ANTH2005 SEX, CULTURE AND SOCIETY
2013 PROFESSOR ROBERT THORNTON ANTHROPOLOGY
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
QUESTIONS � What is sex? � Why does it matter? � Is sex ‘biological’? ‘cultural’? ‘social’?
‘historical’? How? � Are people ‘like animals’ when it comes to
sex? � What’s love got to do with it? � What is sex, anyway??? � Really? Serious?
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
WHAT IS SEX AND WHAT DOES IT HAVE TO DO WITH CULTURE AND SOCIETY? � Sex itself is social, political, cultural, and historical � Marriage, family, children, homes and households; � Divorce, ‘broken’ and different kinds of family, ‘unstable
households’ � Violence (domestic violence, sexual violence), jealousy,
protection, aggression, warfare … � Love (often seen as the problem of the relation between
‘love’ and ‘marriage’ and ‘sex’)
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
Sex. You know it when you see it, but… � It is not so easy to define it! � Sex, sexual acts, action or behaviour is
variable � Moral and religious positions on sex are often
absolute but � In reality, everything about sex seems to be
on a continuum with no clear boundaries, and
� Everything depends on context
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
CAUTION
� This course is about � reality, not fantasy � Sexual ethics, but not restricted to
religious morality � What real people actually do, rather
than what some people think people should do
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
SOURCES OF KNOWLEDGE � Media: radio, TV, books, publications � Religious teachings; Bible, Qur’an, Bhagvad
Gita, or other religious texts � Courses such as this; school and other
educational experiences (e.g. initiation) � ‘Culture’, public knowledge, peers, friends,
family, � Actual experience � Anthropology, archaeology, history
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
We ‘already know about it’ � Sex is perhaps one of the most difficult areas
of social science to study because � Most people think they ‘already know’ � Ideologies are deeply ingrained, literally
embodied � Sexual knowledge is validated as moral
knowledge, prescribed by religion, legitimated by legal systems
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
Nevertheless … � Sex, & sexuality are not confined to ‘acts’,
thoughts, practices, institutions, � But pervade and inform most parts of human
life, and � Are more variable and complex than many
other kinds of transactions. � Anthropology and archaeology, rather than
popular culture, are the most important sources of knowledge
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
Categories and continuums � Desire � Identity � Gender � Drive/motivation � Sex acts—a range of choices, some personal,
some cultural
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
The Moche culture in ancient Peru—100 AD to 500 AD—show a different preference Most commonly represented are: Anal sex, Masturbation Fellatio Vaginal penetration is very rarely represented
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
Moche ‘sex pots’
• The anally penetrated woman is most often shown with a baby at the breast.
• Local sexual beliefs equate breast milk with semen
• By anally inseminating the woman, she passes this on to the child, ensuring family unity and continuity
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
Really? Eeuuu. � “It is the violation of this fundamental
opposition that disconcerts us on the Moche pot, where the same woman enacts sex and motherhood simultaneously.” [Marilyn Weismantel, Moche Sex Pots: Reproduction and Temporality in Ancient South America. Am Anthr. 106(3): 495-505]
� The Moche understanding of sex involved a process of feeding or nurturing over a long period, and over generations. Milk and semen are ‘nutrition’ that grow the baby, the woman, the man and lineage or family
Nasty! 15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
The Moche and Peruvian ideology of sex and reproduction � “the focus is on the body s capacity to generate,
store, and transmit life-giving reproductive substances-including semen, menstrual blood, and breast milk, all of which are perceived as transformed versions of a single essence, at once material and spiritual in nature. Exchanges of these nurturant substances, circulated among young bodies and regulated by elders, lie at the heart of reproduction and of social and spiritual life. This process is not limited to specific orifices, members, or actors but in- volves multiple bodily acts.”
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
Journal articles: e.g. Sexualities, October 2011
Kerman Calvo and José Ignacio Pichardo Sexualities transformed? Inside visions of sexual, social and political change in Spain Raquel Osborne Good girls versus bad girls in early Francoist prisons: Sexuality as a great divide Oscar Guasch Social stereotypes and masculine homosexualities: The Spanish case José Ignacio Pichardo We are family (or not): Social and legal recognition of same-sex relationships and lesbian and gay families in Spain Kerman Calvo and Gracia Trujillo
Fighting for love rights: Claims and strategies of the LGBT movement in Spain Fernando Villaamil and María Isabel Jociles
Risk and community: The impact of HIV among gays in Madrid. The case of sex clubs
Raquel Platero The narratives of transgender rights mobilization in Spain Harvey Molotch Book Reviews: Sheila L. Cavanagh. Queering Bathrooms: Gender, Sexuality, and the Hygienic Imagination. 2010. Toronto and Buffalo, CO: University of Toronto Press
Tom Shakespeare Russell Shuttleworth and Teela Sanders (eds). Sex and Disability: Politics, Identity and Access. 2010. Leeds: The Disability Press.
Matt G Mutchler Benjamin Shepard. Queer Political Performance and Protest. 2010. New York: Routledge.
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
Research methodology � Questionnaires, interviews, Internet � Popular surveys (e.g Cosmo, FHM, Condom
manufacturers such as Trojan) � Ethnography, observation � Literature, texts (e.g. Bible, Kama Sutra) � Physiological and medical studies � Theory, philosophy,
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra
And on Islam & sexuality—recent books Afary, Janet. 2009. Sexual Politics in Modern Iran. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Babayan, Kathryn and Afsaneh Najmabadi (eds). 2008. Islamicate Sexualities: Translations across Temporal Geographies of Desire. (Harvard Middle Eastern Monographs) Cambridge MA and London: Harvard University Press. Ilkkaracan, Pinar (ed.). 2008. Deconstructing Sexuality in the Middle East: Challenges and Discourses. Aldershot and Burlington VT: Ashgate.
15/01/12
ANTH2005 SexInstitutions+Hijra