r,{ta, E
erl iu"0 6t.?t
rlx,qa"u ilcnrrtl
Guaou srqtul ]uqdl
aeII.
s+llct u) iu"[l,tl.ttUl.ltott cUULUl
Gctda"[t r,ilaauJa
urqqft ut]a utual
{l u}z
Page 8 of 10
3q"{I4t ufaR0 arrt
uurtrct uqae
troiQa u[ist{lgttt r,rqtLa
uqd?
5e1 rg atatr"j
"ttq rlanrati
eEur.t sla 5atoil
eu {re iu"0 Brle }ofn +iqt(aa qtq?
rat"e aell or"tt.rdlz
s'Ieturi urE(Lsat e[qLlz
lq:{(Q quotr. r,t"e{
gaalui .&)3dtt
tlastotui r,ttJr.
Atctctl.otl. dPl.L
l48t{tctatt otAtql.
q"rrt E al. eu. rtl utt
iu"0i riqfl uudlz
an3 0t望マ■ 3■ tさ qt
Ц≧ actua 6Ц aЭ t
%3a D, a.% aQatat
cunot Цtと n■■4at
a赳 Цttt 3S3 0 aЦ%
aat utcta Цtを ■■■4Цヽ 。iOnt e
tu4Ц i 3cc・tt ea qミ ■
4a n6 otottq Cta
ct』 ct■ , ミЦЦqQ
認Ц4 3Ц■■ uctot
uc・tot ミa%ヽ記 uaЩQ■ uttaじ,■3al
atЦ n3 uぞ屯 aaじ di
3u4at uma■ ctot
uctot Э[堅ta
ct13■■tq嗅 ■Ott6 ξct u6(`)andぞυЦta Цact e e■ (1)■ ultt R』 ,α3■ (2)
Ц■■マヽЩd,dt t3/OR/tOヽ`ぴ
―ミぴc・t ttttt ЦaC・t(3)■ ■aQt■ ■釧 ,ミattot tta,ミ 3a,
さct aatuaミ記 anQattot(`)■ ■υdRξ tt%,り ]Ц Qtマ da BQttct tttt,(■ )颯 γattは6
2132は6蛯Ct,tttt as,、マd,(9)■ unЧαt6■.ミ5,島 qt■,■3attt,(0)颯 ЦさQt us■ ,
■■qマ尊R■,aQa%,ЦЦetctte,(`)m ou■Ц att,.Цad、マd
ctl到・ttqtt uЭ LC and■ 41%qa γ臥_va ott i』 :Ц4■l Qatq■ett a
Цtq3ta40tl Цa u。 3tマ ЩЦd un ЦaC_tet ttЦ≧ct uaRt t _.マ Ц.,vttatett o■Ц
uutad,2■Ц組 ?颯ctta崚 将 ■mぴ ut Цtt― ■マtu,■3td OttЦ uЩЦd,3 ■Ц■ 3■a■
otqudQtぴ cnRct_■tuu,、 ctt ottЦ ЦЦtact,v ttn t4ぴ m et%_uぞ tu,Ota^t ottЦ u■ad,
Ч■Цa tc.c.t4aく 0■マЦマЦマーattu,■■8 0ttЦ ■atad,9■ 9 ■ ЦマЦtt ― ■2■■,
M48 0ttЦ ■ЩЦct,0 ■ au Цtマ 51oc‐t― ■マ嗅Ц,護aa ua祖■dQぞ 。ttЦ uutad,`.
■Ц■ 3tnaOt utt udatマ ーuマu■,Ц颯48tt OttЦ uutad,こ 颯 6taマ ユЦ quqt― ■ぞЦЦ,
CttCt OttЦ u■tuct,lo■ mBct a、こR・ Цtt._3 attu,cttЧ t4 ottЦ ■utad,tt.■ ctutctt
uυ dQtぴ ミモЩぴ―■tu■,Щ8aat ottЦ uutad,te muマ R6■ utЦtt_■ttЦ,3■6tt O■Ц
■Цtad,■ 3 颯 %ЭtattQt6 a■ uttЦR_utuЦ ,actqt OttЦ u■tad,tv uマ u■ 颯,qqtet ottЦ
tutud,lЦ utuЦ ttn,ctョlottЦ ottЦ uutact
Page 9 of 10
3Ц
5e1 ry se+rr"j
"ux r*iur<ri
rSora sla larr,triq"{Iat ufaRf{ nrt
uurlet urqae
{4[Qa r*Ost{l
attr uurlatU(E.t?
r,{. 6u?[cr Vdt-Vdt {urr,il arte{i iu"flai fQr.tagt u]*sa i r.,nqstral a{ rtee iu"06r.?r. csR !s ar orct 3Q u.enr qtII srarul urtdct (dQq uq.ftur]"0 mql s?cr. qe] ude E *uit. e&r tlsl $sa0 illuradl, Jl$r+er licr\"? il."er, a. a-Iafl sctq r,il$ ct3q arlet act{I, s.
urd{lar lastu ]"r,, x. il"ict mGpr {ir?r.cr ttle l"g}sat{ Qetrt{lrtrer"t.
il{er afs qar.rgfl E?re{tor r.{a?r {s (rt r{l vl"q[ile ufiqtHe ?tq[, ru]t , e&r argell
tIr,ua uda D. ut rl(r,uali iliaa r{l-r eII {l-ea ui t"ti uttgrtri. rliett fl-t tII $l-ec
a{l} gtd.ndl alu{ ttl{ta.u st.u}{[ r,ttqe].
iar{ r0. r4r?. r,n?. "anu, urEGIs r,rfisrfl, oj. u. R. a1S, oqu flet st{{6["t]' tttriu rg s{l
r,raaat"0 utqtac[l ao r,il.au? +to alsuatqqll rlql Eilet qnBa saqtxl uta.a.
lrtL?. Ul.?. caltil
uttGls q[Ust{l,equ uiclmra uquqL fieiaqt
qlS"ti u[iR0
fi,qtdl r,t[0s sd.sar l,tiu[0.s uccu luQar0, otlu
urrn: Lud lq{q0 gtoa}x fa. "flullse rutJa,
r*ila 'i - dl.{q.-td[.t{-a,U.r,tt6.gl.i{I. eBY, at. q.tctat,
u. 0t3q
atflrrt , oolosltotc
Page 10 of 10
Gujarat Pollution Control Board Regional Office, Bharuch
C-1, 119/3, GIDC, Phase-2, Narmadanagar, Bharuch-392015
Website: www.gpcb.gov.in
Annexure – C
A statement showing response and comments received in written format from others concerned persons in
the Environment aspects for M/s. Meghmani Finechem Limited through Expansion in Power Plant
Capacity from 65 MW to 132 MW before Public Hearing held on 07.03.2018 at 11:00 AM at Project Site,
at Plot No. CH-1/CH-2, GIDC Dahej, Taluka: Vagra, District: Bharuch, Gujarat as per the Ministry of
Environment and Forests, Government of India, New Delhi vide its notification no. S.O. 1533 dated
14/09/2006.
Sr. No
Comments received in writing from Concerned Persons Annexure
1 Query by [email protected] via Email dated 13.02.2018 C-1
2 Mr. Dharmesh Mistry, Bharuch by Letter Dated: 26.02.2018 C-2
3 Mr. Yogesh Pandya, Bharuch by Letter Dated: 01.03.2018 C-3
4 Mr. Ajitsinh B. Raj, Bhartiya Kisan Sangh by Letter Dated: 03.03.2018 C-4
5 Mr. Mahesh Pandya, Paryavaran Mitra, Ahmedabad by Letter Dated: 03.03.2018 C-5
6 Mr. Jayeshbhai Shankarbhai Patel via Email dated 05.03.2018 C-6
7 Mr. P.P. Sheth via Email dated 05.03.2018 C-7
8 Mr. Hasmukh Vohra via E-mail dated 06.03.2018 C-8
9 Mr. Ranjit Gohil via Letter provided during Public Hearing Proceeding dated 07.03.2018 C-9
10
to 24
Letters (positive response/welcome letters) from 16 Villages namely:
Sr. No. Name of Village Date of Letter
1 Janiyadara 14.02.2018
2 Atali 12.02.2018
3 Suva 10.02.2018
4 Galenda 09.02.2018
5 Akhod 09.02.2018
6 Koliyad 08.02.2018
7 Sambethi & Samatpor 09.02.2018
8 Paniyadara 09.02.2018
9 Vav 09.02.2018
10 Narnavi 09.02.2018
11 Padariya 09.02.2018
12 Kadodara 01.02.2018
13 Jolwa 15.02.2018
14 Lakhigam 16.02.2018
15 Luwara 16.02.2018
C-10 to
C-24
25
to 29
Other Positive responses were received from other 5 organizations:
Sr. No. Name of Organization Date of Letter
1 Rotary Club of Bharuch Narmada Nagri 05.03.2018
2 Asmita Vikas Kendra 05.03.2018
3 Dahej Eco-Friendly Society 05.03.2018
4 Hariom Solar Foundation 05.03.2018
5 Central South Gujarat Salt Manufacturer Association 05.03.2018
C-25 to C-29
From: xyz xyz <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, February 13, 2018 12:34 PM To: gpcb-bha; [email protected] Subject: Non complaince of EIA Notification -Meghmani Finechem Limited Dahej.
પ્રાદેશિક અશિકારી અન ે
લોકસુનાવણીના સભ્ય સશિવ
ભરૂિ
સાહબેશ્રી
મેઘમની ફાઈનકેમ શલશમટેડ દહજે એ પોતાના હાલના પલાાંટમાાં પાવરપલાાંટના શવસ્તરણ માટ ેઈ.સી
મેળવવા અરજી કરેલ છે. અને તેમાટે લોકસુનાવની રાખેલ છે.વિુમાાંઆ કાંપની એ હાલની જગ્યામાાં
જ હાલના કઓશસ્ટક પલાાંટ અને નવા જાંતુનાિક રસાયણો બનાવવા માટે દદલ્હી અને ગુજરાત
ખાતે બીજી અરજીઓ કરલે છે અન ેતે પડતર છે.આ અરજીઓનો કોઈ જ ઉલ્લખે હાલના EIA
દરપોટટ માાં કરવામાાં આવલે નથી. માત્ર પાવરપલાન્ટ નો લોડ બતાવીન ેસાિો લોડ છુપાવવા પ્રયાસ
કરેલ છે. લોકોન ેઅન ેકમીટીઓને બેવકૂફ અન ેવિારાના લોડની ખબર ના પડ ેતે માટે હાલના EIA
દરપોટટમાાં માશહતી આપલે નથી.આ કાંપનીની તમામ અરજીઓ MOEF ની વેબ્સાઈટ પર ઉપલબ્િ
છે. આ બાબતેને ધ્યાનમાાં રાખીને તાત્કાશલક પગલાાં લેવા શવનાંતી છે. Earlier criminal case was also file by GPCB for violation of EIA Notification which is also not metioned in present EIA Report.
આભાર
Annexure C - 1
Annexure C1 – (English Translation)
From, Xyz xyz
[email protected] Via Email dated Feb. 13, 2018. Subject: Non complaince of EIA Notification -Meghmani Finechem Limited Dahej. Regional Officer and Member Secretary for Public Hearing, Bharuch Dear Sir, Meghmani Finechem Limited, Dahej has applied for EC for Expansion of their Power Plant within their existing plant. And public hearing is being conducted for the said project. Company has also applied for expansion in caustic plant and agro products for the same plot at Delhi and Gujarat, which is in process. Current EIA report does not mention about these application. They are trying to hide actual load by showing load of only power plant. Public and Committee are kept in dark by not showing the additional load in the EIA report. All the applications are available on MoEF’s website. Request you to take immediate actions regarding this issue. Earlier criminal case was also file by GPCB for violation of EIA Notification which is also not metioned in present EIA Report. Regards,
cfr*,
iE{tdtat'
XwrnrqrurFzirud-d
rrift{rrr
sifuq{
Xv-aorryrGzi:uold
q[qt
qf{rfirdd+ i. q x, q{i. I ? Y o, c+qro}qd+€,
qTeTqR$-+fr+ffi,q5q1q]: tsq,zs"sqrq
fr4ls;(t-o1-1oq,a
G. p. s" Efl,eRm
(1)
idw : ffi q.r€r *q (fr, fuffir - sniq) a1 qrrifiufrq
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
8il6 V{qr$ a1 fr+.r-ffir
"ek
4tq'rl q-qEss *1 ect-t\RgEr *1 rrq t *g_€ ffi gq Functionat Area Exped *'am
oerT e€ri +tr-*tr t sRqr b ffi +rq fuqr t 3q-+1qr+Tfr nqr Bsml qqq qqt-qr op{
r+h qE * s-fr +{ dq & sp{ dq e)q. fr. e}q. q Ai il kqfr-ifrr
d;qfr {;r€ee * Qct-Nnerr * firn t s}tr€ M g( Functionat Area Expert *r{fra-arqr e{Fr+rfr t f+ l€. rs+1qm+rff l
ziqfr m;q'-cT€ * QcI-NABET & nrr t oig< ff,+ g( Functionat Area Expert * o16r tff,s ga €r fr s-{h 3fu 5.qer€ & ot< gq s-{R ft1 l-+e eh.. oti. o}q. t di & teq ffi r
d;q-fr s-q€€ * QCI-NABET fr aw * elg€ ffi g( Functionat Area Expert fr eEr tFds d fr s{+1TqM-q dn S-{sri + i.otTi.3i. n$d + fdS stq-+tc s1rffi316fuq mrq-q f{q t 3fu qrq-fu-qr t sr+1qr++rt r
ti,cfr {.ssrd & ecI-NABET + nw t eig< ffi g( Functionat Area Expert fr ot{t tfdse' fr s{*1ffi ds gfii q en{ t ss+1qrrfiftr
6{r€€ q1qqffiq d-{ s_{qd s#r qs ntq-€ + qlt q a1ffi qrfr t sv+i
qrflt r
).6\"2e-2-/, tt
Annexure C- 2
(7)
(8)
(2)
.irqfi i 6{ar{ d qs q}-+€ * fdq f*-flfi ds g'dr€ t Bs*i qrrmrfi opn .iq* ertr
6{s.{ & Ets M Sq flR *1 n+s slq. st. e}q. n- {s} e1 ffi r
drqr1il 6{e€ i {.BtT{.ei. fu}-J & ois{ + e}qt-d ACCREDITATIoN cERTtFtcATE
*1ara tt q- orTA t r q) sne +1nrnu fr qrq d d ur+1aflq-d qn d Ed +1ft.n snccTql
o{frffiTfr dRl e-S ofu ec s{h o}q. 3ti. e)q. t ti +1 frtfr r
NABET-ecrqFfflr slkr dml$hn qfiFn+z elq.oi.elq. fr t+ri.qTt.e\. filtJ or HsTq s{ffi qfr qr ilr, cq nqr sslr +r ilr{, qdr, dqfr fir eir$-
S qn nq wqr sr*rfr "td
d. W +i At{ sTfr +1 r+e e}q. ei. s}q. q {ui s1
ffirq-{€€ i +{-+{ S zirqri + fds Sr€ i.G{ri.ei. Ft'd q-{r{ t se.irffi +r clq o+(
eFlfltr (dr.o1-ot-ioll Q61. 1o-o\s-Qo{\s ncF)
(12) zircrl + er< gFe dr n\ gq{ro qvoi r+iew drd *l nrq t kn Eq ffig q}trq ruT drrs "is*{i +1r}trs oiq.ei.e}q. fr {ut +1fri5,
(13) gq{Tn {rq } qrE{.iq-fr fi +1{ S gn * d w +1 rqwr Fziew dr-d qrcr qft fti..r$ ffiflr)frs ne{r drrfr d-q s{i +1 +Es { g+r ?r a B{+1r?rm o}q.en.olq. t uqn s{i +1
ffir(1 4) s LEAc s1 n{F t dq4 6 qq * ToR 6r comp tiance s1 E+tsn r oo qftffi siq t ql {g
ss+1qn-mn1{ qqr
(1 b) oc r-Nneer +1 ffi-qT€i fd-ilfr dq gfi{ d t 3v+1 rsts f cr+fr I }r Bq{ qfi-+q q-{tiiq.3]} elq. i {ci qfi ffi |
(1 6) QCI-NABET fl frqqEql{ s-q-€E i ftri .d ETE{ + ffi Functionat Area Expert i g+qq q{qm ffi rrn Fd-J fr nq k=o & vfr (wrqr) or v+i t ss+1ErTil e-di +1 ffi |
(17) e+re lfi a+. ffi qqr frA t qr e,nt t s{+1 ffl( r qsi fi tdS lrq1 sti t fdqT rqT sq-+1
l+ro r qrfr qR +qr Go{r fucr .rqr t tr fr-f, elq.eti.e}q. fr d-+ r ger{ ffi gq est Bl fsF-eo
fiAnTfl€ * erq drrr
(18) sLEAC +1om t:+;q+ a Ri gt ron $r compriance *t e+t+-o 100 cR{rd qq Ei frss+1fqrf, rqn +tt
(19) sLEAC +1orq t drffi q} Ri g< ron sr compriance q1Eftt+-( roo qfuqm s-q d a]
ss-+t gfu Eirc+ fufu-d fr u-qo mt r
(20) fr<gvs il Tq, Tdr $q.et.oiq. i d+r(21) 4rqc1{F di h erq a,fr sftnrH'il =nq ero{ i-a il sw csRf( +.ri fr ent cplr es ckfln
emr+ ffi+11M ti fr elrir
(e)
(10)
(11)
(3)
(22) qs fr-+€ at 3idrtd or{trtrRI frRR + elirc{I qrd{ il dli oen ffi & s{,qTfr + drffiorirgnf, t ffi fi n.FR sr g+m t'm n) drffi +1 mqu,l qtfr +sT fr,EmqT ffi +rrq s} s-q€ fsqT A +{ dilrfr qT dqfr + fu{} ffifi qFmTfi sT q}iffiqr B)q.3i.$q. fr
rqn etr(23) rircfr + er< gfu fr cpcB +1ilq. t 4qfr iis s1i +1+Es tt fr qT{ A fr.ircri i 1Hs
*-S qq fdcT Bq+1 qmfl-fr I ap.r ffifi clR 6G S ff,s i{ rg $fi sffi * srTq (?lr
erui-{ o}q.Bt).o}q. q {ui +1 frifr r arrt m+rfi <wr fr qt ..Ts H$tc a{qc{r Es +1 r*-qsl {Rtq qi {+E olq.st.e}q. fr roi qt fuifr I
(24) ft-{r€€ i oct-Nnerr * e}*tr'svm sfiFn'*z lwnorrx) cTi + fe.S *1 rr{ 3trq efu en-q
* vrv aqn H rA *rut€ qi rznd (mrfr) elq.S.otq. fr {si +1ffir(2s) i.e{d.e}. dctJ sT iECcH s{iqrA qftt i{q ffifrs, qfri o'n q{ fr furT & eiv ga
B{-+1slfi wr+ri}r
(26) cqffiq et.{ V{drf fr n*tT Es'n}-+€ fr i.etr{.ii. rlqtj or tH{Tr ft-{ffi qfr +1
HEAffi il Aq-q fr srti fr,ro q-dri +1E.inlt
(27) er{r.trkr kRR + gffi ffi dFr oiM qnr il qrrrr t Bvft1qr-sffi I
(28) oRr.trRT f{ffR + oTeFr ercrq rfs e 5_drd6 ga ed qtr+Tfi oiq.3ti.s}q. t {qi s1
frifrr(2s) eRKtrkI ERR + d,t +l ltqrFm flqsrf, ffi t q] erorr-erc.r rris t TdTfrm emsRl r
(30) fs nt+€ fr eiflt( 3firtrkr fr-RR + effi +l npn drqql + sffiet qi iirffi er*g-ro tt6S sfi czER sT gm<n rS tn tsr qR" driq-{qr iH + qtu iircfr orrqT .irqfi +ffiqR qfrrfir0 +r eli?ffirT nq.3ii.slq. fr ego mG +1ftifir
(31) w q]-+€ + sid'in. er{rtrkr rdw.R + qrTrqr qre{ & ff nqr drq+ + sffif il 4n-fr
ercrsrkT t ffi S !.ffi fi 3+w rfr dmT tsT q}riElrTqr i-e.fr * s.M e) {qF Fmqr d oi{drrfr qr drqfr + fu{t iqr+sr eTRrflt sr q}'ierflqr s}q.ei.slq. fr nq( str
(32) Es.fi-+€ t orvcrw eRR + ffi +1<rn tiqfr + {ffi +1 .i[fr s]ctrsnf, t ffi E1
qihR Fr Ss-sr{G3{r fr q-.qm'{€q1Fffie-{fr t qr +s usat ufr qr;r+Tfr uqds{i +1
ffir(33) enq +me €dq-o Fffiffia fr er +rd *-{ffi t ?
(34) elrr+T Rrd m $"ft q<$q-d M mnq fr qr.q +-cqrqr tz(35) .iqfr effilqrd } qqq sr qr-scrc S .fE + mni qr et< sr<rrq.m frir qr dqr f++roffi t ?
(30) orsqrs il fi{ & ffi ft1gWe EqrflS & a6 qo, firqT t sqh qR fr +S qT{f,rfr
rffit?
(4)
(37) Eiqfr {qsd Es ct+€ * E.ari.e}. fltd q-rTi t srw +t{ .rf,fi qfi d fr Bsil €Tqi
fme v.ner.s ri qT-+-fr t qr +82
(38) q;qfr +-'qer€i Ee q]-+€ & g.ed.oi. d+j q-{ri fr enr *ti rrf,fr s1A d sst sTq}yds ffiqrE 6 qrsni t d Bv*1qn"+rfr o-oq eilr qrqEr h giletfi qTilmrfi t r
(3e) qs !t+€ + oiilfd or{frtrkr ts-ffiR + ffi +l rur qrffi + sffiofr dr d[fi 3ffi-srd tfus fr n.ER 6r go-vm *.n d dtq-fi +1 ffi q+,fr aRT $ra d,iffiqr +es il a-rqziqfi e?rqr drcfi * ffiqr{ o{Frsi0 sT frri*.flqr stq.sn.eh. fr ryo q€ +1B.ffir
fla : u-6raaaru-qmffi wwfi titfuqfuifi r
crS{T Fr*fr
e*qfi6,sfr
Annexure C2 – (English Translation)
Dharmesh Mistry Block No. 14, House No. 1340, Narmada Apartment,
Near Mamlatdar Office, Bharuch.
Mo: 9998609995
Date: 26-02-2018
To,
Member Secretary,
Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Gandhinagar.
Regional Officer
Gujarat Pollution Control Board,
Bharuch.
Subject: Comments/Statements regarding the Public Hearing of M/s. Meghmani Finechem Limited, Dahej (Dist – Bharuch).
1) This is a request to include the names of the Functional Area Expert approved by QCI-NABET, area in
which they have worked, the timeline along with their Sign and Stamps with the MOM.
2) The information whether Functional Area Expert of the consultant approved by QCI-NABET are Salaried Employees or not?
3) This is a request to include the copy of agreement letter between consultant and the Empanelled
Functional Area Expert which are approved by QCI-NABET with the MOM.
4) In which other companies are the Functional Area Expert has signed for the Public hearing of EIA
Report?
5) Information regarding payment of fees for the Empanelled Functional Area Expert approved by QCI-NABET.
6) Please provide information regarding the responsibility of Consultant related to Public Hearing and the
Project.
7) Information regarding the payment given by Company to consultant for this Project and request to
include the copy of agreement letter between Company and Consultant with the MOM?
8) Include NABET approved Accreditation Certificate with the signature and stamp of the authorized person with MoM.
9) Include NABET approved Accreditation Certificate with the MOM.
10) Request to include the Xerox copy of Person’s Name, Designation, ID Proof of the company and Government ID Proof who is doing presentation of EIA Report.
11) Kindly include the details of those companies for which the consultant has made the EIA Reports.
(Date: 01.01.2013 to Date: 30.07.2017)
12) If any show cause notice given by Gujarat Pollution Control Board to the other units of the company, kindly include that with the MOM.
13) If any other unit of the company is located outside the Gujarat, and any show cause notice is given by
Gujarat Pollution Control Board to that unit of the company, then include that copy with the MOM.
14) Whether the ToR compliance of ToR given by SEAC is 100% correct
15) This is a request to include the receipt of payments done by consultant to QCI-NABET.
16) According to the rules of the QCI-NABET, in how many EIA Reports does Empanelled Functional Area
Expert taken by consultant can write their names and sign? Include the details.
17) Information regarding how many trees has been planted till date. Details of source of water. If water has been purchased then include the bill of the same in the Minutes of meeting and digital
photographs of trees planted.
18) Whether the ToR compliance of ToR given by SEAC is 100% correct. Provide the details.
19) Whether the ToR compliance of ToR given by SEAC is 100% correct than company should certify in
written.
20) Include the name & address of Land losers with the MOM.
21) After commencement of the company name of the employees should be written outside the gate and request to provide 85% employment to local people.
22) By this project apart from the affected area and employees and workers of company, if other people and employees meet any accident due to company’s activity then it is the responsibility of company. If
such guarantee along with the notary is given then include with the MOM also.
23) If any closer notice given by Gujarat Pollution Control Board to the other units of the company, than how company acquired the revoke? Also attach all the documents submitted to for revoke. Kindly
include that with the MOM
24) Include the copy of documents submitted by Consultant to get the QCI-NABET Certificate with the
MOM.
25) Information of that person’s joining date, month and year who is doing EIA Presentation.
26) What are the responsibility of that person in Public Hearing and the presentation he is doing of EIA Report?
27) Information about how many affected persons are having knowledge of English language.
28) Total household information of the different villages of the affected area.
29) What is the educational qualification of the people of the affected area? Give the information for different villages.
30) By this project, affected area people and employees and workers of company will not be affected by
any accident in the company. If such guarantee along with the notary is given then include with the MOM also.
31) By this project, affected area people and employees and workers of company will not be affected by
any accident in the company. If such guarantee along with the notary is given then include with the
MOM also.
32) By this project, all the employees and workers of the company will not get affected by pollution and sudden hazards and accidents and any other gas leakage, then whether there is any responsibility of
consultant regarding these issues or not? Provide the information.
33) What are the activities you are performing in Corporate Social Responsibility?
34) Whether the drawing of plant has been approved by Industrial Safety department?
35) Whether the company is providing insurance to the affected person due to any sudden accidents?
36) How you are going to train the people of nearby villages regarding the offsite emergency?
37) If the consultant has done any mistakes in making the EIA Report, then whether police case occur or
not?
38) Whether there will any police case occur if the consultant has done mistakes in EIA Report? Then kindly provide the information in written statement under which section case can be done.
39) By this project apart from the affected area and employees and workers of company, if other people and employees meet any accident due to company’s activity then it is the responsibility of company. If
such guarantee along with the notary is given then include with the MOM also.
Request you to reply the letter in Hindi Language
Dharmesh Mistry
Undersigned
SAFETYHEALTH ANDENVIRONMENT ASSOCIATION
208, Vadilo nu Ghar Shopping Complex
Kasak, Bharuch - 392002
E-mail - voqeshpandya55@r'ahoo.com
Contact - (M) +919825032079
Registration No :1) F/61s/Bharuch uirder the Public Trust Act, 1950
2) Guj. /626lBharuch under the Societies Registration Act, 1860
Donation u/s 80.G. of the Income Tax Act. 1961
Date- 01/03/2018The Chairman,Environment Public Hearing Committee, &The District Collector.Bharuch.
Subject- Environment public hearing of M/s Meghmani Finechem Limited,Dahej
Dear Sir,
We most humbly & respectfully submit our Questions/Suggestions. Kindlyregister the same in the minutes of the meeting and oblige.
1- Please give ihe Safety Penorrnance track record of MeghmaniFinechem Limited, Dahej for last 3 years. i.e. how manyaccidenUincident took place? Severity rate, Frequency rate, Accidentanalysis system & remedial measures taken?
2. Which type of occupational disease is possible in such type ofChemical Industry? How many Occupational Diseases reported atMeghmani Finechem Limited, Dahej till the date?
3. How many persons are trained in First Aid in each shift? Facilities ofambulance room with qualified doctor and antidotes available?
4. Has company provided any mobile dispensary and ambulance van fornear by villages?
5. What is the total strength of manpower (including Managerial stafO atpresent? What will be the additional strength after the expansion?Please give us % of local employment.
6. What is the Environment Track Record of - Meghmani FinechemLimited, Dahej? How many times MoEF or DoEF or GPCB issuedthem Show Cause Notice /closer order for non-compliance of theNorms for last three years?
7- ls there any case/legal proceedings are pending for the violation ofenvironment issues at any court of law in lndia
..i. tr" C. B$ARD \BHARUCH \r\,, -
r\s[,t:Ixfrffi l\\'\ a)-,v/
Annexure C-3
SAFETYHEALTH ANDENVIRONMENT ASSOCIATION
208, Vadilo nu Ghar Shopping Complex
Kasak, Bharuch - 392002
E-mail - [email protected]
Contact - (M) +919825032079
Registration No :1) F/615/Bharuch under the Putrlic Trust Act, 19502) Guj. l626lBharuch under the Societies Registration Act, 1860
Donation u/s 80.G. ofthe Income Tax Act. 1961
8. How many onsite emergency plan rehearsal has been done since last2 yearc? And any offsite emergency plan rehearsal carried out in yourpremises in presence of govt. authorities?
9. Looking to the present siie and potential hazard of the company wehereby strongly recommend lo have two ambulance van and one ful!fledge fire fighter with all necessary equipment.
10. The project proponent are requested to highlight the fly ashmanagement i.e. present data of fly ash generation and itsconsumption as well as the proposed generation of fly ash and itssafe disposal-
11. Whether the design of ESP will satisfy all needs after the expansion.
12.What will be the additional generation of CO, CO2, SOX, and NOX inenvironment and the controlling parameters by M/s. MeghmaniFinechem Limited, Dahej.
l3.Looking to the present potential of hazardous materials and after theexpansion of coal based power plant what is the total green belt areaas on the day and what will be the future action along with the budgetin coming years.
14. Dahej is situated at seashore and there are many possibilities ofnatural disasters like cyclone, earthquake etc. we stronglyrecommend the siructural engineering/ construction should be sustainto all such situations.
15. M/s. Meghmani Finechem Limited., Dahej should hightight the CSRactivities which they have carried out in last three years.
Thanking you & with best regards.
For, Safety Health & Environment Association,
yosey'h e.TFbndya
[-
--,-= /-----.-----+ ---_-__:>qf J>, a
Managing
Annexure C4 – (English Translation)
Bhartiya Kisan Sangh,
Vagra Taluka, At & PO: Vahiyal, Taluka Vagra, Dist. Bharuch, Gujarat,
M-9879359151
Date: 03-03-2018
To, Regional Officer
Gujarat Pollution Control Board,
Bharuch.
Subject: Comments/Statements regarding the Public Hearing of M/s. Meghmani Finechem Limited.
1) The Show cause/Closer notice given by GPCB to be taken in to MOM.
2) Safety related all notice to be taken in to MOM.
3) Certificate of Consultant is valid or not?
4) How to get revocation against closer notice vide dated 2/1/17. Put all evidence with inspection
report of GPCB in MOM.
5) The evidence of CSR activities to be put in MOM.
6) How many Land Looser are taken in company and how many pending and their name and address
to be taken in MOM.
7) Describe details of total greenbelt.
Undersigned,
Ajitsinh B Raj,
President,
Bhartiya Kishan Sangh
Annexure C - 5
From: paryavaran mitra <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, March 5, 2018 2:47 PM To: Collector-Bha Cc: Gpcbpublichearing; ms-gpcb; Rashesh R Vyas(GoG-GPCB Dept.) Subject: Suggestions/comments for EPH of M/s MeghmaniFinechem Ltd, GIDCDahej, Ta: Vagra, Dist. Bharuch to be held on 07/03/2018 Ref: PM/MP/EPHC/2018 Date: 03/03/2018 To, Collector &Chairman Bharuch District level Environmental public hearing Committee, Collector Office, Bharuch Sub:Suggestions/comments for Environmental Public Hearing of M/s MeghmaniFinechem Ltd, GIDCDahej, Ta: Vagra, Dist. Bharuch to be held on 07/03/2018 Dear Sir, Our organization is working for strengthening of public-participation since 1997 and is bridge
between people, government and industries in Gujarat as well as in India. We have been
analyzing almost all the EIA reports of the projects of Gujarat and try to lead industrial
development in sustainable manner.
We have studied the draft EIA report of the above-mentioned project, public hearing of which is going to be held on 7th March 2018 under your chairmanship. Under EIA notification 2006, as a plausible stakeholder, we are taking opportunity to send additional observation/comments/questions regarding project and draft EIA report. We have read and reviewed the EIA report prepared by Kadam Environmental Consultant and, on the basis of our analysis, we submit following suggestions: 1. The EIA report has been divided in 13 chapters, of which 8th chapter is important for
thelocally affected people, namely Project Benefits. We find this chapter very vague and needs
to be detailed. Please explain the benefits in more detail to public during the public hearing. In
8.2, it is written that near-by villagers would get benefits of drinking-water, solar energy,
student-support etc. which is appreciable. But, there are many industries in this area so it must
be taken care that there is no duplication of work done under CSR. So, we suggest that a
committee of near-by villagers and surrounding industries should be made under the
chairmanship of Collector and the said works should be done in correspondence to their needs.
2. On page number 55 of EIA report, in table number 2.22, E-waste Rules, 2011 is printed. It
is a mistake. It should be E-waste Rules, 2016.
3. Please justify the need of expansion of Power Plant’s capacity from 65 MW to 132 MW?
Annexure C - 5
4. On page number 53, in 2.11.2, it is written that ETP capacity shall increase to 10%. We
suggest that it should be increased more than 10%.
We appreciation following things in the Draft EIA Report:
1) Earlier Environmental Clearance copies are attached with the report.
2) Compliance reports are also attached.
3) We appreciate that the report has included the showcausenotices by GPCB.
4) We appreciate the style of preparing this EIA. On various pages, they have put actual
photographs of the place. For example, on page 74, photographs of AAQ Sampling Stations at
different villages are included. Interestingly, on page 84, the report has included photographs
of surface water of different ponds. On page 99, they have included photographs of flora at
project site. We highly appreciate these steps.
Yours truly,
Mahesh Pandya
cc: 1. Member Secretary GPCB, Gandhenagar
2. Regional officer, GPCB, Bharuch
ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING-MEGHMANI-MFL-DAHEJ,GUJARAT,ON -070318
COVERING NOTE- URGENT - date 5 March 18
Proponent : Meghmani finechem ltd, Dahej, Gujarat
Accredited consultant : Kadam environmental consultants,Vadodara.
Environment public hearing on 7 March 2018
EIA REPORT SEEMS TO BE INCOMPLTE IN MANY RESPECTS, It
seems that, lot many statutory and other queries being attracted
from EIA report, we wonder, how project will be environmentally
sustainable, and how GPCB has mere misses for such important
queries, and can, environment public hearing be conducted on the
basis of such misleading EIA report.-can such EIA report ensures
setting up an environmentally SUSTAINABLE project in Gujarat.
FROM
Jayeshbhai Shankarbhai Patel,36, Jai Jalaram Society,Tadwadi,
Rander Road,Surat, 395005,Gujarat.
This e mail sent from our own Email- id [email protected],
To,
Cc,
[email protected], [email protected],
[email protected],( SLEAC copy & file no. not available
in EIA 1 OR 2)
[email protected], confirmation on continuity status of all
FAE , during the period Dec 15 to Jan 18, as referred in EIA
1 page 3,4,5, NOT AVAILABLE IN EIA REPORT,
[email protected], -report is incomplete in many statutory &
technical aspects, it is a question, whether this EIA can
ensure setting up of an environmentally sustainable
project, no wonder, as usual , at later date, GPCB only will
issue a closure notice for non conformances of set norms.
misleading EIA reports, leads to issue of closure notices by
GPCB, and at times, issueing of closure orders by NGT as
applicable, leading the core issues of unemployment, and
loss of revenue to Govt, we definitely expect a better
quality of EIA report prepared by an GOVT.approved
environment consultant, hope all environment ministry &
pollution control board responsible staffs do agree to this,
earlier also lot many short falls-mistakes-
misleading/incomplete information both
Annexure C-6
ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING-MEGHMANI-MFL-DAHEJ,GUJARAT,ON -070318
technical/statutory-were reported on EIA reports prepared
by referred consultant, we strongly appeal MoEF-SLEAC-
GPCB-QCI-NABET, consider this as suo moto, to revarify
the quality of all earlier EIA reports of at least last thee
years for a appropriate desired corrective action, so only
environment sustainable projects can be set up in Gujarat.
Public is not supposed to correct and improve EIA
report, prepared by QCI-NABET ACCREDITED
CONSULTANT, whom, proponent must have paid very
high professional fees, but still, we welcome projects in
Gujarat, we have just taken some pain to refer EIA at
random, in past, as we have been observing, lot many
statutory & other queries has reported in EIA prepared by
referred consultant.
Respected sirs,
WE ARE FORWARDING HEREWITH OUR WRITTEN
COMMEMNTS FOR ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING OF
m/s Meghmani Finechem ltd ( MFL), Dahej, DIST. Bharuch,
Gujarat, on 7 March 18,WITH ATTACHMENTS OF DESIRED
EIA 1, 2, PAGES extracted from EIA report, which was
uploaded on public domain-GPCB web site, for public view
all over the globe.
We appreciate corporate level multi functional proponent
and reputed consultant having enrich experience in
preparing EIA report, is honest & he has submitted most of
details in EIA ,1,2, but we failed to understand why core
information and very important supporting documents NOT
PROVIDED, this leads to raising undue queries wasting
time of all concerned with public consultation process.
We are of the opinion, that, it seems that, neither
consultant OR proponent has carried our any pre-review
studies of EIA,1,2, at their end, and just submitted it to
GPCB/SLEAC,
We more wonder, how GPCB/SLEAC has a mere misses
even by their own experts, responsible and highly paid
ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING-MEGHMANI-MFL-DAHEJ,GUJARAT,ON -070318
staff at RO level, UNIT HEAD level, or any other responsible
staff who has examined this EIA report before requesting
Dist. Magistrate-dist. Bharuch, for a suitable date for
environment public hearing, and EIA reports ( certainly
prepared by QCI-NABET ACCREDITED CERTIFICATE holder,
backed by many well qualified approved coordinator and
many FAE – employed and empanelled one ) up loaded on
GPCB web site for public viewing at global level.
We request MS-GPCB to register
our comments and obtain a
satisfactory reply, from proponent,
incorporate the same in MoM with
all desired explanations and
supporting documents, and send
hard copy to our address as
submitted, HOPE, all statutory &
technical reply also should be
acceptable to GPCB-SLEAC as
applicable, before incorporating in
MoM.
COMMENTS
01
QCI-NABET accredited certificate in EIA 2, pages
139,141,do refers sector 4 approval,( with some remark of
cross reference on the basis of which Accredited
certificate was issued) but we failed to understand, what
was the constraint for NOT SUBMITING further very
important supporting document, as desired in 02, 03, just
to be more transparent on referred issue. PL provide due
justification THROUGH HARD COPIES, why following very
ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING-MEGHMANI-MFL-DAHEJ,GUJARAT,ON -070318
important documents were not submitted in EIA.
02
(i)
PL provide, hard copy of NABET, due justification for all
desired FAE approval, details, from DEC 15 to Jan 18, as
submitted in DECLARATION, on EIA 1, pages 3,4,5.
( pl do not ask us to refer to web site )
(ii)
PL FILL UP ATTACHED ANNEXURE A, WITH ALL DESIRED
DETAILS ON CONTINUITY OF NABET APPROVAL OF ALL
FAE, FROM DECEMBER 15 TO JANUARY 18.
03
(i)
Pl provide copy of Letter of QCI/NABET/ENV/ACO/17/0284
dared 22 March 17, as it is not submitted in EIA 2,
(ii)
Ref ToR compliance on EIA 1 page 30, sr no.53,
Compliance on EIA 1 page 202,
(a)
When ToR 53 issued by SLEAC ( refer EIA 1, page 30,
clearly demands, QCI-NABET ACCREDITED CERTIFICATE (
naturally valid one ) ,then pl confirm whether SLEAC has
approved your written request to submit QCI-NABET ‘letter
of accreditation’ , if so, provide a copy of written approval
from SLEAC, and if you do not have it, how you have take it
granted, that this also will be OK at par with accredited
certificate, then what is value addition of ACCREDITED
CERTIFICATE AS DEMANDED IN ToR ?,
Pl provide explanation, If consultant has complied with all
NABET requirements, then why NABET has not issued an
ACCREDITED CERTIFICATE ?
(b)
PL PROVIDE AN EXPLANATION, WHY THERE IS NO COPY
OF QCI-NABET ACCRDITED CERTIFICATE AT EIA 1,
DESIRED PAGE 202, ( ToR 53 COMPLIANCE) IT IS JUST
MISGUIDING ONE AND ToR IS NOT COMPLIED WITH.
(iii)
ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING-MEGHMANI-MFL-DAHEJ,GUJARAT,ON -070318
Has QCI-NABET taken pre approval from MoEF, that at
times, having some constraint, NABET CAN issue a letter
of accreditation, which MoEF-SLEAC has to accept it in lieu
of ACCREDITED CERTIFICATE, as even a simple letter of
accreditation replace the CERTIFICATE CRDIBILITY!!! ( at
least not acceptable to public-as MoEF-SLEAC HAS NOT
SPECIFIED IN THEIR MANDATORY ToR AS AN
ACCEPTANCE OF ANY ALTERNATE-QUICK FIX IN LIEU OF
ACCREDITED CERTIFICATE ) there is no transparency in
EIA, every thing is confusing.
04
As per Declaration, Period of involvement is mentioned as
from December 2015 to January 2018, BUT, date of NABL
certificate is as mentioned as 03/02/16 to 02/02/18,
pl provide explanation why supporting documents not
provided, for period DECEMBER 15 to 02/02/16,
PL PROVIDE HARD COPIES OF DESIRED DETAILS
IMMIDIATELY.
05
Pl provide due explanation why the of NABL scope of ALL
desired analysis,( other than ‘CHEMICAL TESTING) is not
submitted in EIA 3,
PL PROVIDE HARD COPIES OF DESIRED DETAILS
IMMIDIATELY.
06
MoEF documents, as refers in EIA,2 pages 143 to 147,
refers period up to 06.12.17, pl provide explanation, why
copy of further extension OR fresh approval not submitted
from 07.12.17 to January 18, and onwards,
Pl submit hard copies of desired details.
07
Pl also provide hard copies of SCOPE OF ANALYSIS for all
analysis carried out under a coverage of MoEF lab
approval.
08
Pl refer EIA 2 pages 326 to 334, pl provide explanation as
why proponent’s retained QCI-NABET ACCREDITED
CERTIFICATE HOLDER ENVIRONMENT CONSULTANT-
though mandatorily desired- but has failed to submit hard
ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING-MEGHMANI-MFL-DAHEJ,GUJARAT,ON -070318
copies of NABL/ MoEF lab VALID approval documents of
(Supreme, SAAL, EXCELL,) not in EIA report.
Pl submit all desired documents immediately and cover in
minits, failing of which, all such analytical will be
considered as not authentic AND PROPONENT WIL HAVE
TO CARRY OUT ALL SAMPLING AGAIN,
09
ToR 42 GREEN BELT-Ref EIA 1 page 29, sr no. 42,
Compliance in EIA 1 page 180,
As per EIA page 1, page 321 plot area is 5,33,470,
m2/4047=132 acres=1,32,000 trees to be planted, as per
set norms of 1000 tres per acr of total plot area
Present trees , planted 24,000 species ( EIA 1page 180),
Plus, 11,000 will be planted in five years time, ( EIA1 page
182), and for additional green belt, 2500 additional trees
will be planted in five years time, ( ref EIA 1 page 184) so
total trees will be 37,500 trees , will be short by
94500 trees!!!,
EIA does not comply tree density as 1000 trees per acre of
total plot area, if proponent differs, then pl provide a
written directive from MoEF-SLEAC-GPCB, what tree
density norms are given to proponent and when was given.
Why there is no mention on, PLANTING TREES OUT SIDE
OF PREMISES, ToR IS NOT COMPLIED TO THIS EXTENT.
PERHAPS WATER REQUIREMENT FOR GREEN BELT MAY
CHANE SO WATER BALANCE ALSO WIL BE CHAMNGED, PL
UPDATE EIA REPORT ACCORDINGLY AND CONFIRM.
GPCB-SLEAC, should note , within available time span, we
have just refer two important ToR compliance, but both the
compliances are not in order, so proponent has to recheck
his EIA properly for a due compliance of all other ToR, and
UP DATE it in WELL IN order before conducing of
environment public hearing.
10
Ref EIA 1, page 25, pl provide explanation why details on
SLEAC ToR issue date, file no. and copy of SLEAC ToR not
ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING-MEGHMANI-MFL-DAHEJ,GUJARAT,ON -070318
submitted in EIA 1, OR EIA 2,
Pl provide all details and supporting documents, to confirm
ToR details and it’s compliance.
11
In view of looking at PRIMA FAECIA, so many query on
statutory & technical non conformances are attracted from
EIA prepared by QCI-NABET ACCREDITED CONSULTANT, pl
explain, how mandatory declaration as submitted by
proponent and consultant, on EIA 2 pages 149,150, can be
in order?
12
Pl provide hard copy of presentation, which will be shown
In environment public hearing and if any detail is different
than as submitted in executive summary, pl specify it in
hard copy, and why it is different,
PL SUBMIT THE HARD COPIES DESIRED SUPPORTING
DOCUMTS BEFORE THE COMMENTCEMENT OF SCHEDULE
TIME OF ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING, WITH A
REQUEST TO COVER THE SAME IN MINITS AND COPY OF
REPLY TO US TO BE FORWARDED AT OUR ABOVE
MENTIONED ADDRESS THROUGH SUITABLE MENS
PL NOTE, EVEN AT LATER DATE, IF IT IS KNOWN THAT THERE WERE
SOME INCOMPLETE INFORMATIONS-MISLEADING INFORMATIIONS-
NOT FACTUAL INFORMATIONS,IN DRAFT EIA OR IN FINAL EIA,
THEN ISSUED ENVIRONMENT CLEARANCE MAY BE LIKELY TO
CANCELL BY MoEF-SLEAC AS APLICABLE.
PL DO CONTACT US IF YOU NEED ANY MORE DETAILS-
INFORMATION.
WE WELCOME ALL ENVIRONMENTALLY SUSTAINABLE PROJECTS
IN OUR FAST PROGESING ‘GARVI GUJARAT’
Thanks,
Jayeshbhai s patel,
( email sent through our own e mail id-as above)
Enc:
FEW DESIRED PAGES , EXTRACTED FROM EIA REPORTS, ARE
ATTACHED HERE WITH FOR A READY REFERENCE
ANNEXURE A Date 5 March 18
Ref : Consultant- Kadam environmental consultants, Vadodara, Gujarat, proponent- MEGHMANI FINECHEM LTD, DAHEJ,GUJRAT. NABET SECTOR 4 Thermal power Project category B, study period- December 15 to January 18
Referring, to details of accredited certificates & accreditation letter, as submitted in EIA 1, page 5, last para,& in EIA 3, pages, 410,411,412 , no further confirmatory details available on CONTINUITY of NABET APPROVED all FAE, ( except one month lapse as applicable) as referred in DECLARATION in EIA 1 pages 3,4,5 PL. PRIOVIDE CONFIRMATION ON CONTINUITY OF COORDINATOR FOR NABET SECTOR 4 FOR ALL FAE, FOR PERIOD DEC.15 TO JAN. 18 AS PER EIA page 3,4,5 Proponent has to submit details on attached formate at A, and sr no 1-to-12-as , WITH SUPPORTING COPIES OF NABET( NO EB SITE REFERENCE TO BE GIVEN) PL. WRITE IN COLUMN ‘A I EMPANNALLED, OR EMPLOYEE, AS APPLICABLE, AND IN COLUMN II ,III,IV,V,VI & VII as’ YES OR NO’. AS APPLICABLE.- & IT IS A ‘MUST’ to confirm, TO JUSTIFY the authenticity of DECLARATION as submitted by consultant ,head of ACO, EIA 1 page 5, and ‘UNDERTAKING as submitted by proponent at EIA 3 ,page 420.,HOPE, NABET WILL COOPERATE THE ‘PUBLIC’ WITH AN UNBIAS OPINION, NABET CAN ALSO REFER EARLIER EIA REPORTS OF THIS CONSULTANT ON THE BASIS OF SUO-MOTO. In case if details submitted are not in well order, then we leave it up to GPCB- SLEAC-QCI-NABET to work out further line of action, on ascertaining the treliability of consultant & authenticity of entire EIA report, on the base on other statutory query & technical query as reported by us OR as reported by others in this environment public hearing, pl. note, since this is a mandatory issue, for any non conformance, any types of logical reply will not be acceptable
A
SANGRAM coordinator
I
II III
IV
V VI VII
Employee Or Empannelled
DEC 15 FAE YES / NO
JAN 16 FAE YES/ NO
DEC 16 FAE YES. NO
JAN 17 FAE YES/NO
DEC 17 FAE YES/NO
JAN 18 FAE YES/NO
FAE FA 01 JESSICA LU
02 SAMGRAM AP
03 SANGRAM AQ
04 KUNDAN WP
05 KHUMAN EB
06 SOHAM NV
07 ANIL SE
08 NEERAJ HG
09 NEERAJ GEO
10 B.K PATEL, SC -\
11 JITIXA RH
12 SAMEER SHW
Top Related