Public Service Commission of West Virginia

17
Post Office Box 3627 Charleston, West Virginia 25336 Telephone (304) 357-0101 Fax (304) 357-0788 www.kanawha.us Henry 6. Shores Commissioner W. Kent Carper Commissioner June 18,2018 Ben Salango Commissioner VLA €€AND DELIVERY Ingrid Ferrell, Director Executive Secretary Division Public Service Commission of West Virginia 201 Brooks Street Charleston, WV Re: General Order No. In the Matter of the Effects on Utilities Of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act Dear Secretary Ferrell: Enclosed please find the original and 12 copies the “Notice of Intent to Participate” and “Certificate of Service” showing service on parties of record. Thank you in advance for your consideration of this request. Please contact me with any questions. Sincerely, ATG:lmk Enclosures as stated cc: As stated on the “Certificate of Service’’ Paul D. Ellis, Esq., City Attorney, City of Charleston

Transcript of Public Service Commission of West Virginia

Post Office Box 3627 Charleston, West Virginia 25336

Telephone (304) 357-0101 Fax (304) 357-0788

www.kanawha.us

Henry 6. Shores Commissioner

W. Kent Carper Commissioner June 18,2018

Ben Salango Commissioner

VLA €€AND DELIVERY Ingrid Ferrell, Director Executive Secretary Division Public Service Commission of West Virginia 201 Brooks Street Charleston, WV

Re: General Order No. In the Matter of the Effects on Utilities Of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act

Dear Secretary Ferrell:

Enclosed please find the original and 12 copies the “Notice of Intent to Participate” and “Certificate of Service” showing service on parties of record.

Thank you in advance for your consideration of this request. Please contact me with any questions.

Sincerely,

ATG:lmk Enclosures as stated cc: As stated on the “Certificate of Service’’

Paul D. Ellis, Esq., City Attorney, City of Charleston

PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION OF WEST VIRGINIA

CHARLESTON

\;?;pa A;& .\h - ~ : = -

GENERAL ORDER N0.236.1 In the Matter of the Effects on Utilities of the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act

: .*- ~ ~ .=. b i - k r . % . = ? < ~ . . . . i k .-:= .-.-- : j I .d ~ -2

NOTICE OF INTENT TO PARTICIPATE

Comes now the Kanawha County Commission (“County Commission”), by counsel, and

the City of Charleston (“Charleston”), by counsel, and respectfully submits this Notice of Intent

t o Participate in the above referenced proceeding. In support of this Notice the County

Commission and Charleston state as follows:

1. On January 3, 2018, the Public Service Commission of West Virginia issued an Order

initiating a General investigation into the effects that the 2017 Federal Tax Cuts and Jobs

Act (“TCJA”) would have on West Virginia privately-owned utilities.

2. On or about May 30th, 2018, several utilities filed Direct Testimony in the above

referenced matter indicating that, in total, the TCJA will result in hundreds of millions in

savings for privately-owned utilities in West Virginia.

3. County Commission is a political subdivision of the state of West Virginia, charged with

the superintendence and administration of the fiscal affairs of Kanawha County. W. Vu.

Const. Art. IX, § 11; W. Vu. Code § 7-1-3. Further, County Commission is a public entity

that represents the residents of Kanawha County, especially the residents of the County’s

large unincorporated areas. Similarly, Charleston is also a public entity that represents

the residents of the City of Charleston and pursuant to WV Code 98-12-5(48), Charleston

has the power to “investigate and inquire into all matters of concern to the municipality

or i t s inhabitants.” Both the County Commission and Charleston consistently strive for

public transparency. In this matter, County Commission and Charleston seek t o further

inform the public concerning the enormous savings that privately-owned utilities will

realize from the TUA.

4. The cost of utility services -- particularly electric, gas, and water -- are a significant matter

of public concern to thousands of individuals, businesses, and commercial utility service

users in both Charleston and Kanawha County. In particular, rising utility rates are a

constant matter of concern to many residents and their families, as the costs of utility

service have risen a t a rate that significantly outpaces increases in wages, salaries, and

social security payments.

5. County Commission and Charleston both strongly believe that the proper course of action

is for the privately-owned utilities to find a fair and reasonable means to return the

enormous savings resulting from the TCJA back t o the ratepayers in the form of reduced

costs of utility service, monthly bill credits, or other rate reductions.

6. For the reasons above, County Commission and Charleston submit this Notice of Intent

to Participate and further intend to file a Response to the Direct Testimony submitted by

the privately-owned utilities.

7. The name and address of the Kanawha County Commission’s attorneys are:

Andrew T. Gunnoe, Deputy County Manager Marc J. Slotnick, County Attorney Kanawha County Commission P.O. Box 3627

’ Charleston WV 25336

8. The name and address of Charleston’s attorneys are:

Paul D. Ellis, Esquire Mandi Kay Carter, Esquire City of Charleston, West Virginia 501 Virginia Street, East Charleston, West Virginia 25301

WHEREFORE, for all the foregoing reasons, the Kanawha County Commission and the City

of Charleston respectfully request that they be permitted to participate in this proceeding as

interested parties thereto.

Deputy County Manager Marc J. Slotnick (WVSB# 5956) County Attorney PO BOX 3627 Charleston, WV

Email:

City Attorney City of Charleston, WV Mandi Kay Carter (WVSB# 10295) Assistant City Attorney of Charleston, WV 501 Virginia Street East Charleston, WV 25301

Email:

PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION OF WEST VIRGINIA

CHARLESTON

General Order No. 236.1 In the Matter of the Effects on Utilities Of the 20 17 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I, Andrew Gunnoe, Attorney for the Kanawha County Commission, do hereby certify that a copy of the “Notice of Intent to Participate” has been served upon counsel of record, this 18fh day of June, 2018, as follows:

Via U.S. Mail Jeff Harvey Allied Waste Services of North America, LLC dba: Mountaineer Transfer Station #2 12th Street Fairmont, WV 26554

Via U.S. Mail Gary Higgs American Disposal Services of West Virginia, Inc. dba: Short Creek Landfill Site Manager

* Division Controller 258 North Fork Road Wheeling, WV 26003

Via Email Mike D’Aurora Brooke County Sanitary Landfill Manager Rt #2 Box 410 Colliers, WV 26035 Email Address: Mike .Daurora@jpmascaro. corn

Via U.S. Mail Gary J. Duffield Gary J. Duffield dba: &a David Kelley Route 1, Box 84D Homer, WV 26372

1

Via Email Michael Magee Senior Financial Analyst, LCS Services, Disposal Service, Inc., Meadowfill Landfill, Inc., Northwestern Landfill, Inc., S & S Grading Landfill 1488 Dawson Drive, Suite 102 Bridgeport, WV 26330 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Jason Takash WV Tire Disposal General Manager PO Box 786 Summersville, WV 2665 1 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Steven H. Ferguson Appalachian Power Company Vice-president Regulatory and Finance PO Box 1986 Charleston, WV 25327 Email Address : shferguson@aep. corn

Via Email John Scalzo Wheeling Power Company PO Box 1986 Charleston, WV 25327 Email Address: APCOPSC @aep. corn

Via Email Mike Ross, President Bazzle Gas Company, Inc. c/o Ross-Wharton Gas Company Rt. 5, Box 29 Buckhannon , WV 26201-9104 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email John Jessee Bluefield Gas Company Vice President 220 W. Valley Street Abingdon, VA 242 10 Email Address: [email protected]

2

Via Email Brien J. Fricke, Esq. Hope Gas, Inc. dba: Dominion Energy West Virginia Senior Counsel 925 White Oaks Boulevard Bridgeport, WV 26330 Email Address: Brien. [email protected]

Via Email Thomas D. Westfall Mountaineer Gas Company Director, Gas Supply and Technical Services PO Box 5201 Charleston, WV 25361 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Lynda W. Petrichevich Peoples Gas WV LLC Vice President, Rates and Regulatory 225 North Shore Drive Pittsburgh, PA 1 52 12 Email Address: [email protected]

1

Via Email John D. Lay President, Tawney Gas Services, Inc. PO Box 1795 Oceana, \Nv 24870-1795 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Paul M. Canterbury Owner, Green Acres Utilities 506 Gardner Loop Princeton, WV 24740 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Linda Hensley, Treasurer Hidden Valley Treatment, Inc. PO Box 4154 Chapmanville, WV 25508 Email Address: [email protected]

3

Via Email Kenneth Toler, President Linmont Sanitation System, Inc. PO Box 133 Barboursville , WV 25504 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Bob Smith, General Manager P & P Enterprises Utilities, LLC c/o Avalon Resort LLC RR 1 Box 315 Paw Paw, W 25434-963 1 Email Address: KathyBavalon-resort.com

Via U.S. Mail Douglas E. Warden SCL, PSD, LLC Member, Warden Ventures, LLC 714 Venture Drive, No. 189 Morgantown, WV 26508

Via Email Joseph Midkiff, President Sewage Systems, Inc. One Esquire Drive Barboursville, WV 25504 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email B. Lee Snyder, President Shenandoah Junction Public Sewer, Inc. 270 Industrial Blvd. Keameysville, WV 25430 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Mr. Carey W. Brincefield, Sr. Springer Run Park, L.L.C. Managing Partner PO Box 337 Ashton, MD 20861 Email Address: [email protected]

4

Via U.S. Mail Nicky Blankenship, Owner The Village at Rock Ridge, Inc. HC Box 505 Pipestem, WV 25979

Via Email Fred Herz Timberline Four Seasons Utilities, Inc. 254 Four Seasons Drive Davis, WV 26260 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email David Vitez, President Vitech Enterprises, Inc. 349 Vitez Drive Morgantown, WV 26508-2541 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Robert Passmore, Esq. West Virginia-American Water Company Corporate Counsel PO Box 1906 Charleston, WV 25327 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Matthew W. Stanley, President & CEO Beckley Water Company PO Box 2400 Beckley, WV 25802-2400 Email Address: lwooten@beckleywater. com

Via Email Russell Roper, Member Cave Road Utilities, LLC 46 Fort Washington Circle Charles Town, WV 25414 Email Address: [email protected]

5

Via Email Ronald E. Marcus, Owner Fox Glen Utilities, Inc. 741 E. Washington Street Charles Town, WV 25414 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Shirley Willard, Treasurer Hampton Roads Water System PO Box 100 Big Sandy, WV 248 16-01 00 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Remy Petrucci, President Sunny View Acres Water Project PO Box 45 Farmington, WV 26571 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Darren Akers, General Manager West Logan Water Company PO Box 810

Email Address: [email protected] Logan, WV 25601-0810

Via Email John L. Munsch, Esq. Counsel, Monongahela Power Company, The Potomac Edison Company, West Virginia Power 800 Cabin Hill Drive Greensburg, PA 15601-1689 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Jacqueline Lake Roberts, Esq. Consumer Advocate Division 700 Union Building 723 Kanawha Boulevard, East Charleston, WV 25301 Email Address: [email protected]

6

Via Email Tom White, Esq. Consumer Advocate Division 700 Union Building 723 Kanawha Boulevard, East Charleston, WV 25301 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Susan J. Riggs, Esq. Counsel, WVEUG Spilman Thomas & Battle PO Box 273 Charleston, WV 25321-0273 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Raymond Casuccio Barrackville Garbage Service, LLC Owner PO Box 1020 Barrackville, WV 26559 Email Address: diana.3 13 1 @hotmail.com

Via Email Belinda Hamilton Bebe Enterprize, Inc. President 41 17 Stewart Street Welch, WV 24801 Email Address: bumblebee5 6@yahoo. com

Via Email Mike Prunesti Beckley Garbage Disposal, Inc. President PO Box 1447 Beckley, WV 25802 Email Address: [email protected]

7

Via Email Melvin Boso Boso Equipment, Inc. President 252 Oakland Gardens Washington, WV 26 18 1 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Carl Cavender, Jr. dba: West Side Garbage Company PO Box 540 St. Albans, WV 25 177 Ernail Address: [email protected]

Via U.S. Mail Sharon Stutler E & L, Inc. Owner 1647 McLane Pike Red House, WV 25168-7573

Via U.S. Mail Valerie DeProspero Enterprise Sanitation, Inc. PO Box 282 Enterprise, WV 26568

Via U.S. Mail Elizabeth Jarrett Greenbrier Valley Solid Waste, Inc. President PO Box 82 Williamsburg, WV 2499 1

Via Email Jon Ferguson Haul Away Trash, LLC PO Box 538 Mineral Wells, WV 261 50 Email Address: [email protected]

8

Via Email Kenneth Jackson dba: Main Sanitation Owner 44 Lady Bug Drive Osage, WV 26543 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Joseph Osborne JEO Enterprises, Inc. President PO Box 510 Iaeger, WV 24844 Email Address: j eoenterprisesinc@ yahoo. com

Via U.S. Mail John A. Gray dba: Loup Creek Trash Co. PO Box 546 Mt Hope, WV 25880

Via Email John Jones dba: Farmington Garbage Disposal PO Box 100 Farmington, WV 26571 Email Address: joy 1 [email protected]. com

Via U.S. Mail Lowell Clark dba: Petroleum Sanitation 54 Clark Lane Cairo, WV 26337

Via Email David Elmore Lusk Disposal Service, Inc. Manager PO Box 3000 Bluefield, WV 2470 1 Email Address: [email protected]

9

Via Email Nancy Michael Mannington Refuse, LLC Organizer PO Box 187 Mannington, WV 26582 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Mark Efaw dba: Rachel Garbage Disposal 51 1 Windy Hill Dr Mannington, WV 26582 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Sheila Spratt Morgan Morgan Sanitation & Recycling Corporation PO Box 99 McGraws, WV 25875 Email Address: [email protected]

Via U.S. Mail Geraldine Mullins Mullins Garbage Co. PO Box 297 Jolo, WV 24850

Via Email Don Brown NC Sanitation, Lnc. President PO Box 501 New Manchester, W 26056 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Ronnie White Rural Garbage and Refuse, Inc. Vice President PO Box 5 Mullins, WV 25882 Email Address: cbs. tmcgraw@ yahoo. com

10

Via U.S. Mail Randall Taylor Taylor's Disposal, Inc. President 15 19 Dutch Ridge Road Parkersburg, WV 26 104

Via Email Tim Stout Thomas Solid Waste Collection, LLC Owner PO Box 36 Rachel, WV 26587-0036 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Bobby Mann Union Disposal Service, LLC PO Box 151 Union, WV 24983 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Michael Magee Waste Management of West Virginia, Inc. dba: (Martinsburg Location) 1488 Dawson Drive, Suite 102 Bridgeport, WV 26330 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email William Hood, Jr. Waste Transporters, Inc. President PO Box 267 Westernport, MD 2 1562 Email Address: [email protected]

Via U.S. Mail Brian Howell Western Maryland Waste Systems, LLC PO Box 2421 Cumberland, MD 2 1503

Via Email Barry A. Naum, Esq. Counsel, W E U G Spilman Thomas & Battle, PLLC 1 100 Bent Creek Boulevard, Suite 101 Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Derrick P. Williamson, Esq. Counsel, W E U G Spilman Thomas & Battle, PLLC 1 100 Bent Creek Blvd., Suite 101 Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Jason C. Pizatella, Esq. Counsel, WVEUG Spilman Thomas & Battle, PLLC PO Box 273 Charleston, w7r 25321-0273 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Nicklaus A. Presley, Esq. Counsel, Fly-By-Nite Disposal Service, Inc., Bluefield Gas Company, MGC, WVAWC JacksonKelly, PLLC PO Box 553 Charleston, W 25322 Email Address: napresley@j acksonkelly . corn

Via Email James V. Kelsh, Esq. Counsel, Jochum Motor Carriers, N&N Disposal, Inc. and Tygarts Valley Sanitation, Inc. BowlesRice LLP PO Box 1386 Charleston, W 25325-1386 Email Address: [email protected]

Via Email Samuel F. Hanna, Esq. Counsel, Hizer Trucking, Inc. and Republic Services of West Virginia PO Box 2311 Charleston, WV 25328-23 11 Email Address: [email protected]

12

Via Email Christopher L. Callas, Esq. Counsel, Mon Power and Potomac Edison JacksonKelly PLLC PO Box 553 Charleston, WV 25322 Email Address: [email protected]

13