office of the executive engineer highways division sukkur

are ubmitted for

EXECUT HIG

EER DIVISION

UKKUR

OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NO. EE/HW-D/TC/ t974, 2018 SUKKUR DATED. c2 /O/2018

'To,

The Director (A&F), Sindh Public Procurement Regulatory Authority, Karachi.

SUBJECT:- REQUEST FOR HOISTING OF BID EVALUATION REPORT NIT NO. EE/HW-D/TC/503 DATED. 04.12.2017 AT SPPRA ID NO:2 147483647 S.NO. 35535 DATED: 05-12-20 17

The Bid Evaluation Report impartial duly signed by 03

Members of Procurement Committee with Original Comparative

Statement, Minutes of opening bid meeting, Bidders Qualification!

Technical Evaluation Report attendance s

information please.

ILO

OFFICE OF THE EXECUTWE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NO. EE/HW-D/TC/ 201 SUKKUR DTAED. 1/ /C//2Ol

CORRIGENDUM

Please refer to the NIT issued by this office vide this

office letter No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 dated. 04.12.2017 published in

various daily newspaper as well as hoisted on SPPRA website the

period of bid validity referred in bidding data is treated as 90 days.

All the other terms and condition will remain as same.

EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR Copy submitted with compliments to: -

1. The Worthy Deputy Commissioner, Sukkur.

2. The Secretary, Information Technology, and Government of Sindh Secretariat No: 6, @ Karachi, along with copies of N.I.T's for favour of information and placing them on the web site of Sindh ,.._ Government.

3. The Director (A&F) SPPRA 3-15 Government of Sindh, Public Procurement Regulatory Authority , Planning & Development Department Karachi along with Soft & Hard copy of NIT for favour of information and placement on Web Site.

4. The Director, Information (Advertisement) Public Relation Advertising Department Karachi, for publication in 3 Nos. leading Newspaper "Sindhi" , Urdu & English" (Kawaish, Jung, Down).

5. The Superintending Engineer, Works & Services, Sukkur, for favour of information.

6. The Executive Engineer, (Buildings / Education Works) Department Sukkur, for information for wide publicity.

7. Copy to notice board and drawing branch / HC (Local).

C

EXECUTIVE ENGIER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

Q'•'r *4 U 'I 1 F i(IW'v' I, '.

- I

-U - C(- C lH '- ' U:- 'I''''- H

1 )H

i.1igbi1ity \I. lIRU- PH'KH tC1Ii

vi;UF 201 '1 •in- I I I (:t vr t t:t . tSpec • 'h Hp\11 u:1 U - -i' -.';iOi

i-; I r1 -fl 10- Cl 1(IUI(I Ut' i H

-; C I' IhI' Uph H "CR - - rt 'LU

QU Al JF1CAT1ON

-'CI I';HH 1.

H -- C_ - U

- 'iI

I 1 - ;-

C :1

h1eth)d of Prof tlr( rn ot

13 tdcuing / Tvn d ii

H1'! U- C C

d 1- I O1U' HL IIt

.' 0i' "

H'- CW C. C

'U l.

Cd

tIlIC tI HI CSUWUCL

OH('C LJUH 1 1 (11I

;t. .

dC'

'I'.C'1 \\

jul ,'_11 IuI\It)I

_\ u I \I0

I U I

j)UtCt(CLC('1I Ct

I I tt1411 Tcflt

CO•

)-0(

-' (C HI -

. -1-.L

j )i: tniri

LTau1 nI IcI , ftr pubini Hd1u Uiui ;"

/

IiTGIJpy D7j

1 S1I d j')1Imtto

i';j 111 1-

I u J(.! (': :,f S;r. U ( I c

I. IiI jlf 1,1 ('

ii .1

I \Y I'HA 1 - ifl A',y

k Ii IIi ''tI1

uioi nd 1Il;II IIni 1I Ij.1

kkur/ I<oifl / ; t Aii lot iI'O[

EXECUTiVE INGtNE hIGHWAYS DWISl

I -*

I k P1

IhM l

t)c1 i•or • \1L

1tjOH H I 'i

H dl I l\ l I C

JI

RLs

jd i !3 uUH

0O0

ui H

Wage Qdii I1T L;

'h: ikh

Cxnst: of road iOU ii t 3 H H

Wian Ho H1Vj1!(, O/OU/ 3

ibi11t1()ll & J( loi HI IH Hi I Iih

o' Ii H10 i1 i

U1! AIU]lWflfl1Hd K lU1hH1 Mik 0/

HI IKh ilit u

k

3000

Car' \,:

( U

:- !\-¼

(f JflU

J o tdo 111 V1i

IUo I h il (I ii \\o1

f\iii

LU

ii

Itu mi

th \'

:l 11i

uth' \ l& Ii ()

! th

I tl

I 1i It

11 lt 11 )

I 1 iii.. I \ ii

I

1 k ) 1

n N U

I

Ii(\l

\H;H (h N

i

t.I

ft

'\cI1t' U; UU:

A

Ut li\t ihiI

U H dI NI

H HJ

st

24

14

I Ni

I I kin . He ft

m ill i

Ii Ii \I III

1 I I F

}J) 1.141

I I 1.. i4( 4ThI

t . IIh

N Th I H t 11

ii 1W 1 H t)

fkl "

IIi (Il

N 1 I

L

1 tion 4

41

,..1 .r¶)I :ril 4',_ fl l, i i (jQJt I

• .1)N(U( It ii .4

•'1ii \Ju1,5,Uu1 hi iIs ,i

I IiCJii! \ii; 43/ () i)j

I: hit.

in 1 • 'i' .4 I I H . 1

IIUI II io:4J 1114.1W liiI'k' N

•'i1 iftR1 Lu iuLJi Li4H1)In 11111

N

EXECUTIVE EINEER HWAYS DiV

The lJi:,'to t1lj iL I ft

t

13JF(' )T t 10N 01 1L 1W)/ / 1i\jj ).(M. I 2.:20 1'?,

I yi If'wH (1(htf

N I T SU 13 M S Si ON (I

S AU, Documents Reqtircd with NIT:

EX FCUTIVE EIGINEER

1IGIVJAYSD

U 1 L cr

C 'i I

OFFICE OP THE DEPUTY COMMI$$JONER/PL)

$UKKUR No.DC/Suk-Dev/2013-14J- Sukkur, dated'-3-2i4

RUER

In pursuance of Rule 31 of Sindh Public Procurement Regulatory Authority Rules 2010, thc

dressa! of Grievances and settlement of Dispute Committec° is hereby constituted in the Works &

Srvces Department Sukkur (Projects of District Development portfolios) with following composition:

S.No. Designation Position held

Superintending Engineer Works & Services Sukkur Chairman

2 District Accounts Officer Sukkur

3 Additional Deputy Commissioner-Il of Deputy Commissioner Office Sukkur

Member

Member

Member

Mn )e

4 Executive Engineer Provincial Highway Division Sukkur

S Executive Engineer of the Division concerned

TERMS OF REFERENCE:

The Committee will hear the complaints of bidders against the decisions of piocurin agency.

ii) Prohibit the procurement committee from acting or deciding in a manner, inconsistent wh these rules and regulations;

iii Annual in whokorinparcar.yunaithcried o decision of the pwcercment comnii:te. and

iv) Recommend to the Head of Department that the case be declared a mis-procuremelu if

material violation of Act, Rules, Regulations, orders, instructions or any other law relating 10

public procurement, has been established. v) Reverse any decision of the Procurement Committee or substitute its own decision for such

a decision provided that the complaint Redressal Committee shall not make any decision to award the contract.

vil The Complaint Redressol Committee shall announce its decision within seven days alit!

intimate the same to the bidder and the authority within 3 working days.

/

(SHAHZAD TAHIR THAHEEM)

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER/PD

SUKKUR

Copy fwd: for information to:

1. The Superintending Engineer Works & Services Sukkur,

2. The District Accounts Officer Sukkur

3. The Additionol Deputy Commissioner-li Sukkur

4. The Executive Engineer Provpthl Highways Division. Sukkur

5. The Executive Engineer Higi1"ways/Buiidings/Education Works & Public HethlEngineering Divisions, 5ukkur.

DEPUTh COMMkSStONER/PD 4JJ KK1 R

Execulive Engineer, Highways Division, Sukkw

Assistant Engineer, Highways Sub-Division, Rohri

Assistant Engineer, Public Health Engineering Sub-Division, Rohri

Chairman

Member

Member

2. The Functions & Responsibilities of the Committee will be same as specified in Rule- 7

& So! Sindh Public Procurement Rtiles-2010.

GOVERNMENT OF SINOH WORKS sSERVICES IJEPARTMENT

Karachi dak'd 2S November, 2016.

NO TIFICA i'ION

No.E&A(W&S)3-9/2014 (Sukkur) : in partial modification of this Department's Notification of oven

number dated 02-07-2013 and with the approval of Competent Authority, Procurement Committee, in

terms 01 Ru!e-7 of Sindh Public Procurement Rules-2010 (Amended 2013), is hereby constituiud fo

procurement of Goods / Work? in the Office of Executive Engineer, Hiqhways Division, Sukkur

excluding, procurement involving foreign exchange, with the following cornposition:-

SECRETARY TO GOVT. OF SINDH

No.E&A(W&S)3-9/2014 (Sukkur) Karachi, dated the 28th November, 2016.

A copy is (oswarded for information to:-

1. The Accountant General, Sindh, Karachi. 2. The Managing Director, SPPRA, Karachi. 3. The Chief Engineer (Highways), Sukkur 4. The Chairman /Members of the Committee. 5. The Deputy Director (Monitoring), PM&E Cell, W&SD. 6. PS to Minister, Works & Services Sindh. 7. PS to Secretaiy, W&S Department 8. Notification file.

SECTION OFPCEW(GENERAL) FOR SECRETARY TO GOVT. OF S!NDH

S NIT NO. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 DATED. 09. 12.2017

- METHOD AND PROCEDURE OF NATIONAL COMPETITIVE BIDDING PROCUREMENT (SINGLE STAGE-ONE ENVELOPE)

MINUTES OF BID OPENING MEETING

A meeting of the procurement committee of this department was held on

dated. 22.12.2017 for opening the bids received in respect of subject NIT: the deadline of

supervision the meeting was attended by all following members of the procurement

committee and the representative of bidders (Attendance sheet is enclosed).

The bids were opened at 02:00 PM in the presence of the above

mentioned participants and the rates quoted by bidders were read aloud and encircled by

Chairman of the Procurement Committee. All the members of the procurement committee

signed on each and every page of financial proposal /bids. The bids does not contain any

over-writing or cutting (and mention cutting or over-writing if any), following are the details

of bids announced.

The committee shall examine all the bids as per the Qualification/

eligibility criteria provided in the bidding documents arithmetical checks and verify the

documents and bid security submitted by the bidders.

The meeting ended with the note of thanks to from the chair.

IRAFIQUE AHED SHAIIU{) EXECUT1Y ENGUEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SIJKKIJR

(WAHEW BUX ASSISTANT ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION RORRI

(ABDUL ASSISTANT E GINER

PUBLIC HEALTH E!jGUBDIVISION Rd

!'4 - . i -. -

NL.i

it I h14 tin,.

.4 j- - _t.., 'I.

. .. -

,

1-

1 4 rj) I

- .-

t :_-

1 -''

r i.'

? \ i 1 -

•:- ir. -

4 ,. • -.

-

:} k)2

.4

• . . .- .

n - 'L T11L

11 _.ta •Jv ,t/ .

--::,

U)

.—',Jij .'

I/

ç.:i( ;

V1'f-:', F

'

. - ,. -, .. - '.

1 t.• . .'- t•- -.

." . . . .;__ .. I - - 1- .. .- I . . ',

tl

1

S ATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN 4 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM NATIONAL HIGHWAY TO VILLAGE BHAI KHAN GHANGHRO MILE 0/0-0/3+330' (1.60KM).

EXECUTWE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR HELD ON 22.12.2017

SR. NO.

NAME OF CONTRACTOR SIGNATURE

1 M/S RAVI KUMAR ENTERPRISES

N

7- 2 M/S SUKKUR CONSTRUCTION COMPANY

I

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED SjIAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

441 (WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION ROHRI

4 (ABDUL HAFE Z MEMON] ASSISTANT ENGINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB-DIVISION ROHRI

S ID EVALUTION REPORT

1 Name of Procuring Agency Executive Engineer Highways Division Sukkur

2 Tender Reference No. N.l.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM NATIONAL HIGHWAY TO VILLAGE BHAI KHAN GHANGHRO MILE 0/0-0/3+330 (1.60KM).

4 Method of Procurement Single Stage (By Competitive Rate! Bid)

5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07. 12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17

SPPRA ID NO:2 147483647 S.No. 35535 Dated: 05-12-2017

6 Total Document Sold 02 Nos.

7 Total Bids Received 02 Nos.

8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Anolicable)

--

9 No of Bid Technically Qualified (If Applicable)

01 No.

10 Bids Rejected 01 Nos.

11 Financial Bid Opening Date 22.12.2017

BID EVALUATION REPORT

COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASONS FOR SR # NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER OFFERED BY TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATE ACCEPTANCE/ REMARKS

- THE BIDDER COST COST (SAVING) REJECTION

I M/S RAVI KUMAR ENTERPRISES

5816304 1 Lowest 151696 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S SUKKUR CONSTRUCTION COMPANY

5865596 2h1 Higher 102404 1ejcctcc1 Being Higher

SIGNATURE OF THE TENDERING COMMITTEE.

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED EXECUTIVE EGNEER


MEMBER

'I A'

MEMBER

(WAHEED Bt1 Q'SMI) (ABDUL HA?EEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGthEER ASSISTANT4OINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH E1GG: SUB-DIVISION ROHRI ROHRI

I

PART "B" 190833 189466 191378

GRAND TOTAL A, B: - 5856689 5816304 5865596

ADD: CONTIGENCY (LUM-STJM) 111483

The Lowest Rates Qouted By M/S RAVI KUMAR ENTERPRISES Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" (11 Rs. 7.30% Above (Rupees Seven Point Thirty Percent Above) PART "B" @ Rs. 10% Above (Rupees Ten Percent Above)

Lowest Rates are Recommended for Approval

(A) Total Cost as per Estimate 5968000 (B) Total as per Tender 5816304

Saving (A+B) 151696 Percentage Saving 2.54

A.A Amount 6000000 Lowest Tender Amount 5816304

Saving Over A.A 183696

NAME OF WORK: -

FINANCIAL REVIEW 1 COMPARATIVE STATEMNT

CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM NATIONAL HIGHWAY TO VILLAGE BHAI KHAN GHANGHRO MILE 0/0-0/3+330' (1.60KM).

SR NO

DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE

M/S RAW KUMAR ENTERPRISES

_______ MIS SUKKUR CONSTRUCTION COMPANY

RATE AMOUNT RATE AMOUNT

PART "A" (ROAD WORK 1 AmountofSchcdule'B 5574160 5574160 5574160

2 Add: 8% Above () 445932 7.30% Above (+) 406914 8.15% Above (+) 454294

3 Ded: Diff Cost of Bitumen (-1 354236 354236 354236

PART "A" 5665856 5626838 5674218 PART "B" 13' SPAN CULVERTS

I Amount of Schedule B" 172242 172242 172242

2 Permium -- 10% Above (4-) 17224 11.11% Above(+) 19136

3 Add: Cartagc of Material (+) 18591

RiED AS

BDULHAFEE1 ON) ASSISTANT E'

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG. mQfl HIGH WAYSJWIION

S

TENDER REFERENCE NO. N.LT No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17

NAME OF PROCURING EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM NATIONAL HIGHWAY TO VILLAGE BHAI KHAN GHANGHRO MILE 0/0-0/3+330' (1.60KM.

1 TURNOVER OF O5°• TENDER FEE!

SR. NO.

NAME OF FIRM/ BIDDERS N.T.N REGISTRATION

WITH P.E.0 SINDH BOARD OF REVENUE

RELEVANT EXPERIENCE

AT LEAST LAST THREE YEARS

BUDGET EARNEST

MONEY COST BIDDING

DOCUMENT

I M, S RAVI KUMAR ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS SUKKUR CONSTRUCFION COMPANY

Available Registered Registered Av.idabk Ava:lable Available Available Deposited

CHAIRMAN MEMBER MEMBER

(RAFIQUE ARMED SHAJK (WAHEED BUX QAMI) (ABDUL HAFZ MEMON) EXECUTWE ENGINtER ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB-DIVISION

SUKKUR RORRI RORRI

ATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FORM WASS ROAD TO GHANTAN WARI VIA HAFIZ ABDUL SAMI MANGRIO MILE 0/0-0/5 (1 KM).

EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR HELD ON 22.12.2017

SR. NO.


7

1 MIS JAN MUHAMMAD NAREJO

2 M/S AHMED ALl JAMALI \

I

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED SHAI


SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

7}J S (WAHEED BUX QASMI)

ASSISTANT ENGINEER HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION

ROHRI

(ABDUL HAFE)MON) ASSISTANT NGINEER


BID EVALUTION REPORT


2 Tender Reference No. N.I.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FORM WASS ROAD TO GRANTAN WAR! VIA HAFIZ ABDUL SAMI MANGRIO MILE 0/0-0/5 (1 KM).

4 Method of Procurement Single Stage (By Competitive Rate/ Bid)

5 Tender Published Published in (i)Da*ly Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (II) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (lv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017

SPPRA ID NO:2 147483647 S.No. 35535 Dated: 05-12-20 17



8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If AoDlicableI

--


01 No.




COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASONS FOR SR # NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER OFFERED BY TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATE ACCEPTANCE! REMARKS

THE BIDDER COST COST (SAVING) REJECTION

1 M/S JAN MUHAMMAD NAREJO

6432783 1st Lowest 61217 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S AHMED ALl JAMAL! 6482937 2nd Higher 11063 Rejected Being Higher


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED S EXECUTIVE ENG NEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX 4~XMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


(ABDUL HAFEEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


SR NO

ESTIMATE

I RATE

MIS JAN MUHAMMAD NAREJO

AMOUNT DESCRIPTION

M/S ARMED ALl JAMALI

RATE AMOUNT —j

ABDU[ HAFEEZ ASSISTANT . ER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: S ..

(WAHEE : U') DASM)) ASSISTAN EN("

MIGHWAYS StJB-UiV'- Rt

.4

FINANCIAL REVIEW / COMPARATIVE STATEMNT

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FORM WASS ROAD TO GHANTAN WAR! VIA HAFIZ ABDUL SAM! MANGRIO MILE 0/0-0/5 (1 KM).

PART "A" (ROAD WORK

1 Amount of Schedule"B" 4710827 4710827 4710827

2 Add: 8% Above 376866 7.30% Above (i') 343890 8.13% Above () 382990

3 Ded:DiffCostofBituinen (-) 319423 319423 319423 PART "A" 4768270 4735294 4774394

PART "B" (ROAD WORK

1 Amount of Schedule "B' 1368304 1368304 1368304

2 Add: 14%Above (+) 191562 13.50% Above (+) 184721 14.15% Above (+) 193615

3 Ded: Duff Cost of Bitumen (-j 79799 79799 79799 PART "B" 1480067 1473226 1482120

PART "C" (3' SPAN CULVERTS 1 Amount of Schedule "B" 172242 172242 172242 2 Fermium -- 12.50% Above (+), 21530 13.60% Above (+) 23425 3 Add: Cartage of Material () 22583

PART "C" 194825 193772 195667 PART "D" (PIPE CULVERTS

1 Amount of Schedule "B" 26285 26285 26285 2 Fermium -- 16% Above (+J, 4206 17.0 1% Above (+) 4471 3 Add: Cartage of Material (i') 4329

PART 'D" 30614 30491 30756

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C+D: - 6473776 6432783 6482937

ADD: CONTIGENCY (LUM-SUM) 20000

(A) Total Cost as per Estimate (B) Total as per Tender

Saving (A+B) Percentage Saving

A,A Amount Lowest Tender Amount

Saving Over A.A

6494000 6432783

61217 0.94

6500000 6432783

67217

The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS JAN MUHAMMAD NAREJO Govcrnmcn Contractor are:-

PART "A" Rs. 7.30% Above (Rupees Seven Point Thirty Percent Above) PART "B" (a; Rs. 13.50% Above (Rupees Thirteen Point Fifty Percent Above) PART "C" (a Rs. 12.50% Above (Rupees Twelve Point Fifty Percent Above) PART "D" (a Rs. 16% Above (Rupees Sixteen Percent Above) Loicst Rates are Recommended for Approval

IGH WAYS DIVt81öN

4

TENDER REFERENCE NO.

NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

Q

N.I.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017

EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FORM WASS ROAD TO GHANTAN WAR! VIA HAFIZ ABDUL SAM!

MANGRIO MILE 0/0-0/5 (1 KM).

I -

SR NO.



RELEVANT EXPERIENCE

TURNOVER 0? AT LEAST LAST THREE YEARS

BUDGET

05% TENDER FEEl COST BIDDING

DOCUMENT EARNEST

MONEY

I- - * h

1 M/S JAN MUHAMMAD NAREJO Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS AHMED ALl JAMAL! Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHMED SHAICli) (WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HA11Z MEMON) EXECUTIVE ENGINER ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVII0N PUBLIC HEALTH ENGO: SUB-DIVISION

SUKKUR ROHRI ROHRI

4


NAME OF WORK: - PAV1R BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS (i VILLAGE BHAI KHAN GHANGHRO (REMAINING WORKS).

EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR HELD ON - 22.12.2017

SR. NO.


I M/S SA1B RASH EED & CO

2 M/SAL-NOOR

3 M/SIFTINHARAHMED

y r

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE ATED SHAIKH) EXECUTf'E ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

\Ac\ 'I

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HA Z EMON ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT EER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB-DIVISION ROHRI ROHRI

S

ID EVALUTIQN REPORT

I Name of Procuring Agency Executive Engineer Highways Division Sukkur

2 Tender Reference No. N.J.T No. EE/HW.D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017

3 Tender Description! Name of Work! Item PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS @ VILLAGE BHAI KHAN GHANGHRO (REMAINING WORKS).


5 Tender Published Pu)lished in (i)Daily Awarni Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017

(ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017




8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Applicable)

--


01 No.




SR # NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER COST

OFFERED BY RANKING IN TERMS OF

COMPARISON WITH

REASONS FOR ACCEPTANCE! REMARKS

THE BIDDER COST ESTIMATE cosT

REJECTION

1 MIS SAQIB RASHEED & CO

4833534 i' Lowest 144466 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S ALNOOR 4969964 2' Higher 8036 Rejected Being Higher

3 M/S IFTIKHAR AHMED 5025998 3 Highest -47998 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMjaSHAIKH) EXECUTIVENGINEER

HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKIUJR

*

*1

MEMBER

\l

v,

(WAHEED BUX ASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION ROH RI

MEMBER

(ABDUL HA ASSISTANT E

PUBLIC HEALTH OHRI

EZ MON) INEE

B-DIVISION

GRAND TOTAL A, B, C: - 4880060 4833534 4969964 5025998


Ibe Lowest Rates Qouted l3' M/S SAOIB RASHEED & CO Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" ii Rs. 0.80% Below (Rupees Zero Point Eighty Percent Below)






(ABDULHAF Z*:i ASSISTANt E. NEER

PUBLIC HEALTH EN G: SUB-DIVISION ROHRI

(WAHEED BUX eASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


INANCW REVIEW / COMPARATIVE STATEMNT

NAIVIE OF WORK: - PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS @: VILLAGE BHAI KHAN GHANGHRO (REMAINING WORKS).

r SR NO

DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE M/S SAQIB RASHEED & Co MIS AL-NOOR M/S IFFIKHAR AHMED

RATE-

AMOUNT RATE AMOUNT [] RATE AMOUNT-

PART "A" (ROAD WORK

AmountofScheduleB" 4872514 4872514 4872514 4872514

Dccl: 20% Below (on Paver Block Only) n Rs. 4063321/-

812664 0.80% Below (-) 38980 2% Above (~) 97450 3.15% Above Nj 153484

3 Add: Cartage of Material () 820210

ErC(jT)'r>-'' \!EER -..--. I)S1ON SUKKUR

N

TURNOVER OF 05% TENDER FEEl AT LEAST LAST

FUNDS! EARNEST COST BIDDING

THREE YEARS BUDGET

MONEY DOCUMENT

J

NAME OF FIRM! BIDDERS RELEVANT

EXPERIENCE

'I

TENDER REFERENCE NO. N.I.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17


NAME OF WORK PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS a VILLAGE BHAI KHAN GHANGHRO (REMAINING WORKS).

SR. NO.

1 MIS SAQIB RASHEED & CO .\vailable Registered Registered \va:Iablv Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS AL-NOOR Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

3 MIS 11T1KHAR AHMED Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHffiD SHAIKH) EXECUT-1 ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX QSMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION RO H RI

MEMBER

(ABDUL HAFEEZ MVMON) ASSISTANT ENG

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGc/ . -DIVISION ROH

ATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKJR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM THICKRATHO ROAD TO GHATTI MILE 0/0-2/1.


SR. NO.

NAME OF CONTRACTOR SIGNJWtJRE

1 MIS AM & MJ BUILDERS

2 M/S AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH CONSrF: & CO.

3 M/S MANZOOR AHMED & BROTHERS

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHISHAIKH)


SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAFEE ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT 'i NEER


BID EVALUTiON RP9RT


2 Tender Reference No. N.I.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17

3 Tender Description! Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM THICKRATHO ROAD TO GHATTI MILE 0/0-2/1.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Dally Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17





--


01 No.


11 Financial Bid Opening Date 22.12.20 17




I M/S AM & MJ BUILDERS 22365881 1t Lowest 107219 Accepted Being Lowe St

2 M/S ALMUZAMIL SHAIKH CONSTI': & CO.

22614397 2 Higher -141297 Rejected Being Higher

3 M/S MANZOOR AHMED & BROTHERS

22851243 3fl Highest -378143 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEHAIKH) EXECUTiVE ETGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

L1 ' (WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION ROH



M/S AM & MJ BUILDERS

RATE AMOUNF]

M/S AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH CONSTF: &) CO.

RATE AMOUNT

MIS MANZOOR AHMED BROTHERS

RATE AMOUNT ii



A.A Amount Lowest Tender Amount

Saving Over A.A

22473100 22365881

107219 0.48

23000000 22365881

634119

GRAND TOTAL A+B: - 22473135 22365881 22614397 22851243

ADD: CONTIGENCY (LUM-SUM)

The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS AM & MJ BUILDERS Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" @ Rs. 7.50% Above (Rupees Seven Point Fifty Percent Above) PART "B" @ Rs. 16% Above (Rupees Sixteen Percent Above)


p.

FINANCIAL REVIEW / COMPARATIVE STATEML

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM THICKRATHO ROAD TO GHATTI MILE 0/0-2/1.

SR NO


PART "A" (ROAD WORK

1 AmountofSchedule"B" 21035755 21035755 21035755 21035755

2 Add: 8% Above (+) 1682860 7.50% Above (+) I 1577682 8.63% Above (+i 1815386 9.7 1% Above (+) 2042572

3 Ded: Diff Cost of Bitumen 1357490 1357490 1357490 1357490

PART "A" 21361125 21255947 21493651 21720837 PART "B" (6' SPAN CULVERTS

1 Amount of Schedule "B" 159473 159473 159473 159473

2 Permium -- 16% Above (+) 25516 17.13% Above (+) 27318 18.14% Above (+) 28928

3 Add: Cartage of Material (+) 25862

PART "B" 185335 184989 186791 188401 = 1112010 x 6 = 1109934 x 6 = 1120746 x 6 = 1130406

(ABDUL ASCI5ri' F,.

CG ROJR1

(WAHEED BUX QASMI)' ASS!TANT GiNEER

HG}aYAYS SUB-DVlSlON f'i 0 ii

a%iiLJi2-

EXECCTV GHWAY$ DMSIOPI

SLIKKUR

QTJXaIF'IGA'rIQJ EO'I'

TENDER REFERENCE NO. N.I.T No. EE/HW.D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017


NAME OF WORK CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM THICKRATHO ROAD TO GRATTI MILE 0/0-2/1.

NAME OF FIRM! BIDDERS N.T.N REGISTRATION WITH F.E.0

SINDH BOARIJ OF REVENUE

RELEVANT EXPERIENCE

TURNOVER OF AT LEAST LAST THREE YEARS

FUNDS/ BUDGET EST

MONEY

TENDER FEEl COST BIDDING

DOCUMENT

I M/S AM & MJ BUILDERS Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH CONSTT: & Co.

Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

3 MIS MANZOOR AHMED & BROTHERS Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHIEDSHAIKH) EXECUTW ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

(WAHEEDBUX QA%MI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


(ABDUL-I4AWEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENOG: SUB-DWISION ROHRI


NAME OF WORK: - REHABILITATION & RESTORATION OF HIGH COURT ROAD.

EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR HELD ON 22. 12.2017

SR. NO.


1

2

M/S NEW ROYAL ENTERPRISES

M/S THE TEAM

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHME9SfiAIKH) EXECUTIV1NGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAFEEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER


S B I D EL&L LLQJLR E P 0 R T


2 Tender Reference No. N.l.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item REHABILITATION & RESTORATION OF HIGH COURT ROAD.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awanii Awaz Karachi Dated. 07. 12.2017

(ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017




8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Aoolicable)

--


01 No.






I MIS NEW ROYAL ENTERPRISES

9605144 i Lowest 189856 Accepted Being Lowest

2 MIS THE TEAM 9675088 2 Higher 119912 Rejected Being Higher


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEDHIKH) EXECUTIVE2tGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(ABDUL HAFljAIEMON1 ASSISTANT t1iEER


(WAHEED BUX QIf111r ASSISTANT ENGINEER


M/S NEW ROYAL ENTERPRISES ESTIMATE

RATE ir AMOUNT

SR NO

DESCRIPTION

(ABD(JL HA ''Z N) ASSISTi't1Y

PUBUCHF:: H OH Ifl

'(WAHEED BUX ASSISrANi ENGINEER

H(GNWA1 D)VISLON

FJNANCIALRAWLEW/COMFARATIVESThTEMNT

NAME OF WORK: - REHABILITATION & RESTORATION OF HIGH COURT ROAD.

MIS THE TEAM

RATE AMOUNT

PART "A" (ROAD WORK 1 Amount of Schedule "13" 7163644 7163644 7163644

2 Add: 14% Above on Except Item No. 06 on Rs. 4348236/-

608753 Add: 13.50% Above on Except Item No. 06 on Rs. 4348236/-

587012 Add: 14.30% Above on Except Item No. 06 on Rs. 4348236/-

621798

Add: 20% Above on Asphalt Concrete Only on Rs. 26723 13/- • ) 534463

Add: 19.50% Above on Asphalt Concrete Only on Rs. 2672313/-

521101 Add: 20.10% Above on Asphalt Concrete Only on Rs. 2672313/-

537135

4 Ded: Duff Cost of Bitumen (-) 693792 693792 693792 TOTAL: A 7613068 7577965 7628785

PART "B" (MASONARY STRUCTURE I Amount of Schedule "B" 1912433 1912433 1912433 2 Permium (-) 6% Above (+) 114746 7% Above (+) 133870 3 Add: Cartage of Material (4) 125991

TOTAL: B 2038424 2027179 2046303

GRAND TOTAL A+B: - 9651492 9605144 9675088


The Lowest Rates Qouted By M/S NEW ROYAL ENTERPRISES Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" (l)@ Rs.13.50% Above on Except Item No. 06 on Rs. 4348236/-PART "A" (II) 6 Rs. 19.50% Above on Asphalt Concrete Only on Rs. 26723 13/-PART "B" @ Rs. 6% Above (Rupees Six Percent Above)



Saving (A~B) 189856 Percentage Saving 1.94



EXECUTIVE_SN'GiNEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

ti



NAME OF WORK REHABILITATION & RESTORATION OF HIGH COURT ROAD.

SR. NO.



RELEVANT EXPERIENCE

TURNOVER OF AT LEAST LAST

FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST

TENDER FEE! COST BIDDING

THREE YEARS MONEY DOCUMENT

I

I M/S NEW ROYAL. ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS THE TEAM \.wlable Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHMD..8ffAIKH) (WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAFEE MEMON) EXECUTIVENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG SUB-DIVISION

SUKKUR ROHRI ROHRI


NAME OF WORK: - IMPR:/ RECDG: OF ROAD & PAVER BLOCK ROAD OF ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO ABDUL KAREEM LUND MOULA ABAD MILE 0/0-1/4 (2.40 KM).


SR. NO.


1 M/S BAHADUR ALl SHAIKH _'-)- ___ BAHADUR ALl $AkH i.GOVT:CONTRAtU*IIcH

GUVLuNIRACTOR

2 M/S LAL KHAN BUG HTI & BROTHERS

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMW SHAIKH) EXECUTIWENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT EJEER


\\\

(ABDUL HAFEEZ M,'MON)

(WAHEED BUX4ASMI) ASSISTM(T ENGINEER


JD E V Ui T INE_P.QI


2 Tender Reference No. N.1.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work! Item IMPR:/ RECDG: OF ROAD & PAVER BLOCK ROAD OF ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO ABDUL KAREEM LUND MOULA ABAD MILE 0/0-1/4 (2.40 KM).


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07. 12.2017

(Ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07. 12.2017 (lii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017


6 Total Document Sold 03 Nos. 7 Total Bids Received 03 Nos. 8 Technical Bid Opening Date

(If Applicable) --


01 No.




COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASONS FOR SR 4# NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER OFFERED BY TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATE ACCEPTANCE! REMARKS


I M/S BAHADUR AL! SHAIKH 19468469 in Lowest 207531 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S LAL KHAN BUGHTI & BROTHERS

19579122 2 Higher 96878 Rejected Being Higher


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEJ>1IAIKH) EXECUTIVE-GINEER


MEM BER MEMBER

(ABDUL HA EZ EMON) ASSISTANT GINE

PUBLIC HEALTH - : SUB-DIVISION ROHRI

'MIS HAIJADtJR ALl -aTAIKU

RATE II AMOUNT

M/S LAL K}1AN BUGHTI & BROTHERS

RATE AMOUNT

SR NO


PART 'C" 646309 643440 647330

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C: - 19553954 19468469 19579122


The Lowest Rates 'outed By M/S BAHADUR ALl SHAIKE Government Contractor are:-

PART "A' u Rs, 13.60% Above (Rupees Thirteen Point Sixty Percent Above) PART "B' o R,s. 3.70% Above (Rupees Three Point Seventy Percent Above) PART "C" i Rs. I 5,80% Above (Rupees Fifteen Point Eighty Percent Above)

Lowest Ratesar( Recommended for Approval


Saving (A+ B) Percentage Saving


Saving Over A.A

19676000 19468469

207331 1.05

20000000 19468469

531531

NC1ALRE1VIEW / COMPARATIVE S TEMN

NAME OF WORK: - IMPR:/ RECDG: OF ROAD & PAVER BLOCK ROAD OF ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO ABDUL KAREEM LUND MOULA ABAD MILE 0/0-1/4 (2.40 KM).

PART "A" ROAD WORK)

1 Amount of' Schedule "B" 14170383 14170383 14170383

2 Add: 14% Above (1 1983854 13.60% Above (1 1927172 14.10% Above (~) 1998024

3 Ded: Duff Cost of Bitumen (-') 1410221 1410221 1410221 PART A" 14744016 14687334 14758186

PART B (PAVER BLOCK)

I Amount of Schedule "B" 3990063 3990063 3990063

2 Ded: 20% I3rlow (on Paver Block Onlyon Rs.3164356/-)

632871 3.70% Above (+) 147632 4,60% Above (+) 183543

3 Add: Cartage of Material (+) 806437 PART "B" 4163629 4137695 4173606

PART "C" (DRAINAGE

1 Amount of Schedule "B" 555648 555648 555648

2 Permium -- 15.80% Above (+) 87792 16.50% Above (-') 91682


(ABDUI-HAd ( 'HEED ASSISTAN ENGINEER

PUBUC HE&LTh EiiU. '

RO HR

', HlGHWAYDlVIs;oN SUKKUR

ThE A S SI S TA N

HIGHWAYS RC,i

xIcA'JxoN S TENDER REFERENCE NO. N.I.T No. EE/ HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017


NAME OF WORK IMPR:/ RECDG: OF ROAD & PAVER BLOCK ROAD OF ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO ABDUL

KAREEM LUND MOULA ABAD MILE 0/0-1/4 (2.40 KM).

SR. NO.

NAME OF FIRM! BIDDERS N.T.N REGISTRATION


RELEVANT EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST

MONEY


DOCUMENT

1 MIS BAlIADUR ALl Sl-IAIKH Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available l)eposited

2 MIS LAL KI-IAN BUGHTI & BROTHERS Available Registered Registered Availabk Available Available Available Deposited

CHAIRMAN

MEMBER MEMBER

(ABDUL EMONV ASSISTANT NGINE1(

PUBLIC HEALTH ENp9-SUB-DIVISION ROFJ

(RAFIQUE AHM SHAIKH) EXECUTWENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER



NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS VILLAGE FATEH MOHAMMAD NOONARI (REMAINING WORKS).

EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR HELD ON

22.12.2017

SR. NO.


I M/SGHULAMMURTAZAOHUMRO

2 '1/S JAVED AKHTAR IKElUl-IAWEP

is

3 MIS MOLE DINO CHACHAR

tijS HACHAR GS(T INTRACTOR

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMESHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR MEMBER MEMBER



(ABDUL HAFEEZ;MEMON) ASSISTANT IGINEER


BLPEYALUXLQjLLLEQRI


2 Tender Reference No. N.1.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17

S Tender Description/ Name of Work! Item CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS (i VILLAGE FATEH MOHAMMAD NOONARI (REMAINING WORKS).

4 Method of Pro'uremen Single Stage (By Competitive Rate/ Bid)

Tender Published Published in (i)Dally Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17

(ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07. 12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17




S Technical Bid Opening Date (If Anplicablel

--


01 No.




COST 1 RANKING IN COMPARISÔN1 REASONS FOR

SR # NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER OFFERED BY TERMS OF WITH ACCEPTANCE! REMARKS

THE BIDDER COST ESTIMATE REJECTION

___ COST

I M/S GHULAM MURTAZA GHUMRO

4822943 i' Lowest 168094 Accepted Being 1..owest

2 MIS JAVED AKHTAF KHUHAWER


S M/S MOLE DINO CHACHAR 5022681 3' Highest -31644 Rejected Being Highest

SIGNATURE OF THE TENDBRING COMMITTEE.

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMJSHAIKH) EXECUTIVEENGINEER

HIGHWAYS DIV'SION SUKKUP

MEMBER MEMBER



(ABDUL HA' Df )fEJVIONJ ASSISTANT EJG1NEER


NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS & VILLAGE FATEH MOHAMMAD NOONARI (REMAINING WORKS).

DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE XMtINT RATE r AMOUNT 1 RATE

5022681 4893604 4822943 4993452 GRAND TOTAL A, B, C: -

FINACJAL REVIEW / COMPARATIVE STATEMNT

PART A" (ROAD WORK

1 AmountofSchedule B 4871660 4871660 4871660 4871660

2 Ded: 20% Below (on Paver Block Only) n Rs. 4033756/.

806751 1% Below(-) 48717 2.50% Above () 121792 3.10% Above (+) 151021


I'hc Lowest Rates Qouted 13v MIS GHULAM MURTAZA GHUMRO Government Contractor are:-

1'ART "A" Rs. 1% 13c1ow (Rupees One Percent Below)

Lowest Rates are Recommended for Ap'roval

EXECUTIVEEGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

DIJLHAF :ASSISTANT E' EER PUBLIC HEALTH ENOG: SUBDIVISIO - ROHRI

(WAH)ED 6X ASMI) ASSISTANT EG1NEER GHWAYS SUB.D)VtSOt4

ROHRI

M/S GHULAM MURTAZA GBUMRO

_ir

MIS JAVED AKETAR KHUHAWER 1 M/S MOLE DINO CHACHAR

RATE j AMOUNT

ADD: CONTIGENCY (LUM.sUM) 97433

4991037 4822943

168094 3.37

5000000 4822943

177057

(A) Total Cost as l)C Estimate (B) Total as per Tender

Saving (MB) Percentage Saving


Saving Over A.A

S TENDER REFERENCE NO. N.I.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04. 12.2017


NAME OF WORK CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS a VILLAGE FATEH MOHAMMAD NOONARI (REMAINING WORKS).

SR. NO.


WITH PE.0 SINDH BOARD OF REVENUE

RELEVANT EXPERIENCE

TURNOVER 0F AT LEAST LAST

FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST



1 M/S CHULAM MURTAZA GHUMRO Available Registered Registered Available Available .\aihible Available Deposited

2 MIS JAVEI) AKHTAR KHUHAWEW Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

3 M/S MOLE DINO CHACHAR Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHIjSHAIKH) (WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAF MEMON) EXECUTIVENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENGSUB-DIVISION

SUKKUR ROHRI ROHRI

0 ATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD 100 FT SOCIETY ROAD TO AHSAN LASHARI HOUSE MILE 0/0-0/3+ 160'.



SR. NO.

I M/S JAN MUHAMMAD & BROTHERS /

'S

UFI'

-.ovf_ onLaclor-'

2 M/S S.A MUNAM ENTERPRISES

3 M/S RAVI KUMAR ENTERPRISES

Mis RavIfflar Enterprises Govt: Contractor

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMWSHAIKH) EXECUTIWNGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

\;— (WAHEED BUC QASMI) (ABDUL HAFEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER


J Name of Procuring Agency Executive Engineer Highways Division Sukkur

2 Tender Reference No. Nil' No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work! Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD 100 FT SOCIETY ROAD TO AHSAN LASHARI HOUSE MILE 0/0-0/3+160.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17

(ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (jill Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17




8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Anolicable)

--


01 No.






1 M/S JAN MUHAMMAD & BROTHERS




3 MIS RAVI KUMAR ENTERPRISES

5023312 3' Highct •2M312 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED S KH) EXECUTIVE NEER

HIGHWAY DIVISION SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

JI1; (ABDUL HAFEE MEIYIONf

ASSISTANT ENGINEER PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB-DIVISION

ROFIRI



GRAND TOTAL A, B: - 4969840 4930595 5000746 5023312


The Lowesm Raus Qouted By M/S JAN MUHAMMAD & BROTHERS Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" (iJ Rs. 7.20% Above (Rupees Seven Point Twenty Percent Above)

Lowest Rates are Recommended for Apprtal

(A) Total Cost as ptr Estimate (B) Total as per Tender



Saving Over A.A

4995000 4930595

64405 1.29

5000000 4930595

69405

0 FINA'CIAL REVIEW / COMPARATIVE STATEMNT

SK-034 NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD 100 FT SOCIETY ROAD TO AHSAN LASHARI HOUSE MILE 0/0-0/3~160.

SRDESCRIPTION ESTIMATE

-

M/S JAN MUHAMMAD & BROTHERS

-

M/ S.A MUNAM ENTERPRISES 1 M/S RAVI KUMAR ENTERPRiSES

RATE AMOUNT [] RATE AMOUNT RATE AMOUNT

PART "A" (ROAD WORK

1 Amount of Schedule '13" 4905629 4905629 4905629 4905629

2 Add: 8 % Above (+) 392450 7.20% Above (lj 353205 8.63% Above (+) 423356 9.09% Above (+) 445922

3 Ded: Dill Cost of Bitumen (-) 328239 328239 328239 328239

(ABDUL HAFLI ASSISTANT E I -.

PUBLIC HEALThE ROi.Rj SUB.o,v,s1011

0 BUX QAsMI)! ASSTANT ENGINEER

H c;h\AYS SUB-DIVISION

M ER


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

AIor

N.I.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17


CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD 100 FT SOCIETY ROAD TO AHSAN LASHARI HOUSE MILE 0/0-

0/3+160'.

SR. NO.]

NAME OF FIRMI BIDDERS N.T.N REGISTRATION


RELEVANT EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST

MONEY

TENDER COST BIDDING

DOCUMENT

I M/S .IAN MUHAMMAD & BROTHERS Available Registered Ristered Available Available Available Available l);!

2 MIS S.,\ MUNAM ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposi:1

3 MIS RAVI KUMAR ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(ABDUL HAFI MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


(RAFIQUE AHMEDfi!AIKH) EXECUTIVE1HNEER HIGHWA' DIVISION

SUKKUR



• ATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN


NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD APPROACH TO PRE-STRESSED - BRIDGE RAZA GOTH MILE 0/0-0/2 TALUKA PANOAKIL


SR. NO.


I MIS SAAD KHOKHAR ENTERPRISES

/

1 7/ ie_ -,

2 M/SYAKOOB BROTHERS

3 M/S ROHRI CONSTRUCTION CO

c*

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEfrSHAIKH) EXECUTIVE-INGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION


I'

(WAHEED BUC QASMI) (ABDUL HAP Z MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB-DIVISION ROHRI ROHIU


2 Tender Reference No. N.I.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04. 12.2017

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD APPROACH TO PRE-STRESSED BRIDGE RAZA GOTH MILE 0/0-0/2 TALUKA PANOAKIL


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awaini Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.2017





--

9 No of Bid Technicall' Qualified (If Applicable)

01 No.

10 Bids Rejecte 02 Nos.





1 M/S SAAD KHOKIIAR ENTERPRISES


2 M/S YAKOOB BROTHERS 9830976 2' Higher 109024 Rejected Being Higher

3 M/S ROHRI CONSTRUCTION CO

9898484 3id Highest 41516 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEDSHAIKH) EXECUTWE ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS DWISION SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX ASMI) (ABDUL HAFEEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DWISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB-DWISION ROHRI ROHRI




Saving Over A.A

9940000 9763468

176532 1.78

10000000 9763468

236532

PART "C" 195868 194633 196356 198078 x2 = 391736 x 2 389266 x 2 392712 x 2 396156

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C: - 9814929 9763468 9830976 9898484


The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS SAAED KHOKHAR ENTERPRISES. Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" Rs. 7.70% Above (Rupees Seven Point Seventy Percent Above) PART "B" Rs. 38% Above (Rupees Thirty Eight Percent Above) PART "C" @ Rs. 13% Above (Rupees Thirteen Percent Above)


J'I*ANCIAL REVIEW / COMPARATIVE S4FATEMNT

A NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD APPROACH TO PRE-STRESSED BRIDGE RAZA GOTH MILE 0/0-0/2 TALUKA

PANOAKIL

S

SR NO

DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE MIS SAAD KHOKHAR ENTERPRISES

_______ M/S YAKOOB BROTHERS M/S RORRI CONST1UCTION Co

RATE j AMOUNT [] RATE AMOUNT J__RATE AMOUNT

PART "A" (ROAD WORK

1 AmountofSchedule"B" 6246111 6246111 6246111 6246111

2 Add: 8% Above (+) 499689 7.70% Above (+) 480951 8.40% Above (+) 524673 9.10% Above (+) 568396

3 Ded: Diff Cost of Bitumen (-) 159824 159824 159824 159824

PART 'A' 6585976 6567238 6610960 6654683 PART "B" (STONE PITCHING

1 Amount of Schedule "B 2034032 2034032 2034032 2034032

2 Perrojum -- 38% Above (1-) 772932 39% Above (+) 793272 40°A Above (+) 813613


PART "B" 2837217 2806964 2827304 2847645 PART "B" (3' SPAN CULVERTS

1 Amount of Schedule "B" 172242 172242 172242 172242 2 Permium -- 13% Above (+) 22391 14% Above (+) 24114 15% Above (+) 25836 3 Add: Cartage of Material (+) 23626

(WAHtEL' • SM() ASSISTANI LNGlNEER

1-i IGHVAYS S1JE3-DlVISl0rI RORRI

(ABD(L F!,r.:,E'ON) ASS(STA. EGiflEER

PUBLIC iEAL1 EiG3: SUDVSlO • 4--- ROHRI

EXEcVJt!NEER HHWA'Y. I.MVSIONJ

TENDER REFERENCE NO. N.I.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017


NAME OF WORK CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD APPROACH TO PRE-STRESSED BRIDGE RAZA GOTH MILE 0/0-0/2 TALUKA PANOAKIL



RELEVANT EXPERIENCE


FUNDS! BUDGET

05% EARNEST



1 M/S SAAD KHOKHAR ENTERPRISES :\vadable Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS YAKOOB BROTHERS Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

3 M/S ROHRI CONSTRUCTION CO Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


S

(RAFIQUE AHM SHAIKH) (WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAZ MEMON) EXECUTWEENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB-DIVISION

SUKKUR ROHRI ROHRI


NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM ARIF KHAN TO VILLAGE SHER MUHAMMAD KHOKHAR MILE 0/0-0/7.


SR. NO.


1 M/S MAHTAM ENTERPRISES

2 M/S MUHAMMAD MALOOI< KATO

/

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AH)YSHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED B QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


(

(ABDUL HAF Z MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER




3 Tender Description! Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM ARIF KHAN TO VILLAGE SHER MUHAMMAD KHOKHAR MILE 0/0-0/7.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17 (ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07A22017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017





--


01 No.


11 Financial Bid Opening Date 22. 12.2017





9335052 is Lowest 146804 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S MUHAMMAD MALOOK KATO

9392445 2" Higher 894 II Rejected Being Higher


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHJDs1AIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAFZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ErG1NEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH EPG: SUB-DIVISION ROHRI ROHRI

MIS MAHTAM ENTERPRISES

RATE AMOUNT JT

AMOUNT

MIS MUHAMMAD MALOOK KATO SR NO

DESCRIPTION ESTZMATE RATE

(A) Total Cost as per Estim.i1' (B) Total as per Tender

Saving (A 131 Percentage Saving


Saving Over &A

9481856 9335052

146804 1.55

9500000 9335052

164948

PART "B 202703 201523 203246 Therefor 4 x 810812 x 4 806092 x 4 812984

GRAND TOTAL A+B 9381856 9335052 9392445


The Lowest Raws Qouted By M/S MAHTAM ENTERPRISES Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" (i Rs. 7.50°k Above (Rupees Seven Point Fifty Percent Above) PART "B" à Rs. 17% Above (Rupees Seventeen Percent Above)


ON

B-DIVIjÔ

!WA1WflBUX QASMI)1 ASSISTANT ENGINEER

i-HG HWAYS SUB-DIVISIO R OH RI

A 's TA NT PUBLIG HEALT

NANJL UOMPARA1WTAIFJL Ir

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM ARIF KHAN TO VILLAGE SHER MUHAMMAD KHOKHAR MILE O/OO/7.

PART 'A" (ROAD WORK

I Amount of Schedule "B' 8416739 8416739 8416739

2 Add: 8 % Above () 573339 7.50% Above (j 631255 8.10% Above (4) 681756

3 Ded: Duff Cost of Bitumen F) 519034 519034 519034

PART "A" 8571044 8528960 8579461

PART "B (3 SPAN CULVERTS

I AmountofSchedule"B" 172242 172242 - 172242

2 Premium - 17% Above (+) 29281 18% Abovo 31004

3 Cartage of Material (+) 30461

EXECUTIVE ENe1, GI-(WAYS DIvso


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK



CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM ARIF KHAN TO VILLAGE SHER MUHAMMAD KHOKHAR MILE 0/0-

0/7.

SR. NAME OF FIRM! BIDDERS N.T.N

REGISTRATION SINDU BOARD RELEVANT TURNOVER OF AT LEAST LAST

FUNDS! 05%

EARNEST TENDER FEEl COST BIDDING

NO. WITH P.E.0 OF E.EVENUE EXPERIENCE THREE YEARS

BUDGET MONEY DOCUMENT

I MIS MAHTAM ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS MUHAMMAD MALOOK KATO Available Registered Rstered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(WAHEED flUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGI NEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-D I VISION RO H Ri

(RAFIQUE AHME$HIKHJ EXECUTIVEGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SIJKKUR



SATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM GULAN SHAH TO GUDPUR ROAD AT VILLAGE GUDPUR MILE 0/0-0/6+330.


rsn. NAME OF CONTRACTOR SIGNATURE

1 M/S AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH CONS'fl': & Co.

AL.MUZA CONSTRUTION & CO:

GOVT:CONTICTOR Prop Mad Alt

2 M/SNAJAFENTERPRISES

3 M/S SAAD KHOKHAR ENTERPRISES

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEIISHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAF MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER


r Name of Procuring Agency Executive Engineer Highways Division Sukkur


3 Tender Description! Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM GULAN SHAH TO GUDPUR ROAD AT VILLAGE GIJDPUR MILE 0/0-0/6 + 330.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017

(ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17




8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If ADplicable)

--


01 No.






1 M/S ALMUZAMIL SHAIKH CONSTF: & CO.


2 M/S NAJAF ENTERPRISES 9758791 2nd Higher 128310 Rejected Being Higher


9827228 3rd Highest 59873 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED .HAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER


HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION ROH RI



PART "C" 542920 540446 544252 548058

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C: - 9827228 9657365 9758791 9722134

ADD: ONTIGENCY (LUM-SUM) 164967

(AB0ULj : ASS aNGINER

P1iC 3•DJYISION R OH RI

(WAHEED BU)1 ASMI) ASSISTANT EUGINEER

HIGHA'S 5U3-DlVlSiON "1

I'. L' ,t\

HGHAyS DMSIO

The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKE CONSTT: & CO. Government Contractor arc:-

PART "A" ( Rs. 7.30% Above (Rupees Seven Point Thirty Percent Above) PART "B" Rs. 14% Above (Rupees Fourteen Percent Above) PART "C' @ Rs. 42% Above (Rupees Forty Two Percent Above)




A.A Amount Lowest Tendef Amount

Saving Over A.A

9887101 •9657365

229736 2.32

10000000 9657365 342635

FINANCIAL REWE%* / COMPARATIVE STATEMNL SK-047

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM GULAN SHAH TO GUDPUR ROAD AT VILLAGE GUDPUR MILE 0/0-0/6+330'.

SR NO

DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE M/S AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH CONSTT: & CO.

M/S NAJAF ENTERPRISES MIS SAAD ENTERPRISES

KHOKHAR

RATE AMOUNT RATE ] AMOUNT [] RATE AMOUNT

PART "A" (ROAD WORK


2 Add: 8% Above 659872 7.30% Above (+) 602133 8.40% Above (+) 692865 9.10% Above(+) 750604

3 Ded: Duff Cost of Bitumen 519034 519034 519034 519034

PART "A 8389234 8331495 8422227 8479966 PART "B" (3' SPAN CULVERTS

I Amount of Schedule "B" 172242 172242 172242 172242

2 Permium -- 14% Above (+) 24114 15% Above (+) 25836 16% Above (+) 27559


PART "B" 197495 196356 198078 199801 x4 = 789980 x 4 = 785424 x 4 792312 x4 799204

PART "B" (STONE PITCHI1JG 1 Amount of Schedule "B" 380596 380596 380596 380596 2 Fermium -- 42% Above (+) 159850 43% Above (+) 163656 44% Above (+) 167462 3 Add: Cartage of Material (+) 162324


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

S QALI'ICA'rIWJ



CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM GULAN SHAH TO GUDPUR ROAD AT VILLAGE GUDPUR MILE 0/0-

0/6+330.

SR. F REGIS'RATION SINDH BOARD RELEVANT TURNOVE OF

FUNDS! 05% TENDER FEE!

NO. NAME OF FIRM! BIDDERS N.T.N

WITH P.E.0 OF REVENUE EXPERIENCE AT LEAST AST

BUDGET EARNEST COST BIDDING


I MIS AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH CONSTT: &

-Co.


2 MIS NAJAF ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

3 M/S SAAD KHOKHAR ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHM IKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

(WAHEED BUX/QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


'in (ABDUL HAFBZ MEMON)


ROHRI


NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS AT PUNHAL KHOSO (KHOSA MUHALLA) AND LAGHARI MUHALLA VILLAGE DREHA (REMAINING WORK).


SR. NO.


1 M/S SAQIB RASHEED & Co

t SAQ EED & CO Pr.4

2 M/S ALl BUILDERS


J/S JAN !UH t' .' NAREJO Gove rm •rttractor

op etor

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AH3E SHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(ABDUL HAPLZAEMON ASSISTAN GINEER




I-

&

J_QEVALjLLLQN REPORT SK-030



3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS AT PUNHAL KHOSO (KHOSA MUHALLA) AND LAGHARI MUHALLA VILLAGE DREHA EREMAININf WORICL

4 Method of Procurement Single Stage (By Compeiitive Rate! Bid)

5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017





8 Technical Bid Opening Date (Ii Aoølicablel

--


01 No.




NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER COST


COMPARISON WITH

REASONS FOR ACCEPTANCE/ REMARKS

THE BIDDER COST ESTIMATE REJECTION COST

1 M/S SAQIB RASHEED & CO

4848688 ls Lowest 119878 Accepted Being Lowest

2 MIS AL! BUILDERS 4990682 2"' Higher -22116 Rejected Being Higher


5087561 3d Highest -fl8995 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

(R.AFIQUE AHM1PSHAIKH) EXECUTINGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGIWEER


(ABDUL HA'EZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENft1NER—

PUBLIC HEALTH ENlbB-DIVISION ROHRI

(A) Total Cost as per Estimate (B) Total as per Tendcr



Saving Over A.A

4968566 4848688

119878 2.41

5000000 4848688

151312

[AIAL_IEV1EW /SOMABATJVE STATEMNI SK-030

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS AT PUNHAL KHOSO (KHOSA MUHALLA) AND LAGHARI MUHALLA VILLAGE DREHA (REMAINING WORK).

M/S JAN MUHAMMAD NAREJO SR NO

DESCRIPTION

ESTIMATE SAQIB RASHEED & CO

MIS ALl BUILDERS

RATE AMOUNT

RATE

AMOUNT

RATE AMOUNT

PART "A" ROAD WORK


2 Ded: 20% Below (on Paver Block Only) it Rs. 3424058/-

684812 2.10% Above (+) 99728 5.09% Above () 241722 7.13% Above (+) 338601


GRAND TOTAL A: - 4873587 4848688 4990682 5087561


94979

The Lowest Rates Qouted By M/S SAQIB RASHEED & CO Government Contractor are:-

FART "A Rs. 2.10% Above (Rupees Two Point Ten Fercent Above)


(ABDUL HI MON) ASSISTANT ENINE -

PUBLIC HEALTH EUGG. :.,IVISION ROH

I- •.'

AH1ED I3UX Q.SM) EXECUVEENIfEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER HIGHWY8bIVISION

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION SUKKUR ROHRL--


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

IE s_QTJ I IOJEø



CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING &. DRAINS AT PUNHAL KHOSO (KHOSA MUHALLA) AND LAGHARI MUHALLA VILLAGE DREHA (REMAINING WORK).

SR. NO.



RELEVANT EXPERIENCE

FTURNOVER OF AT LEAST LAST

FUNDS! BUDGET

O5Co EARNEST


I [IREE YEARS MONEY DOCUMENT

I M/S SAQII3 RASHEED & CO Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 M/S AL! BUILDERS Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

3 M/S JAN MIJHAMMAI) NAREJO Available Registered Registiied Available Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHM3.DAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR



(ABDUL RAf'±Z !MON) ASSISTANT ENØINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH EN(: SUB-DIVISION ROI(RI _—

S ATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - IMPR:/ RECDG: OF ROAD HAJI JADAL MAHAR MILE 0/0-0/5 UC TAMACHANI.


ri NAME OF CONTRACTOR SIGNATURE

1 M/SRH&BROTHERSCOMPANY

i ircth ; itop: Rashid Htissaiii

Govt: Coutrictor

2 M/S GHULAM MUSTAFA WASSAN

3 M/S KHALID AHMED I<HAN

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED$HAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

11 (WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAFEEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT. ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB-DIVISION ROHRJ ROHRI

ID EVALUTION REPORT

1 Name of Procuring Agency Executive Engineer Highways Division Sukku

2 Tender Reference No. N.I.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2(

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work! Item IMPR:/ RECDG: OF ROAD a HAJI JADA MILE 0/0-0/5 UC TAMACHANI.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. O

(ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17 (iv) Daily Sobh Kar 07.12.2017




8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Atrnlicable)

--


01 No.




COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASONS FOR SR # NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER OFFERED BY TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATE ACCEPTANCE/


1 M/S RH & BROTHERS COMPANY

5882504 Lowest 102496 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S GHULAM MUSTAFA WASSAN

5939180 21u Higher 45820 Rejected Being Higher

3 M/S KHALID AHMED KHAN 5995039 3 Highest -10039 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

-

(RAFIQUE AHMEDWAIKH) EXECUTIVE?(1INEER

HIGHWAY DIVISION SUKKUR

MEMBER

/

(WAHEE'1IUX c'ASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


MEMBER

(ABDUL HAFEEZMEMON) ASSISTAr9-ENGINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB-DIVISI ROHRI




Saving Over A.A

5985000 5882504

102496 1.71

6000000 5882504

117496

605 191034 191550

GRAND TOTAL A, B: - 5930443 5882504 5939180 5995039 ADD: CONTIGENCY (LUM-SUM) 54794

The Lowest Rates Qouted By M/S RH & BROTHERS COMPANY Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" Rs. 13.15% Above (Rupees Thirteen Point Fifteen Percent Above) PART "B" @ Rs. 9.50% Above (Rupees Nine Point Fifty Percent Above)


(ABDUL HAF ASSISTANT EN

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG. B.DIVISIO ROHRI

I(WAHt 'BUXQ; ' I ASSL ..'T ENGIN IjIGH WAYS SUB-DIVL.

• ROI-IRL.-

MO R

FINAKCIALBVIEW / COMPARATIVE STATEMNT

SK-006 - NAME OF WORK: - IMPR:/ RECDG: OF ROAD ® HAJI JADAL MAHAR MILE 0/0-0/5 UC TAMACHANI.

SR DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE NO

MIS RH S. BROTHERS COMPANY - M/S GHULAM MUSTAFA WASSAN []M/S KHALID AHMED KHAN

j RATE AMOUNT RATE AMOUNT [] RATE AMOUNT

1 Amount of Schedule "B" 5479494 5479494 5479494 5479494 2 Add: 14% Above () 767129 13.15% Above (+) 720553 14.14% Above (+) 774800 15.15% Above 830143 3 Ded:DiffCostofBitumen (-) 506148 506148 506148 506148

5748146 5803489 PART "B (3 SPAN CULVERTS

1 Amount of Schedule "B" 172242 172242 172242 172242 2 Permium -- 9.50% Above (+) 16363 10.91% Above (+) 18792 11.2 1% Above (+) 19308 3 Add: Cartage of Material (+) 17726

EXECUTIVE ENNEER I-JIGHWAYS-t1VISlON,

• SUK cUR

TENDER REFERENCE NO. N.I.T No. EE/HW.D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17


NAME OF WORK IMPR:/ RECDG: OF ROAD a HAJI JADAL MAHAR MILE 0/0-0/5 UC TAMACHANI.

SR. NO.



RELEVANT EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST

MONEY


DOCUMENT

1 MIS RH & BROTHERS COMPANY Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS OHULAM MUSTAFA WASSAN Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

3 MIS KHALID AHMED KHAN Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


I

(RAFIQUE AHME8flAIKH) (WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAFE MEMON) EXECUTIVNGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENG: SUB-DIVISION

SUKKUR ROHRI ROHRI

ATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN • EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAIN SASTI BASTI NEAR CATTLE COLONY SUKKUR.


SR. NO.


I M/SAIJAZALI

MIS Aiaz A% Govt Contractor

2 M/S VEERU MAL ENTERPRISES

MIS Veerui Eoterrises

3 M/S AFTAB & BROTHERS CONSTI': Co

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEp-SHAIKH) EXECUTIVENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

i1 (WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAFEZMEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANTENGINEER


S ID EVALUTION REPORT

SK-017 1 Name of Procuring Agency Executive Engineer Highways Division Sukkur


3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAIN SASTI BASTI NEAR CATTLE COLONY SUKKUR.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)The Express Tribune Karachi Dated. 19.10.2017

(ii) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 19.10.2017 (iii) Daily Jang Karachi Dated. 20. 10.2017 (iv) Daily Nau Sijh Dated. 19.10.2017





--

9 No of Bid Technically Qua hued (If Applicable)

01 No.






COMPARISON WITH



COST ISAVINGI

1 M/S AIJAZ ALl 4834466 l Lowest 139798 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S VEERU MAL ENTERPRISES

4883719 2u111 Higher 90545 Rejected Being Higher

3 M/S AFTAB &. BROTHERS CONSTT: Co

4935363 3' Highest 38901 Rejected Being 1-lighest


CHAIRMAN

C, __ (RAFIQUE AHMEDI1KH)

EXECUTIVE EIGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

Pc' (WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAFEEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER


GRAND TOTAL A: - 4878627 4834466 4883719 4935363


The Lowest Rates Qouted By M/S AIJAZ ALt Government Contractor are:-

PART "A Rs. 1.10% Above (Rupees One Point Ten Percent Above)





Saving Over A.A

4974264 4834466

139798 2.81

5000000 4834466

165534

FINATLCIAL REVIEW /_c_QMARATIvE SThTEMNT.

NAME OF WORK: - SKO17I

CONSTRUCTION OF 1AVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAIN SASTI EAST! NEAR CATTLE COLONY SUKKUR.

SR NO

DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE M/S AIJAZ ALl ]

L MIS VEERU MAL ENTERPRISES MIS AFTAB & BROTHERS CONSTT:

CO

RATE -

AMOUNT RATE AMOUNT [11 RATE AMOUNT

PART A" (ROAD WORK

1 Amount of Schedule"13' 4781865 4781865 4781865 4781865

2 Dcd: 20% Below (on Paver Block Only) n Rs. 3505963/-

701192 1.10% Above (+) 52601 2.13% Above (+) 101854 3.21% Above (+) 153498


!ABDUL HAFEZION ASSISTANT ENGINEER

PUBL!C i1EAL' EGG: SW1.DIVISION IOHRI

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASS(STANT ENGNEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DlVlS)O R OH RI

EXECUTIVE EfitNER HIGHWAYS DV!S!ON

3UKKUR

S N.I.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017



NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAIN SASTI BASTI NEAR CATTLE COLONY SUKKUR.

--

- TURNOVER OF O5° TENDER FEE! R. 0.



RELEVANT EXPERIENCE]

AT LEAST LAST THREE YEARS

FUNDS / BUDGET

EARNEST MONEY

COST BIDDING DOCUMENT

S N

1 M/S AIJAZ ALl Available Registered Registered Available Available Avaihibic Available Deposited

2 M/S VEERU MAL ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available l)eposited

3 MIS AFIAB & BROTHERS CONSTr: CO



(RAFIQUE AHMED S EXECUTIVNINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

(WAHEED BUX (ASMI) ASSISTANT ENdINEER


(ABDULHAP3ME ON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGO: SUB-DIVISION ROIRI

• ATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN 4 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS @ BASHIRABAD UC TAMACHANI.


SR. NO.


1 M/S AGHA GUL HASSAN KHAN

ovt: Co an' * -

ractor

2 M/S ADEEL AHMED CONSTRUCTION COMPANY

3 M/SASIFALI

IYL!S LS F ALl

CHAIRMAN

p. (RAFIQUE AHME98FIAIKH)

EXECUTIGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAFEEZMEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER


jD LY.AJU LLQ±4. R T



3 Tender Description! Name of Work! Item CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS @ BASHIRABAD UC TAMACHANI.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awazni Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17

(ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 liii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017

SPPRA ID NO:2 147483647 S.No. 35535 Dated; 05-12-2017



8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If AplicabIe)

--


01 No.






1 MIS AGHA GUL HASSAN ((HAN


2 M/S ADEEL AHMED CONSTRUCTION COMPANY


3 M/S ASIF AL! 4940961 3 Highest -5961 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED$M1IKH) EXECUTIV)thNEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER

\4çC (WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


MEMBER

(ABDUL HAFE Z- IE1V1GN1 ASSISTANT EG1EER


(A) Total Cost as per Estimatc (B) Total as per Tender



Saving Over AA

4935000 4811246

123754 2.51

5000000 4811246

188754

(WAH EE UX'QMi' ASSISTANT ENG:NE"

HIGHWAYS tnv; k U;

EXEC UTIVE~1tER HIGHWAY IVISION

SUKKUR (ABOUL HAF

ASSISTANTE NEER PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB.D)VISIOH

ROHR

FINArCIAL fEVIEW / COMPARATIVJ STATEMNT

NAME OF WORE: - CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DBAINS BASHIRABAD UC TAMACHANI.

MIS AGHA GUL HASSAN KHAN M/S ADEEL AHMED CONSTRUCTION COMPANY SR

NO

M/S ASIF ALl

RATE AMOUNT DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE

RATE AMOUNT J RATE AMOUNT

PART "A" (ROAD WORK

I Amount of Schedule"B' 4716908 4716908 4716908 4716908

2 Ded: 20% Below (on Paver Block Only) n Rs. 353393 1/-

706786 2% Above (+) 94338 3.50% Above (+) 165092 4.75% Above (+) 224053

3 Add: Cartage of Material (4) 830830

GRAND TOTAL A, B, C:- 4840952 4811246 4882000 4940961


The Lowest Rates Qouted By M/S AGHA GUL HASSAN KHAN Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" Rs. 2% Above (Rupees Two Percent Above)


4.


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

x Q IXXCATION



CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS a BASHIRABAD UC TAMACHANI.

NO.

-



RELEVANT EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

O5 EARNEST


THREE YEARS MONEY DOCUMENT __ I - -,

1 MIS AGHA GUL HASSAN KHAN Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 M/S ADEEL AUMEI) CONSTRUCTION COMPANY


3 M/S ASIF ALl Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


/

(ABDUL HAFJ!.1EMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUBDWISION ROHRI

(RAFIQUE AHMED$&IKH) EXECUTIVE ItINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR



0 ATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS (à HAIDER SHAH MUHALLA VILLAGE GOSERJI UC TAMACHANI.


SR. NO.


1 M/SMAI-ITAM ENTERPRISES

M 1S iA cpg15E

GOVT; cOfACTA

2 M/SBEDILBECUS

M7s (Be i1(Becus çjovt: Contractor

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AH1jY SHAIKH) EXECUTIVENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

I

(WAHEE BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


(ABDUL HAEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


BID EVALTION REPQRI


2 Tender Reference No. N.I.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work! Item CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS i HAIDER SHAH MUHALLA VILLAGE GOSERJI UC TAMACHANI.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)The Express Tribune Karachi Dated. 19. 10.2017 (ii) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 19.10.2017 (iii) Daily Jang Karachi Dated. 20.10.2017 (iv) Daily Nau Sijh Dated. 19.10.2017




8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If ADolicable)

--


01 No.







4875271 l Lowest 118729 Accepted Being Lowest

2 MIS BEDIL BECUS 4926393 2 Higher 67607 Rejected Being Higher I


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEDAIKH) EXECUTIVE1(INEER


MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX 'ASMI) ASSISTANT EGINEER


MEMBER

(ABDUL HA'FEZ MEMQ ASSISTANT DINtER


SR NO

DESCRIPTION

ESTIMATE

M/S MAHTAM ENTERPRISES MIS BEDIL BECUS

RATE AMOUNT RATE ir AMOUNT




Saving Over A.A

4994000 4875271

118729 2.38

5000000 4875271

124729

GRAND TOTAL A, B, C: - 4900623 4875271 4926393


The Lowest Rates Qouted By M/SMAHTAM ENTERPRISES Government Contractor are:-

Part A' l Rs. 4.90% Above (Rupees Four Point Ninety Percent Above)

Lowest Rates arc Recommended for Approval

IABOULHA Z Ms F ASSISTANT E ; - ER PUBUC HEALTH EN : SUB•DIVISIO

ROHRI

ASSISTANT ENGINEER HH WAYS SUBDI VISION

ROHRI

FINANLL_REVIEW / COMPARATIVE STATJVINL

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS a HAIDER SHAH MUHALLA VILLAGE

GOSERJI UC TAMACHANI.

I Amount of Schedule"B" 4647541 4647541 4647541

2 Ded: 20% Below (on Paver Block Only) n

Rs.3238671/- 647734 4.90% Above (+) 227730 6% Above (~) 278852


HIGH WA?S DIVISION SUKKUR


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

Oil XX XQ?

N.I.T No. EE/HW-DfTC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17


CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS a HAIDER SHAH MUHALLA VILLAGE GOSERJI UC TAMACHANI.

SR. NAME OF FIRM/ BIDDERS N.T.N 7 REGISTRATION [NDH BOARD RELEVA7


FUNDS/ 05%

EARNEST TENDER FEE/ COST BIDDING

NO. WITH P.E.0 I OF REVENUE EXPERIENCE I THREE YEARS BUDGET

MONEY DOCUMENT

I MIS MAHTAM ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS BEDIL BECUS Available Registered Registered Available \vailable Available Available Deposited


14 /, (AJ3DUL HAF Z MEMON)

ASSISTANT ENGINEER PUBLIC HEALTH ENOG; SUB-DIVISION

ROHRI

(RAFIQUE AHMEDSIKH) EXECTJTIVE.-.EIcGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR




NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING AND DRAINS FROM AL! MOHAMMAD KHOKHAR HOUSE TO KHALID HUSSAIN MAKO HOUSE GOLIMAR SUKKUR UC-20.


SR. NO.


1 M/SAJMAN ENTERPRISES

2 M/S AKHTAR ALl SOOMRO

3 M/S MUHAMMAD SHAFIQUE

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEP-SIIAIKH) EXECUTIVEINGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

4,'



(ABDUL HAF1EMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


LI_EiL&L!LLLO. LR E PORT SK-021



3 Tender Description! Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING AND DRAINS FROM ALl MOHAMMAD KHOKHAR HOUSE TO KHALID HUSSAIN MAKO HOUSE GOLIMAR SUKKUR UC-20.


5 Tender Published Published in (l)bally Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17





8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Aonlicable)

--


01 No.




COST RANKING IN I COMPARISON I I I REASONS FOR

SR # NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER OFFERED BY TERMS OF WITH I ACCEPTANCE! REMARKS

THE BIDDER COST ESTIMATE [COSTiSAVINGI]

REJECTION

1 M/S AJMAN ENTERPRISES 4873347 151 Lowest 125352 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S AKHTAR AL! SOOMRO 4946083 2 Higher 52616 Rejected Being Higher

3 M/S MUHAMMAD SHAFIQUE

5000393 3f1 Highest -1694 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED IKH) EXECUTIVE INEER


MEMBER MEMBER

Th (ABDUL HAFE Z MEMON)

ASSISTANT ENGEER PUBLIC HEALTH ENG& SUB-DIVISION

ROHRI

(WAHEED BUX\QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


RATE AMOUNT RATE 1 AMOUNT

M/S AJMAN ENTERPSES M/S AKETAR ALl SOOMRO M/S MUHAMMAD SHAFIQUE DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE

(A) 'l'otal Cost as per Estimate (B) Total as per Tender



Savmg Over A.A

4998699 4873347

125352 2.51

5000000 4873347

126653,

EXECUEh EER HJGI1WAYJ DIS/)SION

KUR

(ABDULHAEtZMr 0 ASSISTAoEN R

PUBLIC HEALTH EN -. UB.OIVIS)ON RQiR

(WAHEED BUX ASSISTANT ENGI

FIIGHWAYSSUBDI." ---ROHRI

FINALEV1EW / COMPARAflVE STATEMNT

SK-02 1 NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING AND DRAINS FROM ALl MOHAMMAD KHOKHAR HOUSE TO

KHALID HUSSAIN MAKO HOUSE GOLIMAR SUKKUR UC-20.

PART "A' (ROAD WORK

I AmountofSchedule"B' 4849101 4849101 4849101 4849101

2 Ded: 20% Below (on Paver Block Only) n Rs. 3745688/-

749138 0.50% Above (+) 24246 2% Above (+) 96982 3.12% Above (+) 151292


GRAND TOTAL A, B, C: - 4901717 4873347 4946083 5000393


The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS AJMAN ENTERPRISES Government Contractor are:-

'ART "A" Rs. 0.50% Above (Rupees Zero Point l?ifty Percent Above)


EXECI N3 HIGH WAYS-c1VISION

$UKWR


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

I J I.A?JCLON



CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING AND DRAINS FROM AL! MOHAMMAD KHOKHAR HOUSE TO KHALID HUSSAIN MAKO HOUSE GOLIMAR SUKKUR UC-20.

¶

SR. NO.

NAME OF FIRM/ BIDDERS NT N REGISTRATION

WITH P.E.0 SINDH BOARD RELEVANT OF REVENUE EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST

TENDER FEE/ COST BIDDING

g


1 MIS AJMAN ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS AKHTAR ALl SOOMRO Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

3 M/S MUHAMMAD SI-lAFlQUE Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(Th (ABDUL HA Z MEMON)


ROHRI

(RAFIQUE AHMED SIWKH) EXECUTIVE EN9II(EER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR




NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO JANOJI VIA VILLAGE MIR SHAHID HUSSAIN TALPUR MILE 0/0-0/4 (0.80 KM).


SR. NO.


1 M/S ZAWAR IBRAHIM BHAMBHRO

1.ia " UHI

OL'I )1j,,Iiaett'?

2 M/S MUHIB ALT SADHAYO

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED HAIKH) EXECUTIVE E)KcINEER

HIGHWAYSDIVISION SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

-, (WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER




S BJ EVLUTION REPORT


2 Tender Reference No. N.I,T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO JANOJI VIA VILLAGE MIR SHAHID HUSSAIN TALPUR MILE 0/0-0/4 (0.80 KM).


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awarni Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17






--


01 No.




COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASONS FOR SR U NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER OFFERED BY TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATE ACCEPTANCE! REMARKS


1 M/S ZAWAR IBRAHIM BHAMBHRO


2 M/S MUHIB AL! SADHAYO 5398074 2mf1 Higher -74 Rejected Being Higher


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEDSHAIKH) EXECUTIVE I1GINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEEDX QPSMI) (ABDUL HAPEEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENOG: SUB-DIVISION ROHRI ROHRI

PART "C" 200595 199801 201179

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C:- 5398158 5353048 5398074


(A) Total Cost as per Estimate (B) Total as per Tendei'



Saving Over A.A

The Lowest Rates Qouted 13v MjS ZAWAR IBRAHIM BHAMBHRO Government Contractor are:-

PART "A"@ Rs. 7.10% Above (Rupees Seven Point Ten Percent Above) PART "B" j Rs. 14.60% Above (Rupees Fourteen Point Sixty Percent Above) PART "C" @ Rs, 16% Above (Rupees Sixteen Percent Above)

Lowest Rates are Recomnmencled for Approval

5398000 5353048

44952 0.83

5400000 5353048

46952

4- EXECUTIVE ENGI R HIGHWAYS' ISION

SUKKUR

A8DIJL HAFE 'Z ,. ASSISTANTE NEER

UBUC HEAt.T EN ' SUB.DlVISIOt4 R OH RI

S

WAHEED BUX QSMI)] ASSISTANT ENGINEER L[GHWAYS SUB-DIVISIO

ROHRI

0

FJANC1AL RE'VIEW / COMPARATIVE STATEMNT

NAME OF WORK: CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM ARFORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO JANOJI VIA VILLAGE MIR SHAHID HUSSAIN TALPUR MILE 0/0-0/4 (0.80 KM).

SR NO DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE

M/S ZAWAR IBRAtUM BHAMBMRO MIS MUHIB ALl SADHAYO

RATE AMOUNT RATE iF AMOUNT PART 'A' (ROAD WORK


2 Add: 8% Above (1 369342 7.10% Above (+) 327791 8% Above (+) 369342

3 Ded: Diff Cost of Bitumen (- ) 325526 325526 325526 PART "A" 660591 4619040 4660591

PART "B" (10' SPAN CULVERTS

I Amount of Schedule "B" 466149 466149 466149 2 Permium -- 14.60% Above (-) 68058 15.05% Above (+) 70155

3 Add: Cartage of Material (~) 70823 PART "B" 536972 534207 536304

PART "C" (3 SPAN CULVERTS I Amount of Schedule "B" 172242 172242 172242 2 Perinjum -- 16% Above (+) 27559 16,80% Above (+) 28937 3 Add: Cartage of Material (1 28353


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

QI

NJ.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17


CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO JANOJI VIA VILLAGE MIR SHAHID HUSSAIN TALPUR MILE 0/0-0/4 (0.80 KM).

SR. NO.



RELEVANT EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST

MONEY


DOCUMENT

I MIS ZAWAR lBRAlIIM BHAMBHRO Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 M/S MUl-IIB AL! SADI IAYO Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


/

(RAFIQUE AHMED J1TKH) EXECUTIVE ENtINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR



(ABDUL HAEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


e ATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FORM VILLAGE LAHOTI UMED ALl SHAMBANI TO GHANTAN WARI UC DHANDHI MILE 0/0-0/5 (1 KM).


SR. NO.


1 M/SZ.A QURESHI ( I "

MIS r1t : II

2 MIS MOLE DINO CHACHAR

M/S MOL ACHAR GOVI: CONTRACTOR

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHME7SHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAF EZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANTENGINEER


S ft PORT


2 Tender Reference No. NIT No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FORM VILLAGE LAHOTI UMED ALl SHAMBANI TO GHANTAN WARI UC DHANDHI MILE 0/0-0/5 (1 KM).

4 Method of l'rocurement Single Stage (By Competitive Rate! Bid)

5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awanii Awas Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (LU) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17




8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Aonlicablel

--


01 No.






1 M/S Z.A QURESHI 6286440 1M Lowest 174300 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S MOLE DINO CHACI1AR 6353762 2 Higher 106978 Rejected Being Higher


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED AJK EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER


HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENGO: SUB-DIVISION ROHRI ROHRI

TOTAL: C x2 =

PART "D" (PIPE CULVERTS) 1 Amount of Schedule "B" 2 Permiuni 3 Add: Cartage of Material

TOTAL: D

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C+D: -

193772 194806 x 2 387544 ,c 2 = 389612

26285 26285 16% Above (+) 4206 17% Above (-4.) 4468

30491 30753

6286440 6353762

194686 389372

4288 30573

26285

6345813

(+)

(ABüiji UAFEEZ . ASSISTANT NGN

P1IUCHEALTHEGG OHR1

FINANCIAL REVIEW / CQMPARATIVE STATEMNT

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FORM VILLAGE LAHOTI UMED AL! SHAMBANI TO GHANTAN WARI UC DHANDHI MILE 0/0-0/5 (1 KM).

NO DESCRIPTION

--

ESTIMATE

M/SZ.AQURESHI 7 1M/SMOLEDINOCEACHAR


PART "A" (ROAD WORK 1 Amount of Schedule "B' 4428830 4428830 4428830 2 Add: 8% Above (+) 354306 7% Above (+) 310018 8.17% Above (t) 361835 3 Ded: Duff Cost of Bitumen (-) 279410 279410 279410

TOTAL: A 4503726 4459438 4511255 PART "B" (ROAD WORK

I Amount of Schedule "B' 1317492 1317492 1317492 2 Add: 14% Above (1) 184449 13%Above(+} 171274 14% Above(+) 184449 3 Ded: Dill Cost of Bitumen 1-) 79799 79799 79799

TOTAL: B 1422142 1408967 1422142 PART "C" (3' SPAN CULVERTS

1 Amount of Schedule "B" - 172242 172242 172242 2 Permium 12.50% Above (-") 21530 13.10% Above (4-) 22564 3 Add: Cartage of Material (+) 22444





Saving Over A.A

6460740 6286440

174300 2.70

6500000 6286440 213560

The Lowest Rates Qouted By 4JiS Z.&9JJES_ffl Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" c Rs. 7% Above (Rupees Seven Percent Above) PART "B" @ Rs. 13% Above (Rupees Thirteen Percent Above) PART "C" Rs. 12.50% Above (Rupees Twelve Point Fifty Percent Above) PART "D" @ Rs. 16% Above (Rupees Sixteen Percent Above) Lowest Rats are Recommended for Approval

'WAHEEDBUX QASM)1 ASSISTANT l- GHWAYS Su ..

RO H R

SlG:., WAYS )VS)ON

TENDER REFERENCE NO. N.I.T No. EE/IiW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17


NAME OF WORK CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FORM VILLAGE LAHOTI UMED ALl SHAMBANI TO GHANTAN WARI UC DHANDHI MILE 0/0-0/5 (1 KM).

SR. NO.


WITH PE.0 SINDH BOARD OF REVENUE

RELEVANT EXPERIENCE


FUNDS! BUDGET

05% EARNEST

MONEY


DOCUMENT

I M/S Z.A QURESH! Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS MOLE DINO CI-IACHAR Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHMED SHII EXECUTIVE flEER HIGHWA'1DIVISION

SUKKUR

(WAREED BUX QAMI} ASSISTANT ENGINEER


(ABDUL RAFEEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


ATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SIJKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM VILLAGE SIRAN WARO TO PHOTO MAHAR MILE 0/0-0/7.


SR. NO.


I M/S AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH CONSYI': Co

ALMUZAM(L SHMKH CONSTRUTION & GO:

GOVT: CONTRACTOR Prop: Asad Au

2 M/S AL-AMEER ENTERPRISES

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AJMED SHAIKH) EXECUTfJE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION


'V

(WAHEED BUX'QASMI) (ABDUL HAFEEZMEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT EMGINEER


S I-

S lD EVALUTION REPORT



3 Tender Description! Name of Work! Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM VILLAGE SIRAN WARO TO PHOTO MAHAR MILE 0/0-0/7.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (II) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Datcd. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017

SPPRA ID NO:2147483647 S.No. 35535 Dated: 05-12-2017



8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Aoolicablel

--


01 No.






1 M/S AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH CONSTI': CO

12011592 i 257408 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S AL-AMEER ENTERPRISES

12102577 2nd Higher 166423 Rejected Being Higher


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED$HUKH) EXECUTIVE NINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

Jr (WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER




DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE SR NO

AMOUNT RATE




Saving Over A.A

12269000 12011592

257408 2.10

12300000 12011592

288408

(ABOUL HAF'E ..

•IIPI I(. NI TN ((.

Mo N'

S

(WAHEEDUXI ' ASSISTANT ErUEER

JIIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISO4 I •I

EXECufe r- Iiw. S

-4

NAME OF WORK: -

FINANCIAL REVIEW / COMPARTWE STATEMJT

CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM VILLAGE SIRAN WARO TO PHOTO MAHAR MILE 0/0-0/7. $

PART "A" (ROAD WORK

1 Amount of Schedule "B' 2456762 2456762 2456762

2 Add: 8% Above (1 196541 7.60% Above (+) 186714 8.63% Above (+) 212019

3 Ded: Diff Cost of Bitumen (-) 159824 159824 159824

PART "A" 2493479 2483652 2508957 PART "B" (ROAD WORK


2 Add: 8% Above (+) 636539 7.60% Above (+) 604712 8.30% Above (+) 660409

3 Ded: Duff Cost of Bitumen (-) 399222 399222 399222

PART "B" 8194050 8162223 8217920 PART "C" (10 RFT BRIDGE

1 Amount of Schedule "B" 993781 993781 993781 2 Permium --- 17.20% Above (+) 170930 18.13% Above (+) 180172 3 Add: Cartage of Material (+) 177541

PART "C" 1171322 1164711 1173953 PART "D" (3' SPAR CULVERTS

1 Amount of Schedule "B' 172242 172242 172242 2 Permium --- 16.70%Above(+) 28764 17.13%Above(+) 29505 3 Add: Cartage of Material (+) 29666

PART "D" 201908 201006 201747

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C+D: - 12060759 12011592 12102577


The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS AL-MUZAMIL CONSTT: Co Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" @ Rs. 7.60% Above (Rupees Seven Point Sixty Percent Above) PART "B" @ Rs. 7.60% Above (Rupees Seven Point Sixty Percent Above) PART "C" @ Rs. 17.20% Above (Rupees Seventeen Point Twenty Percent Above) 1'ART "D" Rs. 16.70% Above (Rupees Sixteen Point Seventy Percent Above) Lowest Rates are Recommended for Approval

Q7I-I A.Iwr



NAME OF WORK CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM VILLAGE SIRAN WARO TO PHOTO MAHAR MILE 0/0-0/7.

S

4

SR. NO.



RELEVANT EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST



1 MIS AL-MUZAMIL SHAINII CONSTTs

CO

Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available l)eposited

2 MIS AL-AMEER ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHMJDSHAIKH) EXECUTIVEENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR


HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION ROIIRI




NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM KORAI WAH TO GHULAM MURTAZA SHAIKH MILE 0/0-0/6+330 TALUKA PANOAKIL.

EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SURRUR HELD ON 22.12.2017

SR. NO.


1 M/S MAJID GULZAR SHAJKH

2 M/S ASHIQUE ALT ABBASI

; \\

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMD-SHAIKH) EXECUTIVEENGINEER

HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER



(ABDUL HAF E MON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB-DIVISION RO H RI

BID EVALUTION REPORT


2 Tender Reference No. N.I.T No. EE/l-IW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM KORA! WAH TO GHULAM MURTAZA SHAIKH MILE 0/0-0/6+330 TALUKA PANOAKIL.

4 Method of Procurement Single Stage (By Competitive Rate! B:cl)

5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17 (ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17





- -


01 No.






1 M/S MAJID GULZAR SHAII<H

9951201 lu Ist 38799 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S ASHIQUE AL! ABBASI 10011698 2nd Higher -21698 Rejected Being Higher


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED $icIKH) EXECUTIVE NINEER

HIGHWAYVDIVISION SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER



(ABDUL HAFEEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGt: SUB-DIVISION ROHRI

RATE AMOUNT RATE [1OUNT

CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM TALUKA PANOAKIL.

MORAl WAR TO GHULAM MURTAZA SHAIKH MILE 0/0-0/6~330

ESTIMATE MIS MAJID GULZAR SHAXKU MIS ASHIQUE AL! ABSASI

NAME OF WORK: -

SR NO DESCRIPTION

PART "A" (ROAD WORK

(A) Total Cost as l)e1 Estimate (B) Total as per Tender

Saving (MB) Percentage Saving


Saving Over A.A

9990000 9951201

38799 0.39

10000000 9951201

48799

(ABDtJL HAFE" E' ASSISTANT E'

- EER PUBLIC HEALTH E?Gu: SUB.Di VISION

ROHRI

Fl ANCIAL RIVIEW JCOMPARATIVJ STATEMNT

Amount of Schedule 'B' 9465702 9465702 9465702

2 Add: 8% Above (1 757256 7.60% Above (+) 719393 8.21% Above (+) 777134

3 Dccl: Diff Cost of Bitumen (-) 621438 621438 621438

PART "A" 9601520 9563657 9621398 PART "B" (MASONARY STRUCTURE


2 Permium -- 12.50% Above (~) 21530 13.30% Above (+) 22908

3 Add: Cartage of Material (~) 22126

PART "B" 194368 193772 195150 388736 x 2 387544 x 2 390300

GRAND TOTAL A, B: -

9990256

9951201 10011698


The Lowest Rates Qouted By M/S MAJID GULZAR SHAIKE Government Contractor ire:-

PART "A" Rs. 76()% Above (Rupees Seven Point Sixty Percent Above) PART "B" Qi Rs. 12.50% Above (Rupees 'I\velve Point Fifty Percent Above)


"S

rIWAHEED B1IY" " MI) I ASSISTAN) , ER }IIGHWAYS Su .,1tSION

ROHRI

EXECUTIVEE - 1EER HIGHWAY • IVISION

'•%S Ucwl—



NAME OF WORK CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM KOR.AI WAN TO GHULAM MURTAZA SHAIKH MILE 0/0-0/6+330 TALUKA PANOAKIL.

TURNOVER OF TENDER FEEl SR.

NAME OF FIRM! BIDDERS N.T.N REGISTRATION SINDH BOARD RELEVANT

AT LEAST LAST FUNDS/

EARNEST COST BIDDING NO. WITH P.E.0 OF REVENUE EXPERIENCE

THREE YEARS BUDGET

MONEY DOCUMENT

I MIS MAJID GULZAR SHAIKII Available Registered Registered Avtilablr Available Available Available Deposited

2 M/S ASHIQUE ALl AI3BASl Available Registered Registered Availabli Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHME8flAIKH) EXECUTIVEGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

(WAHEED BUX QA$MI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


(ABDUL HAFEEZMEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENOG: SUB-DIVISION ROHRI


NAME OF WORK: - IMPR: /RECDG: OF ROAD & CONST: OF ROAD ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO OLD JANOJI VIA SHAH MIR MANGSI MILE 0/0-1/5 (2.60 KM)


SR. NO.

NAME OF CONT1ACTOR SIGNATURE

1 M/SBAHADURALISHAIKH

ALl SHAIKH GOV1':CONTRACTO

BAHADUR

2 MIS ASI-I1QUE ALl ABBASI

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMp-SflAIKH) EXECUTIVENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

\J 4

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAF MMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT EN '.1 R

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH EN : SUB-DIVISION ROHRI ROHRI

MEMBER

(ABDUL HA ASSISTANT EN

PUBLIC HEALTH EN ROH I

MON) INEER

VISION

I

BID E VALUTIQJ RE P0 RI



3 Tender Dcscription/ Name of Work! Item

IMPR: /RECDG: OF ROAD & CONST: OF ROAD ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO OLD JANOJI VIA SHAH MIR MANGSI MILE 0/0-1/5 (2.60 KM)


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017





--


01 No.




I COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASONS FOR SR # NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER I

OFFERED BYTHE

TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATE ACCEPTANCE! REMARKS

J BIDDER COST COST (SAVING) REJECTION

1 M/S BAHADUR ALl SHAIKH 15811216 1st Lowest 157784 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S ASHIQUE ALL ABBASI 15953502 2'' Higher 15498 Rejected Being Higher


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHME8HAIKH) EXECUTIVE..E11G!NEER


MEMBER

(WAHEED BUXIQASMI) ASSISTANT ENbINEER


$

NAME OF WORK: - IMPR: /RECDG: OF ROAD & CONST: OF ROAD ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO OLD JANOJI VIA SHAH M MANGSI MILE 0/0-1/5 (2.60 KM)

M/S BAHADUR AL! SHA1KE

RATE

M/S ASHIQUE AL! ABBASI

AMOUNT

SR [_No DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE

AMOUNT

RATE

XEC' 'V HIG. --

r

V1s; A8DUL HA1 ASSiSTANT

' ER PUBLIC NEtLTH EN : SUB.DIVIS(ON

WA.EO BLIXOASMI) ASSiSTANT ENGINEER


FINANCIAL RIWIEW / COMPARATIVE STATEMNT

PART 'A (ROAD WORK 1 Amount of Schedule "B" 6474977 6474977 6474977 2 Add: 8% Above (+1 518000 7.25% Above (+) 469436 8.35% Above (+) 540661 3 Dccl: Diff Cost of Bitumen (-) 399222 399222 399222

TOTAL: A 6593755 6545191 6616416 PART "B" (ROAD WORK

I Amount of Schedule "B" 8442006 8442006 8442006 2 Add: 14% Above (} 1181880 13.50% Above (+) 1139671 l43O%Abovc 1207207 3 Ded: Duff Cost of Bitumen (-1 638846 638846 638846

TOTAL: B 8985040 8942831 9010367 PART "C' (3' SPAN CULVERTS

[i Amount of Non Schedule "B" 172242 172242 172242 2 Permium -- 15% Above (+) 25836 16.41 % Above (+) 28265 3 Add: Cartage of Material (+) 27554

TOTAL: C 199796 198078 200507 PART 'D" (PIPE CULVERTS

I Amount of Non Schedule "B" 26285 26285 26285 2 Permium -- 19% Above (~) 4994 20.04% Above ()_ 5268 3 AcId: Carta of Material (+) 5214

TOTAL: C 31499 31279 31553 X4 = 125996 x 4 125116 c 4 126212

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C:. 15904587 15811216 15953502


The Lowest Rates Qoutcd By MIS BAHADUR AL! SHAIKH Government Cont i-actor are:-

PART "K Rs. 7.25% Above (Rupees Seven Point Twenty Five Percent Above) PART "[3' ': Rs. 13.50% Above (Rupees Thirteen Point Fifty Percent Above) PART "C' r Rs. 15% Above (Rupees Fifteen Percent Above) PART "1)" (ii; Rs. 19% Above (Rupees Nineteen Pci-cent Above) Lowest Rates are Recommend for Apval 4


Saving (A"l) Percentage Saving

A.A Amount Lowest Tender Ainonin

Saving Over A.A

15969000 15811216

157784 0.99

16000000 15811216 188784

I

REGISTRATION DH BoARD WITH P.E.0 OF REVENUE NAI1E OF FIRM! BIDDERS RELEVANT

EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST

MONEY

JD•



NAME OF WORK IMPR: /RECDG: OF ROAD & CONST: OF ROAD ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO OLD JANOJI VIA SHAH MIR MANGSI MILE 0/0-1/5 (2.60 KM)

SR. NO.

1 MIS I IAI-IAI)UR ALl SIlAIKIl Avail,it,li Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 M/S ASHIQUE ALl ABBASI Available Registered Registered Available Available Avaihible Available Deposited


(FAFIQUE AHME.S1TAIKHJ (WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAI1Z M MON) EXECUTIVE,-f1GINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT EN HIGHWAYS DIVISION HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENG . . -DIVISION

SUKKUR ROHRI ROH


DOCUMENT

• TTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD/PAVER BLOCK AND DRAINS AT VILLAGE DOLAT KHAN PATHAN MILE 0/0-0/3.


SR. NO.


1 M/SDKCENTERPRISES

2 M/SSI-IAFQUATALIlTPAR&SONS

7, CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE A D SHAIKH)

EXECUT E ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAF Z EMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT 1(GEE1T


51D VALUTION R.PORT


2 Tender Reference No. N.l.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17

3 Tender Description! Name of Work! Item

CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD/PAVER BLOCK AND DRAINS AT VILLAGE DOLAT KHAN PATHAN MILE 0/0-0/3.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Dafty Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07. 12.2017 (ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017




8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Atnlicablc)

--


01 No.




COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASONS FOR SR # NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER OFFERED

BY THE TERMS OF

COST WITH ESTIMATE COST (SAVING)

ACCEPTANCE! REJECTION rREMARKS

RIDDER - -

1 MIS DKC ENTERPRISES 10681805 1st Lowest 112195 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S SHAFQUAT ALl KATPAR & SONS

10756028 2' Higher 37972 Rejected Being Higher


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHrvIEJHAIKH) EXECUTIVGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(WAH' ASMI} (ABDUL HZ EMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT E I

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH EN : SUB-DIVISION ROHRI ROHRI

MIS DKC ENTERPRISES MIS SHAFQUAT AL! KATPAR & SONS

________RATE k AMOUNT RATE AMOUNT

SR

LNO DESCRIPTION

ESTIMATE

PART 'A" PAVER BLOCK) Amount of Schedule "13" l)ed: 20% Below (on ('aver Block

'I

Add: Cartage of Material TOTAL: A

4387627 4387627 4387627

(.) 743144 0,50% Above (+) 2)938 I (3% AbOVe (+) 49580

(+) 802581 4447064 4409565 4437207

(A) 'l'otal Cost as per Esthnatc (B) Total as per Tender

Saving (MB) lk'tcentage Saving

A.A Amount Lowest 'Fender Amount

Saving Over A.A

10794000 10681805

112195 1.04

10800000 10681805

118195

1'he Lowest Rates Qouted By S DKC ENTERPRISES Government Contractor arc:-

PART "A"'a, Rs. 0,50% Above (Rupees Zero Point Fifty Percent Above) PART "13" 'ii Rs, 14% Above (Rupees Fourteen Percent Above) PART "C" .i Rs. 3470000/- Non Schedule

l.,owest !';ii's arc Recommended for 1\7pr0va1

—

EED BUX Q R XECUTIVE (t 1MEE\ ASSISTANT ENGINEE 1IGHWAYS D1VISIOJ

I)IGHW/YS SUB-DIV° SUKKUR R01R1

(ABDUL HAF EZ EMON ASSISTANT

PUBLIC HEALTH E es,,: SU8DtVlSIO& ROHR(


FINANCIAL REVIEWJ (XMPARATIVE STAAATEMNI

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD/PAVER BLOCK AND DRAINS AT VILLAGE DOLAT KHAN PATHAN MILE 0/0-0/3.

PART "B" (DRAINS 1 Amount of Schedule "[3" 2458105 2458105 2458105 2 Permium (-) 14% Above (:') 344135 15% Above (+) 368716 3 Add: Cartage of Material 364878

TOTAL: B PART "C" (SOLAR LIGHT)

2822983 2802240 2826821

Amount of Non Schedule "B" 3474000 3470000 3492000 2 Perinium 3 Add: Cartage of Material

TOTAL: C 3474000 3470000 3492000

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C:. 10744047 10681805 10756028

TENDER REFERENCE NO. N.1.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017


NAME OF WORK CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD/PAVER BLOCK AND DRAINS AT VILLAGE DOLAT KHAN PATHAN MILE

0/0-0/3.

SR. NO.

NAME OF FIRM/ BIDDERS N.T.N icEGISTRATION


RELEVANT EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST

MONEY


DOCUMENT

1 MIS DKC ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 M/S SHAFQUAT ALl KATPAR & SONS Available Registered Rcgsurrd Available Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE MtVID SHAIKH) (WAHEED BUX QSMI) (ABDUL HAF M ON) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENG EER HIGHWAYS DIVISION HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENG

SUKKUR ROHRI RO

MZE)IDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

2tAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD! PAVER BLOCK & DRAINAGE AT VILLAGE HUSSAIN KALWAR TALUKA PANOAKIL.

XECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR HELD ON 22.12.2017

SIGNATURE SR. N0

NAME OF CONTRACTOR

1 M/S ASHIQUE AL! ABBASI

Ashique All Abbasi Gout: ConivcIor &

General Order Supplier

2 M/S OHULAM MURTAZA GHUMRO

7 -•

< -

--

i

3 M/SRELIANTTRADELINK

j2j//

CHAIRMAN

Cr

(RAFIQUE AH SHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER





I BID EVALUTION REPORT 33



3 Tender DescriprionJ Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD/ PAVER BLOCK & DRAINAGE AT VILLAGE HUSSAIN KALWAR TALUKA PANOAKIL.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)The Express Tribune Karachi Dated. 19.10.2011 (ii) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 19.10.2017 (ill) Daily Jang Karachi Dated. 20. 10.2017 (iv) Daily Nau SiJh Dated. 19.10.2017

SPPRA ID NO:2 147483647 S.No. 35535 Dated: 05- 12-2017




--


0] No.




'F— COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASONS FOR

SR A NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER OFFERED BY TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATE ACCEPTANCE/ REMARKS THE BIDDER COST COST (SAVING) REJECTION

I M/S ASHIQUE ALl ABBASI 9572617 i Lowest 374383 Accepted Being' Lowest

2 MIS OHULAM MURTAZA GHUMRO


3 M/S RELIANT TRADE LINK 9716926 3rd Highest 230074 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHME9-SHAIKH) EXECUT1VE-EGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER


HIGHWAYS SUB-DiVISION ROHRI

(ABDUL HAP Z 1MON) ASSISTANT ENGNEER


SR NO

DESCRIPTION

MIS RELIANT TRAL'E ,.1!K 3 M/S GHULAM MURTAZA GHUMRO 1[s ASRIQUE ALt ABBASI ESTIMATE

AMOUNT AMOUNT AMOUNT RATE RATE RATE

The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS ASHIOUE AL! ABBASI Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" Q Rs. 2.40% Above (Rupees Two Percent Above) PART "B" Rs. 11.80% Above (Rupees Eleven Point Eight Percent Above)





Saving Over A.A

9947000 9572617

374383 3.76

10000000 9572617

427383

PART "B' 1078757 1076038 1082775 1087588

GRAND TOTAL A, B: - 9646526 9572617 9662328 9716926


EER

(ABDUL HA?E ASSicTA!T F

F '•

T(WAHEED BUX ASM!) ASSISTANT LR

HIGHWAYS SUi3DtVtOt RO H RI

FINANCIAL BEEW / OMPARATIVE FATEMNT S K-048

NAME OF WORK: - CONST1UCT1ON 01 ROAD! PVER ELOC & DFAINAGE AT VILLAGE HTJSSAIN KALWAR TALTJIA PAT (AKjL.

PART "A" (PAVER BLOCK

1 Amount of Schedule "B' 8297440 8297440 8297440 8297440


1378413 2.40°A. Above (+) 199139 3.40% Above (4) 282113 4% Above 1+) 331898

3 Add: Cartage of Material (-) 1648742

PART "A" 8567769 8496579 8579553 8629338 PART "B" (MASONARY STRUCTURE


2 Permjum -- 11.80% Above (+) 113571 12.50% Above (+) 120308 13% Above (+) 125)21

3 Add: Cartage of Material (1 116290

EXECUTIVE E1I6INEEF HIGH WP81JIVISION

SUKKUR


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

ø'r


EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUF

CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD/ PAVER BLOCK & DRAINAGE AT VILLAGE HUSSAIN KALWAR TALUKA PANOAKIL.

r SR. NO.

NAME OF FIRM/BIDDERS N.T.N REGISTRATION

WITH F.E.0 SINDH BOARD OF REVENUE

RELEVANT i EXPERIENCE


1JNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST


________ - j THREE YEARS MONEY DOCUMENT

I M/S ASHIQUE AU ABBASI Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS GHULAM MURTAZA GHUMRO Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

3 MIS RELIANT TRADE LINK Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHMBSHAIKH) EXECUTWEENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR



(ABDUL RAPE Z MMON) ASSISTANT EN91NEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG:-SIJB-DWISION RORRI

/'?TENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD LINK ROAD FROM SALEHPAT SIKANDERABAD ROAD AT DARGAH KHUDA BUX SHAH TO VILLAGE KARAMAT MUHALLA UC LAL JURIO MILE 0/0-0/4 (0.80 KM).


SR. NO.


I M/S BADARUDIN & CO.

-'P.1

2

-

M/SAKS&BUILDERS

'Ss gth6R M

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHJ\IED SHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER





BID UTlik R 1

'1 Name of Procuring Agency Executive Engineer Highways Division Sukkur


3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD LINK ROAD FROM SALEHPAT SIKANDERABAD ROAD AT DARGAH KHUDA BUX SHAH TO VILLAGE KARAMAT MUHALLA UC LAL JURIO MILE 0/0-0/4 (0.80 KM).


5 Tender Published Published in (i)The Express Tribune Karachi Dated. 19.10.2011

(uI Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 19.10.2017 (iii) Daily Jang Karachi Dated. 20.10.2017 (iv) Daily Nau Sijh Dated. 19. 10.20 17





--


01 No.






I M/S BADARUDIN & CO. 5144458 1st Lowest 51542 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S AKS & BUILDERS 5206194 2nd Higher -10194 Rejected Being Higher


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEYHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER








Saving Over A.A

5196000 5144458

51542 0.99

5200000 5144458

55542

PART "C" 31960 31542 32102

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C: - 5196403 5144458 5206194


The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS BADARUDIN & CO Government Contractor are:-

PART 'A" Rs. 7% Above (Rupees Seven Percent Above) PART "B" Rs. 16% Above (Rupees Sixteen Percent Above) PART "B" Rs. 20% Above (Rupees Twenty Percent Above)


ABCUL iM-' . EMON) ASSiS1.A'ii ::NGit"lEER

PUBY EGG: S'Ja.DIVISION "—

[(WAHEED ;j QMi) ASS1P,4T ENCU'4ER

HlGHW.'S SUB.DlV3lON l OH Ri

I1FINANCIAL REVIEW L COMPARATIVE STATEMNT

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD LINK ROAD FROM SALEHPAT SIKANDERABAD ROAD AT DARGAH KHUDA BUX SHAH TO VILLAGE KARAMAT MUHALLA UC LAL JTJRIO MILE 0/0-0/4(0.80 KM).

SR NO

DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE M/S BADARUDIN & Co. MIS AKS & BUILDERS


PART "A" (ROAD WORK


2 Add: 8% Above (+) 391218 7% Above (+) 342316 8.17% AbOve (+) 399531

3 Ded: Diff Cost of Bitumen H 319423 319423 319423

PART "A' 4962017 4913115 4970330 PART "B" (3' SPAN CULVERTS


2 Permium -- 16% Above (+) 27559 18.30% Above (+) 31520


PART "B" 202426 199801 203762 PART "C" (PIPE CULVERTS

1 Amount of Schedule "B" 26285 26285 26285 2 Permium -- 20% Above (+) 5257 22.13% Above (+) 5817

- 3 Add: Cartage of Material (+) 5675

_II(_-

EXECU HLGW4" . ;,jiJtLOt41

I

I

IJIR è Q'LTALX wIc'rIøN



NAME OF WORK CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD LINK ROAD FROM SALEHPAT SIKANDERABAD ROAD AT DARGAH KHUDA BUX SHAH TO VILLAGE KARAMAT MUHALLA UC LAL JURIO MILE 0/0-0/4(0.80 KM).

SR. NO.


WITH P.E.0 SINDH BOARD OF REVENU]

RELEVANT 1 EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST

TENDER FEiT COST BIDDING

THREE MONEY DOCUMENT

1 M/S BADARLJDIN & CO. Available Registered Registered Available Available .vailable Available Deposited

2 MIS AKS & BUILDERS Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AH?1flDSHAIKH) EXECUTIVENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

(WAHEED BU?C QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


(ABDUL HAFZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENçUNEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENG SUB-DIVISION ROHRI

ATNDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - RECONDITIONING OF ROAD FROM NATIONAL HIGHWAY TO HUSSAIN KALWAR VIA DAYA GEER POLICE PICKET MILE 0/0-2/2.


SR. NO.


I i K AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH CONS'fl': & Co.

(Ak AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH

CONSTRUTION & CO: GOVT: CONTRACTOR

Prop: Asad All

2 M I/S SHAHZAMAN BROHI CONSfl: COMPANY

4

I,

3 MI/S R.A CONSTRUCTION COMPANY

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AfiMED SHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BOX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER




I ID VA LULLO.NREPORT

Name of Procuring Agency Executive Engineer Highways Division Sukkur


3 Tender Description! Name of Work! Item RECONDITIONING OF ROAD FROM NATIONAL HIGHWAY TO HUSSAIN KALWAR VIA DAYA GEER POLICE PICKET MILE 0/0-2/2.

Single Stage (By Competitive Rate! Bid) 4 Method of Procurement

5 Tender Published Published in (i)The Express Tribune Karachi Dated. 19.1O.2O1

(ii) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 19.10.2017 (iii) Daily Jang Karachi Dated. 20.10.2017 (iv) Daily Nau Sijh Dated. 19. 10 .20 17


Total Document Sold 03 Nos. 6

7 03 Nos. Total Bids Received

S Technical B1 Opening Date (If Applicable)


10 Bids Rejected

11 Financial Bid Opening Date

01 No.

02 Nos.

22.12.2017




1 M/S AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH CONSTI': & CO.


2 M/S SHAHZAMAN BROHI CONSTI': COMPANY


3 M/S R.A CONSTRUCTION COMPANY

10046002 3rd Highest -48002 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEDSHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEM BER MEMBER








Saving Over A.A

9998000 9859647

138353 1.38

10000000 9859647

140353

GRAND TOTAL A, B: - 9947921 9859647 9947921 10046002


The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS AL-MUZA11IL SHAIKH CONSTT: & CO. Government Contractor are:-

PART "A' Rs. 13.10% Above (Rupees Thirteen Point Ten Percent Above)


IABCWL riJL:

A8515TAN 1 ::.iNEER PUBUC E.Li E8G:

RCHRi

AhEED ASS STA NT

110

_ ri (;NEER

V 510 i

FINANCIAL REVIEW I COMPARATIVE STATEMNT

NAME OF WORK: - RECONDITIONING OF ROAD FROM NATIONAL HIGHWAY TO HUSSAIN KALWAR VIA DAYA GEER POLICE PICKET MILE 0/0-2/2.

SRDESCRIPTION ESTIMATE

NO

M/S AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH CONSTT: & CO.

M/S SHAUZAMAN COMPANY

BROHI CONSTT: M/S R.A CONSTRUCTION COMP

RATE AMOUNT - RATE AMOUNT RATE AMOUNT

PART "A" (PAVER BLOCK) 1 AmountofSchedule"B' 9808161 9808161 9808161 9808161

2 Add: 14% Above (+) 1373143 13.10% Above (+) 1284869 14% Above (+) 1373143 15% Above (+) 1471224

3 Ded: Diff Cost of Bitumen (-) 1233383 1233383 1233383 1233383

EXCUTVE jER HC-HWAY)'SiON

'4 TENDER REFERENCE NO.

NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

QJ I'XCAJrIQ



RECONDITIONING OF ROAD FROM NATIONAL HIGHWAY TO HUSSAIN KALWAR VIA DAYA GEER POLICE PICKET MILE 0/0-2/2.

SR. NAME OF FIRM/ BIDDERS N.T.N

REGISTRATION SINDH BOARD ItELEVANT TURNOVER OF AT LEAST LAST

FUNDS/ 05%

EARNEST TENDER FEEl COST BIDDING

NO. WITH P.E.0 OF REVENUE EXPERIENCE THREE YEARS

BUDGET MONEY DOCUMENT

1 M/S AL-MUZAMIL SHAIKH CONSTT: & Co.


2 M/S SHAHZAMAN BROHI CONSTT: COMPANY


3 MIS R.A CONSTRUCTION COMPANY Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited




(RAFIQUE AH)ErfSHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR




NAME OF WORK: - IMPROVEMENT! RECONDITIONING OF ROAD FROM SUKKUR SHIKARPUR TOAD TO KANDO WAHAN VIA FARASH MILE 0/0-1/5.


SR. NO.


1 M/S LAL KHAN BUGHTI & BROTHERS

tO\nI CONTRAUi.)1(

2 M/SBASHIRAHMEDMAHAR

ASHIRA DMAHAR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR.

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMp-SHAIKH) EXECUTIV-ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BU QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


(ABDUL HAFEEZ MEMQN)-ASSISTANT NG1NEER


BLVALUTION REPORT

Name of Procuring Agency Executive Engineer Highways Division Sukkur


3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item IMPROVEMENT/ RECONDITIONING OF ROAD FROM SUKKUR SHIKARPUR TOAD TO KANDO WAHAN VIA FARASH MILE 0/0-1/5.


5 Tender Published Published in (l)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017

(ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (lii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.2017




8 Technical Bid Opening Date (II Anolicable)

--


01 No.





THE BIDDER COST I COST (SAVING) REJECTION

1 M/S LALI<HAN BIJGHTI & BROTHERS


2 M/S BASHIR AHMED MAHAR



CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEDM1UKH) EXECUTIVE ENINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(ABDUL HAFEI MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


(WAHEED UX QMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


PART "B" 191563 191189 193

GRAND TOTAL A, B: - 8929520 8866177 8927655


(ABDUL HAF ASSISTANT EER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB.DIVISION ROI-IRI

(WAHEEDB ÔASM)) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

HIGH WAY 0 IV ISbN

EXECUTIVE .NTNEER HIGHW DIViSION

lowest Rates are Recommended for Approval

The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS LAL KHAN BIJOHTI & BROTHERS Government Contractor are:-

PART 'A" cIj Rs. 13.30% Above (Rupees Thirteen Point Thirty Percent Above) PART "B" @ Rs. 11% Above (Rupees Eleven Percent Above)




Saving Over A.A

8998000 8866177

131823 1.47

9000000 8866177

133823

FINANCIAL REVIEWJ COMPARATIVE STATEMN.L

NAME OF WORK: - IMPROVEMENT! RECONDITIONING OF ROAD FROM SUKKUR SHIKARPUR TOAD TO KANDO WAHAN

VIA FARASH MILE 0/0-1/5.

SR NO

DESCRH>TION ESTIMATE

MIS EAt, KEAN BUGHTI & BROTHERS _fM/S BASI-IIR AHMED MALIAR

_____ I RATE AMOUNT RATE AMOUNT

I Amount of Schedule "B" 8729092 8729092 8729092

2 Add: 14% Above () 1222073 13.30% Above (+) 1160969 14% Above (+) 1222073

3 Ded: DiffCost Bitumen (-) 1215073 1215073 1215073

PART A" 8736092 867498


2 Pennium -- 11% Above (+) 18947 12.30% Above (+) 21186



NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

LJAIX AIIM

N.I.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04. 12.2017


IMPROVEMENT! RECONDITIONING OF ROAD FROM SUKKUR SHIKARPUR TOAD TO KANDO

WAHAN VIA FARASH MILE 0/0.1/5.

SR. NO.

NAME OF FIRMI BIDDERS N.T.N REGISTRATION


I LEV/T EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

O5 EARNEST

MONEY


DOCUMENT

I M/S LAI., KHAN BUGHTI & BROTHERS Available Registered Registered Available Availabli Av,ni lie Available Deposited

2 M/S BASI-IIR AHMED MM tM Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(WAHEC Q) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-bIVISION ROHRI

(RAFIQUE AHMED EXECUTIVE E4EER HIGHWAYIVISION

SUKKUR

(ABDUL HAFE MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGGSUB-DIVISION ROHRI


NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM VILLAGE ALLAH DAD SHAR TO VILLAGE MUHAMMAD SACHAL PHULPOTO MILE 0/0-0/5 (1 KM).


SR. NO.


1 M/S MOLE DINO CHACHAR

M/S MOLI GOVT:

CHACHAR CONTRACTOR

2 M/SJANMUHAMMAD&BROTHERS

:, Go

OOIE int,acto!

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHM9-5HAIKH) EXECUTWE ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS DWISION SIJKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER


HIGHWAYS SUB-DWISION ROHRI


PUBLIC HEALTH ENGGSUB-DWISION ROHRI

LL\ LUJLQ1i Ji- P 0 - I

1 Name of Procuring Agency Executive Engineer I-lighways Division Sukkur

2 Tender Reference No. NIT No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ (tern CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM VILLAGE ALLAH DAD SHAR TO VILLAGE MUHAMMAD SACHAL PHULPOTO MILE 0/0-0/5 (1 KM).


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17

(ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17




8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Applicablel

--


01 No.




COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASONS FOR SR NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER OFFERED BY TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATE ACCEPTANCE/ REMARKS


1 M/S MOLE DINO CHACHAR 6385549 1st Lowest 111451 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S JAN MUHAMMAD & BROTHERS



CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED SJJAIKH) EXECUTWENG1EER


MEMBER

\



MEMBER

(ABDUL HAF ZMEMON) ASSISTANT ENQ1NEER


The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS MOLE DINO CHACHAR Government Contractor are:-

PART "A @ Rs. 7.20% Above (Rupees Seven Point Twenty Percent Above) PART "B" Rs. 14% Above (Rupees Fourteen Percent Above) PART "C" Q Rs, 18% Above (Rupees Eighteen Percent Above)



Saving (A-fBI Percentage Saving


Saving Over A,A

6497000 6385549

111451 1.72

6500000 6385549

114451

PART "C" 31191 31016 31453

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C: - 6436197 6385549 6445562


(ABDULHAF ASSISTANT Et?ER

L.UC HEALTh ENGG: SUB.DIVj ROHRI

(WAHEED BUX QASMI)1 ASSLSTANT ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION ROHR)

r FINANCIAL REVIEW / COMPAIATWE STATEMNT

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM VILLAGE ALLAH DAD SHAR TO VILLAGE MUHAMMAD SACHAL PHULPOTO MILE 0/0-0/5 (1 KM).

SR NO


MIS MOLE DINO CHACHAR MIS JAN MUHAMMAD & BROTHERS

_____ RATE AMOUNT RATE AMOUNT

PART "A" (ROAD WORK


2 Add: 8% Above (+) 489358 7.20% Above (+) 440422 8.17% Above (+) 499757

3 Ded: Duff Cost of Bitumen (-) 399222 399222 399222

PART "A" 6207113 6158177 6217512 PART "B" 1 3' SPAN CULVERTS

1 Amount of Schedulc"B" 172242 172242 172242

2 Fermium -- 14% Above (+) 24114 14,14% Above (') 24355

3 Add: Cai-tage of Material (-) 25651

PART "B" 197893 196356 196597 PART "C" (PIPE CULVERTS

1 Amount of Schedule "B" 26285 26285 26285 2 Permium -- 18% Above (+) 4731 19.66% Above (+) 5168 3 Add: Cartage of Material (4) 4906

EXECUTIVEEMgTNE HIGH WAYS DIVISIOMI

S U K KU R


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

xx xo 'r

N.LT No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17


CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM VILLAGE ALLAH DAD SHAR TO VILLAGE MUHAMMAD SACHAL PHULPOTO MILE 0/0-0/5 (1 KM).

SR. NO.



RETANT EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST



1 MIS MOLE DINO CHACHAR Available Registered Registered A abIe Available Available Available Deposited

2 M/S JAN MUHAMMAD & BROTHERS Available Registered Registered .\vaiIihk Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHMEKAIKH) (WAHEED BUX QSMI) (ABDUL HAFL'MEMON) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB.DIVISION

SUKKIJR ROHRI ROI—


NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM KHUDA BUX MAHTAM ROAD TO GUL KHAN CHANDIO MILE 0/0-0/5.


SR. NO.


1 MIS MAHTAM ENTERPRISES /

:,i "TERPRSE'

GOVI: Cu . ro

2 MIS SAAD KHOKHAR ENTERPRISES p.

Saad Khokh!iprises

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHME9-SHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER



ID EVALUTJ.PN REPORT



3 Tender Description! Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM KHUDA BUX MAHTAM ROAD TO GUL KHAH CHANDIO MILE 0/0. 0/5.


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17 (ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17


6 Total Document Sold 02 Nos,


8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Aonlicable)

- -


01 No.






I M/S MAH'rAM ENTERPRISES





CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED..SMAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX Q'ASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


(ABDUL HAFEEZ MEMON) — - ASSISTANT EN9NE


The Lowest Rates Qouted By M/S MAHTAM ENTERPRISES Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" @ Rs. 7,60% Above (Rupees Seven Point Sixty Percent Above) PART "B" ij Rs, 16% Above (Rupees Sixteen Percent Above)






FINACIAL REVIEW I COMPARA

4 I

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM KHUDA BUX MAHTAM ROAD TO GilL KHAN CHANDIO MILE 0/0-0/5.

SR NO


M/S MARTAM ENTERPRISES MIS SAAI) KROKHAR ENTERPRISES


PART "A" (ROAD WORK

I Amount of Schedule 'B' 6460844 6460844 6460844

2 Add: 8% Above 516868 7,60% Above (+) 491024 8.63% Above (+) 557571

3 Ded: Dill Cost of Bitumen (-) 399222 399222 399222

PART "A" 6578490 6552646 6619193 PART B" (ROAD WORK

1 Amount of Schedule"B" 172242 172242 172242

2 Perimum --- 16% Above (+) 27559 17% Above (+) 29281

3 Add: Cartage of Material (4) 28992

PART "B"

X2

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C+D: -

201234

402468

6980958

x 2

199801

399602

6952248

x 2 =

201523

403046

7022239


[(WAHEEOUXA1I J ASSIS'ANT EN. I1IGHWIYS SUB-P iO

ROHRI

EXECUTIVE Ne11QEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION (ABDUL HE)EMON1

ASSISTANT 1TGINEER PBIIiEAIEALTH ENGG: SUBIvSON

ROHRI



NAME OF WORK CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM KHUDA BUX MAHTAM ROAD TO GUL KHAN CHANDIO MILE 0/0-

0/5.


WITH P.E.0 SIIIDH BOARD OF REVENUE

RELEVANT EXPERIENCE


FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST

MONEY


DOCUMENT

I M/S MAI-ITAM ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available l)cpositid

2 M/S SAAD KHOKHAR ENTERPRISES Available gistered Registered Avatiab AvdabIe Avwi.Ii Available Denosited


(RAFIQUE AHMJ>SRAIKH) (WAHEED BUX QASMI) (ABDUL HAP MEMON) EXECUTENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION HIGHWAYS SUB.DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ENGGtSUBDIVISION

SUKKUR ROHRI ROHRI

• FENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

• NAME OF WORK: - WIDEN: /RECDG OF ROAD FROM VILLAGE AL! WAHAN TO VILLAGE ARAIN SUKKUR MILE 0/0-1/0.


SR. NO.


1 M/S RH & BROTHERS COMPANY &

I'rop:

2 M/SABDULSATTARARBANI&CO

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHIj SHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX 1I) (ABDUL HAFEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER


0

lD EVALUTION REPORI



3 Tender Description! Name of Work/ Item WIDEN: /RECDG OF ROAD FROM VILLAGE ALl WAHAN TO VILLAGE ARAIN SUKKUR MILE 0/0-1/0.


5 Tender Published Published In (i)Daily Awaini Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17

(ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17




8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Apolicablel

--


01 No.

(0 Bids Rejected 01 Nos.





1 MIS RH & BROTHERS COMPANY

6259179 in Lowest 177695 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S ABDUL SATFAR ARBANI & CO



CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED ThflKH) EXECUTIVEN1NEER


MEMBER

ML (WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGtNEER


MEMBER

Th (ABDUL HAFEIMEMON) -

ASSISTANT ENGINEERT PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG SUB-DIVISION

ROHRI

29439 29741 29886 PART "C"

6259179 6319914 6319683 GRAND TOTAL A, B, C: -

116960 ADD: CONTIGENCY (LUM-SUM)

The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS RH & BROTHERS COMPANY Government Contractor are:- 6436874 6259179

177695 2.76

6500000 6259179

240821

PART "A" (j Rs. 13% Above (Rupees Thirteen Percent Above) PART "B" @ Rs. 9.80°i Above (Rupees Nine Point Eighty Percent Above) PART "C" @ Rs. 12% Above (Rupees Twelve Percent Above)


Saving (Ai-B) Percentage Saving


Saving Over A.A

ION, EXECU E HIGHWAYS D

SU' R ABDULHAI ASSISTANT E

PUBLIC HEALTH FC SUB.DIV;SION 1<0 hR

Lowest Rates are Recommet'led for Aproval

I(WAHEED BUXJQASM) ASSISTANT Et4G)NEER t0HW-AS SUBDIVIS)ON

ROHRI

F1NNCIALRJVIEWJ COMPARI.JJVESTATEMNT

NAME OF WORK; - WIDEN: /RECDG OF ROAD FROM VILLAGE ALl WAHAN TO VILLAGE ARAIN SUKKUR MILE 0/0-1/0.

SR NO

ESTIMATE

M/S RH & BROTHERS COMPANY

RATE II AMOUNT

MIS ABDUL, SATTAR ARBANI & CO

RATE AMOUNT DESCRIPTION

PART "A" tROAD WORK


2 Add: 14 % Above )) 818722 13% Above (+) 760242 14% Above (+) 818722

3 Ded: Dill Cost of Bitumen )-) 567637 567637 567637

PART "A" 6099098 6040618 6099098 PART "B" (3' SPAN CULVERT)

I Amount of Schedule "B" 172242 1 72242 172242

2 Pcrmiuin -- 9.80% Above (+) 16880 10.80% Above (+) 18602

3 Add: Cartage of Material () 18688

PART "B" 190930 189122 190844 PART "C" (PIPE CULVERT


2 Permium -- 12% Above ('9 3154 13.15% Above (+) 3456

3 Add: Cartage of Material ('9 3601

N.T.N ] RELEVANT

EXPERIENCE


I 05% TENDER FEEl

EARNEST COST BIDDING MONEY DOCUMENT

SR. NO.

NAME OF FIRM/ BIDDERS REGISTRATION


FUNDS/ BUDGET


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

!3IJ J UA LI TIRJ



WIDEN: /RECDG OF ROAD FROM VILLAGE ALl WAHAN TO VILLAGE ARAIN SUKKUR MILE 0/0-1/0.

1 MIS RH & BROTHERS COMPANY \v,tcI.iIir I'gjsot Registered Available Available .vaiIah1e Available Deposited

2 M/S ABDUI. SATTAl ARI3ANI & CO Available Registered Registered \viilale Available AvaW,l,lc Avad,bl Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHNED$HAIKH) EXECUTIVE E1GINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR



(ABDUL HAFE - MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENUG: SUB-DIVISION RORRI

ATTENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIFATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO LOUNG BHANBHRO MILE 0/0-0/54330'.


SR. NO.


1 M/S PINE HILLS CONSTRUCTION GROUP

2 M/S BILAWAL CONSTRUCTION & CO

'I CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED$1AIKH)

EXECUTIVE EI(GINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

S

(WAHEEDBUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


(ABDUL HAF EZ MEMON) ASSISTANT 9INEER


ID EVALUTION REPORT



3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO LOUNG BHANBHRO MILE 0/0-0/5~330.


5 Tender Published Published in (l)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17 (ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Datcd. 07.12.2017





--


01 No.





THE BIDDER COST COST (SAVING) RLJECTION

1 MIS PINE HILLS CONSTRUCTION GROUP

6052862 i' Lowest 46138 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S BILAWAL CONSTRUCTION & CO

6103194 2nd Higher -4194 Rejected Being Higher


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEDRAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENINEER


MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVPION ROHRI

MEMBER






Saving Over A,A

6099000 6052862

46138 0.76

6100000 6052862

47138

(ABDIJL HAFEZ ASStSTANT Efi4EER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SU6OI VISION -- Rutflcl

FINANCIAL REVIEW I COMPAATIVESI'ATEMINT

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO LOUNG BHANBHRO MILE 0/0- 0/5~330.

SR NO


M/S PINE HILLS CONSTRUCTION GROUP (MIS BILAWAL CONSTRUCTION & Co

L_______________ RATE J AMOUNT RATE 1 AMOUNT

PART "A" (ROAD WORK

1 Amount of Schedule"13" 2935717 2935717 2935717

2 Add: 8% Above (-) 234857 7.40% Above (+) 217243 83O'o Above (+) 243665

3 Ded: Diff Cost of Bitumen (-) 199611 199611 199611 PART "A" 2970963 2953349 2979771

PART "B (ROAD WORK 1 Amount of Schedule "B" 2744037 2744037 2744037 2 Add: 14% Above (+) 384165 13.40% Above (+) 367701 14.20% Above (+) 389653 3 Ded: Diff Cost of Bitumen (-) 239624 239624 239624

PART "B" 2888578 2872114 2894066 PART c (3 SPAN CULVERTS)

I Amount of Schedule"B" 172242 172242 172242

2 Permium -- 14% Above (+) 24114 15% Above (4) 25836

3 Add: Cartage of Material (+) 25957 PART "C' 198199 196356 198078

PART "D" (PIPE CULVERTS


2 Permiuzn -- 18.10% Above (+) 4758 19% Above (+) 4994

3 Add: Cartage of Material 4926 PART "D" 31211 31043 31279

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C+D: - 6088951 6052862 6103194


The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS PINE HILLS CONSTRACTION GROUP Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" @ Rs. 7.40% Above (Rupees Seven Point Forty Percent Above) PART "B" @ Rs. 13.40% Above (Rupees Thirteen Point Forty Percent Above) PART "C" ( Rs. 14% Above (Rupees Fourteen Percent Above) PART "D" ® Rs. 18,10% Above (Rupees Eighteen Point Ten Percent Above) Lowest Rates are Recommended for Approval

(WAHEED BUX cASM' ASSISTANT ENGiNEE"

J-ILGHWAYS SUB-DIVLSION

EXECUTIVE EN4NER HIGH WAYS-tILVISION

SUKKUR

0


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

I'IArIQ?


EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SURKUR

CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD FROM ARRORE BACHAL SHAH ROAD TO LOUNG BHANBHRO MILE 0/0-0/5+330'.

SR. NO. NAME OF FERMI BIDDERS N.T.N

REGISTRATION WITH P.E.0

SINDH BOARD OF REVENUE

RELEVANT EXPERIENCE


BUDGET

05% EARNEST

MONEY


DOCUMENT

1 MIS PINE HILLS CONSTRUCTION

GROUP


2 MIS BILAWAL CONSTRUCTION & CO Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


(RAFIQUE AHMD.-SNA'1KE) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINER


E ' (ABDUL HAF Z MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGGiSUB-DWISION ROHRI


NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD ON CANAL INSPECTION PATH AT VILLAGE BHAI KHAN GHANGHRO UC TAMCHANI MILE 0/0-0/3 (0.60 KM).


SR. NO.



gi's'

2 MIS HASSAN & SONS CONSTRUCTION

3 M/SZAWARBHAMBHRO&CO /

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHM3SHAIKH)

EXECUTIy(ENGINEER

HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER

I i1M 2

MEMBER




PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB-DIVISION

ROHRI

ID EVALUTION REPORT



3 Tender Description! Name of Work! Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD ON CANAL INSPECTION PATH AT VILLAGE BHAI KHAN GHANGHRO UC TAMCHANI MILE 0/0-0/3 (0.60 KM).


5 Tender Published Published in (1)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17

(H) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (Il) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017





--


01 No.





THE BIDDER COST COST (SAVING) 1 REJECTION

1 5952849 i' Lowest 46151 Accepted Being Lowest

2 6010186 2nd Higher -11186 Rejected Being Higher

3 6102198 3 Highest -103198 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMED 5HAIKH) EXECUTIVEENtINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

\,4' E\. _)' '-

(WAHEED BUX QA1SMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER



PUBLIC HEALTH EN(G: SUB-DIVISION ROHRI

M/S ZAWAR BIIAMBHRO & CO

RATE AMOUNT

1'he Lowest Rates Qouted By M/S S.A MUNAM ENTERPRISES Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" @ Rs. 7.20% Above (Rupees Seven Point Twenty Percent Above) PART "B" @ Rs. 11% Above (Rupees Eleven Percent Above)





Saving Over A.A

5999000 5952849

46151 0.77

6000000 5952849

47151

PART "B" 589179 585594 591555 602001

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C: - 5998805 5952849 6010186 6102198


(ABDUL HAFEE ASSISTANT

PUBL(C HEALTH EGG....... "''- ROHRL

4G' pssts. s sUB.0tt GNP'

FINANCIAL REVIEW / COMPARATWE STATEMNT

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD ON CANAL INSPECTION PATH AT VILLAGE BHAI KHAN GHANGHRO UC TAMCHANI MILE 0/0-0/3 (0.60 1CM).

SR NO


M/S S.A MUNAM ENTERPRISES

RATE .1

MIS RASSAN & SONS CONSTRUCTION

AMOUNT RATE AMOUNT

PART "A" (ROAD WORK

1 Amount of Schedule"B" 5296511 5296511 5296511 5296511

2 Add: 8% Above (+) 423720 7.20% Above (+) 381349 8.17% Above (~) 432725 9.71% Above (+) 514291

3 Ded:DiffCostofBitumen () 310605 310605 310605 310605

PART "A" 5409626 5367255 5418631 5500197 PART "B 16 SPAN CTJLVERTS

1 Amount of Schedule"B" 527562 527562 527562 527562

2 Fermium -- 11% Above (+) 58032 12.13% Above (+) 63993 14.11% Above (+) 74439


EXECUTIVEI4TNEER \ HIGHWAYS DIVS1ON

SIJKKUR

QT.IF'IcA?EION



CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD ON CANAL INSPECTION PATH AT VILLAGE BHAI KHAN GHANGHRO UC TAMCHANI MILE 0/0-0/3 (0.60 KM).


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

SR. NAME OF FIRM! BIDDERS N.T.N REGISTRATION SINDH BOARD RELEVANT

EXPERIENCE

TURNOVER OF AT LEAST

05% EARNEST


NO. WITH P.E.0 OF REVENUE THREE BUDGET MONEY DOCUMENT

I

I M/S S.A MUNAM ENTERPRISES Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS HASSAN & SONS CONSTRUCTION


3 MIS ZAWAR BHAMI3IIRO & CO Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHME EXECUT1VEINGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

MEMBER



MEMBER

(ABDUL RAFEZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER



NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS AT VILLAGE ALLAH BUX JAMALI (REMAINING WORK).

EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR HELD ON 22. 12.20 17

SR. NO.


1 MIS ASIF BALOCH & COMPANY

2 M/S GHULAM ALl SOOMRO

3 M/S MUHAMMAD SIDDIQUE SHUJRAH

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHI SHAIKH)


SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

/ (ABDUL HAFEE(EMON)

ASSISTANT E1GINEER PUBLIC HEALTH ENGG: SUB-DIVISION

ROHRI



ID EVAL.UTION REPORT 5K-Oil



3 Tender Description/ Name of Work/ Item CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS AT VILLAGE ALLAH BUX JAMALI (REMAINING WORK).

4 Method of Procurement Single Stage (By Competitive Rate! I3id)

5 Tender Published Published in (l)Daily Awamj Awaz Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17 (ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17




8 Technical Bid Opening Date (If Arrnlicablel

--


01 No.






COMPARISON WITH



COST

1 MIS ASIF BALOCH & COMPANY

4066032 lt Lowest 102968 Accepted Being Lowest

2 MIS GHULAM ALl SOOMRO 4098080 2t Higher 70920 Rejected Being Higher

3 MIS MUHAMMAD SIDDIQUE SHUJRAH

4126121 3rd Highest 42879 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

4d (RAFIQUE AHME-81AIKH)


SUKKUR

MEMBER MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGiNEER


(ABDUL HAF EZ MEMON) ASSISTANT EN9INEER


M/S ASIF BALOCH & COMPANY M/S GHULAM ALt SOOMRO SIDDIQZJ ESTIMATE DESCRIPTION

SR NO

MIS MUHAMMAD SHUJRA}1

AMOUNT AMOUNT AMOUNT RATE RATE RATE




Saving Over A.A

4169000 4066032

102968 2.47

4200000 4066032

133968

(ABDULHAF E ASSISTANT E' INEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGO: SUB.DIVISION ROHRI

(WAHEED BUX ASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


NAME OF WORK: -

EINANCIALREWEW JOMPARATIVE STATEMNT

SR-oil CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS AT VILLAGE ALLAH BUX JAMALI (REMAINING WORK).

PART "A" ROAD WORK


2 Dccl: 20% Below (on Paver Block Only) n Rs. 2947606/-

589521 1.50% Above (+) 60089 2.30% Above (+) 92137 3% Above (+) 120178

3 Add: cartageofMaterial (+) 671981

GRAND TOTAL A, B, C: - 4088403 4066032 4098080 4126121


The Lowest Rates Qouted By ASIF ALl Government Contractor are:-

Part "A" @ Rs. 1,50% Above (Rupees One Point Fifty Percent Above)


EXECUTIVE ENGINiR HIGH WAY,J~tcJ1SION

S U icR U R

4


NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

___IIA'rIJ



CONSTRUCTION OF PAVER BLOCK FLOORING & DRAINS AT VILLAGE ALLAH BUX JAMAL! (REMAINING WORK).

SR. NO. NAME OF FIRM/ BIDDERS N.T.N REGISTRATION


RELEVANT EXPERIENCE

TURNOVER OF AT LEAST LAST THREE

FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST

MONEY


DOCUMENT

I MIS ASIF BALOCH & COMPANY Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposiled

2 M/S (IIIULAM AU SOOMRO Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

3 MIS MUHAMMAD SIDDIQUE SHUJRAH



(RAFIQUE AHMEJ)-8HAIKH) EXECUTIVENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR



(ABDTJL HAF Z MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGGi SUB-DIVISION ROHRI


NAME OF WORK: - Construction of road village Khahi uc Pir Ikhlas Shah


SR. NO.


1 M/SAIJAZALI

M/S Aijai Au Govt: Contrt

2 M/S MUHAMMAD MALOOK KATO

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEBHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER

\J¼ C ,vw' — (WAHEED BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER




JQELALUTLON REPORT


2 Tender Reference No. N.1.T No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17

3 Tender Description! Name of Work! Item Construction of road village Khahi uc Pir Ikhlas Shah


5 Tender Published Published in (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07. 12.2017 (ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (iv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017





--


01 No.






1 M/SAIJAZALI 5248625 1st Lowest 65374 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S MUHAMMAD MALOOI< KATO



CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHjD-sflAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER


MEMBER MEMBER



(WAHEED BUX QSMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


The Lowest Rates Qouted By MIS AIJAZ ALl Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" (j Rs. 7.50% Above (Rupees Seven Point Fifty Percent Above) PART 'B" RS. 13.50% Above (Rupees Thirteen Point Fifty Percent Above) PART "C" @ Rs. 13% Above (Rupees Thirteen Percent Above)

Lowest Rates are Recommended for /*,proval


Saving (A~B) Percentage Saving


Saving Over A.A

5314000 5248626

65374 1.23

5317000 5248626

68374

PART "C" 195706 194633 196356 Therefor 2 x 391412 x 2 = 389266 x 2 392712

GRAND TOTAL A+B+C: - 5273939 5248626 5285139


ABDULHA EE 'EM ASSISTANTE lEER

FUBLIC HEPITH ENGG: SUB.UIVISION ROHR%

EXECUTIVE E81ER -

HIGHWS"DIVSLOJ HVM)

FINANCIAL REVIEW 1 COMPARATWE STATEMNT

NAME OF WORK: - Construction of road village Khahi uc Pir Ikh1as Shah

NO

-

DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE MIS AIJAZ ALl MIS MUHAMMAD MALOOK KATO


PART A (ROAD WORK


2 Add: 8 % Above (+) 160005 7.50% Above (+) 150005 8.10% Above (+) 162005

3 Ded:DiffCostofBitumen (-) 119812 119812 119812 PART "A" 2040258 2030258 2042258

PART "B" (ROAD WORK


2 Add: 14 % Above (+) 368678 13.50% Above (+) 355511 14.30% Above (+) 376578

3 Ded: Duff Cost of Bitumen (-) 159824 159824 159824 PART "B" 2842269 2829102 2850169

PART "C" 13' SPA( CULVERTS 1 Amount of Schedule "B" 172242 172242 172242 2 Permium -- 13% Above (+) 22391 14% Above (+) 24114 3 Add: Cartage of Material () 23464 -

(WAHEE P

(twsvO"

SR. NO. NAME OF FIRM! BIDDERS N.T.N

REGISTRATION WITH P.E.0

SINDH BOARD RELEVANT OF REVENUE I EXPERIENCE



DOCUMENT

FUNDS/ BUDGET

05% EARNEST

MONEY

A V

TENDER REFERENCE NO. N.I.T No. EE/}IW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17

NAME OF PROCURING EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION StJXKUR

NAME OF WORK Construction of road village Khahi uc Pir Ikh1as Shah

1 M/S AIJAZ ALl Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS MUHAMMAD MALOOK KATO Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


/ (RAFIQUE AHMEJ)-SHAIKH) (WAHEED BUX QAS I) (ABDUL HAI4 MEMON)

EXECUTIViGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER ASSISTANT ENGINEER HIGHWYS DIVISION HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISION PUBLIC HEALTH ZNG: SUB-DIVISION

SUKKUR ROHRI ROHRI

SR. NO.

SIGNATURE NAME OF CONTRACTOR

MEMBER MEMBER

TENDANCE SHEET OF PARTICIPATION IN TENDER PROCESS IN EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION SUKKUR

NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD PAVER FLOORING & DRAINAGE AT VILLAGE SILAHI CHACHAR GHULAM ALl MAHESAR AMIR KHAN ARBANI MIR KHAN KHOSO QAIM JISKANI VARIOUS STREET UC PANO GHULAM ALL


1 M/S HAMADULLAH ABBASI

riAMA LLA (OVT cOTP

2 M/S MAJID GULZAR SHAIKH

4. 3 M/S BLUE STONE ASSOCIATE

('I,

CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMJSHAIKH) EXECUTIVENGINEER




(ABDUL HAFEEZMEMON) ASSISTANT F1iNEER


MEMBER

(ABDUL HAFEZ)IEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


LD EVALUTION REPORT SK-081


2 Tender Reference No. N.I.TNo. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.2017

3 Tender Description/ Name of Work! Item CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD PAVER FLOORING & DRAINAGE AT VILLAGE SILAHI CHACHAR GRULAM ALl MAHESAR AMIR KHAN ARBANI MIR KHAN KHOSO QAIM JISKANI VARIOUS STREET UC PANO GHULAM ALl.


5 Tender Published Published In (i)Daily Awami Awaz Karachi Dated. 07. 12.2017

(ii) Daily Express Karachi Dated. 07.12.20 17 (iii) Daily Dawn Karachi Dated. 07.12.2017 (lv) Daily Sobh Karachi Dated. 07. 12.20 17

SPPRA ID NO:2147483647 S.No. 35535 Dated: 05-12-2017




--


01 No.




COST RANKING IN COMPARISON REASONS FOR SR it NAME OF FIRM OF BIDDER OFFERED BY TERMS OF WITH ESTIMATE ACCEPTANCE/ REMARKS


1 M/S HAMADULLAH ABBASI 4415322 1st Lowest 76680 Accepted Being Lowest

2 M/S MAJID GULZAR SHAIKH


3 M/S BLUE STONE ASSOCIATE

4506718 3 Highest -14716 Rejected Being Highest


CHAIRMAN

(RAFIQUE AHMEDfiAIKH) EXECUTIVLEI1INEER


MEMBER

(WAHEED BUX tASMI) ASSISTANT ENINEER


*

EXECUT1VEEN1NR4 HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR I'

ABDUL HAFE ASSSTANTE

PUBLiC riEAL1H ENGG: UB'DIVISION ROHRI

i tHEE.D B4J.XQASMI)l ASSISTANT E'4GINEER

HIGHWAYS SUB-DIVISIO ROHRI

b

C F FINANCIAL REVIEW I COMPARATWE STATEMNT

SK-081 NAME OF WORK: - CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD PAVER FLOORING & DRAINAGE AT VILLAGE SILAHI CHACHAR GHULAM AL!

MAHESAR AMIR KHAN ARBANI MIR KHAN KHOSO QAIM JISKANI VARIOUS STREET UC PANO GHULAM ALl.

ISR NO

DESCRIPTION ESTIMATE M/S HAMADULLAR ABBASI MIS MAJID GULZAR SHAIKH

]

i7S BLUE STONE ASSOCIATE

RATE AMOUNT RATE AMOUNT [] RATE AMOUNT

PART "A' (PAVER BLOCK

1 AmountofSchedule"B' 3670177 3670177 3670177 3670177


609698 2% Above (+) 73404 3% Above (+) 110105 4% Above (+) 146807

3 Add: Cartage of Material (-) 721521

PART "A" 3782000 3743581 3780282 3816984 PART "B" (MASONARY STRUCTURE


2 Perinium -- 12% Above (+) 71972 13% Above (+) 77970 15% Above (+) 89965

3 Add: Cartage of Material (-!-) 73532 -

PART "B" 673301 671741 677739 689734

GRAND TOTAL A, B: - 4455301 4415322 4458021 4506718


The Lowest Rates Qoured By MiS HAMADULLAH ABBASI Government Contractor are:-

PART "A" @ Rs. 2% Above (Rupees Two Percent Above) PART "B" @ Rs. 12% Above (Rupees Twelve Percent Above)



Saving (A~B) 76680 Percentage Saving 1.71




NAME OF PROCURING

NAME OF WORK

1 P.

Q i'i'riw N.LT No. EE/HW-D/TC/ 503 Dated. 04.12.20 17


CONSTRUCTION OF ROAD PAVER FLOORING & DRAINAGE AT VILLAGE SILAHI CHACHAR GHULAM AL! MAHESAR AMIR KHAN ARBANI MIR KHAN KHOSO QAIM JISKANI VARIOUS STREET UC PANO GHULAM AL!.

SR. NO.


WITH P.E.0 SINDH BOARD OF' REVENUE

RELEVANT EXPERIENCE


FUNDS! BUDGET

05% EARNEST



I M/S HAMADULLAH AB13AS1 Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

2 MIS MAJID GULZAR SHAIKH Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited

3 MIS BLUE STONE ASSOCIATE Available Registered Registered Available Available Available Available Deposited


/

(ABDIJL HAP EZ MEMON) ASSISTANT ENGINEER

PUBLIC HEALTH ENGO: SUB-DIVISION ROHRI

(RAFIQUE AHE-SHAIKH) EXECUTIVE ENGINEER HIGHWAYS DIVISION

SUKKUR

(WAHEE1) BUX QASMI) ASSISTANT ENGINEER


office of the executive engineer highways division sukkur

Documents

Transcript of office of the executive engineer highways division sukkur