INTEGRATION PROPOSAL FOR HISTORIC KATRAS INTO DHAKA’S URBAN FABRIC
Qazi Azizul Mowla Zamal Uddin Shaikh Professor, Department of Architecture Lecturer, Department of Architecture
Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology State University of Bangladesh (SUB)
Dhaka-1000 Dhaka 1209 and Graduate Student, BUET
[email protected], [email protected] [email protected]; [email protected]
Abstract
Dhaka’s historic edifices are the evidences of its glorious past as it has experienced a long process of evolution under different
rulers, dynasties and regimes. The cultural heritage of this area is manifested by its buildings, street patterns, use of space,
lifestyle of the people, religious practices, festivals, traditional crafts and so on. Due to rapid urbanization and lack of awareness
or conservation initiatives all these historic monuments/sites are in a state of decay. Uncontrolled and insensitive development
taking place around historic sites has created an adverse effect upon the urban fabric in terms of physical and visual quality
resulting in the area losing its identity and roots.
Among all the severely effected historic sites of Dhaka the Boro Katra and Choto Katra deserve serious attention being the
reminiscence of Dhaka as the first Capital of this region 400 years ago. This paper will illustrate two Mughal Katra sites and
explore the ways to integrate them with the city fabric so the people are constantly aware of their glorious past. The evaluation of
existing development pattern in terms of land use pattern of adjacent areas building height and encroachments is studied
thoroughly on site. Finally Strength, Weakness, Opportunity and Threat of these sites were observed. Based on analysis some
recommendations are made for the redevelopment and conservation of the historic site that, if implemented is expected, to trigger
harmonious improvement of the surrounding area.
1. Introduction:
The old Dhaka was once the glorious capital of the Mughals
in this region is now on the verge of oblivion. During the
Mughal period a number of significant monuments were
constructed of which Katras are important ones. In addition
to architectural, aesthetic, historic, and iconic value, these
artifacts have great emotional value as the symbol of our
cultural identity and hence a part of the heritage (Shaikh and
Mowla, 2009). Mughal glory faded and came to an end with
the shifting of the provincial capital to Murshidabad in
1717A.D. Uncontrolled growth since than is almost
destroying the socio-cultural and historic settings of urban
fabric of old Dhaka. Encroachments are going on unabated,
while open spaces and water bodies are rapidly disappearing,
the roads remain invaded and the overall situation get
deteriorated. In this paper, two Mughal Katras and adjacent
areas were studied to have an overall idea of the present state
of the areas, their morphological changes and existence of
old buildings of significance which have architectural,
cultural, social, political, religious importance. This paper
particularly focuses on analyzing Katras and their
integration into the urban fabric of Dhaka that would show
way for similar integration of historic artifacts into the city
fabric for our identity and posterity.
1.1 Objective and method of the study
A main objective of this paper is to find the factors affecting
historic fabric of Katras by the uncontrolled encroachments
and chalking out a comprehensive plan of intervention to
integrate Katras with the city fabric. This study has gone
through a systematic process of documentation and based on
field and literature survey analysis is done, following which
plan of interventions and recommendation is formulated.
2. Significance of historic sites and their integration with
the urban fabric
Interventions are necessary to develop a harmonious
relationship between historic artifacts and urban settings.
The intangible meaning of historic artifacts has significant
importance in our societal value. Historic artifacts are the
material evidences of our past (Mowla,2008). So their
extinction poses a question towards our own survival as a
proud nation. Any conservation scheme to ingrate the
present urban fabric with its past is of vital importance.
Katras may be taken here as the case.
2.1 About Katra: The word possibly originated from the
Arabic word katrar or Katra. Katra means a building having
arches. In Arabic and Persian literature it has been called a
'Karwan Sarai' or simply a 'Sarai'. A Karwan Sarai would
generally have a courtyard. An arched veranda would
surround the courtyard and beyond the veranda would be the
rooms where the passersby took shelter on their way from
one place to another. The beasts of burden like horses and
camels with carts and other articles necessary for a journey
were kept in the courtyard. It is assumed that there were
numbers of Sarais along the trade routes during the Muslim
period.
In a Katra there was arrangement of sleeping rooms, kitchen,
dining space, lavatories, mosque and even a hospital for the
passersby. Waqf (endowment) estates at private and public
initiatives were created for the maintenance and smooth
running of a saraikhana. Two Katras, the Bara Katra and the
Chhota Katra, built in Dhaka by the Mughals deserve special
mention being among the important architectures of the
Mughals in Dhaka.
2.2 Historic overview of Katras and morphological
analysis:
According to Rennel’s Map (1779) ‘Bara Katra’ seems to
have a quadrangular courtyard enclosed by structures at its
four sides. There were two magnificent gateways in the
north and the south. The stately southern wing, extending
along a river frontage, 223 feet long, is ambitiously planned
and gorgeously decorated in the Imperial Mughal Style.
Fig -01: Bara Katra picture from around 1840
The Bara Katra contains two inscriptions in Persian: one
records that it was built in 1053 AH (1643-44AD) and the
other contains the date 1055 AH (1645-46AD) and confirms
that SHAH SHUJA gave the building to Mir Abul Qasim,
who built it, to be used as a Katra on the condition that the
officials in charge of the endowments (waqf) should not take
any rent from any deserving person alighting therein.
Twenty-two shops were waqf to defray the expenses of the
Bara Katra. It therefore, appears that Bara Katra was a
caravan-serai, the northern part of which has completely
disappeared (Hassan, 1958 (Figs. 01-05)
Taifoor (1956) described the Bara Katra as an extensive
building near the Chawkbazar with four lofty gateways (the
gates to the east and west are now extinct). its southern
stately gateway, bearing three-storied rooms and flanked by
four passages and the massive octagonal towers, had been a
landmark of Dhaka from the river frontage. The three storied
corner towers were hollow and could be approached from
the subsidiary structures. Following the traditional pattern of
the caravan-sarai of Central Asia, the Bara Katra was highly
fortified and was embellished with all the features of the
imperial Mughal style. In 1765 Nayab –e Nazim of Dhaka
used the building as his residence.
2.3 Status of Katras from Historic Documents and their
virtual reconstruction:
Fig-02: Painting of D'Oyly (1823): southern wing (left) and ruin of
northern gate (right)
Fig-03: Entrance Gateway of south wing (left); South wing, north
elevation ((right) in 1930 A.D
Fig-04: Entrance, south wing from the courtyard.1950 (left);
Entrance, south wing, 1964 (right)
Fig-05: Boro katra south view- photo taken 1870 (bottom)
The southern part was 223’ long along the bank of river.
D’Oyly (1823) described the building as magnificent and in
good shape. However, local poor people have occupied the
building by than (Figs. 06-11).
Fig-06: C.S Map of Katras (1912-1915)
Fig-8: First floor plan of Bara Katra done by the authors with
reference drawings form Department of Archaeology, 1981
Fig-9: Second floor plan of Bara Katra done by the authors with
reference drawings form the Department of Archaeology, 1981
Fig-10: River front elevation of south wing of Bara Katra recreated
by the authors with the help of reference drawings form the
Department of Archaeology, 1981
Fig-11: Sectional elevation of south wing of Bara Katra (north
elevation of south wing) visualized by the authors with reference
drawings form Hossain, 2006
Choto Katra is situated about 200 meters east of the Bara
Katra and slightly smaller than the Bara Katra, is similar in
plan and was built almost for the same purpose. The Katra is
rectangular in plan, 101.20m×92.05m externally and
81.07m×69.19m internally. The thickness of the outer walls
is 0.91 to 1.00m and the maximum thickness of the bastion
walls is 1.22m. There are two gateways, one on the north
and the other on the south. The southern one is the main
entrance. Both the gateways, though much altered recently,
are still in situ. In the two outer corners of the south wall of
the structure there are two octagonal turrets.
The structures around the open courtyard have undergone
massive interventions. The three storied gateway on the river
cour t yard
Fig-07: Conjectural Drawing of ground floor of Bara Katra
done by the authors with reference drawings form the
Department of Archaeology, 1981
side has assumed some colonial features. The triple windows
and the lofty angle towers reflect the colonial influence
during subsequent restorations. The minarets were strongly
built and were without parapets and, compared to other
Mughal minarets, they were thicker. The floor and the fairly
wide stairway were built of woods. The room in the ground
floor was vertically divided in to two parts.
The Chota Katra is believed to have been built by SHAISTA
KHAN in about 1664 AD. It is also said that the Katra was
constructed to accommodate some officials and also a part of
Shaista Khan's expanding family. It is evident that the
structure has lost much of its original look through
indiscriminate alterations and unworthy restoration (Fig.12).
Fig-12: The Chota Katra picture from around 1880
Fig-13: Conjectural Drawing of ground floor of Bara Katra
prepared by the authors with reference drawings form the
Department of Archaeology, 1981
Both the katras (Fig.13) have quadrangular space or court
yard. The Mughal reminiscence is in entrance gateways
which are lofty in character. The plan is quite symmetric
except the location of northern gateway of Chota Katra
which shifted its position towards the west. The central axis
running through the court is bold in both katras. The
locations of the octagonal turrets at the pivotal points of two
wings are typical of Mughal buildings. The use of Mughal
arch opening (four centered, multiple cusps), merlon
parapet, symmetric façade having repetition of Mughal
elements are quite harmonious in characters. In the Chota
Katra, European elements like column with ionic volute can
be seen in the upper part of south entrance gateway, because
in the British Colonial period the building was altered.
3.1 Present Status of Bara Katra and Choto Katra and
Way forward
The dense settlements around both the artifacts have resulted
in visual obstacle. Inadequate space around the structure
restricts proper lighting and ventilation. The narrow road
network doesn’t permit vehicular access. Due to
uncontrolled development and high land value, proper urban
space for public gathering could not be provided. The
narrow streets have run through the gateways, created by the
remaining ruins. The open to sky spaces enclosed by the
buildings are almost occupied by the newly built structures.
The riverbank has now receded away from the structures that
once used to flow adjacent to it. More over land filling in the
area has set the ground level above the plinth of the existing
ruins (Hossain, 2006).
Except the Southern wing with gateway and some portion of
east and west wings, all other part of Bara Katra has almost
disappeared. There are traces of walls and foundations of
east and west wings standing with the newly built residences
(colonial structure) in the east and madrasa in the west side.
The wings with entrance on north side have completely
disappeared but the southern wings still exist as ruin with
some alternation as a ruin. In the entrance hall there are so
many incompatible additions of shops of different categories
that impede the visual quality. Addition of newly built toilet
and ablution spaces on the terrace of fist floor has been
made. Some tin shaded structures are also added on the
terrace of second floor.
Though the building has got small openings of traditional
Mughal style entrance of ample natural lighting was ensured
by windows but in the ground floor and staircases most of
the openings are sealed off that prevents the usual
penetration of light. Southern wing along with the northern
gate of choto katra still exist though in a very dilapidated
state. The south elevation of northern gateway is recently
plastered against the usual conservation practices. The east
and west wings are now totally lost and spaces are occupied
by new structures (Figs. 14-35).
Both the Katras in their present state are in a serious identity
crisis due to new settlements within and adjacent the sites.
The visual obstacles are more prominent in all the gateways.
Moreover there are several damages on wall, roof, floor,
staircases can be seen that need proper initiatives for repair
and improvement. The dense settlement in and around the
artifacts is creating visual obstacle. The present use of katras
and surrounding areas is a great threat for katras physical
and visual existence. Katra’s open courts are occupied by
incompatible functions. In the Ward map the physical
footprints of katra’s can still be seen but the plots are used
by newly constructed pucca or semi- pucca constructions
which are obviously illegal as it is a large waqf property.
Fig-14: Ward Map by Dhaka City Corporation showing two Katras and their major connecting roads
Fig-15: Pathetic existence of Katras in city context
(Computer Simulation)
Fig-16: Existing use pattern of ground floor (Bara Katra) Source:
Field Survey, 2010
bara
katr
a lane
residencial area
student hostel
student hostel
Ware
house
shop shop
shopshop
shop shop
restaurant
shopshop
shop
restaurantshop
courtyard
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
medicine
godown
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
residencial area
shop
shop
shop
Doctor's Chamber
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
shop
store
store
shop
shop
shop
residencial area
shoari
ghat
lane
student hostel
Ware
house
Ware
house
Ware
house
Ware
house
Warehouse
Warehouse
Warehouse
Warehouse
Ware
house
Ware
house
Ware
house
Ware
house
Fig-17: Entrance Gateway of Katras almost invisible due to
encroachment (Bara Katra-left, Choto Katra-right)
Fig-18:
Recently
plastered
Northern
Gateway of
Choto Katra
from inner
court (left)
Fig-19:
Northern
Gateway of
Choto Katra
from outside
(left)
Fig-20:
Southern
wings of
Bara Katra
from inner
court (left)
Fig-22: Damage in the wall
Fig-21: : Southern entrance hall
of Bara Katra occupied by the
shops
Fig-23: Umbrella workshop on
the second floor of Choto Katra
Fig-24: Northern entrance hall of
Choto Katra occupied by shops
Fig-25: Small factories on the
first floor of Choto Katra
Fig-26: Residential accommodation
on the second floor of Choto Katra
Fig-27: The entire court of Bara
Katra is encroached by new
structures
Fig-28: View of southern wing of
Bara Katra from roof
3.2 Effect of uncontrolled development around the
Katras
Both katras are still in use. But the way they are being used
is very unsympathetic and hazardous to their physical and
visual existance. Unaware of the value of the building, the
users are frequently demolishing the walls to build new
structures. They also add new floor ignoring the building
morphology and structural safety. The eastern and western
wings are either demolished or altered in a manner that
makes it beyond recognition of its historic past. The
boundaries are occupied by small factories which are
harmful to brick wall of Katras. The only surviving
Gateways are fully occupied by shops. Both the katras are
enlisted as national antiquities of Bangladesh. But these two
Mughal edifices are in a deplorable condition and also in
danger of extinction due to the lack of care by the authority.
4 Analysis and Synthesis
Strength: The building morphology and spatial characters
of Katras are in favor of giving such kind of adaptive re-use
that can ensure better social interaction among the adjacent
community. It is a waqf property, that are governed by
definite rules.
Weakness: There is no local community participation or
awareness to preserve the site. Lack of awareness among the
inhabitants to realize the historic value of Katras resulted in
a shortage of provision or facilities for the tourists.
Fig-29: Shops on the ground
floor of eastern wing of Bara
Katra
Fig-30: Corner turret of Bara
Katra
Fig-31: Wooden staircase to
upper floor of Choto Katra
Fig-32: Warehouse in one of the
ground floor cells of eastern
wing of Bara Katra
Fig-35:
Addition of new
structures by the
Madrasha Committee
demolishing the wall
of Bara Katra (left)
Opportunities: It is enlisted by the department of
Archaeology. If properly maintained and conserved, these
Katras can still attract a huge amount of commercial return
from local, regional, domestic and international tourist as
well as tourist related business. Connecting Katras with near
by water works road at the north and embankment road in
the south and developing connection between these two
nearby Katras would make them accessible to the tourist
Threat: Unplanned, uncontrolled and incompatible
development around the vicinity is gradually swallowing the
Katras, creating adverse effects on physical and visual
quality of the historic area. The physical quality is fast
deteriorating due to lack of conservation initiative.
5.1 Intervention Practices
Criteria for intervention depends on two factors of
morphological control ie. a. Historic fabric control; b.
Transition area control and c. Connectivity with the present
road system.
Historic fabric control is exercised where there is
dominating presence of historic buildings. This can be
conceived as urban restoration operation which aims to
reconstruct the continuity of the traditional fabric. Eg. New
development in Zanzibar historic stone town in Tanzania.
Transition area control is exercised where there is
dominating presence of new buildings encroached the fringe
areas of the historic fabric. In this case of interventions it is
necessary to recover the buffer area of historic buildings and
introduce new pedestrian alleys.
For Katras the second morphological control is expected to
be more appropriate. So it is necessary to demarcate the
buffer areas and reclaim the historic boundary by
demolishing the encroachment. Transfer of Development
Rights (TDR) may be applied for further acquisition of
adjacent land. Type of interventions proposed here are: a)
integral restoration, b) typological restoration, c) New
construction / reconstruction, and d) ordinary maintenance
5.2 Intervention strategies for Katras
Transition area control: Both the katras are now protected as
Historic Monument by the Department of archaeology
Bangladesh. In 1958 Department of Archaeology
demarcated property line to acquire for Bara katra and Choto
Katra but no further steps were taken. The situation has
deteriorated much since than. It is a matter of identity crisis
for both katras and now need immediate intervention from
government end to acquire the land to save these artifacts.
The lost part can be reconstructed and befitting adaptive re-
use can be taken up. The transition area can be redefined and
all the incompatible buildings and functions may be
removed.
For reconstruction of katras and effective transition area
control, more areas will be needed. The study proposes for
more land acquisition for Bara katra’s buffer area control
and reconstruction of missing part along with its northern
gateway. For Chota Katra, similar strategic action may be
adopted.
Fig-33: An entrance portico
added with the southern gateway
of Choto Katra during British
Colonial period (View from
inner court)
Fig-34: Addition of new floor on
existing structure of western
wing of Bara Katra by Madrasa
Committee
Fig-36: Area to be acquired for katras shown in red,
1958 by the Department of Archaeology
Reference (Mouza Shahar Dacca, Ward No: 5 & 6,
Sheet No-16, C.S map 1912-1915):
Protected site of Bara Katra at Dacca required plot no:
27 (part), 46,47,49,91,92,93,94,100,101 (part), 14p,
21p, 22p, 23p, 24p, 34, 42, 43, 44, 45, 101, 32p.
Protected site of Choto Katra at Dacca required plot no:
204, 205, 207, 208, 209, 210, 221, 222,223, 197p,198p,
199p, 200p, 203p, 206p, 211p, 212p, 217p, 218p, 219p,
220p, 224p, 227p, 228p, 229p, 233p, 820p, 263p, 264p,
265p, 266p, 267p, 268p, 269p, 271p, 409p, 410p
Fig-37: Computer simulation on existing situation after removing
incompatible structures in and around Bara Katra from the land
acquired by the Department of Archaeology.
Connectivity with the present road system
All the connecting roads shown in C.S map (Fig-42) can be
revived. The existing commercial patterns of street can run
their business under guidelines to serve the local community
as well as to provide necessary amenities for the tourists. Fig-38: Land acquisition proposal and computer simulation by
the authors for effective buffer area and reconstruction of missing
part of Bara Katra)
Fig -39: Virtual reconstruction of Bara Katra in the acquired land
Fig -40: Full range of view of south wing of Bara Katra.
Fig-41: Full range of view of north wing of Bara Katra.
To manage the historic artifacts to be conserved the
spontaneous public participation is necessary. But it is a
matter of question about how the participation will be
ensured. Polititical government has less concentration in this
regards. So the local panchayat system can be an effective
tool to manage public participation, as it develops from the
root of the community.
5.4 Recommendations for intervention
5.4.1. Recommendations for intervention at macro level
Global Aspects
There is a good possibility for Katras to be enlisted as world
architectural heritage sites. Every year many foreign tourists
visits this sites to have a closer view of the this two Mughal
edifices.
An Heritage Trust Fund can be established for the purpose
of providing financial assistance in the form of grants to
rehabilitate properties listed in the State and/or National
Register of Historic Places. This can also be done under
waqf laws.
Parallel to the existing National Antiquities Act 1968,
International Guidelines should be followed to conserve the
antiquities so that these can become part of world
architectural heritages.
National Level
In the Dhaka Metropolitan Building Construction Rules
2008, it is mentioned that within 250 meter radius of any
declared antiquities, no development or new construction
can take place without the permission of concern authority
(Chapter 7, Clause 61). Katras are enlisted sites by antiquity
act as well as Rajuk building by laws therefore there should
have been specific development guidelines for designated
historic areas to control the urban development.
A key to success in urban revitalization initiatives and their
integration is by forming investment partnerships with the
private sector. It goes without saying that appropriate
economic incentives such as property tax exemptions and
transfers of development rights (TDR) that promote efficient
reuse of historic buildings are necessary conditions for
successfully recruiting private sector participation.
Being a waqf property government can effectively use its
rights to control of the use of the buildings. Less obvious is
the fact that the policies put into place and the specific
projects undertaken must respond to the budget constraints
of citizens and businesses currently active in the historic
urban areas in question, at the same time promoting a
commercial orientation to the conservation and revitalization
effort is necessary.
There may be promotional activities at national level for
social awareness about the value of heritage artifacts and
why they should be persevered.
Urban level
All the illegal and incompatible structures in and around the
Katras should be removed to create buffer space.
Fig-42: Connectivity shown in the C.S map (1912-15)
Fig-43: Connectivity shown in the existing urban fabric (computer
simulation after demolishing the incompatible structures in Katras
For removal of incompatible having legal ownership,
Transfer of Development Rights (TDR) may be applied to
relocate them in the adjacent areas.
There should be restriction on height, scale and volume of
surrounding structure so that katras gets visual and physical
focus.
All the approach and connecting road may be restructured to
create view corridors so that historic artifacts can be
integrated with urban fabric and with the river Burigonga.
Two katras may be a part of heritage walk route as well. To
implement this all the surrounding road networks should be
treated. For revival of Katras Debi Das Lane, Shoarighat
Road, Champatali Lane, Bara Katra Lane, Choto Katra
Lane, Hakim Habibur Rahman Road should be free from
heavy vehicles. Rikshaw and other slow moving vehicle may
be the transport mode. Water Works Road, Midford Road,
Rajani Bashu Lane can be used for medium vehicle.
Historically the approach road towards katras were from
River Buriganga which leads to Chawk (the marketplace)
through Champatali Lane, Shoarighat Road and the access
roads of Bara Katra and Choto Katra. So better connection is
needed to integrate Katras with Burigonga river and water
works road.
Designated offsite parking may be developed with amenities
and comfortable walkways developed connecting the
historic artifacts.
5.4.2. Recommendations for intervention at micro level
The Mughal Katras should be restored and renovated
maintaining the international guidelines. En extensive
documentation of existing and previous condition, analysis
of katra’s building morphology and physical structures is
needed for this conservation work.
The government may relocate the central jail immediately as
already decided from its existing position so that the
inhabitants of relocated incompatible structures of historic
Katras may be rehabilitated therein.
To reconstruct the missing part, more land may be acquired
and international chartered by ICOMOS (International
Council on Monuments and Sites) for reconstruction may be
followed.
A committee of architects, archaeologists, planners,
historians and representatives of the local community and
government may work together in this project.
The open areas should be designed with the reference of
Mughal landscape.
The Katras should be rehabilitated into
educational/recreational center for the local community so
that the community can take better care of their antiquities.
The adaptive reuse of Katras may have some tourist
facilities like hotel, restaurant, shops, entertainment etc.
Existing service and utility systems may be developed so
that the adaptive re-use can run smoothly and are
commercially viable.
Building maintenance committee may be formed with local
participation and from local authority to run the maintenance
and management in an appropriate manner.
6. Concluding Remarks
Dhaka is celebrating its 400 years as capital city. The old
core of Dhaka is gradually being segregated form the newer
part. The rapid urbanization, absence of policy monitoring
system for the development of old core are the great threat
for historic artifacts. Whatever rules, antiquities act, Rajuk
bylaws etc Waqf or so on should be enough to take
initiatives to integrate the historic artifacts with the city
fabric to give a city its true character and pride. Once strong
design decision regarding the control of these artifacts is
taken, other private sector development like tourist
amenities, souvenir shops or other compatible uses will
automatically follow.
The intention of this paper is to present the overall present
situation of Katras, their integration into the urban fabric
and to create the premises for policy makers for laying the
proper guidelines for the revival of Katras. While legislation
and agencies create the legal basis for change, the
community should participate to maintain its interest in
conservation, as ultimately the community harnesses the
benefits.
Reference
D’Oyly, Sir. C (1823): Antiquities of Dacca, John Landseer,
London.
Hassan, S. M. (1958): Ancient Monuments of East Pakistan,
Asiatic Press, Dacca.
Hossain, M.S (2006): Conservation and management a
concept paper for Bara Katra, Unpublished PGT
report submitted at Lund University, Lund,
Sweden.
Mowla, Q.A (2008): Redevelopment Strategy for Old Dhaka
– An analytical Debate, Jahangirnagar Planning
Review, Vol.6, pp.33-38.
Shaikh, Z.U and Mowla, Q.A (2009): Documenting the
Architectural Style of the Antiquity
Buildings in Panam Street, Pratnatattve, Journal of
the Dept. of Archaeology, JU, Vol-15.
Taifoor, S.M (1956): Glimpses of Old Dhaka, Pioneer
Printing Press, Dhaka.