Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understanding Judicial Resistance and...

76
Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law Volume 11 | Issue 2 Article 18 2003 Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understanding Judicial Resistance and Imaging the Solutions Joan S. Meier Follow this and additional works at: hp://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl Part of the Family Law Commons is Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Washington College of Law Journals & Law Reviews at Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Recommended Citation Meier, Joan S. "Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understanding Judicial Resistance and Imaging the Solutions." American University Journal of Gender Social Policy and Law 11, no. 2 (2003): 657-730.

Transcript of Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understanding Judicial Resistance and...

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law

Volume 11 | Issue 2 Article 18

2003

Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and ChildProtection: Understanding Judicial Resistance andImaging the SolutionsJoan S. Meier

Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgsplPart of the Family Law Commons

This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Washington College of Law Journals & Law Reviews at Digital Commons @ AmericanUniversity Washington College of Law. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law by an authorized administratorof Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law. For more information, please contact [email protected].

Recommended CitationMeier, Joan S. "Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understanding Judicial Resistance and Imaging theSolutions." American University Journal of Gender Social Policy and Law 11, no. 2 (2003): 657-730.

����������� � �� ����������

���

��������������������������������������������������

���������� ���������������������������

��������

���!������∗

�"#$%&'(#)%"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!��*�! �+,-��#'&)-,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!��.

! �+,-�� !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!��./! �+,-�0 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!���

��! '&)()+1��(2)3%42$-")+�)"��-,4%",-,�#%��%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-!!!!!!!���! �2+"7-,�)"��%'$#,8��"&-$,#+"&)"7�%9��%5-,#)(��)%1-"(- !!!!��*/! �)5)#,�%9�#2-�:-;��"1)72#-"5-"#< ���������',#%&=�+"&��),)#+#)%"��-#-$5)"+#)%", !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!���

���! >2=�+"&��%;��%'$#,��-,),#��%5-,#)(��)%1-"(-�����������1+)5,�)"��',#%&=��+,-, !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!���

!� �+$-"#+1��?'+1)#=�+#�+11��%,#,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!���/! �),(%'"#)"7�#2-��$-&)@)1)#=�%9��%5-,#)(��������)%1-"(-�((',+#)%",!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!�*�

�! �2-��-+")"7�%9�-'#$+1)#= !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!�*�0! �-"&-$�/)+, !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!�*�

∗��$%9-,,%$�%9��1)")(+1��+;�������������� ���������� �����������!���2-�,--&,�%9

#2),� $#)(1-� ;-$-� )")#)+11=� 41+"#-&� #-"� =-+$,� +7%� ;2-"� :�+,-� 0< � ;+,� 1)#)7+#-&A� +4$-1)5)"+$=�6-$,)%"�%9�)#�;+,�4$-,-"#-&�+#�#2-��BB��""'+1��--#)"7�%9�#2-�5-$)(+",,%()+#)%"� %9� �+;� �(2%%1,!� � �� +5� 7$+#-9'1� #%� �)3� �(2"-)&-$� 9%$� 4'@1),2)"7� 2-$4%;-$9'1�+"&� )"6+1'+@1-�@%%C�+"&� #%�""��2+11-(C� 9%$�%$7+")3)"7� #2),��=54%,)'5�;2)(2�4$%6)&-&�5-�#2-�5%#)6+#)%"�+"&�%44%$#'")#=�#%�5%$-�9'11=�&-6-1%4�#2-�4)-(-!��+5�-,4-()+11=�7$+#-9'1�#%�""��$--&5+"��;2%�,'44%$#-&�#2),�$#)(1-8,�&)99)('1#�@)$#2)"� ;+=,� #%%� "'5-$%',� #%� 1),#�� +"&� ;2%,-� "'+"(-&� +"&� &--4� #2)"C)"7� +@%'#� #2-,-),,'-,�2+,�)"9%$5-&�5'(2�%9�5=�#2)"C)"7�)"�#2),�4)-(-!���2+"C,�+1,%�#%��6+"��#+$C�9%$2),�-6-$D4$-,-"#�;)11)"7"-,,�#%�$-+&�&$+9#,�+"&�%99-$�)"(),)6-�(%55-"#,��+,�;-11�+,�2),@$)11)+"#�-E4%,)#)%",�%"�#2-�4$%@1-5�%9�@+##-$)"7�+"&�5%#2-$)"7!����+1,%�%;-�#2+"C,#%�$-,-+$(2�+,,),#+"#,��=""��),)"7-$�+"&�"F+1)��+4'$��+"&�#%�#2-��-%$7-�>+,2)"7#%"�")6-$,)#=��+;��(2%%1�9%$�9%$�)#,�,'44%$#�)"�#2-�9%$5�%9�+�,'55-$�,#)4-"&!���)"+11=���#2+"C�5=�(1)-"#,�9%$�#2-)$�$-5+$C+@1-�,#$-"7#2�)"�;)#2,#+"&)"7�#2-)$�%$&-+1,�@%#2�)"+"&�%'#�%9�(%'$#��+"&�#2-)$�7-"-$%,)#=�)"�,2+$)"7�#2-)$�,#%$)-,!

1

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��* ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

�! �-5-+"%$��)99-$-"(-,�@-#;--"��-$4-#$+#%$,�+"&��������)(#)5,�%9�@',-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!�B�

�! ��",),#-"(-�%"��'#'+1�/1+5-�%$�/1+5-1-,,"-,, !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!�B0�! ��=4%#2-#)(+1��-@+#-�%"�#2-��'#'+1)#=��-$,4-(#)6- !!!!!!!!!�B.0! �/$)-9��+,-��#'&=I �2-�>%$C�%9� +"-#� %2",#%" !!!!!!!!!!!!!�B*

�! �$-+#)"7��+,#��%5-,#)(��)%1-"(-�+,��������$$-1-6+"#�#%�#2-�/+##-$-$8,��+$-"#)"7�%$�#2-��������2)1&$-"8,��'#'$-�>-11D@-)"7 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!���

�! �$-+#)"7�&'1#��%5-,#)(��)%1-"(-�+,��������$$-1-6+"#�#%��2)1&$-"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!���0! >2=��+,#��%5-,#)(��)%1-"(-�),�-(-,,+$)1=��������-1-6+"#�#%��'#'$-��+$-"#)"7 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!���

�! �6-$D�-1)+"(-�%"�:-'#$+1< ��E4-$#,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!����! �7"%$+"(-�%9��%5-,#)(��)%1-"(-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!��*0! /)+,�7+)",#��-$5)"+#)"7��-1+#)%",2)4, !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!����! �6-$D�-1)+"(-�%"�:�()-"#)9)(< ��-,#,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!��0

�! >2-$-��$%5��-$-J!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!��.��! �2)"C)"7��'#�%9�#2-�/%E�@%'#��%11+@%$+#)6-�����������-,4%",-,�#%��$%#-(#��2)1&$-"�)"��$)6+#-��%5-,#)(�����������)%1-"(- �',#%&=��)#)7+#)%"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!���

!� �'@1)( �$)6+#-��+$#"-$,2)4,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!���/!� �-$5)"+#)"7��+$-"#+1��)72#, !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!�0�

�%"(1',)%" !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!�0�44-"&)E� !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!�0�

����������

�"�5'(2�%9��)3��(2"-)&-$8,�;%$C��,2-�4$%6)&-,�+�4%;-$9'1�($)#)?'-%9� %'$� ('1#'$-8,� 4+#$)+$(2+1� 1-7+1� +"&� ,%()+1� $-,4%",-,� #%� ;%5-"� +,5%#2-$,!� � %#)"7� #2+#� :5%#2-$2%%&� ),� ($)#)(+1� #%� ;%5-"8,,'@%$&)"+#)%"�<

�� ,2-� 4%)"#,� %'#� #2+#�5%#2-$,� +$-� : 1)C-1=� #%� @-� 2-1&

4$)5+$)1=� %$� -6-"� -E(1',)6-1=� $-,4%",)@1-� 9%$� +"=� 2+$5� H#%� +(2)1&K!�!�!�!���+1-�6)%1-"(-�)"�#2-�9+5)1=��-6-"�;2-"�)#�),�-E#$-5-�+"&1-#2+1��,--5,�1)C-�+�"+#'$+1�-E#-",)%"�%9�5+1-�4+#$)+$(2+1�+'#2%$)#=�)"7-"-$+1A� ;%5-"8,� 9+)1'$-� #%� 5%#2-$� 5+C-,� #2-5� 5%",#-$,!<

0� � �2-

)"6),)@)1)#=� )"� %'$� ,%()-#=� %9� @%#2� 5+1-� 6)%1-"(-� +"&� ;%5-"8,5%#2-$)"7�5+C-,�9+)$�F'&75-"#,�+@%'#�;%5-"�L+"&�5-"M�+,�4+$-"#,&)99)('1#�+#�@-,#!��>2)1-�+(C"%;1-&7)"7�#2+#�5%#2-$,�)"�,%5-�(+,-,�&%&-,-$6-� #%� @-� 2-1&� $-,4%",)@1-� 9%$� 2+$5� #%� (2)1&$-"�� �(2"-)&-$"-6-$#2-1-,,�(%"(1'&-,�

�� ���� ���N/�����!� ���������� /������� >���� G� �������� �>����� �.B

L0���M!

0� ��������+#���0D�.!

2

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ��B

H)K#�),�&)99)('1#�#%�&-#-$5)"-�#2-�(%"#%'$,�%9�5+#-$"+1�$-,4%",)@)1)#=)"� +� ('1#'$-� #2+#� @1+5-,� 5%#2-$,� 9%$� +11� 4$%@1-5,� $-1+#)"7� #%(2)1&$-"�� 7)6-,� 5%#2-$,� ,%� 1)##1-� 5+#-$)+1� +"&� ,%()+1� ,'44%$#�� +"&+@,%16-,� 9+#2-$,�%9�+11� $-,4%",)@)1)#=!� ��"1-,,�;-�41+(-�4$%@1-5,�%95%#2-$2%%&� +"&� @+##-$)"7� ;)#2)"� +� 9$+5-;%$C� %9� 7-"&-$,%()+1)3+#)%"� +"&� ,'@%$&)"+#)%"�� ;-� (+""%#� 9'11=� +"&� 9+)$1=� +,,-,,#2-�(%"#%'$,�%9�$-,4%",)@)1)#=!

�(2"-)&-$8,� 9-5)"),#� ($)#)?'-��;)#2�;2)(2� �� +7$--�.� ),� )54%$#+"#� #%

@-+$�)"�5)"&�+,�#2-�"+#)%"+1�(%"6-$,+#)%"�+@%'#�(2)1&$-"�)"�9+5)1)-,-E4-$)-"()"7� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� 2-+#,� '4!� � �"� #2-� 1+,#� ,-6-$+1� =-+$,�#2-�9-&-$+1�7%6-$"5-"#�

��"+#)%"+1� F'&)()+1�@%&)-,�

�� ,#+#-� 1-7),1+#'$-,�

#2-� 5-$)(+"� /+$� ,,%()+#)%"�*� +"&� )"&)6)&'+1� F'&7-,�� +1%"7� ;)#2

(2)1&�;-19+$-�+"&�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�-E4-$#,�2+6-�9)"+11=B�#'$"-&�#2-)$

�� ��������+#���*!

.� �� ����������"%#-�0�!

�! �%$�-E+541-�� )"��BB���%"7$-,,�4+,,-&�+��-,%1'#)%"�-E4$-,,)"7� #2-� ,-",-�%9#2-��%"7$-,,�#2+#�: 9%$�4'$4%,-,�%9�&-#-$5)")"7�(2)1&�(',#%&=��($-&)@1-�-6)&-"(-�%942=,)(+1� +@',-� %9� %"-8,� ,4%',-� ,2%'1&� ($-+#-� +� ,#+#'#%$=� 4$-,'54#)%"� #2+#� )#� ),&-#$)5-"#+1� #%� #2-� (2)1&� #%�@-�41+(-&� )"� #2-� (',#%&=�%9� #2-� +@',)6-� ,4%',-!< � ��!�!�%"!� �-,!� ��0�� ���,#� �%"7!� L�BB�M!� � �'$)"7� #2-� 4+,#� &-(+&-�� #2-� �-4+$#5-"#� %9�-+1#2�+"&��'5+"��-$6)(-,�2+,�,4%",%$-&�+�"'5@-$�%9�)")#)+#)6-,!������������

G� ������ ������ ��/� ���!�� �������� /�� ������ >������ ������� ��� ������

��������� ��������� ���� �O��������� ��� ����� ����������� L�BB�M�� ���������� � 2##4� +,4-!22,!7%6 2,4 (=4 &6 )"#$%!2#5!� � �"� +&&)#)%"�� #2-� 9-&-$+1� 7%6-$"5-"#;+,�+�4$)5+$=�,4%",%$�%9�#2-�,-5)"+1�:�$--"�/%%C< �+"&�)#,�,'@,-?'-"#�4)1%#�4$%F-(#,&),(',,-&�@-1%;!������������"%#-���!���"� '"-��BBB��#2-�9-&-$+1�7%6-$"5-"#�,4%",%$-&+�"+#)%"+1�(%"9-$-"(-�%"�#2-�)54+(#�%9�;)#"-,,)"7�6)%1-"(-�%"�(2)1&$-"!���������!���

��!� ���!�G�����P!�����������!�!����8����� ���!�� ���� �������������������

����������������O�����������������L0���M!

�! �2-�+#)%"+1��%'"()1�%9� '6-")1-� +"&��+5)1=��%'$#� '&7-,� L:� �� < M�2+,1-&� #2-� ;+=� %"� #2),� ),,'-!� � ���� �8�� ������� ��� ��!� G� ������ ��!� ������ �����

�������� ��� ����� ������ ��������� ��������� ������ �������� 0�� L�BB�M!� � �"4+$#)('1+$��+,�),�&),(',,-&�9'$#2-$�@-1%;��#2-�� �� �2+,�4)%"--$-&�#2-�&-6-1%45-"#%9� #2-�(%11+@%$+#)6-�+44$%+(2� #%� #2-�%6-$1+4�%9�(2)1&�+@',-�+"&�&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�;2)(2�2+,�)",4)$-&�#2),��+4-$!������������"%#-���!

�! �"� +&&)#)%"� #%� +5-"&)"7� ,#+#-� (',#%&=� ,#+#'#-,�� ,--� ������ "%#-� �*� +"&+((%54+"=)"7� #-E#�� ,%5-� ,#+#-,� 2+6-� $-(-"#1=� L+"&� (%"#$%6-$,)+11=M� ($-+#-&� +")"&-4-"&-"#� ($)5-� %9� (2)1&� +@',-� 9%$� (+',)"7� +� (2)1&� #%� �� ��� +&'1#� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-!� � ���� ���������� �+'$-1� !� �-"#�� �%55-"#�� ��������� �� ����� � ��� ��� ��!�����������"������#��� ���� ���� ������"��������$���� ��"����������� ��� ���!���������� �� %������� ��� �� "����� 0���� >��!� �!� ���!� ����A� '&$-=� �#%"-� G� �-@-((+� �)+1C�"��������$���� �� &'������ ��� "������� �� (������ !�������#� ����)���� �� "����� ��� ������ 0����!�>���8���! !�0���L�BB�MA��%),�!�>-)#2%$"��%�� �� ����"������������&'������ � ��� ���!�������#�*�������������� ���"����+�� ��� ��� � � � � ��� �����������! !� �L0���M!

*! !/!!������������������������������������������L�BB.M!

B! �"#)1� +44$%E)5+#-1=� #2-� 5)&D�BB�,�� #2-� )541)(+#)%",� %9� +&'1#� @+##-$)"7� 9%$(2)1&$-"�;-$-�6)$#'+11=�)7"%$-&�@=�(2)1&�;-19+$-�+&6%(+#-,�+"&�7%6-$"5-"#+1�-"#)#)-,+&&$-,,)"7�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-!� ��E(-11-"#�$-,-+$(2�2+,�@--"�&%"-�%"� #2),� ,'@F-(#� )"#2-�1+,#�&-(+&-!�����,����������������������������������������������������������

�������������������������������������L�+"&$+�!��$+2+5D/-$5+"�G� -99$-=�&1-,%"� -&,!�� 0���MA� /����� ���������� �������� �������� >��� ���� ���� ����

L0��0MA������� ��������!�������������/�������>����L�BB�M!���2),�+##-"#)%"�#%

3

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

+##-"#)%"� #%� #2),� ),,'-� )"� "+#)%"+1� $-4%$#,�� (%"9-$-"(-,�� ;%$C,2%4,+"&�"+#)%"+1�4%1)(=�&-6-1%45-"#�)")#)+#)6-,!

�2-�5%,#�,)7")9)(+"#�&-6-1%45-"#�)"�#2),�+$-+�#%�&+#-�2+,�@--"�#2-�BBB� 4'@1)(+#)%"� %9� #2-� ,%D(+11-&� :�$--"� /%%C�< � +� ,-#� %9� F%)"#$-(%55-"&+#)%",� &-6-1%4-&� %6-$� +44$%E)5+#-1=� #;%� =-+$,� %9%$7+")3-&�&),(',,)%"�+"&�&-@+#-�+5%"7�(2)1&�;-19+$-� +"&�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-� -E4-$#,�� +&6%(+#-,� +"&� F'&7-,!

��� � �2-� (%11+@%$+#)%"� ;2)(2

,4+;"-&� #2-� �$--"� /%%C� ;+,� $+&)(+1A� )#� ;+,� #2-� 9)$,#� #)5-� #2+#&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +"&� (2)1&� ;-19+$-� +&6%(+#-,� 2+&� ,=,#-5+#)(+11=,%'72#� L+#� +� "+#)%"+1� 1-6-1M� #%� +(#)6-1=� @$)&7-� #2-)$� 4$%9%'"&� 7'19,+"&� 5'#'+1� 5),#$',#!

��� � �2),� 4$%(-,,�� &-,)7"-&� #%� +,,),#� #2-

7%6-$"5-"#� )"� )54$%6)"7� (2)1&� +@',-� +"&� "-71-(#� 4$%(--&)"7,�($-+#-&� +� 5%&-1� %9� (%11+@%$+#)%"� 9%$� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"�� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-� +"&� (%'$#� %99)()+1,!� � �2-� �$--"� /%%C� L+"&� 4$%F-(#,� )#� 2+,,4+;"-&M

�0� $-4$-,-"#,� +� 4+$+&)75� ,2)9#� ;)#2� #2-� 4%#-"#)+1� 9%$

#$+",9%$5)"7� #2-� 4$+(#)(-� %9� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� +7-"()-,!� � #� $%%#�� )#,--C,� #%� $-41+(-� ,'(2� +7-"()-,8� (%"6-"#)%"+1� 4-$,4-(#)6-�� ;2)(2#=4)(+11=�#$-+#,�+"=�2+$5�#%�(2)1&$-"�+,�#2-�9+'1#�%9�5%#2-$,�

���;)#2�+

5%$-�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-D,+66=�4-$,4-(#)6-��;2)(2�41+(-,�$-,4%",)@)1)#=%"� 5+1-� +@',-$,� ;2-"� +44$%4$)+#-�� $-(%7")3-,� #2+#� (2)1&$-"8,)"#-$-,#,�$-?')$-�#2-�,+9-#=�%9�#2-)$�5%#2-$,��+"&�9%$5,�+11)+"(-,�;)#2@+##-$-&�;%5-"�#%�4$%#-(#�@%#2�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"�+"&�#2-5,-16-,!

�.

(2)1&$-"8,� )"#-$-,#,� @=� $-,-+$(2-$,�� +"&� 5%$-� $-(-"#1=� 4%1)(=5+C-$,�� 2+,� "%#4-"-#$+#-&�5+"=� (%'$#� +&F'&)(+#)%",� %9� (',#%&=�� 9%$� #2-� $-+,%",� &),(',,-&� 9'$#2-$@-1%;!

��� ���� &���� ���� �� ����� ���� ��� ��� ��� !�������� ���� "���� +�� ��� ��� � "��#���������� ���� %������ ���� %��� ����� ��� ������������� ����� ���� �8�� ������� ��

��!� �� ������ ��!� ������ ������ �������� ���8�� �0� L�BBBM� H2-$-)"+9#-$� �$--"/%%CK!���2-�:�$--"�/%%C< �")(C"+5-�&-$)6-,�9$%5�#2-�(%1%$�%9�#2-�@%%C8,�(%6-$!

��! �-7+$&)"7� #2-�2),#%$=� %9�5),#$',#� @-#;--"�&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +&6%(+#-,� +"&(2)1&�;-1+$-�+&6%(+#-,��,--��-!7!���',+"��(2-(#-$�G� -99$-=��&1-,%"����� ���� ��� ��� �������������"������#���"��������"�������� ������ �����"���������������� ��� ���!�������"�� � �������L�BB.M������������� �;;;!5)"(+6+!'5"!-&' 4+4-$, ;)"7,4$!2#5!

�0! �)"(-� #2-� �$--"� /%%C8,� 4'@1)(+#)%"�� ,)E� : 4)1%#� 4$%F-(#,< � 9'"&-&� @=� +(%",%$#)'5� %9� 9-&-$+1� +7-"()-,� H2-$-)"+9#-$� �$--"� /%%C� �")#)+#)6-K� 2+6-� @--"1+'"(2-&�+$%'"&�#2-�(%'"#$=!���+$#)()4+"#,�+$-�+##-54#)"7�#%�)541-5-"#�#2-��$--"/%%C8,� $-(%55-"&+#)%",� 9%$� (%11+@%$+#)6-� 4$+(#)(-� +"&� #%� &-6-1%4� ,%5-� 1-+$")"7+@%'#� ;2+#� &%-,� +"&� &%-,� "%#� ;%$C!� � �%$� 9'$#2-$� )"9%$5+#)%"� $-7+$&)"7� #2),�")#)+#)6-��6),)#�#2-�;-@,)#-��2##4� ;;;!#2-7$--"@%%C!)"9%!

��! �"� -������� ��� ��������� +� 7$%'"&@$-+C)"7� (1+,,� +(#)%"� 1+;,')#� 9)1-&� @=@+##-$-&� 5%#2-$,�� #2-� -;� �%$C� �)#=� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� +7-"(=8,� 4%1)(=� %9� #$-+#)"75%#2-$,� +,� "-71-(#9'1� +"&� $-5%6)"7� #2-)$� (2)1&$-"� %"� #2-� 7$%'"&,� #2+#� #2-6)(#)5)3-&� 5%#2-$,� ;-$-� : -"7+7)"7� )"� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�< � ;+,� ,'((-,,9'11=(2+11-"7-&� +"&� 2-1&� '"(%",#)#'#)%"+1!� � ���� ���������� )(2%1,%"� 6!� >)11)+5,�� 0��� �!�'44!� 0&� ����� ����� �B��� 0�*� L0��0M!� � �%54+$+@1-� 4$+(#)(-,� +$-� "%#� '"(%55%"+$%'"&�#2-�(%'"#$=!

�.! �$--"�/%%C�������"%#-�����+#��2!��!���2),�: $-D9$+5-< �),�4$%9%'"&1=�"--&-&�(%"6-"#)%"+1�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�4$+(#)(-�2+,�"%#�%"1=�@1+5-&�@+##-$-&�;%5-"�9%$�@%#2#2-)$� %;"�6)(#)5)3+#)%"� +"&� #2-)$� (2)1&$-"8,�� @'#�2+,� 9+)1-&� #%�4$%6)&-� ,-$6)(-,� +"&

4

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

>2)1-� $-9%$5� %9� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� 4$+(#)(-� ),� ($)#)(+11=� )54%$#+"#�#2-�91'$$=�%9�+##-"#)%"�#%�#2),�+$-"+�+1,%�2)721)72#,�2%;�1)##1-�+##-"#)%"2+,�@--"�4+)&�#%�#2-�4+$+11-1�4$%@1-5�%9�(2)1&�;-19+$-�&),4%,)#)%",�)"����� ��1)#)7+#)%"�(%"(-$")"7�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-!���2)1&$-"8,�,+9-#=�+"&;-11D@-)"7� +$-� %9#-"� F',#� +,� 5'(2� +#� ,#+C-� )"� 1)#)7+#)%"� 9%$� ()6)14$%#-(#)%"�%$&-$,��(',#%&=�+"&�&)6%$(-�+;+$&,��+11�%9�;2)(2�9$-?'-"#1=&-#-$5)"-� #2-� #-$5,� %9� (2)1&� 6),)#+#)%"� %$� (',#%&=� 9%$� +"� +&'1#@+##-$-$!

�����-#��9+$�1-,,�4%1)(=�%$�$-,-+$(2�+##-"#)%"�2+,�@--"�&)$-(#-&

#%�#2),�+$-"+!��

�"� 9+(#�� +� (1-+$� '"&-$,#+"&)"7� %9� ;2+#� ),� 2+44-")"7� )"� 4$)6+#-(',#%&= &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� 1)#)7+#)%"� ),� +� "-(-,,+$=� -E#-",)%"�%9� #2-�$--"� /%%C� 4$%(-,,�� +"&� ;)11� ,2-&� 1)72#� %"� #2-� #2%'72#� 4$%(-,,-,#2+#� (%"#$)@'#-� #%� ;%5+"D@1+5)"7� ;2-$-� (2)1&$-"� +$-� (%"(-$"-&!�"1)C-� #2-� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� +$-"+�� ;2-$-� ,#+#-� 4%1)()-,� 2+6-� @--"-)#2-$�'"#%'(2-&�@=�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+;+$-"-,,�%$�@1+#+"#1=�6)(#)5D@1+5)"7�

���,#+#-�,#+#'#-,�7%6-$")"7�(',#%&=�+"&�6),)#+#)%"�2+6-�+1$-+&=

@--"�$-6),-&�#%�$-91-(#�,%5-�$-(%7")#)%"�%9�#2-�$-1-6+"(-�%9�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-� #%� (',#%&=� +"&� 6),)#+#)%"� &),4%,)#)%",!� � �%,#� ,#+#-,� "%;

)"#-$6-"#)%",�#2+#�(%'1&�5-+")"79'11=�+,,),#�@%#2�#2-�(2)1&$-"�+"&�#2-)$�5%#2-$,��+"&#2-"� (%54%'"&-&� (2)1&$-"8,� ,'99-$)"7� @=� &-4$)6)"7� #2-5� %9� #2-)$� "%"D6)%1-"#5%#2-$,!� � �2-� &),#'$@)"7� (+,-� 2),#%$)-,� &%('5-"#-&� )"� -������� ��� �������&-5%",#$+#-� #2-�-E#-"#� #%�;2)(2�5+"=�(2)1&$-"�L+,�;-11� +,�5%#2-$,M�2+6-� ,'99-$-&'""-(-,,+$)1=�9$%5�#2-,-�5),7')&-&��+"&�#%%�%9#-"�#$+'5+#)(��,#+#-�)"#-$6-"#)%",!�����+#� ����� 0��D�0�� 0�0D��A� ��� �����'+1+")��"%,��%����� ���� �� �����+� ��#� � � �� ���.(������� �� %�� �� � �� ����� ������ ���� ������ "�������� �B� ���!� >���8�� �! !� 00BL�BB�MA��6+"��#+$C����(������� ��%�� �� #�������������/*���� �����+� ��.� ������0��0�>!���!��!��!����!�0B�L0���M!

�2-� �$--"� /%%C� �")#)+#)6-� ,--C,� #%� $-9%$5� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� 4$+(#)(-� ;)#2%'#-E41)()#1=� "+5)"7� #2-� 4+#$)+$(2+1� ,%()+1� +"&� ('1#'$+1� (%"#-E#� ;)#2)"� ;2)(2� #2-,-"%$5,�2+6-�91%'$),2-&!���#�),�#2',�+�4$+75+#)(��"%"D)&-%1%7)(+1�+##-54#�#%�#$+",9%$54+#$)+$(2=�)"�#2),�+$-+A�)#�$-5+)",�#%�@-�,--"�2%;�-99-(#)6-�)#�;)11�@-�)"�(2+"7)"7�#2-('1#'$-,�%9�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�+"&�#2-�(%'$#,!� �>2)1-�#2-�4)1%#�4$%F-(#,�+$-�,#)11� )"�#2--+$1=�,#+7-,��+"�)")#)+1�: �6+1'+#)%"��'55+$=< �;)11�,%%"�@-�+6+)1+@1-!����������/���

�����������P��L1+,#�6),)#-&��+=����0���M������������� �2##4� ;;;!#2-7$--"@%%C!)"9%!

��� �����+,-����������+$#��!!

��! �"�0��0�+�7$%'"&@$-+C)"7�@%%C�+44-+$-&��;2)(2�2+,� (2+$#-&�+�"-;�(%'$,-9%$� #2%,-� ;2%� ;%$C� %"� #2-� %6-$1+4� %9� (',#%&=� 1)#)7+#)%"� +"&� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-!����� /������ G� �� �!� ��������� ���� /������� �� ������ ��������� ���

����������������������������������������� L0��0M!� �>$)##-"�@=� #;%�5-"#+12-+1#2� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,� ;)#2� -E#-",)6-� @+(C7$%'"&� )"� @+##-$-$,8� (%'",-1)"7�� #2),� @%%C"%#� %"1=�5+$,2+1,� 4$-6)%',� &+#+� %"� #2-� )54+(#� %9� @+##-$)"7� %"� (2)1&$-"�� @'#� +1,%&$+;,� %"� #2-� +'#2%$,8� (1)")(+1� -E4-$)-"(-� #%� 4$%6)&-� +� 4%;-$9'1� +"+1=,),� %9� #2-$-+,%",�@+##-$-$,�4%,-�-5%#)%"+1��+,�;-11�+,�42=,)(+1�$),C,�#%�(2)1&$-"�-6-"�+9#-$�#2-4+$-"#,� ,-4+$+#-!� � �"� +&&)#)%"�� #2),� @%%C� +"+1=3-,� 2%;� @+##-$-$,� +$-� +@1-� #%� @-� ,%,'((-,,9'1� )"�(',#%&=�1)#)7+#)%"!� ����� ����+#����D0*!���$-6)%',1=���6+"��#+$C�;+,�%"-�%9#2-� 9)$,#� ,(2%1+$,� +"&� 5-"#+1� 2-+1#2� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,� #%� )&-"#)9=� 2%;� @+##-$-$,� ',-(',#%&=�1)#)7+#)%"�#%�(%"#)"'-�#2-)$�+@',-�%9�#2-�5%#2-$!�������6+"��#+$C��1�2����� ����������� �����#�(������ �������������������� ��"��������"�� ������*��/!��!����!�B������*�L�BB�M�H2-$-)"+9#-$��#+$C��1�2����� ������������ �����K!

��� ���������"%#-���!

5

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��0 ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

$-?')$-��+#�5)")5'5��(%",)&-$+#)%"�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-� )"�(',#%&=+&F'&)(+#)%",A� +44$%E)5+#-1=� ,-6-"#--"� ,#+#-,� 2+6-� +&%4#-&� +4$-,'54#)%"�%9�,%5-�C)"&�+7+)",#�(',#%&=�#%�@+##-$-$,!

�*���#�),�+11�#2-

5%$-� ,#$)C)"7�� #2-"�� #%� $-+1)3-� #2+#� #$)+1� (%'$#,�� -6-"� )"� #2-,-� ,#+#-,�+44-+$� #%�@-�7$+"#)"7� (',#%&=� #%� +11-7-&�@+##-$-$,�5%$-�%9#-"� #2+""%#!

�B

�2),�4+##-$"�),�+1,%�,#$)C)"7�9%$�+"%#2-$�$-+,%"���2-�9+)1'$-�%9�5+"=(%'$#,� #%� +441=� "-;� '"&-$,#+"&)"7,� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� )"� (+,-,(%"(-$")"7�(',#%&=�+(#'+11=�(%"#$+,#,� ,2+$41=�;)#2� #2-�&-5%",#$+@1-)"($-+,-,�%6-$�#2-�4+,#� #-"�=-+$,� )"� F'&)()+1�+;+$-"-,,�+"&�,-",)#)6)#=#%� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� )"� 5%$-� ,#+"&+$&� :&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-< � (+,-,�,'(2�+,�()6)1�4$%#-(#)%"�%$&-$,�%$�($)5)"+1�4$%,-('#)%",!��#�#2-�1-+,#�)#� ),�"%�1%"7-$�:4%1)#)(+11=�(%$$-(#< �%$�(%"6-"#)%"+1�;),&%5�)"� #2-,-,-##)"7,� #%� &),@-1)-6-� @+##-$-&� ;%5-"8,� (1+)5,� %$� #$)6)+1)3-� #2-5� +,4-##=� 9+5)1=�5+##-$,!

0�� � �"� (%"#$+,#�� #2-� '"$-(%",#$'(#-&� 2%,#)1)#=� %9

�*� ���� +"(=� �-5%"�� � � � �� "��� ���� 1��� ����� %����� ���� ����� � "� ���� �

�� ����#�3���&���� ��������*��4��0*�>�!�����������!����!�����L0���MA�(������!����������"����"� ����� � � �#��������������� � ��"��������������%��� �����0B���!��!P!��B���BB�� 00�� +44!� L�BB�M� H2-$-)"+9#-$� (������ !�������� ��� "���� "� ���� � � � �KA� �+'1)"-P')$)%"�-#� +1!��"����� ���#�%�� �� ����"�������&'����� �� ��� ���!�������� ���"�� � ��"� ��������!�� � ������ ��� �������/!�!���/!���!��! !��������B�"!��B�L�BB�M!

�B! �#� ),�&)99)('1#� #%�@-� ,'$-�;2+#� ),�2+44-")"7� )"� #$)+1� (%'$#,� ,)"(-�%"1=� +� ,5+114-$(-"#+7-� %9� (+,-,� +$-� +44-+1-&�� @'#� $-(-"#� ,#'&)-,� 2+6-� )&-"#)9)-&� +� &),#'$@)"7#$-"&!� ������$),#-"��%5@+$&)��"� ���������������/����������O�� +"!�B�� 0����� +#�+$#� �� L$-4%$#)"7� %"� +� 6+$)-#=� %9� (+,-,� +"&� ,#'&)-,� )"&)(+#)"7� #2+#�� ;2-$-� +@',-� ),+11-7-&�� +�5+F%$)#=�%9�(%'$#,� +;+$&� ,%1-�%$� F%)"#�(',#%&=� #%� #2-�+@',-$M������������ � 2##4� ;;;!@%,#%"42%-")E!(%5 @%,#%" "-;,�9-+#'$-, #%4 9-+#'$-, &%('5-"#, �0�.����!2#5!� � �"� �B*B�� #2-� �'4$-5-� '&)()+1��%'$#� %9��+,,+(2',-##,8��-"&-$�/)+,�#'&=�9%'"&�#2+#�5%$-�#2+"���Q�%9�9+#2-$,�$-(-)6-&�,%1-�%$�F%)"#�(',#%&=�$-7+$&1-,,%9� ;2-#2-$� #2-$-� ;+,� +� 2),#%$=� %9� +@',-!� � ���� �%5@+$&)�� ����� L()#)"7� �!� �����

��8�� ��������� �������� �� ���� ���������� L�BB�MMA� /������ G� ������������� "%#-� ���� +#� ���A� ��� ���� �)"&+� -)1,%"�� %�� ���� ����,� "������� ���� � � � ���"����#�"�� �������"����� ���������.������ ��5� ������*�>�������!/!������� ���!����� �..� L0���M� L$-4%$#)"7� #2+#� +� ,#'&=� %9� ��.�� $+"&%51=� ,-1-(#-&� (%'$#� 9)1-,� )"� +�+"+&)+"�F'$),&)(#)%"�9%'"&�#2+#�: "%#�%"1=�&%�+@',-$,�%@#+)"�'"$-,#$)(#-&�+((-,,� #%#2-)$�(2)1&$-"��#2-=�+1,%�%@#+)"�(',#%&=�)"�+�,)7")9)(+"#�"'5@-$�%9�(+,-,!�!�!�!�HFK%)"#�,41)#�%$�9'11�(',#%&=�;+,�7$+"#-&�#%��%$�%@#+)"-&�@=�+@',-$,�)"���Q�%9�#2-�(%'$#D9)1-&(+,-,�!�!�!�: M!

�=� %;"� L+"&� $-,-+$(2� +,,),#+"#8,M� +&5)##-&1=� '",()-"#)9)(� ,'$6-=� %9� 5+"=� %9� #2-�")#-&� �#+#-,� (+,-,� L(%"#+)"-&� )"� 44-"&)E� M� 9%'"&� #2+#�� %9� #2)$#=D-)72#� (+,-,� )";2)(2�5%#2-$,�+11-7-&�+@',-�+"&�,%'72#�#%�1)5)#�9+#2-$,8�+((-,,�#%�(2)1&$-"������� �� ����� ���� � +7$--&�;)#2� #2-�5%#2-$A� #2-� $-5+)")"7� #2)$#=D,)E� (%'$#,� +;+$&-&� +#� 1-+,#F%)"#��+"&�%9#-"�,%1-��(',#%&=�#%�#2-�9+#2-$!���2)$#--"�%9�#2-,-�&-(),)%",�;-$-�'42-1&%"�+44-+1A�%"-�%9�#2-�#;%�9+6%$)"7�#2-�5%#2-$�;+,�$-6-$,-&�%"�+44-+1!�������)")',�6!�)")',����.�!>!0&�����L!�!��BB�M!���%,#�%9�#2-,-�(+,-,�;-$-�&-()&-&�)"�,#+#-,�;)#2+� 4$-,'54#)%"� +7+)",#� (',#%&=� #%� #2-� @+##-$-$!� � �2+#� @+##-$-&� ;%5-"� +$-� "%;9$-?'-"#1=� 1%,)"7� (',#%&=� #%� @+##-$-$,� ,2%(C-&� -6-"� 5-� ;2-"� �� 9)$,#� ,#+$#-&$-,-+$(2)"7�#2-�(+,-�1+;�9%$�#2),�$#)(1-!���%;-6-$�� )#� ),�+1,%�(1-+$�#2+#�� )"�#2%,-�9-;(+,-,� ;2-$-� +44-+1� ),� 4%,,)@1-�� +44-11+#-� (%'$#,� +$-� 5%$-� 1)C-1=� #%� $-(%7")3-� #2-6+1)&)#=�+"&�,)7")9)(+"(-�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�9%$�(2)1&�(',#%&=�&-(),)%",!������P')$)%"-#�+1!�������"%#-��*��+#���BD0�!����������������������44!�

0�� ���,� ������ %+"� �-)-$�� �� ����� 5� ����� >��!� �������� �+=� �B*��� +#� ��D.�

6

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

(%'$#,� L+"&� ,%5-#)5-,� -6-"� #2-� ,+5-� F'&7-,M� #%;+$&� #2-� ,+5-@+##-$-&� ;%5-"� +"&� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +11-7+#)%",�� ;2-"� $+),-&� )"#2-�(%"#-E#�%9�(',#%&=�%$�6),)#+#)%"�1)#)7+#)%"��(+"�@-�,#'"")"7!

0�

�2),� &)99-$-"(-� ,'77-,#,� #2+#�� ;2)1-� ,%()-#=� +"&� #2-� (%'$#,� 2+6-+(?')$-&� +� ,'4-$9)()+1� '"&-$,#+"&)"7� %9� #2-� $-+1)#=� %9� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-�� #2+#� '"&-$,#+"&)"7� ),� "%#� ,'99)()-"#1=� &--41=� )"#-7$+#-&� #%,'$6)6-� #2-� (2+11-"7-� %9� #$'1=� 4+)"9'1� (2%)(-,� $-7+$&)"7� 9+5)1)-,!�2+"C,�#%�#2-�@+##-$-&�;%5-"8,�5%6-5-"#�+"&�5+,,)6-�1-7+1�$-9%$5,%9� #2-�4+,#� #2$--�&-(+&-,��(%'$#,�+$-�"%;�5%$-�;)11)"7� #%�$-(%7")3-&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�)"�,%5-�: 9)$,#�%$&-$< �(+,-,��-!7!��4$%#-(#)%"�%$&-$,�+"&�($)5)"+1�4$%,-('#)%",!��/'#��+,��+$#2+��)"-5+"�2+,�4%)"#-&�%'#�: )#� ),� 9+$� -+,)-$� #%� ;%$C� %'#� +� 4%,)#)%"� ;2-"� #2-� 9%(',� ),� %"� #2-5+1- 9-5+1-�L%$�-?')6+1-"#M�&=+&�#2+"�;2-"�#2-�)541)(+#)%",�%9�+"=+(#)%"�+$-�9%$�#2%,-�$-1+#)%",2)4,�;)#2�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"!<

00���2',��;2-"

#2-�),,'-,�@-(%5-�5%$-�9$+'72#��+"&�9+#2-$,8�$-1+#)%",2)4,�;)#2�#2-)$(2)1&$-"�+$-�+#�,#+C-��2+$&�;%"�)",)72#,�+@%'#�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�#%%%9#-"�9+11�+;+=�+,�F'&7-,�%"(-�+7+)"�+6%)&�9+()"7�#2-�$-+1)#=�%9�;%5-"@+##-$)"7�� +"&� #2-� &)99)('1#� (2%)(-,� "--&-&� #%� 4$%#-(#� ;%5-"� +"&(2)1&$-"�+"&�2%1&�+@',-$,�+((%'"#+@1-!

�2-�$-5+)"&-$�%9�#2),�$#)(1-�9)$,#�%99-$,�#;%�(+,-�,#'&)-,�9$%5�5=%;"� 4$+(#)(-� ;2)(2� )11',#$+#-� #2-� $-,),#+"(-� %9� 9+5)1=� F'&7-,� #%@+##-$-&� ;%5-"8,� (1+)5,� (%"(-$")"7� (2)1&$-"!� � �#� #2-"� ,'$6-=,(2+"7-,�)"�(%'$#,8�'"&-$,#+"&)"7,�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�%6-$�#2-�4+,##;%� &-(+&-,!� � -E#�� )#� &),(',,-,� +� ,-$)-,� %9� +"+1=#)(� 5),(%"(-4#)%",#2+#�2-14�9'-1�(%'$#,8�$-,),#+"(-�#%�@+##-$-&�5%#2-$,8�(1+)5,�)"�(+,-,(%"(-$")"7� (2)1&$-"!� � >2)1-� 5=� +"+1=,),� %9� 9+5)1=� F'&7-,8� )&-%1%7=$-91-(#,�,%5-�+7$--5-"#�;)#2��(2"-)&-$�+"&�%#2-$�9-5)"),#�#2-%$),#,$-7+$&)"7�#2-�4$-6+1-"(-�%9�4+#$)+$(2=�+"&�,-E),5�

0����9%(',�5%$-�%"

H2-$-)"+9#-$��-)-$���� �����5� ���KA���������������+$#���!!

0�� �����������+$#,��!�+"&���!/!

00� ���� �+$#2+� �)"-5+"�� ��� ��� !�������,� "� ���,� ���� !�� � ����� ��� ��!� �!P!0����0���L0��0M!

0�� ���� ���������� ����� "%#-� ��� +#� �.B� L?'%#)"7� �+$#2+� �)"-5+"�� ������ ��+� ��� ��� %���� �� �������� �BB�� ����� �! !� 0�.�� 0*BDB�M!� � �(2"-)&-$� ,#+#-,� #2+#5%#2-$2%%&�),�: +�(%1%")3-&�(%"(-4#�< �&-9)"-&�)"�%'$�('1#'$-�+15%,#�-"#)$-1=�@=�5-")"�+�5+""-$�#2+#�4-$4-#'+#-,�;%5-"8,�,%()+1�,'@%$&)"+#)%"�#%�5-"!������ ��$%5�#2),4-$,4-(#)6-�� )#� ),� "%#� ,'$4$),)"7� #2+#� +&F'&)(+#)%",� %9� #2-� $-1+#)6-� $)72#,� %9�5%#2-$,+"&� 9+#2-$,� ;)#2� $-,4-(#� #%� (2)1&$-"� ;%'1&� @$)"7� %'#� #2-� 5%,#� 4+#$)+$(2+1� +"&;%5+"D@1+5)"7�+##)#'&-,�)"�F'&7-,�+"&�%#2-$�4$%9-,,)%"+1,!���%;-6-$��)#�,--5,�%6-$D&-#-$5)"+#)6-�#%�,'77-,#�#2+#�#2-�$-,),#+"(-�%9�,%�5+"=�F'&7-,�#%�5%#2-$,8�(1+)5,�),4'$-1=� #2-� $-,'1#� %9� ,-E),5!� � �6-"� $-+,%"+@1-�� : -"1)72#-"-&< � +"& %$� : 9-5)"),#<F'&7-,� ,%5-#)5-,� '"&-$D6+1'-� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� -6)&-"(-� )"� #2-,-� (+,-,!� � >2)1-4+#$)+$(2+1� 6+1'-,� 5+=� '"(%",()%',1=� @-� )"91'-"()"7� -6-"� #2-,-� F'&7-,8� +"&-6+1'+#%$,8�#2)"C)"7��#2-=�+$-�'"1)C-1=�#%�@-�#2-�,%1-�-E41+"+#)%"!���%$-%6-$��;2-$-+,(%",()%',�%$�'"(%",()%',�,-E),5�),�"%#�-+,)1=�+5-"+@1-�#%�,%1'#)%",��)&-"#)9)(+#)%"�%9%#2-$� -E41+"+#)%",� 9%$� F'&7-,8� @1)"&"-,,� #%� #2-� 6+1)&)#=� %9� 5%#2-$,8� (1+)5,� 5+=,'77-,#�%#2-$�,%1'#)%",!

7

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��. ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

#2-� +44+$-"#1=� 7-"&-$D"-'#$+1� (%",#$'(#,� ;2)(2� (%",()%',1=� &$)6-5+"=�F'&7-,�+"&�+11%;�#2-5�#%�,--�#2-5,-16-,�+,�&%)"7�: F',#)(-< �%$: $)72#< � ;2-"� #2-=� $-F-(#� @+##-$-&� ;%5-"8,� (1+)5,� %"� @-2+19� %9(2)1&$-"!���"�,%�&%)"7����,--C�#%�%4-"�+�&)+1%7'-�@-#;--"�#2%,-�1)C-5=,-19� ;2%� ,#+$#� ;)#2� +"� +&6%(+#-8,� 4-$,4-(#)6-� +"&� #2%,-� )"-6+1'+#)6-�$%1-,�L(%'$#,�+"&�9%$-",)(�-6+1'+#%$,M�;2%�5',#�,#+$#�9$%5+� :"-'#$+1< � 4-$,4-(#)6-� )"� #2-,-� (+,-,!� � ((',+#)%",� %9� 4+#$)+$(2=�;2)1-� '"9%'"&-&�� (+""%#� @$)&7-� #2-� 7+4� @-#;--"� ',� +"&� ;)11� %"1=(%"#$)@'#-� #%� +� 2+$&-")"7� %9� 4%,)#)%",!� � �=� 2%4-� ),� #2+#� +4$-,'54#)%"�%9� 7%%&� 9+)#2I ,'(2� +,� #2+#�;2)(2� -"+@1-&� #2-��$--"/%%C8,�4$%(-,,� #%�@$)&7-� #2-�(%"91)(#)"7�4$%9-,,)%"+1�4-$,4-(#)6-,�%9&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +&6%(+#-,�� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� +&6%(+#-,� +"&� #2-(%'$#,I 5+=� 9+()1)#+#-� +#� 1-+,#� ,%5-� 5%6-5-"#� #%;+$&� @-##-$'"&-$,#+"&)"7� +"&�4$%#-(#)%"� %9� (2)1&$-"�@=� #2%,-�;2%� ,--C� #%� &%#2-)$�@-,#�)"�&-#-$5)")"7�%'#(%5-,�)"�#2-,-�4+)"9'1�(+,-,!

�)"+11=�� +1,%� )"� #2-� ,4)$)#� %9� #2-� �$--"� /%%C�� �� %99-$� +� #2%'72#-E4-$)5-"#� $-7+$&)"7� #;%� +1#-$"+#)6-� 9%$5,� %9� : (%11+@%$+#)%"< � #2+#(%'1&� (%'"#-$� #2-,-� &="+5)(,!� � �2-� �$--"� /%%C� �")#)+#)6-8,� "-;(%11+@%$+#)%"�@-#;--"�(%'$#,��(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�+7-"()-,�+"&�@+##-$-&;%5-"8,� +&6%(+#-,� 2+,� +1$-+&=� #$)77-$-&� +� $-D6),)%")"7� %9� #2-4+$+&)75� %9� 4'@1)(� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� +(#)%",!� � >2)1-� +,4-(#,� %9� 5=4$%4%,+1,� 9%$� #2-� 4$)6+#-� 1)#)7+#)%"� $-+15� +$-� $+&)(+1� +"&� $+),-4$+(#)(+1� ?'-,#)%",�� :%'#� %9� #2-� @%E< � #2)"C)"7� +@%'#� (%11+@%$+#)6-$-,4%",-,� ),� "--&-&� #%� +&&$-,,� #2-� 4+$+11-1� 4$%@1-5,� )"� 4$)6+#-1)#)7+#)%"�;2-"�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+"&�(2)1&�5+1#$-+#5-"#�%6-$1+4!

�! �����������

�� "���6

�,!��$--"0.�2+&�#;%�,%",��+44$%E)5+#-1=�,)E�+"&�-)72#�=-+$,�%1&��@=

#;%�&)99-$-"#�9+#2-$,!���2-�;+,�1)6)"7�;)#2�+�#2)$&�5+"��;2%�9+#2-$-&2-$�#2)$&�(2)1&�)"�#2-�(%'$,-�%9�#2-�1)#)7+#)%"!���2-�%1&-$�@%=8,�9+#2-$��$!�"&-$,��;+,�6-$=�+##+(2-&�#%�2),� ,%"�+"&�2+&�1%"7�9%'72#��@%#242=,)(+11=�+"&�6-$@+11=��;)#2��,!��$--"�%6-$�#2-�@%=!���2-�2),#%$=�%9&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� L5'(2� %9� )#� "%#� (%"(-$")"7� #2-� @%=M� ;+,� ,-6-$-�)"(1'&)"7�+�$+4-�+#�C")9-D4%)"#�)"��,!��$--"8,�2%5-�+9#-$�#2-�4+$#)-,;-$-�,-4+$+#-&�+"&�+"�+##-54#-&�,#$+"71)"7�;)#2�+�(1%#2-,1)"-!���2-(+,-�(+5-�#%�(%'$#�4'$,'+"#�#%��,!��$--"8,�5%#)%"�9%$�(%"#-54#�9%$6)%1+#)%",�%9�2-$�()6)1�4$%#-(#)%"�%$&-$�L:���<M��1+$7-1=�)"6%16)"7��$!"&-$,8�6-$@+1�#2$-+#,�#%�C)11�2-$!���(%54+")%"�5%#)%"�#%�5%&)9=�#2-

0.! �2-�4+$#)-,8�"+5-,�2+6-�@--"�(2+"7-&!

8

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

����;+,�4-"&)"7�)"�;2)(2��$!�"&-$,�;+,�$-?'-,#)"7�#2+#�(',#%&=�@-#$+",9-$$-&�#%�2)5!���2),�(+,-�;+,�2-+$&�@=�+�F'&7-�;)#2)"�+�&-&)(+#-&�%5-,#)(� �)%1-"(-� �%'$#� #2+#� (%",)&-$-&� )#,-19� 9+)$1=� ;-11D-&'(+#-&%"�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+"&�(%55)##-&�#%�4$%+(#)6-1=�+&&$-,,)"7�)#!���"#2-� (%'$,-�%9� #2-� (%"#-54#� 1)#)7+#)%"�� #2-� F'&7-� +&5)##-&� -E#-",)6-#-,#)5%"=� +@%'#� #2-� 2),#%$=� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�� +"&� )"&)(+#-&� +#6+$)%',�4%)"#,�#2+#�2-�@-1)-6-&�+�9+)$�4%$#)%"�%9�)#!

�2-�1)#)7+#)%"�;+,�4$%#$+(#-&�%6-$�+�,-$)-,�%9�5%"#2,�&'-�#%�+�2%#1=1)#)7+#-&� &'-� 4$%(-,,� ),,'-� (%"(-$")"7� #2-� )"6-,#)7+#)6-� 4$+(#)(-,� %9#2-�&-9-",-� (%'",-1!� �#� #2-� -"&�%9� #2-� 9)$,#� ,#+7-�%9� #2-� (%"#-54#1)#)7+#)%"��;)#2�#2-�"-E#�(%'$#�&+#-�4-"&)"7�)"�#;%�5%"#2,��#2-�(%'$##'$"-&�#%�#2-�?'-,#)%"�%9�)"#-$)5�(',#%&= 6),)#+#)%"!���-?'-,#)"7�"%6),)#+#)%"�;)#2� #2-� 9+#2-$���,!��$--"8,� (%'",-1� L5=,-19M� +$7'-&� #2+#+9#-$� $-#'$")"7� 9$%5� 6),)#,� ;)#2� 2),� 9+#2-$�� #2-� @%=� 2+&� -E4$-,,-&6)%1-"#�2%,#)1)#=�#%;+$&�;%5-"�)"(1'&)"7�2),�5%#2-$��;+,�)"(%$$)7)@1-+"&� )54%,,)@1-� #%� (%"#$%1�� -E4$-,,-&� +� &-,)$-� #%� &)-�� +"&� 4%'"&-&+"&� C)(C-&� ;+11,!� 9#-$� +� 5%"#2� ;)#2%'#� ,--)"7� 2),� 9+#2-$�� 2),@-2+6)%$�2+&�,-##1-&�&%;"!� ��2-�(%'$#�$-,4%"&-&�@=�,+=)"7�:>2-$-&%� =%'� 7-#� #2),� 9$%5J� � �2-��� ��J< � � )"� +� #%"-� %9� )"#-",-� &),7',#�5+C)"7� (1-+$� #2+#� 6),)#+#)%"� ;+,� 7%)"7� #%� @-� +;+$&-&!

0�� � >)#2)"

5)"'#-,�� #2-� 5%#2-$� &-()&-&� #%� #$+",9-$� (',#%&=� #%� #2-� 9+#2-$� +"&7+6-� '4� +11� (%"#+(#� ;)#2� 2-$� ,%"� 9%$� #2-� ,'55-$!� � �2-� ;+"#-&� #%4$%#-(#� 2-$� %;"� ,+9-#=A� +"&� 2-$� (%"#)"'-&� &-+1)"7,� ;)#2� @%#2� #2-(%'$#,�+"&�#2-�+@',-$�%6-$�#2-�@%=�;-$-�#$+'5+#)(�+"&�)"#%1-$+@1-�#%2-$!� ��1#)5+#-1=��,2-�7+6-�'4�(',#%&=�9%$�#2-�$-5+)"&-$�%9�#2-����L+"&�#%�#2-�@-,#�%9�5=�C"%;1-&7-��4-$5+"-"#1=M!

�� "���7

�2),� (+,-� (+5-� #%� (%'$#� )"� +44$%E)5+#-1=� �BB0�� @-9%$-� ,#$'(#'$+1$-9%$5,�;-$-�)",#)#'#-&�#%�)54$%6-�#2-�(%'$#8,�$-,4%",-�#%�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-��+"&�@-9%$-�#2-�F'&7-�L+"&�5%,#�%#2-$,�%"�#2),�@-"(2M�2+&,)7")9)(+"#� -E4-$)-"(-� %$� -&'(+#)%"� )"� #2+#� #%4)(!� � �2-� 2),#%$=� %96)%1-"(-� )"� #2),� $-1+#)%",2)4� )"(1'&-&� #2-� +@',-$�� �$!� /-",%"�(2%C)"7��4'"(2)"7�+"&�#2$-+#-")"7�#%�C)11��,!��'$"-$�+"&�#2-)$�@+@=�+,� ;-11� +,� 7$+@@)"7� #2-� @+@=� +"&� #2$-+#-")"7� #%� #2$%;� 2-$� %'#� #2-;)"&%;!��9#-$��,!��'$"-$�%@#+)"-&�+�4$%#-(#)%"�%$&-$�$-5%6)"7�2)5

0�! %#� +#=4)(+11=�� #2),� (%'$#� $-9',-&� #%� 2%1&� +"� -6)&-"#)+$=� 2-+$)"7� %"� #2-

: #-54%$+$=< �6),)#+#)%" (',#%&=�&-#-$5)"+#)%"!���+#2-$��)#�+&&$-,,-&�#2),�),,'-�,%1-1=#2$%'72�: (%11%?'=< �;)#2�(%'",-1!� ��2-�(%'$#8,�2%,#)1)#=� #%;+$&� #2-�5%#2-$8,� (1+)5,$-7+$&)"7� #2-� @%=� ;+,� )"� (%"#$+,#� ;)#2� )#,� %@F-(#)6)#=� +"&� @+,)(� $-,4-(#� 9%$� 2-$#-,#)5%"=�+@%'#�#2-�2),#%$=�%9�6)%1-"(-!���#�+1,%�(%"#$+,#-&�"%#)(-+@1=�;)#2�#2-�(%'$#8,,#$%"7�(%"(-$"�9%$�#2-�@%=�;2-"�#2-�+@',)"7�9+#2-$�+11-7-&�#2+#�#2-��� ��.�4+$#"-$;+,�42=,)(+11=�+@',)"7�#2-�@%=�@=�4'11)"7�2)5�@=�#2-�-+$�+"&�,4+"C)"7�2)5!

9

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

9$%5�#2-)$�,2+$-&�+4+$#5-"#��2-�@$%C-�)"�$-4-+#-&1=�%"-�")72#!��9#-$#2-� 4%1)(-� &)&� "%#2)"7�� %"� #2-� 9%'$#2� @$-+CD)"�� 2-� ,#+@@-&� �,!�'$"-$� ;)#2� ,(),,%$,� ;2)1-� #2-� (2)1&� ;+#(2-&� 9$%5� 2-$� ($)@!� L�,!�'$"-$8,�1)9-�;+,�,+6-&�@=�+�9$)-"&8,�)"#-$6-"#)%"!M��/%#2�@-9%$-�+"&+9#-$� #2),� )"()&-"#�� �$!� /-",%"� 5+&-� #2$-+#,� )"� 4-$,%"�� %"� #2-#-1-42%"-�+"&�)"�;$)#)"7��,'(2�+,�:;-8$-�+11�7%)"7�#%�&)-�< �+"&�: ��7)6-=%'� &-+&� @+@=!< � � 9#-$� #2-� ,#+@@)"7�� �,!� �'$"-$� 5%6-&� #%� 2-$9+#2-$8,� 2%5-� )"� #2-�"-E#� ,#+#-�� @'#��$!� /-",%"� (%"#)"'-&� #%� ,#+1C+"&�#2$-+#-"�2-$�+"&�#2-�#2-"�9%'$D=-+$D%1&�(2)1&�;)#2�&-+#2!��9#-$;-� %@#+)"-&� +� #-54%$+$=� 4$%#-(#)%"� %$&-$�� ,2-� ;)#2&$-;� #2-� ���4-#)#)%"�@-(+',-�,2-�(%'1&�"%#�+((-4#�+"=�+;+$&�%9�6),)#+#)%"�#%��$!/-",%"��;2)(2���2+&�#%�+&6),-�2-$�;+,�1)C-1=��@+,-&�%"�5=�-E4-$)-"(-;)#2� #2+#� (%'$#!� � L�$!�/-",%"�2+&�@--"�2%5-�;)#2� #2-� @+@=� 9%$� +#1-+,#�#2-�9)$,#�=-+$�%9�2-$�1)9-�;2)1-��,!��'$"-$�;%$C-&M!

�'@,-?'-"#1=���$!�/-",%"�9)1-&�9%$�(',#%&=�%$�6),)#+#)%"!��L�+$1=�%"�#2-� (',#%&=� $-?'-,#� ;+,� &$%44-&!M� � 9#-$� %"-� &+=� %9� #-,#)5%"=� )";2)(2�#2-�2),#%$=�%9�+@',-I )"(1'&)"7� #2-�,#+@@)"7I ;+,�+)$-&�� #2-(%'$#� %4-"-&� #2-� "-E#� 2-+$)"7�@=� 1%'&1=� 1-(#'$)"7� @%#2� 4+$#)-,� 9%$:5'&,1)"7)"7< �+"&�9%$�,'@F-(#)"7�#2-)$�&+'72#-$�#%�: #2-�4%1)(-< �+"&"%#� $-,%16)"7� #2-)$� &),4'#-� %'#� %9� (%'$#!� � �'@,-?'-"#1=�� #2-� (%'$#7$+"#-&��$!�/-",%"�#-54%$+$=�6),)#+#)%"�#;)(-�+�;--C�9%$�9%'$�2%'$,�'"&-$� ,'4-$6),)%"!� � �'$)"7� %"-� 6),)#� #2-� ,'4-$6),%$� ;)#"-,,-&� 2)54'##)"7�2),� #%"7'-� )"� #2-� 7)$18,�5%'#2!� ��-� $-9',-&� #%� ,#%4�� ,#+#)"7#2+#�,2-8,�2),�&+'72#-$�+"&�2-�(%'1&�&%�;2+#�2-�;+"#-&!���,!��'$"-$+1,%� -E4-$)-"(-&� 2-$� &+'72#-$� #)(C1)"7� 2-$� )"� 2-$� ($%#(2� +"&+##-54#)"7�#%�#%"7'-DC),,�2-$��;2)1-�,#+#)"7�#2+#��$!�/-",%"�&)&�#2+#;)#2� 2-$!� � �'$)"7� %#2-$� (%'$#D,'4-$6),-&� 6),)#,�� 2-� 2+&� #+"#$'5,+7+)",#� �,!� �'$"-$� +"&� %"� %"-� %((+,)%"� 1+=� &%;"� %"� #%4� %9� 2),&+'72#-$�#%�4$-6-"#��,!��'$"-$�9$%5�#+C)"7�2-$�2%5-!

�2-�#$)+1�1+,#-&�9%$�+44$%E)5+#-1=�-)72#�&+=,��+"&�)"(1'&-&�-E4-$##-,#)5%"=�6+1)&+#)"7��,!��'$"-$8,�(1+)5,�+"&�#2-�,-$)%',�&+"7-$�,2-+"&� 2-$� &+'72#-$� 9+(-&� 9$%5� �$!� /-",%"�� +,� ;-11� +,� #;%� (%'$#D+44%)"#-&�-6+1'+#)%",��@%#2�%9�;2)(2� -"#)$-1=� )7"%$-&� #2-�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-� 2),#%$=�� +"&� %"-� %9� ;2)(2� -6)&-"(-&� +� &),#)"(#� 1+(C� %9(%54$-2-",)%"� %9� #2-� &="+5)(,� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-!� � /%#2� (%'$#-6+1'+#%$,�,'77-,#-&�#2+#�@%#2�4+$#)-,�5',#�@-�1=)"7�,)"(-�#2-)$�,#%$)-,;-$-�,%�(%"#$+&)(#%$=!���6-"#'+11=��+9#-$�5%$-�#=4-&�#2$-+#,�+44-+$-&�)"(1'&)"7�%"-�,-"#�#%�#2-�F'&7-��#2-� F'&7-�+44%)"#-&�+�7'+$&)+"�+&1)#-5� L:��<M�� %$&-$-&� 5%$-� 4,=(2%1%7)(+1� -6+1'+#)%",� L)"(1'&)"7%"-� 9%$� ,-E'+1� +@',-� )"� ;2)(2� #2-� -6+1'+#%$� $-1)-&� %"� #2-� 9+#2-$8,(1+)5�#2+#�2-�2+&�+�"%$5+1�(2)1&2%%&�+"&�9%'"&�"%�,'44%$#�9%$�#2-,',4)()%"M��+"&�(%"#)"'-&�6),)#,�,'4-$6),-&�@=�#2-���!���2-�%'#,)&-4,=(2%1%7)(+1� -6+1'+#)%",�%"(-� +7+)"� )7"%$-&� #2-�&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-

10

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

+"&�)"&)(+#-&�+�1+(C�%9�(%54$-2-",)%"�%9�#2-�),,'-!���2-����9%'"&#2-�9+#2-$D(2)1&�@%"&�#%�@-�4%,)#)6-�L@+,-&�%"�#2-�(2)1&8,�#-+$,�;2-"2-$�9+#2-$�;%'1&�1-+6-M�+"&�#2-�9+#2-$8,�(%"&'(#�&'$)"7�#2-�6),)#,�,2-,'4-$6),-&�#%�@-�+44$%4$)+#-!� ��2-� 9%'"&�#2-�5%#2-$�L;2%,-�41+,#)(&-5-+"%$��)"+44$%4$)+#-�7)771)"7��+"&�$+()"7�,4--(2�;-$-�)"&)(+#)6-%9� 4%,#D#$+'5+#)(� ,#$-,,� &),%$&-$M� #%� @-� 2)721=� "%"D($-&)@1-!� � �""'5-$%',�%((+,)%",�� #2-� F'&7-�,#+#-&� #2+#�@%#2�4+$-"#,�;-$-� 9+)1)"7#2),�(2)1&�� #2$-+#-"-&�#%�4'#� #2-�(2)1&� )"� 9%,#-$�(+$-��+"&�-E4$-,,-&2),� 6)-;� #2+#� "-)#2-$� 4+$#=� ;+,� ($-&)@1-!� � �1#)5+#-1=�� +9#-$� 1-"7#2=&-1)@-$+#)%"�� #2-� (%'$#� %$&-$-&� 1)5)#-&� 6),)#+#)%"� (%"&)#)%"-&� %",-6-$+1� C)"&,� %9� (%'",-1)"7� +"&� ,'4-$6),)%"!� � �2-� 9+#2-$� "-6-$(%541)-&�;)#2�#2-,-�(%"&)#)%",��+"&�#2-�5%#2-$�$-#+)"-&�(',#%&=!

��! �����������N�������������������������������������

>2)1-�,)7")9)(+"#�4$%7$-,,�2+,�@--"�+(2)-6-&�)"�5+"=�,#+#-�(%'$#,(%"(-$")"7�@+,)(�'"&-$,#+"&)"7,�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-��)"(1'&)"7�#2-(%55)#5-"#� %9� $-,%'$(-,�� ($-+#)6-� -99%$#,� #%� +,,),#� 6)(#)5,�� +"&� +7-"')"-� ('1#'$-� (2+"7-��5+C)"7� #2-� &),5),,+1� %9� ,'(2� (1+)5,� ),� "%1%"7-$�+"�+((-4#+@1-�"%$5�

0�� #2-$-�2+,�@--"�+�,#$)C)"7� )",'1+#)%"�%9

(',#%&= 6),)#+#)%"� +&F'&)(+#)%",� 9$%5� #2),� "-;� :-"1)72#-"5-"#!<�-,4)#-�#2-�;)&-,4$-+&�+((-4#+"(-�%9�#2-�7$%;)"7�@%&=�%9�-6)&-"(-#2+#�+&'1#�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�),�&-#$)5-"#+1�#%�(2)1&$-"�

0��@%#2�(%'$#,

+"&� 1+;=-$,�(%55%"1=� ,-4+$+#-� #2-� ),,'-�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-� 9$%5(',#%&= 6),)#+#)%"�� +"&� -6-"� ,%5-#)5-,� -E(',-� )#� )"� +� &)6%$(-(%"#-E#!

0*���%$-�"%#+@1=��,=54+#2=�+"&�(%"(-$"�#%�+"�+&'1#�@+##-$)"7

0�� ����������"%#-����+"&�+((%54+"=)"7�#-E#!

0�! :�2)1&$-"�%9�@+##-$-&�;%5-"�2+6-�@--"�9%'"&�#%�@-�+#� )"($-+,-&�$),C�9%$�+@$%+&�$+"7-�%9�-5%#)%"+1�+"&�@-2+6)%$+1�&)99)('1#)-,�� )"(1'&)"7�,')()&+1� #-"&-"()-,�,'@,#+"(-� +@',-�� &-4$-,,)%"�� &-6-1%45-"#+1� &-1+=,�� -&'(+#)%"+1� +"&� +##-"#)%"4$%@1-5,��+"&�)"6%16-5-"#�)"�6)%1-"(-!< �/������G���������������"%#-�����+#�B!�'$#2-$5%$-�� (2)1&$-"�-E4%,-&� #%�@+##-$-$,� +$-� #2-5,-16-,� +#� 2)72� $),C� #%� @-(%5-&)$-(#� #+$7-#,� %9� 42=,)(+1� +@',-� +"&� %9� ,-E'+1� +@',-!� ��2-� &+"7-$� -6-"� -E#-"&,� #%2%5)()&-�� %"-� 5'1#)=-+$� ,#'&=� 9%'"&� #2+#� )"� +44$%E)5+#-1=� %"-D9)9#2� %9� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-�2%5)()&-,�+"&�+##-54#-&�2%5)()&-,��+�(2)1&�%9�#2-�@+##-$-&�;%5+"�),�+1,%C)11-&�)"�#2-�4$%(-,,!< ���!� ����������$--"�/%%C�� �����"%#-�����+#�B�L"%#)"7� #2+#���D��Q� %9� @+##-$-&� 5%#2-$,8� (2)1&$-"� +$-� +1,%� 5+1#$-+#-&M!� � /-#,=� �(1),#-$� �$%6-,-1%?'-"#1=�&%('5-"#,�#2-�4$%9%'"&�)54+(#�-6-"�6)%1-"(-�;2)(2�(%'$#,�5)72#�6)-;�+,:5)"%$�< � )!-!�� )"� ;2)(2� "%� )"F'$)-,� ;-$-� $-(-)6-&�� (+"� 2+6-� %"� (2)1&$-"!� � �$%6-,������"%#-�B��+#��.D�0�L&-,($)@)"7�+"�'44-$�5)&&1-�(1+,,� 9+5)1=� )"�;2)(2� #2-� 9+#2-$%"(-�2-1&�+�C")9-�#%�#2-�5%#2-$8,�#2$%+#M!

0*� ���� ������ �+$#� �!/A� �+$-"� �3+4+",C)=�� ��� ��� !�������,� �� (�����,� ���� �����������%����#� ����� ����� � ����� �������������� ��� ��"��� �� 0�� ��!��!P!� 0.��0��D�*� L�BB�M� L-E41+)")"7� #2+#� :5%,#� %9� #2-� ,#'&)-,� %9� 7-"&-$� @)+,� )"� #2-� (%'$#,$-4%$#�#2+#�F'&7-,�$%'#)"-1=�)7"%$-�#2-�),,'-�%$�&),5),,�+,�)",'@,#+"#)+1�#2-�)54+(#�%94+$-"#+1�6)%1-"(-�%"�(2)1&$-"�)"�#2-�2%',-2%1&< M!���2-�$),C,�#%�(2)1&$-"�;2-"�)"�#2-(+$-�%9�+�@+##-$-$��-6-"�+9#-$�#2-�+&'1#�4+$#)-,�+$-�,-4+$+#-&��+$-�&),(',,-&��������+$#���!�!0!

11

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��* ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

6)(#)5� (+"� @-� #$+",9%$5-&� )"#%� +"� +##)#'&-� %9� &),&+)"� +"&� %'#$)72#2%,#)1)#=�;2-"�#2-�@+##-$-&�;%5+"�,--C,� #%� 1)5)#� #2-�+@',-$8,�+((-,,#%�2),� (2)1&!

0B� ��2),�&),F'"(#)%"� (+"�-6-"�%(('$�;)#2)"�+� ,)"71-� (+,-�

2-+$&�@=�+�,)"71-�F'&7-��+,��+,-���+@%6-�&-5%",#$+#-,!��"&��+,��+,-��+1,%� ,'77-,#,�� #2),� F'&)()+1� +##)#'&-� +11� #%%� %9#-"� )"'$-,� #%� #2-4$%9%'"&�&-#$)5-"#�%9�#2-�(2)1&$-"�)"6%16-&!

��

�� "��������"��� .������ ���������� ��� ���!�������

�9�;-�(%",)&-$�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�4$%(--&)"7,�;2)(2�+$-��� �9%(',-&%"�(2)1&$-"��-!7!��4$%#-(#)%"�%$&-$�(+,-,��)#� ),�9+)$�#%�,+=�#2+#�+�@+##1-2+,�@--"�9%'72#�+"&�+#�1-+,#�4+$#)+11=�;%"��$-7+$&)"7�#2-�,-$)%',"-,,;)#2� ;2)(2� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ),� #+C-"� @=� #2-� (%'$#,!� � /+(C� )"� #2-�B*�,�� @-9%$-� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ;+,� ;)&-1=� $-(%7")3-&� +"&'"&-$,#%%&�� ;%5-"� ;-$-� %9#-"� 2%'"&-&� %'#� %9� (%'$#� +"&� %6-$#1=&),&+)"-&� 9%$� (1+)5)"7� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�� -6-"� )"� 4$%#-(#)%"� %$&-$(+,-,!� � �#� ;+,� 4%,,)@1-� #2-"� #%� 2-+$� F'&7-,� ,+=)"7� #2)"7,� #2+#� %"-;%'1&�@-� 9+$� 1-,,� 1)C-1=� #%�2-+$� #%&+=� ��� ��� ����������!� ��2',��%"-�+$=1+"&�;%5+"�;2%� ,%'72#� +�4$%#-(#)%"�%$&-$� $-(+11-&� #2-� F'&7-,+=)"7�

��&%"8#�@-1)-6-�+"=#2)"7�#2+#�=%'8$-�,+=)"7!�!�!�!���2-�$-+,%"���&%"8#@-1)-6-� )#� ),� @-(+',-� �� &%"8#� @-1)-6-� #2+#� +"=#2)"7� 1)C-� #2),� (%'1&2+44-"�#%�5-!���9���;+,�=%'�+"&�,%5-%"-�2+&�#2$-+#-"-&�5-�;)#2�+7'"��#2-$-�),�"%�;+=�#2+#���;%'1&�(%"#)"'-�#%�,#+=�;)#2�#2-5!���2-$-),� "%� ;+=� #2+#� �� (%'1&� #+C-� #2+#� C)"&� %9� +@',-� 9$%5� #2-5!�2-$-9%$-��,)"(-���;%'1&�"%#�1-#�#2+#�2+44-"�#%�5-����(+"8#�@-1)-6-#2+#�)#�2+44-"-&�#%�=%'!

��

0B� ����������+$#��!A���������������+$#���!/!

��! �2+#� (2)1&� -,,-"#)+11=� 1%,#� 2),�5%#2-$� @-(+',-� #2-� (%'$#� ;+,� "%#� ;)11)"7� #%4$)%$)#)3-� 2-$� ,+9-#=� +"&� 4$%#-(#)%"� 9$%5� #$+'5+� %6-$� #2-� 9+#2-$8,� : $)72#,< � #%� 2),(2)1&!��>2)1-�#2-�@%=�;+,�'"?'-,#)%"+@1=�+##+(2-&�#%�2),�9+#2-$��2),�@-2+6)%$�(1-+$1=)"&)(+#-&�2%;�&-,#$'(#)6-�-5%#)%"+11=�2),� 9+#2-$�;+,�9%$�2)5!���-7+$&)"7�(2)1&$-"8,42=,)(+1� +"&�4,=(2%1%7)(+1� $),C,� 9$%5�@+##-$-$,�� ,--� �������+$#� ���!�!� L&),(',,)"7� #2-9'#'$-� -99-(#,� 4+,#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� (+"� 2+6-� %"� +� (2)1&8,� -5%#)%"+1� ;-11D@-)"7M!%#� %"1=� +$-� #2-� $),C,� %9� 42=,)(+1� +"&� ,-E'+1� +@',-� -1-6+#-&� ;2-$-� +� 9+#2-$� ),� +@+##-$-$�� @'#� #2-� -5%#)%"+1� 5+")4'1+#)%"� +"&� +@',-� #2+#� 5+"=� @+##-$)"7� 9+#2-$,)"91)(#�%"�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"��+,�)"��+,-����%9#-"�4%,-�+"�%"7%)"7�+"&�,)7")9)(+"#�#2$-+#�#%(2)1&$-"8,�-5%#)%"+1�;-11D@-)"7!�����

��� �����3+4+",C)=�������"%#-�0*��+#�0�0�L()#)"7�6)(#)58,� #-,#)5%"=�(%"#+)"-&� )"������/�������������������������������������������� ���������������

������/��� �������������0D��L�B*BMM!� � �"�%"-�2)721=�4'@1)()3-&�(+,-� )"� #2-�5)&D�B*�,��#2-�F'&7-�#%1&�%"-�+11-7-&�+@',-$�: H)9K�=%'�;+"#�#%�7"+;�%"�2-$�+"&�,2-�%"=%'�� 9)"-�� @'#� 1-#8,� "%#� &%� )#� +#� #2-� #+E4+=-$,8� -E4-",-A< � #2),� &-9-"&+"#� 1+#-$5'$&-$-&�2),�;)9-!�������-)-$���� �����5� ����������"%#-�0���+#��*!�� �#� ),�"%#�2+$&�#%9)"&�+�1)#+"=�%9�4+,#�-E+541-,�%9�+@',)6-�F'&)()+1�$-+(#)%",�#%�@+##-$-&�;%5-"�,--C)"74$%#-(#)%"� )"� #2-� (%'$#,�� � ���� ���������� � ����� �O�� ����� ���8��� /�� ����/�������G���>���������������L0���M�L-542+,)3)"7�#2+#�#2-�1+;�)#,-19�: (%"#$)@'#-,#%� #2-� +@',-� +@',-&� ;%5-"� '"&-$7%< � +"&� &-,($)@)"7� 6+$)%',� (+,-,� %9� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-M!

12

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ��B

�)5)1+$1=�� )"� �+,-� 0�� 1)#)7+#-&� +@%'#� #-"� =-+$,� +7%�� +9#-$� +� &+=� %9#-,#)5%"=�+@%'#� #2-�2),#%$=�%9� +@',-�� #2-� F'&7-�%4-"-&� #2-� ,-(%"&&+=� %9� 4$%(--&)"7,� @=� =-11)"7� +#� #2-� 4+$#)-,� L+"&� 5=,-19M� +@%'#:5'&,1)"7)"7!< ���'@,-?'-"#1=��#2-�F'&7-�,--5-&�)"(1)"-&�#%�#$-+#�+11%9��,!��'$"-$8,�+11-7+#)%",�%9�6)%1-"(-�+,�9+@$)(+#)%",!

�0���)5)1+$1=��#2-

9%$-",)(� 4,=(2)+#$),#� 9%'"&� �,!� �'$"-$8,� : ,#%$)-,< � %9� �$!� /-",%"8,+@',-� :4'99-&�'4�< � : -E+77-$+#-&< �+"&� :@)3+$$-!< � � �"�4+$#)('1+$�� 2-(2+$+(#-$)3-&�2-$� ,#+#-5-"#,� #2+#� #2-� +@',-�2+&� (+',-&�2-$� #%� 1%,-2-$� F%@�L#2$%'72�+@,-"#--),5�+"&�+((',+#)%",��$!�/-",%"�5+&-� #%2-$�-541%=-$M�+"&�9%$(-&�2-$�#%�7%� 1)6-� )"�+� ,2-1#-$��+,�"%#�5+C)"7,-",-!

��� �L�-�+1,%� 9%'"&��$!�/-",%"�-6-"�5%$-�'"@-1)-6+@1-!M� ��2-

,%()+1� ;%$C-$�� +1#2%'72� 2-� -E4-$)-"(-&� �$!� /-",%"8,� @-11)7-$-"(-+"&�(%-$()%"��+"&�-E4$-,,-&�(%"(-$"�L)"�4$)6+#-M�+@%'#��$!�/-",%"8,&+"7-$%',"-,,�� ,#-+&9+,#1=� )",),#-&�%"� 4$-,-"#)"7� 2)5� +,� $-+,%"+@1-+"&�&-(-"#�)"�2),�,#+#-5-"#,�#%�#2-�(%'$#!

�.

>-�C"%;�"%;�#2+#�#2-�#=4-�%9�6)%1-"(-�+11-7-&�)"�@%#2��+,-�0�+"&#2-��+$=1+"&�(+,-�F',#�&),(',,-&�),�+11�#%%�41+',)@1-��+"&�#2+#�)#�41+=,%'#� )"� 5+"=� $-1+#)%",2)4,!� � "&� )"� #2-� 4+,#� #;-"#=� =-+$,�� )"� 5+"=F'$),&)(#)%",�� #2-� 1)#)7+#)%"� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� 2+,� @--"� 7$-+#1=#$+",9%$5-&�9$%5�;2+#�5)72#�9+)$1=�@-�(+11-&�#2-�:&+$C�+7-,< �#%�;2+#5)72#� @-� (+11-&� +"� : +7-� %9� 4+$#)+1� -"1)72#-"5-"#�< � ;2-$-� F'&7-,5%$-�%9#-"�$-,4-(#�;%5-"8,�$)72#�#%�,--C�4$%#-(#)%"�+"&�9$-?'-"#1=($-&)#� #2-)$� +11-7+#)%",!� � �+"=� (%'$#,� 2+6-� )",#)#'#-&� &-&)(+#-&&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� &%(C-#,� %$� (%'$#,�� +"&� )"� +� 7$%;)"7� "'5@-$� %9F'$),&)(#)%",�)#� ),�"%�1%"7-$�+((-4#+@1-�(%"6-"#)%"+1�4$+(#)(-��� � ��� ��� ��� �� ���� ������ ��� ��������� ����� #%� #$-+#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-+11-7+#)%",� +,� )541+',)@1-� %$� #$)6)+1!

��� � �#� ),� "%;� +#� 1-+,#� ,%5-;2+#

�0� ���� ����� �+$#� �!/!� � �2-� F'&7-� 5+=� 2+6-� @--"� )"91'-"(-&� @=� �,!� �'$"-$8,

4$-6)%',�+6%)&+"(-�%9�#2-�(%'$#�4$%(--&)"7,��+"&�2),�@-1)-9� #2+#�,2-�2+&�1)-&�+@%'#$-(-)6)"7�"%#)(-!��1#)5+#-1=��;2)1-� #2-�(%'$#�&)&�"%#� )"� )#,�%4)")%"� $-F-(#� +11�%9� #2-+@',-�+11-7+#)%",��+"&�&)&�9+,2)%"�+�2)721=�4$%#-(#)6-�6),)#+#)%"�%$&-$��-6-"�=-+$,�1+#-$#2-�F'&7-�,#)11�-E4$-,,-&�&%'@#�#%�#2),�+'#2%$�+,�#%�#2-�#$'#2!

��� �����-4%$#��)1#%"��"7-1��)"��!�!�0�0BDB0&�������L '"-�0����BB�ML%"�9)1-�;)#2+'#2%$M!� ��,!��'$"-$� 1%,#�2-$� F%@�@-(+',-��$!�/-",%"8,� +@',-�(+',-&�2-$� #%�+$$)6-1+#-�+"&�5),,�;%$C�$-4-+#-&1=!���,!��'$"-$8,�(1+)5�#2+#�,2-�2+&�#%�7%�#%�+�,2-1#-$�;+,+44+$-"#1=� )"(%54$-2-",)@1-� #%� #2-� -6+1'+#%$� @-(+',-� �,!� �'$"-$8,� 9+#2-$,'44%,-&1=�2+&�+�6-$=�")(-�2%',-�)"�;2)(2�,2-�2+&�,#+=-&�;)#2�2-$�&+'72#-$!� ��2-9+(#� #2+#� ,2-�;+,� @-)"7� ,#+1C-&� +#� #2+#� 1%(+#)%"� +44+$-"#1=� &)&� "%#� -"#-$� )"� #%� #2-9%$-",)(�4,=(2)+#$),#8,�+,,-,,5-"#!�����

�.� ���������������-4%$#�@=��+"��--"-=��)"��!�!�0�0BDB0(���L�+=�0*���BB�M�L%"�9)1-;)#2�+'#2%$M�L(2%%,)"7�"%#�#%� )"#-$6)-;�4+$#)-,�+@%'#�+@',-�@-(+',-�#2-=�: &),+7$--+@%'#� -6-$=#2)"7< M!� � �"� $-#$%,4-(#�� )#� ,--5,� 1)C-1=� #2+#� #2-� ,%()+1� ;%$C-$� ;+,)"#)5)&+#-&� @=� �$!� /-",%"�� ;2%� ;+,� 6-$=� 1+$7-� +"&� )54%,)"7�� %9#-"� +"7$=� +"&=-11)"7��+"&�(%'1&�@-�?')#-�5-"+()"7!

��� ���� ���������� �-@%$+2� �4,#-)"�� &���� ���� �� ����� ���� ��� ��� ��� !�������� "��#1� ��)���� ��1�������%����� ��,�5����,����� ��"��� ��� ����������� !�!�G����������L�BBBM!

13

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

,2%(C)"7� 9%$� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� 6)(#)5,� +"&� #2-)$� 1+;=-$,� #%� @-&),5),,-&�%'#�%9�2+"&�)"�($)5)"+1�+"&�()6)1�(+,-,�;2-$-�#2-�6)%1-"(-)#,-19�),�#2-�(-"#$+1�(%"(-$"!

��

�(+,-�)"�4%)"#�),�#2-��),#$)(#�%9��%1'5@)+8,�"-;��%5-,#)(��)%1-"(-�%'$#�� ;2)(2� 2+,� @--"� #%'#-&� +,� +� :5%&-1� (%'$#< � 9%$� )#,� 4$%+(#)6-+44$%+(2�+"&�)54$%6-&�+((-,,)@)1)#=��-99)()-"(=�+"&�$-,4%",)6-"-,,�#%&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� (1+)5,!

��� � ,� +� 1)#)7+#%$� )"� #2-� �!�!� (%'$#,� @%#2

@-9%$-�+"&�,)"(-�#2-��%5-,#)(��)%1-"(-��%'$#�;+,�)",#)#'#-&����;%'1&+7$--� #2+#� #2-� "-;� (%'$#� 2+,� )54$%6-&� #2-� 2+"&1)"7� %9� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-� (+,-,� )"� ,%5-� $-,4-(#,�

�*� +"&� #2+#� #2-� ),,'-� 2+,� $),-"� #%� +

��� ���� /-#,=� �,+)�� *�� *����� *������ ��������$��� ��� ��� !�������� "��� #

���������� �������&���� ���������� ������*���������!����!��0*����0B��L0���M�L"%#)"7#2+#�: #2-�1-7+1�,=,#-5�2+,�5+&-�7$-+#�,#$)&-,�)"�)#,�#$-+#5-"#�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-< M!�� � �����-@%$+2��!�>-),,5+"��������2�����!�������� �� 5�������� �������� �� ����� /*�*�����-� ������ ���� �� *����� �����< � .0� /!�!� �!� ���!� ��*��� ��0�� L0���M� L"%#)"7� #2+#: )"($-+,-&� +##-"#)%"� #%� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� 2+,� $-,'1#-&� )"� '"9%'"&-&� +,,'54#)%",+@%'#�4$%7$-,,� )"� #2-� (%'$#,< M!� ��2-� 9)"&)"7,� %9� +5-,��#+(-C8,� 1+"&5+$C� ,#'&=� %9#;%�/%,#%"�(%'$#,8� $-,4%",-,� #%�@+##-$-&�;%5-"� )"�4$%#-(#)%"�%$&-$� (+,-,� ,'44%$##2-�;)&-1=�2-1&�6)-;�#2+#�#2-�(%'$#,8�#$-+#5-"#�%9�@+##-$-&�;%5-"�2+,�)54$%6-&!����� ���� ������� /������� >���� �� ���� ����������� ���� ��>��� ��� ������

��������� ���� L�BBBM!� � �"� 2),� ,'$6-=� �#+(-C� 9%'"&� #2+#� :5%,#� F'&7-,� 4$-,-"#-&� +,'44%$#)6-�&-5-+"%$< �#%�#2-�@+##-$-&�;%5-"�#2+#�+44-+$-&�@-9%$-�#2-5!������+#��������!� � �"�9+(#�� #2-� ,#'&=� 9%'"&�#2+#�-)72#�%'#�%9�-)72#--"� F'&7-,�4$-,-"#-&�+�: 7%%&D"+#'$-&< � &-5-+"%$� #%;+$&� #2-� ;%5-"�� +"&� ����� ���� 8����� ��� ���� �� /����9������������:��;0� ������ �� ������ ������� ���� � L�;%� 5%$-� 4$-,-"#-&� +� : 7%%&D"+#'$-&< � @'#� : (%"&-,(-"&)"7< � &-5-+"%$� #%� #2-� ;%5-"A� ,)E� 4$-,-"#-&� +:@'$-+'($+#)(< �L)!-!��)54-$,%"+1M�&-5-+"%$!M��������-6-"�F'&7-,�;-$-�,--"�+,�: 9)$5<#%;+$&�#2-�5-"��,)E�+,�: @'$-+'($+#)(�< �+"&�%"1=�#2$--�+,�: 7%%&D"+#'$-&< �#%;+$&�#2-5-"!� ����� � �"#-$6)-;,�;)#2�-)72#�%9� #2-�F'&7-,�(%"9)$5-&�#2+#�5+"=�%9�#2-,-�,--C�#%5+C-� @+##-$-&� ;%5-"� ;-1(%5-� +"&� (%59%$#+@1-� )"� #2-� (%'$#�� +"&� #%� #+C-� #2-6)%1-"(-� +11-7+#)%",� ,-$)%',1=!� � ���� +#� ���D��!� � �2-,-� 9)"&)"7,� +$-� ?')#-� +,#%"),2)"7;2-"� 41+(-&� "-E#� #%� #2-� $-(-"#� 9)"&)"7,� %9� +� ,'$6-=� @=� #2-� >-11-,1-=� �-"#-$,� 9%$>%5-"� ;2)(2� &%('5-"#,� $-4-+#-&� )",#+"(-,� %9� /%,#%"� F'&7-,� &-5-+")"7� +"&)",'1#)"7�@+##-$-&�5%#2-$,�@-9%$-� #2-5�)"� �� ������ ��!� �����>�������������!� ���

>����/��������������8������������� �����/��������������� �������������� ������� ������� �� ��������� �������� �� ������ �������� �� ���

������������ ������ ������� L0��0M� H2-$-)"+9#-$� >��������� /���� ������K����������� � �2##4� ;;;!;(;%"1)"-!%$7 ;$" @+##-$-&!2#51!� � �-#� #2-$-�+$-�2)"#,� %9� +,)5)1+$�5-"#+1�@)9'$(+#)%"�@-#;--"�(',#%&=�+"&�:4'$-< �&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�(+,-,�-6-"+5%"7� #2-� : ,'44%$#)6-< � F'&7-,� )"#-$6)-;-&� @=� �#+(-C!� � ���� �#+(-C�� ����� +#� �0.L%@,-$6)"7� #2+#� %"-� ,'44%$#)6-� F'&7-� +1,%� -E4$-,,-&� )"� 2),� )"#-$6)-;� ,=54+#2=� 9%$@+##-$-$8,� 6),)#+#)%"�$)72#,��;2)(2��+((%$&)"7� #%��#+(-C�� : ,--5-&�#%� (%"91)(#�;)#2�2),)")#)+1�$-5+$C,�+@%'#�#2-�,-$)%',"-,,�%9�#2-�6)%1-"(-< M!

��� �����������4,#-)"�������"%#-��*��+#����0*��..�L;$)#)"7�#2+#�: #2-�(%55'")#=�2+,+1$-+&=�;)#"-,,-&�,'@,#+"#)+1�&)99-$-"(-,�)"�F'&)()+1�#$-+#5-"#�%9�#2-,-�(+,-,< M!

�*! �2-� "-;� (%'$#�5+=� +1,%� 2+6-�5+&-� )#� 2+$&-$� 9%$� 6)(#)5,� )"� ,%5-� $-,4-(#,!�%$�)",#+"(-��#2-$-�),�"%;�7$-+#-$�)"6%61-5-"#�%9�#2-�&-9-",-�@+$�)"�#2-,-�(+,-,��+"&#2-� (%'$#� ),� -E#$-5-1=� ,-",)#)6-� #%� #2+#� @+$8,� (1+)5,� #2+#� #2-� (%'$#� ),� @)+,-&� #%;+$&9-5+1-,!�������%@)",%"�6!��")#-&��#+#-,����B�!0&��.��L�!�!�44!�0���M�L$-F-(#)"7�+"-?'+1� 4$%#-(#)%"� (2+11-"7-� #%� #2-��%5-,#)(� �)%1-"(-��")#M!� ��+"=� F'&7-,�5+C-� +4%)"#�%9�-542+,)3)"7��+,�%"-�&)&�+#�+�@-"(2 @+$�5--#)"7�� #2+#�:;%5-"�+$-�6)%1-"##%%!< � ��-"�"%;� +((%'"#� 9%$� +44$%E)5+#-1=� ��D0�Q�%9� #2-� 9)1)"7,� 9%$� ���,� )"� #2),(%'$#� L)"(1'&)"7�($%,,D4-#)#)%",�;2-$-�;%5-"�2+6-�+1,%� 9)1-&MA� ,%5-�4-$(-"#+7-�%9#2-,-� +$-� 7$+"#-&!� � �-1-42%"-� �"#-$6)-;� ;)#2� �+'1� �%&&=�� �2)-9� �1-$C� %9� #2-�%5-,#)(��)%1-"(-��")#���!�!��'4-$)%$��%'$#�L4$!�����0���M!

14

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

5'(2� 2)72-$� 1-6-1� %9� )54%$#+"(-� +"&� ),� "%;� #+C-"� ,-$)%',1=� 5%$-%9#-"�#2+"�"%#!��/'#�)#�),�#2-,-�6-$=�)54$%6-5-"#,�)"�#2-�2+"&1)"7�%9&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�(+,-,� #2+#�2+6-�5+&-�#2-� 1+(C�%9� ,'(2�$-,4-(#� 9%$@+##-$)"7�(1+)5,�)"�(',#%&= 6),)#+#)%"�(+,-,�;)#2)"� #2-�,+5-�(%'$#� ,%,#$)C)"7!

�� ���� ���� ��/-���&���� ����� 0#�"� ��������!�� � ��� � ������ ���

�2',�� )"� �+,-� �� +@%6-�� ;2)(2� ;+,� 1)#)7+#-&� ;)#2)"� #2-� �%5-,#)(�)%1-"(-� �%'$#�� #2-� F'&7-8,� 6-$=� &-5-+"%$� ,;)#(2-&� 9$%5� @-)"7%@F-(#)6-� +"&� @+,)(+11=� $-,4-(#9'1� $-7+$&)"7� #2-� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-+11-7+#)%",� L;2)(2� ;-$-� $-1+#-&� #%� #2-� (1+)5� %9� (%"#-54#� %9� #2-4$%#-(#)%"� %$&-$M�� #%� 2%,#)1-� +"&� &-5-+")"7� ;2-"� #2-� ,'@F-(#� %9(2)1&� 6),)#+#)%"� ;+,� +&&$-,,-&� L+,� 4+$#� %9� #2-� +@',-$8,� 5%#)%"� #%5%&)9=� #2-� ���M!� � �"� $-,4%",-� #%� 5=� +$7'5-"#� #2+#� #2-� @+##-$-$,2%'1&� "%#� $-(-)6-� 6),)#+#)%"� 4-"&)"7� #2-� "-E#� (%'$#� &+#-� )"� #;%5%"#2,��#2-�F'&7-�,"+$1)"71=�&),5),,-&�5=�&-,($)4#)%"�%9�#2-�(2)1&8,&-,#$'(#)6-� @-2+6)%$,� @-(+',-� )#� (+5-� 9$%5� : �� �� ��< � L;2%� ;+,,#+"&)"7�$)72#�"-E#�#%�5-M!

�B���2-�F'&7-8,�2%,#)1)#=�#%;+$&�#2-�+@',-&

5%#2-$8,� (1+)5� %9� $),C� #%� #2-� (2)1&� ;+,� )"� 5+$C-&� (%"#$+,#� #%� 2),$-(-4#)6)#=�#%�#2-������.�(1+)5�#2+#� #2-�5%#2-$8,�"-;�@%=9$)-"&�;+,+@',)"7� #2-� (2)1&!� � �"� 9+(#�� #2-� (%'$#� %$&-$-&� +� (2)1&� +@',-)"6-,#)7+#)%"�%9�#2-��� ���+"&�2-$�@%=9$)-"&��@'#�"%#�#2-�@+##-$-$!���#),�)54%$#+"#�#%�@-+$�)"�5)"&�#2+#�#2),�F'&7-��+1#2%'72�C"%;"�#%�2+6-?')#-� +� #-54-$�� ;+,� 7-"-$+11=� (%",)&-$-&� 9+)$1=� -"1)72#-"-&� %"&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-!� � �%$-%6-$�� 2-� 2+,� ,)"(-� @--"� -1-6+#-&� #%� +,)7")9)(+"#�+&5)"),#$+#)6-�4%,)#)%"��;+,�4$-6)%',1=�($-&)#-&�+,�%"-�%9#2-�5%$-�-99-(#)6-� F'&7-,� )"� #2-��%5-,#)(� �)%1-"(-��%'$#�� +"&�2+,7-"-$+11=� -E4$-,,-&� +� 9+)$� &-7$--� %9� %4-""-,,� #%� #2-� (%"(-$",� %9&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+&6%(+#-,!

��2+6-�2+&�,)5)1+$��+1@-)#�1-,,�)"#-",-��-E4-$)-"(-,�-1,-;2-$-�)"�#2-�!�!��%5-,#)(��)%1-"(-��")#�;)#2�+�6+$)-#=�%9�F'&7-,��#=4)(+11=�)"�(+,-,;2-$-�(1)-"#,�,%'72#�(',#%&=�%$�6),)#+#)%"�+,�+�#-$5�%9�+����!���6-"�)"#2-� (%"#-E#� %9� #2-,-� (+,-,�� @$%'72#� ,4-()9)(+11=� #%� ,--C� 4$%#-(#)%"9$%5� 6)%1-"(-�� 5+"=� �!�!� F'&7-,�� )"(1'&)"7� #2%,-� )"� #2-� �%5-,#)(�)%1-"(-��")#�� (%",()%',1=� ,#$)6-� #%� #$-+#� (',#%&=�%$� 6),)#+#)%"� ),,'-,)"&-4-"&-"#1=� 9$%5� #2-�+@',-�� +"&� #%� (+@)"�%99� #2-)$�C"%;1-&7-�%9#2-�+@',-�9$%5�#2-)$�&-#-$5)"+#)%"�%9�(',#%&=�%$�6),)#+#)%"!

.�

�B� ���� ����� �+$#� �!� L"%#)"7� #2-� )54+(#� %9� #2),� (%55-"#� +"&� #2-� 2%,#)1-

&="+5)(�%9�#2-�(%'$#�4$%(--&)"7,�%"�#2-�5%#2-$8,�&-(),)%"�#%�7)6-�'4�(',#%&=M!

.�� �����#+(-C�� �����"%#-����� +#��0.� L"%#)"7� #2-� F'&7-8,�(%D-E),#)"7�+##)#'&-,�%99)$5"-,,�+7+)",#�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�@'#�,=54+#2=�#%;+$&�6),)#+#)%"�$-?'-,#,M!

15

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��0 ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

�2),� ,-",-� #2+#� 5+"=� 9+5)1=� F'&7-,� ,--5� #%� $-#+)"� +� 5-"#+1:@)9'$(+#)%"< � @-#;--"� : (',#%&= 6),)#+#)%"< � 5+##-$,� +"&� :&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-< �5+##-$,�;+,�($=,#+11)3-&�&'$)"7�41+"")"7�&),(',,)%",�)"�0��09%$�#2-�"-;��+5)1=��%'$#�)"�#2-��),#$)(#�%9��%1'5@)+!��>2)1-�#2-�"-;(%'$#� &%-,� "%#� -"(%54+,,� #2-� -E),#)"7� �%5-,#)(� �)%1-"(-� �")#�;2-$-� 4$%#-(#)%"� %$&-$,� +"&� ($)5)"+1� (+,-,� +$-� 2+"&1-&�� )#+&F'&)(+#-,� +11� %#2-$� 9+5)1=� 1+;� (+,-,!� �>2-"� #2-� ?'-,#)%"� +$%,-� %92%;�&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�;%'1&�@-�2+"&1-&� )"� #2-�"-;� �+5)1=��%'$#�@%#2� #2-� F'&7-,� +"&� +##%$"-=,� )"6%16-&� )"� #2-� 41+"")"7� ,#+#-&� #2+##2),� (%'$#� ;%'1&� "%#� @-� 2+"&1)"7� :&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� (+,-,�< � +,#2%'72�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�),�"%#�+"�),,'-�)"�&)6%$(-�+"&�(',#%&=�(+,-,!

�%'$#,8�&),(%'"#)"7�%9�@+##-$-&�;%5-"8,�(1+)5,�#2+#�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"+$-�+#�$),C�9$%5�#2-�@+##-$-$� ),�+(#'+11=�-E#$+%$&)"+$)1=�(%55%"�+"&%9� 1+#-� 2+,� $-(-)6-&� )"($-+,)"7� 4'@1)(� +##-"#)%"!� � �%$� )",#+"(-�� #2->-11-,1-=� /+##-$-&� �%#2-$,8� �-,#)5%"=� �$%F-(#� 9%'"&�� @+,-&� %")"#-$6)-;,� %9� 9%$#=� +@',-&� ;%5-"� +"&� #2)$#=D%"-� 6)(#)5� +&6%(+#-,+($%,,��+,,+(2',-##,�� #2+#� #2-,-�5%#2-$,�;-$-� (%55%"1=� #$-+#-&� +,:2=,#-$)(+1� +"&� '"$-+,%"+@1-�< � ;)#2� : ,(%$"�� (%"&-,(-",)%"� +"&&),$-,4-(#�< � +"&� ;-$-� 4$-6-"#-&� 9$%5� @-)"7� 2-+$&� )"� (%'$#!

.�

((%$&)"7� #%� )"#-$6)-;--,�� 9)9#--"� %9� #2-� 9%$#=� 2+&� F%)"#� %$� ,%1-(',#%&=�+;+$&-&�#%�#2-)$�+@',)6-�-ED4+$#"-$��-+(2�%9�;2%5�2+&�+1,%+@',-&� #2-� (2)1&$-"!� � �2)$#=D-)72#� ,+)&� #2+#� F'&7-,�� 9+5)1=� ,-$6)(-%99)(-$,��+"&���,�2+&�)7"%$-&�%$�5)")5)3-&�#2-)$�(1+)5,!��)"-�,+)&F'&7-,�+"&���,�9+)1-&�#%�)"6-,#)7+#-�#2-�+11-7-&�42=,)(+1�+"&�,-E'+1+@',-!� � "&� ,)E� ,+)&� F'&7-,� +"&� ��,� $-9',-&� #%� -6-"� (%",)&-$&%('5-"#-&�-6)&-"(-�%9�(2)1&�+@',-!

.0

>2)1-� 4'@1),2-&� %4)")%",� +$-� 2+$&-$� #%� 4+$,-� @-(+',-� #2-)$$-"&)#)%",� %9� #2-� -6)&-"(-� #-"&� #%� ,'44%$#� #2-)$� 1-7+1� $'1)"7,�� )#� ),+44+$-"#� -6-"�2-$-� #2+#�@%#2� #2-�5+F%$)#=�%9� #$)+1� (%'$#,� +"&� ,%5-"'5@-$�%9�+44-11+#-�(%'$#,�+$-�$-F-(#)"7�#2-�)541)(+#)%",�%9�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-� 9%$� (',#%&=!� � �%$� )",#+"(-�� )"� ��� ��� "� ���� ��� <���

.�� #2-

�+,,+(2',-##,� �%'$#� %9� 44-+1,� '42-1&� +� #$)+1� (%'$#8,� 9)"&)"7� #2+##2-$-�;+,� :"%� 2),#%$=� %$� 4+##-$"� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-< � &-,4)#-� #;%

.�� �����%5@+$&)�������"%#-��B��+#��+$#�0!

.0� ���� ���� L$-4%$#)"7� #2-� 9)"&)"7,�%9� #2-�>���������/����������MA�>��������

/�����������������"%#-�����+#�+44!�!���2-�/+##-$-&��%#2-$,8��-,#)5%"=��$%F-(#;+,�+�:5'1#)D=-+$�� 9%'$D42+,-� ,#'&=�',)"7�+�6+$)-#=�%9� $-,-+$(2�+44$%+(2-,� )"�;2)(22'5+"� $)72#,� 9+(#� 9)"&)"7� ;+,� (%541)5-"#-&� @=� ?'+1)#+#)6-� +"&� ?'+"#)#+#)6-� ,%()+1,()-"(-� $-,-+$(2� 5-#2%&%1%7)-,!< � � ���� +#� �!� � �#� 2+,� @--"� ($)#)()3-&� @-(+',-� #2-$-,-+$(2-$,� &)&� "%#� )"#-$6)-;� #2-� +((',-&� +@',-$,!� � �%'$#� $-(%$&,� +"&� %#2-$&%('5-"#+#)%"�;-$-� $-6)-;-&� )"�0�Q�%9�(+,-,A� +11� (%"9)$5-&� #2-�;%5-"8,� $-4%$#,!�%5@+$&)�������"%#-��B��+#��+$#�0�L()#)"7�+"�)"#-$6)-;�;)#2��'"&=�/+"($%9#��+'#2%$%9�#2-�,#'&=M!

.�! ����!�!0&�..B�L�+,,!�44!��#!�0���M!

16

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

$-,#$+)")"7� %$&-$,� +"&� 5'1#)41-� +,,+'1#� (%"6)(#)%",� +7+)",#� #2-9+#2-$!

..� � ,� F',#)9)(+#)%"�� #2-� (%'$#� 4%)"#-&� #%� #2-� 5%#2-$8,

: #2;+$#)"7< � %9� #2-� 9+#2-$8,� F%)"#� 1-7+1� (',#%&=�� 2-$� )"+&-?'+#-@%'"&+$=D,-##)"7� +"&� +$$-,#� 9%$� 4%,,-,,)%"� %9� &$'7,!

.�� � �"� =�� � ��

������.�� #2-�1+@+5+��%'$#�%9��)6)1�44-+1,��%6-$�+� #$%'@1-&�&),,-"#�

'42-1&�+"�+;+$&�%9�,%1-�(',#%&=�%9�+�,)E#--"D5%"#2D%1&�#%�#2-�9+#2-$&-,4)#-� #2-� 9+#2-$8,� '"&),4'#-&� (2%C)"7� %9� #2-�5%#2-$� $-,'1#)"7� )"2-$�2%,4)#+1)3+#)%"�+"&�2),�+$$-,#!���2-�(%'$#�+99)$5-&�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#8,&-#-$5)"+#)%"�%9�#2-�:@-,#�)"#-$-,#,�%9�#2-�(2)1&< �@+,-&�4$)5+$)1=�%"#2-� #-,#)5%"=�%9� +� 4,=(2%1%7),#�� ;2%� 9%'"&� #2+#� #2-� 9+#2-$� ;+,� "%#1)C-1=� #%� (%55)#� 6)%1-"(-�+7+)"�+"&�;+,� )"� #$-+#5-"#� 9%$�2),� +"7-$�;2-$-+,�#2-�5%#2-$�;+,�"%#�$-(-)6)"7�#$-+#5-"#�9%$�2-$�4,=(2%1%7)(+14$%@1-5,!

.�� ��"���� ������� �

.*�#2-��),,%'$)��%'$#�%9�44-+1,�'42-1&

(',#%&=� #%� #2-� 9+#2-$��&-,4)#-� #2-�5%#2-$8,� -E#-",)6-� #-,#)5%"=�%9� +2),#%$=� %9� 6)%1-"(-�� #2$-+#,� %9� 2%5)()&-� +"&� ,')()&-�� +"&� 4$%4-$#=&-,#$'(#)%"�� +"&� #2-� 9+#2-$8,� +&5),,)%"� #%� ,%5-� )"()&-"#,!� � �2-+44-+1,� (%'$#� "%#-&� #2+#� #2-� 1%;-$� : (%'$#� 5+=� @-1)-6-� +11�� 4+$#� %$"%"-�%9�+"=�;)#"-,,8,�#-,#)5%"=!<

.B

�#�),�"%#+@1-�#2+#�(%'$#,8�$-,),#+"(-�#%�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�),,'-,�2+,"%#� @--"� (%",#$+)"-&� @=� ,#+#-� ,#+#'#-,� ;2)(2� ;-$-� +&%4#-&� #%� &%-E+(#1=� #2+#�� -!7!�� @=� +&%4#)%"� %9� 4$-,'54#)%",� +7+)",#� (',#%&=� #%@+##-$-$,!� � �-6-$+1� (%'$#,� 2+6-� -6+&-&� #2-� 1-7),1+#)6-� )"#-"#� %9� ,'(2,#+#'#-,� @=� 2%1&)"7� #2+#�� -6-"� ;2-$-� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ;+,� �������#2%,-� )"()&-"#,� +$-� ,)541=� "%#� ,'99)()-"#� #%� (%",#)#'#-� :&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-< �+,�(%"#-541+#-&�@=�#2-�,#+#'#-!

�����#2-$�(%'$#,�(%"#)"'-�#%

..� ����+#�0.�!

.�� ����+#�.���"!�0!

.�! �����%!�0&�.�L1+!��)6!�44!��BB�M!

.�� ���� +#� �A� ��� ���� ������ �+$#� ���!�� L&),(',,)"7� 2%;� +"&� ;2=� 5-"#+1� 2-+1#2-E4-$#,8�4$-&)(#)%",�+$-�,%�(%",),#-"#1=�5),7')&-&�+"&�&+5+7)"7�)"�#2),�9)-1&MA� �����"%#-����!

.*! B0���!>!0&��0��L�%!�44!��BB�M!

.B� ����+#����!

��� ���,� �������%'(2�6!��%'(2�� B�*� �!>!0&����� L�%!�44!� �BB*M� L'42%1&)"7� #2-#$)+1�(%'$#8,� 9)"&)"7� #2+#� #2-� 9+#2-$8,�@$-+C)"7�%9� #2-�5%#2-$8,� (%11+$@%"-�&%-,�"%#(%",#)#'#-�+�: 4+##-$"�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-< �'"&-$�#2-�,#+#'#-��+"&�&),(%'"#)"7�(2)1&,-E'+1� +@',-�+11-7+#)%",MA��)55%",� 6!� �)55%",���.B��%!�0&��BB�� *�0� L�+!�44!��#!�BB�M�L2%1&)"7�#2+#�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#�4$%4-$1=�9%'"&�"%�:2),#%$=�%9�4-$4-#'+#)"7�9+5)1=6)%1-"(-< � +,� $-?')$-&� @=� ,#+#'#-�� ;2-$-� )#� +((-4#-&� : %"1=� %((+,)%"+1� )"()&-"#,� %96)%1-"(-� #2+#� 5+=� 2+6-� @--"� 4$%6%C-&� @=� #2-� ;)9-8,� +&'1#-$=< � +"&� $-F-(#-&� +@',-+11-7+#)%",� ;2)(2� ;-$-� "%#� (%$$%@%$+#-&� @=� +� &%('5-"#� %$� #2-� 2',@+"&8,+&5),,)%",MA� ��� ���� ��� ��� "� ���� ��� <���� ���� !�!0&� +#� .��� L-E41+)")"7� #2+#� 4+,#$-,#$+)")"7� %$&-$,� +"&� +� 4-"&)"7� +,,+'1#� (2+$7-� &%� "%#� (%",#)#'#-� : +� 4+##-$"� %$,-$)%',� )"()&-"#� %9� +@',-� #2+#� ;%'1&� 7)6-� $),-� #%� #2-� $-@'##+@1-� 4$-,'54#)%"< MA�+5)1#%"�6!��+5)1#%"��**���!>!0&����������L�%!�44!��BB.M�L(%55-"#)"7�#2+#�#2-#;%�+&5)##-&�+,,+'1#,�%6-$�#;-"#=�=-+$,�+"&�;)9-8,�#-,#)5%"=�%9�%"7%)"7�: 6-$@+1�+"&+@',)6-< �@-2+6)%$�&%�"%#�4$%6-�#2-�: 4+##-$"�%9�6)%1-"(-< �$-?')$-&�@=�,#+#'#-MA�/$%;"

17

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��. ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

-E(1'&-� -6)&-"(-� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� &-,4)#-� 1-7),1+#)6-$-?')$-5-"#,�#2+#�)#�@-�(%",)&-$-&!

��

�#)11� 5%$-� &),#'$@)"71=�� (%'$#,8� $-+(#)6)#=� #%� 5%#2-$,8� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-� +11-7+#)%",� )"� #2-� (',#%&= 6),)#+#)%"� (%"#-E#� ,%5-#)5-,@1)"&,� F'&7-,� #%� -6)&-"(-�%9�&)$-(#������ ��� �� �����@=� #2-�@+##-$-$!�2-�9+)1'$-�#%�$-(%7")3-�,'(2�: (%D+@',-< �91)-,�)"�#2-�9+(-�%9�#2-�;-11D-,#+@1),2-&� (%$$-1+#)%"� @-#;--"� +&'1#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +"&� (2)1&+@',-�@=� #2-� +&'1#� @+##-$-$!

�0� � /%#2� #2-� (%$$-1+#)%"� +"&� #2-� (%'$#8,

$-9',+1� #%� (%",)&-$� )#� ;+,� (1+,,)(+11=� 4$-,-"#� )"� �+,-� 0� +@%6-!� � >-4$-,-"#-&� ,'@,#+"#)+1� -6)&-"(-� %9� 6-$=� #$%'@1)"7� @-2+6)%$,� @=� �$!/-",%"� #%;+$&� #2-� (2)1&�� )"(1'&)"7� 2),� #%"7'-DC),,)"7� #2-� (2)1&&'$)"7�(%'$#D,'4-$6),-&�6),)#,� L+"&�+"7$=�$-#%$#�;2-"� #2-� ,'4-$6),%$#%1&�2)5� #%� ,#%4MA� #2-� (2)1&8,� $-4%$#� #2+#� ,2-� ,1-4#� )"� #2-� ,+5-�@-&;)#2�2-$� 9+#2-$�&'$)"7�+"�'",'4-$6),-&�6),)#� +"&� #2+#�2-� #%1&�2-$� +: ,-($-#A< � +"&� ,'@,-?'-"#� $-4%$#,� #2+#�2-� : #)(C1-,< �2-$�@-#;--"�2-$1-7,!

������=�(1)-"#�+1,%�#-,#)9)-&�#%��$!�/-",%"8,�$-4-+#-&�#2$-+#,�#%�C)11

#2-�(2)1&�+1%"7�;)#2�2-$�5%#2-$�L)"(1'&)"7�+�;$)##-"� #2$-+#�� : ��7)6-=%'� &-+&� @+@=< M�� +##-54#� #%� #2$%;� #2-� (2)1&� %'#� #2-� ;)"&%;�� +"&-E(-,,)6-�,4+"C)"7�%9�#2-�(2)1&�;2-"�#2-�4+$#)-,�1)6-&�#%7-#2-$!��11�%9#2-,-� +11-7+#)%",�� +1%"7� ;)#2� #2-� (1+)5,� %9� ,4%',+1� +@',-�� ;-$-6)$#'+11=�)7"%$-&!

�.

7+)"�� #2-� 2%$$%$� ,#%$)-,� +@%'"&!� � �2-� C)"&,� %9� (2)1&� +@',- 6!� /$%;"�� *��� �!0&� .���� .�B� L�C1+!� �#!� 44!� �BB�M� L2%1&)"7� #2+#� #2-� 5%#2-$8,#-,#)5%"=�#2+#�#2-�9+#2-$�,2%6-&�2-$�;)#2�9%$(-�+7+)",#�+�&%$$;+=��@$%C-�(+$�;)"&%;,�+"&�5+&-� 6-$@+1� #2$-+#,� %9� 6)%1-"(-� +7+)",#�2-$�&%-,�"%#� (%",#)#'#-� : +"=� -6)&-"(-;2)(2�,'44%$#,�!�!�!�(1+)5�H%9K�R%"7%)"7�&%5-,#)(�+@',-8�+,�$-?')$-&�@=�#2-�,#+#'#-< MA�%E�6!��%E������!>!0&�������0�� L!�!�0���M� L"%#)"7� #2+#� +�(%"6)(#)%"� 9%$� ,)541-+,,+'1#�;2)(2�(+',-&�@$'),-,�+"&�2)##)"7�#2-�(+$�)",#-+&�%9�#2-�(%541+)"+"#�&)&�"%#(%",#)#'#-�+"� )"()&-"#�(+',)"7� : ,-$)%',� @%&)1=� )"F'$=�< �%$� +� : 4+##-$"�< �;2-$-�%#2-$+11-7+#)%",�;-$-� 9%'"&�"%#� ($-&)@1-MA�/$%;"� 6!�/$%;"�� ����!>!0&�*�B�� *��� L!�!�BBBM� L'42%1&)"7� #2-� #$)+1� (%'$#8,� 9)"&)"7� #2+#� : )"()&-"#,� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� @=@%#2�4+$#)-,< �"-)#2-$� )"&)(+#-&�+�: 4+##-$"�%9�@-2+6)%$< �"%$�: )"()&-"#,�%9� ,'99)()-"#,-6-$)#=� #%� #$)77-$� #2-�$-@'##+@1-�4$-,'54#)%"< MA��)")',�6!��)")',����.�!>!0&���������L!�!��BB�M�L$-6-$,)"7�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#8,� 9)"&)"7�#2+#�#2-�9+#2-$8,�',-�%9�42=,)(+19%$(-� +7+)",#� #2-� &+'72#-$� -"#)#1-&� #2-� 5%#2-$� #%� (',#%&=� @-(+',-� @%#2� )"()&-"#,%(('$$-&�,-6-"�=-+$,�4$)%$��+"&�2%1&)"7�#2-=�&)&�"%#�)"6%16-�,-$)%',�@%&)1=�)"F'$=�%$+�: 4+##-$"�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-< M!

��� ���,� ������ �+"-=� 6!�>$-"�� �00� �%!�0&� �.� L�+!� �#!� 44!� �BB*M� L'42%1&)"7� #2-#$)+1� (%'$#8,� -E(1',)%"� %9� -6)&-"(-� %9� 4+,#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� 4$-D&+#)"7� +� 4$)%$(%",-"#�(',#%&=�%$&-$��&-,4)#-� #2-� 1%;-$�(%'$#8,� 9)"&)"7� #2+#� #2-�5%#2-$8,� 9-+$�;+,'"F',#)9)-&� +"&� #2+#� )#� ;+,� : %'#$+7-&< � @=� 2-$� 5%6-� +;+=� ;)#2%'#� "%#)9=)"7� #2-9+#2-$M!

�0� ���������"%#-�0��+"&�+((%54+"=)"7�#-E#!

��� ���� ������+$#� �!/� L-E41+)")"7� #2+#� ,'(2� -6)&-"(-� (%'1&� @-� (2+$+(#-$)3-&� +,-6)&-"(-�%9�-)#2-$�: +@',-< �%$�%9�: 7$%%5)"7< �9%$�5%$-�9'11D91-&7-&�,-E'+1�+@',-M!

�.! 11-7+#)%",� %9� (2)1&� ,-E'+1� +@',-� +$-� -,4-()+11=� (2+$7-&� +"&� 1)C-1=� #%� @-#'$"-&�+7+)",#� #2-�5%#2-$�� $-7+$&1-,,�%9�;2-#2-$� +&'1#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ),� )"� #2-5)E!�������%5@+$&)�������"%#-��B��+#��+$#���L&-,($)@)"7�(+,-,�%9�+11-7-&�,-E'+1�+@',-+"&�(%'$#,8�$-9',+1�#%�$-,4%"&M!

18

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

)7"%$-&��5)")5)3-&�� &),@-1)-6-&�� %$� +11%;-&� #%� 2+44-"� )"� #2-� (+,-,)"6-,#)7+#-&� @=� #2-� >-11-,1-=� /+##-$-&� �%#2-$,8� �-,#)5%"=� �$%F-(#�)"(1'&-&�#2-�9%11%;)"7�

�=�2',@+"&�#%%C�#2-�@+@=�+"&�,+)&��R�2'#�#2),�9SSSSSS�C)&�'4T8�+"&#2$-;�2)5�+($%,,�#2-�$%%5!��"&�+11���(%'1&�,--�;+,�+#2+"�2)##)"7#2-�;+11��+"&���7$+@@-&�2)5!

��

�2-�#%1&�5-�#2+#�2-�4'#�#;%�9)"7-$,�)",)&-�%9�2-$�6+7)"+!��

>2-"��� 9)$,#�,+;�5=�,%"�+9#-$�#2+#�=-+$�;)#2�2),� 9+#2-$��2-�2+&�%"4+"#,�!�!�!�#2+#�;-$-�$)44-&��2-�2+&�-(3-5+�,%�@+&��2-�2+&�,"-+C-$,#2+#�;-$-� #%%� ,5+11��;)#2�"%� 1+(-,��2-�;+,� -5+()+#-&!�!�!�!� ��%� #2),&+=��#2),�@%=�),�1)C-�+�@%=�%9�,#%"-!

��

���! >�������>���������������������������������������

������������

�#� (+"� 7-"-$+11=� @-� +,,'5-&� #2+#� F'&7-,� +"&� 9%$-",)(� -6+1'+#%$,;2%�$-+(#�"-7+#)6-1=�#%�@+##-$-&�5%#2-$,8�(1+)5,�)"�(',#%&= 6),)#+#)%"(%"#-,#,�&%�"%#�L;)#2�,%5-�"%#+@1-�-E(-4#)%",M�(%",()%',1=�&%�,%�%'#%9� ,-E),5!� � �+#2-$�� #2-=� %9#-"� $-1=� %"� +44+$-"#1=� 7-"&-$D"-'#$+1$+#)%"+1-,��;2)(2�'"&-$('#� #2-� 1)C-1)2%%&� #2+#� +�@+##-$-&�5%#2-$� ),#$'1=� ,--C)"7� #%� 4$%#-(#� 2-$� (2)1&$-"!� � �+$#� � @-1%;� -E41%$-,� %"-,%5-#)5-,�'",4%C-"�@'#�-E#$-5-1=�4%;-$9'1�: 7-"&-$D"-'#$+1< �"%$5;2)(2� 4-$6+,)6-1=� )"91'-"(-,� (%'$#,� +&F'&)(+#)"7� (',#%&=� +"&6),)#+#)%"�� +"&� 5)1)#+#-,� +7+)",#� ,-$)%',� (%",)&-$+#)%"� %9� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-�� #2-�-542+,),�%"�4+$-"#+1�-?'+1)#=��;2)(2�5%$-� ,4-()9)(+11=#+C-,�#2-�9%$5�%9�+�9%(',�%"�9+#2-$,!���#�),�5=�,-",-�#2+#�#2-�&-,)$-�9%$7$-+#-$� 4+$-"#+1� )"6%16-5-"#� ),� -E-$#)"7� +� 5+7"-#)(� 4'11� )"� #2-,-(+,-,� ;2)(2� )54-1,� (%'$#,� #%� +6%)&� 9'11� (%",)&-$+#)%"� %9� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-!� ��%'$#,� +$-� +,,),#-&� )"� #2),� +6%)&+"(-�@=� #2-)$� $-1)+"(-�%",-6-$+1� $+#)%"+1-,�� %$� 5%$-� +(('$+#-1=�� 5),(%"(-4#)%",�� ;2)(25),(%"(-)6-� #2-� $%1-� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� )"� (',#%&=� 1)#)7+#)%"!�2-,-�5),(%"(-4#)%",�+$-�&),(',,-&�)"�,%5-�&-#+)1�)"��+$#,�/�����+"&

��! >���������/�����������������"%#-�����+#���!

��� ��!�+#��.!

��� ���A���������%'(2�6!��%'(2��B�*��!>!0&�����L�%!��#!�44!��BB*M�L'42%1&)"7#2-� #$)+1� (%'$#8,� +;+$&� %9� 4$)5+$=� $-,)&-"#)+1� (',#%&=� #%� 9+#2-$�� &-,4)#-� #2-� (%'$#8,$-9',+1� #%�+44%)"#�+����%$� )"6-,#)7+#-�(2)1&� ,-E'+1�+@',-�+11-7+#)%",�@+,-&�%"� #2-(2)1&8,�: ,#$+"7-< �,-E'+1�@-2+6)%$,��+"&�#2-�'"&),4'#-&�-6)&-"(-�#2+#�#2-�9+#2-$�2+&@$%C-"�#2-�5%#2-$8,�(%11+$@%"-MA��)")',�6!��)")',����.�!>!0&����������L!�!��BB�ML$-6-$,)"7�+�(',#%&=�+;+$&�#%�#2-�5%#2-$�;2-$-�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#�9%'"&�#2+#�#2-�9+#2-$(%55)##-&� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +7+)",#� 2),� &+'72#-$�� +"&� 2%1&)"7� #2+#� 2)##)"7� #2-&+'72#-$�)"�2-$�9+(-�+"&�4'11)"7�2-$�9$%5�+�(+$�@=�7$+@@)"7�2-$�+$5�+"&�2+)$�5+=2+6-� @--"� 4-$5),,)@1-� 4+$-"#+1� &),()41)"-M!� � �"� +#� 1-+,#� %"-� )",#+"(-� #2-� (%'$#� %9+44-+1,�(%$$-(#-&�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#8,�-$$%$!���',,%�6!��+$&"-$��B����!0&�B*�L-6!��BB*ML$-6-$,)"7�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#8,�+;+$&�%9�F%)"#�1-7+1�(',#%&=�;2-$-�#2-$-�;+,�-6)&-"(-�#2+##2-�9+#2-$�2+&�+@',-&�2),�#;%�(2)1&$-"M!

19

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

�� @-1%;!� � >2+#� �� #-$5� #2-� :�?'+1)#=� �$)"()41-< � +1,%� 4%;-$9'11=)"91'-"(-,�9%$-",)(�-E4-$#,�;2%�2+6-�@--"�5+F%$�(%"#$)@'#%$,�#%�#2-(%'$#,8� &-")+1� %9� #2-� ,)7")9)(+"(-� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� 9%$(',#%&= 6),)#+#)%"� +&F'&)(+#)%",!

�*� � /-(+',-� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ),

'"?'-,#)%"+@1=� $-1-6+"#� #%� (2)1&$-"8,�;-11D@-)"7�� +11� %9� #2-,-� 9+(#%$,;%$C�)"�(%"F'"(#)%"�#%�1-+&�(%'$#,�#%%�%9#-"�#%�9+)1�#%�5+C-�(',#%&=+;+$&,�#2+#�4$%#-(#�(2)1&$-"8,�"--&,�+"&�@-,#�)"#-$-,#,!

�B

��� %���� ���&>���� ��� �����"�

�2-� (%55)#5-"#� #%� 4+$-"#+1� -?'+1)#=� )"� (',#%&=� +"&� 6),)#+#)%"1)#)7+#)%"�),�&$)6-"�@%#2�@=�:4$%(-,,< �+"&�@=�: ,'@,#+"#)6-< �"%$5,!��,+�5+##-$� %9� 4$%(-,,�� +11� (%'$#,� +$-� -#2)(+11=� +"&� 1-7+11=� %@1)7+#-&� #%+&F'&)(+#-�(+,-,�9$%5�+�,#+"(-�%9�F'&)()+1�"-'#$+1)#=��#%�2-+$�-6)&-"(-;)#2� +"� %4-"� 5)"&�� +"&� "%#� #%� @$)"7� +"=� 4-$,%"+1� @)+,-,� #%� #2-&-#-$5)"+#)%"�%9�#2-�(+,-!���"�(',#%&=�(+,-,��(%'$#,8�:"-'#$+1< �,#+"(-),� 1)"C-&� #%� #2-)$� '"?'-,#)%"+@1-�%@1)7+#)%"� #%� #$-+#� @%#2� 4+$#)-,� +,,#+$#)"7� ;)#2� -?'+1� $)72#,� #%� (',#%&=�� +"&� "%#� #%� 4$-,'5-�� 9%$-E+541-��#2+#�(2)1&$-"�"--&�#2-)$�5%#2-$,�5%$-�#2+"�#2-)$�9+#2-$,!

��

�"� (%"#$+,#� #%� +� 4$-,'54#)%"� %9� -?'+1� 9)#"-,,�� +11-7+#)%",� %9&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� %$� (2)1&� +@',-� ,--5� #%� 9$+5-� #2-� 4+$#)-,� +#� #2-,#+$#� +,� : )""%(-"#� 6)(#)5< � 6,!� : -6)1� 4-$4-#$+#%$!< � � �2),� 5+C-,� ,'(2+11-7+#)%",� +44-+$� +15%,#� '"9+)$�� #)1#)"7� #2-� ,(+1-,� @-9%$-� +� (%'$#2-+$,� +"&� ,)9#,� +11� #2-� -6)&-"(-!� � �%'$#,�5+=� $-,),#� ,'(2� +11-7+#)%",@-(+',-�#%�+((-4#�#2-5�(+"�2+6-�#2-�-99-(#�%9�$-41+()"7�#2-�-E-$(),-

�*� �����������+$#����!�!

�B� ���� �������+$#����!�!� �"%#2-$�2=4%#2-,),� 9%$�;2=�(%'$#,� ,%�%9#-"�5+$7)"+1)3-&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� )"� #2-,-� (+,-,� ),� #2+#� (%"9$%"#)"7� #2-� 2%$$%$,� )"91)(#-&� ;)#2)"9+5)1)-,� ),� ,%5-#)5-,� ,)541=� #%%�4+)"9'1�� +"&� ),� $-,),#-&�@=�+� 9%$5�%9�4,=(2%1%7)(+1&-")+1!� ��-;�;2%�;%$C� )"� #2),� 9)-1&�&%'@#� #2+#�&-")+1� 9$-?'-"#1=� 9'-1,� $-,),#+"(-� #%@+##-$-&�;%5-"8,� (1+)5,!� � ���� �����������+$#2+� �!��+2%"-=�������� ������ ��� �� ���������#�1���������� �� ������������� �����B������!��!����!��� L�BB�MA�""��$--&5+"�(�� 2(������� ���"����� ��� ���!��������"��#� ����������*����� ��� � ��� ���� ��-���� ���"�������� ���� �����������!� !����������!����8��G��!����� L0���M!� ��%;-6-$�4,=(2%1%7)(+1� &-")+1� &%-,� "%#� 9'11=� -E41+)"� #2-� ����������� @-#;--"� 2%;� (%'$#,� )"(',#%&=�1)#)7+#)%"�+"&�(%'$#,�)"�4$%#-(#)%"�%$&-$�(+,-,�$-,4%"&�#%�,)5)1+$�&),#'$@)"75+#-$)+1� +@%'#� +&'1#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-!� � �+$#� %9� #2-� +",;-$� #%� #2+#� ?'-,#)%"� ),)541)()#�)"�#2-�&),(',,)%"�(%"#+)"-&�)"��+$#��@-1%;!���+$#,�/D��-E41%$-�#2-�4+$#)('1+$$+#)%"+1-,�(%'$#,�',-�#%�F',#)9=�#2-)$�&-(),)%",�+"&�2%;�#2-�(',#%&=�(%"#-E#�($)#)(+11=,2+4-,� #2%,-�$+#)%"+1-,!� �/=�($=,#+11)3)"7�;2+#� )#� ),�+@%'#� #2-�(2)1&D(-"#-$-&�(%"#-E##2+#� $)7)&)9)-,�(%'$#,8� $-,),#+"(-�#%�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-� ),,'-,��;-�5+=�@-�+@1-� #%� 9)"&%#2-$�+44$%+(2-,�#%�)"#-7$+#)"7�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�C"%;1-&7-�)"#%�#2-,-�&-(),)%",!

��! :�2-�#;%�4+$#)-,�,#+"&�%"�-?'+1�9%%#)"7�+#�#2-�%'#,-#�%9� #$)+1��+"&�#2-�(%'$#&-#-$5)"-,�#2-�@-,#� )"#-$-,#�%9� #2-�(2)1&�@+,-&�%"� #2-�$-1+#)6-� 9)#"-,,�+"&�+@)1)#=�%9#2-�(%54-#)"7�4+$#)-,� )"� +11� $-,4-(#,!< � � �)55%",� 6!� �)55%",�� �.B� �%!� 0&� �BB�� *�0L�+!�44!��#!��BB�M�L'42%1&)"7�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#8,�$-9',+1�#%�9)"&�#2+#�#-,#)5%"=�+@%'#�+#;-"#=� =-+$� 2),#%$=� %9� 6)%1-"(-� 5--#,� #2-� ,#+#'#%$=� ,#+"&+$&� 9%$� #$)77-$)"7� +4$-,'54#)%"�+7+)",#� +;+$&)"7� (',#%&=� #%� #2-� +@',-$��;2-$-�%"1=� %"-� )"()&-"#�2+&&%('5-"#+$=�(%$$%@%$+#)%"M!

20

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

%9� #2-� (%'$#8,�'"(%",#$+)"-&�&),($-#)%"�'"&-$� #2-� :@-,#� )"#-$-,#,�%9#2-�(2)1&< �#-,#��;)#2�+"�)541)()#�4$-,'54#)%"�%9�%"-�4+$#=8,�'"9)#"-,,L-99-(#)6-1=�-$+,)"7�F'&)()+1�&),($-#)%"M!

�����%'$#,�+$-�$-1'(#+"#�#%�(-&-

#2-)$�&),($-#)%"�+"&�F'&75-"#�)"�#2),�5+""-$!�0

%"-#2-1-,,�� (%'$#,8� $-1'(#+"(-� #%� +((-4#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(--6)&-"(-��%$� ,%5-#)5-,�-6-"� #%�2-+$� )#�� (+""%#�@-�-E41+)"-&�@=� #2-"-'#$+1)#=� "%$5� +1%"-!� � 9#-$� +11�� #2-� ,+5-� "%$5� &%-,� "%#� 4$-6-"#(%'$#,�9$%5�: 9)"&)"7�9+(#,< �)"��9%$�-E+541-��($)5)"+1�(+,-,�;2-$-�#2-#;%� ,)&-,� 2+6-� &)+5-#$)(+11=� %44%,-&� ,#%$)-,!� � �2-� $-+1)#=� %9� +11F'&7)"7�),�#2+#��+#�,%5-�4%)"#��#2-�%4-"D5)"&-&�2-+$)"7�%9�-6)&-"(-5',#� -6%16-� )"#%� +� F'&)()+1� )"#-$4$-#+#)%"� %$� (%"(1',)%"� +@%'#� #2-9+(#,�� )!-!�� ;2%� ),� #$'#29'1�� ;2%� 2+,� &%"-� ;2+#�� -#(!� � �-#�� )"(',#%&= &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� (+,-,�� #%%�%9#-"� #2-� (%'$#8,� -542+,),� %"4+$-"#+1�-?'+1)#=�4-$,),#,�)"�#2-�9+(-�%9�(1-+$�-6)&-"(-�#2+#�%"-�4+$-"#),�6)%1-"#�+"&�+@',)6-�#%�#2-�%#2-$!� � �"�%#2-$�;%$&,��(%'$#,� #$-+#� #2--?'+1)#=� 4$)"()41-� +,� "%#� F',#� +� ,#+$#)"7� 4%)"#�� @'#� +,� #2-� $-?'),)#-%'#(%5-��+�7%+1�#2+#�%6-$$)&-,�(%"#$+&)(#%$=�)"9%$5+#)%"!

�#� ,--5,� (1-+$�� #2-"�� #2+#� #2-� -?'+1)#=� 4$)"()41-� ),� +1,%� 4%;-$9'11=&$)6-"�@=�,'@,#+"#)6-�6+1'-,!���'(2�6+1'-,�&-$)6-�5%,#�%@6)%',1=�9$%5#2-�4%;-$9'1�L+1#2%'72�)"(%541-#-M�7-"&-$�$-6%1'#)%"�%9�#2-��B��,�;2)(2� ',2-$-&� )"� #2-� $-F-(#)%"� %9� -E41)()#1=� 7-"&-$-&� ,#+"&+$&,� )"9+5)1=�1+;��)"�4+$#)('1+$��#2-�#-"&-$�=-+$,�4$-,'54#)%"�+,�+�5-+",�%9&-#-$5)")"7�#2-�@-,#�)"#-$-,#�%9�#2-�(2)1&!

�����"-�#2)"7�2+,�@--"�(1-+$

,)"(-� :;%5-"8,� 1)@-$+#)%"< ��5%#2-$,� +$-� "%� 1%"7-$� ,'44%,-&� #%� @-(%",)&-$-&�#2-�4$-D-5)"-"#�4+$-"#!��/=�#2-�1+#-��B��,D*�,��"%#)%",�%97-"&-$� -?'+1)#=� ;-$-� #+C)"7� +� 5%$-� +99)$5+#)6-� 9%$5A� : F%)"#(',#%&=<I )!-!�� #2-� 42=,)(+1� +"& %$� 1-7+1� ,2+$)"7� %9� 4+$-"#)"7$-,4%",)@)1)#)-,� +"&� $)72#,� +9#-$� ,-4+$+#)%"I ;+,� "%;� )"($-+,)"71=#%'#-&� @=� 4%1)(=� +"+1=,#,�� (%'$#,�� +"&� -5@%&)-&� )"� +99)$5+#)6-

��! �� +5� &-,($)@)"7� %"1=� +� 5-"#+1� +"+1=#)(� 4$%(-,,�� "%#� -E41)()#� 1-7+1

$-?')$-5-"#,!��>2)1-�5+"=�,#+#-,�2+6-�+&%4#-&�+�1-7+1�4$-,'54#)%"�+7+)",#�(',#%&=#%�+�@+##-$-$����+$7'-�#2+#��-6-"�)"�,#+#-,�;2-$-�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�),�%"1=�+�: 9+(#%$�<&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+11-7+#)%",�+$-� ,--"�+,� $-&'()"7�&),($-#)%"�+"&� #)1#)"7� #2-� ,(+1-,�,%5-#2)"7�#2+#�(%'$#,�$-,),#!

�0! �2-� 4-$-"")+1� &-@+#-� %6-$� ;2-#2-$� F'&)()+1� &),($-#)%"� %$� 1-7),1+#)6-4$-,'54#)%",� )"� (',#%&=� (+,-,� @-##-$� ,-$6-� (2)1&$-"� &%-,� "%#� (2+"7-� #2-� 9+(#� #2+#5%,#� F'&7-,� 1)C-1=� @-1)-6-� #2+#� #2-� -E-$(),-� %9� #2-)$� %;"� &),($-#)%"� +"&� F'&75-"#�+9#-$�2-+$)"7�#2-�9+(#,��),�5%$-�(%"&'()6-�#%�+�F',#�%'#(%5-�#2+"�;%'1&�@-�#2-�@1'"#+441)(+#)%"�%9�+�1-7),1+#)6-�4$-,'54#)%"!�����,��������+6)&��!��2+5@-$,��1� ��)���� ���� �� ����1��������"� ���� ��� ����� ��������*������!��!����!�.���L�B*.M!���2-�%"--E(-4#)%"��#%�(%'$#,8�&),1)C-�%9�4$-,'54#)%",�5+=�;-11�@-�#2-�4$-,'54#)%"�)"�9+6%$�%9F%)"#� (',#%&=�� ;2)(2� ,4-+C,� #%� (%'$#,8� ,#$%"7� +##$+(#)%"� #%� #2),� (%"(-4#� %9� 4+$-"#+1-?'+1)#=!������������"%#-,��.D�.�+"&�+((%54+"=)"7�#-E#!

��� ���,��������E��+$#-��-6)"-���B*��%!�0&��*����B�DB��L1+!��B*�M�L2%1&)"7�#2+#�+4$-,'54#)%"� )"� 9+6%$� %9� 5+#-$"+1� (',#%&=� 9%$� (2)1&$-"� %9� : #-"&-$� =-+$,<'"(%",#)#'#)%"+11=�&),($)5)"+#-,�%"�#2-�@+,),�%9�,-EM!

21

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��* ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

1-7),1+#)%"�$-?')$)"7�+�4$-,'54#)%"�)"�)#,�9+6%$!

�)"(-�#2+#�#)5-��F%)"#�(',#%&=�2+,�@--"�#2-�,'@F-(#�%9�5'(2�&-@+#-!�"�#2-�%"-�2+"&��)#�2+,�@--"�&-9-"&-&�+,�-5@%&=)"7�+"�)&-+1�6),)%"%9� ;2+#� (2)1&$-"� "--&� +"&� 4+$-"#,� &-,-$6-�� +"&� +� 5-+",� %99'$#2-$)"7�7-"&-$�-?'+1)#=� +"&� ,2+$-&�4+$-"#+1� $-,4%",)@)1)#=!

�.� ��"

#2-� %#2-$� 2+"&�� )#,� )54%,)#)%"�%"� '";)11)"7� 4+$-"#,� )"� 4$+(#)(-� 2+,@--"� 5'(2� ($)#)()3-&� +,� 4$%9%'"&1=� '"9+)$� #%� 4$)5+$=� (+$-#+C-$,�#=4)(+11=� ;%5-"�� +"&� %9#-"� (%"#$+$=� #%� (2)1&$-"8,� @-,#� )"#-$-,#,!

��

�2-$-�),�+1,%�+�(%",)&-$+@1-�(%",-",',�+@%'#�)#,�)"+44$%4$)+#-"-,,�)"(+,-,�%9�:2)72�(%"91)(#< �@-#;--"�#2-�,-4+$+#)"7�4+$-"#,!

��

�#� ),� "%#+@1-�� 2%;-6-$�� #2+#� #2),� ;-11D&%('5-"#-&� &-@+#-� +"&� #2-9+)$1=� ;)&-,4$-+&� "'+"(-&� $-(%7")#)%"� %9� #2-� 1)5)#+#)%",� %9� F%)"#(',#%&=� &%� "%#� ,--5� #%� 2+6-� 4-"-#$+#-&� F'&)()+1� #2)"C)"7� #%� +,)7")9)(+"#�&-7$--!� ��"� #2-�(%"#$+$=�� #%� #2-�6+,#�5+F%$)#=�%9� (',#%&=(%'$#,�� ,%5-�9%$5�%9� F%)"#�(',#%&=�2+,� )"($-+,)"71=�@-(%5-�"%#� F',#+"�+,4)$+#)%"��)"6)#+#)%"��%$�-6-"�+�4$-9-$-"(-��@'#�+"�+@,%1'#-�)&-+1!/'##$-,,)"7�#2-�"%#)%"�%9�(%D-?'+1�4+$-"#)"7�+,�#2-�2)72-,#�7%%&�9%$(2)1&$-"�+"&�#2-�%"1=�9+)$�$-,%1'#)%"�9%$�4+$-"#,�2+,�@--"�#2-�$+4)&+&%4#)%"� %9� +� ,-$)-,� %9� %#2-$� 1-7),1+#)6-� +"&� F'&)()+1� 4%1)()-,�)"(1'&)"7� : 9$)-"&1=� 4+$-"#< � 4$-9-$-"(-,� +"&� :4+$-"#+1� +1)-"+#)%"<(1+)5,!� � /%#2� %9� #2-,-� "%#)%",� $-91-(#� +"&� 9'$#2-$� #2-� ,-&'(#)6-+,,'54#)%",� #2+#� +"=� 4+$-"#� ;2%� &%-,� "%#� ,'44%$#� (%D-?'+14+$-"#)"7�L#=4)(+11=�5%#2-$,M�),�@=�&-9)")#)%"�+�&-9)()-"#�4+$-"#��+"&#2+#� +"=� 4+$-"#� ;2%� +&6%(+#-,� F%)"#� 4+$-"#)"7� L#=4)(+11=� 9+#2-$,M� ),)"2-$-"#1=�6)$#'%',!

��

�.� ���,�����������������/��G���/�����������������������������������

�� ����� �������� ��� �������� ��0� L�BB0M� L(+'#)%',1=� -"&%$,)"7� F%)"#� 1-7+1(',#%&=� +,� +� 5-+",� %9� -"(%'$+7)"7� F%)"#� )"6%16-5-"#MA� �+#2+$)"-� �!� /+$#1-##�(�����������(����������������!��!P!�.����.*��"!���L�BBBM�L+(C"%;1-&7)"7�2-$�%;"-+$1)-$�;%$C�,'77-,#)"7�#2+#�F%)"#�(',#%&=�(%'1&�9'$#2-$�7-"&-$�-?'+1)#=��+"&�,#+#)"7#2+#� ,2-� "%;� ,'44%$#,� #2-� "-;� 5-$)(+"� �+;� �",#)#'#-� ,#+"&+$&� %9� &-,)7")"7� +(',#%&=�+;+$&�#%�$-91-(#�#2-�4$)%$�4+$-"#)"7�$%1-,M!

��� ���,� ������ +"+�/!��)"7-$�G�>)11)+5��!��-="%1&,���� ��� � ��� 5��� �"� �����.���!��!����!�.B��L�B**M�L+$7')"7�#2+#�(%'$#D)54%,-&�F%)"#�(',#%&=�+$$+"7-5-"#,�+$-+"� +@&)(+#)%"� @=� F'&7-,� ;2%� +$-� +9$+)&� %9�5+C)"7� #%'72� (',#%&=� &-(),)%",�� +"&� +,+($)9)(-�%9�(2)1&$-"8,�@-,#�)"#-$-,#,�)"�9+6%$�%9�: -?')#+@1-< �$-,'1#,�9%$�4+$-"#,M!

��� �����',+"��#-)"5+"��5��� �"� ���#��� ����=���,��� ����3����?� � �������,���� ��5������������������ ����������� ���������!�!�������!����!���B�L�B*�MA� +99-�-#+1!�������"%#-�B��+#���!

��! �2-,-�#=4-,�%9�4%1)()-,��+1%"7�;)#2�F%)"#�(',#%&=�4$-,'54#)%",��+$-�9$-?'-"#1=)"#-",)6-1=� 1%@@)-&� 9%$� +"&� 4',2-&� #2$%'72� @=� 7$%'4,� ;2)(2� ,--� #2-5,-16-,� +,+&6%(+#-,�9%$�: 9+#2-$,8�$)72#,!< ���"�#2-��),#$)(#�%9��%1'5@)+��F%)"#�(',#%&=�;+,�1%@@)-&#2$--� ,-4+$+#-� #)5-,�� %6-$� +� 4-$)%&� %9� ,-6-$+1� =-+$,�� +"&� ;+,� 9)"+11=� 4+,,-&� %6-$,'@,#+"#)+1�%44%,)#)%"�9$%5�#2-�/+$�+"&�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+&6%(+#-,!���2-�)")#)+#%$,%9� #2-� @)11� ;-$-� 9$%5� +� "+#)%"+1� :�2)1&$-"8,� �)72#,� �%'"()1< � ;2)(2� -"7+7-,� )"1-7),1+#)6-�+&6%(+(=�+$%'"&�#2-�(%'"#$=!���-+&)"7�5-5@-$,�%9�#2-�%$7+")3+#)%"�;-$-)&-"#)9)-&� 9+#2-$,8� $)72#,� +&6%(+#-,!� � �����+$7+$-#� �+$#)"� /+$$=�� �� ����� ���)����# �"�.�5��� �"� �������"��������� ��>��!��>!��%6! �-(!��BB���+#�.�D.0!

22

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ��B

�2-�4$%@1-5,�;)#2� F%)"#� (',#%&=� L+"&� #2-� $-1+#-&� 9$)-"&1=�4+$-"#+"&�4+$-"#+1�+1)-"+#)%"�(%"(-4#,M� )"� #2-�&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�(%"#-E#�;2)(2� +$-� +541=� &%('5-"#-&� )"� #2-� 1)#-$+#'$-�

�*� ;+$$+"#� @$)-9

$-(+4)#'1+#)%"�2-$-!���"�-,,-"(-��4$%6)&)"7�+�@+##-$-$�;)#2�5+E)5'5+((-,,� #%� 2),� (2)1&$-"� 5+=� %"1=� 9'$#2-$� 2),� +@',-� @=� )"($-+,)"7� 2),(%"#$%1�%6-$�+"&�2+$+,,5-"#�%9�#2-�5%#2-$��+"&�,)7")9)(+"#�42=,)(+1+"&�-5%#)%"+1�$),C,�#%�@%#2�#2-�(2)1&$-"�+"&�#2-�5%#2-$!��: �$)-"&1=4+$-"#< � 4$%6),)%",� +$-� )541)()#1=� :'"9$)-"&1=< � #%� @+##-$-&� ;%5-"�;2%�5+=�"--&�#%�+6%)&�)"#-$+(#)%"�;)#2�#2-)$�+@',-$,�9%$�#2-)$�,+9-#=+"&� 5-"#+1� 2-+1#2!

�B� � �)5)1+$1=�� +441)(+#)%"� %9� :4+$-"#+1� +1)-"+#)%"

,="&$%5-< �L&),(',,-&�9'$#2-$�)"��-(#)%"����!/!0�@-1%;M�)"�(+,-,�;)#2+@',-�+11-7+#)%",��,--5,�)"#$)",)(+11=�#%�&-"=�#2-�1)C-1)2%%&�#2+#�,%5-(2)1&$-"�+44$%4$)+#-1=�;+"#�+"&�"--&�#2-)$�-E4%,'$-�#%�9+#2-$,�;2%+@',-�#2-)$�5%#2-$,�%$�#2-5,-16-,�#%�@-�1)5)#-&!��>2)1-�5%,#�,#+#'#-,(%"#+)"� +"� -E(-4#)%"� #%� #2-� 4$-9-$-"(-� 9%$� F%)"#� 4+$-"#)"7� ;2-$-#2-$-�),�-6)&-"(-�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-��)"�4$+(#)(-��'"9-##-$-&�+((-,,#%�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"�),�)"($-+,)"71=�@-)"7�,--"�+,�+�9+#2-$8,�: $)72#�<

���+"&

F%)"#� 1-7+1� +"&� 42=,)(+1� (',#%&=� ),� 9$-?'-"#1=� )54%,-&� &-,4)#-5%#2-$,8� (1+)5,� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-!

��� � �%$-%6-$�� #2-� (%"(-4#� %9

:4+$-"#+1�+1)-"+#)%"< �;+,�+(#'+11=�)"6-"#-&�#%�$-@'#�5%#2-$,8�(1+)5,%9�(2)1&�+@',-��4+$#)('1+$1=�,-E'+1�+@',-!���2',��&-,4)#-�#2-�(%"#$+$=+,,'54#)%",�%9�5+"=�(%'$#,�#2+#�+((-4#�:4+$-"#+1�+1)-"+#)%"< �(1+)5,�)#� ),� 2+$&� #%� +6%)&� #2-� (%"(1',)%"� #2+#� #2),� #2-%$=� ),� %"1=� +� #2)"1=

�*� ���� ���������� /+$@+$+� !� �+$#�� � � �� "���� ��� ��� ��� !�������#� ������,"����� ���� ���� 1��������� ����� .�� ��!� G� ��!� ��!� !� �.� L�BB0MA� %+"� N%$3+�%�� �� ���� �� "������� ��� "� ���� ��� �� ���� @��� %���� � ����� �� @ ���� 0B���������������!���������00D0��L�BB�M!

�B� ����N%$3+�� �����"%#-��*�� +#���00A� ��������%$&�6!� �%$&�������%!�0&��B�� L�1+!�),#!��#!�44!��BB�M�L$-6-$,)"7�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#8,�+;+$&�%9�(',#%&=�#%�+�9+#2-$�;2%�2+&+&5)##-&� #%� +@',-�� @-(+',-� #2-� #$)+1� (%'$#� 9+)1-&� #%� +&&$-,,� #2-� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-+"&��+5%"7�%#2-$�#2)"7,��)#,�)541)(+#)%",�9%$�#2-�: 9$)-"&1=�4+$-"#< �4$-9-$-"(-M!����������������$-&$)(+��-2$5+"��(�� ������ ��� ���!�������� �� ��"� ����"����������L�-@!�BB�M��+#��0D�B�L&),(',,)"7�#2-�)"#-$+(#)%"�@-#;--"�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+11-7+#)%",�+"&9$)-"&1=�4+$-"#�4$%6),)%",M!

��! �"&--&�� +&6%(+#-,� 2+6-� %@,-$6-&� )"� F'&)()+1� #$+)")"7,� #2+#� ,%5-� F'&7-,+44+$-"#1=�@-1)-6-�#2+#�#2-=�+$-�"%#�9$--�#%�$-,#$)(#�9+#2-$,8�+((-,,�#%�(2)1&$-"�@-(+',-,'(2�$-,#$)(#)%",�;%'1&�)"9$)"7-�+�(%",#)#'#)%"+1�4+$-"#+1�$)72#!���-1-42%"-��"#-$6)-;;)#2� �%@-$#+� �+1-"#-�� �-")%$� &6),%$���%5-,#)(� �)%1-"(-� �-,%'$(-� -#;%$C� L�-(!�*��0��0M!� ��2-�"%#)%"� #2+#� #2-�(%",#)#'#)%"+1� $)72#,� +##+(2)"7� #%�4+$-"#2%%&�� ,--�-!7!�� �#+"1-=� 6!� �11)"%),�� .����!�!��.��� ���D�0� L�B�0M�� +441=� )"� (%"#-,#,� @-#;--"� #;%4$)6+#-�4+$#)-,�+44-+$,�&%'@#9'1��+"&�;%'1&�-,,-"#)+11=�5-+"�+@+"&%")"7� #2-� : @-,#)"#-$-,#,� %9� #2-� (2)1&< � #-,#!� � �%;-6-$�� -6-"� )9� (',#%&=� 1)#)7+#)%"� ;-$-� #%� @-+44$%4$)+#-1=� $-(+,#� +,� (%"(-$")"7�4+$-"#,8� (%",#)#'#)%"+1� $)72#,�� ,'(2� $)72#,�;%'1&"%#�5-+"�#2+#�9+#2-$,�+$-�-"#)#1-&�#%�+((-,,�#%�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"������������� ����� ��������2��������� ��������������� ��� ������������ �%�(%",#)#'#)%"+1�$)72#� ),� #2),�+@,%1'#-!�9�(%'$,-��+�(%541-#-�-E41%$+#)%"�%9�#2),�),,'-�&-,-$6-,�)#,�%;"�+$#)(1-!

��� ���� �������� ��!���!�������!��������/��� ��������� ����������������� �

�������������B�L�B*BM�H2-$-)"+9#-$�������������������/��������K���� ��� ��>���������/�����������������"%#-�����+#�.�"!00!

23

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�*� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

6-)1-&� )",#$'5-"#� 9%$� &-"=)"7� 4+#-$"+1� +@',-� +"&� 9'$#2-$)"7� +� @)+,+7+)",#�5%#2-$,!

�0

�+(2�%9� #2-,-�4%1)()-,��+"&�#2-� #$-"&�+,�+�;2%1-��&-,-$6-,�7$-+#-$$-91-(#)%"� #2+"� ),� 4%,,)@1-� 2-$-!� � �%;-6-$�� ;2+#� ),� )54%$#+"#� 9%$4$-,-"#�4'$4%,-,�),�#2-�$-(%7")#)%"�%9�+"&�$-+,%",�9%$�#2-�$-5+$C+@1=4%;-$9'1�2%1&�%9�#2-,-�: -?'+1�4+$-"#)"7< �4$)"()41-,�%"�#2-�(%'$#,!

��

�#�+44-+$,�#2+#�#2-,-�4$)"()41-,��;2)(2�,--C�#%�-",'$-�5%$-�+((-,,�@=9+#2-$,�#%�(2)1&$-"��9+11�%"�9-$#)1-�7$%'"&!���"�-,,-"(-��#2-=�#+4�)"#%�+;)&-,4$-+&��&--41=�9-1#�1+(C�%9�9+#2-$)"7�#2$%'72%'#�%'$�('1#'$-�+"&(%'$#,!� � "=%"-� ;2%� 2+,� 1)#)7+#-&� (',#%&=� C"%;,� #2+#� )#� ),� +"'",4%C-"� :7)6-"< � )"�5%,#� (',#%&=� (%'$#,� #2+#� 9+#2-$,8� )"6%16-5-"#;)#2�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"� ),�@%#2�$+$-�+"&�6-$=� )54%$#+"#!� ��(%"(%5)#+"#+,,'54#)%"� ),� #2-� )541)()#� ,-",-� #2+#� 5%#2-$,� ,#+$#� ;)#2� +"� '"9+)$+&6+"#+7-�� 4$-,'5+@1=� @-(+',-� #2-=� 9)#� %'$� )"#')#)6-� )5+7-� %9:4+$-"#�< � +"&�+$-������� #%�@-�4$)5+$=� +"& %$� :"+#'$+1< � 4+$-"#,!�2-�(%5@)"-&�-99-(#�%9� #2-,-�'",4%C-"�+,,'54#)%",� ),� #2+#�(',#%&=(%'$#,��;2)1-�@-1)-6)"7�#2-=�+$-�5-$-1=�9'$#2-$)"7�4+$-"#+1�: -?'+1)#=�<"%#�)"9$-?'-"#1=�7)6-�9+#2-$,8�(1+)5,�+"&�$-?'-,#,�7$-+#-$�;-)72#�#2+"5%#2-$,8!

�.

�"�,2%$#��#2-�F'&)()+1�-542+,),�%"�@%#2�4+$-"#+1�-?'+1)#=�+"&�9+#2-$)"6%16-5-"#� )"� (',#%&=� ),� 4%;-$9'11=� &$)6-"� @%#2� @=� 4$%(-,,� +"&,'@,#+"#)6-� "%$5,�� ;2)(2� 9'-1� $-,),#+"(-� #%� (%",)&-$)"7� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-� +,� &-#-$5)"+#)6-� %9� (',#%&=� %$� 6),)#+#)%"!� � �2-� "-E#� #2$--�+$#,� 1%%C�5%$-� ,4-()9)(+11=� +#� #2-� %,#-",)@1=� "-'#$+1� $+#)%"+1-,� #2+#+11%;� (%'$#,� #%� 9'$#2-$� #2),� &-,)$-� 9%$� -?'+1� 4+$-"#)"7� @=5+$7)"+1)3)"7� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� (1+)5,� )"� (+,-,� ;2-$-� (',#%&=� %$6),)#+#)%"� ),� +#� ),,'-!� � �2-$-� +$-� +#� 1-+,#� #2$--� :"-'#$+1< � #-"-#,� #2+#

�0� ���� (������!�������� ���"����"� ���� � � � ��� �����"%#-��*�� +#�0��D�0A��)(2+$&�'��%#-���������������� ������%���� ��"� ������ ��� ���#�*��"������������ ����������!��/!� ��!� �! !� ����� �.�� L0��0MA� �2-$)� �!� >%%&�� �%55-"#�� *�� %���� ��� ������ �����������#��� ����������������1�������� ���0�����!��!!��!����!�����������D���L�BB.M!

��! �+$-"#+1� 1)-"+#)%"� �="&$%5-� 2+,� @--"� ;)&-1=� &-@'"C-&� +,� 1+(C)"7� +"=,()-"#)9)(� @+,),�� 5+C)"7� )#,� )"($-&)@1=� $+4)&� +"&� 6)$#'+11=� '")6-$,+1� +&%4#)%"� )"� #2-(%'$#,�+11�#2-�5%$-�,#$)C)"7!������������"%#-����!

�.� ����>���������/�����������������"%#-�����+#�.�L?'%#)"7����!�������/��

������������"%#-�����+#��B���0M�L:>2-"�9+#2-$,�(%"#-,#�(',#%&=��5%#2-$,�+$-�2-1&�#%+� &)99-$-"#� +"&� 2)72-$� ,#+"&+$&� #2+"� 9+#2-$,!< MA� ���������� ����� "%#-� ��� +#� ���L,#+#)"7� #2+#� #2-�5-$-� +(#� %9� ,--C)"7� (',#%&=� ),� #$-+#-&� +,� 4$)5+� 9+()-� -6)&-"(-� %94+#-$"+1I @'#�"%#�5+#-$"+1I 9)#"-,,M!���"�#2-��),#$)(#�%9��%1'5@)+��#2-$-�),�+1,%�+")"#-",-� ,-",)#)6)#=� #%� #2-� 1+(C� %9� 9$)(+"D5-$)(+"� 9+#2-$� 9)7'$-,� )"� #2-� 4%%$(%55'")#)-,�%9�(%1%$��;2)(2� ,#$%"71=� $-)"9%$(-,� #2-� $-1'(#+"(-� #%� $-F-(#� +"=� 9+#2-$;2%�),�+(#)6-1=�,--C)"7��@=�1)#)7+#)"7�(',#%&=�%$�6),)#+#)%"��+�4+$-"#)"7�$%1-!

�$%")(+11=��#2),�5%&-$"�-542+,),�%"�9+#2-$,8�$%1-,�+44-+$,�#%�@-�$-(+4)#'1+#)"7��)"�#2-"+5-� %9� 5%&-$"� 6+1'-,� %9� -?'+1)#=� +"&� 9+)$"-,,�� #2-� %1&� $'1-� #2+#� 7+6-� 9+#2-$,+@,%1'#-� : 4$%4-$#=< � $)72#,� #%� (',#%&=�%9� #2-)$� (2)1&$-"�&)6%$(-!� � ���� ���������� �-)72�%%&5+$C��(����%����� �� ��%�������#��� � ���������� ������������ ����"������� ��(������!��������"������0�>!��!��!����!�0����0�0�L�BBBM!

24

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �*�

(%'$#,�)"6%C-�)"�$-,4%"&)"7�#%�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+11-7+#)%",�� 9)$,#��+,C-4#)(),5� #%;+$&� #2-� 41+',)@)1)#=� %9� #2-� +11-7+#)%",A� ,-(%"&�� +"+,,'54#)%"� #2+#� #2-� #$'#2�5+=�@-�'"C"%;+@1-��@'#� #2+#� )"� +"=� (+,-#2-� 4$%@1-5� ),� 5'#'+1A� +"&� #2)$&�� +"� +,,'54#)%"� #2+#� +"=� 4+,#&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ),� '1#)5+#-1=� )$$-1-6+"#� #%� #2-� 9'#'$-D%$)-"#-&(',#%&=� &-(),)%"!� � �2-�5-(2+"),5,� @=� ;2)(2� #2-,-� @-1)-9,� %4-$+#-�+"&�#2-�9+11+()-,�'4%"�;2)(2�#2-=�$-,#��+$-�&),(',,-&�@-1%;!���#�,2%'1&@-� "%#-&� #2+#�� ;2)1-� -+(2� ),� &-,($)@-&� )"� ,-?'-"(-�� #2-=� +$-� "%#)"#$)",)(+11=�&),#)"(#�(%"(-4#,��@'#�$+#2-$�)&-+,�;2)(2�%6-$1+4�)"�5+"=$-,4-(#,!

�"-�1+,#�(+6-+#�),�+44$%4$)+#-��;)#2�#2-�-E(-4#)%"�%9�#2-�&),(',,)%"%9�7-"&-$�@)+,�L�������+$#�/!0M����,--C�#%�#+C-�#2-,-�$+#)%"+1-,�+#�9+(-6+1'-� +"&� #%� $-,4%"&� #%� #2-5� %@F-(#)6-1=� +"&� +"+1=#)(+11=!� � >2)1--1-5-"#,�%9�7-"&-$�@)+,�(+"�@-�9%'"&�)"�5+"=�%9�#2-�+"+1=,-,�;2)(2&),(%'"#�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-��5+"=U)9�"%#�5%,#UF'&7-,�+$-�,#$'771)"7#%�(%4-�+,�@-,#�#2-=�(+"�;)#2�-E#$-5-1=�&)99)('1#��&),#'$@)"7�5+#-$)+1+"&� 6-$=� 4+)"9'1� (2%)(-,!� � �2-� 9%11%;)"7� &),(',,)%"� $-,4%"&,%@F-(#)6-1=� #%� #2-,-� 4-$,4-(#)6-,� )"� #2-� 2%4-� #2+#� +� &),4+,,)%"+#-&),(',,)%"�;)11� 9+()1)#+#-�7$-+#-$�'"&-$,#+"&)"7��+"&�5%$-�4$%#-(#)6-%'#(%5-,�9%$�(2)1&$-"�+"&�4+$-"#,�;2%�2+6-�,'99-$-&�+@',-!

�� ����� ���� ��"�������� ����� ��� ���!������������� ���

�2-� 7'19� @-#;--"� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +&6%(+#-,� +"&� #2%,-L4$-&%5)"+"#1=�F'&7-,�+"&�(%'$#D+44%)"#-&�9%$-",)(�-6+1'+#%$,M�;2%$-,),#� #2-�(2+$+(#-$)3+#)%"�%9� 9+#2-$,�+,�@+##-$-$,�;2%�+$-�&+"7-$%',#%�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"��),�&-9)"-&�)"�1+$7-�4+$#�@=�+&6%(+#-,8�;)11)"7"-,,�#%@-1)-6-� ;%5-"8,� (1+)5,� L@%#2� +@%'#� $),C� #%� #2-5,-16-,� +"&� #%� #2-(2)1&$-"M�� +"&� #2-� (%'$#,8� ,C-4#)(),5� #%;+$&� #2%,-� ,+5-� (1+)5,!�2-,-�9'"&+5-"#+11=�(%"#$+&)(#%$=�,#+$#)"7�4-$,4-(#)6-,�+$-�9'-1-&�@=&)99-$)"7�+##)#'&-,� #%;+$&� #2$--� (%$-� -1-5-"#,� %9� 9+(#'+1� +,,-,,5-"#;2)(2�,2+4-�#2-�41+=-$,8�F'&75-"#,�)"�#2-,-�(+,-,��L)M�#2-�5-+")"7�%9"-'#$+1)#=�� L))M� 7-"&-$� @)+,�� +"&� L)))M� &-5-+"%$,� %9� 6)(#)5,� +"&4-$4-#$+#%$,!

6� *��+����������-�� ���� �

�-9-"&-$,� %9� F'&)()+1� +"&� -6+1'+#%$� :"-'#$+1)#=< � %9#-"� +,,-$#� #2+#"-;,� $-4%$#,� %$� ,'$6-=,� %9� %"1=� %"-� 4+$#=� #%� +� (+,-�� ,'(2� +,� #2->-11-,1-=� ,'$6-=�� (+""%#� @-� #+C-"� +#� 9+(-� 6+1'-�� +"&� #2+#� #2-� (+,-&-(),)%",�($)#)?'-&�-+$1)-$

���5+=�;-11�2+6-�@--"�(%$$-(#�� @-(+',-�;-

(+"�"-6-$�C"%;�;2+#�#2-�#$'#2�),�)"�+"=�7)6-"�(+,-�;)#2%'#�2-+$)"7�+11

��� ���������"%#-,�.�D���+"&�+((%54+"=)"7�#-E#!

25

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�*0 ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

#2-�-6)&-"(-�%$�+#�1-+,#�$-6)-;)"7�#2-�#$+",($)4#,!�����'$#2-$5%$-��#2-=

;)11� +$7'-� #2+#� "-)#2-$� F'&7-,� "%$� -6+1'+#%$,� ,2%'1&� +44$%+(2� +"=7)6-"�(+,-�;)#2�4$-,'54#)%",�+@%'#�;2%� ),� #-11)"7� #2-� #$'#2!� �>2)1-9+()+11=� )"+$7'+@1-�� #2-$-� +$-� #;%� 9+11+()-,� )"� #2),� 9%$5� %9� ,#'&)-&"-'#$+1)#=!� � �)$,#�� )#� &-")-,� #2-� ;%$C)"7� +,,'54#)%",�� %$� : 1)9--E4-$)-"(-�< � #2+#� )"-6)#+@1=� (%1%$� +"=� -6+1'+#%$� %$� F'&7-8,)"#-$4$-#+#)%"� %9� #2-� -6)&-"(-!� � �%$� )",#+"(-�� #2%,-� ;2%� +$-4$-&),4%,-&� #%� @-1)-6-� #2+#� ;%5-"� %9#-"� 9+@$)(+#-� %$� -E+77-$+#-&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�+11-7+#)%",�+$-� 1)C-1=� #%�@-�2+$&-$� #%�4-$,'+&-�%9#2-� #$'#2� %9� ,'(2� +11-7+#)%",�� #2+"� #2%,-� ;2%� +$-� 4$-&),4%,-&� #%@-1)-6-� #2+#�5-"� 9$-?'-"#1=� @-+#� ;%5-"!� � �-,4)#-� #2-� #-"&-"(=� %94,=(2%1%7)(+1�-6+1'+#%$,�#%�)"6%C-�+�4'$-1=�: ,()-"#)9)(< �@+,),�9%$�#2-)$%4)")%",�L%9#-"�@=�$-1=)"7�%"�4,=(2%1%7)(+1�#-,#,M��#2-�$-+1)#=�),�#2+#�)#),�"%#�4%,,)@1-�9%$�2'5+"�@-)"7,�#%�-$+&)(+#-�#2-)$�1)9-�-E4-$)-"(-�%$4-$,4-(#)6-� 9$%5� #2-)$� )"#-$4$-#+#)%",� %9� 9+(#,!� � �-(%"&�� )",#-+&� %97-"')"-� "-'#$+1)#=�� ;2)(2� ),� $-(-4#)6-� #%� )"9%$5+#)%"�� 5+"=� F'&7-,+"&� -6+1'+#%$,� +(#'+11=� -E2)@)#� ,C-4#)(),5� %$� &),@-1)-9� #%;+$&� +@',-+11-7+#)%",��;2)(2�),�,%5-;2+#�$-,),#+"#�#%�(%"#$+$=�)"4'#!

��

�,� ,'(2� ,C-4#)(),5� ;+$$+"#-&J� � /%#2� -E),#)"7� ,#+#),#)(,� +"&?'+1)#+#)6-� C"%;1-&7-� +@%'#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�%99-$� ,%5-� %@F-(#)6-7')&+"(-!� � �'$$-"#� '"&-$,#+"&)"7,� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ,'77-,#,%5-#2)"7� 5%$-� #2+"� #2-� 5-$-� 4%,,)@)1)#=� #2+#�� )"� +"=� 7)6-"$-1+#)%",2)4��+11-7+#)%",�%9�6)%1-"(-�5+=�%$�5+=�"%#�@-�#$'-��;-�C"%;-54)$)(+11=� #2+#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ),� ,'$4$),)"71=� ;)&-,4$-+&

�*� +"&

��� ���� �%5@+$&)�� ����� "%#-� �B�� +#� �+$#� 0� L)"&)(+#)"7� #2+#� #2-� �+,,+(2',-##,

(%'$#,�+$-��"%#�,'$4$),)"71=��($)#)(+1�%9�#2-�>-11-,1-=�,#'&=�@-(+',-�)#�%"1=�)"#-$6)-;-&#2-�5%#2-$,�� +"&� (%"&'(#-&� +� (%$$%@%$+#)6-� &%('5-"#� $-6)-;� )"� %"1=� 0�Q� %9� #2-(+,-,M!� ��=�'"&-$,#+"&)"7� %9� #2-� : 4$%D"-'#$+1)#=< � 6)-;� 2+,� @--"� 2%"-&� )"� 4+$#� )"&),(',,)%",�%"�-1-(#$%")(�1),#�,-$6-,��)"(1'&)"7�#2-�:�����D��< �1),#!

��� �����)"-5+"�������"%#-�00��+#�0�*D�B�L$-6)-;)"7��������������������

�����P������������������������������������������������������������

���������>�������/�������� ������L�%@-$#� !��-6=�-&!���BB*MM�L: H�K2-� �)���)���� 5����� +44-+$,� #%� +"#)()4+#-� #2+#� &),@-1)-9� ),� #%� @-� "%#� %"1=� -E4-(#-&� @'#� +1,%-"(%'$+7-&�+,�#2-�)")#)+1�F'&)()+1�$-,4%",-!< M!

�*! �2-�+#)%"+1��",#)#'#-,�%9� ',#)(-�9%'"&�)"��BB*�#2+#��0Q�%9�;%5-"�,'$6-=-&,+)&�#2-=�;-$-�42=,)(+11=�+,,+'1#-&�+,�+�(2)1&�%$�+&'1#A�)#�-,#)5+#-&�#2+#�+44$%E)5+#-1=�!B� 5)11)%"� ;%5-"� +$-� +,,+'1#-&� @=� )"#)5+#-,� -+(2� =-+$� )"� #2-� �")#-&� �#+#-,!� � ����������� ���G�������������8�� ���!���� ���!�����!���� ���!����������!�!����8����� ���!���������������������������P���������������������

>����� ������� ����� ����������������������>���� ������� 0� L�BB*M!L�#�),�;%$#2�"%#)"7�#2+#��(%"#$+$=�#%�#2-�+&5%")#)%",�@=�($)#)(,�%9� #2-�$-(-"#�$-4%$#,L>-11-,1-=�/����+"&��>D�+1)9%$")+M�;2)(2�;-$-�@+,-&�%"�;%5-"8,�: #-,#)5%"=�<#2),�2)721=� $-7+$&-&� : %@F-(#)6-�< � : ,()-"#)9)(�< �-54)$)(+1� $-,-+$(2�+1,%�',-,�;%5-"8,,-19D&-,($)4#)%",� +,� #2-� @+,),� 9%$� &),(-$")"7� -54)$)(+1� 9+(#!M� � �#2-$� $-,-+$(2� 2+,&-5%",#$+#-&�#2+#�;)9-D@-+#)"7�$-,'1#,�)"�5%$-�)"F'$)-,�$-?')$)"7�5-&)(+1�#$-+#5-"##2+"�$+4-��+'#%�+(()&-"#,�+"&�5'77)"7,�(%5@)"-&!�������6+"��#+$C�G�""-��1)#($+9#�!�������� ����� � �� ��� ��� ��� ��/���� ��� ������ �������� 0B*� L�)"(-"#� /!� �+"�+,1-##� -#� +1!� -&,!�� �B**M!� � �2-� �'4$-5-� �%'$#� 2+,� +(C"%;1-&7-&� ,#'&)-,� %"4$-6+1-"(-� ;2)(2� : ,'77-,#� #2+#� 9$%5� %"-D9)9#2� #%� %"-D#2)$&� %9� +11� ;%5-"� ;)11� @-

26

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �*�

#2+#�)#�),�4-$4-#$+#-&�5%,#�%9#-"�@=�5+1-,�+7+)",#�9-5+1-,!�B���'$#2-$�

;-�C"%;�#2+#�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�),�5%$-�4$-6+1-"#�)"�#2-�$-1+#)%",2)4,%9�4+$#)-,�;2%�+$-�&)6%$()"7��+"&�,#)11�5%$-�(%55%"I ;)#2�-,#)5+#-,%9�'4�#%���QI +5%"7�(%'41-,�)"�(%"91)(#�%6-$�6),)#+#)%"�%$�(',#%&=!

*�

�%$-%6-$�� (%"#$+$=� #%� #2-� +,,'54#)%",� %9� 5+"=� -6+1'+#%$,� +"&F'&7-,��+,�@-,#�;-�(+"�&-#-$5)"-��9+@$)(+#-&�(1+)5,�%9�+@',-�+$-�$+$-!�2),�?'-,#)%"�2+,�@--"�-E+5)"-&�;)#2�$-,4-(#�#%�(2)1&�,-E'+1�+@',-+11-7+#)%",!� � �-$-�� &-,4)#-� #2-� 4-$,),#-"#� @-1)-9� +5%"7� F'&7-,� +"&-6+1'+#%$,� #2+#� (2)1&� ,-E'+1� +@',-� ),� 9$-?'-"#1=� 9+@$)(+#-&�� ,#'&)-,2+6-�(%",),#-"#1=�,2%;"�#2+#�9+@$)(+#-&�+11-7+#)%",�+$-�?')#-�$+$-!���%$)",#+"(-�� +� "+#)%"+1� ,#'&=� %9� B���� (%"#-,#-&� (',#%&=� +"&� 6),)#+#)%"(+,-,�@=�#2-�,,%()+#)%"�%9��+5)1=�+"&��%"()1)+#)%"��%'$#,�(%"(1'&-&#2+#� %"1=� 0Q� %9� #2-� #%#+1� (%"#+)"-&� (2)1&� ,-E'+1� +@',-� +11-7+#)%",���Q� %9� #2%,-� +11-7+#)%",� ;-$-� 6+1)&�� ��Q� ;-$-� )"(%$$-(#�� L)!-!�� 1-,,#2+"� �Q� %9� +11� (%"#-,#-&� (+,-,� $-6)-;-&M�� +"&� ��Q� ;-$-)"&-#-$5)"+#-!� ��"1=��.Q�;-$-� 9%'"&� #%�@-� )"#-"#)%"+11=� 9+1,-!

*�� �

5%$-� $-(-"#� -E2+',#)6-� ,#'&=� %9� (2)1&� ,-E'+1� +@',-� +11-7+#)%",� )"(',#%&=� (+,-,� @=� ������� �� ��� +������� 4$%9-,,%$� %9� �%()+1� >%$C�+#21--"� �%'1@%$"� �+11-$� 9%'"&� #2+#� ��Q� %9� #2-� +11-7+#)%",� ;-$-9+(#'+11=�#$'-!

*0

>2)1-� #2-$-� +44-+$� #%� @-� "%� -54)$)(+1� ,#'&)-,� %9� 9+@$)(+#)%"� %9

42=,)(+11=� +,,+'1#-&�@=� +�4+$#"-$�%$� -ED4+$#"-$� &'$)"7� #2-)$� 1)9-#)5-!�!�!�!< � ��1+""-&�+$-"#2%%&� 6!� �+,-=�� ���� �!�!� *���� *B�DB0� L�BB0M� L?'%#)"7� �� ������� �

������������������������������>������L�BB�MM!

�B� �����!����������������8���������������������������������������

����������*��L�BB�M�H2-$-)"+9#-$���������K�L:�-,4)#-� #2-�(%"#-"#)%"�@=� ,%5-$-,-+$(2-$,�#2+#�;%5-"�+$-�+,�6)%1-"#�+,�5-"��(1)")(+1� ,#'&)-,� ,2%;�#2+#�5-"�5%$-9$-?'-"#1=� +$-� #2-� +@',-$,� +"&� #2+#� ;%5-"� 5%$-� 9$-?'-"#1=� +$-� #2-� 6)(#)5,� %96)%1-"(-�)"�#2-�9+5)1=!< M!���2-��-4%$#8,�9)"&)"7�),�,'44%$#-&�@=�"'5-$%',�,#+#),#)(+1,'$6-=,!���2-��")#-&��#+#-,�/'$-+'�%9� ',#)(-��#+#),#)(,�)"&)(+#-�#2+#�*�Q�%9�)"()&-"#,%9�6)(#)5)3+#)%"�@=� )"#)5+#-�4+$#"-$,�+$-�+7+)",#�;%5-"A� #2+#�;%5-"�+$-� 9)6-� #)5-,5%$-�1)C-1=�#%�-E4-$)-"(-�6)%1-"(-�9$%5�+"�)"#)5+#-�#2+"�5-"A�+"&�#2+#�#2$--�%'#�%99%'$�5'$&-$�6)(#)5,�)"��BB*�C)11-&�@=�#2-)$�)"#)5+#-�4+$#"-$,�;-$-�;%5-"!�����������

�����������G�����>�����������������������������D0�L/'$-+'�%9� ',#!�#+#!��4-()+1��-4!��� ���*0.����+=�0���M!���'$6-=,�%9��")#-&��#+#-,�+"&��'$%4-+"4%1)(-� +"&� (%'$#� $-(%$&,� (%",),#-"#1=� ,2%;� #2+#� ;%5-"� 5+C-� '4� B�DB�Q� %9� #2-6)(#)5,� %9� $-4%$#-&� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-!� � ���� �!� �5-$,%"� �%@+,2� -#� +1��*�� +� � ����'��������� ������+��� ���!����������B����!����/�����������DB��L�BB0M!

*�� ����/������G���������������"%#-�����+#��0��

*�� ���� ��8� ��� ��!� G� ���������� ���!�� ��������� ��� ��O��� /���� �

�����������������������������������������������0�������L�B**MA��+5-1+/'$C-��(� �"������+���������"� ���� ��������� ����>���8����>����(#!�00��0��0����������� � � 2##4� ;;;!;%5-",-"-;,!%$7 +$#)(1-!(95 &=" +)& ��*�A� ��� ���� +"(=�2%-""-,� G� �+#$)()+� �!� �F+&-"�� *�� &' �� ,� -� ���,� ���� !����� �� ��� ��'���� ���������� ���� ��� "� ���:!�� � ���� ��� ��� �.� ������ /���� G� ������� ����� ��0D��L�BB*M!� � ���� ���������� >%%&�� �����"%#-� �0�� +#� ���.� "!�.� L()#)"7� +&&)#)%"+1� ,%'$(-,&),(',,)"7�#2),�?'-,#)%"M!

*0� �����%5@+$&)�������"%#-��B��+#��+$#�.�L()#)"7�+�,#'&=�@=��+#21--"��%'1@%$"�+11-$M!

27

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�*. ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�*�� �$!� �6+"� �#+$C�� +� ;)&-1=� 4'@1),2-&� +"&

$-(%7")3-&�+'#2%$�+"&�$-,-+$(2-$� )"� #2-� 9)-1&�%9�&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�2+,� #-,#)9)-&� #2+#� #2-$-� ),� "%� &%('5-"#-&� )",#+"(-� %9� +� ;%5+"9+@$)(+#)"7�+�2),#%$=�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-��+"&�#2+#�2-�)"&-4-"&-"#1=C"%;,�%9�"%"-!

*.���"�#2-�(%"#$+$=��;%5-"�#-"&�#%�5)")5)3-�+"&�&-"=

+@',-� ;2)1-� '"&-$,#+#)"7� #2-� +5%'"#� +"&� ,-6-$)#=� %9� +@',-!*�

>%5-"8,� $-1'(#+"(-� #%� $-6-+1� #2+#� #2-=� 2+6-�@--"� +@',-&� ),� ;)&-1=$-(%7")3-&!

*�� ��2),� '"(%"#$%6-$,)+1� #$'#2� ),� 2+$&� #%� ,?'+$-�;)#2� #2-

@-1)-9�4$-6+1-"#�)"�#2-�1-7+1�,=,#-5�#2+#�;%5-"�)"�1)#)7+#)%"�L;2-#2-$+,� 41+)"#)99,� %$� &-9-"&+"#,M� 9$-?'-"#1=� 9+@$)(+#-� ,'(2� (1+)5,!

*�� � �"

,2%$#�� 5'(2� %9� #2-� ,C-4#)(),5� #%;+$&� ;%5-"8,� (1+)5,� %9� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-� +"&� (2)1&� +@',-� +44-+$,� #%� @-� @+,-&� %"� +"� )"+(('$+#-'"&-$,#+"&)"7� %9� #2-� $-+1� 4$-6+1-"(-� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +5%"7(%'41-,�-"7+7-&�)"�(%"#-,#-&�(',#%&=�1)#)7+#)%"!

�)"+11=��;2-"�"%#� &),5),,)"7� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� (1+)5,� +1#%7-#2-$�(%'$#,� +"&� -6+1'+#%$,� %9#-"� $-F-(#� ,'(2� (1+)5,� +,� -E+77-$+#-&� %$)",'99)()-"#!

**� ��%;-6-$��)"�5+"=�(+,-,��#2-�6)-;�#2+#�+@',-�),�5-$-1=

*�! �'(2� ,#'&)-,� +$-� 9'"&+5-"#+11=� )"&-#-$5)"+#-� )"� #2+#� +"=� $-,-+$(2-$� ;2%

,--C,� #%� 5-+,'$-� $+#-,� %9� 9+@$)(+#)%"� 9+(-,� #2-� ,+5-� &)99)('1#=� +,� F'&7-,� +"&-6+1'+#%$,�� #2-$-� ),� "%� 4'$-1=� : %@F-(#)6-< � 5-+",� %9� 6-$)9=)"7� ,'(2� +11-7+#)%",!�%;-6-$��#2-�$-+1)#=�),�#2+#�5%,#�(%'$#,�+"&�-6+1'+#%$,�&%�"%#�%$&)"+$)1=�(%",)&-$�+11-E),#)"7�-6)&-"(-�%9�+@',-A�2-"(-�)#�),�?')#-�4%,,)@1-�#2+#�+�$-,-+$(2-$�;%'1&�@-�+@1-#%�$-+(2�5%$-�,+#),9+(#%$=�+"&�: %@F-(#)6-< �(%"(1',)%",�@+,-&�%"�+�#2%$%'72�9+(#'+1)"6-,#)7+#)%"!�������$--&5+"�������"%#-����L&),(',,)"7�#2-�)"+&-?'+(=�%9�9+(#D9)"&)"7)"�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�(+,-,MA�/������G���������������"%#-�����+#��0�!

*.! �2),� #-,#)5%"=� ;+,� 4$-,-"#-&� )"� �+,-� 0!� � ���� ����� �+$#� �!/!� � �#+$C� "%;+541)9)-,�%"� #2+#�4%)"#� #%� ,+=� #2+#�;2-"�%"-�'"&-$,#+"&,� #2+#�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-� ),&-9)"-&� @=� +� : 4+##-$"� %9� (%-$()6-� (%"#$%1�< � )",#-+&� %9� 5-$-� &),($-#-� )"()&-"#,� %96)%1-"(-�� )#� @-(%5-,�5'(2�2+$&-$� #%� 9+@$)(+#-!� � �D5+)1� 9$%5� �6+"� �#+$C�� ,,%()+#-�$%9-,,%$���-4+$#5-"#�%9��'@1)(�&5)"),#$+#)%"���'#7-$,��")6-$,)#=D-;+$C��#%� %+"�-)-$�L�-(!�0���0��0���0�.�����M�H2-$-)"+9#-$��#+$C��D5+)1K!

*�! �-4%$#�%9��6+"��#+$C��9$%5��+,-�0�L '"-�0����BB�M�L%"�9)1-�;)#2�+'#2%$M!

*�� �����)"-5+"�������"%#-�00��+#�0�*�L"%#)"7�#2+#�:;%5-"�+$-�$-1'(#+"#�#%�$+),-4+##-$",�%9�&%5-,#)(�+@',-�#%�#2-)$�1+;=-$,��1-#�+1%"-�#2-�F'&7-,�+"&�%#2-$,�;2%�4+,,F'&75-"#�%"�#2-5�)"�$-7+$&�#%�(',#%&=�4-#)#)%",< M�L()#)"7��+2%"-=�������"%#-��BM!

*�� ���� %"��!��%"#-��3�� ��"�����������'�����������4#� ������� ���� ��+�� ��3��� �%����������������)� ����������B�����!� ���!�G�/���!��.���0�L�BB0M�L;$)#)"7#2+#� : �� +5�"%#� +;+$-�%9� +� ,)"71-� -54)$)(+1� ,#'&=� #2+#� 2+,� &%('5-"#-&� #2+#� )"� 9+(#9+1,-�(+,-,�%9�,-E'+1�+@',-�+$-�5%$-�1)C-1=�#%�+$),-�)"�&)6%$(- (',#%&=�(+,-,< M!���"�9+(#�)"�5=�-E4-$)-"(-�;)#2�5=�(1)-"#,�� +11�%9�;2%5�;-$-� ,--C)"7� 1-7+1�4$%#-(#)%"��5%,#;-$-� ����� �� � #%� 9'11=� +(C"%;1-&7-� #2-� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� #2-=� 2+&� ,'99-$-&�� +"&5+"=�&)&�"%#�$-(%7")3-�1%;D1-6-1�6)%1-"(-�L-!7!��2)##)"7��,2%6)"7M�+,�;%$#2=�%9�"%#-!�%$-%6-$�� (%"#$+$=� #%� #2-� ,#-$-%#=4-� %9� 6-"7-9'1� 5%#2-$,� +5%"7� (',#%&=� (%'$#,�5+"=�%9�5=�@+##-$-&�(1)-"#,�;-$-�6-$=�$-1'(#+"#�#%�+(C"%;1-&7-�#2+#�#2-)$�@+##-$-$,4%,-&�$),C,�#%�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"!

**� ���,��������"�$-��',#%&=�%9�N)+������!�!0&�..B�L�+,,!�44!��#!�0���M�L,#+#)"7#2+#� #;%� 4$)%$� 4$%#-(#)%"� %$&-$,� +"&� 4-"&)"7� +,,+'1#� (2+$7-� &%� "%#� )"&)(+#-� +:4+##-$"� %$� ,-$)%',� )"()&-"#< � +,� $-?')$-&� @=� ,#+#'#-MA� �+5)1#%"� 6!� �+5)1#%"�� **��!>!0&� ���� L�%!� 44!� �BB.M� L(%55-"#)"7� #2+#� #;%� )"()&-"#,� %6-$� #;-"#=� =-+$5+$$)+7-�&%�"%#�($-+#-�,#+#'#%$)1=�$-?')$-&�: 4+##-$"< �%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-MA�/$%;"�6!/$%;"��*����!0&�.����.�B�L�C1+!��#!�44!��BB�M�L2%1&)"7�+�9+#2-$8,�,2%6)"7�+�5%#2-$

28

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �*�

:5)"%$< � %$� : -E+77-$+#-&< � )7"%$-,� @%#2� #2-� @-##-$D&%('5-"#-&42-"%5-"%"� %9� 5)")5)3+#)%"� +"&� &-")+1�� +"&� #2-� $-+1)#=� #2+#&%5-,#)(�+@',-�,4+",�+�;)&-�,4-(#$'5�%9�@-2+6)%$,�L+"&�#2+#�6)(#)5,%9#-"�$-6-+1� 1-,,-$� )"()&-"#,�@-9%$-� #2-=�&),(1%,-� #2-�5%,#� #$+'5+#)(%"-,M!� �%#�+11�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-� $-,'1#� )"�@$'),-,�%$�@$%C-"�@%"-,!�%5-�9%$5,�%9�+@',-�+$-�4$-&%5)"+"#1=�,-E'+1!���-#�#2-�2+115+$C,�%9+"�+@',)6-�$-1+#)%",2)4��"+5-1=�#2-�4%;-$��(%"#$%1��&%5)"+#)%"�+"&,#+#-�%9�9-+$��-6-"�;)#2%'#�5'(2�,-6-$-�42=,)(+1�6)%1-"(-��5+=�,#)11�@-4$%9%'"&1=�&+5+7)"7!

*B��

>2)1-� (%'$#,� +$-� ?')(C� #%� &),(%'"#� 5%#2-$,8� (1+)5,� %9� @+##-$)"7�#2-=�#-"&�)541)()#1=�#%�%6-$D6+1'-�9+#2-$,8�(1+)5,�%9�&-,)$-�9%$�(',#%&=!�#� ),�"%;�;-11D-,#+@1),2-&� #2+#�5+"=�@+##-$-$,� ,--C�(',#%&=�4$)5+$)1=+,� +"� -E#-",)%"� %9� #2-)$� 4%;-$� +"&� (%"#$%1� %6-$� +"&� +@',-� %9� #2-5%#2-$!

B�� � �2-� 5-$)(+"� �,=(2%1%7)(+1� ,,%()+#)%"� 9%'"&� #2+#

@+##-$-$,� +$-� #;)(-� +,� 1)C-1=� #%� (%"#-,#� (',#%&=� +,� "%"D@+##-$-$,�� +"&+$-�5%$-�1)C-1=�#%�(%"#-,#�(',#%&=�%9�,%",!

B����"�+&&)#)%"�#%�,--C)"7�#%

)54%,-� #2-)$� $)7)&� 6)-;,� %9� 7-"&-$� $%1-,� %"� #2-)$� (2)1&$-"�� 5+"=@+##-$-$,�,--�;)"")"7�(',#%&=�%6-$�#2-�5%#2-$�+,�+�4%;-$9'1�5-+",�%96)"&)(+#)"7�#2-)$�5%$+1�+"&�9'"(#)%"+1�,'4-$)%$)#=!

B0��,�),�&),(',,-&�)"

7$-+#-$�&-#+)1�)"��+$#����!/!���6)(#)5,�+"&�4-$4-#$+#%$,8�&-5-+"%$,�)"

$%'721=�+7+)",#�+�&%%$��,5+,2)"7�(+$�;)"&%;,�%9�+�5+"�2-�@-1)-6-&�,2-�;+,�,--)"7�+"&�$-4-+#-&�#2$-+#,�%9�6)%1-"(-�&%�"%#�(%",#)#'#-�: %"7%)"7�&%5-,#)(�+@',-< �'"&-$,#+#'#-M!����������(+,-,�()#-&������"%#-���!

*B� �����#+$C��1�2����� ������������ ������������"%#-�����+#�B*�!

�2=,)(+1�6)%1-"(-�5+=�"%#�@-�#2-�5%,#�,)7")9)(+"#�9+(#%$�+@%'#�5%,#�@+##-$)"7$-1+#)%",2)4,�!�!�!� #2-=� 2+6-� @--"� ,'@F-(#-&� #%� +"� %"7%)"7� ,#$+#-7=� %9)"#)5)&+#)%"�� ),%1+#)%"�� +"&� (%"#$%1�!�!�!� #2-� '")?'-� 4$%9)1-� %9� R#2-� @+##-$-&;%5+"8�+$),-,�+,�5'(2�9$%5�#2-�&-4$)6+#)%"�%9�1)@-$#=�)541)-&�@=�(%-$()%"�+,)#�&%-,�9$%5�6)%1-"(-�)"&'(-&�#$+'5+!<

���

B�� ����+#������L:�6-$=�+,4-(#�%9�#2),�(+,-�)"&)(+#-&�#2+#��+6)&8,�5+F%$�)"#-$-,#�)"(',#%&=�;+,�#%�-E#-"&�#2-�(%"#$%1�2-�2+&�($-+#-&�#2$%'72�6)%1-"(-�+"&�;)#2&$+;+1�)"#2-� 5+$$)+7-� )"#%� #2-� 4%,#D5+$)#+1� 4-$)%&�� +"� -E+541-� %9� R#+"7-"#)+1� ,4%',-+@',-!8< MA� ��� ������������� �����"%#-� �B�� +#� .�� L:>2-"� +� (%'41-�&)6%$(-,�� #2-1-7+1� ,=,#-5� 5+=� @-(%5-� +� ,=5@%1)(� @+##1-7$%'"&� %"� ;2)(2� #2-� 5+1-� @+##-$-$(%"#)"'-,� 2),� +@',-!< M!� � �2-,-� 9)"&)"7,� +@%'#� @+##-$-$,8� 9$-?'-"#� ',-� %9� #2-� (%'$#,=,#-5�#%�-E#-"&�#2-)$�4%;-$�%6-$�#2-)$�9%$5-$�4+$#"-$,�+$-�$-)"9%$(-&�@=�#2-�$-,'1#,%9� +"� )"D&-4#2� ,#'&=�%9�&)6%$(-&� L@'#�"%#�"-(-,,+$)1=� +@',)6-M� 9+#2-$,� )"�-;��%$C�#+#-�@=��-$$=�$-"&-11!� �$-"&-118,�9)"&)"7,�2+6-�@--"�(2+$+(#-$)3-&�+,�-1'()&+#)"7(%55%"� +##)#'&-,� %9� &)6%$(-&� 9+#2-$,�� )"(1'&)"7� : +� (%",),#-"#� ,2+$-&� 5+,('1)"),#&),(%'$,-�!�!�!� ;)#2� -542+,),� %"� #2-� (-"#$+1� )54%$#+"(-� %9� 9+#2-$,8� $)72#,�� #2-+44$%4$)+#-"-,,� %9� -99%$#,� #%� -,#+@1),2� (%"#$%1� %6-$� #2-� 9%$5-$� ;)9-� &-,4)#-� #2-&)6%$(-�� #2-�1+(C�%9�5+1-�$-,4%",)@)1)#=� 9%$�4%,#D&)6%$(-�(%"91)(#��+"&� #2-�6)+@)1)#=�%9+@,-"(-�+,� +� ,#$+#-7=!�!�!�!< � �/+$+@+$+�11-"�/+@(%(C�-#� +1!�� ��O������������� �

�����>�����������������������������0*.D*��L�BB�M�L&-,($)@)"7��-$$=�$-"&-118,+$#)(1-��� ��� ������#����� ��� ������ ��(� �����������)"���������G�����������0�����D���L�BB0MMA�����������������������������������������D����.�D���L�BB�M!

B�� �������������������"%#-��B��+#�.�!

B0� ����/������G���������������"%#-�����+#���.D��!

29

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�*� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

(%'$#� +1,%� 4%;-$9'11=� )"91'-"(-�� %9#-"� )"+(('$+#-1=�� (%'$#,8)"#-$4$-#+#)%",�%9�9+#2-$,8�+"&�5%#2-$,8�(1+)5,!

�2-� "-#� -99-(#� %9� #2-� (%'$#,8� '";+$$+"#-&� ,C-4#)(),5� #%;+$&5%#2-$,8�(1+)5,�%9�@+##-$)"7�+"&�-E(-,,)6-�&-9-$-"(-�#%;+$&�+((',-&9+#2-$,�� #2-"�� ),� #2+#� )#� ),� 2)721=� '"','+1� 9%$� +� @+##-$-&� ;%5+"� )"4$)6+#-� 1)#)7+#)%"� #%� @-� $-(%7")3-&� @=� +� (%'$#� #%� @-� ,)"(-$-1=+&6%(+#)"7� 9%$� 2-$� (2)1&$-"8,� ,+9-#=!

B�� � �+#2-$�� 2-$� 6-$=� ,#+#',� +,� +

1)#)7+"#�� +� 5%#2-$�� +"&� @+##-$-&�� ,--5,� #%� -",'$-� #2+#� ,2-� ;)11� @-6)-;-&�+,�� +#�@-,#��5-$-1=� ,-19D)"#-$-,#-&�� +"&� +#�;%$,#�� "%#� ($-&)@1-!�%"6-$,-1=��5-"8,�&-5+"&,� 9%$�+((-,,� #%� #2-)$�(2)1&$-"�+$-� #=4)(+11=5-#� ;)#2� +� 4$-,'54#)%"� %9� 7%%&� 9+)#2�� -6-"� ;2-"� #2%,-� 5-"� +$-+&F'&)(+#-&� @+##-$-$,!� � %#+@1=�� #2),� #=4-� %9� $-,),#+"(-� #%� @+##-$-&5%#2-$,8�6-$+()#=�)"�1)#)7+#)%"�%6-$�#2-�(2)1&$-"�(+"�(%D-E),#�;)#2�#2-(%'$#8,�@+,)(�+((-4#+"(-�%9�2-$�(1+)5,�9%$�4'$4%,-,�%9�#2-�"%"D(2)1&D(-"#-$-&�+,4-(#,�%9�#2-�(+,-!

B.���"�%#2-$�;%$&,��#2-�5-$-�4$-,-"(-�%9

(2)1&$-"�+,�+�: ,#+C-< �)"�#2-�1)#)7+#)%"�(+"�4$%9%'"&1=�,2)9#�#2-�('1#'$-%9�+�(+,-!

7� ����������

�)6-"� ;2+#� ),� C"%;"� +@%'#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +"&� @+##-$-$,�� #2-(%'$#,8�)",),#-"(-�%"�:"-'#$+1)#=< �%$�:%@F-(#)6)#=< �1-+&,�',�)"-,(+4+@1=@+(C� #%� #2-�?'-,#)%"�%9�7-"&-$�@)+,!� �"&� )"� 9+(#��;2)1-� #2-�@'1C�%9

B�! �2),�2+,�(%",),#-"#1=�@--"�5=�%;"�-E4-$)-"(-�)"�#2-��!�!�#$)+1�(%'$#,!���$%5

-E(2+"7-,�%"�+� 1),#,-$6�&-6%#-&�#%�#2-�,'@F-(#�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+"&�(2)1&$-"�� )#+44-+$,� #%�@-� #2-�-E4-$)-"(-�%9�%#2-$,� +$%'"&� #2-�(%'"#$=� +,�;-11!� ����� �%5@+$&)������"%#-��B�� +#��+$#�.A�>���������/������������ �����"%#-���!� �>2)1-� +44-11+#-&-(),)%",�+$%'"&�#2-�(%'"#$=�+$-�5)E-&��-6-"�#2-�9+6%$+@1-�%"-,�$-91-(#�'"9+6%$+@1-#$)+1�(%'$#�&-(),)%",!������������+44!�A��%$&�6!��%$&�������%!�0&��B��L�1+!��),#!��#!�44!�BB�M� L9)"&)"7� +@',-� %9� &),($-#)%"� ;2-$-� #2-� #$)+1� (%'$#� @+$-1=� 5-"#)%"-&� +": -,#+@1),2-&�4+##-$"�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-< �+"&�+441)-&�+�: 9$)-"&1=�4+$-"#< �4$)"()41-+7+)",#�#2-�6)(#)5MA��-;),�6!��-;),�������%!�0&�*���L�+!��#!�44!�0���M�L$-6-$,)"7�#2-+;+$&�%9� F%)"#� (',#%&=� #%� #2-� 9+#2-$� +,� 4$)5+$=� $-,)&-"#)+1� 4+$-"#� ;2-$-� #2-� 1%;-$(%'$#�9+)1-&�#%�+441=�+�4$-,'54#)%"�+7+)",#�(',#%&=�&-,4)#-�#2-�2',@+"&8,�+&5)##-&4+,#� +@',)6-� (%"&'(#MA� +3+$� 6!� +3+$�� ���� !>!0&� �0*� L�)""!� �#!� 44!� �BB�ML$-6-$,)"7�+�(',#%&=�+;+$&� #%� #2-� 9+#2-$�+"&� $-F-(#)"7� #2-� #$)+1� (%'$#8,� 9)"&)"7� #2+##2-�5%#2-$�2+&�: 9+1,-1=< �+"&�:5+1)()%',1=< �+11-7-&�6)%1-"(-MA��',,%�6!��+$&"-$��B���!0&�B*�L-6!��BB*M�L$-6-$,)"7�F%)"#�1-7+1�(',#%&=�;2-$-�#2-�9+#2-$�;+,�(%"6)(#-&�%9;)9-� +@',-� +"&� #2-$-� ;+,� -6)&-"(-� #2+#� 2-� +@',-&� (2)1&$-"MA� N'7+$� 6!� N'7+$�� ���!>!0&� *�.� L!�!� �BB�M� L$-F-(#)"7� #2-� #$)+1� (%'$#8,� +;+$&� %9� F%)"#� (',#%&=� %"7$%'"&,�#2+#�#2-�6)(#)5)3-&�4+$-"#�;+,�: %6-$D4$%#-(#)6-�< �#2+#�#2-�6)%1-"(-�;%'1&�"%#%(('$�+7+)"��+"&�#2+#�#2-�6)%1-"(-�;+,�"%#�&)$-(#-&�+#�(2)1&$-"MA��5)#2�6!��5)#2��B���!0&�0.�L�C1+!��)6!�44!��BB*M�L$-6-$,)"7�(',#%&=�+;+$&�#%�9+#2-$�+"&�2%1&)"7�#2+##2-� ;)9-8,� +99)&+6)#� +"&� ;)#"-,,8� #-,#)5%")-,� &-5%",#$+#-&� (1-+$� +"&� (%"6)"()"7-6)&-"(-�%9�%"7%)"7�+@',-M!� ��"9%$#'"+#-1=�� #2-,-�+44-+1,� +$-� #2-�-E(-4#)%"��5%,#(',#%&=�1)#)7+"#,�(+""%#�+"&�&%�"%#�#+C-�+44-+1,!

B.� ���� �)"-5+"�� ����� "%#-� 00�� +#� 0��� L(2+$+(#-$)3)"7� +,� : ,(2)3%42$-")(< � 1-7+1&-(),)%"�5+C-$,8� #-"&-"(=� #%�+((-4#�-,#+@1),2-&� : ,#%$)-,� +"&� ,#+#),#)(,< �%9�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-��=-#� #%�: )7"%$-�#2-�,#%$)-,�+"&�1-,,%",�#2-=�#-+(2< �)"�5%$-�(%541-E�4%1)(=(%"#-E#,�,'(2�+,�(2)1&�(',#%&=�+"&�6),)#+#)%"MA��������������+$#��!!

30

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �*�

#2),�$#)(1-�-E+5)"-,�#2-�"-'#$+1�$+#)%"+1-,�#2+#�9'-1�$-F-(#)%"�%9�#2-)541)(+#)%",� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� )"� (',#%&=� (+,-,�� #2-� &),(',,)%";%'1&�@-�)"(%541-#-�;)#2%'#�,%5-�$-9-$-"(-�#%�;2+#�;-�C"%;�+@%'#7-"&-$�@)+,�)"�#2),�+$-+!

B�

�)$,#���+,-� �� 4$%6)&-,� +� (1+,,)(� (+,-� )"� 4%)"#�� #2-� (%'$#8,� ,"+$1)"7$-F-(#)%"� %9� : #2-� �� ��.0� (1+)5,� +@%'#� #2-� (2)1&8,� (%"&)#)%"� (+"2+$&1=� @-� '"&-$,#%%&� )"� +"=� %#2-$� ;+=� #2+"� +,� +"� -E4$-,,)%"� %92%,#)1)#=� #%� : #2-� 5%#2-$,!<

B�� � �2),� (%55-"#� ),� "%#� -E41+)"+@1-� +,

$-91-(#)"7� #2-� (%'$#8,� "-7+#)6-� 6)-;� %9� +� 4+$#=� ;2%� #2-� (%'$#� 2+&&--5-&�-E(-,,)6-1=�"%"D($-&)@1-�+($%,,�#2-�@%+$&��@-(+',-�#2-�(%'$#2+&�+1$-+&=� )"&)(+#-&�+((-4#+"(-�%9�5+"=�%9�2-$�&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-+11-7+#)%",�;2-"�4$-,-"#-&�)"�#2-�(%"#-54#�L"%"D(',#%&=M�(%"#-E#!

B�

�"� 9+(#�� ,#$)C)"71=�� 5+"=� (%'$#,� #2-5,-16-,� L#2$%'72� +44%)"#-&(%55),,)%",M� 2+6-� )&-"#)9)-&� &="+5)(,� %9� 7-"&-$� @)+,� )"� (',#%&=+"& %$�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+&F'&)(+#)%",!���2-��+,,+(2',-##,��-"&-$/)+,� ,#'&=� %9� 0���� &),4'#-&� (',#%&=� (+,-,� 9%'"&� #2+#� (%'$#,(%",),#-"#1=�2-1&�5%#2-$,�#%�2)72-$�,#+"&+$&,�%9�4$%%9�#2+"�9+#2-$,��+9)"&)"7�#2+#�)#�,#+#-&�:&)$-(#1=�(%"#$+&)(#,�#2-�4%4'1+$�5),(%"(-4#)%"#2+#� )9�7-"&-$�@)+,�&%-,�-E),#� )"�(2)1&�(',#%&=�(+,-,�� )#� ),� )"� 9+6%$�%95%#2-$,!<

B*� � �+$-"� �3+4+",C)=� 2+,� 9%'"&� #2+#� ,#+#-,8� 7-"&-$� @)+,

,#'&)-,� (%",),#-"#1=� )"&)(+#-� #2+#� #2-� : ($-&)@)1)#=� +((%$&-&� ;%5-"1)#)7+"#,�),�1-,,�#2+"�#2+#�+((%$&-&�5-"�1)#)7+"#,< �)"�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-(+,-,!

BB���%$�)",#+"(-�

B�! �2-$-� ),� ,#)11� +� 9+)$1=� ;)&-1=� 2-1&� 6)-;� #2+#� 9+5)1=� (%'$#,� +$-� @)+,-&� +7+)",#

5-"!�����A���,��������+6)&��$+$=��%����� ���� ��1���A�"��� �����%������1�������!���������� �������� ��,�"�� ��������������(� ��.�1�� �����������������L�+"+&+M��%6!�0��0��0�� +#� /�!� � %#� %"1=� #2-� &="+5)(,� &),(',,-&� )"� #2),� $#)(1-� @'#� #2-� +6+)1+@1--54)$)(+1� 9)"&)"7,�(%'"#-$� #2),� 6)-;!� ����� /������G���������� �����"%#-� ���� +#����� �0�D0�� L,#+#)"7� #2+#� : 9+#2-$,� 2+6-� @--"� +#� +� 5+$C-&� +&6+"#+7-� )"� (',#%&=&),4'#-,< M!���=�%;"�-E4-$)-"(-��+,�;-11�+,�#2-�,'$6-=�(%"#+)"-&�)"�44-"&)E���������,'77-,#,� #2+#�@+##-$-$,� +$-������ 1)C-1=� #2+"�"%"D@+##-$-$,� #%�;)"�(',#%&=�@-(+',-�%9#2-� (%'$#,� )"#-",-� "-7+#)6-� $-+(#)%",� ;2-"� 5%#2-$,� $+),-� #2-� ),,'-� %9� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-�)"�+�(',#%&=�&),4'#-!

B�! �#�),�&)99)('1#�#%�)5+7)"-�+�F'&7-�&-$%7+#%$)1=�$-9-$$)"7�#%�+11-7+#)%",�@=�: #2-9+#2-$< �)"�+�(%54+$+@1-�(%"#-E#!

B�! %"-#2-1-,,�� #2-� -"#)$-� 1)#)7+#)%"� ;+,� +1,%� 2)721=� (2+$7-&� ;)#2� )")&)()+� %97-"&-$�@)+,!���"�2-$�$-6)-;�%9�7-"&-$�@)+,�,#'&)-,���+$-"��3+4+",C)=�2+,�)&-"#)9)-&�+:"-7+#)6-� ,="-$7=< � )"� (+,-,� ;)#2� 9-5+1-� +##%$"-=,� +&6%(+#)"7� 9%$� 9-5+1-� (1)-"#,+11-7)"7�@+##-$)"7!� ��3+4+",C)=�� �����"%#-�0*��+#�0�*������!� ��+,-���;+,�+� ,#$)C)"7-E+541-� %9� #2),�� �� ;+,� +� 9-5+1-� +##%$"-=� ;)#2� +� @+##-$-&� ;%5+"� (1)-"#A� #2-� 5+1-@+##-$-$� ;+,� $-4$-,-"#-&� @=� +� 6-$=� +77$-,,)6-� +"&� 2)721=D$-7+$&-&� 5+1-� 4'@1)(&-9-"&-$!� � �2-� 5+1-� F'&7-� +"&� &-9-",-� +##%$"-=� -E2)@)#-&� +� 7$-+#� 9+5)1)+$)#=�)"(1'&)"7� 9$-?'-"#� F%6)+1� @+"#-$�� F%C-,� +"&� -6-"� @-#,� +@%'#� 6+$)%',� #$)6)+�� ;2)1-� �9$-?'-"#1=� 9%'"&� )#� &)99)('1#� #%� 7-#� #2-� (%'$#8,� +##-"#)%"!� � �2-� F'&7-8,� $+;� 6-"%5#%;+$&�5=�(1)-"#�%"� #2-�&+=�;-�,%'72#� #%�-1)5)"+#-� #2-�+@',-$8,�6),)#+#)%"�;)#2� #2-(2)1&�;+,�5-$-1=�#2-�1%;�4%)"#�%9�+�6-$=�(2+$7-&�#$)+1!

B*! >���������/�����������������"%#-�����+#�0!

BB! �3+4+",C)=�������"%#-�0*��+#�0��!

31

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�** ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

�2-,-�$-,4%",-,�$-6-+1�+�,#$%"7�4-$(-4#)%"�@=�@%#2�#2-�@+$�+"&�#2-F'&)()+$=� #2+#�� +#� 1-+,#� )"� $+4-� +"&� )"� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� (+,-,�� +9-5+1-� (%5-,� #%� (%'$#� )"��-%$7)+� @-+$)"7� +� ($-&)@)1)#=� @'$&-"�� +@'$&-"�@+,-&�%"�+�,#-$-%#=4)(�6)-;�%9�7-"&-$�#2+#�&%-,�"%#�+99-(#5+1-,� )"� #2-� ,+5-� ;+=!� � �2-� -99-(#� %9� ,'(2� '"&'-� ,C-4#)(),59$-?'-"#1=� 41+(-,� 9-5+1-� 1)#)7+"#,� )"� +� 4%,)#)%"� ;2-$-� #2-=� 5',#%99-$�5%$-�-6)&-"(-�#2+"�&%�5+1-�1)#)7+"#,!

���

�-,#� )#� @-� #2%'72#� #2+#� #2),� @)+,� ),� 1)5)#-&� #%� (-$#+)"� ,#+#-,� %$$-7)%",��,)5)1+$�%@,-$6+#)%",�2+6-�@--"�5+&-�)"�5%,#�%#2-$�,#+#-,�+,;-11��-!7!�

�-;� �%$C� ($)5)"+1� (%'$#� F'&7-� #%1&� 5-� $-(-"#1=� #2+#� +1#2%'72#2-� (%'$#� 4-$,%""-1� )"� 2-$� (%'$#$%%5� +$-� ','+11=� ?')#-4$%,-('#)%"D5)"&-&��#2),�+##)#'&-�,2)9#,�;2-"�+�;%5+"�#-,#)9)-,�)"�+&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� (+,-!� � �2-"�� (%'$#� 4-$,%""-18,� @%&=� 1+"7'+7-(1-+$1=�(%"6-=,�#%�#2-�F'&7-�+"&�F'$=�+"�+('#-�,C-4#)(),5!

���

�"�(',#%&=�(+,-,��7-"&-$�@)+,�+1,%�%9#-"�+44-+$,�)"�+�5%$-�5+,C-&9%$5!

��0���%$�)",#+"(-��#2-�(1+)5�%9�:4+$-"#+1�+1)-"+#)%"< �),�@-)"7�',-&

;)#2�7$%;)"7�9$-?'-"(=�+7+)",#�;%5-"�+11-7)"7�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�L%$(2)1&�+@',-M!���2),�(%"(-4#�;+,�9)$,#�)"6-"#-&�@=�4,=(2)+#$),#��)(2+$&�+$&"-$�� ;2%� 2)5,-19� ,#+#-&� #2+#� :4+$-"#+1� +1)-"+#)%"� ,="&$%5-<L:��<M� ),� +15%,#� -E(1',)6-1=� )"91)(#-&� @=�5%#2-$,� +7+)",#� 9+#2-$,!

���

�+$&"-$�+"&�%#2-$,�;2%�2+6-�4$%4%'"&-&�#2-����)"�(',#%&=�(+,-,2+6-�+,,-$#-&�#2+#�)#�),�7$%'"&,�9%$�&-"=)"7�(',#%&=�#%�#2-�4-$4-#$+#%$%9� ,'(2� +1)-"+#)%"!

��.� � 1#2%'72� #2-� 5-$)(+"� �,=(2%1%7)(+1

,,%()+#)%"�2+,�$-F-(#-&� )#�+,�+�(1)")(+1�42-"%5-"%"�+"&� ,#+#-,� #2+##2-$-� ),� "%� &+#+� #%� ,'44%$#� )#�� ',-� %9� #2),� #2-%$=� ),� )"($-+,)"71=4$-6+1-"#�)"�(',#%&=�+"&�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�1)#)7+#)%"!

���

���� ����+#�0���"!0�!

���! �=""��(2+9$+"��*��@����� ���� ���� ������#�-��� ���� ���� ����� ������������������� ���� "���� ��� 5�������� "����� �� .� ���!� !� ����� ������� ���� �0� L�BB�M�� �� ��� ���3+4+",C)=�� ����� "%#-� 0*�� +#� 0��!� ����������%5@+$&)�� �����"%#-� �B�� �+$#� .� L()#)"7$-,'1#,� %9� #2-� ���!� ������ /��� ������� #2-� >��������� /���� �������� #2-� �>�+1)9%$")+��-4%$#�+"&�%#2-$�(+,-,M!

��0� ���� /������ G� ��������� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� �00D��� L4$%6)&)"7� +� 9+)$1=(%54$-2-",)6-� 1),#� %9� : #+(#)(,< � @+##-$-$,� ',-� #%� &),($-&)#� 5%#2-$,8� ($-&)@)1)#=� )"(',#%&=�(+,-,M!

���� ���� ���� +#� ���D��� L()#)"7� ������� ������� ���� ������ ������

���������������������������/��>����/�����������������������O��

/���� L�BB�MM!� � #� %"-� 4%)"#� #2-� 7-"&-$-&� @+,),� 9%$� #2-� : ,="&$%5-< � ;+,� 5+&--E41)()#!� � ���� �+6)&� �'$C+#�� ������21��� ��� +�������� +� ��� ���������� ��� !� ��!��������0��D�.�L�BB�M!

��.� ����/������G���������� �����"%#-����� +#����� L()#)"7����������������O�/������������������>���������������������L�BB�MM!

���� �������������� �����"%#-��B�� +#����� L"%#)"7� #2+#� : +1#2%'72� #2-$-� +$-�"%&+#+� #%� ,'44%$#� #2-�42-"%5-"%"�(+11-&� R4+$-"#+1�+1)-"+#)%"�,="&$%5-8� #-$5,� ,'(2+,� R4+$-"#+1� +1)-"+#)%"8� 5+=� @-� ',-&� #%� @1+5-� #2-� ;%5-"� 9%$� #2-� (2)1&$-"8,$-+,%"+@1-�9-+$�%9�%$�+"7-$�#%;+$&�#2-)$�6)%1-"#�9+#2-$< MA��%5@+$&)�������"%#-��B��+#

32

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �*B

>2+#-6-$�#2-�5-$)#�%9�#2-�(%"(-4#�%9�:4+$-"#+1�+1)-"+#)%"< �)"�#2-+@,#$+(#��+,�)#�2+,�@--"�@%#2�(%",#$'(#-&�+"&�#=4)(+11=�',-&�)"�(%'$#��)#),� @%#2�@1+#+"#1=� 7-"&-$�@)+,-&�+"&� 9'"&+5-"#+11=�5),7')&-&!� ��2-6-$=� "%#)%"� #2+#� 9+#2-$,� +$-� #2-� &%5)"+"#� 6)(#)5,� %9� :4+$-"#+1+1)-"+#)%"< � ),� 1'&)($%',� #%� +"=%"-� ;2%� 2+,� ;%$C-&� ;)#2� @+##-$-&;%5-"�)"�#2-�(%'$#,!���"�#2-�6+,#�5+F%$)#=�%9�(+,-,���2+6-�1)#)7+#-&��#2-+@',)6-� 9+#2-$� +(#)6-1=� ,%'72#� #%� : +1)-"+#-< � #2-� (2)1&$-"� 9$%5� #2-)$5%#2-$!� � �-#� #2-� ��� #2-%$=� ;+,� )"6-"#-&� #%� @-I +"&� ','+11=� ),I',-&� %"1=� +7+)",#� 5%#2-$,� (1+)5)"7� +@',-!

���� � "&�� ;2)1-� ,%5-

-6+1'+#%$,� ;)11� +$7'-� #2+#� )#� (+"� @-� +� 7-"&-$D"-'#$+1� (%"(-4#�� )#� ),+15%,#� '"2-+$&� %9� 9%$� +"� -6+1'+#%$� %$� (%'$#� #%� -6-"� $-(%7")3-�� 1-#+1%"-�4-"+1)3-�� +� 9+#2-$�@=� 1)5)#)"7� +((-,,� #%� +� (2)1&�@-(+',-�%9� 2),)"#-"#)%"+11=� +1)-"+#)"7� (%"&'(#!

���� � �"� (%"#$+,#�� ;%5-"� ;2%� +11-7-

9+#2-$,� +$-� +@',)"7� (2)1&$-"� +$-� )"($-+,)"71=� @-)"7� ,'@F-(#-&� #%&$+(%")+"�4'"),25-"#,��)"(1'&)"7�(%541-#-�1%,,�%9�(%"#+(#�;)#2� #2-

�+$#�.�L: �#8,�+�"%"D,="&$%5-�!�!�!�H)9K�=%'�(+""%#�(%"9)$5�+�,="&$%5-�@=�,#+#)"7�#2+#�)#-E),#,!< M� L?'%#)"7� �%@-$#� �-99"-$�� �%'"&-$�� �+5)1=� �)%1-"(-� +"&� �-E'+1� ,,+'1#�",#)#'#-M!���2-�;)&-,4$-+&�+44-+1�%9����+"&�4+$-"#+1�+1)-"+#)%"�L:�< M�(1+)5,�)"#2-�(%'$#,� ),�+11� #2-�5%$-�$-5+$C+@1-� )"� 1)72#�%9� #2-�4-&)7$--�%9� #2-� #2-%$=�+"&� )#,)"6-"#%$���+$&"-$�2)5,-19�2+,� +&6%(+#-&�4-&%42)1)+�� +"&�2+,�"-6-$�(%"(-+1-&� #2+#2-�)"6-"#-&����#%�7)6-�+((',-&�9+#2-$,�+�#%%1�+7+)",#�(2)1&�,-E'+1�+@',-�+11-7+#)%",!�'(%#-�������"%#-��0��+#��.��"!��*�L"%#)"7��+$&"-$8,�(1+)5,�#2+#�#2-��")#-&��#+#-,�),)"+44$%4$)+#-1=�4'")#)6-�+"&�5%$+1),#)(� #%;+$&,� ,-E'+1�+(#)6)#=�@-#;--"�4+$-"#,�+"&(2)1&$-"M�L()#)"7�����������������������������������������������O��

/����L�BB0MMA��+#21--"��%'1@%$"��+11-$��*��%���� ��������� ������������#��� ���� ������ � � �� ������ � � 4�� �� ������ ���������� ���� L�BB*M� L&-,($)@)"7� ��� +,%99-$)"7�: +"�-E41+"+#)%"� 9%$�$-4%$#,�%9� ,-E'+1�+@',-�;2-"�4+$-"#,�+$-�&)6%$()"7< M!�%$-%6-$���+$&"-$8,�2=4%#2-,-,�9%$�;2=�,%�5+"=�;%5-"�4'$4%$#-&1=�9+@$)(+#-�(2)1&,-E'+1�+@',-�+11-7+#)%",��,'(2�+,�#2+#�#2-=�+$-�:;%5-"�,(%$"-&�< �%$�-"F%=�)5+7)")"74-&%42)1)+������+#���.��+$-�2+6-�@--"�+4#1=�(+11-&�: 1'&)($%',!< �������+",%"�6!��4%1")C��*��!�!0&�����*.�L�"&!�44!��BB�M�L�2-3-5�� !��(%"('$$)"7�)"�4+$#�+"&�&),,-"#)"7�)"4+$#M�L($)#)()3)"7� #2-�:;%5-"� ,(%$"-&< � #2-%$=M!� � �)"(-��+$&"-$�2+,�4$%6)&-&� ,'(2+"� -+,=� #+$7-#� 9%$� ($)#)(,�� %#2-$� (1)")()+",� +"&� $-,-+$(2-$,� 2+6-� @-7'"� #%� %99-$� 1-,,%'#1+"&),2�+"+1=,-,�+"&�&-9-",-,�%9�4+$-"#+1�+1)-"+#)%"!���%;-6-$��#2-�6+1)&)#=�%9�#2-(%"(-4#�+"&�)#,�',-�)"�1)#)7+#)%"�(+,-,�$-5+)",�2)721=�(%"#-"#)%',�+#�@-,#!����������������+$%1��!�/$'(2��%���� ��������� �����������������%���� ��������� ���#��� ����� ���������"���� "� ���� "���� ��� ��!� �!P!� �0�� L0���M� L$-6)-;)"7� +"&� ($)#)?')"7� �+$&"-$� %2",#%"�+"&�%#2-$�#2-%$),#,M!

���� �������-4%$#�������"%#-��B��+#�.�A�/������G���������������"%#-�����+#���D��� L%99-$)"7� +� @$)-9� ($)#)?'-� %9� #2-� 4+$-"#+1� +1)-"+#)%"� #2-%$=� +,� ',-&� +7+)",#@+##-$-&� ;%5-"M!� � �-7+$&)"7� +@',-$,8� : +1)-"+#)%"< � %9� #2-)$� (2)1&$-"� 9$%5� #2-)$5%#2-$�� ,--� ������ "%#-� ��.� +"&� +((%54+"=)"7� #-E#!� � �%"#$+$=� #%� #2-� @-1)-9,� %94$%4%"-"#,�%9�4+$-"#+1�+1)-"+#)%"�#2-%$=��)"�%6-$�#-"�=-+$,�%9�1)#)7+#)"7�#2-,-�(+,-,��2+6-�"-6-$�-E4-$)-"(-&�+�(1)-"#�-E4$-,,)"7�(%54+$+@1-�6-"%5�+@%'#�2-$�+@',-$��#2-(2)1&$-"8,� 9+#2-$!� � �+#2-$�� 5%$-� %9#-"� #2+"� �� 2+6-� 1)C-&�� (1)-"#,� 2+6-� )",),#-&� %"4$-,-$6)"7�#2-�(2)1&$-"8,�$-1+#)%",2)4�#2$%'72�6),)#+#)%"!

���! �"��+,-�0��)"�$-,4%",-�#%�%'$�$-?'-,#� #%�4$%#-(#� #2-�(2)1&�9$%5�#2-�+@',-$8,#$+,2)"7� %9� #2-�5%#2-$�� #2-� (%'$#,� -"F%)"-&� @%#2�4+$#)-,� 9$%5� ,4-+C)"7� +@%'#� #2-%#2-$�#%�#2-�(2)1&!������������+$#��!/!� �,� ),�&),(',,-&�9'$#2-$�@-1%;�� #2),� : F%)"#< �%$:5'#'+1< �+((%'"#+@)1)#=�&%-,�"%#�2+6-�#2-�-99-(#�%9�2%1&)"7�+�@+##-$-$�+((%'"#+@1-A$+#2-$�� )#� 4-$4-#'+#-,�2),� (1+)5� #2+#� #2-�5%#2-$� ),� -?'+11=� %$�5%$-� $-,4%",)@1-� 9%$;2+#-6-$�+@',-�),�+#�),,'-!�������������+$#����!�!

33

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�B� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

(2)1&$-"!��*

B� �������� ������������ �����%���� �� �������!�� ����������

/+##-$-&� ;%5-"�� +"&� -,4-()+11=� @+##-$-&� 5%#2-$,�� 5+=� @-&),@-1)-6-&� 9%$� +"%#2-$�� +"&� +$7'+@1=� 5%$-� : +44$%4$)+#-�< � $-+,%"�#2-�4+$#)-,8�$-,4-(#)6-�&-5-+"%$,!�� '&7-,�L+"&�+$7'+@1=��-6+1'+#%$,M+$-� )"� #2-� @',)"-,,� %9� +,,-,,)"7� ($-&)@)1)#=!� � �"9%$#'"+#-1=�� 5+"=(%55%"�+,,'54#)%",�+@%'#�;)#"-,,�($-&)@)1)#=�@+(C9)$-�;2-"�+441)-&#%�6)(#)5,�+"&�4-$4-#$+#%$,�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-!

>2)1-�(%'$#,�%9#-"�9)"&�@+##-$-$,�#%�@-�,=54+#2-#)(�+"&�(%"6)"()"7)"� #2-)$� &-")+1,�� #2-,-� ($-&)@)1)#=� +,,-,,5-"#,� +$-� %9#-"� )"(%$$-(#!�+"=� ;2%� ;%$C� )"� @+##-$-$,8� (%'",-1)"7� +##-,#� #2+#� +� (%55%"(2+$+(#-$),#)(�%9�@+##-$-$,� ),� #2-)$�4+,,)%"+#-�+"&�-1%?'-"#�&-")+1�%9#2-� +@',-� +"&� #2-� )54+(#� %9� #2-)$� %;"� (%"&'(#� %"� %#2-$,!� � ,/+"($%9#�+"&��)16-$5+"�,'(()"(#1=�,#+#-��: )#�),�(%55%"�9%$�%'$�(1)-"#,#%� @-� ,C)119'11=� &),2%"-,#!�!�!�!<

��B� � /+##-$-$,� (%"6)"(-� "%#� %"1=� %#2-$

4-%41-��@'#�+1,%� #2-5,-16-,� #2+#� #2-=�+$-� : $)72#< �+"&� #2-)$�+((',-$,+$-�;$%"7�+"&�'";%$#2=!� ��2-)$�&-")+1,�+$-�-,4-()+11=�@-1)-6+@1-�@=(%'$#,� )"� (+,-,� ;2-$-� #2-� +11-7+#)%",� %9� 42=,)(+1� 6)%1-"(-� (+"� @-4-$(-)6-&�+,�5)"%$!

�+"=� @+##-$-$,� +1,%� -E2)@)#� +� ,5%%#2� +"&� (2+$5)"7� 4-$,%"+� )"4'@1)(� +"&� ;2-"� )#� ),� )"� #2-)$� )"#-$-,#!

���� � "� '"','+11=� -E41)()#

��*� ����>%%&�� �����"%#-� �0�� +#� ����� L&-,($)@)"7� +� (+,-� )"� ;2)(2� +� 9+#2-$� ;+,

7)6-"�,%1-�(',#%&=�+"&�#2-�5%#2-$�;+,�&-")-&�+11�(%"#+(#�;)#2�2-$�=%'"7�&+'72#-$+9#-$�2-$�(2)1&�,-E'+1�+@',-�+11-7+#)%",�;-$-�2-1&�#%�@-�'"4$%6-"MA�/'$C-�������"%#-*��L&),(',,)"7�+��+1)9%$")+��>�,#'&=�;2)(2�9%'"&�)"�4$-1)5)"+$=�$-,-+$(2�#2+#� )"#2)$#--"� (%'"#)-,� #2+#� #2-� 4+$-"#� (2+$7)"7� (2)1&� ,-E'+1� +@',-� $-(-)6-&� ,'4-$6),-&6),)#+#)%"� %$� "%� (%"#+(#� +#� +11� )"� 5%$-� #2+"� ��Q� %9� #2%,-� (+,-,�� +"&� #2-� +11-7-&4-$4-#$+#%$,� $-(-)6-&� 9'11� %$� 4+$#)+1� '",'4-$6),-&� (',#%&=� B�Q� %9� #2-� #)5-M!� � "+#)%"+1�,#'&=�@=�,%()%1%7),#�5=�-',#-)"�%9�%6-$������(+,-,�&%('5-"#-&�5%#2-$,@-)"7�2-1&�)"�(%"#-54#��F+)1-&��1%,)"7�(',#%&=�+"&�2+6)"7�6),)#+#)%"�$-,#$)(#-&�%$�('#%99�� +,� +� $-,'1#� %9� 4'$,')"7� +11-7+#)%",� %9� (2)1&� +@',-� +7+)",#� #2-� 9+#2-$!� � ���� 5=-',#-)"�G�""��%-##)"7��5��������1������ �� ��%�� �� ����%���� .�"������� ����"�����'���� ������ *� !� ������ ��O��� /���� ����� ���� L�BBBM� L($)#)?')"7� ,()-"#)9)(+11=&),($-&)#-&� 4,=(2%1%7)(+1� ,="&$%5-,�� ,'(2� +,� �+$-"#+1� 1)-"+#)%"� �="&$%5-� +"&�+1)()%',� �%#2-$8,� �="&$%5-MA� �%5@+$&)�� �����"%#-� �B!� � � ,5+11-$� ,#'&=� %9� ���(+,-,� %6-$� #-"� =-+$,� 9%'"&� #2+#� +11-7-&� (2)1&� ,-E'+1� +@',-$,� $-(-)6-&�'",'4-$6),-&6),)#+#)%"�%$�,2+$-&�(',#%&=���Q�%9�#2-�#)5-��+"&�%6-$�0�Q�%9�(+,-,�$-,'1#-&�)"�#2-5%#2-$� ;2%� +11-7-&� (2)1&� ,-E'+1� +@',-� 1%,)"7� 6),)#+#)%"� $)72#,� +1#%7-#2-$!� � ����%5@+$&)�������"%#-��B��+#��+$#�.�L&-,($)@)"7�#2-�-',#-)"�,#'&)-,M!� ��2),� #$-"&� ),,#'"")"7�� -,4-()+11=� )"� (%54+$),%"� #%� #2-� #=4)(+1� #$-+#5-"#� %9� +&F'&)(+#-&� (2)1&+@',-$,� %$� @+##-$-$,�� ;2%� $+$-1=� 2+6-� #2-)$� 6),)#+#)%"� -6-"� $-,#$)(#-&�� 1-#� +1%"-#-$5)"+#-&!

��B! /������ G� ��������� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� �0.A� L+$7')"7� #2+#� : H@K+##-$-$,$+$-1=�&),(1%,-�#2-)$�6)%1-"(-�9'11=��-6-"�)"�#2-�9+(-�%9�(%",)&-$+@1-�-6)&-"(-< M!

���� �����+6)&�&+5,������ ������� ������ ����3���������"��� #�?������ ��5��������/����� /! !� 0�� L�B*BM� L"%#)"7� #2+#� ;2)1-� #2-� ;%5+"� %9#-"� +44-+$,� +7)#+#-&� +"&2=,#-$)(+1��#2-�5+"�%9#-"�+44-+$,�(+15�+"&�9$)-"&1=��;2)(2�5+C-,�)#�5%$-�1)C-1=�#2+#9$)-"&,�"-)72@%$,��4%1)(-�%99)(-$,��+"&�(%'$#,�;)11�@-1)-6-�#2-�;%5+"�),�-E+77-$+#)"7MA

34

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �B�

&-4)(#)%"�%9�#2),�4$%@1-5�;+,�4$%6)&-&�@=�+��+$=1+"&�F'&7-�;2%�2+&&-")-&� +� 4$%#-(#)%"� %$&-$� #%� +� ;%5+"�;2%� ;+,� 1+#-$� C)11-&� @=� 2-$+@',-$!� � �2-� F'&7-� ,'@,-?'-"#1=� -E41+)"-&� #2+#� #2-� 5+"� &)&� "%#(%5-� +($%,,� )"� (%'$#� +,� +� : ,)(C< � 4-$,%"� ;2%� ;%'1&� (%55)#� #2-6)%1-"(-� ,2-� 2+&� +11-7-&A� 2-"(-� 2-� 2+&� &),@-1)-6-&� #2-� ;%5+"8,(1+)5�%9�9-+$!

�"�(%"#$+,#��@+##-$-&�;%5-"��4+$#)('1+$1=� #2%,-�;2%�2+6-�5+&-� )##%� (%'$#�� +$-� %9#-"� +"7$=� %$� -5%#)%"+1!

���� � >2)1-� #2),� ),� +� 4-$9-(#1=

'"&-$,#+"&+@1-� $-+(#)%"� #%� &%5-,#)(� +@',-� +"&� (%"#-,#,� %6-$(',#%&=�

��0� #2-,-� &-5-+"%$,� &%� "%#� -"2+"(-� ;%5-"8,� ($-&)@)1)#=� )"

#2-� -=-,�%9� +� F'&7-�%$�%#2-$� -6+1'+#%$!���

� ��%$-%6-$��5+"=� @+##-$-&;%5-"�)"�(%'$#�+$-�-E4-$)-"()"7�,%5-�,#+7-�%9�4%,#D#$+'5+#)(D,#$-,,D&),%$&-$� L:����<M�� ;2)(2�5+=� &),#%$#� #2-)$� +99-(#!

��.� � �"� 4+$#)('1+$�

�����(+"�(+',-�6)(#)5,� #%�%6-$D$-+(#� #%�%,#-",)@1=� #$)6)+1� ),,'-,����

� #%&),41+=� +� ,#$+"7-� 1+(C� %9� +99-(#� ;2-"� &),(',,)"7� #2-� 6)%1-"(-�� %$� #%

/������ G� ��������� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� ���� �00D0�� L,#+#)"7� #2+#� : H#K2-� 7$-+#5+F%$)#=�%9�@+##-$-$,�4$%F-(#� +�4'@1)(� )5+7-� #2+#� ),� )"� ,2+$4� (%"#$+,#� #%� #2-�4$)6+#-$-+1)#=�%9�#2-)$�@-2+6)%$�+"&�+##)#'&-,< MA��2-$=1��+""+��-��1�� � ��"���#�+���� ��!�� ��� %�� ����� ���� ��� ��� ��� !�������� %����� ����� ��B� ���!� �!� ���!� �*.B�� �*�*L�BB�M� L"%#)"7� #2+#� F'&7-,� +"&� %#2-$,� %9#-"� )&-"#)9=� ;)#2� #2-� @+##-$-$,� ;2%� 5+=+44-+$�: (2+$5)"7��$-,4-(#9'1��+"&�4-$,'+,)6-< MA��+#21--"�>+)#,���� �������������� ����"������#�����������@��������.�� ������������!��!����!�0B���.�L�BB*M�L"%#)"7�+,'$6)6%$8,� (%55-"#�� : �',,�� ;)#2� 2),� (2+$5)"7� @+##-$-$8,� &-5-+"%$�� ;%"� -6-$=#)5-< M!

���� �����+'$+��$)#-,�G��%""+��%C-$���� �*����� � ���� � � 5�����+���+�#�����>��������� ��"� ���� ����������� ����������� ��"������� 0�� ������ !�� B�� .�D.�L�B**M!

��0� ����/������G���������������"%#-�����+#��0�!

���� ���,� ������ �+"")"7� 6!� >)-(C%;,C)�� %!� �.DB*D���*�� �BBB� >�� ��*��B�� +#� S�L�)""!��#!�44!��+$!�B���BBBM� L9)"&)"7�"%�-$$%$� )"� #2-�+,,-,,5-"#�%9� +"� -6+1'+#%$+"&�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#�#2+#�#2-�9+#2-$� ),�:;)11)"7�+"&�(+4+@1-�%9� #%")"7�&%;"�2),�+"7-$+"&� "-7+#)6)#=� #%;+$&� H5%#2-$�� @'#� 5%#2-$K� ,--5,� 4$-%(('4)-&� ;)#2� 5+C)"7H$-,4%"&-"#K� %'#� #%� @-� +� 6)11+)"� ;)#2%'#� F',#� (+',-< M!� � �#� ),� (%"6-"#)%"+1� ;),&%5+5%"7� +&6%(+#-,� #2+#� +"7$=� 6)(#)5,� %9� +@',-� +$-� ,--"� +,� 1-,,� ($-&)@1-!� � �"--E41+"+#)%"� ),� )7"%$+"(-�� ,%5-� F'&7-,� +"&� -6+1'+#%$,� -E4-(#� +� : 6)(#)5< � #%� +(#2-141-,,� %$� 4+,,)6-!� � >2-"� #2-=� +44-+$� +"7$=� %$� -6-"� ,#$%"7�� #2-=� (%"#$+&)(#� #2-,#-$-%#=4-!���%;-6-$��)#�,--5,�1)C-1=�#2+#�7-"&-$�@)+,�+1,%�41+=,�+�$%1-!��9#-$�+11��;2)1-(%'$#,� #=4)(+11=�"-7+#)6-1=� F'&7-� +�;%5+"�;2%� ),� +"7$=� %"� #2-� ,#+"&�� #2-=� ,--5� #%2+6-�5%$-�,=54+#2=�9%$�+�9+#2-$�;2%�),�+"7$=��-!7!��@-(+',-�2),�;)9-�2+,�;)#22-1&�#2-(2)1&$-"�9$%5�2)5!

��.� ���� %+"��-)-$��-� �� ����� �� �����������#� �� ���� ���� %����������� ���� �����%����� ������� ��� ���!�������� ���*���������%��� �����0����������!����!��0B������0L�BB�M��H2-$-)"+9#-$��-)-$��-� ������� �������������K�L&-,($)@)"7�-1-5-"#,�%9�����+"&�2%;�#2-=�(+"�+99-(#�@+##-$-&�;%5-"8,�#-,#)5%"=M!� ��%$�+�@$)11)+"#�+"&�"'+"(-&&),(',,)%"�%9� #$+'5+�+"&�,'$6)6%$,�%9�&%5-,#)(� +@',-�� ,--� ����������������

�����������L�BB0M!

���! �"�%"-�%((+,)%"�� #2-�(1)-"#� )"��+,-�0�@-(+5-�-E#$-5-1=�+7)#+#-&�;2-"�2-$@+##-$-$� ;+1C-&� &%;"� #2-� 2+11;+=� %9� #2-� (%'$#2%',-� +9#-$� 2-$� L+"&� 5=,-19M� +"&;+6-&�+�"-;,4+4-$�)"�2-$�9+(-�;2)1-�5+C)"7�+"�+"7$=�,#+#-5-"#!���'(2�@-2+6)%$�5+=;-11�2+6-�#$)77-$-&�2-$�4+,#�-E4-$)-"(-�%9�@-)"7�,#+@@-&�@=�2)5�L+"&�%#2-$�+,,+'1#,M+"&�5+=�2+6-�9-1#�9+$�5%$-�#2$-+#-")"7�#2+"�)#�+44-+$-&�#%�#2-�%'#,)&-�%@,-$6-$!

35

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�B0 ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

7)771-� )"+44$%4$)+#-1=!���

� � �2',�� #2-� 9%$-",)(� 4,=(2)+#$),#� )"� �+,-� 0&-,($)@-&�5=�(1)-"#8,�+99-(#�+,�: 6-$=�,#$+"7-�< �"%#-&�#2+#�)#�;+,�:2+$&#%� #-11� ;2+#� ,2-� 9--1,�< � +"&� &-,($)@-&� +� :41+,#)(D1)C-� ;+11< � @-#;--"#2-5!� � /%#2� 2-� +"&� #2-� -E4-$#� ;)#"-,,� %"� @+##-$)"7� "%#-&� 2-$)"+44$%4$)+#-�7)771)"7A�2%;-6-$�%"1=� #2-� 1+##-$�;+,�+@1-� #%� 1)"C� #2+#@-2+6)%$� #%� 2-$� #$+'5+#)3+#)%"!

���� � �"� ,2%$#�� +11� #2-� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,

;)#2%'#� ,4-()9)(�&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�-E4-$#),-�;2%� ,%'72#� #%� -6+1'+#-#2-� 9+(#,� )"� �+,-� 0� 2+&� #$%'@1-� 9)"&)"7� 5=� (1)-"#� #%� @-� ($-&)@1-!>)#2%'#� #2-� ����� 9$+5-;%$C� 9%$� '"&-$,#+"&)"7� 2-$� &-5-+"%$�� )#;+,��+#�@-,#��,)541=�%99D4'##)"7��+"&�+#�;%$,#��5+&-�2-$�+44-+$�9+C-!

�2',�� F'&7-,� +"&� -6+1'+#%$,� 1+(C)"7� )"D&-4#2� C"%;1-&7-� +@%'#&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +"&� �����5+=� -+,)1=� @-�5),1-&� )"#%� #$',#)"7� #2-(+15��,)"(-$-D,%'"&)"7�+((',-&8,�6-$+()#=�5%$-�#2+"�#2-�: ,#$+"7-< �%$-5%#)%"+1�4'$4%$#-&�6)(#)58,!

��*

"� ���� ��������+� ����������������������

�%$� +11� #2-� $-+,%",� &),(',,-&� +@%6-�� (%'$#,8� 9)$,#� 1)"-� %9� &-9-",-+7+)",#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +11-7+#)%",� ),� %9#-"� &),@-1)-9!� � �%;-6-$�5+"=� (%'$#,� +1,%�5+$7)"+1)3-�%$� "-'#$+1)3-� ,'(2� +11-7+#)%",� ;)#2%'#%6-$#1=�#+C)"7�+�,#+"&�+7+)",#�#2-�5%#2-$��5-$-1=�@=�2-;)"7�9)$51=�#%#2-� :"-'#$+1< � $%1-� +"&� #$-+#)"7� @%#2� 4+$-"#,� : -?'+11=!< � � �2',� +(%55%"� $-,4%",-� #%� #2-� &)99)('1#=� )"� -6+1'+#)"7� #2-� #$'#2� )"� #2-,-(+,-,�),�#%�@1+5-�@%#2�4+$#)-,�9%$�#2-�:5-,,�< �+"&�+@&)(+#-�#2-�&'#=�#%9)"&� #2-� 9+(#,�� #2-� F'&7-� %$� -6+1'+#%$� ,)541=� ,+=,� #2+#� #2-(%"#$+&)(#)%",�%9�#2-�#;%�4+$#)-,�5+C-�"-)#2-$�%"-�($-&)@1-!�� '&7-,8$-,),#+"(-�#%�9)"&)"7�#2-�9+(#,�),�,)7"+1-&�;2-"�#2-=�(2+$+(#-$)3-�#2-&),4'#-�%6-$�+@',-�+,�:5'&,1)"7)"7< �L+,�)"��+,-�0M�%$��5%$-�4%1)#-1=�+�: ,;-+$)"7�(%"#-,#!<

��B

�2',�� )"� �+,-� 0� +@%6-�� #2-� 9%$-",)(� 4,=(2)+#$),#� +"&� #2-� ,%()+1;%$C-$�;2%�&)&�#2-�2%5-�,#'&=�,#+#-&�#2+#�#2-=�(%'1&�"%#�C"%;�#2-#$'#2�� 7)6-"� #2-� (%"#$+&)(#)%",� @-#;--"� #2-� 4+$#)-,8� ,#%$)-,!

�0�� � �2-

F'&7-�-6-"�5%$-�-E41)()#1=� $-4-+#-&1=� -E4$-,,-&�2),� 9$',#$+#)%"�;)#2

���� �����-)-$��-� ������� ��������������������"%#-���.��+#������L-E41+)")"7�#2+#

,'(2�+"�+99-(#�(+"�(+',-�%@,-$6-$,�#%�,--�#2-�6)(#)5�+,�;-)$&�%$�9+@$)(+#)"7M!

���! �-4%$#�%9��6+"��#+$C�������"%#-�*���+#�0�!

��*� �����%5@+$&)�������"%#-��B��+#��+$#�.�L"%#)"7�#2+#�%9#-"�;%5-"�+$-�)"�+�: "%D;)"< �,)#'+#)%"�+"&�+$-�($)#)()3-&�9%$��� �����&-5-+"%$�#2-=�-E2)@)#M�L?'%#)"7��)1--"�)"7���)$-(#%$���!�!�%99)(-�%9� ',#)(-�9%$��2)1&$-"M!� � �9� #2-=�+$-�-5%#)%"+1�� #2-=�+$-#$-+#-&�+,�2=,#-$)(+1�%$�6-"7-9'1!��������9�#2-=�+$-�(+15��#2-=�+$-�(2+$+(#-$)3-&�+,�: (%1&+"&�(+1('1+#-&!< �����

��B� �����+"-=�6!�>$-"���00��%!�0&��.���*� L�+!��#!�44!� �BB*MA� �$--&5+"�� ����"%#-�����+#��+$#���L&-,($)@)"7�(%'$#,8�+6%)&+"(-�%9�9+(#D9)"&)"7M!

�0�� �����-4%$#,�%9��%()+1�>%$C-$�+"&��%$-",)(��,=(2)+#$),#�)"��+,-�0�L%"�9)1-�;)#2+'#2%$M!

36

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �B�

#2-�(%"#$+&)(#)%",�@-#;--"�#2-�4+$#)-,��2),�)"+@)1)#=�#%�C"%;�#2-�#$'#2�+"&�2),�&),#$',#�%9�@%#2�4+$#)-,8�#-,#)5%"=!���-�9+)$1=�?')(C1=�+&%4#-&#2-� ,#+"(-� #2+#� #2-� #;%� 4+$#)-,� ,2%'1&� 2+6-� "%� (%"#+(#� ;)#2� -+(2%#2-$�� +"&� #2+#� ,'(2� (%"#+(#� ;+,� : +� &),+,#-$!< � � �-� ;)11)"71=� ),,'-&)"#-$)5� %$&-$,� $-?')$)"7� @%#2� 4+$#)-,� #%� $-9$+)"� 9$%5� &-$%7+#%$=(%55-"#,�)"�9$%"#�%9�#2-�(2)1&�+"&�$-?')$)"7�#2-5�#%�,#+=�+;+=�9$%5-+(2�%#2-$!� ��-�;+,�(+$-9'1� #%�5+C-�(1-+$� #2+#�-+(2�,'(2�%$&-$�;+,"%#� 4$-5),-&� '4%"� +"=� 9)"&)"7� %9� $-,4%",)@)1)#=� %$� @1+5-�� @'#� ;+,-,,-"#)+11=� +"� +(C"%;1-&75-"#� #2+#� #2-� 4+$#)-,� : (+""%#� 7-#� +1%"7!<�"� 9+(#�� #2),� $-D9$+5-� ;+,� (%"#$+&)(#-&� @=� #2-� 9+(#� #2+#� 5%,#� %9� #2-;%$,#� 6)%1-"(-�� )"(1'&)"7� #2-� ,#+@@)"7�� #2$-+#,� #%� C)11�� +"&� ,#+1C)"7L+"&� 4%,,)@1=� ,-E'+1� +@',-� %9� #2-� (2)1&M�� 2+&� %(('$$-&� +9#-$� #2-4+$#)-,�2+&�,-4+$+#-&�L+7+)",#��$!�/-",%"8,�;)11M!

�)"+11=��@%#2�4+$#)-,�;-$-�@-$+#-&�9%$�@$)"7)"7�#2),�&),4'#-�)"#%�#2-(%'$#$%%5��$+#2-$�#2+"�;%$C)"7�)#�%'#� 1)C-�:5+#'$-�+&'1#,�< �+"&�9%$,'@F-(#)"7� #2-)$� (2)1&� #%� : #2-� 4%1)(-!< � � /%#2� 4+$#)-,� ;-$-� +1,%($)#)()3-&� 9%$� +,,+'1#)"7� -+(2� %#2-$!� � L�,!� �'$"-$� 2+&� #-,#)9)-&� #2+#,2-�2)#��$!�/-",%"�;)#2�+�6+,-�#2-�")72#�2-�@$%C-�)"�+"&�,#+@@-&�2-$A@%#2� 4+$#)-,� $-(-)6-&� 2%,4)#+1� #$-+#5-"#!M� � �2-� F'&7-� $-4-+#-&1=#2$-+#-"-&�#%�4'"),2�#2-�4+$#)-,�@=�$-5%6)"7�#2-�(2)1&�9$%5�@%#2�%9#2-5�+"&�41+()"7�2-$�)"�9%,#-$�(+$-!

�0�

�)5)1+$1=�� )"� +� 4$%#-(#)%"� %$&-$� (+,-� )"��+$=1+"&�� #2-� F'&7-� #%1&�� � 4+$#)-,� : =%'8$-� ,-##)"7� +� $-+1� 7%%&� -E+541-� 9%$� =%'$(2)1&$-"!�!�!�!< � � �2),� ;+,� +9#-$� #2-� +@',)6-� 9+#2-$�� ;2%� 2+&� +1$-+&=@--"� ($)5)"+11=� (%"6)(#-&� %9� +,,+'1#)"7� #2-�5%#2-$�� 2+&� $-4-+#-&1=#+1C-&�@+(C�#%�#2-�4$)%$�F'&7-��#+'"#-&�#2-�5+$,2+1,�@=�,+=)"7�: =%'8$-7%)"7� #%� 2+6-� #%� 4'#� 5-� )"� F+)1�< � +"&� (%"#)"'-&� #%� #2$-+#-"� #2-5%#2-$!� � �2-� F'&7-� #%� ;2%5� #2-� +@',-$� +(#-&� ,%� (%"#-54#'%',1=,#+#-&�� : �� &%"8#� ;+"#� #%� 4%'$� C-$%,-"-� %"� #2-� 9)$-� #2+#8,� +1$-+&=@'$")"7� )"� #2),�(+,-!�!�!�!� H�� #$=K�!�!�!� #%�&-D-,(+1+#-� #-",-� $-1+#)%",2)4,@-#;--"�#2-�4+$#)-,!<

�00� ��'(2�,#+#-5-"#,��;2)1-�4$-,-"#-&�+,�"-'#$+1

L@-(+',-� 5-$-1=� +&6%(+#)"7� +� 4$)6+#-� ,-##1-5-"#M� +$-� +(#'+11=4'"),2)"7� #2-�5%#2-$�@=� +,,)7")"7�2-$�4+$#)+1� $-,4%",)@)1)#=� 9%$� #2-9+#2-$8,�+@',)6-�(%"&'(#!

�0�

�0�� ���� �+2%"-=�� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� .�� L&-,($)@)"7� +� (+,-� )"� ;2)(2� +� ;-19+$-

&-4+$#5-"#� $-(%55-"&-&� #2+#� +� @+@=� ,#+=� )"� +� #-54%$+$=� 41+(-5-"#� ;)#2� #2-9+#2-$8,� 4+$-"#,�� %"� #2-� 7$%'"&,� #2+#� : #2-� 9+(#� #2+#� #2-)$� ,#%$)-,� H;-$-K� ,%(%"#$+&)(#%$=�5+C-,�@%#2�4+$-"#,�,--5�'"$-1)+@1-!< M�L()#)"7�����/��>���>��

/�������>���������L�B*�MM!

�00� �����-%$7-��+$&"-$����� ���� �� �� ��A� �� ���������,� �� ����� 5����C���� �*)�*)����� ���������>��!�������'7!�����BB���+#���!

�0�! �'(2�4'$4%$#-&�:"-'#$+1)#=< �)"�$-,4%",-�#%�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�),�"%#�"-'#$+1)"�-99-(#!���+#2-$��)#�9'$#2-$,�#2-�4%;-$�%9�#2-�+@',-$�+"&�#2-�"-7+#)6-�)54+(#,�%9�#2-+@',-!��/=�+11%;)"7�+@',-�#%�@-�4-$4-#$+#-&�+"&�$-9',)"7�#%�-,#+@1),2�+�(%",-?'-"(-

37

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�B. ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

�� @-1)-6-� #2),� 6)-;I #2+#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�� 1)C-� +11� %#2-$$-1+#)%",2)4� ),,'-,�� ),� +� 5'#'+1� 4$%@1-5I ),�� (%",),#-"#� ;)#2� #2--?'+1)#=� 4$)"()41-�� +#� #2-� $%%#� %9� 5+"=� (%'$#,8� '",+#),9+(#%$=$-,4%",-,� #%� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +11-7+#)%",� )"� (',#%&=� (+,-,!� � �"4+$#)('1+$�� #2-� @-1)-9� )"� 5'#'+1)#=� +44-+$,� %9#-"� #%� 7')&-� 5+"=5-"#+1� 2-+1#2� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,� )"6%16-&� )"� -6+1'+#)%",� )"� ,'(2� (+,-,!

�0.

/-(+',-�#2),�(%",#$'(#�),�,%�(-"#$+1U+"&�7+)")"7�+�7$%;)"7�9%11%;)"7�4+$#)('1+$1=� +5%"7� (',#%&=� -6+1'+#%$,U�� ;)11� #+C-� +� 5%5-"#� #%(%",)&-$�)#�5%$-�&--41=�2-$-!

6� ��3��� � ����� ��� ����� ��+� ���� ��%����� ���

�-#�5-�4%,)#�#2-�9%11%;)"7�6)-;�%9�+�2=4%#2-#)(+1�(',#%&=�-6+1'+#%$�6)%1-"(-�� 1)C-� -5%#)%"+1� +@',-� %$� +"=� %#2-$� ($'-1� @-2+6)%$�� #+C-,41+(-�;)#2)"�+�$-1+#)%",2)4�@-#;--"�#;%�4-%41-!���-;�&="+5)(,�;)#2)"$-1+#)%",2)4,�+$-�,%1-1=�(+',-&�@=�%"-�4-$,%"!���+#2-$��#2-�(2+$+(#-$%9� +� $-1+#)%",2)4� ),� #=4)(+11=� &-9)"-&� @=� )"#-$+(#)%",� +"&� $-+(#)%",@-#;--"� #2-� #;%� 4-$,%"+1)#)-,!� ��%$-%6-$�� #2-� +"+1=,),� +&6+"(-&� @=+"+1=,#,� 1)C-� /+"($%9#� +"&� �)16-$5+"�� +"&� 5+"=� +&6%(+#-,�� ;2)(29%(',-,� ,%1-1=�%"� �� �� ����,� 1-+6-,� %'#� ($)#)(+1� )"9%$5+#)%"�� ,'(2� +,#2-� 4+$-"#+1� (+4+()#=� %9� #2-� 5%#2-$�� +"&� 2-$� (%"#$)@'#)%"� #%� #2-4$%@1-5,�)"�#2-�$-1+#)%",2)4!���2-�: +&6%(+(=�4-$,4-(#)6-�< �+,�)#�5)72#@-� #-$5-&�� ,--5,� #%� +@,%16-� 5%#2-$,� %9� +11� $-,4%",)@)1)#=� 9%$4$%@1-5,�;)#2)"�#2-�$-1+#)%",2)4�%$�-6-"�;)#2)"�2-$,-19!���"�9+(#��-6-")"�+"�+@',)6-� $-1+#)%",2)4��"-)#2-$�4+$#=� ),�4-$9-(#!� � 1#2%'72� ,%5-;%5-"� 5+"+7-� #%� $-5+)"� -E(-11-"#� 5%#2-$,� ;2)1-� -E4-$)-"()"74+$#"-$� +@',-�� +#� #2-� %#2-$� -E#$-5-� ,%5-� ;%5-"� #2-5,-16-,� +$-6)%1-"#�%$�+@',)6-!���%,#�;%5-"�+$-�4$%@+@1=�)"�#2-�5)&&1-A�#2-=�+$-2'5+"�@-)"7,�+"&�5%#2-$,�;)#2�#2-)$�%;"�91+;,!

,� +"� +&6%(+#-� �� 5',#� +(C"%;1-&7-� #2+#�� %6-$� 5=� =-+$,� %9$-4$-,-"#)"7� @+##-$-&� ;%5-"�� �� 2+6-� 2+&� (1)-"#,� ;)#2� &$'7+&&)(#)%",�� ;)#2�5-"#+1� )11"-,,�� ;2%� 1)C-&� #%� 9$-?'-"#1=� 7%� %'#� +"&:4+$#=< � +#�")72#� &-,4)#-�2+6)"7� =%'"7� (2)1&$-"� +#� 2%5-�� +"&� +� 9-;;2%� ;-$-� +#� 1-+,#� -5%#)%"+11=� +"&� ,%5-#)5-,� 42=,)(+11=� +@',)6-� #%#2-)$� (2)1&$-"!� � �%5-� (%'$#� %4)")%",� &-,($)@-� 5%#2-$,� ;2%� +$-

%$� +((%'"#+@)1)#=�� )#� 9'$#2-$,� #2-� #-$$%$)3)"7� +"&�2+$+,,5-"#�� #-+(2-,� (2)1&$-"� #2+#+@',-�,'((--&,��+"&�$-)"9%$(-,�#2-�@+##-$-$8,�)",),#-"(-�#2+#�#2-�6)(#)5�),�-?'+11=�L%$5%$-M�#%�@1+5-!

�0.! "� %"7%)"7� #2-5-� )"� &-@+#-,� %"� #2-� �����D��� 1),#,-$6� 2+,� @--"� #2-+&6%(+#-,8�+,,-$#)%"�#2+#�@+##-$)"7�),�"-6-$�+5-"+@1-�#%�F%)"#�$-,4%",)@)1)#=�+"&�#2+#)#� #$'54,�5%,#�%#2-$�&-9)()#,� #2-�5%#2-$D6)(#)5�5+=�2+6-��(%'"#-$-&�@=� #2-�5-"#+12-+1#2�-6+1'+#%$,8�+,,-$#)%",�#2+#�#%�+,,'5-�#2-�;%5+"�),�#-11)"7�#2-�#$'#2��+"&�#2+#6)%1-"(-� #$'54,� +11� %#2-$� ),,'-,�� ;%'1&� (%",#)#'#-�'"-#2)(+1� @)+,� %"� #2-�4+$#� %9� +"-6+1'+#%$!���$-1+#-&�4-$,4-(#)6-�%9�5+"=�5-"#+1�2-+1#2�4$%9-,,)%"+1,�+44-+$,�#%�@-#2-�6)-;�#2+#�$-1+#)%",2)4�4$%@1-5,�+$-�"-6-$�+##$)@'#+@1-�#%�%"1=�%"-�4+$#=!

38

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �B�

,1%44=�� &%� "%#� @+#2-� #2-� (2)1&$-"� $-7'1+$1=�� +"&� 5+=� 9--&� #2-(2)1&$-"� )"+44$%4$)+#-1=!

�0�� � >2)1-� 5%,#� %9� 5=� (1)")(8,� (1)-"#,� 2+6-

+(#'+11=�@--"�+&5)$+@1-�5%#2-$,��%"-� #$+7)(+11=�C)11-&�2-$�-)72#--"D5%"#2� %1&� &+'72#-$� ;2)1-� 2-+$)"7� 6%)(-,!� � �#� ),� +1,%� #$'-� #2+#�� +,&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+&6%(+#-,��;-�#-"&�#%�,+=�+,�1)##1-�+,�4%,,)@1-�+@%'#%'$�(1)-"#,8�91+;,!

�%;-6-$�� (',#%&=� -6+1'+#%$,� +"&� F'&7-,� +$-� %@1)7+#-&� #%� 1%%C� +##2%,-� 91+;,�� +"&� #%� ;-)72� #2-5!� � �2-� ?'-,#)%"� 9%$� ,'(2� "-'#$+1-6+1'+#%$,�),�;2-#2-$�#%�;-)72�#2-�9+#2-$8,�6)%1-"(-�5%$-�2-+6)1=�#2+"#2-�5%#2-$8,�"%"D6)%1-"#� 91+;,!� ��%�+&&�#%� #2-�:"-'#$+1< �-6+1'+#%$8,4%,)#)%"����5)72#�"%#-�#2+#�%'$�(1)-"#,�+"&�5+"=�+&6%(+#-,�2+6-�1%"7+$7'-&� #2+#� #2-� 6)%1-"(-�&%-,�"%#� (+4#'$-� #2-�;2%1-� 4-$,%"�%9� #2-+@',-$A� )"&--&�� #2-� 1+@-1� : +@',-$< �&%-,�"%#� +&-?'+#-1=� (%"6-=� #2+#,%5-� 6)%1-"#� 9+#2-$,� +$-� +1,%� C)"&�� 1%6)"7�� +99-(#)%"+#-�� 2'5%$%',�+"&�&--41=�)"6%16-&�;)#2�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"!

�0����'$�(1)-"#,�2+6-�1%6-&�#2-

;2%1-� 4-$,%"� )"� #2-)$� 4+$#"-$� +"&� +,C� ',� #%� '"&-$,#+"&� #2+#A� ;2=,2%'1&�-6+1'+#%$,�+"&�(%'$#,�"%#����������(%",)&-$�#2-�;2%1-�4-$,%"�+"&�"%#�1-#�+�9+#2-$8,�6)%1-"(-�@-�2),�,%1-�&-9)")"7�(2+$+(#-$),#)(�;2-"+,,-,,)"7�9)#"-,,�9%$�(',#%&=J

�"� $-,4%",-� #%� #2),� &-6)18,� +&6%(+(=�� �� ;+"#� #%� ,'77-,#� ,-6-$+1$-+,%",� ;2=� 6)%1-"(-� ),� &)99-$-"#�� +"&� (+""%#� @-� #$-+#-&� +,� +:5'#'+1< �4$%@1-5!���)$,#��#2-�4$-5),-�%9�#2-�:5'#'+1)#=< �4-$,4-(#)6-�� �@-�#2+#�#2-$-�+$-�#;%�-?'+1��+'#%"%5%',�+"&�5%$-�%$�1-,,�9$--)"&)6)&'+1,�)"#-$+(#)"7�)"�+�$-1+#)%",2)4!���%$�)",#+"(-��-?'+1�5'#'+1$-,4%",)@)1)#=�),�"%#�%$&)"+$)1=�(%",)&-$-&�+"�+44$%4$)+#-�+44$%+(2�#%4$%@1-5,� )"� 4+$-"#D(2)1&� $-1+#)%",2)4,�� 9%$� #2-� 6-$=� $-+,%"� #2+#(2)1&$-"�+$-�"%#�+"&�,2%'1&�"%#�@-�,--"�+,�-?'+1�+'#%"%5%',�@-)"7,;)#2� +&'1#,!

�0�� ��%;-6-$�� -6-"� )"� +&'1#� $-1+#)%",2)4,� ;)#2� "%5)"+11=

-?'+1� 4+$#"-$,�� 6)%1-"(-� +(#,� +,� +� : #$'54!< � � �2-� ;)11)"7"-,,� #%� ',-6)%1-"(-�4'#,�#2-�+@',-&�4+$#"-$�)"�9-+$�9%$�2-$�1)9-�+#�+11�#)5-,��"%#F',#�+#� #2-�4+$#)('1+$�#)5-,�;2-"��9%$�-E+541-��+�7'"�%$�9),#�),�@-)"7',-&� +7+)",#� 2-$!� ��-"(-�� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +#� 1-+,#� )54+)$,�� )9� "%#&-,#$%=,�� #2-� 4+$#"-$8,� +'#%"%5=�� 2%1&,� #2-� 5%#2-$� +"&� (2)1&$-"2%,#+7-� L5-#+42%$)(+11=M�� +"&� +11%;,� #2-� 9+#2-$� #%� #+C-� 4%;-$� %6-$

�0�� ���� �+"#� 6!� �+"#�� B0�� �!>!0&� �0��� �0BD��� L�%!� �#!� 44!� �BB�M� L+((-4#)"7

#2-,-� (1+)5,� +@%'#� #2-� 5%#2-$�� +"&� '42%1&)"7� 4$)5+$=� $-,)&-"#)+1� (',#%&=� #%� #2-9+#2-$�&-,4)#-�2),�+&5)##-&�4+,#�6)%1-"(-�+7+)",#�2-$M!

�0�� ���� +%5)� �+2"� G� %+"� �-)-$�� ��� ��� !�������� ���� (����� � 5�����������#*������ �� -��� �������� .� /!�!� ��/!� ��!� �! !� ��B�� �..D.�� L�BB�M� L&),(',,)"7� #2-4$%@1-5�;)#2�,#-$-%#=4)"7�%9�@+##-$-&�;%5-"�+"&�+@',-$,�@=�+&6%(+#-,�9%$�@+##-$-&;%5-"M!

�0�� �� ����/������G���������������"%#-�����+#����D�*��L&-,($)@)"7�)",#+"(-,)"�;2)(2�@%#2��+$&"-$�+"&� %2",#%"�+44-+$�#%�#$-+#�(2)1&$-"�+,�4+$#)+11=�%$�;2%11=$-,4%",)@1-�9%$�,-E'+1�)"6%16-5-"#,�;)#2�#2-)$�9+#2-$,M!

39

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�B� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

#2-�%#2-$� )"&)6)&'+1,� )"� #2-� 9+5)1=!� � �#� ),�"%#�+44$%4$)+#-� #%�2%1&�+,:5'#'+11=�$-,4%",)@1-< �+�4-$,%"�;2%�),�"-(-,,+$)1=�+"&�+44$%4$)+#-1=)"� 9-+$� 9$%5�2-$�4+$#"-$!� �%"-�%9� #2-)$� )"#-$+(#)%",�(+"�+(('$+#-1=@-�6)-;-&�+,�%(('$$)"7�;)#2%'#�2),�#2'5@�%"�#2-�,(+1-��-6-"�)9�#2-�1+,#+(#�%9�42=,)(+1�6)%1-"(-�%(('$$-&�=-+$,�+7%!

�#�),�#2-�',-�%9�6)%1-"(-�+,�+�5-+",�%9�%"7%)"7�4%;-$�+"&�(%"#$%1�+"&�"%#�F',#�L+,�),�%9#-"�5),#+C-"1=�@-1)-6-&M�%'#�%9�: 1+(C�%9�(%"#$%1�<#2+#�,-#,�+"�: +@',-$< �+4+$#�9$%5�+�6)(#)5�%$�4+$#"-$�;2%�%((+,)%"+11=2)#,� %'#� )"� 9$',#$+#)%"� %$� &-,4+)$!� � "&� )#� ),� #2-� ',-� %9� 6)%1-"(-� #%&%5)"+#-� +"&� (%"#$%1� +"%#2-$� 4-$,%"� #2+#� ,-#,� )#� +4+$#� 9$%5� 5%,#%#2-$�2'5+"�91+;,�%9�#2-�C)"&,�)11',#$+#-&�+@%6-!

��0*

�-(%"&��6)%1-"(-�),�#$+'5+#)(��+"&�?'+1)#+#)6-1=�&)99-$-"#�)"�)54+(#%"�@%#2�+&'1#,�+"&�(2)1&$-"��9$%5�%#2-$�91+;,�5+"=�5%#2-$,�-E2)@)#�-6-"�4%#-"#)+11=�)"(1'&)"7�&$'7�+@',-!���-(-"#�$-,-+$(2�)"&)(+#-,�#2+#(2)1&$-"� ;2%� -6-"� �� ��� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ,'99-$� ,)7")9)(+"#1=+1#-$-&�@$+)"�(2-5),#$=�%$�,#$'(#'$+1�&-6-1%45-"#!

�0B���E4-$#,�)"�4%,#D

#$+'5+#)(�,#$-,,�&),%$&-$�2+6-�1%"7�@--"�9+5)1)+$�;)#2� #2-� #$+'5+#)("+#'$-� %9� -E4-$)-"()"7� %$� @-)"7� -E4%,-&� #%� 6)%1-"(-�� 4+$#)('1+$1=;2-"�%"-�),�2-141-,,!

���� �/-(+',-�6)%1-"(-�#$)77-$,�%'$�9-+$�%9�&-+#2�

%'$� ,'$6)6+1� )",#)"(#�� )#� #%'(2-,� %'$� &--4-,#� 6'1"-$+@)1)#=� +"&� 9-+$!"&�@-(+',-�)"#)5+#-�6)%1-"(-�),�)"91)(#-&�)"#-"#)%"+11=��@=�+�2'5+"@-)"7��+"&�%"-�;2%5�;-�+$-�,'44%,-&�#%�@-�+@1-�#%�#$',#��9-;�%#2-$2'5+"� 91+;,�� )"(1'&)"7� #2%,-� 5+"=� 5%#2-$,� 5+=� &),41+=�� +$-� ,%4$%9%'"&1=�&+5+7)"7��#-$$)9=)"7��+"&�#$+'5+#)3)"7!

���

�)"+11=�� #%%� %9#-"� -6+1'+#%$,� +"&� (%'$#,� L+"&� ,+&1=�� +##%$"-=,� +,;-11M�%6-$1%%C� #2-� 9+(#� #2+#�5+"=�%9�5%#2-$,8� : (2+$+(#-$< � 91+;,� +$-#2-� ������ � %9� #2-� @+##-$)"7!� � �%$� )",#+"(-�� &$'7� +@',-� L%$� : ,-19D5-&)(+#)%"< � )"� #2-� 6-$"+('1+$M� ),� +� (%55%"� ;+=� %9� (%4)"7� ;)#2+@',-!� ��-4$-,,)%"� +"&�%#2-$�5-"#+1� &),%$&-$,� +$-� +1,%� $-(%7")3-&,-?'-1+-�#%�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-!

��0��-71-(#�%9�(2)1&$-"��9+)1'$-�#%�C--4

�0*� �����#+$C�������"%#-�����+#�B*��L-542+,)3)"7�: (%-$()%"�+"&�(%"#$%1< �+,�C-=

-1-5-"#,� %9� @+##-$)"7M!� � �� &%� "%#� )"(1'&-� 9%$(-� ',-&� )"� ,-19D&-9-",-� ;)#2)"� 5=&-9)")#)%"�%9�: 6)%1-"(-!<

�0B� ������������ �����"%#-�B�� +#���D�*� L()#)"7� $-,-+$(2�@=�/$'(-��-$$=� +#�/+=1%$�")6-$,)#=M!

���� ���� ���� +#��*D�0!� ����� ���������������� �����"%#-� ����� +#� ��� L:�,=(2%1%7)(+1#$+'5+�),�+"�+991)(#)%"�%9�#2-�4%;-$1-,,!< M!

���� ���� ���������� ������ ����� "%#-� ����� +#� �D.� L&-,($)@)"7� +"&� +"+1%7)3)"7#$+'5+#)(�-E4-$)-"(-,�)"�;+$�+"&�+#�2%5-��+"&�(%54+$)"7�,%5-�&%5-,#)(�+@',-�#%#2-�#$+'5+,�-"&'$-&�)"�(%"(-"#$+#)%"�(+54,M!

��0� �����+$=�""��'##%"������� ������������.�1������ �� ��� ��� !�������#��1������� ���� ��� �� ����� ������ ���������� 0�� ������� �!� ���!� ��B��� �00�D00� L�BB�MA�-"-1%4-��)1--"�/$=+"#�������.�(������� ��"�� ��� �� � ������#���+�)� ����"�� �' ���"���������.��/���!��!����!��������0��D���L�BBBM�L&),(',,)"7�#2-�4,=(2%1%7)(+1�)54+(#%9�+@',-�+"&�#2-�,=,#-58,�4+#2%1%7)3)"7�%9�6)(#)5,M!

40

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �B�

#2-�2%',-�%$�(2)1&$-"�(1-+"��+"&�%#2-$�:'"D5%#2-$1=< �@-2+6)%$,�5+=@-�4$-&)(#+@1-�%(('$$-"(-�()$('5,#+"(-,�;2-"�#2-�5%#2-$�),�1)6)"7�)"(%",#+"#� 9-+$�%9� 6)%1-"(-��+"&� ),�%4-$+#)"7� #%� ,'$6)6-� $+#2-$� #2+"� #%9'$#2-$�+�2-+1#2=�&+=D#%D&+=�-E),#-"(-!

���

�(2"-)&-$� +"&� 5+"=� %#2-$,� 2+6-� 4+)",#+C)"71=� &-,($)@-&� #2-42-"%5-"%"� %9� (',#%&=� (%'$#,�;2)(2� +44-+$� #%� 4-"+1)3-� +�5%#2-$;2%� ),� ,'99-$)"7� 9$%5� #2-� -99-(#,� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�� -,4-()+11=#2%,-� &)+7"%,-&� ;)#2� :@+##-$-&� ;%5+"� ,="&$%5-�< � @=� +;+$&)"7(',#%&=�#%�#2-�+@',-$!

��.���-,4)#-�#2-�+44+$-"#�)"F',#)(-�%9�4'"),2)"7

#2-�6)(#)5��)#�,--5,�(1-+$�#2+#�5+"=�(%'$#,�+"&�-6+1'+#%$,��9%(',)"7�%"#2-� 9%$;+$&D1%%C)"7� :@-,#� )"#-$-,#� %9� #2-� (2)1&< � +"+1=,),�� &--5� )#)$$-1-6+"#���� #2-�5%#2-$� ),� &-4$-,,-&�%$� #$+'5+#)3-&!� ��"&-$� #2),6)-;��)9�#2-�9+#2-$�),�+�5%$-�(+4+@1-�4+$-"#��#2-�(2)1&8,�@-,#�)"#-$-,#,5+=�$-?')$-�2)5� #%� $-(-)6-�(',#%&=��-6-"� )9�2-�+1,%�4-$4-#$+#-&� #2-#$+'5+�%$�(+',-&�#2-�5%#2-$8,�&-4$-,,)%"!��"�,2%$#��(%'$#,�5+=�9--1#2-�:@-,#�)"#-$-,#�%9�#2-�(2)1&< �5',#�@-�&-#-$5)"-&�)"&-4-"&-"#�%9: F',#)(-< �@-#;--"�#2-�4+$-"#,!

���

�%;� #2-� (1+,2� @-#;--"� : F',#)(-< � 4$)"()41-,� +"&� :@-,#� )"#-$-,#,<4$)"()41-,� ,2%'1&� @-� $-,%16-&�� )"� (+,-,� ;2-$-� #2-=� +$-� 7-"')"-1=)"(%54+#)@1-��&-,-$6-,�)#,�%;"�+$#)(1-!���%$�#2-�4'$4%,-,�%9�#2),�%"-�1-#�5-�%99-$�#2$--�$-+,%",�;2=��-6-"�;2-$-�+�5%#2-$8,�9'"(#)%")"7�),(%54$%5),-&�&'-�#%�+@',-��+�(2)1&�),�1)C-1=�"%"-#2-1-,,�#%�@-�@-##-$%99�)"�2-$�(',#%&=�#2+"�)"�#2-�+@',-$8,!

������)$,#��+�(2)1&�;2%,-�5%#2-$

2+,� @--"� +@',-&�2+,� +1$-+&=� ,'99-$-&� +� 1%,,� %9� 9'11� :5%#2-$)"7< � @=

���! ��&%�"%#�-6-"�+&&$-,,�2-$-�%#2-$�%9#D()#-&�: 91+;,< �%9�@+##-$-&�5%#2-$,�;2)(2

+$-� 5%$-� %@6)%',1=� $-,4%",-,� #%� @+##-$)"7�� ,'(2� +,� ,%5-� ;%5-"8,� +44+$-"#: )",#+@)1)#=< � %$� 9$-?'-"#� $-1%(+#)%",� #2+#� +$-� %9#-"� #$)77-$-&� @=� -99%$#,� #%� -,(+4-+@',-!���2),�),,'-�2+,�@--"�+&&$-,,-&�$-4-+#-&1=�)"�#2-�1)#-$+#'$-!�����,��������+2%"-=������"%#-�����+#�0�A��"%,�������"%#-��.��+#�0.��L�BB�M!

��.� �������������������"%#-����+#����D��!

���� �����)",-11+� 6!� �)",-11+�� �B�� !0&� ���� L! !� �BB�M� L"%#)"7� #2+#� #2-� (',#%&=(%'$#�&%-,�"%#�+&F'&)(+#-�$-1+#)6-�$)72#,�%9�4+$-"#,�@'#�%"1=�#2-�@-,#�)"#-$-,#,�%9�#2-(2)1&MA� �#+$C� �D5+)1�� ����� "%#-� *.� L"%#)"7� #2-� &)99-$-"(-� @-#;--"� : F',#)(-<4$)"()41-,� +"&� +� @-,#� )"#-$-,#,� +"+1=,),M!� � �#� ,--5,� 1)C-1=� #2+#� #2),� &),#)"(#)%"� ),� #%%7-"&-$-&!� � �#� ),� 5'(2� 2+$&-$� #%� )5+7)"-� (%'$#,� &%)"7� #2-� ,+5-� )9� #2-� $%1-,� ;-$-$-6-$,-&�L-!7!��@-)"7�;)11)"7�#%�: -E(',-< �%$�(+@)"�%99�+�5%#2-$8,�@-2+6)%$��;2-$-�,2-2+,�4-$4-#$+#-&�+�($)5-�%$� ,)7")9)(+"#�2+$5�+7+)",#� #2-� 9+#2-$M!� � �#� ,--5,� 9+$�5%$-1)C-1=�#2+#�+�5%#2-$�9%'"&�#%�2+6-�-"7+7-&�)"�6)%1-"(-�+7+)",#�#2-�9+#2-$�L%$�������M;%'1&� 1%,-� (',#%&=�� -6-"� )9� #2-� 9+#2-$8,� 9'"(#)%")"7� ;+,� 9%'"&� #%� @-� )54+)$-&� @=&-4$-,,)%"��#$+'5+��+"& %$�%#2-$�,=54#%5,�%9�2-$�+@',-!�����,��������!�!�6!�/!�!�����!�!0&��B��L�+,,!�44!��#!��BB�M�L%6-$#'$")"7�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#8,�+;+$&�%9�(',#%&=�#%#2-�9+#2-$�@+,-&�%"�#2-�5%#2-$8,�6)%1-"(-��;2-$-�#2-�1%;-$�(%'$#�2+&�&),$-7+$&-&�+4,=(2%1%7),#8,�#-,#)5%"=�#2+#�#2-�5%#2-$8,�6)%1-"(-�;+,�&-9-",)6-M!

���! �9�(%'$,-�#2-$-�+$-�+1;+=,�-E(-4#)%",!��>2-$-�+�5%#2-$�),�2-$,-19�6)%1-"#�#%#2-�(2)1&�+"&�),�'"1)C-1=�#%�(-+,-�'4%"�,-4+$+#)%"�9$%5�#2-�@+##-$-$��;2-$-�,2-�),�"%#4$%6)&)"7� +� 5)")5'5� %9� 42=,)(+1� +"&� 4,=(2%1%7)(+1� (+$-� 9%$� #2-� (2)1&�� %$� )"(%54+$+@1-� ()$('5,#+"(-,�� 9%,#-$� (+$-� 5+=� @-� #2-� 1-+,#� 2+$59'1� $-,%1'#)%"�� '"#)1,'@,#+"#)+1�,'44%$#)6-�,-$6)(-,�(+"�@-�4$%6)&-&�+"&�)54$%6-5-"#,�+$-�&-5%",#$+#-&!

41

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�B* ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

6)$#'-� %9� #2-� +@',-!� � ,,'5)"7� #2+#� #2-� 5%#2-$� ;+,� 4$-6)%',1=� #2-4$)5+$=�4+$-"#��,-"&)"7�#2-�(2)1&�#%�1)6-�;)#2�#2-�9+#2-$�;%'1&�$-,'1#)"�-6-"�7$-+#-$�1%,,�+"&�,-4+$+#)%"�#$+'5+!��>2+#�#2+#�(2)1&�"--&,�),#%� 7-#� 2),� %$� 2-$� 5%#2-$� @+(C�� )&-+11=� ;2)1-� ,2-� ),� ,'44%$#-&�,#$-"7#2-"-&��+"&�2-+1-&!

���

�-(%"&�� +"�+;+$&�%9� (',#%&=� #%� +"�+@',-$� ),� +�4%;-$9'1� 1-,,%"� #%#2-� (2)1&� #2+#� 6)%1-"(-� +"&� +@',-������ #2+#� 4%;-$� +"&� (%"#$%1� +$-#2-)$� %;"� 1+;�� +"&� #2+#� #2-� (%'$#,� +"&� ,%()-#=� ,--� L-,,-"#)+11=M"%#2)"7�;$%"7�;)#2�;2+#�#2-�9+#2-$�2+,�&%"-�#%�#2-�5%#2-$!���2-$-5+=�@-�"%�5%$-�-99-(#)6-�;+=� #%� #-+(2�(2)1&$-"� #%�@-(%5-�+@',-$,!�2),� 2+,� @--"� $-(%7")3-&� @=� ,%5-�%9� #2-�5%$-� -&'(+#-&� +44-11+#-(%'$#,!

��*

�)"+11=��+"&�4-$2+4,�5%,#� )54%$#+"#1=�� ),� #2-�4%)"#� #2+#�+&6%(+#-,2+6-�"%#�,'99)()-"#1=�5+&-�'"#)1�"%;��5-"�;2%�@+##-$�;%5-"�','+11=5+C-�@+&�4+$-"#,!

��B

�2',�� ;2)1-� @%#2� 5%#2-$,� +"&� 9+#2-$,� +$-� ','+11=� )54-$9-(#� +,4-%41-�+"&�+,�4+$-"#,��+�2),#%$=�%9�(%55)##)"7�6)%1-"(-�)"�#2-�9+5)1=),�� %$� ,2%'1&� @-�� ;-)72-&� +,� '")?'-1=� "-7+#)6-� )"� #2-� %6-$+11+,,-,,5-"#!� � �%$-%6-$�� -6-"� ;2-$-� +� 5%#2-$8,� 9'"(#)%")"7� ),(%54$%5),-&�&'-�#%�#2-�)54+(#�%9�,'(2�+@',-��+�,#$%"7�(+,-�(+"�@-5+&-� #2+#� : F',#)(-< � 4$)"()41-,� +$-� (%",%"+"#� ;)#2� :@-,#� )"#-$-,#<4$)"()41-,�@-(+',-�#2-�(2)1&$-"�;)11��� �@-�@-##-$�%99�;)#2�#2-�@+##-$-$�-6-"�)9�2-�,--5,�#%�@-�5%$-�: 9'"(#)%"+1< �)"�,%5-�$-,4-(#,!

�.�

7� ��������"���� ���C*�����)����5��� �5�� ��

�2-�4$%@1-5,�;)#2�#2-�5'#'+1)#=�4-$,4-(#)6-�+$-�($=,#+11)3-&�)"�#2-;%$C� %9� +"-#� %2",#%"� +"&� �)"&+� �+54@-11!� � %2",#%"� +"&�+54@-118,� ;%$C�� @+,-&� )"� 4+$#� %"� #2-)$� %;"� $-,-+$(2�� ,#'&)-,$-1+#)%",2)4,� )"6%16)"7� %"7%)"7� (',#%&= 6),)#+#)%"� (%"91)(#,!� � �%&-,($)@-� #2-,-� (+,-,� #2-=� (%)"-&� #2-� #-$5� :2)72D(%"91)(#� &)6%$(-�<

���! �%$-%6-$��#2-�5%#2-$�(+"�@-�-E4-(#-&�#%�$-7+)"�2-$�5-"#+1�2-+1#2��+#�1-+,#

#%� ,%5-�&-7$--�� )9� +"&�;2-"� #2-� +@',-� ),� #-$5)"+#-&!� ����,� ������+%5)��+2"��"��������������� ����������#�*������� � ��� ��� ���!�����������"����"� ���� ��������..��!��!����!����.��������"!B��L�BB�M�L()#)"7�������>����������/�������>��

�����������L�B*.MM�L"%#)"7�#2+#�@+##-$-&�;%5-"�;-$-�-)72#�#)5-,�5%$-� 1)C-1=� #%+@',-� #2-)$� (2)1&$-"� ;2-"� @-)"7� @+##-$-&� #2-5,-16-,� #2+"� ;2-"� "%#� )"� @+##-$)"7$-1+#)%",2)4,M!

��*� �����',#%&=�%9��+'72"����.�!�!0&�.�.��.�B�L�+,,!��BB�M�L&),(',,)"7�-E4-$#;)#"-,,� �-#-$� +99-8,� #-,#)5%"=� #2+#� )9� #2-� ,%"� $-5+)"-&� )"� #2-� 9+#2-$8,� (',#%&=� )#;%'1&�: $-)"9%$(-�#2-�+((-4#+@)1)#=�%9�#2-�9+#2-$8,�@-2+6)%$�#%�H#2-�,%"K�;2)(2�2+,�#2-4%#-"#)+1�#%�5+C-�H#2-�,%"K�+�@+##-$-$�2)5,-19�)"�#2-�9'#'$-< M!

��B� ������������+$#����!�!0�L&),(',,)"7�@+&�4+$-"#)"7�+#�7$-+#-$�1-"7#2M!

�.�! �"�5=�6)-;�#2),�+"+1=,),�),�+�$-+,%"+@1-�)"#-$4$-#+#)%"�%9�@-,#�)"#-$-,#,�+"+1=,),'"&-$�,#+#'#-,�L)!-!��5%,#M�$-?')$)"7�(%",)&-$+#)%"�%9�5'1#)41-�9+(#%$,��+"&�&%-,�"%#&-4-"&�%"�#2-�1-7),1+#'$-8,�+&%4#)%"�%9�+�$-@'##+@1-�4$-,'54#)%"!

42

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �BB

)#,-19� +"� )541)()#1=� :5'#'+1< � 1+@-1� 9%$� $-1+#)%",2)4,� #2-� 5+F%$)#=� %9;2)(2� )"6%16-� #2-� 5+"8,� 6)%1-"(-!

�.�� � �-6-$+1� %9� %2",#%"8,� (+,-

-E+541-,� &-5%",#$+#-� 2%;� #2-=� ,'@,'5-� 6)%1-"(-� )"#%� +� :5'#'+1<$-,4%",)@)1)#=� 5%&-1!� � �%$� )",#+"(-�� )"� %"-� (+,-�� : #2-� +'#2%$,+(C"%;1-&7-� #2+#� #2-� 9+#2-$8,� +@',)6-"-,,� +"&� (%"#$%11)"7� @-2+6)%$#%;+$&�#2-�&+'72#-$�;-$-�'"$-1-"#)"7�+9#-$�,-4+$+#)%"�&-,4)#-�-99%$#,+#� #2-$+4-'#)(� )"#-$6-"#)%"�!�!�!� H=-#� #2-=� ,#+#-K� )"(%"7$'%',1=� #2+# '1)+""-8,�(+,-�)11',#$+#-,� ������� ���� �� ��2����� ���������� ���� ������$+#2-$� #2+"� #2-� )54+(#� %9� #2-� 9+#2-$8,� +@',)6-"-,,!<

�.0� � �"� +"%#2-$�

%2",#%"� +"&� �+54@-11� &-,($)@-� +� (%'41-� )"� ;2)(2� #2-� 5+"� 2+&4%)"#-&�+�7'"�+"&�42=,)(+11=�+,,+'1#-&�2),�4+$#"-$�#;)(-��=-#�#2-=�,#+#-#2+#� #2-� 4+$#)-,� 2+6-� : ,%5-;2+#� )$$+#)%"+1� )5+7-,< � %9� -+(2� %#2-$�$-9-$$)"7� #%� #2-�;%5+"8,� 9-+$� %9� #2-�5+"!

�.�� � �)5)1+$1=�� ;2)1-� ()#)"7

,-6-$+1� (+,-� -E+541-,� )"� ;2)(2� #2-� 5+"� ',-&� ,'@,#+"#)+1� 6)%1-"(-�)"(1'&)"7� &-+#2� #2$-+#,�� +"&� 2+,� (%"#)"'-&� #%� ',-� :%((+,)%"+16)%1-"(-�< � #2-� +'#2%$,� "%"-#2-1-,,� ($)#)()3-� #2-� ;%5-"� 9%$� #2-)$$-1'(#+"(-�#%�@-1)-6-�#2-�9+#2-$�2+,�(2+"7-&�,'99)()-"#1=!

�..� �/+"($%9#

+"&��)16-$5+"�+1,%�"%#-� #2+#� %2",#%"�+"&��+54@-11� :%99-$� 6+$)%',-E41+"+#)%",�9%$�(2)1&$-"8,�$-1'(#+"(-�#%�6),)#�;)#2�#2-�"%"D(',#%&)+14+$-"#� )"� R2)72D(%"91)(#8� (+,-,�� "%"-� %9� ;2)(2� 2+,� #%� &%� ;)#2� #2-9+#2-$8,�+@',)6-"-,,!�!�!�!<

�.����)"+11=��#2-=�,#+#-�#2+#�)"�:&%3-",< �%9�(+,-

&-,($)4#)%",�� %2",#%"�+"&��+54@-11�: 9+)1�#%�%99-$�-6-"�%"-�)"�;2)(2+�5%#2-$�+(#,�+,�+"�+44$%4$)+#-�4$%#-(#)6-�4+$-"#�+9#-$� ,-4+$+#)%"A<$+#2-$��5%#2-$,�;2%�,--C� #%�$-,#$)(#� 6),)#+#)%"�+$-�($)#)()3-&��-6-"� )"#2-�9+(-�%9�(%"#)"')"7�: ,4%$+&)(< �6)%1-"(-!

�.�

�2-� 4$-5),-� %9� 5'#'+1)#=� %"� ;2)(2� 5'(2� %9� %2",#%"� +"&�+54@-118,�+"+1=,),�),�4$-&)(+#-&��#2-"��,)541=�$-4-+#,�#2-�@1+5)"7�%95%#2-$,� 9%$� #2-)$� @-2+6)%$,� #2+#� $-,4%"&� #%� 9+#2-$,8� 6)%1-"(-!� �2-+'#2%$,8�1+(C�%9�$-,4-(#�9%$�#2-�$-+1�&+5+7-�+"&�&+"7-$�#%�(2)1&$-"9$%5� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ),� -6)&-"#� )"� #2-)$� &),(',,)%"� %9� 4$%#-(#)%"

�.�! /������ G� ��������� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� ���� L"%#)"7� #2+#� +� 2),#%$=� %9

&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�-E),#-&�)"�+44$%E)5+#-1=���Q�%9�#2-�)"#$+(#+@1-�(',#%&=�(%"91)(#, %2",#%"�+"&��+54@-11�,#'&)-&M�L()#)"7� ����!� ������G������!�!����/������������ ��� ��������� ���� ������� �� ���������� ��� ������ �������� L�B**MM!�2-�9%11%;)"7�&),(',,)%"�%9� %2",#%"�+"&��+54@-118,�;%$C�),�2-+6)1=�)"&-@#-&�#%�#2-,'55+$=�+"&�($)#)?'-�(%"#+)"-&�)"�/������G���������������"%#-�����+#����D.B!

�.0! /������G���������� �����"%#-�����+#�����L-542+,),� )"�%$)7)"+1M�L()#)"7 ����!� ������G������������/��������������������������������������

������� ��� ���������� �� ������� �������� ��� ���������� �� ������

��������L�BB�MM!

�.�� ����+#����!

�..� ����L()#)"7� ������G����/����������"%#-��.���+#�0��D�*M!

�.�� ��!

�.�� ����+#���.!

43

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

%$&-$,I ;2)(2� +$-� $-9-$-"(-&� +,� @-)"7� %((+,)%"+11=� ,%'72#� @=5%#2-$,�;)#2�4'$4%$#-&�:4+$+"%)&�#-"&-"()-,!<

�.�

%2",#%"8,�;%$C�2+,�@--"�;)&-1=�&),,-5)"+#-&��@%#2�+5%"7�5-"#+12-+1#2� -6+1'+#%$,� +"&� #%� F'&7-,!� � �#� 2+,� @-(%5-� +� 4%4'1+$� "-;:+'#2%$)#=< � 9%$� (',#%&=� (+,-,� )"6%16)"7� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�� @-(+',-�'"1)C-�5%,#�5-"#+1�2-+1#2�4$%9-,,)%"+1,8�&),(',,)%",�%9� (',#%&=� +"&&)6%$(-�� )#� +(C"%;1-&7-,� +"&� &),(',,-,� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� )"� ,%5-&-#+)1!���"9%$#'"+#-1=��)"�5+"=�$-,4-(#,�)#�5)")5)3-,�#2-�,)7")9)(+"(-+"&� )54+(#� %9� #2-� +@',-�� 5+C)"7� #2-� +"+1=,),� @%#2� ,-&'(#)6-� +"&&+"7-$%',!

� *��� ����%� � ��� ���!������������������� � �� ���� ����.�%���� ������ ��"������.�(� ��������2�����

�2-�#2)$&�+"&�-E#$-5-1=�(%55%"�&="+5)(�)"�(',#%&=�1)#)7+#)%"�)";2)(2� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ),� +11-7-&� ),� (%'$#,8� $-,),#+"(-� #%� 2-+$)"7+@%'#� #2-� 6)%1-"(-� %$� #%� $-(%7")3)"7� #2-� $-1-6+"(-� %9� #2%,-+11-7+#)%",� #%� #2-� 9'#'$-� ;-11D@-)"7� %9� #2-� (2)1&$-"!� � �%'$#,� @%#2-E41)()#1=�+"&� )541)()#1=� )"6%C-� #;%�$+#)%"+1-,� 9%$� $-F-(#)"7� #2),� 1)"C�L�M�#2+#�2+$5�#%�#2-�5%#2-$�),�"%#�#2-�,+5-�+,�2+$5�#%�#2-�(2)1&A�+"&L0M� #2+#� #2-� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ;)11� -"&� ;2-"� #2-� 4+$#)-,� +$-,-4+$+#-&!

�"� ,%5-� $-,4-(#,�� @+##-$-&� ;%5-"8,� +&6%(+#-,� 2+6-� @--"� 1-+,#-99-(#)6-� )"� -&'(+#)"7� (%'$#,� +"&� ,%()-#=� +,� #%� ;2=� +� 2),#%$=� %9@+##-$)"7� ),� 4-$� ,-� 4%;-$9'11=� "-7+#)6-� &+#+� +@%'#� +� 4+$-"#8,� 9)#"-,,9%$�(',#%&=!

�.*���2-�9%11%;)"7�&),(',,)%"�%99-$,�,-6-$+1�-E+541-,�%9�#2-

4$%@1-5� +"&� #2-"� @$)-91=� +&&$-,,-,� #2-� 9+11+()-,� +#� #2-� 2-+$#� %9(%'$#,8� L+"&� -6+1'+#%$,8M� #-"&-"()-,� #%� ,-4+$+#-� @+##-$)"7� @-2+6)%$9$%5�#2-)$�#2)"C)"7�+@%'#�+�9+#2-$8,�,')#+@)1)#=�9%$�(',#%&=!

6� *��� �������� � ��� ���!������������������� � ��"������

� (%$-� (2+11-"7-� )"� 1)#)7+#)"7� �+,-� 0� ;+,� #2-� "--&� #%� $-9'#-� #2-+44+$-"#� @-1)-9� %9� #2-� F'&7-� +"&� (%'$#D+44%)"#-&� 9%$-",)(� -E4-$#,#2+#�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�;+,�"%#�(-"#$+1�#%�#2-�(',#%&=�&-(),)%"!���+$1=%"�� +9#-$� 2-+$)"7� -E#-"&-&� #-,#)5%"=� %9� +� 2),#%$=� %9� ,-6-$-� +@',-�)"(1'&)"7� +� ,#+@@)"7�� #2-� F'&7-� (+11-&� 5=� (1)-"#8,� +11-7+#)%",:5'&,1)"7)"7�< � (1-+$1=� )541=)"7� #2+#� +11� #2-� (1+)5,�%9� 6)%1-"(-�;-$-

�.�� ����+#����!

�.*! �2),�4+,#� 9+)1'$-� ),� '"&-$,#+"&+@1-!� �>-� +,,'5-&� #2+#� 6)%1-"(-��4+$#)('1+$1=;)#2)"� #2-� 9+5)1=��;%'1&�@-� ,--"�+,����� �� )"(%",),#-"#�;)#2�7%%&�4+$-"#)"7!� �,�;-2+6-�@--"�,#'""-&�#%�-E4-$)-"(-�;)&-,4$-+&�F'&)()+1�$-,),#+"(-�#%�#2),�-?'+#)%"��;-2+6-�$-(%7")3-&�#2-�"--&�#%�5%$-�-E41)()#1=�+$#)('1+#-�2%;�@+##-$)"7�),�)"&)(+#)6-�%9@+&� 4+$-"#)"7!� � /+"($%9#� +"&� �)16-$5+"�� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� 0BD���� %99-$� +"� )"(),)6--E4%,)#)%"�%9�#2),�,'@F-(#!������������"%#-���B!

44

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

)$$-1-6+"#� #%� #2-� (',#%&=� &-#-$5)"+#)%"!� � �'(2� %9� #2-� %44%,)"7(%'",-18,� (+,-� ;+,� @+,-&� %"� #2-� (1+)5� #2+#� 6)%1-"(-� #%;+$&� #2-5%#2-$� ),�"%#�2+$5� #%� #2-�(2)1&!� ��%$-%6-$��"%"-�%9� #2-� :"-'#$+1<5-"#+1�2-+1#2�-6+1'+#%$,�)"6-,#)7+#-&�%$�-6-"�+&&$-,,-&�#2-�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-�+11-7+#)%",!

�.B

�%$-� $-(-"#1=�� )"� �+,-� ��� #2-� F'&7-8,� &-#-$5)"+#)%"� #%� 7)6-� +$-,4%"&-"#I ;2%5�-6-"�2-�+44-+$-&�#%�@-1)-6-�2+&�-"7+7-&�)"�1)9-D#2$-+#-")"7� 6)%1-"(-� +7+)",#� #2-� (2)1&8,� 5%#2-$I (2)1&� 6),)#+#)%"�)"&)(+#-&�2),�'";)11)"7"-,,�#%�2%1&�+�@+##-$-$�+((%'"#+@1-������� ��9%$�2),�6)%1-"(-�+7+)",#�#2-�5%#2-$!���2),�;+,�+�5+"�;2%�2+&�$+4-&#2-� (2)1&8,� 5%#2-$� +#� C")9-D4%)"#� L;2)1-� 5+,C-&�� +9#-$� #2-=� 2+&,-4+$+#-&M��2+&�,#$+"71-&�2-$�;)#2�+�(1%#2-,1)"-��+"&�2+&�#2$-+#-"-&#%�C)11�2-$�$-4-+#-&1=!���+&�2-�@--"�4$%6-"�#%�2+6-�&%"-�#2-,-�#2)"7,#%���� ��� )"&)6)&'+1�� )#� ),�2+$&� #%� )5+7)"-� #2-5�@-)"7� )7"%$-&� )"� +(',#%&=�&-(),)%"!

������"�+"=�-6-"#��;2)1-�;-�2+&�"%#�+11-7-&�+"=�&)$-(#

(2)1&�+@',-�@=�#2-�9+#2-$��#2-�&-7$--�%9�+77$-,,)%"�9-1#�+"&�-E4$-,,-&@=� #2-�+@',-$�+7+)",#� #2-�(2)1&8,�5%#2-$� ,2%'1&�2+6-�@--"�+�('-� #%#2-�F'&7-�#2+#�#2-�(2)1&�;%'1&�@-�+#�1-+,#�-5%#)%"+11=�+#�$),C!

���

�#2-$�-6)&-"(-� #2+#� #2-�(2)1&�;%'1&�@-�+#� 1-+,#�4,=(2%1%7)(+11=�+#$),C� ;+,� #2-� +@',-$8,� -E#$-5-1=� &=,9'"(#)%"+1� +"&� '",#+@1-� 1)6)"7,)#'+#)%",�

���0�+"&�#2-�9+(#�#2+#�2-�2+&�@--"�)"6%16-&�)"�1)#)7+#)%"�%6-$

&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�;)#2�+#�1-+,#�#2$--�%#2-$�;%5-"�)"�+&&)#)%"�#%�5=(1)-"#!� ��2',��#2-�(2)1&�;+,�2)721=�1)C-1=�#%�@-�-E4%,-&�#%�(%"#)"'-&&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ;2)1-� )"� #2-� +@',-$8,� (+$-�� -6-"� )9� %"1=� 9%$6),)#+#)%"!� � �-#� #2-� (%'$#� ;%'1&� "%#� (%",)&-$� #2-� 4%,,)@)1)#=� %9� "%6),)#+#)%"�� +"&� ;+,� -E#$-5-1=� 2%,#)1-� +"&� &),4+$+7)"7� #%;+$&� #2-

�.B� ���� ������ �+$#� ���!�� L$-7+$&)"7� -6+1'+#%$,8� $-,4%",-� #%� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-

+11-7+#)%",M!

���! ,� �� 2+6-� $-91-(#-&� %"� (%'$#,8� ;)11)"7"-,,� #%� ,'@F-(#� (2)1&$-"� #%� -E#$-5-1=6)%1-"#�5-"��#%�;2%5�)#� ),� )"(%"(-)6+@1-�#2+#� F'&7-,�;%'1&�@-�;)11)"7� #%� ,-"&� #2-)$����(2)1&$-"����2+6-�(%"(1'&-&�#2+#� )#�5',#�+#�,%5-� 1-6-1� $-91-(#� #2-�%9#D"%#-&�6)-;#2+#�#2-$-�),�,%5-#2)"7�;$%"7�;)#2�#2-�5%#2-$�9%$�: ,#+=)"7< �%$�: 4'##)"7�'4�;)#2< �#2-+@',-!� � #� $%%#�� �� ,',4-(#� #2+#� 5+"=� F'&7-,� +;+$&� (2)1&$-"� #%� &+"7-$%',� 9+#2-$,@-(+',-� #2-=� 9--1� #2+#� #2-� 5)")5'5� %9� ,+9-#=� #2-=� ;%'1&� &-5+"&� 9%$� #2-)$� %;"(2)1&$-"�&%-,�"%#�+441=�;2-$-�#2-�5%#2-$�2+,�+1$-+&=�: #%1-$+#-&< �%$�: ,'@F-(#-&< �#2-(2)1&$-"�#%�#2-�5+"8,�+@',-!���"�%#2-$�;%$&,��(%",),#-"#�;)#2�5+"=�%9�#2-�&="+5)(,&),(',,-&�2-$-)"�+"&�)&-"#)9)-&�)"�#2-�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�;%$1&��,--������"%#-��.��#2-5%#2-$�),�)541)()#1=�2-1&�$-,4%",)@1-�9%$�;2+#-6-$�2+$5�2-$�(2)1&$-"�,'99-$�9$%5�2-$4+$#"-$8,�+@',-!

���! ,�"%#-&�+@%6-��#2-�5%#2-$�$-4%$#-&�#2+#�-6-$=�#)5-�#2-�-)72#D=-+$D%1&�(2)1&$-#'$"-&�9$%5�+�6),)#�;)#2�2),�9+#2-$�2-�;+,�'"(%"#$%11+@1-��+77$-,,)6-�+"&�2%,#)1-�#%;%5-"�� +"&� ,%5-#)5-,�&-(1+$-&� 2-�;+"#-&� #%�&)-!� � �2-� (%'$#� $-9',-&� #%� 2-+$� %$(%",)&-$�#2),�)"9%$5+#)%"!������������+$#��!!

��0! >2)1-�)#�+44-+$,�#2+#�#2-�9+#2-$�&)&�1%6-�#2-�(2)1&�L)"�+�"+$(),,),#)(�5+""-$M�2-�;+,�"%#� )"�9+(#�(+4+@1-�%9� #+C)"7�+&-?'+#-�(+$-�%9�2)5!���'$)"7�#2-�9)$,#�=-+$�%9@-)"7� )"�2),� 9+#2-$8,�(',#%&=�� #2-�(2)1&�;+,� 1-9#�;)#2�%#2-$� $-1+#)6-,�� ,%5-�%9�;2%542=,)(+11=�+@',-&�2)5!

45

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��0 ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

5%#2-$�+"&�5=,-19�9%$�,'77-,#)"7�)#�5)72#�@-�+44$%4$)+#-!

�"� 2-$� ,'$6-=� %9� #2-� ,#+#-� �-"&-$� /)+,� ,#'&)-,�� �3+4+",C)=� 2+,"%#-&� #2+#� +##%$"-=,� +,� ;-11� +,� F'&7-,� ,--� ,4%',+1� 6)%1-"(-� +,� +9'"(#)%"� %9� 4$%@1-5,� )"� #2-� $-1+#)%",2)4�� $+#2-$� #2+"� +,� #2-4-$4-#$+#%$8,� %;"� &=,9'"(#)%"!� � �"� >+,2)"7#%"� �#+#-�� ;2-$-� 9+5)1=6)%1-"(-�),�+�,#+#'#%$=�7$%'"&�9%$�1)5)#)"7�(',#%&)+1�+((-,,��+�"'5@-$%9� +##%$"-=,� 4+$#)()4+#)"7� )"� +� ,#'&=� )"&)(+#-&� #2+#� #2-=� ;%'1&� "%#)"6-,#)7+#-�%$�$+),-�+11-7+#)%",�%9�9+5)1=�6)%1-"(-�-6-"�;2-$-�)#�;%'1&@-"-9)#� #2-)$�(1)-"#8,�(+,-�@-(+',-�: R,%5-� )"+44$%4$)+#-�@-2+6)%$8� ),4$-##=� #=4)(+1� %9� 4-%41-� 7%)"7� #2$%'72� +� &)6%$(-!< � � %� F'&7-)"6-,#)7+#-&� #2-� @-2+6)%$,� -6-"� ;2-$-� #2-=� ;-$-� +11-7-&�� &-,4)#-@-)"7�,#+#'#%$)1=�$-?')$-&�#%�&%�,%!

���

�-$2+4,� 5%$-� ,'$4$),)"7� ),� #2-� 4$-6+1-"(-� %9� (%'$#,� ;2)(2+(C"%;1-&7-�+�9+#2-$8,�4-$4-#$+#)%"�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-��=-#�#$-+#�)#+,� )$$-1-6+"#� #%� (',#%&=!� � �'11=� 2+19� %9� #2-� �+$=1+"&� F'&7-,� +"&5+,#-$,� ;2%� $-,4%"&-&� #%� +� (',#%&=� 2=4%#2-#)(+1�� ,#+#-&� #2+#� #2-)$&-(),)%"�;%'1&�"%#�(2+"7-�)9�#2-=�1-+$"-&�#2+#�#2-�9+#2-$�2+&�@-+#-"#2-�5%#2-$�@-9%$-�#2-�4+$#)-,�,-4+$+#-&!

��.���2),�+##)#'&-�),�(%55%"1=

,--"� )"� $-+1� (+,-,� +,�;-11!� � �%$� )",#+"(-�� +� �1%$)&+� (%'$#� +((-4#-&� +4,=(2%1%7),#8,�,#+#-5-"#�#2+#�#2-�5+"8,�:4+,#�6)%1-"(-�;+,�$-1+#-&�#%#2-� &-#-$)%$+#)%"� %9� 2),� $-1+#)%",2)4� ;)#2� H2),� ;)9-K< � +"&� '42-1&: ,2+$-&� 4+$-"#+1� $-,4%",)@)1)#=< � 9%$� #2-� 5+"�� &-,4)#-� +� 2),#%$=� %9,-6-$-�6)%1-"(-�;2-"� ,2-�;+,� 4$-7"+"#�� +"&� #2$-+#,� #%�C)11� 2-$�� 2-$9+#2-$�� +"&�2)5,-19!

���� ��+"=� (%'$#,� ,#+#-� -E41)()#1=� #2+#� #2-=� ,--� "%

1)"C�@-#;--"�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+"&�(',#%&=��9%$�)",#+"(-��)"��-%$7)+�: H;K2)1-�F'&7-,�5+=�$-,#$)(#�6),)#+#)%"�;)#2�5)"%$�(2)1&$-"�@-(+',-�%9+1(%2%1),5��&$'7�',-��)"&),($--#�$-1+#)%",2)4��%$�%#2-$�H,)(K�($)5)"+1@-2+6)%$�� #2-=� +$-� "%#� 1)C-1=� #%� &%� ,%� @-(+',-� %9� $-4-+#-&� ,4%',-@+##-$)"7�!�!�!� F'&7-,� &),$-7+$&� %$� 5)")5)3-� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� )"(',#%&=� &),4'#-,� +"&� 6),)#+#)%"� &'-� #%� #2-� 7-"&-$D@)+,-&� @-1)-9� #2+##2-,-�+$-�F',#�R9+5)1=�,?'+@@1-,!8<

���

���� �����3+4+",C)=�������"%#-�0*��+#�0��D�*!

��.� ����+#�0��!

���! �%11)",;%$#2�6!��8�%""-11����*��%!�0&��..�L�1+!��),#!��#!�44!��B*�MA��������+"#�6!��+"#��B0���!>!0&��0�������L�%!�44!��BB�M�L"%#)"7�#2+#�+�(',#%&=�+;+$&�;+,"%#�4$-(1'&-&�@=�+�2),#%$=�%9�6)%1-"(-��+5%"7�%#2-$�$-+,%",�@-(+',-�#2-�: )"()&-"#,%9� 6)%1-"(-�;-$-�"%#� $-(-"#�+"&�;-$-�"%#�&)$-(#-&� +#� #2-�(2)1&$-"< MA��+$#� 6!��+$#����� �!>!0&� ���� L�%!� 44!� �B*BM� L'42%1&)"7� +"� +;+$&� %9� (',#%&=� #%� #2-� 9+#2-$&-,4)#-�6)%1-"(-�@-9%$-�@)$#2�+"&�+�1+#-$�+,,+'1#�"%#�&)$-(#-&�+#��+"&�4'$4%$#-&1=�"%#+&6-$,-1=�+99-(#)"7��#2-�(2)1&MA��(�-$5%##�6!��(�-$5%##��B.���!0&�����L-6!��BB�ML$-6-$,)"7�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#8,�5%&)9)(+#)%"�%9�(',#%&=�)"�9+6%$�%9�#2-�9+#2-$�&-,4)#-�2),(%"6)(#)%"�9%$�+,,+'1#�%9�#2-�5%#2-$�;2-"�,2-�(+5-�#%�7-#�(2)1&MA�>+)#,�������"%#-����� +#� ��� L$-4%$#)"7� #2-� (1)-"#8,� ,#+#-5-"#� #2+#� : #2-� 4,=(2%1%7),#,� +"&� #2-� F'&7-@%'72#�#2-�)&-+�#2+#��',,8,�+@',-�%9�5-�;+,�)$$-1-6+"#�#%�(2)1&�(',#%&=�),,'-,< M!

���! �3+4+",C)=�������"%#-�0*��+#�0�*�"!��!

46

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

,�4$-6)%',1=�"%#-&��-6-"�F'&7-,�;2%�+$-�9+)$1=�4$%+(#)6-�+"&�9)$5%"�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�7-"-$+11=��,'(2�+,�#2-�%"-�)"��+,-����+"&�%#2-$,)"� �!�!8,� �%5-,#)(� �)%1-"(-� �%'$#�� (+@)"� %99� #2+#� ),,'-� 9$%5� #2-)$#2)"C)"7� +@%'#� #2-� +@',-$8,� $-1+#)%",2)4� ;)#2� 2),� (2)1&!� � � ,)5)1+$@)9'$(+#)%"� ),� +1,%� -6)&-"#� )"� �#+(-C8,� $-,-+$(2� )"#%� /%,#%"� F'&7-,8+##)#'&-,�#%;+$&�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-!

�����

�"�,2%$#��;2)1-�F'&7-,�#$+)"-&�)"�+"&�:-"1)72#-"-&< �+@%'#�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-�+$-�'"1)C-1=�#%�6%)(-�,'(2�%4)")%",�-E41)()#1=��)#�+44-+$,�#2+#,%5-� +$-�"%#� 9+$� 9$%5� #2-� 6)-;�%9� #2-��+,,+(2',-##,� F'&7-�;2%�� )"$-9',)"7� #%�&-"=�+�@+##-$-$�6),)#+#)%"�� ,#+#-&�: H-K6-"��)11)"7-$�(%'1&2+6-� 5+&-� +� 7%%&� 9+#2-$�!�!�!� �%;� +@%'#� �+",%"J<

��*� � >2)1-� ,'(2

,+$(+,5� 5+=� @-� 5%$-� $+$-� "%;+&+=,�� #2-� ;)11)"7"-,,� #%� #%1-$+#--E#$-5-� 6)%1-"(-� @=� +� 9+#2-$� 4-$,),#,�� +� "'5@-$� %9� (%'$#,� 2+6-+;+$&-&�(',#%&=� #%� 9+#2-$,�;2%�2+6-�-6-"�C)11-&� #2-)$�;)6-,��%"� #2-7$%'"&� #2+#� #2-� 6)%1-"(-� +7+)",#� #2-� (2)1&$-"8,� 5%#2-$� ;+,� "%#&)$-(#-&� #%;+$&� #2-�(2)1&$-"�+"&�&)&�"%#� )"&)(+#-� #2-� 9+#2-$�;%'1&@-�+�4%%$�4+$-"#!

��B

7� ���%� � ��� ���!����������-���������1������ � ��(� ����%���� ���

�2-� 9+11+(=� )"� #2-� 5-"#+1� ,-4+$+#)%"� %9� (',#%&=� +"&� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-�),�+#�1-+,#�9%'$�9%1&��9)$,#��+,�2+,�@--"�&-#+)1-&�-E#-",)6-1=�)"#2-� 1)#-$+#'$-�� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ),� ?')#-� 2+$59'1� -6-"� #%� (2)1&$-";2%�%"1=�;)#"-,,� )#��+"&�5%,#�(2)1&$-"�&%!

���� �>2)1-� ,%5-�5)72#� ,+=

L)"(%$$-(#1=M�#2+#�4+,#�6)%1-"(-�),�:;+#-$�'"&-$�#2-�@$)&7-�<���

�#2-�9+(#

���� ���������"%#-����+"&�+((%54+"=)"7�#-E#�L&-,($)@)"7�#2-��#+(-C�)"#-$6)-;�)"

;2)(2� #2-� F'&7-� ;+,� 9)$5� %"� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� @'#� ,=54+#2-#)(� #%� #2-� @+##-$-$$-7+$&)"7�6),)#+#)%"MA��������������+$#���!/!

��*� �����-)-$���� �����5� ���,������"%#-�0���+#�.�� L?'%#)"7��+,,+(2',-##,� '&7-�-54%"-M!

��B� ������������"�$-��'#7-"����0�!�!0&�B����B*�D*��L�11!�44!��#!��B**M�L'42%1&)"7+"�+;+$&�%9�(',#%&=�%9�&+'72#-$,� #%� #2-� 9+#2-$�;2%�C)11-&� #2-�5%#2-$�� )"�+�(%"#-,#;)#2� #2-� 5+#-$"+1� +'"#� +"&� '"(1-M!� � �"� #2-� �! !� �)54,%"� (',#%&=� @+##1-� @-#;--"�)54,%"� +"&� #2-� 5+#-$"+1� 7$+"&4+$-"#,�� #2-� (',#%&=� (%'$#� $-9',-&� #%� 2-+$� #2--6)&-"(-�L9$%5�#2-�()6)1�1)+@)1)#=�#$)+1M�#2+#��)54,%"�2+&�C)11-&�#2-�(2)1&$-"8,�5%#2-$�+"&�+;+$&-&�(',#%&=�#%��)54,%"!��"�+44-11+#-�(%'$#�$-6-$,-&�#2),�&-(),)%"��@'#�#2-(+,-�;+,�'1#)5+#-1=�,-##1-&��+11%;)"7��)54,%"�#%�$-#+)"�(',#%&=!��������������������"%#-� ��� +#� ����� 0*�� "!�*!� � �%'$#,� 2+6-� -6-"� $-F-(#-&� � � �.� 4-#)#)%",� #%� #-$5)"+#-4+$-"#+1� $)72#,� %9�5-"�;2%�2+6-� C)11-&�(2)1&$-"8,�5%#2-$,!� � ���� �+)"#-$� 6!� /+$C1-=�0����!�!0&�*���L�+!��#!�44!��B*�M�L+99)$5)"7� #2-� #$)+1�(%'$#8,� $-9',+1� #%� #-$5)"+#-4+$-"#+1�$)72#,�%9�+�9+#2-$�(%"6)(#-&�%9�5'$&-$)"7�#2-�(2)1&8,�5%#2-$MA�/+$#+,+6)(2�6!�)#(2-11�� .��� !0&� *��� L�+!� �'4-$!� �#!� �B*.M� L$-+(2)"7� #2-� ,+5-� $-,'1#� +9#-$� #2-9+#2-$8,�7')1#=�41-+�#%�6%1'"#+$=�5+",1+'72#-$MA��"�$-� +5-,��!������+1!�44!��&�0�.L�+1!��#!�44!��B��M�L$-F-(#)"7�#2-��#+#-8,�4-#)#)%"�#%�#-$5)"+#-�#2-�9+#2-$8,�4+$-"#+1$)72#,�+9#-$�2-�41-&�7')1#=�#%�#2-�5%#2-$8,�5'$&-$M!

���� ����/������G���������������"%#-�����+#���D�BA��+$#�������"%#-��*��+#���D�.!

���! �$� #2+#� @%#2� 4+$-"#,� +$-� $-,4%",)@1-�� �#+$C� �D5+)1�� �����"%#-� *.!� � ���� ��������"%#-����L&-,($)@)"7�#2-�-;��%$C�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�+7-"(=8,�4%1)(=�%9�4-"+1)3)"7

47

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��. ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

$-5+)",� #2+#� (+',)"7� 2+$5� #%� %"-8,� (2)1&$-"I -6-"� %"1=4,=(2%1%7)(+1� 2+$5�� +"&� -6-"� )9� )#� ),� '")"#-"#)%"+1I ),� "%$5+11=(%",)&-$-&�+�9%$5�%9�-)#2-$�(2)1&�+@',-�%$�"-71-(#!���"�9+(#��#2-�$-+1)#=#2+#� +&'1#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� (%",#)#'#-,� +� 9%$5� +@',-� %$� "-71-(#� ),$-91-(#-&� )"� #2-� 7$%;)"7� "'5@-$� %9� ,#+#-,� ;2)(2� +$-� ($)5)"+1)3)"7&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +,� +� 9%$5� %9� (2)1&� +@',-!

��0� � "&� (-$#+)"1=�� 4+,#

+@',-� %$� "-71-(#� %9� (2)1&$-"� 2+,� +1;+=,� @--"� ,--"� +,� )"&),4'#+@1=$-1-6+"#�#%�;2%�,2%'1&�$-#+)"�9'#'$-�(',#%&=!

�-(%"&��#2-�"%#)%"�#2+#�#2-�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�@-#;--"�#2-�4+$-"#,),�)"�#2-�4+,#��+"&�#2+#�#2-�(2)1&$-"�;)11�"%�1%"7-$�@-�,'@F-(#-&�#%�)#�

���

)7"%$-,�#2-�$-+1)#)-,�%9�,-4+$+#)%"�+@',-�+"&�,-$)+1�@+##-$)"7!��>)#2%'#$-2+,2)"7� #2-� 5+"=� -E#+"#� &),(',,)%",� %9� #2-� (%"#)"'+#)%"� %9&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +9#-$� ,-4+$+#)%"�� ,'99)(-� )#� #%� ,+=� #2+#� 5+"=@+##-$-$,� $-9',-� #%� 1-#� #2-)$� 6)(#)5,� : 1-+6-< � +"&� @-� ,+9-!� � �+#2-$�,-4+$+#)%"� 9$%5� #2-)$� +&'1#� 6)(#)5�� -6-"� +9#-$� +� 1-7+1� &)6%$(-4$%(--&)"7��%9#-"�#$)77-$,�7$-+#-$�+"&�5%$-�,-$)%',�6)%1-"(-�+7+)",#2-$�%$�%#2-$�5-5@-$,�%9�#2-�9+5)1=!

��.

>2)1-� 5+"=� @+##-$-$,� (%"#)"'-� #%� 2+$+,,� +"&� +@',-� #2-)$� +&'1#6)(#)5,�+9#-$�,-4+$+#)%"��5+"=�+1,%�&)$-(#�#2-)$�+@',-�#%�#2-�(2)1&$-"+,�#2-�-+,)-,#�;+=�#%�+((%541),2�#2-�7%+1�%9�4'"),2)"7�#2-�5%#2-$!��#)#,�-E#$-5-��#2),�"--&�#%�4'"),2�#2-�5%#2-$�(+"�1-+&�#%�#2-�@+##-$-$8,&-(),)%"�#%�C)11�2-$�(2)1&$-"!

�����#�)#,�1-,,�-E#$-5-��,'(2�@+##-$-$,�5+=

+@',-�#2-�(2)1&$-"�42=,)(+11=��,-E'+11=�%$�-5%#)%"+11=!���

���%"#$+$=�#%

@+##-$-&� 5%#2-$,� 9%$� : -"7+7)"7� )"� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-< M!� � �6-"� )9� @%#2� +$-� 2-1&$-,4%",)@1-��#2-�6)%1-"#�4+$-"#�(%'1&�+"&�,2%'1&�,#)11�@-�&--5-&�1-,,�9)#!

��0� ���� ����� "%#-� B� L()#)"7� +$#)(1-,� &),(',,)"7� #2-� 5-$)#,� +"&� $),C,� %9� #2-,-,#+#'#-,M!

���� ���� ������"%#-��*��L?'%#)"7�+�4,=(2%1%7),#�;2%� ,+)&�� : ,2-8,�=%'"7A� ,2-811� 7-#%6-$�)#< M!

��.� �����+2%"-=�� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� �� L(%)")"7� #2-� #-$5� : ,-4+$+#)%"� +,,+'1#< � #%&-,($)@-� #2-� 6)%1-"(-� )"91)(#-&� %"� ;%5-"� @=� @+##-$-$,� ;2-"� #2-=� 1-+$"� #2+#� #2-)$6)(#)5�),� #+C)"7�,#-4,�#%;+$&�)"&-4-"&-"(-�%$�,-4+$+#)%"MA����������������������"%#-� ��� +#� ��D�*A� >��������� /���� �������� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� ��� L"%#)"7� #2+#� +5+F%$)#=� %9�5%#2-$,� )"#-$6)-;-&� ;-$-� +@',-&� %$� 5),#$-+#-&� @=� +"� -ED4+$#"-$� +9#-$,-4+$+#)%"M!

���� �����+'1��'77+"��%���������������������(�� ������"���������� ������ ��.� �� �>��!��������-4#!�����BB���+#�0��L;$)#)"7�#2+#�#2-�: 4%1)(-�,+)&�#2-�,',4-(#�!�!�!�C)11-&#2-�7)$1,�)"�+�9)#�%9�$+7-�%6-$�2),�-,#$+"7-5-"#�9$%5�2),�('$$-"#�;)9-�� #2-�(2)1&$-"8,5%#2-$< M!���2)72�4$%9)1-�(+,-�)"��+11+,�)"6%16-&� %2"�/+##+71)+8,�5'$&-$�%9�2),�#;%&+'72#-$,� ;2)1-� #2-)$�5%#2-$� 1),#-"-&� %"� #2-� #-1-42%"-�� +11-7-&1=� @-(+',-� 2-� ;+,+"7-$-&� #2+#� ,2-�2+&�7%##-"�+"�+$$-,#�;+$$+"#�+7+)",#�2)5!� ��),� ,-(%"&�;)9-�� +� 1+;4$%9-,,%$��+1,%�,'$6)6-&�#;%�=-+$,�%9�2),�+@',-!���%,#)"7�%9��)(2-11-��2-##)��#%������D���L%6!��*��0��0M�L(%4=�%"�9)1-�;)#2�+'#2%$M!

���� ����/������G���������� �����"%#-����� +#���� ��D��� L&-,($)@)"7�@+##-$-$,8',-� %9� (2)1&$-"� : +,� ;-+4%",< � +9#-$� ,-4+$+#)%"�� )"(1'&)"7� C)&"+44)"7� %9� (2)1&$-"MA�$--"�/%%C�� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� B� L,#+#)"7� #2+#� ��D��Q�%9� @+##-$-$,� +@',-� (2)1&$-"MA�+$#�������"%#-��*��+#���D�.�L()#+#)%",�%5)##-&M!���6+"��#+$C�,#+#-,�#2+#�: H#K+"7-"#)+1,4%',-�+@',-�%(('$,�;2-"� #2-�@+##-$-$�&-#-$5)"-,�2-�(+"�@-,#�2'$#�2),�4+$#"-$�@=

48

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

#2-�+,,'54#)%",�%9�5+"=�(%'$#�4-$,%""-1����

� #2-,-�$),C,� ��������+9#-$#2-�@+##-$-$8,�,-4+$+#)%"�9$%5�#2-�5%#2-$��@%#2�@-(+',-�@+##-$-$,�,%%9#-"� ',-� #2-� (2)1&$-"� +,� +�5-+",� %9� 9'$#2-$)"7� #2-)$� +@',-� %9� #2-5%#2-$�� +"&� @-(+',-� #2-=� +$-� 9$--$� #%� )"&'17-� #2-)$� %;")"+44$%4$)+#-�"--&,�%$�-5%#)%",�;)#2�(2)1&$-"�;2-"�#2-)$�5%#2-$�),"%#�#2-$-!

�)"+11=�� +"&� 5%,#� )54%$#+"#1=�� -6-"� #2%,-� @+##-$-$,� ;2%� &%� "%#"-(-,,+$)1=� )"#-"&� #%� 2+$5� #2-� (2)1&$-"� +$-� '"1)C-1=� #%� @-� 7%%&4+$-"#,��+"&�+$-�%9#-"�?')#-�&-,#$'(#)6-!� �,�4$-6)%',1=�"%#-&��5+"=@+##-$-$,�,--C�(',#%&=��"%#�%'#�%9�+�7-"')"-�&-,)$-�#%�#+C-�(+$-�%9�#2-(2)1&$-"�� @'#� #%� $-#+1)+#-� +7+)",#� %$� 9'$#2-$� #2-)$� (%"#$%1� %9� #2-)$4+$#"-$!

��*� � �2-� 4-$,%"+� %9� 5+"=I #2%'72� "%#� +11I @+##-$-$,�� ),

)"(%",),#-"#� ;)#2� #2-� ?'+1)#)-,� "--&-&� #%� 5+C-� +� 7%%&� 4+$-"#!��B

�-%41-� ;2%� "--&� #%� (%"#$%1� +"&� +@',-� #2-)$� )"#)5+#-� 4+$#"-$,� +$-'"1)C-1=� #%� @-� (+4+@1-� %9� #2-� 1%6)"7�� "'$#'$)"7� +"&� ,-19D&),()41)"-&@-2+6)%$� #2+#� 7%%&� 4+$-"#)"7� $-?')$-,!� /=� &-9)")#)%"�� +� 9+#2-$� ;2%+@',-,� #2-�5%#2-$� 2+,� )"&)(+#-&� #2+#� 2-� (+""%#� 4'#� #2-� (2)1&$-"8,)"#-$-,#,� 9)$,#�� ,)"(-� #2-)$�5%#2-$8,� +@',-�� @=� '"&-$5)")"7�2-$�;-11D@-)"7�� )"2-$-"#1=� 2+$59'1� #%� #2-� (2)1&$-"!� � �+"=� @+##-$-$,� -E4-(#(2)1&$-"�#%�5--#� ����"--&,��$+#2-$�#2+"�6)(-�6-$,+A�#2),�(+"�1-+&�2)5#%�-E4-(#�(2)1&$-"�#%�7)6-�'4�#2-)$�%#2-$�)"#-$-,#,�#%�,4-"&�#)5-�;)#22)5A� #%� &-5+"&� ?')-#� #%� +"� )"+44$%4$)+#-� &-7$--�� #%� &-5+"&42=,)(+1� +99-(#)%"� $-7+$&1-,,� %9� #2-)$� 9--1)"7,A� +"&� #%� @-(%5-@1+5)"7��#-+$9'1��%$�=-11)"7�;2-"�#2-=�9+)1�#%�5--#�2),�"--&,!

����

2'$#)"7� 2-$� (2)1&$-"!< � � �#+$C��1�2%���� ���������� �� ������� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� B��"!��!

���� ���,� ������ �-"#� 6!��$--"�� ���� �%!0&� .�� �� L1+!� �)6!� 44!� �BB�M� L(%55-"#)"7#2+#� #2-� #2-$+4),#� +"&� :4,=(2%1%7)(+1� 4$%9)1-,< � )"&)(+#-&� #2+#� #2-� +@',-$� ;+,:'"1)C-1=�#%�@-�6)%1-"#�)"�#2-�9'#'$-�< �$-,'1#)"7�)"�2),�$-(-)6)"7�(',#%&=M!���"�9+(#��#2-%"1=�9+(#%$�(%",)&-$-&�#%�@-�4$-&)(#)6-�%9�9'#'$-�6)%1-"(-�),�4+,#�+@',-!���������������/������G���������� �����"%#-�����+#���*�L"%#)"7� #2+#� : H"K%�4,=(2%1%7)(+1� #-,#-E),#,� #2+#�(+"�&-#-$5)"-�;2-#2-$�+"�)"&)6)&'+1� ),�+�@+##-$-$�%$�;2)(2�@+##-$-$,�+$-5%,#� 1)C-1=� #%� $-D%99-"&< MA� ���� +#� ���D���� L&),(',,)"7� � 2%;� @-,#� #%� +,,-,,� $),C� #%(2)1&$-"�9$%5�9'#'$-�(%"#+(#�;)#2�@+##-$-$,M!

��*! /+##-$-$,� (+"� +"&�%9#-"�&%�',-� (%"#+(#,�;)#2� #2-)$� 9%$5-$�4+$#"-$� #2$%'72#2-�(2)1&$-"�#%�(%"#)"'-�#%�2+$+,,��%@,#$'(#��'"&-$5)"-��+"&�7-"-$+11=�)"#-$9-$-�;)#2#2-)$� 9%$5-$�4+$#"-$,!� ������-2$5+"�� �����"%#-� �B�� +#� �.A�N%$3+�� �����"%#-� �*�� +#��0.!

��B! /+"($%9#� +"&��)16-$5+"�"%#-� #2+#� ;-� : (+"� -E4-(#� #2+#� %"-� %$�5%$-� %9� #2-9%11%;)"7� 4$%@1-5,�;)11� @-� 4$-,-"#� )"� #2-�4+$-"#)"7� %9� #2-� 7$-+#�5+F%$)#=� %9� #2-,-5-"!< � � ���� /������ G� ��������� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� 0BD��� L&-,($)@)"7� @+##-$-$,84+$-"#)"7� +,� (2+$+(#-$)3-&� @=� +'#2%$)#+$)+"),5�� '"&-$D)"6%16-5-"#�� "-71-(#� +"&)$$-,4%",)@)1)#=�� ,-19D(-"#-$-&"-,,�� +"&� 5+")4'1+#)6-"-,,M!� � �2-=� +1,%� (+'#)%"� #2+#@+##-$-$,8� : 4+$-"#)"7�(2+$+(#-$),#)(,< �+$-� 1-,,�'")6-$,+1� #2+"�+$-� #2-)$� +##)#'&-,�+"&@-2+6)%$,�#%;+$&�#2-)$�+&'1#�4+$#"-$,!� �����+#�0B!���2-�9%11%;)"7�&),(',,)%"�),�&$+;"1)@-$+11=��@'#�"%#�,%1-1=��9$%5�#2-)$�&),(',,)%"!

���! �2),� ),� 5%,#� -6)&-"#� )"� @+##-$-$,� ;2%� +$-� )"#%1-$+"#� %9� @+@)-,� %$� =%'"7(2)1&$-"�($=)"7�� ,--�/������G���������� �����"%#-����� +#��.��;2)(2� ,%5-#)5-,

49

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

/+##-$-$,�+$-�%9#-"�4+#$)+$(2+1��@-1)-6)"7�)"�,#$)(#�7-"&-$�$%1-,�+"&,'@%$&)"+#)%"� %9� 9-5+1-,�� +"&� (+"� @-� (%"#$%11)"7� %$� +'#2%$)#+$)+"#%;+$&� (2)1&$-"� %9� @%#2� ,-E-,!� � /+##-$-$,� : #-"&� #%� @-� $)7)&�+'#2%$)#+$)+"�4+$-"#,!<

������2-=�#-"&�#%�-E4-(#�#2-)$�;)11�#%�@-�%@-=-&

'"?'-,#)%")"71=��%$�#%�@-�)"91-E)@1-�)"�#2-)$�+$$+"7-5-"#,��-E#$-5-1=+"7$=�+#�+"=�,)7"�%9�"%"D(%541)+"(-�%$�&),$-,4-(#��,4+"C�5%$-�%9#-"+"&�@-�+"7$=�5%$-�%9#-"� #2+"�%#2-$� 9+#2-$,!� � �"�,2%$#�� #2-=� #-"&�#%',-�:4%;-$�4+$-"#)"7!<

��0� ��2-=�+$-�'"1)C-1=� #%�4%,,-,,� #2-�-54+#2=

#2+#�+11%;,�4+$-"#,�#%�#$-+#�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"�;)#2�$-,4-(#�+"&�#%�6+1)&+#-#2-)$� 9--1)"7,�� #;%� ?'+1)#)-,� (%",)&-$-&� )54%$#+"#� #%� $+),)"7-5%#)%"+11=�2-+1#2=��(%",()-"#)%',��(+$)"7�(2)1&$-"!

���

�+"=�� )9� "%#� 5%,#�� @+##-$-$,� @%#2� (%",()%',1=� +"&� '"(%",()%',1='"&-$5)"-� #2-� (2)1&$-"8,� 5%#2-$� +"&� $-1+#)%",2)4,� ;)#2� #2-)$5%#2-$!

��.� ��+"=� #-11� #2-�(2)1&$-"� #2+#� )#� ),� #2-)$�5%#2-$8,� 9+'1#� #2+#

#2-�4+$-"#,�+$-�,-4+$+#-&��#2+#�#2-=�(+""%#�,--�#2-)$�9+#2-$�5%$-��#2+##2-=�(+""%#�2+6-�(-$#+)"�#2)"7,��%$�+"=�%#2-$�,%'$(-�%9�,+&"-,,�)"�#2-(2)1&8,�1)9-!���+"=�%9�5=�(1)-"#,8�@+##-$-$,�;%'1&�&-5-+"�#2-�5%#2-$#%�#2-�(2)1&$-"��#-11)"7�#2-5�#2-)$�5%#2-$�),�+�:;2%$-< �%$�: ,1'#�< �+"&)"�+#� 1-+,#�%"-�(+,-��&-5+"&)"7�#2+#�#2-�(2)1&$-"�(%5-�%'#�%9� #2-)$$%%5,�#%�;+#(2�2)5�@-+#�2-$�'4�+,�4'"),25-"#�9%$�,%5-�4'$4%$#-&;$%"7!

�)"+11=�� @+##-$-$,� +$-� %9#-"� 5+")4'1+#)6-� #%� (2)1&$-"� +,� ;-11� +,4+$#"-$,�� &-"=)"7� #2-)$� %;"� (%"&'(#� +"&� )#,� -99-(#,�� @1+5)"7� #2-5%#2-$�� +"&� ,--C)"7� #%� 4-$,'+&-� #2-� (2)1&$-"� #2+#� #2-=� +$-� #2-:")(-$< � %$� :@-##-$< � 4+$-"#!

���� � �9#-"� @+##-$-$,� ',-� #2-� (2)1&$-"� #%

9'$#2-$�#2-)$�(%"#$%1�%6-$�#2-�5%#2-$��-E41)()#1=�%$�)541)()#1=�-"1),#)"7

1-+&,�#%�,2+C-"�@+@=�,="&$%5-!

���� ����+#���!

��0� ���� +#� 0BD��!� � �%;-6-$�� : H2K+$,2� &),()41)"+$=� 4$+(#)(-,�� "-7+#)6-� %$� ($)#)(+1)"#-$+(#)%",�;)#2�(2)1&$-"��%$�-E41%,)6-�+"7-$�#%;+$&�(2)1&$-"�#-+(2�#2-5�#2-�;$%"71-,,%",!< ���������������"%#-�B��+#���0!

���� ���,�������/�����!�/�������������������������������������������������/���

������� ���� ������ �������� ���� ���������� *�� ����� L0���M� L+&6%(+#)"7: 1%6)"7� 7')&+"(-< � ;2)(2� #-+(2-,� $-,4-(#� +"&� ,-19D(%"#$%1� $+#2-$� #2+"� 4'")#)6-&),()41)"-�;2)(2�#-+(2-,�4%;-$�+"&�(%"91)(#MA�/������G���������������"%#-����+#� ��.� L,#+#)"7� #2+#� #$+'5+#)3-&� (2)1&$-"� "--&� #%� @-� ;)#2� +� 4+$-"#� ;2%� ),� +@1-� #%: +(C"%;1-&7-��$-(%7")3-�+"&�@-+$�;)#"-,,�#%�#2-�(2)1&8,�4+)"< MA��������������"%#-B��+#����D�.�L,#+#)"7�#2+#�+11�(2)1&$-"�"--&�4+$-"#,� #%�5%&-1�$-,4-(#�� #%1-$+"(-�+"&"%"D+77$-,,)%"M!

��.� ���� /������ G� ��������� �����"%#-� ���� +#� ��D�.!� � �2),� @-2+6)%$� ),� ;-11D$-(%7")3-&� #%� @-� (2+$+(#-$),#)(� %9� @+##-$-$,�� =-#� +44-+$,� #%� 2+6-� @--"� -"#)$-1=%6-$1%%C-&� @=� #2%,-� ;2%� ,'@,($)@-� #%� #2-� #2-%$=� %9� : 4+$-"#+1� +1)-"+#)%"< � +,� +4$%@1-5�4+$+&)75+#)(+11=�($-+#-&�@=�5%#2-$,�;2%�9+1,-1=�+11-7-�+@',-!

���� ���� +#� ��� L:9#-$� ,-4+$+#)%"�� @+##-$-&� ;%5-"� )"� %'$� (+,-,� $+),-� (%"(-$",+@%'#�5+")4'1+#)%"�%9�#2-�(2)1&$-"�@=�#2-�@+##-$-$�;)#2�7$-+#-$�9$-?'-"(=�#2+"�+"=%#2-$�,)"71-�+,4-(#�%9�2),�4+$-"#)"7!< M!

50

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

#2-�(2)1&$-"�)"�2),�6-"&-##+!���"��+,-���+@%6-��#2-�+@',-$�,-"#�2),�,%"#%�,4=�%"�2),�5%#2-$��#%�$-4%$#�#%�2)5�+@%'#�;2%�,2-�,4-"#�#)5-�;)#2�+"&�#%�5+C-�,'$-�#2+#�2-�(%'1&�C--4�#+@,�%"�2-$!��>2-"�#2-�@%=�;-"##%�1)6-�;)#2�2),� 9+#2-$�� #2-�5%#2-$�(%'1&�"%#� #-11�2)5�;2-$-�,2-�;+,7%)"7�#%�@-�5%6)"7�@-(+',-�,2-�C"-;�#2-�@%=�;%'1&�#-11�2),�9+#2-$!

�"� ,2%$#�� )#� ),� ,)541=� 9+11+()%',� #%� +,,'5-� #2+#� 4+,#� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-�),�)"�#2-�4+,#��#2+#�)#�),�"%#�&)$-(#1=�$-1-6+"#�#%�9'#'$-�(',#%&=�%$�#2+#�)#�(+"�-6-$�$-+11=�"%#�)54+(#�#2-�(2)1&$-"!

&� @���21�����������/-�� ���0�&'���

�-$=� %9#-"� (%'$#,� +$-� +,,),#-&� )"� ,',#+)")"7� #2-� 9%$-7%)"75),(%"(-4#)%",� @=� #2-� )"4'#� %9� ,%D(+11-&� :"-'#$+1< � 4$%9-,,)%"+1,�#=4)(+11=�5-"#+1�2-+1#2�-E4-$#,!���2-,-�"-'#$+1,�)"(1'&-��'+$&)+",�&�)#-5� L:��,< M�� (',#%&=� -6+1'+#%$,�� +"&� +� 2%,#� %9� %#2-$� 4%,,)@1-41+=-$,� )"�(',#%&=� 1)#)7+#)%"!

���� ��2-�&),(',,)%"�@-1%;� 9%(',-,�%"� #2-

9)$,#� #;%� $%1-,�� +,� #2-�5%,#� 4$-6+1-"#� +"&�5%,#� 1)C-1=� #%� )54+(#� #2-(%'$#8,�&-(),)%"!

/-(+',-� #2-� :@-,#� )"#-$-,#� %9� #2-� (2)1&< � ,#+"&+$&� ),� @%#2+5%$42%',I +�6+(''5�#%�@-�9)11-&�@=�#2-�&-(),)%"D5+C-$8,�4-$,%"+16+1'-,I +"&�4$%,4-(#)6-I )!-!�� '"1)C-�5%,#� 1-7+1� (+',-,� %9� +(#)%"� )#&%-,� "%#� )"#$)",)(+11=� $-?')$-� +"� )"?')$=� )"#%� 4+,#� -6-"#,I 9+5)1=(%'$#,� 2+6-� )"($-+,)"71=� 1%%C-&� #%� 5-"#+1� 2-+1#2� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,�� %$%#2-$� :"-'#$+1< � 4$%9-,,)%"+1,�� #%� +,,-,,� #2),� 5'$C=� 4,=(2%1%7)(+1(%"(-4#!� ��2-�$-1)+"(-�%"�"-'#$+1�: -E4-$#,< �%$�-6-"� 1+;=-$,�L)"� #2-(+,-�%9�5+"=���,M��),�'"&-$,#+"&+@1=�,-&'(#)6-!���%'$#,�9--1�#2-=�+$-5%$-� 1)C-1=� #%� 2-+$� +� $-(%55-"&+#)%"� #2+#� #$'1=� $-91-(#,� #2-(2)1&$-"8,� )"#-$-,#,� 9$%5� ,%5-@%&=� ;2%,-� ,%1-� %@1)7+#)%"� ),� #%+,(-$#+)"� #2%,-� )"#-$-,#,� +"&� ;2%� 2+,� "%� %#2-$� 4-$,%"+1� %$4$%9-,,)%"+1� ,#+C-� )"� #2-� %'#(%5-�� #2+"� 9$%5� +"=%"-I -6-"� +4,=(2%1%7)(+1� -E4-$#I 2)$-&� @=� %"-� %9� #2-� 4+$-"#,!� � �-1)+"(-� %"9%$-",)(� -6+1'+#)%",� %$� $-(%55-"&+#)%",�@=�5-&)+#%$,� +1,%� -"+@1-,(%'$#,� #%� 5+"+7-� +"� %6-$;2-15)"7� (+,-1%+&� @=� $-&'()"7� #2-� #)5-,4-"#�%"�9+(#�+&F'&)(+#)%",!

���� ��%;-6-$�� #2),�$-1)+"(-� ),�-E(-,,)6-�@=

5+"=� -,#)5+#)%",�� +"&� )#� ),� -,4-()+11=� 4$%@1-5+#)(� )"� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-�(+,-,!

���� ���� +"-#� �!� /%;-$5+,#-$�� ������ %����� ���� ���� �� 1���� ��� +�� ��� 3���

%�������������"����"� ����%�����������.����P!��!����!�0����0��D���L0��0M!

���� ���� ���� +#� ��0D��� L4%,)#)"7� #2+#� : 4$+(#)(+1� (%"(-$",� H)!-!�� &%(C-#� (%"#$%1K�$+#2-$� #2+"� ,()-"#)9)(� %$� 1-7+1� (%",)&-$+#)%",�� +44-+$� #%� @-� #2-� 4$)5+$=�5%#)6+#)"79%$(-� @-2)"&� #2-� )"($-+,)"7� &-1-7+#)%"� %9� F'&)()+1� $-,4%",)@)1)#=� #%� 5-"#+1� 2-+1#24$%9-,,)%",�)"�(',#%&=�4$%(--&)"7,< M!

51

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��* ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

6� ������������� ��� ���!�������

�)$,#��;)#2�$+$-�-E(-4#)%",��5-"#+1�2-+1#2�4$%9-,,)%"+1,�#-"&�#%�@-'"-&'(+#-&� +@%'#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +"&� #%� '"&-$$+#-� )#� )")54%$#+"(-!

��*� � >2)1-� (-$#+)"� 4,=(2%1%7),#,� 2+6-� 4)%"--$-&� #2-

&-6-1%45-"#�%9�,%5-�%9�#2-�9'"&+5-"#+1�(%"(-4#,�)"�#2-�9)-1&���B

�+,�+;2%1-��#2-�5-"#+1�2-+1#2�4$%9-,,)%",�2+6-�=-#�#%�)"#-7$+#-�-&'(+#)%"+@%'#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� )"#%� 5+)",#$-+5� #$+)")"7� +"&� &-7$--4$%7$+5,!

�*����2',��,'$4$),)"7�#2%'72�)#�5+=�,--5��#2-�#=4)(+1�(',#%&=

-6+1'+#%$�&%-,�"%#�$-(%7")3-�@+,)(�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�&="+5)(,��&%-,"%#� +,C� +@%'#� +@',-�%$�C"%;�2%;� #%� +,C�?'-,#)%",� )"�;+=,� #2+#�;)119+()1)#+#-� &),(1%,'$-� %9� 4-$#)"-"#� )"9%$5+#)%"�

�*�� &%-,� "%#� C"%;� #2-

&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�1)#-$+#'$-��+"&�,)541=�&%-,�"%#�(%",)&-$�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-� #%� @-� +� 5+F%$� 9+(#%$� )"� (',#%&=!

�*0� � �2),� ),� -,4-()+11=� #$'-

;2-$-�#2-�+@',-�),�"%#�2)721=�6),)@1=�42=,)(+1��+,�-6)&-"(-&�@=�@$%C-"@%"-,�+"&�#2-�1)C-��@'#�#+C-,�5%$-�,'@#1-�9%$5,�,'(2�+,�4,=(2%1%7)(+1L+"&� 42=,)(+1M� )"#)5)&+#)%"� +"&� +@',-�� 4%;-$� +"&� (%"#$%1�� +"& %$,-E'+1�+@',-!

�"&--&�� 5%,#� "-'#$+1� -6+1'+#%$,� +44-+$� #%� 2+6-� +� @)+,� #%;+$&&),@-1)-6)"7�+@',-�+11-7+#)%",�L;2)(2� #2-=� 9)"&�-+,)-$� #%� +,,'5-�+$-9+@$)(+#-&�%$� -E+77-$+#-&�@=� +"7$=�5%#2-$,M�� 4-$2+4,�@-(+',-� #2-=+$-�'"+;+$-�%9� #2-�2)72�$+#-�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+5%"7�&)6%$()"7(%'41-,� +"&� -,4-()+11=� +5%"7� #2%,-� 1)#)7+#)"7� (',#%&=!

�*�� � �#$)C)"71=�

-6+1'+#%$,8� )7"%$+"(-� %9� #2-� 4$-6+1-"(-� %9� +@',-� +44-+$,� #%� 9'-1� +4'")#)6-"-,,�#%;+$&�5%#2-$,�;2%�+11-7-�+@',-!��#�1-+,#�%"-�-6+1'+#%$$-(%55-"&-&� #2+#� #2-�5%#2-$� 1%,-� (',#%&=�5-$-1=� %"� #2-� 7$%'"&#2+#� ,2-� +11-7-&� +@',-�� ;2)1-� 2-� 2+&� )"6-,#)7+#-&� 9+(#,� #2+#� 5)72#(%$$%@%$+#-�#2-�;%5+"8,�+11-7+#)%",!

�*.

��*� ����/������G���������������"%#-�����+#���B!

��B� ���,�������������>����������/�������>�����������L�B*.MA�����

�����������>�����������������/�������>�����������������������

������������L�BB0M!

�*�� ���� /������ G� ��������� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� ��B� L:�$+&'+#-� #$+)")"74$%7$+5,�9%$�4,=(2%1%7),#,�R2+6-�1+$7-1=�)7"%$-&�+@',-�+,�+�,4-()9)(�(%"#-"#�+$-+!8< M!

�*�! �"� %"-� (+,-� ;)#2� ;2)(2� �� +5� 9+5)1)+$�� #2-� (',#%&=� -6+1'+#%$� 9%'"&�� )"� 2),)"#-$6)-;,� %9� ,-6-$+1� #2)$&� 4+$#)-,�� "%� (%$$%@%$+#)%"� %9� #2-� 5%#2-$8,� (1+)5,� %94,=(2%1%7)(+1�+"&�42=,)(+1� )"#)5)&+#)%"�+"&�+@',-!� � L�"�4+$#�� #2-�-6+1'+#%$�&)&�"%#$-(%7")3-�#2+#�,%5-�%9�#2-�)"9%$5+#)%"�2-�$-(-)6-&�;+,��)"�9+(#��(%$$%@%$+#)6-!M���-#�+&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� -E4-$#� )"#-$6)-;)"7� #2-� ,+5-� )"&)6)&'+1,� $-(-)6-&�5%$-� &-#+)1-&+"&�$-1-6+"#�)"9%$5+#)%"�(1-+$1=�(%$$%@%$+#)"7�#2-�5%#2-$8,�(1+)5,!

�*0� ����/������G���������������"%#-�����+#���B!

�*�� ��������+#��0�A������"%#-��*D*��+"&�+((%54+"=)"7�#-E#!��>2-$-�(%"(-$"�+@%'#(2)1&� +@',-� ),� +11-7-&�� #2-� 1)C-1)2%%&� %9� +� "-'#$+1� 5-"#+1� 2-+1#2� 4$%9-,,)%"+1(%"9)$5)"7� )#� ),� +#� )#,� "+&)$!� ����� �����������%5@+$&)�� ����� "%#-� �B�� +#� �+$#� .A� ����"%#-���*!

�*.� ���� /������ G� ��������� ����� "%#-� ���� +#� �0�� L&-,($)@)"7� +� ��� ;2%

52

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ��B

�2',�� -6-"� )"� �+,-� 0� +@%6-�� ;2-$-� #2-� 6)%1-"(-� )"(1'&-&� +� 1)9-D#2$-+#-")"7�,#+@@)"7�&%('5-"#-&�;)#2�5-&)(+1�$-(%$&,�+"&�+�4%1)(-$-4%$#�� %#2-$� ;$)##-"� #2$-+#,�� +"&� ,%5-� ;)#"-,,-&� #2$-+#,�� ;)#2� #2--E(-4#)%"� %9� #2-� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� -E4-$#� �� 2)$-&�� "%#� %"-� %9� #2-9%$-",)(� -E+5)"-$,� L)"(1'&)"7� #2-� (%'$#D-541%=-&� 4,=(2)+#$),#� +"&,%()+1�;%$C-$�� +�4$)6+#-�4,=(2%1%7),#� (2%,-"�@=� #2-�%#2-$�4+$#=�� +"&#2-�+11-7-&�(2)1&�,-E'+1�+@',-�-E4-$#�%"�(%"#$+(#�;)#2�#2-�(%'$#M��"%$#2-�����4+)&�#2-�,1)72#-,#�+##-"#)%"�#%�#2-,-�)"()&-"#,�%#2-$�#2+"�)",%5-� )",#+"(-,� #%� ,'77-,#� #2+#� #2-� (%541+)"+"#� ;+,� "%#� +1#%7-#2-$,#+@1-� +"&� "%#� ($-&)@1-!� � �"� +� 5%$-� $-(-"#� ,#%$=� #%1&� @=� �+#21--">+)#,� +@%'#� +� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� (1)-"#� )"� +� (',#%&=� @+##1-�� #2$--,-4+$+#-� 4,=(2%1%7),#,�� )"(1'&)"7� #2-� %"-� �� ������ &),5),,-&� #2-2),#%$=�%9�,-6-$-�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+,�&%'@#9'1�%$�)$$-1-6+"#!

�*�

�2-� 4%;-$� %9� #2-,-� :"-'#$+1� -E4-$#,< � ),� )55-",-!� � �($+#(2� #2-,'$9+(-� %9� 5+"=� (+,-,� ;2-$-� (%'$#,� 2+6-� &),(%'"#-&� 4$%6-"� +@',-�+"&� =%'� ;)11� %9#-"� 9)"&� +� 5-"#+1� 2-+1#2� :-E4-$#< � %4)")%"� %$� ��$-(%55-"&+#)%"�'"&-$1=)"7�#2-�&-(),)%"!

�*����%$-%6-$��;2-$-�+���

$-(%55-"&-&� +� ,;)#(2� %9� (',#%&=� #%� #2-� 9+#2-$� @-(+',-� #2-�5%#2-$� 2+&� 91-&� #%� +@+##-$-&� ;%5-"8,� ,2-1#-$� ;2-"� L2-� @-1)-6-&�� ;)#2%'#� )"6-,#)7+#)%"M� #2+#� ;+,'""-(-,,+$=MA���������D5+)1�9$%5��2+$%"��+$5-$���2)1&�&6%(+#-��$)3%"+��$%#-(#)6-�+$-"#,�-#;%$C��#%� %+"��-)-$�L�(#!�����0��0�����������M�L;$)#)"7�#2+#�#2-�(',#%&=-6+1'+#%$� 1+@-1-&��+$5-$�+"�: +1)-"+#)"7�4+$-"#< �@-(+',-�%9�2-$� $-4-+#-&�(1+)5,�%9#2-�(2)1&8,�,-E'+1�+@',-�@=�2-$�9+#2-$��@+,-&�%"�#2-�#%&&1-$8,�,#+#-5-"#,�+"&�,-E'+1+(#)"7�%'#MA��%5@+$&)�������"%#-��B��+#��+$#�.A�>���������/�����������������"%#-��!

�*�! �"�#2+#�(+,-�#2-�(1)-"#�$-4%$#-&�#2+#�2-$�4,=(2%1%7),#�,+)&��: H,K%�2-8,�+@',-&=%'!��/'#�2-�1%6-,�#2%,-�C)&,!< ��>+)#,�������"%#-������+#�.*D�.!��>2-"�$-5)"&-&�#2+##2-� #2$--D=-+$D%1&� 2+&� ,--"� #2-� +@',-�� #2),� 4,=(2%1%7),#� $-,4%"&-&�� : �2-8,� =%'"7�,2-811� 7-#� %6-$� )#!< � � ���� +#� ��!� � �2-$-� 2+6-� @--"� ,'77-,#)%",� #2+#� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,� +$-&),)"(1)"-&�#%�$-(%7")3-�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+5%"7�'44-$�5)&&1-�(1+,,�;2)#-�4-%41-!>2)1-� #2+#� ),� %9#-"� #$'-�� 5=� -E4-$)-"(-� ),� #2+#� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,� )"� (',#%&=� (+,-,� +$-&),)"(1)"-&�#%�($-&)#�%$�7)6-� )#�+"=�;-)72#� )"�+11�$+(-,�+"&�(1+,,-,!� �/%#2��+,-���+"&�+,-�0�)"6%16-&�9$)(+"D5-$)(+"�5)&&1-�%$�1%;-$D5)&&1-�(1+,,�9+5)1)-,!

�*�� ����>���������/�����������������"%#-�����+#�0��L,#+#)"7�#2+#�5%$-�#2+"�%"-: ,#+#-�+(#%$< �)7"%$-&��5)")5)3-&�%$�$-9',-&�#%�@-1)-6-�;%5-"8,�$-4%$#,�%9�4+$#"-$�%$(2)1&�+@',-�� $-,'1#)"7� )"�(%'$#�&-(),)%",� #%�41+(-�(2)1&$-"� )"�+@',-$,8�(+$-MA� �������!�!�6!�/!�!������!�!0&��B����BB�L�+,,!�44!��#!��BB�M�L"%#)"7�#2+#� #2-� #$)+1�(%'$#9%11%;-&� +� ��� $-(%55-"&+#)%"� %9� F%)"#� 1-7+1� (',#%&=� +"&� 4$)5+$=� $-,)&-"#)+1(',#%&=�#%�#2-�9+#2-$�&-,4)#-�#2-���8,�+(C"%;1-&75-"#�%9�@+##-$)"7�+"&�+�9+)1'$-�#%: +"+1=3-�!�!�!�#2-�9+5)1=�$-1+#)%",2)4,�)"�$-,4-(#�#%�#2-�(2+$+(#-$),#)(,�#%�@-�9%'"&�)"�+@+##-$-&�9+5)1=< MA��-"#�6!��$--"�������%!0&�.����L1+!��)6!�44!��BB�M�L"%#)"7� #2+##;%� 4,=(2%1%7=,#,�� )"(1'&)"7� #2-� 9+#2-$8,� #2-$+4),#�� ,#+#-&� #2+#� #2-� 9+#2-$� ;+,:'"1)C-1=< �#%�@-�6)%1-"#� )"� 9'#'$-�+"&� #2+#� #2-�5%#2-$�2+&�4,=(2%1%7)(+1�4$%@1-5,1)C-1=� #%� &-#-$)%$+#-� ;)#2%'#� #$-+#5-"#MA� /$%;"� 6!� /$%;"�� *��� �!0&� .��� L�C1+!� �#!44!� �BB�M� L+99)$5)"7� #2-� #$)+1� (%'$#8,� +;+$&� %9� +"� )"9+"#� #%� #2-� 9+#2-$�� &-,4)#--6)&-"(-� %9� ,%5-� : 6)%1-"#� %$� +77$-,,)6-� @-2+6)%$�< � ;2-$-� #2-� -E4-$#� ;)#"-,,�� ;2%2+&�4-$9%$5-&�4,=(2%1%7)(+1� #-,#,�%"�@%#2�4+$#)-,�� $-(%55-"&-&�(',#%&=�@-�7)6-"#%�#2-�9+#2-$�@-(+',-�%9�#2-�5%#2-$8,�: 2)72�&-7$--�%9�-6+,)6-"-,,< MA��+"-=�6!�>$-"��00��%!�0&��.���0D���L�+!��#!�44!��BB*M�L'42%1&)"7�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#�;2)(2�$-1)-&�)"4+$#�%"�+�4,=(2%1%7),#8,�9)"&)"7�#2+#�+�4,=(2%1%7)(+1�#-,#�;%'1&�,'77-,#�,2-�),�: )"�#2-&'54,�< �;2)1-� $-F-(#)"7� #2-�(',#%&=�-6+1'+#%$8,� $-(%55-"&+#)%"�%9�(',#%&=� #%� #2-5%#2-$MA� �"� $-� �',#%&=� %9� N)+�� ���� !�!0&� ..B�� .�0� "!�� L�+,,!� 44!� �#!� 0���M

53

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

2+,�@--"�+44%)"#-&�#%�$-4$-,-"#�#2-�(2)1&$-"8,�@-,#� )"#-$-,#,��2),�%$2-$� 9+)1'$-� #%� 1)"C� +&'1#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� #%� #2-� ;-19+$-� %9� #2-(2)1&$-"� 6)$#'+11=� -",'$-,� #2+#� #2+#� $-1+#)%",2)4� ),� $-"&-$-&)"6),)@1-!

�*�� � �6-"� )9� #2-� 5%#2-$8,� +##%$"-=� 4%)"#,� %'#� #2-� 1)"C� +"&

5+C-,�+$7'5-"#,�+@%'#�#2-�(2)1&$-"8,�@-,#�)"#-$-,#,��,'(2�+&6%(+(=�),#=4)(+11=�&),(%'"#-&�+,�5-$-1=�:4+$#),+"< �+"&�1+$7-1=�)7"%$-&!

7� ��������� �*������ ����1��� �����

�2-� ,-(%"&�4$%@1-5�;)#2�$-1)+"(-�%"�"-'#$+1,� )"�(',#%&=�(+,-,� ),#2-� "+#'$-� %9� ,'(2� -E4-$#,8� ,%D(+11-&� :"-'#$+1)#=!< � � �2-� :-?'+1)#=4$)"()41-< � &),(',,-&� +@%6-� )"� (%""-(#)%"� ;)#2� F'&7-,� ),� +(#)6-1=� +#;%$C� 2-$-� #%%!� � �-"#+1� 2-+1#2� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,�� +"&�� )#� +44-+$,�� 5%,#��,�� ,--5� #%� -?'+#-� "-'#$+1)#=� +"&� %@F-(#)6)#=� ;)#2� 4$-,-$6)"7� +"-?'+1� $%1-� 9%$� @%#2� 4+$-"#,�� ;2)(2� #+C-,� #2-� 9%$5� %9� +� ;)&-,4$-+&4$%9-,,)%"+1� @)+,� 9%$� F%)"#� (',#%&=� +"&� ,2+$-&� 4+$-"#)"7!

�**� � �2),

4$-9-$-"(-�&-$)6-,�"%#�%"1=�9$%5�#2-�6)-;�#2+#�F%)"#�(',#%&=�),�)"�#2-@-,#� )"#-$-,#,� %9� (2)1&$-"�� @'#� +1,%� 9$%5� #2-,-� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,8� �����"%$5,!���2-�4$)"()41-,�'"&-$1=)"7�5%,#�5-"#+1�2-+1#2�4$%9-,,)%"+1,8;%$C�� #2+#� $-1+#)%",2)4,� +$-� +� #;%D;+=� ,#$--#�� +"&� #2+#� 4$%@1-5,� )"9+5)1)-,� +$-� #2-� ,2+$-&� $-,4%",)@)1)#=� %9� #2-� 9+5)1=�� 5)1)#+#-� +7+)",##2-� ,-6-$)"7� %9� $-1+#)%",2)4,�� ;2)1-� $-)"9%$()"7� +"� -542+,),� %"&-6-1%4)"7�5%$-� (%",#$'(#)6-� 4%,#D&)6%$(-� )"#-$+(#)%",� @-#;--"� #2-9%$5-$� 5+$$)-&� 4+$#"-$,!

�*B� � �%$� 5%,#� 5-"#+1� 2-+1#2� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,�

L'42%1&)"7�#2-�#$)+1�(%'$#8,�+;+$&�%9�,%1-�1-7+1�+"&�42=,)(+1�(',#%&=�#%�#2-�9+#2-$�%"#2-� 7$%'"&,� #2+#� #2-� 5%#2-$� 2+&� : (%",),#-"#1=� &-")-&� #2-� 9+#2-$� 4+$#)()4+#)%"� )"9'"&+5-"#+1�&-(),)%",< �+"&�;2-$-� #2-����$-(%55-"&-&�F%)"#� 1-7+1�+"&�42=,)(+1(',#%&=MA��+"")"7�6!�>)-(C%;,C)��%!��.DB*D���*���BBB�>����*��B��+#�S���L�)""!��#!44!� �+$!� B�� �BBBM� L'42%1&)"7� #2-� #$)+1� (%'$#8,� +;+$&� %9� 42=,)(+1� (',#%&=� #%� #2-9+#2-$� &-,4)#-� #2-� (2)1&8,� 4$-9-$-"(-� 9%$� #2-� 5%#2-$� @+,-&� )"� 4+$#� %"� #2-$-(%55-"&+#)%"� %9� #2-� 4,=(2%1%7),#� ;2%� 4-$9%$5-&� 4,=(2%1%7)(+1� #-,#,�� %@,-$6-&@%#2� 4+$#)-,� ;)#2� #2-� (2)1&�� +"&� ,'77-,#-&� #2+#� #2-�5%#2-$8,� (1+)5,� %9� +@',-� ;-$-: #$'54-&� '4< MA� �;+"� 6!� �;+"�� �.�� !>!0&� ��B� L!�!� �BB�M� L$-6-$,)"7� #2-� #$)+1(%'$#8,�+;+$&�%9�(',#%&=�#%�#2-�9+#2-$�� )"�4+$#�@-(+',-�%9� )54$%4-$�$-1)+"(-�%"� #2-9+#2-$8,�,%()+1�;%$C-$�;)#"-,,�+,�+"�: -E4-$#< �%"�2),�6)%1-"#�(%"&'(#M!

�*�! >2)1-���,�+$-�2+$&-$� #%�(+#-7%$)3-� L#2-=� #-"&� #%�@-�-)#2-$�5-"#+1�2-+1#24$%9-,,)%"+1,�%$� 1+;=-$,M�� #2-=�+1,%�+$-�#=4)(+11=�5)")5+11=�-&'(+#-&�+@%'#�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-��+"&�2+6-�7-"-$+11=�@--"�"%#�%"1=�'"2-149'1�@'#�&-#$)5-"#+1�)"�#2-,-�(+,-,!�2),�;+,�#$'-�)"��+,-�0!������1�3�������!�!�0&�+#��BBA��D5+)1�9$%5��)"&+��+$"+2+"��#% %+"� �-)-$� L4$!� 0.�� 0����� ���..� ���M� L%"� 9)1-� ;)#2� +'#2%$M� L&-#+)1)"7� +"%#2-$2%$$%$� ,#%$=� )"6%16)"7�@%#2�+����+"&�5-"#+1�2-+1#2�-6+1'+#%$,M!� ����� ������������'�%#-�������"%#-��0��+#����A��+#$)()+�>-"��1���� ������(������"��� ��/��������/��%6!� 0��� 0��0�� +#� /0� L"%#)"7� #2+#� :��,� 2+6-� @--"� +((',-&� %9� 1)")"7� '4� +1%"7)&-%1%7)(+1�1)"-,�#2+#�4$-&),4%,-�#2-5�#%�@-1)-6)"7I %$�"%#�@-1)-6)"7I +11-7+#)%",�%9+@',-< M!

�**� ����/%;-$5+,#-$�������"%#-������+#�0B�!

�*B! ��+5�7$+#-9'1�#%� +"-#�/%;-$5+,#-$�9%$�($=,#+11)3)"7�#2),�4%)"#!������+#�0B�DB�!�2),� '"&-$,#+"&)"7� %9� 5-"#+1� 2-+1#2� 4-$,4-(#)6-,� %"� &)6%$(-� ),� +1,%� )"9%$5-&� @=�+$#2+��)"-5+"!�������+$#2+��)"-5+"�� ������ � ������,�%������������������,���������� "����� ��� "���� "� ���� ��������)����� ���� ���!� �!� ���!� �0��� �.�� L�B**M

54

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

-E(-4#� #2%,-� ;)#2� -E4-$#),-� )"� +@',-�� #2-$-� ),� +� &--4� $-,),#+"(-� #%('##)"7�%99� (%"#+(#� @-#;--"� #2-� 4+$-"#,�� 1-#� +1%"-� $-&'()"7� (%"#+(#@-#;--"�+�4+$-"#�+"&�(2)1&!���$%")(+11=��+"&�,%5-#)5-,�#$+7)(+11=��#2-(%55'")(+#)%"�+"&�4$%(-,,� 6+1'-,� #2+#�5-"#+1� 2-+1#2�4$%9-,,)%"+1,4$)6+#)3-� +$-� +"+#2-5+� #%� 5+"=� @+##-$-&� ;%5-"�� 9%$� ;2%5� ,'(2(%55'")(+#)%"� +"&� :4$%(-,,< � $-4$-,-"#,� +"� %44%$#'")#=� 9%$(%"#)"'-&�2+$+,,5-"#�+"& %$�#$+'5+!

�B����%$-%6-$��#2-�4%;-$�%9�#2-

:-?'+1)#=< � %$� ,2+$-&� 4+$-"#)"7� "%$5� ),� ,'(2� #2+#� -6-"� ,%5-���,;)#2� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� -E4-$)-"(-� +"&� +11-7-&� -E4-$#),-�� ,'@#1=� %$"%#�,%�,'@#1=�&),(%'"#�5%#2-$,8�(1+)5,�%9�+@',-�+"&�$-(%55-"&�F%)"#(',#%&=!

�B�

�'$#2-$5%$-�� +,� )"� #2-� ;%$C� %9� %2",#%"� &),(',,-&� +@%6-�� #2-5-"#+1� 2-+1#2� -542+,),� %"� ,2+$-&� $-,4%",)@)1)#=� 9%$� $-1+#)%",2)44$%@1-5,�� +"&� #2-� 4-$(-4#)%"� %9� +@',-� +,� "%� %"-� 4-$,%"8,� 9+'1#�+15%,#�)"-6)#+@1=�#$+",1+#-,�)"#%�F'&75-"#�+"&�@1+5-�%9�5%#2-$,�;2%$-,),#� (%"#+(#� ;)#2� #2-� +@',-$� 9%$� #2-5,-16-,� %$� #2-)$� (2)1&$-"!/+"($%9#� +"&� �)16-$5+"� "%#-� #2+#� )"� #2-)$� -E4-$)-"(-� ;)#2� (',#%&=1)#)7+#)%"�� +11-7+#)%",�%9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�%$� %9� )"(-,#� 4-$4-#$+#)%"#-"&� #%� $-?')$-� +� 2)72� 5-+,'$-� %9� ,'44%$#)"7� -6)&-"(-�� ;2-$-+,+11-7+#)%",�#2+#�+�5%#2-$�),�+##-54#)"7�#%�+1)-"+#-�#2-�(2)1&$-"�9$%5#2-)$� 9+#2-$� L-!7!�� @=� 5+C)"7� : 9+1,-< � +((',+#)%",� %9� +@',-M� +$-,%5-#)5-,�+((-4#-&�;)#2�1)##1-�%$�"%�9+(#'+1�@+,),!

�B0

�"&--&��)#�),�@-(%5)"7�+15%,#�"%$5+1�#%�,--�+�(1+)5�%9�: +1)-"+#)%"<;2-$-6-$�+@',-�),�+11-7-&�)"�+�(',#%&=�(+,-!

�B�� ��)6-"�#2-�4$-6+1-"(-

L"%#)"7� #2+#� #2-� )"91'-"(-� %9� 5-"#+1� 2-+1#2� -E4-$#,� %"� &)6%$(-� 2+,� @--"� #%-"(%'$+7-� #2-�4$%(-,,� #%� @-� 6)-;-&� 1-,,� +,� %"-� %9� #-$5)"+#)%"� %9� #2-� $-1+#)%",2)4#2+"�%9�$-D,#$'(#'$)"7�#2-�9+5)1=�#%�&-6-1%4�"-;��4%,#D&)6%$(-�$-1+#)%",2)4,M!� �>2)1-�)"-5+"�9%(',-,�4+$#)('1+$1=�%"�#2-�,%()+1�;%$C�4$%9-,,)%"��#2-,-�@)+,-,�+$-�)541)()#)"�%#2-$�5-"#+1�2-+1#2�4$%9-,,)%",�+,�;-11!

�B�! �"�%"-�(+,-�;)#2�;2)(2���+5�9+5)1)+$��#2-�(',#%&=�-6+1'+#%$��;2)1-�&),(%'"#)"7#2-�5%#2-$8,�(1+)5,�%9�,-E'+1�+@',-��42=,)(+1� )"#)5)&+#)%"�+"&�4,=(2%1%7)(+1�+@',-�)",),#-&� #2+#� 5%$-� &)$-(#� (%55'")(+#)%"� @-#;--"� #2-� 4+$-"#,� 5',#� @-� $-?')$-&�+7+)",#� 2-$� ;)11�� +"&� &-,4)#-� 2-$� 9-+$� %9� 2-$� -ED2',@+"&�� : 9%$� #2-� ,+C-� %9� #2-(2)1&$-"!<

�B�! �"� %"-� (+,-� )"� >+,2)"7#%"�� �!�!�� #2-� ���� ;2%� 2+&� 4$-6)%',1=� 1)#)7+#-&&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� (+,-,� %"� @-2+19� %9� 6)(#)5�� +"&� ;+,� ,--"� @=� #2-� (%'$#,� +,� 2+6)"7&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�-E4-$#),-��$-(%55-"&-&�F%)"#�(',#%&=�&-,4)#-�#2-�(1-+$�+11-7+#)%",%9�+@',-!���6-"�)9�#2-�5%#2-$�2+&�@--"�1=)"7�+@%'#�#2-�+@',-��)#�),�&)99)('1#�#%�)5+7)"-2%;�F%)"#�(',#%&=�(%'1&�;%$C�'"&-$�,'(2�(%"&)#)%",!

�B0� ����/������G���������������"%#-�����+#��0�!

�B�! �+&1=�� #2-�+1)-"+#)%"�(1+)5�+1,%�2+,� #2-�-99-(#�%9� ,)1-"()"7�(2)1&$-"8,� 6%)(-,!�"�(+,-,�;)#2�;2)(2���2+6-�@--"�+,,%()+#-&��;2-"�#2-�(2)1&$-"�6%)(-&�+�4$-9-$-"(-��� #%� ,--� #2-)$� 9+#2-$�� %$� %#2-$;),-� )"&)(+#-&� #$%'@1)"7� @-2+6)%$,� @=� #2-� 9+#2-$�� #2-(%'$#,� +"&� 9%$-",)(� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,� 4$-,'5-&� #2-=� ;-$-� : 4$%7$+55-&< � @=� #2-)$+1)-"+#)"7�5%#2-$!� ��2-� )"-6)#+@1-� (%$%11+$=� ),� #2+#������ $+#2-$� #2+"� 1-,,� (%"#+(#� ),%$&-$-&�� ,%�+,� #%� $-&'(-� #2-�5%#2-$8,� +11-7-&�+@)1)#=� #%� +1)-"+#-� #2-�(2)1&$-"� 9$%5#2-)$�9+#2-$!���#�),�+15%,#�'"2-+$&�%9�9%$�+�(%'$#�%$�9%$-",)(�-E4-$#�#%�(%"(1'&-�#2+##2-� (2)1&$-"�;-$-� +44$%4$)+#-1=� +1)-"+#-&� 9$%5� #2-)$� 9+#2-$� @-(+',-� %9� �� +@',)6-

55

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��0 ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

%9�#2),�'",()-"#)9)(�#2-%$=��)#,�+15%,#�,%1-�',-������ ��� ���L&-,4)#-#2-� ;)&-,4$-+&� $-+1)#=� %9� +@',-$,� )"#-"#)%"+11=� +1)-"+#)"7� (2)1&$-"9$%5�#2-)$�5%#2-$M��+"&�#2-�9$-?'-"#�$-F-(#)%"�%9�5%#2-$,8�(1+)5,�%9+@',-��)#�,--5,�%@6)%',�#2+#�:4+$-"#+1�+1)-"+#)%"< �),�#2-�+@',-$8,�5%,#4%#-"#�;-+4%"!���#,�$-5+$C+@1-�,'((-,,�)"�#2-�(%'$#,�),�-6)&-"(-�"%#%"1=� %9� 7-"&-$� @)+,�� @'#� %9� #2-� 4%;-$� %9� 9+1,-� :"-'#$+1)#=< � +"&:4+$-"#+1�-?'+1)#=!<

B� @���21�����������/����� ����0�*�

�2-�#2)$&�4$%@1-5�;)#2�$-1)+"(-�%"�9%$-",)(�-E4-$#,�)"�#2-,-�(+,-,),� #2-� )"+44$%4$)+#-� ;-)72#� #2-=� %9#-"� 7)6-� #%� ,%D(+11-&� %@F-(#)6-�,()-"#)9)(�� %$� (1)")(+1� #-,#)"7�� ,'(2� +,� #2-� �)""-,%#+� �'1#)42+,)(�-$,%"+1)#=� �"6-"#%$=� L:����<M�� #2-� :����D0�< � #2-� �2-5+#)(44-$(-4#)%"��-,#�L:��<M�+"&�%#2-$,!

�B.� �,�)"��+,-�0��+"&�,-6-$+1

%#2-$�(+,-,�;)#2�;2)(2���2+6-�@--"�)"6%16-&��#2-,-�#-,#,�+$-�$-7'1+$1=+&5)"),#-$-&� +"&� $-4%$#-&� @=� (',#%&=� -6+1'+#%$,� +,� #2%'72� #2-=4$%6)&-�$-1-6+"#�)"9%$5+#)%"�+@%'#�#2-�4+$-"#,8�4+$-"#)"7�(+4+()#=!

�B�

�"9%$#'"+#-1=�� 1)C-� %#2-$� +,4-(#,� %9� 9%$-",)(� -6+1'+#)%",� #2+#� 9+)1� #%4$%4-$1=� +,,-,,�&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�� #2-=� +$-�� +#�@-,#�� %9�5)")5+1� ',-�+"&�+#�;%$,#��-E#$-5-1=�&+5+7)"7�)"�#2-,-�(+,-,��@-(+',-�#2-=�#-"&�#%4+#2%1%7)3-� 6)(#)5,� +"&� "%$5+1)3-� #2-� 4-$,%"+1)#=� #$+)#,� %94-$4-#$+#%$,!

�)$,#�� -6-"� %'#,)&-� #2-� ;%$1&� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�� #2-$-� ),,)7")9)(+"#�&%'@#�+@%'#�#2-�6+1)&)#=�%9�#2-�',-�%9�#2-,-�#-,#,I 5%,#�%9;2)(2� ;-$-� )"6-"#-&� 9%$� ��������� ',-I 9%$� 9%$-",)(� 4'$4%,-,!� � �%$)",#+"(-�� #2-� ����� ;+,� )"6-"#-&� +,� +� :7$%,,� ,($--")"7� &-6)(-� 9%$,-6-$-� 4,=(2)+#$)(� &),%$&-$,�!�!�!� #%� )&-"#)9=� ,)7")9)(+"#4,=(2%4+#2%1%7=�� "%#� #2-� ,5+11� &)99-$-"(-,� )"� $-1+#)6-1=� 5)1&4+#2%1%7)-,�5%$-�%9#-"�9%'"&�)"�4+$#)-,�#%�+�(',#%&=�&),4'#-!<

�B�

(%"&'(#!���6-"�)9�)#�;-$-�#$'-�#2+#�5+"=�;%5-"�1)-�+@%'#�+@',-�+"&�;$%"79'11=�,--C#%� +1)-"+#-� #2-)$� (2)1&$-"� 9$%5� #2-)$� 9+#2-$,� L;2)(2�� +,� 4$-6)%',1=� ,#+#-&� ),� #2-%44%,)#-� %9� (%55%"�-E4-$)-"(-M� ,'$-1=� ��� ���� )#� ;%'1&� @-� #$'-� #2+#� +"� +@',)6-9+#2-$8,�(2)1&$-"�;%'1&�+44$%4$)+#-1=�,--C�#%�$-&'(-�#2-)$�(%"#+(#!� ��-#����2+6-�,--"6)$#'+11=�"%�4'@1),2-&�&-(),)%",�#%�#2),�-99-(#!� ��� �����%$&�6!��%$&�������%!�0&��B���B�DB�� L�1+!� �),#!� �#!� 44!� �BB�M� L$-6-$,)"7� #2-� #$)+1� (%'$#8,� %4)")%"� +"&+&5%"),2)"7� #2-� 1%;-$� (%'$#� 9%$� 9+)1'$-� #%� #+C-� )"#%� )#,� (%",)&-$+#)%"� #2+#� #2-5%#2-$� 5+=� "%#� 2+6-� @-2+6-&� +,� +� : 9$)-"&1=� 4+$-"#< � &'-� #%� #2-� 9+#2-$8,� +@',)6-@-2+6)%$M!

�B.� ���� ���������� �+")-1� >!� �2'5+"��*�� 1���� ���+�� ��� 3��� � &'��� � ��� "� ��� ������#��������,�%�����������*� ,�����"��������5������ �������!��!P!��.0D.����.BD��L0��0M!

�B�� ����(+,-,�()#-&������"%#-��*�!

�B�� ���� /%;-$5+,#-$�� ����� "%#-� ����� +#� 0B�� L?'%#)"7��+6)&� !� /%1%(%9,C=����������������+�� ���3��� �&'��� � ���"����"� ���� � ������ �������/���!����!�G��!�B���0���L�B*BMM!

56

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

�,-� %9� ,'(2� +� #-,#� :;)#2%'#� ,()-"#)9)(� 6+1)&+#)%"� 9%$� ',-� )"� (2)1&(',#%&=� (%"#-E#,<

�B�� ;%'1&� +44-+$� #%� $-"&-$� #2-� $-,'1#,� "%"D

,()-"#)9)(+11=� 6+1)&A� =-#�� #2),� #=4-� %9� #-,#� ),� (%55%"1=� $-1)-&� %"� )"(',#%&=�-6+1'+#)%",�+,�4$%6)&)"7�:%@F-(#)6-�< � : ,()-"#)9)(< �&+#+�;2)(2(+"� )"9%$5� #2-� (%'$#� +@%'#� #2-� 4+$#)-,8� $-1+#)6-� 9)#"-,,� 9%$� (',#%&=!>2)1-� %#2-$� #-,#,� ;-$-� )"6-"#-&� ,4-()9)(+11=� 9%$� ',-� )"� (',#%&=-6+1'+#)%",�� #2-,-� 2+6-� +1,%� @--"� ($)#)()3-&� : 9%$� #2-)$� 1+(C� %9&-5%",#$+#-&� $-1)+@)1)#=� +"&� 6+1)&)#=�� #2-� '"$-+1),#)(� %$� '"#-,#-&+,,'54#)%",�#2-=�(%"#+)"��+"&�4$%@1-5,�;)#2�#2-�,+541-�4%4'1+#)%",#2$%'72�;2)(2�#2-=�;-$-�&-6-1%4-&!<

�B*

�2-� #$+&)#)%"+1� 4,=(2%1%7)(+1� #-,#,� +$-� -6-"� 5%$-� 4$%@1-5+#)(;2-$-�&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ),� (%"(-$"-&!� � �#'&)-,� (%"&'(#-&� #%� +,,-,,2%;�#2-,-�#-,#,�;%$C�)"�(+,-,�)"6%16)"7�+�2),#%$=�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-2+6-�(%",),#-"#1=�9%'"&��9%$�-E+541-��#2+#�@+##-$)"7�5-"�:%9#-"�1%%C'"-E(-4#)%"+1�%"�4,=(2%1%7)(+1�#-,#,�,'(2�+,�#2-�����!<

�BB���#'&)-,�%9

#2-������+"&�#2-��)1#%"��1)")(+1��'1#)+E)+1��"6-"#%$=�L:����<M�+,+441)-&�#%�@+##-$-$,�2+6-�9%'"&�#2+#�#2-$-�;-$-�: 9-;�,(+1-�-1-6+#)%",)"&)(+#)"7�4+#2%1%7=!<

0�����%"6-$,-1=�

H#K2-� ����D0�� 9%$� -E+541-�� )"(1'&-,� 5+"=� ?'-,#)%",� #2+#�� )9+",;-$-&� +(('$+#-1=� @=� +� @+##-$-&� ;%5+"�� ;)11� (%"#$)@'#-� #%-1-6+#-&�,(+1-�,(%$-,��,'(2�+,�;2-#2-$�,2-�@-1)-6-,�#2+#�,%5-%"-�),9%11%;)"7�2-$��;2-#2-$� ,2-�2+,� #$%'@1-� ,1--4)"7�+#�")72#��;2-#2-$,2-�;%$$)-,� 9$-?'-"#1=��%$�;2-#2-$�,2-�@-1)-6-,�+"%#2-$� )"&)6)&'+1),�$-,4%",)@1-�9%$�5%,#�%9�2-$�#$%'@1-,!

0��

�"&--&�

H)K"�+"�-+$1)-$�,#'&=�%9�#2-�������@+##-$-&�;%5-"�#-"&-&�#%�2+6-?')#-� -1-6+#-&� ,(%$-,� 9%$� +"7-$�� +1)-"+#)%"�� +"&� (%"9',)%"�,%5-;2+#� -1-6+#-&� ,(%$-,� 9%$� 4+$+"%)+� +"&� 9-+$9'1"-,,�� +"&� 1%;,(%$-,�9%$�)"#+(#"-,,�+"&�-7%�,#$-"7#2�!�!�!

0�0

�B�� ���

�B*� ���� ���� +#� 0B*!� � /%;-$5+,#-$� (%"(1'&-,� #2+#� : H;K)#2%'#�!�!�!� 6+1)&+#)%"�� -6-"#2-,-�"-;1=�&-6-1%4-&�5-+,'$-,�(+""%#�@-�',-&�;)#2�(%"9)&-"(-!< ������/%;-$5+,#-$%99-$,�+�"'5@-$�%9�+&&)#)%"+1�($)#)?'-,�%9�5-"#+1�2-+1#2�9%$-",)(�-E4-$#,8�4$+(#)(-,�)"(',#%&=�-6+1'+#)%",�� )"(1'&)"7� #2+#� #2-$-� ),� +� 1+(C�%9�-54)$)(+1� $-,-+$(2� #%� ,'44%$#5+"=� %9� #2-� 6+1'-� F'&75-"#,� -6+1'+#%$,� 5+C-� +@%'#� &-,)$+@1-� 4+$-"#+1(2+$+(#-$),#)(,A� #2+#� #2-� 4,=(2%1%7)(+1� #-,#,� +$-� @%#2� %6-$D',-&� +"&� 5),D',-&A� #2+#5-"#+1�2-+1#2�4$%9-,,)%"+1,�+$-�"%#�,C)11-&�+#�:5+C)"7�(1)")(+1�F'&75-"#,�9%$�"%$5+1H+,�%44%,-&� #%�4+#2%1%7)(+1K�4%4'1+#)%",A< �+"&� #2+#� #2-)$� F'&75-"#,� +$-�%9#-"� : )"9+(#� )"+(('$+#-!< ������ ����+#�0B�D��A��������/������G���������� �����"%#-�����+#��*� L,#+"&+$&)3-&� 4,=(2%1%7)(+1� #-,#,� #2+#� 4'$4%$#� #%� 5-+,'$-� 4+$-"#)"7� (+4+()#=: +$-�4%%$�4$-&)(#%$,� %9� 4+$-"#)"7� (+4+()#=� +"&� +$-� (%55%"1=� 7)6-"� )"+44$%4$)+#-;-)72#�@=�(',#%&=�-6+1'+#%$,< M!

�BB� ����/������G���������������"%#-�����+#�0B�D��!

0��� �����#+$C��1�2����� ������������ ������������"%#-�����+#����*�"!�B�!

0��� ����/������G���������������"%#-�����+#���*!

0�0� ���

57

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��. ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

�,=(2%1%7)(+1� #-,#-$,� +$-� +4#� #%� @-1)-6-� #2-)$� #-,#,� #-11� #2-5,%5-#2)"7!��>2-"�#2+#�: ,%5-#2)"7< �),�:"%$5+1�< �)#�),�&)99)('1#��)9�"%#)54%,,)@1-��#%�(%"6)"(-�#2-�-6+1'+#%$I +"&�#2-$-@=�#2-�(%'$#I #2+##2),� :"%$5+1< � 9+#2-$� ),� )"� 9+(#� 6)%1-"#� +"&� &+"7-$%',!� � �%"6-$,-1=�;2-"� #2-� #-,#,� )"&)(+#-� : -1-6+#-&� ,(+1-,< � 9%$� #2-� 5%#2-$�� )!-!�)"&)(+#)%",� %9� :4-$,%"+1)#=� &),%$&-$,< � %$� 4+#2%1%7=�� -6+1'+#%$,� ;)11"+#'$+11=� (%"(1'&-� #2+#� #2-�5%#2-$� ),� : ,)(C< � %$� 1-,,� 4,=(2%1%7)(+11=2-+1#2=�#2+"�#2-�9+#2-$!���2-�"-#�-99-(#�),�#2+#�-E),#)"7�4,=(2%1%7)(+1#-,#,� #-"&� #%� 4+#2%1%7)3-� @+##-$-&� ;%5-"�� (-$#)9=� #2-� @+##-$-$� +,:"%$5+1�< � +"&�&-91-(#� +##-"#)%"� +1#%7-#2-$� 9$%5�&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-!�-#�%"(-� ,'(2�&+#+�+$-�4$%6)&-&� #%�+�(%'$#��%9#-"�;)#2%'#� ,'99)()-"#(+6-+#,�� )#� ),� ,--"� +,� :%@F-(#)6-< � +"&� : ,()-"#)9)(< � +"&� 7)6-")"+44$%4$)+#-�4$%@+#)6-�;-)72#!

�"9%$#'"+#-1=�� 5%,#� (%'$#,� +$-� "%#� +;+$-� %9� #2-� 1)5)#+#)%",� +"&)"+&-?'+()-,�%9�#2-�4,=(2%1%7)(+1�: -E4-$#,< �+"&�#-,#,�%"�;2)(2�#2-=$-1=!���%$-%6-$��9%$�#2-�$-+,%",�+1$-+&=�&),(',,-&��(%'$#,�#-"&�#%�$-1=?')#-� 2-+6)1=� %"� #2-,-� +44+$-"#1=� :%@F-(#)6-< � $-(%55-"&+#)%",!�+&1=��#2-�$-,'1#�%9#-"�),�#2+#�(2)1&$-"8,�@-,#�)"#-$-,#,�)"�(',#%&=�(+,-,(%"(-$")"7� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +$-� "-)#2-$� +(('$+#-1=� +,,-,,-&� "%$4$%#-(#-&�)"�#2-�%'#(%5-!

�"-� $-5-&=� 9%$� #2-,-� ;)&-,4$-+&� 9+)1'$-,� %9� 9%$-",)(� +,,-,,5-"#9%$�;2)(2�#2-$-�),�+�7$%;)"7�&-5+"&�),�#2-�+44%)"#5-"#�%9�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-� -E4-$#,� #%� +,,-,,� 9%$� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� )"� #2-,-� (+,-,!

0��

�%;-6-$�� ;2)1-� )"(1',)%"� %9� ,%5-� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� -E4-$#,� 5)72#)54$%6-� %"� #2-� #$+(C� $-(%$&� %9� %#2-$� 5-"#+1� 2-+1#2� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,�(+'#)%"�),�(+11-&�9%$��)"($-+,)"71=��,%5-�9%$-",)(�4$%9-,,)%"+1,��,'(2�+, %2",#%"��+$-�&-6-1%4)"7�-"%'72�C"%;1-&7-�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�#%?'+1)9=� +,� : -E4-$#,�< � @'#� ,#)11� +44-+$� #%� $-#+)"� #2-� @)+,-,� #%;+$&5'#'+1)#=��,2+$-&�$-,4%",)@)1)#=��+"&�,2+$-&�4+$-"#)"7��;2)(2�-",'$-#2+#� #2-=�4-$4-#'+#-�5+"=�%9� #2-�('$$-"#�4$%@1-5,!� � �"� ,2%$#��'"#)1#2-� ,=,#-5� (+"� #$+",9%$5� )#,� 5),#+C-"� 4$-9-$-"(-� 9%$� 4+$-"#+1: -?'+1)#=< � )"� #2-,-� (+,-,� )"#%� +� 9'11-$�� 5%$-� (%541-E�� +"&� 5%$-2%"-,#� '"&-$,#+"&)"7� %9� #2-� $%1-� %9� @+##-$)"7� +"&� #2-� "--&,� %9(2)1&$-"��#2-�'"&-$1=)"7�,%'$(-�%9�#2-�4$%@1-5�;)11�$-5+)"!

(� �����(����3���4

�2-� 4$%@1-5,� &-#+)1-&� +@%6-� &%� "%#� 1-"&� #2-5,-16-,� #%� ,)541-�(1-+"�,%1'#)%",!���"&--&��)9�;-�&%�"%#2)"7�-1,-��#2),�$#)(1-�'$7-,�',�#%#+C-�+�,#-4�@+(C�9$%5�%'$�4%,)#)%",�+,�: +&6%(+#-,< �%$�:"-'#$+1,�< �+"&#$=� #%� (%",)&-$� ;2+#� ),� 6+1)&�� +"&� -6-"� +&5)$+@1-�� )"� #2-� :%#2-$<

0��! �#+$C��D5+)1�������"%#-�*.A�/������G���������������"%#-���A�>��������

/�����������������"%#-�����+#���!

58

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

4-$,4-(#)6-!���%$��+,���2+6-�"%#-&�-+$1)-$��;2)1-�"%#�#$'-�%9�+11��5+"=%9�#2%,-�;2%�&%�&-,#$'(#)6-�#2)"7,� )"�#2-,-�(+,-,�+$-�7%%&�+"&�;-11D5-+")"7� 4-%41-�;2%� &%� "%#� )"#-"&� #%� @-� 7-"&-$� @)+,-&�� +"&� ;2%;+"#� #%� 2-14� (2)1&$-"!� � �%� ,%5-� &-7$--�� +"=� 5-+")"79'1)54$%6-5-"#�)"�#2-�4$+(#)(-�)"�#2-,-�(+,-,�;)11�$-,#�%"�#2-�%4-")"7�%95)"&,�+"&�#2-�&--4-")"7�%9�4-%41-,8�'"&-$,#+"&)"7,��,%5-#2)"7�9%$;2)(2���2+6-�"%�5+7)(�4$-,($)4#)%"!

0�.

�%;-6-$�� #2),� $#)(1-� ;+,� )",4)$-&� )"� 4+$#� @=� #2-� �$--"� /%%C4$%(-,,� ('$$-"#1=� #+C)"7� 41+(-� +#� @%#2� +� "+#)%"+1� +"&� 1%(+1� 1-6-1+5%"7� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"�� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +"&� F'&)()+1� 4-$,%""-1!�)6-"�#2-�%@6)%',�%6-$1+4� )"� #2-�"+#'$-�%9� #2-� ),,'-,�+"&�4$%@1-5,(%"9$%"#-&� )"� #2-� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� +$-"+� +"&� #2-� 4$)6+#-� (',#%&=1)#)7+#)%"�&),(',,-&�2-$-��;2+#�5)72#�;-�#+C-�9$%5�#2+#�4$%(-,,�L"%#1-+,#��)#,�%4#)5),5�+"&�-"-$7=MJ

>2)1-�#2-��$--"�/%%C��")#)+#)6-�),�(-$#+)"1=�(%"9$%"#)"7�"'5-$%',(2+11-"7-,�� +"&� ,'((-,,� ),� 9+$� 9$%5� +,,'$-&�� )#� ),� )",4)$)"7� 9%$� %"-$-+,%"!� � �2),� )")#)+#)6-�� )"� 1-,,� #2+"� 9)6-� =-+$,�� 2+,� @$%C-"� %4-"� +9$%3-"�+$-+�%9� 1-7+1�4$+(#)(-�;2)(2�+&6%(+#-,�2+&� 1%"7�&-,4+)$-&�%9)54$%6)"7��)!-!��#2-�5%#2-$D@1+5)"7�('1#'$-�+"&�@'$-+'($+(=�%9�(2)1&4$%#-(#)%"� +7-"()-,!� � �2-� �$--"� /%%C� �")#)+#)6-8,� )"#-"#)%"+1�(%"(-$#-&�+"&�(+$-9'1�4$%(-,,�%9�(%11+@%$+#)%"�2+,�@-7'"�#%�,2+C-�'4%1&�;+=,� %9� 1%%C)"7� +#� #2-,-� 9+5)1)-,� +"&�2+,� %4-"-&� &)+1%7'-� +"&-6-"� ,4+;"-&� "-;� 4$+(#)(-,� #%� +� &-7$--� #2+#� ;%'1&� 2+6-� @--"&)99)('1#�#%�)5+7)"-�9)9#--"�=-+$,�+7%!

0����"&�;2)1-�7-"&-$�@)+,�),�"%#

&)$-(#1=� +&&$-,,-&� )"� #2-��$--"�/%%C�� )#� ),� "-(-,,+$)1=� +� ,'@D#-E#� #%5'(2�%9�#2-�(%11+@%$+#)6-�&)+1%7'-�#2+#�#+C-,�41+(-�@-#;--"�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-�+&6%(+#-,��(%'$#,�+"&�(2)1&�;-19+$-�$-4$-,-"#+#)6-,!��

/-(+',-� #2-� �$--"� /%%C� �")#)+#)6-� 2+,� )"� 9+(#� 7-"-$+#-&$-5+$C+@1-�5%5-"#'5�+"&�,%5-�-E()#-5-"#�+@%'#�#2-�4%#-"#)+1�9%$&--4� (2+"7-�� +� (%",)&-$+#)%"� %9� )#,� )541)(+#)%",� 9%$� #2-� 4+$+11-1(',#%&=�(%"#-E#�,--5,�;%$#2;2)1-!���2-�9%11%;)"7�,-(#)%"��#2-$-9%$-�

0�.� �� �����$--&5+"�������"%#-����L+$7')"7�#2+#�+441)(+#)%"�%9�: (%54+,,)%"+#-

;)#"-,,)"7< �@=�+11�)"6%16-&�4+$#)-,�),�($)#)(+11=�"--&-&�+"&�5+=�@-�#2-�%"1=�+6-"'-�#%#2-�4$%9%'"&�#=4-,�%9�,%()+1�+"&�1-7+1�(2+"7-�(+11-&�9%$�)"�#2),�+$-+M!

0��! �"� #2-� -+$1=� �BB�,�� �� ;+,� )"6%16-&� )"� ,%5-� &),(',,)%",� +@%'#� @$)"7)"7&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+&6%(+(=�#%�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�+7-"()-,!��+#)%"+1�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-+&6%(+#-,� ;-$-� )"#-",-1=� %44%,-&� #%� #2),� -99%$#� @+,-&� %"� 4$-6)%',� "-7+#)6--E4-$)-"(-,�#2-=�2+&�2+&�;2)(2�(%"6)"(-&�#2-5�#2+#�#2-,-�+7-"()-,�;%'1&�%"1=�',-+"=�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�-&'(+#)%"�#2-=�$-(-)6-&�#%�9'$#2-$�@1+5-�+"&�4'"),2�5%#2-$,!�%� ,%5-�-E#-"#�� #2-�-������� (+,-�� +"&� #2+#� +7-"(=8,� 4%1)(=� %9� $-5%6)"7� (2)1&$-"@-(+',-� #2-)$� 6)(#)5)3-&� 5%#2-$,� ;-$-� : -"7+7)"7� )"� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�< � 4$%6-&#2-5�(%$$-(#!���%;-6-$��+#�#2-�,+5-�#)5-�#2-�-�������&-(),)%"�'1#)5+#-1=�$-4$-,-"#,+� 7$%'"&@$-+C)"7� 6)(#%$=� 9%$� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� +&6%(+#-,!� � �2-� (%'$#8,� ,#$%"71=9+6%$+@1-� %4)")%"� ;+,� )"9%$5-&� )"� 4+$#� @=� #2-� �$--"� /%%C!� � ���� )(2%1,%"� 6!>)11)+5,��0����!��'44!�0&������0���� ��>��L0��0M!

59

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

&$+;,�%"�#2+#�4$-(-&-"#�#%�%99-$�,%5-�)5+7)"+#)6-�#2)"C)"7��+C)"�#%�+: #2%'72#� -E4-$)5-"#�< � +@%'#� 2%;� +� (%11+@%$+#)6-� $-,4%",-� #%� #2-4$%@1-5,�)"�#2-�4$)6+#-�1)#)7+#)%"�+$-"+�(%'1&�5+C-�+�&)99-$-"(-!

��! ������������������/�O�/��������/���������������

�������������������������������������������� �������

��������

:�"1)72#-"-&� (%11+@%$+#)%"< � )"� #2-� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� ,-##)"7� 2+,@-7'"�#%�+&&$-,,�#2-�#$+&)#)%"+11=�5%#2-$D@1+5)"7�+##)#'&-,�%9�(2)1&4$%#-(#)%"� +7-"()-,� L+"&� (%'$#,M�� +"&� #%� &-6-1%4� +� 5%&-1� %9� +$-,4-(#9'1�(%11+@%$+#)6-�4$%(-,,�)"�;2)(2�@%#2�,#+#-�+(#%$,�+"&�4$)6+#-+&6%(+#-,�,--C�#%�+11=�;)#2�+&'1#�6)(#)5,�%9�@+##-$)"7�)"�%$&-$�#%�@-,#4$%#-(#�@%#2�#2-�5%#2-$�+"&�#2-�(2)1&$-"!���"�#2),�(%"#-E#�)#�2+,�@--"$-(%7")3-&� #2+#� )#� ),� ($)#)(+1� #%� -"2+"(-� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� ;%$C-$,8'"&-$,#+"&)"7�%9�@+##-$)"7�+"&�,=54+#2=�9%$�+&'1#�6)(#)5,��+,�;-11�+,&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+&6%(+#-,8�C"%;1-&7-�%9�#2-�(2)1&�;-19+$-�,=,#-58,7%+1,� +"&�4$%(-,,�� +"&�+11� 4+$#)-,8� (%55)#5-"#� #%�2-14)"7�@+##-$-&5%#2-$,� 4$%#-(#� #2-)$� (2)1&$-"!� � � (%11+@%$+#)6-� +44$%+(2� ,--5,)"-6)#+@1-�+"&�"-(-,,+$=!

�"� 4$)6+#-� (',#%&=� 1)#)7+#)%"�� +,� )"� #2-� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� +$-"+�@+##-$-&�5%#2-$,8�(1+)5,�%9�@+##-$)"7�2+6-�@--"�&),(%'"#-&�%$�',-&+7+)",#�#2-5��+"&�#2-�#-"&-"(=�2+,�@--"�#%�@1+5-�#2-�5%#2-$��;2)1--E(',)"7� #2-� 9+#2-$�� 9%$�;2+#-6-$�2+$5,� #2-� (2)1&$-"�2+6-� ,'99-$-&!�2-�"-E#�#;%��+$#,�-"6),)%"�+1#-$"+#)6-�9%$5,�%9�(%11+@%$+#)%"�;2)(2(%'1&� 2-14� "-7+#-� #2-� (%'$#,� +"&� 4,=(2%D,%()+1� 4$%9-,,)%"+1,8#-"&-"(=� #%� &),(%'"#� 5%#2-$,8� (1+)5,�� +"&� -"2+"(-� #2-)$$-,4%",)6-"-,,�#%�#2-�$),C,�#%�(2)1&$-"�9$%5�#2-)$�5%#2-$,8�@+##-$-$,!��(+11� #2),�+�: #2%'72#�-E4-$)5-"#< �@-(+',-� ��+5�;-11�+;+$-� #2+#� #2-4$+(#)(+1�$-+1)#)-,�%9�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�4$+(#)(-�5+=�5-+"�#2+#�)#�;%'1&"%#� ;%$C�� +#� 1-+,#� "%#� '"#)1� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� +7-"()-,� +$-� 9+$� 5%$-#$+",9%$5-&�#2+"�),�1)C-1=�#%�2+44-"�,%%"!���%;-6-$��#2-�-E4-$)5-"#,--5,�;%$#2�(%",)&-$)"7��)9�%"1=�#%�@-##-$�($=,#+11)3-�#2-�4$%@1-5�;-9+(-�)"�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(- (',#%&=�1)#)7+#)%"A�+"&�#%�)5+7)"-�2%;�;-5)72#� ,#$'(#'$-� #2-� 4$%(-,,� )9� #2-� 4$%5),-� %9� #2-� �$--"� /%%C�")#)+#)6-�),�-6-"�4+$#1=�9'19)11-&!

�$%5� #2+#� ,#+"(-�� �� ;%'1&� +$7'-� #2+#�� )9�� +,� #2-� �$--"� /%%C�")#)+#)6-� ,'77-,#,�� #2-� �#+#-� ;-$-� ,-$)%',� +@%'#� )54$%6)"7� #2-4$%#-(#)%"� %9� (2)1&$-"� )"� 9+5)1)-,� ;)#2� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�� )#� ;%'1&#+C-�+�5%$-�+77$-,,)6-� ,#+"(-� #%� $-,#$)(#� #2-� $)72#,� %9� 9+#2-$,�;2%,-+@',-� %9� #2-� 5%#2-$� +"& %$� #2-� (2)1&$-"� 5+C-,� #2-5� '",+9-L42=,)(+11=�%$�4,=(2%1%7)(+11=M�9%$�#2-�(2)1&$-"!���2-$-�+$-�#;%�5-+",@=� ;2)(2� )#� (%'1&� &%� #2),�� L�M� @=� )"#-$6-")"7� )"� 4$)6+#-� 1)#)7+#)%"

60

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

;2-$-� (2)1&�;-19+$-� ),� +#� ,#+C-A� +"&� L0M� @=� )")#)+#)"7� #-$5)"+#)%"�%94+$-"#+1� $)72#,� )"� (+,-,� L4'@1)(� ��� 4$)6+#-M� ;2-$-� +� @+##-$-$� 2+,&-5%",#$+#-&�+"�)"+@)1)#=�%$�'";)11)"7"-,,�#%�-1)5)"+#-�#2-�#2$-+#�2-4%,-,�#%�#2-�9+5)1=!

��� %�����:%���� ��%�� �����

�+"=�F'&7-,8�+"&�5-"#+1�2-+1#2�4$%9-,,)%"+1,8�$-,),#+"(-�#%�#+C)"7,-$)%',1=� +�@+##-$-&�5%#2-$8,� (1+)5,�%9� $),C� #%� (2)1&$-"� ),� &$)6-"�� +#1-+,#� )"�4+$#�� @=� #2-� 9+(#� #2+#� ,2-� ),� +� 1)#)7+"#� ;)#2� +� 4$-,'5-&� ,-19D)"#-$-,#-&�@)+,�+7+)",#�#2-�%44%,)"7�4+$#=��;2)(2�(+,#,�&%'@#�%"�+11�%92-$�(1+)5,�+@%'#�#2-�(2)1&$-"8,�;-19+$-!���"�#2),�(%"#-E#��#2-�9+(#�#2+#,2-� 5+=� 2+6-� @--"� @+##-$-&� (+"� @-I +"&� %9#-"� ),I ,--"� +,� %"1=(%54%'"&)"7�2-$�$-+,%",�#%�,--C�#%�2'$#�#2-�9+#2-$��+"&�#2-$-@=�5+=%"1=�9'-1�#2-�,=,#-58,�,C-4#)(),5�#2+#�,2-�),�+(#'+11=�+&6%(+#)"7�9%$�#2-(2)1&$-"8,�@-,#�)"#-$-,#,!���%$-%6-$��@-(+',-�#2-�(%'$#�),�2-+$)"7�%"1=9$%5� #;%�;+$$)"7�4+$-"#,��@-(+',-� #2-$-� ),� +1$-+&=� ,#$%"7� ,=54+#2=9%$�9+#2-$,�;2%�,--C�)"6%16-5-"#�;)#2�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"��+"&�9%$�+11�#2-$-+,%",�&),(',,-&�-+$1)-$��(%'$#,�@-(%5-�&-+9�#%�5%#2-$,8�(1+)5,�#2+##2-=�+$-�+&6%(+#)"7�9%$�#2-�@-,#� )"#-$-,#,�%9�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"!� �>2+#�)9�2%;-6-$�� #2-�6-$=�+7-"(=�;2%,-�5),,)%"� ),� #%�4$%#-(#�(2)1&$-"��;-$-#%� F%)"� #2-� 1)#)7+#)%"� %"�@-2+19� %9� #2-� (2)1&$-"�� +"&� #%� ,'44%$#� #2-5%#2-$8,�(1+)5�#2+#�#2-�@+##-$-$�4%,-,�+�$),C�#%�#2-�(2)1&$-"J

�"�#2-�;%$1&���+5�-"6),)%")"7��)"�;2)(2�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�+7-"()-,2+6-� @--"� #2$%'72� #2-� �$--"� /%%C� 4$%(-,,�� 2+6-� 1-+$"-&� #%� @-@+##-$-&� 5%#2-$,8� +11)-,� )"� %$&-$� #%� 4$%#-(#� (2)1&$-"�� +"&� 2+6--,#+@1),2-&� +� (%11+@%$+#)6-�� $-,4-(#9'1� $-1+#)%",2)4� ;)#2� &%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-�+&6%(+#-,��)#�;%'1&�@-�+�"+#'$+1�-E#-",)%"�%9�#2-)$�4$%#-(#)6-$%1-� #%� )"#-$6-"-� )"�4$)6+#-� 1)#)7+#)%"�;2-$-� #2-� ,+5-�C)"&,�%9�(2)1&;-19+$-� ),,'-,� +$-� 4$-,-"#!� � �"� #2),� 6),)%"�� ,'(2� )"#-$6-"#)%"� ,2%'1&%(('$�%"1=�;2-"� )"6)#-&�� )!-!��;2-"�#2-�(%'$#�%$� #2-�4+$-"#�+11-7)"7+@',-�$-?'-,#,�#2-)$�+,,),#+"(-!

�2-�4$-,-"(-�%9�#2-��#+#-�+,�+�4+$#=�L%$�+5)(',�('$)+-M�)"#-$6-")"7%"�@-2+19�%9�#2-�(2)1&$-"��+"&�,'44%$#)"7�#2-�5%#2-$8,�(1+)5,��;%'1&9%$(-� (%'$#,� #%� #+C-� #2-� 5%#2-$8,� +11-7+#)%",� +@%'#� #2-� (2)1&$-"8,,+9-#=� ,-$)%',1=�� +"&� ;%'1&� 5+C-� )#� 5'(2� 2+$&-$� #%� &),(%'"#� #2-($-&)@)1)#=� L+"&� $-1-6+"(-M� %9� 2-$� +11-7+#)%",� %9� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-!�2),� ),� +� 4%#-"#)+11=� 4%;-$9'1� +"#)&%#-� #%� #2-� &--4D,-+#-&� #-"&-"(=#%;+$&� 5%#2-$D@1+5)"7� #2+#� $-,)&-,� )"� (',#%&=� (%'$#,!� � �2-4$-,'54#)6-�"-'#$+1)#=�%9�+� ,#+#-�+7-"(=�;2%,-�5),,)%"� ),� #%�4$%#-(#(2)1&$-"�;%'1&�7)6-�+'#%5+#)(�($-&)@)1)#=�#%�#2-�(1+)5�#2+#�+�@+##-$-$8,2),#%$=� %9� 6)%1-"(-� +7+)",#� #2-� 5%#2-$�� +"&� #2$-+#� #%� #2-� (2)1&$-"�,2%'1&�@-�7)6-"�,)7")9)(+"#�;-)72#�)"�&-#-$5)")"7�(2)1&�&),4%,)#)%",!

61

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��* ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

#�#2-�,+5-�#)5-��#2-�(%11+@%$+#)%"�%9�#2-�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�,=,#-5;)#2�+�@+##-$-&�5%#2-$�,2%'1&�9+()1)#+#-�5+C)"7�,-$6)(-,�+6+)1+@1-� #%@%#2� #2-� 5%#2-$� +"&� (2)1&$-"�� ;2)(2� 5+=� @-� ($)#)(+1� #%� +(2)-6)"7,+9-#=� +,� +� 4$+(#)(+1� 5+##-$� :%"� #2-� 7$%'"&!< � � �'(2� ,-$6)(-,� 5)72#)"(1'&-� +,,),#+"(-� ;)#2� $-D1%(+#)%"� +"&� 9)"&)"7� "-;� 2%',)"7�� ;)#2;-19+$-�� -541%=5-"#� +"&� -&'(+#)%"�� ,+9-#=� 41+"")"7� +"&� 5-#2%&,�+"&�%9�(%'$,-��(%'",-1)"7�#%�$-(%6-$�9$%5�#$+'5+�+"&�#%�,#$-"7#2-"#2-5� )"� #2-� (2+11-"7-,� +2-+&!� ��+"=�%9� #2-,-� ,-$6)(-,� ;%'1&� (%5-9$%5� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� %$7+")3+#)%",�� @'#� ,%5-�� -!7!�� -541%=5-"#�2%',)"7��-#(!��5)72#�+1,%�@-�4+$#�%9�#2-�+7-"()-,8�-E),#)"7�,4-(#$'5�%9,-$6)(-,�9%$�#2-)$�#$+&)#)%"+1�+@',-�+"&�"-71-(#�(+,-1%+&!

��-"6),)%"�#2),�:4$%4%,+1< �+,�@%#2�+"�)5+7)"+#)6-�)&-+�9%$�#2%,-�%9',�;2%�+$-�9$',#$+#-&�;)#2�#2-�(%'$#,8�$-,4%",-,�)"�#2-,-�(+,-,��+"&�+,+�(2+11-"7-�#%�#2-��#+#-!���"�#2-�%"-�2+"&��)#�;%'1&�%9�(%'$,-�%"1=�@-@-"-9)()+1�#%�5%#2-$,�+"&�(2)1&$-"�)9�#2-�+7-"(=�;-$-�+@1-�#%�F%)"�#2-1)#)7+#)%"� )"� +� ,'44%$#)6-� $%1-� #2+#� &%-,�� )"� 9+(#�� '"&-$,#+"&� #2-&%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-� ),,'-,�� #2-� $),C,� #%� (2)1&$-"�� +"&� ,--C,� #%,#$-"7#2-"�#2-�5%#2-$8,�4$%#-(#)6-�$%1-!� ��+"=�;)11� ,+=� #2+#�&+=�;)11"-6-$� (%5-I =-#� #2-� �$--"� /%%C� )"6)#-,� ',� #%� )5+7)"-� )#!� � #� #2-,+5-� #)5-�� #2-� 4$%4%,+1� (2+11-"7-,� #2-� �#+#-� #%� 5+C-� 7%%&� )#,(%55)#5-"#� #%� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"!� � �2-$-� 2+,� @--"� ,)7")9)(+"#+##-"#)%"� 7)6-"� #%� #2-� �$--"� /%%C� 4$%(-,,� @=� ,#+#-,� +"&� 9-&-$+1+'#2%$)#)-,!��,�+"�+&6%(+#-�9%$�@+##-$-&�;%5-"�+"&�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"��;+"#�#%�(2+11-"7-�#2-,-�-"#)#)-,�#%�$-(%7")3-�#2+#�#2-�,+5-�),,'-,��+"&,%5-#)5-,�#2-�,+5-�(2)1&$-"��+$-�+#�,#+C-�)"�4$)6+#-�(+,-,!���9�#2-�,#+#-),� ,-$)%',� +@%'#� &-6-1%4)"7� +"� -"1)72#-"-&�� ,'44%$#)6-� $-,4%",-� #%@+##-$-&� 5%#2-$,� ;2-$-� (2)1&$-"� +$-� +#� $),C�� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� L%$%#2-$�)"6%16-&M�+7-"()-,�,2%'1&�@-�+6+)1+@1-�#%�,4-+C�9%$�#2-�(2)1&$-")"�,'(2�(+,-,!

�2-�"%#)%"�%9�(%11+@%$+#)%"�@-#;--"�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�+7-"()-,�+"&@+##-$-&�5%#2-$,��;2)1-�2+$&�#%�)5+7)"-��),�"%#�"-;!

0��� ��"�-�������

0��! �2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�+7-"()-,8�'";)11)"7"-,,�#%�+,,),#�5%#2-$,�,--C)"7�#%�4$%#-(#

#2-)$�(2)1&$-"�9$%5�@+##-$-$,�2+,�@--"�+�,%'$(-�%9�7$-+#�9$',#$+#)%"�#%�5%#2-$,�+"&+&6%(+#-,!� � �),(',,+"#,� %"� #2-� :�����D��< � 1),#� ,-$6-� 2+6-� $-4-+#-&1=� $+),-&� #2),),,'-!� � �%$� )",#+"(-� %"-� 9%$5-$� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� ;%$C-$� +"&� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-,4-()+1),#�;)#2)"�+�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�+7-"(=�;$%#-�

H+K,�+�9%$5-$�����;%$C-$�+"&����,4-()+1),#�)"�+�����+7-"(=������&%-,�2+6-#2-� $-,%'$(-,�� +@)1)#=� +"&� $-,4%",)@)1)#=� #%� C--4� "%#� %"1=� (2)1&$-"�� @'#5%#2-$,I 9+5)1)-,�� ,+9-M!� � ���� 2+,� -"%$5%',� 4%;-$�� )#8,� 2%;����� ',-,� )#,4%;-$��+"&�2%;�#2-=�1-6-$+7-�#2-)$�$-,%'$(-,�+"&�#2-�4+$+&)75�9$%5�;2)(2#2-=�4$+(#)(-� #2+#�&-#-$5)"-,�+"&�7')&-,� ,+9-#=!� ��+#2-$� #2+"� $-1=)"7� ,%1-1=%"�,2-1#-$,�+"&�4%1)(-�#%�,-('$-�,+9-#=��(%",)&-$�4+$#"-$)"7�;)#2�#2-5!

�%,#)"7� %9� �)-"� /$+77�� #%� �����D��V5+)1!+@+"-#!%$7� L +"� 0�� 0���M� L(%4=� %"� 9)1-;)#2�+'#2%$M!���%%�%9#-"�#2-��#+#-8,�$-,4%",-�)"�#2-,-�(+,-,�2+,�@--"�#%�&),5),,� #2-+11-7+#)%",�+,�5-$-�1)#)7+#)%"�#+(#)(,!��,�&),(',,-&�������+$#����!/��2%;-6-$��#2-�9+(##2+#� +@',-� ),� $+),-&� )"� #2-� 1)#)7+#)%"� (%"#-E#� ),� "%#� +1%"-� +"� +&-?'+#-� @+,),� 9%$

62

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ��B

9%$�-E+541-��41+)"#)99,8�1+;=-$,�($)#)?'-&�-;��%$C8,�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"+7-"(=8,� 9+)1'$-� #%� +,,),#� ,%5-� 5%#2-$,� )"� %@#+)")"7� +$$-,#� %9� #2-@+##-$-$!���6-"�#2%'72�#2-�@+##-$-$�2+&�2)#�#2-�(2)1&��+"&�#2-�+7-"(=2+&�%4-"-&�+�(+,-�+7+)",#� #2-��� ���� #2-=� $-9',-&� #%�+&6%(+#-�;)#2#2-� 4%1)(-� 9%$� #2-� @+##-$-$8,� +$$-,#�� 4$-9-$$)"7� #%� $-5%6-� 9%'$#--"+7-$,� 9$%5� #2-� 2%',-� +"&� 4'#� #2-5� )"� #-54%$+$=� 9%,#-$� (+$-�;2)(2�(+',-&�%@6)%',�#$+'5+�+"&�&),$'4#)%"�#%�#2-)$�;-11D@-)"7!

0�����"

)",#+"(-,� ,'(2�+,� #2),�� +� ,)541-�42%"-�(+11� #%� #2-�4%1)(-�5)72#� ,+6-#2-�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�+7-"(=�9$%5�%4-")"7�+�"-;�(+,-�+"&�+&&)"7�#%#2-)$�%;"�(+,-1%+&!

�2-�)&-+�%9�,#+#-�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�+7-"(=�+"&�4$)6+#-�(%11+@%$+#)%"+1,%� +44-+$,� #%� 2+6-� @--"� #%'(2-&� %"� &'$)"7� #2-� �$--"� /%%C4$%(-,,!� � �"-� $-(%55-"&+#)%"� )"� #2-� �$--"� /%%C� ),� #2+#� (2)1&4$%#-(#)%"� ;%$C-$,� ,2%'1&� 5%")#%$� 4-$4-#$+#%$,8� (%541)+"(-� ;)#2,-$6)(-�41+",�+"&�4$%#-(#)%"�%$&-$,��+"&�,2%'1&�#-,#)9=�)"�(%'$#�+@%'##2-)$� 4$%#-(#)%"� %$&-$� 6)%1+#)%",!� �>2)1-� #2-� �$--"� /%%C� &%-,� "%#,4-()9=�)"�;2)(2�(%'$#,�)#�-"6),)%",�#2%,-�%$&-$,�@-)"7�2-+$&�

0�*�5%,#

4$%#-(#)%"�%$&-$�(+,-,�+$-�4$)6+#-1=�1)#)7+#-&!

�5+7)"-&�@-"-9)#,�+,)&-��#2),�&),(',,)%"�),�"%#�(%541-#-�;)#2%'#�+#1-+,#� @$)-91=� +(C"%;1-&7)"7� #2-� %@,#+(1-,� #%� ,'(2� +� (%11+@%$+#)%"!�)$,#� +"&� 9%$-5%,#� ),� #2-� )"+$7'+@1-� $-+1)#=� #2+#� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"+7-"()-,� +$-� "%#%$)%',1=� '"&-$D9'"&-&�� %6-$;2-15-&�@'$-+'($+#)(+11=�&=,9'"(#)%"+1�� +"&��&-,4)#-� #2-� ,5+11� &-"#�5+&-�@=#2-� �$--"� /%%C� �")#)+#)6-�� 9+)$1=� '")6-$,+11=� (%"&)#)%"-&� #%� ,--5%#2-$,�+,�#2-�4$%@1-5!���2',����(+""%#�,+=�-"%'72�#2+#�#2),�#2%'72#-E4-$)5-"#� 4$%4%,+1� ),� 4$-&)(+#-&� %"� #2-� +,,'54#)%"� #2+#� ;-� +$-;%$C)"7� ;)#2� +� ;-11D-&'(+#-&�� -"1)72#-"-&�� 5%&-$+#-1=� 9'"(#)%"+1+"&�,=54+#2-#)(�+7-"(=!

0�B

&),5),,)"7�5%,#�5%#2-$,8�+@',-�+11-7+#)%",!

0��! �%,#)"7� %9� )11� N'((+$&=�� +##%$"-=� 9%$� 41+)"#)99,�� #%� �����D��V5+)1!+@+"-#!%$7� L +"!� 0�� 0���M� L(%4=� %"� 9)1-� ;)#2� +'#2%$M!L,#+#)"7� : H;K-� ;-$-+(#'+11=� 2+44=�;2-"� #2-� 4%1)(-� (+11-&� )"� #%����� %"� #2-� +,,+'1#� %"� #2-� (2)1&!� � /'#;2-"� ��� ,2%;-&� '4�� #2-=� $-9',-&� #%� (+11� #2-� 4%1)(-� #%� +&6%(+#-� 9%$� 2),� +$$-,#T�",#-+&��#2-=�$-5%6-&�#2-�.�#--"+7-$,!�!�!�!���#�#%%C�5-�%6-$�+�;--C�#%�7-#�#2-�4%1)(-#%�+$$-,#�2)5��+"&����;%'1&"8#� -6-"�;-)72� )"�%"� )#< M!� �,� #2),� )",#+"(-� )"&)(+#-,�;2)1-�5+"=� &),(',,)%",� %9� @+##-$)"7� 9%(',� %"� ;%5-"8,� +5@)6+1-"(-� +"&� 9+)1'$-� #%#+C-� +(#)%"�� )"� $-+1)#=� 5+"=� @+##-$-&� ;%5-"� $-4-+#-&1=� ,--C� 4$%#-(#)%"� +"&+,,),#+"(-�� 9$%5�4%1)(-� +"&�%#2-$� +7-"()-,��;)#2%'#� ,'((-,,!� ��2-� )"#-$6-"#)%"�%9� +,#+#-�+7-"(=�%"� #2-)$�@-2+19�;)#2��-!7!�� #2-�4%1)(-��;%'1&� +15%,#� (-$#+)"1=� 7-#�5%$-$-,'1#,!�����

0�*� �����$--"�/%%C�������"%#-�����+#���!

0�B! �-%41-� )"6%16-&� )"� #2-� �$--"� /%%C� �")#)+#)6-� 2+6-� %@,-$6-&� (1-+$)54$%6-5-"#�)"�,%5-�����+7-"()-,8�$-,4%",-�#%�#2-,-�(+,-,� )"�#2-�9-;�=-+$,�%9� #2-�$%F-(#!���2-$-�),�,%5-�(+'#)%',�%4#)5),5�#2+#�#2-,-�)54$%6-5-"#,�(+"�@-�-E4-(#-&#%�(%"#)"'-!� ��-1-42%"-��"#-$6)-;�;)#2� -$$=��)16-$5+"���-")%$��%1)(=�"+1=,#���!�!�-4+$#5-"#� %9� �-+1#2� G� �'5+"� �-$6)(-,� L +"!� 0��� 0���M!� � �%;-6-$�� -6-"� )9� #2-+7-"(=� ;-$-� : -"1)72#-"-&< � %"� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�� #2-$-� $-5+)"� ;-11D&%('5-"#-&

63

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�0� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

�-(%"&1=�� -6-"� +,,'5)"7� ;2+#� �� +5� &-"%5)"+#)"7� +":-"1)72#-"-&< � +7-"(=�� )!-!�� %"-� ,=54+#2-#)(� #%� #2-� 4$%@1-5� %9@+##-$)"7�+"&�(+4+@1-�%9�$-,4%"&)"7�+44$%4$)+#-1=��#2-�5%,#�%@6)%',&%;",)&-�#%�,'(2�(%11+@%$+#)%"�;%'1&�@-�#2-�4$)6+#-�1)#)7+"#8,�1%,,�%9(%"#$%1�%9�#2-�(+,-!��,�+�5+##-$�%9�,#$'(#'$-�+"&�5),,)%"��%"(-�+�,#+#-+7-"(=� F%)",� #2-� 1)#)7+#)%"�� )#� ;)11� )"-6)#+@1=� 4'$,'-� )#,� %;"� +7-"&+!�6-"�+"�:-"1)72#-"-&< �+7-"(=�5+=�&),+7$--�;)#2� #2-�5%#2-$� +@%'#,%5-�#2)"7,��-!7!��-E+(#1=�2%;�5'(2�6),)#+#)%"�#2-�9+#2-$�,2%'1&�2+6-+"&� '"&-$� ;2+#� (%"&)#)%",�� +"&� )#� 5+=� +1,%� ;),2� #%� $+),-� ,%5-(%"(-$",� +@%'#� 2-$� 4+$-"#)"7� +,� ;-11!� �>%'1&� #2-,-� $),C,� %'#;-)72#2-�4%#-"#)+1�@-"-9)#,�%9�+�,'44%$#)6-�,#+"(-�$-7+$&)"7�#2-�$),C,�#%�#2-(2)1&$-"� 9$%5� #2-�@+##-$-$J� � �2),� (+""%#� @-� +",;-$-&� +,� +� 7-"-$+14%1)(=�5+##-$A�)#�;%'1&�2+6-�#%�@-�;-)72-&�)"�-+(2�(+,-�@=�#2-�1)#)7+"#L+"&� 2%4-9'11=� 2-$� (%'",-1M�� @+,-&� %"� #2-)$� +,,-,,5-"#� %9� #2-4+$#)('1+$� +7-"(=� )"� #2-)$� F'$),&)(#)%"� +"&� #2-� 4+$#)('1+$� ),,'-,� )"#2-)$�(+,-!

�2)$&�� ,'@,#+"#)+1� 4$+(#)(+1� +"&� 42)1%,%42)(+1� 4$%@1-5,� +##+(2� #%#2-�?'-,#)%"�%9�2%;�+� (2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"� +7-"(=�;%'1&� )"#-$6-"-�� 9%$)",#+"(-�� 2%;� )#� ;%'1&� &-#-$5)"-� ;2-"� +"&� ;2-#2-$� )#� ,2%'1&)"#-$6-"-�)"�,'(2�(+,-,A�2%;�)#�;%'1&�,#$'(#'$-�,'(2�+"�)"#-$6-"#)%"�-!7!�� ;2-#2-$� )#� ;%'1&� "--&� #%� %4-"� +� 9%$5+1� (+,-� 9)1-�� 2%;� 5'(2)"6-,#)7+#)%"�;%'1&�@-�$-?')$-&� #%� ,'44%$#� ,'(2� )"#-$6-"#)%"� )"� #2-(+,-�� -#(!� ��9� (%'$,-�� #2-� +",;-$,� #%� -+(2�%9� #2-,-� ?'-,#)%",� ;%'1&+99-(#�;2-#2-$�,'(2�+"�)"#-$6-"#)%"�4$%6-&�@-"-9)()+1�#%�#2-�(2)1&$-"+"&�5%#2-$,�%$�"%#!

�)"+11=�0��

�9$%5�#2-��#+#-8,�,#+"&4%)"#�#2-�4$%4%,+1�),�1)C-1=�#%�@-�+"%"D,#+$#-$� )9� )#� 5-+",� +"� )"($-+,-&� (+,-1%+&� 9%$� #2-,-� +1$-+&=+@,'$&1=� %6-$D@'$&-"-&� +7-"()-,!� � >2)1-� #2),� ),,'-� ),� '"&-")+@1=9'"&+5-"#+1��;-�"--&�"%#� +,,'5-� )#� ),� 4$%2)@)#)6-!� ��2-$-� ),� +� $-+14%,,)@)1)#=� #2+#�9$')#9'1�(%11+@%$+#)%"�;)#2�4$)6+#-�1)#)7+"#,��;2)(2�;+,-99-(#)6-� )"� )"($-+,)"7� #2-� 4$%#-(#)%"� %9� (2)1&$-"�� ;%'1&� +(#'+11=&-($-+,-� #2-� +7-"(=8,� (+,-1%+&�� @=� 5+C)"7� )#,� )"#-$6-"#)%",� 5%$--99-(#)6-!

0��� ��-149'1� )"#-$6-"#)%",� )"� 4$)6+#-� (+,-,� (%'1&� $-&'(-� #2-

+"&�4-$6+,)6-�(%"(-$",�+@%'#�$+()+1�+"&�(1+,,�@)+,� #2+#�2),#%$)(+11=�2+,�,2+4-&�(2)1&4$%#-(#)%"�4$+(#)(-!���$--&5+"�������"%#-�����+#��B*�"!B�!

0��! ��&%�"%#�4'$4%$#�#%�$+),-�+11�#2-�4$%@1-5,�;)#2�#2),�4$%4%,+1��@'#�%"1=�,-6-$+1%9� #2-� 5%,#� %@6)%',� +"&� 9'"&+5-"#+1� %"-,� 9%$� 4'$4%,-,� %9� #2-� : #2%'72#-E4-$)5-"#!<

0��! �%,#)"7�%9��+#$)()+�>--1��#%������D��V5+)1!+@+"-#!%$7�L +"!����0���M�L(%4=%"�9)1-�;)#2�+'#2%$M�L,#+#)"7�: #2-�#=4)(+1�����9%$5'1+,�9%$�+&&$-,,)"7�����2+6-� #2-5%#2-$�7-#�+�4$%#-(#)%"�%$&-$��2+6-�5%#2-$�1-+6-�2-$�+@',-$��7-#�,2-1#-$��-#(!�&%�"%#"-(-,,+$)1=� %99-$� ,+9-#=� 9%$� -)#2-$� #2-� 5%#2-$� %$� #2-� (2)1&$-"< M!� � "%#2-$� 1),#5-5@-$��9$%5�#2-�%"D�)%1-"(-�11)+"(- �%5-,#)(��)%1-"(-��"#-$6-"#)%"��$+)")"7�",#)#'#-�2+,�,#+#-&�

64

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �0�

"'5@-$� %9� (2)1&� +@',-� +"&� "-71-(#� (+,-,� )"� #2-� ('$$-"#� (+,-1%+&�)"(1'&)"7� (+,-,� %4-"-&� L)M� ;2-"� (2)1&$-"� ;$%"79'11=� 41+(-&� )"@+##-$-$,8�(+$-�+$-�+@',-&��L))M�+7+)",#�5%#2-$,�;2%�2+6-�@--"�'"+@1-#%�4$%#-(#� #2-)$�(2)1&$-"��%$�L)))M�+7+)",#�5%#2-$,�;2%�2+6-�@-(%5-+@',)6-� &'-� #%� #2-)$� %;"� 6)(#)5)3+#)%"� +"&� )"+@)1)#=� #%� %@#+)",'99)()-"#�,'44%$#�+"&�4$%#-(#)%"�9%$�#2-5,-16-,�+"&�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"!

0�0

��� *������ ����%���� ���1��

�"9%$#'"+#-1=��-6-"�;2-$-�F'&7-,�+"&�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�,=,#-5,�&%#2-�$)72#�#2)"7,�#%�4$%#-(#�(2)1&$-"�+"&�#2-)$�5%#2-$,��,%5-�%9�#2%,-9+5)1)-,�;)11�$-5+)"�+#�$),C!���'$�9%(',�%"�#2-�9+)1'$-,�%9�#2-�1-7+1�+"&,%()+1�,-$6)(-�,=,#-5�,2%'1&�"%#�@1)"&�',�#%�#2-�4+)"9'1�9+(#�#2+#�5+"=@+##-$-$,�� -6-"� +9#-$� +44$%4$)+#-� 1-7+1� )"#-$6-"#)%",�� ,'(2� +,� (%'$#D5+"&+#-&�(%'",-1)"7�%$�-6-"� )"(+$(-$+#)%"��&%�"%#�(2+"7-�-"%'72#%�5+C-�#2-)$�%$)7)"+1�6)(#)5,�,+9-!

0����"&�,)"(-�-6-"�#2%,-�@+##-$-$,

;2%� +$-� )"(+$(-$+#-&� ;)11� %$&)"+$)1=� @-� )"(+4+()#+#-&� 9%$� "%� 5%$-#2+"� +� 9-;� =-+$,�� #2-)$� +@)1)#=� #%� (%"#)"'-� +@',)"7� #2-)$� %$)7)"+16)(#)5,�$-5+)",�+�#2$-+#�#%�5+"=�9+5)1)-,!���2-�;%5-"�5%,#�1)C-1=�#%+(2)-6-� 1%"7D#-$5� ,+9-#=� +$-� #2%,-� ;2%,-� @+##-$-$,� ;-$-� 5-$-1=:%44%$#'"),#)(�< �%$�;2%�,2)9#�#2-)$�9%(',�#%�%#2-$�;%5-"!��/'#�9%$�#2-,)7")9)(+"#�4$%4%$#)%"�%9�;%5-"�;2%,-�@+##-$-$,� $-5+)"� : )"6-,#-&<)"� #2-5�%$� #2-)$� (2)1&$-"�� #2-� 4%#-"#)+1� 9%$� 9'#'$-� +@',-I +"&� #2-

�#8,� 5=� -,#)5+#)%"� #2+#� ;-� 2+6-� "%� )&-+� 2%;� ,'((-,,9'1� ;-� (+"� @-� )")"#-$6-")"7� ,'((-,,9'11=� ;)#2� @+##-$-$,� #%� 4$%#-(#� (2)1&$-"� +"&� $-5%6-� #2-@'$&-"�%9� @1+5-� +"&� $-,4%",)@)1)#=� 9%$�2),� @-2+6)%$� 9$%5� #2-� ,2%'1&-$,� %9+&'1#�6)(#)5,�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�!�!�!�H)"�%"-�(+,-K�#2-�,2)9#�)"�9%(',�%9�#2-(+,-� ;%$C-$� 9$%5� #2-� 6)(#)5� #%� #2-� 4-$4-#$+#%$� ,--5-&� #%� )54$%6-%'#(%5-,�!�!�!� #2-�;%$C-$�&-()&-&�#%�4-#)#)%"� #2-� F'6-")1-�(%'$#� #%�2+6-� #2-@+##-$-$� 5+"&+#-&� #%� )"4+#)-"#� ,'@,#+"(-� +@',-� #$-+#5-"#!� � �"(-� #2-@+##-$-$�;+,�%'#�%9�#2-�2%5-��#2-�5%#2-$�@-(+5-�5'(2�5%$-�9%$#2(%5)"7+@%'#�#2-�-E#-"#�%9�#2-�6)%1-"(-�+"&�@-7+"�#%�4+$#)()4+#-�)"�+�1%(+1�@+##-$-&;%5-"8,�,'44%$#�7$%'4!

�%,#)"7�%9��+6)&��+"&-1��#%������D��V5+)1!+@+"-#!%$7�L +"!�*��0���M�L%"�9)1-�;)#2+'#2%$M!

0�0! �%$-� #2+"� %"-� ,#'&=� 2+,� 9%'"&� #2+#� : %"(-� #2-�;%5-"� 1-+6-� #2-� @+##-$)"7$-1+#)%",2)4�� #2-� "'5@-$� %9� ;%5-"�;2%� (%"#)"'-� #%� -"7+7-� )"� +77$-,,)%"� #%;+$&#2-)$� (2)1&$-"� &$%4,!< � � �-%$7-� >!� �%1&-"� -#� +1!�� %���� ���� �������� ���� ������� ���� ������������ ������������O�����������������������������������������

������� ������� 0*B�� �0�D��� L�-%$7-� >!� �%1&-"� -#� +1!� -&,!�� �BB*M� L()#-&� )"� ����

�����G����N/��������������/������>�����������>�0�0�L0���M!

0��� ���� %+"�N%$3+��-���1�����#���������"��� ��&'������� � ����-�������� � ������ ������� ����� ����%�����������!������������!���-(! +"!�0�����+#�0���0��L+$7')"7#2+#�: H)K9�#2-�@-,#�$-,-+$(2�C--4,�9)"&)"7�#2+#�#2-,-�4$%7$+5,�&%�"%#�$-&'(-�5+"8,6)%1-"(-��)#�5+=�@-�#)5-�#%�$-#2)"C�;2+#�+((%'"#+@)1)#=�;-�"--&�#%�&-5+"&�9$%5�5-";2%�+@',-�#2-)$�)"#)5+#-�4+$#"-$,< M!���"�(%"#$+,#�#%�(%'",-1)"7��+"-(&%#+1�-6)&-"(-L)!-!�� #2-� -E4-$)-"(-� %9�5=,-19� +"&�5+"=� (%11-+7'-,M� ,'77-,#,� #2+#� #2-� 9+(#%$�5%,#$-1)+@1=�+,,%()+#-&�;)#2�,+9-#=�9%$�+�7)6-"�6)(#)5�),�#2-�@+##-$-$8,�5%6)"7�%"�#%�+�"-;6)(#)5!

65

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�00 ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

9-+$� #$)77-$-&� @=� #2-� 4%,,)@)1)#=� #2-$-%9I 5+=� $-5+)"� 9%$� #2-� 1%"7#-$5!

0�.

>2)1-� )"� #2-� 5+F%$)#=� %9� (+,-,� #2),� 4+)"9'1� $-+1)#=� 5+=� @-'"+6%)&+@1-�� #2-$-�+$-�+�,5+11�4-$(-"#+7-�%9�(+,-,�)"�;2)(2���;%'1&1)C-�#%�,--�+�,-(%"&�#2%'72#�-E4-$)5-"#�(%",)&-$-&!���"�#2%,-�(+,-,�)#� ),�"%#�-"%'72�#%�&%�;2+#� ),� #=4)(+11=�&%"-�� )!-!�� )54%,-� #-54%$+$=$-,#$+)"#,�%$�,+"(#)%",�)"�%"-�(+,-�+"&�#2-"�5%6-�%"�#%�#2-�"-E#!���%1%"7� +,� (2)1&$-"� L+"&� 5%#2-$,M� $-5+)"� +#� 7$+6-� $),C� -6-"� +9#-$: ,'((-,,9'1< � )"#-$6-"#)%",�� )!-!�� #2%,-� )"� ;2)(2� +6+)1+@1-� ()6)1� +"&($)5)"+1�$-,#$+)"#,�2+6-�@--"�)54%,-&��#2-��#+#-�2+,�+"�%@1)7+#)%"�#%#+C-�;2+#-6-$�,#-4,�+$-�1+;9'1�+"&�4%,,)@1-�#%�5)")5)3-�#2%,-�$),C,!

�"� #2-� 5%,#� -7$-7)%',� (+,-,�� #2-� 5%#2-$� +"&� #2-� �#+#-� ,2%'1&,-$6)%',1=� (%",)&-$� #-$5)"+#)"7� 4+$-"#+1� $)72#,!� � ,� ;)#2� #2-� 9)$,#4$%4%,+1�� #2),� 4$%4%,+1� -"6),)%",� ,'(2� +"� )"#-$6-"#)%"� #%� @-+44$%4$)+#-�%"1=�)9�)#�),�(2%,-"�@=�#2-�5%#2-$�+"&�#2-�(2)1&$-"�+9#-$;-11D(%'",-1-&�� (+$-9'1� (%",)&-$+#)%"� %9� #2-� 4%#-"#)+1� $),C,� +"&@-"-9)#,!��/-(+',-��+,�),�&),(',,-&�@-1%;��#2-�$),C,�%9�#+C)"7�#2),�+(#)%"5+=�@-�+,�7$-+#�+,�%$�7$-+#-$�#2+"�#2-�$),C,�%9�"%#�&%)"7�,%��5%#2-$,(%",)&-$)"7�4'$,')"7� )#� ,2%'1&� $-(-)6-� ,%42),#)(+#-&� $),C� +,,-,,5-"#+"&�,+9-#=�41+"")"7�@-9%$-�&-()&)"7�;2-#2-$�)#�),�#2-)$�@-,#�%4#)%"!

0��

�2-� ($)#)(+1� ?'-,#)%"�%9� (%'$,-� ),�� )"� ;2)(2� (+,-,� ,2%'1&� ,'(2� +"-E#$-5-� 5-+,'$-� @-� #+C-"J� � �� &%� "%#� )"#-"&� #%� 9'11=� +",;-$� #2+#?'-,#)%"� 2-$-�� %#2-$� #2+"� #%� ,+=� )#� ,2%'1&� @-� (%",)&-$-&� )"� #2%,-(+,-,� ;2-$-�5%,#� %@F-(#)6-� 4-%41-�;%'1&� +7$--� #2+#� #2-�5%#2-$� %$(2)1&$-"�(%"#)"'-� #%�@-�+#�-E#$-5-1=� ,-$)%',� $),C�%9� ,-6-$-�2+$5�%$&-+#2�+,� 1%"7�+,�#2-�+@',-$8,�+((-,,� #%� #2-�(2)1&$-"�(%"#)"'-,!� ��2-4'$4%,-�%9� #2),�4$%4%,+1� ),� "%#� #%�&-9)"-� #2),� (+#-7%$=�%9� (+,-,�� @'#5-$-1=�#%�4'#�%"�#2-�#+@1-�9%$�9'$#2-$�(%"6-$,+#)%"�#2),�'"&-$D'#)1)3-&#%%1�)"�#2-�-99%$#�#%�$-&'(-�6)%1-"(-�+7+)",#�;%5-"�+"&�(2)1&$-"!

0��

0�.! �"�%"-�(+,-�2+"&1-&�@=�,#'&-"#,�)"�5=�(1)")(��#2-�(1)-"#�,'((-,,9'11=�%@#+)"-&

+� 4$%#-(#)%"� %$&-$�� +"&� $-4-+#-&1=� ,%'72#� #%� 2+6-� )#� -"9%$(-&� ;2-"� #2-� @+##-$-$6)%1+#-&� )#�� ;)#2� %"1=� 1)5)#-&� ,'((-,,!� � �-6-$+1� =-+$,� 1+#-$�� +1#2%'72� ,2-� 2+,� "%%"7%)"7� (%"#+(#� ;)#2� 2-$� (2)1&8,� 9+#2-$�� ,2-� ),� ,#)11� -E4-$)-"()"7� ,%5-� 2+$+,,5-"#9$%5�#2-�+@',-$�)"�(%""-(#)%"�;)#2�#2-)$�(2)1&!

0��! �#� (%'1&� @-� +$7'-&� #2+#� ',)"7� #-$5)"+#)%"� %9� 4+$-"#+1� $)72#,� )"� #2),� ;+=� ),+,C)"7� #2-�()6)1� 1+;� #%�&%� #2-�;%$C�%9� #2-�($)5)"+1� 1+;!� ��2+#� ),�� )9� ,%5-%"-� ),� #2+#&+"7-$%',��#2-=�: ,2%'1&< �4$-,'5+@1=�@-�@-2)"&�@+$,!���"�9+(#��#2-$-�+$-�+11�C)"&,�%9$-+,%",��,%5-�6+1)&�+"&�,%5-�"%#��;2=�,'(2�5-"�+$-�%"1=�$+$-1=�)"(+$(-$+#-&�9%$�+"=1-"7#2�%9�#)5-!���"�+"=�(+,-��;2+#�,--5,�(-$#+)"�),�#2+#�;-�(+"�-E4-(#�#2),� #%�@-�#2-$-+1)#=� 9%$� #2-� 9%$-,--+@1-� 9'#'$-!� � "&� ;2)1-� #2-� ($)5)"+1� 1+;� $-5-&=� 5+=� @-4$-9-$+@1-�+,�5%$-�&)$-(#1=�$-,4%",)6-�#%�#2-�: ($)5-�< �$-(#)9=)"7�#2-�()6)1�1+;�,#+#',�%94+$-"#+1�$-1+#)%",2)4,��@+,-&�%"�+�4+$-"#8,�'"+((-4#+@1-�$),C�#%�#2-�(2)1&$-"��),�+1,%+44$%4$)+#-!

0��! ��+5�"%#�#%�9)$,#�#%�,'77-,#�#2),!������5=��+&&)E��������!�� ��#���)���������� ��&���� ���� ��� ���!�����������"�������*������ � � ����*������ �������%���� ���1�� �*.� ��!� �!� ���!� ����� ��*� L�BB�MA� �)11)+"� >+"�� %���� � =������� %���� #� "��� ���� �

66

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �0�

�#�5+=�@-�+,C-&�;2+#�&)99-$-"(-�#-$5)"+#)%"�%9�4+$-"#+1�$)72#,�;)115+C-�� -,4-()+11=�;)#2� $-,4-(#� #%� -E#$-5-1=� &+"7-$%',�@+##-$-$,�;2%+$-�"%#�&-#-$$-&�@=�($)5)"+1� ,+"(#)%",!� ��2-�+",;-$� ),� #2+#��;2)1-� )#;)11�"%#�2-14�)"�+11�(+,-,��#2-$-�),�$-+,%"�#%�@-1)-6-�#2+#�#-$5)"+#)%"�%94+$-"#+1� $)72#,� L:���<M� ;)11�� )"� ,%5-� )",#+"(-,�� ,1%;� %$� -"&� +@+##-$-$8,� 2+$+,,5-"#� +"&� +@',-� %9� 2),� 6)(#)5� +"&� #2-)$� (2)1&$-"!�2),� (%"(1',)%"� 91%;,� 9$%5� +"� )"D&-4#2� '"&-$,#+"&)"7� %9� #2-4,=(2%1%7)(+1�5%#)6+#)%",�%9� @+##-$-$,!� � /-(+',-�@+##-$)"7� ),� +#� (%$-#=4)(+11=� +@%'#� #2-� @+##-$-$,� 6)-;� %9� 2),� : $)72#,�< � 2),� 5%$+1,'4-$)%$)#=��+"&�2),�"--&�#%�4$%6-�2),�(2)1&$-"8,�5%#2-$�:;$%"7�<

�0��

)"� (-$#+)"� (+,-,�� #2-����� +(#)%"�;%'1&� 4%;-$9'11=� (2+11-"7-� ,'(2� +@+##-$-$8,�6)-;�%9�2),�4$-$%7+#)6-,�+"&�2),�$)72#�#%�4%,,-,,�+"&�(%"#$%12),� (2)1&$-"!� � �",%9+$� +,� 5'(2� 5+1-� +@',-� ),� 9'-1-&� @=� +� ,-",-� %9-"#)#1-5-"#�+"&�:4$%4-$#=< �$)72#,�%6-$�(2)1&$-"�+"&�5%#2-$,�

0�*����

+(#)%",U;2)(2� ,-"&� +� (1-+$� 5-,,+7-� #2+#� @+##-$-$,� 2+6-� 1%,#� #2-)$: $)72#,< �#%�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"U5)72#�+(#'+11=�)54+(#�5+"=�+@',-$,�5%$-4%;-$9'11=�#2+"�#2-�5%$-�(%55%"�()6)1�%$�($)5)"+1�F',#)(-�$-,#$+)")"7%$&-$,�%$�($)5)"+1�+&F'&)(+#)%",!������+(#)%",�;%'1&�+1,%�5-+"�#2+##2%,-� +@',-$,� ;2%�� 9%$� ;2+#-6-$� $-+,%",�� 2+6-� "%#� @--"� +&-?'+#-1=$-,#$+)"-&� %$� $-9%$5-&� @=� ()6)1� %$� ($)5)"+1� F',#)(-� )"#-$6-"#)%",�;%'1&� "%� 1%"7-$� @-� 1-7)#)5)3-&� )"� #2-)$� (1+)5,� %9� +((-,,� #%� #2-(2)1&$-"�� +"&� ;%'1&� "%� 1%"7-$� @-� -54%;-$-&� @=� #2-� �#+#-8,-"&%$,-5-"#�L)"�#2-�9%$5�%9�1-7+1�$-(%7")#)%"�%9�2),�4+$-"#+1�$)72#,M%9�#2+#�+((-,,!��#�#2-�1-+,#������;%'1&�-1)5)"+#-�#2-��#+#-�+"&�1-7+1,=,#-58,�)"(1)"+#)%"�#%�+;+$&�#2-,-�@+##-$-$,�+((-,,�#%�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"!

�2),� 4$%4%,+1� ),� 1-,,� $+&)(+1� #2+"� #2-� 9)$,#� %"-� L)"#-$6-"#)%"� )"4$)6+#-� 1)#)7+#)%"M�� )"� #2+#� )#� &%-,� "%#� $-?')$-� #2-� �#+#-� #%� ($-+#-� +(%541-#-1=�"-;�C)"&�%9�1-7+1�+(#)%"!���%;-6-$��)#�$-5+)",�;-11�@-=%"&('$$-"#� 4$+(#)(-�� @%#2� @-(+',-� ('$$-"#� ���� ,#+#'#-,� &%� "%#� -E#-"&#2),� 9+$�

0�B� +"&�@-(+',-� )#� )"6)#-,� ,#+#-� +7-"()-,� #%� )"#-$6-"-� )"� (+,-,

%����� ����������� ��������/!��!����!�����L�BBBM!

0��� ���� �+$1+� �),2-$� -#� +1!�� *�� "�� ���� ��� �� ������ ���� �� 1���� ��� +���� ���� �� ��� ���!��������"����.���!�!�!��!����!��0�����0�0���0���D���L�BB�M�L&-,($)@)"7�+"+@',)6-�$-1+#)%",2)4�+,�: #2-�$'1-$�+"&�#2-�$'1-&< �)"�;2)(2�: @+##-$-$,�!�!�!�(%",),#-"#1=@1+5H-K�;%5-"�9%$�-6-$=#2)"7�#2+#�7%-,�+;$=�)"�#2-)$�1)6-,�< �+"&�,+=�#2)"7,�1)C-�: R�857%""+�#-+(2�=%'�+�1-,,%"A�$+),-�=%'�$)72#8< M!

0�*� �����%%&5+$C�������"%#-��.��+#�0�0D��!

0�B! �('$,%$=� $-6)-;�%9� #-$5)"+#)%"�%9�4+$-"#+1� $)72#,� ,#+#'#-,� +"&� #2-� $-1-6+"#1-7+1�1)#-$+#'$-�)"&)(+#-,�#2+#�#2),�4$%4%,+1�),�)"�9+(#�: %'#�%9�#2-�@%E!< ��,�$-(-"#1=�+,�BB*��"%�,#+#-�#-$5)"+#)%"�,#+#'#-�4$%6)&-&� #2+#�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+7+)",#�+�4+$-"#(%",#)#'#-,�4-$�,-�4+$-"#+1�'"9)#"-,,!� ��-,1)-� %2",%"��"��� ���� ��"��������00��!�G�������!� ���!� 0���� 0*�� L�BB*M!� � �%$-� +5+3)"71=�� %"1=� #2$--� ,#+#-,� 4$%6)&-&� 9%$#-$5)"+#)%"�@+,-&�'4%"�5'$&-$�%9�%"-�4+$-"#�@=�#2-�%#2-$!���+&&)E�������"%#-�0�B�+#���*!���%;-6-$��,%5-�(%'$#,�2+6-�#-$5)"+#-&�4+$-"#+1�$)72#,�9%$�#2-�5'$&-$�%9�#2-%#2-$� 4+$-"#!� � ���,� ������ /$%;"� 6!��-48#� %9��'5+"��-,%'$(-,�� 0��� �!�!0&� ���� L�+!44!��#!��B*�MA��"�$-�@&'11+2��.0��!�!0&�B���L�11!��B*�MA� �"�$-�&%4#)%"�%9�!�!�

67

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�0. ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

;2)(2� 2+6-� "%#� 4$-6)%',1=� (%5-� )"#%� #2-� (2)1&� 4$%#-(#)%"� ,=,#-5!00�

�2),� #=4-� %9� : 9+5)1=� 4$%#-(#)%"< � ),�� 2%;-6-$�� +� 1%7)(+1� -E#-",)%"� %9#2-��$--"�/%%C8,�+&5%")#)%",��;2)(2�)"(1'&-��5%,#�)54%$#+"#1=��#2-$-(%55-"&+#)%"� #%�C--4�(2)1&$-"�;)#2� #2-)$�"%"D%99-"&)"7�4+$-"#�+"&� #%� +,,),#� @+##-$-&� 5%#2-$,� )"� 5)")5)3)"7� #2-� $),C,� 9$%5� #2-@+##-$-$,!

00����"&--&��#2-��$--"�/%%C�+(C"%;1-&7-,�#2+#�����5+=�@-

+44$%4$)+#-�)"�,%5-�)",#+"(-,!000

�2-$-� +$-� %9� (%'$,-� +1,%� ,-$)%',� (%"(-$",� +##+(2-&� #%� #2),4$%4%,+1I 4-$2+4,�-6-"�5%$-� ,-$)%',� #2+"� #2%,-� )&-"#)9)-&� 9%$� #2-9)$,#!� ��%,#�%@6)%',1=� ),� #2-�?'-,#)%"�%9�;2-#2-$�+�����+(#)%"�;%'1&@+(C9)$-� +"&�4'#�;%5-"� +"&� (2)1&$-"� +#� 7$-+#-$� $),C�� @=� 4$%6%C)"7#2-� +@',-$� #%� C)11� #2-5!� � �)"(-� ,%5-� 5-"� &%� #2),� ;2-"� :%"1=<&-4$)6-&�%9�(',#%&=�

00��%$�5-$-1=�+9#-$�@-)"7� #+C-"� #%� (%'$#�@=� #2-)$

6)(#)5,��;-�(+"�+,,'5-�#2+#�5%$-�5+=�&%�,%�+9#-$�#2-)$�4+$-"#+1�$)72#,+$-� #-$5)"+#-&!� � �=� $-,4%",-� ),� #2+#�� ;2)1-� #2),� $),C� ),� ,-$)%',� +"&&),#'$@)"7��)#�(+""%#�&)(#+#-�1-7+1�4%1)(=��+"=�5%$-�#2+"�#2-�$),C�#2+#1%,)"7�(',#%&=�;)11�#$)77-$�2%5)()&-�,2%'1&�&)(#+#-�(',#%&=�+;+$&,��%$#2-� $),C� #2+#� 4$%,-('#)"7� 7+"7� 5-5@-$,� ;)11� #$)77-$� 2%5)()&-,� %9: ,")#(2-,< �,2%'1&�4$-(1'&-�,'(2�4$%,-('#)%",!

�2-� ,-(%"&�4%;-$9'1�(%"(-$"�+,,%()+#-&�;)#2� #2),�4$%4%,+1� ),� #2-4%,,)@)1)#=� %9� )#,� @+(C9)$)"7� )"� +� &)99-$-"#� 5+""-$�� )!-!�� ;2-"� ,#+#-+7-"()-,� ,#+$#� #%� #-$5)"+#-� #2-� 4+$-"#+1� $)72#,� %9� ;%5-"�;2%� 2+6-9%'72#�@+(C�%$�',-&�,-19D&-9-",-�+7+)",#�+@',-$,�L+"&�4$-,'5+@1=�,#)11@--"� (%"6)(#-&� %9� 2%5)()&-M!� � �'(2� ���,� 5+=� 2+6-� +1$-+&=%(('$$-&!

00.� � /'#� +7+)"�� �� ;%'1&� 4%)"#� #%� 5=� %$)7)"+1� 4$-&)(+#-� 9%$

@%#2� #2%'72#� -E4-$)5-"#,�� "-)#2-$� (%'1&� @-� ,-$)%',1=� (%",)&-$-&'"1-,,� #2-�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�+7-"(=�;)#2�;2)(2�;-�;-$-�;%$C)"7�;+,7-"')"-1=� -"1)72#-"-&� +@%'#� &%5-,#)(� 6)%1-"(-�� 2)72D9'"(#)%")"7+"&�#$',#;%$#2=!��>)#2�#2),�4$-&)(+#-��)#�,--5,�41+',)@1-�#2+#�#2-�$),C,%9�#2-�:;$%"7< �4+$-"#,�2+6)"7�#2-)$�$)72#,�#-$5)"+#-&�;%'1&�@-�1-,,#2+"� #2-� $),C,� ;-� ('$$-"#1=� 9+(-� ;2-"� ;-� +11%;� -E#$-5-1=� 6)%1-"#�4%,,-,,)6-�+"&�6)"&)(#)6-�5-"�(%"#)"'-&�$)72#,�#%�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"!

B*0��!0&�B*�� L�+"!��#!�44!��BBBM!� ��%$-� ,'$4$),)"71=��2%;-6-$�� ,%5-� (%'$#,�2+6-+1,%�$-9',-&�#%�&%�,%��&-,4)#-�4-#)#)%",�@=�#2-�,#+#-�(2)1&�4$%#-(#)%"�+7-"(=!������(+,-,()#-&������"%#-���B!

00�! �2-�,+5-�?'-,#)%",�$+),-&�9%$��$%4%,+1���+@%'#�2%;�(+,-,�;%'1&�@-�,-1-(#-&+"&�)"6-,#)7+#)%",�4-$9%$5-&�;%'1&�+441=�-?'+11=�2-$-!

00�� �����$--"�/%%C�������"%#-�����+#��B���.����!

000� ����+#�0�!

00�� ���� �$+$=�� ����� "%#-� B�� L&-,($)@)"7� ,-6-$+1� )",#+"(-,� %9� 5-"� ;2%� C)11-&#2-5,-16-,�+"& %$�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"�+9#-$�1%,)"7�)"�(%'$#M!

00.! �-$5)"+#)%",� %9� 5%#2-$,8� 4+$-"#+1� $)72#,� 2+,� +1$-+&=� @--"� &),#'$@)"71=(%55%"� 9%$� #2-� 1-,,-$� ;$%"7� %9� +11-7-&� : 9+)1'$-� #%� 4$%#-(#< � (2)1&$-"� 9$%5� #2-@+##-$-$!�����������������"%,�������"%#-��.!

68

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �0�

��������

�2-,-� ,'77-,#)%",� 9%$� 4%#-"#)+1� �#+#-� )"#-$6-"#)%"� )"� 4$)6+#-1)#)7+#)%"�,--C�#%�)5+7)"-�+�;+=�#%�(%'"#-$� #2-�-"#$-"(2-&�+##)#'&-,%9�(%'$#,� #2+#�4$-6-"#� #2-5�9$%5�#+C)"7�,-$)%',1=�@+##-$-&�5%#2-$,8(1+)5,�� +"&� #2+#� 1-+&� #2-5� $-4-+#-&1=� +"&� &),#'$@)"71=� #%� 41+(-(2)1&$-"� L+"&� ;%5-"M� +#� '""-(-,,+$=� $),C!� � 1#2%'72� )#� ),� '"1)C-1=#2+#� ,'(2�4$%4%,+1,�;)11� @-� +((-4#-&�-+,)1=�� %$� #2+#� #2-=� +$-�;)#2%'#$),C� #%� #2%,-� �� ,--C� #%� 2-14�� #2-=�� 1)C-� #2-� �$--"� /%%C� �")#)+#)6-�$-4$-,-"#� +� ,)"(-$-� +##-54#� #%� #2)"C� :%'#� %9� #2-� @%E!< � � >2)1-(%7")3+"#�%9�,%5-�%9�#2-�%@6)%',�4%#-"#)+1�4)#9+11,�)"�#2-,-�4$%4%,+1,���#+C-�,-$)%',1=�#2-�4$-5),-�%9�#2-��$--"�/%%C��#2+#�4-%41-�%9�7%%&;)11�� @%#2� )"� ,#+#-� +7-"()-,� +"&� 4$)6+#-� +&6%(+(=� $%1-,�� (+"� ;%$C#%7-#2-$� #%� @-##-$� 4$%#-(#� (2)1&$-"� L+"&� @+##-$-&� 5%#2-$,M�� @=)"($-+,)"7� '"&-$,#+"&)"7� %9� +"&� -54+#2=� 9%$� +&'1#� 6)(#)5,� %9@+##-$)"7!�� �9��+,� #2-��$--"�/%%C�&%-,��;-�7-"')"-1=� ,--C� #%�$-9%$5+"&� )54$%6-� #2-� �#+#-8,� $-,4%",-� #%� (2)1&� 5+1#$-+#5-"#� )"� #2-(%"#-E#�%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-��;-�,2%'1&�+#�1-+,#�(%",)&-$�@$)"7)"7�#2-4%;-$�%9� #2-� �#+#-� +99)$5+#)6-1=� #%� @-+$� )"� ,'44%$#� %9�5%#2-$,� ;2%,--C�#%�4$%#-(#�#2-)$�(2)1&$-"�)"�%#2-$�1-7+1�9%$+!���"�%#2-$�;%$&,��)9�)#),�4$%#-(#)%"�%9�(2)1&$-"�#2+#�#2-��#+#-�+"&�;-�+$-�,--C)"7��#2-��#+#-+"&�;-�5',#� $-(%7")3-�+"&�+&&$-,,� #2-�5'1#)41-� 9%$+� )"�;2)(2� #2+#,+9-#=�L%$�1+(C�#2-$-%9M�5+=�@-�&-#-$5)"-&!

69

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�0� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

�����O�00�

�����������������������������������>������

���������������������������������8�����������������

�����00�

����� �������

��� ��������������� ���E��+$#-��+""��*����%!�0&�����L1+!

0���M�L,%1-�(',#%&=�#%�9+#2-$M!

! �",'99)()-"#�-6)&-"(-�%9�+@',-

! �6)&-"(-�#2+#�#2-=�9$-?'-"#1=+@',-&�+1(%2%1

������������������������

����� ���-"#�6!��$--"�������%!�0&�.�L1+!�)6!�44!��BB�M�L,%1-�(',#%&=�#%�#2-9+#2-$��,'@F-(#�#%�#2-�5%#2-$8,6),)#+#)%"M!

! �2-�9+#2-$�@-7+"�(%'",-1)"7

L+9#-$�(2%C)"7�2),�;)9-�$-,'1#)"7

)"�2-$�2%,4)#+1)3+#)%"�+"&�2),

+$$-,#M!

! �2-�4,=(2%1%7),#�#-,#)9)-&�#2+#

#2-�9+#2-$8,�6)%1-"(-�;+,�'"1)C-1=

#%�$-('$!

! �%#2-$�$-9',-&�(%'",-1)"7��+"&

#2-$+4),#�#-,#)9)-&�#2+#�;)#2%'#

#$-+#5-"#��4$%@1-5,�;%'1&

&-#-$)%$+#-!

����� ����������� ��� ���������������������>+$&� 6!�>+$&�� �.0� �%!� 0&� 0��� L�1!

�)$!� �#!� �BB�M� L4$)5+$=� $-,)&-"#)+1

(',#%&=M!

! �%#2-$�;+,�)"�+�1-,@)+"$-1+#)%",2)4A�(2)1&�-E2)@)#-&)"+44$%4$)+#-�,-E'+1�,#+#-5-"#,+"&�@-2+6)%$�@-1)-6-&�#%�@-�+$-,'1#�%9�)"+44$%4$)+#-�-E4%,'$-#%�,-E'+1�(%"&'(#!

! 1#2%'72�#2-�9+#2-$�;+,(%"6)(#-&�%9�5'$&-$)"7�2),�9)$,#;)9-��2-�(1+)5-&�)#�;+,�#2-�$-,'1#%9�: ,#'4)&)#=��F-+1%',=��+"&+"7-$!< ���2-�9+#2-$�;+,�)"�+�"-;5+$$)+7-�+"&�2+&�"%�"-;($)5)"+1�%99-",-,�,)"(-�2),$-1-+,-�9$%5�4$),%"!

00�! �2-�9%11%;)"7�(2+$#�(%"#+)",�+�,+541-��@'#�"%#�+�(%54$-2-",)6-�%6-$6)-;��%9

�")#-&��#+#-,�(+,-,�(%"(-$")"7�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�+"&�(',#%&=!

00�! �2-�%"-�-E(-4#)%"� ),��)")',� 6!��)")',� L!�!M�� )"�;2)(2� #2-� +44-11+#-� (%'$#��������+"�+;+$&�%9�(',#%&=�#%�#2-��� ��!

70

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �0�

���������������������������������������+"-=�6!�>$-"���00��%!�0&��.�L�+!�#!�44!��BB*M�LF%)"#�(',#%&=M!

! �%&)9)(+#)%"�%9�(',#%&=I #$)+1

(%'$#�-E(1'&-&�-6)&-"(-�%9

2),#%$=�%9�9+5)1=�6)%1-"(-

@-(+',-�)#�%(('$$-&�4$)%$�#%�#2-

,#)4'1+#-&�(',#%&=�(%",-"#

&-($--!

! �2-�$-,'1#)"7�$-(%$&�&)&�"%#

,'44%$#�#2-�+11-7+#)%"�%9

6)%1-"(-!

! �2-�(%'$#�9%'"&�#2-�5%#2-$8,

+11-7+#)%",�: ,',4-(#!<

����� ��� �������� �����������������������)55%",� 6!� �)55%",�� �.B� �%!� 0&

�BB� L�+!� �#!� 44!� �BB�M� L9+#2-$

&-,)7"+#-&� 4$)5+$=� &%5)()1)+$=

4+$-"#M!

! �"-�)",#+"(-�%9�6)%1-"(-�+&5)##-&�@=�#2-�9+#2-$�@'#(1+)5-&�4$%6%C-&�@=�#2-5%#2-$8,�+&'1#-$%',�+99+)$��&)&"%#�$),-�#%�#2-�1-6-1�%9�+�:2),#%$=%9�4-$4-#$+#)"7�9+5)1=�6)%1-"(-<+,�$-?')$-&�@=�,#+#'#-�#%�#$)77-$$-@'##+@1-�4$-,'54#)%"!

�������� ����� ����������������"� $-� �',#%&=� %9� N)+�� ���� !�!0&

..B� L�+,,!� 44!� �#!� 0���M� L,%1-

1-7+1�+"&�42=,)(+1�(',#%&=M!

! �2-�9+#2-$8,�4+,#�(%"&'(#�+"&($)5)"+1�2),#%$=�7+6-�#2-�(%'$#:4+',-< �@'#�#2-�(%'$#�&)&�"%#9)"&��+"&�#2-�5%#2-$�&)&�"%#+$7'-��#2+#�#2-�9+#2-$8,�(%"&'(#(%",#)#'#-&�+�:4+##-$"< �%$: ,-$)%',�)"()&-"#�%9�+@',-< �+,$-?')$-&�@=�,#+#'#-!

! �2-�5%#2-$�;+,�1)6)"7�)"�4'@1)(2%',)"7��+"&�2+&�@--"�+$$-,#-&9%$�4%,,-,,)%"�%9�&$'7,!

! �2-�9+#2-$�-"(%'$+7-&�42=,)(+1+"&�5-"#+1�,#)5'1+#)%"�%9�#2-(2)1&!

! �2-�5%#2-$�9+)1-&�#%�,-#+&-?'+#-�@%'"&+$)-,!

! �2-�9+#2-$�4+$#)()4+#-&�)"#2-$+4=�9%$�(%"#$%11)"7�2),+"7-$!

����� ��� �������� �������������+"")"7� 6!�>)-(C%;,C)��%!��.DB*D

���*�� �BBB� >�� ��*��B� L�)""!� �#!

44!� �+$!� B�� �BBBM� L42=,)(+1

(',#%&=�#%�9+#2-$M!

! �9)"&)"7�%9�&%5-,#)(�+@',-�;+,"%#�5+&-!

! �2-�9+#2-$�;+,�;)11)"7�+"&(+4+@1-�%9�: #%")"7�&%;"�2),+"7-$�+"&�"-7+#)6)#=�#%;+$&�H#2-5%#2-$��;2-$-+,�#2-�5%#2-$K,--5H-&K�4$-%(('4)-&�;)#2

71

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

�0* ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

5+C)"7�$-,4%"&-"#�%'#�#%�@-�+6)11+)"!<

! �2-�9+#2-$�;+,�(%59%$#+@1-�;)#22),�,%"�+"&�(+4+@1-�%9,#$-"7#2-")"7�#2-�@%"&�;)#25%$-�(%"#+(#!

����� ��� �������� �����������������������������+5)1#%"� 6!��+5)1#%"�� **�� �!>!0&

���� L�%!� 44!� �BB.M� L42=,)(+1

(',#%&=�#%�9+#2-$�-6-$=�;--C-"&M!

�+"#�6!��+"#��B0���!>!0&��0��L�%!

�#!�44!��BB�M� LF%)"#� 1-7+1� (',#%&=

;)#2� #2-� 9+#2-$� +,� 4$)5+$=

$-,)&-"#)+1�(',#%&)+"M!

�%'(2� 6!� �%'(2�� B�*� �!>!0&� ���

L�%!� �#!� 44!� �BB*M� L42=,)(+1

(',#%&=�#%�#2-�9+#2-$M!

! �%'$#�&)&�"%#�@-1)-6-�#2+#�#;%)"()&-"#,�%9�6)%1-"(-�:%(('$$)"7�=-+$,�+4+$#�&'$)"7�+0�D=-+$�5+$$)+7-�!�!�!�(%",#)#'#-&+�R4+##-$"�%9�&%5-,#)(6)%1-"(-!8<

! :�',@+"&�;+,�1-+$")"7�#%-E-$(),-�5%$-�,-19�(%"#$%1!<

! �)%1-"(-�;+,�"%#�&)$-(#-&�+#�#2-(2)1&$-"!

! �2-�2',@+"&�;+,�+�7%%&2%5-5+C-$�+"&�@-##-$�+;+$-�%9#2-�&+)1=�"--&,�%9�(2)1&$-"!

! �2-�;)9-�;+,�1+(C)"7�)"�(2)1&(+$-�,C)11,I &)&�"%#�+1;+=,�@+#2-#2-5��@$',2�#2-)$�#--#2��%$�9--&#2-5�+44$%4$)+#-�9%%&,!

! �)%1-"(-�;+,�"%#�&)$-(#-&#%;+$&,�(2)1&$-"!

! �2-�(2)1&8,�$-1+#)%",2)4�;)#24+#-$"+1�7$+"&5%#2-$�;2%�;+,#2-�4$)5+$=�(+$-#+C-$�;-)72-&)"�9+6%$�%9�7$+"#)"7�(',#%&=�#%#2-�9+#2-$!

��� �� ����� ��� ������!�����%E�6!��%E������!>!0&�����L!�!

0���M�L(',#%&=�#%�#2-�9+#2-$M!

�)")',� 6!� �)")',�� ��.� !>!0&� ���

L!�!� �BB�M� L9+#2-$� +;+$&-&

(',#%&=M�L������� ������ ��������� ����

���� .������������ ���� ���� ��M!

! �%,#�%9�#2-�5%#2-$8,�+11-7+#)%",%9�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-�;-$-�"%#($-&)@1-��+"&�#2%,-�#2+#�;-$-L)"(1'&)"7�2)##)"7�+"&�7$+@@)"7#2+#�1-9#�5+$C,�+"&�@$'),-,M�&)&"%#�?'+1)9=�+,�&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-!

! �;%�)",#+"(-,�%9�42=,)(+1�9%$(-#%;+$&�#2-�(2)1&�"%#�(%",)&-$-&&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-A�)",#+"(-,;-$-�9+$�+4+$#�)"�#)5-��+"&(%'1&�2+6-�@--"�(%",)&-$-&$-+,%"+@1-�9%$(-�#%�&),()41)"-(2)1&!

72

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� �0B

/$%;"� 6!� /$%;"�� ���� !>!0&� *�B

L!�!� �BBBM� L(',#%&=� #%� #2-

9+#2-$M!

! /%#2�4+$#)-,�2+&�(%55)##-&6)%1-"(-�+7+)",#�%"-�+"%#2-$A"%"-�%9�#2-�)"()&-"#,�;-$-,-6-$-�-"%'72�#%�#$)77-$�#2-4$-,'54#)%"!

����� ��� �������� ��"!���� ��/$%;"� 6!� /$%;"�� *��� �!0&� .��

L�C1+!� �#!� 44!� �BB�M� L(',#%&=� %9

9+#2-$M!

! �)%1-"# +77$-,,)6-�@-2+6)%$�&)&"%#�+5%'"#�#%�:%"7%)"7&%5-,#)(�6)%1-"(-!<

! �6)&-"(-�#2+#�#2-�5%#2-$�2+&4$%4%,)#)%"-&�+#�1-+,#�#;%�5-"L%#2-$�#2+"�2-$�2',@+"&M&'$)"7�#2-�5+$$)+7-!

73

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003

����������� � �� �����������

��� ����������������������������G������>� H�%1!����0

�����������������������������������8���������>���

���������00�

����� �������������������� +(C,%"�6!� +(C,%"����B��%!�0&�.�

L1+!��)6!�44!��BB�M!

�������������� ������ �"%(C�6!��"%(C���0��!0&�0��

L�%""!��BB�M�L�����������������

�� ���� ���� ��M!

�������������������������������

�%$&�6!��%$&�������%!�0&��B��L�1+!

�),#!��#!�44!��BB�M!

������������������������ �-;),�6!��-;),�������%!�0&�*���L�+!

�#!�44!�0���M!

�)(C,�6!��)(C,�������%!�0&��0���L�+!

�#!�44!��BBBM!

�)(2-11)�6!��)(2-11)�������%!�0&���.0

L�+!��#!�44!��BB�M!

���������������� �#�����������

�"�$-��+'72"����.�!�!0&�.�.�L�+,,!

�BB�M!

������������������������� +3+$�6!�+3+$������!>!0&��0*

L�)""!��#!�44!��BB�M!

��� ���������� ����� �+=-,�6!��+11+(2-$��B�0��!0&����*

L-6!��BBBM!

�',,%�6!��+$&"-$��B����!0&�B*�L-;!

�BB*M!

�-,1-=�6!��-,1-=��B.���!0&�.���L-6!

�BB�M!

�(�-$5%##�6!��(�-$5%##��B.���!0&

����L-6!��BB�M!

�$�%��!������������������� �$+##�6!�>%%&��0���!�!0&��.��L!�!

44!��)6!��BB.M!

��� ���������� ������!���

�+,4$%;)(3�6!��+,4$%;)(3�����

!>!0&�B0��L!�!��BB*M!

N'7-$�6!�N'7-$������!>!0&�*�.

L!�!��BB�M!

"&-$,%"�6!��-",$'&���.*�!>!0&

.���L!�!��BB�M!

�"72�6!� -",-"���.��!>!0&�B00

00�! �2-�%"-�-E(-4#)%"�),��"%(C�6!��"%(C�L�%""!M��)"�;2)(2�#2-�+44-11+#-�(%'$#

������+"�+;+$&�%9�(',#%&=�#%�#2-�5%#2-$!

74

Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, Vol. 11, Iss. 2 [2003], Art. 18

http://digitalcommons.wcl.american.edu/jgspl/vol11/iss2/18

����������� � �� �����������

0���K ���������� ��������������� ���

L!�!��BB�M!

�$+9#�6!��$+9#����.�!>!0&�����L!�!

�BB�M!

�;+"�6!��;+"���.��!>!0&���B

L!�!��BB�M!

/$'"-$�6!�/$'"-$����.�!>!0&�*0�

L!�!��BB�M!

�-(C�6!��--&���0B�!>!0&�����L!�!

�BB�M!

�-1@)"7�6!��-1@)"7����0�!>!0&����

L!�!��BB�M!

�$+"C�6!��$+"C���0B�!>!0&�*..

L!�!��BB�M!

"!���� ����������������� �5)#2�6!��5)#2��B����!0&�0.�L�C1+!

�)6!�44!��BB*M!

75

Meier: Domestic Violence, Child Custody, and Child Protection: Understan

Published by Digital Commons @ American University Washington College of Law, 2003