LegalMetric Company Research Report Samsung
101
LegalMetric Company Research Report Samsung January 2013 to March 2016 This report contains confidential and proprietary information of LegalMetric, Inc. Use of this information by anyone other than the purchaser or, if the purchaser is a law firm, the purchaser's client, or disclosure of this information to persons other than the purchaser or, if the purchaser is a law firm, the purchaser's client, without the consent of LegalMetric, Inc. is prohibited. The information contained in this report is obtained from the official docket records of the federal courts. No attempt has been made to correct that data. For example, cases may be misclassified in the official docket records. In addition, cases are classified only by the primary cause of action. Cases having multiple causes of action are analyzed only under the primary cause of action identitied on the official court docket. LegalMetric, Inc. is not a law firm, does not provide legal advice, and is not engaged in the practice of law. No attorney-client relationship exists between LegalMetric, Inc. and any user of its products. LegalMetric provides statistical and analytical information to anyone who desires to purchase that information. Any purchaser of LegalMetric products who wants legal advice should hire an attorney. 1
-
Upload
khangminh22 -
Category
Documents
-
view
2 -
download
0
Transcript of LegalMetric Company Research Report Samsung
LegalMetric Company Research Report
SamsungJanuary 2013 to March 2016
This report contains confidential and proprietary information of LegalMetric, Inc. Use of this information by
anyone other than the purchaser or, if the purchaser is a law firm, the purchaser's client, or disclosure of this
information to persons other than the purchaser or, if the purchaser is a law firm, the purchaser's client, without
the consent of LegalMetric, Inc. is prohibited.
The information contained in this report is obtained from the official docket records of the federal courts. No
attempt has been made to correct that data. For example, cases may be misclassified in the official docket
records. In addition, cases are classified only by the primary cause of action. Cases having multiple causes of
action are analyzed only under the primary cause of action identitied on the official court docket.
LegalMetric, Inc. is not a law firm, does not provide legal advice, and is not engaged in the practice of law. No
attorney-client relationship exists between LegalMetric, Inc. and any user of its products. LegalMetric provides
statistical and analytical information to anyone who desires to purchase that information. Any purchaser of
LegalMetric products who wants legal advice should hire an attorney.
1
Overview:The dockets of patent cases filed or decided from January 2013 to March 2016 nationwide were examined to identify
cases in which the company identified below and/or its related companies were identified as parties. There were 275
such cases found. The report breaks down these cases by party type (plaintiff, defendant), year, district and outcome.
Cases by District:The districts in which Samsung appeared as a party are identified in the table below.
Total
Total 276
California Central District Court 2
California Northern District Court 16
California Southern District Court 6
Colorado District Court 1
Delaware District Court 40
District of Columbia District Court 1
Florida Middle District Court 8
Florida Northern District Court 1
Florida Southern District Court 1
Georgia Northern District Court 1
Illinois Northern District Court 6
Massachusetts District Court 1
Michigan Eastern District Court 2
Michigan Western District Court 1
New Jersey District Court 3
New York Eastern District Court 1
New York Southern District Court 3
New York Western District Court 1
North Carolina Eastern District Court 1
Pennsylvania Eastern District Court 2
Pennsylvania Middle District Court 1
Puerto Rico District Court 1
Tennessee Western District Court 2
Texas Eastern District Court 160
Texas Northern District Court 2
Texas Western District Court 52
Total
Virginia Eastern District Court 6
Washington Western District Court 1
Venue Choices:The districts in which Samsung filed patent cases are identified in the chart below.
1Delaware District Court
1
Illinois Northern DistrictCourt
1
Texas Eastern DistrictCourt
1
Virginia EasternDistrict Court
Districts Where Company Filed SuitFor Samsung
3
Party Status:The numbers of cases in which this company appeared as a plaintiff or as a defendant are illustrated below.
272Defendant
4Plaintiff
Defendant 98.6%Plaintiff 1.4%
Total: 100.0%
Party Status in LitigationFor Samsung
4
Win Rates by District:The overall, contested and trial win rates for this company by district, are shown below. Note that for most companies
the number of judgments in any given district is fairly low, so the odds of a 100% or a 0% win rate are good.
Total
Overall Win Rate Contested Win Rate Trial Win Rate
Total 83.3 80.0 62.5
California
Central District
Court
Total
Defendant
California
Northern
District Court
Total 66.7 66.7 0.0
Defendant 66.7 66.7 0.0
California
Southern
District Court
Total
Defendant
Colorado
District Court
Total
Defendant
Delaware
District Court
Total 100.0 100.0
Defendant 100.0 100.0
Plaintiff
District of
Columbia
District Court
Total 100.0 100.0
Defendant 100.0 100.0
Florida Middle
District Court
Total 100.0 100.0
Defendant 100.0 100.0
Florida
Northern
District Court
Total
Defendant
Florida
Southern
District Court
Total
Defendant
Georgia
Northern
District Court
Total
Defendant
Illinois
Northern
District Court
Total 100.0 100.0 100.0
Defendant 100.0 100.0 100.0
Plaintiff
Massachusetts
District Court
Total5
Total
Overall Win Rate Contested Win Rate Trial Win Rate
Massachusetts
District Court
Defendant
Michigan
Eastern
District Court
Total
Defendant
Michigan
Western
District Court
Total
Defendant
New Jersey
District Court
Total 100.0 100.0
Defendant 100.0 100.0
New York
Eastern
District Court
Total
Defendant
New York
Southern
District Court
Total
Defendant
New York
Western
District Court
Total
Defendant
North Carolina
Eastern
District Court
Total
Defendant
Pennsylvania
Eastern
District Court
Total
Defendant
Pennsylvania
Middle District
Court
Total
Defendant
Puerto Rico
District Court
Total
Defendant
Tennessee
Western
District Court
Total
Defendant
Texas Eastern
District Court
Total 80.0 75.0 75.0
Defendant 80.0 75.0 75.0
Plaintiff
Texas
Northern
District Court
Total 0.0 0.0 0.0
Defendant 0.0 0.0 0.0 6
Total
Overall Win Rate Contested Win Rate Trial Win Rate
Texas Western
District Court
Total 100.0 100.0 100.0
Defendant 100.0 100.0 100.0
Virginia
Eastern
District Court
Total 100.0 100.0
Defendant 100.0 100.0
Plaintiff
Washington
Western
District Court
Total
Defendant
Cases Filed by Year and Party Status:The number of cases filed in which this company was a party, by year, is shown below.
0
20
40
60
80
100
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
DefendantPlaintiff
Nu
mb
er
of
Ca
se
s
Cases Filed Each Year
7
Outcomes by Type:The breakdown of outcomes in closed cases for this company is shown below.
2Want of Prosecution
4Consent Judgment
18Consolidated
1Intra-District Transfer
4Involuntary Dismissal
8Jury Verdict
22Other Termination
7Stay
7Summary Judgment
9Transfer
136
Voluntary Dismissal andOther Settlement
Overall OutcomesFor Samsung
1Other Termination
1
Voluntary Dismissal andOther Settlement
Plaintiff Overall OutcomesFor Samsung
2Want of Prosecution
4Consent Judgment
18Consolidated
1Intra-District Transfer
4Involuntary Dismissal
8Jury Verdict
21Other Termination
7Stay
7Summary Judgment
9Transfer
135
Voluntary Dismissal andOther Settlement
Defendant Overall OutcomesFor Samsung
8
Outcomes by Judgment Type:The breakdown of outcomes in closed cases, broken out by judgment type, for this company is shown below.
4Involuntary Dismissal
1
Non-trial ContestedJudgment
7Summary Judgment
8Trial
4Uncontested Judgment
194
Case Closed WithoutJudgment
Outcome by Judgment TypeFor Samsung
Total
California Central District Court Total 2
Case Closed Without Judgment 2
California Northern District Court Total 15
Case Closed Without Judgment 12
Summary Judgment 2
Trial 1
California Southern District Court Total 2
Case Closed Without Judgment 2
Colorado District Court Total 1
Case Closed Without Judgment 1
Delaware District Court Total 36
Case Closed Without Judgment 35
Summary Judgment 19
Total
District of Columbia District Court Total 1
Summary Judgment 1
Florida Middle District Court Total 6
Case Closed Without Judgment 4
Involuntary Dismissal 2
Florida Northern District Court Total 1
Case Closed Without Judgment 1
Florida Southern District Court Total 1
Case Closed Without Judgment 1
Georgia Northern District Court Total 1
Case Closed Without Judgment 1
Illinois Northern District Court Total 4
Case Closed Without Judgment 3
Trial 1
Massachusetts District Court Total 1
Case Closed Without Judgment 1
Michigan Eastern District Court Total 2
Case Closed Without Judgment 2
New Jersey District Court Total 3
Case Closed Without Judgment 2
Involuntary Dismissal 1
New York Eastern District Court Total 1
Case Closed Without Judgment 1
New York Southern District Court Total 2
Case Closed Without Judgment 2
New York Western District Court Total 1
Case Closed Without Judgment 1
North Carolina Eastern District
Court
Total 1
Case Closed Without Judgment 110
Total
Pennsylvania Eastern District
Court
Total 2
Case Closed Without Judgment 2
Pennsylvania Middle District Court Total 1
Case Closed Without Judgment 1
Puerto Rico District Court Total 1
Case Closed Without Judgment 1
Tennessee Western District Court Total 2
Case Closed Without Judgment 2
Texas Eastern District Court Total 120
Case Closed Without Judgment 110
Non-trial Contested Judgment 1
Summary Judgment 3
Trial 4
Uncontested Judgment 2
Texas Northern District Court Total 2
Case Closed Without Judgment 1
Trial 1
Texas Western District Court Total 3
Case Closed Without Judgment 2
Trial 1
Virginia Eastern District Court Total 5
Case Closed Without Judgment 2
Involuntary Dismissal 1
Uncontested Judgment 2
Washington Western District Court Total 1
Case Closed Without Judgment 1
11
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Defendant Plaintiff
14.8
52.4
DefendantPlaintiff
Party Type
Mo
nth
s f
rom
Ca
se
Filin
g
Average Time to Case Termination, by Party StatusFor Samsung
0
4
8
12
16
20
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 27 28 29 30 31 33 34 35 36 37 38 40 41 44 47 48 51 61 66 72 78 84 88
Month of Litigation
Nu
mb
er
of
Ca
se
s C
los
ed
Cases Closed Each Month of LitigationFor Samsung
Time to Termination: All Closed CasesThe average time from case filing to termination for this party is shown immediately below, followed by a chart showing
the distribution of cases terminated each month of litigation for this party.
12
Time to Termination: Cases with Contested JudgmentsThe average time from case filing to termination by a contested judgment for this party (if any) is shown immediately
below, followed by a chart showing the distribution of such cases terminated each month of litigation for this party.
Contested judgments do not include consent and default judgments. Judgments resulting from trial, summary
judgments, and any other contested outcome in which a judgment is rendered in favor of a party are included. Note:
For a company with no contested judgments, the charts below are blank.
0
4
8
12
16
20
24
28
32
Defendant Plaintiff
29.2
DefendantPlaintiff
Party Type
Mo
nth
s f
rom
Ca
se
Filin
g
Average Time to Contested Judgment, by Party StatusFor Samsung
0
0.4
0.8
1.2
1.6
2
1
23
45
67
8910
1112
1314
1516
1718
1920
2122
2324
2728
2930
3133
3435
3637
3840
4144
4748
5161
6672
7884
88
Defendant
Plaintiff
Month of Litigation
Nu
mb
er
of
Ca
se
s C
los
ed
Cases Closed by Contested Judgment Each Monthof Litigation
For Samsung
13
Time to Termination: TrialThe average time from case filing to termination by a trial (if any) for this party is shown immediately below, followed by
a chart showing the distribution of such cases terminated each month of litigation for this party. Note: For a company
with no trials, the charts below are blank.
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Defendant Plaintiff
31.2
DefendantPlaintiff
Party Type
Mo
nth
s f
rom
Ca
se
Filin
gAverage Time to Trial Judgment, by Party Status
For Samsung
0
0.4
0.8
1.2
1.6
2
1
23
45
67
8910
1112
1314
1516
1718
1920
2122
2324
2728
2930
3133
3435
3637
3840
4144
4748
5161
6672
7884
88
DefendantPlaintiff
Month of Litigation
Nu
mb
er
of
Cases C
losed
Cases Closed by Trial Each Month of LitigationFor Samsung
14
Time to Termination: SettlementThe average time from case filing to termination by a settlement (if any) for this party is shown immediately below.
Cases terminated by settlement include consent judgments and cases which specifically mention settlement as the
reason for termination, as well as voluntary dismissals.
0
20
40
60
80
100
Defendant Plaintiff
14.5
87.0
DefendantPlaintiff
Mo
nth
s f
rom
Ca
se
Filin
gAverage Time to Settlement
For Samsung
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
1
23
45
67
89
1011
1213
1415
1617
1920
2122
2324
2830
3133
3536
3738
4041
4447
4851
6184
88
Month of Litigation
Nu
mb
er
of
Ca
se
s C
los
ed
Cases Closed by Month of LitigationFor Samsung
15
Current Pendency of Open CasesThe average times (in months) from case filing to the present for all open cases of this party are shown below.
Total
Total 9.5
California Northern District Court 0.9
California Southern District Court 8.9
Delaware District Court 7.5
Florida Middle District Court 12.3
Illinois Northern District Court 3.4
Michigan Western District Court 12.6
New York Southern District Court 3.2
Texas Eastern District Court 10.3
Texas Western District Court 5.2
Virginia Eastern District Court 15.9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
23
45
67
89
1011
1213
1516
1821
2228
3438
Month of Litigation
Nu
mb
er
of
Ca
se
s
Distribution of Pendency of Open CasesFor Samsung
16
Supporting Data: The supporting data for the charts and tables shown above follow.
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome Prevailing Party
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv08545California Central
District Court
Olympic Development AG,
LLC v. AT&T, Inc. et
al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
8:14cv01693California Central
District Court
SOTA Semiconductor LLC
v. Marvell Semiconductor,
Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
3:12cv04143California Northern
District Court
IpVenture Inc. v. Lenovo
Group Limited et al
Summary Judgment3:13cv00194 This PartyCalifornia Northern
District Court
Tse v. Google Inc., et al.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
3:13cv02715California Northern
District Court
Touchscreen Gestures
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co, Ltd; et al
Stay3:14cv05298California Northern
District Court
American Navigation
Systems, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
3:15cv00539California Northern
District Court
Rothschild Storage
Retrieval Innovations, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd., et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
3:15cv00975California Northern
District Court
Grecia v. Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC
Stay3:15cv03752California Northern
District Court
IXI Mobile (R&D) Ltd.
et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
3:16cv00557California Northern
District Court
Advanced Touchscreen
and Gesture Technologies
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD, et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
4:11cv02010California Northern
District Court
Orinda Intellectual
Properties USA Holding
Group, Inc. v. Asustek
Computer Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
4:11cv06636California Northern
District Court
Asustek Computer Inc. et
al v. Round Rock
Research, LLC et al
Other Termination4:14cv02717California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd et al
Consolidated4:14cv02966California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Other Termination4:14cv03030California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., LTD et al
Other Termination4:14cv03031California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. BlackBerry Limited et al
Summary Judgment5:10cv05545 This PartyCalifornia Northern
District Court
Nazomi Communications
Inc v. Samsung
Telecommunications Inc et
al
Jury Verdict5:12cv00630 Party Opposed to This PartyCalifornia Northern
District Court
Apple Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
3:13cv02740California
Southern District
Court
Largan Precision Co., Ltd.
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
3:14cv01474California
Southern District
Court
SPH America, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD. et al 17
Other Termination3:15cv01133California
Southern District
Court
ZiiLabs Inc., Ltd. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
3:15cv01738California
Southern District
Court
Odyssey Wireless, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
3:16cv00385California
Southern District
Court
FastVDO LLC v.
AT&T Mobility LLC et
al
3:16cv00395California
Southern District
Court
FastVDO LLC v. Dell Inc.
et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv00180Colorado District
Court
Cellport Systems, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:08cv00348Delaware District
Court
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. v. Petters Group
Worldwide LLC et al
Other Termination1:10cv00389Delaware District
Court
SoftView LLC v. Apple Inc.
et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00309Delaware District
Court
Walker Digital LLC v.
Google Inc. et al.
Summary Judgment1:11cv00440 This PartyDelaware District
Court
Apeldyn Corporation v.
Sony Corporation et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00798Delaware District
Court
Monec Holding AG v.
Motorola Mobility LLC et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00827Delaware District
Court
CyberFone Systems LLC
v. ZTE (USA) Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00833Delaware District
Court
CyberFone Systems LLC
v. Vizio Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv01165Delaware District
Court
Graphics Properties
Holdings Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
1:12cv00199Delaware District
Court
Pragmatus AV LLC v.
Asustek Computer Inc et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv00346Delaware District
Court
Data Carriers LLC v
Samsung Electronics
America Inc. et al.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv00388Delaware District
Court
Graphics Properties
Holdings Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Want of Prosecution1:12cv00483Delaware District
Court
Golden Bridge Technology
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv00533Delaware District
Court
Semcon Tech LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv00572Delaware District
Court
Smart Audio Technologies
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co Ltd et al
Other Termination1:12cv00987Delaware District
Court
SoftView LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Want of Prosecution1:12cv01167Delaware District
Court
Golden Bridge Technology
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co Ltd et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
1:12cv01278Delaware District
Court
Telecomm Innovations
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv01325Delaware District
Court
LED Tech Development
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics America Inc. et
al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv00011Delaware District
Court
InterDigital
Communications Inc. et al
v. Samsung Electronics
Co. Ltd. et al18
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv00317Delaware District
Court
Semcon Tech LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd, et al.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv00356Delaware District
Court
Technology Innovations
Associates LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv00999Delaware District
Court
PatentMarks
Communications LLC v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America LLC
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
1:13cv01434Delaware District
Court
Wyncomm LLC v.
Samsung, Inc.
Stay1:13cv01529Delaware District
Court
Optical Devices LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co
Ltd et al.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv01683Delaware District
Court
Pragmatus Mobile LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv01787Delaware District
Court
Alex is the Best LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Other Termination1:13cv01808Delaware District
Court
Memory Integrity LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
Company Ltd. et al.
Other Termination1:13cv02033Delaware District
Court
Home Semiconductor
Corporation v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Stay1:14cv00078Delaware District
Court
Cresta Technology
Corporation v. Silicon
Laboratories Inc. et al
Other Termination1:14cv00337Delaware District
Court
Surpass Tech Innovation
LLC v. Samsung Display
Co. Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:14cv00338Delaware District
Court
Surpass Tech Innovation
LLC v. Sharp Corporation
et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:14cv00441Delaware District
Court
Pragmatus Mobile LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co
Ltd et al.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:14cv00624Delaware District
Court
MAZ Encryption
Technologies LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co
Ltd
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
1:14cv00863Delaware District
Court
Sequent Data LLC v.
Toshiba Samsung Storage
Technology Korea
Corporation, et al.
Other Termination1:14cv01127Delaware District
Court
NVIDIA Corporation v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
1:14cv01430Delaware District
Court
Elm 3DS Innovations LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co. Ltd. et al
1:15cv00545Delaware District
Court
Evolved Wireless, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
1:15cv00752Delaware District
Court
Micro Design LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
1:15cv00898Delaware District
Court
ProMOS Technologies,
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
19
1:16cv00002Delaware District
Court
6115187 Canada Inc. v.
Samsung Techwin
America et al
Summary Judgment1:07mc00493 This PartyDistrict of
Columbia District
Court
IN RE: PAPST
LICENSING DIGITAL
CAMERA PATENT
LITIGATION - MDL 1880
3:15cv01477Florida Middle
District Court
Parkervision, Inc. v. Apple
Inc. et al
6:14cv00687Florida Middle
District Court
ParkerVision, Inc. v.
QUALCOMM Incorporated
et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:14cv01017Florida Middle
District Court
Orlando Communications
LLC v. LG Electronics, Inc.
et al
Involuntary Dismissal6:14cv01623 This PartyFlorida Middle
District Court
Orlando Communications
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:14cv01624Florida Middle
District Court
Orlando Communications
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Involuntary Dismissal6:14cv01625 This PartyFlorida Middle
District Court
Orlando Communications,
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:14cv01626Florida Middle
District Court
Orlando Communications
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co.,LTD. et al
Transfer8:14cv01131Florida Middle
District Court
American Navigation
Systems, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Other Settlement4:12cv00651Florida Northern
District Court
GLOBAL
COMMUNICATIONS INC
v. DIRECTV INC et al
Transfer1:14cv22653Florida Southern
District Court
Rothschild Storage
Retrieval Innovations, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd., et al
Other Settlement1:09cv01736Georgia Northern
District Court
Synchrome Technology
Inc. v. Toshiba America
Information Systems, Inc.,
et al
Jury Verdict1:11cv04574 This PartyIllinois Northern
District Court
Cascades Computer
Innovation, LLC v.
Motorola Mobility Holdings,
Inc. et al
Stay1:11cv06241Illinois Northern
District Court
ClassCo Inc. v. Apple, Inc.
et al
Other Termination1:14cv05691Illinois Northern
District Court
Cascades Computer
Innovation, LLC. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd.
Consolidated1:15cv00799Illinois Northern
District Court
Rosetta-Wireless Corp. v.
Apple Inc. et al
1:15cv10278Illinois Northern
District Court
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. v. Sockeye
Licensing TX LLC et al
1:15cv10605Illinois Northern
District Court
Rosetta-Wireless Corp. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv10659Massachusetts
District Court
Trustees of Boston
University v. Samsung
Electronics Company,
Limited et al
20
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:11cv12945Michigan Eastern
District Court
Visual Interactive Phone
Concepts, Inc. v. Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
2:15cv13935Michigan Eastern
District Court
Progme Corporation v.
Comcast Cable
Communications, LLC, et
al.
1:15cv00146Michigan Western
District Court
UUSI, LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Involuntary Dismissal2:09cv04354 This PartyNew Jersey
District Court
CCP SYSTEMS AG v.
SAMSUNG
ELECTRONICS CORP.,
LTD. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:12cv00952New Jersey
District Court
Voxpath RS, LLC v. LG
Electronics U.S.A., Inc. et
al
Consolidated2:13cv01189New Jersey
District Court
Voxpath RS, LLC v. Denon
Electronics (USA), LLC et
al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv04674New York Eastern
District Court
Amethyst IP, LLC v.
Samsung Opto-Electronics
America, Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv01899New York
Southern District
Court
Varia Holdings LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Transfer1:14cv04355New York
Southern District
Court
IXI Mobile (R&D) Ltd.
et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
1:15cv09266New York
Southern District
Court
Sentegra, LLC v. Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv06036New York Western
District Court
Eastman Kodak Company
v. Samsung Electronics
Company, Ltd. et al
Transfer5:14cv00490North Carolina
Eastern District
Court
Odyssey Wireless, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv03175Pennsylvania
Eastern District
Court
INFINITY COMPUTER
PRODUCTS, INC. v.
BROTHER
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION et al
Stay2:12cv06798Pennsylvania
Eastern District
Court
INFINITY COMPUTER
PRODUCTS, INC. v.
SAMSUNG
ELECTRONICS
AMERICA, INC.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
4:14cv00124Pennsylvania
Middle District
Court
The Penn State Research
Foundation v. Samsung
Electronics Co. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
3:13cv01099Puerto Rico
District Court
Canatelo, LLC v. Samsung
Techwin Co., Ltd. et al
Other Termination2:12cv02824Tennessee
Western District
Court
B.E. Technology, L.L.C. v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC
Other Termination2:12cv02825Tennessee
Western District
Court
B.E. Technology, L.L.C. v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00426Texas Eastern
District Court
E-Contact Technologies,
LLC v. Apple Inc. Et Al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv00455Texas Eastern
District Court
E-Contact Technologies
LLC v. Samsung
TeleCommunications
America, LLC21
Transfer1:12cv00557Texas Eastern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:14cv00237Texas Eastern
District Court
PanTaurus LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Summary Judgment1:15cv00052 This PartyTexas Eastern
District Court
AI Automation, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:09cv00372Texas Eastern
District Court
Levine v. Samsung
TeleCommunications
America, LLC et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv00091Texas Eastern
District Court
Microunity Systems
Engineering Inc v. Acer Inc
et al
Other Termination2:10cv00207Texas Eastern
District Court
Keranos, LLC v. Analog
Devices, Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv00490Texas Eastern
District Court
Vertical Computer
Systems, Inc. v.
Interwoven, Inc. et al
Other Settlement2:11cv00090Texas Eastern
District Court
Lodsys, LLC v. Brother
International Corporation
et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:11cv00193Texas Eastern
District Court
Internet Machines MC LLC
v. PLX TECHNOLOGY,
INC. et al
Other Termination2:11cv00331Texas Eastern
District Court
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd et al v. United Module
Corp. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:11cv00390Texas Eastern
District Court
Negotiated Data Solutions,
Inc. v. Apple Inc. et al
Other Settlement2:11cv00416Texas Eastern
District Court
SimpleAir, Inc. v. Microsoft
Corporation et al
Consolidated2:12cv00263Texas Eastern
District Court
Rotatable Technologies
LLC v. Acer America
Corporation et al
Consent Judgment2:12cv00265 This PartyTexas Eastern
District Court
Rotatable Technologies
LLC v. Nokia Inc
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:12cv00581Texas Eastern
District Court
TQP Development, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:12cv00747Texas Eastern
District Court
NovelPoint Tracking LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
America Inc
Consolidated2:12cv00824Texas Eastern
District Court
Concinnitas LLC v
Samsung
TeleCommunications
America LLC et al
2:13cv00017Texas Eastern
District Court
Keranos, LLC v. Silicon
Storage Technology, Inc.,
et al
Other Termination2:13cv00018Texas Eastern
District Court
Keranos, LLC v. Analog
Devices, Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00039Texas Eastern
District Court
Tierra Intelectual
Borinquen, Inc. v. HTC
Corporation et al
Consolidated2:13cv00045Texas Eastern
District Court
Tierra Intelectual
Borinquen, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Jury Verdict2:13cv00213 Party Opposed to This PartyTexas Eastern
District Court
Rembrandt Wireless
Technologies, LP v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
LTD., et al
22
Jury Verdict2:13cv00259 This PartyTexas Eastern
District Court
Mobile
Telecommunications
Technologies, LLC v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC
Other Termination2:13cv00379Texas Eastern
District Court
Black Hills Media, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00426Texas Eastern
District Court
Penovia LLC v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.,
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00452Texas Eastern
District Court
National Cheng Kung
University v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Consolidated2:13cv00504Texas Eastern
District Court
Bluebonnet
Telecommunications
L.L.C. v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00544Texas Eastern
District Court
Institute For Information
Industry v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00563Texas Eastern
District Court
Lake Cherokee Hard Drive
Technologies, L.L.C. v.
MediaTek USA Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00643Texas Eastern
District Court
Power Management
Enterprises LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America Inc
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00695Texas Eastern
District Court
Lake Cherokee Hard Drive
Technologies, L.L.C. v.
Marvell Asia Pte., Ltd et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00882Texas Eastern
District Court
Adrain v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Consolidated2:13cv00900Texas Eastern
District Court
Rockstar Consortium US
LP et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD., et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00906Texas Eastern
District Court
SecureNova, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Other Termination2:13cv00928Texas Eastern
District Court
Vantage Point Technology,
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Consolidated2:13cv00980Texas Eastern
District Court
eDekka LLC v. Samsung
Telecommunications
America LLC
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv01061Texas Eastern
District Court
e-Watch Inc. et al v. Apple,
Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv01062Texas Eastern
District Court
E-Watch, Inc et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Jury Verdict2:13cv01112 This PartyTexas Eastern
District Court
ContentGuard Holdings,
Inc. v. Amazon.com Inc. et
al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00051Texas Eastern
District Court
Tune Hunter Inc. v.
Samsung
TeleCommunications
America, LLC et al
Other Termination2:14cv00053Texas Eastern
District Court
Queens University at
Kingston et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Jury Verdict2:14cv00061 This PartyTexas Eastern
District Court
ContentGuard Holdings,
Inc. v. Google, Inc.
23
Consent Judgment2:14cv00199 This PartyTexas Eastern
District Court
DSS Technology
Management Inc. v.
Taiwan Semiconductor
Manufacturing Company,
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00203Texas Eastern
District Court
ZiiLabs Inc., Ltd v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
2:14cv00235Texas Eastern
District Court
Penovia LLC v. Samsung
Inc
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
2:14cv00293Texas Eastern
District Court
Saint Lawrence
Communications LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Consolidated2:14cv00345Texas Eastern
District Court
Olivistar, LLC v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00352Texas Eastern
District Court
Long Corner Consumer
Electronics LLC v. Archos,
Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00357Texas Eastern
District Court
Long Corner Consumer
Electronics LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00746Texas Eastern
District Court
Freeny et al v. Samsung
Telecommunications
America LLC
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00842Texas Eastern
District Court
Multiplayer Network
Innovations, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
2:14cv00902Texas Eastern
District Court
Parthenon Unified Memory
Architecture LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00940Texas Eastern
District Court
Tactile Feedback
Technology, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00960Texas Eastern
District Court
Magnacross LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv01118Texas Eastern
District Court
Dynamic Hosting
Company LLC v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv01153Texas Eastern
District Court
Dynamic Hosting
Company LLC v. Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC
2:14cv01165Texas Eastern
District Court
Koninklijke Kpn N.V. v.
SAMSUNG
ELECTRONICS
AMERICA, INC. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv01172Texas Eastern
District Court
Trover Group, Inc. et al v.
Kaltec Electronics, Inc. et
al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00086Texas Eastern
District Court
Trover Group, Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics
America Inc et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00103Texas Eastern
District Court
Wetro Lan LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
2:15cv00183Texas Eastern
District Court
Mobile
Telecommunications
Technologies, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al24
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
2:15cv00281Texas Eastern
District Court
Conversant Intellectual
Property Management, Inc.
et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
2:15cv00283Texas Eastern
District Court
NFC Technology, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
2:15cv00303Texas Eastern
District Court
LX Tech, LLC v. Maxim
Integrated Products, Inc. et
al
2:15cv00341Texas Eastern
District Court
Raytheon Company v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
2:15cv00432Texas Eastern
District Court
Corydoras Technologies,
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
2:15cv00456Texas Eastern
District Court
Porto Technology Co.,
LTD v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
et al
2:15cv00457Texas Eastern
District Court
Porto Technology Co.,
LTD v. Apple, Inc.
2:15cv00466Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Apple Inc.
2:15cv00467Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Dell Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00468Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
HTC America, Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00470Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
LG Electronics U.S.A., Inc.
et al
Consolidated2:15cv00471Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Microsoft Corporation
Consolidated2:15cv00473Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
2:15cv00576Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v.
AT&T Inc. et al
2:15cv00579Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v. Sprint
Corporation et al
2:15cv00580Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v.
T-Mobile USA, Inc. et al
2:15cv00581Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v. Verizon
Communications, Inc. et al
2:15cv00596Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Acer Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00598Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Amazon.com, Inc. et al
Other Termination2:15cv00606Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Fujitsu America, Inc. et al
2:15cv00608Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Hewlett-Packard Company
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00620Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Sonim Technologies, Inc.
2:15cv00625Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Toshiba Corporation et al
2:15cv00627Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Panasonic Corporation et
al
25
2:15cv00773Texas Eastern
District Court
Super Interconnect
Technologies LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00917Texas Eastern
District Court
Intellectual Capital
Consulting, Ltd. v. Hyundai
Motor Company et al
Transfer2:15cv00946Texas Eastern
District Court
FastVDO LLC v. Dell Inc.
et al
Consolidated2:15cv00948Texas Eastern
District Court
Koninklijke Kpn N.V. v.
Samsung Electronic
America, Inc., et al
2:15cv00998Texas Eastern
District Court
Display Technologies LLC
v. NVIDIA Corporation
Consolidated2:15cv01000Texas Eastern
District Court
Display Technologies LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Other Settlement2:15cv01077Texas Eastern
District Court
Cypaleo, LLC v. Acer, Inc.
et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv01119Texas Eastern
District Court
Broadqast Solutions, LLC
v. ESCORT Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv01127Texas Eastern
District Court
Broadqast Solutions, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
America Inc
Consolidated2:15cv01191Texas Eastern
District Court
Cypaleo, LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Other Settlement2:15cv01293Texas Eastern
District Court
Packet Tread LLC v.
Apple, Inc.
Consolidated2:15cv01316Texas Eastern
District Court
Packet Tread LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv01381Texas Eastern
District Court
Fujinomaki v. Google, Inc.
et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv01475Texas Eastern
District Court
Carnition LLC v. Apple Inc.
2:15cv01503Texas Eastern
District Court
TiVo Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD., et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv01506Texas Eastern
District Court
Carnition LLC v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
2:15cv01524Texas Eastern
District Court
511 Innovations, Inc. v.
HTC America, Inc. et al
2:15cv01526Texas Eastern
District Court
511 Innovations, Inc. v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
2:15cv01609Texas Eastern
District Court
Sockeye Licensing TX,
LLC v. Samsung
TeleCommunications
America, LLC
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv01686Texas Eastern
District Court
Tune Hunter Inc. v.
Microsoft Corporation et al
2:15cv01754Texas Eastern
District Court
Personalized Media
Communications, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
2:15cv01885Texas Eastern
District Court
IXI IP, LLC et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD, et al
2:15cv01924Texas Eastern
District Court
Iris Connex, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
2:15cv01970Texas Eastern
District Court
Visual Content IP, LLC v.
HTC America, Inc.
2:15cv02032Texas Eastern
District Court
Visual Content IP, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.26
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv02124Texas Eastern
District Court
Innovative Automation,
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
et al
2:16cv00092Texas Eastern
District Court
Meraloc, LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
2:16cv00169Texas Eastern
District Court
Lexington Luminance LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co, Ltd; et al
2:16cv00170Texas Eastern
District Court
Rembrandt Wireless
Technologies LP v.
Samsung Electronics Co
LTD et al
4:14cv00371Texas Eastern
District Court
Imperium IP Holdings
(Cayman), Ltd. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
4:14cv00433Texas Eastern
District Court
PLDN Holdings, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
LTD., et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
4:15cv00026Texas Eastern
District Court
Imperium IP Holdings
(Cayman), Ltd. v.
Samsung Techwin Co.,
Ltd. et al
4:16cv00111Texas Eastern
District Court
Jones v Samsung
Electronics America Inc, et
al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
5:06cv00239Texas Eastern
District Court
Antor Media Corporation v.
Samsung
Telecommunications LLP
et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
5:15cv00114Texas Eastern
District Court
Venadium LLC v. Acer
America Corporation
Consolidated5:15cv00131Texas Eastern
District Court
Venadium LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America Inc. et al
Summary Judgment6:10cv00561 This PartyTexas Eastern
District Court
Gemalto S.A. v. HTC
Corporation et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:11cv00195Texas Eastern
District Court
Hybrid Audio LLC v. HIGH
TECH COMPUTER
CORP. A/K/A HTC CORP.
et al
Summary Judgment6:11cv00474 This PartyTexas Eastern
District Court
Profectus Technology LLC
v. Huawei Technologies
Co., Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:11cv00492Texas Eastern
District Court
Network-1 Security
Solutions, Inc. v.
Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc. et
al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:11cv00647Texas Eastern
District Court
Garnet Digital, LLC v.
Apple, Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00223Texas Eastern
District Court
Unifi Scientific Batteries,
LLC v. Research In Motion
Corporation et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00235Texas Eastern
District Court
U.S. Ethernet Innovations,
LLC v. Ricoh Americas
Corporation
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00252Texas Eastern
District Court
Azure Networks LLC et al
v. MediaTek Inc.
Transfer6:12cv00260Texas Eastern
District Court
Touchscreen Gestures
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co, Ltd; et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00398Texas Eastern
District Court
U.S. Ethernet Innovations,
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al 27
Other Termination6:12cv00421 Party Opposed to This PartyTexas Eastern
District Court
Fractus, S.A. v. Samsung
Electronics Co, Ltd; et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00578Texas Eastern
District Court
Commonwealth Scientific
and Industrial Research
Organisation v. MediaTek
Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00745Texas Eastern
District Court
Azure Networks LLC et al
v. Samsung
Telecommunications
America LLC et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:12cv00894Texas Eastern
District Court
Ericsson Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00895Texas Eastern
District Court
Ericsson Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00985Texas Eastern
District Court
CDD Technologies, LLC v.
ASUS Computer
International
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00991Texas Eastern
District Court
CDD Technologies, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00077Texas Eastern
District Court
Network-1 Security
Solutions, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc et
al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00210Texas Eastern
District Court
Fractus, S.A. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00364Texas Eastern
District Court
Ericsson Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
6:13cv00419Texas Eastern
District Court
Mirror Worlds
Technologies, LLC v.
Apple Inc. et al
6:13cv00448Texas Eastern
District Court
Smartflash LLC et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Stay6:13cv00606Texas Eastern
District Court
Straight Path IP Group,
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00883Texas Eastern
District Court
Chrimar Systems, Inc. et al
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., LTD., et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00941Texas Eastern
District Court
Mirror Worlds
Technologies, LLC v. Dell
Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:14cv00296Texas Eastern
District Court
VStream Technologies,
LLC v. LG Electronics, Inc.
et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:14cv00553Texas Eastern
District Court
Enterprise Systems
Technologies S.a.r.l. v.
Amazon.com Inc.
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:14cv00555Texas Eastern
District Court
Enterprise Systems
Technologies S.a.r.l. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
6:14cv00759Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:15cv00018Texas Eastern
District Court
Azure Networks LLC v.
Acer America Corporation
et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:15cv00019Texas Eastern
District Court
Azure Networks LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al28
Consolidated6:15cv00690Texas Eastern
District Court
DSS Technology
Management, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
6:15cv00692Texas Eastern
District Court
DSS Technology
Management, Inc. v.
Qualcomm Incorporated
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:15cv00894Texas Eastern
District Court
Lance Parker IP, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
6:15cv01071Texas Eastern
District Court
Motile Optics, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
6:15cv01102Texas Eastern
District Court
Papst Licensing GmbH
& Co., KG v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
LTD., et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:15cv01112Texas Eastern
District Court
Cypress Lake Software,
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Jury Verdict3:11cv00367 Party Opposed to This PartyTexas Northern
District Court
Summit 6 LLC v. Research
in Motion Corporation et al
Other Termination3:13cv03599Texas Northern
District Court
Micrografx LLC v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America LLC et al
Jury Verdict1:12cv00318 This PartyTexas Western
District Court
Ushijima v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
1:15cv00613Texas Western
District Court
Daniel L. Flamm, Sc.D. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
1:15cv01080Texas Western
District Court
Twenty-First Century
Technologies, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Transfer6:13cv00364Texas Western
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., LTD et al
Transfer6:15cv00128Texas Western
District Court
Advanced Touchscreen
and Gesture Technologies
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD, et al
Involuntary Dismissal1:15cv01657 This PartyVirginia Eastern
District Court
Kutt v. Apple Inc. et al
Consent Judgment2:12cv00548 This PartyVirginia Eastern
District Court
Virginia Innovation
Sciences, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Consent Judgment2:13cv00332 This PartyVirginia Eastern
District Court
Virginia Innovation
Sciences, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00217Virginia Eastern
District Court
Virginia Innovation
Sciences, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.,
et al
3:14cv00757Virginia Eastern
District Court
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. v. NVIDIA Corporation
Intra-District Transfer3:15cv00640Virginia Eastern
District Court
Kutt v. Apple Inc. et al
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv01059Washington
Western District
Court
REC Software USA, Inc v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
29
Overview:The dockets of patent cases filed from October 2006 to March 2016 nationwide were examined to identify firms that
represented this party. The top 20 (or fewer) such firms are listed below, followed by a chart showing all such firms.
Note that a "Pac-Man" type chart reflects a party that is usually represented by a single firm, while a chart with many
"slices" reflects a party who uses a number of different firms for its patent litigation.
Number of Cases
Gillam & Smith Total 61
Defendant 61
Potter Minton Total 46
Defendant 46
O'Melveny & Myers Total 34
Defendant 33
Plaintiff 1
Fish & Richardson Total 20
Defendant 20
Akin, Gump, Strauss, Hauer &
Feld
Total 19
Defendant 19
Ropes & Gray Total 19
Defendant 19
Covington & Burling Total 18
Defendant 17
Plaintiff 1
Baker Botts Total 17
Defendant 17
DLA Piper Total 17
Defendant 17
Paul, Hastings Total 16
Defendant 16
Young Conaway Total 16
Defendant 16
Arnold & Porter Total 14
Defendant 14
Kirkland & Ellis Total 12
Defendant 12 30
Number of Cases
Quinn and Emanuel Total 12
Defendant 12
Greenberg Traurig Total 10
Defendant 10
Skadden Arps Total 8
Defendant 8
Weil Gotshal Total 8
Defendant 8
Connolly and Bove Total 6
Defendant 6
Howrey Simon Total 5
Defendant 5
Potter Anderson Total 5
Defendant 4
Plaintiff 1
Jones Day Total 4
Defendant 4
McGinnis Lochridge Total 4
Defendant 4
McGuire, Woods Total 4
Defendant 3
Plaintiff 1
Steptoe & Johnson Total 4
Defendant 3
Plaintiff 1
Sughrue Mion Total 4
Defendant 4
Bingham McCutchen Total 3
Defendant 3
Heartfield & McGinnis Total 3
Defendant 3
King & Spalding Total 3
Defendant 2
Plaintiff 1
Latham & Watkins Total 3 31
Number of Cases
Latham & Watkins Defendant 3
Siebman, Burg, Phillips &
Smith LP
Total 3
Defendant 3
Antonelli Harrington &
Thompson LLP
Total 2
Defendant 2
Drinker Biddle Total 2
Defendant 2
LeBoeuf, Lamb Total 2
Defendant 2
McDermott, Will & Emery Total 2
Defendant 2
Provost Umphrey, L.L.P. Total 2
Defendant 2
Sidley Austin Total 2
Defendant 2
White & Case Total 2
Defendant 2
Andrews Kurth Total 1
Defendant 1
Barner & Thornburg Total 1
Defendant 1
Desmarias LLP Total 1
Defendant 1
Dickstein and Shapiro Total 1
Defendant 1
Duane, Morris Total 1
Defendant 1
Edwards & Angell Total 1
Defendant 1
Farella Braun Total 1
Defendant 1
Finnegan Henderson Total 1
Defendant 1
Gibson, Dunn Total 1
Defendant 1 32
Number of Cases
Haltom & Doan Total 1
Defendant 1
Irell & Manella Total 1
Defendant 1
Kelley Donion Total 1
Defendant 1
Orrick Herrington Total 1
Defendant 1
Proskauer Rose Total 1
Plaintiff 1
Ramey & Flock Total 1
Defendant 1
Sheppard, Mullin Total 1
Defendant 1
Shore & Chan Total 1
Defendant 1
Sullivan & Cromwell Total 1
Plaintiff 1
Susman Godfrey Total 1
Defendant 1
Williams Morgan Total 1
Defendant 1
Winston & Strawn Total 1
Defendant 1
33
Akin, Gump, Strauss, Hauer & Feld 4.4%Andrews Kurth 0.2%Antonelli Harrington & Thompson LLP 0.5%Arnold & Porter 3.2%Baker Botts 3.9%Barner & Thornburg 0.2%Bingham McCutchen 0.7%Connolly and Bove 1.4%Covington & Burling 4.2%Desmarias LLP 0.2%Dickstein and Shapiro 0.2%DLA Piper 3.9%Drinker Biddle 0.5%Duane, Morris 0.2%Edwards & Angell 0.2%Farella Braun 0.2%Finnegan Henderson 0.2%Fish & Richardson 4.6%Gibson, Dunn 0.2%Gillam & Smith 14.1%Greenberg Traurig 2.3%Haltom & Doan 0.2%Heartfield & McGinnis 0.7%Howrey Simon 1.2%Irell & Manella 0.2%Jones Day 0.9%Kelley Donion 0.2%King & Spalding 0.7%Kirkland & Ellis 2.8%Latham & Watkins 0.7%LeBoeuf, Lamb 0.5%McDermott, Will & Emery 0.5%McGinnis Lochridge 0.9%McGuire, Woods 0.9%O'Melveny & Myers 7.9%Orrick Herrington 0.2%Paul, Hastings 3.7%Potter Anderson 1.2%Potter Minton 10.6%Proskauer Rose 0.2%Provost Umphrey, L.L.P. 0.5%Quinn and Emanuel 2.8%Ramey & Flock 0.2%
Total: 100.0%
Firms Representing Party
1Covington & Burling
1King & Spalding
1McGuire, Woods
1O'Melveny & Myers
1Potter Anderson
1Proskauer Rose
1Steptoe & Johnson
1Sullivan & Cromwell
Firms Representing Party as Plaintiff
34
Akin, Gump, Strauss, Hauer & Feld 4.5%Andrews Kurth 0.2%Antonelli Harrington & Thompson LLP 0.5%Arnold & Porter 3.3%Baker Botts 4.0%Barner & Thornburg 0.2%Bingham McCutchen 0.7%Connolly and Bove 1.4%Covington & Burling 4.0%Desmarias LLP 0.2%Dickstein and Shapiro 0.2%DLA Piper 4.0%Drinker Biddle 0.5%Duane, Morris 0.2%Edwards & Angell 0.2%Farella Braun 0.2%Finnegan Henderson 0.2%Fish & Richardson 4.7%Gibson, Dunn 0.2%Gillam & Smith 14.4%Greenberg Traurig 2.4%Haltom & Doan 0.2%Heartfield & McGinnis 0.7%Howrey Simon 1.2%Irell & Manella 0.2%Jones Day 0.9%Kelley Donion 0.2%King & Spalding 0.5%Kirkland & Ellis 2.8%Latham & Watkins 0.7%LeBoeuf, Lamb 0.5%McDermott, Will & Emery 0.5%McGinnis Lochridge 0.9%McGuire, Woods 0.7%O'Melveny & Myers 7.8%Orrick Herrington 0.2%Paul, Hastings 3.8%Potter Anderson 0.9%Potter Minton 10.8%Proskauer Rose 0.0%Provost Umphrey, L.L.P. 0.5%Quinn and Emanuel 2.8%Ramey & Flock 0.2%
Total: 100.0%
Firms Representing Party as Defendant
35
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Akin, Gump, Strauss, Hauer & Feld
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00827Delaware District
Court
CyberFone Systems LLC
v. ZTE (USA) Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00833Delaware District
Court
CyberFone Systems LLC
v. Vizio Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv00572Delaware District
Court
Smart Audio Technologies
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co Ltd et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv00356Delaware District
Court
Technology Innovations
Associates LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv01787Delaware District
Court
Alex is the Best LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Involuntary Dismissal6:14cv01623Florida Middle
District Court
Orlando Communications
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Defendant
Involuntary Dismissal6:14cv01625Florida Middle
District Court
Orlando Communications,
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:14cv01017Florida Middle
District Court
Orlando Communications
LLC v. LG Electronics, Inc.
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:14cv01624Florida Middle
District Court
Orlando Communications
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:14cv01626Florida Middle
District Court
Orlando Communications
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co.,LTD. et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:13cv00045Texas Eastern
District Court
Tierra Intelectual
Borinquen, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination2:14cv00053Texas Eastern
District Court
Queens University at
Kingston et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00039Texas Eastern
District Court
Tierra Intelectual
Borinquen, Inc. v. HTC
Corporation et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00563Texas Eastern
District Court
Lake Cherokee Hard Drive
Technologies, L.L.C. v.
MediaTek USA Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00695Texas Eastern
District Court
Lake Cherokee Hard Drive
Technologies, L.L.C. v.
Marvell Asia Pte., Ltd et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00940Texas Eastern
District Court
Tactile Feedback
Technology, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00235Texas Eastern
District Court
U.S. Ethernet Innovations,
LLC v. Ricoh Americas
Corporation
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00398Texas Eastern
District Court
U.S. Ethernet Innovations,
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
36
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Akin, Gump, Strauss, Hauer & Feld
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00883Texas Eastern
District Court
Chrimar Systems, Inc. et al
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., LTD., et al
Defendant
37
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Andrews Kurth
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv01061Texas Eastern
District Court
e-Watch Inc. et al v. Apple,
Inc.
Defendant
38
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Antonelli Harrington & Thompson LLP
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv01118Texas Eastern
District Court
Dynamic Hosting
Company LLC v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
5:06cv00239Texas Eastern
District Court
Antor Media Corporation v.
Samsung
Telecommunications LLP
et al
Defendant
39
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Arnold & Porter
Party Type
3:16cv00557California Northern
District Court
Advanced Touchscreen
and Gesture Technologies
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD, et al
Defendant
3:16cv00385California
Southern District
Court
FastVDO LLC v.
AT&T Mobility LLC et
al
Defendant
3:16cv00395California
Southern District
Court
FastVDO LLC v. Dell Inc.
et al
Defendant
1:15cv00898Delaware District
Court
ProMOS Technologies,
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:14cv01017Florida Middle
District Court
Orlando Communications
LLC v. LG Electronics, Inc.
et al
Defendant
2:15cv00998Texas Eastern
District Court
Display Technologies LLC
v. NVIDIA Corporation
Defendant
Consolidated2:15cv01000Texas Eastern
District Court
Display Technologies LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
Other Termination2:14cv00053Texas Eastern
District Court
Queens University at
Kingston et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Transfer2:15cv00946Texas Eastern
District Court
FastVDO LLC v. Dell Inc.
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00940Texas Eastern
District Court
Tactile Feedback
Technology, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:15cv00018Texas Eastern
District Court
Azure Networks LLC v.
Acer America Corporation
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:15cv00019Texas Eastern
District Court
Azure Networks LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
1:15cv00613Texas Western
District Court
Daniel L. Flamm, Sc.D. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Transfer6:15cv00128Texas Western
District Court
Advanced Touchscreen
and Gesture Technologies
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD, et al
Defendant
40
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Baker Botts
Party Type
Summary Judgment1:11cv00440Delaware District
Court
Apeldyn Corporation v.
Sony Corporation et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv00999Delaware District
Court
PatentMarks
Communications LLC v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America LLC
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv01899New York
Southern District
Court
Varia Holdings LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:14cv01165Texas Eastern
District Court
Koninklijke Kpn N.V. v.
SAMSUNG
ELECTRONICS
AMERICA, INC. et al
Defendant
6:13cv00448Texas Eastern
District Court
Smartflash LLC et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:13cv00045Texas Eastern
District Court
Tierra Intelectual
Borinquen, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Jury Verdict2:13cv01112Texas Eastern
District Court
ContentGuard Holdings,
Inc. v. Amazon.com Inc. et
al
Defendant
Other Termination6:12cv00421Texas Eastern
District Court
Fractus, S.A. v. Samsung
Electronics Co, Ltd; et al
Defendant
Summary Judgment1:15cv00052Texas Eastern
District Court
AI Automation, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:11cv00390Texas Eastern
District Court
Negotiated Data Solutions,
Inc. v. Apple Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00039Texas Eastern
District Court
Tierra Intelectual
Borinquen, Inc. v. HTC
Corporation et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00906Texas Eastern
District Court
SecureNova, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00746Texas Eastern
District Court
Freeny et al v. Samsung
Telecommunications
America LLC
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00223Texas Eastern
District Court
Unifi Scientific Batteries,
LLC v. Research In Motion
Corporation et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00252Texas Eastern
District Court
Azure Networks LLC et al
v. MediaTek Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00210Texas Eastern
District Court
Fractus, S.A. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Jury Verdict1:12cv00318Texas Western
District Court
Ushijima v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
41
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Barner & Thornburg
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00309Delaware District
Court
Walker Digital LLC v.
Google Inc. et al.
Defendant
42
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Bingham McCutchen
Party Type
Consolidated4:14cv02966California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:13cv00045Texas Eastern
District Court
Tierra Intelectual
Borinquen, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Transfer1:12cv00557Texas Eastern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
43
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Connolly and Bove
Party Type
Other Termination1:13cv01808Delaware District
Court
Memory Integrity LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
Company Ltd. et al.
Defendant
Stay1:13cv01529Delaware District
Court
Optical Devices LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co
Ltd et al.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00309Delaware District
Court
Walker Digital LLC v.
Google Inc. et al.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
1:12cv01278Delaware District
Court
Telecomm Innovations
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
Want of Prosecution1:12cv00483Delaware District
Court
Golden Bridge Technology
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd.
Defendant
Want of Prosecution1:12cv01167Delaware District
Court
Golden Bridge Technology
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co Ltd et al
Defendant
44
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Covington & Burling
Party Type
Stay3:14cv05298California Northern
District Court
American Navigation
Systems, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
3:12cv04143California Northern
District Court
IpVenture Inc. v. Lenovo
Group Limited et al
Defendant
3:13cv02740California
Southern District
Court
Largan Precision Co., Ltd.
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination1:10cv00389Delaware District
Court
SoftView LLC v. Apple Inc.
et al
Defendant
Other Termination1:12cv00987Delaware District
Court
SoftView LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination1:14cv00337Delaware District
Court
Surpass Tech Innovation
LLC v. Samsung Display
Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:14cv00338Delaware District
Court
Surpass Tech Innovation
LLC v. Sharp Corporation
et al
Defendant
1:15cv10278Illinois Northern
District Court
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. v. Sockeye
Licensing TX LLC et al
Plaintiff
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv10659Massachusetts
District Court
Trustees of Boston
University v. Samsung
Electronics Company,
Limited et al
Defendant
2:13cv00017Texas Eastern
District Court
Keranos, LLC v. Silicon
Storage Technology, Inc.,
et al
Defendant
2:15cv00466Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Apple Inc.
Defendant
Consolidated2:15cv00473Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Defendant
Consolidated5:15cv00131Texas Eastern
District Court
Venadium LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America Inc. et al
Defendant
Other Settlement2:11cv00090Texas Eastern
District Court
Lodsys, LLC v. Brother
International Corporation
et al
Defendant
Other Termination2:13cv00379Texas Eastern
District Court
Black Hills Media, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00917Texas Eastern
District Court
Intellectual Capital
Consulting, Ltd. v. Hyundai
Motor Company et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
5:15cv00114Texas Eastern
District Court
Venadium LLC v. Acer
America Corporation
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:14cv00553Texas Eastern
District Court
Enterprise Systems
Technologies S.a.r.l. v.
Amazon.com Inc.
Defendant
45
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Desmarias LLP
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
4:11cv06636California Northern
District Court
Asustek Computer Inc. et
al v. Round Rock
Research, LLC et al
Defendant
46
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Dickstein and Shapiro
Party Type
Jury Verdict2:13cv00213Texas Eastern
District Court
Rembrandt Wireless
Technologies, LP v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
LTD., et al
Defendant
47
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
DLA Piper
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv08545California Central
District Court
Olympic Development AG,
LLC v. AT&T, Inc. et
al
Defendant
Summary Judgment3:13cv00194California Northern
District Court
Tse v. Google Inc., et al. Defendant
Summary Judgment5:10cv05545California Northern
District Court
Nazomi Communications
Inc v. Samsung
Telecommunications Inc et
al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
4:11cv02010California Northern
District Court
Orinda Intellectual
Properties USA Holding
Group, Inc. v. Asustek
Computer Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
4:11cv06636California Northern
District Court
Asustek Computer Inc. et
al v. Round Rock
Research, LLC et al
Defendant
3:13cv02740California
Southern District
Court
Largan Precision Co., Ltd.
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Stay1:14cv00078Delaware District
Court
Cresta Technology
Corporation v. Silicon
Laboratories Inc. et al
Defendant
3:15cv01477Florida Middle
District Court
Parkervision, Inc. v. Apple
Inc. et al
Defendant
6:14cv00687Florida Middle
District Court
ParkerVision, Inc. v.
QUALCOMM Incorporated
et al
Defendant
Stay1:11cv06241Illinois Northern
District Court
ClassCo Inc. v. Apple, Inc.
et al
Defendant
2:15cv00466Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Apple Inc.
Defendant
Stay6:13cv00606Texas Eastern
District Court
Straight Path IP Group,
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Summary Judgment6:10cv00561Texas Eastern
District Court
Gemalto S.A. v. HTC
Corporation et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:09cv00372Texas Eastern
District Court
Levine v. Samsung
TeleCommunications
America, LLC et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:11cv00647Texas Eastern
District Court
Garnet Digital, LLC v.
Apple, Inc. et al
Defendant
Jury Verdict3:11cv00367Texas Northern
District Court
Summit 6 LLC v. Research
in Motion Corporation et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv01059Washington
Western District
Court
REC Software USA, Inc v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
48
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Drinker Biddle
Party Type
Summary Judgment1:07mc00493District of
Columbia District
Court
IN RE: PAPST
LICENSING DIGITAL
CAMERA PATENT
LITIGATION - MDL 1880
Defendant
6:15cv01102Texas Eastern
District Court
Papst Licensing GmbH
& Co., KG v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
LTD., et al
Defendant
49
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Duane, Morris
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv03175Pennsylvania
Eastern District
Court
INFINITY COMPUTER
PRODUCTS, INC. v.
BROTHER
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION et al
Defendant
50
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Edwards & Angell
Party Type
Stay1:14cv00078Delaware District
Court
Cresta Technology
Corporation v. Silicon
Laboratories Inc. et al
Defendant
51
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Farella Braun
Party Type
Summary Judgment3:13cv00194California Northern
District Court
Tse v. Google Inc., et al. Defendant
52
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Finnegan Henderson
Party Type
Other Settlement2:11cv00090Texas Eastern
District Court
Lodsys, LLC v. Brother
International Corporation
et al
Defendant
53
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Fish & Richardson
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
3:15cv00539California Northern
District Court
Rothschild Storage
Retrieval Innovations, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd., et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00798Delaware District
Court
Monec Holding AG v.
Motorola Mobility LLC et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv01325Delaware District
Court
LED Tech Development
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics America Inc. et
al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:14cv00441Delaware District
Court
Pragmatus Mobile LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co
Ltd et al.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
1:12cv00199Delaware District
Court
Pragmatus AV LLC v.
Asustek Computer Inc et al
Defendant
Transfer1:14cv22653Florida Southern
District Court
Rothschild Storage
Retrieval Innovations, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd., et al
Defendant
Other Settlement1:09cv01736Georgia Northern
District Court
Synchrome Technology
Inc. v. Toshiba America
Information Systems, Inc.,
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:11cv12945Michigan Eastern
District Court
Visual Interactive Phone
Concepts, Inc. v. Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC
Defendant
2:15cv00432Texas Eastern
District Court
Corydoras Technologies,
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:15cv01503Texas Eastern
District Court
TiVo Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD., et al
Defendant
2:15cv01754Texas Eastern
District Court
Personalized Media
Communications, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:14cv00345Texas Eastern
District Court
Olivistar, LLC v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
Defendant
Summary Judgment6:11cv00474Texas Eastern
District Court
Profectus Technology LLC
v. Huawei Technologies
Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv00091Texas Eastern
District Court
Microunity Systems
Engineering Inc v. Acer Inc
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv00490Texas Eastern
District Court
Vertical Computer
Systems, Inc. v.
Interwoven, Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv01381Texas Eastern
District Court
Fujinomaki v. Google, Inc.
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
5:06cv00239Texas Eastern
District Court
Antor Media Corporation v.
Samsung
Telecommunications LLP
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00895Texas Eastern
District Court
Ericsson Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
54
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Fish & Richardson
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00364Texas Eastern
District Court
Ericsson Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:12cv00894Texas Eastern
District Court
Ericsson Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
55
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Gibson, Dunn
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv00490Texas Eastern
District Court
Vertical Computer
Systems, Inc. v.
Interwoven, Inc. et al
Defendant
56
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Gillam & Smith
Party Type
3:16cv00385California
Southern District
Court
FastVDO LLC v.
AT&T Mobility LLC et
al
Defendant
3:16cv00395California
Southern District
Court
FastVDO LLC v. Dell Inc.
et al
Defendant
2:14cv00902Texas Eastern
District Court
Parthenon Unified Memory
Architecture LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00183Texas Eastern
District Court
Mobile
Telecommunications
Technologies, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00283Texas Eastern
District Court
NFC Technology, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
2:15cv00341Texas Eastern
District Court
Raytheon Company v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00432Texas Eastern
District Court
Corydoras Technologies,
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00456Texas Eastern
District Court
Porto Technology Co.,
LTD v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
et al
Defendant
2:15cv00457Texas Eastern
District Court
Porto Technology Co.,
LTD v. Apple, Inc.
Defendant
2:15cv00466Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Apple Inc.
Defendant
2:15cv00998Texas Eastern
District Court
Display Technologies LLC
v. NVIDIA Corporation
Defendant
2:15cv01503Texas Eastern
District Court
TiVo Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD., et al
Defendant
2:15cv01524Texas Eastern
District Court
511 Innovations, Inc. v.
HTC America, Inc. et al
Defendant
2:15cv01526Texas Eastern
District Court
511 Innovations, Inc. v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC et al
Defendant
2:15cv01754Texas Eastern
District Court
Personalized Media
Communications, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
2:15cv01885Texas Eastern
District Court
IXI IP, LLC et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD, et al
Defendant
2:15cv01970Texas Eastern
District Court
Visual Content IP, LLC v.
HTC America, Inc.
Defendant
2:15cv02032Texas Eastern
District Court
Visual Content IP, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Defendant
Consolidated2:14cv00345Texas Eastern
District Court
Olivistar, LLC v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
Defendant 57
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Gillam & Smith
Party Type
Consolidated2:15cv00473Texas Eastern
District Court
Nonend Inventions, N.V. v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Defendant
Consolidated2:15cv01000Texas Eastern
District Court
Display Technologies LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:15cv01191Texas Eastern
District Court
Cypaleo, LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Consolidated5:15cv00131Texas Eastern
District Court
Venadium LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America Inc. et al
Defendant
Jury Verdict2:13cv00259Texas Eastern
District Court
Mobile
Telecommunications
Technologies, LLC v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC
Defendant
Jury Verdict2:13cv01112Texas Eastern
District Court
ContentGuard Holdings,
Inc. v. Amazon.com Inc. et
al
Defendant
Other Settlement2:11cv00090Texas Eastern
District Court
Lodsys, LLC v. Brother
International Corporation
et al
Defendant
Other Settlement2:11cv00416Texas Eastern
District Court
SimpleAir, Inc. v. Microsoft
Corporation et al
Defendant
Other Settlement2:15cv01077Texas Eastern
District Court
Cypaleo, LLC v. Acer, Inc.
et al
Defendant
Other Termination2:13cv00379Texas Eastern
District Court
Black Hills Media, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination2:13cv00928Texas Eastern
District Court
Vantage Point Technology,
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination2:14cv00053Texas Eastern
District Court
Queens University at
Kingston et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Summary Judgment1:15cv00052Texas Eastern
District Court
AI Automation, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Transfer2:15cv00946Texas Eastern
District Court
FastVDO LLC v. Dell Inc.
et al
Defendant
Transfer6:12cv00260Texas Eastern
District Court
Touchscreen Gestures
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co, Ltd; et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:09cv00372Texas Eastern
District Court
Levine v. Samsung
TeleCommunications
America, LLC et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv00091Texas Eastern
District Court
Microunity Systems
Engineering Inc v. Acer Inc
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:12cv00581Texas Eastern
District Court
TQP Development, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00426Texas Eastern
District Court
Penovia LLC v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.,
Defendant
58
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Gillam & Smith
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00882Texas Eastern
District Court
Adrain v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00746Texas Eastern
District Court
Freeny et al v. Samsung
Telecommunications
America LLC
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00842Texas Eastern
District Court
Multiplayer Network
Innovations, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00940Texas Eastern
District Court
Tactile Feedback
Technology, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv01172Texas Eastern
District Court
Trover Group, Inc. et al v.
Kaltec Electronics, Inc. et
al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00086Texas Eastern
District Court
Trover Group, Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics
America Inc et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00103Texas Eastern
District Court
Wetro Lan LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00917Texas Eastern
District Court
Intellectual Capital
Consulting, Ltd. v. Hyundai
Motor Company et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv01119Texas Eastern
District Court
Broadqast Solutions, LLC
v. ESCORT Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv01127Texas Eastern
District Court
Broadqast Solutions, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
America Inc
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
5:15cv00114Texas Eastern
District Court
Venadium LLC v. Acer
America Corporation
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00235Texas Eastern
District Court
U.S. Ethernet Innovations,
LLC v. Ricoh Americas
Corporation
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00252Texas Eastern
District Court
Azure Networks LLC et al
v. MediaTek Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00398Texas Eastern
District Court
U.S. Ethernet Innovations,
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00578Texas Eastern
District Court
Commonwealth Scientific
and Industrial Research
Organisation v. MediaTek
Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00745Texas Eastern
District Court
Azure Networks LLC et al
v. Samsung
Telecommunications
America LLC et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:14cv00296Texas Eastern
District Court
VStream Technologies,
LLC v. LG Electronics, Inc.
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:15cv00018Texas Eastern
District Court
Azure Networks LLC v.
Acer America Corporation
et al
Defendant
59
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Gillam & Smith
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:15cv00019Texas Eastern
District Court
Azure Networks LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
2:15cv00303Texas Eastern
District Court
LX Tech, LLC v. Maxim
Integrated Products, Inc. et
al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:15cv01112Texas Eastern
District Court
Cypress Lake Software,
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Jury Verdict3:11cv00367Texas Northern
District Court
Summit 6 LLC v. Research
in Motion Corporation et al
Defendant
1:15cv00613Texas Western
District Court
Daniel L. Flamm, Sc.D. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
60
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Greenberg Traurig
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv00180Colorado District
Court
Cellport Systems, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Settlement4:12cv00651Florida Northern
District Court
GLOBAL
COMMUNICATIONS INC
v. DIRECTV INC et al
Defendant
Other Termination2:12cv02824Tennessee
Western District
Court
B.E. Technology, L.L.C. v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC
Defendant
Other Termination2:12cv02825Tennessee
Western District
Court
B.E. Technology, L.L.C. v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Defendant
2:15cv00183Texas Eastern
District Court
Mobile
Telecommunications
Technologies, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00341Texas Eastern
District Court
Raytheon Company v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Jury Verdict2:13cv00259Texas Eastern
District Court
Mobile
Telecommunications
Technologies, LLC v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC
Defendant
Other Settlement2:15cv01077Texas Eastern
District Court
Cypaleo, LLC v. Acer, Inc.
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00985Texas Eastern
District Court
CDD Technologies, LLC v.
ASUS Computer
International
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00991Texas Eastern
District Court
CDD Technologies, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Defendant
61
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Haltom & Doan
Party Type
6:13cv00419Texas Eastern
District Court
Mirror Worlds
Technologies, LLC v.
Apple Inc. et al
Defendant
62
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Heartfield & McGinnis
Party Type
Consolidated4:14cv02966California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination4:14cv02717California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd et al
Defendant
Transfer1:12cv00557Texas Eastern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
63
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Howrey Simon
Party Type
3:16cv00385California
Southern District
Court
FastVDO LLC v.
AT&T Mobility LLC et
al
Defendant
3:16cv00395California
Southern District
Court
FastVDO LLC v. Dell Inc.
et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:13cv00045Texas Eastern
District Court
Tierra Intelectual
Borinquen, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00039Texas Eastern
District Court
Tierra Intelectual
Borinquen, Inc. v. HTC
Corporation et al
Defendant
1:15cv00613Texas Western
District Court
Daniel L. Flamm, Sc.D. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
64
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Irell & Manella
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv00011Delaware District
Court
InterDigital
Communications Inc. et al
v. Samsung Electronics
Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
65
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Jones Day
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
1:12cv00199Delaware District
Court
Pragmatus AV LLC v.
Asustek Computer Inc et al
Defendant
Other Settlement1:09cv01736Georgia Northern
District Court
Synchrome Technology
Inc. v. Toshiba America
Information Systems, Inc.,
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:09cv00372Texas Eastern
District Court
Levine v. Samsung
TeleCommunications
America, LLC et al
Defendant
Jury Verdict3:11cv00367Texas Northern
District Court
Summit 6 LLC v. Research
in Motion Corporation et al
Defendant
66
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Kelley Donion
Party Type
Other Settlement2:11cv00090Texas Eastern
District Court
Lodsys, LLC v. Brother
International Corporation
et al
Defendant
67
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
King & Spalding
Party Type
2:13cv00017Texas Eastern
District Court
Keranos, LLC v. Silicon
Storage Technology, Inc.,
et al
Defendant
Other Termination2:10cv00207Texas Eastern
District Court
Keranos, LLC v. Analog
Devices, Inc. et al
Defendant
Other Termination2:11cv00331Texas Eastern
District Court
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd et al v. United Module
Corp. et al
Plaintiff
68
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Kirkland & Ellis
Party Type
Stay3:15cv03752California Northern
District Court
IXI Mobile (R&D) Ltd.
et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
3:13cv02740California
Southern District
Court
Largan Precision Co., Ltd.
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv00346Delaware District
Court
Data Carriers LLC v
Samsung Electronics
America Inc. et al.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv00533Delaware District
Court
Semcon Tech LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Jury Verdict1:11cv04574Illinois Northern
District Court
Cascades Computer
Innovation, LLC v.
Motorola Mobility Holdings,
Inc. et al
Defendant
Transfer1:14cv04355New York
Southern District
Court
IXI Mobile (R&D) Ltd.
et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Settlement2:11cv00416Texas Eastern
District Court
SimpleAir, Inc. v. Microsoft
Corporation et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:11cv00492Texas Eastern
District Court
Network-1 Security
Solutions, Inc. v.
Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc. et
al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00895Texas Eastern
District Court
Ericsson Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00077Texas Eastern
District Court
Network-1 Security
Solutions, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc et
al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00364Texas Eastern
District Court
Ericsson Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:12cv00894Texas Eastern
District Court
Ericsson Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
69
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Latham & Watkins
Party Type
Jury Verdict5:12cv00630California Northern
District Court
Apple Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:13cv00900Texas Eastern
District Court
Rockstar Consortium US
LP et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD., et al
Defendant
Summary Judgment6:10cv00561Texas Eastern
District Court
Gemalto S.A. v. HTC
Corporation et al
Defendant
70
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
LeBoeuf, Lamb
Party Type
Jury Verdict3:11cv00367Texas Northern
District Court
Summit 6 LLC v. Research
in Motion Corporation et al
Defendant
71
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
McDermott, Will & Emery
Party Type
3:13cv02740California
Southern District
Court
Largan Precision Co., Ltd.
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Summary Judgment1:07mc00493District of
Columbia District
Court
IN RE: PAPST
LICENSING DIGITAL
CAMERA PATENT
LITIGATION - MDL 1880
Defendant
72
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
McGinnis Lochridge
Party Type
Other Termination4:14cv02717California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd et al
Defendant
Other Termination4:14cv03030California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., LTD et al
Defendant
Other Termination4:14cv03031California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. BlackBerry Limited et al
Defendant
Transfer6:13cv00364Texas Western
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., LTD et al
Defendant
73
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
McGuire, Woods
Party Type
3:14cv00757Virginia Eastern
District Court
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. v. NVIDIA Corporation
Plaintiff
Consent Judgment2:12cv00548Virginia Eastern
District Court
Virginia Innovation
Sciences, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Defendant
Consent Judgment2:13cv00332Virginia Eastern
District Court
Virginia Innovation
Sciences, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00217Virginia Eastern
District Court
Virginia Innovation
Sciences, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.,
et al
Defendant
74
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
O'Melveny & Myers
Party Type
Stay3:14cv05298California Northern
District Court
American Navigation
Systems, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
3:13cv02715California Northern
District Court
Touchscreen Gestures
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co, Ltd; et al
Defendant
Other Termination1:13cv01808Delaware District
Court
Memory Integrity LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
Company Ltd. et al.
Defendant
Stay1:13cv01529Delaware District
Court
Optical Devices LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co
Ltd et al.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00309Delaware District
Court
Walker Digital LLC v.
Google Inc. et al.
Defendant
Want of Prosecution1:12cv00483Delaware District
Court
Golden Bridge Technology
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv06036New York Western
District Court
Eastman Kodak Company
v. Samsung Electronics
Company, Ltd. et al
Defendant
Stay2:12cv06798Pennsylvania
Eastern District
Court
INFINITY COMPUTER
PRODUCTS, INC. v.
SAMSUNG
ELECTRONICS
AMERICA, INC.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv03175Pennsylvania
Eastern District
Court
INFINITY COMPUTER
PRODUCTS, INC. v.
BROTHER
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION et al
Defendant
2:15cv00283Texas Eastern
District Court
NFC Technology, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
2:15cv00456Texas Eastern
District Court
Porto Technology Co.,
LTD v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
et al
Defendant
2:15cv00457Texas Eastern
District Court
Porto Technology Co.,
LTD v. Apple, Inc.
Defendant
2:15cv01524Texas Eastern
District Court
511 Innovations, Inc. v.
HTC America, Inc. et al
Defendant
2:15cv01526Texas Eastern
District Court
511 Innovations, Inc. v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America, LLC et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:12cv00824Texas Eastern
District Court
Concinnitas LLC v
Samsung
TeleCommunications
America LLC et al
Defendant
Other Termination2:13cv00928Texas Eastern
District Court
Vantage Point Technology,
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination6:12cv00421Texas Eastern
District Court
Fractus, S.A. v. Samsung
Electronics Co, Ltd; et al
Defendant
Transfer6:12cv00260Texas Eastern
District Court
Touchscreen Gestures
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co, Ltd; et al
Defendant75
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
O'Melveny & Myers
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00426Texas Eastern
District Court
E-Contact Technologies,
LLC v. Apple Inc. Et Al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv00455Texas Eastern
District Court
E-Contact Technologies
LLC v. Samsung
TeleCommunications
America, LLC
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:09cv00372Texas Eastern
District Court
Levine v. Samsung
TeleCommunications
America, LLC et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv00091Texas Eastern
District Court
Microunity Systems
Engineering Inc v. Acer Inc
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00452Texas Eastern
District Court
National Cheng Kung
University v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00203Texas Eastern
District Court
ZiiLabs Inc., Ltd v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv01119Texas Eastern
District Court
Broadqast Solutions, LLC
v. ESCORT Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv01127Texas Eastern
District Court
Broadqast Solutions, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
America Inc
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:11cv00195Texas Eastern
District Court
Hybrid Audio LLC v. HIGH
TECH COMPUTER
CORP. A/K/A HTC CORP.
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00578Texas Eastern
District Court
Commonwealth Scientific
and Industrial Research
Organisation v. MediaTek
Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:15cv01112Texas Eastern
District Court
Cypress Lake Software,
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination3:13cv03599Texas Northern
District Court
Micrografx LLC v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America LLC et al
Defendant
3:14cv00757Virginia Eastern
District Court
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. v. NVIDIA Corporation
Plaintiff
Consent Judgment2:12cv00548Virginia Eastern
District Court
Virginia Innovation
Sciences, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD. et al
Defendant
Consent Judgment2:13cv00332Virginia Eastern
District Court
Virginia Innovation
Sciences, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00217Virginia Eastern
District Court
Virginia Innovation
Sciences, Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.,
et al
Defendant
76
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Orrick Herrington
Party Type
Other Settlement1:09cv01736Georgia Northern
District Court
Synchrome Technology
Inc. v. Toshiba America
Information Systems, Inc.,
et al
Defendant
77
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Paul, Hastings
Party Type
3:15cv01738California
Southern District
Court
Odyssey Wireless, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination1:14cv05691Illinois Northern
District Court
Cascades Computer
Innovation, LLC. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd.
Defendant
Transfer5:14cv00490North Carolina
Eastern District
Court
Odyssey Wireless, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:14cv00902Texas Eastern
District Court
Parthenon Unified Memory
Architecture LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00456Texas Eastern
District Court
Porto Technology Co.,
LTD v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
et al
Defendant
2:15cv00457Texas Eastern
District Court
Porto Technology Co.,
LTD v. Apple, Inc.
Defendant
2:15cv00773Texas Eastern
District Court
Super Interconnect
Technologies LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
6:13cv00419Texas Eastern
District Court
Mirror Worlds
Technologies, LLC v.
Apple Inc. et al
Defendant
6:14cv00759Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00544Texas Eastern
District Court
Institute For Information
Industry v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00643Texas Eastern
District Court
Power Management
Enterprises LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America Inc
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv01061Texas Eastern
District Court
e-Watch Inc. et al v. Apple,
Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv01062Texas Eastern
District Court
E-Watch, Inc et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00103Texas Eastern
District Court
Wetro Lan LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00941Texas Eastern
District Court
Mirror Worlds
Technologies, LLC v. Dell
Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:15cv00894Texas Eastern
District Court
Lance Parker IP, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
78
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Potter Anderson
Party Type
Summary Judgment1:11cv00440Delaware District
Court
Apeldyn Corporation v.
Sony Corporation et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:08cv00348Delaware District
Court
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. v. Petters Group
Worldwide LLC et al
Plaintiff
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00309Delaware District
Court
Walker Digital LLC v.
Google Inc. et al.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv00999Delaware District
Court
PatentMarks
Communications LLC v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America LLC
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv01787Delaware District
Court
Alex is the Best LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Defendant
79
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Potter Minton
Party Type
2:13cv00017Texas Eastern
District Court
Keranos, LLC v. Silicon
Storage Technology, Inc.,
et al
Defendant
2:14cv01165Texas Eastern
District Court
Koninklijke Kpn N.V. v.
SAMSUNG
ELECTRONICS
AMERICA, INC. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00456Texas Eastern
District Court
Porto Technology Co.,
LTD v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
et al
Defendant
2:15cv00457Texas Eastern
District Court
Porto Technology Co.,
LTD v. Apple, Inc.
Defendant
2:15cv00576Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v.
AT&T Inc. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00579Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v. Sprint
Corporation et al
Defendant
2:15cv00580Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v.
T-Mobile USA, Inc. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00581Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v. Verizon
Communications, Inc. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00773Texas Eastern
District Court
Super Interconnect
Technologies LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
4:14cv00371Texas Eastern
District Court
Imperium IP Holdings
(Cayman), Ltd. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
6:13cv00448Texas Eastern
District Court
Smartflash LLC et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
6:14cv00759Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
6:15cv00692Texas Eastern
District Court
DSS Technology
Management, Inc. v.
Qualcomm Incorporated
Defendant
Consent Judgment2:12cv00265Texas Eastern
District Court
Rotatable Technologies
LLC v. Nokia Inc
Defendant
Consent Judgment2:14cv00199Texas Eastern
District Court
DSS Technology
Management Inc. v.
Taiwan Semiconductor
Manufacturing Company,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:12cv00263Texas Eastern
District Court
Rotatable Technologies
LLC v. Acer America
Corporation et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:12cv00824Texas Eastern
District Court
Concinnitas LLC v
Samsung
TeleCommunications
America LLC et al
Defendant
80
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Potter Minton
Party Type
Consolidated2:13cv00045Texas Eastern
District Court
Tierra Intelectual
Borinquen, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:15cv00948Texas Eastern
District Court
Koninklijke Kpn N.V. v.
Samsung Electronic
America, Inc., et al
Defendant
Consolidated6:15cv00690Texas Eastern
District Court
DSS Technology
Management, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Jury Verdict2:13cv01112Texas Eastern
District Court
ContentGuard Holdings,
Inc. v. Amazon.com Inc. et
al
Defendant
Other Termination2:10cv00207Texas Eastern
District Court
Keranos, LLC v. Analog
Devices, Inc. et al
Defendant
Other Termination6:12cv00421Texas Eastern
District Court
Fractus, S.A. v. Samsung
Electronics Co, Ltd; et al
Defendant
Summary Judgment6:10cv00561Texas Eastern
District Court
Gemalto S.A. v. HTC
Corporation et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:14cv00237Texas Eastern
District Court
PanTaurus LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv00091Texas Eastern
District Court
Microunity Systems
Engineering Inc v. Acer Inc
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:11cv00390Texas Eastern
District Court
Negotiated Data Solutions,
Inc. v. Apple Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:12cv00747Texas Eastern
District Court
NovelPoint Tracking LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
America Inc
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00039Texas Eastern
District Court
Tierra Intelectual
Borinquen, Inc. v. HTC
Corporation et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00906Texas Eastern
District Court
SecureNova, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv01061Texas Eastern
District Court
e-Watch Inc. et al v. Apple,
Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00051Texas Eastern
District Court
Tune Hunter Inc. v.
Samsung
TeleCommunications
America, LLC et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00203Texas Eastern
District Court
ZiiLabs Inc., Ltd v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00352Texas Eastern
District Court
Long Corner Consumer
Electronics LLC v. Archos,
Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
4:14cv00433Texas Eastern
District Court
PLDN Holdings, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
LTD., et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:11cv00195Texas Eastern
District Court
Hybrid Audio LLC v. HIGH
TECH COMPUTER
CORP. A/K/A HTC CORP.
et al
Defendant
81
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Potter Minton
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:11cv00647Texas Eastern
District Court
Garnet Digital, LLC v.
Apple, Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00223Texas Eastern
District Court
Unifi Scientific Batteries,
LLC v. Research In Motion
Corporation et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00895Texas Eastern
District Court
Ericsson Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00210Texas Eastern
District Court
Fractus, S.A. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00364Texas Eastern
District Court
Ericsson Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:14cv00553Texas Eastern
District Court
Enterprise Systems
Technologies S.a.r.l. v.
Amazon.com Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:14cv00555Texas Eastern
District Court
Enterprise Systems
Technologies S.a.r.l. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:15cv00894Texas Eastern
District Court
Lance Parker IP, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
6:12cv00894Texas Eastern
District Court
Ericsson Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
1:15cv01080Texas Western
District Court
Twenty-First Century
Technologies, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
82
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Proskauer Rose
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:08cv00348Delaware District
Court
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. v. Petters Group
Worldwide LLC et al
Plaintiff
83
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Provost Umphrey, L.L.P.
Party Type
Consolidated2:13cv00900Texas Eastern
District Court
Rockstar Consortium US
LP et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD., et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00203Texas Eastern
District Court
ZiiLabs Inc., Ltd v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Defendant
84
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Quinn and Emanuel
Party Type
Jury Verdict5:12cv00630California Northern
District Court
Apple Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
1:15cv00545Delaware District
Court
Evolved Wireless, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00576Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v.
AT&T Inc. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00579Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v. Sprint
Corporation et al
Defendant
2:15cv00580Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v.
T-Mobile USA, Inc. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00581Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v. Verizon
Communications, Inc. et al
Defendant
6:13cv00448Texas Eastern
District Court
Smartflash LLC et al v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
6:14cv00759Texas Eastern
District Court
Cellular Communications
Equipment LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:13cv00900Texas Eastern
District Court
Rockstar Consortium US
LP et al v. Samsung
Electronics Co., LTD., et al
Defendant
Summary Judgment6:10cv00561Texas Eastern
District Court
Gemalto S.A. v. HTC
Corporation et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00578Texas Eastern
District Court
Commonwealth Scientific
and Industrial Research
Organisation v. MediaTek
Inc. et al
Defendant
Other Termination3:13cv03599Texas Northern
District Court
Micrografx LLC v.
Samsung
Telecommunications
America LLC et al
Defendant
85
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Ramey & Flock
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
5:06cv00239Texas Eastern
District Court
Antor Media Corporation v.
Samsung
Telecommunications LLP
et al
Defendant
86
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Ropes & Gray
Party Type
Consolidated4:14cv02966California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination4:14cv02717California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd et al
Defendant
Other Termination4:14cv03030California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., LTD et al
Defendant
Other Termination4:14cv03031California Northern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. BlackBerry Limited et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv00011Delaware District
Court
InterDigital
Communications Inc. et al
v. Samsung Electronics
Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
1:15cv10605Illinois Northern
District Court
Rosetta-Wireless Corp. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Consolidated1:15cv00799Illinois Northern
District Court
Rosetta-Wireless Corp. v.
Apple Inc. et al
Defendant
2:15cv01970Texas Eastern
District Court
Visual Content IP, LLC v.
HTC America, Inc.
Defendant
4:14cv00371Texas Eastern
District Court
Imperium IP Holdings
(Cayman), Ltd. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Consent Judgment2:12cv00265Texas Eastern
District Court
Rotatable Technologies
LLC v. Nokia Inc
Defendant
Consolidated2:12cv00263Texas Eastern
District Court
Rotatable Technologies
LLC v. Acer America
Corporation et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:13cv00045Texas Eastern
District Court
Tierra Intelectual
Borinquen, Inc. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Consolidated2:15cv01316Texas Eastern
District Court
Packet Tread LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc.
Defendant
Jury Verdict2:13cv00213Texas Eastern
District Court
Rembrandt Wireless
Technologies, LP v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
LTD., et al
Defendant
Other Settlement2:15cv01293Texas Eastern
District Court
Packet Tread LLC v.
Apple, Inc.
Defendant
Transfer1:12cv00557Texas Eastern
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:12cv00581Texas Eastern
District Court
TQP Development, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics
America, Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00352Texas Eastern
District Court
Long Corner Consumer
Electronics LLC v. Archos,
Inc.
Defendant
Transfer6:13cv00364Texas Western
District Court
Affinity Labs of Texas, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., LTD et al
Defendant
87
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Sheppard, Mullin
Party Type
Jury Verdict5:12cv00630California Northern
District Court
Apple Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
88
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Shore & Chan
Party Type
Transfer1:14cv22653Florida Southern
District Court
Rothschild Storage
Retrieval Innovations, LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co., Ltd., et al
Defendant
89
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Sidley Austin
Party Type
Jury Verdict5:12cv00630California Northern
District Court
Apple Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:09cv00372Texas Eastern
District Court
Levine v. Samsung
TeleCommunications
America, LLC et al
Defendant
90
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Siebman, Burg, Phillips & Smith LP
Party Type
2:16cv00170Texas Eastern
District Court
Rembrandt Wireless
Technologies LP v.
Samsung Electronics Co
LTD et al
Defendant
4:14cv00371Texas Eastern
District Court
Imperium IP Holdings
(Cayman), Ltd. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Jury Verdict2:13cv00213Texas Eastern
District Court
Rembrandt Wireless
Technologies, LP v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
LTD., et al
Defendant
91
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Skadden Arps
Party Type
1:14cv01430Delaware District
Court
Elm 3DS Innovations LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:14cv00902Texas Eastern
District Court
Parthenon Unified Memory
Architecture LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:15cv00456Texas Eastern
District Court
Porto Technology Co.,
LTD v. Samsung
Electronics America, Inc.
et al
Defendant
2:15cv00457Texas Eastern
District Court
Porto Technology Co.,
LTD v. Apple, Inc.
Defendant
2:15cv00773Texas Eastern
District Court
Super Interconnect
Technologies LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD., et al
Defendant
6:13cv00419Texas Eastern
District Court
Mirror Worlds
Technologies, LLC v.
Apple Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv00842Texas Eastern
District Court
Multiplayer Network
Innovations, LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:13cv00941Texas Eastern
District Court
Mirror Worlds
Technologies, LLC v. Dell
Inc. et al
Defendant
92
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Steptoe & Johnson
Party Type
Jury Verdict5:12cv00630California Northern
District Court
Apple Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
2:13cv00017Texas Eastern
District Court
Keranos, LLC v. Silicon
Storage Technology, Inc.,
et al
Defendant
Other Termination2:10cv00207Texas Eastern
District Court
Keranos, LLC v. Analog
Devices, Inc. et al
Defendant
Other Termination2:11cv00331Texas Eastern
District Court
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd et al v. United Module
Corp. et al
Plaintiff
93
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Sughrue Mion
Party Type
4:14cv00371Texas Eastern
District Court
Imperium IP Holdings
(Cayman), Ltd. v.
Samsung Electronics Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv01172Texas Eastern
District Court
Trover Group, Inc. et al v.
Kaltec Electronics, Inc. et
al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00086Texas Eastern
District Court
Trover Group, Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics
America Inc et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
4:15cv00026Texas Eastern
District Court
Imperium IP Holdings
(Cayman), Ltd. v.
Samsung Techwin Co.,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
94
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Sullivan & Cromwell
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:08cv00348Delaware District
Court
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. v. Petters Group
Worldwide LLC et al
Plaintiff
95
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Susman Godfrey
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv00091Texas Eastern
District Court
Microunity Systems
Engineering Inc v. Acer Inc
et al
Defendant
96
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Weil Gotshal
Party Type
6:15cv00692Texas Eastern
District Court
DSS Technology
Management, Inc. v.
Qualcomm Incorporated
Defendant
Consent Judgment2:14cv00199Texas Eastern
District Court
DSS Technology
Management Inc. v.
Taiwan Semiconductor
Manufacturing Company,
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv00091Texas Eastern
District Court
Microunity Systems
Engineering Inc v. Acer Inc
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:10cv00490Texas Eastern
District Court
Vertical Computer
Systems, Inc. v.
Interwoven, Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:13cv00882Texas Eastern
District Court
Adrain v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:14cv01172Texas Eastern
District Court
Trover Group, Inc. et al v.
Kaltec Electronics, Inc. et
al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
2:15cv00086Texas Eastern
District Court
Trover Group, Inc. et al v.
Samsung Electronics
America Inc et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
5:06cv00239Texas Eastern
District Court
Antor Media Corporation v.
Samsung
Telecommunications LLP
et al
Defendant
97
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
White & Case
Party Type
Summary Judgment3:13cv00194California Northern
District Court
Tse v. Google Inc., et al. Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:12cv00578Texas Eastern
District Court
Commonwealth Scientific
and Industrial Research
Organisation v. MediaTek
Inc. et al
Defendant
98
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Williams Morgan
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
6:11cv00195Texas Eastern
District Court
Hybrid Audio LLC v. HIGH
TECH COMPUTER
CORP. A/K/A HTC CORP.
et al
Defendant
99
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Winston & Strawn
Party Type
Jury Verdict1:11cv04574Illinois Northern
District Court
Cascades Computer
Innovation, LLC v.
Motorola Mobility Holdings,
Inc. et al
Defendant
100
Court Case Name Case No. Case Outcome
Young Conaway
Party Type
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
3:12cv04143California Northern
District Court
IpVenture Inc. v. Lenovo
Group Limited et al
Defendant
1:14cv01430Delaware District
Court
Elm 3DS Innovations LLC
v. Samsung Electronics
Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
1:15cv00898Delaware District
Court
ProMOS Technologies,
Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination1:10cv00389Delaware District
Court
SoftView LLC v. Apple Inc.
et al
Defendant
Other Termination1:12cv00987Delaware District
Court
SoftView LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination1:13cv02033Delaware District
Court
Home Semiconductor
Corporation v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
Other Termination1:14cv00337Delaware District
Court
Surpass Tech Innovation
LLC v. Samsung Display
Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00827Delaware District
Court
CyberFone Systems LLC
v. ZTE (USA) Inc.
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv00833Delaware District
Court
CyberFone Systems LLC
v. Vizio Inc. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:11cv01165Delaware District
Court
Graphics Properties
Holdings Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co., Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv00388Delaware District
Court
Graphics Properties
Holdings Inc. v. Samsung
Electronics Co. Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:12cv00572Delaware District
Court
Smart Audio Technologies
LLC v. Samsung
Electronics Co Ltd et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:13cv00356Delaware District
Court
Technology Innovations
Associates LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co.
Ltd. et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:14cv00338Delaware District
Court
Surpass Tech Innovation
LLC v. Sharp Corporation
et al
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Joint
1:14cv00624Delaware District
Court
MAZ Encryption
Technologies LLC v.
Samsung Electronics Co
Ltd
Defendant
Voluntary
Dismissal-Plaintiff
1:14cv00863Delaware District
Court
Sequent Data LLC v.
Toshiba Samsung Storage
Technology Korea
Corporation, et al.
Defendant
101
