Post on 20-Jan-2020
22
LAMPIRAN
22
Lampiran 1. Surat Keterangan Ekstrak Kulit Manggis
23
Lampiran 2. Blanko Angket Uji Respon Rasa Granul Effervescent BLANKO ANGKET PETUNJUK PENGISIAN
1. Isilah data identitas Anda pada tempat yang disediakan dengan lengkap!
2. Berikan tanda cek(√) yang tersedia dengan tepat. Identitas Diri
Nama : Umur : Pekerjaan : Alamat : Tanda tangan :
Setelah mencicipi dan merasakan formula I, II, III, IV, dan V granul
effervescent ekstrak kulit manggis dan buah tomat bagaimana pendapat saudara/i tentang rasa dari kelima formula granul effervescent tersebut?
Granul
effervescent Tanggapan rasa
Sangat manis Manis Kurang manis Hambar Formula l Formula ll Formula lll Formula IV Formula V
Setelah anda merasakan kelima formula tersebut, formula mana yang paling anda sukai dan menurut anda dapat di pasarkan?
Tanggapan responden
Jenis granul Formula l Formula ll Formula lll Formula IV Formula IV
Sangat suka Suka Kurang suka Tidak suka
Dari kelima formula tersebut, formula manakah yang memiliki warna
granul terbaik setelah dilarutkan?
Tanggapan responden
Jenis granul Formula l Formula ll Formula lll Formula IV Formula IV
Sangat baik Baik Kurang baik Tidak baik
24
Lampiran 3. Data Hasil Perhitungan Tanggapan Rasa effervescent Dari 20 responden yang terpilih untuk memberikan penilaian terhadap granul effervescent kulit manggis dan buah tomat adalah sebagai berikut:
a. Rasa sediaan Tanggapan
Rasa F1
(responden) F II
(responden) F III
(responden) F IV
(responden) F V
(responden) Sangat manis 0 0 0 0 0
Manis 5 0 12 1 6 Kurang mnis 15 9 8 12 14 Tidak manis 0 11 0 7 0
b. Kesukaan
Tanggapan suka
F1 (responden)
F II (responden)
F III (responden)
F IV (responden)
F V (responden)
Sangat suka 0 0 0 0 0 Suka 10 3 14 4 5
Kurang suka 18 6 6 10 11 Tidak suka 2 11 0 6 4
c. Warna sediaan
Tanggapan warna
F1 (responden)
F II (responden)
F III (responden)
F IV (responden)
F V (responden)
Sangat baik 0 0 0 0 0 Baik 8 17 3 9 3
Kurang baik 11 2 13 10 15 Tidak baik 1 1 4 1 2
Formula I ada 5 responden yang memilih manis dan 15 responden memilih kurang manis, maka dapat dihitung prosentasenya: Formula I: Manis : 5/20 x 100% = 25% Kurang manis : 15/20 x 100% = 75%
Lampiran 4. Perhitungan Asam Basa Dibuat 500 granul dengan berat 300 mg tiap granul effervescent
Perhitungan asam dan basa untuk setiap formula.
Asam yang digunakan adalah asam sitrat dan asam tartrat serta bagian
basa digunakan natrium bikarbonat. Berikut adalah reaksi asam sitrat dan asam
tartrat dengan natrium bikarbonat:
H3C6H5O7.H2O + 3NaHCO3 → Na3C6H5O7 + 4H2O + 3CO2 asam sitrat + Na-bikarbonat → Na-sitrat + air + C. dioksida H2C4H4O6 + 2NaHCO3 → Na2C4H4O6 + 2H2O + 2CO2 asam tartarat + Na-bikarbonat → Na-tartat + air + C.dioksida
Berdasarkan reaksi diatas, dapat diketahui bahwa untuk menetralkan 1
mol asam sitrat dibutuhkan 3 mol natrium bikarbonat. Serta untuk menetralkan 1
mol asam tartrat dibutuhkan 2 mol natrium bikarbonat. Maka perbandinganya
adalah:
a) Asam sitrat
Jika 2 gram asam sitrat (BM 210) bereaksi dengan 2,4 gram natrium bikarbonat
(BM 84) dengan perhitungan:
x = 2,4
b) Asam tartrat
Jika 2 gram asam tartrat (BM 150) bereaksi dengan 2,24 gram natrium bikarbonat
(BM 84) dengan pehitungan:
x = 2,24
Maka dapat disimpulkan bahwa natrium bikarbonat yang dibutuhkan untuk
bereaksi dengan 2 gram asam sitrat dan 2 gram asam tartrat adalah 4,64 dengan
perhitungan:
2,4 gram + 2,24 gram = 4,64 gram natrium bikarbonat.
Maka perbandingan asam sitrat : asam tartrat : natrium bikarbonat adalah 2:2:4,64
Untuk berat total asam- basa granul effervescent 2 : 2 : 4,64 = 8,64 = 9 gram
26
Formula I
Asam sitrat = 2/9 x 2 g = 0,444 g = 0,5 g
Asam tartrat = 2/9 x 2 g = 0,444 g = 0,5 g
Na. Bikarbonat = 4/9 x 2 g = 0,888 g = 1 g
Formula II
Asam sitrat = 2/9 x 2 g = 0,444 g = 0,5 g
Asam tartrat = 4/9 x 2 g = 0,888 g = 1 g
Na. Bikarbonat = 2/9 x 2 g = 0,444 g = 0,5 g
Formula III
Asam sitrat = 4/9 x 2 g = 0,888 g = 1 g
Asam tartrat = 2/9 x 2 g = 0,444 g = 0,5 g
Na. Bikarbonat = 2/9 x 2 g = 0,444 g = 0,5 g
Formula IV
Asam sitrat = 1/9x 2 g = 0,222 g = 0,25 g
Asam tartrat = 3/9 x 2 g = 0,666 g = 0,75 g
Na. Bikarbonat = 4/9x 2 g = 0,888 g = 1 g
Formula V
Asam sitrat = 3/9 x 2 g = 0,666 g = 0,75 g
Asam tartrat = 1/9x 2 g = 0,222 g = 0,25 g
Na. Bikarbonat = 4/9x 2 g = 0,888 g = 1 g
27
Lampiran 5. Perhitungan Aktivitas Antioksidan Kontrol Positif (Vitamin E) Dan Sediaan Granul Effervescent.
A. Aktivitas antioksidan kontrol positif vitamin E 1. Absorbansi
Kontrol negatif (DPPH) : 1,264 Kontrol positif (vitamin E) :
a. Orientasi : 0,187
b. Replikasi 1 : 0,173
c. Replikasi 2 : 0,126
d. Replikasi 3 : 0,094
e. Replikasi 4 : 0,142
f. Replikasi 5 : 0,187
2. Perhitungan % aktivitas antioksidan
b. Data 1 (0,187)
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 85,20%
c. Data 2 (0,173)
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 86,31%
d. Data 3 (0,187)
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 85,20%
Rata-rata = 85,57% SD = 0,673 RSD = 0,745%
B. Aktivitas antioksidan ekstrak kulit buah manggis dan buah tomat Kontrol negatif (DPPH) : 0,561 Absorbansi ekstrak
a. Replikasi 1 : 0,229
b. Replikasi 2 : 0,230
c. Replikasi 3 : 0,230
Perhitungan % aktivitas antioksidan a. Data 1 (0,229)
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 59,18%
28
b. Data 2 (0,230)
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 59%
c. Data 3 (0,231)
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 59%
Rata-rata = 59,06% SD = 0,103 RSD = 0,174%
Karena dengan ekstrak tomat 300 mg dan buah tomat 500 mg sudah
memiliki aktivitas antioksidan lebih dari 50 % maka dapat digunakan dalam
formula.
C. Aktivitas antioksidan sediaan granul effervescent
Formula 1
DPPH : 0,561
Basis : 0,432
Effervescent 1 : 0,191
Effervescent 2 : 0,192
Effervescent 3 : 0,192
Perhitungan aktivitas antioksidan basis
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 22,99%
Effervescent 1
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 60,41%
Effervescent 2
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 60,18%
Effervescent 3
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 60,18%
Rata-rata replikasi = 60,25%
SD = 0,13
29
Formula 2
DPPH : 0,561
Basis :0,403
Effervescent 1 : 0,184
Effervescent 2 : 0,184
Effervescent 3 : 0,183
Perhitungan aktivitas antioksidan basis
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 28,52%
Effervescent 1
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 54,11%
Effervescent 2
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 54,11%
Effervescent 3
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% =54,36%
Rata-rata = 54,19%
SD = 0,14
Formula 3
DPPH : 0,341
Basis :0,215
Effervescent 1 : 0,076
Effervescent 2 : 0,078
Effervescent 3 : 0,075
Perhitungan aktivitas antioksidan basis
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 36,95%
Effervescent 1
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 64,65%
30
Effervescent 2
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 63,72%
Effervescent 3
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 64,11%
Rata-rata = 64,80%
SD = 0,46
Formula 4
DPPH : 0,461
Basis :0,367
Effervescent 1 : 0,150
Effervescent 2 : 0,149
Effervescent 3 : 0,151
Perhitungan aktivitas antioksidan basis
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 20,17%
Effervescent 1
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 59,12%
Effervescent 2
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 59,40%
Effervescent 3
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% =58,85%
Rata-rata = 59,12%
SD = 0,27
31
Formula 5
DPPH : 0,341
Basis : 0,249
Effervescent 1 : 0,097
Effervescent 2 : 0,095
Effervescent 3 : 0,096
Perhitungan aktivitas antioksidan basis
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 26,97%
Effervescent 1
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 61,84%
Effervescent 2
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% = 61,44%
Effervescent 3
% aktivitas antioksidan = x 100% =61,04%
Rata-rata = 61,17%
SD = 0,40
32
Lampiran 6. Hasil Uji Sifat Fisik Granul Effervescent.
1. Waktu alir Replikasi Waktu alir granul (detik)
Formula I
Formula II Formula III Formuala IV
Formula V
1 11,11 10,18 11,13 11,39 11,44 2 11,23 10,15 11,14 11,35 11,21 3 11,28 10,21 11,11 11,38 11,65
Rata-rata 11,23 10,18 11,13 11.38 11.44 SD 0,08 0,03 0,01 0,02 0,22
2. Indeks kompresibilitas
Formula
Replikasi
Vo (mL)
M (g) Vk (mL)
rk(mL) (M/Vk)
ro(mL) (M/Vo)
C% rk - ro/ rk x 100 %
SD
1 1 100 74,55 96 0,77 0,74 4,70 2 100 74,55 98 0,76 0,74 2,72 1,50 3 100 74,55 99 0,75 0,74 1,72 2 1 100 70,35 97 0,72 0,70 3,47 2 100 70,35 96 0,73 0,70 4,47 0,99 3 100 70,35 98 0,71 0,70 2,47 3 1 100 68,50 97 0,70 0,68 3,69 2 100 68,50 98 0,69 0,68 2,70 0,99 3 100 68,50 96 0,71 0,68 4,69 4 1 100 63,15 96 0,65 0,63 4,22 2 100 63,15 97 0,65 0,63 3,22 0,57 3 100 63,15 97 0,65 0,63 3,22 5 1 100 59,80 97 0,61 0,60 2,66 2 100 59,80 98 0,61 0,60 1,67 0,57 3 100 59,80 97 0,61 0,60 2,66
33
34
4. Waktu larut granul effervescent
formula Suhu air
100 270 600
1 177 123 51 1 178 120 51 1 177 121 49 2 176 118 46 2 176 117 47 2 175 118 48 3 180 125 51 3 181 124 52 3 182 125 52 4 189 135 60 4 189 135 60 4 191 136 61 5 201 144 70 5 199 145 69 5 200 143 68
5. Waktu larut granul
formula Suhu air
100 270 600
1 312 204 120 1 313 204 123 1 313 203 121 2 325 246 132 2 327 247 135 2 324 245 134 3 366 259 146 3 367 257 145 3 368 259 143 4 375 272 166 4 376 271 165 4 374 271 163 5 387 312 189 5 386 314 190 5 388 311 192
35
6. Gambar larutan
Urutan tingkat kejernihan larutan granul effervescent : F2, F4, F1, F3, F5
Gambar larutan granul
36
Lampiran 7. Hasil Uji Statistik Anova 1. Uji waktu alir
Post Hoc Test Multiple Comparisons
waktu.alir LSD
(I) formula
(J) formula
Mean Difference (I-
J) Std. Error Sig.
95% Confidence Interval
Lower Bound Upper Bound
formula 1
formula 2 2.05000* .08446 .000 1.8618 2.2382
formula 3 .08667 .08446 .329 -.1015 .2749
formula 4 -.14333 .08446 .121 -.3315 .0449
formula 5 -.20333* .08446 .037 -.3915 -.0151
formula 2
formula 1 -2.05000* .08446 .000 -2.2382 -1.8618
formula 3 -1.96333* .08446 .000 -2.1515 -1.7751
formula 4 -2.19333* .08446 .000 -2.3815 -2.0051
formula 5 -2.25333* .08446 .000 -2.4415 -2.0651
formula 3
formula 1 -.08667 .08446 .329 -.2749 .1015
formula 2 1.96333* .08446 .000 1.7751 2.1515
formula 4 -.23000* .08446 .021 -.4182 -.0418
formula 5 -.29000* .08446 .006 -.4782 -.1018
formula 4
formula 1 .14333 .08446 .121 -.0449 .3315
formula 2 2.19333* .08446 .000 2.0051 2.3815
formula 3 .23000* .08446 .021 .0418 .4182
formula 5 -.06000 .08446 .494 -.2482 .1282
formula 5
formula 1 .20333* .08446 .037 .0151 .3915
formula 2 2.25333* .08446 .000 2.0651 2.4415
formula 3 .29000* .08446 .006 .1018 .4782
formula 4 .06000 .08446 .494 -.1282 .2482
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.
37
Oneway
ANOVA
waktu.alir
Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
Between Groups 10.893 4 2.723 254.515 .000
Within Groups .107 10 .011
Total 11.000 14
2. Uji pengetapan / indeks kompresibilitas
Oneway
ANOVA
Pengetapan
Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
Between Groups 3.635 4 .909 .917 .491
Within Groups 9.914 10 .991
Total 13.549 14
3. Waktu melarut 100
Oneway
ANOVA
Melarut
Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
Between Groups 6249.067 4 1562.267 1233.368 .000
Within Groups 12.667 10 1.267
Total 6261.733 14
38
Post Hoc Test Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable:waktularut
(I) formula
(J)
formula
Mean
Difference (I-
J) Std. Error Sig.
95% Confidence Interval
Lower Bound
Upper
Bound
Tukey
HSD
formula 1 formula 2 2.00000 .81650 .179 -.6872 4.6872
formula 3 -3.00000* .81650 .028 -5.6872 -.3128
formula 4 -12.00000* .81650 .000 -14.6872 -9.3128
formula 5 -22.00000* .81650 .000 -24.6872 -
19.3128
formula 2 formula 1 -2.00000 .81650 .179 -4.6872 .6872
formula 3 -5.00000* .81650 .001 -7.6872 -2.3128
formula 4 -14.00000* .81650 .000 -16.6872 -
11.3128
formula 5 -24.00000* .81650 .000 -26.6872 -
21.3128
formula 3 formula 1 3.00000* .81650 .028 .3128 5.6872
formula 2 5.00000* .81650 .001 2.3128 7.6872
formula 4 -9.00000* .81650 .000 -11.6872 -6.3128
formula 5 -19.00000* .81650 .000 -21.6872 -
16.3128
formula 4 formula 1 12.00000* .81650 .000 9.3128 14.6872
formula 2 14.00000* .81650 .000 11.3128 16.6872
formula 3 9.00000* .81650 .000 6.3128 11.6872
formula 5 -10.00000* .81650 .000 -12.6872 -7.3128
formula 5 formula 1 22.00000* .81650 .000 19.3128 24.6872
formula 2 24.00000* .81650 .000 21.3128 26.6872
formula 3 19.00000* .81650 .000 16.3128 21.6872
formula 4 10.00000* .81650 .000 7.3128 12.6872
LSD formula 1 formula 2 2.00000* .81650 .034 .1807 3.8193
formula 3 -3.00000* .81650 .004 -4.8193 -1.1807
39
formula 4 -12.00000* .81650 .000 -13.8193 -
10.1807
formula 5 -22.00000* .81650 .000 -23.8193 -
20.1807
formula 2 formula 1 -2.00000* .81650 .034 -3.8193 -.1807
formula 3 -5.00000* .81650 .000 -6.8193 -3.1807
formula 4 -14.00000* .81650 .000 -15.8193 -
12.1807
formula 5 -24.00000* .81650 .000 -25.8193 -
22.1807
formula 3 formula 1 3.00000* .81650 .004 1.1807 4.8193
formula 2 5.00000* .81650 .000 3.1807 6.8193
formula 4 -9.00000* .81650 .000 -10.8193 -7.1807
formula 5 -19.00000* .81650 .000 -20.8193 -
17.1807
formula 4 formula 1 12.00000* .81650 .000 10.1807 13.8193
formula 2 14.00000* .81650 .000 12.1807 15.8193
formula 3 9.00000* .81650 .000 7.1807 10.8193
formula 5 -10.00000* .81650 .000 -11.8193 -8.1807
formula 5 formula 1 22.00000* .81650 .000 20.1807 23.8193
formula 2 24.00000* .81650 .000 22.1807 25.8193
formula 3 19.00000* .81650 .000 17.1807 20.8193
formula 4 10.00000* .81650 .000 8.1807 11.8193
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level. 4. Waktu melarut 270
Oneway
ANOVA
Melarut
Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
Between Groups 6249.067 4 1562.267 1233.368 .000
Within Groups 12.667 10 1.267
Total 6261.733 14
40
Post Hoc Test Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable:waktularut
(I) formula (J) formula
Mean
Difference (I-J) Std. Error Sig.
95% Confidence
Interval
Lower Bound
Upper
Bound
Tukey HSD formula 1 formula 2 3.33333* .91894 .030 .3090 6.3576
formula 3 -3.66667* .91894 .017 -6.6910 -.6424
formula 4 -14.66667* .91894 .000 -17.6910 -
11.642
4
formula 5 -22.66667* .91894 .000 -25.6910 -
19.642
4
formula 2 formula 1 -3.33333* .91894 .030 -6.3576 -.3090
formula 3 -7.00000* .91894 .000 -10.0243 -3.9757
formula 4 -18.00000* .91894 .000 -21.0243 -
14.975
7
formula 5 -26.00000* .91894 .000 -29.0243 -
22.975
7
formula 3 formula 1 3.66667* .91894 .017 .6424 6.6910
formula 2 7.00000* .91894 .000 3.9757 10.024
3
formula 4 -11.00000* .91894 .000 -14.0243 -7.9757
formula 5 -19.00000* .91894 .000 -22.0243 -
15.975
7
formula 4 formula 1 14.66667* .91894 .000 11.6424 17.691
0
formula 2 18.00000* .91894 .000 14.9757 21.024
3
41
formula 3 11.00000* .91894 .000 7.9757 14.024
3
formula 5 -8.00000* .91894 .000 -11.0243 -4.9757
formula 5 formula 1 22.66667* .91894 .000 19.6424 25.691
0
formula 2 26.00000* .91894 .000 22.9757 29.024
3
formula 3 19.00000* .91894 .000 15.9757 22.024
3
formula 4 8.00000* .91894 .000 4.9757 11.024
3
LSD formula 1 formula 2 3.33333* .91894 .005 1.2858 5.3809
formula 3 -3.66667* .91894 .003 -5.7142 -1.6191
formula 4 -14.66667* .91894 .000 -16.7142 -
12.619
1
formula 5 -22.66667* .91894 .000 -24.7142 -
20.619
1
formula 2 formula 1 -3.33333* .91894 .005 -5.3809 -1.2858
formula 3 -7.00000* .91894 .000 -9.0475 -4.9525
formula 4 -18.00000* .91894 .000 -20.0475 -
15.952
5
formula 5 -26.00000* .91894 .000 -28.0475 -
23.952
5
formula 3 formula 1 3.66667* .91894 .003 1.6191 5.7142
formula 2 7.00000* .91894 .000 4.9525 9.0475
formula 4 -11.00000* .91894 .000 -13.0475 -8.9525
formula 5 -19.00000* .91894 .000 -21.0475 -
16.952
5
42
formula 4 formula 1 14.66667* .91894 .000 12.6191 16.714
2
formula 2 18.00000* .91894 .000 15.9525 20.047
5
formula 3 11.00000* .91894 .000 8.9525 13.047
5
formula 5 -8.00000* .91894 .000 -10.0475 -5.9525
formula 5 formula 1 22.66667* .91894 .000 20.6191 24.714
2
formula 2 26.00000* .91894 .000 23.9525 28.047
5
formula 3 19.00000* .91894 .000 16.9525 21.047
5
formula 4 8.00000* .91894 .000 5.9525 10.047
5
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level. 5. Waktu melarut 600
Oneway
ANOVA
Melarut
Sum of Squares Df Mean Square F Sig.
Between Groups 2960.667 4 740.167 584.342 .000
Within Groups 12.667 10 1.267
Total 2973.333 14
43
Post Hoc Test Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable:waktularut
(I) formula (J) formula
Mean
Difference
(I-J) Std. Error Sig.
95% Confidence Interval
Lower Bound Upper Bound
Tukey HSD formula 1 formula 2 3.66667* .91894 .017 .6424 6.6910
formula 3 -1.33333 .91894 .612 -4.3576 1.6910
formula 4 -9.33333* .91894 .000 -12.3576 -6.3090
formula 5 -18.33333* .91894 .000 -21.3576 -15.3090
formula 2 formula 1 -3.66667* .91894 .017 -6.6910 -.6424
formula 3 -5.00000* .91894 .002 -8.0243 -1.9757
formula 4 -13.00000* .91894 .000 -16.0243 -9.9757
formula 5 -22.00000* .91894 .000 -25.0243 -18.9757
formula 3 formula 1 1.33333 .91894 .612 -1.6910 4.3576
formula 2 5.00000* .91894 .002 1.9757 8.0243
formula 4 -8.00000* .91894 .000 -11.0243 -4.9757
formula 5 -17.00000* .91894 .000 -20.0243 -13.9757
formula 4 formula 1 9.33333* .91894 .000 6.3090 12.3576
formula 2 13.00000* .91894 .000 9.9757 16.0243
formula 3 8.00000* .91894 .000 4.9757 11.0243
formula 5 -9.00000* .91894 .000 -12.0243 -5.9757
formula 5 formula 1 18.33333* .91894 .000 15.3090 21.3576
formula 2 22.00000* .91894 .000 18.9757 25.0243
formula 3 17.00000* .91894 .000 13.9757 20.0243
formula 4 9.00000* .91894 .000 5.9757 12.0243
LSD formula 1 formula 2 3.66667* .91894 .003 1.6191 5.7142
formula 3 -1.33333 .91894 .177 -3.3809 .7142
formula 4 -9.33333* .91894 .000 -11.3809 -7.2858
formula 5 -18.33333* .91894 .000 -20.3809 -16.2858
formula 2 formula 1 -3.66667* .91894 .003 -5.7142 -1.6191
44
formula 3 -5.00000* .91894 .000 -7.0475 -2.9525
formula 4 -13.00000* .91894 .000 -15.0475 -10.9525
formula 5 -22.00000* .91894 .000 -24.0475 -19.9525
formula 3 formula 1 1.33333 .91894 .177 -.7142 3.3809
formula 2 5.00000* .91894 .000 2.9525 7.0475
formula 4 -8.00000* .91894 .000 -10.0475 -5.9525
formula 5 -17.00000* .91894 .000 -19.0475 -14.9525
formula 4 formula 1 9.33333* .91894 .000 7.2858 11.3809
formula 2 13.00000* .91894 .000 10.9525 15.0475
formula 3 8.00000* .91894 .000 5.9525 10.0475
formula 5 -9.00000* .91894 .000 -11.0475 -6.9525
formula 5 formula 1 18.33333* .91894 .000 16.2858 20.3809
formula 2 22.00000* .91894 .000 19.9525 24.0475
formula 3 17.00000* .91894 .000 14.9525 19.0475
formula 4 9.00000* .91894 .000 6.9525 11.0475
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.
6. Antioksidan
Oneway
ANOVA
Antioksidan
Sum of Squares Df Mean Square F Sig.
Between Groups 162.783 5 32.557 389.582 .000
Within Groups 1.003 12 .084
Total 163.786 17
45
Post Hoc Test
Multiple Comparisons
Dependent Variable:antioksidan
(I) formula (J) formula
Mean
Difference (I-
J) Std. Error Sig.
95% Confidence Interval
Lower Bound
Upper
Bound
Tukey HSD formula 1 formula 2 6.06333* .20929 .000 5.3603 6.7663
formula 3 -4.23333* .20929 .000 -4.9363 -3.5303
formula 4 1.13667* .20929 .002 .4337 1.8397
formula 5 -1.18000* .20929 .001 -1.8830 -.4770
ekstrak 1.19667* .20929 .001 .4937 1.8997
formula 2 formula 1 -6.06333* .20929 .000 -6.7663 -5.3603
formula 3 -10.29667* .20929 .000 -10.9997 -9.5937
formula 4 -4.92667* .20929 .000 -5.6297 -4.2237
formula 5 -7.24333* .20929 .000 -7.9463 -6.5403
ekstrak -4.86667* .20929 .000 -5.5697 -4.1637
formula 3 formula 1 4.23333* .20929 .000 3.5303 4.9363
formula 2 10.29667* .20929 .000 9.5937 10.9997
formula 4 5.37000* .20929 .000 4.6670 6.0730
formula 5 3.05333* .20929 .000 2.3503 3.7563
ekstrak 5.43000* .20929 .000 4.7270 6.1330
formula 4 formula 1 -1.13667* .20929 .002 -1.8397 -.4337
formula 2 4.92667* .20929 .000 4.2237 5.6297
formula 3 -5.37000* .20929 .000 -6.0730 -4.6670
formula 5 -2.31667* .20929 .000 -3.0197 -1.6137
ekstrak .06000 .20929 1.000 -.6430 .7630
formula 5 formula 1 1.18000* .20929 .001 .4770 1.8830
formula 2 7.24333* .20929 .000 6.5403 7.9463
formula 3 -3.05333* .20929 .000 -3.7563 -2.3503
formula 4 2.31667* .20929 .000 1.6137 3.0197
ekstrak 2.37667* .20929 .000 1.6737 3.0797
46
ekstrak formula 1 -1.19667* .20929 .001 -1.8997 -.4937
formula 2 4.86667* .20929 .000 4.1637 5.5697
formula 3 -5.43000* .20929 .000 -6.1330 -4.7270
formula 4 -.06000 .20929 1.000 -.7630 .6430
formula 5 -2.37667* .20929 .000 -3.0797 -1.6737
LSD formula 1 formula 2 6.06333* .20929 .000 5.6073 6.5193
formula 3 -4.23333* .20929 .000 -4.6893 -3.7773
formula 4 1.13667* .20929 .000 .6807 1.5927
formula 5 -1.18000* .20929 .000 -1.6360 -.7240
ekstrak 1.19667* .20929 .000 .7407 1.6527
formula 2 formula 1 -6.06333* .20929 .000 -6.5193 -5.6073
formula 3 -10.29667* .20929 .000 -10.7527 -9.8407
formula 4 -4.92667* .20929 .000 -5.3827 -4.4707
formula 5 -7.24333* .20929 .000 -7.6993 -6.7873
ekstrak -4.86667* .20929 .000 -5.3227 -4.4107
formula 3 formula 1 4.23333* .20929 .000 3.7773 4.6893
formula 2 10.29667* .20929 .000 9.8407 10.7527
formula 4 5.37000* .20929 .000 4.9140 5.8260
formula 5 3.05333* .20929 .000 2.5973 3.5093
ekstrak 5.43000* .20929 .000 4.9740 5.8860
formula 4 formula 1 -1.13667* .20929 .000 -1.5927 -.6807
formula 2 4.92667* .20929 .000 4.4707 5.3827
formula 3 -5.37000* .20929 .000 -5.8260 -4.9140
formula 5 -2.31667* .20929 .000 -2.7727 -1.8607
ekstrak .06000 .20929 .779 -.3960 .5160
formula 5 formula 1 1.18000* .20929 .000 .7240 1.6360
formula 2 7.24333* .20929 .000 6.7873 7.6993
formula 3 -3.05333* .20929 .000 -3.5093 -2.5973
formula 4 2.31667* .20929 .000 1.8607 2.7727
ekstrak 2.37667* .20929 .000 1.9207 2.8327
ekstrak formula 1 -1.19667* .20929 .000 -1.6527 -.7407
47
formula 2 4.86667* .20929 .000 4.4107 5.3227
formula 3 -5.43000* .20929 .000 -5.8860 -4.9740
formula 4 -.06000 .20929 .779 -.5160 .3960
formula 5 -2.37667* .20929 .000 -2.8327 -1.9207
*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.