POOR 2 PROGRESSIVE- - SIDBI
-
Upload
khangminh22 -
Category
Documents
-
view
1 -
download
0
Transcript of POOR 2 PROGRESSIVE- - SIDBI
ABOUT THIS KNOWLEDGE PRODUCT
We are happy to present this document to you as a Knowledge Product that captures successes, strategies
and approaches adopted during the implementation of Poorest States Inclusive Growth (PSIG)
programme. PSIG programme was supported by UKAid through the Department for International
Development (DFID) and implemented by Small Industries Development Bank of India (SIDBI). It aimed
to enhance income and employment opportunities for poor women and men by enabling them to
participate and benefit from wider economic growth in India. The programme targeted improving access
for poor women and men to a variety of financial services in four low income states namely Bihar,
Madhya Pradesh, Odisha and Uttar Pradesh.
The programme, in its 8 years of implementation made significant strides in increasing the financial
institutions’ ability to reach difficult geographies and excluded groups including women. It made a
substantive contribution in improving access to credit for poor households and capacity building of
women on financial literacy and gender issues.
The programme throughout its period of implementation attempted to adopt a comprehensive approach
to strengthen the financial inclusion ecosystem both on the demand and the supply side. It is important
that you are able to see the efficacy of these approaches including from the eyes of multiple stakeholders.
These stakeholders include first and foremost the communities PSIG program worked with, as also
different partners that helped us reach those communities. We also present key lessons we learnt both
from our independent evaluations and continuous rigorous reviews by DFID.
While we may not have been successful at every approach we adopted but we did draw important lessons
from some of these not so successful attempts. These learnings transformed our strategies to fulfill the
needs of the sector in subsequent engagements.
A constructive approach of working in collaboration with private sector and Government stakeholders
was the hallmark of our approach to sustain and institutionalize the positive impacts of the programme
The diversity and scale of programming under the PSIG umbrella was unique and one of its kind in the
sector. We hope that this document is of value to policy makers, development practitioners, donors and
implementers alike on the issue of looking at social and economic inclusion of the last mile.
SIDBI Vision 2.0 of inclusive, innovative & impact oriented engagements gave new dimensions to our
strategies. We could evolve end to end solutions transitioning from Fin Lit to Credit & Market Connect
for aspirant Bharat.
We hope that through PSIG we were able to contribute our two cents to the UN SDGs mandate to
“LEAVE NO ONE BEHIND!”
Background & Objective
SIDBI implemented Poorest State Inclusive Growth
(PSIG) Programme funded by UK Govt. through
Department for International Development (DFID), UK.
The programme aimed to ensure poor and vulnerable
people in low income states (especially women) benefit
from economic growth through better access to financial
services. This project aimed to reach 12 million poor
households with financial services and support 5 million
women clients to testify improvements in social status and
mobility.
PSIG Focus Areas
PSIG program has created a strong legacy in all the
three areas of its work viz., Policy Advocacy,
Access to Finance and Financial Literacy & Women
Empowerment
(i) Policy Advocacy - PSIG’s advocacy initiatives
combined with direct support to MFIs (funding and
capacity building) have contributed to stabilization
and expansion of the sector in the PSIG States and
to the emergence of Small Finance Banks (SFBs).
PSIG has created strong State Microfinance
Associations and helped in strengthening
Responsible Finance in the sector. There has been
substantial growth in the outreach of PSIG-
supported partner Financial Institutions (PFIs) –
MFIs and SFBs – from 3.8 million borrowers at
baseline to 9.7 million borrowers at endline in the
four PSIG states. This translates to a compound
annual growth rate of 26.3% which is significantly
higher than the 10-15% growth of outreach in the
microfinance sector nationwide.
Overall, the program reached out to 13.27 million
beneficiaries in the four poorest states.
(ii) Access to Finance - PSIG has deepened access to
finance in all the four states, by helping MFIs with
branch expansion in unserved and underserved
areas, strengthening digitization of operations and
institutionalizing focus on poorest of the poor by
using tools such as PPI. PSIG has helped 12 MFI
partners transition into next scale category and has
reached 5 million people with other financial
services such as savings, pension, payments &
insurance.
(iii) Financial Literacy and Women Empowerment
(FLWE) - PSIG has successfully catalyzed systemic
change that is significant in scale and sustainable
beyond the timeframe of the program. More than
10 partners have institutionalized FLWE approach in
their operations and 22 institutions have started to
integrate a gender lens in their policies & products.
Two of the largest livelihood missions of the Govt.
have scaled-up PSIG demonstrated approaches of
FLWE and deepening alternate banking services
through Bank Sakhis. PSIG’s microenterprise
development program for women has demonstrated
the viability of scaling-up businesses of more than
9000 “barefoot” entrepreneurs who often lack access
to technical support and capital to expand and
formalize.
PSIG programme was implemented in the 4 states of
UP, MP, Bihar and Odisha. The programme duration
was 6 years starting from April 2012-March 2018,
which was further extended for 2 years till March
2020.
2012-13
PSIG Program
Launch
2013-14
CB Support to
MFIs (1st phase)
Policy Advocacy
for Differentiated
Banking
100 cr Liquidity
Fund set up
2014-15
CB Support to
MFIs (2nd Phase)
Technology
Advisory Board
Studies on Poverty
Outreach, BC model
& Governance
Pilots on Financial
Literacy & Women
Empowerment in
4 states
2015-16
65 cr Debt Fund set up
FIWE Challenge Funds
launched
Programs with RRBs,
SHPIs and BC model
related interventions
PSIG works with partners
for institutional gender
mainstreaming
On lending support to
Wholesale lenders to
lend to small MFIs
2016-17
Handholding to small MFIs
SCI-FI launched for
Fin- tech Incubation
Partnerships with Government March 2020
Livelihood Missions
Setting up of Regional MFI
industry Associations
Support to the sector to
deal with Demonetization
Demonstrable Models to
Work with Ultra Poor
4 PSIG partners
transitioned from
MFIs to SFBs
PSIG moves from
Financial Literacy to
Financial Linkages
& tech based models
of delivering FLWE
PSIG moves from
capacity building
of MFIs to building
capacity for
Enterprise promotion
development, market
& Credit Connect
PSIG partners reach out
to 13.27 million people
in 4 poorest states
Endline shows significant
gains from the program in
terms of Women
Empowerment &
improvement in access
to microfinance for low
income HHs
2017-19
Programs to support women
enterprises’ credit & market
connect Integration with
SIDBI’s Swavalamban Mission
for entrepreneurship promotion
Support to SIDBI National
Microfinance Congress as first
govt. led platform for sector
related policy dialogue
KEY ACHIEVEMENTS AT A GLANCE: POOR 2 PROGRESSIVE STATES
POLICY ADVOCACY ACCESS TO FINANCE FINANCIAL LITERACY & WOMEN’S EMPOWERMENT
PSIG INDEPENDENT ENDLINE FINDING
2 microfinance associations in UP & Odisha set up by PSIG helped strengthen responsible finance & manage fallout of policy shocks like demonetization & loan waivers
Regular Policy dialogues, policy papers (8), policy level flyers (13) and studies (16) highlighted elements that policy makers needed to address
SCI – FI Fintech incubator set up, promoting innovation in financial products
Supported creation of India’s first Self- regulatory institution for Business Correspondents - (BCFI)
Support to the BCs led to deepening and widening of BC model in the PSIG States
Promoting product diversification through loans for solar products, water & sanitation. 5732 solar energy loans and more than 600 water & sanitation loans given to the women entrepreneurs
Built capacities of 51 Microfinance Institutions in India
Our supported partners/MFIs have reached out to 8.28 million clients (mostly women) with credit services & 5 million people with other financial services
12 MFI partners have increased operations into the next scale category within PSIG States & additional 10 MFIs have expanded entry into PSIG States
Supported graduation of 4000 ultra-poor out of extreme poverty through establishment of micro enterprises
Built financial capability of 6 lakh women
Scalable models created in partnership with Govt. Livelihood Missions ready for replication by others ---E.g. Partnership with Government Livelihood Missions JEEViKA (Bihar‘s SRLM) to help 500 SHG members become financially sustainable banking correspondents. The model has been scaled up by JEEViKA from 4 to 25 districts in Bihar
Supported establishment of more than 9000 women led microenterprises though Business Skills & Financial Literacy trainings, handholding, credit and market connect
Evaluation points towards significant improvement in women’s agency in PSIG geographies and reduction in domestic violence
Small but significant reduction in poverty rates by 9 percentage points for the rural areas and by 13 percentage points for the urban areas on the Poverty Probability Index (PPI)
The benefit-cost ratio (BCR) of 11 indicates that for every rupee spent, benefits were accrued to the tune of 11 times which suggests a very high level of efficiency for the PSIG program
There was a statistically significant increase (from 38.0 to 47.1) in Financial Inclusion Index (FII) and a reduction in the rural/urban and SC ST/ other social groups’ gap. Overall 68% of households showed increase in their FII score (70% of the rural sample, 65% of the urban)
S DEMAND
PSIG SUPPORT TO STRENGTHEN THE FINANCIAL INCLUSION ECOSYSTEM
POLICY ADVOCACY
CAPACITY BUILDING OF MICROFINANCE
LENDERS
FINANCIAL LITERACY & WOMEN EM- POWERMENT APPROACH
INSTITUTIONALIZED
TECHNOLOGY ADVISORY BOARD TO
SUPPORT MFIs PROMOTING WOMEN ENTERPRISES & THEIR
CREDIT & MARKET CONNECT
STRENGTHENING SUPPLY SIDE
STRENGTHENING DEMAND SIDE
DEBT FUND, RISK FUND & LIQUIDITY
FUND
CHALLENGE FUND PROJECTS TO TEST INNOVATIVE MODELS AND SUPPORT TO SHPIS LIKE AGA KHAN, CHAITANYA & SEWA HANDHOLDING
SUPPORT TO SMALL MFIs
STRENGTHENING CAPACITY OF STATE
LIVELIHOOD MISSIONS SETTING UP OF STATE
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATIONS & SCI-FI FINTECH INCUBATOR
RESEARCH MONITORING &
EVALUATION
N
L
SU
`
Bank Sakhi Munni Kumari doing transactions in Samastipur
TECHNICAL SUPPORT FOR DEEPER PENETRATION OF ALTERNATE BANKING SERVICES IN BIHAR
Bihar Rural Livelihoods Promotion Society (BRLPS/ SRLM-
Bihar), referred to as JEEViKA, started its Alternate Banking &
Digital Financial Services initiative in 2016 to enable access to
doorstep banking for rural women by developing a network of
women community agents/ Banking Correspondents (BCs)
known as Bank Sakhis. JEEViKA and SIDBI’s PSIG program
came together for a partnership in early 2017 to promote deeper
penetration of alternate banking services and digital financial
inclusion of JEEViKA SHGs.
The program approach was not just to increase access to
financial services through Jeevika Bank Sakhis or Banking
Correspondents but also to establish strong systems and
processes within Jeevika, which can ensure that Bank Sakhis
become profitable. While several operational parameters,
such as the number of agents, transactions per agent,
commissions etc., are tracked to make the programme
successful the key success metrics include the number and
amount of transactions at the bank level and a sustainable and
consistent income accrued at the agent level to make it a viable
livelihood option.
Program Approach & Methodology
1. Detailed agent selection process- SHG members, being
more financially experienced, are preferred as banking
agents. It helps them in establishing better rapport with the
staff of financial service providers as well as women SHG
members.
2. Agent Training- JEEViKA provides high quality
induction and refresher training to its Bank Sakhis. Bank
Sakhis are provided three-day residential training which covers
basics of banking, products and services knowledge and agent’s
roles and responsibilities. During the agent training special
emphasis is placed on anti- money laundering aspects, risk
management such as identification of fake currency, security of
cash in vault
and dos and don’ts of customer service to be followed by
banking agent. Bank Sakhis are trained on these critical aspects
through various live examples and role plays. Apart from the
residential training JEEViKA’s block office also provides
regular hand-holding support to Bank Sakhis to ensure there are
no incidents of frauds or service denials to the customers.
3. Financial Support- JEEViKA provides establishment
support in the form of grant and an interest-free loan for the
purchase of equipment such as laptop and micro ATM from their
community-based organizations. It also provides financial
support to Bank Sakhis for the first 6 months. Bank Sakhis are
also able to get working capital loan for liquidity management
from their community- based organizations. The financial
support from JEEViKA has helped Bank Sakhis to overcome
familial financial hurdles and expand their business operations.
4. Capacity Building Support- Bank Sakhis are provided
training on various aspects of agency business such as products
and services, customer service, marketing, risk management and
basics of banking in India. Apart from this, Bank Sakhis are
provided regular capacity building support by JEEViKA’s block
office staff to help them better serve their customers.
5. Marketing Support – JEEViKA has launched training
program for its community members to bring awareness of the
products and services and benefits of transacting with banking
agents. The block office team of JEEViKA also supports Bank
Sakhis in routing financial transactions between SHGs and
Community Based Organizations (CBOs) through them. These
financial transactions can provide Bank Sakhis a regular volume of
transactions and help them in overcoming some of their liquidity
management constraints. The brand of JEEViKA also creates
trust amongst customers especially for the first-time female
customers.
6. Monitoring of Agents- JEEViKA’s team conducts regular
monitoring of the performance of their Bank Sakhis. Also,
with continuous performance tracking
done through MIS and subsequent data analytics and dashboard
compilation. This way, JEEViKA is able to provide the required support
to non-performing Bank Sakhis. It has also helped in keeping the number
of dormant/inactive Bank Sakhis to less than 5% which is much less than the
general attrition level in the sector.
Ethical Customer Service & Empowerment
Incidents of frauds through BCs are very common in rural areas and they erode
trust over banking agent channel and build a perception that money is not
safe in bank account. Going to bank branch for transactions is an
inconvenient and costly option for most women and men in rural areas
resulting into their financial exclusion.
Common Frauds Committed by Agents
• Use of customer biometrics to open their bank accounts without their
knowledge
• Use of customer biometrics to conduct withdrawal transactions or higher
withdrawal amount without their knowledge
• Remote transactions - Not conducting deposit/fund transfer transactions
in the customers’ presence
• Imposition of unauthorized charges
• Un-authorized access to customers’ pin number for ATM cards
To preserve trust of its community members in the agency banking, JEEViKA
has put in place simple and speedy grievance redressal mechanism, risk
management structures, fraud prevention systems and is constantly working
towards improving financial capability of its community members. Exhibit 1
lists down JEEViKA’s initiatives to achieve customer empowerment and
ethical approach to customer service
Exhibit 1: Key initiatives of JEEViKA under this program to create safe banking
environment
Inclusion through Bank Sakhis
Bank Sakhis have been able to facilitate better social inclusion by
motivating first-time women customers who are usually illiterate,
semi-literate or still in their teens and yet to earn any income of their
own.
Data from one of the partner banks shows that around 74% of the
accounts opened by the Bank Sakhis are of women. They are also
providing doorstep banking to the neediest and otherwise excluded
segment in the community such as the elderly and the disabled for
account opening and distribution of DBT payments. Currently, around
2 million people in rural areas of Bihar are being covered by
JEEViKA Bank Sakhis placed through this program.
Bank Sakhis playing critical role in digitizing SHG transactions Bank
Sakhis are also supporting digitization of financial transactions
between SHGs and CBOs by visiting the SHG meetings to conduct
financial transactions for the members. This has reduced the cash-
carrying risk for SHG members and improved timely repayment of
loan in addition to creating a digital trail for SHG members.
As on December 2019, more than 552 Bank Sakhis are operational in
25 districts of Bihar with cumulative value of transactions more
thanRs.1000 crore done by these Bank Sakhis across a range of
services such as savings, deposits, withdrawals and remittances.
Employing SHG members as banking agents has benefitted the
community and at the same time provided gainful employment to many
of them for the first time. The SIDBI Jeevika partnership has helped them
become more respected in their family and community. They are able
to earn the epithet of ‘Banker Didi’ for themselves. Once begun, these
SHG members are more likely to continue with the bank agency
business as they are less likely to migrate for lucrative employment
opportunities.
As on March 2019, in India, on an average 1 BC outlet serves around
1,225 people whereas in Bihar, on an average, 1 BC outlet serves
around 5,710people. Bihar needs additional 66,000 BC outlets to be
on par with the national average density of BC outlets. These
additional 66,000 BC outlets have a huge potential to generate livelihood
opportunities especially for women.
PSIG’S PILOT OF TARGETING ULTRA POOR
Brief about the Program Targeting the Hard-core Poor (THP) program
model is a well-tested model aimed at
improving the socio-economic condition of the
poorest-of-the-poor and socially disadvantaged
women through sustainable livelihood
opportunities. Bandhan Konnagar
implemented the THP program in Satna
district of Madhya Pradesh since 2017 with
support from SIDBI’s PSIG Programme.
The THP program was in line with
PSIG’s mission to enhance economic
opportunities and empowerment of the rural
poor and targeted women headed households
in rural and slum locations with minimum or
no sources of income. Over the period of two
years, selected ultra-poor1 women beneficiaries
received a sequence of supports, including an
asset grant (livestock or goods for initiating
small enterprise), entrepreneurship training,
1 As per C Rangarajan Committee, ultra-poor are classified as those with per
capita income below Rs 32 per head/day.
temporary consumption support, weekly
personal mentoring, awareness on social issues,
health and sanitation and aspects of financial
education such as savings and maintenance of
accounts.
The support from SIDBI PSIG was crucial to
carry out this evidence based model in the Satna
district of Madhya Pradesh. This was done by
identifying such 1,000 poorest and deprived
households in blocks of Satna, Unchehara,
Maihar and Rampur and moving them out of
extreme poverty and destitution towards
sustainable livelihood and social mainstreaming.
Approach & Methodology The THP model targeted a specific population
type with an aim to create significant and
sustained positive impact by providing various
income generating assets and enterprise
training. The process map and implementation
model is represented below:
THP Model
Beneficiary Life Cycle
Impact The target of the THP program was to achieve at least
INR 4,000 per month income for its beneficiaries through
introduction of enterprises such as kirana stores, readymade
garments, livestock rearing, tailoring, garment selling etc.
93% of the respondents achieved this target by utilizing the
primary income generating assets given to them under the
program. The remaining 7% have also achieved this target
by income accrued from secondary and tertiary income
generating avenues.
The average annual gross income of the beneficiaries was
found to be INR 2,30,069. This is a significant increase of
INR 2,18,034 from their baseline average annual gross
income of INR 12,035.
The average annual net income of the beneficiaries was INR
85,861as average annual input cost of the enterprise was
calculated at INR 1,44,208.
The beneficiaries also reported an average annual saving of
INR 15,230.
The per month average gross income of the beneficiaries was
found to be INR 19,172and average net income was
calculated at INR 7,155against a target of INR 4,000.
The average cost of enterprise per month was found to be
INR 12,017and the beneficiaries reported an average per
month saving of INR 1,269.
95% beneficiary household had an individual household
latrine (IHHL).
Improved awareness of relevant government schemes and
policies for women, with many beneficiaries getting benefits
from schemes like PM Awas Yojana (80% renovated their
houses either through their own scheme), PM Suraksha Bima
Yojana (100%), Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana, PM Jeevan
Jyoti Bima Yojana (37%) and PM Ujjwala Yojana.
Increased awareness, entrepreneurship traits and resulting
financial independence.
`
GENDER MAINSTREAMING IN MICROFINANCE
PSIGs Program with
Microfinance Partners
About the Intervention As the microfinance sector predominantly works
with women, it is usually assumed that there is
little need for gender mainstreaming in the
sector. However, it is crucial to examine if
microfinance promotes gender equality
especially empowerment of women in its true
sense. PSIG implemented a project to
understand the level of institutional gender
integration within its 26 partner institutions,
build institutional capacity on gender
mainstreaming in policies, products and
people. The project has helped gain critical
insights into how successful microfinance has
been in empowering women, whether and
how gender bias operates within the sector
and how power relations within and beyond
the household shape the context and outcomes
of microfinance initiatives.
Approach
This project therefore began with the premise that,
having a gender perspective will enable MFIs to be
more inclusive and responsive to the needs of
women clients, whose lives are impacted by
unequal and discriminatory gender relations, roles
and responsibilities.
Project started with assessing institutional gender
gaps in terms of policies, products & people. A
gender integration report was compiled
highlighting gaps & good practices in terms of
institutional gender integration. After assessing the
gender gaps, the project worked with partners on
enhancing partner’s capacities on gender
mainstreaming.
The project also developed tools like “Engendering
Microfinance – A Capacity Building Toolkit for
Microfinance Institutions”, “the Gender Integration
Index” that serves as a detailed evaluation as well
as rating tool for institutional gender integration. A
simpler and do-it-yourself monitoring or self-
assessment tool has also been developed for use by
MFIs— titled the ‘Gender Equity Quotient’.
Some of the interesting findings from the
project indicate to the exclusion of single
women and women with difficult circumstances in
the priority client group, monitoring and
evaluation of performance is mostly limited to
financial performance with little attention to
social performance. Gender ratio in most MFIs
decline at the top and bottom with most women
concentrated at office and middle level positions.
In terms of loan products most organizations do
not consider women’s rights over family assets
I MPAC T
IMPAC T
Policy
21 out of 26 Partner Institutions (PIs) included
Gender Objectives in their Vision, Mission
and Human Resource Policy
Project team jointly developed revised
Vision and Mission statement for 14 PIs
21 PIs integrated gender indicators in to their
complaint redressal mechanism
Product
PIs have introduced more products for
different genders like product for unmarried
girls, transgenders, products to purchase land
and house by women
Several PIs have agreed to introduce loan
products with condition of women’s name
in house / land ownership title after 2nd or 3rd
loan cycle
as legitimate. In fact, some practices like
requirement of NOC from male member of the
family strengthen patriarchal controls. The
project also documented good practices in
some partner institutions like flexi timings,
special hostel facilities for women staff,
insurance cover for women and her spouse, all
women branches, loan products for drudgery
reduction like smokeless chulha, other clean
energy products and recognizing female family
members as “guarantors”.
Practice
5 out of 26 PIs have inducted women
for inclusion at the Board level and senior
level management
All PIs are involved in non-financial
programs such as financial literacy. During
the project many of them have started
including men in financial literacy classes,
to ensure support of men for the women
borrowers
This work helps in building a strong, stable and
gender sensitive microfinance sector which is
crucial for enabling access to finance for
millions of poor households in the country. It
also builds an understanding among key
stakeholders that gender inequality cannot be
simply eliminated by recruiting more women, it
requires targeted efforts across all levels of the
organization and developing a critical mass of
support for furthering inclusion through
organizational culture and its work.
The Microfinance sector is increasingly
recognizing that a gendered approach to design
and delivery of financial services will help them
better serve different client segments and tap the
untapped opportunity of bringing many more
unbanked clients into the folds of formal
financial services.
FINANCIAL LITERACY TO ENTREPRENEURSHIP PROMOTION AND CREDIT CONNECT
Approach & Methodology
The program has directly improved financial
capabilities of more than 6 lakh women in
these 4 states. The program provided 30
hours of intensive training to each client. In
addition to client level trainings, deploying
various interesting modes of training, the
program also organized 404 Mass Awareness
Camps (MACs) creating awareness of 1.19 lakh
community members in the 4 states.
About the Intervention
PSIG has pioneered an integrated
approach to financial literacy wherein
financial literacy trainings are integrated
with social and gender issues, rights
and entitlements. The program has
implemented demonstration models with
implementing agencies for strengthening
financial capability of poor women;
PSIG went beyond financial literacy to
financial linkages for clients. Partners
included MFIs, SHPIs and collaboration
and convergence with public institutions
like the State Rural Livelihood Missions
(SRLMs) for promoting equitable access
to financial services. Further PSIG has
tested and implemented innovative
technology-based approaches for
financial & digital literacy and women
empowerment. PSIG has implemented
targeted Financial Literacy & Women
Empowerment (FLWE) programs in Bihar,
MP, Odisha and UP.
FLWE Program with Microfinance Institutions
Methodology Outreach Cost
18 implementing MFI partners 6 lakh women trained 20% cost shared by partners
ToT approach
Mass Awareness Camps Mobile Phone based IVR Platform for Financial Literacy
A cadre of 522 master trainers created 80% cost borne by PSIG
Gender integrated FL modules 8 Films in Hindi/Odiya
63,508 financial linkages Per client cost was Rs 318/-
15-30 hrs. of client training 108 community women leaders trained
Smart phone enabled MIS
Baseline & end-line evaluation
FLEP Program with SHPIs
PSIG worked with three large SHPI’s in UP,
Bihar and MP to enhance financial
literacy, access to financial services,
better use of technology and book
keeping for SHG members.
FLWE programs in the SHG space
strengthened financial capability, book
keeping and credit linkage for SHG groups
in all 4 states. The program has trained 7.2
lakh SHG members on basic financial
literacy, book keeping, audit of SHGs and
credit linked more than 2,500 SHGs.
Methodology Outreach
3 large SHPI Promoting Institutions 7.2 lakh SHG members
TOT Approach with Credit plus services 18,000 financial linkages
Collaborations with State Govt.
for Financial Literacy
Odisha Livelihood Mission
PSIG worked in partnership with Odisha
Livelihood Mission (OLM) for Training and
Strengthening Capacities of their Financial
Literacy - Community Resource Persons
(FL-CRPs). The project has trained a cadre
of 50 Master Trainers and 300 FL-CRPs for
the OLM in 10 blocks of 10 districts who in
Bihar Livelihood Mission – JEEViKA
PSIG partnered with JEEViKA (which is
Bihar Govt. Rural Livelihood Mission
working with 8 million Rural families) in
Sept 2017 to provide them technical
assistance for deeper penetration of
alternate banking and digital financial
services in Bihar. The project trained SHG
members as Bank Sakhis, streamlined
JEEViKA’s processes for identifying,
training and on-boarding Bank Sakhis,
supported to build an MIS system and app
for monitoring Bank Sakhis’ financial
performance and transactions and also
build capacity of the demand side through
Digital Financial Literacy to 60,000 SHG
members.
Impact
Independent endline evaluations show
substantial improvements in women’s lives
in terms of better financial planning, higher
awareness of their rights & entitlements,
savings, increased mobility & better access
to sanitation. The involvement of clients in
the decision-making process, in both the
project and the control areas, witnessed
an overall positive change during endline.
turn built financial capabilities of 86,000 SHG
members.
Key achievements
• OLM has now up-scaled the program to
1000 additional Gram Panchayats (GPs) in
the State of Odisha by positioning the
trained FL-CRPs and Master Trainers and
setting up Gram Panchayat level Aarthik
Saksharta Kendras.
• Odiya Modules developed under the
programme being used across the State by
OLM.
The project area witnessed 84% of the
clients participating in the decision to take
up a job, while 87% of the clients
participated in the decision-making
regarding children’s education. 90% of the
women in the project group practiced
household budgeting during endline against
17% at baseline. Household budgeting
witnessed a significant differential increase of
50%. Awareness level of insurance and
pension increased from 41% to 93% and from
24% to 94% respectively. There was a
significant differential increase of 18% from
baseline to endline in the access to toilet
with water. Overall, the degree of mobility of
women showed a statistically significant
(p<0.05), positive shift in the endline, as
compared to the baseline.
At the institutional level, FLWE program has
created a successful business case for
financial institutions to invest in building
financial capability of poor women. The
integrated approach of empowering women
along with building their financial capability
has been adopted by partners. The training
content created by FLWE program (both
films & training modules) are being used
widely by more than 10 institutions.
Methodology Outreach
TOT & FLWE Films
Odisha Livelihood Mission
• 86000 SHG members
• Cadre of 50 Master Trainers trained
• 300 FL-CRPs
TOT & FLWE Films
Bihar Rural Livelihood Mission – JEEViKA
• 60,000 SHG members trained on Digital Financial Literacy
• Cadre of 200 FL-CRPs Trained for JEEViKA
MUSP (Mahila Udyami
Sashaktikaran Program)
Project Objective: Women
entrepreneurs establish/scale-
up/diversify their micro enterprises
with reported increased income and
employment of the household over
baseline.
Period and location of the Project:
August 2018–October 2019 / Varanasi
& Ghazipur
Impact:
• 16,000 women entrepreneurs
screened using Screening Tool
prepared for MUSP program
• 15,500 women trained in 12 hrs. of
Grass- roots Management Training
(GMT) including concepts like
enterprise selection, planning, value
addition, income & cash flow, break
even, profits, pricing and costing etc.
• 9,832 credit linked through different
channels and Prayas scheme of SIDBI
• 10,673 business plans prepared, 7000+ of
them were tracked monthly. All women
being provided handholding services to
upscale, diversify and set up their
enterprises.
• 6300 women provided market linkages.
• 7 key trades identified and value chain
analysis completed for these trades
• 25 buyer seller meets organized for women
entrepreneurs for market linkages
• Client feedback sought via direct
messages, 7400 messages received from
clients with 97.0% positive feedback for
the program
• IVR platform launched to strengthen
feedback and peer exchange
• Convergence with skill training institutes
for women who need advanced skills
• 9661 micro-enterprises grounded.
THEMATIC AREA
KEY ENGAG E ME N T S & O U T R E A CH
Capacity Building support to
5 MFIs (CDOT, Arohan,
Jagran, Saija and Sahyog)
which impacted more than
21 lakh beneficiaries
CB support to Sewa Bharat
which impacted 20,000
women and their families
Capacity Building support to
Regional Rural Banks (RRBs)
which impacted 5.6 lakh
beneficiaries
Support to Aga Khan
Foundation for strengthening
SHG program enabling
reaching out to 20,000 SHG
members, support to 1,883
persons (PMJDY) and 10,982
persons (Micro Insurance &
Pension Scheme)
Quarterly State Financial
Inclusion Forum (SFIF) for
cross learning in the state
Debt funding for onlending
to small MFIs and their
capacity building through
Ananya and Sa-Dhan
FLWE - 3 MFIs (Saija, Cashpor, Utkarsh)- financial literacy trainings in 10 districts leading to direct training of 25,867 women, and awareness raising of 24,000 members through Mass Awareness Camps
Program with Sewa Bharat and Gram Vani - improving financial and digital literacy in 5 districts leading to direct on-boarding of 14,846 users on the IVR system - engagement with 74,230 community members
Support to Save Solutions - digital financial literacy in 5 clusters, covering more than 10,000 artisans and their family members
Support to Save Solutions - Customer Service Points (CSPs), leading to 44.5 lakh banking customers being provided better service delivery
An MFI-led Swavalamban Enterprise Development Program (SEDP) for around 1000 women micropreneurs for establishing/scaling-up their micro enterprises (ME)
Support to FWWBI - Solar Energy & Sanitation products extended to more than 5,000 disadvantaged people
Scalable model for WE & ME development - created in partnership with Jeevika (SRLM, Bihar), which has so far trained 552 Bank Sakhis and made them financially profitable who are now providing doorstep delivery of banking services to 3.1 million beneficiaries in rural Bihar.
Scaled up from 4 to 20 districts - being further scaled-up to 5 additional districts - 60,000 SHG members have been imparted digital financial literacy.
INTEGRATING WITH STATE LIVELIHOOD
MISSION
FINLIT TO ENTREPRENEURSHIP
EASE OF ACCESS TO CREDIT AND RESPONSIBLE
FINANCE
`
03 02 01
PSIG INTERVENTIONS IN B I H A R
KEY ENGAG E ME N T S & O U T R E A CH
CB support to 7 MFIs (Sahyog, Samhita, Disha, Shakti Mahila Sangh, Mahila Chetna Manch, Pratigya, Sanghmitra) which impacted more than 4.4 lakh beneficiaries. (Disha has since converted into Small Finance Bank (SFB)).
Support to RRB (Narmada Jhabua Gramin Bank) which impacted 3.5 lakh beneficiaries (283352 saving bank accounts opened, operations of 276 BCAs made financially viable in all 6 districts (Khargone, Khandwa, Burhanpur, Jhabua, Alirajpur, Barwani) of the project, 10,374 OD facilities made available, 23631 NPS/ APY accounts opened and 2681 SHGs linked to branch).
State Financial Inclusion Forum (SFIF) for cross-learning SFIF- Regular quarterly forums convened to bring together key FI stakeholders of the state.
Support to Self Help Promoting Institution (SHPI) (Chaitanya) - A BC aggregator model in MP for enhancing SHG bank linkage programme and building institutional capacities of smaller SHPIs/MFIs. The support helped develop integrated software named Micro Lekha for SHGs and SHG federations. The intervention has capacitated 4 smaller SHPIs and 16 federations, which consisted around 10,000 SHGs in 2 districts. The efforts were mainly focused on quality of SHGs and financial management of SHG and federations, which included BC operations. Overall, they have impacted 1.6 lakh beneficiaries.
Combination of Debt Fund and Grant Support for onlending to small MFIs and their capacity building initiatives. While the Debt fund was provided to MFIs for on-lending to poor women at the bottom of pyramid, the Grant Support was provided for confidence building through rating, portfolio audit, Code of conduct /social performance and compliance with regulatory guidelines. Technical assistance is provided for new age technology, MIS automation for greater transparency and cost effectiveness. Strengthening governance, risk management, data submission to Credit Information Companies, HR development and promoting other financial services such as Micro Pension & Insurance.
FLWE - 6 MFIs (Disha, Shakti Mahila
Sangh, Pratigya, Mahila Chetna
Manch, Samhita, Sahayog) - financial
literacy trainings in 13 districts.
Directly trained 29,000 women and
raised awareness of around 22,000
members through 72 Mass
Awareness Camps.
Scale-up of FLWE Program with 4
MFIs (Shakti Mahila Sangh, Pratigya,
Mahila Chetna Manch, Samhita).
Directly trained 48,000 women and
raised awareness of around 11,000
members through 94 Mass Awareness
Camps. 18,359 financial linkages
done.
An MFI-led Swavalamban Enterprise
Development Program (SEDP).
Around 1000 women micropreneurs
for establishing/ scaling-up their
micro enterprises (ME).
Bandhan Konnagar (in Satna). A
comprehensive model of
targeting hard core ultra-poor
was piloted in MP benefitting
1,000 women single-headed
households to graduate out of
extreme poverty through
establishment of small
enterprises.
Humana People to People India
(HPPI) (in Sheopur and Gwalior).
The project worked with 40,000
ultra-poor women and built their
capacities on FL, gender & health
issues and developed their
entrepreneurship skills. 3,409
women established their own
micro enterprises after this
support.
Empowering women to access
improved sanitation facilities
and participate as active
entrepreneurs to promote
sanitation (in Sehore, Raisen and
Panna) through Samarthan –
Centre for Development Support.
Capacities of 323 SHGs built on
sanitation and gender issues.
2678 families were benefited
directly from construction/repair
of toilets. Women’s employment
in non-traditional occupations
encouraged by training 450
women to become masons.
Further, these women were linked
to Prime Ministers Awas Yojana
(PMAY) and other construction
opportunities in their respective
villages. 150 women were linked
to school and panchayats for
maintenance of schools toilets.
60 women/groups were trained as
grassroots entrepreneurs or
vendor for taking the contract for
construction of toilets.
PSIG INTERVENTIONS IN MP
FINANCIAL INCLUSION
AND WOMEN
EMPOWERMENT
CHALLENGE FUND
(FIWECF) SUPPORT
ON INNOVATIVE
IDEAS
TARGETING HARD CORE ULTRA POOR
FINLIT TO
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
EASE OF ACCESS
TO CREDIT AND RESPONSIBLE
FINANCE
`
04 03 02 01
THEMATIC AREA
KEY ENGAG E ME N T S & OU TR E A CH
CB support to 7 MFIs (Annapurna, Mahashakti, Sambandh, GU Financial Services, Swayamshree Micro Credit Services, Swayamshree Mahila Samabaya Samiti Limited, Adhikar) impacting 6.07 lakh beneficiaries
State Financial Inclusion Forum (SFIF) for cross learning - Regular quarterly forums convened to bring together key FI stakeholders of the state.
Microfinance State Association- Odisha State Association for Financial Inclusion (OSAFI) - OSAFI organized trainings and district level meetings with the stakeholders reaching out to 60,000 MFI staffs through direct capacity building programs.
Technology Innovation Fund (TIF) support to 2 MFIs (Sambandh, Annapurna) - The TIF was used to enable MFIs to undertake technology based initiatives such as introduction of document management systems, faster credit delivery mechanism, system digitization, hardware support, development of MIS etc. which improved institutions ability to effectively reach out to the poor.
Soft loan support to 2 MFIs (Annapurna, Mahashakti) for improving partners’ capacity to open more branches in unserved/ underserved areas in the State.
Term loan support to 6 MFIs (Annapurna, Mahashakti, Sambandh, Swayamshree Micro Credit Services, Swayamshree Mahila Samabaya, Adhikar) - for expanding their portfolio for on-lending to unserved and underserved clients which impacted/supported around 50,000 beneficiaries.
FLWE Pilot - 7 MFIs (Swayamshree Cuttack, GU Finance, Mahashakti Foundation, Adhikar, Annapurna, Sambandh, Swayamshree Bhubaneswar) - financial literacy trainings in 13 districts. Directly trained 49,500 women and raised awareness of around 35000 members through 132 Mass Awareness Camps
Scale-up of FLWE Program with 6 MFIs (Swayamshree Cuttack, GU Finance, Mahashakti Foundation, Adhikar, Annapurna, Sambandh) - Directly trained 1.06 lakh women and raised awareness of 45,647 members through 220 Mass Awareness Camps. 45,149 financial linkages done.
An MFI-led Swavalamban Enterprise Development Program (SEDP) - Around 1000 women micropreneurs for establishing/ scaling-up their micro enterprises (ME).
Scalable model for imparting FLWE at scale demonstrated in partnership with Odisha Livelihood Mission - Trained a cadre of 50 Master Trainers and 300+ financial literacy resource persons for Odisha Livelihood Mission (OLM). The FL-CRPs further trained 86,010 women members from 8,053 SHGs on FLWE issues. The pilot up-scaled by OLM from 10 blocks to 1000 Gram Panchayats.
Project on inclusion and old age income security through contributory pension schemes: Increasing enrolments through Nudges, Mobile Payments and Online Crowd Funding in 2 blocks of Jagatsinghpura district-Crosslinks Foundation- Testing behavioural solutions to encourage Atal Pension Yojana (APY) enrolments and for measuring the effectiveness of the interventions by applying Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT).
PSIG INTERVENTIONS IN ODISHA
CHALLENGE
FUND SUPPORT
ON INNOVATIVE
IDEAS
INTEGRATING WITH STATE LIVELIHOOD
MISSION
FINLIT TO
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
EASE OF ACCESS
TO CREDIT AND RESPONSIBLE
FINANCE
`
04 03 02 01
THEMATIC AREA
THEMATIC AREA
K E Y E N G A G E M E N T S & O U T R E A C H
Mahila Udyami Sashaktikaran Program (MUSP), a 15-month pilot, in Varanasi and Ghazipur provided end-to-end support (training, handholding, credit and market linkage) to women micro-entrepreneurs for establishing, scaling-up and diversifying their enterprises under which 15,000 women were trained on business skills; 9,000 women-led micro enterprises helped to set-up/scale-up/diversify their respective businesses.
Swavalamban Enterprise Development Program (SEDP) started in Gorakhpur and Raibareily for creation/up-scaling of livelihood activities by way of skill and entrepreneurship development leading to set-up of 1,000 micro-enterprises.
Udyam Saarthi - An intensive digital financial literacy project in the form of a self-contained Mobile Literacy Lab which sensitized over 60,000 individuals on digital financial literacy and handheld about 12,000 individuals for digital transactions in select 9 blocks of Ghazipur & Varanasi districts covering 344 villages.
An intensive financial inclusion programme through community-based institution for poverty reduction undertook Bank Linkage, Financial Literacy, nurturing and promoting young women SHGs and other related activities in 200 backward blocks of Uttar Pradesh reaching out to a total of around 5 lakh SHG members.
Financial Literacy (FL)
Partnered with 5 MFIs for financial literacy trainings in 25 districts in UP.
1.65 lakh women trained on Financial and Digital Literacy across the State.
SIDBI Centre for Innovation in Financial Inclusion (SCI-FI):
SIDBI has supported IIM-Lucknow for setting- up of SCI-FI at IIM-Lucknow, for development of new age financial products, innovative business models and build FinTech in India.
This would also support new start-ups, thereby helping in setting standards and best practices for a more responsible growth in the sector.
The centre is presently incubating 9 diversified FinTechs and has engaged 15 industry mentors. Out of these, 3 FinTech Start-ups have been acknowledged for their solutions at the different fora. “
Microfinance Association of Uttar Pradesh (UPMA)
SIDBI has been instrumental in setting-up of Microfinance Association of Uttar Pradesh (UPMA), a State-level MFI association.
UPMA is promoting responsible lending, client protection, good governance and a supportive regulatory environment in the state.
UPMA is achieving this via activities like organizing FI conclave, awareness generation for digital financial literacy program, mass awareness campaigns towards confidence building post- demonetization, conducting various theme-based workshops and trainings for the MFI officials and other stakeholders etc.
Green Micro Credit
Cashpor Micro Credit was supported to undertake a pilot on modified microfinance loan product called ‘Green Micro Credit’ to promote tree plantation (suitable for GHS sequestration) among matured income generating loan borrowers and suitably incentivize them by way of interest subvention and in meeting initial plantation and upkeep cost. The initiative helped in mitigating carbon emission and is a kind of long-term economic investment for the client.
Capacity building support was sanctioned to 10 MFIs for conducting Loan Portfolio Audit, Social Performance Ratings, System Audit, Software Up-gradation and expansion in underserved/unserved pockets of UP and promotion of other financial services such as pension and insurance. This capacity building support helped MFIs to serve over 41 lakh (4.1 million) clients in UP.
Debt Fund support extended to 8 MFIs, helping in on-lending to 6.35 lakh beneficiaries.
Innovative support mechanisms like Risk Fund improved MFIs capacity
Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojna
(PMUY)
SIDBI supported an MFI- led intervention for awareness generation and switching over to cleaner methods of cooking under PMUY in 8 districts, viz., Azamgarh, Ballia, Chitrakoot, Gorakhpur, Jaunpur, Kushinagar, Mirzapur and Sonebhadra.
In addition to awareness generation of around 70,000 BPL members, more than 7,500 BPL households have been linked with PMUY by way of Energy Loans.
MAJOR PSIG INITIATIVES IN UTTAR PRADESH
01 02 03
`
`
FINANCIAL LITERACY & WOMEN ENTREPRENEURSHIP
(FLWE)
POLICY ADVOCACY
INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY BUILDING
Key Highlights of Independent Endline Evaluation Independent evaluation of the program points towards
significant improvement in women’s agency captured
through Women’s Agency Index (WAI) in PSIG
geographies and reduction in domestic violence.
There was a small but significant reduction in poverty rates
as measured by the Poverty Probability Index – by 9
percentage points for the rural sample and by 13 percentage
points for the urban households.
There was a statistically significant increase (from
38.0 to 47.1) in Financial Inclusion Index (FII) and a
reduction in the rural/urban and SC ST/ other social groups’
gap. Overall, 68% of households showed increase in their
FII score.
The benefit-cost ratio (BCR) of 11 indicates that for every
rupee spent, benefits were accrued to the tune of 11 times
which suggests a very high level of efficiency for the PSIG
programme.
PSIG Key Learnings
1. Policy Level
PSIG played a critical role in helping the sector absorb
shocks such as 2010 crisis and demonetization
Policy dialogues and position papers highlighted elements
that policy makers needed to address
Important state level role by setting up of MFI
associations in UP & Odisha where these agencies were
instrumental in creating stakeholder awareness and
managing the fallout of policy shocks such as
demonetization and loan waivers in UP and the potential
collateral effects of the collapse of chit funds in Odisha
Strengthened SHGs by supporting the engagement of
SHPIs in the low-income states.
Supported the emergence of the Business
Correspondent model as a para-banking channel to
intensify the engagement of commercial banks with low
income clients and to increase their depth of outreach in the
four poorest states
Lessons
Despite all efforts, limited effect on non-traditional
products like pension & insurance
PSIG could have addressed the knowledge gap through
creating evidence on cost of operations in poor areas that
could have informed policy better.
2. PFI Level
Effectively supported growth & capacity building for MFIs
working at different scales
Supported better institutional readiness for client
protection, gender integration and responsible finance
Strengthened many aspects of operations especially
Governance, IT, Audit & Technology
Lessons
Objectives for product development & diversification only
partially achieved – limited to some adaptation of credit for
WASH and alternative energy – and systematic MIS and
reporting beyond standard portfolio analysis still needs
more attention from MFIs.
Small MFIs had received significant portfolio support from
PSIG, this facilitated some of them to graduate to large or
medium MFI status; whilst others – perhaps inevitably -
failed to make significant progress.
3. Client Level
Contributed to the availability of credit services through
MFIs/SFBs and the ability of MFIs to provide larger loans
Considerable improvement over the baseline on client
understanding of the terms of credit and credit insurance.
Those who attended financial literacy training showed a
marginal increase in use of different services.
In terms of welfare, significant positives changes were
observed in poverty reduction, housing facilities and
ownership of durable assets. Some decrease in dependency
on non-farm casual labour and home- based piece rate
work. Borrowing from moneylenders reduced.
Improvements across geographies and social groups
(including SC/ST, Muslims and women headed
households).
Lessons
On the less positive side, there was a high level of reported
shocks/difficulties with illness/accident followed by
agriculture related difficulties in rural areas.
Non-farm business difficulties were higher for those
borrowing for business use.
4. Women’s Empowerment
Significant improvements for women across all
categories.
Microcredit for women had given some low-income women
the opportunity to start micro non-farm businesses that they
manage themselves. Their reported profits increased since
baseline, but turnover and profits remained lower than for
joint or men managed businesses
Percentage of women saying they experience domestic
violence has fallen significantly to 17.5% (rural & urban)
from 31% at baseline
Endline also reported significant increase in women
reporting better say in family decisions, with this gap also
narrowing between rural and urban women.
Lessons
Work on institutional gender integration remains critical for
the sector to become more client-centred and inclusive.
TEAM MEMOIRS
While considering financial support to an organization
catering to this particular segment of the population, going
deep into the organization’s Balance Sheet is of secondary
importance. In fact, we should look beyond the Balance
Sheet and take a call on the support-worthiness of the
project in terms of the field-level reputation/feedback about
the organization and it’s connect to the roots.
Abhijit Das, DGM, PSIG
The diversity and scale of programming under the PSIG
umbrella helped us make a dent in how gender is perceived
across the spectrum of partners, communities, financial sector
and banks themselves. We learnt to be persistent in our
efforts to integrate a gender lens and learnt a lot ourselves
through this process.
Sonal Jaitly, Theme Leader, Gender & FL, PSIG
I feel privileged and honoured for having
been associated with one of the most
impactful and cost-effective programs of
the development sector catering to the
bottom-of-the pyramid in the
underserved/unserved districts of the 4
PSIG states which was implemented
through a network of NBFCs, MFIs,
corporate BCs, state associations, SRLMs
etc. My biggest learning is that impactful
programs can be implemented in a cost-
effective way; it does not necessarily
require huge quantum of money, it just
requires concerted efforts, dedicated and
meticulous planning and concurrent
monitoring &evaluation of the programs.
Nikhil Raj, Theme Leader, M&E, PSIG
FLWE pilot was my major learning of integrating gender into
financial literacy trainings. 6 months long discussions and
back n forth with resource agency finally led to development
of FLWE modules which tried to imbibe gender analysis tools
in the sessions, calls for prioritizing women’s health and
assets while decision making on savings, investment &
insurance. The pilot gave us a window to directly reach out to
women clients of MFIs. PSIG used micro credit as an
opportunity to further empower women through FLWE and
build their financial well-being.
Archana Ale, Manager, Gender & FL
The provision of debt based financial assistance
mainly at subsidized rates for branch expansion
of MFIs in PSIG States, their technology
upgradation and on lending to their clients
fulfilled the twin objective of promoting financial
inclusion as well as ensuring judicious use &
ownership in the game of financial
intermediaries/implementing partners. PSIG
ensured 100% realization of assistance(s)
extended under debt fund/risk fund, which
ultimately augmented the Institutionalizing of
PSIG Legacy by making the availability of PSIG
residual funds –
Chandan Bajaj, AGM, PSIG
I joined PSIG Project in 2014 when Capacity Building
support to MFI -II, Risk Fund, Debt Fund-II and
Technology Advisory Body was set up. I was involved in
gearing to start these activities being a part of Access
to Finance team.
Indu Rawat, Manager, PSIG
Entering the project in the last phases, our efforts to align it
to SIDBI Vision 2.0 bore fruit. We could, with DFID support,
set-up Legacy Fund for taking forward the pilots &
integrating with Mission Swavalamban-the umbrella
programme which caters to entrepreneurs, enterprise and
entrepreneurship.
Dr. R.K.Singh, GM, PSIG
PSIG TEAM MEMBERS
Involved in the preparation of this Knowledge Product
Dr. R. K Singh, General Manager
Shri Abhijit Das, Dy. General Manager
Ms. Sonal Jaitly, Theme Leader – Gender & Financial Literacy
Shri Nikhil Raj, Theme Leader - Monitoring & Evaluation
DISCLAIMER: The information presented in this document is based on the experience and learnings from DFID supported SIDBI’s interventions under the PSIG program. The document is intended as a knowledge product only, for the purpose of replication of the relevant models by the institutions/organizations who are interested to do so and also as a showcase of the magnitude of the impacts created. SIDBI will not be liable for any damages or loss, direct or indirect, arising out of such use of information provided within this document.