2020 IESF Ordinary

General Meeting Minutes

Date 2020. 12. 21

Venue Zoom (Online)

2020 IESF General Meeting

■ Outline

⮚ Date: 2020. 12. 21. (Mon) 17:00 ~ 2020. 12. 22. (Tue) 02:00 (GMT+9)

⮚ Venue: Zoom (Online)

Quorum: 53 out of 63 Full Members in good standing are present and vote. The Ordinary General

Meeting is quorate.

■ Participation List

⮚ Full Members in good standing (voting participants):

No Nation Member organization Represented by

1 Australia Australian Esports Association Darren Kwan*,

Jason Kwan

2 Austria eSports Association Austria

Manuel Haselberger*,

Alexander Krainz,

Stefan Baloh

3 Azerbaijan Azerbaijan Esports Federation Ramil Aliyev

4 Bahamas Bahamas Esports Federation Michael Armogan

5 Belgium Belgian Esports Federation Samy Bessi

6 Brazil Brazilian Confederation of

Electronic Sports Daniel Cossi

7 Brunei Darussalam Esports Association of Brunei Hawaii Yee

8 Chinese Taipei Chinese Taipei Esports Association Grace Chen

9 Czech Republic Czech Esports Association Lukáš Pleskot

10 Finland Finnish Esports Federation Joonas Kapiainen*,

Otto Takala

11 Georgia Georgia Computer Sports

Federation David Chogovadze

12 India Electronic Sports Federation of

India

Lokesh Suji*,

Yugal Kishore Sharma

13 Indonesia Indonesia Esports Association Eddy Lim

14 Israel Israeli Esports Association Gil Ronen

15 Italy Italian Federation of Electronic

Disciplines

Giulio Cecinelli*,

Jacopo Ierussi,

Igor Lanzoni

16 Jamaica Jamaica Esports Initiative Andrew W Johnson*,

Gregory Moore

17 Jordan Jordan Esports Federation Nasser Ayman Majali*,

H.R.H. Prince Omar Bin Faisal

18 Kuwait Kuwait Esports Club Faisal E Abul*,

Abdullah M Al-Ali

19 Kyrgyzstan E-sport Federation (Kyrgyzstan) Ruslan Ateev*,

Timur Attev

20 Lao People's Democratic

Republic Lao e-Sports Federation Joe Jonathan Sirisackda

21 Libya Libyan Esports Federation

Aladdin Miftah Al Toumi*,

Ahmed Ali Dernawi,

Ahmed Mansur Habil

22 Macau Grow uP eSports

Fernando A. Xavier Pereira*,

Andrew W. Pearson,

Frederico A. Dos Santos Rosario

23 Malaysia Malaysia Electronic Sports

Federation Ananth Sevlanga Nathan

24 Mauritania Federation Esports Mauritania Abdu Abdi Brahim

25 Mexico Mexican eSports Association Luis Eduardo Velez

26 Mongolia Mongolian Esports Association

Erdenechuluun Ganbaatar*,

Amarjargal Altankhuyag,

Ninjtsolmon Bayarsaikhan

27 Montenegro Alliance of Electronic Sports of

Montenegro Filip Soc

28 Myanmar Myanmar Electronic Sports

Federation Kaung Myat San

29 Namibia Namibian Electronic Sports

Association

Flip de Bruyn*,

Andre van Schalkwyk,

David Beukes

30 Nepal Nepal Esports Association Suraj Dangol*,

Bimal Tamrakar

31 Netherlands Dutch Esports Federation Robbin Boer

32 New Zealand New Zealand Esports Federation

Inc.

John McRae*,

Henry Lawton

33 North Macedonia Macedonian Esports Federation Kiril Trajkov*,

Simona Ivanovska

34 Pakistan Pakistan Electronic Sports

Federation

Zulfiqar Ali Butt*,

Saqib Shoukat

35 Philippines Philippine Esports Organization

Brian Lim*,

Joebert Yu,

Jess Tamboboy

36 Poland Esports Association (Poland) Łukasz Klimczyk

37 Republic of Korea Korea e-Sports Association Cheolhag Kim*,

Hyucksoo Shin

38 Russian Federation Russian Esports Federation Konstantin Surkont*,

Dmitry Smit

39 Serbia Serbian e-Sports Association Milan Dukic*,

Nenad Markovic

40 Slovakia Slovak esports association Karol Cagáň

41 South Africa Mind Sports South Africa

Amanda Pakade*,

Colin Webster,

Johan van Breda

42 Sri Lanka Sri Lanka Esports Association

Raveen W Wijayatilake*,

Vikum Jayasekera,

Malinda Jayasekera

43 Sweden Swedish Esports Association Björn Sanders

44 Switzerland Swiss Esports Federation Asif Hanafi

45 Thailand Thailand Esports Federation Samart Benjamin Assarasakorn

46 Tunisia Tunisian Association of Gamers Haroun Bouchrit*,

Houssem Ben Amor

47 Turkey Turkish Esports Federation Talha Karatas

48 Turkmenistan Turkmenistan National Electronic

Sports Federation Mekan Eyeberdiyev

49 Ukraine Federation of Esports of Ukraine Ivan Danishevskyi*,

Eduard Anokhin

50 United Arab Emirates Emirates eSports Association

Saeed Al Tahir*,

David Jenns – representing H.H. Sheikh

Sultan bin Khalifah Al-Nahayan

51 United States United States eSports Federation Lance E Mudd*,

Robin Kent

52 Venezuela Venezuelan Federation of

Electronic Sports Emgelbert F Farfan

53 Vietnam Vietnam Recreational and

Electronic sport Association

Coung Xuan Nguyen*,

Hung Viet Do

* voting representative is marked for Full Members with several representatives

⮚ Full Members in good standing not voting (due to technical issues, being late etc):

No Nation Member organization Represented by

1 Cambodia Esports Association Cambodia Samedy Lun

2 Dominican Republic Dominican Esports Federation Yaqui Nunez

3 Hong Kong Esports Association Hong Kong Chuen Sing Yeung

4 Iran, Islamic Republic of Iran Electronic Sports Association Loghman Shavaran,

Hourieh Nikdast

5 Japan Japan esports Union Akihito Furusawa

6 Kazakhstan Qazaq Cybersport Federation Kazbek Zhangaziyev

7 Syrian Arab Republic Syrian Esports Association Saeed Sharaf

8 Uzbekistan Uzbekistan Esports Federation Azizbek Pattakhov,

Sanjar Usmanov

⮚ Associate Members in good standing (participants with the right to speak):

No Nation Member organization Represented by

1 Argentina Argentinian Esports and

Videogames Association Nicolás Crespo

2 Belarus Belarusian Esports Federation Alexey Kuznetsov

3 Colombia Colombian Federation of Electronic

Sports Alexander Ospina

4 Costa Rica Costa Rican Esports League Felipe Montoya

5 Guatemala Guatemalan Minifootball and

Footgolf Association Pablo Melgar

6 Hungary Hungarian Esports Federation

Balázs György Biró,

Igor Kun,

Dániel Hodozsán

7 Lebanon Esports Lebanon Rayan Khalil

8 Malta Gaming Malta Ivan Filletti,

Malcolm Saleeb

9 Morocco Moroccan Esports Association Othmane Guerrou

Said Karim

10 Norway Norwegian Esports Federation

Bendik Stang

Lars Petter Ø strem

Jack Holand

11 Portugal FNDE – Portuguese E-sports

Association

Tiago Fernandes

Telmo Silva

12 Slovenia E-sports Federation of Slovenia Patricija Potisk

Gašper Bakač

⮚ Other attending organizations (observing):

No Nation, Type Organization Represented by

1 Iraq,

Candidate to Membership Iraqi Esports Federation

Hayder Jaafer

Hassan Bananah

2 Luxembourg,

Candidate to membership Luxembourg Esports Federation

Joe Hoffmann

Tim Miler

Maxime Ferretti

3 Maldives,

Full Member not in good

standing

Maldives Electronic Sports

Federation

Ismail Azmee

Hussain Hamees

⮚ General Meeting officials:

- Vlad Marinescu, Acting President of IESF

- Ido Brosh, Board member of IESF

- Alex Young-man Kim, Board member of IESF

- Boban Totovski, Board member of IESF, Acting General Secretary

- Jeff Bae, Finance and Relations Manager (IESF Secretariat)

- Emily Cho, Secretariat Operations Supervisor (IESF Secretariat)

- Imy Park, Events and BizDev Supervisor (IESF Secretariat)

- Chloe Heo, Secretariat Operation Coordinator (IESF Secretariat)

⮚ Other attendees (physical persons, observing):

- Steve Kim, Asian Electronic Sports Federation (Chief Operating Officer)

- Park Kwon Byeong, Lawyer

- George Yerolimpos (International e-Karate Organization)

- Balázs Takács (IESF)

- Serhat Bekdemir (IESF)

Welcome Statement - Mr. Vlad Marinescu, the Acting President presented and conducted the Opening Address in order to commence

the 2020 General Meeting as the Chairman of the Meeting.

- Mr. Boban Totovski, the General Secretary read the letter from Mauritania member federation, appreciating

IESF for approving his organization as a member. After that, the General Secretary explained the details of the

voting and overall meeting agenda.

■ Confirmation of Present Voting Members

- After the confirmation for roll call, fifty three (53) Full Members confirmed their voting right for the 2020

General Meeting. The rest eight (8) Full Members attending with the right to vote abstained from further voting

due to technical issues, retaining though their right to speak.

■ Minutes of the Previous General Meetings

1. Approval of the previous General Meeting Minutes (2017 OGM Minutes)

- The 2017 OGM Minutes had been shared previously via supporting documents of the meeting.

- With the presence of Legal representative, the voting result was stated as below and such minutes were

approved.

For

43

Against

2

Abstain

8

2. Approval of the previous General Meeting Minutes (2018 OGM Minutes)

- The 2018 OGM Minutes had been shared previously via supporting documents of the meeting.

- With the presence of Legal representative, the voting result was stated as below and such minutes were

approved.

For

41

Against

3

Abstain

9

3. Approval of the previous General Meeting Minutes (2019 OGM Minutes)

- The 2019 OGM Minutes had been shared previously via supporting documents of the meeting.

- The voting result was stated as below and the minutes were approved.

For

44

Against

1

Abstain

8

4. Approval of the previous General Meeting Minutes (2020 EGM Minutes)

- The 2020 EGM Minutes had been shared previously via supporting documents of the meeting.

- The voting result was stated as below and the minutes were approved.

For

47

Against

1

Abstain

5

■ Annual Board Report

- Mr. Ido Brosh, IESF Board Member conducted a presentation for the 2020 Report of the Board.

- General Secretary answered some of the inquiries which were shared via chatting on Zoom. The details of such

talk are contained in the appendix.

For

45

Against

5

Abstain

3

■ Annual Budget and Financial Statement

- Mr. Boban Totovski, the General Secretary explained the incomes and expenses in the IESF Internal Financial

Report.

- Mr. Björn Sanders asked for auditing the Financial Report for 2019 via chat and General Secretary answered the

Financial Report for 2020 shall be audited internally and externally and shared due time.

- Mr. Boban Totovski answered some of the inquiries which Mr. Darren Kwan, Mr. Colin Webster, Mr. Samart

Benjamin Assarasakorn shared, and the details of such talk are contained in the appendix.

For

44

Against

5

Abstain

4

■ Annual Business Plan

- Mr. Vlad Marinescu, the Acting President conducted a presentation of IESF’s Business Plan, which includes

GAISF, Membership, Events, and Projects.

- Mr. Vlad Marinescu, the Acting President answered some of the inquiries via chat. The details of such talk are

contained in the appendix.

For

46

Against

3

Abstain

4

■ Motions to Amend the Statutes

1. Israel A. New IESF Statutes

- Mr. Ido Brosh, IESF Board member made a short introduction of the proposed new IESF Statutes. The

new IESF Statutes has been shared previously via supporting documents of the meeting.

● Registered talk from Mr. Lokesh Suji (Electronic Sports Federation of India)

- Mr. Lokesh Suji stated his opinion about the Statutes and asked the members to not

support it. From his point of view, the new Statutes tie IESF to the industry rather than

pure sport, which is not good for a sport federation, the statutes have some language

issues and also minor mistakes (mis-numeration etc), the role of the Membership

Committee is too big compared to the way it is appointed. Also, there are conflict in the

distribution of powers between the bodies, and quite disputable way of resolving

membership issues between IESF, Confederations and state authorities.

- Mr. Ido Brosh mentioned the participation of Israeli, Slovakian, and Korean lawyers in

the preparation of the Statutes.

● Registered talk from Mr. Talha Karatas (Turkish Esports Federation)

- As a representative of a national esports federation Full Member of IESF, Mr. Talha

Karatas expressed support for the new Statutes.

- The voting result was stated as below and the new IESF Statutes passed.

For

37

Against

12

Abstain

4

2. South Africa & Macedonia

- Due to the approval of new Statutes, the motions of the previous Statutes Amendments from South Africa and

Macedonia were withdrawn.

■ General Motions

1. Sweden

● Remediation of membership changes

Motion

1. All members who had their membership terminated by the Board during 2020

shall be reinstated until the General Meeting has considered the issue and made

their decision.

2. All memberships where a new member replaced a member which was

dismissed by the Board in 2020 shall be revoked.

- Details of each contents had been shared previously via supporting documents of the meeting.

- Mr. Björn Sanders (Swedish Esports Association) briefly commented on the motion that such changes in

membership as termination or replacement made during 2020 needed to be discussed at the General Meeting

and should have been cancelled.

- The voting result was stated as below and such motion did not pass.

For

11

Against

36

Abstain

6

2. Russia

● Counting of votes

Motion

1. To exclude “non present for vote” from counting at the General Meeting and

count “non-voters” as abstaining.

● Counting of vote 2

Motion

1. For the purpose of Voting at the General Meeting, either to have one type of

card and vote in three steps (Yes, No, Abstain), or to have cards of three

different colors and to vote at the same time.

● City bidding for 2020

Motion

1. Recommending the Board makes city bidding for 2022 together with the

bidding for 2021, so as the city and dates of the 2022 Esports World

Championship are known by September 2021.

- Details of each contents had been shared previously via supporting documents of the meeting.

- Mr. Konstantin Surkont on behalf of the Russian Esports Federation withdrew all three (3) motions, due to the

approval of new IESF Statutes.

3. Belgium

● Creation of an Advisory Committee

Motion

1. It is proposed to create an Advisory Committee, which would provide advice

to the Board, and where the Member states could raise any subjects to be

discussed. Member states will elect within their members a number (5) of

their representatives to the Committee.

- Details of each contents had been shared previously via supporting documents of the meeting.

- Mr. Samy Bessi (Belgian Esports Federation) commented on the importance of the establishment of the

Advisory Committee in IESF.

- The voting result was stated as below and such motion did not pass.

For

16

Against

34

Abstain

3

4. Israel

● Clean Slate Initiative

Motion

1. All previous General Decisions made by the General Meetings which are in

effect, shall be voided.

2. The IESF Membership fee shall remain a $500 annual fee.

- Details of each contents have been shared previously via supporting documents of the meeting.

- Mr. Ido Brosh (IESF Board member) commented on this motion about the necessity of the cancellation of all

previous GM decisions that did not concern statutes amendments, excluding the decision on the amount of the

annual membership fee. Such multiple decisions that did not reflect in any guiding document of IESF may

cause inconsistencies and most of them are void due to many changes having happened since the decisions were

made.

- The voting result was stated as below and such motion passed.

For

33

Against

12

Abstain

8

■ Election of President

- Due to the withdrawal of H.H. Sheikh Sultan bin Khalifah Al-Nahayan as a candidate of President election,

only Mr. Vlad Marinescu delivered a short speech as a candidate.

- Mr. Vlad Marinescu was elected as the President of IESF as follows.

For

42

Against

4

Abstain

7

■ Board Members Election

- Short speeches of the four (4) candidates were delivered in the following order.

Number Name of Candidate

1 Flip De Bruyn

2 Cuong Xuan Nguyen

3 Konstantin Surkont

4 Colin Andrew Webster

- Mr. Konstantin Surkont was elected as the IESF Board Member by General Meeting as follows.

Number Name of Candidate Votes

1 Flip De Bruyn 14

2 Cuong Xuan Nguyen 1

3 Konstantin Surkont 30

4 Colin Andrew Webster 3

5 Abstaining votes 5

■ Full Members Application

1. Luxembourg

- Mr. Joe Hoffmann, the President of Luxembourg Esports Federation made a speech that introduces his

organization and vision for being IESF full member.

- Full membership of Luxembourg was approved by the General Meeting as follows.

For

40

Against

1

Abstain

12

2. Norway

- Mr. Bendik Stang, the President of Norwegian Esports Federation made a speech that introduces the vision

and mission of his organization.

- Full membership of Norway was approved by the General Meeting as follows.

For

41

Against

1

Abstain

11

3. Argentina

- Mr. Nicolás M Crespo, the President of Argentinian Esports and Videogames Association made a speech

that introduces the activity and vision of his organization to make esports as a sport.

- Full membership of Argentina was approved by the General Meeting as follows.

For

43

Against

1

Abstain

9

4. Colombia

- Mr. Alexander Ospina, the President of Federacion Colombiana De Deportes Electronicos (Colombian

Federation of Electronic Sports) made a speech that introduced his organization as a national federation of

Colombia, and shared their various activities and commissions.

- Full membership of Colombia was approved by the General Meeting as follows.

For

40

Against

2

Abstain

11

5. Portugal

- Due to the connection issue, Portugal applicant started their presentation ahead of Belarus applicant.

- Mr. Tiago Fernandes, the President of Federação Nacional de Desportos Electrónicos (FNDE – Portuguese

E-sports Association) made a speech that introduced the history and future strategy of his organization.

- Full membership of Portugal was approved by the General Meeting as follows.

For

42

Against

2

Abstain

9

6. Belarus

- Mr. Alexey Kuznetsov, the Board Member of Belarusian eSports Federation made a speech that introduced

the passion of esports, experience of his organization, and lastly the future plan for partnership.

- Full membership of Belarus was approved by the General Meeting as follows.

For

38

Against

2

Abstain

13

7. Hungary

- Mr. Boban Totovski explained the current status of the rivalry issue of Hungary and shared a video of the address

of another applicant, Hungary Gaming and Esports Federation.

- Mr. Biro Balazs, the President of Hungarian Esports Federation, made a speech that introduced the history of

his organization and various partnerships.

- Mr. Vlad Marinescu briefly commented on the effort to merge those organizations and the circumstances of

Hungary. After the speech, an introduction video of Hungarian Esports Federation’s activity was shared.

- Full membership of Hungary (Hungarian Esports Federation) was approved by the General Meeting as

follows.

For

37

Against

2

Abstain

14

8. Iraq

- Mr. Hayder Jaafar, the President of Iraqi Esports Federation made a speech that introduced the previous

activity, experience of his organization and mission to support Iraq esports athletes.

- Full membership of Iraq was approved by the General Meeting as follows.

For

41

Against

0

Abstain

12

■ Closing of Ordinary General Meeting

- Mr. Vlad Marinescu, President conducted the Closing Address in order to close the 2020 General Meeting as

the Chairman of General Meeting.

2020 IESF Ordinary

General Meeting Minutes

Appendix 1

(List of IESF members as of December 21st, 2020

Upon the end of the General Meeting)

Full Members in good standing

No. Member’s name Nation

1 Argentinian Esports and Videogames Association Argentina

2 Australian Esports Association Australia

3 eSports Association Austria Austria

4 Azerbaijan Esports Federation Azerbaijan

5 Bahamas Esports Federation Bahamas

6 Bahrain Mind and Esports Federation Bahrain

7 Belarusian Esports Federation Belarus

8 Belgian Esports Federation Belgium

9 Brazilian Confederation of Electronic Sports Brazil

10 Esports Association of Brunei Brunei Darussalam

11 Esports Association Cambodia Cambodia

12 Chinese Taipei Esports Association Chinese Taipei

13 Colombian Federation of Electronic Sports Colombia

14 Czech Esports Association Czech

15 Dominican Esports Federation Dominican Republic

16 The Finnish Esports Federation Finland

17 Georgia Computer Sports Federation Georgia

18 Esports Association Hong Kong Hong Kong

19 Hungarian Esports Federation Hungary

20 Electronic Sports Federation of India India

21 Indonesia Esports Association Indonesia

22 Iran Electronic Sports Association Iran

23 Iraqi Esports Federation Iraq

24 Israeli Esports Association Israel

25 Italian Federation of Electronic Disciplines Italy

26 Jamaica Esports Initiative Jamaica

27 Japan esports Union Japan

28 Jordan Esports Federation Jordan

29 Qazaq Cybersport Federation Kazakhstan

30 Korea e-Sports Association Korea

31 Kuwait Esports Club Kuwait

32 E-sport Federation Kyrgyzstan

33 Lao e-Sports Federation Laos

34 Libyan Esports Federation Libya

35 Luxembourg Esports Federation Luxembourg

36 Grow uP eSports Macau, China

37 Malaysia Electronic Sports Federation Malaysia

38 Federation Esports Mauritania Mauritania

39 Mexican eSports Association Mexico

40 Mongolian Esports Association Mongolia

41 Alliance of Electronic Sports of Montenegro Montenegro

42 Myanmar Electronic Sports Federation Myanmar

43 Namibian Electronic Sports Association Namibia

44 Nepal Esports Association Nepal

45 Dutch Esports Federation Netherlands

46 New Zealand Esports Federation Inc. New Zealand

47 Macedonian Esports Federation North Macedonia

48 Norwegian Esports Federation Norway

49 Pakistan Electronic Sports Federation Pakistan

50 Philippine Esports Organization Philippines

51 Esports Association (Poland) Poland

52 FNDE - Portuguese E-sports Association Portugal

53 Russian Esports Federation Russia

54 Saudi Arabian Federation for Electronic and

Intellectual Sports Saudi Arabia

55 Serbian e-Sports Association Serbia

56 Slovak esports association Slovakia

57 Mind Sports South Africa South Africa

58 Sri Lanka Esports Association Sri Lanka

59 Swedish Esports Association Sweden

60 Swiss Esports Federation Switzerland

61 Syrian Esports Association Syria

62 Thailand Esports Federation Thailand

63 Tunisian Association of Gamers Tunisia

64 Turkish Esports Federation Turkey

65 Turkmenistan National Electronic Sports Federation Turkmenistan

66 Federation of Esports of Ukraine Ukraine

67 Emirates eSports Association UAE

68 United States eSports Federation US

69 Uzbekistan Esports Federation Uzbekistan

70 Venezuelan Federation of Electronic Sports Venezuela

71 Vietnam Recreational and Electronic sport Association Vietnam

Full Members under suspension

No. Member’s name Nation

1 General Administration of Sports, China Sports

Information Center China

2 Esports Denmark Denmark

3 Egyptian Federation for Electronic Games Egypt

4 Maldives Electronic Sports Federation Maldives

Associate Members

No. Member’s name Nation

1 Esports Association in Bosnia and Herzegovina Bosnia and Herzegovina

2 Street Soccer Sports Management Limited Chile

3 Congolese Federation of Electronic Sports Congo

4 Costa Rican Esports League Costa Rica

5 Equadorian eSports Association Equador

6 Estonia Esports Federation Estonia

7 German Esports Federation Germany

8 Guatemalan Minifootball and Footgolf Association Guatemala

9 Esports and Gaming Federation of Ireland Ireland

10 Esports Lebanon Lebanon

11 Gaming Malta Malta

12 Monaco Esports Federation Monaco

13 Moroccan Esports Association Morocco

14 NextLvls Esports Federation Panama

15 Peruvian Association of Electronic Sports Peru

16 San-Marino e-Sports Association San-Marino

17 E-sports Federation of Slovenia Slovenia

18 Esports Wales Wales

2020 IESF Ordinary

General Meeting Minutes

Appendix 2

(Chatting History)

Following is the chatting history while Original General Meeting was held.

As it is raw file of chat, please consider for its any typo or misspelling.

22:00:13 시작1 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : ok

22:00:24 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : nice report in my opinion

22:02:05 시작 Totovski Boban (IESF) : any comments please write in chat

22:02:27 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : This is far better prepared and detailed than any previously before

22:02:34 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : i remember from the old days it took a week and good luck to get

any sort of answer :D

22:03:03 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Karol thank you for your comment, I will review and make a

reply in a week

22:04:32 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : how modern of you Ido

22:05:13 시작 John McRae (New Zealand) : Which company

22:05:32 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Looks like Mediato…

22:05:52 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: why did leopold leave?

22:06:01 시작 Flip de Bruyn (Namibia) : Bottom right of slides. Mediatoolkit

22:09:13 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Why ISF is not working with IESF for their own esports

championships

22:09:24 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : and FISU?

22:09:36 시작 DAVID JENNS (UAE) : No mention of UAE partners?

22:10:25 시작 John McRae (New Zealand) : Will we be presented the current financial position of the IESF

in the Financial part of agenda?

22:11:26 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Good Viewership numbers :)

22:11:57 시작 Suraj Dangol (Nepal) : Is it possible to breakdown viewership data region wise?

22:12:06 시작 Joonas Kapiainen (Finland) : IESF board should still push to let the countries show the World

Championship streams locally. This is a huge step to gain more viewers on their native language.

22:12:20 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : ^

22:12:23 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : It should be noted that the previous President never refused

to talk to MCST. There were three such meetings.

22:13:18 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : Also in 2019 IESF negotiated agreements with Motivate and

Dubai Sports Council.

22:15:05 시작 Emgelbert Farfán (Venezuela) : very good presentation gentlemen .. plain, simple, direct..

22:15:30 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : Great presentation!

22:15:32 시작 Ismail Azmee Adnan(Maldives) : Great report and presentation

22:15:46 시작 Łukasz Klimczyk (Poland) : Board - good job !

22:15:53 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : In 2019, IESF initiated an extensive marketing campaign

1 *시작 = Recording the hour when such chat was confirmed. (in Korean)

which saw IESF promoting its brand on every continent.

22:16:06 시작 Kiril Trajkov (Macedonia) : awesome presentation ggwp

22:16:14 시작 Alexander Ospina (Colombia) : great report. congratulations.

22:16:29 시작 Ed Anokhin (Ukraine) : Thank you for the presentation!

22:16:33 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : Very good report, congratulations on the work done

22:16:37 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Great report Ido and presentation. Thank you, however I'm not

fully on board with the choice of communication, let's keep it professional and refer to previous board

members with a level of professionality. We know there are and have been issues, and grateful these are being

addressed and the focus is on forward growth and stability.

22:17:11 시작 Eddy Lim (Indonesia) : Great report. Great presentation.

22:17:17 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Great no fuss approach, Tiffany is great

22:17:43 시작 George YEROLIMPOS IEKO : Very professional and productive report!!

22:18:39 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : Agreed with Darren regarding tone of communication

22:18:53 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: FISU & ISF MOU's were done way back

22:19:17 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : Thank you for the report, it was really helpful to understand the

situation and what we achieved and we are going to achieve. Appreciated

22:19:24 시작 DAVID JENNS (UAE) : UAE Ministry of tolerance sgrement was 2020

22:19:27 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : Thank you for great report and presentation!

22:19:45 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : will be the details about the MOUW with WESCO shared?

22:19:55 시작 Talha Karatas🇹🇷(Turkey) : ❤️

22:20:03 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : The previous President did not resign without notice as Boban

has stated. Colin Webster resigned after long discussions as per the press release. It was due to the nature of

COVID-19 and his inability to travel, and believing that it would be better served by Vlad being in the

position.

22:20:11 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Lokesh the MOU with that company, web-something was not

that great, FISU is progressing on their own now with a substantiative esports program.

22:20:48 시작 Hayder Alkaales (Iraq) : thanks for all information's, it was very clear presentation

22:23:34 시작 Ed Anokhin (Ukraine) : Could the NF be the only local representatives in cooperation

between IESF and ISF organizing the national qualifiers and other joint events?

22:26:48 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : I raised the agreements apropos Motivate and Dubai as it was

stated by Ido that IESF had failed in 2019.

22:28:00 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : electronic voting and live graphics update :O

22:28:08 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : IESF 2020 is real

22:28:24 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : The Financial Report for 2019 has not been externally audited, this

is of course not acceptable – but there is sadly nothing to be done about it at this current moment. We have

been reassured and promised that the board will make sure that the Financial Report for 2020 will be

externally audited.

22:29:14 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : Darren last time we needed to pause because the text on the slides

was different from the printed agenda :D

22:29:46 시작 Talha Karatas🇹🇷(Turkey) : can I have this page higher resolution please ?

22:30:26 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : Talha you have all this in an email

22:30:30 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : So, running at a negative $300,000 who wrote off the expense?

22:30:34 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : with all the documents for today, if that helps

22:30:38 시작 Talha Karatas🇹🇷(Turkey) : thanks

22:30:39 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : Hi Talha, you should have in the files sent from the secretariat and

the board

22:30:56 시작 Johan van Breda (South Africa) : Please see the official comment from Mind Sports South

Africa below.

Mind Sports South Africa will vote against accepting the Annual Financial Report as the financials are not

audited and do not contain any balance sheet or comparative figures to previous years. Mind Sports South

Africa is also of the opinion that it is unfair towards the IESF board to have to report on expenditure that

occurred under a previous committee where they were not involved in and wished to see current expenditure

for 2020.

22:31:33 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : Thank you, Boban!

22:31:45 시작 Samart Assarasakorn (Thailand) : IESF pay taxes in korea? or is it exempt as a nonprofit?

22:34:14 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : This ballot doesn't seem to exist. Please contact your election

administrator.

22:34:15 시작 Yaqui Núñez (Dominican Republic) : I am unable to vote, invalid access key

22:34:30 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Are the votes anonymous?

22:35:20 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : i think that only for elected positions, the rest is buplick, but Ido

will know better

22:35:35 시작 Totovski Boban (IESF) : those that didn't do the roll call, can't vote

22:35:57 시작 Totovski Boban (IESF) : only board members and president elections are secret ballot

22:36:02 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : ok cool

22:36:57 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : thank you everyone for your support to the board report. We are in this

together.

22:37:32 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : I notice that the question as to why Leopold departed was

never answered. The 2019 Board (including Vlad) was most displeased with his performance. In 2019

Leopold received 3 earnings from the president. In January 2020 the President asked him to resign which he

did. The previous President was convinced that a forensic audit should be done to recoup lost monies.

22:37:40 시작 Hourieh Nikdast (IRAN) : We have no access to access key!

22:38:17 시작 Joonas Kapiainen (Finland) : Are the vote results are published to members after the meeting?

22:39:30 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : Yes, those will be presented in the minutes

22:39:37 시작 Joonas Kapiainen (Finland) : Thank you!

22:39:39 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : including who voted for what (except pres/board election)

22:39:51 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Can you check the issues with voting? seems like several

members cant vote

22:40:29 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : Those who were late to the meeting and did not confirm participation in

the beginning of the call can't vote according to the rules

22:40:35 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : As Boban is saying re Leopold, this is the reason

22:41:10 시작 Hourieh Nikdast (IRAN) : we were in roll call but not able tp vote!

22:41:30 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : please contact the secretariat

22:41:36 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : immediately

22:41:57 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : I request to pause vote on future topics untill voting is fixed

for everyone

22:42:22 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : Saeed, please contact the Secretariat and Boban

22:42:40 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : if you weren't in the roll call and confirmed participation we can't add you

now, that's the rules of IESF and the GM

22:43:16 시작 Ananth Sevlanga Nathan (Malaysia) : can we record this meeting please?

22:43:17 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : i've been here since the begenning there are issues

22:43:29 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : meeting is being recorded @ananth

22:45:10 시작 Ananth Sevlanga Nathan (Malaysia) : My question is, can we have the permission to record?

22:46:32 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : We prefer not to.

22:46:47 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : I cannot answer this question as the authority belongs to Vlad as chair

and Boban as Secretary

22:49:27 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: What will be the role of NFs in Esports World Series, please

elaborate in detail. Does this mean that athletes/teams from NFs can participate in these events, without NFs

involvement

22:51:25 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : Legally any participant may record.

22:53:10 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : Just to confirm, there is no legal permission or prohibition to record.

22:54:07 시작 Talha Karatas🇹🇷(Turkey) : how to engage disability athletes for run to play ?

22:58:26 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : that would be excellent in Australia, we have a strong program

for abled + disabled competition atm

22:59:05 시작 John McRae (New Zealand) : Is there any programs planned to deal with esports Integrity?

23:00:04 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : can u guys see Vlad, his screen has frozen

23:00:10 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : or is it just me

23:00:14 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : yes his screen is frozen

23:00:22 시작 John McRae (New Zealand) : And will CSGO return to world's?

23:00:44 시작 Hayder Alkaales (Iraq) : I have only one note, based on world organizations, the word

disabled changed to special needs

thank you

23:01:00 시작 Ananth Sevlanga Nathan (Malaysia) : yes, his screen is frozen.

23:01:07 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : The easiest way to contact disability players is to contact the

national federation for disability sports in your own country.

23:01:11 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : Nope, still frozen

23:01:18 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : We can still hear you, yes

23:01:21 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : we can hear you fine

23:01:28 시작 Ahmed Dernawi (Libya)🇱🇾 : yes we can hear you

23:01:29 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : not to worry, it froze on an excellent still of you

23:01:56 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : That was the business plan?

23:02:05 시작 Eddy Lim (Indonesia) : In Indonesia, our association already has a "special needs"

division/committee.

23:03:30 시작 Grace Chen (Chinese Taipei) : Seeing the slides repeatedly these days, I have to express our

gratitude from CTESA for your enjoying 2018 IESF WC in Kaohsiung and all the event photos taken back

then.

23:04:25 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Grace, best event!

23:04:32 시작 Fernando Pereira (Macau) : Missing Taiwan :)

23:06:20 시작 Grace Chen (Chinese Taipei) : Thx. Hope to see ya all soon.

23:06:36 시작 Johan van Breda (South Africa) : Agreed it was the best IESF event to date!

23:07:02 시작 Raveen Wijayatilake (Sri Lanka) : +1 for Taiwan :)

23:07:30 시작 Suraj Dangol (Nepal) : +1 for Taiwan

23:08:01 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : +100 for that event!

23:08:08 시작 Hourieh Nikdast (IRAN) : for the first time we in Iran Esports Association have lauched the

"Esports and sports Integrity Committee" and if any federation want to run such committee in its country,

we are pleased to have cooperation in this regard, just email Mr. Loghman Shavarany

23:09:29 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : and now honestly where did you get the playlist ?

23:09:52 시작 Joonas Kapiainen (Finland) : Was about to ask the same Karol, could add a few more songs

to the rotation.

23:09:54 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : CTESA did do a great event. Previous Boards must have

done something right . Ha ha ha

23:10:13 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : +1 for Taiwan

23:11:16 시작 Tiago Fernandes (Portugal) : +2 for Taiwan

23:11:20 시작 Otto Takala (Finland) : Taiwan was absolutely great! We should organize 20th anniversary

celebrations games in northern Finland, together with Santa Claus and friends.;)

23:12:19 시작 Johan van Breda (South Africa) : Please see the official comment from Mind Sports South

Africa below.

Mind Sports South Africa will vote against the Statutes as proposed by Israel as it contains far too many

vague areas in some cases even provides the board with powers equal to or more than the general meeting

which in Mind Sports South Africa’s opinion would vitiate member’s rights. MSSA is also of the opinion

that these new statutes will create even less oversight and accountability for the board. Something MSSA

believes there should be far more of not less.

23:12:32 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Thank you Hourieh and Loghman, this is great!

23:12:57 시작 Hourieh Nikdast (IRAN) : Darren it is kind of you

23:13:12 시작 Raveen Wijayatilake (Sri Lanka) : Colin, your board needed up your powerpoint game

23:13:38 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : prof. JUDr. PhDr. Tomáš Gábriš, PhD., LL.M., MA senior profesor

of Law in University of Trnava, member of various legislator committees to the SLovak government was one

of the leaders on the team writing the statues

23:13:45 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Tomas_Gabris

23:14:12 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : you can check his research and citation index here, he is highly

admired proffesional

23:14:13 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : There are issues in the new statutes, some language issues which

would set us up against the game publishers in which we should be symbiotic. Also a few other clauses could

be tidied up, so Australia will also be voting against the new statutes in favour of newer version with more

consideration for members needs, revising language that is inconsistent with the esports world and to rethink

WADA and integrity.

23:14:28 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : A note from Sweden on this motion:

Many things are better than the previous ones, but there are several small areas that are not. If these statues

would have been sent on refer to the members nations this could have been avoided. Let us dismiss this

motion and let it be worked with one more year, including a proper refer-round to the members.

23:14:45 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : I see these as minor issues which could be made better in a new

version.

23:15:10 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : Darren is correct about the use of language.

23:15:12 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Lokesh looking great! love the new hair

23:15:13 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : We need to fill criteria for GAISF membership denying statues can

cause problems there

23:15:24 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : we can always correct the mistakes later

23:16:02 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Then we must add amendment notes for what areas need to be

amended, approved subject to amended for sections a, b, c etc.

23:16:14 시작 John McRae (New Zealand) : Fix them and call an extraordinary meeting later.

23:16:27 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : The current Statutes are not an impediment to joining GAISF.

23:16:29 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : yeah that makes sense @john, good idea.

23:16:53 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Please let Lokesh speak longer

23:16:55 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : I yield my time

23:16:57 시작 DAVID JENNS (UAE) : John - good call - this would address the due process issue that

appears to be popping up

23:17:26 시작 Johan van Breda (South Africa) : I agree we cannot pass a flawed set of statutes. Fix it and

propose it in an extraordinary meeting later.

23:17:56 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : Well it makes sense to pass it now, do a revision with an EGM

if needed.

23:18:06 시작 Lance Mudd - (United States) : ^Agreed Asif

23:18:16 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : agree Asif

23:18:17 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Asif a revision may never come if we blindly accept

23:18:32 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : there where statue amendments ant each OGM

23:18:56 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : @Darren if enough of us agree, given the way the Board has

proactively reacted I think a revision in an EGM would be very much possible.

23:18:58 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : i believe the board will listen to us and maybe even get a committee

to address concerns

23:19:26 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : yes, that's why if we approve with an attached note 'subject to

further amendment' and we outline some key areas then that should satisfy

23:19:33 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : besides, every member was asked to nominate their representatives

for the statues committee and nobody was turned down

23:19:41 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : almost approved as version 1.0a waiting for a 1.0b

23:20:12 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : This could have been avoided if the promised refer to the member

nations was kept. It wasn't and thus we should not rush to conclussions. The process is important as it verifies

the results.

23:21:13 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : The way, we view it is the GAISF membership application is

extremely complex and the fact that the previous statutes were not fully compliant with Korean law is also

concerning. I personally feel that approving this now and agreeing with the board to continue a revision and

hold an EGM would be a positive step forward. It's not perfect but its amicable.

23:21:17 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Lokesh, well reasoned, well studied and well spoken as usualy

23:21:35 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Yes Asif

23:22:26 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : I encourage everyone to take Lokesh's comments on board as

they come from the right place

23:22:44 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Asef the new statutes should serve 100+ member nations, not

one nation or one federation

23:22:50 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : arol please refer to Discord chat to understand that SWG has

8 members, but only 3 worked on it without proper coordination and no answered questions.

23:23:04 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : h my respect to the hardwork and time dedicated for new

statutes, 3 people working for 3 months is not enough to have a copy that can work for 100+ members. We

need time to enhance it and then vote on it later, not this OGM.

23:23:09 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Questions coming up here

23:23:28 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : “What’s the relevance of this “Version: Sunday, November 15, 2020.

This should not be there at all.”

23:23:51 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: 2. IESF Headquarters and registered legal seat is in the

Republic of Korea (the "Host Country"). …. “Instead of “seat” it should be “office”

23:24:13 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: 6. Donations (b) Any income received from donations obtained

under the Law shall only be used for the public benefit and benefit any member or related business. ““of”

missing Benefit of any member, does not sound correct, it should be “benefit of all the members”

23:24:16 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : I've followed the discord chat and I understand the perspectives,

I'm just advocating lets move forward with the commitment from the board to support an EGM to revise

statutes where necessary.

23:24:53 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: 7: The IESF Mission is to serve as the critical global

organization representing, coordinating,……. “Need a better word for “critical”

23:25:09 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: The IESF Mission is to serve as the critical

global organization representing, coordinating,

harmonizing, and administrating Esports while preserving the rights and providing a voice to all Stakeholders

of the Esports industry (the "Mission").

“Esports Industry” makes us the industry Body rather than a Sports body.

The word “Industry” should be deleted from here

23:25:27 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Other NF are proposing motions to form committiees, which

is good start if we keep the current statutes.

23:25:32 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 8 d: To promote responsible initiatives for physical and

mental health as well as to protect the interests of all Esports athletes and gamers ; …………….. Are we saying

that we will take care of the interest of gamers playing games like candy crush also, if not then remove “and

Gamers”.

23:25:33 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : onestly i dont think theese are some serious dealbrakers

23:25:48 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: 8 j: To organize, activate, support or recognize Esports

competitions and events;

Does this mean that IESF and/or IESF Board can recognize any esports in any country without the consent

of the National Federation?? That should not be the case any which ways, hence this clause needs to removed

or corrected appropriately. Or a separate subsequent clause should be mentioned in statutes that IESF may

do so only with the consent of the National federations.

23:25:49 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : I'm not concerned that Lokesh has had 8 minutes to speak, or the

rules around this, reasonably Lokesh is providing substantiative reasoning and comments that represents the

best interests of the membership and for that we should be grateful.

The work on the statutes has been extensive, long and worthwhile, though there are still issues with the

current set - so the proposal to have amendments made is important. I think we can vote to approve subject

to these amendments being made.

Also I recommend including Lokesh on the working group this time around and also a representative from

Oceania.

23:25:50 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : Why not call an EGM immediately to elect the third?

23:26:08 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 9: Non-discrimination and Female Athlete Promotion …

“This is a contradictory clause, as on one side we are saying that there should not be any discrimination, and

other side we are saying Female Athlete promotion.

Since we have covered Non-discrimination already, this clause should be “Women Empowerment” and why

only as Athlete, they should be empowered across including IESF board, coaches, ref, casting, marketing,

operations and all of it”

23:26:32 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Lokesh, please also post these as a succinct email to me

darren@aesa.org.au

23:26:42 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : @IDO How can u make such kind of statements

23:27:03 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : despite sharing the facts on discord

23:27:20 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 11: 11. arbritation:

a. In addition to other general provisions of the Statutes, any dispute arising from, or related to the Statutes

and the occasion in connection with IESF events, other than a dispute arising out of the Statutes or a dispute

that can be resolved by an institution of IESF,…………. Which institution and what are the details of such

committee

23:27:41 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 22: An organization that acts as a national body for Esports

in any country may apply for Membership in IESF. ………….. WHY DID WE REMOVE “Not for profit

organization having the structure of a NF (consisting of provincial, regional, or club bodies that are

geographically well distributed)

23:28:24 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q Clause 24. An organization that wishes to become an IESF member

(the "Membership Candidate") shall apply to the IESF Membership Committee (the "Membership

Committee"). The application shall include the following minimal information: Legal name of the

Membership Candidate, Nation, Registration Status. ................ Time frames for each action and response are

missing.

23:28:37 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : seems its better if I upload the document here

23:28:53 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : It should've included all Statutes Work Group members such

as Syria, India, Germany and Iran.

Also it supposed to share the draft with all the members by July so everyone have time to review, evaluate

and enhance.

23:29:29 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : I believe it is important to point out doubts about the new statue but

I believe professionaly speaking the new statue is a good starting point to keep the iesf professional

23:30:00 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : agree with Giulio, we should let lawyers discuss it

23:30:10 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : but we need a fresh start to move on

23:30:13 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : I hope my statements clarified some things and we will continue to grow

and prosper tofether with the new framework the New Statutes bring.

Support us - vote yes! thank you for your consideration :)

23:30:32 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 25. The Membership Committee is entitled to request

additional information to be added to the Membership Candidate application, at its sole discretion …………….

Its important to define the list of documents, it can not be “at its sole discretion” and may lead to bias &

manipulation

23:30:34 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : and for this the presented statues are sufficient, since they are

written bu porffessors and researchers

23:30:45 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 26 a: If the Membership Committee accepts the

Membership Candidate, then such Membership Candidate becomes an Associate Member of IESF following

the Board’s approval, and shall have the right to request admission as Full Member of IESF at the next

General Meeting;

What if the board denies approval to such members who have been approved by membership committee for

associate membership?

And we should also define the time lines within which the membership committee will review and share the

result, similarly the board approval.

23:30:49 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Giulio the quality is not good enough

23:30:59 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 26 b. If the Membership Committee denies the Membership

Candidate, then such Membership Candidate is not accepted into IESF, but shall have the right to appeal to

the next General Meeting of IESF;

Upcoming General Meeting. We should also consider the time availability here.

What will be the appeal process?

23:31:12 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 27: Admission Fee: Membership/Admission fee should be

proposed by the Membership Committe and approved by the General Body.

23:31:31 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Cluse 28. In case of an IESF Member’s request to convert its

membership to another organization in their country, and such organization had been verified by the

Membership Committee, the Board following official request and verification may grant such an amendment

Word to be used here “transfer” and any such transfer should be proposed by the MC and ultimately approved

by the General Assembly.

23:32:06 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 29. b. The Associate Member is an organization that

upholds all of the criteria and terms to be a Full Member of IESF according to these Statutes but was not

approved by the General Meeting.

Or yet to be approved by General Assembly or yet to apply for full membership. If this clause remain, then

exsiting Assocaite members will lose there membership e.g. Germany.

AFFILAITE MEMBERS REMOVED??

23:32:21 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q; Clause 29 b clause (Associate Members shall be accepted by the

Membership Committee; ) is contradictory to 26 a (If the Membership Committee accepts the Membership

Candidate, then such Membership Candidate becomes an Associate Member of IESF following the Board’s

approval,)

23:32:30 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Great move Vlad

23:32:35 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 30 b: Have a representative at any IESF's body session that

concerns the activity of such Member Federation, but without a vote, and be duly notified about such a

session.

What kind of clause is this?? More details to give a proper explanation required.

23:33:02 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 31 c (ii) Allows any Esports player ordinarily resident

within the country of the Member to opt into the structure of the Member and to take part in the governance

and development of Esports in the country;

Citizens of the country, as a member they will have the voting rights and non-citizens of the country can not

vote in any sports structure.

23:33:11 시작 Joonas Kapiainen (Finland) : The result of the this vote determines if the IESF will be more

efficient next year or not, even though there was no reviewing round for the draft. We are patching worse

statutes every year which we don't have to do.

23:33:28 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause Article f 32 d: For Associate Members, upon the decision

of the General Meeting not to accept such Member as Full Member ………… This clause means, that the

member will lose its status of “Associate” if the GA does not accept that associate member as a “full member”.

23:33:43 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 32 e: The Board may approve termination of a member, if

the Member’s national government had duly recognized another entity as the governing or representing body

for Esports within the Member country.

- Any such termination of the member has to be done by the General Assembly on proposal by the

membership committee.

- We all know how the current state of recognition of esports by the local governments (which is

largely dependent on the final decision of IOC; we also know what IOC things in this regards).

- Further the IESF should work along side the NF to get that NF recognized and esports recognized.

- We can not just terminate the membership of exiting full member just because of this, there may be

situations where the exiting NF may have to file some court case etc against the government also and the

exiting NF will need support from IESF.

Highest Sports body or Local Olympic Committee.

23:33:59 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Q: Clause 34: The Membership Committee shall not recommend the

expulsion of a Member for the reasons stated in subsections (F)(27)-(a), (b), or (c) before warning such

Member and allowing reasonable time to remedy the situation.

This clause does not make any sense, what do u mean by (F) and assuming its Article F, then F(27) a/b/c

does not even exist.

Also this clause does not gel well with (32e) and (34),

23:34:36 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : I hope my statements clarified some things and we will continue to grow

and prosper tofether with the new framework the New Statutes bring.

Support us - vote yes! thank you for your consideration :)

23:35:22 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Appreciate if you share the webpage where votes are being

casted.

23:36:04 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : For transparency

23:36:07 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : https://secure.electionbuddy.com/m/IESF2020

23:36:30 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : i meant the results, as i cant open it due to technical things

about roll cast

23:36:45 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : the results are not visible there

23:36:59 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : only here in the meeting

23:37:03 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : thats why i asked to show it from Administrator interface

23:41:03 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : ah my vote wouldn't go through

23:41:29 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : thank you vlad

23:41:30 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : thank you for supporting us! let's make IESF greater together!

23:41:30 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : good move

23:43:55 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : In my winter solstice dinner family time! lol

23:46:41 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : I agree that board should explain entire process and provide

reasoning and their point of view of what happened, however i also think this might derail our GAISF

application and we need to be cautious about it

23:46:46 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : I agree, these terminations didn't follow proper process, neither

were they communicated appropiately or timely, Brazil's termination, for example, never showed up in the

Board Reports, neither did Argentina

23:47:05 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : @karol the views are written in the Agenda under board's

recommendation.

23:47:20 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : i know but they dont address all the coments

23:47:27 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : Boban may also briefly explain our position on this.

23:47:49 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : that i believe will explain everything

23:48:31 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : Allowing the Board to remove members in such terms

jeopardizes the position of any member within IESF

23:49:52 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : Indeed Felipe, correct analysis.

23:50:09 시작 Constantine Surkont (Russian Federation) : The statutes contradict themselves

23:50:19 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : It's not only that they didn't follow adequate procedure, they

weren't communicated properly and transparently

23:50:50 시작 Constantine Surkont (Russian Federation) : Moreover, Member is Full member, or Full and

Associate. It is still disputable. So the decisions were correct

23:51:44 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : the most important point however is that GAISF application will

be derailed

23:52:04 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : if we accept this motion

23:52:36 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : The most important point must be to follow the statues! But you

could argue that the board did, I argue that they didn't.

23:52:45 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : Why weren't these terminations included in the board reports?

23:53:52 시작 Fernando Pereira (Macau) : there is no abstain option, so we are just not voting

23:54:05 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : I think this could have been handled better, I think the issue has

been around transparency of the why's and how's

23:54:13 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : if you don't vote, its considered abstaining.

23:54:40 시작 Fernando Pereira (Macau) : there is no winning choice here.

23:54:42 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : And we can't keep moving forward sticking to dubious

procedures just for the sake of getting into GAISF

23:55:00 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : agree with Felipe

23:55:06 시작 Fernando Pereira (Macau) : agree as well

23:55:14 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : GAISF is not the golden ticket on it's own

23:55:20 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : Regardless of the outcome here, the most important part of this

motion is to make the board aware that we do not tolerate misses in procedure for "the greater good".

23:55:21 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : The batch acceptance of over 20+ new Full Members was

already questionable as it was

23:55:43 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : it is a great achievement and will reset the playing field for us,

bringing stakeholders to the table

23:55:56 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : I want to remind to everybody that the point of the iesf is to get the

recognition of esports internationally and to support the members and advocate esports worldwide. A delay

on recognition shouldn't even be part of the discussion.

23:56:09 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : but I want to avoid making any mistakes along the way

23:56:42 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : To rush is to jeopardize sustainable results!

23:57:18 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : How many compromises are we willing to make regarding

our ethics and proper procedure in order to get into GAISF, I do not think that's correct at all

23:57:47 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Participation in esports should be healthy and sustainable, the

IESF needs to take this approach on it's path to GAISF and otherwise. something to be mindful of, especially

as Italy imho has already experienced enough disaster around international esports bodies & local bodies

23:58:19 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : Italy solved its disasters in the best way possible together with the

support of the iesf

23:59:21 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : I don't know if GAISF conducts a proper audit or investigation

on such internal matters, but if they do I would suspect they will find it lacking severely. Accepting and

removing members in such a careless way might and will come back to bite us in the future

23:59:42 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : Thank you Vlad for your considerations, and thank you all for

discussion and voting. I think we all agree that these discussions are important!

00:00:13 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : huh, he was there just fine

00:00:43 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Great to hear Giulio

00:01:27 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : Bjorn its important you brought it to light, i believe that next time

there will be a more detailed and transparent communication on such as decisions.

00:01:39 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : I'd hope so Karol!

00:02:02 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : its 11 members at least that cant be ignored

00:02:49 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Thank you Constantine

00:02:59 시작 DAVID JENNS (UAE) : Thank you Constantine

00:03:08 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : You´re the best constantine

00:03:17 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : vote 1 Constatine

00:03:49 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : It's fine, the echo makes it sound like you're addressing a stadium

00:03:50 시작 Balázs Takács (IESF) : turn the volume down on ur pc

00:03:51 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : Constantine, Thank you!!!

00:04:31 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Belgian Chocolate the BEST!

00:04:31 시작 Nenad Markovic (Serbia) : Constantine mvp

00:04:37 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : Don't worry, can relate, I think we smaller hahaha

00:04:38 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : great country !

00:04:41 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : we are*

00:04:41 시작 Balázs Takács (IESF) : Thank you!

00:04:45 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : You cannot be smaller than Macau!

00:04:54 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : haha

00:05:39 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Macau is tiny

00:05:55 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Like a nut.

00:07:08 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Let's not compete on how small it is

00:07:26 시작 erdenechuluun ganbaatar (Mongolia) : good point Darren

00:07:48 시작 erdenechuluun ganbaatar (Mongolia) : let's compete how big it is

00:08:00 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : Darren as long as we are talking countryes its OK :D

00:08:31 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Boban, can we have a pin for each committee so we can collect

them?

00:08:38 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : You mean committess like WESCO?

00:09:50 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Felipe we need to confirm a committee before we can discuss if

they mean committees like WESCO

00:12:55 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Lets go Ido!

00:16:00 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Agreed

00:16:05 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : clean house, move forward

00:16:29 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : it's ok to come out of the closet

00:17:30 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : and leths get some of that lovely music back

00:17:40 시작 Constantine Surkont (Russian Federation) : Were the new statutes enacted immediately?

00:17:45 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Karol, it's a late night mix

00:17:53 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : is it open?

00:18:05 시작 Johan van Breda (South Africa) : not open on my side yet

00:18:06 시작 Gregory Moore (Jamaica) : no vote yet

00:18:09 시작 Fernando Pereira (Macau) : I don't see it open yet

00:18:13 시작 Kiril Trajkov (Macedonia) : still not

00:18:13 시작 Raveen Wijayatilake (Sri Lanka) : not open yet

00:18:18 시작 Eddy Lim (Indonesia) : we need a clean plate , to grab a new food :P

00:18:19 시작 Raveen Wijayatilake (Sri Lanka) : Ok now

00:18:24 시작 Kiril Trajkov (Macedonia) : it is now

00:19:45 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Eddy let's eat

00:22:04 시작 Ananth Sevlanga Nathan (Malaysia) : Eddy, Darren can I join?

00:22:19 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Yes, let's have a group outing

00:22:49 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : Thank you for your support everyone. today is a historic day for our

family. Together as one from now!

00:23:12 시작 Talha Karatas🇹🇷(Turkey) : 👍

00:24:07 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : my vote page dose not reload to theVote poll

00:24:52 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : refresh now should be fine

00:24:56 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : got it done thx

00:25:17 시작 houssem ben amor ( Tunisia ) : doesn't work for me

00:25:19 시작 Fernando Pereira (Macau) : voting didn't work here

00:25:21 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : not sure if it recorded my vote, but it was a Yes!

00:25:25 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Please do Karaoke Boban!

00:25:31 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : Congratulations, Mr. President!!!

00:25:37 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Yes I had same issue as Fernando, voting error

00:25:40 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Congrats

00:25:41 시작 Igor Kun (Hungary) : Congratulations!

00:25:41 시작 Kiril Trajkov (Macedonia) : Congratz

00:25:42 시작 Eddy Lim (Indonesia) : Congratulation Mr. President

00:25:44 시작 Fernando Pereira (Macau) : congrats

00:25:45 시작 Zulfiqar Ali butt (Pakistan) : congratulations to Vlad Marinescu

00:25:46 시작 Ahmed Dernawi (Libya)🇱🇾 : Congratulations, Mr. President

00:25:49 시작 Jacopo Ierussi (Italy) : Congratulations

00:25:49 시작 erdenechuluun ganbaatar (Mongolia) : congratulations

00:25:50 시작 houssem ben amor ( Tunisia ) : congratulations

00:25:51 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Full Power to Vlad !

00:25:54 시작 George YEROLIMPOS IEKO : Congratulations to IESF and its Leadership for the

professional new approach in the e-sports entity and I wish to all of you a Happy, Healthy and Prosperous

2021!! Congratulations also to the President Vlad Marinescu for his election!!

00:25:56 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : Coongratulations Mr. President!

00:25:56 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Congratulations Vlad!

00:25:57 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : congratulations Mr. Marinescu

00:25:58 시작 Gregory Moore (Jamaica) : congras

00:26:05 시작 Filip Soc (Montenegro) : Congratulations Vlad!

00:26:06 시작 Gregory Moore (Jamaica) : congrats

00:26:08 시작 Ed Anokhin (Ukraine) : Congratulations!

00:26:09 시작 Hourieh Nikdast (IRAN) : Congratulation Mr. Vlad

00:26:16 시작 Emgelbert Farfán (Venezuela) : Congrat´s Mr Vlad..

00:26:18 시작 Samart Assarasakorn (Thailand) : Congrats Mr. President

00:26:19 시작 Hyucksoo David Shin (Korea) : Congratulations Mr. President!

00:26:19 시작 Lance Mudd - (United States) : Congratulations Mr. Vlad Marinescu

00:26:23 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : Big congratulations from the north! Well deserved!

00:26:26 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : I'm pretty sure the 4 votes where ones that didn't work

00:26:40 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : yes break badly needed :

00:26:42 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : :)

00:26:56 시작 Samy BESSI ( BELGIUM) : Congratulations !

00:27:07 시작 Samy BESSI ( BELGIUM) : To all of us ;)

00:27:45 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : Be sure to be back ON TIME

00:27:47 시작 John McRae (New Zealand) : Just about breakfast here... any recipies?

00:27:53 시작 Ananth Sevlanga Nathan (Malaysia) : Well Done!!!

00:28:04 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : … John it's 2:30, when are you eating breakfast?

00:28:18 시작 Telmo Silva (Portugal) : where is The Coffee Break? 😊

00:28:22 시작 John McRae (New Zealand) : I said just about

00:28:41 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : to the left near elevator

00:29:02 시작 Ananth Sevlanga Nathan (Malaysia) : comeby Malaysia John, I'd serve you some coffee

00:29:08 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Telmo, go front, turn left, right x2, elevator, click M, turn right,

coffee machine

00:29:17 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : It's satchel coffee, in Styrofoam cups

00:29:17 시작 John McRae (New Zealand) : ta

00:29:35 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Fredrico if you start left , right, it has to be up up down down

X Y

00:29:41 시작 Telmo Silva (Portugal) : Same floor?

00:29:56 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : no Telmo, it's on the floor

00:29:58 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Saeed, sorry, almost forgot the command pad code. Sorry...

00:30:20 시작 Gregory Moore (Jamaica) : enter up, up, down, down, left, right, left, right,

00:30:36 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : ... A B Start

00:30:42 시작 SERHAT BEKDEMIR (IESF) : ^^

00:33:25 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : OK, I recharged with a banana! Bring it on, another 3 hours!

00:33:30 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : This would almost be 900 times better if we where all together

00:33:38 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Frederico could have shared his banana

00:34:00 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Would require to purchase a big plaintain

00:34:17 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : definitly better, looking forward to meet all together. Miss my

favorite family in esports

00:34:47 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : I need noodles.

00:35:12 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Freddie why don't you bring SF and challenge people in the

breaks?

00:35:23 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Look at my camera Darren

00:35:24 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : all these years, all these missed bouts

00:35:31 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : HAHAA

00:35:49 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : But with this meeting, it is chess.com

00:36:37 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : chess.com for next world championships

00:37:29 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Could be interesting haha

00:37:32 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : + SFV

00:38:39 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Vietnam has a very committed setup for today's meeting

00:40:08 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Robbin, please don't put your feet into the camera

00:40:17 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : this is esports federation, not IFFF

00:40:35 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Taekwondo?

00:40:47 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : International Foot Fetish Federation

00:41:05 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Man, I just remembered a Federation we met...

00:41:21 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Can't share here. Sorry

00:41:39 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Freddie

00:42:24 시작 Robbin Boer (Netherlands) : sorry there, forgot about camera position

00:42:43 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : it's ok

00:42:54 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : it made for a good comedic interlude

00:43:05 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : tks

00:45:38 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : change the name below

00:45:41 시작 Joebert Yu (Philippines) : Wrong name

00:45:51 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : name

00:46:11 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : xin chao

00:47:27 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Thank you!

00:49:09 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Just sharing Mr CUONG NGUYEN speech in English in case of

the quality is not clear enough

00:49:33 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Thank you Hung, it was well spoken and understood

00:49:49 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : LOL

00:49:50 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Ladies and gentlemen. I am Nguyen Xuan Cuong - the President

of Vietnam Recreational and eSports association (VIRESA). As become an official board member of IESF

I undertake:

Firstly, together with Southeast Asian National Esports federations, VIRESA will contribute a positive voice

to gain recognition from the International Olympic Committee (IOC) through the SEA games 31 held in

Vietnam in 2021.

Secondly, collaborate with IESF board member as well as IESF’s members in developing standards, training

and educational programs which related to professional competition including eSports and digital sports.

And the last, mobilize resources from sponsors to support IESF events around the world as well as comit to

host IESF events in Vietnam,which are approved by The Board, World Championship is the one of first

option. Thank you for your listening and I wish all the countries to win Covid 19. Hope to welcome you soon

in my beautiful country - Vietnam.

00:49:52 시작 Hourieh Nikdast (IRAN) : Great Mr. Constantine

00:49:57 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Thank you all

00:50:13 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Don't worry I will always support :)

00:50:30 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Well done, thanks

00:50:54 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : I can help with the students competitions. We just finished the

first League with the ministry of Education of Argentina.

00:51:18 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : Thank you Constantine!!!

Spasibo!

00:51:32 시작 Hourieh Nikdast (IRAN) : We have the students competitions as well

00:52:31 시작 Hourieh Nikdast (IRAN) : IRAN is the champ of FISU esports championship

00:52:48 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Hourieh it would be lovely to collaborate internationally, we

have one of the most advanced programs in the world.

00:53:16 시작 Hourieh Nikdast (IRAN) : Darren it would be great

00:53:19 시작 Gregory Moore (Jamaica) : not able to hear him speaking

00:53:50 시작 Gregory Moore (Jamaica) : muted

00:53:53 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : Constantine are you working with European university masters

organised by Riot games as well ?

00:53:55 시작 Łukasz Klimczyk (Poland) : Voting is not working

00:54:01 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : voting hasn't started yet

00:54:01 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : i believe they are called amazon

00:54:02 시작 Totovski Boban (IESF) : microphone Colin

00:54:16 시작 Johan van Breda (South Africa) : Can't hear Colin.

00:54:23 시작 Gregory Moore (Jamaica) : can’t hear

00:54:34 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : Muted

00:54:35 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Colin we can't hear you :(

00:55:42 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : maybe remove the earbuds

00:55:54 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : No sounds.

00:55:58 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : it appears that are microphone less and could be cutting the

phone/tablet from enabling the microphone

00:56:09 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : even the music is cut off :(

00:56:31 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : hello....

00:56:36 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : I need the music Karol.

00:57:00 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : under the mic options, has it selected the right device?

00:57:11 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Hi Jonathan

00:57:54 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : we cannot hear you

00:57:57 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : now yes

00:58:00 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : or not

00:58:06 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : hello HUNG

00:58:58 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Select the correct output

00:59:31 시작 Telmo Silva (Portugal) : TeamViewer or Anydesk for help him

00:59:32 시작 Hassan Haitham ( Iraq ) : remove the earbuds

00:59:32 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : We should do waves

00:59:34 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : he may have tried the speaker link

00:59:44 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Sound drivers could be unfriendly some times, try to call on

Discord or phone

00:59:45 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : and then forgot to activate the zoom mic

01:00:01 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : the absolute plays by Vlad

01:00:15 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : good

01:00:17 시작 Telmo Silva (Portugal) : good job Vlad

01:00:21 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : We can hear him fine

01:00:23 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : he's agile, which is what we need

01:00:30 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : good'

01:00:51 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Vlad's pulling those gamer moves

01:01:03 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Judo Master

01:01:26 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : good job vlad!!!

01:02:08 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Black belt moves.

01:02:15 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : What happens if no one receives a majority of votes in the first

election round? Will there be a 2nd round with the top 2 candidates?

01:02:19 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : nothing surprises you guys :D

01:02:31 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Great Job, Vlad!!!

01:02:35 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : whoever gets most votes win

01:02:45 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Bjorn, interestingly they have to compete on chess.com to

determine the outcome.

01:03:04 시작 Flip de Bruyn (Namibia) : Thank you everyone for your time. If there are question I would

be happy to address them.

I hope for your support.

01:03:12 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : whatsapp sponsoring the meeting, that is great

01:03:19 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : Even if they don't get the support from a majority?

01:03:20 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Thank you Collin!!!

01:03:25 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : That can't be right?

01:04:46 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : I'd split my vote if I could

01:04:51 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : but we can only pick one!

01:04:51 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : We cannot reasonably elect someone without confirming majority

back, right? Am I out on a limb here?

01:05:04 시작 houssem ben amor ( Tunisia ) : I can't vote why ?

01:05:17 시작 Totovski Boban (IESF) : whoever has majority wins

01:05:25 시작 Totovski Boban (IESF) : I don't see an issue

01:05:33 시작 houssem ben amor ( Tunisia ) : now it's ok thank you

01:05:42 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : Boban is right.

01:05:43 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : Well if no one gets a majority, Boban?

01:05:45 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Whoever elected, welcome on board!!!

01:06:02 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : Please, elighten me, Colin! :)

01:06:30 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : on?

01:06:55 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : If its equal votes, there should be second cast i belive

01:07:03 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : like if 2 got top votes

01:07:04 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : What happens if no one candidate gets a majority votes in the first

count of votes

01:07:06 시작 DAVID JENNS (UAE) : Where is Logesh and his marker pan

01:07:11 시작 DAVID JENNS (UAE) : pen

01:07:28 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : Which of course is highly likely!

01:07:49 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : If they are equal, Yes, but where there is a majority, winner

takes it.

01:07:53 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Lokesh is the main man

01:08:04 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Agree, Boban!!!

01:08:07 시작 John McRae (New Zealand) : great beats... helping me stay awake

01:08:15 시작 DAVID JENNS (UAE) : Where with Vlad on the presidents chair there are technically two

spots - I think

01:08:20 시작 Abdullah Al-Ali (Kuwait) : Good luck to all members

01:08:21 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : It's very Sim like

01:08:24 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Lokesh and Constantine has great legal knowledge and

attention to details

01:08:34 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Agreed with saeed

01:08:48 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Lokesh and Constantine will cross every t and dot every i

01:09:15 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Congrats

01:09:26 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : oh, the problem is void anyways, since Surkont got a majority on

the first vote!

01:09:27 시작 Colin Webster (South Africa) : Well done Constantine.

01:09:29 시작 Łukasz Klimczyk (Poland) : Congratulation !

01:09:32 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Congrats!!!

01:09:34 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : Congratulations Constantine

01:09:37 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : congratz constantine

01:09:37 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Congrats Costantine

01:09:42 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : Congratulations Constantine!!!!!

01:09:45 시작 Constantine Surkont (Russian Federation) : Thank you everybody!

I’ll do my best to meet expectations of those who voted for me and ensure others that the final choice was

right.

01:09:45 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : congratulations Constantin

01:09:49 시작 Filip Soc (Montenegro) : Congrats Costantine!!! :D

01:09:49 시작 Hassan Haitham ( Iraq ) : Congrats

01:09:57 시작 Hayder Alkaales (Iraq) : congratulations Constantin

01:10:01 시작 Abdullah Al-Ali (Kuwait) : Congratulations Constantine

01:10:13 시작 Celine Cao (Vietnam) : congratulations Constantin

01:10:25 시작 Kiril Trajkov (Macedonia) : congratz Constantine

01:13:11 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Is there a plan to improve the diversity within your board? how

does this reflect on the diversity of your membership?

01:14:20 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : On boarding more members, thats the solution

01:14:45 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : and now with new statutes, confiderations will have VP on

board

01:14:48 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : Diversity is important, advocate the diversity globally to be able to

give equal opportunities to be part of the board is better

01:15:24 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : competence first, definitly something to push since we lack in

diversity for sure

01:15:37 시작 Joonas Kapiainen (Finland) : New member applicants, could you please keep these

introductions short, a couple of minutes max. It has been four hours already and my own board starts in 45

minutes.

01:16:04 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : agree with Joonas we had enough time to review all the documents

01:17:48 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : how much more in the agenda is there?

01:17:57 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : Thanks Joe ! Awesome

01:18:04 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Thank you for presenting

01:18:10 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Thanks Joe

01:18:48 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : my default vote is yes

01:19:00 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : the quality of the assessment process this year has been

outstanding

01:21:37 시작 Maxime Ferretti (Luxembourg) : Thank you very much!

01:21:39 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : Welcome Joe !!! That´s great !

01:21:41 시작 Kiril Trajkov (Macedonia) : welcome Lux!

01:21:44 시작 Joe Hoffmann (Luxembourg) : Thank you everyone for your trust!

01:21:49 시작 Hayder Alkaales (Iraq) : wow congratulations

01:21:51 시작 Abdullah Al-Ali (Kuwait) : Welcome lux

01:22:06 시작 DAVID JENNS (UAE) : Alf Mabrouk Lux

01:22:06 시작 Nenad Markovic (Serbia) : welcome to iesf :)

01:22:18 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : no sound

01:22:22 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : No sound.

01:22:23 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Congrats, Lux!!! Welcome on board!!!

01:22:42 시작 Emgelbert Farfán (Venezuela) : Welcome to IESF LUX!!

01:23:08 시작 abdi brahim (mauritania) : Welcome LUX

01:23:22 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : Welcome Luxembourg

01:23:42 시작 Bimal Tamrakar (Nepal) : Welcome LUX

01:24:05 시작 Raveen Wijayatilake (Sri Lanka) : not seeing the screen

01:24:10 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : no

01:24:26 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : now we can

01:24:28 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : OK

01:25:10 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : I know Bendik and his organisation personally and he has my full

support

01:25:11 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : pretty high ratio

01:25:28 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : it's cold there Saeed

01:25:33 시작 Lars Peter Ø strem (Norway) : thanks @Karol

01:25:45 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : that's why CS:GO did so well throughout scandinavia

01:25:51 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : stay indoors and warm by the computer

01:25:53 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : i agree

01:29:14 시작 Saqib Shoukat (Pakistan) : Congratulations to Constantine Surkont

01:32:00 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Can I default my vote to yes for all remaining votes?

01:32:42 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : lol

01:32:43 시작 Joe Hoffmann (Luxembourg) : congrats!

01:32:44 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Welcome Norway

01:32:45 시작 Lars Peter Ø strem (Norway) : Thank you all!

01:32:48 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : WELCOME NORWAY!!!

01:32:57 시작 Nenad Markovic (Serbia) : welcome Norway :)

01:33:01 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Hello Nicolas

01:33:01 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : welcome

01:33:06 시작 abdi brahim (mauritania) : WELCOME NOR

01:33:19 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : Welcome Norway

01:33:23 시작 Emgelbert Farfán (Venezuela) : Welcome Norway

01:33:41 시작 Joebert Yu (Philippines) : Welcome to IESF!

01:33:58 시작 Ahmed Dernawi (Libya)🇱🇾 : Welcome Norway

01:34:07 시작 Łukasz Klimczyk (Poland) : Norway welcome !

01:35:24 시작 Lars Peter Ø strem (Norway) : We hope to contribute in the future on bringing IESF forward.

01:36:03 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Nicholas working so hard!

01:36:25 시작 Hassan Haitham ( Iraq ) : great work!

01:36:31 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Lars, I expect that classic Norwegian humour at our next

engagement

01:37:05 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : Thanks Darren !! Just like everyone here !!!

01:37:56 시작 Lars Peter Ø strem (Norway) : Its worth the wait @Darren :D

01:38:01 시작 Telmo Silva (Portugal) : great Nicolas

01:38:27 시작 Emgelbert Farfán (Venezuela) : Excelent have you here as a full member Nicolas, Un fuerte

abrazo Felicidades a ti y a toda la familia DEVA.

01:38:41 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : Crew there is one imposter among us :D

01:38:50 시작 Timur Ateev (Kyrgyzstan) : ))))

01:38:53 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : Gracias Emgelbert !!! Thanks guys !!!

01:38:56 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : Let´s go Colombia !!!

01:39:20 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Welcome Nicolas, glad you're back in the crew

01:39:42 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : I vote yes

01:39:48 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Yes, we can hear you

01:39:54 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : No

01:39:58 시작 DAVID JENNS (UAE) : Thumbs up

01:40:16 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : Thanks Darren !!! Hope we can meet soon !

01:40:57 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : I htink the presentation is not showing

01:43:41 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : Thank you!

01:46:02 시작 Emgelbert Farfán (Venezuela) : Alexander deserved recognition for your career and

contributions to the scene in your country.

01:46:03 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : Colombia really worked hard, happy that you got the full-

membership that you deserve

01:46:07 시작 Hùng Đỗ Việt (Vietnam) : Great job

01:46:16 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : Welcome!

01:46:17 시작 Gregory Moore (Jamaica) : Welcome Alex

01:46:20 시작 Bimal Tamrakar (Nepal) : Welcome LUX

01:46:24 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : welcome Alex !!!!

01:46:30 시작 Joe Hoffmann (Luxembourg) : Welcome and congratulations!

01:46:33 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : vote yes

01:46:41 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : Darren is sus guys

01:46:43 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : welcome colombia!!!

01:46:46 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : Vlad where is our Cigar?

01:46:49 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : ahahah

01:47:00 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : What's your proof?

01:47:00 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Nice cigar

01:47:09 시작 Ahmed Dernawi (Libya)🇱🇾 : congratulations ,welcome colombia

01:47:15 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : of course Tiago has animated his presentation

01:47:19 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : I saw you in electricity room doing some tasks but looks weird

dunno

01:47:20 시작 Nicolás Crespo (Argentina) : vlad you need a whisky

01:47:39 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : I can hear Tiago's heavy hammering on the keyboard.

01:47:44 시작 Totovski Boban (IESF) : who mentioned whiskey?

01:47:59 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : we should play for real Among us

01:48:13 시작 Timur Ateev (Kyrgyzstan) : I’m in!)

01:48:16 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : it could be nice content

01:48:41 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : I'm in :)

01:49:06 시작 Gregory Moore (Jamaica) : if the traitor is found he sings the ambient music

01:49:26 시작 Timur Ateev (Kyrgyzstan) : Best streaming content of all times)) Huge organisation playing

among us)) That will stay in history forever)

01:49:44 시작 Gregory Moore (Jamaica) : CIGAR why not

01:49:45 시작 Balázs Takács (IESF) : from Vlad: "After 3 hours of not smoking and having such a great

feeling seeing my esports family I can't help myself...luckily due to covid you do not have to smell the smoke

and I can smoke indoors. : ) GGWP"

01:50:42 시작 Gregory Moore (Jamaica) : mechanical keyboard sounds like its new

01:51:03 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : tbh vlad makes smoking a cigar look so smooth

01:52:02 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : tiaog went over time, maybe i'm voting n.... yes

01:52:12 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : so sus

01:52:25 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : we don't have the heart to disconnect him

01:52:30 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : he's so passionate :D

01:52:46 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : really guys, I live in Portugal and the difficulties that tiago and the

federation in Portugal were facing are a lot and they created something incredible here

01:52:57 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : Ypu cant hear me but I'm lcapping

01:53:07 시작 Darren Kwan - (Australia) : can we please get a confirmation the keyboard is ok

01:53:09 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : You*, clapping*

01:53:12 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : definitely passion and competence

01:53:24 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : wait why are you living in Portugal but representing Italy?

01:54:05 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : Lisbon is my workplace, I travel a lot :)

01:54:36 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Tiago, strong hands!

01:55:16 시작 Grace Chen (Chinese Taipei) : Well done, Tiago.

01:55:33 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : welcome

01:55:35 시작 Ahmed Dernawi (Libya)🇱🇾 : welcome Portugal to the family,,,great presentation

01:55:37 시작 Emgelbert Farfán (Venezuela) : Congrat´s Tiago Welcome!!

01:55:40 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : welcome !!!! Portugal

01:55:41 시작 Hung Do Viet (VIET NAM) : great

01:55:44 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Welcome amigooos

01:55:44 시작 erdenechuluun ganbaatar (Mongolia) : congrats

01:55:48 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : congrats portugal, welcome in the family

01:55:48 시작 Bimal Tamrakar (Nepal) : welcome

01:55:50 시작 Tiago Fernandes (Portugal) : Thanks everyone!

01:55:50 시작 Ismail Azmee Adnan(Maldives) : welcome Portugal! to the family, long waited!

01:55:53 시작 Łukasz Klimczyk (Poland) : Portugal congratulations !

01:55:54 시작 Tiago Fernandes (Portugal) : Hope to you see you soon

01:55:56 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : Welcome Portugal!

01:55:59 시작 Hayder Alkaales (Iraq) : congratulations

01:56:39 시작 Telmo Silva (Portugal) : thanks to all

01:56:44 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : is that REAL FIRE!

01:56:57 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Congrats Tiago

01:57:59 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Luxemburg, Norway, Argentina, Columbia ...Congrats Guys !

01:58:19 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : so far really passionate and good faces here

02:00:41 시작 Samart Assarasakorn (Thailand) : I need a drink

02:01:30 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Not showing up

02:01:32 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Error

02:01:35 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : error!

02:02:03 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Welcome guys

02:02:04 시작 Ismail Azmee Adnan(Maldives) : Welcome Belarus!

02:02:06 시작 Emgelbert Farfán (Venezuela) : Alexey Congrat´s to you, Welcome Belarus

02:02:11 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : Welcome Belarus

02:02:44 시작 Ahmed Dernawi (Libya)🇱🇾 : Congrats Welcome Belarus

02:02:48 시작 Kiril Trajkov (Macedonia) : welcome Belarus :D

02:02:53 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : Welcome Belarus!

02:03:49 시작 Łukasz Klimczyk (Poland) : Belarus congratulation !

02:04:04 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : Great video!

02:04:45 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : waw

02:05:27 시작 Ismail Azmee Adnan(Maldives) : great video!

02:07:11 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : I know Balázs for a long time, we cooperate internationally. We

even send players to their competitions. Therefore they have my full support since they are the ones that

organise the biggest events. Therefore Hunesz and Balázs have my full support to become full members

02:07:45 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : what is the confusion here, please enlighten

02:07:48 시작 Daniel Hodozsan (Hungary) : Here's the video of what HUNESZ managed to achieve in the

past years: https://youtu.be/ayNx-y-7lqo

02:08:11 시작 Łukasz Klimczyk (Poland) : I can confirm what Karol wrote about HUNESZ and Balazs !

02:08:14 시작 Joebert Yu (Philippines) : Two Hungary esport federation

02:11:01 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : We've been able to make unity in other countries and i believe

the friends in Hungary will do their best to unite forces and benefit their members.

02:11:19 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Their players

02:11:31 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : just wote yes :D we are their neighbours we know them

02:11:35 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : we shd support our existing memners

02:11:41 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : *members

02:11:47 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : thats true Lokesh aso

02:12:01 시작 Ananth Sevlanga Nathan (Malaysia) : true Lokesh

02:12:12 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : the one which Board is proposing is the existing member, m I correct

02:12:13 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Eh carol thats you in the presintation

02:12:27 시작 Daniel Hodozsan (Hungary) : yes, HUNESZ is the current associate member

02:12:34 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : exactly this is the real one

02:12:35 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : we were also confused when we saw the documents

02:12:59 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : So the non-accepted member is the one supported by NOC ?

02:13:00 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : and indeed that is me in the presentation along with Poland, Czech

Republic

02:13:16 시작 Joebert Yu (Philippines) : The first video, one of the speaker is from Hungary Olympic

Committee correct?

02:13:23 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : NOC in HUngary does not support any organisation

02:13:29 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : which one approve by NOC

02:13:37 시작 Daniel Hodozsan (Hungary) : noone is approved by NOC

02:13:49 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Interest of existing members should always be upheld, ir respective

of NOC recognization,

02:14:14 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : i met with their sport offitials when in Budapest and they made

clear they are not supporting any, but it should be mentioned that Hunesz gets monetary support from

Hungarian goverment

02:14:21 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Lokesh in this case, the one supported by NOC is not the

current member

02:14:22 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : Hunesz iz she one we are voting on

02:15:21 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : @saeed: Interest of existing members should always be upheld,

irrespective of NOC recognition,

02:15:45 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : NOC will automatically recognize the one with IESF membership

02:15:47 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : and they Hunesz have government support even finantial one

02:15:51 시작 Joebert Yu (Philippines) : Interesting to see the result

02:15:53 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : its just not sports recognition

02:15:56 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : NOC's typically follow the IFs

02:16:13 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : sure i agree, just clarifying

02:16:26 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : Welcome guys

02:16:34 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : welcome

02:16:36 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Give love for Iraq

02:16:39 시작 Emgelbert Farfán (Venezuela) : Á dam Congrat´s Welcome Hungary

02:17:09 시작 Balázs György Biró (Hungary) : Thank you very much!

02:17:18 시작 Hung Do Viet (VIET NAM) : Congrat

02:17:33 시작 houssem ben amor ( Tunisia ) : good Luck Haydar

02:17:55 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Congratulations Balazs and Hungary

02:18:14 시작 Ahmed Dernawi (Libya)🇱🇾 : Congrat

02:19:08 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : share screen?

02:19:08 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Select Full Screen sharing

02:19:13 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : full screen sharing

02:19:58 시작 Balázs Takács (IESF) : congrats Balázs, congrats everyone!

02:21:44 시작 Łukasz Klimczyk (Poland) : Congrats !

02:22:36 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : That is very sweet! :)

02:22:39 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : really nice to see

02:22:41 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : super sweet!

02:22:45 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : very Cute

02:22:51 시작 Hassan Haitham ( Iraq ) : love from the Iraqi players

02:22:54 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : this is also esports, passion!

02:23:13 시작 Balázs György Biró (Hungary) : Thank you very much! We are veryhappy in Hungary! thank

you for support

02:23:41 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : it 12:23 Am time to rest @lun

02:23:50 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : 1:@3am

02:23:58 시작 Timur Ateev (Kyrgyzstan) : 23:23)

02:24:16 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Congrats all the new Members, Iraq, Belarus, Hungary

02:24:18 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : @macau never sleep

02:24:19 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : all the best

02:24:21 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : Vlad has cigar, I need my street fighter

02:24:24 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : time to sleep now

02:24:39 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Congrats to Vlad (and his Cigar) & Constantine

02:24:49 시작 Samart Assarasakorn (Thailand) : Time for a drink and sleep congrats to everyone

02:24:50 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Mabroook Iraq ل دل ني ت ي D: ع

02:24:51 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : So as @Laos Jon

02:24:56 시작 houssem ben amor ( Tunisia ) : Congratulations 🎊🎉👏

02:25:00 시작 Hayder Alkaales (Iraq) : woooow

02:25:00 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : new record

02:25:05 시작 Balázs Takács (IESF) : wuuuhuuuuu

02:25:06 시작 Kiril Trajkov (Macedonia) : gg

02:25:08 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : Iraq got it!!!

02:25:10 시작 Johan van Breda (South Africa) : Congratulations and welcome to all the new members!

02:25:11 시작 Kiril Trajkov (Macedonia) : welcome to all the new members

02:25:13 시작 Emgelbert Farfán (Venezuela) : Hayder Congrat´s Welcome Iraq

02:25:17 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : GGWP!

02:25:18 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : gg

02:25:21 시작 John McRae (New Zealand) : Just for the record Australia went to bed before New Zealand

- soft

02:25:22 시작 Hayder Alkaales (Iraq) : thank you all

02:25:22 시작 Balázs Takács (IESF) : GGWP!

02:25:23 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : my wife getting MAD!

02:25:24 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : haha

02:25:28 시작 Hung Do Viet (VIET NAM) : GREAT, IRAQ!!!

02:25:28 시작 Hassan Haitham ( Iraq ) : thank you so much everyone for your lovely support !

02:25:35 시작 Joebert Yu (Philippines) : Congratulations to all new full members!

02:25:36 시작 Frederico Rosario (Macau) : My wife desisted my needs.

02:25:39 시작 Ananth Sevlanga Nathan (Malaysia) : Well Done Everyone

02:25:41 시작 Ahmed Dernawi (Libya)🇱🇾 : Congrats Iraq

02:25:44 시작 Hassan Haitham ( Iraq ) : Iraqi players will be more than happy to join you in this journey

02:25:50 시작 Daniel Hodozsan (Hungary) : Congratulations everyone and welcome all new members!

02:25:52 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : Merry Christmas and Very Happy New Year, Stay Safe & well !

02:25:54 시작 Emgelbert Farfán (Venezuela) : Extraordinary meeting Congratulations to the entire board

of directors and the IESF family

02:25:56 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : Welcome IRAQ

02:25:59 시작 Łukasz Klimczyk (Poland) : Congrats to Vlad, Constantine and all full members !

02:26:02 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : the only bad side is the next WCm the competition is heating

up :D :D

02:26:02 시작 David Chogovadze (Georgia) : THX! GL!

02:26:09 시작 Samart Assarasakorn (Thailand) : We can have a corona together

02:26:09 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : Thank Boban for everything.

02:26:11 시작 John McRae (New Zealand) : Congrats - stay safe all

02:26:15 시작 Asif Hanafi (Switzerland) : *Thank you

02:26:16 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : 1 mins Vlad, that's it

02:26:17 시작 Hayder Alkaales (Iraq) : really appreciate your support , kids are happy and calibrating now ,

regards to you all

02:26:20 시작 SERHAT BEKDEMIR (IESF) : congrats everyone one, we are making the history ^^

02:26:21 시작 Constantine Surkont (Russian Federation) : Thanks guys for this great works, thanks all for

the attendance.

02:26:21 시작 Ed Anokhin (Ukraine) : Congratulations to all new Members!

02:26:23 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : we are done for the day

02:26:24 시작 Maxime Ferretti (Luxembourg) : Thank you for the organisational work! Great job on your

side!

02:26:31 시작 Otto Takala (Finland) : Thank you all! Have a lovely time with your families!

02:26:33 시작 Jess Tamboboy (Philippines) : Congratulations and welcome to new members!

Thank you every one!

02:26:42 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : thought the online meetings will be less tiring

02:26:46 시작 Lokesh Suji (INDIA) : :)

02:26:47 시작 Hung Do Viet (VIET NAM) : Thank you every one!!! Stay Safe!!! WELL DONE, IESF

Official!!!

02:26:49 시작 Ahmed Dernawi (Libya)🇱🇾 : Thank you for your the great work

02:26:52 시작 Johan van Breda (South Africa) : Thank you all! I hope to see you all again in-person soon!

02:27:04 시작 Joonas Kapiainen (Finland) : Thank you everyone! It has been a long but a successful

meeting!

02:27:14 시작 Ido Brosh (IESF) : thank you everyone! I am proud of our achievements today together. We

move now as one to unite Esports and to promote it

02:27:27 시작 Mekan Eyeberdiyev (Turkmenistan) : Thank You and stay safe all, GG WP

02:27:37 시작 Björn Sanders (Sweden) : Special thanks to Boban for great leadership of a difficult meeting!

02:27:37 시작 Jonathan Sirisackda (Laos) : @thailand Vietnam Cambodia brunie Malaysia Brunei

Philippine time for beer

02:27:48 시작 Felipe Montoya (Costa Rica) : Thank you everyone, happy holidays

02:27:49 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : thanks it was a pleasere seeing you even virtually

02:27:50 시작 Ananth Sevlanga Nathan (Malaysia) : Indeed!

02:27:52 시작 Totovski Boban (IESF) : thank yo!!!

02:27:53 시작 Saeed Sharaf - Syrian Esports : Looking forward to meet with you guys.

Congrats every new member for leveling up your character at IESF :D

02:27:53 시작 Jess Tamboboy (Philippines) : @Laos cheers to that! hahah

02:27:56 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : stay safe guys

02:27:56 시작 Balázs György Biró (Hungary) : Happy Holidays

02:27:59 시작 Karol Cagan (Slovakia) : leths grab a beer next time we see each other

02:28:00 시작 Ismail Azmee Adnan(Maldives) : Thank you for a great OGM. Congratulations to all new

members and the board.

02:28:06 시작 Totovski Boban (IESF) : your words are my reward!!!

02:28:07 시작 Giulio Cecinelli (Italy) : Happy holidays to all of youi

02:28:08 시작 Tiago Fernandes (Portugal) : Happy holidays everyone

02:28:12 시작 Tiago Fernandes (Portugal) : Stay safe